16. six_the sins of greenwhasing

8/16/2019 16. Six_the Sins of Greenwhasing

1/15

#$ %&'( &')* +, -.$$)/0*#')1 2 3

4 &5678 +, 9):'.+);$)50< =+.5# 4;$.'?0) =+)*6;$. 20.@$5*

4 A-.$$) B0C$.D E8"$..0=#+'?$ 9):'.+);$)50< 20.@$5')1 F)?G

H>+:$;E$. IJJKL


2/15

0E% ?;":71111111111111111111111 G T !"# %& @"AA"#5 11111111111111111111111 NNNGGGT

P$?+;;$)705'+)* ,+. =+)?$.)$7 =+)*6;$.*NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGGG U

P$?+;;$)705'+)* ,+. 20.@$5$.*NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNG K

=+)?


3/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

!"##$%&'() +," ē $-&ŏ ()-. /&0()-1 2 !"#$% 3)# '43 56 78(9#':8$, 45$(;7#"( "#,'":8$, 3)# #$ 56 H$"#=5"3#: 8$ 3)# =5=;9'" ="#((@ A)# "8(# 8$ B,"##$F7'"K#38$, 49'87( )'( '9(5 ?##$ c :54;7#$3#:@N#(( (3;:8#: 8( 3)# '=='"#$3 8$4"#'(# 8$B,"##$&'()8$,F 2 6'9(# 5" 78(9#':8$, ,"##$

7'"K#38$, 49'87(@M$ '$ #665"3 35 :#(4"8?#. ;$:#"(3'$:. '$: O;'$386>3)# ,"5&3) 56 ,"##$&'()8$,. A#""'I)584#H$ 6'9(# 5" 3)'3 "8(K 78(9#':8$, 8$3#$:#:';:8#$4#(@

V'(#: 5$ 3)# (;" "#(;93(. 8:#$3868#: (8D='33#"$( 8$ 3)# ,"##$&'()8$,. &)84) $5&"#45,$8W# '( 3)# BC8D C8$( 56 !"##$&'()8$,AEF@

A)#(# 68$:8$,( (;,,#(3 3)'3 ,"##$&'()8$, 8(=#"


4/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

b#(#' 4)*E#3)5:595,>*M$ 3)# (="8$, 56 [QQS. A#""'I)584# (#$3 "#(#'"4)

3#'7( 8$35 (8D 4'3#,5">/9#':8$, ?8, ?5D (35"#( &83)8$(3";4385$( 35 "#45": # "#6#"#$4#( 566#"#:65" 6;"3)#" 8$65"7'385$@

G63#" "#45":8$, P.STU #$ (;,,#(38$, '="5:;43 8( B,"##$F ?'(#: 5$ ' (8$,9##$&55:1 3)'3 ="5753# 3)#8""#4>49#: 45$3#$3 5" (;(3'8$'?9# )'"


5/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

♦ L6684# 3#4)$595,> +="8$3#"(. 45=8#"(. 6'D7'4)8$#(1 3)'3 ="5753# #$#",> #66848#$4> &83)5;3'33#$385$ 35 )'W'":5;( 7'3#"8'9 45$3#$3. 8$:55"'8" O;'983>. 5" 457='38?8983> &83) "#4>49#: ='=#" 5""#7'$;6'43;"#: 35$#" 4'"3"8:,#(@

♦ L3)#" ="5:;43 49'87( 3)'3 4577833#: 3)8( (8$8$49;:# 8$K 4'"3"8:,#(. 9';$:"> :#3#",#$3(. :8():#3#",#$3. '8" 6"#()#$#"(. ?'3)"557 49#'$#"(.7'"K#"(. 6955"8$, 9'78$'3#. ?',(. 7;938/=;"=5(#49#'$#"(. &55: ='$#9(. '$: =#(3848:#(@

'( &*+-&/0&9( & '44#((8?9#(;==5"38$, 8$65"7'385$. 5" ?> ' "#98'?9# 3)8":/='"3>4#"38684'385$. 457783( 3)# C8$ 56 J5 \"556@ +_5" 3)8("#(#'"4). :#3#"78$#: 3)#"# 35 ?# g$5 ="556h 86(;==5"38$, # :#68$#: 5"?"5': 3)'3 83( "#'9 7#'$8$, 8( 98K#9> 35 ?#78(;$:#"(355: ?> 3)# 8$3#$:#: 45$(;7#"@

A)#"# '"# (57# "#4;""8$, 3)#7#( &83)8$ 3)#(# ,#$. '$: ('93 '"# '99=53#$38'99> )'W'":5;(@

♦ BG99 J'3;"'9F@ G"(#$84 8( $'3;"'9@ C5 '"# ;"'$8;7.7#"4;">. '$: 65"7'9:#)>:#@ G99 '"# =58(5$5;(@

♦ B!"##$F. BH$F. '$: BH45/45$(485;(F +35 $'7# i;(3 ' 6#&1 &)84) '"# ;33#"9>7#'$8$,9#(( &83)5;3 #9'?5"'385$@

C57# ="5:;43 #D'7=9#( 6"57 3)# "#(#'"4)X♦ !'":#$ 8$(#43848:#( ="5753#: '( B4)#784'9/

6"##F@♦ BJ'3;"'9F )'8" 75;((#@♦ j834)#$ +&'D1 ='=#" 3)'3 49'87( B"#4>49#:

45$3#$3F ?;3 :5#( $53 O;'$386> 83 +Y5;9: Q@PfO;'986>k1

A)8(*75?8;(*955=*8(*8$3 $: :*35*7 '$*3)'3*3) *= 5:;43*8(*7': *6 57* 4>49 :*7'3 8'9@*V;3*8(*83*3) *&)59 *= 5:;43.*5 *3) *='4K', k*G$:*8(*83*7': *56*PQQf* 4>49 :*7'3 8'9.*5 *9 ((k*G$:*8(*83*=5(3/45$(;7 *&'(3 .*5 *=5(3/8$:;(3 8'9*&'(3 k*Y83)5;3*'*O;'986>8$,*(3'3 7 $3.*3) *(>7?59*8(*98K 9>*35*78(9 ':*3) *?;> .*45778338$,*3) *C8$*56*]',; $ ((@*

a [QQS@ A#""'I)584# H$


6/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

♦ !#$#"'9 =;"=5(# )5;(#)59: 49#'$#"( 3)'3 49'8735 ?# B$5$/35D84F &83)5;3 #D=9'$'385$ 5" 3)8":/='"3> (;?(3'$38'385$@

• BPQQf $'3;"'9F ?'3)"557 49#'$#"(@

P-&/?# . 3#A(&.38I@ B&QRK&+-:+ +:?3@&I#/:?A9.&S/#&QQE&/0&9( & - +#/-8 -93@&A@3+8.T&A/88+99 :&9( &*+-&/0&U34? - ..F&

C8$*56*M #9# 7'K8$, '$ #$#'"(. 3)#"# '"#-/ ="5:;43( 3)'3 '"# 7'$;6'43;"#: &83) 83@J#.?;3 3)'3 "8(K :8(3"'438$, 3)# 45$(;7#" 6"57 3)#,"#'3#" #$ '( '&)59#@ HD'7=9#( 8$49;:#X

♦ L",'$84 48,'"#33#(@♦ B!"##$F 8$(#43848:#( '$: )#"?848:#(@

L?. 3)#"# '"# (57# 48"4;7(3'$4#( '$:45$(;7#"( 3)'3 :#7'$: 3)#(# ="5:;43(@ I577#"48'98$(#43848:#( '$: )#"?848:#( '"# #((#$38'9 35 (57#',"84;93;"'9 '==984'385$(@ M$ 3)5(# 48"4;7(3'$4#(.4)55(8$, 3)# ,"##$#(3 5=385$ 8( #((#$38'9@ Z5 65"7'$> 45(7#384 '==984'385$( +(;4) '( 9'&$(1@L",'$84 35?'445 7'> ?# ' 75"# "#(=5$(8?9# 4)584#

65" (75K#"(. ?;3 ()5;9:$h3 75(3 45$(;7#"( ?#:8(45;"',#: 6"57 (75K8$, 8$ 3)# 68"(3 =9'4#k

Y# 45$(8:#" ' 49'87 35 457783 3)# C8$ 56 N#((#" 56A&5 H 7'K8$, #$ 6'9(#@

M$ 5;" 68$:8$,(. 5$9> ' 6#& ="5:;43( "# 65;$: 35457783 3)# C8$ 56 _8??8$,@ E5(3 56 3)#(# "#78(;(# 5" 78("#="#(#$3'385$ 56 4#"38684'385$ ?> '$8$:#=#$:#$3 ';3)5"83>@ A)#(# 4'(#( 8$49;:#:. 65"#D'7=9#X

♦ C# C3'"?(83# (;,,#(3( 3)8( 8( 6'9(#@

♦ G :8()&'()#" :#3#",#$3 3)'3 =;"=5"3( 35 ?#='4K',#: 8$ BPQQf "#4>49#: ='=#"F. '$: >#3 3)#45$3'8$#" 8( =9'(384@

I_I (*)'< *? $*9 ,'99>*?'$$ :*65 *'975(3*UQ*> ' (.*> 3*7'$>*= 5:;43(*(3899*49'87*I_I /6 *'(*86*83*8(*'*;$8O; *457= 3838< *':


7/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

QY&I#/:?A9.&S@ ..&9(3-&QE&/0& - +#/-8 -93@&A@3+8.T&A/88+99 :&9( &*+-&/0&Z+$$+-4B&83O+-4&+9&/- &/0&9( &92/&@ 3.9&0# >? -9@;&A/88+99 :&.+-.F&

b#4577#$:'385$(*65 *I5$(;7# (*

!549# +6"57 "#(5;"4# #D3"'4385$ 35 #$:/56/986#1@ A)#(# ="5,"'7( :#98l

• A)8":/='"3> ' (8$,9#

#$49#:/45$3#$3 5"#$#",>/#66848#$4>@ Y)89# 87=5"3'$3. (8$,9# '33"8?;3#49'87( 4'$ )8:# 87=5"3'$3 '::8385$'9 #$


8/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

[@***N55K*_5 *H*56*3)#*BC8D*C8$(F*V>*****G(K8$,*3)#*_5995&8$,*e;#(385$(X

'1 M( 3)# B,"##$F 49'87 "#(3"843#: 35 i;(3 5$#. 5" '$'""5& (#3 56 #$ 4#"3868#"(. '$: 3599/6"## =)5$# $;7?#"( '"# #'(> '$: #66#438 ()5;9: 4';(# >5; 35?# (;(=8485;(@ M6 3)# 7'"K#38$, 49'87 :5#($h3#D=9'8$ 83(#96 +B)#"#h( &)'3 7#'$ ?> g#45hmF1. 3)# 49'87 8( F. '$: B#'"3)/6"8#$:9>@FY83)5;3 ':#O;'3# #D=9'$'385$. (;4) 49'87( '"#(5 ?#$#683(>5; ()5;9: ?# (;(=8485;(@1 I57='"8(5$/()5=+'$: '(K 3)# 457=#3838 c ?# 8""#9# 4#"38684'385$(@ A)'$K6;99>3)#(# '"# #'(> 35 45$68"7@ N#,8387'3# 3)8":/='"3>4#"3868#"( 2 H45N5,5IE . I)95"8$# _"## \"5:;43(

G((548'385$ +I_\G1. _5"#(3 C3#&'":()8= I5;$489+_CI1. !"##$ !;'":. !"##$ C#'9 +65" #D'7=9#1 2'99 7'8$3'8$ =;?9849> ' "#:;48$, 3)#8";(# 3)'$ ?> 955K8$, 65" ,"##$#" '93#"$'38


9/15


10/15

"#$ %&' %&() *+ ,-$$(./)#&(0 "1

^1 G 35 7'K# ' 4;(357#" 6##9 B,"##$F'?5;3 ' 4)584# 3)'3 8( ?'(84'99> )'"76;9 5";$$#4#(('">@

`1 G(@

?1 G9&'>( 3#99 3)# 3";3)@

I5$49;:8$,*A)5;,)3(

!"##$ 7'"K#38$, 8( ' =5"6;9 45$#"( '$: (#99#"( @ E5"# '$: 75"#45$(;7#"( #D=#43 35 ;(# 3)#8" (=#$:8$, '( '$

#D="#((85$ 56 3)#8" #$ 35&'": (;(3'8$'?8983>@

Y83) 3)'3 8$ 78$:. 3)# =;"=5(# 56 3)8( (3;:> 8( $53 35:8(45;"',# ,"##$ 7'"K#38$,. $5" 35 8$:843 ='"384;9'"7'"K#3#"(@ M3 8( $53 8$3#$:#: 35 (4'"# 45$(;7#"('&'> 6"57 ,"##$ 49'87(@ L;" =;"=5(# 8( 35 '((8(37'"K#3#"( '$: 45$(;7#"( 35 ?;89: ' 75"# )5$#(3'$: #66#438 #$ '$: :##=9>@A)8( &899 ?# ,"#'3 65" 45$(;7#"(. ,"#'3 65" ?;(8$#((.'$: ,"#'3 65" 3)# =9'$#3@

Y# #D=#43 35 "#=#'3 3)8( "#(#'"4) '$$;'99>. '$: 955K65"&'": 35 3)#(# =5(8385; 98K# 35 (=#'K 35 '$>5$# '3 A#""'I)584#k \9#'(#


11/15

#$%&'#() )

#$%&*) )+))

)

,-./01)'2134-,536)&7)89509) 7:5,-7;3712


12/15

)

#$%&*)A)UV)#0-V


13/15

L`M)8921)?,-0366)56)/63.)1-):3,5GC)1921)?,-./016)201/2


14/15

!""#$#%&'( *&+#,%&-.&$'( /$'&"',"0 /#&1(. !$$,#23$. *&+#,%&-.&$'( /$'&"'," /.$$#&1 '&"4.,$#5#6'$#%& 7,1''$#%&

"#$%& '&()&*+, *--(. +*/01*2#0&%&, #( 3%2-*&%#$%4& '&(302#, +%%# * '05-42-6 *7*4-*5-% ,#*/3*&389$%6 #$%/ 2(/302# &*/3(+ *034#, #( +*4/#*4/ #$%4/#%)&4#6 (1 #$% %/74&(/+%/#*- 3%2-*&*#4(/,8 9$%%:4,#%/2% (1 #$% '05-42 ,#*/3*&3, *-,( *--(., (#$%&,#( 4/3%'%/3%/#-6 7%&416 #$% *220&*26 (1 #$% 2-*4+,

9$%,% '&()&*+, 1(20, (/ * ,4/)-% %/74&(/+%/#*-4,,0% ,02$ *, 4/3((& *4& ;0*-4#6 (& &%262-%3 2(/#%/#8*7*4-*5-% ,#*/3*&38

?(&%,# @#%.*&3,$4' A(0/24- B...81,20,8(&)C D/%&)6 @#*& E&()&*+ B...8%/%&)6,#*&8)(7C

9$% ?(&%,# @#%.*&3,$4' A(0/24- 2%ƞ%, .((3'&(302#, (5#*4/%3 1&(+ ,0,#*4/*5-6 $*&7%,#%31(&%,#,8 F# *-,( 2%ƞ%, %/74&(/+%/#*--6 '&%1%&*5-%'*'%&, 5*,%3 (/ * +0-#4>*##&450#%

9$% G8@8 ?%3%&*- H(7%&/+%/#I, D/%&)6 @#*&'&()&*+ %,#*5-4,$%, %/%&)6>%11424%/26 2&4#%&* .43% 7*&4%#6 (1 '&(302#, 4/ +(&% #$*/ JK'&(302# 2*#%)(&4%,8 9$% ,4#% -4,#, *-- (1 #$%'&(302#, +%%#4/) #$% %11424%/26 &%;04&%+%/#*-,( 4/2-03%, &%2(++%/3%3 '0&2$*,4/),'%24142*#4(/, */3 (/-4/% #&*4/4/) &%,(0&2%,8

*''&(*2$8

H&%%/>% B...8)&%%/>%8(&)C

H&%%/>% 2%ƞ%, ,(0&2%, (1 &%/%.*5-% %-%2#&424#6*/3 &%/%.*5-% %/%&)6 2&%34#, )%/%&*#%3 1&(+2-%*/ %/%&)6 ,(0&2%, ,02$ *, .4/3= ,(-*&= (&,+*-->,2*-% $63&(>%-%2#&428 F# *-,( 2%ƞ%,'&(302#, #$*# .%&% +*/01*2#0&%3 4/ 1*24-4#4%,0,4/) &%/%.*5-% %/%&)68

DEDL9 B...8%'%*#8/%#C

DEDL9 &*/M, 2(+'0#%& 3%,M#(',= -*'#(',= */3+(/4#(&, 4/#( DEDL9


15/15

##$%&'( ) * +,-,.,/0,1

2 34456778889:1;9;.4>?;4>?;4>?;:?934BC01/@BD,.EFG2HI

FJK 34456778889-4099:B1934B

H 34456778889PD09/1-7,/73=0>OFGOF,934B?

Q FOON9 R,..>)3;:0, $/L:.;/B,/4>? S>.T,4:/< '/092F

16. six_the sins of greenwhasing

Documents