york: what has heritage ever done for us? · the ‘what has heritage ever done for us?’ event...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
York: What has heritage
ever done for us?
![Page 2: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
York: What has heritage ever done for us? 20th June 2015Proceedings and Reflections Part of the ‘How should heritage decision be made?’ research project
Contents
1 HelenGraham,UniversityofLeeds,Introduction
Part 15 LianneBrigham,RichardBrigham,PeterBrown,HelenGraham,Paul
Furness‘Howshouldheritagedecisonsbemade?’researchprojectandtheYork:LivingwithHistorystrand–anoverview
Part 211 Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?Eventheld20thJune2015 LisaPickering,YorkStories,contributionbeforetheevent
13 ChrisSteward,CityofYorkCouncilLeader
16 DaveTaylor,CityofYorkCouncillorandChair,CultureandLeisureScrutinyCommittee
20 PeterAddyman,Chair,YorkCivicTrustandformallyDirector,YorkArchaeologyTrust
23 LianneBrighamandRichardBrigham,YorkPastandPresent
26 MichaelHayes,PlasticFortune
29 VictoriaHoyle,CityofYorkArchivist,ExploreYorkLibrariesandArchivesMutual
31 JohnOxley,CityofYorkArchaeologist
33 HelenWeinstein,Director,Historyworks
Reflections
39 PaulFurness,authorYork:AWalkontheWildSide
42 KitHeyam,LGBTHistoryMonth
44 LisaPickering,YorkStories
October2015
![Page 3: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Introduction HelenGraham
On 20th June 2015 we asked ‘what has heritage ever done for us?’, we did this as a way of drawing to a close the ‘York: Living with History’ strand of an Arts and Humanities Research Council funded research project which asked ‘How should heritage decision be made?’
Thetitleoftheeventwasmeanttobeabitfacetious,referencingMontyPython’s‘whathavetheRoman’severdoneforus?’sketchinLifeofBrian.Wethrewthetitleouttoimplythatmaybeheritagehasdonenothing(theintendedresponsetoJohnCleese’srhetoricalquestion)andmaybeheritagehasdonealot(muchastheRomansweresaidtogivenJudearoads,sewageandwineinthesketch)andmaybe,likeMontyPython’scharacterizationoftheRomanregime,heritagecanbeoppressiveanddangerous.Allthesepossibleresonances,werecognised,couldbesaidtoapplytoanyconsiderationoftheimpactof‘heritage’onYork.
Theideaforeventcamefromthoseofuswho’dbeeninvolvedintheYorkstrandofthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisionbemade?’project–LianneBrigham,RichardBrigham,PeterBrown,HelenGraham,PaulFurness–reflectingontheworkwe’ddonetogether.Wewantedtousewhatwe’dlearntthroughourresearcheventsandexperiences,andthenetworkswe’ddeveloped,tobuildonourthinkingabouthowwemightincreaseparticipationindecisionmakingaboutheritageinthecitytoexplorehowheritageaffectslifeinYorkandtoextendourfocustoaskwhetherheritagecanbearesourcethathelpsuslivewellanddemocraticallytogether.
How should heritage decisions be made?wasfundedbyanArtsandHumanitiesResearchCouncilConnectedCommunitiespilotprojectfocusedonthecollaborativedesignofresearch.BetweenFebruary2013andFebruary2015ateamofpeoplecomingfromlotsofdifferentperspectivesworkedtogether;academics,policymakers,aLocalAuthorityconservationofficer,peopleshapingmuseumpracticeinparticipationandresearchandpeoplewhoareactivistsabouttheirownhistoriesandheritage.WecarriedourresearchinlotsofdifferentplacesUK-wideandtherewasastrandofwork–LivingwithHistory–heldinYork.
What has heritage ever done for us?20thJune2015The‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventwasheldaspartoftheArtsandHumanitiesResearchCouncilConnectedCommunitiesFestivalinJune2015.Weinvitedlotsofthepeoplewe’dmetandworkedwith–andthenewlyelectedCityofYorkCouncilleadership–toexploretheevent’squestionsfromlotsofperspectives.Aspartofourresearchwe’dbeenthinkingofthecityandheritagewithinitsystemically,tryingtonoticewhichpeople,organisationsandstructuresofdecision-makingarewellconnectedandwherethedisconnectionsandexclusionshappen.Theaimofinvitinglotswrittenandspokencontributionswastobringdifferentpartsofthesystem,thoseattheheartofdecision-makingandthosefrustratedwiththecity,intoopendiscussion.Whatstrikesmethreemonthsonfromthe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’event,reflectingonthecontributionspublishedhere,isthatheritageoperatedintwoimportantwaysinourconversationsandintheseproceedings.Thefirst
1
![Page 4: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
way,whichwasanticipatedbytheevent’squiteinstrumentalquestion,wasasathingwhichinturndoesthingsandcanbemadetodothings:Heritageasakindoftool.Thesecondwasheritageasawayoftalkingandimaginingthecity:Heritageasakindofmedium.
Thefinalbookletforthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisonsbemade?’projectissubtitled‘Increasingparticipationfromwhereyouare’,andisstructuredaroundfourwaysofworkingweidentifiedthatmighthelpprofessionalsandothers,todevelopnewformsoflegitimacyfromavarietyofdifferentsourcesandnetworks:
Act:MakechangefromwhereyouareActaimstoencourageusalltostarttomakethingshappen.
Connect:CrossboundariesandcollaborateConnectdrawsattentiontotheimportanceofbuildingnetworksacrossinstitutionalboundariesandbetweenprofessionalsandactivists.
Reflect: Seeyourworkthroughotherpeople’seyesReflectisfocusedonthepowerofseeingissuesfromlotsofdifferentperspectives.
Situate:UnderstandyourworkincontextSituatewasawayofevokingakeyinfluencetoourresearchmethodology–systemsthinking.
2
![Page 5: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Heritage as a toolThemostpositivereadingofheritageemphasizedtheeducationbenefitsofferedbyYork’sarchaeologicalheritageortheeconomicandculturalbenefitswhichmakesYorkagoodplacetolive,somethingPeterAddymanandCllrDaveTaylornoted.
Amuchmorecriticaltendencytendedtoseeheritage–or‘heritigisation’,theprocessbywhichYorkhasbeenpackagedasheritage–assomethingwhichworkstocreateanexclusiveandboringmonocultureinthecity,MichaelHayesandPaulFurnessarguealongtheselines.Thisisthekindofheritagethatfiltersouteverythingbutthesafestorthemosteasilyaesthetised,commercializedorsimplifiedideasofthepast.ThekindofheritagewhichmakesYorkfamousonlyfor‘oldbuildings’,tearoomsandpeopledressedupasVikings.
Heritage as a mediumHowever,itwasn’tintheroleofatoolthatheritageseemedthemostpowerfulattheevent.Formuchoftheevent,heritagewasnotevokedasaseparableentityorphenomena,itseemedtoactsmoreasawayoftalkingaboutthecity–akindofmedium.Mediuminthesenseof‘growingmedium’,likeearth,compost,water.
AttimesheritageseemedmorelikethesubstancethroughwhichwhatYorkis,wasandmightbe,wasarticulatedandcontestedaswellascultivatedandgrown.
Inthissenseheritagegaveameansbywhichmanyspeakers,andcontributorsheresuchasLisaPickering,KitHeyam,PaulFurnessandHelenWeinstein,contestwhatYorkistoensurethesenseofwhatthecityiscanbestretchedtofullyrecognizethelivesofpeoplewhoarelesbian,gay,bisexualortrans,toindicatethatthecityisn’tonlywhite(afalsehoodfartoooftensaid),tomaintainasenseofworkingclasscultureortraditionandtoremembertheprogromagainstJewishpeoplein1190atClifford’sTowerandthelongtermnegativeimpactonthereputationofthecityamongsttheJewishcommunityworldwide.
Yetthroughtheseinterventionsheritagealsoseemedtogiveusacommonsubstancethroughwhichtogiveformtothecity’schallengesanditsinequities,notleastinrelationshiptohousingwhichisaveryliveissueasYorkisoftencitedasthemostunaffordablecitytoliveinwiththenorthofEngland.WiththeLocalPlan(whichfailedtobepassedin2014)onthehorizonagainandbeingdevelopedunderanewleadership,perhaps‘heritage’canlooselyholdsusindialoguewhilewedisagree,asindeedwedidquiteabiton20thJuneandaswe’relikelytointhecomingyears.
Democratizing heritage, heritage democratising YorkIftherewasoneblazingthemeofboththeUK-wide‘Howshouldheritagedecisionsbemade?’projectaswellastheYork:LivingwithHistorystrandandtheevent,however,itwastransparencyandtheneedformorethoroughgoingparticipationinshapingwhatcountsasYork’sheritageanditsimpactonthecity’sfuture,apointmadepowerfullybyLianneandRichardBrighamfromYorkPastandPresentintheircontribution.Afewcontroversialissuesforthecity–Reynard’sGarageandGuildhall–wereregularlycitedasexampleswherepublicinvolvementhadfailedandasaresultproducedangeranddisillusionment.
3
![Page 6: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Respondingtothiswidersenseofdemocraticdeficit,bothJohnOxley,theCityArchaeologistandVictoriaHoyle,theCityArchivistemphasizedtheimportanceofsharingknowledgeandarchivestoenablemoreinvolvementindecisionmaking(HistoricEnvironmentRecordandplanningdecisionsforexample)andforthecityasawholetomakebetterdecisions(drawingonourknowledgeofpastdecisionstohelpmakemoreinformeddecisions).Inthesubsequentdiscussionsitwasreallyclearthatthecity’scouncilorleader,ChrisSteward,sawtheenormouspotentialinthis,amorepro-activeandopenpublicengagementearliertopreventantagonismlater.
Anumberofideasemergedfromtheresearchandbecamecrystalizedattheevent–fromhowtocommunicatebetteracrosscouncil,organizationalandcommunityboundariesandabouthowthecity’sheritagemightbeusedtoengagemorepeopleinurgentissuesfacingthecity.ThelatterhasdevelopedintotheHistoriesBehindtheHeadlines,whichtheCityArchiveswillbehostinginNovember2015withafocuson‘housing’wherewewillbeusingengagementwithcityarchives,ourhistoricenvironmentandlocalmemoriesandknowledgetoenrichcity-levelpublicdebate.
So what has heritage done for us? Alot,mostofusthought.Whenthoughtofasatoolsomeofwhathasbeenenabledbyourframingofbuildings,memoriesandobjectsas‘heritage’hasbeenbrilliant,somelesssoand,infact,posesthreatstothelivabilityofthecity.Yetwhenheritageisthoughtofmoreasmediumandasopen,dynamicandnecessarilycreatedtogether,thereisevenmoresocialandpoliticalpotentialforanengageddialogueaboutthefutureofthecity.Intheendtheeventsuggeststhatitwasnotreallyaboutwhatheritagecandomuchforus,aswhatcanbedonebyusandthroughheritage.
Thisbookletisintwoparts.Part1offersasummaryoftheYork:LivingwithHistoryprojectconducted,asparoftheUKwideresearchprojectin2013-2015.Part2offersproceedingsfromthe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’
4
![Page 7: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Part 1 York: Living with History‘How should heritage decisions be made?’ and the York: Living with History strand: Situating participation in heritage decision-making in a city’s systems
MartinBashforth(York’sAlternativeHistory),LianneBrigham,RichardBrigham(YorkPastandPresent),PeterBrown(YorkCivicTrust),HelenGraham(UniversityofLeeds),PaulFurness(radicalhistorianandwriter)
AllofuswereinvolvedintheUK-wide‘Howshouldheritagedecisionsbemade?’project.HerewewanttosharespecificallyanoverviewofwhatwedidinYorkasawayofframingtheproceedingsofthe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus’event.
Yorkisknownasaheritagecity.Mappingheritagedecision-makingsystemsandcruciallyhowtheythesesystemsareexperiencedbythepeoplewholiveinthecity,madecleartheurgentneedforalternativestotraditionalformsof‘consultation’.Insteadweexperimentedwithparticipativeapproachesandfocused–notsomuchon‘sharingyouropinion’or‘havingasay’–butonactionandargument.
York systemically:Westartedbymappingformalstructuresandinformalnetworkswhichmakeupofficialheritagedecision-makinginthecity.Wethenalso–throughlotsofconversationsatdropinsandonpublicstalls–infusedthesemapswiththelivedexperienceofbeingpartof,andnotbeingpartof,theseprocesses.TherewerepeoplewhowereverywellconnectedandhadalotofinfluenceoverwhatcountsasheritageinYork.Butalsowefoundpeoplewhowantedtotakeanactivepartwhofoundithardtogetan‘in’.
Mappingheritagedecision-makingsystemicallyprovedapowerfulmethodology.Ifyoucanseehowformalstructuresandinformalnetworksfittogether,thenyoucanstarttonoticekeypeopleandkeypointsforincreasingparticipationindecision-making.
Weused‘thinkingsystemically’asaresearchmethodology.Wealsofoundthistechniqueusefulforreflectingonourownpracticeandactivismandforplanningactionandconnection.Systemicthinkingoffersawayofthinkingaboutheritagenotinisolationorfixedbutasadynamicprocesswhichisproduced,andshaped,bypeople,ideasandthingsandthewaytheyinteract–anddon’t.
•Mapprocesses•Lookforpatterns•Noticeboundariesanddisconnections
“We do Urban Exploring and all we wanted to do was go in and take some photographs of some ex-military hutments before they were demolished. We tried everything to get permission to go in. We phoned the Council. We got passed on to the Art Gallery. Then they passed us back to the Council. We were passed from pillar to post. Even to the point that we asked a security guard to take our camera and take photos – and the answer was still no. We thought we’ve had enough, we’re going to start something new. Start afresh. That’s when we started the Facebook group – now over 9000 strong – York Past and Present.”
RichardBrighamandLianneBrigham,YorkPastandPresent
5
![Page 8: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
LianneandRichardandYorkPastPresenthavesinceworkedwiththeCityofYorkCounciltoconductanumberofpublicdocumentationprojects,includingofwoodenbuildingsneartheGuildhall.YoucanhearmoreaboutYorkPastandPresent’srecentdevelopsinthetranscriptofLianneandRichardcontributionoftheWhathasheritageeverdoneforuseventbelow.Credit:RichardBrigham
‘Us’ and ‘Them’:Wefoundthattheword‘them’wasusedalotinourinitialmappingprocessestorefertoelectedofficialsandcouncilstaff.Thiswasdirectlylinkedtopeople’sexperiencesof‘consultation’–themostcommonoforganizationalattemptsat‘participation’.Theuseof‘them’revealedasenseofdisempowermentoverdecisions:thefeelingthatconsultationwasa‘figleaf’fordecisionsthatalreadybeentaken.Butwedidalsonoticethattheflipsideofevoking‘them’seemedtobethatittooeasilyabsolvedthepersonspeakingofresponsibilityfortakingtheinitiativeorfindingwaysofsharingresponsibility. “Before it was like a 6ft wall with anti-climb paint on, whatever way we
went it blocked you. It was only meeting some key people that we could see a way around the wall. You’ve got to find a way beyond the ‘them’ and ‘us’. We’re all working for a common goal, so let’s work together.”
LianneBrigham,YorkPastandPresent
6
![Page 9: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
‘”They” are people too!’:Therewasalsoanimportant‘livedexperience’dimensionforthoseindecision-makingpositions.Someexpressedasenseofbeingconstantlybeingattacked,bothbycentralgovernmentthroughrecentcutsandbydebatesinthelocalpressandontwitter.
Criticisms of ‘participation’:Yetwealsoranintoanumberofpeopleindecision-makingroleswhojustdidn’tbelieveinparticipation.Themostcommoncriticismsofparticipationweencounteredwere:thatitunderminesexpertise,thatthepubliccan’tdealwithcomplexinformation,itcan’tbescaledandonlyattractstheusualsuspects.
Experimental action:Wedevisedaseriesofexperimentalpublicevents,whichaimedtomodelwaysofbreakingdownthedivisionof‘us’and‘them’bydiversifyingwhoisincludedintheinformalnetworksinfluencingheritageinYork,by‘humanising’thoseindecision-makingpositionswhilealsoaddressingsomeofthehard-edgedcritiquesofparticipationwe’dunearthed.
“There is a danger in writing up research that you tell a nice neat story. While Peter, Martin and I had put in place a backbone of mapping and then experimental events, almost everything that’s been truly revelatory or that has shifted something has come from improvising and taking opportunities which arose as we went along – not least meeting Richard and Lianne in the first month of the project, admins of what was then a new Facebook page.”
HelenGraham,MuseumandHeritageStudies,UniversityofLeeds
Contesting what ‘York’ is:PaulFurnessledtworadicalhistorywalksaspartoftheresearchproject.Bypluralizingthesenseofthecity’spast,weaimedtoopenupaspacefordebateabouttheroleofheritageinthecity.Thewalkwasthenturnedintoabook,whichinturnenteredthepublicdomainwithasplashthroughasomewhatcontroversialYorkPressarticle.Thepressreactionmadevisiblehowcontroloverheritageandclassareintertwinedinthecity:
“There was a lot of coverage when we published the York: A Walk on the Wild Side book. In York Press it was centre spread, there was a news article, an editorial and a banner headline. It certainly worked – the saying that all publicity is good publicity is true. But the news article did put words into my mouth – about York ‘being twee’ – and I didn’t like the personal aspect of it, the number of people who told me to pack my bags and leave town. Yet I’m interested in the fact that what I wrote did touch a nerve. The controversy in the end wasn’t so much about the histories, it was more about what I said about the raucous drinking culture of the York races and Saturday night, ‘when York comes alive’. It was the challenge to that dull middle class mentality of a genteel city that riled people. It’s good to stir things up once in a while.”
PaulFurness,WriterandHistorian,York
7
![Page 10: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
PaulFurnessleadingtheWalkontheWildSidein2014,youcanhearmorefromPaulinhisreflectionsontheissuesraisedbythe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventbelow.
Arguments not Opinions:Inresponsetoboththegeneralpublicconsensuson‘consultation’andthehard-edgedcritiquesofparticipationwe’dencounteredfromdecisionmakers,wemodelledalternatives.WeusedasourcasestudythecontroversialbrutalistbuildingStonebowHouseandbegantoexplorethewaysinwhich‘argument’,insteadofthe‘opinions’usuallyaskedforinconsultations,mightbeusedtoaddressquestionsofscalingparticipationindecision-making.Wealsobroughtdifferenttypesofexpertiseintoactivedebatethroughevents,Facebookandpressarticlesandshowedhowtoexpandbeyondwhatmightbeconsidered‘theusualsuspects’.Itwasn’tthatmanypeoplechangedtheirmindsbuttheirengagementintheissuesdeepenedanddevelopedtheirperspectives.Moresolidgroundforanydecision–andthetermsofanyfuturedecisions–emerged.
‘StonebowHouseinThreeWords’contributedaspartoftheStonebowHouseeventandthroughLisaPickering’sYorkStorieswebsite.
8
![Page 11: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
StonebowHouse,oftencitedasYork’sleastfavouritebuilding.JonWright–aconsultantonin20thcenturyarchitectureandheritage–playedacrucialroleinshowinghowexpertisecanbeengagedtoenhanceanddeveloppublicdebate.CreditYorkMix.
Proactive Community-Led Planning:Wealsoexploredproactivecommunityengagementbymodellinghowcommunity-initiatedplanningmightwork,focusedontheCastlearea.
“The Castle area meeting allowed a wide range of interested parties time to formulate a consensus on what would be the best (or at least the most acceptable) treatment of the spaces in and around the world class collection of historic buildings. Preliminary discussions with City Council officers have been encouraging and further meetings are planned.”
PeterBrown,YorkCivicTrust
9
![Page 12: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Diversifying networks and crossing boundaries:Throughdoingtheseeventsweencounteredsomepeoplewhowereasexcitedaswewereaboutincreasingparticipationinheritagedecision-making,notleastJohnOxley,CityArchaeologistwhometRichardandLiannefirstatoneoftheproject’sdrop-ins.This‘magicnetworkingpath’,asRichardhasnamedit,bothhelpedusunderstandthecomplexitiesofthecityandalsomadepossibletheYorkPastandPresentpublicdocumentation(urbanexplorationwithpermission!)ofthecity’sGuildhall.
“We’ve found that networking works. There’s like this magic path. You need to find one person and then they introduce you to their friends. There are two types of people in the council/organisations. The ones that want to work with people and want change; and those that don’t. The key is find those that do want change and then they usually know other people who do too. ”
RichardBrigham,YorkPastandPresent
“The principal benefit I gained from that was seeing how effective personal networking can be in broadening the constituency of people who might be involved in public decision-making around heritage issues. That takes effort, confidence and leadership – qualities that are not equally distributed but do have the benefit of encouraging involvement and collective work across a diverse range of people. Collectives have to be built, whether from inside or outside public institutions.”
MartinBashforth,radicalfamilyhistorianandpartofYork’sAlternativeHistory
The living stream sustaining York:CertainpossibilitieshavecertainlybeenopenedupthroughourresearchinYork,butotherboundariesstillseemquiteintractable.Findingoutwhatisgoingonishardworkandreliesonpeoplelikingyouoryoubeingusefultotheminsomeway–whichisn’talwayseasytoachieve!Sometimesofferingtogetinvolvedandshareresponsibilityhasbeenverywarmlywelcomed–suchasYorkPastandPresent’sworkwiththeMansionHouse–andatothertimesactivelydiscouraged.Yetthemosttransformativemomentsintheprojecthavecomewhenpeoplewhohadn’tmetbefore,andperhapswouldn’tusuallymeet,havegottogetherandstartedtalking.Wesawthe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventinJune2015asjustonespaceforthesetypeofdiscussions.
“My organisation has, until recently, functioned in ‘silo-mode’, considering itself one of a small number of ‘experts’ engaged in the heritage decision-making process in York. Involvement in this project, however, has shown the benefits of a more democratic and inclusive engagement with a broad spectrum of opinion, thereby offering a more measured view on issues of common interest.”
PeterBrown,YorkCivicTrust
Youcanfindoutmoreaboutthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisionbemadeproject’:http://heritagedecisions.leeds.ac.uk/
TheYorkstrandoftheprojectcanbefollowedhere:https://livingwithhistory.wordpress.com/
10
![Page 13: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Lisa Pickering, York StoriesLisaPickeringisawriterandphotographerwho,since2004,hasbeenreflectingonthecity
throughherwebsiteYorkStories:AResident’sRecordofYorkanditsChanges.LisaistheauthorofChocolateandChicory:Yorkandbeyond,bybicycleandWhenthesuburbsburned:awalkaround17thcenturyYork.www.yorkstories.co.uk
Lisacontributedtothe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventthroughashortarticlepublishedinadvanceoftheevent.Inherpiece,Lisadrawsattentiontothewaysinwhicholdandnew;heritageandinnovationaretoooftenopposed,heldapartasopposites.Lisacallsforthosewanting‘tomaketheirmarkonthecity’todosowiththegrainofYork’slocaldistinctivenessand‘moresympatheticallytothesoliditythatcamebefore,thedistinctiveshapeofwhat’salreadythere’.
I’moneofthoseYorkbornandbredpeople.Iknowwecanbeannoyingwhenwegoonaboutthis,andthatwecanmakeotherpeoplewho’vemovedheremorerecentlyfeellikethey’renotacceptedanddon’tbelong.Idon’twanttodothat,butIdohavetowritefromtheperspectiveofsomeonewhohaslivedherefor40-plusyears.
Heritageiswhatweinherit.Andifyou’reborninaplaceandliveinitfordecadesthenyouhaveaweightierinheritancetothinkabout,assumingyou’vegrowntohaveattachmentsandunderstandingsabouttheplace,asmostofusdo.I’mthinkingnotjustofthebuiltheritagebutofaculturalheritagetoo.
Concernsabouttheprotectionofheritageareoftendismissedas‘fearofchange’.I’veoftenthought,ifIdidfearchangeasmuchasmembersofthe‘heritagebrigade’areaccusedofdoingthenI’dbecoweringinacornersilentandterrifiedbynow,asthere’sbeensomuchchange.
York-bornpeopleofmygenerationandolderhaveseenenormouschangesinrecentdecades.ThefactorieswheresomanypeopleworkedwhenIwasachildarenowpartofour‘heritage’ratherthanworkplaces.Thecityturnedtowardstourismandwelcomedvisitors,morerecentlyithasseenamassiveincreaseinthestudentpopulationandresidentswhohavegraduatedfromtheuniversities.Thishaschangedthefeeloftheplacequitedramatically.It’smostnoticeableprobablyintheWalmgatearea,wherewenowhavetheinterestinglynamed‘StudentCastle’.
Thishasresultedintensionanddifficultybetweenopposingperspectives,the‘newstuff’andthe‘oldstuff’,thosewhowanttomaketheirmarkonthecityandthosewhowanttoprotectitsheritage.
I’vefoundittroublingthewayheritageand‘newstuff’haverecentlybeensetupasifinoppositionbymembersofthegrowingcreativesector.Heritageisoftenportrayedassomedulldustythinggettingintheway.
TheUNESCOdesignationasaCityofMediaArtsandassociatedplansfortheGuildhallprovokedparticularlyheateddebate,emphasisingthedivisionsbetweendifferentcommunitieswithinthecity.
Part 2 What has heritage ever done for us? 20thJune2015Havingintroducedthewiderproject,wenowsharethecontributionsandreflectionsgeneratedbythe‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’event.
11
![Page 14: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
‘TheproposalfortheGuildhallcomplexispartofabiggerpictureanddemandbeingpushedthroughthecitybythecreativesector’saidanarticleinoneandother.com.TheUNESCOdesignationis‘aboutYorkpushingforward’suggestedarecentpieceinthePress.Thereseemstobequitealotofpushinggoingon.It’snowondersomeofusfeelalittleconcerned,andfearthatthethingswecareaboutwillbepushedoutoftheway,destroyedorsilenced.RecentlyonTwitterInoticedaphototakeninBeverley,inEastYorkshire,somedecadesago.AphotoofabusgoingthroughBeverley’sNorthBar.Thebushadareallyunusualshape,atthetop.Notflatandwide,butwiththesidesoftheroofatanangle,formingamorepointedroof.TheroofmatchedtheshapeoftheNorthBar’sopeningandallowedthebusestogothroughit.Asolutiontoheritagebeing‘intheway’oftheneedsof20thcenturylife,animaginativeandthoughtfulone,andalocalone.
BeverleyNorthBarBus.Theimportanceofworkingwith‘thedistinctiveshapeofwhat’sthere’.Credit:EastRidingMuseumsServicecourtesyofDarrenKendre.
There’samessagethereforthosewantingtodrivethroughchangeinYork.Ihopethatthey’lltaketheirjourneythroughthecitywithmorerespectforwhat’salreadythere,shapingtheirchangesmoresympatheticallytothesoliditythatcamebefore,thedistinctiveshapeofwhat’salreadythere,ratherthandrivingthroughchangeregardless.
InBeverley,tohelpwithtrafficflow,theycouldhaveknockeddownthebar.InYorkwenearlyremovedours,andtookthebarbicanfrommostofthem.Nodoubtatthetimethe‘heritagebrigade’wereseenastryingtostandinthewayofprogress…
Forthefuture,Iwouldliketoseeusbroadenourawarenessandappreciationofheritagetoincludetheplacesandexperiencesperhapsmoreresonanttogroupsofpeoplecurrentlyunder-representedinthemanydialoguesaboutthecity’sheritage.Manyvoicesremainunheard.
It’sclearthatthosewhoknowhowtogetsupportandfundingwillhaveaclearadvantage,andthattherearemanypeopleleftontheperipheryunabletoinfluencedecisionsonheritageorhavetheirstoriesandexperiencesrecognisedaspartofYork’sstory.Ifearthatthedominantnarrativeswillendupwipingoutorobscuringthelocaldistinctiveness,ignoringwhatisalreadyknown.Achallengeforthefutureistomakesurethatthelessvisibleheritageandthequietervoicesarerecognisedandrecorded.
@YorkStorieswww.yorkstories.co.uk12
![Page 15: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Chris Steward, City of York Council LeaderCllrChrisStewardrepresentsRuralWestYorkWardfortheConservativePartyand,since
May2015,hasactedasCouncilLeader.ChrisopenedtheeventbysettingoutthechallengesheseesforheritageinYorkinbalancingdevelopmentandconservationthroughtheLocalPlan.Chrisdrewattentiontohousingasaparticularlycontentiousissue,andemphasizedacommitmentfromhisadministrationtoopenengagementwithYorkresidentsarguingitis‘absolutelykeytogetmorepeoplecontributing’.BelowisaneditedtranscriptofChris’sspeech.
Goodafternoon,everybody,itisgreattobehere.ObviouslyitisprettysoonaftertheelectionandYork’sfutureandhowheritagefeaturedinthatwasakeyissuefortheelection.WhenIgotinvitedtospeaktodayitreallymademethinkthatit’sfareasiertowriteapartypoliticalleafletsayingweneedtotalkaboutYork’sheritagethantomaybeexplainwhatwethinkofbyit.
Idothinkthewhole‘whathavetheRomanseverdoneforus?’isarealparallelbecauseobviouslyitisverytrueinYorkthatwe’vehadalotofRomaninfluence.ButequallysomuchofthegreatstuffaboutYorkwetakeforgranted.I,myself,havelivedinYorkallmylife;it’salovelyplace.Weknowwe’vegotincrediblebuildings,citywallsandeverythinglikethatandwe’vealsogottwothousandyearsofdevelopment.We’rethemostimportantcityintheNorth.WearethesecondmostimportantcitytoLondonand,asGeorgeVIfamouslysaid,‘thehistoryofYorkisthehistoryofEngland.’Sowe’vedefinitelygotsomethingtobuildonandwe’vegotsomethingtohelpinfluence.
Ididactuallylookupthedefinitionof‘heritage’inthedictionary.Ithoughtitwasworthdoingandgotvariousdefinitions,whichseemsunusualbutanyway.Everythingfromsomethinginheritedatbirth,suchaspersonalcharacteristicstoanythingthathasbeentransmittedfromthepastorhandeddownbytradition.Whichisreallyabouthowwe’vegotthismassiveopportunitytoinfluencethingsbecausethingsinYorkdochange,theyshouldchangeandwe’vegottothinkaboutwhatwewanttopreserveandenhance.
Wehavejusthadtheelection.TheLocalPlanwassomethingHelentouchedoninhere-mailinvitationtospeaktodayand,asmanyofyouwillbeaware,theLocalPlanlooksathousing,employment,land,transportandthewholefeelofYork.Idoactuallythinkforallthestuffyouwillhearinthemedia,thereisprobablyafarbroaderagreementontheheritagesideacrosspoliticiansofdifferentpartiesthanyoumightthink.Wherethereisabigdisagreementisonthelevelofhousing,wherethathousingshouldbebuiltandweasapartyandweasanewadministrationareveryclear.Wedonotthinkthereshouldbeanythinglikethelevelofdevelopmentonthegreenbeltthatwasproposedinthepreviousdraftlocalplan.Wethinkbrownfieldsitesshouldbeprioritizedfordevelopmentforanumberofreasons:fromthepointofviewofenhancingurbanregenerationtokeepingtheuniquefeelofYork.IthinkYorkwouldlosealotifdevelopmentaspreviouslyproposedwastohappenand,ifyoulookatsomeofthesites,forexamplewherewegethousingtotheringroadandthenhousingbeyondreallyisn’tthewayforwardforme.Sothere’shopefullylotsofthingswecanworkon.
Thereiseventhingswhere,althoughDaveTaylormaynotliketoadmittoit,weandtheGreensagree;Ithinkwehaveasimilarviewonthingslikethelocalplanandhopefullyheritagebeingatthecoreofthat.
13
![Page 16: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Idoverymuchthinkthisistherightformatfortoday,justhavingafewminutesofusoutliningourviewsandtheninthemainhearingfrompeoplewhatyouthink.Becausewhilstthingslikeprotectingthegreenbeltarepoliticalthings,itisourpoliticalviewwedon’twantthevasthousingasproposed.WewantsomehousingatalowerlevelandindifferentlocationsbutheritagereallyissomethingthathasgottobeaboutthewholeofYorkandtakingeveryonewithus.
ObviouslyYorkapplyingforWorldHeritageStatushasbeenaverybigthingovertherecentyearsandIamnotgoingtotalkatallaboutthat,excepttosayweallknowYorkessentiallyoneofthebestcitiesaroundanditwouldbegreattogetthatacknowledgement.Sotherearevariousdecisionsatthemomentthatweface,whicharesortofweighinguptheprosandconsoftheheritageissuesthatconcernshowwemoveforward,withalsosomeofthequestionsthatwereraisedabouttheaffordabilityofYorkandtheenvironmentthatwelivein.SomeofthebuildingsyoumayhaveseenarethingslikewhatwillhappentoReynard’sGarage?WhatwillhappentotheMaltingsinClementhorpe?Buttheyareinterestingexamplesofthere’safinancialaspecttothingsandthere’saculturalaspecttothings.InthecaseoftheMaltingstherearethehousingaspectsandtheremaybewiththeReynard’sGaragetoo,dependingonwhathappens.Butinbothcasestheyareclearexamplesofwherenothinghashappenedforyearsandyearsandyearsandthatalmostisthegreatestwrongofallthattheyhavejustbeenleft.SoIknowthatitisabsolutelykeytogetmorepeoplecontributingand–Iwouldsaythiswouldn’tI?–Idon’tthinkthepreviousadministrationwasthemostreceptivetocontributions.Butnowwe’vegotadifferentCouncil;we’vedoneanadministrationwiththeLiberalDemocratsbutitis‘nooverallcontrol’,whichmeansthatdifferentCouncillorshaveasayatdifferentcommitteemeetingsandIthinkthatisapositiveandwewillreachoutwhereverwepossiblycanbe.
TwothencurrentissuesraisedasexamplesduringtheeventwereReynard’sGarageandtheMaltingsinClementhorpe.Reynard’sGarage–ortheformerAirspeedFactorywithconnectionstopioneeringaviatorAmyJohnson-provedthemorecontroversialoftwo.Shortlyaftertheeventadecisionwasmadetodemolishthebuilding.
Reynard’sGarage.ValuedbymanyforitsartdecofeaturesanditsconnectiontotheAirspeedFactory.TherehadbeenhopethattheYorkshireAirMuseummighttakethesiteover.Credit:IanTempest
14
![Page 17: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
SohowmightYork’sheritagebecomearesourcethathelpsuslivetogether,wasoneoftheevent’squestions?Andalsotheissuesaboutwages,affordablecities;wellIthinkthekeythingisaboutthecitygrowing,thecitychanging.Italwayshaschanged;italwayswillchange.Ifwethink,forexample,ofReynard’sGaragethatpeoplewilltalkaboutthelinkswiththeairindustry,theywilltalkaboutthelinksforholdingtramsinthere;formeIwillalwaysknowitastheplacethatwasLazerQuest,so,youknow,it’sbeendifferentthingsovertheyears.ItisabouthowwegetthebestdealandIthinkthatisaboutheritageworkingbestwhenwereallydoprotectwhatwe’vegot,enjoywhatwe’vegotandsavourwhatwe’vegot.
YorkGuildhall,abuildingwhosefutureiscurrentlyunderdiscussion.Credit:IanTempest
Tourismisakeythingbecausewewanttherightsortoftourists,ifwecansaythat.Soweareincreasinglygettingstagandhenpartiesbutthere’sabetterwayforward.NottohavetouristsjustasacommoditybuttoreallysharewiththemthebrillianceofYork.AndIwouldjustreallyfinishonwhatisoneofthetoughestdecisionsthatwearegoingtofaceatthemoment,whichiswhattodowiththeGuildhall?Andthatisafascinatingproject,andforme,youknow,itcomesbacktothesamesortofthingthatthebiggestwrongwiththeGuildhallatthemomentisthefactthatwe’vegotthisincrediblebuildingandveryfewpeoplegoandseeit.Youknow,ifyouhavefriendshereyoumightsortofsay,we’llhaveawanderdownandlet’slookroundtheGuildhall.Iwastalkingearlieraboutthetours[withYorkPastandPresent]thatpeoplecando.Butinthemainit’sjusttotallyneglected,totallyunloved;sowe’vegottolookatthecityofmediaandartsandhowthatcanhavearolewithinthebuildingthroughaviablebusinessplan.Butit’sacombinationoffactorstopreservetheold,tomovewiththenew,timeschangebuttherereallyisnotinanyofthisarightorawronganswer.AndtherearecertainthingsthatwewillthinkaspoliticiansbutIthinkinheritage,itisallaboutthisjourneyofwhatwewanttoseeinYork,whatwewanttopreserveandthatissomethingwherewehopefullycangetfarmoreengagementamongstresidentsgoingforward.
15
![Page 18: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Dave Taylor, City of York Councillor and Chair, Culture and Leisure Scrutiny CommitteeCllrDaveTaylorrepresentsFishergateWardfortheGreenParty.Daveopenedbysayingit
washeritage–intheformtheCastleAreaCampaignagainstCoppergateII–thatfirstgothimpoliticallyengagedinYork.CllrTaylorwaskeentoseeheritageasan‘agentofchange’andof‘regeneration,‘Ithinktooofteninourcity[…]heritagehasbeenseenasanobstacle,amillstone.Andyetitcanbetheoppositeofthat–itisagreatattractor.’AthemerunningthroughDave’stalkwashowtosubstantiallyincreasetransparencyandpublicparticipationinthecity’sdecisionmakingandconcluded,‘SoI’llleaveyouwithaphrase,turningHelen’squestiononitsheadperhaps,asknotwhatYork’sheritagecandoforyou,butwhatyoucandoforYork’sheritage?’BelowisaneditedtranscriptofDave’scontribution.
AshasbeenexplainedtoyouI’mtheGreenPartyCouncillorforFishergateandIamcurrentlytheChairoftheLearningandCulturePolicyandScrutinyCommitteeandIwasalsotheHeritageChampionforYork,arolewhichsadlyLabourdeleted.Itwasanunpaid,anunremuneratedrole,soI’mnotquitesurewhytheyfelttheneedtodothat.HoweverIhavebeenspeakingtothenewadministrationtoseewhetherwecanrestorethatroleforsomebody.IamalsoChairmanfortheScrutinyReviewintotheCulturalQuarterforYorkandIamalifememberofYorkCivicTrust.IhavealsoworkedwithpeoplelikeJohnOxleyonYork’sbidforWorldHeritageSitestatus.
So,whathasheritageeverdoneforus?WellIthinkperhapsoneofthemostimportantthingsistoeducateourselvesaboutthepastandhowthepastimpactsonthepresentandthefuture;hopefullywecanlearnfromthemistakesofthepastandlearnnottorepeatthem.
Clifford’sTower,DaveTaylorarguesthatpreviousdevelopmentplansdidnotadequatelyrespectthesite’sspecifichistory,notleastthe1190pogromsagainsttheJewishcommunity.Credit:BarryPitcher
16
![Page 19: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
ItwasClifford’sTowerbuildingthatreallygotmeinvolvedinpoliticsinYork.ThesiteofoneofthefirstpogromsagainsttheJewshereinYorkin1190andtheCouncilwantedtoplonkashoppingmallnexttoit,onthecastlecarpark,backin1998.AndIgotinvolvedinthecitizen’sgroupcalledtheCastleAreaCampaign,withsomepeoplewhoareinthisroomheretodayandaswellasYorkCivicTrust.Wecampaignedveryhardforyearsonthat,andtheCouncil’splans,alongwithLandSecurities,weredefeatedinapublicinquiryin2003.AndtheancientmonumentofClifford’sTowernowstandsasasymboloftheneedtoguardagainstreligiousintolerance.Thisisatheme,whichhasvisitedYorkandYorkshiresince,withminoritiesliketheCatholicsbeingpersecutedandtheirterroristresponsebackin1605,anoldboyofSt.Peter’sSchool,GuyFawkes,beingthebombmaker,rightuptothealienationofMuslimstoday.Thisisathreadofhistoryfromwhichwecanlearn.
Iwanttotalkalittlebitabouthowheritagecanbeanagentforchangetoo.Howitcanplayapartinregenerationandattractinginwardinvestmentandinrenewingoureconomy.Ithinktooofteninourcity,andelsewhereofcourse,heritagehasbeenseenasanobstacle,amillstone.Andyetitcanbetheoppositeofthatasitisagreatattractor.WhentheVisitYorksurveypeoplewhocometovisitourfaircity,asteady80%saytheycomehereforthehistoryandheritage.Theydon’tcomeheretoshopinDebenhams.
Buthereisabuilding,whichtheCouncilisstrugglingtofindauseforandweareresponsible:York’sGuildhall.TheGuildhallitselfwhichIamsuremanypeoplehavebeeninto,isusedforoccasionalartexhibitionsandtherehavebeentoursroundorganizedbythegreatYorkPastandPresent.ThereistheGuildhallitself,theCouncilChamberandthewonderfulCommitteeRoomsandtherearesomelesslovelyofficebuildingsaswell.ButtherecouldbeagreatattractorinsuchafabulouslocationandIhavebeenawareofaneedfortenyearsormoreforabusinesslocationwheresmalldigitalandartscompaniescanco-locate,theycanshareprojectsandbidforlargerpiecesofwork.AndIthinktherestorationoftheGuildhall,whichweneedtodocouldprovidethatincubatoranditcouldbethespringboardforthosedigitalmediacompaniestogrowthatlivelytechnologysectorinYork.Thereneedstobeasoundbusinesscase,ofcoursetheredoes,buttheideaofatwenty-firstcenturyguildtotakeovertheGuildhallisveryappealing.
17
![Page 20: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
ThegardensofStAntony’sHall,nowhometotheQuiltMuseumandGallery.Credit:AmandaTodd
St.Anthony’sHall,isanotherGuildhallpreviouslyusedbytheBorthwickInstituteuntil2004whentheyabandonedittomovetonewarchivespaceattheUniversityofYork.IbroughttheQuilter’sGuildoftheBritishIslestolookatthisbuilding,astheCouncilwas,atthetime,cluelessastowhattheycoulddowithit.Therewassometalkofpossiblyturningitintooffices.Butthescaleofthishall,whichisquitemagnificent,wasperfectforhanginglargetapestriesanditonlyhasawindowatoneendandattheotherendsothereisalotofwallspacethereforhangingtheselargetapestries,whichcouldeasilybedamagedbystrongsunlight.Andyoucanseesomeoftheexhibitionshereandoneofthemorecontemporarydesignsaswellhere.IdiscoveredthatYorkSt.JohnhascoursesindesignandImadetherelevantintroductionstotheQuilter’sGuildbackin2004.AswellastherestorationofSt.Anthony’sHallitself,thisre-development,thisregeneration,providedofficesforYorkArchaeologicalTrust,hostedbythenewlandlord,YorkConservationTrust,whichtookontheownershipofthisbuildingfromtheCouncil.Thegardensarefabulousandrunallthewayuptothecitywalls.Theywereinadisgracefulmess,butarenowsuperblyredesignedbyBishopBurtonCollege,withthenewSchoolhouseGalleryinthegroundsandtheOldPrintWorks,whichwasonthissidenowturnedintoarestaurant,theLeLangheRestaurant.
Imustbringyouuptodatewithacoupleofrecentissues,bothbadlyhandledbythepreviouscounciladministration.TheMalthouseatClementhorpe,whichhadbeenusedasamuseumstore.Asecretdecisionwasmadetoflogitofftoadeveloperandthishasonlyrecentlyenteredintothepublic’sconsciousness.However,astheMalthousewasgoingtoberestored,albeitconvertedtoprivateflats,Ididn’treallyobjecttothisasIthoughtitwouldbeasensitiveconversion.Iwasmoreconcernedaboutthisdebacle.Thesamesecretprocessundertheformeradministrationwouldhaveleftthisbuildingdemolished.Thedirectorhadrefusedtogiveme,overthecourseofaboutamonthcouncilofficershad
18
![Page 21: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
refusedtogivemeinformationabouttheprocess,whichdeliveredtotheCabinetfourchoicesofwhattodowiththebuilding.1)Knockitdownandbuildahotel.2)Knockitdownandbuildahotel.3)Knockitdownandbuildahotel.Or4)knockitdownandbuildahotel.It’sjustscandalousreallythatthatsecretprocesstookplacewithnoopportunityformembersofthepublic,andnoopportunityforoppositionCouncillorsatthattime,toengagewithit.IfeltthiswouldbeashockinglossofoneofYork’sfewArtDecobuildingsofnote.Youcanseesomeofthedetailinghereandwiththeassociationswiththeauthor,NevilShute,hewasaformeraircraftbuilder,andAmyJohnson,thefamousaviator,whoinvestedinShute’sfactory.Ithoughtitdeservedabetterfate.YorkshireAirMuseumenvisagedturningthestructureintoa1930sexperiencetohonourShute,Johnsonandthetechnologicalrevolutionofthosetimes.ThishasbeendiscussedwiththeCouncillongbeforetheshoddyandshabbysecretprocess,whichtookplacetobringaboutitsdestruction.Thisbattleison-going.WhenthehotelbidwasrejectedIarrangedadealtosaveitwiththelastLabourleader,DafyddWilliamsandtocontractdirectlywiththeYorkshireAirMuseum.ButnowtheCouncilaresayingit’sunsafe.Itisprobablynomoreunsafenowthanithasbeenforthelasttwentyyears.
Sowhathasheritageeverdoneforus?Wellwithoutgoingintothesketchfrom‘LifeofBrian’,Iwouldsaythatheritagegivesusatremendousamount,certainlyintermsofitseducativepotential.Ifpeopletookasmuchinterestintheirheritageasyoudo,ifwealltookaninterestintheheritageitwouldbebetter.Historyandheritageisthebedrockofourtouristeconomy,ashasbeensaid.Thissupports10%ofemploymentinthecityandithasthepotentialtoattractinwardinvestmenttogrowourtargetbusinessclusters,asIhaveargued.MoreoverIthinkitjustaddsmassivelytoourqualityoflifeandthisiswhyIchoosetolivehereinYorkandnotinRochdale,whereIgrewupandwhyIwouldneverchoosetoliveinanewtownlikeMiltonKeynes.ButIwouldsayChris(gesturingtotheCouncilLeader,ChrisSteward)thatmaybestrategicbuildingintheGreenBeltisbetterthanover-developmentinthecitycentre,whichdestroysthequalityoflifeinthecity.SoI’llleaveyouwithaphrase,turningHelen’squestiononitsheadperhaps,asknotwhatYork’sheritagecandoforyou,butwhatyoucandoforYork’sheritage?
19
![Page 22: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Peter AddymanPeterAddymanisthefoundingDirectorofYorkArchaeologyTrustandcurrentchairofYork
CivicTrust.Peterbeganbysayinginanswertotheevent’squestionthathebecameanarcheologistbecauseofthechancetocomeoverasateenagertogetinvolvedindigsinYork.Then,havingbecomeaprofessionalarchaeologist,AddymanwascalledbacktoYorktoreviewaschemein1969/1970whichsuggestedthat‘thatfivemulti-storeycarparkswithinthecitywallswereneeded,proposedbytheEsherScheme’.Outofthatworkhe‘recommendedthesettingupofwhatturnedouttobetheYorkArchaeologicalTrustandinthereportthatwepresentedwepromisedthecityinreturn,andIquote,“avastlyenrichedhistory,avastlyenhancedmuseumcollectionandmassiveeducational,touristicandrecreationalbenefits,”andthathasallhappened.’Addymanconcludedbyarguing:‘Sowhathasheritageeverdoneforus?Theshortanswerisit’smadeusalotmoreprosperousthanweotherwisemighthavebeen.’
Thankyouverymuch,IamnotreallyspeakingthisafternoonIthinkasChairmanoftheCivicTrust,Iamspeakingasmeand,asyouhaveheard,formerlyanarchaeologistofthisparish.Iamgoingtotryansweringthisquestionfrommyownexperience.ThatstartedformeinYorkin1954.Iwasaschoolboy.IcameoverfromHarrogatetoYorkregularlytolearnhowtoexcavateinresearchexcavationsthatweregoingonatthattimeinthemuseumgardensoftheYorkshireMuseum.Sotheanswer,thefirstanswerIcangiveyou,isthatitsoldmeonarchaeologyanditsetmeoffonacareerthatisstilldeveloping64yearslater.ThathappenedinYorkanditwasasaresultofYork’sheritage.Andwhat’sthelessonfromthat?WellthelessonisthatthearchaeologicalheritageinYorkhasdonethesamethingforcountlesshundredsofotherpeopleovertheyears,manyofthemnowamongstthemostdistinguishedarchaeologistsinthecountry,whogainedmeaningfulexperienceofarchaeology,oftentheirfirstexperience,andoftenabsolutelyfirst-classexperience,inexcavationsandmuseumsinYorkandinitsuniversity.SoYorkhaseducatedgenerationsofarchaeologicalscholarsforthenationoverthelastfortyyears.
MynextmajorexperienceherecameIthinkin1969/1970,whenYorkwasaflourishingcity,believeitornot,pulsatingwithindustry,withahugecarriageworks,withtwogreatchocolatefactories,withasugarfactoryandcountlessotherlesserbusinessesgeneratinghugeamountsoftrafficatgoinghometime;lotsofthemonbikesbutcarsaswell.Anditwassuggestedthataninnerringroadwasneededtoclearallthataway;thatanouterringroadwasneeded;thatfivemulti-storeycarparkswithinthecitywallswereneeded,proposedbytheEsherSchemeandmassivecitycentreredevelopmentwasneeded.SoIwashauledupfromauniversitypostinSouthamptonatthattimetoadviseonwhateventheywasseenasathreattoheritageandespeciallyofcoursethebelow-groundheritage,whichwasmyforte.IthinkIandacoupleofstudentsassessedthethreats,werecommendedthesettingupofwhatturnedouttobetheYorkArchaeologicalTrustandinthereportthatwepresentedwepromisedthecityinreturn,andIquote,‘avastlyenrichedhistory,avastlyenhancedmuseumcollectionandmassiveeducational,touristicandrecreationalbenefits,’andthathasallhappened.
Newlighthasbeenthrownonthecity’shistorythroughendlessexcavations;over1,500hadtakenplacebytheyear2000onthingsliketheRomanfortressortheRomancity,southoftheriver.OrtheAnglo-SaxontownofEoforwic,whichtoallintentsandpurposeswasunknownatthattime,exceptfromtheliteraryrecord.Andthenthehardly-knownVikingtownturnedupandyounowknowitasJorvik;nobodyevenknewthewordinthosedays;andendlessaspectsofmedievaland
20
![Page 23: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
post-medievalYorkhavebecomeelucidated.Asyouknowmillionshavevisitedthoseexcavationsand,Iamtold,IamnotsureIbelieveit,butIamtoldthatupwardsof30millionpeoplehavenowvisitedtheJorvikVikingCentre,about40,000schoolchildreneveryyearfor30yearshavehadanintensiveeducationinarchaeologyatDig,theArchaeologicalResourceCentreinSt.SaviourGate,whichitselfusesaheritagebuilding,St.Saviour’sChurch.Nowifyouworkitout30years,40,000schoolchildren,1,200,000schoolkidshavebeeneducatedaboutheritageinYork.About30,000visitorsannuallygotoBarleyHall,offStoneGateinCoffeeYard.OutatHuntingdonthereisoneofthenation’sfewlaboratoriesthatpreservesartefacts,especiallywater-loggedwood,andtheyarecurrentlypreservingforthenationthetimbersofaDutchEastIndiamanandalsothefamousNewportboat,amedievalboat,oneofourbestmedievalboats,thebestmedievalboatthatsurvivesaswellas,ofcourse,massesofstufffromYork.BesidesthelabthereisoneofBritain’sbiggestandbestartefactstores,therawmaterialforresearchonYorkfordecades,probablycenturiestocome.
Sowhathasheritagedoneforusthroughallthis?WellIthinkwe’vealreadylearnedithasvastlystimulatedheritage-basedinterestinYork,ithasvastlyenrichedYork’shistoryandithasprovidedunforgettableandinspiringeducationalexperiencesforschoolchildrenfromalloverBritainandexperiencesthatareavailableallthetime,ontheirdoorstep,forourownchildrenwholiveinYork.Ithasprovidedjobs,andjobsforover40years,forabout100archaeologistsonaverageandscholars,whoseworkhasbecomeanexemplarofexcellenceonaworldscale,vastlyenhancingYork’sinternationalprofileasatouristcentre,asanacademiccentreandasacentreforresearchandgoodpractice.Peoplecomefromallovertheworldtolookatwhatwedo.
Meanwhilewhathashappenedtothetwochocolateworks?Onehasgone,oneismuchreduced.Whathashappenedtothesugarfactory?Gonewithouttrace.Whathashappenedtothecarriageworks?Whathashappenedtoallthosejobs?Gone.Andwhathasreplacedthem,wellamongstotherthingsavastandvastlyenlargedandenhancedtouristindustrygeneratingscadsofjobsinhostsofsectors;accommodation,thefoodindustry,retail,attractionsrangingfromRichardIIItoChocolateStory,carhire,taxis,buses,carparking,printing,goodnessknowswhat.
Yes,yousay,butwhat’sitdoneforus,theordinarypeopleofYork?Well,afteronlytwoyearstheJorvikVikingCentrewasawardedtheNationalAwardfortheBestMarketedSmallCompanyinBritain–amazing!Andthisiswhatthecitationsaid,andIamquotingthis,‘JorvikwithanannualturnoveratMarch1987ofmorethan£2.5millionisnowintheninthpositionnationallyamongstleisureattractionswhereanadmissionchargeismade.
NowthatcanonlybegoodforYork’spresentdayresidentstoo.’Goingon,‘ResearchrecentlyconductedbytheEnglishTouristBoardshowedthatforevery£1spentinJorvik,afurther£7isspentbyvisitorsinthecommunity.’AndtheInstituteofMarketingcommented,‘Imaginativemarketingtechniqueshaveestablishedthatthislivingmuseumisoneofthetopleisureattractionswithanimpressiveinternationalreputation.’Andnowlet’sjustthinkwhatthatnowmeanstoday.Say,asweheardbefore30millionpeoplehavebeenthroughJorvikatamodernequivalentpriceof£10ahead;ifeachofthosepoundsgeneratesafurther£7forYork’seconomythataddsupto£2.1billionforYorkoverthelast30
21
![Page 24: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
years.Sowhathasheritageeverdoneforus?Theshortanswerisit’smadeusalotmoreprosperousthanweotherwisemighthavebeen.Andthatunderlinesmyfinalpoint,wecan’taffordtoletourheritagego.
ThethingthatnowbringsstreamsofpeopletoYorkandcreatesthatbenefitforoureconomy;wecan’tallowanirresponsibleCityofYorkCouncilletitsheritageassetsliketheReynard’sGarageinPiccadilly,birthplaceofsomeofBritain’smosticonicearlyaeroplanes,fallintorackandruinandthendemanditsdemolitionwhenitcouldbeanotherhugevisitorandrevenuegeneratorforYorkifonlysomeonehadthevisiontoseeit.ComeonCityofYorkCouncil,Iamsureyoucandobetter.
TheJorvikVikingCentre–runbyYorkArcheologyTrust–hasactedasahugevisitorattraction.CreditIanTempest
Weshouldn’tlettheCityofYorksanctionthemostrudimentaryofrescuearchaeologyjobsonahugelyimportantsite,theremainsofMedievalEngland’slargest,secondlargest,hospitalIthinkandthenearuniqueremainsofYork’sRoyalMint,ifnotthedepositsfromitjustincaseaseasonofpantomimemightbemissedinourtheatre.Thejobthatisbeingdonethereisnotreallyanadequatejobfortheimportanceofthesite.SocomeonJohnOxley,whereveryouare,comeonCityofYorkCouncil–IthinktherearetoomanygeeseinYorkbuttheseparticulargeeseandothergeeselikethemcouldlayusgoldeneggsandwecan’taffordtoslaughterthem.Thankyou.
22
![Page 25: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Lianne Brigham and Richard Brigham, York Past and PresentLianneBrighamandRichardBrighamfromYorkPastandPresent,whohavebeeninvolved
intheLivingwithHistoryprojectandthewiderHowshouldHeritageDecisionsbeMade?researchproject.Theyopenedbyexplainingthat‘heritagehasgivenusasenseofworth,afeelingofprideforthecityweliveinandIcanhonestlysayitissomethingweneverhadbefore’.LianneandRichardthentalkedabouttheirexperiencesofgettinginvolvedindocumentingMansionHouse:‘thisisinvolvingoverthirtymembersofthepublictodocumentthebuilding,helppacktheitemsandrecord’.Overall,theyreflectedthattheyfoundwaysofmaking‘ourvoicesheard,evenifitdoesmeanshoutingatthetopofthemorbeingslightlyannoyingatthesametime!’
YorkPastandPresenthavebeeninvolvedinphotographyandpackingupalltheobjectsinYork’sMansionHouseaspartoftheirrenovationanddevelopmentHeritageLotteryproject.Credit:YorkPastandPresent
Whenwewereaskedwhatheritagehasdoneforyou?Wethoughtthiswasaninterestingquestion.SinceformingYorkPastandPresentoverayearagoIhavetosayheritagehasgivenusasenseofworth,afeelingofprideforthecityweliveinandIcanhonestlysayitissomethingweneverhadbefore.Whenyoulookaroundwhereweliveandtakealookattheheritagethatexistsyousooncometorealisenoteverythinginthiscityishowitshouldbe.Youtendtorealiseyourbelovedcityinsomewaysiscrumblingaroundyou.Theredoesn’tseemtobeanythingwecandoaboutit.Oristhere?AsfoundersofYorkPastandPresentwesetoutwithacoupleofwhatseemedtobesimpleideas;toengagetheCityofYorkCouncilinpublicparticipationandtostartwhatwasgoingtobecomeapublicarchive.Noneofusthoughtthiswasgoingtobeeasy.InallfairnesswehadthesameexpectationsaturkeyhadaweekbeforeChristmas.However,withourthoughtsandideasandalotofstubbornnessweembarkedonaheritagejourneythatwouldtakeustoplaceswenevereventhoughtwaspossible.FromourhumblebeginningsasasmallFacebookgroup,overthepastyearwehaveincreasedmembershiptojustunder8,000,alotofwhomactivelyparticipateinmanyofthethingswedo.Wearealiving,breathing,onlinecommunityandwehaveachievedmuchmorethananybody,including–wethoughtwecouldachievealittlebit.Wehaveachievedalotmore.WiththehelpofandcontinuedsupportofpeoplelikeHelen,RichardPollitt,JohnOxley,VictoriaHoyle–withinthelastyearwehavedocumentedWorldWarIIhuts,participatedinanarchaeologicaldigandphotographedtheGuildhallfromtoptobottom.
23
![Page 26: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
ApictureofsomewoodenbuildingsneartheGuildhall,documentedbyYorkPastandPresentbeforetheyweredemolishedin2014.Credit:RichardBrigham
24
![Page 27: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Butitdoesn’tstopthere.WeeklytoursoftheGuildhallhavebeengoingforovereightmonthsnowandseveralhundredpeoplehavepassedthroughitsdoorsandarchesandasweknow,noothergroupdoesthetourasintensiveandasinformativeaswedo.NotbadforthemembersofJoePublic.Aswellasprideforwhatwearedoing,wealsomeeteverymonthandraisemoneyforcharityandYorkPastandPresentmembershaveraisedover£900forvariouscharitableorganisationsinthelastfewmonths.YesterdaywewereengagedindocumentingtheworkthathasnowstartedontheMansionHouse;thisisinvolvingoverthirtymembersofthepublictodocumentthebuilding,helppacktheitemsandrecord.Thishasincludedpacking,doingphotography,3Dvideoimagingandinterviewers,againalldonewillinglybymembersofthepublic.YorkPastandPresent,ifanything,hasbroughtthecommunityofpeopletogether,notonlytotakeanactiveinterestinourheritagebutalsotakingtheideaswehaveandputtingthemtousebyhelpingtopreservebothheritageandthehistoryofourcity.ForusandIamsureIcanspeakforourmembersaswell,heritagehasgivenusavoice,asparkofinterestandawayofparticipatinginthingsthatwefeelwecanmakeadifferenceinourcity.Wecanmakeourvoicesheard,evenifitdoesmeanshoutingatthetopofthemorbeingslightlyannoyingatthesametime.Forustheheritageisallaboutmakingadifference.Itisaboutus,thepublic,havingavoiceandanopinionthatnotonlycanbeheardbutalsolistenedto.Bydoingthisitgivesustheabilitytosaveandrecordthehistoryofourcityforit’sfuture.
Lianne Brigham and Richard Brigham, York Past and PresentWhatwe’dliketopassonissomeadviceforotherpeoplehopingtogetmoreinvolvedin
heritagedecision-makingintheircity.
•Buildacommunityofpeoplewiththesameinterest.•MeetkeypeoplebasedinInstitutions(likeinaUniversityorintheCouncil).‘Be
giveyourfreetimebecauseit’svolunteeringthatmakestheconnections’.•Tapintothesekeypeople’snetworks.•Crossoverfromsocialmediatoreallifeeventsandlifeliveeventsbackto
socialmedia.•Youneedanideatotalkabout[forYorkPastandPresentthishasbeenpublic
documentation].•Communicationandlanguage–youneedtospeaktodifferentpeoplein
differentways.•Gainmoreandmoreconfidencefromspeakingtolotsofdifferentpeople–and
seeingthattheylikewhatyouaredoing.•Begeneroustopeopleininstitutions/council.‘Theycanshutthedoor,faster
thanyoucanopenit’.•Don’tsettleforsmallthings,keepyoureyesonyourmaingoal.‘Belikea
child,behappywithwhatthoseindecision-makingpositionsofferbutalwaysdemandmore’.
25
![Page 28: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Michael Hayes, Plastic FortuneMichaelHayesisoneofthefoundersofPlasticFortunewhich‘aimstobuildanetworkof
creativeyoungpeopleinthecityofYork’.Michaelbeganbyarguingthat‘Yorkcatersverywelltothetouristandnotsomuchtotheresident’.Michaelwantedtodrawattentiontoallofthecontemporaryculturethatisgoingoninthecity–somethingthey’vebeencapturingwiththePeopleofYorkseries.HegaveoneexampleofbeingatInkwellwheretherewasagigintheshopforRecordStoreDay,therestartedoffbeingaround30peoplebutasthegigwentonthecrowdstartedtoblock‘thestreetbecauseloadsoftouristswanttoseewhatishappeningbecausesomethingishappening.Itisnotsomethingthathashappenedhere,somethingishappening!’InstructuraltermsMichaeldrewattentiontohowharditwastoliveinthecityasayoungpersonandtofindspacetorenttostartabusiness.
I’mfromPlasticFortuneandwe’reacreativecollective.Wemakefilms,wehosteventsandweareopeningouronlinestoreinSeptember.Right,IreadtheresearchquestionsandbeforewegetstartedIjustwanttochallengeabitoftheterminology.ItsaysweneedtolookatheritagedecisionsandIamgoingtoarguethatitistoopreciseatermforwhatwehave.Wedon’thaveheritagedecisions;wehaveaheritageculturewhereeverythingissacred.SobasicallywhatIamgoingtotryandofferisanewperspective,onethatkindofgetsignored.Notthetourists,ortheprofessionalortheacademic,justthepeoplewhohavelivedhavetodealwithlivinghere.
Isay‘dealwithlivinghere’becausebasicallyYorkcatersverywelltothetouristandnotsomuchtotheresident.Sothefutureofheritage.CurrentlyYorkisacitythatdid;itisnotacitythatdoes,whichtobehonestisabitofawastebecausethere’ssomuchgoesoninthecitybutit’snotputoutthere,whichtakesmetotwoofthemajorpointsIwanttotalkabout.Thatisinefficiencyinthewaythatwegetthingsoutthere;whatwedoaswellaswhatwe’vedone.AndthesecondpointwouldthatthereputationofYorkissoimportanttowhocomeshere.So,withmycompanywewentoutandwedidabitofsurveyingofpeopleinthestreetandwejustspentadaytalkingtoactualpeoplewhowereherevisiting,livinghere,allthatsortofstuff.Andweaskedthemwhatareyoudoing?WhatdoyouthinkaboutYork?Themaintwoanswersweredrinkingandoldbuildings.SobasicallythatisYork’sactualreputation,whichpeopleseeitasanddespitetherebeingasmallcliqueofpeoplewhothinkthatYorkissomefaroutbastionoftechnologyandart,thatmightbetrueto1%ofthepopulation.ButifIgooutonthestreetorIgetsomeonefromoutthereandgoandshowthemtheUNESCOCityofMediaArtsthingtheygo,what’sthat?Mostpeoplehaven’theardofit,whichisjustsuchawaste.Itissuchagoodthingandcouldbesopowerfulbutit’snot.
Thereasonit’sawasteisbecauseofhowmuchwedorightnow.It’snotthatweneedtogrowthings.We’vegotafranklydisproportionatelygoodmusicsceneforhowsmallweare.We’vegottheatrecompaniesthataren’tlikebigonesliketheTheatreRoyalandtheGrandOperaHouse–theyaremoreDIY,they’llfindachurchthatwillhostatheatregroupforpeoplewhomaybecan’taffordthenormaltheatreticketprices.Andthenmagazines;wehaveAesthetica,whichisinternationallyrenownedforartanddesignanditstartedhere,right?Notmanypeopleactuallyknowthat,likeofthegeneralpublicandthepeoplewhomatterdon’tknowthatandthatisridiculousbecauseitissosuccessfulandthefactthatwedon’tadvertiseordemonstratethatwecandoallthesethingstoeveryoneiswaste.
26
![Page 29: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Weneedtodemonstratethatwecandothings,notthatwedidthings.Becausewe’vecultivatedthisimagethatbasicallythatweareaheritagetown;everythingwedoissteepedinhistory.It’squaint.Welltheproblemisyouhaveaone-linereputationsoonlygetcertainsortsoftouriststhatvisit.Infacttwosortsactually,theoneswholiketodrinkandtheoneswholikeoldbuildingsandthat’sit.Sothisreputationiscausingabitofaproblem.Wehavetwouniversities,wehavequiteafew,wedidhavequiteafewtechbusinesses,buttheproblemisthesepeopleleave,especiallypeoplemyage,like22becauseoftwoparticularreasons.YorkshiesawayfromsupportingthecreativeindustriesinYorkandnumbertwo,housing.Housingissuchabigproblem.Sowhatyouhaveisaskillsexodus–graduatesleave.
It’sactuallyaproblemforbusinessesbecause,whenItellpeoplewhatPlasticFortunedoandthatourcollectivehasdesigners,writers,presenters,everything,theyaresurprised.ThequestionI’maskedis,Ican’tfindagraphicdesigner.Ican’tfindafilmmakerformypromotionalvideoinYork.Becauseifyouput‘York’and‘designer’intoGoogleandyougetsomeonefromNewYork.YouputYork,UKandyougetachairmakerorsomethinglikethat.Wedon’tshoutenoughaboutitandtheproblemisthenthesepeoplego,I’llhiresomeonefromLondon.Andthisisgenuinelytrue.TheywillhirepeoplefromLondonandthey’llpaythemthetrainfaretocomeup,they’llpaythehotel,alltheexpensesandthensendthembackdownafewdayslater.Right?Nowisn’tthatawasteofabusiness?Itistakingawayfrompeoplewhoareactuallyinthecityandthesepeoplewouldlovetoknowiftherewasadesignercoulddowhattheyneededtodoathalfthepricebecauseofwheretheywere.
Wedon’twanttopushheritageawaybecauseitisimportantanditaddstothebeautyofthecityandlet’smakenomistakeaboutit.ImeanYorkispretty;andthatsoundsquitevainbutitisaprettyplaceandyoudon’twanttopushitawaybutwhatweneedtodoistofindanewpurposeforit.Itneedstostartsupportingwhatishappeninginthecity.IthinkagoodcaseinpointiswewenttogofilmtheInkwellonRecordStoreDayandifnoneofyouhavebeentoInkwell,gothere,vinyl,magazines,crafts,it’sincredible–it’sanindependentshopandonRecordStoreDaytheyhadaneventintheshopanditholdsaboutthirtypeopletops.SoIfilmeditthereanditwasfullbeforeIevenbegan.Sowestartedplayingthemusicandafteraboutfiveminutespeoplestartedcongregatingoutside.Soeventuallyitgetstothepointwherethere’saboutthirtypeopleinsideandanotherthirtyonthestreet,inGillygate.It’sblockingthestreetbecauseloadsoftouristswanttoseewhatishappeningbecausesomethingishappening.Itisnotsomethingthathashappenedhere,somethingishappening!Sothatplaysitoutandtheyallgoandbuytheirvinylandwhatnot.IwalkroundtoParliamentStreetbecausethere’saneventgoingonthereandIgetthereandthere’sabigstage,itlooksexpensive,veryniceandthere’safewbandsandallthegearisthere–butthemusicisniceandsoft,it’squaint.ItfitsthereputationofYorkbeautifullyandthecrowd?Sevenpeople.Thatisjustawaste,anutterwaste,andallitdoesisjustembellishthefactthatYorkisn’taplaceformusic.Itisn’taplaceforindependentvendors.Itisn’taplaceforthepeoplethatlivethere.
Sowhatisoursolutiontoit?Wellweneedsomeperspective.Weneedtolookatthefactthatnoteverytinylittlethingissacred.TherearesomeveryoldplacesinYorkandwearenotlookingattearingthingsdownorputtingaholeinthecitywallsoranythingstupidlikethat.It’sbeingrealisticandlookingatthingslike
27
![Page 30: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
theGuildhall.It’saveryoldbuilding;itisabeautifulbuilding.Buttheinsideofitneedstobeusedforsomethingdifferent.NowIdon’treallyhavetoomuchofaviewonthemakingitamediacentrething,Idon’tknowiftheamountofpeoplewhocomeintothecitywouldsupportthatbutrefurbishingbuildingsiswhatweneedtodobecausethebuildingsneedtostay.Theyarewhatpeoplecometosee.Buttheinsidesneedtohaveanewpurpose;theyneedtocreatenewhistory.
Ifwe’vegot1,000yearsofhistory,whereisthenext1,000yearsgoingtogo.Weneedtostartdoingsomething.Asthegentlemanovertheresaid,stoptalkinganddo!SoIdon’tseewhythereissuchareluctancetoembracesomethingthatcouldmakeYorkbetter.Itisnotaboutsacrifice.ItisabouttakingthewasteandmakingYorkbetterforeveryonewholiveshere.So,forexample,thereisnoopencreativespace.WhatitmeansisincitieslikeManchester,Newcastle,Leedstheyhavetheseplacesthatareeithercommerciallybought,rented,orCouncil-rentedwherepeoplecangoinandcreateinventionsandbusinessescangoinandtesttheirnewideasinawaythatisnotgoingtopenalisethemiftheygetitslightlywrong.Whentheyhaveamodel,theycanturnitintoafinancialmodelandthentheycantakethiscreativityandmakemoneyforYork.Butwedon’thaveone.PartlythereasonisbecauseinYorkbecauseifyouwanttorentsomewhereoutinYork,itisreally,really,really,reallyexpensive.Sounlessyouhaveamassivecommercialbacking,youhaveaproblem.Wehaveaproblemwiththat.Sowhatweneedtodoistotakeagraspofheritage.Weneedtostartmakingheritagedecisions,notheritageculture,weneedtostartmakingdecisionsandgettingsomethingdone.Thankyou.
28
![Page 31: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Victoria Hoyle, York City ArchivistVictoriaHoyleisYorkCityArchivistandaPhDstudentattheUniversityofYork,beganby
challengingourdefinitionsof‘archive’,‘IthinkthattheArchiveofYorkshouldbeallthedocuments,ephemera,memoriesandcapturedmomentsthatallowustounderstandourpastandrelatetoourpresentandenableustomakethosejustifieddecisionsabouthowwecanlivewelltogether’.CruciallyVictoriaarguedthatthiswasn’tjustaboutthecity’spast.Amoredrivenandengagedapproachtoarchivingaspartofthecity’sdemocraticlife,Victoriaargued,requiresadifferentapproachto‘cataloguing’and‘digitising’:‘Ratherthanprioritisingourdecisionsabouthowwemakethearchiveaccessiblebasedonwhatwasimportantinthepast,wethinkperhapsaboutnewpriorities,aboutwhatisimportantnow,andbeingmoreresponsive.So,forexample,ifthereisadebateinYorkatpresentoverhousingandsustainabilityandthegreenbelt,perhapsthearchiverelatingtothatmaterialshouldbeprioritisedforaccessibility?’
Iamheretotalkaboutheritagefromquiteadifferentangle,specificallyarchivalheritage.I’mnotsurehowmanypeopleherearefamiliarwithYorkCityArchive–hasanyonevisited?[About40%oftheaudienceraisetheirhands.]Well,youareaveryunusualgroup.York’sCityArchiveholdstherecordsoftheCityCouncilanditspredecessorsforthelast800yearsanditalsocollectsmaterialthatrepresentsactivecitizenshipandlifehereinYork.So,businesses,societies,organisations,familiesandindividualsandithasbeendoingthatforthelast60years.Wehaverecentlyre-openedtothepublicafterour£1.6milliongrantfromtheHeritageLotteryFundandsinceJanuarywehavehadover40,000peoplethroughthedoors.Butunfortunatelyonlyafewofthosepeoplehaveactuallyusedtheoriginalarchivalmaterial.
Iamgoingtostartbytalkingaboutwhatisanarchive?Whatisthedefinitionofanarchive?Andnormallyanarchivist’sdefinitionwillsoundextremelyformalanditisusuallyaboutdifferentiatinganarchivefromotherthings.Thischarter,oraccountbook,ormapisanarchivebecauseitisauthoritative,official,valuable,thisposter,orFacebookpost,orfamilyalbumnotanarchivebecauseitisnotthosethings.ButthedefinitionthatIwouldliketoofferyoutodayisn’tsoeasytopindown.IthinkthattheArchiveofYorkshouldbeallthedocuments,ephemera,memoriesandcapturedmomentsthatallowustounderstandourpastandrelatetoourpresentandenableustomakethosejustifieddecisionsabouthowwecanlivewelltogether.ToagreaterorlesserextentIwouldarguethatweareallarchivists.IwenttouniversityanddidaMastersDegreeinArchiveManagementbutthatreallyonlyqualifiesmetomakeacertainkindsofdecisionaboutwhatisimportant.LikeallcitiesYorkisfullofarchivalheritage.ThearchivalheritageisnotlimitedtothematerialwhichsitsinastrongroomintheArchiveonMuseumStreet.Itisinhomesandbusinesses,itisinschoolsanditisinthosededicatedcollectingarchivesliketheCityCouncilbutalsoattheBorthwick,theRailwayMuseumandtheMinster.Itisnowincreasinglyonline,itisonsocialmedia,itisontablets,itisonyourphone.Someofitwon’tlastbecauseitwillliveanditwilldiewiththepeopletowhomitmattersnow.Mostofyouherewillhavefamilyphotographalbumsanddocumentationathome,whichwepassdownthroughourfamilies.Partsofitwillbepreservedandtakencareofand,hopefully,repurposeduntilsuchasatimeasitnolongersurvivesorconnectspeopletooneanother.ThatiswhattheCityArchiveIthinkaimstodowithitsmaterial,butonacity-widescale.
Iwouldsuggestthatarchivesareessentialfordemocracy;formakingdecisions,forknowingwhoweareandwherewecamefrom.Atthemomentthearchiveisvisitedbyaverysmallnumberofresidents.Whenweconductedasurveyin2011,
29
![Page 32: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
only6%ofpeoplesurveyedhadevervisitedthearchivemorethanonceand14%didnotevenknowthatitexisted.ButinthefutureIwouldliketoseethearchiveinYorkputtoworkinlotsofdifferentways.IwouldliketoseeitusedmoreasaresourcebyCouncilofficersandalsobyresidents,toaccessinformationabouthowthecitygovernsitself.Thereisahugeanduntappeddepthofinformationinourcollectionsabouthousing,abouttransport,infrastructureandeducation.ThatinformationnotonlyhelpsustorecallourpastdecisionsandrevisitouroldreportsbutsituatescurrentdebatesincontextandIthinkthatisincrediblyvaluable.Itcouldalsosupportpeopletoinvestigatetheirowncommunities,theirhistories,theirplaces,theirspacesandthethingsthatareimportantforthem.Iwouldliketothinkthatthereisafuturewherelookingsomethingupinthearchive,visitingthearchive,isthefirststepindesigningsolutionstoproblemsandcelebratingourpastachievements.Thearchiveisabodyofknowingthatisitselfverylittleknownatthemoment.Howdowedothat?That’squiteanambition.
Therearepracticalthingsthatmustbedone.ThereisabodyofmaterialthatthecitycurrentlystewardsandExploreYourLibrariesandArchives,whichismyorganisation,doesthatontheirbehalf.Wehavetomakesurethatthatthearchiveasitexistsnowissearchable.Ithastobenavigableinlotsofways.Youhavetobeabletovisititonsiteandyouhavetobeabletovisititonline.
Cataloguing,digitising,sharing–thesearequiteoldstoriesforarchivistsandanybodyIthinkinmypositionwouldtellyouthesame.ButIwouldsuggestthatperhapsweneedtoapproachthisproblemnowinnewways.That,ratherthanprioritisingourdecisionsabouthowwemakethearchiveaccessiblebasedonwhatwasimportantinthepast,wethinkperhapsaboutnewpriorities,aboutwhatisimportantnow,andbemoreresponsive.So,forexample,ifthereisadebateinYorkatpresentoverhousingandsustainabilityandthegreenbelt,perhapsthearchiverelatingtothatmaterialshouldbeprioritisedforaccessibility?Itcan’tbeachievedusingoldwaysofworkingeither.Weneedtofindinnovativepartnersinthecityamongresidentsandvisitorsandtheuniversitiestohelpustackleit.Ithinkthatvolunteeringandfund-raisingandcrowdsourcingareallpartofthispictureandIthinkthat,finally,thedayhasgonewhenthearchivelivedinalockedroom.ThearchiveofYorkisincreasinglyoutthere.Itisdispersed.Thereisnowaythat,asCityArchivist,Icanbethesteward,norwouldIwanttobethestewardforallarchivalheritageinthecity.Iseeafuturewheretheroleofthecityarchivistisasabroker,isasafacilitator,whobringspeopletogethertoshareinarchivalheritage,whichislocal,individual,onlineandontheground.IndoingthatIwouldsuggestthatweneedtobechallengingtotraditionaldynamics.Weneedtobemorerapid;weneedtobemoredemocraticallyresponsiveandweneedtobefearless.Thankyou.
30
![Page 33: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
John Oxley, York City ArchaeologistJohnOxleyisYork’sCityArcheaologist.Johnopenedhistalkwithathoughtforthosewho
mightbelessenthusedbytourismtothecity:‘IfyouwanttoknowwhatYorkmightbelikewithouttheeconomicbenefitsthatcomealongwiththeheritageindustry,Ialwayssaytopeople,comeandhavealookatYorkonWednesdayinJanuarybecauseIthinkthatisprobablybaselevelactivitywithinthecity’.Johndrewsomeconnectionsbetweenideasofwhatheritageis–‘itisthemicro-andmacro-,thesmalllevelandthebigleveldecisionsthathavebeenmadeinthepastthatgiveusthecitythatweliveintoday’–andhowwemightimagine‘conservation’as‘adynamicprocess.Itisthewaythatwemakedecisionstodayaboutwhatwetakewithusintothefuture.’JohnsharedideasheisdevelopingatthemomentforYork’sHistoricEnvironmentRecordand,likeVictoria,heiskeentoseethisasplayinganactiveroleindemocraticengagementinthecitytoday.
Theevent’stitle‘Whathasheritagedoneforus?’Ithinkinmanywaysisadrivingconcept.WhatwehaveinYorkisthisincrediblyamazingcitythathasbeengiventousbythepeoplewhohavebeenherebeforehand.IfyouwanttoknowwhatYorkmightbelikewithouttheeconomicbenefitsthatcomealongwiththeheritageindustry,Ialwayssaytopeople,comeandhavealookatYorkonWednesdayinJanuarybecauseIthinkthatisprobablybaselevelactivitywithinthecity.Heritagefrommypointofviewis,assomebodyelsehasalreadysaidtoday,aboutinheritance.Itisaboutwhatwehavebeengiven,whatwehaveinheritedfrompastgenerationsandfrompastdecisions.AndIthinkthedecision-makingaspectisvery,veryimportantinthisbecauseitisthemicro-andmacro-,thesmalllevel,thebigleveldecisionsthathavebeenmadeinthepastthatgiveusthecitythatweliveintoday.Nowthatdecision-makingprocesstodayisgenerallylodgedwithinplanningandwithinplanningthereisthisareacalled‘conservation’.Andconservationcanbeseenasbeingafairlynegativeprocess.Iamsurealotofpeopleseeconservationasanegativeprocess.
Sohowdoesconservationfitintothisconceptofheritage?Well,forme,conservationisadynamicprocess.Itisthewaythatwemakedecisionstodayaboutwhatwetakewithusintothefuture.Soconservationisaboutthatdecision-makingprocess.Itisaboutcreatingthatnext1,000yearsasMichaelwassaying.Whatdowetakeforward?Whatdowemakethecity?And,asanarchaeologist,Iamoftenaskedwheredoesarchaeologybegin?Whatisarchaeological?Wellformeeverythingisarchaeologicalbecauseeverythingisinthepast.Wherewearenowisthispointintimeandsowhatwe’vedonecomingtothisplacetoday,theeventsthatwe’vegonethrough,thethingsthatarediscarded,formsomethingthatwecanstudy,wecanappreciateandwecanrecordandwecanuse.Historybeginsnow.Soconservationisthissortofdynamicwayofmakingdecisionsaboutwhatwewantthefuturetobe.Nowinthatprocessthekeyisinformation.Information,knowledgeispowerandifyouhavetherightinformationavailable,ifyouhaveaccesstotheinformation,thenthatcanassistyouinmakingdecisions.Itempowersyouasanindividual,asabodyandyoucanthentakeparteffectivelyinthatdecision-makingprocess.Howdoyougetyourhandsonthatinformation?WellmyparticularareaofconcernisarchaeologyandIwanttomentiontodayadatabase,theHistoricEnvironmentRecord.NowtheHistoricEnvironmentRecordtodayisaveryimpoverisheddatabase.MyselfandmycolleagueClairearegoingthroughaprocessoflookingathowwecanimprovethatdatasetandhowwecanmakeitmoreaccessible.Sowearestartingaprocessoflookingbackatworkwe’vedonewithintheCouncilbutalsowantingtostartconversationswiththepeoplearoundthetables,inthisroomandoutsideabouthowthisHistoricEnvironmentRecordmighttake
31
![Page 34: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
advantage,mightinclude,mightreferto,mightbringforward,othersetsofinformationthatwillmakethatamoreauthoritative,amoreusefulsetofdata.Butmoreimportantly,makeitavailableinawaythatmakessensetoawholerangeofaudiencesouttheresothepeoplecanusethatinformationinthewayinwhichtheywanttouseit.Anditverymuchmakesmefeel,havinglistenedtoVictoriaspeak,thatperhapsweneedtogoandworkwithVictoria.AndinWorcestershiretheHistoricEnvironmentRecordispartofthearchiveserviceandthereisastrongargumenttosaythatitisjustanotherarchiveandthereforebureaucraticallyitshouldberelocatedwithinthearchiveservice.SoweareworkingforthenextcoupleofmonthstoproduceaproposalfortheHistoricEnvironmentRecordwithinthecity.Weneedtotalktopeopleinthisroomandtherewillbealittlequestionnairegoingaround,whichIwouldgratefullyappreciateifyoucouldalljusttickthedifferentelementsinitsoyoucantelluswhatyourareasofinterestandconcernare.WhatwewanttomovetowardsisexactlywhatVictoriawastalkingabout,whichishowdoweempowerpeopletomakedecisionsortoengageinthedemocraticprocessmoreeffectivelybecauseyoucanonlydothatreallyifyouhavetheinformationthatallowsyoutoengageeffectivelyinthatprocess.
AndIthinkitalsotakesustoaveryinterestingcontributionthatLisafromYorkStoriesmade[inherpieceabove].Whereshesaysthatthechallengeforthefutureistomakesurethatthelessvisibleheritageandthequietervoicesarerecognisedandrecorded.Andthatalsosaidthatthelessvisibleheritageandthequietervoicesareabletousetheinformationtomakethecaseforwhateveritisthattheyareinterestedinandincorporatedandembeddedintofuturedecisions.So,forme,theHistoricEnvironmentRecordisaprettyturgidtechnicalplacetoworkbutthepotentialitofferseverybodysatinthisroom,everybodyinYork,theopportunitytobeabletopullinformationforwardthatallowsthemtosay,thisiswhyweshouldn’tbeknockingdownReynard’sGarage;thisiswhyJohnOxleyhasgotitcompletelywrongattheTheatreRoyalandtheyshouldn’tbedoingwhattheyaredoingthere.ThisiswhyweshouldbelookingatthehistoryofculturalactivityinYorkoverthepasttenyearsandlookingatwhatweweredoingbackinthe90sandhowthathascontributedtowherewearetodayandhowthatmighttakeusforwardintoamuchmoreexcitingfuturethanperhapsmightbethecaseotherwise.Sothat’saverystrangewaytotalkaboutthisideathatIwantyoualltohelpmeputtogetheranewHistoricEnvironmentRecordforthecity–butIwantedtosituatethatexercisewithinthisdecision-makingprocessandtheconceptofinformationempoweringpeopleandencouragingpeopletoengageinthatdemocraticprocess.
32
![Page 35: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Helen Weinstein, Director, Historyworks HelenWeinstein,Director,HistoryworksHelenWeinsteinisaHistoryProfessorandthe
DirectorofHistoryworkswhichsupportsthepracticeandtheoryofPublicHistoryintheUKbypromotingeducationprogrammesandpartnershipsandbycollaboratingwithpartnerstodevelopmediainterpretation.Helen’stalkfocusedonherrecentworkonClifford’sTowerandtheEyeofYorkwhichcameaboutaftershemovedtoYorktenyearsago.Shebecame‘Jewishinapublicway’asshebegantodealwiththelegacyofthe12thcenturypogrom.ThisisacomplicatedpasttonavigatebecausetheJewishcommunitywaskilledatthesiteofClifford’sToweron16thMarch1190andthereislittleinterpretationpubliclyavailable.EnglishHeritageisnow‘onajourneytopresentClifford’sTowerinamuchmorelayeredway’.Helenhasbeenworkingtobringstakeholderstogether,includingYorkMuseumsTrust,YorkCivicTrust,EnglishHeritage,theJewishcommunitiesinandaroundYork,andtheCityArchaeologist‘torethinkthesite’.Withherbackgroundintelevision,filmmakinganddigitalcontent,Helenhasalsohighlightedthevalueof‘digital’technologyinhelpingustellmorecomplexstoriesaboutYork‘sothatmultiplevoices,multiplelayersofresourcesandmultiplematerialscanbelodgedthere’.
Thankyouverymuchforinvitingme.IhavehadaninterestingjourneyinYork,atenyearstoryfrom2005to2015.DuringthisdecadeYorkhasgonefromaplaceofstasis,whereIfeltitwasquitehardtohaveavoiceinheritagedecision-making,toapositiontodaywhentherereallyisanopportunitytobeheard,formultiplevoicestobeconsultedandanewwayforwarddevelopedformoreinclusivepolicymaking.TheheritageprojectIhavebeenmostcloselyidentifiedwithinYorkisapublicengagementprojectthatIbeganasan‘out-Jew’attheUniversityofYork.Thishadn’tbeensomethingI’dencounteredintheworkplacebefore–aboutbeingJewishasanhistorianinapublicway.ButwhenIarrivedatYorktobeaHistoryProfessor,therewerehardlyanyseniorJewishacademicsonthecampus.ItseemedexpectedthatIwouldparticipateinaleadershiproleatpublicevents-particularlybygivingpublicreadingsandspeakingatcivicevents,forexampleatHolocaustMemorialDay.TherewasnoidentifiableJewishcommunityinYorkduringtheseyears.Therewasnosynagogueeither,althoughindividualJewswhodidn’ttraveltonearbyLeedsorKnaresborough,didgatherforthemajorJewishholidays.Recently,aliberalcongregationhasbeenfounded,meetingregularlyintheQuakerMeetingHouseatFriargate.Buttenyearsago,ourmodestaimwastomarkourJewishidentitypubliclybycommemoratingboththepogromatClifford’sTowerandHolocaustMemorialDay.Outofthis,anidentifiablegroupdevelopedwhichcouldstarttohaveourvoicesheardwithintheciviclandscapeofYork.
Clifford’sToweristhesiteofthe1190pogromagainstYork’sJewishpopulationandhasledtoYorkhavingaverynegativereputationamongsttheJewishcommunityworldwide.Credit:RichardBrigham
33
![Page 36: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
AfterIarrivedattheUniversitymynewlinemanager,theHeadofHistorydidnotsupportmyinvolvement.HefeltthatIwassteppingoutsidemyareaofexpertiseandthatIshouldn’tbeworkingonthecommemorationandtheinterpretationofClifford’sTower.IhadtodistancemyselffromthisviewandinsteadthinkaboutwhatmyroleshouldbeattheUniversityofYork.IwasaProfessorwhohappenedtobeaJew,andIwasalsoaPublicHistorianandaDirectorofTheInstituteforthePublicUnderstandingofthePast.Infact,asanacademic,Ithoughtmyrolewasnotonlytostudythepublicengagementofthepast,butalsotoenableeverybodyinYorktofeelthattheyhadavoiceintheinterpretationoftheirheritageandthattheyalsohadvalidexpertisetoofferheritagepractitionersandpolicymakers,inexactlythemannerthatisbeingdiscussedinthisroom.Weallhaveexpertisethatwecanbringtothiskindofquestion.AndfromtheJewishcommunity’spointofview,therewasn’tanychoice.SomethinghadtobedonewhichinvolvedmyworkingwiththeJewishcommunity.IteamedupwiththeCityArchaeologist,JohnOxley,toleadwalksonthehistoryofClifford’sTower.WesoughttoinspireconversationandconfidenceforthepublicandtheJewishcommunityinparticulartohandlethecomplexinterpretationsofthe1190massacreand,atthesametime,developanarrativefromfirstsettlementtothepresentday.Hundredsattendedthewalks.AsDirectoroftheInstituteIinvitedheritagepractitionerstoworkwithmeandwestartedtorediscoverthecomplicatedpastofClifford’sTowermanagementandarchaeologicalrecord,andalsoitsresearchhistoryandinterpretationoverthetwentiethcentury.MyconversationswithEnglishHeritagewerepositive.Akeymomentcamewhenwerealisedthatthedaffodilsonthemoundhavesixpetalsonthem.ThesesixpetalsrepresenttheStarofDavid.EnglishHeritagehadforgottenthesignificancethatthosedaffodilsonthatmound–themoundthatisshownonallthoseprettypostcardpicturesrepresent.Theyareaspecialkindofdaffodil.TheyweredonatedbytheAmericanJewishFoundation,aftermanyyearsofcampaigning,torepresenttheStarofDavid.TheywereactuallydevelopedtoflowerearlierthananyofthetraditionaldaffodilssurroundingYork’swalls,inorderthattheyareinbloomwhenthemassacreiscommemoratedonthe16thMarch.ItwasanexampleofourengagementwithEnglishHeritage,tohelpthemstartthinkingabouthowwecouldrecoverandre-considerallaspectsofthehistoryoftheTower.
Daffodils,CliffordTower,‘donatedbytheAmericanJewishFoundation,aftermanyyearsofcampaigning,torepresenttheStarofDavidandtoflowerearlierthananyofthenormaltraditionalmounddaffodils’.Credit:Chrisse_MacviaFlickr.CreativeCommonsAttributionShareAlike]
34
![Page 37: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Beforeourrecentgatheringstoshareknowledgeandexpertise,EnglishHeritagewaspresentingthesiteintwoprimaryways:aplacethatwasaboutcastlesandknightswithanicepictureofacastleatthetopofthestepsandtheplacewhereyoucouldgetsomeofthebestviewsofYork.ThismeantthatfortheJewishcommunitythesitewasaplacewellservedbycommemorationthoughnotbyinterpretation.Butoncewestartedtoworktogether,we’veorganizedlearningdaysforEnglishHeritagepractitionerstolearnfromthecommunity,shareexpertiseanddevelopunderstanding.Forreportsofthelearningdays,goto:
http://historyworks.tv/projects/2014/11/02/york-castle-project/
Ashistorianswhatdowedo?Oneofourtaskswastoconsiderhowbesttopresentastoryfamiliarinheadlineform-medievalJewsweremassacredinYork.AndtheobviouspartnersformetostartworkingwithwereYorkCityCouncilandYorkMuseumsTrust(YMT).TheCastleMuseumispartofthewidercomplexoftheCastlefortificationwhichincludesClifford’sTower,soalthoughthemuseumhasnoJewishobjects,YMTisinvolved.IthasactivelysupportedacommunityprojecttoallowamassaudiencetoengagewiththeJewishHistoryofYork.ThisissomethingwehavedonetogetherinpartnershipwiththeCityArchaeologist,JohnOxley.Istartedbringinguniversitystudentsandacademicstotheprojecttoprovideadigitalresourcethattranslatedallthecurrentresearchintoaneasyto-accessaudiotrail.WhatwecameupwithwasastorythatstartedtolayertheJewishexperienceaswell.BecauseitcanbedifficultifyouareaJewinYork.Youareaskedallthetime,whatisitliketolivehere?Isn’titawful,thatalltheJewsweremassacredin1190?ManyinternationalJewsImethadheardtherewasa‘cherem’(aprohibition)thatyoushouldn’tactuallyresideinYork,stayovernightinYorkoreatinYork,becauseofthemassacre.Thereweresomanymythsaroundthatwehadtoinvestigatefurther.Icontactednumerousinternationalrabbinicalscholarstoprovideguidanceifnotanswersabouttheseclaims.WebeganbyconductingwalkingtoursaroundYorkwiththeJewishcommunityfromLeeds,fromMiddleborough,fromHalifax.Wefoundoutmoreanddiscoveredthisstorytogether,especiallyabouttheformerJewishcongregationthatmetaboveacarpenter’sshoponAldwarkbetweenabout1890and1978.WewereabletobringthehistoryoftheJewishcommunitiesofYorkintothemodernage,tellingthestoryofJewsreturningtoYorkinthe19thand20thcenturiesandtheimpactoftheUniversityindrawingbackJewstoliveinYorkbothasanemployerandasanattractiveplaceoflearningforstudents.Ifyouwouldliketoaccessthefreeguidecalled“TheYorkJewishHistoryTrail”youcanfinditasanupdatedaudioguide(withscriptsinpdf)byclickingonthesectionsonaudiboomanddownloadingthemapandmaterialshere:
http://historyworks.tv/projects/2014/11/02/york-castle-project/#audiobooscripts-york-jewish-history-trail-by-historyworks
It’sbeenfascinatingtohelpsetupacommunityprojectbutalsotobeinthefantasticsituationofbeingabletoreclaimthishistorywithinEnglishHeritageaswell.SoEnglishHeritagearenowonajourneyofparticipatorylearningwiththeJewishcommunity.WeareallbetterequippedtoconsiderClifford’sTowerinamuchmorelayeredway.Inthinkingaboutthepast,youhavetotravelintwodirectionsatthesametime.Sometimestheyconverge;sometimestheydonot.First,makingsureit’snotonlythetraumaof1190thatisfocusedon,becausethatactuallymakessomeJewsinYorkfeelveryuncomfortable.Butsecondly,it’s
35
![Page 38: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
beenimportanttotellthatstorywithinalargernarrative.Because,forexample,theQuakersofYorkinthelate1930sraisedmoneyforJews,particularlyyoungpeoplewhodidn’thaveafamilyaffiliationorwhoweretoooldtocomeonKindertransport.TheirfundingwasusedtosponsoryoungJewishpeoplewhowerehostedbyYorkfamilies.SomeofthosechildrenarealiveinYorktoday;thoseyoungpeoplearenowintheir80sand90s.ManyofthembecameQuakersorAnglicans.Anditisrightthattheyhaveaplacewheretheycannowtelltheirstory.TheotherthingthathasbeenreallyimportantisfortheJewishcommunitytothinkofthewholehistoryofClifford’sTowerwithinaCastlecomplex,andnotsolelyasaplacewhereJewsweremurdered.
On16thMarch1190thatstonebuildingwasnotthere.Itwasatimberstructure.ManyJewsfromYorkshireandnationallyandinternationallyareunawareofthesebasicfactsthatClifford’sTowerhasbeenmodifiedorrebuiltonnumerousoccasions.Theirlearningjourneyneedstobetheotherwaytoo,sothattheyhaveabroaderhistoricalunderstandingoftheotherswhohavediedaroundthatsiteandwhy.Forexample,thereissignificantevidenceofRomanburialsfromarchaeologicalexcavations–skeletons,sarcophagi,burialobjects–showingthattheCastleareawaspreviouslythesiteofaRomancemetery.Moreover,themoundandtowerisalsouniquehistoricallybecausetheCastlefortificationwasusedbytheCrowntogovernthenorthandhasbeenthesiteofviolenceanddeathovermanycenturies.Notmanyknowthatitwasusedforpoliticalrepressionafterthemedievalperiod.Forexample,RobertAskewashungfromacagetodieapainfultraitor’sdeathin1537forhisroleintherevoltcalled‘ThePilgrimageofGrace’.Lateron,notoriously,itwasthesitewherethePeterlooprotestorswereincarceratedafterthemassacreatStGeorge’sfieldsinManchesterin1816,andbeforethat17Ludditeactivistswerebroughttobeexecutedin1813.Soifarchaeologistsfindabody,itisnotnecessarilyaJewishbody.Andithasbeenrevelatoryinthinkingaboutheritageissuestolearnthesethingstogether.SoIhavefoundthejourneyofbeingaheritagepractitioner,andIguess,insomewaysaheritageleader,intheUniversityquitetrickytonavigate.IthasbeenavaluablelearningexperiencetoworkwithEnglishHeritageandhelpthemcollaboratewiththestakeholders,particularlyintheJewishcommunity,tosharesomeofthegoodpracticeswehaveinYorkofsharingknowledgeandideasacrosssectors.AndIthinkthatisoneofthepointsIwanttounderline.Whatwehavelearned,asallthegroupshavecometogetherforre-thinkingClifford’sTowersite,isthatwearedealingwithalayeredhistoryandweneedtomakespaceformultiplevoices.Weneedtohaveourconversationsaboutplanninginanholisticway.Weneedalwaystobeworkinginpartnership.Weneedtotryandkeeptheseconversationsopenandcollaborativesothatridiculousdecisionsmadeinignorancethatprovokecampaigns.
Inmyview,thebestwaylearningcanbeeasilysharedistoputinformationonthenet.Imeanisn’ttheWebfantastic?Itallowsyoutoshare,immediately,whateveryouhavelearnt.Noonecansaynowthattheydon’tknowaboutthemultipleburialsaroundthesitebecausewe’veproducedlotsofdocumentation,lotsofbite-sizethumbnailhistories,aswellasdeeperhistoricalreports.ThesamewithHelenGraham’swork,itisveryeasynowtoinformtheCouncilandbecontinuallylearningtogether.Assomeonesaidearlier,knowledgegivesacertainpowerhere.Somywayforward,comingfromthisexperience,isthatacademicexpertisecanbeveryuseful.Itcanbeharnessedwithinthiskindoflearningaboutdifficultheritage,butunlessitistranslated,unlesstheacademicscanbeguidedintonewwaysofworking,sotheyareworkingwiththecommunity
36
![Page 39: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
insteadoftalkingatthecommunity,itisnoteasy,particularlyinasmallcitylikeYorktochangethedynamic.ButIthinkwehavetoworkcontinuallyatthat.AtthelearningdaysIorganizedinJanuary2015aboutthehistoriesofClifford’sTower,GrahamBellsaidthattheissuewiththeareaseemstobeoneofaspaceleftoverafterparkingratherthantheusualproblemofspaceleftoverafterplanning.Wehavebeenabletobringstakeholderstogether,YorkMuseumsTrust,YorkCivicTrust,EnglishHeritageandalsotheCityArchaeologist,torethinkthesite.AndIamveryheartenedthattherediscussionshavebeguntoconsiderwhethertherecouldbeanundergroundcarpark.Unfortunatelytheexistingcarparkisamillion-poundgeneratorfortheCouncil;it’salotofmoneyfromaverysmallspacebutit’sahorriblespace-difficulttowalkacross,unsightlyanddeeplyunattractive.Ifwecanbuildaconsensusthatacarparkisnotappropriatebetweenthesedifferentcivicsites,wouldn’titbewonderfulifitwasagreenarea;ifitwasaplacewhereyoungpeoplecouldhaveahubandhavepublicartanddifferenteventsandactivitiesforcommunitiesinsteadofbeinganeye-soreinthedaytimeandaplaceforanti-social-behaviouratnight?Itcouldbecomeareallyvibrantplaceofpleasureandleisureandlearning.
Insum,recentyearshaveseenintensediscussionsabouttheredevelopmentoftheYorkCastlesite.Thepossibilityofimprovingthesitewouldencompasstheareaoccupiedbythecarpark,Clifford’sTower,theEye-of-York,TowerStreet,andtheRiverFoss.Ifdiscussionscancontinueacrosssectorswiththepublicinvolvedonanequitablebasis,thereisafantasticopportunitytoestablishtheareaasapublicandcivicspace,remainingfaithfultothecurrentopen-airnatureofthesiteanditshistorictraditions.WhatwehavelearntwiththejourneyoftheJewishcommunityisthatthereisathirstforknowledgeaboutuncomfortable
37
ThecontroversialcarparknearClifford’sTower.CreditIanTempest
![Page 40: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
paststobepresentedhoweverdifficulttheywere.Moreover,iftheYorkCastleareacanbelandscapedasaconnectedheritagesite,thehistoryofjusticeandpoweroverthecenturieswillbeintroducedtothisandfuturegenerations.IbelievethattheUNESCOwinfortheArtsandMediaHubisagreatopportunity.Also,YorkisoneoftheonlyplacesintheUKthathasWi-FiofferedfreelyinthecentreoftheCity.Thismeanswecannowhaveavirtualspacewheresomuchofthelearningaboutthesitecanbeshared.AsJohnOxleywastalking,Iwasre-rememberingagreatpieceofpractice,Bristol’s‘KnowYourPlace’project.BristolCityCouncilstartedonthejourneyofsharingtheirheritageandplanningresourcesalongtimeago,withalltheirmaps,alltheirarchivesandthekindofworkthatyouguysaredoingatYork‘PastandPresent’pinnedontoawholewebstructuretoshareknowledgewithinthecity.YoungpeopleinBristolaredoingamazingartworkaroundheritage,challengingpeopletothinkabouttheheritagespaces.Thiscommunicationispossiblebecausetheyhavemadeaviablecivicspacealongtheharbour,alongsidethevirtualspaceof‘KnowYourPlace’.WecouldreplicatethatideaaroundtheYorkCastlearea.And,mostimportantly,reallyusethedigitalopportunitiesavailablenowsothatmultiplevoices,multiplelayersofresources,multiplematerialscanbelodgedthere.WhenIfirstarrivedherein2005,therewasthisstaticpicture,whichiswhatClifford’sTowerkindofsymbolisedtomethen,akindofuninformative,unimaginativefixednarrativethatdidn’ttellyouverymuchabouttheCityofYorkeitherinthetouristguidesorontheexplanatorypanels.Nowanauthoritativethumbnailvoicecanbereplacedbyusingthewebandusingdigitalplatforms.Therecanbeasharedcollectivesitelike‘KnowYourPlace’sothatYorkcanhaveaspaceforknowledgesharingandmultiplevoices,freelyavailableonsiteattheswipeofasmartphoneortablet.Thisfuturecanbeoneofadvocacyandactivism,ratherthanstarchyheritagethatcanonlyrepeatthekindofstoriesthatfeelsafe.
Yorkmaybeaveryoldcity,butembracingnewtechnologiesandthinkingimaginativelyabouthowbesttorevealandexplainitsrichandvariedhistorycanonlyenhanceitsstatusasa‘must-visit’touristattractionandaddanotherlayertothelevelofcivicpridefeltbymostofitsinhabitants.
38
![Page 41: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Paul Furness, author York: A Walk on the Wild SidePaulFurnessisawriterandradicalhistorianofYorkandLeedsandisauthorofYork:AWalk
ontheWildSide(2014).Paulwasinvolvedinthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisionsbemade?’researchprojectandrananumberofhistorywalksfortheYork:LivingwithHistorystrandoftheproject.Paulwasn’tabletoattendtheeventbuthascontributedhisreflectionsofthequestion‘whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’
There’snofutureinnostalgia.......
WhenBloodaxe,theimportant–andNorthern–poetrypublisherissuedHomeandAwaybySteveEllisin1984,itincludedapoemcalled‘IntheCityArtGallery,York’which,whenElliswasgrowingupinthecity,wasfreeforhim–andthemotherswithprams,romancingschoolkidsandvisitingfamilieswhopopulatehispoem–tovisit.Notsonow.WhenYorkMuseumsTrustwassetupbytheCouncilin2002,thenewChiefExecutivetoldapackedmeetingofFriendsofYorkArtGallerythat‘artshouldbefree’.13yearslateritdescribeditselfasa‘culturalbusiness’andcost£7.50togetin–excluding,atonestroke,thelikesofnotjustEllisbutHarlandMiller,too.ThesonofaRowntree’schocolateworker,MillerisnotrepresentedintheYorkcollectiondespitebeingouronlyrepresentativeoftheYoungBritishArtiststobeintheTateandmajoroverseasgalleries–theDutchlovehim.HavingworkedasamodelforSamTaylorWood(betterknownthesedaysasthedirectorof50ShadesofGrey),hisbig,brashcanvassesofnortherntownsbasedonthefrontcoversofoldPenguinbooksinclude,ofcourse,onetohishometown–‘York,SoGoodtheyNameditOnce’.Butthisneglectishardlysurprisingfromatownthatletsthebirthplace–theoldLawrenceStreetWorkingMen’sClub–ofanimportant19thcartist,HenryScottTuke,falltorackandruin.
York:AWalkontheWildSide,PaulFurnessdevelopedthispublicationaspartofthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisionsbemade?’researchproject.
39
![Page 42: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
DowntheroadfromhereistheMeccaBingoClubonFishergatewhosecarparksitsonthesiteoftheRialtocinema,anArtDecogemwhichwasranbythefatherofJohnBarry–whowrotemostoftheJamesBondthemetunesaswellas‘MidnightCowboy’.TheBeatles,theRollingStonesandLouisArmstrongallplayedhere.Itwasdemolished,tomakewayforacarpark,in2003-whichwasjustasneedlessasthedestructionoftheJohnBullpubonLayerthorpebackin1994togiveacarsalesshowroomaforecourt.Yearslater,EnglishHeritageownedupandsaidsorry–thiswas,indeed,abuildingwhichshouldhavebeensaved.
JohnBullPub,controversiallydemolishedin1994‘tomakewayforacarsalesforecourt’Credit:YorkExplore
WillthesameapologybegiveninhindsightafterReynard’sGarageonPiccadillygoestothatgreatlandfillintheskysometimesoon?HavingturneddownnumerousrequestsfromtheYorkshireAirMuseumtoturnthisformeraircraftfactory,wherethenovelistNevilShuteworked,intoacitycentremoneyspinner,thewreckersballsarereadytoswingasItype.Addtothistheslowerosionofthealleysandsnickets–theNormanHouseoffStonegateandtheoneatthesideofAllSaints,NorthStreet,bothspringtomind–whicharefastbecominggatedcommunities,thentimestheyareindeedachanging.
StepinArtsCouncilfunding.WhenYorkCouncilrespondedtotheclarioncallstorevampthesalaciousnighttimeeconomy,itdidsobykickstartinganartsfestivalcalledVespertine,aLatinwordthatYorkPresswasobligedtotranslate(andtherebybecominginstantlyelitist)foritsreaders,informingthemitwassomethingwhichhappenedafterdark.Aneventthathasn’tyetquitedeliveredtheculturalgoods,itwaskickedintothegrassbytheunderfundedanddislikedbysomeArtsBargeprojectandthejohnnycomelatelyGreatYorkshireFringe,setupinParliamentStreetbyaYorkieworkingtheWestEndasaoneofftaster.Soitsbacktothebarrenlandscapeof‘culturalbusiness’offilmedopera(nowherebigenoughtoputtherealthingoninYork)andwomendressingasskivviesattheTreasure’sHouseorsallowyouthsasbloodsoakedvictimsofmedievaltortureattheYorkDungeon.Infact,ifyouhaveapassionfordressingupassomeonerippedlimbfromlimbinadubiouspastandtellingporkiestovisitorsyoucanmakeafortuneinYork-whichiswhytheLondontouristshopsandbusesadvertising‘LondonNecropolisGhostTours’areturningupeverywhereover200milesfromwheretheyshouldbe!‘Culturalbusiness’sitsonideologicalquicksandand,whileRomansandVikingsruletheroostinYork,therestofthe2000yearoldstoryofYorkshirehumanitygetssidelinedandstultifiedthroughatoxicmixtureofbothignoranceandneglect.Goneisthefactthathistoryismadeinthehereandnowthatwehavetolookaftertodayforsomeoneelse’stomorrow.
TheNormanHouse,justoffStonegate.Sometimesentryisnowpreventedwithashutgate.Credit:IanTempest
40
![Page 43: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
Shafted,too,istherichnessofcharacterthatmadeYorkwhatitwasbutcannolongergetintoitsArtGallerywithoutdiggingdeepandforkingout.
Thesadrealityofculturalbusinessisthatonlythesecondratesells.AgoodexampleofthisisDavidStarkeyappearingatthelastYorkLiteratureFestivalwhilethelocallybornSteveEllishasneverreador,evenmoredepressing,thatJackMapanje,theMalawibornpoetwhocametoYorkasarefugeeandhaslivedhereforover20years,hasnotbeenaskedtoreadalso.ThereisafrustratingfeelingthatsomethinghasgoneawryinYork,thatawrongturningtakensometimeagohasledusuptheyellowbrickroadtonowhere–thatmindlessplacewheremediocrityandthestatusquoarecelebratedastimestandsstill(quiteliterally,inthecaseofYork,asmanyofthehistoricclocksinthecitystreetsnolongerwork!).
Sowhat’stobedone?Forastartoffwecanownuptoourfailures–lookingatwhatYorkhasn’tgotinsteadoftubthumpingallthetimeaboutwhatitHASgotwillimprovetheplacenoend.I’mremindedof,sometimeagonow,whentheBelgiancityofBrugesdecideditwasgettingtoofrumpyforitsowngoodanddecidedtoupitstouristofferbyusingculturenotasabusinessbutasacreativewaytobringthetown(whichisnotsounlikeYork)intomoderntimes.Thecouncilthendecidedtocommissionanumberofwellknowncontemporaryartiststodesignarangeofqualitysouvenirswhichsoldlikehotcakesandbroughtvisitorsflocking.AnotherexampleofthisnewfoundculturalconfidencecamewhenplaywrightMartinMcDonaghwasaskedtowritethescriptforInBruges-oneoftoday’scultfilms.ImaginethatinYork!Sadly,no.Thecityneedsitseyesprisedwideopenbyitsownpastinordertoinvigorateitsfuture.It’seasilydone.ItalsoneedstoloosenupandputmusicclubslikeFibbersbackcentrestagewheretheybelong(itmovedfromthemainstreetofStonebowtothebackstreetofToftGreen)andgiveeventslikeYorkPrideprominenceinthecitycentreinsteadofhidingitawayatthebackendoftheKnavesmire.Yorkneedstotakealong,hardstareatitself.Onlythencanitcastofitsfancydressandleapintotherealworldofcontemporaryculture.PuttingaheftypricetagonashedloadofcrockeryintheArtGallerywhilesellingracistgolliwogsinShamblesgiftshopsisnotgoingtodoit.Abraverapproachisneededinordertomoveforward.Afterall,thereisnofutureinnostalgia.
AlldressedupasVikings,crucialpartoftheeducativefunctionofYork’sarcheologyor‘fancydress’?Credit:BarryPitcher
41
![Page 44: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
Kit Heyam, LGBT History Month
KitHeyamisOutreachCoordinatorforYorkLGBTHistoryMonth.KitworkedwithHelenandYork’sAlternativeHistorytoputontheRainbowPlaqueseventinFebruary2015.The‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventwasheldonthesametimeasYorkPride,Kithasinsteadcontributedsomereflectionsontheevent’squestion.
WhenyouthinkaboutYork’sheritage,doyouseeLGBTstories?Ifyourfirstencounterwiththeheritageofthiscityisthestorymarketedbythetourismindustryandpackagedasaunifiedimpressionbypopularunderstanding,theanswerisalmostcertainlyno.ThosewiththemostpowertoshapeimpressionsofYork’shistory–thosewhoworkintourism,marketing,museums–havelargelyfocusedonitscivicandstrategicimportanceratherthanontheidentitiesofthepeoplewhoshapedandpopulatedthecity.Whilesomeorganisationsaremakingaconcertedefforttoshiftthisfocus–notablytheCastleMuseum(whoareactivelyexpandingtheirLGBT-relatedcollections)andYorkExplore(whoarepursuingtheideaofanLGBTarchive)–othersstill,implicitlyorexplicitly,perceiveLGBThistorytobeirrelevanttotheheritagestorytheywanttotell.
OneofthecardboardplaquesdevelopedfortheLGBTHistoryMonthRainbowPlaquesday.
Inpart,thisrelativeabsenceofLGBTstoriesfromwhatweinstinctivelyconsidertobe‘York’sheritage’reflectsageneralexclusionofmarginalisedgroups.Itisilluminating,forexample,tocompareYorktoManchester,whosemainstreamheritagestorydoesincluderadicalpoliticalmovements(Chartism,thePeterloomassacre)aswellasLGBThistory(throughManchester’searlyroleasacentreofnortherngaylife).Bycontrast,York’spresentationofitsheritagedoesnotfocusonordinaryworkingpeople;thisgapcouldpotentiallybefilledbytheNationalRailwayMuseum,butitcurrentlylackssubstantialYork-specificinterpretation.However,italsoreflectsawiderproblemfacingproponentsofLGBThistoryineverycity:bymodernconceptionsatleast,‘LGBT’isnotsomethingpeopledo,butsomethingtheyare.Actionsmakehistorybooks;identitiesmaybeincludedasephemeralcontext,butarerarelyforegroundedasintegral.
AsYorkLGBTHistoryMonth,ouraimisthereforenotjusttohighlightpastactionsthatrelatetoLGBTactivismorthedirectexpressionofLGBTidentities,buttoreframethewritingofhistoryasanexercisethatcustomarilyandnecessarilyrecordsthewholeselvesofhistoricalfigures.Doingthis
KitputsupaplaqueonRainbowPlaquesdayinFebruary2015.
42
![Page 45: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
providesavaluableindicationofcontinuityformarginalisedgroupswhosehistoryandexistencehaspreviouslybeendeniedorerased,andanimportantacknowledgementthatactionsarerarelyentirelydivisiblefromtheidentitiesofthosewhoaccomplishthem.It’seasytoarguethatperformativeLGBT-relatedacts,suchasthe1834weddingofAnneListerandAnnWalkeratHolyTrinityChurchonGoodramgate,shouldbeincludedintheYorkguidebooks;it’sharder,butnolessimportant,tofightforthementionofW.H.Auden’ssexualorientationasamatterofcoursewhenrecordingthefacthewasborninahouseonBootham.FocusingonlyonLGBThistoryasitismanifestedthrougheventscontributestoitsghettoization:totheperceptionofitasaseparatestrandofhistory,ratherthanasanaspectofalltheotherstrands(politicalhistory,literaryhistory,militaryhistory).Itiscrucial,too,toensurethatlesspositiveaspectsofYork’sLGBThistoryareincorporatedintoYork’sstoryalongsidemilestonesofequality.WhenlookingbackatthepeopleimprisonedinwhatisnowtheCastleMuseum,wemustrememberthepeopleimprisonedthereforsodomy;whenlookingbackatthepsychiatrichospitalsatNaburn,CliftonParkandBootham,wemustrememberthosetreatedthereforidentitiesoractsnotacceptedbytheirsocieties.Toooften,whenLGBThistoryisembraced,itbecomesaselectionofcelebratorymilestonesonalinearprogressiontowardsfulltoleranceandequality;whileitisimportanttocelebrateourpast,itisequallyimportant(whenrecordingthehistoryofastill-relevantissue)tobearwitnesstopastinjusticeandtragedy.
Howmightallthisbeachieved?Itrequirestheinvolvementofacross-sectionofheritageorganisations–including,butnotlimitedto,thosenebulousandinaccessibletourismbodies.ItrequiresYork’sLGBTstoriestobeconsistentlymadevisible,thuspromptingtheremembranceandrecognitionofothers.Itrequires,too,encouragingpeopletowidentheirconceptionof‘history’.YorkLGBTHistoryMonthhaspromotedafocusonpersonalhistories–our‘rainbowplaques’event,co-organisedwiththisresearchproject,wasanexampleofthis,aswastheCastleMuseum’scallforobjectsduringLGBTHistoryMonth2015–andwearekeenthatthisshouldcontinue.Mostofall,itrequiresawillingnessfromallpartiesnottodismissLGBThistoryasirrelevant,buttothinkinsteadaboutthewaysinwhichitmightberelevant.Ifwecontinuetoconceiveofhistoryasastreamofevents,weareindangeroferasingthepeople–andtheidentities–thatmadethoseeventshappen.
43
![Page 46: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
Lisa Pickering, York StoriesLisa,actingasaresidentjournalistfortheevent,wrotesoonafterherreflectionsontheevent
Myinitialimpression,onseeingthenumberofpeopleattendingtheevent,wassurpriseathowmanypeoplecaredaboutthecity’sheritageenoughtospendaSaturdayafternoondiscussingit.Ishouldknowthisofcourse,butIspendalotofmytimeengagingwithheritage-relatedissueswhilesittingatacomputerinaroomonmyown.
Thespeakersanddiscussionmademethinkmoreaboutthemanyperspectivesonwhat‘ourheritage’mightbe.There’sclearlysharedheritage,andageneralacceptancethatcertainhistoricbuildingsareveryobviously‘ourheritage’.ButIwassurprisedtootoseehowmanypeoplementionedtheReynard’sgarage/Airspeedbuilding,whichisstill,inmanypeople’seyes,justan‘eyesore’,not‘heritage’atall.Butclearlyinthisroom,atthisevent,itssignificancewasrecognised.
Iappreciatedinparticularthe‘longview’givenbysomeofthespeakerswhohavebeenworkingwithandforYork’sheritageformanyyears.Ithastakenmeyearstodevelopanunderstandingofitsmanylayers,andI’mstillworkingonit.InmyincreasingawarenessandengagementI’veappreciatedbeingabletoemailknowledgeablepeoplewithexperienceandperspective,likeAlisonSinclair,whenIwantedtoincludeaccurateandhelpfulinformationonyorkstories.co.uktoraiseawarenessofplanningapplicationsregardingheritageassets(unlisted,industrial,‘LocalList’buildings).Aswasmentionedinthediscussions,theworkneededtoincreaseengagementandparticipationneedspeopletodoworkwhichisgenerallyunpaid,andrequiresenergyandenthusiasmandtime,andthisperhapsneedsmorerecognitionandappreciation.
2007:RecordingtheremnantsofbuildingsintheHungatearea,beforedemolitionandredevelopment.Credit:YorkStories
44
![Page 47: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
I’moftenstruckbythemanydifferentversionsandperceptionsofYork.ThiswasperhapsparticularlyobviouswhenlisteningtoMichaelHayes,whoexpressedfrustrationatnotenoughhappening.Myperception,basedonmyinterestsandconcerns,isoftenthattoomuchishappeningtokeepupwith.
IntalkingabouttheLocalPlan,whichwillshapeYorkinthefuture,ChrisStewardemphasisedwhat’sseenbymanyasacrucialaspect–protectionofthecity’sgreenbelt.Notwantingtobuildongreenfieldsisarecognitionthatthenaturalenvironmentisalsopartofourheritage.Butnaturealsocreepsintoourbuilt-upareasonmanyofthose‘brownfield’sites(oftenquitegreen),wherewealsooftenstillhaveafewremnantsofstillunder-appreciatedindustrialheritage.Theclearanceandredevelopmentofbrownfieldsiteshasmeantthelossofindustrialheritageonalargescale.Itriedtorecordoncamerawhatwasleftofitin2004,andsincethen.
AssomeonewhohasoftenwonderedwhatpastresidentsthoughtabouttheirgreenfieldsbeingbuiltonIlikedVictoriaHoyle’ssuggestionthatthearchivesshouldbe‘aboutwhatisimportantnow,andbeingmoreresponsive’,thattheycouldbeprioritisedforaccessibilityonissuesofcurrentconcernsuchasthis.Readingthethoughtsofearlierresidentsofthecityingenerationspastisalwaysilluminatingandcanhelpformamoremeasuredperspectiveonchangesinthepresent.I’veappreciatedthewaythearchiveshavebeenopenedupandmademoreaccessible,particularlyonline.Therecognitionthat‘thecityarchives’aren’tjustinthatonebuildingbutarespreadacrossthecity,heldbyindividuals,seemsanimportantpoint.
OnCarmeliteStreet,intheHungateredevelopmentarea,in2006.Alargestudentaccommodationblocknowoccupiesthesite.Credit:YorkStoriesCredit:YorkStories
45
![Page 48: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
HelenWeinstein’scontributionwastheoneIthoughtaboutthemostonmywayhome,andlater,assheconveyedclearlythedifficultiesoftellingthestoriesofClifford’sTower,discomfortwiththewaythebuildingisportrayed,andthelackofunderstanding,andassheexploredthedepthsandcomplexitiesoftraumatichistories,andhowtomarkthem.IwasoneoftheYorkchildrenwhogrewupheredrawingpicturesofClifford’sTowerasaniconicbuildingrepresentingthecity’shistorywhenweweregivenprojectsinclass.Itwasn’tuntilIwasinmy30s,puttingmyfirst‘YorkWalks’photosonlineandfindingontheBBCwebsiteanarticleonthehistoryofClifford’sTowerentitled‘York’sblackestday’thatIbegantofullyrecogniseandappreciatethemeaningandsignificanceofthesite.Helen’scontributiondeepenedmyawarenessofthemanylayersandinterpretationsandperspectives.
AssomeonewhohasbeenmakingwebsitesandputtinginformationonlineforaboutfifteenyearsnowIwasparticularlyinterestedintheroletheinternetwasseentohave,thehopesregardinghowitcouldbeused.I’vebeenobservingtheonlineworldlongenoughtoknowthatyoucan’thaveoneplaceassomekindofcentralrepository,wehavetoacceptthatmanydifferentplatformsandchannelswillbeused.Alsothatmuchofthegoodandusefulstuffhasbeenmadebypeopleindividuallyjustgettingonwithit,theirdiverseheritageandtheirmakinginthenow.
Ifwe’rewantingtoinfluenceheritagedecisionsthenwedoneedtolinkupmoreeffectivelyintheonlineworld,beginningwithmorerecognitionofwhat’salreadythere.Therearesomeexcellentonlineresourcesbutthelinksbetweenthemoftenaren’tthere.Includinglinkstosourcesusedtobestandardpractice,butinanageofwidespread‘sharing’Ifearwe’relosingthoseconnections,asresourcesthatrecordheritagehaveimagesrippedfromtheircontext,historiesadrift.
TalkingwithDannyCallaghanaboutissuesinvolvedin‘DIYheritage’andheritageactivismwashelpfulinrelationtomyongoingworkatwww.yorkstories.co.ukandwithassociatedprojectsIwasstartingworkonatthetimeoftheevent.AspectsofYork’sculturalheritageandrecenthistorystillseemquiet/absent/invisiblebehindmoredominantnarratives,butit’suptoustorecordthem.I’llcontinuetodomybitin‘DIYheritage’andininformationsharingonissuesrelatedtolocalengagementandtheplanningprocesswhereIcan.
Thingshavechangedandshiftedsomuchinthelastfewyearsintermsofincreasingengagementwithheritage-relatedissues,andIhopethatthismomentumcanbesustainedandbuilton,withsimilareventsinthefuture.
46
![Page 49: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
Acknowledgements
The‘Whathasheritageeverdoneforus?’eventtookplaceinthecontextofthe‘Howshouldheritagedecisionsbemade?’project.Thefullresearchteamis:
Martin BashforthradicalfamilyhistorianandYork’sAlternativeHistoryMike BensonDirector,Bede’sWorldTim BoonHeadofResearchandPublicHistory,ScienceMuseumLianne BrighamYorkPastandPresentRichard BrighamYorkPastandPresentKaren BrookfieldDeputyDirector(Strategy),HeritageLotteryFundPeter BrownDirector,YorkCivicTrustDanny CallaghanIndependentConsultant(PublicArt,HistoryandEngagement)includingThePotteriesTileTrail(HLF),CeramicCityStoriesJean-Phillipe CalvinComposerandResearcherRichard CourtneySchoolofManagement,UniversityofLeicesterKathy CreminDirector,HivePaul FurnessYork’sAlternativeHistoryHelen GrahamSchoolofFineArt,HistoryofArtandCulturalStudiesandCentreforCriticalStudiesinMuseums,GalleriesandHeritage,UniversityofLeedsAlex HaleArchaeologist,RoyalCommissionontheAncientandHistoricalMonumentsofScotlandPaddy HodgkissRiccallArchiveCo-ordinatorJohn LawsonStoryteller,LoftusRebecca MadginUrbanStudies,UniversityofGlasgowPaul MannersDirector,NationalCo-ordinatingCentreforPublicEngagementDavid RobinsonTechnicalEditorandMusicianJohn StanleyWriterandElectronicMusicianMartin SwanMusicianandEducatorJennifer TimothySeniorBuildingConservationOfficer,LeicesterCityCouncilRachael Turner Director,MadLabandTheGhostsofStPauls(HLFAllOurStories)
www.heritagedecisions.leeds.ac.uk
CreativeCommonsAttributionNonCommericalShareAlike4.0InternationalLicense
47
![Page 50: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
![Page 51: York: What has heritage ever done for us? · The ‘What has heritage ever done for us?’ event was held as part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council Connected Communities](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042216/5ebe11f4ac666a50c7143398/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
York: What has heritage ever done for us?