working table cultural he ritag e
DESCRIPTION
Working Table Cultural He ritag e. the Hague 2012. G.W.O. Boissevain Msc. Content. Working Table Projects Grey zone Cases. Working Table Cultural Heritage. Meetings and projects. Projects 2009-2011 Cultural Heritage Portfolio >>> report (2011) - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Working Table Cultural Heritage
G.W.O. Boissevain Msc
the Hague 2012
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Content
• Working Table• Projects• Grey zone• Cases
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
3
Working Table Cultural Heritage
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Sweden Marja-Leena Pilvesmaa Statens fastighetsverk
Ellen Björk Statens fastighetsverk
Italy Daniele Clavenzani Agenzia del Demanio
The Netherlands Gustaaf Boissevain Directie Rijksvastgoed
Arno Wijtenburg Rijksgebouwendienst
Norway Gisle Erlien Statsbygg
Ulrika Bergström Statsbygg
Finland Juha Lemström Senaatti-kiinteistöt
Mitro Mero Senaatti-kiinteistöt
2009June 2009 Stockholm2010Feb 2010 RomeMarch 2010 web meetingNov 2010 Amsterdam2011April 2011 web meetingMay 2011 Londen2012January 2012 web meetingApril 2012 StockholmJune 2012 web meetingSept 2012 web meetingOct 2012 video meeting2013Jan 2013 workshop ?
Projects2009-20111. Cultural Heritage Portfolio >>>
report (2011)2. Redevelopment of Cultural
Heritage properties
2012-2013…3. Basic information about Cultural
Heritage (per country)4. Strategies for the “grey zone”
Pure-Net | 19 september 20124
Meetings and projects
5
Portfolio of the State
C Obsolete
No strategic goal or future plans
State ownership
Private ownership
D For sale
For sale to market
B Reserve (flexible)
For strategic goals or future plans
A Basic need
Related to goals of the State
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
6
Portfolio of the State
C Obsolete
No strategic goal or future plans
Necessary for the StateNot necessary for the
State
Grey zone
State ownership
Private ownership
D For sale
For sale to market
B Reserve (flexible)
For strategic goals or future plans
A Basic need
Related to goals of the State
STRA
TEG
IES
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
7
Portfolio of the State
C Obsolete
No strategic goal or future plans
Keep properties
Look for various forms of use (incl. temporary flexible contracts)Look for alternative forms of financial arrangements
Develop markets and usersLook for alternative forms of use, financial arrangements and forms of ownership
Necessary for the StateNot necessary for the
State
Grey zone
State ownership
Private ownership
D For sale
For sale to market
B Reserve (flexible)
For strategic goals or future plans
A Basic need
Related to goals of the State
STRA
TEG
IES
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
8
Criteria Ownership of Cultural Heritage by the State(arguments not to sell)
Sweden
Norway
Finland
Italy The Netherlands
Cultural history value X X
History of the State X X
Symbolic value X
Safety of the nation X
State tenants/ use by government organisations X X X
Public interest by nature (“Demanio”) X
Public interest by destination (“Demanio”) X
Temporary public interest X
Historic acquisition X X
Finances (costs vs rent) X X
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
9
Financing Cultural Heritage Sweden
Norway
Finland
Italy The Netherlands
Rent from government organisations cover management costs X X X X
Parliamentary grants (not financed by return on rents) X X
Rent from leases to private parties X (x) X X X
Sales of byproducts (biomass, wood, etc) X
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Selling of Cultural Heritage Sweden
Norway
Finland
Italy The Netherlands
“Demanio” (assets with public interest by nature of destination) can be sold
X X X
Assets with temporary public interest can be sold X X X X
Historic assets can be sold X X X X
Cases
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
10
11
1. Rent and open to publicSalsta Castle, 1672-78State owned (Sweden).
Problem• Difficulties to cover costs by rental income• Long-term tenant while keeping the castle open for the
public (two last tenants went bankrupt).
Goal• Keeping it open for the public;• Long-term lease.• . Strategy• The tenant rents part of the castle for conferences and
other events. • Rent increases over three years.• The tenant must give guided tours in the castle (min.
three times a year) and is allowed to use the whole castle for tours as a part of conferences and events.
• Promotion of success of the tenants business.
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Bohus Fortress, Swedena ruin since 1789
Problem• Maintenance problematic due to lack of resources, neglect,
inappropriate conservation.• No basic infrastructure for visitors.
Goal• to become one of the most known historical places to visit
in Scandinavia,• to attract more than 170 000 income generating visitors
yearly • contribute strongly to regional and local social
development.
Strategy• 10 year development plan in cooperation with the
municipality, 2010 – 2020 • Municipal company for the development and funding.
Bohus is participating in IKON, an Interreg Project financed by EU 2009-2012
.
Pure-Net | 19 september 201212
2.Develop historic site
13
3.Potential tenantsBlaker skanse, North of Oslo. Part of the historic defence line against Sweden. Transformed in a college. - 10 buildings, over 7 000 m2, from 1683 – 1977- Protected by the Cultural Heritage Act.- In 2011 placed in the small portfolio with grant
directly financed by Parliament.
Problem- Vacant since 2003. - Contracts with private organisations without
results.- Weak property market in the area.
GoalFind potential tenants who are willing to pay.
Strategy- Negotiation of a small private company and an
association of artists to rent the property at a cost as low as possible. The outcome of this process is uncertain.
- If no satisfactory solution is reached, state ownership may be questioned.
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
14
4.Choices for re-useNational Gallery, Oslo, Norway- 9000 m2, from 1882, 1908 to 1924- Protected by the Cultural Heritage Act- Central location
Problem- Museum for Arts, Crafts and Design will move into a
new building in 2017-18. - Heated public debate on the use of the building and
the adjoining public space- What level of investment is politically acceptable?- Choice for one large or for several smaller
institutions?- The University museum of Cultural History may be
interested, but have not committed themselves yet.
GoalRe-use
Strategy- Four different scenarios for future use are
developed to stimulate strategic discussions in the government.
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
15
5.Public consultationPeschiera del Garda (Verona), ItalyFormer barracks (33.500 m2)
Problem• New approach to redevelopment for State property by
Agenzia del Demanio;
Goal• Create conditions for an public-public partnership
between the State players and local Authorities;• Long lease concession (up to 50 years) for private
national/international parties; to be rented by the State;
Strategy• Public consultation as new tool for participation of
citizens, companies and financial parties; • Agreement between National investments and
developing Agency and the National Association of Italian Municipalities;
• Adapted town planning of the Historic Centre by Municipality (2011);
• Scenarios for converting registered property with public, social and rental functions (mostly tourist-accommodation and commercial ).
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
6. Redevelop heritageHembrug complex, Zaanstad, the NetherlandsFormer guns and munitions factory + MOD test site; Good location (industry, Amsterdam) on major shipping route.42,5 ha with 125 derelict industrial buildings (65 listed buildings) dating from 1897 to 2003 ; 90.000m2; Woods, canals, nature reserve, etc
Problem• Soil pollution and zoning (ships with dangerous substances)
limit use;• Since 2003 vacant, no clear redevelopment policy;• Reluctant (local and State) authorities.
GoalRedevelop and sell
Strategy• Agreement between State, Province and Local Council
about step-by-step approach with open end; • Restoration of first of 65 listed monuments (2012);• Cleaning of soil pollution (oil, mustard gas, etc);• Short term contracts and (temporary) use; Temporary
activities and use to cherish location; See and love it.
Pure-Net | 19 september 201216
7.Redevelop heritageIndustrial complex since 1800, KAIKUKATU 5, Helsinki, FinlandGrain silos, a smithy and foundry, a mill and storage, different type of industrial usage.
Good location but not yet prime. Region transforming from industrial to offices and housing.
Problem• Major contamination fond. • Demolition as an option for 3 of the 5 buildings due to
protection problematic. • Transformation problematic due to CH protection.
GoalProperty class A with safe and healthy office spaces, after years of "grey zone".
Strategy• New zoning makes transformation and demolition possible. • Plans for about 15.000 m2 of new or renovated office for
Tax Administration with a total investment budget of around 52 million euro.
Pure-Net | 19 september 201217
8.Less than balance valueOffices, Heerlen, The Netherlands43.500m2 offices (1974-84) , since 2009 partially vacantExcellent location; Excellent technical condition; Partially in use as temporary offices for starting firms,
Problem• Still in use by Governmental Revenue office (6.000m2) • Heritage of the coal age (National Mining Museum)• Office for city council cancelled due to economical crisis;• Too large for mono-function;• Shrinkage region with high unemployment• Maintenance costs and balance sheet value (15 million)
GoalDecrease costs
Strategy• Creative workshop with stakeholders (April 2011);• Accept loss on balance sheet of 14,5 million: Sold for 0,5
million to private company with help of municipally (May 2012)
• Development into urban farming, offices, creative and cultural functions and housing for students. Creation of est. new 700 workplaces.
Pure-Net | 19 september 201218
9.Better business modelBlokhuispoort, Leeuwarden, the NetherlandsFormer State prison (since 1499-2007)Since 2007 many temporary cultural activities and users (a.o. 120 creative businesses) and museum (2010-2012);Strong relation to the city; of great social importance for inhabitants of Leeuwarden; historical site (WO II) with many monumental (listed) buildings;
Problem• Temporary activities do not pay rent;• Redevelopment only possible with a solution for parking;• High balance sheet value, maintenance and protection
costs;• Strong local pressure groups and squatters.
GoalRedevelopment and sale
Strategy• Market consultation (2011/12) as base for
redevelopment;• Agreement with city council expected (2012)• End of temporary use for free;• Develop parking facilities in the city centre.
19 Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
10.Uneconomical officesEROTTAJA, Helsinki, FinlandSell government owned offices, Very good location with enough market potential.
Problem• Large repairs (accessibility, air conditioning, etc) necessary
to meet today's workplace requirements.• Location not suitable for Finnish Customs or any other
government use.• Investment impractical and/or uneconomical. • Only developers are interested. They see only risks and the
risks affect the price.
GoalSell to market parties.
StrategyAdapt current zoning for public buildings.
Pure-Net | 19 september 201220
21
11.Overcome limitations
Dømmesmoen in Agder, NorwayFormer academy of horticulture, since 2010- 147 acre, 25 buildings from 1700 – 2002,
10 000 m2, (several protected) - archaeological sites, landscape and nature
preservation zones.- Strong wish of further state ownership to guarantee
preservation (local and national);Problem• limitations due to preservation rules, limited
possibilities to adaptation to new use• The project (started in 2006) did not succeed in
finding users;• Rent within current regulations for Statsbyggs
activities not possible;• No alternative governmental tenant found.
GoalSell property (2009)
Strategywith approval from the minister, the property is sold to Grimstad municipality at approx. 3 000 000 nok (March 2012)
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
22
Problem Strategy B C D
1 Rent and open to public
Salsta castle, Sweden Keep castle open with long-term tenants
Finding long-term tenant X
2 Develop historic site
Bohus fortressSweden
NeglectNo infrastructure for visitors
10 year development plan X
3 Potential tenants Blaker skanse,Norway
Finding tenants to cover costsor state ownership is at risk.
Negotiation with interested party for low rent
? ?
4 Choices for re-use National Gallery, Norway
What investment is politically acceptable?Public debate over use
4 scenario’s X
5 Public consultation
Peschiera del Garda (Verona),Italy
Create conditions for PPPNew approach to redevelopment
Long term lease concession to private national/ international actors (up to 50 years)
X
Cases (1)
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Concept
23
Problem Strategy B C D
6 Redevelop heritage
Hembrug complex,The Netherlands
derelict industrial buildings Limited use due to soil pollution and zoning
Agreement local authorities; Step-by-step;Clean soil, start restoration;
? X
7 Redevelop heritage
Kaikukatu, Finland CH-Protection limits update to modern offices
New zoning X
8 Less than balance value
CBS-complex, Heerlen, The Netherlands
Balance sheet value (15 million) vs real value (0,5 million)
Accept loss on balance sheet of 14,5 million
X
9 Better business model
Blokhuispoort, Leeuwarden,The Netherlands
Redevelop former State prison
Market consultationAgreement local municipalityParking facilities
? X
10 Uneconomical offices
Erottaja,Finland
Investment impractical and/or uneconomical
Adapt zoning X
11 Overcome limitation
Dömmesmoen,Norway
Limited options (state) ownership to guarantee preservation in the future.
Sold to Grimstad municipality
X
Cases (2)
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Concept
24
Questions1. Compare strategies
• Interesting subjects?• What is applicable at home?
2. Cultural Heritage portfolio: • Specific policy needed ?• As part of Real Estate policy ?
Pure-Net | 19 september 2012
Questions?
Pure-Net | 19 september 201225