washington, d.c. 20530 · [email protected] michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new...

24
U.S. Department of Justice Office of the Solicitor General Washington, D.C. 20530 March 2, 2018 Honorable Scott Harris, Clerk Supreme Court of the United States Washington, D.C. 20543 Re: Daniel Berninger, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-498 AT&T Inc. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-499 American Cable Association v. FCC, et al., No. 17-500 CTIA-The Wireless Association, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-501 NCTA-The Internet & Television Association v. FCC, et al., No. 17-502 Techfreedom, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-503 U.S. Telecom Association, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-504 Dear Mr. Harris: The petitions for writs of certiorari were filed on September 27, 2017, and September 28, 2017, and were placed on this Court’s docket on October 3, 2017. After four extensions, the response for the government is due on March 5, 2018. We respectfully request, pursuant to Rule 30.4 of the Rules of this Court, a further extension of time for all respondents to and including April 4, 2018, within which to file the government’s response. Counsel for the petitioners have informed us that they do not oppose this request. Sincerely, Noel J. Francisco Solicitor General cc: see attached service list

Upload: others

Post on 06-Apr-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

U.S. Department of Justice

Office of the Solicitor General

Washington, D.C. 20530

March 2, 2018 Honorable Scott Harris, Clerk Supreme Court of the United States Washington, D.C. 20543

Re: Daniel Berninger, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-498 AT&T Inc. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-499 American Cable Association v. FCC, et al., No. 17-500 CTIA-The Wireless Association, et al. v. FCC, et al.,

No. 17-501 NCTA-The Internet & Television Association v. FCC, et

al., No. 17-502 Techfreedom, et al. v. FCC, et al., No. 17-503 U.S. Telecom Association, et al. v. FCC, et al., No.

17-504

Dear Mr. Harris: The petitions for writs of certiorari were filed on September 27, 2017, and September 28, 2017, and were placed on this Court’s docket on October 3, 2017. After four extensions, the response for the government is due on March 5, 2018. We respectfully request, pursuant to Rule 30.4 of the Rules of this Court, a further extension of time for all respondents to and including April 4, 2018, within which to file the government’s response. Counsel for the petitioners have informed us that they do not oppose this request. Sincerely, Noel J. Francisco Solicitor General cc: see attached service list

Page 2: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0498BERNINGER, DANIELFCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

Page 3: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHRIS FEDELIJUDICIAL WATCH425 THIRD ST., SWSUITE 800WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

SAM KAZMANCOMPETITIVE ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE1310 L ST. NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 4: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

JEFFREY A. MANDELLSTAFFORD ROSENBAUM LLP222 WEST WASHINGTON AVE.SUITE 900P.O. BOX 1784MADISON , WI [email protected]

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE., N.W.WASHINGTON , DC [email protected]

Page 5: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 6: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0499AT&T INC.FCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

Page 7: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

PETER D. KEISLERSIDLEY AUSTIN LLP1501 K STREET, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

DAVID R. MCATEE, IIAT & T INC.1120 20TH STREET, NWSUITE 1000WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-457-3055

Page 8: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE. N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 9: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0500AMERICAN CABLE ASSOCIATIONFCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

Page 10: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

BARBARA S. ESBINPETR1875 EYE STREET, NWSUITE 700WASHINGTON, DC 20006202-872-6811

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

JEFFREY A. LAMKENMOLOLAMKEN LLPTHE WATERGATE600 NEW HAMPSHIRE AVE., NWSUITE 660WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 11: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

ROSS J. LIEBERMANAMERICAN CABLE ASSOCIATION2415 39TH PLACE, NWWASHINGTON, DC 20007202-494-5561

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE., N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 12: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 13: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0501CTIA-THE WIRELESS ASSOCIATION, ET AL.FCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

Page 14: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

REBEKAH PERRY RICKETTSGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP2100 MCKINNEY AVE.DALLAS, TX 75201

Page 15: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE. N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 16: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0502NCTA-THE INTERNET & TELEVISIONASSOCIATIONFCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

RICK C. CHESSENNCTA-THE INTERNET & TELEVISIONASSOCIATION25 MASSACHUSETTS AVENUE, NWSUITE 100WASHINGTON, DC 20001202-222-2445

Page 17: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

MIGUEL A. ESTRADAGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 18: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE., N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 19: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0503TECHFREEDOM, ET AL.FCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

Page 20: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHARLES KENNEDYTECHFREEDOM110 MARYLAND AVENUE, NESUITE 409WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

Page 21: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE., N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

CHRISTOPHER J. WRIGHTHARRIS, WILTSHIRE &GRANNIS LLP1919 M STREET N.W.EIGHTH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

Page 22: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

17-0504U.S. TELECOM ASSOCIATION, ET AL.FCC, ET AL.

DAVID C. BERGMANN3293 NOREEN DRIVECOLUMBUS, OH [email protected]

TIMOTHY M. BOUCHERCENTURYLINK1099 NEW YORK AVENUE, NWSUITE 250WASHINGTON, DC 20001303-992-5751

ANTHONY T. CASOCENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONALJURISPRUDENCEFOWLER SCHOOL OF LAWCHAPMAN UNIVERSITYONE UNIVERSITY DRIVEORANGE, CA [email protected]

MICHAEL A. CHEAHVIMEO, INC.555 WEST 18TH STREETNEW YORK, NY [email protected]

Page 23: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

OLIVER J. DUNFORDPACIFIC LEGAL FOUNDATION930 G STREETSACRAMENTO, CA [email protected]

MARKHAM C. ERICKSONSTEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP1330 CONNECTICUT AVENUE, NWWASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

LISA A. HAYESCENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY1401 K STREET, NWSUITE 200WASHINGTON, DE 20005

MICHAEL K. KELLOGGKELLOGG,HANSEN,TODD,FIGEL &FREDERICK P.L.L.C1615 M STREET, NWSUITE 400WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

RYAN C. RADIACOMPETITIVE ENTERPISE INSTITUTE1310 L STREET NW7TH FLOORWASHINGTON, DC 20005202-331-1010

Page 24: Washington, D.C. 20530 · caso@chapman.edu michael a. cheah vimeo, inc. 555 west 18th street new york, ny 10011 212-314-7457 michael@vimeo.com oliver j. dunford pacific legal foundation

STEPHEN J. ROSENLB3 LEVINEBLASZAK BLOCK & BOOTHBY2001 L STREET NWSUITE 900WASHINGTON, DC 20036202-875-2550

KEVIN K. RUSSELLGOLDSTEIN & RUSSELL, P.C.7475 WISCONSIN AVE.SUITE 850WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]

HELGI C. WALKERGIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP1050 CONNECTICUT AVE. N.W.WASHINGTON, DC [email protected]