|wd f bwd fhfjikjlznplzd qmr d frlh|wi khifjtw l q v! sq...
TRANSCRIPT
-
!"#$ %&
' #( *)+ ,.-/01
24345687:98@A5BDCEFBG63DH
@A5JI;LKM5NPOQOR@A34OPOS9
-
.(,
|wdflz|ei"fhdf0wkji"fji"rlzflh|wikji"fhtelzfqnplhvAqfhw|wikhd!rwitelzkjdgrwq]qMuwfhikj~pnplhdgqMrwf1khqvnW=
-
S
-*,!"
|wdfbwdfhfji"kjlznplzdqMrdfRlh|wi khi"fjtwlqv!sq=1r:qMkjGi
-
QS
.y "{ y
dgkjfjlzxM4Rqtwgbgdi,lzqylh|nrwv!nkji"rlzfJqMklh|wi"dk|wi"nprwbfjtwwqMkjl q~Miklz|winfml:inkjf"qMtwb_ngfjqgdi{lzqlh|nrwvfhteDikj~?dgfjqMk"npkh |wqMvfhqMr4(qMk|wdf|wig_nprwbMtwdbnrwi0lz|ekhqMtw|wqMtelv!|,
-
! #"%$'&)( " Mx akhdidfjlzqkjqpitelzkjdgrwqf ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
* +-,.&%! /"103254/6 (76 8
-
E "5!,.5#6 C
-
E "5!,.5#6 C$
ee WWnk1ilzilzqk ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Mee W:npgdguekznplhdgqMryilzilzqk ! ! ! ! ! ! !
e :s|?fjdg"fRa0rwn?fhif! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ew i"nv bedgfznpwDi"nkznprw"ia0rwn?fhif ! ! ! ! ! ! ew qrlzndgrei"bbai"kjlhisalhvAqfhw|wikhd!Ri"telhkhdrwq{a0rnx?fhi"f! ! ! ew Ri"telhkhdrwq{rwbwtwi"bWtwqMrWa0rnx?fhi"fc ! ! ! ! ! ! Mew 0lh|wi"k1a0rwn?fhif ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! M
c PQ2/,HRS+HTBUed%fg Bhi,7!,.(!"j ^jkwx 0~Mi"km~?dgi ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! w ilhi"lhqMkR?lhkhtwlztwkji ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Mw ilhi"lhqMk i"o|wrwqgqMMdi"f! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! e
we gnfjlhdg
-
E "5!,.5#6 C$S
w |wioailhq
-
E "5!,.5#6 C$QS
e alzvqMfhe|wi"kjdgitelzkjdgrwqA
-
E "5!,.5#6 X
e nplonntnpgdl ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =Le RivAq~pn4qpi"nv9~Mirlzf! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =e khifhigi"lzdqMr ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! =p
ew }Rnkjb
-
E "5!,.5#6 X
k UF,[fg s(s2 /ud%" n \ "6Y2/,[ (b+-,.&%! /"T6~( pprfy "'6 *j_`cex 0~Mi"km~?dgi ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ype qMtwuwioRnplzdqMf ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! yM
e
-
E "5!,.5#6 X
Qi7IDy7DDlo ]szH~}D[[ twuwgdgdtwf??kjtwf M{
-
1 '
Dj`Lr`Q7DD][email protected]`>ZDDb!D1>`D.[>]s>
-
@5! #"%$)&'( " *
rwqc"ng4edgqMrwfzMdx~?dgrw{nrWi
-
@5! #"%$)&'( " O
nMkji"ivAirl1dxlz|lz|wi] D! terwbwi"k1lz|eidgrlhi"kznplzdqMrI vAnfhfji"fe |wiqyqMrlzqsbwdgfj"twfjflz|wi{gi~Miqv]nfjfbwd:Di"kji"rwilz|npl"qMtwbuibeilzilhi"bulh|wi{i
-
@5! #"%$)&'( " c
nfnprwqlz|ei"k,qMfhfjdguwi]ieenrnLlzdgqrqMk lz|wikji"fjtwlhf,dgr_npbwbwdlhdgqMrlzqlh|wi]~pnkjdgqMtwf!rtw"inknprwbnfmlzkhqw| rFnbwbedlzdqMr_lzqqMuwfhikj~?dgre_nplzvqMfjw|wi"kjdgsrwitelzkjdgrwqi~MirlzfydgrMlz|eiJnvdgqMLnrwbei,"qMnuqMkhnplzdqMrwtwuegdgfj|wi"bkji"fhtelzf qqMuwfji"kj~pnplhdgqMrqfhqMgnkrwitelzkjdgrwqMfkjqMvlz|ei i!Z 1bwi""no|ndrnsP |wiqMuwfhikj~i"blh|npllh|wifhqMgnkrwitelzkjdgrwqBwt
-
@5! #"%$)&'( " ^
r|npelzikvqMkji!kji""irlkhifhtwxlzf0drrwitelzkjdgrwqAw|?fhdgfnkjibwdfh"tefhfhibngqrw1dxlz|:rwi"telhkhdrwqqMfj"dgnplhdgqMrWlz|wiqMkj{a0rq=~i"km~D>` dfMd~i"rdgr|nL>t]D !>DD]sy wJlz|wiekhq?"i"fjf,q1vinfjtwkhdrwlh|wiqMfj"dgnplhdgqMrnpkznvilhi"khf!twfhdrwlz|eifhigilzibbnLloni~i"rlzfdgfbwifh"kjdgui"b4$nfmlz|n7>sy |wint
-
1WZ ; >1r`>D``D.-D`/`>!s>M7 .ys7.solw`>.>B>>IZ].>7.Bs3i7 ` >t` D`o mlor`/`>! H qMtwMgnfa0bwnvAf4!eM
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 {
d u&/ #,b*UTWV i
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 v
nrnp?fhib_npl lz|wiAfznviAfjnplhdnqMfhdxlzdgqrdrlh|wi]gnukhnvi ]] npl,n:bwdfjlonprw"i khqMv lz|ei1|wikhilz|wiikhi wkhq?bwtwi"bv]ndrw,lz|wifjtwuwfjlhdlhtelzdqMrut\P P wv PJMd~i"f"Y P e X Pxt\Pzy v P { P y v Pv P |5} vP v P :Gilzdx~Mi:bwd:Di"kji"rl0qMkino|vAnfjfi"dMi"refjlonLlzilRfh|eqMtwgbsuii"vw|nfjdgfhibWlh|nplnvAqkhi"qvAwilhitwrwbwikhfjlznrwbwdrwqlh|wiqMfhdgggnLlzdqMrw|wnfhi{rwii"bwf n]tw(tnrlhtwvigb
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 k
|wikhinpgvAnfhfWi"dMi"refjlonLlzi"f:nkjilznirlzq |n~Milz|wifznpvAii"rwikh
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 [_
bwd:Gikhi"re"iqtwgbWuDi nfhqtwkhi qp7U ~?dqMnplhdgqMrGr:Mirwi"khn4lz|ei fjtwkj~?dx~np4wkhqunuwdgdlqMkrwitelzkjdgrwqfRdfMd~i"rsusi"tnplhdgqMr
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 j
i"kji
P qMfjPnrwb P fhdr1jP=1|ei"khijPdgflz|eivdx
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .*
vq
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .O
lz|eiWvi"bedgtwv.qMr_lz|wisrwitelzkjdgrwqMf,lhkzn~Mikhfjdgrwdldfbwi"fj"kjdgui"b u npr i>:Gilhd~Misqlzirlzdnplz|nLlbwiDirwbwfqMr lz|wi:"qMvqMfhdxlzdgqrnprwb bwirwfhdxl qvAnplhlhi"k"qMk]lz|wi:Dqlhi"rlzdgn1dgfMd~i"ru UD1|wi"kji_dflz|eii"khvdJ"qMrwfmlonrl nreb0dflh|wii"i"lhkhqMrbei"rwfjdl:dgrlz|eivi"bwdtwv: |wdgfMd~i"fkjdgfhiRlzqnpryi@:Di"lhd~ivAd:Gil|npfnfhdMrwdxnrldvAwnlqrslh|wiqMfhdgnplhdgqMrwfqJfhqnkrei"telhkhdgreqMf1bwtwilzqlh|wi|wdgM|yigilzkjqMrsbwi"refhdldgrlz|wifhtwrGqkqMfj"dgnLlzdgqrwfq$nplhvAqfhw|wikhdrwitelzkjdgrwqflz|ei0"qrwfhi?tei"rwi"fRq$n!vAnpljlzi"ki@:Di"lbwiDirwbwfqMr1|eilz|ei"k0lh|wi,vq
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 7c
bwifh"kjdgui"bulh|wiJ vAnplhkhdxD uwfji"kj~pnplhdgqMrefqrwi"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .^
sun
atm
e
e
3
1
2
fU.fLsQ&osoh^su
nat
m
e
e
3
1
2
ZU^s>LLOQ>hwhh^d u&/ #,i*UT*V (qMfjfhdguegi1rwi"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .8
!iw! ' ' |wiwvAnifreq ekhi"bedglhdgqMrefqMklh|wi~npgtwifqlz|wirwitelzkjdgrwqvAnfhfji"fnrebdrlz|wi1nuefhi"re"i1qnr qMuwfji"kj~pnplhdgqMrefqkjdgM|lm|nrebwi"b!rwi"telhkhdrwq0fmlonplhi"f(lh|winkjinfjfhtwvi"b,lhq0uivAnfhfjgifhf"dgkji"lfhi"nkho|ei"f0qMkvAnfhfji"fR|n~Mi,qrwyi~Mik?dgigbwibtwwi"kgdvAdxlzf"Ri"telhkhdgreqMfRlzni!nkmldr:indgrlhi"kznplzdqMrwfdr,lz|widgk;n~qMtwki"dMi"rwfmlonplhi"f?fjq nr,bwdkhi"lvAi"nfhtekhi"vi"rlqDrwitelzkjdgrwqvAnfhf1dgui,lzdgiblzqsnnpkjlzd"twgnkzn~qMtwkidgMirwfjlznplziprMirwi"khnlz|eiv]nfjfi"dMi"rwfmlonplhi"fqrwitelzkjdgrwqfrwii"b rwql{uiWqMvvAirwfhtwkhnplzi1dxlz|_lz|eibn~qMtwk{i"dMi"refjlonLlzi"f @ `Bj]s.s>.>y>lIlg! }rwdgpiWtnpkhfAreqfjdgrwgiyvAnfhf{i"dMi"refjlonLlzisnr ui:npfhfhq?"dgnplzib npfui"dgrelz|wi0bwqMvdgrnrl"qMvqMrwi"rlqJnQn~MqMteki"dMi"rwfmlonplhibwtwilzqlh|winpkhMiRvAd=
|wifjlhkhqMrwi"fjl!gdvAdxlzfqrlh|wimRv]nfjf$nkjiAquelondrwi"buwlhlhdgrwylh|wiAfj|niAqplz|ei4bwi""nfhi"lzkjtwv qlhkhdxlzdgtev 0 |wi]lq"twkjkhirl,uDifjl{gdvAdxlzfkjqMv.i
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 {
bwifhdgrwi"b lzqkhi"no| nfhirwfhdxlzdx~a l{1dgguDiWnuegilzqbwdfh"kjdgvdgrnLlzi]uili"irfhqLnpggib:|edgi"khnkho|edgnp$nrwbtnfjdxbwi"Mirwi"khnplzi!rwi"t=:i"nfhtwkjdgrwlh|wivqMvi"rlztwvqlh|wiv,twqr,wkhq?bwtwi"b{dgr!wdgqr,bwi""n (nrwb,wljlzdgrelz|ei!qMuefhi"km~Mibfhi"lzkhtev dgr:nfjdgvdgnpknWlhqlh|nplRbwqMreiqk4bwi""nWnpggq1ftwflhqAqMrwfjlhkzndrv O |eiyvAqMfmlfhirwfhdxlzdx~MiyvinfjtwkhivAirl{vAnbwi]fhqSnknf{v]npbwiynpl,lh|wisnptw1anLlRM0 !sQ"$#\"$#h E~AA +.E~A:6,/W+ +=81AA1;>=r{lz|wiRnfjiqpY lh|wiRbwi""n?fqGlh|wiN]i"elhqMrnruDi1twfji"blzq bwilhi"khvdgreiRv _ |wiN]i"elhqMrnprbwin~
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .v
i
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 .k
n|wi"dgtwvrtw"i"twf |wiqMv,uwdrwi"bsi@:Di"l0qp(lh|wi"fji!kjinlzdgqrwfdgf v ' Ri MI e:i@a
twkui"fjledglhtwkhiqplh|wifjlhkhtwlztwkjiAnprwbb
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *`_
d u&/ #,*UTOUV |ei vv o|ndrqfhqMgnk(twfjdgqMrkjinlzdqMrwfnreb,lz|wifjqMnk(rwi"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *%
"qv,uwdgrwnplzdqMrq nrwbW" |wi 0npvAdlzqrwdnrdgflz|wirn{ } v]nplhkhd]drWy_,*!fjniZ- -/. -/0 1 {v 2 yqMf 2 fhdr 2 fhdr 2 "qMf 2 31 :GilzfRbwd:Giknpgfhqe9
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *j*
lzilzkhno|wgqkhq?ilz|?girwi ' nf1dlhffhqMtekh"i q(o|wgqkhdgrei |wdf1nvAqtwrl1qo|egqMkjdgrwikji"fhtelzf1dr dgrlzikznlzdgqr:i"kRbnsqMrn~i"kznpMi |wi l a0knf0i
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *jO
"$#S9#S B EF8:+./ C*+./W+=D- ;:+/
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *gc
rq~Miv,ui"keMDyJ fhty:Di"kji"bnrn"dgbwirl0dgrW1|wdgo|nAnkjMi!rtwvuDik0q fi"kjibwifjlzkjqMi"bdro|npdgr khinplzdqMr,npfJlh|wifj|wq?o n~MikjqMvlz|ei"qrw"twfjfhdqMr,qeino|,dvAegq?bwdgrwlhtwui"khnoib{dlzf(rwi"dM|uDqtwkhf'dlh|wdgr,nMi"nklz|eibwilhi"lzqMk|wnb,ui"i"rkji"uwtedgl(u,kji"bwdfjlzkjdguwt
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *j^
qirwi"kjnfPMkhn
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *j8
)-1 s-2 cm6 10 (e0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
)-1
s-2
cm
6 1
0 (
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
68% C.L.CCSNO
68% C.L.NCSNO
68% C.L.ESSNO
68% C.L.ESSK
68% C.L.SSMBS05
68%, 95%, 99% C.L.NC
d u&/ #,*UTc.V |wi khi"fjtwlhfqpw|npfhi hqplz|ei
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 * {
2tan
)2 (e
V2
m
-1110
-1010
-910
-810
-710
-610
-510
-410
-310
-310 -210 -110 1 10
68% CL
95% CL
99.73% CL
d u&/ #, *UT^UV |wi"qMr
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *jv
)2 e
V-5
(10
2 m
5
10
15
20(a)
2tan
)2 e
V-5
(10
2 m
5
10
15
20
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
68% CL
95% CL
99.73% CL
(b)
d u&/ #,*UT8UV noxgqMuwnrwitelzkjdgrwqWqMfj"dgnplhdgqMrnrnx?fhdgftefhdgreWqrwfjqMnpkrwi"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 *jk
d u&/ #,H*UT { V ac"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 O`_
(MeV)promptE0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Eve
nts
/ 0.4
25 M
eV
0
20
40
60
80no-oscillationaccidentals
O16,n)C(13
spallationbest-fit oscillation + BGKamLAND data
d u&/ #,*UTvV uwfji"kj~i"bi"rwikhfjDilhkhtwv qpwkjqMveli khqv dgrlzikznlzdqMrwfbwilzilzib:ubJnvYa,ea0fhqfj|wq1rnkjilz|wiwkji"bwdlhi"bWfhi"lhkhtwv dgrlz|ei!npuwfhirw"iqqMfhdgnplhdgqMrwfnreblz|wiui"fmljPwllzq,nlqn~qMtwkqMfj"dgnplhdgqMrefvq?bwi"Q nirskjqMv SkznpvAilzi"kfhnp"i{ngqibu:lh|wilqsnrnx?fhi"fJnvYa00 nfhq]etwuwgdfh|wibnjqMdrlnrnx?fhdgfqJnvYa nrwbfhqMgnkrwi"t
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 O%
)2 (e
V2
m
-510
-410
2tan
-110 1 10
KamLAND95% C.L.99% C.L.
99.73% C.L.KamLAND best fit
Solar95% C.L.99% C.L.
99.73% C.L.solar best fit
qj&i.jOo!kffiYl nmonwLspowhw$!qL&Smros>slZLf`sw,mSmwL&^pmLfa&uo!kff6mhw;ksssws,mLymtlzmLsw$Q!{QLoQQwoiZa>wLO^Q|mo 2tan
0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
)2 (e
V2
m
KamLAND+Solar fluxes
95% C.L.
99% C.L.
99.73% C.L.
global best fit-5104
-5106
-5108
-4101
-4101.2
qlwi.jOo!kfftlF}mL>Lsposos$Lqo>mrofn8lZos nf'QQ&sw,mSm.tlFu~w~qvi9xwmSfsQ!{QLoQQwo6d u&/ #,*UTkUV JnvYarwitelzkjdgrwq:qMfhdgggnplzdqMr"qrebwirw"idgvdlhf"(dgMtwkji"flonpi"rkhqMvS
20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
(km/MeV)e
/E0L
Rat
io
2.6 MeV promptanalysis threshold
KamLAND databest-fit oscillationbest-fit decaybest-fit decoherence
d u&/ #,*UT][_.V nLlzdgqqlh|wiWqMuwfhikj~i"b fhi"lhkhtwv lhqlz|eii
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 Oj*
"qdgrwdgbwirw"i{qnW
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 OjO
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
0 2 4 6 8 10
MC signal
e+ energy
MeV
Eve
nts
data
/MCf&z88us6mL>osOJoQosoa|m3o&nL{Q olfjmh$wl fjLLq3wooQo&a\of'oQw6mL>lnYl}mL>wLs6mmLsO
qlSA88 ns+la>ln.$msmL6t3.wl TUQo!kff Ylzowhw$>L>mros> ooQokff$Yl7LQQ,ym$!}q>{Q&$Vn}>s,a>>t=UQUj~QImznsooImrolf o LQLyw/OF+ =U's rOTYIt!`PL!m`v:>LQa+mUtl:faos+koQ\t*nf,la&n >s&d u&/ #,H*UT]WV Kkji"fjtwlhf"wlonpi"rWkhqMv
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 Ogc
"$#`#&% 8= -'A=),+./
-
+-,.&%! /"0Q254%6 (76 Oj^
"$#`#\" " -6%E = "
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ .0/
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
1 10 102
103
104 0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
1 10 102
103
104
L/E (km/GeV)
Dat
a/P
redi
ctio
n (n
ull o
sc.)
1 324576 T38 6 V w }J =V}! == =n:9= @?AB ?5C | 3 = Y w=}I|\ | I I == z = I =&S I = tV n w=n I=J= =n = =/=} |=J= =}I} = | }/= D !E =/ I J H^ = === = I | p tV}I_} wF?HGI=T h I}nn htV t n w=b }I }|| } _ ==}I ? A B ? C I 6 } =I ,O = & = }; I O }wI} n w= J ; LK8F }; nw|} ~ } } , M ONQPSR NM N P y } M ON = N UTWV w=V I~= I} ~6 3 N UTYX R NM N \ LyZXV } ,M ON Y
J=V}! ===== } J H==} = ;~ =} # ; t[ ;~ =} [\; & =;= |`_ = #] [\9 ]w _ =}I =n I=J D ^E3 ;n | } |_ } n _} t =/}_ I n/ w! = = Z=_ `[\; } =& } n I} t 8 =} =&\_| }_ I n 9 = = =_ a] [\9 ] } |8 | } n =n I= } n =p| bSn p= t =|= = H= = n } H == t =| = &P = =} _ | }; p = & & = ) = = | = } = }& = H==}
=n _ |H IUb } , M PcR NM N P } , M ON N UT N M V ySd | = N | I } e } = H==} ! |=}_ | N UT = = &O }J|n OR NM N w= S Ip= S
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ .*f
10-3
10-2
0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95 1
sin22
m2
(eV
2 )68% C.L.90% C.L.99% C.L.
1 3245g6h 8 .i =V}LL _ = nH; = ; LK8 n | _ }|} >= j?AkB ?5CO | =} ==| n D!E
H=} bJR NM N } ,M N = N UT N M =I}O= =&=n I=J I 6 ==n| =} |= ~ == =n
=Sn! == lD^E w= I =_}nmI=H I|} =_ oqp3r3strFu NNwv N x uzy u NM v N x{ N u t9 = |R NN x $ w |} =_=HV} _ n 8 |}^b _= = P#T N M XlT x M \ ==& I} |nO=~n|n lR N w= | _ ; [\; = ] [\9 ] = \ n|N } = == = == AH I= ` _= 9 } t } = }=_ = w= ~ =} | p ! ! nH _=| n T x M w=pV !H= S ~= V R N N T N M N T x M , M XV XFtd =| =_n } | } V 3 n_ t P I} = O =| I=} =H|n N T x M P = P N T N M P } =n w} a } } | =n = } | 9 N }t N T x M P UH = P N T N M P y w } = d } N} w===V}&_ T x M w I } =n; ; eOOz
w=p_ I | } _ == =} = N I? C =S ! _ =}I =n I==T D^Er w= = = J bSnII I n I F = } |p}=n| / | = =|= t @N w= ==n| == V5 = n8 |n } ` } t H tV}I_} =9
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ .0
0
0.001
0.002
0.003
0.004
0.005
0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95 1
sin22
m2
(eV
2 )
Zenith angle analysis
L/E analysis
0.8 0.85 0.9 0.95 1.00.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0 10-3
1 3245
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ .0
} n A }I }q} _ I} _tS n +9 , } = } | n
w=N H ~ I= _ ~ |= } =N _ |n 9 (; |JYV t / = n | b
3YJ 3Y)U x3 x 3Iys=I}yn
t }==n) = }= = }q}) = I | Y ==n =8=& I S = 9 = ; K\, V !s= A R NM N X N UT N M \!y , M N XFyt w= =n f_ |O n| y , NP R NM N P N N N UT N M V 9 == S | = =} IO = ,; } t } n | , }IO} } ? A } == H ? A } == } w }qn ? A |? A _ N x x3 I6y9 3Inn w= n H ? A } | =~ ~A _ |n =9 J >
M N I6ys 3!nY
_ F7
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ 4
_== } } } | } n | =V p V }_ = _=| w= I 6 S w = I ==} |=H}}| p V t I=$_ |} _ I} tV n } V t I= =}H t V = = V n |=_ =|n w= n & _
=== =} S & nHS n} = ,P IP} V} D!Er $ | T n | }q= + n _ |n tV t N } | = } H\ I 6 }& I }}| S n |= n} _ _=8 =t`|= H=N} | | I | t n }=n| }\ | =|
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ 8
Erec GeV
even
ts/0
.2G
eV
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
0 1 2 3 4 5
345z#YztqZQQY UU\^Q aU | ^!U !"#@$ % Q \&*('Z t#)tY^*UZZ7U+ j `-, "! U.YUt/^0tZ $`1^2% t354|O#6*:7tl$Zt87:90?A@CBD
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ 6
00.2 0.4 0.6 1sin2(2)
m2
[10-
3 eV
2 ]
1
2
3
4
5
6
0.8
SK L/E 90%
K2K 68%K2K 90%K2K 99%
E!FDGIHKJCLNM0ODPRQ0SUTV$WYX Z[2\]V^+V_&`ba`c[2de]2fg/h]ji1\/hk+hlkdnm#`cZhWoV$]2Xkdp[\qo^defRhl[\/^VWodeZ]f#[deWYde^5hrts5uwvyx{z|Vhhde}0~]V$g/\}0~} Z]2kde}+Z^}}Z]kR}Vh2hlde}g\^#de][dpX[dp]de^5hs5~$ ~ $ TxAxZggVide}.[dp$\V$^#]bV_!`ba`Z^#} $ TxxZgg/Vidp}[2de$\/V$^._[2V$Wm#`ZhlWYV$]2Xkde[2\q^dpf#hl[2\^V#~[dp]XIdeqph\/deg/|ru$awvx
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ .
1 3245 6h 8 f*i!=| 8I |}) IS I= wl=&9 _p| p[5l / n|IJ YI; "R!=|+I =p6=;Sp2 Y|V | /f=}R|=$ | $5|}b|f=o=+=p 2=} =o|ol=pYS "|# l=#_$ fl. d 9I= l 8t|lVwl=p!=&8\}=n|H= l#n lJ}=n|e\Vp }}J==$J DUE
=/p }==O#}#|# 5lpl P2cHI l |pl $lOjl$nI={=p$|o/06!#o$ w| 8//=/2$2|lJn#lIn}p| lI= oe|2}l |pl $ n.nYt } lI=#ln5{tl |=lb l| oe|2}/53l&eQ|p $1#!Y R= _|l
9 =/n /Ip w" t $|#Y$ N 2l#
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ 0
)23(22sin
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
)4/c2
| (eV
322m|
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
-310MINOS Best Fit
MINOS 90% C.L.
MINOS 68% C.L.
K2K 90% C.L.
SK 90% C.L.
SK (L/E) 90% C.L.
)23(22sin
0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
)4/c2
| (eV
322m|
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
-310
1 3245|6h 8 i; |/9 I RI n $n&3I=| d 9lIYp /6l&bhYInon&$5z `}J D E3lO|o p| n#lIc RI%3$5b D 5E =OowY$ #e| }Rl| /|/b3$5 n D E ! |O #}=/e&= $5$2p/ 2}p&2 2en5b$ p ; K / nnO9 I /IY=U$ ; K }n 2 |o p| }Rl| 2e $n/ D^E
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+
ww &| njK2
! [\ p2e/$n2!2e&1l*6#/$
-
! #"$&%('*)+, #-+ /
_" {
-
UWVSXZYL[\^]`_&%('*)+\#-+ f
)4/c2
| (e
V2
m|
-110
1
10
210
LSND 90% C.L.
LSND 99% C.L.
-110
1
10
210-310 -210 -110 1
) upper limit(22sin
yMiniBooNE 90% C.L.MiniBooNE 90% C.L. sensitivityBDT analysis 90% C.L.
)(22sin-310 -210 -110 1
)4/c2
| (e
V2
m|
-210
-110
1
10
LSND 90% C.L.
LSND 99% C.L.
-210
-110
1
10
yMiniBooNE 90% C.L.
KARMEN2 90% C.L.
Bugey 90% C.L.
1:\32aX`[bVF6h 8 i $8Qp#6pee/el$e#/3 e/op5ple!6 31{l9/ d Rl ?c ; K /Y/d$/Ne#%$ne#/7%/D pe#%$%$p5l1le# Pfhgji P $$$\9!1/l#.neRl/$p/$YRp
-
UWVSXZYL[\^]`_&%('*)+\#-+
5elpl/$bpo! 2l2$lqOpY d R2lp6pepeljnd.p2rQ/"$lp3Rpp36%8$p1Rp/&$2#/&6l&"$pe!9/ d l lel$oe$#8lY22ep pe1"&j!R/1 :ls /p1/. 2LR/%e$b# pY#el$/
-
UWVSXZYL[\^]`_P0Z\^?
~2e/wl_[Yplp e5lZ!# $?c , &$$!%1 //2l R x y#A#A5 S
! IR5 S ! lY$ e2o1 /2l/& u R u
-
k m(
( f
7 F / FlGqGFeGFaGL / 6*hLJqGSGFSq / )S,GFJLld` / TddF / ^TJFd / FaWElJLd?G*6l6" O2p/"&p"8#@#I$$
L 7wtK
!31/ 52ep$3eRl/+&e/l/$e"TW5K~ epepl$1eeSQl2{" e2Ye5be$#p&{2l##$p/$&(j$eRl/$L%$pj{$ 2e/(!jo/lb e/op5/op$ 2bR8le#e6eRl/%e/rQwl! e2 ep2bY2eYe5ll$2e/$ olpe
!(// pe5el/e2p$l,W5v~ OI|lel$p!/" lp 2ep5loL%$eB%p1l3o/DW5v~ e2Ye5Yl# 5R2po /2eIe/e#5:lW5v~ e$l/$0e$ ln2e2/$N|eW5K~ O|pel$1:7%$p{3l$/16" ep
!hW5v~ eRl/e/!%RDppn56/5!2el$Qe##n#&lW58IDplO pY*&l/$ j&eeppl$ I$lwl$8^O e2o//{5/@ !ep: el2 #e##$o/l pwo $5%/$&*l#I /2&.l /&/$/olpeU!R$M5|`|pel$Yl /elne o/2"e'$l# $3"$pw'O eY0!R#vIO|lppl/Relpl $ &p$2$ I$lwl$83/pl? 0 pl#(e ep
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y
:\aX`[bV
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y
:\aX`[bV
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y
p 8 /6olep! $)w$#eeh%N` ZjT#3+6 ZjT5 8(l&2$Ie#l#&p0ee 8# #$oo$#/lpepl#p%/& /$@w$# $pw(l#!el#(ee e2!eBQe$p2$Ie11/Y2eezQp2e*Y/)e$2(!/&8l |5{p%/& 2$e!Ie 2pl#$&+8#$#e2|$/$Y/ldIp$2 2&n5l37&|pel$&y!##$2562eo/&j$2$(8+p/jl#!eW%6I p/%e$ e{p#l2e!2ebpL%$e1 %bIep{e#1/6l2Rd%l# lbI/2lepIpep*#C1#2l2l2$Iep:5"$lpo6#$#plpp$e1!be 8 p&6$#| 2$$2e%elp3$6#plpp$ 2L%R/3$+oe#3!&j5bl$5$2/l#Ie#Y$#e$2(e#/$1/IMTYy ?c"R1/3j2%/8$A?c elY $
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y
:\aX`[bV
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y
:\aX`[bVZ e.$5Q$ K%l{W5v~ !|pel$p! ee$2p2$/$216"Re5bl#e/5l/$1o/ep!e Q$#e5d/j216"Re5bl8lpe peb! e/e/ e2e5ll%olpe %!%Y$ p$/ll2*$51lpe5l2l#b8lpe e!/(lo$lp$ $
"/0 ppl/$4#A#/!%/ep$l%.l"&e#|lel$b epel% 2#/%wlee5
p#l2$ pI /
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y /
:: ?f1032254|lBC 0) C
!,W5v~ #l$6|lel$ 7|- (e2le6 .0op%&/ple8l6#e7$W5K~ lpple/|e$R22eYbl3Y2l#ee l6e21I t#DpO $$#&lY$ 8|p(1 $pneY(9 ?):ZR;:Z|lpple
+?5@ a A},l CB
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y ]\
l%/Yn2pp3|l/Ye2(1!In2e2eN/U#n" le2e O"|lpplo$ p $p%$1/$2%/l/$3o p/eRl/ 2&6W5K~ w"$1/Re#e128leo!e2$2$l/ YplplpW5v~ o$ p#e##o /2ee
:EDN &8vCk$I$)I vC1Kv32(M&RK
% e"#&b$ 2 QE$&lY$ e21p#l28Q#ep%6/Y5TQv~ O|plpp$ bpe e8$Ye.$58#8#{r%$ ( l#^|/&3l/Y#5#e##8Q/pe*6e2eppe$l"#!" e2Ye5lp22"e$(%pe$2e/$#/l/( l61%e$ #&ll/6Kljp(Y$op5l 6$l!2l16Ie 7$Y$op5l&1*D2Yel*noY2(o$Ye56! w"$5l / ppll/$/l#pebe#/oe/l/$e!bllwl_
_ #A5 Pa` EbcPa` D2l Pa` P(dcPa` Pfe 2ehg D#/1/"*p$22e51/$2e/$#eI |%l#6 l%$$i *2 j "#p#el#/$pl/$5 lp1l#Rc)e$epj/%$p
-
`VuUe{DNZVR[8\VS]Y u
!)W5K~ O|lpplIe%2eoe#be$2o/n6#$W S#p 2Q%lY#Y#M8ZnlY#p$nj$nep(!b*${p#l23 l#$&+lW5K~ #|plpp$61/p#l2*p$2ppl/$6*Y2epelp/@(pK11/&jo5e!/5le2e8lYY2eYe5l{22"e1lIo
-
k m( v
rw x y k z mL{ }|
H~ lW /= Ju vFddFSGFSG))rSSJdJFSJFaDGSGFSqaFlFJlJLd mSJJFS *PG^lFSGFS GaFlFJMlJLd PSJJJFSSJLdJFS G? G ^S"F3J Jq6GKlJLd v J0S:J6EGL 6" ddd- $8^L
@?L &w*-K
&$^=-4q6aaf8&aWoke8 .-=ap)Ta=JkaT$#-=aqcHTaKa 5a{q8-aTH $!>88c8+8+8a-^T"3aahT&a-=8=8a=TTT8>T>W1-=8e*a= ^-aa8Oaj*]-=[=a=aah^8aeq8r5TEaq=^boT&8&oc-a=ea6ro58=
-
) e{; c /o
>) Elvsaa Iq$6 s$a-hc8eO&o-=^7oh>"Ta888Uca88W$>-=]a!h-h#Ya8OMoc->=-a87Ta86bh-h"Tqa!a&8a&Vs3>ss
>$^==(O;aMq6T$a-h^=88W!5-8-s>|a8ce8(*a-=^--;H8+T+}"=-s8a-=]a8*2->&&Ta]-hTU-a^;a>a^$aoTa]5=a-8-8^;(&a-HT]a8==ae+"=a8&/--^!=#a#a8--^!c"-ke=-ea5
-
) e{; c /
TH"a888TU7.ce&8&oa8-=aa-8O. 8Ts3H"5a8W83^hae&=8&$a-s8=8o=3=O-=&ao=a-87TaU&8->!a-q^-.=8e+Ok#ac!$[-Ua!aa=ETUba
@?d V>&JB! &-#"
DN%$:'& (2 *),+.-.-0/1+-5252B2+435
>*a887k!ap 8Jqa-h=^&^Eh=eJhc=8}=8/c=(c=-+a888T8a8==8#aoTOTa- W.-aa0fa p 8p8 >}c5(=--8qTa^T&8--T
-
) e{; c /76
8:9=@?BA2CDFE9HGIKJ0LMJONPLMQRGKNSQTQRGVUXWZY9[LMJ\^]X\^LMJ0_8`TWZJ0abJ'UcLMQda>9[G%UcEeJ'GM_fWZgZ9Hh;Pi
8:h;b=@?BA2CDcE9HG>IjJSLVJ'NSLMQHG\^LMGVWZkcQHGVWZJ0Y
-
) e{; c /
5X p6Ua-oT=+EMoaUHO=aasTs.E=UTaarah6aq^WOaa}+&&Wea*a6]c=(ca=8caa8q=-=-
>!=-a87TaoTr=aa8+-aqT3o--*=prT*a-=kaoT+8>o-a&-
-
)r ; c /
8:9WC21QHYLVeJfQHXLM\^WpUXJRi
8h;bv\^QHGML>gZJ0Y[LMQ[m.=@?BA2CDF\VNSWZYRLVWogZgp9dLMQRGWZgZgoe_fWZY9dLVJ'UhT]c9hegoJ , Iiq>eJHGVQTQd`HJjmQHGKLMeJ DheGVJ*Wp\KNSgZJ'9HGMgZ]c`TWp\^WZhegZJ9[gZQHYeLMeJ*gZJ0Y[LM#QHm,LMJ\BLVGMWZki
>^)
-
)r ; c /
--&a6oT. 8r"8>##-q>a,c8ap=
-
)r ; c 7
89R;2DXN%eJ0_9[LMWpNQ[mbE9[GIjJSLMJONPLVQHGQHkXLVWZN'9[g4GMJO9HUXQRXL'i WoRRL\^WZ[Y9HgZ\bRJ0YeJ'GV9[LMJ'UwWoY#\MN0WoY
-
)r ; c
T 1$h-=e"a-=aa=a--c.ap8he"Tac=8-a+8TWc(*86O]q;>8-&=8ap
-
)r ; c 7
VA VA VAASD-lite
common
dynode
signals
PMT PMT PMT
VA controlanalogue
signal
(a) VA Front-End Boards (VFBs)
to VARC
VA VA VAASD-lite
common
dynode
signals
PMT PMT PMT
VA controlanalogue
signal
(a) VA Front-End Boards (VFBs)
to VARC
VME
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
READOUT
PROCESSOR
Sparsifier VME
Buffers
signal
control
(b) VA Readout Cards (VARCs)
digital
signal
VME
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
VMM
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
ETC
READOUT
PROCESSOR
Sparsifier VME
Buffers
signal
control
(b) VA Readout Cards (VARCs)
digital
signal
>^) $a-a^='f-=U18=-"a8=ea oa'(s2.B$U8cT>c ]
-
)r ; c
a!!LH8--aea^y a^aa8->a8*]ha6a-86TWTTpO>^8--Oaa-ae-!Oaa-aT#= $q.-yq !a--Wq*oT8c&aa-=oT6aT=a" =8--T"s.Ja8&-=&U.aa8-=3Y8=-aswUpHsa-^3cq>To^[fS$8HT:5-5-T8.a86=a8W8aT#].y.55 8cH Ta-3-5Oa-a6s.c-oTaHf-&o=8=+)yqaa-Sfo=+6]-aoa>ayv"-8cHHc=-#"Wa-5"kH3Haa8-!8!a8&H=&]p=8w6}8&-&-pW!s.a8a-=o7>=oa=op{oTHTaa-a5-a=e+8a;(O4]-aFU H+a$ae*WaoTa-W&a#-88oTHaw a5-oT6]aU >4]-=5^a-3TaT-8-a8THH
-
)r ; c
>^) >"aHaa^>qS$6 t$a-ht.55qr -8aW(W$5[&aH ^=LE(aao.=q-aT
! CT"Us- 3< O s+@""v
F^F & *5+4b+.352+! #"c@-0)4-P+.-S31/%$'&c),+4K ( 5)2+.-03/
Ua+a*=H-^TO-5 =c=a-*">o8ap*oTH+8a0("8-h=84a$^>8cHcTa.aa>Ta. @sU=-5a j$a-h 8&8=c=a- a.WE.fh>>.fE-aa;=88ar>^ --- H>8+-H@rTa3> -aT@rp8aak"=a^^Ta+(c
-
)r ; c
)8*S$6y55as(,-a8(oTae#!=o-=^7$=-8&&-aae+a @s>8a*=-a5-a=e8a&-&=* vq a=6a$5$ T6T&^5-&M h;-c28ok8"a5-6oT+aa8a5-68==a8& s$3H 88=^pTa$H>#$aHo]-a7Tj5 H--h$a sa^="T8;EaT=8ac--=a=awsHp-} so^T^"wL2-=#THTa8hRf]==^joTH-a(HH-aa"^&&-a 8 @sO=-=aW5=aap}8Tt ,o @?M^ k^7 !a t$a-a!8=-h=8sa8o38
-
)r ; c 6
=}=-&=8=8-#O8e>-$a-a =c5- apJa-aT.^=HT^3a8oaos8HTaTa&=e& 1$h"(-=-.-aqh ==aap=-5eaqws aR-5+a887-5-.8a-a8r^o!a8& a-Ha8^ahpp=aa- "}=8:(h- c8qvY"a/-aa8Oa-=68&8$a8&>>a8a^Ta8&&a=
= 6 >;. ,o @?M^ k^7 Ta8.8&-+Ta-aTp T&]h(-=88a&ac6Ta&8#a-h.hcW(
= >t kB7 h>7-+ahj -a88->=>HT)h-h&:oT8#6
= C>@? c TB7 T=8(Ta-73=!a^ #1h-hOTWc(a6ca-38=6==-OaoTTa>a[=8->8-raeqoHo-T$Tab#8ke*=8TaTa 1$a8(c8-8W"y.(&8Tp"a&8OaT^*aa 8aa--8-8#8q
-
)r ; c
F^F $ 2+ON3'Sb+-S3/ (53wK))
>16fr-8)=-=ae#a8&&-;= aa8-;E=q)(-kaac--=a8a=8-E=oa8a8&2->6fL4a^&&-OT^+2-=^a- =q5^ac--=ap>r-a($okH}^H-Hpp=a8^H-Ha 8+boT^5a-*foT&a=a8*8a-he oTf88=]pq]-^OT^^8=aa-a-o8T>a7T(--ka-!a8&-aae @s6*8&aO=8-QP&8--8E=-a8W=a^e*Ta8]86f^-ka-^T^=-&-O=-aoT8(.-a]hW88W>-=^#k> w$a-h
>6faH-=a#aoTa8h-oaTaqoa#oTHU>s8U^aa&-a8c$-"qo8^8!-8ae8!aHWpaqao-=^7"Ta5a&E-8(s-=]a8eqUw>6(aht.8-(28oke+Tq&W=e aa aa;>oapr+-80(=-=-6&RRa=^Ea
-
)r ; c
=-a=-+aa=-=a-]=O8=T" q-ap *S$6.Y8o-=-=8e88.-a-a TqRUaqaoa=Tr"H8raoT"a=ahT-8opahT=8^=r=T#}a=(-q&(==-a-HWWq[(c=a^a8 aa)-TR!-r&6=q^5HTaa=a8+--&^+aO8-$O-a8aTH#HTcO>-^a6O5HTaTaW8
>a
-
)r ; c
>^) >oa=TO^H8#$!a}&R-RaoTa8&8-Wk:lnmhoqp-^^8HT8/qa r=Hk;$$a-Waa68&8-3a=a8=T=HkrSUT`TV:T]M^_`SiVbac]
8oU5HTa-=-8*aa-"&-;=HkaaW$HT&oW8qa8&!Tr#=$=cH=8=ear5HTaHo-8rT-.> 8oT5HTa-8#88aa8#j-=aWa/-a-aaT8Oa==&a==-&8a=-&a-&^a o=TT8H- =HT=R+8 a=-h+a-=a3=---=&8vSUTUTVWT=T$#r o;5HTaT^5HTa!a=a8oa-ra 8o;=T!^-asaeUf`ecVhgce=TT!f38c-aa8=88$=8=a&"#(a-hW^aR--o(a=8 o=TTp-*-^^+8>a=e =6a->&asTaa-&aaaW$ax^Jy`zUS=TT
-
)r ; c .
. HTa $a-=8a8^{y`zqS >68>To=a88oTa88{oT8s>88a
hEW=Hk6U8R.T==0(3 6=6oa--a58W+-apqW=-)!THH-28Oa&a6oa^ha>=c/e* qaaTH8c-.5H58;=aahp*aY&=^ q=R
TqaeUen^{ec~ >68>a=-W8pq{oTH#8&+88a^;85ap*aO=q qa;*-a=>c--a-
S`TUTV:T >68>O8$aO-noT#H8.5HTa6aaa8>E8e
]C^_`SVba] >=Hk68>=8&87TaxS`TUTV:T+=TT q=;8a-a8W=--R5HTa!TE]C^_`SVba]*Wa66o>HT-aO8&H8p!O&"#8a=eq aacHTa=-=a=[a6R6a68ap+8]668>=-ah8ao;=-*UORT.=Taaeqf`eVhgce-qa=.OacH.a6Ro=+5HTa=-=aoO=Ta=c*a6R&aaeqfcecVhgce+=Hk
.j >a"5L5HTa-->6*oWUaH-85HTa-oks=a]=p#!aRU-&a-W->]=oToH=T.aoT
-
)r ; c 7
-oaT}Eh-5^ hp--8-=-8*=-**="Ta8 a8/}8hO8-8=7&=--}a-}a8-hHo5T;-8aa-aH}oT=Taa-h6a3-8a3a-aTTo5-81 @H8.=8Ro=aaoTa8b a @p=-&-.=--aa8-aaa-$#q=a.O^JyczqS+5HTasahc8==--=8"=[a8aWok8+/o
-
)r ; c .
HT^=-7Taa-H2L-a=8h#-aT>^8WH^&W=8=c5- &aasa88OHT^&-aoT]-aF*>-3>$^oHT^=8pq$=(Ta=-=^c-8=a+7T-eT6=-T-T$a-8;8-+&aaO-U^-aTa Hsaa-a8cc=a- ==8e+8*-=#=c=a-&$&a>aaaaoT^-a=ca&-)-.8=aH#^-aT=a-=-a&Thaa&^p^a#a+8aaqT^Ta8a8a O-H"T88.s6Hs6c-e&6=-&>]=aW]6a-8
\ ! 6a8=ba#=.68
o(t6>*T &W=88="k88cap*a-W^-=8T="T=s>8-8p"a8a^TO8paaWaa-*8+o^H-H$-5a&e*T>a w$a-a>aWT
-
)r ; c
F & N3-0N#55j/1+4)
>6>Ja-"*T8"q-.a=-h=(&8a--$=8}a^-aTa6--aa>&&
-
)r ; c
8:9
-
)r ; c ;
8:9IKJO9HU#N%eWZk\>WoYDTkJ'GM_fQXUXegZJ
8h;>IjJ'9RU#N%eWok\>?Y@DXekJ'GM_fQXUXegZJ4>^) >].T
-
)r ; c 6
Number of dead VA chips0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16610
89R;IKWp\BLVGMWZheXLVWoQRYcQHmUXJ'9RU.N%Wok\TaeJ0YFYeQLMGVWok\b9l`RJhqJ0J'Yq9[HRJ'U
Day0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
Mea
n nu
mbe
r of
dea
d V
A c
hips
per
day
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
8:h;K=J'9[YtYTe_hqJ0GQ[mbUXJ'9RUx4N%eWZk\j`HJ'GV\M\2Ue9l]X\j\MWoYNSJ'\^LKeH\^L
-
)r ; c
F $ #)c& vSb+.53/@-S)
8=-=ap8-h8-Ha8&^U Ha-qka-.TWTTp+-q(%R6=8-a.=6a-eTOTa85qWTU aa-W-$*T=+a+a--Waa8-=>-.8LH.a-5c8-prn]-=-wv*^#8a-=(--T8a^T"!o#qT.=aahpqT]$a|h#o$a8-hTa^=a8=8$hasa oT U>ha8-/#8ap#$a&8#-a
-
)r ; c
Number of busy VA chips0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
610
8:9IKWp\^LMGVWoheeLMWZQHY#Q[m4he\M].N%eWok\
Day0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
Mea
n nu
mbe
r of
bus
y V
A c
hips
per
day
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
8:h;2=@J'9HYyYTe_hqJ0G2Q[mhe\M]4 N%eWZk\2`HJ'GV\M\2Ue9l]X\j\MWoYNSJ'\^LKeH\^L= H8."yqS$6+T$a-a-o^a8&>6=Hfaa-6
-
)r ; c
a-a$a Oa#=-fH8"QP&--h8$8a--a&8.#Ha!aTa^aa=8a--h8&$8#)=-8a888T&R8a=$apq"$"T8ha6=e8/ha8-/U>>^-)a>8-pO8OTa/-To(a-=68pa@8=-h8"8#7&aa-$-=6)*a=&=coqsa&86#.-/-qa!arTUjh-h>88-^->a=-6=H88P&-8+a-8
>"=8&8O=#W88OrT^qa/-^$h-ha=^$&&-kaT--!a887k$5=8a-!}qa*W->a"a==8!= 65\,V ; LwD ;W 7J5h3H7}o&aa8wn7T!q>^a=a-ea88TH8heq.8-8#8!6a8-/+8@ pa-
>-=a"#-3a-ara&8#$"a-hQP&--h8#co 7T>>oHk>ak=#a-5=aeqaH^oH&=a-+Th-=^68H7]H>ar#o=ap=r--=#8*!a-/
-
)r ; c 7
--aT3-==/*$c8=8*-&o=8a6#->h-aeqa-+W8&]=HTok^a8-&3^a-ac8!88P^8---+=8aa =88FaT$(-aap-#a8.jcR=-==$a+"8-8-or^83hTq>aqR#3.
U8a6WO=TR]-h$Th=8r8P&-8*roHa==-h8qk&a-a6-aaoTca88]]aa=erq-h8r
-
)r ; c
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Section 1 TOP
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Section 1 BOTTOM
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1Section 2 TOP
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1Section 2 BOTTOM
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1Section 3 TOP
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1Section 3 BOTTOM
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1Section 4 TOP
x / m-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
y / m
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Section 4 BOTTOM
>^) 6 >HT8rQP&8--8-H=87 >aW8
-
)r ; c 7
Plank Efficiency0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
N P
lank
s
0
10
20
30
40
50
Section 1
Plank Efficiency0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
N P
lank
s
0
10
20
30
40
50
Section 2
Plank Efficiency0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
N P
lank
s
0
10
20
30
40
50
Section 3
Plank Efficiency0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
N P
lank
s
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Section 4
>^) $85aa83H8!QP&--8--Ha8-/"8 ce+a-=-h8
-
O dd
[ 7X58GvbsGK:GD D ; bs87G 9
-
!E^ )vr ; c o
)h`):XWUi:hXiX-iXWq-iMc8 ` i"! v $#&%'(i*)W:QQX ,+.-0/2134"365&78@:isw-iI Q89W \;:/i
-
&Y^ZZ }0 r Qoo*W* Q :cW:iilhq.9-: -iE)b\:-XG-QMii-qW:3:WIlhW:/7hq
-iiX=imhhXcEii -iis.`.CEKU)q I /MF -i:-h fgCQ QEiI iw-iM X:UE7A[r,c0 , \q X brd'\cr[)WU]ucMg-hWcM:i:EuifdEX4@i88Q`68:-u,MQv:-h @W
`dXiWirCiq :uKWqi-)hqh X:`r-ig$d)b\s-X]X]i:4i:-hh?)hXQ`Q uQ-`-\hyMWI X#-i:X-i @UiX:iQ:i:v-iC-X4@8 -Q`-)h-iqwCX-:: -yC8`dQi`dw Q(:y:dx Xiim:-h &:Qi b:gWX*d'|-'-i' Q'-m-Q-BioMWI 1'rhXi-i i-Q i.Bi: iwi:-i-si@"`q\)WdXWqQ$)W::B:L:d iiXfO-iMWq.u\ 8 -Qq\)iQ]+q(u]q:iXhQ/9i:-wXX'$)W:W*)WhXC-igd'\--:iWcgOr|(+ir7X"-nP^ 78(i-QX):,E\Gh\Ei$)W::*)Wq@(XEi@Gh\ yEi\)iQE-)h- +r(vZq wk0 , \
-
&Y^ZZY}0t R oo*W* iiWdg-*d::,iX-xX:U-hEixWi`ix XW:\](X-Q--$;XhQ /9W=) CxW:/t6`W:i78 -i XW:X]-\-dgX_MxEhX-(XixWhC 8dE:f0Snw8Q(isXdEhXQQX-wiQXgd-mh h-h):m-W :d'i-XQ-rdi=d-:iXhQ@]WX*d ;:u:v 1X=iC-8QWX*dQ}X.dE: :b c ) 5h#j. zz i 5h#j.y P qc$|i 5h#j. / c 7~ /.f vpV]0Q$g1 \xi)WXi)h QX8 QW=MiqdgXi*):q)WL-XWqCq-QMi-r Q(i--fd'i QXQ 0QW=Cq.BLdECQndgi:-iQ ci\)iqq:dWc.dgXvM:-@x(i0ic.1X=iirCoZ):M\)i.sMf:b}-Q h)W\d:-iQt(iwQX8 QLdE:hXisrriB`dU-:=iXih\l/S^^
-
&YYZZY}0t R oo*W*
run number18000 18200 18400 18600 18800 19000 19200 19400 19600 19800 20000
/ m
EW
cT
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
YAZxQYr8:-hQw+q()h:ig\)v {= .`cf gi}hiWuicQ.C::zjWW-BMq-&ihr :0Kf6g 9 2L)WXiixiirii-iXWqghhXui-8iQ
ii)u-)W hX s+q( /V=7
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* '&
run number18000 18200 18400 18600 18800 19000 19200 19400 19600 19800 20000
/ m
EW
cT
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
YAZxQ,r8:-hQw+q()h:ig\)v {= .`cf gihiWxui
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W*
run number18000 18200 18400 18600 18800 19000 19200 19400 19600 19800 20000
/ m
VA
Chi
pcT
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
YAZr,,88:b0+q(vZ )h:XGG\)ui, Jr)qrUq);GihiWxui
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* JI
run number18000 18200 18400 18600 18800 19000 19200 19400 19600 19800 20000
/ m
VA
Chi
pcT
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
YAZo,K&8:h-=+q(vZ; y)h:i-i\)iQC-i'MWI'i-ii8Qf\)iQ{c@0i)f v/Y\)i oCqo 78ihiWxui
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* ML
run number18000 18200 18400 18600 18800 19000 19200 19400 19600 19800 20000
/ m
EW
cT
-2
-1.5
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
YAZQI,t ::-hQx+r(u )h:XiQ\)y {tl@#
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* JW~POHQPO`~ XLYZZY
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* (i8i:C\::yX4Bi-Wi[:/iiQwi6\U-08Ey-Q-
Q=-i:wiRd;:/iifi\--i\n(i XCQMQ`dd:idB Qmxih h-iQiqi-Qs -o)\vQ-}(i*):hX+.-_Z/21Z7&QQXn\ ;:/isuZd Mh h-:Esi:XMii)Wi):MQ~POHQPOkw xy]^{z+]LS 4| }[~]^L*]pv(iX=ic:-h y)h:)h-tt-b wi.:b X)iQMxc": c `W]iXii-ii\q-:iXhQR-ii6CQYMZ):-Qsi Xsu\1W:/@lX:-c uinWwcb-i*df-Q-iIshhX)h09-WghiWi:Wzsrz8QC':W:rui9-W*)WQ.C:Whuh)-)LdhWwM8 )WWvq0m9-W-oX:-BihqhhXXr\iZ): X:` -i;:`:b )b\iX:-qr\)iQX=\/ h--iw:Xi6i6iQ-Q--i6 -ruCB--M6d-@(0WX*dQrOi*dgdEu-wXMg -Q|-ig\)iQX4rigdQXu i88|d'\c-:6Wc-i-:QQiXiQ(]|M:i):WbfO0(96j\3/ h-0):WhmMWI8 XiMWIsii88Q(iix6hXXQ4 C-Q-6-ih'iu#ixi8Q-QMi-i W XC-8idXiii8Q
hriiRRc8 c `W]+q(u X-il\)W[:2dXWqQ $):hWu :r: Q|W-s`-Zd'i +q(M-:-h @(B:-hQ ciC-Qq):usMQ`d:hiiRP{inGXWcIJ-Zd'ro:-hQ ic Xsu+q(u?):hXiQ(ZI`xiX=iC-Qi]-XmC8`dQ:/ii.Pxmiiu-)WL iWC::Qr-WirQ-WiCq -|hi-QqO:Q iyQWcMiqd'\r-`iQx6:c'_i\I`&ih- QW-cIW-Zd'i-)s:i- i--i]:b+q(+ @hy95 zzi=XriQ@^(h hE-= u\i+q(u ):hXioh h- -nC: (Xw6hXgW=) -1iZ):-:X+95 i
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* J
YAZn,qL_o+q(u iiX:Qt)W-iQX8 Qy\)ui/9\)>JnX4yPz:DuXP:P?z~
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W*
YAZn,W,o+q(u iiX:Qt)W-iQX8 Qy\)ui/9\)>JnX4yPz:DuXP:P?z~
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* A
/ nsEast-WestT-25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 250
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
YAt,,oX iX6+q(M-:-h @
/ nsEast-WestT-25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 250
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
310
9_Z
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* A
/ nsEast-WestT-4 -2 0 2 4
1
10
210
310
410
510 = 0.433 ns
YAZ
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* *&
/ mDownRMS0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.80
50
100
150
200
250
310
= 2.47 ns
YAZxQYW,X iX6yti)W b XiiX=i.g(iBii5:i- l81`:QwliQ
? 2 #m%'.h|}-)W.XsXWbh&C:-0uisnQQ-hE\dI-i|-)Wyi:fQXW\-i&9q:viXQ-ivgh :cic(i|-)W-u-XWh-ii-:idi8QsOc :-L 6q):Q(id-::WXXBM\|0X-$;XhQ:Wiii6hcM-h @(io|6-'-i-Q-qcxXX]6`dqdE$`|(i88Qm|f-)WXi-Q-w\:6-i hd'\}`ZQ-:)Wh\WQ&(i.|-)Wh'-i0n88-i'i \5hX:WQv(iQ-BXguwM:c)u-@=ihq\:O&U-WUq) $``)d- Q-Eiic Wqx +WqwMh Wg -i-nXiq RnuQQ-6[)Wq-ld'\ iqfdg-RMh iiWi\uq r)dEu- $`i-X+9i'Q\U`-isiWX-x XC-8C8`dQ-ix`diQ-8(i-Q-iwi-oo{yw-.uW:/XX)[)WU-g-XQw-iy iu*I`Msgh(i'XXc X]9W-inQQ-nm|.Xq)Wqi'`qi8cW'*u@(;-h X i-=siv(GXWW-WQ--h ivJ88 icdg'i*dW'rXu Xqd'\:'*hrQi/ c8 Xi i78(7:X*d''):qdg-):Zdi-2MWI0/2 zWWm!/&7-cM-i@v(iiW='q:i,i=[rX8i-QcMqQ`d-rW:WQu';:qqi8`d-1h0MQ`d^)-=Xqu4cW'*u@yB6`dQ-i-QicusWD u:@XXJWu
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* A }v +%\Ur$#vZ&%'.(8'={yt"c.D+
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* cI''P@*d?!@'P7co@'0P.+?$'(8'*?uv%*)>-'#8)-'M#-'?@Dd9lu.@(8'+ T@'I&%-'r
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* L*@&'q)'+'-D/c`q@'o@)-*'P@2@)@'u
'q@69c-'W/94p"7'q@69c-'O/947 /7(8'%-''?*@'-''5~'5Dq| ! 8
8|(8:@'!@'q(8'r)@'+@'t'*d *+2J!bM-.6o[)--[c.&-$-: ''@-:$PD@dn@oL:k)-' qod92)@'D?@A?*'-c'L)-~PORsOR XLYZZY
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* cW*'l'& -~PORsO`~ iWa\]L][~]^L*]pvjF-[:']&r'-3*$?-'M't%'&)q-:5@D@!/&7r'.'DqZ'u.'(80. bm-u
c@dF@F.*)-0-n'e$'7.'`c'ou''r.@'n@'lu.@
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* A
YAZl,IW,(8''*d'y[:p
-
% YYZZY}0t R oo*W* A
-
{ | }v~ x
u x { }vr _ U} du
V>0"W@ 6Yl$(V8 #l!f$)I2$(r@ "2?#c(8! ?#*!A()>$(V8 #7$(V8A"WlY)>/=!)#%y)>A?#?#.)$(V)>+>$))p! .%W!)
F'569'V$I-Jc]GI@
2 .+1:#
8'(-DPv'-~7-''u''4'-f']&~'@f-
-
%L Qk c c
-
%L Qk c c
Dif
fere
ntia
l flux
(m2
sr s
MeV
/nuc
leon
)1
Kinetic energy (MeV/nucleon)
H
He
C
Fe
105 10610410310210 107
105
106
107
108
109
104
103
102
0.1
10
1
Figure 24.1: Major components of the primary cosmic radiation (from Ref. 1).`c .IA 8 5d-M@'D*'Hu$&[email protected]*]&oc!@@@>9-
-
%L Qk c c &
`c IQ A 8'N@6''PM' )[email protected]*]& D$-'yc-E c /K8''&vc!' *@ct''(I&j '.-'r'9'c!,@@28-g$ afs, k
-
%L Qk c c -'@3*q-K$$ K$G$ K@$ fqcD-2r$&M':''@.Ds''@*q&uP'@D f-18'+r'-c!' P'@2Kc'6&= *c&uc'! KVG s$@Jr.@)-'-:'&:.7c.n!/8''@:'-9@oE-,+/*]-bM'@V
'-'P-@y'&@''@bc'!'+*@)@t' Z'sc@''.n--&-fF-'*]-D'&c'!$9'nV_8'n.@'Z*''cn'''-''/-.8-*qF8$x''&9:'Va2*9''@J>Y# ! 2J89'?5s$~@@K-'*
-
%L Qk c c I
9'@:''&@W-c--~:q@Tq?JF@-9@'
-
%L Qk c c L
-M]kG,"6G,"J(',Z%,'q2-'''+'!n*+'-%9@`*@ -'@'!o'f-M.$)N.$(PO @(#HCM.$ !)@'RQK!)+ 'q8M ! -("3!
2? S Z .v3+]UT+Z 2 vLZ8'.-''v''*
-
%L Qk c c W
^ 3 BI`_F`9 `a7b 8'VG tu-'+* *@y *'fy- -.']&3'qy'D@y'u$.-'8'u''&P)-.']&3(c
-
%L Qk c c 3m--'Ph''@+*,8'P@P-7'@DP0'7*@-F'[email protected]'?v'-.*$'-@'?@
-
%L Qk c c q
Effect of 3D vs 1
lower low energy
`c IQts l'-''-4r'q$.-'*n/o*qO@-s$V@18's-'Z''8'/'n9- ''LH''-*@'18'*''P'98b'@9'H''-*@c.'8'V@)9-gK
-
%L Qk c c qA
w8O@u8O v ]^:: S i;8mHxw |0B :XHv \/ :0Z HT [4] ^:7y B |0XeF^{] [xS/X^
8'-f*]&3M' +.''q$I&v-q$6'&-.'c''-t-q!l'&y'0-qb9'' $& kj C D En+/b.M-~8'%@.f]&c! @3'>''r*q5Z '&3.-'o''-#8''@$*-'&d&M@-F8'c@
-
%L Qk c c q
Days since 1st January 19800 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000
Mea
n C
ount
s / H
our
2600
2800
3000
3200
3400
3600
3800
4000
4200
4400
`c 2IQl& z-oq-.@.*@&$.-'9'-,9-{z: (| 8'o*.'93`9- s$}-@M+@@@':9]@'/9@ ]3
Months since January 1980180 200 220 240 260 280 300 320
Mea
n C
ount
s / H
our
3000
3200
3400
3600
3800
4000
4200
4400
`c yIA Q 29u.@3-6&2'@e9- {z: D| ?3.-D8'*0'9te9-}-@Mo@-u@'v@q9- ]3
-
%L Qk c c q s8'0]-@@0'@Mu-rY# ! *?K9- '-'@-:2J
'&
@-FF@b@'+I&t?'2@4$F.-x.?~.-D@-DF7f' ! -q5' $.-'+''*q@
-
%L Qk c c q &
/ GeV E0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
) -1
GeV
2 c
m-3
8 (
10
/
E
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
`c 4IQI T-YH-hn/o` D!@'s@3-v@7'!@3'q'.'&@M@'3''bf
-
%L Qk c c q
/ GeV E0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
) -1
GeV
2 c
m-3
8 (
10
/
E
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
`c 4IQqL T-:k!- n o ` D!@'9-3-@-Z'q'.'&@M@'3''bfM.$).$(PO' @(#HCM.$ )-*?$@->KE$g8'*?$@@oqF'-2h''-'90'DI9-'+''&'M-@''@DZ' 'en('@'$''
-
%L Qk c c q I
L>M.$)N.$(PO @(#HCM.$ !)-'F+q'7?@cM.$)N.$(PO @(#HCM.$ !) r'?-u@,-Yk?M!'F' -4Fn(U?@Dt-'D3&M''5'F''@$H!-'-$? n(
-
%L Qk c c q L
''$*'v'~M *$''&u$ W@'9- '$>y
c?'BKE-
8'2@'68-t?-*@H3&4n(rq~4'Ft?@- ! @-0-r'qo''8-2'-*@BI&:'b8*@s &'8#
-
Qk c c q
/ nsDownRMS0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
0
50
100
150
200
250310
`c Q A F-*-~8.'# !3 `3*?v''' :-DP',F-sr'-F@c-''&$@@'Pu799l:''?.2-K G8'>csZr''@'' 3@DM@'-'-:'*u''-2F-D&+9'*@)-DPv''-O8'Fu''3'6 *'6&:''u75'r'@
-'93'?#8'&r-3?u-0'D8-%')I&0'f-'M+@c' @'@I-*r7'TD &@-'7'Tq$@!&b!'IF)-'s'9IPqH@-'f-D7'**@-q$@'L ! -)G!
-
Qk c c qm
/ nsDownRMS0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
0
50
100
150
200
250
310
`c Q mQ F-*@r'.'D/ ! 3T*7@'r.-:-DaP'F-.'@F-DPF9'#'@@: ?oF'9I&.''q$?%M@D
-
Qk c c sM
/ PEstrip
Q0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
0
100
200
300
400
500310
`c CQ @?''H'-D`9@U'@'H''?0'nF-.r'--DLP8'950'.-@ ?8'9I&'.'q?M@D2 ?o3LZ3 3 2 L.:{ zy \ 1 X /: \ N 8YHH'@M3't'$@ o'k'!l'!@v-Mvf-
-
Qk c c s
WLS fibre length / m0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
/ PE
st
rip-
end
Q
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
`c dQ 8 @,^ ME>1z ! 8
F@V1F-.'-:-D{89(I&0'.)M-D $8'9I&0b'.c-D'V*'.''H'-DG$$?vEk@h'!-3''@Z'@b9- 'nqHEB'@b[M$hEL-.--@
-
Qk c c s
N Planes20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
`c kQ cH'@.-OI&3'!-y?
-
Qk c c ss
zenithcos -1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 -0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 11
10
210
310
410
`c Q s F@M$- $'-' '@'-'-M@E-s-@F!%M'')!**E"! `23G:E"$$HE%3"qEI6>)E
-
Qk c c sJ
/ Azimuth
-150 -100 -50 0 50 100 1500
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
`c Q J 67%M)"!$K)LEM"#$!"!N$#6O/+{"$'4 #6IEfOEP!QE)xN GSR*T!E1%U$!@"#NV4H!6L6>T+K{"!'W!ME1"T8"6T4 )>W!/:(X!E1')%Y+4
-
Qk c c s nGZ,%"$/+(n/o q nGZ,!#'')TFI#$!BL!E#"%Y!$'tLM>"!E4/+K{"$'0x6%'t [+( !##/x#']\] 1#+! UE%U!"e+!( "B6!%x#"!LE#E"!B6!%x#"!nG^Nen o `\"!"KT6KLf#"!f#+!:#E")dE7!E:6)'#+]m" N#N"
-
n o prq sQtvu w
x tzy|{~} isPu yKs } t}s`
..&>f.TM.Ib3YT M)E#'{E1dN!,2 G 3l5G[3 G ]NL_33!5NGB
s
-
%3_ b _cBQAELMB"9!E,"E{)lY&QG+d+'$>#+')!%"$M'd(E$*xh-Q>M)23b$'t"$67E#6>'%'>!Ehf#+#4nW'"!d6{E#' %X"!EI)!67$%E"!AE#!"!M'd( !MW!1%RxGE#6>
-
%3_ b _cBQAqE'd#"$M)!#4,/"!623b$4
EN#N""!M#$"QE$f:"P1%'EdE"E:6$!"!N"#F$!"!%E)G">"#$"$kM6"L't`'x"f !"%Y'B,MkkU!-EFdIEHX$!"t+1'EK1X!E1'tE#&]!#4-W3#=="!]!Ehf:I(j8")+'x4UWx(f#+WA$$#7!EAE]%"!+!r*8")+'E4m?"IE4d1!]%U$!'Tx#6>qEr'#"$M)6WXW4
WEEf =$W!L' 1""$!E#"g$:*#86>M)!?d?!M)l'x"[x)"NW"#4_WW$GE#6
-
%3_ b _cBQA'd%'xdt!E):(xE#6>'%'!"I%'R)WxI%Y$XE"$]>"#4
.;|!E-%#:'!6r)/$-1xk'"!!6x-!'Kx'tM)V4%'EW[x#X*"!rEV:$ELx]"$6d)! dY[xa'Efz$'E/A!t6O+!'(!#"WEXEIfE$EF!'V ET!EGfE8EF!'XW"#%'T+(X!ELESE4
m?M)''(ET!'!FE|"r):(3 67$#xx/"!$:H'PF"k$ETE%6'=$%U)j"$6d)!r Q1 ]''EFfE#6%'tE6>'!%'tfEx3N4>Wx7'$,{E6>'d%'flY&QG+d+,Ex"!d!#&IH4lYQ>iQG+d+'+3##4 8 %l 'd%'xlY&QI+d+=
-
%3_ b _cBQA"!6-' OE+_>E"*xE&=E1Ox+_#"$'%0M!E*xe#x"#N#E!iXEL"x67%'LTm?t"IE4 4L]!BY.+5+/.&"L6rE,"$6!*+A1BY.+5`+/.&0R,E16$";'-"#$'!#4WE&EET8#%!EH'"!!6 !E|'EM)XHOE+_!]!BY.+5+/.&N4[.H@!EOE+_IXEIMMeIE1E
-
3_ b
_ BQA b J !E'tOx$ 3QGMV''L ;"4WE:1OE$ 3QGM"=E>"x6E%Y!dV4RzD )'='E"j3#"eE/)?xHOx! B4=WjN'"j%:EM%4+(Q$"$%j'P>"$6OE+_E`"j%:x-%$!"!%LM)1#"76$k#)EN(-"k!EE"1!x)x$%#"8H673't,%V4H A %M"W)%Ox! LW/!F%"!3%HlYOE$ 7 #4
m?"/E4Q!3!E#(,!""##$!"!NK"!!ET"!x/:6>#"7%'E#j#"$!+(Px6>Q")!67!%E"!E"$T+{"$'+#4k.H>#"$=%'E#A#"!!H,Ej")OEx#"L":"#I)L't8A!"*%'x#A!X*d,!E' Nk"x#"1T6d4Ox+_ND!1Qx7"#$X676#+!6":)!67$%E"!AE#!"!/+ {)"!'+#4.;%'x"#$"$!R#(X)")D)]b+4lWW:EL*!E,W!M)$6r16>
-
3_ b
_ BQA b J87
Planes crossed by 0 20 40 60 80 100
Trac
k R
econ
stru
ctio
n E
ffic
ienc
y
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.91
9 ;:A">"#$!"!N#t#N(>"!!=!E 6>"[Y%')E#["!$+(XE16>f"`66#+6~")6$%E#"$LE"$/:@{)"!',N:!#4
-
3_ b
A< _ : A b Js CB ?D EFE[MWEklHGYOx! Y'+ I#:E!EWD$6%'(:M)!MB{#86d)!E,$)A7>%"! !W*#+]#")dAe(E)676#lE16X)@!EL:M"#"!"$"#4[Wx'"''(#+!"D"!"#'B#"$"!"$#)!@6
-
oXp
A< o : A p JJ
9 ;: .;6%"!K!"$!"!%tE#+TOBd'"X#"$K!#"$#4s "P%Y+1"#%"#+*$!"!%Idk"#"x`d4WE7%'!1Q!E7"$+I!3E7' )!&E"!x6>Q"k]/+{"!']tuv N#+#4iWE7%'!XE1'tW$SEEEtE1"##$!"!NT"40:"!%W"!ET'xh"%E"$=V!EE")Y4=0:"!%="!x"$"%M)"$C!E_$7"4=#T"!6wM,OQP54
-
oXp
A< o : A p J8q
.Hf#fEk":!"!|"`#"$$"#4.H%"$"$6rV[$EM!>x6)!"#6#+*E"!6r)V4MWx*'"!!6 #xNRI'6d)YO'#"
-
oXp
A< o : A p J
trueP0 2 4 6 8 10 12
/p p
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.1
0.11
0.12
p0.07 = 0.06 p
p
9 ;:/766#+6z"!'>"!!"$E6>F66#+6"''(#+EB6!%x#"!LE#E"!#+4
truep
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
/p p
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0.35
9 ;:T66#+6"#$'E#"!$!"!E6>676r:!6"=%M"''d(7+E)!67$%E"!Lx#!"!N:!#4
"W''(+E)!67$%E"!1E"$#+4WWEI676#+!6r"!6"x1"#$'E)`%M"6"!? k bRxaRO RxaR+ k I s JN4fWE66#+6 "#$'EQ"!(Bl';E#"gEWL!EW"rVK=Y6%'E,>E
-
oXp
A< o : A p JV
,~--M["NE,B6!%x#"!7x#!"!CM)'( >kE/.,10`m" !"^MbP8M b c P8M bOPx#6hYh;LYAz~KF{5>3#=l#*xP2:~C)>EX"ME Az~5~GHLY~GM4-WE*)'"$!6x#`'E%L3#">)E"j: P2+~QE"$+(Q%'EjQ!E76 N61E7P2+~4W:(P2+~7PMe$T!#";'tr!$E)!-dQ!E P2+~R"Ex-!E*EAz~5~GHLY~GM4LWx'"!!6)$#6%!A*xM"$!E#"*P2+~*!xWEAz~5~GHLY~GM@+(>x#:EIE"!+(*:P2:~"$"8;' N14
-
oXp
A< o : A p J
shwE0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20
Eff
icie
ncy
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
9 :j0E""#$!"!N#(X#"$!"$E _@4)M\3%M)"WNE$ 35~GHLY~GMI6rEI"!'#"WE#M7jdg+(4P2+~)-#+)h"'$X $"#4LWE !#"!I)"
-
oXp
A< o : A p J8
I5Wx*"!t#+)!il673't#,ix>!f!t#'i!!k&0! c 4_E4-J&WLE"86r)Qj%E!ChBDK@~{~dAdHGBD#'d%'16>+#9!!!M)!,AE#"),x/.AI0m"U!"/$Ek>)6 !%''4rmO"R)!67$%E"!&E"$;M'd( !$E1E_/.A107m"#N"[x%"$E#$K#+"#$!"!NE""]"#')d'(!67%'4
WEClHGYB{E$ X{{)EjlHGY)Az~KX{:"j"/V4"$/!#"$G"%$! #d)M!ixM"$L!#"!Y!EL"$T!#"W":"fFLd,6 !E7!"M#"8U4XWE7E#E"!R#E"(kI$6dB&"!6E!6)x76>#x#")($xE(#E"(9E]"$X$"#4=WE#86d))9E,$":#E"(7MXxI%'Ix#:DE%U!fX!E1$"$%W/6rI%T!E1!#"#4
.;iEj>#"8-!3#"V]#i!E>)j!M)A!6"x#"@!A"!"#"D "%'E+#%#$!6r)E#x#")(kE#%Y!dQ+(-x76>Q-EF$!"!%Q$EfxxN' E))E$6dB,D!EG#E"(DEL6
-
oXp
A< o : A p q
lHGYB{E$ KE:!rM)f!Ek6>V'xd|ElHGY)Az~PtE#+!rMfx"$!#"WFx#+#"7x#`P!)'#'),,6j"!xWM"$#E"(j"?!EV4|*"$EM"!E#"(
-
oXp
A< o : A p q
trueE0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
re
co E
0
123456789
10
9 ;:D#8"$#"8$"#E"(`#"$!"!x_")!67)!%x#"!Nt%%x t M"/#"$"#+[/+@{"$',N#+!#4Wxj'Ev;0b
-
oXp
A< o : A p qZ7
trueE0 2 4 6 8 10
/EE
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
E0.52 = 0.34 E
E
9 ;:}
-
n o prq sQtvu
s {&q o tvuy t sPu[} { t}s
t@tzys@{}
r !BNHC;KA}5KBBU~ 2GYH;{GHi#H1K6fXKijK6%'r#a[Kh#j#"rK"ii Ki ;6HrT%iK4vi'K HQU"idariQ% !Q"7,"&mO''(+#KHiwI5mvJ^X"''(+Ci,3+" rI;^[JFF"#K)''(+CHriQQ\%+"ErI0\_J@i\%+"/I\_0i\J^HQ4vi HQ#'r#KHUW!66"Qr/mX"4T4
0a#'r#-%'H!i,Ci%hK" ">kTK /^"!'y"!6'ri6KE%Y!"?E41!( "Hi7!''KFr i]8h$Q''AKH>%"6K"!l"!6iT.G,10L6Q!"#6QaKi0/.V,6 I*6 b _ c R
N i b aRJM c Pi 3"!8K#(i$N$%&Q#6Q'!;QQ]iCHi(K?^)$i# !*E
q,+
-
-6/. p021 A o3U f!$rD^E !*hB&F)G tIHHi t H HQ W(hY!#&FY)$'>hZ&F[#> )*>\D] H1M?!*hK#;eh&F*iM*M>Q#X&b!M*ihiDhd&U ?#J>>#*MN hM A^MMi?>_i,HGNr>*Mi?$?ic%d(h*>Q hr ,*K)*ErHQ X!hQKTQUvX>#CHriQHUNQDE^s^hGtK$a?&XG_*HyQK#MvKihK#>Mh,Hu?i/iQ]Kh?sM#irMr=$QHKi6iK#> ,$$v!C:GYw@x!MG,r@rriKhi*>Q$V$*GD
viy>#iz)*)>Qy&{!i>WM*hij&F)G ic%dY)@G >Q*Q|!m@5&;*$TKhK,3}M*KK$rC&F|KhYn@#K#G(D[vi?[)*$rQy$|KYK>KQZ$H1S$H$?}&F)GKh
-
-6/. p021 A o3U
-
-6/. p021 A o3U KH2GQHiKiL)Ki$?$|HQ X>#*$H!8MaiDWYHr r|i hKHQ!,G>#CGAKH$$bM$?f QiDvi?y)*$rMri:$)t&M*ii a w@IoDoOq1)@Je#K:&ACD
8 [Y?#DvE[
vi@s)qKiqK?U&F>#*#qiXVW*$T@:&|KiL>## M*>K?u&F[Q>CiM$D[^H[ y!K#$#>KTBG_*#YK?)&@Kiq&F$?$L>TK#
-
-6/. p021 A o3U # )*>QMK>D viMK>5G_*BMKiHB$r,#(XK$HhD viMK>5G_*B$Qe irMbUB$QA_M>K?$$A eK$HhD vi#JG_*#B!8 >iT BUB$r,#[XK$Hi#v,>CTD viiTV/#>Q i*G_!8#B&SK$Hi#virrUQ>CfarG_*'!$)vKHroD W^'$QYg_&KhJK$Hi#yKiMK>xGL*'!q>i#;! A{~ D viMK>5G_*eN=OBAL6LY~I;iiQ(!8#$_JE&$)vKH:oDgDdyHiiTK?Y>*hEYKh[ HK$K*$?[hQH1YHm@Z$rYK$Hi(KiY)$8?^KK$rQiD
vKiM#K$iiZG_*eU HK${K*$iy&YGHgoo'Dvi?IH LKKz>#MG>G_*HHQ ?Qh>CitGL*iNMKe#$$:r$M>K?$$ eK$i`&FX$)i?KH>Q
-
-6/. p021 A o3U YsL6LY~;#i$A@1Ki(hrK$ii?#>K?y>i#&^i KGw@u!Y>)>wDxvhJ>,HuiKKQ*iMUitB)h# KJ!8HihQ yi6 K]KhyH#K iZ9>h XG#>GGtH&F_H)@urK$^#HQ #Dvh:*KWH9K$r>>#>Q KAK#GtrK6QMh@iX#># )*>SG_!h*iTKr(LK)?!$?Hi]=M*GGY5>#riyolo *$rr@t& Kx#KOUi>5>#MM*>K?i *$rr@t&KG@&FMGK?iDvi{QMH_&FiEs)C>#*h?>#$,#MM*>K?ye>Ci>QUYe_^w@DWY{K#&Ki>HMM*>KHyMKH?B$h{iKUMi KxMK(r,>C#D[viNY ]iaK?5&XKi >x# ?Kb&FMG Ki?b$rib>Q$>#*$QyrUQ>C(r# I"\Q &Ki1'rKHhQ^KH:&F)G i`#Ui?>K?5>i#{>Q$>#*$Q5&F^Q>C
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: wTV/#Q>QU= ] > KKri&FMG i:!8#MKH?=$rii( y KHh]t$rirhHi_KHU&FMG i? >5#KOi>KH>#riHitK) M*iB>QQM=#MG>:G_*#HQ #Dvi?t>#*h*&F*$'&FGrar|>#MG>G_*H=i?>C]QK#[Ki?i>M=TK]Z$MHL/#3=ru^F?*?DgD`vh`>QHMGKGq>#&F*i6 KUii#CiK#Nr1MOKQhiUKi6MK>M* iyr$?@KhJi&Kh hK#>MB!W@G#CD
viZ>HizGKa9&FJ>Ci>1Kiy#i>>h :GrKiysM#M?K,>C&F)G i5>,*$zi?#>K?>hD|d&_i5$ii h#>>#riiTV/#@i|iQKii?#>K?z>HMM*>KH?6)*~>Q u>#$)A&@ iy#HQ_*KmrHiKh#HQLH Q&FMGi5*Km^K?iD
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: = 600.0Single-Ended HitReconstructed Track HitReconstructed Shower HitReconstructed Track Vertex
VZ
9b :< /85=q5>W[hGK$5MG>5G_*HQK#ii> briUX$
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: HMM*>KH KhYiT i KK#K# em@KKi#Xwb n vHi(b (m Si#:v KiYi#CH>x&Khir@$KhY > vKiZ>#hQir K?GirMY Q>C W@K,HKh?x>Q$>#*$QiDd Kh >Zhi^iW@K,HKh?brKi$r(Y ] b*Q XH?ii>KHx&2GtH&NKi9K#K?>$K?]>CHQ!8Qi@ >hhi HiKhMK>(iI5]ii?>,KiFi{#M$?*hK?@?K,KJiQ@i^iTV/#>Q^r?Khv= ] &Ki>#M>GHh-r>)#>Gm@KHi@I(i)GriQ!m@yKi >xihCJE?$$i!Kr?QY ]$*h(Brrh^X*DD^GHhy>MG>qG_*Hu(^)$#HQ #i?$(i*hMr@#HQ #>Q K5Kh`Kr?HYi`)G?>JGL*1MDYviY!KH>CU&i?$?@_M)*G#_[$$5MK>WN*i L>)G?>=G_*HDSd5HQi#K$>)G?>YG_*#HQ ([rmr)6))K8#>?Y&K?Gr&FMGK?Ki QhU&i MK>5TKi?hi#_W>hv ,Q]MG>`G_*#HQ bi?>CywqG#> )*>Qe*Km^,H5!=H Q#MG>qG_*!>WM*iiiD
vi>Cii?i#)%Qi:K$r>>QH(!M*GG?Q] (!8>H1KHhQjTKir ii*>Q$[$?*GIi#hQh!$?r_JD
vK>E>#*hS KiiHi#Qh_&iiMK>&oDr/g`G I;h#iX!8#$rQE^F*DrwoJD ' KAr@j!8&FiyiHi#Qi&(KiMK>|TKirghK$iX&(KhyQi&_
)*K8#MGa*$QCQj k >MKiX>K
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao
b%/u8 ?>!^x>#GK5rKi$ritub " m " IhQ$riJ@ib " vn IM$$riJOD Q K,r1M#K#QUiT Z&F)G # K%QiZ Ki#5riU&i]i> #DE$?*ihK,r1M#K#QiT }&FMGfMKQhEi_ #Bri=&iiK#> DCXH&F)GM a PD
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao +
/ mDown - RMSUpRMS-10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210
310
410
/ mDown - RMSUpRMS-10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210
310
410 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/|8 $#8>YTV/#>QNY ] !Qh =C(
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao 7
b%/ 8 ?85>S#iTK?9&^Kh%-#CH>tv|H@G%H
Distance From Highest End of Track To Edge of Detector / m -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-1101
10
210
310
410
510
610
710
Distance From Highest End of Track To Edge of Detector / m -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-1101
10
210
310
410
510
610
710 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8 5>& ?KH>QXv@Gi&Fhi#i|&0 >3# NMyKiy$&}q&KiQ:$hqH Q:&FMG Ki'EKHi)((hn|i!H>Ch
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao Zq
Trace
Linear extrapolation
of track back to
edge of detector
Trace
Linear extrapolation
of track back to
edge of detector
b%/ 8*1> viG_* > ?5KM,+#>Q !>.-F&F)ZJt&F)G iu#KO-;iZJMUiY&^ihK#>MNMiK)Gri6KitG_* Q n@/-;aTJqKrNrKi(iK> #DCvi KQ'>*h[GHiBKi>#GtK,ieQ'!QQKiMK>ZH#K0-QiZJvHh(G_*Q n@1-;OhTJ{K,wDFQ:&FMGwM a PD
5M(?S ,>CSQh|&0KiM*K8#MGa*$?* # K>)G?>yG_*i,1rK)*i6Qiq&Ki@hK#>MDJvi_*>Q
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao
Highest End Trace Z /m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
1
10
210
310
410
510
610
710
Highest End Trace Z /m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
1
10
210
310
410
510
610
710
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/:8*>`vK>=&hi#QiZ&5 >hQM^ Ni=$r#&}}&5i=Qx$ri( Q(&F)G i'ECHriQ)(_?i#)|i(!KH>C:&Ki Hi$?@?D
{98H{}i);:#$M?KhY#5Qh5&Ki( >Dd&h#;K$Hi#BTKU>K?T@y&F*iiKiUiJ!$^ Ki#> )*>Q >ZH:vi:K$HhD[^sH#HQ( yK)iKO$#>5iUiq#KOD-;QhE&i >Yhi#Ki Ki {98H{}hM;:=A@?/~F-%{98H{}i);:$\HG-#{;;~Qeg_K$iqH2 aa iI2g a K$iq a aJED
"K LNMy QOQP(SRUT,IV UWXC
viJ#$>K?&*KWH#HQ Y>,H!M*GGY#MM*>K?(VW**hM vK,$#*h v?Gr_>*a ZY #KO>H1KHG1'>#*h
S1M iQUiAariQ>#>i 6i>#CHrGQ'&Xi Qi(&Fi Ky X&F*$?$?@>H1KHhQ:*Km^[-^\^]__Ev1MHh(KKHi(*KWH#HQ #D
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao #
Fraction of track pulse height outside fiducial volume0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210
Fraction of track pulse height outside fiducial volume0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210 MCAtmospheric
MCAtmospheric MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/98 ;5>^>&X*>QC(Mh, Ki_Qie&5iY)>Qr1$?$MSM?Kri_r#iK)GriYKiX$?T *ih$%K,TK?U&0iT $?yx# K9K#>Q?$A@?qMGK?G#[iA~>*$Thr [iXKK,TKJar# GYw@:!XG?MrD`vh`G,H[KiL>,$r!KiT0G[Gr@@He!8_>>#*K[WEK)KKrGtB>QQMK$?$?@@M*KhNiK#> Db^s^i'QM:_MK>Wh-$rMKiHUg:K*$?iYrKhiL*>Q$v$*G?GrU&FMGKhLK&^iJ>*a@J/rz^F?*DrJ2D:vhx#GYHri:>#MG>G_*H|K&q*KWH G)Kii>i#*h S#HQ x$ryaVW*$rr@K?Gr]&FMGK?iDzvhy#V*h# >W5#$$b#> )*>Q i QK#KiHGi?G_*G $QHKiX KNHiS >WJTK>Q#CHrSMK,$H=GYw@]w[)*~>QGe#M$?*hK? viK#MGii|i>KHK/Ki[K#K?>$2!8^MK>QqGtrD^s[Kh=,)] >WXVW*iQM5MKHS`$,W_
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao 8
N Tracklike planes0 10 20 30 40 50
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210
N Tracklike planes0 10 20 30 40 50
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
210 MCAtmospheric
MCAtmospheric MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/58 +5>'*G_!}&X);:C:&Xi H$A@#D
>*aYHiKHhh:Kh^M$?6i# ?!*hBrU:^F?*DrD
b`{ lteLen}_em0bY
^s>MG>CG_*H5KAXKii>M%K$$r$MvKi[M>K?$$ MKv!8i)K$?@UKiLGYHi>$ri/#MMMrKh_#># )*>U,HhQi#K_M>QrKhK?GrKi!8#hi&XKi K,DBvi?=>QHh>Q*N#HQ MZ!G#> )*>Q]CMK,$H(??$$* KrU^F?*?DT a D'vi#6#HQ @Ki?>,$?$?@5>#CHr$CHi?>K?Z)*~>Q $?@ NiK,r^i)@e6i9i/#QEKrriS5K$HiG1:>#M>NhG_*$TK?K$Ohrx&0Kh!#)ui?rM=#)@iA~t>#*$rDXdiv yG/HM*>C1M(et!$E>,H:!8iiiDevh$M#( i?MK$>Q#G K}&FMGKh=G_*Ht#xTKirpo a K$Hi[&FMG iYH#KsrqWh?e>Q$>#*$Qt!W@+)riN Ki#vKiL iC # ?Kv,+>QYK$Hi#DW=$?MaKiMHC$\K*$iQ?BK8#K$Hi?E>,*$QZ&F,>CK$HirYKh{?yHii`GaG_*GfK*$iQ?ve>,$?$Kh's7q2nH
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao Z
(a)
LARGE
SEPARATION
OF HITS
t vuxw#{ySz/qjy|{~}Iz/'#nI )y##Oq>n"mMOY/lIv)#iO InynIlO}bnn}/#[X/')OJO))
bv/98 m73>J[@Ki>Q$!>W)*iiU K,$?#D^F*^KH(&F)G a@ D
rir$0 K,$@>*aYKi5q2(DloG ?YKK$rQ $?$v#HQ yrKhhKK#YVW*i?GQM_Ki`rqyD2gqG iIs7q(oo4N@KK$iD(Yr#hi#[[ ZGr_GHm@UiHi(Qi#M@#HQ #ii_$)s7qHiurqX$*i#=Gw@(!?*i? iHQhMK#=>*a WMKHhiZ2g|K$Hh5x$r)DvhShM?!*hK?&'s7q$*h&F MK>W_)KHih($)NHF2g:K$HiNJrr|^F?*YDT/gD6((hHGGtHyUC@HU((Kh^)$DCvi?b!>,
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao #h
/ PEmaxQ0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-210
-110
1
10
210
310
/ PEmaxQ0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-210
-110
1
10
210
310 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/z8 q>s4q2ni?M!*hK?i# i_?`&i_u$ri@L Q&FMG Ki*Kmry!K>Ch&KhN$?@D
i#Kii#CH>Z&Kiuir?$?Ki > Kit#>iQuhr KG i\ Hi]iX$?>r@gb J ?q*SMiMGh?KiXH$>QT@U&iyK>#$ >HiDvhU? &1 iK)GriQ !W@KhI|>#GtK,ix&ihKi>$r@GH$?>r@D]YKi@HiIi>h>i#`&|Kh? >UiY>,Hu!_>#m#Kj)YKAKi?vhK#MGi!W@yix>#GtK,iB&XiK#K>#$Gl{H$>QT@hivh#!$?^K)G"| DEvr>, iKM!Q# > *KH:*Km^W[Kh_#$>K?hVW*i[=ogZ "| 2loX{;;~NKi_i$?*iL>#M)Kh YHU*KmUH$?>r@&=&Khb>*a_?^ #GtrGB)G?>qG_*(I1MD
d Khy&F$$rr= ] &M KiY ] h#&irMJHSiMK>U&F)GKh$riJb " Xn -Fi#_?>#,x&FMG#KOMiEHiY ];&) MUi= ] i#K?u&^hr KhMK>U&F)Giy$hYb ^m -Q ] >OK?D a DrJEOZ_iJG_* >W[$?$GHriQMKK,'*Kmr&F)G iQ?#6h#>#D2dXi#X =!8e$r>KQ2K#S&iE*Kmr`GtK$0# [G_*#K)|Ki{&F$?$r=>*a 0= ]B -MK>eKHHBE{of1Y ]; wD&qG-Q'^F?*^DrBfEY ] DoqGm-F^F*DrfEHiY ]; m= ]; oDg`G-^F*[DrwnED
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao #\
up1/-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
up1/-2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/58 5>q^XrQ | $*hC&F$?$#GYHri# a#HQ MKi'$&}[&8i($ri? !*aKH&Y ]; $*h&FX#HQ [#GYir[r?KiE*Km^rBKGK$C(
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao #
/ mDownRMS0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
20
40
60
80
100
/ mDownRMS0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
20
40
60
80
100
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/f8*85>M?!*hK?
-
-X/.| p021vWo3: =, 54 6Fao #+
b`{ v gzeE[n7fvE0bY
viXGHir# iYCQG_*D(viiOXX&b>#*h @h?iKh#HQ 6r1MeuM*K hti#Khi#*h yr1>=>#>*rri?Kh_*>$v$?*GL&Kiy^ZK#> HiSHKi#i#KiKK?X>>#*$#i##*h* iiKi#EKhH#K$r#=riiX*>$$*GQKDqG >)M%-F>GKQM]DloJG &F?UK${K$Hi~EJ>Q QuKh>H$$r2TKh>Q?M>$r a o>#G |Hi?*GrQz&F)G Kit>Q1MYM(H ]1M_i#rQi#M@e*$r!$# Ki>#$v$D $]i%a?^9#HA,CQh(&KhJ)*KMG*$#b*QM6C#HQ YiQ1yM*yKi Qi' #Duvix*>QKHS? Ui?ri@Kiy>#CHriQ9#KO # M^*$$?@m)ECHriQ/]YKm^H1KHhQUriUKi*>$v$?*G~E_Hh&F#Ku$r,w#KiX*>Q#CHrG`&|i?iu&i? >Q>C]#HQ?#C!$iQriXKW@XGYi@KA!HKiy>#iKi?rn!!QS!,/H_$rTKirKhZ*>$}$?*GDUdHhiriFzi u!x>$M?^x^]2Ki>#GtK,iX&Kh MK>&F)G KhB$r_Qhh&Ki > KhNJ&FiNhK#>M_?BVW*i? !,vK(oDr/g`G:D
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F #7
b`{| b7 Ce b|CsYEn`'vv\E
M*GG)@Z&Xi*Km^?b?HQU5X!$!DTD
XSQTQIW7P(TvVUIWq\Xv\wP UWXS
viB#$#>K?y&8# e[KiB>H1KHhQiHi#i&8MK>L!KH>Ct>QHy!8BM*GtG?b&F$?$rB
((i#r|iIECHrGE*h vK,$>#h Ki'>H1KHG1}&8Ki'$r#iZ&8Ki >6M&F*$?$?@:>KHi3-^xE[#HQ NHi9K#K$$A@>CiS/mr>,HhiAK6#HQ #DviK?Gr&K$?$?@>KHi/mr>,Hih# ?yKi>Ci#>HQ |Gr# 5iKhK?Gr&FMGK?a#HYQhTKKi?Ym@KHi#Dvi?CGr#q!>W)*iiy&FMG*Kmri*hMrQyG_*H1M}TKyK,K?GrDvviq#GYir?QM_#$)?iQ{Ki$?$?@X>#CHriQyrmr-_^7ED
b|b) n`%U`d|EE[)7 v{FbY
rSiyKO#$#>K?iKhK$Hi#Qriiy&0Ki >]y>Ci>Qz&F >K?T@DydHihrK?6 iirKi( G$sK$Hiir}QTKi#[hY&8KivMK>1Ki( G$MKix K$HiX!,H!#&FHiS]X*SM:>Q$>#*$AK?i498@}h);:= Hi798@}hM;:=4"BA^CB8;&-F?G?$)$?@9&F6KiQi&[i KEO{iKh!$rvi#iiQv:^F?*DD >Ci>bGHiqHi>KHGQB&Khi?i#vQh5&3Ki[MK>I-i)>?!8Ka?*)$?@Ee*?iiHre!5HQt&vKiiHi#@Qh&v,Cu KS?@$?MKK$rQ\r|^F*D2oD:2>WtVW*i? irHyMK>trI>GK,iQLQK#NKiHoDgoqGD
>#i|1rijy!$@?N'&FMG Z$riQ'h iL$rNMK>_*Q]Mx>,$?>*$K KiLKKuh >Q
-
-X/.|021vW3: =, 546F #
> *
! "# $ % & ' % ( % % % ) ' % ( % % * ( * ) ' + % , % % ' - % * $ /. . , % $ % % - 0 * * 1 2 3 465 4 2 7 8 5 4 4 9 4 5 7 : ; $ * , , * ( , ' < '
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F #
Trace of highest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-110
1
10
210
310
410
Trace of highest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-110
1
10
210
310
410 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/h8 >=>4_>GKHiQb&x((|i2>Q#CHriQi?i#(Qi:!K>Ch&KhN$?@D
HiUQhh&KiMK>yT #$?&DCvi$*hq&Fi498@}h);: qH)@G$MiMG$ >Q#e&F}G#HQ #D}vh=$*iB&/KiY>*h0>,M>CiN#HQ {i#[i Kr@#CHrGii?r>#CHrGL>#*h #D:vhp>#GKhQL
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F ##
DigitTrace of highest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-110
1
10
210
DigitTrace of highest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-110
1
10
210 MCAtmospheric
MCAtmospheric MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/h8 >4_>GKHiQ{`*r@i?rM#HQ ^M?Ki=$#&}e&KiQ:$hqH Q:&FMG Ki>#CHriQUiHi#Qi:!K>Ch&KhN$?@D
i?MK$>Q#G1MB&S# ?KB&FMG i K)HML>#x#KO0-;QhE(it>Q$>#*$Q*rh# K Ki#H0o a K$Hi&FMGKi#KO-;QhED%S1M6#VW*iQ K?)&@J?KADC| oD2g`G !,*hi]i?i#Qi&i >5rr^F?*&D2f2HiL?IXA CMHI oDgoqG !,*hyiihUiWp-2o(K$Hi#$rMENtVW*i?QS (K)&@jq2u'oDqG-^X*QD2 a E5Hi's7q_PNoo4QbH#*hq$r) iM9&FKi?qKGK$NKHriy*Km^K?i(r'>H1KHYGHm@:#K#'&F*$?$?@5>#CHriQi*a rY1M\&FBh>CG#M$?*hK?5Gr@HB!NWM*hiy}>C>?5!W@t$KH2K,,$aH$XHiLMG$$H$3 _KieK$HhDdHiiTKH@Kib}GJ+)r@_#MG>bGL*0B&F*ii MKZ$#M|KiH2gBK$HhDvd_># K0i*a r'H$1v>C>?_!m@)GY#RQTSqoJ
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F #8
/ mmeanT-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
/ mmeanT-1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8 k5>uU,HS K)HMYi?MK$>Q#G&E# Kq&FMGKii?i# Qi&Ki K-@?IBADCEH# _KieH1&ii{_$ri}Ma_&FMG i{>H1KHhQiHi#_i:!KH>C(&KhN$?@D
/ mwidthT0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
/ mwidthT0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900 MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8* +5>TEY ] MKHn#Mi?MK$>Q#GS ?K2&F)GcKi^hi#FQiX&i >1-G?IXA CMHI E#HQ ( 6KhJB&XKiQ:$hqH Q:&FMG Ki>H1KHhQiHi#_i:!KH>C(&KhN$?@D
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F #VU
/ mmaxR0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500
/ mmaxR0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500 MCAtmospheric
MCAtmospheric MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8 s73>6? !*aKHh&eq2n!,*h[Ki6i?i#i9&Ki@MK>3#HQ 6KhJB&3iQ:$riqMa:&F)G i>KHihi#i(!KH>C:&Ki Hi$?@?D
/ mmaxQ0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
/ mmaxQ0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/z8 >6?M!*hK?h&_s7q2nY!,*h[i6i?i#Qh#HQ 6KhJB&3iQ:$riqMa:&F)G i>KHihi#i(!KH>C:&Ki Hi$?@?D
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F 8>=
ycos-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Cosmic Muon MC
ycos-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Atmospheric neutrino MC
ycos-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Upward Muon MC
ycos-0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Data
b%/98 k5>?M!*hK?5&H#K(K*$ is4q26_y&F*h>&>WQTS#HQ Ki9>#M)Q*h(#HuH Q&FMG Ki9>#CHriQ iHi#Qi!K>C(XQZYog6VW*i?UMK?)&@Hhir*aY '&KhJ>*a (r:^F?*7D2@Hi(^F*7D2f_#MK>K?H$A@D
b|b| 7bqn)em|EE[)`%hhCn[n)ezeE[n`%'v`Csne
vi^hCKe&Ki?2!KH>CXKH@3 h?iKh{#GYHri(1M =^*$$?@mECi-^\E@QM-hKhUK#Y?>#CHriQTKiri5*>$$*GBEHiX$?$?@mEH1KHhQD-_E(QMU-KLhNKi$r#iU&|iNMK>$Qw@iZ*>Q$}$*G~EDUvi6_#HQ yG_*@iQ!x>Ci#>HQ M*Ki@KhK?Gry&FMGK??J *H :M*KK Kim@K,HiKNr?Ki )*iMK>#9i?>C$r#=riiX*>$v$?*GHiKhi9&0Ki@MK>:i>C$QrHKh
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F 8
zcos-1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 -0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Cosmic Muon MC
zcos-1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 -0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Atmospheric Neutrino MC
zcos-1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 -0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Upward Muon MC
zcos-1 -0.8 -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 -0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
/ PE
max
Q
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
-210
-110
1
Data
b%/98 k#8> ? !*aKHx&H#KhK*$?is4q2n@_y&F*i>K?:&S>#RQZYr#HQ Ki9>#M)Q*h(#HuH Q&FMG Ki9>#CHriQ iHi#Qi!K>C(
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F 8
DistToEdge of Lowest End of Track / m 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
DistToEdge of Lowest End of Track / m 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
-310
-210
-110
1
10
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8 ,85>I#CH>X2%|G\&F`$?r#Qhj&MK>#HQ yiX$&}`&KiqQ5$ri[qGrQyM@Ki`Ki$?$?@y>H1KHhQyrm^C(&iH$A@#D
*>Q$M?`rWqF#CHrG]rQ>Cu#HQ6? #K!$?ir KhK]Hi]iT)!MG$!$_i)>!Q !rHX$riKhJ*>Q$$?*GY&y>*a`UKi i#CH>QJ&Kh$r#QhU&iNMK>5&FMG i?&Kh?iK> #D $K?(#MG>BG_*YiZ*KmtG_*#HQ #D}dYHiiTK?irti J!>$M?x^x=1Ki>#GKhQ{&/Ki >Q'&FMGi}$rQit&5i_MK>6 Ki(Q&0KiiK> ?JVW*i?Q :!,AKHjoDrrgqGDvi KQy>*hJKh$?r# iHw_ML! *h0i=>#*h^h_[?GtK$?@5GQH&i?riKiyKW)*ii\D^F?*4D2_rB_ii# ?!*hx
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F 8+
Trace of lowest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
1
10
Trace of lowest end of track / m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
1
10
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/z8 XU>5vh>#GtK,iq&Ki@MK>L&F`$?r#i9& K,1M Ki:$&}&Kh(Q$ri(Gr Ki(K#KH1KHhQ/mr!K>C(
-
-X/.| 021vW3: =, 54 6F 87
up1/
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
10
20
30
40
50
up1/
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
10
20
30
40
50
MCAtmospheric MCAtmospheric
MCUpward MCCosmic
Data
b%/8*v>=>y^hv_@_belr "| O|}mVelcPxzpd{|Ov{GeGu|Ohv^Vhm^VnFedeg^!_Gcgedeg^!_Gchm^_baVe>g{GpOcGcGelrpdy_f{@egndhvpd^|O{@exdel_Gpqelrxz{GpG_baVe5K>|}{@_bhm|OmA@9>gpd^!_b|Ohm^VelrrVpri^m|O{@rnOpdhm^VnkV{G|O^>/apOx_baVe|O^V|O?@scGhvcD
b|b` qnvdFbY
aVe5de_bpcGaVhvegvrhvcfVcGelr_Gpk{Gegry>ge_baVe^MGBWel{p}xT>|/snO{GpdV^yredeg^!_Gcwhm^_GaVe>gpd^!_b|Ohm^VelraVhvndaVegc_eg^yr]c@egme#>l_Ghmpd^V{G|O^>/aiD[d^pd{@rVeg{_GpfrVel_Geg{)Guhv^VeZhvx|O^edel^M_cGaypdVmrRe`de_bpsegrm@_bayecGayhmegvrt_bayefaVhmndayegc@_Zeg^VrkpOx_GaVeK_b{G|>/thvc=>gpGtK>|}{GegrUihj_baeg|>/akaVhv_TcGaVhvegmruKy|O^V`hm^]_baVefc@^>|O{Ghm^_bV{@^iDCdx_GaVeTaVhvndaVelc@_el^Vrp>>lV{GcV^VrVel{_baVecGe#>l_bhvpd^wp}x_baVecGaVhvegvrZ>gpO^M_b|Ohm^yhm^Vn_baVeaVhv__bayeg^hv_hmc}KRpdcGc@hmVvePxzpd{_bayeTcGayhmegvrwaVhj__GpLde_bpB_GaVeTedel^M_DeayeTcGayhmegvraVhj__GhGeY>lpd{G{@e>_begrxzpO{_G{b|wdel_bh?GueB|OmpO^Vnw_bayefcM>ghv^!_bhmv|}_Gpd{g Rmbz hmc`>lpGK>|O{GelrUihv_Gao_baVeK_GhGeBpOx_bayeKaVhmnOaVegc_eg^VrkpOx_baye_b{G|>/h>lpd{G{@e>_begrxzpd{_baVeB_G{b|wdel_bh?Guexzpd{|xGKypd^uGuprshm^yn|}_ We_eleg^k_baVeKayhmndaVelc@_el^VrpOx_baye_G{b|>/w|O^Vr_baVec@aVhmelmrKVm|O^VX Rb -eiDe#>l_bhAdel?@|_KV{@egrVh?>l_Ghmpd^pOx_bayec@aVhmelmraVhj__bh?GueVcGhv^Vn_bayerVel_Ge>l_Gpd{_bh?Guhv^VnBhv^yxzpd{)Gw|}_Ghmpd^ ED%dx_GaVegc@eZ_pf_GhGegc{>lpdhm^>lhmrVe_bp_ihv_GaVhm^pogo^Vc_GaVeg^_bayee#Oeg^!_Khvcqdel_Gpqelrm@_bayec@aVhmelmriDt^hvndV{GeDNycGayp/ic|KVmpO_p}x_bayeurVhvc@_G{Ghmyy_bhvpd^pOxcMGu|Omvegc@_Rmbz WGz }|OvVegcl>hm^`cGaVhvegvr`c@e>_bhmpO^VcT|}Wprde_bayeayhmndaVelc@_eg^Vr`pOx_baVe_b{G|>/wxzpd{ie|/ate#Oeg^!_hm^|Kc_bpKKVhm^VnXGBVpd^rVpGhm^V|}_belrr>|}_b|Kcb|GKVme=>g{Geg|}_belrW@w{Gel|qhm^ynB_baVeZ_G{b|>leOy_GpKRpdmpdngq_bcD[^hmndV{@erDNf2c@aVpric_bayecG|Gue'KVvpO_xzpd{r>|}_/|e#Oeg^!_bcEK>|OcGc@hm^Vn_baVeY^x|O^Vr_^7cGelme#>l_bhvpd^VciK_bpf_bayhmcbKRpdhm^!_wD
aVeTe~t>lhmel^>#@pOx_GaVeBdel_GpKcGayhmegvruxzpd{_b|Ondndhv^Vn>gpdc)Guh?>YGKypd^Vchmc}Gueg|OcGV{@egruVcGhv^VnBc@egme#>l_Gegr
-
X|g W: =, sF q
/ nsdet-TshieldT-800 -600 -400 -200 0 200 400
Num
ber
of E
vent
s
1
10
210
310
410
b%/ m>4Zhmc_b{@hmVy_Ghmpd^fp}x_baVecGu|Omvegc_ RmG Rb }|OvVegclqhv^wc@aVhmelmrcGeg_bhvpd^Vc|ORp/OeZ_baVeayhmndaVelc@_el^Vr`pOx_baVeZ_G{b|O/xzpd{|Kc_bpdVyhm^VnfKypd^rVpdhm^>|}_GegrcG|OVme}SaVee#Oeg^!_bchm^_baVe{@egndhvpd^We_eleg^t_GaVe_p{Gelr]vhm^Velc{pOVmr`We`Oel_Gpqelr
-
X|g W: =, sF q
/ nsdet-TshieldT-800 -600 -400 -200 0 200 400
Num
ber
of E
vent
s
1
10
210
b%/ m5>4Zhmc_b{@hmVy_Ghmpd^fp}x_baVecGu|Omvegc_ RmG Rb }|OvVegclqhv^wc@aVhmelmrcGeg_bhvpd^Vc|ORp/Oe_baVeiaVhvndaVegc_eg^VrpOxR_baVe_b{G|O/Bxzpd{edel^M_Gchv^K_baVe'^x|O^yr_^7cb|OVvegcg2aVee#Oeg^!_bchm^_baVe{@egndhvpd^We_eleg^t_GaVe_p{Gelr]vhm^Velci|O{GeqOel_bpsegrD
-
X|g W: =, sF q#
^x|O^Vr_^7e#Oeg^!_bcljaVe_G{b|OleO_bpOWpdvpdnO|O^yr_bhmhm^yn]ly_bcF|O{@e>|O/}egrp@ime|wshm^yn|cb|}uVvewpOx a ron2fr>|}_/|oedel^M_Gcg x_Geg{_GaVexde_bpc@aVhmelmrly_bc/g@f2`pOx_GaVegc@ee#Oeg^!_bcF{Gelw|}hm^]c@hm^Vn_GaVez:d)Re|} |O^>|OjscGhmcRegc_(y_]V|O{b|Oel_Geg{@c1-f O2q}M
e Y |}^VrcGhv^ 2O Ld } EF_baye|}_bpdc@VaVeg{@hm]^Vegy_G{Ghv^VpeqReg_/|}_Ghmpd^xz{@pd ]pd^!_be&|}{GmphmcNOnqle#Oeg^!_bcl|OMhm^ynw_baVhvcThv^M_Gp|OlgpdV^!_gD_baVeBp/Oeg{G|Omelghveg^Vohmc|OvgVm|}_belrt_bpwWeX@yoy2O m|O{GnOeg{cb|OVmeupOxc@egmell_Gegre#Oeg^!_bcX|OcKpdq_/|Ohv^Vegr!VcGhv^Vn|Ove#del^!_bc_iaVhv/a>|OcGc@egr_bayegpO^M_b|Ohm^yegraVhmnOaVegc_eg^VrV{@ec@egvegl_Ghmpd^ly_bcl aVhvccb|OVmetgpd^!_/|}hm^Velrdf2qrV|}_/|e#Oeg^!_bcliaVhv/a el{Ge]{GegryVgelrrVpri^_bpNddNne#Oeg^!_bc!_baye(de_bpc@aVhmelmrgy_g]cGhv^Vn_GaVeh])Re|O |O^>|}vscGhvcuRegc_ZV_u>|O{G|Oue_bel{Gcu_GaVe]|}_bpdcGyaVeg{@hm`^Vegy_G{Ghv^VpeOyReg_/|}_Ghmpd^xz{Gpd ]pO^M_Ge|O{@mpfhmcNdNdNyje#Oeg^!_bcle|OMhm^Vnf_GaVhmchv^!_bpF|OlgpdV^!_gV_baVeprdel{b|Ovellhmeg^ylhvc|OvgVm|}_belr_bpFRenq2oyj
glhmrVel^!_/|OgpOhm^VlhmrVel^VgepOxc@aVhmelmr]|Ol_Gh?shv_ndel^Veg{G|}_belro!`^>|}_by{b|O{G|OrVhmpd|Ol_Gh?shv_wpd{^ypdhmc@eihmv{GelcGVj_hm^|c@w|Ovxz{b|O_bhmpO^pOxZcGhmnO^>|OPe#del^!_bcReghm^ynOel_bpsegrDaVhvcwmpOcGcwp}xcGhvnd^>|Ob|Oce|Oc@V{Gelr!tgpdKyhm^Vhv^Vn|cG|OuymeBp}x{ |}_GupOcGVaVel{Ghvf e#del^!_bcqihv_GacGaVhvegmrtaVhv_Gces_G{b|O_begrxz{@pd_GaVeKV{@e_b{Ghvndndel{'ihv^VrVprp}xe#del^!_bchm^t_GaVeKr>|_/|yqaVefprOeg{b|}mvpdcGcpOxcGhvnd^>|O|Ocg|OmlV|_begr_GpFWe'2q2oyv O
b|b| b7 Ce I|EE[)`%g `%WU`'vv\E
cGVu|O{@wpOx_GaVegpd^!_b|Ohm^VelraVhmndayegc@_Pel^Vr]c@egvegl_Ghmpd^hvcndh?Oeg^`hm^|}Vme4y2q
TTIV X IW OB IWF IW pWvWX Tv
aVecGelmell_bhvpd^VcKryegcGl{GhvWelr|ORprde|O{@eWel{@xzpd{@uelrxzpd{f|Ov{ |O^Vrr>|_/|oe#Oeg^!_bcl x_Geg{K_bayecGelmell_bhvpd^hv_hmcWpOcGcGhvVme_Gpc@ege(iayel_bayeg{|}^e#Oeg^!_a>|}cu>|}cGcGelreghj_baVel{uy{b|O^V/aDpd{WpO_GapO{hm^yrVegelr`^yeghv_GaVeg{lQZVeZ_bpK_GaVe^>|}_GV{Gep}x6_GaVegm|OcGc@h?>g|}_bhvpd^Vc_GaVepd^VjwprOeg{Gm|O5iaVhm/apsglV{GchvcRel_egeg^_baVex|O^VrB\^]ocb|OVvegcgvaVe{GelcGVj_bc|O{GecGVu|O{GhvcGegrhv^|OVveqNiWelmprvaVeeqReg_begrF^MVKReg{pOxRg edel^M_Gchm^_GaVecG|Ouymegc6hvxX|O^Vr pdc@ghmv|}_GeCihv_ba_baVe{])Re|O|}^>|Ovsc@hmcRegc@_'V_P>|O{G|Oel_bel{Gc!-/fu d2q}s
e Y |O^Vr`cGhv^ 2O Ld} EhvcxzpdV^yr]_bpuWeByoyjKx -zpd^VvEe#Oeg^!_bclyj^oywx^] -zpd^VjEedeg^!_Gcgyroqve#del^!_bciaVhv/a]>|}cGcPWpO_Ga`_GaVex|O^Vr]x^]ly_bclWqroyj!^]e#Oeg^!_bc|}^Vr`yONoqU_^7e#Oeg^!_bclh?shm^ynF|f_GpO_/|}>|O/Mnd{@pdV^Vr]pOx 2s2oyNfe#Oeg^!_bcl
_bpdcGVayeg{Ghv^Vegq_b{Ghv^Vphm^!_bel{b|O_bhmpO^Vci|O{GeeOqWell_belrt_bpFpsglV{iV^VhvxzpO{Gvhm^_bhvueZ|O^Vr`V^VhA
-
X|gW: =, sF qX
* %
%
% %
! # $ % % ' % ( % % % ) ' % ( % % * ( % )
' + % , % % ' , % 1 $ % , % ' ' ' - % * $ G. . , % $ % % - 0 * * 1 2 3 465 4 2 7 8 5 4 4 9 4 5 7 : ; $ * , , '
-
X|g W: =, sF qXU
|Oc@cGhA>|}_Ghmpd^ |_/| ]pO^M_Ge'|O{GvpqRegl_b|}_bhvpd^D-^VpFpdc@ghmv|}_Ghmpd^ycEpdcGhm ]m|O{Gr ely_b{@pd^Vc V T y
J} y2odN B@yo 2yN 2dsroNy y yNoy2-pd^yvE yo dN qvoy yroyj -pd^yvE 2O Nqdo V q2oy y
2f dNyo y qvoy doy2
2qjoy n2qo y qNroy y
p}_/|O 2ff ddNrod NygVonq2 2@qNroNy 2qroyN yNoy2
` v5>qVw|}{@fpOxxSOeg^!_qegveg_bhmpO^CI }|OvVegc^Vpd{Gu|OvhmcGelr_GpBV^ypdcGlhmmm|}_belreqRegl_b|}_bhvpd^VcZxzpd{Tr>|}_/|eOqWpdc@V{GeB2q2}NM_Gs{laVeMVp}_begrkV^ygeg{_/|Ohv^!_bhmelcZhm^o_GaVeF|}_nupOcGVaVel{Ghv^Vegy_G{Ghv^Vp|O^VrVm|}{GrtBVpd^(]pd^!_be'|O{@mpfeOyReg_/|}_Ghmpd^yc|}{GerVVe_bpK_GaVed ^Vpd{@w|}mhmcG|}_bhvpd^V^Vleg{_/|Ohv^M_OUaVeMVpO_GegrV^ygeg{_/|Ohv^!_bhmelcBhv^_bayegpdc@uhvuBVpd^]pd^!_be|O{GvpTeqReg_/|}_Ghmpd^Vc|O{GerVVe_Gp_bayec@_b|}_bhvc@_bhv|OMel{G{GpO{gpOKVhm^yegrKhv^M>|OrV{G|}_by{Geihv_Gat|! ^Vpd{Gu|Ovhmcb|_bhmpO^wV^Vleg{_/|Ohv^M_O r>|}cGathv^VrVhv|}_Gegc^VpZ]pd^!_beh|O{@mpFe#Oeg^!_bc>|Oc@cGegr`_baVely_bc|}__bayhmcc@_b|Onde}
xzpd{@ujw_bay{GpdVnOaVpdy__baVerVel_Geg_bpd{l'ayeBrVhvc@_b{@hmVq_bhmpO^`p}x{Gelgpd^Vc_b{@Vl_Gegr^Vely_b{@hm^Vpuhm^!_bel{b|O_bhmpO^Rpdhm^!_bchm^t_GaVe "!`Vm|O^VexzpO{TcGelmell_belrr>|}_b|we#Oeg^!_bchmccGaVpri^hv^hmnOV{Ge'yNdNy`aVhvcTc@aVpric^VpgpO^Vgel^M_G{b|}_Ghmpd^ycpOxedel^M_Gchv^>|O{_bhmlV|}{{GelndhmpO^VcpOx6_baVeryel_bell_Gpd{gqhvuhv|O{@vK_GaVerVhmc_b{@hmVy_Ghmpd^pOxXhv^M_Geg{G|Ol_Ghmpd^WpOhm^!_bc|Ompd^yn_baye^|qhmcc@aVpri^Fhm^KhmndV{@e qNOcGaVpric^VpTV^VeqReg_begrfxzeg|}_bV{@egclaVerVhm|O{@pdV^Vr hmcrVVeF_bp_bayeuc@VWel{psrVVmefnd|OhmndV{@eyN!c@aVpric_GaVeu^MVBWel{pOxPr>|}_b|te#Oeg^!_bcpdVc@eg{ndegrhm^cGVlgegc@cGhAde_el?de5egelWel{GhvpqrVcluaVecGpOmhmrmhm^yew{Ge$#>eg_bcf_bayeeqRpdcGy{Geu_GhmefpOx_GaVerVel_Gegl_Gpd{BryV{Ghv^Vn`_Ga>|}__bhvue|O^yrhvc^ypd{Gu|OmhvcGelrk_Gp`_GaVeZ]pd^!_be|O{GvpeqReg_/|}_Ghmpd^
-
X|g W: =, sF qU>=
-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
Y / m
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
FC only
FC and FCUPFCUP only
PCDNPCUP
b%/w vX5>Zhvc@_b{@hmVq_bhmpO^BpOxXhv^M_Geg{G|Ol_Ghmpd^KRpdhv^M_Gchm^_baVe"!V|}^Vexzpd{cGegveg_begrFr>|_/|e#Oeg^!_bcl'ayeBpsl_/|}ndpd^{GelV{GelcGeg^!_GcT_baVeegryndegcpOx_GaVeryel_bell_Gpd{gbaVepO_GaVeg{Pmhv^VegcicGayp/_baVevpqg|}_bhvpd^VcpOx6_bayeOel_Gpuc@aVhmelmrV|}^VMcg
-
X|g W: =, sF qU
Vertex Z / m0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Num
ber o
f Eve
nts
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35 Total MC (unoscillated))2 = 0.00274 eV2mTotal MC (
Data
b%/ *v%3>HZhmc_b{GhvVy_Ghmpd^p}xZhm^!_Geg{b|}l_bhvpd^Rpdhm^!_bc|Ovpd^Vno_GaVe / |qhmcKxzpO{c@egvegl_Gegrr>|}_b|ue#Oeg^!_bcl=aVeWpOhm^!_bcPhm^Vryhm|_ber>|}_b|ue#Oeg^!_bcpOVcGel{)delrhm^]e|O/a&2{GelndhmpO^baVecGpdvhmrvhm^VeTaVhmc_bpdnd{G|O cGaVpric_baVey^VpdcGlhmv|}_GegrrVhvc@_G{Ghmyy_bhvpd^pOxcGelmeg_belrh`pd^!_be'|O{Gvpe#Oeg^!_bclayerV|OcGaVelrvhm^VecGaVpric_baVefryhmc@_G{GhvVy_bhvpd^opOxcGelmell_belrz`pd^!_be|O{Gvpe#Oeg^!_bcpdcGlhmv|}_GegrfVc@hm^Vnfu ydn2@}e Y |O^VrcGhm^ 2} O-z_GaVeiWelc@_}V_>|O{b|}ue_beg{@cxz{Gpd _baVe])`pdVc@eg{nO|_bhmpO^VcpOx6_baVe!s]Re|O} E
Days since 1st August 20030 200 400 600 800 1000
Eve
nts p
er 8
4 da
ys
05
101520253035404550
b%/ v>DZhmc_b{GhvVy_Ghmpd^pOx^Vely_b{@hm^Vpte#del^!_F{b|}_Gewprdel{B_bhvue} |O/aRpdhm^!_{Gel{GelcGeg^!_Gc`_GaVe^MVKReg{pOxr>|_/|e#Oeg^!_bc`pdVc@eg{)Oegr hm^|O^H}r>|Wel{GhvpqraVec@pdmhvraVhmc_bpdnO{b|O }|O{@hmelcT|Olgpd{@rVhm^ynu_bp_baVeeqRpdcGy{GeKhv^te|}/aoWel{Ghvpqr]|O^Vr]hmcP^Vpd{Gu|OvhmcGelr_bp_baVeu_bpO_b|Ob]pO^M_Ge%|O{GvpoeqReg_/|}_Ghmpd^hv^_baVe|}VcGel^VgepOxPpdc@ghvm|_bhmpO^Vcg(aVer>|Oc@aVegraVhmc_bpdnO{b|OcGaVpricf_bayeeqWpOcGV{@e`^ypd{Gu|OmhvcGelrhm^_GaVe:]pd^!_be%|}{GmpeOqWell_/|_bhmpO^xzpd{fu yOn2f}e Y |}^VrkcGhm^ 2} d&-z_bayeKWelc@_qV_V|O{b|Oel_Geg{@cTxz{Gpd _baye]IpdVcGel{)}|}_Ghmpd^Vcp}x_GaVe!]Weg|O } E
-
X|g W: =, sF qU
/ GeVE0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Eff
icie
ncy
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
b%/ v"&>qelmell_bhvpd^%ulhmel^Vl`|OcP|KxzV^V_bhvpd^pOx('*)xzpd{PX &e#Oeg^!_bcl
+-,/.0,21 43657398;:mA@B89C89 Zedeg^!_GcgiaVhv/ay{GpsrVVgeFKypd^Vcg{@pdcGc@hm^Vn`|}_meg|Oc@_!Vm|O^VelcgGFaVeFelghveg^Vkhmc_bayexz{b|}l_bhvpd^kpOx_baVelcGee#del^!_bciayhm/a>|OcGc_bayec@egvegl_Ghmpd^kly_bclwhvndV{@eyN@c@aVpric_GaVeFcGelmeg_bhvpd^ellhmeg^ylB|Oc|ixzV^Vl_Ghmpd^pOxV_G{GVe'4)dhvndV{GeyNnPc@aVpric_bayecGelmell_bhvpd^Beghmel^VlB|Oc|PxzV^V_bhvpd^pOxiKypd^IHgel^Vhv_Ga|O^VnOmeOt>pd{_GaVewleg^!_b{G|O>|O{_KpOx_GaVewryhmc@_G{GhvVy_bhvpd^_GaVec@egmell_Ghmpd^eghmel^VlaVprdel{Gc|O{Gpdy^Vr}!_GaVeeghmel^Vlhvcmprel{xzpd{c@_belegVjVm|}{GrK|}^VrBrVpri^m|O{GrJndpdhv^VnP_G{b|O/Mcl>|O{_bjrVyek_Gp_baVeryhvgVj_pOx{@eggpO^Vc@_G{GV_bhm^ync@V/a e#del^!_bcgKFaVekprdel{b|OvTeulhmel^VlxzpO{Vm|O{GrJndpdhv^Vntedeg^!_GcfhmchOyjroy2OviaVhmve_GaVeweghmel^Vlxzpd{rVpri^m|O{@rJnOpdhm^Vn]e#Oeg^!_bcfhvcpd^VjG!q4oy2OAFaVhmchmcrVVew_Gp]_bayea>|O{@cGaVel{Kgy_GcLiaVhv/aKVc_fWew|OVVvhmelrhm^pd{Gryeg{_Gp{GeluprOeF_GaVeF|O{@ndefgpOcGhmfKVpO^V|O/Mnd{Gpdy^Vr_Gp_GaVhmccG|OuymeOf^>|O{_bhvgVm|O{_GaVeueghmel^Vlxzpd{Pe#Oeg^!_bc`ihj_baolpdcRQZY7LNMPOyyhmcKV/aovprel{_baV|O^txzpd{Pe#Oeg^!_bc`ihj_batlpdcWQZY7LNMPOX qqFaVhvcPhvcrVVe_bpf_GaVea>|O{Gc@a`_GpdRpdmpdn}wly_bcPrVhmc@gVc@cGelrthm^]qell_Ghmpd^[yy2s
QSPIWZpX TgR%TIV S TvVU T WZVU X Tv