yet voters cling to key element where ... - the new york times · ma s health care law. if they can...

1
VOL. CLXVII .... No. 58,080 © 2018 The New York Times Company SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2018 MARMET, W.Va. — There were the beauty queens, ages 6 to 60, riding in style in the Labor Day Parade, including Teen Miss West Virginia Coal. There was the man driving a pickup truck memorial to 29 workers killed in a 2010 mine disaster, each victim’s portrait air- brushed on metal. And there was Senator Joe Manchin, in a sky-blue shirt with the state’s craggy outline on its crest, walking the route and greet- ing voters who brought up his fa- vorite issue themselves. “Save our health care!” Bar- bara Miller shouted. Mr. Manchin stopped to give her a hug. After he passed, she said she feared that Republicans in Washington will continue to try to repeal President Barack Oba- ma’s health care law. “If they can’t overturn that, then they hope they can at least favor their big-insur- ance buddies by allowing them to block pre-existing conditions,” said Ms. Miller, a nurse educator. “I have a pre-existing condition.” “We all do,” chimed in four other women seated with her on a porch. In a state where approval of President Trump is near the coun- try’s highest, Mr. Manchin, a Dem- ocrat, was once thought to be deeply endangered in his re-elec- tion this year. But the 71-year-old incumbent, who likes to say “Washington sucks,” has a 7-to-10- point polling edge over his Repub- lican opponent, Patrick Morrisey. A lot can happen before Election Day, but for now, he is the envy of other red-state Democrats as the parties wrestle over control of the Senate. Where ‘Obamacare’ Is Epithet, Yet Voters Cling to Key Element By TRIP GABRIEL Continued on Page 18 The Trump administration held secret meetings with rebellious military officers from Venezuela over the last year to discuss their plans to overthrow President Nicolás Maduro, according to American officials and a former Venezuelan military commander who participated in the talks. Establishing a clandestine channel with coup plotters in Ven- ezuela was a big gamble for Wash- ington, given its long history of covert intervention across Latin America. Many in the region still deeply resent the United States for backing previous rebellions, coups and plots in countries like Cuba, Nicaragua, Brazil and Chile, and for turning a blind eye to the abuses military regimes commit- ted during the Cold War. The White House, which de- clined to answer detailed ques- tions about the talks, said in a statement that it was important to engage in “dialogue with all Vene- zuelans who demonstrate a desire for democracy” in order to “bring positive change to a country that has suffered so much under Ma- duro.” But one of the Venezuelan mili- tary commanders involved in the secret talks was hardly an ideal figure to help restore democracy: He is on the American govern- ment’s own sanctions list of cor- rupt officials in Venezuela. He and other members of the Venezuelan security apparatus have been accused by Washington of a wide range of serious crimes, including torturing critics, jailing hundreds of political prisoners, wounding thousands of civilians, trafficking drugs and collaborat- ing with the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, or FARC, which is considered a terrorist or- ganization by the United States. American officials eventually decided not to help the plotters, and the coup plans stalled. But the Trump administration’s willing- ness to meet several times with U.S. MET REBELS FROM VENEZUELA ABOUT COUP PLOT RISK BY TRUMP OFFICIALS Dissidents’ Secret Plans to Overthrow Maduro Eventually Stalled By ERNESTO LONDOÑO and NICHOLAS CASEY Continued on Page 11 WASHINGTON — All Su- preme Court confirmation hear- ings are, in a way, empty exer- cises, but most have a redeeming feature or two. For a few mo- ments, at least, the nominee can come into focus. Recall the folksiness of Justice Neil M. Gorsuch, the sly wit of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justice Elena Kagan, or the inspiring up-from-the-projects life story of Justice Sonia So- tomayor. Last week’s confirmation hearings for Judge Brett M. Kavanaugh, President Trump’s Supreme Court nominee, lacked those clarifying glimpses. Judge Kavanaugh’s demeanor was bland and unruffled, and he navigated two marathon days of questioning without revealing anything not already on his long résumé, one reflecting a slashing partisan background and a deeply conservative judicial record. Judge Kavanaugh must have studied earlier confirmation hearings carefully, as he had absorbed all of their key lessons: Say nothing, say it at great length, and then say it again. A Simple Script: Saying Nothing, Over and Over By ADAM LIPTAK WASHINGTON MEMO Continued on Page 19 One of the world’s top breast cancer doctors failed to disclose millions of dollars in payments from drug and health care compa- nies in recent years, omitting his financial ties from dozens of re- search articles in prestigious pub- lications like The New England Journal of Medicine and The Lancet. The researcher, Dr. José Ba- selga, a towering figure in the can- cer world, is the chief medical offi- cer at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York. He has held board memberships or advisory roles with Roche and Bristol-Myers Squibb, among other corporations, has had a stake in start-ups testing cancer therapies, and played a key role in the development of breakthrough drugs that have revolutionized treatments for breast cancer. According to an analysis by The New York Times and ProPublica, Dr. Baselga did not follow finan- cial disclosure rules set by the American Association for Cancer Research when he was president of the group. He also left out pay- ments he received from compa- nies connected to cancer research in his articles published in the group’s journal, Cancer Discov- ery. At the same time, he has been one of the journal’s two editors in chief. At a conference this year and before analysts in 2017, he put a positive spin on the results of two Roche-sponsored clinical trials that many others considered dis- appointments, without disclosing his relationship to the company. Since 2014, he has received more than $3 million from Roche in con- sulting fees and for his stake in a Cancer Doctor Didn’t Disclose Corporate Ties Paid Millions by Firms Linked to Research By CHARLES ORNSTEIN and KATIE THOMAS Continued on Page 21 HOTAN, China — On the edge of a desert in far western China, an imposing building sits behind a fence topped with barbed wire. Large red characters on the facade urge people to learn Chinese, study law and acquire job skills. Guards make clear that visitors are not welcome. Inside, hundreds of ethnic Uighur Mus- lims spend their days in a high-pressure indoctrination program, where they are forced to listen to lectures, sing hymns praising the Chinese Communist Party and write “self-criticism” essays, accord- ing to detainees who have been released. The goal is to rid them of devotion to Is- lam. Abdusalam Muhemet, 41, said the po- lice detained him for reciting a verse of the Quran at a funeral. After two months in a nearby camp, he and more than 30 others were ordered to renounce their past lives. Mr. Muhemet said he went along but quietly seethed. “That was not a place for getting rid of extremism,” he recalled. “That was a place that will breed vengeful feelings and erase Uighur identity.” This camp outside Hotan, an ancient oasis town in the Taklamakan Desert, is one of hundreds that China has built in the past few years. It is part of a campaign of breathtaking scale and ferocity that has swept up hundreds of thousands of Chi- nese Muslims for weeks or months of what critics describe as brainwashing, usually without criminal charges. Though limited to China’s western re- gion of Xinjiang, it is the country’s most sweeping internment program since the Mao era — and the focus of a growing chorus of international criticism. China has sought for decades to restrict the practice of Islam and maintain an iron grip in Xinjiang, a region almost as big as Alaska where more than half the popula- tion of 24 million belongs to Muslim ethnic minority groups. Most are Uighurs, whose religion, language and culture, along with a history of independence movements and resistance to Chinese rule, have long unnerved Beijing. After a succession of violent antigov- ernment attacks reached a peak in 2014, the Communist Party chief, Xi Jinping, sharply escalated the crackdown, orches- trating an unforgiving drive to turn ethnic Uighurs and other Muslim minorities into loyal citizens and supporters of the party. “Xinjiang is in an active period of ter- rorist activities, intense struggle against separatism and painful intervention to treat this,” Mr. Xi told officials, according to reports in the state news media last year. In addition to the mass detentions, the authorities have intensified the use of in- An indoctrination camp in Hotan, China. Below, Abdusalam Muhemet, 41, was detained for two months in one such camp. Anti-Islam Detention Camps in China Minority Swept Up in Biggest Internment Program Since Mao Era Continued on Page 10 By CHRIS BUCKLEY ERIN TRIEB FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES A 5-year-old tigress that seems to have developed a taste for human flesh has been blamed for killing at least 13 peo- ple in India. PAGE 6 INTERNATIONAL 4-14 On the Trail of a Tiger Players and coaches are puzzling over a rule intended to make the game safer by minimizing the helmet’s use as a weapon during tackles. PAGE 1 SPORTSSUNDAY Confusion on New N.F.L. Rule With a single scholarly article, Lina Khan reframed decades of monopoly law, taking aim at one of the most ad- mired companies of our era. PAGE 1 SUNDAY BUSINESS Amazon’s Antitrust Antagonist A new Playboy Club finds a home in Midtown Manhattan. No expense has been spared in plans for the defiant time capsule. PAGE 1 SUNDAY STYLES Rebirth of the Bunny Carol Anderson PAGE 1 SUNDAY REVIEW U(DF47D3)W+%!]!/!=!: NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT Seventeen years after the twin towers crushed the Cortlandt Street subway station, it was set to re- open on Saturday. Work on the station, which cost $181.8 million, began in 2015. Page 23. A Final Piece of Rebuilding After 9/11 Printed in Chicago $6.00 Mostly cloudy. Some morning rain southeast. Breezy. Highs in the mid- dle 60s to the lower 70s. Mostly cloudy east tonight. Mostly clear west. Weather map is on Page 22. National Edition

Upload: others

Post on 25-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Yet Voters Cling to Key Element Where ... - The New York Times · ma s health care law. If they can t overturn that, then they hope they can at least favor their big-insur-ance buddies

C M Y K Yxxx,2018-09-09,A,001,Bs-4C,E1

VOL. CLXVII . . . . No. 58,080 © 2018 The New York Times Company SUNDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2018

MARMET, W.Va. — There werethe beauty queens, ages 6 to 60,riding in style in the Labor DayParade, including Teen Miss WestVirginia Coal. There was the mandriving a pickup truck memorialto 29 workers killed in a 2010 minedisaster, each victim’s portrait air-brushed on metal.

And there was Senator JoeManchin, in a sky-blue shirt withthe state’s craggy outline on itscrest, walking the route and greet-ing voters who brought up his fa-vorite issue themselves.

“Save our health care!” Bar-bara Miller shouted.

Mr. Manchin stopped to giveher a hug. After he passed, shesaid she feared that Republicansin Washington will continue to tryto repeal President Barack Oba-ma’s health care law. “If they can’toverturn that, then they hope they

can at least favor their big-insur-ance buddies by allowing them toblock pre-existing conditions,”said Ms. Miller, a nurse educator.“I have a pre-existing condition.”

“We all do,” chimed in four otherwomen seated with her on aporch.

In a state where approval ofPresident Trump is near the coun-try’s highest, Mr. Manchin, a Dem-ocrat, was once thought to bedeeply endangered in his re-elec-tion this year. But the 71-year-oldincumbent, who likes to say“Washington sucks,” has a 7-to-10-point polling edge over his Repub-lican opponent, Patrick Morrisey.A lot can happen before ElectionDay, but for now, he is the envy ofother red-state Democrats as theparties wrestle over control of theSenate.

Where ‘Obamacare’ Is Epithet,Yet Voters Cling to Key Element

By TRIP GABRIEL

Continued on Page 18

The Trump administration heldsecret meetings with rebelliousmilitary officers from Venezuelaover the last year to discuss theirplans to overthrow PresidentNicolás Maduro, according toAmerican officials and a formerVenezuelan military commanderwho participated in the talks.

Establishing a clandestinechannel with coup plotters in Ven-ezuela was a big gamble for Wash-ington, given its long history ofcovert intervention across LatinAmerica. Many in the region stilldeeply resent the United Statesfor backing previous rebellions,coups and plots in countries likeCuba, Nicaragua, Brazil and Chile,and for turning a blind eye to theabuses military regimes commit-ted during the Cold War.

The White House, which de-clined to answer detailed ques-tions about the talks, said in astatement that it was important toengage in “dialogue with all Vene-zuelans who demonstrate a desirefor democracy” in order to “bringpositive change to a country thathas suffered so much under Ma-duro.”

But one of the Venezuelan mili-tary commanders involved in thesecret talks was hardly an idealfigure to help restore democracy:He is on the American govern-ment’s own sanctions list of cor-rupt officials in Venezuela.

He and other members of theVenezuelan security apparatushave been accused by Washingtonof a wide range of serious crimes,including torturing critics, jailinghundreds of political prisoners,wounding thousands of civilians,trafficking drugs and collaborat-ing with the Revolutionary ArmedForces of Colombia, or FARC,which is considered a terrorist or-ganization by the United States.

American officials eventuallydecided not to help the plotters,and the coup plans stalled. But theTrump administration’s willing-ness to meet several times with

U.S. MET REBELSFROM VENEZUELA ABOUT COUP PLOT

RISK BY TRUMP OFFICIALS

Dissidents’ Secret Plansto Overthrow Maduro

Eventually Stalled

By ERNESTO LONDOÑOand NICHOLAS CASEY

Continued on Page 11

WASHINGTON — All Su-preme Court confirmation hear-ings are, in a way, empty exer-cises, but most have a redeemingfeature or two. For a few mo-ments, at least, the nominee cancome into focus.

Recall the folksiness of JusticeNeil M. Gorsuch, the sly wit ofChief Justice John G. Roberts Jr.and Justice Elena Kagan, or theinspiring up-from-the-projectslife story of Justice Sonia So-tomayor.

Last week’s confirmationhearings for Judge Brett M.Kavanaugh, President Trump’sSupreme Court nominee, lackedthose clarifying glimpses. JudgeKavanaugh’s demeanor wasbland and unruffled, and henavigated two marathon days ofquestioning without revealinganything not already on his longrésumé, one reflecting a slashingpartisan background and adeeply conservative judicialrecord.

Judge Kavanaugh must havestudied earlier confirmationhearings carefully, as he hadabsorbed all of their key lessons:Say nothing, say it at greatlength, and then say it again.

A Simple Script:Saying Nothing,Over and Over

By ADAM LIPTAK

WASHINGTON MEMO

Continued on Page 19

One of the world’s top breastcancer doctors failed to disclosemillions of dollars in paymentsfrom drug and health care compa-nies in recent years, omitting hisfinancial ties from dozens of re-search articles in prestigious pub-lications like The New EnglandJournal of Medicine and TheLancet.

The researcher, Dr. José Ba-selga, a towering figure in the can-cer world, is the chief medical offi-cer at Memorial Sloan KetteringCancer Center in New York. Hehas held board memberships oradvisory roles with Roche andBristol-Myers Squibb, amongother corporations, has had astake in start-ups testing cancertherapies, and played a key role inthe development of breakthroughdrugs that have revolutionizedtreatments for breast cancer.

According to an analysis by TheNew York Times and ProPublica,Dr. Baselga did not follow finan-cial disclosure rules set by theAmerican Association for CancerResearch when he was presidentof the group. He also left out pay-ments he received from compa-nies connected to cancer researchin his articles published in thegroup’s journal, Cancer Discov-ery. At the same time, he has beenone of the journal’s two editors inchief.

At a conference this year andbefore analysts in 2017, he put apositive spin on the results of twoRoche-sponsored clinical trialsthat many others considered dis-appointments, without disclosinghis relationship to the company.Since 2014, he has received morethan $3 million from Roche in con-sulting fees and for his stake in a

Cancer DoctorDidn’t DiscloseCorporate Ties

Paid Millions by FirmsLinked to Research

By CHARLES ORNSTEINand KATIE THOMAS

Continued on Page 21

HOTAN, China — On the edge of adesert in far western China, an imposingbuilding sits behind a fence topped withbarbed wire. Large red characters on thefacade urge people to learn Chinese,study law and acquire job skills. Guardsmake clear that visitors are not welcome.

Inside, hundreds of ethnic Uighur Mus-lims spend their days in a high-pressureindoctrination program, where they areforced to listen to lectures, sing hymnspraising the Chinese Communist Partyand write “self-criticism” essays, accord-ing to detainees who have been released.

The goal is to rid them of devotion to Is-lam.

Abdusalam Muhemet, 41, said the po-lice detained him for reciting a verse ofthe Quran at a funeral. After two monthsin a nearby camp, he and more than 30others were ordered to renounce theirpast lives. Mr. Muhemet said he wentalong but quietly seethed.

“That was not a place for getting rid ofextremism,” he recalled. “That was aplace that will breed vengeful feelings anderase Uighur identity.”

This camp outside Hotan, an ancientoasis town in the Taklamakan Desert, isone of hundreds that China has built in thepast few years. It is part of a campaign ofbreathtaking scale and ferocity that hasswept up hundreds of thousands of Chi-nese Muslims for weeks or months ofwhat critics describe as brainwashing,usually without criminal charges.

Though limited to China’s western re-gion of Xinjiang, it is the country’s most

sweeping internment program since theMao era — and the focus of a growingchorus of international criticism.

China has sought for decades to restrictthe practice of Islam and maintain an irongrip in Xinjiang, a region almost as big asAlaska where more than half the popula-tion of 24 million belongs to Muslim ethnicminority groups. Most are Uighurs,whose religion, language and culture,along with a history of independencemovements and resistance to Chineserule, have long unnerved Beijing.

After a succession of violent antigov-ernment attacks reached a peak in 2014,the Communist Party chief, Xi Jinping,sharply escalated the crackdown, orches-trating an unforgiving drive to turn ethnicUighurs and other Muslim minorities intoloyal citizens and supporters of the party.

“Xinjiang is in an active period of ter-rorist activities, intense struggle againstseparatism and painful intervention totreat this,” Mr. Xi told officials, accordingto reports in the state news media lastyear.

In addition to the mass detentions, theauthorities have intensified the use of in-

An indoctrination camp in Hotan, China. Below, Abdusalam Muhemet, 41, was detained for two months in one such camp.

Anti-Islam Detention Camps in ChinaMinority Swept Up in Biggest Internment Program Since Mao Era

Continued on Page 10

By CHRIS BUCKLEY

ERIN TRIEB FOR THE NEW YORK TIMES

A 5-year-old tigress that seems to havedeveloped a taste for human flesh hasbeen blamed for killing at least 13 peo-ple in India. PAGE 6

INTERNATIONAL 4-14

On the Trail of a TigerPlayers and coaches are puzzling over arule intended to make the game saferby minimizing the helmet’s use as aweapon during tackles. PAGE 1

SPORTSSUNDAY

Confusion on New N.F.L. RuleWith a single scholarly article, LinaKhan reframed decades of monopolylaw, taking aim at one of the most ad-mired companies of our era. PAGE 1

SUNDAY BUSINESS

Amazon’s Antitrust AntagonistA new Playboy Club finds a home inMidtown Manhattan. No expense hasbeen spared in plans for the defianttime capsule. PAGE 1

SUNDAY STYLES

Rebirth of the Bunny Carol Anderson PAGE 1

SUNDAY REVIEW

U(DF47D3)W+%!]!/!=!:

NEW YORK CITY TRANSIT

Seventeen years after the twin towers crushed the Cortlandt Street subway station, it was set to re-open on Saturday. Work on the station, which cost $181.8 million, began in 2015. Page 23.

A Final Piece of Rebuilding After 9/11

Printed in Chicago $6.00

Mostly cloudy. Some morning rainsoutheast. Breezy. Highs in the mid-dle 60s to the lower 70s. Mostlycloudy east tonight. Mostly clearwest. Weather map is on Page 22.

National Edition