12070_2015_927_author j

Upload: rajendran-dinesh-kumar

Post on 05-Jul-2018

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    1/9

    Dear Author,

    Here are the proofs of your article.

    • You can submit your correctionsonline, via e-mail or by fax.

    • For online submission please insert your corrections in the online correction form. Always

    indicate the line number to which the correction refers.

    • You can also insert your corrections in the proof PDF andemail the annotated PDF.

    • For fax submission, please ensure that your corrections are clearly legible. Use a fine black 

    pen and write the correction in the margin, not too close to the edge of the page.

    • Remember to note the journal title, article number, and your name when sending your

    response via e-mail or fax.

    • Check the metadata sheet to make sure that the header information, especially author names

    and the corresponding affiliations are correctly shown.

    • Check the questions that may have arisen during copy editing and insert your answers/ corrections.

    • Check that the text is complete and that all figures, tables and their legends are included. Also

    check the accuracy of special characters, equations, and electronic supplementary material if 

    applicable. If necessary refer to the Edited manuscript .

    • The publication of inaccurate data such as dosages and units can have serious consequences.

    Please take particular care that all such details are correct.

    • Please do not make changes that involve only matters of style. We have generally introduced

    forms that follow the journal’s style.

    Substantial changes in content, e.g., new results, corrected values, title and authorship are notallowed without the approval of the responsible editor. In such a case, please contact the

    Editorial Office and return his/her consent together with the proof.

    • If we do not receive your correctionswithin 48 hours, we will send you a reminder.

    • Your article will be publishedOnline First approximately one week after receipt of your

    corrected proofs. This is the official first publication citable with the DOI. Further changes

    are, therefore, not possible.

    • The printed version will follow in a forthcoming issue.

    Please note

    After online publication, subscribers (personal/institutional) to this journal will have access to the

    complete article via the DOI using the URL: http://dx.doi.org/[DOI].

    If you would like to know when your article has been published online, take advantage of our free

    alert service. For registration and further information go to: http://www.link.springer.com.

    Due to the electronic nature of the procedure, the manuscript and the original figures will only be

    returned to you on special request. When you return your corrections, please inform us if you would

    like to have these documents returned.

    http://www.link.springer.com/

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    2/9

    Metadata of the article that will be visualized in

    OnlineFirst

    ArticleTitle Endoscopic Ear Surgery: Critical Review of Anatomy and Physiology of Normal and Reconstructive

    Middle Ear

    Article Sub-Title

    Article CopyRight Association of Otolaryngologists of India

    (This will be the copyright line in the final PDF)

    Journal Name Indian Journal of Otolaryngology and Head & Neck Surgery

    Corresponding Author Family Name Dinesh Kumar

    Particle

    Given Name Rajendran

    Suffix

    Division Department of ENT and Head-Neck Surgery

    Organization Navodaya Medical College Hospital and Research Centre

    Address Raichur, Karnataka, 584 103, India

    Email [email protected]

    Author Family Name Udagatti

    Particle

    Given Name Vithal D.

    Suffix

    Division

    Organization N.R.M ENT Hospital

    Address Near Mahila Samaj, Raichur, Karnataka, 584101, India

    Email [email protected]

    Schedule

    Received 9 October 2015

    Revised

    Accepted 7 December 2015

    Abstract Middle ear anatomy is complex hence it is difficult to study the microscopic vibration of tympanic

    membrane and ossicles. The basic research has been done in few centres. Our experience is based on

    clinical data. The lack of quantitative understanding of structural and functional relationship in the

    mechanical response of the normal and reconstructed middle ear is major factor in poor hearing results

    after surgery (Merchant et al. in J Laryngol Otol 112:715–731, 1998). The vibration pattern of tympanic

    membrane changes with different frequencies. It depends upon shape, position and tension of tympanic

    membrane. Sometimes reconstructed tympanic membrane loses its shape and tension and thus its vibratory

    response (Pusalkar and Steinbach in Transplants and implants in otology II, 1992). Then what should be

    the shape, position, tension of the tympanic membrane and the ossicles. In order to have a serviceable

    hearing, dry and safe ear, there is a necessity of answering all these queries by us.

    Keywords (separated by '-') Endoscopic ear surgery - Tympanic membrane - Ossicles - Vibratory pattern

    Footnote Information

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    3/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    O R I G I N A L A R T I C L E1

    2   Endoscopic Ear Surgery: Critical Review of Anatomy

    3   and Physiology of Normal and Reconstructive Middle Ear

    4   Vithal D. Udagatti2

    • Rajendran Dinesh Kumar1

    5   Received: 9 October 2015 / Accepted: 7 December 20156    Association of Otolaryngologists of India 2015

    7   Abstract   Middle ear anatomy is complex hence it is

    8   difficult to study the microscopic vibration of tympanic9   membrane and ossicles. The basic research has been done

    10   in few centres. Our experience is based on clinical data.

    11   The lack of quantitative understanding of structural and

    12   functional relationship in the mechanical response of the

    13   normal and reconstructed middle ear is major factor in poor

    14   hearing results after surgery (Merchant et al. in J Laryngol

    15   Otol 112:715–731,   1998). The vibration pattern of tym-

    16   panic membrane changes with different frequencies. It

    17   depends upon shape, position and tension of tympanic

    18   membrane. Sometimes reconstructed tympanic membrane

    19   loses its shape and tension and thus its vibratory response

    20   (Pusalkar and Steinbach in Transplants and implants in

    21   otology II, 1992). Then what should be the shape, position,

    22   tension of the tympanic membrane and the ossicles. In

    23   order to have a serviceable hearing, dry and safe ear, there

    24   is a necessity of answering all these queries by us.

    25

    26   Keywords   Endoscopic ear surgery 

    27   Tympanic membrane   Ossicles     Vibratory pattern

    28Introduction

    29Endoscope ear surgery is not the technique what we nor-

    30mally find and learn from the text books, at least in the

    31beginning of the era of the endoscopic ear surgery. Middle

    32ear endoscopy was first introduced by Mer and colleagues

    33in 1967 but till the last decade endoscopes have been

    34mainly used for diagnostic and photographic purposes.

    35Recently few surgeons have been doing endoscopic middle

    36ear surgery [3] (Fig.  1).

    37In the 70’s of last century, the concept of the ear surgery

    38was dry cavity and dry ear. Some seniors were doing

    39grafting to cover the perforated ear drum and the concept

    40changed to safe ear. Though ossiculoplasty and tym-

    41panoplasty was primarily much talked subject but hearing

    42restoration was secondary in nature. Even up to 90’s of last

    43century, every third child we saw in our practice used to be

    44with ear discharge.

    45Now there is dramatic reduction in ear discharge cases.

    46This probably is due to

    47(1) Introduction of newer molecules of antibiotics, anti-

    48inflammatory and anti allergy drugs.

    49(2) Good health education by medical faculty.

    50(3) Practice of hygienic condition by parents.

    51Nowadays the patient’s symptomatology has changed to

    52hard of hearing after one or two bouts of discharge during

    53their childhood and they are desirous of prompt rectifica-

    54tion and restoration of hearing. We did reconstructive

    55surgery with our old technique by using the microscope;

    56pts were not satisfied with results.

    57Then we sat back and started critically reviewing our

    58technique. At that movement we peeped through endo-

    59scope into the ear. Better illumination, higher magnifica-

    60tion, ability to have repeated observation and better

    A1   &   Rajendran Dinesh Kumar

    A2 [email protected]

    A3 Vithal D. Udagatti

    A4 [email protected]

    A5  1

    Department of ENT and Head-Neck Surgery, Navodaya

    A6 Medical College Hospital and Research Centre, Raichur,

    A7 Karnataka 584 103, India

    A8  2

    N.R.M ENT Hospital, Near Mahila Samaj, Raichur,

    A9 Karnataka 584101, India

    AQ1

    AQ2

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

    DOI 10.1007/s12070-015-0927-3

    http://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1007/s12070-015-0927-3&domain=pdfhttp://crossmark.crossref.org/dialog/?doi=10.1007/s12070-015-0927-3&domain=pdfhttp://orcid.org/0000-0001-6136-130X

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    4/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    61   documentation changed our perspective views regarding

    62   the normal anatomy physiology of ear and its reconstruc-

    63   tive technique [3].

    64   Anatomy

    65   Ear is series of compartments- external ear, middle ear and

    66   internal ear. The external ear permits sound to reach the ear

    67   drum, it is elliptical (Fig. 2). Middle ear pneumatic cavity,

    68   bounded by bony walls except laterally where, tympanic

    69   membrane is located, which is cone shaped, obliquely

    70   placed tense and transparent with surface area of 80 sq

    71   mms and vibrative area of 55 sq mms. Tympanic mem-

    72   brane is formed by endothelial, fibrous and epithelial lay-

    73   ers. Fibrous layer is converging from annulus tympanicus

    74   which is tugged into tympanic sulcus and is attached to

    75   handle of malleus (Figs. 3,  4).

    76   Eustachian tube is trachea of the ear connecting middle

    77   ear to nasopharynx. Tensor palati muscle guards its

    78   nasopharyngeal end and acts like sphincter and regulates

    79   the air flow [4] (Fig. 5).

    80Round window is covered with semi permeable mem-

    81brane and takes part in pressure release of inner ear and its

    82surface area is 2 sq mms. Oval window is closed by foot

    83plate of stapes which has surface area of 3.2 sq mm.

    84Ossicles extend from tympanic membrane to oval window.

    Fig. 1   Endoscopic view of middle ear

    Fig. 2   Endoscopic view of external auditory cannal. It is elliptical

    Fig. 3  Endoscopic view of tympanic membrane, it is cone shaped,

    Obliquely placed, tensed and transparent

    Fig. 4   Endoscopic view of middle ear (bone), Tympanic sulcus, Oval

    window and round window, Surface area and plane

    Fig. 5   Endoscopic view of eustachian tube opening in middle ear

    AQ3

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    5/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    85   The articular facet covers 90 % of surface area of 

    86   malleus head. Other two bones to have this type of articular

    87   facet are Humerus and Femur. They articulate over fixed

    88   bones, scapula and pelvis. Both Shoulder and hip joints are

    89   dynamic synovial joints and articulate to 360 degrees.

    90   Though having same articulate facet but malleus will not

    91   articulate over medial wall of middle ear (attic region).

    92   It hangs by ligaments in middle ear space, only handle

    93   attached to the tympanic membrane and articulate with

    94   incus. Incus has four articular facets two on its body which

    95   articulates with the malleus head, thus it vibrates along

    96   with malleus as a single unit (Figs. 6,  7).

    97   This ossicle also hangs in middle ear space by liga-

    98   ments, except articulate with fossa incudis by articular

    99   facet over its short process, causing axial vibration. Facet

    100   over the long process articulate with facet over stapes head.

    101   Stapes is not a solid ossicle but is like inverted tuning fork 

    102   with a foot plate (Figs. 8,  9). All synovial joints, whether

    103   they are hinge joints also and move in particular direction.

    104Where are the Muscles to Cause the Movements?

    105Two muscles- tensor tympani originate in tympanic canal.

    106Stapes muscle originates in the pyramid and inserted to the

    107ossicles. Thus they take part in the stability and protecting

    108the inner ear against loud sounds but will not cause the

    109movements, because muscles do not originate and insert in

    110the neighboring ossicles.

    111Then, What Does This Ossicular Chain Do?

    112Probable it is only a vibration along with tympanic mem-

    113brane and transforming the vibration to foot plate and

    114cochlear fluid.The chronological reduction of weight of 

    115ossicles helps to enhance the stapes linear movement.

    116Mucus membrane is composite having stratified ciliated

    117columnar epithelium and squamous epithelium and quan-

    118tum of air space is 6 ml in volume including mastoid air

    119cells [1, 4].

    Fig. 6   Endoscopic view of malleus. Articular surface cover 90 % of 

    its head

    Fig. 7   -Endoscopic view of incus. It has four articular facets two on

    body and one on each in long and short processes

    Fig. 8   Endoscopic view of stapes. It has only one articular facet on

    head

    Fig. 9   Endoscopic view of stapes (lateral view). Stapes is not a solid

    bone instead it is a hallow arch like tyre

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    6/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    120  Stapes, long process of incus and tendons of the muscles

    121   are visceral contents of mesotympanum. Chorda tympani

    122   and handle of the malleus are in tympanic membrane. No

    123   mucosal folds in mesotympanum which help in the free air

    124   flow (Fig. 10).

    125   Thus annulus, handle of malleus, fibrous layer and two

    126   muscles take part in changing the shape and tension of 

    127   tympanic membrane and ossicles [5]. Malleus and incus

    128   acts as a unit and are in horizontal plane where as stapes in

    129   vertical plane and two planes are of 45 degree angulation

    130   [1].

    131   Physiology

    132   External Auditory Canal

    133   Ear canal acts as resonator and it resonates between 2000 to

    134   5000 cycles/s.

    135   Middle Ear 

    136   If sound energy hits inner ear directly most of energy

    137   would be reflected because of resistance of fluid media

    138   hence there is need for transformer mechanism that is filled

    139   by middle ear (Air media to solid media to fluid media).140   The cone shaped, tensed transparent tympanic mem-

    141   brane provides optimal acoustic pick up, at this level first

    142   transduction takes place (i.e. sound energy converts to

    143   mechanical energy) Vibrative pattern of tympanic mem-

    144   brane is complex and it changes with different frequency.

    145   The sound energy that reaches tympanic membrane

    146   (vibrative area 55 sq mms) is conducted across the chain

    147   and concentrated on stapes foot plate (3.2 sq mm) and the

    148   ratio being 17.1:1. Length of handle of malleus is 9 mm

    149and long process of incus is 7 mm and the ratio being 1.3:1

    150which two factors combined enhance the sound transmis-

    151sion through the middle ear and overcome the resistance of 

    152liquid media.

    153Middle ear aeration helps for optimal vibration and

    154middle ear muscles provide stability and tension to ossicles

    155and tympanic membrane. After acoustic pickup and

    156transduction of sound energy into mechanical vibration, it157passes through the ossicular coupling. Vibration of the

    158tympanic membrane also travels through the air in the

    159middle ear and vibrates both foot plate of stapes and round

    160window membrane. This is called acoustic coupling.

    161•   Net vibrative pressure difference at

    162Oval window and round window is  =   Ossicular cou-

    163pling  ?   Acoustic coupling.

    164•   Stapes volume vibrative velocity  =   Linear vibration of 

    165stapes  9  area of foot plate.

    166•  Net Vibrative pressure transfer to the cochlear

    167fluid  =  Ossicular coupling  ?  Acoustic cou-

    168pling  9  area of foot plate/Impedance of fluid  ?  annu-

    169lar ligament of stapes.

    170Following are the functions of tympanic membrane.

    1711. Lateral border of middle ear.

    1722. Protects against spreading of the infection from the

    173External auditory canal.

    1743. Creates air column- thus protects against the entry of 

    175nasal regurgitation, autophonia and also clearance of 

    176the middle ear.

    1774. Maximum acoustic pick up.1785. Transduction

    1796. Middle ear gain

    1807. Bone Conduction gain.

    181Certain questions are thus raised during reconstructive

    182surgery.

    183Question

    184Whether stenosis of the EAC reduces the resonating

    185quality? Does canaloplasty enhance it? Does mastoid 

    186cavity alter it?   [1]  (Goode et al. 1997)

    187 Answer 

    1881. Middle ear pathology is tackled transmeatally and

    189mastoid post aurally without elevating the meatal skin

    190because Endoscope brings the surgeons eye to tip of 

    191the scope, hence the view through endoscope is not

    192restricted by the narrow segment of external auditory

    193canal and anterior and posterior buldge, so no need of 

    Fig. 10   Endoscopic view of middle ear. Stapes long process of incus

    and tendons of the muscles are visceral contents of the mesotympa-

    num. Chorda tympani and handle of the malleus are in the tympanic

    membrane

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    7/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    194   canaloplasty. Doesn’t amount to risk of meatal

    195   stenosis.

    196   2. Endoscope mounted with camera and visualized

    197   through monitor will remove the disadvantage of 

    198   monocular vision which would have lead to the loss of 

    199   depth of perception.

    200   3. Endoscope view gives better illumination and higher

    201   magnification, it gives flexible movements and middle202   ear can be observed in different angles and fields

    203   easily.

    204   4. Endoscope gives wide angled view which includes the

    205   entire tympanic membrane the graft and medial end of 

    206   external auditory canal at one frame so positioning the

    207   graft was much easier and precise.

    208   Question

    209   1. Whether in tympanoplasty removal of annulus from

    210  sulcus (inlay and inter lay grafting) changes shape and 

    211   tension of tympanic membrane?

    212   Answer 

    213   Yes. Do not remove the annulus from sulcus either do

    214   onlay or inlay to onlay technique.

    215   Question

    216   2. Can the graft which is dry dead inert material (tem-

    217   poralis fascia) and absorbed by phagocyte activity and 218   healed with only endothelial and epithelial layer main-

    219   tain the tension shape of tympanic membrane?

    220   Answer 

    221   The aim of the grafting is epithelization, endothelial-

    222   ization and vascularisation (converting the graft material

    223   into fibrous layer). So use the wet graft which is not

    224   scraped and crushed, it can act like fibrous layer and

    225   over it endothelial and epithelial layer develops.Minimal

    226   dissection and creating tympanomeatal epithelial flaps

    227   will help in vascularisation.

    228   Question

    229   Is it necessary only malleus is attached to tympanic

    230   membrane?

    231 Answer 

    232Yes, it is necessary to have free movements of malleus

    233and incus and it can be achieved only when graft

    234material placed lateral to the handle of malleus.

    235Question

    236Whether ratio of tympanic membrane and foot plate of 

    237stapes is to be maintained?

    238 Answer 

    239Yes.

    240Then how to maintain it in stapedectomy? (Rasowsky

    241and Merchant 1995)[6].

    242Question

    243Whether middle ear air space & pressure is necessary

    244 for vibration?

    245 Answer 

    246Yes. In canal down technique bony canal can be reduced

    247up to annular sulcus only and graft should put over it

    248because at least 0.5 ml of air has to be maintained in the

    249middle ear.

    250Question

    251 Is it necessary to maintain horizontal plane of 

    252malleoincus unit and vertical plan of stapes?

    253 Answer 

    254Needs further evaluation ossicles weight share stout and

    255cramping should be appropriate for free vibration of 

    256them in middle ear air chamber. It is an observation that

    257presence of the supra structure of the stapes helps in the258good hearing than only a foot plate.

    259The inverted tuning fork shape and the resonance of the

    260stapes are entirely different of columella effect.(How can

    261columellar vibrative pattern replace the pattern of the

    262chain system). Thus, we have limited understanding of 

    263mechanics of ossicular reconstruction.

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    8/9

       U   N  C   O

       R   R   E  C

       T   E   D P   R

       O   O   F

    264   Question

    265   Is it necessary to have muscle attachment to ossicles to

    266   maintain shape and tension of the ossicles?

    267   Answer 

    268   Yes.

    269

    270   1. Try to preserve the ossicles and muscle attachments.

    271   Do not become too radical to middle ear during

    272   cholesteatoma clearance because it is very difficult

    273   to create muscles, ossicles and their articular

    274   surfaces [7].

    275   2. Continuity of the mucosa of middle ear avoids

    276   adhesions

    277   3. Patency of Eustachian tube should be maintained by

    278   clearing and suctioning the tube.

    279   4. No gel foam in the middle ear- creates instantaneous280   air chamber, soaked with the blood and swollen gel

    281   foam may change position of graft material.

    282   Question

    283   What about the patency of Eustachian tube?

    284   Answer 

    285   Should be maintained by clearing and suctioning the

    286   tube.

    287   Conclusion

    288   Endoscope view gives better illumination and higher

    289   magnification. It gives flexible movements and middle ear

    290   can be observed in different angles and fields easily. Shape,

    291   position, tension of tympanic membrane and ossicles are at

    292   most important to maintain during reconstruction surgery.

    293   It is very much difficult to create articular surface of 

    294   ossicles and muscles to have proper chain movements

    295along with vibrating tympanic membrane so try to preserve

    296them wherever possible. Creation of near normal anatomy

    297of middle ear in reconstructive surgery will provide max-

    298imum hearing improvement.

    299Lastly this helps in creating good hearing, safe and dry

    300ear. Endoscope ear surgery is far easier than microscopic

    301surgery.   302

    303Compliance with Ethical Standards

    304Conflict of interest   None.

    305Ethical Approval   All procedures performed in studies involving306human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of 307the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964308Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical309standards.

    310Informed Consent   Informed consent was obtained from all indi-311vidual participants included in the study.

    312References

    3131. Merchant SN, Ravicz ME, Voss SE, Peake WT, Rosowski JJ314(1998) Middle ear mechanics in normal, diseased and recon-315structed ears. J Laryngol Otol 112:715–7313162. Pusalkar AG, Steinbach E (1992) Gold implants in middle ear317reconstructive surgery. In: Yanagihara N, Suzuki J (eds) Trans-318plants and implants in otology II. Matsuyama, Japan, pp 111–1133193. Haragop S, Mudhol RS, Godhi RA (2008) A comparative study of 320endoscope assisted myringoplasty and micrsoscope assisted321myringoplasty. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 60:298–3023224. Udwadia R (2000) Brief review of current studies on otitis media323with effusion. In: Shah VH, Karnik P (eds) Otolaryngology review3242000, a collection of review articles. Alembic Limited, Surat,

    325pp 46–493265. Hawkins JE (2014) Human ear.   http://www.britannica.com/ 327science/ear#toc65029. Accessed 14 Dec 20143286. Merchant SN, Rosowski JJ, Raicz ME (1995) Middle ear329mechanics of type 4 and 5 tympanoplasty—clinical analysis and330surgical implantation. Am J Otol 16(5):565–5753317. Desai ABR, Desai A (2000) Tympanomastoid surgery today–the332principle & practice. In: Shah VH, Karnik P (eds) Otolaryngology333review 2000, a collection of review articles. Alembic Limited,334Surat, pp 54–673358. Mahadevaiah A, Parikh B (2009) Use of autogenic and allogenic336malleus in tympanic membrane to footplate assembly—long-term337results. Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 61:9–13

    AQ4

    Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg

     1 3Journal :  Large_Springer-India12070   Dispatch :   14-12-2015   Pages :   6

    Article No. :   927h   LE   h   TYPESET

    MS Code :   IJOO-D-15-00449   h   CP   h   DISK 4 4

    http://www.britannica.com/science/ear%23toc65029http://www.britannica.com/science/ear%23toc65029http://www.britannica.com/science/ear%23toc65029http://www.britannica.com/science/ear%23toc65029

  • 8/16/2019 12070_2015_927_Author j

    9/9

    Journal :   12070

    Article :  927  1 3the language of science

    Author Query Form

    Please ensure you fill out your response to the queries raised below and return this form along

    with your corrections

    Dear Author

    During the process of typesetting your article, the following queries have arisen. Please check your typeset proof carefully

    against the queries listed below and mark the necessary changes either directly on the proof/online grid or in the ‘Author’s

    response’ area provided below

    Query Details Required Author’s Response

    AQ1   Please check and confirm the author name and initials are correct for the author (Rajendran DineshKumar).

    AQ2   References [1, 2] are cited in Abstract section only. As per style all references should be cited in text.Please appropriate citations for references [1, 2].

    AQ3   Please confirm the section level headings are correctly identified.

    AQ4   Reference [8] was provided in the reference list; however, this was not mentioned or cited in themanuscript. As a rule, if a citation is present in the text, then it should be present in the list. Please providethe location of where to insert the reference citation in the main body text. Kindly ensure that allreferences are cited in ascending numerical order.