1

Change It Up! What Girls Say About Change It Up! What Girls Say About Redefining LeadershipRedefining Leadership

Summary of Research FindingsSummary of Research Findings

Girl Scout Research InstituteGirl Scout Research Institute

Girl Scouts of the USAGirl Scouts of the USA

March 18, 2008March 18, 2008

Change It Up! What Girls Say About Change It Up! What Girls Say About Redefining LeadershipRedefining Leadership

Summary of Research FindingsSummary of Research Findings

Girl Scout Research InstituteGirl Scout Research Institute

Girl Scouts of the USAGirl Scouts of the USA

March 18, 2008March 18, 2008

2

Research Goal: To explore and understand the attitudes, perceptions, and experiences of girls ages 8-17 towards leadership

3

Qualitative -- 13 focus groups and 6 ethnographies in Hackensack, NJ; Cincinnati, OH; Atlanta, GA; and San Diego, CA (165 girls, boys, and mothers)

Quantitative-- Nationwide online survey: 2,475 girls and 1,514 boys between ages 8 and 17

-- Mall-intercept interviews: 649 African American and Hispanic pre-teen and teen girls and boys at 15 locations

Expert Interviews-- In-depth interviews: 15 experts in leadership, youth development, and girls

Research Advisory Body and Girl Scout Council Advisory Body-- Expert advisors from the youth development/leadership field and Girl Scout councils

Methodology

4

Insight #1

Girls are Redefining Leadership in Meaningful Terms

Most common definition: Command and Control

Least aspirational definition:               Command and Control

Most aspirational definition: Purpose-Driven and Social Change

Values

 

5

Change It Up!   68% of girls say that they want to be a leader who “stands up for her beliefs and values” in the future.

59% say they want to be like someone “who tries to change the world for the better” in the future.

6

Leadership Ingredients: Setting the Bar High 

Girls highly idealize leadership qualities and skills: responsible, caring, honest, hardworking, decision-maker, confident, good listener, team player, organized, motivated…

 

Only 21% of girls and boys believe they currently have most of the key qualities required to be a good leader.

Leadership is so highly idealized in young people’s minds that most of them do not believe they can attain this goal.

7

Leadership AspirationsTODAY:

• 61% of girls currently think of themselves as leaders.

THE FUTURE:

• When asked if they want to be leaders, 39% of girls say yes.

• The majority, 52%, say they would not mind being a leader, but it’s not that important to them.

• 9% say no, they do not want to be leaders.

8

Insight #1: Girls are Redefining Leadership in Meaningful Terms

Insight #1 Implications

(1) Make clear which aspects of leadership are at the core of program activities.

(2) Define leadership in meaningful terms to girls.

(3) Set reasonable and attainable leadership development goals so that girls don’t feel they have to possess every imaginable skill and competency.

9

Insight #2

Self-Confidence + Skills = New Girl Leaders

• The factor that most strongly influences a girl’s desire to actively pursue leadership is confidence in her own skills and competencies.

• The greatest single barrier to leadership is low self-regard about skills and qualities.

Very simply put, youth who report high self-regard on a number of

leadership skills and qualities are more likely to aspire to leadership.

10

Additional factors that influence a girl’s desire to actively pursue leadership:

• Organizational skills• Extraversion• “Dominant” profile/identity• Experience with leadership roles

11

African American, Hispanic, and Asian American girls and boys as well as higher income youth are more likely to aspire to leadership.

This is because:

• They rate themselves higher on leadership skills and dimensions.

• They are more likely to report having had a leadership experience.

• They are more likely to think of themselves as leaders.

12

Age and gender have very little effect on a youth’s desire to pursue leadership:

The age effect is significant, but small. Self-perception as a

leader is highest at younger ages (grades 2-4), drops in grades 7-10,

and rises again slightly in grades 11-12.

Girls and boys have an equal likelihood of aspiring to and thinking of themselves as leaders.

13

Barriers to Leadership Aspiration (N=360)* * denotes statistically significant difference

45%

43%

32%

32%

32%

30%

29%

29%

28%

27%

25%

23%

21%

21%

18%

16%

14%

38%

26%

34%

25%

25%

27%

27%

13%

26%

19%

26%

29%

24%

15%

21%

19%

17%

I do not want to speak in front of others* *

I am too shy* *

I am simply not interested

I am afraid I would fail

I do not want to be laughed at

I don’t want people to get mad at me

I don’t want the responsibility

I do not want to come across as bossy* *

I don’t want to tell others what to do

People might not like me* *

There are other people who are better qualified than me

I don’t have the experience to be a good leader

I don’t have the skills

To much stress in my life already

I t doesn’t matter if I am a leader or not as long as I dowhat I like to do

I ts not a priority for me – I am focused on the needs oftoday

I want to be a team player

Girls Boys

14

Insight #2: Self-Confidence + Skills = New Girl Leaders

Insight #2 Implications

(1)Provide opportunities to develop leadership skills and experiment with leadership roles in supportive environments.

(2) Boost girls’ self-confidence and skill set. This in turn makes them more likely to be interested in leadership.

15

Insight #3: Leadership Experiences + Support System =New Girl Leaders

Girls’ past leadership experience and extracurricular participation predict leadership aspirations.

Most youths (67%) have had a chance to be a leader, with non-white youths (75%) significantly more likely than white youth (64%) to report having had a chance to be a leader.

Youth experience leadership mostly at school (75%), home (24%), and church (22%), with the most influential support and adult role modeling found at home.

16

The Girl Scout Effect

60% of current Girl Scouts report being encouraged to be a leader by Girl Scout adult volunteers.

Compared to girls who were never in Girl Scouts, a high representation of Girl Scouts want to be leaders (50% vs. 36%), think of themselves as leaders (67% vs. 57%), and have had the opportunity and experience to be a leader (72% vs. 48%).

17

Youths identify family (especially mothers), teachers, and friends as influencers.

People Who I nfluence You to Be a Leader

81%

65%62%

55%

43%

35%31%

27%

23% 22%

13%11%

75%

56%

64%

47%

40%

32%29%

23%

32%

25%

11% 10%

Mother Teacher Father Friends Uncle, aunt,cousin,

grandparent

Classmatesor peers

Brothers orsisters

Religiousleaders

Coach Teammates GirlScouts/Boy

Scouts

Celebrities

Girls Boys

18

Gender Differences

Girls are more driven by altruistic motives; boys are more driven bypower and money.

Girls are more likely than boys to want to be leaders because they want to help other people (67% vs. 53%), share their knowledge and skills with others (53% vs. 45%), and change the world for the better (45% vs. 31%).

Boys are more likely than girls to be motivated by the desire to be their own boss (38% vs. 33%), make more money (33% vs. 26%), and have more power (22% vs. 14%).

Girls derive greater satisfaction from learning (31% vs. 22%) in leadership experiences; boys derive great satisfaction from being in charge (26% vs. 16%).

19

Gender Differences

While the majority of respondents (82%) agree that girls and boys are equally good at being leaders, 56% of girls and boys say "in our society, it is more difficult to become a leader for a woman than a man.“

More than half (52%) of girls and boys agree that “girls have to work harder than boys in order to gain positions of leadership.” More girls (57%) than boys (44%) feel this way.

20

Insight #3: Leadership Experiences + Support System = New Girl Leaders

Insight #3 Implications

To be relevant and successful to girls, a leadership program must:

(1) Teach new skills relevant to leadership development.

(2) Create mentoring relationships (peer-to-peer and girl-to-adult).

(3) Provide safe environments for free expression.

(4) Create opportunities to effect change in communities.

(5) Address the gender stereotypes that girls and boys face.

21

Insight #4: Girls Have a Range of “Leadership Identities”

Girls cannot be approached as a homogenous group in relation to leadership aspiration.

(36%) Vanguard – Think of selves as leaders / Want to be leaders

(25%) Ambivalent – Think of selves as leaders / Wouldn’t mind being leaders

(4%) Hopefuls – Don’t think of selves as leaders / Want to be leaders

(26%) Unmotivated – Don’t think of selves as leaders / Wouldn’t mind being leaders

(8%) Rejecters – Don’t think of selves as leader / Don’t want to be leaders

22

Insight #4: Girls Have a Range of “Leadership Identities”

Insight #4 Implications

(1) Do not treat girls like one homogenous block.

(2) Tailor programming, delivery, and activities to their different identities.

23

The Girl Scout Research Institute

For more information contact the GSRI: gsresearch@girlscouts.org

And visit the GSRI Web page: http://www.girlscouts.org/Research/