washington state department of ecology water quality program amy jankowiak, compliance specialist,...
TRANSCRIPT
WASHINGTON STATE WASHINGTON STATE DEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGYDEPARTMENT OF ECOLOGY
WATER QUALITY PROGRAMWATER QUALITY PROGRAMAmy Jankowiak, Compliance Specialist, NWROAmy Jankowiak, Compliance Specialist, NWRO
(425) 649-7195(425) [email protected]
Kevin Fitzpatrick, Water Quality Section Manager, NWROKevin Fitzpatrick, Water Quality Section Manager, NWRO(425) 649-7033(425) 649-7033
Ecology Website: Ecology Website: http://www.ecy.wa.gov/ecyhome.html
Cruise Ship Website: Cruise Ship Website: http://www.ecy.wa.gov/programs/wq/wastewater/cruise_mou/index.html
Department of EcologyDepartment of Ecology& the Water Quality Program& the Water Quality Program
OUR ROLE / MISSIONOUR ROLE / MISSION
To protect, preserve and enhance Washington’sTo protect, preserve and enhance Washington’s environment, and promote the wise environment, and promote the wise
management of our air, land and watermanagement of our air, land and water
To protect and restore Washington’s watersTo protect and restore Washington’s waters
GOALS:GOALS: Prevent pollutionPrevent pollution Clean pollutionClean pollution Support sustainable Support sustainable communities & natural resourcescommunities & natural resources Focus on cleaning up Puget SoundFocus on cleaning up Puget Sound
Cruise Ships in Washington WatersCruise Ships in Washington Waters
Cruise ships to Seattle 1999 Cruise ships to Seattle 1999 Early 2003: BMPs for cruise ship maintenance in PortEarly 2003: BMPs for cruise ship maintenance in Port May 2003: sludge discharge from vessel;May 2003: sludge discharge from vessel;
discussions - MOUdiscussions - MOU Local Economic Impact (2008)Local Economic Impact (2008)
– $274 million annual business$274 million annual business– 2,380 jobs2,380 jobsSource – Port of SeattleSource – Port of Seattle
Why Focus on Cruise ShipsWhy Focus on Cruise Ships Protect State watersProtect State waters Cruise ships are similar to small citiesCruise ships are similar to small cities
– We have a number of permitted wastewater treatment plants on land We have a number of permitted wastewater treatment plants on land smaller than the average cruiseship discharge volumesmaller than the average cruiseship discharge volume
– Moving outfallMoving outfall– Various waste streamsVarious waste streams– Operating a treatment system – part art, part science; upsets/problems Operating a treatment system – part art, part science; upsets/problems
occuroccur Unique shape of State/marine watersUnique shape of State/marine waters
– Ships can be greater than 3nm from shore and still in WA watersShips can be greater than 3nm from shore and still in WA waters– The Puget Sound is the second largest estuary in the U.S.The Puget Sound is the second largest estuary in the U.S.– Poor flushingPoor flushing
Shellfish protection – public healthShellfish protection – public health– Over 1000 miles of Approved and Prohibited Area shellfish shorelineOver 1000 miles of Approved and Prohibited Area shellfish shoreline
RegulationRegulation
CRUISE SHIP CRUISE SHIP DISCHARGESDISCHARGES
MEMORANDUM OF MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDINGUNDERSTANDING
CRUISE OPERATIONS IN CRUISE OPERATIONS IN WASHINGTON STATEWASHINGTON STATE
The MOUThe MOU
SHIPS COVERED:SHIPS COVERED:– NWCA member lines (all > 1day, all >250 passengers, NWCA member lines (all > 1day, all >250 passengers,
15 ships in 2008)15 ships in 2008)
SHIPS NOT COVERED:SHIPS NOT COVERED:– Non NWCA large cruise ships that come to WA Non NWCA large cruise ships that come to WA – Small cruise ships (if not part of NWCA, <250)Small cruise ships (if not part of NWCA, <250)– AK Marine Hwy System (out of Bellingham)AK Marine Hwy System (out of Bellingham)– WA State Ferries (to land)WA State Ferries (to land)– Other types of ships or boatsOther types of ships or boats
The MOUThe MOU Signed April 20, 2004Signed April 20, 2004
One day before start of cruise seasonOne day before start of cruise season Major componentsMajor components
– Defines “Waters subject to the MOU”Defines “Waters subject to the MOU”– Prohibits untreated blackwater and untreated graywater Prohibits untreated blackwater and untreated graywater
dischargesdischarges– Prohibits treated blackwater and treated graywater discharges Prohibits treated blackwater and treated graywater discharges
unless AWTS. Can be approved 2 different ways:unless AWTS. Can be approved 2 different ways: One nm away from berth and moving at six knotsOne nm away from berth and moving at six knots
– AWTS which meets Alaska certification standardsAWTS which meets Alaska certification standards– continuous TSS/turbidity and disinfection effectiveness monitoring with continuous TSS/turbidity and disinfection effectiveness monitoring with
immediate shut downimmediate shut down– Documentation prior to dischargeDocumentation prior to discharge
OROR ContinuouslyContinuously
– AWTS which meets Alaska certification standardsAWTS which meets Alaska certification standards– continuous TSS/turbidity and disinfection effectiveness monitoring with continuous TSS/turbidity and disinfection effectiveness monitoring with
immediate shut down, and UV just prior to dischargeimmediate shut down, and UV just prior to discharge– Documentation prior to dischargeDocumentation prior to discharge
The MOU cont. The MOU cont. Sampling, etc.Sampling, etc.
If approved for discharge, agree to:If approved for discharge, agree to:– Not discharge within ½ mile of shellfish bedsNot discharge within ½ mile of shellfish beds– Immediately stop discharges if high Immediately stop discharges if high
turbidity/disinfection system upset & notifyturbidity/disinfection system upset & notify– Sample and provide test resultsSample and provide test results– Meet limitsMeet limits– Vessel inspections Vessel inspections
AWTS sampling
The MOU cont. The MOU cont. Residual Solids Residual Solids
Residual Solids (biomass, sludge) Residual Solids (biomass, sludge) discharges prohibited in waters subject to discharges prohibited in waters subject to MOU, within 12 nautical miles from shore, MOU, within 12 nautical miles from shore, and within the Olympic Coast National and within the Olympic Coast National Marine SanctuaryMarine Sanctuary
The MOU cont.The MOU cont.OtherOther
Solid waste, discharge prohibitedSolid waste, discharge prohibited Hazardous waste managementHazardous waste management Oily Bilge waterOily Bilge water USCG jurisdictionUSCG jurisdiction Non-compliance notification, compliance Non-compliance notification, compliance
letterletter Annual meeting, Annual Report, Annual meeting, Annual Report,
Amendments, FundingAmendments, Funding
Advanced Wastewater Treatment Advanced Wastewater Treatment SystemsSystems
Typically = Secondary treatment plus Typically = Secondary treatment plus ultrafiltration followed by UV disinfectionultrafiltration followed by UV disinfection(Integrated systems of enhanced aerobic digestion and low-(Integrated systems of enhanced aerobic digestion and low-pressure membrane filtration, followed by UV disinfection)pressure membrane filtration, followed by UV disinfection)– Zenon – membrane bioreactor with ultrafiltrationZenon – membrane bioreactor with ultrafiltration– Rochem – reverse osmosisRochem – reverse osmosis– Scanship – biological-biofilm with polishing microfiltrationScanship – biological-biofilm with polishing microfiltration– Hamworthy – membrane bioreactor with ultrafiltrationHamworthy – membrane bioreactor with ultrafiltration
High quality effluentHigh quality effluentComparison of Advanced Treatment System Medians
pH BOD5 TSS Total Residual Chlorine
Fecal Coliform
Units Standard units
mg/L mg/L mg/L MPN/100 ml
Rochem 7.28 14.9 0 0 0
Zenon 7.64 0 0 0 0
Scanship 6.94 10.9 7 0 0
Hamworthy
7.33 2.2 0 0 0
Source: ADEC Large Passenger Vessel Wastewater Discharge General Permit Information Sheet
MOU AmendmentsMOU Amendments
Amendments – July 2005, May 2006, May 2007, Amendments – July 2005, May 2006, May 2007, May 2008May 2008– Clarification changesClarification changes– Now covers other ports in WANow covers other ports in WA– Added requirement for annual compliance reportAdded requirement for annual compliance report– Specifies limits set for monitoring resultsSpecifies limits set for monitoring results– Expands sludge discharge prohibition to entire OCNMSExpands sludge discharge prohibition to entire OCNMS– DOH virus report recommendations incorporated (1/2 DOH virus report recommendations incorporated (1/2
mile from beds, disinfection system monitoring, mile from beds, disinfection system monitoring, shutdown and reportingshutdown and reporting
The MOU OverallThe MOU Overall
BenefitsBenefits– Without regulation specific to cruise ships (except VGP), Without regulation specific to cruise ships (except VGP),
at least have agreement in place to protect water qualityat least have agreement in place to protect water quality– Learning more about the vessels and equipment and Learning more about the vessels and equipment and
getting datagetting data– Procedure for notification of noncomplianceProcedure for notification of noncompliance– Still have enforcement capabilities for WQ violations and Still have enforcement capabilities for WQ violations and
press coverage if violate MOUpress coverage if violate MOU IssuesIssues
– Inability to enforce on the agreement itselfInability to enforce on the agreement itself– Lack of coverage of MOU for other vessels Lack of coverage of MOU for other vessels – Air quality issues not currently covered by the MOUAir quality issues not currently covered by the MOU
THE END!THE END!
QUESTIONS?QUESTIONS?