2009 market share reports for the top 25 …...48 wall street, 6th floor new york, ny 10005-2906...

540
2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 Property/Casualty Insurers Over 25 Years DIRECT PREMIUMS MARKET SHARE CUMULATIVE MARKET SHARE

Upload: others

Post on 16-Mar-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2009 Market

Share Reports

for the Top 25 Property/Casualty

Insurers Over 25 Years

DIRECT

PREMIUMS

MARKET

SHARE

CUMULATIVE

MARKET

SHARE

Page 2: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,
Page 3: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2009 Market Share Reports

for the Top 25 Property/Casualty

Insurers Over 25 Years

2010

Page 4: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Accounting & Reporting

Accountants, members of the insurance industry and

educators will find relevant information about statutory

accounting practices and procedures.

Consumer Information

Consumers, educators and members of the insurance

industry will find important answers to common questions

in guides about auto, home, health and life insurance.

Financial Regulation

Accountants, financial analysts and lawyers will find

handbooks, compliance guides and reports on financial

analysis, state audit requirements and receiverships.

Legal

State laws, regulations and guidelines apply to members

of the legal and insurance industries.

NAIC Activities

Insurance industry members will find directories,

newsletters and reports affecting NAIC members.

Special Studies

Accountants, educators, financial analysts, members of

the insurance industry, lawyers and statisticians will find

relevant products on a variety of special topics.

Statistical Reports

Insurance industry data directed at regulators, educators,

financial analysts, insurance industry members, lawyers

and statisticians.

Supplementary Products

Accountants, educators, financial analysts, insurers,

lawyers and statisticians will find guidelines, handbooks,

surveys and NAIC positions on a wide variety of issues.

Securities Valuation Office

Provides insurers with portfolio values and procedures

for complying with NAIC reporting requirements.

White Papers

Accountants, members of the insurance industry and

educators will find relevant information on a variety of

insurance topics.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners. All rights reserved.

ISBN: 978-1-59917-375-7

Printed in the United States of America

No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or

mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or any storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the NAIC.

The NAIC is the authoritative source for insurance industry information. Our expert solutions support the efforts of

regulators, insurers and researchers by providing detailed and comprehensive insurance information. The NAIC

offers a wide range of publications in the following categories:

For more information about NAIC publications, view our online catalog at:

http://store.naic.org

NAIC Central Office

2301 McGee Street, Suite 800

Kansas City, MO 64108-2662

816.842.3600

NAIC Securities Valuation Office

48 Wall Street, 6th Floor

New York, NY 10005-2906

212.398.9000

NAIC Executive Office

444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701

Washington, DC 20001

202.471.3990

Page 5: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

The following companion products provide additional information on the same or similar subject matter. Many

customers who purchase the Market Share Reports for the Top 25 Property/Casualty Insurers Over 25 Years also purchase one or more of the following products:

Companion Products

Profitability by Line by State

Statistics derived from state page data in the annual statement and the

Insurance Expense Exhibit can be used to compare profitability among

different states and property/casualty lines. For each line and each state,

this publication presents aggregate statistics on premiums, losses,

expenses, investment income and estimated profits for the preceding

calendar year. Also shows estimated underwriting profits and operating

profits, as well as estimated federal taxes. Updated annually.

Market Share Reports for Groups and Companies

An easy reference for identifying top writers by premium volume. Allows

monitoring of increases and decreases in market share and overall level of

market concentration. The Property/Casualty reports include the top 10

company groups by state and the top 125 groups countrywide for each P/C

annual statement line of business. The Life and Fraternal reports contain the

top 125 groups by state and countrywide for life insurance, annuity

considerations and total premiums written. The Accident & Health reports

contain the top 125 groups by state and countrywide for total A&H premiums

written. Contains the latest available year of data. Updated annually.

Statistical Compilation of Annual Statement Information

The Statistical Compilation provides aggregate annual statement data for

property/casualty, life/health insurance companies, all HMOs and companies

that write accident and health insurance and file annual statements with the

NAIC. Divided into three sections — Annual Statement Financial Data, State

and Countrywide Insurance Data, and Selected Data Elements from Company

and Combined Statements — the information provided will satisfy a wide

range of needs and uses. Updated annually.

Competition Database Report

The Competition Database Report is a reference for examining the

competitiveness of state insurance markets. This report is meant to be a

starting point for studies of competition and can provide insight when used to

make multi-state and multi-year comparisons. The report includes various

structural and performance measures that are readily determinable or

available from NAIC databases or other sources. Updated annually.

International orders must be prepaid, including shipping charges. Please contact an NAIC Customer Service Representative, Monday - Friday, 8:30 am - 5 pm CST.

Page 6: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,
Page 7: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 Property/Casualty Insurers Over 25 Years

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 1 Five-Year Market Share Reports By Line of Business Line Number

35 Total All Lines......................................................................501 Fire ........................................................................................602.1 Allied Lines...........................................................................702.2 Multiple Peril Crop..............................................................802.3 Federal Flood .......................................................................903 Farmowners Multiple Peril...............................................1004 Homeowners Multiple Peril ..............................................1105.1, 05.2 Total Commercial Multi-Peril ..........................................1206 Mortgage Guaranty ...........................................................1308 Ocean Marine.....................................................................1409 Inland Marine ....................................................................1510 Financial Guaranty............................................................1611 Medical Professional Liability ..........................................1712 Earthquake.........................................................................1816 Workers’ Compensation ...................................................1917.1, 17.2 Other Liability ...................................................................2017.3 Excess Workers’ Compensation .......................................2118 Products Liability ..............................................................2219.1, 19.2 Private Passenger Auto Liability......................................2321.1 Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage .......................2419.1, 19.2, 21.1 Total Private Passenger Auto ...........................................2519.3, 19.4 Commercial Auto Liability ...............................................2621.2 Commercial Auto Physical Damage.................................2719.3, 19.4, 21.2 Total Commercial Auto.....................................................2822 Aircraft (All Perils) ............................................................2923 Fidelity ................................................................................3024 Surety ..................................................................................3126 Burglary and Theft ............................................................3227 Boiler and Machinery........................................................3328 Credit ..................................................................................3430 Warranty ............................................................................3534 Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business...........36

Page 8: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2009 Market Share Reports for

the Top 25 Property/Casualty Insurers Over 25 Years

TABLE OF CONTENTS CONTINUED Market Share Reports By Line of Business for Years 2009-1985 Line Number

35 Total All Lines....................................................................3901 Fire ......................................................................................4502.1 Allied Lines.........................................................................5102.2 Multiple Peril Crop............................................................5702.3 Federal Flood .....................................................................6203 Farmowners Multiple Peril...............................................6604 Homeowners Multiple Peril ..............................................7205.1, 05.2 Total Commercial Multi-Peril ..........................................7806 Mortgage Guaranty ...........................................................8408 Ocean Marine.....................................................................8709 Inland Marine ....................................................................9310 Financial Guaranty............................................................9911 Medical Professional Liability ........................................10312 Earthquake.......................................................................10916 Workers’ Compensation .................................................11517.1 Other Liability .................................................................12117.3 Excess Workers’ Compensation .....................................12718 Products Liability ............................................................12919.1, 19.2 Private Passenger Auto Liability....................................13421.1 Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage .....................14019.1, 19.2, 21.1 Total Private Passenger Auto .........................................14619.3, 19.4 Commercial Auto Liability .............................................15221.2 Commercial Auto Physical Damage...............................15819.3, 19.4, 21.2 Total Commercial Auto...................................................16422 Aircraft (All Perils) ..........................................................17023 Fidelity ..............................................................................17624 Surety ................................................................................18225 Glass ..................................................................................18826 Burglary and Theft ..........................................................19027 Boiler and Machinery......................................................19628 Credit ................................................................................20230 Warranty ..........................................................................20834 Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business.........210

Technical Notes............................................................................................................... 217 Index of Insurer Groups and Companies (by Group)................................................. 225 Index of Insurer Groups and Companies (by Individual Company) ........................ 465

Page 9: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

INTRODUCTION These 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 Property/Casualty Insurers Over 25 Years are intended to make historical property and casualty market share information more readily available. Direct written premium is taken from the “Exhibit of Premiums and Losses” (Statutory Page 14) in the NAIC property and casualty annual statement. When possible, direct written premium for the Workers’ Compensation and Total All Lines sections of this report include supplemental state fund premium data as reported directly to the NAIC. Additionally, when possible, the Fire, Homeowners, Allied and Total All Lines sections of this report include premium data reported directly to the NAIC from the Louisiana state-run property insurer of last resort. The Florida state-run property insurers of last resort have been reported to the NAIC since 2007, and information for the years 2005 and 2006 are included in the technical notes section given in this report. Due to subsequent filings or refilings of insurer financial statements to the NAIC, the data in this historical report may deviate from market share publications produced in previous years. For purposes of this report, “group” refers to those companies with a common NAIC group code. Companies that are not part of a group are identified by their individual NAIC company code. Insurers continuously merge, change names, and buy and sell companies. In this report, group structures reflect the organizational groupings as filed with the NAIC in each of the reported years. An index listing the individual insurers within a group for each of the reported years is included at the end of the report. The index also provides prior names associated with the reported NAIC group code. The Five-Year Market Share Summary section of this report provides 2009 market share rankings, premium data and direct loss ratios for the top 25 groups and companies in the United States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien for each of the property and casualty lines of business. This section also presents how each of these insurers ranked in the previous four years. This format depicts the market share patterns of the top property/casualty writers over the five year period of 2005-2009. If a company did not exist in a prior year, N/R indicates that there was no ranking for this company. The Market Share Reports and the By Line of Business for Years 1985-2009 section provides market share information for the years 1985, 1990, 1995, 2000, and 2005-2009. Reported for each of these years is the market share rankings, premium data, and direct loss ratios for the top 25 groups and companies and for the various property and casualty lines of business. Unlike the Five-Year Market Share Summary section, which displays how the top 25 insurers in 2009 ranked in prior years, the market shares for each group in this section are independent for each year. It should be noted that the Total All Lines market share in this publication represents Total Line 35 as reported on the 2009 Exhibit of Premiums and Losses and will therefore include accident and health data. The line numbers associated with accident and health data include:

Line 13 Group accident and health Line 14 Credit A&H (group and individual) Line 15.1 Collectively renewable A&H Line 15.2 Non-cancelable A&H Line 15.3 Guaranteed renewable A&H Line 14.5 Non-renewable for stated reasons only Line 15.5 Other accident only Line 15.6 Medicare Title XVIII exempt from state taxes or fees Line 15.7 All other A&H Line 15.8 Federal employees health benefits program premium

For the year 2009, the total direct written premium, for accident and health data reported by property and casualty companies, was $7,567,441,053. The line numbers associated with the lines of business reported on the “Exhibit of Premium and Losses” vary historically. For purposes of this report, the lines of business are matched with the line numbers as reported on the 2009 “Exhibit of Premiums and Losses.”

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners1

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 10: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Commercial Multi-Peril (CMP) is shown in total only, as the distinction between the property and liability portions of CMP are meaningful for analysis of loss development, but less so for analysis of market share. No Fault and Liability coverages are combined for both private passenger and commercial auto due to inconsistent reporting of No-Fault data among the various companies and states. The loss ratios in this report reflect a simple calendar-year result. In cases in which groups and companies have zero or negative earned premiums, the loss ratios are reported as n/a. While loss ratios provide some information about results for a given year, they should not be considered as measures of overall profitability. Many other factors, including expenses and investment income, are used in developing profitability measures. Many property lines, such as earthquake, homeowners, allied lines, and inland marine, are subject to significant fluctuations in results, due to the occurrences of major catastrophes such as tornados, earthquakes and civil disturbances. For further analysis of the profitability of lines of business, refer to the NAIC Report on Profitability By Line By State. That report is also on a calendar-year basis, but includes a 10-year aggregation of results. For lines not specifically included in the Report on Profitability, the NAIC Statistical Compilation of Annual Statement Information for Property/Casualty Companies contains a countrywide, calendar-year industry aggregation of the Insurance Expense Exhibit (IEE). If you have any questions regarding this report, please contact Aaron Brandenburg at the NAIC at (816) 783-8271 or Sara Robben at (816) 783-8225. Additional copies of this report can be obtained from:

NAIC CENTRAL OFFICE 2301 McGee Street, Suite 800 Kansas City, MO 64108-2604

Telephone (816) 783-8300 E-mail: [email protected]

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners2

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 11: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

FIVE-YEAR MARKET SHARE REPORTS BY LINE OF BUSINESS

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners3

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 12: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners4

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 13: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

35 - Total All Lines

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %10.50 %72.59 1111%69.5951,063,110,761212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %5.96 %58.47 4333%53.6828,979,691,684

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP3 %5.38 %61.53 3444%58.9426,153,440,23112 AMERICAN INTL GRP4 %5.38 %76.92 2222%69.3426,140,201,178

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP5 %5.10 %61.83 6665%56.8924,772,894,3283548 TRAVELERS GRP6 %4.40 %49.39 5556%43.3121,409,548,242

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP7 %3.30 %69.32 9887%64.8316,054,658,656140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP8 %3.17 %63.53 7778%60.5515,405,561,636155 PROGRESSIVE GRP9 %2.92 %63.16 8999%61.5814,200,294,349

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP10 %2.15 %55.72 10101010%50.2210,473,026,375200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP11 %2.15 %63.56 13131212%61.8410,439,501,509

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP12 %1.94 %41.36 11111111%38.659,419,255,363218 CNA INS GRP13 %1.67 %68.68 12121314%59.748,131,205,861626 ACE LTD GRP14 %1.60 %61.17 14141413%56.197,780,534,083761 ALLIANZ INS GRP15 %1.19 %50.82 18171715%47.405,764,589,841473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP16 %1.17 %66.96 16151516%64.365,681,564,588280 AUTO OWNERS GRP17 %0.92 %81.52 19181817%78.264,451,729,312213 ERIE INS GRP18 %0.79 %62.62 21202120%58.763,860,839,234

19 ASSURANT INC GRP19 %0.77 %28.50 31292319%28.323,735,278,48684 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP20 %0.73 %46.58 22211918%41.703,565,868,30898 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP21 %0.67 %54.42 20192021%45.363,255,838,29965 FM GLOBAL GRP22 %0.66 %34.62 27262928%31.363,199,857,312

796 QBE INS GRP23 %0.64 %56.42 84782626%50.683,128,630,118244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP24 %0.63 %63.26 24252523%56.923,071,344,125241 METROPOLITAN GRP25 %0.61 %57.03 25272824%55.682,984,332,558

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %65.12%60.26486,152,051,401

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners5

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 14: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

01 - Fire

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %16.01 %25.50 1111%24.352,059,465,98419 ASSURANT INC GRP2 %10.28 %18.29 5522%18.281,323,281,14765 FM GLOBAL GRP3 %6.28 %25.52 3444%25.14808,305,394

1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP4 %6.04 %11.81 N/RN/RN/RN/R%11.79777,233,8443548 TRAVELERS GRP5 %5.84 %42.73 2233%40.51751,951,260

212 ZURICH INS GRP6 %5.53 %51.39 4356%50.69712,029,054111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %3.85 %56.22 6677%54.03495,314,134361 MUNICH RE GRP8 %2.36 %30.53 7865749%31.35303,804,764761 ALLIANZ INS GRP9 %2.21 %59.20 7788%60.33283,760,712280 AUTO OWNERS GRP10 %1.82 %73.14 9111010%71.37234,452,519171 GERMANIA INS GRP11 %1.47 %84.81 11151513%84.72189,535,491501 ALLEGHANY GRP12 %1.33 %42.08 881114%41.37170,834,284140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP13 %1.32 %40.26 14161412%39.28169,320,564

10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP14 %1.19 %93.58 389911%86.53153,480,151626 ACE LTD GRP15 %1.04 %106.60 12171716%100.76133,533,633

1285 XL AMER GRP16 %1.01 %21.48 15121315%19.42129,358,369200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP17 %0.94 %36.88 27252318%35.99121,270,430181 SWISS RE GRP18 %0.92 %44.30 143142420%43.47118,508,641

3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP19 %0.92 %23.71 21231817%23.42117,924,1891279 ARCH INS GRP20 %0.81 %32.27 17181921%30.25104,144,553

147 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP21 %0.74 %78.54 23282622%73.1294,697,0364509 IRONSHORE GRP22 %0.67 %46.90 N/RN/RN/R182%43.3586,147,557

242 SELECTIVE INS GRP23 %0.64 %36.22 28292725%35.7682,199,38231 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP24 %0.64 %31.46 24212819%27.6681,892,742

785 MARKEL CORP GRP25 %0.61 %16.64 22243027%15.3278,977,001** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %37.87%36.5912,866,796,013

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners6

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 15: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

02.1 - Allied Lines

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %11.43 %66.00 3322%61.551,294,329,96710064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2 %10.93 %)(0.17 2111%1.021,237,046,374

65 FM GLOBAL GRP3 %9.45 %13.47 1233%13.331,070,199,2491281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP4 %6.41 %20.48 N/RN/RN/RN/R%20.19725,859,947

19 ASSURANT INC GRP5 %4.54 %25.26 131066%25.21513,990,304212 ZURICH INS GRP6 %4.44 %29.91 5445%25.46502,916,996

3548 TRAVELERS GRP7 %4.36 %67.33 4557%65.56493,359,585111 LIBERTY MUT GRP8 %2.60 %44.02 1716138%43.00293,909,003626 ACE LTD GRP9 %2.55 %17.70 78109%18.68288,544,557501 ALLEGHANY GRP10 %2.30 %11.39 671112%9.89260,668,275218 CNA INS GRP11 %2.04 %10.86 86910%5.77230,556,183761 ALLIANZ INS GRP12 %2.00 %40.64 10141411%38.31226,583,551140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP13 %1.85 %63.09 12131213%61.06209,866,991

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP14 %1.76 %38.14 18211614%37.23199,078,491361 MUNICH RE GRP15 %1.73 %37.24 1441118115%37.33195,818,989200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP16 %1.36 %67.12 19191718%66.91153,937,332

3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP17 %1.28 %)(2.57 14121517%)(5.29144,612,580569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP18 %1.22 %84.95 20221816%84.77138,211,379796 QBE INS GRP19 %0.94 %58.23 36422419%51.97106,384,529

1279 ARCH INS GRP20 %0.93 %42.19 23232322%37.68105,526,318181 SWISS RE GRP21 %0.87 %)(16.30 68202825%)(16.2998,582,465

LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS.22 %0.82 %30.65 52432220%26.6992,829,7581285 XL AMER GRP23 %0.75 %86.75 11111921%78.7585,038,858

175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP24 %0.75 %47.11 39403629%46.2584,434,4374636 MAX CAPITAL GRP25 %0.74 %31.98 N/RN/RN/R26%34.6483,344,113

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %37.56%36.0711,320,172,054

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners7

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 16: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Rankby

471 WELLS FARGO GRP1 %16.39 %81.23 2221%81.231,401,035,911626 ACE LTD GRP2 %16.03 %77.43 1112%77.431,369,795,753

25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO3 %10.51 %46.06 6333%46.06898,445,29584 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP4 %9.12 %58.26 4544%58.28779,684,960

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP5 %8.00 %24.47 3455%24.47683,947,1853786 ENDURANCE GRP6 %6.02 %88.67 N/RN/RN/R6%88.67514,405,884

306 CUNA MUT GRP7 %5.51 %87.86 N/R312117%87.59471,248,96412 AMERICAN INTL GRP8 %4.46 %75.96 N/RN/RN/R22%72.61381,363,258

42757 AGRI GEN INS CO9 %4.00 %66.95 7779%66.95342,126,407569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP10 %3.76 %37.57 111198%37.56321,112,268

1285 XL AMER GRP11 %3.49 %92.21 981010%92.47298,122,4981331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP12 %3.26 %78.26 12131313%78.26278,559,406

513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP13 %2.87 %54.36 15141212%54.36245,259,26813412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO14 %1.11 %91.87 24261616%91.8795,255,504

50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP15 %1.11 %37.56 17161414%37.5694,461,867361 MUNICH RE GRP16 %0.93 %147.43 N/R181515%148.8279,841,910158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP17 %0.86 %99.30 N/RN/R1918%97.2573,488,949

3500 NODAK MUT GRP18 %0.49 %54.34 20202019%52.9141,504,330176 STATE FARM GRP19 %0.48 %90.70 19191720%90.7040,689,205303 GUIDEONE INS GRP20 %0.39 %57.26 14151821%57.2633,127,965542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP21 %0.32 %128.15 22232323%128.1527,650,986

10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO22 %0.29 %68.88 21212424%68.8825,128,077225 IAT REINS CO GRP23 %0.21 %133.16 13172231%133.1618,237,007220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP24 %0.20 %223.37 28252726%223.0416,752,525324 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP25 %0.08 %46.66 23272827%46.667,199,599

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %68.96%68.838,547,373,473

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners8

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 17: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

02.3 - Federal Flood

Rankby

670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP1 %16.60 %38.90 1111%38.37485,346,166176 STATE FARM GRP2 %13.59 %35.80 2222%34.55397,392,483

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP3 %10.36 %37.23 3333%37.23302,853,57291 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP4 %8.29 %34.92 4444%33.54242,331,719

3548 TRAVELERS GRP5 %6.66 %31.80 5555%28.92194,731,980242 SELECTIVE INS GRP6 %6.12 %20.69 7777%19.50178,933,886

19 ASSURANT INC GRP7 %6.11 %28.14 6666%28.14178,613,936212 ZURICH INS GRP8 %4.01 %104.82 10101010%98.84117,198,538140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP9 %3.98 %48.26 8888%48.21116,515,266200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP10 %3.92 %42.80 9999%40.41114,488,176253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP11 %2.98 %22.60 11111111%21.9787,135,320280 AUTO OWNERS GRP12 %1.39 %57.07 13151413%54.3040,599,124111 LIBERTY MUT GRP13 %1.33 %29.07 14131514%29.0138,945,554677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR14 %1.20 %23.49 15141315%22.6135,036,862

1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP15 %1.16 %7.69 21171717%7.6933,979,43836560 SERVICE INS CO16 %1.01 %0.00 17161616%0.0029,605,891

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP17 %0.97 %53.05 12121212%53.6728,219,7803484 TOWER HILL INS GRP18 %0.82 %5.19 19201919%4.9123,842,794

41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO19 %0.65 %7.75 18192021%7.7719,151,142483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP20 %0.65 %32.00 20181818%32.0019,121,456411 MAPFRE INS GRP21 %0.54 %16.22 22252122%14.8715,856,343311 MAIN STREET AMER GRP22 %0.51 %3.55 26242224%3.5514,817,676473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP23 %0.46 %33.25 24222525%30.6813,307,133

15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON24 %0.39 %70.11 25212323%64.7811,447,805408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP25 %0.38 %420.48 23232426%420.4811,187,707

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %36.85%35.742,924,277,875

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners9

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 18: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Rankby

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP1 %8.38 %50.37 1111%48.54236,602,540513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP2 %6.68 %79.18 3333%78.59188,581,950176 STATE FARM GRP3 %6.48 %65.48 2222%63.41182,932,691

3548 TRAVELERS GRP4 %5.06 %60.05 4444%61.03142,924,65150 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP5 %3.79 %81.68 5555%80.61106,891,318

473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP6 %3.45 %69.88 6666%68.0697,494,153694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP7 %3.21 %86.72 7777%86.1390,597,684796 QBE INS GRP8 %3.16 %61.79 31302219%59.5389,101,510109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP9 %3.03 %130.83 8888%129.6085,598,541542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP10 %2.84 %75.91 9999%75.0980,067,207111 LIBERTY MUT GRP11 %2.67 %68.29 27252010%66.3175,365,232561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP12 %2.38 %107.86 11111011%106.8067,173,046

67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP13 %2.07 %61.36 12121313%59.5758,583,366220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP14 %1.93 %108.02 14131214%105.9854,583,346

13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE15 %1.92 %75.96 15161415%74.6654,326,316228 WESTFIELD GRP16 %1.66 %57.37 13151617%56.9346,819,079

19 ASSURANT INC GRP17 %1.61 %64.64 16141516%61.7045,482,153809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP18 %1.61 %80.55 24212120%78.9845,425,880

5 ALFA INS GRP19 %1.53 %98.49 17171718%97.7443,187,690280 AUTO OWNERS GRP20 %1.46 %66.90 19181821%65.9041,192,627214 ALLIANCE INS GRP21 %1.42 %66.74 18191922%65.5440,081,733

14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO22 %1.38 %57.54 22202323%55.9538,970,33415091 RURAL MUT INS CO23 %1.37 %66.59 23242424%64.2138,769,920

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP24 %1.35 %49.51 25272525%48.4538,139,58684 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP25 %1.21 %26.70 26232626%23.2434,158,749

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %70.62%69.062,823,343,509

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners10

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 19: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %21.58 %68.50 1111%66.5314,737,236,4498 ALLSTATE INS GRP2 %10.01 %62.40 2222%60.406,837,285,776

212 ZURICH INS GRP3 %7.42 %51.92 3333%50.385,066,034,148111 LIBERTY MUT GRP4 %5.07 %57.76 7774%56.333,461,188,432

3548 TRAVELERS GRP5 %4.51 %48.56 5555%47.203,082,154,511200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP6 %4.35 %56.29 6667%55.202,969,697,662140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP7 %4.26 %65.72 4446%64.352,909,147,923

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP8 %2.59 %39.72 8888%41.391,772,267,678473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP9 %2.14 %69.04 99109%68.241,460,618,362

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP10 %1.64 %69.38 10111110%65.911,122,779,740280 AUTO OWNERS GRP11 %1.29 %93.37 11121314%91.93878,807,476241 METROPOLITAN GRP12 %1.26 %53.27 12131213%52.86860,986,068213 ERIE INS GRP13 %1.16 %70.77 15161615%67.23792,687,542

10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP14 %1.16 %42.37 1710911%41.85790,756,46912 AMERICAN INTL GRP15 %1.05 %59.60 13151412%53.19716,396,488

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP16 %0.95 %38.37 16171716%37.39647,504,95650 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP17 %0.84 %88.56 18181817%87.51577,090,552

4663 UNIVERSAL INS HOLDING GRP18 %0.75 %34.60 N/RN/RN/R19%33.80513,340,8651278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP19 %0.75 %54.69 20191918%52.69511,857,303

88 THE HANOVER INS GRP20 %0.72 %64.60 19202020%63.55493,687,7701318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP21 %0.68 %48.59 27222321%45.52463,117,940

28 AMICA MUT GRP22 %0.63 %51.18 22212222%49.25431,265,405361 MUNICH RE GRP23 %0.58 %46.46 N/RN/RN/R23%46.41393,833,029

55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP24 %0.54 %66.41 28272726%65.67367,095,2921344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP25 %0.47 %33.04 48283134%31.01321,405,260

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %60.93%59.2768,297,271,637

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners11

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 20: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %8.88 %40.45 1111%35.683,020,229,250212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %7.08 %45.51 2222%38.442,408,607,560111 LIBERTY MUT GRP3 %6.53 %55.09 7743%48.822,220,102,045

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP4 %5.32 %48.72 3334%38.991,810,444,46938 CHUBB & SON INC GRP5 %4.78 %31.74 4455%31.751,625,901,419

176 STATE FARM GRP6 %4.72 %59.08 5566%50.271,606,023,479140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP7 %4.27 %65.82 6677%58.721,453,046,303677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR8 %3.22 %42.31 10101110%36.211,095,208,690761 ALLIANZ INS GRP9 %3.10 %56.77 9999%53.451,054,442,711218 CNA INS GRP10 %2.92 %52.09 8888%46.63993,742,984244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP11 %2.52 %59.22 11111011%49.82856,225,884796 QBE INS GRP12 %2.49 %57.87 25231312%48.43845,880,580

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP13 %1.97 %65.13 15151614%61.01669,112,906280 AUTO OWNERS GRP14 %1.87 %52.11 12131413%48.13634,992,523

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP15 %1.76 %40.52 13121216%32.17597,132,54098 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP16 %1.57 %51.93 16161815%44.40533,920,504

213 ERIE INS GRP17 %1.47 %74.07 17181918%61.57498,574,755626 ACE LTD GRP18 %1.40 %48.51 24171717%35.94474,941,649

88 THE HANOVER INS GRP19 %1.36 %51.68 22222320%44.40462,915,020253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP20 %1.26 %61.96 18192019%54.59427,997,606

18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO21 %1.21 %73.10 20202121%72.17412,411,710473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP22 %1.10 %65.91 21212222%60.36373,215,939

3703 TOWER GRP23 %1.07 %36.49 41393125%41.33363,074,7751129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP24 %1.01 %43.74 19242423%33.11344,749,991

228 WESTFIELD GRP25 %0.88 %62.51 28282624%53.02299,738,476** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %51.89%45.0534,000,334,901

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners12

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 21: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

06 - Mortgage Guaranty

Rankby

105 MGIC GRP1 %24.21 %195.36 1111%189.021,316,165,3941135 PMI GRP2 %15.44 %235.68 3432%235.68839,052,473

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP3 %15.02 %244.49 4344%251.14816,248,574766 RADIAN GRP4 %14.70 %178.88 2223%178.88798,977,291

4011 GENWORTH FIN GRP5 %13.15 %206.25 N/R555%206.25714,561,567150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP6 %11.67 %199.02 6666%189.29634,084,852421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP7 %3.99 %401.70 7777%401.70217,011,872306 CUNA MUT GRP8 %1.82 %139.59 8888%139.5999,073,304

16047 SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO9 %0.00 %22.67 N/R999%22.67234,566** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %214.99%213.295,435,412,551

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners13

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 22: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

08 - Ocean Marine

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %19.78 %32.75 1111%29.30739,792,3353548 TRAVELERS GRP2 %8.14 %43.75 2222%39.23304,547,544

218 CNA INS GRP3 %6.76 %54.87 4444%49.30252,735,538626 ACE LTD GRP4 %5.76 %54.30 3333%49.21215,377,302761 ALLIANZ INS GRP5 %5.72 %74.61 5677%62.37214,041,666510 NAVIGATORS GRP6 %5.35 %74.64 8555%75.07200,192,379

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP7 %4.83 %47.12 7766%46.83180,523,43031 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP8 %3.79 %81.21 1032288%76.21141,775,294

1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP9 %3.77 %38.02 101099%35.94140,879,60713366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT10 %2.94 %124.59 981210%113.63109,907,089

212 ZURICH INS GRP11 %2.80 %37.77 11111111%35.45104,826,5011285 XL AMER GRP12 %2.66 %12.61 691012%12.8099,353,091

984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP13 %2.47 %45.60 13121314%38.8892,252,11284 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP14 %2.14 %16.42 14141615%9.8880,154,051

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP15 %1.91 %73.93 20211818%69.1271,245,562785 MARKEL CORP GRP16 %1.89 %55.69 15151513%48.7970,862,203

4670 STARR GRP17 %1.84 %64.30 N/RN/RN/RN/R%57.9068,793,793256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP18 %1.81 %14.32 12131416%10.6867,850,767

3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP19 %1.51 %51.46 16172019%46.9956,395,9393416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP20 %1.38 %12.48 19161920%12.5951,729,600

783 RLI INS GRP21 %1.05 %104.12 34242121%101.3039,237,8191279 ARCH INS GRP22 %0.81 %23.31 17192327%20.7530,362,304

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP23 %0.78 %35.00 18202222%35.5829,015,49698 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP24 %0.70 %54.90 36363537%54.6426,124,082

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP25 %0.64 %71.12 23252525%77.2124,004,605** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %50.53%46.473,739,903,099

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners14

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 23: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

09 - Inland Marine

Rankby

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP1 %14.01 %60.16 11631%60.171,879,152,584218 CNA INS GRP2 %9.05 %69.97 2222%69.801,213,328,063

65 FM GLOBAL GRP3 %6.40 %44.43 6566%43.23857,815,0223548 TRAVELERS GRP4 %5.67 %44.03 3444%43.23759,905,425

176 STATE FARM GRP5 %4.72 %43.65 7877%42.79633,286,91438 CHUBB & SON INC GRP6 %4.54 %31.21 91099%32.26608,243,97412 AMERICAN INTL GRP7 %4.35 %35.67 1113%35.41583,315,143

212 ZURICH INS GRP8 %4.27 %38.49 4355%37.18573,102,904761 ALLIANZ INS GRP9 %4.23 %57.52 8788%55.03567,744,96719 ASSURANT INC GRP10 %2.76 %35.41 1091010%35.22370,351,044

150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP11 %2.75 %56.76 25271611%56.38368,822,098626 ACE LTD GRP12 %2.13 %13.53 14151414%13.57285,431,918

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP13 %1.81 %51.69 5111112%51.87242,421,82684 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP14 %1.73 %33.47 12131213%32.14231,694,760

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP15 %1.67 %34.89 13141315%34.29224,215,864155 PROGRESSIVE GRP16 %1.56 %47.29 20191717%46.97209,648,274796 QBE INS GRP17 %1.36 %29.95 82821516%28.86182,263,882140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP18 %1.35 %30.16 19171818%29.59180,882,573200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP19 %1.13 %38.83 21242220%38.39151,380,278785 MARKEL CORP GRP20 %1.09 %57.69 17202019%57.04146,791,703

88 THE HANOVER INS GRP21 %1.03 %48.22 35262322%46.70138,153,811361 MUNICH RE GRP22 %0.90 %41.29 106464024%41.00121,147,424

27928 AMEX ASSUR CO23 %0.88 %44.08 N/RN/R2121%43.84117,832,874280 AUTO OWNERS GRP24 %0.73 %40.69 23252625%40.1697,573,239

14354 JEWELERS MUT INS CO25 %0.71 %49.79 29303026%49.0494,936,369** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %45.92%45.3113,408,738,126

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners15

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 24: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

10 - Financial Guaranty

Rankby

194 ASSURED GUAR GRP1 %46.90 %87.56 3331%86.16901,581,655528 MBIA GRP2 %21.21 %289.55 2224%253.56407,682,475

1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP3 %16.91 %210.13 1115%194.60325,118,6094676 SYNCORA HOLDINGS GRP4 %4.54 %)(1051.61 N/RN/RN/RN/R%)(1,064.8787,333,7291135 PMI GRP5 %4.49 %1047.37 4447%1,044.8786,253,000

766 RADIAN GRP6 %2.42 %184.86 6668%180.7046,525,69831 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP7 %1.72 %0.00 N/RN/RN/R3%0.0033,105,513

4687 CIFG GRP8 %1.40 %5413.90 N/RN/RN/RN/R%5,407.8626,959,41740568 TRIPLE S PROPIEDAD INC9 %0.33 %0.00 N/RN/RN/RN/R%0.006,281,25522896 ACA FIN GUAR CORP10 %0.04 %99.26 79820%68.22864,386

468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP11 %0.04 %0.00 N/RN/RN/RN/R%0.00750,000761 ALLIANZ INS GRP12 %0.01 %)(2.53 12131212%)(2.53100,427

12633 CENTURY INS CO GU LTD13 %0.00 %5.59 N/RN/R1514%23.4063,07117493 NAZARETH MUT INS CO14 %0.00 %0.00 N/RN/RN/RN/R%0.0011,865

218 CNA INS GRP16 %0.00 %)(7.75 14141413%)(175.03)(23,4343548 TRAVELERS GRP17 %)(0.01 %0.00 11111111%0.00)(112,483

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %266.98%250.431,922,495,183

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners16

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 25: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Rankby

1210 MLMIC GRP1 %7.01 %73.93 1111%49.63756,843,91031 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP2 %6.72 %68.56 3322%47.40725,511,559

831 DOCTORS CO GRP3 %5.57 %44.33 6643%23.32601,223,4632698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP4 %5.01 %36.94 4456%20.61541,033,064

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP5 %4.86 %45.26 2234%27.51524,252,247218 CNA INS GRP6 %4.79 %50.88 5565%38.16517,259,789

41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS7 %3.69 %84.06 121077%67.84397,879,3231154 PROMUTUAL GRP8 %3.55 %13.28 9999%6.12382,540,5342358 ISMIE GRP9 %2.98 %69.09 7788%41.68321,936,854413 MAG MUT INS GRP10 %2.47 %50.95 881010%29.55266,255,263

10697 MCIC VT INC RRG11 %2.44 %90.61 15141311%79.49263,048,9651282 NORCAL GRP12 %2.34 %36.32 11121212%12.67252,789,594

33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO13 %2.19 %43.46 14131113%19.86236,389,8931272 FPIC INS GRP14 %1.81 %55.74 13151414%28.62195,424,403

212 ZURICH INS GRP15 %1.54 %31.74 16171515%20.79165,828,927377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP16 %1.44 %40.93 17161616%27.06155,323,398

3239 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP17 %1.40 %40.00 21020314522%27.61150,903,29530317 HOSPITALS INS CO INC18 %1.39 %106.11 47412719%98.72150,009,67032832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ19 %1.36 %63.42 20181717%46.10146,743,912

184 MEDICAL INS GRP20 %1.18 %39.10 24242018%19.06127,389,07216942 MMIC INS INC21 %1.16 %45.85 25252121%27.71125,629,168

966 AP CAPITAL GRP22 %1.05 %20.23 19192223%1.52113,232,197626 ACE LTD GRP23 %1.02 %50.66 26262624%25.33110,602,081785 MARKEL CORP GRP24 %1.01 %39.87 18201920%34.02109,370,521

98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP25 %1.00 %41.34 34353329%29.82107,878,005** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %53.92%35.5510,790,766,436

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners17

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 26: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

12 - Earthquake

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %12.74 %0.60 1111%0.00251,599,062212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %11.95 %0.46 2223%0.41235,869,337

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP3 %8.11 %)(2.49 3332%)(2.50160,096,1903829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP4 %6.63 %0.16 4444%0.16130,817,7563548 TRAVELERS GRP5 %5.18 %)(0.43 5666%)(0.15102,230,4953416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP6 %4.85 %)(7.57 6777%)(7.4395,818,481

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %4.05 %)(0.41 1112105%)(0.3379,988,653626 ACE LTD GRP8 %3.94 %2.02 7558%2.0077,848,272

3786 ENDURANCE GRP9 %3.47 %)(3.27 2381111%)(3.1468,556,038761 ALLIANZ INS GRP10 %3.46 %1.00 8999%0.5968,356,584

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP11 %2.63 %)(0.01 15161312%)(0.0151,995,095922 AMERICAN ASSETS GRP12 %2.53 %0.00 1010810%0.0049,973,083

1279 ARCH INS GRP13 %2.40 %)(0.57 26141415%)(0.5647,285,709140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP14 %2.32 %)(0.59 16201513%)(0.4945,709,517200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP15 %1.85 %0.16 18211814%0.1636,539,831181 SWISS RE GRP16 %1.67 %20.69 147131718%20.7033,065,093783 RLI INS GRP17 %1.38 %)(0.21 17171617%)(0.2127,166,22591 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP18 %1.26 %0.05 20232019%)(0.0224,968,629

3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP19 %1.00 %0.00 21242120%)(0.0119,796,1914636 MAX CAPITAL GRP20 %1.00 %15.26 N/RN/RN/R31%17.1419,714,857

39861 GOLDEN BEAR INS CO21 %0.96 %)(0.43 42332427%)(0.3118,926,3911285 XL AMER GRP22 %0.94 %3.78 19253321%5.9918,564,530

28 AMICA MUT GRP23 %0.89 %0.11 25272322%0.1417,662,984411 MAPFRE INS GRP24 %0.89 %0.07 28312816%0.0617,612,767473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP25 %0.72 %)(0.05 32323125%)(0.0514,218,050

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %0.18%0.151,974,229,017

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners18

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 27: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

16 - Workers' Compensation

Rankby

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP1 %9.73 %79.33 3221%72.214,468,726,85512 AMERICAN INTL GRP2 %8.39 %93.96 1112%82.883,853,087,982

3548 TRAVELERS GRP3 %5.97 %66.48 4443%56.982,739,325,74391 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP4 %5.44 %55.38 5655%51.832,498,224,667

212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %5.39 %85.91 6534%75.172,473,549,340OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION6 %5.38 %83.96 7766%67.512,469,550,000WASHINGTON STATE FUND7 %2.96 %186.31 99109%172.641,360,533,000

36102 STATE INS FUND8 %2.85 %95.47 8888%92.811,309,601,07735076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND9 %2.80 %80.36 2377%73.211,287,041,223

626 ACE LTD GRP10 %2.33 %76.74 1010911%67.041,068,737,571218 CNA INS GRP11 %2.07 %88.54 11111110%79.60951,095,026572 BCBS OF MI GRP12 %1.73 %69.10 17181212%63.46794,453,914

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP13 %1.58 %46.21 13141313%46.63725,229,59298 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP14 %1.40 %58.60 14171715%54.68642,256,752

22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO15 %1.38 %52.42 16161514%44.09634,389,226336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP16 %1.01 %50.21 12131616%44.59465,199,256150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP17 %1.00 %85.77 18201918%76.87457,741,915767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP18 %0.99 %66.97 33302422%59.77454,682,293

2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP19 %0.98 %55.41 61432523%48.78452,008,329708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP20 %0.89 %85.87 24212221%71.42407,469,145

3363 EMPLOYERS HOLDINGS GRP21 %0.82 %54.84 23273220%49.50376,650,70231 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP22 %0.81 %87.94 19121417%82.69370,316,613

41190 PINNACOL ASSUR23 %0.77 %67.13 20192119%65.05353,823,991244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP24 %0.74 %109.63 31262726%102.42337,521,584

36196 SAIF CORP25 %0.68 %93.13 26222025%88.57312,907,874** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %78.87%71.0045,912,920,114

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners19

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 28: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %14.84 %91.05 1111%77.256,860,901,304212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %6.54 %75.38 2222%68.783,023,365,468

3548 TRAVELERS GRP3 %6.35 %51.15 3333%36.282,935,970,89538 CHUBB & SON INC GRP4 %5.42 %49.17 4444%37.422,505,751,831

626 ACE LTD GRP5 %4.86 %63.91 5555%59.872,248,616,273218 CNA INS GRP6 %4.66 %93.60 6666%73.902,156,404,890111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %4.02 %63.83 8777%45.391,860,320,005

1285 XL AMER GRP8 %3.15 %74.73 7888%64.301,458,067,267140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP9 %2.77 %56.87 10999%47.201,281,593,20391 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP10 %1.96 %25.86 9101010%21.50904,875,373

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP11 %1.78 %68.51 13131311%58.68825,356,61298 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP12 %1.77 %45.07 11111112%28.00819,892,974

176 STATE FARM GRP13 %1.65 %58.31 20181614%54.84762,032,65084 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP14 %1.64 %43.37 12121213%32.36760,517,147

984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP15 %1.55 %66.71 17212017%53.35714,434,1013416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP16 %1.53 %70.17 19191916%62.11709,767,1261279 ARCH INS GRP17 %1.38 %58.25 15151518%48.10639,039,153

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP18 %1.23 %60.31 14141715%43.72567,102,677677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR19 %1.08 %50.28 40282623%43.41500,857,826244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP20 %1.06 %37.13 22222121%29.91492,347,089501 ALLEGHANY GRP21 %1.03 %51.32 18161419%44.22477,539,287

3239 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP22 %0.94 %69.70 61616531%56.24435,702,527785 MARKEL CORP GRP23 %0.87 %57.72 16171820%40.77404,306,368181 SWISS RE GRP24 %0.87 %75.04 52202222%41.99401,311,672510 NAVIGATORS GRP25 %0.87 %46.87 32262425%38.87400,299,040

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %65.88%53.1746,239,066,965

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners20

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 29: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

17.3 - Excess Workers' Compensation

Rankby

74 DELPHI FIN GRP1 %29.98 %77.92 N/RN/RN/R1%77.34274,321,52712 AMERICAN INTL GRP2 %12.03 %51.50 N/RN/RN/R3%49.89110,047,971

626 ACE LTD GRP3 %11.89 %56.06 N/RN/RN/R4%40.56108,815,584111 LIBERTY MUT GRP4 %8.41 %104.69 N/RN/RN/R5%98.9276,917,328212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %4.66 %83.58 N/RN/RN/R6%77.9042,686,186

1346 AMERICAN SAFETY HOLDING GRP6 %4.63 %2.56 N/RN/RN/RN/R%1.4542,359,19484 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP7 %4.14 %47.31 N/RN/RN/R8%46.3437,848,874

256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP8 %3.81 %52.16 N/RN/RN/R9%46.4534,865,1953548 TRAVELERS GRP9 %3.58 %44.39 N/RN/RN/R11%38.0332,793,5041208 GRAY INS GRP10 %3.53 %54.26 N/RN/RN/R7%50.9832,300,8491279 ARCH INS GRP11 %3.35 %74.91 N/RN/RN/R10%72.5430,648,110

748 MEADOWBROOK INS GRP12 %3.22 %66.79 N/RN/RN/R12%50.8829,426,799150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP13 %1.59 %336.20 N/RN/RN/R13%324.5914,533,423

1285 XL AMER GRP14 %1.02 %102.47 N/RN/RN/R14%95.999,344,34888 THE HANOVER INS GRP15 %0.68 %)(1.79 N/RN/RN/R15%)(2.446,239,64838 CHUBB & SON INC GRP16 %0.51 %19.79 N/RN/RN/R16%22.274,629,425

572 BCBS OF MI GRP17 %0.42 %339.08 N/RN/RN/R17%339.083,856,440361 MUNICH RE GRP18 %0.41 %93.15 N/RN/RN/R20%90.813,739,433

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP19 %0.36 %2635.66 N/RN/RN/R29%2,369.613,265,716867 BALDWIN & LYONS GRP20 %0.33 %)(160.57 N/RN/RN/R18%)(156.073,024,409

40134 CASTLEPOINT NATL INS CO21 %0.30 %3.05 N/RN/RN/R21%)(22.832,781,12611118 FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS EXCH22 %0.26 %44.89 N/RN/RN/R23%44.892,398,333

169 SENTRY INS GRP23 %0.24 %83.68 N/RN/RN/R19%69.492,175,891181 SWISS RE GRP24 %0.17 %10437.94 N/RN/RN/R28%8,880.551,575,594

3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP25 %0.16 %66.69 N/RN/RN/R24%65.821,424,766** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %60.17%56.67915,107,893

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners21

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 30: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

18 - Products Liability

Rankby

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP1 %9.14 %48.31 3431%36.10261,913,096212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %7.79 %193.38 2222%72.61223,049,499

3548 TRAVELERS GRP3 %7.24 %44.47 6654%5.81207,425,256218 CNA INS GRP4 %6.20 %90.44 9885%59.77177,525,490626 ACE LTD GRP5 %5.37 %71.95 4368%57.93153,829,371111 LIBERTY MUT GRP6 %4.75 %211.05 7776%121.61135,964,406

21261 ELECTRIC INS CO7 %4.18 %65.16 N/RN/RN/RN/R%51.47119,746,33898 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP8 %4.09 %81.41 5547%47.64117,173,404

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP9 %3.49 %)(156.01 13131212%)(77.9699,847,31291 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP10 %2.76 %196.24 23171310%9.8878,973,656

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP11 %2.65 %70.41 12111113%51.9075,871,11712 AMERICAN INTL GRP12 %2.61 %243.15 1113%181.9974,777,576

785 MARKEL CORP GRP13 %2.56 %24.22 8999%8.8873,290,040457 ARGONAUT GRP14 %2.49 %63.69 19191516%47.1271,351,513242 SELECTIVE INS GRP15 %2.32 %84.15 18201414%61.6166,345,871244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP16 %2.09 %62.50 21212218%36.7059,916,005

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP17 %1.88 %58.66 10101015%38.2853,778,1841113 MEDMARK INS GRP18 %1.87 %101.92 15161717%25.9753,618,5301285 XL AMER GRP19 %1.49 %203.84 22232338%131.6542,681,226

501 ALLEGHANY GRP20 %1.25 %60.60 17151919%39.5435,851,355248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP21 %1.23 %144.28 26252421%88.8835,134,705158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP22 %1.17 %32.49 20182120%1.8033,518,184

3617 FIRST MERCURY FIN GRP23 %1.05 %25.67 54393027%31.0130,193,4877 FEDERATED MUT GRP24 %0.95 %10.16 24242522%5.6727,237,501

3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP25 %0.94 %19.16 36363628%15.7926,927,902** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %82.14%39.802,864,171,938

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners22

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 31: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %18.76 %84.53 1111%79.2118,444,685,6258 ALLSTATE INS GRP2 %10.03 %71.77 2222%67.289,858,846,559

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP3 %8.56 %76.88 4433%72.348,414,544,523155 PROGRESSIVE GRP4 %7.81 %68.71 3344%66.467,683,348,699212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %6.41 %59.77 6555%56.336,301,549,005140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP6 %4.60 %70.89 5666%68.574,520,320,273111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %4.36 %63.41 9997%60.174,285,819,736200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP8 %3.75 %73.68 8778%70.343,692,312,404

3548 TRAVELERS GRP9 %2.17 %63.99 10101010%58.552,130,665,693473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP10 %1.90 %69.82 11111111%64.621,871,906,342

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP11 %1.71 %72.01 13121212%69.251,685,867,654660 MERCURY GEN GRP12 %1.28 %59.14 14141413%50.571,254,316,425241 METROPOLITAN GRP13 %1.19 %66.81 15151514%63.951,169,438,607

1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP14 %1.12 %54.72 17161615%51.291,100,116,016213 ERIE INS GRP15 %1.11 %73.21 16171716%69.941,093,552,007

1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP16 %0.97 %65.32 18181817%62.38954,523,577215 UNITRIN GRP17 %0.88 %69.84 21222119%66.71868,785,929816 COMMERCE INC GRP18 %0.82 %67.76 19191918%63.48806,374,527280 AUTO OWNERS GRP19 %0.76 %140.21 22242422%135.65747,711,074

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP20 %0.74 %64.62 7889%63.20730,413,5251129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP21 %0.70 %76.52 25232221%71.23691,022,050

169 SENTRY INS GRP22 %0.69 %59.84 23212323%57.72681,893,59579 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP23 %0.69 %81.28 20202020%78.44680,065,21555 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP24 %0.66 %126.97 24272827%121.42651,743,09088 THE HANOVER INS GRP25 %0.62 %77.00 27252524%74.17607,285,460

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %73.03%69.0498,337,355,206

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners23

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 32: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %18.42 %66.46 1111%66.3212,141,780,5168 ALLSTATE INS GRP2 %11.21 %47.85 2222%47.417,390,478,255

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP3 %7.69 %58.17 4443%58.035,066,993,596155 PROGRESSIVE GRP4 %6.94 %57.49 3334%57.414,574,420,271212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %6.28 %56.33 5555%56.024,140,550,898200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP6 %4.63 %62.51 7778%61.983,055,058,263111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %4.36 %54.43 9987%54.062,874,788,466140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP8 %4.36 %57.94 6666%57.702,872,542,879473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP9 %2.18 %59.13 10101010%58.951,436,530,434

3548 TRAVELERS GRP10 %1.87 %54.27 11111111%53.921,233,500,77691 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP11 %1.47 %52.83 14141213%52.67966,290,295

1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP12 %1.45 %52.24 15131312%51.95953,992,151660 MERCURY GEN GRP13 %1.30 %61.14 13121514%61.15854,811,191241 METROPOLITAN GRP14 %1.28 %49.82 16161615%49.54843,099,380

1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP15 %1.22 %53.66 17171716%53.50807,216,582213 ERIE INS GRP16 %1.17 %60.70 18181817%60.40771,554,544

55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP17 %0.98 %56.54 19202019%56.20648,019,415280 AUTO OWNERS GRP18 %0.93 %64.89 21222220%64.68612,116,612215 UNITRIN GRP19 %0.80 %59.84 25242422%59.36530,299,659816 COMMERCE INC GRP20 %0.79 %66.88 22212121%66.44517,917,314

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP21 %0.71 %54.36 8899%53.88467,729,36879 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP22 %0.67 %56.41 20191918%56.29441,308,17588 THE HANOVER INS GRP23 %0.64 %59.62 26262524%59.52421,180,72550 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP24 %0.61 %58.57 24252626%58.41401,557,732

1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP25 %0.61 %60.07 29292725%59.33400,266,563** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %58.28%57.9265,924,057,193

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners24

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 33: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

Total Private Passenger Auto

Rankby

176 STATE FARM GRP1 %18.62 %77.28 1111%74.0430,586,466,1418 ALLSTATE INS GRP2 %10.50 %61.48 2222%58.7317,249,324,814

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP3 %8.21 %69.82 4443%66.9413,481,538,119155 PROGRESSIVE GRP4 %7.46 %64.48 3334%63.0512,257,768,970212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %6.36 %58.40 5555%56.2110,442,099,903140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP6 %4.50 %65.84 6666%64.337,392,863,152111 LIBERTY MUT GRP7 %4.36 %59.79 9997%57.717,160,608,202200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP8 %4.11 %68.61 7778%66.546,747,370,667

3548 TRAVELERS GRP9 %2.05 %60.41 11111111%56.843,364,166,469473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP10 %2.01 %65.16 10101010%62.153,308,436,776

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP11 %1.61 %64.90 13121212%63.112,652,157,949660 MERCURY GEN GRP12 %1.28 %59.95 14141413%54.882,109,127,616

1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP13 %1.25 %53.56 17151514%51.602,054,108,167241 METROPOLITAN GRP14 %1.23 %59.70 15161615%57.922,012,537,987213 ERIE INS GRP15 %1.14 %68.15 16181816%66.081,865,106,551

1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP16 %1.07 %59.98 18171717%58.311,761,740,159215 UNITRIN GRP17 %0.85 %66.00 23232120%63.891,399,085,588280 AUTO OWNERS GRP18 %0.83 %106.12 21212221%103.531,359,827,686816 COMMERCE INC GRP19 %0.81 %67.42 19201918%64.621,324,291,841

55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP20 %0.79 %91.59 22222323%88.661,299,762,50512 AMERICAN INTL GRP21 %0.73 %60.63 8889%59.571,198,142,89379 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP22 %0.68 %71.36 20192019%69.611,121,373,390

1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP23 %0.66 %70.49 28262622%66.861,091,288,61388 THE HANOVER INS GRP24 %0.63 %69.96 26252525%68.231,028,466,18550 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP25 %0.60 %62.90 25272726%61.37986,141,887

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %67.07%64.55164,261,412,399

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners25

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 34: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %8.34 %43.57 1111%40.731,570,555,740212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %7.06 %47.18 4223%41.191,329,185,082111 LIBERTY MUT GRP3 %6.86 %52.86 5552%48.711,292,156,333155 PROGRESSIVE GRP4 %6.23 %59.22 2345%55.521,172,906,601

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP5 %5.68 %65.20 3434%57.381,069,799,289140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP6 %3.96 %66.79 6666%61.40745,756,266150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP7 %2.57 %66.07 10977%57.79484,636,662

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP8 %2.34 %50.60 91188%49.44440,244,658218 CNA INS GRP9 %2.01 %78.92 771110%72.09378,422,949280 AUTO OWNERS GRP10 %1.96 %75.59 13131211%71.12369,192,927

98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP11 %1.91 %70.76 121299%64.77358,945,643176 STATE FARM GRP12 %1.87 %69.31 881612%62.35351,834,017796 QBE INS GRP13 %1.84 %54.39 1251351513%47.42346,504,222626 ACE LTD GRP14 %1.63 %55.83 15161816%47.61306,147,247244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP15 %1.55 %56.21 19171717%51.95291,648,178

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP16 %1.54 %53.28 23222015%47.53290,091,0698 ALLSTATE INS GRP17 %1.50 %47.50 14141414%43.92282,247,766

677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR18 %1.38 %95.79 92902519%84.37260,168,480242 SELECTIVE INS GRP19 %1.25 %62.39 24232220%59.01235,455,969213 ERIE INS GRP20 %1.17 %44.96 26262422%40.36219,943,986

93 STATE NATL GRP21 %1.13 %70.54 76674737%63.61212,813,905169 SENTRY INS GRP22 %1.03 %99.62 20202121%92.00193,179,926253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP23 %1.00 %52.40 25252623%47.93188,971,420

88 THE HANOVER INS GRP24 %0.94 %54.09 35323127%50.72177,385,23631 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP25 %0.89 %42.03 22242826%35.10167,224,839

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %59.28%52.8118,838,456,418

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners26

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 35: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %7.67 %51.06 3421%51.22443,280,677155 PROGRESSIVE GRP2 %6.56 %54.62 4312%54.45379,116,722212 ZURICH INS GRP3 %5.51 %52.44 2233%51.32318,404,681111 LIBERTY MUT GRP4 %5.49 %56.12 8754%55.42317,093,925140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP5 %3.70 %53.96 7566%52.63213,860,649280 AUTO OWNERS GRP6 %3.41 %51.21 5677%50.84197,012,131150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP7 %3.30 %61.55 10988%59.92190,822,848

1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP8 %2.84 %63.57 N/RN/RN/RN/R%62.55164,226,951176 STATE FARM GRP9 %2.52 %53.78 11119%53.53145,469,84484 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP10 %2.36 %52.68 1310910%51.81136,071,703

796 QBE INS GRP11 %2.05 %58.93 1191241313%53.15118,464,62798 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP12 %1.92 %52.17 14141412%51.09110,939,12691 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP13 %1.86 %59.23 12131515%59.49107,643,880

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP14 %1.77 %35.91 11111214%35.36102,500,055244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP15 %1.68 %62.98 16151616%62.0597,300,758306 CUNA MUT GRP16 %1.64 %49.48 17161823%49.4794,792,201

79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP17 %1.47 %72.44 9121011%71.7985,156,866218 CNA INS GRP18 %1.45 %52.04 15171717%48.0183,622,013213 ERIE INS GRP19 %1.40 %51.81 20202018%51.4181,126,100225 IAT REINS CO GRP20 %1.06 %65.12 22212422%59.7060,990,576361 MUNICH RE GRP21 %1.05 %68.14 41403826%64.5460,904,074242 SELECTIVE INS GRP22 %1.05 %63.41 33312924%63.1560,678,035677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR23 %0.98 %43.64 1951294030%43.1756,507,692

62 EMC INS CO GRP24 %0.96 %57.78 31323027%57.5355,533,691228 WESTFIELD GRP25 %0.92 %53.97 34343231%52.9753,148,519

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %55.04%53.885,776,043,591

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners27

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 36: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

Total Commercial Auto

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %8.18 %45.21 1111%43.032,013,836,417212 ZURICH INS GRP2 %6.69 %48.24 2223%43.241,647,589,763111 LIBERTY MUT GRP3 %6.54 %53.50 5552%50.031,609,250,258155 PROGRESSIVE GRP4 %6.31 %58.07 3334%55.261,552,023,323

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP5 %4.55 %67.57 4445%59.771,119,419,954140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP6 %3.90 %63.88 7766%59.41959,616,915150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP7 %2.74 %64.79 9877%58.39675,459,510280 AUTO OWNERS GRP8 %2.30 %67.03 11111010%64.00566,205,058

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP9 %2.23 %52.26 101088%51.38547,888,538176 STATE FARM GRP10 %2.02 %64.73 661311%59.75497,303,861

98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP11 %1.91 %66.46 131399%61.60469,884,769796 QBE INS GRP12 %1.89 %55.56 1271311513%48.89464,968,849218 CNA INS GRP13 %1.88 %74.20 891112%67.86462,044,962

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP14 %1.73 %53.09 19151714%48.92426,162,772244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP15 %1.58 %57.91 15171816%54.48388,948,936

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP16 %1.56 %44.35 12141415%41.60384,747,821626 ACE LTD GRP17 %1.33 %55.52 22222317%47.56326,800,992677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR18 %1.29 %86.41 1131042822%76.96316,676,172213 ERIE INS GRP19 %1.22 %46.83 24242519%43.38301,070,086242 SELECTIVE INS GRP20 %1.20 %62.60 25252421%59.84296,134,004

93 STATE NATL GRP21 %1.07 %68.59 47444035%61.92262,609,113169 SENTRY INS GRP22 %1.00 %97.14 21212018%91.34245,990,186253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP23 %0.93 %53.20 26262625%49.48229,378,052

88 THE HANOVER INS GRP24 %0.92 %55.04 36313229%52.16226,381,65662 EMC INS CO GRP25 %0.89 %56.27 30293128%53.28220,119,566

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %58.27%53.0724,614,500,009

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners28

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 37: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %19.34 %56.10 1113%45.51384,622,411761 ALLIANZ INS GRP2 %14.63 %89.50 15942%82.54290,909,181

31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP3 %10.31 %74.22 2221%62.52205,098,7351285 XL AMER GRP4 %7.11 %60.82 3334%47.48141,519,778

626 ACE LTD GRP5 %6.20 %9.67 6566%8.85123,327,728984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP6 %5.89 %62.24 4455%52.00117,181,415361 MUNICH RE GRP7 %5.02 %26.18 7797%28.2099,926,694150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP8 %4.42 %31.12 5678%28.1087,967,520111 LIBERTY MUT GRP9 %4.35 %61.93 8889%50.1286,467,108

1279 ARCH INS GRP10 %4.07 %154.49 17131011%148.4481,026,68738 CHUBB & SON INC GRP11 %3.51 %59.60 25211410%60.6969,878,55398 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP12 %2.54 %66.16 21121212%59.7550,509,030

4574 CATLIN US INS GRP13 %2.08 %50.13 N/RN/RN/RN/R%48.2341,434,183181 SWISS RE GRP14 %1.84 %75.57 13141113%74.2336,678,350

3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP15 %1.65 %58.82 12151615%52.3932,825,5482978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP16 %1.25 %55.31 16171816%46.7624,783,3584509 IRONSHORE GRP17 %0.94 %53.50 N/RN/RN/RN/R%48.1518,638,1163478 HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP18 %0.94 %51.22 N/R191717%49.4718,613,613

968 AXA INS GRP19 %0.89 %34.48 11111514%23.6017,627,3114670 STARR GRP20 %0.69 %60.00 N/RN/RN/RN/R%55.1513,715,709

816 COMMERCE INC GRP21 %0.48 %60.79 N/RN/RN/RN/R%51.109,555,6883548 TRAVELERS GRP22 %0.40 %74.33 43282621%)(30.907,917,745

697 VAN ENT GRP23 %0.34 %60.29 N/R232220%59.696,761,657749 SCOR GRP24 %0.30 %70.94 N/RN/R2018%67.905,972,408408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP25 %0.26 %32.79 14161919%32.795,133,876

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %62.58%54.131,989,119,458

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners29

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 38: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

23 - Fidelity

Rankby

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP1 %22.62 %71.32 1111%73.37253,395,8123548 TRAVELERS GRP2 %15.26 %11.69 3332%5.79170,990,167

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP3 %11.28 %59.72 2223%63.24126,321,191212 ZURICH INS GRP4 %7.85 %58.42 4444%56.3187,894,133306 CUNA MUT GRP5 %7.72 %84.35 5555%83.3486,489,715

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP6 %7.53 %10.42 8666%15.1484,342,607218 CNA INS GRP7 %5.11 %54.25 6788%52.6957,270,182

91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP8 %4.97 %37.91 7877%20.0655,700,387111 LIBERTY MUT GRP9 %1.93 %18.72 914699%21.1621,577,808626 ACE LTD GRP10 %1.81 %43.67 1091011%32.5020,273,547783 RLI INS GRP11 %1.04 %51.02 32293030%36.1611,611,088155 PROGRESSIVE GRP12 %1.02 %22.97 11111112%21.0911,423,933

11268 ICI MUT INS CO RRG13 %0.94 %)(2.11 N/RN/RN/RN/R%)(1.7210,511,8513416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP14 %0.86 %8.04 14102314%5.839,677,357

244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP15 %0.79 %175.72 13121313%167.568,878,455984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP16 %0.59 %)(29.50 34414221%)(44.766,556,144158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP17 %0.58 %206.90 28131210%197.726,529,432

18538 BANCINSURE INC18 %0.57 %104.55 16141416%104.556,341,67798 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP19 %0.54 %36.85 79778079%35.006,044,618

150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP20 %0.51 %19.76 18171515%17.755,657,267242 SELECTIVE INS GRP21 %0.47 %43.02 20191819%41.555,261,342

7 FEDERATED MUT GRP22 %0.45 %50.47 19181617%48.865,094,08231 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP23 %0.43 %61.08 17161718%61.094,870,261

176 STATE FARM GRP24 %0.41 %5.32 23202020%3.974,589,181677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR25 %0.40 %43.16 N/R523629%43.164,525,555

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %50.66%48.991,120,159,654

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners30

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 39: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

24 - Surety

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %17.80 %14.48 1111%5.20924,173,009111 LIBERTY MUT GRP2 %13.93 %20.62 6652%20.70723,214,004212 ZURICH INS GRP3 %9.37 %6.62 2223%2.67486,753,862218 CNA INS GRP4 %7.82 %15.96 3334%13.47406,141,296

38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP5 %5.33 %)(0.03 5565%0.53276,977,32891 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP6 %3.49 %40.37 7776%35.79181,037,257

984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP7 %3.18 %25.03 9987%20.61165,159,32811592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO8 %2.27 %16.77 1012118%14.19117,983,963

626 ACE LTD GRP9 %2.10 %15.45 1314109%13.64109,048,82184 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP10 %2.01 %26.03 11111210%21.49104,470,06288 THE HANOVER INS GRP11 %1.93 %72.69 23181513%63.72100,061,100

181 SWISS RE GRP12 %1.81 %28.68 12131412%20.9393,875,1623488 J A PATTERSON GRP13 %1.67 %31.72 N/RN/RN/R14%27.7486,665,4051279 ARCH INS GRP14 %1.51 %81.82 88911%69.6178,606,428

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP15 %1.49 %148.78 14101315%143.5877,281,831783 RLI INS GRP16 %1.48 %19.36 17161716%17.7877,041,705228 WESTFIELD GRP17 %1.12 %7.04 18171818%3.1258,307,59175 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP18 %1.10 %34.44 16151617%30.3257,356,313

3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP19 %1.06 %8.02 21211919%6.0055,232,096244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP20 %0.94 %37.58 26232321%32.9248,888,147

98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP21 %0.94 %16.15 29312523%12.6148,766,603501 ALLEGHANY GRP22 %0.86 %19.84 22202020%14.4244,523,403

10916 SURETEC INS CO23 %0.80 %16.29 37332224%13.3241,561,421150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP24 %0.76 %23.41 24252727%20.2139,291,638

3592 PROALLIANCE GRP25 %0.66 %0.98 25262826%1.1134,256,572** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %24.55%19.475,193,066,043

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners31

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 40: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

26 - Burglary and Theft

Rankby

3548 TRAVELERS GRP1 %22.52 %3.14 2211%)(3.7237,910,62738 CHUBB & SON INC GRP2 %19.91 %5.85 1322%7.7933,514,394

212 ZURICH INS GRP3 %10.17 %32.74 4444%31.9317,124,85312 AMERICAN INTL GRP4 %7.47 %)(5.62 3633%)(6.6712,579,03391 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP5 %6.05 %11.54 5565%7.1610,178,546

215 UNITRIN GRP6 %5.53 %26.09 6756%26.099,311,33788 THE HANOVER INS GRP7 %3.47 %40.46 51564422%40.465,839,785

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP8 %2.67 %16.05 7988%15.264,487,836218 CNA INS GRP9 %1.71 %46.43 161099%38.782,883,886626 ACE LTD GRP10 %1.61 %49.91 15111012%42.832,703,699306 CUNA MUT GRP11 %1.20 %14.30 N/R421210%14.242,012,197

71 UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP12 %1.08 %0.00 13281111%0.001,812,136796 QBE INS GRP13 %0.81 %23.15 27331514%21.281,362,057244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP14 %0.79 %7.71 11151416%7.641,327,931

1285 XL AMER GRP15 %0.66 %35.15 35252128%20.111,110,758111 LIBERTY MUT GRP16 %0.65 %)(1.23 12177%)(1.341,098,537291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP17 %0.63 %45.45 23181820%45.451,058,42384 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP18 %0.62 %15.57 22242623%12.831,042,177

963 OHIO MUT GRP19 %0.59 %48.73 8131617%47.62998,800253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP20 %0.57 %42.31 19201918%42.22966,357225 IAT REINS CO GRP21 %0.55 %143.44 17222521%131.46932,961280 AUTO OWNERS GRP22 %0.52 %48.01 14162024%46.75869,477123 SHELTER INS GRP23 %0.51 %39.11 21232225%38.47859,913

7 FEDERATED MUT GRP24 %0.51 %11.71 10141719%11.82854,124248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP25 %0.50 %30.07 20212326%29.00834,359

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %14.89%12.60168,331,342

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners32

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 41: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Rankby

65 FM GLOBAL GRP1 %26.96 %56.96 1111%56.44370,110,74012 AMERICAN INTL GRP2 %18.51 %13.42 2222%12.42254,179,494

3548 TRAVELERS GRP3 %8.88 %31.73 3333%32.19121,883,54938 CHUBB & SON INC GRP4 %7.49 %10.98 4444%11.42102,799,803

212 ZURICH INS GRP5 %6.91 %19.80 5555%18.4894,902,374361 MUNICH RE GRP6 %5.07 %26.95 124135N/R134%24.2669,668,327218 CNA INS GRP7 %4.60 %72.35 6666%66.0363,200,590761 ALLIANZ INS GRP8 %2.13 %)(4.33 7778%)(2.7829,294,649140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP9 %2.01 %46.58 8887%46.5427,631,36062 EMC INS CO GRP10 %1.61 %12.70 10999%12.7022,161,551

181 SWISS RE GRP11 %1.28 %)(44.77 N/R131413%)(41.9717,510,432242 SELECTIVE INS GRP12 %1.27 %24.96 12121010%24.8717,449,574244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP13 %1.02 %27.10 9101112%26.9014,025,621

1285 XL AMER GRP14 %0.89 %1.21 18111211%0.8312,242,33798 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP15 %0.60 %13.90 14161518%13.598,229,09884 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP16 %0.59 %10.14 27242115%10.138,056,750

7 FEDERATED MUT GRP17 %0.56 %24.06 11141314%24.067,735,72613528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO18 %0.54 %18.79 19181819%18.797,421,59414974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS19 %0.52 %13.07 21201916%13.077,145,660

3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP20 %0.41 %7.65 17171617%7.615,586,45036 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP21 %0.37 %13.78 22212020%13.785,115,212

111 LIBERTY MUT GRP22 %0.37 %4.03 15151721%5.275,046,123626 ACE LTD GRP23 %0.34 %)(11.21 16192222%)(10.994,706,013

3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP24 %0.34 %22.72 26343742%22.814,609,99691 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP25 %0.33 %35.96 20222323%34.504,577,008

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %30.83%30.071,372,955,593

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners33

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 42: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

28 - Credit

Rankby

19 ASSURANT INC GRP1 %17.33 %28.19 28313640%28.15327,362,54512 AMERICAN INTL GRP2 %13.44 %288.53 6713%287.75253,886,831

761 ALLIANZ INS GRP3 %10.58 %74.77 1132%74.37199,793,457796 QBE INS GRP4 %8.21 %31.65 34282921%30.58155,143,007150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP5 %8.11 %161.93 4421%148.65153,249,555408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP6 %6.97 %36.91 3354%36.91131,720,423

31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO7 %3.91 %116.55 9986%113.6573,945,05293 STATE NATL GRP8 %3.26 %57.35 1921119%50.3261,624,408

181 SWISS RE GRP9 %2.70 %61.28 7677%60.2851,042,4381129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP10 %2.65 %58.91 10111310%58.9150,087,3181279 ARCH INS GRP11 %2.46 %39.45 8101213%39.3946,508,937

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP12 %2.43 %94.54 5245%94.5745,855,02584 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP13 %1.68 %43.21 17151515%43.0931,757,916

4254 THE WARRANTY GRP14 %1.57 %32.48 N/R141412%32.4829,748,748468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP15 %1.57 %37.88 2568%37.8929,614,585681 SERVICE LIFE GRP16 %1.53 %34.88 12131011%34.8828,970,459626 ACE LTD GRP17 %1.52 %4.84 11121816%1.4328,768,606212 ZURICH INS GRP18 %1.50 %693.64 18171717%679.7228,422,478984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP19 %0.98 %153.70 29242119%150.2218,558,108458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP20 %0.91 %29.76 148914%29.7617,133,561697 VAN ENT GRP21 %0.84 %47.36 21191918%47.3615,815,944

79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP22 %0.84 %7.88 N/RN/R4228%7.8815,789,664641 FIRST TOWER GRP23 %0.69 %10.12 N/R442324%10.1212,999,838

2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP24 %0.67 %35.05 N/R161620%35.0512,678,76318538 BANCINSURE INC25 %0.43 %57.55 23262626%57.558,123,420

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %106.52%104.671,888,866,148

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners34

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 43: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

30 - Warranty

Rankby

12 AMERICAN INTL GRP1 %34.82 %75.49 N/RN/RN/R1%75.49924,459,10179 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP2 %16.16 %58.71 N/RN/RN/R2%58.72429,067,988

4254 THE WARRANTY GRP3 %9.40 %69.92 N/RN/RN/R3%69.52249,484,182212 ZURICH INS GRP4 %6.69 %43.10 N/RN/RN/R8%43.04177,631,886

2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP5 %5.03 %80.17 N/RN/RN/R4%80.17133,397,333281 JM FAMILY GRP6 %4.16 %55.99 N/RN/RN/R7%55.28110,363,381

19 ASSURANT INC GRP7 %3.50 %41.25 N/RN/RN/R5%41.2292,947,73018 AMERICAN ROAD GRP8 %2.65 %40.20 N/RN/RN/R9%40.2070,223,440

471 WELLS FARGO GRP9 %2.61 %69.01 N/RN/RN/R11%67.9869,183,44216705 DEALERS ASSUR CO10 %2.09 %60.91 N/RN/RN/R13%60.9155,551,987

458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP11 %2.08 %96.39 N/RN/RN/R10%96.3955,098,441697 VAN ENT GRP12 %2.00 %44.37 N/RN/RN/R12%44.3753,200,895

1285 XL AMER GRP13 %1.96 %100.36 N/RN/RN/R6%98.9852,040,2188 ALLSTATE INS GRP14 %1.22 %46.35 N/RN/RN/R15%46.3232,504,426

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP15 %1.21 %83.20 N/RN/RN/R14%83.2132,104,712660 MERCURY GEN GRP16 %1.03 %91.39 N/RN/RN/R16%91.4027,284,272218 CNA INS GRP17 %0.63 %66.83 N/RN/RN/R18%66.3716,838,793150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP18 %0.61 %66.56 N/RN/RN/R19%66.5616,104,997

84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP19 %0.49 %80.72 N/RN/RN/R17%80.7213,065,98037621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO20 %0.29 %36.53 N/RN/RN/R23%36.537,605,292

1226 GEORGE A PARMER GRP21 %0.28 %41.01 N/RN/RN/RN/R%39.257,526,88532107 SUTTER INS CO22 %0.20 %70.72 N/RN/RN/R21%70.725,270,300

1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP23 %0.18 %109.35 N/RN/RN/R20%109.354,770,44110499 CHRYSLER INS CO24 %0.17 %61.30 N/RN/RN/R22%61.184,637,04923479 NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC25 %0.14 %57.33 N/RN/RN/R24%57.463,645,368

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %65.43%65.252,654,619,879

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners35

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 44: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

NAICCode Company/Group NamePrem

MarketShare

Direct WrittenPremium

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio¹

2009 2008 2007 2006 2005

Rank Rank Rank Rankto EP Ratio²Direct Loss

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

five-year rankings for top 25 companies

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Rankby

10899 ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG1 %14.37 %53.67 N/R771%53.67203,320,88798 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP2 %12.22 %58.28 45544%57.82172,906,63884 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP3 %7.29 %13.52 7982%13.02103,224,107

212 ZURICH INS GRP4 %5.07 %63.44 1613107%52.6671,800,02429378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO5 %4.93 %0.00 1918185%0.0069,772,777

18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP6 %4.37 %59.51 2344%59.5161,804,5684254 THE WARRANTY GRP7 %4.16 %0.34 N/R23N/R%0.3458,902,843

37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC8 %3.78 %31.65 2220216%31.6553,542,91241 CITIGROUP GRP9 %3.60 %105.95 2017173%105.9550,989,267

34738 ARAG INS CO10 %3.60 %53.20 2729248%53.2050,919,240281 JM FAMILY GRP11 %3.50 %70.55 131011N/R%66.6949,479,637

3702 LOYA GRP12 %2.91 %0.00 N/R322913%0.0041,201,4961279 ARCH INS GRP13 %2.85 %103.88 13128199%101.6840,342,0291208 GRAY INS GRP14 %2.71 %56.48 12111310%49.1438,330,090

140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP15 %2.70 %52.75 15141412%52.7538,138,72731 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP16 %2.42 %103.77 21212311%103.7734,234,065

26565 OHIO IND CO17 %1.65 %66.89 26242616%65.1423,382,19012 AMERICAN INTL GRP18 %1.48 %62.78 9272815%62.7820,975,254

10906 COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO19 %1.37 %33.57 N/R373317%25.7719,384,5313483 PARTNERRE GRP20 %1.27 %59.81 N/RN/RN/RN/R%59.8117,944,723

626 ACE LTD GRP21 %1.24 %94.56 40383219%93.7217,614,3174071 RVI GRP22 %1.13 %12.57 N/R252714%12.5716,037,328

8 ALLSTATE INS GRP23 %1.12 %0.15 1061313521%0.1515,837,374761 ALLIANZ INS GRP24 %1.09 %28.41 12813313563%28.3915,384,573984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP25 %1.01 %)(0.04 33496934%)(0.0414,274,088

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** %100.00 %53.57%52.251,415,117,811

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners36

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 45: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

MARKET SHARE REPORTS BY LINE OF BUSINESS FOR YEARS 1985 THROUGH 2009

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners37

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 46: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners38

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 47: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 51,063,110,761 %69.59 %10.50 %10.5072.59%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 28,979,691,684 %53.68 %5.96 %16.4658.47%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 26,153,440,231 %58.94 %5.38 %21.8461.53%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 26,140,201,178 %69.34 %5.38 %27.2276.92%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 24,772,894,328 %56.89 %5.10 %32.3261.83%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 21,409,548,242 %43.31 %4.40 %36.7249.39%7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 16,054,658,656 %64.83 %3.30 %40.0269.32%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 15,405,561,636 %60.55 %3.17 %43.1963.53%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,200,294,349 %61.58 %2.92 %46.1163.16%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 10,473,026,375 %50.22 %2.15 %48.2755.72%11 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 10,439,501,509 %61.84 %2.15 %50.4163.56%12 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 9,419,255,363 %38.65 %1.94 %52.3541.36%13 218 CNA INS GRP 8,131,205,861 %59.74 %1.67 %54.0268.68%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 7,780,534,083 %56.19 %1.60 %55.6361.17%15 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 5,764,589,841 %47.40 %1.19 %56.8150.82%16 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 5,681,564,588 %64.36 %1.17 %57.9866.96%17 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 4,451,729,312 %78.26 %0.92 %58.9081.52%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 3,860,839,234 %58.76 %0.79 %59.6962.62%19 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 3,735,278,486 %28.32 %0.77 %60.4628.50%20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,565,868,308 %41.70 %0.73 %61.1946.58%21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 3,255,838,299 %45.36 %0.67 %61.8654.42%22 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 3,199,857,312 %31.36 %0.66 %62.5234.62%23 796 QBE INS GRP 3,128,630,118 %50.68 %0.64 %63.1656.42%24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,071,344,125 %56.92 %0.63 %63.7963.26%25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,984,332,558 %55.68 %0.61 %64.4157.03%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 486,152,051,401 %60.26 %100.00 %100.0065.12%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 49,944,110,234 %74.05 %9.96 %9.9676.78%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 32,088,391,298 %78.02 %6.40 %16.3686.77%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 28,157,387,522 %65.74 %5.62 %21.9770.70%4 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 26,880,105,440 %61.94 %5.36 %27.3364.22%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 26,331,557,661 %60.85 %5.25 %32.5965.71%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 21,807,760,469 %48.11 %4.35 %36.9354.58%7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 16,225,291,933 %61.35 %3.24 %40.1765.65%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 15,826,371,498 %63.24 %3.16 %43.3366.14%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 13,776,834,518 %61.34 %2.75 %46.0762.90%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 11,049,580,528 %53.68 %2.20 %48.2858.57%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 9,836,727,259 %43.82 %1.96 %50.2453.17%12 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 9,575,491,347 %69.24 %1.91 %52.1570.81%13 626 ACE LTD GRP 8,656,266,131 %55.94 %1.73 %53.8764.58%14 218 CNA INS GRP 8,528,226,320 %62.69 %1.70 %55.5870.12%15 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 6,093,099,134 %48.91 %1.22 %56.7953.00%16 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 5,835,203,659 %75.97 %1.16 %57.9578.96%17 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 4,409,410,913 %72.46 %0.88 %58.8376.39%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners39

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 48: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 4,091,749,579 %56.97 %0.82 %59.6560.60%19 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 3,853,077,113 %33.32 %0.77 %60.4233.47%20 213 ERIE INS GRP 3,799,901,584 %56.63 %0.76 %61.1859.25%21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 3,579,386,081 %52.05 %0.71 %61.8959.65%22 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 3,219,625,816 %88.98 %0.64 %62.5394.82%23 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,180,460,976 %57.33 %0.63 %63.1762.05%24 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 3,050,105,058 %53.80 %0.61 %63.7755.15%25 1285 XL AMER GRP 3,035,011,919 %44.67 %0.61 %64.3854.24%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 501,453,284,834 %66.78 %100.00 %100.0071.67%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 49,350,410,793 %61.27 %9.60 %9.6063.82%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 37,665,191,217 %51.92 %7.33 %16.9358.79%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 29,108,738,299 %55.14 %5.66 %22.5963.20%4 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 27,688,686,882 %51.50 %5.39 %27.9753.94%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 22,151,581,789 %45.28 %4.31 %32.2850.65%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 20,235,814,135 %56.80 %3.94 %36.2262.01%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 16,122,637,912 %53.44 %3.14 %39.3656.61%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 15,368,968,125 %56.99 %2.99 %42.3560.76%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 13,983,744,485 %59.36 %2.72 %45.0761.12%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 11,508,536,793 %48.46 %2.24 %47.3053.34%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 9,969,685,276 %39.58 %1.94 %49.2447.94%12 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 9,229,086,291 %62.37 %1.80 %51.0463.99%13 218 CNA INS GRP 9,117,428,063 %49.88 %1.77 %52.8158.91%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 8,474,530,756 %50.13 %1.65 %54.4658.38%15 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 6,007,066,371 %71.93 %1.17 %55.6375.70%16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 5,918,953,989 %50.63 %1.15 %56.7853.90%17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 5,864,181,851 %37.64 %1.14 %57.9242.32%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 4,468,079,313 %64.35 %0.87 %58.7968.85%19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,924,497,833 %46.03 %0.76 %59.5549.19%20 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 3,923,625,449 %45.24 %0.76 %60.3252.24%21 213 ERIE INS GRP 3,784,890,541 %52.08 %0.74 %61.0554.50%22 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 3,717,970,890 %29.64 %0.72 %61.7830.99%23 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 3,439,882,875 %29.05 %0.67 %62.4529.29%24 1285 XL AMER GRP 3,401,910,840 %83.30 %0.66 %63.1190.35%25 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,271,993,623 %47.23 %0.64 %63.7453.17%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 514,085,055,846 %54.25 %100.00 %100.0059.20%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 49,614,181,342 %57.02 %9.70 %9.7059.56%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 37,859,639,382 %52.79 %7.40 %17.1059.17%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners40

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 49: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 28,021,316,595 %54.82 %5.48 %22.5861.85%4 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 27,879,415,516 %46.82 %5.45 %28.0348.97%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 22,042,924,690 %46.33 %4.31 %32.3452.34%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 18,121,842,366 %56.90 %3.54 %35.8863.30%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 16,045,068,763 %48.42 %3.14 %39.0251.18%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 15,211,387,209 %54.20 %2.97 %42.0058.78%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,389,700,920 %54.07 %2.81 %44.8155.90%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 11,734,579,797 %54.80 %2.29 %47.1059.46%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 10,026,327,161 %36.89 %1.96 %49.0647.20%12 218 CNA INS GRP 9,507,786,698 %51.90 %1.86 %50.9262.12%13 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 9,029,324,353 %57.44 %1.77 %52.6959.09%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 8,153,887,418 %43.64 %1.59 %54.2858.25%15 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 5,971,195,296 %73.60 %1.17 %55.4577.10%16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 5,715,412,721 %44.96 %1.12 %56.5749.36%17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 5,626,666,717 %41.63 %1.10 %57.6746.05%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 4,513,101,864 %57.28 %0.88 %58.5560.80%19 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 3,986,337,871 %45.38 %0.78 %59.3354.17%20 213 ERIE INS GRP 3,803,414,453 %56.18 %0.74 %60.0758.74%21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,733,359,308 %47.75 %0.73 %60.8054.88%22 1285 XL AMER GRP 3,681,701,459 %46.22 %0.72 %61.5251.82%23 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 3,567,371,141 %61.20 %0.70 %62.2263.45%24 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 3,400,399,570 %12.74 %0.66 %62.8816.08%25 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,314,386,572 %51.60 %0.65 %63.5357.25%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 511,469,795,881 %51.99 %100.00 %100.0057.14%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 48,762,121,982 %78.08 %9.78 %9.7880.21%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 35,135,544,786 %80.45 %7.05 %16.8388.46%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 27,423,130,490 %78.30 %5.50 %22.3380.51%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 27,352,305,517 %67.20 %5.49 %27.8275.32%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 21,495,050,200 %62.63 %4.31 %32.1369.92%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 16,560,114,521 %66.25 %3.32 %35.4676.54%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 15,376,057,583 %61.62 %3.08 %38.5464.89%8 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,298,029,105 %54.92 %2.87 %41.4157.08%9 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 13,487,689,544 %59.26 %2.71 %44.1263.67%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 12,259,450,103 %63.63 %2.46 %46.5868.61%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 10,009,323,860 %52.96 %2.01 %48.5863.99%12 218 CNA INS GRP 9,255,348,514 %61.16 %1.86 %50.4472.89%13 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 8,546,866,778 %72.14 %1.71 %52.1673.98%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 7,509,377,368 %69.78 %1.51 %53.6677.78%15 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 6,141,322,743 %67.37 %1.23 %54.8970.90%16 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 6,022,059,494 %56.98 %1.21 %56.1059.06%17 163 SAFECO INS GRP 5,785,817,368 %49.54 %1.16 %57.2654.19%18 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 5,381,400,260 %67.43 %1.08 %58.3480.55%19 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 4,501,413,713 %55.75 %0.90 %59.2560.16%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners41

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 50: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 3,994,563,433 %46.57 %0.80 %60.0558.20%21 213 ERIE INS GRP 3,956,941,146 %54.64 %0.79 %60.8457.70%22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,625,235,271 %57.48 %0.73 %61.5767.53%23 1285 XL AMER GRP 3,388,659,301 %89.89 %0.68 %62.2597.06%24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,233,635,266 %49.30 %0.65 %62.9053.92%25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 3,042,187,591 %57.71 %0.61 %63.5160.10%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 498,432,593,767 %68.07 %100.00 %100.0073.91%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 33,740,606,112 %74.52 %10.32 %10.3277.70%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 19,708,684,302 %62.74 %6.03 %16.3566.62%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 18,520,182,905 %73.69 %5.67 %22.0179.34%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 16,526,008,134 %73.55 %5.06 %27.0778.43%5 218 CNA INS GRP 10,279,634,237 %74.14 %3.14 %30.2178.53%6 41 CITIGROUP GRP 10,085,763,056 %64.37 %3.09 %33.3068.82%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 9,921,454,502 %70.26 %3.03 %36.3374.57%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 9,711,349,212 %76.54 %2.97 %39.3183.12%9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 6,792,421,495 %61.23 %2.08 %41.3866.71%

10 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,702,303,666 %76.10 %2.05 %43.4378.98%11 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 6,408,267,031 %69.53 %1.96 %45.3972.06%12 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 5,730,099,170 %54.27 %1.75 %47.1564.85%13 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 5,720,211,038 %66.31 %1.75 %48.9068.60%14 164 ST PAUL GRP 5,653,366,309 %54.97 %1.73 %50.6361.82%15 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 4,940,211,460 %82.09 %1.51 %52.1486.33%16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 4,687,063,146 %70.59 %1.43 %53.5774.89%17 44 AVIVA GRP 4,655,614,965 %87.72 %1.42 %54.9993.92%18 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 4,268,657,345 %75.83 %1.31 %56.3082.55%19 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,782,518,134 %74.26 %1.16 %57.4676.92%20 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 3,756,184,621 %69.59 %1.15 %58.6180.18%21 671 WELLPOINT INC GRP 3,433,218,732 %84.80 %1.05 %59.6684.80%22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,354,967,383 %62.62 %1.03 %60.6868.49%23 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 3,015,731,186 %53.08 %0.92 %61.6161.57%24 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,894,991,811 %63.44 %0.89 %62.4973.70%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 2,397,334,826 %71.08 %0.73 %63.2274.04%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 326,911,319,886 %69.74 %100.00 %100.0074.77%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 33,720,190,815 %70.63 %12.00 %12.00n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 17,944,946,199 %67.46 %6.39 %18.39n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 13,363,721,554 %61.24 %4.76 %23.14n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 10,170,658,176 %70.85 %3.62 %26.76n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners42

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 51: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 69 FARMERS INS GRP 9,175,948,536 %74.61 %3.27 %30.03n/a6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 8,407,604,990 %66.77 %2.99 %33.02n/a7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,077,884,601 %73.23 %2.16 %35.18n/a8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 5,657,092,499 %64.93 %2.01 %37.20n/a9 1 AETNA GRP 5,170,714,211 %70.24 %1.84 %39.04n/a

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 5,142,088,793 %78.73 %1.83 %40.87n/a11 41 CITIGROUP GRP 4,728,117,782 %75.82 %1.68 %42.55n/a12 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 4,600,311,013 %57.62 %1.64 %44.19n/a13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 4,343,203,278 %50.52 %1.55 %45.73n/a14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 3,886,509,364 %76.81 %1.38 %47.11n/a15 164 ST PAUL GRP 3,665,546,107 %50.54 %1.30 %48.42n/a16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 3,598,616,782 %61.63 %1.28 %49.70n/a17 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 3,377,754,819 %58.04 %1.20 %50.90n/a18 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 3,029,737,581 %61.64 %1.08 %51.98n/a19 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 2,879,982,308 %57.81 %1.02 %53.00n/a20 81 GOVERNMENT EMPLYS 2,788,382,365 %72.83 %0.99 %54.00n/a21 159 RELIANCE GRP 2,650,310,721 %52.07 %0.94 %54.94n/a22 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 2,609,821,293 %66.59 %0.93 %55.87n/a23 163 SAFECO INS GRP 2,346,743,755 %57.69 %0.84 %56.70n/a24 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 2,126,483,571 %64.03 %0.76 %57.46n/a25 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 2,053,162,796 %76.82 %0.73 %58.19n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 280,996,854,123 %65.48 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 24,701,285,962 %77.70 %10.44 %10.44n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 13,972,684,840 %73.78 %5.91 %16.35n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 13,140,776,022 %72.91 %5.56 %21.91n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 10,923,091,679 %72.37 %4.62 %26.53n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 9,896,579,597 %73.78 %4.18 %30.71n/a6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 7,097,898,898 %82.96 %3.00 %33.71n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 6,936,002,563 %75.23 %2.93 %36.64n/a8 69 FARMERS INS GRP 6,641,212,868 %76.41 %2.81 %39.45n/a9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 5,735,793,092 %65.68 %2.43 %41.88n/a

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 5,624,302,845 %71.79 %2.38 %44.25n/a11 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 5,497,064,225 %75.55 %2.32 %46.58n/a12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 3,475,383,503 %68.31 %1.47 %48.05n/a13 164 ST PAUL GRP 3,313,466,381 %54.94 %1.40 %49.45n/a14 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 3,294,313,538 %50.75 %1.39 %50.84n/a15 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 3,150,254,334 %69.68 %1.33 %52.17n/a16 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 3,074,049,770 %78.80 %1.30 %53.47n/a17 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,047,455,726 %68.21 %1.29 %54.76n/a18 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 2,453,123,292 %68.11 %1.04 %55.80n/a19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,388,261,204 %63.15 %1.01 %56.81n/a20 159 RELIANCE GRP 2,158,745,648 %66.96 %0.91 %57.72n/a21 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 2,046,743,535 %68.15 %0.87 %58.59n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners43

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 52: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

35 - Total All Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 162 ROYAL GRP 1,984,499,226 %69.07 %0.84 %59.43n/a23 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,954,406,221 %65.83 %0.83 %60.25n/a24 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 1,861,433,440 %66.52 %0.79 %61.04n/a25 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,859,194,776 %84.52 %0.79 %61.83n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 236,516,458,671 %70.37 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 13,986,818,357 %77.52 %8.91 %8.91n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 10,136,846,127 %78.70 %6.46 %15.37n/a3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,820,356,610 %76.25 %4.98 %20.35n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 5,925,098,154 %78.97 %3.77 %24.12n/a5 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 5,005,954,304 %95.81 %3.19 %27.31n/a6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,985,927,083 %88.56 %3.18 %30.48n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,862,015,372 %80.62 %3.10 %33.58n/a8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,345,908,841 %68.48 %2.77 %36.35n/a9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,344,456,009 %84.08 %2.77 %39.12n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,105,815,027 %85.35 %2.62 %41.73n/a11 69 FARMERS INS GRP 4,103,526,396 %74.77 %2.61 %44.35n/a12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 3,857,138,913 %82.69 %2.46 %46.80n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 3,082,071,442 %104.00 %1.96 %48.77n/a14 164 ST PAUL GRP 2,633,740,198 %70.69 %1.68 %50.44n/a15 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,243,819,280 %76.36 %1.43 %51.87n/a16 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 2,032,437,334 %83.46 %1.29 %53.17n/a17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,879,329,555 %78.57 %1.20 %54.36n/a18 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,791,030,460 %75.86 %1.14 %55.50n/a19 162 ROYAL GRP 1,624,621,829 %72.67 %1.03 %56.54n/a20 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,499,220,431 %72.30 %0.95 %57.49n/a21 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,400,863,491 %73.00 %0.89 %58.39n/a22 138 COMMUNITY INS GRP 1,372,001,482 %89.00 %0.87 %59.26n/a23 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 1,334,429,676 %79.38 %0.85 %60.11n/a24 40690 NJ AUTOMOBILE FULL INS UNDWRTG ASN 1,329,583,678 %132.16 %0.85 %60.96n/a25 671 WELLPOINT INC GRP 1,175,573,396 %82.02 %0.75 %61.71n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 156,999,648,089 %80.08 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners44

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 53: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,059,465,984 %24.35 %16.01 %16.0125.50%2 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 1,323,281,147 %18.28 %10.28 %26.2918.29%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 808,305,394 %25.14 %6.28 %32.5725.52%4 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 777,233,844 %11.79 %6.04 %38.6111.81%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 751,951,260 %40.51 %5.84 %44.4642.73%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 712,029,054 %50.69 %5.53 %49.9951.39%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 495,314,134 %54.03 %3.85 %53.8456.22%8 361 MUNICH RE GRP 303,804,764 %31.35 %2.36 %56.2030.53%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 283,760,712 %60.33 %2.21 %58.4159.20%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 234,452,519 %71.37 %1.82 %60.2373.14%11 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 189,535,491 %84.72 %1.47 %61.7084.81%12 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 170,834,284 %41.37 %1.33 %63.0342.08%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 169,320,564 %39.28 %1.32 %64.3540.26%14 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 153,480,151 %86.53 %1.19 %65.5493.58%15 626 ACE LTD GRP 133,533,633 %100.76 %1.04 %66.58106.60%16 1285 XL AMER GRP 129,358,369 %19.42 %1.01 %67.5821.48%17 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 121,270,430 %35.99 %0.94 %68.5236.88%18 181 SWISS RE GRP 118,508,641 %43.47 %0.92 %69.4544.30%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 117,924,189 %23.42 %0.92 %70.3623.71%20 1279 ARCH INS GRP 104,144,553 %30.25 %0.81 %71.1732.27%21 147 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP 94,697,036 %73.12 %0.74 %71.9178.54%22 4509 IRONSHORE GRP 86,147,557 %43.35 %0.67 %72.5846.90%23 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 82,199,382 %35.76 %0.64 %73.2236.22%24 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 81,892,742 %27.66 %0.64 %73.8531.46%25 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 78,977,001 %15.32 %0.61 %74.4716.64%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,866,796,013 %36.59 %100.00 %100.0037.87%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,114,414,672 %39.26 %17.16 %17.1639.67%2 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 1,332,815,627 %20.75 %10.82 %27.9820.76%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 730,945,795 %62.33 %5.93 %33.9263.83%4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 696,414,212 %143.26 %5.65 %39.57145.00%5 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 668,841,114 %13.91 %5.43 %45.0013.94%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 659,245,774 %48.27 %5.35 %50.3549.09%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 532,070,154 %91.47 %4.32 %54.6793.84%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 264,995,543 %83.45 %2.15 %56.8289.93%9 361 MUNICH RE GRP 263,281,410 %35.54 %2.14 %58.9636.39%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 221,474,936 %77.33 %1.80 %60.7680.08%11 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 177,680,952 %67.19 %1.44 %62.2067.89%12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 168,930,823 %47.10 %1.37 %63.5748.15%13 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 168,137,163 %97.29 %1.36 %64.9497.36%14 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 158,639,854 %17.23 %1.29 %66.2317.38%15 1285 XL AMER GRP 139,922,855 %22.11 %1.14 %67.3624.27%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 131,340,626 %115.45 %1.07 %68.43119.36%17 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 125,121,357 %20.35 %1.02 %69.4421.08%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners45

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 54: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 104,493,994 %40.37 %0.85 %70.2940.23%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 96,257,422 %23.09 %0.78 %71.0724.02%20 181 SWISS RE GRP 96,188,531 %63.07 %0.78 %71.8567.01%21 1279 ARCH INS GRP 91,658,490 %37.44 %0.74 %72.6039.87%22 147 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP 88,613,198 %90.69 %0.72 %73.3298.20%23 215 UNITRIN GRP 85,739,444 %39.04 %0.70 %74.0138.99%24 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 84,788,528 %50.65 %0.69 %74.7051.73%25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 79,228,655 %46.41 %0.64 %75.3447.21%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,318,394,146 %51.72 %100.00 %100.0052.65%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,277,916,266 %28.35 %18.59 %18.5928.89%2 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 956,446,979 %21.03 %7.80 %26.3921.05%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 777,986,121 %43.96 %6.35 %32.7445.18%4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 723,689,684 %31.54 %5.91 %38.6533.88%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 676,423,811 %33.56 %5.52 %44.1734.57%6 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 442,173,223 %17.82 %3.61 %47.7818.45%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 438,584,744 %47.05 %3.58 %51.3548.52%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 278,130,947 %-21.74 %2.27 %53.62-20.85%9 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 230,692,178 %43.66 %1.88 %55.5145.04%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 215,712,954 %61.22 %1.76 %57.2763.61%11 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 198,537,591 %13.42 %1.62 %58.8913.60%12 127 AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP 177,179,533 %33.86 %1.45 %60.3334.55%13 1285 XL AMER GRP 167,937,575 %26.26 %1.37 %61.7028.12%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 166,950,819 %39.40 %1.36 %63.0740.60%15 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 163,518,933 %43.85 %1.33 %64.4043.91%16 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 134,416,288 %61.05 %1.10 %65.5070.06%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 133,479,844 %149.85 %1.09 %66.59156.33%18 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 132,728,357 %36.91 %1.08 %67.6738.12%19 1279 ARCH INS GRP 119,296,171 %2.51 %0.97 %68.644.66%20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 115,924,560 %45.92 %0.95 %69.5945.25%21 163 SAFECO INS GRP 105,089,707 %49.32 %0.86 %70.4550.54%22 215 UNITRIN GRP 99,783,811 %38.47 %0.81 %71.2639.03%23 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 95,778,505 %46.18 %0.78 %72.0446.76%24 181 SWISS RE GRP 95,629,778 %34.43 %0.78 %72.8235.11%25 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 94,575,228 %33.65 %0.77 %73.5934.82%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,254,512,812 %34.67 %100.00 %100.0035.96%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,521,032,936 %40.60 %21.11 %21.1141.05%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 775,596,577 %57.47 %6.49 %27.6060.03%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners46

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 55: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 715,508,131 %-19.92 %5.99 %33.59-18.67%4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 648,423,101 %56.94 %5.43 %39.0257.70%5 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 625,948,390 %22.54 %5.24 %44.2622.59%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 417,103,943 %32.49 %3.49 %47.7634.45%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 268,587,140 %-16.79 %2.25 %50.01-28.77%8 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 246,818,464 %25.39 %2.07 %52.0726.03%9 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 220,757,758 %-60.58 %1.85 %53.92-63.82%

10 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 216,251,168 %24.85 %1.81 %55.7325.22%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 211,020,042 %62.84 %1.77 %57.5063.32%12 1285 XL AMER GRP 199,363,073 %17.47 %1.67 %59.1716.86%13 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 190,155,340 %83.66 %1.59 %60.7690.69%14 181 SWISS RE GRP 166,831,414 %31.72 %1.40 %62.1632.34%15 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 166,461,217 %46.81 %1.39 %63.5546.91%16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 157,629,212 %43.20 %1.32 %64.8744.83%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 153,057,469 %30.77 %1.28 %66.1534.14%18 1279 ARCH INS GRP 146,377,715 %59.25 %1.23 %67.3859.94%19 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 143,854,754 %105.26 %1.20 %68.58130.42%20 127 AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP 116,239,614 %38.46 %0.97 %69.5638.57%21 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 104,047,343 %20.63 %0.87 %70.4322.95%22 215 UNITRIN GRP 100,143,564 %37.01 %0.84 %71.2737.42%23 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 96,895,724 %25.82 %0.81 %72.0825.19%24 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 94,913,859 %28.87 %0.79 %72.8731.00%25 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 89,256,133 %43.04 %0.75 %73.6243.31%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,942,888,804 %39.37 %100.00 %100.0040.46%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,122,239,918 %9.92 %11.94 %11.9410.69%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 728,453,965 %42.18 %7.75 %19.6942.64%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 590,930,104 %74.54 %6.29 %25.9875.33%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 547,289,871 %122.54 %5.82 %31.80123.62%5 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 463,444,257 %34.72 %4.93 %36.7334.72%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 336,852,291 %69.15 %3.58 %40.3271.92%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 296,926,856 %119.45 %3.16 %43.47136.46%8 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 249,971,767 %28.51 %2.66 %46.1329.07%9 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 204,553,769 %52.67 %2.18 %48.3154.45%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 178,970,883 %204.17 %1.90 %50.21206.74%11 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 169,605,431 %60.49 %1.80 %52.0260.63%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 168,006,950 %-58.54 %1.79 %53.81-60.61%13 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 162,164,988 %26.49 %1.73 %55.5326.29%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 149,999,728 %53.76 %1.60 %57.1355.19%15 1285 XL AMER GRP 148,274,832 %27.87 %1.58 %58.7131.44%16 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 135,597,274 %97.85 %1.44 %60.15104.04%17 1279 ARCH INS GRP 134,475,263 %-3.37 %1.43 %61.58-2.31%18 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 108,588,484 %63.35 %1.16 %62.7364.45%19 215 UNITRIN GRP 96,158,231 %35.29 %1.02 %63.7635.42%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners47

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 56: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 127 AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP 92,924,720 %48.46 %0.99 %64.7550.22%21 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 90,934,799 %69.15 %0.97 %65.7169.49%22 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 85,270,993 %13.75 %0.91 %66.6215.09%23 147 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP 81,947,625 %75.07 %0.87 %67.4979.61%24 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 81,299,533 %37.28 %0.86 %68.3639.61%25 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 81,292,103 %61.41 %0.86 %69.2263.82%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 9,398,878,781 %57.35 %100.00 %100.0059.18%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 668,538,834 %41.62 %12.47 %12.4742.80%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 355,360,171 %70.88 %6.63 %19.1072.66%3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 345,618,382 %67.82 %6.45 %25.5471.25%4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 310,238,812 %76.22 %5.79 %31.3374.33%5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 208,100,726 %38.99 %3.88 %35.2140.08%6 164 ST PAUL GRP 142,903,746 %51.56 %2.67 %37.8853.64%7 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 141,263,942 %25.43 %2.63 %40.5125.64%8 626 ACE LTD GRP 121,923,352 %59.81 %2.27 %42.7862.70%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 114,534,193 %63.09 %2.14 %44.9264.34%

10 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 100,594,613 %24.65 %1.88 %46.8026.55%11 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 96,987,297 %84.94 %1.81 %48.6088.80%12 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 91,909,610 %84.88 %1.71 %50.3285.00%13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 85,561,049 %48.48 %1.60 %51.9150.66%14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 82,653,270 %54.05 %1.54 %53.4656.83%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 80,643,386 %70.96 %1.50 %54.9672.09%16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 80,578,509 %50.91 %1.50 %56.4652.10%17 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 80,064,557 %64.26 %1.49 %57.9665.36%18 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 77,085,831 %40.88 %1.44 %59.3942.81%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 69,497,270 %65.92 %1.30 %60.6975.22%20 218 CNA INS GRP 61,187,799 %39.98 %1.14 %61.8347.09%21 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 58,886,123 %28.57 %1.10 %62.9328.84%22 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 53,733,716 %40.66 %1.00 %63.9341.51%23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 52,770,108 %59.09 %0.98 %64.9277.02%24 215 UNITRIN GRP 47,110,097 %45.35 %0.88 %65.7946.05%25 147 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP 46,460,139 %71.54 %0.87 %66.6676.82%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,361,724,729 %58.42 %100.00 %100.0060.25%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 635,100,969 %60.86 %11.45 %11.45n/a2 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 245,892,760 %24.45 %4.43 %15.88n/a3 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 221,719,053 %59.47 %4.00 %19.87n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 217,188,269 %87.52 %3.91 %23.79n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners48

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 57: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 198,566,916 %68.03 %3.58 %27.37n/a6 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 166,390,961 %30.80 %3.00 %30.37n/a7 164 ST PAUL GRP 149,943,542 %105.86 %2.70 %33.07n/a8 41 CITIGROUP GRP 138,636,987 %86.47 %2.50 %35.57n/a9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 136,197,659 %43.38 %2.45 %38.02n/a

10 162 ROYAL GRP 103,246,035 %74.57 %1.86 %39.88n/a11 69 FARMERS INS GRP 102,071,424 %39.32 %1.84 %41.72n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 100,518,524 %63.29 %1.81 %43.53n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 99,021,458 %114.42 %1.78 %45.32n/a14 218 CNA INS GRP 97,901,866 %123.35 %1.76 %47.08n/a15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 93,256,542 %88.29 %1.68 %48.76n/a16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 91,894,162 %55.14 %1.66 %50.42n/a17 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 83,710,107 %25.54 %1.51 %51.93n/a18 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 76,160,757 %38.22 %1.37 %53.30n/a19 171 GERMANIA INS GRP 72,364,806 %84.31 %1.30 %54.60n/a20 215 UNITRIN GRP 72,183,483 %40.84 %1.30 %55.91n/a21 159 RELIANCE GRP 66,533,530 %64.01 %1.20 %57.10n/a22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 58,240,066 %68.05 %1.05 %58.15n/a23 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 53,774,451 %25.52 %0.97 %59.12n/a24 33499 DORINCO REIN CO 53,648,802 %72.50 %0.97 %60.09n/a25 163 SAFECO INS GRP 53,599,946 %43.95 %0.97 %61.06n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,548,619,774 %57.54 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 345,980,866 %47.32 %7.82 %7.82n/a2 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 323,255,953 %49.34 %7.31 %15.13n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 289,879,082 %55.66 %6.56 %21.69n/a4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 249,716,893 %37.03 %5.65 %27.34n/a5 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 168,097,281 %61.93 %3.80 %31.14n/a6 218 CNA INS GRP 106,925,493 %48.30 %2.42 %33.56n/a7 164 ST PAUL GRP 104,363,315 %51.90 %2.36 %35.92n/a8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 96,853,487 %43.78 %2.19 %38.11n/a9 69 FARMERS INS GRP 95,332,389 %81.93 %2.16 %40.26n/a

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 93,129,831 %46.70 %2.11 %42.37n/a11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 89,610,903 %47.11 %2.03 %44.39n/a12 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 80,395,047 %76.78 %1.82 %46.21n/a13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 75,562,939 %36.24 %1.71 %47.92n/a14 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 68,607,921 %26.66 %1.55 %49.47n/a15 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 67,014,982 %44.41 %1.52 %50.99n/a16 215 UNITRIN GRP 56,862,764 %57.47 %1.29 %52.27n/a17 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 56,111,834 %47.40 %1.27 %53.54n/a18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 54,368,796 %56.32 %1.23 %54.77n/a19 162 ROYAL GRP 49,401,233 %44.02 %1.12 %55.89n/a20 1111 TIG INS GRP 48,787,960 %51.01 %1.10 %56.99n/a21 29610 45,724,912 %67.83 %1.03 %58.03n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners49

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 58: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

01 - Fire

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 44,561,998 %83.32 %1.01 %59.03n/a23 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 44,412,454 %49.37 %1.00 %60.04n/a24 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 44,195,358 %45.96 %1.00 %61.04n/a25 159 RELIANCE GRP 40,206,409 %46.46 %0.91 %61.95n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,422,070,286 %50.87 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 349,723,264 %45.83 %8.39 %8.39n/a2 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 319,682,999 %73.60 %7.67 %16.05n/a3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 271,132,644 %62.51 %6.50 %22.56n/a4 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 233,367,646 %134.01 %5.60 %28.15n/a5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 178,613,032 %58.16 %4.28 %32.44n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 125,969,097 %34.88 %3.02 %35.46n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 115,467,463 %36.93 %2.77 %38.23n/a8 218 CNA INS GRP 114,546,167 %14.68 %2.75 %40.98n/a9 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 104,978,438 %50.07 %2.52 %43.49n/a

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 94,283,521 %45.94 %2.26 %45.76n/a11 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 87,689,206 %50.21 %2.10 %47.86n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 84,144,731 %63.90 %2.02 %49.88n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 83,063,314 %52.34 %1.99 %51.87n/a14 69 FARMERS INS GRP 73,110,006 %45.02 %1.75 %53.62n/a15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 68,286,045 %57.57 %1.64 %55.26n/a16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 60,451,380 %80.70 %1.45 %56.71n/a17 162 ROYAL GRP 46,918,216 %24.63 %1.13 %57.84n/a18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 46,435,271 %86.33 %1.11 %58.95n/a19 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 40,238,422 %57.91 %0.97 %59.91n/a20 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 39,275,915 %58.39 %0.94 %60.86n/a21 215 UNITRIN GRP 38,041,591 %49.75 %0.91 %61.77n/a22 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 36,620,414 %44.40 %0.88 %62.65n/a23 783 RLI INS GRP 36,278,658 %54.11 %0.87 %63.52n/a24 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 34,121,091 %44.67 %0.82 %64.34n/a25 1111 TIG INS GRP 30,342,008 %32.79 %0.73 %65.06n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,169,460,724 %55.71 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners50

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 59: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,294,329,967 %61.55 %11.43 %11.4366.00%2 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,237,046,374 %1.02 %10.93 %22.36-0.17%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,070,199,249 %13.33 %9.45 %31.8213.47%4 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 725,859,947 %20.19 %6.41 %38.2320.48%5 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 513,990,304 %25.21 %4.54 %42.7725.26%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 502,916,996 %25.46 %4.44 %47.2129.91%7 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 493,359,585 %65.56 %4.36 %51.5767.33%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 293,909,003 %43.00 %2.60 %54.1744.02%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 288,544,557 %18.68 %2.55 %56.7117.70%

10 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 260,668,275 %9.89 %2.30 %59.0211.39%11 218 CNA INS GRP 230,556,183 %5.77 %2.04 %61.0510.86%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 226,583,551 %38.31 %2.00 %63.0640.64%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 209,866,991 %61.06 %1.85 %64.9163.09%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 199,078,491 %37.23 %1.76 %66.6738.14%15 361 MUNICH RE GRP 195,818,989 %37.33 %1.73 %68.4037.24%16 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 153,937,332 %66.91 %1.36 %69.7667.12%17 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 144,612,580 %-5.29 %1.28 %71.03-2.57%18 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 138,211,379 %84.77 %1.22 %72.2684.95%19 796 QBE INS GRP 106,384,529 %51.97 %0.94 %73.2058.23%20 1279 ARCH INS GRP 105,526,318 %37.68 %0.93 %74.1342.19%21 181 SWISS RE GRP 98,582,465 %-16.29 %0.87 %75.00-16.30%22 LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS. 92,829,758 %26.69 %0.82 %75.8230.65%23 1285 XL AMER GRP 85,038,858 %78.75 %0.75 %76.5786.75%24 175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP 84,434,437 %46.25 %0.75 %77.3247.11%25 4636 MAX CAPITAL GRP 83,344,113 %34.64 %0.74 %78.0531.98%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,320,172,054 %36.07 %100.00 %100.0037.56%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,558,659,302 %12.38 %13.84 %13.8413.02%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,186,819,571 %151.74 %10.54 %24.39154.43%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 993,271,672 %40.35 %8.82 %33.2140.14%4 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 538,858,963 %35.76 %4.79 %37.9935.53%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 518,698,665 %109.86 %4.61 %42.60114.08%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 485,588,340 %35.40 %4.31 %46.9235.43%7 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 475,529,490 %95.68 %4.22 %51.1499.42%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 414,964,666 %45.86 %3.69 %54.8248.06%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 296,205,241 %107.28 %2.63 %57.46113.68%

10 218 CNA INS GRP 259,006,410 %116.90 %2.30 %59.76121.85%11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 231,760,919 %48.48 %2.06 %61.8258.43%12 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 231,308,955 %84.00 %2.05 %63.8786.19%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 204,228,887 %93.63 %1.81 %65.6895.63%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 174,075,713 %52.23 %1.55 %67.2352.35%15 361 MUNICH RE GRP 163,553,665 %45.88 %1.45 %68.6846.89%16 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 151,386,398 %81.32 %1.34 %70.0381.42%17 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 146,743,000 %91.94 %1.30 %71.3394.36%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners51

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 60: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 129,093,010 %74.05 %1.15 %72.4874.59%19 796 QBE INS GRP 107,848,253 %39.08 %0.96 %73.4442.70%20 LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS. 107,522,437 %136.30 %0.96 %74.39134.54%21 1285 XL AMER GRP 99,126,110 %68.14 %0.88 %75.2773.85%22 1279 ARCH INS GRP 91,128,175 %67.91 %0.81 %76.0875.24%23 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 76,544,583 %64.81 %0.68 %76.7665.54%24 62 EMC INS CO GRP 75,768,676 %121.69 %0.67 %77.43122.29%25 181 SWISS RE GRP 74,463,009 %67.11 %0.66 %78.0975.16%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,258,357,689 %74.57 %100.00 %100.0076.82%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,985,025,114 %26.21 %17.31 %17.3127.77%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,231,537,003 %49.94 %10.74 %28.0551.96%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,081,171,903 %-1.07 %9.43 %37.48-0.12%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 527,438,504 %51.74 %4.60 %42.0853.72%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 495,153,598 %27.98 %4.32 %46.4028.33%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 352,699,112 %18.88 %3.08 %49.4718.91%7 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 321,865,174 %29.34 %2.81 %52.2831.48%8 163 SAFECO INS GRP 321,761,570 %29.68 %2.81 %55.0933.55%9 218 CNA INS GRP 304,214,862 %54.56 %2.65 %57.7456.66%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 293,849,268 %72.44 %2.56 %60.3074.95%11 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 266,742,354 %21.71 %2.33 %62.6323.56%12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 206,893,259 %49.68 %1.80 %64.4351.87%13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 199,562,678 %74.25 %1.74 %66.1778.97%14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 196,524,038 %63.07 %1.71 %67.8976.48%15 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 190,706,115 %31.09 %1.66 %69.5533.03%16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 151,369,724 %26.99 %1.32 %70.8727.22%17 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 121,292,788 %51.20 %1.06 %71.9351.71%18 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 109,483,151 %45.16 %0.95 %72.8845.16%19 1285 XL AMER GRP 97,559,667 %34.05 %0.85 %73.7336.51%20 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 97,181,430 %27.94 %0.85 %74.5836.19%21 127 AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP 95,547,543 %26.21 %0.83 %75.4127.04%22 LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS. 91,361,586 %7.26 %0.80 %76.21-3.00%23 1279 ARCH INS GRP 90,427,288 %-19.19 %0.79 %77.00-15.86%24 796 QBE INS GRP 85,340,824 %56.54 %0.74 %77.7463.02%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 77,524,192 %8.98 %0.68 %78.4211.34%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,466,883,600 %34.95 %100.00 %100.0037.07%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,881,253,357 %13.34 %17.30 %17.3018.60%2 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,306,259,572 %33.41 %12.01 %29.3133.47%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners52

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 61: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 785,403,041 %10.91 %7.22 %36.5410.32%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 503,234,532 %92.79 %4.63 %41.1798.67%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 501,920,906 %39.63 %4.62 %45.7844.34%6 218 CNA INS GRP 367,148,033 %19.49 %3.38 %49.1619.81%7 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 299,837,779 %2.58 %2.76 %51.923.92%8 626 ACE LTD GRP 291,642,254 %-205.96 %2.68 %54.60-200.86%9 163 SAFECO INS GRP 245,525,065 %29.64 %2.26 %56.8633.02%

10 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 224,184,990 %32.43 %2.06 %58.9232.53%11 1285 XL AMER GRP 213,719,554 %63.51 %1.97 %60.8868.24%12 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 203,096,884 %-1.14 %1.87 %62.75-3.52%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 200,673,771 %51.19 %1.85 %64.6053.59%14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 189,020,173 %85.58 %1.74 %66.34107.04%15 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 181,380,238 %12.30 %1.67 %68.0013.68%16 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 161,061,375 %63.06 %1.48 %69.4867.72%17 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 156,990,325 %47.77 %1.44 %70.9348.39%18 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 129,569,142 %34.27 %1.19 %72.1244.00%19 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 115,201,490 %48.51 %1.06 %73.1849.57%20 181 SWISS RE GRP 108,293,678 %205.75 %1.00 %74.18219.77%21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 99,934,645 %5.88 %0.92 %75.090.89%22 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 93,753,280 %44.66 %0.86 %75.9644.70%23 1279 ARCH INS GRP 91,019,551 %157.76 %0.84 %76.79167.98%24 62 EMC INS CO GRP 78,336,454 %35.47 %0.72 %77.5135.29%25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 68,181,792 %39.22 %0.63 %78.1439.75%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 10,873,449,404 %32.31 %100.00 %100.0034.79%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,147,338,340 %63.91 %13.17 %13.1764.21%2 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,046,543,031 %268.54 %12.01 %25.17270.96%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 529,939,781 %724.78 %6.08 %31.26730.81%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 493,720,267 %186.22 %5.67 %36.92188.41%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 403,665,866 %182.11 %4.63 %41.55188.23%6 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 257,733,724 %478.74 %2.96 %44.51482.42%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 250,717,963 %540.30 %2.88 %47.39540.69%8 218 CNA INS GRP 229,164,560 %324.89 %2.63 %50.02332.64%9 163 SAFECO INS GRP 210,140,052 %66.49 %2.41 %52.4369.90%

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 196,275,480 %220.33 %2.25 %54.68242.22%11 1285 XL AMER GRP 182,660,610 %284.12 %2.10 %56.78298.68%12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 177,841,923 %138.04 %2.04 %58.82141.29%13 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 166,171,628 %120.62 %1.91 %60.72120.65%14 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 143,759,485 %378.30 %1.65 %62.37382.59%15 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 138,753,478 %112.02 %1.59 %63.97112.52%16 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 126,841,120 %297.21 %1.46 %65.42300.81%17 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 126,527,378 %174.31 %1.45 %66.87179.00%18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 110,789,726 %105.31 %1.27 %68.14110.32%19 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 98,884,559 %100.76 %1.13 %69.28101.43%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners53

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 62: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 95,676,535 %45.39 %1.10 %70.3845.55%21 2578 POE FINANCIAL GRP 94,403,404 %535.35 %1.08 %71.46535.60%22 62 EMC INS CO GRP 76,856,828 %67.98 %0.88 %72.3468.16%23 1279 ARCH INS GRP 74,982,032 %834.88 %0.86 %73.20851.50%24 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 66,869,435 %573.15 %0.77 %73.97565.10%25 215 UNITRIN GRP 65,516,231 %166.79 %0.75 %74.72167.41%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 8,714,654,299 %235.15 %100.00 %100.00239.59%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 367,991,745 %44.63 %9.42 %9.4242.57%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 301,607,884 %87.42 %7.72 %17.1492.85%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 216,249,220 %134.00 %5.53 %22.67137.41%4 164 ST PAUL GRP 156,465,739 %63.65 %4.00 %26.6864.20%5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 124,949,482 %90.48 %3.20 %29.8791.89%6 163 SAFECO INS GRP 124,655,163 %57.03 %3.19 %33.0658.62%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 121,912,058 %36.99 %3.12 %36.1838.12%8 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 117,907,861 %65.46 %3.02 %39.2067.81%9 218 CNA INS GRP 116,065,527 %114.07 %2.97 %42.17116.26%

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 111,487,772 %59.77 %2.85 %45.0361.58%11 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 101,766,563 %24.34 %2.60 %47.6326.71%12 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 72,340,242 %57.43 %1.85 %49.4857.53%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 72,258,099 %54.93 %1.85 %51.3357.11%14 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 60,865,369 %121.61 %1.56 %52.89131.85%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 60,098,792 %74.65 %1.54 %54.4376.25%16 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 56,820,529 %112.35 %1.45 %55.88115.56%17 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 53,460,844 %120.45 %1.37 %57.25120.58%18 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 53,167,443 %66.61 %1.36 %58.6167.07%19 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 52,903,646 %248.85 %1.35 %59.96269.86%20 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 50,321,944 %46.41 %1.29 %61.2546.83%21 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 50,079,943 %61.27 %1.28 %62.5363.18%22 44 AVIVA GRP 44,441,775 %63.22 %1.14 %63.6765.24%23 215 UNITRIN GRP 41,760,427 %57.11 %1.07 %64.7457.69%24 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 39,607,883 %70.34 %1.01 %65.7580.50%25 62 EMC INS CO GRP 38,952,506 %68.15 %1.00 %66.7568.29%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,907,322,771 %73.46 %100.00 %100.0075.74%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 220,925,958 %103.06 %5.78 %5.78n/a2 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 177,489,162 %116.45 %4.64 %10.42n/a3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 175,349,822 %137.09 %4.59 %15.01n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 139,872,516 %87.23 %3.66 %18.67n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners54

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 63: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 138,182,301 %65.23 %3.61 %22.28n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 132,014,574 %80.23 %3.45 %25.73n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 124,977,915 %70.18 %3.27 %29.00n/a8 218 CNA INS GRP 123,386,730 %99.84 %3.23 %32.23n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 117,114,253 %70.95 %3.06 %35.29n/a

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 113,605,073 %69.37 %2.97 %38.26n/a11 162 ROYAL GRP 113,143,311 %103.03 %2.96 %41.22n/a12 261 MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP 84,670,357 %281.23 %2.21 %43.44n/a13 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 83,094,830 %38.27 %2.17 %45.61n/a14 689 BANKERS INS GRP 81,702,469 %149.85 %2.14 %47.75n/a15 69 FARMERS INS GRP 79,073,848 %107.51 %2.07 %49.82n/a16 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 75,623,435 %67.65 %1.98 %51.79n/a17 176 STATE FARM GRP 72,385,803 %95.36 %1.89 %53.69n/a18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 71,001,281 %96.91 %1.86 %55.54n/a19 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 59,453,330 %57.32 %1.56 %57.10n/a20 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 48,806,094 %46.02 %1.28 %58.38n/a21 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 48,766,818 %158.07 %1.28 %59.65n/a22 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 39,665,393 %119.36 %1.04 %60.69n/a23 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 38,530,591 %98.51 %1.01 %61.70n/a24 159 RELIANCE GRP 36,388,315 %166.45 %0.95 %62.65n/a25 163 SAFECO INS GRP 34,949,971 %94.00 %0.91 %63.56n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,823,325,640 %92.53 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 228,967,586 %71.60 %7.85 %7.85n/a2 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 220,783,422 %132.36 %7.57 %15.41n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 174,869,387 %55.61 %5.99 %21.41n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 108,402,280 %98.73 %3.71 %25.12n/a5 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 106,476,855 %57.98 %3.65 %28.77n/a6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 101,286,451 %68.78 %3.47 %32.24n/a7 164 ST PAUL GRP 88,219,886 %51.15 %3.02 %35.26n/a8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 75,105,107 %19.67 %2.57 %37.84n/a9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 61,811,878 %118.08 %2.12 %39.96n/a

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 60,991,478 %80.02 %2.09 %42.05n/a11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 54,978,717 %94.73 %1.88 %43.93n/a12 69 FARMERS INS GRP 54,501,077 %60.59 %1.87 %45.80n/a13 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 48,794,500 %63.01 %1.67 %47.47n/a14 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 44,052,508 %66.72 %1.51 %48.98n/a15 215 UNITRIN GRP 41,329,475 %65.42 %1.42 %50.40n/a16 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 40,342,612 %64.68 %1.38 %51.78n/a17 3 ALLIED GRP 38,492,508 %101.48 %1.32 %53.10n/a18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 34,836,695 %55.09 %1.19 %54.29n/a19 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 34,259,974 %87.80 %1.17 %55.47n/a20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 34,222,729 %109.33 %1.17 %56.64n/a21 162 ROYAL GRP 31,504,330 %92.26 %1.08 %57.72n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners55

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 64: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.1 - Allied Lines

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 31,212,935 %96.16 %1.07 %58.79n/a23 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 30,290,868 %75.93 %1.04 %59.83n/a24 163 SAFECO INS GRP 29,172,532 %64.08 %1.00 %60.83n/a25 407 GORAN CAPITAL GRP 27,254,874 %104.52 %0.93 %61.76n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,917,992,037 %73.60 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 207,437,110 %83.54 %9.16 %9.16n/a2 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 126,200,420 %68.06 %5.58 %14.74n/a3 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 103,329,680 %98.25 %4.56 %19.30n/a4 164 ST PAUL GRP 102,673,597 %53.61 %4.54 %23.84n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 92,094,307 %89.12 %4.07 %27.91n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 78,520,006 %57.65 %3.47 %31.38n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 68,959,682 %62.08 %3.05 %34.42n/a8 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 58,854,333 %106.58 %2.60 %37.02n/a9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 52,880,162 %85.77 %2.34 %39.36n/a

10 176 STATE FARM GRP 50,027,126 %95.51 %2.21 %41.57n/a11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 47,097,928 %60.86 %2.08 %43.65n/a12 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 45,924,195 %41.67 %2.03 %45.68n/a13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 44,834,311 %83.55 %1.98 %47.66n/a14 69 FARMERS INS GRP 42,026,657 %63.26 %1.86 %49.52n/a15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 41,763,770 %66.22 %1.85 %51.36n/a16 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 34,851,361 %51.14 %1.54 %52.90n/a17 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 33,726,291 %77.05 %1.49 %54.39n/a18 162 ROYAL GRP 33,664,582 %79.77 %1.49 %55.88n/a19 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 31,109,639 %68.09 %1.37 %57.25n/a20 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 25,211,390 %102.80 %1.11 %58.37n/a21 168 SEIBELS BRUCE GRP 24,737,589 %62.18 %1.09 %59.46n/a22 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 22,270,602 %94.19 %0.98 %60.44n/a23 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 20,914,211 %94.75 %0.92 %61.37n/a24 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 20,809,183 %182.56 %0.92 %62.29n/a25 215 UNITRIN GRP 20,484,085 %45.69 %0.90 %63.19n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,263,607,485 %73.06 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners56

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 65: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 1,401,035,911 %81.23 %16.39 %16.3981.23%2 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,369,795,753 %77.43 %16.03 %32.4277.43%3 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 898,445,295 %46.06 %10.51 %42.9346.06%4 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 779,684,960 %58.28 %9.12 %52.0558.26%5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 683,947,185 %24.47 %8.00 %60.0524.47%6 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 514,405,884 %88.67 %6.02 %66.0788.67%7 306 CUNA MUT GRP 471,248,964 %87.59 %5.51 %71.5887.86%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 381,363,258 %72.61 %4.46 %76.0575.96%9 42757 AGRI GEN INS CO 342,126,407 %66.95 %4.00 %80.0566.95%

10 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 321,112,268 %37.56 %3.76 %83.8137.57%11 1285 XL AMER GRP 298,122,498 %92.47 %3.49 %87.2992.21%12 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 278,559,406 %78.26 %3.26 %90.5578.26%13 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 245,259,268 %54.36 %2.87 %93.4254.36%14 13412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 95,255,504 %91.87 %1.11 %94.5491.87%15 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 94,461,867 %37.56 %1.11 %95.6437.56%16 361 MUNICH RE GRP 79,841,910 %148.82 %0.93 %96.58147.43%17 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 73,488,949 %97.25 %0.86 %97.4499.30%18 3500 NODAK MUT GRP 41,504,330 %52.91 %0.49 %97.9254.34%19 176 STATE FARM GRP 40,689,205 %90.70 %0.48 %98.4090.70%20 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 33,127,965 %57.26 %0.39 %98.7857.26%21 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 27,650,986 %128.15 %0.32 %99.11128.15%22 10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO 25,128,077 %68.88 %0.29 %99.4068.88%23 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 18,237,007 %133.16 %0.21 %99.62133.16%24 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 16,752,525 %223.04 %0.20 %99.81223.37%25 324 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP 7,199,599 %46.66 %0.08 %99.9046.66%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 8,547,373,473 %68.83 %100.00 %100.0068.96%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 1,727,914,534 %97.53 %16.81 %16.8197.53%2 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,726,345,074 %59.24 %16.80 %33.6159.24%3 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 1,109,416,693 %88.92 %10.79 %44.4088.92%4 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,011,536,804 %82.22 %9.84 %54.2483.19%5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 846,521,678 %-5.79 %8.24 %62.48-5.79%6 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 613,516,078 %110.08 %5.97 %68.45110.08%7 3382 PRODUCERS LLOYDS GRP 461,943,014 %88.33 %4.49 %72.9489.52%8 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 403,888,588 %83.56 %3.93 %76.8783.57%9 42757 AGRI GEN INS CO 402,789,112 %84.80 %3.92 %80.7984.80%

10 1285 XL AMER GRP 326,221,061 %50.15 %3.17 %83.9649.30%11 228 WESTFIELD GRP 314,547,882 %70.36 %3.06 %87.0272.22%12 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 307,399,968 %96.87 %2.99 %90.0196.87%13 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 282,609,031 %79.98 %2.75 %92.7679.98%14 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 116,670,123 %75.97 %1.14 %93.9075.97%15 361 MUNICH RE GRP 94,770,643 %51.94 %0.92 %94.8253.04%16 13412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 94,282,796 %55.93 %0.92 %95.7455.93%17 306 CUNA MUT GRP 66,975,288 %73.22 %0.65 %96.3973.22%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners57

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 66: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 62,329,595 %95.46 %0.61 %97.0095.46%19 3500 NODAK MUT GRP 61,360,427 %99.37 %0.60 %97.59100.75%20 176 STATE FARM GRP 59,265,640 %52.75 %0.58 %98.1752.75%21 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 51,171,724 %76.64 %0.50 %98.6776.64%22 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 36,601,213 %8.00 %0.36 %99.0211.31%23 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 31,617,310 %29.45 %0.31 %99.3329.45%24 10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO 26,858,093 %101.96 %0.26 %99.59101.96%25 1213 DIRECT GEN GRP 14,229,960 %130.83 %0.14 %99.73130.83%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 10,278,360,620 %73.70 %100.00 %100.0073.91%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,143,812,310 %88.90 %17.01 %17.0188.91%2 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 1,116,355,095 %65.54 %16.60 %33.6165.54%3 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 708,129,256 %41.48 %10.53 %44.1441.48%4 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 704,277,830 %51.60 %10.47 %54.6152.01%5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 571,126,619 %12.44 %8.49 %63.1012.44%6 12548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 357,547,340 %56.77 %5.32 %68.4256.77%7 42757 AGRI GEN INS CO 282,977,796 %45.59 %4.21 %72.6345.59%8 3382 PRODUCERS LLOYDS GRP 281,459,164 %56.81 %4.19 %76.8157.17%9 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 265,877,681 %27.33 %3.95 %80.7627.32%

10 1285 XL AMER GRP 213,100,363 %114.17 %3.17 %83.93115.53%11 228 WESTFIELD GRP 207,171,772 %53.09 %3.08 %87.0155.70%12 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 199,146,533 %44.66 %2.96 %89.9744.66%13 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 183,259,656 %57.70 %2.72 %92.7057.70%14 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 89,044,216 %12.29 %1.32 %94.0212.29%15 361 MUNICH RE GRP 72,299,250 %62.83 %1.08 %95.1064.03%16 13412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 64,643,007 %65.70 %0.96 %96.0665.70%17 176 STATE FARM GRP 44,618,542 %38.24 %0.66 %96.7238.24%18 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 42,164,635 %69.94 %0.63 %97.3569.94%19 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 29,135,562 %84.71 %0.43 %97.7884.71%20 3500 NODAK MUT GRP 28,853,396 %52.23 %0.43 %98.2154.31%21 306 CUNA MUT GRP 27,880,627 %100.00 %0.41 %98.63100.00%22 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 26,998,385 %-23.50 %0.40 %99.03-23.50%23 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 19,452,058 %37.38 %0.29 %99.3237.38%24 10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO 17,616,366 %59.07 %0.26 %99.5859.07%25 1213 DIRECT GEN GRP 7,619,348 %90.78 %0.11 %99.6990.78%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,725,186,057 %57.74 %100.00 %100.0057.95%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 626 ACE LTD GRP 864,094,159 %80.50 %17.68 %17.6880.50%2 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 813,880,028 %92.24 %16.66 %34.3492.24%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners58

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 67: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 527,389,391 %52.47 %10.79 %45.1352.47%4 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 476,893,083 %0.00 %9.76 %54.890.00%5 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 424,397,842 %48.76 %8.68 %63.5850.34%6 12548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 239,943,869 %103.55 %4.91 %68.49103.55%7 42757 AGRI GEN INS CO 217,278,970 %58.10 %4.45 %72.9358.10%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 179,171,052 %67.09 %3.67 %76.6067.67%9 3382 PRODUCERS LLOYDS GRP 176,938,842 %94.71 %3.62 %80.2294.98%

10 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 153,371,567 %65.52 %3.14 %83.3665.52%11 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 143,518,295 %33.77 %2.94 %86.2933.77%12 228 WESTFIELD GRP 122,794,652 %90.91 %2.51 %88.8192.90%13 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 122,662,012 %67.79 %2.51 %91.3267.79%14 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 82,672,690 %73.35 %1.69 %93.0173.35%15 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 71,317,305 %61.59 %1.46 %94.4761.59%16 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 64,161,734 %15.54 %1.31 %95.7815.54%17 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 52,333,575 %84.74 %1.07 %96.8584.74%18 361 MUNICH RE GRP 35,971,790 %17.28 %0.74 %97.5920.04%19 176 STATE FARM GRP 28,274,912 %96.13 %0.58 %98.1796.13%20 3500 NODAK MUT GRP 20,752,768 %88.68 %0.42 %98.5990.77%21 10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO 12,284,060 %59.87 %0.25 %98.8459.87%22 10783 CORNERSTONE NATL INS CO 11,752,567 %30.03 %0.24 %99.0830.03%23 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 10,783,719 %19.33 %0.22 %99.3119.33%24 1141 NORTH POINTE GRP 10,707,200 %29.54 %0.22 %99.5229.54%25 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 7,140,128 %104.17 %0.15 %99.67104.17%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,886,590,569 %64.08 %100.00 %100.0064.32%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 626 ACE LTD GRP 875,250,516 %39.96 %22.43 %22.4339.96%2 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 608,500,694 %43.40 %15.60 %38.0343.40%3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 422,592,616 %2.37 %10.83 %48.862.37%4 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 344,316,393 %60.61 %8.83 %57.6947.44%5 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 277,790,646 %100.00 %7.12 %64.81100.00%6 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 209,434,196 %73.96 %5.37 %70.1873.96%7 42757 AGRI GEN INS CO 173,870,259 %75.96 %4.46 %74.6375.96%8 12548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 143,443,238 %65.30 %3.68 %78.3165.30%9 1285 XL AMER GRP 136,710,108 %85.29 %3.50 %81.8284.40%

10 3382 PRODUCERS LLOYDS GRP 119,201,482 %56.41 %3.06 %84.8756.93%11 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 113,419,294 %43.59 %2.91 %87.7843.64%12 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 75,327,964 %43.77 %1.93 %89.7143.77%13 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 75,038,547 %39.20 %1.92 %91.6339.20%14 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 65,438,506 %86.20 %1.68 %93.3186.20%15 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 63,538,432 %29.41 %1.63 %94.9429.41%16 228 WESTFIELD GRP 50,224,689 %77.84 %1.29 %96.2379.91%17 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 43,267,019 %58.40 %1.11 %97.3358.44%18 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 34,106,454 %93.87 %0.87 %98.2193.87%19 176 STATE FARM GRP 18,408,529 %86.35 %0.47 %98.6886.35%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners59

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 68: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 3500 NODAK MUT GRP 16,992,606 %59.11 %0.44 %99.1261.66%21 10103 AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO 12,396,718 %72.91 %0.32 %99.4372.91%22 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 9,312,786 %9.42 %0.24 %99.679.42%23 324 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP 3,555,315 %41.16 %0.09 %99.7641.16%24 13412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 2,735,118 %0.07 %99.830.00%25 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 2,453,277 %34.58 %0.06 %99.9034.58%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,901,335,592 %54.06 %100.00 %100.0052.90%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 426,236,696 %92.87 %19.21 %19.2192.87%2 626 ACE LTD GRP 415,823,514 %104.72 %18.74 %37.94104.72%3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 306,046,041 %85.34 %13.79 %51.7385.34%4 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 177,690,227 %193.51 %8.01 %59.74193.62%5 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 144,535,619 %86.87 %6.51 %66.2587.61%6 407 GORAN CAPITAL GRP 142,871,532 %109.13 %6.44 %72.69109.24%7 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 130,535,263 %90.57 %5.88 %78.5790.57%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 66,621,946 %55.39 %3.00 %81.5757.98%9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 66,332,291 %158.55 %2.99 %84.56158.55%

10 42757 AGRI GENERAL INS CO 49,183,028 %62.45 %2.22 %86.7862.45%11 218 CNA INS GRP 48,793,961 %0.18 %2.20 %88.970.18%12 44 AVIVA GRP 45,544,519 %126.20 %2.05 %91.03126.20%13 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 33,360,158 %23.08 %1.50 %92.5323.08%14 718 NAU GRP 22,694,902 %172.34 %1.02 %93.55172.34%15 176 STATE FARM GRP 18,421,781 %65.50 %0.83 %94.3865.50%16 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 16,873,400 %125.15 %0.76 %95.14125.15%17 49 COTTON STATES GRP 16,377,200 %125.48 %0.74 %95.88125.48%18 556 AMERICAN FEED INS GRP 14,384,356 %82.75 %0.65 %96.5382.75%19 33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 12,251,156 %118.71 %0.55 %97.08118.94%20 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 11,986,211 %39.34 %0.54 %97.6239.34%21 34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 11,100,651 %97.63 %0.50 %98.12100.16%22 517 HANNOVER GRP 10,877,417 %268.73 %0.49 %98.61269.06%23 569 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP 9,784,423 %43.92 %0.44 %99.0544.51%24 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 6,000,000 %70.87 %0.27 %99.3270.87%25 227 MUTUAL SVC GRP 5,433,190 %53.42 %0.24 %99.5762.21%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,219,367,472 %101.74 %100.00 %100.00101.92%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 263,513,839 %0.09 %27.49 %27.49n/a2 218 CNA INS GRP 144,457,517 %95.51 %15.07 %42.57n/a3 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 91,244,762 %215.60 %9.52 %52.09n/a4 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 59,649,842 %114.94 %6.22 %58.31n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners60

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 69: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.2 - Multiple Peril Crop

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 718 NAU GRP 55,927,689 %164.24 %5.84 %64.15n/a6 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 51,586,412 %147.78 %5.38 %69.53n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 48,896,972 %85.95 %5.10 %74.63n/a8 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 44,757,599 %56.69 %4.67 %79.30n/a9 407 GORAN CAPITAL GRP 29,904,756 %257.08 %3.12 %82.42n/a

10 13927 DAWSON HAIL INS CO 29,753,467 %86.96 %3.10 %85.52n/a11 129 PROP & CAS STANDARD GRP 26,505,306 %115.13 %2.77 %88.29n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 15,171,966 %148.97 %1.58 %89.87n/a13 42757 AGRI GENERAL INS CO 14,954,292 %102.09 %1.56 %91.43n/a14 176 STATE FARM GRP 13,887,840 %86.47 %1.45 %92.88n/a15 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 13,299,998 %54.78 %1.39 %94.27n/a16 49 COTTON STATES GRP 10,617,027 %173.46 %1.11 %95.38n/a17 33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 9,989,139 %74.56 %1.04 %96.42n/a18 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 9,494,983 %122.90 %0.99 %97.41n/a19 34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 7,853,358 %86.71 %0.82 %98.23n/a20 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 6,528,868 %152.11 %0.68 %98.91n/a21 320 RURAL GRP 3,483,754 %26.05 %0.36 %99.28n/a22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 1,841,158 %741.24 %0.19 %99.47n/a23 13749 FARM BUREAU INS CO OF NE 1,684,113 %29.49 %0.18 %99.64n/a24 324 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP 1,572,011 %187.02 %0.16 %99.81n/a25 309 WESTERN NATL MUT 1,059,241 %31.57 %0.11 %99.92n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 958,426,536 %94.58 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners61

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 70: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.3 - Federal Flood

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP 485,346,166 %38.37 %16.60 %16.6038.90%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 397,392,483 %34.55 %13.59 %30.1935.80%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 302,853,572 %37.23 %10.36 %40.5437.23%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 242,331,719 %33.54 %8.29 %48.8334.92%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 194,731,980 %28.92 %6.66 %55.4931.80%6 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 178,933,886 %19.50 %6.12 %61.6120.69%7 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 178,613,936 %28.14 %6.11 %67.7228.14%8 212 ZURICH INS GRP 117,198,538 %98.84 %4.01 %71.72104.82%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 116,515,266 %48.21 %3.98 %75.7148.26%

10 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 114,488,176 %40.41 %3.92 %79.6242.80%11 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 87,135,320 %21.97 %2.98 %82.6022.60%12 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 40,599,124 %54.30 %1.39 %83.9957.07%13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 38,945,554 %29.01 %1.33 %85.3229.07%14 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 35,036,862 %22.61 %1.20 %86.5223.49%15 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 33,979,438 %7.69 %1.16 %87.687.69%16 36560 SERVICE INS CO 29,605,891 %0.00 %1.01 %88.700.00%17 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 28,219,780 %53.67 %0.97 %89.6653.05%18 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 23,842,794 %4.91 %0.82 %90.485.19%19 41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO 19,151,142 %7.77 %0.65 %91.137.75%20 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 19,121,456 %32.00 %0.65 %91.7832.00%21 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 15,856,343 %14.87 %0.54 %92.3316.22%22 311 MAIN STREET AMER GRP 14,817,676 %3.55 %0.51 %92.833.55%23 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 13,307,133 %30.68 %0.46 %93.2933.25%24 15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON 11,447,805 %64.78 %0.39 %93.6870.11%25 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 11,187,707 %420.48 %0.38 %94.06420.48%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,924,277,875 %35.74 %100.00 %100.0036.85%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP 473,240,221 %196.33 %16.73 %16.73197.13%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 388,457,240 %103.53 %13.73 %30.47105.10%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 292,082,294 %133.70 %10.33 %40.79133.70%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 236,094,284 %51.14 %8.35 %49.1453.17%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 188,007,778 %82.36 %6.65 %55.7985.46%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 171,291,849 %99.60 %6.06 %61.8499.52%7 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 166,649,226 %57.08 %5.89 %67.7459.27%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 118,900,767 %43.13 %4.20 %71.9443.25%9 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 109,022,492 %95.85 %3.85 %75.7998.71%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 96,160,679 %264.82 %3.40 %79.19271.75%11 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 82,572,429 %32.48 %2.92 %82.1133.98%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 45,941,038 %-14.29 %1.62 %83.74-15.82%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 37,440,227 %136.79 %1.32 %85.06142.95%14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 36,950,929 %44.32 %1.31 %86.3744.32%15 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 36,498,683 %36.11 %1.29 %87.6636.11%16 36560 SERVICE INS CO 29,001,011 %0.00 %1.03 %88.680.00%17 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 28,662,984 %26.22 %1.01 %89.7026.22%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners62

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 71: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.3 - Federal Flood

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 22,366,758 %438.54 %0.79 %90.49438.54%19 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 22,253,860 %-0.94 %0.79 %91.27-1.22%20 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 19,360,725 %119.56 %0.68 %91.96123.57%21 41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO 19,271,743 %2.68 %0.68 %92.642.92%22 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 14,443,232 %0.00 %0.51 %93.150.00%23 15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON 14,297,278 %412.32 %0.51 %93.66423.81%24 311 MAIN STREET AMER GRP 14,193,371 %8.74 %0.50 %94.168.74%25 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 12,653,539 %312.34 %0.45 %94.60325.90%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,828,407,566 %110.80 %100.00 %100.00112.27%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP 446,374,351 %20.50 %17.32 %17.3221.38%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 360,871,204 %-72.74 %14.00 %31.32-71.27%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 271,471,120 %25.43 %10.53 %41.8525.43%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 201,201,132 %37.36 %7.81 %49.6538.78%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 173,195,022 %39.28 %6.72 %56.3741.70%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 152,189,020 %35.73 %5.90 %62.2836.42%7 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 143,404,235 %36.88 %5.56 %67.8438.61%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 108,994,537 %16.34 %4.23 %72.0716.31%9 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 96,533,823 %16.96 %3.75 %75.8117.58%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 86,909,769 %27.46 %3.37 %79.1929.39%11 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 76,154,325 %24.60 %2.95 %82.1425.53%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 61,994,165 %3.73 %2.41 %84.556.23%13 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 34,805,883 %7.20 %1.35 %85.907.20%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 33,842,250 %46.81 %1.31 %87.2149.06%15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 33,526,374 %42.47 %1.30 %88.5142.55%16 36560 SERVICE INS CO 27,723,710 %0.00 %1.08 %89.590.00%17 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 26,354,907 %4.79 %1.02 %90.614.79%18 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 20,262,729 %18.63 %0.79 %91.3918.63%19 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 20,075,781 %-2.83 %0.78 %92.17-2.57%20 41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO 19,178,845 %0.50 %0.74 %92.920.84%21 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 13,064,167 %-0.07 %0.51 %93.42-0.07%22 311 MAIN STREET AMER GRP 12,007,962 %17.53 %0.47 %93.8917.53%23 15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON 11,804,826 %52.67 %0.46 %94.3554.71%24 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 11,676,700 %60.74 %0.45 %94.8060.74%25 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 11,504,174 %61.09 %0.45 %95.2564.33%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,577,638,815 %12.19 %100.00 %100.0013.25%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP 397,659,917 %75.79 %17.10 %17.1075.79%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 336,616,215 %-12.02 %14.47 %31.57-11.60%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners63

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 72: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.3 - Federal Flood

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 251,055,332 %13.97 %10.79 %42.3613.86%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 186,910,108 %272.89 %8.04 %50.40280.92%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 168,746,602 %230.62 %7.25 %57.65242.81%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 131,408,378 %-6.43 %5.65 %63.30-4.11%7 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 120,003,392 %53.34 %5.16 %68.4655.90%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 101,812,165 %-10.48 %4.38 %72.84-18.73%9 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 86,148,221 %55.38 %3.70 %76.5455.40%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 76,895,323 %59.17 %3.31 %79.8563.02%11 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 66,684,629 %41.03 %2.87 %82.7135.62%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 47,042,054 %-47.67 %2.02 %84.74-46.02%13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 32,156,653 %613.22 %1.38 %86.12613.22%14 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 31,764,546 %66.75 %1.37 %87.4866.33%15 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 29,889,950 %31.42 %1.29 %88.7730.56%16 36560 SERVICE INS CO 24,776,608 %0.00 %1.07 %89.830.00%17 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 21,559,184 %56.38 %0.93 %90.7656.47%18 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 19,524,536 %32.74 %0.84 %91.6033.51%19 41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO 19,110,694 %-1.62 %0.82 %92.42-1.66%20 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 19,045,731 %33.12 %0.82 %93.2433.38%21 15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON 10,742,674 %39.19 %0.46 %93.7041.06%22 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 10,617,995 %12.71 %0.46 %94.1613.56%23 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 10,539,234 %3,640.01 %0.45 %94.613,640.01%24 311 MAIN STREET AMER GRP 10,295,099 %46.48 %0.44 %95.0546.85%25 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 8,829,612 %2.29 %0.38 %95.432.73%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,326,040,352 %89.40 %100.00 %100.0090.96%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 670 FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP 331,573,270 %1,209.99 %16.90 %16.901,242.55%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 292,281,053 %1,854.88 %14.90 %31.801,855.12%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 210,976,744 %1,658.40 %10.76 %42.561,658.61%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 164,866,093 %82.47 %8.40 %50.9685.22%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 131,736,326 %281.73 %6.72 %57.68286.43%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 102,470,444 %962.64 %5.22 %62.90972.20%7 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 93,660,486 %127.50 %4.77 %67.68132.23%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 88,310,344 %318.44 %4.50 %72.18327.55%9 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 73,914,164 %688.39 %3.77 %75.95701.56%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 58,361,083 %87.84 %2.98 %78.9289.73%11 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 55,900,648 %321.31 %2.85 %81.77337.10%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 31,809,311 %2,379.19 %1.62 %83.392,379.96%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 27,646,576 %146.05 %1.41 %84.80149.30%14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 26,895,304 %454.25 %1.37 %86.17454.09%15 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 26,082,109 %131.17 %1.33 %87.50129.29%16 2578 POE FINANCIAL GRP 23,859,820 %0.00 %1.22 %88.720.00%17 36560 SERVICE INS CO 19,872,890 %0.00 %1.01 %89.730.00%18 41041 AUTO CLUB S INS CO 17,222,965 %12.75 %0.88 %90.6113.23%19 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 16,677,543 %192.44 %0.85 %91.46193.42%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners64

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 73: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

02.3 - Federal Flood

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 14,969,688 %1,370.84 %0.76 %92.221,370.84%21 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 13,798,038 %154.81 %0.70 %92.93154.81%22 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 10,377,329 %3.99 %0.53 %93.454.32%23 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 9,830,712 %94.53 %0.50 %93.9694.53%24 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 9,707,089 %5.46 %0.49 %94.456.18%25 15458 DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON 9,548,417 %22.60 %0.49 %94.9423.47%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,961,654,466 %872.23 %100.00 %100.00880.79%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 242,276,943 %13.85 %19.01 %19.0114.20%2 689 BANKERS INS GRP 167,782,475 %30.24 %13.16 %32.1731.80%3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 148,339,120 %18.27 %11.64 %43.8019.78%4 261 MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP 101,427,951 %10.31 %7.96 %51.769.79%5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 83,340,897 %22.73 %6.54 %58.3025.16%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 71,378,933 %32.59 %5.60 %63.9032.61%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 63,018,726 %30.81 %4.94 %68.8432.04%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 54,668,103 %13.01 %4.29 %73.1313.82%9 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 46,134,018 %5.19 %3.62 %76.755.03%

10 168 SEIBELS BRUCE GRP 38,311,426 %2.99 %3.01 %79.754.86%11 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 35,084,641 %20.14 %2.75 %82.5122.37%12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 26,144,531 %15.77 %2.05 %84.5616.66%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 19,443,939 %15.64 %1.53 %86.0817.52%14 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 18,846,819 %14.82 %1.48 %87.5615.80%15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 13,880,745 %27.40 %1.09 %88.6527.54%16 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 10,778,904 %65.61 %0.85 %89.5068.63%17 36560 SERVICE INS CO 10,741,229 %0.84 %90.340.00%18 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 10,702,360 %16.18 %0.84 %91.1816.19%19 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 10,503,950 %9.56 %0.82 %92.0010.98%20 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 10,103,091 %11.66 %0.79 %92.7911.52%21 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 9,043,567 %11.04 %0.71 %93.5011.04%22 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 7,487,112 %4.47 %0.59 %94.094.47%23 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 7,255,228 %3.05 %0.57 %94.663.57%24 517 HANNOVER GRP 7,059,246 %-2.92 %0.55 %95.21-2.51%25 41041 AUTO CLUB SOUTH INS CO 7,015,833 %0.50 %0.55 %95.760.70%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,274,768,967 %19.00 %100.00 %100.0019.92%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners65

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 74: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 236,602,540 %48.54 %8.38 %8.3850.37%2 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 188,581,950 %78.59 %6.68 %15.0679.18%3 176 STATE FARM GRP 182,932,691 %63.41 %6.48 %21.5465.48%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 142,924,651 %61.03 %5.06 %26.6060.05%5 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 106,891,318 %80.61 %3.79 %30.3981.68%6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 97,494,153 %68.06 %3.45 %33.8469.88%7 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 90,597,684 %86.13 %3.21 %37.0586.72%8 796 QBE INS GRP 89,101,510 %59.53 %3.16 %40.2161.79%9 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 85,598,541 %129.60 %3.03 %43.24130.83%

10 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 80,067,207 %75.09 %2.84 %46.0775.91%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 75,365,232 %66.31 %2.67 %48.7468.29%12 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 67,173,046 %106.80 %2.38 %51.12107.86%13 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 58,583,366 %59.57 %2.07 %53.2061.36%14 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 54,583,346 %105.98 %1.93 %55.13108.02%15 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 54,326,316 %74.66 %1.92 %57.0575.96%16 228 WESTFIELD GRP 46,819,079 %56.93 %1.66 %58.7157.37%17 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 45,482,153 %61.70 %1.61 %60.3264.64%18 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 45,425,880 %78.98 %1.61 %61.9380.55%19 5 ALFA INS GRP 43,187,690 %97.74 %1.53 %63.4698.49%20 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 41,192,627 %65.90 %1.46 %64.9266.90%21 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 40,081,733 %65.54 %1.42 %66.3466.74%22 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 38,970,334 %55.95 %1.38 %67.7257.54%23 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 38,769,920 %64.21 %1.37 %69.0966.59%24 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 38,139,586 %48.45 %1.35 %70.4449.51%25 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 34,158,749 %23.24 %1.21 %71.6526.70%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,823,343,509 %69.06 %100.00 %100.0070.62%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 230,000,847 %70.40 %8.49 %8.4973.91%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 178,781,423 %95.19 %6.60 %15.0997.79%3 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 172,257,296 %94.35 %6.36 %21.4594.96%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 130,705,959 %48.35 %4.83 %26.2852.65%5 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 103,251,673 %77.60 %3.81 %30.0977.17%6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 96,677,380 %96.50 %3.57 %33.6697.55%7 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 87,381,424 %92.27 %3.23 %36.8993.62%8 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 80,563,771 %139.07 %2.97 %39.86140.58%9 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 76,011,123 %108.29 %2.81 %42.67109.12%

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 72,852,522 %104.84 %2.69 %45.36112.96%11 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 67,013,987 %93.75 %2.47 %47.8394.25%12 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 59,304,642 %83.69 %2.19 %50.0287.73%13 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 55,968,078 %80.20 %2.07 %52.0982.33%14 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 54,144,610 %101.39 %2.00 %54.09102.90%15 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 51,017,844 %107.49 %1.88 %55.97107.85%16 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 49,913,772 %77.21 %1.84 %57.8279.45%17 228 WESTFIELD GRP 47,012,910 %55.06 %1.74 %59.5555.29%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners66

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 75: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 5 ALFA INS GRP 43,550,595 %82.11 %1.61 %61.1682.47%19 796 QBE INS GRP 40,709,180 %77.55 %1.50 %62.6679.75%20 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 39,555,441 %94.01 %1.46 %64.1296.07%21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 39,531,477 %90.03 %1.46 %65.5892.13%22 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 38,559,072 %79.17 %1.42 %67.0180.59%23 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 36,487,960 %71.76 %1.35 %68.3572.79%24 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 36,432,682 %85.83 %1.35 %69.7086.86%25 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 35,518,755 %49.90 %1.31 %71.0151.11%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,708,357,708 %82.69 %100.00 %100.0084.73%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 221,296,936 %74.48 %8.47 %8.4778.94%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 173,652,992 %49.62 %6.65 %15.1251.29%3 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 157,653,191 %69.89 %6.04 %21.1670.74%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 118,123,195 %38.43 %4.52 %25.6842.23%5 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 98,157,600 %50.41 %3.76 %29.4451.60%6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 90,378,141 %67.24 %3.46 %32.9069.71%7 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 83,724,248 %49.63 %3.21 %36.1050.16%8 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 76,790,517 %63.78 %2.94 %39.0465.29%9 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 75,631,859 %65.24 %2.90 %41.9466.25%

10 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 64,958,559 %81.56 %2.49 %44.4282.85%11 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 63,234,752 %64.51 %2.42 %46.8470.29%12 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 53,165,257 %59.80 %2.04 %48.8861.40%13 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 53,163,838 %73.29 %2.04 %50.9274.98%14 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 52,350,161 %56.00 %2.00 %52.9256.47%15 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 49,112,546 %53.94 %1.88 %54.8056.15%16 228 WESTFIELD GRP 46,379,532 %42.02 %1.78 %56.5841.76%17 5 ALFA INS GRP 44,516,672 %61.31 %1.70 %58.2862.27%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 39,069,360 %53.16 %1.50 %59.7854.84%19 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 37,761,063 %51.71 %1.45 %61.2252.51%20 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 37,305,461 %58.00 %1.43 %62.6564.85%21 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 36,716,508 %51.25 %1.41 %64.0654.12%22 796 QBE INS GRP 36,400,211 %44.48 %1.39 %65.4545.81%23 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 35,981,113 %48.06 %1.38 %66.8349.38%24 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 33,333,945 %72.52 %1.28 %68.1075.07%25 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 32,547,382 %73.38 %1.25 %69.3574.28%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,612,027,113 %58.12 %100.00 %100.0060.31%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 212,333,527 %53.22 %8.49 %8.4957.16%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 167,086,958 %57.11 %6.68 %15.1858.79%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners67

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 76: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 143,857,592 %50.77 %5.75 %20.9351.33%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 105,396,413 %30.71 %4.22 %25.1532.82%5 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 90,858,331 %88.42 %3.63 %28.7891.08%6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 86,077,532 %77.42 %3.44 %32.2378.13%7 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 79,192,566 %104.94 %3.17 %35.40106.24%8 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 74,035,402 %84.75 %2.96 %38.3685.27%9 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 72,195,824 %75.12 %2.89 %41.2476.44%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 61,819,101 %49.68 %2.47 %43.7253.33%11 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 60,656,826 %84.07 %2.43 %46.1484.99%12 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 51,379,461 %53.59 %2.06 %48.2055.38%13 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 51,302,454 %63.91 %2.05 %50.2564.88%14 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 47,853,154 %51.45 %1.91 %52.1753.40%15 228 WESTFIELD GRP 46,117,819 %48.54 %1.84 %54.0149.73%16 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 45,549,943 %43.56 %1.82 %55.8344.04%17 5 ALFA INS GRP 43,903,259 %72.73 %1.76 %57.5973.29%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 38,288,628 %54.81 %1.53 %59.1256.35%19 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 37,996,668 %63.77 %1.52 %60.6465.18%20 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 34,570,305 %43.55 %1.38 %62.0245.53%21 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 33,648,482 %73.46 %1.35 %63.3773.96%22 163 SAFECO INS GRP 33,504,671 %59.01 %1.34 %64.7162.19%23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 33,413,996 %43.21 %1.34 %66.0550.54%24 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 32,490,118 %43.02 %1.30 %67.3544.36%25 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 32,194,834 %48.46 %1.29 %68.6352.78%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,499,780,356 %59.31 %100.00 %100.0061.12%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 199,053,936 %47.06 %8.25 %8.2550.76%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 158,248,371 %68.98 %6.56 %14.8170.82%3 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 134,261,499 %54.74 %5.56 %20.3756.47%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 98,390,703 %45.66 %4.08 %24.4547.18%5 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 87,454,161 %48.52 %3.62 %28.0849.63%6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 85,805,941 %40.00 %3.56 %31.6339.60%7 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 76,046,068 %59.85 %3.15 %34.7860.82%8 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 70,960,948 %48.41 %2.94 %37.7349.29%9 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 68,949,198 %62.92 %2.86 %40.5863.67%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 60,266,183 %47.59 %2.50 %43.0851.72%11 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 55,549,884 %94.82 %2.30 %45.3895.58%12 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 50,553,006 %53.70 %2.10 %47.4854.99%13 228 WESTFIELD GRP 48,066,278 %37.83 %1.99 %49.4739.00%14 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 48,034,853 %57.05 %1.99 %51.4658.06%15 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 44,158,166 %60.62 %1.83 %53.2960.94%16 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 44,052,626 %79.79 %1.83 %55.1280.00%17 5 ALFA INS GRP 41,126,749 %108.49 %1.70 %56.82108.20%18 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 38,695,420 %57.91 %1.60 %58.4359.23%19 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 38,012,608 %53.99 %1.58 %60.0054.82%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners68

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 77: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 626 ACE LTD GRP 37,092,044 %58.53 %1.54 %61.5464.69%21 163 SAFECO INS GRP 35,398,028 %33.92 %1.47 %63.0135.72%22 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 33,787,807 %44.78 %1.40 %64.4145.86%23 15091 RURAL MUT INS CO 32,689,174 %47.43 %1.35 %65.7649.78%24 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 30,324,481 %78.24 %1.26 %67.0280.16%25 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 30,277,218 %40.09 %1.25 %68.2741.56%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,412,727,829 %52.80 %100.00 %100.0054.46%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 120,297,184 %56.18 %7.18 %7.1862.42%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 98,432,751 %75.12 %5.87 %13.0575.55%3 44 AVIVA GRP 78,706,147 %64.80 %4.70 %17.7566.58%4 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 63,334,185 %71.28 %3.78 %21.5273.61%5 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 61,253,452 %85.79 %3.65 %25.1886.27%6 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 55,326,224 %60.35 %3.30 %28.4861.17%7 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 54,538,835 %71.19 %3.25 %31.7373.35%8 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 46,824,026 %78.16 %2.79 %34.5379.93%9 41 CITIGROUP GRP 43,388,988 %58.95 %2.59 %37.1261.95%

10 228 WESTFIELD GRP 41,207,356 %68.97 %2.46 %39.5770.03%11 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 36,027,910 %87.42 %2.15 %41.7289.16%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 34,537,322 %58.22 %2.06 %43.7864.30%13 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 34,174,498 %73.56 %2.04 %45.8274.18%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 32,172,405 %55.95 %1.92 %47.7458.66%15 5 ALFA INS GRP 31,620,671 %77.81 %1.89 %49.6379.37%16 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 30,254,929 %59.04 %1.81 %51.4360.35%17 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 28,465,477 %72.59 %1.70 %53.1373.46%18 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 28,164,375 %96.96 %1.68 %54.8199.41%19 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 27,310,487 %68.55 %1.63 %56.4469.44%20 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 25,538,960 %51.15 %1.52 %57.9752.20%21 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 25,498,754 %54.76 %1.52 %59.4956.79%22 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 24,892,726 %60.55 %1.49 %60.9766.12%23 123 SHELTER INS GRP 23,708,288 %72.02 %1.41 %62.3973.54%24 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 20,900,829 %74.06 %1.25 %63.6374.94%25 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 20,802,880 %71.88 %1.24 %64.8873.54%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,676,113,719 %67.63 %100.00 %100.0069.54%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 106,303,786 %67.46 %7.98 %7.98n/a2 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 57,943,417 %69.99 %4.35 %12.33n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 51,576,085 %83.72 %3.87 %16.20n/a4 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 40,945,788 %80.41 %3.07 %19.27n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners69

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 78: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 40,114,587 %68.39 %3.01 %22.28n/a6 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 38,872,977 %70.96 %2.92 %25.20n/a7 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 37,112,832 %82.20 %2.79 %27.99n/a8 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 36,486,444 %65.13 %2.74 %30.73n/a9 3 ALLIED GRP 28,741,460 %61.13 %2.16 %32.88n/a

10 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 26,227,150 %65.40 %1.97 %34.85n/a11 5 ALFA INS GRP 25,884,011 %153.23 %1.94 %36.80n/a12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 25,386,233 %64.00 %1.91 %38.70n/a13 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 24,469,068 %79.89 %1.84 %40.54n/a14 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 22,915,296 %64.55 %1.72 %42.26n/a15 44 AVIVA GRP 22,433,438 %66.99 %1.68 %43.94n/a16 13889 FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE 21,787,062 %60.26 %1.64 %45.58n/a17 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 20,568,174 %70.41 %1.54 %47.12n/a18 214 ALLIANCE INS GRP 20,211,454 %76.42 %1.52 %48.64n/a19 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 19,941,344 %80.59 %1.50 %50.13n/a20 123 SHELTER INS GRP 19,663,655 %70.38 %1.48 %51.61n/a21 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 19,440,059 %71.58 %1.46 %53.07n/a22 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 18,609,879 %58.86 %1.40 %54.47n/a23 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 18,397,207 %68.12 %1.38 %55.85n/a24 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 15,587,250 %81.61 %1.17 %57.02n/a25 846 OLD GUARD INS GRP 15,494,437 %67.94 %1.16 %58.18n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,332,254,959 %69.77 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 71,055,220 %84.45 %6.73 %6.73n/a2 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 45,836,201 %83.05 %4.34 %11.07n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 44,632,347 %72.51 %4.23 %15.30n/a4 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 30,185,507 %56.90 %2.86 %18.16n/a5 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 28,537,286 %63.99 %2.70 %20.86n/a6 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 27,072,405 %89.34 %2.56 %23.42n/a7 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 26,381,148 %57.52 %2.50 %25.92n/a8 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 25,611,314 %64.79 %2.43 %28.35n/a9 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 23,941,992 %80.72 %2.27 %30.61n/a

10 5 ALFA INS GRP 22,810,423 %75.16 %2.16 %32.77n/a11 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 21,490,695 %54.60 %2.04 %34.81n/a12 41 CITIGROUP GRP 20,540,831 %52.90 %1.95 %36.75n/a13 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 19,711,793 %71.39 %1.87 %38.62n/a14 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 18,208,054 %48.40 %1.72 %40.35n/a15 69 FARMERS INS GRP 18,054,754 %56.05 %1.71 %42.06n/a16 123 SHELTER INS GRP 17,252,343 %78.38 %1.63 %43.69n/a17 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 17,139,290 %71.58 %1.62 %45.31n/a18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 16,542,072 %71.47 %1.57 %46.88n/a19 809 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP 15,238,869 %82.01 %1.44 %48.32n/a20 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 14,912,760 %65.25 %1.41 %49.73n/a21 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 14,294,920 %99.86 %1.35 %51.09n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners70

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 79: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

03 - Farmowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 14,195,841 %58.46 %1.34 %52.43n/a23 320 RURAL GRP 13,734,040 %85.59 %1.30 %53.73n/a24 846 OLD GUARD INS GRP 13,203,284 %62.61 %1.25 %54.98n/a25 324 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP 13,099,932 %74.72 %1.24 %56.22n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,055,917,774 %70.78 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 39,758,722 %61.24 %4.69 %4.69n/a2 218 CNA INS GRP 37,135,030 %74.80 %4.38 %9.08n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 31,647,685 %76.62 %3.74 %12.81n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 22,887,280 %61.76 %2.70 %15.51n/a5 513 IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP 21,801,487 %60.30 %2.57 %18.08n/a6 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 21,522,170 %78.28 %2.54 %20.63n/a7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 19,590,946 %67.99 %2.31 %22.94n/a8 67 MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP 18,185,923 %84.98 %2.15 %25.08n/a9 69 FARMERS INS GRP 18,152,329 %81.49 %2.14 %27.23n/a

10 694 TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP 18,061,555 %60.22 %2.13 %29.36n/a11 542 INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP 17,455,788 %69.50 %2.06 %31.42n/a12 109 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP 16,576,799 %77.02 %1.96 %33.37n/a13 261 MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP 14,848,185 %162.17 %1.75 %35.13n/a14 5 ALFA INS GRP 14,496,974 %90.25 %1.71 %36.84n/a15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 14,003,600 %77.52 %1.65 %38.49n/a16 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 13,952,620 %78.05 %1.65 %40.14n/a17 561 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP 12,683,623 %92.20 %1.50 %41.63n/a18 14176 HASTINGS MUT INS CO 12,345,489 %59.34 %1.46 %43.09n/a19 220 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP 12,274,850 %74.91 %1.45 %44.54n/a20 123 SHELTER INS GRP 11,970,061 %80.30 %1.41 %45.95n/a21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 11,969,351 %73.83 %1.41 %47.37n/a22 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 11,907,766 %64.22 %1.41 %48.77n/a23 66 KANSAS FARM BU GRP 11,735,415 %69.07 %1.39 %50.16n/a24 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 11,297,138 %53.60 %1.33 %51.49n/a25 122 MERIDIAN MUT GRP 10,747,744 %67.06 %1.27 %52.76n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 847,281,279 %74.67 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners71

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 80: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 14,737,236,449 %66.53 %21.58 %21.5868.50%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 6,837,285,776 %60.40 %10.01 %31.5962.40%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 5,066,034,148 %50.38 %7.42 %39.0151.92%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,461,188,432 %56.33 %5.07 %44.0757.76%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,082,154,511 %47.20 %4.51 %48.5948.56%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,969,697,662 %55.20 %4.35 %52.9456.29%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,909,147,923 %64.35 %4.26 %57.2065.72%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,772,267,678 %41.39 %2.59 %59.7939.72%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,460,618,362 %68.24 %2.14 %61.9369.04%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,122,779,740 %65.91 %1.64 %63.5769.38%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 878,807,476 %91.93 %1.29 %64.8693.37%12 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 860,986,068 %52.86 %1.26 %66.1253.27%13 213 ERIE INS GRP 792,687,542 %67.23 %1.16 %67.2870.77%14 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 790,756,469 %41.85 %1.16 %68.4442.37%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 716,396,488 %53.19 %1.05 %69.4959.60%16 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 647,504,956 %37.39 %0.95 %70.4438.37%17 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 577,090,552 %87.51 %0.84 %71.2888.56%18 4663 UNIVERSAL INS HOLDING GRP 513,340,865 %33.80 %0.75 %72.0334.60%19 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 511,857,303 %52.69 %0.75 %72.7854.69%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 493,687,770 %63.55 %0.72 %73.5064.60%21 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 463,117,940 %45.52 %0.68 %74.1848.59%22 28 AMICA MUT GRP 431,265,405 %49.25 %0.63 %74.8151.18%23 361 MUNICH RE GRP 393,833,029 %46.41 %0.58 %75.3946.46%24 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 367,095,292 %65.67 %0.54 %75.9366.41%25 1344 ARX HOLDING CORP GRP 321,405,260 %31.01 %0.47 %76.4033.04%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 68,297,271,637 %59.27 %100.00 %100.0060.93%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 14,031,606,297 %81.24 %21.32 %21.3283.21%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 6,970,171,745 %72.18 %10.59 %31.9073.84%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,636,100,387 %86.42 %7.04 %38.9588.80%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,210,946,420 %68.57 %4.88 %43.8270.29%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,906,041,145 %52.35 %4.41 %48.2454.70%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,860,599,917 %74.38 %4.35 %52.5875.79%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,665,225,051 %69.23 %4.05 %56.6370.47%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,841,959,186 %44.91 %2.80 %59.4346.55%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,414,173,569 %91.45 %2.15 %61.5892.46%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,101,874,438 %65.14 %1.67 %63.2563.72%11 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,035,505,843 %37.45 %1.57 %64.8339.76%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,016,214,784 %65.08 %1.54 %66.3770.11%13 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 846,509,796 %59.81 %1.29 %67.6660.73%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 829,188,271 %100.18 %1.26 %68.92101.65%15 213 ERIE INS GRP 743,324,938 %62.06 %1.13 %70.0463.90%16 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 674,501,661 %49.87 %1.02 %71.0752.39%17 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 547,134,272 %80.71 %0.83 %71.9081.29%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners72

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 81: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 490,018,778 %47.28 %0.74 %72.6449.01%19 4663 UNIVERSAL INS HOLDING GRP 460,152,021 %27.16 %0.70 %73.3427.90%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 456,154,769 %60.60 %0.69 %74.0461.71%21 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 424,236,201 %79.63 %0.64 %74.6885.29%22 28 AMICA MUT GRP 415,013,213 %58.28 %0.63 %75.3159.88%23 361 MUNICH RE GRP 375,088,153 %68.37 %0.57 %75.8869.53%24 215 UNITRIN GRP 318,305,376 %72.52 %0.48 %76.3773.42%25 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 302,802,493 %93.16 %0.46 %76.8395.15%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 65,828,490,432 %70.76 %100.00 %100.0072.55%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 14,057,357,769 %54.54 %21.52 %21.5256.37%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,189,668,217 %47.51 %11.01 %32.5349.14%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,474,142,703 %56.79 %6.85 %39.3857.08%4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,882,513,153 %49.53 %4.41 %43.7950.82%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,821,286,017 %40.61 %4.32 %48.1142.26%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,655,818,201 %48.41 %4.07 %52.1849.26%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,228,631,752 %45.32 %3.41 %55.5946.32%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,837,297,724 %40.93 %2.81 %58.4043.13%9 10064 CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,502,253,598 %32.18 %2.30 %60.7033.25%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,426,049,759 %81.74 %2.18 %62.8982.56%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,114,707,319 %49.21 %1.71 %64.5949.15%12 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 860,186,231 %45.79 %1.32 %65.9146.80%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 827,788,929 %71.73 %1.27 %67.1872.94%14 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 822,040,426 %66.78 %1.26 %68.4469.54%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 787,658,190 %48.67 %1.21 %69.6450.53%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 732,882,472 %51.08 %1.12 %70.7753.39%17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 666,752,194 %53.57 %1.02 %71.7953.43%18 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 521,490,766 %61.57 %0.80 %72.5862.70%19 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 490,468,826 %46.61 %0.75 %73.3449.13%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 457,243,206 %45.98 %0.70 %74.0447.07%21 10861 UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS 449,795,430 %20.03 %0.69 %74.7220.81%22 28 AMICA MUT GRP 410,671,526 %36.55 %0.63 %75.3537.77%23 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 399,935,629 %87.31 %0.61 %75.9791.46%24 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 321,833,252 %20.37 %0.49 %76.4621.72%25 215 UNITRIN GRP 308,684,013 %52.36 %0.47 %76.9353.43%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 65,314,740,344 %50.30 %100.00 %100.0051.73%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 13,580,290,765 %50.69 %21.67 %21.6751.96%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,309,829,331 %39.68 %11.66 %33.3341.01%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners73

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 82: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,280,574,076 %48.35 %6.83 %40.1649.30%4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,853,602,498 %42.15 %4.55 %44.7143.55%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,660,259,168 %33.01 %4.24 %48.9533.87%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,504,863,318 %40.63 %4.00 %52.9542.08%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,889,462,753 %52.77 %3.01 %55.9754.19%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,745,024,544 %39.48 %2.78 %58.7540.82%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,431,084,633 %93.04 %2.28 %61.0393.87%

10 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 1,298,388,455 %24.48 %2.07 %63.1025.78%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,047,858,055 %47.28 %1.67 %64.7847.20%12 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 836,446,842 %62.45 %1.33 %66.1164.37%13 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 835,054,359 %48.77 %1.33 %67.4449.29%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 752,267,642 %43.55 %1.20 %68.6445.00%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 726,560,403 %34.86 %1.16 %69.8037.92%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 725,160,754 %55.30 %1.16 %70.9657.60%17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 605,980,530 %45.52 %0.97 %71.9346.31%18 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 479,275,458 %63.61 %0.76 %72.6964.44%19 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 456,991,831 %33.76 %0.73 %73.4235.87%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 439,618,488 %46.72 %0.70 %74.1247.68%21 28 AMICA MUT GRP 398,557,648 %37.20 %0.64 %74.7638.45%22 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 379,170,979 %65.01 %0.60 %75.3668.20%23 3484 TOWER HILL INS GRP 342,029,077 %35.64 %0.55 %75.9136.07%24 10861 UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS 338,419,633 %29.14 %0.54 %76.4530.04%25 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 306,224,350 %69.96 %0.49 %76.9471.22%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 62,679,486,747 %48.13 %100.00 %100.0049.31%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,835,979,825 %77.31 %21.94 %21.9478.53%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,054,404,747 %93.43 %12.06 %34.0095.13%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,000,219,400 %49.48 %6.84 %40.8451.26%4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,703,828,124 %61.67 %4.62 %45.4663.28%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,416,817,093 %66.54 %4.13 %49.6066.84%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,277,258,486 %72.06 %3.89 %53.4972.94%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,716,040,534 %73.44 %2.93 %56.4275.12%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,611,231,713 %47.29 %2.75 %59.1850.74%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,434,808,923 %51.12 %2.45 %61.6351.80%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 943,717,132 %75.79 %1.61 %63.2475.80%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 840,000,408 %60.47 %1.44 %64.6860.46%12 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 798,771,646 %74.90 %1.37 %66.0576.28%13 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 781,725,840 %128.52 %1.34 %67.38131.69%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 774,962,362 %39.95 %1.32 %68.7141.64%15 213 ERIE INS GRP 735,872,601 %41.04 %1.26 %69.9642.76%16 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 542,111,086 %70.26 %0.93 %70.8970.61%17 10064 FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP 511,493,021 %120.54 %0.87 %71.77124.89%18 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 453,718,834 %52.57 %0.78 %72.5454.03%19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 423,046,507 %69.74 %0.72 %73.2671.51%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners74

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 83: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 409,066,285 %35.95 %0.70 %73.9638.67%21 2578 POE FINANCIAL GRP 402,430,257 %326.98 %0.69 %74.65327.48%22 28 AMICA MUT GRP 386,997,990 %54.09 %0.66 %75.3155.67%23 958 VESTA INS GRP 342,706,982 %58.49 %0.59 %75.9062.00%24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 303,158,472 %66.76 %0.52 %76.4266.81%25 215 UNITRIN GRP 294,018,127 %56.51 %0.50 %76.9257.97%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 58,494,903,262 %76.69 %100.00 %100.0078.46%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 7,530,049,063 %71.33 %21.66 %21.6673.21%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 3,971,989,819 %58.66 %11.43 %33.0960.49%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,899,188,455 %73.72 %8.34 %41.4378.14%4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,553,972,585 %70.03 %4.47 %45.9072.14%5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,246,640,348 %65.57 %3.59 %49.4966.86%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,234,487,566 %54.67 %3.55 %53.0455.79%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 834,870,607 %54.53 %2.40 %55.4457.30%8 163 SAFECO INS GRP 756,897,305 %75.85 %2.18 %57.6278.20%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 734,601,460 %89.28 %2.11 %59.7390.25%

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 712,978,496 %68.40 %2.05 %61.7870.72%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 573,855,680 %56.57 %1.65 %63.4359.30%12 218 CNA INS GRP 480,070,949 %68.56 %1.38 %64.8271.99%13 44 AVIVA GRP 471,822,837 %70.97 %1.36 %66.1774.50%14 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 439,912,058 %51.81 %1.27 %67.4453.52%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 411,429,275 %75.25 %1.18 %68.6276.46%16 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 400,264,815 %61.95 %1.15 %69.7764.36%17 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 376,510,166 %84.62 %1.08 %70.8686.65%18 517 HANNOVER GRP 362,269,745 %28.14 %1.04 %71.9031.99%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 354,971,422 %64.88 %1.02 %72.9266.58%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 308,361,240 %73.90 %0.89 %73.8174.85%21 164 ST PAUL GRP 210,029,911 %68.73 %0.60 %74.4171.92%22 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 202,852,457 %68.81 %0.58 %75.0070.69%23 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 202,104,728 %65.70 %0.58 %75.5868.93%24 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 197,947,696 %54.75 %0.57 %76.1556.29%25 28 AMICA MUT GRP 197,596,704 %48.60 %0.57 %76.7151.05%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 34,759,488,721 %66.44 %100.00 %100.0068.57%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 6,201,238,139 %68.94 %23.81 %23.81n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 3,039,452,008 %66.65 %11.67 %35.48n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 1,518,642,828 %96.96 %5.83 %41.31n/a4 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 865,569,616 %63.10 %3.32 %44.63n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners75

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 84: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 813,079,027 %65.43 %3.12 %47.75n/a6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 522,953,585 %46.81 %2.01 %49.76n/a7 1 AETNA GRP 512,986,833 %51.26 %1.97 %51.73n/a8 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 474,713,646 %62.87 %1.82 %53.55n/a9 163 SAFECO INS GRP 440,521,213 %70.53 %1.69 %55.24n/a

10 218 CNA INS GRP 417,530,508 %63.36 %1.60 %56.84n/a11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 411,113,038 %68.29 %1.58 %58.42n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 407,239,038 %60.87 %1.56 %59.99n/a13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 374,001,693 %64.14 %1.44 %61.42n/a14 41 CITIGROUP GRP 316,258,685 %56.25 %1.21 %62.64n/a15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 288,667,973 %61.36 %1.11 %63.74n/a16 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 286,752,579 %69.44 %1.10 %64.84n/a17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 272,535,296 %57.16 %1.05 %65.89n/a18 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 246,042,903 %59.59 %0.94 %66.84n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 223,354,819 %55.73 %0.86 %67.69n/a20 44 AVIVA GRP 222,175,032 %65.94 %0.85 %68.55n/a21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 209,357,701 %70.18 %0.80 %69.35n/a22 164 ST PAUL GRP 196,966,038 %62.46 %0.76 %70.11n/a23 213 ERIE INS GRP 195,423,856 %65.57 %0.75 %70.86n/a24 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 187,755,894 %69.17 %0.72 %71.58n/a25 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 175,397,765 %65.49 %0.67 %72.25n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 26,047,957,072 %67.15 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 3,677,810,829 %80.28 %19.25 %19.25n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 2,356,070,864 %77.28 %12.33 %31.58n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 963,495,684 %56.15 %5.04 %36.63n/a4 69 FARMERS INS GRP 843,162,338 %96.25 %4.41 %41.04n/a5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 513,306,357 %66.08 %2.69 %43.73n/a6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 493,070,999 %68.91 %2.58 %46.31n/a7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 383,592,834 %54.40 %2.01 %48.32n/a8 218 CNA INS GRP 382,076,822 %75.13 %2.00 %50.32n/a9 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 344,673,414 %65.29 %1.80 %52.12n/a

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 339,617,925 %60.50 %1.78 %53.90n/a11 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 292,195,472 %81.38 %1.53 %55.43n/a12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 274,802,681 %66.37 %1.44 %56.86n/a13 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 264,835,977 %83.21 %1.39 %58.25n/a14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 259,814,817 %72.73 %1.36 %59.61n/a15 212 ZURICH INS GRP 235,626,312 %74.87 %1.23 %60.84n/a16 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 202,472,323 %64.01 %1.06 %61.90n/a17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 185,446,571 %63.11 %0.97 %62.87n/a18 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 182,786,236 %81.22 %0.96 %63.83n/a19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 178,858,369 %60.88 %0.94 %64.77n/a20 148 OHIO CAS GRP 177,232,277 %66.48 %0.93 %65.70n/a21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 161,857,546 %71.21 %0.85 %66.54n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners76

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 85: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

04 - Homeowners Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 152,137,045 %53.11 %0.80 %67.34n/a23 164 ST PAUL GRP 149,472,342 %68.72 %0.78 %68.12n/a24 162 ROYAL GRP 126,760,780 %56.55 %0.66 %68.78n/a25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 124,465,114 %67.29 %0.65 %69.44n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 19,104,809,374 %71.29 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 2,614,363,366 %75.61 %18.22 %18.22n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 1,375,800,285 %73.70 %9.59 %27.81n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 872,531,692 %65.01 %6.08 %33.89n/a4 69 FARMERS INS GRP 657,583,899 %75.32 %4.58 %38.48n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 356,465,380 %75.83 %2.48 %40.96n/a6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 355,257,934 %70.01 %2.48 %43.44n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 256,506,989 %63.67 %1.79 %45.22n/a8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 254,177,928 %77.06 %1.77 %47.00n/a9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 249,285,757 %65.29 %1.74 %48.73n/a

10 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 238,690,934 %67.13 %1.66 %50.40n/a11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 235,254,267 %57.08 %1.64 %52.04n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 228,898,904 %70.75 %1.60 %53.63n/a13 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 221,133,289 %63.87 %1.54 %55.17n/a14 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 195,571,377 %60.26 %1.36 %56.54n/a15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 193,781,933 %62.48 %1.35 %57.89n/a16 164 ST PAUL GRP 191,360,365 %65.07 %1.33 %59.22n/a17 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 165,107,173 %68.79 %1.15 %60.37n/a18 148 OHIO CAS GRP 154,061,648 %61.28 %1.07 %61.45n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 152,788,728 %71.54 %1.06 %62.51n/a20 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 148,728,750 %61.21 %1.04 %63.55n/a21 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 110,606,764 %70.25 %0.77 %64.32n/a22 162 ROYAL GRP 109,778,745 %61.63 %0.77 %65.08n/a23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 107,941,598 %65.14 %0.75 %65.84n/a24 44 AVIVA GRP 107,893,515 %63.44 %0.75 %66.59n/a25 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 106,066,540 %73.42 %0.74 %67.33n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 14,347,492,755 %70.82 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners77

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 86: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,020,229,250 %35.68 %8.88 %8.8840.45%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,408,607,560 %38.44 %7.08 %15.9745.51%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,220,102,045 %48.82 %6.53 %22.5055.09%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,810,444,469 %38.99 %5.32 %27.8248.72%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,625,901,419 %31.75 %4.78 %32.6031.74%6 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,606,023,479 %50.27 %4.72 %37.3359.08%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,453,046,303 %58.72 %4.27 %41.6065.82%8 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 1,095,208,690 %36.21 %3.22 %44.8242.31%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,054,442,711 %53.45 %3.10 %47.9256.77%

10 218 CNA INS GRP 993,742,984 %46.63 %2.92 %50.8552.09%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 856,225,884 %49.82 %2.52 %53.3659.22%12 796 QBE INS GRP 845,880,580 %48.43 %2.49 %55.8557.87%13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 669,112,906 %61.01 %1.97 %57.8265.13%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 634,992,523 %48.13 %1.87 %59.6952.11%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 597,132,540 %32.17 %1.76 %61.4440.52%16 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 533,920,504 %44.40 %1.57 %63.0151.93%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 498,574,755 %61.57 %1.47 %64.4874.07%18 626 ACE LTD GRP 474,941,649 %35.94 %1.40 %65.8848.51%19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 462,915,020 %44.40 %1.36 %67.2451.68%20 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 427,997,606 %54.59 %1.26 %68.5061.96%21 18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO 412,411,710 %72.17 %1.21 %69.7173.10%22 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 373,215,939 %60.36 %1.10 %70.8165.91%23 3703 TOWER GRP 363,074,775 %41.33 %1.07 %71.8836.49%24 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 344,749,991 %33.11 %1.01 %72.8943.74%25 228 WESTFIELD GRP 299,738,476 %53.02 %0.88 %73.7762.51%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 34,000,334,901 %45.05 %100.00 %100.0051.89%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,035,751,096 %30.24 %8.68 %8.6835.77%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,711,916,906 %51.34 %7.75 %16.4355.87%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,386,316,487 %62.05 %6.82 %23.2568.30%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,975,228,129 %70.19 %5.65 %28.9076.39%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,706,395,746 %49.04 %4.88 %33.7756.28%6 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,635,168,081 %70.15 %4.67 %38.4578.72%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,559,098,420 %78.49 %4.46 %42.9185.58%8 218 CNA INS GRP 1,108,659,199 %31.16 %3.17 %46.0726.99%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,076,968,071 %72.41 %3.08 %49.1582.18%

10 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 989,702,570 %64.49 %2.83 %51.9872.44%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 878,196,599 %58.40 %2.51 %54.4963.11%12 796 QBE INS GRP 689,114,135 %35.27 %1.97 %56.4642.83%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 661,336,474 %64.70 %1.89 %58.3575.02%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 642,906,301 %67.11 %1.84 %60.1971.92%15 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 579,480,431 %56.75 %1.66 %61.8567.17%16 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 516,749,112 %21.56 %1.48 %63.3230.60%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 499,337,538 %127.32 %1.43 %64.75126.45%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners78

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 87: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 213 ERIE INS GRP 490,580,366 %51.37 %1.40 %66.1558.71%19 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 455,709,161 %52.31 %1.30 %67.4661.77%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 450,664,815 %48.88 %1.29 %68.7453.51%21 18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO 409,844,890 %77.04 %1.17 %69.9278.21%22 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 400,040,300 %84.17 %1.14 %71.0695.81%23 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 381,149,388 %48.55 %1.09 %72.1559.65%24 228 WESTFIELD GRP 295,781,923 %55.91 %0.85 %72.9963.25%25 3703 TOWER GRP 291,451,920 %36.33 %0.83 %73.8344.79%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 34,983,912,860 %55.67 %100.00 %100.0062.37%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,181,090,063 %28.76 %8.81 %8.8135.75%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,612,799,865 %28.77 %7.24 %16.0552.00%3 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,083,484,271 %46.04 %5.77 %21.8252.32%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,785,824,379 %36.70 %4.95 %26.7743.59%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,763,737,208 %37.28 %4.89 %31.6541.55%6 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,674,636,352 %51.70 %4.64 %36.2957.15%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,641,820,413 %48.06 %4.55 %40.8454.81%8 218 CNA INS GRP 1,167,891,417 %49.06 %3.23 %44.0757.90%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,125,531,405 %35.73 %3.12 %47.1939.45%

10 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 903,527,152 %38.70 %2.50 %49.6949.99%11 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 874,525,948 %43.80 %2.42 %52.1149.78%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 752,826,890 %44.88 %2.09 %54.2054.11%13 796 QBE INS GRP 709,633,372 %47.82 %1.97 %56.1758.74%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 702,557,112 %48.52 %1.95 %58.1158.40%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 657,725,428 %40.38 %1.82 %59.9348.13%16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 628,853,295 %46.58 %1.74 %61.6850.94%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 628,233,009 %47.04 %1.74 %63.4254.84%18 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 619,867,488 %42.46 %1.72 %65.1350.05%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 488,044,529 %47.27 %1.35 %66.4853.92%20 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 471,938,795 %45.38 %1.31 %67.7954.63%21 18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO 416,451,085 %54.41 %1.15 %68.9457.09%22 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 413,843,205 %85.57 %1.15 %70.09104.68%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 408,442,615 %44.21 %1.13 %71.2251.59%24 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 382,337,415 %52.09 %1.06 %72.2868.98%25 303 GUIDEONE INS GRP 303,321,910 %43.74 %0.84 %73.1252.36%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 36,102,870,135 %41.68 %100.00 %100.0050.21%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,224,354,537 %30.49 %8.84 %8.8439.23%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,544,134,854 %45.05 %6.98 %15.8256.09%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners79

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 88: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,138,069,775 %41.83 %5.86 %21.6850.41%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,818,201,716 %20.16 %4.99 %26.6725.86%5 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,653,622,571 %56.84 %4.53 %31.2062.90%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,641,875,477 %42.14 %4.50 %35.7147.16%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,500,383,737 %50.93 %4.11 %39.8260.34%8 218 CNA INS GRP 1,282,913,520 %54.70 %3.52 %43.3466.71%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,133,605,175 %67.44 %3.11 %46.4576.66%

10 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 943,608,848 %27.66 %2.59 %49.0333.94%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 892,975,867 %47.45 %2.45 %51.4857.06%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 737,646,814 %40.59 %2.02 %53.5149.38%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 725,727,450 %43.93 %1.99 %55.5049.92%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 654,652,559 %34.56 %1.80 %57.2943.85%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 644,364,333 %39.77 %1.77 %59.0642.89%16 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 614,345,467 %45.09 %1.68 %60.7452.92%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 612,805,178 %67.95 %1.68 %62.4280.10%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 491,261,798 %48.43 %1.35 %63.7756.18%19 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 465,084,798 %43.79 %1.28 %65.0555.38%20 18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO 410,943,212 %55.62 %1.13 %66.1756.40%21 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 407,708,024 %70.32 %1.12 %67.2979.07%22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 406,864,503 %46.72 %1.12 %68.4152.81%23 796 QBE INS GRP 375,166,881 %47.06 %1.03 %69.4454.71%24 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 367,547,115 %31.74 %1.01 %70.4453.06%25 148 OHIO CAS GRP 353,505,169 %45.70 %0.97 %71.4153.35%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 36,466,069,179 %42.25 %100.00 %100.0050.44%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,044,596,247 %74.48 %8.82 %8.8282.50%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,572,077,376 %73.86 %7.45 %16.2687.21%3 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,074,308,168 %71.23 %6.01 %22.2779.91%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,770,317,141 %62.35 %5.13 %27.4070.46%5 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,554,227,772 %75.86 %4.50 %31.9080.94%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,510,118,625 %56.58 %4.37 %36.2762.78%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,355,164,079 %67.55 %3.92 %40.2078.62%8 218 CNA INS GRP 1,258,562,613 %51.01 %3.64 %43.8466.01%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,006,250,651 %51.52 %2.91 %46.7562.93%

10 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 878,131,147 %44.81 %2.54 %49.3049.22%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 848,905,074 %47.08 %2.46 %51.7652.86%12 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 730,377,416 %36.03 %2.12 %53.8749.86%13 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 701,568,546 %43.72 %2.03 %55.9052.33%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 677,529,503 %30.89 %1.96 %57.8634.03%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 657,235,105 %115.17 %1.90 %59.77120.88%16 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 618,562,829 %43.23 %1.79 %61.5652.67%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 496,467,108 %34.70 %1.44 %63.0043.71%18 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 450,022,809 %48.55 %1.30 %64.3057.07%19 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 396,946,319 %43.12 %1.15 %65.4563.39%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners80

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 89: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 18767 CHURCH MUT INS CO 394,518,116 %92.85 %1.14 %66.5997.89%21 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 392,096,729 %46.88 %1.14 %67.7354.44%22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 376,538,493 %127.68 %1.09 %68.82133.40%23 148 OHIO CAS GRP 348,542,417 %51.88 %1.01 %69.8360.92%24 626 ACE LTD GRP 336,844,717 %12.47 %0.98 %70.8018.65%25 796 QBE INS GRP 329,596,377 %64.78 %0.95 %71.7675.34%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 34,532,655,197 %59.68 %100.00 %100.0069.03%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,666,295,078 %57.57 %7.38 %7.3864.94%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,612,408,903 %64.15 %7.14 %14.5276.44%3 218 CNA INS GRP 1,246,570,923 %72.49 %5.52 %20.0482.58%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,185,169,683 %49.62 %5.25 %25.2854.65%5 44 AVIVA GRP 931,139,324 %83.71 %4.12 %29.4193.52%6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 902,647,352 %59.97 %4.00 %33.4071.02%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 824,102,708 %69.12 %3.65 %37.0575.80%8 176 STATE FARM GRP 822,560,847 %71.21 %3.64 %40.6979.80%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 778,846,631 %59.41 %3.45 %44.1464.18%

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 664,414,099 %67.67 %2.94 %47.0876.66%11 163 SAFECO INS GRP 619,787,433 %66.65 %2.74 %49.8376.60%12 164 ST PAUL GRP 524,821,578 %53.80 %2.32 %52.1549.14%13 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 523,673,551 %64.82 %2.32 %54.4775.52%14 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 487,931,259 %62.45 %2.16 %56.6371.86%15 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 383,296,773 %64.69 %1.70 %58.3371.35%16 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 376,506,146 %82.07 %1.67 %60.0093.61%17 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 370,450,230 %54.24 %1.64 %61.6458.37%18 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 367,672,979 %72.62 %1.63 %63.2682.60%19 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 343,079,240 %82.93 %1.52 %64.78109.28%20 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 304,219,628 %82.10 %1.35 %66.1395.55%21 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 277,589,958 %47.62 %1.23 %67.3655.75%22 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 236,910,165 %59.82 %1.05 %68.4168.43%23 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 236,793,441 %53.51 %1.05 %69.4660.57%24 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 218,723,417 %92.93 %0.97 %70.43103.45%25 213 ERIE INS GRP 201,807,175 %59.25 %0.89 %71.3270.63%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 22,585,124,860 %64.65 %100.00 %100.0073.37%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 1,717,957,455 %64.41 %8.10 %8.10n/a2 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,065,395,888 %61.10 %5.03 %13.13n/a3 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 942,318,161 %51.30 %4.45 %17.58n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 888,351,529 %54.04 %4.19 %21.77n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners81

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 90: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 825,227,861 %78.37 %3.89 %25.66n/a6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 819,519,880 %41.84 %3.87 %29.53n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 674,360,451 %63.75 %3.18 %32.71n/a8 69 FARMERS INS GRP 651,015,996 %77.34 %3.07 %35.78n/a9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 576,341,603 %61.15 %2.72 %38.50n/a

10 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 524,196,249 %61.39 %2.47 %40.97n/a11 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 498,810,086 %60.10 %2.35 %43.32n/a12 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 465,523,299 %71.52 %2.20 %45.52n/a13 44 AVIVA GRP 445,720,258 %53.03 %2.10 %47.62n/a14 162 ROYAL GRP 419,736,585 %60.08 %1.98 %49.60n/a15 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 394,726,051 %66.36 %1.86 %51.46n/a16 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 369,911,318 %50.71 %1.75 %53.21n/a17 41 CITIGROUP GRP 356,719,295 %61.34 %1.68 %54.89n/a18 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 353,221,847 %53.09 %1.67 %56.56n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 338,673,045 %68.43 %1.60 %58.16n/a20 196 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY GRP 321,425,172 %59.04 %1.52 %59.67n/a21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 312,276,215 %62.82 %1.47 %61.15n/a22 164 ST PAUL GRP 296,036,078 %38.80 %1.40 %62.54n/a23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 275,962,904 %55.52 %1.30 %63.84n/a24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 258,169,670 %53.51 %1.22 %65.06n/a25 159 RELIANCE GRP 236,663,240 %53.05 %1.12 %66.18n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 21,197,334,949 %59.82 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 1,676,488,805 %54.22 %8.66 %8.66n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,192,080,596 %43.30 %6.16 %14.82n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,170,620,903 %71.84 %6.05 %20.87n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 1,096,781,762 %55.19 %5.67 %26.53n/a5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 807,165,178 %55.87 %4.17 %30.70n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 729,800,941 %50.87 %3.77 %34.47n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 616,082,951 %64.27 %3.18 %37.65n/a8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 615,975,823 %46.55 %3.18 %40.83n/a9 162 ROYAL GRP 552,498,239 %60.83 %2.85 %43.69n/a

10 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 516,511,612 %49.41 %2.67 %46.36n/a11 69 FARMERS INS GRP 489,747,954 %67.85 %2.53 %48.89n/a12 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 466,387,624 %77.78 %2.41 %51.30n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 433,641,925 %52.96 %2.24 %53.54n/a14 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 430,079,519 %59.53 %2.22 %55.76n/a15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 424,461,330 %64.50 %2.19 %57.95n/a16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 399,800,716 %38.45 %2.07 %60.02n/a17 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 303,400,822 %59.65 %1.57 %61.58n/a18 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 302,061,878 %61.22 %1.56 %63.14n/a19 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 298,409,524 %46.54 %1.54 %64.68n/a20 44 AVIVA GRP 273,716,665 %27.68 %1.41 %66.10n/a21 164 ST PAUL GRP 258,997,092 %49.55 %1.34 %67.44n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners82

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 91: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

05.1, 05.2 - Total Commercial Multiple Peril

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 253,151,339 %50.27 %1.31 %68.74n/a23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 244,375,675 %51.10 %1.26 %70.01n/a24 159 RELIANCE GRP 227,567,941 %61.94 %1.18 %71.18n/a25 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 218,186,406 %44.51 %1.13 %72.31n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 19,358,636,712 %54.99 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 1,196,049,595 %93.74 %8.55 %8.55n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,009,151,457 %72.93 %7.21 %15.76n/a3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 901,998,998 %62.86 %6.45 %22.21n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 898,230,941 %67.47 %6.42 %28.63n/a5 176 STATE FARM GRP 687,995,426 %76.42 %4.92 %33.55n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 596,352,235 %50.55 %4.26 %37.81n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 486,647,711 %93.85 %3.48 %41.29n/a8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 458,559,684 %74.21 %3.28 %44.57n/a9 162 ROYAL GRP 445,725,574 %74.98 %3.19 %47.76n/a

10 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 440,714,019 %68.35 %3.15 %50.91n/a11 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 354,228,157 %103.37 %2.53 %53.44n/a12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 350,694,797 %71.89 %2.51 %55.95n/a13 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 243,420,738 %87.66 %1.74 %57.69n/a14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 209,125,519 %68.93 %1.49 %59.18n/a15 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 194,852,593 %61.83 %1.39 %60.57n/a16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 189,866,079 %75.79 %1.36 %61.93n/a17 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 186,989,519 %62.74 %1.34 %63.27n/a18 44 AVIVA GRP 183,924,012 %88.84 %1.31 %64.58n/a19 159 RELIANCE GRP 181,044,032 %67.56 %1.29 %65.88n/a20 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 179,241,206 %88.60 %1.28 %67.16n/a21 1111 TIG INS GRP 173,379,897 %68.15 %1.24 %68.40n/a22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 161,658,745 %61.84 %1.16 %69.55n/a23 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 147,890,298 %55.06 %1.06 %70.61n/a24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 139,408,240 %69.88 %1.00 %71.61n/a25 164 ST PAUL GRP 134,275,908 %55.57 %0.96 %72.57n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 13,989,134,682 %73.17 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners83

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 92: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

06 - Mortgage Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 1,316,165,394 %189.02 %24.21 %24.21195.36%2 1135 PMI GRP 839,052,473 %235.68 %15.44 %39.65235.68%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 816,248,574 %251.14 %15.02 %54.67244.49%4 766 RADIAN GRP 798,977,291 %178.88 %14.70 %69.37178.88%5 4011 GENWORTH FIN GRP 714,561,567 %206.25 %13.15 %82.51206.25%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 634,084,852 %189.29 %11.67 %94.18199.02%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 217,011,872 %401.70 %3.99 %98.17401.70%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 99,073,304 %139.59 %1.82 %100.00139.59%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,435,412,551 %213.29 %100.00 %100.00214.99%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 1,649,872,085 %146.30 %25.67 %25.67149.19%2 1135 PMI GRP 929,826,282 %236.66 %14.46 %40.13236.66%3 766 RADIAN GRP 926,201,450 %264.78 %14.41 %54.54264.78%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 900,969,346 %276.04 %14.02 %68.55284.27%5 4011 GENWORTH FIN GRP 899,052,274 %186.72 %13.99 %82.54186.72%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 708,632,754 %192.20 %11.02 %93.56196.81%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 316,308,949 %305.37 %4.92 %98.48305.37%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 97,094,008 %78.39 %1.51 %100.0078.39%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,428,268,489 %212.80 %100.00 %100.00215.18%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 1,509,808,305 %72.65 %24.54 %24.5480.24%2 766 RADIAN GRP 1,031,289,069 %135.54 %16.76 %41.30135.54%3 1135 PMI GRP 972,707,211 %113.59 %15.81 %57.12113.59%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 792,031,993 %90.69 %12.87 %69.9993.43%5 4011 GENWORTH FIN GRP 787,773,798 %53.96 %12.81 %82.7953.96%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 637,957,000 %98.53 %10.37 %93.16100.59%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 339,006,491 %111.39 %5.51 %98.68111.39%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 81,170,975 %29.70 %1.32 %99.9929.70%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,152,079,537 %93.62 %100.00 %100.0096.07%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 1,354,674,137 %62.16 %25.02 %25.0264.86%2 766 RADIAN GRP 920,422,512 %43.23 %17.00 %42.0243.23%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 877,044,284 %39.42 %16.20 %58.2239.74%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners84

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 93: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

06 - Mortgage Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

4 1135 PMI GRP 815,230,233 %29.83 %15.06 %73.2829.93%5 4011 GENWORTH FIN GRP 587,291,160 %21.80 %10.85 %84.1321.80%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 534,922,510 %34.02 %9.88 %94.0135.63%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 256,704,771 %35.56 %4.74 %98.7535.56%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 67,135,471 %11.65 %1.24 %99.9911.65%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,413,846,936 %41.21 %100.00 %100.0042.11%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 1,381,091,903 %57.99 %26.61 %26.6159.70%2 766 RADIAN GRP 928,073,115 %41.86 %17.88 %44.4941.86%3 1135 PMI GRP 822,449,909 %29.53 %15.85 %60.3329.64%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 714,484,861 %16.53 %13.77 %74.1017.18%5 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 557,573,750 %18.45 %10.74 %84.8418.46%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 511,780,185 %29.21 %9.86 %94.7030.19%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 207,260,277 %31.40 %3.99 %98.6931.40%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 67,443,958 %10.86 %1.30 %99.9910.86%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,190,563,485 %36.00 %100.00 %100.0036.67%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 105 MGIC GRP 954,666,750 %49.45 %25.63 %25.6350.21%2 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 651,685,343 %2.83 %17.50 %43.132.83%3 766 RADIAN GRP 590,552,713 %26.59 %15.86 %58.9926.59%4 1135 PMI GRP 531,934,397 %16.52 %14.28 %73.2716.80%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 523,006,698 %11.74 %14.04 %87.3213.39%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 361,493,508 %12.73 %9.71 %97.0213.21%7 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 76,867,731 %9.48 %2.06 %99.099.48%8 306 CUNA MUT GRP 33,385,278 %4.39 %0.90 %99.984.39%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,724,262,800 %22.69 %100.00 %100.0023.21%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 642,006,298 %75.36 %30.88 %30.88n/a2 105 MGIC GRP 492,295,245 %71.61 %23.68 %54.56n/a3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 336,720,087 %57.14 %16.20 %70.76n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 235,324,894 %43.53 %11.32 %82.08n/a5 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 170,271,570 %33.78 %8.19 %90.27n/a6 766 RADIAN GRP 139,469,073 %40.72 %6.71 %96.98n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners85

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 94: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

06 - Mortgage Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

7 827 AMERIN GRP 34,337,883 %27.79 %1.65 %98.63n/a8 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 18,889,934 %12.84 %0.91 %99.54n/a9 35831 POLICYHOLDERS BENEFIT CORP 5,166,415 %78.48 %0.25 %99.79n/a

10 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,866,126 %-2.98 %0.09 %99.88n/a11 306 CUNA MUT GRP 1,770,222 %-0.69 %0.09 %99.96n/a12 16497 AZTEC INS CO 537,668 %0.00 %0.03 %99.99n/a13 239 LEUCADIA GRP 279,876 %-90.29 %0.01 %100.00n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,078,940,768 %60.78 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners86

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 95: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 739,792,335 %29.30 %19.78 %19.7832.75%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 304,547,544 %39.23 %8.14 %27.9243.75%3 218 CNA INS GRP 252,735,538 %49.30 %6.76 %34.6854.87%4 626 ACE LTD GRP 215,377,302 %49.21 %5.76 %40.4454.30%5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 214,041,666 %62.37 %5.72 %46.1674.61%6 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 200,192,379 %75.07 %5.35 %51.5274.64%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 180,523,430 %46.83 %4.83 %56.3447.12%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 141,775,294 %76.21 %3.79 %60.1381.21%9 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 140,879,607 %35.94 %3.77 %63.9038.02%

10 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 109,907,089 %113.63 %2.94 %66.84124.59%11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 104,826,501 %35.45 %2.80 %69.6437.77%12 1285 XL AMER GRP 99,353,091 %12.80 %2.66 %72.3012.61%13 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 92,252,112 %38.88 %2.47 %74.7745.60%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 80,154,051 %9.88 %2.14 %76.9116.42%15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 71,245,562 %69.12 %1.91 %78.8173.93%16 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 70,862,203 %48.79 %1.89 %80.7155.69%17 4670 STARR GRP 68,793,793 %57.90 %1.84 %82.5564.30%18 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 67,850,767 %10.68 %1.81 %84.3614.32%19 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 56,395,939 %46.99 %1.51 %85.8751.46%20 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 51,729,600 %12.59 %1.38 %87.2512.48%21 783 RLI INS GRP 39,237,819 %101.30 %1.05 %88.30104.12%22 1279 ARCH INS GRP 30,362,304 %20.75 %0.81 %89.1223.31%23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 29,015,496 %35.58 %0.78 %89.8935.00%24 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 26,124,082 %54.64 %0.70 %90.5954.90%25 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 24,004,605 %77.21 %0.64 %91.2371.12%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,739,903,099 %46.47 %100.00 %100.0050.53%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 667,739,890 %56.81 %16.91 %16.9162.13%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 317,651,517 %35.61 %8.04 %24.9538.36%3 626 ACE LTD GRP 279,354,634 %73.10 %7.07 %32.0283.60%4 218 CNA INS GRP 258,304,235 %47.10 %6.54 %38.5651.74%5 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 221,236,209 %64.05 %5.60 %44.1667.55%6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 206,539,252 %57.58 %5.23 %49.3963.16%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 199,253,559 %64.74 %5.04 %54.4370.38%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 192,242,835 %86.90 %4.87 %59.3091.29%9 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 164,369,746 %65.97 %4.16 %63.4667.26%

10 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 145,466,336 %90.14 %3.68 %67.14100.31%11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 135,166,022 %48.94 %3.42 %70.5752.72%12 1285 XL AMER GRP 103,114,788 %67.55 %2.61 %73.1868.27%13 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 92,494,157 %59.89 %2.34 %75.5267.33%14 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 89,218,783 %124.94 %2.26 %77.78130.24%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 80,616,293 %46.52 %2.04 %79.8247.18%16 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 75,720,446 %38.66 %1.92 %81.7445.35%17 93 STATE NATL GRP 68,931,651 %77.22 %1.75 %83.4877.55%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners87

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 96: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 67,679,614 %154.13 %1.71 %85.19158.11%19 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 58,661,616 %58.86 %1.49 %86.6859.70%20 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 53,126,331 %57.59 %1.34 %88.0259.07%21 783 RLI INS GRP 48,689,687 %61.96 %1.23 %89.2665.16%22 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 36,238,737 %28.34 %0.92 %90.1729.43%23 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 30,803,305 %361.89 %0.78 %90.95365.00%24 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 27,332,114 %127.66 %0.69 %91.65130.11%25 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 25,194,426 %70.27 %0.64 %92.2877.59%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,949,926,507 %65.73 %100.00 %100.0070.33%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 594,568,854 %55.84 %15.16 %15.1660.57%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 324,487,599 %42.10 %8.27 %23.4347.93%3 626 ACE LTD GRP 295,548,850 %51.04 %7.53 %30.9649.60%4 218 CNA INS GRP 280,386,895 %32.15 %7.15 %38.1140.03%5 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 205,374,394 %62.30 %5.24 %43.3565.84%6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 204,227,229 %45.65 %5.21 %48.5651.90%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 203,945,649 %21.93 %5.20 %53.7523.21%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 178,409,964 %74.13 %4.55 %58.3079.57%9 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 166,650,060 %36.43 %4.25 %62.5537.48%

10 1285 XL AMER GRP 149,504,719 %91.32 %3.81 %66.3699.15%11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 144,082,074 %46.42 %3.67 %70.0449.56%12 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 132,649,595 %65.02 %3.38 %73.4271.49%13 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 113,885,180 %-2.09 %2.90 %76.323.76%14 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 93,568,836 %54.07 %2.39 %78.7157.36%15 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 83,523,629 %19.79 %2.13 %80.8421.02%16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 80,035,328 %23.78 %2.04 %82.8833.22%17 93 STATE NATL GRP 66,150,262 %23.33 %1.69 %84.5621.86%18 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 61,261,746 %120.50 %1.56 %86.12122.05%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 57,452,542 %40.38 %1.46 %87.5941.07%20 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 53,229,593 %44.77 %1.36 %88.9545.73%21 783 RLI INS GRP 38,786,821 %52.44 %0.99 %89.9456.34%22 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 35,697,974 %32.18 %0.91 %90.8533.39%23 1279 ARCH INS GRP 27,406,741 %11.31 %0.70 %91.5425.29%24 176 STATE FARM GRP 22,350,832 %32.06 %0.57 %92.1133.29%25 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 22,334,476 %54.43 %0.57 %92.6870.01%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,922,517,060 %46.54 %100.00 %100.0050.69%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 546,147,073 %78.63 %14.64 %14.6480.58%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 323,877,642 %29.42 %8.68 %23.3332.94%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners88

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 97: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 626 ACE LTD GRP 295,472,018 %56.56 %7.92 %31.2566.87%4 218 CNA INS GRP 281,855,074 %100.60 %7.56 %38.81105.75%5 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 207,443,433 %80.08 %5.56 %44.3778.52%6 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 206,576,872 %52.42 %5.54 %49.9152.90%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 202,315,680 %46.46 %5.42 %55.3351.46%8 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 175,967,376 %67.14 %4.72 %60.0574.71%9 1285 XL AMER GRP 173,996,652 %96.56 %4.67 %64.7284.95%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 149,435,857 %47.73 %4.01 %68.7248.71%11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 147,362,082 %46.40 %3.95 %72.6749.07%12 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 117,126,796 %183.89 %3.14 %75.81188.22%13 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 97,438,504 %53.64 %2.61 %78.4359.50%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 81,422,376 %58.08 %2.18 %80.6165.83%15 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 70,665,523 %30.56 %1.89 %82.5039.87%16 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 56,898,154 %54.90 %1.53 %84.0355.14%17 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 47,034,730 %96.94 %1.26 %85.29102.43%18 93 STATE NATL GRP 44,920,480 %39.67 %1.20 %86.5043.26%19 1279 ARCH INS GRP 42,353,958 %90.87 %1.14 %87.6396.45%20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 36,222,785 %3.71 %0.97 %88.605.89%21 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 34,133,709 %62.89 %0.92 %89.5265.65%22 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 30,504,428 %60.02 %0.82 %90.3465.78%23 37923 SEAWORTHY INS CO 30,207,412 %60.32 %0.81 %91.1560.32%24 783 RLI INS GRP 27,172,290 %62.34 %0.73 %91.8765.52%25 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 22,347,596 %88.88 %0.60 %92.47106.78%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,729,623,953 %65.90 %100.00 %100.0069.23%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 461,998,168 %93.77 %13.64 %13.64100.15%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 315,043,059 %84.98 %9.30 %22.9491.66%3 626 ACE LTD GRP 284,074,297 %78.49 %8.39 %31.3382.96%4 218 CNA INS GRP 274,749,656 %67.13 %8.11 %39.4574.14%5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 197,819,217 %56.92 %5.84 %45.2964.88%6 1285 XL AMER GRP 190,888,415 %160.69 %5.64 %50.92189.33%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 188,214,302 %59.56 %5.56 %56.4865.87%8 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 181,395,050 %150.50 %5.36 %61.84161.12%9 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 147,341,337 %86.10 %4.35 %66.1996.31%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 144,959,530 %58.56 %4.28 %70.4760.24%11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 125,713,555 %98.24 %3.71 %74.18102.67%12 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 98,406,267 %90.27 %2.91 %77.0993.14%13 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 83,082,516 %339.15 %2.45 %79.54344.72%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 73,003,556 %59.37 %2.16 %81.6966.98%15 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 61,851,714 %78.05 %1.83 %83.5276.75%16 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 43,287,599 %57.22 %1.28 %84.8061.28%17 1279 ARCH INS GRP 38,650,105 %179.40 %1.14 %85.94184.58%18 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 33,496,955 %25.79 %0.99 %86.9327.83%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 31,551,928 %87.12 %0.93 %87.8690.30%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners89

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 98: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 29,390,009 %46.05 %0.87 %88.7349.04%21 37923 SEAWORTHY INS CO 25,979,870 %52.43 %0.77 %89.5052.62%22 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 24,262,624 %43.28 %0.72 %90.2145.96%23 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 21,991,520 %91.90 %0.65 %90.8693.83%24 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 21,884,263 %54.83 %0.65 %91.5154.35%25 176 STATE FARM GRP 21,808,619 %40.54 %0.64 %92.1540.77%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,386,632,248 %89.44 %100.00 %100.0096.56%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 261,326,795 %66.94 %12.63 %12.6370.51%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 250,839,522 %85.93 %12.13 %24.7688.24%3 1285 XL AMER GRP 158,346,054 %81.66 %7.66 %32.4194.98%4 626 ACE LTD GRP 109,107,996 %40.89 %5.27 %37.6943.73%5 164 ST PAUL GRP 104,852,956 %53.34 %5.07 %42.7656.08%6 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 99,837,269 %62.03 %4.83 %47.5966.04%7 44 AVIVA GRP 98,394,077 %72.92 %4.76 %52.3473.56%8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 84,363,467 %49.05 %4.08 %56.4252.51%9 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 82,201,737 %64.17 %3.97 %60.3976.15%

10 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 70,523,343 %52.25 %3.41 %63.8053.63%11 41 CITIGROUP GRP 67,467,730 %66.12 %3.26 %67.0771.86%12 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 53,567,079 %78.26 %2.59 %69.6580.27%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 51,187,890 %41.23 %2.47 %72.1345.53%14 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 42,778,437 %74.36 %2.07 %74.2074.32%15 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 40,379,318 %68.55 %1.95 %76.1571.19%16 181 SWISS RE GRP 36,543,667 %138.10 %1.77 %77.92160.66%17 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 30,814,081 %94.78 %1.49 %79.41105.31%18 212 ZURICH INS GRP 29,315,333 %74.69 %1.42 %80.8287.33%19 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 26,759,985 %29.19 %1.29 %82.1230.62%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 26,184,847 %51.27 %1.27 %83.3855.57%21 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 23,957,399 %59.32 %1.16 %84.5462.70%22 950 TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED 22,324,148 %68.77 %1.08 %85.6266.99%23 968 AXA INS GRP 20,826,854 %69.38 %1.01 %86.6373.12%24 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 20,544,288 %38.51 %0.99 %87.6238.97%25 176 STATE FARM GRP 18,596,236 %45.59 %0.90 %88.5247.75%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,068,529,371 %67.11 %100.00 %100.0071.94%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 281,848,786 %62.92 %12.91 %12.91n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 243,053,960 %48.49 %11.14 %24.05n/a3 164 ST PAUL GRP 145,016,846 %44.08 %6.64 %30.70n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 133,098,976 %55.24 %6.10 %36.80n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners90

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 99: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 44 AVIVA GRP 91,282,557 %54.52 %4.18 %40.98n/a6 159 RELIANCE GRP 86,694,839 %42.90 %3.97 %44.95n/a7 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 83,194,651 %25.50 %3.81 %48.76n/a8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 82,291,015 %21.75 %3.77 %52.53n/a9 162 ROYAL GRP 76,487,830 %54.59 %3.50 %56.04n/a

10 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 73,100,068 %45.37 %3.35 %59.39n/a11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 61,166,702 %58.50 %2.80 %62.19n/a12 390 GRE INS GRP 57,014,694 %34.57 %2.61 %64.80n/a13 212 ZURICH INS GRP 53,998,651 %46.91 %2.47 %67.28n/a14 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 46,355,254 %46.21 %2.12 %69.40n/a15 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 46,209,137 %52.71 %2.12 %71.52n/a16 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 40,267,772 %56.69 %1.85 %73.37n/a17 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 36,023,200 %90.07 %1.65 %75.02n/a18 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 34,618,538 %10.93 %1.59 %76.60n/a19 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 29,670,060 %74.67 %1.36 %77.96n/a20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 26,948,775 %43.61 %1.23 %79.20n/a21 1 AETNA GRP 22,753,620 %64.78 %1.04 %80.24n/a22 258 INTERCARGO CORP GRP 22,642,331 %61.81 %1.04 %81.28n/a23 1134 CHARTWELL GRP 19,045,881 %64.84 %0.87 %82.15n/a24 950 TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED 18,981,178 %54.01 %0.87 %83.02n/a25 1116 HIGHLANDS INS GRP INC 18,894,306 %59.97 %0.87 %83.88n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,182,347,838 %52.39 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 153,506,093 %81.60 %10.62 %10.62n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 138,894,886 %74.18 %9.61 %20.24n/a3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 102,452,876 %113.46 %7.09 %27.33n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 100,054,140 %69.51 %6.92 %34.25n/a5 164 ST PAUL GRP 90,689,617 %103.19 %6.28 %40.53n/a6 390 GRE INS GRP 74,136,570 %91.64 %5.13 %45.66n/a7 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 63,853,640 %74.30 %4.42 %50.07n/a8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 56,555,081 %42.37 %3.91 %53.99n/a9 41 CITIGROUP GRP 53,840,406 %55.21 %3.73 %57.71n/a

10 162 ROYAL GRP 43,351,103 %75.25 %3.00 %60.71n/a11 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 38,658,011 %98.05 %2.68 %63.39n/a12 44 AVIVA GRP 29,398,021 %83.48 %2.03 %65.42n/a13 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 27,241,813 %97.22 %1.89 %67.31n/a14 655 CHRISITANIA GRP 26,651,331 %145.03 %1.84 %69.15n/a15 212 ZURICH INS GRP 26,418,090 %41.37 %1.83 %70.98n/a16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 25,448,498 %67.21 %1.76 %72.74n/a17 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 20,029,328 %74.72 %1.39 %74.13n/a18 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 19,617,065 %123.64 %1.36 %75.49n/a19 1116 HIGHLANDS INS GRP INC 18,511,738 %87.52 %1.28 %76.77n/a20 1134 CHARTWELL GRP 18,424,153 %147.11 %1.28 %78.04n/a21 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 16,699,716 %111.31 %1.16 %79.20n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners91

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 100: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

08 - Ocean Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 159 RELIANCE GRP 16,300,406 %44.16 %1.13 %80.33n/a23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 15,437,192 %28.74 %1.07 %81.40n/a24 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 15,174,718 %54.36 %1.05 %82.45n/a25 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 13,860,490 %230.94 %0.96 %83.40n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,445,008,211 %78.71 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 150,098,850 %60.50 %11.22 %11.22n/a2 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 121,432,127 %65.68 %9.07 %20.29n/a3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 101,797,316 %72.18 %7.61 %27.90n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 70,784,580 %113.52 %5.29 %33.19n/a5 164 ST PAUL GRP 67,910,925 %73.01 %5.07 %38.26n/a6 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 66,865,821 %-0.23 %5.00 %43.26n/a7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 51,117,359 %52.79 %3.82 %47.08n/a8 390 GRE INS GRP 48,408,210 %107.14 %3.62 %50.70n/a9 41 CITIGROUP GRP 48,404,138 %71.83 %3.62 %54.32n/a

10 162 ROYAL GRP 42,137,198 %77.07 %3.15 %57.46n/a11 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 39,982,734 %68.35 %2.99 %60.45n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 33,953,854 %110.44 %2.54 %62.99n/a13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 31,098,888 %104.89 %2.32 %65.31n/a14 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 28,719,577 %56.85 %2.15 %67.46n/a15 1116 HIGHLANDS INS GRP INC 27,795,475 %108.73 %2.08 %69.54n/a16 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 26,996,640 %65.89 %2.02 %71.55n/a17 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 24,251,427 %55.38 %1.81 %73.37n/a18 239 LEUCADIA GRP 22,041,343 %61.14 %1.65 %75.01n/a19 159 RELIANCE GRP 21,299,246 %88.73 %1.59 %76.61n/a20 44 AVIVA GRP 21,006,377 %70.63 %1.57 %78.18n/a21 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 20,029,010 %63.96 %1.50 %79.67n/a22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 18,383,816 %64.90 %1.37 %81.05n/a23 13366 AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT 17,272,189 %71.08 %1.29 %82.34n/a24 41912 PACIFIC MARINE INS CO 11,734,247 %75.54 %0.88 %83.21n/a25 201 UTICA GRP 11,175,231 %62.40 %0.84 %84.05n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,338,147,894 %70.55 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners92

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 101: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,879,152,584 %60.17 %14.01 %14.0160.16%2 218 CNA INS GRP 1,213,328,063 %69.80 %9.05 %23.0669.97%3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 857,815,022 %43.23 %6.40 %29.4644.43%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 759,905,425 %43.23 %5.67 %35.1344.03%5 176 STATE FARM GRP 633,286,914 %42.79 %4.72 %39.8543.65%6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 608,243,974 %32.26 %4.54 %44.3931.21%7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 583,315,143 %35.41 %4.35 %48.7435.67%8 212 ZURICH INS GRP 573,102,904 %37.18 %4.27 %53.0138.49%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 567,744,967 %55.03 %4.23 %57.2557.52%

10 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 370,351,044 %35.22 %2.76 %60.0135.41%11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 368,822,098 %56.38 %2.75 %62.7656.76%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 285,431,918 %13.57 %2.13 %64.8913.53%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 242,421,826 %51.87 %1.81 %66.6951.69%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 231,694,760 %32.14 %1.73 %68.4233.47%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 224,215,864 %34.29 %1.67 %70.0934.89%16 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 209,648,274 %46.97 %1.56 %71.6647.29%17 796 QBE INS GRP 182,263,882 %28.86 %1.36 %73.0229.95%18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 180,882,573 %29.59 %1.35 %74.3730.16%19 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 151,380,278 %38.39 %1.13 %75.5038.83%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 146,791,703 %57.04 %1.09 %76.5957.69%21 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 138,153,811 %46.70 %1.03 %77.6248.22%22 361 MUNICH RE GRP 121,147,424 %41.00 %0.90 %78.5241.29%23 27928 AMEX ASSUR CO 117,832,874 %43.84 %0.88 %79.4044.08%24 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 97,573,239 %40.16 %0.73 %80.1340.69%25 14354 JEWELERS MUT INS CO 94,936,369 %49.04 %0.71 %80.8449.79%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 13,408,738,126 %45.31 %100.00 %100.0045.92%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,745,727,066 %61.56 %11.96 %11.9661.85%2 218 CNA INS GRP 1,199,096,926 %60.87 %8.22 %20.1860.92%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,187,525,571 %57.41 %8.14 %28.3158.31%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 909,377,674 %42.05 %6.23 %34.5443.34%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 710,357,791 %77.47 %4.87 %39.4180.79%6 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 706,722,228 %74.43 %4.84 %44.2574.59%7 176 STATE FARM GRP 645,752,337 %42.91 %4.42 %48.6843.85%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 638,228,816 %39.59 %4.37 %53.0541.57%9 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 574,358,826 %39.88 %3.94 %56.9940.79%

10 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 500,390,145 %40.31 %3.43 %60.4240.48%11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 354,554,795 %54.36 %2.43 %62.8554.69%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 319,542,082 %48.22 %2.19 %65.0353.91%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 309,821,172 %41.90 %2.12 %67.1643.29%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 273,799,459 %28.70 %1.88 %69.0335.59%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 253,905,004 %35.31 %1.74 %70.7735.19%16 796 QBE INS GRP 208,142,029 %27.92 %1.43 %72.2029.27%17 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 199,804,712 %59.83 %1.37 %73.5760.20%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners93

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 102: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 178,068,189 %38.59 %1.22 %74.7939.04%19 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 151,350,739 %48.18 %1.04 %75.8350.34%20 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 143,177,413 %41.54 %0.98 %76.8141.75%21 27928 AMEX ASSUR CO 134,931,784 %42.33 %0.92 %77.7342.52%22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 122,070,092 %46.64 %0.84 %78.5748.12%23 1285 XL AMER GRP 120,901,316 %33.03 %0.83 %79.4037.67%24 361 MUNICH RE GRP 120,185,042 %32.19 %0.82 %80.2233.87%25 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 104,030,860 %43.16 %0.71 %80.9343.57%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 14,594,738,305 %51.28 %100.00 %100.0052.43%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,665,148,694 %22.46 %10.86 %10.8622.50%2 218 CNA INS GRP 1,361,145,031 %38.86 %8.88 %19.7539.15%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,121,006,639 %52.60 %7.31 %27.0653.25%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 944,427,751 %27.95 %6.16 %33.2228.74%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 880,164,057 %38.64 %5.74 %38.9641.09%6 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 787,122,936 %37.36 %5.14 %44.1040.36%7 176 STATE FARM GRP 636,078,274 %40.24 %4.15 %48.2541.11%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 617,242,143 %30.75 %4.03 %52.2832.34%9 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 564,865,722 %31.63 %3.69 %55.9631.98%

10 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 558,383,556 %43.17 %3.64 %59.6143.23%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 360,061,595 %25.82 %2.35 %61.9525.51%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 322,871,277 %35.76 %2.11 %64.0636.48%13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 297,805,485 %32.78 %1.94 %66.0033.95%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 288,989,801 %-39.03 %1.89 %67.89-34.18%15 796 QBE INS GRP 287,626,312 %40.06 %1.88 %69.7740.43%16 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 227,475,678 %49.21 %1.48 %71.2549.67%17 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 187,810,122 %42.96 %1.23 %72.4843.25%18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 178,943,495 %31.66 %1.17 %73.6432.14%19 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 172,806,381 %72.88 %1.13 %74.7772.89%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 146,838,248 %31.73 %0.96 %75.7333.01%21 27928 AMEX ASSUR CO 145,897,364 %34.86 %0.95 %76.6835.01%22 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 132,606,288 %40.01 %0.87 %77.5540.08%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 129,202,661 %44.19 %0.84 %78.3945.17%24 1285 XL AMER GRP 128,150,235 %5.47 %0.84 %79.235.24%25 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 112,419,912 %58.35 %0.73 %79.9658.78%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 15,326,714,093 %35.37 %100.00 %100.0036.21%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,375,605,331 %57.23 %9.69 %9.6955.30%2 218 CNA INS GRP 1,074,652,121 %53.58 %7.57 %17.2653.70%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners94

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 103: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 939,240,965 %60.35 %6.62 %23.8762.81%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 890,503,274 %30.91 %6.27 %30.1431.37%5 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 761,168,569 %15.44 %5.36 %35.5016.37%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 635,466,605 %61.37 %4.48 %39.9862.28%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 609,696,760 %31.12 %4.29 %44.2731.71%8 176 STATE FARM GRP 606,727,610 %39.40 %4.27 %48.5540.18%9 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 596,679,693 %49.15 %4.20 %52.7549.16%

10 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 544,669,328 %14.75 %3.84 %56.5916.54%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 386,932,987 %45.91 %2.73 %59.3146.94%12 517 HANNOVER GRP 340,629,651 %54.39 %2.40 %61.7156.12%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 321,916,652 %36.56 %2.27 %63.9837.42%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 300,080,812 %32.19 %2.11 %66.0933.18%15 626 ACE LTD GRP 298,095,871 %154.70 %2.10 %68.19160.34%16 1285 XL AMER GRP 192,539,958 %-34.82 %1.36 %69.55-36.71%17 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 178,970,816 %31.45 %1.26 %70.8131.97%18 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 174,736,410 %72.29 %1.23 %72.0472.30%19 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 167,873,102 %41.21 %1.18 %73.2241.59%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 167,505,276 %27.36 %1.18 %74.4028.41%21 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 147,285,952 %61.38 %1.04 %75.4461.65%22 4 AMERIPRISE FIN GRP 135,404,859 %31.94 %0.95 %76.3932.11%23 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 125,302,595 %35.41 %0.88 %77.2736.36%24 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 118,763,454 %38.39 %0.84 %78.1138.98%25 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 110,031,575 %39.75 %0.77 %78.8840.50%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 14,198,609,885 %44.34 %100.00 %100.0044.96%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,113,271,630 %175.23 %8.79 %8.79179.90%2 218 CNA INS GRP 934,695,765 %47.35 %7.38 %16.1747.42%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 821,586,439 %48.14 %6.49 %22.6547.71%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 798,614,465 %67.38 %6.30 %28.9670.24%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 677,354,416 %79.86 %5.35 %34.3079.55%6 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 640,652,086 %93.78 %5.06 %39.3694.54%7 176 STATE FARM GRP 570,071,842 %55.21 %4.50 %43.8656.29%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 554,468,994 %49.31 %4.38 %48.2452.69%9 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 512,225,259 %58.20 %4.04 %52.2862.34%

10 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 504,096,298 %51.51 %3.98 %56.2651.56%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 334,802,977 %66.16 %2.64 %58.9067.43%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 302,923,725 %35.70 %2.39 %61.2936.27%13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 291,535,880 %49.10 %2.30 %63.5949.99%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 271,470,187 %19.22 %2.14 %65.7428.18%15 517 HANNOVER GRP 218,673,378 %36.29 %1.73 %67.4638.65%16 1120 EVEREST REINS HOLDINGS GRP 184,534,775 %87.13 %1.46 %68.9287.13%17 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 176,461,709 %30.85 %1.39 %70.3131.77%18 1285 XL AMER GRP 165,638,704 %360.56 %1.31 %71.62375.96%19 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 159,053,486 %36.96 %1.26 %72.8837.24%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners95

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 104: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 148,905,414 %90.80 %1.18 %74.0591.47%21 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 110,685,154 %39.16 %0.87 %74.9339.56%22 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 110,525,668 %63.95 %0.87 %75.8064.08%23 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 108,410,540 %39.77 %0.86 %76.6540.34%24 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 106,299,291 %93.36 %0.84 %77.4994.38%25 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 102,952,962 %36.96 %0.81 %78.3137.61%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,668,136,092 %68.38 %100.00 %100.0070.22%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 898,789,548 %47.16 %10.83 %10.8348.94%2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 490,581,069 %34.44 %5.91 %16.7535.61%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 482,699,312 %48.97 %5.82 %22.5650.79%4 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 434,132,108 %14.26 %5.23 %27.8014.42%5 176 STATE FARM GRP 428,839,236 %47.74 %5.17 %32.9648.59%6 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 341,150,486 %60.73 %4.11 %37.0864.63%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 330,016,365 %48.55 %3.98 %41.0552.22%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 263,297,740 %41.21 %3.17 %44.2340.91%9 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 249,475,041 %30.79 %3.01 %47.2329.74%

10 164 ST PAUL GRP 231,776,902 %48.81 %2.79 %50.0349.69%11 218 CNA INS GRP 225,175,592 %53.72 %2.71 %52.7454.18%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 219,231,776 %47.92 %2.64 %55.3863.03%13 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 202,360,778 %38.09 %2.44 %57.8238.89%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 184,660,036 %53.96 %2.23 %60.0555.20%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 182,909,063 %44.78 %2.20 %62.2545.53%16 44 AVIVA GRP 170,206,704 %75.51 %2.05 %64.3075.46%17 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 143,786,224 %44.55 %1.73 %66.0446.06%18 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 142,058,050 %62.64 %1.71 %67.7566.57%19 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 136,486,175 %115.60 %1.65 %69.39129.86%20 783 RLI INS GRP 100,893,545 %13.17 %1.22 %70.6113.85%21 163 SAFECO INS GRP 100,813,550 %45.16 %1.22 %71.8345.96%22 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 94,017,105 %24.90 %1.13 %72.9628.86%23 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 92,875,466 %33.29 %1.12 %74.0833.85%24 517 HANNOVER GRP 70,522,537 %43.61 %0.85 %74.9343.80%25 169 SENTRY INS GRP 65,159,968 %83.77 %0.79 %75.7185.90%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 8,296,937,042 %45.90 %100.00 %100.0047.79%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 831,724,663 %43.17 %11.51 %11.51n/a2 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 761,921,038 %17.90 %10.55 %22.06n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 364,807,630 %48.58 %5.05 %27.11n/a4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 278,005,439 %60.04 %3.85 %30.96n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners96

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 105: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 267,659,979 %30.00 %3.71 %34.66n/a6 218 CNA INS GRP 252,045,662 %54.69 %3.49 %38.15n/a7 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 222,742,383 %55.07 %3.08 %41.24n/a8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 207,360,546 %39.75 %2.87 %44.11n/a9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 197,705,297 %55.06 %2.74 %46.84n/a

10 41 CITIGROUP GRP 174,517,854 %30.42 %2.42 %49.26n/a11 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 138,967,504 %53.11 %1.92 %51.18n/a12 1 AETNA GRP 125,752,401 %42.20 %1.74 %52.92n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 125,525,700 %55.04 %1.74 %54.66n/a14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 124,439,203 %50.74 %1.72 %56.38n/a15 164 ST PAUL GRP 124,225,261 %51.88 %1.72 %58.10n/a16 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 115,593,023 %48.19 %1.60 %59.70n/a17 159 RELIANCE GRP 112,038,324 %89.71 %1.55 %61.25n/a18 783 RLI INS GRP 95,941,530 %42.70 %1.33 %62.58n/a19 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 85,806,624 %43.37 %1.19 %63.77n/a20 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 75,721,943 %12.95 %1.05 %64.82n/a21 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 75,452,356 %49.16 %1.04 %65.86n/a22 162 ROYAL GRP 74,339,036 %40.61 %1.03 %66.89n/a23 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 73,570,985 %36.19 %1.02 %67.91n/a24 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 72,740,811 %46.69 %1.01 %68.92n/a25 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 70,247,688 %9.20 %0.97 %69.89n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 7,224,048,537 %43.81 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 830,292,995 %84.06 %14.22 %14.22n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 380,606,275 %75.89 %6.52 %20.74n/a3 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 339,984,542 %25.32 %5.82 %26.56n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 295,881,540 %39.78 %5.07 %31.63n/a5 176 STATE FARM GRP 265,656,015 %54.41 %4.55 %36.18n/a6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 260,787,576 %46.69 %4.47 %40.65n/a7 218 CNA INS GRP 234,721,960 %37.96 %4.02 %44.67n/a8 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 202,987,548 %81.10 %3.48 %48.14n/a9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 194,817,461 %47.44 %3.34 %51.48n/a

10 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 161,830,889 %71.84 %2.77 %54.25n/a11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 119,217,455 %53.23 %2.04 %56.29n/a12 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 118,098,388 %50.50 %2.02 %58.32n/a13 164 ST PAUL GRP 98,517,020 %33.59 %1.69 %60.00n/a14 159 RELIANCE GRP 97,196,221 %110.56 %1.66 %61.67n/a15 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 83,103,472 %50.50 %1.42 %63.09n/a16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 72,362,055 %40.72 %1.24 %64.33n/a17 162 ROYAL GRP 71,153,164 %49.53 %1.22 %65.55n/a18 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 69,335,118 %116.13 %1.19 %66.74n/a19 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 62,596,340 %52.86 %1.07 %67.81n/a20 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 57,387,424 %56.08 %0.98 %68.79n/a21 1111 TIG INS GRP 56,128,025 %84.29 %0.96 %69.75n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners97

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 106: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

09 - Inland Marine

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 219 DEERE & CO GRP 53,429,638 %71.62 %0.92 %70.67n/a23 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 52,496,589 %60.31 %0.90 %71.57n/a24 69 FARMERS INS GRP 50,519,788 %37.05 %0.87 %72.43n/a25 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 50,249,996 %61.68 %0.86 %73.29n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,838,693,778 %56.68 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 409,155,763 %77.14 %8.84 %8.84n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 262,380,312 %58.23 %5.67 %14.51n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 229,405,527 %52.25 %4.96 %19.46n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 227,883,536 %51.54 %4.92 %24.39n/a5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 219,770,921 %71.75 %4.75 %29.14n/a6 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 201,648,065 %66.21 %4.36 %33.49n/a7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 199,452,610 %47.47 %4.31 %37.80n/a8 176 STATE FARM GRP 157,663,215 %52.81 %3.41 %41.21n/a9 164 ST PAUL GRP 150,631,915 %43.39 %3.25 %44.46n/a

10 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 149,318,439 %53.34 %3.23 %47.69n/a11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 146,455,465 %66.72 %3.16 %50.85n/a12 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 102,743,879 %51.11 %2.22 %53.07n/a13 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 93,166,253 %59.90 %2.01 %55.08n/a14 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 88,192,348 %78.32 %1.91 %56.99n/a15 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 82,898,976 %42.69 %1.79 %58.78n/a16 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 76,264,712 %55.16 %1.65 %60.43n/a17 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 68,454,448 %92.81 %1.48 %61.91n/a18 162 ROYAL GRP 67,826,997 %58.11 %1.47 %63.37n/a19 159 RELIANCE GRP 63,754,364 %40.18 %1.38 %64.75n/a20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 62,201,075 %63.54 %1.34 %66.09n/a21 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 60,861,942 %114.62 %1.31 %67.41n/a22 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 58,642,726 %60.92 %1.27 %68.67n/a23 201 UTICA GRP 49,911,155 %35.77 %1.08 %69.75n/a24 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 47,993,121 %44.57 %1.04 %70.79n/a25 217 CENTRAL NATL INS CO PR GRP 46,879,215 %27.55 %1.01 %71.80n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,628,778,863 %57.89 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners98

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 107: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

10 - Financial Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 194 ASSURED GUAR GRP 901,581,655 %86.16 %46.90 %46.9087.56%2 528 MBIA GRP 407,682,475 %253.56 %21.21 %68.10289.55%3 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 325,118,609 %194.60 %16.91 %85.01210.13%4 4676 SYNCORA HOLDINGS GRP 87,333,729 %-1,064.87 %4.54 %89.56-1,051.61%5 1135 PMI GRP 86,253,000 %1,044.87 %4.49 %94.041,047.37%6 766 RADIAN GRP 46,525,698 %180.70 %2.42 %96.46184.86%7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 33,105,513 %0.00 %1.72 %98.180.00%8 4687 CIFG GRP 26,959,417 %5,407.86 %1.40 %99.595,413.90%9 40568 TRIPLE S PROPIEDAD INC 6,281,255 %0.33 %99.910.00%

10 22896 ACA FIN GUAR CORP 864,386 %68.22 %0.04 %99.9699.26%11 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 750,000 %0.00 %0.04 %100.000.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,922,495,183 %250.43 %100.00 %100.00266.98%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 194 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR HOLDINGS GR 787,593,581 %502.82 %24.00 %24.00502.82%2 626 ACE LTD GRP 584,542,065 %107.23 %17.81 %41.81107.74%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 576,024,123 %0.00 %17.55 %59.360.00%4 528 MBIA GRP 524,004,734 %340.33 %15.97 %75.32342.75%5 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 440,473,347 %126.86 %13.42 %88.74130.13%6 20311 SYNCORA GUAR INC 130,089,162 %1,603.52 %3.96 %92.701,608.84%7 1135 PMI GRP 114,858,114 %401.22 %3.50 %96.20401.22%8 766 RADIAN GRP 83,439,636 %342.14 %2.54 %98.75342.70%9 25771 CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC 54,151,967 %2,945.86 %1.65 %100.402,950.21%

10 4675 MUTUAL INSURERS HOLDING GRP 2,944,528 %21.91 %0.09 %100.4921.91%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 667,584 %-1.90 %0.02 %100.51-2.38%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 421,852 %-1.72 %0.01 %100.52-1.72%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,282,164,594 %479.63 %100.00 %100.00482.26%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 898,138,798 %10.30 %25.26 %25.2610.13%2 528 MBIA GRP 847,956,109 %109.84 %23.85 %49.11109.46%3 194 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR HOLDINGS GR 691,063,529 %14.49 %19.44 %68.5514.49%4 1135 PMI GRP 331,343,535 %429.76 %9.32 %77.87429.76%5 1285 XL AMER GRP 256,010,050 %647.06 %7.20 %85.07649.43%6 766 RADIAN GRP 193,075,167 %117.69 %5.43 %90.50118.05%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 159,202,565 %-15.66 %4.48 %94.98-15.66%8 22896 ACA FIN GUAR CORP 98,695,872 %30.89 %2.78 %97.7631.54%9 25771 CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC 75,077,441 %864.07 %2.11 %99.87867.44%

10 4675 MUTUAL INSURERS HOLDING GRP 2,758,134 %25.90 %0.08 %99.9525.90%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 906,973 %0.00 %0.03 %99.970.00%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 566,859 %-2.41 %0.02 %99.99-2.41%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners99

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 108: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

10 - Financial Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,555,261,817 %130.63 %100.00 %100.00130.70%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 835,519,020 %4.53 %24.47 %24.476.29%2 528 MBIA GRP 808,115,530 %9.07 %23.67 %48.1410.56%3 194 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR HOLDINGS GR 620,316,500 %-0.40 %18.17 %66.31-0.40%4 1135 PMI GRP 376,855,003 %-0.76 %11.04 %77.35-0.76%5 1285 XL AMER GRP 301,434,720 %17.84 %8.83 %86.1818.79%6 766 RADIAN GRP 197,844,567 %49.69 %5.80 %91.9850.94%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 99,833,562 %-5.61 %2.92 %94.90-5.61%8 25771 CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC 98,807,711 %0.00 %2.89 %97.800.00%9 22896 ACA FIN GUAR CORP 71,897,220 %-2.74 %2.11 %99.90-0.97%

10 10859 FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO 2,229,621 %13.92 %0.07 %99.9713.92%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 432,089 %-3.35 %0.01 %99.98-2.13%12 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 323,184 %0.00 %0.01 %99.990.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,413,975,828 %7.32 %100.00 %100.008.42%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 950,477,317 %10.34 %25.98 %25.9811.02%2 528 MBIA GRP 933,170,385 %19.78 %25.51 %51.4917.89%3 194 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR HOLDINGS GR 752,415,863 %4.06 %20.57 %72.064.06%4 1135 PMI GRP 392,257,374 %10.30 %10.72 %82.7810.30%5 1285 XL AMER GRP 197,741,168 %17.60 %5.41 %88.1817.56%6 766 RADIAN GRP 183,055,471 %1.09 %5.00 %93.193.19%7 22896 ACA FIN GUAR CORP 89,218,248 %17.96 %2.44 %95.6318.69%8 25771 CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC 84,408,067 %0.00 %2.31 %97.930.00%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 71,072,005 %-0.19 %1.94 %99.88-0.19%

10 10859 FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO 2,182,226 %38.68 %0.06 %99.9438.68%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,089,879 %-42.30 %0.03 %99.96-42.40%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 685,957 %2.89 %0.02 %99.9824.37%13 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 372,014 %0.00 %0.01 %99.990.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,658,374,627 %11.04 %100.00 %100.0010.74%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 528 MBIA GRP 623,301,487 %14.37 %39.68 %39.6814.37%2 1248 AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP 433,499,168 %3.16 %27.60 %67.273.33%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners100

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 109: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

10 - Financial Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 194 ASSURED GUAR GRP 325,876,487 %6.88 %20.74 %88.026.88%4 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 102,323,364 %-0.92 %6.51 %94.53-0.92%5 22896 ACA FINANCIAL GAURANTY CORP 43,144,596 %0.00 %2.75 %97.280.00%6 398 ENHANCE FNCL GRP 37,241,762 %23.93 %2.37 %99.6528.72%7 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,711,827 %-22.97 %0.11 %99.76-22.71%8 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 1,522,167 %41.11 %0.10 %99.8542.14%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 1,069,892 %-3.21 %0.07 %99.92-3.21%

10 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 518,832 %0.00 %0.03 %99.960.00%11 218 CNA INS GRP 356,630 %477.89 %0.02 %99.98534.78%12 30317 HANYS INS CO 267,570 %6.57 %0.02 %100.006.57%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,570,899,294 %8.89 %100.00 %100.009.12%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 528 MBIA GRP 325,185,681 %0.67 %38.53 %38.53n/a2 18708 AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP 192,681,705 %2.48 %22.83 %61.36n/a3 194 ASSURED GUAR GRP 130,070,746 %18.71 %15.41 %76.77n/a4 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 97,170,660 %10.82 %11.51 %88.29n/a5 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP 56,541,186 %5.45 %6.70 %94.99n/a6 24961 CONNIE LEE INS CO 16,656,143 %0.00 %1.97 %96.96n/a7 398 ENHANCE FNCL GRP 8,635,130 %0.00 %1.02 %97.98n/a8 1 AETNA GRP 5,904,882 %241.61 %0.70 %98.68n/a9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 2,688,345 %-12.34 %0.32 %99.00n/a

10 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 2,027,109 %45.74 %0.24 %99.24n/a11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 1,591,070 %0.00 %0.19 %99.43n/a12 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,556,579 %-34.04 %0.18 %99.62n/a13 218 CNA INS GRP 919,511 %545.70 %0.11 %99.72n/a14 10112 NORTHEAST CAS RRG INC 855,249 %0.00 %0.10 %99.83n/a15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 550,000 %-226.41 %0.07 %99.89n/a16 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 261,266 %-106.28 %0.03 %99.92n/a17 355 LYNDON INS GRP 247,200 %67.49 %0.03 %99.95n/a18 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 211,031 %97.73 %0.03 %99.98n/a19 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 210,474 %3,925.14 %0.02 %100.00n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 843,958,265 %17.64 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 528 MBIA GRP 199,046,589 %0.00 %31.54 %31.54n/a2 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 146,039,988 %15.59 %23.14 %54.68n/a3 18708 AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP 128,699,600 %43.55 %20.39 %75.08n/a4 194 ASSURED GUAR GRP 117,378,220 %0.00 %18.60 %93.68n/a5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 10,695,610 %7.51 %1.69 %95.37n/a6 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP 9,154,538 %0.00 %1.45 %96.82n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners101

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 110: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

10 - Financial Guaranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 4,894,233 %1.27 %0.78 %97.60n/a8 40037 LEHMAN INS CO 3,599,548 %0.00 %0.57 %98.17n/a9 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 3,010,350 %0.00 %0.48 %98.65n/a

10 159 RELIANCE GRP 1,913,367 %33.50 %0.30 %98.95n/a11 218 CNA INS GRP 1,863,433 %103.79 %0.30 %99.24n/a12 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 1,718,745 %71.71 %0.27 %99.52n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 1,501,066 %64.90 %0.24 %99.75n/a14 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,108,047 %483.50 %0.18 %99.93n/a15 827 AMERIN GRP 906,375 %40.62 %0.14 %100.07n/a16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 883,127 %142.79 %0.14 %100.21n/a17 398 ENHANCE FNCL GRP 845,116 %0.00 %0.13 %100.35n/a18 105 MGIC GRP 667,028 %0.00 %0.11 %100.45n/a19 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 616,822 %1,211.70 %0.10 %100.55n/a20 355 LYNDON INS GRP 498,980 %37.98 %0.08 %100.63n/a21 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 227,110 %972.34 %0.04 %100.67n/a22 1120 EVEREST REINS HOLDINGS GRP 168,215 %0.03 %0.03 %100.69n/a23 43133 APEX LLOYDS INS CO 58,468 %103.73 %0.01 %100.70n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 631,063,753 %25.25 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners102

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 111: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1210 MLMIC GRP 756,843,910 %49.63 %7.01 %7.0173.93%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 725,511,559 %47.40 %6.72 %13.7468.56%3 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 601,223,463 %23.32 %5.57 %19.3144.33%4 2698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP 541,033,064 %20.61 %5.01 %24.3236.94%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 524,252,247 %27.51 %4.86 %29.1845.26%6 218 CNA INS GRP 517,259,789 %38.16 %4.79 %33.9750.88%7 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 397,879,323 %67.84 %3.69 %37.6684.06%8 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 382,540,534 %6.12 %3.55 %41.2113.28%9 2358 ISMIE GRP 321,936,854 %41.68 %2.98 %44.1969.09%

10 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 266,255,263 %29.55 %2.47 %46.6650.95%11 10697 MCIC VT INC RRG 263,048,965 %79.49 %2.44 %49.1090.61%12 1282 NORCAL GRP 252,789,594 %12.67 %2.34 %51.4436.32%13 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 236,389,893 %19.86 %2.19 %53.6343.46%14 1272 FPIC INS GRP 195,424,403 %28.62 %1.81 %55.4455.74%15 212 ZURICH INS GRP 165,828,927 %20.79 %1.54 %56.9831.74%16 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 155,323,398 %27.06 %1.44 %58.4240.93%17 3239 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP 150,903,295 %27.61 %1.40 %59.8140.00%18 30317 HOSPITALS INS CO INC 150,009,670 %98.72 %1.39 %61.20106.11%19 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 146,743,912 %46.10 %1.36 %62.5663.42%20 184 MEDICAL INS GRP 127,389,072 %19.06 %1.18 %63.7539.10%21 16942 MMIC INS INC 125,629,168 %27.71 %1.16 %64.9145.85%22 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 113,232,197 %1.52 %1.05 %65.9620.23%23 626 ACE LTD GRP 110,602,081 %25.33 %1.02 %66.9850.66%24 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 109,370,521 %34.02 %1.01 %68.0039.87%25 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 107,878,005 %29.82 %1.00 %69.0041.34%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 10,790,766,436 %35.55 %100.00 %100.0053.92%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1210 MLMIC GRP 826,339,639 %58.45 %7.37 %7.3783.85%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 744,469,946 %46.26 %6.64 %14.0167.59%3 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 668,617,772 %21.45 %5.96 %19.9835.21%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 608,280,855 %4.07 %5.43 %25.4021.45%5 218 CNA INS GRP 534,110,673 %34.47 %4.76 %30.1753.22%6 2698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP 455,581,822 %27.10 %4.06 %34.2344.92%7 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 378,695,525 %60.02 %3.38 %37.6183.90%8 2358 ISMIE GRP 357,617,015 %41.02 %3.19 %40.8064.42%9 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 302,726,086 %31.90 %2.70 %43.5053.67%

10 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 291,792,089 %31.84 %2.60 %46.1053.70%11 10697 MCIC VT INC RRG 262,864,866 %86.89 %2.34 %48.4599.67%12 1282 NORCAL GRP 258,906,367 %22.55 %2.31 %50.7643.04%13 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 245,779,824 %35.16 %2.19 %52.9565.83%14 1272 FPIC INS GRP 185,213,895 %24.75 %1.65 %54.6057.29%15 212 ZURICH INS GRP 184,526,357 %70.55 %1.65 %56.2579.57%16 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 164,394,767 %19.89 %1.47 %57.7134.78%17 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 160,938,812 %17.56 %1.44 %59.1525.87%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners103

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 112: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 184 MEDICAL INS GRP 135,604,677 %13.86 %1.21 %60.3633.18%19 30317 HOSPITALS INS CO INC 133,679,282 %133.12 %1.19 %61.55148.42%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 131,869,984 %24.57 %1.18 %62.7318.22%21 16942 MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO 131,029,056 %38.55 %1.17 %63.8955.50%22 3239 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP 127,895,525 %32.37 %1.14 %65.0445.32%23 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 125,017,843 %16.46 %1.12 %66.1538.60%24 626 ACE LTD GRP 112,578,242 %6.15 %1.00 %67.1530.07%25 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 108,758,161 %11.29 %0.97 %68.1317.84%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,210,681,520 %34.88 %100.00 %100.0053.76%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1210 MLMIC GRP 929,665,971 %76.61 %7.97 %7.97102.71%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 755,636,959 %50.81 %6.48 %14.4669.55%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 702,722,410 %31.60 %6.03 %20.4844.20%4 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 564,602,288 %41.21 %4.84 %25.3357.16%5 2698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP 528,041,840 %32.47 %4.53 %29.8665.15%6 218 CNA INS GRP 496,408,100 %40.60 %4.26 %34.1165.23%7 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 385,593,962 %72.58 %3.31 %37.4299.45%8 2358 ISMIE GRP 373,273,838 %35.71 %3.20 %40.6264.40%9 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 315,789,137 %42.66 %2.71 %43.3361.72%

10 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 310,452,565 %38.21 %2.66 %46.0058.16%11 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 257,815,983 %32.74 %2.21 %48.2175.31%12 1282 NORCAL GRP 248,685,480 %37.21 %2.13 %50.3460.41%13 10697 MCIC VT INC RRG 247,545,417 %94.08 %2.12 %52.46109.70%14 1272 FPIC INS GRP 205,522,946 %25.14 %1.76 %54.2349.19%15 212 ZURICH INS GRP 186,975,004 %-15.81 %1.60 %55.83-28.89%16 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 177,901,834 %23.43 %1.53 %57.3635.23%17 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 172,544,228 %39.02 %1.48 %58.8453.20%18 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 158,122,994 %29.14 %1.36 %60.1942.42%19 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 146,161,103 %26.22 %1.25 %61.453.05%20 184 MEDICAL INS GRP 143,056,558 %28.70 %1.23 %62.6743.99%21 16942 MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO 137,022,573 %42.92 %1.18 %63.8559.35%22 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 135,394,865 %14.17 %1.16 %65.0137.30%23 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 134,224,135 %63.95 %1.15 %66.1691.59%24 1125 SCPIE GRP 129,047,396 %30.42 %1.11 %67.2747.44%25 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 126,798,977 %32.33 %1.09 %68.3640.98%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 11,657,936,560 %41.57 %100.00 %100.0061.20%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1210 MLMIC GRP 945,444,291 %97.31 %7.68 %7.68130.46%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 819,221,841 %37.93 %6.65 %14.3351.29%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners104

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 113: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 724,939,335 %35.73 %5.89 %20.2266.22%4 2698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP 616,159,704 %19.77 %5.00 %25.2366.98%5 218 CNA INS GRP 578,205,675 %43.37 %4.70 %29.9259.35%6 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 531,822,507 %28.46 %4.32 %34.2445.43%7 2358 ISMIE GRP 385,713,544 %43.63 %3.13 %37.3766.98%8 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 345,182,749 %33.03 %2.80 %40.1850.92%9 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 334,992,234 %58.69 %2.72 %42.9076.33%

10 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 331,691,058 %84.80 %2.69 %45.59110.59%11 35904 HEALTH CARE IND INC 311,242,530 %20.53 %2.53 %48.1251.56%12 1282 NORCAL GRP 300,750,861 %29.95 %2.44 %50.5659.99%13 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 266,547,722 %49.99 %2.16 %52.7377.68%14 10697 MCIC VT INC RRG 256,855,155 %89.33 %2.09 %54.81106.65%15 1272 FPIC INS GRP 245,916,731 %30.27 %2.00 %56.8155.91%16 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 189,565,536 %32.43 %1.54 %58.3546.79%17 212 ZURICH INS GRP 181,727,299 %13.63 %1.48 %59.8340.95%18 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 171,574,576 %47.27 %1.39 %61.2266.05%19 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 156,861,711 %36.69 %1.27 %62.4957.15%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 153,158,423 %5.65 %1.24 %63.74-4.02%21 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 149,479,295 %21.79 %1.21 %64.9523.65%22 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 147,855,597 %43.32 %1.20 %66.1560.89%23 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 143,714,671 %25.86 %1.17 %67.3249.41%24 184 MEDICAL INS GRP 141,053,006 %31.51 %1.15 %68.4756.58%25 16942 MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO 139,936,935 %62.75 %1.14 %69.6080.96%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,312,129,387 %42.74 %100.00 %100.0065.08%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 1210 MLMIC GRP 871,089,149 %96.92 %7.15 %7.15136.66%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 857,085,635 %27.97 %7.03 %14.1834.50%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 710,026,551 %56.69 %5.82 %20.0090.02%4 2698 PROASSURANCE CORP GRP 612,241,641 %28.36 %5.02 %25.0276.23%5 218 CNA INS GRP 523,358,784 %60.68 %4.29 %29.3278.38%6 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 494,474,400 %40.81 %4.06 %33.3754.35%7 2358 ISMIE GRP 405,419,581 %56.14 %3.33 %36.7080.40%8 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 355,949,046 %43.08 %2.92 %39.6263.14%9 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 344,705,804 %55.93 %2.83 %42.4579.85%

10 35904 HEALTH CARE IND INC 331,637,721 %55.99 %2.72 %45.1780.29%11 1282 NORCAL GRP 297,647,510 %43.65 %2.44 %47.6174.28%12 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 290,698,476 %76.62 %2.38 %50.00107.99%13 1272 FPIC INS GRP 279,539,989 %45.52 %2.29 %52.2980.65%14 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 259,063,146 %55.03 %2.13 %54.4188.44%15 10697 MCIC VT INC RRG 247,508,167 %94.38 %2.03 %56.44110.80%16 212 ZURICH INS GRP 206,219,980 %56.21 %1.69 %58.1482.14%17 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 186,133,966 %47.52 %1.53 %59.6670.74%18 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 179,820,113 %26.31 %1.48 %61.1430.16%19 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 174,911,735 %47.55 %1.43 %62.5772.21%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners105

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 114: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 168,571,648 %70.71 %1.38 %63.96100.00%21 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 148,700,989 %40.48 %1.22 %65.1837.23%22 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 142,702,803 %59.84 %1.17 %66.3580.73%23 1125 SCPIE GRP 141,069,284 %25.58 %1.16 %67.5052.46%24 184 MEDICAL INS GRP 134,743,518 %51.01 %1.11 %68.6168.78%25 16942 MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO 129,919,465 %60.43 %1.07 %69.6778.80%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 12,189,796,510 %51.87 %100.00 %100.0074.57%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 580,158,799 %127.53 %9.02 %9.02144.99%2 1245 MLMIC GRP 499,719,314 %46.42 %7.77 %16.7970.30%3 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 320,977,369 %51.45 %4.99 %21.7868.39%4 35904 HEALTH CARE IND INC 243,168,084 %95.52 %3.78 %25.57138.37%5 218 CNA INS GRP 233,341,831 %56.34 %3.63 %29.2083.37%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 230,070,898 %148.26 %3.58 %32.77153.58%7 1282 NORCAL GRP 212,374,079 %62.83 %3.30 %36.0885.46%8 1166 MEDICAL INTER INS EXCH GRP 209,750,300 %111.78 %3.26 %39.34144.75%9 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 204,977,381 %51.40 %3.19 %42.5368.67%

10 711 PHICO GRP 190,109,424 %89.74 %2.96 %45.48108.10%11 568 MUTUAL ASSUR CO 168,266,130 %35.91 %2.62 %48.1087.84%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 163,849,570 %76.85 %2.55 %50.65116.60%13 2358 ISMIE GRP 163,847,539 %68.56 %2.55 %53.1988.39%14 1125 SCPIE GRP 154,008,642 %46.12 %2.40 %55.5977.50%15 792 PROFESSIONALS GRP 137,854,458 %98.20 %2.14 %57.73127.73%16 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 133,995,260 %38.87 %2.08 %59.8281.10%17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 131,892,295 %48.96 %2.05 %61.8792.02%18 1210 MLMIC GRP 131,029,521 %103.24 %2.04 %63.91111.66%19 1272 FPIC INS GRP 111,919,311 %63.85 %1.74 %65.6599.71%20 1154 PROMUTUAL GRP 105,612,807 %163.30 %1.64 %67.29192.57%21 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 97,895,175 %77.05 %1.52 %68.81105.60%22 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 94,849,370 %61.31 %1.48 %70.2987.13%23 30317 HANYS INS CO 91,343,713 %0.68 %1.42 %71.7119.48%24 42617 MAG MUT INS CO 84,736,970 %85.07 %1.32 %73.02115.49%25 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 80,818,113 %52.09 %1.26 %74.2877.65%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,430,407,577 %79.85 %100.00 %100.00106.18%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 533,208,832 %51.71 %8.64 %8.64n/a2 218 CNA INS GRP 354,407,754 %82.74 %5.74 %14.37n/a3 32247 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO 346,063,455 %12.79 %5.60 %19.98n/a4 35904 HEALTH CARE IND INC 292,083,110 %87.27 %4.73 %24.71n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners106

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 115: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO 244,292,606 %51.37 %3.96 %28.67n/a6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 222,541,668 %102.07 %3.60 %32.27n/a7 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 198,350,709 %52.71 %3.21 %35.48n/a8 32921 ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH 197,240,774 %87.35 %3.19 %38.68n/a9 33928 PIE MUT INS CO 180,434,156 %91.70 %2.92 %41.60n/a

10 929 MMI COS GRP 172,151,322 %63.08 %2.79 %44.39n/a11 924 PRINCETON INS CO 166,873,753 %91.10 %2.70 %47.09n/a12 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 148,591,219 %51.33 %2.41 %49.49n/a13 34398 MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ 135,294,492 %77.20 %2.19 %51.69n/a14 10206 MA MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL INS ASSOC 122,999,234 %44.05 %1.99 %53.68n/a15 1125 SCPIE GRP 121,247,491 %49.61 %1.96 %55.64n/a16 961 FRONTIER INS GRP 117,431,071 %68.97 %1.90 %57.54n/a17 33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 113,249,424 %44.57 %1.83 %59.38n/a18 568 MUTUAL ASSUR CO 111,443,123 %49.25 %1.80 %61.18n/a19 35718 PHICO INS CO 103,436,953 %29.32 %1.68 %62.86n/a20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 102,679,251 %29.98 %1.66 %64.52n/a21 69 FARMERS INS GRP 87,596,801 %50.01 %1.42 %65.94n/a22 30317 HANYS INS CO 84,191,908 %36.48 %1.36 %67.30n/a23 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 75,234,220 %56.21 %1.22 %68.52n/a24 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 74,959,581 %47.96 %1.21 %69.73n/a25 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 73,788,177 %42.34 %1.19 %70.93n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,174,897,774 %53.13 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 616,980,477 %40.79 %11.73 %11.73n/a2 218 CNA INS GRP 321,119,903 %53.89 %6.11 %17.84n/a3 32247 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO 299,938,394 %28.29 %5.70 %23.54n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 203,955,836 %95.36 %3.88 %27.42n/a5 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO 193,078,766 %82.63 %3.67 %31.09n/a6 32921 ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH 179,006,718 %69.34 %3.40 %34.50n/a7 1144 PIE MUT INS GRP 160,329,949 %68.93 %3.05 %37.55n/a8 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 151,891,885 %6.31 %2.89 %40.43n/a9 924 PRINCETON INS CO 143,968,385 %85.87 %2.74 %43.17n/a

10 69 FARMERS INS GRP 132,742,801 %6.96 %2.52 %45.70n/a11 32468 MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INS ASN 132,404,178 %160.05 %2.52 %48.21n/a12 1125 SCPIE GRP 122,482,473 %52.00 %2.33 %50.54n/a13 35718 PHICO INS CO 118,549,511 %11.64 %2.25 %52.80n/a14 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 112,588,013 %101.26 %2.14 %54.94n/a15 34681 MEDICAL PFL LIAB CATASTROP LOSS FUND 105,653,454 %2.01 %56.95n/a16 34398 MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ 98,272,714 %96.01 %1.87 %58.82n/a17 33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 93,205,206 %55.78 %1.77 %60.59n/a18 568 MUTUAL ASSUR CO 90,231,000 %59.83 %1.72 %62.30n/a19 377 MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP 69,084,400 %65.84 %1.31 %63.62n/a20 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 68,421,602 %51.14 %1.30 %64.92n/a21 35904 HEALTH CARE IND INC 68,193,699 %81.45 %1.30 %66.22n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners107

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 116: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

11 - Medical Professional Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 413 MAG MUT INS GRP 66,471,782 %50.14 %1.26 %67.48n/a23 929 MMI COS GRP 61,713,307 %65.08 %1.17 %68.65n/a24 33049 STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO 60,385,526 %71.45 %1.15 %69.80n/a25 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 56,380,502 %63.15 %1.07 %70.87n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,258,667,623 %56.96 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 582,836,668 %86.57 %16.67 %16.67n/a2 32247 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO 254,316,730 %135.07 %7.27 %23.94n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 173,887,662 %150.13 %4.97 %28.92n/a4 32921 ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH 124,546,335 %164.68 %3.56 %32.48n/a5 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO 119,329,792 %161.46 %3.41 %35.89n/a6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 117,570,024 %84.81 %3.36 %39.25n/a7 35718 PHICO INS CO 101,452,350 %93.94 %2.90 %42.16n/a8 34681 MEDICAL PFL LIAB CATASTROP LOSS FUND 95,282,144 %2.73 %44.88n/a9 1125 SCPIE GRP 92,382,644 %86.20 %2.64 %47.52n/a

10 69 FARMERS INS GRP 87,024,352 %110.03 %2.49 %50.01n/a11 1144 PIE MUT INS GRP 85,069,850 %72.65 %2.43 %52.45n/a12 831 DOCTORS CO GRP 78,853,756 %69.24 %2.26 %54.70n/a13 34398 MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ 74,410,902 %108.97 %2.13 %56.83n/a14 924 PRINCETON INS CO 69,858,907 %55.22 %2.00 %58.83n/a15 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 69,385,398 %198.29 %1.98 %60.81n/a16 32468 MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INS ASN 66,398,734 %259.24 %1.90 %62.71n/a17 33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 57,782,326 %54.17 %1.65 %64.36n/a18 966 AP CAPITAL GRP 55,725,884 %142.74 %1.59 %65.96n/a19 480 PARTHANON GRP 52,629,339 %124.91 %1.51 %67.46n/a20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 50,486,577 %86.09 %1.44 %68.91n/a21 41 CITIGROUP GRP 48,921,521 %185.14 %1.40 %70.31n/a22 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 41,629,290 %60.11 %1.19 %71.50n/a23 41467 PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS 37,706,722 %82.81 %1.08 %72.58n/a24 32832 MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ 37,642,550 %140.23 %1.08 %73.65n/a25 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 37,139,686 %54.80 %1.06 %74.71n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,496,347,990 %122.67 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners108

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 117: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 251,599,062 %0.00 %12.74 %12.740.60%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 235,869,337 %0.41 %11.95 %24.690.46%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 160,096,190 %-2.50 %8.11 %32.80-2.49%4 3829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP 130,817,756 %0.16 %6.63 %39.430.16%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 102,230,495 %-0.15 %5.18 %44.61-0.43%6 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 95,818,481 %-7.43 %4.85 %49.46-7.57%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 79,988,653 %-0.33 %4.05 %53.51-0.41%8 626 ACE LTD GRP 77,848,272 %2.00 %3.94 %57.452.02%9 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 68,556,038 %-3.14 %3.47 %60.93-3.27%

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 68,356,584 %0.59 %3.46 %64.391.00%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 51,995,095 %-0.01 %2.63 %67.02-0.01%12 922 AMERICAN ASSETS GRP 49,973,083 %0.00 %2.53 %69.550.00%13 1279 ARCH INS GRP 47,285,709 %-0.56 %2.40 %71.95-0.57%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 45,709,517 %-0.49 %2.32 %74.26-0.59%15 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 36,539,831 %0.16 %1.85 %76.110.16%16 181 SWISS RE GRP 33,065,093 %20.70 %1.67 %77.7920.69%17 783 RLI INS GRP 27,166,225 %-0.21 %1.38 %79.17-0.21%18 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 24,968,629 %-0.02 %1.26 %80.430.05%19 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 19,796,191 %-0.01 %1.00 %81.430.00%20 4636 MAX CAPITAL GRP 19,714,857 %17.14 %1.00 %82.4315.26%21 39861 GOLDEN BEAR INS CO 18,926,391 %-0.31 %0.96 %83.39-0.43%22 1285 XL AMER GRP 18,564,530 %5.99 %0.94 %84.333.78%23 28 AMICA MUT GRP 17,662,984 %0.14 %0.89 %85.230.11%24 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 17,612,767 %0.06 %0.89 %86.120.07%25 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 14,218,050 %-0.05 %0.72 %86.84-0.05%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,974,229,017 %0.15 %100.00 %100.000.18%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 248,874,389 %0.26 %12.66 %12.660.51%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 193,816,592 %-2.83 %9.86 %22.53-2.86%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 174,489,128 %-1.00 %8.88 %31.41-0.74%4 3829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP 130,226,654 %0.02 %6.63 %38.030.08%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 118,834,054 %0.14 %6.05 %44.080.18%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 94,558,472 %1.75 %4.81 %48.892.06%7 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 92,426,185 %-10.43 %4.70 %53.60-10.62%8 626 ACE LTD GRP 82,543,876 %4.52 %4.20 %57.804.61%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 68,970,509 %-20.45 %3.51 %61.31-21.49%

10 922 AMERICAN ASSETS GRP 65,592,753 %0.53 %3.34 %64.640.58%11 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 57,029,349 %-0.66 %2.90 %67.55-1.36%12 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 50,497,465 %-0.05 %2.57 %70.12-0.04%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 45,004,382 %0.55 %2.29 %72.410.58%14 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 35,493,547 %0.20 %1.81 %74.210.20%15 1279 ARCH INS GRP 33,395,819 %0.62 %1.70 %75.910.63%16 411 MAPFRE INS GRP 27,965,895 %-0.06 %1.42 %77.34-0.09%17 783 RLI INS GRP 26,359,542 %0.55 %1.34 %78.680.58%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners109

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 118: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 181 SWISS RE GRP 25,970,934 %0.60 %1.32 %80.000.59%19 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 25,128,252 %0.20 %1.28 %81.280.34%20 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 18,263,426 %0.00 %0.93 %82.210.01%21 1285 XL AMER GRP 17,572,170 %-3.70 %0.89 %83.10-2.87%22 28 AMICA MUT GRP 17,111,452 %-0.03 %0.87 %83.970.04%23 40568 TRIPLE S PROPIEDAD INC 14,765,762 %0.02 %0.75 %84.720.02%24 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 14,178,649 %3.24 %0.72 %85.443.24%25 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 13,760,169 %0.21 %0.70 %86.150.21%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,965,091,317 %-1.04 %100.00 %100.00-0.95%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 232,887,325 %0.15 %11.39 %11.39-0.03%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 228,652,833 %-25.63 %11.18 %22.57-25.25%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 189,928,825 %-8.28 %9.29 %31.85-8.20%4 3829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP 124,130,108 %0.03 %6.07 %37.920.02%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 98,802,940 %6.87 %4.83 %42.757.11%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 97,542,338 %2.29 %4.77 %47.521.69%7 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 96,549,871 %6.25 %4.72 %52.246.39%8 922 ICW GRP 77,884,359 %-0.08 %3.81 %56.05-0.08%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 69,037,770 %8.92 %3.38 %59.428.95%

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 67,814,293 %-0.47 %3.32 %62.74-0.32%11 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 53,063,077 %5.44 %2.59 %65.33-0.32%12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 48,350,301 %0.08 %2.36 %67.700.10%13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 45,656,983 %-0.06 %2.23 %69.93-0.05%14 1279 ARCH INS GRP 41,206,349 %0.08 %2.01 %71.940.07%15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 40,413,810 %-2.11 %1.98 %73.92-1.76%16 783 RLI INS GRP 39,463,063 %0.83 %1.93 %75.850.86%17 181 SWISS RE GRP 34,601,767 %-0.05 %1.69 %77.54-0.05%18 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 33,949,891 %-0.08 %1.66 %79.20-0.01%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 26,661,295 %-4.96 %1.30 %80.50-4.97%20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 24,597,338 %-0.03 %1.20 %81.710.07%21 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 19,968,340 %0.00 %0.98 %82.680.03%22 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 18,587,557 %-0.89 %0.91 %83.59-0.64%23 28 AMICA MUT GRP 16,446,200 %-0.09 %0.80 %84.40-0.09%24 39861 GOLDEN BEAR INS CO 15,086,963 %0.00 %0.74 %85.13-0.02%25 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 14,156,972 %-0.01 %0.69 %85.83-0.10%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,045,335,726 %-1.86 %100.00 %100.00-2.03%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 210,483,860 %0.14 %10.30 %10.300.79%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 202,055,698 %4.28 %9.89 %20.194.73%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners110

Page 119: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 159,476,928 %28.89 %7.80 %27.9929.05%4 3829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP 111,326,823 %0.01 %5.45 %33.44-0.04%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 94,548,443 %-2.96 %4.63 %38.07-8.38%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 91,194,164 %-33.36 %4.46 %42.53-33.28%7 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 88,290,665 %8.73 %4.32 %46.858.22%8 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 82,490,645 %-1.99 %4.04 %50.896.01%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 67,533,521 %2.54 %3.31 %54.202.10%

10 922 ICW GRP 66,650,206 %0.11 %3.26 %57.460.12%11 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 62,581,933 %12.17 %3.06 %60.526.99%12 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 57,790,858 %0.61 %2.83 %63.351.51%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 56,972,899 %0.00 %2.79 %66.140.01%14 1279 ARCH INS GRP 50,801,924 %-4.95 %2.49 %68.62-5.26%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 43,237,605 %-0.10 %2.12 %70.74-0.22%16 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 39,330,673 %0.21 %1.92 %72.660.24%17 783 RLI INS GRP 39,313,627 %-3.73 %1.92 %74.59-3.69%18 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 39,248,371 %24.74 %1.92 %76.5124.26%19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 35,951,368 %0.26 %1.76 %78.271.67%20 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 35,821,545 %-3.30 %1.75 %80.02-3.16%21 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 31,503,631 %1.42 %1.54 %81.561.48%22 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 25,058,826 %-1.30 %1.23 %82.791.25%23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 23,399,646 %0.21 %1.15 %83.940.39%24 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 19,214,163 %0.01 %0.94 %84.880.02%25 1285 XL AMER GRP 17,600,613 %6.54 %0.86 %85.748.36%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,043,309,639 %2.07 %100.00 %100.002.20%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 192,416,934 %-0.67 %11.41 %11.414.90%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 151,869,690 %125.85 %9.00 %20.41131.61%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 141,117,459 %7.94 %8.37 %28.786.38%4 3829 GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP 105,365,819 %-0.13 %6.25 %35.02-0.02%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 86,688,532 %21.02 %5.14 %40.1621.22%6 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 84,794,797 %10.05 %5.03 %45.1910.56%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 74,841,761 %-6.33 %4.44 %49.63-7.85%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 71,480,496 %11.60 %4.24 %53.8613.61%9 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 59,708,034 %16.77 %3.54 %57.4019.69%

10 922 ICW GRP 52,897,702 %0.00 %3.14 %60.540.03%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 43,783,418 %-0.79 %2.60 %63.13-0.89%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 42,987,547 %0.57 %2.55 %65.680.43%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 42,097,575 %-0.45 %2.50 %68.18-1.53%14 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 36,652,313 %0.00 %2.17 %70.350.02%15 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 33,131,224 %0.04 %1.96 %72.320.10%16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 31,940,398 %4.32 %1.89 %74.214.35%17 783 RLI INS GRP 29,890,332 %3.39 %1.77 %75.983.41%18 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 29,206,803 %-0.46 %1.73 %77.71-0.46%19 1285 XL AMER GRP 22,608,833 %3.22 %1.34 %79.053.84%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners111

Page 120: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 21,102,005 %0.87 %1.25 %80.301.18%21 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 17,143,093 %-0.28 %1.02 %81.32-0.31%22 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 15,214,206 %-14.93 %0.90 %82.22-14.64%23 3786 ENDURANCE GRP 14,563,290 %49.26 %0.86 %83.0957.26%24 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 14,451,196 %-0.87 %0.86 %83.94-0.38%25 28 AMICA MUT GRP 13,747,646 %-0.20 %0.82 %84.76-0.19%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,686,816,152 %14.94 %100.00 %100.0016.20%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 141,348,439 %18.19 %14.93 %14.9325.04%2 164 ST PAUL GRP 84,053,285 %0.23 %8.88 %23.810.26%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 73,827,758 %-1.72 %7.80 %31.61-1.03%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 48,628,309 %342.91 %5.14 %36.75376.30%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 47,969,053 %-2.14 %5.07 %41.82-11.27%6 626 ACE LTD GRP 46,250,487 %11.82 %4.89 %46.709.24%7 163 SAFECO INS GRP 42,011,396 %0.30 %4.44 %51.140.72%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 33,109,104 %1.97 %3.50 %54.643.53%9 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 30,573,442 %-14.62 %3.23 %57.8740.22%

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 23,382,548 %-7.71 %2.47 %60.34-5.64%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 23,177,284 %-0.24 %2.45 %62.79-0.37%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 22,075,765 %35.49 %2.33 %65.1235.92%13 922 AMERICAN ASSETS GRP 21,856,440 %-27.94 %2.31 %67.43-27.49%14 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 21,258,363 %8.92 %2.25 %69.679.49%15 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 19,616,764 %1.64 %2.07 %71.752.14%16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 12,407,537 %0.58 %1.31 %73.060.60%17 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 11,943,422 %-4.11 %1.26 %74.32-4.20%18 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 11,556,095 %-0.83 %1.22 %75.54-0.22%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 10,090,379 %13.19 %1.07 %76.6015.19%20 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 9,725,836 %4.27 %1.03 %77.634.81%21 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 8,686,060 %34.46 %0.92 %78.5539.57%22 26905 CENTURY-NATL INS CO 8,604,770 %25.61 %0.91 %79.4637.38%23 40568 SEGUROS TRIPLES INC 7,831,840 %0.00 %0.83 %80.290.00%24 157 PUBLIC EMPLOYEES GRP 7,360,825 %0.00 %0.78 %81.060.00%25 28 AMICA MUT GRP 7,179,194 %0.45 %0.76 %81.820.45%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 946,591,859 %23.89 %100.00 %100.0028.98%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 313,833,168 %223.13 %23.52 %23.52n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 160,695,131 %65.95 %12.04 %35.56n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 93,509,360 %119.74 %7.01 %42.56n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 76,538,106 %12.63 %5.74 %48.30n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners112

Page 121: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 55,274,133 %56.88 %4.14 %52.44n/a6 163 SAFECO INS GRP 47,669,048 %61.17 %3.57 %56.01n/a7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 42,926,180 %113.66 %3.22 %59.23n/a8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 29,416,346 %127.63 %2.20 %61.43n/a9 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 28,593,984 %-0.06 %2.14 %63.58n/a

10 218 CNA INS GRP 25,431,804 %101.97 %1.91 %65.48n/a11 162 ROYAL GRP 24,278,315 %14.57 %1.82 %67.30n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 23,276,146 %49.25 %1.74 %69.05n/a13 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 23,255,984 %-4.75 %1.74 %70.79n/a14 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 18,065,144 %93.29 %1.35 %72.14n/a15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 17,705,875 %117.05 %1.33 %73.47n/a16 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 17,618,428 %43.95 %1.32 %74.79n/a17 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 17,270,149 %6.41 %1.29 %76.08n/a18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 15,607,035 %11.96 %1.17 %77.25n/a19 1111 TIG INS GRP 14,096,723 %118.17 %1.06 %78.31n/a20 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 13,880,685 %32.84 %1.04 %79.35n/a21 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 13,728,957 %103.54 %1.03 %80.38n/a22 26905 CENTURY-NATL INS CO 13,061,579 %38.88 %0.98 %81.36n/a23 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 12,669,085 %59.36 %0.95 %82.31n/a24 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 10,846,456 %1.54 %0.81 %83.12n/a25 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 10,769,062 %19.71 %0.81 %83.93n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,334,533,906 %98.08 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 154,627,216 %-27.35 %26.13 %26.13n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 66,395,957 %115.22 %11.22 %37.35n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 50,960,718 %92.13 %8.61 %45.96n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 44,272,177 %78.03 %7.48 %53.44n/a5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 23,400,452 %67.33 %3.95 %57.39n/a6 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 20,797,622 %36.92 %3.51 %60.91n/a7 218 CNA INS GRP 16,328,003 %27.72 %2.76 %63.67n/a8 163 SAFECO INS GRP 14,792,078 %27.63 %2.50 %66.17n/a9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 13,771,946 %49.40 %2.33 %68.49n/a

10 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 11,914,035 %3.51 %2.01 %70.51n/a11 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 11,632,794 %2.28 %1.97 %72.47n/a12 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 9,908,748 %171.83 %1.67 %74.15n/a13 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 8,848,698 %5.04 %1.50 %75.64n/a14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 8,571,977 %11.30 %1.45 %77.09n/a15 1111 TIG INS GRP 7,601,529 %41.15 %1.28 %78.37n/a16 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 7,383,545 %-1.05 %1.25 %79.62n/a17 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,355,254 %225.73 %1.07 %80.70n/a18 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 6,046,863 %45.48 %1.02 %81.72n/a19 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 5,703,518 %4.37 %0.96 %82.68n/a20 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 5,262,315 %11.44 %0.89 %83.57n/a21 148 OHIO CAS GRP 4,996,840 %16.13 %0.84 %84.42n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners113

Page 122: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

12 - Earthquake

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 4,691,463 %22.50 %0.79 %85.21n/a23 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 4,225,698 %-19.08 %0.71 %85.92n/a24 323 CIVIL SERV EMPLOYEE GRP 3,472,020 %62.58 %0.59 %86.51n/a25 800 WESTERN MUT INS GRP 3,434,237 %2.50 %0.58 %87.09n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 591,805,071 %38.10 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 33,007,834 %-0.22 %15.24 %15.24n/a2 69 FARMERS INS GRP 27,422,128 %0.17 %12.66 %27.91n/a3 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 20,716,907 %11.66 %9.57 %37.47n/a4 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 14,741,228 %-8.03 %6.81 %44.28n/a5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 10,486,312 %0.04 %4.84 %49.12n/a6 218 CNA INS GRP 8,620,339 %12.29 %3.98 %53.10n/a7 163 SAFECO INS GRP 7,775,249 %-1.80 %3.59 %56.70n/a8 133 MISSION EQUITIES GRP 7,134,858 %8.04 %3.29 %59.99n/a9 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 6,360,489 %3.83 %2.94 %62.93n/a

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 5,259,226 %-0.81 %2.43 %65.36n/a11 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 5,217,056 %-7.00 %2.41 %67.77n/a12 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 3,983,765 %3.55 %1.84 %69.61n/a13 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,433,927 %-0.23 %1.59 %71.19n/a14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,202,586 %0.25 %1.48 %72.67n/a15 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 2,971,691 %-0.10 %1.37 %74.04n/a16 161 TOPA EQUITIES LTD GRP 2,682,580 %10.00 %1.24 %75.28n/a17 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 2,666,337 %-0.61 %1.23 %76.51n/a18 1111 TIG INS GRP 2,470,714 %-0.41 %1.14 %77.65n/a19 164 ST PAUL GRP 2,164,146 %-0.25 %1.00 %78.65n/a20 159 RELIANCE GRP 2,125,271 %0.25 %0.98 %79.63n/a21 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 2,104,601 %0.00 %0.97 %80.61n/a22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,037,782 %1.33 %0.94 %81.55n/a23 343 NATIONAL INS CO GRP 2,012,744 %0.26 %0.93 %82.48n/a24 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 1,654,222 %1.11 %0.76 %83.24n/a25 162 ROYAL GRP 1,605,396 %0.24 %0.74 %83.98n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 216,542,395 %1.81 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners114

Page 123: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,468,726,855 %72.21 %9.73 %9.7379.33%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 3,853,087,982 %82.88 %8.39 %18.1393.96%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,739,325,743 %56.98 %5.97 %24.0966.48%4 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,498,224,667 %51.83 %5.44 %29.5355.38%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,473,549,340 %75.17 %5.39 %34.9285.91%6 OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION 2,469,550,000 %67.51 %5.38 %40.3083.96%7 WASHINGTON STATE FUND 1,360,533,000 %172.64 %2.96 %43.26186.31%8 36102 STATE INS FUND 1,309,601,077 %92.81 %2.85 %46.1195.47%9 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,287,041,223 %73.21 %2.80 %48.9280.36%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,068,737,571 %67.04 %2.33 %51.2576.74%11 218 CNA INS GRP 951,095,026 %79.60 %2.07 %53.3288.54%12 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 794,453,914 %63.46 %1.73 %55.0569.10%13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 725,229,592 %46.63 %1.58 %56.6346.21%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 642,256,752 %54.68 %1.40 %58.0358.60%15 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 634,389,226 %44.09 %1.38 %59.4152.42%16 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 465,199,256 %44.59 %1.01 %60.4250.21%17 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 457,741,915 %76.87 %1.00 %61.4285.77%18 767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP 454,682,293 %59.77 %0.99 %62.4166.97%19 2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP 452,008,329 %48.78 %0.98 %63.3955.41%20 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 407,469,145 %71.42 %0.89 %64.2885.87%21 3363 EMPLOYERS HOLDINGS GRP 376,650,702 %49.50 %0.82 %65.1054.84%22 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 370,316,613 %82.69 %0.81 %65.9187.94%23 41190 PINNACOL ASSUR 353,823,991 %65.05 %0.77 %66.6867.13%24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 337,521,584 %102.42 %0.74 %67.41109.63%25 36196 SAIF CORP 312,907,874 %88.57 %0.68 %68.0993.13%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 45,912,920,114 %71.00 %100.00 %100.0078.87%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,392,810,788 %65.72 %10.65 %10.6573.42%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,444,907,595 %73.93 %8.77 %19.4282.92%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,820,154,079 %69.84 %5.57 %24.9981.09%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,678,891,611 %74.22 %5.29 %30.2884.31%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,570,689,096 %49.59 %5.07 %35.3553.22%6 OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION 2,235,092,000 %97.57 %4.41 %39.76115.77%7 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,725,240,012 %73.24 %3.41 %43.1778.84%8 36102 STATE INS FUND 1,355,120,978 %70.84 %2.68 %45.8475.71%9 WASHINGTON STATE FUND 1,123,824,000 %170.74 %2.22 %48.06174.28%

10 218 CNA INS GRP 1,036,855,811 %119.46 %2.05 %50.11126.17%11 626 ACE LTD GRP 963,114,542 %32.41 %1.90 %52.0138.94%12 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 861,255,475 %58.45 %1.70 %53.7162.85%13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 788,704,364 %39.81 %1.56 %55.2744.57%14 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 756,894,080 %53.34 %1.49 %56.7660.64%15 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 710,237,020 %51.28 %1.40 %58.1655.59%16 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 605,578,221 %26.03 %1.20 %59.3629.14%17 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 547,872,675 %58.86 %1.08 %60.4467.23%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners115

Page 124: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 507,178,361 %67.30 %1.00 %61.4476.12%19 41190 PINNACOL ASSUR 484,458,594 %51.30 %0.96 %62.4057.81%20 3363 EMPLOYERS GRP 480,459,286 %41.25 %0.95 %63.3546.24%21 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 474,303,394 %70.21 %0.94 %64.2876.25%22 767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP 461,129,981 %66.87 %0.91 %65.1972.34%23 2538 AMTRUST GRP 455,417,678 %39.58 %0.90 %66.0946.34%24 12372 BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO 424,512,693 %55.15 %0.84 %66.9361.68%25 36196 SAIF CORP 403,123,019 %87.53 %0.80 %67.7291.46%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 50,657,709,302 %67.37 %100.00 %100.0074.63%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 6,157,333,569 %50.46 %10.77 %10.7753.58%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,575,863,331 %71.43 %9.75 %20.5181.51%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,164,430,919 %80.94 %5.53 %26.0573.91%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,806,740,294 %71.10 %4.91 %30.9581.07%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,594,272,215 %53.34 %4.54 %35.4959.75%6 OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION 2,453,850,000 %82.75 %4.29 %39.78108.69%7 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 2,387,691,628 %68.02 %4.17 %43.9672.47%8 36102 STATE INS FUND 1,719,024,027 %73.04 %3.01 %46.9676.36%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,321,945,273 %24.33 %2.31 %49.2739.84%

10 WASHINGTON STATE FUND 1,294,870,000 %136.71 %2.26 %51.54136.71%11 218 CNA INS GRP 1,057,261,959 %82.90 %1.85 %53.3990.35%12 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 839,320,855 %57.98 %1.47 %54.8562.44%13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 836,141,992 %38.51 %1.46 %56.3143.40%14 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 780,597,601 %52.25 %1.36 %57.6858.18%15 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 751,916,281 %66.22 %1.31 %58.9970.32%16 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 736,686,421 %35.57 %1.29 %60.2838.24%17 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 733,472,192 %55.39 %1.28 %61.5658.78%18 12372 BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO 707,705,563 %53.09 %1.24 %62.8054.94%19 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 598,309,653 %66.05 %1.05 %63.8573.35%20 36196 SAIF CORP 588,876,866 %86.40 %1.03 %64.8889.75%21 41190 PINNACOL ASSUR 546,642,471 %56.51 %0.96 %65.8361.60%22 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 500,291,660 %65.42 %0.87 %66.7169.64%23 4485 SCF GRP 496,991,661 %95.31 %0.87 %67.5897.67%24 767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP 461,075,971 %66.62 %0.81 %68.3872.94%25 2538 AMTRUST GRP 404,926,728 %54.52 %0.71 %69.0960.38%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 57,194,054,321 %63.94 %100.00 %100.0070.21%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 6,575,396,892 %53.65 %11.15 %11.1562.23%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,580,220,527 %66.13 %9.47 %20.6273.15%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners116

Page 125: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 3,567,371,141 %61.20 %6.05 %26.6763.45%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,798,472,882 %72.70 %4.75 %31.4281.86%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,722,281,768 %57.15 %4.62 %36.0371.99%6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,669,898,517 %63.49 %4.53 %40.5669.64%7 OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION 2,165,098,000 %74.33 %3.67 %44.2489.32%8 36102 STATE INS FUND 1,702,141,794 %85.08 %2.89 %47.1287.91%9 WASHINGTON STATE FUND 1,338,983,000 %105.54 %2.27 %49.39105.54%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,294,543,633 %46.59 %2.20 %51.5955.28%11 218 CNA INS GRP 1,117,708,510 %71.17 %1.90 %53.4983.00%12 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,099,166,795 %48.96 %1.86 %55.3555.68%13 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 921,446,487 %16.12 %1.56 %56.9120.40%14 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 840,074,049 %40.64 %1.42 %58.3445.50%15 12372 BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO 765,963,205 %79.13 %1.30 %59.6480.46%16 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 743,095,200 %64.37 %1.26 %60.9069.58%17 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 719,842,200 %48.00 %1.22 %62.1252.12%18 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 687,219,306 %64.83 %1.17 %63.2868.78%19 41190 PINNACOL ASSUR 587,714,160 %60.06 %1.00 %64.2864.27%20 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 529,421,126 %74.58 %0.90 %65.1881.64%21 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 506,534,556 %77.66 %0.86 %66.0481.62%22 36196 SAIF CORP 449,794,189 %92.86 %0.76 %66.8094.90%23 4485 SCF GRP 427,268,395 %95.84 %0.72 %67.53101.91%24 169 SENTRY INS GRP 414,701,570 %64.03 %0.70 %68.2370.54%25 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 398,233,207 %50.05 %0.68 %68.9059.33%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 58,954,941,040 %61.75 %100.00 %100.0068.59%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 6,439,193,540 %71.39 %10.61 %10.6179.76%2 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 6,141,322,743 %67.37 %10.12 %20.7270.90%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,070,809,128 %73.33 %8.35 %29.0779.89%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,944,278,957 %54.42 %4.85 %33.9262.68%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,943,887,218 %62.39 %4.85 %38.7769.93%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,761,840,078 %68.07 %4.55 %43.3280.22%7 OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION 2,194,573,000 %111.89 %3.61 %46.94134.44%8 36102 STATE INS FUND 1,596,553,305 %76.45 %2.63 %49.5778.05%9 WASHINGTON STATE FUND 1,268,213,000 %109.33 %2.09 %51.66109.33%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,252,050,331 %41.18 %2.06 %53.7239.36%11 218 CNA INS GRP 1,148,748,274 %87.71 %1.89 %55.6192.78%12 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 1,130,994,850 %34.52 %1.86 %57.4740.23%13 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 882,022,718 %46.11 %1.45 %58.9348.97%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 741,581,890 %55.54 %1.22 %60.1560.72%15 WV WORKERS' COMPENSATION DIVISION 710,501,000 %43.29 %1.17 %61.3243.29%16 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 701,956,102 %67.79 %1.16 %62.4772.08%17 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 679,887,633 %57.92 %1.12 %63.5960.63%18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 594,162,813 %73.97 %0.98 %64.5781.78%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 576,025,110 %54.24 %0.95 %65.5260.55%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners117

Page 126: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 41190 PINNACOL ASSUR 562,796,481 %63.88 %0.93 %66.4568.12%21 317 AON CORP GRP 508,105,014 %51.50 %0.84 %67.2855.50%22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 468,804,690 %49.35 %0.77 %68.0654.75%23 3363 EMPLOYERS GRP 450,739,641 %46.67 %0.74 %68.8052.95%24 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 449,921,164 %91.64 %0.74 %69.5495.26%25 169 SENTRY INS GRP 449,205,035 %59.73 %0.74 %70.2865.20%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 60,711,481,341 %67.11 %100.00 %100.0073.44%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,977,860,882 %81.89 %8.68 %8.6888.31%2 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,798,962,415 %90.97 %5.25 %13.9396.84%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,606,665,269 %82.00 %4.69 %18.6189.61%4 218 CNA INS GRP 1,570,914,772 %84.01 %4.58 %23.2074.61%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,551,326,538 %86.21 %4.52 %27.7294.04%6 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,326,358,541 %65.39 %3.87 %31.5980.07%7 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,280,241,569 %69.46 %3.73 %35.3275.37%8 36102 STATE INSURANCE FUND 1,104,627,262 %101.34 %3.22 %38.5498.41%9 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 1,085,755,485 %79.70 %3.17 %41.7184.36%

10 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 1,077,017,038 %108.98 %3.14 %44.85122.14%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,056,635,050 %61.77 %3.08 %47.9367.11%12 1172 LEGION INS GRP 726,087,621 %71.36 %2.12 %50.0578.75%13 164 ST PAUL GRP 635,224,008 %-18.63 %1.85 %51.90-13.94%14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 610,640,298 %110.17 %1.78 %53.68121.92%15 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 605,778,345 %65.34 %1.77 %55.4577.22%16 44 AVIVA GRP 545,593,265 %106.66 %1.59 %57.04114.53%17 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 408,179,204 %49.29 %1.19 %58.2354.17%18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 387,133,590 %88.87 %1.13 %59.3696.11%19 163 SAFECO INS GRP 385,942,189 %84.54 %1.13 %60.4889.93%20 517 HANNOVER GRP 370,023,597 %144.12 %1.08 %61.56153.75%21 474 FCCI MUT INS GRP 352,213,143 %74.46 %1.03 %62.5978.58%22 680 AMERISAFE GRP 341,880,331 %110.22 %1.00 %63.59118.71%23 336 ZENITH NATL INS GRP 317,893,104 %73.99 %0.93 %64.5176.99%24 41190 COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY 316,428,184 %80.17 %0.92 %65.4485.09%25 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 304,639,637 %74.34 %0.89 %66.3277.57%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 34,292,515,066 %80.12 %100.00 %100.0086.20%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,297,431,036 %63.63 %6.79 %6.79n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,838,133,231 %63.42 %5.43 %12.21n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 1,722,650,856 %49.25 %5.09 %17.30n/a4 36102 STATE INSURANCE FUND 1,634,498,840 %92.41 %4.83 %22.13n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners118

Page 127: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,261,329,201 %72.00 %3.73 %25.86n/a6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,141,489,003 %61.28 %3.37 %29.23n/a7 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,096,800,851 %137.34 %3.24 %32.47n/a8 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,096,322,974 %45.94 %3.24 %35.70n/a9 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,051,403,980 %65.86 %3.11 %38.81n/a

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 818,787,328 %52.76 %2.42 %41.23n/a11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 716,920,143 %71.19 %2.12 %43.35n/a12 1 AETNA GRP 709,785,207 %49.74 %2.10 %45.44n/a13 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 675,245,280 %40.13 %1.99 %47.44n/a14 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 572,691,593 %69.33 %1.69 %49.13n/a15 22945 TEXAS MUT INS CO 519,923,191 %60.59 %1.54 %50.66n/a16 159 RELIANCE GRP 462,294,779 %47.43 %1.37 %52.03n/a17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 457,743,708 %51.92 %1.35 %53.38n/a18 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 441,406,080 %63.30 %1.30 %54.68n/a19 623 HEALTH NET INC GRP 395,672,820 %57.60 %1.17 %55.85n/a20 708 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP 363,251,770 %68.52 %1.07 %56.93n/a21 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 345,689,205 %41.85 %1.02 %57.95n/a22 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO 339,606,404 %60.57 %1.00 %58.95n/a23 36714 STATE COMP FUND 334,559,342 %93.52 %0.99 %59.94n/a24 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 332,952,906 %51.90 %0.98 %60.92n/a25 41190 COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY 321,139,048 %85.16 %0.95 %61.87n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 33,857,842,256 %61.17 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,776,167,079 %90.87 %9.84 %9.84n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 3,501,123,873 %98.64 %9.13 %18.97n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 2,740,593,398 %89.27 %7.14 %26.12n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 2,055,082,434 %93.18 %5.36 %31.47n/a5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,956,617,556 %100.66 %5.10 %36.58n/a6 35076 STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND 1,859,194,776 %84.52 %4.85 %41.42n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,667,350,692 %81.65 %4.35 %45.77n/a8 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,539,031,993 %78.89 %4.01 %49.78n/a9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,282,341,025 %73.09 %3.34 %53.12n/a

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,262,890,477 %99.15 %3.29 %56.42n/a11 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 881,386,134 %79.75 %2.30 %58.71n/a12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 830,788,805 %85.11 %2.17 %60.88n/a13 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 726,812,189 %67.85 %1.89 %62.77n/a14 767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP 532,901,420 %73.94 %1.39 %64.16n/a15 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 523,430,336 %94.09 %1.36 %65.53n/a16 164 ST PAUL GRP 515,886,712 %83.08 %1.34 %66.87n/a17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 508,459,620 %71.46 %1.33 %68.20n/a18 1111 TIG INS GRP 465,078,553 %70.47 %1.21 %69.41n/a19 159 RELIANCE GRP 424,767,800 %72.53 %1.11 %70.52n/a20 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 416,989,053 %77.35 %1.09 %71.61n/a21 457 ARGONAUT GRP 347,189,352 %73.30 %0.91 %72.51n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners119

Page 128: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

16 - Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 323,071,314 %73.14 %0.84 %73.35n/a23 41190 COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY 271,934,000 %194.72 %0.71 %74.06n/a24 36196 SAIF CORP 265,410,555 %61.48 %0.69 %74.75n/a25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 263,933,736 %82.34 %0.69 %75.44n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 38,358,252,192 %85.43 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 2,033,099,863 %87.80 %10.24 %10.24n/a2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,830,649,387 %88.48 %9.22 %19.46n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 1,040,753,419 %89.62 %5.24 %24.70n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 967,578,440 %43.63 %4.87 %29.57n/a5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 931,640,258 %80.68 %4.69 %34.26n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 890,494,920 %74.08 %4.48 %38.75n/a7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 839,484,718 %88.00 %4.23 %42.98n/a8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 836,734,370 %86.79 %4.21 %47.19n/a9 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 654,352,208 %97.03 %3.30 %50.49n/a

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 604,987,749 %87.52 %3.05 %53.53n/a11 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 531,492,826 %78.14 %2.68 %56.21n/a12 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 425,837,453 %78.81 %2.14 %58.35n/a13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 328,765,876 %73.64 %1.66 %60.01n/a14 162 ROYAL GRP 301,593,591 %82.79 %1.52 %61.53n/a15 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 275,162,109 %95.50 %1.39 %62.91n/a16 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 271,571,527 %103.90 %1.37 %64.28n/a17 883 TEXAS EMPLOYERS INS ASSOC GRP 249,630,202 %108.12 %1.26 %65.54n/a18 457 ARGONAUT GRP 243,502,489 %91.97 %1.23 %66.77n/a19 15 AMERICAN MUT LIAB GRP 238,179,756 %73.66 %1.20 %67.97n/a20 767 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP 230,276,754 %51.25 %1.16 %69.13n/a21 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 229,738,867 %78.76 %1.16 %70.28n/a22 164 ST PAUL GRP 221,055,363 %105.76 %1.11 %71.40n/a23 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 205,897,318 %67.70 %1.04 %72.43n/a24 196 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY GRP 204,406,922 %105.79 %1.03 %73.46n/a25 133 MISSION EQUITIES GRP 197,800,332 %94.53 %1.00 %74.46n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 19,856,398,387 %83.38 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners120

Page 129: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 6,860,901,304 %77.25 %14.84 %14.8491.05%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,023,365,468 %68.78 %6.54 %21.3875.38%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,935,970,895 %36.28 %6.35 %27.7351.15%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,505,751,831 %37.42 %5.42 %33.1549.17%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,248,616,273 %59.87 %4.86 %38.0163.91%6 218 CNA INS GRP 2,156,404,890 %73.90 %4.66 %42.6793.60%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,860,320,005 %45.39 %4.02 %46.6963.83%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,458,067,267 %64.30 %3.15 %49.8574.73%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,281,593,203 %47.20 %2.77 %52.6256.87%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 904,875,373 %21.50 %1.96 %54.5825.86%11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 825,356,612 %58.68 %1.78 %56.3668.51%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 819,892,974 %28.00 %1.77 %58.1445.07%13 176 STATE FARM GRP 762,032,650 %54.84 %1.65 %59.7858.31%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 760,517,147 %32.36 %1.64 %61.4343.37%15 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 714,434,101 %53.35 %1.55 %62.9766.71%16 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 709,767,126 %62.11 %1.53 %64.5170.17%17 1279 ARCH INS GRP 639,039,153 %48.10 %1.38 %65.8958.25%18 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 567,102,677 %43.72 %1.23 %67.1260.31%19 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 500,857,826 %43.41 %1.08 %68.2050.28%20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 492,347,089 %29.91 %1.06 %69.2637.13%21 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 477,539,287 %44.22 %1.03 %70.3051.32%22 3239 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP 435,702,527 %56.24 %0.94 %71.2469.70%23 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 404,306,368 %40.77 %0.87 %72.1157.72%24 181 SWISS RE GRP 401,311,672 %41.99 %0.87 %72.9875.04%25 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 400,299,040 %38.87 %0.87 %73.8546.87%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 46,239,066,965 %53.17 %100.00 %100.0065.88%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 8,315,785,054 %90.31 %16.83 %16.83108.20%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,503,454,709 %49.49 %7.09 %23.9161.44%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,169,006,692 %29.49 %6.41 %30.3336.92%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,656,882,637 %45.97 %5.38 %35.7068.04%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,281,985,202 %32.37 %4.62 %40.3246.15%6 218 CNA INS GRP 2,204,561,292 %68.60 %4.46 %44.7885.00%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,047,721,449 %41.74 %4.14 %48.9257.43%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,614,519,264 %40.18 %3.27 %52.1952.68%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,311,427,655 %44.91 %2.65 %54.8452.68%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,062,395,594 %20.27 %2.15 %56.9939.90%11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 927,399,954 %41.25 %1.88 %58.8744.88%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 854,951,899 %44.78 %1.73 %60.6056.69%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 838,993,535 %39.91 %1.70 %62.3044.93%14 176 STATE FARM GRP 737,532,190 %67.25 %1.49 %63.7968.93%15 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 664,773,884 %29.14 %1.35 %65.1346.60%16 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 638,333,796 %64.83 %1.29 %66.4369.98%17 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 636,218,016 %39.25 %1.29 %67.7155.08%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners121

Page 130: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 1279 ARCH INS GRP 633,456,103 %62.43 %1.28 %68.9970.56%19 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 543,083,268 %47.06 %1.10 %70.0942.36%20 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 518,619,292 %54.56 %1.05 %71.1460.92%21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 507,548,326 %37.23 %1.03 %72.1740.90%22 181 SWISS RE GRP 453,844,397 %7.25 %0.92 %73.0938.74%23 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 442,847,943 %30.48 %0.90 %73.9835.49%24 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 430,197,022 %37.25 %0.87 %74.8557.19%25 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 417,218,611 %42.86 %0.84 %75.7053.77%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 49,423,238,490 %52.92 %100.00 %100.0066.52%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 11,099,311,596 %54.82 %20.32 %20.3270.02%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,767,810,381 %68.31 %6.90 %27.2199.03%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,304,754,558 %53.44 %6.05 %33.2663.08%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,736,613,128 %47.42 %5.01 %38.2764.87%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,657,011,824 %54.51 %4.86 %43.1460.66%6 218 CNA INS GRP 2,398,373,036 %49.80 %4.39 %47.5367.07%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,912,053,337 %60.77 %3.50 %51.0369.06%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,680,214,473 %45.61 %3.08 %54.1053.35%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,351,678,551 %38.30 %2.47 %56.5847.74%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,140,676,870 %25.69 %2.09 %58.6739.04%11 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 1,002,434,286 %41.34 %1.83 %60.5052.75%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 963,588,348 %48.07 %1.76 %62.2649.01%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 930,775,625 %52.32 %1.70 %63.9765.38%14 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 729,834,199 %46.79 %1.34 %65.3058.35%15 1279 ARCH INS GRP 709,044,782 %47.56 %1.30 %66.6056.06%16 176 STATE FARM GRP 693,916,791 %76.71 %1.27 %67.8778.12%17 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 690,129,705 %22.93 %1.26 %69.1436.09%18 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 613,987,199 %40.61 %1.12 %70.2649.57%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 608,728,729 %62.85 %1.11 %71.3773.95%20 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 544,405,241 %61.68 %1.00 %72.3770.98%21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 536,041,923 %42.91 %0.98 %73.3546.66%22 181 SWISS RE GRP 500,980,288 %104.97 %0.92 %74.27138.48%23 457 ARGONAUT GRP 447,385,891 %48.42 %0.82 %75.0955.76%24 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 440,396,374 %46.45 %0.81 %75.8952.03%25 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 439,733,427 %29.75 %0.80 %76.7037.74%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 54,628,720,800 %50.11 %100.00 %100.0063.45%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 11,082,065,559 %64.58 %19.85 %19.8575.53%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,986,782,309 %70.63 %7.14 %26.9987.69%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners122

Page 131: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,430,162,043 %64.73 %6.14 %33.1382.15%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,878,265,053 %62.89 %5.15 %38.2888.04%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,589,777,806 %42.51 %4.64 %42.9269.19%6 218 CNA INS GRP 2,480,676,471 %32.80 %4.44 %47.3650.60%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,647,370,200 %67.39 %2.95 %50.3183.48%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,619,165,790 %40.70 %2.90 %53.2148.61%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,350,471,204 %37.67 %2.42 %55.6345.75%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,261,196,573 %44.32 %2.26 %57.8957.84%11 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 1,103,474,843 %44.30 %1.98 %59.8757.34%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,026,363,513 %53.24 %1.84 %61.7066.14%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 963,081,946 %40.15 %1.72 %63.4347.33%14 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 797,386,989 %29.20 %1.43 %64.8645.86%15 1279 ARCH INS GRP 755,394,557 %39.66 %1.35 %66.2149.31%16 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 733,386,330 %51.71 %1.31 %67.5265.57%17 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 682,590,718 %35.85 %1.22 %68.7549.33%18 176 STATE FARM GRP 639,971,943 %52.19 %1.15 %69.8953.21%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 610,054,443 %56.18 %1.09 %70.9865.02%20 181 SWISS RE GRP 607,283,738 %46.33 %1.09 %72.0767.39%21 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 550,457,987 %40.92 %0.99 %73.0648.41%22 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 535,984,653 %33.83 %0.96 %74.0239.62%23 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 459,029,332 %13.51 %0.82 %74.8423.56%24 457 ARGONAUT GRP 444,885,728 %33.26 %0.80 %75.6455.78%25 783 RLI INS GRP 386,416,820 %39.74 %0.69 %76.3351.93%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 55,839,957,721 %51.45 %100.00 %100.0065.68%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 10,763,421,537 %85.19 %19.91 %19.9198.77%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,087,999,115 %77.77 %7.56 %27.4796.67%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,462,256,412 %78.49 %6.40 %33.8791.68%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,973,915,057 %55.59 %5.50 %39.3777.83%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,449,809,310 %74.88 %4.53 %43.9087.13%6 218 CNA INS GRP 2,402,789,169 %40.54 %4.44 %48.3564.93%7 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,491,117,819 %55.56 %2.76 %51.1060.19%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,457,450,974 %84.75 %2.70 %53.80136.49%9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,294,789,770 %33.35 %2.39 %56.1945.98%

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,237,268,745 %38.61 %2.29 %58.4850.75%11 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 1,144,860,045 %33.80 %2.12 %60.6056.27%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 998,402,606 %66.09 %1.85 %62.4593.59%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 928,594,954 %62.80 %1.72 %64.1687.80%14 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 910,455,819 %51.79 %1.68 %65.8563.11%15 1279 ARCH INS GRP 773,950,941 %40.69 %1.43 %67.2846.74%16 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 634,484,211 %41.00 %1.17 %68.4551.48%17 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 624,964,879 %52.10 %1.16 %69.6157.10%18 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 618,995,697 %58.03 %1.14 %70.7569.78%19 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 615,569,730 %60.09 %1.14 %71.8971.82%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners123

Page 132: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 176 STATE FARM GRP 608,766,370 %65.86 %1.13 %73.0269.41%21 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 597,615,729 %92.23 %1.11 %74.12122.37%22 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 516,599,384 %29.09 %0.96 %75.0837.39%23 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 452,550,098 %75.60 %0.84 %75.91100.00%24 783 RLI INS GRP 385,177,619 %50.78 %0.71 %76.6361.07%25 457 ARGONAUT GRP 355,007,624 %40.45 %0.66 %77.2851.46%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 54,069,317,472 %64.11 %100.00 %100.0080.29%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 5,337,266,988 %89.97 %20.68 %20.6894.23%2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,811,538,507 %35.60 %7.02 %27.6952.65%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,761,711,912 %63.47 %6.82 %34.5278.73%4 218 CNA INS GRP 1,137,045,733 %72.10 %4.40 %38.9291.53%5 164 ST PAUL GRP 1,024,163,945 %39.68 %3.97 %42.8955.01%6 41 CITIGROUP GRP 818,809,222 %91.60 %3.17 %46.06100.89%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 772,199,296 %63.34 %2.99 %49.0588.31%8 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 686,475,764 %95.92 %2.66 %51.71112.19%9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 657,565,148 %76.51 %2.55 %54.2693.32%

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 653,879,202 %81.49 %2.53 %56.7972.26%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 606,715,480 %73.31 %2.35 %59.1597.00%12 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 520,671,823 %101.62 %2.02 %61.16126.21%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 504,079,623 %52.28 %1.95 %63.1176.23%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 501,415,111 %47.65 %1.94 %65.0656.69%15 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 427,375,685 %78.62 %1.66 %66.7190.43%16 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 425,325,821 %122.18 %1.65 %68.36161.99%17 176 STATE FARM GRP 416,004,417 %83.16 %1.61 %69.9784.92%18 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 390,421,310 %84.63 %1.51 %71.48114.62%19 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 285,612,871 %50.73 %1.11 %72.5963.04%20 1285 XL AMER GRP 281,205,098 %50.38 %1.09 %73.6861.76%21 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 275,109,952 %62.51 %1.07 %74.7566.30%22 163 SAFECO INS GRP 237,725,822 %57.16 %0.92 %75.6775.96%23 1172 LEGION INS GRP 227,366,961 %35.05 %0.88 %76.5549.28%24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 221,195,267 %89.25 %0.86 %77.4197.33%25 44 AVIVA GRP 216,150,764 %188.82 %0.84 %78.24224.69%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 25,813,408,612 %72.03 %100.00 %100.0085.28%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,655,039,625 %63.14 %20.52 %20.52n/a2 218 CNA INS GRP 1,454,271,284 %110.49 %6.41 %26.93n/a3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 1,221,891,734 %50.27 %5.39 %32.31n/a4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,004,602,745 %87.34 %4.43 %36.74n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners124

Page 133: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 1 AETNA GRP 914,478,195 %121.99 %4.03 %40.77n/a6 159 RELIANCE GRP 826,243,555 %40.45 %3.64 %44.42n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 680,353,164 %120.32 %3.00 %47.41n/a8 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 597,222,167 %119.47 %2.63 %50.05n/a9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 576,915,557 %112.53 %2.54 %52.59n/a

10 41 CITIGROUP GRP 575,514,487 %73.54 %2.54 %55.13n/a11 164 ST PAUL GRP 544,284,141 %52.91 %2.40 %57.53n/a12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 442,998,346 %33.48 %1.95 %59.48n/a13 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 414,137,196 %147.65 %1.83 %61.30n/a14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 406,523,025 %50.23 %1.79 %63.10n/a15 176 STATE FARM GRP 347,036,167 %62.67 %1.53 %64.63n/a16 80 GENERAL REIN CP 286,388,468 %54.99 %1.26 %65.89n/a17 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 276,548,107 %127.20 %1.22 %67.11n/a18 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 227,422,697 %30.87 %1.00 %68.11n/a19 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 225,343,686 %70.08 %0.99 %69.10n/a20 1111 TIG INS GRP 209,395,124 %99.65 %0.92 %70.02n/a21 162 ROYAL GRP 202,325,077 %48.81 %0.89 %70.92n/a22 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 168,363,316 %34.73 %0.74 %71.66n/a23 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 164,077,770 %72.88 %0.72 %72.38n/a24 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 154,114,570 %57.55 %0.68 %73.06n/a25 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 132,648,338 %33.30 %0.58 %73.65n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 22,687,054,426 %74.14 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,353,399,825 %66.81 %18.79 %18.79n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,685,076,972 %52.43 %7.27 %26.06n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 1,412,765,074 %84.23 %6.10 %32.16n/a4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,161,119,772 %55.72 %5.01 %37.17n/a5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 994,414,974 %57.94 %4.29 %41.47n/a6 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 982,126,630 %105.05 %4.24 %45.71n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 808,387,088 %76.30 %3.49 %49.19n/a8 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 603,075,714 %55.34 %2.60 %51.80n/a9 164 ST PAUL GRP 577,523,190 %46.88 %2.49 %54.29n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 577,298,637 %65.53 %2.49 %56.78n/a11 159 RELIANCE GRP 577,291,047 %58.91 %2.49 %59.27n/a12 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 576,269,362 %87.98 %2.49 %61.76n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 558,577,362 %100.19 %2.41 %64.17n/a14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 494,925,676 %74.11 %2.14 %66.31n/a15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 310,319,259 %41.11 %1.34 %67.65n/a16 1111 TIG INS GRP 243,225,419 %60.86 %1.05 %68.70n/a17 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 229,097,207 %74.62 %0.99 %69.69n/a18 162 ROYAL GRP 223,738,116 %44.55 %0.97 %70.65n/a19 80 GENERAL REIN CP 189,875,530 %51.24 %0.82 %71.47n/a20 176 STATE FARM GRP 174,487,685 %105.23 %0.75 %72.22n/a21 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 168,262,534 %26.37 %0.73 %72.95n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners125

Page 134: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.1, 17.2 - Other Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 167,252,054 %79.36 %0.72 %73.67n/a23 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 163,203,485 %37.97 %0.70 %74.38n/a24 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 163,181,496 %46.86 %0.70 %75.08n/a25 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 154,822,255 %72.00 %0.67 %75.75n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 23,167,872,750 %63.87 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,724,046,515 %94.10 %11.17 %11.17n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,151,367,566 %91.40 %7.46 %18.63n/a3 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 938,565,453 %156.33 %6.08 %24.71n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 832,973,735 %98.59 %5.40 %30.10n/a5 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 791,803,713 %212.32 %5.13 %35.23n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 686,061,577 %86.36 %4.44 %39.68n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 652,099,763 %121.64 %4.22 %43.90n/a8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 574,275,705 %121.30 %3.72 %47.62n/a9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 491,457,481 %95.65 %3.18 %50.80n/a

10 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 442,355,656 %77.33 %2.87 %53.67n/a11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 425,979,138 %56.88 %2.76 %56.43n/a12 164 ST PAUL GRP 386,310,450 %74.28 %2.50 %58.93n/a13 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 382,386,023 %78.93 %2.48 %61.41n/a14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 367,804,561 %92.67 %2.38 %63.79n/a15 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 286,353,973 %74.94 %1.85 %65.65n/a16 133 MISSION EQUITIES GRP 162,615,078 %502.72 %1.05 %66.70n/a17 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 153,370,668 %135.38 %0.99 %67.69n/a18 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 143,372,901 %92.09 %0.93 %68.62n/a19 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 139,210,039 %164.03 %0.90 %69.52n/a20 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 138,249,814 %67.41 %0.90 %70.42n/a21 162 ROYAL GRP 134,262,606 %86.85 %0.87 %71.29n/a22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 116,043,897 %163.98 %0.75 %72.04n/a23 176 STATE FARM GRP 115,195,450 %99.57 %0.75 %72.79n/a24 784 NAC RE CORP 108,558,790 %119.65 %0.70 %73.49n/a25 80 GENERAL REIN CP 108,225,888 %83.53 %0.70 %74.19n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 15,437,050,301 %110.83 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners126

Page 135: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.3 - Excess Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 274,321,527 %77.34 %29.98 %29.9877.92%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 110,047,971 %49.89 %12.03 %42.0051.50%3 626 ACE LTD GRP 108,815,584 %40.56 %11.89 %53.8956.06%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 76,917,328 %98.92 %8.41 %62.30104.80%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 42,686,186 %77.90 %4.66 %66.9683.58%6 1346 AMERICAN SAFETY HOLDING GRP 42,359,194 %1.45 %4.63 %71.592.56%7 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 37,848,874 %46.34 %4.14 %75.7347.31%8 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 34,865,195 %46.45 %3.81 %79.5452.16%9 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 32,793,504 %38.03 %3.58 %83.1244.42%

10 1208 GRAY INS GRP 32,300,849 %50.98 %3.53 %86.6554.26%11 1279 ARCH INS GRP 30,648,110 %72.54 %3.35 %90.0074.91%12 748 MEADOWBROOK INS GRP 29,426,799 %50.88 %3.22 %93.2266.79%13 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 14,533,423 %324.59 %1.59 %94.80336.20%14 1285 XL AMER GRP 9,344,348 %95.99 %1.02 %95.83102.47%15 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 6,239,648 %-2.44 %0.68 %96.51-1.79%16 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 4,629,425 %22.27 %0.51 %97.0119.79%17 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 3,856,440 %339.08 %0.42 %97.43339.08%18 361 MUNICH RE GRP 3,739,433 %90.81 %0.41 %97.8493.15%19 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 3,265,716 %2,369.61 %0.36 %98.202,635.64%20 867 BALDWIN & LYONS GRP 3,024,409 %-156.07 %0.33 %98.53-160.57%21 40134 CASTLEPOINT NATL INS CO 2,781,126 %-22.83 %0.30 %98.833.05%22 11118 FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS EXCH 2,398,333 %44.89 %0.26 %99.1044.89%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 2,175,891 %69.49 %0.24 %99.3383.68%24 181 SWISS RE GRP 1,575,594 %8,880.55 %0.17 %99.5110,437.94%25 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 1,424,766 %65.82 %0.16 %99.6666.69%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 915,107,893 %56.67 %100.00 %100.0060. .17%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 258,131,640 %79.41 %21.77 %21.7779.60%2 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 209,945,769 %98.52 %17.70 %39.4798.97%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 137,561,188 %58.60 %11.60 %51.0760.65%4 626 ACE LTD GRP 132,621,806 %34.23 %11.18 %62.2540.00%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 117,136,896 %82.97 %9.88 %72.1388.48%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 56,682,545 %509.60 %4.78 %76.91571.82%7 1208 GRAY INS GRP 41,644,611 %57.21 %3.51 %80.4260.71%8 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 38,327,433 %68.04 %3.23 %83.6568.04%9 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 35,235,186 %55.75 %2.97 %86.6261.43%

10 1279 ARCH INS GRP 32,963,638 %63.48 %2.78 %89.4064.72%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 30,126,121 %548.83 %2.54 %91.94590.74%12 748 MEADOWBROOK INS GRP 27,572,531 %40.94 %2.33 %94.2758.62%13 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 11,824,777 %14.03 %1.00 %95.27-11.16%14 1285 XL AMER GRP 10,188,514 %380.60 %0.86 %96.13418.48%15 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 7,039,739 %94.31 %0.59 %96.72100.27%16 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 6,520,194 %24.80 %0.55 %97.2727.75%17 572 BCBS OF MI GRP 4,122,480 %121.41 %0.35 %97.62121.41%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners127

Page 136: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

17.3 - Excess Workers' Compensation

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 867 BALDWIN & LYONS GRP 3,915,600 %207.75 %0.33 %97.95213.62%19 169 SENTRY INS GRP 3,165,028 %89.69 %0.27 %98.21103.20%20 361 MUNICH RE GRP 2,946,231 %20.98 %0.25 %98.4622.61%21 40134 CASTLEPOINT NATL INS CO 2,584,577 %49.45 %0.22 %98.6820.32%22 796 QBE INS GRP 2,566,353 %168.90 %0.22 %98.90183.18%23 11118 FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS EXCH 2,385,188 %13.74 %0.20 %99.1013.74%24 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 1,953,706 %432.82 %0.16 %99.26446.85%25 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 1,654,438 %49.01 %0.14 %99.4048.71%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,185,911,991 %94.03 %100.00 %100.0093.88%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners128

Page 137: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

18 - Products Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 261,913,096 %36.10 %9.14 %9.1448.31%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 223,049,499 %72.61 %7.79 %16.93193.38%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 207,425,256 %5.81 %7.24 %24.1744.47%4 218 CNA INS GRP 177,525,490 %59.77 %6.20 %30.3790.44%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 153,829,371 %57.93 %5.37 %35.7471.95%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 135,964,406 %121.61 %4.75 %40.49211.05%7 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO 119,746,338 %51.47 %4.18 %44.6765.16%8 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 117,173,404 %47.64 %4.09 %48.7681.41%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 99,847,312 %-77.96 %3.49 %52.25-156.01%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 78,973,656 %9.88 %2.76 %55.01196.24%11 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 75,871,117 %51.90 %2.65 %57.6570.41%12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 74,777,576 %181.99 %2.61 %60.27243.12%13 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 73,290,040 %8.88 %2.56 %62.8224.22%14 457 ARGONAUT GRP 71,351,513 %47.12 %2.49 %65.3263.86%15 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 66,345,871 %61.61 %2.32 %67.6384.15%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 59,916,005 %36.70 %2.09 %69.7262.50%17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 53,778,184 %38.28 %1.88 %71.6058.64%18 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 53,618,530 %25.97 %1.87 %73.47101.92%19 1285 XL AMER GRP 42,681,226 %131.65 %1.49 %74.96203.84%20 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 35,851,355 %39.54 %1.25 %76.2260.60%21 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 35,134,705 %88.88 %1.23 %77.44144.28%22 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 33,518,184 %1.80 %1.17 %78.6132.49%23 3617 FIRST MERCURY FIN GRP 30,193,487 %31.01 %1.05 %79.6725.09%24 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 27,237,501 %5.67 %0.95 %80.6210.16%25 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 26,927,902 %15.79 %0.94 %81.5619.16%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,864,171,938 %39.80 %100.00 %100.0082.14%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 287,619,931 %26.40 %8.60 %8.6050.85%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 243,729,241 %107.69 %7.29 %15.89135.01%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 226,519,080 %44.86 %6.77 %22.6693.61%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 216,205,334 %145.84 %6.46 %29.12262.59%5 218 CNA INS GRP 187,761,124 %37.53 %5.61 %34.7358.02%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 173,074,450 %37.02 %5.17 %39.9183.34%7 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 171,949,206 %27.69 %5.14 %45.0540.30%8 626 ACE LTD GRP 162,219,114 %352.80 %4.85 %49.90453.84%9 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 96,579,791 %17.48 %2.89 %52.7928.61%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 94,340,597 %31.79 %2.82 %55.6174.08%11 57 ELECTRIC INS GRP 94,012,853 %77.27 %2.81 %58.4294.61%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 91,581,910 %208.63 %2.74 %61.15174.74%13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 90,355,246 %21.54 %2.70 %63.8655.05%14 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 78,597,380 %63.79 %2.35 %66.2184.19%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 77,171,115 %24.31 %2.31 %68.5151.08%16 457 ARGONAUT GRP 73,080,224 %41.68 %2.18 %70.7056.53%17 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 60,981,916 %62.72 %1.82 %72.5290.79%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners129

Page 138: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

18 - Products Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 60,290,993 %-5.19 %1.80 %74.321.51%19 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 51,306,136 %41.70 %1.53 %75.8652.96%20 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 45,343,331 %24.45 %1.36 %77.2192.13%21 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 42,839,824 %70.70 %1.28 %78.49114.98%22 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 35,802,064 %15.90 %1.07 %79.5619.66%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 34,867,052 %80.48 %1.04 %80.61112.51%24 3219 SOMPO JAPAN INS GRP 32,841,656 %45.46 %0.98 %81.5982.39%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 32,153,553 %-15.50 %0.96 %82.55-22.92%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,344,963,443 %70.85 %100.00 %100.00109.97%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 502,923,951 %44.29 %12.43 %12.4382.89%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 324,656,041 %17.60 %8.02 %20.45100.77%3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 301,997,010 %50.68 %7.46 %27.9194.50%4 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 228,445,844 %33.03 %5.64 %33.5549.23%5 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 213,468,250 %15.33 %5.27 %38.8326.39%6 626 ACE LTD GRP 210,693,193 %63.97 %5.21 %44.03127.61%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 169,879,217 %62.73 %4.20 %48.2392.18%8 218 CNA INS GRP 152,879,723 %41.27 %3.78 %52.0150.36%9 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 122,885,893 %33.16 %3.04 %55.0433.01%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 108,774,947 %18.95 %2.69 %57.7328.73%11 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 107,307,295 %46.64 %2.65 %60.3872.43%12 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 102,106,438 %-100.42 %2.52 %62.91-121.66%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 100,481,722 %-21.81 %2.48 %65.3921.56%14 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 83,498,108 %53.38 %2.06 %67.4574.14%15 457 ARGONAUT GRP 77,356,162 %31.59 %1.91 %69.3647.05%16 57 ELECTRIC INS GRP 74,913,708 %81.46 %1.85 %71.21127.06%17 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 69,183,826 %60.01 %1.71 %72.9270.63%18 1279 ARCH INS GRP 68,199,212 %38.77 %1.69 %74.6140.18%19 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 67,582,201 %50.27 %1.67 %76.2870.09%20 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 61,991,306 %-10.14 %1.53 %77.81-9.93%21 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 57,764,890 %85.84 %1.43 %79.24140.59%22 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 56,805,870 %22.88 %1.40 %80.6446.30%23 1285 XL AMER GRP 51,211,777 %47.19 %1.27 %81.9096.05%24 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 44,818,208 %21.09 %1.11 %83.0130.40%25 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 41,930,354 %13.56 %1.04 %84.0516.94%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,047,399,455 %38.99 %100.00 %100.0072.54%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 590,001,293 %47.77 %13.04 %13.0484.90%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 432,228,339 %70.82 %9.55 %22.59102.12%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners130

Page 139: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

18 - Products Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 626 ACE LTD GRP 328,188,249 %69.32 %7.25 %29.85122.73%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 308,439,210 %-93.40 %6.82 %36.67-70.26%5 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 258,295,932 %29.13 %5.71 %42.3855.64%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 203,360,873 %-155.69 %4.49 %46.87-197.28%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 178,510,589 %-74.36 %3.95 %50.82-17.48%8 218 CNA INS GRP 168,259,986 %81.51 %3.72 %54.54110.50%9 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 139,737,158 %31.46 %3.09 %57.6243.34%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 131,194,291 %18.34 %2.90 %60.5234.51%11 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 123,032,715 %40.16 %2.72 %63.2468.74%12 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 102,504,570 %11.36 %2.27 %65.5122.90%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 99,877,118 %117.07 %2.21 %67.72143.07%14 1279 ARCH INS GRP 80,453,278 %41.05 %1.78 %69.4946.03%15 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 79,151,249 %48.05 %1.75 %71.2468.53%16 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 78,650,847 %61.21 %1.74 %72.9889.75%17 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 77,436,562 %-40.30 %1.71 %74.69-214.54%18 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 77,200,002 %83.42 %1.71 %76.40130.46%19 457 ARGONAUT GRP 77,177,016 %37.11 %1.71 %78.1153.63%20 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 73,823,946 %64.87 %1.63 %79.7487.37%21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 58,402,067 %11.31 %1.29 %81.0333.36%22 57 ELECTRIC INS GRP 49,529,578 %66.12 %1.09 %82.1282.75%23 1285 XL AMER GRP 46,551,153 %-1.37 %1.03 %83.1538.20%24 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 46,259,766 %21.46 %1.02 %84.1826.56%25 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 42,124,894 %23.10 %0.93 %85.1137.94%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,524,196,445 %31.14 %100.00 %100.0056.80%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 555,402,303 %81.16 %12.39 %12.39105.75%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 514,033,766 %71.84 %11.47 %23.86111.31%3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 297,563,847 %88.30 %6.64 %30.50130.87%4 626 ACE LTD GRP 294,463,370 %63.55 %6.57 %37.07127.82%5 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 271,914,974 %26.28 %6.07 %43.1349.57%6 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 231,082,534 %-28.51 %5.16 %48.29105.56%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 198,369,473 %-9.72 %4.43 %52.7278.54%8 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 157,065,613 %39.58 %3.50 %56.2255.13%9 218 CNA INS GRP 149,099,128 %35.88 %3.33 %59.5578.31%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 123,361,097 %25.21 %2.75 %62.3039.92%11 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 117,752,285 %-3.36 %2.63 %64.93-1.07%12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 110,909,248 %19.66 %2.47 %67.4031.81%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 105,432,873 %353.30 %2.35 %69.75521.52%14 57 ELECTRIC INS GRP 81,165,908 %88.09 %1.81 %71.5699.81%15 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 80,975,993 %46.51 %1.81 %73.3769.03%16 1279 ARCH INS GRP 78,918,930 %71.01 %1.76 %75.1379.19%17 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 70,382,988 %41.04 %1.57 %76.7062.25%18 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 62,997,669 %69.31 %1.41 %78.1194.91%19 457 ARGONAUT GRP 59,775,388 %43.88 %1.33 %79.4456.90%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners131

Page 140: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

18 - Products Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 58,908,354 %56.16 %1.31 %80.7588.32%21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 55,534,022 %24.09 %1.24 %81.9971.35%22 1285 XL AMER GRP 53,065,235 %69.11 %1.18 %83.18136.19%23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 48,408,248 %45.56 %1.08 %84.26131.82%24 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 46,883,419 %34.81 %1.05 %85.3046.57%25 169 SENTRY INS GRP 41,009,856 %133.53 %0.91 %86.22162.47%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,482,184,285 %59.71 %100.00 %100.00107.84%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 209,096,250 %34.21 %10.86 %10.8651.74%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 187,999,524 %132.94 %9.76 %20.62167.29%3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 146,498,465 %153.94 %7.61 %28.23199.21%4 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 126,673,638 %242.61 %6.58 %34.81244.80%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 91,999,373 %119.93 %4.78 %39.59165.22%6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 80,299,743 %228.38 %4.17 %43.76323.57%7 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 55,228,205 %91.81 %2.87 %46.62140.49%8 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 54,005,927 %66.77 %2.80 %49.4381.12%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 53,196,895 %148.05 %2.76 %52.19212.99%

10 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 49,099,004 %163.07 %2.55 %54.74139.85%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 47,106,504 %59.74 %2.45 %57.1991.85%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 46,286,712 %18.15 %2.40 %59.5936.62%13 218 CNA INS GRP 43,623,977 %167.31 %2.27 %61.86233.66%14 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 41,416,092 %41.45 %2.15 %64.0160.43%15 33499 DORINCO REIN CO 38,430,000 %104.75 %2.00 %66.00104.26%16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 38,052,952 %140.47 %1.98 %67.98220.07%17 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 37,473,933 %89.95 %1.95 %69.93104.14%18 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 31,886,726 %38.56 %1.66 %71.5855.46%19 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 30,141,038 %-6.33 %1.57 %73.157.14%20 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 29,705,079 %76.24 %1.54 %74.6999.17%21 41 CITIGROUP GRP 29,406,860 %-52.92 %1.53 %76.2246.57%22 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 28,910,590 %21.90 %1.50 %77.7225.67%23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 27,903,817 %3.74 %1.45 %79.1725.66%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 26,359,218 %66.05 %1.37 %80.5489.65%25 169 SENTRY INS GRP 23,551,092 %69.22 %1.22 %81.7691.58%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,925,614,543 %99.02 %100.00 %100.00127.95%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 244,477,169 %73.30 %10.84 %10.84n/a2 164 ST PAUL GRP 188,043,827 %43.98 %8.34 %19.18n/a3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 182,391,637 %147.47 %8.09 %27.28n/a4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 164,521,386 %378.42 %7.30 %34.57n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners132

Page 141: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

18 - Products Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 41 CITIGROUP GRP 121,401,005 %34.83 %5.38 %39.96n/a6 218 CNA INS GRP 114,526,004 %119.08 %5.08 %45.04n/a7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 91,707,734 %85.86 %4.07 %49.11n/a8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 79,563,458 %284.80 %3.53 %52.63n/a9 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 78,799,585 %101.69 %3.50 %56.13n/a

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 60,636,962 %83.13 %2.69 %58.82n/a11 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 60,439,225 %-5.42 %2.68 %61.50n/a12 162 ROYAL GRP 56,883,720 %104.84 %2.52 %64.02n/a13 159 RELIANCE GRP 56,122,136 %39.76 %2.49 %66.51n/a14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 36,751,065 %162.04 %1.63 %68.14n/a15 1111 TIG INS GRP 35,283,272 %106.86 %1.57 %69.71n/a16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 31,612,700 %27.72 %1.40 %71.11n/a17 785 MARKEL CORP GRP 31,326,919 %83.42 %1.39 %72.50n/a18 80 GENERAL REIN CP 29,491,405 %23.18 %1.31 %73.81n/a19 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 29,141,582 %28.60 %1.29 %75.10n/a20 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 27,436,810 %1,280.08 %1.22 %76.32n/a21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 24,244,925 %75.50 %1.08 %77.39n/a22 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 23,431,655 %-52.96 %1.04 %78.43n/a23 1 AETNA GRP 21,805,524 %930.45 %0.97 %79.40n/a24 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 20,925,737 %82.67 %0.93 %80.33n/a25 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 20,646,828 %16.00 %0.92 %81.24n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,254,484,185 %143.60 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners133

Page 142: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 18,444,685,625 %79.21 %18.76 %18.7684.53%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 9,858,846,559 %67.28 %10.03 %28.7871.77%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 8,414,544,523 %72.34 %8.56 %37.3476.88%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 7,683,348,699 %66.46 %7.81 %45.1568.71%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 6,301,549,005 %56.33 %6.41 %51.5659.77%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,520,320,273 %68.57 %4.60 %56.1670.89%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,285,819,736 %60.17 %4.36 %60.5263.37%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,692,312,404 %70.34 %3.75 %64.2773.68%9 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,130,665,693 %58.55 %2.17 %66.4463.99%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,871,906,342 %64.62 %1.90 %68.3469.82%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,685,867,654 %69.25 %1.71 %70.0571.96%12 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,254,316,425 %50.57 %1.28 %71.3359.14%13 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,169,438,607 %63.95 %1.19 %72.5266.81%14 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,100,116,016 %51.29 %1.12 %73.6454.72%15 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,093,552,007 %69.94 %1.11 %74.7573.21%16 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 954,523,577 %62.38 %0.97 %75.7265.32%17 215 UNITRIN GRP 868,785,929 %66.71 %0.88 %76.6069.84%18 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 806,374,527 %63.48 %0.82 %77.4267.76%19 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 747,711,074 %135.65 %0.76 %78.18140.21%20 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 730,413,525 %63.20 %0.74 %78.9364.62%21 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 691,022,050 %71.23 %0.70 %79.6376.52%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 681,893,595 %57.72 %0.69 %80.3259.84%23 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 680,065,215 %78.44 %0.69 %81.0281.28%24 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 651,743,090 %121.42 %0.66 %81.68126.97%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 607,285,460 %74.17 %0.62 %82.3077.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 98,337,355,206 %69.04 %100.00 %100.0073.03%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 17,762,125,297 %73.61 %18.29 %18.2978.25%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 9,925,640,770 %61.89 %10.22 %28.5166.30%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 7,750,908,587 %68.39 %7.98 %36.4972.32%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 7,160,220,561 %61.99 %7.37 %43.8664.09%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 5,301,902,153 %59.67 %5.46 %49.3262.64%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,603,672,203 %62.61 %4.74 %54.0664.69%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,302,423,149 %67.91 %4.43 %58.4969.58%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,384,979,085 %75.33 %3.49 %61.9777.97%9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,682,404,781 %72.53 %2.76 %64.7476.26%

10 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,128,378,006 %58.68 %2.19 %66.9362.51%11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,943,851,966 %67.86 %2.00 %68.9372.31%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,649,685,386 %64.70 %1.70 %70.6366.63%13 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,386,843,657 %55.84 %1.43 %72.0663.78%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,209,292,215 %52.62 %1.25 %73.3055.19%15 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,117,642,749 %55.36 %1.15 %74.4557.69%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,102,266,038 %51.55 %1.13 %75.5953.60%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 968,149,215 %54.65 %1.00 %76.5857.75%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners134

Page 143: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 859,460,879 %55.86 %0.88 %77.4759.14%19 215 UNITRIN GRP 830,177,409 %62.65 %0.85 %78.3265.96%20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 799,964,962 %75.17 %0.82 %79.1578.19%21 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 732,273,098 %62.88 %0.75 %79.9069.22%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 686,416,312 %85.24 %0.71 %80.6190.50%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 684,359,498 %56.25 %0.70 %81.3157.79%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 636,450,798 %70.54 %0.66 %81.9773.57%25 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 586,537,292 %64.83 %0.60 %82.5767.12%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 97,124,001,028 %65.84 %100.00 %100.0069.48%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 17,334,848,348 %68.45 %17.82 %17.8273.19%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 10,246,109,410 %59.56 %10.53 %28.3564.21%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 7,273,331,942 %65.00 %7.48 %35.8368.18%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 7,193,304,238 %59.76 %7.39 %43.2262.24%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 5,287,715,615 %63.47 %5.44 %48.6665.27%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,686,461,886 %61.64 %4.82 %53.4764.11%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,237,612,046 %76.78 %3.33 %56.8080.05%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,949,948,278 %68.32 %3.03 %59.8370.56%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,723,795,464 %59.04 %2.80 %62.6360.36%

10 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,105,714,581 %55.90 %2.16 %64.8057.99%11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 2,044,625,578 %67.92 %2.10 %66.9072.73%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,660,052,481 %71.42 %1.71 %68.6073.63%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,552,843,555 %65.15 %1.60 %70.2068.41%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,518,989,213 %52.72 %1.56 %71.7657.68%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,229,272,960 %54.76 %1.26 %73.0358.54%16 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,133,063,713 %58.91 %1.16 %74.1961.82%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,103,479,851 %49.95 %1.13 %75.3252.43%18 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,021,784,837 %58.87 %1.05 %76.3863.84%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 950,066,266 %55.47 %0.98 %77.3558.92%20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 861,779,720 %60.50 %0.89 %78.2463.46%21 215 UNITRIN GRP 759,055,057 %65.38 %0.78 %79.0267.62%22 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 708,196,623 %57.99 %0.73 %79.7563.16%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 681,015,821 %53.22 %0.70 %80.4554.51%24 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 667,279,775 %91.12 %0.69 %81.1396.18%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 654,925,575 %62.20 %0.67 %81.8066.19%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 97,286,773,489 %63.76 %100.00 %100.0067.34%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 17,524,298,022 %58.93 %17.96 %17.9664.04%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 10,366,531,550 %54.12 %10.62 %28.5958.08%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners135

Page 144: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 7,478,868,534 %52.32 %7.67 %36.2554.96%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,995,976,439 %62.21 %7.17 %43.4264.72%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,687,288,591 %63.57 %4.80 %48.2266.25%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,685,151,046 %53.86 %4.80 %53.0356.17%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,194,629,055 %74.76 %3.27 %56.3077.69%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 3,015,452,783 %62.63 %3.09 %59.3963.69%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,505,668,510 %55.67 %2.57 %61.9661.24%

10 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,190,610,532 %52.86 %2.25 %64.2055.85%11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 2,015,186,080 %67.62 %2.07 %66.2774.63%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,627,291,629 %62.65 %1.67 %67.9464.75%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,599,832,291 %53.47 %1.64 %69.5857.64%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,516,994,115 %56.67 %1.55 %71.1362.69%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,233,708,591 %51.43 %1.26 %72.4054.77%16 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,141,138,971 %55.91 %1.17 %73.5759.21%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,096,762,526 %62.43 %1.12 %74.6964.60%18 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,008,211,365 %56.96 %1.03 %75.7262.17%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 964,143,823 %50.05 %0.99 %76.7151.91%20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 939,787,288 %72.63 %0.96 %77.6776.24%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 710,571,438 %58.35 %0.73 %78.4059.19%22 215 UNITRIN GRP 708,076,520 %61.77 %0.73 %79.1365.22%23 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 705,046,015 %58.18 %0.72 %79.8563.47%24 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 680,425,009 %75.08 %0.70 %80.5578.47%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 640,270,504 %71.05 %0.66 %81.2073.67%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 97,570,413,048 %59.39 %100.00 %100.0063.12%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 17,456,990,267 %61.27 %17.97 %17.9765.35%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 10,371,624,245 %59.52 %10.68 %28.6563.07%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 7,507,114,177 %51.11 %7.73 %36.3854.11%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,442,984,228 %62.76 %6.63 %43.0165.21%5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,651,500,224 %71.93 %4.79 %47.8074.74%6 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,537,586,992 %66.24 %4.67 %52.4770.46%7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 3,131,402,851 %57.19 %3.22 %55.7061.14%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,090,640,733 %71.77 %3.18 %58.8875.70%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,532,203,644 %59.94 %2.61 %61.4966.51%

10 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,090,090,219 %53.90 %2.15 %63.6457.03%11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,968,805,303 %65.47 %2.03 %65.6669.64%12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,683,141,646 %63.25 %1.73 %67.4067.57%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,647,359,894 %63.35 %1.70 %69.0962.79%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,494,880,586 %51.71 %1.54 %70.6357.04%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,257,431,605 %57.11 %1.29 %71.9361.94%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,130,377,377 %74.59 %1.16 %73.0978.04%17 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,025,374,019 %49.54 %1.06 %74.1552.68%18 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,001,386,441 %50.70 %1.03 %75.1855.27%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 991,716,610 %51.57 %1.02 %76.2054.95%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners136

Page 145: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 905,300,775 %67.62 %0.93 %77.1370.32%21 215 UNITRIN GRP 744,372,171 %62.35 %0.77 %77.9066.29%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 712,348,818 %75.91 %0.73 %78.6380.33%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 675,439,924 %65.72 %0.70 %79.3368.64%24 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 627,732,305 %112.91 %0.65 %79.97116.97%25 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 625,660,371 %52.88 %0.64 %80.6260.28%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 97,132,105,825 %62.17 %100.00 %100.0066.01%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,609,463,865 %78.08 %17.79 %17.7984.20%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,977,830,761 %71.34 %11.25 %29.0478.90%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,001,203,279 %73.55 %5.64 %34.6876.75%4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 3,448,219,963 %71.27 %4.86 %39.5474.86%5 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 3,422,918,720 %75.21 %4.83 %44.3778.97%6 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 3,414,075,263 %84.31 %4.82 %49.1987.36%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,192,354,901 %80.56 %3.09 %52.2885.39%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,061,064,340 %71.23 %2.91 %55.1974.33%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,719,814,484 %73.48 %2.43 %57.6179.34%

10 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,456,762,750 %78.84 %2.05 %59.6782.17%11 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,330,827,673 %68.27 %1.88 %61.5473.53%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,181,107,376 %67.86 %1.67 %63.2173.54%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 962,801,780 %79.64 %1.36 %64.5782.63%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 917,853,941 %68.17 %1.29 %65.8671.44%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 820,646,498 %70.73 %1.16 %67.0275.69%16 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 807,823,692 %63.62 %1.14 %68.1670.16%17 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 795,312,331 %56.21 %1.12 %69.2860.27%18 218 CNA INS GRP 762,370,698 %66.04 %1.08 %70.3668.78%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 719,488,720 %69.99 %1.01 %71.3774.44%20 44 AVIVA GRP 687,907,301 %93.23 %0.97 %72.3497.18%21 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 674,592,997 %66.38 %0.95 %73.2970.92%22 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 663,586,060 %60.73 %0.94 %74.2369.41%23 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 632,678,071 %65.85 %0.89 %75.1268.00%24 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 582,854,582 %60.28 %0.82 %75.9462.21%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 515,564,698 %70.92 %0.73 %76.6771.82%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 70,899,014,377 %74.11 %100.00 %100.0079.03%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 14,360,460,421 %70.95 %21.11 %21.11n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 8,008,920,293 %67.22 %11.78 %32.89n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 4,017,920,876 %69.14 %5.91 %38.80n/a4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,637,015,406 %58.38 %3.88 %42.68n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners137

Page 146: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,138,245,431 %49.90 %3.14 %45.82n/a6 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,725,295,494 %64.38 %2.54 %48.36n/a7 81 GOVERNMENT EMPLYS 1,721,310,672 %74.56 %2.53 %50.89n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,244,095,584 %74.66 %1.83 %52.72n/a9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,227,212,340 %70.68 %1.80 %54.52n/a

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,072,044,573 %65.25 %1.58 %56.10n/a11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,008,771,798 %71.22 %1.48 %57.58n/a12 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 993,965,074 %78.83 %1.46 %59.04n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 917,075,669 %78.04 %1.35 %60.39n/a14 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 818,043,145 %60.41 %1.20 %61.59n/a15 218 CNA INS GRP 739,006,704 %80.85 %1.09 %62.68n/a16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 736,533,440 %67.75 %1.08 %63.76n/a17 41 CITIGROUP GRP 696,234,232 %70.99 %1.02 %64.79n/a18 213 ERIE INS GRP 695,881,714 %76.37 %1.02 %65.81n/a19 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 684,791,915 %69.77 %1.01 %66.82n/a20 163 SAFECO INS GRP 672,161,627 %55.40 %0.99 %67.80n/a21 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 598,443,567 %37.21 %0.88 %68.68n/a22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 575,213,865 %58.82 %0.85 %69.53n/a23 1 AETNA GRP 532,056,269 %58.33 %0.78 %70.31n/a24 169 SENTRY INS GRP 522,341,899 %67.19 %0.77 %71.08n/a25 103 INTEGON CORP 509,708,838 %72.60 %0.75 %71.83n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 68,011,561,420 %67.85 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 10,096,722,312 %86.27 %20.30 %20.30n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 6,070,379,439 %79.59 %12.21 %32.51n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 2,873,732,464 %85.09 %5.78 %38.28n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,949,313,363 %89.20 %3.92 %42.20n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,947,346,835 %73.21 %3.92 %46.12n/a6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,342,332,247 %77.50 %2.70 %48.82n/a7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,033,565,743 %73.19 %2.08 %50.90n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 918,878,762 %90.50 %1.85 %52.74n/a9 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 908,594,413 %61.04 %1.83 %54.57n/a

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 726,491,521 %84.38 %1.46 %56.03n/a11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 721,580,867 %85.64 %1.45 %57.48n/a12 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 707,574,584 %76.77 %1.42 %58.90n/a13 218 CNA INS GRP 650,239,552 %93.29 %1.31 %60.21n/a14 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 591,501,163 %55.32 %1.19 %61.40n/a15 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 589,050,031 %69.73 %1.18 %62.59n/a16 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 575,815,004 %69.40 %1.16 %63.74n/a17 163 SAFECO INS GRP 537,701,513 %82.41 %1.08 %64.82n/a18 213 ERIE INS GRP 513,985,108 %79.14 %1.03 %65.86n/a19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 493,890,343 %74.28 %0.99 %66.85n/a20 239 LEUCADIA GRP 482,443,564 %96.13 %0.97 %67.82n/a21 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 448,003,266 %81.17 %0.90 %68.72n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners138

Page 147: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.1, 19.2 - Private Passenger Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 433,820,937 %90.01 %0.87 %69.59n/a23 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 433,453,970 %119.82 %0.87 %70.47n/a24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 393,233,934 %70.96 %0.79 %71.26n/a25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 364,082,865 %69.56 %0.73 %71.99n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 49,735,735,449 %81.86 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 5,218,738,951 %85.47 %17.64 %17.64n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 3,121,111,366 %74.17 %10.55 %28.19n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 1,628,186,704 %79.60 %5.50 %33.70n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,422,470,096 %80.58 %4.81 %38.50n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,164,094,538 %75.33 %3.94 %42.44n/a6 40690 NJ AUTOMOBILE FULL INS UNDWRTG ASN 928,220,338 %140.61 %3.14 %45.58n/a7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 631,159,839 %82.73 %2.13 %47.71n/a8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 624,340,809 %81.99 %2.11 %49.82n/a9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 535,031,398 %85.83 %1.81 %51.63n/a

10 218 CNA INS GRP 514,205,409 %87.78 %1.74 %53.37n/a11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 428,621,043 %80.42 %1.45 %54.82n/a12 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 415,772,573 %80.00 %1.41 %56.22n/a13 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 398,336,974 %69.53 %1.35 %57.57n/a14 169 SENTRY INS GRP 342,849,157 %86.55 %1.16 %58.73n/a15 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 324,077,726 %90.22 %1.10 %59.82n/a16 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 311,604,610 %82.68 %1.05 %60.88n/a17 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 292,796,702 %76.49 %0.99 %61.87n/a18 212 ZURICH INS GRP 290,829,720 %89.81 %0.98 %62.85n/a19 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 281,843,065 %119.84 %0.95 %63.80n/a20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 275,672,840 %93.93 %0.93 %64.73n/a21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 273,654,589 %93.12 %0.93 %65.66n/a22 163 SAFECO INS GRP 271,528,603 %83.40 %0.92 %66.58n/a23 213 ERIE INS GRP 264,162,970 %77.49 %0.89 %67.47n/a24 148 OHIO CAS GRP 253,906,808 %80.14 %0.86 %68.33n/a25 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 247,551,764 %61.39 %0.84 %69.16n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 29,582,647,663 %84.76 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners139

Page 148: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,141,780,516 %66.32 %18.42 %18.4266.46%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,390,478,255 %47.41 %11.21 %29.6347.85%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,066,993,596 %58.03 %7.69 %37.3158.17%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 4,574,420,271 %57.41 %6.94 %44.2557.49%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 4,140,550,898 %56.02 %6.28 %50.5356.33%6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,055,058,263 %61.98 %4.63 %55.1762.51%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,874,788,466 %54.06 %4.36 %59.5354.43%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,872,542,879 %57.70 %4.36 %63.8957.94%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,436,530,434 %58.95 %2.18 %66.0759.13%

10 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,233,500,776 %53.92 %1.87 %67.9454.27%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 966,290,295 %52.67 %1.47 %69.4052.83%12 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 953,992,151 %51.95 %1.45 %70.8552.24%13 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 854,811,191 %61.15 %1.30 %72.1561.14%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 843,099,380 %49.54 %1.28 %73.4349.82%15 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 807,216,582 %53.50 %1.22 %74.6553.66%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 771,554,544 %60.40 %1.17 %75.8260.70%17 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 648,019,415 %56.20 %0.98 %76.8056.54%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 612,116,612 %64.68 %0.93 %77.7364.89%19 215 UNITRIN GRP 530,299,659 %59.36 %0.80 %78.5459.84%20 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 517,917,314 %66.44 %0.79 %79.3266.88%21 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 467,729,368 %53.88 %0.71 %80.0354.36%22 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 441,308,175 %56.29 %0.67 %80.7056.41%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 421,180,725 %59.52 %0.64 %81.3459.62%24 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 401,557,732 %58.41 %0.61 %81.9558.57%25 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 400,266,563 %59.33 %0.61 %82.5660.07%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 65,924,057,193 %57.92 %100.00 %100.0058.28%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,293,604,196 %69.90 %18.30 %18.3070.07%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,765,492,698 %49.32 %11.56 %29.8649.75%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 4,765,905,015 %60.66 %7.10 %36.9660.70%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 4,518,538,535 %60.89 %6.73 %43.6861.06%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,582,592,812 %65.61 %5.33 %49.0266.09%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,986,752,546 %58.17 %4.45 %53.4658.45%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,928,535,403 %56.53 %4.36 %57.8256.80%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,866,066,423 %64.59 %4.27 %62.0965.31%9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,763,297,166 %56.50 %2.63 %64.7257.08%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,496,964,436 %65.34 %2.23 %66.9465.50%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,258,980,134 %54.70 %1.87 %68.8255.07%12 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,004,579,086 %54.35 %1.50 %70.3154.67%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,002,081,023 %52.15 %1.49 %71.8152.09%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 916,376,154 %65.32 %1.36 %73.1765.62%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 875,787,116 %49.94 %1.30 %74.4750.11%16 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 817,381,718 %54.69 %1.22 %75.6954.93%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 723,467,197 %63.01 %1.08 %76.7763.26%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners140

Page 149: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 577,212,617 %56.67 %0.86 %77.6356.77%19 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 573,514,478 %58.69 %0.85 %78.4859.05%20 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 570,604,953 %67.11 %0.85 %79.3367.34%21 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 532,220,996 %61.68 %0.79 %80.1261.92%22 215 UNITRIN GRP 529,313,193 %62.79 %0.79 %80.9162.98%23 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 494,584,720 %70.48 %0.74 %81.6571.26%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 427,018,472 %60.67 %0.64 %82.2860.77%25 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 423,093,482 %63.46 %0.63 %82.9164.50%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 67,171,959,785 %60.63 %100.00 %100.0061.02%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,143,532,468 %64.93 %18.01 %18.0165.09%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 8,082,509,845 %46.86 %11.98 %29.9947.32%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 4,554,059,236 %60.01 %6.75 %36.7460.20%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 4,457,735,942 %60.23 %6.61 %43.3560.25%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,623,014,529 %58.52 %5.37 %48.7258.92%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,943,983,931 %55.94 %4.37 %53.0956.25%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,730,441,619 %63.17 %4.05 %57.1463.75%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,898,099,848 %53.91 %2.81 %59.9554.10%9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,828,609,192 %56.63 %2.71 %62.6657.10%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,515,132,043 %64.74 %2.25 %64.9165.02%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,239,572,010 %51.88 %1.84 %66.7552.06%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,042,693,618 %51.04 %1.55 %68.2950.57%13 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,000,627,913 %56.97 %1.48 %69.7857.24%14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 989,282,707 %59.71 %1.47 %71.2460.02%15 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 976,123,449 %64.74 %1.45 %72.6965.20%16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 888,785,409 %47.65 %1.32 %74.0147.86%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 869,176,675 %54.92 %1.29 %75.3055.21%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 698,659,928 %59.68 %1.04 %76.3359.97%19 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 623,516,320 %60.46 %0.92 %77.2660.63%20 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 574,470,133 %56.22 %0.85 %78.1156.47%21 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 556,139,175 %58.69 %0.82 %78.9359.08%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 544,930,639 %64.43 %0.81 %79.7464.62%23 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 493,548,106 %61.67 %0.73 %80.4762.14%24 215 UNITRIN GRP 475,899,958 %61.29 %0.71 %81.1861.29%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 431,569,189 %56.92 %0.64 %81.8257.05%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 67,443,437,741 %57.69 %100.00 %100.0058.04%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,057,728,412 %63.96 %17.97 %17.9764.09%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,927,907,773 %45.17 %11.81 %29.7845.68%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners141

Page 150: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 4,598,227,886 %58.28 %6.85 %36.6458.46%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 4,109,024,481 %58.31 %6.12 %42.7658.56%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,426,279,701 %56.28 %5.11 %47.8657.05%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,925,677,409 %52.03 %4.36 %52.2252.32%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,769,616,147 %55.25 %4.13 %56.3555.79%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,987,525,015 %56.02 %2.96 %59.3156.45%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,745,339,291 %51.15 %2.60 %61.9150.61%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,521,728,336 %64.72 %2.27 %64.1864.81%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,280,746,152 %49.55 %1.91 %66.0949.89%12 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,043,651,955 %61.07 %1.56 %67.6561.58%13 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,032,498,554 %54.66 %1.54 %69.1855.21%14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,025,689,639 %48.74 %1.53 %70.7148.90%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 989,948,160 %58.80 %1.48 %72.1959.20%16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 877,525,311 %46.92 %1.31 %73.5047.07%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 848,590,242 %56.61 %1.26 %74.7656.85%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 714,908,497 %52.72 %1.07 %75.8353.01%19 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 659,113,307 %55.55 %0.98 %76.8155.85%20 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 602,956,570 %53.70 %0.90 %77.7154.06%21 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 551,968,824 %56.81 %0.82 %78.5357.12%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 548,906,353 %57.76 %0.82 %79.3557.78%23 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 502,501,194 %63.91 %0.75 %80.1064.65%24 215 UNITRIN GRP 443,426,655 %57.51 %0.66 %80.7657.68%25 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 438,149,571 %54.12 %0.65 %81.4154.20%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 67,104,546,463 %55.61 %100.00 %100.0056.01%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,014,241,725 %68.51 %17.99 %17.9968.57%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 7,760,790,563 %49.39 %11.62 %29.6149.65%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 4,545,159,679 %61.18 %6.81 %36.4261.44%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 3,658,340,801 %62.59 %5.48 %41.8962.33%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,489,289,426 %53.80 %5.22 %47.1254.27%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,945,884,284 %51.94 %4.41 %51.5352.20%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,672,390,359 %59.19 %4.00 %55.5359.22%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,874,006,387 %58.02 %2.81 %58.3459.13%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,728,710,373 %51.01 %2.59 %60.9351.14%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,620,232,238 %51.02 %2.43 %63.3550.95%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,220,564,769 %48.65 %1.83 %65.1849.04%12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,048,914,382 %54.90 %1.57 %66.7555.18%13 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,014,612,454 %60.16 %1.52 %68.2760.63%14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,014,269,019 %53.90 %1.52 %69.7953.43%15 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 886,912,056 %54.87 %1.33 %71.1255.15%16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 882,067,832 %51.70 %1.32 %72.4451.74%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 820,786,390 %55.73 %1.23 %73.6755.92%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 793,111,501 %50.77 %1.19 %74.8551.08%19 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 635,544,830 %55.74 %0.95 %75.8055.97%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners142

Page 151: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 596,893,034 %56.85 %0.89 %76.7057.00%21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 584,459,432 %57.09 %0.88 %77.5757.76%22 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 558,744,368 %57.26 %0.84 %78.4157.54%23 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 498,648,871 %66.25 %0.75 %79.1667.02%24 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 456,424,610 %51.56 %0.68 %79.8451.78%25 215 UNITRIN GRP 454,279,481 %56.35 %0.68 %80.5256.73%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 66,784,846,207 %56.91 %100.00 %100.0057.21%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 9,533,020,619 %75.54 %18.42 %18.4275.72%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 6,304,300,743 %57.74 %12.18 %30.6158.04%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,999,303,996 %69.82 %5.80 %36.4070.39%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 2,272,176,786 %64.04 %4.39 %40.8064.41%5 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 2,212,047,676 %70.36 %4.28 %45.0770.65%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,181,670,146 %73.90 %4.22 %49.2974.28%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,929,783,863 %62.48 %3.73 %53.0262.85%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,198,972,962 %64.64 %2.32 %55.3365.14%9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,148,821,171 %72.83 %2.22 %57.5572.89%

10 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,089,501,659 %66.16 %2.11 %59.6667.25%11 41 CITIGROUP GRP 919,163,624 %60.77 %1.78 %61.4460.94%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 763,032,270 %63.58 %1.47 %62.9165.02%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 760,655,020 %66.58 %1.47 %64.3866.78%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 667,547,941 %65.34 %1.29 %65.6765.44%15 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 654,271,494 %70.04 %1.26 %66.9471.84%16 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 573,611,414 %69.58 %1.11 %68.0469.46%17 213 ERIE INS GRP 534,963,440 %62.26 %1.03 %69.0862.71%18 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 529,490,540 %62.89 %1.02 %70.1062.96%19 218 CNA INS GRP 528,560,512 %76.52 %1.02 %71.1277.94%20 44 AVIVA GRP 492,578,346 %67.99 %0.95 %72.0768.49%21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 481,895,795 %66.25 %0.93 %73.0166.94%22 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 478,395,756 %58.18 %0.92 %73.9358.47%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 472,652,590 %64.08 %0.91 %74.8464.19%24 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 472,640,898 %59.18 %0.91 %75.7659.84%25 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 459,860,979 %61.39 %0.89 %76.6561.57%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 51,743,059,637 %67.22 %100.00 %100.0067.75%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 8,673,836,443 %68.56 %22.87 %22.87n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 4,650,121,986 %63.52 %12.26 %35.12n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 2,115,257,121 %71.28 %5.58 %40.70n/a4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,355,096,183 %64.87 %3.57 %44.27n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners143

Page 152: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,261,221,137 %63.01 %3.32 %47.60n/a6 81 GOVERNMENT EMPLYS 880,409,485 %69.60 %2.32 %49.92n/a7 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 845,893,132 %61.64 %2.23 %52.15n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 646,383,881 %64.30 %1.70 %53.85n/a9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 645,200,322 %73.18 %1.70 %55.55n/a

10 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 481,686,692 %70.49 %1.27 %56.82n/a11 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 479,772,247 %75.39 %1.26 %58.09n/a12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 459,044,019 %76.02 %1.21 %59.30n/a13 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 437,480,384 %63.85 %1.15 %60.45n/a14 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 432,380,353 %64.36 %1.14 %61.59n/a15 218 CNA INS GRP 402,441,658 %57.85 %1.06 %62.65n/a16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 378,522,357 %61.62 %1.00 %63.65n/a17 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 372,727,120 %66.87 %0.98 %64.63n/a18 213 ERIE INS GRP 362,839,601 %68.87 %0.96 %65.59n/a19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 361,068,065 %67.15 %0.95 %66.54n/a20 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 337,307,059 %75.33 %0.89 %67.43n/a21 41 CITIGROUP GRP 306,869,651 %54.99 %0.81 %68.24n/a22 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 268,218,469 %80.05 %0.71 %68.95n/a23 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 263,295,226 %57.00 %0.69 %69.64n/a24 103 INTEGON CORP 238,847,382 %69.50 %0.63 %70.27n/a25 1 AETNA GRP 237,339,566 %55.82 %0.63 %70.89n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 37,934,175,662 %65.81 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 7,013,915,304 %68.31 %22.59 %22.59n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 3,823,426,940 %64.38 %12.31 %34.90n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 1,554,196,281 %60.30 %5.01 %39.91n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,130,096,305 %61.08 %3.64 %43.55n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 997,957,946 %68.98 %3.21 %46.76n/a6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 972,107,122 %58.81 %3.13 %49.89n/a7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 541,781,517 %66.17 %1.74 %51.64n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 532,602,279 %65.13 %1.72 %53.35n/a9 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 470,699,844 %68.57 %1.52 %54.87n/a

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 469,704,186 %76.40 %1.51 %56.38n/a11 218 CNA INS GRP 431,566,123 %47.15 %1.39 %57.77n/a12 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 424,735,157 %59.77 %1.37 %59.14n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 350,333,174 %56.96 %1.13 %60.27n/a14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 314,678,607 %54.32 %1.01 %61.28n/a15 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 309,722,327 %64.74 %1.00 %62.28n/a16 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 302,475,730 %55.00 %0.97 %63.26n/a17 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 290,812,711 %46.87 %0.94 %64.19n/a18 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 286,991,075 %52.63 %0.92 %65.12n/a19 213 ERIE INS GRP 269,452,472 %60.00 %0.87 %65.98n/a20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 269,005,560 %56.19 %0.87 %66.85n/a21 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 237,902,753 %69.31 %0.77 %67.62n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners144

Page 153: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.1 - Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 229,203,674 %52.42 %0.74 %68.35n/a23 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 223,527,493 %64.93 %0.72 %69.07n/a24 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 211,878,212 %59.15 %0.68 %69.76n/a25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 194,730,426 %61.79 %0.63 %70.38n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 31,048,800,102 %62.41 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 4,044,727,198 %71.35 %18.58 %18.58n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 2,070,477,685 %67.16 %9.51 %28.08n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 1,111,721,130 %69.85 %5.11 %33.19n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 979,305,596 %65.17 %4.50 %37.69n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 758,934,828 %66.92 %3.49 %41.17n/a6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 486,484,880 %62.72 %2.23 %43.41n/a7 40690 NJ AUTOMOBILE FULL INS UNDWRTG ASN 401,363,340 %111.25 %1.84 %45.25n/a8 218 CNA INS GRP 390,604,060 %60.73 %1.79 %47.04n/a9 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 384,392,017 %69.00 %1.77 %48.81n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 381,411,481 %77.35 %1.75 %50.56n/a11 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 306,735,667 %81.10 %1.41 %51.97n/a12 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 289,889,242 %55.16 %1.33 %53.30n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 257,827,338 %61.79 %1.18 %54.48n/a14 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 246,903,849 %68.37 %1.13 %55.62n/a15 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 225,985,300 %53.49 %1.04 %56.66n/a16 212 ZURICH INS GRP 224,025,119 %60.46 %1.03 %57.68n/a17 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 215,979,631 %64.06 %0.99 %58.68n/a18 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 211,563,631 %66.53 %0.97 %59.65n/a19 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 198,760,944 %49.32 %0.91 %60.56n/a20 163 SAFECO INS GRP 195,122,898 %56.16 %0.90 %61.46n/a21 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 194,544,744 %70.29 %0.89 %62.35n/a22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 177,537,615 %72.38 %0.82 %63.17n/a23 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 176,577,910 %66.82 %0.81 %63.98n/a24 169 SENTRY INS GRP 176,565,403 %65.20 %0.81 %64.79n/a25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 172,017,316 %61.86 %0.79 %65.58n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 21,774,835,263 %67.88 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners145

Page 154: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 30,586,466,141 %74.04 %18.62 %18.6277.28%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 17,249,324,814 %58.73 %10.50 %29.1261.48%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 13,481,538,119 %66.94 %8.21 %37.3369.82%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 12,257,768,970 %63.05 %7.46 %44.7964.48%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 10,442,099,903 %56.21 %6.36 %51.1558.40%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 7,392,863,152 %64.33 %4.50 %55.6565.84%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 7,160,608,202 %57.71 %4.36 %60.0159.77%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 6,747,370,667 %66.54 %4.11 %64.1268.61%9 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,364,166,469 %56.84 %2.05 %66.1660.41%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,308,436,776 %62.15 %2.01 %68.1865.16%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,652,157,949 %63.11 %1.61 %69.7964.87%12 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 2,109,127,616 %54.88 %1.28 %71.0859.95%13 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 2,054,108,167 %51.60 %1.25 %72.3353.56%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,012,537,987 %57.92 %1.23 %73.5559.70%15 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,865,106,551 %66.08 %1.14 %74.6968.15%16 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,761,740,159 %58.31 %1.07 %75.7659.98%17 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,399,085,588 %63.89 %0.85 %76.6166.00%18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,359,827,686 %103.53 %0.83 %77.44106.12%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 1,324,291,841 %64.62 %0.81 %78.2567.42%20 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 1,299,762,505 %88.66 %0.79 %79.0491.59%21 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,198,142,893 %59.57 %0.73 %79.7760.63%22 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,121,373,390 %69.61 %0.68 %80.4571.36%23 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 1,091,288,613 %66.86 %0.66 %81.1170.49%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 1,028,466,185 %68.23 %0.63 %81.7469.96%25 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 986,141,887 %61.37 %0.60 %82.3462.90%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 164,261,412,399 %64.55 %100.00 %100.0067.07%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 30,055,729,493 %72.09 %18.29 %18.2974.89%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 17,691,133,468 %56.36 %10.77 %29.0659.02%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 12,516,813,602 %65.44 %7.62 %36.6867.88%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 11,678,759,096 %61.57 %7.11 %43.7962.92%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 8,884,494,965 %62.07 %5.41 %49.2064.03%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 7,590,424,749 %60.87 %4.62 %53.8262.25%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 7,230,958,552 %63.30 %4.40 %58.2264.40%8 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 6,251,045,508 %70.41 %3.80 %62.0272.17%9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,445,701,947 %66.16 %2.71 %64.7368.64%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,440,816,402 %66.77 %2.09 %66.8269.36%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,387,358,140 %57.20 %2.06 %68.8859.74%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,651,766,409 %59.90 %1.61 %70.5061.07%13 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 2,303,219,811 %59.59 %1.40 %71.9064.51%14 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 2,122,221,835 %54.88 %1.29 %73.1956.26%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,085,079,331 %51.49 %1.27 %74.4653.05%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,825,733,235 %56.02 %1.11 %75.5757.37%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,785,530,933 %54.67 %1.09 %76.6656.46%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners146

Page 155: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 1,391,681,875 %58.04 %0.85 %77.5160.18%19 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,377,177,579 %67.42 %0.84 %78.3469.21%20 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,359,490,602 %62.70 %0.83 %79.1764.81%21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,257,021,265 %77.05 %0.77 %79.9480.04%22 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 1,155,366,580 %63.09 %0.70 %80.6467.56%23 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 1,145,702,964 %74.36 %0.70 %81.3477.07%24 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 1,081,122,012 %67.40 %0.66 %81.9969.00%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 1,063,469,270 %66.60 %0.65 %82.6468.46%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 164,295,960,813 %63.71 %100.00 %100.0066.01%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 29,478,380,816 %67.00 %17.89 %17.8969.86%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 18,328,619,255 %53.98 %11.13 %29.0256.79%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 11,747,363,474 %59.86 %7.13 %36.1561.45%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 11,731,067,884 %63.21 %7.12 %43.2765.20%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 8,910,730,144 %61.45 %5.41 %48.6862.68%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 7,630,445,817 %59.45 %4.63 %53.3261.09%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 5,968,053,665 %70.54 %3.62 %56.9472.57%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 4,778,557,470 %63.86 %2.90 %59.8465.42%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,621,895,312 %56.93 %2.81 %62.6457.79%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,559,757,621 %66.56 %2.16 %64.8169.45%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,345,286,591 %54.42 %2.03 %66.8455.80%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,702,746,099 %63.54 %1.64 %68.4864.72%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 2,542,126,262 %63.05 %1.54 %70.0265.17%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 2,495,112,662 %57.46 %1.51 %71.5460.65%15 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 2,133,691,626 %58.00 %1.30 %72.8359.67%16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,118,058,369 %51.79 %1.29 %74.1254.08%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,890,961,512 %57.06 %1.15 %75.2659.88%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,802,139,779 %53.74 %1.09 %76.3655.37%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 1,506,205,441 %56.64 %0.91 %77.2758.98%20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,485,296,040 %60.48 %0.90 %78.1762.28%21 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,234,955,015 %63.80 %0.75 %78.9265.18%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,212,210,414 %79.18 %0.74 %79.6682.05%23 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 1,170,158,931 %68.25 %0.71 %80.3771.40%24 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 1,097,902,590 %66.20 %0.67 %81.0467.99%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 1,086,494,764 %60.12 %0.66 %81.7062.58%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 164,730,211,230 %61.28 %100.00 %100.0063.54%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 29,582,026,434 %60.98 %17.96 %17.9664.06%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 18,294,439,323 %50.26 %11.11 %29.0752.73%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners147

Page 156: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 12,077,096,420 %54.58 %7.33 %36.4156.29%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 11,105,000,920 %60.77 %6.74 %43.1562.45%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 8,113,568,292 %60.46 %4.93 %48.0862.33%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 7,610,828,455 %53.15 %4.62 %52.7054.69%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 5,964,245,202 %65.68 %3.62 %56.3267.50%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 5,002,977,798 %60.06 %3.04 %59.3660.88%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,251,007,801 %53.83 %2.58 %61.9456.91%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,536,914,416 %66.36 %2.15 %64.0970.37%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,471,356,684 %51.64 %2.11 %66.2053.65%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,652,981,268 %57.28 %1.61 %67.8158.63%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 2,589,780,451 %55.51 %1.57 %69.3858.24%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 2,560,646,070 %58.46 %1.55 %70.9462.24%15 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 2,173,637,525 %55.32 %1.32 %72.2657.33%16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,111,233,902 %49.56 %1.28 %73.5451.58%17 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,856,801,607 %56.80 %1.13 %74.6659.75%18 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,811,671,023 %58.50 %1.10 %75.7759.90%19 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,598,900,595 %65.56 %0.97 %76.7467.80%20 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 1,516,112,647 %52.50 %0.92 %77.6653.79%21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,229,331,362 %67.35 %0.75 %78.4069.24%22 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 1,206,379,826 %71.73 %0.73 %79.1474.43%23 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,151,503,175 %60.13 %0.70 %79.8462.33%24 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 1,116,479,209 %66.10 %0.68 %80.5167.77%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 1,060,581,305 %63.88 %0.64 %81.1665.49%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 164,674,959,511 %57.85 %100.00 %100.0060.22%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 29,471,231,992 %64.23 %17.98 %17.9866.67%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 18,132,414,808 %55.20 %11.06 %29.0457.35%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 12,052,273,856 %54.91 %7.35 %36.3956.88%4 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 10,101,325,029 %62.70 %6.16 %42.5664.17%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 8,026,876,418 %60.79 %4.90 %47.4563.36%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 7,597,384,508 %64.17 %4.63 %52.0965.99%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 5,763,031,092 %65.96 %3.52 %55.6068.09%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 5,005,409,238 %57.51 %3.05 %58.6660.38%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,260,914,017 %56.35 %2.60 %61.2660.33%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 3,589,037,541 %58.87 %2.19 %63.4561.11%11 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,310,654,988 %51.95 %2.02 %65.4754.06%12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 2,732,056,028 %60.03 %1.67 %67.1362.80%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,661,628,913 %59.75 %1.62 %68.7659.22%14 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 2,509,493,040 %55.12 %1.53 %70.2958.49%15 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 2,139,499,437 %54.87 %1.31 %71.5957.72%16 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,923,488,878 %64.79 %1.17 %72.7766.95%17 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,912,286,075 %52.00 %1.17 %73.9353.82%18 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,822,172,831 %52.95 %1.11 %75.0455.56%19 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 1,550,460,978 %53.67 %0.95 %75.9955.90%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners148

Page 157: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,502,193,809 %63.32 %0.92 %76.9165.01%21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,296,808,250 %67.32 %0.79 %77.7070.03%22 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 1,263,277,135 %83.86 %0.77 %78.4785.97%23 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,198,651,652 %60.08 %0.73 %79.2062.66%24 483 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP 1,105,107,060 %66.79 %0.67 %79.8768.89%25 50 COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP 1,045,766,046 %60.56 %0.64 %80.5162.70%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 163,916,952,032 %60.02 %100.00 %100.0062.42%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 22,142,484,484 %76.99 %18.05 %18.0580.57%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 14,282,131,504 %65.38 %11.65 %29.7069.76%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 7,000,507,275 %71.96 %5.71 %35.4174.04%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 5,695,095,506 %70.83 %4.64 %40.0573.26%5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 5,629,890,109 %72.29 %4.59 %44.6474.63%6 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,626,122,939 %78.84 %4.59 %49.2380.81%7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 4,122,138,764 %72.13 %3.36 %52.5974.88%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 3,150,565,999 %69.53 %2.57 %55.1671.96%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,918,787,446 %69.88 %2.38 %57.5473.56%

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 2,479,648,844 %70.36 %2.02 %59.5673.23%11 41 CITIGROUP GRP 2,375,926,374 %71.88 %1.94 %61.5074.00%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,944,139,646 %66.20 %1.59 %63.0870.25%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,723,456,800 %73.90 %1.41 %64.4975.66%14 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,585,401,882 %66.98 %1.29 %65.7868.92%15 1278 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP 1,462,095,186 %66.43 %1.19 %66.9770.89%16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,302,542,293 %69.11 %1.06 %68.0472.53%17 218 CNA INS GRP 1,290,931,210 %70.28 %1.05 %69.0972.49%18 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 1,273,708,087 %56.95 %1.04 %70.1359.60%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,254,452,160 %66.77 %1.02 %71.1569.55%20 1318 AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP 1,204,083,537 %64.86 %0.98 %72.1367.45%21 44 AVIVA GRP 1,180,485,647 %82.82 %0.96 %73.0985.34%22 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 1,136,226,958 %60.08 %0.93 %74.0265.42%23 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 1,092,539,050 %63.98 %0.89 %74.9165.31%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 988,217,288 %67.64 %0.81 %75.7268.16%25 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 961,182,777 %88.05 %0.78 %76.5090.03%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 122,642,074,014 %71.22 %100.00 %100.0074.30%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 23,034,296,864 %70.04 %21.74 %21.74n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 12,659,042,279 %65.87 %11.95 %33.69n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 6,133,177,997 %69.88 %5.79 %39.48n/a4 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 3,992,111,589 %60.58 %3.77 %43.25n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners149

Page 158: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 3,399,466,568 %54.73 %3.21 %46.46n/a6 81 GOVERNMENT EMPLYS 2,601,720,157 %72.90 %2.46 %48.91n/a7 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 2,571,188,626 %63.48 %2.43 %51.34n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,890,479,465 %71.16 %1.78 %53.12n/a9 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,717,244,895 %68.23 %1.62 %54.74n/a

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,467,815,817 %72.72 %1.39 %56.13n/a11 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 1,431,445,458 %74.26 %1.35 %57.48n/a12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,389,852,260 %70.94 %1.31 %58.79n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,349,456,022 %73.63 %1.27 %60.07n/a14 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 1,299,729,837 %64.11 %1.23 %61.29n/a15 218 CNA INS GRP 1,141,448,362 %72.71 %1.08 %62.37n/a16 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 1,109,260,560 %67.46 %1.05 %63.42n/a17 213 ERIE INS GRP 1,058,721,315 %73.85 %1.00 %64.42n/a18 163 SAFECO INS GRP 1,050,683,984 %57.63 %0.99 %65.41n/a19 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 1,022,098,974 %71.61 %0.96 %66.37n/a20 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,003,103,883 %66.15 %0.95 %67.32n/a21 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 965,233,295 %76.52 %0.91 %68.23n/a22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 936,281,930 %61.99 %0.88 %69.11n/a23 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 866,662,036 %50.27 %0.82 %69.93n/a24 1 AETNA GRP 769,395,835 %57.56 %0.73 %70.66n/a25 103 INTEGON CORP 748,556,220 %71.61 %0.71 %71.37n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 105,945,737,082 %67.12 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 17,110,637,616 %78.90 %21.18 %21.18n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 9,893,806,379 %73.71 %12.25 %33.43n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 4,427,928,745 %76.37 %5.48 %38.91n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 3,079,409,668 %78.72 %3.81 %42.72n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,945,304,781 %71.78 %3.65 %46.37n/a6 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 2,314,439,369 %69.66 %2.86 %49.23n/a7 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,575,347,260 %70.79 %1.95 %51.18n/a8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,451,481,041 %80.96 %1.80 %52.98n/a9 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 1,333,329,570 %60.64 %1.65 %54.63n/a

10 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 1,196,195,707 %81.20 %1.48 %56.11n/a11 218 CNA INS GRP 1,081,805,675 %74.59 %1.34 %57.45n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 1,071,914,041 %76.27 %1.33 %58.78n/a13 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 1,017,296,911 %73.10 %1.26 %60.03n/a14 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 904,153,814 %92.71 %1.12 %61.15n/a15 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 882,313,874 %52.39 %1.09 %62.25n/a16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 852,380,120 %72.06 %1.06 %63.30n/a17 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 812,577,524 %68.43 %1.01 %64.31n/a18 213 ERIE INS GRP 783,437,580 %72.68 %0.97 %65.28n/a19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 762,895,903 %67.85 %0.94 %66.22n/a20 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 720,812,012 %75.15 %0.89 %67.11n/a21 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 695,709,664 %63.89 %0.86 %67.97n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners150

Page 159: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Private Passenger Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 353 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP 685,906,019 %77.15 %0.85 %68.82n/a23 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 674,479,153 %67.73 %0.83 %69.66n/a24 239 LEUCADIA GRP 672,872,962 %87.61 %0.83 %70.49n/a25 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 558,813,291 %66.82 %0.69 %71.18n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 80,784,535,551 %74.34 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 9,263,466,149 %79.25 %18.04 %18.04n/a2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 5,191,589,051 %71.38 %10.11 %28.15n/a3 69 FARMERS INS GRP 2,739,907,834 %75.66 %5.33 %33.48n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 2,401,775,692 %74.37 %4.68 %38.16n/a5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,923,029,366 %72.03 %3.74 %41.90n/a6 40690 NJ AUTOMOBILE FULL INS UNDWRTG ASN 1,329,583,678 %132.16 %2.59 %44.49n/a7 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 1,110,825,689 %73.54 %2.16 %46.65n/a8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 1,015,551,856 %77.52 %1.98 %48.63n/a9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 916,442,879 %82.34 %1.78 %50.42n/a

10 218 CNA INS GRP 904,809,469 %76.16 %1.76 %52.18n/a11 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS 688,226,216 %63.45 %1.34 %53.52n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 686,448,381 %73.32 %1.34 %54.85n/a13 15598 INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA 631,752,204 %74.23 %1.23 %56.08n/a14 473 AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP 570,981,575 %80.77 %1.11 %57.20n/a15 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 523,168,241 %76.12 %1.02 %58.21n/a16 55 AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP 520,826,198 %92.39 %1.01 %59.23n/a17 169 SENTRY INS GRP 519,414,560 %79.25 %1.01 %60.24n/a18 212 ZURICH INS GRP 514,854,839 %77.07 %1.00 %61.24n/a19 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 470,217,584 %84.06 %0.92 %62.16n/a20 163 SAFECO INS GRP 466,651,501 %71.90 %0.91 %63.07n/a21 241 METROPOLITAN GRP 453,860,381 %97.66 %0.88 %63.95n/a22 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 448,428,149 %72.39 %0.87 %64.82n/a23 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 446,312,708 %56.03 %0.87 %65.69n/a24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 436,957,014 %82.58 %0.85 %66.54n/a25 148 OHIO CAS GRP 419,413,561 %70.80 %0.82 %67.36n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 51,357,482,926 %77.61 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners151

Page 160: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,570,555,740 %40.73 %8.34 %8.3443.57%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,329,185,082 %41.19 %7.06 %15.3947.18%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,292,156,333 %48.71 %6.86 %22.2552.86%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,172,906,601 %55.52 %6.23 %28.4859.22%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,069,799,289 %57.38 %5.68 %34.1665.20%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 745,756,266 %61.40 %3.96 %38.1266.79%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 484,636,662 %57.79 %2.57 %40.6966.06%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 440,244,658 %49.44 %2.34 %43.0250.60%9 218 CNA INS GRP 378,422,949 %72.09 %2.01 %45.0378.92%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 369,192,927 %71.12 %1.96 %46.9975.59%11 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 358,945,643 %64.77 %1.91 %48.9070.76%12 176 STATE FARM GRP 351,834,017 %62.35 %1.87 %50.7769.31%13 796 QBE INS GRP 346,504,222 %47.42 %1.84 %52.6154.39%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 306,147,247 %47.61 %1.63 %54.2355.83%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 291,648,178 %51.95 %1.55 %55.7856.21%16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 290,091,069 %47.53 %1.54 %57.3253.28%17 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 282,247,766 %43.92 %1.50 %58.8247.50%18 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 260,168,480 %84.37 %1.38 %60.2095.79%19 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 235,455,969 %59.01 %1.25 %61.4562.39%20 213 ERIE INS GRP 219,943,986 %40.36 %1.17 %62.6244.96%21 93 STATE NATL GRP 212,813,905 %63.61 %1.13 %63.7570.54%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 193,179,926 %92.00 %1.03 %64.7799.62%23 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 188,971,420 %47.93 %1.00 %65.7752.40%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 177,385,236 %50.72 %0.94 %66.7254.09%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 167,224,839 %35.10 %0.89 %67.6042.03%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 18,838,456,418 %52.81 %100.00 %100.0059.28%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,602,609,481 %47.68 %7.81 %7.8152.23%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,464,455,933 %56.91 %7.14 %14.9561.60%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,411,039,959 %54.88 %6.88 %21.8361.58%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,321,351,290 %50.45 %6.44 %28.2753.06%5 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,286,783,075 %62.29 %6.27 %34.5566.20%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 796,186,969 %61.47 %3.88 %38.4366.15%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 524,968,303 %62.64 %2.56 %40.9967.77%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 493,582,792 %46.11 %2.41 %43.3950.19%9 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 472,542,685 %54.28 %2.30 %45.7060.72%

10 218 CNA INS GRP 438,895,214 %71.11 %2.14 %47.8476.31%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 392,991,868 %54.48 %1.92 %49.7558.99%12 176 STATE FARM GRP 371,779,550 %63.44 %1.81 %51.5670.63%13 796 QBE INS GRP 368,183,419 %36.91 %1.79 %53.3644.27%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 323,935,115 %45.43 %1.58 %54.9449.29%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 319,111,417 %59.19 %1.56 %56.4966.52%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 311,286,115 %30.52 %1.52 %58.0136.23%17 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 302,987,630 %58.96 %1.48 %59.4963.93%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners152

Page 161: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 263,590,629 %78.01 %1.29 %60.7788.03%19 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 242,955,749 %33.92 %1.18 %61.9635.21%20 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 241,096,426 %57.42 %1.18 %63.1360.06%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 240,489,708 %67.20 %1.17 %64.3172.32%22 213 ERIE INS GRP 224,727,405 %47.52 %1.10 %65.4051.13%23 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 205,083,148 %51.53 %1.00 %66.4054.82%24 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 191,016,435 %65.38 %0.93 %67.3379.97%25 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 182,614,391 %34.90 %0.89 %68.2240.54%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 20,512,464,243 %53.82 %100.00 %100.0059.44%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,703,667,322 %47.61 %7.74 %7.7453.27%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,505,710,746 %52.72 %6.84 %14.5865.41%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,466,465,916 %47.92 %6.66 %21.2456.63%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,398,138,709 %60.11 %6.35 %27.5963.88%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,215,635,817 %51.74 %5.52 %33.1155.93%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 881,996,908 %59.91 %4.01 %37.1264.86%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 557,632,847 %62.00 %2.53 %39.6569.57%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 535,140,263 %51.66 %2.43 %42.0855.16%9 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 515,678,714 %53.82 %2.34 %44.4260.64%

10 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 498,677,185 %82.61 %2.27 %46.6987.33%11 218 CNA INS GRP 495,160,604 %44.72 %2.25 %48.9446.16%12 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 418,811,919 %66.29 %1.90 %50.8473.13%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 388,052,792 %59.32 %1.76 %52.6064.43%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 382,123,657 %45.66 %1.74 %54.3450.18%15 796 QBE INS GRP 379,716,987 %57.33 %1.72 %56.0661.79%16 176 STATE FARM GRP 377,322,084 %56.23 %1.71 %57.7861.38%17 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 315,592,212 %55.08 %1.43 %59.2159.61%18 626 ACE LTD GRP 296,821,000 %51.68 %1.35 %60.5664.43%19 262 CANAL GRP 290,667,020 %74.96 %1.32 %61.8888.02%20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 287,865,644 %46.20 %1.31 %63.1953.13%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 284,087,908 %50.17 %1.29 %64.4853.98%22 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 254,738,408 %49.31 %1.16 %65.6452.78%23 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 244,896,258 %65.52 %1.11 %66.7578.19%24 213 ERIE INS GRP 223,712,401 %43.67 %1.02 %67.7645.64%25 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 218,758,022 %29.06 %0.99 %68.7630.28%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 22,015,062,272 %53.74 %100.00 %100.0060.27%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,636,025,804 %41.26 %7.14 %7.1443.51%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,520,253,365 %57.77 %6.64 %13.7861.96%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners153

Page 162: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,501,570,173 %51.46 %6.56 %20.3454.94%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,349,140,720 %44.99 %5.89 %26.2351.45%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,096,115,634 %48.65 %4.79 %31.0254.10%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 903,751,270 %61.73 %3.95 %34.9666.00%7 218 CNA INS GRP 674,730,782 %60.27 %2.95 %37.9162.94%8 176 STATE FARM GRP 645,229,093 %56.71 %2.82 %40.7362.05%9 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 586,405,322 %64.67 %2.56 %43.2971.12%

10 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 578,054,871 %65.69 %2.52 %45.8170.13%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 571,496,954 %55.98 %2.50 %48.3157.66%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 509,318,985 %50.90 %2.22 %50.5358.09%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 453,750,871 %59.73 %1.98 %52.5165.95%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 426,303,424 %48.80 %1.86 %54.3852.29%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 358,492,446 %50.02 %1.57 %55.9455.15%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 343,191,044 %50.08 %1.50 %57.4461.36%17 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 324,701,063 %55.40 %1.42 %58.8659.56%18 262 CANAL GRP 306,779,329 %76.09 %1.34 %60.2081.73%19 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 302,462,160 %63.56 %1.32 %61.5273.21%20 169 SENTRY INS GRP 287,224,753 %71.41 %1.25 %62.7777.06%21 517 HANNOVER GRP 274,000,710 %47.64 %1.20 %63.9760.68%22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 272,977,480 %38.53 %1.19 %65.1642.15%23 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 249,539,199 %48.30 %1.09 %66.2551.54%24 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 244,471,338 %33.03 %1.07 %67.3241.19%25 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 226,371,772 %58.80 %0.99 %68.3163.11%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 22,900,477,525 %52.75 %100.00 %100.0058.01%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,696,629,975 %48.26 %7.43 %7.4351.36%2 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,478,185,423 %50.59 %6.47 %13.9055.20%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,472,997,109 %62.22 %6.45 %20.3470.73%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,459,330,083 %58.92 %6.39 %26.7364.23%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,041,241,765 %47.14 %4.56 %31.2952.35%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 800,822,154 %54.88 %3.51 %34.7958.14%7 218 CNA INS GRP 719,406,375 %63.26 %3.15 %37.9469.72%8 176 STATE FARM GRP 590,794,847 %53.00 %2.59 %40.5356.41%9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 590,703,530 %49.84 %2.59 %43.1155.34%

10 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 581,371,323 %61.72 %2.54 %45.6667.16%11 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 534,427,272 %68.24 %2.34 %48.0075.72%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 486,367,600 %65.12 %2.13 %50.1374.13%13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 454,680,043 %59.02 %1.99 %52.1264.00%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 448,142,040 %54.59 %1.96 %54.0861.96%15 626 ACE LTD GRP 348,632,988 %30.94 %1.53 %55.6037.66%16 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 347,399,738 %73.87 %1.52 %57.1384.62%17 163 SAFECO INS GRP 330,982,209 %36.75 %1.45 %58.5739.37%18 262 CANAL GRP 328,937,479 %71.27 %1.44 %60.0179.00%19 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 323,497,186 %54.21 %1.42 %61.4357.39%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners154

Page 163: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 169 SENTRY INS GRP 288,182,977 %54.52 %1.26 %62.6960.05%21 517 HANNOVER GRP 278,820,730 %33.56 %1.22 %63.9146.43%22 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 269,811,840 %35.79 %1.18 %65.0943.29%23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 253,268,488 %48.83 %1.11 %66.2055.96%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 245,320,441 %29.83 %1.07 %67.2834.09%25 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 241,527,400 %60.80 %1.06 %68.3365.54%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 22,846,418,173 %53.93 %100.00 %100.0059.91%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 212 ZURICH INS GRP 955,266,521 %81.73 %6.32 %6.3288.35%2 218 CNA INS GRP 745,367,903 %82.85 %4.93 %11.2686.75%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 721,033,558 %109.65 %4.77 %16.03119.09%4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 698,110,494 %73.08 %4.62 %20.6577.29%5 164 ST PAUL GRP 626,580,748 %66.68 %4.15 %24.8071.73%6 44 AVIVA GRP 540,735,932 %95.79 %3.58 %28.38100.58%7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 520,124,446 %94.22 %3.44 %31.82100.56%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 400,526,961 %78.23 %2.65 %34.4785.93%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 374,609,084 %63.82 %2.48 %36.9569.21%

10 176 STATE FARM GRP 372,769,265 %61.02 %2.47 %39.4265.52%11 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 332,304,803 %67.13 %2.20 %41.6279.14%12 163 SAFECO INS GRP 305,690,434 %78.42 %2.02 %43.6482.82%13 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 287,570,207 %95.98 %1.90 %45.55104.40%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 286,033,638 %72.22 %1.89 %47.4485.59%15 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 277,122,933 %80.88 %1.83 %49.2790.02%16 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 268,905,432 %70.03 %1.78 %51.0574.93%17 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 226,145,678 %77.35 %1.50 %52.5584.82%18 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 212,826,373 %103.75 %1.41 %53.96117.48%19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 198,885,275 %90.29 %1.32 %55.2795.65%20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 187,060,364 %127.27 %1.24 %56.51133.71%21 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 185,168,645 %81.29 %1.23 %57.7488.66%22 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 184,804,041 %64.82 %1.22 %58.9669.64%23 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 167,590,517 %106.71 %1.11 %60.07115.48%24 517 HANNOVER GRP 162,798,200 %77.59 %1.08 %61.1595.30%25 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 161,289,291 %66.63 %1.07 %62.2278.63%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 15,107,431,229 %80.97 %100.00 %100.0088.30%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 715,319,144 %60.26 %5.27 %5.27n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 612,922,868 %67.79 %4.51 %9.78n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 526,983,266 %79.63 %3.88 %13.66n/a4 176 STATE FARM GRP 400,365,996 %59.80 %2.95 %16.61n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners155

Page 164: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 1 AETNA GRP 392,968,951 %59.52 %2.89 %19.50n/a6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 379,744,960 %63.50 %2.80 %22.29n/a7 41 CITIGROUP GRP 379,563,392 %63.91 %2.79 %25.09n/a8 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 366,725,648 %76.03 %2.70 %27.79n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 363,579,273 %64.53 %2.68 %30.46n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 350,907,526 %96.08 %2.58 %33.05n/a11 159 RELIANCE GRP 298,259,499 %73.60 %2.20 %35.24n/a12 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 291,758,539 %82.23 %2.15 %37.39n/a13 164 ST PAUL GRP 274,449,372 %52.00 %2.02 %39.41n/a14 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 265,506,405 %72.87 %1.95 %41.37n/a15 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 261,805,710 %57.97 %1.93 %43.29n/a16 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 200,917,032 %57.81 %1.48 %44.77n/a17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 199,937,896 %64.77 %1.47 %46.25n/a18 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 193,465,134 %74.63 %1.42 %47.67n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 192,530,337 %72.21 %1.42 %49.09n/a20 44 AVIVA GRP 180,903,477 %60.37 %1.33 %50.42n/a21 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 180,429,905 %53.19 %1.33 %51.75n/a22 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 167,985,255 %73.59 %1.24 %52.98n/a23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 167,955,675 %39.63 %1.24 %54.22n/a24 1111 TIG INS GRP 166,688,698 %81.39 %1.23 %55.45n/a25 162 ROYAL GRP 165,107,843 %57.95 %1.22 %56.66n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 13,583,458,488 %66.94 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 994,212,385 %69.97 %7.55 %7.55n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 730,278,135 %67.35 %5.55 %13.10n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 717,056,798 %86.11 %5.45 %18.55n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 685,854,970 %67.63 %5.21 %23.76n/a5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 610,241,077 %74.54 %4.64 %28.39n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 437,993,223 %67.51 %3.33 %31.72n/a7 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 369,446,506 %78.65 %2.81 %34.52n/a8 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 340,976,075 %67.68 %2.59 %37.11n/a9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 338,719,862 %63.51 %2.57 %39.69n/a

10 176 STATE FARM GRP 322,045,071 %63.16 %2.45 %42.13n/a11 159 RELIANCE GRP 304,653,030 %74.44 %2.31 %44.45n/a12 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 296,702,895 %51.28 %2.25 %46.70n/a13 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 270,380,835 %74.26 %2.05 %48.76n/a14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 247,619,233 %72.83 %1.88 %50.64n/a15 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 229,822,326 %80.51 %1.75 %52.38n/a16 162 ROYAL GRP 222,780,819 %95.22 %1.69 %54.07n/a17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 200,458,415 %80.98 %1.52 %55.60n/a18 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 199,623,642 %81.51 %1.52 %57.11n/a19 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 189,512,730 %70.35 %1.44 %58.55n/a20 69 FARMERS INS GRP 181,572,764 %73.89 %1.38 %59.93n/a21 164 ST PAUL GRP 175,474,024 %61.46 %1.33 %61.27n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners156

Page 165: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

19.3, 19.4 - Commercial Auto Liability

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 164,298,092 %71.93 %1.25 %62.51n/a23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 158,134,001 %70.08 %1.20 %63.71n/a24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 137,536,938 %73.81 %1.04 %64.76n/a25 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 129,664,155 %67.79 %0.98 %65.74n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 13,164,679,780 %69.96 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 761,934,547 %83.36 %8.72 %8.72n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 500,855,863 %99.54 %5.73 %14.45n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 489,913,901 %92.51 %5.61 %20.06n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 435,580,993 %106.22 %4.99 %25.05n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 410,724,553 %78.91 %4.70 %29.75n/a6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 410,139,717 %93.91 %4.69 %34.44n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 370,950,884 %69.14 %4.25 %38.69n/a8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 301,847,237 %123.55 %3.46 %42.15n/a9 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 298,697,553 %105.79 %3.42 %45.56n/a

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 227,190,841 %101.66 %2.60 %48.17n/a11 176 STATE FARM GRP 186,169,104 %60.47 %2.13 %50.30n/a12 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 174,554,130 %80.37 %2.00 %52.29n/a13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 170,439,431 %90.13 %1.95 %54.24n/a14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 155,408,478 %86.97 %1.78 %56.02n/a15 162 ROYAL GRP 135,295,850 %73.81 %1.55 %57.57n/a16 164 ST PAUL GRP 132,615,048 %75.79 %1.52 %59.09n/a17 159 RELIANCE GRP 128,465,383 %87.50 %1.47 %60.56n/a18 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 116,721,446 %62.81 %1.34 %61.90n/a19 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 114,252,127 %96.36 %1.31 %63.20n/a20 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 109,759,680 %74.53 %1.26 %64.46n/a21 69 FARMERS INS GRP 106,472,555 %99.85 %1.22 %65.68n/a22 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 96,051,000 %70.56 %1.10 %66.78n/a23 148 OHIO CAS GRP 87,865,299 %73.47 %1.01 %67.79n/a24 44 AVIVA GRP 86,284,987 %94.94 %0.99 %68.77n/a25 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 81,607,294 %97.15 %0.93 %69.71n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 8,736,291,761 %92.90 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners157

Page 166: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 443,280,677 %51.22 %7.67 %7.6751.06%2 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 379,116,722 %54.45 %6.56 %14.2454.62%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 318,404,681 %51.32 %5.51 %19.7552.44%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 317,093,925 %55.42 %5.49 %25.2456.12%5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 213,860,649 %52.63 %3.70 %28.9453.96%6 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 197,012,131 %50.84 %3.41 %32.3551.21%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 190,822,848 %59.92 %3.30 %35.6661.55%8 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 164,226,951 %62.55 %2.84 %38.5063.57%9 176 STATE FARM GRP 145,469,844 %53.53 %2.52 %41.0253.78%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 136,071,703 %51.81 %2.36 %43.3852.68%11 796 QBE INS GRP 118,464,627 %53.15 %2.05 %45.4358.93%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 110,939,126 %51.09 %1.92 %47.3552.17%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 107,643,880 %59.49 %1.86 %49.2159.18%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 102,500,055 %35.36 %1.77 %50.9835.91%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 97,300,758 %62.05 %1.68 %52.6762.98%16 306 CUNA MUT GRP 94,792,201 %49.47 %1.64 %54.3149.48%17 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 85,156,866 %71.79 %1.47 %55.7872.44%18 218 CNA INS GRP 83,622,013 %48.01 %1.45 %57.2352.04%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 81,126,100 %51.41 %1.40 %58.6451.81%20 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 60,990,576 %59.70 %1.06 %59.6965.12%21 361 MUNICH RE GRP 60,904,074 %64.54 %1.05 %60.7568.14%22 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 60,678,035 %63.15 %1.05 %61.8063.41%23 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 56,507,692 %43.17 %0.98 %62.7843.64%24 62 EMC INS CO GRP 55,533,691 %57.53 %0.96 %63.7457.78%25 228 WESTFIELD GRP 53,148,519 %52.97 %0.92 %64.6653.97%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,776,043,591 %53.88 %100.00 %100.0055.04%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 459,142,712 %54.86 %7.02 %7.0256.24%2 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 443,843,032 %60.56 %6.78 %13.8060.93%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 389,129,498 %57.47 %5.95 %19.7458.36%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 353,035,944 %63.71 %5.39 %25.1464.71%5 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 279,840,632 %56.44 %4.28 %29.4157.03%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 236,462,787 %53.91 %3.61 %33.0355.96%7 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 214,940,478 %51.79 %3.28 %36.3151.92%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 201,828,951 %62.99 %3.08 %39.4064.17%9 176 STATE FARM GRP 156,706,264 %61.25 %2.39 %41.7961.40%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 156,301,133 %59.26 %2.39 %44.1857.92%11 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 153,937,893 %75.04 %2.35 %46.5375.66%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 136,766,615 %56.30 %2.09 %48.6257.83%13 796 QBE INS GRP 130,817,953 %56.94 %2.00 %50.6261.33%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 124,440,531 %37.21 %1.90 %52.5237.62%15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 116,711,649 %61.31 %1.78 %54.3062.25%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 101,563,329 %65.80 %1.55 %55.8666.68%17 218 CNA INS GRP 87,301,544 %80.67 %1.33 %57.1983.38%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners158

Page 167: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 213 ERIE INS GRP 86,450,920 %49.08 %1.32 %58.5149.39%19 10499 CHRYSLER INS CO 79,971,014 %65.53 %1.22 %59.7364.43%20 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 78,768,993 %101.76 %1.20 %60.94106.80%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 74,655,855 %70.32 %1.14 %62.0870.61%22 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 74,129,539 %58.22 %1.13 %63.2163.29%23 306 CUNA MUT GRP 68,076,153 %52.78 %1.04 %64.2552.80%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 59,466,643 %70.82 %0.91 %65.1671.24%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 59,457,081 %39.25 %0.91 %66.0743.13%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,544,502,527 %57.73 %100.00 %100.0058.92%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 483,976,622 %58.16 %6.68 %6.6858.36%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 472,286,676 %41.16 %6.52 %13.2041.74%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 442,876,500 %50.65 %6.12 %19.3250.69%4 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 372,201,632 %44.90 %5.14 %24.4645.60%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 282,671,449 %54.59 %3.90 %28.3655.18%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 260,901,830 %49.72 %3.60 %31.9650.67%7 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 231,622,161 %48.87 %3.20 %35.1649.18%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 202,137,453 %63.20 %2.79 %37.9564.04%9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 176,473,759 %52.27 %2.44 %40.3953.29%

10 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 169,803,668 %47.71 %2.34 %42.7448.15%11 176 STATE FARM GRP 162,790,528 %58.07 %2.25 %44.9858.37%12 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 148,865,176 %37.90 %2.06 %47.0438.29%13 796 QBE INS GRP 148,259,153 %52.83 %2.05 %49.0955.14%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 144,158,446 %50.59 %1.99 %51.0852.13%15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 127,299,544 %56.72 %1.76 %52.8357.74%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 109,056,185 %52.30 %1.51 %54.3452.88%17 218 CNA INS GRP 103,274,290 %51.52 %1.43 %55.7752.33%18 306 CUNA MUT GRP 100,493,669 %54.50 %1.39 %57.1554.53%19 163 SAFECO INS GRP 94,358,077 %61.13 %1.30 %58.4661.59%20 213 ERIE INS GRP 92,266,789 %46.82 %1.27 %59.7347.09%21 10499 CHRYSLER INS CO 89,853,049 %38.49 %1.24 %60.9738.52%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 84,670,029 %58.82 %1.17 %62.1459.07%23 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 81,119,165 %115.04 %1.12 %63.26119.28%24 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 79,113,332 %51.48 %1.09 %64.3554.88%25 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 76,524,250 %52.96 %1.06 %65.4153.92%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 7,242,170,027 %50.94 %100.00 %100.0051.96%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 609,249,363 %59.56 %7.90 %7.9059.75%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 490,779,102 %50.15 %6.36 %14.2651.52%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners159

Page 168: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 479,213,960 %57.31 %6.21 %20.4857.66%4 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 455,393,707 %52.05 %5.91 %26.3854.17%5 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 260,659,471 %49.23 %3.38 %29.7650.44%6 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 246,052,726 %45.95 %3.19 %32.9546.22%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 219,924,431 %52.95 %2.85 %35.8153.83%8 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 215,575,155 %45.00 %2.80 %38.6045.80%9 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 206,399,496 %59.67 %2.68 %41.2860.34%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 177,271,078 %55.13 %2.30 %43.5856.38%11 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 165,345,086 %36.95 %2.14 %45.7237.56%12 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 149,189,108 %77.75 %1.93 %47.6678.06%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 145,543,196 %50.15 %1.89 %49.5451.33%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 136,315,211 %43.49 %1.77 %51.3144.70%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 123,489,251 %48.78 %1.60 %52.9149.04%16 306 CUNA MUT GRP 116,590,299 %42.15 %1.51 %54.4242.06%17 218 CNA INS GRP 114,761,405 %50.74 %1.49 %55.9153.39%18 517 HANNOVER GRP 103,540,086 %42.08 %1.34 %57.2648.03%19 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 100,977,686 %40.44 %1.31 %58.5640.35%20 213 ERIE INS GRP 98,653,934 %39.60 %1.28 %59.8439.77%21 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 95,892,332 %50.47 %1.24 %61.0953.57%22 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 92,511,301 %89.48 %1.20 %62.2992.29%23 163 SAFECO INS GRP 91,232,369 %50.64 %1.18 %63.4751.19%24 169 SENTRY INS GRP 85,992,776 %62.71 %1.12 %64.5963.27%25 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 83,261,654 %49.01 %1.08 %65.6649.40%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 7,711,588,447 %50.49 %100.00 %100.0051.59%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 566,191,622 %66.73 %7.31 %7.3166.98%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 520,094,926 %44.90 %6.71 %14.0246.13%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 446,711,208 %40.37 %5.77 %19.7941.42%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 439,797,129 %63.02 %5.68 %25.4763.35%5 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 257,713,325 %43.32 %3.33 %28.8043.95%6 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 228,076,066 %50.24 %2.94 %31.7450.85%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 227,167,365 %44.15 %2.93 %34.6745.31%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 210,842,365 %47.47 %2.72 %37.4048.65%9 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 204,397,080 %70.82 %2.64 %40.0471.12%

10 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 195,334,461 %57.93 %2.52 %42.5658.55%11 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 178,130,427 %40.39 %2.30 %44.8640.83%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 164,889,013 %48.39 %2.13 %46.9950.46%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 140,958,959 %47.26 %1.82 %48.8148.55%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 134,928,465 %46.88 %1.74 %50.5548.73%15 218 CNA INS GRP 127,721,746 %50.56 %1.65 %52.2053.55%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 124,524,491 %44.52 %1.61 %53.8045.17%17 306 CUNA MUT GRP 119,148,835 %54.84 %1.54 %55.3454.86%18 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 109,134,623 %71.56 %1.41 %56.7571.54%19 517 HANNOVER GRP 104,738,915 %37.48 %1.35 %58.1042.85%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners160

Page 169: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 213 ERIE INS GRP 102,720,410 %37.76 %1.33 %59.4338.11%21 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 101,283,700 %81.11 %1.31 %60.7482.77%22 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 96,959,984 %54.10 %1.25 %61.9956.18%23 163 SAFECO INS GRP 89,597,656 %50.01 %1.16 %63.1550.97%24 169 SENTRY INS GRP 88,252,173 %48.93 %1.14 %64.2950.37%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 87,456,039 %36.62 %1.13 %65.4140.53%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 7,745,636,943 %50.08 %100.00 %100.0051.30%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 212 ZURICH INS GRP 387,419,962 %71.00 %6.40 %6.4072.12%2 176 STATE FARM GRP 343,841,050 %74.34 %5.68 %12.0874.72%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 229,638,389 %76.36 %3.79 %15.8776.75%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 207,544,194 %54.88 %3.43 %19.2955.42%5 44 AVIVA GRP 198,953,478 %60.53 %3.29 %22.5861.38%6 218 CNA INS GRP 190,223,142 %86.32 %3.14 %25.7285.79%7 164 ST PAUL GRP 165,490,931 %61.00 %2.73 %28.4558.31%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 158,510,397 %51.57 %2.62 %31.0752.22%9 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 155,760,856 %75.43 %2.57 %33.6476.74%

10 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 148,369,576 %61.07 %2.45 %36.0961.40%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 142,395,095 %78.93 %2.35 %38.4579.66%12 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 137,876,668 %63.40 %2.28 %40.7266.53%13 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 133,635,955 %62.05 %2.21 %42.9362.54%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 126,620,594 %68.58 %2.09 %45.0270.38%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 116,296,408 %71.39 %1.92 %46.9472.07%16 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 106,018,399 %85.75 %1.75 %48.6990.17%17 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 102,057,297 %78.90 %1.69 %50.3879.73%18 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 92,073,831 %66.12 %1.52 %51.9066.23%19 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 90,391,210 %97.32 %1.49 %53.39104.98%20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 87,958,984 %71.89 %1.45 %54.8472.44%21 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 86,419,254 %46.15 %1.43 %56.2746.51%22 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 75,852,558 %65.88 %1.25 %57.5267.56%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 74,181,449 %71.39 %1.22 %58.7571.29%24 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 70,066,770 %75.10 %1.16 %59.9073.11%25 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 67,661,427 %60.86 %1.12 %61.0263.18%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 6,055,729,077 %69.90 %100.00 %100.0071.16%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 176 STATE FARM GRP 262,542,776 %75.42 %5.37 %5.37n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 231,358,251 %59.67 %4.73 %10.11n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 164,004,097 %67.46 %3.36 %13.46n/a4 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 162,539,246 %73.85 %3.33 %16.79n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners161

Page 170: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 132,149,072 %50.74 %2.70 %19.50n/a6 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 126,028,116 %46.83 %2.58 %22.07n/a7 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 123,107,437 %55.37 %2.52 %24.59n/a8 1 AETNA GRP 112,796,859 %42.48 %2.31 %26.90n/a9 165 BALBOA INS GRP (THE) 106,773,564 %48.18 %2.19 %29.09n/a

10 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 103,019,494 %49.82 %2.11 %31.20n/a11 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 98,883,556 %71.47 %2.02 %33.22n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 96,692,350 %52.75 %1.98 %35.20n/a13 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 88,843,515 %67.98 %1.82 %37.02n/a14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 84,907,557 %63.54 %1.74 %38.75n/a15 41 CITIGROUP GRP 84,643,955 %51.88 %1.73 %40.49n/a16 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 82,390,847 %71.94 %1.69 %42.17n/a17 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 81,782,036 %52.50 %1.67 %43.85n/a18 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 77,219,531 %78.29 %1.58 %45.43n/a19 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 76,993,833 %52.63 %1.58 %47.00n/a20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 73,886,992 %61.79 %1.51 %48.52n/a21 164 ST PAUL GRP 69,597,735 %53.81 %1.42 %49.94n/a22 1111 TIG INS GRP 68,834,351 %46.78 %1.41 %51.35n/a23 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 60,737,886 %64.65 %1.24 %52.59n/a24 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 55,289,819 %55.73 %1.13 %53.72n/a25 44 AVIVA GRP 54,439,346 %52.36 %1.11 %54.84n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,886,219,700 %58.92 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 271,209,381 %47.55 %5.65 %5.65n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 222,351,097 %53.60 %4.63 %10.28n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 220,847,430 %62.52 %4.60 %14.87n/a4 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 196,942,166 %72.98 %4.10 %18.97n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 179,421,864 %34.70 %3.74 %22.71n/a6 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 147,869,446 %42.16 %3.08 %25.79n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 119,721,329 %44.09 %2.49 %28.28n/a8 1111 TIG INS GRP 113,900,081 %51.68 %2.37 %30.65n/a9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 110,869,207 %50.58 %2.31 %32.96n/a

10 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 105,727,987 %41.43 %2.20 %35.16n/a11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 99,028,580 %58.97 %2.06 %37.22n/a12 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 92,974,958 %51.36 %1.94 %39.16n/a13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 90,404,407 %43.98 %1.88 %41.04n/a14 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 86,506,463 %44.58 %1.80 %42.84n/a15 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 86,489,366 %40.54 %1.80 %44.64n/a16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 77,433,935 %57.68 %1.61 %46.25n/a17 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 72,192,194 %52.56 %1.50 %47.76n/a18 69 FARMERS INS GRP 69,803,124 %51.08 %1.45 %49.21n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 69,364,865 %44.66 %1.44 %50.65n/a20 165 BALBOA INS GRP (THE) 68,318,726 %43.57 %1.42 %52.07n/a21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 65,283,562 %53.51 %1.36 %53.43n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners162

Page 171: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

21.2 - Commercial Auto Physical Damage

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 64,174,346 %75.62 %1.34 %54.77n/a23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 59,592,594 %44.33 %1.24 %56.01n/a24 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 55,780,355 %47.57 %1.16 %57.17n/a25 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 53,181,418 %37.78 %1.11 %58.28n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,803,425,051 %49.57 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 306,172,188 %59.95 %7.09 %7.09n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 219,417,822 %59.54 %5.08 %12.17n/a3 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 160,841,032 %60.11 %3.72 %15.89n/a4 176 STATE FARM GRP 160,808,584 %64.61 %3.72 %19.62n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 156,566,036 %59.23 %3.63 %23.24n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 145,439,136 %52.15 %3.37 %26.61n/a7 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 141,562,210 %63.94 %3.28 %29.89n/a8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 131,874,879 %65.72 %3.05 %32.94n/a9 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 128,664,096 %54.43 %2.98 %35.92n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 106,161,490 %94.37 %2.46 %38.38n/a11 217 CENTRAL NATL INS CO PR GRP 106,109,648 %57.89 %2.46 %40.84n/a12 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 99,082,710 %85.25 %2.29 %43.13n/a13 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 78,468,106 %44.21 %1.82 %44.95n/a14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 78,089,052 %67.39 %1.81 %46.76n/a15 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 71,296,249 %46.86 %1.65 %48.41n/a16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 65,185,014 %63.61 %1.51 %49.92n/a17 69 FARMERS INS GRP 60,778,635 %71.54 %1.41 %51.32n/a18 1111 TIG INS GRP 59,382,733 %77.91 %1.38 %52.70n/a19 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 58,609,040 %61.10 %1.36 %54.06n/a20 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 53,735,090 %76.09 %1.24 %55.30n/a21 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 50,141,030 %64.42 %1.16 %56.46n/a22 159 RELIANCE GRP 47,808,820 %53.94 %1.11 %57.57n/a23 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 47,801,513 %63.60 %1.11 %58.68n/a24 29343 NATIONAL COUNTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO 47,783,091 %78.87 %1.11 %59.78n/a25 164 ST PAUL GRP 47,432,014 %50.62 %1.10 %60.88n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,318,668,522 %61.56 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners163

Page 172: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,013,836,417 %43.03 %8.18 %8.1845.21%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,647,589,763 %43.24 %6.69 %14.8848.24%3 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,609,250,258 %50.03 %6.54 %21.4153.50%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,552,023,323 %55.26 %6.31 %27.7258.07%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,119,419,954 %59.77 %4.55 %32.2767.55%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 959,616,915 %59.41 %3.90 %36.1663.88%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 675,459,510 %58.39 %2.74 %38.9164.78%8 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 566,205,058 %64.00 %2.30 %41.2167.03%9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 547,888,538 %51.38 %2.23 %43.4352.25%

10 176 STATE FARM GRP 497,303,861 %59.75 %2.02 %45.4664.73%11 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 469,884,769 %61.60 %1.91 %47.3666.46%12 796 QBE INS GRP 464,968,849 %48.89 %1.89 %49.2555.56%13 218 CNA INS GRP 462,044,962 %67.86 %1.88 %51.1374.20%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 426,162,772 %48.92 %1.73 %52.8653.09%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 388,948,936 %54.48 %1.58 %54.4457.91%16 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 384,747,821 %41.60 %1.56 %56.0144.35%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 326,800,992 %47.56 %1.33 %57.3355.52%18 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 316,676,172 %76.96 %1.29 %58.6286.41%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 301,070,086 %43.38 %1.22 %59.8446.83%20 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 296,134,004 %59.84 %1.20 %61.0562.60%21 93 STATE NATL GRP 262,609,113 %61.92 %1.07 %62.1168.59%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 245,990,186 %91.34 %1.00 %63.1197.14%23 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 229,378,052 %49.48 %0.93 %64.0453.20%24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 226,381,656 %52.16 %0.92 %64.9655.04%25 62 EMC INS CO GRP 220,119,566 %53.28 %0.89 %65.8656.27%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 24,614,500,009 %53.07 %100.00 %100.0058.27%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,061,752,193 %49.27 %7.62 %7.6253.12%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,817,491,877 %58.22 %6.72 %14.3462.20%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,800,169,457 %55.45 %6.65 %20.9960.87%4 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,730,626,107 %61.84 %6.40 %27.3964.84%5 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,400,120,283 %53.52 %5.17 %32.5656.28%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,032,649,756 %59.74 %3.82 %36.3863.82%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 726,797,254 %62.73 %2.69 %39.0666.79%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 610,294,441 %49.00 %2.26 %41.3252.48%9 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 609,309,300 %54.73 %2.25 %43.5760.08%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 607,932,346 %53.53 %2.25 %45.8256.48%11 176 STATE FARM GRP 528,485,814 %62.79 %1.95 %47.7767.88%12 218 CNA INS GRP 526,196,758 %72.71 %1.94 %49.7277.49%13 796 QBE INS GRP 499,001,372 %42.29 %1.84 %51.5648.85%14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 475,412,550 %59.22 %1.76 %53.3263.60%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 448,375,646 %43.13 %1.66 %54.9846.03%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 404,550,959 %60.69 %1.50 %56.4764.63%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 321,923,182 %33.59 %1.19 %57.6639.23%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners164

Page 173: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 169 SENTRY INS GRP 315,145,563 %67.93 %1.16 %58.8271.92%19 213 ERIE INS GRP 311,178,325 %47.96 %1.15 %59.9750.64%20 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 303,301,629 %77.21 %1.12 %61.1086.23%21 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 300,563,069 %60.04 %1.11 %62.2162.25%22 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 296,183,925 %35.90 %1.09 %63.3036.96%23 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 279,840,632 %56.50 %1.03 %64.3457.10%24 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 265,145,974 %63.39 %0.98 %65.3275.35%25 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 249,953,426 %53.32 %0.92 %66.2456.04%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 27,056,966,770 %54.77 %100.00 %100.0059.31%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,175,953,998 %46.21 %7.44 %7.4450.76%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,948,587,246 %52.25 %6.66 %14.1062.07%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,882,115,331 %59.62 %6.43 %20.5362.50%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,547,585,081 %51.71 %5.29 %25.8260.17%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,498,307,266 %52.27 %5.12 %30.9455.79%6 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,142,898,738 %57.58 %3.91 %34.8561.61%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 759,770,300 %62.31 %2.60 %37.4468.13%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 662,439,807 %52.65 %2.26 %39.7155.66%9 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 659,837,160 %53.13 %2.26 %41.9658.82%

10 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 650,434,080 %60.11 %2.22 %44.1964.64%11 218 CNA INS GRP 598,434,894 %45.80 %2.05 %46.2347.14%12 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 575,201,435 %78.77 %1.97 %48.2083.00%13 176 STATE FARM GRP 540,112,612 %56.79 %1.85 %50.0460.47%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 530,988,833 %43.49 %1.81 %51.8646.85%15 796 QBE INS GRP 527,976,140 %56.08 %1.80 %53.6659.95%16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 482,410,869 %59.68 %1.65 %55.3163.87%17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 464,339,403 %48.46 %1.59 %56.9053.19%18 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 424,648,397 %54.34 %1.45 %58.3557.83%19 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 372,201,632 %44.90 %1.27 %59.6245.60%20 169 SENTRY INS GRP 368,757,937 %52.17 %1.26 %60.8855.16%21 262 CANAL GRP 362,959,972 %70.24 %1.24 %62.1281.71%22 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 324,009,590 %62.10 %1.11 %63.2372.51%23 626 ACE LTD GRP 323,977,281 %54.42 %1.11 %64.3466.65%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 316,613,045 %51.10 %1.08 %65.4253.97%25 213 ERIE INS GRP 315,979,190 %44.61 %1.08 %66.5046.07%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 29,257,232,299 %53.05 %100.00 %100.0058.23%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,091,419,511 %43.57 %6.83 %6.8345.79%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 2,011,032,467 %55.88 %6.57 %13.4059.38%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners165

Page 174: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,980,784,133 %52.85 %6.47 %19.8755.58%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,441,652,021 %47.76 %4.71 %24.5853.99%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,316,040,065 %49.38 %4.30 %28.8854.05%6 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,254,478,456 %58.09 %4.10 %32.9860.93%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,164,410,741 %58.98 %3.80 %36.7862.58%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 792,804,818 %63.40 %2.59 %39.3768.38%9 218 CNA INS GRP 789,492,187 %58.87 %2.58 %41.9561.54%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 717,040,150 %54.76 %2.34 %44.2956.33%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 699,803,597 %54.84 %2.29 %46.5858.95%12 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 661,316,525 %63.52 %2.16 %48.7467.44%13 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 645,634,196 %49.32 %2.11 %50.8555.22%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 591,648,510 %45.46 %1.93 %52.7848.14%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 450,248,558 %45.15 %1.47 %54.2547.82%16 163 SAFECO INS GRP 449,724,815 %50.15 %1.47 %55.7254.32%17 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 448,190,314 %53.56 %1.46 %57.1956.63%18 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 398,354,492 %60.53 %1.30 %58.4968.68%19 262 CANAL GRP 384,707,078 %71.33 %1.26 %59.7476.75%20 517 HANNOVER GRP 377,540,796 %46.20 %1.23 %60.9857.40%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 373,217,529 %69.37 %1.22 %62.2073.83%22 626 ACE LTD GRP 362,330,996 %46.91 %1.18 %63.3857.71%23 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 327,078,253 %32.28 %1.07 %64.4539.06%24 213 ERIE INS GRP 322,172,778 %50.58 %1.05 %65.5053.56%25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 312,892,617 %49.00 %1.02 %66.5251.66%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 30,612,065,972 %52.18 %100.00 %100.0056.39%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 2,143,341,183 %46.65 %7.01 %7.0149.33%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,979,425,009 %55.26 %6.47 %13.4859.50%3 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 1,917,982,552 %53.40 %6.27 %19.7557.04%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,574,280,809 %63.50 %5.15 %24.8971.54%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,252,084,130 %47.19 %4.09 %28.9951.73%6 176 STATE FARM GRP 1,156,986,469 %59.72 %3.78 %32.7761.58%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,027,989,519 %52.55 %3.36 %36.1355.35%8 218 CNA INS GRP 847,128,121 %61.25 %2.77 %38.9067.16%9 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 776,705,784 %60.78 %2.54 %41.4465.01%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 755,592,543 %49.52 %2.47 %43.9154.25%11 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 712,393,368 %53.30 %2.33 %46.2356.70%12 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 626,272,467 %50.47 %2.05 %48.2855.83%13 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 621,296,065 %61.10 %2.03 %50.3168.53%14 1326 KINGSWAY GRP 620,409,883 %65.97 %2.03 %52.3472.69%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 448,021,677 %51.45 %1.46 %53.8053.91%16 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 444,359,722 %69.56 %1.45 %55.2678.42%17 163 SAFECO INS GRP 420,579,865 %39.70 %1.37 %56.6341.94%18 262 CANAL GRP 413,934,612 %68.30 %1.35 %57.9875.46%19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 394,227,447 %48.26 %1.29 %59.2753.27%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners166

Page 175: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 517 HANNOVER GRP 383,559,645 %34.67 %1.25 %60.5345.42%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 376,435,150 %53.21 %1.23 %61.7657.78%22 626 ACE LTD GRP 367,912,607 %29.14 %1.20 %62.9635.93%23 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 357,267,879 %35.99 %1.17 %64.1342.63%24 213 ERIE INS GRP 330,387,882 %54.98 %1.08 %65.2158.83%25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 309,546,592 %33.46 %1.01 %66.2236.90%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 30,592,055,116 %52.95 %100.00 %100.0057.73%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,342,686,483 %78.56 %6.34 %6.3483.56%2 218 CNA INS GRP 935,591,045 %83.46 %4.42 %10.7786.58%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 927,748,883 %73.83 %4.38 %15.1577.17%4 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 863,428,653 %104.53 %4.08 %19.23112.52%5 164 ST PAUL GRP 792,071,679 %65.48 %3.74 %22.9768.90%6 44 AVIVA GRP 739,689,410 %86.48 %3.50 %26.4790.23%7 176 STATE FARM GRP 716,610,315 %67.33 %3.39 %29.8569.88%8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 610,515,656 %94.71 %2.88 %32.74101.25%9 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 582,153,278 %60.59 %2.75 %35.4964.22%

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 527,147,555 %75.95 %2.49 %37.9882.25%11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 446,080,604 %80.09 %2.11 %40.0985.73%12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 438,323,202 %71.62 %2.07 %42.1681.80%13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 434,403,214 %68.50 %2.05 %44.2177.51%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 424,666,288 %72.00 %2.01 %46.2275.59%15 163 SAFECO INS GRP 421,986,842 %76.49 %1.99 %48.2179.87%16 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 369,196,764 %77.27 %1.74 %49.9684.19%17 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 323,045,313 %72.94 %1.53 %51.4878.34%18 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 286,861,338 %70.09 %1.36 %52.8473.42%19 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 275,019,348 %109.48 %1.30 %54.14114.03%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 273,066,724 %85.10 %1.29 %55.4388.96%21 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 271,351,222 %75.25 %1.28 %56.7181.72%22 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 268,268,157 %97.99 %1.27 %57.98109.59%23 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 243,443,075 %94.60 %1.15 %59.13101.27%24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 228,594,652 %66.30 %1.08 %60.2175.20%25 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 215,550,591 %77.17 %1.02 %61.2384.75%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 21,163,160,306 %77.81 %100.00 %100.0083.41%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 879,323,241 %61.60 %4.76 %4.76n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 844,281,119 %65.67 %4.57 %9.33n/a3 176 STATE FARM GRP 662,908,772 %65.95 %3.59 %12.92n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 630,002,760 %75.12 %3.41 %16.33n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners167

Page 176: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 1 AETNA GRP 505,765,810 %55.73 %2.74 %19.07n/a6 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 489,833,085 %70.91 %2.65 %21.72n/a7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 464,652,517 %63.51 %2.52 %24.24n/a8 41 CITIGROUP GRP 464,207,347 %61.47 %2.51 %26.75n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 460,271,623 %62.08 %2.49 %29.24n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 433,298,373 %91.67 %2.35 %31.59n/a11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 423,907,611 %72.49 %2.30 %33.89n/a12 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 387,833,826 %54.29 %2.10 %35.98n/a13 159 RELIANCE GRP 345,213,089 %70.71 %1.87 %37.85n/a14 164 ST PAUL GRP 344,047,107 %52.36 %1.86 %39.72n/a15 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 318,015,207 %71.15 %1.72 %41.44n/a16 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 282,308,649 %72.54 %1.53 %42.97n/a17 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 274,312,373 %66.43 %1.49 %44.45n/a18 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 273,824,888 %63.97 %1.48 %45.93n/a19 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 252,063,378 %59.29 %1.36 %47.30n/a20 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 241,167,791 %56.10 %1.31 %48.61n/a21 1111 TIG INS GRP 235,523,049 %71.58 %1.28 %49.88n/a22 44 AVIVA GRP 235,342,823 %58.53 %1.27 %51.15n/a23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 218,149,195 %41.20 %1.18 %52.34n/a24 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 206,860,855 %78.44 %1.12 %53.46n/a25 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 202,078,375 %62.15 %1.09 %54.55n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 18,469,678,188 %64.83 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,265,421,766 %64.99 %7.04 %7.04n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 952,629,232 %64.06 %5.30 %12.34n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 896,478,662 %75.31 %4.99 %17.33n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 796,724,177 %65.27 %4.43 %21.77n/a5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 709,269,657 %72.30 %3.95 %25.72n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 557,714,552 %62.40 %3.10 %28.82n/a7 176 STATE FARM GRP 542,892,501 %62.90 %3.02 %31.84n/a8 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 455,935,872 %71.02 %2.54 %34.38n/a9 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 446,704,062 %61.33 %2.49 %36.86n/a

10 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 444,572,341 %48.00 %2.47 %39.34n/a11 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 429,124,269 %59.52 %2.39 %41.73n/a12 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 363,355,793 %68.24 %2.02 %43.75n/a13 159 RELIANCE GRP 348,424,596 %70.47 %1.94 %45.69n/a14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 325,053,168 %69.19 %1.81 %47.50n/a15 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 276,019,193 %62.04 %1.54 %49.03n/a16 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 269,508,844 %75.72 %1.50 %50.53n/a17 162 ROYAL GRP 269,252,255 %85.88 %1.50 %52.03n/a18 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 253,639,833 %71.90 %1.41 %53.44n/a19 69 FARMERS INS GRP 251,375,888 %67.54 %1.40 %54.84n/a20 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 245,926,305 %74.83 %1.37 %56.21n/a21 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 233,662,957 %63.81 %1.30 %57.51n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners168

Page 177: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Total Commercial Auto

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 164 ST PAUL GRP 213,245,023 %58.68 %1.19 %58.70n/a23 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 199,818,986 %71.61 %1.11 %59.81n/a24 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 197,129,532 %64.64 %1.10 %60.91n/a25 1111 TIG INS GRP 195,449,983 %54.06 %1.09 %62.00n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 17,968,104,831 %64.40 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,068,106,735 %76.18 %8.18 %8.18n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 720,273,685 %86.74 %5.52 %13.70n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 588,996,611 %91.18 %4.51 %18.21n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 567,290,589 %73.28 %4.35 %22.56n/a5 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 564,245,089 %93.83 %4.32 %26.88n/a6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 516,390,020 %64.06 %3.96 %30.83n/a7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 516,301,207 %94.00 %3.95 %34.79n/a8 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 459,538,585 %89.32 %3.52 %38.31n/a9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 433,722,116 %105.44 %3.32 %41.63n/a

10 176 STATE FARM GRP 346,977,688 %62.42 %2.66 %44.29n/a11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 305,279,893 %91.74 %2.34 %46.63n/a12 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 253,022,236 %66.98 %1.94 %48.57n/a13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 224,174,521 %86.26 %1.72 %50.28n/a14 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 220,593,492 %79.31 %1.69 %51.97n/a15 162 ROYAL GRP 180,935,165 %69.02 %1.39 %53.36n/a16 164 ST PAUL GRP 180,047,062 %68.60 %1.38 %54.74n/a17 159 RELIANCE GRP 176,274,203 %78.14 %1.35 %56.09n/a18 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 168,368,720 %69.77 %1.29 %57.38n/a19 69 FARMERS INS GRP 167,251,190 %89.95 %1.28 %58.66n/a20 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 157,033,283 %57.21 %1.20 %59.86n/a21 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 152,903,543 %73.06 %1.17 %61.03n/a22 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 151,835,406 %85.10 %1.16 %62.20n/a23 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 146,192,030 %68.40 %1.12 %63.32n/a24 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 142,553,264 %63.79 %1.09 %64.41n/a25 217 CENTRAL NATL INS CO PR GRP 132,969,987 %101.07 %1.02 %65.43n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 13,054,960,283 %82.19 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners169

Page 178: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 384,622,411 %45.51 %19.34 %19.3456.10%2 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 290,909,181 %82.54 %14.63 %33.9689.42%3 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 205,098,735 %62.52 %10.31 %44.2774.22%4 1285 XL AMER GRP 141,519,778 %47.48 %7.11 %51.3960.82%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 123,327,728 %8.85 %6.20 %57.599.67%6 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 117,181,415 %52.00 %5.89 %63.4862.24%7 361 MUNICH RE GRP 99,926,694 %28.20 %5.02 %68.5026.18%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 87,967,520 %28.10 %4.42 %72.9231.12%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 86,467,108 %50.12 %4.35 %77.2761.93%

10 1279 ARCH INS GRP 81,026,687 %148.44 %4.07 %81.34154.49%11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 69,878,553 %60.69 %3.51 %84.8659.60%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 50,509,030 %59.75 %2.54 %87.4066.16%13 4574 CATLIN US INS GRP 41,434,183 %48.23 %2.08 %89.4850.13%14 181 SWISS RE GRP 36,678,350 %74.23 %1.84 %91.3275.56%15 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 32,825,548 %52.39 %1.65 %92.9758.82%16 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 24,783,358 %46.76 %1.25 %94.2255.31%17 4509 IRONSHORE GRP 18,638,116 %48.15 %0.94 %95.1653.50%18 3478 HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP 18,613,613 %49.47 %0.94 %96.0951.22%19 968 AXA INS GRP 17,627,311 %23.60 %0.89 %96.9834.48%20 4670 STARR GRP 13,715,709 %55.15 %0.69 %97.6760.00%21 816 COMMERCE INC GRP 9,555,688 %51.10 %0.48 %98.1560.79%22 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 7,917,745 %-30.90 %0.40 %98.5574.33%23 697 VAN ENT GRP 6,761,657 %59.69 %0.34 %98.8960.29%24 749 SCOR GRP 5,972,408 %67.90 %0.30 %99.1970.94%25 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 5,133,876 %32.79 %0.26 %99.4532.79%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,989,119,458 %54.13 %100.00 %100.0062.58%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 266,276,238 %49.37 %14.09 %14.0953.13%2 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 260,182,551 %51.76 %13.77 %27.8755.40%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 233,385,617 %54.50 %12.35 %40.2257.38%4 1285 XL AMER GRP 218,580,830 %45.47 %11.57 %51.7954.08%5 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 142,471,981 %58.60 %7.54 %59.3369.53%6 626 ACE LTD GRP 132,162,149 %-33.24 %7.00 %66.33-30.33%7 361 MUNICH RE GRP 113,234,003 %61.93 %5.99 %72.3268.70%8 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 101,249,269 %46.52 %5.36 %77.6858.64%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 96,157,136 %37.57 %5.09 %82.7762.11%

10 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 56,003,043 %60.37 %2.96 %85.7474.54%11 1279 ARCH INS GRP 54,914,430 %99.44 %2.91 %88.64104.76%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 41,430,764 %35.96 %2.19 %90.8340.87%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 38,038,646 %46.01 %2.01 %92.8543.57%14 968 AXA INS GRP 32,987,509 %112.18 %1.75 %94.59117.79%15 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 31,151,042 %44.94 %1.65 %96.2452.29%16 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 21,064,214 %64.48 %1.11 %97.3670.27%17 3478 HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP 18,163,930 %49.65 %0.96 %98.3251.44%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners170

Page 179: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 749 SCOR GRP 11,688,802 %68.46 %0.62 %98.9474.12%19 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 6,786,896 %22.54 %0.36 %99.3022.54%20 697 VAN ENT GRP 5,658,645 %91.67 %0.30 %99.6091.94%21 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 3,900,920 %-119.79 %0.21 %99.80-52.18%22 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 1,450,677 %-36.56 %0.08 %99.88-40.75%23 212 ZURICH INS GRP 670,718 %259.56 %0.04 %99.92325.24%24 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 485,267 %1.91 %0.03 %99.941.72%25 1169 GENERALI GRP 456,179 %19.71 %0.02 %99.9727.57%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,889,196,689 %44.97 %100.00 %100.0054.06%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,227,892,771 %58.55 %40.87 %40.8761.08%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 327,776,293 %50.22 %10.91 %51.7855.66%3 1285 XL AMER GRP 238,108,741 %54.83 %7.93 %59.7067.68%4 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 225,379,919 %57.88 %7.50 %67.2169.85%5 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 162,975,493 %43.46 %5.42 %72.6352.58%6 626 ACE LTD GRP 149,895,677 %41.83 %4.99 %77.6246.85%7 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 117,871,860 %30.39 %3.92 %81.5433.06%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 104,594,027 %64.36 %3.48 %85.0274.09%9 361 MUNICH RE GRP 100,409,509 %78.93 %3.34 %88.3779.47%

10 1279 ARCH INS GRP 73,517,320 %42.72 %2.45 %90.8146.40%11 181 SWISS RE GRP 44,517,093 %47.59 %1.48 %92.2950.81%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 41,003,450 %34.18 %1.36 %93.6636.78%13 212 ZURICH INS GRP 37,263,665 %82.72 %1.24 %94.9089.45%14 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 32,217,330 %26.39 %1.07 %95.9756.57%15 968 AXA INS GRP 28,037,938 %5.69 %0.93 %96.902.46%16 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 23,956,920 %49.59 %0.80 %97.7054.43%17 3478 HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP 20,899,717 %52.72 %0.70 %98.4052.98%18 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 19,379,152 %49.45 %0.65 %99.0455.90%19 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 8,240,730 %30.44 %0.27 %99.3230.44%20 749 SCOR GRP 6,838,403 %63.02 %0.23 %99.5467.21%21 517 HANNOVER GRP 4,656,787 %195.38 %0.15 %99.70200.42%22 697 VAN ENT GRP 4,625,803 %57.42 %0.15 %99.8557.25%23 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 1,951,699 %23.24 %0.06 %99.9223.96%24 32727 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS 1,843,339 %124.32 %0.06 %99.98129.30%25 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 1,528,342 %-2.92 %0.05 %100.03-3.43%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,004,455,583 %53.09 %100.00 %100.0058.41%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,330,823,602 %36.16 %43.50 %43.5038.27%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 333,173,939 %26.14 %10.89 %54.4030.24%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners171

Page 180: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 1285 XL AMER GRP 274,306,702 %59.77 %8.97 %63.3670.82%4 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 176,059,176 %52.58 %5.76 %69.1261.45%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 144,026,064 %-5.33 %4.71 %73.831.83%6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 137,044,316 %38.34 %4.48 %78.3150.52%7 361 MUNICH RE GRP 115,472,330 %60.35 %3.77 %82.0866.95%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 94,930,488 %60.22 %3.10 %85.1868.42%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 91,444,718 %54.13 %2.99 %88.1760.99%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 77,128,702 %50.90 %2.52 %90.6955.28%11 968 AXA INS GRP 64,178,614 %38.79 %2.10 %92.7938.75%12 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 38,114,959 %55.78 %1.25 %94.0457.75%13 1279 ARCH INS GRP 34,568,718 %69.76 %1.13 %95.1771.83%14 181 SWISS RE GRP 34,112,499 %25.23 %1.12 %96.2828.12%15 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 28,439,060 %40.51 %0.93 %97.2147.85%16 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 22,308,623 %33.07 %0.73 %97.9433.07%17 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 21,817,318 %39.46 %0.71 %98.6644.52%18 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 18,141,313 %-50.46 %0.59 %99.25-62.00%19 3478 HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP 9,010,710 %51.89 %0.29 %99.5451.89%20 517 HANNOVER GRP 5,532,728 %80.26 %0.18 %99.7281.26%21 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 2,800,128 %4,118.17 %0.09 %99.8210,115.86%22 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 1,933,327 %69.59 %0.06 %99.8869.12%23 697 VAN ENT GRP 1,814,202 %67.67 %0.06 %99.9468.75%24 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 942,359 %-284.42 %0.03 %99.97-297.86%25 1169 GENERALI GRP 681,308 %0.00 %0.02 %99.990.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,059,082,577 %35.68 %100.00 %100.0041.67%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 1,239,907,564 %40.67 %42.34 %42.3445.81%2 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 394,017,018 %40.33 %13.45 %55.7943.91%3 1285 XL AMER GRP 311,862,923 %50.86 %10.65 %66.4448.41%4 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 168,060,964 %55.43 %5.74 %72.1867.29%5 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 135,026,996 %54.97 %4.61 %76.7967.42%6 626 ACE LTD GRP 134,763,367 %176.21 %4.60 %81.39218.14%7 361 MUNICH RE GRP 127,813,054 %63.42 %4.36 %85.7667.31%8 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 84,642,286 %35.85 %2.89 %88.6543.26%9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 75,789,920 %36.49 %2.59 %91.2440.71%

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 70,661,943 %83.44 %2.41 %93.65100.00%11 968 AXA INS GRP 46,021,187 %37.14 %1.57 %95.2237.47%12 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 34,577,094 %72.51 %1.18 %96.4082.93%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 30,635,608 %54.94 %1.05 %97.4568.19%14 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 27,423,907 %39.25 %0.94 %98.3839.25%15 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 24,030,457 %91.04 %0.82 %99.20134.98%16 2978 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP 23,396,086 %79.44 %0.80 %100.0086.69%17 1279 ARCH INS GRP 8,094,327 %33.28 %0.28 %100.2834.49%18 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 6,144,146 %-186.03 %0.21 %100.49-170.40%19 517 HANNOVER GRP 5,489,547 %-115.44 %0.19 %100.68-115.16%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners172

Page 181: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 3,544,635 %29.76 %0.12 %100.8029.34%21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 1,534,580 %50.00 %0.05 %100.8550.00%22 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 900,758 %39.17 %0.03 %100.8843.28%23 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 715,159 %-553.40 %0.02 %100.91-544.62%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,928,535,497 %50.02 %100.00 %100.0056.09%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 425,081,364 %74.28 %29.85 %29.8579.96%2 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 160,240,576 %59.63 %11.25 %41.1167.74%3 626 ACE LTD GRP 94,197,853 %49.99 %6.62 %47.7257.08%4 1285 XL AMER GRP 77,301,772 %91.54 %5.43 %53.15102.84%5 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 72,460,877 %58.26 %5.09 %58.2471.59%6 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 72,233,920 %66.40 %5.07 %63.3171.63%7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 66,572,501 %131.31 %4.68 %67.99143.22%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 54,780,558 %61.89 %3.85 %71.8467.97%9 218 CNA INS GRP 52,207,855 %73.50 %3.67 %75.5088.99%

10 164 ST PAUL GRP 51,025,262 %47.85 %3.58 %79.0954.49%11 968 AXA INS GRP 43,706,386 %92.04 %3.07 %82.1692.45%12 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 42,544,905 %51.07 %2.99 %85.1556.53%13 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 36,576,331 %54.06 %2.57 %87.7161.57%14 212 ZURICH INS GRP 32,548,475 %33.67 %2.29 %90.0039.12%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 19,539,786 %61.65 %1.37 %91.3770.11%16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 18,887,505 %120.91 %1.33 %92.70137.24%17 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 17,208,765 %106.15 %1.21 %93.91104.87%18 181 SWISS RE GRP 14,750,576 %86.18 %1.04 %94.9498.60%19 1172 LEGION INS GRP 13,171,882 %138.37 %0.93 %95.87138.80%20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 11,754,467 %78.80 %0.83 %96.6999.71%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 11,197,722 %83.72 %0.79 %97.4885.96%22 24 ATLANTIC CO GRP 9,330,652 %113.53 %0.66 %98.14127.98%23 41 CITIGROUP GRP 8,341,961 %69.40 %0.59 %98.7281.60%24 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 6,701,204 %57.67 %0.47 %99.1959.30%25 1331 GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP 6,241,070 %71.33 %0.44 %99.6384.22%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,423,859,108 %71.27 %100.00 %100.0079.18%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 340,594,026 %58.05 %23.82 %23.82n/a2 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 118,026,636 %75.24 %8.25 %32.07n/a3 968 AXA INS GRP 98,240,023 %12.27 %6.87 %38.94n/a4 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 97,193,962 %17.14 %6.80 %45.74n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 84,777,637 %55.49 %5.93 %51.67n/a6 41 CITIGROUP GRP 68,411,162 %67.92 %4.78 %56.45n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners173

Page 182: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

7 164 ST PAUL GRP 61,839,732 %51.99 %4.32 %60.78n/a8 345 AVEMCO INS GRP 59,423,016 %55.64 %4.16 %64.93n/a9 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 46,162,876 %70.51 %3.23 %68.16n/a

10 784 NAC RE CORP 41,060,000 %69.55 %2.87 %71.03n/a11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 35,612,472 %30.37 %2.49 %73.52n/a12 1 AETNA GRP 34,865,041 %64.90 %2.44 %75.96n/a13 159 RELIANCE GRP 28,345,428 %89.43 %1.98 %77.94n/a14 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 27,292,669 %63.94 %1.91 %79.85n/a15 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 25,842,738 %72.76 %1.81 %81.66n/a16 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 25,429,887 %40.67 %1.78 %83.43n/a17 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 23,116,007 %47.64 %1.62 %85.05n/a18 163 SAFECO INS GRP 21,953,349 %63.55 %1.54 %86.59n/a19 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 19,652,282 %91.15 %1.37 %87.96n/a20 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 18,559,529 %51.51 %1.30 %89.26n/a21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 16,842,365 %37.31 %1.18 %90.44n/a22 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 16,823,094 %16.03 %1.18 %91.61n/a23 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 14,292,513 %4.52 %1.00 %92.61n/a24 181 SWISS RE GRP 14,263,294 %62.21 %1.00 %93.61n/a25 162 ROYAL GRP 11,215,574 %36.24 %0.78 %94.39n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,430,000,264 %48.96 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 168,123,317 %124.07 %22.47 %22.47n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 70,259,138 %119.96 %9.39 %31.85n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 62,424,117 %53.57 %8.34 %40.20n/a4 345 AVEMCO INS GRP 48,357,105 %42.96 %6.46 %46.66n/a5 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 39,718,816 %79.11 %5.31 %51.97n/a6 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 39,637,873 %113.62 %5.30 %57.26n/a7 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 34,504,094 %63.15 %4.61 %61.87n/a8 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 33,188,862 %14.45 %4.43 %66.31n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 27,405,537 %59.57 %3.66 %69.97n/a

10 164 ST PAUL GRP 26,271,156 %96.63 %3.51 %73.48n/a11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 22,666,806 %95.54 %3.03 %76.51n/a12 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 20,796,493 %109.69 %2.78 %79.29n/a13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 20,322,521 %50.62 %2.72 %82.00n/a14 212 ZURICH INS GRP 18,574,734 %75.01 %2.48 %84.49n/a15 783 RLI INS GRP 13,648,129 %42.88 %1.82 %86.31n/a16 162 ROYAL GRP 13,477,048 %65.53 %1.80 %88.11n/a17 163 SAFECO INS GRP 11,151,169 %54.77 %1.49 %89.60n/a18 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 9,126,911 %102.19 %1.22 %90.82n/a19 1111 TIG INS GRP 8,170,859 %338.12 %1.09 %91.91n/a20 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 7,133,813 %-87.06 %0.95 %92.87n/a21 176 STATE FARM GRP 6,700,777 %97.44 %0.90 %93.76n/a22 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 6,417,241 %112.71 %0.86 %94.62n/a23 510 NAVIGATORS GRP 5,370,609 %322.18 %0.72 %95.34n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners174

Page 183: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

22 - Aircraft (all Perils)

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

24 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,208,502 %46.18 %0.56 %95.90n/a25 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 4,006,999 %53.08 %0.54 %96.43n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 748,344,389 %91.34 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 93,196,346 %90.75 %11.43 %11.43n/a2 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 82,875,314 %51.47 %10.17 %21.60n/a3 345 AVEMCO INS GRP 78,707,848 %66.66 %9.66 %31.26n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 73,943,972 %144.56 %9.07 %40.33n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 62,024,020 %89.10 %7.61 %47.94n/a6 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 60,959,684 %100.00 %7.48 %55.42n/a7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 52,345,711 %66.18 %6.42 %61.84n/a8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 48,659,702 %63.93 %5.97 %67.81n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 39,229,280 %0.00 %4.81 %72.62n/a

10 164 ST PAUL GRP 26,419,556 %69.09 %3.24 %75.86n/a11 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 23,105,496 %72.12 %2.83 %78.69n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 14,271,322 %60.78 %1.75 %80.45n/a13 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 13,354,652 %187.45 %1.64 %82.08n/a14 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 12,416,267 %105.63 %1.52 %83.61n/a15 159 RELIANCE GRP 11,703,847 %48.02 %1.44 %85.04n/a16 162 ROYAL GRP 11,129,683 %83.05 %1.37 %86.41n/a17 143 ARMCO INS INC GRP 10,693,515 %100.69 %1.31 %87.72n/a18 11487 IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO 8,298,792 %87.80 %1.02 %88.74n/a19 80 GENERAL REIN CP 8,209,528 %58.78 %1.01 %89.75n/a20 176 STATE FARM GRP 7,980,923 %74.55 %0.98 %90.72n/a21 133 MISSION EQUITIES GRP 7,222,586 %62.24 %0.89 %91.61n/a22 929 MMI COS GRP 6,771,578 %81.61 %0.83 %92.44n/a23 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 6,510,027 %51.63 %0.80 %93.24n/a24 460 AMERICAS GRP 6,287,964 %76.82 %0.77 %94.01n/a25 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 6,181,303 %69.83 %0.76 %94.77n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 815,130,939 %77.93 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners175

Page 184: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 253,395,812 %73.37 %22.62 %22.6271.32%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 170,990,167 %5.79 %15.26 %37.8911.69%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 126,321,191 %63.24 %11.28 %49.1659.72%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 87,894,133 %56.31 %7.85 %57.0158.42%5 306 CUNA MUT GRP 86,489,715 %83.34 %7.72 %64.7384.35%6 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 84,342,607 %15.14 %7.53 %72.2610.42%7 218 CNA INS GRP 57,270,182 %52.69 %5.11 %77.3754.25%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 55,700,387 %20.06 %4.97 %82.3537.90%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 21,577,808 %21.16 %1.93 %84.2718.49%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 20,273,547 %32.50 %1.81 %86.0843.67%11 783 RLI INS GRP 11,611,088 %36.16 %1.04 %87.1251.02%12 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 11,423,933 %21.09 %1.02 %88.1422.97%13 11268 ICI MUT INS CO RRG 10,511,851 %-1.72 %0.94 %89.08-2.11%14 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 9,677,357 %5.83 %0.86 %89.948.04%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 8,878,455 %167.56 %0.79 %90.73175.72%16 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 6,556,144 %-44.76 %0.59 %91.32-29.50%17 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 6,529,432 %197.72 %0.58 %91.90206.90%18 18538 BANCINSURE INC 6,341,677 %104.55 %0.57 %92.47104.55%19 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 6,044,618 %35.00 %0.54 %93.0136.85%20 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 5,657,267 %17.75 %0.51 %93.5119.76%21 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 5,261,342 %41.55 %0.47 %93.9843.02%22 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 5,094,082 %48.86 %0.45 %94.4450.47%23 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 4,870,261 %61.09 %0.43 %94.8761.08%24 176 STATE FARM GRP 4,589,181 %3.97 %0.41 %95.285.32%25 677 PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR 4,525,555 %43.16 %0.40 %95.6943.16%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,120,159,654 %48.99 %100.00 %100.0050.66%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 274,315,263 %36.39 %23.61 %23.6138.66%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 177,136,301 %38.60 %15.24 %38.8547.47%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 156,208,014 %43.49 %13.44 %52.2941.71%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 101,837,740 %41.21 %8.76 %61.0545.33%5 306 CUNA MUT GRP 91,815,616 %23.87 %7.90 %68.9524.80%6 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 70,026,256 %23.16 %6.03 %74.9838.34%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 61,798,514 %37.84 %5.32 %80.3047.76%8 218 CNA INS GRP 56,441,847 %45.65 %4.86 %85.1643.54%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 19,239,039 %74.68 %1.66 %86.8182.43%

10 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 17,853,903 %154.67 %1.54 %88.35154.30%11 626 ACE LTD GRP 14,977,772 %206.46 %1.29 %89.64246.09%12 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 10,487,012 %16.79 %0.90 %90.5420.71%13 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 9,476,740 %61.88 %0.82 %91.3567.60%14 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 5,944,247 %77.83 %0.51 %91.8793.12%15 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 5,875,071 %7.79 %0.51 %92.378.93%16 18538 BANCINSURE INC 5,651,840 %179.17 %0.49 %92.86179.17%17 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 5,616,687 %50.81 %0.48 %93.3452.28%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners176

Page 185: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,248,688 %104.56 %0.45 %93.79104.57%19 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 5,059,964 %25.08 %0.44 %94.2326.14%20 176 STATE FARM GRP 4,242,961 %8.33 %0.37 %94.598.74%21 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 4,223,257 %762.17 %0.36 %94.96766.33%22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 4,183,867 %9.56 %0.36 %95.3212.75%23 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 3,733,119 %12.13 %0.32 %95.6410.13%24 10758 COLONIAL SURETY CO 3,625,911 %43.22 %0.31 %95.9561.22%25 62 EMC INS CO GRP 3,546,434 %40.23 %0.31 %96.2639.78%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,162,083,190 %41.83 %100.00 %100.0045.91%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 303,281,520 %36.39 %23.31 %23.3138.86%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 245,791,078 %23.71 %18.89 %42.2027.93%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 187,926,447 %41.20 %14.44 %56.6444.94%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 105,497,681 %67.05 %8.11 %64.7567.61%5 306 CUNA MUT GRP 102,060,173 %38.60 %7.84 %72.5939.96%6 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 67,469,246 %32.62 %5.19 %77.7832.88%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 62,787,826 %32.54 %4.83 %82.6142.84%8 218 CNA INS GRP 60,457,864 %50.01 %4.65 %87.2538.55%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 19,075,292 %-9.36 %1.47 %88.727.40%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 15,686,890 %41.19 %1.21 %89.9249.41%11 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 13,907,104 %33.35 %1.07 %90.9935.40%12 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 12,814,807 %29.56 %0.98 %91.9870.15%13 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 9,369,069 %40.63 %0.72 %92.7044.60%14 18538 BANCINSURE INC 7,417,305 %74.47 %0.57 %93.2774.47%15 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 6,084,942 %7.90 %0.47 %93.747.49%16 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 5,988,988 %22.04 %0.46 %94.2022.52%17 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,463,692 %15.39 %0.42 %94.6215.39%18 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 5,027,605 %30.46 %0.39 %95.0030.34%19 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 4,245,941 %-10.38 %0.33 %95.33-4.18%20 176 STATE FARM GRP 4,157,682 %8.67 %0.32 %95.659.59%21 62 EMC INS CO GRP 3,734,906 %40.46 %0.29 %95.9340.50%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 3,627,447 %53.67 %0.28 %96.2158.69%23 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 3,567,006 %55.98 %0.27 %96.4967.13%24 228 WESTFIELD GRP 3,557,243 %14.79 %0.27 %96.7614.64%25 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 3,354,749 %17.40 %0.26 %97.0222.39%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,301,142,536 %36.04 %100.00 %100.0039.10%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 294,227,802 %38.09 %22.95 %22.9540.83%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 269,829,606 %32.26 %21.05 %44.0034.54%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners177

Page 186: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 194,398,223 %32.37 %15.17 %59.1732.23%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 109,711,904 %9.65 %8.56 %67.7310.11%5 306 CUNA MUT GRP 100,935,265 %98.79 %7.87 %75.60100.10%6 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 65,455,225 %45.39 %5.11 %80.7153.63%7 218 CNA INS GRP 62,525,639 %24.04 %4.88 %85.5925.92%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 60,210,511 %23.57 %4.70 %90.2828.16%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 19,932,540 %43.91 %1.55 %91.8449.82%

10 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 15,365,552 %48.55 %1.20 %93.0462.49%11 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,109,225 %-0.17 %1.10 %94.140.00%12 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 10,249,185 %85.03 %0.80 %94.9495.50%13 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 8,825,229 %37.54 %0.69 %95.6343.39%14 18538 BANCINSURE INC 6,681,846 %56.27 %0.52 %96.1556.27%15 148 OHIO CAS GRP 6,395,997 %7.70 %0.50 %96.654.57%16 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,904,013 %110.89 %0.46 %97.11110.89%17 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 5,856,470 %4.32 %0.46 %97.564.59%18 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 5,675,710 %20.73 %0.44 %98.0120.80%19 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 4,961,057 %6.85 %0.39 %98.398.93%20 176 STATE FARM GRP 4,027,024 %4.49 %0.31 %98.716.27%21 228 WESTFIELD GRP 3,867,728 %58.35 %0.30 %99.0160.09%22 62 EMC INS CO GRP 3,829,825 %29.89 %0.30 %99.3130.57%23 169 SENTRY INS GRP 3,784,604 %30.58 %0.30 %99.6034.26%24 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 3,602,097 %6.07 %0.28 %99.886.53%25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 2,634,059 %-22.76 %0.21 %100.09-14.04%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,281,836,649 %36.78 %100.00 %100.0039.07%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 293,012,082 %36.56 %21.73 %21.7338.14%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 279,524,180 %39.99 %20.73 %42.4643.83%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 187,662,406 %30.05 %13.92 %56.3832.73%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 116,907,962 %42.93 %8.67 %65.0549.52%5 306 CUNA MUT GRP 105,121,550 %78.11 %7.80 %72.8577.37%6 218 CNA INS GRP 62,704,599 %66.37 %4.65 %77.5088.21%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 61,288,921 %38.76 %4.55 %82.0442.15%8 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 60,892,503 %40.10 %4.52 %86.5648.19%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 19,333,426 %24.33 %1.43 %87.9929.47%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 18,378,497 %42.93 %1.36 %89.3547.58%11 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,407,664 %49.14 %1.07 %90.4255.18%12 3496 QUANTA US HOLDINGS GRP 10,977,496 %29.00 %0.81 %91.2431.13%13 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 9,489,738 %17.41 %0.70 %91.9419.47%14 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 8,036,094 %83.56 %0.60 %92.5498.58%15 148 OHIO CAS GRP 6,743,803 %39.24 %0.50 %93.0442.48%16 18538 BANCINSURE INC 6,482,329 %105.19 %0.48 %93.52105.19%17 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,411,071 %71.61 %0.48 %93.9971.61%18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 5,600,392 %12.40 %0.42 %94.4115.23%19 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 5,278,571 %14.94 %0.39 %94.8015.51%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners178

Page 187: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 4,721,819 %17.16 %0.35 %95.1516.27%21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 4,045,463 %48.33 %0.30 %95.4550.46%22 62 EMC INS CO GRP 3,842,921 %16.99 %0.29 %95.7417.28%23 176 STATE FARM GRP 3,823,605 %4.50 %0.28 %96.025.26%24 3526 COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP 3,473,603 %19.93 %0.26 %96.2820.27%25 15792 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON 3,452,546 %40.59 %0.26 %96.5345.23%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,348,366,414 %41.25 %100.00 %100.0045.33%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 238,108,517 %84.44 %25.51 %25.5188.06%2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 140,430,644 %63.51 %15.04 %40.5567.56%3 306 CUNA MUT GRP 110,323,207 %68.20 %11.82 %52.3769.42%4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 106,362,457 %33.45 %11.39 %63.7635.41%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 60,954,996 %70.59 %6.53 %70.2974.88%6 218 CNA INS GRP 49,462,807 %24.97 %5.30 %75.594.37%7 164 ST PAUL GRP 46,625,021 %76.44 %4.99 %80.5879.43%8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 37,130,787 %37.25 %3.98 %84.5641.11%9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 12,692,080 %68.30 %1.36 %85.9271.70%

10 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 12,384,318 %43.52 %1.33 %87.2546.37%11 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 11,517,971 %37.68 %1.23 %88.4844.99%12 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 10,236,139 %65.86 %1.10 %89.5884.19%13 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 9,311,361 %25.25 %1.00 %90.5729.54%14 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,645,239 %84.01 %0.71 %91.2884.06%15 148 OHIO CAS GRP 5,530,695 %-12.59 %0.59 %91.88-17.62%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 5,236,761 %39.73 %0.56 %92.4440.28%17 18538 BANCINSURE INC 4,937,830 %82.08 %0.53 %92.9782.08%18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 4,518,210 %1.33 %0.48 %93.452.42%19 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 4,011,962 %124.70 %0.43 %93.88133.94%20 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 3,422,245 %-12.03 %0.37 %94.25-16.52%21 176 STATE FARM GRP 3,172,577 %5.13 %0.34 %94.596.07%22 228 WESTFIELD GRP 3,042,912 %27.56 %0.33 %94.9132.32%23 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 3,005,972 %29.26 %0.32 %95.2432.19%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 2,790,260 %13.36 %0.30 %95.5319.70%25 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 2,789,883 %38.59 %0.30 %95.8340.73%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 933,544,402 %60.39 %100.00 %100.0062.20%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 306 CUNA MUT GRP 163,852,814 %37.57 %16.87 %16.87n/a2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 149,032,128 %47.70 %15.34 %32.21n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 143,266,533 %56.65 %14.75 %46.96n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 81,511,167 %8.89 %8.39 %55.35n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners179

Page 188: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 61,972,825 %48.56 %6.38 %61.73n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 53,418,744 %59.16 %5.50 %67.23n/a7 218 CNA INS GRP 52,105,659 %32.80 %5.36 %72.60n/a8 159 RELIANCE GRP 31,384,724 %39.98 %3.23 %75.83n/a9 397 NUCORP INS GRP 27,538,529 %4.14 %2.84 %78.66n/a

10 41 CITIGROUP GRP 26,672,685 %37.57 %2.75 %81.41n/a11 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 18,257,723 %65.41 %1.88 %83.29n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 17,566,731 %36.02 %1.81 %85.10n/a13 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 10,162,428 %23.45 %1.05 %86.14n/a14 18538 BANCINSURE INC 9,240,061 %18.76 %0.95 %87.09n/a15 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 8,658,419 %8.30 %0.89 %87.99n/a16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 7,720,305 %10.82 %0.79 %88.78n/a17 201 UTICA GRP 6,972,937 %0.81 %0.72 %89.50n/a18 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 6,497,345 %6.90 %0.67 %90.17n/a19 148 OHIO CAS GRP 6,399,600 %5.46 %0.66 %90.83n/a20 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 5,405,052 %45.47 %0.56 %91.38n/a21 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 4,840,349 %7.99 %0.50 %91.88n/a22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 4,525,479 %7.78 %0.47 %92.35n/a23 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 4,249,042 %10.78 %0.44 %92.78n/a24 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,534,638 %33.59 %0.36 %93.15n/a25 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 3,456,986 %39.13 %0.36 %93.50n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 971,342,135 %38.00 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 199,720,704 %32.95 %18.59 %18.59n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 173,078,527 %42.89 %16.11 %34.70n/a3 306 CUNA MUT GRP 108,313,192 %55.06 %10.08 %44.79n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 106,616,130 %23.70 %9.92 %54.71n/a5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 73,625,237 %37.36 %6.85 %61.56n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 57,260,213 %35.35 %5.33 %66.89n/a7 218 CNA INS GRP 46,190,985 %44.19 %4.30 %71.19n/a8 159 RELIANCE GRP 35,923,565 %80.56 %3.34 %74.54n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 34,743,081 %62.43 %3.23 %77.77n/a

10 397 NUCORP INS GRP 22,186,932 %4.91 %2.07 %79.84n/a11 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 20,054,495 %34.55 %1.87 %81.71n/a12 317 AON CORP GRP 19,679,769 %0.46 %1.83 %83.54n/a13 148 OHIO CAS GRP 15,034,001 %15.69 %1.40 %84.94n/a14 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 14,804,169 %21.92 %1.38 %86.31n/a15 155 PROGRESSIVE GRP 14,220,224 %87.65 %1.32 %87.64n/a16 18538 BANCINSURE INC 11,583,579 %40.93 %1.08 %88.72n/a17 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 11,305,084 %119.95 %1.05 %89.77n/a18 15792 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON 9,387,439 %19.32 %0.87 %90.64n/a19 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 8,583,290 %66.75 %0.80 %91.44n/a20 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 8,230,066 %7.29 %0.77 %92.21n/a21 201 UTICA GRP 5,735,623 %11.50 %0.53 %92.74n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners180

Page 189: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

23 - Fidelity

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 5,664,924 %70.55 %0.53 %93.27n/a23 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 4,414,967 %71.43 %0.41 %93.68n/a24 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 4,101,068 %36.88 %0.38 %94.06n/a25 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 3,127,158 %41.39 %0.29 %94.35n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,074,243,638 %42.18 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 119,500,329 %26.37 %16.78 %16.78n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 105,038,610 %49.16 %14.75 %31.54n/a3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 89,346,758 %68.50 %12.55 %44.09n/a4 306 CUNA MUT GRP 64,704,238 %49.93 %9.09 %53.17n/a5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 49,898,178 %59.15 %7.01 %60.18n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 40,562,278 %43.30 %5.70 %65.88n/a7 218 CNA INS GRP 40,317,698 %62.71 %5.66 %71.54n/a8 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 28,497,173 %109.27 %4.00 %75.55n/a9 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 25,987,370 %134.01 %3.65 %79.20n/a

10 159 RELIANCE GRP 21,668,823 %38.03 %3.04 %82.24n/a11 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 18,710,117 %81.22 %2.63 %84.87n/a12 397 NUCORP INS GRP 14,131,831 %8.56 %1.98 %86.85n/a13 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 13,530,769 %88.35 %1.90 %88.75n/a14 148 OHIO CAS GRP 10,554,667 %49.98 %1.48 %90.23n/a15 317 AON CORP GRP 7,565,964 %86.45 %1.06 %91.30n/a16 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 5,160,539 %60.16 %0.72 %92.02n/a17 15792 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON 4,514,040 %42.05 %0.63 %92.66n/a18 1111 TIG INS GRP 4,367,200 %117.55 %0.61 %93.27n/a19 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 3,417,574 %19.19 %0.48 %93.75n/a20 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 3,382,982 %68.92 %0.48 %94.22n/a21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,888,364 %46.54 %0.41 %94.63n/a22 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 2,652,685 %54.75 %0.37 %95.00n/a23 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 2,375,170 %17.57 %0.33 %95.34n/a24 229 ING AMER INS HOLDING GRP 2,136,499 %25.40 %0.30 %95.64n/a25 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 1,917,267 %52.20 %0.27 %95.91n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 711,973,873 %57.18 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners181

Page 190: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 924,173,009 %5.20 %17.80 %17.8014.48%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 723,214,004 %20.70 %13.93 %31.7220.62%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 486,753,862 %2.67 %9.37 %41.106.62%4 218 CNA INS GRP 406,141,296 %13.47 %7.82 %48.9215.96%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 276,977,328 %0.53 %5.33 %54.25-0.03%6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 181,037,257 %35.79 %3.49 %57.7440.37%7 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 165,159,328 %20.61 %3.18 %60.9225.03%8 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 117,983,963 %14.19 %2.27 %63.1916.77%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 109,048,821 %13.64 %2.10 %65.2915.45%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 104,470,062 %21.49 %2.01 %67.3026.03%11 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 100,061,100 %63.72 %1.93 %69.2372.69%12 181 SWISS RE GRP 93,875,162 %20.93 %1.81 %71.0428.68%13 3488 J A PATTERSON GRP 86,665,405 %27.74 %1.67 %72.7031.72%14 1279 ARCH INS GRP 78,606,428 %69.61 %1.51 %74.2281.82%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 77,281,831 %143.58 %1.49 %75.71148.78%16 783 RLI INS GRP 77,041,705 %17.78 %1.48 %77.1919.36%17 228 WESTFIELD GRP 58,307,591 %3.12 %1.12 %78.317.04%18 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 57,356,313 %30.32 %1.10 %79.4234.44%19 3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP 55,232,096 %6.00 %1.06 %80.488.02%20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 48,888,147 %32.92 %0.94 %81.4237.58%21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 48,766,603 %12.61 %0.94 %82.3616.15%22 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 44,523,403 %14.42 %0.86 %83.2219.84%23 10916 SURETEC INS CO 41,561,421 %13.32 %0.80 %84.0216.29%24 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 39,291,638 %20.21 %0.76 %84.7723.41%25 3592 PROALLIANCE GRP 34,256,572 %1.11 %0.66 %85.430.98%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,193,066,043 %19.47 %100.00 %100.0024.55%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 991,622,402 %-1.20 %17.97 %17.978.97%2 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 832,837,018 %15.74 %15.10 %33.0719.50%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 482,534,917 %3.60 %8.75 %41.827.09%4 218 CNA INS GRP 434,336,483 %13.97 %7.87 %49.6917.09%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 297,286,287 %34.06 %5.39 %55.0836.43%6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 210,598,774 %21.72 %3.82 %58.9027.49%7 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 148,820,786 %12.97 %2.70 %61.5917.80%8 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 118,769,830 %6.76 %2.15 %63.758.23%9 626 ACE LTD GRP 109,099,679 %25.86 %1.98 %65.7234.17%

10 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 108,694,388 %10.62 %1.97 %67.6914.62%11 1279 ARCH INS GRP 105,916,055 %49.64 %1.92 %69.6162.29%12 181 SWISS RE GRP 101,786,548 %18.25 %1.84 %71.4627.08%13 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 96,771,455 %12.78 %1.75 %73.2120.20%14 3488 J A PATTERSON GRP 86,852,650 %22.95 %1.57 %74.7925.19%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 76,559,935 %-48.38 %1.39 %76.17-32.74%16 783 RLI INS GRP 73,007,842 %-1.20 %1.32 %77.504.86%17 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 68,131,444 %14.23 %1.23 %78.7314.90%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners182

Page 191: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 228 WESTFIELD GRP 65,564,630 %4.30 %1.19 %79.925.06%19 3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP 51,763,692 %2.74 %0.94 %80.863.21%20 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 48,156,503 %19.77 %0.87 %81.7324.21%21 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 46,796,669 %35.96 %0.85 %82.5840.17%22 922 AMERICAN ASSETS GRP 44,716,269 %85.95 %0.81 %83.39107.79%23 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 42,424,767 %11.76 %0.77 %84.1615.46%24 10916 SURETEC INS CO 42,105,814 %13.77 %0.76 %84.9218.87%25 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 38,402,177 %115.10 %0.70 %85.62115.33%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,516,959,231 %12.16 %100.00 %100.0017.92%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 1,017,180,437 %24.15 %18.64 %18.6432.56%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 451,511,433 %11.29 %8.28 %26.9217.92%3 218 CNA INS GRP 436,119,897 %18.79 %7.99 %34.9222.32%4 163 SAFECO INS GRP 423,274,038 %11.63 %7.76 %42.6714.46%5 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 341,250,239 %17.35 %6.26 %48.9318.77%6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 303,639,444 %-2.61 %5.57 %54.49-0.87%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 223,298,096 %11.62 %4.09 %58.5914.95%8 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 158,138,026 %6.50 %2.90 %61.4910.34%9 1279 ARCH INS GRP 127,067,051 %114.12 %2.33 %63.82116.97%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 118,743,840 %4.98 %2.18 %65.999.71%11 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 113,844,786 %7.51 %2.09 %68.087.29%12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 108,697,067 %20.37 %1.99 %70.0727.25%13 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 94,716,313 %10.59 %1.74 %71.8122.22%14 181 SWISS RE GRP 91,010,747 %24.46 %1.67 %73.4833.05%15 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 78,516,710 %20.93 %1.44 %74.9126.25%16 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 68,841,345 %12.66 %1.26 %76.1817.29%17 783 RLI INS GRP 66,679,242 %4.94 %1.22 %77.406.90%18 228 WESTFIELD GRP 61,991,226 %2.85 %1.14 %78.535.92%19 3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP 52,120,087 %2.62 %0.96 %79.494.03%20 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 51,110,606 %17.64 %0.94 %80.4322.60%21 922 ICW GRP 48,440,084 %16.16 %0.89 %81.3123.95%22 10916 SURETEC INS CO 44,217,562 %9.93 %0.81 %82.1314.16%23 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 42,423,260 %12.29 %0.78 %82.9015.89%24 27081 BOND SAFEGUARD INS CO 41,312,647 %12.48 %0.76 %83.6614.13%25 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 40,077,427 %14.73 %0.73 %84.3918.81%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,455,564,565 %18.25 %100.00 %100.0023.41%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 940,806,315 %25.20 %18.64 %18.6428.64%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 429,530,172 %-9.38 %8.51 %27.16-2.89%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners183

Page 192: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 218 CNA INS GRP 417,820,853 %-0.03 %8.28 %35.443.52%4 163 SAFECO INS GRP 359,684,752 %13.48 %7.13 %42.5619.38%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 275,489,568 %11.88 %5.46 %48.0213.77%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 260,424,654 %17.75 %5.16 %53.1920.08%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 206,345,552 %22.16 %4.09 %57.2730.05%8 1279 ARCH INS GRP 142,176,734 %54.16 %2.82 %60.0956.64%9 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 130,958,862 %17.29 %2.60 %62.6921.88%

10 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 120,937,352 %-31.96 %2.40 %65.08-23.08%11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 99,381,385 %28.95 %1.97 %67.0534.37%12 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 96,632,414 %9.99 %1.92 %68.9713.09%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 84,527,681 %24.82 %1.68 %70.6435.94%14 626 ACE LTD GRP 76,579,973 %-4.69 %1.52 %72.16-0.04%15 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 69,511,988 %6.72 %1.38 %73.5411.91%16 783 RLI INS GRP 64,121,538 %7.22 %1.27 %74.8114.90%17 228 WESTFIELD GRP 60,801,631 %8.15 %1.20 %76.0113.80%18 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 58,965,222 %26.42 %1.17 %77.1834.56%19 148 OHIO CAS GRP 54,396,394 %1.19 %1.08 %78.262.62%20 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 51,141,240 %9.94 %1.01 %79.2713.74%21 3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP 51,024,534 %3.20 %1.01 %80.295.97%22 922 ICW GRP 48,639,361 %-1.91 %0.96 %81.2513.64%23 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 41,179,207 %9.94 %0.82 %82.0717.00%24 13307 LEXON INS CO 36,201,440 %1.00 %0.72 %82.781.70%25 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 35,512,349 %9.13 %0.70 %83.4912.89%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 5,046,036,005 %15.74 %100.00 %100.0021.48%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 885,169,863 %29.63 %19.52 %19.5232.64%2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 387,400,254 %35.01 %8.54 %28.0741.60%3 218 CNA INS GRP 382,001,062 %62.20 %8.43 %36.4968.05%4 163 SAFECO INS GRP 309,506,325 %12.48 %6.83 %43.3223.98%5 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 234,054,288 %30.74 %5.16 %48.4834.00%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 209,928,408 %24.50 %4.63 %53.1125.94%7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 180,810,500 %17.47 %3.99 %57.1019.57%8 1279 ARCH INS GRP 109,005,413 %30.56 %2.40 %59.5030.27%9 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 102,925,374 %18.16 %2.27 %61.7721.81%

10 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 86,612,299 %19.48 %1.91 %63.6822.92%11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 86,291,217 %29.35 %1.90 %65.5934.61%12 181 SWISS RE GRP 73,194,527 %26.69 %1.61 %67.2035.89%13 626 ACE LTD GRP 71,180,600 %-15.73 %1.57 %68.77-4.97%14 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 68,079,810 %42.49 %1.50 %70.2757.42%15 1285 XL AMER GRP 64,079,519 %69.00 %1.41 %71.6980.55%16 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 60,177,505 %17.26 %1.33 %73.0123.75%17 783 RLI INS GRP 58,010,497 %33.23 %1.28 %74.2939.84%18 228 WESTFIELD GRP 49,987,224 %33.24 %1.10 %75.4037.27%19 148 OHIO CAS GRP 47,481,744 %28.85 %1.05 %76.4433.46%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners184

Page 193: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 922 ICW GRP 43,000,098 %11.34 %0.95 %77.3918.09%21 3479 MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP 42,535,734 %7.06 %0.94 %78.339.12%22 501 ALLEGHANY GRP 38,295,213 %20.98 %0.84 %79.1728.48%23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 38,260,419 %29.09 %0.84 %80.0235.85%24 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 34,122,877 %11.05 %0.75 %80.7714.20%25 3592 PROALLIANCE GRP 33,569,834 %4.86 %0.74 %81.516.66%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,533,965,659 %39.90 %100.00 %100.0047.27%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 164 ST PAUL GRP 387,649,214 %53.77 %11.18 %11.1858.94%2 218 CNA INS GRP 285,528,321 %7.08 %8.24 %19.427.59%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 263,445,530 %24.50 %7.60 %27.0229.10%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 246,079,014 %106.19 %7.10 %34.12144.41%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 224,387,480 %35.55 %6.47 %40.6042.78%6 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 141,603,042 %51.84 %4.09 %44.6854.80%7 626 ACE LTD GRP 125,724,143 %69.38 %3.63 %48.3170.91%8 163 SAFECO INS GRP 124,739,260 %44.39 %3.60 %51.9144.22%9 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 120,138,454 %60.52 %3.47 %55.3867.43%

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 106,143,728 %33.72 %3.06 %58.4433.80%11 2 AMWEST GRP 105,390,117 %64.41 %3.04 %61.4876.13%12 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 99,266,167 %70.64 %2.86 %64.3481.69%13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 87,974,391 %37.40 %2.54 %66.8838.93%14 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 81,108,210 %47.89 %2.34 %69.2249.18%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 63,725,661 %24.06 %1.84 %71.0624.54%16 961 FRONTIER INS GRP 58,442,783 %104.65 %1.69 %72.75109.71%17 181 SWISS RE GRP 53,430,238 %32.07 %1.54 %74.2942.20%18 1285 XL AMER GRP 43,226,408 %30.30 %1.25 %75.5332.05%19 783 RLI INS GRP 41,152,877 %35.42 %1.19 %76.7240.55%20 148 OHIO CAS GRP 32,900,948 %11.50 %0.95 %77.6713.29%21 44 AVIVA GRP 32,609,322 %26.82 %0.94 %78.6136.05%22 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 30,260,644 %11.72 %0.87 %79.4813.55%23 10216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 28,295,184 %21.30 %0.82 %80.3023.71%24 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 26,851,234 %19.07 %0.77 %81.0824.28%25 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL) 26,663,731 %2.23 %0.77 %81.84-4.83%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,465,992,631 %45.50 %100.00 %100.0052.61%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 212 ZURICH INS GRP 165,800,791 %58.34 %5.97 %5.97n/a2 159 RELIANCE GRP 163,319,920 %10.79 %5.88 %11.85n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 162,859,669 %3.64 %5.87 %17.72n/a4 4 AMERIPRISE FIN GRP 150,054,000 %103.50 %5.40 %23.12n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners185

Page 194: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 164 ST PAUL GRP 141,774,751 %4.20 %5.11 %28.23n/a6 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 132,581,272 %36.25 %4.77 %33.00n/a7 1 AETNA GRP 122,764,431 %26.22 %4.42 %37.42n/a8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 117,399,922 %48.30 %4.23 %41.65n/a9 163 SAFECO INS GRP 98,523,279 %27.63 %3.55 %45.20n/a

10 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 89,903,546 %48.76 %3.24 %48.44n/a11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 77,542,086 %31.29 %2.79 %51.23n/a12 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 75,822,036 %28.54 %2.73 %53.96n/a13 2 AMWEST GRP 69,854,390 %22.96 %2.52 %56.48n/a14 397 NUCORP INS GRP 57,386,034 %10.33 %2.07 %58.54n/a15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 50,149,479 %41.54 %1.81 %60.35n/a16 961 FRONTIER INS GRP 48,774,016 %20.94 %1.76 %62.10n/a17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 41,494,634 %40.79 %1.49 %63.60n/a18 41 CITIGROUP GRP 37,235,510 %37.17 %1.34 %64.94n/a19 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 36,809,334 %8.72 %1.33 %66.27n/a20 148 OHIO CAS GRP 30,212,186 %9.75 %1.09 %67.35n/a21 196 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY GRP 29,128,052 %1.46 %1.05 %68.40n/a22 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 28,539,283 %-8.21 %1.03 %69.43n/a23 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 27,104,968 %20.23 %0.98 %70.41n/a24 258 INTERCARGO CORP GRP 26,330,192 %12.36 %0.95 %71.35n/a25 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 26,155,307 %37.94 %0.94 %72.30n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,776,796,606 %31.17 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 218 CNA INS GRP 179,599,816 %30.29 %8.23 %8.23n/a2 164 ST PAUL GRP 153,402,974 %-3.28 %7.03 %15.25n/a3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 141,387,464 %11.98 %6.48 %21.73n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 123,975,963 %88.81 %5.68 %27.40n/a5 159 RELIANCE GRP 121,028,200 %25.59 %5.54 %32.95n/a6 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 96,630,511 %29.19 %4.43 %37.37n/a7 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 95,350,987 %22.68 %4.37 %41.74n/a8 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 78,013,872 %12.46 %3.57 %45.31n/a9 163 SAFECO INS GRP 74,612,102 %5.53 %3.42 %48.73n/a

10 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 71,053,018 %30.73 %3.25 %51.98n/a11 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 62,406,525 %8.09 %2.86 %54.84n/a12 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 55,048,549 %5.40 %2.52 %57.36n/a13 2 AMWEST GRP 54,289,528 %20.74 %2.49 %59.85n/a14 397 NUCORP INS GRP 43,379,579 %11.94 %1.99 %61.84n/a15 11592 INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO 38,946,214 %47.27 %1.78 %63.62n/a16 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 31,089,399 %0.94 %1.42 %65.04n/a17 148 OHIO CAS GRP 30,659,532 %3.53 %1.40 %66.45n/a18 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 28,823,212 %14.11 %1.32 %67.77n/a19 246 INDIANA LUMBERMENS GRP 27,641,007 %20.20 %1.27 %69.03n/a20 196 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY GRP 27,009,795 %8.56 %1.24 %70.27n/a21 75 INSCO INS SERVICES GRP 25,607,221 %18.87 %1.17 %71.44n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners186

Page 195: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

24 - Surety

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 24,891,615 %11.75 %1.14 %72.58n/a23 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 24,692,503 %20.02 %1.13 %73.71n/a24 1111 TIG INS GRP 19,885,597 %46.67 %0.91 %74.63n/a25 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL) 19,012,931 %12.29 %0.87 %75.50n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,183,478,898 %22.65 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 41 CITIGROUP GRP 281,616,703 %48.07 %11.44 %11.44n/a2 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 276,164,403 %13.94 %11.22 %22.66n/a3 218 CNA INS GRP 152,153,444 %84.58 %6.18 %28.84n/a4 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 150,240,162 %151.21 %6.10 %34.94n/a5 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 135,428,980 %112.45 %5.50 %40.44n/a6 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 127,630,459 %314.27 %5.18 %45.62n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 104,974,851 %59.06 %4.26 %49.89n/a8 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 99,447,249 %98.93 %4.04 %53.93n/a9 18708 AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP 99,066,443 %1.28 %4.02 %57.95n/a

10 164 ST PAUL GRP 83,535,277 %37.67 %3.39 %61.34n/a11 159 RELIANCE GRP 74,698,828 %123.23 %3.03 %64.38n/a12 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 70,683,577 %24.94 %2.87 %67.25n/a13 528 MBIA GRP 58,230,705 %-64.10 %2.37 %69.62n/a14 163 SAFECO INS GRP 48,628,534 %74.09 %1.98 %71.59n/a15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 45,522,464 %22.40 %1.85 %73.44n/a16 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 44,442,192 %58.84 %1.81 %75.24n/a17 1111 TIG INS GRP 37,181,539 %46.62 %1.51 %76.76n/a18 397 NUCORP INS GRP 31,300,589 %24.88 %1.27 %78.03n/a19 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 29,356,065 %-2.78 %1.19 %79.22n/a20 484 CLARENDON INS GRP 23,781,368 %0.00 %0.97 %80.18n/a21 907 ALLIED FIDELITY GRP 21,537,841 %85.23 %0.87 %81.06n/a22 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 20,257,087 %26.60 %0.82 %81.88n/a23 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 18,721,045 %33.10 %0.76 %82.64n/a24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 18,686,670 %73.99 %0.76 %83.40n/a25 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 18,394,363 %75.30 %0.75 %84.15n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,461,912,788 %76.38 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners187

Page 196: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

25- Glass

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 118 GRYPHON HOLDINGS INC 3,375,797 %29.05 %21.83 %21.83n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,401,211 %25.21 %9.06 %30.89n/a3 389 CENTRIS GRP INC 953,122 %10.08 %6.16 %37.05n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 868,630 %16.75 %5.62 %42.67n/a5 28497 USPLATE GLASS INS CO 865,624 %12.07 %5.60 %48.27n/a6 175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP 566,697 %27.24 %3.66 %51.93n/a7 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 495,017 %67.81 %3.20 %55.13n/a8 164 ST PAUL GRP 368,515 %26.50 %2.38 %57.52n/a9 215 UNITRIN GRP 365,950 %33.04 %2.37 %59.88n/a

10 181 SWISS RE GRP 298,470 %25.67 %1.93 %61.81n/a11 41 CITIGROUP GRP 293,771 %30.34 %1.90 %63.71n/a12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 277,555 %0.48 %1.79 %65.51n/a13 228 WESTFIELD GRP 273,207 %53.10 %1.77 %67.27n/a14 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 249,941 %27.24 %1.62 %68.89n/a15 83 GRANGE INS GRP 234,173 %27.51 %1.51 %70.40n/a16 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 233,145 %73.19 %1.51 %71.91n/a17 69 FARMERS INS GRP 231,233 %54.88 %1.50 %73.41n/a18 219 DEERE & CO GRP 224,482 %30.21 %1.45 %74.86n/a19 62 EMC INS CO GRP 219,161 %34.67 %1.42 %76.28n/a20 515 EAGLE INS GRP 182,382 %36.53 %1.18 %77.46n/a21 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 179,848 %-1.78 %1.16 %78.62n/a22 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 171,545 %37.13 %1.11 %79.73n/a23 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 130,411 %12.10 %0.84 %80.57n/a24 271 PENNSYLVANIA NATL INS GRP 125,482 %20.99 %0.81 %81.38n/a25 148 OHIO CAS GRP 124,474 %37.39 %0.80 %82.19n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 15,464,364 %45.68 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 389 CENTRIS GRP INC 5,132,146 %21.52 %26.46 %26.46n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 1,829,793 %35.78 %9.43 %35.89n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,017,311 %18.75 %5.25 %41.14n/a4 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 570,790 %38.08 %2.94 %44.08n/a5 215 UNITRIN GRP 544,736 %27.97 %2.81 %46.89n/a6 164 ST PAUL GRP 529,646 %11.47 %2.73 %49.62n/a7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 495,350 %14.08 %2.55 %52.18n/a8 175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP 467,083 %36.07 %2.41 %54.58n/a9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 438,134 %22.37 %2.26 %56.84n/a

10 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 392,548 %54.86 %2.02 %58.87n/a11 69 FARMERS INS GRP 338,159 %41.20 %1.74 %60.61n/a12 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 337,839 %26.25 %1.74 %62.35n/a13 228 WESTFIELD GRP 318,807 %54.89 %1.64 %64.00n/a14 62 EMC INS CO GRP 300,074 %32.27 %1.55 %65.54n/a15 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 291,023 %29.16 %1.50 %67.04n/a16 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 283,177 %43.16 %1.46 %68.50n/a17 148 OHIO CAS GRP 278,334 %32.07 %1.44 %69.94n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners188

Page 197: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

25- Glass

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 218 CNA INS GRP 232,613 %-33.79 %1.20 %71.14n/a19 83 GRANGE INS GRP 222,536 %41.31 %1.15 %72.29n/a20 219 DEERE & CO GRP 221,786 %40.70 %1.14 %73.43n/a21 515 EAGLE INS GRP 194,997 %54.07 %1.01 %74.43n/a22 3 ALLIED GRP 180,696 %25.46 %0.93 %75.37n/a23 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 171,657 %26.45 %0.89 %76.25n/a24 271 PENNSYLVANIA NATL INS GRP 170,500 %25.14 %0.88 %77.13n/a25 163 SAFECO INS GRP 152,895 %31.46 %0.79 %77.92n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 19,395,552 %26.94 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 389 CENTRIS GRP INC 4,030,617 %23.74 %15.40 %15.40n/a2 212 ZURICH INS GRP 3,021,078 %18.92 %11.55 %26.95n/a3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 2,800,401 %21.02 %10.70 %37.65n/a4 164 ST PAUL GRP 1,282,585 %20.96 %4.90 %42.55n/a5 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 988,620 %33.30 %3.78 %46.33n/a6 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 981,000 %27.37 %3.75 %50.08n/a7 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 871,059 %21.73 %3.33 %53.41n/a8 203 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU GRP 747,538 %49.33 %2.86 %56.27n/a9 69 FARMERS INS GRP 594,804 %39.79 %2.27 %58.54n/a

10 228 WESTFIELD GRP 546,137 %27.27 %2.09 %60.63n/a11 218 CNA INS GRP 527,972 %29.00 %2.02 %62.65n/a12 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 521,683 %31.20 %1.99 %64.64n/a13 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 446,458 %27.58 %1.71 %66.35n/a14 175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP 395,280 %29.10 %1.51 %67.86n/a15 159 RELIANCE GRP 372,774 %27.79 %1.42 %69.28n/a16 169 SENTRY INS GRP 308,019 %33.69 %1.18 %70.46n/a17 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 295,380 %20.26 %1.13 %71.59n/a18 148 OHIO CAS GRP 275,266 %28.03 %1.05 %72.64n/a19 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 267,933 %27.90 %1.02 %73.66n/a20 168 SEIBELS BRUCE GRP 255,650 %31.21 %0.98 %74.64n/a21 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 219,713 %37.65 %0.84 %75.48n/a22 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 219,480 %19.71 %0.84 %76.32n/a23 83 GRANGE INS GRP 217,098 %38.50 %0.83 %77.15n/a24 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 216,622 %22.26 %0.83 %77.98n/a25 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 215,820 %14.86 %0.82 %78.80n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 26,166,162 %25.52 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners189

Page 198: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 37,910,627 %-3.72 %22.52 %22.523.14%2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 33,514,394 %7.79 %19.91 %42.435.85%3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 17,124,853 %31.93 %10.17 %52.6032.74%4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 12,579,033 %-6.67 %7.47 %60.08-5.62%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 10,178,546 %7.16 %6.05 %66.1211.54%6 215 UNITRIN GRP 9,311,337 %26.09 %5.53 %71.6626.09%7 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 5,839,785 %40.46 %3.47 %75.1240.46%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,487,836 %15.26 %2.67 %77.7916.05%9 218 CNA INS GRP 2,883,886 %38.78 %1.71 %79.5046.43%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 2,703,699 %42.83 %1.61 %81.1149.91%11 306 CUNA MUT GRP 2,012,197 %14.24 %1.20 %82.3114.30%12 71 UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP 1,812,136 %0.00 %1.08 %83.380.00%13 796 QBE INS GRP 1,362,057 %21.28 %0.81 %84.1923.15%14 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 1,327,931 %7.64 %0.79 %84.987.71%15 1285 XL AMER GRP 1,110,758 %20.11 %0.66 %85.6435.15%16 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,098,537 %-1.34 %0.65 %86.29-1.23%17 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 1,058,423 %45.45 %0.63 %86.9245.45%18 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,042,177 %12.83 %0.62 %87.5415.57%19 963 OHIO MUT GRP 998,800 %47.62 %0.59 %88.1348.73%20 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 966,357 %42.22 %0.57 %88.7142.31%21 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 932,961 %131.46 %0.55 %89.26143.44%22 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 869,477 %46.75 %0.52 %89.7848.01%23 123 SHELTER INS GRP 859,913 %38.47 %0.51 %90.2939.11%24 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 854,124 %11.82 %0.51 %90.8011.71%25 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 834,359 %29.00 %0.50 %91.2930.07%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 168,331,342 %12.60 %100.00 %100.0014.89%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 36,917,269 %16.60 %20.40 %20.4026.75%2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 34,079,107 %-0.73 %18.83 %39.240.42%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 28,684,771 %28.18 %15.85 %55.0927.85%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 15,171,138 %31.44 %8.38 %63.4832.81%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 10,976,909 %24.81 %6.07 %69.5432.76%6 215 UNITRIN GRP 10,067,316 %20.19 %5.56 %75.1120.19%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 4,924,516 %0.64 %2.72 %77.830.19%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,723,127 %26.05 %2.61 %80.4426.45%9 218 CNA INS GRP 2,366,175 %14.72 %1.31 %81.7513.43%

10 306 CUNA MUT GRP 2,280,863 %-64.00 %1.26 %83.01-64.23%11 71 UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP 1,761,229 %0.00 %0.97 %83.980.00%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,743,750 %41.74 %0.96 %84.9449.19%13 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 1,588,805 %25.34 %0.88 %85.8224.50%14 796 QBE INS GRP 1,479,173 %53.01 %0.82 %86.6455.23%15 169 SENTRY INS GRP 1,144,457 %10.33 %0.63 %87.2710.40%16 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 1,125,205 %9.02 %0.62 %87.899.03%17 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,101,536 %51.64 %0.61 %88.5051.89%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners190

Page 199: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 1,057,509 %31.65 %0.58 %89.0931.63%19 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,014,317 %20.58 %0.56 %89.6520.38%20 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 993,680 %19.38 %0.55 %90.2019.38%21 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 991,958 %186.95 %0.55 %90.75199.01%22 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 924,437 %2.86 %0.51 %91.262.87%23 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 902,594 %7.63 %0.50 %91.7611.31%24 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 876,175 %22.99 %0.48 %92.2423.14%25 123 SHELTER INS GRP 856,345 %20.63 %0.47 %92.7120.98%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 180,937,112 %17.90 %100.00 %100.0021.12%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 35,251,979 %18.77 %20.51 %20.5121.16%2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 32,723,216 %2.98 %19.04 %39.553.27%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 24,852,644 %13.74 %14.46 %54.0216.32%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 11,812,946 %39.23 %6.87 %60.8940.32%5 215 UNITRIN GRP 10,698,372 %21.29 %6.23 %67.1221.29%6 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 10,287,646 %8.89 %5.99 %73.1016.43%7 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 8,126,802 %-12.05 %4.73 %77.83-11.03%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 3,767,985 %17.43 %2.19 %80.0217.69%9 218 CNA INS GRP 2,284,138 %34.64 %1.33 %81.3544.60%

10 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,908,484 %38.99 %1.11 %82.4652.13%11 71 UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP 1,701,583 %0.12 %0.99 %83.450.12%12 306 CUNA MUT GRP 1,638,601 %134.16 %0.95 %84.41134.93%13 169 SENTRY INS GRP 1,347,735 %36.47 %0.78 %85.1936.54%14 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 1,238,226 %2.78 %0.72 %85.912.81%15 796 QBE INS GRP 1,186,429 %12.08 %0.69 %86.6011.77%16 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,156,685 %36.34 %0.67 %87.2836.58%17 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,144,898 %14.67 %0.67 %87.9414.66%18 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 966,064 %7.53 %0.56 %88.507.47%19 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 955,297 %26.76 %0.56 %89.0626.09%20 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 931,857 %14.96 %0.54 %89.6014.96%21 1285 XL AMER GRP 921,346 %2.57 %0.54 %90.142.44%22 123 SHELTER INS GRP 841,092 %21.86 %0.49 %90.6322.24%23 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 835,061 %34.28 %0.49 %91.1136.09%24 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 750,865 %10.25 %0.44 %91.5510.19%25 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 724,268 %218.76 %0.42 %91.97219.11%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 171,851,117 %16.50 %100.00 %100.0018.48%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 65,730,938 %13.89 %30.44 %30.4417.21%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 33,333,081 %25.34 %15.44 %45.8827.07%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners191

Page 200: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 31,771,639 %3.41 %14.71 %60.603.76%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 12,643,989 %46.90 %5.86 %66.4547.70%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 12,208,709 %-39.35 %5.65 %72.11-23.35%6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 11,499,251 %2.43 %5.33 %77.432.95%7 215 UNITRIN GRP 10,654,744 %18.88 %4.93 %82.3718.88%8 71 UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP 3,531,997 %0.00 %1.64 %84.000.00%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,524,599 %16.55 %1.17 %85.1717.00%

10 218 CNA INS GRP 1,971,170 %22.97 %0.91 %86.0829.31%11 626 ACE LTD GRP 1,582,894 %59.92 %0.73 %86.8277.22%12 169 SENTRY INS GRP 1,456,222 %-5.03 %0.67 %87.49-7.03%13 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,325,486 %35.68 %0.61 %88.1135.67%14 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,210,693 %22.14 %0.56 %88.6720.04%15 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 1,201,939 %-20.20 %0.56 %89.22-20.11%16 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,008,947 %14.97 %0.47 %89.6915.10%17 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 936,541 %8.53 %0.43 %90.128.33%18 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 926,130 %23.68 %0.43 %90.5523.43%19 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 925,725 %39.97 %0.43 %90.9840.09%20 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 896,971 %34.96 %0.42 %91.4035.60%21 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 870,550 %12.42 %0.40 %91.8016.28%22 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 835,618 %121.81 %0.39 %92.19123.01%23 123 SHELTER INS GRP 802,069 %17.77 %0.37 %92.5617.89%24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 712,704 %8.70 %0.33 %92.899.64%25 1285 XL AMER GRP 709,686 %2.26 %0.33 %93.223.15%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 215,918,175 %16.75 %100.00 %100.0019.25%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 31,498,959 %10.09 %23.52 %23.5210.48%2 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 29,484,171 %18.42 %22.02 %45.5419.86%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 14,005,480 %19.90 %10.46 %55.9920.96%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 12,177,512 %40.10 %9.09 %65.0940.76%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 8,403,527 %-3.10 %6.27 %71.36-5.53%6 215 UNITRIN GRP 5,890,861 %14.73 %4.40 %75.7614.72%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,777,463 %7.70 %1.33 %77.097.61%8 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,639,855 %33.27 %1.22 %78.3133.62%9 169 SENTRY INS GRP 1,500,058 %49.05 %1.12 %79.4351.32%

10 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,227,819 %18.90 %0.92 %80.3521.34%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 1,190,274 %35.27 %0.89 %81.2435.33%12 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,170,201 %22.79 %0.87 %82.1126.37%13 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 1,098,394 %36.73 %0.82 %82.9336.70%14 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,087,943 %12.61 %0.81 %83.7413.00%15 626 ACE LTD GRP 861,989 %32.92 %0.64 %84.3946.48%16 218 CNA INS GRP 855,761 %-5.43 %0.64 %85.03-3.49%17 225 IAT REINS CO GRP 851,167 %58.63 %0.64 %85.6657.70%18 228 WESTFIELD GRP 848,251 %27.59 %0.63 %86.2928.16%19 253 HARLEYSVILLE GRP 838,742 %27.81 %0.63 %86.9228.39%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners192

Page 201: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 834,846 %19.11 %0.62 %87.5419.99%21 123 SHELTER INS GRP 801,407 %25.15 %0.60 %88.1425.34%22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 766,204 %-3.96 %0.57 %88.71-4.03%23 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 700,390 %6.15 %0.52 %89.246.03%24 41394 BENCHMARK INS CO 682,561 %39.16 %0.51 %89.7541.74%25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 651,310 %6.17 %0.49 %90.236.43%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 133,925,464 %19.51 %100.00 %100.0020.24%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 35,712,649 %10.70 %29.82 %29.8210.84%2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 12,729,732 %34.08 %10.63 %40.4536.89%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 11,441,116 %31.39 %9.55 %50.0032.02%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 10,728,543 %42.40 %8.96 %58.9543.37%5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 6,484,333 %31.18 %5.41 %64.3734.67%6 164 ST PAUL GRP 5,916,110 %29.14 %4.94 %69.3127.56%7 215 UNITRIN GRP 3,326,707 %17.95 %2.78 %72.0918.03%8 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 2,394,980 %-1.48 %2.00 %74.09-6.04%9 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,923,704 %-49.95 %1.61 %75.69-48.76%

10 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,705,965 %31.30 %1.42 %77.1231.57%11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,624,921 %53.29 %1.36 %78.4756.47%12 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,560,755 %39.92 %1.30 %79.7839.99%13 898 CAPITOL COUNTY GRP 1,560,268 %20.59 %1.30 %81.0820.84%14 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,479,680 %28.07 %1.24 %82.3128.35%15 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,471,268 %14.95 %1.23 %83.5414.88%16 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,167,511 %39.34 %0.97 %84.5243.73%17 44 AVIVA GRP 958,214 %20.03 %0.80 %85.3220.00%18 169 SENTRY INS GRP 904,442 %37.15 %0.76 %86.0738.45%19 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 879,383 %54.30 %0.73 %86.8154.44%20 123 SHELTER INS GRP 776,460 %31.33 %0.65 %87.4531.38%21 62 EMC INS CO GRP 729,244 %30.06 %0.61 %88.0630.08%22 228 WESTFIELD GRP 665,524 %35.96 %0.56 %88.6236.03%23 175 STATE AUTO MUT GRP 602,944 %13.88 %0.50 %89.1213.93%24 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 591,149 %43.12 %0.49 %89.6244.05%25 248 UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP 563,739 %73.39 %0.47 %90.0975.44%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 119,773,406 %23.95 %100.00 %100.0025.01%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 37,073,109 %10.16 %27.71 %27.71n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 20,947,550 %20.89 %15.65 %43.36n/a3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 13,265,454 %21.41 %9.91 %53.27n/a4 1 AETNA GRP 7,595,811 %23.26 %5.68 %58.95n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners193

Page 202: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 159 RELIANCE GRP 5,582,071 %1.99 %4.17 %63.12n/a6 41 CITIGROUP GRP 3,013,982 %13.60 %2.25 %65.37n/a7 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 2,416,796 %0.67 %1.81 %67.18n/a8 164 ST PAUL GRP 2,249,298 %27.97 %1.68 %68.86n/a9 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 2,216,265 %9.80 %1.66 %70.52n/a

10 223 INDEPENDENT LIFE & ACC 2,165,792 %18.92 %1.62 %72.14n/a11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,165,152 %33.33 %1.62 %73.75n/a12 218 CNA INS GRP 2,074,059 %18.03 %1.55 %75.30n/a13 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,551,980 %30.29 %1.16 %76.46n/a14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,493,540 %63.05 %1.12 %77.58n/a15 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 1,271,762 %14.32 %0.95 %78.53n/a16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 1,220,092 %67.88 %0.91 %79.44n/a17 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 1,189,739 %20.34 %0.89 %80.33n/a18 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,168,568 %29.59 %0.87 %81.21n/a19 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 1,122,353 %7.46 %0.84 %82.04n/a20 129 PROP & CAS STANDARD GRP 1,042,609 %21.83 %0.78 %82.82n/a21 280 AUTO OWNERS GRP 1,011,316 %22.61 %0.76 %83.58n/a22 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 1,002,899 %0.01 %0.75 %84.33n/a23 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 798,596 %7.78 %0.60 %84.93n/a24 62 EMC INS CO GRP 685,249 %23.96 %0.51 %85.44n/a25 228 WESTFIELD GRP 626,905 %38.30 %0.47 %85.91n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 133,810,126 %19.53 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 27,799,982 %13.43 %22.05 %22.05n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 14,471,930 %-1.61 %11.48 %33.53n/a3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 12,973,421 %19.60 %10.29 %43.82n/a4 41 CITIGROUP GRP 10,192,570 %11.39 %8.09 %51.91n/a5 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 5,644,201 %10.47 %4.48 %56.38n/a6 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 4,456,205 %8.48 %3.53 %59.92n/a7 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,143,571 %8.29 %3.29 %63.21n/a8 218 CNA INS GRP 3,327,008 %9.27 %2.64 %65.85n/a9 159 RELIANCE GRP 2,916,631 %32.15 %2.31 %68.16n/a

10 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,252,939 %48.79 %1.79 %69.95n/a11 164 ST PAUL GRP 2,186,398 %10.74 %1.73 %71.68n/a12 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,959,894 %35.45 %1.55 %73.24n/a13 215 UNITRIN GRP 1,942,360 %21.54 %1.54 %74.78n/a14 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 1,605,257 %4.77 %1.27 %76.05n/a15 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 1,456,748 %10.93 %1.16 %77.21n/a16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,277,629 %8.25 %1.01 %78.22n/a17 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 1,183,171 %3.03 %0.94 %79.16n/a18 963 OHIO MUT GRP 1,099,870 %28.37 %0.87 %80.03n/a19 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 1,080,654 %25.09 %0.86 %80.89n/a20 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 1,072,926 %49.45 %0.85 %81.74n/a21 207 WESTERN RESERVE 923,190 %29.62 %0.73 %82.47n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners194

Page 203: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

26 - Burglary and Theft

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 62 EMC INS CO GRP 895,684 %25.11 %0.71 %83.18n/a23 240 DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP 859,579 %25.24 %0.68 %83.86n/a24 69 FARMERS INS GRP 774,594 %79.90 %0.61 %84.48n/a25 15792 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON 670,613 %0.00 %0.53 %85.01n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 126,065,751 %16.06 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 34,525,877 %60.63 %26.69 %26.69n/a2 41 CITIGROUP GRP 17,905,995 %23.74 %13.84 %40.53n/a3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 13,071,775 %20.30 %10.11 %50.64n/a4 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 6,097,827 %23.30 %4.71 %55.35n/a5 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 5,305,536 %11.80 %4.10 %59.46n/a6 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 4,944,635 %34.09 %3.82 %63.28n/a7 164 ST PAUL GRP 3,864,119 %16.91 %2.99 %66.27n/a8 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 3,440,658 %15.77 %2.66 %68.93n/a9 218 CNA INS GRP 3,330,687 %40.58 %2.57 %71.50n/a

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 2,721,194 %74.88 %2.10 %73.60n/a11 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 2,651,953 %37.94 %2.05 %75.65n/a12 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,197,065 %61.17 %1.70 %77.35n/a13 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 1,998,402 %40.81 %1.54 %78.90n/a14 159 RELIANCE GRP 1,926,105 %21.72 %1.49 %80.39n/a15 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 1,209,385 %72.29 %0.93 %81.32n/a16 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 985,751 %15.28 %0.76 %82.08n/a17 963 OHIO MUT GRP 924,662 %23.01 %0.71 %82.80n/a18 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 912,953 %9.59 %0.71 %83.50n/a19 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 813,918 %10.75 %0.63 %84.13n/a20 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 773,539 %-2.26 %0.60 %84.73n/a21 457 ARGONAUT GRP 748,386 %18.30 %0.58 %85.31n/a22 228 WESTFIELD GRP 742,582 %36.10 %0.57 %85.88n/a23 148 OHIO CAS GRP 693,208 %17.16 %0.54 %86.42n/a24 207 WESTERN RESERVE 681,236 %34.20 %0.53 %86.95n/a25 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 676,098 %-7.54 %0.52 %87.47n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 129,351,858 %34.86 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners195

Page 204: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 370,110,740 %56.44 %26.96 %26.9656.96%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 254,179,494 %12.42 %18.51 %45.4713.42%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 121,883,549 %32.19 %8.88 %54.3531.73%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 102,799,803 %11.42 %7.49 %61.8410.98%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 94,902,374 %18.48 %6.91 %68.7519.80%6 361 MUNICH RE GRP 69,668,327 %24.26 %5.07 %73.8226.95%7 218 CNA INS GRP 63,200,590 %66.03 %4.60 %78.4372.35%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 29,294,649 %-2.78 %2.13 %80.56-4.33%9 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 27,631,360 %46.54 %2.01 %82.5746.58%

10 62 EMC INS CO GRP 22,161,551 %12.70 %1.61 %84.1912.70%11 181 SWISS RE GRP 17,510,432 %-41.97 %1.28 %85.46-44.77%12 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 17,449,574 %24.87 %1.27 %86.7324.96%13 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 14,025,621 %26.90 %1.02 %87.7527.10%14 1285 XL AMER GRP 12,242,337 %0.83 %0.89 %88.651.21%15 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 8,229,098 %13.59 %0.60 %89.2413.90%16 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 8,056,750 %10.13 %0.59 %89.8310.14%17 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 7,735,726 %24.06 %0.56 %90.3924.06%18 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 7,421,594 %18.79 %0.54 %90.9418.79%19 14974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS 7,145,660 %13.07 %0.52 %91.4613.07%20 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 5,586,450 %7.61 %0.41 %91.867.65%21 36 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP 5,115,212 %13.78 %0.37 %92.2413.78%22 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,046,123 %5.27 %0.37 %92.604.03%23 626 ACE LTD GRP 4,706,013 %-10.99 %0.34 %92.95-11.21%24 3416 AXIS CAPITAL GRP 4,609,996 %22.81 %0.34 %93.2822.72%25 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,577,008 %34.50 %0.33 %93.6135.96%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,372,955,593 %30.07 %100.00 %100.0030.83%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 304,791,773 %103.57 %24.35 %24.35104.61%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 275,331,249 %17.80 %21.99 %46.3416.57%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 123,577,632 %23.52 %9.87 %56.2124.22%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 104,322,581 %13.37 %8.33 %64.5413.37%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 100,727,903 %29.56 %8.05 %72.5930.81%6 218 CNA INS GRP 67,692,275 %2.49 %5.41 %78.003.14%7 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 27,932,275 %46.44 %2.23 %80.2346.50%8 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 26,730,637 %-39.76 %2.14 %82.36-43.05%9 62 EMC INS CO GRP 19,705,474 %15.12 %1.57 %83.9415.12%

10 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 15,904,371 %18.09 %1.27 %85.2118.14%11 1285 XL AMER GRP 14,275,722 %-7.53 %1.14 %86.35-7.24%12 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 13,958,692 %38.82 %1.12 %87.4639.06%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 9,124,444 %361.85 %0.73 %88.19385.84%14 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 8,564,063 %26.31 %0.68 %88.8826.31%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 7,563,857 %21.83 %0.60 %89.4821.97%16 14974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS 7,290,223 %7.16 %0.58 %90.067.16%17 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 7,033,260 %-9.77 %0.56 %90.63-11.07%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners196

Page 205: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 6,863,611 %11.31 %0.55 %91.1711.85%19 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 6,738,729 %15.29 %0.54 %91.7115.29%20 36 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP 6,647,602 %10.85 %0.53 %92.2410.85%21 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,272,206 %8.63 %0.50 %92.747.34%22 626 ACE LTD GRP 4,744,910 %-15.97 %0.38 %93.12-17.31%23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,617,013 %10.15 %0.37 %93.494.04%24 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 4,023,040 %3.64 %0.32 %93.813.58%25 23108 LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE 3,988,980 %44.73 %0.32 %94.1344.73%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,251,883,880 %42.07 %100.00 %100.0042.38%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 352,662,745 %66.05 %28.81 %28.8166.81%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 207,629,708 %18.92 %16.96 %45.7721.61%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 129,309,020 %9.72 %10.56 %56.3410.87%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 110,088,337 %7.76 %8.99 %65.338.52%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 109,735,254 %6.95 %8.97 %74.307.60%6 218 CNA INS GRP 56,414,656 %34.06 %4.61 %78.9142.71%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 25,275,995 %23.57 %2.06 %80.9722.37%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 24,282,080 %37.80 %1.98 %82.9638.21%9 62 EMC INS CO GRP 18,091,762 %15.64 %1.48 %84.4315.64%

10 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 14,879,729 %25.72 %1.22 %85.6525.77%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 14,680,176 %25.47 %1.20 %86.8525.75%12 1285 XL AMER GRP 13,862,251 %2.41 %1.13 %87.982.42%13 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 9,194,402 %22.61 %0.75 %88.7322.61%14 181 SWISS RE GRP 7,595,772 %32.82 %0.62 %89.3533.71%15 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 6,978,820 %15.72 %0.57 %89.9215.59%16 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 6,974,608 %-46.17 %0.57 %90.49-48.55%17 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,544,726 %4.07 %0.53 %91.036.03%18 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 6,210,394 %19.40 %0.51 %91.5319.40%19 14974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS 6,125,513 %18.48 %0.50 %92.0318.48%20 36 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP 5,630,774 %35.31 %0.46 %92.4935.31%21 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 5,608,388 %17.73 %0.46 %92.9518.74%22 626 ACE LTD GRP 4,983,622 %19.08 %0.41 %93.3620.81%23 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,369,238 %177.68 %0.36 %93.72195.12%24 23108 LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE 4,340,548 %12.14 %0.35 %94.0712.14%25 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 3,883,619 %4.96 %0.32 %94.394.94%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,224,034,335 %31.08 %100.00 %100.0032.51%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 367,293,134 %44.65 %29.78 %29.7844.59%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 169,552,748 %65.90 %13.75 %43.5369.36%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners197

Page 206: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 131,747,276 %17.84 %10.68 %54.2218.92%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 117,112,771 %23.10 %9.50 %63.7123.55%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 115,667,561 %15.20 %9.38 %73.0916.48%6 218 CNA INS GRP 85,106,362 %38.21 %6.90 %79.9940.72%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 24,681,881 %14.75 %2.00 %81.9916.45%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 20,846,135 %35.87 %1.69 %83.6836.70%9 62 EMC INS CO GRP 16,422,024 %15.44 %1.33 %85.0215.44%

10 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 15,362,340 %52.03 %1.25 %86.2652.16%11 1285 XL AMER GRP 13,944,711 %7.87 %1.13 %87.397.18%12 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 12,163,122 %19.43 %0.99 %88.3819.49%13 181 SWISS RE GRP 10,576,537 %18.81 %0.86 %89.2418.61%14 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 9,631,052 %18.38 %0.78 %90.0218.38%15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,850,228 %-47.42 %0.56 %90.57-52.89%16 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 6,664,844 %22.73 %0.54 %91.1123.91%17 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 6,491,721 %-28.93 %0.53 %91.64-47.10%18 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 5,806,167 %14.72 %0.47 %92.1114.72%19 626 ACE LTD GRP 5,797,323 %5.36 %0.47 %92.589.34%20 14974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS 5,301,787 %35.42 %0.43 %93.0135.42%21 36 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP 5,148,984 %13.19 %0.42 %93.4313.19%22 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,962,606 %16.08 %0.40 %93.8317.33%23 23108 LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE 4,296,762 %16.41 %0.35 %94.1816.41%24 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 4,013,024 %18.56 %0.33 %94.5118.91%25 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 3,777,760 %1.70 %0.31 %94.811.72%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,233,205,443 %34.19 %100.00 %100.0035.07%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 347,149,830 %45.18 %29.20 %29.2045.60%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 173,917,382 %14.94 %14.63 %43.8223.07%3 3548 TRAVELERS GRP 135,721,848 %1.71 %11.41 %55.240.77%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 119,788,526 %8.56 %10.07 %65.318.74%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 107,133,148 %6.15 %9.01 %74.327.57%6 218 CNA INS GRP 83,589,745 %-26.67 %7.03 %81.35-27.36%7 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 27,483,748 %31.22 %2.31 %83.6632.82%8 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 18,635,895 %29.66 %1.57 %85.2329.65%9 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 14,970,097 %28.10 %1.26 %86.4927.96%

10 62 EMC INS CO GRP 14,939,263 %12.82 %1.26 %87.7512.82%11 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 9,935,526 %18.83 %0.84 %88.5818.83%12 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 9,169,496 %12.33 %0.77 %89.3512.40%13 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 7,804,794 %86.95 %0.66 %90.0184.86%14 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 6,168,932 %17.86 %0.52 %90.5317.01%15 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 5,903,886 %-5.78 %0.50 %91.02-7.35%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 5,707,176 %-37.37 %0.48 %91.50-35.72%17 3098 TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP 5,688,327 %74.44 %0.48 %91.9887.19%18 1285 XL AMER GRP 5,634,752 %-13.41 %0.47 %92.46-13.64%19 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 5,358,617 %14.09 %0.45 %92.9114.06%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners198

Page 207: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,770,344 %10.17 %0.40 %93.3132.47%21 14974 PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS 4,574,578 %30.29 %0.38 %93.6930.25%22 36 CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP 4,138,877 %19.64 %0.35 %94.0419.64%23 23108 LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE 4,048,101 %17.77 %0.34 %94.3817.77%24 802 CAPITAL INS GRP 3,628,922 %2.47 %0.31 %94.691.71%25 289 ACUITY MUT GRP 2,871,154 %16.45 %0.24 %94.9316.45%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,189,035,828 %18.73 %100.00 %100.0020.21%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 177,883,003 %44.96 %22.50 %22.5046.25%2 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 156,346,880 %83.21 %19.78 %42.2882.24%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 90,002,454 %75.43 %11.38 %53.6676.94%4 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 72,518,362 %57.52 %9.17 %62.8358.56%5 212 ZURICH INS GRP 54,480,531 %44.92 %6.89 %69.7346.28%6 218 CNA INS GRP 51,612,669 %45.14 %6.53 %76.2547.40%7 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 40,753,288 %34.04 %5.15 %81.4137.04%8 164 ST PAUL GRP 25,667,879 %53.14 %3.25 %84.6658.74%9 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 12,805,758 %62.26 %1.62 %86.2864.25%

10 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 10,761,499 %19.48 %1.36 %87.6422.34%11 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 9,052,303 %24.57 %1.15 %88.7825.24%12 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 8,988,483 %33.44 %1.14 %89.9233.65%13 163 SAFECO INS GRP 6,224,787 %21.33 %0.79 %90.7120.30%14 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 4,950,869 %41.16 %0.63 %91.3340.64%15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 4,505,125 %21.10 %0.57 %91.9021.90%16 13528 BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO 3,689,448 %20.99 %0.47 %92.3720.99%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 3,608,632 %-49.39 %0.46 %92.83-43.78%18 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 3,240,873 %85.71 %0.41 %93.2382.52%19 158 FAIRFAX FIN GRP 3,202,742 %26.13 %0.41 %93.6438.08%20 7 FEDERATED MUT GRP 3,114,402 %72.95 %0.39 %94.0372.96%21 62 EMC INS CO GRP 3,103,477 %20.17 %0.39 %94.4320.48%22 169 SENTRY INS GRP 2,954,375 %22.84 %0.37 %94.8022.98%23 950 TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED 2,713,973 %22.41 %0.34 %95.1423.78%24 23108 LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE 2,503,815 %27.21 %0.32 %95.4627.21%25 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,445,286 %28.85 %0.31 %95.7730.66%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 790,575,769 %54.36 %100.00 %100.0055.38%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 388 HARTFORD STEAM BOILER GRP 156,384,165 %32.42 %18.63 %18.63n/a2 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 80,430,432 %44.73 %9.58 %28.21n/a3 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 78,575,105 %28.01 %9.36 %37.57n/a4 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 77,827,892 %35.84 %9.27 %46.84n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners199

Page 208: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 71,821,897 %55.31 %8.56 %55.40n/a6 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 68,869,895 %47.89 %8.20 %63.60n/a7 41 CITIGROUP GRP 51,141,342 %61.71 %6.09 %69.70n/a8 159 RELIANCE GRP 40,776,999 %86.83 %4.86 %74.55n/a9 218 CNA INS GRP 39,954,286 %81.57 %4.76 %79.31n/a

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 31,949,935 %238.49 %3.81 %83.12n/a11 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 21,022,155 %62.30 %2.50 %85.62n/a12 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 13,741,431 %141.45 %1.64 %87.26n/a13 164 ST PAUL GRP 11,799,013 %68.69 %1.41 %88.67n/a14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 10,603,505 %22.14 %1.26 %89.93n/a15 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 10,503,095 %38.32 %1.25 %91.18n/a16 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 10,003,281 %137.63 %1.19 %92.37n/a17 1 AETNA GRP 9,805,258 %86.53 %1.17 %93.54n/a18 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 6,428,116 %15.71 %0.77 %94.31n/a19 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 6,366,406 %56.27 %0.76 %95.06n/a20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 5,885,185 %-54.58 %0.70 %95.77n/a21 44 AVIVA GRP 4,938,447 %23.74 %0.59 %96.35n/a22 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 3,050,690 %316.08 %0.36 %96.72n/a23 88 THE HANOVER INS GRP 3,049,970 %79.68 %0.36 %97.08n/a24 162 ROYAL GRP 2,991,479 %44.99 %0.36 %97.44n/a25 242 SELECTIVE INS GRP 1,688,484 %22.90 %0.20 %97.64n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 839,436,113 %57.75 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 388 HARTFORD STEAM BOILER GRP 152,276,652 %42.42 %22.63 %22.63n/a2 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 76,654,391 %130.25 %11.39 %34.01n/a3 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 64,690,141 %67.03 %9.61 %43.63n/a4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 59,786,315 %96.47 %8.88 %52.51n/a5 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 59,366,441 %122.24 %8.82 %61.33n/a6 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 50,436,433 %31.91 %7.49 %68.82n/a7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 38,743,679 %93.91 %5.76 %74.58n/a8 41 CITIGROUP GRP 37,023,823 %133.52 %5.50 %80.08n/a9 218 CNA INS GRP 31,552,209 %49.44 %4.69 %84.77n/a

10 162 ROYAL GRP 14,975,304 %69.29 %2.23 %86.99n/a11 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 12,530,813 %59.08 %1.86 %88.86n/a12 159 RELIANCE GRP 9,819,190 %50.21 %1.46 %90.31n/a13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 6,805,236 %75.85 %1.01 %91.33n/a14 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 6,734,015 %52.80 %1.00 %92.33n/a15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 6,295,872 %53.12 %0.94 %93.26n/a16 164 ST PAUL GRP 5,834,248 %44.38 %0.87 %94.13n/a17 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 5,646,583 %48.78 %0.84 %94.97n/a18 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 4,859,412 %15.06 %0.72 %95.69n/a19 44 AVIVA GRP 4,135,037 %15.60 %0.61 %96.30n/a20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 3,697,362 %30.22 %0.55 %96.85n/a21 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 3,543,872 %63.28 %0.53 %97.38n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners200

Page 209: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

27 - Boiler and Machinery

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 2,433,075 %67.47 %0.36 %97.74n/a23 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 1,841,874 %-4.42 %0.27 %98.02n/a24 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 1,799,081 %88.97 %0.27 %98.28n/a25 950 TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED 1,310,346 %6.35 %0.19 %98.48n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 673,040,849 %75.80 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 388 HARTFORD STEAM BOILER GRP 128,705,305 %43.83 %22.33 %22.33n/a2 419 ARKWRIGHT BOSTON 89,600,699 %48.85 %15.55 %37.88n/a3 212 ZURICH INS GRP 63,220,286 %38.34 %10.97 %48.85n/a4 65 FM GLOBAL GRP 56,280,854 %27.60 %9.77 %58.62n/a5 29467 PROTECTION MUT INS CO 54,748,593 %38.11 %9.50 %68.12n/a6 108 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP 34,895,096 %33.10 %6.05 %74.17n/a7 38 CHUBB & SON INC GRP 28,560,450 %26.32 %4.96 %79.13n/a8 41 CITIGROUP GRP 26,947,051 %51.86 %4.68 %83.80n/a9 218 CNA INS GRP 24,012,559 %50.71 %4.17 %87.97n/a

10 162 ROYAL GRP 17,342,773 %22.13 %3.01 %90.98n/a11 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 7,067,176 %41.37 %1.23 %92.20n/a12 44 AVIVA GRP 5,915,383 %14.23 %1.03 %93.23n/a13 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 4,777,592 %73.75 %0.83 %94.06n/a14 164 ST PAUL GRP 4,230,963 %28.53 %0.73 %94.79n/a15 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,023,956 %30.79 %0.70 %95.49n/a16 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 3,661,809 %18.81 %0.64 %96.13n/a17 20 LINCOLN NATL GRP 3,036,344 %23.87 %0.53 %96.65n/a18 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 2,783,587 %36.87 %0.48 %97.14n/a19 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 2,508,394 %10.60 %0.44 %97.57n/a20 244 CINCINNATI FIN GRP 2,203,854 %29.48 %0.38 %97.96n/a21 52 CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP 1,846,469 %43.47 %0.32 %98.28n/a22 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 1,727,293 %42.20 %0.30 %98.58n/a23 159 RELIANCE GRP 986,470 %94.44 %0.17 %98.75n/a24 77 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS 755,657 %54.26 %0.13 %98.88n/a25 515 EAGLE INS GRP 515,360 %25.87 %0.09 %98.97n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 576,306,310 %39.65 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners201

Page 210: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 327,362,545 %28.15 %17.33 %17.3328.19%2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 253,886,831 %287.75 %13.44 %30.77288.53%3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 199,793,457 %74.37 %10.58 %41.3574.77%4 796 QBE INS GRP 155,143,007 %30.58 %8.21 %49.5631.65%5 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 153,249,555 %148.65 %8.11 %57.68161.93%6 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 131,720,423 %36.91 %6.97 %64.6536.91%7 31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO 73,945,052 %113.65 %3.91 %68.56116.55%8 93 STATE NATL GRP 61,624,408 %50.32 %3.26 %71.8357.35%9 181 SWISS RE GRP 51,042,438 %60.28 %2.70 %74.5361.28%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 50,087,318 %58.91 %2.65 %77.1858.91%11 1279 ARCH INS GRP 46,508,937 %39.39 %2.46 %79.6439.45%12 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 45,855,025 %94.57 %2.43 %82.0794.54%13 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 31,757,916 %43.09 %1.68 %83.7543.21%14 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 29,748,748 %32.48 %1.57 %85.3332.48%15 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 29,614,585 %37.89 %1.57 %86.9037.88%16 681 SERVICE LIFE GRP 28,970,459 %34.88 %1.53 %88.4334.88%17 626 ACE LTD GRP 28,768,606 %1.43 %1.52 %89.954.84%18 212 ZURICH INS GRP 28,422,478 %679.72 %1.50 %91.46693.60%19 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 18,558,108 %150.22 %0.98 %92.44153.70%20 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 17,133,561 %29.76 %0.91 %93.3529.76%21 697 VAN ENT GRP 15,815,944 %47.36 %0.84 %94.1847.36%22 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 15,789,664 %7.88 %0.84 %95.027.88%23 641 FIRST TOWER GRP 12,999,838 %10.12 %0.69 %95.7110.12%24 2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP 12,678,763 %35.05 %0.67 %96.3835.05%25 18538 BANCINSURE INC 8,123,420 %57.55 %0.43 %96.8157.55%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,888,866,148 %104.67 %100.00 %100.00106.52%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 266,623,126 %106.77 %15.77 %15.77114.34%2 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 223,634,444 %77.00 %13.23 %29.0077.26%3 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 220,569,649 %904.45 %13.05 %42.04906.23%4 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 144,048,013 %31.69 %8.52 %50.5631.69%5 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 81,084,247 %150.58 %4.80 %55.36150.52%6 31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO 79,544,395 %56.96 %4.70 %60.0758.22%7 181 SWISS RE GRP 78,572,606 %55.77 %4.65 %64.7157.41%8 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 69,049,620 %34.82 %4.08 %68.8034.81%9 93 STATE NATL GRP 60,158,154 %42.74 %3.56 %72.3648.84%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 46,594,499 %60.70 %2.76 %75.1160.70%11 681 SERVICE LIFE GRP 43,825,570 %31.46 %2.59 %77.7031.46%12 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 41,209,295 %34.70 %2.44 %80.1434.70%13 1279 ARCH INS GRP 38,287,072 %35.69 %2.26 %82.4135.79%14 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 34,578,202 %25.88 %2.05 %84.4525.88%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 33,106,691 %24.69 %1.96 %86.4124.73%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 30,847,960 %8.78 %1.82 %88.239.02%17 212 ZURICH INS GRP 29,483,508 %34.78 %1.74 %89.9855.01%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners202

Page 211: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 697 VAN ENT GRP 18,862,178 %41.42 %1.12 %91.0941.42%19 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 18,720,717 %34.26 %1.11 %92.2036.69%20 2538 AMTRUST GRP 17,618,582 %17.97 %1.04 %93.2417.97%21 796 QBE INS GRP 12,669,891 %26.92 %0.75 %93.9930.69%22 218 CNA INS GRP 12,366,689 %47.35 %0.73 %94.7247.35%23 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 11,193,855 %48.41 %0.66 %95.3948.59%24 641 FIRST TOWER GRP 11,021,023 %16.23 %0.65 %96.0416.23%25 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 10,020,288 %30.89 %0.59 %96.6330.89%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,690,668,535 %139.70 %100.00 %100.00141.99%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 304,710,578 %281.09 %17.23 %17.23282.44%2 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 232,729,765 %96.42 %13.16 %30.3897.82%3 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 207,070,702 %48.72 %11.71 %42.0948.92%4 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 128,080,827 %78.30 %7.24 %49.3378.18%5 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 126,132,510 %34.44 %7.13 %56.4634.44%6 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 90,368,687 %39.29 %5.11 %61.5739.29%7 181 SWISS RE GRP 86,267,016 %18.72 %4.88 %66.4518.46%8 31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO 69,397,359 %32.77 %3.92 %70.3734.45%9 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 63,553,009 %26.45 %3.59 %73.9726.45%

10 681 SERVICE LIFE GRP 50,063,204 %25.16 %2.83 %76.8025.16%11 93 STATE NATL GRP 49,928,397 %42.91 %2.82 %79.6248.48%12 1279 ARCH INS GRP 49,474,086 %36.14 %2.80 %82.4227.16%13 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 43,644,406 %48.76 %2.47 %84.8848.76%14 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 39,299,805 %19.05 %2.22 %87.1119.05%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 28,241,518 %12.84 %1.60 %88.7013.68%16 2538 AMTRUST GRP 23,194,143 %12.62 %1.31 %90.0112.62%17 212 ZURICH INS GRP 23,095,202 %10.35 %1.31 %91.3213.88%18 626 ACE LTD GRP 21,939,963 %-28.81 %1.24 %92.56-19.97%19 697 VAN ENT GRP 15,189,071 %23.71 %0.86 %93.4223.71%20 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 14,935,627 %39.93 %0.84 %94.2640.44%21 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 12,843,218 %15.64 %0.73 %94.9916.48%22 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 11,839,423 %27.55 %0.67 %95.6627.55%23 641 FIRST TOWER GRP 11,451,450 %9.34 %0.65 %96.319.34%24 1285 XL AMER GRP 11,351,771 %129.81 %0.64 %96.95128.45%25 218 CNA INS GRP 9,129,722 %-148.73 %0.52 %97.46-149.13%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,768,784,932 %89.93 %100.00 %100.0090.56%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 200,062,653 %34.84 %14.30 %14.3034.84%2 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 141,447,978 %81.60 %10.11 %24.4281.28%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners203

Page 212: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 136,188,032 %41.65 %9.74 %34.1541.65%4 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 115,878,354 %56.71 %8.28 %42.4457.51%5 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 101,345,416 %52.20 %7.25 %49.6852.24%6 181 SWISS RE GRP 87,969,206 %49.04 %6.29 %55.9750.37%7 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 83,879,422 %19.42 %6.00 %61.9719.47%8 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 72,681,283 %22.20 %5.20 %67.1622.20%9 31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO 58,235,764 %42.22 %4.16 %71.3343.36%

10 1279 ARCH INS GRP 43,503,128 %36.61 %3.11 %74.4439.48%11 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 41,388,668 %57.48 %2.96 %77.4057.48%12 626 ACE LTD GRP 40,600,402 %36.50 %2.90 %80.3031.00%13 681 SERVICE LIFE GRP 40,154,737 %23.67 %2.87 %83.1723.67%14 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 33,782,075 %27.03 %2.42 %85.5927.03%15 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 29,095,106 %31.05 %2.08 %87.6731.94%16 2538 AMTRUST GRP 25,558,547 %10.84 %1.83 %89.4910.84%17 212 ZURICH INS GRP 20,968,467 %74.85 %1.50 %90.9978.55%18 1285 XL AMER GRP 17,887,290 %9.24 %1.28 %92.2710.87%19 697 VAN ENT GRP 13,605,007 %19.84 %0.97 %93.2419.84%20 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 13,537,603 %27.81 %0.97 %94.2128.19%21 93 STATE NATL GRP 13,207,332 %61.83 %0.94 %95.1669.83%22 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 11,728,225 %22.73 %0.84 %95.9922.73%23 218 CNA INS GRP 11,433,937 %-41.35 %0.82 %96.81-43.43%24 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 10,778,718 %126.61 %0.77 %97.58128.13%25 34568 CENTENNIAL CAS CO 8,070,840 %50.84 %0.58 %98.1650.84%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,398,729,855 %43.25 %100.00 %100.0043.54%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 177,694,951 %27.17 %14.72 %14.7227.17%2 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 140,173,989 %61.44 %11.61 %26.3361.44%3 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 130,621,745 %33.99 %10.82 %37.1533.99%4 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 105,512,166 %58.91 %8.74 %45.8960.32%5 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 90,526,664 %98.10 %7.50 %53.3998.50%6 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 65,105,247 %11.24 %5.39 %58.7811.35%7 181 SWISS RE GRP 61,190,050 %32.80 %5.07 %63.8533.54%8 1279 ARCH INS GRP 41,132,291 %58.64 %3.41 %67.2565.60%9 31887 COFACE N AMER INS CO 39,569,721 %43.07 %3.28 %70.5343.35%

10 1129 WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP 39,271,888 %56.30 %3.25 %73.7856.30%11 626 ACE LTD GRP 35,056,934 %77.60 %2.90 %76.6977.62%12 681 SERVICE LIFE GRP 31,479,206 %22.99 %2.61 %79.3022.99%13 352 HSBC GRP 30,607,306 %20.17 %2.54 %81.8320.17%14 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 30,309,638 %27.03 %2.51 %84.3427.03%15 218 CNA INS GRP 28,544,064 %36.49 %2.36 %86.7134.59%16 317 AON CORP GRP 27,037,788 %19.62 %2.24 %88.9519.62%17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 25,320,834 %0.41 %2.10 %91.041.28%18 212 ZURICH INS GRP 15,050,232 %33.79 %1.25 %92.2936.95%19 93 STATE NATL GRP 13,400,751 %66.95 %1.11 %93.4076.00%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners204

Page 213: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 13,025,866 %82.24 %1.08 %94.4882.46%21 697 VAN ENT GRP 12,927,529 %27.55 %1.07 %95.5527.55%22 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 10,337,737 %18.08 %0.86 %96.4118.08%23 18538 BANCINSURE INC 8,898,583 %55.95 %0.74 %97.1455.95%24 26565 OHIO IND CO 8,521,487 %37.79 %0.71 %97.8539.77%25 34568 CENTENNIAL CAS CO 7,984,944 %34.84 %0.66 %98.5134.84%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,207,291,509 %43.85 %100.00 %100.0044.59%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 119,652,456 %58.00 %23.41 %23.4158.87%2 553 ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP 60,539,274 %39.48 %11.84 %35.2544.71%3 352 HSBC GRP 55,032,253 %12.92 %10.77 %46.0212.92%4 218 CNA INS GRP 51,322,137 %34.96 %10.04 %56.0633.34%5 626 ACE LTD GRP 48,576,944 %1.23 %9.50 %65.561.10%6 44 AVIVA GRP 32,535,544 %59.06 %6.37 %71.9359.06%7 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 24,497,305 %24.25 %4.79 %76.7224.54%8 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 20,762,404 %9.18 %4.06 %80.789.95%9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 15,950,381 %74.51 %3.12 %83.9074.42%

10 181 SWISS RE GRP 14,265,592 %58.68 %2.79 %86.6964.12%11 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 11,107,495 %49.17 %2.17 %88.8751.92%12 408 AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP 10,422,049 %22.14 %2.04 %90.9122.14%13 34568 CENTENNIAL CAS CO 5,947,954 %54.60 %1.16 %92.0754.60%14 317 AON CORP GRP 5,654,282 %79.99 %1.11 %93.1879.99%15 686 SOREMA N AMER GRP 5,596,275 %29.19 %1.09 %94.2729.66%16 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 5,233,272 %124.31 %1.02 %95.30124.72%17 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 4,319,709 %-0.06 %0.85 %96.14-0.06%18 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 2,313,697 %16.91 %0.45 %96.5916.91%19 41 CITIGROUP GRP 2,251,767 %0.00 %0.44 %97.030.00%20 766 RADIAN GRP 2,181,607 %9.95 %0.43 %97.469.95%21 18538 BANCINSURE INC 1,874,899 %25.62 %0.37 %97.8325.62%22 164 ST PAUL GRP 1,576,340 %218.34 %0.31 %98.14211.42%23 210 TITUS GRP 1,234,808 %11.70 %0.24 %98.3811.70%24 948 NATL GEN GRP 1,053,152 %34.51 %0.21 %98.5835.01%25 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 817,369 %13.25 %0.16 %98.7413.25%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 511,144,191 %39.26 %100.00 %100.0040.18%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 20516 AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO 81,358,690 %88.58 %21.20 %21.20n/a2 165 BALBOA INS GRP (THE) 36,748,127 %18.50 %9.57 %30.77n/a3 583 GUARANTY NATL CORP GRP 27,416,977 %43.64 %7.14 %37.91n/a4 218 CNA INS GRP 26,829,361 %44.12 %6.99 %44.90n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners205

Page 214: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 44 AVIVA GRP 23,525,048 %71.62 %6.13 %51.03n/a6 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 21,765,475 %59.66 %5.67 %56.70n/a7 206 BENEFICIAL INS GRP 21,310,032 %38.15 %5.55 %62.25n/a8 777 AMERICAN HERITAGE GRP 20,440,637 %34.60 %5.33 %67.58n/a9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 14,818,267 %45.80 %3.86 %71.44n/a

10 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 13,694,799 %16.90 %3.57 %75.01n/a11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 13,637,516 %71.35 %3.55 %78.56n/a12 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 11,152,569 %13.71 %2.91 %81.46n/a13 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 10,822,344 %45.77 %2.82 %84.28n/a14 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 9,761,622 %37.43 %2.54 %86.83n/a15 34568 CENTENNIAL CAS CO 6,702,981 %40.10 %1.75 %88.57n/a16 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 6,178,411 %86.11 %1.61 %90.18n/a17 15008 MS CAS INS CO 5,690,503 %100.08 %1.48 %91.67n/a18 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 5,483,338 %-7.22 %1.43 %93.09n/a19 894 CITICORP INTL GRP 5,061,187 %7.45 %1.32 %94.41n/a20 159 RELIANCE GRP 4,995,918 %63.81 %1.30 %95.71n/a21 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 4,008,484 %12.98 %1.04 %96.76n/a22 948 NATL GEN GRP 3,024,087 %46.47 %0.79 %97.55n/a23 210 TITUS GRP 2,235,967 %3.16 %0.58 %98.13n/a24 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 1,722,348 %34.09 %0.45 %98.58n/a25 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 1,642,229 %78.73 %0.43 %99.01n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 383,845,881 %49.35 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 105,616,207 %61.17 %24.62 %24.62n/a2 20516 AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO 73,646,544 %86.12 %17.17 %41.79n/a3 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 71,065,000 %40.67 %16.57 %58.36n/a4 926 ORION CAPITAL GRP 25,447,061 %51.27 %5.93 %64.29n/a5 218 CNA INS GRP 23,708,419 %101.92 %5.53 %69.82n/a6 35831 POLICYHOLDERS BENEFIT CORP 22,253,094 %78.64 %5.19 %75.00n/a7 165 BALBOA INS GRP (THE) 15,762,504 %22.99 %3.67 %78.68n/a8 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 12,013,091 %16.36 %2.80 %81.48n/a9 306 CUNA MUT GRP 11,127,471 %207.60 %2.59 %84.07n/a

10 342 CONSOLIDATED INTL INS GRP 9,943,114 %38.87 %2.32 %86.39n/a11 304 PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP 7,297,040 %17.75 %1.70 %88.09n/a12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 7,121,518 %122.55 %1.66 %89.75n/a13 923 ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP 7,040,651 %13.06 %1.64 %91.39n/a14 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 6,245,676 %-17.82 %1.46 %92.85n/a15 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 5,958,442 %63.25 %1.39 %94.24n/a16 91 HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP 4,578,341 %-8.90 %1.07 %95.30n/a17 206 BENEFICIAL INS GRP 4,297,860 %35.26 %1.00 %96.31n/a18 777 AMERICAN HERITAGE GRP 3,142,253 %43.00 %0.73 %97.04n/a19 421 COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP 2,332,027 %12.20 %0.54 %97.58n/a20 210 TITUS GRP 1,606,454 %3.54 %0.37 %97.96n/a21 519 SKANDIA AMER GRP 1,499,000 %100.00 %0.35 %98.31n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners206

Page 215: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

28 - Credit

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 41 CITIGROUP GRP 1,468,631 %56.22 %0.34 %98.65n/a23 30945 NATIONAL ALLIANCE INS CO 1,431,545 %35.44 %0.33 %98.98n/a24 15008 MS CAS INS CO 1,127,769 %85.06 %0.26 %99.25n/a25 35874 OLD HICKORY CAS INS CO 1,028,328 %45.68 %0.24 %99.49n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 428,964,507 %62.79 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 252,292,193 %84.78 %28.15 %28.15n/a2 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 89,687,879 %111.63 %10.01 %38.16n/a3 105 MGIC GRP 86,910,434 %56.33 %9.70 %47.86n/a4 642 TI CORP GRP 85,367,210 %96.25 %9.53 %57.39n/a5 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 83,226,858 %100.39 %9.29 %66.67n/a6 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 51,479,939 %61.37 %5.74 %72.42n/a7 306 CUNA MUT GRP 48,107,612 %93.66 %5.37 %77.79n/a8 20516 AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO 44,806,533 %32.61 %5.00 %82.79n/a9 766 RADIAN GRP 34,417,762 %64.35 %3.84 %86.63n/a

10 159 RELIANCE GRP 23,380,165 %26.17 %2.61 %89.24n/a11 218 CNA INS GRP 15,095,543 %41.69 %1.68 %90.92n/a12 342 CONSOLIDATED INTL INS GRP 9,262,647 %78.52 %1.03 %91.95n/a13 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 8,905,514 %169.16 %0.99 %92.95n/a14 1125 SCPIE GRP 8,001,063 %88.46 %0.89 %93.84n/a15 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 5,858,245 %55.30 %0.65 %94.50n/a16 165 BALBOA INS GRP (THE) 5,799,875 %33.68 %0.65 %95.14n/a17 41 CITIGROUP GRP 5,760,190 %16.15 %0.64 %95.79n/a18 827 AMERIN GRP 3,599,954 %52.44 %0.40 %96.19n/a19 790 FREMONT GEN GRP 2,869,980 %50.87 %0.32 %96.51n/a20 623 HEALTH NET INC GRP 2,654,248 %22.20 %0.30 %96.80n/a21 169 SENTRY INS GRP 2,650,038 %0.00 %0.30 %97.10n/a22 164 ST PAUL GRP 2,553,303 %23.64 %0.28 %97.38n/a23 299 INTEGRITY INS GRP 2,086,478 %236.54 %0.23 %97.62n/a24 1113 MEDMARK INS GRP 1,793,414 %23.24 %0.20 %97.82n/a25 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 1,620,081 %23.15 %0.18 %98.00n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 896,130,527 %85.46 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners207

Page 216: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

30 - Warranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 924,459,101 %75.49 %34.82 %34.8275.49%2 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 429,067,988 %58.72 %16.16 %50.9958.71%3 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 249,484,182 %69.52 %9.40 %60.3969.92%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 177,631,886 %43.04 %6.69 %67.0843.10%5 2538 AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP 133,397,333 %80.17 %5.03 %72.1080.17%6 281 JM FAMILY GRP 110,363,381 %55.28 %4.16 %76.2655.99%7 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 92,947,730 %41.22 %3.50 %79.7641.25%8 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 70,223,440 %40.20 %2.65 %82.4140.20%9 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 69,183,442 %67.98 %2.61 %85.0169.01%

10 16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO 55,551,987 %60.91 %2.09 %87.1160.91%11 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 55,098,441 %96.39 %2.08 %89.1896.39%12 697 VAN ENT GRP 53,200,895 %44.37 %2.00 %91.1844.37%13 1285 XL AMER GRP 52,040,218 %98.98 %1.96 %93.15100.36%14 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 32,504,426 %46.32 %1.22 %94.3746.35%15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 32,104,712 %83.21 %1.21 %95.5883.20%16 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 27,284,272 %91.40 %1.03 %96.6191.39%17 218 CNA INS GRP 16,838,793 %66.37 %0.63 %97.2466.83%18 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 16,104,997 %66.56 %0.61 %97.8566.56%19 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 13,065,980 %80.72 %0.49 %98.3480.72%20 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 7,605,292 %36.53 %0.29 %98.6336.53%21 1226 GEORGE A PARMER GRP 7,526,885 %39.25 %0.28 %98.9141.01%22 32107 SUTTER INS CO 5,270,300 %70.72 %0.20 %99.1170.72%23 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 4,770,441 %109.35 %0.18 %99.29109.35%24 10499 CHRYSLER INS CO 4,637,049 %61.18 %0.17 %99.4661.30%25 23479 NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC 3,645,368 %57.46 %0.14 %99.6057.33%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 2,654,619,879 %65.25 %100.00 %100.0065.43%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 795,727,457 %85.87 %25.42 %25.4285.87%2 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 610,607,849 %53.05 %19.51 %44.9353.06%3 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 296,816,042 %68.64 %9.48 %54.4169.13%4 2538 AMTRUST GRP 208,400,451 %63.83 %6.66 %61.0763.81%5 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 195,244,910 %38.79 %6.24 %67.3138.81%6 1285 XL AMER GRP 156,364,392 %5.00 %72.300.00%7 281 JM FAMILY GRP 114,389,818 %48.80 %3.65 %75.9649.51%8 212 ZURICH INS GRP 112,133,997 %205.11 %3.58 %79.54205.11%9 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 106,028,883 %38.75 %3.39 %82.9338.75%

10 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 103,363,630 %85.05 %3.30 %86.2385.05%11 471 WELLS FARGO GRP 71,140,182 %63.87 %2.27 %88.5064.93%12 697 VAN ENT GRP 62,944,041 %45.56 %2.01 %90.5145.56%13 16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO 59,630,250 %51.42 %1.91 %92.4251.42%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 50,341,060 %80.25 %1.61 %94.0380.25%15 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 47,741,408 %1.53 %95.550.00%16 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 29,847,948 %86.28 %0.95 %96.5186.27%17 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 24,069,717 %83.00 %0.77 %97.2783.00%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners208

Page 217: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

30 - Warranty

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 218 CNA INS GRP 20,826,048 %52.17 %0.67 %97.9452.37%19 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 15,943,282 %63.23 %0.51 %98.4563.23%20 1281 BANKAMERICA CORP GRP 13,133,711 %84.75 %0.42 %98.8784.75%21 32107 SUTTER INS CO 8,007,344 %70.72 %0.26 %99.1270.72%22 10499 CHRYSLER INS CO 7,536,989 %63.66 %0.24 %99.3763.66%23 37621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO 6,790,335 %41.59 %0.22 %99.5841.59%24 23479 NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC 3,603,033 %57.92 %0.12 %99.7057.98%25 10817 PLATEAU CAS INS CO 2,488,319 %33.05 %0.08 %99.7833.05%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,130,100,234 %78.81 %100.00 %100.0078.85%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners209

Page 218: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2009

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 10899 ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG 203,320,887 %53.67 %14.37 %14.3753.67%2 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 172,906,638 %57.82 %12.22 %26.5958.28%3 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 103,224,107 %13.02 %7.29 %33.8813.52%4 212 ZURICH INS GRP 71,800,024 %52.66 %5.07 %38.9563.44%5 29378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 69,772,777 %0.00 %4.93 %43.880.00%6 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 61,804,568 %59.51 %4.37 %48.2559.51%7 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 58,902,843 %0.34 %4.16 %52.410.34%8 37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC 53,542,912 %31.65 %3.78 %56.2031.65%9 41 CITIGROUP GRP 50,989,267 %105.95 %3.60 %59.80105.95%

10 34738 ARAG INS CO 50,919,240 %53.20 %3.60 %63.4053.20%11 281 JM FAMILY GRP 49,479,637 %66.69 %3.50 %66.9070.55%12 3702 LOYA GRP 41,201,496 %0.00 %2.91 %69.810.00%13 1279 ARCH INS GRP 40,342,029 %101.68 %2.85 %72.66103.88%14 1208 GRAY INS GRP 38,330,090 %49.14 %2.71 %75.3756.48%15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 38,138,727 %52.75 %2.70 %78.0652.75%16 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 34,234,065 %103.77 %2.42 %80.48103.77%17 26565 OHIO IND CO 23,382,190 %65.14 %1.65 %82.1366.89%18 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 20,975,254 %62.78 %1.48 %83.6262.78%19 10906 COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO 19,384,531 %25.77 %1.37 %84.9933.57%20 3483 PARTNERRE GRP 17,944,723 %59.81 %1.27 %86.2559.81%21 626 ACE LTD GRP 17,614,317 %93.72 %1.24 %87.5094.56%22 4071 RVI GRP 16,037,328 %12.57 %1.13 %88.6312.57%23 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 15,837,374 %0.15 %1.12 %89.750.15%24 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 15,384,573 %28.39 %1.09 %90.8428.41%25 984 HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP 14,274,088 %-0.04 %1.01 %91.85-0.04%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,415,117,811 %52.25 %100.00 %100.0053.57%

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 10899 ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG 202,428,047 %57.53 %15.82 %15.8257.53%2 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 155,101,338 %146.32 %12.13 %27.95146.43%3 41 CITIGROUP GRP 112,957,285 %35.68 %8.83 %36.7835.68%4 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 88,080,645 %82.09 %6.89 %43.6782.09%5 29378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 57,258,792 %0.00 %4.48 %48.140.00%6 37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC 54,236,771 %31.12 %4.24 %52.3831.12%7 212 ZURICH INS GRP 50,057,620 %72.21 %3.91 %56.3086.19%8 34738 ARAG INS CO 49,963,194 %51.63 %3.91 %60.2051.63%9 1279 ARCH INS GRP 44,533,464 %76.59 %3.48 %63.6875.26%

10 1208 GRAY INS GRP 43,031,956 %61.26 %3.36 %67.0570.81%11 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 41,048,313 %150.77 %3.21 %70.26150.77%12 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 37,648,784 %53.81 %2.94 %73.2053.81%13 3702 LOYA GRP 35,015,718 %0.00 %2.74 %75.940.00%14 4071 RVI GRP 27,828,148 %95.38 %2.18 %78.1195.38%15 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 25,460,042 %13.64 %1.99 %80.1013.64%16 26565 OHIO IND CO 25,280,723 %68.62 %1.98 %82.0872.11%17 10906 COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO 19,821,664 %22.44 %1.55 %83.6329.59%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners210

Page 219: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2008

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

18 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 19,454,056 %44.28 %1.52 %85.1544.53%19 626 ACE LTD GRP 18,982,282 %20.92 %1.48 %86.6321.89%20 457 ARGONAUT GRP 15,760,825 %113.37 %1.23 %87.87113.37%21 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 15,666,844 %-0.10 %1.22 %89.09-0.09%22 468 AEGON US HOLDING GRP 15,244,845 %44.35 %1.19 %90.2843.15%23 3569 CATERPILLAR GRP 12,873,171 %62.74 %1.01 %91.2962.74%24 176 STATE FARM GRP 12,465,571 %91.57 %0.97 %92.2691.57%25 11835 PARIS RE AMER INS CO 10,815,071 %0.00 %0.85 %93.110.00%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 1,279,169,984 %50.08 %100.00 %100.0050.92%

2007

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 710,570,975 %59.53 %16.71 %16.7159.59%2 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 298,808,152 %46.09 %7.03 %23.7346.16%3 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 276,869,203 %70.14 %6.51 %30.2471.02%4 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 274,980,074 %39.68 %6.47 %36.7139.68%5 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 253,209,618 %53.50 %5.95 %42.6653.80%6 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 208,325,058 %70.41 %4.90 %47.5671.18%7 10899 ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG 186,807,772 %63.61 %4.39 %51.9663.61%8 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 181,032,801 %79.05 %4.26 %56.2179.14%9 1285 XL AMER GRP 175,015,864 %87.73 %4.12 %60.3389.18%

10 212 ZURICH INS GRP 171,054,533 %67.51 %4.02 %64.3574.72%11 281 JM FAMILY GRP 135,738,634 %42.33 %3.19 %67.5443.03%12 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 110,083,086 %88.84 %2.59 %70.1388.84%13 1208 GRAY INS GRP 97,683,570 %1,572.65 %2.30 %72.431,580.94%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 94,542,860 %75.28 %2.22 %74.6575.29%15 39527 HERITAGE IND CO 80,142,799 %63.47 %1.88 %76.5364.63%16 697 VAN ENT GRP 78,463,510 %47.56 %1.84 %78.3847.56%17 41 CITIGROUP GRP 77,094,470 %31.46 %1.81 %80.1931.46%18 29378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 57,983,799 %0.00 %1.36 %81.560.00%19 1279 ARCH INS GRP 56,717,866 %55.64 %1.33 %82.8960.44%20 16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO 52,915,153 %49.38 %1.24 %84.1349.38%21 37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC 51,915,240 %30.93 %1.22 %85.3530.93%22 796 QBE INS GRP 47,684,654 %53.71 %1.12 %86.4849.43%23 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 44,061,979 %75.42 %1.04 %87.5179.45%24 34738 ARAG INS CO 40,400,253 %50.65 %0.95 %88.4650.65%25 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 40,094,025 %81.29 %0.94 %89.4081.30%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,252,822,171 %93.03 %100.00 %100.0094.14%

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 801,299,038 %61.14 %18.33 %18.3361.18%2 4254 THE WARRANTY GRP 397,757,969 %69.00 %9.10 %27.4470.18%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners211

Page 220: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2006

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

3 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 280,149,898 %53.59 %6.41 %33.8553.59%4 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 276,453,220 %42.95 %6.33 %40.1743.07%5 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 258,452,963 %68.97 %5.91 %46.0969.17%6 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 208,155,266 %64.67 %4.76 %50.8564.91%7 10899 ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG 198,456,178 %75.70 %4.54 %55.3975.70%8 1285 XL AMER GRP 187,327,246 %82.35 %4.29 %59.6884.06%9 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 177,022,556 %124.43 %4.05 %63.73124.56%

10 281 JM FAMILY GRP 123,490,108 %41.58 %2.83 %66.5542.33%11 1208 GRAY INS GRP 113,699,779 %60.31 %2.60 %69.1568.17%12 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 89,748,426 %94.34 %2.05 %71.2194.34%13 212 ZURICH INS GRP 85,434,927 %52.37 %1.95 %73.1652.37%14 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 82,250,761 %71.40 %1.88 %75.0471.41%15 697 VAN ENT GRP 77,860,331 %47.78 %1.78 %76.8347.78%16 517 HANNOVER GRP 76,990,393 %82.59 %1.76 %78.5986.18%17 41 CITIGROUP GRP 63,307,595 %26.52 %1.45 %80.0426.52%18 29378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 59,750,109 %0.00 %1.37 %81.400.00%19 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 57,096,622 %61.03 %1.31 %82.7162.01%20 37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC 51,558,312 %30.97 %1.18 %83.8930.97%21 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 48,629,849 %171.04 %1.11 %85.00178.21%22 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 40,018,981 %77.59 %0.92 %85.9277.64%23 256 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP 38,916,991 %61.85 %0.89 %86.8168.57%24 26565 OHIO IND CO 38,326,177 %58.88 %0.88 %87.6860.92%25 4071 RVI GRP 36,046,101 %23.33 %0.82 %88.5123.33%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,370,376,971 %64.73 %100.00 %100.0065.55%

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 893,168,944 %74.60 %19.17 %19.1774.66%2 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 509,842,106 %55.67 %10.94 %30.1155.67%3 317 AON CORP GRP 338,609,098 %70.76 %7.27 %37.3871.93%4 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 262,910,790 %90.20 %5.64 %43.0290.30%5 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 253,630,273 %45.60 %5.44 %48.4645.56%6 1285 XL AMER GRP 188,833,481 %81.27 %4.05 %52.5281.93%7 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 187,854,545 %136.91 %4.03 %56.55137.00%8 70 FIRST AMER TITLE GRP 186,598,898 %51.78 %4.00 %60.5551.78%9 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 182,701,113 %42.00 %3.92 %64.4753.69%

10 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 163,522,021 %66.72 %3.51 %67.9867.37%11 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 114,765,123 %163.15 %2.46 %70.45181.68%12 1208 GRAY INS GRP 98,120,107 %57.18 %2.11 %72.5564.62%13 281 JM FAMILY GRP 98,059,300 %39.60 %2.10 %74.6639.60%14 517 HANNOVER GRP 90,585,020 %64.65 %1.94 %76.6064.68%15 140 NATIONWIDE CORP GRP 89,617,300 %97.73 %1.92 %78.5297.73%16 212 ZURICH INS GRP 79,278,415 %57.47 %1.70 %80.2257.47%17 697 VAN ENT GRP 73,377,338 %54.27 %1.57 %81.8054.27%18 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 69,873,423 %91.95 %1.50 %83.3091.95%19 29378 OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 69,300,528 %0.00 %1.49 %84.790.00%

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners212

Page 221: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

2005

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

20 41 CITIGROUP GRP 67,275,033 %9.41 %1.44 %86.239.06%21 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 57,835,175 %196.24 %1.24 %87.47208.58%22 37869 PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC 50,616,078 %31.32 %1.09 %88.5631.32%23 660 MERCURY GEN GRP 38,983,838 %80.70 %0.84 %89.3980.49%24 10344 RVI AMER INS CO 37,598,671 %26.16 %0.81 %90.2026.16%25 218 CNA INS GRP 36,565,222 %54.63 %0.78 %90.9955.59%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,659,563,636 %71.18 %100.00 %100.0072.51%

2000

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 896,884,956 %53.67 %22.19 %22.1953.67%2 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 715,384,671 %89.37 %17.70 %39.9089.37%3 317 AON CORP GRP 478,430,945 %80.20 %11.84 %51.7480.95%4 218 CNA INS GRP 181,712,892 %86.72 %4.50 %56.2387.91%5 458 PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP 145,649,747 %101.90 %3.60 %59.84101.90%6 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 131,513,835 %73.64 %3.25 %63.0975.76%7 34215 NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD 125,707,638 %5.77 %3.11 %66.205.82%8 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 117,297,785 %30.92 %2.90 %69.1133.58%9 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 111,395,857 %31.75 %2.76 %71.8630.62%

10 1285 XL AMER GRP 88,650,715 %96.38 %2.19 %74.06106.60%11 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 77,838,649 %-123.55 %1.93 %75.98-129.12%12 212 ZURICH INS GRP 63,133,276 %73.95 %1.56 %77.5573.96%13 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 61,305,476 %67.67 %1.52 %79.0668.58%14 281 JM FAMILY GRP 56,448,254 %68.01 %1.40 %80.4668.56%15 37869 PRE-PAID LEGAL CAS INC 49,148,773 %35.58 %1.22 %81.6837.57%16 626 ACE LTD GRP 43,679,812 %39.53 %1.08 %82.7639.46%17 697 VAN ENT GRP 43,338,149 %73.77 %1.07 %83.8373.77%18 74 DELPHI FIN GRP 42,919,449 %77.26 %1.06 %84.8978.04%19 268 JC PENNEY CO 41,905,439 %3.39 %1.04 %85.933.39%20 41 CITIGROUP GRP 40,652,369 %15.89 %1.01 %86.9316.01%21 98 WR BERKLEY CORP GRP 38,783,661 %-194.49 %0.96 %87.89-193.62%22 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 26,758,988 %7.11 %0.66 %88.567.11%23 1208 GRAY INS GRP 24,828,613 %107.50 %0.61 %89.17111.02%24 1330 BALBOA INS GRP 24,261,856 %5.40 %0.60 %89.775.40%25 12 AMERICAN INTL GRP 23,560,423 %26.70 %0.58 %90.3528.03%

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 4,040,954,413 %57.81 %100.00 %100.0058.27%

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 79 GMAC INS HOLDING GRP 386,985,259 %90.16 %12.75 %12.75n/a2 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 339,106,567 %44.45 %11.17 %23.92n/a3 317 AON CORP GRP 298,610,804 %85.96 %9.84 %33.76n/a4 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 272,697,226 %112.81 %8.98 %42.75n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners213

Page 222: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1995

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

5 34215 NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD 226,033,794 %0.97 %7.45 %50.19n/a6 176 STATE FARM GRP 205,806,944 %134.71 %6.78 %56.98n/a7 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 172,468,200 %64.46 %5.68 %62.66n/a8 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 117,247,155 %57.77 %3.86 %66.52n/a9 31364 NUCLEAR MUT LTD 87,496,816 %40.06 %2.88 %69.40n/a

10 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 79,324,360 %18.57 %2.61 %72.02n/a11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 44,292,987 %73.43 %1.46 %73.48n/a12 80 GENERAL REIN CP 43,475,962 %177.19 %1.43 %74.91n/a13 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP 40,278,680 %60.64 %1.33 %76.24n/a14 812 HIGHMARK GRP 39,448,374 %18.14 %1.30 %77.54n/a15 355 LYNDON INS GRP 36,220,774 %10.36 %1.19 %78.73n/a16 36307 GRAY INS CO 35,943,953 %49.94 %1.18 %79.91n/a17 218 CNA INS GRP 34,264,571 %76.92 %1.13 %81.04n/a18 761 ALLIANZ INS GRP 31,603,188 %71.30 %1.04 %82.08n/a19 168 SEIBELS BRUCE GRP 28,576,345 %197.03 %0.94 %83.03n/a20 84 AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP 28,058,469 %94.10 %0.92 %83.95n/a21 200 UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP 25,309,664 %194.67 %0.83 %84.78n/a22 111 LIBERTY MUT GRP 20,246,569 %111.75 %0.67 %85.45n/a23 901 CIGNA HLTH GRP 19,789,441 %210.75 %0.65 %86.10n/a24 268 JC PENNEY CO 18,880,581 %17.23 %0.62 %86.73n/a25 41 CITIGROUP GRP 18,367,558 %38.41 %0.61 %87.33n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,035,064,884 %68.56 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 519,478,593 %63.80 %15.72 %15.72n/a2 730 MEDICAL MUT OF OH GRP 347,055,919 %86.86 %10.50 %26.22n/a3 18 AMERICAN ROAD GRP 291,061,508 %80.01 %8.81 %35.03n/a4 105 MGIC GRP 251,323,723 %71.45 %7.60 %42.63n/a5 34215 NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD 175,097,000 %0.88 %5.30 %47.93n/a6 8 ALLSTATE INS GRP 123,119,046 %42.17 %3.73 %51.66n/a7 317 AON CORP GRP 98,916,168 %82.80 %2.99 %54.65n/a8 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 85,841,451 %7.34 %2.60 %57.25n/a9 212 ZURICH INS GRP 80,370,641 %92.16 %2.43 %59.68n/a

10 31364 NUCLEAR MUT LTD 80,260,000 %10.61 %2.43 %62.11n/a11 261 MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP 78,953,598 %19.60 %2.39 %64.50n/a12 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 78,141,447 %35.54 %2.36 %66.86n/a13 80 GENERAL REIN CP 75,413,000 %57.94 %2.28 %69.14n/a14 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 59,275,663 %47.94 %1.79 %70.94n/a15 329 ACCEPTANCE INS GRP 58,329,183 %94.74 %1.76 %72.70n/a16 766 RADIAN GRP 56,452,462 %58.91 %1.71 %74.41n/a17 11 AMERICAN GEN GRP 42,744,241 %57.79 %1.29 %75.70n/a18 1111 TIG INS GRP 42,626,758 %58.02 %1.29 %76.99n/a19 176 STATE FARM GRP 42,105,996 %93.62 %1.27 %78.27n/a20 556 AMERICAN FEED INS GRP 41,751,886 %181.80 %1.26 %79.53n/a21 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 40,716,780 %19.84 %1.23 %80.76n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners214

Page 223: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

34 - Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

States, U.S. Territories, Canada, and Aggregate Other Alien

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

1990

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

22 291 MOTORISTS MUT GRP 37,385,472 %96.30 %1.13 %81.89n/a23 306 CUNA MUT GRP 36,523,616 %46.02 %1.11 %83.00n/a24 129 PROP & CAS STANDARD GRP 34,768,481 %71.65 %1.05 %84.05n/a25 168 SEIBELS BRUCE GRP 33,620,061 %97.41 %1.02 %85.07n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 3,304,773,370 %66.32 %100.00 %100.00n/a

1985

ShareMarket

Prem Company/Group NameDirect Written

PremiumDirect Loss

to EP Ratio¹NAICCode

Direct Lossand DCC

to EP Ratio²MarketShare

Cumulativeby

Rank

1 317 AON CORP GRP 88,262,145 %68.48 %15.30 %15.30n/a2 261 MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP 49,549,326 %70.18 %8.59 %23.89n/a3 238 FOREMOST CORP AMER 36,299,155 %45.10 %6.29 %30.18n/a4 129 PROP & CAS STANDARD GRP 36,064,014 %134.40 %6.25 %36.43n/a5 80 GENERAL REIN CP 35,235,093 %84.98 %6.11 %42.53n/a6 167 UNITED EQUITABLE GRP 31,225,378 %112.00 %5.41 %47.95n/a7 32727 UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS 28,403,880 %31.08 %4.92 %52.87n/a8 10200 AMERICAN LIVE STOCK INS CO 23,991,251 %75.45 %4.16 %57.03n/a9 783 RLI INS GRP 18,165,899 %49.35 %3.15 %60.18n/a

10 330 AMERICAN FIDELITY CORP GRP 13,838,009 %50.17 %2.40 %62.57n/a11 212 ZURICH INS GRP 12,498,283 %2.17 %64.74n/a12 556 AMERICAN FEED INS GRP 8,551,535 %93.55 %1.48 %66.22n/a13 465 AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP 8,379,877 %70.51 %1.45 %67.68n/a14 150 OLD REPUBLIC GRP 7,567,769 %68.37 %1.31 %68.99n/a15 239 LEUCADIA GRP 7,400,954 %107.03 %1.28 %70.27n/a16 19 ASSURANT INC GRP 6,917,641 %24.09 %1.20 %71.47n/a17 31 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP 6,730,573 %51.05 %1.17 %72.64n/a18 169 SENTRY INS GRP 6,482,286 %36.07 %1.12 %73.76n/a19 350 GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP 6,337,082 %93.65 %1.10 %74.86n/a20 441 ACCELERATION CORP 5,566,342 %106.00 %0.96 %75.82n/a21 275 AUSTIN MUT GRP 5,455,758 %60.08 %0.95 %76.77n/a22 11231 GENERALI-US BRANCH 5,369,396 %68.63 %0.93 %77.70n/a23 41 CITIGROUP GRP 5,329,075 %46.28 %0.92 %78.62n/a24 400 CREDIT SUISSE GRP 5,297,392 %129.50 %0.92 %79.54n/a25 215 UNITRIN GRP 5,194,012 %45.41 %0.90 %80.44n/a

** INDUSTRY TOTAL ** 576,962,810 %79.64 %100.00 %100.00n/a

¹ (Direct losses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned)

² (Direct losses incurred + Direct defense and cost containment expenses incurred) / (Direct premiums earned). N/A prior to 2000.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners215

Page 224: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners216

Page 225: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

TECHNICAL NOTES

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners217

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 226: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners218

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 227: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2009 MARKET SHARE REPORTS FOR THE TOP 25 PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURERS OVER 25 YEARS

TECHNICAL NOTES Direct Written Premium – 2009 Annual Statement Page 19 (State Page), Column 1

Line Number Line Description 35 Total All Lines (previous to 2008 this line number was 34) 01 Fire

02.1 Allied Lines

02.2 Multiple Peril Crop

02.3 Federal Flood

03 Farmowners Multiple Peril

04 Homeowners Multiple Peril

05.1 + 05.2 Total Commercial Multiple Peril

06 Mortgage Guaranty

08 Ocean Marine

09 Inland Marine

10 Financial Guaranty

11 Medical Malpractice

12 Earthquake

16 Workers’ Compensation

17.1 + 17.2 Other Liability * (Occurrence and Claims Made – split out in 2008)

17.3 Excess Workers’ Compensation * (split out in 2008)

18 Products Liability

19.1 + 19.2 Private Passenger Auto Liability

21.1 Private Passenger Auto Physical Damage

19.1 + 19.2 + 21.1 Total Private Passenger Auto

19.3 + 19.4 Commercial Auto Liability

21.2 Commercial Auto Physical Damage

19.3 + 19.4 + 21.2 Total Commercial Auto

22 Aircraft (All Perils)

23 Fidelity

24 Surety

26 Burglary and Theft

27 Boiler and Machinery

28 Credit

30 Warranty * (new in 2008)

34 Aggregate Write-Ins for Other Lines of Business

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners219

Page 228: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Other Liability – Lines 17.1 and 17.2 For this report, Line 17.1—Other Liability Occurrence and Line 17.2—Other Liability Claims Made are reported as follows:

[(Other Liability Occurrence + Other Liability Claims Made) – Excess Workers’ Compensation]

Years prior to 2009 may have included Excess Workers’ Compensation. Additionally, the line number for Excess Workers’ Compensation in the year 2008 was Line 17.1. Products Liability – Line 18 For the State Page (and thus Top 25 report), the NAIC has been instructing companies to report line 18—Products Liability as:

[(Products Liability Occurrence) + (Products Liability Claims Made)] Glass – Line 25 Line 25—The Glass line of business was broken out in the NAIC Property and Casualty Annual Statement prior to the year 1996. After 1996, line 25 was combined with the Allied Lines line of business. Warranty – Line 30 Line 30—Warranty was broken out beginning with the 2008 annual statement. Prior to 2008, this data was included in the write-in line of business section. Loss Ratio If earned premiums are zero or negative, then Loss Ratio = n/a. Direct Loss to Earned Premium Ratio = [(Direct Losses Incurred/Direct Premiums Earned)*100] Direct Loss and Direct Defense and Cost Containment Expenses to Earned Premium Ratio = [(Direct Losses Incurred + Direct Defense and Cost Containment Expenses Incurred)/(Direct Premiums Earned)*100] Effective January 1, 1998, the NAIC redefined Allocated Loss Adjustment Expense (ALAE) and Unallocated Loss Adjustment Expense (ULAE) as Defense and Cost Containment Expenses and Adjusting and Other Expenses. As such, the Direct Loss and Defense and Cost Containment Expenses Incurred ratio is not available for years prior to 1998. Market Share Market Share is equal to a company or group’s premiums divided by the total premiums multiplied by 100. Rankings for years in which a group either did not exist or did not write business in the designated line are indicated by the letters “N/R,” meaning there is no ranking. The report includes only those companies that filed by May 26, 2010. Market share reports produced by the NAIC characterize a moment in time, and therefore are a snapshot of data as it existed on the date this report was run. Due to insurer filings and refilings, data in historical years may not match data as reported in the market shares of previous years. For purposes of this report, “group” refers to those companies with a common NAIC group code as reflected for that reporting year in the NAIC database.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners220

Page 229: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Workers’ Compensation & Other State Funds Data for certain state funds/residual market mechanisms are provided directly to the NAIC. It should be noted that the year-end for many of these funds is June 30 instead of December 31. Some of the state funds use allocated loss adjustment expenses instead of direct defense and cost containment expenses. Not all of the state funds are reported to the NAIC in each of the years included in this report. Additionally, the direct premium written figure for Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is unaudited, and thus subject to restatement. The funds for the years 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009 are listed in the tables below:

2005 Supplemental State Fund Data

State Name

Direct Premiums Written

Direct Premiums

Earned Direct Losses

Incurred

Direct Defense & Cost

Containment Exp. Incurred

MT The Montana State Compensation Ins. Fund 198,286,132 189,378,858 152,545,131 2,571,036 ND* Workforce Safety & Insurance 121,119,872 120,533,401 101,710,196 3,831,429 OH* Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation 2,194,573,000 2,194,573,000 2,455,577,000 494,729,000 OK CompSource Oklahoma 282,306,742 280,872,094 250,842,254 10,112,705 PA* Pennsylvania State Workers' Insurance Fund 416,586,359 419,145,470 295,860,523 70,199,756 SC South Carolina State Accident Fund 81,084,143 78,689,929 127,366,000 None reported WA Washington State Fund 1,268,213,000 1,268,213,000 1,386,587,000 None reported WV WV Workers' Compensation Division 710,501,000 710,501,000 307,577,000 None reported WY* The Wyoming Div. of Workers’ Safety & Comp. 194,554,600 194,554,600 159,236,000 13,990,000 LA* Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 130,049,752 131,584,039 1,325,497,671 150,139,000 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 33,720,606 29,513,673 17,463,137 8,900,814 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 25,278,990 27,641,915 581,355,331 61,204,186 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 71,050,156 74,428,451 726,679,203 80,034,000 FL The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 1,609,084,705 1,513,893,768 3,376,765,739 51,967,392 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 51,048,653 45,927,863 197,129,893 6,541,101 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 511,493,021 515,156,045 620,972,059 22,383,248 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 1,046,543,031 952,809,860 2,558,663,787 23,043,043 *LAE was used in lieu of cost containment

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners221

Page 230: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2006 Supplemental State Fund Data

State Name

Direct Premiums Written

Direct Premiums

Earned Direct Losses

Incurred

Direct Defense & Cost

Containment Exp. Incurred

MT The Montana State Compensation Ins. Fund 235,272,312 223,298,751 180,614,395 4,854,654 ND* Workforce Safety & Insurance 132,953,580 127,366,278 111,476,580 3,284,980 OH* Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation 2,165,098,000 2,165,098,000 1,609,421,000 324,392,000 OK CompSource Oklahoma 288,397,679 289,983,053 254,497,078 12,513,876 PA* Pennsylvania State Workers' Insurance Fund 374,051,379 385,948,354 449,028,262 57,684,703 SC South Carolina State Accident Fund 87,700,811 72,706,067 50,779,720 None reported WA Washington State Fund 1,338,983,000 1,338,983,000 1,413,139,000 None reported WY* The Wyoming Div. of Workers’ Safety & Comp. 226,521,964 226,521,964 171,557,000 6,759,000 LA* Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 187,669,137 153,026,394 299,507,420 -81,552,127 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 42,765,253 36,961,730 13,046,385 -66,570 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 40,798,805 30,597,555 91,958,887 -42,112,590 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 104,105,079 85,467,109 194,502,148 -39,372,967 FL The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 3,400,399,570 2,550,062,464 324,889,570 85,106,378 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 220,757,758 156,557,816 -94,840,764 -5,078,742 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 1,298,388,455 900,978,861 220,600,253 11,677,407 The Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 1,881,253,357 1,492,525,787 199,130,081 78,507,713 *LAE was used in lieu of cost containment; West Virginia began filing with the NAIC in 2006 as Brickstreet Mutual Ins.

2007 Supplemental State Fund Data

State Name

Direct Premiums Written

Direct Premiums

Earned Direct Losses

Incurred

Direct Defense & Cost

Containment Exp. Incurred

MT The Montana State Compensation Ins. Fund 257,218,119 250,707,178 187,821,156 8,197,319 ND* Workforce Safety & Insurance 147,135,979 128,119,000 100,499,068 3,547,772 OH* Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation 2,453,850,000 2,453,850,000 2,030,596,000 636,552,000 OK CompSource Oklahoma 269,284,362 268,338,382 241,055,116 12,298,571 PA* Pennsylvania State Workers’ Insurance Fund 371,238,818 384,197,761 487,632,243 78,346,209 SC South Carolina State Accident Fund 97,184,946 87,677,773 81,970,188 None reported WA Washington State Fund 1,294,870,000 1,294,870,000 1,770,168,000 51,448 WY* The Wyoming Div. of Workers’ Safety & Comp. 262,106,565 262,106,565 142,834,000 8,837,000 LA* Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 265,857,107 219,210,588 57,384,660 -22,011,496 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 43,528,057 43,815,624 20,491,327 251,011 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 91,361,586 62,688,691 4,553,862 -6,432,571 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 130,967,464 112,706,273 32,339,471 -15,829,936 *LAE was used in lieu of cost containment; West Virginia began filing with the NAIC in 2006 as Brickstreet Mutual Ins.; The Citizens Property Ins. Corporation of Florida began filing with the NAIC in 2007.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners222

Page 231: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

2008 Supplemental State Fund Data

State Name

Direct Premiums Written

Direct Premiums

Earned Direct Losses

Incurred

Direct Defense & Cost

Containment Exp. Incurred

MT The Montana State Compensation Ins. Fund 243,664,980 243,316,926 193,080,206 4,730,691 ND* Workforce Safety & Insurance 164,030,226 158,819,923 134,792,609 3,925,507 OH* Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation 2,235,092,000 2,235,092,000 2,180,823,000 406,660,000 OK CompSource Oklahoma 263,390,232 261,897,870 222,660,465 11,531,479 PA* Pennsylvania State Workers’ Insurance Fund 270,346,843 289,580,055 313,138,527 26,087,770 SC South Carolina State Accident Fund 95,385,632 101,658,115 80,460,433 None reported WA Washington State Fund 1,123,824,000 1,123,824,000 1,918,808,000 39,847,000 WY* The Wyoming Div. of Workers’ Safety & Comp. 265,398,271 265,398,271 135,295,405 6,683,000 LA* Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 279,969,503 282,311,752 264,552,582 -1,072,162 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 33,868,038 37,120,483 7,485,322 -95,315 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 107,552,437 104,837,054 142,889,278 -1,838,822 Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 138,549,028 140,354,215 114,177,982 861,975 *LAE was used in lieu of cost containment; The Citizens Property Ins. Corporation of Florida began filing with the NAIC in 2007.

2009 Supplemental State Fund Data

State Name Direct Premiums

Written

Direct Premiums

Earned Direct Losses

Incurred

Direct Defense & Cost

Containment Exp. Incurred

MT The Montana State Compensation Ins. Fund 206,218,075 214,966,226 177,543,578 5,195,927 ND* Workforce Safety & Insurance 185,752,645 177,412,233 146,686,639 3,305,031 OH* Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation 2,469,550,000 2,469,550,000 1,667,092,000 406,442,000

OK CompSource Oklahoma (2008 data used as the NAIC did not receive current data from the state fund)

263,390,232 261,897,870 222,660,445 11,531,479

PA* Pennsylvania State Workers' Insurance Fund (2008 data was used as the NAIC did not receive current data from the state fund)

270,346,843 289,580,055 313,138,527 26,087,770

SC South Carolina State Accident Fund 94,095,017 94,095,017 51,347,946 None reported WA* Washington State Fund 1,360,533,000 1,360,533,000 2,348,838,000 185,980,000

WY* The Wyoming Div. of Workers’ Safety & Comp. 240,363,197 240,363,197 274,696,000 5,329,359

LA* Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Total 222,251,490

247,515,562

58,885,270

10,323,323

Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Fire 32,719,873 32,772,127 9,274,469 287,516

Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-Allied 92,829,758 99,019,291 26,428,307 3,921,512

Louisiana Citizens Property Ins. Corp.-HO 96,701,859 115,724,144 58,885,270 6,114,295 *LAE was used in lieu of cost containment; the Citizens Property Ins. Corporation of Florida began filing with the NAIC in 2007.

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners223

Page 232: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners224

Page 233: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

GROUP INDEX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners225

Page 234: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners226

Page 235: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

Market Share

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

group index

1 Group Name:Group Code: AETNA GRP2009

36153 AETNA INS CO OF CT2008

36153 AETNA INS CO OF CT2007

36153 AETNA INS CO OF CT2006

36153 AETNA INS CO OF CT2005

36153 AETNA INS CO OF CT2000

36153 AETNA INSURANCE COMPANY OF CT1995

10520 WESTERN HORIZON INSURANCE COMPANY 19038 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO19046 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO OF IL 19054 AETNA LIFE & CAS CO19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO29696 AETNA EXCESS & SURPLUS LINE CO 31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC 36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO36145 AETNA PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO 36153 AETNA CASUALTY COMPANY36161 AETNA INSURANCE COMPANY 36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT38130 AETNA INS CO OF ILLINOIS 41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO41564 AETNA LLOYDS OF TEXAS INS CO 44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

199019054 AETNA LIFE & CAS CO 35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC36153 AETNA CASUALTY COMPANY

198519054 AETNA LIFE & CAS CO 35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC

2 Group Name:Group Code: AMWEST GRP2000

34983 AMWEST SURETY INS CO 42633 FAR WEST INS CO1995

34983 AMWEST SURETY INS CO 42633 FAR WEST INS CO1990

33669 CONDOR INS CO 34983 AMWEST SURETY INS CO42633 FAR WEST INS CO

198534983 AMWEST SURETY INS CO 42633 FAR WEST INS CO

3 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIED GRP1995

19097 ALLIED MUT INS CO 19100 AMCO INS CO37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO

199019097 ALLIED MUT INS CO 19100 AMCO INS CO37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO

198519097 ALLIED MUT INS CO 19100 AMCO INS CO37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO

4 Group Name:Group Code: AMERIPRISE FIN GRP2009

12504 AMERIPRISE INS CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners227

Page 236: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4 Group Name:Group Code: AMERIPRISE FIN GRP2008

12504 AMERIPRISE INS CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO2007

12504 AMERIPRISE INS CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO2006

12504 AMERIPRISE INS CO 27928 AMEX ASSUR CO29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

200527928 AMEX ASSUR CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

200027928 AMEX ASSUR CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

199527928 AMEX ASSUR CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

199027928 AMEX ASSUR CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

198527928 AMEX ASSUR CO 29068 IDS PROP CAS INS CO

5 Group Name:Group Code: ALFA INS GRP2009

11004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 12188 ALFA VISION INS CORP18791 ALFA ALLIANCE INS CORP 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GEN INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GEN INS CORP

200811004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 12188 ALFA VISION INS CORP18791 ALFA ALLIANCE INS CORP 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GEN INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GEN INS CORP

200711004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 12188 ALFA VISION INS CORP18791 ALFA ALLIANCE INS CORP 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GEN INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GEN INS CORP

200611004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 12188 ALFA VISION INS CORP18791 ALFA ALLIANCE INS CORP 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP

200511004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 12188 ALFA VISION INS CORP18791 VIRGINIA MUT INS CO 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP

200011004 ALFA SPECIALTY INS CORP 19135 ALFA MUT INS CO19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO 19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO22330 ALFA INS CORP 41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP

199519135 ALFA MUT INS CO 19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO 22330 ALFA INS CORP41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP

199019135 ALFA MUT INS CO 19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO 22330 ALFA INS CORP41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP

198519135 ALFA MUT INS CO 19143 ALFA MUT FIRE INS CO19151 ALFA MUT GENERAL INS CO 22330 ALFA INS CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners228

Page 237: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

5 Group Name:Group Code: ALFA INS GRP1985

41661 ALFA GENERAL INS CORP6 Group Name:Group Code: ABINGTON MUT GRP

199013277 ABINGTON MUT INS CO

198513277 ABINGTON MUT INS CO

7 Group Name:Group Code: FEDERATED MUT GRP2009

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERV INS CO2008

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERV INS CO2007

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERV INS CO2006

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO2005

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO2000

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO1995

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO1990

13935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 23124 FEDERATED LLOYDS OF TX28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO

198513935 FEDERATED MUT INS CO 23124 FEDERATED LLOYDS OF TX28304 FEDERATED SERVICE INS CO

8 Group Name:Group Code: ALLSTATE INS GRP2009

10071 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMER 10072 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS CO10358 ENCOMPASS INS CO 10835 CASTLE KEY IND CO10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO 11110 ALLSTATE N AMER INS CO11251 ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO 11252 ENCOMPASS HOME & AUTO INS CO11599 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ 11993 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN INS CO11996 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN IND CO 12154 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF MA12344 ALLSTATE NJ PROP & CAS INS CO 12496 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ13167 NORTH LIGHT SPECIALTY INS CO 15130 ENCOMPASS IND CO17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO 19232 ALLSTATE INS CO19240 ALLSTATE IND CO 26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS29335 ALLSTATE CNTY MUT INS CO 29688 ALLSTATE FIRE & CAS INS CO29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO 30511 CASTLE KEY INS CO36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO 37907 DEERBROOK INS CO

200810071 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMER 10072 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS CO10358 ENCOMPASS INS CO 10835 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN IND CORP10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO 11110 ALLSTATE N AMER INS CO11251 ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO 11252 ENCOMPASS HOME & AUTO INS CO11599 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ 11993 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN INS CO11996 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN IND CO 12154 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF MA12344 ALLSTATE NJ PROP & CAS INS CO 12496 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ13167 NORTH LIGHT SPECIALTY INS CO 15130 ENCOMPASS IND CO17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO 19232 ALLSTATE INS CO19240 ALLSTATE IND CO 26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS29335 ALLSTATE CNTY MUT INS CO 29688 ALLSTATE FIRE & CAS INS CO29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO 30511 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN INS CO36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO 37907 DEERBROOK INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners229

Page 238: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

8 Group Name:Group Code: ALLSTATE INS GRP2007

10071 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMER 10072 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS CO10358 ENCOMPASS INS CO 10835 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN IND CORP10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO 11110 ALLSTATE N AMER INS CO11251 ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO 11252 ENCOMPASS HOME & AUTO INS CO11599 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ 11993 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN INS CO11996 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN IND CO 12154 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF MA12344 ALLSTATE NJ PROP & CAS INS CO 12496 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ15130 ENCOMPASS IND CO 17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS 29335 ALLSTATE CNTY MUT INS CO29688 ALLSTATE FIRE & CAS INS CO 29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO30511 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN INS CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO37907 DEERBROOK INS CO

200610071 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMERICA 10072 ENCOMPASS PROPERTY & CAS CO10358 ENCOMPASS INS CO 10835 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN IND CORP10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO 11110 ALLSTATE NORTH AMERICAN INS CO11251 ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO 11252 ENCOMPASS HOME AND AUTO INS CO11599 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ 11993 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN INS CO11996 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN IND CO 12154 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF MA12344 ALLSTATE NJ PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO 12496 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ15130 ENCOMPASS IND CO 17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS 29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO29688 ALLSTATE FIRE AND CAS INS CO 29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO30511 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN INS CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO37907 DEERBROOK INS CO

200510071 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF AMERICA 10072 ENCOMPASS PROPERTY & CAS CO10358 ENCOMPASS INS CO 10835 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN IND CORP10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO 11110 ALLSTATE NORTH AMERICAN INS CO11251 ENCOMPASS INDEPENDENT INS CO 11252 ENCOMPASS HOME AND AUTO INS CO11599 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF NJ 11993 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN INS CO11996 ENCOMPASS FLORIDIAN IND CO 12154 ENCOMPASS INS CO OF MA12344 ALLSTATE NJ PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO 12496 ENCOMPASS PROP & CAS INS CO OF NJ15130 ENCOMPASS IND CO 17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS 29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO29688 ALLSTATE FIRE AND CAS INS CO 29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO30511 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN INS CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO37907 DEERBROOK INS CO

200010835 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN IND CORP 10852 ALLSTATE NJ INS CO15130 AMERICAN SURETY & CAS CO 17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS 29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO29688 FORESTVIEW MORTGAGE INSCO 29980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO30511 ALLSTATE FLORIDIAN INSURANCE CO 37907 DEERBROOK INSURANCE COMPANY

199510287 PMI REINSURANCE COMPANY 17230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO19224 NORTHBROOK PROP & CAS INS CO 19232 ALLSTATE INS CO19240 ALLSTATE IND CO 26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO 29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO29688 FORETVIEW MORTAGE INS CO 30511 FIRST ASSURANCE CO36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO 36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO37907 DEERBROOK INSURANCE COMPANY

199017230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO 19224 NORTHBROOK PROP & CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners230

Page 239: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

8 Group Name:Group Code: ALLSTATE INS GRP1990

19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO26530 ALLSTATE TX LLOYDS 27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO 29688 PMI INS CO30511 FIRST ASSURANCE CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 37907 BELVEDERE AMERICA REINSURANCE CO

198517230 ALLSTATE PROP & CAS INS CO 19224 NORTHBROOK PROP & CAS INS CO19232 ALLSTATE INS CO 19240 ALLSTATE IND CO27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO 29335 ALLSTATE COUNTY MUT INS CO29688 PMI INS CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 37907 BELVEDERE AMERICA REINSURANCE CO

9 Group Name:Group Code: JPMORGAN CHASE & CO GRP2009

11344 BANC ONE INS CO 12338 SEQUOIA IND CO12832 PERSONAL EXPRESS INS CO 22985 SEQUOIA INS CO

200811344 BANC ONE INS CO 12338 SEQUOIA INDEMNITY CO12832 PERSONAL EXPRESS INS CO 22985 SEQUOIA INS CO

200711344 BANC ONE INS CO 12338 SEQUOIA INDEMNITY CO12832 PERSONAL EXPRESS INS CO 22985 SEQUOIA INS CO

200611344 BANC ONE INS CO 12338 SEQUOIA INDEMNITY CO12832 PERSONAL EXPRESS INS CO 22985 SEQUOIA INS CO27103 GREAT LAKES INS CO

200511344 BANC ONE INS CO 12338 SEQUOIA INDEMNITY CO22985 SEQUOIA INS CO 27103 GREAT LAKES INS CO

11 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN GEN GRP2000

22616 INDEPENDENT FIRE INS CO FL 24376 AMERICAN GENERAL INDEMNITY CO26220 YOSEMITE INS CO 31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO

199526220 YOSEMITE INS CO 31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO

199011606 INTERSTATE FIRE INS CO 22608 INDEPENDENT FIRE INS CO22616 HERALD FIRE INS CO 25402 THOMAS JEFFERSON INSURANCE CO26220 YOSEMITE INS CO 31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO42781 INDEPENDENT PROP & CASUALTY INS CO

198511606 INTERSTATE FIRE INS CO 22608 INDEPENDENT FIRE INS CO22616 HERALD FIRE INS CO 25402 THOMAS JEFFERSON INSURANCE CO26220 YOSEMITE INS CO 31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO

12 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INTL GRP2009

10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO 10932 CHARTIS SELECT INS CO11583 AMERICAN LIFE INS CO 11685 UNITED GUAR MORTGAGE INS CO11715 UNITED GUAR INS CO 11740 UNITED GUAR MORTGAGE INS CO OF NC13694 FIRST MORTGAGE INS CO 15873 UNITED GUAR RESIDENTIAL INS CO16659 UNITED GUAR COMM INS CO OF NC 16667 UNITED GUAR RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO 19399 AIU INS CO19402 CHARTIS PROP CAS CO 19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA 19437 LEXINGTON INS CO19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS 19453 TRANSATLANTIC REINS CO19925 AUDUBON IND CO 19933 AUDUBON INS CO23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO 23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 24376 AMERICAN GEN IND CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners231

Page 240: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INTL GRP2009

26220 YOSEMITE INS CO 26883 CHARTIS SPECIALTY INS CO26999 UNITED GUAR MORTGAGE IND CO 31208 AMERICAN GEN PROP INS CO31674 CHARTIS INS CO PR 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA35157 PUTNAM REINS CO 35637 LANDMARK INS CO40258 CHARTIS CAS CO 40525 UNITED GUAR CREDIT INS CO

200810184 AIG AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO 10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC 10932 AIG EXCESS LIAB INS CO LTD11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 11583 AMERICAN LIFE INS CO11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 AIG CAS CO19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 20796 AIG PREMIER INS CO22225 AIG PREFERRED INS CO 22616 AMERICAN GENERAL PROP INS CO OF FL23795 AMERICAN INTL PACIFIC INS 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 24376 AMERICAN GEN IND CO25232 AIG ADVANTAGE INS CO 26220 YOSEMITE INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY MTG INDEM CO28487 AIG HI INS CO INC 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT31208 AMERICAN GEN PROP INS CO 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA34789 AIG CENTENNIAL INS CO 35157 PUTNAM REIN CO35637 LANDMARK INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO36587 AIG NATL INS CO INC 40258 AMERICAN INTL S INS CO40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 43761 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF CA43974 AIG IND INS CO 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

200710184 AIG AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO 10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC 10932 AIG EXCESS LIAB INS CO LTD11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 11583 AMERICAN LIFE INS CO11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 AIG CAS CO19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 20796 AIG PREMIER INS CO22225 AIG PREFERRED INS CO 22616 AMERICAN GENERAL PROP INS CO OF FL23795 AMERICAN INTL PACIFIC INS 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 24376 AMERICAN GEN IND CO25232 AIG ADVANTAGE INS CO 26220 YOSEMITE INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY MTG INDEM CO28487 AIG HI INS CO INC 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT31208 AMERICAN GEN PROP INS CO 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA34789 AIG CENTENNIAL INS CO 35157 PUTNAM REIN CO35637 LANDMARK INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO36587 AIG NATL INS CO INC 40258 AMERICAN INTL S INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners232

Page 241: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INTL GRP2007

40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 43761 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF CA43974 AIG IND INS CO 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

200610184 AIG AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO 10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC 10932 STARR EXCESS LIABILITY INS CO LTD11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 11583 AMERICAN LIFE INS CO11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 20796 AIG PREMIER INS CO22225 AIG PREFERRED INS CO 22616 AMERICAN GENERAL PROP INS CO OF FL23795 AMERICAN INTL PACIFIC INS 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 24376 AMERICAN GENERAL IND CO25232 AIG ADVANTAGE INS CO 26220 YOSEMITE INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY MTG INDEM CO28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA34789 AIG CENTENNIAL INS CO 35157 PUTNAM REIN CO35637 LANDMARK INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO36587 AIG NATL INS CO INC 40258 AMERICAN INTL SOUTH INS CO40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 43761 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF CA43974 AIG IND INS CO 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

200510184 AIG AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO 10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC 10932 STARR EXCESS LIABILITY INS CO LTD11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 11583 AMERICAN LIFE INS CO11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 20796 AIG PREMIER INS CO22225 AIG PREFERRED INS CO 22616 AMERICAN GENERAL PROP INS CO OF FL23795 AMERICAN INTL PACIFIC INS 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 24376 AMERICAN GENERAL IND CO25232 MINNESOTA INS CO 26220 YOSEMITE INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY MTG INDEM CO28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT31208 AMERICAN GENERAL PROPERTY INS CO 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA34789 AIG CENTENNIAL INS CO 35157 PUTNAM REIN CO35637 LANDMARK INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO36587 AIG NATL INS CO INC 40258 AMERICAN INTL SOUTH INS CO40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 43761 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF CA43974 AIG IND INS CO 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners233

Page 242: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INTL GRP2000

10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW 10651 AIG GLOBAL TRADE & POL RISK INS CO10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ 10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC10932 STARR EXCESS LIABILITY INS CO LTD 11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 23795 AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL PACIFIC IN CO23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO 23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC 23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO25232 MINNESOTA INS CO 26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO26999 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INDEM CO 28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT 30205 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO TX31500 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA35157 PUTNAM REIN CO 35637 LANDMARK INS CO36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO 36587 AIG NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY INC40258 AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL SOUTH INS CO 40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO43761 AMERICAN INTL INSURANCE CO OF CA INC 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

199510008 WESTERN INS CO 10048 HYUNDAI MARINE & FIRE INS CO LTD11685 UNITED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 11715 UNITED GUARANTY INS CO11740 UNITED GUARANTY MRTG INS CO OF NC 15873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC 16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO 19399 AIU INS CO19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA 19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA 19437 LEXINGTON INS CO19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS 19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO19461 AI LLOYDS INS CO 19925 AUDUBON IND CO19933 AUDUBON INS CO 21725 UNION & PHENIX ESPANOL INS CO US BR23795 AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL PACIFIC IN CO 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 25232 MINNESOTA INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY COMMERCIAL INS CO28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC 31500 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR 32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA 32301 NICHIDO FIRE & MARINE INS CO LTD35157 PUTNAM REIN CO 35637 LANDMARK INS CO36587 ABEILLE GENERAL INS INC 40258 AMERICAN INTERNATIONAL SOUTH INS CO40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 43761 AMERICAN INTL INSURANCE CO OF CA INC44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

199015873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19461 AI LLOYDS INS CO19925 AUDUBON IND CO 19933 AUDUBON INS CO21725 UNION & PHENIX ESPANOL INS CO US BR 23795 AMERICAN FIDELITY CO23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO 23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC 23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO25232 MINNESOTA INS CO 26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO26999 UNITED GUARANTY COMMERCIAL INS CO 28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC31500 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD 31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners234

Page 243: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INTL GRP1990

32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 32298 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF LA32301 NICHIDO FIRE & MARINE INS CO LTD 35157 PUTNAM REIN CO35637 LANDMARK INS CO 40258 AMERICAN GLOBAL INS CO40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO 41130 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD43761 FIRST ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW INS CO 44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

198515873 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO 16659 UNITED GTY COML INS CO OF NC16667 UNITED GTY RESIDENTIAL INS CO OF NC 19380 AMERICAN HOME ASSUR CO19399 AIU INS CO 19402 BIRMINGHAM FIRE INS CO OF PA19410 COMMERCE & INDUSTRY INS CO 19429 INSURANCE CO OF THE STATE OF PA19437 LEXINGTON INS CO 19445 NATIONAL UNION FIRE INS CO OF PITTS19453 TRANSATLANTIC REIN CO 19461 AI LLOYDS INS CO19925 AUDUBON IND CO 19933 AUDUBON INS CO21725 UNION & PHENIX ESPANOL INS CO US BR 22420 AIUO INS LTD (U S BRANCH23795 AMERICAN FIDELITY CO 23809 GRANITE STATE INS CO23817 ILLINOIS NATL INS CO 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC23841 NEW HAMPSHIRE INS CO 25232 MINNESOTA INS CO26883 AMERICAN INTL SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 26999 UNITED GUARANTY COMMERCIAL INS CO27715 LA MERIDIONAL CO ARGENTIN SEGUROS US 28487 AIG HAWAII INS CO INC30473 COMPANIA ANONIMA DE SEGUROS US BR 31500 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD31674 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF PR 32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO32301 NICHIDO FIRE & MARINE INS CO LTD 33464 AMER INTL UNDRWRTRS OVRSEAS LTD35157 PUTNAM REIN CO 35637 LANDMARK INS CO40258 AMERICAN GLOBAL INS CO 40525 UNITED GUARANTY CREDIT INS CO41130 CHINA AMER INS CO LTD

13 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN IND FINANCIAL1995

19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO 19518 AMERICAN IND CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

199019496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO 19518 AMERICAN IND CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

198519496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO 19518 AMERICAN IND CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

15 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MUT LIAB GRP1995

19550 AMERICAN MUT INS CO OF BOSTON 19569 AMERICAN MUT LIAB INS CO19577 AMERICAN POLICYHOLDERS INS CO

199019550 AMERICAN MUT INS CO OF BOSTON 19569 AMERICAN MUT LIAB INS CO19577 AMERICAN POLICYHOLDERS INS CO

198519550 AMERICAN MUT INS CO OF BOSTON 19569 AMERICAN MUT LIAB INS CO19577 AMERICAN POLICYHOLDERS INS CO

17 Group Name:Group Code: LIFE OF THE SOUTH CORP GRP2009

10051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 11162 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH2008

10051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 11162 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH35521 AMERICAN GUAR INS CO

200710051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 11162 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH35521 AMERICAN GUAR INS CO

200610051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 11162 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners235

Page 244: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

17 Group Name:Group Code: LIFE OF THE SOUTH CORP GRP2005

11162 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH1990

24970 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH1985

24970 INSURANCE CO OF THE SOUTH18 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN ROAD GRP

200919631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

200819631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

200719631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

200619631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

200519631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

200019631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO

199519631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO 19658 VISTA INS CO34959 PARKLANE INS CO

199019631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO 19658 VISTA INS CO28061 AMERICAN RENAISSANCE INS CO 34959 PARKLANE INS CO

198519631 AMERICAN ROAD INS CO 19658 VISTA INS CO28061 AMERICAN RENAISSANCE INS CO 34959 PARKLANE INS CO

19 Group Name:Group Code: ASSURANT INC GRP2009

10111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO28843 RELIABLE LLOYDS INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMER PROP INS CO40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO 42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO42986 STANDARD GUAR INS CO

200810111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO28843 RELIABLE LLOYDS INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMER PROP INS CO40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO 42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

200710111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO28843 RELIABLE LLOYDS INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMER PROP INS CO35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

200610111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO28843 RELIABLE LLOYDS INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMERICAN PROPERTY INS CO35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

200510111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 11971 WASHINGTON SECURITY INS CO18570 FINANCIAL INS EXCH 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO28843 RELIABLE LLOYDS INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMERICAN PROPERTY INS CO35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

200010111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 15008 MS CAS INS CO18570 FINANCIAL INS EXCH 19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners236

Page 245: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

19 Group Name:Group Code: ASSURANT INC GRP2000

30590 CARIBBEAN AMERICAN PROPERTY INS CO 35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO 42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

199510168 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 10169 SUPERIOR AMER INS CO12220 SUPERIOR INS CO 27626 FINANCIAL AMERICAN INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

199012220 SUPERIOR INS CO 27626 FINANCIAL AMERICAN INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

198512220 SUPERIOR INS CO 27626 FINANCIAL AMERICAN INS CO42978 AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 42986 STANDARD GUARANTY INS CO

20 Group Name:Group Code: LINCOLN NATL GRP2000

38822 LINSCO REINSURANCE CO 38830 LINCOLN NATL HLTH & CAS INS CO1995

19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 26093 LINCOLN NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL 31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO 38822 LINSCO REINSURANCE CO38830 LINCOLN NATL HLTH & CAS INS CO

199019690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO38822 LINCOLN NATIONAL REINSURANCE CO 38830 LINCOLN NATL HLTH & CAS INS CO

198519690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO38822 LINCOLN NATIONAL REINSURANCE CO 38830 LINCOLN NATL HLTH & CAS INS CO

21 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN UNIVESAL GRP1985

19747 AMERICAN UNIVERSAL INS CO 19755 CANADIAN UNIVERSAL INS CO LTD37826 CANADIAN UNIVERSAL INS CO INC

22 Group Name:Group Code: ANDOVER GRP2009

19763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

200819763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

200719763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

200619763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

200519763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

200019763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

199519763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners237

Page 246: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

22 Group Name:Group Code: ANDOVER GRP1995

19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO1990

19763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

198519763 BAY STATE INS CO 19771 CAMBRIDGE MUT FIRE INS CO19798 MERRIMACK MUT FIRE INS CO

23 Group Name:Group Code: BCS INS GRP2009

26794 PLANS LIAB INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO2008

26794 PLANS LIAB INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO2007

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO2006

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO2005

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO2000

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO1995

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO1990

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO1985

26794 PLANS LIABILITY INS CO 38245 BCS INS CO24 Group Name:Group Code: ATLANTIC CO GRP

200919895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO43141 ALICOT INS CO

200819895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO43141 ALICOT INS CO

200719895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO43141 ALICOT INS CO

200619895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO43141 ALICOT INS CO

200519895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO43141 ALICOT INS CO

200019895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO 43141 ATLANTIC LLOYDS INS CO OF TX

199519895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO 43141 ATLANTIC LLOYDS INS CO OF TX

199019895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO27154 ATLANTIC REINSURANCE CO 33952 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY LINES INS CO43141 ATLANTIC LLOYDS INS CO OF TX

198519895 ATLANTIC MUT INS CO 19909 CENTENNIAL INS CO27154 ATLANTIC REINSURANCE CO 33952 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY LINES INS CO43141 ATLANTIC LLOYDS INS CO OF TX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners238

Page 247: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

26 Group Name:Group Code: PRESERVER GRP2006

10205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 15586 PRESERVER INS CO23639 MCA INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO

200510205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 15586 PRESERVER INS CO23639 MCA INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO

200010205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 15586 PRESERVER INS CO23639 MCA INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO37451 MOTOR CLUB OF AMER INS CO 40665 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO

199515586 PRESERVER INS CO 23639 MCA INS CO26140 PROPERTY-CASUALTY CO OF MCA 37451 MOTOR CLUB OF AMER INS CO

199023639 MCA INS CO 26140 PROPERTY-CASUALTY CO OF MCA37451 MOTOR CLUB OF AMER INS CO

198523639 MCA INS CO 26140 PROPERTY-CASUALTY CO OF MCA

28 Group Name:Group Code: AMICA MUT GRP2009

10896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 12287 AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

200810896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 12287 AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

200710896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 12287 AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

200610896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 12287 AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

200510896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 12287 AMICA PROP & CAS INS CO19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

200010896 AMICA LLOYDS OF TX 19976 AMICA MUT INS CO

199519976 AMICA MUT INS CO

199019976 AMICA MUT INS CO

198519976 AMICA MUT INS CO

29 Group Name:Group Code: LE MARS MUT GRP1995

14389 LE MARS MUT INS CO OF IA1990

14389 LE MARS MUT INS CO OF IA 15229 SUNSHINE INS CO1985

14389 LE MARS MUT INS CO OF IA 15229 SUNSHINE INS CO30 Group Name:Group Code: BEACON INS GRP

200611284 BEACON LLOYDS INS CO 20028 BEACON NATL INS CO20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO 36935 PETROLIA INS CO

200511284 BEACON LLOYDS INS CO 20028 BEACON NATL INS CO20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO 36935 PETROLIA INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners239

Page 248: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

30 Group Name:Group Code: BEACON INS GRP2000

20028 BEACON NATL INS CO 20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO36935 PETROLIA INS CO

199520028 BEACON NATL INS CO 20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO36935 PETROLIA INS CO

199020028 BEACON NATL INS CO 20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO36935 PETROLIA INS CO

198520028 BEACON NATL INS CO 20036 FIRST PREFERRED INS CO36935 PETROLIA INS CO

31 Group Name:Group Code: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP2009

10391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 10685 CITADEL INS CO10855 CYPRESS INS CO 11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 12040 COMMERCIAL GEN IND INC12319 PHILADELPHIA REINS CORP 13070 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY ASSUR CORP15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 20931 ATLANTA INTL INS CO22039 GENERAL REINS CORP 22047 NORTH STAR REINS CORP22055 GEICO IND CO 22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO25895 UNITED STATES LIAB INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO27812 COLUMBIA INS CO 28258 CONTINENTAL IND CO32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INS CO34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 34991 GENESIS IND INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO 35882 GEICO GEN INS CO35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO 36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO 37923 SEAWORTHY INS CO38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 38962 GENESIS INS CO39136 FINIAL REINS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH 43460 FFG INS CO44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

200810391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 10855 CYPRESS INS CO11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO 11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO 11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO12040 COMMERCIAL GEN IND INC 12319 PHILADELPHIA REINS CORP13070 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY ASSUR CORP 15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO 20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO 20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID AMER20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 20087 NATIONAL IND CO22039 GENERAL REINS CORP 22047 NORTH STAR REINS CORP22055 GEICO IND CO 22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO25895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO27812 COLUMBIA INS CO 28258 CONTINENTAL IND CO32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INS CO34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 34991 GENESIS IND INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO 35882 GEICO GEN INS CO35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO 36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO 37923 SEAWORTHY INS CO38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 38962 GENESIS INS CO39136 FINIAL REINS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH 44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners240

Page 249: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

31 Group Name:Group Code: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP2007

10855 CYPRESS INS CO 11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 12040 COMMERCIAL GEN IND INC13070 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY ASSUR CORP 13071 BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY ASSUR CORP15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 22039 GENERAL REINS CORP22047 NORTH STAR REINS CORP 22055 GEICO IND CO22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO 22730 FINIAL INS CO25895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO27812 COLUMBIA INS CO 28258 CONTINENTAL IND CO33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER 34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA34630 OAK RIVER INS CO 34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP34991 GENESIS IND INS CO 35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO35882 GEICO GEN INS CO 35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER 37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO37923 SEAWORTHY INS CO 38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO38962 GENESIS INS CO 39136 FINIAL REINS CO41491 GEICO CAS CO 42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

200610855 CYPRESS INS CO 11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 12040 COMMERCIAL GENERAL IND INC15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 22039 GENERAL REIN CORP22047 NORTH STAR REIN CORP 22055 GEICO IND CO22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO 22730 CONVERIUM INS NORTH AMER INC25895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO27812 COLUMBIA INS CO 28258 CONTINENTAL IND CO33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER 34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA34630 OAK RIVER INS CO 34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP34991 GENESIS IND INS CO 35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO 35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER 37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO38318 REPUBLIC INS CO 38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO38962 GENESIS INS CO 39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC41491 GEICO CAS CO 42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

200510855 CYPRESS INS CO 11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO 11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO 20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO 20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 20087 NATIONAL IND CO22039 GENERAL REIN CORP 22047 NORTH STAR REIN CORP22055 GEICO IND CO 22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO25895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO27812 COLUMBIA INS CO 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INS CO34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 34991 GENESIS IND INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO 35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO 36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO 38318 REPUBLIC INS CO38962 GENESIS INS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners241

Page 250: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

31 Group Name:Group Code: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP2005

42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH 44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO2000

10855 CYPRESS INS CO 11014 BROOKWOOD INS CO11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO 11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 22039 GENERAL REIN CORP22047 NORTH STAR REINSURANCE CORPORATION 22055 GEICO IND CO22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO 25895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO 27812 COLUMBIA INS CO33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER 34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA34630 OAK RIVER INSURANCE COMPANY 34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP34991 GENESIS IND INS CO 35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO 35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO36048 UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER 37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO38318 REPUBLIC INS CO 38962 GENESIS INS CO41491 GEICO CAS CO 42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

199510855 CYPRESS INS CO 11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 27812 COLUMBIA INS CO34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INSURANCE COMPANY35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO 40045 STARNET INS CO42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH

199010855 CYPRESS INS CO 11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 22055 GEICO IND CO22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO 27812 COLUMBIA INS CO34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INSURANCE COMPANY35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO 35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO40045 STARNET INS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH

198510855 CYPRESS INS CO 11673 REDWOOD FIRE & CAS INS CO15962 KANSAS BANKERS SURETY CO 19500 WESCO-FINANCIAL INS CO20044 CORNHUSKER CAS CO 20052 NATIONAL LIAB & FIRE INS CO20060 NATIONAL IND CO OF MID-AMER 20079 NATIONAL FIRE & MARINE INS CO20087 NATIONAL IND CO 22055 GEICO IND CO22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO 27812 COLUMBIA INS CO34274 CENTRAL STATES IND CO OF OMAHA 34630 OAK RIVER INSURANCE COMPANY35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO 35939 CONTINENTAL DIVIDE INS CO40045 STARNET INS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO42137 NATIONAL IND CO OF THE SOUTH

33 Group Name:Group Code: CALIFORNIA CAS MGMT GRP2009

10063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO OF OR

200810063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners242

Page 251: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

33 Group Name:Group Code: CALIFORNIA CAS MGMT GRP2008

35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO OF OR2007

10063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO OF OR

200610063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO OF OR

200510063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO OF OR

200010063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO

199510063 CALIFORNIA CAS COMP INS CO 20117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO 27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO

199020117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH 20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO 35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO

198520117 CALIFORNIA CAS IND EXCH 20125 CALIFORNIA CAS INS CO27464 CALIFORNIA CAS & FIRE INS CO 35955 CALIFORNIA CAS GEN INS CO

34 Group Name:Group Code: PROVIDIAN GRP1995

20133 PROVIDIAN PROPERTY AND CASUALTY 26050 PROVIDIAN AUTO AND HOME INS CO36110 PROVIDIAN AUTO AND HOME INS CO 39896 PROVIDIAN FIRE ISN CO

199012424 PUBLIC SAVINGS FIRE & CAS INS CO 20133 CAPITAL ENTERPRISE INS CO26050 WORLDWIDE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE UNDERWRITERS INS CO OF NC39896 CAPITAL LANDMARK INS CO

198512424 PUBLIC SAVINGS FIRE & CAS INS CO 20133 CAPITAL ENTERPRISE INS CO26050 WORLDWIDE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE UNDERWRITERS INS CO OF NC39896 CAPITAL LANDMARK INS CO

35 Group Name:Group Code: CELINA GRP2009

15431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 16764 MIAMI MUT INS CO20176 CELINA MUT INS CO 20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO

200815431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 16764 MIAMI MUT INS CO20176 CELINA MUT INS CO 20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO

200715431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 16764 MIAMI MUT INS CO20176 CELINA MUT INS CO 20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO

200615431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 16764 MIAMI MUT INS CO20176 CELINA MUT INS CO 20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO

200515431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 20176 CELINA MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners243

Page 252: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

35 Group Name:Group Code: CELINA GRP2005

20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO 20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO2000

15431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 20176 CELINA MUT INS CO20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO 20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO38504 WEST VIRGINIA FIRE & CAS CO

199515431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 20176 CELINA MUT INS CO20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO 20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO38504 WEST VIRGINIA FIRE & CAS CO

199018481 FIRST NATIONAL IND CO 20176 CELINA MUT INS CO20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO 20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO38504 WEST VIRGINIA FIRE & CAS CO

198515431 WEST VIRGINIA FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC 16780 PATRONS MUT INS CO18481 FIRST NATIONAL IND CO 20176 CELINA MUT INS CO20184 NATIONAL MUT INS CO 20192 REPUBLIC MUT INS CO32123 BLACK HAWK MUT INS CO 38504 WEST VIRGINIA FIRE & CAS CO

36 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL MUT INS CO GRP2009

20222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

200820222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

200720222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

200620222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

200520222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

200020222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

199520222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

199020222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

198520222 ALL AMER INS CO 20230 CENTRAL MUT INS CO42382 CMI LLOYDS

38 Group Name:Group Code: CHUBB & SON INC GRP2009

10052 CHUBB NATL INS CO 12777 CHUBB IND INS CO20281 FEDERAL INS CO 20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO 20346 PACIFIC IND CO20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO 20397 VIGILANT INS CO27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX 35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO 41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

200810052 CHUBB NATL INS CO 12777 CHUBB IND INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners244

Page 253: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

38 Group Name:Group Code: CHUBB & SON INC GRP2008

20281 FEDERAL INS CO 20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO 20346 PACIFIC IND CO20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO 20397 VIGILANT INS CO27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX 35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO 41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

200710052 CHUBB NATL INS CO 12777 CHUBB IND INS CO20281 FEDERAL INS CO 20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO 20346 PACIFIC IND CO20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO 20397 VIGILANT INS CO27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX 35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO 41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

200610052 CHUBB NATL INS CO 10829 QUADRANT IND CO12777 CHUBB IND INS CO 20281 FEDERAL INS CO20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO 20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO20346 PACIFIC IND CO 20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO20397 VIGILANT INS CO 27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC 38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ 44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

200510052 CHUBB NATL INS CO 10829 QUADRANT IND CO12777 CHUBB IND INS CO 20281 FEDERAL INS CO20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO 20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO20346 PACIFIC IND CO 20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO20397 VIGILANT INS CO 27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC 38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ 44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

200010052 CHUBB NATIONAL INS CO 10829 QUADRANT IND CO12777 CHUBB INDEMNITY INS CO 20281 FEDERAL INS CO20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO 20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO20346 PACIFIC IND CO 20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO20397 VIGILANT INS CO 27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX35181 EXECUTIVE RISK IND INC 38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ 44792 EXECUTIVE RISK SPECIALITY INS CO

199510052 CHUBB NATIONAL INS CO 12777 CHUBB INDEMNITY INS CO20281 FEDERAL INS CO 20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO 20346 PACIFIC IND CO20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO 20397 VIGILANT INS CO27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX 38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ

199012777 SUN INS CO OF NY 20281 FEDERAL INS CO20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO 20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO20346 PACIFIC IND CO 20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO20397 VIGILANT INS CO 27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO 41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ

198512777 SUN INS CO OF NY 20281 FEDERAL INS CO20303 GREAT NORTHERN INS CO 20338 NORTHWESTERN PACIFIC IND CO20346 PACIFIC IND CO 20389 TEXAS PACIFIC IND CO20397 VIGILANT INS CO 27774 CHUBB LLOYDS INS CO OF TX38989 CHUBB CUSTOM INS CO 39632 VIK RE SYNDICATE INC41386 CHUBB INS CO OF NJ

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners245

Page 254: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

41 Group Name:Group Code: CITIGROUP GRP2009

10572 CITICORP INS USA INC 11315 CITIBANK MORTGAGE REINS INC11353 PRINCIPAL MORTGAGE REINS CO 41211 TRITON INS CO

200810572 CITICORP INS USA INC 11315 CITIBANK MORTGAGE REINS INC11353 PRINCIPAL MORTGAGE REINS CO 41211 TRITON INS CO

200710572 CITICORP INS USA INC 11315 CITIBANK MORTGAGE REINS INC11353 PRINCIPAL MORTGAGE REINS CO 41211 TRITON INS CO

200610572 CITICORP INS USA INC 11315 CITIBANK MORTGAGE REINS INC11353 PRINCIPAL MORTGAGE REINS CO 41211 TRITON INS CO

200510572 CITICORP INS USA INC 11315 CITIBANK MORTGAGE REINS INC11353 PRINCIPAL MORTGAGE REINS CO 27111 CITICORP INTL TRADE IND INC41211 TRITON INS CO 45039 CITICORP ASSUR CO

200010647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO 10785 RED OAK INS CO10796 GULF INS CO UK LTD 10826 TRAVCAL IND CO10827 TRAVCAL SECURE INS CO 12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA19038 TRAVELERS CASUALTY & SURETY CO 19046 TRAVELERS CASUALTY&SURETY CO OF IL19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO22209 ATLANTIC INS CO 22217 GULF INS CO22233 MARGARETS PREMIER INS CO 25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO25623 PHOENIX INS CO 25658 TRAVELERS IND CO25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER 25674 TRAVELERS IND CO OF IL25682 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF CT 27111 CITICORP INTL TRADE IND INC27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO 28188 TRAVCO INS CO29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO 29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER 36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO 36161 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CASUALTY INS CO36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT 37249 ASSOCIATES LLOYDS INS CO37494 GULF GROUP LLOYDS 38130 TRAVELERS PROP & CAS INS CO OF IL39357 TRAVELERS INS CO ACCIDENT DEPT 40282 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF MO41211 TRITON INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO 45039 CITICORP ASSUR CO

199512850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA 22209 ATLANTIC INS CO22217 GULF INS CO 22233 MARGARETS PREMIER INS CO25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO 25623 PHOENIX INS CO25658 TRAVELERS IND CO 25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER25674 TRAVELERS IND CO OF IL 25682 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF CT27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO 28188 TRAVCO INS CO29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO 37494 GULF GROUP LLOYDS39047 TRAVELERS INS GROUP INC 39357 TRAVELERS INS CO ACCIDENT DEPT40282 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF MO 41211 TRITON INS CO41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO 42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO

199019038 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO 19046 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO OF IL19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO22209 ATLANTIC INS CO 22217 GULF INS CO22233 SELECT INS CO 25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO25623 PHOENIX INS CO 25658 TRAVELERS IND CO25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER 25674 TRAVELERS IND CO OF IL25682 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF RI 29696 AETNA EXCESS & SURPLUS LINE CO31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER 36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO36145 AETNA PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO 36161 AETNA INSURANCE COMPANY36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT 37494 GULF GROUP LLOYDS

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners246

Page 255: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

41 Group Name:Group Code: CITIGROUP GRP1990

38130 AETNA INS CO OF ILLINOIS 39047 CONSTITUTION STATE INS CO39357 TRAVELERS INS CO ACCIDENT DEPT 40282 PENN CASUALTY INS CO41211 VOYAGER GUARANTY INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 AETNA LLOYDS OF TEXAS INS CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO

198518554 COMMERCIAL CREDIT UNDERWRITERS 19038 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO19046 AETNA CASUALTY & SURETY CO OF IL 19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO 22209 ATLANTIC INS CO22217 GULF INS CO 22233 SELECT INS CO25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO 25623 PHOENIX INS CO25658 TRAVELERS IND CO 25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER25674 TRAVELERS IND CO OF IL 25682 TRAVELERS INDEMNITY CO OF RI29696 AETNA EXCESS & SURPLUS LINE CO 31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER37494 GULF GROUP LLOYDS 39047 CONSTITUTION STATE INS CO39357 TRAVELERS INS CO ACCIDENT DEPT 40282 PENN CASUALTY INS CO41211 VOYAGER GUARANTY INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 AETNA LLOYDS OF TEXAS INS CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO

44 Group Name:Group Code: AVIVA GRP2000

10238 POTOMAC INS CO 15385 CGU INS CO OF IL16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 18643 HOUSTON GENERAL LLOYDS19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO 20613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO 20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO21741 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO21946 CGU INS CO OF NJ 21962 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO21970 CGU INS CO 23752 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION STD INS CO23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO 23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO 25712 TRI-STATE INS CO30210 GENERAL ACCIDENT REIN CO OF AMERICA 31267 COMMERICAL UNION YORK INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 GENERAL ASSUR CO34479 CGU INS CO OF NY 37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO 39489 CU LLOYDS OF TX40134 POTOMAC INS CO OF IL 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO41718 TRADERS & PACIFIC INS CO 42650 COMMERCIAL UNION MIDWEST INS CO

199520613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO 20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO 37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 39489 CU LLOYDS OF TX40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO 42650 COMMERCIAL UNION MIDWEST INS CO

199020613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO 20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO 37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 39489 CU LLOYDS OF TX40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO

198520613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO 20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO 29815 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO 38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER39489 CU LLOYDS OF TX 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO40339 CU SYNDICATE INC

45 Group Name:Group Code: CONCORD GRP2009

13110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GEN MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners247

Page 256: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

45 Group Name:Group Code: CONCORD GRP2008

13110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GEN MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

200713110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GEN MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

200613110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 15625 PEOPLES SERVICES INS CO16020 STATE MUT INS CO 20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC 28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

200513110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 15625 PEOPLES SERVICES INS CO16020 STATE MUT INS CO 20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC 28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

200013110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 15625 PEOPLES SERVICES INS CO16020 STATE MUT INS CO 20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC 28479 SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO

199513110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC

199013110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC

198513110 VERMONT ACCIDENT INS CO INC 16020 STATE MUT INS CO20672 CONCORD GENRL MUT INS CO 20680 GREEN MOUNTAIN INS CO INC

46 Group Name:Group Code: BUCKEYE INS GRP2009

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO2008

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO2007

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO2006

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO2005

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO2000

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO1995

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO1990

16713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO43150 PATRONS MUT INS ASSOC MUT INS CO

198516713 BUCKEYE STATE MUT INS CO 17639 HOME & FARM INS CO

48 Group Name:Group Code: CONTINENTAL CORP1985

39810 MAIDEN LANE SYNDICATE INC 40622 SOUTH PLACE SYNDICATE INC49 Group Name:Group Code: COTTON STATES GRP

200020966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO

199520966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners248

Page 257: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

49 Group Name:Group Code: COTTON STATES GRP1990

20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO1985

20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO50 Group Name:Group Code: COUNTRY INS & FIN SERV GRP

200914206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 23655 MODERN SERV INS CO42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

200814206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 23655 MODERN SERV INS CO42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

200714206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 23655 MODERN SERV INS CO42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

200614206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

200514206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20966 COTTON STATES MUT INS CO 20974 SHIELD INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 23647 MUTUAL SERVICE CAS INS CO23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO 42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

200014206 HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM 14532 MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO 42951 MSI PREFERRED INS CO

199520982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO

199018880 NORTHWEST FARM BUREAU INS CO 20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO 21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO

198512564 PINNACLE INS CO 18880 NORTHWEST FARM BUREAU INS CO20982 COUNTRY CAS INS CO 20990 COUNTRY MUT INS CO21008 COUNTRY PREF INS CO

51 Group Name:Group Code: COVENANT GRP1995

10062 COVENANT INS CO 10230 COMMONWEALTH REIN CO10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO

52 Group Name:Group Code: CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP1995

10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11690 CRUM & FORSTER UNDERWRITERS CO OH17400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 18970 INDUSTRIAL INS CO21032 CONSTITUTION REINSURANCE CORP 21040 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners249

Page 258: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

52 Group Name:Group Code: CRUM & FORSTER INS GRP1995

21059 EMPLOYERS FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY 21075 INDUSTRIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO21083 INTERNATIONAL INS CO 21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO 21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO21148 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO OF THE NW 21156 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF AK21318 COREGIS INSURANCE CO 31348 CRUM AND FORSTER INDEMNITY CO38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO43087 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF ID

199011690 CRUM & FORSTER UNDERWRITERS CO OH 17400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO17442 PREMIER INS CO 18970 INDUSTRIAL INS CO21040 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO 21059 ALL WEST INS CO21067 INDUSTRIAL INS CO OF HI LTD 21075 INDUSTRIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO21083 INTERNATIONAL INS CO 21091 INTERNATIONAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 21148 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO OF THE NW21156 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF AK 21318 MT AIRY INS CO28789 COMMONWEALTH LLOYDS INS CO 31348 FINMAR REINSURANCE CORP38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO43087 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF ID

198511690 CRUM & FORSTER UNDERWRITERS CO OH 17400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO17442 PREMIER INS CO 18970 INDUSTRIAL INS CO21040 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO 21059 ALL WEST INS CO21067 INDUSTRIAL INS CO OF HI LTD 21075 INDUSTRIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO21083 INTERNATIONAL INS CO 21091 INTERNATIONAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 21148 INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO OF THE NW21156 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF AK 21318 MT AIRY INS CO28789 COMMONWEALTH LLOYDS INS CO 31348 FINMAR REINSURANCE CORP38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 39721 WILLIAM STREET SYNDICATE INC42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO 43087 INDUSTRIAL IND CO OF ID

53 Group Name:Group Code: COBALT CORPORATION GRP2000

29157 UNITED WI INS CO1995

29157 UNITED WI INS CO1990

29157 UNITED WI INS CO1985

29157 UNITED WI INS CO54 Group Name:Group Code: CUMBERLAND GRP

200910448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

200810448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

200710448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

200610448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

200510448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

200010448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

199510448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

199010448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners250

Page 259: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

54 Group Name:Group Code: CUMBERLAND GRP1985

10448 CUMBERLAND INS CO INC 13684 CUMBERLAND MUT FIRE INS CO55 Group Name:Group Code: AUTOMOBILE CLUB MI GRP

200911983 AUTO CLUB PROP CAS INS CO 16101 MEEMIC INS CO21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC 21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

200811983 AUTO CLUB PROP CAS INS CO 21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO 21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

200711983 AUTO CLUB PROP CAS INS CO 21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO 21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

200611983 AUTO CLUB PROP & CAS INS CO 21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO 21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

200511983 MOTOR CLUB OF IA INS CO 21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO 21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

200015601 CHICAGO MOTOR CLUB INS CO 21202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO 21229 MEMBERSELECT INS CO

199521202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC 21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO21229 CASTLE INS CO

199021202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC 21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO21229 CASTLE INS CO

198521202 AUTO CLUB INS ASSOC 21210 AUTO CLUB GRP INS CO21229 CASTLE INS CO

56 Group Name:Group Code: CASUALTY RECIP EXCH GRP2000

21237 CASUALTY RECIPROCAL EXCH 21245 EQUITY MUT INS CO1995

21237 CASUALTY RECIPROCAL EXCH 21245 EQUITY MUT INS CO21253 RECIPROCAL EXCHANGE

199021237 CASUALTY RECIPROCAL EXCH 21245 EQUITY MUT INS CO21253 RECIPROCAL EXCHANGE

198521237 CASUALTY RECIPROCAL EXCH 21245 EQUITY MUT INS CO21253 RECIPROCAL EXCHANGE

57 Group Name:Group Code: ELECTRIC INS GRP2008

10961 ELECTRIC LLOYDS OF TX 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO2007

10961 ELECTRIC LLOYDS OF TX 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO2006

10961 ELECTRIC LLOYDS OF TX 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO2005

10961 ELECTRIC LLOYDS OF TX 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO2000

10961 ELECTRIC LLOYDS OF TX 21261 ELECTRIC INS CO1995

21261 ELECTRIC INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners251

Page 260: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

57 Group Name:Group Code: ELECTRIC INS GRP1990

21261 ELECTRIC INS CO1985

21261 ELECTRIC INS CO61 Group Name:Group Code: EMPLOYERS CAS CORP GRP

199510600 EMPLOYERS OF TX LLOYDS 21369 EMPLOYERS CAS CO21377 EMPLOYERS CAS CORP 21385 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CO21393 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CORP 38717 EMPLOYERS IND CO

199010600 EMPLOYERS OF TX LLOYDS 21369 EMPLOYERS CAS CO21377 EMPLOYERS CAS CORP 21385 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CO21393 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CORP 38717 EMPLOYERS IND CO41670 PERFORMANCE INS CO

198510600 EMPLOYERS OF TX LLOYDS 21369 EMPLOYERS CAS CO21377 EMPLOYERS CAS CORP 21385 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CO21393 EMPLOYERS NATL INS CORP 38717 EMPLOYERS IND CO

62 Group Name:Group Code: EMC INS CO GRP2009

10863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 EMC PROP & CAS INS CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REINS CO

200810863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 EMC PROP & CAS INS CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REINS CO

200710863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 EMC PROP & CAS INS CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REINS CO

200610863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO 21407 EMCASCO INS CO21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO 21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE25186 EMC PROP & CAS INS CO 32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO40509 EMC REIN CO

200510863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO 21407 EMCASCO INS CO21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO 21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE25186 EMC PROP & CAS INS CO 32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO40509 EMC REIN CO

200010863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO14125 HAMILTON MUT INS CO OF CINCINNATI 21407 EMCASCO INS CO21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO 21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE25186 EMC PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO40509 EMC REIN CO

199510863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 AMERICAN LIBERTY INSURANCE CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REIN CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners252

Page 261: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

62 Group Name:Group Code: EMC INS CO GRP1990

10863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 AMERICAN LIBERTY INSURANCE CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REIN CO

198510863 DAKOTA FIRE INS CO 11053 FARM & CITY INS CO21407 EMCASCO INS CO 21415 EMPLOYERS MUT CAS CO21423 UNION INS CO OF PROVIDENCE 25186 AMERICAN LIBERTY INSURANCE CO32808 ILLINOIS EMCASCO INS CO 40509 EMC REIN CO

65 Group Name:Group Code: FM GLOBAL GRP2009

10014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

200810014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

200710014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

200610014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

200510014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

200010014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO 31887 ARKWRIGHT INS CO

199510014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO

199010014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO 32310 RHODE ISLAND MUT FIRE INS CO

198510014 AFFILIATED FM INS CO 10316 APPALACHIAN INS CO21482 FACTORY MUT INS CO 42315 FACTORY MUT INS CO

66 Group Name:Group Code: KANSAS FARM BU GRP2000

21520 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO INC 21539 KFB INS CO INC1995

21520 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO INC 21539 KFB INS CO INC1990

21520 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO INC 21539 KFB INS CO INC1985

21520 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO INC 21539 KFB INS CO INC67 Group Name:Group Code: MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP

200921547 FARM BUREAU GEN INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI

200821547 FARM BUREAU GEN INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI

200721547 FARM BUREAU GEN INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI

200621547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners253

Page 262: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

67 Group Name:Group Code: MICHIGAN FARM BUREAU GRP2005

21547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI2000

21547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI1995

21547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI1990

21547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI1985

21547 FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO OF MI 21555 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF MI69 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS INS GRP

199510315 CIVIC PROPERTY & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID 21628 FARMERS INS CO INC21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR 21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA21652 FARMERS INS EXCH 21660 FIRE INS EXCH21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO 21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO 21709 TRUCK INS EXCH24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO 28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC

199021598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ 21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID21628 FARMERS INS CO INC 21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA 21652 FARMERS INS EXCH21660 FIRE INS EXCH 21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO 21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO21709 TRUCK INS EXCH 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC

198521598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ 21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID21628 FARMERS INS CO INC 21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA 21652 FARMERS INS EXCH21660 FIRE INS EXCH 21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO 21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO21709 TRUCK INS EXCH 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC

70 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST AMER TITLE GRP2009

11099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 34525 FIRST AMER SPECILATY INS CO37710 FIRST AMER PROP & CAS INS CO 42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200811099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 34525 FIRST AMER SPECILATY INS CO37710 FIRST AMER PROP & CAS INS CO 42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200711099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 34525 FIRST AMER SPECILATY INS CO37710 FIRST AMER PROP & CAS INS CO 42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200611099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 34525 FIRST AMERICAN SPECILATY INS CO37710 FIRST AMERICAN PROP & CAS INS CO 42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200511099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 34525 FIRST AMERICAN SPECILATY INS CO37710 FIRST AMERICAN PROP & CAS INS CO 42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200011099 FIRST AMERICAN HOME BUYERS PRO CORP 37710 FIRST AMERICAN PROP & CAS INS CO42773 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners254

Page 263: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

71 Group Name:Group Code: UNIVERSAL INS CO GRP2009

10363 RICHPORT INS CO 10759 UNIVERSAL N AMER INS CO11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMER INS CO11986 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF NA 12573 ICAT SPECIALTY INS CO31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200810363 RICHPORT INS CO 10759 UNIVERSAL N AMER INS CO11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMER INS CO11986 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF NA 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200710363 RICHPORT INS CO 10759 UNIVERSAL N AMER INS CO11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMER INS CO11986 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF NA 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200610363 RICHPORT INS CO 10759 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF TX11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMER INS CO11986 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF NA 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200510363 RICHPORT INS CO 10759 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF TX11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMER INS CO11986 UNIVERSAL INS CO OF NA 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200010363 RICHPORT INS CO 11827 EASTERN AMERICA INSURANCE COMPANY31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

199511827 EASTERN AMERICA INSURANCE COMPANY 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

199011827 RICHPORT INS CO 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

198511827 RICHPORT INS CO 31704 UNIVERSAL INS CO

74 Group Name:Group Code: DELPHI FIN GRP2009

11123 SAFETY FIRST INS CO 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP2008

11123 SAFETY FIRST INS CO 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP2007

11123 SAFETY FIRST INS CO 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP2006

11123 SAFETY FIRST INS CO 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP2005

11123 SAFETY FIRST INS CO 15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP2000

15105 SAFETY NATL CAS CORP75 Group Name:Group Code: INSCO INS SERVICES GRP

200912718 DEVELOPERS SURETY & IND CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA

200812718 DEVELOPERS SURETY & IND CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA

200712718 DEVELOPERS SURETY & IND CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA

200612718 DEVELOPERS SURETY AND IND CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA

200512718 DEVELOPERS SURETY AND IND CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA

200012718 DEVELOPERS SURETY AND INDEMNITY CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA38334 DEVELOPERS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners255

Page 264: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

75 Group Name:Group Code: INSCO INS SERVICES GRP1995

12718 DEVELOPERS SURETY AND INDEMNITY CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA38334 DEVELOPERS INS CO

199012718 STATE SURETY CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA38334 DEVELOPERS INS CO

198512718 STATE SURETY CO 25550 INDEMNITY CO OF CA38334 DEVELOPERS INS CO

77 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL ACCIDENT INS1995

15385 WESTERN STATES INSURANCE CO 19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO21741 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSN 21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO21970 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF AMERICA 23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO 25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO25712 TRI-STATE INS CO 30210 PACIFIC SECURITY INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 GENERAL ASSUR CO34479 PG INS CO OF NY 38229 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF PR LTD40134 POTOMAC INS CO OF IL

199015385 WESTERN STATES INSURANCE CO 19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO21741 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSN 21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO21970 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF AMERICA 23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO 25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO25712 TRI-STATE INS CO 30210 PACIFIC SECURITY INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 GENERAL ASSUR CO34479 PG INS CO OF NY 38229 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF PR LTD40134 POTOMAC INS CO OF IL

198515385 WESTERN STATES INSURANCE CO 19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO21741 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSN 21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO21970 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF AMERICA 23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO 25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO25712 TRI-STATE INS CO 30210 PACIFIC SECURITY INS CO38229 GENERAL ACCIDENT INS CO OF PR LTD 40134 POTOMAC INS CO OF IL

78 Group Name:Group Code: GREYHOUND CORP GRP1990

17809 VEREX CREDIT INS INC 26751 PINE TOP INS CO41165 PINE TOP SYNDICATE INC

198510090 VEREX REINS INC 17809 VEREX CREDIT INS INC26751 PINE TOP INS CO 41165 PINE TOP SYNDICATE INC

79 Group Name:Group Code: GMAC INS HOLDING GRP2009

11044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO22004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP22772 INTEGON IND CORP 22780 INTEGON GEN INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GEN INS CO 27930 INTEGON CAS INS CO29742 INTEGON NATL INS CO 31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP 38660 MIC GEN INS CORP42447 NATIONAL GEN ASSUR CO

200811044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO16101 MEEMIC INS CO 22004 CIM INS CORP22012 MOTORS INS CORP 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GEN INS CORP 23728 NATIONAL GEN INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners256

Page 265: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

79 Group Name:Group Code: GMAC INS HOLDING GRP2008

27930 INTEGON CAS INS CO 29742 INTEGON NATL INS CO31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO 37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP 38660 MIC GEN INS CORP42447 NATIONAL GEN ASSUR CO

200711044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 11054 GMAC DIRECT INS CO12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 16101 MEEMIC INS CO22004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP22772 INTEGON IND CORP 22780 INTEGON GEN INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GEN INS CO 27930 INTEGON CAS INS CO29742 INTEGON NATL INS CO 31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS 38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP38660 MIC GEN INS CORP 42447 NATIONAL GEN ASSUR CO

200611044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 11054 GMAC DIRECT INS CO12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 16101 MEEMIC INS CO22004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP22772 INTEGON IND CORP 22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO 27930 INTEGON CAS INS CO29742 INTEGON NATL INS CO 30945 NATIONAL ALLIANCE INS CO31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO 37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP 38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

200511044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 11054 GMAC DIRECT INS CO12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 22004 CIM INS CORP22012 MOTORS INS CORP 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP 23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO27930 INTEGON CAS INS CO 29742 INTEGON NATL INS CO30945 NATIONAL ALLIANCE INS CO 31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INS CO37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS 38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP 42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

200011044 GMAC INS CO ONLINE INC 11054 GMAC DIRECT INS CO12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 22004 CIM INS CORP22012 MOTORS INS CORP 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP 23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO27930 INTEGON CASUALTY INSURANCE CO 29742 INTEGON NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INSURANCE CO 37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP 38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

199522004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO 38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP 42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

199022004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO 38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP 42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

198522004 CIM INS CORP 22012 MOTORS INS CORP23728 NATIONAL GENERAL INS CO 38601 MIC PROP & CAS INS CORP38660 MIC GENERAL INS CORP 42447 NATIONAL GENERAL ASSUR CO

80 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL REIN CP1995

11967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 22039 GENERAL REIN CORP22047 NORTH STAR REINSURANCE CORPORATION 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 34991 GENESIS IND INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners257

Page 266: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

80 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL REIN CP1995

37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO 38962 GENESIS INS CO44784 FAIRFIELD INS CO

199011967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 22039 GENERAL REIN CORP22047 SIGNET STAR REINSURANCE COMPANY 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 34991 GENESIS IND INS CO37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO 38962 GENESIS INS CO

198511967 GENERAL STAR NATL INS CO 22039 GENERAL REIN CORP22047 SIGNET STAR REINSURANCE COMPANY 33197 COLOGNE REINS CO OF AMER34835 NATIONAL REINS CORP 37362 GENERAL STAR IND CO38962 GENESIS INS CO

81 Group Name:Group Code: GOVERNMENT EMPLYS1995

22055 GEICO IND CO 22063 GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INS CO35882 GEICO GENERAL INS CO 41491 GEICO CAS CO

82 Group Name:Group Code: GRAIN DEALERS GRP1995

22071 COMPANION INS CO 22098 GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO1990

22071 COMPANION INS CO 22098 GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO1985

22071 COMPANION INS CO 22098 GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO83 Group Name:Group Code: GRANGE INS GRP

200922101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

200822101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

200722101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

200622101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

200522101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

200022101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

199522101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

199022101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

198522101 GRANGE INS ASSN 22128 ROCKY MOUNTAIN FIRE & CAS CO

84 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP2009

10646 GREAT AMER CONTEMPORARY INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC15380 MID CONTINENT ASSUR CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMER INS CO 22136 GREAT AMER INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 23418 MID CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 26344 GREAT AMER ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMER ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMER SECURITY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33723 GREAT AMER SPIRIT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO37532 GREAT AMER E&S INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMER LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMER PROTECTION INS CO39896 GREAT AMER CAS INS CO 41106 TRIUMPHE CAS CO41858 GREAT AMER FIDELITY INS CO 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners258

Page 267: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

84 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP2008

10646 GREAT AMER CONTEMPORARY INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC15380 MID CONTINENT ASSUR CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMER INS CO 22136 GREAT AMER INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 23418 MID CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 26344 GREAT AMER ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMER ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMER SECURITY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33723 GREAT AMER SPIRIT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO37532 GREAT AMER E&S INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMER LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMER PROTECTION INS CO39896 GREAT AMER CAS INS CO 41106 TRIUMPHE CAS CO41858 GREAT AMER FIDELITY INS CO 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

200710646 GREAT AMER CONTEMPORARY INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC15380 MID CONTINENT INS CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMER INS CO 22136 GREAT AMER INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 23418 MID CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 26344 GREAT AMER ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMER ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMER SECURITY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33723 GREAT AMER SPIRIT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO37532 GREAT AMER E&S INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMER LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMER PROTECTION INS CO39896 WORLDWIDE CAS INS CO 41106 TRIUMPHE CAS CO41858 GREAT AMER FIDELITY INS CO 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

200610646 GREAT AMERICAN CONTEMPORARY INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC15380 MID-CONTINENT INS CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO 22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 26344 GREAT AMERICAN ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33723 GREAT AMERICAN SPIRIT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO37532 GREAT AMERICAN E&S INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO39896 WORLDWIDE CAS INS CO 41106 TRIUMPHE CAS CO41858 GREAT AMERICAN FIDELITY INS CO 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

200510646 GREAT AMERICAN CONTEMPORARY INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC15380 MID-CONTINENT INS CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO 22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 26344 GREAT AMERICAN ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33723 GREAT AMERICAN SPIRIT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO 36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO37532 GREAT AMERICAN E&S INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO39896 WORLDWIDE CAS INS CO 41858 GREAT AMERICAN FIDELITY INS CO43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

200010061 LEADER SPECIALTY INS CO 10068 INFINITY NATL INS CO10195 LEADER PREFERRED INS CO 10646 GREAT AMERICAN CONTEMPORARY INS CO10968 ATLANTA RESERVE INS CO 11051 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO OF HI INC11738 LEADER INS CO 12203 FIDELITY EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO12599 WINDSOR INS CO 13820 GREAT TEXAS COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO15380 MID-CONTINENT INS CO 15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners259

Page 268: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

84 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP2000

16802 AMERICAN DEP INS CO 20133 WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INS CO20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO 21792 ATLANTA CAS CO22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY 22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER22268 INFINITY INS CO 23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 24899 ALEA NORTH AMERICA INS CO26050 WORLDWIDE INSURANCE COMPANY 26344 GREAT AMERICAN ASSUR CO26832 GREAT AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO31925 ATLANTA SPECIALTY INS CO 32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO33014 TRANSPORT INS CO 33723 GREAT AMERICAN SPIRIT INS CO35211 COVENTRY INS CO 35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO36110 WORLDWIDE INS CO 37001 AMERICAN PREMIER INS CO37532 GREAT AMERICAN E&S ISURANCES CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO38873 REGAL INS CO 39497 TICO INS CO39896 PROVIDIAN FIRE ISN CO 41858 AMERICAN DYNASTY SURPLUS LINES INS43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

199510061 LEADER SPECIALTY INS CO 10068 INFINITY SOUTHERN INS CORP10195 LEADER PREFERRED INS CO 11738 LEADER INS CO12203 FIDELITY EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO 12599 WINDSOR INS CO13820 GREAT TEXAS COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO 15380 MID-CONTINENT INS CO15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO 16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO16802 AMERICAN DEP INS CO 20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO21792 ATLANTA CAS CO 22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER 22268 INFINITY INS CO22276 STONEWALL INS CO 23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO 24899 ALEA NORTH AMERICA INS CO26344 AGRICULTURAL INS CO 26832 AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO 31925 ATLANTA SPECIALTY INS CO32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO 33014 TRANSPORT INS CO33723 GREAT AMERICAN SPIRIT INS CO 35211 COVENTRY INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO 37001 AMERICAN PREMIER INS CO37532 AGRICULTURAL EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO38873 REGAL INS CO 39497 TICO INS CO41858 AMERICAN DYNASTY SURPLUS LINES INS 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

199011738 LEADER INS CO 12203 FIDELITY ENVIRONMENTAL INS CO12599 WINDSOR INS CO 13820 AMERICAN SPIRIT COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO 16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO16802 AMERICAN DEP INS CO 21792 ATLANTA CAS CO22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY 22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER22268 INFINITY INS CO 22276 STONEWALL INS CO23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO 23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO24899 ALEA NORTH AMERICA INS CO 26344 AGRICULTURAL INS CO26832 AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO31925 PRINCIPAL CASUALTY INS CO 32620 NATIONAL INTERSTATE INS CO33014 TRANSPORT INS CO 33723 GREAT AMERICAN SPIRIT INS CO34967 PENN CENTRAL REINS CO 35211 COVENTRY INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO 37001 AMERICAN PREMIER INS CO37532 AGRICULTURAL EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO 37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38580 GREAT AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO38873 REGAL INS CO 39497 TICO INS CO41858 STONEWALL SURPLUS LINES INS CO 43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

198511738 LEADER INS CO 12203 FIDELITY ENVIRONMENTAL INS CO12599 WINDSOR INS CO 13820 AMERICAN SPIRIT COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO15920 AMERICAN EAGLE INS CO 16691 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO16802 AMERICAN DEP INS CO 21792 ATLANTA CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners260

Page 269: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

84 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FINANCIAL GRP1985

22136 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF NY 22179 REPUBLIC IND CO OF AMER22268 INFINITY INS CO 22276 STONEWALL INS CO23418 MID-CONTINENT CAS CO 23426 OKLAHOMA SURETY CO24899 ALEA NORTH AMERICA INS CO 26344 AGRICULTURAL INS CO26832 AMERICAN ALLIANCE INS CO 31135 GREAT AMERICAN SECURITY INS CO31925 PRINCIPAL CASUALTY INS CO 33014 TRANSPORT INS CO35351 AMERICAN EMPIRE SURPLUS LNS INS CO 37532 AGRICULTURAL EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO37990 AMERICAN EMPIRE INS CO 38016 GREAT AMERICAN INS CO OF AK38024 GREAT AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 38873 REGAL INS CO39497 TICO INS CO 41858 STONEWALL SURPLUS LINES INS CO43753 REPUBLIC IND CO OF CA

88 Group Name:Group Code: THE HANOVER INS GRP2009

10176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FIN ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL10815 VERLAN FIRE INS CO MD 11705 HANOVER NJ INS CO12833 AIX SPECIALTY INS CO 13147 HANOVER NATL INS CO22292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO25585 PROFESSIONALS DIRECT INS CO 31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO 41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO41840 ALLMERICA FIN BENEFIT INS CO 42552 NOVA CAS CO

200810176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FIN ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL10815 VERLAN FIRE INS CO MD 11705 HANOVER NJ INS CO12833 AIX SPECIALTY INS CO 13147 HANOVER NATL INS CO22292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO25585 PROFESSIONALS DIRECT INS CO 31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO 41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO41840 ALLMERICA FIN BENEFIT INS CO 42552 NOVA CAS CO

200710176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FIN ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL11705 HANOVER NJ INS CO 22292 HANOVER INS CO22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO 25585 PROFESSIONALS DIRECT INS CO31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER 36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO 41840 ALLMERICA FIN BENEFIT INS CO

200610176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FNCL ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL11705 HANOVER NJ INS CO 22292 HANOVER INS CO22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO 31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO 41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO41840 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL BENEFIT INS CO

200510176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FNCL ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL11705 HANOVER NJ INS CO 22292 HANOVER INS CO22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO 31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO 41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO41840 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL BENEFIT INS CO

200010176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO10395 CITIZENS INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 10714 CITIZENS INS CO OF IL22292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER 36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO 41840 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL BENEFIT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners261

Page 270: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

88 Group Name:Group Code: THE HANOVER INS GRP1995

10176 CITIZENS INS CO OF OH 10212 HANOVER NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY22292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER 36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO

199022292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER 36064 HANOVER AMER INS CO41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO 41840 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL BENEFIT INS CO

198522292 HANOVER INS CO 22306 MASSACHUSETTS BAY INS CO31534 CITIZENS INS CO OF AMER 41602 HANOVER LLOYDS INS CO

91 Group Name:Group Code: HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP2009

10046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCIDENT & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO 38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL 39608 NUTMEG INS CO41629 NEW ENGLAND REINS CORP

200810046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCIDENT & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO 38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL 39608 NUTMEG INS CO41629 NEW ENGLAND REINS CORP

200710046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCIDENT & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO 38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL 39608 NUTMEG INS CO41629 NEW ENGLAND REINS CORP

200610046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO 38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL 39608 NUTMEG INS CO41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP

200510046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners262

Page 271: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

91 Group Name:Group Code: HARTFORD FIRE & CAS GRP2005

34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 34940 OMNI IND CO37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST 38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL39098 OMNI INS CO 39608 NUTMEG INS CO41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP

200010046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 11000 SENTINEL INS CO LTD19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD 37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO 38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL 39098 OMNI INS CO39608 NUTMEG INS CO 41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP

199510046 PACIFIC INS CO LTD 19682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO21822 FIRST STATE INS CO 22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO22403 SENTINEL INS CO LTD 27120 TRUMBULL INS CO29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO 29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO 34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST 38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL39608 NUTMEG INS CO

199019682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO 22381 PACIFIC INS CO LTD22403 SENTINEL INS CO LTD 27120 TRUMBULL INS CO29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO 29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO 34690 PROPERTY & CAS INS CO OF HARTFORD37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST 38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL39365 LYNDON INS CO P & L 39608 NUTMEG INS CO

198519682 HARTFORD FIRE IN CO 21822 FIRST STATE INS CO22357 HARTFORD ACCID & IND CO 22365 HARTFORD CAS INS CO22373 NEW YORK UNDERWRITERS INS CO 22381 PACIFIC INS CO LTD22403 SENTINEL INS CO LTD 22411 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO27120 TRUMBULL INS CO 29424 HARTFORD CAS INS CO29459 TWIN CITY FIRE INS CO CO 30104 HARTFORD UNDERWRITERS INS CO37478 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 38253 HARTFORD LLOYDS INS CO38261 HARTFORD INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST 38288 HARTFORD INS CO OF IL38296 HARTFORD INS CO OF AL 39365 LYNDON INS CO P & L39608 NUTMEG INS CO 41696 FIRST STATE SYNDICATE INC

92 Group Name:Group Code: HAWAIIAN INS GRP1990

22446 UNITED NATL INS CO LTD 41890 HAWAIIAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO LTD1985

22446 UNITED NATL INS CO LTD 41890 HAWAIIAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO LTD93 Group Name:Group Code: STATE NATL GRP

200912537 UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO 12831 STATE NATL INS CO INC22608 NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO

200812537 UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO 12831 STATE NATL INS CO INC22608 NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 29408 STATE & COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO

200712537 UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO 12831 STATE NATL INS CO INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners263

Page 272: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

93 Group Name:Group Code: STATE NATL GRP2007

22608 NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 29408 STATE & COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2006

12537 UNITED SPECIALTY INS CO 12831 STATE NATL INS CO INC22608 NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 29408 STATE & COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO

200512831 STATE NATL INS CO INC 22608 NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO29408 STATE & COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO

200012831 STATE NATL INS CO INC 22608 STATE NATL SPECIALTY INS CO29408 STATE & COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO

199512831 STATE NATL INS CO INC 24470 VALOR INS CO INC29408 STATE & COUNTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

199012831 STATE NATL INS CO INC 29408 STATE & COUNTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

198512831 STATE NATL INS CO INC 29408 STATE & COUNTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

95 Group Name:Group Code: HOME INS GRP NY1985

41505 HOME RE SYNDICATE INC96 Group Name:Group Code: SECURA INS GRP

200910239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

200810239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

200710239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

200610239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

200510239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

200010239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

199510239 SECURA SUPREME INS CO 22543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

199022543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

198522543 SECURA INS A MUT CO

98 Group Name:Group Code: WR BERKLEY CORP GRP2009

10510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO10833 GEMINI INS CO 10885 KEY RISK INS CO10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO 15911 AMERICAN MINING INS CO INC17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25844 UNION INS CO29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INS CO 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN31295 BERKLEY REGIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 31325 ACADIA INS CO32603 BERKLEY INS CO 33480 CLERMONT INS CO36684 RIVERPORT INS CO 38911 BERKLEY NATL INS CO40045 STARNET INS CO 43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS44318 ADMIRAL IND CO

200810510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO10833 GEMINI INS CO 10885 KEY RISK INS CO10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners264

Page 273: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

98 Group Name:Group Code: WR BERKLEY CORP GRP2008

15911 AMERICAN MINING INS CO INC 17370 NAUTILUS INS CO21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC 23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO24856 ADMIRAL INS CO 25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO25844 UNION INS CO 29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INS CO31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN 31295 BERKLEY REGIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO31325 ACADIA INS CO 32603 BERKLEY INS CO33480 CLERMONT INS CO 36684 RIVERPORT INS CO38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO 40045 STARNET INS CO43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS 44318 ADMIRAL IND CO

200710510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO10833 GEMINI INS CO 10885 KEY RISK INS CO10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO 15911 AMERICAN MINING INS CO INC17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25844 UNION INS CO29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INS CO 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN31295 BERKLEY REGIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 31325 ACADIA INS CO32603 BERKLEY INS CO 33480 CLERMONT INS CO36684 RIVERPORT INS CO 38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO40045 STARNET INS CO 43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS44318 ADMIRAL IND CO

200610510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO10833 GEMINI INS CO 10885 KEY RISK INS CO10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO 17370 NAUTILUS INS CO21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC 23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO24856 ADMIRAL INS CO 25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO25844 UNION INS CO 29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INS CO31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN 31295 BERKLEY REGIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO31325 ACADIA INS CO 32603 BERKLEY INS CO33480 CLERMONT INS CO 36684 RIVERPORT INS CO38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO 40045 STARNET INS CO43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS 44318 ADMIRAL IND CO

200510389 BERKLEY INS CO OF THE CAROLINAS 10510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO 10833 GEMINI INS CO10885 KEY RISK INS CO 10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25844 UNION INS CO29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INS CO 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN31295 BERKLEY REGIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO 31325 ACADIA INS CO32603 BERKLEY INS CO 33480 CLERMONT INS CO36684 RIVERPORT INS CO 38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO40045 STARNET INS CO 43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS44318 ADMIRAL IND CO

200010389 BERKLEY INS CO OF THE CAROLINAS 10510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO 10833 GEMINI INS CO10885 KEY RISK INS CO 10900 PREFERRED EMPLOYERS INS CO11001 RIVERPORT INS CO OF CA 17370 NAUTILUS INS CO18468 GREAT RIVER INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25844 UNION INS CO29580 BERKLEY REGIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN31295 CHESAPEAKE BAY PROP & CAS INS CO 31307 CADILLAC MOUNTAIN INS CO31325 ACADIA INS CO 32603 SIGNET STAR REINSURANCE CO33480 CONTINENTAL WESTERN CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners265

Page 274: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

98 Group Name:Group Code: WR BERKLEY CORP GRP2000

38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO 40045 STARNET INS CO43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO44318 ADMIRAL INDEMNITY CO

199510510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 18468 GREAT RIVER INS CO21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC 23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO24856 ADMIRAL INS CO 25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO25844 UNION INS CO 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN31295 ACADIA COMPENSATION INSURANCE CO 31325 ACADIA INS CO32603 SIGNET STAR REINSURANCE CO 33480 CONTINENTAL WESTERN CAS CO38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO 43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO 44318 FICO INS CO

199010510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25844 UNION INS CO31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN 32603 SIGNET REINSURANCE CO33480 CONTINENTAL WESTERN CAS CO 38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO

198510510 CAROLINA CAS INS CO 10804 CONTINENTAL WESTERN INS CO17370 NAUTILUS INS CO 21784 FIREMENS INS CO OF WASHINGTON DC23612 MIDWEST EMPLOYERS CAS CO 24856 ADMIRAL INS CO25224 GREAT DIVIDE INS CO 25836 NEBRASKA HARDWARE MUT INS CO25844 UNION INS CO 31003 TRI STATE INS CO OF MN32603 SIGNET REINSURANCE CO 33480 CONTINENTAL WESTERN CAS CO38911 UNION STANDARD INS CO 39446 NORTH STAR SYNDICATE INC43435 UNION STANDARD LLOYDS

100 Group Name:Group Code: INDIANA FARMERS1995

22624 INDIANA FARMERS MUT INS CO1990

14273 INDIANA UNION MUTUAL INS CO 22624 INDIANA FARMERS MUT INS CO22632 TOWN & COUNTRY MUT INS CO

198514273 INDIANA UNION MUTUAL INS CO 22624 INDIANA FARMERS MUT INS CO22632 TOWN & COUNTRY MUT INS CO

103 Group Name:Group Code: INTEGON CORP1995

12130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP 27930 BANKERS & SHIPPERS INDEMNITY CO29742 BANKERS & SHIPPERS INSURANCE COMPANY 31488 INTEGON PREFERRED INSURANCE CO37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS

199012130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP 29742 BANKERS & SHIPPERS INSURANCE COMPANY31488 AMSTATS INSURANCE CO 37745 INTEGON SPECIALTY INS

198512130 NEW SOUTH INS CO 22772 INTEGON IND CORP22780 INTEGON GENERAL INS CORP 31488 AMSTATS INSURANCE CO

105 Group Name:Group Code: MGIC GRP2009

10247 MGIC REINS CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REINS CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP16470 MGIC REINS CORP 18740 MGIC IND CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GEN ACCOUNT

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners266

Page 275: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

105 Group Name:Group Code: MGIC GRP2009

29858 MORTGAGE GUAR INS CORP2008

10247 MGIC REINS CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REINS CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP16470 MGIC REINS CORP 18740 MGIC IND CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GEN ACCOUNT 29858 MORTGAGE GUAR INS CORP

200710247 MGIC REINS CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REINS CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP16470 MGIC REINS CORP 18740 MGIC IND CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GEN ACCOUNT 29858 MORTGAGE GUAR INS CORP

200610247 MGIC REIN CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REIN CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP16470 MGIC REIN CORP 18740 MGIC IND CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GENERAL ACCOUNT 29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

200510247 MGIC REIN CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REIN CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP16470 MGIC REIN CORP 18740 MGIC IND CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GENERAL ACCOUNT 29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

200010247 MGIC REIN CORP OF WI 10252 MGIC RESIDENTIAL REIN CORP10666 MGIC MORTGAGE REINS CORP 10682 MGIC CREDIT ASSUR CORP10722 MGIC SURETY CORP 11006 MGIC ASSUR CORP SEGREGATED ACCOUNT16470 MGIC REIN CORP 18740 MGIC INDEMNITY CORP22594 MGIC ASSUR CORP GENERAL ACCOUNT 29564 MGIC MORTGAGE INS CORP29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

199516470 MGIC REIN CORP 17981 MORTGAGE GTY REIN CORP22594 M G I C ASSURANCE CORPORATION 29564 MGIC MORTGAGE INS CORP29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

199016470 MGIC REIN CORP 17981 MORTGAGE GTY REIN CORP22594 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR OF OK INC 29564 MGIC MORTGAGE INS CORP29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

198516470 MGIC REIN CORP 17981 MORTGAGE GTY REIN CORP22594 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR OF OK INC 29564 MGIC MORTGAGE INS CORP29858 MORTGAGE GUARANTY INS CORP

106 Group Name:Group Code: ISLAND INS CO GRP2009

11689 ISLAND PREMIER INS CO LTD 22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD

200811689 ISLAND PREMIER INS CO LTD 22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD

200711689 ISLAND PREMIER INS CO LTD 22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD

200611689 ISLAND PREMIER INS CO LTD 22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD

200511689 ISLAND PREMIER INS CO LTD 22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners267

Page 276: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

106 Group Name:Group Code: ISLAND INS CO GRP2000

22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD 22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD1995

22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD 22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD1990

22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD 22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD1985

22845 ISLAND INS CO LTD 22853 TRADEWIND INS CO LTD107 Group Name:Group Code: JEFFERSON PILOT CP

199511240 JEFFERSON PILOT PROPERTY INS CO

199011240 JEFFERSON PILOT PROPERTY INS CO

198511240 JEFFERSON PILOT PROPERTY INS CO

108 Group Name:Group Code: LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP2009

11622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER INS CO OF TX

200811622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER INS CO OF TX

200711622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER INS CO OF TX

200611622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

200511622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 14770 UNIVERSAL BONDING INS CO22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO 22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO 30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

200010249 KEMPER COMP INS CO 10668 KEMPER COMMERCIAL INS CO10678 KEMPER SAFEGUARD SURPLUS INS CO 10877 KEMPER ENVIROMENTAL LTD10892 LONG GROVE INS CO 10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO10915 KEMPER AUTO & HOME INSURANCE COMPAN 10940 KEMPER SURPLUS LINES INS CO11012 RIDGELAND INS CO 11013 GREATLAND INS CO11622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 14770 UNIVERSAL BONDING INS CO15563 KEMPER EMPLOYERS INS CO 18910 AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO20524 SPECIALTY NATIONAL INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 27138 KEMPER CAS INS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 36986 EAGLE PACIFIC INS CO40380 PACIFIC EAGLE INS CO 40991 KEMPER INDEMNITY INS CO41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

199518910 AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22969 GE REINS CORP 22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

199018910 AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22969 GE REINS CORP 22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO 41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners268

Page 277: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

108 Group Name:Group Code: LUMBERMENS MUT CAS GRP1985

18910 AMERICAN PROTECTION INS CO 22918 AMERICAN MOTORISTS INS CO22942 IOWA KEMPER INS CO 22969 GE REINS CORP22977 LUMBERMENS MUT CAS CO 30562 AMERICAN MANUFACTURERS MUT INS CO41351 KEMPER LLOYDS INS CO

109 Group Name:Group Code: KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU GRP2009

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUR MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO2008

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUR MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO2007

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUR MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO2006

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO2005

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO2000

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO1995

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO1990

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO1985

22993 KENTUCKY FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 23000 FB INS CO110 Group Name:Group Code: PROFESSIONAL GRP

199032476 PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL INS CO 44024 PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO RRG

111 Group Name:Group Code: LIBERTY MUT GRP2009

10335 BRIDGEFIELD CAS INS CO 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10792 AVOMARK INS CO 10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO 11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO 11070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR 11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO11215 SAFECO INS CO OF IN 11526 AMERICA FIRST LLOYDS INS CO11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO 12484 LIBERTY MUT PERSONAL INS CO12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO 14486 LIBERTY MUT MID ATLANTIC INS CO14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 18333 PEERLESS IND INS CO19544 LIBERTY CNTY MUT INS CO 19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO 19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX19917 LIBERTY INS UNDERWRITERS INC 21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO 23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO23507 MID AMER FIRE & CAS CO 23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO 23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE24198 PEERLESS INS CO 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GEN INS CO26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 32352 LM PROP & CAS INS CO33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP 33600 LM INS CORP36439 LM PERSONAL INS CO 36447 LM GEN INS CO36919 HAWKEYE SECURITY INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL 41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners269

Page 278: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

111 Group Name:Group Code: LIBERTY MUT GRP2009

41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP 42404 LIBERTY INS CORP44393 WEST AMER INS CO

200810073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10335 BRIDGEFIELD CAS INS CO10337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10792 AVOMARK INS CO 10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO 10937 OHIO CAS OF NJ INC11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO11070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11215 SAFECO INS CO OF IN11312 GLOBE AMER CAS CO 11526 AMERICA FIRST LLOYDS INS CO11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO 12484 LIBERTY MUT PERSONAL INS CO12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO 14486 LIBERTY MUT MID ATLANTIC INS CO14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 18333 PEERLESS IND INS CO19544 LIBERTY CNTY MUT INS CO 19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO 19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX19917 LIBERTY INS UNDERWRITERS INC 21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO 23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO23507 MID AMER FIRE & CAS CO 23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO 23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE24198 PEERLESS INS CO 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 32352 LM PROP & CAS INS CO33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP 33600 LM INS CORP36439 LM PERSONAL INS CO 36447 LM GEN INS CO36919 HAWKEYE SECURITY INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL 41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP 42404 LIBERTY INS CORP44393 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

200710073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10335 BRIDGEFIELD CAS INS CO10337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10792 AVOMARK INS CO 10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO 10937 OHIO CAS OF NJ INC11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO11312 GLOBE AMER CAS CO 11526 AMERICA FIRST LLOYDS INS CO11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO 12484 LIBERTY MUT PERSONAL INS CO12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO 14486 LIBERTY MUT MID ATLANTIC INS CO14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 18333 PEERLESS IND INS CO19544 LIBERTY CNTY MUT INS CO 19917 LIBERTY INS UNDERWRITERS INC21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU 22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO22659 INDIANA INS CO 23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO 23507 MID AMER FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO 24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO24074 OHIO CAS INS CO 24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE 24198 PEERLESS INS CO26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO 26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN32352 LM PROP & CAS INS CO 33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP33600 LM INS CORP 36439 LM PERSONAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners270

Page 279: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

111 Group Name:Group Code: LIBERTY MUT GRP2007

36447 LM GEN INS CO 36919 HAWKEYE SECURITY INS CO41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO 41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP42404 LIBERTY INS CORP 44393 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

200610073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10335 BRIDGEFIELD CAS INS CO10337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP 10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 11526 AMERICA FIRST LLOYDS INS CO11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO 12484 LIBERTY MUT PERSONAL INS CO12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO 14486 LIBERTY MUT MID ATLANTIC INS CO14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 18333 PEERLESS IND INS CO19544 LIBERTY COUNTY MUT INS CO 19917 LIBERTY INS UNDERWRITERS INC21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU 22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO22659 INDIANA INS CO 23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO 23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO 24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE24198 PEERLESS INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN 32352 LM PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INS. CO.33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP 33600 LM INS CORP36439 LM PERSONAL INS CO 36447 LM GENERAL INS CO36919 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO 41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP 42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

200510073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10335 BRIDGEFIELD CAS INS CO10337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP 10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 11526 AMERICA FIRST LLOYDS INS CO11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO 12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO14486 MERCHANTS & BUSINESS MENS MUT INS CO 14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO18333 PEERLESS IND INS CO 19544 LIBERTY COUNTY MUT INS CO19917 LIBERTY INS UNDERWRITERS INC 21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO 23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO23892 NORTH PACIFIC INS CO 23922 OREGON AUTOMOBILE INS CO24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE 24198 PEERLESS INS CO26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO 26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN32352 LM PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INS. CO. 33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP33600 LM INS CORP 36439 LM PERSONAL INS CO36447 LM GENERAL INS CO 36919 HAWKEYE-SECURITY INS CO41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO 41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

200010073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10335 BRIDGEFIELD CASUALTY INS CO10337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 10375 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO10701 BRIDGEFIELD EMPLOYERS INS CO 10725 LIBERTY SURPLUS INS CORP10836 GOLDEN EAGLE INS CORP 10837 SAN DIEGO INS CO11041 LIBERTY LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 11045 EXCELSIOR INS CO11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 11746 LIBERTY PERSONAL INS CO12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO 14486 MERCHANTS & BUSINESS MENS MUT INS CO14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 16900 MONTGOMERY IND CO18333 ATLAS ASSUR CO OF AMER 19917 LIBERTY INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners271

Page 280: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

111 Group Name:Group Code: LIBERTY MUT GRP2000

21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU 22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO22659 INDIANA INS CO 23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO 23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE24198 PEERLESS INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN 33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP33600 LM INS CORP 36919 TOWER INS CO INC41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO 41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

199510337 LIBERTY INS CO OF AMER 23035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO 33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP33600 LM INS CORP 41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

199023035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO 23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO33588 FIRST LIBERTY INS CORP 33600 LM INS CORP41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP 42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

198523035 LIBERTY MUT FIRE INS CO 23043 LIBERTY MUT INS CO41939 LIBERTY NORTHWEST INS CORP 42404 LIBERTY INS CORP

112 Group Name:Group Code: LLOYDS OF NM GRP1990

23078 LLOYDS OF NM INS CO1985

23078 LLOYDS OF NM INS CO114 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHEASTERN GRP

198516560 SOUTHEASTERN CAS & IND INS CO OF NJ 26476 SOUTHEASTERN REINS CO INC42641 SOUTHEASTERN CAS & IND INS CO

116 Group Name:Group Code: MANUFACT & MCHTS GRP2000

23159 CAPITAL FIRE INS CO 23167 MANUFACTURERS & MCHTS MUT INS CO23175 PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO

199523159 CAPITAL FIRE INS CO 23167 MANUFACTURERS & MCHTS MUT INS CO23175 PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO

199023159 CAPITAL FIRE INS CO 23167 MANUFACTURERS & MCHTS MUT INS CO23175 PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO

198523159 CAPITAL FIRE INS CO 23167 MANUFACTURERS & MCHTS MUT INS CO23175 PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO

117 Group Name:Group Code: HOME ST GRP1995

10107 WESTBROOK INS CO 16772 PINNACLE INS CO23205 QUAKER CITY INS CO 30660 HOME STATE IN CO

199016772 PINNACLE INS CO 23205 QUAKER CITY INS CO30660 HOME STATE IN CO

198516772 PINNACLE INS CO 23205 QUAKER CITY INS CO

118 Group Name:Group Code: GRYPHON HOLDINGS INC1995

20524 CALVERT INS CO 27189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners272

Page 281: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

118 Group Name:Group Code: GRYPHON HOLDINGS INC1990

20524 CALVERT INS CO 27189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO1985

20524 CALVERT INS CO 27189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO120 Group Name:Group Code: MEMBERS INS GRP

199023302 MEMBERS INS CO 23310 MEMBERS MUT INS CO31984 MEMBERS SERVICES INS CO

198523302 MEMBERS INS CO 23310 MEMBERS MUT INS CO31984 MEMBERS SERVICES INS CO

122 Group Name:Group Code: MERIDIAN MUT GRP2000

10502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUTUAL INS CO 23345 MERIDIAN MUT INS CO23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO 26654 MERIDIAN CITIZENS SECURITY INS CO41599 INSURANCE CO OF OH

199513129 VERNON FIRE & CAS INS CO 23345 MERIDIAN MUT INS CO23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO

199013129 VERNON FIRE & CAS INS CO 23345 MERIDIAN MUT INS CO23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO

198513129 VERNON FIRE & CAS INS CO 23345 MERIDIAN MUT INS CO23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO

123 Group Name:Group Code: SHELTER INS GRP2009

23361 SHELTER GEN INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO 31550 HAULERS INS CO INC

200823361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO 31550 HAULERS INS CO INC

200723361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

200623361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

200523361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

200023361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

199523361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

199023361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

198523361 SHELTER GENERAL INS CO 23388 SHELTER MUT INS CO26557 SHELTER REINS CO

124 Group Name:Group Code: AMERISURE CO GRP2009

11050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners273

Page 282: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

124 Group Name:Group Code: AMERISURE CO GRP2008

11050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

200711050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

200611050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

200511050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

200011050 AMERISURE PARTNERS INS CO 19488 AMERISURE INS CO23396 AMERISURE MUT INS CO

199519488 AMERISURE INS CO 19534 UNISUN INS CO19542 CAROLINA AMERICAN INS CO 23396 MICHIGAN MUT INS CO

199019488 AMERISURE INS CO 19534 UNISUN INS CO19542 CAROLINA AMERICAN INS CO 23396 MICHIGAN MUT INS CO27448 AMERISURE LLOYDS

198519488 AMERISURE INS CO 19534 UNISUN INS CO19542 CAROLINA AMERICAN INS CO 23396 MICHIGAN MUT INS CO

125 Group Name:Group Code: PENN MILLER GRP2009

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO2008

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO2007

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO2006

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO2005

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO2000

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO1995

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO1990

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO1985

14982 PENN MILLERS INS CO 23477 AMERICAN MILLERS INS CO126 Group Name:Group Code: EDUCATORS MUT GRP

199017060 EDUCATORS INS CO

127 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP2007

12314 AMERICAN MODERN INS CO OF FL 12489 AMERICAN MODERN SURPLUS LINES INS CO23450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 AMERICAN MODERN SELECT INS CO41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

200612314 AMERICAN MODERN INS CO OF FL 12489 AMERICAN MODERN SURPLUS LINES INS CO23450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 AMERICAN MODERN SELECT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners274

Page 283: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

127 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MODERN INS GRP2006

41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO2005

12314 AMERICAN MODERN INS CO OF FL 12489 AMERICAN MODERN SURPLUS LINES INS CO23450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 GUIC INS CO41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

200023450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 GUIC INSURANCE COMPANY41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

199523450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 GUIC INSURANCE COMPANY41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

199023450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 GUARDIAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO INC41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

198523450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO 38652 GUARDIAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO INC41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO 42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO

128 Group Name:Group Code: MIDLAND INS GRP1985

23493 MIDLAND INS CO 31860 MIDLAND PROPERTY & CAS INS CO129 Group Name:Group Code: PROP & CAS STANDARD GRP

199516217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 23752 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION STD INS CO

199016217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 23752 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION STD INS CO

198516217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 23744 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS CO23752 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION STD INS CO

130 Group Name:Group Code: MILLERS AMER GRP INC2000

20150 MILLERS DIRECT INS CO THE 23523 MILLERS CAS INS CO23531 MILLERS INS CO 34037 PHOENIX IND INS CO

199523523 MILLERS CASUALTY INSURANCE CO 23531 MILLERS MUTUAL FIRE INS CO (THE)

199023523 MILLERS CASUALTY INS CO OF TX 23531 MILLERS MUTUAL FIRE INS CO OF TX

198523523 MILLERS CASUALTY INS CO OF TX 23531 MILLERS MUTUAL FIRE INS CO OF TX

133 Group Name:Group Code: MISSION EQUITIES GRP1985

23590 HOLLAND AMER INS CO 23604 MISSION INS CO25607 MISSION AMERICAN INS CO 35033 MISSION NATL INS CO37702 ENTERPRISE INS CO 38431 MISSION REIN CORP40096 COMPAC INS CO 41092 HOLLAND AMER LLOYDS INS CO

134 Group Name:Group Code: REINSURANCE CO OF AMER GRP2000

15440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC1995

15440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC1990

15440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners275

Page 284: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

134 Group Name:Group Code: REINSURANCE CO OF AMER GRP1985

15440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC138 Group Name:Group Code: COMMUNITY INS GRP

199015857 COMMUNITY MUT INS CO

198515857 COMMUNITY MUT INS CO

140 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONWIDE CORP GRP2009

10070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10127 ATLANTIC FLORIDIAN INS CO 10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INS CO 10778 VICTORIA NATL INS CO10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13242 TITAN IND CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 18961 CRESTBROOK INS CO19100 AMCO INS CO 22209 FREEDOM SPECIALTY INS CO23760 NATIONWIDE GEN INS CO 23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO 25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER26093 NATIONWIDE AFFINITY CO OF AMER 28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO 36269 TITAN INS CO37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO 37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO 42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS42285 VETERINARY PET INS CO 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO 42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

200810070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10127 ATLANTIC FLORIDIAN INS CO 10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INS CO 10778 VICTORIA NATL INS CO10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13242 TITAN IND CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 18961 CRESTBROOK INS CO19100 AMCO INS CO 22209 ATLANTIC INS CO23760 NATIONWIDE GEN INS CO 23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO 25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER26093 NATIONWIDE AFFINITY CO OF AMER 28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO 36269 TITAN INS CO37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO 37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO 42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS42285 VETERINARY PET INS CO 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO 42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

200710070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10127 ATLANTIC FLORIDIAN INS CO 10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INS CO 10778 VICTORIA NATL INS CO10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13242 TITAN IND CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 18961 CRESTBROOK INS CO19100 AMCO INS CO 23760 NATIONWIDE GEN INS CO23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO 23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER 26093 NATIONWIDE AFFINITY CO OF AMER28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO 29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO36269 TITAN INS CO 37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS 42285 VETERINARY PET INS CO42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO 42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners276

Page 285: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

140 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONWIDE CORP GRP2006

10070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10127 ATLANTIC FLORIDIAN INS CO 10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INS CO 10778 VICTORIA NATL INS CO10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13242 TITAN IND CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 18961 CRESTBROOK INS CO19100 AMCO INS CO 23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO 23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER 26093 NATIONWIDE AFFINITY CO OF AMER28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO 29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO36269 TITAN INS CO 37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS 42285 VETERINARY PET INS CO42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO 42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

200510070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10127 NATIONWIDE ATLANTIC INS CO 10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INS CO 10778 VICTORIA NATL INS CO10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13242 TITAN IND CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 18961 CRESTBROOK INS CO19100 AMCO INS CO 23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO 23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMER 26093 NATIONWIDE AFFINITY CO OF AMER28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO 29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO36269 TITAN INS CO 37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS 42285 VETERINARY PET INS CO42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO 42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

200010070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10672 SCOTTSDALE SURPLUS LINES INS CO10723 NATIONWIDE ASSUR CO 10948 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF FL11052 CARRIBEAN ALLIANCE INS CO 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO 15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO18961 CALFARM INS CO 19100 AMCO INS CO23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO 23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO 25453 NATIONWIDE INS CO OF AMERICA26093 WATERFORD INS CO 28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO 37150 WESTERN HERITAGE INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS 42579 ALLIED PROP & CAS INS CO42587 DEPOSITORS INS CO

199510070 NATIONWIDE IND CO 10723 COLONIAL INS CO OF WI11991 NATIONAL CAS CO 13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO 23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO 29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 NATIONWIDE LLOYDS

199010723 COLONIAL INS CO OF WI 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners277

Page 286: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

140 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONWIDE CORP GRP1990

15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO 21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO 23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO 26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO 26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO 29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO 41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO42110 WAUSAU LLOYDS

198510723 COLONIAL INS CO OF WI 11991 NATIONAL CAS CO13838 FARMLAND MUT INS CO 15580 SCOTTSDALE IND CO21458 EMPLOYERS INS OF WAUSAU 23760 NATIONWIDE GENERAL INS CO23779 NATIONWIDE MUT FIRE INS CO 23787 NATIONWIDE MUT INS CO26042 WAUSAU UNDERWRITERS INS CO 26069 WAUSAU BUSINESS INS CO26425 WAUSAU GENERAL INS CO 28223 NATIONWIDE AGRIBUSINESS INS CO29262 COLONIAL CNTY MUT INS CO 37877 NATIONWIDE PROP & CAS INS CO41297 SCOTTSDALE INS CO 42110 WAUSAU LLOYDS

141 Group Name:Group Code: FRONT ROYAL GRP2000

10726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 34118 PREFERRED NATL INS CO35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO 36927 FRONT ROYAL INSURANCE CO39993 COLONY INS CO

199511444 HAMILTON INS CO 36927 FRONT ROYAL INSURANCE CO39993 COLONY INS CO

199011444 HAMILTON INS CO 36927 CARDINAL CASUALTY CO39993 COLONY INS CO

198511444 HAMILTON INS CO 36927 CARDINAL CASUALTY CO39993 COLONY INS CO

143 Group Name:Group Code: ARMCO INS INC GRP2009

10154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 11977 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO SEG ACCNT21989 COMPASS INS CO 23914 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO MILWAUKEE

200710154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 11977 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO SEG ACCNT21989 COMPASS INS CO 23914 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO MILWAUKEE

200610154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 11977 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO SEG ACCNT21989 COMPASS INS CO 23914 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO MILWAUKEE

200510154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 11977 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO SEG ACCNT21989 COMPASS INS CO 23914 NORTHWESTERN NATL INS CO MILWAUKEE

200010154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 21989 COMPASS INS CO23914 NORTHWESTERN NTL INS CO MILWAUKEE

199510154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 21989 COMPASS INS CO23914 NORTHWESTERN NTL INS CO MILWAUKEE

199010154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 21989 COMPASS INS CO23914 NORTHWESTERN NTL INS CO MILWAUKEE 23949 UNIVERSAL REINS CORP26727 BELLEFONTE UNDERWRITERS INS CO

198510154 AMERICAN DRUGGISTS INS CO 21989 COMPASS INS CO23914 NORTHWESTERN NTL INS CO MILWAUKEE 23949 UNIVERSAL REINS CORP26727 BELLEFONTE UNDERWRITERS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners278

Page 287: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

144 Group Name:Group Code: NORFOLK & DEDHAM GRP2009

11648 CHARLES RIVER INS CO 13706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO13943 FITCHBURG MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO

200811648 CHARLES RIVER INS CO 13706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO13943 FITCHBURG MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO

200711648 CHARLES RIVER INS CO 13706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO13943 FITCHBURG MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO

200611648 CHARLES RIVER INS CO 13706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO13943 FITCHBURG MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO

200511648 CHARLES RIVER INS CO 13706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO13943 FITCHBURG MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO

200013706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 23973 WEST NEWBURY MUT FIRE INS CO

199513706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 23973 WEST NEWBURY MUT FIRE INS CO

199013706 DORCHESTER MUT INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 23973 WEST NEWBURY MUT FIRE INS CO

198513706 DORCHESTER MUT FIRE INS CO 16160 GROVELAND MUT INS CO23965 NORFOLK & DEDHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 23973 WEST NEWBURY MUT FIRE INS CO

146 Group Name:Group Code: NORTHLAND GRP1995

22454 MENDAKOTA INSURANCE COMPANY 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO33650 MENDOTA INS CO 43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

199022454 CELFOR INS CO INC 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO33650 MENDOTA INS CO 43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

198522454 CELFOR INS CO INC 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

147 Group Name:Group Code: HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP2009

31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO2008

31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO2007

31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO2006

31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO2005

31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO2000

20630 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE INS CO 31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners279

Page 288: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

147 Group Name:Group Code: HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE GRP2000

36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO1995

20630 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE INS CO 31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO

199020630 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE INS CO 31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO

198520630 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE INS CO 31054 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE FARM MUT INS ASSOC36862 HOCHHEIM PRAIRIE CAS INS CO

148 Group Name:Group Code: OHIO CAS GRP2006

10792 AVOMARK INS CO 10937 OHIO CAS OF NJ INC24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 44393 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

200510792 AVOMARK INS CO 10937 OHIO CAS OF NJ INC24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 44393 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

200010792 AVOMARK INSURANCE COMPANY 10937 OHIO CAS OF NJ INC24066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 44393 WEST AMERICAN INSURANCE CO

199524066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 44393 WEST AMERICAN INSURANCE CO

199024066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 24090 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

198524066 AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24074 OHIO CAS INS CO24082 OHIO SECURITY INS CO 24090 WEST AMERICAN INS CO

150 Group Name:Group Code: OLD REPUBLIC GRP2009

11371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 11458 GROUP MORTGAGE REINS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 OLD REPUBLIC GEN INS CORP24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO35424 OLD REPUBLIC SECURITY ASSUR CO 40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

200811371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 11458 GROUP MORTGAGE REINS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 OLD REPUBLIC GEN INS CORP24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO35424 OLD REPUBLIC SECURITY ASSUR CO 40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

200711371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 11458 GROUP MORTGAGE REINS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 OLD REPUBLIC GEN INS CORP24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners280

Page 289: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

150 Group Name:Group Code: OLD REPUBLIC GRP2007

32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO35424 OLD REPUBLIC SECURITY ASSUR CO 40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

200611371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 11458 GROUP MORTGAGE REINS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 OLD REPUBLIC GENERAL INS CORP24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO35424 OLD REPUBLIC SECURITY ASSUR CO 40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

200510630 EMPLOYERS GENERAL INS CO 11371 GREAT WEST CAS CO11458 GROUP MORTGAGE REINS CO 18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP 20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO24139 INTERNATIONAL BUS & MERC REASSUR CO 24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO 31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC 32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO 35424 OLD REPUBLIC SECURITY ASSUR CO40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO 40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

200010630 EMPLOYERS GENERAL INS CO 11371 GREAT WEST CAS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 INTERNATIONAL BUS & MERC REASSUR CO24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO29092 OLD REPUBLIC STANDARD INS CO 31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC 32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO 35424 OLD REPUBLIC MINNEHOMA INS CO40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO 40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC

199510630 EMPLOYERS GENERAL INS CO 11371 GREAT WEST CAS CO18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 INTERNATIONAL BUS & MERC REASSUR CO24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 27456 INTER CAPITAL ASS CO28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO 29092 OLD REPUBLIC STANDARD INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33685 UPPER PENINSULA INS CO33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO 35424 OLD REPUBLIC MINNEHOMA INS CO40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO 40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC42013 AMERICAN BUS & MERC REASSUR CO

199011371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP 20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO24139 INTERNATIONAL BUS & MERC REASSUR CO 24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO27456 INTER CAPITAL ASS CO 28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO29092 OLD REPUBLIC STANDARD INS CO 31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC 32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL33685 UPPER PENINSULA INS CO 33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO35424 MINNEHOMA INS CO 40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC 42013 AMERICAN BUS & MERC REASSUR CO

198511371 GREAT WEST CAS CO 12637 AMERICAN TREATY REASSURANCE CO LTD18635 OLD REPUBLIC LLOYDS OF TX 20095 BITUMINOUS CAS CORP20109 BITUMINOUS FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24139 INTERNATIONAL BUS & MERC REASSUR CO24147 OLD REPUBLIC INS CO 27456 INTER CAPITAL ASS CO28452 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO 29092 OLD REPUBLIC STANDARD INS CO31143 OLD REPUBLIC UNION INS CO 31275 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS OF NC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners281

Page 290: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

150 Group Name:Group Code: OLD REPUBLIC GRP1985

32174 REPUBLIC MORTGAGE INS CO OF FL 33685 UPPER PENINSULA INS CO33693 WEXFORD GENERAL INS CO 33707 SIERRA INTL RE INS CO33715 OLD REPUBLIC MERCANTILE INS CO 35424 MINNEHOMA INS CO40444 OLD REPUBLIC SURETY CO 40789 AMERICAN BUS & PERSONAL INS MUT INC42013 AMERICAN BUS & MERC REASSUR CO

153 Group Name:Group Code: PEKIN INS GRP2009

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO2008

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO2007

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO2006

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO2005

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO2000

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO1995

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO1990

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO1985

24201 FARMERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC 24228 PEKIN INS CO154 Group Name:Group Code: KENSU HOLDINGS GRP

198516110 LARAMIE INS CO 18040 RAM SYNDICATE INC20214 OHIO GENERAL INS CO THE

155 Group Name:Group Code: PROGRESSIVE GRP2009

10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO 10067 PROGRESSIVE HI INS CORP10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO 10192 PROGRESSIVE SELECT INS CO10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO 10194 ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO 11410 DRIVE NJ INS CO11770 UNITED FINANCIAL CAS CO 11851 PROGRESSIVE ADVANCED INS CO12302 PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO 12879 PROGRESSIVE COMMERCIAL CAS CO14800 PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO 16322 PROGRESSIVE DIRECT INS CO17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO 21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMER INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PROGRESSIVE WEST INS CO 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO37605 PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO 44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO44288 PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO 44695 PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO

200810042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS CO 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 PROGRESSIVE HI INS CORP 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 PROGRESSIVE SELECT INS CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11410 DRIVE NJ INS CO 11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO11851 PROGRESSIVE ADVANCED INS CO 12302 PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO12879 PROGRESSIVE COMMERCIAL CAS CO 14800 PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO16322 PROGRESSIVE DIRECT INS CO 17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO 21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners282

Page 291: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

155 Group Name:Group Code: PROGRESSIVE GRP2008

24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO 24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO 27804 PROGRESSIVE WEST INS CO29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO 32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO 37605 PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO 38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO 42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO 42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO 44288 PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO44695 PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO

200710042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS CO 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 PROGRESSIVE HI INS CORP 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 PROGRESSIVE SELECT INS CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11410 DRIVE NJ INS CO 11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO11851 PROGRESSIVE ADVANCED INS CO 12302 PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO12879 PROGRESSIVE COMMERCIAL CAS CO 14800 PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO16322 PROGRESSIVE DIRECT INS CO 17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO 21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO 24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO 27804 PROGRESSIVE WEST INS CO29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO 32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO 37605 PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO 38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO 42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO 42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO 44288 PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO44695 PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO

200610042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS CO 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 PROGRESSIVE HI INS CORP 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 PROGRESSIVE SELECT INS CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 ARTISAN & TRUCKERS CAS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11410 DRIVE NJ INS CO 11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO11851 PROGRESSIVE ADVANCED INS CO 12302 PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO14800 PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO 16322 PROGRESSIVE DIRECT INS CO17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO 21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PROGRESSIVE WEST INS CO 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO37605 PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO 44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO44288 PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO 44695 PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO

200510042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS CO 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 PROGRESSIVE HI INS CORP 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 PROGRESSIVE AUTO PRO INS CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 PROGRESSIVE CONSUMERS INS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO 11851 PROGRESSIVE HOME INS CO12299 DRIVE NEW JERSEY INS CO 12301 PROGRESSIVE GARDEN STATE INS CO12302 PROGRESSIVE FREEDOM INS CO 16322 PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INS CO17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO 21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PROGRESSIVE WEST INS CO 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners283

Page 292: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

155 Group Name:Group Code: PROGRESSIVE GRP2005

37605 PROGRESSIVE MARATHON INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INS CO 44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO44288 PROGRESSIVE CHOICE INS CO 44695 PROGRESSIVE PALOVERDE INS CO

200010042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS COMPAN 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 PROGRESSIVE HAWAII INS CORP 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 PROGRESSIVE AUTO PRO INSSURANCE CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 PROGRESSIVE CONSUMERS INS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO 11851 PROGRESSIVE HOME INS CO16322 PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INS CO 17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO OF IL 21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO 24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO 27804 PRO-WEST INSURANCE CO29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO 32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO 37605 MARATHON INS CO37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO 38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO 42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO 42994 PROGRESSIVE CLASSIC INSURANCE CO44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO 44288 SPECIALTY RISK INS CO44695 PROGRESSIVE PALAVERDE INS CO

199510042 PROGRESSIVE NORTHEASTERN INS COMPAN 10050 PROGRESSIVE SECURITY INS CO10067 OHANA INS CO OF HAWAII INC 10187 PROGRESSIVE MI INS CO10192 AUTO PRO INSURANCE CO 10193 PROGRESSIVE EXPRESS INS CO10194 PREFERRED CONSUMERS INS CO 10243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO 16322 PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INS CO17350 PROGRESSIVE BAYSIDE INS CO 21727 PROGRESSIVE UNIVERSAL INS CO OF IL21735 PROGRESSIVE PREMIER INS CO OF IL 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PRO-WEST INSURANCE CO 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO37605 MARATHON INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 CLASSIC INS CO 44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO44695 PALOVERDE INSURANCE CO OF ARIZONA

199010243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO 11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO16322 PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INS CO 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PEOPLES INSURANCE COMPANY 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 35190 PROGRESSIVE MOUNTAIN INS CO37605 MARATHON INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 CLASSIC INS CO 44180 MOUNTAIN LAUREL ASSUR CO

198510243 NATIONAL CONTINENTAL INS CO 11770 UNITED FNCL CAS CO16322 PROGRESSIVE HALCYON INS CO 24252 PROGRESSIVE AMERICAN INS CO24260 PROGRESSIVE CAS INS CO 24279 PROGRESSIVE MAX INS CO27804 PEOPLES INSURANCE COMPANY 29203 PROGRESSIVE CNTY MUT INS CO32786 PROGRESSIVE SPECIALTY INS CO 37834 PROGRESSIVE PREFERRED INS CO38628 PROGRESSIVE NORTHERN INS CO 38784 PROGRESSIVE SOUTHEASTERN INS CO42412 PROGRESSIVE GULF INS CO 42919 PROGRESSIVE NORTHWESTERN INS CO42994 CLASSIC INS CO

156 Group Name:Group Code: PW GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners284

Page 293: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

156 Group Name:Group Code: PW GRP2009

24295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24325 YORK INS CO31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO

200724295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24325 YORK INS CO31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO

200624295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24325 YORK INS CO31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO

200524295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24325 YORK INS CO31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO 35726 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO OF NY

200024295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24325 YORK INS CO26506 PROVIDENCE LLOYDS 31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO35726 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO OF NY

199524295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24317 WESTERN ALLIANCE INS CO24325 YORK INS CO 26506 PROVIDENCE LLOYDS31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO 35726 BALOISE INS CO OF AMERICA

199024295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24317 WESTERN ALLIANCE INS CO24325 YORK INS CO 26506 PROVIDENCE LLOYDS26514 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO OF AK 31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO35726 BALOISE INS CO OF AMERICA

198524295 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO 24317 WESTERN ALLIANCE INS CO24325 YORK INS CO 26506 PROVIDENCE LLOYDS26514 PROVIDENCE WASHINGTON INS CO OF AK 31909 AMERICAN CONCEPT INS CO35726 BALOISE INS CO OF AMERICA

157 Group Name:Group Code: PUBLIC EMPLOYEES GRP2009

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO2008

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO2007

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO2006

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO2005

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO2000

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO1995

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO1990

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO1985

18805 PEMCO INS CO 24341 PEMCO MUT INS CO158 Group Name:Group Code: FAIRFAX FIN GRP

200910019 CLEARWATER SELECT INS CO 10220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO 10936 SENECA INS CO INC18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO 23680 ODYSSEY AMER REINS CO24384 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY INS CO 25054 HUDSON INS CO25070 CLEARWATER INS CO 25496 TIG IND CO25518 FAIRMONT PREMIER INS CO 25534 TIG INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners285

Page 294: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

158 Group Name:Group Code: FAIRFAX FIN GRP2009

31348 CRUM & FORSTER IND CO 37079 HUDSON SPECIALTY INS CO42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO 44520 CRUM & FORSTER SPECIALTY INS CO

200810019 CLEARWATER SELECT INS CO 10220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO 10936 SENECA INS CO INC18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 19160 OLD LYME INS CO OF RI INC21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO23680 ODYSSEY AMER REINS CO 24384 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY INS CO25054 HUDSON INS CO 25070 CLEARWATER INS CO25496 TIG IND CO 25518 FAIRMONT PREMIER INS CO25534 TIG INS CO 31348 CRUM & FORSTER IND CO37079 HUDSON SPECIALTY INS CO 42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO44520 CRUM & FORSTER SPECIALTY INS CO

200710019 CLEARWATER SELECT INS CO 10220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO 10936 SENECA INS CO INC18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 19160 OLD LYME INS CO OF RI INC21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO23680 ODYSSEY AMER REINS CO 24384 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY INS CO25054 HUDSON INS CO 25070 CLEARWATER INS CO25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP 25496 TIG IND CO25518 FAIRMONT PREMIER INS CO 25534 TIG INS CO31348 CRUM & FORSTER IND CO 37079 HUDSON SPECIALTY INS CO42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO 44520 CRUM & FORSTER SPECIALTY INS CO

200610019 CLEARWATER SELECT INS CO 10220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO 10936 SENECA INS CO INC18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 19160 OLD LYME INS CO OF RI INC21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO23680 ODYSSEY AMERICA REINS CO 24384 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY INS CO24406 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY LLOYDS 25054 HUDSON INS CO25070 CLEARWATER INS CO 25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP25496 TIG IND CO 25518 FAIRMONT PREMIER INS CO25534 TIG INS CO 31348 CRUM & FORSTER IND CO37079 HUDSON SPECIALTY INS CO 42471 CRUM AND FORSTER INS CO44520 CRUM & FORSTER SPECIALTY INS CO

200510019 CLEARWATER SELECT INS CO 10220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO 10936 SENECA INS CO INC18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 19160 OLD LYME INS CO OF RI INC21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO23680 ODYSSEY AMERICA REINS CO 24384 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY INS CO24406 FAIRMONT SPECIALTY LLOYDS 25054 HUDSON INS CO25070 CLEARWATER INS CO 25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP25496 TIG IND CO 25518 FAIRMONT PREMIER INS CO25534 TIG INS CO 31348 CRUM & FORSTER IND CO37079 HUDSON SPECIALTY INS CO 42471 CRUM AND FORSTER INS CO44520 CRUM & FORSTER SPECIALTY INS CO

200010220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER 10729 SENECA SPECIALTY INS CO10936 SENECA INS CO INC 11690 CRUM & FORSTER UNDERWRITERS CO OH18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 21083 INTERNATIONAL INS CO21105 NORTH RIVER INS CO 21113 UNITED STATES FIRE INS CO23680 ODYSSEY AMERICA REINS CO 24384 RANGER INS CO24406 RANGER LLOYDS 25054 HUDSON INS CO25070 ODYSSEY REINSURANCE CORP 25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP25461 TIG INS CO OF TX 25488 TIG INS CO OF NY25496 TIG IND CO 25518 TIG PREMIER INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners286

Page 295: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

158 Group Name:Group Code: FAIRFAX FIN GRP2000

25526 TIG INS CORP OF AMER 25534 TIG INS CO25542 TIG INS CO OF MI 29327 INDUSTRIAL COUNTY MUT INS CO30150 ZENITH STAR INS CO 31348 CRUM AND FORSTER INDEMNITY CO35610 TIG INS CO OF CO 42021 TIG LLOYDS INS CO42471 CRUM & FORSTER INS CO 43184 TIG AMERICAN SPECIALTY INSURANCE CO44520 TRANSNATIONAL INSURANCE

199510220 COMMONWEALTH INS CO OF AMER 24384 RANGER INS CO24406 RANGER LLOYDS 37567 COMMONWEALTH INS CO US BR

199024384 RANGER INS CO 24406 RANGER LLOYDS37567 COMMONWEALTH INS CO US BR

198524368 PAN AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO 24384 RANGER INS CO24406 RANGER LLOYDS 37567 COMMONWEALTH INS CO US BR

159 Group Name:Group Code: RELIANCE GRP2000

10681 RELIANCE DIRECT INS CO 11034 RELIANT CAS INS CO24430 RELIANCE NATIONAL INDEMNITY CO 24457 RELIANCE INS CO24473 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO 24481 RELIANCE INS CO OF IL36471 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO OF NY 39438 RELIANCE LLOYDS40592 RELIANCE NATL INS CO 41980 RELIANCE SURETY CO44482 RELIANCE UNIVERSAL INS CO

199510019 OVERSEAS PARTNERS US RE CO 24430 RELIANCE NATIONAL INDEMNITY CO24457 RELIANCE INS CO 24473 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO24481 RELIANCE INS CO OF IL 36471 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO OF NY36498 RELIANCE NATIONAL INS CO OF NEW YORK 39438 RELIANCE LLOYDS40592 RELIANCE NATL INS CO 41840 ALLMERICA FINANCIAL BENEFIT INS CO41980 RELIANCE SURETY CO 44482 RELIANCE UNIVERSAL INS CO OF CA

199024430 PLANET INS CO 24457 RELIANCE INS CO24473 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO 24481 RELIANCE INS CO OF IL36471 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO OF NY 36498 RELIANCE INS CO OF NEW YORK39438 RELIANCE LLOYDS 40592 RELIANCE NATL INS CO41980 RELIANCE NATL P & C INS CO 44482 RELIANCE UNIVERSAL INS CO OF CA

198524430 PLANET INS CO 24457 RELIANCE INS CO24473 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO 24481 RELIANCE INS CO OF IL32042 PRUDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO 36471 UNITED PACIFIC INS CO OF NY36498 RELIANCE INS CO OF NEW YORK 39438 RELIANCE LLOYDS40592 RELIANCE NATL INS CO

161 Group Name:Group Code: TOPA EQUITIES LTD GRP2009

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD2008

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD2007

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD2006

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD2005

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD2000

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD1995

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners287

Page 296: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

161 Group Name:Group Code: TOPA EQUITIES LTD GRP1990

18031 TOPA INS CO 31461 DORCHESTER INS CO LTD1985

18031 TOPA INS CO162 Group Name:Group Code: ROYAL GRP

199517221 ROYAL SPECIAL RISKS INS CO 24589 AMERICAN & FOREIGN INS CO24600 GLOBE IND CO 24678 ROYAL IND CO24694 SAFEGUARD INS CO 26980 ROYAL INS CO OF AMER36749 ROYAL INS CO OF PUERTO RICO 41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO43346 ROYAL LLOYDS OF TX

199017221 ROYAL SPECIAL RISKS INS CO 24589 AMERICAN & FOREIGN INS CO24600 GLOBE IND CO 24678 ROYAL IND CO24694 SAFEGUARD INS CO 26980 ROYAL INS CO OF AMER36749 ROYAL INS CO OF PUERTO RICO 41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO43346 ROYAL LLOYDS OF TX

198517221 ROYAL SPECIAL RISKS INS CO 24589 AMERICAN & FOREIGN INS CO24600 GLOBE IND CO 24678 ROYAL IND CO24694 SAFEGUARD INS CO 26980 ROYAL INS CO OF AMER36749 ROYAL INS CO OF PUERTO RICO 41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO43346 ROYAL LLOYDS OF TX

163 Group Name:Group Code: SAFECO INS GRP2007

11070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11215 SAFECO INS CO OF IN19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

200611070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11215 SAFECO INS CO OF IN19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

200511070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11215 SAFECO INS CO OF IN19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

200011070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11071 SAFECO INS CO OF OR11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO 11215 SAFECO INSURANCE COMPANY OF PA19690 AMERICAN ECONOMY INS CO 19704 AMERICAN STATES INS CO19712 AMERICAN STATES INS CO OF TX 24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER 24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO 26700 INSURANCE CO OF IL31933 AMERICAN STATES LLOYDS INS CO 37214 AMERICAN STATES PREFERRED INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners288

Page 297: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

163 Group Name:Group Code: SAFECO INS GRP2000

39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL1995

11070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER 24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER 24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

199011070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER 24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER 24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

198511070 SAFECO LLOYDS INS CO 11100 SAFECO SURPLUS LINES INS CO24724 FIRST NATL INS CO OF AMER 24732 GENERAL INS CO OF AMER24740 SAFECO INS CO OF AMER 24759 SAFECO NATL INS CO39012 SAFECO INS CO OF IL

164 Group Name:Group Code: ST PAUL GRP2000

10173 US F&G INS CO OF WISC 10182 USF&G SPECIALTY INS CO10213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10357 USF&G FAMILY INS CO10358 US F&G BUSINESS INS CO 10620 USF&G INS CO OF MS10644 VICTORIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INSURANCE COMPANY10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROPERTY INS CO 12246 AMERICAN CONTINENTAL INS CO19224 NORTHBROOK PROP & CAS INS CO 22535 SEABOARD SURETY CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24783 ST PAUL INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO24805 ST PAUL INS CO OF IL 25879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO 36455 NORTHBROOK IND CO36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO41521 ST PAUL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 41572 ST PAUL INS CO OF ND41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO 41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO41831 ST PAUL IND 44440 DISCOVER REIN CO

199522535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24783 ST PAUL INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO24805 ST PAUL INS CO OF IL 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO33553 NML INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO38814 ST PAUL LLOYDS 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41521 ST PAUL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO41572 ST PAUL INS CO OF ND 41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO 41831 ST PAUL IND

199022535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24783 ST PAUL INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO24805 ST PAUL INS CO OF IL 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO33553 NML INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO38814 ST PAUL LLOYDS 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41521 ST PAUL PROP & CAS INS CO41572 ST PAUL INS CO OF ND 41750 RAMSEY INS CO41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO 41831 ST PAUL IND

198522535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24783 ST PAUL INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO24805 ST PAUL INS CO OF IL 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners289

Page 298: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

164 Group Name:Group Code: ST PAUL GRP1985

33553 NML INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO38814 ST PAUL LLOYDS 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41521 ST PAUL PROP & CAS INS CO41572 ST PAUL INS CO OF ND 41750 RAMSEY INS CO41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO 41831 ST PAUL IND

165 Group Name:Group Code: BALBOA INS GRP (THE)1995

24813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO

199024813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO

198524813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO

167 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED EQUITABLE GRP2009

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO2007

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO2006

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO2005

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO2000

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO1995

10031 AMERICAN HEARTLAND INS CO 24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO1990

24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO 35734 UNITED EQUITABLE CAS CO1985

24910 UNITED EQUITABLE INS CO 35734 UNITED EQUITABLE CAS CO168 Group Name:Group Code: SEIBELS BRUCE GRP

200924937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMER INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200824937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMER INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200724937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMER INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200624937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200524937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

200024937 CATAWBA INS CO 24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO 32972 UNIVERSAL INS CO

199511665 CITIZENS INS CO INC 24937 CATAWBA INS CO24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO 24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO

199011665 CITIZENS INS CO INC 24937 CATAWBA INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners290

Page 299: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

168 Group Name:Group Code: SEIBELS BRUCE GRP1990

24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO 24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO1985

11665 CITIZENS INS CO INC 24937 CATAWBA INS CO24945 CONSOLIDATED AMERICAN INS CO 24953 SOUTH CAROLINA INS CO

169 Group Name:Group Code: SENTRY INS GRP2009

13137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP21164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INS CO23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO 23442 PATRIOT GEN INS CO24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO 26441 DAIRYLAND CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX28460 SENTRY CAS CO 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

200813137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP21164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INS CO23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO 23442 PATRIOT GEN INS CO24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO 26441 DAIRYLAND CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX28460 SENTRY CAS CO 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

200713137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP21164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INS CO23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO 23442 PATRIOT GEN INS CO24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO 26441 DAIRYLAND CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX28460 SENTRY CAS CO 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

200613137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP21164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INS CO23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO 23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO 26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX28460 SENTRY CAS CO 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

200513137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP21164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INS CO23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO 23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO 26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX28460 SENTRY CAS CO 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

200021164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 21180 SENTRY SELECT INSURANCE COMPANY21199 ROCK RIVER INS CO 23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO 24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX 28460 SENTRY CASULATY COMPANY43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

199521164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO 24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX 43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

199021164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO 24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX 40207 SENTRY SYNDICATE INC43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

198521164 DAIRYLAND INS CO 23434 MIDDLESEX INS CO23442 PATRIOT GENERAL INS CO 24988 SENTRY INS A MUT CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners291

Page 300: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

169 Group Name:Group Code: SENTRY INS GRP1985

26441 DAIRYLAND COUNTY MUT INS CO OF TX 36803 SENTRY INS OF IL INC36811 SENTRY INS OF MI INC 40207 SENTRY SYNDICATE INC40215 SENTRY SYNDICATE / IL INC 41173 SENTRY REINS CO43370 SENTRY LLOYDS OF TX

171 Group Name:Group Code: GERMANIA INS GRP2009

11521 GERMANIA SELECT INS CO 12598 TEXAS HERITAGE INS CO19470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INS CO

200811521 GERMANIA SELECT INS CO 12598 TEXAS HERITAGE INS CO19470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INS CO

200711521 GERMANIA SELECT INS CO 12598 TEXAS HERITAGE INS CO19470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INS CO

200611521 GERMANIA SELECT INS CO 12598 TEXAS HERITAGE INS CO19470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INS CO

200511521 GERMANIA SELECT INS CO 19470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC 36854 GERMANIA INS CO

200019470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INS CO

199519470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 29610 GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC36854 GERMANIA INSURANCE CO

199019470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 36854 GERMANIA INSURANCE CO

198519470 GERMANIA FIRE & CAS CO 36854 GERMANIA INSURANCE CO

173 Group Name:Group Code: DEALERS ASSUR GRP1995

16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO1990

16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO1985

16705 DEALERS ASSUR CO175 Group Name:Group Code: STATE AUTO MUT GRP

200910502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUT INS CO 11017 STATE AUTO INS CO OF OH11284 BEACON LLOYDS INS CO 11502 STATE AUTO FL INS CO12311 BLOOMINGTON COMPENSATION INS CO 13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO14923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO20028 BEACON NATL INS CO 23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO 25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO28053 ROCKHILL INS CO 30945 PLAZA INS CO31755 STATE AUTO INS CO OF WI 32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO41653 MILBANK INS CO 45934 AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO

200810502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUT INS CO 11017 STATE AUTO INS CO OF OH11284 BEACON LLOYDS INS CO 11502 STATE AUTO FL INS CO13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO 14923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 20028 BEACON NATL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners292

Page 301: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

175 Group Name:Group Code: STATE AUTO MUT GRP2008

23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO 25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO 31755 STATE AUTO INS CO OF WI32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO 41653 MILBANK INS CO

200710502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUT INS CO 11017 STATE AUTO INS CO OF OH11284 BEACON LLOYDS INS CO 11502 STATE AUTO FL INS CO13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO 14923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 20028 BEACON NATL INS CO23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO 25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI31755 STATE AUTO INS CO OF WI 32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO41653 MILBANK INS CO 43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

200610502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUT INS CO 11017 STATE AUTO INS CO OF OH11502 STATE AUTO FL INS CO 13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO 25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO31755 STATE AUTO INS CO OF WI 41653 MILBANK INS CO

200510502 MERIDIAN CITIZENS MUT INS CO 11017 STATE AUTO INS CO OF OH11502 STATE AUTO FL INS CO 13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 23353 MERIDIAN SECURITY INS CO25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO 25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO31755 STATE AUTO INS CO OF WI 41653 MILBANK INS CO

200011017 STATE AUTO INS CO 13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO19530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO 31755 MIDWEST SECURITY INS CO31976 MID-PLAINS INS CO 41653 MILBANK INS CO

199519530 STATE AUTO NATL INS CO 25127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO 41653 MILBANK INS CO

199025127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO 25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO41653 MILBANK INS CO

198525127 STATE AUTO PROP & CAS INS CO 25135 STATE AUTOMOBILE MUT INS CO41653 MILBANK INS CO

176 Group Name:Group Code: STATE FARM GRP2009

10739 STATE FARM FL INS CO 12251 STATE FARM GUAR INS CO25143 STATE FARM FIRE & CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GEN INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

200810739 STATE FARM FLORIDA INS CO 12251 STATE FARM GUARANTY INS CO25143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

200710739 STATE FARM FLORIDA INS CO 12251 STATE FARM GUARANTY INS CO25143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

200610739 STATE FARM FLORIDA INS CO 12251 STATE FARM GUARANTY INS CO25143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners293

Page 302: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

176 Group Name:Group Code: STATE FARM GRP2006

43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO2005

10739 STATE FARM FLORIDA INS CO 12251 STATE FARM GUARANTY INS CO25143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

200010739 STATE FARM FLORIDA INS CO 25143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO 25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX 43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS43796 STATE FARM IND CO

199525143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

199025143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS 43796 STATE FARM IND CO

198525143 STATE FARM FIRE AND CAS CO 25151 STATE FARM GENERAL INS CO25178 STATE FARM MUT AUTO INS CO 26816 STATE FARM CTY MUT INS CO OF TX43419 STATE FARM LLOYDS

177 Group Name:Group Code: STATESMAN GRP1990

25194 DIVERSIFIED INSURERS CO 25259 STATE AUTO INS ASSOC1985

25194 DIVERSIFIED INSURERS CO 25259 STATE AUTO INS ASSOC178 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONWIDE FUND GRP

200914249 FOUNDERS INS CO 18180 FOUNDERS INS CO OF MI

200814249 FOUNDERS INS CO 18180 FOUNDERS INS CO OF MI

200714249 FOUNDERS INS CO 18180 FOUNDERS INS CO OF MI

200614249 FOUNDERS INS CO 18180 FOUNDERS INS CO OF MI

200514249 FOUNDERS INS CO 18180 FOUNDERS INS CO OF MI

200014249 FOUNDERS INS CO

199514249 FOUNDERS INS CO

199014249 FOUNDERS INS CO

198514249 FOUNDERS INS CO

179 Group Name:Group Code: STEEN GRP1985

25283 GREAT SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS INS CO181 Group Name:Group Code: SWISS RE GRP

200910818 FACILITY INS CORP 20107 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO NJ25038 NORTH AMER CAPACITY INS CO 25364 SWISS REINS AMER CORP25422 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO 29700 NORTH AMER ELITE INS CO29874 NORTH AMER SPECIALTY INS CO 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners294

Page 303: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

181 Group Name:Group Code: SWISS RE GRP2009

34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP 39845 WESTPORT INS CORP2008

10818 FACILITY INS CORP 20107 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO NJ25038 NORTH AMER CAPACITY INS CO 25364 SWISS REIN AMERICA CORP25422 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO 29700 NORTH AMER ELITE INS CO29874 NORTH AMER SPECIALTY INS CO 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP 39845 WESTPORT INS CORP

200710818 FACILITY INS CORP 20107 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO NJ25038 NORTH AMER CAPACITY INS CO 25364 SWISS REIN AMERICA CORP25422 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO 29700 NORTH AMER ELITE INS CO29874 NORTH AMER SPECIALTY INS CO 32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO34207 WESTPORT INS CORP 34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP

200610818 FACILITY INS CORP 11555 EMPLOYERS DIRECT INS CO20107 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO NJ 21318 COREGIS INS CO22969 GE REINS CORP 25038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO25364 SWISS REIN AMERICA CORP 25422 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO29700 NORTH AMERICAN ELITE INS CO 29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 34207 WESTPORT INS CORP34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP 39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP

200510818 FACILITY INS CORP 11555 EMPLOYERS DIRECT INS CO20107 ALTRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO NJ 25038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO25364 SWISS REIN AMERICA CORP 25422 ATRADIUS TRADE CREDIT INS CO29700 NORTH AMERICAN ELITE INS CO 29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 38830 FORT WAYNE HLTH & CAS INS CO

200010006 PARTNERRE INS CO OF NY 10690 NEWMARKET UNDERWRITERS INS CO10818 FACILITY INS CORP 10971 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS LLOYDS INS CO TX18619 UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE COMPANY 19489 COMMERCIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO22314 UNDERWRITERS REIN CO 25038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO25364 SWISS REINSURANCE AMERICA CORP 25422 NCM AMERICAS INC29700 NORTH AMERICAN ELITE INS CO 29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO32778 WASHINGTON INTL INS CO 38636 PARTNER REINSURANCE CO OF THE US

199525038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO 25364 SWISS REINSURANCE AMERICA CORP29700 WESTERN ATLANTIC REINSURANCE CORP 29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO

199025038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO 25364 NORTH AMERICAN REINSURANCE CORP25372 SWISS REINS CO US BR 29700 WESTERN ATLANTIC REINSURANCE CORP29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO

198525038 NORTH AMERICAN CAPACITY INS CO 25364 NORTH AMERICAN REINSURANCE CORP25372 SWISS REINS CO US BR 29874 NORTH AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO

182 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN PIONEER GRP1990

42706 AMERICAN PIONEER CASUALTY INS CO1985

42706 AMERICAN PIONEER CASUALTY INS CO183 Group Name:Group Code: CITIZENS SECURITY GRP

199510502 CITIZENS SECURITY MUTUAL INS CO 26654 CITIZENS SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY41599 INSURANCE CO OF OH

199010502 CITIZENS SECURITY MUTUAL INS CO 26654 CITIZENS SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners295

Page 304: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

183 Group Name:Group Code: CITIZENS SECURITY GRP1990

41599 INSURANCE CO OF OH1985

10502 CITIZENS SECURITY MUTUAL INS CO 26654 CITIZENS SECURITY INSURANCE COMPANY41599 INSURANCE CO OF OH

184 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL INS GRP2009

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO2008

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO2007

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO2006

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO2005

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO2000

32522 MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO OF NC1995

32522 MEDICAL MUTUAL INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO OF NC1990

32522 MEDICAL MUTUAL INS CO OF NC 33090 MEDICAL SECURITY INS CO OF NC1985

32522 MEDICAL MUTUAL INS CO OF NC185 Group Name:Group Code: TRANSAMERICA GRP

199528100 ARCADIA GENERAL INS CO

199028100 ARCADIA GENERAL INS CO

187 Group Name:Group Code: CENTURY INS GRP2000

33642 CENTURY PROP & CAS INS CO1995

33642 CENTURY PROP & CAS INS CO1990

33642 CENTURY PROP & CAS INS CO188 Group Name:Group Code: SAFETY GRP

200912808 SAFETY PROP & CAS INS CO 33618 SAFETY IND INS CO39454 SAFETY INS CO

200812808 SAFETY PROP & CAS INS CO 33618 SAFETY IND INS CO39454 SAFETY INS CO

200712808 SAFETY PROP & CAS INS CO 33618 SAFETY IND INS CO39454 SAFETY INS CO

200633618 SAFETY IND INS CO 39454 SAFETY INS CO

200533618 SAFETY IND INS CO 39454 SAFETY INS CO

200033618 SAFETY IND INS CO 39454 SAFETY INS CO

199533618 SAFETY INDEMNITY INS CO 39454 SAFETY INS CO

199033618 SAFETY INDEMNITY INS CO 39454 SAFETY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners296

Page 305: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

188 Group Name:Group Code: SAFETY GRP1985

39454 SAFETY INS CO191 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST AMERICAN COS GRP

199511150 FIRST AMER INS CO

199011150 FIRST AMER INS CO

198511150 FIRST AMER INS CO

193 Group Name:Group Code: UNION INS GRP2000

25828 AMERICAN UNION INS CO1995

10226 UNION AUTOMOBILE INDEMNITY CO 25801 PRAIRIE STATE FARMERS INS COMPANY25828 UNION AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY

199025801 PRAIRIE STATE FARMERS INS COMPANY 25828 UNION AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY

198525801 PRAIRIE STATE FARMERS INS COMPANY 25828 UNION AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY

194 Group Name:Group Code: ASSURED GUAR GRP2009

10021 ASSURED GUAR MORTGAGE INS CO 10843 FSA INS CO18287 ASSURED GUAR MUNICIPAL CORP 30180 ASSURED GUAR CORP

200810843 FSA INS CO 18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC

200710843 FSA INS CO 18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC

200610843 FSA INS CO 18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC

200510843 FSA INS CO 18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC

200010350 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR OF OK INC 10843 FSA INS CO18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC

199510350 MGIC ASSURANCE CORP 18287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC22896 CAPITAL GUARANTY INS CO 25439 COMMERCIAL REIN CO40517 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR INTRNTL INC

199018287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC 22896 CAPITAL GUARANTY INS CO40517 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR INTRNTL INC

198518287 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASSUR INC 22896 CAPITAL GUARANTY INS CO40517 FINANCIAL SECURITY ASR INTRNTL INC

195 Group Name:Group Code: UNION MUTUAL FIRE INS GRP2009

25852 NEW ENGLAND GUAR INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

200825852 NEW ENGLAND GUAR INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

200725852 NEW ENGLAND GUAR INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

200625852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners297

Page 306: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

195 Group Name:Group Code: UNION MUTUAL FIRE INS GRP2005

25852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

200025852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO43320 EASTERN MUT INS CO

199525852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO

199025852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO

198525852 NEW ENGLAND GUARANTY INS CO INC 25860 UNION MUT FIRE INS CO

196 Group Name:Group Code: US FIDELITY & GUARANTY GRP1995

10040 INNER HARBOR RE INC 10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO10173 US F&G INS CO OF WISC 10182 USF&G SPECIALTY INS CO10213 US F&G INS CO OF ILLINOIS 10620 USF&G INS CO OF MS25879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS 35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO 44440 DISCOVER REIN CO

199025879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS 35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO 44440 DISCOVER REIN CO

198525879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS 35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

199 Group Name:Group Code: UNIVERSAL SURETY GRP2009

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO2008

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO2007

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO2006

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO2005

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO2000

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO1995

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO1990

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO1985

23264 INLAND INS CO 25933 UNIVERSAL SURETY CO200 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP

200910078 USAA CNTY MUT INS CO 11120 USAA TX LLOYDS CO12578 CATASTROPHE REINS CO 18600 USAA GEN IND CO21253 GARRISON PROP & CAS INS CO 25941 USAA25968 USAA CAS INS CO

200810078 USAA COUNTY MUT INS CO 11120 USAA TEXAS LLOYDS CO12578 CATASTROPHE REINS CO 18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO21253 GARRISON PROP & CAS INS CO 25941 USAA25968 USAA CAS INS CO

200710078 USAA COUNTY MUT INS CO 11120 USAA TEXAS LLOYDS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners298

Page 307: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

200 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED SERV AUTOMOBILE ASSN GRP2007

12578 CATASTROPHE REINS CO 18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO21253 GARRISON PROP & CAS INS CO 25941 USAA25968 USAA CAS INS CO

200610078 USAA COUNTY MUT INS CO 11120 USAA TEXAS LLOYDS CO12578 CATASTROPHE REINS CO 18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO21253 GARRISON PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO 25941 USAA25968 USAA CAS INS CO

200510078 USAA COUNTY MUT INS CO 11120 USAA TEXAS LLOYDS CO18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO 21253 GARRISON PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO25941 UNITED SERVICES AUTO ASSOC 25968 USAA CAS INS CO

200010078 USAA COUNTY MUTUAL INSURANCE CO 18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO21253 GARRISON PROPERTY & CASULTY ASSN 25941 UNITED SERVICES AUTO ASSOC25968 USAA CAS INS CO

199510078 AMERISTAR COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO 18600 USAA GENERAL IND CO25941 UNITED SERVICES AUTO ASSOC 25968 USAA CAS INS CO

199018600 USAA GENERAL IND CO 25941 UNITED SERVICES AUTO ASSOC25968 USAA CAS INS CO

198518600 USAA GENERAL IND CO 25941 UNITED SERVICES AUTO ASSOC25968 USAA CAS INS CO

201 Group Name:Group Code: UTICA GRP2009

10687 UTICA NATL ASSUR CO 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

200810687 UTICA NATL ASSUR CO 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

200710687 UTICA NATL ASSUR CO 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

200610687 UTICA NATL ASSUR CO 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

200510687 UTICA NATL ASSUR CO 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

200010687 UTICA NATIONAL ASSURANCE COMPANY 10990 UTICA LLOYDS OF TX12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA SPECIALTY RISK INS CO43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners299

Page 308: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

201 Group Name:Group Code: UTICA GRP1995

12475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA LLOYDS OF TEXAS43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

199012475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 25976 UTICA MUT INS CO25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO 43451 UTICA LLOYDS OF TEXAS43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

198512475 REPUBLIC-FRANKLIN INS CO 16730 UTICA NATL INS CO OF DE25976 UTICA MUT INS CO 25984 GRAPHIC ARTS MUT INS CO43451 UTICA LLOYDS OF TEXAS 43478 UTICA NATL INS CO OF TX

202 Group Name:Group Code: COMMONWEALTH GEN INS GRP1990

27910 COMMONWEALTH GENERAL INS CO203 Group Name:Group Code: VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU GRP

200910086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

200810086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

200710086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

200610086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

200510086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

200010086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

199510086 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU TOWN & CNTRY 26026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

199026026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS 26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

198526026 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU FIRE & CAS INS 26034 VIRGINIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO

204 Group Name:Group Code: TITAN GRP OF CO1995

13242 TITAN IND CO 23566 MILLERS NAT INS CO36269 TITAN INS CO

199013242 TITAN IND CO 23566 MILLERS NAT INS CO34061 TITAN INS CO 36269 TITAN INS CO

198513242 TITAN IND CO 23566 MILLERS NAT INS CO

205 Group Name:Group Code: DE SMET INS GRP2009

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD2008

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD2007

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners300

Page 309: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

205 Group Name:Group Code: DE SMET INS GRP2006

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD2005

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD2000

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD1995

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD1990

31445 DE SMET FARM MUT INS CO OF SD 38539 DE SMET INS CO OF SD206 Group Name:Group Code: BENEFICIAL INS GRP

199525011 WESCO INS CO 28657 SERVICE GENERAL INS CO

199025011 WESCO INS CO 28657 SERVICE GENERAL INS CO

198525011 WESCO INS CO 28657 SERVICE GENERAL INS CO

207 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN RESERVE2009

10271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

200810271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

200710271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

200610271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

200510271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

200010271 SONNENBERG MUT INS ASSOC 26123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

199526123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO 26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

199026123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO 26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

198526123 LIGHTNING ROD MUT INS CO 26131 WESTERN RESERVE MUT CAS CO

208 Group Name:Group Code: WINDSOR MOUNT JOY1995

26158 EASTERN SHORE OF VA FIRE INS CO INC 26166 WINDSOR MOUNT JOY MUT INS CO1990

26158 EASTERN SHORE OF VA FIRE INS CO INC 26166 WINDSOR MOUNT JOY MUT INS CO1985

26158 EASTERN SHORE OF VA FIRE INS CO INC 26166 WINDSOR MOUNT JOY MUT INS CO210 Group Name:Group Code: TITUS GRP

200926190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

200826190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners301

Page 310: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

210 Group Name:Group Code: TITUS GRP2007

26190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

200626190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

200526190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

200026190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

199526190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

199026190 CONSOLIDATED INS ASSOC 26204 CONSOLIDATED LLOYDS29246 CONSUMERS CNTY MUT INS CO

212 Group Name:Group Code: ZURICH INS GRP2009

10184 AIG AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10245 21ST CENTURY INS CO OF THE SW10315 CIVIC PROP & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10710 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF NJ10805 AMERICAN PACIFIC INS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11034 BRISTOL W CAS INS CO11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROP & CAS INS CO12774 BRISTOL W PREFERRED INS CO 12963 21ST CENTURY INS CO16535 ZURICH AMER INS CO 19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY 19658 BRISTOL W INS CO20796 AIG PREMIER INS CO 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID 21628 FARMERS INS CO INC21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR 21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA21652 FARMERS INS EXCH 21660 FIRE INS EXCH21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO 21687 MID CENTURY INS CO21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO 21709 TRUCK INS EXCH22225 AIG PREFERRED INS CO 22527 HOME INS CO23795 AMERICAN INTL PACIFIC INS 23833 NEW HAMPSHIRE IND CO INC24317 ZC SPECIALTY INS CO 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO25089 COAST NATL INS CO 25232 AIG ADVANTAGE INS CO26247 AMERICAN GUAR & LIAB INS 26387 STEADFAST INS CO27855 ZURICH AMER INS CO OF IL 28487 AIG HI INS CO INC28673 MID CENTURY INS CO OF TX 29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO32220 AMERICAN INTL INS CO 33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO34347 COLONIAL AMER CAS & SURETY CO 34649 CENTRE INS CO34789 AIG CENTENNIAL INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO36587 AIG NATL INS CO INC 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO43761 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF CA 43974 AIG IND INS CO44245 AMERICAN INTL INS CO OF DE

200810315 CIVIC PROP & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11034 BRISTOL W CAS INS CO11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROP & CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners302

Page 311: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

212 Group Name:Group Code: ZURICH INS GRP2008

12774 BRISTOL W PREFERRED INS CO 16535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER 19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19364 NATIONAL STANDARD INS CO 19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY19658 BRISTOL W INS CO 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID 21628 FARMERS INS CO INC21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR 21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA21652 FARMERS INS EXCH 21660 FIRE INS EXCH21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO 21687 MID CENTURY INS CO21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO 21709 TRUCK INS EXCH22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO 22527 HOME INS CO24317 ZC SPECIALTY INS CO 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO25089 COAST NATL INS CO 26247 AMERICAN GUAR & LIAB INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL28673 MID CENTURY INS CO OF TX 29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO 34347 COLONIAL AMER CAS & SURETY CO34649 CENTRE INS CO 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

200710315 CIVIC PROP & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11034 BRISTOL W CAS INS CO11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROP & CAS INS CO12774 BRISTOL W PREFERRED INS CO 16535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER 19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19364 NATIONAL STANDARD INS CO 19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY19658 BRISTOL W INS CO 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID 21628 FARMERS INS CO INC21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR 21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA21652 FARMERS INS EXCH 21660 FIRE INS EXCH21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO 21687 MID CENTURY INS CO21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO 21709 TRUCK INS EXCH22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO 22527 HOME INS CO24317 ZC SPECIALTY INS CO 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO25089 COAST NATL INS CO 26247 AMERICAN GUAR & LIAB INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL28673 MID CENTURY INS CO OF TX 29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO 34347 COLONIAL AMER CAS & SURETY CO34649 CENTRE INS CO 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

200610315 CIVIC PROPERTY & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 16535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER 19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO 19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO 21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ 21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners303

Page 312: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

212 Group Name:Group Code: ZURICH INS GRP2006

21628 FARMERS INS CO INC 21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA 21652 FARMERS INS EXCH21660 FIRE INS EXCH 21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO 21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO21709 TRUCK INS EXCH 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22527 HOME INS CO 24317 ZC SPECIALTY INS CO24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO 26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL 28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO 34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO34649 CENTRE INS CO 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

200510315 CIVIC PROPERTY & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 16535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER 19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO 19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO 21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ 21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID21628 FARMERS INS CO INC 21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA 21652 FARMERS INS EXCH21660 FIRE INS EXCH 21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO 21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO21709 TRUCK INS EXCH 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22527 HOME INS CO 24317 ZC SPECIALTY INS CO24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO 26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL 28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO 34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO34649 CENTRE INS CO 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

200010315 CIVIC PROPERTY & CAS CO 10317 NEIGHBORHOOD SPIRIT PROP & CAS CO10318 EXACT PROP & CAS CO INC 10806 FARMERS NEW CENTURY INS CO10873 FARMERS REINS CO 11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 16535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER 19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO19348 MARYLAND INS CO 19356 MARYLAND CAS CO19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO 19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO 21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO21598 FARMERS INS CO OF AZ 21601 FARMERS INS CO OF ID21628 FARMERS INS CO INC 21636 FARMERS INS CO OF OR21644 FARMERS INS CO OF WA 21652 FARMERS INS EXCH21660 FIRE INS EXCH 21679 ILLINOIS FARMERS INS CO21687 MID-CENTURY INS CO 21695 TEXAS FARMERS INS CO21709 TRUCK INS EXCH 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22527 HOME INS CO 22730 Z C INSURANCE COMPANY24317 ZC SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 24392 FARMERS TX CNTY MUT INS CO24996 CEDAR HILLS ASSURANCE COMPANY 26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners304

Page 313: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

212 Group Name:Group Code: ZURICH INS GRP2000

27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL 28519 MOUNTBATTEN SURETY COMPNAY INC28673 MID-CENTURY INS CO OF TX 29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO 34649 BUSINESS INSURANCE COMPANY36242 MARYLAND LLOYDS 36889 FARMERS INS OF COLUMBUS INC38032 US INTL REINS CO 39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD 40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX INS 41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO 41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

199516535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO 19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO 19348 MARYLAND INS CO19356 MARYLAND CAS CO 19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22527 HOME INS CO 22730 Z C INSURANCE COMPANY24996 CEDAR HILLS ASSURANCE COMPANY 25422 MARYLAND NETHERLANDS CREDIT INS CO26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS 26387 STEADFAST INS CO26611 VALIANT INS CO 27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL29432 HOME INS CO OF IL(NH) 33596 CENTRE REINSURANCE CO OF NEW YORK34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO 36242 MARYLAND LLOYDS38032 US INTL REINS CO 39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD 40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO40347 ZURICH AMERICAN LLOYDS 40363 HOME INS CO OF WI40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX 41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO

199016535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO 19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO 19348 MARYLAND INS CO19356 MARYLAND CAS CO 19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22500 CITY INS CO 22519 HOME IND CO22527 HOME INS CO 22730 RE CAPITAL REIN CORP24996 CENTRAL LLOYDS 26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL 28177 HOME INS CO OF IN29432 HOME INS CO OF IL 33596 CENTRE REINSURANCE CO LTD34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO 36242 MARYLAND LLOYDS38032 US INTL REINS CO 39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD 40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO40347 ZURICH AMERICAN LLOYDS 40363 HOME INS CO OF WI40614 HOME INS CO OF TX 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO

198516535 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO 19305 ASSURANCE CO OF AMER19321 MAINE BONDING & CAS CO 19348 MARYLAND INS CO19356 MARYLAND CAS CO 19364 NATIONAL STD INS CO19372 NORTHERN INS CO OF NY 21326 EMPIRE FIRE & MARINE INS CO21334 EMPIRE IND INS CO 22144 CONSTELLATION REIN CO22500 CITY INS CO 22519 HOME IND CO22527 HOME INS CO 22730 RE CAPITAL REIN CORP24996 CENTRAL LLOYDS 26247 AMERICAN GUARANTEE & LIABILITY INS26387 STEADFAST INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO27855 ZURICH AMERICAN INS CO OF IL 28177 HOME INS CO OF IN29432 HOME INS CO OF IL 34347 COLONIAL AMERICAN CAS & SURETY CO36242 MARYLAND LLOYDS 38032 US INTL REINS CO39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC 39306 FIDELITY & DEPOSIT CO OF MD40142 AMERICAN ZURICH INS CO 40347 ZURICH AMERICAN LLOYDS40614 HOME INS CO OF TX 40843 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS OF TX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners305

Page 314: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

212 Group Name:Group Code: ZURICH INS GRP1985

41181 UNIVERSAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO213 Group Name:Group Code: ERIE INS GRP

200916233 ERIE INS CO OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

200816233 ERIE INS CO OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

200716233 ERIE INS CO OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

200616233 ERIE INS CO OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

200516233 ERIE INS CO OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

200016233 ERIE INSURANCE COMAPNY OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

199516233 ERIE INSURANCE COMAPNY OF NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH 26830 ERIE INS PROP & CAS CO35585 FLAGSHIP CITY INS CO

199016233 CO-OPERATIVE INS CO OF WESTERN NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH

198516233 CO-OPERATIVE INS CO OF WESTERN NY 26263 ERIE INS CO26271 ERIE INS EXCH

214 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIANCE INS GRP2009

19186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

200819186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

200719186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

200619186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

200519186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

200019186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

199519186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners306

Page 315: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

214 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIANCE INS GRP1995

33154 ALLIANCE IND CO1990

19186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

198519186 ALLIANCE INS CO INC 19194 FARMERS ALLIANCE MUT INS CO33154 ALLIANCE IND CO

215 Group Name:Group Code: UNITRIN GRP2009

10226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO10811 RESPONSE IND CO 10881 UNITRIN ADVANTAGE INS CO10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO 10915 UNITRIN DIRECT PROP & CAS CO10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA 11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO16063 UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO 20133 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INS C25909 UNITRIN PREFERRED INS CO 26050 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE INS CO26085 WARNER INS CO 29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO29351 UNITRIN CNTY MUT INS CO 31178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO31968 MERASTAR INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO37524 CHARTER IND CO 38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO 40703 UNITRIN SAFEGUARD INS CO43044 RESPONSE INS CO

200810226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO10881 UNITRIN ADVANTAGE INS CO 10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO10915 UNITRIN DIRECT PROPERTY & CAS CO 11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO16063 UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO 25909 UNITRIN PREFERRED INS CO29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 29351 UNITRIN COUNTY MUT INS CO31178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO 31968 MERASTAR INS CO36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO 37524 CHARTER IND CO38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO 40703 UNITRIN SAFEGUARD INS CO

200710226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO10881 UNITRIN ADVANTAGE INS CO 10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO10915 UNITRIN DIRECT PROPERTY & CAS CO 11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS 16063 UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO19852 FINANCIAL IND CO 19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO 25909 UNITRIN PREFERRED INS CO26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO 26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 29351 UNITRIN COUNTY MUT INS CO31968 MERASTAR INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO37524 CHARTER IND CO 38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO

200610226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO10881 UNITRIN ADVANTAGE INS CO 10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO10915 UNITRIN DIRECT PROPERTY & CAS CO 11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO14591 MILWAUKEE INS CO 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS16063 UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO25909 UNITRIN PREFERRED INS CO 26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO 29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO29351 UNITRIN COUNTY MUT INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners307

Page 316: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

215 Group Name:Group Code: UNITRIN GRP2006

37524 CHARTER IND CO 38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO

200510226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO10881 UNITRIN ADVANTAGE INS CO 10914 KEMPER INDEPENDENCE INS CO10915 UNITRIN DIRECT PROPERTY & CAS CO 11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO14591 MILWAUKEE INS CO 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS16063 UNITRIN AUTO & HOME INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO25909 UNITRIN PREFERRED INS CO 26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO 29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO29351 UNITRIN COUNTY MUT INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO37524 CHARTER IND CO 38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO

200010226 UNITRIN DIRECT INS CO 10698 VALLEY PROP & CAS INS CO11142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER 12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO14133 VALLEY INS CO 14591 MILWAUKEE MUT INS CO15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS 19007 CLAYTON REIN LTD19852 FINANCIAL IND CO 19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO 26409 GEORGIA INS CO26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO 26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO29351 CHARTER COUNTY MUT INS CO 37524 CHARTER IND CO38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO 40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO

199511142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER 12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO14591 MILWAUKEE MUT INS CO 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS17353 LEHIGH VALLEY INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO26662 MILWAUKEE GUARDIAN INS INC 26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO 40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO43427 UNITED LLOYDS INS CO

199011142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER 12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO14591 MILWAUKEE MUT INS CO 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS17353 LEHIGH VALLEY INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO26662 MILWAUKEE GUARDIAN INS INC 26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO 40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO43427 UNITED LLOYDS INS CO

198511142 UNITED CAS INS CO OF AMER 12998 UNION NATL FIRE INS CO14591 MILWAUKEE MUT INS CO 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS17353 LEHIGH VALLEY INS CO 19852 FINANCIAL IND CO19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 19887 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO26662 MILWAUKEE GUARDIAN INS INC 26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO38156 ALPHA PROP & CAS INS CO 40703 MILWAUKEE SAFEGUARD INS CO43427 UNITED LLOYDS INS CO

217 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL NATL INS CO PR GRP2000

10294 ANGELINA CAS CO 20249 CENTRAL NATL INS CO OF OMAHA20265 PROTECTIVE NATL INS CO OF OMAHA 34363 CENTRAL NAT INS CO OF PR

199510294 ANGELINA CAS CO 20249 CENTRAL NATL INS CO OF OMAHA20265 PROTECTIVE NATL INS CO OF OMAHA 34363 CENTRAL NAT INS CO OF PR

199010294 ANGELINA CAS CO 20249 CENTRAL NATL INS CO OF OMAHA

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners308

Page 317: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

217 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL NATL INS CO PR GRP1990

20265 PROTECTIVE NATL INS CO OF OMAHA 34363 CENTRAL NAT INS CO OF PR1985

10294 ANGELINA CAS CO 20249 CENTRAL NATL INS CO OF OMAHA20265 PROTECTIVE NATL INS CO OF OMAHA 34363 CENTRAL NAT INS CO OF PR

218 Group Name:Group Code: CNA INS GRP2009

10938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC 13188 WESTERN SURETY CO13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

200810938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC 13188 WESTERN SURETY CO13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

200710938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC 13188 WESTERN SURETY CO13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

200610938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC 13188 WESTERN SURETY CO13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO 20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO 24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO 35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC 41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD 42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

200510201 GALWAY INS CO 10938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC13188 WESTERN SURETY CO 13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA 20435 CNA CAS OF CA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO 20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO 20761 BOSTON OLD COLONY INS CO20788 BUCKEYE UNION INS CO 20850 FIREMENS INS CO OF NEWARK NJ20885 KANSAS CITY FIRE & MARINE INS CO 20893 NATIONAL-BEN FRANKLIN INS CO OF IL20923 CONTINENTAL REIN CORP 22152 MAYFLOWER INS CO LTD24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 24333 CONTINENTAL LLOYDS INS CO31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO 34622 GLENS FALLS INS CO35106 NIAGARA FIRE INS CO 35270 FIDELITY & CAS CO OF NY35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 37338 PACIFIC INS CO41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC 41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD 42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners309

Page 318: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

218 Group Name:Group Code: CNA INS GRP2000

10071 CNA REINSURANCE COMPANY LTD 10072 CNA CAS OF IL10201 GALWAY INS CO 10344 RVI AMER INS CO10938 FIRST SECURITY INS OF HI INC 12440 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF PR13188 WESTERN SURETY CO 13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA 20435 CNA CAS OF CA20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO 20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO 20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO 20761 BOSTON OLD COLONY INS CO20788 BUCKEYE UNION INS CO 20850 FIREMENS INS CO OF NEWARK NJ20885 KANSAS CITY FIRE & MARINE INS CO 20893 NATIONAL-BEN FRANKLIN INS CO OF IL20923 CONTINENTAL REIN CORP 22152 MAYFLOWER INS CO LTD24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 24333 CONTINENTAL LLOYDS INS CO31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO 34622 GLENS FALLS INS CO35106 NIAGARA FIRE INS CO 35270 FIDELITY & CAS CO OF NY35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 37338 PACIFIC INS CO38903 CNA LLOYDS OF TX 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

199510071 CNA REINSURANCE COMPANY 10072 CNA CAS OF IL10201 GALWAY INS CO 10344 RVI AMER INS CO12440 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF PR 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20435 CNA CAS OF CA 20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD 20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO20761 BOSTON OLD COLONY INS CO 20788 BUCKEYE UNION INS CO20850 FIREMENS INS CO OF NEWARK NJ 20885 KANSAS CITY FIRE & MARINE INS CO20893 NATIONAL-BEN FRANKLIN INS CO OF IL 20923 CONTINENTAL REIN CORP22152 MAYFLOWER INS CO LTD 24333 CONTINENTAL LLOYDS INS CO31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO 34622 GLENS FALLS INS CO35106 NIAGARA FIRE INS CO 35270 FIDELITY & CAS CO OF NY35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 37338 PACIFIC INS CO38903 CNA LLOYDS OF TX 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

199012440 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF PR 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20435 CNA CAS OF CA 20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD 20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO20761 BOSTON OLD COLONY INS CO 20788 BUCKEYE UNION INS CO20850 FIREMENS INS CO OF NEWARK NJ 20885 KANSAS CITY FIRE & MARINE INS CO20893 NATIONAL-BEN FRANKLIN INS CO OF IL 20923 CONTINENTAL REIN CORP22152 MAYFLOWER INS CO LTD 24333 CONTINENTAL LLOYDS INS CO31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO 34622 GLENS FALLS INS CO35106 NIAGARA FIRE INS CO 35270 FIDELITY & CAS CO OF NY35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO 37338 PACIFIC INS CO38903 CNA LLOYDS OF TX 41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC 41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

198512440 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF PR 20427 AMERICAN CAS CO OF READING PA20435 CNA CAS OF CA 20443 CONTINENTAL CAS CO20478 NATIONAL FIRE INS CO OF HARTFORD 20486 TRANSCONTINENTAL INS CO20494 TRANSPORTATION INS CO 20508 VALLEY FORGE INS CO20761 BOSTON OLD COLONY INS CO 20788 BUCKEYE UNION INS CO20850 FIREMENS INS CO OF NEWARK NJ 20885 KANSAS CITY FIRE & MARINE INS CO20893 NATIONAL-BEN FRANKLIN INS CO OF IL 20923 CONTINENTAL REIN CORP22152 MAYFLOWER INS CO LTD 31127 COLUMBIA CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners310

Page 319: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

218 Group Name:Group Code: CNA INS GRP1985

34622 GLENS FALLS INS CO 35106 NIAGARA FIRE INS CO35270 FIDELITY & CAS CO OF NY 35289 CONTINENTAL INS CO37338 PACIFIC INS CO 38903 CNA LLOYDS OF TX41726 FIRST FIRE & CAS INS OF HI INC 41734 FIRST IND INS OF HI INC41742 FIRST INS CO OF HI LTD 42625 CONTINENTAL INS CO OF NJ

219 Group Name:Group Code: DEERE & CO GRP1995

21180 JOHN DEERE INS CO 21199 ROCK RIVER INS CO28460 TAHOE INS CO

199021180 JOHN DEERE INS CO 21199 ROCK RIVER INS CO28460 TAHOE INS CO

198521180 JOHN DEERE INS CO 21199 ROCK RIVER INS CO28460 TAHOE INS CO

220 Group Name:Group Code: OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU GRP2009

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO2008

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO2007

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO2006

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO2005

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO2000

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO1995

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO1990

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO1985

21563 OKLAHOMA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21571 AG SECURITY INS CO222 Group Name:Group Code: GREATER NY GRP

200910814 GNY CUSTOM INS CO 11024 STRATHMORE INS CO22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

200810814 GNY CUSTOM INS CO 11024 STRATHMORE INS CO22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

200710814 GNY CUSTOM INS CO 11024 STRATHMORE INS CO22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

200610814 GNY CUSTOM INS CO 11024 STRATHMORE INS CO22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

200511024 STRATHMORE INS CO 22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

200011024 STRATHMORE INS CO 22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

199522187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners311

Page 320: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

222 Group Name:Group Code: GREATER NY GRP1990

22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY1985

22187 GREATER NY MUT INS CO 22195 INSURANCE CO OF GREATER NY223 Group Name:Group Code: INDEPENDENT LIFE & ACC

199522608 INDEPENDENT FIRE INS CO 22616 INDEPENDENT FIRE INS CO FL25402 THOMAS JEFFERSON INSURANCE CO 42781 INDEPENDENT PROP & CASUALTY INS CO

224 Group Name:Group Code: INTERNATIONAL SVC1985

22799 FORT WORTH LLOYDS225 Group Name:Group Code: IAT REINS CO GRP

200910349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 13234 WILSHIRE INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC26433 HARCO NATL INS CO 28886 TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC36560 SERVICE INS CO

200810349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 13234 WILSHIRE INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC26433 HARCO NATL INS CO 28886 TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC

200710349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 13234 WILSHIRE INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC26433 HARCO NATL INS CO 28886 TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC

200610349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 13234 WILSHIRE INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC26433 HARCO NATL INS CO 28886 TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC

200510349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 13234 WILSHIRE INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC26433 HARCO NATL INS CO 28886 TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC

200013234 WILSHIRE INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC

199513234 WILSHIRE INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC

199013234 WILSHIRE INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC

198513234 WILSHIRE INS CO 23248 OCCIDENTAL FIRE & CAS CO OF NC

226 Group Name:Group Code: MERCHANTS MUT GRP2009

12775 MERCHANTS NATL INS CO 12901 MERCHANTS PREFERRED INS CO23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO

200812775 MERCHANTS NATL INS CO 12901 MERCHANTS PREFERRED INS CO23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO

200712775 MERCHANTS NATL INS CO 12901 MERCHANTS PREFERRED INS CO23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO

200612775 MERCHANTS NATL INS CO 23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC

200523329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO 23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners312

Page 321: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

226 Group Name:Group Code: MERCHANTS MUT GRP2000

23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO 23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC1995

23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO 23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC1990

23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO 23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC1985

23329 MERCHANTS MUT INS CO 23337 MERCHANTS INS CO OF NH INC227 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL SVC GRP

200023647 MUTUAL SERVICE CAS INS CO 23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO

199523647 MUTUAL SERVICE CAS INS CO 23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO42951 MSI INS CO

199023647 MUTUAL SERVICE CAS INS CO 23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO42951 MSI INS CO

198523647 MUTUAL SERVICE CAS INS CO 23655 MODERN SERVICE INS CO42951 MSI INS CO

228 Group Name:Group Code: WESTFIELD GRP2009

17558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

200817558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

200717558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

200617558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

200517558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO20001 BEACON INS CO OF AMER 24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO24112 WESTFIELD INS CO 24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

200014052 FIRST PATRIOT INSURANCE COMPANY 16853 OLD GUARD FIRE INS CO17558 OLD GUARD INS CO 19992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO20001 BEACON INS CO OF AMER 24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO24112 WESTFIELD INS CO 24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO27421 NEFFSVILLE MUT FIRE INS CO

199519992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO 20001 BEACON INS CO OF AMER24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

199019992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO 20001 BEACON INS CO OF AMER24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO

198519992 AMERICAN SELECT INS CO 20001 BEACON INS CO OF AMER24104 OHIO FARMERS INS CO 24112 WESTFIELD INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners313

Page 322: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

228 Group Name:Group Code: WESTFIELD GRP1985

24120 WESTFIELD NATL INS CO229 Group Name:Group Code: ING AMER INS HOLDING GRP

199511045 EXCELSIOR INS CO 11134 FIDELITY SOUTHERN INS CO12319 PHILADELPHIA REIN CORP 12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE 24198 PEERLESS INS CO42064 ALABAMA FIRST INS CO

199011045 EXCELSIOR INS CO 11134 FIDELITY SOUTHERN INS CO12319 PHILADELPHIA REIN CORP 12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE 24198 PEERLESS INS CO38555 NRG AMERICA SYNDICATE INC 42064 ALABAMA FIRST INS CO

198511045 EXCELSIOR INS CO 11134 FIDELITY SOUTHERN INS CO12319 PHILADELPHIA REIN CORP 12696 AMERICA FIRST INS CO22640 CONSOLIDATED INS CO 22659 INDIANA INS CO24171 NETHERLANDS INS CO THE 24198 PEERLESS INS CO38555 NRG AMERICA SYNDICATE INC 42064 ALABAMA FIRST INS CO

230 Group Name:Group Code: HEALTH PROVIDERS INS GRP1990

21610 HEALTH PROVIDERS INS CO OF VT1985

34401 HEALTH PROVIDERS INS CO232 Group Name:Group Code: US INVESTMENT GRP

199525895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO

199025895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO

198525895 UNITED STATES LIABILITY INS CO 26522 MOUNT VERNON FIRE INS CO35416 US UNDERWRITERS INS CO

233 Group Name:Group Code: CONSECO GRP1990

11789 LINCOLN FIRE & CAS INS CO1985

11789 LINCOLN FIRE & CAS INS CO234 Group Name:Group Code: VERMONT MUT GRP

200914095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

200814095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

200714095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

200614095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

200514095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners314

Page 323: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

234 Group Name:Group Code: VERMONT MUT GRP2000

14095 GRANITE MUT INS CO 25500 CHAMPLAIN CAS CO OF VT25992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC 26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

199525992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC 26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

199025992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC 26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

198525992 NORTHERN SECURITY INS CO INC 26018 VERMONT MUT INS CO

235 Group Name:Group Code: SEABOARD LIFE GRP1995

36781 VASA NORTH ATLANTIC INS CO1990

10626 BROUGHER SYNDICATE INC 36781 VASA NORTH ATLANTIC INS CO1985

10626 BROUGHER SYNDICATE INC 36781 VASA NORTH ATLANTIC INS CO237 Group Name:Group Code: WESTWARD GRP

200024635 WESTWARD INS CO

199524635 WESTWARD INS CO

199024635 WESTWARD INS CO

238 Group Name:Group Code: FOREMOST CORP AMER1995

11185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

199011185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

198511185 FOREMOST INS CO GRAND RAPIDS MI 11800 FOREMOST PROPERTY & CAS INS CO29254 FOREMOST CNTY MUT INS CO 41513 FOREMOST SIGNATURE INS CO41688 FOREMOST LLOYDS OF TX 43699 AMERICAN FEDERATION INS CO

239 Group Name:Group Code: LEUCADIA GRP2000

18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP 21342 ALLCITY INS CO21350 EMPIRE INS CO 24716 CENTURION INS CO26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP

199510184 BAYSIDE CAS INS CO 18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP18740 WISCONSIN MORTGAGE ASSUR CORP 20796 COLONIAL PENN FRANKLIN INS CO21342 ALLCITY INS CO 21350 EMPIRE INS CO22225 BAY COLONY INSURANCE COMPANY 24716 CENTURION INS CO26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP 34789 COLONIAL PENN INS CO43974 COLONIAL PENN MADISON INS CO

199018732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP 18740 WISCONSIN MORTGAGE ASSUR CORP20796 COLONIAL PENN FRANKLIN INS CO 21342 ALLCITY INS CO21350 EMPIRE INS CO 22225 COLONIAL PENN HERITAGE INS CO24716 CENTURION INS CO 26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP34789 COLONIAL PENN INS CO 43974 COLONIAL PENN MADISON INS CO

198518732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP 18740 WISCONSIN MORTGAGE ASSUR CORP20796 COLONIAL PENN FRANKLIN INS CO 21342 ALLCITY INS CO21350 EMPIRE INS CO 22225 COLONIAL PENN HERITAGE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners315

Page 324: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

239 Group Name:Group Code: LEUCADIA GRP1985

24716 CENTURION INS CO 26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP34789 COLONIAL PENN INS CO

240 Group Name:Group Code: DAIMLER CHRYSLER GRP2006

10499 DAIMLERCHRYSLER INS CO 10749 INTREPID INS CO2005

10499 DAIMLERCHRYSLER INS CO 10749 INTREPID INS CO2000

10499 CHRYSLER INS CO 10749 INTREPID INS CO1995

10499 CHRYSLER INS CO1990

10499 CHRYSLER INS CO1985

10499 CHRYSLER INS CO241 Group Name:Group Code: METROPOLITAN GRP

200913092 METLIFE REINS CO OF VT 13938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO 25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO26298 METROPOLITAN PROP & CAS INS CO 34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO 39950 METROPOLITAN GEN INS CO40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

200813092 METLIFE REINS CO OF VT 13938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO 25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO26298 METROPOLITAN PROP & CAS INS CO 34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO 39950 METROPOLITAN GEN INS CO40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

200713938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO 26298 METROPOLITAN PROP & CAS INS CO34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO39950 METROPOLITAN GEN INS CO 40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

200613938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO 26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO39357 METLIFE INS CO OF CT 39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

200513938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO 26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO39357 TRAVELERS INS CO ACCIDENT DEPT 39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO 40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

200013938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX 22926 ECONOMY FIRE & CAS CO25321 METROPOLITAN DRT PROP & CAS INS CO 26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO 38067 ECONOMY PREFERRED INS CO39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO 40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO40649 ECONOMY PREMIER ASSUR CO

199513938 METROPOLITAN LLOYDS INS CO TX 25321 FIRST GENERAL INS CO26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO 40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners316

Page 325: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

241 Group Name:Group Code: METROPOLITAN GRP1990

12467 MARKETFORCE INTL INS CO 25321 FIRST GENERAL INS CO26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO 40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO

198512467 MARKETFORCE INTL INS CO 25321 FIRST GENERAL INS CO26298 METROPOLITAN PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 34339 METROPOLITAN GRP PROP & CAS INS CO39950 METROPOLITAN GENERAL INS CO 40169 METROPOLITAN CAS INS CO

242 Group Name:Group Code: SELECTIVE INS GRP2009

11074 SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ 11867 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

200811074 SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ 11867 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

200711074 SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ 11867 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

200611074 SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ 11867 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

200511074 SELECTIVE AUTO INS CO OF NJ 11867 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INS CO OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

200012572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 SELECTIVE INSURANCE COMPANY OF NY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

199512572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER 13730 EXCHANGE INSURANCE COMPANY19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC 26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

199012211 CHARLESTON INS CO 12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER13730 EXCHANGE INSURANCE COMPANY 19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO 39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

198512211 CHARLESTON INS CO 12572 SELECTIVE INS CO OF AMER13730 EXCHANGE INSURANCE COMPANY 19259 SELECTIVE INS CO OF SC26301 SELECTIVE WAY INS CO 39926 SELECTIVE INS CO OF THE SOUTHEAST

244 Group Name:Group Code: CINCINNATI FIN GRP2009

10677 CINCINNATI INS CO 13037 THE CINCINNATI SPECIALTY UNDERWRITER23280 THE CINCINNATI IND CO 28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

200810677 CINCINNATI INS CO 13037 THE CINCINNATI SPECIALTY UNDERWRITER23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO 28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners317

Page 326: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

244 Group Name:Group Code: CINCINNATI FIN GRP2007

10677 CINCINNATI INS CO 13037 THE CINCINNATI SPECIALTY UNDERWRITER23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO 28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

200610677 CINCINNATI INS CO 23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

200510677 CINCINNATI INS CO 23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

200010677 CINCINNATI INS CO 23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

199510677 CINCINNATI INS CO 23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

199010677 CINCINNATI INS CO 23280 THE CINCINNATI INDEMNITY CO28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

198510677 CINCINNATI INS CO 28665 CINCINNATI CAS CO

245 Group Name:Group Code: SECURITY INDL I CO1990

28274 SECURITY INDUSTRIAL FIRE INS CO1985

28274 SECURITY INDUSTRIAL FIRE INS CO246 Group Name:Group Code: INDIANA LUMBERMENS GRP

200911087 LONE STAR NATL INS CO 11089 NATIONAL BUILDING MATERIAL ASSUR CO14265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

200811087 LONE STAR NATL INS CO 11089 NATIONAL BUILDING MATERIAL ASSUR CO14265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

200711087 LONE STAR NATL INS CO 11089 NATIONAL BUILDING MATERIAL ASSUR CO14265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

200611087 LONE STAR NATL INS CO 11089 NATIONAL BUILDING MATERIAL ASSUR CO14265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

200511087 LONE STAR NATL INS CO 11089 NATIONAL BUILDING MATERIAL ASSUR CO14265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

200014265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

199514265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

199014265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

198514265 INDIANA LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO

247 Group Name:Group Code: COMMODORE FINANCIAL CORP1990

24864 COMMODORE INS CO 29386 COMMODORE COUNTY MUT INS CO1985

24864 COMMODORE INS CO 29386 COMMODORE COUNTY MUT INS CO248 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP

200910324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners318

Page 327: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

248 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED FIRE & CAS GRP2009

18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & IND CO19526 TEXAS GEN IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

200810324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

200710324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

200610324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO 43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

200510324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO19518 AMERICAN IND CO 19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

200010324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 19496 UNITED FIRE & INDEMNITY CO19518 AMERICAN IND CO 19526 TEXAS GENERAL IND CO43559 UNITED FIRE LLOYDS

199510324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO

199010324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO

198510324 ADDISON INS CO 13021 UNITED FIRE & CAS CO18295 LAFAYETTE INS CO 43567 UNITED SURPLUS LINES INS CO

249 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS HOME MUT2005

13846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO40312 PIONEER INS CO

200013846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO40312 PIONEER INS CO

199513846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 16268 GOPHER STATE MUT INS CO26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO 40312 PIONEER INS CO

199013846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 16268 GOPHER STATE MUT INS CO26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO 40312 PIONEER INS CO

198513846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 16268 GOPHER STATE MUT INS CO26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO 40312 PIONEER INS CO

250 Group Name:Group Code: DONEGAL GRP2009

13692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 14389 LE MARS INS CO14958 PENINSULA INS CO 15148 SHEBOYGAN FALLS INS CO22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO 26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA39900 PENINSULA IND CO

200813692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 14389 LE MARS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners319

Page 328: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

250 Group Name:Group Code: DONEGAL GRP2008

14958 PENINSULA INS CO 15148 SHEBOYGAN FALLS INS CO22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO 26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA39900 PENINSULA IND CO

200713692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 14389 LE MARS INS CO14958 PENINSULA INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA 39900 PENINSULA IND CO

200613692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 14389 LE MARS INS CO14958 PENINSULA INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA 39900 PENINSULA IND CO

200513692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 14389 LE MARS INS CO14958 PENINSULA INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA 39900 PENINSULA IND CO

200013692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 13870 DELAWARE ATLANTIC INS CO15016 PIONEER MUTUTAL INSURANCE COMPANY 15717 PIONEER INS CO18090 SOUTHERN HERITAGE INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA

199513692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 13870 DELAWARE ATLANTIC INS CO15717 PIONEER INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA

199013692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 13870 DELAWARE ATLANTIC INS CO15717 PIONEER INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA

198513692 DONEGAL MUT INS CO 13870 DELAWARE ATLANTIC INS CO15717 PIONEER INS CO 22586 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO26867 SOUTHERN INS CO OF VA

253 Group Name:Group Code: HARLEYSVILLE GRP2009

10060 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF OH 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE ATLANTIC INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NY35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 40983 HARLEYSVILLE PENNLAND INS CO42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

200810060 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF OH 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE ATLANTIC INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NY35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 40983 HARLEYSVILLE PENNLAND INS CO42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

200710060 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF OH 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE ATLANTIC INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NY35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 40983 HARLEYSVILLE PENNLAND INS CO42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

200610060 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF OH 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners320

Page 329: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

253 Group Name:Group Code: HARLEYSVILLE GRP2006

26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 37630 MID-AMERICA INS CO40983 HARLEYSVILLE PENNLAND INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

200510060 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF OH 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 37630 MID-AMERICA INS CO40983 HARLEYSVILLE PENNLAND INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

200010060 GREAT OAKS INSURANCE COMPANY 10674 MAINLAND INS CO13382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO 13498 BERKSHIRE MUT INS CO14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO 14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO 26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO30770 HARLEYSVILLE-GARDEN STATE INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 37630 MID-AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY40983 PENNLAND INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

199510060 GREAT OAKS INSURANCE COMPANY 13382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO13498 BERKSHIRE MUT INS CO 14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO 26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO30770 HARLEYSVILLE-GARDEN STATE INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 37630 MID-AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY40983 PENNLAND INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

199013382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO 13498 BERKSHIRE MUT INS CO14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO 14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 37630 CONNECTICUT UNION INSURANCE CO40983 PENNLAND INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

198513382 HARLEYSVILLE-ATLANTIC INS CO 13498 BERKSHIRE MUT INS CO14168 HARLEYSVILLE MUT INS CO 14516 HARLEYSVILLE LAKE STATES INS CO26182 HARLEYSVILLE WORCESTER INS CO 33235 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NEW YORK35696 HARLEYSVILLE PREFERRED INS CO 42900 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO OF NJ

254 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHERN GEN GRP2009

37141 SOUTHERN GEN INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO2008

37141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C2007

11447 SOUTHERN GENERAL IND INS CO 37141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

200611447 SOUTHERN GENERAL IND INS CO 37141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

200511447 SOUTHERN GENERAL IND INS CO 37141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

200037141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

199537141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

199037141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners321

Page 330: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

254 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHERN GEN GRP1985

37141 SOUTHERN GENERAL INS CO 37311 SOUTHERN GENERAL UNDERWRITERS INS C256 Group Name:Group Code: NEW YORK MARINE & GEN GRP

200912294 SOUTHWEST MARINE & GEN INS CO 16608 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN INS CO25569 GOTHAM INS CO

200812294 SOUTHWEST MARINE & GEN INS CO 16608 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN INS CO25569 GOTHAM INS CO

200712294 SOUTHWEST MARINE & GEN INS CO 16608 NEW YORK MARINE & GEN INS CO25569 GOTHAM INS CO

200612294 SOUTHWEST MARINE & GEN INS CO 16608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO25569 GOTHAM INS CO

200516608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO 25569 GOTHAM INS CO

200016608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO 25569 GOTHAM INS CO

199516608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO 25569 GOTHAM INS CO

199016608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO 25569 GOTHAM INS CO

198516608 NEW YORK MARINE & GNRL INS CO 25569 GOTHAM INS CO

257 Group Name:Group Code: SAFEWAY INS GRP2009

10248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROP INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK CNTY MUT INS CO

200810248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROP INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK CNTY MUT INS CO

200710248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROP INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK CNTY MUT INS CO

200610248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROP INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK CNTY MUT INS CO

200510248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROP INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK CNTY MUT INS CO

200010248 SAFEWAY INS CO OF LA 10939 SAFEWAY DIRECT INS CO11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 SAFEWAY PROPERTY INSURSNCE CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 OAK BROOK COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO

199510203 ARGUS FIRE & CASUALTY INSURANCE CO 11223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners322

Page 331: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

257 Group Name:Group Code: SAFEWAY INS GRP1995

12521 SAFEWAY INS CO 17248 REGAL CASUALTY OF OMAHA INS CO25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA 29300 INA COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO

199011223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 REGAL CASUALTY OF OMAHA INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 INA COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO

198511223 SAFEWAY INS CO OF AL 12521 SAFEWAY INS CO17248 REGAL CASUALTY OF OMAHA INS CO 25640 SAFEWAY INS CO OF GA29300 INA COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO

258 Group Name:Group Code: INTERCARGO CORP GRP1995

37885 INTERCARGO INS CO1990

35580 BINFORD INS CO 37885 INTERCARGO INS CO39233 OCEANIC INS & SURETY CO

261 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL OF OMAHA GRP2000

12254 OMAHA IND CO 37540 OMAHA PROP & CAS INS CO1995

12254 OMAHA IND CO 37540 OMAHA PROP & CAS INS CO1990

12254 OMAHA IND CO 37540 OMAHA PROP & CAS INS CO1985

12254 OMAHA IND CO 37540 OMAHA PROP & CAS INS CO262 Group Name:Group Code: CANAL GRP

200910464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

200810464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

200710464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

200610464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

200510464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

200010464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

199510464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

199010464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

198510464 CANAL INS CO 27790 CANAL IND CO

264 Group Name:Group Code: HEALTHMARKETS GRP2005

11134 FIDELITY FIRST INS CO2000

11134 FIDELITY FIRST INSURANCE COMPANY265 Group Name:Group Code: BERKSHIRE MUT

199014745 MUTUAL INS CO OF BURLINGTON

198514745 MUTUAL INS CO OF BURLINGTON

267 Group Name:Group GRANGE MUT CAS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners323

Page 332: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

267 Group Name:Group Code: GRANGE MUT CAS GRP2009

10322 GRANGE IND INS CO 11136 GRANGE INS CO OF MI11982 GRANGE PROP & CAS INS CO 12986 INTEGRITY PROP & CAS INS CO14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO 14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

200810322 GRANGE IND INS CO 11136 GRANGE INS CO OF MI11982 GRANGE PROP & CAS INS CO 12986 INTEGRITY PROP & CAS INS CO14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO 14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

200710322 GRANGE IND INS CO 11136 GRANGE INS CO OF MI11982 GRANGE PROP & CAS INS CO 12986 INTEGRITY PROP & CAS INS CO14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO 14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

200610322 GRANGE INDEMNITY INS CO 11136 GRANGE INS CO OF MI11982 GRANGE PROP & CAS INS CO 14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO 40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

200510322 GRANGE INDEMNITY INS CO 11136 GRANGE INS CO OF MI11982 GRANGE PROP & CAS INS CO 14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO 40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

200010322 GRANGE INDEMNITY INS CO 14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

199510322 GRANGE INDEMNITY INS CO 14060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

199014060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO 14893 OHIO STATE GRANGE MUTUAL INS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

198514060 GRANGE MUT CAS CO 14893 OHIO STATE GRANGE MUTUAL INS CO40118 TRUSTGARD INS CO

268 Group Name:Group Code: JC PENNEY CO2000

10952 JC PENNEY CAS INS CO1995

10952 JC PENNEY CAS INS CO1990

10952 JC PENNEY CAS INS CO1985

10952 JC PENNEY CAS INS CO271 Group Name:Group Code: PENNSYLVANIA NATL INS GRP

200910994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NATL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

200810994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NATL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

200710994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

200610994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners324

Page 333: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

271 Group Name:Group Code: PENNSYLVANIA NATL INS GRP2005

10994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

200010994 FOUNDERS INS CO 14990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

199514990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO 32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

199014990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO 32441 PENN NATL SECURITY INS CO

198514990 PENNSYLVANIA NTL MUT CAS INS CO

273 Group Name:Group Code: WORKMENS GRP2009

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO2008

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO2007

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO2006

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO2005

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO2000

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO1995

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO1990

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO1985

13250 WORKMENS AUTO INS CO275 Group Name:Group Code: AUSTIN MUT GRP

200013412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 16314 NORTHERN MUT INS CO

199513412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 16314 NORTHERN MUT INS CO29475 WASECA MUT INS CO

199013412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 16314 NORTHERN MUT INS CO29475 WASECA MUT INS CO

198513412 AUSTIN MUT INS CO 16314 NORTHERN MUT INS CO29475 WASECA MUT INS CO

277 Group Name:Group Code: MINNESOTA MUT GRP1995

10054 HOMEPLUS INS CO 23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO1990

23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO 40002 VIKING FIRE INS CO1985

23582 HARLEYSVILLE INS CO280 Group Name:Group Code: AUTO OWNERS GRP

200910190 SOUTHERN OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY OWNERS INS CO

200810190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO OWNERS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners325

Page 334: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

280 Group Name:Group Code: AUTO OWNERS GRP2008

26638 HOME OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

200710190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

200610190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

200510190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

200010190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

199510190 SOUTHERN-OWNERS INS CO 18988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO 32700 OWNERS INS CO32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

199018988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO 26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO32700 OWNERS INS CO 32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

198518988 AUTO-OWNERS INS CO 26638 HOME-OWNERS INS CO32700 OWNERS INS CO 32905 PROPERTY-OWNERS INS CO

281 Group Name:Group Code: JM FAMILY GRP2009

26492 COURTESY INS CO2008

26492 COURTESY INS CO2007

26492 COURTESY INS CO2006

26492 COURTESY INS CO2005

26492 COURTESY INS CO2000

26492 COURTESY INS CO1995

26492 COURTESY INS CO1990

26492 COURTESY INS CO284 Group Name:Group Code: CITATION INS GRP

199525810 CITATION NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY 27731 CITATION GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY42242 CITATION INS CO

199025810 CALIFORNIA CONSUMERS INS CO 27731 CANADIAN INS CO OF CALIFORNIA42242 CITATION INS CO

198527731 CANADIAN INS CO OF CALIFORNIA 42242 CITATION INS CO

285 Group Name:Group Code: JOHN ALDEN GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners326

Page 335: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

285 Group Name:Group Code: JOHN ALDEN GRP1995

30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CASUALTY INS CO1990

30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CASUALTY INS CO1985

18716 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CAS INS CO 30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CASUALTY INS CO286 Group Name:Group Code: MILWAUKEE INS GRP

199018422 PRAIRIE STATES INS CO 28762 HEARTLAND MUT INS CO

198518422 PRAIRIE STATES INS CO 28762 HEARTLAND MUT INS CO

287 Group Name:Group Code: PHILADELPHIA UNITED GRP2009

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO2007

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO2006

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO2005

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO2000

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO1995

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO1990

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO1985

12327 PHILADELPHIA UNITED FIRE INS CO288 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MGMT GRP

199510251 AMERICAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO

199010251 AMERICAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 18198 AMERICAN MUT INS CO

198510251 AMERICAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 18198 AMERICAN MUT INS CO

289 Group Name:Group Code: ACUITY MUT GRP2005

14184 ACUITY A MUT INS CO 29793 GREATWAY INS CO2000

14184 ACUITY A MUT INS CO 29793 GREATWAY INS CO1995

14184 ACUITY A MUT INS CO 29793 GREATWAY INS CO1990

14184 ACUITY A MUT INS CO 29793 GREATWAY INS CO1985

14184 ACUITY A MUT INS CO 29793 GREATWAY INS CO290 Group Name:Group Code: LIBERTY NATL GRP

198511754 SHEFFIELD INS CO 30929 SHEFFIELD INS CO

291 Group Name:Group Code: MOTORISTS MUT GRP2009

13331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14338 IOWA MUT INS CO14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO 19950 WILSON MUT INS CO23175 PHENIX MUT FIRE INS CO 31577 IOWA AMER INS CO40932 MICO INS CO

200813331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14338 IOWA MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners327

Page 336: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

291 Group Name:Group Code: MOTORISTS MUT GRP2008

14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO 19950 WILSON MUT INS CO31577 IOWA AMER INS CO 40932 MICO INS CO

200713331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14338 IOWA MUT INS CO14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO 19950 WILSON MUT INS CO31577 IOWA AMER INS CO 40932 MICO INS CO

200613331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14338 IOWA MUT INS CO14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO 19950 WILSON MUT INS CO31577 IOWA AMER INS CO 40932 MICO INS CO43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CAS

200513331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14338 IOWA MUT INS CO14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO 19950 WILSON MUT INS CO31577 IOWA AMER INS CO 40932 MICO INS CO43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CAS

200013331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO40932 MICO INS CO 43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CASUALTY

199513331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO40932 MICO INS CO 43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CASUALTY CO

199013331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO40932 MICO INS CO 43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CASUALTY CO

198513331 AMERICAN HARDWARE MUT INS CO 14621 MOTORISTS MUT INS CO40932 MICO INS CO 43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CASUALTY CO

292 Group Name:Group Code: MERCHANTS & BUS MENS1990

17604 PENN ALLEN MUT INS CO1985

17604 PENN ALLEN MUT INS CO293 Group Name:Group Code: CIRCLE INVESTORS GRP

199037729 RIVERSIDE NATL INS CO

296 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN SOUTHERN GRP1995

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO1990

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO1985

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO297 Group Name:Group Code: STATE CAPITAL GRP

199512084 AMERICAN PROFESSIONALS INS CO 12661 STATE CAPITAL INS CO23086 LMI INS CO 23906 NORTHWESTERN NATL CAS CO23930 PACIFIC NATL INS CO 25208 STATESMAN INS CO27820 NORTHWESTERN NTL CTY MUTUAL INS CO 29785 NN INS CO41408 PACIFIC AUTOMOBILE INS CO

199012084 AMERICAN PROFESSIONALS INS CO 12661 STATE CAPITAL INS CO23086 LMI INS CO 23906 NORTHWESTERN NATL CAS CO23930 PACIFIC NATL INS CO 23957 NORTHWESTERN NTL LLOYDS INS CO23990 ATLANTIC STATES INS CO 25208 STATESMAN INS CO27820 NORTHWESTERN NTL CTY MUTUAL INS CO 29785 NN INS CO41408 PACIFIC AUTOMOBILE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners328

Page 337: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

297 Group Name:Group Code: STATE CAPITAL GRP1985

12084 AMERICAN PROFESSIONALS INS CO 12661 STATE CAPITAL INS CO23086 LMI INS CO 23906 NORTHWESTERN NATL CAS CO23930 PACIFIC NATL INS CO 23957 NORTHWESTERN NTL LLOYDS INS CO25208 STATESMAN INS CO 27820 NORTHWESTERN NTL CTY MUTUAL INS CO29785 NN INS CO 41408 PACIFIC AUTOMOBILE INS CO

299 Group Name:Group Code: INTEGRITY INS GRP1985

11584 INTEGRITY INS CO 14303 INTEGRITY MUT INS CO300 Group Name:Group Code: HORACE MANN GRP

200910996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

200810996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

200710996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

200610996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

200510996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

200010996 HORACE MANN LLOYDS 22578 HORACE MANN INS CO22683 TEACHERS INS CO 22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

199522578 HORACE MANN INS CO 22683 TEACHERS INS CO22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

199022578 HORACE MANN INS CO 22683 TEACHERS INS CO22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

198522578 HORACE MANN INS CO 22683 TEACHERS INS CO22756 HORACE MANN PROP & CAS INS CO

301 Group Name:Group Code: BANKERS INVEST GRP1995

30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO1990

30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO303 Group Name:Group Code: GUIDEONE INS GRP

200913984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDEONE SPECIALTY MUT INS CO15032 GUIDEONE MUT INS CO 31283 GUIDEONE LLOYDS INS CO42331 GUIDEONE AMER INS CO 42803 GUIDEONE ELITE INS CO

200813984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDEONE SPECIALTY MUT INS CO15032 GUIDEONE MUT INS CO 31283 GUIDEONE LLOYDS INS CO42331 GUIDEONE AMER INS CO 42803 GUIDEONE ELITE INS CO

200713984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDEONE SPECIALTY MUT INS CO15032 GUIDEONE MUT INS CO 31283 GUIDEONE LLOYDS INS CO42331 GUIDEONE AMER INS CO 42803 GUIDEONE ELITE INS CO

200613984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDEONE SPECIALTY MUT INS CO15032 GUIDEONE MUT INS CO 31283 GUIDEONE LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners329

Page 338: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

303 Group Name:Group Code: GUIDEONE INS GRP2006

42331 GUIDEONE AMERICA INS CO 42803 GUIDEONE ELITE INS CO2005

13984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDEONE SPECIALTY MUT INS CO15032 GUIDEONE MUT INS CO 31283 GUIDEONE LLOYDS INS CO42331 GUIDEONE AMERICA INS CO 42803 GUIDEONE ELITE INS CO

200010920 MILLENNIUM INS CO 12289 PERSONAL SERVICE INS CO13984 GUIDEONE PROP & CAS INS CO 14559 GUIDANT SPECIALTY MUTUAL INS CO15032 GUIDANT MUTUAL INSURANCE CO. 28746 GUIDEONE CAS INS CO31283 GUIDANT LLOYDS INSURANCE COMPANY 42331 GUIDEONE AMERICA INS CO42803 GUIDANT ELITE INSURANCE CO

199513984 CENTRAL PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 14559 MIDWEST MUTUAL INS CO15032 PREFERRED RISK MUTUAL INS CO 31283 PREFERRED RISK LLOYDS INS CO42331 PREFERRED AMERICA INS CO 42803 PREFERRED ABSTAINERS INS CO

199014559 MIDWEST MUTUAL INS CO 15032 PREFERRED RISK MUTUAL INS CO31283 PREFERRED RISK LLOYDS INS CO 42331 ANSVAR AMERICA INS CO42803 PREFERRED ABSTAINERS INS CO

198514559 MIDWEST MUTUAL INS CO 15032 PREFERRED RISK MUTUAL INS CO42331 ANSVAR AMERICA INS CO 42803 PREFERRED ABSTAINERS INS CO

304 Group Name:Group Code: PRUDENTIAL OF AMER GRP2000

10105 VICTORIA SELECT INS CO 10777 VICTORIA SPECIALTY INSURANCE CO10778 VICTORIA NATIONAL INSURANCE CO 10930 PRUDENTIAL GENERAL INS CO OF NJ10931 PRUDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INS CO OF 13242 TITAN IND CO28959 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO NJ 31968 MERASTAR INS CO32352 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO 36269 TITAN INS CO36439 PRUDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INS CO 36447 PRUDENTIAL GENERAL INS CO42889 VICTORIA FIRE & CAS CO

199528959 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO NJ 32352 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO35947 GIBRALTAR CAS CO 36439 PRUDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INS CO36447 PRUDENTIAL GENERAL INS CO 44253 PRUDENTIAL LLOYDS

199028959 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO NJ 32352 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO35947 GIBRALTAR CAS CO 36439 PRUDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INS CO36447 PRUDENTIAL GENERAL INS CO 44253 PRUDENTIAL LLOYDS

198528959 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO NJ 32352 PRUDENTIAL PROP & CAS INS CO35947 GIBRALTAR CAS CO 36439 PRUDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INS CO36447 PRUDENTIAL GENERAL INS CO 39764 ESSEX SYNDICATE INC39772 GOLDEN HILL SYNDICATE INC 39780 PRUCO SYNDICATE INC

306 Group Name:Group Code: CUNA MUT GRP2009

10847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO12758 CUMIS SPECIALTY INS CO INC 29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 34312 PRODUCERS AGRICULTURE INS CO40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

200810847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO12758 CUMIS SPECIALTY INS CO INC 29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

200710847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO12758 CUMIS SPECIALTY INS CO INC 29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners330

Page 339: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

306 Group Name:Group Code: CUNA MUT GRP2007

40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO2006

10847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO12758 CUMIS SPECIALTY INS CO INC 29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

200510847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO 40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

200010847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 10992 CMG MORTGAGE REINS CO29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO 40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

199510847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 11746 LEAGUE GENERAL INS CO29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO 40266 CMG MORTGAGE INS CO

199010847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 11746 LEAGUE GENERAL INS CO29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO 40266 INVESTORS MORTGAGE INS CO

198510847 CUMIS INS SOCIETY INC 11746 LEAGUE GENERAL INS CO29114 CMG MORTGAGE ASSUR CO 40266 INVESTORS MORTGAGE INS CO

308 Group Name:Group Code: PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP GRP2009

11282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP FOR IN

200811282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP FOR IN

200711282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

200611282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

200511282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

200011282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

199511282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

199011282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

198511282 GERMANTOWN INS CO 17914 PHILADELPHIA CONTRIBUTIONSHIP INS17930 PHILADELPHIA CBSP FOR INS OF HOUSES

309 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN NATL MUT2009

13187 TITAN PROP & CAS INS CO 15377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO 26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO40312 PIONEER SPECIALTY INS CO

200815377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO 40312 PIONEER SPECIALTY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners331

Page 340: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

309 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN NATL MUT2007

15377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO 40312 PIONEER SPECIALTY INS CO

200613846 FARMERS HOME MUT INS CO 15377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO 26395 WESTERN HOME INS CO40312 PIONEER INS CO

200515377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO

200015377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO

199515377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO

199015377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO

198515377 WESTERN NATL MUT INS CO 24465 WESTERN NATL ASSUR CO

311 Group Name:Group Code: MAIN STREET AMER GRP2009

10787 GREAT LAKES CAS INS CO 11066 MSA INS CO13026 MAIN STREET AMER PROTECTION INS CO 14788 NGM INS CO22098 GRAIN DEALERS MUT INS CO 29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

200810787 GREAT LAKES CAS INS CO 11066 MSA INS CO13026 MAIN STREET AMER PROTECTION INS CO 14788 NGM INS CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO 40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

200711066 MSA INS CO 13026 MAIN STREET AMER PROTECTION INS CO14788 NGM INS CO 29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

200611066 MSA INS CO 14788 NGM INS CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO 40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

200511066 MSA INS CO 14788 NGM INS CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO 40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

200014788 NATL GRANGE MUT INS CO 29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

199511215 AMERICAN LOYALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 12726 ARIES INS CO INC14788 NATL GRANGE MUT INS CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REIN CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO

199011215 AMERICAN LOYALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 12726 ARIES INS CO INC14788 NATL GRANGE MUT INS CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REIN CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO 40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

198511215 AMERICAN LOYALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 12726 ARIES INS CO INC14788 NATL GRANGE MUT INS CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REIN CO29939 MAIN ST AMER ASSUR CO 40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO

313 Group Name:Group Code: AEGIS GRP2009

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO2008

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners332

Page 341: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

313 Group Name:Group Code: AEGIS GRP2007

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO2006

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO2005

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO2000

17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO1995

28444 AEGIS IND INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO1990

28444 AEGIS IND INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO1985

28444 AEGIS IND INS CO 33898 AEGIS SECURITY INS CO315 Group Name:Group Code: INDUSTRIAL ALLIANCE GRP

199016519 ALLIANCE GENERAL INS CO 38199 CANADIAN UNION INS CO OF AMERICA

198516519 ALLIANCE GENERAL INS CO 38199 CANADIAN UNION INS CO OF AMERICA

316 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONAL SECURITY GRP2009

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO2008

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO2007

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO2006

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO2005

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO2000

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO1995

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO 16212 OMEGA ONE INS CO1990

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO1985

12114 NATIONAL SECURITY FIRE & CAS CO317 Group Name:Group Code: AON CORP GRP

200610685 CITADEL INS CO 43460 FFG INS CO

200510685 CITADEL INS CO 40827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC43460 FFG INS CO

200010685 CITADEL INS CO 40827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

199510685 CITADEL INS CO 29912 DEARBORN INS CO40827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

199010685 CITADEL INS CO 29912 DEARBORN INS CO40827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

198510685 CITADEL INS CO 29912 DEARBORN INS CO40827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

319 Group Name:Group Code: DAUPHIN MGMT CORP GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners333

Page 342: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

319 Group Name:Group Code: DAUPHIN MGMT CORP GRP1985

17027 DAUPHIN MUT INS CO 18783 PAXTON NATL INS CO39403 REMCO INS CO

320 Group Name:Group Code: RURAL GRP1995

15091 RURAL MUT INS CO1990

15091 RURAL MUT INS CO1985

15091 RURAL MUT INS CO321 Group Name:Group Code: CAPITAL MUT GRP

199510025 COMMUNITY MUT INS CO 41947 CAPITAL MUT INS CO

199041947 CAPITAL MUT INS CO

198541947 CAPITAL MUT INS CO

323 Group Name:Group Code: CIVIL SERV EMPLOYEE GRP2009

10693 CIVIL SERV EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO2008

10693 CIVIL SERV EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO2007

10693 CIVIL SERV EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO2006

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO2005

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO2000

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO1995

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO1990

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO1985

10693 CIVIL SVC EMPLOYEES INS CO 18953 CSE SAFEGUARD INS CO324 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU GRP

200910034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

200810034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

200710034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

200610034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

200510034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

200010034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

199510034 FARM BUREAU INS OF NC INC 14842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

199014842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

198514842 NORTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

328 Group Name:Group Code: MONTGOMERY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners334

Page 343: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

328 Group Name:Group Code: MONTGOMERY INS CO1995

14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 16900 MONTGOMERY IND CO1990

14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO 16900 MONTGOMERY IND CO1985

14613 MONTGOMERY MUT INS CO329 Group Name:Group Code: ACCEPTANCE INS GRP

200010349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 16403 AMERICAN GROWERS INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 37958 ACCEPTANCE INS CO

199510349 ACCEPTANCE CAS INS CO 16403 AMERICAN GROWERS INS CO20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO 34037 PHOENIX IND INS CO37303 REDLAND INS CO 37958 ACCEPTANCE INS CO

199016403 AMERICAN GROWERS INS CO 20010 ACCEPTANCE IND INS CO34037 PHOENIX IND INS CO 37303 REDLAND INS CO37958 ACCEPTANCE INS CO

198516403 AMERICAN GROWERS INS CO 37303 REDLAND INS CO37958 ACCEPTANCE INS CO

330 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FIDELITY CORP GRP1995

16810 AMERICAN FIDELITY INSURANCE COMPANY 20400 CIMARRON INS CO INC1990

16810 AMERICAN FIDELITY INSURANCE COMPANY 20400 CIMARRON INS CO INC1985

16810 AMERICAN FIDELITY INSURANCE COMPANY 20400 CIMARRON INS CO INC333 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW GRP

200911232 ENUMCLAW PROP & CAS INS CO 14761 MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO

200811232 ENUMCLAW PROP & CAS INS CO 14761 MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO

200711232 ENUMCLAW PROP & CAS INS CO 14761 MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO

200611232 ENUMCLAW PROP & CAS INS CO 14761 MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO

200511232 ENUMCLAW PROP & CAS INS CO 14761 MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO

334 Group Name:Group Code: V J SALGADO & ASSOC INC1995

25356 MANUFACTURERS TRUST INS CO 26778 INTEGRAND ASSUR CO1990

25356 MANUFACTURERS TRUST INS CO 26778 INTEGRAND ASSUR CO1985

25356 MANUFACTURERS TRUST INS CO 26778 INTEGRAND ASSUR CO336 Group Name:Group Code: ZENITH NATL INS GRP

200913269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO

200813269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO

200713269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO

200613269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO

200513269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners335

Page 344: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

336 Group Name:Group Code: ZENITH NATL INS GRP2000

13269 ZENITH INS CO 30120 ZNAT INS CO1995

13269 ZENITH INS CO 18961 CALFARM INS CO30120 ZNAT INS CO 30150 ZENITH STAR INS CO

199013269 ZENITH INS CO 18961 CALFARM INS CO30120 ZNAT INS CO

198513269 ZENITH INS CO 18961 CALFARM INS CO30120 ZNAT INS CO

337 Group Name:Group Code: BENEFICIAL STAND1985

39195 INSURANCE CO OF MD339 Group Name:Group Code: IOWA MUT GRP

200014338 IOWA MUT INS CO 31577 IOWA AMER INS CO

199514338 IOWA MUT INS CO 31577 IOWA AMER INS CO

199014338 IOWA MUT INS CO 31577 IOWA AMER INS CO

198514338 IOWA MUT INS CO 31577 IOWA AMER INS CO

342 Group Name:Group Code: CONSOLIDATED INTL INS GRP1995

10391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 14520 CONSOLIDATED INS CO OF PR14958 PENINSULA INS CO 25003 COMCO INS CO39900 PENINSULA IND CO

199010391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 14958 PENINSULA INS CO25003 COMCO INS CO 39900 PENINSULA IND CO

198510391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 14958 PENINSULA INS CO25003 COMCO INS CO

343 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONAL INS CO GRP2009

12076 NATIONAL INS CO 12216 NATIONAL GRP INS CO2008

12076 NATIONAL INS CO 12216 NATIONAL GRP INS CO2007

12076 NATIONAL INS CO 12216 NATIONAL GRP INS CO2006

12076 NATIONAL INS CO 12216 NATIONAL GRP INS CO2005

12076 NATIONAL INS CO 12216 NATIONAL GRP INS CO2000

12076 NATIONAL INS CO1995

12076 NATIONAL INS CO1990

12076 NATIONAL INS CO1985

12076 NATIONAL INS CO344 Group Name:Group Code: CHURCH PENSION FUND GRP

200710669 CHURCH INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners336

Page 345: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

344 Group Name:Group Code: CHURCH PENSION FUND GRP2006

10669 CHURCH INS CO2005

10669 CHURCH INS CO2000

10669 CHURCH INS CO1995

10669 CHURCH INS CO1990

10669 CHURCH INS CO1985

10669 CHURCH INS CO345 Group Name:Group Code: AVEMCO INS GRP

199510367 AVEMCO INS CO 23736 NATIONAL INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS29580 NATIONAL ASSURANCE UNDERWRITER INC 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO

199010367 AVEMCO INS CO 23736 NATIONAL INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS29580 NATIONAL ASSURANCE UNDERWRITER INC 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO

198510367 AVEMCO INS CO 23736 NATIONAL INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS29580 NATIONAL ASSURANCE UNDERWRITER INC 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO

348 Group Name:Group Code: FARM FAMILY GRP2000

13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO 29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO1995

13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO 29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO1990

13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO 29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO1985

13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO349 Group Name:Group Code: FLORISTS MUT GRP

200913978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

200813978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

200713978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

200613978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

200513978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

200013978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

199513978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

199013978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

198513978 FLORISTS MUT INS CO 33278 FLORISTS INS CO

350 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP2009

32077 HERITAGE CAS INS CO2008

32077 HERITAGE CAS INS CO2007

32077 HERITAGE CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners337

Page 346: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

350 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL ELECTRIC GRP2006

32077 HERITAGE CASUALTY INS CO 39527 HERITAGE IND CO2005

10641 CORE INS CO 11049 GENWORTH MORTGAGE REINS CORP11365 SPONSORED CAPTIVE RE INC 16675 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC18759 VEREX ASSURE INC 21318 COREGIS INS CO22969 GE REINS CORP 29823 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MRT INS CORP NC32077 HERITAGE CASUALTY INS CO 34207 WESTPORT INS CORP34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP 37095 PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO38458 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP 39527 HERITAGE IND CO39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP 41432 GENWORTH HOME EQUITY INS CORP42722 FIRST MARINE INS CO

200010026 WESTWOOD INDEMNITY COMPANY 10184 BAYSIDE CAS INS CO10641 CORE INS CO 11049 GE MORTGAGE REINS CORP OF NC11843 MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO 12815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO16675 GEN ELEC MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC 17400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO18759 VEREX ASSURE INC 20796 COLONIAL PENN FRANKLIN INS CO21318 COREGIS INSURANCE CO 22225 GE AUTO & HOME ASSUR CO22969 GE REINS CORP 29823 GE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CORP NC32077 MONTGOMERY WARD INS CO 34207 WESTPORT INS` CORP34789 COLONIAL PENN INS CO 34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP37095 PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO 38458 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE INS CORP38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO 39527 HERITAGE IND CO39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP 41432 GEN ELEC HOME EQUITY INS CORP OF NC42722 FIRST MARINE INS CO 43974 COLONIAL PENN MADISON INS CO

199512815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO 16675 GEN ELEC MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC17680 FORUM INS CO 18450 FRANKONA AMERICA REINS CO18759 VEREX ASSURE INC 28916 HOME GUARANTY INS CORP29823 GE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CORP NC 32018 FIRST EXCESS & REINS CORP32077 MONTGOMERY WARD INS CO 34207 WESTPORT INSURANCE CORP34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP 37095 PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO38458 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE INS CORP 39527 HERITAGE IND CO39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP 39985 PURITAN EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES IN CO40711 FRANKONA REINS CO US BRANCH 41432 GEN ELEC HOME EQUITY INS CORP OF NC

199012815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO 16675 GEN ELEC MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC17680 FORUM INS CO 18759 VEREX ASSURE INC28916 HOME GUARANTY INS CORP 29823 GE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CORP NC32018 FIRST EXCESS & REINS CORP 32077 MONTGOMERY WARD INS CO34207 WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION 34916 FIRST SPECIALTY INS CORP37095 PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO 38458 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE INS CORP39527 HERITAGE IND CO 39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP39985 PURITAN EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES IN CO 40711 FRANKONA REINS CO US BRANCH41432 GEN ELEC HOME EQUITY INS CORP OF NC

198512815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO 16675 GEN ELEC MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC17680 FORUM INS CO 18759 VEREX ASSURE INC28916 HOME GUARANTY INS CORP 29823 GE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CORP NC32018 FIRST EXCESS & REINS CORP 32077 MONTGOMERY WARD INS CO34207 WESTPORT INSURANCE CORPORATION 38458 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE INS CORP39527 HERITAGE IND CO 39845 EMPLOYERS REINS CORP39985 PURITAN EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES IN CO 40711 FRANKONA REINS CO US BRANCH41432 GEN ELEC HOME EQUITY INS CORP OF NC

351 Group Name:Group Code: GEORGE WASHINGTON GRP1990

37796 AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners338

Page 347: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

351 Group Name:Group Code: GEORGE WASHINGTON GRP1985

37796 AMERICAN SPECIALTY INS CO352 Group Name:Group Code: HSBC GRP

200928657 HSBC INS CO OF DE

200828657 HSBC INS CO OF DE

200728657 HSBC INS CO OF DE

200628657 HSBC INS CO OF DE

200525011 WESCO INS CO 28657 HSBC INS CO OF DE

200025011 WESCO INS CO 28657 SERVICE GENERAL INS CO

199527138 HOUSEHOLD INSURANCE COMPANY

199027138 ALEXANDER HAMILTON INS CO OF AMERICA

198527138 ALEXANDER HAMILTON INS CO OF AMERICA

353 Group Name:Group Code: TWENTIETH CENTURY INS GRP1995

12963 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO1990

12963 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS CO 36404 21ST CENTURY CAS CO1985

12963 TWENTIETH CENTURY INS CO354 Group Name:Group Code: OMNI INS GRP

200034940 OMNI IND CO

199534940 OMNI IND CO 39098 OMNI INS CO

199034940 OMNI IND CO 39098 OMNI INS CO

355 Group Name:Group Code: LYNDON INS GRP1995

35769 LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO1990

35769 ITT LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO1985

35769 ITT LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO356 Group Name:Group Code: JOHN HANCOCK GRP

199516187 JOHN HANCOCK PROP & CAS INS CO 25763 UNIGARD SECURITY INS CO43044 JOHN HANCOCK INDEMNITY CO

199016187 JOHN HANCOCK PROP & CAS INS CO 25763 UNIGARD SECURITY INS CO43044 JOHN HANCOCK INDEMNITY CO

198516187 JOHN HANCOCK PROP & CAS INS CO 25763 UNIGARD SECURITY INS CO41645 UNIGARD LLOYDS OF TX 43044 JOHN HANCOCK INDEMNITY CO

357 Group Name:Group Code: KENTUCKY CENTRAL1990

11657 KENTUCKY CENTRAL INS CO1985

11657 KENTUCKY CENTRAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners339

Page 348: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

359 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP GRP2009

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP2008

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP2007

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP2006

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP2005

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP2000

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP1995

10003 EXCESS SHARE INS CORP 12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP1990

12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP 23183 NATIONAL DEPOSIT INS CORP1985

12700 AMERICAN MUT SHARE INS CORP 23183 NATIONAL DEPOSIT INS CORP361 Group Name:Group Code: MUNICH RE GRP

200910227 MUNICH REINS AMER INC 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 12314 AMERICAN MODERN INS CO OF FL12489 AMERICAN MODERN SURPLUS LINES INS CO 19720 AMERICAN ALT INS CORP23450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO 23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT 35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO38652 AMERICAN MODERN SELECT INS CO 41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO 42722 FIRST MARINE INS CO

200810227 MUNICH REINS AMER INC 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS12314 AMERICAN MODERN INS CO OF FL 12489 AMERICAN MODERN SURPLUS LINES INS CO19720 AMERICAN ALT INS CORP 23450 AMERICAN FAMILY HOME INS CO23469 AMERICAN MODERN HOME INS CO 35912 AMERICAN WESTERN HOME INS CO38652 AMERICAN MODERN SELECT INS CO 41998 AMERICAN SOUTHERN HOME INS CO42005 AMERICAN MODERN LLOYDS INS CO 42722 FIRST MARINE INS CO

200710227 MUNICH REINS AMER INC 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS19720 AMERICAN ALT INS CORP

200610227 MUNICH REINS AMER INC 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS19720 AMERICAN ALT INS CORP

200510227 AMERICAN REIN CO 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS19720 AMERICAN ALT INS CORP

200010227 AMERICAN REIN CO 10786 PRINCETON EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES INS19720 AMERICAN UNION REINSURANCE CO

363 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL ASSUR1995

40231 OLD DOMINION INS CO1990

17841 VALLEY INS CO 18899 MUTUAL ASSUR CO1985

17841 VALLEY INS CO 18899 MUTUAL ASSUR CO364 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICO CO GRP

200031119 MUTUAL PROTECTIVE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners340

Page 349: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

364 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICO CO GRP1995

31119 MUTUAL PROTECTIVE INS CO1990

31119 MUTUAL PROTECTIVE INS CO1985

31119 MUTUAL PROTECTIVE INS CO368 Group Name:Group Code: CII INS GRP

199532271 CALIFORNIA IND INS CO 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO

199032271 CALIFORNIA IND INS CO 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO

369 Group Name:Group Code: KIEWIT HOLDINGS GRP1990

32883 WESTERN EMPLOYERS INS CO 41270 WESTERN EMPLOYERS INS CO OF AMER1985

29084 INVESTORS MORTGAGE INS CO OF HI INC 32883 WESTERN EMPLOYERS INS CO41270 WESTERN EMPLOYERS INS CO OF AMER

371 Group Name:Group Code: BOMAR INVESTMENT GRP1990

39179 FIDELITY FIRE & CAS INS CO372 Group Name:Group Code: TOYOTA MOTOR INS GRP

199537621 TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO

374 Group Name:Group Code: CNL INS CO2000

30112 CNL INS AMER INC1995

30112 CNL INS AMER INC1990

30112 CNL INS AMER INC377 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL INS OF MD GRP

200929017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOCIETY OF MD

200829017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOCIETY OF MD

200729017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOCIETY OF MD

200629017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

200529017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

200029017 PROFESSIONALS ADVOCATE INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

199529017 MID-ATLANTIC MEDICAL INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

199029017 MID-ATLANTIC MEDICAL INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

198529017 MID-ATLANTIC MEDICAL INS CO 32328 MEDICAL MUT LIAB INS SOC OF MD

378 Group Name:Group Code: TENERE GRP INC1995

10037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS COMPANY1990

33367 RCA MUTUAL INS CO1985

33367 RCA MUTUAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners341

Page 350: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

379 Group Name:Group Code: FEDERATED GRP1995

11096 FEDERATED AMER INS CO 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO1990

11096 FEDERATED AMER INS CO 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO1985

11096 FEDERATED AMER INS CO 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO381 Group Name:Group Code: GREAT WESTERN GRP

198520834 ARISTAR INS CO

382 Group Name:Group Code: PROVIDENCE GRP2009

15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO 33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO2007

15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO 33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO2006

15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO 33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO2005

15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO 33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO2000

14079 GRANGE MUT INS CO 15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO

199514079 GRANGE MUT INS CO 15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO

199014079 GRANGE MUT INS CO 15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO33430 PROVIDENCE PLANTATIONS INS CO

198514079 GRANGE MUT INS CO 15040 PROVIDENCE MUT FIRE INS CO

383 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN EUROPEAN GRP2009

11245 RUTGERS ENHANCED INS CO 23337 AMERICAN EUROPEAN INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

200811245 RUTGERS ENHANCED INS CO 23337 AMERICAN EUROPEAN INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

200711245 RUTGERS ENHANCED INS CO 23337 AMERICAN EUROPEAN INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

200611245 RUTGERS ENHANCED INS CO 29149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

200511245 RUTGERS ENHANCED INS CO 29149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

200029149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO 31399 UNITED INTL INS CO41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

199528410 UNITED INTERNATIONAL UDRWTS INS CO 29149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

199028410 UNITED INTERNATIONAL UDRWTS INS CO 29149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO31399 UNITED INTL INS CO 41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

198528410 UNITED INTERNATIONAL UDRWTS INS CO 29149 KENTUCKY NATL INS CO41378 RUTGERS CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners342

Page 351: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

384 Group Name:Group Code: CLASSIC INS GRP1990

41530 CLASSIC FIRE AND MARINE INS CO386 Group Name:Group Code: ELIC CORP GRP

199011363 GREAT PLAINS INS CO INC 24210 REGENCY EQUITIES REINS CO

198511363 GREAT PLAINS INS CO INC 24210 REGENCY EQUITIES REINS CO

388 Group Name:Group Code: HARTFORD STEAM BOILER GRP1995

11452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT30205 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO TX

199011452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO 29890 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC INS CO CT

198511452 HARTFORD STEAM BOIL INSPEC & INS CO

389 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRIS GRP INC1995

11835 USF RE INS CO 17159 USF INS CO1990

11835 USF RE INS CO 17159 USF INS CO1985

11835 USF RE INS CO 17159 USF INS CO390 Group Name:Group Code: GRE INS GRP

199510073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10413 CALEDONIAN INS CO OF AMER11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 18333 ATLAS ASSUR CO OF AMER19917 ALBANY INS CO 23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN36919 TOWER INS CO INC

199010073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10413 CALEDONIAN INS CO OF AMER11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 18333 ATLAS ASSUR CO OF AMER19917 ALBANY INS CO 23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN36919 TOWER INS CO INC

198510073 AMERICAN AMBASSADOR CAS CO 10413 CALEDONIAN INS CO OF AMER11312 GLOBE AMERICAN CAS CO 18333 ATLAS ASSUR CO OF AMER19917 ALBANY INS CO 23507 MID AMERICAN FIRE & CAS CO23515 MIDWESTERN IND CO 27944 NATIONAL INS ASSN36919 TOWER INS CO INC

393 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN BONDING GRP2000

10138 AMERICAN BONDING CO 33030 INSURANCE CO OF THE AMERICAS1995

10138 AMERICAN BONDING CO 33030 INSURANCE CO OF THE AMERICAS1990

10138 AMERICAN BONDING CO 33030 INSURANCE CO OF THE AMERICAS1985

10138 AMERICAN BONDING CO 33030 INSURANCE CO OF THE AMERICAS397 Group Name:Group Code: NUCORP INS GRP

199513188 WESTERN SURETY CO 13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER24047 SURETY BONDING CO OF AMER 39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO

199013188 WESTERN SURETY CO 13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners343

Page 352: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

397 Group Name:Group Code: NUCORP INS GRP1985

13188 WESTERN SURETY CO 13200 UNIVERSAL SURETY OF AMER39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO

398 Group Name:Group Code: ENHANCE FNCL GRP2000

27545 ENHANCE REINS CO 36250 ASSET GUARANTY INS CO39870 VAN-AMERICAN INS CO

199527545 ENHANCE REINS CO 36250 ASSET GUARANTY INS CO39870 VAN-AMERICAN INS CO

199027545 ENHANCE REINS CO 36250 ASSET GUARANTY INS CO39870 VAN-AMERICAN INS CO

400 Group Name:Group Code: CREDIT SUISSE GRP2005

11096 UNIGARD PACIFIC INS CO 18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INS CO22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO 24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI24449 REGENT INS CO 24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO25747 UNIGARD INS CO 25798 UNIGARD IND CO27570 HOOSIER INS CO 34100 MASSWEST INS CO INC40754 BLUE RIDGE IND CO 40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

200010809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 11096 FEDERATED AMER INS CO18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL 19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS 19216 SOUTHERN INS CO19607 WINTERTHUR INTL AMERICA UNDERWRITER 22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INSURANCE COMPANY22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO 24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI24449 REGENT INS CO 24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO 24554 WINTERHUR INTERNATL AMER INS CO25747 UNIGARD INS CO 25798 UNIGARD IND CO27570 HOOSIER INS CO 27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO34100 MASSWEST INS CO INC 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO 40754 BLUE RIDGE INDEMNITY CO40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

199510006 WINTERTHUR REINSURANCE CORP OF AMER 18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 19208 INSURED LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 19607 VANGUARD UNDERWRITERS INS CO22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INSURANCE COMPANY 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO24554 VANGUARD INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 34100 MASSWEST INS CO INC38318 REPUBLIC INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO40754 SOUTHERN FUND INS CORP 40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

199010006 WINTERTHUR REINSURANCE CORP OF AMER 18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 19208 INSURED LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 19607 VANGUARD UNDERWRITERS INS CO22861 JEFFERSON-PILOT FIRE & CAS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO24554 VANGUARD INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 32263 REPUBLIC-VANGUARD REINS CO34100 MASSWEST INS CO INC 38318 REPUBLIC INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners344

Page 353: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

400 Group Name:Group Code: CREDIT SUISSE GRP1990

40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO 40754 SOUTHERN FUND INS CORP40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

198510006 PARTNERRE INS CO OF NY 18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 19208 INSURED LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 19607 VANGUARD UNDERWRITERS INS CO22861 JEFFERSON-PILOT FIRE & CAS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO24554 VANGUARD INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 32263 REPUBLIC-VANGUARD REINS CO38318 REPUBLIC INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO40754 SOUTHERN FUND INS CORP 40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

403 Group Name:Group Code: PHOENIX COS GRP1990

29807 PXRE REINS CO 44520 TRANSNATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY407 Group Name:Group Code: GORAN CAPITAL GRP

200510168 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 10169 SUPERIOR AMER INS CO12220 SUPERIOR INS CO 26891 IGF INS CO29572 PAFCO GENERAL INS CO

200010168 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 10169 SUPERIOR AMER INS CO12220 SUPERIOR INS CO 26891 IGF INS CO29572 PAFCO GENERAL INS CO

199526891 IGF INS CO 29572 PAFCO GENERAL INS CO

199026891 IGF INS CO 29572 PAFCO GENERAL INS CO

408 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP2009

10043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO11140 ANPAC LA INS CO 13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL CNTY MUT INS CO29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GEN INS CO

200810043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO11140 ANPAC LA INS CO 13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL CNTY MUT INS CO29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GEN INS CO

200710043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO11140 ANPAC LA INS CO 13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL CNTY MUT INS CO29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GEN INS CO

200610043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO11140 ANPAC LA INS CO 13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL COUNTY MUT INS CO29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

200510043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO11140 ANPAC LA INS CO 13803 FARM FAMILY CAS INS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL COUNTY MUT INS CO29963 UNITED FARM FAMILY INS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners345

Page 354: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

408 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN NATL FIN GRP2000

10043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 11048 PACIFIC PROP & CAS CO28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 29319 AMERICAN NATL COUNTY MUT INS CO39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

199510043 AMERICAN NATL LLOYDS INS CO 28401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

199028401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

198528401 AMERICAN NATL PROP & CAS CO 39942 AMERICAN NATL GENERAL INS CO

411 Group Name:Group Code: MAPFRE INS GRP2009

13161 COMMERCE W INS CO 18120 MAPFRE PREFERRED RISK INS CO19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO 23876 MAPFRE INS CO25275 STATE WIDE INS CO 31690 MAPFRE PAN AMER INS CO34754 COMMERCE INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL40274 CITATION INS CO 43052 MAPFRE PRAICO INS CO

200813161 COMMERCE W INS CO 18120 MAPFRE PREFERRED RISK INS CO19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO 23876 MAPFRE INS CO25275 STATE-WIDE INS CO 31690 MAPFRE PAN AMER INS CO34754 COMMERCE INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL35840 AMSTAR INS CO 40274 CITATION INS CO43052 MAPFRE PRAICO INS CO

200718120 MAPFRE PREFERRED RISK INS CO 23876 MAPFRE INS CO31690 MAPFRE PAN AMER INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL35840 AMSTAR INS CO 43052 MAPFRE PRAICO INS CO

200618120 MAPFRE PREFERRED RISK INS CO 23876 MAPFRE REINS CORP31690 MAPFRE PAN AMER INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL35840 AMSTAR INS CO 43052 MAPFRE PRAICO INS CO

200518120 MAPFRE PREFERRED RISK INS CO 23876 MAPFRE REINS CORP31690 MAPFRE PAN AMER INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL35840 AMSTAR INS CO 43052 MAPFRE PRAICO INS CO

200018120 PREFERRED RISK INS CO 23876 MAPFREE REINSURANCE CORP31690 PAN AMER INS CO 35840 AMSTAR INS CO42790 MAPFRE INS CO OF AMER INC 43052 PUERTO RICAN AMERICAN INS CO

199535840 AMSTAR INS CO 42790 MAPFRE INS CO OF AMER INC

199035840 AMSTAR INS CO

413 Group Name:Group Code: MAG MUT INS GRP2009

11811 PROFESSIONAL SECURITY INS CO 42617 MAG MUT INS CO2008

11811 PROFESSIONAL SECURITY INS CO 42617 MAG MUT INS CO2007

11811 PROFESSIONAL SECURITY INS CO 42617 MAG MUT INS CO2006

11811 PROFESSIONAL SECURITY INS CO 42617 MAG MUT INS CO2005

11811 PROFESSIONAL SECURITY INS CO 42617 MAG MUT INS CO1995

42617 MAG MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners346

Page 355: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

413 Group Name:Group Code: MAG MUT INS GRP1990

42617 MAG MUT INS CO1985

42617 MAG MUT INS CO415 Group Name:Group Code: PLYMOUTH ROCK INS GRP

200910394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 13643 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CAS CO14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP 21750 PILGRIM INS CO43982 MT WA ASSUR CORP

200810394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP21750 PILGRIM INS CO 43982 MT WA ASSUR CORP

200710394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP21750 PILGRIM INS CO 43982 MT WA ASSUR CORP

200610394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP21750 PILGRIM INS CO 43982 MT WASHINGTON ASSUR CORP

200510394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP21750 PILGRIM INS CO 43982 MT WASHINGTON ASSUR CORP

200010394 BUNKER HILL INS CO 14737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP21750 PILGRIM INS CO 43982 MT WASHINGTON ASSUR CORP

199514737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP 21750 PILGRIM INS CO43982 MT WASHINGTON ASSUR CORP

199014737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP 21750 PILGRIM INS CO43982 MT WASHINGTON ASSUR CORP

198514737 PLYMOUTH ROCK ASSUR CORP

417 Group Name:Group Code: EQUIBEN INS GRP1995

12270 PENNSYLVANIA REIN CO 17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO1990

12270 PENNSYLVANIA REIN CO 17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO31410 INCOME SECURITY INS CO

198512270 PENNSYLVANIA REIN CO 17965 AMERICAN SENTINEL INS CO

418 Group Name:Group Code: HICA GRP2000

10047 HICA SURETY CORP 34550 HEMAR INS CORP OF AMER1995

10047 HICA SURETY CORP 34550 HEMAR INS CORP OF AMER1990

34550 HEMAR INS CORP OF AMER419 Group Name:Group Code: ARKWRIGHT BOSTON

199521490 ARKWRIGHT MUT INS CO 31887 ARKWRIGHT INS CO

199021490 ARKWRIGHT MUT INS CO 31887 ARKWRIGHT INS CO

198521490 ARKWRIGHT MUT INS CO 31887 ARKWRIGHT INS CO

421 Group Name:Group Code: COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP2009

10217 TRIAD GUAR ASSUR CORP 24350 TRIAD GUAR INS CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners347

Page 356: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

421 Group Name:Group Code: COLLATERAL HOLDINGS GRP2008

10217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 11354 TRIAD RE INS CORP24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

200710217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 11354 TRIAD RE INS CORP24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

200610217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 11354 TRIAD RE INS CORP24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

200510217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 11354 TRIAD RE INS CORP24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

200010217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

199510217 TRIAD GUARANTY ASSUR CORP 24350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

199024350 TRIAD GUARANTY INS CORP

423 Group Name:Group Code: EAGLE PACIFIC INS GRP1995

36986 EAGLE PACIFIC INS CO 40380 PACIFIC EAGLE INS CO1990

36986 EAGLE PACIFIC INS CO 40380 PACIFIC EAGLE INS CO1985

36986 EAGLE PACIFIC INS CO428 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST HEARTLD INVE

199530996 MINNESOTA TRUST CO OF AUSTIN 32212 FIRST HEARTLAND SUR & CAS INS CO

199030996 MINNESOTA TRUST CO OF AUSTIN 32212 FIRST HEARTLAND SUR & CAS INS CO

198530996 MINNESOTA TRUST CO OF AUSTIN 32212 FIRST HEARTLAND SUR & CAS INS CO

433 Group Name:Group Code: MEDCO CONTAINMENT SERV GRP1995

18750 MEDCO INSURANCE COMPANY 34720 MEDCO CONTAINMENT INS CO OF NY435 Group Name:Group Code: MASS MUT LIFE INS GRP

198510774 MML SYNDICATE INC

441 Group Name:Group Code: ACCELERATION CORP1995

35742 ACCELERATION NATL INS CO1990

35742 ACCELERATION NATL INS CO1985

35742 ACCELERATION NATL INS CO446 Group Name:Group Code: WATERMAN GRP

199023698 GOVERNMENTAL CAS INS CO 30392 AMERICAN COMMERCIAL LIABILITY INS

198523698 GOVERNMENTAL CAS INS CO 30392 AMERICAN COMMERCIAL LIABILITY INS

447 Group Name:Group Code: HARFORD GRP2009

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO2008

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO2007

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners348

Page 357: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

447 Group Name:Group Code: HARFORD GRP2006

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO2005

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO2000

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO1995

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO1990

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO 40100 FIRSTLINE NATL INS CO1985

14141 HARFORD MUT INS CO450 Group Name:Group Code: GENEVE HOLDINGS INC GRP

200926581 INDEPENDENCE AMER INS CO

200726581 INDEPENDENCE AMER INS CO

200626581 INDEPENDENCE AMER INS CO

200526581 INDEPENDENCE AMER INS CO

456 Group Name:Group Code: LANCER FINANCIAL GRP2009

26077 LANCER INS CO 29548 WESTERN IND INS CO34266 FRONTIER INS CO 38148 NORTH SEA INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

457 Group Name:Group Code: ARGONAUT GRP2009

10726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 19801 ARGONAUT INS CO19828 ARGONAUT MIDWEST INS CO 19836 SELECT MARKETS INS CO19844 ARGONAUT SW INS CO 19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS CO26409 ARGONAUT LTD RISK INS CO 34118 COLONY NATL INS CO35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO 36927 COLONY SPECIALTY INS CO39993 COLONY INS CO

200810726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 19801 ARGONAUT INS CO19828 ARGONAUT MIDWEST INS CO 19836 SELECT MARKETS INS CO19844 ARGONAUT SW INS CO 19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS CO26409 ARGONAUT LTD RISK INS CO 34118 COLONY NATL INS CO35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO 36927 COLONY SPECIALTY INS CO39993 COLONY INS CO

200710726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 19801 ARGONAUT INS CO19828 ARGONAUT MIDWEST INS CO 19836 SELECT MARKETS INS CO19844 ARGONAUT SW INS CO 19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS CO26409 ARGONAUT LTD RISK INS CO 29807 PXRE REINS CO34118 COLONY NATL INS CO 35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO36927 COLONY SPECIALTY INS CO 39993 COLONY INS CO

200610726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 19801 ARGONAUT INS CO19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO 19836 SELECT MARKETS INS CO19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO 19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS CO26409 ARGONAUT LTD RISK INS CO 34118 COLONY NATL INS CO35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO 36927 COLONY SPECIALTY INS CO39993 COLONY INS CO

200510726 SOMERSET CAS INS CO 19801 ARGONAUT INS CO19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO 19836 SELECT MARKETS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners349

Page 358: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

457 Group Name:Group Code: ARGONAUT GRP2005

19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO 19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS CO26409 ARGONAUT LTD RISK INS CO 34118 COLONY NATL INS CO35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO 36927 COLONY SPECIALTY INS CO39993 COLONY INS CO

200019801 ARGONAUT INS CO 19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO19836 ARGONAUT-NW INS CO 19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS COMPANY

199519801 ARGONAUT INS CO 19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO19836 ARGONAUT-NW INS CO 19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO19860 ARGONAUT GREAT CENTRAL INS COMPANY 26409 GEORGIA INS CO

199019801 ARGONAUT INS CO 19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO19836 ARGONAUT-NW INS CO 19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO19860 GREAT CENTRAL INS CO 26409 GEORGIA INS CO

198519801 ARGONAUT INS CO 19828 ARGONAUT-MIDWEST INS CO19836 ARGONAUT-NW INS CO 19844 ARGONAUT-SOUTHWEST INS CO19860 GREAT CENTRAL INS CO 26409 GEORGIA INS CO

458 Group Name:Group Code: PROTECTIVE LIFE INS GRP2009

12492 TOWER CAPTIVE INS CO 35769 LYNDON PROP INS CO2008

12492 TOWER CAPTIVE INS CO 35769 LYNDON PROP INS CO2007

12492 TOWER CAPTIVE INS CO 35769 LYNDON PROP INS CO2006

12492 TOWER CAPTIVE INS CO 35769 LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO2005

10051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 35769 LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO2000

10051 LYNDON SOUTHERN INS CO 30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CAS INS CO35769 LYNDON PROPERTY INS CO

459 Group Name:Group Code: NATL HLTH ASSOC1985

20958 UNITED GENERAL INS CO460 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAS GRP

200010035 AMERICAS SURPLUS LINES INS CO 27898 AMERICAS INS CO

199510035 AMERICAS SURPLUS LINES INS CO 27898 AMERICAS INS CO

199027898 AMERICAS INS CO

198527898 AMERICAS INS CO

464 Group Name:Group Code: PHYSICIANS INS A MUT GRP2009

10942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO2008

10942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO2007

10942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO2006

10942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 32417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners350

Page 359: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

464 Group Name:Group Code: PHYSICIANS INS A MUT GRP2005

10942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 32417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO

200010942 WESTERN PROFESSIONAL INS CO 32417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO40738 PHYSICIANS INS A MUT CO

199532417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO 40738 PHYSICIANS INSURANCE EXCHANGE

199032417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO 40738 WASHINGTON STATE PHYSICIANS INS EXCH

198540738 WASHINGTON STATE PHYSICIANS INS EXCH

465 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN BANKERS FL GRP1995

10111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 18570 FINANCIAL INS EXCH19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO 30590 CARIBBEAN AMERICAN PROPERTY INS CO31011 NATIONAL UNITED INS CO 35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO

199010111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 18570 FINANCIAL INS EXCH19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO 31011 NATIONAL UNITED INS CO35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO

198510111 AMERICAN BANKERS INS CO OF FL 18570 FINANCIAL INS EXCH19615 AMERICAN RELIABLE INS CO 31011 NATIONAL UNITED INS CO35971 VOYAGER PROPERTY & CAS INS CO 40428 VOYAGER IND INS CO

468 Group Name:Group Code: AEGON US HOLDING GRP2009

10952 STONEBRIDGE CAS INS CO2008

10952 STONEBRIDGE CASUALTY INS CO2007

10952 STONEBRIDGE CASUALTY INS CO2006

10952 STONEBRIDGE CASUALTY INS CO2005

10952 STONEBRIDGE CASUALTY INS CO2000

31232 MONUMENTAL GENERAL CAS CO 35165 CORPA REIN CO1995

10553 TRANSUNION CASUALTY CO 31232 MONUMENTAL GENERAL CAS CO35165 CORPA REIN CO

199010553 TRANSUNION CASUALTY CO 31232 MONUMENTAL GENERAL CAS CO35165 CORPA REIN CO

198510553 TRANSUNION CASUALTY CO 31232 MONUMENTAL GENERAL CAS CO35165 CORPA REIN CO

471 Group Name:Group Code: WELLS FARGO GRP2009

10534 SUPERIOR GUAR INS CO 11279 GREAT PLAINS INS CO11345 NORTH STAR MORTGAGE GUAR REINS CO 11486 GOLDEN PACIFIC INS CO39039 RURAL COMM INS CO 39527 HERITAGE IND CO42765 CENTURION CAS CO

200810534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 11279 GREAT PLAINS INS CO11345 NORTH STAR MORTGAGE GUAR REINS CO 11486 GOLDEN PACIFIC INS CO39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners351

Page 360: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

471 Group Name:Group Code: WELLS FARGO GRP2008

39527 HERITAGE IND CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO2007

10534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 11279 GREAT PLAINS INS CO11345 NORTH STAR MORTGAGE GUAR REINS CO 11486 GOLDEN PACIFIC INS CO39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO

200610534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 11279 GREAT PLAINS INS CO11345 NORTH STAR MORTGAGE GUARANTY REINS 11486 GOLDEN PACIFIC INS CO39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO

200510534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 11279 GREAT PLAINS INS CO11345 NORTH STAR MORTGAGE GUARANTY REINS 11486 GOLDEN PACIFIC INS CO39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO

200010534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO42765 CENTURION CAS CO

199510534 SUPERIOR GUARANTY INS CO 39039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO42765 CENTURION CAS CO 44563 CHM INS CO

199039039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO44563 CHM INS CO

198539039 RURAL COMMUNITY INS CO 42765 CENTURION CAS CO

472 Group Name:Group Code: WARRIOR INS GRP2000

35220 VALOR INSURANCE COMPANY 39268 GALLANT INSURANCE COMPANY1995

35220 VALOR INSURANCE COMPANY 39268 GALLANT INSURANCE COMPANY1990

35220 HALLBERG DIRECT INS CO 39268 ALLIED AMERICAN INS CO1985

39268 ALLIED AMERICAN INS CO473 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP

200910386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF WI

200810386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF WI

200710386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF WI

200610386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI

200510386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI

200010386 AMERICAN FAMILY INS CO 10387 AMERICAN STANDARD INS CO OF OH19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI

199519275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI

199019275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners352

Page 361: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

473 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP1985

19275 AMERICAN FAMILY MUT INS CO 19283 AMERICAN STD INS CO OF WI474 Group Name:Group Code: FCCI MUT INS GRP

200910178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO12842 FCCI ADVANTAGE INS CO 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO32506 MONROE GUAR INS CO 33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

200810178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO12842 FCCI ADVANTAGE INS CO 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO32506 MONROE GUAR INS CO 33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

200710178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO12842 FCCI ADVANTAGE INS CO 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO32506 MONROE GUAR INS CO 33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

200610178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO12842 FCCI ADVANTAGE INS CO 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO32506 MONROE GUARANTY INS CO 33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

200510178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO 32506 MONROE GUARANTY INS CO33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

200010178 FCCI INS CO 10993 BRIERFIELD INS CO20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO 32506 MONROE GUARANTY INS CO33472 FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO

199510178 FCCI MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO

198510178 FCCI MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 20141 NATIONAL TRUST INS CO

475 Group Name:Group Code: TRUST INS GRP1995

10055 TRUST ASSUR CO 27227 TRUST INS CO1990

27227 TRUST INS CO479 Group Name:Group Code: IFG CO GRP

200910956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FIN INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

200810956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FIN INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

200710956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FIN INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

200610956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

200510956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

200010956 GUILFORD INS CO 10957 ALAMANCE INS CO11177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 13633 COLONIAL COOPERATIVE INS CO23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

199511177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners353

Page 362: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

479 Group Name:Group Code: IFG CO GRP1990

11177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO1985

11177 FIRST FINANCIAL INS CO 23620 BURLINGTON INS CO480 Group Name:Group Code: PARTHANON GRP

199533359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO

199033359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO

198533359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 33413 PARTHENON INS CO

481 Group Name:Group Code: PRESBYTERIAN HLTHCARE SERV GRP1995

33529 GREAT STATES INS CO1990

33529 GREAT STATES INS CO482 Group Name:Group Code: PELICAN GRP

199021920 PELICAN STATE MUT INS 36218 MAGNOLIA FIRE & CAS INS CO

483 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP2009

10058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO21817 FLORIDA FARM BUR GEN INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200810058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 13004 TEXAS FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 21817 FLORIDA FARM BUR GEN INS CO27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200710058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 13004 TEXAS FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 21817 FLORIDA FARM BUR GEN INS CO27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200610058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO21817 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUTL INS CO OF TX 31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200510058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO21817 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUTL INS CO OF TX 31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200010058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO21817 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUTL INS CO OF TX 31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

199510058 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU PROP 18325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO21817 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU GENERAL INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

199018325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

198518325 SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 27669 MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners354

Page 363: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

483 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHERN FARM BUREAU CAS GRP1985

31216 FLORIDA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 40924 LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO484 Group Name:Group Code: CLARENDON INS GRP

199510175 CASCADE NATL INS CO 10260 BALTIMORE CAS INS CO12530 PEGASUS INS CO 20532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO21024 TWICKENHAM INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY22560 WINSTON INS CO 43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

199010260 BALTIMORE CAS INS CO 10880 LIGONIER INS CO12530 PEGASUS INS CO 20532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO21024 TWICKENHAM INS CO 21806 FIRST OF GEORGIA INS CO22560 WINSTON INS CO 43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

198510260 BALTIMORE CAS INS CO 10880 LIGONIER INS CO12530 PEGASUS INS CO 20532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO21024 TWICKENHAM INS CO 21806 FIRST OF GEORGIA INS CO22560 WINSTON INS CO 43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

486 Group Name:Group Code: JEFFERSON INS CO1995

11630 JEFFERSON INS CO489 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL SAVINGS GRP

200731178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

200631178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

200531178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

200031178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

199531178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

199031178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

198531178 MUTUAL SAVINGS FIRE INS CO

490 Group Name:Group Code: WISCONSIN RE GRP2009

30260 WISCONSIN REINS CORP 44725 1ST AUTO & CAS INS CO2007

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP 44725 1ST AUTO & CAS INS CO2006

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP 44725 1ST AUTO & CAS INS CO2005

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP 44725 1ST AUTO & CAS INS CO2000

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP 44725 FIRST AUTO & CASUALTY INS CO1995

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP 44725 FIRST AUTO & CASUALTY INS CO1990

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP1985

30260 WISCONSIN REIN CORP494 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED FIRE GRP

198542528 UNITED FIRE INS CO

497 Group Name:Group Code: BLACKSTONE FIN GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners355

Page 364: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

497 Group Name:Group Code: BLACKSTONE FIN GRP2009

14931 PAWTUCKET INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO2007

14931 PAWTUCKET INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO2006

14931 PAWTUCKET INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO2005

14931 PAWTUCKET INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO2000

14931 PAWTUCKET MUT INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO1995

14931 PAWTUCKET MUT INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO1990

14931 PAWTUCKET MUT INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO1985

14931 PAWTUCKET MUT INS CO 43001 NARRAGANSETT BAY INS CO498 Group Name:Group Code: US LIFE CORP

199524376 USLIFE INDEMNITY CO

199024376 USLIFE INDEMNITY CO

500 Group Name:Group Code: AUTOMATED FNCL SVC2000

10359 AUTOMATED FINANCIAL IND CO1995

10359 AUTOMATED FINANCIAL IND CO1990

10359 AUTOMATED FINANCIAL IND CO501 Group Name:Group Code: ALLEGHANY GRP

200910328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP10745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL11156 HOMESITE INS CO OF FL 11237 HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX11555 EMPLOYERS DIRECT INS CO 12640 AIHL RE LLC13027 COVINGTON SPECIALTY INS CO 13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST17221 HOMESITE INS CO 18619 PLATTE RIVER INS CO20419 HOMESITE IND CO 22314 RSUI IND CO33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO

200810328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP10745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL11156 HOMESITE INS CO OF FL 11237 HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX11555 EMPLOYERS DIRECT INS CO 12640 AIHL RE LLC13027 COVINGTON SPECIALTY INS CO 13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST17221 HOMESITE INS CO 18619 PLATTE RIVER INS CO20419 HOMESITE IND CO 22314 RSUI IND CO33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO

200710328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP11555 EMPLOYERS DIRECT INS CO 12640 AIHL RE LLC13027 COVINGTON SPECIALTY INS CO 16624 DARWIN NATL ASSUR CO18619 PLATTE RIVER INS CO. 22314 RSUI IND CO24319 DARWIN SELECT INS CO 33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO44768 MIDWAY INS CO OF IL

200610328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners356

Page 365: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

501 Group Name:Group Code: ALLEGHANY GRP2006

12640 AIHL RE LLC 16624 DARWIN NATL ASSUR CO18619 PLATTE RIVER INS CO. 22314 RSUI IND CO24319 DARWIN SELECT INS CO 33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO

200510328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP16624 DARWIN NATL ASSUR CP 18619 PLATTE RIVER INS CO.22314 RSUI IND CO 24319 DARWIN SELECT INS CO33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO

200010328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP

199510328 CAPITOL SPECIALTY INS CORP 10472 CAPITOL IND CORP

199010472 CAPITOL IND CORP

198510472 CAPITOL IND CORP

503 Group Name:Group Code: LANDCAR INS GRP2009

37109 LANDCAR CAS CO2007

37109 LANDCAR CAS CO2006

37109 LANDCAR CAS CO2005

37109 LANDCAR CAS CO2000

37109 LANDCAR CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY1995

37109 LANDCAR CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY1990

37109 LANDCAR INS CO OF COLORADO505 Group Name:Group Code: EMPLOYERS OF AL GRP

199011010 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF AL INC

198511010 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF AL INC

506 Group Name:Group Code: INDEMNITY UNDERWRITERS GRP1990

27979 INTERNATIONAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 33146 INDEMNITY UNDERWRITERS INS CO37559 UNDERWRITERS LLOYDS INS CO

198527979 INTERNATIONAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO 33146 INDEMNITY UNDERWRITERS INS CO

508 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONAL GRP2009

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 OMS NATL INS CO RRG2008

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 OMS NATL INS CO RRG2007

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 OMS NATL INS CO RRG2006

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 OMS NATL INS CO RRG2005

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 OMS NATL INS CO RRG2000

10801 FORTRESS INS CO 44121 AAOMS NATL INS CO RRG

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners357

Page 366: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

508 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONAL GRP1995

12513 FORTRESS INS CO OF AMERICA 44121 AAOMS NATIONAL INS CO RRG1990

12513 FORTRESS INS CO OF AMERICA 44121 AAOMS NATIONAL INS CO RRG1985

12513 FORTRESS INS CO OF AMERICA510 Group Name:Group Code: NAVIGATORS GRP

200936056 NAVIGATORS SPECIALTY INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

200836056 NAVIGATORS SPECIALTY INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

200736056 NAVIGATORS SPECIALTY INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

200636056 NIC INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

200536056 NIC INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

200036056 NIC INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

199536056 NIC INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

199036056 NIC INS CO 42307 NAVIGATORS INS CO

512 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN TRANSIT INS GRP2000

16616 AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO1995

16616 AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO1990

16616 AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO1985

16616 AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO513 Group Name:Group Code: IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP

200913773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

200813773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

200713773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

200613773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21539 KFB INS CO INC27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

200513773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 21539 KFB INS CO INC27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

200013773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 15369 WESTERN FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO15733 UTAH FARM BUREAU INS CO 27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

199513773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 15369 WESTERN FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO15733 UTAH FARM BUREAU INS CO 27782 SOUTH DAKOTA FARM BUR MUT INS CO27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

199013773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 15369 WESTERN FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO15733 UTAH FARM BUREAU INS CO 27782 SOUTH DAKOTA FARM BUR MUT INS CO27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners358

Page 367: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

513 Group Name:Group Code: IOWA FARM BUREAU GRP1985

13773 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 15369 WESTERN FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO15733 UTAH FARM BUREAU INS CO 27782 SOUTH DAKOTA FARM BUR MUT INS CO27871 WESTERN AGRIC INS CO

514 Group Name:Group Code: MISSOURI FARM BUREAU GRP2009

12345 FARM BUREAU NEW HORIZONS INS CO OF M 26859 FARM BUREAU TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO OF2008

12345 FARM BUREAU NEW HORIZONS INS CO OF M 26859 FARM BUREAU TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO OF2007

12345 FARM BUREAU NEW HORIZONS INS CO OF M 26859 FARM BUREAU TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO OF2006

12345 FARM BUREAU NEW HORIZONS INS CO OF M 26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO2005

12345 FARM BUREAU NEW HORIZONS INS CO OF M 26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO2000

26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO1995

26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO1990

26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO1985

26859 FARM BUR TOWN & COUNTRY INS CO MO515 Group Name:Group Code: EAGLE INS GRP

200510928 EAGLE INS CO 11576 GSA INS CO22937 NATIONAL CONSUMER INS CO 24643 NEWARK INS CO26675 URBAN INS CO OF PA 28991 COLONIAL IND INS CO42340 LION INS CO

200010928 EAGLE INS CO 11576 GSA INS CO22937 NATIONAL CONSUMER INS CO 24643 NEWARK INS CO26675 URBAN INS CO OF PA 28991 COLONIAL IND INS CO42340 LION INS CO

199510928 EAGLE INS CO 11576 GSA INS CO22937 NATIONAL CONSUMER INS CO 24643 NEWARK INS CO26675 URBAN INS CO OF PA 28991 COLONIAL IND INS CO42340 LION INS CO

199010928 EAGLE INS CO 11576 GSA INS CO24643 NEWARK INS CO 28991 COLONIAL IND INS CO42340 LION INS CO

198510928 EAGLE INS CO 11576 GSA INS CO24643 NEWARK INS CO 28991 COLONIAL IND INS CO

516 Group Name:Group Code: CENTURY AMER INS GRP1995

11711 CENTURY AMERICAN CASUALTY CO 34762 CENTURY AMERICAN INS CO1990

11711 LAWYERS SURETY CORP1985

11711 LAWYERS SURETY CORP517 Group Name:Group Code: HANNOVER GRP

200920532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INS CO22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS CO 41343 HDI GERLING AMER INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners359

Page 368: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

517 Group Name:Group Code: HANNOVER GRP2009

43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO2008

20532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INS CO22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS CO 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

200720532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INS CO22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS CO 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

200620532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INS CO22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS CO 37257 PRAETORIAN INS CO37303 REDLAND INS CO 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO 44776 PRAETORIAN SPECIALTY INS CO

200520532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO 21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INS CO22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS CO 37257 INSURANCE CORP OF HANNOVER37303 REDLAND INS CO 43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

200011075 LION INS CO 20532 CLARENDON NATL INS CO21806 HARBOR SPECIALTY INSURANCE COMPANY 22560 CLARENDON SELECT INS COMPANY37257 INSURANCE CORP OF HANNOVER 37303 REDLAND INS CO43095 CLARENDON AMER INS CO

199537257 INSURANCE CORP OF HANNOVER

199037257 INSURANCE CORP OF HANNOVER

198537257 INSURANCE CORP OF HANNOVER

518 Group Name:Group Code: GRINNELL MUT GRP2009

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO2008

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO2007

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO2006

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO2005

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO2000

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO1995

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO1990

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO1985

14117 GRINNELL MUT REINS CO 16144 GRINNELL SELECT INS CO519 Group Name:Group Code: SKANDIA AMER GRP

200036617 CAPITAL ASSUR CO INC

199525054 HUDSON INS CO 25070 SKANDIA AMERICA REINSURANCE CORP26107 SKANDIA US INSURANCE COMPANY 29602 CAPITAL ALLIANCE INS CO INC36617 CAPITAL ASSUR CO INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners360

Page 369: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

519 Group Name:Group Code: SKANDIA AMER GRP1990

25054 HUDSON INS CO 25070 SKANDIA AMERICA REINSURANCE CORP26107 SKANDIA US INSURANCE COMPANY 29602 CAPITAL ALLIANCE INS CO INC36595 AMERICAN EUROPEAN REINS CORP 36617 CAPITAL ASSUR CO INC37230 VESTA AMERICAN REINS CORP

198525054 HUDSON INS CO 25070 SKANDIA AMERICA REINSURANCE CORP26107 SKANDIA US INSURANCE COMPANY 29602 CAPITAL ALLIANCE INS CO INC36595 AMERICAN EUROPEAN REINS CORP 36617 CAPITAL ASSUR CO INC37230 VESTA AMERICAN REINS CORP

521 Group Name:Group Code: CONSUMERS INS GRP1990

28975 CONSUMERS INS CO1985

28975 CONSUMERS INS CO528 Group Name:Group Code: MBIA GRP

200912041 MBIA INS CORP 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSUR CORP23825 NATIONAL PUBLIC FINANCE GUAR CORP

200812041 MBIA INS CORP 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSUR CORP23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

200712041 MBIA INS CORP 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSUR CORP23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

200612041 MBIA INS CORP 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

200512041 MBIA INS CORP 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

200012041 MBIA INSURANCE COMPANY 20877 CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

199512041 MBIA INSURANCE COMPANY 23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

199012041 MUNICIPAL BOND INVESTORS ASSUR CORP 23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

198512041 MUNICIPAL BOND INVESTORS ASSUR CORP 23825 MBIA INS CORP OF IL

529 Group Name:Group Code: ICH CORP GRP2000

23132 BANKERS MULTIPLE LINE INS CO1995

23132 BANKERS MULTIPLE LINE INS CO1990

23132 BANKERS MULTIPLE LINE INS CO1985

23132 BANKERS MULTIPLE LINE INS CO530 Group Name:Group Code: AIM INS GRP

199033692 IDAHO CAS INS CO INC

532 Group Name:Group Code: CAMERON MUT GRP2009

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO2008

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners361

Page 370: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

532 Group Name:Group Code: CAMERON MUT GRP2007

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO2006

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO2005

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO2000

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO1995

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO1990

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO1985

15725 CAMERON MUT INS CO 42498 CAMERON NATL INS CO533 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUREAU MUT GRP

200915164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

200815164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

200715164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

200615164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

200515164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

200015164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

199515164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO 42393 PALMETTO CAS INS CO

199015164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

198515164 SOUTH CAROLINA FARM BUR MUT INS CO

536 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF FL GRP2009

10834 COMP OPTIONS INS CO INC2007

10834 COMP OPTIONS INS CO INC2006

10834 COMP OPTIONS INS CO INC2005

10834 COMP OPTIONS INS CO INC2000

10834 COMP OPTIONS INS CO INC540 Group Name:Group Code: WACO INS CO

199519003 WACO FIRE & CAS INS CO

199019003 WACO FIRE & CAS INS CO

198519003 WACO FIRE & CAS INS CO

541 Group Name:Group Code: SPECTERA INS GRP2000

33570 SPECTERA INSURANCE COMPANY1995

33570 UNITED HEALTHCARE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners362

Page 371: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

541 Group Name:Group Code: SPECTERA INS GRP1990

33570 UNITED HEALTHCARE INS CO542 Group Name:Group Code: INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP

200910022 COUNTRYWAY INS CO 15288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUT INS CO23868 UFB CAS INS CO

200810022 COUNTRYWAY INS CO 15288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUT INS CO23868 UFB CAS INS CO

200710022 COUNTRYWAY INS CO 15288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUT INS CO23868 UFB CAS INS CO

200610022 COUNTRYWAY INS CO 15288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUT INS CO23868 UFB CAS INS CO

200510022 COUNTRYWAY INS CO 15288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUT INS CO23868 UFB CAS INS CO

200015288 UNITED FARM FAMILY MUTUAL INS CO 23868 UFB CAS INS CO

199515288 UNITED FARM BUREAU MUTUAL INS CO 23868 UFB CAS INS CO

199015288 UNITED FARM BUREAU MUTUAL INS CO 23868 UFB CAS INS CO

198515288 UNITED FARM BUREAU MUTUAL INS CO 23868 UFB CAS INS CO

544 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS CAS GRP1995

13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO 31976 MID-PLAINS INS CO1990

13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO 31976 MID-PLAINS INS CO1985

13811 FARMERS CAS INS CO545 Group Name:Group Code: OAKLEY INS GRP

199537184 FIRST REINSURANCE CO OF HARTFORD

553 Group Name:Group Code: ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP2009

24678 ARROWOOD IND CO 41807 ARROWOOD SURPLUS LINES INS CO2008

24678 ARROWOOD IND CO 41807 ARROWOOD SURPLUS LINES INS CO2007

24678 ARROWOOD IND CO 41807 ARROWOOD SURPLUS LINES INS CO2006

24678 ROYAL IND CO 24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO

200511401 GUARANTY NATL INS CO 24678 ROYAL IND CO24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD 29998 MARINE IND INS CO OF AMER41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO

200010733 FINANCIAL STRUCTURES INS CO 11401 GUARANTY NATL INS CO13137 VIKING INS CO OF WI 15610 CONNECTICUT SPLTY INS CO18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP 18260 DESIGN PROFS INS CO19534 UNISUN INS CO 19542 CAROLINA AMERICAN INS CO20273 ALLIANCE ASSUR CO OF AMER 20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC20354 SEA INS CO OF AMER 20370 ROYAL & SUNALLIANCE PERSONAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners363

Page 372: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

553 Group Name:Group Code: ARROWPOINT CAPITAL GRP2000

24589 AMERICAN & FOREIGN INS CO 24600 GLOBE IND CO24678 ROYAL IND CO 24694 SAFEGUARD INS CO24872 CONNECTICUT IND CO 24880 FIRE & CAS INS CO OF CT24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD 26860 ATLANTIC SECURITY INS CO26948 GUARANTY NATIONAL INS CO OF CT 26980 ROYAL INS CO OF AMER27915 TARIFF REIN LTD US BRANCH 29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO29998 MARINE IND INS CO OF AMER 32794 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INS CO33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO 35262 PHOENIX ASSUR CO OF NY37010 ATLANTIC IND CO 37818 ORION INSURANCE COMPANY40541 GROCERS INS CO 41807 ROYAL SURPLUS LINES INS CO42684 EBI IND CO 43346 ROYAL LLOYDS OF TX

199520273 ALLIANCE ASSUR CO OF AMER 20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC20354 SEA INS CO OF AMER 20370 ROYAL & SUNALLIANCE PERSONAL INS CO27915 TARIFF REIN LTD US BRANCH 29998 MARINE IND INS CO OF AMER35262 PHOENIX ASSUR CO OF NY

199020273 ALLIANCE ASSUR CO OF AMER 20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC20354 SEA INS CO OF AMER 20370 ROYAL & SUNALLIANCE PERSONAL INS CO29998 MARINE IND INS CO OF AMER 35262 PHOENIX ASSUR CO OF NY

198520273 ALLIANCE ASSUR CO OF AMER 20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC20354 SEA INS CO OF AMER 20370 ROYAL & SUNALLIANCE PERSONAL INS CO29998 MARINE IND INS CO OF AMER 35262 PHOENIX ASSUR CO OF NY

554 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHERN UNITED1995

12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO1990

12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO1985

12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO556 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FEED INS GRP

200012548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 44202 AMERICAN FEED INDUSTRY INS CO RRG

199510038 AMERICAN FEED INS CO 44202 AMERICAN FEED INDUSTRY INS CO RRG

199012548 INSURANCE CO OF PRAIRIE STATES 44202 AMERICAN FEED INDUSTRY INS CO RRG

198512548 INSURANCE CO OF PRAIRIE STATES

559 Group Name:Group Code: NOBEL INS GRP1990

16500 NOBEL LLOYDS INS CO 44040 LPG RRG INS CO1985

16500 NOBEL LLOYDS INS CO 26840 NORTH AMERICAN NOBEL INS CO561 Group Name:Group Code: GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP

200914001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200814001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200714001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200614001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

200514001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners364

Page 373: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

561 Group Name:Group Code: GEORGIA FARM BUREAU GRP2000

14001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO1995

14001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO1990

14001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 34436 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO1985

14001 GEORGIA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO562 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN COLONIAL

199510146 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO

198510146 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO

567 Group Name:Group Code: FORTUNE FINANCIAL INC2000

12530 PEGASUS INS CO 28045 FORTUNE INS CO1995

28045 FORTUNE INS CO1990

28045 FORTUNE INS CO1985

28045 FORTUNE INS CO568 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL ASSUR CO

200023272 MEDICAL ASSURANCE OF W VIRGINIA INC 33391 MEDICAL ASSUR CO INC

199523272 MEDICAL ASSURANCE OF W VIRGINIA INC 33391 MUTUAL ASSURANCE INC36668 MISSOURI MEDICAL INS CO 41254 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF INDIANA

199023272 WEST VIRGINIA HOSPITAL INS CO 33391 MUTUAL ASSURANCE INC36668 MISSOURI MEDICAL INS CO 41254 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF INDIANA

198523272 WEST VIRGINIA HOSPITAL INS CO 33391 MUTUAL ASSURANCE INC36668 MISSOURI MEDICAL INS CO 41254 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF INDIANA

569 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS MUT HAIL INS GRP2009

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOP INS CO2008

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOP INS CO2007

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOP INS CO2006

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOP INS CO2005

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOPERATIVE INS CO NE2000

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOPERATIVE INS CO NE1995

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOPERATIVE INS CO NE1990

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOPERATIVE INS CO NE1985

13897 FARMERS MUT HAIL INS CO OF IA 16381 FARMERS UNION COOPERATIVE INS CO NE572 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF MI GRP

200910166 ACCIDENT FUND INS CO OF AMER 10713 THIRD COAST INS CO12177 COMPWEST INS CO 12304 ACCIDENT FUND GEN INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners365

Page 374: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

572 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF MI GRP2009

12305 ACCIDENT FUND NATL INS CO 29157 UNITED WI INS CO2008

10166 ACCIDENT FUND INS CO OF AMER 10713 THIRD COAST INS CO12177 COMPWEST INS CO 12304 ACCIDENT FUND GEN INS CO12305 ACCIDENT FUND NATL INS CO 29157 UNITED WI INS CO

200710166 ACCIDENT FUND INS CO OF AMER 10713 THIRD COAST INS CO12177 COMPWEST INS CO 12304 ACCIDENT FUND GEN INS CO12305 ACCIDENT FUND NATL INS CO 29157 UNITED WI INS CO

200610166 ACCIDENT FUND INS CO OF AMER 12304 ACCIDENT FUND GENERAL INS CO12305 ACCIDENT FUND NATIONAL INS CO 29157 UNITED WI INS CO

200510166 ACCIDENT FUND INS CO OF AMER 12304 ACCIDENT FUND GENERAL INS CO12305 ACCIDENT FUND NATIONAL INS CO 29157 UNITED WI INS CO

200010166 ACCIDENT FUND CO

199510166 ACCIDENT FUND CO

574 Group Name:Group Code: AMERCO CORP GRP2009

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO2008

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO2007

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO2006

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO2005

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO2000

10027 NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO1995

31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO1990

11720 REPUBLIC WESTERN SYNDICATE INC 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO1985

11720 REPUBLIC WESTERN SYNDICATE INC 31089 REPUBLIC WESTERN INS CO575 Group Name:Group Code: PAULA INS GRP

200032115 PAULA INS CO

199532115 PAULA INS CO

199032115 PAULA INS CO

198532115 PAULA INS CO

583 Group Name:Group Code: GUARANTY NATL CORP GRP1995

11401 GUARANTY NATL INS CO 13137 VIKING INS CO OF WI18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP 26948 GUARANTY NATL INSURANCE CO OF CA29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO 33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO

199011401 GUARANTY NATL INS CO 13137 VIKING INS CO OF WI18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP 26948 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE CO OF CA

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners366

Page 375: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

583 Group Name:Group Code: GUARANTY NATL CORP GRP1990

29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO 33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO

198511401 GUARANTY NATL INS CO 13137 VIKING INS CO OF WI18139 PEAK PROP & CAS INS CORP 26948 GENERAL ELECTRIC MORTGAGE CO OF CA29238 VIKING CNTY MUT INS CO 33138 LANDMARK AMER INS CO41785 COLORADO CAS INS CO

585 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FMRS IOWA1985

13315 AMERICAN FARMERS MUT CAS CO586 Group Name:Group Code: ARBELLA INS GRP

200910017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10230 COMMONWEALTH REINS CO 10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO 41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

200810017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10230 COMMONWEALTH REINS CO 10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO 41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

200710017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10230 COMMONWEALTH REINS CO 10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO 41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

200610017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10230 COMMONWEALTH REIN CO 10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO 41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

200510017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10230 COMMONWEALTH REIN CO 10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO 41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

200010017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 10062 COVENANT INS CO10231 COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO 17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

199510017 ARBELLA IND INS CO 17000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO41360 ARBELLA PROTECTION INS CO

199017000 ARBELLA MUT INS CO

587 Group Name:Group Code: ATLANTIC AMER GRP2009

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO2008

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO2007

10235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO 35629 ASSOCIATION CAS INS CO

200610235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO 35629 ASSOCIATION CAS INS CO

200510235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO 35629 ASSOCIATION CAS INS CO

200010235 AMERICAN SOUTHERN INS CO 11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO33103 AMERICAN SAFETY INS CO 35629 ASSOCIATION CASUALTY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners367

Page 376: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

587 Group Name:Group Code: ATLANTIC AMER GRP1995

11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO1990

11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO1985

11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO594 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS GRP

200912300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 ACIG INS CO

200712300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 ACIG INS CO

200612300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 ACIG INS CO

200512300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 ACIG INS CO

200012300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 AMERICAN RISK FUNDING INS CO

199512300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 AMERICAN RISK FUNDING INS CO

199012300 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS INS CO RRG 19984 AMERICAN RISK FUNDING INS CO

595 Group Name:Group Code: HARVARD PILGRIM HTH CARE GRP2000

18975 HARVARD PILGRIM INS CO INC 23137 FIRST RETURN INSURANCE COMPANY1995

18975 HCHP INSURANCE COMPANY598 Group Name:Group Code: DELTA GRP

200910898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

200810898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

200710898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

200610898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

200510898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

200010898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

199510898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

199010898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

198510898 DELTA FIRE & CAS INS CO

602 Group Name:Group Code: PRS INS GRP1995

10297 GENERAL AUTO INS CO (THE) 12912 CREDIT GENERAL INS CO1990

12912 CREDIT GENERAL INS CO1985

12912 CREDIT GENERAL INS CO603 Group Name:Group Code: CORONET INS GRP

199510812 CORONET INS CO 40410 NATIONAL ASSUR IND CO43907 CASUALTY INS CO OF FL 44342 CROWN CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners368

Page 377: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

603 Group Name:Group Code: CORONET INS GRP1990

10812 CORONET INS CO 34827 CASUALTY INS CO OF GA40410 NATIONAL ASSUR IND CO 43907 CASUALTY INS CO OF FL44342 CROWN CAS CO

198510812 CORONET INS CO

604 Group Name:Group Code: GERLING GLOBAL RE GRP2007

11266 GLOBAL REINS CORP US BRANCH 21032 GLOBAL REINS CORP OF AMER32190 CONSTITUTION INS CO

200611266 GLOBAL REINS CORP US BRANCH 21032 GLOBAL REINS CORP OF AMERICA32190 CONSTITUTION INS CO

200511266 GLOBAL REINS CORP US BRANCH 21032 GLOBAL REINS CORP OF AMERICA32190 CONSTITUTION INS CO 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO

200011266 GERLING GLOBAL REINS CORP OF US BR 21032 GERLING GLOBAL REINS CORP OF AMERICA32190 CONSTITUTION INS CO 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO

199511266 GERLING GLOBAL REINS CORP OF US BR 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO

199011266 GERLING GLOBAL REINS CORP OF US BR 41343 GERLING AMER INS CO

606 Group Name:Group Code: LAWRENCE GRP1995

15741 UNITED COMM INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO29220 UNITED REPUBLIC INSURANCE CO

199015741 UNITED COMM INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO29220 UNITED REPUBLIC REIN CO

198515741 UNITED COMM INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO29220 UNITED REPUBLIC REIN CO

608 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA GRP2009

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIAB INS CO2008

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIAB INS CO2007

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIAB INS CO2006

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIABILITY INS CO2005

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIABILITY INS CO2000

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIABILITY INS CO1995

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIABILITY INS CO1990

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA 36412 CLAREMONT LIABILITY INS CO1985

32433 MEDICAL INS EXCH OF CA610 Group Name:Group Code: GUARANTY NATL GRP

198530694 GUARANTY MUT INS CO

612 Group Name:Group Code: CITIZENS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners369

Page 378: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

612 Group Name:Group Code: CITIZENS GRP2009

10246 SECURITY PLAN FIRE INS CO2007

10246 SECURITY PLAN FIRE INS CO2006

10246 SECURITY PLAN FIRE INS CO2005

10246 SECURITY PLAN FIRE INS CO615 Group Name:Group Code: BENEFICIAL LIFE GRP

199513099 UTAH HOME FIRE INS CO

199013099 UTAH HOME FIRE INS CO

198513099 UTAH HOME FIRE INS CO

616 Group Name:Group Code: ELECTRIC LIFE I CO1985

35556 ELECTRIC MUT BENEFIT ASSN617 Group Name:Group Code: FOLKSAMERICA GRP

199517205 SURETY REINSURANCE CO 32190 FOLKSAMERICA NATL REINSURANCE CO38776 FOLKSAMERICA REIN CO

199017205 SURETY REINSURANCE CO 32190 FOLKSAMERICA NATL REINSURANCE CO38776 FOLKSAMERICA REIN CO

618 Group Name:Group Code: IVY INS GRP1995

23701 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE & CAS INS CO1990

23701 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE & CAS INS CO1985

23701 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE & CAS INS CO619 Group Name:Group Code: ONEAMERICA FIN PARTNERS GRP

200530112 CNL INS AMER INC

621 Group Name:Group Code: AMALGAMATED COS1990

13293 AMALGAMATED CAS INS CO623 Group Name:Group Code: HEALTH NET INC GRP

200010360 HEALTH NET INS OF CT INC

199510392 COMBINED BENEFIT INS CO 22284 CALIFORNIA COMPENSATION INS CO34649 BUSINESS INSURANCE COMPANY

199022284 CALIFORNIA COMPENSATION INS CO 34649 LONDON GUARANTEE & ACCIDENT CO OF NY

198522284 CALIFORNIA COMPENSATION INS CO 34649 LONDON GUARANTEE & ACCIDENT CO OF NY

624 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST ST GRP1995

21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP1990

21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP1985

21830 NEW ENGLAND INS CO 41629 NEW ENGLAND REIN CORP626 Group Name:Group Code: ACE LTD GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners370

Page 379: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

626 Group Name:Group Code: ACE LTD GRP2009

10030 ACE IND INS CO 10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO 20591 BANKERS STANDARD FIRE & MARINE CO20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO 20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO20710 CENTURY IND CO 21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO22667 ACE AMER INS CO 22713 INSURANCE CO OF N AMER22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO 30953 ACE INS CO38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER

200810021 ASSURED GUAR MORTGAGE INS CO 10030 ACE IND INS CO10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO20591 BANKERS STANDARD FIRE & MARINE CO 20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 20710 CENTURY IND CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 22667 ACE AMER INS CO22713 INSURANCE CO OF N AMER 22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO30180 ASSURED GUAR CORP 30953 ACE INS CO35130 CENTURY REINS CO 38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER

200710021 ASSURED GUAR MORTGAGE INS CO 10030 ACE IND INS CO10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO20591 BANKERS STANDARD FIRE & MARINE CO 20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 20710 CENTURY IND CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 22667 ACE AMER INS CO22713 INSURANCE CO OF N AMER 22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO30180 ASSURED GUAR CORP 30953 ACE INS CO35130 CENTURY REINS CO 38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER

200610021 ASSURED GUARANTY MORTGAGE INS CO 10030 ACE IND INS CO10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO 20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 20710 CENTURY IND CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 22667 ACE AMERICAN INS CO22691 ACE INS CO OF IL 22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO 30180 ASSURED GUARANTY CORP30953 ACE INS CO 35130 CENTURY REIN CO38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER

200510021 ASSURED GUARANTY MORGAGE INS CO 10030 ACE IND INS CO10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 10943 ASSURED VALUE INS CO18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO 18511 ACE AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO 20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO 20710 CENTURY IND CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 22667 ACE AMERICAN INS CO22691 ACE INS CO OF IL 22705 ACE AMER REINS CO22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER 22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO22764 ACE INS CO OF OH 26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO 30180 ASSURED GUARANTY CORP30953 ACE INS CO 35130 CENTURY REIN CO38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER

200010021 ACE CAPITAL MORTGAGE REIN CO 10030 ACE INDEM INS CO10172 WESTCHESTER SURPLUS LINES INS CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO18511 ACE AMERICAN LLOYDS INS CO 20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners371

Page 380: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

626 Group Name:Group Code: ACE LTD GRP2000

20699 ACE PROP & CAS INS CO 20702 ACE FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO20710 CENTURY IND CO 21075 INDUSTRIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO21121 WESTCHESTER FIRE INS CO 22667 ACE AMERICAN INS CO22691 ACE INS CO OF IL 22705 ACE AMERICAN REINS CO22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER 22721 ACE INS CO OF TX22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 22764 ACE INS CO OF OH26417 ACE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO30180 ACE GUARANTY RE INC 30953 ACE INS CO35130 CENTURY REIN CO 36528 ALLIED INS CO38741 ACE EMPLOYERS INS CO 38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO42072 INA SURPLUS INSURANCE COMPANY 43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NA

199016640 BELK STORES INS RECIPROCAL

198516640 BELK STORES INS RECIPROCAL

635 Group Name:Group Code: CONTINENTAL INS CO GRP2009

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO2008

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO2007

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO2006

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO2005

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO1995

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO1990

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO1985

16993 CONTINENTAL MUT INS CO637 Group Name:Group Code: PILGRIM INTEGRITY

199017655 PILGRIM MUT INS CO

198517655 PILGRIM MUT INS CO

640 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL BENEFIT GRP2009

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO2007

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO2006

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO2005

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO2000

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO1995

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO1990

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO1985

14664 MUTUAL BENEFIT INS CO 17752 SELECT RISK INS CO641 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST TOWER GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners372

Page 381: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

641 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST TOWER GRP2009

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO2008

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO2007

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO2006

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO2005

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO2000

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO1995

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO1990

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO1985

10170 AMERICAN FEDERATED INS CO642 Group Name:Group Code: TI CORP GRP

199531496 TMIC INS CO INC 39055 GALAXY INS CO39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

199031496 TMIC INS CO INC 39055 GALAXY INS CO39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

198517590 TICOR ASSUR CO 31496 TMIC INS CO INC39055 GALAXY INS CO 39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

643 Group Name:Group Code: NCRIC GRP2000

39560 COMMONWEALTH MEDICAL LIABILITY INS C 41149 NCRIC INC1995

39560 COMMONWEALTH MEDICAL LIABILITY INS C 41149 NCRIC INC1990

39560 COMMONWEALTH MEDICAL LIABILITY INS C 41149 NCRIC INC1985

41149 NCRIC INC645 Group Name:Group Code: OREGON MUT GRP

200914907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

200814907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

200714907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

200614907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

200514907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

200014907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

199514907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

199014907 OREGON MUT INS CO 30961 WESTERN PROTECTORS INS CO

198514907 OREGON MUT INS CO

646 Group Name:Group Code: BANKERS INDEPENDENT GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners373

Page 382: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

646 Group Name:Group Code: BANKERS INDEPENDENT GRP1995

13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO1990

13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO1985

13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO649 Group Name:Group Code: AGWAY INS GRP

198534193 AGWAY IND INS CO

650 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN FAMILY INS GRP2000

40010 ANCHOR GENERAL INS CO1995

40010 ANCHOR GENERAL INS CO1990

40010 ANCHOR GENERAL INS CO1985

40010 ANCHOR GENERAL INS CO655 Group Name:Group Code: CHRISITANIA GRP

199510650 CHRISTIANIA GENERAL INS CORP OF NY

199010650 CHRISTIANIA GENERAL INS CORP OF NY

198510650 CHRISTIANIA GENERAL INS CORP OF NY

657 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST SECURITY LIFE GRP1995

24490 FIRST SECURITY CASUALTY CO1990

24490 FIRST SECURITY CASUALTY INS CO1985

24490 FIRST SECURITY CASUALTY INS CO659 Group Name:Group Code: MISSOURI PHYSICIANS ASSOC GRP

200023701 NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE & CAS INS CO 32654 MISSOURI PHYSICIANS ASSOC

199532654 MEDICAL DEFENSE ASSOCIATES 42730 MEDICAL DEFENSE INS CO

199032654 MEDICAL DEFENSE ASSOCIATES 42730 MEDICAL DEFENSE INS CO

198532654 MEDICAL DEFENSE ASSOCIATES 42730 MEDICAL DEFENSE INS CO

660 Group Name:Group Code: MERCURY GEN GRP2009

10015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11201 MERCURY IND CO OF AMER11202 MERCURY INS CO OF FL 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY NATL INS CO29394 MERCURY CNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

200810015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11201 MERCURY IND CO OF AMER11202 MERCURY INS CO OF FL 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY NATL INS CO29394 MERCURY CNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners374

Page 383: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

660 Group Name:Group Code: MERCURY GEN GRP2008

38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO2007

10015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11201 MERCURY IND CO OF AMER11202 MERCURY INS CO OF FL 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY NATL INS CO29394 MERCURY CNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

200610015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11201 MERCURY IND CO OF AMER11202 MERCURY INS CO OF FL 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY NATL INS CO29394 MERCURY COUNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

200510015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11201 MERCURY IND CO OF AMER11202 MERCURY INS CO OF FL 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INS CO 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY NATL INS CO29394 MERCURY COUNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

200010015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11908 MERCURY CAS CO16810 AMERICAN MERCURY INSURANCE COMPANY 25470 AMERICAN MERCURY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 27988 MERCURY IND CO OF IL29394 ELM COUNTY MUT INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

199510015 MERCURY IND CO OF GA 11908 MERCURY CAS CO25470 AMERICAN FIDELITY LLOYDS INS CO 27553 MERCURY INS CO27988 MERCURY IND CO OF IL 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

199011908 MERCURY CAS CO 25470 AMERICAN FIDELITY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO34410 MERCURY INS CO OF GA 34444 MERCURY INS CO OF IL38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

198511908 MERCURY CAS CO 25470 AMERICAN FIDELITY LLOYDS INS CO27553 MERCURY INS CO 31046 CALIFORNIA GEN UNDERWRITERS INS CO38342 CALIFORNIA AUTOMOBILE INS CO

661 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF SC GRP2009

10794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 11208 AMFED NATL INS CO11963 AMFED CAS INS CO 11985 COMPANION CAPTIVE INS CO12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO 13124 COMPANION SPECIALTY INS CO

200810794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 11208 AMFED NATL INS CO11963 AMFED CAS INS CO 11985 COMPANION CAPTIVE INS CO12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO 13124 COMPANION SPECIALTY INS CO

200710794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 11985 COMPANION CAPTIVE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners375

Page 384: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

661 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF SC GRP2007

12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO2006

10794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 11985 COMPANION CAPTIVE INS CO12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO

200510794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 11985 COMPANION CAPTIVE INS CO12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO

200010794 COMPANION COMMERCIAL INS CO 12157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO38520 BCBS OF SC INC

199512157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO 38520 BCBS OF SC INC

199012157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO 38520 BCBS OF SC INC

198512157 COMPANION PROP & CAS INS CO 38520 BCBS OF SC INC

663 Group Name:Group Code: IMT INS CO1985

31631 FARMERS MUT INS ASSN OF IA669 Group Name:Group Code: ZALE CORP GRP

200930325 ZALE IND CO

200830325 ZALE IND CO

200730325 ZALE IND CO

200630325 ZALE IND CO

200530325 ZALE IND CO

200030325 ZALE IND CO

199530325 ZALE IND CO

199030325 ZALE IND CO 39128 DIAMOND GUARANTY INS CO

198530325 ZALE IND CO 39128 DIAMOND GUARANTY INS CO

670 Group Name:Group Code: FIDELITY NATL FIN GRP2009

11523 FIDELITY NATL IND INS CO 16578 FIDELITY NATL PROP & CAS INS CO25180 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200811523 FIDELITY NATL IND INS CO 16578 FIDELITY NATL PROP & CAS INS CO25180 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200711523 FIDELITY NATL IND INS CO 16578 FIDELITY NATL PROP & CAS INS CO25180 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200611523 FIDELITY NATIONAL IND INS CO 16578 FIDELITY NATL PROP AND CAS INS CO25180 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

200511523 FIDELITY NATIONAL IND INS CO 16578 FIDELITY NATL PROP AND CAS INS CO25180 FIDELITY NATL INS CO

671 Group Name:Group Code: WELLPOINT INC GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners376

Page 385: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

671 Group Name:Group Code: WELLPOINT INC GRP2005

28207 ANTHEM INS CO INC2000

10345 COMMUNITY INSURANCE COMPANY 11011 ROCKY MOUNTAIN HOSPITAL & MEDICAL28207 ANTHEM INSURANCE COMPANIES INC

199510345 ANTHEM BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD 15156 SHELBY INS CO28207 ASSOCIATED INS COS INC 30503 ANTHEM CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO 42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

199015156 SHELBY INS CO 28207 ASSOCIATED INS COS INC30503 INS CO OF DECATUR (THE) 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

198515156 SHELBY INS CO 28207 ASSOCIATED INS COS INC30503 INS CO OF DECATUR (THE) 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

673 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN WAY1990

11924 AMERICAN WAY CAS CO OF MI 31771 AMERICAN WAY CAS CO OF MD1985

11924 AMERICAN WAY CAS CO OF MI 39241 AMERICAN WAY CAS CO674 Group Name:Group Code: BORG WARNER CORP GRP

198530015 CENTAUR INS CO 32719 TRENTON NATL INS CO

677 Group Name:Group Code: PHILADELPHIA CONSOLIDATED HOLDING GR2009

10955 LIBERTY AMER INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA INS CO 32760 LIBERTY AMER SELECT INS CO

200810955 LIBERTY AMER INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA INS CO 32760 LIBERTY AMER SELECT INS CO

200710955 LIBERTY AMER INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA INS CO 32760 LIBERTY AMER SELECT INS CO

200610955 LIBERTY AMERICAN INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA INS CO 32760 LIBERTY AMERICAN SELECT INS CO

200510955 LIBERTY AMERICAN INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA IN CO 32760 MOBILE USA INS CO

200010955 LIBERTY AMERICAN INS CO 18058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO23850 PHILADELPHIA IN CO 32760 MOBILE USA INS CO

199518058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO 23850 PHILADELPHIA IN CO

199018058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO 23850 PHILADELPHIA IN CO

198518058 PHILADELPHIA IND INS CO 23850 PHILADELPHIA IN CO

680 Group Name:Group Code: AMERISAFE GRP2009

12228 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF TX 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO

200812228 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF TX 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners377

Page 386: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

680 Group Name:Group Code: AMERISAFE GRP2007

12228 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF TX 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO

200612228 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF TX 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO

200512228 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF TX 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO

200026869 SILVER OAK CAS INC 31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS COMPANY

199515490 AMERICAN INTERINS EXCH 26869 SILVER OAK CAS INC31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS COMPANY

199015490 AMERICAN INTERINS EXCH 31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF GA

198515490 AMERICAN INTERINS EXCH 31895 AMERICAN INTERSTATE INS CO OF GA

681 Group Name:Group Code: SERVICE LIFE GRP2009

10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO2008

10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO2007

10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO2006

10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO2005

10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO2000

10224 SERVICE CAS INS CO 10590 HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO

199510224 SERVICE CAS INS CO 43389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO

199043389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO

198543389 SERVICE LLOYDS INS CO

683 Group Name:Group Code: ROYAL STATE GRP1995

37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD1990

37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD1985

37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD685 Group Name:Group Code: WASATCH CREST GRP

200013099 WASATCH CREST INS CO 33219 WASATCH CREST MUTUAL INS CO

199533219 WASATCH CREST MUTUAL INS CO

199033219 ENERGY MUTUAL INS CO

198533219 ENERGY MUTUAL INS CO

686 Group Name:Group Code: SOREMA N AMER GRP2000

20559 FULCRUM INSURANCE COMPANY 25771 WESTERN CONTINENTAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners378

Page 387: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

686 Group Name:Group Code: SOREMA N AMER GRP2000

38512 RAMPART INS CO 39322 SOREMA NORTH AMER REINS CO1995

20559 FULCRUM INSURANCE COMPANY 39322 SOREMA NORTH AMER REINS CO689 Group Name:Group Code: BANKERS INS GRP

200913041 BANKERS SPECIALTY INS CO 13990 FIRST COMMUNITY INS CO33162 BANKERS INS CO

200813041 BANKERS SPECIALTY INS CO 13990 FIRST COMMUNITY INS CO33162 BANKERS INS CO

200713041 BANKERS SPECIALTY INS CO 13990 FIRST COMMUNITY INS CO33162 BANKERS INS CO

200613990 FIRST COMMUNITY INS CO 33162 BANKERS INS CO

200513990 FIRST COMMUNITY INS CO 33162 BANKERS INS CO

200013990 BANKERS SECURITY INS CO 16578 FIRST COMM INS CO33162 BANKERS INS CO

199513990 BANKERS SECURITY INS CO 16578 FIRST COMM INS CO33162 BANKERS INS CO

199016578 FIRST COMM INS CO 33162 BANKERS INS CO

198516578 FIRST COMM INS CO 33162 BANKERS INS CO

690 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL STATES GRP2009

11499 CENSTAT CAS CO693 Group Name:Group Code: WHEAT GROWERS GRP

199010596 CENTRAL STATES INS CO INC 42854 WHEAT GROWERS MUT HAIL INS CO

198510596 CENTRAL STATES INS CO INC 42854 WHEAT GROWERS MUT HAIL INS CO

694 Group Name:Group Code: TENNESSEE FARMERS GRP2009

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO2008

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO2007

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO2006

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO2005

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO2000

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO1995

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO1990

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO 41220 TENNESSEE FARMERS ASSUR CO1985

15245 TENNESSEE FARMERS MUT INS CO697 Group Name:Group Code: VAN ENT GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners379

Page 388: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

697 Group Name:Group Code: VAN ENT GRP2009

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO2008

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO2007

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO2006

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO2005

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO2000

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO1995

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO1990

37060 OLD UNITED CAS CO698 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH STAR CO GRP

200914850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 42293 NORTH STAR GEN INS CO

200814850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 42293 NORTH STAR GEN INS CO

200714850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 42293 NORTH STAR GEN INS CO

200614850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 42293 NORTH STAR GENERAL INS CO

200514850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 42293 NORTH STAR GENERAL INS CO

200014850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 34614 WALLE MUT INS CO42293 NORTH STAR GENERAL INS CO

199514850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 34614 WALLE MUT INS CO42293 NORTH STAR GENERAL INS CO

199014850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 34614 WALLE MUT INS CO42293 NORTH STAR GENERAL INS CO

198514850 NORTH STAR MUT INS CO 34614 WALLE MUT INS CO

708 Group Name:Group Code: NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP2009

10732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE INS CO

200810732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE INS CO

200710732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE INS CO

200610732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO

200510732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO

200010732 NEW JERSEY CAS INS CO 10978 NEW JERSEY IND INS CO12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners380

Page 389: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

708 Group Name:Group Code: NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS GRP1995

12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO1990

12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO1985

12122 NEW JERSEY MANUFACTURERS INS CO 35432 NEW JERSEY RE-INSURANCE CO711 Group Name:Group Code: PHICO GRP

200010951 INDEPENDENCE IND INS CO 26107 PENNSYLVANIA CASUALTY COMPANY35718 PENNSYLVANIA CASUALTY CO

712 Group Name:Group Code: SIERRA PACIFIC GRP2000

35041 SIERRA PACIFIC INS CO1995

35041 SIERRA PACIFIC INS CO1990

35041 SIERRA PACIFIC INS CO1985

35041 SIERRA PACIFIC INS CO713 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN DIVERSIFIED

198511541 INDUSTRIAL FIRE & CAS INS CO

717 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN MINING GRP1990

34673 AMERICAN MINING INS CO OF TN718 Group Name:Group Code: NAU GRP

200025240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 34312 MOUNTAIN STATES INS CO

199524627 NAU INSURANCE CO 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO34312 MOUNTAIN STATES INS CO

199024627 NAU INSURANCE CO 25240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO34312 MOUNTAIN STATES INS CO

198525240 NAU COUNTRY INS CO 34312 MOUNTAIN STATES INS CO

725 Group Name:Group Code: PRAICO GRP1995

18120 PREFERRED RISK INS CO 31690 PAN AMER INS CO43052 PUERTO RICAN AMERICAN INS CO

199018120 PREFERRED RISK INS CO 31690 PAN AMER INS CO43052 PUERTO RICAN AMERICAN INS CO

198518120 PREFERRED RISK INS CO 31690 PAN AMER INS CO

726 Group Name:Group Code: UNION NATL GRP1990

18546 UNION NATL LLOYDS FIRE INS CO1985

18546 UNION NATL LLOYDS FIRE INS CO730 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL MUT OF OH GRP

200029076 MEDICAL MUTUAL OF OHIO

199515644 MEDICAL INSURANCE COMPANY OF OH 29076 BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD MUT OF OH

199015644 BLUE GUARDIAN INS CO 29076 BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD MUT OF OH

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners381

Page 390: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

730 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL MUT OF OH GRP1985

15644 BLUE GUARDIAN INS CO 29076 BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD MUT OF OH732 Group Name:Group Code: NLASCO GRP

200915474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

200815474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

200715474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

200615474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

200515474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

200015474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 19623 AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO

199515474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO 43338 FINANCIAL SAVINGS INSURANCE CO

199011495 IMPERIAL INS CO 15474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO43338 FINANCIAL REINSURANCE CORP

198511495 IMPERIAL INS CO 15474 NATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO43338 FINANCIAL REINSURANCE CORP

733 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INDEPENDENT COS1995

17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO1990

17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO1985

17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO734 Group Name:Group Code: PINNACLE FINANCIAL GRP

199031321 CENTURY CAS CO

741 Group Name:Group Code: MID S GRP1985

35440 MID AMERICAN CAS CO 37842 MID AMERICAN IND CO743 Group Name:Group Code: SOCIETY GRP INC

200515261 SOCIETY INS 42480 VENTURE INS CO

200015261 SOCIETY INS 42480 VENTURE INS CO

199515261 SOCIETY INS 42480 VENTURE INS CO

199015261 THRESHERMENS MUTUAL INS CO 42480 VENTURE INS CO

198515261 THRESHERMENS MUTUAL INS CO

745 Group Name:Group Code: GROUP HOSP SVC2000

12882 GHS FIRE & CASUALTY INS CO 29718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO1995

29718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO1990

29718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO748 Group Name:Group Code: MEADOWBROOK INS GRP

200910665 AMERITRUST INS CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners382

Page 391: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

748 Group Name:Group Code: MEADOWBROOK INS GRP2009

16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO 18023 STAR INS CO21903 PROCENTURY INS CO 25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO36951 CENTURY SURETY CO

200810665 AMERITRUST INS CORP 16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO18023 STAR INS CO 21903 PROCENTURY INS CO25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO

200710665 AMERITRUST INS CORP 16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO18023 STAR INS CO 25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO

200610665 AMERITRUST INS CORP 16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO18023 STAR INS CO 25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO

200510665 AMERITRUST INS CORP 16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO18023 STAR INS CO 25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO

200010665 AMERITRUST INS CORP 16551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO18023 STAR INS CO 25780 WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO

199516551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO 18023 STAR INS CO

199016551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO 18023 STAR INS CO

198516551 SAVERS PROP & CAS INS CO 18023 STAR INS CO

749 Group Name:Group Code: SCOR GRP2009

20559 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO OF AZ 30058 SCOR REINS CO39322 GENERAL SECURITY NATL INS CO

200820559 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO OF AZ 27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE INS CO30058 SCOR REINS CO 39322 GENERAL SECURITY NATL INS CO

200720559 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO OF AZ 27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE INS CO30058 SCOR REINS CO 39322 GENERAL SECURITY NATL INS CO

200620559 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO OF AZ 27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE-INS CO30058 SCOR REINS CO 39322 GENERAL SECURITY NATL INS CO

200520559 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO OF AZ 27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE-INS CO30058 SCOR REINS CO 39322 GENERAL SECURITY NATL INS CO

200016063 GENERAL SECURITY INS CO 25909 GENERAL SECURITY PROP & CAS CO27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE-INS CO 30058 SCOR REINS CO37079 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO

199516063 GENERAL SECURITY INS CO 25909 UNITY FIRE & GENERAL INS CO27955 COMMERCIAL RISK RE-INS CO 30058 SCOR REINS CO37079 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO

199016063 GENERAL SECURITY INS CO 25909 UNITY FIRE & GENERAL INS CO25925 GENERAL SECURITY ASR CORP OF NY 30058 SCOR REINS CO37079 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO

198516063 GENERAL SECURITY INS CO 25909 UNITY FIRE & GENERAL INS CO25925 GENERAL SECURITY ASR CORP OF NY 30058 SCOR REINS CO37079 GENERAL SECURITY IND CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners383

Page 392: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

753 Group Name:Group Code: GAN GRP1995

25771 GAN NORTH AMERICAN INS CO 38512 GAN NATIONAL INSURANCE CO1990

25771 GAN NORTH AMERICAN INS CO 38512 GAN NATIONAL INSURANCE CO1985

25771 GAN NORTH AMERICAN INS CO 38512 GAN NATIONAL INSURANCE CO754 Group Name:Group Code: THE COLONIAL CO

199531151 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO INC

199031151 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO INC

198531151 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO INC

755 Group Name:Group Code: QUAKER STATE MUT1990

17418 MANOR MUT INS CO1985

17418 MANOR MUT INS CO759 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL BENEFITS GRP

199528363 CENTRAL BENEFITS MUT INS CO

199028363 CENTRAL BENEFITS MUT INS CO

761 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIANZ INS GRP2009

10079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11630 JEFFERSON INS CO 20516 EULER HERMES AMER CREDIT IND CO21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO 21857 AMERICAN INS CO21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP 21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 AGCS MARINE INS CO 29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO30023 AMERICAN STANDARD LLOYDS INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH 40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA

200810079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11630 JEFFERSON INS CO 20516 EULER HERMES AMER CREDIT IND CO21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO 21857 AMERICAN INS CO21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP 21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 AGCS MARINE INS CO 29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO30023 AMERICAN STANDARD LLOYDS INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH 40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA

200710079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11630 JEFFERSON INS CO 20516 EULER HERMES AMER CREDIT IND CO21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO 21857 AMERICAN INS CO21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP 21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 INTERSTATE IND CO 29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO30023 AMERICAN STANDARD LLOYDS INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC 39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners384

Page 393: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

761 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIANZ INS GRP2006

10079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11630 JEFFERSON INS CO 20516 EULER HERMES AMERICAN CREDIT IND CO21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO 21857 AMERICAN INS CO21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP 21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 INTERSTATE IND CO 29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO 33189 MONTICELLO INS CO35300 ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO 36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA 39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH 40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA42860 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF MO 44768 MIDWAY INS CO OF IL

200510079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11410 PARKWAY INS CO 11630 JEFFERSON INS CO20516 EULER AMERICAN CREDIT IND CO 21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO21857 AMERICAN INS CO 21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO 21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO 22810 CHICAGO INS CO22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO 22837 INTERSTATE IND CO29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO 30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO33189 MONTICELLO INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 38474 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF NE38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA 39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH 40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA42860 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF MO 44768 MIDWAY INS CO OF IL

200010079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11410 PARKWAY INS CO 11630 JEFFERSON INS CO20516 EULER AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO 21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO21857 AMERICAN INS CO 21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO 21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP21903 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF TX 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 INTERSTATE IND CO 26085 WARNER INS CO29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO 30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO33189 MONTICELLO INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 37273 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF WI38474 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF NE 38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC 39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA 42860 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF MO44768 MIDWAY INS CO OF IL

199510079 VINTAGE INS CO 11380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP11410 PARKWAY INS CO 21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO21857 AMERICAN INS CO 21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO 21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP21903 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF TX 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 INTERSTATE IND CO 26085 WARNER INS CO29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO 30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO33189 MONTICELLO INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 37273 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF WI38474 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF NE 38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC 39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA 42860 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF MO44768 MIDWAY INS CO OF IL

199011380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners385

Page 394: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

761 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIANZ INS GRP1990

11410 PARKWAY INS CO 11630 JEFFERSON INS CO21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO 21857 AMERICAN INS CO21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP 21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP 21903 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF TX21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO 22810 CHICAGO INS CO22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO 22837 INTERSTATE IND CO26085 WARNER INS CO 29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO 33189 MONTICELLO INS CO35300 ALLIANZ INS CO 36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO37273 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF WI 38474 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF IOWA38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA 39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH 39829 ALLIANZ SYNDICATE INC40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA

198511380 FIREMANS FUND IND CORP 11410 PARKWAY INS CO11630 JEFFERSON INS CO 21849 AMERICAN AUTOMOBILE INS CO21857 AMERICAN INS CO 21865 ASSOCIATED IND CORP21873 FIREMANS FUND INS CO 21881 NATIONAL SURETY CORP21903 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF TX 21911 SAN FRANCISCO REINS CO22810 CHICAGO INS CO 22829 INTERSTATE FIRE & CAS CO22837 INTERSTATE IND CO 26085 WARNER INS CO29181 FIREMANS FUND CNTY MUT INS CO 30023 AMERICAN STD LLOYDS INS CO33189 MONTICELLO INS CO 35300 ALLIANZ INS CO36420 ALLIANZ UNDERWRITERS INS CO 37273 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF WI38474 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF IOWA 38482 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF GA39500 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF HI INC 39640 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF OH39829 ALLIANZ SYNDICATE INC 40681 FIREMANS FUND INS CO OF LA

762 Group Name:Group Code: FRANKLIN MUT GRP2009

15750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

200815750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

200715750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

200615750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

200515750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

200015750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

199515750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

199015750 FIDELITY MOHAWK INS CO 16454 FRANKLIN MUT INS CO37699 FMI INS CO

763 Group Name:Group Code: INDEPENDENT ORDER OF FORESTERS1995

35815 FORESTERS IND CO US BRANCH1990

35815 FORESTERS IND CO US BRANCH

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners386

Page 395: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

763 Group Name:Group Code: INDEPENDENT ORDER OF FORESTERS1985

35815 FORESTERS IND CO US BRANCH766 Group Name:Group Code: RADIAN GRP

200911472 RADIAN MORTGAGE REINS CO 15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSUR CO OF20720 RADIAN INS INC 30872 AMERIN GUAR CORP33790 RADIAN GUAR INC 33944 RADIAN MORTGAGE INS INC36250 RADIAN ASSET ASSUR INC

200811472 RADIAN MORTGAGE REINS CO 15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSUR CO OF20720 RADIAN INS INC 30872 AMERIN GUAR CORP33790 RADIAN GUARANTY INC 33944 RADIAN MORTGAGE INS INC36250 RADIAN ASSET ASSUR INC

200710185 AMERIN RE CORP 11472 RADIAN MORTGAGE REINS CO15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSUR CO OF 20720 RADIAN INS INC30872 AMERIN GUAR CORP 33790 RADIAN GUARANTY INC33944 RADIAN MORTGAGE INS INC 36250 RADIAN ASSET ASSUR INC

200610185 AMERIN RE CORP 11472 RADIAN MORTGAGE REINS CO15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF TX 20720 RADIAN INS INC30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP 33790 RADIAN GUARANTY INC33944 RADIAN MORTGAGE INS INC 36250 RADIAN ASSET ASSUR INC

200510185 AMERIN RE CORP 11472 RADIAN MORTGAGE REINS CO15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF TX 20720 RADIAN INS INC30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP 33790 RADIAN GUARANTY INC33944 RADIAN MORTGAGE INS INC 36250 RADIAN ASSET ASSUR INC

200010185 AMERIN RE CORP 15909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF TX20720 RADIAN INS INC 30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP33790 RADIAN GUARANTY INC 33944 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF AZ

199515909 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF TX 20720 CMAC MORTGAGE INS CO33790 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSURANCE 33944 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF AZ

199033790 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSURANCE 33944 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF AZ

198533790 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASSURANCE 33944 COMMONWEALTH MORTGAGE ASR CO OF AZ

767 Group Name:Group Code: PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP2009

12262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOC IN 36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

200812262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASSOC IN 36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

200712262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

200612262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

200512262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

200012262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 26743 CALIBER ONE INDEMNITY CO36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO 39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners387

Page 396: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

767 Group Name:Group Code: PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS GRP2000

41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO1995

12262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 25267 MID-ATLANTIC STATES CAS CO36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO 39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

199012262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 25267 MID-ATLANTIC STATES CAS CO36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO 39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO39748 JOHNSON & HIGGINS WF SYNDICATE A INC 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

198512262 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS ASN INS 25267 MID-ATLANTIC STATES CAS CO36897 MANUFACTURERS ALLIANCE INS CO 39675 PMA CAPITAL INS CO39748 JOHNSON & HIGGINS WF SYNDICATE A INC 41424 PENNSYLVANIA MANUFACTURERS IND CO

771 Group Name:Group Code: AAA MID ATLANTIC INS GRP2009

10675 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

200810675 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

200710675 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MID ATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

200610675 AAA MID-ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MIDATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

200510675 AAA MID-ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MIDATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

200010675 AAA MID-ATLANTIC INS CO 11681 KEYSTONE INS CO42960 AAA MIDATLANTIC INS CO OF NJ

199511681 KEYSTONE INS CO 42960 KEYSTONE INS CO OF NJ

199011681 KEYSTONE INS CO 42960 KEYSTONE INS CO OF NJ

198511681 KEYSTONE INS CO

772 Group Name:Group Code: PHYSICANS OF OH2000

22985 SEQUOIA INS CO 32999 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF OH37222 PROFESSIONALS INS CO 42242 CITATION INS CO

199522985 SEQUOIA INS CO 32999 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF OH37222 PROFESSIONALS INS CO

199022985 SEQUOIA INS CO 32999 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF OH37222 PROFESSIONALS INS CO

198522985 SEQUOIA INS CO 32999 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF OH37222 PROFESSIONALS INS CO

775 Group Name:Group Code: PHARMACISTS MUT GRP2009

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO2008

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners388

Page 397: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

775 Group Name:Group Code: PHARMACISTS MUT GRP2007

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO2006

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO2005

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO2000

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO1995

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO1990

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO1985

13714 PHARMACISTS MUT INS CO777 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN HERITAGE GRP

199529980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO

199029980 FIRST COLONIAL INS CO

780 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH EAST INS CO GRP1995

24007 NORTH EAST INS CO 40665 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO1990

24007 NORTH EAST INS CO 40665 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO1985

24007 NORTH EAST INS CO 40665 AMERICAN COLONIAL INS CO781 Group Name:Group Code: UNION LABOR GRP

200910004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 37893 ULLICO CAS CO

200810004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 37893 ULLICO CAS CO

200710004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 37893 ULLICO CAS CO

200610004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 37893 ULLICO CAS CO

200510004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 37893 ULICO CAS CO

200010004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 24319 ULICO IND CO37893 ULICO CAS CO

199510004 ULICO STANDARD OF AMER CAS CO 24319 ULICO IND CO37893 ULICO CAS CO

199037893 ULICO CAS CO

198537893 ULICO CAS CO

782 Group Name:Group Code: TRYGG HANSA GRP1995

33421 TRYGG-HANSA INS CO LTD US BRANCH 39187 HANSA REIN CO OF AMER1990

33421 TRYGG-HANSA INS CO LTD US BRANCH 39187 HANSA REIN CO OF AMER1985

33421 TRYGG-HANSA INS CO LTD US BRANCH 39187 HANSA REIN CO OF AMER783 Group Name:Group Code: RLI INS GRP

200913056 RLI INS CO 28860 RLI IND CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners389

Page 398: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

783 Group Name:Group Code: RLI INS GRP2009

37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO2008

13056 RLI INS CO 28860 RLI IND CO37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

200713056 RLI INS CO 28860 RLI IND CO37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

200613056 RLI INS CO 28860 RLI IND CO37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

200513056 RLI INS CO 28860 RLI IND CO37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

200013056 RLI INS CO 13307 UNDERWRITERS IND CO28860 PLANET IND CO 37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

199513056 RLI INS CO 37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

199013056 RLI INS CO 37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

198513056 RLI INS CO 37974 MT HAWLEY INS CO

784 Group Name:Group Code: NAC RE CORP1995

20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC 22322 GREENWICH INS CO36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO

199020583 XL REINS AMERICA INC 22322 GREENWICH INS CO

198520583 XL REINS AMERICA INC 22322 GREENWICH INS CO

785 Group Name:Group Code: MARKEL CORP GRP2009

27189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMER INS CO35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INS CO 39020 ESSEX INS CO

200827189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMER INS CO35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INS CO 39020 ESSEX INS CO

200727189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMER INS CO35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INS CO 39020 ESSEX INS CO

200627189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMERICAN INS CO35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INS CO 39020 ESSEX INS CO

200527189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMERICAN INS CO35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INS CO 39020 ESSEX INS CO

200027189 ASSOCIATED INTL INS CO 28932 MARKEL AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY35378 EVANSTON INS CO 37184 DEERFIELD INS CO38970 MARKEL INSURANCE COMPANY 39020 ESSEX INS CO

199511622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 26743 LINCOLN INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners390

Page 399: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

785 Group Name:Group Code: MARKEL CORP GRP1995

28932 MARKEL AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY 35378 EVANSTON INS CO38970 MARKEL INSURANCE COMPANY 39020 ESSEX INS CO43745 INVESTORS SPECIAL RISK INS CO

199011622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 26743 LINCOLN INS CO28932 MARKEL RHULEN INSURANCE COMPANY 35378 EVANSTON INS CO38970 INSURANCE CO OF EVANSTON 39020 ESSEX INS CO39730 RICHMOND INS CO 43745 INVESTORS SPECIAL RISK INS CO

198511622 SPECIALTY SURPLUS INS CO 26743 LINCOLN INS CO28932 MARKEL RHULEN INSURANCE COMPANY 35378 EVANSTON INS CO38970 INSURANCE CO OF EVANSTON 39020 ESSEX INS CO

787 Group Name:Group Code: NEW LONDON CNTY GRP2009

14826 NEW LONDON CNTY MUT INS CO 37354 THAMES INS CO INC2007

14826 NEW LONDON CNTY MUT INS CO 37354 SUMMIT INS CO2006

14826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO 37354 SUMMIT INS CO2005

14826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO 37354 SUMMIT INS CO2000

10430 SUMMIT INSURANCE COMPANY 14826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO37354 THAMES INS CO INC

199514826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO 37354 THAMES INS CO INC

199014826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO 37354 THAMES INS CO INC

198514826 NEW LONDON CTY MUT INS CO 37354 THAMES INS CO INC

788 Group Name:Group Code: RISCORP GRP1995

13390 ATLAS INS CO 33766 RISCORP INSURANCE COMPANY44296 RISCORP PROPERTY & CASUALTY CO

199013390 ATLAS INS CO 33766 COMMERCE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY44296 FLORIDA INTERSTATE CASUALTY RE CO

198513390 ATLAS INS CO

790 Group Name:Group Code: FREMONT GEN GRP2000

10545 FREMONT CAS INS CO 11207 FREMONT IND CO21040 FREMOUNT INDUSTRIAL INDEMNITY CO 37761 FREEMONT COMPENSATION INS CO38725 FREMONT PACIFIC INSURANCE COMPANY

199510545 CASUALTY INS CO 11207 FREMONT IND CO25593 BEAVER INSURANCE COMPANY 29920 FREMONT COMPENSATION INS CO31291 WORKERS COMPENSATION & IND CO CA 38725 PACIFIC COMPENSATION INS CO

199010545 CASUALTY INS CO 11207 FREMONT IND CO25593 BEAVER INSURANCE COMPANY 29920 FREMONT COMPENSATION INS CO31291 WORKERS COMPENSATION & IND CO CA 38180 COMSTOCK INS CO38725 PACIFIC COMPENSATION INS CO 40746 FREMONT REINS CO43516 FREMONT SYNDICATE INC

198510545 CASUALTY INS CO 11207 FREMONT IND CO25593 BEAVER INSURANCE COMPANY 29920 FREMONT COMPENSATION INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners391

Page 400: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

790 Group Name:Group Code: FREMONT GEN GRP1985

31291 WORKERS COMPENSATION & IND CO CA 38180 COMSTOCK INS CO38725 PACIFIC COMPENSATION INS CO 40746 FREMONT REINS CO43516 FREMONT SYNDICATE INC

791 Group Name:Group Code: MOUNTAIN STATES INS CO GRP2009

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO2008

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO2007

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO2006

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO2005

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO2000

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO1995

10177 MOUNTAIN STATES IND CO 14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO1990

14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO1985

14648 MOUNTAIN STATES MUT CAS CO792 Group Name:Group Code: PROFESSIONALS GRP

200010179 PRONATIONAL CASUALTY COMPANY 16101 MEEMIC INS CO31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH 38954 PRONATIONAL INS CO

199510179 PICOM INSURANCE COMPANY OF IL 38954 PICOM INSURANCE COMPANY

199038954 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF MICHIGAN

198538954 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF MICHIGAN

796 Group Name:Group Code: QBE INS GRP2009

10219 QBE REINS CORP 11515 QBE SPECIALTY INS CO16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 18821 GENERAL CAS INS CO19178 SOUTHERN GUAR INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO 30589 CAPITAL CITY INS CO INC37257 PRAETORIAN INS CO 37303 REDLAND INS CO39217 QBE INS CORP 39462 NORTH POINTE CAS INS CO40754 BLUE RIDGE IND CO

200810219 QBE REINS CORP 11515 QBE SPECIALTY INS CO16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 18821 GENERAL CAS INS CO19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO 30589 CAPITAL CITY INS CO INC37257 PRAETORIAN INS CO 37303 REDLAND INS CO39217 QBE INS CORP 39462 NORTH POINTE CAS INS CO40754 BLUE RIDGE IND CO 44776 PRAETORIAN SPECIALTY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners392

Page 401: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

796 Group Name:Group Code: QBE INS GRP2007

10219 QBE REINS CORP 11515 QBE SPECIALTY INS CO16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 18821 GENERAL CAS INS CO19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO37257 PRAETORIAN INS CO 37303 REDLAND INS CO39217 QBE INS CORP 40754 BLUE RIDGE IND CO44776 PRAETORIAN SPECIALTY INS CO

200610219 QBE REINS CORP 11515 QBE SPECIALTY INS CO16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO39217 QBE INS CORP

200510219 QBE REINS CORP 11515 QBE SPECIALTY INS CO16217 NATIONAL FARMERS UNION PROP & CAS 21776 UNITED SECURITY INS CO39217 QBE INS CORP

200010219 QBE REINS CORP 39217 QBE INSURANCE CORPORATION

199510219 QBE REINS CORP 39217 MELBOURNE REINSUANCE CORPORATION

199010219 QBE REINS CORP 39217 VICTORY REINSURANCE OF AMERICA INC

798 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INDUSTRIES2000

32360 AMERICAN INDUSTRIES FIRE INS CO1995

32360 AMERICAN INDUSTRIES FIRE INS CO1990

32360 AMERICAN INDUSTRIES FIRE INS CO800 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN MUT INS GRP

200913625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

200813625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

200713625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

200613625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

200513625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

200013625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

199513625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

199013625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO38490 ARIZONA HOME INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners393

Page 402: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

800 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN MUT INS GRP1985

13625 WESTERN MUT INS CO 15776 RESIDENCE MUT INS CO802 Group Name:Group Code: CAPITAL INS GRP

200911165 NEVADA CAPITAL INS CO 12890 EAGLE W INS CO13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO 23540 MONTEREY INS CO

200811165 NEVADA CAPITAL INS CO 12890 EAGLE W INS CO13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO 23540 MONTEREY INS CO

200711165 NEVADA CAPITAL INS CO 12890 EAGLE W INS CO13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO 23540 MONTEREY INS CO

200611165 NEVADA CAPITAL INS CO 12890 EAGLE WEST INS CO13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO 23540 MONTEREY INS CO

200511165 NEVADA CAPITAL INS CO 12890 EAGLE WEST INS CO13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO 23540 MONTEREY INS CO

200012890 EAGLE WEST INS CO 13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO23540 MONTEREY INS CO

199512890 EAGLE WEST INS CO 13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO23540 MONTEREY INS CO

199012890 EAGLE WEST INS CO 13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO23540 MONTEREY INS CO

198512890 EAGLE WEST INS CO 13544 CALIFORNIA CAPITAL INS CO

807 Group Name:Group Code: COLUMBIA INS GRP2009

11258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO35629 ASSOCIATION CAS INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

200811258 GEORGIA CAS & SURETY CO 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO35629 ASSOCIATION CAS INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

200719640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

200619640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

200519640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO 35017 PATRONS INS CO40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

200015903 GREAT PLAINS MUTUAL INSURANCE CO 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO35017 PATRONS INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

199515903 GREAT PLAINS MUTUAL INSURANCE CO 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO35017 PATRONS INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

199015903 COLUMBIA MUTUAL CASUALTY INS COMPAN 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO35017 PATRONS INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

198515903 COLUMBIA MUTUAL CASUALTY INS COMPAN 19640 COLUMBIA NATL INS CO28428 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO 40371 COLUMBIA MUT INS CO

808 Group Name:Group Code: SUTTER INS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners394

Page 403: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

808 Group Name:Group Code: SUTTER INS GRP2000

25180 FIDELITY NATIONAL INS CO1995

25180 FIDELITY NATIONAL INS CO 32107 SUTTER INS CO1990

32107 SUTTER INS CO1985

32107 SUTTER INS CO809 Group Name:Group Code: TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT GRP

200913004 TEXAS FARM BUREAU CAS INS CO 25380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS 27820 FARM BUREAU CNTY MUT INS CO OF TX

200825380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

200725380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

200625380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

200525380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

200025380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

199525380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

199025380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

198525380 TEXAS FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO 25399 TEXAS FARM BUREAU UNDERWRITERS

811 Group Name:Group Code: RUMFORD GRP1985

25720 RUMFORD PROP & LIABILITY INS CO812 Group Name:Group Code: HIGHMARK GRP

200911435 HCI INC 13016 HM CAS INS CO35599 HIGHMARK CAS INS CO

200711435 HCI INC 13016 HM CAS INS CO35599 HIGHMARK CAS INS CO

200611435 HCI INC 35599 HIGHMARK CAS INS CO

200511435 HCI INC 35599 HIGHMARK CAS INS CO

200035599 HIGHMARK CASUALTY INS CO

199535599 TRANS GENERAL CASUALTY INS CO INC

199035599 CONSUMER SERVICE CASUALTY INS CO

198535599 CONSUMER SERVICE CASUALTY INS CO

814 Group Name:Group Code: BRISTOL WEST INS GRP2006

11034 BRISTOL WEST CAS INS CO 12774 BRISTOL WEST PREFERRED INS CO19658 BRISTOL WEST INS CO 25089 COAST NATL INS CO33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO

200511034 BRISTOL WEST CAS INS CO 19658 BRISTOL WEST INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners395

Page 404: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

814 Group Name:Group Code: BRISTOL WEST INS GRP2005

25089 COAST NATL INS CO 33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO2000

25089 COAST NATL INS CO 33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO1995

25089 COAST NATL INS CO 33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO1990

25089 COAST NATL INS CO 33120 SECURITY NATL INS CO816 Group Name:Group Code: COMMERCE INC GRP

200713161 COMMERCE W INS CO 19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO25275 STATE-WIDE INS CO 34754 COMMERCE INS CO40274 CITATION INS CO

200613161 COMMERCE WEST INS CO 19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO34754 COMMERCE INS CO 40274 CITATION INS CO

200513161 COMMERCE WEST INS CO 19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO34754 COMMERCE INS CO 40274 CITATION INS CO

200013161 COMMERCE WEST INS CO 19941 AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO34754 COMMERCE INS CO 40274 CITATION INS CO

199513161 WESTERN PIONEER INS CO 34754 COMMERCE INS CO40274 CITATION INS CO

199013161 WESTERN PIONEER INS CO 34754 COMMERCE INS CO40274 CITATION INS CO

198513161 WESTERN PIONEER INS CO 34754 COMMERCE INS CO40274 CITATION INS CO

818 Group Name:Group Code: LONE STAR GRP1985

18627 VICTORIA LLOYDS INS CO821 Group Name:Group Code: AON SERV GRP

200012734 STONE MOUNTAIN INS CO 20931 ATLANTA INTL INS CO35092 AMERICAN SPECIAL RISK INS CO 38946 PALADIN REINS CORP

199512734 STONE MOUNTAIN INS CO 20931 ATLANTA INTL INS CO35092 AMERICAN SPECIAL RISK INS CO 38946 PALADIN REINS CORP

199012734 STONE MOUNTAIN INS CO 20931 ATLANTA INTL INS CO35092 AMERICAN SPECIAL RISK INS CO 38946 PALADIN REINS CORP

198512734 STONE MOUNTAIN INS CO 20931 ATLANTA INTL INS CO35092 AMERICAN SPECIAL RISK INS CO 38946 PALADIN REINS CORP

827 Group Name:Group Code: AMERIN GRP1995

10185 AMERIN RE CORP 30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP1990

30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP1985

30872 AMERIN GUARANTY CORP828 Group Name:Group Code: GUARD INS CO GRP

200911981 WESTGUARD INS CO 14702 EASTGUARD INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners396

Page 405: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

828 Group Name:Group Code: GUARD INS CO GRP2009

31470 NORGUARD INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO2008

11981 WESTGUARD INS CO 14702 EASTGUARD INS CO31470 NORGUARD INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO

200711981 WESTGUARD INS CO 14702 EASTGUARD INS CO31470 NORGUARD INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO

200611981 WESTGUARD INS CO 14702 EASTGUARD INS CO31470 NORGUARD INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO

200511981 WESTGUARD INS CO 14702 EASTGUARD INS CO31470 NORGUARD INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO

200014702 EASTGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY 31470 NORGUARD INS CO42390 AMGUARD INS CO

199514702 EASTGUARD INSURANCE COMPANY 31470 NORGUARD INS CO42390 AMGUARD INS CO

199014702 MUTUAL FIRE INS CO 31470 NORGUARD INS CO42390 AMGUARD INS CO

198514702 MUTUAL FIRE INS CO 42390 AMGUARD INS CO

829 Group Name:Group Code: SIERRA HLTH SERV GRP2000

10856 SIERRA INS CO OF TX 10929 CII INS CO32271 CALIFORNIA IND INS CO 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO

831 Group Name:Group Code: DOCTORS CO GRP2009

10352 SCPIE IND CO 12486 NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS INS CO34487 PROFESSIONAL UNDERWRITERS LIAB INS C 34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCH35602 OHIC INS CO 38920 AMERICAN HLTHCARE SPECIALTY INS CO39152 AMERICAN HLTHCARE IND CO 41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

200810352 SCPIE IND CO 12486 NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS INS CO34487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO 34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCH35602 OHIC INS CO 38920 AMERICAN HLTHCARE SPECIALTY INS CO39152 AMERICAN HLTHCARE IND CO 41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

200712486 NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS INS CO 34487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCH 35602 OHIC INS CO41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

200612486 NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS INS CO 34487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN 41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

200512486 NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS INS CO 34487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN 41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

200034487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO 34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

199534487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO 34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS

199034487 PROFESSIONAL UNDRWTRS LIAB INS CO 34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners397

Page 406: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

831 Group Name:Group Code: DOCTORS CO GRP1990

41050 UNDERWRITER FOR THE PROFESSIONS INS1985

34495 DOCTORS CO AN INTERINS EXCHN832 Group Name:Group Code: MIDLAND FINANCIAL GRP INC

199511851 MIDLAND RISK INS CO 44288 SPECIALTY RISK INS CO

199011851 MIDLAND RISK INS CO 44288 SPECIALTY RISK INS CO

198511851 MIDLAND RISK INS CO

833 Group Name:Group Code: STRICKLAND INS GRP1995

26860 ATLANTIC SECURITY INS CO 37010 ATLANTIC IND CO42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO

199037010 ATLANTIC IND CO 42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO

198542846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO

838 Group Name:Group Code: CINCINNATI EQUITABLE CO GRP2007

16721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO 30457 SOUTHERN MI INS CO2006

16721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO 17507 LAKELAND INS CO30457 SOUTHERN MI INS CO

200516721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO 17507 LAKELAND INS CO30457 SOUTHERN MI INS CO

200016721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO 30457 SOUTHERN MI INS CO

199516721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO

199016721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO

198516721 CINCINNATI EQUITABLE INS CO

842 Group Name:Group Code: FARM BUREAU GRP2009

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMM INS CO2008

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO2007

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO2006

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO2005

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO2000

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO1995

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO1990

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO1985

13765 FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF ID 39519 WESTERN COMMUNITY INS CO843 Group Name:Group Code: CLASSIC FIRE & MARINE INS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners398

Page 407: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

843 Group Name:Group Code: CLASSIC FIRE & MARINE INS GRP1995

16284 CLASSIC FIRE & MARINE INS CO 23256 UNITED SOUTHERN ASSUR CO1990

16284 CLASSIC FIRE & MARINE INS CO 23256 UNITED SOUTHERN ASSUR CO1985

16284 CLASSIC FIRE & MARINE INS CO 23256 UNITED SOUTHERN ASSUR CO846 Group Name:Group Code: OLD GUARD INS GRP

200032735 FIRST DE INS CO

199514052 GOSCHENHOPPEN HOME INSURANCE CO 16853 OLD GUARD FIRE INS CO17558 OLD GUARD INS CO 27421 NEFFSVILLE MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

199014052 GOSCHENHOPPEN HOME INSURANCE CO 16853 OLD GUARD FIRE INS CO17558 OLD GUARD INS CO 27421 NEFFSVILLE MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

198514052 GOSCHENHOPPEN HOME INSURANCE CO 16853 OLD GUARD FIRE INS CO17558 OLD GUARD INS CO 27421 NEFFSVILLE MUTUAL FIRE INS CO

848 Group Name:Group Code: ARI INS CO GRP2009

13900 ARI MUT INS CO 37680 ARI CAS CO2008

13900 ARI MUT INS CO 37680 ARI CAS CO2007

13900 ARI MUT INS CO 37680 ARI CAS CO2006

13900 ARI MUT INS CO 37680 ARI CAS CO2005

13900 ARI MUT INS CO 37680 ARI CAS CO2000

13900 ARI MUTUAL INSURNACE COMPANY 20107 ARI IND CO37680 ARI CASUALTY COMPANY

199513900 ARI MUTUAL INSURNACE COMPANY 20107 ARI IND CO37680 ARI CASUALTY COMPANY

199013900 AMERICAN RELIANCE INS CO 37680 AMERICAN RELIANCE CASUALTY CO

198513900 AMERICAN RELIANCE INS CO 37680 AMERICAN RELIANCE CASUALTY CO

852 Group Name:Group Code: GENERAL AGENTS GRP2006

36838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC 40150 MGA INS CO INC2005

36838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC 40150 MGA INS CO INC2000

19544 GAINSCO CNTY MUT INS CO 36360 MIDWEST CAS INS CO36838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC 40150 MGA INS CO INC

199519544 GAINSCO CNTY MUT INS CO 36838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC40150 MGA INS CO INC

199036838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC 40150 MGA INS CO INC

198536838 GENERAL AGENTS INS CO OF AMER INC 40150 MGA INS CO INC

853 Group Name:Group Code: PUBLIC SERV GRP2009

10830 BUSINESS ALLIANCE INS CO 10997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners399

Page 408: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

853 Group Name:Group Code: PUBLIC SERV GRP2009

15059 PUBLIC SERV MUT INS CO 40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO2008

10830 BUSINESS ALLIANCE INS CO 10997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO15059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO 40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

200710997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO 15059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

200610997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO 15059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

200510997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO 15059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

200010997 WESTERN SELECT INS CO 15059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

199515059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO 40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

199015059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO 40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

198515059 PUBLIC SERVICE MUT INS CO 40177 PARAMOUNT INS CO

855 Group Name:Group Code: MILLERS FIRST INS CO GRP2009

14583 MILLERS FIRST INS CO 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INS CO2008

14583 MILLERS FIRST INS CO 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INS CO2007

14583 MILLERS FIRST INS CO 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INS CO2006

14583 MILLERS FIRST INS CO 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INS CO2005

14583 MILLERS FIRST INS CO 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INS CO2000

14583 MILLERS MUT INS ASSOC 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INSURANCE COMPANY1995

14583 MILLERS MUT INS ASSOC 40185 MILLERS CLASSIFIED INSURANCE COMPANY1990

14583 MILLERS MUT INS ASSOC 22160 CLASSIFIED INS CO INC40185 MILLERS GENERAL INS CO

198514583 MILLERS MUT INS ASSOC 22160 CLASSIFIED INS CO INC40185 MILLERS GENERAL INS CO

861 Group Name:Group Code: HOSPITAL SERV GRP2009

10686 MEDICAL LIAB ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN2008

10686 MEDICAL LIAB ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN2007

10686 MEDICAL LIAB ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN2006

10686 MEDICAL LIABILITY ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN2005

10686 MEDICAL LIABILITY ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN2000

10686 MEDICAL LIABILITY ALLIANCE 27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners400

Page 409: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

861 Group Name:Group Code: HOSPITAL SERV GRP1995

27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN1990

27642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN 33863 MISSOURI PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS ASN40401 PROVIDERS INS CO

198527642 MISSOURI HOSPITAL PLAN 33863 MISSOURI PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS ASN40401 PROVIDERS INS CO

863 Group Name:Group Code: INTER AMER GRP2006

26697 CASUALTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2005

26697 CASUALTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2000

26697 CASUALTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO1995

26697 CASUALTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO1990

26697 CASUALTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO866 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN WORLD GRP

200913196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

200813196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

200713196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

200613196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

200513196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

200013196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

199513196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

199013196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

198513196 WESTERN WORLD INS CO 37982 TUDOR INS CO40436 STRATFORD INS CO

867 Group Name:Group Code: BALDWIN & LYONS GRP2009

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 13149 PROTECTIVE SPECIALTY INS CO40460 SAGAMORE INS CO

200812416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 13149 PROTECTIVE SPECIALTY INS CO40460 SAGAMORE INS CO

200712416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners401

Page 410: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

867 Group Name:Group Code: BALDWIN & LYONS GRP2006

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO2005

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO2000

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO1995

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO1990

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO1985

12416 PROTECTIVE INS CO 40460 SAGAMORE INS CO869 Group Name:Group Code: MINNESOTA MUT GRP

200910054 SECURIAN CAS CO 30112 CNL INS AMER INC

200810054 SECURIAN CAS CO 30112 CNL INS AMER INC

200710054 SECURIAN CAS CO 30112 CNL INS AMER INC

200610054 SECURIAN CAS CO 30112 CNL INS AMER INC

200510054 SECURIAN CAS CO

200010054 HOMEPLUS INS CO

878 Group Name:Group Code: COLONIAL SAVINGS GRP2009

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO2007

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO2006

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO2005

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO2000

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO1995

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO1990

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO1985

40673 COLONIAL LLOYDS 43192 COLONIAL MORTGAGE INS CO882 Group Name:Group Code: ROCKWOOD GRP

199517671 PITTSBURGH MUT INS CO 35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO

199017671 PITTSBURGH MUT INS CO 35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO

198517671 PITTSBURGH MUT INS CO 35505 ROCKWOOD CAS INS CO

883 Group Name:Group Code: TEXAS EMPLOYERS INS ASSOC GRP1985

15253 TEXAS EMPLOYERS INS ASSOC 18503 TEXAS EMPLOYERS IND CO885 Group Name:Group Code: QUEENSWAY FIN HOLDINGS GRP

200018376 HERMITAGE INS CO 27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO28185 PARADIGM INS CO 29750 KODIAK INS CO32867 UNIVERSAL FIRE & CAS INS CO 34932 MAPFRE INS CO OF FL

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners402

Page 411: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

885 Group Name:Group Code: QUEENSWAY FIN HOLDINGS GRP2000

35777 INTERNATIONAL IND CO 37443 ATLANTIC ALLIANCE FIDELITY & SRTY CO38113 QUEENSWAY CAS INS CO 39462 QUEENSWAY INTERNATIONAL INDEMNITY C

199535777 INTERNATIONAL IND CO 39462 FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL INDEMNITY CO

199035777 INTERNATIONAL IND CO 39462 FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL INDEMNITY CO

198535777 INTERNATIONAL IND CO 39462 FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL INDEMNITY CO

888 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS GRP2009

10680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO17124 ELIZABETHTOWN INS CO

200810680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

200710680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

200610680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

200510680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

200010680 FRANKLIN HOMEOWNERS ASSUR CO 14729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

199014729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO

198514729 MUTUAL FIRE MARINE & INLAND INS CO 39705 FIRST NY SYNDICATE CORP

892 Group Name:Group Code: CARIBBEAN STAR GRP1990

35238 TRANS WORLD ASSUR CO 35645 EAGLE STAR INS CO OF PR1985

35238 TRANS WORLD ASSUR CO 35645 EAGLE STAR INS CO OF PR894 Group Name:Group Code: CITICORP INTL GRP

199527111 CITICORP INTL TRADE IND INC 38920 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SPECIALTY39152 FG INSURANCE CORP 43893 CITICORP INTERNATIONAL TRADE INS INC45039 CITICORP ASSUR CO

199027111 CITICORP INTL TRADE IND INC

898 Group Name:Group Code: CAPITOL COUNTY GRP2000

29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO1995

29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO1990

29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO1985

29211 CAPITOL CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO 36625 OLD RELIABLE CAS CO899 Group Name:Group Code: ROCKINGHAM GRP

200910214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO

200810214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO

200710214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO

200610214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners403

Page 412: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

899 Group Name:Group Code: ROCKINGHAM GRP2005

10214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO2000

10214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO1995

10214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO1990

10214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO1985

10214 ROCKINGHAM MUT INS CO 42595 ROCKINGHAM CAS CO901 Group Name:Group Code: CIGNA HLTH GRP

199510030 CIGNA INDEMNITY INSURANCE COMPANY 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO18511 CIGNA LLOYDS INS CO 20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO20699 CIGNA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 20702 CIGNA FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO20710 CENTURY IND CO 22667 CIGNA INS CO22691 CIGNA INS CO OF ILLINOIS 22705 CIGNA REINSURANCE CO22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER 22721 CIGNA INS CO OF TX22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 22764 CIGNA INS CO OF OH26417 CIGNA INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO30953 CIGNA INS CO OF PUERTO RICO 35130 CENTURY REIN CO36528 ALLIED INS CO 38741 CIGNA EMPLOYERS INS CO38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 40819 CIGNA WORLDWIDE INS CO42072 INA SURPLUS INSURANCE COMPANY 43575 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMERICA

199010030 ALASKA PACIFIC ASR CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO18511 CIGNA LLOYDS INS CO 20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO20699 CIGNA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 20702 CIGNA FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO20710 CENTURY IND CO 22667 CIGNA INS CO22675 CALIFORNIA UNION INS CO 22691 CIGNA INS CO OF ILLINOIS22705 CIGNA REINSURANCE CO 22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER22721 CIGNA INS CO OF TX 22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO22764 CIGNA INS CO OF OH 25348 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER26417 CIGNA INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 26670 AFIA INS CO27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO 30953 CIGNA INS CO OF PUERTO RICO35130 CENTURY REIN CO 36528 ALLIED INS CO38741 CIGNA EMPLOYERS INS CO 38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO40819 CIGNA WORLDWIDE INS CO 42072 DELAWARE REINSURANCE CO43575 CONNECTICUT GENERAL FIRE & CAS INS C

198510030 ALASKA PACIFIC ASR CO 18279 BANKERS STANDARD INS CO18511 CIGNA LLOYDS INS CO 20591 BANKERS STD FIRE & MARINE CO20699 CIGNA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO 20702 CIGNA FIRE UNDERWRITERS INS CO20710 CENTURY IND CO 22667 CIGNA INS CO22675 CALIFORNIA UNION INS CO 22691 CIGNA INS CO OF ILLINOIS22705 CIGNA REINSURANCE CO 22713 INSURANCE CO OF NORTH AMER22721 CIGNA INS CO OF TX 22748 PACIFIC EMPLOYERS INS CO22764 CIGNA INS CO OF OH 25348 INDEMNITY INS CO OF NORTH AMER26417 CIGNA INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 26670 AFIA INS CO27960 ILLINOIS UNION INS CO 35130 CENTURY REIN CO36528 ALLIED INS CO 38741 CIGNA EMPLOYERS INS CO38938 ATLANTIC EMPLOYERS INS CO 40819 CIGNA WORLDWIDE INS CO42072 DELAWARE REINSURANCE CO 43575 CONNECTICUT GENERAL FIRE & CAS INS C

902 Group Name:Group Code: SAIF GRP1985

41548 SAIF CORP OF OR905 Group Name:Group Code: THE LDS GRP

200911124 VERSANT CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners404

Page 413: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

905 Group Name:Group Code: THE LDS GRP2008

11124 VERSANT CAS INS CO2007

11124 VERSANT CAS INS CO2006

11124 VERSANT CAS INS CO2005

11124 VERSANT CAS INS CO907 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIED FIDELITY GRP

198510065 ALLIED FIDELITY INS 29165 TEXAS FIRE & CAS CO

910 Group Name:Group Code: MEAD RECO GRP1995

20451 MEAD REINSURANCE CORP1990

20451 MEAD REINSURANCE CORP 41815 ADENA SYNDICATE LIMITED1985

20451 MEAD REINSURANCE CORP 41815 ADENA SYNDICATE LIMITED917 Group Name:Group Code: HCSC GRP

200929718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO

200729718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO

200610713 THIRD COAST INS CO 12882 GHS FIRE INS CO29718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO

200510713 THIRD COAST INS CO 12882 GHS FIRE INS CO29718 GHS PROP & CAS INS CO

200010713 THIRD COAST INS CO

919 Group Name:Group Code: BARNSTABLE GRP2009

13463 BARNSTABLE CNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE CNTY INS CO2007

13463 BARNSTABLE CNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE CNTY INS CO2006

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO2005

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO2000

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO1995

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO1990

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO1985

13463 BARNSTABLE COUNTY MUT INS CO 41955 BARNSTABLE COUNTY INS CO920 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED AMER IND GRP

200910121 PENN PATRIOT INS CO 10673 PENN STAR INS CO11445 UNITED NATL CAS INS CO 13064 UNITED NATL INS CO32859 PENN AMER INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

200810121 PENN PATRIOT INS CO 10673 PENN STAR INS CO11445 UNITED NATL CAS INS CO 13064 UNITED NATL INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners405

Page 414: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

920 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED NATL GRP2008

32859 PENN AMER INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

200710121 PENN PATRIOT INS CO 10673 PENN-STAR INS CO11445 UNITED NATL CAS INS CO 13064 UNITED NATL INS CO32859 PENN AMER INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

200610121 PENN PATRIOT INS CO 10673 PENN-STAR INS CO11445 UNITED NATL CAS INS CO 13064 UNITED NATL INS CO32859 PENN-AMER INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

200510121 PENN PATRIOT INS CO 10673 PENN-STAR INS CO11445 UNITED NATL CAS INS CO 13064 UNITED NATL INS CO32859 PENN-AMER INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

200013064 UNITED NATL INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

199513064 UNITED NATL INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

199013064 UNITED NATL INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

198513064 UNITED NATL INS CO 41335 UNITED NATL SPECIALTY INS CO42048 DIAMOND STATE INS CO

922 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN ASSETS GRP2009

10024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 24635 WESTWARD INS CO27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST 40029 EXPLORER INS CO

200810024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 24635 WESTWARD INS CO27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST 40029 EXPLORER INS CO

200710024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST40029 EXPLORER INS CO

200610024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST40029 EXPLORER INS CO

200510024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST40029 EXPLORER INS CO

200010024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST40029 EXPLORER INS CO

199510024 INDEPENDENCE CAS & SURETY CO 27847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST40029 EXPLORER INS CO

199027847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST 40029 EXPLORER INS CO

198527847 INSURANCE CO OF THE WEST 40029 EXPLORER INS CO

923 Group Name:Group Code: ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners406

Page 415: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

923 Group Name:Group Code: ASSOC FIRST CAPITAL GRP2000

10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO 21296 CITICAPITAL INS CO.22454 MENDAKOTA INSURANCE COMPANY 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO33650 MENDOTA INS CO 38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

199521296 CITICAPITAL INS CO. 37249 ASSOCIATES LLOYDS INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO

199021296 CITICAPITAL INS CO. 37249 ASSOCIATES LLOYDS INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO

198521296 CITICAPITAL INS CO. 37249 ASSOCIATES LLOYDS INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO

924 Group Name:Group Code: PRINCETON INS CO1995

33456 HEALTH CARE INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO1990

33456 HEALTH CARE INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO1985

33456 HEALTH CARE INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO926 Group Name:Group Code: ORION CAPITAL GRP

199515610 CONNECTICUT SPLTY INS CO 18260 DESIGN PROFS INS CO24872 CONNECTICUT IND CO 24880 FIRE & CAS INS CO OF CT24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD 32794 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INS CO37818 SECURITY REINSURANCE CO 42684 EBI IND CO

199015610 CONNECTICUT SPLTY INS CO 18260 DESIGN PROFS INS CO24872 CONNECTICUT IND CO 24880 FIRE & CAS INS CO OF CT24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD 32794 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INS CO37818 SECURITY REINSURANCE CO 42684 EBI IND CO43524 SECURITY LLOYDS INS CO

198515610 CONNECTICUT SPLTY INS CO 18260 DESIGN PROFS INS CO24872 CONNECTICUT IND CO 24880 FIRE & CAS INS CO OF CT24902 SECURITY INS CO OF HARTFORD 32794 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INS CO37818 SECURITY REINSURANCE CO 38377 EBI INS CO42102 EMPLOYEE BENEFITS INS CO OF IL 42684 EBI IND CO43524 SECURITY LLOYDS INS CO

927 Group Name:Group Code: URC GRP1995

18619 UNDERWRITERS INSURANCE COMPANY 19489 COMMERCIAL UNDERWRITERS INS CO22314 UNDERWRITERS REIN CO

199018619 PINNACLE PROPERTY & CAS INS CORP 22314 UNDERWRITERS REIN CO

198518619 PINNACLE PROPERTY & CAS INS CORP 22314 UNDERWRITERS REIN CO

929 Group Name:Group Code: MMI COS GRP1995

12246 AMERICAN CONTINENTAL INS CO 36200 HEALTH PROVIDERS INS CO1990

12246 AMERICAN CONTINENTAL INS CO 36200 HEALTH PROVIDERS INS CO42501 UNITED STATES SEC FIRE & CAS INS CO

198512246 AMERICAN CONTINENTAL INS CO 41823 MULTI MEDICAL INS CO42501 UNITED STATES SEC FIRE & CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners407

Page 416: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

930 Group Name:Group Code: DHC GRP2009

19245 DANIELSON IND CO 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INS CO 19308 DANIELSON REINS CORP23671 NATIONAL AMER INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC

200819245 DANIELSON IND CO 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INS CO 19308 DANIELSON REINS CORP23671 NATIONAL AMER INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC

200719245 DANIELSON IND CO 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INS CO 19308 DANIELSON REINS CORP23671 NATIONAL AMER INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC

200619245 DANIELSON IND CO 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INS CO 19308 DANIELSON REIN CORP23671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC

200519245 DANIELSON IND CO 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INS CO 19308 DANIELSON REIN CORP23671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC

200019245 DANIELSON INDEMNITY COMPANY 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INSURANCE COMPANY 19308 DANIELSON REINSURANCE CORP23671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA 24470 VALOR INS CO INC44490 MISSION AMERICAN INS CO

199519245 DANIELSON INDEMNITY COMPANY 19269 DANIELSON NATL INS CO19285 DANIELSON INSURANCE COMPANY 19308 DANIELSON REINSURANCE CORP23671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA 44490 MISSION AMERICAN INS CO

199023671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA 44490 MISSION AMERICAN INS CO

198523671 NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO OF CA

933 Group Name:Group Code: INVESTORS INS HOLDING CORP1995

40991 CARLISLE INS CO1990

40991 CARLISLE INS CO1985

16420 U S RESERVE SYNDICATE CORP 40991 CARLISLE INS CO936 Group Name:Group Code: INDEPENDENCE BLUE CROSS GRP

200910975 AMERIHEALTH CAS INS CO

200710975 AMERIHEALTH CAS INS CO

200610975 AMERIHEALTH CAS INS CO

200510975 AMERIHEALTH CAS INS CO

937 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST NATL GRP1985

23019 FIRST NATL IND CO941 Group Name:Group Code: STATE NATL GRP

199543664 STATE NATL FIRE INS CO

944 Group Name:Group Code: INGRAM GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners408

Page 417: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

944 Group Name:Group Code: INGRAM GRP2000

12858 TENNESSEE INS CO 22906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH37648 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSURANCE CORP

199512858 TENNESSEE INS CO 22906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH37648 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSURANCE CORP

199012858 TENNESSEE INS CO 37648 NORDIC UNION REINSURANCE CORP43079 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSUR CORP

198512858 TENNESSEE INS CO 37648 NORDIC UNION REINSURANCE CORP43079 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSUR CORP

946 Group Name:Group Code: LUMBER INS COS GRP2000

14435 LUMBER MUT INS CO 15695 FOREST PRODUCTS INS EXCH21130 SEACO INS CO 43702 NORTH AMERICAN LUMBER INS CO

199514435 LUMBER MUT INS CO 15695 FOREST PRODUCTS INS EXCH21130 SEACO INS CO 43702 NORTH AMERICAN LUMBER INS CO

199014435 LUMBER MUT INS CO 15695 FOREST PRODUCTS INS EXCH21130 SEACO INS CO 43702 NORTH AMERICAN LUMBER INS CO

198514435 LUMBER MUT INS CO 15695 FOREST PRODUCTS INS EXCH21130 SEACO INS CO 43702 NORTH AMERICAN LUMBER INS CO

948 Group Name:Group Code: NATL GEN GRP2009

36765 GULF GUAR INS CO2008

36765 GULF GUAR INS CO2007

36765 GULF GUAR INS CO2006

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO2005

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO2000

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO1995

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO1990

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO1985

36765 GULF GUARANTY INS CO949 Group Name:Group Code: IMPERIAL MGMT GRP

200044369 IMPERIAL FIRE & CAS INS CO

199528690 IMPERIAL LLOYDS 44369 IMPERIAL FIRE & CAS INS CO

950 Group Name:Group Code: TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED2000

10738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO12904 TOKIO MARINE & FIRE INS CO LTD US BR 41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

199512904 TOKIO MARINE & FIRE INS CO LTD US BR 18643 HOUSTON GENERAL LLOYDS38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO 41718 TRADERS & PACIFIC INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners409

Page 418: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

950 Group Name:Group Code: TOKIO MARINE CONSOLIDATED1990

12904 TOKIO MARINE & FIRE INS CO LTD US BR 18643 HOUSTON GENERAL LLOYDS38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO 41718 TRADERS & PACIFIC INS CO

198512904 TOKIO MARINE & FIRE INS CO LTD US BR 18643 HOUSTON GENERAL LLOYDS38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO 41718 TRADERS & PACIFIC INS CO

952 Group Name:Group Code: WALSHIRE ASSUR GRP1995

10036 COMP AMERICA INSURANCE CO INC 33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO1990

33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO1985

33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO954 Group Name:Group Code: ADVANTA INS GRP

200933987 ADVANTA INS CO

200733987 ADVANTA INS CO

200633987 ADVANTA INS CO

200533987 ADVANTA INS CO

200033987 ADVANTA INS CO

199533987 ADVANTA INS CO

957 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN RE GRP1995

10227 AMERICAN REIN CO 19720 AMERICAN UNION REINSURANCE CO1990

10227 AMERICAN REIN CO 19720 AMERICAN UNION REINSURANCE CO1985

10227 AMERICAN REIN CO 19720 AMERICAN UNION REINSURANCE CO958 Group Name:Group Code: VESTA INS GRP

200910663 FLORIDA SELECT INS CO 11762 VESTA FIRE INS CORP15156 SHELBY INS CO 22438 HIG LTD30503 SHELBY CAS INS COMP 42668 VESTA INS CORP43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

200710663 FLORIDA SELECT INS CO 11762 VESTA FIRE INS CORP15156 SHELBY INS CO 22438 HIG LTD30503 SHELBY CAS INS COMP 42668 VESTA INS CORP43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

200610663 FLORIDA SELECT INS CO 11762 VESTA FIRE INS CORP15156 SHELBY INS CO 22438 HIG LTD30503 SHELBY CAS INS COMP 42668 VESTA INS CORP43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

200510663 FLORIDA SELECT INS CO 11762 VESTA FIRE INS CORP15156 SHELBY INS CO 22438 HAWAIIAN INS & GTY CO LTD30503 SHELBY CAS INS COMP 42668 VESTA INS CORP43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners410

Page 419: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

958 Group Name:Group Code: VESTA INS GRP2000

10959 VESTA CAPITAL INS SYNDICATE INC 11762 VESTA FIRE INS CO15156 SHELBY INS CO 22438 HAWAIIAN INS & GTY CO LTD26620 SHEFFIELD INS CORP (ALABAMA) 30503 SHELBY CASUALTY INSURANCE COMP38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO 42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO42668 VESTA INS CORP 43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

199511762 VESTA FIRE INS CO 22438 HAWAIIAN INS & GTY CO LTD26620 SHEFFIELD INS CORP (ALABAMA) 29394 RANGER COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO42668 VESTA INS CORP 43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

199011762 LIBERTY NATIONAL FIRE INS CO 22438 HAWAIIAN INS & GTY CO LTD26620 SHEFFIELD INS CORP (ALABAMA) 29394 RANGER COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO42668 VESTA INS CORP 43885 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO

198511762 LIBERTY NATIONAL FIRE INS CO 22438 HAWAIIAN INS & GTY CO LTD26620 SHEFFIELD INS CORP (ALABAMA) 29394 RANGER COUNTY MUTUAL INS CO42668 VESTA INS CORP

959 Group Name:Group Code: CENTURY SURETY GRP2007

21903 PROCENTURY INS CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO2006

21903 PROCENTURY INS CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO2005

21903 PROCENTURY INS CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO2000

12750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

199512750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

199012750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

198512750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 36951 CENTURY SURETY CO39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

960 Group Name:Group Code: FCB CO GRP2006

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO2005

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO2000

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO1995

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO1990

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO1985

35521 AMERICAN GUARANTY INS CO961 Group Name:Group Code: FRONTIER INS GRP

200829548 WESTERN IND INS CO 34266 FRONTIER INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

200729548 WESTERN IND INS CO 34266 FRONTIER INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners411

Page 420: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

961 Group Name:Group Code: FRONTIER INS GRP2006

29548 WESTERN IND INS CO 34266 FRONTIER INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

200529548 WESTERN IND INS CO 34266 FRONTIER INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

200029548 WESTERN IND INS CO 34266 FRONTIER INS CO39330 UNITED CAPITOL INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

199534266 FRONTIER INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

199034266 FRONTIER INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

198534266 FRONTIER INS CO 42250 FRONTIER PACIFIC INS CO

963 Group Name:Group Code: OHIO MUT GRP2009

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO2008

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO2007

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO2006

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO2005

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO2000

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO1995

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO1990

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO1985

10202 OHIO MUT INS CO 13072 UNITED OHIO INS CO964 Group Name:Group Code: MERIT FINANCIAL GRP

199510188 MERIT INS CO 11916 MERIT CASUALTY COMPANY

199011916 MERIT INS CO

198511916 MERIT INS CO

966 Group Name:Group Code: AP CAPITAL GRP2009

10229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 33006 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS ASSUR CORP2008

10229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 10927 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER33006 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS ASSUR CORP

200710229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 10927 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER33006 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS ASSUR CORP

200610229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 10927 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER33006 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS ASSUR CORP

200510229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 10927 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER33006 AMERICAN PHYSICIANS ASSUR CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners412

Page 421: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

966 Group Name:Group Code: AP CAPITAL GRP2000

10229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 10927 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER33006 MUTUAL INSURANCE CORPORATION OF AME

199510229 APSPECIALITY INS CORP 33006 MICHIGAN PHYSICIANS MUTUAL LIAB CO38105 KENTUCKY MEDICAL INS CO

199033006 MICHIGAN PHYSICIANS MUTUAL LIAB CO 38105 KENTUCKY MEDICAL INS CO

198533006 MICHIGAN PHYSICIANS MUTUAL LIAB CO 38105 KENTUCKY MEDICAL INS CO

967 Group Name:Group Code: AIB INS GRP1995

15075 UNION AMERICAN INS CO1990

15075 UNION AMERICAN INS CO1985

15075 UNION AMERICAN INS CO968 Group Name:Group Code: AXA INS GRP

200916187 AXA RE PROP & CAS INS CO 33022 AXA INS CO36552 COLISEUM REINS CO

200816187 AXA RE PROP & CAS INS CO 33022 AXA INS CO36552 COLISEUM REINS CO

200716187 AXA RE PROP & CAS INS CO 33022 AXA INS CO36552 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS REINS CO

200611096 UNIGARD PACIFIC INS CO 16187 AXA RE PROP & CAS INS CO18821 GENERAL CAS CO OF IL 19178 SOUTHERN GTY INS CO22861 SOUTHERN PILOT INS CO 22888 SOUTHERN FIRE & CAS CO24414 GENERAL CAS CO OF WI 24449 REGENT INS CO24503 BLUE RIDGE INS CO 25747 UNIGARD INS CO25798 UNIGARD IND CO 27570 HOOSIER INS CO33022 AXA INS CO 34100 MASSWEST INS CO INC36552 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS REINS CO 40754 BLUE RIDGE IND CO40762 SOUTHERN GUARANTY INS CO OF GA

200510971 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS LLOYDS INS CO TX 11835 AXA RE AMER INS CO16187 AXA RE PROP & CAS INS CO 33022 AXA INS CO36552 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS REINS CO

200011835 AXA RE AMERICA INS CO 15989 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS EX & SURP LNS INS16187 JOHN HANCOCK PROP & CAS INS CO 33022 AXA GLOBAL RISKS US INS CO36552 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS REINS CO

199536552 AXA CORP SOLUTIONS REINS CO

982 Group Name:Group Code: PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI2005

23400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI 34762 CENTURY AMERICAN INS CO2000

11711 CENTURY AMERICAN CASUALTY CO 23400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI34762 CENTURY AMERICAN INS CO

199523400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI 44334 PROFESSIONAL ASSUR CO

199023400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI 44334 PROFESSIONAL ASSUR CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners413

Page 422: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

984 Group Name:Group Code: HCC INS HOLDINGS GRP2009

10216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 10367 AVEMCO INS CO10656 UNITED STATES SURETY CO 11243 HCC SPECIALTY INS CO12670 PIONEER GEN INS CO 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO36781 HCC INS CO 42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

200810216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 10367 AVEMCO INS CO10656 UNITED STATES SURETY CO 11243 HCC SPECIALTY INS CO12670 PIONEER GEN INS CO 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO36781 HCC INS CO 42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

200710216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 10367 AVEMCO INS CO10656 UNITED STATES SURETY CO 11243 HCC SPECIALTY INS CO12670 PIONEER GENERAL INS CO 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO36781 HCC INS CO 42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

200610216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 10367 AVEMCO INS CO10656 UNITED STATES SURETY CO 11243 HCC SPECIALTY INS CO29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO 36781 HCC INS CO42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

200510216 AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO 10367 AVEMCO INS CO10656 UNITED STATES SURETY CO 11243 HCC SPECIALTY INS CO29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO 36781 HCC INS CO42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

200010367 AVEMCO INS CO 17159 USF INS CO23736 NATIONAL INSURANCE UNDERWRITERS 29599 US SPECIALTY INS CO36781 CENTRIS INS CO 42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

199525433 TRAFALGOR INSURANCE COMPANY 42374 HOUSTON CAS CO

199042374 HOUSTON CAS CO

198542374 HOUSTON CAS CO

999 Group Name:Group Code: RISK RETENTION GRP1995

10082 PEER INS RRG CORP1990

44210 ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION INS CO RRG1111 Group Name:Group Code: TIG INS GRP

199518864 FAIRMONT INS CO 23680 TIG REIN CO25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP 25453 TIG COUNTRYWIDE INS CO25461 TIG INS CO OF TX 25488 TIG INS CO OF NY25496 TIG IND CO 25518 TIG PREMIER INS CO25526 TIG INS CORP OF AMER 25534 TIG INS CO25542 TIG INS CO OF MI 29327 INDUSTRIAL COUNTY MUT INS CO35610 TIG INS CO OF CO 42021 TIG LLOYDS INS CO43184 TIG AMERICAN SPECIALTY INSURANCE CO

199018864 FAIRMONT INS CO 23680 TIG REIN CO25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP 25453 TIG COUNTRYWIDE INS CO25461 TIG INS CO OF TX 25488 TIG INS CO OF NY25496 TIG IND CO 25518 TIG PREMIER INS CO25526 TIG INS CORP OF AMER 25534 TIG INS CO25542 TIG INS CO OF MI 29327 INDUSTRIAL COUNTY MUT INS CO35610 TIG INS CO OF CO 42021 TIG LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners414

Page 423: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1111 Group Name:Group Code: TIG INS GRP1990

43184 CHILTON INS CO1985

18864 FAIRMONT INS CO 23680 TIG REIN CO25445 TIG SPECIALTY INS CORP 25453 TIG COUNTRYWIDE INS CO25461 TIG INS CO OF TX 25488 TIG INS CO OF NY25496 TIG IND CO 25518 TIG PREMIER INS CO25526 TIG INS CORP OF AMER 25534 TIG INS CO25542 TIG INS CO OF MI 29327 INDUSTRIAL COUNTY MUT INS CO35610 TIG INS CO OF CO 42021 TIG LLOYDS INS CO43184 CHILTON INS CO

1112 Group Name:Group Code: NEW MEXICO MUT GRP2009

10207 NEW MEXICO SW CAS CO 13673 NEW MEXICO ASSUR CO13674 NEW MEXICO EMPLOYERS ASSUR CO 13675 NEW MEXICO PREMIER INS CO23051 NEW MEXICO FOUNDATION INS CO 40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

200810207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO 23051 FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

200710207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO 23051 FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

200610207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO 23051 FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

200510207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO 23051 FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

200010207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO 23051 FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC40627 NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO

199510207 SOUTHWEST CAS CO

1113 Group Name:Group Code: MEDMARK INS GRP2009

17400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 22241 MEDMARC CAS INS CO32089 MEDMARC MUT INS CO

200817400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 22241 MEDMARC CAS INS CO32089 MEDMARC MUT INS CO

200717400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 22241 MEDMARC CAS INS CO32089 MEDMARC MUT INS CO

200617400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 22241 MEDMARC CAS INS CO32089 MEDMARC MUT INS CO

200517400 NOETIC SPECIALTY INS CO 22241 MEDMARC CAS INS CO32089 MEDMARC MUT INS CO

200022241 MEDMARC CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPAN 32089 MEDMARC MUTUAL INSURANCE CO

199522241 MEDMARC CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPAN 32089 MEDMARC INSURANCE COMPANY INC

199022241 DEPENDABLE INS CO INC

198522241 DEPENDABLE INS CO INC

1114 Group Name:Group Code: MERCER INS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners415

Page 424: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1114 Group Name:Group Code: MERCER INS GRP2009

10728 FRANKLIN INS CO 14478 MERCER INS CO31453 FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

200810728 FRANKLIN INS CO 14478 MERCER INS CO31453 FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

200710728 FRANKLIN INS CO 14478 MERCER INS CO31453 FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

200610728 FRANKLIN INS CO 14478 MERCER INS CO31453 FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

200510728 FRANKLIN INS CO 14478 MERCER INS CO31453 FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

200014478 PATTIS FAVORITE INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO OF NJ INC

199514478 PATTIS FAVORITE INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO INC

199014478 MERCER MUTUAL INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO INC

198514478 MERCER MUTUAL INS CO 43540 MERCER INS CO INC

1116 Group Name:Group Code: HIGHLANDS INS GRP INC2000

12084 AMERICAN PROFESSIONALS INS CO 12661 STATE CAPITAL INS CO22489 HIGHLANDS INS CO 22497 HIGHLANDS UNDERWRITERS INS CO23086 LMI INS CO 23906 NORTHWESTERN NATL CAS CO23930 PACIFIC NATL INS CO 25208 STATESMAN INS CO29785 NN INS CO 32549 ABERDEEN INS CO37966 HIGHLANDS CAS CO 40851 HIGHLANDS LLOYDS41408 PACIFIC AUTOMOBILE INS CO

199522489 HIGHLANDS INS CO 22497 HIGHLANDS UNDERWRITERS INS CO32549 ABERDEEN INS CO 37966 HIGHLANDS CAS CO40851 HIGHLANDS LLOYDS

199022489 HIGHLANDS INS CO 22497 HIGHLANDS UNDERWRITERS INS CO32549 ABERDEEN INS CO 37966 HIGHLANDS CAS CO40851 HIGHLANDS LLOYDS

198522489 HIGHLANDS INS CO 22497 HIGHLANDS UNDERWRITERS INS CO32549 ABERDEEN INS CO 37966 HIGHLANDS CAS CO40851 HIGHLANDS LLOYDS

1120 Group Name:Group Code: EVEREST REINS HOLDINGS GRP2009

10120 EVEREST NATL INS CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

200810120 EVEREST NATL INS CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

200710120 EVEREST NATL INS CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners416

Page 425: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1120 Group Name:Group Code: EVEREST REINS HOLDINGS GRP2006

10120 EVEREST NATL INS CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

200510120 EVEREST NATL INS CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

200010120 EVEREST NATIONAL INSURANCE CO 10851 EVEREST IND INS CO22110 EVEREST SECURITY INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO35947 MT MCKINLEY INS CO

199510120 PRUDENTIAL NATIONAL INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO

199010120 PRUDENTIAL NATIONAL INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO

198510120 PRUDENTIAL NATIONAL INS CO 26921 EVEREST REINS CO

1124 Group Name:Group Code: RAS DAKOTA GRP2009

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS2008

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS2007

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS2006

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS2005

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS2000

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS1995

10351 FIRST DAKOTA IND CO 34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS1990

34924 DAKOTA TRUCK UNDERWRITERS1125 Group Name:Group Code: SCPIE GRP

200710352 SCPIE IND CO 38920 AMERICAN HLTHCARE SPECIALTY INS CO39152 AMERICAN HLTHCARE IND CO

200610352 SCPIE IND CO 38920 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SPECIALTY39152 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE IND CO

200510352 SCPIE IND CO 38920 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SPECIALTY39152 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE IND CO

200010352 SCPIE IND CO 38920 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SPECIALTY39152 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE INDEMNITY CO

199510352 SCPIE IND CO 32824 SOUTHERN CA PHYS INS EXCH

199032824 SOUTHERN CA PHYS INS EXCH 38920 AMERICAN HEALTHCARE SPECIALTY39152 FG INSURANCE CORP

198532824 SOUTHERN CA PHYS INS EXCH 39152 FG INSURANCE CORP

1129 Group Name:Group Code: WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners417

Page 426: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1129 Group Name:Group Code: WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP2009

10238 POTOMAC INS CO 11988 HOUSTON GEN INS EXCH20621 ONEBEACON AMER INS CO 20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO21741 ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ 21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSOC21962 PENNSYLVANIA GEN INS CO 21970 ONEBEACON INS CO25712 ESURANCE INS CO 27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO30210 ESURANCE PROP & CAS INS CO 31267 YORK INS CO OF ME34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 AUTOONE INS CO34479 AUTOONE SELECT INS CO 37915 ESSENTIA INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 38776 WHITE MOUNTAINS REINS CO OF AMER38849 HOUSTON GEN INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GEN INS CO39489 ONEBEACON LLOYD'S OF TX 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO42650 ONEBEACON MIDWEST INS CO

200810238 POTOMAC INS CO 11988 HOUSTON GEN INS EXCH20621 ONEBEACON AMER INS CO 20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO21741 ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ 21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSOC21962 PENNSYLVANIA GEN INS CO 21970 ONEBEACON INS CO25712 ESURANCE INS CO 27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO30210 ESURANCE PROP & CAS INS CO 31267 YORK INS CO OF ME34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 AUTOONE INS CO34479 AUTOONE SELECT INS CO 37915 ESSENTIA INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 38776 WHITE MOUNTAINS REINS CO OF AMER38849 HOUSTON GEN INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO39489 ONEBEACON LLOYD'S OF TX 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO42650 ONEBEACON MIDWEST INS CO

200710238 POTOMAC INS CO 10391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO11988 HOUSTON GEN INS EXCH 19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO20621 ONEBEACON AMER INS CO 20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO21741 ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ 21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSOC21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO 21970 ONEBEACON INS CO25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO 25712 ESURANCE INS CO27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO 30210 ESURANCE PROP & CAS INS CO31267 YORK INS CO OF ME 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 AUTOONE INS CO34479 AUTOONE SELECT INS CO 37915 ESSENTIA INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 38776 FOLKSAMERICA REINS CO38849 HOUSTON GEN INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO39489 ONEBEACON LLOYD'S OF TX 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO42650 ONEBEACON MIDWEST INS CO

200610238 POTOMAC INS CO 10391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO11988 HOUSTON GENERAL INS EXCH 19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO20613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO 20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO 21741 ESURANCE INS CO OF NJ21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSOC 21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO21970 ONEBEACON INS CO 23647 STOCKBRIDGE INS CO25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO 25712 ESURANCE INS CO27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO 30210 ESURANCE PROP AND CAS INS CO31267 YORK INS CO OF ME 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 AUTOONE INS CO34479 AUTOONE SELECT INS CO 37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER 38776 FOLKSAMERICA REIN CO38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO 38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO39489 ONEBEACON LLOYD'S OF TX 40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO42650 ONEBEACON MIDWEST INS CO

200510238 POTOMAC INS CO 10391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO11988 HOUSTON GENERAL INS EXCH

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners418

Page 427: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1129 Group Name:Group Code: WHITE MOUNTAINS GRP2005

19011 MIDWESTERN INS CO 20613 AMERICAN EMPLOYERS INS CO20621 ONEBEACON AMERICA INS CO 20648 EMPLOYERS FIRE INS CO21741 HOMELAND CENTRAL INS CO 21946 CAMDEN FIRE INS ASSOC21962 PENNSYLVANIA GENERAL INS CO 21970 ONEBEACON INS CO25704 FARMERS & MERCHANTS INS CO 25712 ESURANCE INS CO27154 ATLANTIC SPECIALTY INS CO 30210 ESURANCE PROP AND CAS INS CO31267 YORK INS CO OF ME 32280 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO34452 HOMELAND INS CO OF NY 34460 AUTOONE INS CO34479 AUTOONE SELECT INS CO 35408 SIRIUS AMER INS CO37915 AMERICAN CENTRAL INS CO 38369 NORTHERN ASSUR CO OF AMER38776 FOLKSAMERICA REIN CO 38849 HOUSTON GENERAL INS CO38857 TRADERS & GENERAL INS CO 39489 ONEBEACON LLOYD'S OF TX40320 MASSACHUSETTS HOMELAND INS CO 42650 ONEBEACON MIDWEST INS CO

200010391 AMERICAN CENTENNIAL INS CO 11166 C-F INS CO14958 PENINSULA INS CO 28711 PCA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO38776 FOLKSAMERICA REIN CO 39900 PENINSULA IND CO

199510205 WHITE MOUNTAINS INS CO 14133 VALLEY INS CO29351 CHARTER COUNTY MUT INS CO 37524 CHARTER IND CO

199014133 VALLEY INS CO 26093 LINCOLN NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO29351 CHARTER COUNTY MUT INS CO 37524 CHARTER IND CO

198514133 VALLEY INS CO 26093 LINCOLN NATIONAL SPECIALTY INS CO29351 CHARTER COUNTY MUT INS CO 37524 CHARTER IND CO

1131 Group Name:Group Code: GREAT CENTRAL INS GRP2009

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO2007

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO2006

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO2005

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO2000

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO1995

43621 GREAT CENTRAL FIRE INS CO1132 Group Name:Group Code: ARMOR INS GRP

199510059 TEXAS EMPLOYERS INDEMNITY COMPANY 33782 ARMOR INS CO

199033782 ARMOR INS CO

1134 Group Name:Group Code: CHARTWELL GRP1995

18341 REINSURANCE CORP OF NY 29378 OLD AMERICAN CTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO34908 RECOR INS CO INC 36870 CHARTWELL REIN CO

199018341 REINSURANCE CORP OF NY 29378 OLD AMERICAN CTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO34908 RECOR INS CO INC 36870 CHARTWELL REIN CO

198518341 REINSURANCE CORP OF NY 29378 OLD AMERICAN CTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO34908 RECOR INS CO INC 36870 CHARTWELL REIN CO

1135 Group Name:Group Code: PMI GRP2009

10287 PMI INS CO 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUAR CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners419

Page 428: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1135 Group Name:Group Code: PMI GRP2009

10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO 12815 FINANCIAL GUAR INS CO12917 PMI REINS CO 18732 PMI MORTGAGE ASSUR CO26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP 27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

200810287 PMI INS CO 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUAR CO10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO 12815 FINANCIAL GUAR INS CO12917 PMI REINS CO 18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP 27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

200710287 PMI INS CO 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUARANTY CO10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO 12618 PMI GUARANTY CO12815 FINANCIAL GUAR INS CO 12917 PMI REINS CO18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP 26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

200610287 RESIDENTIAL GUARANTY CO 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUARANTY CO10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO 12618 PMI GUARANTY CO12815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO 18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP 27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

200510287 RESIDENTIAL GUARANTY CO 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUARANTY CO10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO 12815 FINANCIAL GUARANTY INS CO18732 COMMERCIAL LOAN INS CORP 26786 WMAC CREDIT INS CORP27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

200010287 RESIDENTIAL GUARANTY COMPANY 10670 PMI MORTGAGE GUARANTY CO10706 PINEBROOK MORTGAGE INS CO 10741 RESIDENTIAL INS CO27251 PMI MORTGAGE INS CO

1137 Group Name:Group Code: COVENTRY CORP GRP2009

11531 CHC CAS RRG2007

11531 CHC CAS RRG2006

11531 CHC CAS RRG2005

11531 CHC CAS RRG1138 Group Name:Group Code: BLUE CROSS & BLUE SHIELD OF ME

199032069 BLUE ALLIANCE MUT INS CO

198532069 BLUE ALLIANCE MUT INS CO

1141 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH POINTE GRP2007

11072 HOME POINTE INS CO 27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO30589 CAPITAL CITY INS CO INC 39462 NORTH POINTE CAS INS CO

200611072 HOME POINTE INS CO 27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO39462 NORTH POINTE CASUALTY INS CO

200511072 HOME POINTE INS CO 27740 NORTH POINTE INS CO39462 NORTH POINTE CASUALTY INS CO

199027740 NORTH POINTE INS CO

1142 Group Name:Group Code: WORKCOMP INS GRP2007

10390 WORKCOMP HI INS CO INC 10797 WORKCOMP HI SELECT INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners420

Page 429: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1142 Group Name:Group Code: WORKCOMP INS GRP2006

10390 WORKCOMP HI INS CO INC 10797 WORKCOMP HI SELECT INC2005

10390 WORKCOMP HI INS CO INC 10797 WORKCOMP HI SELECT INC2000

10390 WORKCOMP HI INS CO INC 10797 WORKCOMP HAWAII SELECT INC1143 Group Name:Group Code: GEISINGER INS GRP

200010244 GEISINGER INDEMNITY INS CO

1144 Group Name:Group Code: PIE MUT INS GRP1990

28800 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER 33928 PIE MUT INS CO1985

28800 INSURANCE CORP OF AMER 33928 PIE MUT INS CO1146 Group Name:Group Code: PLAINS DAWSON GRP

199013927 DAWSON HAIL INS CO 20419 PLAINS INS CO

198513927 DAWSON HAIL INS CO 20419 PLAINS INS CO

1147 Group Name:Group Code: WORKERS COMP OF UTAH GRP2009

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND2008

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND2007

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND2006

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND2005

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND2000

10033 WORKERS COMP FUND OF UT 40517 ADVANTAGE WORKERS COMP INS CO1148 Group Name:Group Code: AUTO CLUB GRP

200515512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO

200015512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO

199015512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO

198515512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO

1154 Group Name:Group Code: PROMUTUAL GRP2009

10206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO20400 PROSELECT NATL INS CO INC 33111 MHA INS CO42510 WASHINGTON CAS CO

200810206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO20400 PROSELECT NATL INS CO INC

200710206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO20400 PROSELECT NATL INS CO INC

200610206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO20400 PROSELECT NATL INS CO INC

200510206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUT INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners421

Page 430: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1154 Group Name:Group Code: PROMUTUAL GRP2005

20400 PROSELECT NATL INS CO INC2000

10206 MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL MUTUAL INS CO 10638 PROSELECT INS CO20400 PROSELECT NATIONAL INS CO INC

1159 Group Name:Group Code: R W HOUSER INC1990

31755 MIDWEST SECURITY INS CO1985

31755 MIDWEST SECURITY INS CO1162 Group Name:Group Code: UNIVERSAL BONDING GRP

199014770 UNIVERSAL BONDING INS CO 15563 HEART OF AMERICA FIRE & CASUALTY CO

198514770 UNIVERSAL BONDING INS CO 15563 HEART OF AMERICA FIRE & CASUALTY CO

1164 Group Name:Group Code: LOEWEN GRP2000

10246 SECURITY PLAN FIRE INS CO1166 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICAL INTER INS EXCH GRP

200010933 MIIX INS CO 17205 MIIX INS CO OF NY28916 LAWRENCEVILLE PROP & CAS CO INC

1167 Group Name:Group Code: OPTIMUM GRP2000

16543 OPTIMUM PROPERTY & CASUALTY INSUR CO1169 Group Name:Group Code: GENERALI GRP

200911231 GENERALI US BRANCH

200811231 GENERALI US BRANCH

200711231 GENERALI US BRANCH

200611231 GENERALI US BRANCH

200511231 GENERALI US BRANCH

200011231 GENERALI US BRANCH

199511231 GENERALI-US BRANCH

199011231 GENERALI-US BRANCH

1172 Group Name:Group Code: LEGION INS GRP2000

19577 VILLANOVA INSURANCE CO 24422 LEGION INS CO29912 LEGION INDEMNITY COMPANY 35025 US INSURORS CO

1178 Group Name:Group Code: CHARTER INS GRP2009

10664 ENDEAVOUR INS CO 11984 INDEPENDENCE CAS INS CO44326 ATLANTIC CHARTER INS CO

200710664 ENDEAVOUR INS CO 11984 INDEPENDENCE CAS INS CO44326 ATLANTIC CHARTER INS CO

200610664 ENDEAVOUR INS CO 11984 INDEPENDENCE CAS INS CO44326 ATLANTIC CHARTER INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners422

Page 431: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1178 Group Name:Group Code: CHARTER INS GRP2005

10664 ENDEAVOUR INS CO 11984 INDEPENDENCE CAS INS CO44326 ATLANTIC CHARTER INS CO

1179 Group Name:Group Code: WAWANESA INS GRP2009

10683 WAWANESA GEN INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH2008

10683 WAWANESA GENERAL INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH2007

10683 WAWANESA GENERAL INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH2006

10683 WAWANESA GENERAL INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH2005

10683 WAWANESA GENERAL INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH2000

10683 WAWANESA GENERAL INS CO 31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH1995

31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH1990

31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH1985

31526 WAWANESA MUT INS CO US BRANCH1189 Group Name:Group Code: VISION SERV PLAN GRP

200032395 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO 39616 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO

199532395 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO 39616 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO

199032395 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO 39616 VISION SERVICE PLAN INS CO

1196 Group Name:Group Code: ONYX INS GRP2000

12726 ARIES INS CO INC 15270 ARIES INS CO1995

15270 ARIES INS CO 33065 AMERICAN SKYHAWK INS CO1990

15270 ARIES INS CO 33065 AMERICAN SKYHAWK INS CO1985

15270 ARIES INS CO1202 Group Name:Group Code: BCBS OF NJ GRP

200010918 HORIZON HEALTHCARE INS CO OF PA

1204 Group Name:Group Code: AULTMAN HEALTH FOUNDATION2000

10694 PRIMETIME MEDICAL INS CO1205 Group Name:Group Code: TRAVEL AIR INS GRP

200010696 TRAVEL AIR INS CO LTD 40584 TRAVEL AIR INS CO KS

1208 Group Name:Group Code: GRAY INS GRP2009

10671 THE GRAY CAS & SURETY CO 36307 GRAY INS CO2008

10671 THE GRAY CASUALTY & SURETY CO 36307 GRAY INS CO2007

10671 THE GRAY CASUALTY & SURETY CO 36307 GRAY INS CO2006

10671 THE GRAY CASUALTY & SURETY CO 36307 GRAY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners423

Page 432: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1208 Group Name:Group Code: GRAY INS GRP2005

10671 THE GRAY CASUALTY & SURETY CO 36307 GRAY INS CO2000

10671 GRAY CAS CO 36307 GRAY INS CO1210 Group Name:Group Code: MLMIC GRP

200934231 MEDICAL LIAB MUT INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO

200834231 MEDICAL LIAB MUT INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO

200734231 MEDICAL LIAB MUT INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO

200634231 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO 35602 OHIC INS CO42226 PRINCETON INS CO

200534231 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO 35602 OHIC INS CO42226 PRINCETON INS CO

200034231 HEALTHCARE UNDERWRITERS MUTUAL I C 35602 OHIC INS CO

1213 Group Name:Group Code: DIRECT GEN GRP2009

10889 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF LA23736 DIRECT NATL INS CO 37220 DIRECT INS CO42781 DIRECT GEN INS CO

200810889 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF LA23736 DIRECT NATL INS CO 37220 DIRECT INS CO42781 DIRECT GEN INS CO

200710889 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GEN INS CO OF LA23736 DIRECT NATL INS CO 37220 DIRECT INS CO42781 DIRECT GEN INS CO

200610889 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO OF LA23736 DIRECT NATL INS CO 37220 DIRECT INS CO42781 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO

200510889 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO OF LA23736 DIRECT NATL INS CO 37220 DIRECT INS CO42781 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO

200010889 DIRECT GENERAL INS CO OF MS 14630 DIRECT GENERAL INSURANCE CO OF LA37220 DIRECT INS CO 42781 DIRECT GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY

1214 Group Name:Group Code: PEMBRIDGE AMER GRP1995

15130 AMERICAN SURETY & CAS CO1990

15130 AMERICAN SURETY & CAS CO1985

15130 AMERICAN SURETY & CAS CO1217 Group Name:Group Code: UAP CKAG GRP

199515989 COLONIA UNDERWRITERS INS CO 33022 COLONIA INS CO

199015989 COLONIA UNDERWRITERS INS CO 33022 COLONIA INS CO

198515989 COLONIA UNDERWRITERS INS CO 33022 COLONIA INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners424

Page 433: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1218 Group Name:Group Code: PENN AMER GRP2000

10673 PENN-STAR INS CO 32859 PENN-AMER INS CO1995

32859 PENN-AMER INS CO1990

32859 PENN-AMER INS CO1985

32859 PENN-AMER INS CO1221 Group Name:Group Code: PATRONS INS GRP

200614923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO 43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

200514923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO 43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

200014923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI32085 LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO 43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

199514923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

199014923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

198514923 PATRONS MUT INS CO OF CT 30937 PATRONS FIRE INS CO OF RI43532 PROVISION STATE INS CO

1222 Group Name:Group Code: HEALTH PROVIDERS MUT INS RRG2000

10080 HEALTH PROVIDERS MUT INS CO INC RRG 18872 PACIFIC HEALTH PROVIDERS INS CO1995

10080 HEALTH PROVIDERS MUT INS CO INC RRG 18872 ACHD INSURANCE COMPANY1990

18872 ACHD INSURANCE COMPANY1223 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED SECURITY ASSUR GRP

200042129 UNITED SECURITY ASSUR CO OF PA

1226 Group Name:Group Code: GEORGE A PARMER GRP2009

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2008

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2007

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2006

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2005

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO2000

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO1995

28649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 40940 WESTERN PACIFIC MUT INS CO RRG43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO

199028649 EASTERN ATLANTIC INS CO 40940 WESTERN PACIFIC MUT INS CO RRG43486 WARRANTY UNDERWRITERS INS CO

1227 Group Name:Group Code: PALISADES GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners425

Page 434: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1227 Group Name:Group Code: PALISADES GRP2009

10100 PALISADES PROP & CAS INS CO 10791 PALISADES INS CO10930 HIGH POINT PROP & CAS INS CO 10931 HIGH POINT SAFETY & INS CO12212 TEACHERS AUTO INS CO 12357 TWIN LIGHTS INS CO22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC 28959 HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO

200810100 PALISADES PROP & CAS INS CO 10791 PALISADES INS CO10930 HIGH POINT PROP & CAS INS CO 10931 HIGH POINT SAFETY & INS CO12212 TEACHERS AUTO INS CO 12357 TWIN LIGHTS INS CO22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC 28959 HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO

200710791 PALISADES INS CO 10930 HIGH POINT PROP & CAS INS CO10931 HIGH POINT SAFETY & INS CO 12212 TEACHERS AUTO INS CO12357 TWIN LIGHTS INS CO 22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC28959 HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO

200610791 PALISADES INS CO 10930 HIGH POINT PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO10931 HIGH POINT SAFETY AND INS CO 12357 TWIN LIGHTS INS CO22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC 28959 HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO

200510791 PALISADES INS CO 10930 HIGH POINT PROPERTY AND CAS INS CO10931 HIGH POINT SAFETY AND INS CO 12357 TWIN LIGHTS INS CO22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC 28959 HIGH POINT PREFERRED INS CO

200010791 PALISADES INS CO 22050 PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC

1228 Group Name:Group Code: BAR PLAN GRP2009

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY & FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO2008

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY & FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO2007

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY & FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO2006

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY AND FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO2005

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY AND FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO2000

10966 BAR PLAN SURETY AND FIDELITY CO 29513 THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO1229 Group Name:Group Code: HINGHAM MUT GRP

200914192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

200714192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

200614192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

200514192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

200014192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

199514192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

199014192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

198514192 HINGHAM MUT FIRE INS CO 37346 DANBURY INS CO

1230 Group Name:Group Code: CAPITAL BLUE CROSS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners426

Page 435: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1230 Group Name:Group Code: CAPITAL BLUE CROSS GRP2000

41203 CAPITAL ADVANTAGE INS CO1995

41203 CAPITAL ADVANTAGE INS CO1990

41203 CAPITAL ADVANTAGE INS CO1985

41203 CAPITAL ADVANTAGE INS CO1231 Group Name:Group Code: DELTA INS SERVICES INC

200014028 GEORGIA MUT INS CO 36374 COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO OF NC

1234 Group Name:Group Code: RESPONSE INS GRP2008

10811 RESPONSE IND CO 10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA20133 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INS C 26050 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE INS CO26085 WARNER INS CO 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO43044 RESPONSE INS CO

200710811 RESPONSE IND CO 10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA20133 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INS C 26050 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE INS CO26085 WARNER INS CO 36609 CONNECTICUT LIFE & CAS INS CO39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO 43044 RESPONSE INS CO

200610811 RESPONSE IND CO 10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA20133 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INS C 26050 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE INS CO26085 WARNER INS CO 36609 CONNECTICUT LIFE & CAS INS CO39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO 43044 RESPONSE INS CO

200510290 RESPONSE IND CO OF DE 10811 RESPONSE IND CO10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA 20133 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE DIRECT AUTO INSCO26050 RESPONSE WORLDWIDE INS CO 26085 WARNER INS CO36609 CONNECTICUT LIFE & CAS INS CO 39004 NATIONAL MERIT INS CO43044 RESPONSE INS CO

200010290 RESPONSE IND CO OF DE 10727 RESPONSE INS CO OF AMER10811 RESPONSE INDEMNITY CO 10970 RESPONSE IND CO OF CA43044 RESPONSE INSURANCE COMPANY

1235 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS GRP2009

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CAS INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO2008

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CAS INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO2007

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CAS INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO2006

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CAS INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO2005

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CAS INS CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO2000

10203 ARGUS FIRE & CASUALTY INSURANCE CO 35319 UNITED AUTOMOBILE INS CO1237 Group Name:Group Code: AMCOMP GRP

200710346 AMCOMP PREFERRED INS CO 25402 AMCOMP ASSUR CORP

200610346 AMCOMP PREFERRED INS CO 25402 AMCOMP ASSUR CORP

200510346 AMCOMP PREFERRED INS CO 25402 AMCOMP ASSUR CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners427

Page 436: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1237 Group Name:Group Code: AMCOMP GRP2000

10346 AMCOMP PREFERRED INS CO 25402 AMCOMP ASSURANCE CORPORATION1241 Group Name:Group Code: ALBRIGHT TITLE & TRUST GRP

199517647 UNITED HOME INS CO

199017647 UNITED HOME INS CO

198517647 UNITED HOME INS CO

1243 Group Name:Group Code: WEST BEND MUT GRP2009

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO2008

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO2007

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO2006

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO2005

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO2000

10857 MICHIGAN INS CO 15350 WEST BEND MUT INS CO1244 Group Name:Group Code: EML INS GRP

200010724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO

1245 Group Name:Group Code: MLMIC GRP2000

12513 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO OF AMERICA 32247 MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO33456 HEALTH CARE INS CO 42226 PRINCETON INS CO

1248 Group Name:Group Code: AMBAC ASSUR CORP GRP2009

18708 AMBAC ASSUR CORP 24961 EVERSPAN FIN GUAR CORP2008

18708 AMBAC ASSUR CORP 24961 EVERSPAN FIN GUAR CORP2007

18708 AMBAC ASSUR CORP 24961 CONNIE LEE INS CO2006

18708 AMBAC ASSUR CORP 24961 CONNIE LEE INS CO2005

18708 AMBAC ASSUR CORP 24961 CONNIE LEE INS CO2000

18708 AMBAC ASSURANCE CORP 24961 CONNIE LEE INS CO1258 Group Name:Group Code: HEALTHPARTNERS GRP

200044547 MIDWEST ASSUR CO

1260 Group Name:Group Code: MAGELLAN HLTH SERV INC GRP2000

18750 MERIT HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANY1261 Group Name:Group Code: THE SALEM GRP

200013854 FARMERS MUT FIC OF SALEM CTY 14800 SALEM INS CO

1264 Group Name:Group Code: HIH AMER GRP2000

10321 HIH AMERICA INS CO OF HI INC 10919 HIH AMERICAN COMP & LIAB20656 HIH AMERICA COMP & LIAB INS CO 33529 GREAT STATES INS CO

1269 Group Name:Group Code: ALS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners428

Page 437: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1269 Group Name:Group Code: ALS GRP2000

10200 AMERICAN LIVE STOCK INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO1272 Group Name:Group Code: FPIC INS GRP

200910037 INTERLEX INS CO 11989 ADVOCATE MD INS OF THE SW INC33367 INTERMED INS CO 33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO37656 ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PRO ASSUR CO

200810037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS CO33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO 37656 ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PRO ASSUR CO

200710037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS CO33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO 37656 ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PRO ASSUR CO

200610037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS CO33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO 37656 ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PRO ASSUR CO

200510037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS CO33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO 37656 ANESTHESIOLOGISTS PRO ASSUR CO

200010037 INTERLEX INS CO 33367 INTERMED INS COMPANY33383 FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO 37656 ANESTHESIOLOGIST PRO ASR CO A RRG

1275 Group Name:Group Code: QUINCY MUT GRP2009

12725 NEW ENGLAND MUT INS CO 15067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

200812725 NEW ENGLAND MUT INS CO 15067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

200712725 NEW ENGLAND MUT INS CO 15067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

200612725 NEW ENGLAND MUT INS CO 15067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

200515067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO 28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

200015067 QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO 28290 PATRONS OXFORD INS CO

1276 Group Name:Group Code: ACMAT GRP2000

22950 ACSTAR INS CO 28053 UNITED COASTAL INS CO1278 Group Name:Group Code: CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP

200910921 ACA INS CO 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASSN INTER INS37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO

200810921 ACA INS CO 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASSN INTER INS37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO

200710921 ACA INS CO 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASSN INTER INS37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO

200610921 ACA INS CO 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO

200510921 ACA INS CO 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners429

Page 438: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1278 Group Name:Group Code: CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO GRP2005

37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO2000

10921 AAA MOUNTAIN WEST INS 15539 CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS37770 WESTERN UNITED INS CO

1279 Group Name:Group Code: ARCH INS GRP2009

10348 ARCH REINS CO 10946 ARCH EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO11150 ARCH INS CO 21199 ARCH SPECIAITY INS CO30830 ARCH IND INS CO

200810348 ARCH REINS CO 10946 ARCH EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO11150 ARCH INS CO 21199 ARCH SPECIAITY INS CO30830 ARCH IND INS CO

200710348 ARCH REINS CO 10946 ARCH EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO11150 ARCH INS CO 21199 ARCH SPECIAITY INS CO30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CAS INS CO

200610348 ARCH REINS CO 10946 ARCH EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO11150 ARCH INS CO 21199 ARCH SPECIAITY INS CO30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CAS INS CO

200510348 ARCH REINS CO 10946 ARCH EXCESS & SURPLUS INS CO11150 ARCH INS CO 21199 ARCH SPECIALITY INS CO30830 WESTERN DIVERSIFIED CAS INS CO

1281 Group Name:Group Code: BANKAMERICA CORP GRP2009

24813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO 30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

200810735 FLEET INS CO 11191 NEWPORT E&S INS CO24813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO 30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

200710735 FLEET INS CO 30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

200610735 FLEET INS CO 30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

200510735 FLEET INS CO 30007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

200030007 GENERAL FIDELITY INS CO

1282 Group Name:Group Code: NORCAL GRP2009

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PMSLIC INS CO2008

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PMSLIC INS CO2007

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PMSLIC INS CO2006

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PMSLIC INS CO2005

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PMSLIC INS CO2000

33200 NORCAL MUT INS CO 35114 PENNSYLVANIA MED SOC LIAB INS CO1285 Group Name:Group Code: XL AMER GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners430

Page 439: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1285 Group Name:Group Code: XL AMER GRP2009

19607 XL SELECT 20583 XL REINS AMER INC22322 GREENWICH INS CO 24554 XL INS AMER INC36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO 37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO40193 X L INS CO OF NY

200811938 XL LLOYDS INS CO 19607 XL SELECT20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC 22322 GREENWICH INS CO24554 XL INS AMER INC 36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO 40193 X L INS CO OF NY

200711938 XL LLOYDS INS CO 19607 XL SELECT20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC 20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC22322 GREENWICH INS CO 24554 XL INS AMER INC36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO 37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO40193 X L INS CO OF NY

200611938 XL LLOYDS INS CO 19607 XL SELECT20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC 20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC22322 GREENWICH INS CO 24554 XL INS AMER INC36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO 37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO40193 X L INS CO OF NY

200511938 XL LLOYDS INS CO 19607 XL SELECT20311 XL CAPITAL ASSURANCE INC 20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC22322 GREENWICH INS CO 24554 XL INS AMER INC36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO 37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO40193 X L INS CO OF NY

200010963 XL CAPITAL ASSUR INC 11007 XL CAPITAL ASSUR INC20583 XL REINS AMERICA INC 22322 GREENWICH INS CO36940 INDIAN HARBOR INS CO 37885 XL SPECIALTY INS CO40193 X L INS CO OF AMERICA

1289 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FIDELITY & LIBERTY INC GRP2009

35963 AF&L INS CO2000

35963 AF&L INS CO1292 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN HORIZON GRP

200010870 AMERICAN HORIZON P&C INS CO 28100 AMERICAN HORIZON INS CO

1293 Group Name:Group Code: HOMESITE INS GRP2007

10745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL11156 HOMESITE INS CO OF FL 11237 HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 17221 HOMESITE INS CO20419 HOMESITE IND CO

200610745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL11156 HOMESITE INS CO OF FL 11237 HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 17221 HOMESITE INS CO20419 HOMESITE IND CO

200510745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL11156 HOMESITE INS CO OF FL 11237 HOMESITE LLOYDS OF TX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners431

Page 440: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1293 Group Name:Group Code: HOMESITE INS GRP2005

13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 17221 HOMESITE INS CO20419 HOMESITE IND CO

200010745 HOMESITE INS CO OF PA 10986 HOMESITE INS CO OF NY11005 HOMESITE INS CO OF CA 11016 HOMESITE INS CO OF IL13927 HOMESITE INS CO OF THE MIDWEST 17221 HOMESITE INS CO20419 HOMESITE INDEMNITY CO

1298 Group Name:Group Code: HYNEMAN GRP2005

16047 SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO2000

16047 SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO1299 Group Name:Group Code: HUG SERV GRP

200933359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 37788 HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC

200733359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 37788 HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC

200633359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 37788 HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC

200533359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 37788 HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC

200033359 PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO 37788 HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC

1302 Group Name:Group Code: BUILDERS INS GRP2009

10704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO16632 VININGS INS CO

200810704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO16632 VININGS INS CO

200710704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO16632 VININGS INS CO

200610704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO16632 VININGS INS CO

200510704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO16632 VININGS INS CO

200010704 BUILDERS INS 11240 ASSOCIATION INS CO

1303 Group Name:Group Code: THOMSON INS GRP2000

10980 RISK MGMT IND INC 11398 GUARANTEE INS CO1305 Group Name:Group Code: US AGENTS HOLDING CORP

200010789 AMERICAN AGENTS INS CO 10982 LONG ISLAND INS CO

1306 Group Name:Group Code: AAA MINNESOTA GRP2000

11983 MOTOR CLUB OF IA INS CO 12351 VOYAGEURS INS CO1309 Group Name:Group Code: FRANKENMUTH GRP

200910984 ANSUR AMER INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO11511 ASURE WORLDWIDE INS CO 13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO32069 PATRIOT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners432

Page 441: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1309 Group Name:Group Code: FRANKENMUTH GRP2008

10984 ANSUR AMER INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO11511 ASURE WORLDWIDE INS CO 13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO32069 PATRIOT INS CO

200710984 ANSUR AMER INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO11511 ASURE WORLDWIDE INS CO 13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO32069 PATRIOT INS CO

200610984 ANSUR AMERICA INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO11511 ASURE WORLDWIDE INS CO 13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO

200510984 ANSUR AMERICA INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO11511 ASURE WORLDWIDE INS CO 13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO

200010984 ANSUR AMERICA INS 10985 FORTUITY INS CO13986 FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO

1312 Group Name:Group Code: COMMUNITY RESEARCH BUREAU GRP2000

27324 HANOVER FIRA AND CASUALTY INS CO1313 Group Name:Group Code: OREGON DENTAL GRP

200918813 DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO 32417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO

200718813 DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO 32417 NORTHWEST DENTISTS INS CO

200618813 DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO

200518813 DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO

200018813 DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO

1314 Group Name:Group Code: TRENWICK AMER REINS CORP GRP2005

18341 INSURANCE CORP OF NY 34894 TRENWICK AMER REINS CORP2000

10717 DAKOTA SPECIALTY INS CO 18341 INSURANCE CORP OF NEW YORK (THE)34894 TRENWICK AMER REINS CORP 34908 RECOR INS CO INC36870 CHARTWELL INS CO

1316 Group Name:Group Code: EXCESS REINS GRP2009

13722 KNIGHTBROOK INS CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REINS CO2008

13722 KNIGHTBROOK INS CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REINS CO2005

13722 EXCESS REIN CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REIN CO2000

13722 EXCESS REIN CO 28630 GUILDERLAND REIN CO1318 Group Name:Group Code: AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP

200911008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO12813 AUTO CLUB INS CO OF FL 15512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO29327 AAA TX CNTY MUT INS CO

200811008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO12813 AUTO CLUB INS CO OF FL 15512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners433

Page 442: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1318 Group Name:Group Code: AUTO CLUB ENTERPRISES INS GRP2008

29327 AAA TX CNTY MUT INS CO2007

11008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO12813 AUTO CLUB INS CO OF FL 15512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO29327 AAA TX CNTY MUT INS CO

200611008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO12813 AUTO CLUB INS CO OF FL 15512 AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB 27235 AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO29327 AAA TX COUNTY MUT INS CO

200511008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB 29327 AAA TX COUNTY MUT INS CO

200011008 AUTO CLUB IND CO 11009 AUTO CLUB CAS CO15598 INTERINS EXCH OF THE AUTOMOBILE CLUB

1319 Group Name:Group Code: LITITZ MUT GRP2009

10748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

200810748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

200710748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

200610748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

200510748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

200010748 LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO 14400 LITITZ MUT INS CO17086 FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO 17620 PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO

1321 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS GRP2009

37931 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS INS CO 41475 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS MUT INS2008

37931 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS INS CO 41475 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS MUT INS2007

12960 AMERICAN RANCH AUTO & HOME INC 37931 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS INS CO41475 AMERICAN FARMERS & RANCHERS MUT INS

200641475 OKLAHOMA FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO

200541475 OKLAHOMA FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO

200041475 OKLAHOMA FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO

1324 Group Name:Group Code: UPMC HLTH SYSTEM GRP2009

10599 FREEDOM INS CO 17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO2008

10599 FREEDOM INS CO 17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners434

Page 443: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1324 Group Name:Group Code: UPMC HLTH SYSTEM GRP2007

10599 FREEDOM INS CO 17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO2006

10599 FREEDOM INS CO 17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO2005

10599 FREEDOM INS CO 17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO2000

17990 TRI CENTURY INS CO1325 Group Name:Group Code: RHINE RE GRP

200524899 ALEA NORTH AMERICA INS CO 44776 ALEA NORTH AMER SPECIALTY INS CO

1326 Group Name:Group Code: KINGSWAY GRP2009

12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO 21300 US SECURITY INS CO22454 MENDAKOTA INS CO 33650 MENDOTA INS CO33855 LINCOLN GEN INS CO 38237 AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO 42897 AMERICAN SERV INS CO INC

200811026 ZEPHYR INS CO INC 12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO21300 US SECURITY INS CO 22454 MENDAKOTA INS CO33650 MENDOTA INS CO 33855 LINCOLN GEN INS CO38237 AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO 42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO42897 AMERICAN SERV INS CO INC

200711026 ZEPHYR INS CO INC 12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO21300 US SECURITY INS CO 22454 MENDAKOTA INS CO33650 MENDOTA INS CO 33855 LINCOLN GEN INS CO38237 AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO 42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO42897 AMERICAN SERV INS CO INC

200611026 ZEPHYR INS CO INC 12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO21300 US SECURITY INS CO 33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO38237 AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO 42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO42897 AMERICAN SERVICE INS CO INC

200511026 ZEPHYR INS CO INC 12629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO21300 US SECURITY INS CO 33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO38237 AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO 42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO42897 AMERICAN SERVICE INS CO INC

200012629 SOUTHERN UNITED FIRE INS CO 21300 US SECURITY INS CO33855 LINCOLN GENERAL INS CO 42862 UNIVERSAL CAS CO42897 AMERICAN SERVICE INS CO INC

1328 Group Name:Group Code: NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS GRP2009

11020 NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS CO INC 11025 BUILDERS INS CO INC2007

11020 NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS CO INC 11025 BUILDERS INS CO INC2006

11020 NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS CO INC 11025 BUILDERS INS CO INC2005

11020 NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS CO INC 11025 BUILDERS INS CO INC2000

11020 NEVADA CONTRACTORS INS CO INC 11025 BUILDERS INS CO INC1330 Group Name:Group Code: BALBOA INS GRP

200711191 NEWPORT E&S INS CO 24813 BALBOA INS CO24821 MERITPLAN INS CO 24848 NEWPORT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners435

Page 444: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1330 Group Name:Group Code: BALBOA INS GRP2006

11191 NEWPORT E&S INS CO 24813 BALBOA INS CO24821 MERITPLAN INS CO 24848 NEWPORT INS CO

200511191 NEWPORT E&S INS CO 24813 BALBOA INS CO24821 MERITPLAN INS CO 24848 NEWPORT INS CO

200024813 BALBOA INS CO 24821 MERITPLAN INS CO24848 NEWPORT INS CO

1331 Group Name:Group Code: GLENCOE US HOLDINGS GRP2009

10044 NEWSTEAD INS CO 10340 STONINGTON INS CO11497 STONINGTON LLOYDS INS CO 12176 INVERNESS INS CO

200810044 NEWSTEAD INS CO 10340 STONINGTON INS CO11497 STONINGTON LLOYDS INS CO 12176 INVERNESS INS CO

200710044 NEWSTEAD INS CO 10340 STONINGTON INS CO11497 STONINGTON LLOYDS INS CO 12176 INVERNESS INS CO

200610044 NEWSTEAD INS CO 10340 STONINGTON INS CO11497 STONINGTON LLOYDS INS CO 12176 INVERNESS INS CO

200510044 NEWSTEAD INS CO 10340 STONINGTON INS CO11497 STONINGTON LLOYDS INS CO 12176 INVERNESS INS CO

200010340 STONINGTON INS CO 11027 DESOTO PRIME INS CO

1332 Group Name:Group Code: MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS GRP2009

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2008

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2007

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2006

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2005

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2000

11030 MEMIC IND CO 11149 MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO1333 Group Name:Group Code: GRANGE MUT GRP

200011031 TIMBERLAND STATES INS CO 44890 GRANGE MUT INS CO

1335 Group Name:Group Code: PENN GRP2000

10250 GREEN TREE PERPETUAL ASSUR CO 14966 PENN MUT INS CO1336 Group Name:Group Code: PATRIOT GRP

200632069 PATRIOT MUT INS CO

200532069 PATRIOT MUT INS CO

200032069 PATRIOT MUT INS CO

1338 Group Name:Group Code: TRIUMPHE HOLDING GRP2000

41106 TRIUMPHE CAS CO1341 Group Name:Group Code: FLORIDA SELECT HOLDINGS GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners436

Page 445: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1341 Group Name:Group Code: FLORIDA SELECT HOLDINGS GRP2000

10663 FLORIDA SELECT INS CO 11035 TEXAS SELECT LLOYDS INS CO1342 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS MUT PROTECTION ASSN GRP

200911047 NEW CENTURY INS CO 21733 RVOS FARM MUT INS CO36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

200811047 NEW CENTURY LLOYDS 21733 RVOS FARM MUT INS CO36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

200711047 NEW CENTURY LLOYDS 21733 RVOS FARM MUT INS CO36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

200611047 NEW CENTURY LLOYDS 21733 FARMERS MUT PROTECTIVE ASN OF TX36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

200511047 NEW CENTURY LLOYDS 21733 FARMERS MUT PROTECTIVE ASN OF TX36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

200011047 NEW CENTURY LLOYDS 21733 FARMERS MUT PROTECTIVE ASN OF TX36943 PRIORITY ONE INS CO

1343 Group Name:Group Code: DUKES PLACE HOLDINGS GRP2000

22276 STONEWALL INS CO 25763 SEATON INS CO1344 Group Name:Group Code: ARX HOLDING CORP GRP

200910872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS12196 ASI ASSUR CORP 13142 ASI PREFERRED INS CORP

200810872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS12196 ASI ASSUR CORP 13142 ASI PREFERRED INS CORP

200710872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS12196 ASI ASSUR CORP

200610872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS12196 ASI ASSUR CORP 12601 AMERICAN CAPITAL ASSUR CORP

200510872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS12196 ASI ASSUR CORP

200010872 AMERICAN STRATEGIC INS CORP 11059 ASI LLOYDS

1345 Group Name:Group Code: USAGENCIES GRP2006

10295 USAGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO2005

10295 USAGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO2000

10295 US AGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO1346 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN SAFETY HOLDING GRP

200925433 AMERICAN SAFETY IND CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

200825433 AMERICAN SAFETY IND CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners437

Page 446: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

1346 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN SAFETY HOLDING GRP2007

25433 AMERICAN SAFETY IND CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

200625433 AMERICAN SAFETY IND CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

200525433 AMERICAN SAFETY IND CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

200025433 AMERICAN SAFETY INDEM CO 25448 AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC39969 AMERICAN SAFETY CAS INS CO

1552 Group Name:Group Code: MEDICA GRP2000

12459 MEDICA INSURANCE COMPANY1591 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH AMER ENTERPRISE GRP

200010041 EASTERN CAS IND CO 39659 EASTERN CAS INS CO

1631 Group Name:Group Code: DALLAS GEN GRP2009

32271 DALLAS NATL INS CO2008

32271 DALLAS NATL INS CO2007

32271 DALLAS NATL INS CO2006

32271 DALLAS NATIONAL INS CO2005

32271 DALLAS NATIONAL INS CO2358 Group Name:Group Code: ISMIE GRP

200911084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ISMIE MUT INS CO

200811084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ISMIE MUT INS CO

200711084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ISMIE MUT INS CO

200611084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ISMIE MUT INS CO

200511084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ISMIE MUT INS CO

200011084 ISMIE IND CO 32921 ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH

2378 Group Name:Group Code: BRERA CAPITAL PARTNERS LTD GRP2009

10691 RESIDENTIAL INS CO INC A RRG 12876 RESIDENTIAL REINS CO INC44016 NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG

200710691 RESIDENTIAL INS CO INC A RRG 12876 RESIDENTIAL REINS CO INC44016 NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG

200610691 RESIDENTIAL INS CO INC A RRG 44016 NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG

200510691 RESIDENTIAL INS CO INC A RRG 35700 2 10 HOME BUYERS WARRANTY OF VA44016 NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG

200010691 RESIDENTIAL INS CO INC RRG 11187 2-10 HBW OF NV INC44016 NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners438

Page 447: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

2398 Group Name:Group Code: RBC HOLDINGS (USA) GRP2000

43664 STATE NATL FIRE INS CO2438 Group Name:Group Code: AG WORKERS INS GRP

200911090 WORTH CAS CO 18430 AGRICULTURAL WORKERS MUT AUTO INS

200711090 WORTH CAS CO 18430 AGRICULTURAL WORKERS MUT AUTO INS

200611090 WORTH CAS CO 18430 AGRICULTURAL WORKERS MUT AUTO INS

200511090 WORTH CAS CO 18430 AGRICULTURAL WORKERS MUT AUTO INS

2479 Group Name:Group Code: DENTEGRA GRP2007

12210 DENTEGRA INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND2006

12210 DENTEGRA INS CO OF NEW ENGLAND2498 Group Name:Group Code: AIM MUT GRP

200911104 ASSOCIATED EMPLOYERS INS CO 12886 MASSACHUSETTS EMPLOYERS INS CO13083 EMPLOYERS SECURITY ASSUR CO 33758 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF MA MUT INS

200811104 ASSOCIATED EMPLOYERS INS CO 12886 MASSACHUSETTS EMPLOYERS INS CO13083 EMPLOYERS SECURITY ASSUR CO 33758 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF MA MUT INS

200711104 ASSOCIATED EMPLOYERS INS CO 12886 MASSACHUSETTS EMPLOYERS INS CO33758 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF MA MUT INS

200611104 ASSOCIATED EMPLOYERS INS CO 33758 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF MA MUT INS

200511104 ASSOCIATED EMPLOYERS INS CO 33758 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES OF MA MUT INS

2518 Group Name:Group Code: CENTRAL SERV GRP2009

11105 A CENTRAL INS CO 14834 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO2008

11105 A CENTRAL INS CO 14834 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO2007

11105 A CENTRAL INS CO 14834 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO2006

11105 A CENTRAL INS CO 14834 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO2005

11105 A CENTRAL INS CO 14834 NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO2538 Group Name:Group Code: AMTRUST FINANCIAL SERV GRP

200912491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 15954 AMTRUST INS CO OF KS INC19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 23140 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES INS CO INC25011 WESCO INS CO 26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO 42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC

200812491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 15954 TRINITY UNIVERSAL INS CO OF KS19879 SECURITY NATL INS CO 23140 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES INS CO INC25011 WESCO INS CO 26662 MILWAUKEE CAS INS CO26689 TRINITY LLOYDS INS CO 42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC

200712491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 23140 ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES INS CO INC25011 WESCO INS CO 42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC

200612491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 25011 WESCO INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners439

Page 448: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

2538 Group Name:Group Code: AMTRUST GRP2006

42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC2005

12491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC2000

12491 ROCHDALE INS CO OF NY 42376 TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC2558 Group Name:Group Code: NIPPONKOA GRP

200612190 NIPPONKOA INS CO OF AMERICA 27073 NIPPONKOA INS CO LTD U.S. BRANCH

200512190 NIPPONKOA INS CO OF AMERICA 27073 NIPPONKOA INS CO LTD U.S. BRANCH

2578 Group Name:Group Code: POE FINANCIAL GRP2005

10661 SOUTHERN FAMILY INS CO 10902 ATLANTIC PREFERRED INS CO11577 FLORIDA PREFERRED PROP INS CO

2638 Group Name:Group Code: NCMIC GRP2009

11127 PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS INS CO 15865 NCMIC INS CO2008

11127 PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS INS CO 15865 NCMIC INS CO2007

11127 PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS INS CO 15865 NCMIC INS CO2006

11127 PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS INS CO 15865 NCMIC INS CO2005

11127 PROFESSIONAL SOLUTIONS INS CO 15865 NCMIC INS CO2698 Group Name:Group Code: PROASSURANCE CORP GRP

200910179 PROASSURANCE SPECIALTY INS CO 10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER 23400 PROASSURANCE WI INS CO31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH 33391 PROASSURANCE IND CO INC38954 PROASSURANCE CAS CO 41149 PROASSURANCE NATL CAPITAL INS CO

200810179 PROASSURANCE SPECIALTY INS CO 11131 AMERICAN CAPTIVE CORP23400 PROASSURANCE WI INS CO 31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH33391 MEDICAL ASSUR CO INC 38954 PRONATIONAL INS CO41149 PROASSURANCE NATL CAPITAL INS CO

200710179 RED MOUNTAIN CAS INS CO INC 11131 AMERICAN CAPTIVE CORP23272 WOODBROOK CAS INS INC 23400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH 33391 MEDICAL ASSUR CO INC38954 PRONATIONAL INS CO 41149 NCRIC INC

200610179 RED MOUNTAIN CAS INS CO INC 11131 AMERICAN CAPTIVE CORP23272 WOODBROOK CAS INS INC 23400 PHYSICIANS INS CO OF WI31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH 33391 MEDICAL ASSUR CO INC38954 PRONATIONAL INS CO 41149 NCRIC INC

200510179 RED MOUNTAIN CAS INS CO INC 11131 AMERICAN CAPTIVE CORP16101 MEEMIC INS CO 23272 WOODBROOK CAS INS INC31402 AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH 33391 MEDICAL ASSUR CO INC38954 PRONATIONAL INS CO 41149 NCRIC INC

2758 Group Name:Group Code: WEA INC GRP2009

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO2007

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners440

Page 449: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

2758 Group Name:Group Code: WEA INC GRP2006

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO2005

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO2000

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO1995

14550 WEA PROP & CAS INS CO2778 Group Name:Group Code: VFH CAPTIVE GRP

200910798 VFH CAPTIVE INS CO 12156 CROWN CAPTIVE INS CO INC

200710798 VFH CAPTIVE INS CO 12156 CROWN CAPTIVE INS CO INC

200610798 VFH CAPTIVE INS CO 12156 CROWN CAPTIVE INS CO INC

200510798 VFH CAPTIVE INS CO 12156 CROWN CAPTIVE INS CO INC

2878 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED HERITAGE MUT GRP2009

18939 UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO 26824 SUBLIMITY INS CO2008

18939 UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO 26824 SUBLIMITY INS CO2007

18939 UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO 26824 SUBLIMITY INS CO2006

18939 UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO 26824 SUBLIMITY INS CO2005

18939 UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO 26824 SUBLIMITY INS CO2879 Group Name:Group Code: 21ST CENTURY HOLDING GRP

200910790 AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO 27980 FEDERATED NATL INS CO

200810790 AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO 27980 FEDERATED NATL INS CO

200710790 AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO 27980 FEDERATED NATL INS CO

200610790 AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO 27980 FEDERATED NATL INS CO

200510790 AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO 27980 FEDERATED NATL INS CO

2898 Group Name:Group Code: WESTERN SERV CONTRACT GRP2009

11168 PACIFIC SPECIALTY PROP & CAS CO 37850 PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO2008

11168 PACIFIC SPECIALTY PROP & CAS CO 37850 PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO2007

11168 PACIFIC PROP & CAS INS CO 37850 PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO2006

11168 PACIFIC SPECIALTY LLOYDS 37850 PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO2005

11168 PACIFIC SPECIALTY LLOYDS 37850 PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO2978 Group Name:Group Code: MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP

200913697 MSIG INS (SINGAPORE) PTE LTD 20362 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER22551 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC

200813697 MSIG INS (SINGAPORE) PTE LTD 20362 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER22551 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners441

Page 450: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

2978 Group Name:Group Code: MITSUI SUMITOMO INS GRP2007

20362 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER 22551 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC2006

20362 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER 22551 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC2005

20362 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS CO OF AMER 22551 MITSUI SUMITOMO INS USA INC3018 Group Name:Group Code: CONVERIUM HOLDING GRP

200522730 CONVERIUM INS NORTH AMER INC 39136 CONVERIUM REINS NORTH AMER INC

3098 Group Name:Group Code: TOKIO MARINE HOLDINGS INC GRP2009

10738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO11216 TOKIO MARINE PACIFIC INS LTD 12904 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO13206 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO L 32301 TNUS INS CO41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

200810738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO11216 TOKIO MARINE PACIFIC INS LTD 12904 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO13206 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO L 32301 TNUS INS CO41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

200710738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO11216 TOKIO MARINE PACIFIC INS LTD 12904 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO32301 TNUS INS CO 41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

200610738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO11216 TOKIO MARINE PACIFIC INS LTD 12904 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO32301 TNUS INS CO 41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

200510738 TM SPECIALTY INS CO 10945 TM CAS INS CO11216 NICHIDO INS CO PACIFIC LTD 12904 TOKIO MARINE & NICHIDO FIRE INS CO32301 TNUS INS CO 41238 TRANS PACIFIC INS CO

3118 Group Name:Group Code: LACKAWANNA INS GRP2009

11219 LACKAWANNA AMER INS CO 11703 LACKAWANNA CAS CO12274 LACKAWANNA NATL INS CO

200811219 LACKAWANNA AMER INS CO 11703 LACKAWANNA CAS CO12274 LACKAWANNA NATL INS CO

200711219 LACKAWANNA AMER INS CO 11703 LACKAWANNA CAS CO12274 LACKAWANNA NATL INS CO

200611219 LACKAWANNA AMERICAN INS CO 11703 LACKAWANNA CAS CO12274 LACKAWANNA NATL INS CO

200511219 LACKAWANNA AMERICAN INS CO 11703 LACKAWANNA CAS CO12274 LACKAWANNA NATL INS CO

3138 Group Name:Group Code: WISCONSIN CNTY MUT GRP2009

11250 COMMUNITY INS CORP 26956 WISCONSIN CNTY MUT INS CORP2008

11250 COMMUNITY INS CORP 26956 WISCONSIN COUNTY MUT INS CORP2007

11250 COMMUNITY INS CORP 26956 WISCONSIN COUNTY MUT INS CORP2006

11250 COMMUNITY INS CORP 26956 WISCONSIN COUNTY MUT INS CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners442

Page 451: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3138 Group Name:Group Code: WISCONSIN CNTY MUT GRP2005

11250 COMMUNITY INS CORP 26956 WISCONSIN COUNTY MUT INS CORP3158 Group Name:Group Code: EASTERN HOLDING CO GRP

200910724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO 11242 ALLIED EASTERN IND CO13019 EASTERN ADVANTAGE ASSUR CO 32005 EMPLOYERS SECURITY INS CO

200810724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO 11242 ALLIED EASTERN IND CO13019 EASTERN ADVANTAGE ASSUR CO 32005 EMPLOYERS SECURITY INS CO

200710724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO 11242 ALLIED EASTERN IND CO13019 EASTERN ADVANTAGE ASSUR CO

200610724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO 11242 ALLIED EASTERN IND CO

200510724 EASTERN ALLIANCE INS CO 11242 ALLIED EASTERN IND CO

3179 Group Name:Group Code: HOME STATE INS GRP2009

28746 EQUITY INS CO 29297 HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO2008

28746 EQUITY INS CO 29297 HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO2007

28746 EQUITY INS CO 29297 HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO2006

28746 EQUITY INSURANCE CO 29297 HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO2005

28746 EQUITY INSURANCE CO 29297 HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO3219 Group Name:Group Code: SOMPO JAPAN INS GRP

200911126 SOMPO JAPAN INS CO OF AMER 38997 SOMPO JAPAN FIRE & MAR INS CO AMER

200811126 SOMPO JAPAN INS CO OF AMER 38997 SOMPO JAPAN FIRE & MAR INS CO AMER

200711126 SOMPO JAPAN INS CO OF AMER 38997 SOMPO JAPAN FIRE & MAR INS CO AMER

200611126 SOMPO JAPAN INS CO OF AMER 38997 SOMPO JAPAN FIRE & MAR INS CO AMER

200511126 SOMPO JAPAN INS CO OF AMER 38997 SOMPO JAPAN FIRE & MAR INS CO AMER

3239 Group Name:Group Code: ALLIED WORLD ASSUR HOLDING GRP2009

10690 ALLIED WORLD NATL ASSUR CO 16624 DARWIN NATL ASSUR CO19489 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR CO US INC 22730 ALLIED WORLD REINS CO24319 DARWIN SELECT INS CO 44768 VANTAPRO SPECIALTY INS CO

200810690 ALLIED WORLD NATL ASSUR CO 16624 DARWIN NATL ASSUR CO19489 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR CO US INC 22730 ALLIED WORLD REINS CO24319 DARWIN SELECT INS CO 44768 VANTAPRO SPECIALTY INS CO

200710690 ALLIED WORLD NATL ASSUR CO 19489 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR CO US INC

200610690 NEWMARKET UNDERWRITERS INS CO 19489 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR CO US INC

200510690 NEWMARKET UNDERWRITERS INS CO 19489 ALLIED WORLD ASSUR CO US INC

3259 Group Name:Group Code: SUMMA HLTH GRP2000

10649 SUMMA INS CO INC3279 Group Name:Group Code: INSURORS IND GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners443

Page 452: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3279 Group Name:Group Code: INSURORS IND GRP2009

11496 INSURORS IND LLOYDS 43273 INSURORS IND CO2008

11496 INSURORS IND LLOYDS 43273 INSURORS IND CO2007

11496 INSURORS IND LLOYDS 43273 INSURORS IND CO2006

11496 INSURORS IND LLOYDS 43273 INSURORS IND CO2005

11496 INSURORS IND LLOYDS 43273 INSURORS IND CO3299 Group Name:Group Code: AJK HOLDINGS GRP

200917159 USF INS CO 29033 CRANBROOK INS CO

200817159 USF INS CO 29033 VICTORIA INS CO

200717159 USF INS CO 29033 VICTORIA INS CO

200617159 USF INS CO 29033 VICTORIA INS CO

200517159 USF INS CO 29033 VICTORIA INS CO

3320 Group Name:Group Code: LAWYERS MUT LIAB GRP2009

11341 LAWYERS REINS CO 36013 LAWYERS MUT LIAB INS CO OF NC2007

11341 LAWYERS REINS CO 11501 GEORGIA LAWYERS INS CO36013 LAWYERS MUT LIAB INS CO OF NC

200611341 LAWYERS REINS CO 11501 GEORGIA LAWYERS INS CO36013 LAWYERS MUT LIAB INS CO OF NC

200511341 LAWYERS REINS CO 11501 GEORGIA LAWYERS INS CO36013 LAWYERS MUT LIAB INS CO OF NC

3341 Group Name:Group Code: NEW SKYLANDS GRP2009

11453 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS CO 11454 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN2008

11453 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS CO 11454 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN2007

11453 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS CO 11454 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN2006

11453 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS CO 11454 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS ASSN2005

11453 NEW JERSEY SKYLANDS INS CO 11454 NEW JERSEY SKLANDS INS ASSN3362 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS GRP

200910336 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO INC 11508 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF GA INC12825 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF TN INC

200810336 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO INC 11508 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF GA INC12825 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF TN INC

200710336 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO INC 11508 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF GA INC12825 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF TN INC

200610336 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO INC 11508 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF GA INC12825 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO OF TN INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners444

Page 453: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3362 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS GRP2005

10336 FIRST ACCEPTANCE INS CO INC 11508 VILLAGE AUTO INS CO INC3363 Group Name:Group Code: EMPLOYERS HOLDINGS GRP

200910346 EMPLOYERS PREFERRED INS CO 10640 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF NV11512 EMPLOYERS COMPENSATION INS CO 25402 EMPLOYERS ASSUR CO

200810346 EMPLOYERS PREFERRED INS CO 10640 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF NV11512 EMPLOYERS COMPENSATION INS CO 25402 EMPLOYERS ASSUR CO

200710640 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF NV 11512 EMPLOYERS COMPENSATION INS CO

200610640 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF NV 11512 EMPLOYERS COMPENSATION INS CO

200510640 EMPLOYERS INS CO OF NV 11512 EMPLOYERS COMPENSATION INS CO

3382 Group Name:Group Code: PRODUCERS LLOYDS GRP2008

33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 34312 PRODUCERS AGRICULTURE INS CO2007

33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 34312 PRODUCERS AGRICULTURE INS CO2006

33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 34312 PRODUCERS AGRICULTURE INS CO2005

33170 PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO 34312 PRODUCERS AGRICULTURE INS CO3384 Group Name:Group Code: KERNAN GRP

200915440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC30175 ORISKA INS CO

200715440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC30175 ORISKA INS CO 33030 INS CO OF THE AMERICAS

200615440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC30175 ORISKA INS CO 33030 INS CO OF THE AMERICAS

200515440 FINANCIAL BENEFITS INS CO 26549 REINSURANCE CO OF AMER INC30175 ORISKA INS CO 33030 INS CO OF THE AMERICAS

3385 Group Name:Group Code: ANACOSTIA HOLDING GRP2009

10183 EQUITABLE LIAB INS CO 14699 FIRST WA INS CO INC2007

10183 EQUITABLE LIAB INS CO 14699 FIRST WA INS CO INC2006

10183 EQUITABLE LIABILITY INS CO 14699 FIRST WASHINGTON INS CO INC2005

10183 EQUITABLE LIABILITY INS CO 14699 FIRST WASHINGTON INS CO INC3407 Group Name:Group Code: TUSCARORA GRP

200912199 KEYSTONE NATL INS CO 17825 TUSCARORA WAYNE INS CO30880 WASHINGTON FIRE & STORM INS

200811505 TUSCARORA WAYNE INS CO 12199 KEYSTONE NATL INS CO17825 TUSCARORA WAYNE MUT INS CO 30880 WASHINGTON MUT FIRE & STORM INS

200711505 TUSCARORA WAYNE INS CO 12199 KEYSTONE NATL INS CO17825 TUSCARORA WAYNE MUT INS CO 30880 WASHINGTON MUT FIRE & STORM INS

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners445

Page 454: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3407 Group Name:Group Code: TUSCARORA GRP2006

11505 TUSCARORA WAYNE INS CO 12199 KEYSTONE NATL INS CO17825 TUSCARORA WAYNE MUT INS CO 30880 WASHINGTON MUT FIRE & STORM INS

200511505 TUSCARORA WAYNE INS CO 12199 KEYSTONE NATL INS CO17825 TUSCARORA WAYNE MUT INS CO 30880 WASHINGTON MUT FIRE & STORM INS

3416 Group Name:Group Code: AXIS CAPITAL GRP2009

15610 AXIS SPECIALTY INS CO 20370 AXIS REINS CO26620 AXIS SURPLUS INS CO 37273 AXIS INS CO

200815610 AXIS SPECIALTY INS CO 20370 AXIS REINS CO26620 AXIS SURPLUS INS CO 37273 AXIS INS CO

200715610 AXIS SPECIALTY INS CO 20370 AXIS REINS CO26620 AXIS SURPLUS INS CO 37273 AXIS INS CO

200615610 AXIS SPECIALTY INS CO 20370 AXIS REINS CO26620 AXIS SURPLUS INS CO 37273 AXIS INS CO

200515610 AXIS SPECIALTY INS CO 20370 AXIS REINS CO26620 AXIS SURPLUS INS CO 37273 AXIS INS CO

3456 Group Name:Group Code: CYPRESS HOLDINGS GRP2009

10953 CYPRESS PROP & CAS INS CO 11578 CYPRESS TX LLOYDS2008

10953 CYPRESS PROP & CAS INS CO 11578 CYPRESS TX LLOYDS2007

10953 CYPRESS PROP & CAS INS CO 11578 CYPRESS TX LLOYDS2006

10953 CYPRESS PROP & CAS INS CO 11578 CYPRESS TX LLOYDS2005

10953 CYPRESS PROP & CAS INS CO 11578 CYPRESS TX LLOYDS3478 Group Name:Group Code: HALLMARK FIN SERV GRP

200926808 HALLMARK SPECIALTY INS CO 29408 HALLMARK CNTY MUT INS CO34037 HALLMARK INS CO 43494 AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX

200826808 HALLMARK SPECIALTY INS CO 34037 HALLMARK INS CO43494 AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX

200726808 HALLMARK SPECIALTY INS CO 34037 PHOENIX IND INS CO43494 AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX

200626808 GULF STATES INS CO 34037 PHOENIX IND INS CO43494 AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX

200534037 PHOENIX IND INS CO 43494 AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX

3479 Group Name:Group Code: MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP2009

11595 NATIONS BONDING CO 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO A MUT31593 NORTHERN CAS CO

200811595 NATIONS BONDING CO 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO A MUT31593 NORTHERN CAS CO

200711595 NATIONS BONDING CO 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO A MUT

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners446

Page 455: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3479 Group Name:Group Code: MERCHANTS BONDING CO GRP2007

31593 NORTHERN CAS CO2006

11595 NATIONS BONDING CO 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL)31593 NORTHERN CAS CO

200511595 NATIONS BONDING CO 14494 MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL)31593 NORTHERN CAS CO

3482 Group Name:Group Code: NORTH AMER BUILDERS GRP2009

11603 CONTRACTORS INS CO OF N AMER INC RRG 41920 NORTH AMER BUILDERS IND CO2007

11603 CONTRACTORS INS CO OF N AMER INC RRG 41920 NORTH AMER BUILDERS IND CO2006

11603 CONTRACTORS INS CO OF NORTH AMER RRG 41920 NORTH AMERICAN BUILDERS IND CO2005

11603 CONTRACTORS INS CO OF NORTH AMER RRG 41920 NORTH AMERICAN BUILDERS IND CO3483 Group Name:Group Code: PARTNERRE GRP

200910006 PARTNERRE INS CO OF NY 11835 PARIS RE AMER INS CO38636 PARTNER REINS CO OF THE US

3484 Group Name:Group Code: TOWER HILL INS GRP2009

11027 TOWER HILL PRIME INS CO 12011 TOWER HILL SELECT INS CO29050 TOWER HILL PREFERRED INS CO 38644 OMEGA INS CO

200811027 TOWER HILL PRIME INSURANCE COMPANY 12011 TOWER HILL SELECT INS CO29050 TOWER HILL PREFERRED INS CO 38644 OMEGA INS CO

200711027 TOWER HILL PRIME INSURANCE COMPANY 12011 TOWER HILL SELECT INS CO29050 TOWER HILL PREFERRED INS CO 38644 OMEGA INS CO

200611027 TOWER HILL PRIME INSURANCE COMPANY 12011 TOWER HILL SELECT INS CO29050 TOWER HILL PREFERRED INS CO 38644 OMEGA INS CO

200511027 TOWER HILL PRIME INSURANCE COMPANY 12011 TOWER HILL SELECT INS CO29050 TOWER HILL PREFERRED INS CO 38644 OMEGA INS CO

3485 Group Name:Group Code: ROTHSCHILD INTL GRP2009

41580 RED SHIELD INS CO 43915 RAINIER INS CO2008

41580 RED SHIELD INS CO 43915 RAINIER INS CO2007

41580 RED SHIELD INS CO 43915 RAINIER INS CO2006

11667 RED SHIELD SURPLUS INS CO 41580 RED SHIELD INS CO43915 RAINIER INS CO

200511667 RED SHIELD SURPLUS INS CO 41580 RED SHIELD INS CO43915 RAINIER INS CO

3488 Group Name:Group Code: J A PATTERSON GRP2009

13307 LEXON INS CO 27081 BOND SAFEGUARD INS CO2008

13307 LEXON INS CO 27081 BOND SAFEGUARD INS CO3489 Group Name:Group Code: DELEK GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners447

Page 456: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3489 Group Name:Group Code: DELEK GRP2009

10809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO27863 SOUTHERN CNTY MUT INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO

200810809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO

200710809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO

200610809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO

200510809 SOUTHERN UNDERWRITERS INS CO 10810 REPUBLIC FIRE & CAS INS CO10925 SOUTHERN VANGUARD INS CO 19208 REPUBLIC LLOYDS19216 SOUTHERN INS CO 24538 REPUBLIC UNDERWRITERS INS CO27863 SOUTHERN COUNTY MUT INS CO 40479 REPUBLIC VANGUARD INS CO

3490 Group Name:Group Code: BEACON MUT GRP2009

11837 CASTLE HILL INS CO 24017 BEACON MUT INS CO2008

11837 CASTLE HILL INS CO 24017 BEACON MUT INS CO2007

11837 CASTLE HILL INS CO 24017 BEACON MUT INS CO2006

11837 CASTLE HILL INS CO 24017 BEACON MUT INS CO2005

11837 CASTLE HILL INS CO 24017 BEACON MUT INS CO3493 Group Name:Group Code: SM MARIANO GRP

200611398 GUARANTEE INS CO 11707 FOUNDATION INS CO

200511398 GUARANTEE INS CO 11707 FOUNDATION INS CO

3494 Group Name:Group Code: JAMES RIVER GRP2009

11828 STONEWOOD INS CO 12203 JAMES RIVER INS CO13685 JAMES RIVER CAS CO

200811828 STONEWOOD INS CO 12203 JAMES RIVER INS CO

200711828 STONEWOOD INS CO 12203 JAMES RIVER INS CO

200611828 STONEWOOD INS CO 12203 JAMES RIVER INS CO

200511828 STONEWOOD INS CO 12203 JAMES RIVER INS CO

3495 Group Name:Group Code: INFINITY PROP & CAS INS GRP2009

10061 INFINITY IND INS CO 10068 HILLSTAR INS CO10195 INFINITY PREFERRED INS CO 10968 INFINITY RESERVE INS CO11738 INFINITY AUTO INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners448

Page 457: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3495 Group Name:Group Code: INFINITY PROP & CAS INS GRP2009

12599 INFINITY STANDARD INS CO 13820 INFINITY CNTY MUT INS CO16802 INFINITY SAFEGUARD INS CO 20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO21792 INFINITY CAS INS CO 22268 INFINITY INS CO31925 INFINITY SPECIALTY INS CO 35211 INFINITY GEN INS CO37001 INFINITY PREMIER INS CO 38873 INFINITY SECURITY INS CO39497 INFINITY ASSUR INS CO

200810061 INFINITY IND INS CO 10068 HILLSTAR INS CO10195 INFINITY PREFERRED INS CO 10968 INFINITY RESERVE INS CO11738 INFINITY AUTO INS CO 12599 INFINITY STANDARD INS CO13820 INFINITY CNTY MUT INS CO 16802 INFINITY SAFEGUARD INS CO20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO 21792 INFINITY CAS INS CO22268 INFINITY INS CO 31925 INFINITY SPECIALTY INS CO35211 INFINITY GEN INS CO 37001 INFINITY PREMIER INS CO38873 INFINITY SECURITY INS CO 39497 INFINITY ASSUR INS CO

200710061 INFINITY IND INS CO 10068 HILLSTAR INS CO10195 INFINITY PREFERRED INS CO 10968 INFINITY RESERVE INS CO11738 INFINITY AUTO INS CO 12599 INFINITY STANDARD INS CO13820 INFINITY CNTY MUT INS CO 16802 INFINITY SAFEGUARD INS CO20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO 21792 INFINITY CAS INS CO22268 INFINITY INS CO 31925 INFINITY SPECIALTY INS CO35211 INFINITY GEN INS CO 37001 INFINITY PREMIER INS CO38873 INFINITY SECURITY INS CO 39497 INFINITY ASSUR INS CO

200610061 INFINITY IND INS CO 10068 INFINITY NATL INS CO10195 INFINITY PREFERRED INS CO 10968 INFINITY RESERVE INS CO11738 INFINITY AUTO INS CO 12599 INFINITY STANDARD INS CO13820 INFINITY CNTY MUT INS CO 16802 INFINITY SAFEGUARD INS CO20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO 21792 INFINITY CAS INS CO22268 INFINITY INS CO 31925 INFINITY SPECIALTY INS CO35211 INFINITY GENERAL INS CO 37001 INFINITY PREMIER INS CO38873 INFINITY SECURITY INS CO 39497 INFINITY ASSURANCE INS CO

200510061 LEADER SPECIALTY INS CO 10068 INFINITY NATL INS CO10195 LEADER PREFERRED INS CO 10968 ATLANTA RESERVE INS CO11738 LEADER INS CO 12599 WINDSOR INS CO13820 GREAT TX COUNTY MUT INS CO 16802 AMERICAN DEP INS CO20260 INFINITY SELECT INS CO 21792 ATLANTA CAS CO22268 INFINITY INS CO 31925 ATLANTA SPECIALTY INS CO35211 COVENTRY INS CO 37001 AMERICAN PREMIER INS CO38873 REGAL INS CO 39497 TICO INS CO

3496 Group Name:Group Code: QUANTA US HOLDINGS GRP2009

11446 QUANTA SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 23752 QUANTA IND CO2008

11446 QUANTA SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 23752 QUANTA IND CO2007

11446 QUANTA SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 23752 QUANTA IND CO2006

11446 QUANTA SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 23752 QUANTA IND CO2005

11446 QUANTA SPECIALTY LINES INS CO 23752 QUANTA IND CO3497 Group Name:Group Code: MIRAGE INTERESTS GRP

200910199 RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO 11853 RANCHERS & FARMERS INS CO

200810199 RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners449

Page 458: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3497 Group Name:Group Code: MIRAGE INTERESTS GRP2008

11853 RANCHERS & FARMERS INS CO2007

10199 RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO 11853 RANCHERS & FARMERS INS CO2006

10199 RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO 11853 RANCHERS & FARMERS INS CO2005

10199 RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO 11853 RANCHERS & FARMERS INS CO3499 Group Name:Group Code: PROVIDENCE HOLDINGS INC GRP

200711487 IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO 28711 PROVIDENCE PROPERTY & CAS INS CO

200611487 IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO 28711 PROVIDENCE PROPERTY & CAS INS CO

200511487 IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO 28711 PROVIDENCE PROPERTY & CAS INS CO

3500 Group Name:Group Code: NODAK MUT GRP2009

34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO2008

34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO2007

34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO2006

34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO2005

34592 NODAK MUT INS CO 44270 AMERICAN WEST INS CO3501 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN GEN HOLDINGS GRP

200910343 APOLLO CAS CO 11862 DELPHI CAS CO12615 APOLLO CAS CO OF FL

200710343 APOLLO CAS CO 11862 DELPHI CAS CO12615 APOLLO CAS CO OF FL

200610343 APOLLO CAS CO 11862 DELPHI CAS CO12615 APOLLO CAS CO OF FL

200510343 APOLLO CAS CO 11862 DELPHI CAS CO

3504 Group Name:Group Code: PICA GRP2008

10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC 14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER A MUT CO2007

10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC 14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER A MUT CO2006

10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC 14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER A MUT CO2005

10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC 14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER A MUT CO2000

10222 PACO ASSUR CO INC 14460 PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER RRG MUT CO3526 Group Name:Group Code: COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP

200910074 MARTINGALE NATL INS CO 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR36749 REAL LEGACY ASSUR CO INC

200810074 MARTINGALE NATL INS CO 18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR36749 REAL LEGACY ASSUR CO INC

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners450

Page 459: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3526 Group Name:Group Code: COOPERATIVA DE SEGUROS MULTIPLES GRP2007

18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 36749 REAL LEGACY ASSUR CO INC2006

18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 36749 REAL LEGACY ASSUR CO INC2005

18163 COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR 36749 REAL LEGACY ASSUR CO INC3528 Group Name:Group Code: AMFED GRP

200711208 AMFED NATL INS CO 11963 AMFED CAS INS CO

200611208 AMFED NATL INS CO 11963 AMFED CAS INS CO

200511208 AMFED NATL INS CO 11963 AMFED CAS INS CO

3548 Group Name:Group Code: TRAVELERS GRP2009

10213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO10785 TRAVELERS AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO10950 MOUNTAIN RIDGE INS CO 12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA19038 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO 19046 TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO19224 ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO 22233 SELECT INS CO24015 NORTHLAND INS CO 24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO 25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO25623 PHOENIX INS CO 25658 TRAVELERS IND CO25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER 25674 TRAVELERS PROP CAS CO OF AMER25682 TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT 25879 FIDELITY & GUAR INS UNDERWRITERS INC25887 UNITED STATES FIDELITY & GUAR CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO 28188 TRAVCO INS CO29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO 29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO 31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER35386 FIDELITY & GUAR INS CO 36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO 36161 TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT 36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO38130 TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO 38385 COMMERCIAL GUAR INS CO40282 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO 40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO 41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIAB INS CO41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO 42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

200810213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO10785 TRAVELERS AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO10950 MOUNTAIN RIDGE INS CO 12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA19038 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO 19046 TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO19224 ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO 22233 SELECT INS CO22535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO 25623 PHOENIX INS CO25658 TRAVELERS IND CO 25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER25674 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CAS CO OF AMER 25682 TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT25879 FIDELITY & GUAR INS UNDERWRITERS INC 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO 27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO28188 TRAVCO INS CO 29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER 35386 FIDELITY & GUAR INS CO36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO 36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners451

Page 460: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3548 Group Name:Group Code: TRAVELERS GRP2008

36161 TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO 36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 38130 TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUAR INS CO 40282 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO 41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO 43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

200710213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO10785 TRAVELERS AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO10950 MOUNTAIN RIDGE INS CO 12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA19038 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO 19046 TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO19224 ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO 21296 COMMERCIAL GUAR CAS INS CO22209 ATLANTIC INS CO 22233 SELECT INS CO22535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO 25623 PHOENIX INS CO25658 TRAVELERS IND CO 25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER25674 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CAS CO OF AMER 25682 TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT25879 FIDELITY & GUAR INS UNDERWRITERS INC 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO 27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO28188 TRAVCO INS CO 29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER 35386 FIDELITY & GUAR INS CO36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO 36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO36161 TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO 36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 38130 TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUAR INS CO 40282 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO 41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO 43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO

200610213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO10785 TRAVELERS AUTO INS CO OF NJ 10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO10950 MOUNTAIN RIDGE INS CO 12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA19038 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO 19046 TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT 19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO19224 ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO 21296 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY CAS INS CO22209 ATLANTIC INS CO 22233 SELECT INS CO22454 MENDAKOTA INS CO 22535 SEABOARD SURETY CO24015 NORTHLAND INS CO 24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO 24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO 25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO25623 PHOENIX INS CO 25658 TRAVELERS IND CO25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER 25674 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CAS CO OF AMER25682 TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT 25879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO 27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO 28188 TRAVCO INS CO29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO 29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO 31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER33650 MENDOTA INS CO 35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO 36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO36161 TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO 36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO 38130 TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO 40282 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO 41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners452

Page 461: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3548 Group Name:Group Code: TRAVELERS GRP2006

41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO 41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO 41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO 43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO44440 DISCOVER REIN CO

200510213 DISCOVER SPECIALTY INS CO 10620 USF&G INS CO OF MS10647 FIRST FLORIDIAN AUTO & HOME INS CO 10785 TRAVELERS AUTO INS CO OF NJ10819 AMERICAN EQUITY SPECIALTY INS CO 10950 MOUNTAIN RIDGE INS CO12850 PREMIER INS CO OF MA 19038 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO19046 TRAVELERS CAS INS CO OF AMER 19062 AUTOMOBILE INS CO OF HARTFORD CT19070 STANDARD FIRE INS CO 19224 ST PAUL PROTECTIVE INS CO21296 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY CAS INS CO 22209 ATLANTIC INS CO22233 SELECT INS CO 22454 MENDAKOTA INS CO22535 SEABOARD SURETY CO 24015 NORTHLAND INS CO24031 NORTHLAND CAS CO 24767 ST PAUL FIRE & MARINE INS CO24775 ST PAUL GUARDIAN INS CO 24791 ST PAUL MERCURY INS CO25615 CHARTER OAK FIRE INS CO 25623 PHOENIX INS CO25658 TRAVELERS IND CO 25666 TRAVELERS IND CO OF AMER25674 TRAVELERS PROPERTY CAS CO OF AMER 25682 TRAVELERS IND CO OF CT25879 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS UNDERWRITERS 25887 US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO27987 NORTHFIELD INS CO 27998 TRAVELERS HOME & MARINE INS CO28188 TRAVCO INS CO 29696 TRAVELERS EXCESS & SURPLUS LINES CO29930 FIRST TRENTON IND CO 30481 ST PAUL SURPLUS LINES INS CO31194 TRAVELERS CAS & SURETY CO OF AMER 33650 MENDOTA INS CO35386 FIDELITY & GUARANTY INS CO 36137 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL INS CO36145 TRAVELERS PERSONAL SECURITY INS CO 36161 TRAVELERS PROP CAS INS CO36170 TRAVELERS CAS CO OF CT 36463 DISCOVER PROP & CAS INS CO37249 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY LLOYDS INS CO 37494 GULF GROUP LLOYDS38130 TRAVELERS PERSONAL INS CO 38385 COMMERCIAL GUARANTY INS CO40282 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CAS CO 40967 ST PAUL FIRE & CAS INS CO41262 TRAVELERS LLOYDS INS CO 41483 FARMINGTON CAS CO41564 TRAVELERS LLOYDS OF TX INS CO 41750 ST PAUL MEDICAL LIABILITY INS CO41769 ATHENA ASSUR CO 42811 GULF UNDERWRITERS INS CO43117 AMERICAN EQUITY INS CO 44440 DISCOVER REIN CO

3550 Group Name:Group Code: MIDDLE GA GRP2009

14524 MIDDLE GA MUT INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO2007

14524 MIDDLE GA MUT INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO2006

14524 MIDDLE GA MUT INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO2005

14524 MIDDLE GA MUT INS CO 20168 GLOBAL INS CO3569 Group Name:Group Code: CATERPILLAR GRP

200911255 CATERPILLAR INS CO

200811255 CATERPILLAR INS CO

200711255 CATERPILLAR INS CO

200611255 CATERPILLAR INS CO

200511255 CATERPILLAR INS CO

3589 Group Name:Group Code: MAXUM SPECIALTY INS GRP2009

10784 MAXUM CAS INS CO 26743 MAXUM IND CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners453

Page 462: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3589 Group Name:Group Code: MAXUM SPECIALTY INS GRP2008

10784 MAXUM CAS INS CO 26743 MAXUM IND CO2007

10784 MAXUM CAS INS CO 26743 MAXUM IND CO2006

10784 MAXUM CAS INS CO 26743 MAXUM IND CO2005

10784 MAXUM CAS INS CO 26743 MAXUM IND CO3592 Group Name:Group Code: PROALLIANCE GRP

200912750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

200812750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

200712750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

200612750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

200512750 EVERGREEN NATL IND CO 39551 CONTINENTAL HERITAGE INS CO

3593 Group Name:Group Code: USIC GRP2009

12152 USIC OF FL INC 44423 UNITED SURETY & IND CO2008

12152 USIC OF FL INC 44423 UNITED SURETY & IND CO2007

12152 USIC OF FL INC 44423 UNITED SURETY & IND CO2006

12152 USIC OF FL INC 44423 UNITED SURETY & IND CO2005

12152 USIC OF FL INC 44423 UNITED SURETY & IND CO3596 Group Name:Group Code: AFFIRMATIVE INS GRP

200910295 USAGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO12569 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO OF MI 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

200810295 USAGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO12569 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO OF MI 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

200710295 USAGENCIES CAS INS CO INC 10413 USAGENCIES DIRECT INS CO12569 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO OF MI 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

200612569 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO OF MI 38806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

200538806 INSURA PROP & CAS INS CO 42609 AFFIRMATIVE INS CO

3617 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST MERCURY FIN GRP2009

10049 FIRST MERCURY CAS CO 10251 AMERICAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO10657 FIRST MERCURY INS CO 12884 AMC RE INC

200810049 FIRST MERCURY CAS CO 10251 AMERICAN UNDERWRITERS INS CO10657 FIRST MERCURY INS CO 12884 AMC RE INC

200710049 ALL NATION INS CO 10657 FIRST MERCURY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners454

Page 463: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3617 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST MERCURY FIN GRP2006

10049 ALL NATION INS CO 10657 FIRST MERCURY INS CO2005

10049 ALL NATION INS CO 10657 FIRST MERCURY INS CO3636 Group Name:Group Code: LANCER INS GRP

200612212 LANCER CAS CO 26077 LANCER INS CO

200512212 LANCER CAS CO 26077 LANCER INS CO

3638 Group Name:Group Code: PGC HOLDING CORP GRP2009

13703 THE GEN AUTOMOBILE INS CO INC 22906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH37648 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP

200822906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH 37648 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP

200722906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH 37648 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSUR CORP

200622906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH 37648 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSUR CORP

200522906 PERMANENT GEN ASSUR CORP OF OH 37648 PERMANENT GENERAL ASSUR CORP

3678 Group Name:Group Code: AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS GRP2009

12289 PERSONAL SERV INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO 34940 OMNI IND CO39098 OMNI INS CO

200812289 PERSONAL SERV INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO 34940 OMNI IND CO39098 OMNI INS CO

200712289 PERSONAL SERVICE INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO 34940 OMNI IND CO39098 OMNI INS CO

200612289 PERSONAL SERVICE INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO 34940 OMNI IND CO39098 OMNI INS CO

200512289 PERSONAL SERVICE INS CO 13455 BANKERS INDEPENDENT INS CO17957 AMERICAN INDEPENDENT INS CO

3702 Group Name:Group Code: LOYA GRP2009

10157 VISION INS CO 11198 LOYA INS CO12589 LOYA CAS INS CO

200810157 VISION INS CO 11198 LOYA INS CO12589 LOYA CAS INS CO

200710157 VISION INS CO 11198 LOYA INS CO12589 LOYA CAS INS CO

200610157 VISION INS CO 11198 LOYA INS CO12589 LOYA CAS INS CO

200510157 VISION INS CO 11198 LOYA INS CO

3703 Group Name:Group Code: TOWER GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners455

Page 464: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3703 Group Name:Group Code: TOWER GRP2009

10205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 13599 CASTLEPOINT FL INS CO15586 PRESERVER INS CO 17205 CASTLEPOINT INS CO18376 HERMITAGE INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO29750 KODIAK INS CO 40134 CASTLEPOINT NATL INS CO43702 TOWER NATL INS CO 44300 TOWER INS CO OF NY

200810205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 15586 PRESERVER INS CO17205 CASTLEPOINT INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO43702 TOWER NATIONAL INS CO 44300 TOWER INS CO OF NY

200710205 MOUNTAIN VALLEY IND CO 15586 PRESERVER INS CO17205 CASTLEPOINT INS CO 24007 NORTH EAST INS CO43702 TOWER NATIONAL INS CO 44300 TOWER INS CO OF NY

200617205 TOWER IND CO OF AMER 43702 TOWER NATIONAL INS CO44300 TOWER INS CO OF NY

200543702 TOWER NATIONAL INS CO 44300 TOWER INS CO OF NY

3724 Group Name:Group Code: PARTNERS LTD GRP2008

18376 HERMITAGE INS CO 29750 KODIAK INS CO2007

18376 HERMITAGE INS CO 29750 KODIAK INS CO2006

18376 HERMITAGE INS CO 29750 KODIAK INS CO2005

18376 HERMITAGE INS CO 29750 KODIAK INS CO3764 Group Name:Group Code: CARDIF HOLDINGS GRP

200921075 CARDIF PROP & CAS INS CO

200821075 CARDIF PROP & CAS INS CO

200721075 CARDIF PROP & CAS INS CO

200621075 CARDIF PROP & CAS INS CO

3765 Group Name:Group Code: RTW INC GRP2006

12311 BLOOMINGTON COMPENSATION INS CO 45934 AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO2005

12311 BLOOMINGTON COMPENSATION INS CO 45934 AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO3786 Group Name:Group Code: ENDURANCE GRP

200910641 ENDURANCE AMER INS CO 11551 ENDURANCE REINS CORP OF AMER12548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 41718 ENDURANCE AMER SPECIALTY INS CO43630 ENDURANCE RISK SOLUTIONS ASSUR CO

200810641 ENDURANCE AMER INS CO 11551 ENDURANCE REINS CORP OF AMER12548 AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO 41718 ENDURANCE AMER SPECIALTY INS CO43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CAS

200710641 ENDURANCE AMER INS CO 11551 ENDURANCE REINS CORP OF AMER41718 ENDURANCE AMER SPECIALTY INS CO 43630 AMERICAN MERCHANTS CAS

200610641 ENDURANCE AMER INS CO 11551 ENDURANCE REINS CORP OF AMER41718 ENDURANCE AMER SPECIALTY INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners456

Page 465: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

3786 Group Name:Group Code: ENDURANCE GRP2005

11551 ENDURANCE REINS CORP OF AMER 41718 TRADERS & PACIFIC INS CO3829 Group Name:Group Code: GEOVERA HOLDINGS INC GRP

200910182 GEOVERA SPECIALTY INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INS CO10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROP INS CO 12759 GEOVERA SECURITY INS CO

200810182 GEOVERA SPECIALTY INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INS CO10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROP INS CO 12759 GEOVERA SECURITY INS CO

200710182 GEOVERA SPECIALTY INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INS CO10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROP INS CO

200610182 USF&G SPECIALTY INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INS CO10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROPERTY INS CO

200510182 USF&G SPECIALTY INS CO 10799 GEOVERA INS CO10887 PACIFIC SELECT PROPERTY INS CO

3890 Group Name:Group Code: APPLIED UNDERWRITERS GRP2005

12040 COMMERCIAL GENERAL IND INC 28258 CONTINENTAL NATL IND CO38865 CALIFORNIA INS CO

3911 Group Name:Group Code: STRICKLAND INS GRP2009

12508 COASTAL CAS INS CO 42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO2008

12508 COASTAL CAS INS CO 42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO2007

12508 COASTAL CAS INS CO 42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO2006

12508 COASTAL CAS INS CO 42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO2005

42846 ATLANTIC CAS INS CO3951 Group Name:Group Code: HMHSI TRUST GRP

200912519 HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO INC 31224 HANYS MEMBER HOSP SELF INS TRUST

200812519 HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO INC 31224 HANYS MEMBER HOSP SELF INS TRUST

200712519 HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO INC 31224 HANYS MEMBER HOSP SELF INS TRUST

200612519 HEALTHCARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO INC 31224 HANYS MEMBER HOSP SELF INS TRUST

3991 Group Name:Group Code: IMT MUT HOLDING GRP2009

12528 WADENA INS CO 14257 IMT INS CO2008

12528 WADENA INS CO 14257 IMT INS CO2007

12528 WADENA INS CO 14257 IMT INS CO2006

12528 WADENA INS CO 14257 IMT INS CO MUT4011 Group Name:Group Code: GENWORTH FIN GRP

200911049 GENWORTH MORTGAGE REINS CORP 11365 SPONSORED CAPTIVE RE INC13093 RIVER LAKE INS CO V 16675 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC18759 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE ASSU 29823 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS C37095 GENWORTH FINANCIAL ASSUR CORP 38458 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners457

Page 466: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4011 Group Name:Group Code: GENWORTH FIN GRP2009

41432 GENWORTH HOME EQUITY INS CORP2008

11049 GENWORTH MORTGAGE REINS CORP 11365 SPONSORED CAPTIVE RE INC13093 RIVER LAKE INS CO V 16675 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC18759 VEREX ASSURE INC 29823 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS C37095 GENWORTH FINANCIAL ASSUR CORP 38458 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP41432 GENWORTH HOME EQUITY INS CORP

200711049 GENWORTH MORTGAGE REINS CORP 11365 SPONSORED CAPTIVE RE INC16675 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC 18759 VEREX ASSURE INC29823 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS C 37095 GENWORTH FINANCIAL ASSUR CORP38458 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP 41432 GENWORTH HOME EQUITY INS CORP

200611049 GENWORTH MORTGAGE REINS CORP 11365 SPONSORED CAPTIVE RE INC16675 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP OF NC 18759 VEREX ASSURE INC29823 GENWORTH RESIDENTIAL MRT INS CORP NC 37095 PRIVATE RESIDENTIAL MORTGAGE INS CO38458 GENWORTH MORTGAGE INS CORP 41432 GENWORTH HOME EQUITY INS CORP

4051 Group Name:Group Code: OCEAN HARBOR GRP2009

11026 ZEPHYR INS CO INC 12360 OCEAN HARBOR CAS INS CO12563 SAFE HARBOR INS CO

200812360 OCEAN HARBOR CAS INS CO 12563 SAFE HARBOR INS CO

200712360 OCEAN HARBOR CAS INS CO 12563 SAFE HARBOR INS CO

200612360 OCEAN HARBOR CAS INS CO 12563 SAFE HARBOR INS CO

4071 Group Name:Group Code: RVI GRP2009

10344 RVI AMER INS CO 23132 RVI NATL INS CO2008

10344 RVI AMER INS CO 23132 RVI NATL INS CO2007

10344 RVI AMER INS CO 23132 RVI NATL INS CO2006

10344 RVI AMER INS CO 23132 RVI NATL INS CO4072 Group Name:Group Code: FIRST COMMERCIAL GRP

200810347 FIRST COMMERCIAL INS CO 41700 FIRST COMMERCIAL TRANSPORTATION & PR

200710347 FIRST COMMERCIAL INS CO 41700 FIRST COMMERCIAL TRANSPORTATION & PR

200610347 FIRST COMMERCIAL INS CO 41700 FIRST COMMERCIAL TRANSPORTATION & PR

4111 Group Name:Group Code: HOMEWISE GRP2009

12438 HOMEWISE INS CO 12582 HOMEWISE PREFERRED INS CO2008

12438 HOMEWISE INS CO 12582 HOMEWISE PREFERRED INS CO2007

12438 HOMEWISE INS CO 12582 HOMEWISE PREFERRED INS CO2006

12438 HOMEWISE INS CO 12582 HOMEWISE PREFERRED INS CO4131 Group Name:Group Code: PRIME HOLDINGS INS GRP

200811264 PRIME INS SYNDICATE INC 12588 PRIME INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners458

Page 467: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4131 Group Name:Group Code: PRIME HOLDINGS INS GRP2007

11264 PRIME INSURANCE SYNDICATE INC 12588 PRIME INS CO2006

11264 PRIME INSURANCE SYNDICATE INC 12588 PRIME INS CO4152 Group Name:Group Code: RELIAMAX HOLDING GRP

200912535 RELIAMAX INS CO 12623 RELIAMAX SURETY CO

200712535 RELIAMAX INS CO 12623 RELIAMAX SURETY CO

200612535 RELIAMAX INS CO 12623 RELIAMAX SURETY CO

4233 Group Name:Group Code: WL DUNN GRP2009

12810 MDOW INS CO 20320 COLUMBIA LLOYDS INS CO2008

12810 MDOW INS CO 20320 COLUMBIA LLOYDS INS CO2007

12810 MDOW INS CO 20320 COLUMBIA LLOYDS INS CO2006

12810 MDOW INS CO 20320 COLUMBIA LLOYDS INS CO4254 Group Name:Group Code: THE WARRANTY GRP

200940827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

200840827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

200740827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

200640827 VIRGINIA SURETY CO INC

4256 Group Name:Group Code: ANCHOR INS HOLDINGS GRP2009

29793 PACIFIC STAR INS CO 40010 ANCHOR GEN INS CO2008

29793 PACIFIC STAR INS CO 40010 ANCHOR GEN INS CO2007

29793 PACIFIC STAR INS CO 40010 ANCHOR GEN INS CO2006

29793 GREATWAY INS CO 40010 ANCHOR GENERAL INS CO4257 Group Name:Group Code: AIX GRP

200712833 AIX SPECIALTY INS CO 42552 NOVA CAS CO

200612833 AIX SPECIALTY INS CO 42552 NOVA CAS CO

4277 Group Name:Group Code: TD FRIEDKIN GRP2009

12870 SENTRUITY CAS CO2007

11448 GSFS RRG INC 12870 SENTRUITY CAS CO2006

11448 GSFS RRG INC2005

11448 GSFS RRG INC4278 Group Name:Group Code: SECURITY BANCSHARES GRP

200711457 FIRST APEX RE INC 43133 APEX LLOYDS INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners459

Page 468: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4278 Group Name:Group Code: SECURITY BANCSHARES GRP2006

11457 FIRST APEX RE INC 43133 APEX LLOYDS INS CO2005

11457 FIRST APEX RE INC 43133 APEX LLOYDS INS CO4279 Group Name:Group Code: SFM GRP

200911347 SFM MUT INS CO 27049 SFM SELECT INS CO

200811347 SFM MUT INS CO 27049 SFM SELECT INS CO

200711347 SFM MUT INS CO 27049 SFM SELECT INS CO

200611347 SFM MUT INS CO 27049 SFM SELECT INS CO

4318 Group Name:Group Code: FINCOR HOLDINGS GRP2008

33111 MHA INS CO 42510 WASHINGTON CAS CO2007

33111 MHA INS CO 42510 WASHINGTON CAS CO2006

33111 MHA INS CO 42510 WASHINGTON CAS CO4339 Group Name:Group Code: FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT GRP

200912611 FARMERS & MECHANICS FIRE & CAS INS I 36315 FARMERS MECH MUT FIRE INS OF WV

200812611 FARMERS & MECHANICS FIRE & CAS INS I 36315 FARMERS MECH MUT FIRE INS OF WV

200712611 FARMERS & MECHANICS FIRE & CAS INS I 36315 FARMERS MECH MUT FIRE INS OF WV

200612611 FARMERS & MECHANICS FIRE & CAS INS I 36315 FARMERS MECH MUT FIRE INS OF WV

4359 Group Name:Group Code: HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP GRP2009

10069 HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP A MUT CO 11206 HOUSING ENTERPRISE INS CO INC26797 HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC

200810069 HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP A MUT CO 11206 HOUSING ENTERPRISE INS CO INC26797 HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC

200710069 HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP A MUT CO 11206 HOUSING ENTERPRISE RISK SERV INC26797 HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC

200610069 HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP A MUT CO 11206 HOUSING ENTERPRISE RISK SERVICES INC26797 HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC

200510069 HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP A MUT CO 11206 HOUSING ENTERPRISE RISK SERVICES INC26797 HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC

4381 Group Name:Group Code: LIGHTYEAR DELOS GRP2009

12936 NAXOS INS CO 35408 DELOS INS CO2008

12936 NAXOS INS CO 35408 DELOS INS CO2007

12936 NAXOS INS CO 35408 DELOS INS CO4463 Group Name:Group Code: ROCKHILL HOLDING GRP

200812311 BLOOMINGTON COMPENSATION INS CO 28053 ROCKHILL INS CO30945 PLAZA INS CO 45934 AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners460

Page 469: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4463 Group Name:Group Code: ROCKHILL HOLDING GRP2007

12311 BLOOMINGTON COMPENSATION INS CO 28053 ROCKHILL INS CO30945 PLAZA INS CO 45934 AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO

4485 Group Name:Group Code: SCF GRP2009

12741 SCF PREMIER INS CO 13043 SCF GEN INS CO13209 SCF WESTERN INS CO 13210 SCF CAS INS CO36714 SCF AZ

200812741 SCF PREMIER INS CO 36714 SCF ARIZONA

200712741 SCF PREMIER INS CO 36714 SCF ARIZONA

200636714 SCF ARIZONA

4486 Group Name:Group Code: NORTHERN CAPITAL GRP2008

12568 NORTHERN CAPITAL INS CO 13023 LANDMARK ONE INS CO2007

12568 NORTHERN CAPITAL INS CO 13023 LANDMARK ONE INS CO4507 Group Name:Group Code: BUILDERS GRP

200910844 BUILDERS MUT INS CO 13036 BUILDERS PREMIER INS CO

200810844 BUILDERS MUT INS CO 13036 BUILDERS PREMIER INS CO

200710844 BUILDERS MUT INS CO 13036 BUILDERS PREMIER INS CO

4508 Group Name:Group Code: LOCKHART INS GRP2008

13040 GUARDIAN PROP & CAS CO INC 17779 GUARDIAN INS CO INC2007

13040 GUARDIAN PROP & CAS CO INC 17779 GUARDIAN INS CO INC4509 Group Name:Group Code: IRONSHORE GRP

200923647 IRONSHORE IND INC 25445 IRONSHORE SPECIALTY INS CO

200823647 IRONSHORE IND INC 25445 IRONSHORE SPECIALTY INS CO

4511 Group Name:Group Code: NATIONAL GUAR GRP2009

12068 NATIONAL GUAR INS CO 19011 DRIVERS INS CO4513 Group Name:Group Code: AIOI INS GRP

200912903 DTRIC INS UNDERWRITERS LTD 13740 AIOI INS CO LTD34886 AIOI INS CO OF AMER 37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

200812903 DTRIC INS UNDERWRITERS LTD 34886 AIOI INS CO OF AMER37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

200712903 DTRIC INS UNDERWRITERS LTD 34886 AIOI INS CO OF AMER37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

200634886 AIOI INS CO OF AMER 37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

200534886 AIOI INS CO OF AMER 37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

200034886 CHIYODA FIRE & MARINE INS CO OF AM 37265 DTRIC INS CO LTD

4533 Group Name:Group Code: MIC HOLDING CO GRP

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners461

Page 470: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4533 Group Name:Group Code: MIC HOLDING CO GRP2007

11822 MILLENNIUM INS CO 11823 PENNSYLVANIA MEDICAL REINS CO4573 Group Name:Group Code: NBIS GRP

200911671 PROBUILDERS SPECIALTY INS CO RRG 12303 NATIONSBUILDERS INS CO

200811671 PROBUILDERS SPECIALTY INS CO RRG 12303 NATIONSBUILDERS INS CO

200711671 PROBUILDERS SPECIALTY INS CO RRG 12303 NATIONSBUILDERS INS CO

200611671 PROBUILDERS SPECIALTY INS CO RRG 12303 NATIONSBUILDERS INS CO

200511671 PROBUILDERS SPECIALTY INS CO RRG 12303 SOUTHWESTERN CAS INS CO

4574 Group Name:Group Code: CATLIN US INS GRP2009

15989 CATLIN SPECIALTY INS CO 19518 CATLIN INS CO2008

15989 CATLIN SPECIALTY INS CO 19518 CATLIN INS CO2007

15989 CATLIN SPECIALTY INS CO 19518 CATLIN INS CO2006

15989 WELLINGTON SPECIALTY INS CO 19518 CATLIN INS CO4575 Group Name:Group Code: FLEXPOINT FUND GRP

200911072 ACA HOME INS CORP 12601 AMERICAN CAPITAL ASSUR CORP

200811072 ACA HOME INS CORP 12601 AMERICAN CAPITAL ASSUR CORP

4576 Group Name:Group Code: GNW ACQUSITION CORP GRO2009

12767 HAWAIIAN INS & GUAR CO LTD 26654 GREAT NORTHWEST INS CO2007

12767 HAWAIIAN INS & GUAR CO LTD 26654 GREAT NORTHWEST INS CO2006

12767 HAWAIIAN INS & GUARANTY CO LTD 26654 GREAT NORTHWEST INS CO4636 Group Name:Group Code: MAX CAPITAL GRP

200921296 MAX AMER INS CO 33189 MAX SPECIALTY INS CO

200821296 MAX AMER INS CO 33189 MAX SPECIALTY INS CO

4637 Group Name:Group Code: CLARIAN HLTH PARTNERS GRP2009

11992 CLARIAN HLTH RRG INC2008

11992 CLARIAN HLTH RRG INC4641 Group Name:Group Code: D & J ROTTMAN GRP

200910008 WESTERN INS CO 13191 WESTERN BONDING CO

200810008 WESTERN INS CO 13191 WESTERN BONDING CO

4661 Group Name:Group Code: PLICO COS GRP2009

13205 PLICO SPONSORED CAPTIVE INS CO 39594 PHYSICIANS LIAB INS CO2008

13205 PLICO SPONSORED CAPTIVE INS CO 39594 PHYSICIANS LIAB INS CO4662 Group Name:Group Code:

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners462

Page 471: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4662 Group Name:Group Code: ARIEL HOLDINGS GROUP2009

13551 VALIANT SPECIALTY INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO2008

13551 VALIANT SPECIALTY INS CO 26611 VALIANT INS CO4663 Group Name:Group Code: UNIVERSAL INS HOLDING GRP

200910861 UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS 13563 AMERICAN PLATINUM PROP & CAS INS CO

200810861 UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS 13563 AMERICAN PLATINUM PROP & CAS INS CO

4664 Group Name:Group Code: PURE COMPANIES GRP2009

12873 PRIVILEGE UNDERWRITERS RECP EXCH 13204 PURE INS CO2008

12873 PRIVILEGE UNDERWRITERS RECP EXCH 13204 PURE INS CO4666 Group Name:Group Code: HISCOX INS GRP

200910200 HISCOX INS CO INC 13578 HISCOX SPECIALTY INS CO INC

4669 Group Name:Group Code: SOUTHWEST INS PARTNERS GRP2009

18694 GREAT MIDWEST INS CO4670 Group Name:Group Code: STARR GRP

200913604 STARR SURPLUS LINES INS CO 38318 STARR IND & LIAB CO

4671 Group Name:Group Code: FIRE DISTRICTS NY GRP2009

13608 FDM PREFERRED INS CO INC 13610 FIRE DISTRICTS INS CO INC37400 FIRE DISTRICTS OF NY MUT INS CO INC

4672 Group Name:Group Code: DONGBU INS GRP2009

12502 DONGBU INS CO LTD 13620 DONGBU INS CO LTD2008

12502 DONGBU INS CO LTD 13620 DONGBU INS CO LTD4674 Group Name:Group Code: BARRINGTON CAPITAL GRP

200910688 FLORIDA FAMILY INS CO 13648 LAKEVIEW INS CO

4675 Group Name:Group Code: MUTUAL INSURERS HOLDING GRP2009

10859 FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO 14591 MILWAUKEE INS CO2008

10859 FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO 14591 MILWAUKEE INS CO2007

10859 FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO 14591 MILWAUKEE INS CO4676 Group Name:Group Code: SYNCORA HOLDINGS GRP

200913666 SYNCORA CAPITAL ASSUR INC 20311 SYNCORA GUAR INC

4678 Group Name:Group Code: WAYNE & WASHINGTON MUT GRP2009

10255 WASHINGTON MUT INS ASSOC 16799 WAYNE MUT INS CO4680 Group Name:Group Code: AIC HOLDINGS GRP

200910702 MADISON INS CO 11573 ACCIDENT INS CO INC

4682 Group Name:Group Code: UNITED INS GRP2009

10118 EZ AUTO INS CO 12256 UNITED INS COGroup Name:Group Code:

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners463

Page 472: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

4683 Group Name:Group Code: MOUNTAIN WEST FARM GRP2009

13686 360 INS CO 29440 MOUNTAIN W FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO4684 Group Name:Group Code: MAIDEN HOLDINGS GRP

200911054 MAIDEN REINS CO 37745 MAIDEN SPECIALTY INS CO

4686 Group Name:Group Code: JERGER HOLDINGS GRP2009

12359 AMERICAN TRADITIONS INS CO 12957 MODERN USA INS CO4687 Group Name:Group Code: CIFG GRP

200913723 CIFG GUAR INC 25771 CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC

4695 Group Name:Group Code: HEREFORD HOLDING GRP2009

10645 DRIVERS INS CO 24309 HEREFORD INS CO

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners464

Page 473: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

INDIVIDUAL COMPANY INDEX

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners465

Page 474: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners466

Page 475: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty Insurance Industry

Market Share

Top 25 Companies for 25 Years

Individual company index

Company Code:LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS.2009WASHINGTON STATE FUND2009OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION2009WASHINGTON STATE FUND2008WORKERS' SAFETY & COMP DIV OF WY2008SOUTH CAROLINA STATE ACCIDENT FUND2008WORKFORCE SAFETY & INSURANCE OF ND2008OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION2008MT STATE COMPENSATION INSURANCE FUND2008LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS.2008LOUISIANA CITIZENS PROPERTY INS.2007OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION2007WASHINGTON STATE FUND2007OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION2006WASHINGTON STATE FUND2006OHIO BUREAU OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION2005WASHINGTON STATE FUND2005WV WORKERS' COMPENSATION DIVISION2005

10000Company Code:COMMERCIAL MUT INS CO INS CO1995

10001Company Code:QUALCHOICE HEALTH PLAN INC1995

10002Company Code:MUNICIPAL MUT INS CO1995

10007Company Code:NEVADA GENERAL INS CO1995

10009Company Code:TOWER BONDING & SURETY CO2008

10011Company Code:MADA INS EXCHANGE1995

10020Company Code:UNITED EDUCATORS INS RRG INC2008UNITED EDUCATORS INS RRG INC1995

10022Company Code:AGWAY INS CO1995

10027Company Code:NORTH AMER FIRE & CAS INS CO1995

10033Company Code:WORKERS COMP FUND OF UT1995

10039Company Code:GA TIMBER HARVESTERS MUTL CAPTIVE IC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners467

Page 476: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10045Company Code:FLORIDA BLDRS & EMPLRS MUT INS CO1995

10049Company Code:ALL NATION INS CO1995

10056Company Code:MANAGEDCOMP INS CO1995

10064Company Code:CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2009CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2008CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2007FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2006FLORIDA CITIZENS PROP INS CORP2005

10069Company Code:HOUSING AUTHORITY PROP INS INC1995

10075Company Code:CONSUMER SPECIALTIES INS CO RRG1995

10077Company Code:AMERICAN MEDICAL MUT INC RRG1995

10083Company Code:THE NATIONAL CATHOLIC RRG1995

10084Company Code:TITLE INDUSTRY ASSUR CO RRG1995

10085Company Code:TANK OWNERS INS CO OF TX RRG1995

10089Company Code:PLASTICS INDUSTRY RRG INC1995

10100Company Code:PROFORMANCE INS CO (THE)1995

10101Company Code:AMHS INSURANCE COMPANY RRG1995

10102Company Code:FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS RESERVE RRG1995

10103Company Code:AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO2009AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO2008AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO2007AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO2006AMERICAN AGRICULTURAL INS CO2005

10106Company Code:REAL ESTATE AGENTS RRG INC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners468

Page 477: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10112Company Code:NORTHEAST CAS RRG INC1995

10113Company Code:TERRA INS CO RRG1995

10114Company Code:NONPROFITS MUT RRG INC1995

10115Company Code:EASTERN DENTISTS INS CO RRG2008EASTERN DENTISTS INS CO RRG1995

10116Company Code:EY RISK RETENTION GROUP1995

10124Company Code:MEDSTAR LIAB LTD INS CO INC RRG2008

10140Company Code:OPTIMA INS CO2008

10163Company Code:GENERAL EASTERN SKI INS RRG INC1995

10164Company Code:CPA MUT INS CO OF AMER RRG1995

10171Company Code:ORDINARY MUT RRG CORP1995

10174Company Code:BAR VERMONT RISK RETENTION GRP INC1995

10180Company Code:SPRING VALLEY MUT TORNADO INS CO1995

10183Company Code:EQUITABLE LIABILITY INS CO1995

10191Company Code:MO EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2008MO EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO1995

10199Company Code:RANCHERS & FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

10200Company Code:HISCOX INS CO INC2008AMERICAN LIVE STOCK INS CO1995AMERICAN LIVE STOCK INS CO1985

10204Company Code:CONSUMERS INS USA INC1995

10206Company Code:MA MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL INS ASSOC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners469

Page 478: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10208Company Code:FLORIDA BUSINESS MUT INS CO1995

10209Company Code:MI AUTO INS PLACEMENT FACILITY1995

10211Company Code:TPA CAPTIVE INS CO INC1995

10216Company Code:AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO2000AMERICAN CONTRACTORS IND CO1995

10221Company Code:ALISTAR INS CO1995

10222Company Code:PACO ASSUR CO INC1995

10228Company Code:FIRST NV INS CO1995

10232Company Code:AMERICAN ASSOC OF ORTHODONTIST RRG1995

10233Company Code:TWIN FALLS MUT INS CO1995

10234Company Code:NATIONAL SRVC CONTRACT INS CO RRG1995

10289Company Code:UNITED AGENTS INS CO OF LA1995

10293Company Code:INTEGRA INS INC2008INTEGRA INS INC1995

10295Company Code:US AGENCIES CAS INS CO INC1995

10308Company Code:ANTILLES INS CO2008ANTILLES INS CO1995

10320Company Code:KENTUCKY EMPLOYERS MUT INS2008KENTUCKY EMPLOYERS MUT INS1995

10323Company Code:FARMERS MUT INS CO2008FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

10325Company Code:CRYSTAL-LAKE UTICA MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners470

Page 479: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10335Company Code:BRIDGEFIELD CASUALTY INS CO1995

10336Company Code:USAUTO INS CO1995

10340Company Code:STONINGTON INS CO1995

10341Company Code:CONTROLLED RISK INS CO OF VT RRG2008CONTROLLED RISK INS CO OF VT INC1995

10343Company Code:APOLLO CAS CO1995

10344Company Code:RVI AMER INS CO2005

10346Company Code:PINNACLE ASSURANCE CORP1995

10353Company Code:OOIDA RRG INC1995

10354Company Code:NEW ENGLAND MED CENTER INS CO VT1995

10374Company Code:ERIE & NIAGRA INS ASSOC2008

10375Company Code:GOLDEN EAGLE INS CO1995

10384Company Code:ASSOCIATED BUSINESS & COMMERCE INS1995

10385Company Code:FFVA MUT INS CO2008

10430Company Code:SUMMIT INSURANCE COMPANY1995

10476Company Code:STICO MUT INS CO RRG2008

10480Company Code:CAPITOL INS CO1995

10499Company Code:CHRYSLER INS CO2009CHRYSLER INS CO2008CHRYSLER INS CO2007

10537Company Code:CASUALTY CORP OF AMER1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners471

Page 480: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10541Company Code:AGRINATIONAL INS CO2008

10561Company Code:CATHOLIC RELIEF INS CO OF AMER2008CATHOLIC RELIEF INS CO OF AMER1995

10590Company Code:HEARTLAND LLOYDS INS CO1995

10637Company Code:COMMUNITY HEALTHCARE INS RECIPROCAL1995

10639Company Code:ATTORNEYS LIAB ASSUR SOCIETY INC RRG2008

10642Company Code:CHEROKEE INS CO2008CHEROKEE INS CO1995

10697Company Code:MCIC VT INC RRG2009MCIC VT INC RRG2008MCIC VT INC RRG2007MCIC VT INC RRG2006MCIC VT INC RRG2005

10749Company Code:INTREPID INS CO2008

10758Company Code:COLONIAL SURETY CO2008COLONIAL SURETY CO1995

10781Company Code:HAWAII EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO2008

10783Company Code:CORNERSTONE NATL INS CO2008CORNERSTONE NATL INS CO2006

10790Company Code:AMERICAN VEHICLE INS CO1995

10808Company Code:CASSATT RRG INC2008

10815Company Code:VERLAN FIRE INS CO MD1995

10817Company Code:PLATEAU CAS INS CO2008

10831Company Code:MT MORRIS MUT INS CO2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners472

Page 481: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

10838Company Code:SUNDERLAND MARINE MUT CO LTD2008

10839Company Code:COUNTRYWIDE INS CO1995

10842Company Code:FRANKLIN CAS INS CO RRG2008

10859Company Code:FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO2008FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO2006FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO2005

10861Company Code:UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS2007UNIVERSAL PROP & CAS INS2006

10871Company Code:DELTA CAS CO1995

10897Company Code:FIRST PROTECTIVE INS CO2008

10899Company Code:ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG2009ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG2008ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG2007ASOC DE SUSCRIPCION CONJUNTA DEL SEG2006

10903Company Code:AMERICAN EXCESS INS EXCH RRG2008

10906Company Code:COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO2009COMMERCIAL ALLIANCE INS CO2008

10916Company Code:SURETEC INS CO2009SURETEC INS CO2008SURETEC INS CO2007

10936Company Code:SENECA INS CO INC1995

10972Company Code:FIRST NET INS CO2008

10976Company Code:VIRGINIA HLTH SYSTEMS ALLIANCE RRG2008

10979Company Code:ELITE INS CO US BRANCH1995

11003Company Code:WVA INS CO2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners473

Page 482: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

11028Company Code:SPRING VALLEY MUT INS CO2008

11036Company Code:MCMILLAN WARNER MUT INS CO2008

11037Company Code:EVEREADY INS CO1995

11039Company Code:INJURED WORKERS INS FUND2008

11042Company Code:STONETRUST COMMERCIAL INS CO2008

11061Company Code:FARMERS FIRE INS CO1995

11075Company Code:GULF ATLANTIC INSURANCE CO1995

11078Company Code:SIMED2008

11101Company Code:HARTLAND MUT INS CO2008

11118Company Code:FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS EXCH2009FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS EXCH2008FEDERATED RURAL ELECTRIC INS CORP1995

11126Company Code:YASUDA FIRE & MARINE INS CO OF AMER1995

11149Company Code:MAINE EMPLOYERS MUT INS CO1995

11186Company Code:FAIRMONT FARMERS MUT INS CO2008

11231Company Code:GENERALI-US BRANCH1985

11259Company Code:COMMUNITY HOSPITAL RRG2008

11260Company Code:NEVADA MUT INS CO INC2008

11268Company Code:ICI MUT INS CO RRG2009

11304Company Code:GLOBAL SURETY & INS CO1995

11320Company Code:GOLD MEDAL INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners474

Page 483: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

11347Company Code:STATE FUND MUT INS CO1995

11398Company Code:GUARANTEE INS CO1995

11460Company Code:HOMESTEAD INS CO1995

11487Company Code:IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO1995IMPERIAL CAS & IND CO1985

11498Company Code:MDADVANTAGE INS CO OF NJ2008

11513Company Code:PHYSICIANS SPECIALTY LTD RRG2008

11530Company Code:HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS INS EXCH2008

11533Company Code:MID-ATLANTIC INS CORP1995

11535Company Code:CONVENTUS INTER INS EXCH2008

11539Company Code:NEW JERSEY PHYSICIANS UNITED RECIP2008

11544Company Code:CAREGIVERS UNITED LIAB INS CO RRG2008

11547Company Code:MOUNTAIN LAUREL RRG INC2008

11550Company Code:NEW YORK SURETY CO1995

11568Company Code:CONSTITUTIONAL CAS CO1995

11582Company Code:MISSOURI PROFESSIONALS MUT2008

11585Company Code:MOUNTAIN STATES HLTHCARE RECIP RRG2008

11592Company Code:INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO2009INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO2008INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO2007INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO2006INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO2005INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO1995INTERNATIONAL FIDELITY INS CO1990

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners475

Page 484: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

11598Company Code:APPLIED MEDICO LEGAL SOLUTIONS RRG2008

11668Company Code:COASTAL INS RRG INC2008

11669Company Code:SUPERIOR INS CO RRG2008

11683Company Code:HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS INS CO RRG2008

11692Company Code:INDIANA HLTHCARE RECIP RRG2008

11703Company Code:LACKAWANNA CAS CO1995

11704Company Code:PHYSICIANS PROFESSIONAL IND ASSN2008

11796Company Code:YELLOWSTONE INS EXCH RRG2008

11832Company Code:HEALTH CARE INDUSTRY LIAB RECIP INS2008

11835Company Code:PARIS RE AMER INS CO2008

11839Company Code:CIRCLE STAR INS CO RRG2008

11843Company Code:MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO1995MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO1990MEDICAL PROTECTIVE CO1985

11844Company Code:ST JOHNS INS CO INC2008

11854Company Code:HEALTHCARE UNDERWRITERS GRP OF KY2008

11860Company Code:COPIC INS CO2008COPIC INS CO1995

11872Company Code:KENTUCKIANA MEDICAL RECIP RRG2008

11878Company Code:MUTUALAID EXCHANGE2008

11894Company Code:MERCHANTS PROPERTY INS CO OF IN1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners476

Page 485: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

11932Company Code:MID-CONTINENT INS CO1995

11939Company Code:KENTUCKY HOSPITAL INS CO RRG2008

11964Company Code:MISSOURI DOCTORS MUT INS CO2008

11972Company Code:WEST VIRGINIA MUT INS CO2008

11983Company Code:MOTOR CLUB OF IA INS CO1995

11989Company Code:ADVOCATE MD INS OF THE SW INC2008

11998Company Code:HEARTLAND HLTHCARE RECIP RRG2008

12005Company Code:SENTINEL ASSUR RRG INC2008

12068Company Code:NATL GUARANTY INS CO1995

12150Company Code:FIRST FOUNDERS ASSUR CO2008

12153Company Code:PHYSICIANS PREFERRED INS CO2008

12190Company Code:NIPPONKOA INS CO OF AMERICA1995

12200Company Code:AMERICAN LIBERTY INS CO2008

12238Company Code:INTEGRAL INS CO1995

12260Company Code:CAMPMED CAS & IND CO INC MD2008CAMPMED CAS & IND CO INC MD1995

12263Company Code:HEALTH FUTURE INS EXCH RRG2008

12289Company Code:PERSONAL SERVICE INS CO1995

12296Company Code:WHITECAP SURETY CO2008

12297Company Code:PETROLEUM CAS CO2008PETROLEUM CAS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners477

Page 486: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12308Company Code:CIMARRON INS EXCH RRG2008

12332Company Code:PUERTO RICO MED DEFENSE MUT INS CO2008

12348Company Code:PINE TREE INS A RECIP RRG2008

12351Company Code:VOYAGEURS INS CO1995

12355Company Code:MD RRG INC2008

12360Company Code:OCEAN HARBOR CAS INS CO1995

12372Company Code:BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO2008BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO2007BRICKSTREET MUT INS CO2006

12373Company Code:CARING COMMUNITIES RECIP RRG2008

12378Company Code:GERMAN MUT INS CO1995

12441Company Code:FLORIDA DOCTORS INS CO2008

12459Company Code:MEDICA INSURANCE COMPANY1995

12472Company Code:LUBA CAS INS CO2008

12513Company Code:PROFESSIONAL LIAB INS CO OF AMER2008

12548Company Code:AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO2007AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO2006AMERICAN AGRI BUSINESS INS CO2005INSURANCE CO OF PRAIRIE STATES1995

12565Company Code:CONTINENTAL RISK INS CO2008

12573Company Code:ICAT SPECIALTY INS CO2008

12610Company Code:SOUTHERN TRUST INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners478

Page 487: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

12613Company Code:PREMIER PHYSICIANS INS CO INC A RRG2008

12633Company Code:CENTURY INS CO GU LTD2009CENTURY INS CO GU LTD2008CENTURY INS CO GU LTD2007

12645Company Code:STANDARD CAS CO1995

12670Company Code:PIONEER GENERAL INS CO1995

12754Company Code:MEDICUS INS CO2008

12779Company Code:MOUNTAINEER FREEDOM RRG INC2008

12793Company Code:SURETY CO OF THE PACIFIC1995

12838Company Code:INDEPENDENT NV DOCTORS INS EXCH2008

12841Company Code:AMERICAN INTEGRITY INS CO OF FL2008

12866Company Code:THE INS CO1995

12875Company Code:CARDINAL SELECT RRG INC2008

12900Company Code:VICTORY INS CO INC2008

12920Company Code:HOUSTON UNITED CAS INS CO1995

12939Company Code:TOWN & COUNTRY FIRE & CAS INS CO1995

12968Company Code:AMERICAN COASTAL INS CO2008

13013Company Code:ABBA IND CO1995

13030Company Code:COLONIAL CAS INS CO1995

13060Company Code:BUILDING INDUSTRY INS ASSN INC2008

13067Company Code:PROFESSIONALS RRG INC2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners479

Page 488: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

13101Company Code:MEDICAL MALPRACTICE JOINT UNDERWRITI2008

13121Company Code:PALMETTO SURETY CORP2008

13285Company Code:ALLEGHENY CAS CO2008ALLEGHENY CAS CO1995

13293Company Code:AMALGAMATED CAS INS CO2008AMALGAMATED CAS INS CO1995

13307Company Code:LEXON INS CO2006UNDERWRITERS IND CO1995

13323Company Code:AMERICAN FELLOWSHIP MUT INS CO1995

13350Company Code:ODS HEALTH PLAN1995

13366Company Code:AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2009AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2008AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2007AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2006AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2005AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT2000AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT1995AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT1990AMERICAN STEAMSHIP OWNERS MUT PROT1985

13374Company Code:ARROW MUT LIABILITY INS CO1995

13400Company Code:DELL USA CORPORATION1995

13412Company Code:AUSTIN MUT INS CO2009AUSTIN MUT INS CO2008AUSTIN MUT INS CO2007AUSTIN MUT INS CO2005

13420Company Code:BADGER MUT INS CO1995

13439Company Code:PARTNERS MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners480

Page 489: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

13445Company Code:FIRST NONPROFIT INS CO A RECIPROCAL1995

13471Company Code:BEAR RIVER MUT INS CO2008BEAR RIVER MUT INS CO1995

13501Company Code:BRETHREN MUT INS CO2008BRETHREN MUT INS CO1995

13528Company Code:BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2009BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2008BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2007BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2006BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2005BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO2000BROTHERHOOD MUT INS CO1995

13579Company Code:CHESTER COUNTY MUT INS CO1995

13587Company Code:CHICAGO MUT INS CO1995

13595Company Code:SPARTAN INS CO1995

13597Company Code:CHUNG KUO INS CO LTD2008

13598Company Code:KESWICK GUARANTY INC2008

13633Company Code:COLONIAL COOPERATIVE INS CO1995

13635Company Code:NIPPONKOA INS CO LTD2008

13641Company Code:COLORADO FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO2008COLORADO FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO1995

13650Company Code:EMPIRE LLOYDS INS CO1995

13668Company Code:COMMERCIAL MUT INS CO1995

13749Company Code:FARM BUREAU INS CO OF NE1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners481

Page 490: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

13757Company Code:FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF AR INC2008FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO OF AR INC1995

13781Company Code:US LLOYDS INS CO1995

13854Company Code:FARMERS MUT FIC OF SALEM CTY1995

13889Company Code:FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2009FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2008FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2007FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2006FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2005FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE2000FARMERS MUT INS CO OF NE1995

13893Company Code:COMMUNITY BLOOD CNTR EXCH RRG1995

13919Company Code:DRYDEN MUT INS CO1995

13927Company Code:DAWSON HAIL INS CO1995

13943Company Code:FITCHBURG MUT INS CO1995

13986Company Code:FRANKENMUTH MUT INS CO1995

13994Company Code:FREMONT INS CO2008FREMONT MUT INS CO1995

14010Company Code:CRUSADER INS CO1995

14028Company Code:GEORGIA MUT INS CO1995

14036Company Code:GERMANTOWN MUT INS CO1995

14044Company Code:GOODVILLE MUT CAS CO2008GOODVILLE MUT CAS CO1995

14087Company Code:GRANGERS MUTUAL INS CO1995

14095Company Code:GRANITE MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners482

Page 491: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

14125Company Code:HAMILTON MUT INS CO OF CINCINNATI1995

14176Company Code:HASTINGS MUT INS CO2009HASTINGS MUT INS CO2008HASTINGS MUT INS CO2007HASTINGS MUT INS CO2006HASTINGS MUT INS CO2005HASTINGS MUT INS CO2000HASTINGS MUT INS CO1995HASTINGS MUT INS CO1990HASTINGS MUT INS CO1985

14184Company Code:ACUITY A MUT INS CO2008

14206Company Code:HOLYOKE MUT INS CO IN SALEM1995

14214Company Code:HOME MUT INS CO OF BINGHAMTON NY1995

14222Company Code:CONTINENTAL AMERICAN INS CO1995

14257Company Code:IMT INS CO MUT1995

14281Company Code:INLAND MUT INS CO1995

14303Company Code:INTEGRITY MUT INS CO1995

14311Company Code:INTERBORO MUT IND INS CO1995

14320Company Code:DISTRIBUTORS INS CO1995

14354Company Code:JEWELERS MUT INS CO2009JEWELERS MUT INS CO2008JEWELERS MUT INS CO1995

14362Company Code:KANSAS MUT INS CO1995

14370Company Code:LEBANON MUT INS CO1995

14397Company Code:LINCOLN MUT CAS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners483

Page 492: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

14400Company Code:LITITZ MUT INS CO1995

14427Company Code:LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO2008LOUISIANA FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO1995

14443Company Code:MADISON MUT INS CO1995

14451Company Code:MARYSVILLE MUT INS CO2008MARYSVILLE MUT INS CO1995

14460Company Code:PODIATRY INS CO OF AMER RRG MUT CO1995

14465Company Code:MONTANA LOGGERS EXCHANGE1995

14486Company Code:MERCHANTS & BUSINESS MENS MUT INS CO1995

14494Company Code:MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL)2000MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL)1995MERCHANTS BONDING CO (MUTUAL)1990

14508Company Code:MICHIGAN MILLERS MUT INS CO1995

14524Company Code:MIDDLE GA MUT INS CO1995

14532Company Code:MIDDLESEX MUT ASSUR CO1995

14575Company Code:MILLERS MUT INS CO1995

14605Company Code:MISSISSIPPI FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO1995

14656Company Code:MUNICIPAL MUT INS CO2008MUNICIPAL MUT INS CO1995

14680Company Code:MUTUAL FIRE & AUTOMOBILE INS CO1995

14699Company Code:FIRST WASHINGTON INS CO INC1995

14753Company Code:FREDERICK MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners484

Page 493: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

14761Company Code:MUTUAL OF ENUMCLAW INS CO1995

14770Company Code:UNIVERSAL BONDING INS CO1995

14800Company Code:SALEM INS CO1995

14818Company Code:NEW CASTLE INS CO OF DE1995

14834Company Code:NEW YORK CENTRAL MUT FIRE INS CO1995

14885Company Code:NORTHWEST GF MUT INS CO2008NORTHWEST GF MUT INS CO1995

14915Company Code:OTSEGO MUT FIRE INS CO1995

14940Company Code:FIRST JERSEY CAS INS CO INC1995

14966Company Code:PENN MUT INS CO1995

14974Company Code:PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS2009PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS2008PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS2007PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS2006PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS2005PENNSYLVANIA LUMBERMENS MUT INS1995

15008Company Code:MS CAS INS CO1995MS CAS INS CO1990

15016Company Code:PIONEER MUTUTAL INSURANCE COMPANY1995

15024Company Code:PREFERRED MUT INS CO1995

15067Company Code:QUINCY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

15083Company Code:RETAIL LUMBERMENS MUT INS CO OF WI1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners485

Page 494: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

15091Company Code:RURAL MUT INS CO2009RURAL MUT INS CO2008RURAL MUT INS CO2007RURAL MUT INS CO2006RURAL MUT INS CO2005

15105Company Code:SAFETY NATL CAS CORP1995

15110Company Code:NEWPORT BONDING & SURETY CO2008NEWPORT BONDING & SURETY CO1995

15113Company Code:SECURITY MUT INS CO1995

15148Company Code:SHEBOYGAN FALLS MUT INS CO1995

15172Company Code:SOUTHERN MUT INS CO1995

15199Company Code:STANDARD MUT INS CO1995

15202Company Code:STATE MUTUAL INS CO1995

15210Company Code:STERLING INS CO1995

15261Company Code:SOCIETY INS2008

15296Company Code:UPLAND MUT INS INC2008UPLAND MUT INS INC1995

15326Company Code:UTICA FIRST INS CO1995

15334Company Code:UTILITIES MUT INS CO1995

15350Company Code:WEST BEND MUT INS CO1995

15393Company Code:WISCONSIN AMERICAN MUT INS CO1995

15407Company Code:WOLVERINE MUT INS CO2008WOLVERINE MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners486

Page 495: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

15458Company Code:DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON2009DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON2008DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON2007DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON2006DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON2005DELTA LLOYDS INS CO OF HOUSTON1995

15466Company Code:LLOYDS NEW YORK INSURANCE COMPANY1995

15512Company Code:AUTOMOBILE CLUB INTERINS EXCH1995

15539Company Code:CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS1995CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS1990CALIFORNIA STATE AUTO ASN INTER-INS1985

15555Company Code:COMMERCIAL FISHERMENS INTER-INS EXCH1995

15563Company Code:SEABRIGHT INS CO2008

15571Company Code:ILLINOIS CAS CO1995

15598Company Code:INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA1995INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA1990INTERINS EXCH-AUTO CLUB OF SO CA1985

15601Company Code:CHICAGO MOTOR CLUB INS CO1995

15625Company Code:PEOPLES SERVICES INS CO1995

15628Company Code:LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITERS1995

15636Company Code:LUTHERAN BENEVOLENT INS EXCHANGE INC1995

15638Company Code:ARISTA INS CO1995

15652Company Code:MIDWEST LUMBERMENS INTERINS EXCH1995

15660Company Code:MOTOR CLUB INS ASSOC1995

15679Company Code:NATIONAL FIRE & IND EXCH1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners487

Page 496: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

15709Company Code:SOUTHERN STATES INS EXCH1995

15768Company Code:MERCED MUT INS CO1995

15792Company Code:UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON2008UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON2005UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON1995UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON1990UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS LONDON1985

15814Company Code:GROWERS AUTOMOBILE INS ASSOC1995

15865Company Code:NCMIC INS CO1995

15881Company Code:BREMEN FARMERS MUT INS CO2008BREMEN FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

15890Company Code:CONNECTICUT MEDICAL INS CO2008CONNECTICUT MEDICAL INSURANCE CO1995

15911Company Code:AMERICAN MINING INS CO INC1995

15997Company Code:MMG INS CO2008MAINE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

16039Company Code:BALTIMORE EQUITABLE SOCIETY1995

16047Company Code:SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO2009SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO2008SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO2007SOUTHERN PIONEER PROP & CAS INS CO2006AMERICAN PIONEER PROPERTY INS CO1995

16055Company Code:FARMERS MUT FIRE INS CO OF DUG HILL2008FARMERS MUT F I C OF DUG HILL1995

16071Company Code:MUTUAL FIRE INS CO IN CALVERT CNTY1995

16098Company Code:MUTUAL FIRE INS CO OF CARROLL CTY1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners488

Page 497: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

16101Company Code:MI EDUCATIONAL EMPLOYEES MUT INS CO1995

16128Company Code:PARAMOUNT INS CO1995

16136Company Code:TANEYTOWN MUT FIC OF CARROL CTY1995

16152Company Code:NEWBURYPORT MUT FIRE INS CO1995

16250Company Code:UNITED FRONTIER MUT INS CO1995

16276Company Code:HOME FARMERS MUT INS ASSOC1995

16292Company Code:LAND OF LAKES MUT INS CO1995

16330Company Code:RAM MUT INS CO2008RAM MUT INS CO1995

16373Company Code:BATTLE CREEK MUT INS CO1995

16390Company Code:CHENANGO MUT INS CO1995

16411Company Code:COOPERATIVE MUT INS CO2008COOPERATIVE MUT INS CO1995

16446Company Code:FARMERS INS CO OF FLEMINGTON2008FARMERS INS CO OF FLEMINGTON1995

16489Company Code:ASSOCIATED MUT INS CO1995

16497Company Code:AZTEC INS CO2009AZTEC INS CO2008AZTEC INS CO2007AZTEC INS CO2006AZTEC INS CO2005AZTEC INS CO2000AZTEC INS CO1995

16519Company Code:ALLIANCE GENERAL INS CO1995

16543Company Code:MONTFORT INSURANCE COMPANY1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners489

Page 498: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

16616Company Code:AMERICAN TRANSIT INS CO2008

16624Company Code:PENINSULA PROPERTY/CASUALTY COMPANY1995

16632Company Code:TYVOLA INS CO1995

16683Company Code:NORTH CAROLINA GRANGE MUT INS CO2008NORTH CAROLINA GRANGE MUT INS CO1995

16705Company Code:DEALERS ASSUR CO2009DEALERS ASSUR CO2008DEALERS ASSUR CO2007

16748Company Code:ELEVATORS MUT INS CO1995

16764Company Code:MIAMI MUT INS CO1995

16799Company Code:WAYNE MUT INS CO1995

16845Company Code:ASHLAND MUT FIRE INS CO OF PA1995

16861Company Code:BAKERSTOWN MUT FIRE INS CO1995

16870Company Code:GRANADA INS CO1995

16888Company Code:BEDFORD COUNTY GRANGE MUTUAL INS CO1995

16896Company Code:BOYERTOWN MUT INS CO1995

16918Company Code:BRIAR CRK MUT INS CO1995

16926Company Code:ARECA INS EXCH2008ARECA INS EXCH1995

16934Company Code:BUCKS CNTY CONTRIBUTIONSHIP1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners490

Page 499: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

16942Company Code:MMIC INS INC2009MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO2008MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO2007MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO2006MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO2005MIDWEST MEDICAL INS CO1995

16950Company Code:BIRMINGHAM INS CO INC1995

16969Company Code:CLEARFIELD CTY GRNGE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

16985Company Code:CONEMAUGH VALLEY MUT INS CO1995

17043Company Code:EVERETT CASH MUT INS CO2008EVERETT CASH MUT INS CO1995

17078Company Code:FARMERS ALLI & IND UNION MU FIRE I C1995

17086Company Code:FARMERS & MECHANICS MUT INS CO1995

17094Company Code:FARMERS MUT FIRE INS CO OF MARBLE1995

17108Company Code:FARMERS MUT F I C OF MCCANDLESS1995

17116Company Code:FARMERS MUT F I C OF SCHUYLKILL1995

17124Company Code:FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

17140Company Code:FRANCONIA MENNONITE AID PLAN FOR M F1995

17167Company Code:FREEHOLD MUT INS CO1995

17175Company Code:FRIENDS COVE MUT INS CO1995

17191Company Code:GRANGE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17213Company Code:EVER-GREENE MUT INS CO1995

17256Company Code:HANNAHSTOWN MUT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners491

Page 500: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

17264Company Code:HANOVER MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17299Company Code:MENNONITE MUT INS CO1995

17329Company Code:JUNIATA MUT INS CO1995

17335Company Code:PIEDMONT MUT INS CO1995

17337Company Code:HANOVER FIRE & CAS INS CO2008PHILANTHROPIC MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17426Company Code:MENDON GRANGE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17434Company Code:MENNONITE MUT INS ASSN1995

17450Company Code:MILLVILLE MUT INS CO2008MILLVILLE MUT INS CO1995

17469Company Code:MONTOUR MUT INS CO1995

17477Company Code:MUTUAL FIRE INS CO OF S BEND TWNSHP1995

17485Company Code:MUTUAL INS CO OF LEHIGH CNTY1995

17493Company Code:NAZARETH MUT INS CO2009NAZARETH MUT INS CO1995

17507Company Code:LAKELAND INS CO1995

17515Company Code:NORTH WESTERN MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17531Company Code:OLD ELIZABETH MUT F I C1995

17566Company Code:PARADISE MUT INS CO1995

17574Company Code:PATRONS MUT FIRE ASSOC OF NW PA1995

17582Company Code:PATRONS MUT FIRE INS CO OF IN PA1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners492

Page 501: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

17620Company Code:PENN CHARTER MUT INS CO1995

17647Company Code:UNITED HOME INS CO2008

17701Company Code:PYMATUNING MUT FIRE INS CO1995

17710Company Code:ALABAMA MUNICIPAL INS CORP2008ALABAMA MUNICIPAL INS CORP1995

17728Company Code:REAMSTOWN MUT INS CO1995

17736Company Code:SAUCON MUT INS CO1995

17744Company Code:SEAWAY MUT INS CO1995

17760Company Code:SOUTHWESTERN MUT FIRE ASSOC1995

17779Company Code:GUARDIAN INS CO INC1995

17817Company Code:TRI COUNTY MENNONITE MUT INS CO1995

17825Company Code:TUSCARORA WAYNE MUT INS CO1995

17833Company Code:UNION MUT I C OF WESTMORELAND CTY1995

17868Company Code:WALLROSE MUT INS CO1995

17876Company Code:WASHINGTON MUT FIRE OF LAWRENCE CTY1995

17884Company Code:GERMAN MUT INS CO2008GERMAN MUT INS CO1995

17892Company Code:WEST BRANCH MUT INS CO1995

17906Company Code:WHITE HALL MUT INS CO1995

17922Company Code:YORKTOWNE INS CO1995

17990Company Code:TRI CENTURY INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners493

Page 502: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

18007Company Code:CLOISTER MUT CAS INS CO1995

18074Company Code:COCALICO MUT INS CO1995

18090Company Code:SOUTHERN HERITAGE INS CO1995

18104Company Code:ANTHRACITE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

18147Company Code:COMPANIA DE FIANZAS DE PR1995

18160Company Code:SAVANT INSURANCE CO1995

18163Company Code:COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR2000COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR1995COOPERATIVA D SEGUROS MULTIPLES PR1990

18201Company Code:DECATUR INS CO INC1995

18228Company Code:FARMERS HOME MUT FIRE INS CO1995

18236Company Code:AGENTS MUT INS CO1995

18252Company Code:TOWN & COUNTRY MUT INS CO1995

18309Company Code:PIONEER STATE MUT INS CO2008PIONEER STATE MUT INS CO1995

18350Company Code:CUMBERLAND SURETY INS CO INC1995

18376Company Code:HERMITAGE INS CO1995

18380Company Code:PACIFIC IND INS CO2008PACIFIC IND INS CO1995

18406Company Code:SPARTAN PROP INS CO1995

18430Company Code:AGRICULTURAL WORKERS MUT AUTO INS1995

18449Company Code:DALLAS FIRE INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners494

Page 503: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

18457Company Code:GRANGE MUTUAL FIRE INS CO OF ID1995

18468Company Code:INDEMNITY NATL INS CO2008

18538Company Code:BANCINSURE INC2009BANCINSURE INC2008BANCINSURE INC2007BANCINSURE INC2006BANCINSURE INC2005BANCINSURE INC2000BANCINSURE INC1995BANCINSURE INC1990

18597Company Code:SLAVONIC MUT FIRE INS ASSOC1995

18686Company Code:CO OPERATIVE INS CO2008COOPERATIVE FIRE INS ASSOC OF VT1995

18694Company Code:GREAT MIDWEST INS CO1995

18708Company Code:AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP1995AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP1990AMBAC INDEMNITY CORP1985

18767Company Code:CHURCH MUT INS CO2009CHURCH MUT INS CO2008CHURCH MUT INS CO2007CHURCH MUT INS CO2006CHURCH MUT INS CO2005CHURCH MUT INS CO1995

18791Company Code:VIRGINIA MUT INS CO1995

18813Company Code:DENTISTS BENEFITS INS CO1995

18939Company Code:UNITED HERITAGE PROP & CAS CO1995

18945Company Code:PINE CREEK MUT FIRE INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners495

Page 504: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

19020Company Code:BELL UNITED INS CO2008BELL UNITED INS CO1995

19090Company Code:WOODLAND INS CO OF MN1995

19119Company Code:NATIONAL UNITY INS CO2008NATIONAL UNITY INS CO1995

19160Company Code:OLD LYME INS CO OF RI INC1995

19623Company Code:AMERICAN SUMMIT INS CO1995

19780Company Code:SPRINGFIELD FIRE & CAS CO1995

19870Company Code:CAPITAL CAS INS1995

19941Company Code:AMERICAN COMMERCE INS CO1995

19950Company Code:WILSON MUT INS CO1995

20150Company Code:AMTEX INSURANCE COMPANY1995

20311Company Code:SYNCORA GUAR INC2008

20320Company Code:COLUMBIA LLOYDS INS CO1995

20362Company Code:SUMITOMO MAR & FIRE INS CO OF AMER1995

20419Company Code:PLAINS INS CO1995

20516Company Code:AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO1995AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO1990AMERICAN CREDIT INDEMNITY CO1985

20656Company Code:CAREAMERICA HLTH COMP & LIAB INS CO1995

20690Company Code:NEW YORK MUNICIPAL INS RECIPROCAL1995

20800Company Code:SOUTHLAND LLOYDS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners496

Page 505: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

20818Company Code:COMMERCIAL INS CO OF NEWARK NJ1995

20877Company Code:CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP1995CAPITAL MARKETS ASSR CORP1990

21172Company Code:VANLINER INS CO1995

21261Company Code:ELECTRIC INS CO2009

21270Company Code:TRANSIT MUT INS CORP OF WI1995

21300Company Code:US SECURITY INS CO1995

21431Company Code:UNDERWRITERS GUARANTEE INS CO1995

21560Company Code:COMMERCE MUT INS CO INC1995

21640Company Code:CM INS CO INC1995

21733Company Code:FARMERS MUT PROTECTIVE ASN OF TX1995

21790Company Code:DEROYAL INS CO INC1995

22020Company Code:WI LAWYERS MUT INS CO1995

22050Company Code:PALISADES SAFETY & INS ASSOC1995

22110Company Code:EVEREST SECURITY INS CO1995

22250Company Code:PATHFINDER INS CO1995

22350Company Code:LOUISIANA WORKERS COMP CORP2008LOUISIANA WORKERS COMP CORP1995

22390Company Code:WELLINGTON INS CO1995

22551Company Code:TAISHO MARINE & FIRE INS CO1995

22624Company Code:INDIANA FARMERS MUT INS CO2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners497

Page 506: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

22635Company Code:DISCOVERY INS CO1995

22670Company Code:ATTORNEYS INS MUT RRG INC1995

22870Company Code:ONTARIO INS CO1995

22896Company Code:ACA FIN GUAR CORP2009ACA FIN GUAR CORP2008ACA FIN GUAR CORP2007ACA FIN GUAR CORP2006ACA FIN GUAR CORP2005ACA FINANCIAL GAURANTY CORP2000

22900Company Code:LOUISIANA PEST CONTROL INS CO1995

22930Company Code:MARKET TRANSITION FACILITY1995

22945Company Code:TEXAS MUT INS CO2009TEXAS MUT INS CO2008TEXAS MUT INS CO2007TEXAS MUT INS CO2006TEXAS MUT INS CO2005TEXAS MUT INS CO2000TEXAS MUT INS CO1995

22950Company Code:ACSTAR INS CO2008ACSTAR INS CO1995

23051Company Code:FOUNDATION RESERVE INS CO INC1995

23060Company Code:TRI-STATE CONSUMER INS CO1995

23108Company Code:LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE2008LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE2007LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE2006LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE2005LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE2000LUMBERMENS UNDERWRITING ALLIANCE1995

23137Company Code:PHC HEALTH INS CO INC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners498

Page 507: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

23140Company Code:ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES INS CO1995

23177Company Code:AMERICAN HOME SHIELD OF NV INC1995

23191Company Code:AMERICAN SHIPBLDRS & SHIPOWNERS MUT1995

23221Company Code:TRANSPORTATION MUT INS CO1995

23230Company Code:ALLIANCE MUT INS CO1995

23424Company Code:INDEPENDENT RECIPROCAL EXCH1995

23479Company Code:NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC2009NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC2008NATIONAL HOME WARRANTY INC1995

23558Company Code:ILLINOIS INS CO1995

23574Company Code:MIDWEST FAMILY MUT INS CO2008MIDWEST FAMILY MUT INS CO1995

23663Company Code:NATIONAL AMER INS CO2008NATIONAL AMERICAN INS CO1995

23770Company Code:AUTOMOTIVE CAS INS CO1995

23820Company Code:GREAT NORTHWEST INS CO1995

24017Company Code:BEACON MUT INS CO1995

24058Company Code:SURPLUS UNDERWRITERS CAS INS CO1995

24180Company Code:NATIONAL FAMILY INS CORP1995

24309Company Code:HEREFORD INS CO2008HEREFORD INS CO1995

24422Company Code:LEGION INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners499

Page 508: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

24520Company Code:LAWYERS MUT INS CO OF KY1995

24568Company Code:PING AN IN (USA) CO LTD1995

24619Company Code:TRANSPORTATION CAS INS CO1995

24651Company Code:US CAPITAL INS CO1995

24660Company Code:CUMBERLAND CAS & SURETY CO1995

24830Company Code:CITIES & VILLAGES MUT INS CO1995

24961Company Code:CONNIE LEE INS CO1995

25100Company Code:COASTAL INS EXCH1995

25123Company Code:DEPENDABLE PROTECTIVE MUT I C RRG IN1995

25240Company Code:NAU COUNTRY INS CO2009NAU COUNTRY INS CO2008NAU COUNTRY INS CO2007NAU COUNTRY INS CO2006NAU COUNTRY INS CO2005

25275Company Code:STATE-WIDE INS CO1995

25291Company Code:ARDI EXCH RRG1995

25330Company Code:PATTERSON INS CO1995

25394Company Code:ISLA INS CO1995

25405Company Code:SAFE AUTO INS CO1995

25448Company Code:AMERICAN SAFETY RRG INC1995

25500Company Code:CHAMPLAIN CAS CO OF VT1995

25585Company Code:PROFESSIONALS DIRECT INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners500

Page 509: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

25690Company Code:K-M INS CO1995

25739Company Code:PIC INSURANCE GROUP INC1995

25740Company Code:FINANCIAL SERVICES MUT INS CO RRG1995

25755Company Code:PEACHTREE CAS INS CO1995

25771Company Code:CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC2008CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC2007CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC2006CIFG ASSUR N AMER INC2005

25780Company Code:WILLIAMSBURG NATL INS CO1995

25887Company Code:US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO1995US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO1990US FIDELITY & GUARANTY CO1985

25917Company Code:EXECUTIVE INS CO1995

25950Company Code:CASCO IND CO1995

26077Company Code:LANCER INS CO1995

26166Company Code:WINDSOR MOUNT JOY MUT INS CO2008

26174Company Code:SECURITY IND INS CO1995

26257Company Code:MEDAMERICA MUT RRG INC2008EMPAC MUTUAL RISK RETENTION GRP INC1995

26275Company Code:AMERICAN NATL LAWYERS INS RCPL RRG1995

26310Company Code:GRANITE RE INC2008GRANITE RE INC1995

26352Company Code:FIRST EMPLOYEES INS CO1995

26379Company Code:ACCREDITED SURETY & CAS CO INC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners501

Page 510: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

26433Company Code:HARCO NATL INS CO1995

26468Company Code:SOUTHERN MUT CHURCH INS CO2008SOUTHERN MUT CHURCH INS CO1995

26565Company Code:OHIO IND CO2009OHIO IND CO2008OHIO IND CO2006OHIO IND CO2005OHIO IND CO1995

26590Company Code:SPECTRUM GENERAL INS CO1995

26735Company Code:MOUNT CARROLL MUT FIRE INS CO1995

26760Company Code:FULMONT MUT INS CO1995

26778Company Code:INTEGRAND ASSUR CO2008

26797Company Code:HOUSING AUTHORITY RRG INC1995

26808Company Code:GULF STATES INS CO1995

26818Company Code:MIDSTATE MUT INS CO1995

26824Company Code:SUBLIMITY INS CO1995

26826Company Code:WASATCH FIRE INS CO1995

26835Company Code:MIDROX INS CO2008MIDROX INS CO1995

26905Company Code:CENTURY NATL INS CO2008CENTURY-NATL INS CO2000CENTURY-NATL INS CO1995

26956Company Code:WISCONSIN COUNTY MUT INS CORP1995

27014Company Code:MUTUAL FIRE & STORM INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners502

Page 511: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

27022Company Code:WISCONSIN MUT INS CO1995

27065Company Code:ROCKFORD MUT INS CO1995

27073Company Code:NIPPONKOA INS CO LTD U.S. BRANCH1995

27081Company Code:BOND SAFEGUARD INS CO2007BOND SAFEGUARD INS CO1995

27170Company Code:TEXAS BUILDERS INS CO1995

27197Company Code:APOLLO MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27200Company Code:CAMBRIA COUNTY MUT INS CO1995

27219Company Code:CENTER VALLEY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27235Company Code:AUTO CLUB FAMILY INS CO1995

27278Company Code:PROTECTION MUT INS CO1995

27332Company Code:CANONSBURG MUT FIRE INS CO2006CANONSBURG MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27340Company Code:CENTRE COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27359Company Code:CLARION COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27375Company Code:ELK COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27391Company Code:HUSBANDMANS MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27405Company Code:LOCUST MUTUAL FIRE INS CO1995

27480Company Code:MID-STATE MUT INS CO1995

27499Company Code:SOUTHWEST GEN INS CO2008LLOYDS OF THE SOUTHWEST1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners503

Page 512: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

27502Company Code:WESTERN GENERAL INS CO1995

27529Company Code:LAUNDRY OWNERS MUT LIAB INS ASN1995

27588Company Code:ASSOCIATED INDUSTRIES FL P & C TRUST1995

27596Company Code:LR INS INC1995

27626Company Code:FIRSTCOMP INS CO2008

27645Company Code:ST JUDES PROTECTIVE ASSN INC1995

27650Company Code:SHAMOKIN TOWNSHIP MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27685Company Code:STONE VALLEY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

27723Company Code:REAMSTOWN MUTL FIRE INS CO1995

27740Company Code:NORTH POINTE INS CO1995

27766Company Code:MISSOURI VALLEY MUT INS CO1995

27880Company Code:WISCONSIN MUNICIPAL MUT INS CO1995

27905Company Code:NLC MUT INS CO1995

27928Company Code:AMEX ASSUR CO2009AMEX ASSUR CO2008AMEX ASSUR CO2007

27938Company Code:CNP INSURANCE CO1995

27952Company Code:HOOSIER MOTOR MUT INS CO1995

27980Company Code:FEDERATED NATL INS CO1995

28010Company Code:ABBEY CAS INS CO OF DC1995

28053Company Code:UNITED COASTAL INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners504

Page 513: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

28126Company Code:INTERSTATE BANKERS CAS CO1995

28134Company Code:LUTHERAN MUT FIRE INS CO1995

28185Company Code:PARADIGM INS CO1995

28209Company Code:MOHAWK MINDEN INS CO1995

28225Company Code:CONTRACTORS CAS & SURETY CO1995

28231Company Code:FIDELIO INS CO1995

28240Company Code:SERVICE INS CO1995

28258Company Code:CONTINENTAL NATL IND CO1995

28274Company Code:SECURITY INDUSTRIAL FIRE INS CO1995

28290Company Code:PATRONS-OXFORD MUTUAL INS CO1995

28339Company Code:GATEWAY INS CO1995

28371Company Code:INDEPENDENT RECIPROCAL EXCH1995

28380Company Code:AGRI INS EXCH RRG1995

28436Company Code:FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO2008FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO1995

28479Company Code:SUNAPEE MUT FIRE INS CO1995

28495Company Code:BUTTE MUT INS CO1995

28497Company Code:USPLATE GLASS INS CO1995

28517Company Code:VICTORE INS CO2008VICTORE INS CO1995

28519Company Code:MOUNTBATTEN SURETY COMPNAY INC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners505

Page 514: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

28535Company Code:TRIANGLE INS CO INC1995

28550Company Code:HOUSING & REDEVELOPMENT INS EXCH1995

28568Company Code:NEW YORK MERCHANT BANKERS INS CO1995

28576Company Code:ASSOCIATED PHYSICIANS INS CO1995

28606Company Code:LIVINGSTON MUT INS CO1995

28614Company Code:COMMERCIAL INDEMNITY INSURANCE CO1995

28681Company Code:UNION MUT INS CO2008UNION MUT INS CO1995

28711Company Code:PCA PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO1995

28720Company Code:COLORADO WESTERN INS CO1995

28738Company Code:FARMERS MUT F I C OF OKARCHE1995

28746Company Code:EQUITY FIRE & CASUALTY CO1995

28800Company Code:INSURANCE CORP OF AMER1995

28835Company Code:LAWYERS PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY EXCH1995

28843Company Code:SPECIALTY LLOYDS INS CO1995

28860Company Code:PLANET IND CO1995

28886Company Code:TRANSGUARD INS CO OF AMER INC1995

28924Company Code:GARDEN STATE IND CO INC1995

29033Company Code:VICTORIA INS CO1995

29050Company Code:REGENCY INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners506

Page 515: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

29297Company Code:HOME STATE CNTY MUT INS CO1995

29319Company Code:AMERICAN NATL COUNTY MUT INS CO1995

29343Company Code:NATIONAL COUNTY MUTUAL FIRE INS CO1985

29378Company Code:OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2009OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2008OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2007OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2006OLD AMER CNTY MUT FIRE INS CO2005

29440Company Code:MOUNTAIN W FARM BUREAU MUT INS CO2008MOUNTAIN WEST FARM BU MUT INS CO1995

29467Company Code:PROTECTION MUT INS CO1995PROTECTION MUT INS CO1990PROTECTION MUT INS CO1985

29483Company Code:LA REUNION FRANCAISE US BRANCH1995

29491Company Code:FINANCIAL INS CO OF AMER1995

29505Company Code:NEW JERSEY ASN FOR INS OF HOUSES1995

29513Company Code:THE BAR PLAN MUT INS CO1995

29521Company Code:SALEM COUNTY MUT FIRE INS CO1995

29530Company Code:NORDSTERN INS CO OF AMERICA1995

29548Company Code:WESTERN IND INS CO1995

29610Company Code:GERMANIA FARM MUT INS ASSOC1990

29629Company Code:NAMIC INS CO INC1995

29637Company Code:PSYCHIATRISTS RISK RETENTION GRP INC1995

29645Company Code:PARK GLEN NATL INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners507

Page 516: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

29670Company Code:CHERRY VALLEY COOPERATIVE INS CO1995

29734Company Code:BOWLING PROPRIETORS INS CORP INC1995

29750Company Code:KODIAK INS CO1995

29769Company Code:CAPITOL CAS CO1995

29831Company Code:INDEPENDENT MUT FIRE INS CO2008INDEPENDENT MUT FIRE INS CO1995

29840Company Code:PATCO ASSURANCE1995

29947Company Code:WESTERN GROWERS INS CO1995

29955Company Code:LEGAL MUT LIAB INS SOCIETY OF MD1995

30031Company Code:PREFERRED SURETY CORP1995

30082Company Code:CPA INS CO2008CPA INS CO1995

30139Company Code:MLBA MUT INS CO1995

30147Company Code:BARABOO MUT FIRE INS CO1995

30155Company Code:NATIONAL INS CO OF WI INS1995

30175Company Code:ORISKA INS CO1995

30201Company Code:EASTERN MUT INS CO1995

30228Company Code:LAKELAND MUT INS CO1995

30317Company Code:HOSPITALS INS CO INC2009HOSPITALS INS CO INC2008HANYS INS CO2000HANYS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners508

Page 517: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

30341Company Code:FARMERS & MERCHANTS MUT FIRE INS CO2008FARMERS AND MERCH MUT FIRE INS CO1995

30350Company Code:OTSEGO CO PATRONS COOP FIRE RELIEF1995

30368Company Code:FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

30376Company Code:NORTHERN MUT INS CO1995

30384Company Code:GREAT LAKES MUT INS CO1995

30430Company Code:SANILAC MUT INS CO1995

30449Company Code:MADISON MUT INS CO1995

30457Company Code:SOUTHERN MI MUT INS CO1995

30465Company Code:UPPER PENINSULA MUT INS CO1995

30520Company Code:POLICYHOLDERS MUT INS CO1995

30570Company Code:PACIFIC RIM ASSURANCE CO1995

30589Company Code:CAPITAL CITY INS CO INC1995

30619Company Code:INDEPENDENT MUT FIRE INS CO OF MO1995

30635Company Code:NORTH AMERICAN TRANSPORT INS CO1995

30643Company Code:EXCHANGE INS CO1995

30651Company Code:FARMERS MUT OF TN1995

30732Company Code:CROP INS PROTECTIVE ASSN1995

30805Company Code:FARM CREDIT SYSTEM ASSN CAPTIVE INS2008

30821Company Code:OAK CASUALTY INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners509

Page 518: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

30880Company Code:WASHINGTON MUT FIRE & STORM INS1995

30902Company Code:ALPINE INS CO1995

30910Company Code:HARMONY INS CO1995

30945Company Code:NATIONAL ALLIANCE INS CO1995NATIONAL ALLIANCE INS CO1990

30970Company Code:ALLEGANY CO-OP INS CO2008ALLEGANY CO-OP INS CO1995

31020Company Code:EMPLOYERS PROTECTIVE INS CO1995

31062Company Code:IFA INS CO1995

31186Company Code:BALDWIN MUT INS CO2008BALDWIN MUT INS CO1995

31224Company Code:HANYS MEMBER HOSP SELF INS TRUST1995

31240Company Code:COMMONWEALTH MUT INS CO OF AMER2008COMMONWEALTH INS CO1995

31259Company Code:FARMERS MECH MUT INS ASN CECIL CTY1995

31267Company Code:YORK INSURANCE COMPANY OF MAINE1995

31280Company Code:NORTH AMERICAN IND CO1995

31307Company Code:COMPENSATION MUTUAL INSURANCE CO1995

31364Company Code:NUCLEAR MUT LTD1995NUCLEAR MUT LTD1990

31380Company Code:AMERICAN SURETY CO1995

31402Company Code:AMERICAN MEDICAL INS EXCH1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners510

Page 519: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

31429Company Code:MICHIGAN PROFESSIONAL INS EXCH2008BUTTERWORTH INS EXCHANGE1995

31453Company Code:FINANCIAL PACIFIC INS CO1995

31550Company Code:HAULERS INS CO INC1995

31593Company Code:NORTHERN CAS CO1995

31658Company Code:ZURICH INS (GUAM) INC1995

31755Company Code:MIDWEST SECURITY INS CO1995

31780Company Code:MAPLE VALLEY MUT INS CO1995

31887Company Code:COFACE N AMER INS CO2009COFACE N AMER INS CO2008COFACE N AMER INS CO2007COFACE N AMER INS CO2006COFACE N AMER INS CO2005

31968Company Code:MERASTAR INS CO1995

32005Company Code:EMPLOYERS SECURITY INS CO1995

32069Company Code:BLUE ALLIANCE MUT INS CO1995

32085Company Code:LITCHFIELD MUT FIRE INS CO1995

32107Company Code:SUTTER INS CO2009SUTTER INS CO2008

32182Company Code:MIDWESTERN LIABILITY INS RRG1995

32247Company Code:MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO1995MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO1990MEDICAL LIABILITY MUT INS CO1985

32387Company Code:STAR CAS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners511

Page 520: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

32450Company Code:ATTORNEYS LIAB PROTECTION SOC RRG2008ATTORNEYS LIAB PROTECTION SOC RRG1995

32468Company Code:MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INS ASN1995MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INS ASN1990MEDICAL MALPRACTICE INS ASN1985

32506Company Code:MONROE GUARANTY INS CO1995

32514Company Code:TEXAS HOSPITAL INS EXCH1995

32530Company Code:TRANSWORLD INS CO INC1995

32557Company Code:AMERICAN PHYSICIANS INS CO2008AMERICAN PHYSICIANS INS EXCH1995

32573Company Code:OHIO FAIR PLAN UNDERWRITING ASSOC1995

32670Company Code:FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO2008FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO1995

32689Company Code:PETROSURANCE CAS CO1995

32697Company Code:TEXAS MEDICAL LIAB INS UNDWRITING AS2008TEXAS MEDICAL LIAB INS UNDWRG ASSOC1995

32727Company Code:UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS2008UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS2007UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS1995UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYDS1985

32735Company Code:FIRST DE INS CO1995

32743Company Code:ALLIANCE MUT INS CO1995

32760Company Code:MOBILE USA INS CO1995

32778Company Code:WASHINGTON INTL INS CO1995WASHINGTON INTL INS CO1990WASHINGTON INTL INS CO1985

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners512

Page 521: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

32832Company Code:MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ2009MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ2008MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ2007MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ2006MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ2005MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ1995MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ1990MUTUAL INS CO OF AZ1985

32867Company Code:UNIVERSAL FIRE & CAS INS CO1995

32875Company Code:BRITISH AMER INS CO1995

32921Company Code:ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH1995ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH1990ILLINOIS STATE MED INTERINS EXCH1985

32930Company Code:CAPACITY INS CO1995

32972Company Code:UNIVERSAL INS CO1995

33049Company Code:STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2009STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2008STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2007STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2006STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2005STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO2000STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO1995STATE VOLUNTEER MUT INS CO1990

33073Company Code:HERITAGE MUT INS CO1995

33111Company Code:MICHIGAN HOSPITAL ASN INS CO1995

33170Company Code:PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO2000PRODUCERS LLOYDS INS CO1995

33200Company Code:NORCAL MUT INS CO1995NORCAL MUT INS CO1990NORCAL MUT INS CO1985

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners513

Page 522: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

33227Company Code:NEW MEXICO PHYSICIANS MUTUAL LIAB CO1995

33383Company Code:FIRST PROFESSIONALS INS CO1995

33405Company Code:WISCONSIN HLTH CARE LIAB INS PLAN2008WISCONSIN HEALTH CARE LIAB INS PLAN1995

33448Company Code:FARMERS MUT FIRE INS OF BRANCH CNTY1995

33472Company Code:FCCI COMMERCIAL INS CO1995

33499Company Code:DORINCO REINS CO2008DORINCO REIN CO2000DORINCO REIN CO1995

33502Company Code:MACHINERY INS INC ASSESSABLE MUT CO1995

33537Company Code:PENNSYLVANIA PROF LIAB JUA1995

33545Company Code:SEMINOLE CAS INS CO1995

33561Company Code:SAFECARD SERVICE INS CO1995

33669Company Code:CONDOR INS CO1995

33677Company Code:ATTORNEYS INS MUT OF AL INC1995

33758Company Code:MASSACHUSETTS EMPLOYERS INS EXCH1995

33812Company Code:VIRGINIA INS RECIP OF RICHMOND VA1995

33928Company Code:PIE MUT INS CO1995

34002Company Code:TRANS CITY CAS INS CO1995

34029Company Code:MICHIGAN BASIC PROP INS ASSN2008MICHIGAN BASIC PROPERTY INS ASN1995

34118Company Code:PREFERRED NATL INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners514

Page 523: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

34142Company Code:AMERICAN JUSTICE INS RECIPROCAL RRG1995

34150Company Code:FLORIDA LAWYERS MUT INS CO1995

34169Company Code:COMMONWEALTH INS CO1995

34215Company Code:NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD2008NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD2000NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD1995NUCLEAR ELECTRIC INS LTD1990

34223Company Code:GROUP COUNCIL MUT INS CO1995

34231Company Code:HEALTHCARE UNDERWRITERS MUTUAL I C1995

34240Company Code:INLAND AMER INS CO1995

34282Company Code:OAK BROOK PROPERTY & CASUALTY INS CO1995

34355Company Code:EL FENIX DE PR-COMPANIA DE SEGUROS1995

34398Company Code:MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ1995MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ1990MEDICAL INTER-INS EXCH OF NJ1985

34509Company Code:RIDER INS CO1995

34517Company Code:HARBOUR INS INC1995

34525Company Code:FIRST AMERICAN SPECILATY INS CO1995

34541Company Code:ALLEGHENY SURETY CO1995

34568Company Code:CENTENNIAL CAS CO2008CENTENNIAL CAS CO2006CENTENNIAL CAS CO2005CENTENNIAL CAS CO2000CENTENNIAL CAS CO1995

34576Company Code:WORKERS COMP EXCH1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners515

Page 524: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

34584Company Code:LICENSED BEVERAGE INS EXCH1995

34592Company Code:NODAK MUT INS CO2000NODAK MUT INS CO1995

34606Company Code:CENTER MUT INS CO2008CENTER MUT INS CO1995

34657Company Code:HOSPITAL CAS CO1995

34681Company Code:MEDICAL PFL LIAB CATASTROP LOSS FUND1990MEDICAL PFL LIAB CATASTROP LOSS FUND1985

34703Company Code:KANSAS MEDICAL MUT INS CO2008KANSAS MEDICAL MUT INS CO1995

34711Company Code:COMPUTER INS CO1995

34738Company Code:ARAG INS CO2009ARAG INS CO2008ARAG INS CO2007ARAG INS CO1995

34843Company Code:NEW YORK SCHOOLS INS RECIP2008NEW YORK SCHOOLS INS RECIPROCAL1995

34886Company Code:CHIYODA FIRE & MARINE INS CO OF AM1995

34932Company Code:CONSOLIDATED PROP & CAS INS CO INC1995

34975Company Code:LIBERTY SOUTHERN INS CO INC1995

35009Company Code:FINANCIAL CAS & SURETY INC1995

35025Company Code:US INSURORS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners516

Page 525: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

35076Company Code:STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2009STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2008STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2007STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2006STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2005STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND2000STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND1995STATE COMPENSATION INS FUND1990

35114Company Code:PENNSYLVANIA MED SOC LIAB INS CO1995

35173Company Code:AGENCY INS CO OF MARYLAND INC1995

35246Company Code:LAURIER IND CO1995

35360Company Code:GIBRALTAR NATL INS CO1995

35483Company Code:DAILY UNDERWRITERS OF AMER1995

35513Company Code:HAA OF VIRGINIA INC1995

35548Company Code:AMERICAN TRANSPORTATION INS CO INC1995

35564Company Code:SUNBELT INS CO1995

35602Company Code:OHIC INS CO1995

35629Company Code:ASSOCIATION CASUALTY1995

35653Company Code:MEDICAL LIAB MUT INS CO OF NE1995

35700Company Code:UNITED ONE HOME PROTECTION CORP VA1995

35718Company Code:PHICO INS CO1995PHICO INS CO1990PHICO INS CO1985

35831Company Code:POLICYHOLDERS BENEFIT CORP2000POLICYHOLDERS BENEFIT CORP1995POLICYHOLDERS BENEFIT CORP1990

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners517

Page 526: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

35858Company Code:COMPANION INC2008COMPANION INC1995

35866Company Code:MID-HUDSON CO-OPERATIVE INS CO1995

35874Company Code:OLD HICKORY CAS INS CO1990

35904Company Code:HEALTH CARE IND INC2008HEALTH CARE IND INC2006HEALTH CARE IND INC2005HEALTH CARE IND INC2000HEALTH CARE IND INC1995HEALTH CARE IND INC1990

35963Company Code:AF&L INS CO1995

36013Company Code:LAWYERS MUT LIAB INS CO OF NC1995

36030Company Code:MERRION INS CO1995

36048Company Code:UNIONE ITALIANA REINS CO OF AMER1995

36072Company Code:NATIONAL GUARDIAN RRG INC2008NATIONAL GUARDIAN RRG INC1995

36102Company Code:STATE INS FUND2009STATE INS FUND2008STATE INS FUND2007STATE INS FUND2006STATE INS FUND2005STATE INSURANCE FUND2000STATE INSURANCE FUND1995

36103Company Code:STATE INS FUND DISABILITY BENEFITS1995

36129Company Code:IDAHO STATE INS FUND2008IDAHO STATE INS FUND1995

36188Company Code:COMPSOURCE OKLAHOMA2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners518

Page 527: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

36196Company Code:SAIF CORP2009SAIF CORP2008SAIF CORP2007SAIF CORP2006SAIF CORP1995SAIF CORP1990

36226Company Code:UNITED CAS & SURETY INS CO1995

36234Company Code:PREFERRED PROFESSIONAL INS CO2008PREFERRED PROFESSIONAL INS CO1995

36277Company Code:MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF ME2008MEDICAL MUT INS CO OF ME1995

36285Company Code:UNITED AMERICAS INS CO1995

36307Company Code:GRAY INS CO1995

36315Company Code:FARMERS MECH MUT FIRE INS OF WV1995

36331Company Code:TEXAS LAWYERS INS EXCH1995

36340Company Code:CAMICO MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY1995

36360Company Code:MIDWEST CAS INS CO1995

36374Company Code:COMMERCIAL CAS INS CO OF NC1995

36480Company Code:IDAHO COUNTIES RISK MGMT PROGRAM2008ID COUNTIES RISK MGMNT PROGRAM UNDW1995

36510Company Code:ASSOC OF TRIAL LAWYERS ASR A MUT RRG1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners519

Page 528: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

36560Company Code:SERVICE INS CO2009SERVICE INS CO2008SERVICE INS CO2007SERVICE INS CO2006SERVICE INS CO2005SERVICE INS CO2000SERVICE INS CO1995

36579Company Code:CGU INS CO OF CANADA1995

36609Company Code:CONNECTICUT LIFE & CAS INS CO1995

36620Company Code:USA PROPERTY & CAS INS CO1995

36650Company Code:GUARANTEE CO OF N AMER USA2008MID-STATE SURETY CORP1995

36676Company Code:UTAH MEDICAL INS ASSOC2008UTAH MEDICAL INS ASSOC1995

36684Company Code:NONPROFITS INS ASSN INTERINS1995

36706Company Code:LAWYERS MUT INS CO1995

36714Company Code:STATE COMP FUND1995

36790Company Code:SPRINGFIELD INS CO INC1995

36820Company Code:OKLAHOMA TRANSIT INS CO1995

36943Company Code:TEXAS RVOS INS CO1995

36960Company Code:CONNECTICUT SURETY CO1995

37028Company Code:NEW JERSEY CITIZENS UNITED RCP EXCH1995

37036Company Code:GOVERNMENTAL INTERINS EXCH1995

37052Company Code:REGIS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners520

Page 529: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

37176Company Code:OHIO BAR LIABILITY INS CO1995

37206Company Code:CONTRACTORS BONDING & INS CO2008CONTRACTORS BONDING & INS CO1995

37220Company Code:DIRECT INS CO1995

37281Company Code:INDEPENDENT TRUCKERS INS CO1995

37370Company Code:ASSOCIATED LOGGERS EXCH2008ASSOCIATED LOGGERS EXCH1995

37397Company Code:FIRST CENTRAL INS CO1995

37400Company Code:FIRE DISTRICTS OF NY MUT INS CO INC1995

37419Company Code:UNISOURCE INS CO1995

37435Company Code:PROFESSIONAL INS EXC1995

37443Company Code:ATLANTIC ALLIANCE FIDELITY & SRTY CO1995

37486Company Code:NATIONAL AUTOMOTIVE INS1995

37613Company Code:FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO2008FARMERS MUT AID ASSN1995

37621Company Code:TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2009TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2008TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2007TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2006TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2005TOYOTA MOTOR INS CO2000

37656Company Code:ANESTHESIOLOGIST PRO ASR CO A RRG1995

37672Company Code:SEVEN SEAS INS CO INC2008SEVEN SEAS INS CO INC1995

37710Company Code:FIRST AMERICAN PROP & CAS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners521

Page 530: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

37753Company Code:SUPERIOR NATL INS CO1995

37761Company Code:UNICARE INS CO1995

37770Company Code:WESTERN UNITED INS CO1995

37788Company Code:HOSPITAL UNDERWRITING GRP INC1995

37800Company Code:LG INSURANCE COMPANY LTD US BRANCH1995

37850Company Code:PACIFIC SPECIALTY INS CO1995

37869Company Code:PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC2009PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC2008PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC2007PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC2006PRE PAID LEGAL CAS INC2005PRE-PAID LEGAL CAS INC2000PRE-PAID LEGAL CAS INC1995

37923Company Code:SEAWORTHY INS CO2006SEAWORTHY INS CO2005SEAWORTHY INS CO1995

37931Company Code:UNIVERSAL OF OMAHA CAS INS CO1995

37940Company Code:LEXINGTON NATL INS CORP1995

38113Company Code:BISCAYNE INS CO1995

38148Company Code:NORTH SEA INS CO1995

38237Company Code:AMERICAN COUNTRY INS CO1995

38300Company Code:SAMSUNG FIRE & MARINE INS CO LTD2008SAMSUNG FIRE & MARINE INS CO LTD1995

38326Company Code:FIRST IND OF AMER INS CO1995

38466Company Code:EVERGREEN USA RRG INC1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners522

Page 531: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

38644Company Code:OMEGA INS CO1995

38687Company Code:ALASKA TIMBER INS EXCH2008ALASKA TIMBER INS EXCHANGE1995

38733Company Code:ALASKA NATL INS CO2008ALASKA NAT INS CO1995

38997Company Code:NISSAN FIRE & MARINE INS CO US BR1995

39292Company Code:UNIVERSAL INSURANCE EXCHANGE1995

39381Company Code:ADRIATIC INS CO1995

39411Company Code:OKLAHOMA ATTNYS MUTUAL INS CO1995

39527Company Code:HERITAGE IND CO2008HERITAGE IND CO2007

39594Company Code:PHYSICIANS LIABILITY INS CO1995

39659Company Code:EASTERN CAS INS CO1995

39861Company Code:GOLDEN BEAR INS CO2009GOLDEN BEAR INS CO2007GOLDEN BEAR INS CO1995

39934Company Code:GEORGIA GENERAL INS CO1995

40037Company Code:LEHMAN INS CO1990

40070Company Code:FARMERS MUT INS CO2008FARMERS MUT INS CO1995

40126Company Code:UMIALIK INS CO2008UMIALIK INS CO1995

40134Company Code:CASTLEPOINT NATL INS CO2009SUA INS CO2008

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners523

Page 532: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

40273Company Code:COASTAL INS ENTERPRISES INC1995

40517Company Code:ADVANTAGE WORKERS COMP INS CO2008

40541Company Code:GROCERS INS CO1995

40550Company Code:PACIFIC PIONEER INS CO1995

40568Company Code:TRIPLE S PROPIEDAD INC2009TRIPLE S PROPIEDAD INC2008SEGUROS TRIPLES INC2000TRIPLE S INC1995

40584Company Code:TRAVEL AIR INS CO KS1995

40627Company Code:NEW MEXICO MUT CAS CO1995

40690Company Code:NJ AUTOMOBILE FULL INS UNDWRTG ASN1985

40720Company Code:INTERSTATE AUTO INS CO INC1995

40800Company Code:AMERICAN STERLING INS CO1995

40975Company Code:DENTISTS INS CO2008DENTISTS INS CO1995

41041Company Code:AUTO CLUB S INS CO2009AUTO CLUB S INS CO2008AUTO CLUB S INS CO2007AUTO CLUB S INS CO2006AUTO CLUB S INS CO2005AUTO CLUB SOUTH INS CO2000AUTO CLUB SOUTH INS CO1995

41068Company Code:NATIONAL FIRE & CAS CO1995

41076Company Code:OCEAN MARINE IND INS CO1995

41106Company Code:TRIUMPHE CAS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners524

Page 533: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

41114Company Code:ATLANTIC BONDING CO1995

41190Company Code:PINNACOL ASSUR2009PINNACOL ASSUR2008PINNACOL ASSUR2007PINNACOL ASSUR2006PINNACOL ASSUR2005COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY2000COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY1995COLORADO COMPENSATION INS AUTHORITY1990

41300Company Code:AMERICAN RESOURCES INS CO INC1995

41394Company Code:BENCHMARK INS CO2008BENCHMARK INS CO2005BENCHMARK INS CO1995

41416Company Code:STATEWIDE INS CO1995

41459Company Code:ARMED FORCES INS EXCHANGE1995

41467Company Code:PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2009PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2008PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2007PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2006PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2005PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS2000PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS1995PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS1990PHYSICIANS RECIP INSURERS1985

41475Company Code:OKLAHOMA FARMERS UNION MUT INS CO1995

41580Company Code:RED SHIELD INS CO1995

41700Company Code:SOUTHERN GROUP IND INC1995

41767Company Code:PROLIANCE INS CO1995

41874Company Code:ANDERSON LLOYDS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners525

Page 534: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

41882Company Code:INTERNATIONAL LLOYDS INS CO1995

41912Company Code:PACIFIC MARINE INS CO1985

42056Company Code:SLAVONIC INS CO OF TX1995

42129Company Code:UNITED SECURITY ASSUR CO OF PA1995

42200Company Code:TRANSTATE INS CO1995

42234Company Code:MINNESOTA LAWYERS MUT INS CO1995

42269Company Code:MAJESTIC INS CO1995

42277Company Code:STERLING CAS INS CO1995

42285Company Code:VETERINARY PET INS CO1995

42376Company Code:TECHNOLOGY INS CO INC1995

42510Company Code:WASHINGTON CAS CO1995

42544Company Code:ACADEMIC HLTH PROFESSIONALS INS2008ACADEMIC HLTH PROFESSIONALS INS1995

42552Company Code:NOVA CAS CO1995

42617Company Code:MAG MUT INS CO2000

42722Company Code:FIRST MARINE INS CO1995

42749Company Code:TRADERS INS CO1995

42757Company Code:AGRI GEN INS CO2009AGRI GEN INS CO2008AGRI GEN INS CO2007AGRI GEN INS CO2006AGRI GEN INS CO2005AGRI GENERAL INS CO2000AGRI GENERAL INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners526

Page 535: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

42773Company Code:FIDELITY NATL INS CO1995

42862Company Code:UNIVERSAL CAS CO1995

42897Company Code:AMERICAN SERVICE INS CO INC1995

42923Company Code:CITADEL INSURANCE CO1995

42927Company Code:IL STATE BAR ASSOC MUT INS CO1995

42935Company Code:NEW ALLIANCE INS CO1995

43010Company Code:MARYLAND FIDELITY INS CO1995

43125Company Code:DELAWARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO2008DELAWARE PROFESSIONAL INS CO1995

43133Company Code:APEX LLOYDS INS CO1995APEX LLOYDS INS CO1990

43257Company Code:GENERAL AMER FIDELITY & GUAR CORP1995

43265Company Code:GRAMERCY INS CO2008GRAMERCY INS CO1995

43273Company Code:INSURORS IND CO1995

43290Company Code:WAYNE COOP INS CO2008WAYNE COOPERATIVE INS CO1995

43320Company Code:EASTERN MUT INS CO1995

43354Company Code:SAN ANTONIO REINS CO1995

43443Company Code:INTERNATIONAL SURETY & CASUALTYCO1995

43460Company Code:FFG INS CO1995

43494Company Code:AMERICAN HALLMARK INS CO OF TX1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners527

Page 536: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

43583Company Code:NORTHWEST PHYSICIANS MUT INS CO1995

43656Company Code:LOUISIANA MED MUT INS CO2008LOUISIANA MED MUT INS CO1995

43680Company Code:WESTERN WI MUT INS CO1995

43710Company Code:PENNSYLVANIA PATRIOT INS CO1995

43770Company Code:CLINIC MUT INS CO RRG1995

43800Company Code:CALLICOON CO-OPERATIVE INS CO1995

43826Company Code:CENTRAL CO OPERATIVE INS CO2008CENTRAL CO-OPERATIVE INS CO1995

43834Company Code:CLAVERACK COOPERATIVE INS CO1995

43842Company Code:FINGER LAKES FIRE & CASUALTY INS CO1995

43850Company Code:OSWEGO COUNTY MUT INS CO1995

43869Company Code:NORTH COUNTRY INS CO2008NORTH COUNTRY INS CO1995

43877Company Code:FIRST MUT INS CO2008

43915Company Code:RAINIER INS CO1995

43958Company Code:COMMERCE PROTECTIVE INS CO2008COMMERCE PROTECTIVE INS CO1995

43966Company Code:DOCTORS INS RECIP RRG1995

44016Company Code:NATIONAL HOME INS CO RRG1995

44032Company Code:SECURE UNDERWRITERS RRG1995

44059Company Code:AMERICAN GOVMTL RECP INS EXCH RRG1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners528

Page 537: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

44075Company Code:STATES SELF-INSURERS RRG1995

44083Company Code:PREFERRED PHYSICIANS MEDICAL RRG2008PREFERRED PHYSICIANS MEDICAL RRG1995

44105Company Code:OPHTHALMIC MUT INS CO RRG2008OPHTHALMIC MUT INS CO RRG1995

44113Company Code:NATIONAL DENTAL MUT INS CO RRG1995

44130Company Code:PARATRANSIT RRG GRP INS CO1995

44148Company Code:ARCHITECTS & ENGINEERS INS CO RRG2008ARCHITECTS & ENGINEERS INS CO RRG1995

44156Company Code:TECHNOLOGIES ASSUR RRG ASSN INC1995

44172Company Code:SENIOR CITIZENS MUT INS CO RRG1995

44199Company Code:APPLIANCE MANUFACTURERS ASR CO RRG1995

44229Company Code:ORANGE INSURANCE EXCHANGE1995

44237Company Code:MENTAL HEALTH RRG1995

44300Company Code:TOWER INSURANCE COMPANY OF NEW YORK1995

44326Company Code:ATLANTIC CHARTER INS CO1995

44350Company Code:HEALTH FACILITIES INS EXCH1995

44377Company Code:HALIFAX MUT INS CO2008HALIFAX MUT INS CO1995

44415Company Code:YEL CO INS1995

44423Company Code:UNITED SURETY & IND CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 538: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

Property/Casualty top 25 companies for 25 years

44504Company Code:CALIFORNIA HLTHCARE INS CO INC RRG2008CA HOSPITAL INS CO INC A RRG1995

44547Company Code:MIDWEST ASSUR CO1995

44598Company Code:COLLEGE LIABILITY INS CO LTD RRG1995

44610Company Code:PHYSICIANS DEFENSE ASSN1995

44890Company Code:GRANGE MUT INS CO1995

44997Company Code:CONSOLIDATED CATHOLIC CAS RRG1995

45934Company Code:AMERICAN COMPENSATION INS CO1995

46493Company Code:AMERICAN HOME SHIELD OF VA INC1995

46515Company Code:MISSISSIPPI PHYSICIANS INS CO1995

© 2009-2010 National Association of Insurance Commissioners

Page 539: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,
Page 540: 2009 Market Share Reports for the Top 25 …...48 Wall Street, 6th Floor New York, NY 10005-2906 212.398.9000 NAIC Executive Office 444 North Capitol Street NW, Suite 701 Washington,

TOP- PU- 10- EL

Formed in 1871, the National Association of Insurance

Commissioners (NAIC) is a voluntary organization of the chief

insurance regulatory officials of the 50 states, the District of

Columbia and five U.S. territories. The NAIC has three offices:

Executive Office, Washington, D.C.; Central Office, Kansas

City, Mo.; and Securities Valuation Office, New York City.

The NAIC serves the needs of consumers and the industry,

with an overriding objective of supporting state insurance

regulators as they protect consumers and maintain the

financial stability of the insurance marketplace.

For more information, visit www.naic.org.