1 life as a complex system frederick h. willeboordse [email protected]
Post on 18-Dec-2015
223 views
TRANSCRIPT
2
Abstract
Life is certainly complicated and indeed often complex. However, is it a “complex system” in the Physicists’ sense? In this talk it shall be arguedthat the answer to this question is affirmative by comparing certaincharacteristics of life with those of physical systems.
Underlying the ideas of life as a complex system is the notion that complex systems have intrinsic properties that can lead to unexpected but robust and adaptable dynamics. This is rather different from the currently prevailing view that evolution is a random walk over adaptation space. Thus, whether this notion eventually will prevail or not, the consideration of life as a complex system clearly illustrates how the interaction between seemingly radically different fields can enrich the experiences of both.
The complex systems properties of life and their conceptual parallels in Physics will be discussed through selected examples and the live demonstration of simulation programs used in my research.
Abstract
3
Today’s Talk:
• Introduction• Is life a complex system? Yes!• Examples of complex systems from Physics and Biology• Study of life as a complex system• Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology• Conclusion
Today’s talk
4
Introduction:
Aim: Argue that Life is a complex system
Give some illustrations using aniterative approach
What does Physics have to do with this? Physicists like to look for universalities (e.g. laws of nature). Most theorists of biological evolution, however, have thus far assumed a random walk to new adaptations.If life is a complex system, the physicists’ approach can contribute significantly.
Introduction
5
Obviously, Life is complex but does that mean that it is a complex system?
In order to answer this question, at least two aspects need to be considered:
The physical/mathematical aspect
The biological aspect
what is commonwhat is different
Can Life be considered a complex system?
Is life a complex system?
6
The physical/mathematical aspect
Generally speaking a complex system is a system of interacting elements whose collective behavior cannot be described as the simple sum the elements’ behavior
Complex is not the same as complicated!
Hence many systems studied in physics are in that sense not complex. E.g. in Quantum Physics we can simply ADDthe wave functions.
Five boys and five girls together on a deserted island though will likely behave quite differently from one boy or girl on the same deserted island.
Is life a complex system?
7
Complex:
Some double pendula linked byrubber bands
Function: easy to design and understandBehavior: difficult to understand
Complicated:
Microprocessor
Function: difficult to design and understandBehavior: easy to understand
The physical/mathematical aspect
Complex is not the same as complicated!
Is life a complex system?
8
The physical/mathematical aspect
An essential ingredient of complex systems is their built-in non-linearity.
A difference keepson increasing
A difference can increasebut also decrease
It’s a bit similar to a winding mountain road. Take the wrong turn or make the wrong step and you could end up somewhere completely else!
Is life a complex system?
linear non-linear
9
The physical/mathematical aspect
Complex systems often exhibit the following characteristics:
RobustnessSelf-organizationAdaptability
Furthermore:
Clear mathematical definitionBasically deterministic
Is life a complex system?
10
The biological aspect
Clearly, life is “built” up by combining many elements at many levels
Phospholipids Cell (intra)Cell (inter)Etc.
→ Cell walls→ DNA (made of base-pairs)→ Multi-cellular organisms
Is life a complex system?
Next, let us investigate whether some of the characteristics of a physical complex system can be found in living systems.
11
H
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
OC
OH
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
OC
OH
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
OC
OH
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
Tristearin
Glycerol
Fatty acidHydrocarbon chain
Is life a complex system?
12
H
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
OC
OH
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
OC
OH
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
H
C
H
C
C
C
H
H
H
H
Chephalin (= Phosphatidyl ethanolamine)
GlycerolFatty acidHydrocarbon chain
+
O
H..
-N C
OH
POC
OH
H H
H
HFatty acid replaced by phosphate group and nitrogen containing molecule
Is life a complex system?
13
The biological aspect
The interesting thing is that phospholipids can from bi-layers
The properties of the bi-layer are rather different from those of its elements
Schematically, phospholipids can be drawn as
where the hydrocarbon chains are represented as wiggly tails.
The tails are hydrophobicThe heads are hydrophilic
~5nm
Is life a complex system?
14
The biological aspect
They can also form micelles or vesicles
The bi-layer is semi-permeable,H2O, e.g., can diffuse through.
Hence at the molecular level, we already see that the sum is different from the elements so lets jump the gun and draw some conclusions …
Giant vesicles can be larger than 1 m!
Is life a complex system?
15
The biological aspect
Hence I believe it is fair to describe life as a complex system!
Let us look back at our definition: A complex system is a system of interacting elements whose collective behavior cannot be described as the simple sum the elements’ behavior
We have also seen that:
Phospholipids
can form membranes
A Cell behaves very differently from its components
DNA by itself is static
..and it is clear that cells posses the following qualities:
• Robustness• Self-organization• Adaptability
But the cell is alive
Is life a complex system?
16
Life is a complex system.
Common Points Differing Points
ElementsCollective Behavior
RobustnessSelf-organizationAdaptable
Underlying equations not available in the Life SciencesBio systems are not deterministic (at least not in the same way).
Is life a complex system?
17
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Bio
Coupled Map Lattice
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
A coupled map lattice is a collection of individual (chaotic) elements connected by some sort of “rubber” bands.
Once the prevailing view was akin to “there’s a gene for everything a cell does”. Now that we know that there are less than 30K genes a different picture is necessary.
18
The logistic map is the element
This means that one starts with a certain value, calculates the result and then uses this result as the starting value of a next calculation.
2n1n αx1x
223 αx1x
212 αx1x
201 αx1x
given
The logistic map is defined as:
Step 1
Step 3
Step 2
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
19
Plot 200 successive values of xfor every value of
The so-called bifurcation diagram
As the nonlinearity increases we sometimes encounter chaos
21nn αx1x
nx
α
n
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
20
The bifurcation diagram exhibits unexpected properties.
Let's enlarge this area
The marvelous bifurcation diagram
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
21
An almost identical diagram!
Let's try this again...
The marvelous bifurcation diagram
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
22
This time, let us enlarge a much smaller area.
Now let's enlarge this area
Hard to see, isn't it?
This is the region we enlarged before
The marvelous bifurcation diagram
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
23
Amazing! It’s basically the same again.
Indeed, the bifurcation diagram contains an infinite number of ever repeating structures.
The marvelous bifurcation diagram
Hence, even though the underlying equation is very simple we have a ‘source’ of limitless complexity.
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
24
We can think of the logistic map as a simple chaotic oscillator.
Then we can construct a system of interacting elements by simply tying them together with “rubber bands”.
This yields a so-called coupled map lattice. A simple prototype for a complex system.
Our element is the logistic map
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
25
Coupled Map Lattices
The coupled map discussed here is simply an array of logistic maps. The formula appears more complicated than it is.
Or in other words:
f is the logistic map
f( ) f( ) f( )Time n
Time n+1
)()(2
)()1( 111
i
nin
in
in xfxfxfx
2
2
1
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
26
Frozen RandomPattern
Parts of the lattice are chaotic and parts of the lattice are periodic.The dynamics is dominated by the band structure of the logisticmap.
Coupled Map Lattices
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
27
Even though the nonlinearity has increased and the logistic map ischaotic for a=1.7, the lattice is entirely periodic.
My Research
Pattern Selection
Coupled Map Lattices
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
28
The coupled map lattice is symmetric, yet here we see atravelling wave. This dynamical behaviour is highly non-trivial!
Travelling Waves
Coupled Map Lattices
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
29
Of course we have spatio-temporal chaos too. No order to be foundhere ... or ??? . No, despite the way it looks, this is far from random!
Spatio-temporalChaos
Coupled Map Lattices
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
30
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
From Oxford English Dictionary:
1970 Sci. Amer. Oct. 19/1 The human genome..consists of perhaps as many as 10 million genes.
In this context it is particularly noteworthy that:
In fact:
The human genome has only about 30 thousand genes! This is a remarkably small number.
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
31
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
Complementary to considering DNA as a hard disk is the idea that evolution is a process of natural genetic engineering. It should be stressed that this is a complex systems view and does not require ‘intelligent’ as in ‘divine’ design. The genetic engineering properties are simply consequences of (by natural selection) surviving systems designs. The most simple ones reflecting nothing but the chemical properties of its constituents (e.g. bi-layers made of phospholipids).
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
32
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
A genome consists of many parts. The most commonly studied parts (due to their perceived relevance for medical applications) are the so-called coding regions that determine the proteins that can be synthesized.
The other regions are often referred to as junk!Is that a reasonable assessment though?
In fact there are many classes genomicinformation:
?
?
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
33
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
• start and stop sites for transcription• control signals for e.g. level of expression• Signals for chromatin remodeling• Signals for DNA replication• Signals for DNA repair
It is very important to realize that the genome only functions in response to its environment. DNA, by itself, doesn’t do anything, it is inert.The information stored in the DNA is only activated due to its interaction with the rest of the cell (this should be obvious considering e.g. cell differentiation).
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
34
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
A concrete example: The lac operon
OED: operon: A unit of co-ordinated gene activity which is believed to account for inducible and repressible enzymes in bacteria and hence for the regulation of protein synthesis, and is usu. conceived as a linear sequence of genetic material comprising an operator, a promoter, and one or more structural genes.
The lac operon encodes the capacity for lactose utilization in E. coli.
1947lac The operon is a small section
of the genome
What is interesting, though, is that E. coli can distinguish glucose and lactose. If available, they’ll first consume the glucose. Hence there must be some kind of mechanism to regulated this.
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
35
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
1961
And of course it wouldn’t end here:
YZO AI
Structural genes for encoding the proteins of lactose transport and metabolism
An operator: here, the site where the repressor binds to stop lacZYA (note this is not a gene!)
Regulator gene that encodes a repressor protein
It’s not that simple!
YZO AI
O2O3 CRP P O
Co-operative binding site for the repressor together with O3The repressor binding site
A promoter siteBinding site for the transcription factor that mediates glucose control
Co-operative binding site for the repressor together with O2
1990
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
36
DNA as a ‘hard disk’
Overall, the cell performs the following computation:
IF lactose presentAND glucose not presentAND cell can actually synthesize active LacZ and LacY
THEN transcribe lacZYA from lacP
It is important to note that the computation involves many molecules and compartments of the cell, not just DNA. E.g. the availability of lactose needs to be signaled to it.
Examples of complex systems in Physics and Biology
37
Digressing a bit, thinking of Life as a complex system we bring together:
Study of Life as a complex system
It is of course impossible to give even a remotely complete list. But topics will include:
Complex systems theory, developmental biology, biophysics and bio-molecular science
Construction of Artificial Life Systems Analysis of Dynamic Life Processes Robust Developmental Processes
Study of Life as a complex system
38
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
Coupled Map Lattice with growth and death
Amoebae
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
39
Coupled Map Lattice with growth and death
)(ixn
Model by Kaneko 1997
We can represent the internal state by the variable.
Let us assume we have a system of very simple interacting cells that receive a fixed amount of “food” each unit of time.
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
40
Coupled Map Lattice with growth and death
nnnn Sixfixix ))(()()(1
N
jxfs
S jn
n
))((Amount of foods such that the total food for all cells is s.
)(2sin2
))(( ixK
ixf nn
K is a “parameter”
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
41
Coupled Map Lattice with growth and death
The formulas on the previous sheet are not enough to obtain ‘cell-type’ dynamics. In order to do so, we’ll need to have criteria for growth and death.
A) A cell splits when
B) A cell dies when 0)( ixn
10)( ixn
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
42
Coupled Map Lattice with growth and death
For increasing K, there are three basic phases
1) Ordered Phase2) Partially Ordered Phase3) Desynchronized Phase
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
43
1) Ordered Phase
Cells tend to be synchronized.When a cell splits, there are two clusters for a short time.
K = 2.0
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
44
2) Partially Ordered Phase
The number of clusters fluctuates between 1 and N
K = 3.3
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
45
3) Desynchronized Phase
Typically the cells are desyncronised.
K = 4.0
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
46
Amoebae
Oxford English Dictionary:
A microscopic animalcule (class Protozoa) consisting of a single cell of gelatinous sarcode, the outer layer of which is highly extensile and contractile, and the inner fluid and mobile, so that the shape of the animal is perpetually changing.
I would now like to show some of the dynamics of the Dictyostelium amoebae. A good reference site is:http://www.zi.biologie.uni-muenchen.de/zoologie/dicty/dicty.html
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
47
Amoebae
Darkfield Waves
The coordinated chemotactic movement of cells can be seen as propagating darkfield waves in aggregates, where the waves propagate mostly as spirals, in streaming mounds where the waves appear as multiarmed spirals in the mound transforming into single waves fronts in the aggregation streams. In slugs waves can be seen to propagate from the tip towards the end of the prespore zone.
Professor Cornelis WeijerProfessor of Developmental PhysiologyUniversity of Dundee
From his website
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
48
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
Lifecycle ofDictyostelium
49
Amoebae
Side view of an older Dictyostelium discoideum slug stained with neutral red. The migration of older slugs (48 h and more) is characterised by a strong periodic up- and downward movement of the whole prestalk region. This is accompanied by the repeated aggregation of anterior-like cells at the prestalk-prespore boundary, where they stop, while at the same time the unstained prespore cells continue to move over the pile. The tip of the slug is lifted from the substrate into the air until it becomes unstable and falls back onto the agar surface. Time between successive images: 20 seconds. Scale bar: 100 µm, (see Dormann D., Siegert F. & C.J.Weijer (1996), Development, 122, 761-769
Migrating Slug
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
50
Amoebae
Side view of a culminating Dictyostelium discoideum slug stained with neutral red. During early culmination all cells in the prestalk zone rotate. Later during stalk tube formation the prestalk cells rotate most vigorous at the prestalk-prespore boundary. Time between successive images: 5 seconds. Scale bar: 50 µm, (see Dormann D., Siegert F. & C.J.Weijer (1996), Development, 122, 761-769
Cluminating Slug
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology
51
Amoebae
Time-lapse video showing slug formation, migration and culmination. From R. Chisholm, Northwestern University
Lifecycle
Examples of studies of life as a complex system from Physics and Biology