volume 2, chapter 1 the allocation of rewards in athletic contests -individual sports
DESCRIPTION
Volume 2, Chapter 1 The allocation of rewards in athletic contests -individual sports. Individual sports. Individual athletes operate outside league structure Organized around professional tour of events, matches, races in disparate geographic locations - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
1
Volume 2, Chapter 1The allocation of rewards in athletic contests-individual sports
2
Individual sports Individual athletes operate outside league structure
Organized around professional tour of events, matches, races in disparate geographic locations
Usually include governing bodies, event owners/operators, athletes, agents
Governing body establish playing and eligibility rules, sanction events, administration similar to league office in team sports Generate revenue from media rights, sponsorships,
tickets, athlete fees PGA Tour, LPGA Tour, ATP Tour, WTA Tour,
NASCAR… Require strong leader to improve sport, maximize profit
3
Individual athletes
Independent contractors Income from prize money, endorsements,
appearance fee Not unionized, do not deal with owners and
governing bodies in singular fashion Average individual athletes earn less money than
average team sport athletes Responsible for many of their own expenses
Travel, lodging, coaching, equipment, training facilities…
4
Event owners
Gate receipts significant revenue for event owners Important to secure commitment from marquee
athletes In Tennis, IMG and Octagon agencies control
~80% events, represent ~75% athletes
5
PGA Tour – history/membership
Professional Golfers Association of America
Formed in 1968 as nonprofit organization Regulate, promote, improve business of
professional tournament golf Players must satisfy reasonable performance
criteria, 258 members in 2004 Organize PGA Tour, Champions Tour (age >
50 years), Nationwide Tour
6
PGA Tour purses
Tournament purses: ~3.5 M -9 M 4 major championships purses: ~8 M Champions Tour: purses 1.6 M -2.6 M Nationwide Tour: purses 450 K – 775 K
7
Typical PGA Tour tournament set up
PGA Tour contract with a local sponsor, usually nonprofit organization that donate net receipts to charity Local sponsor arrange golf course, staffing (may
up to 1000-1500 people for 80000-160000 spectators)
Local sponsor responsible for paying tournament prize money (tournament purse)
PGA Tour’s major responsibility: arrange and receive right fee for broadcast deal
8
PGA Tour – media contract Networks unwilling to broadcast PGA Tour unless
local sponsors/PGA ensure substantial portion of TV advertising in late 70s to early 80s
Strategies by former Commissioner Deane Beman PGA Tour and local sponsor sold advertisers and
network package of tournaments, rather than single Reduce risk for advertisers and networks Networks often are asked by advertisers to compensate if
programming fail to reach anticipated audiences Use title sponsors to purchase large portion of network
advertising, underwrite most/all tournament purse Conflicting Events Rule, Media Rights Rule
9Conflicting Events RuleMedia Rights Rule Conflicting Events Rule: Limit but not prohibit
members from competing at non-PGA tournament No member shall participate any other golf event on a
date when PGA Tour co-sponsored regular event is scheduled
Media Rights Rule: Players assign their media rights to PGA Tour In return for benefits of membership in PGA tour,
including TV coverage Players agree to limit their appearance on other live or
recorded TV golf programs without prior approval of PGA Tour commissioner. Wholly instructional golf program and personal appearance are exempted
10
PGA Tour not involved PGA Tour does not run any of the four major
championships (the Masters Tournament, the U.S. Open, The Open Championship and the PGA Championship), or the Ryder Cup
The PGA of America, runs the PGA Championship also co-organizes the Ryder Cup with the PGA European
Tour The R&A runs The Open Championship, The
Open, British Open) the governing body of golf outside the USA and Mexico only "major" held outside the USA
Augusta National Golf Club runs the Masters Tournament
11
Association of Tennis Professionals
Association of Tennis Professionals (ATP) Tournaments with considerable variation in prize purses:
332 K to 3.7 M in 2007 ATP 1000, ATP 500, ATP 250 ATP World Tour Finals (changed from Masters Cup
since 2009) : 8 highest-ranked players from preceding year, singles and doubles, purse 5.07 M in 2011
ATP Champions Tour (older players) ATP Challenger Tour 1951 ranked players in 2011
4 Grand Slams, organized by International Tennis Federation Purse ~ 8 M
12
13
NASCAR National Association for Stock Car Auto Racing
(NASCAR) a family-owned and -operated business venture sanctions and governs > 1500 races at >100 tracks in 39
states founded by Bill France Sr. in 1947–48. Current CEO,
Brian France, his grandson 2nd highest TV ratings in professional sports in US
Sprint Cup (highest level), 36 races in 10 months Nationwide Series, Camping World Truck Series,
iRacing.com Series, several regional series
14
WTA – a troubled model Women’s tennis has story lines and name
recognition In 2003, no title sponsor, not own its tournaments,
not control TV rights World Tennis Association officially disappeared several
years ago Title sponsor: Corel Sanex none No title sponsor renewed deal since Virginal Slims
pulled out in 1994 Players stronger affiliation to country, agents,
coaches than governing body Poor media relations staff
IMG and Octagon control flow of information
15
WTA – a troubled model WTA hired IMG to find title sponsor
Find Sanex, a European personal products company, not even distribute its brands in US, as title sponsor for 2000
suggestion in 2003: sell a series of regional sponsorships in ATP model
Most tournaments owned by same agencies that represent players IMG and Octagon control 75% players, 80%
tournaments, control several seats on WTA board Conflict of interest between agencies and tennis
Individual tournaments sell TV rights No consistent network appearance
16
WTA - now Sony Ericsson WTA Tour, administered and governed by
WTA Tour, Inc. Members: players, recognized Tour Tournaments worldwide,
International Tennis Federation (ITF) Tournament categories: Grand Slam Events, Sony Ericsson
Championships, Tier Tournaments Sony Ericsson Championships: Season-ending championships in
November, prize money 3M 1 mandatory play Tier I Tournament: Sony Ericsson Open - Miami,
Florida, USA, prize money 3.45M Tier I tournaments, minimum prize money 1.34M Tier II tournaments, minimum prize money 0.6M Tier III tournaments, minimum prize money 175K Tier IV tournaments, minimum prize money 145K
17
WTA - now Use Player Commitment Formula to regulate good
players of the minimum number of participation in tournaments If a Tournament’s Player Commitment Formula is not
met, the affected Tournament shall be compensated (by a percentage of forfeiture to the player)
Apply for a new Tournament to WTA Tours by the owner Geographical practicality and balance Television exposure and whether there exists a finalized
television commitment or a substantial prospect for same Facilities Marketing consideration
18
WTA - now Tournament ownership rights:
a week on the Calendar Level of player participation determined by the WTA
Tour (Player Commitment) exclusive right to organize, promote and exploit the
Tournament, to retain any and all proceeds negotiated benefits package, which may preclude Title
Sponsorship of any Tournament in one product category for the Tour Sponsor
advertise and promote the Tournament’s association with the Tour, advertise and promote the participants entered in the Tournament
19
WTA - now Tournaments pay WTA Tour fees
funding Tour Operations and Player Services deducted from each Tournament’s minimum prize
money WTA Tour pay Tournaments from commercial
benefits, from 68.7K to 3.5K website
http://www.wtatennis.com Results, players, schedule Live games/videos, App, ringtone, wallpaper, screen
saver http://www.wtatennis.com/page/Calendar
20
21
Order of prize in individual sports
Prize money: difference (1st-2nd) >> difference (57th-58th) Difference in performance may be same (e.g. 1
stroke) PGA: Usually ~18% total prize money to 1st
place, 10.8% to 2nd, 6.8% to 3rd Difference between 22nd and 23rd: ~0.1% total
prize Similar in tennis
22
Road races
Participation usually open Unlike restricted entry in tennis, golf
Prize distribution: 1st: 1; 2nd: 0.5, 3rd: ~0.38 Only top finishers will be paid
Usually top 5-16 Performance-related bonuses
23
24
25
26
27
28Economic point of view:rank-order tournaments Prizes are fixed in advance, independent of absolute
performance Except road races Winner receives first prize not for being good, but for
being better than 2nd 1st prize money not affected by the difference between
1st and 2nd Level of effort depends on size of prize
The larger the prize spread, the higher the effort exerted Prize structure designed to induce maximal effect
Increase interest of sports fans Average prize money must be high enough to attract
athlete participation
29Economic point of view:rank-order tournaments Athletes adjust behavior/effort in response to his
ranking in the tournament Small or large lead/behind Risky or safe strategies Supported in the literature: golf, tennis, bowling,
distance running, football… Sorting function: a pyramidal structure of events
Equivalent to multi-round elimination tournament Ensure only most able competitors make it to final
round/contest Function of minor tournaments: identify able athletes,
avoid contamination of the elite Prize to 1st round loser in GS > champ in minor
tournament
30Economic point of view:rank-order tournaments
Top events limit number of entries Effort the largest effect on changing probability of
winning when contestants of similar ability If ability differs, both contestants restricted their efforts In road races: organizers support traveling/hotel for
seletected top runners ‘Super contest’ that links together each tournaments
PGA Championship, ATP World Tour Finals, World Marathon Majors
Addition motivation to perform well in individual tournaments over a season
Very high prize
31
Exception in order of prize: NASCAR
Difference in prize money smaller than that in PGA
Drivers may prevent competitors from succeeding
If incentive for winning is too high, drives may take risk Tragedy, accident
Give drivers incentive to remain on track for entire race, rather than risk crashing in order to achieve more prize money
32
NASCAR ranking, 2011
33
World Wrestling Entertainment Formerly World Wrestling Federation
Entertainment, established in 1987 Initial public offering (IPO) in 1999 Began trade stock on New York Stock Exchange in 2000
Integrated media and entertainment company, engaged in development, production, marketing of TV programming, pay-per-view programming, live events, licensing and sale of branded consumer products featuring WWE brand Key economic drivers: live event attendance, pay-per-
view buys, TV ratings
34
Creative development/production Create 2 separate and distinct brands: Raw,
SmackDown! Distinct storylines, separate live event tours Acquisition of assets/wrestlers from World
Championship Wrestling and other competing companies Creative team, headed by Vincent McMahon,
develop soap opera-like storylines Same techniques used by many successful TV series Compelling and complex characters, combine social
satire, action adventure, drama, athleticism, humor Exaggerated version of real life situations, good vs evil,
settling the score Storyline played in ring, weekly/monthly TV show/event
35
Creative development/production Develop character for each performer
Define and emphasize through various accessories: costumes, entrance music…
Success lies in continuing popularity of performers Exclusive contracts with ~150 performers in 2002 Long-term contracts with established performers Continue to recruit talent, participate in extensive
developmental training program Promising candidates often ‘loaned’ to regional
promoters to hone skills by working in front of live audience and appearing on local TV programs
Popular performers incorporated into TV/pay-per-view to fully develop their characters
36WWE – live events and programming Each event highly theatrical production
Involve significant degree of audience participation, special effects including lighting, powerful entrance music, pyrotechnics (煙火 )
327 live events in 193 north American cities in 2003, ~30 international events planned $39 per ticket
Promote live events on TV, radio, print, internet Independent producer of TV programming
7 shows, 9 hrs/week for 52 weeks/year, broadcast in >130 countries and 12 different languages
12 domestic pay-per-view, some also international Audience aged 12-34
37
WWE - revenue 2003 Live events, TV/pay-per-view 295.4M
72.2M from live events, domestic TV rights fee 38.8M, international TV rights fee 19.7M, advertising 72.9M, pay-per-view 91.1M
Sold advertising time to food/beverage, video game, toy, movie, telecommunication
Package sponsorships: TV, internet, print, arena signage, on-air announcements, special appearance by performers, produce commercial featuring performers
Branded merchandise 78.9M Toys, video games, apparel
Use internet to promote brand, create community experience, market/distribute products
38
WWE - analysis Softening in key drivers in 2002, continue in 2003
Net revenue 438.2M in 2001, 409.6M in 2002, 374.3M in 2003
2002 vs 2001: 7%, 12.2M in live/TV, 18.8 M in branded merchandise
2003 vs 2002: 9%, 28.1M in live/TV, 7.2 M in branded merchandise
TV ratings, attendance at live events, pay-per-view buys all decreased
Audience for sports entertainment contracted and/or moved to other forms of entertainment
39
40
Professional boxing Many parties influence/direnct boxer’s career
Manager: represent boxer in all business negotiations, including selection and negotiation contract of promoter, selecting trainer, approving opponents; in exchange for percentage of boxer’s purse for each bout (usually 1/3 for manager and trainer)
Manager usually pay training expenses and rent in boxer’s early career
Promoter: agree to provide certain number of bouts and compensation, in exchange for exclusive promotional rights to the boxer
Boxing commission of the state: regulate each bout held in the state, health/safety procedure, select judges
Boxer’s goal: rank as contender, fight/win world champ
41
Professional boxing - promoter Assume financial risk for promotion of each match
Guarantee each fighter a certain purse Pay all expenses of promotion Earn the difference between total revenues and total
expenses for promotion of a bout Direct conflict of interest with boxers
Revenue sources Live gate receipt, or site fee paid to promoter (usually
major fights take place in casino, casino responsible for ticket sale)
Domestic/foreign TV rights: most important Sale of advertising rights, video, fight programs
42Professional boxing – sanctioning organizations Only involved with championship and title-
elimination matches International Boxing Federation, World Boxing
Association, World Boxing Council Each designate a world champ in each weight division,
and top 10-20 contenders per division Sanction ‘championship bout’, attract TV and live
attendance Sanction fee usually 3% each boxer’s purse
No matter how talented a boxer may be, can only be guaranteed a fair opportunity at success if all parties fulfill their roles in honest and faithful manner
German media company ProSiebenSat.1 has acquired rights for fights promoted by the Sauerland boxing agency and plans to launch a new boxing channel.
The length of the agreement was not disclosed, but reports have suggested that the deal is worth $10m (€7.9m) per year and will include eight events in 2015.
43
http://www.sportbusiness.com/sport-news/prosiebensat1-signs-sauerland-boxing-rights-deal
The rights will be exploited on commercial channel Sat.1, but Sauerland said that “there are also plans to found a 24/7 boxing channel by ProSiebenSat.1.”
The deal has been agreed after German public-service broadcaster ARD decided against renewing a rights deal with Sauerland beyond the end of this year.
44