westfield high school - 2015 fed challenge - round 2

15
Are we there yet? Conundrum warrants poise. 1 “For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong.” – H.L. Mencken. So while there is no substitute for considering a variety of theories, we offer a reasonable framework for timing consideration for reducing accommodative policies.

Upload: jameslane

Post on 23-Jul-2015

10 views

Category:

Economy & Finance


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Are we there yet? Conundrum warrants poise.

1

“For every complex problem there is an answer that is clear, simple, and wrong.” – H.L. Mencken. So while there is no substitute for considering a variety of theories, we offer a reasonable framework for timing consideration for reducing accommodative policies.

Output: Few Recent Concerns, But Dollar Strength May Slow Positive Momentum

Source: FRED.2

Output: Manufacturing-related Data Trends Likely More Volatile in 2015, but expect Consistent Rise in Post-Recession Household Formation

ISM

HO

US

EH

OL

D

FO

RM

AT

ION

Sources: Bloomberg and U.S. Census Bureau.3

Labor: Unemployment Improvement Since 2009; Quits Rate Rising Gradually, but Still Below Pre-Recession Level

4

Labor: “Adjusted” U-3 as a key policy factor?

5Sources: F.O.M.C. and estimates (see Slide 14).

Adjusted U-3 could provide a more stable NAIRU indicator for policy discussions, decisions and communications.

One current data set suggests a baseline NAIRU achievement timeframe of mid-2016, with expansionary upside of late-2015, and global economic downside risk of early-2017.

Jason Previlon
Should be percent change

Labor: Upward Wage Trajectory, Below Pre-Recession Levels, Controlled by LFPR Level

6

Currency: Net Exports likely suppressing real GDP growth by 0.25%-0.75%

7

Given the roughly 10-15% weighting of international trade in the the U.S. economy according to the Chamber of Commerce, the recent roughly 15% strength in the U.S. dollar may depress real GDP growth by 0.25%-0.75%. See slide 14 for calculation.

Source: N.Y. Times.

PCE: Core Lagging 2% target; LFPR and strong dollar partly to blame.

8Source: Barron’s, March 30, 2015.

Inflation: Subdued expectations likely until ‘adjusted’ U-3 NAIRU in mid- or late-2016; expect inflation ‘wiggles’ with dollar weakness.

9

Balance Sheet: Despite “Tantrum,” Tapering Has Been Right F.O.M.C. Adjustment; Strong U.S. asset demand may offer opportunities for securities sales in later stages of policy normalization process

10

Jennifer Lane
from Mr. Lane: can this graph be combined with a graph of U.S. real GDP over the same time period to help speak to a theory of what the 'new normal' size of the Fed balance sheet might

Preferred Sequence of Normalization Actions

1. Cease reinvestment of maturing bonds.

2. Fed Funds Rate target increases as ‘adjusted’ U-3 approaches NAIRU.

• Consistent with Taylor Rule principles (see Appendix III on Slide 15)• Implemented with scheduled communications and Interest-On-Excess-

Reserves and Over-Night-Reverse-Repurchase-Agreements

3. Controlled, opportunistic, limited, periodic Treasury bond sales during peak financial markets demand periods for U.S. Dollar-denominated assets – initial sales should favor shorter maturities to keep mortgage rates attractive.

11

Recommendation: Data-Driven “When” on FFR

Summary: (1) consistent U.S. output recovery, albeit below historical trend; (2) ‘adjusted U-3” suggests little urgency to FFR change; (3) global economies and currencies weakness limiting U.S. inflation expectations; (4) domestic wages and loan growth controlled, but upwardly biased; and (5) FFR target increases historically problematic when USD demand high

Key Tools: (1) “Opportunistic Overheating” in absence of target PCE data and when LFPR below historical norms; (2) Employment and output trends solid, with wage trends controlled due to LFPR; and (3) focus on global economic stability, not currency fluctuations. 12

Appendix I: Calculation of ‘adjusted U-3” at 65% LFPR

13

Appendix II: Estimated Impact of U.S. Dollar Strength on Reported Real G.D.P.

14

Appendix III: Synthesis of Taylor Rule principles, ‘adjusted U-3’ and Okun’s Law

15