8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

1/6

STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, PUNJAB SCO No. 32-34, Sector 17-C, CHANDI ARH, P!. No. "172-4#3""$4

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.com

M%. S&'(!)& J*'(&+,& %!&+& Ro&(,*((er &!& 1$21"1,D*%tt. Sr*M /t%&r S&!* ..0A e++&'t

%

P +*c I' or &t*o' O *cer,O5o T!e E6ec t* e O *cer,N&8&r Co 'c*+,*((er &!& 1$21"1,D*%tt. Sr*M /t%&r S&!*

P +*c I' or &t*o' O *cer,O5o S D* *%*o'&+ M&8*%tr&te,*((er &!& 1$21"1,D*%tt. Sr*M /t%&r S&!*

F*r%t A e++&te A t!or*t),O5o T!e De t) Co *%%*o'er,Sr*M /t%&r S&!* 0Re% o'(e't

A e&+ C&%e No. 1397 o 2"14

Pre%e't : No'e o' e!&+ o t!e & e++&'t. S!. B&+;*'(er S*'8!, N&* Te!%*+(&r, *((er &!&, o' e!&+ o t!e re% o'(e't.

ORDER O' t!e +&%t (&te o !e&r*'8, !e+( o' "3."#.2"14, t!e re% o'(e't-PIO, S!. H&r(ee

S*'8! D!&+* *%*te *' or &t*o' !&% &+re&() ee' % +*e( to t!e & e++&'t, M%.

S&'(!)& J*'(&+ o' 11."#.2"14 *' er%o'. He &+%o ro( ce% &

8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

2/6

A e&+ C&%e No. 1397 o 2"14 -2-

S!. B&+;*'(er S*'8!, %t&te% t!&t &% t!e *' or &t*o' !&% &+re&() ee' % +*e(, re +)

8* e' ) S. D. M., *((er &!& *(e +etter 'o. 773 (&te( 17."#.2"14, &) e t&/e' &% !*% re +).

T&/*'8 *'to co'%*(er&t*o' t!e re +), 8* e' ) S. D. M., *((er &!& *(e +etter 'o.

773 (&te( 17."#.2"14, t!e c&%e *% (*% o%e( o &'( c+o%e(.

Co *e% o t!e or(er e %e't to t!e &rt*e%.

?C!&'(er P&r/&%!@t! J +), 2"14 St&te I' or &t*o' Co *%%*o'er

P. S. :

T!e & e++&'t, M%. S&'(!)& J*'(&+, & e&re( *' er%o' & ter t!e !e&r*'8

8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

3/6

STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, PUNJAB SCO No. 32-34, Sector 17-C, CHANDI ARH, P!. No. "172-4#3""$4

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comH&r*'(er P& + D!*'8r&,r. No. # J,ABOHAR, C&'&+ Co+o') D*%tt. - F& *+/& ..0Co +&*'&'t

%

P +*c I' or &t*o' O *cer,O5o B+oc/ Pr* &r)E( c&t*o' O *cer,A o!&r 1, D*%tt. - F& *+/& ..0Re% o'(e't

Co +&*'t C&%e No. 3# 1 o 2"13Pre%e't : S!. H&r*'(er P& + D!*'8r&, t!e co +&*'&'t *' er%o'.

No'e o' e!&+ o t!e re% o'(e't.

ORDER O' t!e +&%t (&te o !e&r*'8, !e+( o' "4."#.2"14, &'ot!er o ort '*t)

!e&r*'8 %t&te% t!&t re &*'*'8 *' or &t*o' *' co''ect*o' e%t !&%

'ot ee' % +*e( to !* ) t!e re% o'(e't-PIO %o &r.

I t!e co +&*'&'t *% 'ot %&t*% *e(

no power to provide access to the information which has been requested for by

any person but which has been denied to him. The only order which can be passed

by the Central Information Commission or the State Information Commission, as

the case may be, under Section 18 is an order of penalty provided under Section

!. "owever, before such order is passed the Commissioner must be satisfied that

the conduct of the Information #fficer was not bona fide.

8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

4/6

Co't(025-

Co +&*'t C&%e No. 3# 1 o 2"13 -2-

$1% &e uphold the said contention and do not find any error in the impu'ned (ud'ment

of the "i'h court whereby it has been held that the Commissioner while

entertainin' a complaint under Section 18 of the said Act has no (urisdiction to

pass an order providin' for access to the information).

He'ce, No co8'* &'ce *% re> *re( to e t&/e' *' t!*% c&%e.

O' t!e !e&r*'8 !e+( o' 21."3.2"14, S!. A%!o/ &r D!o%*

8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

5/6

STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, PUNJAB SCO No. 32-34, Sector 17-C, CHANDI ARH, P!. No. "172-4#3""$4

Visit us @ www.infocommpunjab.comR&; S*'8!S5o S!. I%!er S*'8!,*++&8e To(&r er) No. #

to t!e & e++&'t

S*'8! ( r*'8 t!e !e&r*'8 *' t!e Co *%%*o' to(&). A co ) o t!e %& e &+o'8e6 re%%e% !*% (*%%&t*% &ct*o' o er t!e *' or &t*o' % +*e( to !* ) t!e re% o'(e't-PIO.

T!e re% o'(e't-PIO,

*+e & re +) *' t!e %!& e o & *(& *t %t&t*'8 t!&t

recor(.

T!e c&%e *% &(;o r'e( to 7 t! A 8 %t, 2"14 ?T! r%(&)@ &t 11:"" A. M. *'

C!& er, S. C. O. 32 34, Sector 17 C, C!&'(*8&r!.

Co *e% o t!e or(er e %e't to t!e &rt*e%.

?C!&'(er P&r/&%!@t! J +), 2"14 St&te I' or &t*o' Co *%%*o'er

CC :

8/11/2019 08.07.2014Orders(CP)

6/6

S!. H&r(*&+ S*'8! M&&',Sr. S (t. o Po+*ce, P&t*&+&