water supply power optimization (efficiency 101)
TRANSCRIPT
Water Supply Power Optimization (Efficiency 101)
A review of energy efficiency actions from simple to complex
• Have a Policy & Shared Vision for Energy Efficiency
• Efficient Design Elements
• Tools
• Controls
• Operational procedures
• Conservation
• Measure It to Manage It
Energy Efficiency – From Simple to Complex
2 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Make a Commitment - Written policy that promotes and supports energy efficiency in design, construction and operations activities
• Create a Multi-disciplinary energy efficiency team, with high profile and ability to make changes
• Communicate - train all employees on the policy, encourage participation in programs, show how to make a difference
Shared Vision of Energy Efficiency Goals W/Team, Power Utility, Contractors, and Consultants
3 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Power providers identify energy efficiency programs as one of the least expensive ways to enhance available power supply
• Rebates are available to reduce the cost for installing efficient equipment and systems
• Peak Shaving incentives for commercial customers with ability to shut down facilities during peak electrical usage events
Energy Efficiency is good business
4 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Idaho Power 2017 Integrated Resource Plan (IRP)
Idaho Power 2017 IRP Fixed Costs
• Correctly sized pipes reduce energy needed to move water
• Pump tests and selection of best pump curve for existing conditions • Use wire to water efficiency calculations
• Adequate water tank storage provides a “battery” to support peak demands and can reduce power used for peak demand pumping
• Water system modeling and master planning to guide capital investment in the system and assure energy efficiency is a key driver
Efficient System Design
7 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Hydraulic Model
Mass Balance Energy Map
Equipment Audit
Operational Practices
Training
Tools of Water System Optimization for Energy Efficiency
8 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Tools –Hydraulic Model
9 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Tools – Hydraulic Model
10 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Looping
• Leaping
• Losing
• Loading
• Leaking
Eliminate The Five “Ls”
11 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
12 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
13 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
14 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
15 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
16 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Read and understand your power utility tariff
• Use power bill data to drive decision making and maintenance
• Do you know someone at your power utility? (They Can Help!)
• Maintain a Comprehensive Map of Variable Cost for Power and Chemicals by facility
Tools – Understand How Your System Uses Energy - Have an Energy Map of your System
17 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Tools - Energy Map
18 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500Island Woods #1Redwood CreekChamberlain #2
Roosevelt #3KirkwoodVeterans
FiskLicorice
Long MeadowSettlers 2 (2x power ASR)
FrontierWillow Lane 2
CentennialLa GrangeEdge View
Sunset WestMcMillan
Taggart 1HillcrestBali Hai
Amity27th street
ByrdTerteling
Market (2x power ASR)Beacon
Ten Mile
Energy Intensity kWh/MG
Tools - Energy Map (Chemical Cost and WQ Factors)
19 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Pressure Zone Water Source Chemical $/MG Power $/MG Total $/MG Water Quality Columbia Pleasant Valley 10 225 235 AAA Good Columbia Pioneer 10 225 235 AAA Good
Columbia Columbia WTP& River PS 10 230 240 AAA Good Columbia Ten Mile 10 240 250 Cloudy Columbia Raptor 23 300 323 AAA Good
East First Cassia #1 39 100 139 Fe/Mn East First Vista 11 130 141 AAA Good East First Taggart 2 14 130 144 AAA Good East First Taggart 1 14 130 144 AAA Good East First Cassia #2 46 140 186 Ammonia
East Main Marden WTP 29 82 111 AAA Good East Main Long Meadow 21 100 121 AAA Good East Main Warm Springs 2 26 100 126 AAA Good East Main Chamberlain #2 15 120 135 AAA Good East Main Cliffside 22 120 142 AAA Good East Main Beacon 22 150 172 Fluoride East Main 27th street 33 160 193 AAA Good East Main Chamberlain #1 67 120 187 High Fe East Main Idaho 80 210 290 Fe/Mn
TRIAGE (SORTING) FOR ENERGY EFFICIENCY PROJECTS
20 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Don’t Do Strategic
Quick Wins GEMS
Low Energy Savings High
Low
E
ffort
and/
or C
ost
Hig
h
• Identify Description (What) Location (Where) Submitted by (Who)
• Prioritize (Use Triage Matrix)
• Implement
• Persistence
Opportunity Register: Capture and Track Efficiency Ideas to Completion
21 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
1. Pump sequencing investigation to determine individual efficiencies of pumps, use the efficiencies to determine lead lag settings, and priority of sources
2. Review of all Compressor PSI setpoints to verify that they are optimized,
3. A/C and heat issues: Optimize thermostat settings and train all operations personnel on correct settings for heat and cooling
4. Meet Power Company to review upcoming projects for energy efficiency rebate potential
5. Lighting upgrades, occupancy sensors
6. Work management system: Reminders for duty operators to change valve, reservoir and pressure systems as needed (diurnally or seasonally)
7. Identify well cleaning projects, execute, define the savings and document results.
8. Evaluate kWh/MG trends and identify efficiency changes, investigate and correct
Opportunity Register – Suez Examples in 2016
22 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Perform equipment inventory/populate asset management system
• Tracking performance and planning for rebuilds and replacements (impellers, motors, VFDs)
• Groundwater well performance tracking and well maintenance to maintain productivity
• Eliminate use of valves to throttle pumps. Replacement with correctly sized equipment or variable frequency drives
Equipment
23 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Local control
• Remote control between several facilities
• System control with supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) systems
• Water System Modeling coupled with Advanced Algorithms
Control of plants, wells, pumps, valves, storage tanks and other system facilities: Use Controls to maintain optimum pressure, tank levels, etc.
24 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Bringing it all together - Algorithm that uses water model and system SCADA data to plan and predict system demand
• System demand profiles, daily and seasonally • Ability to schedule facilities on/off • Daily: 24 hour advance plan; 48 hour advance estimate.
Plan set once each day at a fixed time • Plan is revised/updated every 30 minutes Note: There will be an In-depth Aquadvanced Energy (AE) Presentation @ 4 PM Friday
System Modeling and Advanced Control Strategies
25 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Write & maintain Standard Operating Procedures & Operation and Maintenance manuals (Hard copy or attachment on MMS device)
• Distribution system routine valve maintenance programs - verify that all system valves are in correct position
• Train all team members to understand and pursue opportunities for energy efficiency – True change requires full participation and engagement of all personnel
Operational Procedures
26 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
SUMMER CONSERVATION CAMPAIGN:
Bill Insert
Conservation Guide
TV Commercials
Free Conservation Kits
Conservation and water audit programs Water savings = Power savings
27 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
Suez Energy Performance
Sunset West well – March 2016 Added Reservoir backup & optimization with Aquadvanced Energy.
29 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
1650
1700
1750
1800
1850
1900
1950
2000
2050
KW
H p
er M
G P
rodu
ced
SUNSET WEST
Hidden Valley #1 well – Shows Decline in Efficiency due to failure of a 20 year old pump
30 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
KW
H p
er M
G P
rodu
ced
HIDDEN VALLEY 1
Cole – Aquifer Storage and Recovery (ASR) Efficiency improvement after chemical well cleaning
31 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
KW
H p
er M
G P
rodu
ced
COLE WELL
1. Turn it off - 40 HP motor running 4 extra hours per day = $1,500/yr.
2. Tune it up - Reliable and calibrated measuring instruments to measure PSI, Flow, Level, etc.
3. Fix the leaks (Lost water = Lost energy)
4. Meet loads efficiently - Are you throttling pumps using a valve?
5. Question Assumptions -Just because you’ve “always done it that way”, doesn’t mean it’s the most efficient way
6. Do it Right the first time - Are you pumping water twice?
7. Make it a Habit – Sustaining change is challenging. Use SOPs and clear instructions to stay on track/avoid falling back to old ways
Seven (7) Quick Wins – Ways to talk to your team
32 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
1. Have an energy policy and educate the entire team
2. Use storage effectively & use most efficient sources of supply
3. Eliminate the Five L’s (Looping, Leaping, Losing, Loading, Leaking.
4. Redesign pumps to match conditions, Use VFDs
5. Consistent operational procedures, optimized pressures
6. Perform routine maintenance on equipment
7. Use Data to Track performance
It’s Not One Thing, It’s Everything
33 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
• Stephanie Raddatz, • Suez Idaho Operation
• Layne McWilliams • Cascade Energy
• Steve Jones • Hansen, Allen & Luce, Inc.
• Chellie Jensen • Idaho Power
Acknowledgements
34 I Water Supply Power Optimization - PNWSAWWA Conference May 2017
QUESTIONS?