[xls]dodcio.defense.govdodcio.defense.gov/portals/0/documents/dodaf/dm2... · web viewthe state or...

DoDAF 2.0 Meta Model (DM2) Alias / TBD Terms 05/06/2023

FOUO 1 of 22 FOUO

DoDAF-DM2 Term Definition

Stat

us

Source Definitions Examples

Asso

ciat

ion?

CDM

?

Who

DM2 Submodel Applicability DoDAF Legacy Model Applicability ("Monster Matrix")

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV

-3

Activity

a. In

Mod

el

YY GC x x x x x x x x x x ### n o n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n o o o n n n n n n n o n n o o o n n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o

activityConsumesResource Represents that an activity consumes a resource

y

x x x x x x x x x

### n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n o n o o o o o o

y x ### o n o o n

activityPartOfCapability

a. In

Mod

el

DoDAF Meta Model Y 1 x ### o o n n n n n n n o

activityPartOfProjectType DM2 associative entity Y 1 x x x ### o o n n

Y 1 x x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n n n n n o

a. In

Mod

el

DoDAF Meta Model Y 1 x x x x x x x x x x ### o n n n o n n n n n o o n o o o o o o n n o o n o o o o o o n n n o o o o o o n o

activityProducesResource Represents that an activity produces a resource

y

x x x x x x x x x

### n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n o n o o o o o o

ActivityType Powertype of Activity

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

AdaptabilityMeasure Adaptation of SEI Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

AdaptabilityMeasureType The Powertype of AdaptabilityMeasure.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Address

a. In

Mod

el

Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

AddressType The Powertype of Address.

### o o o o o o o o o o o

Agreement Need to deconflict YY GC x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

AgreementType The Powertype of Agreement.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o

ArchitecturalDescription YY x x x ### n o n n n

The Powertype of ArchitecturalDescription.

### o o o o o

associationOfInformation (DoDAF Meta Model): Whole-part association DoDAF Meta Model Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n

axesDescribedBy DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

beforeAfter proceeds, succeeds Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

BeforeAfterType

a. In

Mod

el

IDEAS Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

Capability

a. In

Mod

el

YY FS x x ### o o o n n n n n n n n

capabilityOfPerformer DM2 associative entity Y 1 x x x ### o o o o o o n

CapabilityType Category or type of capability x ### o n o o n

CircularArea The space enclosed by a circle. (IDEAS): The space enclosed by a circle. IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

Potentially Related Terms or Aliases

Definition Rationale, Further work, other Comments

Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion

Work, not specific to a single organization, weapon system or individual that transforms inputs (Resources) into outputs (Resources) or changes their state.

Action, Process Operational Activity, Processes, Function, System Function, Operation, Task, Plan, Project

representation of a means by which a process acts on some input to produce a specific output. (DDDS Counter (4204/3)(A))(MODAF): An action performed in conducting the business of an enterprise. It is a general term that does not imply a placement in a hierarchy (eg, it could be a process or a task as defined in other documents and it could be at any level of the hierarchy). It is used to portray operational actions not hardware/software system functions. Operational Activity may include either military operations or business processes."(NAF): A logical process, specified independently of how the process is carried out. Note: an <OperationalActivity>> may only be carried out by a logical <<Node>>. (MM)(JCS 1-02): Activity: 1. A unit, organization, or installation performing a function or mission, e.g.,reception center, redistribution center, naval station, naval shipyard. 2. A function, mission, action, or collection of actions. Also called ACT. See also establishment.(Zachman): Activity: A general term to decribe something that is done. It is used when a more specific definition is not available. An ACTIVITY must be either a FUNCTION or a PROCESS.

Confirm that defs and structures align. Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions, with emphasis on MODAF and Webster's Dictionary.

a. In

M

odel

activityMapsToCapabilityType

Represents that an activity was / is / can-be/ must-be conducted under certain conditions with a spatiotemporal overlap of the activity with the condition.

a. In

M

odel

A disposition to manifest an Activity. An Activity to be performed to achieve a desired effect under specified [performance] standards and conditions through combinations of ways and means.

(DoDAF Meta Model): A disposition to manifest an Activity. An Activity to be performed to achieve a desired effect under specified [performance] standards and conditions through combinations of ways and means.

A wholePart relationship between a Project and an Activity (Task) that is part of the Project a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A wholePart relationship between a Project and an Activity (Task) that is part of the Project

activityPerformableUnderCondition

Represents that an activity was / is / can-be/ must-be conducted under certain conditions with a spatiotemporal overlap of the activity with the condition.

a. In

M

odel (DoDAF Meta Model): Represents that an activity was / is /

can-be conducted under certain conditions with a spatio-temporal overlap of the activity with the condition.

Need to see how constraints and conditions are similar or differ.. DoDAF Meta Model

activityPerformedByPerformer

An overlap between a Performer and an Activity that is non-specific as to whether:1. the Activity is solely performed by the Performer2. the Activity is performed by several Performers3. the Performer performs only this Activity4. the Performer performs other Activities

(DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap of an Activity with a Resource, in particular a consuming or producing Activity that expresses an input, output, consumption, or production Activity of the Resource

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A measure of the ease with which Performers satisfy differing Constraints and Capability and Service needs. a.

In

Mod

el (SEI): the ease with which software satisfies differing system constraints and user needs [Evans 87]

a. In

M

odel

The name of a location along with the location-finding scheme that allows a location to be found from the name. Examples include postal address, email address, URL, datalink address.

(Dictionary.com): The place or the name of the place where a person, organization, or the like is located or may be reached: What is your address when you're in Des Moines? (WordNet): 1. (computer science) the code that identifies where a piece of information is stored 2. the place where a person or organization can be found or communicated with

(Dictionary.com): The place or the name of the place where a person, organization, or the like is located or may be reached: What is your address when you're in Des Moines? (WordNet): 1. (computer science) the code that identifies where a piece of information is stored 2. the place where a person or organization can be found or communicated with

WR / DM / TM

a. In

M

odel

A consent among parties regarding the terms and conditions of activities that said parties participate in. a.

In

Mod

el

(DoDAF/CADM): An arrangement between parties. (DDDS Counter (332/1)(A))(Webster's): 1. Harmony of opinion; accord. 2. An arrangement between parties regarding a course of action; a covenant.

a. In

M

odel

Information describing an architecture such as an OV-5 Activity Model document. a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): Information describing an architecture such as an OV-5 Activity Model document.

ArchitecturalDescriptionType

a. In

M

odel

A relationship or association between two elements of information. a.

In

Mod

el

A relationship describing the straight lines about which bodies rotate a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A relationship describing the straight lines about which bodies rotate

A couple that represents that the temporal extent end time for the individual in place 1 is less than temporal extent start time for the individual in place 2.

a. In

M

odel (IDEAS): A couple that represents that the temporal extent end

time for the individual in place 1 is less than temporal extent start time for the individual in place 2.

Can't do a BA on the instances because they are owned by the type. IDEAS

An association between two Individual Types signifying that the temporal end of all the Individuals of one Individual Type is before the temporal start of all the Individuals of the other Individual Type.

(IDEASl): An association between two Individual Types signifying that the temporal end of all the Individuals of one Individual Type is before the temporal start of all the Individuals of the other Individual Type.

The ability to achieve a Desired Effect under specified [performance] standards and conditions through combinations of ways and means [activities and resources] to perform a set of activities.

currently achieve, but which may be planned or aspired to. Capabilities in MODAF are not time-dependent – once defined they are persistent. It is only the Capability Requirement that changes.(NAF): The ability of one or more resources to deliver a specified type of effect or a specified course of action. (GEN TERM)(NAF): A high level specification of the enterprise's ability. (MM)(JCS 1-02): The ability to execute a specified course of action. (A capability may or may not be accompanied by an intention.)(Webster's): 1. The quality of being capable; ability. 2. A talent or ability that has potential for development or use. 3. The capacity to be used, treated, or developed for a specific purpose.(Merriam-Webster's Eleventh Collegiate Dictionary): A feature or factor capable of development: POTENTIALITY. 3. The facility or potential for an indicated use or deployment.(Joint Publication 1-02, Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms, 12 Apr 2001 (as amended trhough 30 May 2008) ): The ability to exercise a specified course of action (A capability may

Authority: "The Secretary of Defense, by DOD Directive 5025.12, 23 August 1989, Standardization of Military and Associated Terminology, has directed the use of JP 1-02 throughout the Department of Defense to ensure standardization of military and associated terms.

"The soldier shall be able to load and fire his individual weapon." (JP 1-02) "The soldier shall be able to load and fire his individual weapon from (positions) on a trainfire range, in (weather) to achieve a minimum score of "Marksman" on the Army Marksm

A couple that represents the capability that a performer manifests a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the capability that a performer manifests

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

Legend:n=necessaryo=optionaldf=DM2 foundation - not useddfo=DM2 foundation optionally usedif=IDEAS foundation - not usedifo=IDESA foundation optionally usedm=metadatas=securitynp=xml schema class needed for naming pattern shortcut


FOUO 2 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV

-3Potentially Related Terms or Aliases


Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion

Legend:n=necessaryo=optionaldf=DM2 foundation - not useddfo=DM2 foundation optionally usedif=IDEAS foundation - not usedifo=IDESA foundation optionally usedm=metadatas=securitynp=xml schema class needed for naming pattern shortcutCircularAreaType Powertype Of CircularArea (DM2): Powertype Of CircularArea ### o o o o o o o o o o

CircularAreaTypeType The Powertype of CircularAreaType.

### o o o o o o o o o o

Condition

a. In

Mod

el

see UJTL YY DM x x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n n n n n o

ConditionType The Powertype of Condition.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

Country A political state or nation or its territory. (IDEAS): A political state or nation or its territory. IDEAS Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

CountryType Powertype Of Country (DM2): Powertype Of Country ### o o o o o o o o o o

CountryTypeType The Powertype of CountryType.


couple IDEAS Y x x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

CoupleType DoDAF Meta Model Y x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

Data

a. In

Mod

el

YY GC x ### o n n o o o o n n o o o o o o o o o o n n

DataType Powertype of Data (DM2): Powertype of Data Target Report Y x x ### n n

describedBy DoDAF Meta Model Y 1 x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

DescriptionScheme x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

descriptionSchemeInstance y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

desiredEffect A desired state of a Resource Y YY x x ### n o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n

desiredEffectDirectsActivity DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o

desiredEffectOfCapability

a. In

Mod

el

Y x ### n n n n n n n n

desireMeasure

y

x x x

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

DomainInformation DoDAF Meta Model Y ### o n o o o o o o o o o n o o

DomainInformationType The Powertype of DomainInformation.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

effectMeasure y x x x ### n o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n

EllipticalArea The space enclosed by an ellipse. (Answers.com): The space enclosed by an ellipse. x ### o o o o o o o o o o

EllipticalAreaType Powertype Of EllipticalArea (DM2): Powertype Of EllipticalArea ### o o o o o o o o o o

EllipticalAreaTypeType The Powertype of EllipticalAreaType.


endBoundary (IDEAS): The maximum time value of a temporal extent. IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

EndBoundaryType IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

The state of an environment or situation in which a Performer performs or is disposed to perform.

(The American Heritage Dictionary): the particular mode or being of a person or thing(Dictionary.com): a circumstance indispensable to some result; prerequisite; that on which something else is contingent (UJTL) Those variables of an operational environment or situation in which a unit, system, or individual is expected to operate and may affect performance. Some conditions are designed to help describe the theater of operations (e.g., host-nation support); others describe the immediate joint operations area (e.g., maritime superiority), while still others describe the battlefield conditions (e.g., littoral composition). Not to be confused with "condition" as it applies to triggers, e.g., in state transition models(WordNet) A state at a particular time

Possibly environment. Derived from UJTL and WordNet

a. In

M

odel

coordinateCenterDescribedBy

A relationship describing the mid point of a position reference frame a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A relationship describing the mid point of a position reference frame

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

An ordered relationship (tuple) between two Things, i.e., that has two place positions. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An ordered relationship (tuple) between two Things, i.e., that has two place positions.

A couple in which the places are taken by Types only.

entity relationship, class association a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A couple in which the places are taken by Types only.

Representation of information in a formalized manner suitable for communication, interpretation, or processing by humans or by automatic means. Examples could be whole models, packages, entities, attributes, classes, domain values, enumeration values, records, tables, rows, columns, and fields.

interpretation, or processing by humans or by automatic means. Any representations such as characters or analog quantities to which meaning is or might be assigned.(Zachman): The column in the Architecture Framework that is concerned with what things are significant enough to an enterprise that they require holding information about them.(American Heritage Dictionary.): Factual information, especially information organized for analysis or used to reason or make decisions.(Webster's): Factual information (as measurements or statistics) used as a basis for reasoning, discussion, or calculation(DoD Net-Centric Data Strategy, App. A (Terminology), May 2003): Data asset refers to any entity that is composed of data. For example, a database is a data asset that comprises data records. In this document, “data asset” means system or application output files, databases, documents, or web pages. “Data asset” also includes services that may be provided to access data from an application. For example, a service that returns individual records from a database would be a data asset. Similarly, a website that returns data in response to

e.g., target 123 report. Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions, with emphasis on NAF, JCS 1-02, and the American Heritage and Webster's dictionaries.

1. "These data represent the results of our analyses."2. "Data are entered by terminal for immediate processing by the computer."3. "Additional data is unavailable."

a. In

M

odel

A tuple that asserts that Information describes a Thing. a.

In

Mod

el

(DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between the possible state or causal disposition of an Activity to a future state of a Desired Effect that constrains the full future state or casual dispositions of the Activity that would be present otherwise.

A RepresentationScheme and DescriptionType whose members are intentionally descriptions a.

In

Mod

el

A representationSchemeInstance that asserts a Description is a member of a DescriptionScheme. a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el (JP 1-02) Effect: (n) The result, outcome, or consequence of an action [activity].

Tentative in DMM, needs further work, e.g., structuring like DM2.. JP 1-02

The couple that represents how a desired effect directs an activity a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): The couple that represents how a desired effect directs an activity

desiredEffectIsRealizedByProjectType

The couple that represents how a desired effect is realized by a project type a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): The couple that represents how a desired effect is realized by a project type

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a desired effect and a capability

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a desired effect and a capability

Tentative in DMM, needs further work, e.g., to describe what the association means.. DM2 associative entity

A measureOfType that relates a DesiredEffect to a MeasureOfDesire

a. In

M

odel

Types of information within the scope or domain of the architecture. a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): Types of information within the scope or domain of the architecture.

a. In

M

odel

A measureOfType that relates a DesiredEffect to a MeasureOfEffect a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

A temporal whole part couple that relates the temporal boundary to the whole. a.

In

Mod

el

A temporal whole part couple that relates the temporal boundary to the whole taken over a Type. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): The maximum value of a temporal extent taken over a Type, i.e., the maximum time value taken over all it's members.


FOUO 3 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Facility

a. In

Mod

el

DDDS + JCS + 4165 Y DM x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

facilityPartOfSite DoDAF Meta Model Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

FacilityType Powertype Of Facility (DM2): Powertype Of Facility ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

FacilityTypeType The Powertype of FacilityType.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o

FunctionalStandard (ISE FS 200) Y DM x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

FunctionalStandardType The Powertype of FunctionalStandard.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

GeoFeature

a. In

Mod

el

Generalization of JC3IEDM Y GC x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

GeoFeatureType Powertype Of GeoFeature (DM2): Powertype Of GeoFeature ### o o o o o o o o o o o

GeoFeatureTypeType The Powertype of GeoFeatureType.


GeoPoliticalExtent IDEAS Y x x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

GeoPoliticalExtentType Powertype Of GeoPoliticalExtent (DM2): Powertype Of GeoPoliticalExtent x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

GeoPoliticalExtentTypeType The Powertype of GeoPoliticalExtentType.

x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

GeoStationaryPoint IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

GeoStationaryPointType Powertype Of GeoStationaryPoint (DM2): Powertype Of GeoStationaryPoint ### o o o o o o o o o o

The Powertype of GeoStationaryPointType.


Guidance

a. In

Mod

el

Need to deconflict YY GC x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

GuidanceType The Powertype of Guidance.


Individual IDEAS x x x x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

IndividualActivity x x x ### n n o

IndividualPerformer A specific thing that can perform an action (DM2): A specific thing that can perform an action x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

IndividualPersonRole (DM2): An individual person x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

y

x

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

IndividualResource x x x x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

IndividualType The powertype of Individual. (IDEAS): The powertype of Individual. IDEAS x x x x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

IndividualTypeType

(IDEAS): The powertype of an IndividualType IDEAS x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

Information

a. In

Mod

el

YY GC x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

InformationType Category or type of information (DM2): Category or type of information x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

A real property entity consisting of underlying land and one or more of the following: a building, a structure (including linear structures), a utility system, or pavement.

built or maintained by people. (DDDS Counter (334/1)(A)). (JC3IEDM): An ObjectItem that built, installed or established to served some particular purpose and is identified by the service it provides rather than by its content.(NAF): Physical Asset: A <<Resource>> that can host systems and/or people. Note 1: synonyms for <<PhysicalAsset>>; would be "platform", "facility", or "host". This is the original intent for the SystemsNode" concept in DoDAF. (MM)(JCS 1-02): A real property entity consisting of one or more of the following: a building, a structure, a utility system, pavement, and underlying land. See also air facility.(Webster's): 1. Something designed, built, installed, etc., to serve a specific function affording a convenience or service. 2. Something that permits the easier performance of an action, course of conduct, etc.(DoDI 4165.14): A building, structure, or linear structure out to an imaginary line surrounding a facility at a distance of five feet from the foundation that, barring specific direction to the contrary such as a utility privatization agreement, denotes what is included in the basic record for the facility (e.g., landscaping, sidewalks, utility connections). This imaginary line is what is

A whole part association between a Facility (part) and the Site (whole) in which it resides.

project goals, objectives, desired outcomes a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap of the future state or casual disposition of a Project to manifested Goals (states of Effect Objects).

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

Functional standards set forth rules, conditions, guidelines, and characteristics. a.

In

Mod

el (ISE FS 200, adapted from): Functional standards set forth rules, conditions, guidelines, and characteristics.

a. In

M

odel

An object that encompasses meteorological, geographic, and control features mission significance

(DoDAF/CADM): A set of characteristics, structures or other entities that are of military significance. (DDDS Counter (4134/2)(A)).(JC3IEDM): An OBJECT-ITEM that encompasses meteorological, geographic, and control features of military significance.(Webster's): 1. A prominent or conspicuous part or characteristic. 2. Outward appearance; form or shape.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A geospatial extent whose boundaries are by declaration or agreement by political parties. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A geospatial extent whose boundaries are by declaration or agreement by political parties.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

Unidimensional Individual (dimensionless in space, existant over all time) a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): Unidimensional Individual (dimensionless in space, existant over all time)

a. In

M

odel

GeoStationaryPointTypeType

a. In

M

odel

An authoritative statement intended to lead or steer the execution of actions.

(DoDAF/CADM): A statement of direction received from a higher echelon. (DDDS Counter (336/4)(A))(Zachman): A kind of DIRECTION from a DIRECTIVE describing an overall supervision of a BUSINESS PROCESS.(Webster's): The act or function of guiding; leadership; direction. Synonyms: management, conduct, supervision, control, government.

a. In

M

odel

A Thing that has spatio-temporal extent. Note - this may be something that existed in the past, exists now, or may exist in some future possible world.

a. In

M

odel (IDEAS): A Thing that has spatio-temporal extent. Note - this

may be some that existed in the past, exists now, or may exist in some future possible world.

Activities that are Individuals, i.e., that occur in space and time. a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): Activities that are Individuals, i.e., that occur in space and time.

A Type - Individual distinction introduced in the DM2 LDM

a. In

M

odel A Type - Individual distinction

introduced in the DM2 LDM

Person roles defined by the role or roles they share that are relevant to an architecture. Includes assigned materiel. a.

In

Mod

el

individualPersonRolePartOfIndividualPerformer

Whole part relationship between an individual person role and an individual performer

a. In

M

odel

Any specific physical or virtual entity of limited availability a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): Any specific physical or virtual entity of limited availability


individualResourceInLocation

A wholePart that asserts an IndividualResourceState is in a Location a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

A PlaceableType that is the Powertype of IndividualType

a. In

M

odel

Information is the state of a something of interest that is materialized -- in any medium or form -- and communicated or received.

within a certain context have a particular meaning. (GEN TERM)(JCS 1-02): 1. Facts, data, or instructions in any medium or form. 2. The meaning that a human assigns to data by means of the known conventions used in their representation. (JP 3-13.1)(IDEAS): For Individuals, an instance of a piece of information - e.g. an utterance, and electronic message, a particular instance of a written document, or a particular instance of an electronic file.(American Heritage Dictionary.): 1. Knowledge communicated or received concerning a particular fact or circumstance. 2. Factual data.(Webster's): 1. The communication or reception of knowledge or intelligence. 2. Knowledge obtained from investigation, study, or instruction.(Wikipedia): Information is the state of a system of interest. Message is the information materialized. Even though information and data are often used interchangeably, they are actually very different. Data is a set of unrelated information, and as such is of no use until it is properly evaluated. Upon

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions, with emphasis on IDEAS and Webster's Dictionary.

1. "Information concerning a crime."2. "Using the input data, we have come up with some significant new information."

a. In

M

odel


FOUO 4 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Installation

a. In

Mod

el

Regulation (DODI 4165.14) Y DM x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

InstallationType Powertype Of Installation (DM2): Powertype Of Installation ### o o o o o o o o o o o

InstallationTypeType The Powertype of InstallationType.


jointAction Relating two parts of a joint action

y

x

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Line IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

linePartOfPlanarSurface DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

LineType Powertype Of Line (DM2): Powertype Of Line ### o o o o o o o o o o o

LineTypeType The Powertype of LineType.


Location

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

locationNamedByAddress DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

LocationType The powertype of Location (DM2): The powertype of Location x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

LocationTypeType The Powertype of LocationType.

x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

MaintainabilityMeasure Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

MaintainabilityMeasureType The Powertype of MaintainabilityMeasure.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Materiel

a. In

Mod

el

Derived from JC3IEDM. YY GC x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

materielPartOfPerformer

a. In

Mod

el

IDEAS Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

MaterielType The Powertype of Materiel.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Measure The magnitude of some attribute of an individual.

a. In

Mod

el

YY DM x x x x x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

MeasureableSkill x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o

(DM2): skillPartOfPersonType is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y x x ### o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o n n o o o o o o

MeasureableSkillType The Powertype of MeasureableSkill.


MeasureOfDesire DesiredEffect is a member of Measure (DM2): DesiredEffect is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity x x x 1 ### o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n

MeasureOfDesireType The Powertype of MeasureOfDesire.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

MeasureOfEffect Category of measures on Effect Objects (Answers.com): Category of measures on Effect Objects Y x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n

MeasureOfEffectType The Powertype of MeasureOfEffect.


measureOfIndividual

a. In

Mod

el

y x x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

A base, camp, post, station, yard, center, or other activity, including leased facilities, without regard to the duration of operational control. An installation may include one or more sites.

(DODI 4165.14): A base, camp, post, station, yard, center, or other activity, including leased facilities, under the jurisdiction, custody, or control of the Secretary of Defense or the Secretary of a Military Department or, in the case of an activity in a foreign country, under the operational control of the Secretary of Defense or the Secretary of a Military Department, without regard to the duration of operational control. An installation may include one or more sites.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A geometric figure formed by a point moving along a fixed direction and the reverse direction. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A geometric figure formed by a point moving along a fixed direction and the reverse direction.

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between Line and PlanarSurface a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between Line and PlanarSurface

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A point or extent in space that may be referred to physically or logically.

(JC3IEDM) A specification of position and geometry with respect to a specified horizontal frame of reference and a vertical distance measured from a specified datum.(UCORE) A position on the earth’s surface or in geographic space definable by coordinates or some other referencing system, such as a street address or space indexing system.(WordNet) A point or extent in space

WordNet better matches requirements than UCORE because: (1) the positions may reference other than earth, e.g., for solar activity models for comms environment predications and (2) often extents are intended to be represented, not just positions.

WR/DM/TM

A relationship that represents a location being named by an address a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A relationship that represents a location being named by an address

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A category of measures of the amount of time a Performer is able to conduct Activities over some time interval. a.

In

Mod

el (Answers.com): A category of measures of the amount of time a Performer is able to conduct Activities over some time interval.

a. In

M

odel

Equipment, apparatus or supplies that are of interest, without distinction as to its application for administrative or combat purposes.

(DoDAF/CADM): An object of interest that is non-human, mobile and physical. (DDDS Counter (337/1)(A))(JC3IEDM): An ObjectItem that is equipment, apparatus or supplies, that is of military interest, without distinction as to its application for administrative or combat purposes.(JCS 1-02): All items (including ships, tanks, self-propelled weapons, aircraft, etc., and related spares, repair parts, and support equipment, but excluding real property, installations, and utilities) necessary to equip, operate, maintain, and support military activities without distinction as to its application for administrative or combat purposes. See also equipment; personal property.(Webster's): That in a complex system which constitutes the materials, or instruments employed, in distinction from the personnel, or men; as, the baggage, munitions, provisions, etc., of an army.

A whole-part association between a Performer (whole) and the Materiel parts of the Performer. (A Performer can have Personnel Type, System, Service, and Organizational components.)

(IDEAS): A whole-part association between a System (whole) and the Materiel parts of the System. (A System can have Personnel Type and Organizational components.)

a. In

M

odel

(DoDAF/CADM): N/A(JC3IEDM): ObjectItemCapabilityNorm: The standard of a specific Capability of an ObjectType.(Webster's): the extent, dimensions, quantity, etc., of something(Wikipedia, "Measurement"): the estimation of the magnitude of some attribute of an object(Software Engineering Institute (SEI)): Need Satisfaction (QM.1) How well does the system meet the user's needs and requirements? Performance (QM.2) How well does the system function? Maintenance (QM.3) How easily can the system be repaired or changed? Adaptive (QM.4) How easily can the system evolve or migrate? Organizational (QM.5) none specifically, usually indirect (IDEAS): An Property whose members are Individuals that all share a common, measurable property, or whose properties lie within a MeasureRange.

"Attribute" is probably more usual language than "Capability" and magnitude avoids overloading of "standard".

A Skill that can be measured numerically

a. In

M

odel

measureableSkillOfPersonRoleType

skillPartOfPersonRoleType is a member of Measure a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

A propertyOfIndividual that asserts an Individual is an instance of a Measure - i.e. the Individual "has" a property corresponding to the Measure.

Examples:

A laptop weighing 2.2kgA car travelling between 40 and 50 km/h


FOUO 5 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion

Legend:n=necessaryo=optionaldf=DM2 foundation - not useddfo=DM2 foundation optionally usedif=IDEAS foundation - not usedifo=IDESA foundation optionally usedm=metadatas=securitynp=xml schema class needed for naming pattern shortcutendBoundary is a member of Measure (DM2): endBoundary is a member of Measure Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

measureOfIndividualPoint Point is a member of Measure (DM2): Point is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y x x ### o o o o o o o o o o

startBoundary is a member of Measure (DM2): startBoundary is a member of Measure Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

measureOfType

a. In

Mod

el


measureOfTypeActivity (DM2): A measureOfType that relates an Activity to a Measure DM2 associative entity Y 1 x x x x x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

measureOfTypeCondition Condition is a member of Measure (DM2): Condition is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y 1 x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n o

endBoundaryType is a member of Measure (DM2): endBoundaryType is a member of Measure Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

measureOfTypeProjectType ProjectType is a member of Measure (DM2): ProjectType is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y x x ### o o o o o o o

measureOfTypeResource ResourceType is a member of Measure (DM2): ResourceType is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y x x x x x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

startBoundaryType is a member of Measure (DM2): startBoundaryType is a member of Measure Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

wholePart is a member of Measure (DM2): wholePart is a member of Measure DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o n n o n o n o n n

MeasureType A category of Measures (DM2): A category of Measures YY x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

(DM2): activityType is a member of MeasureType DM2 associative entity Y 1 x x ### o o o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o n n o n o n o

The subtype of MeasureType that has units. x x x x


Name IDEAS x x ### np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np

namedBy IDEAS y x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

NameType x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

NamingScheme IDEAS x ### np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np np

namingSchemeInstance y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

NeedsSatisfactionMeasure Y x ### o o n o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

The Powertype of NeedsStatisfactionMeasure.


Organization

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o

OrganizationalMeasure Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

OrganizationalMeasureType The Powertype of OrganizationalMeasure.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

OrganizationType A type of Organization (DM2): A type of Organization x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

OrganizationTypeType The Powertype of OrganizationType.


overlap y x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

OverlapType IDEAS y x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

partiesToAnAgreement The two parties involved in an agreement

y

x x x


PedigreeInformation Information describing pedigree x x x x


measureOfIndividualEndBoundary a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

measureOfIndividualStartBoundary a.

In

Mod

el

A propertyOfType that asserts an IndividualType is a subtype of a Measure - i.e. it asserts all members of the Individual type have a property corresponding to the Measure

Examples:

All Porsche 911 2.2S have a mass between 900 and 960 kgAll atoms of mercury have an atomic weight of 200.59 g·mol−1

A measureOfType that relates an Activity to a Measure a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

measureOfTypeEndBoundaryType a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

measureOfTypeStartBoundaryType a.

In

Mod

el

measureOfTypeWholePartType a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el A Type - Individual distinction introduced in the DM2 LDM

measureTypeApplicableToActivity

Type instance relationship between Activity and MeasureType a.

In

Mod

el

MeasureTypeUnitsOfMeasure

a. In

M

odel

The type of all utterances of a given name for a Thing. The exemplarText provides a written example of the uttered name. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): The type of all utterances of a given name for a Thing. The exemplarText provides a written example of the uttered name.

A couple that asserts that a Name describes a Thing. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A couple that asserts that a Name describes a Thing.

A RepresentationType that is the Powertype of Name a.

In

Mod

el

A Type whose members are Names. What kind of name the name is. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A Type whose members are Names. What kind of name the name is.

Webster's dictionary, Oxford dictionary

A representationSchemeInstance that asserts a Name is a member of a NamingScheme. a.

In

Mod

el

A category of quality measures that address how well a system meets the user's needs and requirements. a.

In

Mod

el (SEI): a category of quality measures that address how well a system meets the user's needs and requirements.

NeedsSatisfactionMeasureType

a. In

M

odel

A specific real-world assemblage of people and other resources organized for an on-going purpose.

Department, Agency, Enterprise

(DoDAF/CADM): An administrative structure with a mission. (DDDS Counter (345/1)(A))(JC3IEDM): An ObjectItem that is an administrative or functional structure.(NAF): ActualOrganization: An actual specific organisation, an instance of an organisation class - e.g. "The US Department of Defense" (MM)(Zachman): A collection of people brought together for a specific purpose and generally recognized as such.(IDEAS): No definition yet, possibilities are: (1) An agreement amongst parties to act as a whole; (2) A structure for arranging and classifying; (3) the process of obscuring information to make it unreadable without special knowledge.(Webster's): 1. A group of persons organized for some end or work; association. 2. Something that has been organized or made into an ordered whole. 3. The administrative personnel or apparatus of a business.

To be of interest to architecture, an organization should not be temporary or structured informally.

DoD, a human resources office, a rifle squad, General Motors

A category of quality measures that address how costly a Performer is to operate and maintain. a.

In

Mod

el (SEI): a category of quality measures that address how costly a system is to operate and maintain.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel A Type - Individual distinction

introduced in the DM2 LDMCY/KL

a. In

M

odel

A couple of wholePart couples where the part in each couple is the same. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A couple of wholePart couples where the part in each couple is the same.

An overlap in which the places are taken by Types only. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An overlap in which the places are taken by Types only.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel


FOUO 6 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


PedigreeInformationType The Powertype of PedigreeInformation.


PerformanceMeasure Y x ### o o n o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

PerformanceMeasureType The Powertype of PerformanceMeasure.


Performer

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x x x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo n dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

PerformerType The Powertype of Performer.

x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo n dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

PersonRoleType Role

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o

DoDAF Meta Model Y x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

PersonRoleTypeType The Powertype of PersonRoleType.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

PhysicalMeasure Y x x ### n o n o o n n o o o o n o o o o o n o o o o n o o o o n n o n o o o n n n o o

PhysicalMeasureType The Powertype of PhysicalMeasure.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

PlanarSurface A two-dimensional portion of space. (IDEAS): A two-dimensional portion of space. IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

PlanarSurfaceType Powertype Of PlanarSurface (DM2): Powertype Of PlanarSurface ### o o o o o o o o o o o

PlanarSurfaceTypeType The Powertype of PlanarSurfaceType.


Point IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

pointPartOfLine DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

pointPartOfPlanarSurface DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

PointType Powertype Of Point (DM2): Powertype Of Point ### o o o o o o o o o o

PointTypeType The Powertype of PointType.


PolygonArea The space enclosed by a polygon. (IDEAS): The space enclosed by a polygon. IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

PolygonAreaType Powertype Of PolygonArea (DM2): Powertype Of PolygonArea ### o o o o o o o o o o

PolygonAreaTypeType The Powertype of PolygonAreaType. ### o o o o o o o o o o

Port

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Y DM x ### o n o o n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o o o o o o o o

portPartOfPerformer IDEAS Y x ### n o o n o o o o o o o o o o o

PortType The Powertype of Port. ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

PositionReferenceFrame IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

The Powertype of PositionReferenceFrame.


Powertype IDEAS x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

powertypeInstance DoDAF Meta Model Y x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

a. In

M

odel

A category of quality measures that address how well a Performer meets Capability needs. a.

In

Mod

el (SEI): a category of quality measures that address how well a system functions.

a. In

M

odel

Any entity - human, automated, or any aggregation of human and/or automated - that performs an activity and provides a capability.

Actor, Agent, Capability Configuration (MODAF)

(SUMO): Something or someone that can act on its own and produce changes in the world. (SUMO)

Attempts to define the most broad definition possible for an entity that performs activity

EXAMPLE: A human or organization that executes a processEXAMPLE: A software application that performs a functionEXAMPLE: An IT system that provides a capabilityEXAMPLE: "President George W Bush"EXAMPLE: "Boeing"EXAMPLE: "The UK Ministry of Defence"EXAMPLE: "Truman Parmele"EXAMPLE: "Charles Dickens"EXAMPLE: "A Future Autonomous UAV"

CY/KL

a. In

M

odel

A category of person roles defined by the role or roles they share that are relevant to an architecture. Includes assigned materiel.

(DoDAF/CADM): A class of persons. (DDDS Counter (897/2)(A))(JC3IEDM): An ObjectItem that represents human beings about whom information is to be held.(JCS 1-02): Personnel: Those individuals required in either a military or civilian capacity to accomplish the assigned mission.(Zachman): A human individual.(IDEAS): An individual human being.(Webster's): Personnel: The body of persons employed by or active in an organization, business, or service.

Our primary motive for rolling up a class of persons is the activities or skills - potential activities - they share.

Users of a given IT system, a Military Occupational Specialty (MOS)

CY/KL

personRoleTypePartOfPerformer

A wholePart between a PersonRoleType and a Performer in which it performs a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): A an association of the whole Performer to its Port that is visible and interfaces with other Performers

a. In

M

odel

A category of measures of spatio-temporal extent of an Individual such as length, mass, energy, velocity, … a.

In

Mod

el (Answers.com): A category of measures of spatio-temporal extent of an Individual such as length, mass, energy, velocity, …

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

Unidimensional Individual (dimensionless in space, existant over all time) a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): Unidimensional Individual (dimensionless in space, existant over all time)

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a line and a point a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a line and a point

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a planar surface and a point a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a planar surface and a point

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

An interface (performer) provided by a Performer that is disposed to perform production or consumption of resources external to the Performer.

part of a Performer or the Materiel connector part of a performer

(DoDAF/CADM): NodePort: The specification of a physical interface point for a specific Node. (DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(NAF): SystemPort: An interface (logical or physical) provided by a <<System>>. A <<SystemPort>> may implement a <<PortType>>, though there is no requirement for <<SystemPort>>s to be typed. (MM).(Webster's): 1. A data connection in a computer to which a peripheral device or a transmission line from a remote terminal can be attached. 2. An entrance to or exit from a data network. 3. A connection point for a peripheral device.

This is a teleological definition, not a good way to define things.

A an association of the whole Performer to its Port that is visible and interfaces with other Performers a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A an association of the whole Performer to its Port that is visible and interfaces with other Performers

a. In

M

odel

An arbitrary set of axes with reference to which the position or motion of something is described or physical laws are formulated. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An arbitrary set of axes with reference to which the position or motion of something is described or physical laws are formulated.

PositionReferenceFrameType

a. In

M

odel

A Type that is the is the set (i.e., Type) of all subsets (i.e., subTypes) that can be taken over the some Type. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A Type that is the powerType of some other Type where a powerType (or power set) is the set of all subsets that can be taken over the other Type.

An association that between of the sets within the powerType and the powerType. A special form of typeInstance. a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): A part of an Activity that produces a Resource


FOUO 7 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Project

a. In

Mod

el

Taken from NAF YY RW x x x ### n n n n o o o

ProjectType The powertype of Project (DM2): The powertype of Project x x x ### n n n n n o n

ProjectTypeType The Powertype of ProjectType.

### o o o o o o o

Property

a. In

Mod

el

x x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

propertyOfIndividual

a. In

Mod

el


propertyOfType

a. In

Mod

el


PropertyType The Powertype of Property.


RealProperty Land and improvements to land (i.e., facilities).

a. In

Mod

el

Regulation Y DM x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

RealPropertyType Powertype Of RealProperty (DM2): Powertype Of RealProperty x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

RealPropertyTypeType The Powertype of RealPropertyType.


RectangularArea The space enclosed by a rectangle. (IDEAS): The space enclosed by a rectangle. IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

RectangularAreaType Powertype Of RectangularArea (DM2): Powertype Of RectangularArea ### o o o o o o o o o o

RectangularAreaTypeType The Powertype of RectangularAreaType.


RegionOfCountry IDEAS Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

RegionOfCountryType Powertype Of RegionOfCountry (DM2): Powertype Of RegionOfCountry ### o o o o o o o o o o

RegionOfCountryTypeType The Powertype of RegionOfCountryType.


RegionOfWorld IDEAS Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

RegionOfWorldType Powertype Of RegionOfWorld (DM2): Powertype Of RegionOfWorld ### o o o o o o o o o o

RegionOfWorldTypeType The Powertype of RegionOfWorldType.


Representation x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

RepresentationScheme x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

RepresentationType A Type that is the Powertype of Representation x x x x x x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

representedBy y x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

Resource

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

resourceInLocationType Y x x x x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

A temporary endeavor undertaken to create Resources or Desired Effects.

Plan, Tactic, Strategy, Activity

(Project Management Institute, A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge (PMBOK), 3rd edition 2004): A Project is a temporary endeavor undertaken to create a unique product, service, or result. (DoDAF/CADM): A planned action that represents a set of activities organized and managed to produce a specified product in a specified period of time with specified resources. (DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(NAF): A time-limited endeavour to create a specific set of products or services. (MM).(Webster's): 1. Something that is contemplated, devised, or planned; plan; scheme. 2. A large or major undertaking, esp. one involving considerable money, personnel, and equipment.

Send a shipment to San Jose,

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

An IndividualType whose members all exhibit a common trait or feature. Often the Individuals are states having a property (the state of being 18 degrees centigrade), where this property can be a CategoricalProperty (qv.) or a DispositionalProperty (qv.).

A typeInstance that asserts an Individual is an instance of a Property - i.e. the Individual "has" a property

Examples:

A product being "expensive"A laptop weighing 2.2kgA car travelling between 40 and 50 km/h

A superSubtype that asserts an IndividualType is a subtype of a Property - i.e. it asserts all members of the Individual type "have" a property

Examples:

All London Buses are redAll Porsche 911 2.2S have a mass between 900 and 960 kgAll atoms of merc

a. In

M

odel

(DODI 4165.14): Land and improvements to land (i.e., facilities), equipment affixed and built into the facility as an integral part of the facility heating systems), but not movable equipment (e.g., plant equipment, industrial buoys). In many instances this term is synonymous with real estate.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A large, usually continuous segment of a political state or nation or its territory. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A large, usually continuous segment of a political state or nation or its territory.

regionOfCountryPartOfCountry

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a country and a region within it a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between a country and a region within it

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A large, usually continuous segment of a surface or space; area. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A large, usually continuous segment of a surface or space; area.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A SignType where all the individual Signs are intended to signify the same Thing. a.

In

Mod

el

A RepresentationType that is a collection of Representations that are intended to be the preferred Representations in certain contexts. a.

In

Mod

el

representationSchemeInstance

A typeInstance that asserts a Representation is a member of a RepresentationScheme. a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

A couple that asserts that a Representation represents a Thing. a.

In

Mod

el

Data, Information, Performers, Materiel, or Personnel Types that are produced or consumed.

service participants (or their agents) interact with each other. There are two primary modes of interaction: joint actions that cause real world effects, and notification of events that report real world effects. A message exchange is used to affect an action when the messages contain the appropriately formatted content that should be interpreted as joint action and the agents involved interpret the message appropriately. A message exchange is also used to communicate event notifications. An event is a report of an occurrence that is of interest to some participant; in our case when some real world effect has occurred. Just as action messages will have formatting requirements, so will event notification messages. In this way, the Information Model of a service must specify the syntax (structure), and semantics (meaning) of the action messages and event notification messages as part of a service interface. It must also specify the syntax and semantics of any data that is carried as part of a payload of the action or event notification message. The Information Model is described in greater detail

The relationship that describes the location of a performer or type of performer a.

In

Mod

el


FOUO 8 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


ResourceType The Powertype of Resource.


Rule

a. In

Mod

el

YY FL x x x x x x x x x x x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

ruleConstrainsActivity DoDAF Meta Model Y x x x x x x x x x x ### o n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

rulePartOfMeasureType DM2 associative entity Y x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

RuleType The Powertype of Rule.


SecurityAttributesGroupa.

In M

odel

UCORE 1.1 ### s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s

The Powertype of SecurityAttributesGroup.

### s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s

Service

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x x ### o n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o o o o o o o o o n o

ServiceDescription

a. In

Mod

el

Y x x x ### n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o o o o o o o n o

ServiceDescriptionType The Powertype of ServiceDescription.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n

ServiceLevel Y x x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

ServiceLevelType The Powertype of ServiceLevel.


ServicePort

a. In

Mod

el

Y DM x ### o n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o o o o o o o

servicePortDescribedBy y x ### o n n n n n n n n n n n n n o o o o o o o o o o n o

ServicePortType The Powertype of ServicePort.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

ServiceType The Powertype of Service.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Sign x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

SignType An IndividualType that is the Powertype of Sign. x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

SignTypeType The Powertype of SignType.


SingletonActivity A set of activities containing only one activity. x

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

SingletonIndividualType A set of individuals containing only one individual.


SingletonResource A set of resources containing only one resource x


a. In

M

odel

A principle or condition that governs behavior; a prescribed guide for conduct or action

(BMM Concept Catalog): Business Rules provide specific, actionable guidance to implement Business Policies. Some Business Rules could be automated in software; some are actionable only by people.‘Business Rule’ participates in the following associations:• is derived from Business Policy• may guide Business Processes• may have an enforcement level effected by a Tactic. ‘Business Rule’ in version 1.2 of the BMM is adopted from SBVR.(dictionary.com): a principle or regulation governing conduct, action, procedure, arrangement, etc.; the customary or normal circumstance, occurrence, manner, practice, quality, etc.: (wordnet): a principle or condition that customarily governs behavior; prescribed guide for conduct or action (wikipedia): Business rules or business rulesets describe the operations, definitions and constraints that apply to an organization in achieving its goals.

An overlap between a Rule and the Activities it allows a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between the Service mechanism and the Performer capabilities it provides access to

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between types of measures and rules a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between types of measures and rules

a. In

M

odel

The group of Information Security Marking attributes in which the use of attributes 'classification' and 'ownerProducer' is required. This group is to be contrasted with group 'SecurityAttributesOptionGroup' in which use of those attributes is optional.

(UCORE 1.1): The group of Information Security Marking attributes in which the use of attributes 'classification' and 'ownerProducer' is required. This group is to be contrasted with group 'SecurityAttributesOptionGroup' in which use of those attributes is optional.

SecurityAttributesGroupType

a. In

M

odel

A mechanism to enable access to a set of one or more capabilities , where the access is provided using a prescribed interface and is exercised consistent with constraints and policies as specified by the service description. The mechanism is a Performer. The "capabilities" accessed are Resources -- Information, Data, Materiel, Performers, and Geo-political Extents.

with constraints and policies as specified by the service description.(Wordnet): Work done by one person or group that benefits another; "budget separately for goods and services" (The Free On-line Dictionary of Computing): Work performed (or offered) by a server. This may mean simply serving simple requests for data to be sent or stored (as with file servers, gopher or http servers, e-mail servers, finger servers, SQL servers, etc.); or it may be more complex work, such as that of irc servers, print servers, X Windows servers, or process servers. E.g. "Access to the finger service is restricted to the local subnet, for security reasons".(http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/xml/library/ws-support-soa/ ): Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) introduces a highly distributed architecture which assumes multiple consumers executing the same service. In such systems, different consumers can have different quality of service (QoS) requirements for the invocation of the same service. Additionally, new versions of services can be introduced over time, which might require correct routing of requests from different consumers to particular service versions. All of these requirements can be collectively described as service invocation policies. These policies

Used to say: "Activities done by a service provider (performer) to achieve desired results for a service consumer (other performer) under conditions and standards specified in a service contract"

The way DM reads NCSS def emphasis on "mechanism to enable access to" vice actually providing the activities, QoS, etc. In the garbage pickup service, the service would then be the ordering of, contract with, etc. for the service. The garbage pickup would be the capability accessed.

Information necessary to interact with the service in such terms as the service inputs, outputs, and associated semantics. The service description also conveys what is accomplished when the service is invoked and the conditions for using the service.

Service Interface Description (UPDM)

consistent way to describe the use, composition, and implementation of a service to service providers, users, developers, and managers. a specification for metadata about a serviceOASIS SOA RM: Contains the information necessary to interact with the service and describes this in such terms as the service inputs, outputs, and associated semantics. The service description also conveys what is accomplished when the service is invoked and the conditions for using the service.OASIS SOA Ref Arch: A service description is an artifact, usually document-based, that defines or references the information needed to use, deploy, manage and otherwise control a service. This includes not only the information and behavior models associated with a service to define the service interface but also includes information needed to decide whether the service is appropriate for the current needs of the service consumer. Thus, the service description will also include information such as service reachability, service functionality, and the policies and contracts associated with a

FD / CY / KL

a. In

M

odel

serviceEnablesAccessToResource

An overlap between the Service (i.e., mechanism) and the Resources (i.e., capabilities) to which it provides access. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An overlap between the Service mechanism and the Performer capabilities it provides access to

A measurement of the performance of a system or service. a.

In

Mod

el (Answers.com): A measurement of the performance of a system or service.

a. In

M

odel

A part of a Performer that specifics a interaction component through which the Performer interacts with other Performers. This isolates dependencies between performers to particular interaction points rather than to the performer as a whole.

Mediator (OASIS SOA RA), Service Interface (UPDM)

(MODAF): The mechanism by which a <<Service>> communicates. Note: a <<ServiceInterface>> specifies the <<ServiceInterfaceDefinition>> provided and required by the <<Service>>.

A tuple that asserts that Information describes a Thing. a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

An Individual that signifies a Thing.

Example: 'BOSTON' signifies BOSTON a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel


FOUO 9 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Site

a. In

Mod

el

Regulation (DODI 4165.14) Y DM x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

sitePartOfInstallation DoDAF Meta Model Y x ### o o o o o o o o o o

SiteType Powertype Of Site (DM2): Powertype Of Site ### o o o o o o o o o o

SiteTypeType The Powertype of SiteType.


Skill

a. In

Mod

el

Derived from Webster's. YY x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o

skillOfPersonRoleType IDEAS Y x x x x ### o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o n n o o o o o o

SkillType The Powertype of Skill.


SolidVolume IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

SolidVolumeType Powertype Of SolidVolume (DM2): Powertype Of SolidVolume ### o o o o o o o o o o

SolidVolumeTypeType The Powertype of SolidVolumeType.


SpatialMeasure IDEAS Y x x ### o o o o o o o o o o

SpatialMeasureType The Powertype of SpatialMeasure.


Standard

a. In

Mod

el

YY FL x x ### df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df df

StandardType The Powertype of Standard.


startBoundary The beginning of a temporalBoundary. (IDEAS): The beginning of a temporalBoundary. IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

StartBoundaryType The beginning of a temporalBoundaryType. (IDEAS): The beginning of a temporalBoundaryType. IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

superSubType IDEAS y x ### ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo

Surface (IDEAS): Note: as opposed to spatio-temporal area IDEAS x ### o o o o o o o o o o o

SurfaceType Powertype Of Surface (DM2): Powertype Of Surface ### o o o o o o o o o o o

SurfaceTypeType The Powertype of SurfaceType.


System

a. In

Mod

el

YY x x x ### o o n n n o n n n n n n n n o o n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

SystemType The Powertype of System.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

TechnicalStandard (ISE FS 200) Y DM x ### o o o n o o n o o o o n o o o n o o o n n o o o o o o o o

Physical (geographic) location that is or was owned by, leased to, or otherwise possessed. Each site is assigned to a single installation. A site may exist in one of three forms: (1) Land only, where there are no facilities present and where the land consists of either a single land parcel or two or more contiguous land parcels. (2) Facility or facilities only, where the underlying land is neither owned nor controlled by the government. A stand-alone facility can be a site. If a facility is not a stand-alone facility, it must be assigned to a site. (3). Land and all the facilities thereon, where the land consists of either a single land parcel or two or more contiguous land parcels.

(DODI 4165.14): Physical (geographic) location that is or was owned by, leased to, or otherwise possessed by a DoD Component. Each site is assigned to a single installation. A site may exist in one of three forms: (1) Land only, where there are no facilities present and where the land consists of either a single land parcel or two or more contiguous land parcels. (2) Facility or facilities only, where the underlying land is neither owned nor controlled by the government. A stand-alone facility can be a site. If a facility is not a stand-alone facility, it must be assigned to a site. (3). Land and all the facilities thereon, where the land consists of either a single land parcel or two or more contiguous land parcels.

A whole-part association representing that a Site (the part) is spatio-temporally contained within an Installation (the whole). a.

In

Mod

el (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between a Personnel Type and the Skills it entails

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

The ability, coming from one's knowledge, practice, aptitude, etc., to do something well.

Training, Knowledge, Ability

(DoDAF/CADM): Skill: An ability. (DDDS Counter (2226/1)(A))(NAF): Competence: A specific set of abilities defined by knowledge, skills andattitude. (MM)(Webster's): 1. The ability, coming from one's knowledge, practice, aptitude, etc., to do something well. 2. Competent excellence in performance; expertness

GC/RW

A type property between a PersonRoleType and the Skills it entails a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An overlap between a Personnel Type and the Skills it entails

a. In

M

odel

The amount of space occupied by a three-dimensional object of definite shape; not liquid or gaseous. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): The amount of space occupied by a three-dimensional object of definite shape; not liquid or gaseous.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A category of measures of the spatio-temporal location of an Individual. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A category of measures of the spatio-temporal location of an Individual.

a. In

M

odel

A formal agreement documenting generally accepted specifications or criteria for products, processes, procedures, policies, systems, and/or personnel.

• Production operation• User support• Asset management• Technology evaluation• Architecture governance• Configuration management• Problem resolution.(NAF): A ratified and peer-reviewed specification that is used to guide or constrain the architecture. A <<Standard>> may be applied to any element in the architecture via the [constrainedItem] property of UML::Constraint. (MM)(Webster's): 1. Something considered by an authority or by general consent as a basis of comparison; an approved model. 2. A rule or principle that is used as a basis for judgment. 3. An average or normal requirement, quality, quantity, level, grade, etc. 4. An authoritative principle or rule that usually implies a model or pattern for guidance, by comparison with which the quantity, excellence, correctness, etc., of other things may be determined. Synonyms: gauge, basis,pattern, guide. Standard, criterion refer to the basis for making a judgment. A criterion is a rule or principle used to judge the value, suitability, probability, etc., of something, without necessarilyimplying any comparison.(American Heritage Dictionary): an acknowledged measure of comparison for quantitativeor qualitative value; criterion.(ISE-FS-200): A specific technical methodology and practice.

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

An association in which one Type (the subtype) is a subset of the other Type (supertype). a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): An association in which one Type (the subtype) is a subset of the other Type (supertype).

A portion of space having length and breadth but no thickness or regards to time. a.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

ela.

In

Mod

el

A functionally, physically, and/or behaviorally related group of regularly interacting or interdependent elements.

united and regulated by interaction or interdependence to accomplish a set of specific functions.(NAF): A collection of components organized to accomplish a specific function or set of functions. (GEN TERM)(NAF): A coherent combination of physical artifacts, energy and information, assembled for a purpose. (MM)(JCS 1-02): A functionally, physically, and/or behaviorally related group of regularly interacting or interdependent elements; that group of elements forming a unified whole. (JP 3-0)(Zachman): A MECHANISM TYPE that consists of one of more linked computers, along with associated software.(Webster's): 1. An assemblage or combination of things or parts forming a complex or unitary whole. 2. Any assemblage or set of correlated members. 3. An ordered and comprehensive assemblage of facts, principles, doctrines, or the like in a particular field of knowledge or thought. 4. A coordinated body of methods or a scheme or plan of procedure; organizational scheme. 5. Any formulated, regular, or special method or plan of procedure ocedure; organizational scheme. 5. Any formulated, regular, or special method or plan of procedure (INCOSE) A system is a construct or collection of different

JP 1-02 is most authoritative.

Agree we can use "system" for now; suggest we're going to need the other two Real Quick.

weapon system, UAV, GCSS, JOPES, GSORTS, GTN, any specific DCGS

CY/KL

a. In

M

odel

Technical standards document specific technical methodologies and practices to design and implement. a.

In

Mod

el (ISE FS 200, adapted from): Technical standards document specific technical methodologies and practices to design and implement.


FOUO 10 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


TechnicalStandardType The Powertype of TechnicalStandard.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

temporalBoundary IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

TemporalBoundaryType IDEAS y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

TemporalMeasure A type of measure of time (DoDAF Meta Model): A type of measure of time. Y x ### n n o o n n o o o o n o o o o o n o o o o n o o o o n n o n o o o n n n o o

TemporalMeasureType The Powertype of TemporalMeasure.

### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

temporalWholePart IDEAS Y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

TemporalWholePartType y x ### dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo dfo

Thing The union of Individual, Type, and tuple. (IDEAS): The union of Individual, Type, and tuple. IDEAS x x x x x x ### ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo

tuple IDEAS y x x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

TupleType IDEAS Y x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

Type

a. In

Mod

el

IDEAS x x ### if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if if

typeInstance IDEAS Y x ### ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo

Vision

a. In

Mod

el

Best available YY FS x ### o o o o o o o o o o

DM2 associative entity Y x ### o o o o o o o o o

VisionType The Powertype of Vision.


wholePart IDEAS Y x x ### ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo

WholePartType IDEAS Y x x ### ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo ifo

informationPedigree The line of ancestry of information (DM2): The line of ancestry of information DM2 associative entity Y x m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m

Ability The quality of being able to perform

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

AccuracyPrecision The nearness of a functional goal to the true value

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Actor

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Agent Perfomer?

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Architecture The fundamental underlying design of something

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Architecture Description A type of Information

c. A

lias/

com

posi

tea.

In

Mod

el

The start and end times for the spatio-temporal extent of an Individual a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A relationship between two or more things. Note: Tuples are identified by their places (i.e. the ends of the relationship).

The start and end times for the Individual members of a Type. a.

In

Mod


a. In

M

odel

a. In

M

odel

A wholePart that asserts the spatial extent of the (whole) individual is co-extensive with the spatial extent of the (part) individual for a particular period of time.

a. In

M

odel (IDEAS): A wholePart that asserts the spatial extent of the

(whole) individual is co-extensive with the spatial extent of the (part) individual for a particular period of time.

A couple between two Individual Types where for each member of the whole set, there is a corresponding member of the part set for which a wholePart relationship exists, and conversely

a. In

M

odel

(IDEAS): A couple between two Individual Types where for each member of the whole set, there is a corresponding member of the part set for which a wholePart relationship exists, and conversely

a. In

M

odel

A relationship between two or more things. Note: Tuples are identified by their places (i.e. the ends of the relationship). a.

In

Mod


The powertype of tuple that provides the stereotype for tuples of Types. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): The powertype of tuple that provides the stereotype for tuples of Types.

A set (or class) of Things. Note1: Types are identified by their members (i.e. all the things of that type). Note2: The IDEAS Foundation is a higher-order ontology, so Types may have members that are also Types.

(IDEAS): A set (or class) of Things. Note1: Types are identified by their members (i.e. all the things of that type). Note2: The IDEAS Foundation is a higher-order ontology, so Types may have members that are also Types.

A Thing can be an instance of a Type - i.e. set membership. Note that IDEAS is a higher-order model, hence Types may be instances of Types. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A Thing can be an instance of a Type - i.e. set membership. Note that IDEAS is a higher-order model, hence Types may be instances of Types.

An end that describes the future state of the enterprise, without regard to how it is to be achieved; a mental image of what the future will or could be like

(BMM Concept Catalog): A Vision is an overall image of what the organization wants to be or become. An enterprise can use the Business Motivation Model without defining a Vision explicitly. An end that is about the future state of the enterprise, without regard to how it is to be achieved. Dictionary Basis: a mental image of what the future will or could be like [NODE 'vision' (2), bullet 1]

visionIsRealizedByDesiredEffect

The relationship that exists between a vision and the specific desired effect that realised it a.

In

Mod

el (DM2): The relationship that exists between a vision and the specific desired effect that realised it

a. In

M

odel

A couple that asserts one (part) Individual is part of another (whole) Individual. a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A couple that asserts one (part) Individual is part of another (whole) Individual.

A coupleType that asserts one Type (the part) has members that have a whole-part relation with a member of the other Type (whole). a.

In

Mod

el (IDEAS): A coupleType that asserts one Type (the part) has members that have a whole-part relation with a member of the other Type (whole).

b.

Met

adat

a

(WordNet): The quality of being able to perform; a quality that permits or facilitates achievement or accomplishment (The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition): The quality of being suitable for or receptive to a specified treatment; capacity: the ability of a computer to be configured for use as a file server.

Performance Measure

(SEI): a quantitative measure of the magnitude of error [IEEE 90]. (Wikipedia, accuracy): accuracy is the degree of conformity of a measured or calculated quantity to its actual (true) value(Wikipedia, precision): Accuracy is closely related to precision, also called reproducibility or repeatability, the degree to which further measurements or calculations show the same or similar results. (WordNet, accuracy): the quality of being near to the true value

We're not trying to describe the accuracy of a measurement, but, rather a measure of the accuracy of some object's behavior or function.

A performer that is external to and invokes the performer to be architected.

User, customer, agent, performer

(DoDAF): A coherent set of roles that users of use cases play when interacting with these use cases. An actor has one role for each use case with which it communicates.(NAF): An actor is an implementation independent unit of responsibility that performs a certain role. (ARCH ELEM)(Webster's): 1. One who takes part; a participant. 2. A person who does something

Since we have "performer" to stand for the general concept, it makes sense to define "actor" iaw UML.

Comment # 1: Since we don't need to support specific methodologies at this point, recommend delete.Comment # 2: I don't see ACTOR as a candidate. Because DoD is not in the movie, television or theatre business and because this term is used in the contex

A customer who triggers an organizational process ("end-to-end" or value chain); a user who invokes an automated function

CY/KL

(SoAML): An Agent is a classification of autonomous entities that can adapt to and interact with their environment. It describes a set of agent instances that have features, constraints, and semantics in common. Agents in SoaML are also participants, providing and using services. something that produces or is capable of producing an effect : an active or efficient cause (IDEAS v1.0): TBS(OASIS RA 1.0): TBS(www.merriam-webster.com): 2 a : something that produces or is capable of producing an effect : an active or efficient cause

A collection of associations of the components of the underlying design to the "something".

of furnishings and decorations, supervision of construction work, and the examination, restoration, or remodeling of existing buildings. 2. the character or style of building: the architecture of Paris; Romanesque architecture. 3. the action or process of building; construction. 4. the result or product of architectural work, as a building. 5. buildings collectively. 6. a fundamental underlying design of computer hardware, software, or both.7. the structure of anything: the architecture of a novel. (American Heritage Dictionary): Architecture: 1. The art and science of designing and erecting buildings. 2. Buildings and other large structures: the low, brick-and-adobe architecture of the Southwest. 3. A style and method of design and construction: Byzantine architecture. 4. Orderly arrangement of parts; structure: the architecture of the federal bureaucracy; the architecture of a novel. 5. Computer Science The overall design or structure of a computer system, including the hardware and the software required to run it, especially the internal structure of the microprocessor.

(DoDAF v 1.5): "The Framework products portray the basic architecture data elements and relationships that constitute an architecture description", therefore architecture description: architecture data elements and relationships that make up an architecture model or product. Hence, and "architecture description" is an architecture model or product.

(DoDAF v 1.5): "The Framework products portray the basic architecture data elements and relationships that constitute an architecture description", therefore architecture description: architecture data elements and relationships that make up an architecture model or product. Hence, and "architecture description" is an architecture model or product.


FOUO 11 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Behavior

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Business Process

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Capability Configuration aggregated Performer

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

Capability Increment

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

CapabilityPhase

Capacity

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Concept of Operations Activity

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Constraint The range of permissible states for an object.

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Need to deconflict YY GC ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Cost

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Course of Action A path towards a goal

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

Data Dependency Resource consumed by Performer

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Definition A statement conveying fundamental character Description

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(Answers.com): A statement conveying fundamental character

Desired Result

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

The manner in which an individual, group or machine functions, operates or reacts/responds to stimuli.

Composite of Performer and its Activities and the Events that Trigger them and the Performer State changes and/or Activities and outputs (Exchange Objects) or trigger Events resulting from those Activities.

(DoDAF): The way machines or systems operate or interact.(American Heritage Dictionary): 1. The aggregate of responses to internal and external stimuli. 2. The action or reaction of any material under given circumstances. 3. The manner in which something functions or operates. 4. The manner in which a physical system acts or functions, especially under specified conditions.(Webster's): 1. The manner of conducting oneself. 2. Anything that an organism does involving action and response to stimulation. 3. The response of an individual, group, or species to its environment. 4. The way in which someone behaves. 5. The way in which something functions or operates.

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions.

1. "The behavior of dying stars."2. "The behavior of the enemy while under fire."3. "The behavior of atoms when stimulated."4. "The behavior of a system when overloaded."

A functionally or temporally linked collection of structured activities/ tasks aimed at producing specific services and products for an end-user.

Activity, Process, Function, Job, Chore, Assignment.

synchronization), structure (decomposition and reuse), interactions, and connection to events that trigger the processes.Courses of Action are governed by Business Policies. Business Processes are also governed by Business Policies.‘Business Process’ participates in the following associations:• realizes Courses of Action• is governed by Business Policies• may be guided by Business Rules• is the responsibility of one or more Organization Units (BMM Concept Catalog): ‘Business Process’ in version 1.2 of the Business Motivation Model is a draft definition, taken from the August 2004 draft of BDPM and anticipating a definition to be adopted from BDPM when it is further developed.(Wikipedia): 1. Management processes, the processes that govern the operation of a system. Typical management processes include "Corporate Governance" and "Strategic Management". 2. Operational processes, processes that constitute the core business and create the primary value stream. Typical operational processes are Purchasing, Manufacturing, Marketing, and Sales. 3. Supporting processes, which support the core processes.

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions. Redundant with Activity.

A combination of organizational aspects (with their competencies) and equipment that combine to provide a capability.

(DoDAF/CADM): CapabilityAssociation: The association of one Capability to another Capability (DDDS Counter (20846/1)(A))(NAF): A combination of organizational aspects (with their competencies) and equipment that combine to provide a capability. A <<CapabilityConfiguration>> is a physical asset or organization configured to provide a capability, and must be guided by [doctrine] which may take the form of <<Standard>> or <<OperationalConstraint>> stereotypes. (MM)(MODAF 1.2): A composite structure representing the physical and human resources (and their interactions) in an enterprise.A CapabilityConfiguration is a set of artefacts or an organisation configured to provide a capability, and should be guided by [doctrine] which may take the form of Standard or OperationalConstraint stereotypes.

Derived from NAF. Then found Performer covered all aspects of realizing a Capability.

A capability that can be effectively developed, produced, acquired, deployed and sustained.

composite of Capability temporal part (with time period) - Performer (and its time period)

(Defense Acquisition Acronyms & Terms, Defense Acquisition University (DAU)) In the context of Joint Capabilities Integration and Development System (JCIDS), a militarily useful and supportable operational capability that can be effectively developed, produced, acquired, deployed and sustained. Each increment of capability will have its own set of threshold and objective values.

Generalized and simplified from DAU.

A temporal part of a whole capability that relates to temporal parts of the desired effect resource states of the whole capability.

Capability, desired Effect resource state c.

A

lias/

com

pos

ite

(DM2): A temporal part of a whole capability that relates to temporal parts of the desired effect resource states of the whole capability.

The amount a Performer can hold, receive, or absorb.

Performance Measure

(Wikipedia): Capacity is the ability to hold, receive or absorb, or a measure thereof, similar to the concept of volume.(SEI): a measure of the amount of work a system can perform [Barbacci 95].

A general idea derived or inferred from specific instances or occurrences of major planning and operating functions

(JP 5-0): A verbal or graphic statement that clearly and concisely expresses what the joint force commander intends to accomplish and how it will be done using available resources. The concept is designed to give an overall picture of the operation. Also called commander’s concept or CONOPS.

Business Rule, Rule, Restraint, Operational Limitation, Guidance

(DoDAF/CADM): DirectedConstraint: An instance of Guidance that represents a specific limitation (DDDS Counter (19597/1)(A)); (OperationalRule) An instance of Guidance that specifies a set of procedures to achieve an objective; (OperationalCondition) A variable of the operational environment or situation in which a unit, system or individual is expected to operate that may affect performance. (DDDS Counter (19589/1)(A))(NAF): OperationConstrain: A rule governing an operational behavior or property. (MM)(NAF): ResourceConstraint: A rule governing the structural or functional aspects of an implementation - this may also include onstraints on <<OrganisationalResource>>s that are part of an implementation. (MM)(JCS 1-02): In the context of joint operation planning, a requirement placed on the command by a higher command that dictates an action, thus restricting freedom of action. See also operational limitation; restraint. (JP 5-0)(Zachman): A business rule that constrains behavior in some way, or constrains what data may or may not be updated.(Webster's): The state of being restricted or confined within prescribed bounds.

1. Cost - financial: The price paid to acquire, produce, accomplish, or maintain anything. 2. Cost – general: The expenditure of something, such as time or labor, necessary for the attainment of a goal.

Organizational Measure

(DoDAF/CADM): (ArchitectureProject, costAmount): The amount that represents the best estimate of cost for a specific ArchitectureProject. (DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(SEI): Cost estimation -- the process of estimating the "costs" associated with software development projects, to include the effort, time, and labor required. Cost of maintenance -- the overall cost of maintaining a computer system to include the costs associated with personnel, training, maintenance control, hardware and software maintenance, and requirements growth. Cost of operation -- the overall cost of operating a computer system to include the costs associated with personnel, training, and system operations. Cost of ownership -- the overall cost of a computer system to an organization to include the costs associated with operating and maintaining the system, and the lifetime of operational use of the system. (Webster's): 1. The price paid to acquire, produce, accomplish, or maintain anything. 2. An outlay or expenditure of money, time, labor, trouble, etc.(American Heritage Dictionary): The expenditure of something, such as time or labor, necessary for the attainment of a goal

Mission, strategy, plan

aspect of the enterprise (things, processes, locations, people, time) to channel efforts towards Desired Results - the result of a decision by the enterprise about the best way to use its resources, skills, and competencies. A Course of Action defines what has to be done, not how well it has to be done. Measures of Performance are defined in Objectives that are supported by the Courses of Action. Definition: means that is an approach or plan for configuring some aspect of the enterprise involving things, processes, locations, people, timing, or motivation undertaken to achieve ends Note: Categories of course of action include: strategy, tactic. Dictionary Basis: a mode of action; “if you persist in that course you will surely fail”; “once a nation is embarked on a course of action it becomes extremely difficult for any retraction to take place” [www.dictionary.com - Source: WordNet® 2.0 'course of action']. Dictionary Basis: a chosen manner of conducting oneself: way of acting “our wisest course is to retreat” [MWCD 'course' (3b)]. In the

adaptation of BMM

Agree that this is a good overarching concept, but perhaps too vague.

Their course of action was designed to win the football game.

1. Resource consumed by Performer2. dataAssociation

(DISA TBD): Data is, somewhat artificially, divided into two types: Operations, Administration, Maintenance, and Provisioning (OAM&P) data and service/application-specific content data. OAM&P data includes user identity/authorization data, service description data, performance data, etc. The DEERS personnel data used by the PKI program is an example of OAM&P data. Service/application-specific content data is data that is processed by a consumer. The consumer may be human or machine. Examples include map data, email, weather data, etc. (Entity-Relationship TBD): The values for one data element depend on some other data element.

The wished for result, outcome, or consequence of an action. A desired result may be either a goal or an objective.

desired effect, desired outcome, desired consequence

Desired Results are categorized as Goals and Objectives.(BMM Concept Catalog): An end that is a state or target that the enterprise intends to maintain or sustain Dictionary Basis: A favorable outcome of an undertaking or contest [ODE 'result' (bullet 1)] Note: Categories of desired result include: goal, objective.

Expansion of Jp 1-02 defintion of "effect". Redundant with Goal and Objective, see definition.


FOUO 12 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Directive Guidance, Agreement

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Doctrine

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Need to deconflict

Effect The result, outcome, or consequence of an action.

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

End

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

Enduring Task A continuing function to be performed Activity

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(MODAF) TBS Dandashi

Enterprise System

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Enterprise Phase Capability Phase

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Event

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

Federation

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FoS

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

Function

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Functional Dependency

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

An authoritative statement intended to impel actions and the achievement of goals.

Policies define what can be done and what must not be done, and may indicate how or set limits on how it should be done. Compared to a Business Rule, a Business Policy tends to be less formally-structured; and may not be atomic - i.e. not focused on a single aspect of governance or guidance - and may be less formally articulated. Business policies are not directly actionable. Business Rules are actionable Directives. They need to be defined as actionable Directives and managed for consistency and completeness. Business Rules are derived from Business Policies. Apart from its role in the structure, ‘Business Rule’ is outside the scope of the Business Motivation Model. Its place in the structure provides a “hook” to another model, where ‘Business Rule’ is defined and associated with other concepts. (BMM Concept Catalog): Definition: means that defines or constrains some aspect of an enterprise Note: A directive is intended to assert business structure or to control or influence the behavior of the enterprise. Note: Categories of directive include: business policy, business

Shades of gray difference from Agreement or Guidance

The body of principles by which an enterprise seeks to guide its activities.

Composite of Activities and their structure, sequencing, state transitions, their assignment to Organizations, Organization structure, and Rules

(DoDAF/CADM): (Guidance, catCode=1): A statement of direction received from a higher echelon. (DDDS Counter (336/4)(A))(JCS 1-02): Fundamental principles by which the military forces or elements thereof guide their actions in support of national objectives. It is authoritative but requires judgment in application. See also multinational doctrine; joint doctrine; multi-Service doctrine.(Webster's): 1. Something that is taught; teachings collectively. 2. A body or system of teachings relating to a particular subject. 3. A rule or principle of law, especially when established by precedent. 4. A statement of official government policy, especially in foreign affairs and military strategy.

GC/RW

A change in the state of a Resource as a result of some Activity. Goal, Objective, Desired Result, Outcome, Consequence, Effect Object

(DoDAF/CADM): N/A. (JC3IEDM): A perceived effectiveness of a specific Action against a specific battle space object or its class.(JCS 1-02): 1. The physical or behavioral state of a system that results from an action, a set of actions, or another effect. 2. The result, outcome, or consequence of an action. 3. A change to a condition, behavior, or degree of freedom. (JP 3-0).(Webster's): 1. Something brought about by a cause or agent; a result. 2. The power to produce an outcome or achieve a result; influence. 4. A scientific law, hypothesis, or phenomenon.(UJTL): A change to a condition, behavior, or degree of freedom.

Authority of UJTL and relevancy to JCIDS and CPfM.

an outcome worked toward especially with forethought, deliberate planning, and organized effort

effect, outcome, result

Ends are about what an enterprise wants to be. Ends can be about changing what the enterprise is - e.g. developing new lines of business, moving into new markets - or about maintaining its current position relative its market and competition. The definition of an end does not say how it will be achieved. (BMM Concept Catalog): General Concept: motivation element. Definition: Something that is to be accomplished. Dictionary Basis: an outcome worked toward especially with forethought, deliberate planning, and organized effort [MWUD 'end' (4a)]In the Business Motivation Model, Ends are categorized as Vision and Desired Results.

Dictionary definition is closer to meaning than JP 1-02 definition of "end state"

An umbrella term for the management systems, information systems and computer systems within an organization.

(Answers.com): An umbrella term for the management systems, information systems and computer systems within an organization.(MODAF 1.2): Enterprise Phase: A current or future state of the whole life enterprise or enterprise phase; Whole-Life Enterprise: An enterprise phase that is the whole of the enterprise.(UDEF): Any data or information about any definable boundary collection of human and asset resources used to perform a collection of processes to create one or more products which are intended for use or consumption by outside entities

A current or future state of the whole life enterprise or enterprise phase.

(MODAF 1.2): A current or future state of the whole life enterprise or enterprise phase.(Bailey email 2010-06-02): An EP is just a phase of the enterprise you’re modelling – in IDEAS/DM2 terms that would be an individual with the spatial extent of the enterprise, and a finite temporal extent defined by the start and the end of the phase. Projects deliver capability, and they also have phases, the starts/ends of which are shown as project milestones in MODAF. It’s imperative to keep this separate from the enterprise phase, because project are about delivery and enterprise phases are about strategic intent. If someone states a capability for a future enterprise phase, that is a statement of requirement – e.g. “we need bad weather ISTAR by 2015”. The project that delivers that capability may well intend to deliver on time, but may slip. By keeping these two aspects separate, we can see how reality matches the requirement.

Something that happens at an instant in the world, i.e., a near-zero-duration process (Activity).

Milestone, Trigger, Activity

use of events to include only those types of events that will affect the sequence or timing of activities of a process. BPMN further categorizes Events into three main types: Start, Intermediate, and End. Start and most Intermediate Events have “Triggers” that define the cause for the event. There are multiple ways that these events can be triggered (“Start Event Triggers” on page 38 and “Intermediate Event Triggers” on page 45). End Events may define a “Result” that is a consequence of a Sequence Flow ending. There are multiple types of Results that can be defined (“End Event Results” on page 41). Start As the name implies, the Start Event indicates where a particular Process will start. In terms of Sequence Flow, the Start Event starts the flow of the Process, and thus, will not have any incoming Sequence Flow—no Sequence Flow can connect to a Start Event. Start Event Triggers There are many ways that business process can be started (instantiated). The Trigger for a Start Event is designed to show the general mechanism that will instantiate that particular Process. There are six (6) types of Start Events in BPMN: None, Message, Timer, Conditional Signal, and Multiple. End As the name implies, the End Event indicates where a process will end. In

Concise and easy to understand

The shipment was sent, the database was loaded into memory

A union comprising a number of partially self-governing states or regions united by a central ("federal") government

A type of Performer interaction (overlap of their Activities).

(Answers.com): A union comprising a number of partially self-governing states or regions united by a central ("federal") government

A set of systems that provide similar capabilities through different approaches to achieve similar or complementary effects. For instance, the warfighter may need the capability to track moving targets. The FoS that provides this capability could include unmanned or manned aerial vehicles with appropriate sensors, a space-based sensor platform, or a special operations capability. Each can provide the ability to track moving targets but with differing characteristics of persistence, accuracy, timeliness, etc.

Systems with similar Capability overlaps.

(CJCSI 3170.01F): A set of systems that provide similar capabilities through different approaches to achieve similar or complementary effects. For instance, the warfighter may need the capability to track moving targets. The FoS that provides this capability could include unmanned or manned aerial vehicles with appropriate sensors, a space-based sensor platform, or a special operations capability. Each can provide the ability to track moving targets but with differing characteristics of persistence, accuracy, timeliness, etc.

CJCSI 3170.01F is the defining authority.

The action for which a person or thing is specially designed, fitted, used or intended to accomplish or execute.

Activity, Process, Job, Chore, Assignment.

(NAF): An activity which is specified in context of the resource (human or machine) that performs it.Note1: Contrast with <<OperationalActivity>>, where the actor performing the activity is not known (i.e. it is just a logical node). A <<Function>> is implementation-specific. Note2: Should the <<Function>> be specific to one usage of a type of system, then the usageContext is specified by a reference to the composite structure property <<ResourceComposition>> typed by the system. (MM)(Zachman): A type of activity to carry out a mission, goal or objective of the enterprise. It is described solely in terms of what it is intended to accomplish, without regard to the technology used to carry it out or who is to perform it. This is also described without reference to time.(American Heritage Dictionary): 1. The kind of action or activity proper to a person, thing, or institution; the purpose for which something is designed or exists; role. 2. A factor related to or dependent upon other factors. 3. What something is used for.(Webster's): 1. The action for which a person or thing is

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions, with emphasis on the American Heritage and Webster's Dictionaries. Redundant with Activity.

1. "In my function as chief engineer."2. "Growth is a function of nutrition."3. "The table functions as a desk."4. "The function of a lie detector is to identify untruths"

A constraint on, or dependence of, a function on one or more outside influences, conditions, functions, triggers or events.

Composite of Activity with Constraint or dependence on one or more Conditions, Activities, triggers (composite of Activity and Event), Events.

(DoDAF/CADM): (multiple entities)(Zachman): Functional Verifier: If it is an integrity constraint (Condition indicator = "False"), it requires an object to assume a function relative to the constrained object. For example, the value of an attrobute may be required to be unique within an entity class. If this is a condition (Condition indicator = "True"), it tests to see if this is so. This is an example of an OTHER SYSTEM CONSTRAINT TYPE.(American Heritage Dictionary): Dependency: Something dependent or subordinate; appurtenance.(UNK - TBD): Functional dependencies ties two distinct capabilities together. For example, NECC uses PKI to provide authentication, authorization, and non-repudiation of users.

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions.


FOUO 13 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Geolocation

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Y

Goal A desired state of a Resource

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

Instruction An imparted or acquired item of knowledge Skill

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(Answers.com): An imparted or acquired item of knowledge

Interoperability AdaptabilityMeasure

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

JCA CapabilityType

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Manual Information

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Means

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

MeasurePoint

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

MeasureRange

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Mechanism Performer

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Metadata Information about information

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(Wordnet): Data about data Generalized from data

Milestone

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

Mission

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Authority FS

A place or site that is either occupied or available for occupancy and is marked by some distinguishing feature .

GeoFeatureGeoPoliticalExtent

(DoDAF/CADM): A specific place.(DDDS Counter (343/2)(A))(JC3IEDM): A specification of position and geometry with respect to specified horizontal frame of reference and a vertical distance measured from a specified datum.(NAF): ActualLocation: A location anywhere on the earth. The means of describing the location is a string (locationDescription). The information contained in that string is governed by the taxonomy reference - e.g. if the <<ActualLocation>> is a GPS reference, the string will contain the GPS coordinates. (MM)(Zachman): The column in the Architecture Framework that describes the places where the enterprise does business and how these places are connected.(Webster's): 1. A place of settlement, activity, or residence. 2. A place or situation occupied. 3. A place where something is or could be located; a site.

WR/DM/TM

Desired Result, Effect, Outcome, Consequence

Desired Results – Goals and Objectives - are more specific. A Goal tends to be longer term, and defined qualitatively rather than quantitatively. It should be narrow - focused enough that Objectives can be defined for it. (BMM Concept Catalog): An end that is a state or condition of the enterprise to be brought about or sustained through appropriate means (Dictionary Basis): the end toward which effort or ambition is directed [MWUD 'goal' (2)] (Dictionary Basis): the object of a person's ambition or effort; an aim or desired result [ODE 'goal' (2)] Note: Compared to an objective, a goal tends to be: ongoing; qualitative (rather than quantitative).; general (rather than specific); longer term.

A Goal tends to be longer term, and defined qualitatively rather than quantitatively. It should be narrow - focused enough that Objectives can be defined for it. (BMM Concept Catalog):

A category of measures of the ability of two or more Performers to exchange Resources and to use the Resources that have been exchanged.

(SEI): the ability of two or more systems or components to exchange information and to use the information that has been exchanged [IEEE 90].

Generalization of SEI to Resource exchange

A small reference book, especially one giving instructions.

(Answers.com): A small reference book, especially one giving instructions.

An action or system by which a result is brought about; a method

Tactics, Strategy, Project, any DOTMLPF elements. A type of Resource or System. Activity, Performer, Resources, APBP, and ARO's associated with.

(BMM Concept Catalog): Means are about what an enterprise has decided to do in order to become what it wants to be. A Means is some “device, capability, regime, technique, restriction, agency, instrument, or method that may be called upon, activated, or enforced to achieve Ends”. A Means does not include either the tasks (business processes and workflow) necessary to exploit it, nor responsibility for such tasks. In the Business Motivation Model, Means are organized into Mission, Courses of Action and Directives. A Mission indicates the ongoing operational activity of the enterprise. Its definition should be broad enough to cover all Strategies and the complete area of operations. An enterprise can use the Business Motivation Model without defining a Mission explicitly. General Concept: motivation element Definition: device, capability, regime, technique, restriction, agency, instrument, or method that may be called upon, activated, or enforced to achieve ends Dictionary Basis: an action or system by which a result is brought about; a method [ODE 'means' (1)] Note Categories of means include: mission; course of action; directive.(Dictionary.com): 1. Usually, means. (used with a singular or plural verb ) an agency, instrument, or method used to attain an end: The telephone is a means of communication. There are several means of solving the problem. 2. means, a. available resources, esp. money: They lived beyond their means.b. considerable financial resources; riches: a man of means.(David Hay): Any capability that may be called upon, activated, or enforced to achieve an organization's objectives.(dictionary.cambridge.org): a method or way of doing something. money, for example from an income, that allows you to buy things(Wordcentral.com Merriam-Webster): 3 plural : something by which a desired result is achieved or furthered <means of production> <use any means you can> 4 plural : WEALTH 1 <a person of means> - by all means : without fail : CERTAINLY - by means of : through the use of

definitions relate to means in a statistical, logical, and/or mathematical sense. I believe Activity covers our current definition of Means and Performer (system, personneltype, organization) covers "Available resources." I suggest we delete Means and use Activity or Performer as needed.

I recommended that it be removed, but we are using the phrase "ways and means," taken from JCIDS, in our definition of capability so it must stay. Above are several definitions taken from 3 sources. We have often turned to David Hay, but in this case means is a capability and capability uses ways and means which is a capability . . . Obviously, we can not depend on Mr. Hay in this instance. Definition 1 from dictionary.com is actually synonymous with "ways." We recently changed "exchange object" (formaly "stuff") to "resource." Definition 2a from dictionary.com is explicitly "resource" while several of the other definitions point in that direction. I suggest that means be defined as "available resources," that is,

The new instruction was the means he used to justify his actions.

A Measure whose members are Individuals that all share a common property that can be measured.

Examples:

2kg4 weeks2km

A Measure that is characterised by two MeasurePoints that define its upper and lower bounds.

An instrument or a process, physical or mental, by which something is done or comes into being.

(Answers.com): An instrument or a process, physical or mental, by which something is done or comes into being.

Thing describedBy Information where the Thing is Information

1. A library catalog is information that describes the information in the library

Something that happens at an instant in the world, i.e., a zero-duration process (Activity).

Activity, possibly Event

(DoDAF): A decision point that separates the phases of a directed, funded effort that is designed to provide a new or improved material capability in response to a validated need.(NAF): ProjectMilestone: An event in a <<Project>> by which progress is measured – modeled as a <<Project>> of zero duration. Note: in the case of an acquisition project, there are two key types of milestone which shall be represented using subtypes - <<CapabilityIncrement>> and <<OutOfService>>. (MM)(Webster's): A significant event or stage in the life, progress, development, or the like of a person, nation, etc

Same as Event as a zero duration Activity. Recommend Delete as Milestone is a type of Event and can either be subclassed or made an attribute of the class of event

The task, together with the purpose [DesiredEffect], that clearly indicates the action [Activity] to be taken and the reason [DesiredEffect]; a duty [Activity] assigned to an individual [Personnel Type] or unit [Organization].

Task (=Activity) and DesiredEffect associated with it (them); Activity and ActivityPerformerOverlap where Performer = PersonType or Organization.

clearly indicates the action to be taken.(DDDS Counter (1/3)(A))(NAF) A clear, concise statement of the task of the command and its purpose. Notes: Also, the execution of that task. A purpose to which a person, organisation or autonomous system is tasked. (GEN TERM)(NAF): A purpose to which a person, organisation or autonomous system is tasked. (MM)(JCS 1-02): 1. The task, together with the purpose, that clearly indicates the action to be taken and the reason therefore. 2. In common usage, especially when applied to lower military units, a duty assigned to an individual or unit; a task. 3. The dispatching of one or more aircraft to accomplish one particular task.(Zachman): An overall method for the ongoing operation of the enterprise (what the business is or will be doing on a day-to-day basis).(Webster's): 1. An operational task, usually assigned by a higher headquarters. 2. A sending or being sent for some duty or purpose. 3. A special assignment given to a person or group. 4. A combat operation assigned to a person or military


FOUO 14 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Needline

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Network

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Derived from Webster's. GC

Objective

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

OccupationalTraining Skill

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Operational Activity Activity

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Operational Condition Condition

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Redundant with Condition FL

Outcome An end result; a consequence.

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(Answers.com): An end result; a consequence.

Performer Role

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

performerSupportingActivity

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DoDAF Meta Model Y

Phasing/Evolution/Forecast

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

Physical Asset

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Plan

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

Platform System

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

UPMS

An information technology requirement that is the logical expression of the need to transfer information among performers

composite term accomplished by ActivityOverlap and two PerformerActivityOverlaps

(DoDAF/CADM): ExchangeNeedlineRequirement: An InformationTechnologyRequirement that is the logical expression of the need to transfer information among nodes. (DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(MODAF): A requirement that is the logical expression of the need to transfer information between nodes.(NAF): A relationship specifying the need to exchange information between nodes, uniquely identified in context of the product by its needlineNumber. Note: The needline does not indicate how the transfer is implemented. (MM)

RECOMMEND DELETE as confusing and unnecessary and since "nodes" are gone. Not a core process business object. Also, we don't call out "activitylines", "systemlines", "systemfunctionlines", …

An interconnected or interrelated chain, group, or system

System, group of systems, chain of systems

(DoDAF/CADM): The specification of the joining of two or more nodes for a specific purpose. (DDDS Counter (10972/1)(A))(JC3IEDM): A Facility that provides bearer services for communications and information services and is composed of one or more links and nodes.(NAF): A network is a specialisation of system and is used for communication networks that have a geographical extension. (MM)(Webster's): 1. An openwork fabric or structure in which cords, threads, or wires cross at regular intervals. 2. A system of lines or channels that cross or interconnect. 3. A complex, interconnected group or system. 4. A group or system of electric components and connecting circuitry designed to function in a specific manner. 5. A system of computers interconnected by telephone wires or other means in order to share information.

A clearly defined, decisive, and attainable end toward which every operation is directed. An objective is a specific, time-targeted, measurable, and attainable target that an enterprise seeks to meet in order to achieve its goals.

Desired Result, Effect, Outcome, Consequence

(See above) (BMM Concept Catalog): An end that is a specific time-targeted, measurable, attainable target that an enterprise seeks to meet in order to achieve its goals.Dictionary Basis: something toward which effort is directed: an aim or end of action [MWUD 'objective' (1)] Note: Compared to a goal, an objective is: short-term; not continuing beyond its time frame (although such time frames can be cyclical – monthly, quarterly, etc.). objective quantifies goal Definition: objectives provide the basis for measures to determine that progress is being made towards a goal.

JP 1-02 definition with change of word "goal" in the first line to "end", and addition of requirement to be specific, time-targeted, measurable, and attainable. (from the BMM Concept Catalog). Since Goal is an aggregation of Objectives, one or the other may be redundant.

To make proficient by instruction and practice in particular knowledge or skills.

(DoDAF/CADM): Occupation: A field of work.(DDDS Counter (2009/1)(A)); (See also attributes in ArchitectureFindingRequirementDomain for DOTMLPF)(American Heritage Dictionary): Occupation: 1. A person's usual or principal work or business, esp. as a means of earning a living; vocation. 2. Any activity in which a person is engaged. Education: 1. The act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life. 2. The act or process of imparting or acquiring particular knowledge or skills. 3. The result produced by instruction, training, or study. Training: 1. To make proficient by instruction and practice, as in some art, profession, or work. 2. To discipline and instruct, as in the performance of tasks. 3. To give the discipline and instruction, drill, practice, etc., designed to impart proficiency or efficiency.

Derived from American Heritage definition(s) of Training

Redundant with Skill.

An activity is an action performed in conducting the business of an enterprise. It is a general term that does not imply a placement in a hierarchy (e.g., it could be a process or a task as defined in other documents and it could be at any level of the hierarchy of the Operational Activity Model). It is used to portray operational actions not hardware/software system functions. (DoDAF)

An activity is an action performed in conducting the business of an enterprise. It is a general term that does not imply a placement in a hierarchy (e.g., it could be a process or a task as defined in other documents and it could be at any level of the hierarchy of the Operational Activity Model). It is used to portray operational actions not hardware/software system functions. (DoDAF)

A statement of the values or states needed for the execution of actions within the processes and transactions of an enterprise.

(DoDAF/CADM): A variable of the operational environment or situation in which a unit, system or individual is expected to operate that may affect performance. (DDDS Counter (19589/1)(A))(NAF): OperationalConstraint: A rule governing an operational behaviour or property. (MM)(JCS 1-02): Condition: Those variables of an operational environment or situation in which a unit, system, or individual is expected to operate and may affect performance. See also joint mission essential tasks.

desired effect, desired outcome, desired consequence

Any entity - human, automated, or any aggregation of human and/or automated - that performs a function, activity, or role, or provides a capability.

1. Composite of Performer (and its parts in the case of an aggregate), the Activities it performs, the processes (Activities) it is within (overlaps), and the Capabilities in provides.2. Alias with function (Activity)

of responsibility that performs a certain role. (ARCH ELEM)(Zachman): Party: A PERSON or an ORGANIZATION of interest to the enterprise. This includes PARTIES who are playing roles of "Vendor", "Customer", and "Employee", among others.(American Heritage Dictionary): A function or position. See Synonyms at function. (Wordnet): What something is used for; "the function of an auger is to bore holes"; "ballet is beautiful but what use is it?" [syn: function] (Kernerman English Multilingual Dictionary): The actions or functions of a person in some activity(OMG): A Performer Role is a Part Group that takes responsibility of performing activities in the process. Being an Interactive Part, a Performer Role also has responsibilities to fulfill Interactions that it is involved with other Performer Roles or with Interaction Roles at the boundary of the Process. A Performer Role is a Typed Part for specifying Actor that can play the role at process enactment. A Performer Role can be decomposed into sub Performer Role to delegate responsibility for a subset of its activities or

Derived from CY/KL definition of PERFORMER. Checkout how in ASM. Covered by Performer. Recommend DELETE.

A type of Activity - Performer overlap between a Performer and those Activities which may not necessarily be carried out by the Performer but which are necessary for the performance of the Activity

ActivityPerformerOverlap of the Activities actually performed by the Performer and then Activity overlaps between them and the supported Activity

(DoDAF Meta Model): A type of Activity - Performer overlap between a Performer and those Activities which may not necessarily be carried out by the Performer but which are necessary for the performance of the Activity

Phase: A stage in a process of change or development. Evolution: Any process of formation or growth; development. Forecast: To predict a future condition or occurrence

before after relationships, temporal state, time period

(DoDAF/CADM): (multiple entities)(NAF): Forecast: A statement about the future state of one or more types of system or standard. (MM)(Webster's): Phasing: 1. Any of the major appearances or aspects in which a thing of varying modes or conditions manifests itself to the eye or mind. 2. A stage in a process of change or development. Evolution: 1. Any process of formation or growth; development. 2. A product of such development; something evolved. Forecast: 1. To predict (a future condition or occurrence); calculate in advance. 2. To serve as a prediction of; foreshadow. 3. To contrive or plan beforehand; prearrange. 4. To conjecture beforehand; make a prediction. 5. To plan or arrange beforehand. 6. A prediction. Synonyms: foretell, anticipate, project, estimate, forethought, prescience.

The butterfly is in the caterpillar phase of it's life; I forecast it will soon evolve into a beautiful Monarch.

Covered by the Real Property and Materiel concepts

Real Property, Materiel

(NAF): PhysicalAsset: A <<Resource>> that can host systems and/or people. Note 1: synonyms for <<PhysicalAsset>>; would be "platform", "facility", or "host". This is the original intent for the "SystemsNode" concept in DoDAF. Note 2: A <<PhysicalAsset>> can contribute to a <<CapabilityConfiguration>>, and is usually configured for that purpose. It may be that a given platform can be configured and manned in many different ways to achieve different capabilities. In these cases, a class should be created for the <<PhysicalAsset>> in general, and this should be abstract. The variants of the asset should be created as concrete classes, specializing from the abstract class. (MM)(Webster's): Asset: 1. A useful or valuable quality, person, or thing; an advantage or resource. 2. A valuable item that is owned.

A set of Activities that result in a Goal, Desired Effect, outcome, or objective.

Course of Action, Activity aggregate (temporal or otherwise)

(BMM Concept Catalog): Courses of Action are what the enterprise has decided to do. A Course of Action is more than simply a resource, skill, or competency that the enterprise can call upon. A Course of Action is a way of configuring some aspect of the enterprise (things, processes, locations, people, time) to channel efforts towards Desired Results - the result of a decision by the enterprise about the best way to use its resources, skills, and competencies. A Course of Action defines what has to be done, not how well it has to be done. Measures of Performance are defined in Objectives that are supported by the Courses of Action.

A set of subsystems/technologies that provide a coherent set of functionality through interfaces and specified usage patterns that any subsystem that depends on the platform can use without concern for the details of how the functionality provided by the platform is implemented.

UML Profile and Metamodel for Services (UPMS) RFP OMG Document: soa/2006-09-09: A set of subsystems/technologies that provide a coherent set of functionality through interfaces and specified usage patterns that any subsystem that depends on the platform can use without concern for the details of how the functionality provided by the platform is implemented.


FOUO 15 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Policy Rule

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Process

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Program Project

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Quality of Services

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RateThroughput

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Seems to be the most general DM

Relationship A connection, association, or involvement. Tuple, TupleType

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(dictionary.com): a connection, association, or involvement.

Reliability

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Generalization of SEI

Requirement Rule

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Responsibility

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Restraint Rule

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Role

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Schedule Dependency

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

SecurityMeasure

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

SEI

Service Level Agreement

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

ServiceFunction

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

ServicePolicy An agreement governing one or more Services

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

A course of action, guiding principle, or procedure considered expedient, prudent, or advantageous

(Answers.com): A course of action, guiding principle, or procedure considered expedient, prudent, or advantageous

A logical, systematic sequence of activities, triggered by an event, producing a meaningful output.


(NAF): A predetermined course of events defined by its purpose or by its effect, achieved under given conditions. (GEN TERM)(NAF): OperationalProcess: An Operational Process is a logical sequence of activities that is triggered by an event and transforms a specific input into a meaningful output. (ARCH ELEM)(Zachman): A kind of ACTIVITY performed by the enterprise to produce a specific output or achieve a goal. It may or may not be described in terms of the MECHANISMS or the PARTIES performing it. A set of PROCESSES is usually described in sequence.(American Heritage Dictionary): 1. A systematic series of actions directed to some end. 2. A continuous action, operation, or series of changes taking place in a definite manner. 3. The action of going forward or on. 4. The condition of being carried on.(Webster's): 1. A natural phenomenon marked by gradual changes that lead toward a particular result. 2. A continuing activity or function. 3. A series of actions or operations

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions, with emphasis on NAF. Redundant with Activity.

1. "The process of growth."2. "The process of sorting mail"

A directed funded effort that provides a new, improved, or continuing materiel, weapon or information system or service capability in response to an approved need.

(AR 70-1): A directed funded effort that provides a new, improved, or continuing materiel, weapon or information system or service capability in response to an approved need.

The ability to provide different priority to different applications, users, or data flows, or to guarantee a certain level of performance to a data flow.

activityPerformerOverlapTypeInstanceOfMeasure activityResourceOverlapTypeInstanceOfMeasure

(Answers.com): The ability to provide different priority to different applications, users, or data flows, or to guarantee a certain level of performance to a data flow.

The ratio of the effective or useful output to the total input in any system.

Performance Measure

(SEI): the amount of work that can be performed by a computer system or component in a given period of time [IEEE 90].(WordNet, throughput): output relative to input; the amount passing through a system from input to output (American Heritage, efficiency): The ratio of the effective or useful output to the total input in any system. (Wikipedia, business throughput): In the business management Theory of Constraints, throughput is the rate at which a system produces money

A category of measures of the ability of a Performer to perform its required Activities under stated conditions for a specified period of time.

(SEI): the ability of a system or component to perform its required functions under stated conditions for a specified period of time [IEEE 90].

A singular documented need of what a particular product or service should be or do

be or do. It is most commonly used in a formal sense in systems engineering or software engineering. It is a statement that identifies a necessary attribute, capability, characteristic, or quality of a system in order for it to have value and utility to a user.[Young, Ralph R. Effective Requirements Practices. Boston: Addison-Wesley, 2001. See also RalphYoung.net, a website devoted to requirements-related topics.] In the classical engineering approach, sets of requirements are used as inputs into the design stages of product development. Requirements show what elements and function are necessary for the particular project. In systems engineering, a requirement can be a description of what a system must do, referred to as a Functional Requirement. This type of requirement specifies something that the delivered system must be able to do. Another type of requirement specifies something about the system itself, and how well it performs its functions. Such requirements are often called Non-functional requirements, or 'performance requirements' or 'quality of service requirements.' Examples of such requirements include

Answerable or accountable, as for something within one's power, control, or management

Association between a Performer and an Activity by or under an Agreement between an authority Performer and a performing Performer that performing Performer perform Activities in accordance with certain Metrics, Rules, Conditions, and Locations.

(Dictionary.com): 1. answerable or accountable, as for something within one's power, control, or management (often fol. by to or for): He is responsible to the president for his decisions. 2. involving accountability or responsibility: a responsible position. 3. chargeable with being the author, cause, or occasion of something (usually fol. by for): Termites were responsible for the damage. 4. having a capacity for moral decisions and therefore accountable; capable of rational thought or action: The defendant is not responsible for his actions. 5. able to discharge obligations or pay debts. 6. reliable or dependable, as in meeting debts, conducting business dealings, etc. 7. (of a government, member of a government, government agency, or the like) answerable to or serving at the discretion of an elected legislature or the electorate.

to moderate or limit the force, effect, development, or full exercise of

(Webster's) to moderate or limit the force, effect, development, or full exercise of

A set of similar or otherwise logically related activities, implying a set of skills or capabilities, to which a performer may be assigned.

Performer, Activity, and their overlap

(DoDAF): A function or position. (Webster’s)(DoDAF/CADM): OperationalRole: The specification of a set of abilities required for performing assigned activities and achieving an objective. (DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(MODAF): A function or position filled by a person or organisation.(NAF): An aspect of a person or organisation that enables them to fulfill a particular function. (MM)(IDEAS): An AgentRole is an AgentState where the agent is conducting processes.(Webster's): 1. A function or position. 2. The actions and activities assigned to or required or expected of a person or group.(WordNet): What something is used for; "the function of an auger is to bore holes"; "ballet is beautiful but what use is it?" [synonym: function] (OASIS EA file): A role is an identified relationship between a participant and a social structure that defines the rights, responsibilities, qualifications, and authorities of that participant within the context of the social structure.

The role is not the performer, but we have other concepts to capture a logical structure of activities. Useful, however, to be able to extract activities by performer.

Cross-reference between two more basic concepts is derivative; recommend delete until we go to logical.

Any set of activities to which a single performer may be assigned; an MOS or any other definition of a set of related skills that a single performer might have

CY/KL

Schedule dependencies deal with Resources that an Activity requires in order to proceed.

Before after relationships between Activities and Resources

(DISA doc TBS): Schedule dependencies include capabilities that a program is relying upon to meet life-cycle events. For example, program Alpha needs functionality from Program Bravo in order to meet milestone B.

A measure of the ability of a Performer to manage, protect, and distribute sensitive information.

Performance Measure

(SEI): the ability of a system to manage, protect, and distribute sensitive information.

Part of a service contract where the level of service is formally defined

Agreement, Constraint

(Answers.com): Part of a service contract where the level of service is formally defined

White box implementation of the Activities of the Service.

Activity known to be a Service Function when it is performed by a Service

(MODAF): White box description of the Activities of the Service.OASIS SOA RA: Action is the application of intent by a participant (or agent) to achieve a real world effect.

Agreement, Constraint

OASIS SOA RA: As described in the Reference Model, a policy is the representation of a constraint or condition on the use, deployment, or description of an owned entity as defined by any participant. A contract is a representation of an agreement between two or more participants. Technically, the only difference between a policy and a contract is the agreement between two or more parties to a contract and the enforceability of a policy by one party on other parties.


FOUO 16 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


SoA Service composite term

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

SoS

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

FS

Source pedigree model

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Strategy A long-term plan to achieve pre-set goals Plan, project

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

System Function

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Tactic A short-term action used to accomplish a strategy Plan, project

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Task

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

GC

Technical Dependency

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Technology

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DoDAF/CADM defintion. Y

Term Name

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Timeliness

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

DM

A distinct part of the functionality that is provided by a technical system on one side of an interface to a general system on the other side of the interface (Derived from IEEE 1003.0). Characterized by transparency, autonomy, loose coupling, and discovery.

(DoDAF): Service Oriented Architecture is a paradigm for organizing and utilizing distributed capabilities that may be under the control of different ownership domains. It provides a uniform means to offer, discover, interact with and use capabilities to produce desired effects consistent with measurable(DoDAF/CADM): A business or computational resource available within an enterprise that can be linked on demand to achieve a desired result.(NAF): Service: A type of delivered functionality, specified independently of the capabilities that provide it. Note: A service may or may not have a physical effect on its environment. (MM).(Wikipedia): An architectural style that guides all aspects of creating and using business processes, packaged as services, throughout their lifecycle, as well as defining and provisioning the IT infrastructure that allows different applications to exchange data and participate in business processes loosely coupled from the operating systems and programming languages underlying those applications.

To simplify the concept and avoid unhelpful controversy, suggest we follow OASIS' lead and limit the "service" concept to software services.

Suggest that we do NOT include the term SOA Service in the DoDAF 2.0 concept model at this time. The term appears to be used most frequently to refer to infrastructure type services (software) and because SOA is a design approach, don't think we want to

NCES SOA Foundation Services, including Service Discovery, Service Security, Enterprise Service Management, Metadata Services and Mediation (DISA brief, Dr. Robert Wojcik, 14 Mar 06).

CY/KL

A set or arrangement of interdependent systems that are related or connected to provide a given capability. The loss of any part of the system could significantly degrade the performance or capabilities of the whole. The development of an SoS solution will involve trade space between the systems as well as within an individual system performance.

Systems that have interface overlaps necessary to achieve Capabilities.

(CJCSI 3170.01F): A set or arrangement of interdependent systems that are related or connected to provide a given capability. The loss of any part of the system could significantly degrade the performance or capabilities of the whole. The development of an SoS solution will involve trade space between the systems as well as within an individual system performance.

CJCSI 3170.01F is the defining authority.

One, such as a person or document, that supplies information

(Answers.com): One, such as a person or document, that supplies information

In the Business Motivation Model, Courses of Action are categorized as Strategies and Tactics. The model does not make a hard distinction between the two. Enterprises define their own criteria. Strategies tend to be long term and fairly broad in scope. Each Strategy is implemented by Tactics, which tend to be shorter term and narrower in scope. A Tactic may contribute to the implementation of more than one Strategy. (BMM Concept Catalog): Definition: a course of action that is an element of a plan devised through the science and art of business leadership exercised to ensure the most advantageous conditions Dictionary Basis: the science and art of military command exercised to meet the enemy in combat under advantageous conditions [MWUD 'strategy' (1a2)] Dictionary Basis: a careful plan or method or a clever stratagem [MWUD 'strategy' (2a)] Note Compared to a tactic, a strategy tends to be: longer term; broader in scope.

Adapted from BMM

Strategy has a very specific meaning in a military context and should probably not be used outside of that meaning.

Reduce the ability of an enemy to fight by cutting off financial income

A function that is performed by a system. Although commonly used to refer to the automation of activities, data transformation or information exchanges within IT systems, it also refers to the delivery of military capabilities.


activities or information elements exchange.(DoDAF/CADM): (ProcessActivity, catCode=2) The representation of a means by which a process acts on some input to produce a specific output. (DDDS Counter (4204/3)(A))(MODAF): A function that is performed by a system. Although commonly used to refer to data transformation within IT systems it may also refer to the delivery of military capabilities such a “ground manoeuvre” or “deep strike”.(NAF): Function: An activity which is specified in context of the resource (human or machine) that performs it. Note1: Contrast with <<OperationalActivity>>, where the actor performing the activity is not known (i.e., it is just a logical node). A <<Function>> is implementation-specific. Note2: Should the <<Function>> be specific to one usage of a type of system, then the usageContext is specified by a reference to the composite structure property <<ResourceComposition>> typed by the system. (MM)(Zachman): Function: A type of ACTIVITY to carry out a MISSION, GOAL or OBJECTIVE of the enterprise. It is described solely in terms of what it is intended to accomplish, without regard to the technology used to carry it out or who is to perform it. This is

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions DoDAF and MODAF.

candidate for deletion? Need good definitions of System and Function.

(BMM Concept Catalog): Definition: a course of action that is a device or expedient to be employed as part of a strategy Note: Compared to a strategy, a tactic tends to be: shorter term and narrower in scope. Dictionary Basis: a device or expedient for accomplishing an end [MWUD 'tactics' (2b)] Dictionary Basis: a plan scheme or trick with a particular aim [ODE 'device' (2)] There is a de-facto correspondence between Course of Action and Desired Results. Generally, Strategies are selected to move the enterprise towards its Goals, and Tactics to ensure that it meets its Objectives. But this is not hard-wired into the model; enterprises can make the correspondences they need. Courses of Action do not necessarily have to support Desired Results directly; some are selected to enable other Courses of Action.

Adapted from the dictionary

Tactic has a very specific meaning in a military context and should probably not be used outside of that meaning.

Use a blockade to financially strangle an opponent.

Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTP)

The actions and methods that implement doctrine and describe how forces will be employed in operations

Activity, Rule, Organization and their inter-relationships

(DOD) The actions and methods which implement joint doctrine and describe how forces will be employed in joint operations. They will be promulgated by the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, in coordination with the combatant commands, Services, and Joint Staff.

A action, activity or undertaking enabling missions, activities or functions to be performed or accomplished.


(DoDAF): An action or activity (derived from an analysis of the mission and concept of operations) assigned to an individual or organization to provide a capability. (UJTL, CJCSM 3500.04D, 2005)(DoDAF/CADM): A directed activity.(DDDS Counter (290/2)(A))(MODAF): A discrete unit of work, not specific to a single organisation, weapon system or individual, that enables missions or functions to be accomplished.(NAF): EnduringTask: A type of behavior recognized by an enterprise as being essential to achieving its goals – i.e., a strategic specification of what the enterprise does. (MM)(American Heritage Dictionary): 1. A function to be performed. 2. A definite piece of work assigned to, falling to, or expected of a person; duty. 3. Any piece of work. Potential Aliases: function, activity, process activity.(Webster's): 1. A usually assigned piece of work often to be finished within a certain time. Potential Aliases: (WordNet): 1. Any piece of work that is undertaken or attempted. 2. A specific piece of work required to be done as a duty. 3. A well-defined responsibility that is usually imposed by another.

Derived from a commonality among candidate definitions DoDAF and MODAF. (NOTE: The concept of Tasks as "directives" and/or "assignments" is omitted from this definition, as Tasks can arise or exist unassigned).

1. "Completing the task at hand."2. "The endless task of classifying the samples."3. "Being tasked to refuel a vehicle."

A Constraint on an Activity related to Performer(s) or Resource(s) needed.

Rule to PerformerResource - Performer overlapResource consumed by Performer

(TBS): Technical dependencies include technical specifications (e.g. HTTP, FTP, etc), network infrastructures (e.g. AirNet), and hosting environments (e.g. DISA's Denver, CO DECC).

The application of science to meet one or more objectives.

type of Project or Performer?

(DoDAF/CADM): The application of science to meet one or more objectives.(DDDS Counter (19607/1)(A))(American Heritage Dictionary): 1. The branch of knowledge that deals with the creation and use of technical means and their interrelation with life, society, and the environment, drawing upon such subjects as industrial arts, engineering, applied science, and pure science. 2. The terminology of an art, science, etc.; technical nomenclature. 3. A technological process, invention, method, or the like. 4. The sum of the ways in which social groups provide themselves with the material objects of their civilization. 5. The application of science, especially to industrial or commercial objectives. 6. The scientific method and material used to achieve a commercial or industrial objective.(Webster's): 1. The practical application of knowledge especially in a particular area. 2. A capability given by the practical application of knowledge. 3. A manner of accomplishing a task especially using technical processes, methods, or knowledge. 4. The specialized aspects of aparticular field of endeavor

A word or group of words having a particular meaning

(Answers.com): A word or group of words having a particular meaning

The time from the occurrence of an event to the time required action occurs.

Performance Measure

(DoDAF): Required maximum time from node to node expressed in seconds(CADM, timeliness code): The code that represents how quickly information should be transmitted using a specific InformationTechnologyRequirement.

Generalized the DoDAF beyond node and specific units.


FOUO 17 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Trigger

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

RW

Trustworthiness

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

SEI

Unit Organization

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

JP 1-02 authority

Used In Put into service

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

(Answers.com): Put into service

User Actor

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Users of a given IT system

WholeLifeEnterprise

c. A

lias/

com

posi

te

Classification

d. E

xter

nal

UCORE 1.1 s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s

d. E

xter

nal

DM2 associative entity Y

ClassificationReason

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


ClassificationType

d. E

xter

nal


ClassifiedBy Use as specified by E.O. 12958.

d. E

xter

nal

(UCORE 1.1): Use as specified by E.O. 12958. UCORE 1.1 s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s

d. E

xter

nal


DateOfExemptedSource

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DeclassDate

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DeclassEvent

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DeclassException

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DeclassManualReview

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DerivedFrom

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


DisseminationControls

d. E

xter

nal


Something that happens at an instant in the world, i.e., a zero-duration process (Activity).

Event or composite of Event and the Activity it triggers

(DoDAF): Specifies the event that fires a transition. There can be at most one trigger per transition. (A Transition is defined in DoDAF as "A relationship between two states indicating that an object in the first state will perform certain specified actions and enter the second state when a specified Event occurs and specified conditions are satisfied. On such a change of state, the transition is said to fire.")(DoDAF/CADM): (Events trigger OperationalMissionThreads)(Webster's): Anything, as an act or event, that serves as a stimulus and initiates or precipitates a reaction or series of reactions.

Recommend Delete as Milestone is a type of Event and can either be subclassed or made an attribute of the class of event

A category of measures of the degree to which a Performer avoids compromising, corrupting, or delaying sensitive information.

Performance Measure

(SEI): the degree to which a system or component avoids compromising, corrupting, or delaying sensitive information.

Any military element whose structure is prescribed by competent authority, such as a table of organization and equipment; specifically, part of an organization.

(JP 1-02): 1. Any military element whose structure is prescribed by competent authority, such as a table of organization and equipment; specifically, part of an organization. 2. An organization title of a subdivision of a group in a task force. 3. A standard or basic quantity into which an item of supply is divided, issued, or used. In this meaning, also called unit of issue. 4. With regard to Reserve Components of the Armed Forces, denotes a Selected Reserve unit organized, equipped, and trained for mobilization to serve on active duty as a unit or to augment or be augmented by another unit. Headquarters and support functions without wartime missions are not considered units. (JC3IEDM): A military ORGANISATION whose structure is prescribed by competent authority.(Dictionary.com): an organized body of soldiers, varying in size and constituting a subdivision of a larger body. (Wordnet): an organization regarded as part of a larger social group

Description whole part

Any actor (as defined above) that invokes an automated performer.

(DoDAF): Humans or machines who must exchange information in pursuit of their shared goals, interests, missions, or business processes and who therefore must have shared vocabulary for the information they exchange.(Webster's): A person who makes use of a thing; someone who uses or employs something.

Given "performer" and "actor", seems useful to specialize "user" to refer to the original, narrow Jacobsen concept of "actor".

Since we don't need to support specific methodologies at this point, recommend delete. May add it back in logical.

CY/KL

(MODAF 1.2): An EnterprisePhase that represents the whole existance of an enterprise.(Bailey email 2010-06-02): WLEP is also a phase, it’s just that it lasts the whole life of the enterprise (hence it is a special case of an enterprise phase, and therefore a subtype).

This attribute is used at both the product and the element levels to identify the highest level of classification of the information. It is manifested in portion marks and security banners.

(UCORE 1.1): This attribute is used at both the product and the element levels to identify the highest level of classification of the information. It is manifested in portion marks and security banners.

classificationPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between Classification and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between Classification and SecurityAttributeGroup

A text string containing one or more paragraph numbers, 1.4(a) through 1.4(h), taken from E.O. 12958, as amended. Enter the paragraph references as they should appear in a classification/declassification block.

(UCORE 1.1): A text string containing one or more paragraph numbers, 1.4(a) through 1.4(h), taken from E.O. 12958, as amended. Enter the paragraph references as they should appear in a classification/declassification block.

classificationReasonPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ClassificationReason and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ClassificationReason and SecurityAttributeGroup

A simple type in which a name token is restricted to the US, non-US, and joint classification portionmark abbreviations from the CAPCO Register.

(UCORE 1.1): A simple type in which a name token is restricted to the US, non-US, and joint classification portionmark abbreviations from the CAPCO Register.

classifiedByPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ClassifiedBy and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ClassifiedBy and SecurityAttributeGroup

A specific date, in the format YYYY-MM-DD. Used in conjunction with attribute "typeOfExemptedSource." If there are multiple exempted sources, specify the date of the exempted source that has the most recent date.

(UCORE 1.1): A specific date, in the format YYYY-MM-DD. Used in conjunction with attribute "typeOfExemptedSource." If there are multiple exempted sources, specify the date of the exempted source that has the most recent date.

dateOfExemptedSourcePartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DateOfExemptedSource and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DateOfExemptedSource and SecurityAttributeGroup

A specific date, in the format YYYY-MM-DD, at which the applicable information is automatically declassified.

(UCORE 1.1): A specific date, in the format YYYY-MM-DD, at which the applicable information is automatically declassified.

declassDatePartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassDate and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassDate and SecurityAttributeGroup

A textual description of an event that triggers declassification.

(UCORE 1.1): A textual description of an event that triggers declassification.

declassEventPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassEvent and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassEvent and SecurityAttributeGroup

One or more of the exceptions to 25-year declassification: specify "25X1-human", "25X1", "25X2", ..., "25X9". If more than one exception applies, use a space-delimited list. If "25X1-human" applies, it should be first in a list.

(UCORE 1.1): One or more of the exceptions to 25-year declassification: specify "25X1-human", "25X1", "25X2", ..., "25X9". If more than one exception applies, use a space-delimited list. If "25X1-human" applies, it should be first in a list.

declassExceptionPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassException and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassException and SecurityAttributeGroup

A true/false indication that manual review is required for declassification. Use this attribute to force the appearance of "//MR" in the header and footer marking titles. Use this attribute ONLY when it is necessary to override the business logic applied to classification and control markings in the document to determine whether manual review is required.

(UCORE 1.1): A true/false indication that manual review is required for declassification. Use this attribute to force the appearance of "//MR" in the header and footer marking titles. Use this attribute ONLY when it is necessary to override the business logic applied to classification and control markings in the document to determine whether manual review is required.

declassManualReviewPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassManualReview and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DeclassManualReview and SecurityAttributeGroup

A text string containing (a) the title and date of a specific source document, or (b) the title and date of an organization classification guide, or (c) the literal string "Multiple Sources".

(UCORE 1.1): A text string containing (a) the title and date of a specific source document, or (b) the title and date of an organization classification guide, or (c) the literal string "Multiple Sources".

derivedFromPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DerivedFrom and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DerivedFrom and SecurityAttributeGroup

Authorized dissemination control portion mark abbreviation(s). Either (a) a single abbreviation or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order shown in the CAPCO Register. Exception: For the "REL" abbreviation, omit the country code trigraph(s) and instead place the trigraph(s) in the "releasableTo" attribute value.

(UCORE 1.1): Authorized dissemination control portion mark abbreviation(s). Either (a) a single abbreviation or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order shown in the CAPCO Register. Exception: For the "REL" abbreviation, omit the country code trigraph(s) and instead place the trigraph(s) in the "releasableTo" attribute value.


FOUO 18 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


d. E

xter

nal


FGIsourceOpen

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


FGIsourceProtected

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


NonICmarkings

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


OwnerProducerd.

Ext

erna

lUCORE 1.1 s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s s

d. E

xter

nal


ReleasableTo

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


SARIdentifier

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


SCIControls

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


TypeOfExemptedSource

d. E

xter

nal


d. E

xter

nal


Attribute Property, Measure

AuthentificationInfo

Capability

Collaboration Operational Node?

Collaboration

CollaborationUse

Consumer

Contract

DisclosurePoliciesInfo

Education

e. N

ew D

D te

rm

Derived from Webster's. Y

disseminationControlsPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DisseminationControls and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between DisseminationControls and SecurityAttributeGroup

Non-US classification portion marking for foreign government information in a document portion. Use this attribute to record a source country when the intent is to post the document to a shared space with the source identified.

(UCORE 1.1): Non-US classification portion marking for foreign government information in a document portion. Use this attribute to record a source country when the intent is to post the document to a shared space with the source identified.

FGIsourceOpenPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between FGIsourceOpen and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between FGIsourceOpen and SecurityAttributeGroup

Non-US classification portion marking for foreign government information in a document portion. Use this attribute to record a source country when the intent is to filter out the identity of the source prior to posting the document to a shared space.

(UCORE 1.1): Non-US classification portion marking for foreign government information in a document portion. Use this attribute to record a source country when the intent is to filter out the identity of the source prior to posting the document to a shared space.

FGIsourceProtectedPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between FGIsourceProtected and SecurityAttributeGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between FGIsourceProtected and SecurityAttributeGroup

Authorized non-IC portion marking abbreviation(s) from the CAPCO Register. Either (a) a single non-IC abbreviated marking or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order shown in the CAPCO Register.

(UCORE 1.1): Authorized non-IC portion marking abbreviation(s) from the CAPCO Register. Either (a) a single non-IC abbreviated marking or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order shown in the CAPCO Register.

nonICmarkingsPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between NonICmarkings and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between NonICmarkings and SecurityAttributesGroup

ISO 3166-1 trigraph(s) of the owner or producer country(ies) and/or CAPCO-specified tetragraphs of international organizations. Either (a) a single trigraph or tetragraph or (b) a space-delimited list of trigraphs followed by tetragraphs. Trigraphs must be in alphabetical order and tetragraphs must be in alphabetical order.

(UCORE 1.1): ISO 3166-1 trigraph(s) of the owner or producer country(ies) and/or CAPCO-specified tetragraphs of international organizations. Either (a) a single trigraph or tetragraph or (b) a space-delimited list of trigraphs followed by tetragraphs. Trigraphs must be in alphabetical order and tetragraphs must be in alphabetical order.

ownerProducerPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between OwnerProducer and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between OwnerProducer and SecurityAttributesGroup

ISO 3166-1 trigraphic codes of countries to which the associated content can be released. Include "USA" in all instances. Use a space- delimited list with "USA" first, followed by the other trigraph(s) in alphabetical order.

(UCORE 1.1): ISO 3166-1 trigraphic codes of countries to which the associated content can be released. Include "USA" in all instances. Use a space- delimited list with "USA" first, followed by the other trigraph(s) in alphabetical order.

releasableToPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ReleasableTo and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between ReleasableTo and SecurityAttributesGroup

Authorized Special Access Required program digraph(s) or trigraph(s) preceded by "SAR-". Either (a) a single digraph or trigraph or (b) a space-delimited list of digraphs or trigraphs. Example: "SAR-ABC SAR-DEF ..."

(UCORE 1.1): Authorized Special Access Required program digraph(s) or trigraph(s) preceded by "SAR-". Either (a) a single digraph or trigraph or (b) a space-delimited list of digraphs or trigraphs. Example: "SAR-ABC SAR-DEF ..."

SARIdentifierPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between SARIdentifier and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between SARIdentifier and SecurityAttributesGroup

Authorized abbreviation(s) of SCI control system(s). Either (a) a single abbreviation or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order prescribed in the CAPCO Register.

(UCORE 1.1): Authorized abbreviation(s) of SCI control system(s). Either (a) a single abbreviation or (b) a space-delimited list of abbreviations in the order prescribed in the CAPCO Register.

SCIControlsPartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between SCIControls and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between SCIControls and SecurityAttributesGroup

One or more tokens indicating that a source that is exempted from automatic declassification applies. Specify "OADR", "X1", "X2", ..., "X8". If more than one applies, use a space-delimited list.

(UCORE 1.1): One or more tokens indicating that a source that is exempted from automatic declassification applies. Specify "OADR", "X1", "X2", ..., "X8". If more than one applies, use a space-delimited list.

typeOfExemptedSourcePartOfSecurityAttributesGroup

A couple that represents the whole part relationship between TypeOfExemptedSource and SecurityAttributesGroup

(DM2): A couple that represents the whole part relationship between TypeOfExemptedSource and SecurityAttributesGroup

e. N

ew D

D

term

(Random House Dictionary): something attributed as belonging to a person, thing, group, etc.; a quality, character, characteristic, or property: Sensitivity is one of his attributes. (CJSCI 3170.01G): A quantitative or qualitative characteristic of an element or its actions.

e. N

ew D

D

term

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A Capability is the ability to act and produce an outcome that achieves a result. It can. Specify a general capability of a participant as well as the specific ability to provide a service.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML): Collaboration is extended to indicate whether the role to part bindings of CollaborationUses typed by a Collaboration are strictly enforced or not. 3 : to cooperate with an agency or instrumentality with which one is not immediately connected

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): Collaboration is extended to indicate whether the role to part bindings of CollaborationUses typed by a Collaboration are strictly enforced or not.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): CollaborationUse is extended to indicate whether the role to part bindings are strictly enforced or loose.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): Consumer models the type of a service consumer. A consumer is then used as the type of a role in a service contract and the type of a port on a participant.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(dictionary): an agreement between two or more parties for the doing or not doing of something specified.(OO): TBS

e. N

ew D

D

term

1. The act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life. 2. the act or process of imparting or acquiring particular knowledge or skills.

(JCS 1-02): Military Education: The systematic instruction of individuals in subjects that will enhance their knowledge of the science and art of war.(Webster's): Leadership: 1. The position or function of a leader. 2. Ability to lead. Education: 1. The act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life. 2. the act or process of imparting or acquiring particular knowledge or skills.

GC/RW


FOUO 19 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Knowledge

e. N

ew D

D te

rm

Y

Leadership

e. N

ew D

D te

rm

Derived from Webster's. Y

Milestone

Participant

Port

provider

Real World Effect

Request (port stereotype)

e. N

ew D

D te

rm

Service

Service Interface

ServiceChannel

ServiceContract

e. N

ew D

D te

rm

ServiceContract

Services Architecture

Ways and Means (BMM) TBD

effectPartOfCapability Whole-part association IDEAS Y

goalsRealizedByProject

z. c

hang

ed

Best generalizes to "stuff" Y DM

overlapPart overlap IDEAS Y

the fact or state of knowing; the perception of fact or truth; clear and certain mental apprehension.

(www.dictionary.com): 1. acquaintance with facts, truths, or principles, as from study or investigation; general erudition: knowledge of many things. 2. familiarity or conversance, as with a particular subject or branch of learning: A knowledge of accounting was necessary for the job. 3. acquaintance or familiarity gained by sight, experience, or report: a knowledge of human nature. 4. the fact or state of knowing; the perception of fact or truth; clear and certain mental apprehension. 5.awareness, as of a fact or circumstance: He had knowledge of her good fortune 6. something that is or may be known; information: He sought knowledge of her activities. 7. the body of truths or facts accumulated in the course of time. 8. the sum of what is known: Knowledge of the true situation is limited."

1. The position or function of a leader. 2. Ability to lead.

(JCS 1-02): Military Education: The systematic instruction of individuals in subjects that will enhance their knowledge of the science and art of war.(Webster's): Leadership: 1. The position or function of a leader. 2. Ability to lead. Education: 1. The act or process of imparting or acquiring general knowledge, developing the powers of reasoning and judgment, and generally of preparing oneself or others intellectually for mature life. 2. the act or process of imparting or acquiring particular knowledge or skills.

GC/RW

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A Milestone is a means for depicting progress in behaviors in order to analyze liveness. Milestones are particularly useful for behaviors that are long lasting or even infinite.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A participant is the type of a provider and/or consumer of services. In the business domain a participant may be a person, organization or system. In the systems domain a participant may be a system, application or component.

PerformerCapableOfResponsibility

e. N

ew D

D

term

e. N

ew D

D

term (SoAML UPMS, beta 2): Extends UML Port with a means to

indicate whether a Connection is required on this Port or not

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): Provider models the type of a service provider in a consumer/provider relationship. A provider is then used as the type of a role in a service contract and the type of a port on a participant.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A ServicesContract is used to model an agreement between two or more parties and may constrain the expected real world effects of a service.

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A Request represents a feature of a Participant that is the consumption of a service by one participant provided by others using well-defined terms, conditions and interfaces. A Request designates ports that define the connection point through which a Participant meets its needs through the consumption of services provided by others. A request port is a “conjugate” port. This means that the provided and required interfaces of the port type are inverted; this creates a port that uses the port type rather than implementing the port type.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A Service represents a feature of a Participant that is the offer of a service by one participant to others using well defined terms, conditions and interfaces. A Service designates a Port that defines the connection point through which a Participant offers its capabilities and provides a service to clients

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): Provides the definition of a service. Defines the specification of a service interaction as the type of a «Service» or «Request» port.

e. N

ew D

D

term (SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A communication path between

Services and Requests within an architecture.

Specification for a Service that then serves as a vehicle to communcated terms and conditions. Specification of the joint action between the parties, including roles, what exchanged, metrics, rules, yada, yada. Proposed contract, not the instance to instance level agreement. High level and lower level things. From SoaML: A ServiceContract is the specification of the agreement between providers and consumers of a service as to what information, products, assets, value and obligations will flow between the providers and consumers of that service – it specifies the service without regard for realization, capabilities or implementation. A ServiceContract does not require the specification of who, how or why any party will fulfill their obligations under that ServiceContract, thus providing for the loose coupling of the SOA paradigm. In most cases a ServiceContract will specify two roles (provider and consumer) – but other service roles may be specified as well. The ServiceContract may also own a behavior that specifies the sequencing of the exchanges between the parties as well as the resulting state and delivery of the capability. The owned behavior is the choreography of the service and may use any of the standard UML behaviors such as an interaction, timing, state or activity diagram.

(SoAML): A ServiceContract is the formalization of a binding exchange of information, goods, or obligations between parties defining a service. (regular dictionary): Contract: 1 a : a binding agreement between two or more persons or parties; especially : one legally enforceable b : a business arrangement for the supply of goods or services at a fixed price <make parts on contract> c : the act of marriage or an agreement to marry. 2 : a document describing the terms of a contract(OASIS SoA RM): TBS

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): A ServiceContract is the formalization of a binding exchange of information, goods, or obligations between parties defining a service.

e. N

ew D

D

term

(SoAML UPMS, beta 2): The high-level view of a Service Oriented Architecture that defines how a set of participants works together, forming a community, for some purpose by providing and using services.

Activities or collections of activities.

e. N

ew D

D

term

DesiredEffectTypePartOfCapability

z. c

hang

ed

(IDEAS): A whole part association between a Facility (part) and the Site (whole) in which it resides.

An overlap of the future state or casual disposition of a Project to manifested Goals (states of Effect Objects).

IndividualDesiredEffectIsRealizedByProject

(DoDAF/CADM): TechnicalIterface: A generic connection between two elements that implements information technology in which information is capable of being transmitted from the source element to the destination element. (DDDS Counter (21694/1)(A))(NAF): ServiceInterface: The mechanism by which a <<Service>> communicates. Note: a <<ServiceInterface>> specifies the <<ServiceInterfaceDefinition>> provided and required by the <<Service>>. (MM)(JCS 1-02): A boundary or point common to two or more similar or dissimilar command and control systems, sub-systems, or other entities against which or at which necessary information flow takes place.(Webster's): 1. A surface regarded as the common boundary of two bodies, spaces, or phases. 2. The facts, problems, considerations, theories, practices, etc., shared by two or more disciplines, procedures, or fields of study. 3. A common boundary or interconnection between systems, equipment, concepts, or human beings.

A wholePart that relates a ProperOverlap to the Individual it is a part of.

z. c

hang

ed

(IDEAS): A wholePart that relates a ProperOverlap to the Individual it is a part of.


FOUO 20 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion

Legend:n=necessaryo=optionaldf=DM2 foundation - not useddfo=DM2 foundation optionally usedif=IDEAS foundation - not usedifo=IDESA foundation optionally usedm=metadatas=securitynp=xml schema class needed for naming pattern shortcutOverlapPartType Foundation -- overlaps at the Type level overlap DoDAF Meta Model Y

performerRealizesCapability Manifest DoDAF Meta Model Y

PerformerType Performer

ProperOverlap overlap

activityChangesResource

z. d

elet

ed

DoDAF Meta Model Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n o o

activityResourceOverlap output, produce DoDAF Meta Model Y 1 ### n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n o n o o o o o o

activityResourceOverlap is a member of Rule

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): activityResourceOverlap is a member of Rule Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

ActivityType Classes of Activities. (DM2): Classes of Activities.

input, consume DoDAF Meta Model Y ### n n o n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n o o o o o

proceeds, succeeds DM2 associative entity Y ### n n o n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n o o o o o

(DODAF 1): (AV-1 description TBS) Y n o

beforeAfter is a member of BeforeAfterType (DM2): beforeAfter is a member of BeforeAfterType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

CircularArea is a member of CircularAreaType (DM2): CircularArea is a member of CircularAreaType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

ConsumingPartOfActivity A part of an Activity that consumes a Resource (IDEAS): A tuple with two places. IDEAS ### o n n o n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n o o n o o o o n n o o n n n o o o o o o o

CoreAttributes

z. d

elet

ed

DoDAF Meta Model

Country is a member of CountryType (DM2): Country is a member of CountryType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

couple is a member of CoupleType (DM2): couple is a member of CoupleType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

dataPartOfInformation Whole-part association Y

Data is a member of DataType (DM2): Data is a member of DataType y 1 ### n n

Dependability Adaptation of SEI Y DM

z. d

elet

ed

DM2 AI #485 Y n o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n

disjoint IDEAS y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f o f o f f f f f

DispositionalMeasure

DispositionalProperty

z. d

elet

ed

dispositionManifestation DM2 plans to remove.

EffectObject An object to which effects are directed. (DoDAF Meta Model): An object to which effects are directed. DoDAF Meta Model Y

EffectObjectType Classes of Effect Objects (DM2): Classes of Effect Objects

EllipticalArea is a member of EllipticallyAreaType (DM2): EllipticalArea is a member of EllipticallyAreaType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

endBoundary is a member of EndBoundaryType (DM2): endBoundary is a member of EndBoundaryType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

Facility is a member of FacilityType (DM2): Facility is a member of FacilityType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

GeoFeature is a member of GeoFeatureType (DM2): GeoFeature is a member of GeoFeatureType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o

Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

GeoStationary is a member of GeoStationaryType (DM2): GeoStationary is a member of GeoStationaryType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

IndividualActivity is a member of Activity (DM2): IndividualActivity is a member of Activity DM2 associative entity Y ### n n o

IndividualDesiredEffect ### n o o

z. c

hang

ed (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between the possible state or causal disposition of a Capability to a possible state of a Performer.

An overlap between the possible state or causal disposition of a Capability to a possible state of a Performer.

z. c

hang

ed

(DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between the allowed Activities of a Rule and a Performer

Types of Performers, taken from the powerset over individual Performers.

z. c

hang

ed

(DM2): Types of Performers, taken from the powerset over individual Performers.


The individual defined by the overlap of two other individuals

z. c

hang

ed

(IDEAS): The individual defined by the overlap of two other individuals

Represents that an activity was / is / will-be the cause of change in the effected object with a before-after relationship.

DM2 not related to incidental, unintended, or effects not related to desires or goals. Also issue of ARO redundancy with this.

(DoDAF Meta Model): Represents that an activity was / is / will-be the cause of change in the effected object with a before-after relationship.

An overlap of an Activity with a Resource. The Resource can be an input for a consuming Activity or an output for a producing Activity.

z. d

elet

ed

(DoDAF Meta Model): An whole - part association between an Activity and the part of it that consumes a Resource

activityResourceOverlapSuperSubtypeOfRule

In 2.02, this will be de-bundled so that the Rule constrains either the producing activity, the consumeing activity, both, or the properOverlapPart.. DM2 associative entity

z. d

elet

edA Type - Individual distinction introduced in the DM2 LDM

activityWholeConsumingPartOfActivity

A whole - part association between an Activity and the part of it that consumes a Resource.

z. d

elet

ed

(DoDAF Meta Model): An whole - part association between an Activity and the part of it that produces a Resource

activityWholeProducingPartOfActivity

A whole - part association between an Activity and the part of it that produces a Resource.

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): A whole - part association between an Activity and the part of it that produces a Resource.

ArchitectureOverviewAndPurpose

Types of information that describe an architecture including AV-1 information on Purpose, Scope, Use, Methods, Findings, etc.

z. d

elet

ed

(DODAF 1): (AV-1 description TBS)

beforeAfterPowertypeInstanceOfBeforeAfterType

z. d

elet

ed

circularAreaPowertypeInstanceOfCircularAreaType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

Relationships to information that apply to all information in the DM2: security clasification markings, pedigree, and Time Instant or Period of the Individual or the set of Things in a Type or for which a Tuple exists.

(DoDAF Meta Model): Relationships to information that apply to all information in the DM2: security clasification markings and pedigree.

countryPowertypeInstanceOfCountryType

z. d

elet

ed

couplePowertypeInstanceOfCoupleType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

(DoDAF Meta Model): A tuple that asserts that Information describes a Thing.

Generalization of IDEAS "Name"

dataPowertypeInstanceOfDataType

z. d

elet

ed

A category of measures of properties of a Performer such that reliance can justifiably be placed on the Capabilities it delivers.

Maintainability Measure

z. d

elet

ed (SEI): That property of a computer system such that reliance can justifiably be placed on the service it delivers [Barbacci 95]. Availability / Robustness, Reliability, Safety, Trustworthiness, Security

desiredEffectWholeResourcePartType

A couple between two Individual Types where for each member of the whole set, there is a corresponding member of the part set for which a wholePart relationship exists, and conversely

Asserts that two Types define disjoint sets (i.e. they share no common members).

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): Asserts that two Types define disjoint sets (i.e. they share no common members).

A MeasureableProperty and a DispositionalProperty whose members share a common property that is measurable.

z. d

elet

ed

A Property whose members are Individuals that have a property of being capable to manifest a CategoricalProperty under certain conditions other things being equal. It is critical when describing the disposition to specify the conditions both for the dispo

A couple that asserts a CategoricalProperty has members that manifest a DispositionalProperty

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

z. d

elet

ed


ellipticalAreaPowertypeInstanceOfEllipticalAreaType

z. d

elet

ed

endBoundaryPowertypeInstanceOfEndBoundaryType

z. d

elet

ed

facilityPowertypeInstanceOfFacilityType

z. d

elet

ed

geoFeaturePowertypeInstanceOfGeoFeatureType

z. d

elet

ed

geoPoliticalExtentPowertypeInstanceOfGeoPoliticalExtentType

GeoPoliticalExtent is a member of GeoPoliticalExtentType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): GeoPoliticalExtent is a member of GeoPoliticalExtentType

geoStationaryPointPowertypeInstanceOfGeoStationaryPointType

z. d

elet

ed

individualActivityPowertypeInstanceOfActivity

z. d

elet

ed

A desired change in the state of a Effect Object as a result of some activity.

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): A desired change in the state of a Effect Object as a result of some activity.



FOUO 21 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


DM2 associative entity Y ### n o o

IndividualEffectObject (DM2): A specific object that an individual effect is acting upon


IndividualPerformer is a member of Performer (DM2): IndividualPerformer is a member of Performer DM2 associative entity Y ### n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o

individual is a member of IndividualType (DM2): individual is a member of IndividualType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

IndividualResource is a member of Resource (DM2): IndividualResource is a member of Resource DM2 associative entity Y ### n o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n o o o o o o o o o o

IndividualTypeTypeType The powertype of an IndividualTypeType (IDEAS): The powertype of an IndividualTypeType IDEAS

information is a member of InformationType (DM2): information is a member of InformationType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

Installation is a member of InstallationType (DM2): Installation is a member of InstallationType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o

Foundation (IDEAS): Foundation IDEAS



interface DoDAF Meta Model Y

interface is a member of InterfaceType (DM2): interface is a member of InterfaceType Y

interfaceType Types capable of interfacing (IDEAS): Types capable of interfacing IDEAS

intersection IDEAS x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f o f o f f f f f

Line is a member of LineType (DM2): Line is a member of LineType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o

Location is a member of LocationType (DM2): Location is a member of LocationType DM2 associative entity Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

Manifest Detailed statement of something's content (DM2): Detailed statement of something's content

activityPartOfCapability is a member of Measure (DM2): activityPartOfCapability is a member of Measure Y 1 ### o n n n n n n n o

Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o o o n n n n n n n n o

activityPerformerOverlap is a member of Measure (DM2): activityPerformerOverlap is a member of Measure Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

activityResourceOverlap is a member of Measure

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): activityResourceOverlap is a member of Measure Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Measure is a member of MeasureType (DM2): Measure is a member of MeasureType DM2 associative entity Y ### n o n o o n n o o o o n n o o o n n o o o o n n o o o n n o n n n n n n n n n

Name is a member of NameType (DM2): Name is a member of NameType DM2 associative entity Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

nameTypeInstance IDEAS Y

Organization is a member of OrganizationType (DM2): Organization is a member of OrganizationType DM2 associative entity Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

overlap is a member of OverlapType (DM2): overlap is a member of OverlapType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

DM2 associative entity Y ### o o o o o o o

place1Type Foundation (IDEAS): Foundation IDEAS



PlaceType Foundation (IDEAS): Foundation IDEAS

PlanarSurface is a member of PlanarSurfaceType (DM2): PlanarSurface is a member of PlanarSurfaceType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

Point is a member of PointType (DM2): Point is a member of PointType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

PolygonArea is a member of PolygonAreaType (DM2): PolygonArea is a member of PolygonAreaType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

ProducingPartOfActivity A part of an Activity that produces a Resource DoDAF Meta Model ### o n n o n o n n n n n n n o n n n n n n o o n o o o o n n o o n n n o o o o o o o

Project is a member of ProjectType (DM2): Project is a member of ProjectType DM2 associative entity Y ### n n n n o o o

RealProperty is a member of RealPropertyType (DM2): RealProperty is a member of RealPropertyType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o

individualDesiredEffectPowertypeInstanceOfDesiredEffect

IndividualDesiredEffect is a member of DesiredEffectType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): IndividualDesiredEffect is a member of DesiredEffectType

A specific object that an individual effect is acting upon

z. d

elet

ed


individualEffectObjectPowertypeInstanceOfEffectObjectType

IndividualEffectObject is a member of EffectObjectType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): IndividualEffectObject is a member of EffectObjectType

individualPerformerPowertypeInstanceOfPerformer

z. d

elet

ed

individualPowertypeInstanceOfIndividualType

z. d

elet

ed

individualResourcePowertypeInstanceOfResource

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

informationPowertypeInstanceOfInformationType

z. d

elet

ed

installationPowertypeInstanceOfInstallationType

z. d

elet

edIntentionallyConstructedIndividual

z. d

elet

ed

IntentionallyConstructedThing

z. d

elet

ed

IntentionallyConstructedType

z. d

elet

ed

An overlap between Performers for the purpose of producing a Resource that is consumed by the other.

z. d

elet

ed (DoDAF Meta Model): A whole part association between a System (whole) and the Materiel parts of the System. (A System can have Personnel Type and Organizational components.)

interfacePowertypeInstanceOfInterfaceType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

A couple of couples where each constituent couple represents the subset that is common to both sets.

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): A couple of couples where each constituent couple represents the subset that is common to both sets.

linePowertypeInstanceOfLineType

z. d

elet

ed

locationPowertypeInstanceOfLocationType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

measureOfTypeActivityPartOfCapability

z. d

elet

ed

These will be taken apart in 2.02. DM2 associative entity

measureOfTypeActivityPerformableUnderCondition

activityPerformableUnderCondition is a member of Measure

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): activityPerformableUnderCondition is a member of Measure

measureOfType on the Activity in 2.02. DM2 associative entity

measureOfTypeActivityPerformedByPerformer

z. d

elet

ed

S/B measureOfTypeActivity in 2.02. DM2 associative entity

measureOfTypeActivityResourceOverlap

3 MOT's: one for Resrouce, one for each Activity. The Measure for the two activities is the same.. DM2 associative entity

measurePowertypeInstanceOfMeasureType

z. d

elet

ed

namePowertypeInstanceOfNamingScheme

z. d

elet

ed

A typeInstance relationship, wherein each Name may be of one or more NameTypes.

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): A typeInstance relationship, wherein each Name may be of one or more NameTypes.

organizationPowertypeInstanceOfOrganizationType

z. d

elet

ed

overlapPowertypeInstanceOfOverlapType

z. d

elet

ed

performerPerformsAtLocationType

The relationship that describes the location of a performer or type of performer

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): The relationship that describes the location of a performer or type of performer

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

planarSurfacePowertypeInstanceOfPlanarSurfaceType

z. d

elet

ed

PointPowertypeInstanceOfPointType

z. d

elet

ed

polygonAreaPowertypeInstanceOfPolygonAreaType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between the Activities

allowed by a Rule and the Conditions under which the Rule applied

projectPowertypeInstanceOfProjectType

z. d

elet

ed

realPropertyPowertypeInstanceOfRealPropertyType

z. d

elet

ed


FOUO 22 of 22 FOUO


Stat

us


Ass

ocia

tion?

CDM

?

Who

Per

form

er

Cap

abili

ty

Ser

vice

s

Pro

ject

Ped

igre

e

Rul

es

Mea

sure

Loca

tion

Exa

min

e

Aut

oExa

min

e

AV

-1

AV

-2

OV

-1

OV

-2

OV

-3

OV

-4

OV

-5a

OV

-5b

OV

-6a

OV

-6b

OV

-6c

SV

-1

SV

-2

SV

-3

SV

-4

SV

-5a

SV

-5b

SV

-6

SV

-7

SV

-8

SV

-9

SV

-10a

SV

-10b

SV

-10c

Svc

V-1

Svc

V-2

Svc

V-3

a

Svc

V-3

b

Svc

V-4

Svc

V-5

Svc

V-6

Svc

V-7

Svc

V-8

Svc

V-9

Svc

V-1

0a

Svc

V-1

0b

Svc

V-1

0c

Std

V-1

Std

V-2

PV

-1

PV

-2

PV

-3

CV

-1

CV

-2

CV

-3

CV

-4

CV

-5

CV

-6

CV

-7

DIV

-1

DIV

-2

DIV



Res

ourc

e Fl

owIn

form

atio

n A

nd D

ata

Rei

ficat

ion

Leve

lsO

rgan

izat

ion

al S

truct

ure

Info

rmat

ion

Ped

igre

e

IDE

AS

Fo

unda

tion

DM

2 Fo

unda

tion


Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

(DM2): RegionOfCountry if a member if RegionOfCountryType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

ResourceType A class that represents types of resources (DM2): A class that represents types of resources

DoDAF Meta Model Y

activityPerformerOverlap is a member of Rule (DM2): activityPerformerOverlap is a member of Rule Y 1 ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o n n o o o

DoDAF Meta Model Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

serviceChannel y Y ### o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o

Site is a member of SiteType (DM2): Site is a member of SiteType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

SolidVolume is a member of SolidVolumeType (DM2): SolidVolume is a member of SolidVolumeType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

startBoundary is a member of startBoundaryType (DM2): startBoundary is a member of startBoundaryType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

Surface is a member of SurfaceType (DM2): Surface is a member of SurfaceType Y ### o o o o o o o o o o

Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

TemporalIndividual IDEAS

TemporalThing IDEAS

TemporalType

z. d

elet

ed

IDEAS

Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

tupleplace Foundation (IDEAS): Foundation IDEAS

tuplePlace1 The first position in an ordered tuple (IDEAS): The first position in an ordered tuple IDEAS

tuplePlace2 The second position in an ordered tuple (IDEAS): The second position in an ordered tuple IDEAS

tuplePlace3 The third position in an ordered tuple (IDEAS): The third position in an ordered tuple IDEAS

tuple is a member of TupleType (DM2): tuple is a member of TupleType Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

union IDEAS y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f o f o f f f f f

wholePart is a member of wholePartType (DM2): wholePart is a member of wholePartType DM2 associative entity Y x ### f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f f

rectangularAreaPowertypeInstanceOfRectangularAreaType

ReactangularArea is a member of RectangularAreaType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): ReactangularArea is a member of RectangularAreaType

regionOfCountryPowertypeInstanceOfRegionOfCountryType

RegionOfCountry if a member if RegionOfCountryType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted


ruleConstrainsActivityForPerformer

An overlap between an Activity performed by a Perfomer and a Rule that constrains that Activity

z. d

elet

ed (DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap between an Activity performed by a Perfomer and a Rule that constrains that Activity

ruleConstrainsActivityPerformedByPerformer

z. d

elet

ed DM2 relationship between Activity and Rule. DM2 associative entity

ruleConstraintOfActivityValidUnderCondition

An overlap between theActivities constrained by a Rule and the Conditions under which the Rule applies

z. d

elet

ed

(DoDAF Meta Model): An overlap (intersection) between a Rule and the Activities it allows

A logical or physical communication path between requisitions and services.

z. d

elet

ed

(Answers.com): A logical or physical communication path between requisitions and services.

sitePowertypeInstanceOfSiteType

z. d

elet

ed

solidVolumePowertypeInstanceOfSolidVolumeType

z. d

elet

edstartBoundaryPowertypeInstanceOfStartBoundaryType

z. d

elet

ed

surfacePowertypeInstanceOfSurfaceType

z. d

elet

ed

temporalBoundaryPowertypeInstanceOfTemporalBoundaryType

temporalBoundary is a member of temporalBoundaryType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): temporalBoundary is a member of temporalBoundaryType

A specific thing that has temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with itself or others over time.

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): A specific thing that has temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with itself or others over time.

A thing or set of things that has temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with itself or others over time.

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): A thing or set of things that has temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with itself or others over time.

Sets of (and powersets based on) individuals that have temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with themseleves or others over time.

(IDEAS): Sets of (and powersets based on) individuals that have temporal relations (time dimension before/after) with themseleves or others over time.

temporalWholePartPowertypeInstanceOfTemporalWholePartType

temporalWholePart is a member of temporalWholePartType

z. d

elet

ed

(DM2): temporalWholePart is a member of temporalWholePartType

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

z. d

elet

edz.

del

eted

tuplePowertypeInstanceOfTupleType

z. d

elet

ed

A couple of couples where each constituent couple represents the superset union over the unioned sets.

z. d

elet

ed

(IDEAS): A couple of couples where each constituent couple represents the superset union over the unioned sets.

wholePartPowertypeInstanceOfWholePartType

z. d

elet

ed

[xls]dodcio.defense.govdodcio.defense.gov/portals/0/documents/dodaf/dm2... · web viewthe state or...

Documents