web site int audit checklist intent

20
wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 1 The following is a brief Review highlighting The development and use of an Audit Checklist. A fictitious procedure is used to demonstrate the process of developing checklists that give the auditor a strong starting point. This goes a long way to ensure a through audit. Each ‘click’ of your mouse will take you through this free presentation in only a few minutes. You may save this file for future use or return to this web-site at any time to utilize these free presentations. This skill is invaluable to an effective and comprehensive internal audit program. Mastery of this skill by the internal auditor adds greatly to the overall audit program within an organization. This skill applies to the internal audit for any of the international standards.

Upload: martinbusiness

Post on 14-Jun-2015

603 views

Category:

Technology


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 1

The following is a brief Review highlighting The development and use of an Audit Checklist.

A fictitious procedure is used to demonstrate the process of developing checklists that give the auditor a strong starting point. This goes a long way to ensure a through audit.

Each ‘click’ of your mouse will take you through this free presentation in only a few minutes. You may save this file

for future use or return to this web-site at any time to utilize these free presentations.

This skill is invaluable to an effective and comprehensive internal audit program. Mastery of this skill by the internal auditor adds greatly to the overall audit program within an organization. This skill applies to the internal audit for any of the international standards.

Page 2: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 2

Audit Checklist Development

Set-up Procedure – SOP 101

5.1 The “Utility” person will do machine set-ups per the production schedule.

5.2 The “Utility” person runs 3 parts for set-up verification.

5.3 “Utility” person takes the set-up parts to the Lab for measurement.

5.4 All material produced after set-up is contained until the verification of the set-up.

5.5 After verification the normal sampling plan is followed.

Let’s Breakdown the process of developing and using a checksheet.

Page 3: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 3

Audit Checklist Development

Set-up Procedure – SOP 101

5.1 The “Utility” person will do machine set-ups per the production schedule.

5.2 The “Utility” person runs 3 parts for set-up verification.

5.3 “Utility” person takes the set-up parts to the Labfor measurement.

5.4 All material produced after set-up is containeduntil the verification of theset-up.

5.5 After verification the normal sampling plan is followed.

1. The auditor in the development of the checksheet must account for each requirement of the procedure.

2. Some items are accounted for by questions to the responsible person.

3. Other items are accounted for by direct observation of the auditor

Page 4: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 4

Checklist – SOP 101

2. When are set-ups conducted? (5.1)

1. Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Audit Checklist Development

4. Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

3. How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

2. When are set-ups conducted? (5.1)

1. Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

4. Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

3. How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Procedure – SOP 101

5.1 The “Utility” person will do machine set-ups perthe production schedule.

5.2 The “Utility” person runs 3 parts for set-up verification.

5.3 “Utility” person takes the set-up parts to the Labfor measurement.

5.4 All material produced after set-up is containeduntil the verification of theset-up.

5.5 After verification the normal sampling plan is followed.

Page 5: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 5

Checklist – SOP 101

Audit Checklist Development

5. How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

6. How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

5. How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

6. How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Set-up Procedure – SOP 101

5.1 The “Utility” person will do machine set-ups perthe production schedule.

5.2 The “Utility” person runs 3 parts for set-up verification.

5.3 “Utility” person takes the set-up parts to the Labfor measurement.

5.4 All material produced after set-up is containeduntil the verification of theset-up.

5.5 After verification the normal sampling plan is followed.

Page 6: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 6

1. Once the questions are developed, the auditor must transfer them to a checksheet

2. The format of the checksheet isn’t important and may vary by auditor.

3. Each auditor will develop a format that they are comfortable with.

4. The format development comes from auditor experience.

Audit Checklist Development

Page 7: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 7

Audit Checklist Development

Check out the next slide

for a possible format!

Page 8: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 8

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

CHECKLIST FOR AUDIT REPORT NO: Page _____ of _____

Audit date May 12, 2008

Audit Checklist Development

Let’s go through this checksheet format

item by item to see just how helpful this

tool becomes to the auditor!

Page 9: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 9

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

CHECKLIST FOR AUDIT REPORT NO: Page _____ of _____

Audit date May 12, 2008

Audit Checklist Development

1. The Procedure number, Procedure issue date and

the audit date links this document to the

procedure at the time/date of the audit.

2. The completed checksheet becomes objective

evidence for future audits.

3. Verification as to the proper completion of the

internal audit process.

Page 10: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 10

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

CHECKLIST FOR AUDIT REPORT NO: Page _____ of _____

Audit date May 12, 2008

Audit Checklist Development

1. The “item No.”, “Requirement”, and “Interview” field give the auditor a place to itemize the questions to be ask and the person to be interviewed.

2. In most cases the interviewee is identified by job title.

3. There may be some exceptions where a proper name is utilized.

Page 11: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 11

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

CHECKLIST FOR AUDIT REPORT NO: Page _____ of _____

Audit date May 12, 2008

Audit Checklist Development

The “Activity Compliance.” and “Comments/Remarks” fields give the auditor a place to document compliance and to record information about the answers given the auditor, or observation of the auditor.

Page 12: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 12

Audit Checklist Development

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

1. Here we have the

questions that become our

starting point for our

audit process.

2. The number in

parentheses indicates the

procedure element being

investigated.

1. In the “Interview”

column is the person to

be interviewed.

Page 13: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 13

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

1. The first question is confirmed as OK and the name of the person being interviewed is noted.

2. This allows the auditor to confirm training at a later interview, perhaps in the HR department.

Page 14: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 14

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

1. The second question is confirmed by the set-up person.

2. Note the follow-up comment to confirm this important set-up step.

Page 15: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 15

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

No Per the set-up person only two (2) parts are being taken to the lab to verify set-up. Inspection records in the lab confirm this statement

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

1. The third question is confirmed by the set-up person.

2. Note the noncompliance is also confirmed by lab records.

Page 16: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 16

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

No

4, Yes/4A Yes

Per the set-up person only two (2) parts are being taken to the lab to verify set-up. Inspection records in the lab confirm this statement

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

1. The fourth question is confirmed by the set-up person, as well as observation of the auditor.

Page 17: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 17

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

4, Yes/4A Yes

Per the set-up person only two (2) parts are being taken to the lab to verify set-up. Inspection records in the lab confirm this statement

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Check training records for supervisor “Kathy Connor”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

1. The fifth question is confirmed by the supervisor.

2. The auditor records the supervisors name to confirm proper training.

3. This training is confirmed later in HR.

Page 18: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 18

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

4, Yes/4A Yes

Per the set-up person only two (2) parts are being taken to the lab to verify set-up. Inspection records in the lab confirm this statement

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Check training records for supervisor “Kathy Connor”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

1. The last question is confirmed by the line operator.

2. The auditor confirms proper process control by verifying inspection records correspond to job instructions for the operator.

Yes Confirmed by Job instructions and corresponding inspection records

Page 19: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 19

Audit Checklist Use

ItemNo: REQUIREMENT Interview

ACTIVITYCOMPLIANCE COMMENTS/REMARKS

1 Who does the machine set-up? (5.1)

Set-up Tech

2 When are set-ups conducted? (5.1) Set-up Tech

3 How many parts are run for set-up verification? (5.2)

Set-up Tech

4 Where are the parts transferred to? (5.3) 4A. Transfer by Who? (5.3)

Set-up Tech

5 How is production material handled while awaiting verification of set-up parts? (5.4)

Supervisor

6 How is the process controlled after part verification? (5.5)

Machine Operator

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Procedure Number SOP 101 Rev A Issue Date 2/14/08

Audit date May 12, 2008

Yes

Yes

No

Yes

4, Yes/4A Yes

Per the set-up person only two (2) parts are being taken to the lab to verify set-up. Inspection records in the lab confirm this statement

Check training records for set-up man “John Allen”

Check training records for supervisor “Kathy Connor”

Confirmed by lab inspection records and the production schedule for the past 4 set-ups

Yes Confirmed by Job instructions and corresponding inspection records

1. This completed checksheet now

becomes part of the audit record.

2. This is valuable objective evidence

for surveillance audits and future

internal audits.3. Giving objective evidence that the

procedure in question was

thoroughly audited.

Page 20: Web site int audit checklist intent

wwwMBCIncorp.com - Martin Business Consulting, Inc. 20

Thank you

• If you need additional information, training or direction about “Internal Audit”. Visit our web-site

www.MBCIncorp.com • Select the menu tab “Course List & Services”, or “Public

Seminars”• Or just contact National Quality Services,

– E-mail – [email protected]– Phone – 931-637-1446

• Check the web site often for new PowerPoint presentation on many topics of interest