wastewater reuse at the mountain home air force...

46
Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service Daniel D. Ayers, CH2M HILL William Leaf, CH2M HILL Tom Kendall, Mountain Home Air Force Base WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE BASE

Upload: others

Post on 20-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Daniel D. Ayers, CH2M HILL William Leaf, CH2M HILL

Tom Kendall, Mountain Home Air Force Base

WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE BASE

Page 2: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Vicinity Map

Page 3: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

TREATMENT PLANT SITE PLAN

Page 4: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

TREATMENT PLANT SCHEMATIC

Page 5: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse System Layout

Page 6: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse System Schematic

Page 7: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Influent Characteristics

219Total Suspended Solids, mg/l39.3Total Kjeldahl Nitrogen,

mg/l0.033Nitrate, mg/l0.071Nitrite, mg/l

238Biochemical Oxygen Demand, mg/l

1.87Peak Hour, mgd0.93Maximum Day, mgd0.49Maximum Month, mgd0.43Annual Average Flow, mgd

Page 8: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Effluent Characteristics

4.652.89TP, mg/l

0.01130.0055Nitrite, mg/l

7.55.25Nitrate, mg/l

2.191.48TKN, mg/l

115TSS, mg/l

134BOD, mg/l

Max MonthAnnual AverageParameter

Page 9: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Permit Requirements

• Permitted Discharges– Rapid Infiltration– Plant Grounds Irrigation– Golf Course Irrigation– Compost Moisture Control– Soil Farm Moisture Control– Landfill Dust Suppression– NPDES

Page 10: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Permit Requirements

• Rapid Infiltration Discharge– Flow - 310 MG annually– TSS - 100 mg/l, 30 day average– TN - 20mg/l, 30 day average

Page 11: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Permit Requirements

• Reuse– Application Season - 4/1 to 10/1– Application time– 85 lbs TN/acre-year– Buffer Distances and Disinfection

• 100 feet requires 2.2 TC/100 ml• 300 feet requires 23 TC/100 ml• 1,000 feet requires 230 TC/100 ml

– Disinfection – 23 TC/100 ml– Future Filtration

Page 12: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Buffer Zone of 300 feet • Wind Drift Analysis

Page 13: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Isolation of Potable Water

• New Backflow Preventer

Page 14: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Irrigation Watering Times

• Effluent at Night• Well water during day

Page 15: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Sampling Times • Change of Sample procedures

Page 16: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

New Reporting Requirements• Reuse Wastewater

and Well Water Flows

• Total Coliform• Nitrogen and

Phosphorus– Reuse Wastewater– Fertilizer– Soil

Page 17: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Pond Water Quality • Post Chlorination• Point of Compliance

Page 18: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Permit Issues

• Water Balance • Historical Usage

Page 19: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study - Scope

• Class A versus Class B• UV Disinfection Upgrade• Equalization• Effluent Storage• Filtration Technologies

Page 20: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Design Criteria

• Class A/B common criteria– Suitable for Golf Course Irrigation– Secondary Treatment– Filtration – Disinfection - 2.2TC/100 ml– Pilot testing

Page 21: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Design Criteria

• Class A only requirements– Allows reuse for residential homes, groundwater

recharge, parks, playgrounds– Chlorine Disinfection CT=450 mg-min/l, modal contact

time=90 minutes– 5 log inactivation of virus– BOD <5 mg/l for groundwater recharge, <10 mg/l for

residential irrigation– TN < 10 mg/l for groundwater recharge, <30 mg/l for

residential irrigation

Page 22: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Design Criteria

• Class A Redundancy Requirements– Alternative disposal option or 7 days storage– Redundant facilities– Standby Power– Standby Filtration or bypass to alternate disposal

Page 23: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – UV versus Hypochlorite Disinfection

• Class A Disinfection Limits• Equalization

– New or Retrofit CCT

• CCT Retrofit– Equalization and UV disinfection– Construction Sequence

Page 24: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Retrofit of existing Hypochlorite Building versus new

Building

• Code Issues• Construction Sequencing• New Building

Page 25: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Reuse Water Storage Analysis

• Mixing of Class A water with existing stored water

• Storage Options– Pond Cleaning– New Steel Tank– New pond Storage

• New Pump Station

Page 26: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Option 1 Flow Schematic

Page 27: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Option 2 Flow Schematic

Page 28: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Filtration Technologies

• Cloth Disk

• Zimpro Hydroclear

• Parkson Dynasand

Page 29: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Filter Comparison Criteria

• Title 22 Certified• Performance• Fit in Existing Hypochlorite Building• Backwash volume• Headloss• Cost• Maintenance Issues

Page 30: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection

• All Filters Title 22 certified• All Filters had acceptable performance history• Cloth Disk Fit Best in Hypo building• All filters had acceptable BW volumes• Cloth Disk lowest headloss, pumped anyway• Cloth Disk lowest quote• Cloth Disk low maintenance• Cloth Disk selected for this application

Page 31: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Option 1 versus Option 2

• UV versus Hypo analysis affected option costs• Option 2 selected• Keep Hypochlorite disinfection• New Cloth Disk Filter installed in a new filter

building• Requires New Equalization tank• New Effluent Storage and Pumping

Page 32: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Option 2

Page 33: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Option 2

Page 34: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Effluent Storage

Page 35: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Current Status of Project

• Waiting on funding for design and construction

Page 36: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

• Insert Photo

Page 37: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

• Insert Photo

Page 38: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

Page 39: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

• Insert Photo

Page 40: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

• Insert Photo

Page 41: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Aqua Aerobics Factory Visit

• Insert Photo

Page 42: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

QUESTIONS?

Page 43: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Filtration Study – Option 2 Hydraulic Profile

Page 44: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Storage

Page 45: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Golf Course

Page 46: WASTEWATER REUSE AT THE MOUNTAIN HOME AIR FORCE …air.idaho.gov/media/569901-ww_reuse_conf_07_id_case_study1.pdfFiltration Study – Filtration Comparison and Selection • All Filters

Knowledge… Commitment... Integrity… at Your Service

Treatment Plant