vol.8 issue 24 - oct 17-oct 23, 2015

Upload: thesouthasian-times

Post on 07-Aug-2018

222 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    1/32

    By Parveen Chopra 

    New York South Asians in America

    are set to witness history as icons

    of cricket will be seen in action on

    American soil for the first time in

    November. The inaugural T20

    match will be played at the Citi

    Field baseball stadium in New Yorkon Nov 7.

    "It's been my dream to help

    bring the best of cricket to

    America. Cricket is the second

    most popular sport in the world

    (after soccer) and we couldn't have

    asked for better partners than

    Sachin Tendulkar and Shane

    Warne on this exciting venture,”

    Ben Sturner told The South Asian

    Times. He is founder, CEO and

    President of NYC based Leverage

    Agency, which is producingCricket All‑Stars and will also han‑

    dle the marketing and promotion

    for the mega event. Sturnerʼs aim

    The South Asian Timese x c e l l e n c e i n j o u r n a l i s m

    excellence in journalism SPIRITUAL AWARENESS 30OP ED 12 MEDIA 16 MUSIC 25

    Ben Sturner (middle) is the founder‑CEO of Leverage Agency in NYC,which is producing and marketing Cricket All‑Stars series.

    (Photo: Leverage)

    BENJAMIN STURNER

    Vol.8 No. 24 October 17-23, 2015 60 Cents New York Edition Follow us on TheSouthAsianTimes.info

    The AmericanKerry Packer

    Continued on page 4

    Bringing cricket in an epic way to US shores in partnershipwith Sachin Tendulkar and Shane Warne.

    New York The Obama adminis‑

    tration is exploring a deal with

    Pakistan that would limit the

    scope of Pakistanʼs nuclear

    arsenal, the fastest‑

    growing on earth.

    The discussions are

    the first in the decade

    since one of the

    founders of its

    nuclear program,

    Abdul Qadeer Khan, was

    caught selling the countryʼsnuclear technology around the

    world.

    The talks are being held in

    advance of the arrival of Prime

    Minister Nawaz Sharif in

    Washington next

    week. They focus on

    American concern

    that Pakistan might be

    on the verge of 

    deploying a small

    tact ical nuclear

    weapon ̶ explicitly modeled

    on weapons the United Statesput in Europe during the Cold

    War to deter a Soviet invasion ̶

    that would be far harder to

    secure than the countryʼs arsenal

    of larger weapons, New York

    Times reported. But outside

    experts familiar with the discus‑

    sions, which have echoes of the

    Obama administrationʼs first

    approaches to Iran on its nuclear

    program three years ago,

    expressed deep skepticism that

    Pakistan is ready to put any limi‑

    tations on a program that is the

    US mulling deal to limit Pak nukes arsenal: NYT report

    Washington Unlike the frontrun‑

    ner for GOP nomination, Donald

    Trump, who is widely seen as

    somebody who will eventually

    drop out, Hillary Clinton seems to

    have sealed her place as the Dems

    nominee after the first Democratic

    presidential debate on Tuesday inLas Vegas hosted by CNN.

    Such was Hillaryʼs commanding

    performance that she put the dis‑

    rupter Bernie Sanders in his place,

    and also blocked Vice President

     Joseph R. Bidenʼs entry point, who

    would have been in demand if she

    kept faltering as in the past she fell

    prey to revelations about her use

    Hillary Clinton stronger aftercommanding debate showing

    Hillary Clinton with Housing and Urban Development Secretary JulianCastro Thursday at a rally in San Antonio, Texas.

    If she wins Dems nomination, she’d lookhard at a Latino as running mate.

    Continued on page 4

    New York The Indo‑American Press Club (IAPC) held its secondInternational Media Conference in Ronkonkoma, NY, over theColumbus Day weekend, bringing together an array of eminent jour‑nalists and media experts. The honorees were Daya Bai (originallyMercy Mathew), a social activist working for and living with the tribalsin Madhya Pradesh; and Boby Chemmanur, founder chairman of aninternational jewelry chain who shares some of the profit from hisbusiness with the poor, starting homes for them wherever there are his

     jewelry stores; & VK Ebrahimkunju, Keralaʼs Minster for Public Works.

    Daya Bai and Boby Chemmanur honored

    by Indo-American Press Club

    Continued on page 4

    For the first interview of Ben with The South Asian Times,the proud Print Media Partner of Cricket All-Stars series, go to page 17.For detailed story and more pictures, turn to page 16.

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    2/32

    TheSouthAsianTimes.info  October 17-23, 2015

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    3/32

    3October 17-23, 2015TheSouthAsianTimes.info  TR I S TATE COMMUNI TY

    By Jinal Shah

    N e w Y o r k The Asia Society on

    Tuesday honored boxing champion

    Manny Pacquiao and three persons

    of Indian origin among its second

    annual class of Asia Game Changers

    for making a transformative and

    positive difference for the future of 

    Asia and the world.

    The award ceremony, held at the

    United Nations, honored the CEO of 

    ICICI bank and the first woman to

    head an Indian bank, Chanda

    Kochhar, comedian and actor Aasif 

    Mandvi, founder, Design for Change

    and the Riverside School champion

    of youth volunteerism, Kiran BirSethi.

    At the awards event, Josette

    Sheeran, Asia Society's President

    and CEO, noted the insufficient

    recognition Asians receive despite

    their remarkable contributions to

    the world. “More than 950 Nobel

    prizes have been awarded since

    1901, and less than 6% have gone

    to Asians ‑‑ even though 60 percent

    of the world's population is in Asia

    and Asia has 50 percent of the

    world's patents,” she said. "We at

    Asia Society want to recognize the

    brilliance of Asia ‑‑ those who are

    changing the world for the better."

    Asia Society selected the hon‑

    orees through a survey of over

    1,000 global leaders who inspired

    the world to do things differently.

    Last year, Chinese billionaire Jack

    Ma, of Alibaba fame, neurologist

    Pawan Sinha and co‑founder and

    CEO of Pratham Education

    Foundation Madhav Chavan werethe honorees.

    Kochhar was honored not only for

    breaking the glass ceiling but also

    for transforming the banking indus‑

    try through technology and empow‑

    ering the masses by bringing bank‑

    ing services to rural areas.

    “I stand here as a proud Indian,

    proud of all the strides that my

    country has made so far but even

    more proud of the potential that

    the country offers all of us to make

    an impact to whatever we do in our

    country,” she said. “I accept this

    award on behalf of everybody who

    works for financial inclusion

    because banking and technologytogether can create a transforma‑

    tional impact by bringing millions

    of unbanked people into the bank‑

    ing fold.”

    Talking to The South Asian Times,

    Kochhar said the infamous glass

    ceiling is a myth. “The ceiling is

    really in the minds of the girls and

    the women themselves. We all haveto free ourselves up of that inhibi‑

    tion and if we believe, we can do it

    all ‑ have a great family life and at

    the same time have a great career,”

    she said.

    Kiran Bir Sethi, honored for

    empowering children to change the

    world, spoke of the importance of 

    spotlighting educators. "It's because

    of honors like this that the response

    goes from 'oh, you're just a teacher'

    to 'teachers are game changers.”

    Aasif Mandvi was awarded for

    using comedy to challenge stereo‑

    types of Muslims and Asian

    Americans. Pacquiao credited his

    humble beginnings for his workoutside the boxing ring. He rose to

    global stardom as a result of his

    sensational performances in the

    ring and has utilized his star pres‑

    ence to increase awareness on

    social issues such as human traf‑

    ficking, poverty and the plight of 

    his countrymen during calamities.

    New York The Network of Indian

    Professionals, North America (NetIP NA)

    hosted their Silver Jubilee Anniversary con‑

    ference Oct 9‑11 at Marriott Marquis hotel

    here. Among the 600 attendees were

    keynote speaker Preet Bharara, U.S.

    Attorney for the Southern District of New

    York, former Miss America Nina Davuluri,

    comedian Hari Kondabolu, Sree

    Sreenivasan, chief digital officer at the

    Metropolitan Museum of Art, Jimmy Soni,

    author and former managing editor of The

    Huffington Post, and NetIP Founder Dr.

    Satish Chandra.

    NetIPʼs annual conference brings together

    South Asian professionals, empowering

    them to explore their heritage and move

    beyond their traditional boundaries. The

    theme for 2015 “Begin Again" aims to

    inspire individuals to reinvest in the organi‑

    zations and communities in which they live

    and work.

    For the first time organizations such as

    AAPI NYC Metro, SABA NYC, SAJA, TiE and

    SAALT have worked together on such a

    large platform. These col laborations

    allowed NetIP to feature panels on Health,

    Legal Advice, Media, Technology,

    Unconventional Careers, Non Profit, and

    Cooking. Special events included the

    screening of ʻGirl Rising ‑ Woh Padegi Woh

    Udegiʼ, a health fair sponsored by AAPI NYC

    Metro, Comedy Show, Fashion Show byIndiaʼs POPUP and a Shark Tank like

    Startup Competition hosted by Sava360.

    "What a wonderful group of individuals to

    share my story about diversity, cultural

    competency, and Girl Rising," said Davuluri,

    the emcee of the event.

    “As we look ahead into the next 25 years,

    NetIP will continue its mission to serve as

    the voice for the South Asian diaspora by

    developing and engaging a cohesive net‑

    work of professionals to benefit the com‑munity," said Dhaval Shah, President of 

    NetIP North America.

    NetIP has 23 chapters across North

    America with 60% of members having grad‑

    uate or professional degrees and over 35%

    working for Fortune 1000 companies.

    NetIPʼs Silver Conference hosts over 600 professionals

    (from left) Aasif Mandvi, Mariam al‑Mansouri, Kiran Bir Sethi, Li Cunxin,Manny Pacquiao and Chanda Kochhar were among the honorees.

    (Photo: Asia Society)

    Asia Society honors 3 of Indianorigin as game changers

    Community support for Santino and Nasrin Ahmad

    Prominent Indian American community members on Long Island extended theirsupport recently to Tony Santino for Supervisor and Nasrin Ahmad for Clerk of Townof Hempstead. The election is on Nov 3. Indian American Voters Forum has appealed

    all to vote for Santino and Ahmad.

    Preet Bharara, Nina Davuluri and comedian Hari Kondaboluat the conference. (Photos: Jay Mandal)

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    4/32

    Garden C ity N Y : Nartan Rang

    Dance Academy of Bharatiya

    Vidya Bhavan hosted one of the

    biggest Navratri celebrations on

    Long Island on Oct 10 at MitchellField Athletic Complex in Garden

    City, NY. It was a festive affair

    with the full support of the com‑

    munity, and people of all ages

    enjoyed and joined the celebra‑

    tion to worship Amba Mata. A

    live orchestra led by Naishad

    Pandya and his group of seven

    musicians enthralled the devo‑

    tees with new and traditional

    garba and dandiya raas. The cel‑

    ebrations lasted for over four

    hours, with the attendees asking

    for more. "This was the fourth annual Navratri event

    and the participation and enthusiasm from the devo‑

    tees has grown multifold. Almost 400 people attend‑

    ed the event this year with full vigor and devotion,"

    said Swati Vaishnav, Board of 

    Director of Bharatiya Vidya

    Bhavan. Most of the festivities

    have now shifted to New Jersey

    and it was my passion to bringgarba raas to Long Island to

    make it more convenient for

    people in the area to attend, she

    added.

    People appreciated the large

    Mitchell Field venue which can

    easily accommodate up to 700

    people with ample room to

    dance freely, as well as free

    parking. The primary aim of 

    Nartan Rang Dance Academy

    continues to be the promotion

    of the awareness of Indian tradi‑

    tion & culture among today's youth, as well as giving

    those who miss the festivals from the motherland an

    opportunity to celebrate here in the US. Next year's

    Navratri will be held on October 8, 2016.

    Washington: Upset over the ground

    rules for the next Republican presi‑

    dential debate, frontrunners Donald

    Trump and Ben Carson are threaten‑

    ing to boycott the Oct 28 showdown

    on CNBC unless the debate format is

    changed. Media mogul Trump and

    noted neurosurgeon Carson, the two

    non‑politician candidates, who have

    been leading the Republican field in

    recent polls, are seeking an overall

    time limit on the debate, given that the

    last one went on for three hours, and the ability to

    make opening and closing statements.

    According to latest Real Clear Politics average of 

    poll Trump leads the Republican pack with 23.4 per‑

    cent votes followed by Carson with 19.1 percent.

    Establishment favorite Jeb Bush has fallen to the

    fifth place with 7.3 percent.

    "Neither Mr. Trump or Dr. Carson

    will participate in your debate if it is

    longer than 120 minutes including

    commercials and does not include

    opening and closing statements,"

    they wrote in a letter to CNBC

    Thursday.

    CNBC spokesman Brian Steel indi‑

    cated in a statement that the net‑

    work might change the format to

    accede to Carson's and Trump's

    demands. "Our practice in the past

    has been to forego opening statements to allow

    more time to address the critical issues that matter

    most to the American people," he said. "We started a

    dialogue yesterday with all of the campaigns

    involved and we will certainly take the candidates'

    views on the format into consideration as we finalize

    the debate structure."

    Chairman and Co-Founder

    Kamlesh C. Mehta

    Co-Founder: Saroosh Gull

    ([email protected])

    President: Arjit Mehta

    Chief Operating Officer:

    Ginsmon P. Zacharia

    P: 516 776 7061

    [email protected]

    Board Advisors (Honorary)

    Ajay Lodha, MD,

    Lakhpat B. Mehta, Esq.

    Rajasthan High Court & Supreme Court

    Managing Editor: Parveen Chopra

    P : 516.710.0508

    [email protected]

    Associate Editors Jinal Shah,

    Hiral Dholakia-Dave, Meenakshi Iyer 

    Contributing Editors: Ni lima Madan,

    Melvin Durai, Dr Prem Kumar Sharma,

    Harry Aurora, Ashok Vyas,

    Dr Akshat Jain, Nupur Joshi

    Contributing Editors (Youth):

    Rhea Gupta, Shweta Lodha, Sidharth Goyal

    West Coast Correspondent

    Pooja Jain,

    [email protected]

    New Delhi Bureau

    Meenakshi Iyer 

    [email protected]

    Strategy and Marketing

    Jinal Shah

    P: 315-436-1142

     [email protected]

    Marketing & PR (Washington DC)

    Chander Gambhir, P: 703.717.1667

    Jaipur (India) Bureau

    Prakash Bhandari

    [email protected]

    Photographs: Gunjesh Desai/

    masalajunction.com.

    Xitij Joshi/xitijphoto.com

    Photo Journalist: Sandeep Ganatra

    Cartoonist: Mahendra Shah

    Art and Design: Vladimir Tomovski

    Bhagwati Creations,

    Dhiraj Kumar 

    Web Editor: B.B.Chopra

    News Service: HT Media Ltd.

    IANS Newswire Services

    IANS Washington Bureau

    Arun Kumar 

    arun.kumar@ians,in

    Printing: Five Star Printing, NY

    Contacts

    [email protected]

    [email protected]

    Advertisements

    [email protected]

    P : 516.390.7847, F : 516.465.1343

    Website:

    www.TheSouthAsianTimes.info

    Notice: The South Asian Times is published weekly by The Forsythe Media Group, LLC. POSTMASTER: Send all address notices, subscription orders/payments and other inquiries to The South Asian

    Times, 76 N Broadway, Suite 2004, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA. Copyright and all other rights reserved. No material herein or portions thereof may be reprinted without the consent of the publisher. The

    views expressed on the opinion pages and in the letters to the editor pages are those of the writers and do not necessarily reflect those of The South Asian Times. The editor/publisher does not warrant accuracy

    and cannot be held responsible for the content of the advertisements placed in the publication and/or inaccurate claims, if any, made by the advertisers. Advertisements of business or facilities included in this

     publication do not imply connection or endorsement of these businesses. All rights reserved.

    4 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info TURN P AGE

    Printed Every Saturday by: Forsythe Media Group, LLC, ISSN 1941-9333, 76 N Broadway, Suite 2004, Hicksville, NY 11801 P: 516.390.7847

    Website: TheSouthAsianTimes.info Updated Daily

    The American Kerry Packer

    Continued from page 1

    is to inspire a generation in the hope

    that cricket takes off in a big way in

    America and to make people excited

    about the sport. Undoubtedly South

    Asians have been starved of cricket in

    America. "A big showcase like this

    hopefully will make cricket consid‑

    ered as very cool. And cricket will

    make South Asian culture cool inAmerica,” he assures.

    “I donʼt just support cricket, but

    support culture,” Sturner asserts. “I

    want everyone to come out. Besides

    the actual matches, there will be

    galas, meet and greet events, fun mer‑

    chandise and memorabilia.”

    If all goes according to plan,

    Sturnerʼs name will get etched in

    cricketing history books along with

    saviors and promoters of the gentle‑

    manʼs game like the Australian Kerry

    Packer, who founded World Series

    Cricket in 1977 and made one‑day

    cricket popular.

    US mulling deal to limit Pak

    Continued from page 1

    pride of the nation, and that it

    regards as its only real defense

    against India.

    The discussions are being led by

    Peter R. Lavoy, a longtime intelligence

    expert on the Pakistani program who

    is now on the staff of the National

    Security Council. White House offi‑

    cials declined to comment on the

    talks ahead of Sharifʼs visit.

    But the central element of the pro‑

    posal, according to other officials and

    outside experts, would be a relaxation

    of the strict controls imposed on

    Pakistan by the Nuclear Suppliers

    Group, a loose affiliation of nationsthat try to control the proliferation of 

    weapons.

    “If Pakistan would take the actions

    requested by the US, it would essen‑

    tially amount to recognition of reha‑

    bilitation and would essentially

    amount to parole,” said George

    Perkovich, vice president for studies

    at the Carnegie Endowment for

    International Peace, who has main‑

    tained contacts with the Pakistani

    nuclear establishment.

    “I think itʼs worth a try,” Perkovich

    said. “But I have my doubts that the

    Pakistanis are capable of doing this.”

    Hillary Clinton stronger after

    Continued from page 1

    of a private email server as secretaryof state. But with Mrs. Clinton turning

    her negatives into positives and show‑

    ing her mettle in the CNN debate,

    Democrats are now increasingly con‑

    vinced that questions about her

    emails are little more than a

    Republican and news media fixation.

    Even Sanders came to her defense on

    the email issue.

    On Thursday, she won the backing

    of Housing and Urban Development

    Secretary Julian Castro and said she

    would seriously consider making the

    rising Hispanic leader her running

    mate if she wins her party's nomina‑

    tion. Clinton and the other Democrats

    in the November 2016 race for theWhite House have pushed hard for

    support among Hispanics, a fast‑

    growing and critical voting bloc that

    has moved toward Democrats in

    recent elections as Republicans have

    stymied comprehensive immigration

    reform in Congress and disparaged

    Mexican immigrants on the campaign

    trail.

     "I am going to look really hard at

    him for anything, because that's how

    good he is," Clinton said at a U.S.

    Hispanic Chamber of Commerce

    meeting in San Antonio, Texas, when

    asked if Castro might be her vice

    presidential pick.

    Appearing with Clinton at a later"Latinos for Hillary" rally, Castro said

    he has long respected her ability to

    appeal to people of all backgrounds.

     Clinton condemned the hardline

    comments about immigration that

    have been prominent in the

    Republican presidential race, particu‑

    larly by Donald Trump.

    Most of the festivities have nowshifted to New Jersey and it was mypassion to bring garba raas to Long

    Island, said Swati Vaishnav.

    Republican presidentialcandidate Donald Trump

    Nartan Rang Dance Academy hostsNarvratri celebrations on Long Island

    Frontrunners Trump, Carson threatento boycott next GOP Debate

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    5/32

    5October 17-23, 2015TheSouthAsianTimes.info  TR I S TATE COMMUNI TY

    By Jinal Shah

    N e w Y o r k The Giving Back

    Foundation (GBF) last Thursday

    honored Hollywood actress

    Phylicia Rashad and Indian entre‑

    preneur, author, columnist and

    socialite Suhel Seth at its second

    gala hosted at The Carlyle in New

    York City.

    Founded by philanthropist Meera

    Gandhi in 2010, GBFʼs mission is to

    mitigate poverty, illness and suffer‑

    ing, empower women through edu‑

    cation. It partners with other chari‑

    ty groups and beneficiaries around

    the world, in order to allocate

    resources and empower underpriv‑

    ileged people, and has several part‑

    ners in India.

    The organizat ion honored

    Rashad for her philanthropic work

    and Seth for his active role in social

    change in India. “We do what we

    do because we are part of this uni‑

    verse and the universe gives and so

    should we,” said Rashad while

    accepting her award. Seth, who

    flew from India to attend the gala,

    said, “We live in troubled times in

    India. GDP is not a modicum of suc‑

    cess of a society. What is, is the

    rule of law, what is, is the rule of 

    tolerance, and what is, is the meas‑

    ure of giving back.”

    He further talked about what the

    worldʼs oldest democracy, India,

    and worldʼs largest democracy,

    America, can teach each other. He

    even called India and America

    “twins joined at the hip.”

    “India is not a poor country nor

    is America. India has impoverished

    sections and they are impoverished

    because there is a denial of oppor‑

    tunity for lack of education, health‑

    care…to my mind India teaches

    America three things –the value of 

    values, the value of culture and the

    value of history. What America

    teaches us in abundance is the

    value of law, value of giving back

    and value of innovation.

    “I am not proud of the ʻrich listsʼ

    that the world produces. I will be

    delighted if The New York Times

    ever creates a ʻgive list ,” Seth

    added. At the event, a 20‑minute

    PBS documentary, originally aired

    on June 28, highlighting Meera

    Gandhi charityʼs work at Delhiʼs St.

    Michaelʼs school and hostel was

    shown. Rev. Timothy Shaw of the

    school blessed the guests from

    New Delhi via Skype.

    GBF supports many programs

    including a 5‑year Giving Back

    Foundation grant to the

    Woodstock Film Festival in

    Woodstock, New York, to encour‑

    age socially uplifting films and sup‑

    porting five girls at the Eleanor

    Roosevelt Leadership Center in

    Hyde Park, NY. The organization

    will soon add another program ‑

    mindfulness program to its exist‑

    ing programs.

    “We have added a third arm to

    our foundation ‑ the mindfulness

    platform. I believe that the rapid

    pace in our world has left our

    minds stripped of peace and joy. To

    address this we will start holding

    mindfulness camps every year with

    gurus like Deepak Chopra and

    Donna Karan. The first 500 camp

    is scheduled for upstate New York

    in July 2016,” Gandhi said.

    There was also an auction of sev‑

    eral glamorous items, all donated

    to GBF.

    Giving Back gala honors PhyliciaRashad and Suhel Seth

    New York A new, $18 million

    outpatient pavilion at St. MaryʼsHealthcare in Amsterdam, NY is

    nearly ready to open, thanks in

    part to a $1 million donation

    from Govind and Jyothi Rao, an

    Indian American couple.

    According to the Daily Gazette,

    the family had previously

    pledged $250,000 to the facility

    at the start of its capital cam‑

    paign last year but increased it

    to $1 million earlier this month,

    according to an announcement

    from St. Maryʼs.

    Construction on the

    40,000‐square‐foot Rao

    Outpatient Pavilion, located next

    to the former AmsterdamMemorial Hospital campus on

    Route 30, got underway last

    October.

    The faci l i ty wi l l include a

    Cancer Medicine Center with

    radiation oncology, medical

    oncology and infusion therapy,

    as well as the Womenʼs Breast

    Health Center, an expanded med‑

    ical imaging center, laboratoryservices, outpatient registration,

    pre‐surgical teaching and test‑

    ing, and a new urgent care cen‑

    ter.

    The pavilion is set to open Oct.

    12. Victor Giulianelli, president

    and CEO of St. Maryʼs Healthcare,

    said the Raos established “an

    exceptional philanthropic pace

    for others” with their initial$250,000 donation, which

    spurred other six‐figure dona‑

    tions.

    Rao runs a pediatric practice in

    Amsterdam. The family, which

    includes eight other pediatri‑

    cians, founded the Neena Rao

    Charitable Corp. to support and

    promote health care and educa‑

    tion for women and children in

    the United States and in India,

    where Rao still has many family

    members.

    Rao said the donation is a way

    for him to give back to the city.

    “Fortunately I have been very

    good in practice. God has beengreat to us,” he said. “My chil‑

    dren are on their own now.

    Theyʼre doing very well. And

    whatever money I have, I donʼt

    take it when I pass away. The

    Amsterdam community helped

    me a lot. So this is my time to

    pay them back.

    New York The Mayorʼs Office of 

    Immigrant Affairs (MOIA) , de

    Blasio Administration officials, and

    others celebrated the accomplish‑ments of the first cohort of MOIAʼs

    Fellowship for Immigrant Women

    Leaders in a ceremony at the New

    York City Surrogateʼs Court last

    week.

    Renee Mehrra, TV personality

    and activist for womenʼs rights,

    was among the 13 fellows.

    The Fellowship was established

    by MOIA as part of the

    Administrationʼs “One New York

    Rising Together” platform to build

    closer relationships between immi‑

    grant women and the City and

    enhance the capacity of emerging

    and established leaders to promote

    positive social change in their com‑munities. “It has been an uplifting

    and insightful journey with kin‑

    dred spirits that deepened my

    emotional intelligence and leader‑

    ship skills,” commented Renee

    Mehrra, community activist. “The

    fellowship gave me rare insights

    and strategic tools to overcome

    barriers to progress and advance‑

    ment, including internalized

    oppression, discrimination and

    racism, so we can become catalysts

    for change and heal, transform and

    empower ourselves and our com‑

    munities.”At the conclusion of the

    Fellowship, Commissioner Nisha

    Agarwal of the Mayorʼs Office of 

    Immigrant Affairs invited the 13

    participants from this yearʼs inau‑

    gural Fellowship to serve on

    MOIAʼs Womenʼs Advisory Cabinet

    starting in November.

    Meera Gandhi, founder and chair of the Giving Back Foundation, with

    honorees Hollywood actress Phylicia Rashad, and Indianentrepreneur, author, columnist and socialite Suhel Seth.(Photo: Mohammed Jaffer‑SnapsIndia).

    Dr Govind and Jyothi Rao(Photo: dailygazette. com)

     TV personality and womenʼsrights activist Renee Mehrra will

    be in panel advisingMayorʼs Office of Immigrant Affairs

    The Raos donate $1 millionto St. Maryʼs Hospital

    Renee Mehrra amongImmigrant Women Leaders

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    6/32

    6 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info TR I S TATE COMMUNI TY

    New Jersey: More than 100 South‑

    Asians attended the kick‑off event

    for the Monmouth County

    Democrats South Asian Caucus.

    The event was held at Shokla

    Indian Restaurant in Freehold, NJ

    on October 10.

    Among the public officials and

    community leaders who attended

    the event were the United States

    Congressman Frank Pallone Jr.,

    Monmouth County Democratic

    Chairman Vin Gopal, MarlboroMayor Jon Hornik, State Assembly

    Candidates Eric Houghtaling,

     Joann Downey, Satish Poondi‑New

     Jersey DSC Vice‑Chairman, Dhiren

    Amin‑ President of Indian Business

    Association, D.K. Patel‑ President

    of Monmouth County Indian

    Association and their committee

    members.

    "It is important for the Indian‑

    American community to organize

    and vote, so their voices are

    heard," stated Congressman

    Pallone, the founder of the Indian‑

    American Caucus in Congress.

    Many of those in attendance

    expressed anticipation and excite‑

    ment of the caucus and of 

    Democratic Chairman Gopal, New

     Je rs ey 's fir st In di an ‑A me ri ca n

    elected to head a Major Party in

    Monmouth County. At young age

    of only 30, Vin Gopal is also

    Deputy Vice‑Chairman of the New

     Je rs ey De mo cr at ic St at e

    Committee.

    Hicksville NY: A long‑

    time resident of 

    Hicksville and treasur‑

    er of the local

    Northwest Civic

    Association Subodh

    Batra was honored

    with the Dick Evers

    Award by the

    Hicksville Community

    Council on Oct 8 for

    service to theHicksville community.

    Elected officials

    Nassau County legisla‑

    tor Rose Walker and New York

    Senator Jack Martins were also

    present at the function, with

    Martins also among the three hon‑

    orees of the evening.

    Batra said in his acceptance

    speech, “My family and I have lived

    in Hicksville for the past 19 years.

    I could not have found a better

    place to live, raise my family, and

    soon, enjoy my retirement.”

    He came to America armed with

    an engineering degree from IIT

    Mumbai in 1972. He has been

    married to Prabha for 38 years.

    He explained how he learnt early

    on that getting involved within the

    community at grass roots level is

    the way to make it a better place.

    Congressman Frank Pallone Jr addressingSouth Asian Democrats. Monmouth

    County DemocraticChairman Vin Gopal (inset)

    Congressman Pallone meetsSouth Asian Democrats

    Subodh Batra honoredby HicksvilleCommunity Council

    New York NY:

    Wells Fargo &

    Company is celebrating Diwali

    with a $50,000 donation to

    Operation Smile to help provide

    life‑changing surgeries for chil‑

    dren and young adults in India

    who are born with cleft lip and

    cleft palate. To help kick‑off the

    Indian New Year, the company

    will participate in a series of 

    Diwali community celebrations

    throughout the country, including

    events in California, New Jersey

    and Texas.

    “Operation Smile is honored to

    be partnering again this year with

    Wells Fargo to celebrate the

    Diwali season,” said Lisa

     Jardanhazy, Vice President Global

    Media Strategy & Public Relations

    for Operation Smile. From Oct. 16,

    2015 to Nov. 30, 2015, Wells

    Fargo encourages customers to

    send their own smiles and holiday

    goodwill to those in India by mak‑

    ing a donation to Operation Smile.

    Customers can make a donation

    and learn more about the compa‑

    nyʼs collaboration with Operation

    Smile by visiting www.wellsfar‑

    go.com/diwalismiles.

    “Weʼre very proud to support

    Operation Smile, which makes an

    incredible difference in the lives

    of children and their families who

    couldnʼt otherwise afford the sur‑

    geries which cost approximately

    $240,” said Rajnish Bharadwaj,

    executive vice president and head

    of Cross Border Strategy and

    Governance at Wells Fargo.

    “At Wells Fargo, weʼre commit‑

    ted to support the diverse com‑

    munities where we live and work

    and I encourage everyone to join

    us this year as we celebrate

    Diwali and support such a worthy

    cause.”

    WELLS FARGO CELEBRATES DIWALI WITH$50,000 DONATION TO OPERATION SMILE

    Della NG‑VP, Rahul Baig‑MD from Wells Fargo, William & KathleenMagee, CoFounders of OperationSmile at

    Diwali Celebration press conference.

    Subodh Batra with his wife, Prabha, andNassau County legislator Laura Schaefer at theawards function.

    Pradip Peter Kothari addressing the crowd at Patel Brothers and Indo AmericanReligious & Cultural Centerʼs Navratri 2015 held at Garden State Exhibition Center.

    Rang Tarangʼs Kashyap Sompura seen next to him. Hundreds dancing to the garba tunes. (Photos: Facebook pages)

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    7/32

    New York: Indian‑American yoga

    guru Bikram Choudhury is not

    entitled to copyright protection

    over yoga poses and breathing

    exercises he uses in hot rooms

    developed by him, a US appeals

    court has ruled.

    In an order by the Court of 

    Appeals for the Ninth Circuit in

    California yesterday, a bench of 

    three judges ruled in favor of city‑

    based Evolation Yoga, against

    whom Choudhury had filed a law‑

    suit in 2011.

    In the lawsuit, Choudhury had

    claimed that Evolation founders,

    the husband‑wife duo of Mark

    Drost and Zefea Samson had set

    up a "copy‑cat yoga system that

    offers classes that utilize and

    infringe" on his copyrighted

    sequence of yoga postures.

    The appeals court ruled that the

    sequence of yoga poses and

    breathing exercises developed by

    Choudhury was not entitled to

    copyright protection because "it

    was an idea, process, or system

    designed to improve health, rather

    than an expression of an idea."

    "Because the Sequence (of yoga

    postures) was an unprotectable

    idea, it was also ineligible for

    copyright protection as a compila‑

    tion or choreographic work," it

    said. Choudhury founded the

    'Bikram Yoga' form of exercise,

    which is among the most

    renowned forms of the art, with

    participants performing yoga pos‑

    tures in rooms heated to 40.6

    degrees Celsius.

    The court noted that the Indian

    practice and philosophy of yoga

    date back thousands of years and

    "derived from ancient Hindu

    scriptures, including the

    Bhagavad Gita" and that the prac‑

    tice of yoga teaches students to

    attain spiritual fulfillment through

    control of the mind and body. The

     judges said that the quest ion of 

    whether the sequence of 26 yoga

    poses and two breathing exercises

    developed by Choudhury "impli‑

    cates a fundamental principle

    underlying constitutional and

    statutory copyright protection ‑

    the idea/expression dichotomy.”

    "Because copyright protection is

    limited to the expression of ideas,

    and does not extend to the ideas

    themselves, the Bikram Yoga

    Sequence is not a proper subject

    of copyright protection," they

    said, adding that by claiming

    copyright protection for the

    sequence of yoga postures,

    Choudhury "misconstrues" the

    scope of copyright protection for

    compilations.

    "Our day‑to‑day lives consist of 

    many routinized physical move‑

    ments, from brushing one's teeth

    to pushing a lawnmower to shak‑

    ing a Polaroid picture, that could

    be... characterized as forms of 

    dance," the judges said.

    Washington DC: Indian‑American Bhagwati

    Agrawal is listed among CNN's Top 10

    Heroes of 2015, for bringing safe drinkingwater to more than 10,000 drought‑strick‑

    en people in his native Rajasthan.

    Each of the ten "everyday people doing

    remarkable things to make the world a bet‑

    ter place" will receive $10,000 and be hon‑

    ored at "CNN Heroes: An All‑Star Tribute," a

    globally broadcast event on December 6.

    The CNN Hero of the Year chosen on the

    basis of readers' votes will receive an addi‑

    tional $100,000 for his cause, CNN

    announced Thursday.

    Spurred by a water crisis in his homeland,

    Agrawal's nonprofit Sustainable

    Innovations created a rainwater harvesting

    system that now provides life‑changing,

    safe drinking water across six villages in

    Rajasthan, the driest region of India.His system, called Aakash Ganga ‑‑ Hindi

    for "River from the Sky" ‑‑ is a network of 

    rooftops, gutters, pipes and underground

    reservoirs that collect and store the mon‑

    soon rains, which fall from July to

    September, CNN reported.

    The system frees women and children,

    who had to walk miles to get water and

    clean dishes with sand to conserve it, to

    spend time doing more valuable activities.

    Not having to fetch water allows children,

    especially girls, to spend more time inschool, CNN said. People report fewer

    health problems. Dairy cows have become

    twice as productive. "The way I look at it,

    I'm 70 years old" Agrawal told CNN. "I only

    have maybe 10 years left of active life.

    Right now I'm like Usain Bolt, the sprinter.

    ... And I will run very fast to accomplish this

    mission."

    Washington DC: Two Indian‑American

    teenagers figured among 10 finalists of 

    NASAʼs national 3‑D Space Container

    Challenge which asked students to design

    models of containers that could help

    astronauts keep things in order in space.

    However, both Rajan Vivek from Arizona

    and Prasanna Krishnamoorthy from

    Delaware failed to win the prestigious

    competition which went to Ryan Beam of 

    California.

    Rajanʼs Hydroponic Plant Box contain‑

    er tackles the challenge of containing

    water in a microgravity environment

    while still allowing plants to grow roots

    in it. Hydroponics, growing plants with‑out soil, would be very effective in space‑

    crafts because it requires less space and

    plants grow faster and stronger, NASA

    said. Prasanna on the other hand devel‑

    oped a Collapsible Container. In order to

    use the limited space on international

    Space Station, the Collapsible Container

    can expand and compress to perfectly fit

    its contents. When empty, it can com‑

    press fully for easy storage, NASA said.

    “The simplest tasks on earth can be

    quite challenging, and even dangerous, in

    space,” said Niki Werkheiser, NASAʼs In‑

    Space Manufacturing project manager.

    NASA, in partnership with the American

    Society of Mechanical Engineers

    Foundation, which managed the competi‑

    tion, announced the winners of the

    Future Engineers 3‑D Space Container

    Challenge on Thursday.

    The winning designs focused on mak‑

    ing life in space a little more comfortable

    for astronauts, NASA said. Studentsacross the US spent part of their summer

    using 3‑D modelling software to design

    containers that could be 3‑D printed,

    with the ultimate goal of advancing

    human space exploration on the

    International Space Station, Mars and

    beyond.

    Houston An Indian‑American bil‑

    lionaire plans to distribute 10,000stationary bikes to India in a bid

    to provide electricity to millions of 

    homes.

    By 2016, Manoj Bhargava plans

    to test the first 50 bikes in 15 or

    20 small villages in Uttarakhand,

    before larger distribution of the

    bikes.

    According to Bhargava, the

    bikes will keep lights and basic

    appliances going for an entire day

    with just one hour of pedaling.

    "This is going to affect a few bil‑

    lion people," Bhargava said. The

    main challenge is expected to be

    distribution.

    While he doesn't intend to givethe bike away, he'd prefer to

    incentivize distributors with prof‑

    its.

    He says a village can also pool

    its resources, buying one bike but

    multiple batteries that can be

    swapped out to power individual

    homes.

    Michigan‑based Bhargava

    whose family moved to the US in1967, is set to distribute 10,000

    free electric battery‑ equipped

    bikes in India in 2016.

    The 62‑year‑old billionaire is

    also the creator of the famous 5‑

    hour Energy drink.

    7October 17-23, 2015TheSouthAsianTimes.info  NAT I ONAL COMMUNI TY

    Billionaire to distribute10,000 bikes to power

    homes in India

    Manoj Bhargava

    Bhagwati Agrawal

    No copyright protectionover Yoga poses: Court

    Bhagwati Agrawal listedamong CNN's top ten heroes

    2 Indian‑American teensamong NASAʼs 3‑D space

    contest finalists

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    8/32

    8 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info NAT I ONAL COMMUNI TY

    New York:

    An Indian‑

    American judge, along with

    four other attorneys, has

    been named for National AsiaPacific American Bar

    Association (NAPABA) Daniel

    K. Inouye Trailblazer Award.

    Amul Thapar will be hon‑

    ored at a NAPABA convention

    in New Orleans on November

    6, India‑West on Monday

    quoted a NAPABA statement

    as saying.

    NAPABA, in a statement

    released on October 8, con‑

    gratulated the recipients for

    paving the way for the

    advancement of other Asian Pacific

    American (APA) attorneys.

    "NAPABA recognizes the

    demonstrated vision,

    courage and tenacity, andmade substantial and last‑

    ing contributions to the

    APA legal profession, as

    well as to the broader

    APA community," the

    statement said.

    Thapar became first

    South Asian American

    Article III judge in the US

    when country's senate

    appointed him in 2007.

    For the post, former US

    President George W. Bush

    nominated him to the US district court.

    New York:

    American Banker recently

    released its “Women to Watch” and

    “25 Most Powerful Women in

    Banking” lists and Indian Americansappeared on both.

    Ranjana Clark, the head of transac‑

    tion banking at MUFG Union Bank

    North America, made it into the most

    powerful list coming in at No. 25.

    Clark, a graduate of Lady Shri Ram

    College in Delhi, the Indian Institute

    of Management in Ahmedabad and

    Duke University, took advantage of an

    opportunity to help grow the

     Japanese‑owned bank by switching

    out an approach that was limiting its

    potential, according to American

    Banker.

    She safely expanded deposits

    aggressively by carving out a niche

    holding deposits from other financial

    institutions which, according to someresearch, she found to be most effec‑

    tive. It allowed her to convince senior

    management she could make a signif‑

    icant profit from this method.

    Nandita Bakhshi, North America

    head of director channels at TD Bank,

    came in at No. 21 on the “Women to

    Watch” list.

    Bakhshi moved to New York from

    Kolkata nearly three decades ago, and

    her experiences in life, according to

    American Banker, have taught her

    how to read any room and tailor her

    management style accordingly.

    Amul Thapar

    IndianAmerican judgeto be felicitated

    New York NY: Luxury retailer

    Neiman Marcus unveiled its

    2015 Christmas Book this

    week, and one of the 11 fanta‑

    sy gifts includes a 12‑day, five‑

    city luxury excursion through

    Northwest India priced at

    $400,000. The 89th edition of 

    this legendary book continues

    Neiman Marcusʼ unmatched

    tradition of offering its cus‑

    tomers a selection of spectacu‑

    lar and unique holiday giftssure to make even their wildest

    dreams come true.

    Curated by OʼHarani Luxe

    Experiences, a luxury travel concierge

    company co‑founded by New York and

    Dallas entrepreneurs Jitin Hingorani

    and Patrick OʼHara, the “Dream Trip

    to India” covers everything from leg‑

    endary Delhi and the Taj Mahal to

    artistic Jaipur, romantic Udaipur and

    bustling Mumbai. The lucky couple

    who purchases the trip will travel in

    private planes and vintage cars to the

    finest hotels, restaurants and experi‑

    ences, which include dinners hosted

    by royalty, a private cricket game at

    the Cricket Club of India and aBollywood dance lesson by famed cho‑

    reographer Ashley Lobo on a movie

    set in Film City, followed by dinner

    with a Bollywood movie star. Neiman

    Marcus will donate $15,000 from the

    sale of this trip to The Heart of 

    Neiman Marcus Foundation, which

    brings enriching art experiences to

     youth in communities nationwide.

    “We are thrilled to be included in

    this yearʼs Neiman Marcus Christmas

    Book,” said Hingorani. “As someone

    who moved to the U.S. from India in

    my youth, it is heart‑warming for me

    to be able to share my country of ori‑

    ginʼs culture, hospitality and warmth

    with Americans on such a massive

    scale. India is really on everyoneʼs

    radar right now, and we want to show‑

    case the decadence and first‑class hos‑

    pitality that this country has to offer.”

    First published in 1926 as a 16‑page

    booklet, the Neiman MarcusChristmas Book was initially intended

    as a Christmas card to the storeʼs best

    customers.

    Building on tradition through the

     years, the book has maintained its

    personal touch, while evolving into a

    legendary source for alluring and

    mystical gifts.

    N e w J e r s e y The

    thought of periodic

    health check‑ups is

    daunting for many,

    however, early

    detection and pre‑

    vention is the key

    to a healthier life.

    Nonetheless, pre‑

    ventable ailments

    such as cardiovas‑cular diseases and

    diabetes are stil l

    largely prevalent

    across the United

    States. Recognizing

    early detection and prevention as vital for the

    well‑being of communities, BAPS Charities hosted

    its 9th annual Health Fair in Parsippany on

    October 4. The Health Fair saw participation from

    40 medical professionals, including specialties

    dentists, nurses, physicians, and specialists in the

    fields of Internal Medicine/Family practice,

    Cardiology, Gastroenterology, Ophthalmology,

    Podiatry, Dentistry, Physical Therapy,

    Chiropractor and OBGYN. These professionals vol‑

    unteered to provide individual consultations to

    over 320 community participants who benefitedfrom various screenings offered free or at subsi‑

    dized costs. Screenings included blood pressure,

    dental exam, glaucoma screening, glucose screen‑

    ing, eye exam. In an ef fort to encourage preventive

    care and disease management health awareness

    lectures were also organized. These lectures pro‑

    vided participants with insights on high choles‑

    terol, diabetes, preventive health, obesity and

    heart disease. Doctors that volunteered their time

    at the Health Fair came from a diverse set of local

    hospitals and private practices.

    “I was very much impressed with the turnout

    and the professionalism of all of the volunteers in

    putting together such a great community event,”

    said Dr.Kamal Patel. “I will definitely be back next

     year.”

    “We are pleased to be able to provide this serv‑

    ice and thank all the physicians, phlebotomists ns,

    Carol G Simon Cancer Centre who volunteered

    their time to make this event a success,” TejasPatel , BAPS Charities volunteer, said. BAPS

    Charities hosted similar community Health Fairs at

    over 40 locations across North America benefiting

    over 15,000 participants. Extending that senti‑

    ment throughout the year, BAPS Charities hosts

    medical fairs, walkathons, education & career

    development seminars, disaster relief operations,

    blood drives & much more.

    American Banker honorstwo women bankers

     The $400,000 luxury trip to India

    ʻDream Trip to Indiaʼ isNeiman Marcus fantasy gift B PS Charities hosts health

    fair in Parsippany

    Over 40 medical professionals volunteered for the event

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    9/32

    Washignton Hillary Clinton has passed her first big test at the

    Democratic presidential debate held here on CNN Tuesday and has

    momentum going into the upcoming ones.

    As candidates faced off for the first time, Clinton, without offer‑

    ing any specifics, said she would be different than President

    Obama, even as closest rival Bernie Sanders promised a "political

    revolution."Asked how her presidency would not be a "third term" for

    Obama, Clinton said: "I think being the first woman president

    would be quite a change."

    But the former first lady and secretary of state could not specify

    if there would be a policy difference even as she insisted

    she would build on Obama's policies in some areas, and go further

    in others.

    Self‑proclaimed socialist senator Sanders, on the other hand,

    claimed he would bring about a "political revolution," in which far

    more Americans would turn out to vote, and in which the balance

    of power was shifted sharply away from the rich. Clinton also

    sought to combat suggestions that she is too closely aligned with

    Wall Street banks by saying she had personally scolded Wall Street

    bankers to "cut it out," months before the financial crisis of 2008.

    "I respect the passion and intensity. I represented Wall Street, as

    a senator from New York," Clinton said, after hearing Sanders out‑

    line a plan to break up big banks.To that Sanders countered, "Congress does not regulate Wall

    Street. Wall Street regulates Congress. Going to them and saying

    please do the right thing is kind of naïve."

    But on Clinton's use of a private e‑mail system while serving as

    secretary of state, an issue that has dogged her campaign, Sanders

    appeared to come to her defense, arguing that Americans are sick

    and tired of the controversy because we should be discussing real

    issues affecting middle and working class Americans.

    Amid loud and sustained applause, Clinton turned to thank him

    with a handshake.

    Clinton cited a statement made by Republican House Majority

    Leader Kevin McCarthy, in which he implied that the committee's

    best outcome was to undercut Clinton's poll numbers.

    Clinton also cited the judgment of Obama to whom she lost in

    the 2008 party primary as a testament to her skill on foreign poli‑

    cy. "He asked me to be secretary of state," she said, after being crit‑

    icized for her vote in favor of the Iraq War in 2002. "He valued my

     judgment," she said, and trusted her advice in situation‑room dis‑

    cussions, Clinton said.

    Denying she flip‑flopped on key issues for political gain, Clinton

    deftly parried questions on the depth of her political convictions

    and insisting she is a "progressive" despite the doubts of some on

    the left of the party.

    Three other candidates‑ Chafee, Webb and former Maryland

    Governor Martin O'Malley‑whose campaigns are languishing in the

    single digits, failed to create any buzz.

    And if Vice President Joe Biden was looking for an opportunity

    (and rationale) to jump into the race, he didn't get it at the debate.

    9TheSouthAsianTimes.info 

    India figured just once in the two‑and‑a‑

    half‑hour long Democratic presidential

    primary debate ‑ and that too negative‑

    ly ‑ when long‑shot candidate Jim Webbsaid the US must have "highest polluting

    countries" like China and India on board

    in a climate deal. On the climate‑change

    issue, the former Virginia senator said

    unilateral action by the US wouldn't mean

    as much when many of the highest poll ut‑

    ing nations in the world are China and

    India. Frontrunner Hillary Clinton jumped

    on his comments, saying she was part of 

    the White House's effort to force China to

    make concessions on climate change. She

    said more should be done, though, at the

    upcoming Paris conference on climate

    change.

    Her closest rival Bernie Sanders said he

    agreed with Pope Francis, who called it a

    "moral issue."The influential Washington Post, ,

     joined issue with what it called "Webb's

    grandstanding over India and China as

    the 'world's worst polluters." "It's simply

    not fair to pin the blame on these coun‑

    tries, given the size of their populations,"

    wrote columnist Ishaan Tharoor. "Of 

    course, India and China are faced with

    huge questions over how to manage and

    grow their economies in a sustainable

    fashion," he wrote.

    New York A federal appeals court on Tuesday

    reinstated a lawsuit challenging the New York

    Police Department's surveillance of Muslim

    groups in New Jersey after the Sept. 11 ter‑

    rorist attacks, saying any resulting harm came

    from the city's tactics, not the media's report‑

    ing of them.

    The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals,

    reversing a judge's decision last year to dis‑

    miss the case, found the Muslim plaintiffs

    raised sufficient allegations of religious‑free‑

    dom and equal‑protection violations and put

    the case on track for trial. The court com‑

    pared the spying to other instances of height‑

    ened scrutiny of religious and ethnic groups,

    including Japanese‑Americans during WorldWar II. In dismissing the lawsuit, U.S. District

     Judge Wil lia m Martin i had concluded the

    police could not keep watch "on Muslim ter‑

    rorist activities without monitoring the

    Muslim community itself" and concurred with

    the city in blaming reporting by The

    Associated Press, which exposed the surveil‑

    lance program, for any harm.

    The appeals court said the attempt to blame

    the AP was akin to saying, "What you don't

    know can't hurt you. And, if you do know,

    don't shoot us. Shoot the messenger."

    The lawsuit revived Tuesday was among

    legal actions that followed reports by the AP

    that revealed how city police infiltrated

    Muslim student groups, put informants in

    mosques and otherwise spied on Muslims as

    part of a broad effort to prevent terrorist

    attacks. The reporting was honored with a

    Pulitzer Prize. Plaintiff Farhaj Hassan said he

    was "extremely ecstatic" about the court's

    decision.

    "I'm very happy we will get our day in

    court," said Hassan, a U.S. Army sergeant who

    served in Iraq. "Muslim‑Americans were theinnocent community in this matter, and lo and

    behold their civil rights should be protected

    like everyone else." The city called the intelli‑

    gence gathering an appropriate and legal

    anti‑terrorism tactic and said it never spied on

    people or businesses solely because they were

    Muslim. Such a practice would be contrary to

    its values, a spokesman for the city's Law

    Department said.

    Climate change to bring spring three weeks earlier to USNew York Driven by rising global temperatures, winter will be shorter and the onset of 

    spring plant growth will shift by a median of three weeks earlier over the next century,

    scientists have projected. The findings have long term implications for the growing season

    of plants and the relationship between plants and the animals that depend upon them.

    "Our projections show that winter will be shorter ‑ which sound great for those of us inWisconsin," explained one of the study authors Andrew Allstadt from University of 

    Wisconsin, Madison. "But long distance migratory birds, for example, time their migration

    based on day length in their winter range. They may arrive in their breeding ground to

    find that the plant resources that they require are already gone," Allstadt noted.

    Corporate Office: 385 Seneca Avenue, Ridgewood NY 11385

    718.821.3182, www.AtlanticDialysis.com

    India just a blipin debate

    Court reinstates lawsuit over

    NYPD surveillance of Muslims

    October 17-23, 2015U S AFFA IRS

    Bernie Sanders gave Hillarya boost with his comments on the email controversy.

    HILLARY DOMINATES DEMS DEBATE

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    10/32

    10 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info I ND IA

    Mumbai Maharashtra chief minis‑

    ter Devendra Fadnavis said his gov‑

    ernment will go in appeal, shortly

    after the Supreme Court stayed a

    2014 amendment to the state

    police act banning dance perform‑

    ances in bars and some other

    places.

    “Although SC interim order man‑

    dates regulation instead of ban on

    dance bars, Govt still favors ban.

    We will examine & press our

    demand in SC, “ Fadnavis tweeted

    shortly after the apex court

    removed the ban and allowed

    licencing authorities to regulate

    indecent dance performances.

    The bench of justices Dipak Misra

    and Prafulla C Pant said it is

    “appropriate to stay the provision”

    that prohibits the dance perform‑ances and noted the said provision

    was brought back in the

    Maharashtra Police Act in 2014

    after being held ultra vires in 2013

    by the top court.

    “However, we have a rider that no

    performance of dance will be

    remotely expressive of any kind of 

    obscenity...the licensing authority

    can regulate such dance perform‑

    ances so that individual dignity of 

    woman performer is not harmed,”

    the bench said.The apex court fixed the petition

    filed by Indian Hotel and

    Restaurant Association for final

    hearing on November 5 adding that

    a similar matter had already been

    decided in 2013.

    The Maharashtra government

    had reintroduced the law in 2014

    to bypass an SC judgment which

    had struck down a similar law a

     year ago. The SC had in April 2013

    upheld the right of women bar

    dancers to follow their professionand dismissed the state govern‑

    mentʼs appeal to ban them.

    The court had then questioned

    why Maharashtra did not find it

    indecent or derogatory to the digni‑

    ty of women if they worked as a

    receptionist, waitress or bartender

    at such bars and backed the

    Bombay high court verdict quash‑

    ing the 2005 ban.

    New Delhi Prime Minister

    Narendra Modi paid tributes to

    former president A.P.J. Abdul

    Kalam and said a memorial for

    him will be built at his birthplace

    Rameswaram in Tamil Nadu.

    "The government has acquired

    land at Kalam sahab's birthplace

    to build a memorial for him. We

    want it to be an inspiration for

    future generations," Modi said at

    a function to mark Kalam's birth

    anniversary.

    The prime minister went on:

    "Soon after quitting the presi‑

    dent's post, he took a flight to

    Chennai and started teaching."And look at his last moments...

    Where is Rameswaram, where is

    Delhi, and where is northeast...

    Going there at his age and spend‑

    ing time with students reflects

    his commitment," he said.

    Modi said Kalam was commit‑

    ted to enriching India's human

    resource.

    "India must be powerful, but

    not just by weapons... This was

    not Kalam sahab's thought.

    Weapon power is important, and

    he contributed to it, but hebelieved a nation is not identified

    by boundaries, but by the people.

    "So he took up both together,

    defence research and ... enrich‑

    ment of human resource," Modi

    said.

    The prime minister was speak‑

    ing after unveiling a bust of 

    Kalam at the DRDO complex here.

    A scientist‑turned‑politician,

    Kalam was born and raised in

    Rameswaram and studied physics

    and aerospace engineering.

    He spent four decades as a sci‑entist and science administrator,

    mainly at the Defence Research

    and Development Organisation

    (DRDO) and the Indian Space

    Research Organisation (ISRO),

    and was intimately involved in

    India's civilian space program

    and military missile development

    efforts.

    Kalam was the 11th president

    of India in 2002‑07. He died on

     July 27 this year.

    Mumbai The Shiv Sena said that since

    every person who arrives here from

    Pakistan is "a messenger of peace", so

    the three terrorists who have reported‑

    ly sneaked into the country should also

    be treated similarly.

    According to recent intell igence

    reports, three Pakistani terrorists have

    sneaked into Mumbai and preparing to

    carry out attacks similar to 26/11

    here.

    The central government has warned

    Maharashtra and a red alert has beensounded for the terrorist trio who

    could strike in the crowded festivals

    like the ongoing Navratri or the forth‑

    coming Diwali, the Shiv Sena said in an

    edit in the party mouthpiece Saamana

    today.

    However, it assured that people of 

    the state have no cause for worry as a

    new "Pakistan‑loving ambassador of 

    peace" has taken over responsibility to

    protect the nation from them, referring

    to its latest bete‑noir, Sudheendra

    Kulkarni, chairman of think‑tank,

    Observer Research Foundation (ORF).

    "Since every person who arrives here

    from Pakistan is 'a messenger of 

    peace', these three terrorists must also

    be treated similarly. We lay out the red

    carpet for them and accord them high‑

    est security," the Sena sarcastically

    demanded.

    N e w D e l h i The CBI moved the

    Supreme Court to challenge a

    Himachal Pradesh High Court order

    restraining it from interrogating

    Himachal Pradesh Chief Minister

    Virbhadra Singh and his wife in an

    alleged disproportionate assets

    case and sought their custodial

    interrogation.

    The Central Bureau of 

    Investigation (CBI) also filed a peti‑

    tion in the apex court to seek trans‑

    fer of the case against Virbhadra

    Singh from Himachal Pradesh to

    Delhi, where a similar case is pend‑

    ing against him.

    An apex court bench headed by

    Chief Justice H.L. Dattu said the

    plea would be heard on the opening

    day after the Dussehra holidays.

    Additional Solicitor General P.S.

    Patwalia mentioned the matterbefore the court in the morning and

    sought early hearing. The high

    court order of October 1 has virtu‑

    ally stalled the investigation

    process, he said.

    The high court has asked the CBI

    not to arrest the chief minister and

    his wife in the disproportionate

    assets case. However, it directed the

    central agency to go ahead with the

    investigation.

    "...by way of abundant precaution,

    it's made clear that the petitioners

    shall not be arrested," a division

    bench of Justice Rajiv Sharma and

     Jus tic e Suresh war Sin gh Thakur

    said while hearing a writ petition

    filed by Virbhadra Singh.

    In his petition, Virbhadra Singh

    said the CBI's action of raiding his

    residences on September 26 in

    Delhi and Shimla was mala fide and

    political vendetta.

    Regarding interrogation of 

    Virbhadra Singh and his wife

    Pratibha Singh following the regis‑

    tration of the case on September

    23, the high court said: "It's also

    made clear that as and when the

    dossier is complete, it shall be open

    for the CBI to approach this court

    for permission to interrogate thepetitioners in accordance with law."

    It clarified to the CBI that it shall

    not file a challan without the

    express leave of this court. "These

    observations shall have no bearing

    on the pendency of any case,

    including before the Delhi High

    Court."

    The next date of hearing in the

    high court is November 18.

     The Maharashtra government had reintroduced the law in 2014 tobypass an SC judgment which had struck down a similar law a year ago.

    Narendra Modi said Kalam was committed to enriching India'shuman resource.

    Maharashtra to appeal SC decisionallowing dance bars reopening

    Government to build Kalam

    memorial in Rameswaram

    CBI moves SC seeks to

    question Himachal CM

    Government

    booster for

    affordable

    housing in

    Rajasthan

      y Prakash handari

    Jaipur The Tata HousingDevelopment Corporation Ltdwill invest Rs 2000 crore inbuilding affordable and mixeduse housing in Jaipur.

    Tata Housing signed an MoUwith the state governmentunder which the company willbe allocated 10.17 hectares of land. The MoU was signed byBrotin Iannerjee, CEO of theTata Housing.

    In the run‑up to the“Resurgent RajasthanPartnership Summit”, theRajasthan Government signed27 MoUs worth Rs 12,478crore in the presence of UnionMinister for UrbanDevelopment Venkaiah Naidu,Chief Minister Vaundhara Raje,and state's urban developmentminister Rajpal SinghShekhawat.

    The investments shall pro‑vide a boost to the urban devel‑

    opment, tourism and socialdevelopment sectors in thestate, and are expected to cre‑ate employment for over38,950 people.

    Honor Pakistani

    terrorists as

    peace doves:

    Shiv Sena

    tells BJP

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    11/32

    11October 17-23, 2015TheSouthAsianTimes.info    I ND IA

    New Delhi Prime Minister Narendra Modi

    has announced that the government willstart de‑classifying files related to Netaji

    Subhas Chandra Bose from January 23 ‑ his

    birth anniversary.

    Modi said this in a series of tweets after

    meeting 35 members of Netaji Bose's

    extended family at his official residence

    here.

    The prime minister said the government

    would also request foreign governments to

    declassify their files on Bose, whose report‑

    ed death in a plane crash in 1945 in

    Formosa, now Taiwan, is widely disputed.

    Modi said he will begin the process

    involving other countries with Russia in

    December when he visits Moscow.

    During the hour‑long interaction, the fam‑

    ily members requested for declassificationof the files relating to Netaji, available with

    the government of India.

    They also suggested that the government

    of India initiate the process to get declassi‑

    fied the files on Netaji available with for‑

    eign governments.

    Bose, a leading light of India's freedom

    movement who at one time was elected the

    Congress president, was said to have been

    fleeing to Russia when his plane reportedly

    crashed and caught fire. This version has

    been challenged for decades by innumer‑able Bose fans who have held varying ver‑

    sions of what happened to him after 1945.

    Bose's family members met Modi in the

    light of the West Bengal government's

    declassification of official files related to

    the last days of Bose, who set up the Indian

    National Army (INA).

    "It was a privilege to welcome family

    members of Subhas Babu to 7 RCR. We had

    a remarkable and extensive interaction,"

    Modi said.

    "I told Subhas Babu's family members ‑please consider me a part of your family.

    They shared their valuable suggestions

    with me," he added.

    The prime minister said he found the sug‑

    gestions of the family members of Netaji to

    be similar to his own thinking and the view

    of the union government.

    Modi said: "There is no need to strangle

    history. Nations that forget their history

    lack the power to create it."

    Chandigarh The Punjab gov‑ernment ordered a probe bya high court judge into dese‑cration of Guru Granth Sahib,as a clash between Sikh pro‑testors and police over theissue left two people deadand many others injured inKotkapura area of Faridkotdistrict.

    Sources said police and

    Sikh protestors exchangedgunfire in Behbal Kalan areanear Kotkapura, 230 kmfrom here, leading to thedeath of two people and

    injuries to nearly 70 othersin the wake of protest overthe desecration of the Sikhholy book.

    Police used batons andwater cannons and even firedin the air to disperse hun‑dreds of protestors whohurled bricks, stones andother things at them. Most of the injured included protes‑tors and around 30 police

    officials. They were rushed tohospitals.The Sikh protestors were

    up in arms against the dese‑cration of a 'bir' (holy book)

    in Bargari vil lage, 15 kmfrom Kotkapura.

    Tension mounted inKotkapura area on Mondayafter over 100 pages of theSikh holy book were foundscattered in a street near agurdwara. The holy book wasstolen from a gurdwara in

     June.Following Wednesday's vio‑

    lence, Chief Minister ParkashSingh Badal in the eveningordered the inquiry by a highcourt judge to probe the des‑ecration and the incidents of 

    violence in its aftermath.Condemning the incident

    and the violence, Badal said"exemplary punishmentwould be gien to the perpe‑trators of this dastardly act".

    In a statement issued here,Badal said: "The desecrationof Sri Guru Granth Sahib is adeep‑rooted conspiracyaimed at inciting communaltension and destabilizing the

    hard‑won peace in Punjab. Iappeal to the people to bevigilant against such ele‑ments and keep calm despitegrave provocation."

    It's authors' wish toreturn Sahitya Akademi

    awards: MinisterKolkata With eminent authors returning

    Sahitya Akademi awards to protest rising

    intolerance, union minister Bandaru

    Dattatreya said it was their individual

    right and intellectuals were free to act asper their wish in a democracy.

    "It is their individual wish and India is

    a democratic country," the minister of 

    state for labour told media persons while

    attending an event organised by the

    Confederation of Indian Industry (CII).

    Nearly two dozen authors have

    announced their decision to return their

    awards as a mark of protest since a man

    was lynched in Uttar Pradesh's Dadri

    area allegedly for consuming beef, and in

    the wake of murders of writers in the

    country.

    Asked about Monday's incident of Shiv

    Sena cadres pouring black paint on

    Sudheendra Kulkarni, chairman of the

    think‑tank Observer ResearchFoundation, Dattatreya said, "The politi‑

    cal leadership of BJP has already com‑

    mented on it and my stand is the same as

    that of the national leadership."

    A group of Shiv Sena cadres poured

    paint on Kulkarni to protest launch of a

    book by Pakistan's former foreign minis‑

    ter Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri at a func‑

    tion in Mumbai on Monday.

    Patna Forget development... It is

    caste factor that will play the domi‑

    nating role when 32 of the 243 con‑

    stituencies go to the polls in the sec‑

    ond round of assembly elections.

    About 8.58 million voters will be

    eligible to elect 32 legislators from

    among 456 candidates. Six districts

    will see balloting, including poverty‑

    stricken Kaimur and Rohtas.

    Most of the 8,849 polling booths

    on Friday are in rural areas.

    The districts covered are Gaya, the

    birthplace of Buddhism, Aurangabad,

     Jeha na ba d, Ar wa l, Ka im ur an d

    Rohtas, which saw some horrificcaste massacres in the 1980s and

    1990s.

    Some of these areas are also known

    as Maoist hubs, and officials admit

    security will be a major concern.

    The stakes are high both for the

    Grand Alliance of the JD‑U, RJD and

    Congress led by Chief Minister Nitish

    Kumar as well as the BJP‑led NDA of 

    Prime Minister Narender Modi, the

    two main contenders for power.

    The second of the staggered five

    rounds will decide the political fate

    of former chief minister and HAM

    president Jitan Ram Manjhi, Speaker

    Uday Narayan Choudhary and BJP

    leader Prem Kumar, one of the con‑tenders for the chief minister's post.

    Manjhi, a BJP ally, is contesting from

    two seats: Makhdumpur in

     Jehanabad and Imamganj in Gaya .

    His son Santosh Kumar Manjhi is also

    in the fray from Kutumba and his

    son‑in‑law Devender Kumar Manjhi is

    contesting from Bodh Gaya as an

    independent.

    The Grand Alliance is banking on

    OBCs and Muslims and sections of 

    Dalits and EBCs to capture most of 

    the 32 seats.

    But the BJP is confident of the

    overwhelming support of upper

    castes along with sections of OBCs

    and EBCs along with Dalits, mainly

    Manjhi's castemen Mushahars as

    well as Paswans, who owe allegiance

    to LJP leader Ram Vilas Paswan,

    another BJP ally.The BJP is keen to make its pres‑

    ence felt in the wake of the euphoria

    created by Modi's rallies in Jehanand,

    Aurangabad and Bhabhua. This is

    also the strongest base of the Janata

    Dal‑United (JD‑U) and the Rashtriya

     Janata Dal (RJD).

    The region is home to a sizeable

    number of Yadavs, Lalu Prasad's

    community, and Muslims ‑‑ the two

    communities who helped the RJD to

    emerge as a major force in Bihar.

    "The OBC‑EBC‑Dalit votes along

    with Muslims will be a decisive caste

    arithmetic," political analyst Soroor

    Ahmad said.

    Officials say five hel icopters,

    drones and 993 companies of para‑

    military forces have been deployed

    for Friday, Additional Chief Electoral

    Officer R. Lakshaman said. The stag‑gered elections to pick a 243‑mem‑

    ber Bihar assembly will end on

    November 5 . The result wi l l be

    known three days later.

    Netaji files to be declassifiedfrom January 23: Modi

     The family members of Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose meet PM Narendra Modiat 7 Race Course Road in New Delhi.

    In the firstphase onMonday,

    polling washeld in 49

    constituencies. The third roundwill be held on

    October 28.

    Caste major factor in Bihar

    second round voting

    Punjab orders

     judicial probeinto desecration

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    12/32

    12 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info OP-ED

    By Vir Sanghvi 

    Images of Sudheendra Kulkarni,

    his face and body blackened by

    the ink flung at him by protest‑

    ers, are now being flashed all over

    the world. As the protest was over

    Kulkarniʼs willingness to help a for‑

    mer Pakistan foreign minister

    launch a memoir, the message that

    has gone out is this: How can there

    ever be peace between Pakistan

    and India when there are extremist

    groups within India that are bitter‑

    ly opposed to any contact ̶ let

    alone the peace process ̶ with

    Pakistan?

    This tears a gaping hole in the

    Indian messaging ̶ carefully cal‑iberated over the years ̶ that

    India wants peace but that the

    Pakistani regime is in the grip of 

    extremists, fundamentalists and

    terrorists. What makes it worse is

    that, till recently, Kulkarni was a

    pillar of the BJP establishment. He

    was a senior member of the

    Vajpayee PMO and an adviser to

    LK Advani. Worse still, the people

    who doused him in ink were not

    extremists from some little‑known

    fringe organization.

    The Shiv Sena is the BJPʼs ally

    and a part of the Maharashtra gov‑

    ernment, the same government

    that is supposed to protect citizens

    against such attacks.

    Every way you look at it, the

    Kulkarni‑Kasuri incident is a disas‑

    ter for India. It does not help that it

    comes on the heels of the Shiv

    Senaʼs refusal to allow Pakistani

    singer, Ghulam Ali, to perform in

    Mumbai.

    On that occasion, the chief minis‑

    ter of Maharashtra had promised

    security to Ali. But the organizers

    decided to abandon the concert

    anyway; one indication of the

    importance people attach to the

    state governmentʼs guarantees. The

    general view was that even if the

    government had provided security,

    the Shiv Sena would still have been

    able to disrupt the performanceand perhaps harm those who per‑

    formed or attended.

    The two incidents, on the heels of 

    each other, in what was once

    Indiaʼs most liberal and cosmopoli‑

    tan city, illustrate the dilemma that

    Narendra Modi now faces.

    In the case of the Shiv Sena he

    can distance himself by arguing

    that he cannot be held responsible

    for everything an ally does.

    But this position seems weaker

    when the violence, intolerance, and

    hatred emanate from closer home.

    The murders and attacks on liberal

    writers, the hysteria over beef, and

    the abuse of Muslims, that havedominated the headlines, all

    emerge from the Hindutva right

    wing, from members of the extend‑

    ed Sangh Parivar, from the BJP and

    even, from Modiʼs own ministers.

    The prime minister can claim,

    with some justification, that he

    does not condone such attacks or

    such statements. He can point to

    his own record at South Block and

    say that he has never said or done

    anything that could be construed

    as communal.

    But his critics will ask the obvi‑ous questions. Does he not see that

    there is now a mood of Hindu tri‑

    umphalism in which a Hindutva

    fringe believes that the BJPʼs victo‑

    ry in the last general election gives

    them the right to reshape the idea

    of India to match their own bigoted

    vision? Does he not notice or mind

    when his avowed supporters ask

    people who believe in the old liber‑

    al idea of India to emigrate to

    Pakistan? Does he not worry when

    so many writers return their

    awards, resign from the Sahitya

    Akademi, and declare that they are

    distressed by the rising hatred and

    intolerance in India?Modi has said nothing. But my

    guess is that he must be very wor‑

    ried. If India becomes a cauldron of 

    intolerance, will Modi still be treat‑

    ed as a respected global statesman

    the next time he meets a world

    leader?

    The answers are clear. Sooner or

    later, Modi will have to speak out

    for tolerance and act against those

    who spread hatred.

    If not for Indiaʼs sake, then for his

    own.

    Rise of intolerant India threatensPM Modiʼs global image

    The views expressed in Op Eds are not necessarily those of The South Asian Times.

    Shiv Sainiks flung ink at Sudheendra Kulkarni, chairman of theObserver Research Foundation, to protest the launch of former

    Pakistan foreign minister Khurshid Mahmud Kasuri's book.

    By Mayabhushan Nagvenkar 

    Public lynching over a slab of meat, coldblooded murders of writers, rational‑

    ists and a wave of crimes of intoler‑

    ance has led well‑known Indian writers andwinners of the prestigious Sahitya Akademi

    award, to innovatively script their dissent.

    Their protest is against what they call thegrowing intolerance within the country and

    the muted response of the establishment,including the Akademi, to the series of hate

    crimes.

    Noted writer Nayantara Sahgal's decisionlast week to return her Sahitya Akademi

    award over the public lynching in Dadri last

    month and the murder of rationalists inMaharashtra and Karnataka has triggered a

    wave of similar reactions from other

    awardees across the country.Sahgal, a 1986 Sahitya Akademi awardee,

    said she was disturbed at the lynching of Mohammad Akhlaq,52, by a public mob at

    Dadri last month, after accusing him of stor‑

    ing beef at his home and the murder of rationalists like Narendra Dabolkar, Govind

    Pansare and Kannadiga writer M.M.

    Kalburgi over the last couple of years."I have decided to return the award as I

    felt that it's time to speak up. I am disturbed

    at the Dadri killing and the killing of ratio‑

    nalists," Sahgal told IANS, adding that shewas upset over Prime Minister Narendra

    Modi's silence on the issue.Since her renouncement, nearly two dozen

    winners of the Sahitya Akademi award have

    emulated Sahgal, a niece of India' first primeminister, Jawaharlal Nehru.

    In Modi's home state of Gujarat, poet

    writer Anil Joshi joined another Vadodara‑based writer Ganesh Devy, in returning his

    award."There is no breathing space and no free‑

    dom of expression for literary writers. It is

    like losing oxygen because we are writers

    who wish for free breathing space. I do not

    need an oxygen cylinder in the form of awards to live. The attack on the brood of lit‑

    erarians is unfortunate and has taken awaythe freedom of expression," Joshi said in a

    statement.

    In Punjab, as many as seven writers andpoets Surjit Patar, Jaswinder Singh, Baldev

    Singh Sadaknama Darshan Bhuttar, Ajmer

    Singh Aulakh, Atamjit Singh, GurbachanBhullar and Canada‑based writer Waryam

    Sandhu also gave up their respectiveawards, which were instituted in 1955.

    In the southern state of Kerala too, poet

    Satchidanandan, writers P.K. Parakkadavuand K.S. Ravikumar quit all posts in the

    Akademi over Kalburgi's killing, while

    Malayalam writer Sara Joseph, who alsoreturned the award, said that India was

    passing through a phase "worse than the

    black days of the (1975‑77) emergency"."There is a fear that has engulfed in what

    one eats, when one expresses love, and thereis some sort of curb on what one wants to

    write and speak. This does not augur wella

    Our prime minister is a frequent flyer and

    gives big speeches on his trips abroad. Thesad thing is that while he was away a man

    was beaten to death because he ate beef,"

     Joseph said, referring to the Dadri lynching.

    In New Delhi, former head of the Lalit Kala

    Akademi Ashok Vajpayi also returned hisaward, in Kashmir poet‑writer Ghulam Nabi

    Khayal also followed suit , while in

    Bengaluru, well known author ShashiDeshpande has resigned from the Sahitya

    Akademi general council.In Goa too, over 30 winners of the Award

    are expected to deliberate on Wednesday

    over the issue of mass renunciation.Akademi president V.P. Tiwari, who has

    been criticized by the writer fraternity for

    his silence, insists that the situation isunprecedented.

    "We are facing an unprecedented situa‑tion. At present, we do not know how to

    respond to those wanting to give back their

    awards," Tiwari said, adding that a meetingof the Akademi's council would be held on

    October 23 to discuss the issue.

    Adding to the fire, as it were, CultureMinister Mahesh Sharma, who is emerging

    as the government's stormy petrel, told theIndian Express on Monday: "This is an

    award given by writers to writers. It has

    nothing to do with the government. It is

    their personal choice to return it...we acceptit." One thing is for sure: this is an issue that

    is unlikely to die down soon.

    Indian writers renounce awards;script dissent against intolerance

    Noted writer Nayantara Sahgal.

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    13/32

    TheSouthAsianTimes.info  October 17-23, 2015

  • 8/20/2019 Vol.8 Issue 24 - Oct 17-Oct 23, 2015

    14/32

    The views expressed in Op Eds are not necessarily those of The South Asian Times.

    14 October 17-23, 2015   TheSouthAsianTimes.info OP - ED

    By Minhaz Merchant 

    Suleiman Khan returned to India from

    Saudi Arabia last week. He was appre‑

    hensive. Suleiman confided his fears to

    his friend Anwar Shaikh: "Nayantara Sahgal,

     Jawaharlal Nehru's niece, says that things in

    India are worse today than they've been

    since the partition riots in 1947."

    Anwar replied grimly: "Yes. They are. The

    government tells us what to eat, what to

    read, what to watch. They even blackened

    Sudheendra Kulkarni's face before Khurshid

    Mahm