vissim calibration & validation · vissim calibration & validation august 8, 2006 10...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
VISSIMCalibration & Validation
VISSIMCalibration & Validation
August 8, 2006
Presentation to the Modeling Working GroupPresentation to the Modeling Working Group
![Page 2: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Presentation Outline
• Study area• VISSIM model• Data used in model development• Calibration goals• Validation results
![Page 3: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Study Corridor
• I-5 corridor from Pioneer Street in Ridgefield to the Marquam Bridge in Portland
• 23-mile corridor with 25 interchanges
![Page 4: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
VISSIM Model• Microscopic/stochastic simulation model
• Link/connector network structure
• Driver behavioral model
(4 driving modes)• Free driving• Approaching• Following• Braking
I-5 at Marine Drive
![Page 5: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Why We Chose VISSIM?• Powerful multi-model modeling capabilities• Can simulate unique operational conditions
• HOV lanes• Toll lanes• Exclusive lanes• Merging/diverging segments• Weaving segments• Interacting bottlenecks• Ramp meters
• 3D animation features
• Existing VISSIM model from the I-5/Delta Park Study
![Page 6: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Data Used in VISSIM Model Development
• Highway geometry
• Traffic control
• Traffic flow
![Page 7: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Geometric Data Used in Model Development:
• Number of mainline & ramp lanes
• Ramp locations
• Lane additions and drops
• Auxiliary lanes
• Weaving sections
• Highway curvature
• Data obtained from aerial photographs, design plans, and site visits
![Page 8: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Traffic Control Used in Model Development:
• Traffic signal timing sheets from WSDOT, ODOT, and City of Portland
• Ramp meter rates from ODOT and WSDOT
• Unsignalized intersection control identified from aerial photos and site visits
• Posted speed limits
![Page 9: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Traffic Flow Data Used in Model Development:
• Ramp/ramp terminal turning movement counts (84 ramps)
• I-5 mainline vehicle classification counts (10 locations)
• Lane utilization/speed counts (10 locations)
• Travel time runs (4-hour peak periods along I-5 & I-205)
• Auto occupancy (4-hour peak periods at Evergreen Blvd.)
• Origin-destination surveys (peak period-peak direction within BIA)
Columbia River
_ CROSSING
![Page 10: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Calibration Goals:
Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and queuing
Goal 2 - Modeled capacity to be within 10% of field measurements
Goal 3 - Model link versus observed flows and travel time meet widely used micro-simulation criteria
Goal 4 - Visually acceptable on- and off-ramp queuing
Goal 5 - Modeled average speeds to be within the acceptable range of observed speeds on the mainline links
Goal 6 - Visually acceptable utilization of the lanes at the lane drop locations and the HOV lane
![Page 11: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 1 – Peak Period Recurring Bottlenecks
Bottleneck locations, activation and dissipation times, and queue extents were identified using:
• Inductive loop detector data
• Real time speed maps
• Road cameras/data collection videos
• I-5/Delta Park queue and speed diagrams
![Page 12: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Source: http://portal.its.pdx.edu/index.php
Jantzen Beach 307.5
Bot
tlene
ck A
ctiv
atio
nB
ottle
neck
Act
ivat
ion
Queue Build
Queue Build--upup
End
of Q
ueui
ngEn
d of
Que
uing
Inductive Loop Detector Data
Que
ue D
issi
patio
n
Que
ue D
issi
patio
n
Portland Boulevard
Lake Oswego/Durham
Marquam Bridge
Capitol Highway
![Page 13: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Real Time Speed Maps
WSDOT ODOT
![Page 14: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Road Cameras
1-5 at Mill Plain in Vancouve r. WA
1-5 at SR-14 in Vam;ouver, WA
Columbia River
_ CROSSING
1-5 at Victory Updated May 9 2006 08:00:01 AM
TripCheck .com
Camera 83
Milepost306.80
1-5 at Portland Bh'd. Updated May 1 6200608 :40:20 AM
Milepost304.90
![Page 15: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
• Travel Time Observations – I-5 Delta Park to Lombard Project
![Page 16: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 1 – Peak Period Recurring Bottlenecks
Bottleneck locations, activation and dissipation times, and queue extents were identified using:
• Inductive loop detector data
• Real time speed maps
• Road cameras/data collection videos
• I-5/Delta Park queue and speed diagrams
![Page 17: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 2 – Modeled vs. Field Capacity Within 10% at Key Locations
• Delta Park lane drop – Southbound
- Field 3,300-3,400 - Modeled 3,400 - Diff. 0%
• Interstate Bridge – Northbound and Southbound
- Field 5,200-5,500 - Modeled 5,100 - Diff. 2-8%
![Page 18: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 3 – Modeled vs. Field Flows & Travel Time
Pass-Pass--15%Travel Paths
Travel Time
Pass-Pass-> 85%< 5GEH Statistic
Pass-Pass--5%Sum of All Links
Sum of Link Volumes
Pass100%Pass91%> 85%5GEH Statistic
Pass100%Pass85%> 85%400 vph> 2,700 vph
Pass100%Pass100%> 85%15%Between 700 & 2,700 vph
Pass100%Pass100%> 85%100 vph< 700 vph
Link Volumes
Pass/Fail% MetPass/Fail% Met
NorthboundSouthbound% MetTargetCriteria ThresholdCriteria
Validation Criteria Thresholds Comparison - Four Hours Total AM Peak
![Page 19: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 3 – Modeled vs. Field Flows & Travel Time Cntd.
Pass-Pass--15%Travel Paths
Travel Time
Pass-Pass-> 85%< 5GEH Statistic
Pass-Pass--5%Sum of All Links
Sum of Link Volumes
Pass92%Pass100%> 85%5GEH Statistic
Pass89%Pass100%> 85%400 vph> 2,700 vph
Pass100%Pass100%> 85%15%Between 700 & 2,700 vph
Pass100%Pass100%> 85%100 vph< 700 vph
Link Volumes
Pass/Fail% MetPass/Fail% Met
NorthboundSouthbound% Met TargetCriteria ThresholdCriteria
Validation Criteria Thresholds Comparison - Four Hours Total PM Peak
![Page 20: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 4 – Visually Acceptable Ramp Queuing
• I-5 AM at SR-14/Bridgehead (7:00-8:00 AM)
VISSIM ModelWSDOT Camera
![Page 21: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 5 – Modeled vs. Field Speeds
• Modeled speeds were compared with:
• Web based real time speed maps
• I-5/Delta Park speed diagrams
• Field measured travel times
![Page 22: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Goal 6 – Visually Acceptable Lane Utilization
• VISSIM driver behavior parameters adjusted to match lane utilization at HOV, lane drop, and merge locations
VISSIM ModelWSDOT Camera
![Page 23: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
• 2030 No Build conditions
• 2030 Build Alternatives
• Development of 16-hour speed profiles
• Summarize performance measures
Next Steps
![Page 24: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
Existing 2005 16 Hour Speed Profile
Columbia River
_ CROSSING
![Page 25: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
,,,;!' I '1-" '" :-:::: ,,-,,.. -
Columbia River
1·5 Corridor· Calibrated Existing 2005 Conditions Southbound Speed Profiles: 5:00 AM • 9:00 PM
po P=
CROSSING
P- I , , ~
" , < •
![Page 26: VISSIM Calibration & Validation · VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006 10 Calibration Goals: Goal 1 - Identification of AM and PM peak period recurring bottlenecks and](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022033123/5ec81faf0a8eab61dd2b9b59/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
26VISSIM Calibration & Validation August 8, 2006
1-5 Corridor - Calibrated Existing 2005 Conditions Northbound Speed Profiles: 5:00 AM - 9:00 PM lIOIND I .. " .... ...... • .'--a, __
I .. ~ .-~ 'Q).,.oaAW ,tIC .1,00'" 100.,.oc ... ' .'X" IO)AW 1000. IDODo" .O!lO.11oa ... " ,00 . .. . , 2110"'" UOCd.oa"", 1.011 _UOI'M "1Il.J:OD~ .. lOD_UOI'M • .oo·UIII"" l.OIl·I.oo"", 1110 ,1 ,111 "" 1110_1.00"'" U3· I !IO~" _.-
liE
_.-,--' .... or.
j~ ,--,-"or' _.-....... 00 •
•••
i!1~ _ .... , _ .. IH! ...... "'.
I I I~ _ .. .. _,--.---.---............ .., ...
I ... " .. r <.,,_OJ. • I ... ,.or, > 'p Colwnbl. RJt;" , " 'I ,----• I If , ... ., _oro ~ ,
II ---~ .. _ ... , ....... ---
I~ ................. ' __ .on
............. I II~ ........... .... __ .. l
.... _ .... on .......... .......... it _ ..... ,--
-
_ ....... !t --..........
!~ --, ' .. _ ....... ,.-
fe •• "" .... ' .• 0.11' .• 0:. ,OO " .... " • ... . " ....... .... " .. " .... ,,, ... ,,'0:.,, .. ,,,. ""IO"'" ", ...... "" " ... ,~ .. '* \." "" " .. • .• t." ~." • • M UI."". . .•. " .... .... .,.~"u .... 0:.,,, .... ,,,. , .. ",."." .. 0 .• '.11""'" DltAFT H .,141 ..
Columbia River
CROSSING