water licence application for construction of inuvik ... · figure 3-1 is a map of the inuvik to...
TRANSCRIPT
WaterInuvik
Submi
June 2
PrepareGovern
Departm
Yellowk
PrepareKavik-S
Inuvik, N
Project
r Licence Ak - Tuktoya
ission to the
013
ed for: nment of the
ment of Tran
knife, Northwe
ed by: Stantec Inc.
Northwest Te
Number: 123
Applicationaktuk Highw
e Northwes
Northwest T
nsportation
est Territories
erritories and
3511113
n for Constway
st Territorie
Territories
s
Calgary, Albe
truction of
s Water Bo
erta
f
oard
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Table of Contents
June 2013
iii
Table of Contents
1 PROJECT NAME..........................................................................................................................1-1
2 APPLICANT AND CONTRACTOR CONTACT INFORMATION.................................................2-1
2.1 APPLICANT INFORMATION........................................................................................................2-1
2.2 CONTRACTOR AND SUB-CONTRACTORS INVOLVED IN THE PROJECT ............................2-1
3 LOCATION OF UNDERTAKING..................................................................................................3-1
4 DESCRIPTION OF UNDERTAKING............................................................................................4-1
4.1 PROJECT DETAILS .....................................................................................................................4-44.1.1 Embankment Construction ...........................................................................................4-44.1.2 Watercourse Crossings Construction ...........................................................................4-4
4.1.2.1 Bridge Crossings .....................................................................................4-134.1.2.2 Culverts ...................................................................................................4-13
4.1.3 Borrow Pit Development .............................................................................................4-144.1.3.1 Additional Studies Required for Borrow Sources....................................4-17
4.1.4 Winter Road Construction...........................................................................................4-184.1.5 Camps and Other Supporting Infrastructure...............................................................4-18
4.2 ABANDONMENT PLAN..............................................................................................................4-19
4.3 PROPOSED TIME SCHEDULE .................................................................................................4-20
5 TYPE OF UNDERTAKING ...........................................................................................................5-1
6 STUDIES UNDERTAKEN TO DATE ...........................................................................................6-1
7 WATER USE.................................................................................................................................7-1
7.1 OBTAINING WATER ....................................................................................................................7-1
7.2 CROSSING WATERCOURSES ...................................................................................................7-1
7.3 MODIFYING THE BED OR BANK OF A WATERCOURSE.........................................................7-1
8 QUANTITY OF WATER INVOLVED ............................................................................................8-1
8.1 WINTER ACCESS ROAD CONSTRUCTION...............................................................................8-6
8.2 CAMP WATER USE .....................................................................................................................8-8
8.3 WATER SOURCES ......................................................................................................................8-8
9 WASTE DEPOSITED ...................................................................................................................9-1
9.1 WASTE MATERIALS GENERATED ............................................................................................9-19.1.1 Greywater and Sewage ................................................................................................9-19.1.2 Solid Waste...................................................................................................................9-29.1.3 Recyclables and Hazardous Waste..............................................................................9-2
9.2 SURFACE WATER RUNOFF.......................................................................................................9-3
9.3 STORAGE OF FUEL ....................................................................................................................9-39.3.1 Fuel and Lubricants ......................................................................................................9-39.3.2 Explosives.....................................................................................................................9-4
10 OTHER PERSONS OR PROPERTIES AFFECTED BY THIS UNDERTAKING.......................10-1
Water LicSubmissTable of CJune 2013
iv
11 C11.1 S
11.2 S
12 E12.1 T12.2 H
12.3 F
13 P
M13.1 O
13.2 S13.3 V
13.4 P
13.5 IM
13.6 R1313131313131313
13.7 A
13.8 E13.9 P
13.10 C
14 E
15 R
List of
Table 2-1Table 4-1Table 4-2
Table 4-3Table 4-4Table 4-5Table 4-6
Table 4-7Table 4-8
cence Applicion to the No
Contents
COMMUNITY UMMARY OF
UMMARY OF
NVIRONMENERRAIN, SO
HYDROLOGY
ISH AND FIS
REDICTED E
MITIGATION .OVERVIEW ...
PATIAL AND
VALUED COM
ROJECT INT
MPACT ASSE
RESIDUAL EF3.6.1 Asse3.6.2 Terr3.6.3 Wate3.6.4 Wate3.6.5 Fish3.6.6 Mus3.6.7 Wate3.6.8 Harv
ASSESSMENT
FFECTS OF ROPOSED M
CUMULATIVE
NVIRONMEN
REFERENCES
f Tables
ApplicScopeBorrowDeveloWatercBorrowPrimarOptionSourceConstrWater
cation for Coorthwest Ter
CONSULTATF PUBLIC INV
F ISSUES AN
NTAL OVERVILS AND PER
Y AND WATER
SH HABITAT .
ENVIRONME..........................................
D TEMPORAL
MPONENTS ..
TERACTIONS
ESSMENT AN
FFECTS OF Tessment of Rain, Soils ander Quantity (Ser Quality ..... and Fish Hakrat and Beaverbirds and Wvesting and T
T OF RESIDU
ACCIDENTS
MONITORING
E EFFECTS...
NTAL MANAG
S ...................
ant Contact Ine of Developmw Sources anopment as Recourse Crossw Sources Pory Constructional (Preferredes .................ruction ActivitLicence App
onstruction oritories Wate
TION ............VOLVEMENT
ND CONCERN
VIEW ............RMAFROST .
R QUALITY ..
.....................
NTAL IMPAC
.....................
.....................
L SCOPE ......
.....................
S WITH THE
ND MITIGATI
THE PROJECesidual Envird Permafrost .Surface Wate.....................bitat ..............ver ................
Waterfowl ......Traditional Lan
UAL ENVIRO
S AND MALFU
G PROGRAM
.....................
GEMENT PL
.....................
nformation ....ment as Revie
d Material Reeviewed by Esing Type andotentially to beon Plan includ) Constructio.....................ty Timing (Winlication Pre-C
of Inuvik - Tuer Board
......................T ....................
NS ................
......................
......................
......................
......................
CTS OF UND
......................
......................
......................
......................
ENVIRONME
ON ...............
CT ON THE Eonmental Effe......................r) ..........................................................................................................nd Use ..........
ONMENTAL E
UNCTIONS ...
MS ..................
......................
ANS .............
......................
......................ewed by EIRBequirements CIRB ...............
d Locations ....e Used Duringding Use of Sn Plan Includ......................nter/ Summer
Construction P
ktoyaktuk H
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
DERTAKING A
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
ENT ..............
.....................
ENVIRONMENects .................................................................................................................................................................
EFFECTS ................................................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................B ....................Considered in..........................................g Project Con
Six Borrow Soing Use of Fo.....................r) ..................Program Sche
ighway
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
AND PROPO
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
NT ........................................................................................................................................................................................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................n the Scope o..........................................
nstruction ......urces ............ourteen Borro..........................................edule and Sta
......................
.....................
.....................
......................
.....................
.....................
.....................
OSED
......................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
.....................
......................
......................
.....................
.....................of the ....................................................................................ow ..........................................atus ..............
.. 11-1
.. 11-1
.. 11-1
.. 12-1
.. 12-1
.. 12-2
.. 12-7
.. 13-1
.. 13-1
.. 13-2
.. 13-2
.. 13-3
.. 13-4
13-11 13-11 13-11 13-12 13-12 13-12 13-13 13-14 13-14
13-15
13-16
13-18
13-18
.. 14-1
.. 15-1
.... 2-1
.... 4-1
.... 4-3
.... 4-5
.. 4-15
.. 4-16
.. 4-17
.. 4-20
.. 4-20
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Table of Contents
June 2013
v
Table 8-1 Annual Project Water Use – Southern Spread ................................................................8-1Table 8-2 Annual Project Water Use – Northern Spread.................................................................8-1Table 8-3 Proposed Water Sources (Year 1)...................................................................................8-2Table 8-4 Proposed Water Sources (Year 2)...................................................................................8-4Table 8-5 Proposed Water Sources (Year 3)...................................................................................8-5Table 8-6 Daily and Annual Water Use Requirements per Construction Period .............................8-7Table 8-7 Length of Access Trails and Winter Roads Over Land and Water ..................................8-7Table 12-1 List of Common Freshwater Fish found in the Project Area (modified from
Rescan 1999).................................................................................................................12-7Table 13-1 Candidate and Selected Valued Components in the Project Area and Rationale
for Selection ...................................................................................................................13-3Table 13-2 Project Activity Interaction Matrix...................................................................................13-4Table 13-3 Potential Environmental Effects and Mitigations............................................................13-5Table 13-4 Synopsis of Recommended EIRB Mitigations Additional to Developer
Commitments ...............................................................................................................13-15
List of Figures
Figure 3-1 ITH Project Overview .......................................................................................................3-3Figure 3-2 Watercourse Crossings along the ITH Alignment............................................................3-5Figure 4-1 Culvert Type Section........................................................................................................4-7Figure 4-2 Large Diameter Bridge Culvert Type Section ..................................................................4-9Figure 4-3 Major Crossing - Bridge Type Section ...........................................................................4-11Figure 12-1 ITH Project Drainage Basins..........................................................................................12-3Figure 12-2 ITH Project Watersheds.................................................................................................12-5
Appendices
APPENDIX A Schedule III FormAPPENDIX B Construction Plan Overview AtlasAPPENDIX C Watercourse Crossing Overview AtlasAPPENDIX D Studies Undertaken to DateAPPENDIX E Environmental Management PlansAPPENDIX F Hunter and Trapper Committee PresentationAPPENDIX G EIRB’s Final Report of the Panel for the Substituted Environmental Impact
Review Proposal to Construct the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk HighwayAPPENDIX H Government of Canada Response to the Panel Report on the Proposal to
Construct the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk HighwayAPPENDIX I Developer/ Applicant Commitments
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardTable of Contents
June 2013
vi
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 1: Project Name
June 2013
1-1
1 PROJECT NAME
Construction of the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 1: Project Name
June 2013
1-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 2: Applicant and Contractor Contact Information
June 2013
2-1
2 APPLICANT AND CONTRACTOR CONTACT INFORMATION
Applicant and contractor contact information are provided in the following subsections. A signed Schedule
III form is included in Appendix A.
2.1 Applicant Information
The contact information for the Applicant, and their Primary and Field contact persons are provided in
Table 2-1.
Table 2-1 Applicant Contact Information
Applicant
Name Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of Transportation
(GNWT-DOT)
Mailing Address Lahm Ridge Tower, 2nd Floor
4501 50 Avenue
P.O. Box 1320
Yellowknife, NT X1A 2L9
Phone 867-920-6247
Fax 867-920-2565
Primary Contact Field Contact
Name Jim Stevens
Title Director Mackenzie Valley Highway
Phone 867-920-6247
Alternate Phone 867-445-3151
Fax 867-920-2565
2.2 Contractor and Sub-contractors Involved in the Project
A contractor will be confirmed in September 2013.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 2: Applicant and Contractor Contact Information
June 2013
2-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 3: Location of Undertaking
June 2013
3-1
3 LOCATION OF UNDERTAKING
Figure 3-1 is a map of the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk (ITH) project (the ITH project) area, situated between
Inuvik and Tuktoyaktuk in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region (ISR). The ITH project traverses Tuktoyaktuk
7(1)(a) and 7(1)(b) lands, as identified in the Inuvialuit Final Agreement, and Crown lands. Proposed
borrow sources, watercourses, water sources, camps, and access trails are shown in the Construction
Atlas (Appendix B) and watercourse crossings are shown in Figure 3-2 and the Watercourse Crossings
Atlas (Appendix C). No wastes are proposed for deposit in the ITH project area.
The UTM coordinates (UTM Zone 8, NAD 83) of the Project are as follows:
KP 0 (at the end of Navy Road) - Easting: 550347.89, Northing: 75910194.07
KP 119 (at the junction of the Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 Access Road) –
Easting: 579470.03, Northing: 7690056.87
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 3: Location of Undertaking
June 2013
3-2
NUNWTYT
INUVIK TO TUKTOYAKTUK CONSTRUCTION PROGRAM
ITH Project OverviewFIGURE NO. 3-1
ProjectLocation
Acknowledgements: Original Drawing by Jacques Whitford - AXYS Ltd.
Last
Modif
ied: J
une 1
1, 20
13 B
y: jpe
tho
PW13
170
309
173/305
314/325
Navy Pit
I401AI401A
PW11 (2.46)
PW10 (2.46)
GSC4
GSC3
PW17
PW18
PW19
312 West
174
177
27A
Inuvik
Tuktoyaktuk
SitidgiLake
NoelLake
HuskyLakes
ParsonsLake
HuskyLakes
Old ManLake
Macken
zie Ri
ver
Holmes Creek
Middle Channel
East Channel
8
43
31
18
35a
30a
23a
PREPARED FOR
123510689-175
0 5 10 15
KilometresMetres - 1:375,000
Major Bridge Crossing
Potential Borrow Source
Highway Alignment
Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 Access Road
Navy Road
Inuvik, 7(1)a Private Lands
Inuvik, 7(1)b Private Lands
Tuktoyaktuk, 7(1)a Private Lands
Tuktoyaktuk, 7(1)b Private Lands
Provincial Park/Reserve
PREPARED BY
NUNWTYT
INUVIK TO TUKTOYAKTUK HIGHWAY OVERVIEW
Watercourse Crossings along the ITH AlignmentFIGURE NO. 3-2
ProjectLocation
Acknowledgements: Original Drawing by Jacques Whitford - AXYS Ltd.
Last
Modif
ied: J
une 1
1, 20
13 B
y: jpe
tho
PW13
170
309
173/305
314/325
I401AI401A
PW11 (2.46)
PW10 (2.46)
GSC4
GSC3
PW17
PW18
PW19
312 West
174
177
27A
Inuvik
Tuktoyaktuk
SitidgiLake
NoelLake
HuskyLakes
ParsonsLake
HuskyLakes
Old ManLake
Macken
zie Ri
ver
Holmes Creek
Middle Channel
East Channel
Pingo CanadianLandmark
9 87 6
543
1
A2
A3
A8
A9
31
2625
21
20
1817
15
14
13
1210
39d39c
39b
39a
A2a
A10A11
A1335a
34e34c
34b
34a33b
30a29a
28a
27c27b
24a23a
22b
22a
21a
13a
2
19
16
11
5a
A12
33a
27a
24b
20a
18a
17a
12b12a
34a2
27b2
PREPARED FOR
123510689-169
0 5 10 15
KilometresMetres - 1:375,000
Major Bridge Crossing
Large Diameter Bridge Culvert
Culvert
Potential Borrow Source
Highway Alignment
Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 Access Road
Navy Road
Provincial Park/Reserve
PREPARED BY
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-1
4 DESCRIPTION OF UNDERTAKING
GWNT-DOT is submitting a Water Licence Application to the Northwest Territories Water Board
(NWTWB), to authorize certain activities associated with construction of the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk
Highway pursuant to requirements of the Northwest Territories Waters Act and the Northwest Territories
Waters Regulations.
The ITH project is a proposed 140 km all-season highway between the Town of Inuvik and the Hamlet of
Tuktoyaktuk in the ISR. The ITH project has undergone substituted panel review by the Environmental
Impact Review Board (EIRB) pursuant to the Inuvialuit Final Agreement and the Canadian Environmental
Assessment Act. The EIRB concluded in its decision report of January 25, 2013 that the ITH project will
result in significant impacts to the environment, but that these impacts can be mitigated through the
implementation of 51 recommended measures (Appendix G, EIRB 2013). The Governments of Canada
and Northwest Territories have responded to the EIRB’s report by accepting, accepting the intent or
rejecting each of the EIRB’s recommendations (Appendix H, Government of Canada 2013).
The EIRB’s recommendations were based on the scope of the development as shown in Table 4-1.
Table 4-1 Scope of Development as Reviewed by EIRB
Project Component Included in Scope of Development Not Included in Scope of Development
All-weather highwayfrom Inuvik toTuktoyaktuk
Primary Alignment as amended byAlternatives 1 and 3
Alternative 2 (Upland Route), and thoseportions of the Primary alignment amendedby Alternatives 1 and 3
Watercourse crossingstructures
84 stream crossing structures,consisting of 52 culverts, 9 bridges, 23culverts or short bridges
Summer works – limited to out-of-streambed activities, such as bridgegirder and deck construction andassociated works
Winter works – all instream activitiesand associated works
Any additional stream crossingstructures not included in this inventory
Summer works – no instream work orassociated activities
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-2
Table 4-1 Scope of Development as Reviewed by EIRB (cont’d)
Project Component Included in Scope of Development Not Included in Scope of Development
Aggregate Sources(borrow and quarryareas to supportconstruction,operations andmaintenancerequirements)
The aggregate sources and volumes to beextracted in the indicated timeframes, asidentified in Table 1
Any additional aggregate sources notidentified in Table 1
1
Any additional volumes not identified inTable 1
Any additional volume of aggregaterequired from any of the identifiedsources during any of the operationaltime periods (i.e., construction, years 1-20, 21-40, 41-50) indicated in Table 1
Construction stagingareas
Construction staging areas to be usedduring construction of the ITH
None
Maintenance areas Winter and summer season maintenanceareas associated with the temporaryconstruction camp locations
Any other maintenance area required duringconstruction but not identified
Temporaryconstruction campfacilities (includingwater use,wastewater disposal,resupply, powersupply, and domesticwaste disposal)
Temporary construction camp facilitieslocated at the borrow source closer to theconstruction activities
Any other temporary construction campfacilities not located at the closest borrowsource
Temporaryconstruction accessroads
Temporary winter access road that isparallel to the permanent alignmentduring construction
Temporary winter access roads to theborrow sources during construction
None
Ongoing operationsof the all-weatherhighway
All equipment and associated activities foroperations phase will be staged locallyfrom Inuvik and Tuktoyaktuk
Maintenance or staging areas that maybe required for operations that will belocated at any point along the Inuvik toTuktoyaktuk Highway
Temporary or permanent access roadsto water sources to be used for dustsuppression during operations phase
Stockpile areas along the permanentroad alignment used to store granularmaterial for summer maintenance andre-habilitation during the operationsphase
1Note that this should refer to “Table 2” in the EIRB report (EIRB 2013) titled “Estimated Material Requirements for
the 50-year Period”. For reference, these include Sources 325/314, 309, 174, 170, 177, 173/305 and 307.
Table 2 of
Table 4-2
The ITH p
Const
Winte
Winte
Winte
Const
Summ
Winte
Trans
Storag
Construct
f the EIRB’s R
2 BorroDevel
project compr
truction and o
er developmen
er and summe
er construction
truction of per
mer embankm
er and summe
sportation of fu
ge of fuel
tion activities
Water Lice
Report of EIR
ow Sourceslopment as
ises:
operation of w
nt and operati
er operation of
n of new emb
rmanent wate
ment compacti
er operation of
uel, waste, eq
are planned t
nce Applicat
R is reproduce
and MateriReviewed b
winter roads an
ion of borrow
f temporary c
ankment
ercourse cross
ion, surfacing
f temporary m
quipment and
to begin winte
tion for ConsSubmission
ed here for ref
ial Requiremby EIRB
nd access tra
sources
camps
sing and drain
and grading
maintenance a
personnel
er 2013 and w
struction of In to the North
Secti
ference, as T
ments Cons
ails
nage structure
and storage a
will be comple
Inuvik - Tukthwest Territoon 4: Descrip
Table 4-2.
sidered in th
es
areas
eted summer
toyaktuk Higories Water Bption of Undert
June
he Scope o
2017.
ghwayBoardtaking e 2013
4-3
f the
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-4
4.1 Project Details
Throughout this discussion, construction activities are described as being undertaken in either “winter” or
“summer”. For the purpose of this application, “winter” is defined as the period between approximately
November 15 and April 30, and “summer” is considered to be the period between May 1 and
November 14. These periods may change annually based on snow and ground conditions.
4.1.1 Embankment Construction
Approximately 40 km of new alignment will be constructed each winter, along separate spreads, each
approximately 20 km in length. Construction spreads will progress from North to South (beginning at
Source 177 Access Road), and South to North (generally beginning at the end of Navy Road, within the
ISR). Progressive spreads constructed each winter will begin at the end of the embankment constructed
the previous winter. Construction of the embankment for the ITH project will occur during the winter
months to protect the ice-rich terrain along the alignment and to establish a frozen core embankment for
the highway.
Embankment material will be sourced from borrow pits authorized for use on the project. Material will be
hauled directly from borrow pits to the end of constructed embankment, where it will be “end-dumped”
over geotextile fabric, and leveled. Successive “lifts” (thicknesses) of material will be placed until the
specified thickness is achieved.
Surfacing and grading of constructed embankment will be conducted in summer, once the constructed
embankment is able to support heavy equipment: during mid-July to late September. During this time,
compaction of the embankment and installation of insulation in certain areas may also be completed.
Material suitable for surfacing will be sourced from approved sources and will have been stockpiled along
the embankment in winter.
4.1.2 Watercourse Crossings Construction
The ITH from Kilometer Post (KP) 0 to KP 119 crosses 65 watercourses. In summer 2012, a
hydrotechnical field assessment of the stream crossings was completed to obtain site specific information
for the design of each watercourse crossing (KAVIK-STANTEC 2012e). Specific information collected on
each watercourse crossing including geographic coordinates (UTM based), channel descriptions,
topographical information including channel cross sections, elevation, water velocity measurements, and
photographs. A desktop hydrologic analysis was completed to estimate the 2-year, 10-year, 20-year,
50-year and 100-year return flow for each watershed along the proposed highway. A copy of this study is
included in Appendix B of KAVIK-STANTEC’s (2012e) Hydrotechnical Assessment of Stream Crossings
(provided in Appendix D.3). This information was used to complete an advanced design of the size and
type of the crossings for each of the 65 watercourses. A final design is expected in August 2013.
Fish and fish habitat related assessments have also been undertaken at select watercourse crossings
with potential fish habitat (Appendix D.4, D.5, D.6).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-5
The construction of the watercourse crossings will be concurrent with the construction of the new highway
embankment. Crossing structures will comprise culverts, large diameter bridge culverts, and bridges.
Final crossing designs will be submitted to support applications for fisheries authorizations.
Three crossing categories are proposed for the ITH project. The crossing locations, categorized by type,
are shown in Figure 3-2 and the Watercourse Crossing Atlas (Appendix C). The crossing types include:
Culvert crossings – crosses watercourses that are small in width, with peak 100-year flows of up to 3.0
metres/second (m3/s). Culvert structures of minimum 1,200 mm diameter will be used. A type section
drawing of a culvert is shown in Figure 4-1.
Large diameter bridge culvert crossings – will be used to cross watercourses with larger wetted widths
than culvert crossings and with peak 100-year flows of between 3.0 m3/s and 4.0 m
3/s. A type section
drawing of a large diameter bridge culvert is shown in Figure 4-2.
Major bridge crossings – typically crosses watercourses larger in width than watercourses crossed by
large diameter bridge culvert crossings, and with peak 100-year flows greater than 4.0 m3/s. A type
section drawing of a major bridge crossing is shown in Figure 4-3.
Final crossing designs will be available in August 2013.
The crossings types and geographic coordinates are listed in Table 4-3 and shown on Figure 3-2.
Table 4-3 Watercourse Crossing Type and Locations
Crossing Type Crossing # Northing Easting Crossing # Northing Easting
Culvert Crossing 1 7591582.3 550663.1 25 7629147.3 559101.8
2 7591899.5 550677.3 26 7630498.2 558692.7
5 7594078.0 550770.7 27a 7632088.7 559103.4
5a 7594199.8 550776.2 27b 7633290.0 558943.2
6 7596008.5 550877.7 27b2 7634125.3 558597.0
7 7596782.8 550489.2 27c 7634927.0 558119.7
9 7598256.7 550524.8 28a 7638033.9 558406.2
10 7598920.1 550436.2 29a 7639756.6 558215.9
11 7599279.2 550485.0 33a 7656657.9 567410.9
12 7600900.1 550243.5 33b 7656660.9 567653.9
12a 7601903.5 550447.4 34a 7657858.4 569591.3
12b 7602926.7 550398.4 34a2 7660124.8 571503.8
13 7602970.6 550405.2 34b 7660497.8 572206.4
13a 7606561.1 551297.6 34c 7661864.8 573369.7
14 7608123.4 552137.6 34e 7662853.5 573754.7
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-6
Table 4-3 Watercourse Crossing Type and Locations (cont’d)
Crossing Type Crossing # Northing Easting Crossing # Northing Easting
Culvert Crossing(cont’d)
16 7611749.0 553248.2 A13 7664637.7 575960.8
17 7612085.1 553395.0 A11 7667973.0 576384.9
18a 7614160.4 555251.5 A10 7668519.5 576566.3
19 7614235.2 555440.8 A9 7669715.5 577775.8
20 7614393.5 556120.3 A8 7671465.9 577944.0
20a 7614578.6 556336.0 A2 7676338.5 578994.3
21a 7616111.9 557674.4 A2a 7678011.7 582169.6
22a 7618194.1 558218.8 39a 7680357.8 583457.9
22b 7622664.6 558812.1 39b 7683024.2 582861.7
24a 7628182.3 558907.9 39c 7683711.4 582984.8
24b 7628460.1 558988.5 39d 7685257.4 582320.0
Large DiameterBridge CulvertCrossing
15 7610783.2 553217.9
17a 7612979.5 554011.6
21 7614766.9 556660.1
A12 7667634.6 576340.0
A3 7674365.3 577908.5
Major BridgeCrossing
3 7592392.6 550644.5
4 7593258.0 550710.9
8 7597730.2 550570.8
18 7613971.9 554813.2
23a 7626147.9 559229.3
30a 7640372.3 558731.5
31 7648594.3 563401.5
35a 7664134.8 575596.5
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-13
There are nine watercourse crossings greater than 5 m wide at the ordinary high water mark, as
assessed by KAVIK-STANTEC in Hydrotechnical Assessment of Stream Crossings (2012e,
Appendix D.3). These crossings include 3, 4, 13A, 18, 21, 30A, 31, 35, A2a; their locations are shown on
the Watercourse Crossing Atlas (Appendix C).
The in-stream activities for closed bottom culvert installations will be confined to winter months, when all
locations are anticipated to be frozen to the bottom. In-stream activities are described in the following
subsections.
4.1.2.1 Bridge Crossings
Bridges and bridge foundations will be constructed at up to eight watercourse crossing locations
(Table 4-3). Bridge foundations will be constructed concurrent with embankment construction - within
spreads to be constructed each winter.
The construction of the foundations at most bridge crossings consists of:
installation of pilings (January - February) - these piles will be located outside of the stream channel in
all cases. No piles will be installed within the normal flow channel. The ad-freeze piles will be bored
into the stream bank, the cutting material hauled away for disposal, the piles installed in the boring,
and a sand slurry mix poured into the hole to bond the pile to boring wall.
installation of foundations/abutments and wing walls (February - March) - these abutments and wing
walls are installed on top of the piles, out of the stream bed itself. As such there is no work in the
stream itself on these items.
launching girders (May)
placement of erosion control (April - May) - erosion control may consist of placement of large diameter
clean rock, hand placed from the edge of the stream bed covering the embankment and protecting the
piles, abutments, and wing walls from erosion. Erosion control will be conducted in a manner
consistent with the Sediment and Erosion Control Plan (Appendix E.1).
While bridge foundations are being constructed, a winter ice bridge or snow fill detour will be constructed
adjacent to the works to allow movement of equipment around the construction site. Decking will be
placed in winter, but final manual installation of railings will be completed in summer.
4.1.2.2 Culverts
The embankment construction will include the placement of small and large diameter culverts for
watercourse crossings and to prevent ponding along the edges of the embankment (equalization
culverts). These crossing locations are distributed along the length of the highway. Culvert installation will
be concurrent with embankment construction along that section.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-14
The placement of large diameter culverts will occur after the stream to be crossed has frozen to the
bottom, and will involve the following steps:
excavation of ice out of the streambed to the installation elevation
sub-excavation, if required (at the present time, sub-excavation is not anticipated for any crossing)
placement of suitable granular material as the foundation bedding
compaction, installation of the culvert and backfilling
placement of erosion control as required
All culvert crossings are anticipated to be frozen to the bottom during installation. However, if it is found
that installation will be required in a stream that does not freeze to the bottom, an isolated crossing
construction will be applied with appropriate approval from DFO.
The final design of culverts, including consideration of diameter, material, and closed- versus open-
bottom culverts will be determined as a part of final design. Final design will also specify the type of
culvert to be constructed at each crossing location.
While culverts are being constructed, a temporary winter ice bridge or snow fill detour will be constructed
adjacent to the works to allow movement of equipment around the construction site.
4.1.3 Borrow Pit Development
Borrow pits will be developed to provide material for embankment construction. Up to fourteen borrow pits
may be developed during the three to four year construction period. A number of these borrow sources
may be used for more than one year of winter construction. The development and use of material from six
of these borrow sources was included within the scope of the EIRB’s review. Eight additional sources are
being considered for development and use during the construction period, as identified in Table 4-4. All
borrow sources potentially to be used for project construction will require authorizations from Aboriginal
Affairs and Northern Development Canada or the Inuvialuit Land Administration. Use of Source 177 is
already authorized. Applications for land use permits, quarry licences and quarry permits will be
submitted in August 2013.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-15
Table 4-4 Borrow Sources Potentially to be Used During Project Construction
Borrow Source Land Owner
Status
GeotechnicalInvestigations Reviewed by EIRB
Source 177 Inuvialuit permitted
Source 170 Inuvialuit √ √
Source 173/305orSource 174*
Inuvialuit √ √
Inuvialuit/Crown planned √
Source 309 Crown planned √
Source 312W Crown planned -
Source PW19A Inuvialuit planned -
Source 314/325 Inuvialuit/Crown √ √
Source PW18 Crown planned -
Source PW17 Crown planned -
Source PW13 Crown planned -
Source GSC 3-4 Crown √ -
Source PW 10-11 Crown √ -
Source I401A Inuvialuit √ -
PRIMARY CONSTRUCTION PLAN – SIX BORROW SOURCES
A project construction plan has been developed around use of the six sources previously included within
the EIRB’s review (the “primary construction plan”), summarized in Table 4-5 and shown in Appendix B.
Borrow pit development will consist of:
construction of winter roads for hauling material
removal and stockpiling of overburden
blasting or ripping of material
temporary stockpiling of material
material hauling
erosion control and meltwater management
progressive (annual) reclamation of areas of the pit
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-16
Table 4-5 Primary Construction Plan including Use of Six Borrow Sources
Borrow Source Land Owner
Alignment Segment / Timing Status
Year 1(N or S)
Year 2(N or S)
Year 3(N or S)
GeotechnicalInvestigations
Reviewedby EIRB
Source 177 Inuvialuit N - - permitted
Source 170 Inuvialuit N N - √ √
Source 173/305 Inuvialuit N N √ √
Source 174 Inuvialuit/Crown N N planned √
Source 309 Crown N planned √
Source 314/325 Inuvialuit/Crown S S √ √
Pits will be developed in accordance with the associated Pit Development Plan, to be approved by
Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada or Inuvialuit Land Administration, as part of
authorizations issued for individual pit development.
Borrow pits will be developed and operated in winter. During late summer (August – September), some
local grading and stockpiling may be undertaken at the source using equipment stored there during
summer. Winter camps and equipment will be stored during the summer at borrow sources, on a pad of
adequate thickness to protect permafrost. No summer road access to borrow pits will be required.
The methods for developing and operating these six borrow sources will apply to all sources proposed for
construction and will be detailed in pit development plans.
OPTIONAL CONSTRUCTION PLAN – FOURTEEN BORROW SOURCES
Use of other borrow sources identified in Table 4-6 is at this time optional, although preferred, and
described as the “optional construction plan”. The integration of optional sources into the construction
plan is being considered because it will reduce environmental effects, reduce project costs and improve
construction efficiency. Use of optional borrow sources during construction will:
Reduce the length of winter roads to be constructed
Limit operation of borrow sources to 1-2 construction seasons
Minimize need to construct winter roads to borrow sources over multiple seasons
Allow camps located at borrow sources to be closer to the alignment
Reduce project costs by reducing haul distance
The “optional” (yet preferred) integration of additional borrow sources is summarized in Table 4-6 and
illustrated in Appendix B.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-17
Table 4-6 Optional (Preferred) Construction Plan Including Use of Fourteen BorrowSources
Borrow Source Land Owner
Alignment Segment / Timing Status
Year 1(N or S)
Year 2(N or S)
Year 3(N or S)
GeotechnicalInvestigations
Reviewed byEIRB
Source 177 Inuvialuit N - - permitted
Source 170 Inuvialuit N N - √ √
Source 27A Inuvialuit - N X -
Source 173/305orSource 174*
Inuvialuit N √ √
Inuvialuit/Crown N planned √
Source 309 Crown N planned √
Source 312W Crown S planned -
Source PW19A Inuvialuit S planned -
Source 314/325 Inuvialuit/Crown S √ √
Source PW18 Crown S planned -
Source PW17 Crown - - - planned -
Source PW13 Crown planned -
Source GSC 3-4 Crown S S √ -
Source PW 10-11 Crown S √ -
Source I401A Inuvialuit S S S √ -
The GNWT-DOT made several commitments to mitigate effects from borrow pit development and
operation during the EIRB review process (Appendix I), and the EIRB made a number of
recommendations necessary to mitigate effects from borrow pit operations (Appendix G). GNWT-DOT
expects that these mitigations would apply to all fourteen borrow sources proposed for construction.
4.1.3.1 Additional Studies Required for Borrow Sources
Geotechnical investigations of all potential borrow sources to be used for construction have been ongoing
in 2012 and 2013, and additional investigations are planned for 2014. These investigations confirm the
volume, quality and extent of material, and will support applications for regulatory authorizations. All
geotechnical investigations of these fourteen proposed borrow sources were completed with the
appropriate permits and consultation with Inuvialuit organizations (KAVIK-STANTEC 2012a, 2012f).
During these consultations, GNWT-DOT communicated that the purpose of these investigations was to
identify additional potential borrow sources for use during project construction.
Water LicSubmissSection 4:June 2013
4-18
Evaluation
develop a
Additiona
be subjec
4.1.4
Winter roa
camp sup
Winter roa
support he
roads will
a minimum
snow off e
thickness
alignment
roads will
Construct
Novembe
each seas
Water to c
are shown
Access tra
and to mo
will consis
4.1.5
During wi
include:
const
fuel st
waste
equip
Construct
operated
preferably
can be ad
cence Applicion to the No Description o
n of results of
a final constru
l borrow sour
ct to the Inuvia
Winter
ads and acce
pplies during w
ads comprise
eavy equipme
be constructe
m 20 cm of ic
established ic
of ice sufficie
t, and will max
be constructe
tion of the win
er of each yea
son.
construct acc
n in Appendix
ails will be co
obilize equipm
st of 20 cm of
Camps
nter and sum
ruction camps
torage facilitie
e storage, tran
ment and ma
tion camps wi
per spread (N
y be located a
ddressed by m
cation for Coorthwest Terof Undertaking
f geotechnica
ction plan, wh
ces not previo
aluit Final Agr
Road Cons
ss trails will b
winter constru
overland roa
ent operation
ed by sprayin
ce cover over
ce surface on
ent for the equ
ximize use of
ed immediate
nter and ice a
ar. Access roa
ess roads wil
x B and furthe
onstructed to c
ment to summ
f compacted s
and Other
mer construc
s
es
nsportation, tr
terials staging
ill be operated
North and Sou
at operational
moving borrow
onstruction oritories Wateg
al investigation
hich will acco
ously include
reement’s scr
struction
be constructed
uction.
ads and ice ro
s such as gra
ng water over
frozen groun
the lake and
uipment loads
f overwater po
ely adjacent to
ccess roads w
ads must be c
l be sourced
er details are p
conduct clear
mer storage loc
snow, and wil
Supporting
ction activities
reatment and
g areas
d in winter an
uth), for a tota
borrow sourc
w sources clo
of Inuvik - Tuer Board
ns of borrow s
ompany applic
d in the EIRB
reening proce
d to facilitate
oads. Winter r
avel hauling, f
a packed sno
d. Ice roads (
then, as requ
s. Winter road
ortions (ice ro
o the alignme
will begin as e
completed prio
from approve
provided in S
ring where req
cations, at the
l not require t
g Infrastruct
s, supporting f
disposal facil
nd summer. Tw
al of four cam
ces. Where lo
oser to the alig
ktoyaktuk H
sources is un
cations of use
B review, but p
ess.
movement of
roads will be c
fuel re-supply
ow trail, to cre
(over water) w
uired, flooding
ds will be loca
oads) where p
ent.
early as poss
or to commen
ed water sour
Section 8.
quired, to sup
e end of each
the applicatio
ture
facilities will b
ities
Two camps, of
mps during eac
ocal concerns
gnment, optio
ighway
nderway and w
e of individual
proposed for
f material, pe
constructed e
y and waste tr
eate a layer o
will be constru
g the ice surfa
ated in proxim
practical. In ot
sible in the win
ncing embank
rces. Potentia
pport winter ro
h winter seaso
on of any wate
be required. S
f 60 person c
ch winter. Wi
s, or environm
onal camp loc
will be used t
l borrow sourc
construction,
rsonnel, fuel,
each year to
ransfer. Winte
of ice, to estab
ucted by clea
ace to build u
mity to the
ther areas, w
nter, possibly
kment constru
al water sourc
oad construct
on. Access tr
er.
Supporting fac
capacity will b
nter camps w
mental impact
cations have b
o
ces.
may
and
er
blish
ring
p a
winter
y mid-
uction
ces
tion
ails
cilities
e
will
ts
been
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-19
identified (Appendix B). Winter camps and borrow pit equipment will be stored during the summer at
borrow sources, on a pad of adequate thickness to protect permafrost.
Four camps will be operated in summer. Summer camps will have a capacity of 20 people, and will be
located on previously constructed embankment. Summer camps will support activities to be conducted
along the embankment, including compaction, grading and installation of railings.
Fuel storage areas will be needed at each camp location or at equipment and materials staging areas.
Diesel and gasoline will be required to support construction and camp operations. Fuel will be supplied
from Tuktoyaktuk and Inuvik, and refueling of vehicles will be undertaken either at the fuel storage
location, or at designated locations along the construction spread. Fuel will remain stored at camp
locations to be operated the following winter.
Five anticipated waste streams will be generated during the construction operations:
camp greywater
camp sewage
camp solid waste
recyclables
hazardous waste
The construction camps will utilize waste management facilities (greywater, sewage, solid waste and
recyclable waste) in both Inuvik and Tuktoyaktuk for the treatment and disposal of the waste generated at
the camps. Negotiations for this waste management service have been initiated with both communities.
Hazardous waste will be managed independently using the appropriate contracted resources for
collection, transport and ultimate disposal.
During construction, equipment maintenance will be required, and materials such as culverts and bridge
decks may need to be temporarily stored until emplacement. Designated areas will be constructed during
winter to allow for equipment and materials storage and maintenance. These storage and maintenance
areas will be located on or adjacent to borrow sources or constructed embankments.
4.2 Abandonment Plan
Reclamation plans will be included in each Pit Development Plan to be approved by the appropriate
regulator in accordance with the requirements of the Inuvialuit Settlement Region Granular Resources
Management Plan (ILA and INAC nd). A table of contents for a Pit Development Plan is provided in
Appendix E.4. GNWT-DOT is in discussion with Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development Canada
and the Inuvialuit Land Administration regarding the content and details of such plans. The highway itself
is a permanent public infrastructure and as such, will not be abandoned.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-20
4.3 Proposed Time Schedule
Construction activities are planned to begin December 2013 and will be completed in September 2017.
The primary embankment construction activities shown in Table 4-7 ends in Summer 2016; however, it is
anticipated that some additional grading activities may carry over during Winter 2016-17 and Summer
2017. The program will experience periods of shutdown from approximately May 1 to July 15 each year.
Table 4-7 summarizes generally, the timing of construction activities in winter and summer.
A fourth winter of construction (2016-17) may be required to complete embankment construction,
including placement of surfacing material.
Certain additional pre-construction studies are planned. These are summarized in Table 4-8.
Table 4-7 Construction Activity Timing (Winter/ Summer)
Winter2013-14
Summer2014
Winter2014-15
Summer2015
Winter2015-16
Summer2016
Embankment and CrossingsConstruction
Year 1-N
Year 1-S
Year 2-N
Year 2-S
Year 3-N
Year 3-S
Borrow Pit Development 4 to 51
4 to 6 4 to 5
Access Road Construction Year 1-N
Year 1-S
Year 2-N
Year 2-S
Year 3-N
Year 3-S
Camps and SupportingInfrastructure
42
2 4 2 4 2
Surfacing/Grading/Railings Year 1-N
Year 1-S
Year 2-N
Year 2-S
Year 3-N
Year 3-S
NOTES:1
Indicates number of borrow sources to be developed2
Indicates number of camps to be operated
Table 4-8 Water Licence Application Pre-Construction Program Schedule and Status
Program Activity Proposed Timing Status
Fisheries/ Hydrology
Fish habitat assessments at locations notpreviously surveyed
Field Survey July 2013 Planned
Final Report August 2013 -
Bathymetric studies (of 38 lakes not previouslysurveyed)
Field Survey July 2013 Planned
Final Report August 2013 -
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-21
Table 4-8 Water Licence Application Pre-Construction Program Schedule and Status(cont’d)
Program Activity Proposed Timing Status
Borrow Sources:
2013 geotechnical investigations of borrow sources Drilling NA Completed
Final Report June 2013 Working
2014 geotechnical investigations of borrow sources Drilling January –February 2014
Planned
Final Report June 2014 -
Consultation
Water Sources, Camp Locations, Navigable Waters(Tuktoyaktuk)
Consultation June 2013 Completed
Water Sources, Camp Locations, Navigable Waters
(Inuvik)
Consultation June 2013 Planned
Fish Habitat Assessments – DFO Authorization Consultation July 2013 Planned
Permitting
DFO Authorizations Submit July 2013 Working
DFO Compensation Plan Draft Options Plan September 2013 Working
Municipal Waste Transfer Agreements Agreement August 2013 In Discussion
ILA / AANDC Land Use Permit Applications Submit August 2013 Working
Quarry Permit / Licence Applications Application August 2013 Working
EISC Pre-Screening To Be Determined June 2013 In Discussion
Navigable Waters Application Application June 2013 Working
Update Final BridgeLocations
August 2013 Working
Environmental Management Plans
Emergency Response Plan Draft NA Completed
Final for Approval August 2013 Working
Spill Response Procedure NA NA Completed
Spill Contingency Plan Draft July 2013 Working
Final for Approval August 2013 -
Safe Work Procedure – Fueling Equipment NA NA Completed
Safe Work Procedure – Handling Petroleum NA NA Completed
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 4: Description of Undertaking
June 2013
4-22
Table 4-8 Water Licence Application Pre-Construction Program Schedule and Status(cont’d)
Program Activity Proposed Timing Status
Environmental Management Plans (cont’d)
Waste Management Plan Draft July 2013 Working
Final for Approval August 2013 -
Pit Development Plans Draft July 2013 Working
Final for Approval August 2013 -
Sediment and Erosion Control Plan Draft NA Completed
Final for Approval July 2013 Working
Explosives Management Plan Draft July 2013 Working
Final for Approval August 2013 -
Fish and Fish Habitat Protection Plan Draft July 2013 Working
Final for Approval August 2013 -
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 5: Type of Undertaking
June 2013
5-1
5 TYPE OF UNDERTAKING
The ITH construction project is considered an Industrial Undertaking as it comprises the construction of
an all-weather highway to provide access between the two communities of Inuvik and Tuktoyaktuk.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 5: Type of Undertaking
June 2013
5-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 6: Studies Undertaken to Date
June 2013
6-1
6 STUDIES UNDERTAKEN TO DATE
Several studies have been undertaken to date in support of the environmental assessment and the water
licence. A copy of these studies is included in Appendix D.
Studies undertaken related to watercourse crossings and potential water sources include:
Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway 2013 Bathymetric Survey (Kiggiak-EBA 2013, Appendix D.1)
Lake Bathymetry Survey for the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway (IMG-Golder 2012b, Appendix D.2)
Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk Highway Hydrotechnical Assessment of Stream Crossings (KAVIK-STANTEC
2012e, Appendix D.3)
Other studies undertaken related to watercourse crossings include:
Fish Habitat Assessment at Select Watercourse Crossings along the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway
(IMG-Golder 2012a, Appendix D.4)
Spring 2010 Aquatic Field Program Results for the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway, Northwest
Territories (Kiggiak-EBA 2010, Appendix D.5)
Assessment of Fisheries Potential of the Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 All-Weather Road Impact Area
(IMG-Golder 2009, Appendix D.6)
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 6: Studies Undertaken to Date
June 2013
6-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 7: Water Use
June 2013
7-1
7 WATER USE
The proposed water uses associated with the ITH project are:
To obtain water
To cross a watercourse
To modify the bed or bank of a watercourse (installation of culverts)
7.1 Obtaining Water
Water will be obtained for the purpose of daily camp operations and winter road construction. The use of
water will range from 32 m3/day, to 1,524 m
3/day during a short period of approximately 6 weeks. Water
use varies significantly throughout a construction year, depending on the construction period. Details are
provided in Section 8.
7.2 Crossing Watercourses
As discussed in Section 4.1.2, nine watercourses greater than 5 m wide at the ordinary high water mark
will be crossed.
7.3 Modifying the Bed or Bank of a Watercourse
The ITH project involves modifying the bed or bank of watercourses with continuous water flow and of
watercourses greater than 5 m wide at the ordinary high water mark (see Section 4.1.2).
Construction of all watercourse crossings, as described in the previous section, will require modification of
the bed or bank of the watercourse. The construction of bridges will require the excavation and
modification of “bed and banks” for the installation of pilings, the installation of foundations and
embankments and the placement of erosion control. All of these works will be undertaken during the
winter months when the bed and banks are in a frozen condition. The construction of culverts will also
require modification of “bed and banks”. The placement of large diameter culverts will occur after the
stream to be crossed has frozen to the bottom, and will involve the excavation of ice out of the streambed
to the installation elevation, sub-excavation (if required), placement of suitable granular material as the
foundation bedding and compaction, installation of the culvert and backfilling.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 7: Water Use
June 2013
7-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-1
8 QUANTITY OF WATER INVOLVED
Water will be used for domestic camp use, winter and ice road construction and maintenance, and
summer embankment construction and surfacing. The annual project water use volumes per spread are
described in Tables 8-1 and 8-2.
Table 8-1 Annual Project Water Use – Southern Spread
Water UseNov 15 – Dec 31
(Total m3)
Jan 1 – May 15(Total m
3)
May 16 – Nov 14(Total m
3)
Total Water Useper Year (m
3)
Domestic camp use1
564 1,620 1,098 3,282
Winter road construction 37,600 12,150 - 52,930
Winter road maintenance - 1,350 -
Summer embankmentconstruction and surfacing
- - 1,830
Ice roads* Not Applicable
ANNUAL TOTAL 56,212
NOTE:1
Bottled drinking water will be supplied from the Town of Inuvik
Table 8-2 Annual Project Water Use – Northern Spread
Water UseNov 15 – Dec 31
(Total m3)
Jan 1 – May 15(Total m
3)
May 16 – Nov 14(Total m
3)
Total Water Useper Year (m
3)
Domestic camp use1
564 1,620 1,098 3,282
Winter road construction 32,900 12,150 - 48,230
Winter road maintenance - 1,350 -
Summer embankmentconstruction and surfacing
- - 1,830
Ice roads Not Applicable
ANNUAL TOTAL 51,512
NOTE:1
Bottled drinking water will be supplied from the Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-2
The proposed water sources and proposed volume of water withdrawal for each year of construction will
be in accordance with the DFO’s (2010) Protocol for Water Withdrawal from Ice-covered Waterbodies in
the Northwest Territories and Nunavut. Proposed volumes to be withdrawn are identified in Tables 8-3
(Year 1), 8-4 (Year 2), and 8-5 (Year 3). GNWT-DOT is applying to use 10% of the available volume,
although actual water use will be significantly less. The locations of the water sources are shown in
Appendix B. Note that at the time of application, not all lake volumes are known. Lake volumes for lakes
to be used during first year construction (2013-14) are indicated in Table 8-3. Lakes for which volumes
will be reported through planned bathymetric studies in 2013, are indicated in Table 8-3 as “not available”.
Table 8-3 Proposed Water Sources (Year 1)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
SOUTHERN SPREAD
Lake at KP1 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP4 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP5 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP6 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP7 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP11 NA Will submit October 20131
Inuvik 4 (KP14) 1,154,0002
115,400 26,000 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 5 (KP15 Frozen toground –max. depth1.7 m
Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 6 (KP17) Frozen toground –max. depth2.0 m
NA Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Lake 6 (KP18) 42,5002
4,250 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 7 (KP23) 29,5002
2,950 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Lake at KP24 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP25 NA Will submit October 20131
38 (Jimmy Lakes)(KP28)
NA Will submit October 20131
37 (KP29) NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP29A NA Will submit October 20131
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-3
Table 8-3 Proposed Water Sources (Year 1) (cont’d)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
SOUTHERN SPREAD (cont’d)
Lake at KP29B NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP33 NA Will submit October 20131
35 (KP33) NA Will submit October 20131
Mackenzie River unlimited unlimited 25,300 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
TOTAL 56,300
NORTHERN SPREAD
Tuk 4 (KP102) 169,0002
16,900 16,000 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Tuk 3/ Lake 105(KP105)
528,0002,3
52,800 16,600 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013;IMG-Golder 2012)
KP110 NA Will submit October 20131
KP111 NA Will submit October 20131
Tuk 2/ Lake 106(KP113)
32,5002,3
3,250 3,000 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013;IMG-Golder 2012)
Tuk 1 (KP 115) 46,0002
4,600 4,000 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Lake 119 (KP119) 721,7242
72,172 12,000 Completed (IMG-Golder 2012)
Lake 120 (KP120) 4,231,0942
423,109 Completed (IMG-Golder 2012)
TOTAL 51,600
NOTES:1
Additional bathymetric surveys of proposed lakes are planned for August 2013; results will be submitted tothe NWT Water Board August 2013
2Available under ice volume
3Values used are from Kiggiak-EBA 2013
NA – not available
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-4
Table 8-4 Proposed Water Sources (Year 2)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
SOUTHERN SPREAD
Lake at KP1 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP4 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP5 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP6 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP7 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP11 NA Will submit October 20131
Inuvik 4 (KP14) 1,154,0002
115,400 26,000 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 5 (KP15 Frozen toground –max. depth1.7 m
Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 6 (KP17) Frozen toground –max. depth2.0 m
NA Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Lake 6 (KP18) 42,5002
4,250 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Inuvik 7 (KP23) 29,5002
2,950 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
Lake at KP24 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP25 NA Will submit October 20131
38 (Jimmy Lakes)(KP28)
NA Will submit October 20131
37 (KP29) NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP29A NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP29B NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP33 NA Will submit October 20131
35 (KP33) NA Will submit October 20131
Mackenzie River unlimited unlimited 25,300 Completed (Kiggiak-EBA 2013)
TOTAL 56,300
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-5
Table 8-4 Proposed Water Sources (Year 2) (cont’d)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
NORTHERN SPREAD
Lake at KP82A NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP82B NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP85 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP86 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP91 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP100 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP101 NA Will submit October 20131
TOTAL 51,600
NOTES:1
Additional bathymetric surveys of proposed lakes are planned for August 2013; results will be submitted tothe NWT Water Board August 2013
2Available under ice volume
NA – not available
Table 8-5 Proposed Water Sources (Year 3)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
Lake at KP40 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP41 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP42 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP45 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP47 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP50A NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP50B NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP52 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP54 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP55 NA Will submit October 20131
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-6
Table 8-5 Proposed Water Sources (Year 3) (cont’d)
Water SourceName
AvailableVolume
(m3)
10% of AvailableWater Volume(Application
volume)(m
3)
ProposedVolume to be
Withdrawn(m
3) Bathymetric Data
Lake at KP61 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP70 NA Will submit October 20131
11BC (KP71) NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP77 NA Will submit October 20131
Lake at KP78 NA Will submit October 20131
TOTAL 107,900
NOTES:1
Additional bathymetric surveys of proposed lakes are planned for August 2013; results will be submitted tothe NWT Water Board August 2013
NA – not available
8.1 Winter Access Road Construction
Water will be used for the construction and maintenance of winter and ice roads.
During construction, there are four distinct water use periods per construction year (November 15 to
November 14). From approximately November 15 to December 31, the maximum quantity of water used
per day may be up to 1,500 m3
(1,500,000 litres) to construct winter roads; this would be 700 m3
per day
at the northern construction spread, and 800 m3
per day at the southern construction spread. After the
roads are constructed, the water withdrawal rates decline significantly, to approximately 200 m3
(200,000
litres) per day (total of both spreads), from January 1 to May 15 for continued winter road construction
and maintenance, then 20 m3
(20,000 litres) per day (total of both spreads) from May 16 to November 14
for compaction of the embankment material and the final granular surfacing.
Table 8-6 identifies the per day cubic metre water use in each construction spread within each annual
construction period and the annual domestic water use.
The total annual water quantity required for the ITH project is approximately 107,724 m3; approximately
48,230 m3at the northern construction spread, approximately 52,930 m
3at the southern construction
spread, and approximately 6,564 m3
for domestic camp use. Water use will peak for a period of
approximately six weeks during the annual construction period.
The water used for the construction of winter roads will not be returned to source, except where it exists
as an overwater ice road. Melt water is expected to slowly infiltrate into the active layer.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-7
Table 8-6 Daily and Annual Water Use Requirements per Construction Period
ConstructionPeriod
Number ofDays
Daily Water Use(m
3)
Total PerConstruction
Period(m
3)Southern Spread Northern Spread
Nov 15 –Dec 31 47 800 700 70,500
Jan 1 - May 15 135 100 100 27,000
May 16 - Sept 30 138 10 10 2,760
Oct 1 - Nov 14 45 10 10 900
Annual Construction Water Use 101,160
Annual Domestic Water Use 6,564
ANNUAL TOTAL 107,724
Water withdrawal will be in accordance with the DFO’s (2010) Protocol for Water Withdrawal from Ice-
covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories and Nunavut, whereby no more than 10% of available
water will be withdrawn from any waterbody (Tables 8-3, 8-4, 8-5).
The operating capacity of the submersible pump will be 45 litres per second (600 gallons per minute) and
the size of the intake screen will be 0.70 m2
and will conform to DFO’s (1995) Freshwater Intake End-of-
Pipe Fish Screen Guideline and (2011) Fish Screen Design Criteria for Flood and Water Truck Pumps.
The length of access trails and winter roads over land and over water are shown in Table 8-7 below.
Table 8-7 Length of Access Trails and Winter Roads Over Land and Water
ConstructionYear Construction Spread
Access Trail Winter Road
Total(km)
Over Land(km)
Over Water(km)
Over Land(km)
Over Water(km)
Year 1 South (Optional/Preferred) 9.4 1.7 35.3 3.6 50.0
South (Primary) 42.9 0.0 29.4 1.0 73.3
North 2.4 15.5 4.9 12.1 34.9
Year 2 South (Optional/Preferred) 11.2 0.0 32.7 13.0 56.9
South (Primary) 11.2 0.0 29.5 4.9 45.6
North 5.9 17.8 5.5 29.7 58.9
Year 3 South (Optional/Preferred) 0.0 0.0 0.3 0.0 0.3
South (Primary) 0.0 0.0 21.8 0.0 21.8
North 0.0 0.0 28.1 12.6 40.7
Total (Optional/ Preferred) 28.9 35.0 106.8 71.0 241.7
Total (Primary) 62.4 33.3 119.2 60.3 275.2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 8: Quantity of Water Involved
June 2013
8-8
8.2 Camp Water Use
Domestic water use will include cooking, bathing, toilet, and laundry related activities. Bathing, toilets and
laundry are the largest consumers of water; therefore, low or no-flow toilets and low water use showers
and laundry facilities will be used at the camps. A maximum of approximately 6 m3
(6,000 litres) per day
will be required during peak construction periods, for a 60 person camp. It is estimated that each person
will use up to 100 litres of water per day. This is approximately 24 m3
(24,000 litres) of water required per
day over the four camps operating in the northern and southern spreads during peak construction
periods.
Bottled drinking water for camp use will be supplied from the Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk and the Town of
Inuvik.
8.3 Water Sources
Tables 8-3 to 8-5 lists the approximately 50 potential water sources identified over the length of the all-
weather highway to provide water for the winter and ice road construction. The locations of these water
sources are shown on the Construction Atlas (Appendix B). The bathymetric investigation of many of
these water sources has been completed (Appendix D), and the remainder of the bathymetric
investigations will be completed in 2013 (as identified in Table 4-8). The bathymetric investigations will
form the basis of the final selection of the water sources to be used in the road construction in compliance
with DFO’s (2010) Protocol for Water Withdrawal from Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest
Territories.
Bathymetric surveys for the identification of the appropriate water source have been undertaken using
two different methodologies. Winter bathymetric surveys were completed over ice using Ground
Penetrating Radar (GPR) to measure the depth of the water along several cross sections of a given lake
(Kiggiak-EBA 2013). Summer bathymetric surveys were completed from a boat using sonar depth
recording and Global Position System (GPS) position recording (IMG-Golder 2012b).
DFO will require that fish be protected from entrainment or impingement where water is extracted from
fish-bearing waters, including any water withdrawals made using water trucks. DFO has a Freshwater
Intake End-of-Pipe Fish Screen Guideline and Fish Screen Design Criteria for Flood and Water Truck
Pumps to assist proponents in the design and installation of fish screens.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 9: Waste Deposited
June 2013
9-1
9 WASTE DEPOSITED
During the construction activities for the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway various waste materials will be
generated, and various hazardous materials will be utilized. Methodologies have been developed for the
collection, transportation, treatment and disposal of the waste materials generated during the construction
activities with no anticipated deposition of the waste as part of project operations. In addition,
methodologies have been developed for the transportation, storage, containment, and utilization of the
various hazardous materials utilized during the construction activities with no anticipated deposition of
the hazardous materials as part of project operations.
Contingency plans for managing accidental discharges of waste materials or hazardous materials have
been developed to manage unanticipated events.
9.1 Waste Materials Generated
Five types of waste will be generated during construction operations, none of which will be discharged to
land or in or near any waterbodies. The waste types include:
camp greywater
camp sewage
camp solid waste
recyclables
hazardous waste
9.1.1 Greywater and Sewage
Management of greywater and sewage will include the storage of wastewater generated at the
construction camps (if required) and the periodic transport and disposal of sewage waste. Sewage from
no-flow (Pacto) or low flow toilets will be stored in sealed watertight containers and transported to
approved sewage lagoon facilities at either Tuktoyaktuk or Inuvik.
Greywater will be stored using approved holding tanks and will not receive any treatment while stored. All
camp greywater will be stored in 14,000 litre skid-mounted tanks. Full tanks will be transported to
approved wastewater facilities in Tuktoyaktuk or Inuvik.
The largest camps associated with the construction will have capacity for up to 60 people, depending on
the construction season. The wastewater generation associated with the maximum number of people (60
people) will be approximately 6 m3
(6,000 litres) per day per camp during the winter construction season
(November to May), or up to 24 m3
(24,000 litres) per day including all camps at both the northern and
southern spreads. Less wastewater will be generated during summer construction activities.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 9: Waste Deposited
June 2013
9-2
Each camp location will typically have a three day supply of water and wastewater storage available,
approximately 18-20 m3
(18,000-20,000 litre) each, with an additional 45 m3
(45,000 litre) insulated skid
mounted tank at each winter camp as additional storage in the event of a blizzard or other unforeseen
event.
The Town of Inuvik operates under a water licence with the Gwichin Land and Water Board, and the
Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk operates under a water licence with the NWTWB. Waste transfer agreements will
be negotiated with municipalities prior to construction.
There are no alternative methods for sewage and greywater treatment/disposal proposed, as package
treatments plants with subsequent discharge to land may be ineffective and unreliable for this type of
sensitive environment and cold climate.
9.1.2 Solid Waste
The management of solid waste from the camps and construction activities may include incineration or
the storage of the solid waste and the periodic collection of the wastes in a covered container vehicle.
The vehicle will haul the waste to the waste disposal facilities at either Tuktoyaktuk or Inuvik for disposal
within each of these facilities.
The camps associated with the construction program will have 20 to 60 people in residence at any one
time. The solid waste generated during maximum occupancy (60 people) will be approximately 1 m3
per
day. There are four camps proposed, two in the northern spread, and two in the southern spread, for an
approximate total of 4 m3
of waste generated per day during peak construction periods.
The solid waste disposal facility at the Town of Inuvik operates under a water licence with the Gwichin
Land and Water Board, and the solid waste disposal facility at the Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk operates under
a water licence with the NWTWB. The Applicant is currently negotiating an agreement with the
municipalities to receive this waste.
9.1.3 Recyclables and Hazardous Waste
The solid waste generated at the construction camps and equipment maintenance areas will include
minor amounts of hazardous wastes. Hazardous waste types will typically include fuel, lubricants, and
residuals from explosives.
Hazardous waste will be separated from solid waste and stored in ventilated enclosures, in closed-bottom
containers, in accordance with the Waste Management Plan. It will then be packaged, and hauled to
Inuvik for the appropriate treatment and ultimate disposal. The hazardous waste will be either treated and
disposed through a working arrangement with the Town of Inuvik, or transported for disposal via a
licensed carrier and an appropriate manifest to an approved disposal facility outside the NWT.
Recyclable waste will be disposed of through the recycling depot in Inuvik (if the facility is operational).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 9: Waste Deposited
June 2013
9-3
9.2 Surface Water Runoff
Sediment dislodged during project activities, such as borrow pit operation or watercourse crossing
construction, has the potential to enter adjacent watercourses or waterbodies.
The operation of the borrow pits for the supply of material for the road construction, as well as the
construction of watercourse crossings has the potential to generate seasonal surface runoff that may
contain sediment. Any runoff containing sediment will be managed in accordance with the project specific
Sediment and Erosion Control Plan (SECP, Appendix E.1).
9.3 Storage of Fuel
Two types of hazardous materials will be used during construction operations:
Fuel and Lubricants
Explosives
Storage and transport of explosives will be authorized under the NWT Explosives Act and any other
applicable legislation. The blasting contractor will be responsible for obtaining and operating in
accordance with applicable legislation.
9.3.1 Fuel and Lubricants
The management of the fuel and lubricants will include the winter and summer transportation of fuel and
lubricants to storage facilities at the borrow sites and strategic sites along the all-weather highway. The
fuel and lubricants will be transported along the winter roads, ice roads and constructed embankment by
fuel transport vehicles operated by qualified drivers. The fuel will be stored in approved storage tanks,
with appropriate secondary containment. The lubricants will be stored in sheltered facilities with
secondary containment. Lubricants that are waste material from oil changes and related activities will be
managed as hazardous wastes.
Fuel and lubricant transportation, storage, and application activities will be executed with the application
of the appropriate regulations, including approved procedures for packaging and handling during
transportation, approved containers (tanks and secondary containment for storage), and approved
application procedures.
Fuel storage areas will need to be constructed at each camp location or at equipment and materials
staging areas. Diesel and gasoline will be required to support construction operations. Exact fuel amounts
and types are not yet known, but it is estimated that each fuel storage locations may require capacity to
store up to 150 m3
(150,000 litres) of diesel and 5 m3
(5,000 litres) of gasoline.
Plans for the handling petroleum products, fuelling equipment, and responding to spills have been
developed or are currently being developed (Appendix E).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 9: Waste Deposited
June 2013
9-4
9.3.2 Explosives
The operation of the borrow pits will require the use of explosives as part of the extraction process. ANFO
(or AN/FO, for ammonium nitrate/fuel oil) explosives will be used during borrow pit operations. Explosives
will be managed in accordance with the Guidelines for the Use of Explosives In or Near Canadian
Fisheries Waters (DFO 1998). The storage and transport of ANFO will be permitted pursuant to
applicable legislation.
Blasting will be done at times when the ground is frozen, but in the event that water is encountered,
plastic blast hole liners will be used.
10
The Haml
discussion
OTHER PUNDERT
let of Tuktoya
n with these l
Water Lice
PERSONTAKING
aktuk and Tow
icencees rega
nce Applicat
Section 10
S OR PR
wn of Inuvik h
arding the rec
tion for ConsSubmission: Other Perso
ROPERTIE
ave licenced
ceipt of solid w
struction of In to the Northons or Propert
ES AFFEC
waste manag
waste and wa
Inuvik - Tukthwest Territoies Affected b
CTED BY
gement facilit
astewater.
toyaktuk Higories Water Bby This Undert
June
Y THIS
ties. The DOT
ghwayBoardtaking e 2013
10-1
T is in
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 10: Other Persons or Properties Affected by This Undertaking
June 2013
10-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 11: Community Consultation
June 2013
11-1
11 COMMUNITY CONSULTATION
11.1 Summary of Public Involvement
The ITH project recently completed an environmental review by a substituted panel review process
pursuant to the Inuvialuit Final Agreement and the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act. This
process was open to the public, and several interested parties engaged in the process during the
information request, technical hearings, and public hearing stages of the process.
Consultation was held with co-management agencies (e.g., Wildlife Management Advisory Council,
Fisheries Joint Management Committee, Inuvialuit Games Council, Tuktoyaktuk-Inuvik Work Group),
municipal councils, community corporations, hunter and trapper committees, and/or with the public on
several aspects of the ITH project, including traditional knowledge and traditional land use (February
2012), wildlife and fish protection (September, October and November 2012), and watercourse crossings
(September 2012).
Consultation regarding geotechnical investigations of the borrow sources listed in Table 4-4, was
undertaken as part of the Environmental Impact Screening Committee’s review of Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk
2013-2014 Geotechnical Investigations Program (EISC File No. 12/12-01). During this consultation, the
GNWT-DOT made it clear that the objective for investigating these borrow sources were for further
consideration for use during construction of the ITH project.
Water licence-related consultation was also conducted with the Tuktoyaktuk Hunter and Trapper
Committee in June 2013 to discuss camp site and water withdrawal locations. A copy of this presentation
is provided in Appendix F. Additional consultation with the Inuvik Hunter and Trapper Committee is
scheduled for June 17, 2013. Consultation records for these meetings will be provided by June 20, 2013.
Project plans will be adjusted as required to respond to concerns raised about locations of camps, use of
specific water sources or other aspects of construction.
11.2 Summary of Issues and Concerns
On January 25, 2013 the Environmental Impact Review Board (EIRB) released its Final Report for the
Environmental Impact Review of the ITH project (EIRB 2013) – the “Report of EIR”. The Report of EIR
made 51 recommendations it deemed necessary to mitigate the adverse environmental and socio-
economic effects of the project (Appendix G).
On April 5, 2013 the Government of Canada responded to the EIRB’s report, as required by the Canadian
Environmental Assessment Act. The Government of Canada “accepted”, “accepted the intent” of, or
“rejected” each of the 51 recommendations (Government of Canada 2013, Appendix H).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 11: Community Consultation
June 2013
11-2
During the EIRB’s review of the ITH project, the Applicant made a number of commitments related to
environmental management and protection, benefits and collaboration, project construction and
operation, project design and ongoing monitoring. A complete list of Applicant commitments is provided in
Appendix I.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 12: Environmental Overview
June 2013
12-1
12 ENVIRONMENTAL OVERVIEW
12.1 Terrain, Soils and Permafrost
The ITH project area spans two distinct Ecoregions: the Mackenzie Delta and the Tuktoyaktuk Coastal
Plain (Ecosystem Classification Group 2007). The Mackenzie Delta Ecoregion is part of the Taiga Plain
Ecozone and consists of the southern two-thirds portion of the Mackenzie River Delta. Typical terrain
along the Delta consists of low-lying fluvial and marine deltaic deposits characterized by a complex
network of small lakes and interconnected fluvial channels. North and east of the Mackenzie Delta is the
Tuktoyaktuk Coastal Plain. Part of the Southern Arctic Ecozone, the Tuktoyaktuk Coastal Plain includes
active portion of the Mackenzie River delta as well as uplands areas characterized by older glacial and
marine deltaic sediments.
More specifically, the terrain along the ITH project area consist of rolling to gently undulating landscape
characterized by glacial and post glacial deposits. Undulating till, hummocky outwash deposits and
extensive lacustrine plains modified by thermokarst and other periglacial processes are the most common
types of deposit. Alluvial and colluvial deposits are found overlying glacial deposits in several areas.
These materials are deposited by streams and gravity related processes and are found along
watercourses and moderate to steep slopes. Very poorly-drained peat-covered areas are extensive in
topographic lows and at proximity to small water bodies. Detailed terrain and surficial material
characterization and mapping in the project area was undertaken by KAVIK-STANTEC in 2012 (KAVIK-
STANTEC 2012b, 2012c, 2012d).The region is underlain by continuous permafrost with sediments often
containing excess ice in the form of ice veins, lenses, wedges, and massive ice (Rampton 1988).
Permafrost related landforms are present throughout the area as represented by extensive polygonal
networks and unique landforms such as pingos. The depth of the active layer (i.e. the portion of soil that
thaws seasonally) varies greatly in relation with the type of material and local site conditions (i.e.,
drainage, water content, micro-topography, etc.). Work from Tarnocai et al. (2004) in the Inuvik –
Tuktoyaktuk area indicates that active layer range anywhere from 30 cm to over 150 cm.
Organic and Turbic Cryosols developed on level to rolling organic, morainal, alluvial, glaciofluvial, and
marine deposits are the dominant soils of the Ecoregion. Areas where permafrost is found within one
metre of the surface, Brunisolic, Regosolic or Gleysolic Static Cryosols have developed. Wetlands are
typically composed of moderately decomposed fen peat, and polygonal peat bogs.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 12: Environmental Overview
June 2013
12-2
12.2 Hydrology and Water Quality
The study area includes three separate drainage areas (Figure 12-1) within two watersheds (Figure 12-2).
Most of the study area drains into Husky Lakes (Figure 12-1). Less than 10% of the study area drains into
the Mackenzie River primarily in the vicinity of Inuvik. The most northerly portion of the study area drains
into Kugmallit Bay and Tuktoyaktuk Harbour. Surface hydrology in the study area is influenced by long
cold winters, short cool summers and relatively low precipitation (IOL et al. 2004). Low terrain also
influences the hydrology causing the formation of diffuse drainage patterns. There are many shallow
lakes and ponds throughout the study area, as well as deeper larger lakes such as Husky Lakes,
Parsons, Noell and Jimmy lakes. Lakes are generally connected to other lakes or large drainage systems
by small creeks.
Permafrost in the study area restricts the amount of subsurface drainage. As a result, most spring runoff
drains to nearby wetland and lake complexes. However, in areas of predominantly peat and inter-
hummock channels, subsurface runoff into streams can also be important (Quinton and Marsh 1999).
Most of the smaller shallow lakes, ponds, and streams freeze to, or near to the bottom during the winter
period. Larger streams such as Zed Creek and Hans Creek may not freeze to the bottom and maintain
running water throughout the year (IMG-Golder 2012a).
Salts originating from the Beaufort Sea and transported by the air result in chlorine and sodium ions being
the dominant ions found in lakes on the Tuktoyaktuk Peninsula. Lakes have low levels of inorganic
nitrogen and inorganic phosphorus. Generally, there is a decline of nutrients in lakes located north of the
treeline compared to those in the tree line transition zone, except where local thaw-related failures have
directly impacted tundra lakes (Kokelj et al. 2009). Organically bound nutrients are closely associated with
vegetational and climatic zones (Pienitz et al. 1997). Total metal concentrations in the Lower Mackenzie
sub-basin, in which the study area is within, are typically lower than guideline levels for aquatic health and
drinking water but seasonally high levels can occur with increased discharge and suspended sediment
loads as occurs during spring run-off (Kiggiak-EBA 2011).
NUNWTYT
INUVIK TO TUKTOYAKTUK HIGHWAY OVERVIEW
ITH Project Drainage BasinsFIGURE NO.12-1
ProjectLocation
Base Data: Government of Canada; Drainage Basins: Rescan & Stantec Ltd.
Last
Modif
ied: J
une 1
1, 20
13 B
y: jpe
tho
Inuvik
Tuktoyaktuk
SitidgiLake
NoelLake
HuskyLakes
ParsonsLake
HuskyLakes
Old ManLake
Macken
zie Ri
ver
Holmes Creek
Middle Channel
East Channel
Husky LakesDrainage Basin
Kugmallit BayDrainage Basin
Mackenzie Delta
DrainageBasin
314/325
GSC3GSC4
309
PW13
I401A
170
174
PW17
177
173/305
PW19A
PW18
312 West
PW11 (2.46)
PW10 (2.46)
27A
8
43
31
18
35a
30a
23a
PREPARED FOR
123510689-174
0 5 10 15
KilometresMetres - 1:375,000
Drainage Basin
Major Bridge Crossing
Potential Borrow Source
Highway Alignment
Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 Access Road
Navy Road
Provincial Park/Reserve
PREPARED BY
NUNWTYT
INUVIK TO TUKTOYAKTUK HIGHWAY OVERVIEW
ITH Project WatershedsFIGURE NO.12-2
ProjectLocation
Base Data: Government of Canada; Watersheds: Government of Canada.
Last
Modif
ied: J
une 7
, 201
3 By:
jpetho
Inuvik
Tuktoyaktuk
SitidgiLake
NoelLake
HuskyLakes
ParsonsLake
HuskyLakes
Old ManLake
Macken
zie Ri
ver
Holmes Creek
Middle Channel
East Channel
Eastern Mackenzie Delta
Southern Beaufort Sea - Eskimo Lakes
Lower Peel andWestern Mackenzie Delta
Mackenzie River Delta (Main Channel)
43
A3
31
2118
15
A12
35a
30a
23a
17a
PREPARED FOR
123510689-148
0 5 10 15
KilometresMetres - 1:375,000
Single Span Bridge
Major Stream Crossing
Watersheds
Potential Borrow Source
Highway Alignment
Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 Access Road
Navy Road
Provincial Park/Reserve
PREPARED BY
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 12: Environmental Overview
June 2013
12-7
12.3 Fish and Fish Habitat
The fish fauna for the study area is represented by eight freshwater families of which the Salmonidae
family, including whitefish, is the most diverse and abundant. Families and species common to the area
are listed in Table 12-1. Some marine or estuarine species will move up streams short distances and can
be found at the mouths of creeks especially those draining into Kugmallit Bay or Husky Lakes during the
open water season. These species include fourhorn sculpin, rainbow smelt, starry flounder and arctic
flounder (Rescan 1999).
Table 12-1 List of Common Freshwater Fish found in the Project Area (modified fromRescan 1999)
Family Species Common Name
Esocidae Esox Lucius Northern pike
Osmeridae Hypomesus olidus Pond smelt
Salmonidae Coregonus autumnalis Arctic cisco (herring)
C. sardinella Least cisco (big-eye herring)
C. clupeaformis Lake whitefish (humpack)
C. nasus Broad whitefish (whitefish)
Prosopium cylindraceum Round whitefish
Salvelinus namaycush Lake trout
Stenodus leucichthys Inconnu (coney)
Thymallus arcticus Arctic grayling
Cyprinidae unidentified Unidentified minnows
Catostomidae Catostomus catostomus Longnose sucker
Gadidae Lota lota Burbot (loche)
Gasterosteidae Pungitius pungitius Ninespine stickleback
Cottidae Cottus cognatus Slimy sculpin
Important lakes for fisheries in the ITH project area include Noell Lake, Jimmy Lake, Parsons Lake and
Husky Lakes. Noell Lake supports Arctic grayling and lake trout populations (Rescan 1999), as well as
lake and broad whitefish (ICC et al. 2006). Jimmy Lake receives the outflow of Noell Lake and drains into
Husky Lakes via Stanley Creek. Jimmy Lake supports at least seven species of fish including Arctic
grayling, lake trout and northern pike. Broad whitefish are also present in Jimmy Lake and it has been
speculated that these whitefish utilize the lake as a nursery and have migrated to Jimmy Lake via the
creek system from Husky Lakes (Rescan 1999).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 12: Environmental Overview
June 2013
12-8
Parsons Lake supports at least 10 species of fish (Rescan 1999). Harvested species include Arctic
grayling, northern pike, lake trout, broad and lake whitefish and Arctic cisco. Zed Creek connects Parsons
Lake with Husky Lakes and allows fish passage between both lake systems. Husky Lakes consists of a
series of five interconnected basins which eventually drain into Liverpool Bay. During fish surveys in 2002
(Harwood 2003), 12 species of fish were captured including both freshwater and marine species (species
tolerant of brackish water). Fish species include lake trout, broad and lake whitefish, Arctic and least
ciscoes, inconnu, Arctic grayling, northern pike, starry and Arctic flounders, Pacific herring, saffron cod.
Fourhorn sculpin are also present in Husky Lakes.
Creeks such as Hans Creek, Zed Creek and Jimmy Creek provide habitat and migratory corridors for a
variety of species including lake whitefish, round whitefish, lake trout, Arctic grayling, ninespine
stickleback and slimy sculpin (Rescan 1999). Northern pike and burbot may also occur in these creeks
(IOL et al. 2004). There is suitable spawning habitat for Arctic grayling in both Hans and Zed Creek (IMG-
Golder 2011).
Most creeks in the study area will freeze to or near the bottom preventing the use of these systems by
fish during the winter period however community harvesters have reported that now some creeks no
longer freeze to the bottom, such as a creek into Noell Lake and some creeks in the Parsons Lake area
(ICC et al. 2006). There is sufficient water depth and flow in Hans Creek and Zed Creek to suggest the
potential for these creeks to provide overwintering fish habitat (IMG-Golder 2011).
For creeks and lakes (e.g., Keneksek and Canyanek systems) which drain into Kugmallit Bay the
shallower lakes may be used by different fish species for rearing and feeding. Deeper lakes may also be
used for overwintering. The streams connecting these lakes are mainly used for migrating between the
lakes and the ocean. Large upstream and downstream runs of broad and lake whitefish, and least cisco
can occur in these streams as fish either try to move up to the lakes to feed, rear, overwinter or move
down to return back to the ocean or Mackenzie River system (Chang-Kue and Jessop 1992; Bond and
Erickson 1987).
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-1
13 PREDICTED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS OF UNDERTAKINGAND PROPOSED MITIGATION
13.1 Overview
This section describes the potential effects of ITH project activities on Valued Components (VCs),
identifies mitigation measures to reduce, control or eliminate the effects, and presents the implications of
residual effects.
The ITH project, as an Industrial Undertaking defined in the Northwest Territories Waters Regulations, will
require a water license for the following activities:
Construction of a structure across a watercourse 5 or more metres wide at ordinary high water mark at
point of construction
Watercourse training (culverts)
Use of 300 or more cubic metres per day of water
In addition, there may be an indirect deposit of waste to surface water in conjunction with quarrying above
ordinary high water mark.
Project activities related to water licence requirements include:
Watercourse crossings
Water withdrawal for winter road construction and camp use
Waste management
Storage and handling of petroleum products
Potential environmental effects associated with these activities were identified through community
consultation, a review of the previous environmental assessment and screenings conducted for the ITH
project, and a review of scientific literature, maps, the Inuvialuit CCPs (ICCP 2008, TCCP 2008) and the
Inuvialuit Harvest Study (Joint Secretariat 2003).
The scope of development related to this water licence application that was included in the Panel’s review
(EIRB 2013) is as follows:
Temporary construction camp facilities located at the borrow source closer to the construction activities
Temporary winter access road that is parallel to the permanent alignment during construction
Temporary winter access roads to the borrow sources during construction
Watercourse crossing structures
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-2
The ITH project has undergone an environmental review by a substituted panel review process pursuant
to the Inuvialuit Final Agreement and the Canadian Environmental Assessment Act.
The proposed activities are consistent with those reviewed by the EIRB. All borrow sources will be
operated consistent with the Developer’s Commitments (Appendix I) and in response to the EIRB’s
relevant recommendations (Appendix G). Winter roads will be constructed in the same direction as, and
within 1 km of, (parallel to) the alignment to be constructed. Camp facilities will be located at borrow
sources.
13.2 Spatial and Temporal Scope
The spatial scope of the ITH project is evaluated at the following three scales: Project Footprint, Project
Area and Regional Area. The Project Footprint includes the highway embankment, winter and ice roads,
borrow sources, water sources, and camp areas. The Project Area includes a 1 km buffer extending from
Project Footprint boundaries. The Regional Area includes a 15 km buffer extending from Project Footprint
boundaries, and the seasonal range of each VC has been included in the assessment.
The temporal scope of the ITH project is limited to December 2013 (Year 1) to September 2017 (Year 4),
as discussed in Section 4.3: Proposed Time Schedule.
13.3 Valued Components
A Valued Component (VC) is defined as an environmental, social, economic or cultural component that is
considered important by the proponent, local communities, technical specialists and/or government. The
assessment of ITH project effects on VCs provides an indication of ITH project effects on broader
environmental and social conditions. Similarly, mitigation measures for ITH project effects on VCs provide
protection for the broader environmental and social systems they represent.
Candidate VCs in relation to the ITH project were selected based on:
Sensitivity to project effects
Importance to local communities and resource users
Territorial, national or international importance (including status under the SARA)
Value as an indicator of effects on related resources and broader systems
Candidate VCs were identified for the ITH project based on the environmental overview and community
consultation. Candidate VCs were screened to select final VCs based on their potential to be affected by
ITH project activities. In this study, candidate VCs were excluded if they did not overlap temporally or
spatially with the ITH project, or if there is no, or negligible, potential for the ITH project to affect them.
Selected VCs and the rationale for selection are provided in Table 13-1. The selected VCs are the subject
of further assessment and mitigation planning in Section 13.5.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-3
Table 13-1 Candidate and Selected Valued Components in the Project Area andRationale for Selection
Candidate VC Selection Rationale
Terrain, Soil and Permafrost Potential for ground disturbance during construction activities
Soil will be disturbed during borrow source activities
Water Quantity (Hydrology) Drainage patterns may be affected by the use of snow fills at creek crossings
Water withdrawal may affect lake water levels
Water Quality Water quality may be affected by accidental degradation of lake and creek banksand improper fill materials at lake and creek crossing locations
Water quality may be affected in the case of an accidental spill or discharge
Fish and Fish Habitat Fish and fish habitat may be affected through water withdrawal reducing or alteringviable fish habitat
Fish may be entrained or impinged by the water intake
Fish migration may be delayed or blocked due to snowfills used in watercourses
Improper fill materials at creek and lake crossings or cutting of banks may lead tosedimentation of watercourses or waterbodies potentially affecting fish habitat andfish health
Accidental fuel spills could have health effects or cause tainting of fish
Muskrat and Beaver Potential for push ups and dens to be disturbed by winter road construction andoperation
Waterbirds and Waterfowl Potential for changes to water quality from project activities
Harvesting and TraditionalLand Use
The winter and ice roads will provide access to subsistence fishing and harvestingareas
Lakes are an important subsistence fish harvest source
Larger watercourses may be used for transportation
13.4 Project Interactions with the Environment
A summary of potential ITH project interactions with environmental components is presented in
Table 13-2.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-4
Table 13-2 Project Activity Interaction Matrix
Te
rrain
,S
oil
an
dP
erm
afro
st
Wa
ter
Qu
an
tity(H
yd
rolo
gy
)
Wa
ter
Qu
ality
Fis
ha
nd
Fis
hH
ab
itat
Mu
sk
rat
an
dB
ea
ve
r
Wa
terb
irds
an
dW
ate
rfow
l
Ha
rve
stin
ga
nd
Tra
ditio
nal
La
nd
Us
e
Clearing of Right-of-Way and Access Roads √ √ √ √ √
Ice Road Construction and Use √ √ √ √ √
Overland Winter Road Construction and Use √ √ √ √ √ √ √
Winter Access Trail Construction and Use √ √ √ √ √ √
Winter Highway Embankment Construction √ √ √ √ √
Summer Highway Embankment Construction √ √ √ √
Watercourse Crossing Construction √ √ √ √ √
Camp & Equipment Mobilization andDemobilization
√ √
Camp Operation √ √ √ √ √ √
Camp Waste Management √ √
Borrow Source Development and Operation √ √ √ √ √
Equipment Maintenance and Storage √ √ √ √
Fuel Transfer and Storage √ √ √ √
Equipment Refueling √ √ √ √
13.5 Impact Assessment and Mitigation
The Applicant has developed many mitigation measures and commitments during the environmental
review process. This has resulted in the Substituted Panel determining that “it will cause impacts on the
environment”, but that “the potential adverse effects of the ITH project can be mitigated and properly
managed if the Panel’s recommendations and the Developer’s commitments are implemented” (EIRB
2013, p. iii). The Government of Canada (2013, p. 5) stated that “taking into consideration the Panel
Report and the implementation of mitigation measures that are considered appropriate, the Government
of Canada has determined that the ITH project is not likely to cause significant adverse environmental
effects.” The Applicant/Developer Commitments are included in Appendix I.
Potential environmental effects and corresponding mitigation measures are identified in Table 13-3. The
mitigation measures will be implemented for the duration of ITH project construction activities.
Table 13
Potentia
Terrain, S
Disturbancof permafrof-way and
Potential dterrain andconstructioroads, acccamps
Disturbancresult of nconstructio
Potential dcamp anddemobiliza
Disturbancof permafrdevelopme
3-3 Poten
al Environmen
Soil and Perma
ce of soil and drost from clearid access trails
disturbance of d permafrost duon and operatiocess trails and
ce of sensitive ew embankmeon
disturbance to equipment moation
ce of soil and drost during borrent and operat
Water Lice
Section 13: P
ntial Environ
tal Effects
afrost
degradation ing of right-
sensitive uring on of winter temporary
terrain as a ent
soil from obilization /
degradation row source tion
nce Applicat
Predicted Envi
nmental Eff
Clearing w
Clearing w
Equipment
Constructioroads, acce
Winter roadcrossings a
A minimumon the wintperiods)
Access trai
Constructioconditions
Engineeredterrain (e.g
Constructioroads, acce
Constructioroads, acce
A minimumon winter ro
Access trai
Mobilizatioconducted
Pit developDevelopme
Pit DevelopGranular R
Pit developGuidelines
Pit operatio
Borrow pitsreclaimed iPlan
Overburdereclamation
tion for ConsSubmissionronmental Im
fects and M
ill only be cond
ill be done by h
t used for clear
on vehicles will ess trails or con
ds and access as much as pra
m depth of 20 cmter road and at
ils will be const
on of new emba
d mitigation willg., polygonal ter
on vehicles will ess trails or con
on vehicles will ess trails or con
m depth of 20 cmoads and acce
ils will be const
n of camps andalong construc
pment and operent Plan
pment Plans wResources Man
pment will followVolume 7: Pits
on will primarily
s will be closedin a progressive
n, including orgn
struction of In to the North
pacts of Unde
Mitigations
Mitigation
ducted during fr
hand, where pr
ing will be equi
only be operatnstructed emba
trails will be roactical
m of packed sncamp locations
tructed to trans
ankment will oc
l be applied onrrain, ice-rich g
only be operatnstructed emba
only be operatnstructed emba
m of packed sness trails during
tructed to trans
d equipment ducted embankme
ration will be co
ill conform to thagement Plan
w guidance in Is and Quarries
y be during wint
d as soon as thee manner, as d
ganic material w
Inuvik - Tukthwest Territoertaking and P
n
rozen ground c
ractical
ipped with mus
ted on designaankment
outed so as to m
now or ice coves (during winte
sport heavy equ
ccur primarily d
slopes and areground)
ted on designaankment
ted on designaankment
now or ice coveg winter operatio
sport heavy equ
uring summer went
onducted accor
he Inuvialuit Se(ILA and INAC
NAC’s (2010) N
ter
ey are no longedescribed in the
will be stockpile
toyaktuk Higories Water BProposed Mitig
June
conditions
shroom shoes
ated winter road
minimize overla
er will be maintaer construction
uipment as req
during winter (fr
eas of sensitive
ated winter road
ated winter road
er will be maintaons
uipment as req
will only be
rding to the Pit
ettlement RegioC nd)
Northern Land
er required ande Pit Developm
ed for use durin
ghwayBoardgation e 2013
13-5
ds, ice
and
ained
uired
rozen)
e
ds, ice
ds, ice
ained
uired
on
Use
d ment
ng
Water LicSubmissSection 13June 2013
13-6
Table 13
Potentia
Terrain, S
Potential lyear winte
Degradatiosummer sequipmen
Degradatiosummer oequipmen
EIRB R36Water Boasame roadto access year in ordand terrainrepeated u
EIRB R37develop a respect tothat includsurface pewinter roaaggregatereports shappropriatAANDC, oless that eparticular impacts ofterrain chamonitoringshall be incumulativemanagemestablishe
cence Applicion to the No3: Predicted E
3-3 Poten
al Environmen
Soil and Perma
ong term effecer roads on soil
on of permafrotorage of campt
on of permafrooperation of camt
6: AANDC and tard shall ensurd alignments araggregate sou
der to avoid then damage caususe.
7: The Developemonitoring pro vegetation and
des active layerermafrost impad construction
e sources. Monould be filed wte regulators, inon a regular baevery two yearsemphasis on cf the roads on taracteristics. Tg program and ntegrated into the effects and aent programs t
ed by the IEMO
cation for Coorthwest Ternvironmental
ntial Environ
tal Effects
afrost (cont’d)
cts of multi-l
ost due to ps and
ost from mps and
the NWT e that the re not used
urces every e vegetation sed by
er shall ogram with d terrain r and near-cts from to the itoring
with the ncluding sis and not s, with cumulative these his its results
he daptive to be
OC.
onstruction oritories WateImpacts of Un
nmental Eff
)
Winter roadwhere poss
Additional bmulti-year o
Camps andadequate t
Camps andconstructed
Winter roadwhere poss
Additional bmulti-year o
Monitoring
of Inuvik - Tuer Board ndertaking an
fects and M
ds will be desigsible
borrow sourcesoperations
d equipment wihickness to pro
d equipment opd embankment
ds will be desigsible
borrow sourcesoperations
programs will b
ktoyaktuk H
nd Proposed M
Mitigations (
Mitigation
gned to minimiz
s have been pr
ill be stored at otect permafros
perated during t only
gned to minimiz
s have been pr
be developed i
ighway
Mitigation
cont’d)
n
ze length of ove
roposed to mini
borrow sourcesst
summer will op
ze length of ove
roposed to mini
in discussion w
erland portions
imize the need
s, on a pad of
perate on
erland portions
imize the need
with regulators
s,
for
s,
for
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-7
Table 13-3 Potential Environmental Effects and Mitigations (cont’d)
Potential Environmental Effects Mitigation
Water Quantity (Hydrology)
Changes to water volume or flowdue to water withdrawal duringconstruction and operation of winterroads, access trails, watercoursecrossings, and temporary camps
Water withdrawal will not exceed 10% of the available volume of anywaterbody, as per the DFO (2010) Protocol for Winter Water Withdrawalfrom Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories and Nunavut
Changes to water volume or flowdue to watercourse crossingconstruction
Construction of watercourse crossings will be conducted primarily in winter
Temporary watercourse crossings will be constructed in winter only, as icebridges or snow fills, in accordance with the DFO (2007b) OperationalStatement for Ice Bridges and Snow Fills
Snow fills will be removed or v-notched at Program closure as per DFO’s(2007b) Operational Statement for Ice Bridges and Snow Fills
EIRB R34: The 10 per cent waterwithdrawal limit contained in theDFO Protocol for Winter WaterWithdrawal from Ice-coveredWaterbodies in the NorthwestTerritories and Nunavut (2010) shallbe applied to every lake and waterbody used as a water source overthe lifetime of the Project.
Water withdrawal will not exceed 10% of the available volume of anywaterbody, as per the DFO (2010) Protocol for Winter Water Withdrawalfrom Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories and Nunavut
EIRB R35: Monitoring of the effectsof long term water use for theconstruction of these roads shall beincluded in the regulatory approvalsgranted by DFO, AANDC and theNWT Water Board, as appropriate,and the results of this monitoringshall be integrated into thecumulative effects and adaptivemanagement programs to beestablished by the IEMOC.
DOT will develop a monitoring program for monitoring the long term effectsof water use in discussion with the appropriate regulators
Water Quality
Sedimentation due to erosion andrunoff from clearing activities,borrow source operation, andconstruction of watercoursecrossings, winter roads, ice roads,access trails, and new embankment
All project activities will follow measures to prevent or minimizesedimentation and erosion as described in the Sedimentation and ErosionControl Plan (Appendix E.1)
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-8
Table 13-3 Potential Environmental Effects and Mitigations (cont’d)
Potential Environmental Effects Mitigation
Water Quality (cont’d)
Contamination of waterbody fromaccidental release of greywater,sewage or solid waste
All camp waste will be handled, stored and disposed of in accordance withthe Waste Management Plan (AppendixE.2)
Tanks used for transporting greywater will:
be watertight and designed to reduce surge during transport
be regularly and properly maintained by the operator to ensuredependable performance
All sewage will be contained and sealed in watertight containers
All solid waste will be stored in sealed, bear-proof containers
No wastewater will be discharged to land
Contamination of waterbody fromaccidental release of deleteriousmaterials from borrow sourcedevelopment and operation
All project activities will follow measures to prevent or minimizesedimentation and erosion as described in the Sediment and ErosionControl Plan (Appendix E.1)
All project activities will follow measures to prevent accidental release ofdeleterious materials as described in the Explosives Management Plan(Appendix E.3)
Borrow pit development will be conducted in accordance with the PitDevelopment Plan (Appendix E.4)
Contamination of waterbody fromaccidental release of fuel orhazardous materials duringequipment maintenance or storage,or fuel transport, transfer or storage
The Spill Response Procedure and Spill Contingency Plan (AppendicesE.5 and E.6) will be implemented if a spill occurs
All refueling and fuel transfer will be conducted in accordance with the SafeWork Practices for Fueling Equipment and Handling Petroleum
All hazardous waste will be handled, stored and disposed of in accordancewith the Waste Management Plan (Appendix E.2)
Refueling and servicing of machinery and storage of fuel and othermaterials for the machinery will occur a minimum of 100 m away from anywaterbody
Drip pans and drip trays will be placed under all equipment while not in use
All equipment will be inspected regularly to ensure it is free of leaks
All fuel storage containers will have integrated 110% secondarycontainment
Potential water quality effects wereidentified by the EIRB in relation tofish and fish habitat. As such, thoserecommendations are provided inthe Fish and Fish Habitat section ofthis table.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-9
Table 13-3 Potential Environmental Effects and Mitigations (cont’d)
Potential Environmental Effects Mitigation
Fish and Fish Habitat
Potential alteration of fish habitatassociated with clearing activities,borrow source operation, andconstruction of watercoursecrossings, winter roads, accesstrails, and new embankment
All project activities will follow measures to prevent or minimizesedimentation and erosion as described in the Sediment and ErosionControl Plan (Appendix E.1)
Alteration of fish habitat will be authorized by DFO
Potential alteration of fish habitatfrom water withdrawal
Water withdrawal will follow DFO’s (2010) Protocol for Winter WaterWithdrawal from Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories andNunavut
Potential fish entrapment andmortality from water intake
Water intakes will contain a fish screen as per DFO’s (1995) FreshwaterIntake end-of-Pipe Fish Screen Guidelines and/or DFO’s (2011) FishScreen Design Criteria for Flood and Water Truck Pumps
EIRB R30: The Developer shall,prior to construction, developmanagement plans for theprotection of fish and fish habitat inany areas affected by constructionin collaboration with DFO, and theTuktoyaktuk and Inuvik HTCs andFJMC.
Developer Commitment (Appendix I):
The Developer will develop and implement a fish and fish habitat protectionplan in cooperation with DFO, FJMC and the Tuktoyaktuk-Inuvik WorkingGroup that will include mitigation measures and adherence to OperationalStatements or other direction by DFO.
EIRB R31: The Developer shalldevelop a long-term maintenanceplan for the Hans and Zed Creekcrossings to protect fish habitat.
All project activities will follow measures to prevent or minimizesedimentation and erosion as described in the Sediment and ErosionControl Plan (Appendix E.1)
All Program activities will be conducted in accordance with the Fish andFish Habitat Protection Plan to be developed in consultation with theappropriate agencies
Wildlife and Wildlife Habitat
Disturbance or destruction ofmuskrat push-ups or nests from iceroad construction or winter waterwithdrawal
Muskrat surveys will be conducted prior to water withdrawal or winter roadconstruction
Disturbance or destruction of nestsof migratory birds due to summerconstruction activities
Bird nest sweeps will be conducted prior to summer construction activities
EIRB R32: The IEMOC shalldetermine appropriate setbackdistances for… critical habitat ofSAR, waterfowl and tundra-nestingbird species.
All Program activities will be conducted in accordance with the Wildlife andWildlife Habitat Protection Plan to be developed in consultation with theappropriate agencies
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-10
Table 13-3 Potential Environmental Effects and Mitigations (cont’d)
Potential Environmental Effects Mitigation
Harvesting and Traditional Land Use
Potential disruption of access toharvesting and traditional land useareas during winter construction
No construction activities will take place within 1,000 m of Husky Lakes
HTCs will be notified of construction schedule and location of activities
Temporary site-specific signage will be posted, as necessary, ifconstruction activities occur near traditional trails
Potential disruption of access toharvesting and traditional land useareas during summer construction
No construction activities will take place within 1,000 m of Husky Lakes
HTCs will be notified of construction schedule and location of activities
Summer construction activities will be limited to the constructedembankment
Potential disruption of fish harvestactivities due to watercoursecrossing construction or waterwithdrawal activities
No construction activities will take place within 1,000 m of Husky Lakes
HTCs will be notified of construction schedule and location of activities
EIRB R20: The Developer shallwork with the Parties (DFO, EC,ENR) and comanagement bodies(FJMC, WMAC) and HTCs toensure that the Developer’smitigation, monitoring andmanagement commitments relatedto wildlife, fish and harvesting aremet and reported on annuallythrough IEMOC or through thespecific comanagement bodiesresponsible for resourcemanagement in the ISR.
Developer Commitment (Appendix I):
An annual construction monitoring report will be provided to applicableregulators and interested parties that will include:
Encounters and mortalities;
Notifications provided to workers regarding wildlife presence;
Waste management practices;
Measures used to reduce disturbance to any nesting birds;
Dust control effectiveness;
Conformance with the Wildlife Management Plan, EnvironmentalManagement Plan, Erosion and Sediment Control Plan, and otherplans;
Adaptive management measures that were implemented, if any.
An Environmental Management Plan (EMP) will be prepared prior toconstruction, and will be submitted for regulatory approval prior to use. TheEMP will clearly define expectations for compliance monitoring,responsibilities, requirements for training, and reporting.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-11
13.6 Residual Effects of the Project on the Environment
13.6.1 Assessment of Residual Environmental Effects
As discussed in Section 13.5, the Substituted Panel reviewed the ITH project’s environmental effects and
determined that “it will cause impacts on the environment”, but that “the potential adverse effects of the
ITH project can be mitigated and properly managed if the Panel’s recommendations and the Developer’s
commitments are implemented” (EIRB 2013, p. iii). The Government of Canada (2013, p. 5) stated that
“taking into consideration the Panel Report and the implementation of mitigation measures that are
considered appropriate, the Government of Canada has determined that the ITH project is not likely to
cause significant adverse environmental effects.” The Government of Canada responded to the EIRB’s
recommendations by “accepting”, “accepting the intent of” or “rejecting” each of the recommendations.
Residual environmental effects are those effects to environmental components which remain after the
application of mitigation. The mitigation to be applied has been summarized in Table 13-3.
13.6.2 Terrain, Soils and Permafrost
To mitigate residual effects to terrain, soil and permafrost, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R36: AANDC and the NWT Water Board shall ensure that the same road alignments are not used to
access aggregate sources every year in order to avoid the vegetation and terrain damage caused by
repeated use.
R37: The Developer shall develop a monitoring program with respect to vegetation and terrain that
includes active layer and near-surface permafrost impacts from winter road construction to the
aggregate sources. Monitoring reports should be filed with the appropriate regulators, including
AANDC, on a regular basis and not less that every two years, with particular emphasis on cumulative
impacts of the roads on these terrain characteristics. This monitoring program and its results shall be
integrated into the cumulative effects and adaptive management programs to be established by the
IEMOC.
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R36: The Government of Canada accepts the intent of this recommendation and notes that it is
directed at AANDC and the Northwest Territories Water Board. The Government of Canada
understands the intent of this recommendation is to reduce the damage to vegetation and terrain from
repeated use of winter access roads. AANDC, as a regulator of land-use activities, has the ability to
manage this activity on a case-by-case basis, and will work with the Northwest Territories Water Board
and the Developer to ensure the appropriate management of winter road alignment.
R37: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer and
accepts its intent. The Government of Canada agrees with the need for monitoring reports to be
provided to the regulators, consistent with legislative and regulatory requirements, and will work with
the Developer to determine the appropriate scope of a monitoring program with respect to vegetation
and terrain.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-12
13.6.3 Water Quantity (Surface Water)
To mitigate residual effects to water quantity, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R34: The 10 per cent water withdrawal limit contained in the DFO Protocol for Winter Water
Withdrawal from Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories and Nunavut (2010) shall be
applied to every lake and water body used as a water source over the lifetime of the Project.
R35: Monitoring of the effects of long term water use for the construction of these roads shall be
included in the regulatory approvals granted by DFO, AANDC and the NWT Water Board, as
appropriate, and the results of this monitoring shall be integrated into the cumulative effects and
adaptive management programs to be established by the IEMOC.
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R34: The Government of Canada accepts this recommendation. The Developer has committed to
using DFO’s “Protocol for Winter Water Withdrawal from Ice-Covered Waterbodies in the Northwest
Territories” and other relevant guidelines. The Government of Canada notes that detailed information
is not required for all waterbodies according to the protocol; however, location and quantities being
withdrawn would still be required for each water source to determine compliance. This information
requirement will be addressed through the Northwest Territories Water Board process.
R35: The Government of Canada accepts the intent of this recommendation. Currently, there is no
program in place for the monitoring of long term water use; however, DFO will work with other parties
as appropriate, including AANDC and the Northwest Territories Water Board, to ensure that impacts
from water use are avoided and by providing expert advice in the development of monitoring plans,
coordinating monitoring efforts and sharing of information.
13.6.4 Water Quality
Potential water quality effects were identified by the EIRB in relation to fish and fish habitat. As such,
those recommendations are provided in Section 13.6.5.
13.6.5 Fish and Fish Habitat
To mitigate residual effects to fish and fish habitat, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R29: The Developer shall consult with both DFO and AANDC to determine appropriate mitigation
measures before using a chemical dust suppressant technique on the ITH.
R30: The Developer shall, prior to construction, develop management plans for the protection of fish
and fish habitat in any areas affected by construction in collaboration with DFO, and the Tuktoyaktuk
and Inuvik HTCs and FJMC.
R31: The Developer shall develop a long-term maintenance plan for the Hans and Zed Creek
crossings to protect fish habitat.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-13
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R29: The Government of Canada accepts the intent of this recommendation and notes that it is
directed at the Developer. The Government of Canada supports the need to manage the use of
chemical dust suppressants and would like to note that EC, TC, DFO, AANDC and the Northwest
Territories Water Board have overlapping jurisdiction with respect to the management of this matter.
The Developer shall consult with these departments to determine appropriate mitigation measures
before using a chemical dust suppressant techniques on the Project. The Government of Canada will
work with the Developer and other appropriate parties to promote compliance with relevant legislation
and to provide advice on proposed mitigation measures related to chemical dust suppressant
techniques.
R30: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer and
accepts its intent. As a participant in the co-management structure set out in the Inuvialuit Final
Agreement, DFO will continue to work with the Fisheries Joint Management Council and Hunters and
Trappers Committees on the management of fisheries resources in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region.
DFO will ensure that the mitigation measures as well as monitoring and management plans required
under any potential Fisheries Act authorizations are met through standard compliance monitoring and
enforcement.
R31: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer and
accepts its intent. DFO will work with the Developer with respect to crossing design details, fish habitat
compensation, mitigation measures and monitoring to address the information requirements necessary
to make a regulatory decision and issue potential authorizations under paragraph 35(2)(b) of the
Fisheries Act. If the crossings are properly designed, long-term maintenance to protect fish and fish
habitat may not be required.
13.6.6 Muskrat and Beaver
To mitigate residual effects to muskrat, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R25: The Developer shall complete pre-construction surveys for muskrat push-ups on lakes where
winter snow removal and/or winter water withdrawal will take place.
R26: The Developer shall follow mitigation measures set out in permits issued under the Wildlife Act
and monitor mitigation success, if muskrats are present.
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R25: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer. The
Government of Canada accepts the intent of the recommendation and will work with the Developer
and appropriate parties, as required, to ensure its implementation.
R26: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer. The
Government of Canada accepts the intent of the recommendation and will work with the Developer
and appropriate parties, as required, to ensure its implementation.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-14
No recommendations were made by the EIRB related to beavers.
13.6.7 Waterbirds and Waterfowl
Potential water quality effects were identified by the EIRB in relation to species at risk. To mitigate
residual effects to waterbirds and waterfowl, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R32: The IEMOC shall determine appropriate setback distances for… critical habitat of SAR, waterfowl
and tundra-nesting bird species.
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations (relevant to bird species) are as
follows:
R32: The Government of Canada accepts the intent of this recommendation. The Government of
Canada expects the Developer to work with parties to determine appropriate setback distances for …
nests of bird species at risk, waterfowl and other tundra-nesting bird species under the umbrella of the
follow-up program and through the development of the WEMP. The Government of Canada notes that
regulatory authorities may have the ultimate discretion to determine setbacks where they may be
included as conditions in permits or authorizations issued for the Project. The Government of Canada
would also like to clarify that critical habitat as defined in the federal Species at Risk Act has not been
identified for any of the species at risk that may occur in the area proposed for development of the
Project…The Government of Canada will work with the appropriate parties to meet the intent of this
recommendation, as required.
13.6.8 Harvesting and Traditional Land Use
To mitigate residual effects to harvesting and traditional land use, the EIRB (2013) recommended that:
R20: The Developer shall work with the Parties (DFO, EC, ENR) and comanagement bodies (FJMC,
WMAC) and HTCs to ensure that the Developer’s mitigation, monitoring and management
commitments related to wildlife, fish and harvesting are met and reported on annually through IEMOC
or through the specific comanagement bodies responsible for resource management in the ISR.
R50: The Inuvialuit Land Administration shall work with the Developer, HTCs, FJMC and WMAC
(NWT) to ensure proper signage and guidelines are established to monitor access to the Husky Lakes
area.
R51: Developer shall consult with the communities, HTC's and ISR comanagement boards on the
development and content of the Project's environmental management plans in relation to Category E
lands.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-15
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R20: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer. The
Government of Canada accepts the intent of the recommendation and modifies it such that the results
of monitoring would be met and reported on through a combination of regulatory instruments, the
follow-up program and specific co-management bodies responsible for resource management in the
Inuvialuit Settlement Region. DFO will continue to work closely with co-management bodies such as
the Fisheries Joint Management Committee and the Tuktoyaktuk to Inuvik working group to manage
fisheries resources in the Inuvialuit Settlement Region. DFO will ensure that the mitigation measures
as well as monitoring and management plans required under any potential Fisheries Act authorizations
are met through standard compliance monitoring and enforcement. Environment Canada will continue
to work closely with co-management bodies such as the Wildlife Management Advisory Council to
manage wildlife resources within their departmental mandate. The Government of Canada will work
with other appropriate parties, as required, to monitor implementation of the Developer’s commitments
related to mitigation, monitoring and management for wildlife, fish and harvesting.
R50: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Inuvialuit Land
Administration.
R51: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer and
accepts its intent.
13.7 Assessment of Residual Environmental Effects
With the application of the mitigation measures (Table 13-3), the Developer Commitments (Appendix I),
the EIRB’s recommendations (Appendix G), and the Government of Canada’s recommendations
(Appendix H) residual effects to the VCs will be prevented or mitigated.
Additional monitoring and consultation requirements not included in Developer Commitments and not
otherwise required as part of regulatory approvals are summarized in Table 13-4:
Table 13-4 Synopsis of Recommended EIRB Mitigations Additional to DeveloperCommitments
EIRB Mitigation GNWT-DOT Action Anticipated Timing
Wildlife EffectsManagement Plan(WEMP)
The GNWT-DOT will need to ensure that the relevant co-management agencies are given the opportunity to provide input onthe inclusion of specific items to be addressed in the WEMP, priorto its finalization (e.g. R21, R24, R33).
Prior to construction
Mitigation andMonitoring forMuskrat
The GNWT-DOT will need to discuss the requirements for muskratmitigation with ENR.
The GNWT-DOT will need to determine, in discussion with ENR,the specific objectives and methods for monitoring the effects ofproject activities to muskrat.
Prior to construction
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-16
Table 13-4 Synopsis of Recommended EIRB Mitigations Additional to DeveloperCommitments (cont’d)
EIRB Mitigation GNWT-DOT Action Anticipated Timing
Monitoring of effectsto water resources,vegetation, terrainand permafrost
The GNWT-DOT will need to determine, in discussion with DFOand the NWTWB, the specific objectives and methods formonitoring the effects of long-term water use on water resources.
The GNWT-DOT will need to determine, in discussion with AANDCand the NWTWB, the specific objectives and methods formonitoring the effects of project access roads on terrain, vegetationand near-surface permafrost.
Prior to construction
Evidence ofpermafroststabilization inborrow pits
The GNWT-DOT will need to develop a methodology for adequatelyproving to regulators that permafrost has been re-established in pitfloors and walls following pit reclamation.
By end of secondyear operation
13.8 Effects of Accidents and Malfunctions
The following section states the findings of the EIRB (2013, p. 145-147).
The potential exists for accidents or malfunctions to occur in association with any human activity,
including those proposed for the construction of the ITH. Environmental consequences of potential
accidents or malfunctions related to the ITH project and associated aggregate borrow and construction
camp activities would be primarily limited to those related to vehicle crashes and fuel storage,
transportation and handling system failures.
The Developer has proposed to employ a number of preventative and mitigation measures to minimize
environmental effects of malfunctions or accidents that may occur in connection with the project. Their
key strategy will be to prevent accidents and malfunctions through education, monitoring, follow-up and
enforcement. With the application and implementation of preventative and mitigation measures, the
Developer anticipates no significant fuel, chemical or other product spills are expected to occur.
These measures include:
implementation of best management and industry practices to prevent or minimize the occurrence of
accidents or malfunctions;
ensuring that all on-site contractors have industry-compliant and satisfactory Health, Safety and
Environmental (HSE) policies, programs and manuals and that they are successfully implemented
throughout the project;
ensuring that the Developer and its contractors have an environmental management plan and spill
contingency plan that will address potential accidents and malfunctions for the life of the project. In
particular, the Developer will ensure that a spill contingency plan is in place that conforms to INAC’s
(2007) Guidelines for Spill Contingency Planning. In particular, the plan will include:
descriptions of the type and amount of contaminants stored at the project location;
site map of the location;
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-17
steps to be taken to report, contain, clean-up and dispose of contaminants in the case of a spill;
a description of the training provided to employees to respond to a spill; and
an inventory of and the location of response and clean-up equipment available to implement the
spill contingency plan.
compliance with the terms and conditions of the necessary Inuvialuit Land Administration and
AANDC’s land use and quarry permits and authorizations that will be issued for the construction
project;
conformance with existing applicable GNWT and Workers Compensation Board standards;
fuel and other hydrocarbons will be stored in accordance with Canadian Council of Ministers of the
Environment (CCME’s) (2003) Environmental Code of Practice for Aboveground and Underground
Storage Tank Systems Containing Petroleum and Allied Petroleum Products, INAC’s (2011b) Northern
Land Use Guidelines: Camp and Support Facilities, and to the extent applicable, and the Canadian
Environmental Protection Act (CEPA) Storage Tank System for Petroleum Products and Allied
Petroleum Products Regulations.
all vehicles and equipment will be re-fuelled at least 100 m from water bodies following INAC’s (2011b)
Northern Land Use Guidelines: Camp and Support Facilities; and,
spills will be reported to the 24-hour Spill Report Line.
The project construction team will work closely with the ILA environmental and wildlife monitors when the
proposed ITH is being constructed.
The Developer and its contractors are expected to generate hazardous wastes. DOT is currently a
registered generator of hazardous waste and is directly responsible for the hazardous waste generated
from their operations. Further, DOT is indirectly responsible for the hazardous waste generated from
private contractors on the project. The Developer is aware that hazardous waste must be disposed of at
an approved facility, and that it is not appropriate to dispose of hazardous waste in NWT community solid
waste facilities.
To mitigate potential adverse environmental effects associated with improper hazardous waste disposal
and to further demonstrate that proper hazardous waste management planning is in place, the Developer
has committed to the development of a hazardous waste management plan (HWMP) that will encompass
all pre-construction and construction phases of the project and will apply to the Developer and all
contractors involved in receiving, transferring, and transporting hazardous waste for the Developer’s
activities on land, water, and air.
The HWMP will include, but not be limited to:
identifying hazardous waste sources, types, and approximate quantities to be produced, including
liquid, solid, dangerous goods and non-dangerous goods;
describing waste segregation methods;
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-18
describing all on-site treatment and disposal methods; and,
describing hazardous wastes that will be transported to approved receiving facilities.
Safety measures to prevent vehicle accidents on the proposed ITH have been and will continue to be
incorporated into the ITH design by the Developer. Measures to avoid or minimize accidents will include
posted speed limits and adequate signage alerting drivers to highway curves and upcoming bridges.
Bridge design will incorporate guardrails to prevent a vehicle from going off the bridge and into a
watercourse in the event of an accident.
With respect to environmental effects, a worst case would involve environmental damage to the Husky
Lakes and effects to traditional activities and harvesting as a result of a fuel supply truck crash or rollover
on the ITH, in a location nearest the Husky Lakes (e.g., km 80) and which causes a fuel spill of greater
than 10,000 L into an open watercourse that is a direct tributary to the Husky Lakes. This scenario is
discussed under section 13 of this report.
The Panel accepts the Developer’s evidence on accidents and malfunctions.
13.9 Proposed Monitoring Programs
Monitoring plans that will be implemented during the ITH project to verify the effectiveness of mitigation
measures are as follows:
Wildlife Effects Monitoring Plan (Developer Commitment, Appendix I)
Aquatic Effects Monitoring Plan (EIRB R35)
Terrain, Vegetation and Permafrost Monitoring Plan (if needed) (EIRB R37)
Compliance Monitoring Plan (Developer Commitment, Appendix I)
13.10 Cumulative Effects
No new projects have been proposed in the region since the Substituted Panel’s review. The Panel’s
analysis of the cumulative effects resulted in recommendations for ongoing monitoring. EIRB (2013,
p. 137-141) recommendations are as follows:
R46: The Developer, in collaboration with GNWT-ENR, EC and wildlife comanagement organizations,
working through the IEMOC [Independent Environmental Monitoring and Oversight Committee], shall
further develop and implement the proposed WEMP to ensure that it addresses both direct and
cumulative effects from highway construction and operations on wildlife distribution and abundance
within the regional cumulative effects study area.
R47: The results of WEMP monitoring of cumulative effects on wildlife, vegetation and land use shall
be integrated into the IEMOC’s adaptive management framework, and, to the extent possible, into any
government regional cumulative effects monitoring programs.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-19
The Government of Canada’s responses to the EIRB’s recommendations are as follows:
R46: The Government of Canada notes that this recommendation is directed at the Developer and
accepts its intent. The recommendation requires the Developer to collaborate with Government of
Northwest Territories Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Environment Canada and
wildlife co-management organizations. The Government of Canada believes that the WEMP can be
developed and implemented as part of the follow-up program in such a way that it addresses direct
effects from construction and operations on wildlife distribution and abundance and can contribute
towards broader cumulative effects monitoring within the regional cumulative effects study area. The
Government of Canada will work with the appropriate parties, as required, to ensure that the
development and implementation of the WEMP meets the intent of this recommendation.
R47: The Government of Canada accepts the intent of this recommendation. However, the
Government of Canada believes that the results of the WEMP monitoring of project-specific effects on
wildlife, vegetation and land use could be integrated into an adaptive management framework formed
under the umbrella of the follow-up program. The Government of Canada will work with the appropriate
parties, as required, to ensure the results of the project-specific WEMP are integrated into any
government regional cumulative effects monitoring programs to the extent possible.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 13: Predicted Environmental Impacts of Undertaking and Proposed Mitigation
June 2013
13-20
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 14: Environmental Management Plans
June 2013
14-1
14 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLANS
Several environmental management plans have been prepared or are being developed for the ITH
project. These plans describe management actions, mitigation measures, and equipment available to
prevent, manage, mitigate, or respond to potential issues. These plans are provided in Appendix E, and
include:
Sediment and Erosion Control Plan (Appendix E.1)
Waste Management Plan (Appendix E.2)
Explosives Management Plan (Appendix E.3)
Pit Development Plan (Appendix E.4)
Spill Response Procedure (Appendix E.5)
Spill Contingency Plan (Appendix E.6)
Safe Work Procedure – Fueling Equipment (Appendix E.7)
Safe Work Procedure – Handling Petroleum (Appendix E.8)
Emergency Response Plan (Appendix E.9)
Each plan’s current stage of development and schedule for completion is shown in Table 4-8.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 14: Environmental Management Plans
June 2013
14-2
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 15: References
June 2013
15-1
15 REFERENCES
Bond, W.A., and R.N. Erikson. 1987. Fishery data from Phillips Bay, Yukon, 1985. Can. Data Rep. Fish.
Aquat. Sci. 635: v + 39 p.
Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment (CCME). 2003. Environmental Code of Practice for
Aboveground and Underground Storage Tank Systems Containing Petroleum and Allied
Petroleum Products. Accessed from: http://www.ccme.ca/assets/pdf/pn_1326_eng.pdf
Chang-Kue, K.T.J., and Jessop, E.F. 1992. Coregonid migration studies at Kukjuktuk Creek, a coastal
drainage on the Tuktoyaktuk Peninsula, Northwest Territories. Canadian Technical Report of
Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 1811. Winnipeg: Central and Arctic Region, Dept. of Fisheries
and Oceans.
Community of Inuvik, the Wildlife Management Advisory Council (NWT) and the Joint Secretariat (ICCP).
2008. Inuvik Inuvialuit Community Conservation Plan: A Plan to Provide Guidance Regarding the
Conservation and Management of Renewable Resources and Lands within the Inuvialuit
Settlement Region in the Vicinity of Inuvik, Northwest Territories. Inuvik, Northwest Territories.
Community of Tuktoyaktuk, the Wildlife Management Advisory Council (NWT) and the Joint Secretariat
(TCCP). 2008. Tuktoyaktuk Community Conservation Plan: A Plan for the Conservation and
Management of Natural Resources and Lands within the Inuvialuit Settlement Region in the
Vicinity of Tuktoyaktuk, Northwest Territories. Tuktoyaktuk, Northwest Territories.
Craighead, L., D. Paetkau, H.V. Reynolds, E.R. Vyse, and C. Strobeck. 1995. Microsatellite analysis of
paternity and reproduction in arctic grizzly bears. Journal of Heredity 86:255-261.
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 1995. Freshwater Intake
End-of-Pipe Fish Screen Guideline. Accessed from: http://www.dfo-
mpo.gc.ca/habitat/role/141/1415/14155/pipe/index-eng.asp
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 1998. Guidelines for the Use
of Explosives In or Near Canadian Fisheries Waters. Prepared by D.G. Wright and G.E. Hopky.
Accessed from: http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/Library/232046.pdf
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 2007a. Clear Span Bridges.
. Northwest Territories Operational Statement. Version 3.0. Accessed from: http://www.dfo-
mpo.gc.ca/regions/central/habitat/os-eo/provinces-territories-territoires/nt/os-eo05-eng.htm
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 2007b. Ice Bridges and
Snow Fills: Northwest Territories Operational Statement Version 3.0. Accessed from:
http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/regions/central/habitat/os-eo/provinces-territories-territoires/nt/pdf/os-
eo10_e.pdf
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 15: References
June 2013
15-2
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 2010. DFO Protocol for
Winter Water Withdrawal from Ice-covered Waterbodies in the Northwest Territories and
Nunavut. Accessed from:
http://mvlwb.ca/Boards/WLWB/Registry/2010/W2010C0005/W2010C0005%20-
%20Land%20Use%20Permit%20Application%20-
%20DFO%20Water%20Withdrawal%20Protocol%20-%20Aug%2025_10.pdf
Department of Fisheries and Oceans/ Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO). 2011. Fish Screen Design
Criteria for Flood and Water Truck Pumps.
Environmental Impact Review Board (EIRB). January 25, 2013. Final Report of the Panel for the
Substituted Environmental Impact Review of the Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk, Town of Inuvik and
GNWT - Proposal to Construct the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway.
Government of Canada. April 5, 2013. Government of Canada Response to the Panel Report on the
Proposal to Construct the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway.
Harwood, L. 2003. Husky Lakes Ecological Assessment Progress Report (2002). Unpublished report
prepared for the Fisheries Joint Management Committee, PERD, Devon Canada Corporation and
the Tuktoyaktuk and Inuvik Hunter and Trapper Committees. 7 p.
IMG-Golder Corporation. 2009. Assessment of Fisheries Potential of the Tuktoyaktuk to Source 177 All-
Weather Road Impact Area. Prepared for GNWT Department of Transportation.
IMG-Golder Corporation. January 2012a. Fish Habitat Assessment at Select Watercourse Crossings
along the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories –
Department of Transportation. Project Number: 11-1320-0001.
IMG-Golder Corporation. September 28, 2012b. Lake Bathymetry Survey for the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk
Highway. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of Transportation.
Project Number: 11-1320-0001-12.
Imperial Oil Resources Ventures Limited Partnership, ConocoPhillips Canada (North) Limited,
ExxonMobil Canada Properties, Shell Canada Limited and Mackenzie Valley Aboriginal Pipeline
Limited (IOL et al.). 2004. Environmental Impact Statement for the Mackenzie Gas Project.
Submitted to the National Energy Board.
Inuvialuit Land Administration and Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (ILA and INAC). No Date (nd).
Inuvialuit Settlement Region Granular Resources Management Plan. Accessed from:
http://www.inuvialuitland.com/resources/ISR_GRMP.pdf
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC). 2003. Northern Land Use Guidelines – Access: Roads and
Trails. Accessed from: http://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/1100100023568
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC). April 2007. Guidelines for Spill Contingency Planning.
Prepared by Water Resources Division, Indian and Northern Affairs Canada. Yellowknife NT.
Accessed from: http://www.nwtwb.com/Downloads/Spill_Contingency_Planning_2007.pdf
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water Board
Section 15: References
June 2013
15-3
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC). 2010. Northern Land Use Guidelines: Pits and Quarries.
Volume 7
Indian and Northern Affairs Canada (INAC). 2011. Northern Land Use Guidelines: Camp and Support
Facilities. Accessed from: http://www.aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/DAM/DAM-INTER-
NWT/STAGING/texte-text/nlug6_1313789162200_eng.pdf
Joint Secretariat. March 2003. Inuvialuit Harvest Study: Data and Methods Report 1988-1997. Inuvik,
NWT. Accessed from: http://www.jointsecretariat.ca/pdf/js/IHS10yrDataMethodsReport.pdf.
Accessed December 22, 2011.
KAVIK-STANTEC. January 2012a. Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk Highway Potential Borrow Source Geotechnical
Investigations Program – Project Description Report. Submitted to the Environmental Impact
Screening Committee. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation. Project Number: 123510744.
KAVIK-STANTEC. March 12, 2012b. Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk Highway Baseline Data Acquisition Program
Terrain Evaluation. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation. Project Number: 123510689.
KAVIK-STANTEC. August 30, 2012c. Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway – Surficial Geology and Terrain
Constraints (Mapbook). Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation. Project Number: 123510689.
KAVIK-STANTEC. August 31, 2012d. Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway – Terrain and Permafrost Field
Verification Program. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation. Project Number: 123510689.
KAVIK-STANTEC. September 30, 2012e. Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk Highway Hydrotechnical Assessment of
Stream Crossings. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation c/o E. Gruben’s Transport Ltd. Project Number: 1144901635.
KAVIK-STANTEC. December 10, 2012f. Inuvik – Tuktoyaktuk Highway 2013-2014 Geotechnical
Investigations Program – Project Description Report. Submitted to the Environmental Impact
Screening Committee. Prepared for Government of the Northwest Territories – Department of
Transportation. Project Number: 1235110025.
Kokelj, S.V., B. Zajdlik, and M.S. Thompson. 2009. The Impacts of Thawing Permafrost on the Chemistry
of Lakes across the Subarctic Boreal-Tundra Transition, Mackenzie Delta Region, Canada.
Permafrost and Periglacial Processes. 20:185-199.
Kiggiak-EBA Consulting Ltd. October 2010. Spring 2010 Aquatic Field Program Results for the Inuvik to
Tuktoyaktuk Highway, Northwest Territories. Prepared for Hamlet of Tuktoyaktuk, Town of Inuvik
and the Government of the Northwest Territories. Project Number V23201098.1300.
Kiggiak-EBA. 2011. Environmental Impact Statement for Construction of the Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk
Highway, NWT. Inuvik, NT. May 2011.
Water Licence Application for Construction of Inuvik - Tuktoyaktuk HighwaySubmission to the Northwest Territories Water BoardSection 15: References
June 2013
15-4
Kiggiak-EBA Consulting Ltd. June 2013. Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Highway 2013 Bathymetric Survey –
Rev.1. Prepared for EGT Northwind Ltd. Project Number. KE1057 (E11103030-01).
Pienitz, R., Smol, J.P., and Lean, D.R.S. 1997. Physical and chemical limnology of 59 lakes located
between the southern Yukon and the Tuktoyaktuk Peninsula, Northwest Territories (Canada).
Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci. 54: 330–346.
Quinton, W.L. and Marsh, P. (1999). A conceptual framework for runoff generation in a permafrost
environment. Hydrol. Process., 13, 2563–2581.
Rampton, V.N. 1988. Surficial Geology of Tuktoyaktuk, District of Mackenzie. Geological Survey of
Canada Surficial Geology Map 1647a 1:500,000 Scale.
Rescan Environmental Services Ltd. (Rescan). 1999. Proposed Inuvik to Tuktoyaktuk Road:
Environmental/ Socioeconomic Baseline Report. Prepared for GNWT Department of
Transportation. Yellowknife, NWT.