winning election power in turkey, erdogan extends · 2018/6/25  · stems from his campaign promise...

1
VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 58,004 + © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, MONDAY, JUNE 25, 2018 U(D54G1D)y+$!.!#!=!{ The company is appealing a ban in its largest European market, in a test of changes made by its new chief. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-4 Uber Seeks London’s Approval The local Communist Party chief has turned to yoga to bring health and vitality to a fading hamlet. PAGE B1 Yoga on a Chinese Farm ANKARA, Turkey — Turkish voters gave President Recep Tayyip Erdogan a decisive victory in national elections on Sunday, lengthening his 15-year grip on power and granting him vastly ex- panded authority over the legisla- ture and the judiciary. The election was the first to be held since Turkish voters nar- rowly approved a referendum last year to give the president — once a largely ceremonial role sweeping executive powers. Mr. Erdogan will also have a pliant Parliament, with his conservative party and its allies having won about 53 percent of the vote in leg- islative elections on Sunday. Mr. Erdogan has overseen a crackdown on lawyers, judges, civil servants and journalists un- der a state of emergency declared after a failed coup two years ago. His critics had portrayed Sun- day’s election as their last chance to prevent Turkey from becoming an authoritarian state. The victory has potentially grave consequences for coopera- tion within NATO, security in Iraq and Syria, and control of immigra- tion flows into Europe. Turkey has continued to cooper- ate with its Western partners on counterterrorism efforts, but Mr. Erdogan has tested the NATO alli- ance by drawing closer to Presi- dent Vladimir V. Putin of Russia, buying an advanced Russian mis- sile defense system and planning a Russian-built nuclear reactor in Turkey. Like people in other countries where strongmen have gained at the ballot box, many Turkish vot- ers appeared to have accepted Mr. Erdogan’s argument that power- ful centralized authority was es- sential to forge a strong state and guard against terrorist threats. The results released by the offi- cial Anadolu news agency showed Mr. Erdogan with just under 53 percent of the vote, enough to spare him a runoff against his leading challenger, Muharrem Ince, who won nearly 31 percent. At 10:30 p.m., Mr. Erdogan, 64, gave a short televised speech to applauding supporters at the gates of Huber Pavilion, one of his residences in Istanbul. “It seems the nation has en- trusted me with the duty of the presidency, and to us a very big re- sponsibility in the legislature,” Mr. Erdogan said. “Turkey has given a lesson of democracy with a turn- out of close to 90 percent. I hope that some will not provoke to hide ERDOGAN EXTENDS POWER IN TURKEY, WINNING ELECTION KEEPS LEGISLATIVE GRIP Results Likely to Affect NATO and Security in Iraq and Syria By CARLOTTA GALL President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey, waving at a polling station in Istanbul on Sunday, lengthened his 15-year grip on power. CHRIS McGRATH/GETTY IMAGES Continued on Page A9 President Trump unleashed an aggressive attack Sunday on un- authorized immigrants and the ju- dicial system that handles them, saying that those who cross into the United States illegally should be sent back immediately without due process or an appearance be- fore a judge. “We cannot allow all of these people to invade our Country,” Mr. Trump tweeted while on the way to his golf course in Virginia. “When somebody comes in, we must immediately, with no Judges or Court Cases, bring them back from where they came.” It was another twist in a head- spinning series of developments on immigration since the adminis- tration announced a “zero toler- ance” policy two months ago, leading to the separation of chil- dren from parents who cross the border illegally and an outcry from Democrats and many Re- publicans. Mr. Trump signed an executive order to end the separations last week, but the sudden shifts have led to confusion along the border about how children and parents will be reunited and to turmoil in Congress as the House prepares to vote on a sweeping immigration bill this week. Still, the president, who has al- ways dug his heels in when criti- Trump Wants No Due Process At U.S. Border Constitutional Worries After a Fiery Attack By KATIE ROGERS and SHERYL GAY STOLBERG Continued on Page A14 XINGFU, China — Last month, scientists disclosed a global pollu- tion mystery: a surprise rise in emissions of an outlawed industri- al gas that destroys the atmos- phere’s protective ozone layer. The unexpected increase is un- dermining what has been hailed as the most successful interna- tional environmental agreement ever enacted: the Montreal Proto- col, which includes a ban on chlorofluorocarbons, or CFCs, and which was expected to bring a full recovery of the ozone layer by midcentury. But the source of the pollution has remained unknown. Now, a trail of clues leads to this scrappy industrial boomtown in rural China. Interviews, documents and ad- vertisements collected by The New York Times and independent investigators indicate that a ma- jor source — possibly the over- whelming one — is factories in China that have ignored a global ban and kept making or using the chemical, CFC-11, mostly to produce foam insulation for re- frigerators and buildings. “You had a choice: Choose the cheaper foam agent that’s not so good for the environment, or the expensive one that’s better for the environment,” said Zhang Wenbo, owner of a refrigerator factory here in Xingfu, in Shandong Prov- ince, where he and many other small-scale manufacturers said that until recently, they had used CFC-11 widely to make foam insu- lation. “Of course, we chose the cheaper foam agent,” Mr. Zhang said during an interview in his of- fice. “That’s how we survived.” As he spoke, a crackdown was underway in the town and mo- ments later, four officials entered Mr. Zhang’s factory, handed him a leaflet warning against a range of An Environmental Win Falters. Why? Some Clues Point to China. By CHRIS BUCKLEY and HENRY FOUNTAIN Continued on Page A10 The Mysterious Rise of a Banned Chemical SILVER SPRING, Md. — Their rock star had arrived. As the sun set on a sticky June evening, hundreds of supporters screamed. They chanted his name. They tried to get close enough to touch him. “You all ready to make a poli- tical revolution?” Senator Bernie Sanders, the Vermont independ- ent, asked them last week, fist pumping, voice booming. Then, for more than 15 minutes, he riffed on his familiar themes: “Medicare for All,” tuition-free public college, a $15 minimum wage. Someone held a sign urging a 2020 presi- dential run. Mr. Sanders, however, was not campaigning for himself. At least not explicitly. Ahead of the Maryland primary this Tuesday, Mr. Sanders had made the short trip from Capitol Hill to this Washington suburb to campaign with Ben Jealous, a for- mer leader of the N.A.A.C.P. and one of the state’s top Democratic candidates for governor. The rally was part of what Mr. Sanders and his allies say is a cross-country en- dorsement strategy intended to help spread his ideological mes- sage. But the race in Maryland has also become a critical test of Mr. Sanders’s ability to sway elec- tions. If his policy agenda has caught on widely among Demo- cratic candidates, and succeeded in moving the party to the left, Mr. Sanders himself has struggled so far to expand his political base and propel his personal allies to vic- tory in Democratic primaries. Sanders’s Allies Stumble as His Cause Takes Off By SYDNEY EMBER and ALEXANDER BURNS Continued on Page A15 Senator Bernie Sanders has offered few endorsements. TOYA SARNO JORDAN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES PLYMOUTH, Wis. — It’s a com- mon observation here that you can’t turn off the cows — not for Christmas, and not for a trade war. So as President Trump’s ag- gressive trade measures prompt other countries to retaliate with barriers to American goods, dairy farmers and cheesemakers in the rolling, bright green hills of Wis- consin are growing anxious about what will happen to all of the milk and cheese they churn out and typically sell overseas. “If export markets get shut off, I could see us getting to the point where we’re dumping our milk in the fields,” said Jeff Schwager, the president of Sartori Company, which has produced cheese in a nearby town for generations with milk it purchases from more than 100 dairy farms throughout Wis- consin. “It’ll be a big ripple effect through the state.” Mr. Trump has set off trade clashes with countries around the world, demanding new trade agreements and slapping tariffs on allies to reset what he says are deeply unfair terms that hurt American companies and work- ers. He has singled out certain American industries that he says are at a global disadvantage, in- cluding automobiles and dairy — which led to a public spat between Mr. Trump and the Canadian prime minister, Justin Trudeau, over Canada’s dairy tariffs. The president’s trade approach stems from his campaign promise to revive American industry, par- ticularly manufacturing, by putting “America First.” That promise helped propel Mr. Trump A Trade War Hits Home for U.S. Cheesemakers By ANA SWANSON Continued on Page A13 The U.S. dairy industry is vul- nerable to retaliatory tariffs. NARAYAN MAHON FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES GABRIELLA ANGOTTI-JONES/THE NEW YORK TIMES Two onlookers making a heart with their hands during New York City’s Pride March on Sunday. A Day for Rainbows The pearl bracelet arrived in May 2014, in the spring of Ali Watkins’s senior year in college, a graduation gift from a man many years her senior. It was the sort of bauble that might imply some- thing more deeply felt than friend- ship — but then again, might not. Ms. Watkins, then a 22-year-old intern in the Washington bureau of McClatchy Newspapers, was not entirely surprised. She had met James Wolfe, a 50-something senior aide to the Senate Intelli- gence Committee, while hunting for scoops on Capitol Hill. He had become a helpful source, but there were times when he seemed inter- ested in other pursuits — like when he presented her with a Val- entine’s Day card. On that occasion, Ms. Watkins explained to Mr. Wolfe that their relationship was strictly profes- sional. The bracelet suggested that her message had not gotten through. She asked an editor for advice, and was told that as long as the gift was not exorbitant — no stock in a company, the editor joshed — it was fine. Ms. Watkins kept the bracelet. The story of what happened next — of a three-year affair that unfolded between a young report- er and a government official with access to top-secret information — is now part of a federal investi- gation that has rattled the world of Washington journalists and the sources they rely on. Mr. Wolfe, 57, was arrested on How Affair Between Journalist And Senate Aide Rattled Media This article is by Michael M. Gryn- baum, Scott Shane and Emily Flit- ter. Continued on Page A16 RED TAPE A released Brazilian migrant has struggled with bu- reaucratic hurdles to recovering her 9-year-old son. PAGE A14 Prune Nourry’s sculpture, on view in the meatpacking district, honors women who have battled breast cancer. PAGE C1 Tribute to Cancer Survivors Israel has long wanted to clear the West Bank of Bedouin herders to build settle- ments. It will start soon. PAGE A4 INTERNATIONAL A4-10 Israel Pushing Out Herders A new law will allow Medicare plans to provide extra benefits to patients with multiple chronic illnesses. PAGE A12 NATIONAL A11-16 Enhanced Medicare Coverage The scourge of school shootings raises questions on how theater departments depict weapons. PAGE C1 ARTS C1-8 Portraying Guns in School Plays FIFA is looking into gestures made by players. Any suspensions could shake the tournament. PAGE D1 SPORTSMONDAY D1-10 Politics Collide at World Cup David Leonhardt PAGE A23 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23 The English trounced Panama, 6-1, at the World Cup, giving their often pes- simistic fans a reason for hope. PAGE D1 England Erupts, and Advances Under President Trump, once stately medallions have gotten glitzier, and some are blurring ethical lines. PAGE A11 Presidential Coins With Bling Faced with dismal polls, the ruling party is pulling the levers of govern- ment to try to stay in power. PAGE A5 Hardball Politics in Mexico Stephanie Clifford, the actress known as Stormy Daniels, was set to meet with prosecutors investigating Michael D. Cohen, but officials canceled. PAGE A17 NEW YORK A17-21 Interview on Cohen Called Off Donald Hall, a prolific writer and poet laureate whose beloved New England farm inspired his reflections on the majesty of rural life, was 89. PAGE D12 OBITUARIES D11-12 Poet of the Glorious Ordinary Late Edition Today, sunny, patchy clouds, less hu- mid, high 81. Tonight, clear, low 62. Tomorrow, sunny to partly cloudy, continued low humidity, high 77. Weather map appears on Page B5. $3.00

Upload: others

Post on 01-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WINNING ELECTION POWER IN TURKEY, ERDOGAN EXTENDS · 2018/6/25  · stems from his campaign promise to revive American industry, par-ticularly manufacturing, by putting America First

VOL. CLXVII . . . No. 58,004 + © 2018 The New York Times Company NEW YORK, MONDAY, JUNE 25, 2018

C M Y K Nxxx,2018-06-25,A,001,Bs-4C,E2_+

U(D54G1D)y+$!.!#!=!{

The company is appealing a ban in itslargest European market, in a test ofchanges made by its new chief. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-4

Uber Seeks London’s Approval

The local Communist Party chief hasturned to yoga to bring health andvitality to a fading hamlet. PAGE B1

Yoga on a Chinese Farm

ANKARA, Turkey — Turkishvoters gave President RecepTayyip Erdogan a decisive victoryin national elections on Sunday,lengthening his 15-year grip onpower and granting him vastly ex-panded authority over the legisla-ture and the judiciary.

The election was the first to beheld since Turkish voters nar-rowly approved a referendum lastyear to give the president — oncea largely ceremonial role —sweeping executive powers. Mr.Erdogan will also have a pliantParliament, with his conservativeparty and its allies having wonabout 53 percent of the vote in leg-islative elections on Sunday.

Mr. Erdogan has overseen acrackdown on lawyers, judges,civil servants and journalists un-der a state of emergency declaredafter a failed coup two years ago.His critics had portrayed Sun-day’s election as their last chanceto prevent Turkey from becomingan authoritarian state.

The victory has potentiallygrave consequences for coopera-tion within NATO, security in Iraqand Syria, and control of immigra-tion flows into Europe.

Turkey has continued to cooper-ate with its Western partners oncounterterrorism efforts, but Mr.Erdogan has tested the NATO alli-ance by drawing closer to Presi-dent Vladimir V. Putin of Russia,buying an advanced Russian mis-sile defense system and planninga Russian-built nuclear reactor inTurkey.

Like people in other countrieswhere strongmen have gained atthe ballot box, many Turkish vot-ers appeared to have accepted Mr.Erdogan’s argument that power-ful centralized authority was es-sential to forge a strong state andguard against terrorist threats.

The results released by the offi-cial Anadolu news agency showedMr. Erdogan with just under 53percent of the vote, enough tospare him a runoff against hisleading challenger, MuharremInce, who won nearly 31 percent.

At 10:30 p.m., Mr. Erdogan, 64,gave a short televised speech toapplauding supporters at thegates of Huber Pavilion, one of hisresidences in Istanbul.

“It seems the nation has en-trusted me with the duty of thepresidency, and to us a very big re-sponsibility in the legislature,” Mr.Erdogan said. “Turkey has given alesson of democracy with a turn-out of close to 90 percent. I hopethat some will not provoke to hide

ERDOGAN EXTENDSPOWER IN TURKEY,WINNING ELECTION

KEEPS LEGISLATIVE GRIP

Results Likely to AffectNATO and Security

in Iraq and Syria

By CARLOTTA GALL

President Recep Tayyip Erdogan of Turkey, waving at a polling station in Istanbul on Sunday, lengthened his 15-year grip on power.CHRIS McGRATH/GETTY IMAGES

Continued on Page A9

President Trump unleashed anaggressive attack Sunday on un-authorized immigrants and the ju-dicial system that handles them,saying that those who cross intothe United States illegally shouldbe sent back immediately withoutdue process or an appearance be-fore a judge.

“We cannot allow all of thesepeople to invade our Country,” Mr.Trump tweeted while on the wayto his golf course in Virginia.“When somebody comes in, wemust immediately, with no Judgesor Court Cases, bring them backfrom where they came.”

It was another twist in a head-spinning series of developmentson immigration since the adminis-tration announced a “zero toler-ance” policy two months ago,leading to the separation of chil-dren from parents who cross theborder illegally and an outcryfrom Democrats and many Re-publicans.

Mr. Trump signed an executiveorder to end the separations lastweek, but the sudden shifts haveled to confusion along the borderabout how children and parentswill be reunited and to turmoil inCongress as the House preparesto vote on a sweeping immigrationbill this week.

Still, the president, who has al-ways dug his heels in when criti-

Trump WantsNo Due ProcessAt U.S. Border

Constitutional Worries After a Fiery Attack

By KATIE ROGERSand SHERYL GAY STOLBERG

Continued on Page A14

XINGFU, China — Last month,scientists disclosed a global pollu-tion mystery: a surprise rise inemissions of an outlawed industri-al gas that destroys the atmos-phere’s protective ozone layer.

The unexpected increase is un-dermining what has been hailedas the most successful interna-tional environmental agreementever enacted: the Montreal Proto-col, which includes a ban on

chlorofluorocarbons, or CFCs, andwhich was expected to bring a fullrecovery of the ozone layer bymidcentury. But the source of thepollution has remained unknown.

Now, a trail of clues leads to thisscrappy industrial boomtown inrural China.

Interviews, documents and ad-

vertisements collected by TheNew York Times and independentinvestigators indicate that a ma-jor source — possibly the over-whelming one — is factories inChina that have ignored a globalban and kept making or using thechemical, CFC-11, mostly toproduce foam insulation for re-frigerators and buildings.

“You had a choice: Choose thecheaper foam agent that’s not sogood for the environment, or theexpensive one that’s better for theenvironment,” said Zhang Wenbo,owner of a refrigerator factory

here in Xingfu, in Shandong Prov-ince, where he and many othersmall-scale manufacturers saidthat until recently, they had usedCFC-11 widely to make foam insu-lation.

“Of course, we chose thecheaper foam agent,” Mr. Zhangsaid during an interview in his of-fice. “That’s how we survived.”

As he spoke, a crackdown wasunderway in the town and mo-ments later, four officials enteredMr. Zhang’s factory, handed him aleaflet warning against a range of

An Environmental Win Falters. Why? Some Clues Point to China.By CHRIS BUCKLEY

and HENRY FOUNTAIN

Continued on Page A10

The Mysterious Rise ofa Banned Chemical

SILVER SPRING, Md. — Theirrock star had arrived.

As the sun set on a sticky Juneevening, hundreds of supportersscreamed. They chanted hisname. They tried to get closeenough to touch him.

“You all ready to make a poli-tical revolution?” Senator BernieSanders, the Vermont independ-ent, asked them last week, fistpumping, voice booming. Then,for more than 15 minutes, he riffedon his familiar themes: “Medicarefor All,” tuition-free public college,a $15 minimum wage. Someoneheld a sign urging a 2020 presi-dential run.

Mr. Sanders, however, was notcampaigning for himself. At leastnot explicitly.

Ahead of the Maryland primarythis Tuesday, Mr. Sanders hadmade the short trip from Capitol

Hill to this Washington suburb tocampaign with Ben Jealous, a for-mer leader of the N.A.A.C.P. andone of the state’s top Democraticcandidates for governor. The rallywas part of what Mr. Sanders andhis allies say is a cross-country en-dorsement strategy intended tohelp spread his ideological mes-sage.

But the race in Maryland hasalso become a critical test of Mr.Sanders’s ability to sway elec-tions. If his policy agenda hascaught on widely among Demo-cratic candidates, and succeededin moving the party to the left, Mr.Sanders himself has struggled sofar to expand his political base andpropel his personal allies to vic-tory in Democratic primaries.

Sanders’s Allies Stumble as His Cause Takes OffBy SYDNEY EMBER

and ALEXANDER BURNS

Continued on Page A15

Senator Bernie Sanders hasoffered few endorsements.

TOYA SARNO JORDAN FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

PLYMOUTH, Wis. — It’s a com-mon observation here that youcan’t turn off the cows — not forChristmas, and not for a trade war.

So as President Trump’s ag-gressive trade measures promptother countries to retaliate withbarriers to American goods, dairyfarmers and cheesemakers in therolling, bright green hills of Wis-consin are growing anxious aboutwhat will happen to all of the milkand cheese they churn out andtypically sell overseas.

“If export markets get shut off, Icould see us getting to the pointwhere we’re dumping our milk inthe fields,” said Jeff Schwager, thepresident of Sartori Company,

which has produced cheese in anearby town for generations withmilk it purchases from more than100 dairy farms throughout Wis-consin. “It’ll be a big ripple effectthrough the state.”

Mr. Trump has set off tradeclashes with countries around theworld, demanding new tradeagreements and slapping tariffson allies to reset what he says aredeeply unfair terms that hurtAmerican companies and work-ers. He has singled out certainAmerican industries that he saysare at a global disadvantage, in-cluding automobiles and dairy —which led to a public spat betweenMr. Trump and the Canadianprime minister, Justin Trudeau,over Canada’s dairy tariffs.

The president’s trade approachstems from his campaign promiseto revive American industry, par-ticularly manufacturing, byputting “America First.” Thatpromise helped propel Mr. Trump

A Trade War Hits Home for U.S. CheesemakersBy ANA SWANSON

Continued on Page A13

The U.S. dairy industry is vul-nerable to retaliatory tariffs.

NARAYAN MAHON FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

GABRIELLA ANGOTTI-JONES/THE NEW YORK TIMES

Two onlookers making a heart with their hands during New York City’s Pride March on Sunday.A Day for Rainbows

The pearl bracelet arrived inMay 2014, in the spring of AliWatkins’s senior year in college, agraduation gift from a man manyyears her senior. It was the sort ofbauble that might imply some-thing more deeply felt than friend-ship — but then again, might not.

Ms. Watkins, then a 22-year-oldintern in the Washington bureauof McClatchy Newspapers, wasnot entirely surprised. She hadmet James Wolfe, a 50-somethingsenior aide to the Senate Intelli-gence Committee, while huntingfor scoops on Capitol Hill. He hadbecome a helpful source, but therewere times when he seemed inter-ested in other pursuits — likewhen he presented her with a Val-

entine’s Day card.On that occasion, Ms. Watkins

explained to Mr. Wolfe that theirrelationship was strictly profes-sional. The bracelet suggestedthat her message had not gottenthrough. She asked an editor foradvice, and was told that as longas the gift was not exorbitant — nostock in a company, the editorjoshed — it was fine.

Ms. Watkins kept the bracelet.The story of what happened

next — of a three-year affair thatunfolded between a young report-er and a government official withaccess to top-secret information— is now part of a federal investi-gation that has rattled the world ofWashington journalists and thesources they rely on.

Mr. Wolfe, 57, was arrested on

How Affair Between JournalistAnd Senate Aide Rattled Media

This article is by Michael M. Gryn-baum, Scott Shane and Emily Flit-ter.

Continued on Page A16

RED TAPE A released Brazilianmigrant has struggled with bu-reaucratic hurdles to recoveringher 9-year-old son. PAGE A14

Prune Nourry’s sculpture, on view in themeatpacking district, honors womenwho have battled breast cancer. PAGE C1

Tribute to Cancer Survivors

Israel has long wanted to clear the WestBank of Bedouin herders to build settle-ments. It will start soon. PAGE A4

INTERNATIONAL A4-10

Israel Pushing Out HerdersA new law will allow Medicare plans toprovide extra benefits to patients withmultiple chronic illnesses. PAGE A12

NATIONAL A11-16

Enhanced Medicare CoverageThe scourge of school shootings raisesquestions on how theater departmentsdepict weapons. PAGE C1

ARTS C1-8

Portraying Guns in School PlaysFIFA is looking into gestures made byplayers. Any suspensions could shakethe tournament. PAGE D1

SPORTSMONDAY D1-10

Politics Collide at World Cup

David Leonhardt PAGE A23

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A22-23

The English trounced Panama, 6-1, atthe World Cup, giving their often pes-simistic fans a reason for hope. PAGE D1

England Erupts, and AdvancesUnder President Trump, once statelymedallions have gotten glitzier, andsome are blurring ethical lines. PAGE A11

Presidential Coins With BlingFaced with dismal polls, the rulingparty is pulling the levers of govern-ment to try to stay in power. PAGE A5

Hardball Politics in Mexico

Stephanie Clifford, the actress known asStormy Daniels, was set to meet withprosecutors investigating Michael D.Cohen, but officials canceled. PAGE A17

NEW YORK A17-21

Interview on Cohen Called OffDonald Hall, a prolific writer and poetlaureate whose beloved New Englandfarm inspired his reflections on themajesty of rural life, was 89. PAGE D12

OBITUARIES D11-12

Poet of the Glorious Ordinary

Late EditionToday, sunny, patchy clouds, less hu-mid, high 81. Tonight, clear, low 62.Tomorrow, sunny to partly cloudy,continued low humidity, high 77.Weather map appears on Page B5.

$3.00