visualization of complex hydrocarbon reaction systems. archive/files/merge/vol-41... ·...

23
Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology Company, Richmond, CA 94802 Abstract Many hydrocarbon reactions of interest involve either poorly characterized reactants and products andor large numbers of simultaneous reactions. An important step in understanding the behavior of such systems is to develop quantitative pictures of the feeds and products and the transformations which connect them. The processes for constructing these reaction visualizations is illustrated by examining the construction of a molecular model for coal liquefaction and subsequent conversion to distillate products, and the construction of a video simulation of catalytic petroleum naphtha reforming. New techniques which are permitting advances in these visualizations are discussed. Introduction When studying feedstocks such as coal or reactions such as those used in converting petroluem to commercial products one must confront an overabundance of information concerning chemical composition and molecular transformations. The essential features which govern the behavior of a material or process may be lost in the detail. In such cases, the production of a simple picture, or visualization can be important. Visualizations can have many values including. -identifying major deficiencies in knowledge -highlighting the most important aspects of the structure or reaction system which control reaction behavior, and those which are of relatively minor importance -setting the stage for more quantitative tools such as predictive kinetic models used in process optimization and control -training -as a basis of coinparison between the composition of similar materials or the reactions of similar feedstocks -to stimulate discussion creating focus on controversial aspects of the knowledge. Over the past 15 years, we have been utilizing visualizations to examine several complex reactions systems. In this paper, we provide a review of the process of creating quantitative reaction visualizations and review their use. We will use as examples the construction of models of coal and coal liquefaction and in a video model of catalytic naphtha reforming. Making m Quantitative Visual Model - Model of Coal and Coal Liquefaction The first step in assembling a visual model is to collect available information on composition and reactivity. In the case of coal structure, such information includes the proper distribution of elements, element groups. aliphatic and aromatic carbon species, functional groups (oxygen, sulhr and nitrogen), and reactive crosslinks. Knowledge of the reaction chemistry is critical in providing the glue which binds the structures together in a manner which may be used to simulate reaction behavior. Quantitative reaction models require information on product yields and quality at many stages of reaction, so that the progressive steps in conversion can be illustrated. By assembling composition information on the feedstock and each of the intermediate products, one constructs structures which are consistent with this information at each severity level. The product distribution at the most mild reaction conditions may be used in conjunction with knowledge of the important reaction processes to feedback information to the necessary structures which must be present in the feed to explain the appearance of the products. In the caSe of mild coal liquefaction, the processes of aliphatic and etheric crosslink cleavage between aromatic centers, the hydrogenatioddehydrogenation and associated hydrogen transfer reactions, and hnctional group distribution changes (particularly dissappearance of reactive oxygen hnctional groups) have long be attributed to as the primary important reaction paths. A likely representation assumes that the original coal structure contains components similar to those in the products of 510

Upload: dinhdat

Post on 05-May-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology Company, Richmond, CA 94802

Abstract

Many hydrocarbon reactions of interest involve either poorly characterized reactants and products andor large numbers of simultaneous reactions. An important step in understanding the behavior of such systems is to develop quantitative pictures of the feeds and products and the transformations which connect them. The processes for constructing these reaction visualizations is illustrated by examining the construction of a molecular model for coal liquefaction and subsequent conversion to distillate products, and the construction of a video simulation of catalytic petroleum naphtha reforming. New techniques which are permitting advances in these visualizations are discussed.

Introduction

When studying feedstocks such as coal or reactions such as those used in converting petroluem to commercial products one must confront an overabundance of information concerning chemical composition and molecular transformations. The essential features which govern the behavior of a material or process may be lost in the detail. In such cases, the production of a simple picture, or visualization can be important.

Visualizations can have many values including. -identifying major deficiencies in knowledge -highlighting the most important aspects of the structure o r reaction system which control reaction behavior, and those which are of relatively minor importance -setting the stage for more quantitative tools such as predictive kinetic models used in process optimization and control -training -as a basis of coinparison between the composition of similar materials or the reactions of similar feedstocks -to stimulate discussion creating focus on controversial aspects of the knowledge.

Over the past 15 years, we have been utilizing visualizations to examine several complex reactions systems. In this paper, we provide a review of the process of creating quantitative reaction visualizations and review their use. We will use as examples the construction of models of coal and coal liquefaction and in a video model of catalytic naphtha reforming.

Making m Quantitative Visual Model - Model of Coal and Coal Liquefaction

The first step in assembling a visual model is to collect available information on composition and reactivity. In the case of coal structure, such information includes the proper distribution of elements, element groups. aliphatic and aromatic carbon species, functional groups (oxygen, sulhr and nitrogen), and reactive crosslinks. Knowledge of the reaction chemistry is critical in providing the glue which binds the structures together in a manner which may be used to simulate reaction behavior.

Quantitative reaction models require information on product yields and quality at many stages of reaction, so that the progressive steps in conversion can be illustrated. By assembling composition information on the feedstock and each of the intermediate products, one constructs structures which are consistent with this information at each severity level. The product distribution at the most mild reaction conditions may be used in conjunction with knowledge of the important reaction processes to feedback information to the necessary structures which must be present in the feed to explain the appearance of the products. In the caSe of mild coal liquefaction, the processes of aliphatic and etheric crosslink cleavage between aromatic centers, the hydrogenatioddehydrogenation and associated hydrogen transfer reactions, and hnctional group distribution changes (particularly dissappearance of reactive oxygen hnctional groups) have long be attributed to as the primary important reaction paths. A likely representation assumes that the original coal structure contains components similar to those in the products of

510

Page 2: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

mild liquefaction, modified by hydrogen transfer and defunctionalization, and joined by certain reactive crosslinks. In a similar manner, the products and reactions from somewhat more severe processing may be used to imply the structures of the less severe products forming an iterative chain connecting the products of most severe treatment with the structure of the original feed.

To maintain a quantitative picture, the molar quantities of elements, functional groups, aromatics and aliphatics and the like are continuously accounted for throughout the transformation. Choosing the molecular size of the model is also critical - for coal the size of 10000 daltons proved a good compromise. This provided us with a model which WR he!!! !xgc eiioiigii io represent the -.&?r;i=ns in piuduct composition which are observed and to include sufficient quantities of crosslinks and functional groups to characterize the feed properly. Larger models required a far more complex task of construction and resulted in a loss of detail in the overall mass. Smaller models would not permit incorporation of product distribution detail and reactivity which are important in liquefaction behavior.

Figures 1 and 2 show models of a subbituminous and a bituminous coal produced in the manner described above. The models are quantitative in terms of the elemental distributions, aromatic and aliphatic components and functional groups as collected from composition and reaction data. The visualizations allow for a quick comparison between the two coals highlighting similarities and differences. Both illustrate a relatively low degree of aromatics condensation (in comparson to heavy crude oils, for instance) and although differences in the distribution of aromatics exist between the two, these features are relatively minor. The role of oxygen in the chemistry of both is apparent : oxygen is prevalent throughout the structure as crosslinks and ring substituents and multiple opportunities for hydrogen bond formation are seen, especially in the bituminous coal. Clearly any consideration of the reactions of these coals without including oxygen would be insufficient. At the time that these models were constructed, very little information was available on the detailed distribution of much of the oxygen, particularly the ether oxygen. Thus the percentage of ether oxygen present in important structural crosslinks, and the nature o f non- crosslink ethers is seen as an important uncertainty in coal structure. For both of these coals, sulfur and nitrogen are seen to play relatively unimportant roles (with only a handful of each element in the 10000 dalton model), at least so far as their importance in the overall structure is concerned.

These models are presented in planar form with the intention of allowing for better visualization of the chemical connectivity. In reality, coal is a three-dimensional structure. Recent advances have allowed construction of more sophisticated models utilizing molecular dynamics to provide energy minimized three dimensional structures. Such models are far superior in representing the constraints imposed by spatial and energetic considerations and provide better tools for examination of three dimensional properties such as density and porosity.

Figures 3 and 4 show the progressive conversion of the bituminous coal via donor solvent liquefaction. The reactive crosslinks are disrupted and products of various functionalities, aromaticities and molecular sizes are generated. With more severe processing, both forward and reverse reactions occur leading to both smaller and larger products. Even at relatively severe conditions, these liquefaction products are substantial in molecular size and contain a significant amounts of heteroatom species (particularly oxygen). Figure 5 shows the products from two- stage liquefaction employing a thermal donor solvent stage and a catalytic hydrotreating stage in close sequence. The comparison of figures 4 and 5 provides a rapid visual sense of the advantages of two-stage technology. In contrast t o the solvent products, the two-stage products are of far reduced molecular size and dramatically reduced heteroatom content.

Construction of n Model of Cntnlytic Nnphthn Reforming

The process of catalytic naphtha reforming is an essential feature of the production of high quality gasoline components from crude oil. In reforming, a feedstock consisting entirely of hydrocarbons (no heteroatoms) of carbon numbers typically between C6 and C12 are processed over a catalyst (platinum-rhenium on alumina, for instance) to convert species having a low gasoline octane rating to species with improved octane values. The principal desired reactions involve the dehydrogenation of naphthenes and the dehydrocyclization of paraftins to produce aromatic species. Side reactions of cracking, hydrocracking, and isomerization occur with the desired reactions.

511

Page 3: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Modeling reforming reactions is complex because many species are reacting simultaneously via many potential reaction paths. Unlike liquefaction, the individual species in reforming can be largely identified using relatively straightforward techniques. The difficulty lies in understanding the balance of reactions occurring for each species, the relative contributions of the reactions for the different feed molecules, and in understanding how to control the reaction to provide the highest yields of desired products.

The process of producing a visualization of the reforming reactions involves many of the steps outlined in construction of the coal models: Namely, collecting detailed information on product composition at various levels of reaction severity and iterating back to the prior composition and reaction changes via information on the reaction matrix allow the transformation model to be constructed. Figures 6 and 7 show a quantitative represenation of the feed and products from the reforming of an Arabian naphtha. Even for the relatively mild reforming to a product octane of 81, there has been considerable production of aromatic species and conversion of most of the naphthenes. Heavy paraffins have also been converted, substantial hydrogen has been produced and some ofthe product has been converted to undesired light gases. Relatively few reactions are needed to explain the product distribution shifts, beyond the dominant roles of dehydrogenation, dehydrocyclition and cracking.

For the reforming visualization, we were interested in producing a tool to enhance the training of new operators and engineers involved in commercial reformer operation. We extended our visualization by creating individual ‘snapshots’ of the composition at various ranges of severity, taking the reactions one group at a time. These snapshots were then assembled using computer drawings and video tape and assembled into a video depicting the entire sequence of reactions. We have found this video visualization can provide an excellent overall feel for the process of reforming in a very short period of time.

Visualizing - the Future.

A number of emerging tools are permitting visualizations to be created with greater ease, high detail, greater accuracy, and with better ability to serve the valuable roles of visualizations outlined above. These tools include:

-Computational tools for representing molecular connectivity permitting construction of models on a computer platform. -Use of molecular dynamics software to produce energy-minimized three-dimensional structures. -Use of quantum mechanical simulations to predict reaction pathways from molecular energetics, reducing the need for experimental determinations of reaction paths and rates. -Monte-Carlo approaches to assembling possible structures from component pieces and for displaying a full range of potential structures from multiple possibilities. -Advances in compositional capability permitting models of greater molecular detail.

512

Page 4: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Figure 1. Model of Subbituminous Coal Structure

Figure 2. Model of Bituminous Coal Structure.

513

Page 5: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Figure 3. Model of Products from Mild Donor Solvent Liquefaction ofBituminous Coal

Figure 4. Model ofProducts from Severe Donor Solvent Liquefaction of Bituminous Coal

514

Page 6: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Figure 5. Model of Products from Two-Stage Liquefaction of Bituminous Coal

Figures 6 and 7. Feed and Products from Mild Reforming of an Arabian Naphtha

515

Page 7: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

I

i

Feasibility and Status of Coal Gasification Combined Cycle Plant in JAPAN

S. Uchida,O. Shinada,T.Furuya Power Systems Headquaters

Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd. 3-1 Minatomirai 3 chome Nishi-ku Yokohama, JAPAN

KeywordsCoal gaifier,Combined cycle,Thermal efficiency

1.Introduction Integrated Gasification Combined Cycle (IGCC) is regarded as the most powerful candidate for new coal firing power plant in the next generation, because of the following two points: it has a significantly high net thermal efficiency of 46.50+% which can be achieved by increasing the gas turbine inlet temperature, and it maintains superior environmental performance attained by means of a conversion process from "dirty" coal to "clean" purified gas and the disposal of glassy slag ash.

IGCC R&D in JAPAN is being carried out as a part of the "Sunshine Project", a national project concerned with promoting the use of new energies. The Ministry of International Trade and IndustryWTI) had started the IGCC R&D project in 1974 , to focus on a fluidized bed coal gasifiers. In 1986, MITI commissioned the New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization(NED0) to restart an IGCC R&D project using an air blown entrained bed coal gasifier a t the NAKOSO 200 tonlday pilot plant, the over all plant project schedule is shown in Figure 1.

This project, now in its fmal stage of the test operation, was in 1991 entrusted to the IGC Research Association by NEDO. The essential technologies for IGCC have been verified a t this pilot plant through the achievement of a month of stable and continuous operation in March, 1995.

This air blown entrained bed gasification concept is more suitable for power generation as compared to the oxygen blown ones developed mainly for chemical plants in Europe and the USA, air blown ones do not require large amounts of the auxiliary power to produce oxygen (See Table 1). However, the air blown entrained bed gasification bad several fault to its operation and was, therefore, never successful until our first success in April, 1995. Due to its successful results, Mitsubishi has newly designed an IGCC system,"THE IGCC system ", which provides the highest net thermal plant efficiency and environmental benign in a cost.effective manner.

2. Results of the 200 tonlday air blown entrained bed coal gasification

2.1 Outline of the 200 tonlday pilot plant A schematic diagram of the pilot plant's system is shown in Figure 2. This plant, mainly consists of the air blown gasifier (gasifying 200 ton/day of coal), the hot and dry gas clean. up unit and the low calorie coal gas fired gas turbine (12.5MWe of capacity). The gas turbine can be tested and the performance, operational flexibility, reliability, and durability of the air blown IGCC technologies can be verified. Dry gas cleawup is composed of two parallel systems, one is a granular bed gas filter and fluidized bed desulfurization system, and the other is a candle ceramic filter and fmed bed honeycomb desulfurization system. MHI is in charge of supplying the air blown 200 tonlday gasifier, the fixed bed hot and dry gas clean-up unit and the testing stand for the full pressure and full scale gas turbine combustor.

pilot plant operation

516

Page 8: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

MHI's fixed bed hot and dry gas clean-up unit is composed of a dust removal system made of a porous ceramic filter and honeycomb shaped stationary oxidized iron desulfurization unit. This system is of a significantly compact size and is completely water free. Its superior cleamup performance under high gas temperature conditions of 350-45Ot enables the effective use of sensitive heat from coal gas to be used as the gas turbine heat input. The handling system including valves, pipes and controls have been greatly simplified, as there are no moving materials, increasing system reliability and economy. As of September 1995, the accumulative operating hours of the gasifier and the fixed bed clean-up exceeded 3800 hours and 1200 hours respectively, including the one month continuous operation of 789 hours.

It has successfully performed with the satisfactory results. The testing at the pilot plant will be completed by the end of March, 1996.

2.2 Results of the One Month Reliability Test The 200 ton/day gasifier had achieved one month of continuous operation totaling 789 hours (about 33 days) from 3rd March to 5th April 1995. During this test period, the operation of the gasifier had been continuously stable, and the testing was completed according to the planned schedule. Table 2 shows the major operating parameters of the gasifier during this test. I t was confirmed that the gasifier can maintain sufficiently high heating values to produce coal gas for stable combustion in the gas turbine and also keep discharging continuously molten slag through the slag hole with 100% recycling of char.

Collected data shows superior performance of air blown gasification. 70% of cold gas efficiency, 99.9% of carbon conversion efficiency were obtained, and passes the highest net thermal plant efficiency at any demonstration plant. All of the ash in the coal fed to the gasifier is converted to non-leaching and compact glassy slag with negligible small unreacted carbon, thus enabling simple ash handling and economical ash disposal without fly ash, including unreacted carbon.

The fixed bed gas clean up test facility of a sue of 20 ton/day had also achieved 765 hours of continuous operation during the same period of the long term reliability test operation as the 200 ton/day gasifier. This test shows 1-5 mg/NmS of dust concentration and 20-50 ppm of sulfur content (HB,COS) a t the outlet of the clean-up and the durability of the ceramic filter element, the oxidized iron desulfurization agent and the whole system. Instead of elemental sulfur recovery system, gypsum recovery system under pressurized condition had been tested in the pilot plant. Another advantage of this fixed bed clean-up equipment is the easiness to scale-up its capacity, because of the simple scale up criteria that requires that only the quantity of the element to be increased in accordance with the gas flow.

4. Mitsubishi IGCC system( THE IGCC system ) Based on the successful results of the 200 ton/day pilot plant, the base data for scaling-up to a 2000 ton/day class demonstration plant were able to be achieved. The IGCC may be a more complicated system when compared to conventional fossil plants, so system integration and simplification is very important. Since MHI can supply all the key components of IGCC, MHI can drastically simplify the system based on an optimized integration among the interdependent main component and under a single responsibility, The feasibility study on THE IGCC system has been executed, and details ita superior performance and economical feasibility.

THE IGCC system is composed of the air blown two stage gasifier , the fixed bed dry gas

511

Page 9: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

clean-up unit and the 13009) or 15009) class gas turbine, 701F or 701G (for 50 Hz use) and 501F or 501G (for 60 Hz use).

Adopting the fixed bed gas cleawup system, which is very compact in size and water-free, contributes to the simplicity of the whole plant system and a significant reduction of plant area. The small sized air separation unit ( A S 0 IS installed in order to produce nitrogen a s an inert gas for pressurized coaVchar handling and seal gas a t the gasifier. The remaining oxygen a t ASU is mixed with air in the gasifier, so that the oxygen concentration in the gasifier will be 25 vol.%. The predicted performance data is indicated in Table 3.

The net thermal efficiency of THE IGCC system is predicted to be 46-5W LHV% It achieves a 20% reduction in the COz gas emission with super critical steam condition compared with conventional pulverized coal firing power plants. The SOxNOx emission a t the stack inlet is anticipated to be 10 ppm and the dust concentration is predicted to be less than 1 mg/NmS at the inlet of the stack. MHI is also ready to supply large capacity coal gas fired gas turbines. MHI has the proven technologies of the 13009) class natural gas fired gas turbines, the 1250 “c class blast furnace gas @FG gas) fired gas turbines and is presently designing the 15009) class natural gas firing gas turbines. MHI has also conducted coal gas fuing test with the full pressure and full scale test stand

of a gas turbine combustor a t the 200 tonlday pilot plant. Its capacity corresponds to one can of the gas turbine for utility use. This test shows stable combustion a t a low NOx conversion rate of 30-40 % (at IOOOppm of NHs), which is required for the combustion of ammonia rich coal gas. The gasifier and the gas clean-up unit can he arranged in a single steel structure. The required plant area per power output is reduced by 20% in comparison with conventional coal fired power plants. The capital cost estimation of THE IGCC system executed at the feasibility study predicts 95% a t the commercial phase when compared to conventional coal fued power plants. Consequently, THE IGCC system offers economical feasibility in the generation cost equivalent to that of the existing coal fued power plant.

5. Conclusion The successful results of the R&D a t the 200 tonlday pilot plant have verified the IGCC technologies of the air blown two stage coal gasifier and the fixed bed gas clean-up. The development of air blown IGCC has stepped up to the demonstration phase. The Mitsubishi IGCC system, composed of these technologies, is able to realize the highest net thermal efficiency and environmental benign in a cost-effective manner.

Reference : (11 H. Ishikawa, T. Hamamatsu, H. Moritsuka, T. Toda ,S. Ishigami ,T.Furuya :

“Current Status ofIGCCDevelopment in Japan’: VGB kraftwerkstechnik Vol. 72 No. 5 1992 p.405 T. Toyoda, 0. Shinada, S. Kaneko, K. Tokuda : “Eaperience of ZOO todday Coal Gasifier Operation: JSMElASME International Conference on Power Generation ’93 Vol. 2 1993 p. 538 Takahata : ’Development of the 200 todday entrained coal gasification pilot plant: Proc. 4th The Japan Institute of Energy Congress No. 7 1995 p. 180 S. Kaneko,T. Hashimoto,T. Huruya,S,Uchida,A,Hashimoto : ‘Operation Experience with Air Blown ZOOtodday Entrained Bed Coal Gasifier“P0WER GEN in 1996

f.21

f.31

(41

518

Page 10: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

I I Garifvina Aaent I Coal Feed Ip+g* ,Can-up p e r m a l I ,$$ &+ Wet Etficiency ,p@~

I Oxvclen Blown TvDe B I l o 1 l o 1 I 0 I Medium I

Table 1 Comparison of IGCC System

-

Unit Plan Result

Coal Gas Calorie (HHV) kJ/m3N 4.150 4.200-4.600

Coal Gas Flow T/hr 50.2ial IW%LOAD) 4oi75%1-5OilW%)

Sulfur Concentration (Inlet) pprn <1.500 570-670

Sulfur Concentrotion (Outlet) ppm <1M) 20-50

Dust Concentration (inlet) rng/ m3N <3.000 180-230

Dust Concentration (Outlet) rng/ m3N <10 -1.1

Table 2 One Month Continuous Operation Data of the Pilot Plant

Table 3 Major Specification of THE IGCC system

519

Page 11: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

n

11975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 I

Figure 1 Master Schedule of IGCC Project in JAPAN

Figure 2 System Flow Diagram of 200ton/day pilot plant

Figure 3 System Flow Diagram of THE IGCC plant

520

Page 12: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

COKING PROBLEMS ASSOCIATED WITH HYDROCARBON CONVERSION PROCESSES

R. Teny K. Baker Catalytic Materials Center, Materials Research Laboratory,

The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802

Keywords: coke formation, coke mitigation, catalytic carbon, metal catalysts

ABSTRACT

The understanding of the factors controlling the deposition of carbonaceous solids resulting from the decomposition of hydrocarbons over hot metal surfaces has a considerable impact on a number of commercial processes including, catalytic steam reforming of methane, steam cracking of paraffiiic feed stocks and systems involving carbon monoxide disproportionation reactions. The potential for carbon formation exists in any system in which hydrocarbons undergo thermal decomposition and it is well known that cenain metals can increase the overall rate of this process by catalyzing the growth of filamentous and graphitic types of deposit. The highest catalytic activity for carbon deposition is exhibited by iron, cobalt and nickel, and alloys containing these metals. In this paper a review of the information obtained from the use of a combination of controlled atmosphere and high resolution transmission electron microscopy techniques to study the dynamics of carbon deposition arising from the metal catalyzed decomposition of hydrocarbons will be presented.

INTRODUCTION

A number of review articles have highlighted the complex nature of carbon deposits produced during hydrocarbon decomposition reactions (1-6). The major constituents of a typical carbonaceous solid that might accumulate on a metal surface, either in the form of a tube or as a particle dispersed on a support medium, can be divided into three main classes: amorphous, filamentous and graphitic platelets. During a traditional routine analysis of a contaminated reactor vessel or a spent catalyst, these three forms of carbon would not be necessarily distinguished, but merely referred to collectively as "coke". Available evidence indicates that the amorphous carbon component is formed via condensation and polymerization reactions and this material originates from thermal processes. It is conceivable that a signifcant amount of hydrogen is incorporatcd in the deposit, however, as the temperature is raised dehydrogenation reactions will tend to reduce the hydrogen content. There is now a general consensus that the formation of the filamentous and graphitic forms of carbon require the participation of a catalytic entity that usually operates in a particulate form.

The mechanism commonly accepted to account for the observed characteristics of the steady-state growth of carbon filaments from the metal catalyzed decomposition of carbon- containing gases involves the following steps (7-9) :

(a) adsorption of reactant gas molecules at particular faces of the metal particle followed by decomposition to generate carbon species, and

(h) dissolution in and diffusion of carbon species through the metal particle to a different set of faces that favor precipitation of carbon in the form of a fibrous structure.

The latter set of faces control not only the degree of crystalline perfection of the deposited carbon filament, but also the conformational characteristics of the material. A consequence of this phenomenon is that certain metal faces will remain free of deposited carbon and therefore, available for continued reaction with the hydrocarbon.

While the rudiments of the formation of the graphite platelet deposit have not received the same attention as that devoted to the growth of fdamentous carbon it is probable that many of the steps outlined above are also operative in the formation of this type of carbon. Nolan and coworkers (10) reported that graphite, in the form of a shell structure surrounding a metal particle core, was the exclusive type of deposit produced from a carbon monoxide tractant containing no added hydrogen. They observed that the limiting thickness of the graphite shells was about 30 layers, and that this parameter was dependent on the lifetime of the metal catalyst particles. Based on t h e findings, they argued that the growth of graphite layers did not occur via a mechanism that involved precipitation of carbon from the surface of the metal. These claims were in d k c t conflict those of earlier studies (1 1-13) that clearly demonstrated that precipitation was the key step in the formation of graphite.

CHARACTERIZATION OF CARBON DEPOSITS

Before proceeding further it is worthwhile to consider the relative rates of the formation of these three types of carbon as a function of reaction temperature and the plot, Figure 1 provides an indication of the typical composition of the "coke deposit" that one might

521

Page 13: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

expect under various conditions from the interaction of a metal with a hydrocarbon environment It can be Seen that for reactions conducted between 400 to 65OoC, the composition of the deposit will tend to consist of a large fraction of filamentous carbon and when such reactions are allowed to proceed for a prolonged period of time the fibrous structures will undergo a thickening process due the accumulation of an amorphous carbon Coating. A further ramification of this sequence of events is that the growth of fdamentoUS carbon on a reactor tube wall provides a high surface collection site for trapping the amorphous carbon constituent and this combination effectively produces a very strong composite material. At temperatures in excess of 75OOC the contribution of carbon fdaments to the overall deposit will tend to decline while that of amorphous carbon will exhibit a steady increase and the emergence of the graphite platelet constituent will become evident.

The details of the growth kinetic aspects of individual carbon filaments was elucidated a number of years ago from quantitative analysis of the dynamic events captured on video- tape. from experiments performed in the controlled atmosphere electron microscope. From measurements of the rate of increase in length of similar width sUuctures as a function of temperature it was possible to evaluate apparent activation energies for the growth of filaments from various metal catalysts. The important aspect to emerge from this exercise was that from the accumulated data Baker and coworkers (7) were able to develop a mechanism that accounted for several of the growth characteristics and also established that the rate controlling step in the process was carbon diffusion through the catalyst particle. In more recent years (14-17) it has been recognized that the structural perfection of the deposited carbon solid is a parameter that is governed by the nature and shape of the catalyst particle and crystallographic orientation of the precipitating faces as shown schematically in Figure 2a-2c. In addition, symmetrical diffusion of carbon species through the particle will give rise to a relatively straight structure. In contrast, when certain additives are present in the metal particle the diffusion characteristics are modified and this factor causes a non-balanced process that results in the formation of coiled structures.

METHODS OF INHIBITING CATALYTIC CARBON FORMATION

The realization that the chemical and physical nature of metal particles plays a key role in catalyzing the growth of the filamentous form of carbon and that this material is also responsible for providing a very efficient method of trapping other types of deposit has lead to a number of approaches designed to inhibit its formation. These methods have tended to fall into the categories of either coating treatments of the metal surface with inert materials or the addition of selected compounds to the gas phase that might be expected to poison the activity of the metal towards catalytic carbon formation. From a consideration of the investigations that have been canied out, it is possible to establish a classification for the roles of various additives on the inhibition of filamentous carbon growth (18).

(a) There are some materials that merely provide a physical barrier towards hydrocarbon adsorption and subsequent decomposition on the metal surface, but during repeated temperature cycling tend to spa11 and the coating loses its effectiveness. e.g. Al2O3,

(b) Other additives reduce carbon solubility in the metal catalyst, but have no effect on the carbon diffusion characteristics through the particle, e.g. Moos, wo3 and TazOs

(c) There are cases where an additive can reduce both the solubility of carbon and its diffusion through the metal particles, e.g. SiOz, and finally,

(d) There certain electro-negative elements that when introduced into the either as a pre- treatment or on a continuous basis, effectively modify the chemistq of the metal surface so that it can no longer function as a catalyst to dissociatively chemisorb the carbon-containing gas molecules, e.g. sulfur, phosphorus and halides.

ISSUES THAT NEED TO BE ADDRESSED WITH REGARD TO CATALYTIC CARBON DEPOSITION

When one examines the ramifications of filamentous carbon formation under conditions where such structures are produced on either a metal tube surface or on isolated metal particles supported on a carrier material there are a number of questions that at p in t in time have not been satisfactorily answered. It is not clear whether these fibrous structures merely function as a high surface collection site or if they perform a catalytic function in being able to promote the formation of amorphous carbon from interaction with gas phase reactants. One might also offer a counter argument that an enhancement in the formation of the amorphous carbon component could effectively form a physically blockage of the metal surface, thereby inhibiting its catalytic action with respect to growth of filamentous carbon. A funher factor could have a significant impact on the particular hydrocarbon conversion process is the possible impact of the fibrous material on ttie mass flow of reactants under either gas or liquid phase conditions.

I Bz03

5 2 2

Page 14: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Other potential problems center around the identity and fate of metal particles that perform the catalytic function. While we have established which metals are the most catalytically active for the growth of f h e n t o u s carbon there are still unsolved mysteries surrounding the precise influence of small amounts of a second metal. The addition of very small amounts of silver, tin, or copper to nickel, iron or cobalt can result in a dramatic increase in the ability of the ferromagnetic metal to catalyze the growth of filamentous carbon. Under a typical commercial reactor condition one must be aware that the likelihood of introducing impurity species into a host metal is extremely high and this behavior could have catastrophic effects on the carbon deposition process. Finally, it is imperative that we are able to determine the influence, if any, of the metallic inclusions in the deposit on the sch~ql lez? d-~king step. Ii wuuid 'be perrinent to ask whether such species function as catalysts for the removal of carbon and under these circumstances what is the fate of the metal patticles following the gasification reaction. The ramifications of the difference in behavior of metal particles associated with filamentous carbon during reaction in oxygen is depicted in Figure 3. In the case where the metal facilitates the removal of carbon the particle returns to the original location on the support medium. In contrast, where gasification proceeds without the participation of the metal, then there is a high probability will eventually be swept out of the system by the reactant gas stream. In this context it might be worthwhile in certain reaction systems to consider introducing additives during the decoking cycle that are. known to be good catalysts for the carbon gasification step and that are either benign towards carbon deposition or can easily be removed prior to re- introduction of the hydrocarbon feed.

SUMMARY

In conclusion, it is clear that significant improvements have been made over recent years with respect to controlling the rate of carbon deposition in a selected number of systems. There is, however, a strong case to be made for attention to be focused on some of the fundamental aspects of this problem so more effective treatments can be developed. One must be mindful that such Ueatments may not have universal application and it is necessary to be cognizant of a number of prevailing factors when one is attempting to design an inhibition package for a given system. These aspects include, the nature of the metal surfaces and the reactant molecules, the temperature at which contact between these components will occur and some knowledge of the identity and concentration of possible contaminants that may be present, particularly in the gas phase.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

A large fraction of the work reported here was canied out under a grant from the United States Department of Energy, Basic Energy Sciences, Grant DE-FG02-93ER14358.

REFERENCES I .

2.

3.

4. 5 .

Hofer, L. J. E., in "Catalysis", Vol. 4 (P. H. Emmettxd.) Reinhold Publishing Co.. New York, 1956, p.373. Palmer, H. B., and Cullis, C. F., in "Chemistry and Physics of Carbon", Vol. 1 (P. L. Walker, Jr. ed.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1965, p. 265. Rosuup-Nielsen, J. R., "Steam Reforming Catalysts", Tekorisk Forlay A I S , Danish Technical Press. Inc. 1975. Trimm, D. L., Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 66, 155 (1977). Baker, R. T. K., and Harris, P. S., in "Chemistry and Physics of Carbon". Vol. 14,(P. L. Walker, Jr. and P. A. Thrower, eds.), Marcel Dekker, New York, 1978, p. 83. Bartholomew. C. H., Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng.a!, 67 (1982). B e e r , R. T. K.. Barber, M. A,, Feates, F. S., Harris, P. S., and Waite, R. J., J . Catal .3 . 51 (1972. Lobo, L. S., Trimm, D. L., and Figueiredo, J. L., in "Proc. 5th Intern. Congr. Catalysis, Palm Beach, 1972" (J. W. Hightower, ed.) V01.2, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1973, p. 1125.

9. Alstrup, I., J. Catal. 14p, 241 (1988). 10. Nolan, P. E., Lynch, D. C., and Cutler, A. H., Carbon 2 , 4 7 7 (1994). 11. Presland, A. E. B., Roscoe, C., and Walker. P. L.. Jr.. 3rd.Conf. Ind. Carbon and

6 . 7.

8.

Graphite, London, 1970. 12. Baker, R. T. K., Feates, F. S., and Hams, P. S., Carbon 10.93 (1972). 13. Baker, R. T. K., Hams, P. S., Henderson, J., and Thomas, R. B., Carbon u, 17

(1975). 14. Audi&, M., Oberlin, A., Oberlin, M., Coulon, M., and Bonnetain, L., Carbon 1p,

717 f19R1) - - . , - ~ --,. 15. Yang, R. T., and Chen, J. P., J. Catal. m, 52 (1989). 16. Kim, M. S., Rodriguez, N. M., and Baker, R. T. K.. J. Catal. m, 253 (1992). 17. Rodriguez, N. M., Chambers, A,, and Baker, R. T. K., Langmuir 11,3862 (1995). 18. Baker, R. T. K., and Chludzinski, J. J., J. Catal. 64,464 (1980).

523

Page 15: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

\

Temperature "C

Rgurel. Relativeratesofformationof~threetypesofcarbondepositasafunctionofreactionT

Figure 2. Schemak representation of different types of filamentous carbon sbvctures

Uncatalyzed Gasification e.g. Fe 8 Ni

' 1 600°C

@

600%

- r n s u p p o r t ~ - =support= = s u p p o r t s _.

- - _.

Catalyzed Gasification e.g. Ru 8 Co

Figure 3. Fates of catdyst pmes during gcsjbtion of filamentous carbon in 9

524

Page 16: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Introduction to Hydrocarbon Conversion Science and Achievements of Professor Isao Mochida

Harry Marsh Department of Inorganic Chemistry Uniuersity of Alicante, Aparfado 99

E-03080-Alicante, SPA%

Background to the studies of I. Mochida Fossil fuels, such as coal, petroleum and natural gas (methane), although used domi-

nantly as fuels, either by direct combustion, or to power engines, have other significant uses. Coal is carbonized, directly, to produce metallurgical coke and coal-tar from which is derived coal-tar pitch, this material being a precursor to seberal carbon artifacts. Further, coal can be 'liquefied' to produce acceptable fuels, although the economics for this, currently, are far from favorable. Each of these conversion processes has been studied extensively by Mochida, to produce,industrially acceptable materials, and to be able to use, more effectively, raw materials or feedstocks with less and less acceptable specifications, and to improve the overall economy of the conversion processes.

Likewise, it is with petroleum. Crude petroleum is processed by thermal and vacuum distillation, i-cluding catalytic systems, to produce a variety of liquid fuels, for gasoline, diesel and aircraft engines, and for space heating. Not all of the barrel can be converted to such high value products. There exists a variety of 'pitch residues' from the conversion processes. Mid- century, these residues would be used either as a fuel, or would be converted to a solid in the so-called 'delayed cokers', the solid 'delayed coke' being itself used as a fuel or disposed of in land-fill operations. Mid-century onwards, after W.W. II, saw a tremendous increase in the use

of petroleum, with associated increases in the tonnage of 'pitch residues' which required dis- posal. However, during this growth process it was realized that these 'pitch residues' could have commercial application, and that their status could be raised to that of a 'by-product'. Thus, the 'delayed coker' became more than a disposal unit, it became specialized equipment to produce the required 'sponge' (or 'regular') cokes and 'needle' cokes. Mochida undertook a mas- sive programme of research into the workings of delayed cokers, and improvements in quality of delayed cokes. Delayed cokes find an irreplaceable use in the manufacture of carbon anodes which are used in the Hall-Heroult cells of the aluminum industry, and the large electrodes of the steel industry, used to transmit electrical energy into the crucibles of steel production.

Personal notes: I. Mochida Professor Isao Mochida, born in 1944, took his B. Eng. in the University of Tokyo in

1963, with a M. Eng. also from the University of Tokyo, specializing in Linear Free Energy Relationships in Heterogeneous Catalysis. He joined the University of Kyushu in 1968, and cur- rently has the title of Professor: Institute of Advanced Material Study. During these years in Kyushu, Professor Mochida has published 485 Technical Papers, has written 10 Books and has 25 Patents. He spent one year with Professor Harry Marsh, 1977-1978, in the University of Newcastle upon Tyne, U.K. The scientific community has recognized the massive contribution he has already. made to the ciences associated with coal and petroleum, and their many derivatives, ir? the form of eigl t A ~ a r d s from Societies both within Japan and abroad. Trained initially in catalysis, he has applied this discip1ir.e successfully in his studies associated with carbon science and with coal and petroleum refining. There is more. At the time when relation-

525

Page 17: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

ships between Universities in Japan and Industry needed to be strengthened (and this was a world-wide problem) Mochida worked intensely to build-up a research school, and to relate the findings of this research to the problems which industry was experiencing. Further, this period of time saw a significant growth in the size of research teams from the occasional two or three, to numbers approaching about twenty. And other changes were taking place. These research teams were now including students from outside Japan, and students from Japan were being offered opportunities to study in Universities, worldwide. At the centre of these activities Mochida operated with an apparent limitless energy, with the welfare of his students very much at the fore-front of his thinking. So, simultaneously, massive contributions were made to the sciences of hydrocarbon conversions, and young people were being highly trained to take their place in industrial and academic societies.

New materials: I. Mochida

Mochida has the ability, also, to be extremely innovative. Taking a look at recent issues of the journal Carbon, e.g., Carbon 1996, Mochida has, with his co-authors, studied the axial nano-scale microstructures in graphitized fibers inherited from liquid crystal mesophase. Limitations to thermal conductance, thermal capacity, tensile strength and Young's modulus of fibre materials, and hence limitations in applications, ultimately depend on the continuity of crystal alignments in such fibres. Such studies are to the forefront of research into the applica- tions of fibres and are both timely and relevant. Also, Mochida has recently looked at the carbonization properties of the fullerenes C6o and C70. Further, in the area of new carbon

forms, he has studied the mechanical properties of binderless carbon moulds prepared from heat-treated mesophase pitch of controlled grain size. A similar, but quite distinct problem is that of gas separations. Molecular sieve carbons, similar in behaviour to the microporous zeo- lites, have been known for some years now. Mochida has applied these approaches to the separation of carbon dioxide from coal-bed methane, a mixture of these two gases, usually heavily contaminated with water vapour. Such a separation requires not only a carbon with the appropriate microporosity, but with this contained between surfaces which are of a hydro- phobic nature. The coal-bed methane needs to be of a suitable purity for use in homes and industry.

The mesophase story: I. Mochida

During his career, Mochida has applied his earlier training in catalysis to reactions associated with the formation of carbons, of diverse properties, from various original, aromatic feedstocks. Studies have been published of catalytic syntheses of 'mesophase' pitch from aro- matic hydrocarbons, such processes allowing the molecular design of carbon precursors. Synthetic methods have been developed for the creation of pitches from pure aromatic hydro- carbons using such Lewis acids as HF/BF3 or AlCl3 as catalysts. The preparation of nitrogen-

containing pitches, from quinoline and isoquinoline, is an attempt to understand how differ- ences in locations of nitrogen atoms, within the ring structures of the graphene layer of graphiti- zable carbons, influences the carbonization properties of the starting materials and the proper- ties of the derived carbons.

However, very significar.: contributions of Mochida are with the conversions of coal and petroleum to carbons and further derived materials. These two sources or feedstocks have two aspects in common. Both are very complex organic materials which require careful structural and chemical analyses, and both, on pyrolysis and carbonization, when in the fluid state, are able to form liquid-crystal systems, that is, the so-called mesophase. In simple terms, there are

526

Page 18: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

many 'mesophases' which give the diverse structures to graphitizable carbons. Mesophases are generated from molecules (mesogens), size ~1,000 u, formed during carbonizations of coals and pitches. Mesogens, themselves, possess a wide range of chemical reactivity, and it is this varia- tion which results in liquid crystal formation of differing size and ability to coalesce. Herein lies another long story. It is the 'crystallinity' of these liquid-crystals which is carried over into the solid phase of the carbon or coke, and which imparts the associated properties of anisotropy and graphitizability. By way of comparison, if wood v.?!eriz! a a phenohc resin is carbonized,

limited structural order, is isotropic, and certainly is non-graphitizable.

uri+l..-..L .. .r.VY. - pdSSing through a fluid phase, then the resultant carbon, although not amorphous, is of

Coal carbonization: I. Mochida As far as coal is concerned it has to be recognized that 'coal materials' exhibit a wide

range of chemical and physical properties, called 'coal rank'. The youngest of coals, the lignites and brown coals, with their internal co-valent bonding, do not fuse on carbonization, but pro- duce carbons (or chars) which are meso- and micro-porous and hence have the properties of an

adsorbent. As the rank range is traversed, the co-valent bonding is progressively replaced by hydrogen bonding and Van der Waals bonding, this enabling the coals to fuse on Carbonization. The structure of the coal also becomes progressively more aromatic in content. With a further increase in rank, it is found that this fusibility, or softening or plasticity reaches a maximum to descend to zero in the semi-anthracites and anthracites, where the weak hydrogen bonding is replaced by carbon to carbon co-valent bonding. It is the coals with descending fusibility which have coking ability. However, the making of metallurgical coke no longer depends upon the use of a single coal being fed to the coking ovens. Rather, quite often, more than ten coals are previ- ously blended and it is the blend which is charged to the coke ovens to be subsequently car- bonized. Each of the ten or more coals, on their own, would not make a metallurgical coke. Procedures involving co-carbonizations of the coal (coal blend) with additives of high solubility parameters and hydrogen transfer ability were developed. It is this theory of the carbonization process, the interactions within the mixed fused states, and the formation of liquid-crystal sys- tems and the fusing of these liquid-aystals, which has enabled the technology of coke-making to advance in the way it has done.

Coal, essentially, and considering the vitrinite macerals, is an organic, macromolecular system, containing microporosity. The ability of the coal to fuse (depolymerize) is a function of the strength of bonding within the macromolecular networks. Pyrolysis of coal produces molecular degradation to form the plastic (liquid) system. Subsequent carbonization brings about dehydrogenative polymerization of the dominantly aromatic molecules within plastic coal such that when the molecular size is about 1,000 u, formation of liquid crystals occurs and coke structure is established. Depolymerization of higher activation energies is favoured at higher temperatures, with rapid heating to prevent the retrogressive reactions at lower temperatures. Rapid heating under pressure is favorable with the use of additives in co-carbonizations because they have an enhanced fadlity for dissolution in the coal and reaction at higher temper- atures. Mochida has submitted a proposal to the Ministry of International Trade and Industry and Japanese Association of Iron and Steel Making, which outlines coke-making procedures to be adopted in the next decade. The proposal includes coal pretreatment, rapid heating to enhance the fusibility for coke strength, by lower temperature of calcination, and potential for anisotropic development, hot moulding, and carbonization at controlled heating rates. The application of such a scheme would widen the range of usable coals, would make coke making less energy intensive, improving quality and productivity, and suggesting the possibility of a continuous rather than a batch process of coke making.

527

Page 19: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

Coal liquefaction: I. Mochida A thorough understanding of the macromolecular structures of coal, of bondings within

and between these macromolecules, as well as the microporosity (so enabling reactive molecules to enter into coal structure) has enabled Mochida to improve the process of coal liquefaction. Early on, he demonstrated the importance of coal liquefaction solvents in terms of their boiling range, their dissolving ability and capacity as well as the reactivity of hydrogen donating molecules. Hydrogen donors not only stabilize radicals from coal pyrolysis but also lead to bond fissure of the rather more stable bridges, so achieving larger extents of depolymerization and hence of oil yield. In the area of liquefaction catalysts, the contribution of Mochida is with the design, the recovery and regeneration of catalysts, proposing the use of Ti@ and carbon.

He has advanced integrated schemes which include coal pretreatment, coal dissolution using donors at high temperatures, with two or three steps for the catalytic upgrading, such as hydro- desulfurization and hydrodenitrification.

Activated cokes (carbons): I. Mochida Professor Mochida applied his combined understanding of coal chemistry and structure,

as well as surface chemistry and heterogeneous catalysis to the production of activated carbons from coal, with the viewpoint of efficient removal of oxides of nitrogen and sulfur from com- bustion gases. Using a bituminous coal, he produced an activated carbon of higher performance characteristics than that of Bergbau Forschung (now DMT). He found (a) that the activity of the carbon for NOx reduction, using ammonia, is intimately related to the oxygen functionality associated with the oxidatively adsorbed SOL (b) that nitrogen functional groups introduced into the carbon, during the stage of the NH3-No reaction, enhance the NOx reduction, and (c) that the regeneration of SO2 adsorption activity, after SO2 recovery, relates to extents of sur- face oxygen complexes contained on carbon surfaces. Removal of SOx and NO, using activated coke (from coal) is now commercialized in Japan. The same principles have been applied to activated carbon fibers from PAN (polyacrylonitrile).

528

Page 20: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

TECHNOLOGICAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE COAL AND HEAVY PETROLEUM UP-GRADING TO FUTURE SOCIETY

lsao Mochida Institute of Advanced Material Study, Kyushu University,

6-1 Kasugakoen, Kasuga, Fukuoka 816, Japan

INTRODUCTION Energy basically obtained from the fossil carbonaceous resources on the earth will suffer

the shortaze nfw:p!;r ixixi$!y dice io iapkiiy growing demand in the developing countries of large population, Huge consumption of the resources will bring about significant damages to the global environment. Hence, extensive up-grading of petroleum and coal at very high efficiency, energy saving, and environmental protection should be pursued at the same time. The correct structure of fossil resources, molecular transformation of their complete conversion and reforming by multi-stage scheme, catalysis and catalyst designs for the respective stage, molecular transformation into the carbon of high performances for energy saving and environmental protection are the targets of current research.

In the present paper, concepts and results in such areas that have been studied by the author for 20 years are overviewed.

Structural Understanding of Coal and Petroleum Coal and petroleum are both complex mixtures of hydrocarbons. Their heaviest ends are

targets of detail structural analyses. Coal has been characterized by its maceral compositions and ranks, which tell us

empirical but useful correlations on its properties. Recent approach is to clarify its structure on molecular basis. Basically heavy molecules in the coal are polynuclear polyaromatic hydrocarbons with heteroatoms and alkyl substituents. Sizes of molecule and aromatic ring, number of nuclei, bindings among nuclei, moiety of heteroatoms, number and length of alkyl substituents are primary factors of molecules. The distribution of the factors is concerned while the molecular weight is estimated around 1500. Such macromolecular chains are entangled each other to form colloid or micelle which occludes smaller molecules. The bridges among the chains can be covalent or non-covalent. Recent study indicates that non-covalent bonds among the chains are breakable rather easily by physical as well as chemical pretreatment at least in active macerals, providing high solubility and fusibility after the liberation. Non-covalent bridges are hydrogen bond, charge transfer interaction, aromatic ring stacking and metallic ion bridges. The author emphasized the carboxyl linkage and their coordination to divalent cations in lower ranking coals as shown in Figure 1. Although the complete picture of coal molecules is not disclosed yet, analysis based on such a profile of molecules gives us an image of its chemical nature.

The asphaltene is another target of structural study, while the molecules in naphtha, gas oil, vacuum gas oil and maltene are fairly clarified, their accuracy depending on their molecular size and type of structure. The asphaltene is soluble in benzene, but is believed to be present in the micelle or an entangled assembly, molecular weight of the component being beyond 10,000. Molecular assembly of the asphaltene in vacuum residue should be clarified at elevated and ambient temperatures. The present authors have hydrogenated 99% of hexane insoluble component into hexane soluble. Interestingly, solubilized asphaltene inherits the basic metal porphyrin structures. Structural change at this solubilization gives us some keys to elucidate the molecular assembly in the asphaltene.

Molecular Transformation of Coal and Heavv Petroleum When coal and heavy fraction of asphaltene are heated, their molecular assembly is to be

liberated to give a fused state from coal and solution from the asphaltene. Solvent present or added plays an important role to produce such a liquid state. In another situation without adequate solvent or with strong intermolecular linkages, condensation reactions of macromolecules can take place within the cage of molecular assembly, giving less soluble and less fusible component. Hence, the decoagulation of molecular assembly prior to the heating is claimed by the author very favorable to suppress such retrogressive reactions. The condensed product, thus produced, is called char or isotropic carbon with least stacking of aromatic planes. The author emphasizes the importance of hydrogen donor and dissolving activity of the solvent.

The polymeric substances in the liquid state can be depolymerized through the breakage of the weakest intermolecular linkages. Such breakage can be spontaneous, hydrogenation assisted, and hydrogenolysis as schematically illustrated in Figure 2. The fissured linkage can be capped with hydrogen to give smaller molecules, otherwise another type of condensation reaction takes place to give large molecule of more stability, leading to carbonaceous product. Such a process can be defined as carbonization or coking, being a principle pathway to produce carbon materials of functionality or process-troubles such as sludge, plugging and carbonaceous poisons as described later. Competitive reaction scheme is illustrated in Figure 3. Hydrogenation-assisted and hydrogenolysis breakages are performed with hydrogen donors at rather high temperature and rapid heating.

The limitation in such mechanisms of depolymerization is certainly present in the reactivities of acceptors and donors, limiting the extent of depolymerization. The catalyst can

529

Page 21: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

I

I 1

perform further depolymerization through the hydrogenation, acidic and hydro-cracking to give distillates.

s and for t u o l e c u l a r Conves lne The catalysts can hydrogenate the aromatic ring and break the single C-C, C-S, C-N, C - 0

bonds due to their hydrogenation activity originating from transition metal components and their acidity. The hydrogenation produces hydrogen donor, caps the free radical, and saturates the double bonds to be fissured by acidity. The aromatic ring can be opened into chain molecule through the successive steps of hydrogenation and acidic bond fission. Alkylation and trans- alkylation modify the nature of aromatic species.

The hydrogenation can suppress the retrogressive and coking reactions though the control of condensation reactions and enhancing fusibility or solubility. On the other hand, acidity of the catalyst adsorbs strongly the polar molecules, trapping them on the surface for a long time while the condensation reaction take places consecutively, leading to the carbon or coke on the catalyst surface..

Demetallation, desulfurization, denitrogenation and deoxygenation are major catalytic reactions for up-grading the hydrocarbon fuels. The molecular conversions pathways involved in the reactions are now being schematically described, although the difficulty increases with increasing molecular size because of difficulty in their molecular identification.

Another important factor is the intermolecular interactions in the liquid phase and on the catalyst surface. In some combinations, such interaction enhances the reaction while retards the reaction in other cases. Desulfurization of gas oil has been described on molecular bases. Chemistry involved in the desulfurization of 4,6-dimethyldibenzothiophene has been clarified.

The catalysts of better performances such as longer life, easy recovery and regeneration as well as high activity and selectivity are continuously looked for. The catalytic species and support are combined to achieve high performance, their chemical as well as physical interactions being concerned. Carbon and titania are reported to provide non-polar surface of intimate interaction with the catalytic species. Very fine particles of carbon as photographed in Figure 4 are well dispersed and recoverable from ash minerals. New materials and new combinations are examined to obtain multi-functions.

The catalysis schemes are designed to allow the best performances of the catalysts. Optimum conditions are present to the optimum feed on the respective catalyst. Multi-stage reaction scheme is thus appropriate for the complete and selective conversion of coal and heavy petroleum, selecting the best catalyst and conditions for the respective stage. Solvent plays an important role even in the catalytic reactions.

Molecular Conversion of Coal a o d v v P e t r Q h m into Carbons of High Performances

Carbons produced from coal and heavy petroleum are very indispensable by their high performances in the modem industry. Blast furnace coke, needle coke, carbon fiber and a variety of carbon artifacts are the case. Majority of such carbons is graphitizable through the ordered stacking of aromatic planes which is built in the early stage of carbonization. The mesophase or discotic liquid crystal is the intermediate state and product, leading to such carbons.

It is emphasized that the condensation into large aromatic planes and their stacking are balanced by selecting the feed, additive, preparative conditions and even catalysts of easy separation to form the mesophase. The author particularly emphasized roles of additives of hydrogen donating and dissolving activity. Molecular structure and molecular assembly at micro-, meso- and macro-scopic levels have been analyzed, and their relation to their properties is established. Figure 5 illustrates microscopic views of mesophase, its as-spun and carbonized fibers. Thus, the carbons of high performance are designed through the preparation of precursor, and control of carbonization, graphitization, and forming on chemical and physical bases.

Carbon Mater ials for Enernv Savine and En vironmental P r o t e c t h The energy saving and environmental protection are the key issues for the effective use of

resources. Carbon can provide some of excellent devices for these purposes. High strength per weight, high thermal conductivity, rapid and large adsorption and desorption, catalytically active surface of carbon fiber and active carbon fibers are such cases. Detail structural control for aromatic molecules including substituents and heteroatoms, and their stacking is the base for the design of the mesophase pitch and hence its derived high performance carbons. Very high strength and thermal conductivity are now achieved from aromatic hydrocarbon derived mesophase pitches prepared with HFBF3.

The author proposed a novel scheme of SOX and NOx removal over activated carbon fibers of controlled surface as shown in Figure 6. The calcination after the activation was found very effective to increase the activity for SOX oxidation and NOx reduction.

The authors is very grateful to all of his colleagues and many students at Kyushu University, a number of friends in the academics and industries of international linkages for their significant cowork and helps, and expresses special thanks to Professors Kenjiro Takeshita, Tetsuro Seiyama, Yukio Yoneda, John C. Bailar Jr.. and Harry Marsh for their continuous guidance and friendship for many years of his research.

530

Page 22: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

pig.? Hydrogen-transferrins liquefaction mechanism (1) Ilydrogenative stabilization of fragmental radicals (2) Hydrogenative bond-loosening ( 3 ) llydroqenatlve bond-dissociation

(moiecu~ar hydrogen participation)

m

' SRC-CHAR

531

Page 23: VISUALIZATION OF COMPLEX HYDROCARBON REACTION SYSTEMS. archive/Files/Merge/Vol-41... · Visualization of Complex Hydrocarbon Reaction Systems John H. Shinn, Chevron Research and Technology

H O . l p m

Figure 4 TEM photomicrograph of Ketjen Black

Figure 5 HR-SEM of mesophase pitch carbon fiber

De-SOX

so2 0 2 H 2 0 H20

De-NOx H 2 0

Figure 6 A Novel Scheme of SOX and NOx Removal over ACF

532