@ dynamic coast
DESCRIPTION
Slide showTRANSCRIPT
The Dynamic Coast
Right PlaceResourcesRight PlaceResources
A presentation about the interaction between the dynamic coast and people
Houses threatened by coastal erosion in California
For the rest of the presentations in this series
visit
www.rightplace.sqrl.net
Right Place Resources
People and the Coast
People have always lived by the sea. The sea provides food, opportunities to trade and is a great place to relax…
…but the coast can change and affect people and their
property. Protection from the sea might be necessary.
Right Place Resources
Cliff erosion along Auckland’s coastline and erosion at Omaha Beach (below).
What do you think causes erosion of the coastline?
What makes it worse?
Can it be stopped or lessened?
Images courtesy of Auckland Regional Council
Right Place Resources
Natural processes that cause coastal erosion
The coastline
Coastal Geomorphology
•The geology of the coast
•The shape of the seabed
Aeolian (Wind)
The wind determines the waves and also carries fine sediments
Biological
• Weathering can weaken rocks
• Vegetation can strengthen and stabilise slopes.
Hydrological
• Wave energy and force
• Movement of sediment
• Currents
• Changes in sea level
Right Place Resources
Erosion and deposition over time
Do you know of a beach that is eroding?
A collapsed cliff face in East Anglia, England.
Most coastal erosion occurs during storms. Storms cause great damage, but often the rock or beach has been exposed to years of weathering and erosion by the wind so is already in a weakened state. The storm really just finishes it off.
Time
Storm events
erosion
Right Place Resources
Examples of coastal landforms
Which landforms are caused by erosion?
Which coastlines are growing?
Right Place Resources
Can you name these landforms and describe how they might have been caused?
Right Place Resources
Look carefully at this coastline
Why has this part eroded?
This part of the coastline has remained stable.
Why has it not eroded?
This dotted line is the original coastline
Right Place Resources
Stacks – a well known coastal landform
Old Man of Hoy, Scotland
You’ve probably seen pictures of stacks before, but did you know that they are a
landform caused by coastal erosion?
The Twelve Apostles, Australia
Ha Long Bay, Vietnam
Right Place Resources
The Dynamic System of the Beach
Why do some coastlines erode away? Why do some grow?
All beaches exist in a dynamic equilibrium involving four factors:
1.The supply of sand2.The energy of the waves3.Changes in sea-level4.The location of the shorelineIt is the balance of these four factors and how they interact with each other that determines whether a beach erodes or grows.
This sand dune pictured above is evidence that this beach has lots
of sand.
How might this sand have been deposited here?
Right Place Resources
The Sand Supply
Sand is food for beaches and gives shorelines protection from the waves. Being starved of sand can cause higher rates of erosion.
The Dynamic Equilibrium is affected by…
The Waves
The erosive action of a wave is greatest when the wave is high. The angle at which they strike a beach and how much sand they are carrying can also influence the rate of erosion.
The Sea Level
In New Zealand the sea level is rising at approximately 15 cm/100yrs. Climate change may cause this to rise further.
The location of the shoreline
Shorelines move back and forth between storms and their location can either increase or decrease erosion rates
Right Place Resources
Storms – a major cause of coastal erosion
Higher than usual wave heights, and thus, greater wave energy
Erosion of a beach is often in spurts, with high rates of erosion occurring during a storm, and lower rates occurring in calm periods.
Storms bring:Waves containing sand that has been churned up from the sea floor, causing them to be more erosive.
Image: Richard Vroom
Right Place Resources
These photos show a beach on the west coast of the USA.
The top photo shows a cliff face with a beach below.
A year later, after a series of winter storms, attributed to El Nino, the beach beneath the cliffs has all but disappeared.
The natural ‘bank’ of sand has gone, leaving the cliff more exposed to erosion.
October 1997
April 1998
Images from USGS
Right Place Resources
These photos show a part of the coastline of the state of Louisiana, USA, that was affected by Hurricane Katrina
The top image, taken in July 2001, shows narrow sandy beaches and adjacent overwash sandflats, low vegetated dunes, and backbarrier marshes broken by ponds and channels. The second image shows the same location on August 31, 2005, two days after Hurricane Katrina made landfall on the Louisiana and Mississippi coastline. Storm surge and large waves from Hurricane Katrina submerged the islands, stripped sand from the beaches, and eroded large sections of the marsh.
Right Place Resources
Coastal Erosion and People
Over 80% of the world’s shorelines are retreating at a rate from centimeters to meters per year. Many governments, local authorities and individuals spend large amounts of money protecting their developments from being washed away by coastal erosion.
Examples of houses affected by coastal erosion in the United States
Do you know of someone who has property or land affected by coastal erosion?
Right Place Resources
People versus the Sea: Who wins?
A seawall left battered by the July 1978 storm at Omaha on the east coast of Auckland, New
Zealand.(Image courtesy of NIWA)
Who do you think would win the battle of People versus the Sea?
Which is more powerful?
Hold a quick class survey to see who thinks
the sea will ultimately always win and who
thinks that people can tame the sea and control
coastal erosion.
Right Place Resources
Humans: Negative Impact
A poor understanding of how a shoreline works can actually cause human activity to accelerate the rate of erosion.
Key factors often over-looked are:
The supply of sand.
The energy of the waves.
The natural shape of the coastline.
Human activity can cause these factors to be altered, and this will affect the dynamic equilibrium of a beach.
Look at these groynes. They are designed to trap
sand, but in doing so, they are probably starving a beach further down the
coast of sand.
Right Place Resources
Accelerating Erosion
Can a man-made structure designed to prevent coastal erosion actually achieve the opposite and accelerate the rate of erosion?
Example: Wave Energy
When a wave strikes at a beach all its energy has to go somewhere. If a large wave in a storm hits a straight wall, its energy is concentrated and it can do more damage, often undermining the wall.
Study these two diagrams of coastlines and discuss which one dissipates wave energy and which one concentrates wave energy
Right Place Resources
Shore protection (a revetment) by massive concrete armour units fronting a resort in Japan. (Photo: Jess Walker, courtesy of NIWA)
What effect do you think this structure has? Have you seen something similar?
Right Place Resources
Why might some structures work and others not?
Although hardening of the shoreline may temporarily protect property, it often results in beach loss on chronically eroding shores.
Images: Coastal Lands Program, Hawai’i
In this photo, there was not enough distance between the building and the shore, and people have put sacks down to try and stabilise the beach.
Right Place Resources
Coastal Management
Over the course of history, humans have interacted with the coastline in a variety of ways.
There are three main approaches to managing shoreline erosion:
1. Hard Stabilisation2. Soft Stabilisation3. RelocationThe approach that is taken can depend on the cost, how many people or properties are affected, and the rate of erosion.
What would you spend millions of dollars on protecting from coastal
erosion?
A housing estate.A tourism resort.
A historical Maori Pa site. A golf course.
Right Place Resources
1. Hard Stabilisation Methods
This involves holding the shoreline in place using fixed structures, usually made out of concrete.
Examples include:
• Sea walls that run parallel to the shoreline and aim to protect buildings. They often require maintenance and can look ugly.
• Revetments are sloping walls usually made of large concrete blocks not cemented together. In New Zealand they are often big boulders.
• Groynes that run perpendicular to the shoreline and aim to prevent sand loss and also deflect wave energy.
• Breakwaters are large concrete structures built offshore that aim to alter the wave direction and dissipate wave energy before it reaches the shore.
Image: Coastal Lands Program, Hawai’i
What would you do here?
Right Place Resources
Examples of Hard Stabilisation Methods
groyne
Sometimes the sea just jumps over the wall!
Images: Coastal Lands Program, Hawai’i
Right Place Resources
2. Soft Stabilisation
A beach usually erodes because of a lack of sand to protect it. Thus, soft stabilisation methods involve building up the supply of sand and protecting it.
Examples include:
• Beach Nourishment: Trucking sand in from one beach to another
• Sand dune stabilisation: Planting grasses and fencing the dunes
• Beach Drainage: This involves lowering the water table that is under the beach to enable sand to remain on the beach and not be washed away.
Planting marram grass is a common method of dune
protection.
Can you think of other ways in which dunes are
protected?
Right Place Resources
3. Relocation
This can be thought of as the “the sea has won” approach, because it is really saying that people should move out of the way of the sea.
There are advantages and disadvantages:
1. The natural events of coastal erosion are allowed to continue.
2. Money is saved by not doing any construction work.
3. Money is lost by not doing anything, as land is lost and people have to relocate.
The management and planning of development along a coastline has a big impact into how a coastline affects human development.
If councils don’t allow anyone to build within say, 500m of an actively eroding coastline, there will be less chance of any building being affected.
What do you think the locals would think of this planning restriction? View this video clip:
“Should they have been allowed to build there?”
Included in retail version
Right Place Resources
The New Zealand Situation
With over 11 000 km of coastline, New Zealand actually has very little coastal protection, mostly because there is very little concentrated human development on the coastline. Most of the ports have some form of protection and some of the cities, like Auckland, have extensive sea walls. The vast majority of coastal protection works are done by local and regional councils or by individuals.
This has resulted in a variety of structures all over New Zealand’s coast, often protecting baches and small coastal settlements. In some cases the structures are causing erosion to occur.
Think of a beach you visit regularly. Is there any coastal protection at this beach?
Image: University of Waikato, Department of Earth and Ocean Sciences
Old Tyres used as
protection
Right Place Resources
Image: Auckland City Council
An example of a seawall that doubles as a walkway. Visually pleasing and also practical.
Examples from around New Zealand
Right Place Resources
Image: R.K. Smith www.climatechange.govt.nz
Note the fence out on the right
Right Place Resources
Image: Environment Waikato
Right Place Resources
Matapouri Bay, Image: Northland Regional Council
Right Place Resources
Image: Coastal Lands Program, Hawai’i
If this was your house, what would you do?
Right Place Resources
Revision
Go back to considering who wins in “Humans vs the Sea”. What do you think?
1. Can you remember the various processes that cause coastal erosion? How many can you identify?
2. Explain the four factors that make up the dynamic equilibrium of a beach.
3. Describe how a man-made structure designed to protect a beach from erosion, could actually cause erosion to increase.
4. Name the three approaches to coastal management and give examples for each.
5. Choose one fact or piece of information that you have learnt from this presentation and explain what it is.
Right PlaceResourcesRight PlaceResources
We are very grateful for the use of information and images from the following websites and organisations:
• United States Geological Survey: Center for Coastal and Watershed Studies; coastal.er.usgs.gov/
• National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NZ): www.niwascience.co.nz
• The Why Files: www.whyfiles.org
• University of Hawai’i Sea Grant College Program
• Auckland Regional Council: www.arc.govt.nz
• Auckland City Council
• Environment Waikato
• www.climatechange.govt.nz
• Northland Regional Council
• Department of Earth and Ocean Sciences, University of Waikato.
All images are from Wikipedia unless otherwise noted
The Dynamic Coast
Get the rest of the presentations
www.rightplace.sqrl.net