07 lecture, eif - fall 2013.ppt
TRANSCRIPT
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 1/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 1
Essentials of Islamic Banking and Finance
Talha Saleem Kapadia [email protected]
Salam and Istisnaa'Salam and Istisnaa'
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 2/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 2
SalamSalam
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 3/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 3
Scope ofScope ofpresentationpresentation
Introduction;Defnition o Salam; Conditions o Salam; Comparison with Murabahah;
Parallel Salam; Parallel Salam: important points; Application; and Risks and its mitiations!
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 4/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 4
IntroductionIntroduction
"asic principle or #alidit$ o a sale in Shari%ah is that: – The commodity must be existing;Non-existing goods are not eligible for sale;
– The seller must have ownership of the commodity;Short sale (selling of what is not owned by seller) is
not allowed;
– The commodity must be in the physical or constructivepossession of the seller;Selling of what is not possessed by seller is not
allowed; All sale transactions should conorm to these rules;
&here are onl$ two e'ceptions to these principles inShari%ah and the$ are: – Bai’ Salam ; and – Bai’ Istisna'; – Both these are sales of special nature and are exceptions to
the general rules of sale.
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 5/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 5
IntroductionIntroduction
Salam is a t$pe o Sale in which: – the seller underta!es to supply some speci"c goods
to the buyer at a future date# against an agreed pricewhich is fully paid in advance and the delivery of thesold commodity is deferred;
So there are three distinuishin eatures oSalam: – The sub$ect matter %commodity to be purchased&sold
is delivered in future;
– The price is paid full in advance; – The goods for sale will be speci"c; – (nother name of Salam is Salaf)# meaning of both
are same;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 6/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 6
*xplanation of*xplanation ofSalamSalam "eore prohibition o interest( armers in Madinah
Munawwarah used to obtain interest)based loans ortheir aricultural and routine lie needs;
Ater prohibition o interest( the armers aced hardship; Similarl$ trade cara#ans o Arabs used to et interest
based loans or purchasin the commodities or trade; Ater prohibition o interest( the traders ha#e also aced
di*culties; &o sol#e this problem o +mmat( ,ol$ Prophet - .
allowed "ai% Salam; &he purpose o this permission was to ease the fnancial
needs o small armers and traders; Salam transactions has been allowed b$ the ,ol$
Prophet - . with some conditions;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 7/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 7
*xplanation of*xplanation ofSalamSalam
"$ the permissibilit$ o Salam it becomesbenefcial or both bu$er and seller;
It is benefcial to the seller because herecei#es the price in ad#ance and it isbenefcial to the bu$er because the ad#anceSalam price is usuall$ lower than the spotprice;
Since Salam is an e'ception to the eneralrules o sale and it is allowed beore e'istence
o oods( the element o /hare is ob#ioushere; &o minimi0e the element o /harar certain
conditions ha#e been laid down b$ Shari%ah; &he element o /harar or this special t$pe o
sale has been lowered down b$ imposin some
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 8/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 8
+onditions of+onditions of
SalamSalam Conditions or #alidit$ o Salam are:
► The Salam price must be paid in full at the time of e,ecting sale; – Because, in the absence of full payment it will be selling
debt (commodity whose delivery is deferred) against debt(price deferred) which is prohibited;
– lso this is against the basic wisdom behind permissibilityof Salam which is ful!lling the instant needs of thefarmers and traders;
– "f the price is not paid in advance this purpose can not beachieved;
► Salam can be e,ected only in those commodities that can beexactly speci"ed in -uantity and -uality;
– "t means only those goods can be sold under Salamtransaction which fall under the category of #$hawatul- mthal% ( !"$% &%'( );
– &he term #$hawatul-mthal% refers to such commodities,the units of which are homogeneous in characteristics;
– "t means the commodities which are traded by counting,measuring or weighing according to usage and customs oftrade;
–
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 9/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # )
+onditions of Salam+onditions of Salam
►+onditions for validity of Salam %contd. – n the other hand, Salam is not allowed in
heterogeneous % *+,-% &%'( ) goods;
– eterogeneous goods are those goods the units ofwhich are di*erent among each other incharacteristics+ eaning thereby each piece is
di*erent, in sie, weight and value;/or example animals and precious stones are not
possible to precisely de"ned beforehand.
►Sub$ect matter of Salam should be of commonnature;
– &herefore Salam cannot be e*ected on a particularcommodity of a particular !eld or farm;
– &he reason is that it is not necessary that the farmor the tree would be able to produce the re.uiredcommodity or fruit;
– lternatively, one can de!ne a particular type of thecommodity for which Salam is being done+
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 10/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 1
+onditions of+onditions of
SalamSalam► +onditions for validity of Salam %contd.
► Both the -uality and -uantity of the goods should be very clearlyagreed upon;
– ll the possible details in this respect must be expresslymentioned;
– 'or example if the commodity is .uanti!ed in weight inthe mar/et, its weight must be determined and if it is
.uanti!ed through measures, its exact measure should be/nown+ &herefore, if something is sold by measuring itcannot be sold by weighing in a Salam transaction;
► The exact date and place of delivery must be speci"ed in thecontract;
– &he date may be in range form (e+g+ from 01 to 02 on
3uly); – &he place should be speci!ed as per custom;
► Salam cannot be e,ected in respect of things which must bedelivered on spot;
– 4old with silver or wheat with barley are example of it+ ccording to Shari5ah delivery of these goods should besimultaneous;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 11/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 11
+onditions of Salam+onditions of Salam► +onditions for validity of Salam %contd.
► The commodity which is the sub$ect of Salam contract is normallyavailable in the mar!ets at the time of delivery; – Salam of angoes in 3anuary is invalid Salam;
– $elivery of goods to buyer is mandatory;
► The seller should hand over commodities to buyer at the time ofdelivery. 1e can not give money bac! to the buyer on the basis of set2
o,; – Buyer can not contractually bind the seller to buy-bac/ the
sold commodity+ &his will be a case of implicit interest(eelah);
► Similarly the seller can not contractually bind the buyer to sell2bac!the sold commodity to seller# because it would be conditional sale;
1owever# after the delivery# both may enter in a transaction ofsale with mutual consent# independently from Salam sale.
► The buyer shall not sell or transfer ownership of the goods beforeta!ing possession %actual or constructive of these goods;
– &his would be case of short-selling;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 12/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 12
+omparison with 3urabahah+omparison with 3urabahah
Salam
In Salam Price is paidat Spot;
In Salam deli#er$ osub1ect is deerred!
Murabahah
In Murabahah Price isdeerred;
&he deli#er$ osub1ect matter is atspot!
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 13/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 13
4(0(55*5 S(5(34(0(55*5 S(5(3
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 14/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 14
4arallel Salam4arallel Salam
Parallel Salam is not a kind o Salam; It is an arranement b$ bu$er to sell the
commodit$ he purchased rom some one; &he bu$er can not sell the commodit$ beore
he takes the possession rom seller in a Salam
contract as we discussed earlier; "ut the bu$er ma$ sell the commodit$ he
bouht it on Salm to another person on Salambasis;
&his arranement is called %Parallel Salam%;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 15/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 15
4arallel Salam4arallel Salam
►5ets assume 3r. '(hmed' enters into a Salam+ontract with 3r. 'Basheer' to purchase onethousand bales of cotton at a price 677#777&8 perbale to be delivered on 97 (ugust; – "n this contract (6Salam 7)8 – r+ 5hmed5 is a 9urchaser:Buyer; and – r+ 5Basheer5 is a Seller;
►3r. '(hmed' can enter into another Salam with 3r.':halid' to sell the same cotton at a price of67#777&8 per bale on a 96 (ugust;
– "n this contract (6Salam B7)8 – r+ 55 is a Seller; and – r+ 5halid5 is a 9urchaser+
Mr Basheer
Salam 1Contract on 25 June
Delivery on 20 August
Mr KhalidMr Ahmed
Salam 2Contract on 05 July
Delivery on 23 August
A parallel Salam transaction
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 16/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 16
4arallel Salam important points4arallel Salam important points
Parallel Salam is allowed with a third part$onl$;
&he seller in the frst contract cannot be madepurchaser in the parallel contract o Salam;
It will be a bu$)back arranement( which is not
permissible;
I the purchaser in the second contract is aseparate leal entit$( then it is necessar$ thatit should not be a subsidar$ or sister concern
o the seller compan$ in the frst contract;&he arranement will not be allowed because
in practical sense it will be a %bu$)back%arranement!
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 17/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 17
IstisnIstisnaa%aa%
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 18/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 18
Scope of presentationScope of presentation
Introduction of Istisnaa';
<e"nition;
*xplanation of Istisnaa'# its rules and re-uirements;
+omparison with other modes;
4arallel Istisnaa';
(pplication of Istisnaa';
0is!s analysis and mitigations;
= > (.
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 19/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 1)
IntroductionIntroduction
As we discussed earlier two t$pes o sales aree'ceptions rom eneral rules or sale;
Istisnaa% is the second e'ception where sale oa sub1ect matter which is not there at the timeo transaction( has been allowed;
In act permissibilit$ o Istisnaa% is #er$ loicaland understandable;
In routine lie an$ person ma$ need a thinwhich re2uires manuacturin;
&he manuacturer is not read$ to manuacturebeore commitment rom a bu$er to bu$;
3eepin this need in #iew Islam has permittedIstisnaa% transaction;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 20/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 2
<e"nition<e"nition
Istisnaa% is %an order rom purchaser -bu$er. toa manuacturer -seller. to produce a specifcood or him -bu$er. aainst mutuall$ areedprice and period or manuacturin anddeli#er$%;
−So the main feature is manufacturing of the soldgood;
−Istisnaa' is only possible in goods which re-uiremanufacturing;
&here is 4e'ibilit$ in pa$ment o price;It is ma$ be paid accordin to an$ schedule b$mutual consent -In ad#ance( in tranches or atthe time o deli#er$ o the oods.;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 21/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 21
/eatures of Istisnaa'/eatures of Istisnaa'
5ssential re2uirements or Istisnaa%:
−?oods & commodities should re-uire manufacturing;►anufacturing means8
/ (ny type of wor! that change the material signi"cantly;0 5i!e wor! of carpenter;
/ @alue addition in which material changes its values;0 5i!e powdering of li-uid mil!;
−3anufacturer %seller must use his own material;►"f the material is provided by the buyer then this
will be case of Services "<arah and not of "stisnaa5;
− The commodity must be !nown and speci"ed interms of !ind# type# -uality and -uantity;
► mbiguity in these elements lead to 4harar;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 22/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 22
/eatures of Istisnaa'/eatures of Istisnaa' 5ssential re2uirements or Istisnaa% -contd.:
−Aature of price in Istisnaa'
► s other /ind of sales, price of goods sold under "stisnaa5could be anything i+ e+ money, commodity and usufruct(ana!5);
− 4rice of the goods in Istisnaa'
►9rice in "stisnaa5 should be preferably !xed;►9rice in "stisnaa5 may be tied up with the time of delivery;
►'or example the buyer may !x 5=5 price for delivery in 01days and 5>5 price (reduced price) if the manufacturerdelays delivery from the agreed time schedule;
►&he reason for this ?exibility is resemblance of "stisnaa5
with "<arah;− 4ayment of 4rice of Istisnaa'
►&he price can be paid immediately (spot); or
►@an be paid at delivery (deferred); or
►@ould be paid in installments+ &he installments may be
tied up with di*erent stages of manufacturing:pro<ects;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 23/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 23
/eatures of Istisnaa'/eatures of Istisnaa'
5ssential re2uirements or Istisnaa%:
−?oods & commodities should re-uire manufacturing;►anufacturing means8
/ (ny type of wor! that change the material signi"cantly;0 5i!e wor! of carpenter;
/ @alue addition in which material changes its values;0 5i!e powdering of li-uid mil!;
−3anufacturer %seller must use his own material;►"f the material is provided by the buyer then this
will be case of Services "<arah and not of "stisnaa5;
− The commodity must be !nown and speci"ed interms of !ind# type# -uality and -uantity;
► mbiguity in these elements lead to 4harar;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 24/29Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 24
Istisnaa' +omparisonIstisnaa' +omparison%Istisnaa' and Salam%Istisnaa' and Salam
Istisnaa'
− &he sub1ect matter o anIstisnaa% contract isalwa$s somethin whichre2uires manuacturin;
−Price ma$ be paid underan$ areed schedule;
− Contract ma$ be canceledunilaterall$ beore themanuacturer starts work;
−Ma$ chane with theconsent o thecontractors;
Salam
− Sub1ect o Salam could bean$thin which cansatis$ Salam conditionslaid down b$ Shari%ah!
−Price must be paid in ullin ad#ance;
− Salam contract( oncee6ected( cannot becanceled unilaterall$;
− Determinin the time odeli#er$ is an essentialpart in Salam;
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 25/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 25
Istisnaa' +omparison %Istisnaa' andIstisnaa' +omparison %Istisnaa' andI$arahI$arah
Istisnaa'
− In Istinsa% manuacturerarees to produce there2uired oods usin hisown material!
−&hereore( the material inIstisnaa% should bepro#ided b$ themanuacturer himsel!
I$arah
− In I1arah themanuacturer utili0es hislabour and skills!
− &hereore( i the raw
material is pro#ided b$the customer andmanuacturer uses hislabor and skills onl$( thetransaction would be oI1arah and not istisnaa%!
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 26/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 26
4(0(55*5 ISTISA(('4(0(55*5 ISTISA(('
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 27/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 27
4arallel Istisnaa'4arallel Istisnaa'
Parallel Istisnaa%:
−5i!e Salam parallel Istisnaa' is not a !ind of Istisnaa';
−It is parallel arrangement for an other Istisnaa'transaction that follows "rst Istisnaa';
− The second transaction is also an Istisnaa'
transaction in all manners and conditions;
− This arrangement of two transaction has beenintroduced to reduce the ris! of buyer %Ban! forholding the commodities&goods.
−In a 4arallel Istisnaa' contract# the buyer enters intoa 4arallel Istisnaa' contract in which he is a seller toa another buyer;
−(pplying to ban!ing# in one of these twotransactions# the Ban! is the buyer and in the
second it is the seller.
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 28/29
Essentials of Islamic Finance – IU Gulshan Campus, Slide # 28
4arallel Istisnaa'4arallel Istisnaa'
Conditions or parallel Istisnaa%:
−*ach of the two contracts must be independent ofthe other;
− They cannot be tied up in a manner that the rightsand obligations of one contract are dependent on
the rights and obligations of the parallel contract;−Similar to 4arallel Salam# 4arallel Istisna is allowed
with a third party only;
− Therefore# 4arallel Istisnaa' to the same party %sellerin "rst Istisnaa' is not allowed.
7/21/2019 07 Lecture, EIF - Fall 2013.ppt
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/07-lecture-eif-fall-2013ppt 29/29
=uestions=uestions