your website, the americans with disabilities act, and ... · is covered under the ada. first...

37
YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND OTHER NON- DISCRIMINATION REQUIREMENTS

Upload: others

Post on 21-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

YOUR WEBSITE THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT AND OTHER NON-DISCRIMINATION REQUIREMENTS

Presenters

Minh N Vu Esq Tyler Steben Vice President Preety Kumar CEO Seyfarth Shaw LLP Product Marketing Deque Washington DC Deque Herdon VA (202) 828-5337 Herdon VA (877) 225-3932 mvuseyfarthcom (877) 225-3932 preetykumardequecom

tylerstebendequecom 2 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Disclaimer

bull This presentation has been prepared by Seyfarth Shaw LLP for informational purposes only and is not legal advice This information is not intended to create and receipt of it does not constitute an attorney-client relationship Participants should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel The material discussed during this webinar should not be construed as legal advice or a legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances The content is intended for general information purposes only and you are urged to consult a lawyer concerning your own situation and any specific legal questions you may have Any tax information or written tax advice contained here in (including any attachments) is not intended to be and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on the taxpayer

3 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

    

       

TODAYrsquoS AGENDA

bull INTRODUCTION Who we are ndash the role of lawyers and accessibility experts What types businesses should be concerned about website

accessibility

bull Accessible and Assistive Technology 101 bull Current Legal Requirements bull Trends Affecting Website Accessibility bull What Businesses Should Be Doing Now

4 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

      

   

     

INTRODUCTION Role of Lawyer amp Consultant

bull Attorney Provides advice on legal obligations under federal and state statutes Oversees privileged review of websites done by consultants Represents clients in actual or threatened lawsuits and government

investigations Develops legal policies and procedures

bull Accessibility Expert Provides technical expertise to help businesses assess their

websites and solutions for accessibility Provides software amp training Develop strategies for minimizing risk amp maximizing opportunity Helps manage logistics in the event of legal or regulatory attention

5 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 2: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Presenters

Minh N Vu Esq Tyler Steben Vice President Preety Kumar CEO Seyfarth Shaw LLP Product Marketing Deque Washington DC Deque Herdon VA (202) 828-5337 Herdon VA (877) 225-3932 mvuseyfarthcom (877) 225-3932 preetykumardequecom

tylerstebendequecom 2 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Disclaimer

bull This presentation has been prepared by Seyfarth Shaw LLP for informational purposes only and is not legal advice This information is not intended to create and receipt of it does not constitute an attorney-client relationship Participants should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel The material discussed during this webinar should not be construed as legal advice or a legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances The content is intended for general information purposes only and you are urged to consult a lawyer concerning your own situation and any specific legal questions you may have Any tax information or written tax advice contained here in (including any attachments) is not intended to be and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on the taxpayer

3 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

    

       

TODAYrsquoS AGENDA

bull INTRODUCTION Who we are ndash the role of lawyers and accessibility experts What types businesses should be concerned about website

accessibility

bull Accessible and Assistive Technology 101 bull Current Legal Requirements bull Trends Affecting Website Accessibility bull What Businesses Should Be Doing Now

4 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

      

   

     

INTRODUCTION Role of Lawyer amp Consultant

bull Attorney Provides advice on legal obligations under federal and state statutes Oversees privileged review of websites done by consultants Represents clients in actual or threatened lawsuits and government

investigations Develops legal policies and procedures

bull Accessibility Expert Provides technical expertise to help businesses assess their

websites and solutions for accessibility Provides software amp training Develop strategies for minimizing risk amp maximizing opportunity Helps manage logistics in the event of legal or regulatory attention

5 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 3: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Disclaimer

bull This presentation has been prepared by Seyfarth Shaw LLP for informational purposes only and is not legal advice This information is not intended to create and receipt of it does not constitute an attorney-client relationship Participants should not act upon this information without seeking professional counsel The material discussed during this webinar should not be construed as legal advice or a legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances The content is intended for general information purposes only and you are urged to consult a lawyer concerning your own situation and any specific legal questions you may have Any tax information or written tax advice contained here in (including any attachments) is not intended to be and cannot be used by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding tax penalties that may be imposed on the taxpayer

3 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

    

       

TODAYrsquoS AGENDA

bull INTRODUCTION Who we are ndash the role of lawyers and accessibility experts What types businesses should be concerned about website

accessibility

bull Accessible and Assistive Technology 101 bull Current Legal Requirements bull Trends Affecting Website Accessibility bull What Businesses Should Be Doing Now

4 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

      

   

     

INTRODUCTION Role of Lawyer amp Consultant

bull Attorney Provides advice on legal obligations under federal and state statutes Oversees privileged review of websites done by consultants Represents clients in actual or threatened lawsuits and government

investigations Develops legal policies and procedures

bull Accessibility Expert Provides technical expertise to help businesses assess their

websites and solutions for accessibility Provides software amp training Develop strategies for minimizing risk amp maximizing opportunity Helps manage logistics in the event of legal or regulatory attention

5 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 4: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

    

       

TODAYrsquoS AGENDA

bull INTRODUCTION Who we are ndash the role of lawyers and accessibility experts What types businesses should be concerned about website

accessibility

bull Accessible and Assistive Technology 101 bull Current Legal Requirements bull Trends Affecting Website Accessibility bull What Businesses Should Be Doing Now

4 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

      

   

     

INTRODUCTION Role of Lawyer amp Consultant

bull Attorney Provides advice on legal obligations under federal and state statutes Oversees privileged review of websites done by consultants Represents clients in actual or threatened lawsuits and government

investigations Develops legal policies and procedures

bull Accessibility Expert Provides technical expertise to help businesses assess their

websites and solutions for accessibility Provides software amp training Develop strategies for minimizing risk amp maximizing opportunity Helps manage logistics in the event of legal or regulatory attention

5 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 5: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

      

   

     

INTRODUCTION Role of Lawyer amp Consultant

bull Attorney Provides advice on legal obligations under federal and state statutes Oversees privileged review of websites done by consultants Represents clients in actual or threatened lawsuits and government

investigations Develops legal policies and procedures

bull Accessibility Expert Provides technical expertise to help businesses assess their

websites and solutions for accessibility Provides software amp training Develop strategies for minimizing risk amp maximizing opportunity Helps manage logistics in the event of legal or regulatory attention

5 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 6: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

   

   

WHAT TYPES OF BUSINESSES NEED TO BE CONCERNED

bull Public Accommodation Generally any enterprise thatdoes business with the public Covered by ADA Title III Non-discrimination requirements

bull Recipients of Federal Funding Universities health care providers some non-profits etc Covered by Section 504 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-

discrimination requirements bull Federal Government Contractors amp Subcontractors

Covered by Section 503 of Rehabilitation Actrsquos non-discrimination requirements

bull Employers that use online application systems Covered by ADA Title I non-discrimination requirements

6 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 7: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

     

   

   

ACCESSIBLE amp ASSISTIVE TECHNOLOGY 101

bull Making digital resources usable to people with disabilities

bull Both customer- and employee-facing Web sites Online applications (eg online banking employment

applications) Mobile applications Digital content documentsstatementsvideos

bull Compatible with assistive technology bull There are objective technical guidelines that denote

accessibility compliance

7 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 8: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull ADA Title III Applies to public accommodations Public accommodations must provide auxiliary aids and services necessary to

ensure equal access to their goods and services and to ensure effective communication Accessible electronic and information technology is included in the definition of auxiliary aids and services

DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement Websites that provide goods and services must be accessible to people with disabilities unless the goods and services are available in some other equivalent manner

Courts have held that the website of a business with a brick amp mortar presence is covered under the ADA

First Circuit amp DOJ position No brick amp mortar presence required for coverage

bull Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to recipients of federal funding DOJ 2010 ANPRM Statement ldquo[t]here seems to be little debate that the

websites of recipients of federal financial assistance are covered by Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Actrdquo

8 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 9: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

   

   

CURRENT STATE OF THE LAW

bull Section 503 of the Rehabilitation Act Applies to federal contractors and subcontractors FAQ that is on the OFCCP website states that contractors are not required to

have accessible online application systems as long as people who cannot use the online system have an equally effective means of applying http wwwdolgovofccpregscompliancefaqsdir281faqshtm

OFCCP has proposed to change this rule

bull ADA Title I Applies to all employers with more than 15 employees No formal position taken by EEOC about whether online application websites

must be accessible In an 21703 informal letter the EEOC said that accessibility of online application systems was an ldquoemerging issuerdquo but stressed that employers must make reasonable accommodations upon request

9 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 10: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Trends Shaping 2013

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 10 |

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 11: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

EMERGING TECHNOLOGY

How will new technology impact ADA Compliance for web sites in 2013

11 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 12: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 12 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 13: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 13 |

Emerging Technology

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 14: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 14 |

Emerging Technology

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 15: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Emerging Technology

bull  Adoption of Mobile technology  Mobile driving expansion in scope of compliance activity

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 16: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

The Obama Administration How will the second term of the Obama Administration impact ADA Compliance for digital resources

13 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 17: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

The Obama Administrationrsquos Second Term

ldquoOn the issue of civil rights the disability community has no better friend in Washington than President Obama He has a very strong record of ADA enforcementhellipparticularly in the areas of their desire to try to enforce the ADA and issues such as access to swimming pools in hotelsrdquo

--Teddy Kennedy Jr representing President Obama at the 2012 National Disability Forum October 9 2012

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 18: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Section 508 (Procurement) refocus

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 15 |

EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDG ET

WASH INGTON DC 20503

January 24 2013

MEMORANDUM FOR THE CHIEF ACQUISITION OFFICERS SENIOR PROCUREMENT EXECUTIVES CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICERS

FROM

SUBJECT

SMALL AGENCY CO CIL MEMBERS

Joseph G Jordan _ Administrator for F fieral Procuretnent Policy

Steven VanRoekel t~ Chief Information 0~ Strategic Plan for Improving Management of Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 19: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

What will the Department of Justice do in 2013 to impact ADA compliance for websites

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 16 |

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 20: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title II for state and local government websites July 2013

bull Projected date for NPRM under ADA Title III for public accommodations December 2013

bull WCAG 20 Level AA likely to be the accessibility standard adopted

17 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 21: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE ACTIVITIES

bull Investigations and compliance reviews focused on websites

bull Continued demands for website accessibility in agreements resolving non-website related complaints

18 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 22: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

OFFICE OF FEDERAL CONTRACT COMPLIANCE PROGRAMS

bullDecember 9 2011 OFCCP issues proposed rule thatwould require government contractors to ldquoensure that their use of information and communication technology is accessible to applicants and employees with disabilitiesrdquo

Proposed rule refers to WCAG 20 and Section 508 Standards

bullApril 2013 Final Rule projected date

19 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 23: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

The States How will legal and regulatory activities at the state level impact accessibility of bank web sites

20 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 24: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

THE STATES

State agencies and Attorney General Officescan exert pressure on banks to requirewebsite accessibility under state non-discrimination statutes

New York AGrsquos office has been active in this area in the past for example The MA AGrecently announced the monstercom settlement

State agencies pay attention to federal ADA mandates and will seek to enforce them through their own state mechanisms

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 25: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

ADVOCACY GROUPS

How will disability advocacy groups shape ADA compliance for websites in 2013

22 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 26: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 23 |

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 27: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 24 |

Thank you for participating in our survey Banking arnd finano al seryenices are an

important part of our everyday lives and llere at A B we want to find out hov well these

institutions are meeting the needs of people with vision loss Addi onally we want to be

able to demonstrate to these same instttutions that there is still more work to be done

1m~rove online accessibility he responses you provide will help AFB reach out to the

bankang industry to improve online accessibalrty

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 28: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LL 25 |

Blind man files discrimination suit over law school admission test By Philip Rosenbaum CNN May 252011 758pm EDT

(CNN) -- A blind Michigan man rejected by three law schools after scoring poorly on the Law School Admission Test is suing the American Bar Association arguing that the groups exam requirements discriminate against the visually impaired

Angelo Binno left and his lawyer Richard Bernstein say schools should be able to waive the LSAT

In a suit filed Tuesday in the US District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan Angelo Binno alleges the Chicago-based ABA prevents law schools from waiving the admission test known as the LSAT for blind

STORY HIGHLIGHTS

bull Angelo Binno of Michigan is blind and he aspires to go to law school

bull He is suing the American Bar Association claiming discrimination in testing

bull Law schools follow ABA policy oo testing tho suit says

bull The ABA has not yet respooded to the suit

RELATED TOPICS

American Bar Association

applicants The suit alleges that visually impaired students face considerable difficulties with visually-oriented parts of the exam

The associations rules require students to take a middotvalid and reliable test Binnos lawsuit counters that the LSAT is the only widely used commercially available exam for assessing law school applicants leaving in effect no alternative

The suit says according to ABA policy schools could face sanctions be put on probation or lose accreditation if they fail to comply Binno says this violates protections for the disabled provided by the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990

I want to help disabled and disadvantaged people who otherwise would struggle to have their voices be heard Binno said

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 29: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

       

           

Advocacy Groups

bull 2012 Recap Disability advocacy groups

bull Organized effective focused on equal opportunity employment bull Catalyst for voluntary agreements to make websites and mobile

apps accessible

bull 2013 trends to watch Continued focus on industry leaders amp government agencies Increased use of social media and web Inclusion of mobile and digital documents in scope Watchdog for new rules in industry and state and local govt Legal activity can originate with groups or individuals

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 30: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

2013 TRENDS SUMMARY

bull The national and state political climates will result inadditional ADA enforcement regulation in 2013 that willinclude web and mobile technology

bull The Department of Justicersquos and OFCCPrsquos rule makingprocess will result in issuing more pointed directives around web accessibility for industry employment andstate and local governments

bull Advocacy group momentum will continue to focus on all industries and government agencies

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 31: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

       

ALL OF THIS MEANS

bull An organized and proactive approach to making websites and mobile apps accessible minimizes risk and cost

bull A reactive approach can result in Time tables and milestones being set for third parties Internal priorities focus and spend being dictated Negative PR and brand impact

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 32: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

WHAT YOUR COMPANY SHOULD BE DOING NOW

How can my company be proactive with regard to its website in 2013

29 | copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 33: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

5 things your company can do to be proactive 1 Executives understand the level of risk the organization has--evaluate

existing website and mobile apps for ADA compliance

2 Consider strategies for protecting internal evaluations of legal compliance from discovery

3 If any digital resources are not accessible implement measures to ensure access to your goods and services using alternate channels

4 Train business leaders and the organizationrsquos technical teams on accessibility best practices and coding

5 Plan to remediate the accessibility bugs that represent the greatest amount of risk to the organization using internal resources or a knowledgeable third party

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 34: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Path to Accessibility

Assessment Policy amp Plan Audit Develop amp

Remediate Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 35: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 36: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

Assessment Policy

amp Plan Audit Develop amp Remediate

Self- Sufficiency Awareness

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |

Page 37: YOUR WEBSITE, THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT, AND ... · is covered under the ADA. First Circuit & DOJ position: No brick & mortar presence required for coverage. • Section

QUESTIONS

copy2013 Seyfarth Shaw LLP 34 |