www.crtech.com c&r technologies, inc. phone 303.971.0292 fax 303.971.0035 fdm/fem system-level...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
www.crtech.com
C&R Technologies, Inc.Phone 303.971.0292
Fax 303.971.0035
FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments
Aerospace Thermal Control Workshop 2005
Brent Cullimore, Jane Baumann
![Page 2: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
The Need for Analysis
The user’s confidence in any technology is based in part on its predictability The ability to model predictable behavior The ability to bound unpredictable behavior
Must have compatibility with industry standard thermal analysis tools, including radiation/orbital analyzers
Should be able to integrate with concurrent engineering methods such as CAD and structural/FEM
![Page 3: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
How Not to Model a Heat Pipe:Common Misconceptions
“Full two-phase thermohydraulic modeling is required” Overkill with respect to heat pipe modeling at the system level Applicable thermohydraulic solvers are available for detailed modeling,
but uncertainties in inputs can be quite large “Heat pipes can be represented by solid bars with an artificially
high thermal conductivity” Disruptive to the numerical solution (especially in transient analyses) Unlike a highly conductive bar, a heat pipe’s axial resistance is
independent of transport length: not even anisotropic materials approximate this behavior
No information is gleaned regarding limits, design margin “Heat pipes can be modeled as a large conductor”
Analyst shouldn’t assume which sections will absorb heat and which will reject it
Heat pipes can exhibit up to a two-fold difference in convection coefficients between evaporation and condensation
![Page 4: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Typical System-Level Approach
Targeted toward users (vs. developers) of heat pipes: Given simple vendor-supplied or test-correlated data …
How will the heat pipe behave? (Predict temps accurately) How far is it operating from design limits?
From this perspective, no need to model what happens past these limits!!
Network-style “Vapor node, conductor fan” approach:
Gi = 1/Ri = Hi*P*Li
where:Hi = Hevap (Ti > Tvapor)Hi = Hcond (Ti < Tvapor)
![Page 5: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Next Level: QLeff
Checking Power-Length Product Limits Sum energies along pipe, looking for peak capacity:
QLeff = maxi | [ i( Qi/2 + j=0,i-1Qj ) Li ] |
Can be compared with vendor-supplied QLeff as a function of temperature, tilt
What matters is verifying margin, not modeling deprime Exception: start-up of liquid metal pipes (methods available)
![Page 6: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Noncondensible Gas
Gas Front Modeling (VCHP or gas-blocked CCHP) Amount of gas (in gmol, kmol, or lbmol) must be known or
guessed (can be a variable for automated correlation) Gas front modeled in 1D: “flat front” Iteratively find the location of the gas front
Sum gas masses from reservoir end (or cold end). For a perfect gas:*
mgas = i {(P-Psat,i)*Li*Apipe/(Rgas*Ti)}
Block condensation in proportion to the gas content for each section
Provides sizing verification for VCHP, degradation for CCHP
____________* Real gases may be used with full FLUINT FPROP blocks
![Page 7: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Gas Blockage in CCHPs
Parametric Study ofHeat Pipe Degradationfrom Zero NCG (left)
to 8.5e-9 kg-mole (right)
![Page 8: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
VCHP Modeling
Requires reservoir volume and gas charge (sized by heat pipe vender)
Model axial conduction along pipe to capture heat leak through adiabatic section of pipe
Accurately capture reservoir parasitics through system model
Easy to integrate 1D or 2D Peltier device (TEC), proportional heater, etc. for reservoir (or remote payload) temperature control
VCHP rejecting heat through a remote
radiator
![Page 9: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
2D Wall Models
Relatively straightforward to extend methods to 2D walls Example: top half can
condense while bottom half evaporates
However: QLeff remains a 1D
concept Gas blockage remains
flat front (1D, across cross-section)
This can complicate vapor chamber fin modeling Condenser Section
![Page 10: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The Old Meets the New
Proven Heat Pipe Routines VCHPDA SINDA subroutine
1D Modeling of VCHP gas front Vapor node as boundary node for stability
SINDA/FLUINT Heat Pipe routines (HEATPIPE, HEATPIPE2) Modeling of CCHP with or w/out NCG present Modeling of VCHP gas front 1D or 2D wall models available QLeff reported
Vapor node as boundary node optionally Implicit within-SINDA solution used for improved stability
New CAD-based methods CAD based model generation New 1D piping methods within 2D/3D CAD models
![Page 11: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
New CAD Methods
Modeling heat pipes in FloCAD Import CAD geometry Quickly convert CAD lines and polylines to “pipes” Generates HEATPIPE and HEATPIPE2 calls automatically
Heat Pipes Embedded in a Honeycomb Panel
without heat pipes with heat pipes
![Page 12: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Heat Pipe Data Input
User-defined heat pipe options and inputs
![Page 13: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
CAD-based Centerlines and Arbitrary Cross Sections
![Page 14: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Attach to 2D/3D Objects (contact), radiate off walls …
![Page 15: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
What’s Missing?Future Heat Pipe Modeling Efforts
Currently heat pipe walls are limited to 1D or 2D finite difference modeling (FDM) Other FloCAD objects (like LHP condenser lines) allow walls to be
unstructured FEM meshes, collections of other surfaces, etc. But a detailed model can conflict with common assumptions such as
heat transfer at the “vapor core diameter”
Vapor Chamber Fins 2D “power-length” capacity checks 2D gas front modeling (not currently a user concern)
![Page 16: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
A little about Loop Heat Pipes (LHPs)
CCHPs and VCHPs are “SINDA only” (thermal networks) Can access complex fluid properties, but FLUINT is not required
LHPs require more complex solutions (two-phase thermohydraulics: fluid networks)
Condenser can be quicklymodeled using FloCAD’spipe component. Walls can be FEM meshes,
Thermal Desktop surfaces,or plain tubes (piping scheduleavailable)
Easy to connect or disconnect pipes Manifolds, etc.
![Page 17: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Must accurately predict subcooling production and minor liquid line heat leaks Import CAD geometry for condenser layout Requires sufficient resolution to capture thermal gradients Capture variable heat transfer
coefficient in the condenser line based on flow regime
Model flow splits in parallel leg condenser
Model flow regulators
LHP Condenser Modeling
![Page 18: Www.crtech.com C&R Technologies, Inc. Phone 303.971.0292 Fax 303.971.0035 FDM/FEM System-level Analysis of Heat Pipes and LHPs in Modern CAD Environments](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022070307/551a3843550346cb358b52cf/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Conclusions
Heat pipes and LHPs are can be easily modeled at the system-level Heat pipes: using modern incarnations of “trusted” methods LHPs: using off-the-shelf, validated thermohydraulic solutions
New CAD methods permit models to be developed in a fraction of the time compared with traditional techniques