why the difference the truth?-aakhir ikhtilaaf kyun?-okarvi
TRANSCRIPT
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 1/206
Qoy
tol
Dkcclrlefls>
h`okr `otkihhc @yue
Hiihmho
@hu`hb
Ennrhek
N`hrvk
Zhrt
-
8
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 2/206
Hiihho, ke wonsl ehml K blake, ks tol Mnst Fnmphssknehtl, tol Mnst
Mlrfkcui
Hi-Ihhou Rhbbu Muohmmhdke Vhiih 'Hihkok Qh Vhiihmh Hiihho Vubohhehou
ks tol Frlhtnr hed Enurksolr nc Vhkyykdkeh Muohmmhd
(Vhiihi Ihhou 'Hihklok Qh Vhiihm),
hed sleds
Zlhfl hed Vhiuthtknes tn okm.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 3/206
Mkehz-zuiumhhtk Kihe-ennr
PCrnm Dhr`elss ketn Ikaot] PHi-Xur‛hhe ]
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 4/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 5/206
Toks Zrlslethtkne ks pubiksold cnr hii tonsl7
Qon skeflrliy whet tn `enw hbnut tol fnecuskne fnecikft, kssuls,
hed dkcclrlefls bltwlle tol sfonihrs nc tol Hoil-Vueeht-Qh-
Ghmh'ht's hed nc tol Dlnbhed Qhohbll arnup. Qon wnuid rlhiiy
ik`l tn `enw‟ Hh`okr K`otkihhc @yue‛
PHctlr hii woy hed woht hrl tol Dkcclrlefl]>
Hisn lxpihehtkne ks ke nrdlr woy hed wole tol cnuedhtknes nc toks
dksputl wlrl ihkd - hed woht hrl tol fhusls nwkea tn wokfo tol
dksputl stkii fnetkeuls hii nvlr tol wnrid, cnr dlfhdls.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 6/206
Fnetlets…
• Lxflrpt- Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy…tol Truto
• Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht
• Bliklcs nc Dlnbhedk Qhohhbll Thbillaok
• Tol Rlhsne cnr Dkcclrlefls
• Okstnrkfhi Chfts- Fnespkrhfkls nc tol Lelmkls nc Ksihhm…
• Lxfliilefl's nc tol Blinvld
• PVhihi Ihhon Hihklok Qhshihm]
• Fnefiuskne
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 7/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 8/206
Tn hii cnur Crkleds* (nc tol Zrnpolt) K onid dlhr K hm tol sihvls tn tol prnaley nc ‟Hill **
bl pilhsld wkto tolm)
Nc tol Oheckyyho frlld K hm hed blinea tn tol ehtkne nc
Ohzrht Kbrhhollm @ohilli ui Ihho, (Hihkloks Vhihhm)
Dust crnm uedlr tol cllt nc Aohus-l- H‛zhm*** (Mlrfy nc Hiihho bl ne okm), K hm, uedlr t
nc lvlry Crkleds nc Hiihho.
(Mhy Hiihho bl pilhsld wkto tolm)
Ohzrht Hbu Bh`r, Ohzrht ‟\mhr, Ohzrht ‟ \smhhe, Ohzrht ‟Hill
(Hiihho mhy bl pilhsld wkto tolm)
Ohzrht Kmhhm Ohshe, Kmhhm Oushkle (Hiihho mhy bl pilhsld wkto
Ohzrht Vohkl`o Vhkyykd ‟Hbdui Xhhdkr Gllihhell (Mlrfy nc Hiihho bl ne o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 9/206
DLDKFHTLD T
Mhobnnb-l-Vubo
Aohus-l-VhmhdhVohbohhz-l-Ih Mh
Xutb-l-Rhbbhh
Ohzrht Hbu Muohmmhd M
Vohkl`o Vhkyykd Hbdu
Ohshek Oushklek GllVhkyykdkeh
Aohus-l- H'zhm
( Rhdkyhi Ihhou He
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 10/206
Himkaoty Hiihho's Fnmmh[nu (N Zrnpolt) wkii ent cked plnpil won bliklvl ke Hiihho hed tol Dhy nc Gudamlet
ckaot hahkest Hiihho hed Oks Mlsslealr, lvle tonuao toly bl tolkr chtolrs, nr tolkbrntolrs, nr tolkr kedrld. Tolsl hrl toly ne wonsl olhrts Ol ohs kesfrkbld chkto he
strleatoleld wkto h Vpkrkt crnm Okm, hed wonm Ol wkii hdmkt ketn Ahrdles blelh
cinw tn ikvl tolrl cnrlvlr. Hiihho ks wlii pilhsld wkto tolm hed toly hrl wlii pilhs
Toly hrl Hiihho's phrty, mnst surliy, Hiihho's phrty, toly wkii htthke tn ltlre
(Hi-Xur'hhe, Fohptlr7 Hi-Muguhhdkiho, Zhrt 2?, Slrsl 22)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 11/206
Lxflrpt…Zrliudl-
Muohmmhd Bheh Vohck‛ll Xhhdk
DLNBHED TN BHRLK
tol TR\TO…
by
Hiihmho @hu`hb Ennrhek N`h
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 12/206
Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiyks tol ehrrhtkvl nc tol gnurely
crnm dhr`elss tn ikaot nc tolkmplrclft ketliilft tn tol trul
invl.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 13/206
Kt whs h bilssld hed blhutkcui mnmlet wole tol arlht prl
Ksihhm, tol kefnmphrhbil nrhtnr nc tol wnrid nc Ksihhm h
lmbndkmlet nc invl cnr tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). O
Mhuiheh Muohmmhd Vohcll N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), ohd slt
tol snki nc Vnuto Hcrkfh ke 8;13. Tol levkrnes nc tol letkrl
wlrl ckiild wkto tol rlmlmbrhefl nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ih
Vhiihm) by oks kespkrkea mhakfhi tnel nc vnkfl. Elvlr, blcnrl okm
okm, ohd nur lyls slle sufo h spiledkd plrsnehikty enr oh
sufo h splii bnuedkea splh`lr. Kt whs ik`l woht tol pnlt oh
’Oks ehml ks ne lvlrybndy‛s ikps hed lvlrybndy ks mhdiy
wkto okm”.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 14/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 15/206
Ohzrht Mhuiheh N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), vksktld Vnuto Hcrkfh cnr
tol slfned tkml ke 8;1;- ?:, hed tol wlifnml akvle tn okm olrl
whs splfthfil. Ol whs kevktld tn chr-ciuea hrlhs nc tol fnuetry.
Vlvlrhi mlltkeas wlrl olid lvlry dhy hed plnpil wnuid fnml
ke tolm ke vhst eumblrs. Qolrlvlr ol ikvld, wokfolvlr pihfl ol
wlet tn, oks plrsnehikty whs kedlikbiy kmprketld ne lvlry olhrt.
Tol splfkhi trhkts, wokfo tol Bnuetkcui Frlhtnr ohd lednwld
okm, hrl ent akvle tn lvlrynel. Durkea tol fnursl nc 4: ylhrs nc
strkvkea hctlr truto ol mhdl mnrl tohe 8?::: kespkrkea
spllfols, h wnrid rlfnrd sn chr. Oks mlmnry ks uecnraltthbil.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 16/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 17/206
Nur blelchftnr hed spkrktuhi aukdl, Ohzrht Mhuiheh Vohcll N(Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), ilct toks mnrthi wnrid cnr oks olhvleiy
ne tol mnrekea nc tol Hprki 24, 8;?4, wokil leahald ke sled
Durnnd hed Vhihhm tn oks blinvld
Ohzrht Muohmmhd Musthchh (Vhiihi Ihhou 'Hihklok Qh Vhiihm).
Ke-ehh Iki-Ihhok Qh ie-ehh Kihklok Rhhgk‛nne
(Tn Hiihho wl blinea hed tn Okm wl rlture).
Tol elws nc oks suddle dlphrturl brnuaot tlhrs tn tol lyls
uehffnuethbiy eumblr nc plnpil hed lsplfkhiiy tol Vueell Mu
Vnuto Hcrkfh wlrl stueeld. Tol phsskea hwhy nc toks fnmmhe
tol fhrhvhe nc tol Hoil Vueeht whs ent he nrdkehry trhaldy. O
tol arlhtlst hsslt nc tol Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht , ol whs he
tn tol wnrid nc Hoil Vueeht.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 18/206
Lvle oks nppnelets wlrl cnrfld tn hfflpt oks arlhtelss hed oks
stlhdchstelss. Oks ehml usld tn sled trlmnrs tornuao tol
fohmblrs nc chislonnd. Aouihhm @ohe, h Qhohhbk sfonihr nc
Rhwhipkedk (Zh`ksthe) npleiy hdmkttld, ’Ohd h arlht plrsnehikty
ik`l Mhuiheh N`hrvk blle prlslet ke tol cnid nc Dlnbhed hiiZh`kstheks wnuid ohvl lmbrhfld tol frlld.‛‛ Tol shykea nc Ohzrht
Vhkyykd Homhd Vh'lld @hhzkmk, he Kmhhm nc tol Hoil Vueeht whs
toht, ’Blfhusl nc oks splfkhi trhkts, Ohzrht Mhuiheh Vohcll N`hrvk
(Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo ), whs levkld by tol wonil wnrid.”
Toks ks h trul tlstkmney tn oks arlhtelss
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 19/206
Hctlr okm, ntolr ‟ \ihmh crnm Zh`ksthe hed Kedkh blahe tn fnml tn Vn
enel nc tolm whs hbil tn ilhvl tol kmprket nc tolkr cnntstlps ik`l ol
Lyls wlrl slhrfokea cnr snmlnel tn rlnple tol fohptlr ilct ueckeksol
wlrl tokrsty tn olhr snmlbndy wkto oks trhkts, wkto h aikmpsl nc okm. En
rlpihflmlet nc snmlbndy lisl, hed Ohzrht Mhuiheh Vohcll N`hrvk (Rh
Hihklo), whs uednubtcuiiy he kefnmphrhbil shket.Ohhgk [nnsuc Oushke Mhesnnr, h rlskdlet nc Zklt Rltklc, h Vnuto Hcrkfh
finsl tn okm hed ol whs h arlht hdmkrlr nc my rlvlrld Ohzrht Mhuiheh
Ohhsokm [nnsuc Mhesnnr, whs mhdiy ke invl wkto okm. Ol ohd olhrd O
N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), rlplhtkea toks sletlefl,
’ [nu ohvl slle ml.
[nu sonuid sll hed olhr @hu`hb.”
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 20/206
Lvlrybndy `elw toht @hu`hb ks tol lidlst sne nc Ohzrht Mhuiheh Mu
Vohcll N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), but enbndy ohd hs ylt slle
lvlrybndy whetld tn kevktl okm tn Vnuto Hcrkfh. Qon `elw toht ol wn
olrl wole nur rlvlrld Ohzrht wkii ent bl ke toks wnrid> Ckehiiy, Ohhsok
snmlonw sufflldld ke mh`kea okm fnml tn Vnuto Hcrkfh hed wl, tol
nppnrtuekty tn sll Ohzrht Hiihmho @hu`hb Ennrhek N`hrvk hed clit sh
tol rlvlrld Mhuiheh N`hrvk ohd ilct us h trul hed wnrtoy sufflssnr
Mhuiheh N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), must ohvl prhyld cnr okm
wnrtoy nc oks ehml.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 21/206
Oh`llm Mkyhhe Ehwhhb Dlle Vohrqpurk nc Rhkwked, won dkld toks y
nc nvlr 8:: ylhrs, h dksfkpil nc Vohyr-l-Rhbbhhek Ohzrht Mkyhhe Vohy
Vohrqpurk (Rhomhtui Ihhok ‟ Hihklok)
, ohs shkd, "Qole Hiihmho @hu`hb EnnrheOhzrht Mhuiheh N`hrvk ohd kecnrmld okm toht ’Ikaot ohd fnml ketn
Ohzrht Vohyr-l-Rhbbhhek Mkyhhe Vohyr Muohmmhd Vohrqpurk (Rhomhtui
plrsne won ohd nel ylhr blcnrl tol bkrto nc Ohzrht Mhuiheh N`hrvk a
tkdkea tn Mhuiheh N`hrvk‛s chtolr hisn, Ohhgk @hrhm Kihhok Vhhokb , ’ @
Mnrl strlhms nc ikaot wkii cinw. Vtrlhms nc Hiihho Th‛hhihh‛ s arhfl
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 22/206
Tol wnrid ohs hirlhdy wktelss
polenmlene toht Ohzrht Mhuiheh
whs bnre dul tn tol aihd tkdkeas nshket hii oks ikcl, sprlhd ikaot ke hii dk
dkspliild dhr`elss hii hrnued. Hiihm
Ennrhek N`hrvk ks tol slfned mhekc
Ohzrht Vohyr-l-Rhbbhhek's aihd
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 23/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 24/206
Tol skilefl, wokfo ohd blle prlvhkikea skefl tol phsskea hwhy
Mhuiheh N`hrvk (Rhomhtui Ihho Hihklo), ckehiiy, yklidld tn tol p
mhakfhi vnkfl nc Hiihmho @hu`hb N`hrvk.
Hiihmho @hu`hb sthrtld h elw lrh ke Vnuto Hcrkfh, wktoke h c
rlvkvld oks arlht chtolr's mksskne olrl. Ol wnr`ld tkrlilssiy hed
trhdktknes nc oks rlvlrld chtolr nc rledlrld rlvniutknehry slrvkfls Ksihhm hed tn uponid tol truto nc tol Hoil Vueeht frlld. Ol rlm
mkdst nc plnpil hed bnn`s, hddrlsskea slvlrhi ahtolrkeas dhkiy h
wkto tol shml dlvntkne hed fnetlmpihtkne, but wkto h crlsoels
Ke ckvl ylhrs, crnm 8;?1 tn 8;;8, Hiihmho N`hrvk whs kevktld o
Durkea toks plrknd, ol vksktld Vwhzkihed, Bntswheh, Mnzhmbkqul,
uekne, Ilsnton hed Wkmbhbwl ltf. Ol hutonrld lkaot bnn`s, wok
trhesihtld ketn Leaikso.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 25/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 26/206
Tol slrkls nc rlmlmbrhefl-ahtolrkeas sprlhd, tol Vueeht (tol trhdktkne) nc
rlfktkea Durnnd Vohrllc ke mhshhgkd blcnrl hed hctlr Hzhhe whs rlvkvld, tol
prhftkfl nc onidkea Lkd-l-Mllihhd-ue-Ehbll (Vhiihi Ihhou‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ke mhey phrts
nc tolsl fnuetrkls whs kehuaurhtld cnr tol ckrst tkml. Brhefols nc Mhuiheh
N`hrvk Hfhdlmy (Hi- H‛ihmk ) wlrl lsthbiksold, mhdhhrks (rlikaknus sfonnis) wlrl
slt up. Tonusheds nc wnr`lrs wlrl trhkeld tn slrvl tol frlld nc tol Hoil
Vueeht, mhey plnpil lmbrhfld Ksihhm hed cnr tol ckrst tkml lvlr, tol onidkea
nc tle-dhy Muohrrhm fnmmlmnrhtkvl mlltkeas fhml ketn vnaul ke Vnuto
Hcrkfh's prnvkefl.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 27/206
Hiihmho N`hrvk ohs tn oks frldkt hentolr kmpnrthet hed mlmnrhbil hfVnuto Hcrkfh. Ne Crkdhy, tol 83to Dlflmblr, 8;??, ol plrsnehiiy wlet tn M
dlikvlrld tn tol ilhdlrs nc tol Dlnbhedk -Qhohhbk -Thbillaok arnup he ke
Muehhzkrho (dlbhtl) hed Mubhhokiho (h mlltkea nc fnetledkea plrsnes nr
fursls nc Hiihho ne tonsl won dley tol truto). Ne tol rlfnaekzld prkefkpil
tol truto hed lxpnskea tol chislonnd ol whetld he htmnspolrl nc plhfl
prlvhki hmneast tol Musikm mkenrkty pnpuihtkne nc Vnuto Hcrkfh. Ol ohd brnwonil folst nc nid hed elw bnn`s nc tol ‟ \ihmh nc Dlnbhed . Vn toht tol
hfts, cnr wokfo tol ilhdlrs nc tol Qhohhbk -Thbillaok arnup ohd sprlhd to
fhiikea us keckdlis hed keenvhtkvl, fnuid bl prnvld rkaot hffnrdkea tn tol X
Vueeht tornuao bnn`s wrkttle by tol ‟ \ihmh nc Dlnbhed tolmslivls. Hed t
ke toks fnuetry fnuid alt rkd nc tolsl fnetrnvlrskls hed hii mhy ikvl ke plhfl
C to
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 28/206
Cnr torll ylhrs fn
kevkthtkne nc Hiihm
rlplhtldiy pub
elwsphplr ’Vued
Hiihmho N`hrvk o
tnpkfs cnr dlbhtl, fnevlyld tn tol
Dlnbhedk-Qhoh
sfonni nc ton
fnmmuekfhtkne
pubiksold ke elws
slic- prnfihkmld
‟ \ihmh nc tol Dln
Thbillaok sfonni d
auts tn chfl Hiihm
chkild tn prnvl toh
hs toly ohd bl
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 29/206
Ke Huaust, 8;;8, hctlr lxohustkea hii hraumlets wkto tolm, Hiihm
N`hrvk pubiksold ke tol shml elwsphplr oks ihst entkfl hed mhdl kt
toht enw plnpil nc tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok sfonni wlfneckrmld oypnfrktls hed wktonut hey cnuedhtkne.
Tol Musikms nc Vnuto Hcrkfh wkii cnrlvlr rlmlmblr tol chvnrs dne
tolm by Hiihmho N`hrvk. By lxpnskea tol trul chfts hbnut tolsl s
prnfihkmld rkaotlnus plnpil hed by lxpnskea tolm ol shvld mhey s
Musikm crnm ankea hstrhy.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 30/206
Hiihho bl prhksld! Tol ehml nc Hiihmho @hu`hb Ennrhek N`hrvk oh
symbni nc truto hed h eh`ld swnrd cnr lvlry chislonnd tornuaonut Vnut
tol Himkaoty Hiihho prlslrvl tol dltlrmkehtkne hed tol stlhdchstelss
invlr nc Oks blinvld Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihlkok Qh Vhiihm) , hed mhy Ol mh l o
blelcktkea hsslt cnr tol Ksihhmkf Mkiiht! Hhmlle.
Cnr tlhfokea Hiihmho N`hrvk ohs akvle chfts sn toht plnpil wnuid `en
hed woy Vueells dkcclr wkto Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-ksm, woht hrl kts fhusl
tol sniutkne tn kt> Tol bnn` blcnrl ml, ’ Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy, (tol Truto),
dlthkis hbnut hii toks. Ke chft, kt mhy bl fhiild h rlvniutknehry hbnn`. Tor
wkii hisn fnml tn `enw tol plnpil won hrl rldllmld.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 31/206
Toks bnn` ’ Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy, (tol Truto)” by Hiihmho N`hrvk whs
ckrst pubiksold ke Vnuto Hcrkfh ke 8;??. Vkefl tole, kts torll mnrl
ldktknes ohvl blle pubiksold hed dkstrkbutld. Kt ohs blle
trhesihtld ketn ckvl kmpnrthet iheauhals.
Ke tol mlhetkml, Hiihmho N`hrvk‛s bnn` fhiild ’Qoktl hed
Bihf`” ohs hisn blle pubiksold, wokfo akvls hii tol dlthkis hedmh`ls kts filhr tn lvlrynel tol rlhikty nc Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-ksm.
’Qoktl hed Bihf`” fhrrkls hinea fneskdlrhbil lxpihehtkne nc tol
pnkets rhksld ke tol bnn` ’ Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy.” Lxflrpts crnm
bnn`s wrkttle by tol ‟ \ihmh nc Dlnbhed akvkea aikmpsls nc tolkr
bihspolmnus wrktkeas hrl hisn kefiudld ke kt.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 32/206
Blcnrl tol pubikfhtkne nc tol 4to ldktkne nc ’ Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy,” Hii
ohd mhdl snml hddktknes hed fnrrlftknes ke kt ke nrdlr tn mh`l kt
vhiuhbil. Tol ihtl Ghehhb Vhaollr Mhiihi ckrst trhesihtld kt ketn Leai pnlt hed wrktlr nc @hrhfok, hctlr fnrrlftknes hed hddktknes tn kt, kt
trhesihtld hcrlso by rlsplftld Vhkyykd Aouihhm @ohwhgho, h prn
Mhobnnb-l-Vubohhek Ohzrht Vhkyykdkeh Aohus-l- H‛zhm (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟H
dkstkeauksold Leaikso sfonihr hed gnurehikst nc Zh`ksthe, won ohs
trhesihtld ckvl bnn`s nc Hiihmho @hu`hb Ennrhek N`hrvk
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 33/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 34/206
Hs hii plnpil dne‛t rlhd tolsl bnn`s hed ke mhey hrlhs tolsl b
hvhkihbil lsplfkhiiy ke cnrlkae fnuetrkls. Zlnpil mkaot toke`
rlclrlefls hrl ent crnm hutoletkf bnn`s sn Mhuiheh N
Hfhdlmy Hi'Hhihmk dlfkdld ne tol wksols nc cniinwlrs hed crkle
vkdln dnfumlethry prnnc nc tolsl rlclrlefls cnr tol pubikf. To
prlphrld ke he lvlekea ht Mhuiheh N`hrvk‛s plrsnehi ikbrhry tn f
rlhi chfts hbnut Hoil-Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht hed tn lehbil tolm tn
hed fnevly tol bhskf bliklcs nc Dlnbhedk arnup.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 35/206
Muohmmhd Bheh
Vohck‛ll Xhhdkrk,
8;;2-Z.N. Bnx 64:,
Durbhe, Vnuto Hcrkfh
K hm fneckdlet toht hctlr ankea tornuao kt rlhdlrs wkii rlhikzl toht t
must rlhfo tol oheds nc lvlry Musikm ke nrdlr tn lehbil okm tn rlcnr
hed kdlninakls hed ent tn bl h vkftkm tn hey dlvkhtkne. Dlspktl ikmktl Mhuiheh N`hrvk Hfhdlmy (Hi H‛ihmk ), Vnuto Hcrkfh, ks busy ke slrv
hed tol Ksihhmkf Mkiiht, hed kt rlqulsts ynu tn fnnplrhtl wkto kt hed
Mhy Hiihho @hrllm arhet us tol hbkikty tn bl stlhdchst ne tr
K rlhikzl toht K hm sthedkea bltwlle Hiihmho N`hrvk hed ynu, but
toht dlspktl my ketruskne ynur lhalrelss tn an tornuao toks bnn` mh
kefrlhsld, ent dkmkeksold.
Zrliudl - Lxflrpt…Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy by Hiihmho @hu`hb E
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 36/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 37/206
Hiihhou Rhbbu Muohmmhdke Vhiihh ‟ Hihklo
Qh Vhiihmhh(Hiihho Vubohhehou ks tol Frlhtnr hed Enurksolr nc
Vhkyykdkeh Muohmmhd (VhiihiIhhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ,
hed sleds plhfl hed shiuthtknes tn okm).
Hiihmho `hu`hb Ennrhek N`hrvk …
Lxflrpt …Dlnbhed tn B
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 38/206
Vkefl my fokidonnd, K ohvl blle ke nel why nr ntolr kevnivld wkto
bnn` hed ple, Mhdrkssho hed Mh`thb (sfonni), rlikaknus hed
spkrktuhi dksfusskne hed nbslrvhtkne. K ohvl hirlhdy ikvld torll
dlfhdls nc my ikcl. K hm hwhrl toht K ohvl ylt tn frnss dllp nflhes
hed tol bnht nc ikcl ks vlry kefneskstlet hed uerlikhbil. Heyonw, Kohvl h bliklc hed onpl toht snmlonw wkto my nwe dlskrl, ineakea
hed pilhsurl hed snml wkto tol `kedelss hed arhfl nc my lidlrs
hed tol prhylrs nc my crkleds hs tol prnvksknes nc toks gnurely K wkii,
‟ Ke sohh Hiihho, bl frnweld wkto sufflss.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 39/206
Lvle lhriklr, K whs arlhtiy dkstrlssld by toks tonuaot but ihtliy kt kef
lvle mnrl wole K vksktld tol Hcrkfhe fnuetrkls. K wktelssld toks str
polenmlene hmnea tol hdolrlets nc Ksihhm ikvkea ke my nwe onmli
hisn chr hwhy crnm tol onmlihed toht toly hrl hctlr tolkr nwe fniih pnket hffuskea ckealrs ht ntolrs> Lvle tol sn-fhiild whychrlrs nc tol
Mhdkeho, tol prlhfolrs hrl foheakea tol truto hed trutocuielss, h
sthedhrd-blhrlrs nc plhfl hed slfurkty (slic-prnfihkmld) hrl wkto
tneauls, ples hed dllds, dksarhfkea tolkr nwe Mkiiht hed arnup, tol
Mhsgkd hed puipkt.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 40/206
My olhrt billds wole K splh` nc tol trhaldy nc whstkea nur lelrakl
ke mutuhi rnws hed mutuhi tussils. Qoht h pkty toht fnetrnvlrskls he
dkcclrlefls fletlrs rnued nur nwe fletlr hed hxks! Tol Ksihhmkf chkt
fheent bl uedlrstnnd wktonut tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
ylt wl hrl dkcclrkea ke ketlrnplrhtkea, dlsfrkbkea hed lxpihkekea tol
dlthkis nc tol arlhtelss hed tol ainrkckfhtkne nc tol plrsnehikty nc to
oniy Zrnpolt okmslic (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 41/206
Kt ks my Kllmhhe (chkto) toht my Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ks ik l h m
Ol ks h mlrfy tn tol wnrids, h ikaot plrsnekckld hed h arlht ketlrflssnr (Vhiihi Ihhou
Qh Vhiihm). Ol ahvl oumhekty tn mle won usld tn bl wnrsl tohe blhsts hed wkt
lxfliilefl nc oks arlht fohrhftlr ol foheald ohtrld ketn invl. Tol tlhfokeas hed trhk
toks oniy hed enbil Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) rhksld tonsl won usl t
ke tol dlslrts bloked tol fhttil tn bl tol ilhdlrs nc fnmkea alelrhtknes. Tol chft ks
ent cnued h bliklvlr ke hey ntolr chkto nr rlikakne hii hrnued tol wnrid shykea sn mfnetrhdkftnry hed dlmlhekea tokeas hbnut tol cnuedlr nc tolkr chkto, wokfo mhy
fhtlanrkzld hs dksrlsplftcui, kesnilefl hed cnuimnutold-elss. Zlrohps, plnpil nc he
Mkiiht (ehtkne) wkii ent tnilrhtl sufo he httktudl wokfo wl uearhtlcui ohvl tnilrhtld
plrclft aukdl hed arlhtlst blelchftnr
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 42/206
Kt ks mnst kefnmprloleskbil woy dn toly mh`l tol butt n
frktkfksm hed blikttikea tol bilssld plrsnehikty hed tol httr
tolkr Zrnpolt, won ks hisn tol Vlhi nc tol Zrnpoltonnd, kc to
ckrm ke tolkr tonuaots hed bliklcs hed dn ent ik`l tol mnst
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) nc tol Rlhi Frlhtnr Hiihho Vubhed toly dne‛t ik`l oks mkrhfils hed httrkbutls, hed dne‛t
onenr hed rlsplft okm tole woy dn toly keskst ne blkea fh
cniinwlrs hed bliklvlrs nc sufo h Zrnpolt>
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 43/206
Cnr ohvkea chkto ke tol Zrnpolt nc Hiihho Vubohhehou
cniinwkea oks shykeas hed fohrhftlr wl hrl ent bnued b
mhdl ruils, prkefkpils hed whys but wl ohvl tn cniinw t
hed tol Vueeht. Nur rlihtknesokp wkto tol Zrnpolt ks en
nc h pokinsnpolr, toke`lr, tlhfolr, nr hs h ruilr hed tol
`kea hed pubikf, fnequlrnr hed tol fnequlrld nr hs h m
oks sihvl (uedlr durlss). But kt ks hs bltwlle h aukdl
whychrlr, hs h Zrnpolt hed oks cniinwlr hed hbnvl hii, to
ks ik`l h blinvld hed h invlr. Neiy ketlesl invl ks tol bh
rlihtknesokp wkto tol oniy Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 44/206
Toks ks ent h fhsl nc nppnsktkne cnr tol sh`l nc nppnsktkne. Tn bl dkccl
snmltokea lisl, but tn bl hahkest ks snmltokea hitnaltolr dkcclrlet
kmmhturl ketliilft nc tolsl wrltfold hed hbuskvl plnpil ks tol bhsks nc
hffushtkne hed dkcclrlefls. Qoht hrl tol ikmkts nc oumhe ketliilft> Onw
pnlt nc tol Lhst, ihtl Hiihmho Muohmmhd Kqbhhi, ohs shkd kt,
’ Auzhr Ghh ‟ Hqi Vl Hhhahy `l ylo Ennr
Fokrhhao-l-Rhho Ohk Mhezki Eholle Ohk”
(Zhss nvlr ketliilft blfhusl toks ikaot neiy kiiumkehtls tol phto kt ks e
dlstkehtkne).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 45/206
Qkto tol phsshal nc tkml, oumhe ketliilft ohs htthkeld tn arlht olkaots. Blfhusl
mhrvlis, mhe ks, tndhy ciykea ke tol s`kls ik`l bkrds. Mhe ohs akctld okmslic wkto wkeas
ke h mheelr nc splh`kea, frlhtld mle nc krne (rnbnts) won wnr` wkto arlhtlr trhkis,
ketlrlst hed letouskhsm. Enw, oks vnkfl ohs htthkeld sufo vniuml toht h mhe splh`k
Enrto Znil fhe bl olhrd ht tol Vnuto Znil….. Mhe‛s mnst wnedrnus hfoklvlmlet
sorke`kea nc dksthefls. Mhe ohs sonrtleld tol wnrid, crnm lhst tn wlst hed enrto tn s
dnls brlh`chst ke tol lhst hed th`l oks mkddhy mlhi ke tol wlst. But lvle tndhy, wkt
pnwlr hed swhy onw olipilss hed pnwlrilss ol ks, onw ikmktld, hed keskaekckfhet>
wkpld nut lpkdlmkfs crnm tol chfl nc tol lhrto, but ks stkii pnwlrilss nvlr dlhto. O
subduld tol ehturl but ks stkii uehbil tn fnetrni tol dksturbhefls nc stnrms, typonn
vnifhenls.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 46/206
Ikcl hed dlhto hed toks systlm nc tol uekvlrsl hrl blyned mhe‛s ketliilftuhi arhsp. Hi
ohs, nc fnursl lednwld mhe wkto ketliilft but ent tn he ueikmktld nr uefnuethbil lxtle
ohvl frnssld tolkr ikmkts toly `llp alttkea mnrl letheaild. Tol lyls fhe sll neiy hs muf
fnetrni. Tol mked fhe toke` neiy hs mufo hs kt fhe blhr blyned toht tol vlkes wnu
Ketliilft ks ent tol dlstkehtkne. Ohd kt blle sn tole hctlr phsskea nc tonusheds nc alelr
wnuid ohvl rlhfold snml dlstkehtkne. Ketliilft fhe neiy bl tol why kt fhe elvlr bl tol dtol pnlt ohs shkd,
’ Vohhyld ‟ \shy ‟ isoq Boll Eh Vhmgol
Gks @hrb Mhye ‟ Hqi Mubtkihh Ohk ”
(Zlrohps lvle invl fheent uedlrsthed tol heaukso wokfo ketliilft uedlranls
Ketliilft must uedlran heaukso, cnr ketliilft ks wnrtoilss. Kt blakes tn phet hctlr uerlvlhik
dnnr (sthals).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 47/206
’ Ksoq sl On Ghh‛l Mum`ke Ohk Qhahreho
@lyh Muqhhm - l - Musthch Ohk Chksiho DusoOhk.‛‛(Kt ks pnsskbil tn dn sn tornuao neiy invl, ntolrwketliilft kt ks dkcckfuit tn dltlrmkel tol sthtkne nc B
Musthchh (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) .
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 48/206
H Mu‛mke‛s Kllmhhe tlhfols okm tol ilssne nc invl herlsplft, hed wole kt ks h qulstkne nc invl kt ks kesnilefl
tn inn` (bhdiy) tnwhrds tol blinvld woht tn splh` nc pnkeckealr ht okm. Aletilmhe, kt ks h mhttlr nc tnthi nbldklefoumkikty. Crkled, tol sthtkne nc okm, won ks ent neiy nur bl
but ks hisn tol blinvld nc Hiihho Vubohhehou Okmslic, snmltokea vlry splfkhi. Onw lxfliilet, kedlld, ks toht sth
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 49/206
Invl ks h dlstkehtkne by ktslic. Invl ks tol lxfliilefl nc mhe hed toks
ik`l h mkrhal kecrnet nc h invlr. Tol invlr ks h uekvlrsl wktoke okmslic. I
rlhikty kt ks tol dlstkehtkne hed tol likxkr nc ikcl hed ltlrekty. Ketliilf
blakeekea, invl ks tol uitkmhtl. Ketliilft ks h bhy onrsl, invl ks quhikty. K
he httrkbutl nc mhe, invl ks tol fuimkehtkea pnket, Ketliilft ks dnubt,flrthkety. Tolrlcnrl, ketliilft ks snmltkml dlekhi snmltkmls hcckrmhtkn
hcckrmhtkne tornuao hed tornuao. Ketliilft ks h drlhm, invl ks kts ketlrpr
Ketliilft ks h mkrhal tole invl ks tol rlhikty, (Ketliilft dnls ent mlhe ke
sihedlr, hffushtkne nr hbusl).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 50/206
Hs` Ohzrht Bhhyhzlld Bksthhmk
(Mhy Hiihho ohvl mlrfy ne okm) hbnut tol sthtus nc invl. Kt ks shk’Oks snui `lpt ciykea ke tol wnrid nc snuis cnr 1: tonushed ylhrs he
shykea toks neiy toht tol ikmkts nc tol arhedlur nc tol oniy Zrnp
Musthchh
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) fheent bl `enwe.”
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 51/206
Ql tol invlrs rlfnaekzl hed hf`enwildal tol Mhstlr nc tol oniy f
Mhdkeho ent tornuao ketliilft but wkto invl. Chkto ks invl. Hffushtkn
dkcclrlefls hrl tol prndufts nc ketliilft. Invl dnls ent blohvl ik`l tok
tnthi nbldklefl hed harllmlet. Invl dnls ent toke`, kt slls. Kt n
wktelssls tol ainry hed tol blhuty nc tol blinvld. Kt olhrs tol fnm
hed bnws kts olhd. Kt ks chsfkehtld by lvlry hft nc tol blinvld. Kt ks h
kts blinvld‛s lxkstlefl, kts sohdnw hed kts rlcilftkne…
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 52/206
Tol ihst Mlsslealr slet tn toks lhrto by Himkaoty Hiihho ks nur Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Ol ks tol Zrnpolt nc mle, healis, gkees, onurkls hed
aokimhhe. Ol ks tol Zrnpolt nc mnuethkes hed nc dhils, nc cinwlrs hed
nc ilhvls, nc trlls hed nc stnels, nc phrtkfils hed nc drnps, nc whtlr hed
nc lhrto. Tol Trul Frlhtnr Okmslic sleds Durnnd hed Vhihhm
(shiuthtkne) ne okm, swlhrs by oks inf`s hed oks chfl, hed fhiis nbldklefl
tn okm hs nbldklefl tn Okmslic hed hiilakhefl tn okm hs hiilakhefl tn
Okmslic. Fhiis oks ohed hs Oks nwe ohed hed cniinwkea okm hs Oks
ohppkelss, akvls tol annd elws nc Zhrhdksl tn oks sihvls hed whres
tonsl won dley okm wkto tol tnrturls nc Olii.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 53/206
Ne tol ntolr ohed, tol clhturl nc Dlnbhedk ks uerlstrhkeld ketliilft. Toly shy,
nr tol hmnuet nc `enwildal nc tol ueslle wokfo tol Zrnpolt nc Hiihho (Vhiih
‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) ohs tol hekmhis hisn ohvl ik l toks.” (Mhy Hiihho prntl
Tonsl won hrl fneflreld wkto neiy ketliilft tolsl fnmphrksnes hed fnmpltktkne
tolm. He kevkthtkne nc invl ks tol mlsshal nc toks dust crnm uedlr tol cllt nc tolnc tol Zrnpolt. Onw fhe lquhikty bltwlle tol Zrnpolt hed oks cniinwlrs bl hfflp
tol sthedhrds slt by tol ketliilft ktslic dnls ent tnilrhtl lquhikty bltwlle he Kaen
h `enwildalhbil. Tol cniinwlrs hrl oumhe hed tol Zrnpolt ks hisn h oumhe b
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ks sufo h oumhe won ks kefnmphrhbi
uekqul hed nutsthedkea crnm hii ntolrs. Enbndy ks lquhi tn okm, enr ks heynel lq
sthtus.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 54/206
Tol Frlhtnr Okmslic shys hbnut my Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ), ’Ol dnls ent l
oks ikps wkto oks nwe dlskrl, oks ikps mnvl neiy wole h rlvlihtkne ( Qho‛y) crnm Ml dlsfleds
Tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) wkto oks nwe trutocui tneaul okmslic shys, ’K
ynu (Iustu Mksiu`um ).”
Qole kt ks shkd ke Xur‛hhe , N Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) shy kt, ’Ke hpplhrh
oumhe sohpl ik`l ynu.” Kc toks symbnikf lxprlsskne mlhes lquhi neiy hs h oumhe tole tol Zrsonuid hisn bl dlekld blfhusl hii tol quhiktkls, lxfliilefls, dkstkeftknes hed onenr elldld c
rlvlihtknes ks ent tol quhikty nc lvlry oumhe. Vkmkihriy, mhey ketliilftuhi hsslssmlets fhe bl
truto nc toks Xur‛hhekf phsshal ks toks (hctlr sllkea hed olhrkea prnpolts‛ lxfliilefls hed
ik`l tol Forkstkhes, wl wnuid ent fneskdlr tol Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) hs
Hiihho (And).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 55/206
K whet tn qulstkne tolsl plnpil wkto ketliilft hed slesls kc toly keskst ne
lquhikty wkto tol Zrnpolt tole toly sonuid sonw ke tolmslivls ht ilhst nel
aikmpsl nc tol oumhe trhkts nc Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Ke my chkto kt ks
fneskdlrld kesnilefl hed keckdlikty tn fihkm lquhikty wkto tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vh
Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) nr tn fhii tol Zrnpolt h mlrl oumhe. Tol Oniy Xur‛hhe ktslic
tliis us, kt ks tol why nc keckdlis tn fhii tol Zrnpolt h mhe ik`l nurslivls. Tolrl
ks en sufo fnmmhed ke tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Ohdlls toht tol plnpil nc chkto
sonuid fhii tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) h mhe ik`l tolmslivls kestlhd kt k
vlry filhriy shkd ke tol Xur‛hhe toht wl sonuid elvlr hddrlss tol Zrn polt to
shml why hs wl hddrlss nel hentolr.
Tol dnnrs nc toks chqllr (slrvhet) hrl nple cnr hii
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 56/206
c c q ( ) p c
tonsl won hctlr rlhdkea toks bnn`ilt cked snmltokea,
wokfo ellds tn bl lxpihkeld. Rlclrlefl nc lvlry bnn`
hed tlstkmney cnr lvlry rlclrlefl ohs blle akvle.
Tolsl bnn`s hrl alelrhiiy hvhkihbil. Kt ks ent tol whync h Mu ‟mke tn sihedlr nr chisliy hffusl snmlnel. Ql
hii ohvl tn an tn tol mllzhhe (sfhils) nel dhy. Kc ynu
`llp toks ke mked tole hii ynur gudamlets' wkii bl ne
tol bhsks nc lqukty hed gustkfl. Ntolrwksl onw chr
hwhy hrl tol sthals nc arhvl…..>
@hu`hb-l-Ennrhek Rh Homhd Vohcll(Mhy Muohmmhd (VhiihiIhhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) Bl tol ketlrflssnr
ne blohic nc @hu`hb Ennrhek) N`hrvk (Aouckrh Ihou)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 57/206
Tolsl dhys, mhey plnpil ohvl blfnml slic-hppnketld mnenpniksts nc chkto hed Ksihhm lv
tolkr ‟ Hqhhkd (hrtkfils nc chkto) hrl ent fnrrlft ht hii. Hitonuao ke tol Oniy Xur‛hhe toly oh
vlry wlii toht tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohd fhiild nut tol ehmls
plnpil won ohd rlfktld tol @hikmho hed hisn ncclrld tolkr Ehmhhz, hed nrdlrld tolm tn b
crnm oks mhsgkd (mnsqul). Tol Xur‛hhe hed Hohhdlls ohvl fhiild sufo plnpil oypnfrktls (M
Himkaoty Hiihho ohs splfkckfhiiy shkd hbnut tolm,
’ Qh Mkehe-Ehhsk Mhkle-[hqnniu Hhmhe-ehh Bki Ihhok Qh Bki [humki Hh`okrk
Oum Bk Mu‛mkelle.”(Vnnrho Bhqhrho, Hhyht ?)
(Tonsl plnpil won shy toht wl bliklvl ke tol Himkaoty Hiihho hed tol Dnnmsdhy toly h
hii Mu‛mkes ).
Hed Ol ohs hisn lxpihkeld woy toks ks sn, ’Cll Xuinnbkokm Mhrhdue”(’Tolrl ks h dkslhsl ke tolkr olhrts.”)
Toks rlclrrld dkslhsl ks surliy ent phipkthtkne n
fnedktkne nc tol olhrtblht. Tol dkslhsl ks to
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 58/206
fnedktkne nc tol olhrtblht. Tol dkslhsl ks to
kdlninay, wokfo ks bliklc, kt whs ent rkaot. Hff
Hiihho‛s vlrdkft toly hrl ent Mu‛mke (bliklvl
tonuao toly ohvl rlfktld tol @hikmho hed nccl
Qole wl shy tol dkslhsl ks ke tolkr olhrts wl mik`l Kllmhhe rlskdls ke nels olhrt skmkihriy tol
keckdlis hed oypnfrksy nc tol oypnfrktls ks hisn
tol olhrt. Toks lxpihkes toht bliklc ks tol ehm
bliklvl lmblddld ke nur olhrts hed Hiihho‛
(Slrsls) filhriy kedkfhtls toht tonsl wonsl bli
fnrrlft en mhttlr onw rlauihr hed ckrm toly mshykea tolkr Ehmhhz hed ` llpkea tol Vhum
elvlr bl Mu‟mke.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 59/206
Ht toks sthal iktlrhtl mle hed wnmle splfkhiiy tol ynutos alt vlry crustrhtld hs t
mhey chftknes hmneast tol Musikms hed lhfo chftkne trkls tn prnvl ktslic tn bl rkao
bhsks nc tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht hed fhiis tolkr nppnelets tn bl wrnea. Tol
(sfonihrs) nc lhfo chftkne rlhd tol Xur‛hhe hed Hohhdlls toly hrl fnmmkttld tn
hed Rnzho (chstkea) hed ohvl lpt blhrds hed sllm tn bl vlry enwildalhbil kebrhzkea hraumlets ke chvnr nc tolkr nwe sthedpnket. Ql tol ikstlelrs hed tol rlhd
sonuid wl fneskdlr rkaot hed wonm tn bl wrnea. Tolrlcnrl, hs h rlsuit nc toks fne
toly ohvl stnppld ikstlekea tn Mhuivlls hed ankea tn tol mhshhgkd.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 60/206
Qkto tol clhr nc Himkaoty Hiihho onelstiy ilt ml rlpiy tn toks tolrl ks en dnubt toht yn
dksturbld ht tol fnetrhdkftnry sthtlmlets nc tol alelrhi Mhuivlls. Alelrhiiy plnpil h
hwhrl nc tol rlikaknus `enwildal sn toly fheent rlfnaekzl tol truto hed tol chisl, tol rk
wrnea hed toly hrl ent hwhrl nc tol rlhi chfts sn toly alt vlry crustrhtld. Ke toks sktuhtkn
hrl wrnea blfhusl hinea wkto tol wnridiy enwildal toly dne‛t hfqukrl rlikaknus en
ilhre tol truto wkto httletkne hed ketlrlst. Hed tonsl won fhii tolmslivls Mhuivlls toly
rlhi truto tn plnpil hed dne‛t cuickii tolkr rlikaknus rlspneskbkiktkls hed nbikahtknes fnmp
onelsty hed trutocuielss. Toly ohvl plrohps cnranttle toht nel dhy hii nc us ohvl tn dlp
mnrthi wnrid hed an ketn tol dhr` hed drlhry arhvls. Hed ne tol Dhy nc Gudamlet wl o
hffnuet nc nur bliklcs hed hfts blcnrl Himkaoty Hiihho. Zlrohps toly ohvl hisn cnranttle t
tn dlflkvl plnpil by prlsletkea wrnea hs rkaot, but kt ks kmpnsskbil tn prlslet wrnea hs rka
Hiihho Thh‛ihh. Tolsl plnpil sonuid rlmlmblr toht toly wkii bl mnrl hffnuethbil tole n
bl mnrl ikhbil tn an tn Olii hed succlr Dkvkel tnrmlet cnr tlhfokea wrnea bliklcs he
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 61/206
Dlhr rlhdlrs, woht ks trhesarlsskne (Wuim )> Qoht ks fhiild trhesa
Qoht ks tol kdletkckfhtkne nc trhesarlsskne> ’Qhd‛uso-Vohkl‛k Cll Aohk
ikok ,” puttkea h tokea ht h wrnea pihfl. Ke skmpil wnrds shy kt ik l toks
fnmmkttld by ’H” hed tol pueksomlet ks akvle tn ’B.” Bihmkea snmlne
snmlnel lisl‛s wnr`. Fhiikea rkaot hs wrnea hed wrnea hs rkaot. Fohea
Thh‛ihh‛s wnrds hed fnmmheds ht nel‛s nwe dlskrls foheakea kts mlh
hddkea nr subtrhftkea. Tn hppiy he Hhyht ne snmlbndy lisl kestlhd nc
wonm kt ks ketledld hed dlsfrkbl kt cnr snmlnel lisl, toks ks
trhesarlsskne hed h plrsne dnkea sn ks h trhesarlss nr.
Tolrl ks h bilssld
Ohdlls
wrkttle ke
Bu`ohhrk
Vohrllc
Vhkyykd
Ihho
(
Rhdkyhi
Ihhou
‟Heou)
, sne nc
Ohzrht
Vhkyykdkeh
‟\mhr
Chhrnnq
(
Rhd
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 62/206
Ihho ( Rhdkyhi Ihhou Heou) , sne nc Ohzrht Vhkyykdkeh \mhr Chhrnnq ( Rhd
shys, ’Tol wnrst hmnea tol frlhtknes nc Hiihho hrl tonsl won
Musikms Hhyhht dlsfledkea hbnut tol keckdlis hed tol hpnst
( Bu`ohhrk , Za8:24, Sni -2)
Toks whs tol prhftkfl nc tol @ohwhhrkg (slphrhtkst crnm Ksihhm) hed tol oypnfrktls durkea
Fnmpheknes nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Tndhy toks ks hisn tol prhftkfl nc oue
fhiild Muiihhs. Toly hppiy Hhyhht dlsfledld cnr tol kdnis hed tol hpnsthtls tn tol Zrnpolt
Hiihho, hed tol chktocui. Ikstlelrs hed rlhdlrs dn ent enw tol nffhskne wole hed cnr wonm
dlsfledld> Toly olhr sufo Hhyhht crnm tonsl fhiikea tolmslivls Mhuivlls hed hrl mksild
nwe kaenrhefl. Toly sonuid bl rlhiiy pktkld won fhii tolmslivls Mhuivlls hed fneskdlrhutonrktkls ne rlikakne but by chbrkfhtkea tol fnrrlft `enwildal toly fnmmkt sufo slrknus
mksilhd tol plnpil. Ohzrht ‟Hbdui -Ihho Kbel \mhr (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟Heou) ohs fnuetld sufo plnpil
@ohwhhrkg. Hffnrdkea tn okm, tolsl hrl tol wnrst nc tol frlhtknes hmnea tol plnpil won k
hfts hed cniinw tol @ohwhhrkg (olrltkf).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 63/206
K hpplhi tn tonsl ynutos nc tol Musikm \m-mho won hrl dksthefkea tolmslivls
spkrktuhikty hed tol spkrkt nc Ksihhm blfhusl nc tol enesleskfhi uttlrhefls by tolsl M
Hiihho Th‛hhihh ohs bilssld ynu wkto rnbust fnmmneslesl ynu sonuid toke` hed
ynurslivls. Zlrohps, ynu hrl uedlr tol kmprlsskne toht tol wonil fnetrnvlrsy ks hb
dkvkskne nc inhvls hed cksols. Toks ks hbsniutliy wrnea. Toks ruil sonuid bl `lpt ke vkl
tokea ks enwe by kts nppnsktl Tu‛ rhcui Hsoyhh‛u Bk Hzdhhdkoh. Ekaot tliis us hbnut
cnui smlii tliis hbnut tol rlhikty nc crharhefl, hed tol Dlle-sliikea Muiihhs mh`l us
tol prlslefl nc ‟ \ihmhh-k-Ohq (rkaot-aukdld sfonihrs). Fhe ynu fneskdlr tol truto
chisl hik l> Ent ht hii, sn ynu sonuid uedlrsthed toht toks ks tol rlhi fnetrnvlr
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 64/206
[nu surliy whet tn `enw woht tol truto ks hed woht ks chisl> Qon ks rkaot hed won ks wrnearkaot-aukdld '\ihmh hed wokfo hrl tol chisl arnup> Ke hii onelsty, wkto clhr nc Hiihho hed cu
toks slrvhet nc Dlle hed mki-iht submkts blcnrl ynu tol cniinwkea. Zilhsl phy httl
Hmllr-ui-Mu‛mkelle Vhkyykdkeh '\mhr Chhrnnq (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟ Heou) ohs shkd, ’To
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs kecnrmld us hbnut tol blakeekea nc tol frlhtkne tn tol le
Zhrhdksl by tol plnpil nc Zhrhdksl hed tol letlrkea ketn Olii by tol plnpil nc Olii." (Bu`ohhrk V
vni-8). Toks bilssld Ohdlls tliis us toht tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) en dn
arhfl nc Hiihho Th‛hhihh `enwildal nc hii tokeas crnm tol blakeekea tn tol led. Tolrlcnrl, tol o(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) shkd, "My \m-mht wkii bl dkvkdld ketn 16 chftknes, nel nc toks w
hed 12 wkii an tn Olii." Tol Fnmpheknes nc tol Zrnpolt (Rkdwhheui Ihhok Th‛hhihh ‟ Hihklokm Hgm
Zrnpolt nc Hiihho! (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) wokfo nel wkii bl toht shivhtld arnup> Tol
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) shkd, "Kt wnuid bl tol Ehhgkyho arnup, wokfo wnuid cniinw my
nc my fnmpheknes." (Tkrmkzll, Hbu Dhhwnnd, Kbel Mhhgho).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 65/206
Rlhdlrs mhy, plrohps, shy toht dlspktl toks filhr shykea nc tol
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) lvlry arnup fhiis ktslic Ehhgkyho. Ke rlp
ml shy toht en fihkmhet fhe bl trutocui hbnut oks fihkm ueilss ol prn
vhikd hraumlets ke suppnrt tn oks fihkm hed ueilss ol prnvls tol trut
fihkm tornuao tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht. Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou
Vhiihm) ohs fihrkckld toht tol Ehhgkyho arnup wnuid bl tol ihralst hedenbilst arnup) hed ohs urald us tn hssnfkhtl wkto kt hed ohs hisn tn
hbnut kts skaes, kt wnuid bl cniinwkea oks why hed tol why nc oks fnmp
(Rhdkyhi Ihhou Th‛hhihh ‟ Heoum).
‟ HOIL V\EEHT QH GHMHH‛
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 66/206
Ne tol bhsks nc tolsl shykeas nc tol oniy
Zrnpolt (‛ Hihh Vhhokbhohs-Vhihhtu Qhs-Vhihhm) , tol Ehhgkyho
arnup ks tktild hs ‟ Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht ',
nr ke nel wnrd,
’ Vue-ell” (mlhekea toks ks tol arnup wonslbliklcs hed hfts hrl hffnrdkea tn tol whys nc
tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) hed nc oks
fnmpheknes
(Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟ Heoum).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 67/206
[nu sonuid enw try tn uedlrsthed tol sthtl nc hcchkrs wkto tol Ehhgkyho arnup. Zihf
ketn kts rnnt ks tol spkrkt nc Ksihhm, chkto, aukdhefl hed mlrfy, hed sn hii tol brhefol
sprnutkea crnm toks nel annd rnnt ohvl tol shml lcclft hs tol rnnt ktslic. Ilt ml
lxpihke kt curtolr. Hii cnur nc tol frllds (mhzhhokb) nc Vohrll'ht (Ohehcl
Vohhck'll, Mhhik`ll hed Ohembhill) hed tolkr curtolr brhefols
Hso‛hrll , Mhhturlldll hed skmkihriy tol cnur nrdlrs nc Thrllqht
(spkrktuhi nrdlrs nc Ksihhm) Ehqsobhedll, Xhhdkrll, Foksotll hed
Vuohrhwhrdll hed tolkr curtolr brhefols, Vhhbkrll, Ekzhhmll,
Hsorhcll, Vohhzill, Rkchh'll, Mughd-dkdll ltf. Hii nc tolsl blinea tn tol
Hoil Vueeht ,” Ehhgkyho arnup. Hii nc tolsl ohvl neiy nel rnnt hed nel
cnuedhtkne hed tolrl ks en cuedhmlethi
dkcclrlefl hmnea tolm rlahrdkea keckdlikty hed Kllmhhe.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 68/206
Toks fohrhftlrkstkf ks neiy lxfiuskvl tn Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht toht hii to
ohvl lxfliilet ohrmney ke tolkr bliklcs hed vklws. Hed tolkr dllds hed blikl
ke sufflsskne. Tonsl chftknes hsslrtkea tolmslivls hs Hoil Vueeht, kc toly f
fihkm fnrrlft hed trul tole toly sonuid filhriy prnvl wktoke tolmslivls tol
hed dnkea nc tol Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht ntolrwksl tolkr fihkm wkii bl chis
Vueeht hed tn bl fhiild Hoil Vueeht hrl twn slphrhtl tokeas. Fhiikea nel
Vueeht by h arnup nr h chftkne nc plnpil ks ent he lenuao lvkdlefl nc kts
Vueeht. Rlmlmblr toht tolrl ks en arnup ntolr tohe tol trul Hoil Vueeht
wokfo fhe fnmpiltliy prnvl kts trutocuielss tornuao tol Xur‛hhe hed tol
prnvl tolkr bliklcs hed hfts lxhftiy ke hffnrdhefl wkto tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhi
Vhiihm) hed oks fnmpheknes (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟ Heoum).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 69/206
Lvle hctlr tol ihpsl nc 84:: ylhrs, fnetkeuhefl nc bliklcs hed hfts n
Vueeht Qh Ghmhh‛ht ke fnmpiltl hffnrdhefl wkto tol Xur‛hhe hed tol
prnvld, wokil hii ntolr chftknes hrl elwiy frlhtld hed hii tolkr bliklcs,hfts hed fnedktknes hrl ent dlrkvld crnm tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeh
chftknes ohvl fnetrkbutld tn tolkr nwe dlvkhtkne hed rukehtkne by dkst
rlhi mlhekea nc tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 70/206
Kt ks ent tolsl plnpil's sohrl tn ohvl aukdhefl hed mlrfy, tolkr sohrl ksinss ke toks wnrid hed ke tol Olrlhctlr. Tol ihralst arnup nc tol Hoil-V
( Ehhgkyho arnup) ohvl blle akvle tol annd elws hed surlty nc ml
bilsskea, suppnrt hed vkftnry ne tolm nc Hiihho ne hffnuet nc tolkr
sihvls hed trul cniinwlrs tn tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) he
fnmpheknes (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟ Heoum) ke toks wnrid hed olrlhctlr . Kt ks tolsl won
blle aukdld ke tol rkaot phto, hed kt ks kefumblet upne us tn rlmhke whssnfkhtld wkto tolm. . Tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok chftkne, hmn
elw lmlrakea arnups nc tol \m-mht hrl tonsl won ent neiy wkso tn bl
’ Hoil Vueeht ” (Vue-ell) but hrl hisn leahald ke alttkea hii tol ntolr ch
blskdl tolmslivls dlfihrld hs hpnsthtl, keenvhtkvl hed chisl.
Xur‛hhe & tol Rlsplft cnr tol
Blinvld
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 71/206
Blinvld…(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
Fnmmhed ke tol Oniy Xur‛hhe ….ks Qhtu'hz-zkrnnou Qhtu Qhq-qkrnno
(" Vonw rlsplft tn okm hed vlelrhtl okm").
Ke tol hrrhealmlet nc tol Xur‛hhe , wolrl tol wnrds, [hh Hkly
[uohi Ihzlleh Hhmhenn (n ynu won bliklvl), ckrst nffur, tol
ckrst fnmmhed wokfo ks akvle tn mle nc Chkto ks toks toly sonuid
sonw utmnst rlsplft tn tol My Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
lvle wokil hddrlsskea okm, hed must ent fhii okm (Ihh Thqnnin
rhh‛kehh ) mh`l fneflssknes tn us, but shy tn okm (Qh Xnniue
zurehh) pilhsl ohvl `ked aihefl ne us. (Vnnrho-l-Bhqhrho,
Hhyht 8:4). (Zilhsl ohvl `ked lyls upne us.)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 72/206
Hiihho dkd ent lvle ik`l h wnrd tn bl usld cnr oks bilssld Zrnp
‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) wokfo fnuid bl, neiy wkto h sikaot foheal ke snued, mksth`
snmltokea dkcclrlet. Toks wnrd whs, tolrlcnrl, dlfihrld dksrlsplftcui h
hed kts usl whs prnokbktld. Vn, tonsl filhriy wrnea wnrds wokfo hrl
kmprnplr ke hey why onw tolkr usl fnuid bl hpprnprkhtl cnr tol oniy Zrn
‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)! Tol rlsplft nc wonsl fnurt tol Trul Frlhtnr Okmslic tlhfo
tolsl wnrds nc ynurs hrl mnst dksarhflcui. Hphrt crnm keckdli lxprlsskn
ynu ohvl usld skmkils ynu ohvl hisn usld tolm kmprnplriy
Rlhdlrs wnuid hisn surliy ik`l tn `enw won hrl
tolsl plnpil, won ohvl wrkttle hed shkd sufo
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 73/206
tolsl plnpil, won ohvl wrkttle hed shkd sufo
bihspolmkf wrktkeas>
Tolsl plnpil won bliklvl toht lvle Hiihho dnls ent ohvl hey prknr `enwwole h plrsne dnls snmltokea tole Hiihho `enws hbnut kt. …Vohkthhe's `enwil
arlhtlr tohe tol `enwildal nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhii
Tolsl plnpil wonsl bliklc ks toht Hiihho fhe splh` ikls. Tolsl plnpil won b
tol oniy Zrnpolt ks he nrdkehry mhe ik`l us. Tolsl plnpil won bliklvl tol hmn
hed tol `ked nc `enwildal nc tol ueslle wokfo tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihh
‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs ks tol shml ked nc `enwildal pnsslssld by hekmhis,
plnpil hed kechets. Hed tol bkrto nc h prnpolt ks pnsskbil hctlr tol oniy Zrnp
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Tolsl plnpil won dn ent pnsslss hey invl
fnurt nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) onw wkii toly phs
blelckt tn ntolrs> (Hiihho @hrllm cnrakvl us crnm sufo tonuaots!)
Qkii ynu hfflpt sufo wrktkea cnr Tohevk Vhhokb nr cnr ynur chtolr, tol fnu
Zrlskdlet, ynur tlhfolr, nr hey rlsplfthbil plrsne> Gust rlcilft .!!!
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 74/206
Rlhdlrs wnuid hisn surliy ik`l tn `enw won hrl tolsl plnpil, won ohvl wrkttle h
bihspolmkf wrktkeas> [nu ohvl hirlhdy slle tol ehml nc tol bnn` hed tol phal eu
wrktkea. Vll blinw, hinea wkto tol tktils nc tol bnn`s rlhd tol ehmls nc tolkr huto
bnn`s crnm wokfo hii tolsl wrktkeas hrl fnpkld tolkr ehmls hed tolkr hutonrs ehm
blinw.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----
*Tol dlthkis nc tol lxhft tlxt nc tolsl cnrty sthtlmlets nc tolsl Dlnbhedk, Qhohh
tolkr nwe chthhwhs ne tolm sll my bnn`, ’Qoktl hed Bihf`.”
@hu`hb Ennrhek .
Rlhd wlii hed rlfnaekzl tol kesuits ne Himkaoty Hiiho hed Oks Blinvld Oniy Zrnpo
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ).
BLIKLCV NC TOL
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 75/206
DLNBHEDK QHOHH
THBILLAOK
ARN\Z…
4: Rlclrlefls crnm tol
Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy…
8. Hiihho Th'hhihh fhe tlii ikl.
(Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, vni. 8, pa 8;)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 76/206
( y , , pa )
2.Hiihho Th'hhihh dnls ent `enw blcnrlohed woht Oks frlhtknes wnuid
fnmls tn `enw nc tolkr dnkeas neiy hctlr toly ohvl dnel snmlt
(Thcsllr Buiaohtui Ohklrhhe pa 8<1 hed 8<?)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 77/206
(Thcsllr Buiaohtui Ohklrhhe, pa 8<1 hed 8<?)
6. @enwildal nc Vohkthhe PVhthe] hed tol Heali nc dlht
Mhut] ks mnrl tohe tol oniy Zrnpolt
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 78/206
Mhut] ks mnrl tohe tol oniy Zrnpolt
PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm]. PBhrhholle-l-Xhhtk‛h
4. Tol Zrnpolt nc Hiihho ohs en `enwildal nc oks led hed nc toltokeas lvle bloked h whii. (Bhrhholle-l-Xhhtk‛ho , pa <8)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 79/206
<-Tol hmnuet nc `enwildal hed tol `ked nc `enwildal nc tol ueslle w Himkaoty Hiihho tn tol oniy Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm] suf
hisn blle akvle tn hekmhis, iuehtkfs hed fokidrle. POkczui Kllmhh
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 80/206
3.Lvle tol tonuaot nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) nEhmhhz ks mufo wnrsl tohe tn bl kmmlrsld ke tol tonuaot nc he nx n
(Vkrhht-l-Musthqllm, pa ?3)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 81/206
1-Tol wnrd Rhomhtui Iki ‟ Hhihmlle ks ent he lxfiuskvl httrkbutl nc tol onIhhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Blskdl oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Q
shketiy plnpil fhe hisn bl fhiild Rhomhtui Iki ‟ Hhihmlle. (Chthhwh Rhso
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 82/206
82)
?.Tn tol fnmmne plnpil, tol lxprlsskne ’ @ohhtkm-ue-Ehbky-ylle” mlhes tTn tol `enwildalhbil plnpil toks mlhekea ks ent fnrrlft … Lvle kc h Zrnpolt
oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) kt wnuid stkii ohvl en lcclft
tol ckehikty nc Muohmmhd (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) (Thozllrue E
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 83/206
tol ckehikty nc Muohmmhd (Vhiihi Ihhou Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). (Thozllrue-E
;.Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ilhret tol \
wkto tol fneelftkne nc '\ihmh nc Dlnbhed. (Bhrhholle-l-Xhh
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 84/206
8:.Tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) sonuid neiy bl rlsplf
brntolr. (Thqwkyhtui illmhhe, pa <?).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 85/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 86/206
82-Hctlr oks dlhto, tol Oniy Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qmkeaild wkto dust.PAnd P Mh‛hhzhi Ihho summh Mh‛hhz
PThqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, pa <;].
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 87/206
86.Hii Zrnpolts hed Mlsslealrs hrl wnrtoilss. (Thqwkyhtui ill
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 88/206
84-Kt ks ent elflsshry cnr h Zrnpolt tn bl crll hed keenflet crnm lvlPThsckyhtui ‟Hqhh‛kd ], pa 2<]
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 89/206
8<.Zrhksl tol Zrnpolt neiy hs h oumhe blkea hisn dn rlduftkne lvle(Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, pa 6<).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 90/206
83-Tol lidlr Ptol Zrnpolt] hed tol ynuealr Phii ntolr ou
hrl uehwhrl hed cnnikso. Bnn` Thqwkyhtui illmhhe,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 91/206
81.Tol bka frlhtknes, mlhekea tol Zrnpolts, hed tol smhii frlhtknes, mfrlhtknes,
hrl, ke crnet nc tol Arhedlur nc Hiihho, mnrl dksarhfld tohe h fnbbilr. (T
pa 84 )
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 92/206
pa )
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 93/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 94/206
8;.H Zrnpolt onids tol shml sthtus hmneast oks um-mht (cniinwlrs) hs ksfohudohry (olhdmhe) nr h ihedinrd ke h vkiihal. (Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, p
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 95/206
2:. Qonsnlvlr ehmld hs Muohmmhd (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhi
(Rhdk Hiihhou Th‛hhihh Heou) toly ohvl en hutonrkty nvlr heytokea. H Zrnp
Hiihho fhe dn entokea. (Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, pa 48)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 96/206
28. Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs inst o(Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, pa << )
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 97/206
22-H Cniinwlr hpphrletiy lxflis ke dllds tohe tol Zr PZlhfl bl upne], bnn` Thozllr ue-Ehhs, phal <
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 98/206
26.H Dlnbhedk Mui-ihh shvld tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ih
Qh Vhiihm) crnm chiikea ncc Zuiskrhht (tol brkdal nvlr
rkaotlnus
wkii phss ketn Zhrhdksl). (Buiaohtui Ohklrhhe,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 99/206
wkii phss ketn Zhrhdksl). (Buiaohtui Ohklrhhe,
24-Tolrl ks en ohrm ke shykea hed kt ks shtkscykea tn shy Ihh'iihhoh ki-ihi Ihhou Hsorhc ‟Hill Hiihhoum-mh Vhiik 'Hih Vhky-ykdkeh Qh Ehblly-ykeh Hsorhc ‟Hill hed tolrl ks en ohrm ke sh
imdhhd, pa 6<] cnr tol mneto nc Vhchr 8663 H.O, hed prnflldkeas nc h Muehhzkrho Prlikaknu
Curqhhe, vni 6, pa <?)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 100/206
2<-Flilbrhtkea Mllihhd-ue-Ehbll,PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm] Pbkr
Zrnpolt] ks ik`l tol Okedus flilbrhtl tol bkrtodhy nc tolkr @hehkoyh. PChth
Vohrllc, pa ? hed Bhrhholle-l-Xhhtk‛ho , pa 84?].
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 101/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 102/206
23-Tol oniy Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm] hed tol Dhg-ghhi bn
bilssld wkto ikcl. Tol trhkts wokfo fohrhftlrkzl tol oniy Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihh
Vhiihm] hrl hisn sohrld by tol Dhg-ghhi. (Hhbl Ohyhht, pa i3
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 103/206
21.Entokea ohpples ne tol wkso nc tol Zrnpolt (Zlhfl bl upne okm)
Bnn` Thqwkyhtui illmhhe,, phal <3.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 104/206
2?-Bliklvl ke Hiihho hinel, hed dn ent bliklvl ke heynel lxfl
(Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, pa 84)
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 105/206
2;- Blcnrl Hiihho Th'hihh hii tol Hmbkyhh hed Huikyhh hrl keclrknkeskaekckfhet dust wnrtoilss splf`. Zhal-<4-
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 106/206
6:-Kt ks plrmksskbil tn fhii Ehbll tol Zrnpolt Muohmmhd PVhiihi Ihh
Qh Vhiihm ], ynur brntolr, bnn` ’ Bhrhholle-l-Xhhtk'ho”, hed p
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 107/206
68-Tol nel won bliklvls Ehbll hed Qhik hrl oumhe blkea hed A
frlhtkne lvle tole an tn tolm cnr rlclrlefl, olip hed prlslets to
ncclrkeas dlspktl blkea Musikm ks lquhi tn Hbu Ghohi ke @ucr. Rlclr
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 108/206
Bnn` ’ Thqwkyhtui illmhhe ,” phal 1 & 21. Ksmhlli Dloivk
62-Durnnd Thhg ks dkschvnrld hed rlfktkea kt ks ent
plrmkttld. (Chzhh'ki-k-Durnnd Vohrllc, pa 16 hed
Thz`krhtur Rhsolld vni. 2, pa 881).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 109/206
66-Ohzrht 'Hill PRhdkyhi Ihhou 'Heou] wkto oks nwe oheds bhtold he
Dlnbhedks, PVhkyykd Homhd nc Rhhl Bhrlkiiy] hed Ohzrht Chhtkmho PRhdk
olrslic put fintols ne okm. Tol rlclrlefl ks Vkrhht-k-Musthqllm,, Zlrskhe,
phal 2?:.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 110/206
64-Hii tol Mllihhd Vohrllc, Mk'rhhg Vohrllc, Akyhhrovlle Vohrllc, '\rs V
Vohrllc, Vnylm, Foloium, Chhtkoho @ohwhek, hed illshhi-l-Vhwhhb, h
hed chisl keenvhtknes hed tol whys nc tol keckdlis hed Okedus. (Chthhwh
2, Zhal <?, Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, vni 2, phals 844 hed 8<:, hed vni 6,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 111/206
2, Zhal <?, Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, vni 2, phals 844 hed 8<:, hed vni 6,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 112/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 113/206
6<-Tn lht h wlii-`enwe kedkalenus PEhtkvl] frnw ks h rlw
(Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, Sni 2, pa, 86:).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 114/206
63-Tn fhii upne tol crkleds nc Hiihho P Thh‛ihh ] lvle tonuao rlahrdkefrlhtknes ks keckdlikty. PThqwkyhtui Kllmhhe, 1].
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 115/206
61-Kt ks cnrbkddle tn prhy hctlr tol cuelrhi prhylr Tn suppikfhtl prhylrs ks ent plrmkttld.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 116/206
6?-Kt ks plrmkttld tn th`l phrsohhd (tol rlmehets nc cnnd prlsletld tn
nffhskne nc tol Okedu clstkvhis nc Onik hed Dllwhhik.(Chthhwh Rhsolldky
(But tn th`l cnnd dkstrkbutld ne tol nffhskne nc Chhtkoho hed Ekyhhz
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 117/206
6;-Tolrl ks en ohrm ke lhtkea cnnd, kc filhe, prlphrld ht t
fnbbilrs hed swllplrs. PChthhwh Rhsolldkyho, Sni 2,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 118/206
4:-Drke`kea whtlr crnm tol shblli (`kns`) slt up by Okedus (hpnsthtls) nut
lhreld tornuao ketlrlst ks plrmkttld.(Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, Sni 6, pa 88
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 119/206
Hii tol Mllihhd Vohrllc, Mk'rhhg Vohrllc, Akyhhrovlle Vohrllc, '\rs Vo
Vohrllc, Vnylm, Foloium, Chhtkoho @ohwhek, hed illshhi-l-Vhwhhb, h
hed chisl keenvhtknes hed tol whys nc tol keckdlis hed Okedus. (Chthhwh
2, Zhal <?, Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, vni 2, phals 844 hed 8<:, hed vni 6,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 120/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 121/206
O[ZNFRKV[ KE HFTKNE…
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 122/206
O[ZNFRKV[ KE HFTKNE…
Toks ks Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho. K ohvl hirlhdy sonwe ynu tol ckrst twn vniumls, toks ks tol tokrd. Ke 86<8 kt whs prketld ht @utb
Vuelork Mhsgkd Dliok . Kt fnesksts nc tol ldkfts nc Rhsokd Homhd Aheanok ke torll vniumls. Gust inn` ht woht ol shys, snml
plrmksskbil tn httled he \rs ke wokfo neiy tol Oniy Xur‛hhe ks rlfktld hed swllts hrl dkstrkbutld>” Olrl ol mlhet Chhtkoho to
cnr Llshhi l-Vhwhhb hed ke wokfo neiy tol Oniy Xur‛hhe ks rlfktld hed swllts hrl dkstrkbutld, wnuid kt bl plrmksskbil tn httled
Tol heswlr whs , ’Kt ks ent prnplr tn httled hey \rs nr Mllihhd Vohrll c. En `ked nc \rs nr Mllihhd ks prnp
Homhd Aheanok ).”
Mhy K hs` onw kt whs prnplr tn flilbrhtl tol fletlehry nc Dhrui \innm Dlnbhed> K whet tn `enw toks. Hed onw tole ks
fnmmlmnrhtl tol dlmksl nc tol muctks> Ks tolrl h Dlnbhedk muctk wonsl dlhto ks ent fnmmlmnrhtld tndhy> Ke chft, he he pubiksold ke Ghea elwsphplr ne 8:to Hprki rlahrdkea tol Bhrsk nc Mhuiheh Lotksohhm ui Ohq Tohevk . Enw Mllihhd
heekvlrshrkls hrl blkea flilbrhtld hitonuao toly shy ke tolkr prlhfokea hed wrktkea tornuao hed tornua
prnplr. Kt ks blyned uedlrsthedkea woltolr tolkr bliklc PHqlldho] ks trul nr tolkr prhftkfls PHmhi].Vn ks k
PChtwhh ] toht ks chuity, nr tol prhftkfl> K fhe‛t uedlrsthed onw toly fhe shy nel tokea hed dn gust tol
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 123/206
Ol lvle anls sn chr hs tn dlfihrl hs Ohrhhm P Cnrbkddle]tol vksktkea nc arhvls ne toldhy nc \rs. Toks ks onw chr ol ohs anel. Ol ohs hisn hahke hed hahke rlglftld kt ke ntolr
bnn`s nc oks. (Mllihd-l-Chtkohh, phal 8<:). Kt hisn mletknes rlhdkea nc tol Xur‛hhe by
tol arhvl, rlfktkea tol @hikmh, Vnylm, ltf., hed dlfihrls tolm hs uehfflpthbil ke hey
fkrfumsthefls. Tllgh, Dhswhe, ohvl hii blle filhriy dlfihrld hs mksaukdld keenvhtknes.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 124/206
Tn rlfktl Ch‛tkohh ne cnnd nr swllts ks h mksaukdld keenvhtkne, kt ks filhriy wrkttle.
Mllihhd ks ueihwcui ke lvlry why. Tous ol ks rlglftkea tol rlfktkea nc Ch‛tkohh —wonsl
purpnsl ks Llshhi -l-Vhwhhb, woltolr kt ks ne tol tokrd, slvleto nr tleto dhy hctlr h
plrsne‛s dlhto. Toly dlfihrl kt snmltkmls hs ueihwcui, snmltkmls hs mksaukdld
keenvhtkne hed snmltokea toht ilhds tn lrrnr hed mksaukdhefl, hed snmltkmls kt ks
fhiild Ohrhhm, ltf. Hed tol strheal tokea ks toht tolsl plnpil tolmslivls prhftkfl hii
tolsl tokeas hed ohvl en quhims ke lhtkea tol cnnd ne tolsl nffhsknes.
Vn toks ks woht K whet tn hs` tolm, hed tn kecnrm ynu, toht hahke hed hahke
toly dlfihrl snmltokea tn bl ueihwcui, but tole prhftkfl kt0 sn wokfo kswrnea, woht toly ohvl wrkttle nr woht toly prhftkfl> Nel sonuid hs` tolm
toht kc toly onid kt tn bl Ohrhhm , tole woy dn toly lht Ohrhhm>
Mllihhd ks ent ht hii plrmksskbil, mlhes Tllghho nr Dhswhhe hrl ent rlfnmmledld tonuao
tolsl hrl gust ehmls nc tol dhys wole tol prhylr ks olid cnr tol dlflhsld plrsne. Toly hrl ent
hiinwkea hey nc tonsl fhiikea tolm Bkdhht l Whihhihh nr uechkr. Bkdhht l Whihhihh mlhes
snmltokea elw toht wnuid ilhd nel hstrhy. Lvle ht pihfls toly wrktl tolsl tokeas ohrhhm hed
snmltokea lisl. Vtrheal tokea ks toly hrl dnkea tolsl tokeas hed lht hii tonsl tokeas tnn. K whet
tn hs` crnm tolm hed tlii ynu hs wlii toht toly hrl cnrbkddkea kt enw hed tole hed dnkea kt tnn
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 125/206
tn hs` crnm tolm hed tlii ynu hs wlii toht toly hrl cnrbkddkea kt enw hed tole hed dnkea kt tnn.
Dne‛t `enw woltolr tolkr hftknes hrl rkaot nr shykeas>> Kc kts ohrhhm tole woy dn toly lht
ohrhhm.
Kt sonuid bl entld toht tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok plnpil won dlfihrl toht flilbrhtkea
Mllihhd Pbkrto] nc tol oniy Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm] hs h wrnea, ueihwcui hed
cnrbkddle hft nc hpnsthsy, must bl qulstkneld onw ks kt plrmksskbil hed rkaot tn flilbrhtl
tol cnuedhtkne-dhy nc tol Dhhrui '\innm, Dlnbhed, hed tn fhii upne he hpnsthtl
wnmle tn kehuaurhtl kt, tn flilbrhtl tol dhys hed tol dlhto heekvlrshrkls nc tolkr
Muiihhs hed tolkr Mu ctlls, tn hppnket tol tkml, tol dhtl hed tol pihfl nc sufo
ahtolrkeas, tn onid pniktkfhi hed ene-pniktkfhi dlmnestrhtknes, tn lsthbikso kestktutkneske tol ehml nc ene-Hiihho, tn hs` cnr ckehefkhi hed ntolr `keds nc olip cnr tol
prnphahtkne nc ene-Hiihho onw fhe toks bl fnrrlft hed prnokbktld>
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 126/206
4:-Drke`kea whtlr crnm tol shblli (`kns`) slt up by Okedus (hpnsthtls) nut
lhreld tornuao ketlrlst ks plrmkttld.(Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, Sni 6, pa 88
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 127/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 128/206
Ql ohvl hirlhdy slle h rlclrlefl cnrm Chthhwh Rhsolldkyho, vniuml torll. Olrl ks hento
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 129/206
ohvl wkto ml ks nid hed dkihpkdhtld. But toks tlxt fhe bl filhriy slle. [nu sll toht toly‛vl
ihwcui tol lhtkea nc cnnd fnn`ld by mlekhi wnr`lrs, hed tol cnnd slrvld ne Onik hed Dlwhh
shy olrl> Xulstkne7 Dlsfrkbkea tol lvlets nc tol mhrtyrdnm ne tol tleto dhy nc Muohrrhm …
dkstrkbutl crll cnnd, hed akvkea fohrkty, hed ncclrkea swllt whtlr hed mki` tn fokidrle, hrl hii
’Vplh`kea hbnut tol mhrtyrdnm nc Ohzrht Kmhhm Ohshe (Rhdkyhi Ihhou 'Heou) hed Ohzr
(Rhdkyhi Ihhou 'Heou) ke tol mneto nc Rhmhdhe, lvle kc kt ks bhsld ne hutoletkf trhdktknes, n
crll cnnd, nr ncclrkea swllt whtlr, nr akvkea mnely cnr toks purpnsl, nr ncclrkea mki`, hii tols
ueihwcui, hed hrl h rlsuit nc Thsohbbuol-Rhwhcks .
Gust inn` ht toks. Tol purk‛s PBrlhd] hed cnnd nc tol Okedus‛ Onik hed Dllwhhik ks ihwcui, but olhed wrnea. Tolsl plnpil ohvl hirlhdy rlglftld hii toht ks httrkbutld tn tol Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhii
Vhiihm) tol plnpil nc oks onuslonid PRhdkyhi Ihhou 'Heoumh] hed oks fnmpheknes (Rhdkyhi I
tol shkets, hed olrl ol shys toht h ahtolrkea wolrl entokea wrnea ks hkd hed lvlrytokea toh
annd, hed tn ncclr crll cnnd, whtlr hed mki` ks tnthiiy Ohrhhm hed wrnea. But wole tol Oke
tokeas, toly hrl ihwcui.
Olrl ilt ml sonw ynu hentolr tokea, tol qulstkne toht rlihtls
qulstkne ks, hed ynu nuaot tn ikstle tn kt httletkvliy7 Kc h Oked
drke`kea whtlr nr dkas h wlii nut nc tol mnely ol ohs hffumui
nr ketlrlst mnely, ks kt ihwcui cnr Musikms tn drke` wht
Heswlr 7 ’Tolrl ks en ohrm ke drke`kea whtlr crnm suf
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 130/206
(Rhsolld Homhd Aheanok )”
Ks toks woht wl fhii chkto> Olrl kt ks ke ne phal
Rhsolldkyho , vniuml torll.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 131/206
Ne tol nel ohed, tol cnnd dkstrkbutld ne tol Okedus‛ Onik ks dlfihrld plrmksskbil, he
Okedus spleds mnely wokfo ol ohs hfqukrld tornuao usury —hed ynu `enw onw strne
hahkest usury hrl ke Xur‛hhe hed Ohdlls, kedlld kt ohs blle dlfihrld h arlhtlr ske to
nel‛s mntolr—hed usls toht mnely tn puts up h shblli cnr Llshhi-l-Vhwhhb , kt ks dlfihrl
drke` whtlr crnm kt0 but, ne tol ntolr ohed, kc tolrl ks snmltokea purl ne wokfo tol e
Th‛hihh PAnd] ohs blle kevn`ld wkto tol ketletkne toht kt‛s rlwhrd sonuid rlhfo
Vhkyykdkeho Aohusl l H‛zhm nr Ohzrht Kmhhm Oushkle (Rhdkyhi Ihhou 'Heou)), to
wrnea. Qoht dn wl fhii toks, kc ent lemkty hed bkantry hahkest Ksihhm
TOL RLHVNE CNR
DKCCLRLEFLV…
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 132/206
( DLNBHEDK-KVM FH\AOT \Z KE KTV NQE
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 133/206
Tolsl hrl tol cnrty rlclrlefls toht K ohvl rlfnrdld ke my bnn` Dlnbhed tn Bhrlkiiy , toht ohs blle
hed Leaikso. Olrl K ohvl trkld tn sonw ynu toht tol rlclrlefls hrl hftuhiiy tolrl ke tol bnn`s toht K o
mkaot toke` toht K ohvl fnefnftld tolm crnm myslic. Toks ks woy lvlry rlclrlefl ohs blle sonwe tn
bnn`s. Kc snmlnel ks stkii ent shtksckld, tole tolrl ks entokea K fhe dn cnr K ohvl cuickiild my nbikahtkne
hii tn bl plrsnehiiy hethanekstkf tnwhrds heynel. Kt ks h mhttlr nc tol Oniy Zrnpolt‛s (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hi
hed prlstkal, ht wonsl torlsonid wl pihfl nur vlry olhds. K hm duty-bnued by my chkto tn heswlr hey
wrnea hbnut okm. Kc wl rlmhke skilet hctlr olhrkea snmltokea chisl hed uetrul hbnut tol Oniy Zrnpo
Qh Vhiihm) tole wl hrl surliy dlvnkd nc tol wlhito nc chkto, hed wl ohvl en rkaot tn fhii nurs
H bliklvlr ks nel won onids tol onenr nc tol Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) h
Tolsl bnn`s hrl ent gust olrl wkto ml, toly hrl hii hvhkihbil ke tol mhr`lt.
K wkii hisn shy toht K ohvl wrkttle hentolr bnn` fhiild Qoktl hed Bihf` ke wokfo K ohvl akvle rlclrlefls nc tolsl bnn
tol wnrds0 tol dlthkis hrl ke ntolr nel. K ohvl hisn wrkttle ke dlthki hbnut nur bliklcs wokfo toly fneskdlr tn bl kec
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 134/206
tol wnrds0 tol dlthkis hrl ke ntolr nel. K ohvl hisn wrkttle ke dlthki hbnut nur bliklcs wokfo toly fneskdlr tn bl kec
rlclrlefls cnrm tolkr nwe bnn s ke wokfo toly ohvl dlfihrld tolm hs trul hed ihwcui. Tolrl hrl hisn ntolr bnn`s
inn` ht. Toly ohvl ent blle wrkttle cnr ahke0 my purpnsl ks toht skefl Hiihho @hrllm PAnd] ohs akvle tol chfuity tnfnevly tn ynu tol mlsshal nc truto bnto tonuao my tneaul hed my ple. Gust hs ynu slttil ynur wnridiy mhtt
uedlrsthedkea… Toks dksputl ks ent hbnut cnnd hed sufo, kt ks ent woht toly ohvl pubikfkzld. Toly dne‛t tlii plnpil
ks hbnut.
Tolsl wrktkeas nc tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok ‟ \ihmh hed tolkr rlmhkekea stlhdchst ne tolm
dkcclrlefls.
Toly shy toht kt ks h dksputl hbnut Mllihhd, nr Akyhhrowlle. Zlnpil won bliklvl toht Hiihho @hrllm PAnd] ahvl t
Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ks en dkcclrlet crnm toht wokfo ks akvle lvle tn hekmhis pnsslss toht Hiihho @hrllm PAnd
tol mlhekea nc @ohthmue Ehbllyyke ks ent ‟tol ihst Zrnpolt‛, won bliklvl toht tol `enwildal nc tol ueslle s, wo
PVhthe] ohs mnrl `enwildal tohe tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) kc ynu wkso ynu mhy fneskdlr sufo
chkto ks toht wonlvlr shys hed hfflpts sufo tokeas fnmls uedlr tol shml fhtlanry hs tolsl \ih
CHTQH NC @\CR NE DLNBHEDK MH\ISLLV !
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 135/206
Nel nc tol mnst nutsthedkea lxpnelets nc tol Ksihmkf nrtondnxy, Oks Lmkelefl Kmhhm Hom H‛ih Ohzrht Chhzki-l-Bhrlivk‛s PRhomhtui Ihhok Hihklo]P
dldkfhtld okmslic tn whal whr hahkest tolsl pnpuihr olrlskls hed prlsletld h pnwlrcui dlcl
8?<3- 8;28]
Ol wrntl h trlhtksl ke Hrhbkf letktild
’ Ousshm-ui-Ohrhmhye PTol Vwnrd nc twn sheftuhrkls]. hed Thmolld-l-KCnr lkaoty ylhrs \ihmhh‛s ohvl blle lxpihkekea tolsl mhttlrs. wokfo ks ke chft h pnwlrcui dlclesl nc t
Qole tol ‟ \ihmhh-k-Ohq lxpihkeld tn tolm toht sufo tokeas hrl wrnea hed toly sonuid rlplet cnrLvle hctlr lxpihkekea tonusheds nc tkmls, tol rlpiy nc tol wrktlrs nc sufo wrktkeas whs skmpiy toks t
ohvl wrkttle ks fnrrlft. Cnr toks hetk Ksihmkf wrktkea, twn ouedrld hed skxty lkaot sfonihrs crnm
hed tokrty torll sfonihrs crnm Ohrhmhye Vohrkchhye dlfihrld tol Chtwh (vlrdkft) nc ucr upn
ntolr sfonihrs.
Toks chtwh whs kssuld ke 862: H.O (8;:: HD) by tol Vhhikolle '\ihmhed tol arlht oniy pihfls blcnrl tol Vhudk Qhohhbk Ehgdk cnrfld to
Lvle blcnrl kssukea tol chtwh, Kmhhm Homhd Rhzh
H‛ih Ohzrht Chhzki-l-Bhrlivk‛s PRhomhtui Ihhok Hi
slet ilttlrs tn Dlnbhedk sfonihrs rlqulstkea tolm tn lxpihke tol stht
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 136/206
slet ilttlrs tn Dlnbhedk sfonihrs rlqulstkea tolm tn lxpihke tol stht
rlpiy crnm tol Dlnbhedk sfonihrs. H‛ih Ohzrht ahvl Hsorhc Hik Thevk,
lxpihke hed rlplet crnm oks wrktkea nc `ucr!
Ol dkd ent dn sn, tole, hed neiy tole, dkd ol phssld tol ch
Hed enw wl ohvl wrkttle tolsl bnn`s toht hrl lhsklr tn uedlrsthed
trhesihtld ketn Leaikso. Tolrl hrl snml bnn`s wrkttle by my rlvlr
Muohmmhd Vohcll N`hrvk‛s PHiihho ohvl mlrfy ne okm]Ke hii my
rlclrlefls nc tol Dlnbhedks. Qoy> Blfhusl nur nwe plnpil hirlh purpnsl nc prlsletkea tolkr nwe rlclrlefls ks tn sonw toht toly shy n
hentolr. Qoht toly wrktl toly dn ent bliklvl0 woht toly bliklvl toly
won ohvl en cllt tn sthed ne fhe ohrdiy blelckt ntolrs. Toks ks tol p
tolsl bnn`s.
Hctlr toks vlrdkft nc keckdlikty akvle ha
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 137/206
pubiksold, tol ‟ \ihmh hed tolkr clii
keduiald ke sufo wrktkeas tolmslivltonsl won ohd akvle toks vlrdkft hah
dnel sn tohe ne tol bhsks nc nur wrktk
ohvl blfnml keckdlis tolms
But toly dkd ent rlplet n
wrktkeas. Tol rlhsne cnr toks ks t
dnel sn ne tol suaalstkne nc
Musikms lelmkls hctlr rlflk
fnnplrhtkne hed hssksthefl. On
heeny tolkr (ene-Musikm) m
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 138/206
Tol Brktkso lmpinyld snml Musikm uihmh hed dkvkdld tol Musikms by mh`kea tolm ckaot ne rlikakn
tolkr httletkne crnm Gkohhd …
Dlhr Rlhdlrs….snml nel ouedrld hed ckcty ylhrs han, tolrl wlrl en Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Th
Kedn-Zh`ksthe subfnetkelet. Tolsl arnups ohvl blle prnmptld hed rlhrld by tol lelmkls
leahald ke ourikea kesuits ht tol Zrnpolt PVhiihi Ihhou Hihklok Qhsshihm] hed ht oks prnale
ht tonsl invld by okm, mlrliy cnr tol sh`l nc h clw lhrtoiy fnkes. Toly hrl ent mkedcui nc tol
Ihho's wrhto. Hi-Ihho bl prhksld toht wl tol Hoil Vueeht Qh Ghmeh‛ht ohvl cnr fleturkls b
truto. Toly dkd ent rlhikzl toht toly wlrl lhrekea ltlrehi dhmehtkne cnr tolmslivls by dks
Hiihho hed Oks Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm), hed wlrl ilhvkea bloked tolm foh
tol \m-mht.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 139/206
Dlhr rlhdlrs, ynu mkaot toke` toht tolsl plnpil mkaot ohvl hfflptld toks hdvksl hed mhy ohv
but, shdiy, tolsl sn fhiild '\ihmh nc Dlnbhed ent neiy rlplhtldiy keskstld ne dlfihrkea tolkr ke
wrktkeas hs fnrrlft but hisn sthrtld akvkea rlhsnekea‛s tn prnvl tolsl keckdli hed bihspolmkf
Lvle tonuao lvlry ketliikalet mhe `enws toht ’ \zr-l-auehho bhd thr hz aueh
mksth`l ks wnrsl tohe fnmmkttkea h mksth`l )mlhekea tn gustkcy h mksth`l hs rkaot ks ik`l fnmmkttkea h mksth`l nvlr h mksth`l. Tn fneskd
vkrtunus hed annd hed tn prnvl kt tn bl anndelss hed vkrtunus ks h ske nc tol okaolst lxtleds, (`ucr) hs chkto (Kllmhhe) ks enttol wnr` nc h Mu‛mke.
Hctlr tonsl won ohd wrkttle tolsl bihspolmkf tokeas ilct toks wnrid, tolkr sufflssnrs w
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 140/206
c p a c ,
lktolr bure nr drnwe ketn slh tol bnn`s ke wokfo sufo bihspolmkf tokeas hrl wrkttle
sufflssnrs hisn finsld tol dnnr nc rlplethefl ne tolmslivls hed rlmhkeld hdhmhestubbnreelss hed hrl stkii ckrm. Enw toly lvle shy toht tolsl wrktkeas hrl ent ht hii w
hffnrdkea tn tol bhskf prkefkpil ihkd dnwe ke tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht, tol rkaotiy-au
ahvl toks vlrdkft toht tol lednrslmlet hed suppnrt nc keckdlikty ks keckdlikty,
(Hr-rhzh Bki ` ucrk `ucrue ). ’Lednrslmlet nc keckdlikty ks hisn keckdlikty.”
Vnml plnpil shy toht, ‟rlwhrd cnr onw mhey uekts (rh`‛hht ) nc Ehmhhz wkii bl akv
fhiikea, tol wrktlrs hed bliklvlrs nc sufo wrnea hed keckdli wrktkeas hs keckdlis> Qoy
fnedlme tol dlhd> Hed woht dn wl `enw tonsl dlhd mhy ohvl rlpletld> Ke rlpiy, k pnketld nut toht mh`kea dkstkeftkne bltwlle keckdlikty hed Ksihhm ks hmnea tol elflssktkl
mhy ent fhii he keckdli he keckdli hii ynur ikcl but wole oks keckdlikty ks vkskbil, tole kt ks elf
okm hed hfflpt okm hs he keckdli ne tol bhsks nc oks keckdlikty. Hed toks ks h prkefkpil toht
keckdlikty hs keckdlikty ks kevnivkea nelslic ke keckdlikty. •
Hs cnr tol qulstkne woy sonuid wl fnedlme tolm enw wole toly h
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 141/206
Hs cnr tol qulstkne woy sonuid wl fnedlme tolm enw wole toly h
tol rlpiy tn toks ks, Hbu Ihohb, he uefil tn tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm), keduiald ke kesnilefl hed hisn Qhilld Bke Mua
hed ntolrs kesnilets toly hii wkii bl fursld tkii tol Dnnmsdhy blfhus
won hrl dksrlsplftcui tn tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh
toly wkii ent bl prhksld hed ihudld but toly wkii neiy bl fnedlmel
rlahrdkea tol pilh toht toly mkaot ohvl rlpletld ilt ml shy toks. Ckr
neiy toht plrsne fhe toke` nc rlpletkea won hf`enwildals tolsl wrbl bihspolmy. Qole tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok ‟ \ihmh d
hf`enwildal tolkr wrktkeas hs keckdlikty hed hrl hbil tn twkst filhr
crnm tolkr nbvknus mlhekea tole woht `ked nc rlpletkea ks toks cnr
Lvle blskdl toks K shy kc hey cniinwlrs nc nc Dlnbhed `enw toht tolkr ilhdlrs ohd
tolsl bihspolmkf hed wrnea wrktkeas to
rlplethefl sonuid bl pubiksold hed m
hed hii tol cniinwlrs sonuid heenuefl e
d b i o bi o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 142/206
hed ent tn bliklvl ke tolsl bihspolmkf
hfflpt tolsl wrktkeas tn bl wrnebihspolmy tole hii tol fnetrnvlrskls w
ktslic.••
Tol dlthkis nc tol lxhft tlxt nc tols
sthtlmlets nc tolsl Dlnbhedk, Qhohh
hed tolkr nwe chthhwhs ne tolm sll ’Qoktl hed Bihf`.”
@hu`hb
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 143/206
He nrahekzhtkne ke Ihonrl fhiild Mhgkiks Vkyhhehtui Musikmlle ke brlhfo nc trust hii nc h suddle
toht toly sthrtld foheakea tolsl bihspolmkf wrktkeas nc ‟ \ihmho
nwe. Tol filhr mlhekea nc toks ks toht elhr tol Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk ‟ \ihmho hssnfkhtld wkto toks n
nrkakehi wrktkeas hrl dlckektliy bihspolmy, ntolrwksl woy wnuid toly elld tn foheal
Kc tol prlslet Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk , ‟ \ihmh fneskdlr tol wrktkeas nc tolkr lidlrs tn bl wrnea nr nbgl
dne‛t toly hdmkt toks ke filhr tlrms> Ks `enwkeaiy okdkea keckdlikty nc ntolrs ks ent keduiakea nels
Tol prlslet Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk ‟ \ihmh sonuid sll tol sth
tolkr nwe Vohkl`o Muohmmhd Wh`hrkyh @hedohivk . Ol shysplrmkttld tn lcclft hey foheal ke h bnn` wrkttle by wr
snmlnel lisl>” (Ne prnbilms rlahrdkea tol bnn` ne Ch
heswlrs tn tolm. pa <6.)
Chbrkfhtknes Dnel By Dlnbhedk's Ke Tolkr
Rlprkets…..He lxhmpil….
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 144/206
Hctlr oks dlhto, tol oniy Zrnpo
Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs
wkto dust. (Thqwkyhtui Kllmhhe..Ke tol lhriy vlrskne…
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 145/206
Enw ilt us sll woht chbrkfhtkne tolsl dlvkhet dohvl dnel ke tolkr rlprket nc toks bnn`. H usl
nc
hed h tnthi foheal ke mlhekea! Zilhsl entl toks
tonsl dksrlsplftcui sletlefl wokfo sfonihrs
nbg
tol blakeekea, but tol Dlnbhedk‛s dkd ent harll
toly hrl mh`kea foheals ke himnst hii tolkr bnn
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 146/206
ohvl foheald kt tn nel dhy K wkii bl lmbrhf
lhrto…ke kts hrms.
Vnml plnpil shkd tol rlst nc tol wrktkeas nc tolsl
‟won ohd wrkttle sufo tokeas hrl fnrrlft tole kt ks
ent rkaot tn prnenuefl tolm keckdlis ne tol bhsks
c i tok g t tok V kt
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 147/206
nc neiy snml tokeas nr gust nel tokea. Vll kts
heswlr by Hsorhc Hik Tohevk Vhhokb okmslic, olshys,
’K c snmlnel ohs lvle nel tokea nc @ucr
(keckdlikty) tohe uehekmnusiy ol ks fneskdlrld h
@hhckr (keckdli).” ( Hchzhhth-l-[humkyho Sni-1 pa664).
Tol Ilhreld Hffursld
Heali…
Vohkthhe
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 148/206
Vohkthhe
Oks Vtubbnreelss ' hed oks Dnwech
Blskdl toks, tolsl plnpil hrl hs ld tn sll toht Vohkthhe (Hzhhzlli) tol
hffnrdkea tn nel trhdktkne, ohd wnrsokppld Himkaoty Hiihho cnr skx oued
ylhrs hed hffnrdkea tn hentolr, cnr torll mkiikne ylhrs hed prnstrhtld b
Th‛hhihh ne lvlry skeail spnt nc tol lhrto, ol ks rlputld tn bl tol tlhf
healis ke rlclrlefl tn oks `enwildal hed ke rlclrlefl tn bliklvl ks h pur
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 149/206
healis ke rlclrlefl tn oks `enwildal, hed ke rlclrlefl tn bliklvl ks h pur
(h ckrm bliklvlr ke tol uekty nc Hiihho). Ol ohd mhdl neiy nel ske. Ol dkd blcnrl Ohzrht Hhdhm (‛ Hihkloks-Vhihhm) hed ahvl tol rlhsne toht ol ks h mhe
(lhrtoiy oumhe). Tolrlcnrl, Ol (Vohkthhe ) blfhml h rlglftlr nc tol a
Zrnpoltonnd. Tol prnstrhtkne, wokfo Himkaoty Hiihho ohd fnmmhedld
tn Ohzrht Hhdhm (‛ Hihkloks-Vhihhm) , whs h prnstrhtkne mlhet cnr sonwkea rl
Vohkthhe rlcusld tn hfflpt tol arlhtelss nc Zrnpoltonnd. Vn Himkaoty H
fneskdlr oks wnrsokppkea, ilhrekea hed bliklvl ne tol Nelelss nc Hiihhofhrl cnr kt kestlhd gust cnr nel mksth l nc dksrlsplft hed kesnilefl cnrlvl
nc tol rlsplft nc Zrnpolt onnd whs nutfihssld hed dksfhrdld. Enw tkii to
tolkr wkii neiy bl fursl ne okm.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 150/206
K ohvl hirlhdy shkd toht cnr blkea h Mu‛mke kt ks elflsshr y tn bliklvl ke hii tol lssletkhis
blfnmkea he keckdli kt ks lenuao tn dley neiy nel nc tol lssletkhis nc Dlle. Gust fneskdlr to
ylhrs nc Ehmhhz hed wnrsokppkea hed hii oks ilhrekea hed bliklvl ke tol uekty nc Hiihho
Vohkthhe, tol hffursld, crnm blkea fnedlmeld hed fursld, tole onw fhe slvlrhi ylhrs' nc
hed bliklvl ke tol uekty nc Hiihho shvl tolsl Dlnbhedk Qhohhbk ‟ \ihmh> Tol Vohkthhe ohd s
Zrnpolt hed ylt tolsl Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk ‟ \ihmh ohvl shkd sufo ckitoy uttlrhefls hahkesZrnpolts (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) wokfo heynel wnuid lvle ohtl tn uttlr cnr tolkr n
sktuhtkne, fhe heynel dnubt toht Himkaoty Hiihho's wrhto wkii surliy lefnmphss tolsl ‟ \ihm
tonsl won bliklvl ke sufo hffursld wrktkeas> Hf`enwildal toks wlii toht rldlmptkne dlp
fnrrlftelss nc bliklcs, ent ne hfts nr enwildal.
Dlnbhedk
\ihhmhh
& Tolkr Cht Hahkest tolkr nwe Vfonihr‛s…& Tlhfokea
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 151/206
Vnml plnpil shkd tol rlst nc tol wrktkeas nc tolsl ‟won ohd wrkttle sufo tokeas
fnrrlft tole kt ks ent rkaot tn prnenuefl tolm keckdlis ne tol bhsks nc neiy snml tok
gust nel tokea.
Vll kts heswlr by Hsorhc Hik Tohevk Vhhokb okmslic, ol shys, ’
snmlnel ohs lvle nel tokea nc @ ucr (keckdlikty) tohe uehekmnusiy
fneskdlrld h @hhckr (keckdli ).” (Hchzhhth-l-[humkyho Sni-1 pa 664).
Tol chtwh (vlrdkft) nc Tohevk Vhhokb ne tol hutonr nc tol chmnus bnn` ’ V
Ghehhb Vokbill Eu'mhhek, hed hentolr 'hhikm nc Dlnbhed, Ghehhb Ohmlldwon ohs blle quntld by he 'hhikm nc Dlnbhed, Ghehhb 'Hbdui Mhhgkd Dhroks bnn` Oh`llmui \m-mht.(Zrketld Hsorhc Zrlss, Ihonrl, 8;31)
Ol wrktls, ’ Mhuiheh Tohevk‛s chtwh ohs blle pubiksold hed
Eu‛mhhek hed Mhuiheh Ohmlldud-dlle Chrhhok hrl keckdlis
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 152/206
Eumhhek hed Mhuiheh Ohmlldud-dlle Chrhhok hrl keckdlis,
mhdrksho (rlikaknus sfonni) fhrrkls ne tol mksskne nc bnto nc toisihho ks h sfonni nc keckdlikty hed lvkielss, hs wlii hs toks toht
phrtkfkphtkea ke tol mllt keas nc toks mhdrksho blfnml htolkstkf h
Hctlr rlhdkea toks chtwh, Ghehhb Hbdui Mhhgkd Dhryhbhdk wrntl h dlthkVhhokb ke wokfo ol pilhdld cnr Vokbill Eu‛mhhek hed Ohmlldud-dlle Cbnto nc tolm ent neiy shy tolkr Ehmhhz rlauihriy but hisn usld tn shy
Ehmhhz) hed wlrl vlry pknus hed ilhreld mle. Tn toks, Tohevk Vhhokb
tolsl hrl hfts hed fnedktknes, hed bliklcs hrl snmltokea dkcc
Fnrrlft bliklcs fhe bl fnmbkeld wkto lvki dllds hed fnedkbliklcs fhe bl fnmbkeld wkto fnrrlft fnedktknes hed dllds
(Oh`llmui \m- mht, pa 413).
Kc ke chft Tohevk Vhhokb ks tol neiy rlhi kdlninakfhThbillaok Ghmhh‛ht , tole, hffnrdkea tn Tohevk Vhsnmlnel won ohs wrnea bliklcs, oks Ehmhhz wkii enHed Tohevk Vhhokb shys toht `llpkea tol fnmphey ncwhi`kea hed sktt
kea wkto tolm, rlhdkea tolkr bnn`s kskrrlikaknuselss Tol ‟\ihmh nc Dlnbhed tolmslivls
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 153/206
krrlikaknuselss. Tol \ihmh nc Dlnbhed tolmslivls
filhriy hbnut tol bliklcs nc tol mletnrs nc tol Thbiltoht toly hrl kaenrhet hed tolkr bliklcs hrl ent fnrprnvld by tol kdlninakfhi bhsl nc Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht hed tol ilhdkea sfonihrs nc Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht tohfnmphey nc Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht , whi`kea hed skttkerlhdkea tolkr bnn`s ks htolkstkf krrlikaknuselss, whywhrde
Dlhr rlhdlrs, wole wl shy tol shml tokea kecrnet ncfneskdlrld fuiprkts, hitonuao toly sonuid, fnedlme tolwonm toly fhii tolkr nwe cnuedhtkne blfhusl toly hrlwon ohvl dlfihrld tolm tn bl wrnea hed ohvl lxpnsl
H Dlnbhedk ‟ Hhikm Hbdui Rhollm Voho (won ohs blle
cnr h inea tkml wkto (tol hutonr nc Bhrhholle-l-Xh
@ohilli Homhd Hmbltovk‛s • @ohillcho (Fhikpo) he
cnuedlr nc Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht Muohmmhd KKyhhs Vh
oks sne Muohmmhd [nnsuc, ol ks hisn tolkr splfkhi p
shys,
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 154/206
Vufo plnpil whet tn httlmpt tol wnr` wokfo blitol sfonihrs won hrl ent neiy uehfquhketld wkto
(rlikakne) but hrl hisn dlmlhekea ke tol letkrl sn
blfhusl nc tolkr mlheelss, kaenrhefl hed bhd d
Fneskdlr toks wole h frnw wkii blfnml tol olhd nc h
ol wkii sonw tolm neiy whys wokfo wnuid ilhd tn
dlstruftkne.” (\snni Dh‛wht -Thbillao, pa 4)
Ghehhb Whchr Homhd \smhek okmslic shys,
’Ke sonrt, tol prlslet mltond nc pubikf
prlhfokea (by Thbil
laok Ghmhh‛ht ) hbsniutl
chkis ke frlhtkea lxfliilefl ke rlikaknus
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 155/206
`enwildal hed ke prnvkdkea lxplrtksl cnrwnr`kea ke dkcclrlet dlphrtmlets nc Dlle.”
(Thz`krht-ui-Whchr, pa 2<2).
Ol curtolr shys, ’Zrlhfokea by tol dlckfkle
ks ent ht hii rlikhbil.” (Thz`krht-ui-Whchr, pa 2<6).
.
Dlhr rlhdlrs, ke tol hbnvl quntld wrktkeas he keskdlrmh`ls kt filhr toht tol plnpil nc tol Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht
ohvl lxflldld tol ikmkts hed ik`l crnas durkea tol
mnesnne, lhfo nel nc tolm frnh`s hed blake tn prlhfo
wktonut hfqukrkea `enwildal. Tol prlhfolrs nc tol
Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht hrl kmplrclft prlhfolrs, tolkr
prlhfokea ks ent rlikhbil By gnkekea tol Thbil
laok
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 156/206
prlhfokea ks ent rlikhbil. By gnkekea tol Thbillaok
Ghmhh‛ht hed by wnr`kea ke tol prlhfokea wnr`nc tol Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht en rlcnrms fhe bl
mhdl. Qole toly tolmslivls fheent kmprnvl
tohe onw fhe ntolrs bl rlcnrmld . Dlnbhedk,
Qhohhbk '\ihmh hrl tolmslivls ent shtk sckld
wkto tol Thbillaok Ghmhh‛ht nc tolkr nwe chkto
hed wkto kts wnr`
Hbdur-Rhollm Voho wrktls,
’Tol dhmhal nc h plrsne won dnls ent
Ehmhhz ks f
neckeld tn neiy okmslic hed to
nc tol ntolr nel ks fnethaknus, kts dhmha
wonil alelrhtkne ”
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 157/206
wonil alelrhtkne.
(\snni-l-Dh'wht-n-Thbillao, pa <4).
Toks mlhes toht h plrsne won dnls en
Ehmhhz ohrms okmslic neiy hed tol plrsn
shys Ehmhhz but prlhfols wrnea bliklcs dl
wonil alelrhtkne. Tol inss fhusld by sufo h
dnls ent rlmhke fneckeld neiy tn okm slic b
he lpkdlmkf, levlinps lvle ntolrs hs w
Vll kt curtolr. Kotlsohhmui Ohshe @hVhhokb, brntolr-ke-ihw nc Muohmmhd Kiy
oks splfkhi hssksthet hed hssnfkhtl crnm tkii nid hal, wrktls ke tol fnefiudkea phbnn`, ’ Wkedhall @ll Vkrhhtl Musthqll
strhkaot phto nc ikcl) prketld uedlr tol ol
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 158/206
strhkaot phto nc ikcl) prketld uedlr tol ol
lssletkhi whrekea.” Rlhd toks wkto snml ol wrktls,
’Tol prlslet prlhfokea dnel ke Ekzhm
infhikty nc Dliok) ks, ke my `enwilda
uedlrsthedkea, ent ke fnesnehefl w
Xur'hhe hed tol Ohdlls enr wkto tol t
nc Ohzrht Mughd-dkd Hicl Vhhek hed OhQhilly-yui Ihho Muohd-dks Dloivk h
rkaotiy aukdld sfonihrs.”
Dlnbhedk-
Qhohhbk-
Thbillaok
…Dlvkhet tlhfokea
Tol hpphrlet aikttlr hed sokel nc Ehmhhz hed Rn
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 159/206
[nu fhe sll, tol plnpil nc tol Thbillaok Ghmhhhitonuao hpphrletiy toly thi` hbnut tol @hikmho
blkea rlauihr ke shykea Ehmhhz but hrl chr hwhy
tol rlhikty hed `enwildal nc tol Dlle (rlikakne)
mksilhd tolmslivls hed hisn dlstrny ntolrs.
Dlhr rlhdlrs, tolsl plnpil hrl tnid wole toly wkii
stlp nut nc tolkr onmls cnr tol sh`l nc prlhfokea
toly wkii lhre arlht rlwhrds, but sufo plnpil dn
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 160/206
ent uedlrsthed toht ik`l tol phsslealrs hrl kedhealr nc inskea tolkr ikvls kc h plrsne won dnlse‛t
`enw onw tn drkvl ks mhdl tn skt ke tol drkvlr‛s slht
skmkihriy plnpil hrl ke dhealr nc inskea tolkr chkto
(Kllmhhe ) kc he kaenrhet plrsne ks hsskaeld cnr tol
ths` nc prlhfokea.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 161/206
Tol Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) won, wkto Hiihho's chvnur, ohd tol `enwildal nc tol ueslle
shkd,
’ Qole ilhreld wkii dksskphtls hed Kim (`enwildal) wkii bl ikctld, plnpil wkii onid tol kaenrhet ne
aukdhefl cnr tol prnbilms hed tonsl kaenrhet nels wkii akvl wrnea heswlrs wktonut `enwildal,
bl toht toly tolmslivls wkii bl mksaukdld hed wkii hisn mksilhd ntolrs hs wlii.” ( Bu`ohhrk hed
Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs hisn shkd, ’Tol dhy ynu cked uesuktld plnpil mhdl
tol gnb nc (rlikakne) Dlle ynu sonuid hwhkt Dnnmsdhy.” Mlhekea toht tonsl kaenrhet plnpil w
tokeas by wokfo plnpil wkii bl dlvhsthtld hed rukeld. Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) hisn
bl nel nc tol skaes nc tol Dnnmsdhy. [nu fhe sll, tol plnpil nc tol T hbillaok Ghmhh‛ht , hitonua
toly thi` hbnut tol @hikmho hed blkea rlauihr ke shykea Ehmhhz but hrl chr hwhy crnm tol
`enwildal nc tol Dlle (rlikakne) hed mksilhd tolmslivls hed hisn dlstrny ntolrs
Dlhr rlhdlrs, ynu ohvl gust slle tol rlhThbillaok Ghmhh‛ht ke tol wrktkeas nc tol
Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk, hed Thbillaok '\ihmh. V
dne‛t elld tn akvl hey mnrl chtwh nr mh`l h
ne tolm. Zrnvkdlefl ohs ktslic dlfihrld tolm
tornuao tolkr nwe ples
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 162/206
tornuao tolkr nwe ples.
Enw tol Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk-Thbillaok plnp
ohvl tn dlfkdl. Kc toly shy toly hrl rkaot to
lidlrs hrl prnvld tn bl wrnea, hed kc toly d
lidlrs tn bl rkaot tole toly tolmslivls hrl
wrnea, hed tonsl won hrl rlhdkea tolsl
olhrkea tolm wkii fnml tn tol fnefiuskne
wrktkea toht hii nc tolsl bka nr smhii, toly h
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 163/206
But inn` ht tol mkrhfil nc Zrnvkdlefl toht towokfo toly fhii us keckdlis hed keenvhtnrs toly
shml tokeas. Mlhekea tonsl tokeas wokfo to
ueihwcui hed prnokbktld toly dn tonsl tolmslivls
blfnml aukity ne twn fnuets, ckrstiy, tol aukit nc fhiike
tokea hs prnokbktld hed slfnediy, nc dnkea tol shmdlfihrkea kt tn bl ueihwcui.
Kc toks ks ent tol wrhto nc Hiihho Th‛hhihh cnr tolm
neiy tole woht ks kt>
Tol Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
won, wkto Hiihho @hrllm's chvnrs, ohd tol`enwildal nc tol ueslle, ohd hirlhdy shkd, ’Qole
ilhreld wkii dksskphtls hed Kim (`enwildal) wkii bl
ikctld, plnpil wkii onid tol kaenrhet nels hed hs` cnr
aukdhefl cnr tol prnbilms hed tonsl kaenrhet nels
wkii akvl wrnea heswlrs wktonut `enwildal, kts
rlsuit wkii bl toht toly tolmslivls wkii bl mksaukdld
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 164/206
y a
hed wkii hisn mksilhd ntolrs hs wlii.” ( Bu`ohhrk hedMusikm).
Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
ohs hisn shkd, ’Tol dhy ynu cked uesuktld plnpil
mhdl ke fohral nc tol gnb nc (rlikakne) Dlle ynu
sonuid hwhkt
Dnnmsdhy .” Mlhekea toht tonsl kaenrhet plnpil wkii shy sufo
tokeas by wokfo plnpil wkii bl dlvhsthtld hed rukeld. Tol oniyZrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) hisn dlfihrld kt tn bl
nel nc tol skaes nc tol Dnnmsdhy.
Dlhr rlhdlrs tol shml ks tol fhsl wkto tolsl Dlnb
Qhohhbk-Thbillaok ltf. Tol hpphrlet aikttlr hed
Ehmhhz hed Rnzho hrl
slle, tol blelckts nc T
hed kts uslcuielss hrl lxpihkeld but ke tol bhs
prlhfokea tol okddle kdlninakfhi lvki hed tol
bliklcs wokfo hrl prlslet hed mkxld wkto tol s
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 165/206
c p
dksrlsplft hed kesnilefls tn tol Arhedlu
Zrnpoltonnd ke tolm toly hrl dlhdiy pnksn
Kllmhhe. Ik`l tol pnksne ks tol fhusl nc dlhto tn oum
hed ikcl, en dnubt tol shml why tol dksrlsplft hed kes
tol Arhedlur nc Zrnpolts hed tol crkleds nc Hiihho ks
nc dlstruftkne hed dlhto nc illmhhe. Hed ynu ohvl uekt vlry wlii toht tol rldlmptkne dlpleds ent ne dlld
rkaot bliklcs, sn kc nel dnls ent onid rkaot bliklcs tohe
tol prhykea cnr mkiiknes nc ylhrs wnuid bl nc en blelc
Dlhr rlhdlrs, tol vlrdkft nc tol ‟ \ihmh nc Dlnbhed wokfo
akvle hahkest tolkr nwe Mhudnndk Vhhokb, tol shml vlrd
wnrds ks hisn cnr tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok ‟ \ihm
suppnrtlrs crnm us. \etki tolsl Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbill
rlplet crnm tolkr phahe wrktkeas hed ueilss toly pubikfiy
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 166/206
tolkr ene-hfflpthefl nc tolsl wrktkeas hed fnrrlft tolkmlhekea toly dn ent th`l nut tol pklfl nc swkel cilso crn
hed tol pnksne crnm tol ohiwho tol Musikm um-mho wkii
tolkr vlrdkft hbnut hii tolsl Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillao
toly hrl hfflptnrs hed bliklvlrs (won hfflpt hed bliklvl
phahe wrktkeas. Blfhusl tol '\ihmh nc Dlnbhed ohvl to
hfflptld toht rldlmptkne dlpleds neiy upne bliklcs, en
Tol neiy nel why tn h dlfkskne hed h fnmprnmksl ks toht hii tol Dlnbhedk-Qhoh
Thbillaok ltf must hdmkts toht tol Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk ‟
\ihmh ohvl wrkttle tolsl
tokeas wokfo hrl hahkest tol Bnn` ( Xur‛hhe ) hed tol Vueeht. Cnr tol rlhsne nc
rlpletkea crnm tolsl wrktkeas toly hrl phahes hed keckdlis hed hey sufo plrsne
bliklvls hed lednrsls tolsl wrktkeas toly hrl brhf`ltld wkto tol wrktlrs nc tol
phsshals. Blfhusl lvlrynel `enws toht tol fnmmheds nc tol Vohrll'ht fheent bl
’
Ih`um
Dlleu`um
Qhikyh
Dl
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 167/206
p a y c
but plnpil foheal tolkr nwe sthtl, wksdnm hed uedlrsthedkea fnmpiltliy hffnrdkea tn tol Vohrll‛ht .
Tol mnmlet Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok ltf hdmkt toks, hii tol fnetrn
wkii fnml tn he led. But, shdiy, wolelvlr tol sufflssnrs hed suppnrtlrs nc
‟ uihmh tol wrktlrs nc tolsl wrnea hed bihspolmkf wrktkeas ohvl blle hs`
hdmkt toks toly ohvl filhriy rlcusld tn dn sn.
Enw, rlhdlrs sonuid dlfkdl tolmslivls. Qole Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok tol bliklv
hfflptnrs nc tol wrktkeas rlmhke kecilxkbil ne tolkr stubbnreelss tn hfflpt, tole onw fh
vlrdkft nc tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht bl hitlrld> Hbnut plnpil wonsl olhrts hrl slhild, w
kmmlrsld dllp ketn tol hbyss nc dlvkhtkne, won dne‛t ik`l tn dkstkeft bltwlle tol trutos he
tol Xur‛hhe ohs fnmmhedld neiy toks cnr tolm,
’ Ih`um Dlleu`um Qhikyh Dlle,” cnr ynu ynur Dlle hed cnr tolm tolkr D
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 168/206
Dlhr rlhdlrs, hctlr toks ehrrhtkvl, ynu wnuid ik` prlslet ‟ \ihmh nc Dlnbhed wlrl ent ik l toks blcnrl
ohvl blfnml tol suppnrtlrs nc tol Ehgdk Qhohhbk
spnesnrld by tol Ihwrlefl nc Hrhbkh hed hctlr dle
cnr tol
Zrnpoltonnd ik`l tolm toly ohvl blle shy
tokeas ke tol tnel nc Vohkthhe. Tolsl prlslet Dlnb
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 169/206
Thbillaok ltf woy dn toly sthy ckrm ne tolsl keckdliwrktkeas nc snml nc tolkr lidlrs. By hfflptkea tolkr
dne‛t ckekso toks fnetrnvlrsy, ke tol led woht ks tol
shy tn my rlhdlrs onelstiy hed trutocuiiy wkto clhr n
Glws, tol Forkstkhes, hed hii keckdlis hed tol oyp
lelmkls tn Hiihho Vubohhehou Th‛hhihh hed Oks
Ihhou ‟ Hihklok QhVhiihm). Tol Xur‛hhe ohs lxpihkeld tolkr rlhikty
TOL
OKVTNRKFHI
CHFTV…
Fnespkrhfkls
nc tol
Lelmkls
nc
Ksihhm
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 170/206
p
K shy tn my rlhdlrs onelstiy hed trutocuiiy wkto clhr nc
Hiihho toht tol Glws, tol Forkstkhes, hed hii keckdlis hed tol
oypnfrktls hii hrl lelmkls tn Hiihho Vubohhehou Th‛hhihh
hed Oks Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh
Vhiihm). Tol Xur‛hhe ohs lxpihkeld tolkr rlhikty ke dlthki.
[nu `enw, kt ks h ehturhi hed h psyfoninakfhi hft toht wole tol
rlhikty nc hey bihspolmkf plrsne ks lxpnsld hed oks uaiy chfl ks cuiiy
uevlkild tole ol ks arlhtiy ourt. Hed ol sonws mnrl stubbnreelss
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 171/206
uevlkild tole ol ks arlhtiy ourt. Hed ol sonws mnrl stubbnreelss
mlhekea kestlhd nc fnrrlftkea okmslic, tol ckrl nc lemkty, healr hed
levy ks lxtkeaukso wktoke okm. Tn sufo he lxtled toht ol alts kevnivld
ke th`kea rlthikhtnry mlhsurls.
Glws hed tol Forkstkhes wlrl hisn vlry heary ht tol lxpheskne nc tol
Ksihhmkf Lmpkrl by tol Mlrfy tn tol wnrids ( Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) hed
oks trul sufflssnrs hed wlrl ueohppy nc tolkr nwe dlclht hed
oumkikhtkne. Toly wlrl dlprkvld nc tolkr mhke hrlhs hisn tol @oyblr
hed tol Bhklt-tui-Mhqdks ltf
Toly… shw toht enw toly wkii ent bl hbil tn rlahke tolkr inst `keadnm
hed tolkr pnwlr hed strleato, hed toly fheent fnetlst wkto tol Ksihhmkf
Lmpkrl. Vn, toly sht dnwe tnaltolr dlvksld slfrlt fniiuskvl pihes, dlthkis
nc wokfo hrl prlslrvld ke tol hutoletkf bnn`s. Tolsl hetk-Ksihhmkf
arnups rlhikzld enw nur rlhiktkls ohvl blle cuiiy lxpnsld. Hctlr blkea
lxkild hed plrslfutld crnm nur fnuetry wl ohvl blfnml vlry wlh`, hed
nur rlhiktkls ohvl blle lxpnsld, tolrl ks neiy nel why enw tn pleltrhtl
bltwlle Musikms hed dlstrny tol Musikm uekty hed Ksihhmkf
brntolronnd . Hed tol why cnr toks ks ke olhrt cuiiy hdolrl tn nur chisl
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 172/206
y c c y c
bliklcs hed kdlninakls, neiy (hs oypnfrktls) suplrckfkhiiy blfnml Musikms,
cnr toks wl ohvl tn neiy rlfktl tol @hikmho hed shy Ehmhhz, toks wl wkii
fnetkeul tn dn neiy suplrckfkhiiy, sn toht wl wkii alt tol crlldnm tn ikvl
hed slttil ke nur nwe hrlhs. Tole wl wkii mh`l Musikms vkftkms nc
hexklty hed dksuekty by dkcclrlet pihes, hed tolkr httletkne wkii bl
dkvlrtld crnm us hed toly wkii alt hahkest lhfo ntolr by letheaikea ke
tolkr nwe fnecikfts. Qole toks wkii ohpple, by blelckttkea crnm toks fkvki
whr nc tol Musikms wl wkii bl hbil tn rlnffupy nur nwe tlrrktnrkls hed
wl wkii rlstnrl nur rlputhtkne
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 173/206
Tol chftnrs toht fnetrkbutld tn tol Ksihhmkf sufflssls wlrlketlesl invl nc tol Himkaoty Hiihho , Oks blinvld ihst Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ), hed tol spkrkt nc Oniy whr
(Gkohhd Ck Vhblli iki Ihho ). Toks fnespkrhtnrkhi arnup hed oks
suppnrtkea cliinws dlfkdld toht wkto wrktkeas, spllfols hed
lvlry pnsskbil why, sufo tokeas wnuid bl ketrndufld ke tol
rlikakne wokfo wnuid fhusl crkftkne hmneast Musikms, hed tol
Gkohhd wnuid blake hmnea tolmslivls hahkest nel hentolr.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 174/206
Tolrlcnrl, h Glw, ‟Hbdui Ihho Bke Vhbhh blfhml tol ilhdlr nc toks mnvlmlet h
cniinwlrs oypnfrktkfhiiy hfflptld Ksihhm.
Toks fnespkrhtnrkhi arnup blahe tn wnr` ne kts ckitoy pihes snmltkmls hctlr tol m
nc
Ohzrht Vhkyykdkeh ‟\mhr Chhrnnq
(Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟Heou). Hed tol trhakf mhrtyrdnm nc
Ohzrht ‟ \smhhe Aohek (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟Heou)
whs hisn tol rlsuit nc tol fnespkrhfy by toks mnst hetk-Ksihhmkf arnup
Toks arnup sprlhd kts prlhfolrs tornuaonut tol
Ksihhmkf Lmpkrl. Toks prnflss ohppleld fnetkeunusiy
crnm alelrhtkne tn alelrhtkne. Tolsl plnpil shw
toht tol Musikms ohd ketlesl invl cnr tolkr Oniy
Zrnpolt Muohmmhd
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm),
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 175/206
sufo invl toht toly lvle shfrkckfl tolkr ikvls, tolkr
wlhito, tolkr lvlrytokea ke tol ehml nc tol oniy
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm), hed tol
rlhsne cnr toks invl ks tol blhuty, tol spilednr hed
tol lxfliilefl nc tol Oniy Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm).
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 176/206
Vn, toks oypnfrktkfhi, hetk-Ksihhmkf arnup hed tolkr s
halets dlfkdld toht uetki toks invl ks ent dlstrnyld, t
strleato nc tol Musikm uekty wkii fhrry ne hed tolkr m
hffnmpiksold. Tolsl plnpil ohd hssurld tol Glws hed
tolkr skeflrkty toht ke rlhikty wl hrl ynurs, cnr toks to
Forkstkhes ohd npleld tolkr trlhsurls cnr t
Tolrlcnrl, tol mlhekeas nc tol Xur‛hhe hed tol Vueeht blahe tn bl hitlrld, tokeas wokfo wlr
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 177/206
c , a c a , a
tn bl fhiild ihwcui hed ihwcui tokeas wlrl dlfihrld ueihwcui , vkrtunus dllds hed (Zrnpoltkf
wlrl fhiild bkdh‛ht (keenvhtkne). Hahkest tol ruils nc tol rlikakne tolsl sn-fhiild ‟ \ihmh nc to
akvle tol sthtus nc Kmhhm hed tolkr nppnelets wlrl fhiild keckdlis, keenvhtnrs hed dlvkhtknek
nc Zrnpoltonnd wlrl mhdl tn mh l tolkr hpplhrhefl. Vlrkls nc dksrlsplft hed kesnilefl ke to
oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm), oks oniy wkvls, oks vlelrhbil fnmpheknes, tol b
oks onuslonid, hed tol crkleds nc Hiihho (Rkdwhheui Ihhok ‟ Hihklokm Hgmh‛lle ) wlrl blahe tn
toht kestlhd nc ehrrhtkea tol quhiktkls nc tolsl pknus plrsnehiktkls tolkr sli c-frlhtld dlclfts
tolkr invl hed dlvntkne tn tolm wnuid bl dlstrnyld crnm tol olhrts nc tol plnpil. Qole plntoht Zrnpolts hed Crkleds nc Hiihho Th‛hhihh ohvl en quhiktkls, toly hrl ik`l ntolr fnmmne pl
skecui tol invl, letouskhsm hed tol dlskrl nc tol plnpil wkii fnml tn he led by ktslic. Qole tol
tol pnwlr tn hft wkii hisn dkmkekso hed tol slrkls nc Gkohhd ltf wkii hisn ckekso
ZRNZOLF[
…
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 178/206
Qkto tol bilsskea nc Hiihho tol @enwlr nc tol \eslle, Oniy Zrn
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 179/206
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) crnm wonm, enel nc tolsl tokeas wlrl okddle, toks Oniy Zrnp
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
ohd hirlhdy tnid tol wnrid ke hdvhefl hbnut toks arnup hed hbnu
fnedktknes surrnuedkea kt.
Tolrlcnrl, hffnrdkea tn Trul Hohhdlls, nefl wole tol on
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) whs dkstrkbutkea t
bnuetkls' nc whr hmneast tol Ksihhmkf hrmy, h plrsne,
Ohrqnns Bke Wuohkr by ehml, hisn fhiild Wui @ouwhkshrho
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 180/206
fhiild nut, ’N Hiihho‛s Zrnpolt! Dn gustkfl.” Ne olhrkea to
uttlrhefl nc tol kesnilet plrsne, tol zlhi nc Kllmhhe nc to
dlvntld invlrs nc Zrnpolt whs hrnusld. Ohzrht '\mhr
Chhrnnq (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟Heou) rlqulstld tol oniy Zrnpol
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) tn plrmkt okm tn led tol
nc toks kesnilet plrsne, hed tn fut okm ketn pklfls wkto oksswnrd. But tol Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiih
dkd ent akvl okm plrmksskne tn dn sn.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 181/206
Ol, onwlvlr, tnid Wui @ouwhkshrho , ’Mhy ynur mntolr wllp nvlr ynu
Zrnpolt nc Hiihho, hed kc K wne't dn gustkfl tole won fnuid bl mnrl gu
letkrl wnrid tohe K>” Hed hddrlsskea oks fnmpheknes, ol shkd, ’Ol wki
hed crnm oks alelrhtkne plnpil wkii `llp fnmkea, `llp fnmkea hed
fnmkea uetki tol ihst plnpil nc tolm wkii gnke tol hrmy nc tol Dhg-g
Ol hisn shkd, ’Tol blst hmnea my \m-mht wkii `kii okm. Tol dhy ol
fnmpheknes wkii bl `kiild ne toht dhy toly wkii bl tol wnrst plnpil hm
\m-mht hed tonsl won wkii `kii tolm wkii bl tol blst hmnea my \m
Qonlvlr ohs tnthi bliklc ke tol plrsnehikty nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok
Qh Vhiihm) ol wkii hisn ohvl hed must ohvl, trul hed plrclft bliklc ke tol trul
shykeas nc tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi
Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohs tnid us lvlrytokea filhriy hahke hed hahke. Tolsl
i d ` i c o i o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 182/206
plnpil mhy fnml ke hey dksauksl mhy lvle `llp hey tktil cnr tolmslivls nr tolkrmnvlmlet, tolkr rlhikty ks hs lvkdlet hs tol brnhd dhy ikaot. \edlr tol prltlxt nc
tlhfokea fnrrlft @hikmho hed Ehmhhz tn skmpil Musikms, tolsl plnpil hrl
pusokea Musikm \m-mht tn tol hbyss nc dlstruftkne hed rukehtkne. Qkto tol hkd
hed fn-nplrhtkne nc Glws, Forkstkhes hed ene-Musikms arnups tolsl prldhtnrs nc
tol chkto hrl leahald ke hetk-Ksihhmkf fnespkrhfkls. Onw fhe sufo plnpil bl
crklediy hed chktocui tn us wole toly hrl ent inyhi nr crklediy tn Himkaoty Hiihho hed
Oks blinvld Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)>
Ol curtolr shkd, ’Tol skaes nc oks prnaley wkii bl tolsl, toly wkii ent ilt tol ohkr arnw ne tolk
wlhr tolkr trnuslrs mufo hbnvl tolkr he`ils, toly wkii shy prhylrs nc inea durhtkne sn toht nt
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 183/206
prhy mkaot toke` nc tolkr nwe prhylrs tn bl ilss lxfliilet.” Ol hisn shkd,
’ Toly wkii rlfktl tol Xur‛hhe wkto dlflet hfflet, but tol Xur'hhe wkii bl mlrliy ne tolkr ikps
blyned tolkr tornhts, mlhekea, kt wkii ohvl en lcclft keskdl tolm.”
Ol hisn shkd,
’Tolkr tneauls wkii bl hs swllt hs suahr but tolkr olhrts wkii bl ohrsolr hed wnrsl tohe
Ol hisn shkd, ’Toly wkii sonw tolmslivls tn bl vlry annd wkto chfl hed hpplhrhefl ltf,
lxpliild crnm tol Dlle (rlikakne) ik`l hed he hrrnw ks drhwe nut nc kts prly. Ol curto
’Tolsl plnpil wkii tolmslivls bl mksild hed wkii sprlhd neiy lvkielss.”
(Mks`ohht Vohrllc, pa <64,6:;, Bu`ohhrk Vohrllc, pa 412, vni-8, pa 324,8:24,882?, vni-2, M
64:, 648 vni-8).
Tol ynutos sonuid rlcilft onw ke toks hal nc mhtlrkhiprnarlss wole sfklefl ohs mhdl sufo hmhzkea
kevletknes, wokfo ohs pihfld tol oumhe kehstneksomlet. Tol mhe ohs slt cnnt ne tol mnne.Tolrl tol bihspolmkf wrktkeas hed wrnea kdlninaklsnc tolsl Dlle-sliikea Muiihhs ohvl dksthefld us tolbliklvlrs crnm tol Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) , wonspikt tol mnne ketn twn by mlrliy pnketkea h ckealr ht
kt cnrm spkrktuhikty hed Dlle. Ke tol ehml ncok (T bi o) kii to ik
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 184/206
prlhfokea (Thbillao) ynu wkii sll tolm smuaaikeahed drua-plddikea but ynu wkii elvlr sll tolm fnmlke fnecikft wkto hey anvlremlet nvlr tol kssuls ncketlrlst. [nu wkii elvlr sll tolm hs`kea plnpil tn
dlskst crnm keduiakea ke skecui hfts ke tol slx mhr`ltsnc Bhea`n`, Blkrut, Bnmbhy nr hey ntolr hrlhs
hrnued tol wnrid. Frnwds nc tolm wkii elvlr bl slle
prlhfokea ht fkelmh onusls. Toly wkii elvlr bl slleprlhfokea eudl plnpil ne blhfols tornuaonut tol
wnrid tn rlfktl tol @hikmho.
Ne tol ntolr ohed toly wnuid an hwhy ne foki-ihs (4: dhys mkssknes) cnr mnetos
ilhvkea bloked tolkr chmkikls tn keduial ke whywhrdelss. Toly wkii ent bl slle
hftkea ne tolsl shykea nc Xur‛hhe hed Vueeht toht wl ohvl mnrl rkaots ne nur
i i k o o To i o c kiik i
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 185/206
finsl rlihtkvls tohe ntolrs. Tolsl plnpil, won cnrfl kiiktlrhtl mhils tn an nut ne
foki-ihs ilhvkea bloked tolkr nid phrlets hed ynuea skstlrs, dhuaotlrs hed wkvls,
toly dne‛t sll toht hitonuao Ohzrht \whkls Xhrek (Rhdkyhi Ihhou ‟Heou) whs
prlslet durkea tol tkml nc tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ylt ol
dkd ent hvhki tol spiledkd nppnrtuekty nc blfnmkea h Vhohhbk (fnmphekne) gust
blfhusl ol ohd oks nid, biked mntolr tn th`l fhrl nc. Tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou
‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ) wnuid inn` tnwhrds [lmle hed shy, ’Tol crharhefl nc invl
fnmls crnm toks dkrlftkne,” hed toly dn ent lvle rlmlmblr woht tol Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohd shkd hbnut Ohzrht \whkls Xhrek (Rhdkyhi
Ihhou ‟Heou).
Tolkr prlhfokea ks elktolr hahkest
Forkstkhekty hed kdni wnrsokppkea e
uegustiy `kiikea nc 1 mkiikne plnpil fih
M ik k K d K k
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 186/206
Musikms ke Krhe hed Krhq, enr hahkbhrbhrksm ke Glrushilm hed ke Mhsgkd
neiy tokea toly dn ks tn mh`l ynu tol
uedlr tol prltlxt nc fnrrlftkea ynur
Ehmhhz hed tole, by dlsfrkbkea tol
ynur Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhihs keckdlikty, vnkd ynu nc hii ynur spk
dksslmkehtkea tolsl phahe tonuaots
fnevlrt tol ene-Musikms ketn M
BLINSLD NC HIIHHO @HRLLM…
Hed Oks Lxfliile
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 187/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 188/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 189/206
Toht Vue-ell Musikm, h sihvl hed h invlrZrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) wnuid hddrlss tol ahnc plnpil tn dlsfrkbl ke toks mheelr … hed shyplnpil! ’K hm h Musikm . Nur chkto ks toht Himkaoty
ks nur Trul Dlkty won ks tol Frlhtnr hed Nwlvlrytokea. Ol frlhtld Ohzrht ‟ Kllshh hed Ohzrht(Hihklokm-us-Vhihhm) hed hisn Rhm nc tol Okedus. Ql blikOhzrht ‟ Kllshh nc tol Forkstkhes hed hisn ke Ohzrht
’ Nur Rhbb shkd, Kc Ol ohd ent frlhtld nur Zrnpolt, tole ol wnuid ohvl ent
mhekclstld Okmslic. Tolrlcnrl, toks letkrl uekvlrsl hed hii kts bilsskeas hrl
dul tn tol arhfl nc nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm ). ’Nur oniy
Zrnpolt's (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) bilssld ehml ks Muohmmhd)
wole wl shy toks nur ikps mllt tn `kss. • Hed hctlr olhrkea wokfo wl hisn `kss
kt hed put kt tn nur lyls, hed wl sled plhfl hed shiuthtkne tn okm. Tol
mlhekea nc toks ehml hisn tliis us kt ks tol ehml nc h plrsnehikty won ohs
blle mnst prhksld Nur Rhbb ohs akvle toks ehml toks ehml ks tliikea us toht
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 190/206
blle mnst prhksld. Nur Rhbb ohs akvle toks ehml, toks ehml ks tliikea us tohttol plrsnehikty blhrkea toks oniy ehml ks prhkslwnrtoy ke lvlry why. Lvle tol
Frlhtnr nc nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm ) prhksls nur Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm ). Qolrlhs lvle ol won prhksls tol Zrnpolt
ks okmslic rhksld tn tol ilvli nc blkea prhkslwnrtoy hed nur Rhbb prhksls okm.
Nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) ohs blle prhksld by Ohzrht
Mnnsh hed Ohzrht 'Kllshh. Tol Thurhht hed tol Keglli mletknes nur Zrnpolt
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) hed tol Bnn` toht dlsfledld upne okm hisn
mletknes oks lxfliilefls. Ohzrht Mnnsh hed Ohzrht 'Kllshh fhml wktomkrhfils, nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) fhml hs h mkrhfil
plrsnekckld.
’Hiihho Himkaoty ohd bilssld Ohzrht Mnnsh hed Ohzrht ‟Kllshh wkto arlht chvnrs Ohzr
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 191/206
Hiihho Himkaoty ohd bilssld Ohzrht Mnnsh hed Ohzrht Kllshh wkto arlht chvnrs. Ohzr
(‛ Hihkloks-Vhihhm) wnuid an tn tol Mnuet Tnnr hed thi` tn nur Rhbb, Ohzrht ‟ Kllshh (‛ H
Vhihhm) whs rhksld hikvl by nur Rhbb tn tol olhvles, hed nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ H
Vhiihm) whs fhiild wkto oks bilssld bndy tn Oks Okaolst Tornel hed akvle he hudklefl
(sonwe Oks vklw). Tol heali won usl tn fnml tn Ohzrht Mnnsh hed Ohzrht ‟ Kllshh (‛ Hi
Vhihhm) hisn fhml tn nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) hahke hed hahke, he
tn nur Zrnpolt Hiihho's ihst fndl nc ikcl tol Xur‛hhe. Toks ks tol snurfl nc aukdhefl uetki
toks wnrid cnr oumhekty. Tol nrkakehi Thurhht hed Keglli hrl ent prlslet tndhy, enr ohs
mlmnrkzld tolm. Ne tol ntolr ohed, tol Xur‛hhe ks prlslrvld ke kts nrkake hed wkii hiwh
sn, wnrd tn wnrd hed vnwli pnket cnr vnwli pnket. Hed tolrl hrl mkiiknes nc tonsl wo
mlmnrkzld kt.
’Ke toks Xur‛hhe , wokfo dlsfledld upne nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) , kdni-wn
cnrbkddle blfhusl wonlvlr wnrsokps heynel lisl blskdls Hiihho ks keckdli Tolsl kdb c b ckt o t To t d k ci ok o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 192/206
cnrbkddle blfhusl wonlvlr wnrsokps heynel lisl blskdls Hiihho ks keckdli. Tolsl kdfhe bl nc en blelckt nr ohrm tn heynel. Toly fheent drkvl hwhy lvle h ciy wokfo
fnmphrksne tn kdnis toks nrdkehry mhe won fhrvls he kdni wkto oks nwe oheds ohs
hed hutonrkty. ’Tol Okedus wnrsokp kdnis, hed onid tolm tn bl lquhi tn Hiihho. N
Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) bnwld tonsl won wnuid bnw blcnrl tonusheds nc chis
Truiy Qnrsokpcui Hiihho, won ks tol Nrkakehtnr nc tol lhrto hed tol s`
Frlhtnr nc ikcl hed dlhto. Toht Hiihho won ohs mhdl tol letkrl uekvlrsl, won
ke tol lhst hed slt ke tol wlst, won ohs akvle us tol bndy hed tol snui, tol w
fnesfknuselss hed ohs blstnwld ueikmktld bilsskea upne us. arhfl, ke fnrdkhikty h
dkvkel mlrfy hed `kedelss, ke blhuty hed fohrhftlr, ke spllfo hed ehturl hed
ohbkts.
Ol dkd fnml ke tol cnrm nc mhe but sufo h mhe toht tolrl ks en mhe ik`l
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 193/206
Ol dkd fnml ke tol cnrm nc mhe but sufo h mhe toht tolrl ks en mhe ik`l
okm ke tol uekvlrsl. Ol ks tol mnst blinvld bnedsmhe nc Hiihho.
Ol ks Hiihho‛s blst Zrnpolt hed tol Mlsslealr. Nur Rhbb invls
okm sn mufo toht hitonuao nur Rhbb won ks oks Frlhtnr hed oks Dlkty, Ol
prhksls hed splh`s ke ainwkea tlrms nc toks blinvld, rlsplftld hed
vhiuld bnedsmhe. Rlmlmblrs‛ okm wkto invl hed rlsplft hed sleds‛shiuthtknes hed plhfl ne okm (Zrnpolt). Nur Rhbb swlhrs wkto invl nc oks
ikcl, oks spllfo, oks fkty hed oks lrh. Fhiis tol invl nc okm (Zrnpolt) hs invl
cnr Okmslic hed nbldklefl tn okm (prnpolt) hs nbldklefl tn Okmslic.
Tol plrsnehikty, httrkbutls, blhuty hed plrclftkne nc nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh V
hrl h mkrrnr tn tol arlhtelss hed httrkbutls nc Himkaoty Hiihho. Hiihho ohd slet okm hs h rh prnnc nc Okmslic sn toht hii frlhtknes wnuid sll hed rlhikzl by inn`kea ht tol arlhtelss, arh
sthtus hed httrkbutls nc toks bnedsmhe, tol Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) onw
wnuid bl Ol wonsl bnedsmhe ks sn arlht. Onw arlht wnuid bl oks Frlhtnr hed oks Nwe
Nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) ks he lvkdlefl nc Trutocuiels
arlhtelss nc nur Rhbb. Nur Rhbb ohs fhiild invl n
c Oks blinvld Zrnpolt (V
Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) hed cniinwkea okm hs tol mlhes nc htthkekea O
pilhsurl hed nur sufflss
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 194/206
pilhsurl hed nur sufflss.
Nur Rhbb ohs mhdl kt mhedhtnry upne us tol rlsplft hed vlelrhtkne nc Oks Zrnpolt (Vh
Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm). Nur Rhbb ohs fhiild tol hrrkvhi nc toks Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihk
Vhiihm) nc Oks tn toks wnrid hs Oks arlhtlst chvnur upne us, blfhusl nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ih
‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) ks tol rlhi fhusl nc tol frlhtkne nc tol letkrl uekvlrsl, tol lhrto hed tol
ks neiy dul tn oks mldkhtkne toht tol frlhtknes ohvl blfnml hwhrl nc Hiihho‛s arlhtelss kdletkty. Tol wnrid blfnmls h sihvl tn okm won blfnmls h trul sihvl tn toks Zrnpolt (Vhiihi
‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm) hed Hiihho's mlrfkls ture hwhy crnm okm won tures hwhy crnm toks Zrn
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklo Qh Vhiihm).
Dlhr rlhdlrs, gust rlcilft, tol oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ks tol blinvld
Hiihho Himkaoty, ks tol Zrnpolt nc tol Zrnpolts hed tol Mlsslealr nc tol Mlsslealrs, ks to
mlrfy tn tol wnrids, ks tol ketlrflssnr ne blohic nc tol skeelrs, ks tol Thhohh (tol rlspiledl
cuii mnne) hed tol [hhslle (tol fnmmhedlr nc mhe`ked), ks tol Bhsollr (tol akvlr nc aihd
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 195/206
cuii mnne) hed tol [hhslle (tol fnmmhedlr nc mhe`ked), ks tol Bhsollr (tol akvlr nc aihdtkdkeas) hed tol Ehzllr (whrelr tn tol whywhrdelss), ks tol Vkrhhg-l-Muellr (tol kiiumkehtk
sue) (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) invl nc okm, nbldklefl tn okm, cniinwkea okm hed sihv
tn okm en dnubt auhrhetll nur sufflss, nur anndelss hed surlty nc nur shivhtkne. Kt ks neiy
tornuao tol mldkhtkne hed ketlrflsskne nc tol blinvld nc Hiihho toht wl ohvl rlflkvl Kllmh
(Chkto), tol Xur‛hhe , Rhmhdhe, lvle tol Rhomhhe (tol Mnst Fnmphssknehtl) Okmslic hed
hisn ant kts enwildal crnm tol mldkhtkne hed snurfl nc tol blinvld nc Hiihho Th‟hhihh.
Kt ks blfhusl nc toks blinvld nc Hiihho (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) toht wl ohvl bllakvle h ekaot wokfo ks blttlr tohe h tonushed mnetos (Ihklihtui-l-Xhdr ). Kt ks blfhusl nc o
mldkhtkne hed oks hiikhefl toht wl ohvl blle akvle tol dkstkeftkne nc blkea tol blst nc h
ntolr ehtknes \mhm.
Kc K wlrl tn an ne ehrrhtkea tol lxfliilefls nc nur oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiih
neiy my ikcl, my vnkfl, my `enwildal hii wnuid lxohust but tol ehrrhtkne nc tol lxfliilefls n
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 196/206
neiy my ikcl, my vnkfl, my `enwildal hii wnuid lxohust but tol ehrrhtkne nc tol lxfliilefls n
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) wnuid ent fnml tn he led. Oks tlhfokeas, toly hrl h slh cui
tolrl ks aukdhefl cnr nur sufflss hed prnarlss ke lvlry why tkii tol led nc tol wnrid. Nei
rlihtknesokp wkto nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) ohd mhdl tolm suplrknr tn h
hekmhis ke tol dlslrts, frlhtld ohvnf, burkld tolkr dhuaotlrs hikvl wkto tolkr nwe oheds
bhrbhrksm whs tolkr wnr`, but wole toly blfhml hssnfkhtld wkto nur Oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi
Vhiihm), hed mhdl tol rlikakne nc nur oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) mh
tolmslivls tole dul tn tol cniinwkea hed kmmlesl invl nc nur oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Htoly blfhml tol fnequlr nc tol wnrid hed tol blinvld nc tol Hiihho @hrllm
’ K kevktl hii nc ynu hisn tn lhre tol anndelss nc toks wnrid hed tol olrlhctlr by cuiiy htthf
nur Chkto hed tn nur oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm ).”
Qoht ks kt toht toks blinvld nc Hiihho
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)
ohs ent akvle us. Kc wl dn ent onenr hed sonw rlsplft tn toks arlhtlst,
tol mnst invld bilsskea hed tol arlhtlst chvnur nc Hiihho tole wl wkii
hisn ent bl hbil tn pilhsl nur Frlhtnr. Nur wnrsokps wkii ent bl
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 197/206
hisn ent bl hbil tn pilhsl nur Frlhtnr. Nur wnrsokps wkii ent bl
hfflptld. Onw fhe nel ohvl tol fihkm nc tol invl cnr Hiihho Ghiih
Vohheuou hed ylt sonw hrrnahefl tn tol arhedlur nc oks blinvld
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Qoht `ked nc illmhhe ks toks> Gust
inn` hrnued! Vnml hrl frktkfkzkea tol Zrnpolts. Vnml hrl dlmlhekea
tol mlmblrs nc tol Zrnpolt's onuslonid, snml hrl shykea bhd tokeas
hbnut tol oniy wkvls nc tol prnpolt, snml hrl frktkfkzkea tol bilssld
fnmpheknes nc tol Zrnpolt, snml hrl frktkfkzkea tol crkleds nc Hiihho,
ynu hs` wonm sonuid wl bliklvl, wonm sonuid wl cniinw>
Inn`, elhriy nel ouedrld hed ckcty ylhrs han, tolrl
wlrl en Dlnbhedk-Qhohhbk-Thbillaok arnups ke tol
Kedn-Zh`ksthe subfnetkelet. Tolsl arnups ohvl blled b o i c i
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 198/206
Kedn Zh`ksthe subfnetkelet. Tolsl arnups ohvl blle prnmptld by tol Ene-Musikms lelmkls nc Ksihhm
won cnr tol sh`l nc clw lhrtoy fnkes hed tolkr chisl
lan hrl blkea hrrnahet tn tol Arhedlur nc tol
Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm), oks
prnaley hed chmkiy, oks fnmpheknes, oks blinvlds.
Toly dne‛t rlmlmblr tolkr nwe led hed HiihhoTh‛hhihh's wrhto.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 199/206
Kt ks tol ledlhvnr nc tol Forkstkhes hed tol GMusikms \m-mht hwhy crnm invkea tol Zrnp
Qh Vhiihm). Hed `llp tolm letheaild mnrl he
tolmslivls. Vn tolkr httletkne ks dkvlrtld c
Musikms. Tol Musikms wkto uedlrsthedkea h
toly dne‛t uedlrsthed tol fnespkrhfkls nc tol
wl fhe neiy rlarlt ne sufo slesls hed uedk d k tok t d t d o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 200/206
y asnmlnel ks dnkea tokeas tn dlstrny hed ohrm
oks lelmy wkii ent stnp okm nr mh`l okm u
Ene-Musikms hrl cuiiy hwhrl toht tol typl n
’ Dlnbhedk, Qhohhbk, Thbillaoks ,” wkii bl h
Toly hrl nc en ohrm tn ene Musikms hed o
hiinwld tolm, tol Thbillaks (prlhfolrs) tn rwnrid crnm fnuetry tn fnuetry fhrrykea tol
tolkr tnkilt pnts.
Ql dne‛t fnmprnmksl wkto okm, dne‛t try tn ohvl crkledsokp wkto okm. Kt ks h pkty
wl fneskdlr nur dlhr nels hed nur rlihtkvls mnrl hdnrhbil hed kmpnrthet tohe H
@hrllm hed tol plrsnehikty nc Oks Mlsslealr (Vhiihi Ihhou‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Toks ks tol neic bi d k k B ki d ‛ b o d o
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 201/206
fhusl nc nur trnubils hed mkslrkls. Blfhusl uetki wl dne‛t blhr tol mnst hed tol
invl tn nur oniy Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) , hrl ent lhalr tn cniinw okm, wl hr
tol plrclft sihvls nc okm, tkii toht tkml wl fheent hfoklvl prnarlss, snikdhrkty, pl
hmkty hed prnsplrkty. Tonsl won ruild tol Xhkshr hed @ksrh (Rnmhe hed Zlrsk
lmplrnrs) toly wlrl tol trul sihvls nc nur Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm)toly o
rlflkvld onenr hed arlhtelss dul tn tol bilsskea nc tolkr sihvlry tn tol Zrnpolt
tndhy elhriy nel bkiikne ke quhetkty tonsl won hrl fihkmlrs nc Kllmhhe toly hrl oumkikhtld by neiy cnur mkiikne Glws. Gust sll hed rlcilft.
F
nefiuskne
…
Ke fnefiuskne, K wkii neiy shy toks mufo tn my rlhdlrs. Qole ynu hrl qulstkneld ke arhvls woht wlrl
tol Mlrfy tn tol uekvlrsls, tol Ikaot plrsnekckld hed tol bilssld ketlrflssnr (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Q
ynur dlhto), hed ke tol arnued nc Gudamlet wole tol sue wkii bl ht h dksthefl nc nel-hed-h-quhrtlwole lvlrybndy wkii bl wnrrkld hbnut tolmslivls fhiikea (Ehcsll Ehcsll) crnm tol wrhto nc Hiihh
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 202/206
wole lvlrybndy wkii bl wnrrkld hbnut tolmslivls fhiikea (Ehcsll, Ehcsll) crnm tol wrhto nc Hiihh
prntlftkne blskdl tol sohdnw nc tol Mlrfy nc Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm). Kc ynu dkl o
hed bihspolmkf bliklcs tole ht toht tkml onw wkii ynu shvl ynurslic crnm tol wrhto nc Hiihho> T
ynurslic.
Nur H‛ihh Ohzrht Kmhhm-l-Hoil Vueeht, Mhuiheh Voho Homhd Rhzh @ohe Bhrlivk (mhy Hiihho o
neiy lpt fhiikea toks,
’ Hhg Il \e`ll Zhehho Hhg Mhdhd Mhhea \e Vl
@hi Eh Mhhehye Al Xkyhhmht Mhye Hahr Mhhe Ahyhh”(Vll` rlcual ke okm (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) tndhy hed hs` cnr oks olip tn
Cnr kc ynu wkii hdmkt, ne tol Dhy nc Gudamlet tole ynu wkii ent bl fneskdlrld.
Fnml , ilt us dkstkeaukso bltwlle crkleds hed lelmkls, rlfnaekzl bltwlle nur
nwe hed tol strhealr, strleatole nur tkls wkto tol trul sihvls nc tol Dkvkel mlrfy
tol blinvld Zrnpolt (Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm) hed blfnml nel hentolr's dlcledlr hed
crkled ke tol ehml nc tol shml Zrnpolt hed wkto uekty hmnea us blfnml ik`l h
ilhd-ckiild snikd whii. [nu must bliklvl Hiihho‛s mlrfy hed olip wkii bl wkto us ht
lvlry mnmlet. Hed arlhtelss, onenr, sufflss hed prnsplrkty wkii bl nur dlstkey.
Cnr kt ohs blle prnfihkmld,
’@ll Muohmmhd Vl Qhchh Tuuel Tun Ohm Tlrhy Ohye
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 203/206
’ @ll Muohmmhd Vl Qhchh Tuuel Tun Ohm Tlrhy Ohye
[lo Ghohhe Follz Ohk @lyhh Ihuo-n-Xhihm Tlrhy Ohye”
(K Myslic hm ynurs kc ynu hrl chktocui tn Muohmmhd
(Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Qh Vhiihm).
Qoht tokea ks toks wnrid, lvle tol Thbilt hed tol Zle wkii bl ynurs)
Qh Vhiihi Ihhou ‟ Hihklok Ohbllbkok Vhky-ykdkeh Muohmmhdke Qh Hhikok Qh Hs
ohhbkok Qh Bhhrh`h Qh Vhiihmh Hgmh‛lle.
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 204/206
@hu`hb-l- E
V
(Mhy Muohmmhke
ne blohic nc
@hrhfok, 8;
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 205/206
7/21/2019 Why the Difference the Truth?-Aakhir Ikhtilaaf Kyun?-Okarvi
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/why-the-difference-the-truth-aakhir-ikhtilaaf-kyun-okarvi 206/206
Fnpyrkaot- Mhuiheh N`hrvk Hfhdlmy Hi‛hihmk-2: