2016-2017 - texas department of public safety · collected by the texas department of public safety...
TRANSCRIPT
Report Prepared By: Eric J. Fritsch, Ph.D. Chad R. Trulson, Ph.D. University of North Texas Copyright © 2018 Department of Criminal Justice University of North Texas 1155 Union Circle #305130 Denton, TX 76203 Denton, TX 76203-5017 All rights reserved
Texas
Department of Public Safety
Racial Profiling Analysis 2016-2017
Draft Report
September 2018
Analysis of Traffic Stop Data by Race/Ethnicity
2016-2017
Final Report
November 2018
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Scope of Work and Methodology ................................................................................................. 1 Research Task #1 ................................................................................................................ 1 Research Task #2 ................................................................................................................ 2 Research Task #3 ................................................................................................................ 4 Research Task #4 ................................................................................................................ 4 Research Task #5 ................................................................................................................ 5 Research Task #6 ................................................................................................................ 5 Research Task #7 ................................................................................................................ 6 Research Task #8 ................................................................................................................ 7 Research Task #9 ................................................................................................................ 7
Variables ........................................................................................................................................ 8
Data Analysis Process ................................................................................................................. 10 Stage1:TrafficStopDataAnalysis .................................................................................. 11 Stage2:TrafficStopEnforcementActionAnalysis .......................................................... 13 Stage3:SearchAnalysis ................................................................................................... 17 Stage4:ContrabandHitAnalysis .................................................................................... 20 Internal Controls ......................................................................................................................... 23
Research Team ............................................................................................................................ 25
Highway Patrol – 2017 Statewide Analysis ............................................................................... 27
Highway Patrol – 2016 Statewide Analysis ............................................................................... 30
Commercial Vehicle Enforcement – 2017 Statewide Analysis ................................................ 33
Commercial Vehicle Enforcement – 2016 Statewide Analysis ................................................ 36
Appendix A – Region 1: Dallas Analysis ................................................................................... 39
Appendix B – Region 1: Dallas – District Level Analysis ........................................................ 49
Appendix C – Region 2: Houston Analysis ............................................................................... 86
Appendix D – Region 2: Houston – District Level Analysis .................................................... 96
Appendix E – Region 3: McAllen Analysis ............................................................................. 133
Appendix F – Region 3: McAllen – District Level Analysis .................................................. 143
Appendix G – Region 4: El Paso Analysis .............................................................................. 181
Appendix H – Region 4: El Paso – District Level Analysis ................................................... 191
Appendix I – Region 5: Lubbock Analysis ............................................................................. 210
Appendix J – Region 5: Lubbock – District Level Analysis .................................................. 220
Appendix K – Region 6: San Antonio Analysis ...................................................................... 248
Appendix L – Region 6: San Antonio – District Level Analysis ............................................ 258
1
The purpose of this study is to perform an analysis of traffic stop data, by race and ethnicity, collected by the Texas Department of Public Safety (TX DPS). According to the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, “racial profiling means a law enforcement-initiated action based on an individual's race, ethnicity, or national origin rather than on the individual's behavior or on information identifying the individual as having engaged in criminal activity.”1 Scope of Work and Methodology This section reviews each research task specified in the project scope of work, discusses the methodology utilized to address each research task, and identifies where within the report each item is covered. For items in the project scope of work that do not appear in the report, an explanation for each is provided. Research Task #1 Determine if racial/ethnic disparities exist in the traffic stops at a statewide, regional, and district level Subtasks
• Examine the traffic stop data by service, Highway Patrol (HP) and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement (CVE) separately at the statewide, regional, and district level.
• Traffic stop data that is examined should include trooper-initiated enforcement. Data from crash investigations, agency assists, and commercial vehicle static inspection stations should be excluded.
• Commercial vehicle enforcement inspections as a result of a traffic stop (such as, roadside inspections) should be included in the traffic stop data.
Methodology
Racial profiling during traffic stops applies specifically to trooper-initiated (i.e., self-initiated or proactive) actions as reflected in the Texas state law definition of racial profiling. The traffic stop data assessed included all 2016 and 2017 traffic stops, separated by Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement, that were trooper-initiated. For Highway Patrol, the data excluded activities such as accident investigations, agency assists, and citations for failure to pay toll since these activities are not trooper-initiated. Instead, these activities are due to a call for service, request for assistance, or electronic identification by a license plate reader.
1 Texas Code of Criminal Procedure 3.05.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
2
For Commercial Vehicle Enforcement, the traffic stops assessed were limited to roadside inspections. Roadside inspections occur pursuant to a trooper-initiated traffic stop. Inspections which occur at commercial vehicle static inspection stations and scale houses were excluded from the data because the activity is not trooper-initiated. All ports of entry weigh stations are classified as scale houses. Further, inspections completed by non-commissioned inspectors were excluded from the data. Non-commissioned inspectors are not allowed to conduct roadside inspections which is the focus of the traffic stop analysis included in this report. Instead, non-commissioned inspectors are assigned to scale houses only.
Report Location The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement at the statewide level for 2016 and 2017 are included in the primary text. The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity, for Highway Patrol2 and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement for 2016 and 2017 at the region and district levels are included in Appendices A-L. Research Task #2 Identify a representative population “base-rate” based on county-level demographic data from the U.S. Census Bureau for which demographic comparisons can be made to determine if racial/ethnic disparities exist. Subtasks
• Demographic comparisons should consider geographical areas of traffic stops, and race/ethnicity groupings of traffic stop violators, compared to the race/ethnicity of troopers.
Why Data are not Presented in Report
TX DPS personnel provided the data on the location of each trooper-initiated traffic stop, race/ethnicity of traffic stop violators as well as the race/ethnicity of the trooper to the UNT research team. However, county-level demographic data from the U.S. Census Bureau is not a representative population base rate for comparison purposes and thus invalid. Therefore, the UNT research team decided to exclude the analysis from this report due to its invalidity. The most common benchmark used in racial profiling research is the United States Census due to its easy availability at the city and county level. In other words, it is easy to know the percentage breakdown of Whites, Blacks, Asians and other races as well as Hispanics for any city or county
2 There were 32 stops in 2016 and 2017 for Highway Patrol where the region and district were missing. In the region and district level tables in the appendices, these 32 stops are not included as they do not correspond to any region or district.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
3
through the census.gov website (https://www.census.gov/). With the two data points of 1) percentage of traffic stops by race/ethnicity of traffic stop violator and 2) percentage of residents by race/ethnicity in a city or county, an analysis can be completed to determine if there is a disparity between the two data points. It is important to note that all TX DPS regions and districts are comprised of entire counties which makes this type of analysis feasible at the statewide, region, and district levels. As an illustration, perhaps 40% of the traffic stops made by troopers in a particular district were of Hispanics and 10% of the district residents were Hispanic. Some then use this disparity as evidence of racial profiling against Hispanics. This conclusion is invalid. In other words, a pattern of disparities in traffic stops in comparison to U.S. Census data does not establish a pattern of racial profiling. Two justifications for this statement are presented below. First, the U.S. Census is an invalid benchmark for comparison to traffic stops at the state, region, and district level. The U.S. Census is not an accurate measure of the driving population because it includes all ages, not just those who are old enough to drive and have a driver’s license. In addition, since TX DPS troopers focus their enforcement efforts on interstates and state highways, traffic stop violators are not necessarily residents of the city or county in which the traffic stop occurred. When comparisons are made to the U.S. Census, the benchmark is commonly the city or county population demographic which only includes information on the racial/ethnic composition of the residents of the city or county and residents at the time of the census. Non-residents (i.e., individuals who did not reside in the city or county at the time of the census) are subject to traffic stops, but are not included in the comparison/base rate census data. As mentioned, this is particularly true for TX DPS troopers since their enforcement efforts focus on interstates and state highways which are commonly traversed by drivers from throughout Texas and other states. For example, a resident of Dallas can receive a traffic citation on Interstate 37 outside San Antonio but will not be included in the U.S. Census data for that TX DPS region or district. Invalid conclusions are drawn if the racial/ethnic composition of individuals stopped by TX DPS troopers in a particular region or district are compared to the U.S. Census, because the U.S. Census is limited to the racial/ethnic composition of individuals who resided in the region or district when the census was collected. Second, using the U.S. Census as a benchmark is based on the false assumption that drivers are at equal risk of being stopped for a traffic violation. Every driver does not have an equal chance of being stopped for a traffic violation. For example, if a person never commits a traffic violation, the person does not have a chance of being stopped. However, the individual is included in the U.S. Census data that is used as the benchmark as long as the individual was a resident of the region or district at the time of the census. Similarly, risk levels for traffic stops vary based on an individual’s quality of driving, travel patterns (i.e., using interstates and state highways), frequency of driving, and driver exposure to TX DPS troopers. There are exposure and risk differentials across individuals for traffic stops which limits the use of the U.S. Census as a benchmark for disparity analysis.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
4
Research Task #3 Examine the changes across time in the traffic stops at the statewide, regional, and district level
Methodology Traffic stops at the statewide, region, and district levels are analyzed for 2016 and 2017.
Report Location The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement at the statewide level for 2016 and 2017 are included in the primary text. The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement at the region and district levels for 2016 and 2017 are included in Appendices A-L. Research Task #4 Examine DPS traffic stop findings by race/ethnicity against those of the largest city and county law enforcement agency at the statewide, regional, and district levels as available on the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement website.
Why Data are not Presented in Report Law enforcement agencies are required to submit a racial profiling report annually to the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement (TCOLE). The standardized report is available on TCOLE’s website. TX DPS personnel provided the UNT research team with the data on the location of each trooper-initiated traffic stop as well as the race/ethnicity of traffic stop violators. This same information is available for each law enforcement agency in Texas which makes traffic stops through the standardized reporting form on the TCOLE website. In order to complete the statewide comparison, the TX DPS data would have been compared to the TCOLE reporting form data from the Houston Police Department (i.e., largest city in Texas) and the Harris County Sheriff’s Office (i.e., largest county in Texas). As an example at the region level, the analysis of the TX DPS Region 6 data would have been compared to the TCOLE reporting form data from the San Antonio Police Department (i.e., largest city in TX DPS Region 6) and the Bexar County Sheriff’s Office (i.e., largest county in TX DPS Region 6). Furthermore, as an example at the district level, the analysis of the TX DPS District 1A data would have been compared to the TCOLE reporting form data from the Dallas Police Department (i.e., largest city in TX DPS District 1A) and the Dallas County Sheriff’s Office (i.e., largest county in TX DPS District 1A). The UNT research team determined that comparing the TX DPS data at the statewide, region, and district level with the largest city and county law enforcement agency in the state, region, or district, depending on the analysis performed, was invalid. TX DPS troopers focus their enforcement efforts on interstates and state highways while city and county law enforcement agencies commonly make traffic stops throughout their respective jurisdictions including arterial
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
5
roadways as well as collector and residential streets. In addition, the data from the largest city and county law enforcement agency in the state, region, and district are not representative of the traffic stop data throughout the state or the respective region or district. Therefore, the UNT research team decided to exclude the analysis from the report due to its invalidity. Research Task #5 Determine if disparities exist in the likelihood of a citation versus a warning for all racial/ethnic groups, statewide, regionally, and at the district level.
Subtasks • Examine the likelihood of a citation versus a warning for all racial/ethnic groups by
service, HP and CVE separately at the statewide, regional, and district levels. Methodology
Traffic stops at the statewide, region, and district levels are analyzed for 2016 and 2017. For each traffic stop, one of two enforcement actions occurs; citation or warning. In instances in which a citation and a warning was issued (e.g., citation for speeding and warning for equipment violation) during the same traffic stop, the enforcement action was analyzed as a citation since it is the more severe outcome. For analysis purposes, only one enforcement action was analyzed per traffic stop, either citation or warning, regardless of the number of citations or warnings issued during the stop.
Report Location The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity and enforcement action, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement at the statewide level for 2016 and 2017 are included in the primary text. The traffic stop data, by race/ethnicity and enforcement action, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement for 2016 and 2017, at the region and district levels are included in Appendices A-L. It is important to note that the Commercial Vehicle Enforcement analysis includes a third category of “clean” in addition to “citation” and “warning” since the outcome of a CVE stop can include no violations found. Research Task #6 Determine if disparities exist in conditional search rates for the different types of searches for racial/ethnic groups.
Subtasks • If practical, determine if disparities exist in the contraband found rates for the
different types of searches for racial/ethnic groups.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
6
Methodology For each traffic stop, if a search occurred, the data were analyzed for research task #6. The data included the four types of searches collected by TX DPS; consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory. For each search completed, whether contraband was discovered during the search was analyzed. All data were disaggregated by race/ethnicity.
Report Location The search data, by race/ethnicity and whether contraband was discovered, at the statewide level are included in the primary text. The search data, by race/ethnicity and whether contraband was discovered, at the region and district levels are included in Appendices A-L. Research Task #7 Determine if conditional search rates display different patterns across the districts and regions compared to the statewide pattern.
Subtasks • Examine the conditional search rates by service, HP and CVE separately at the
statewide, regional, and district levels. • If practical, determine if contraband found rates display different patterns across the
districts and regions when compared to statewide.
Methodology For each traffic stop, if a search occurred, the data were analyzed for research task #7. The data included four types of searches; consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory. For each search completed, whether contraband was discovered during the search was analyzed. All data were disaggregated by race/ethnicity and were analyzed at the statewide, region, and district levels for 2016 and 2017.
Report Location The search data, by race/ethnicity and whether contraband was discovered, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement at the statewide level for 2016 and 2017 are included in the primary text. The search data, by race/ethnicity and whether contraband was discovered, for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement for 2016 and 2017 at the region and district levels are included in Appendices A-L.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
7
Research Task #8 Determine if racial/ethnic disparities exist in use of force incidents at a statewide level Why Data are not Presented in Report The UNT research team received a report from TX DPS personnel, dated April 11, 2017, on use of force from 2012-2016. The report documented: a) the number of use of force incidents by race/ethnicity from 2012-2016; b) number of use of force incidents excluding injury or death by a firearm by race/ethnicity from 2012-2016; c) number of deadly use of force incidents by firearm by race/ethnicity from 2012-2016; and, d) the number of suspect deaths by use of force by firearms by race/ethnicity from 2012-2016. The data are not limited to use of force incidents pursuant to traffic stops. For example, a use of force incident during an agency assist would be included in the use of force report, but the agency assist is not included in the traffic stop data analyzed for this report. The UNT research team decided to exclude the analysis from this report due to its limited utility for the purposes of this report. It is important to note that beginning January 1, 2018, law enforcement officers in Texas are required to collect “whether the officer used physical force that resulted in bodily injury, as that term is defined by Section 1.07, Penal Code,”3 for each traffic stop. Therefore, data on use of force, exclusive to trooper-initiated traffic stops, will be available at the end of calendar year 2018 and can be included in any future reports. Research Task #9 If race/ethnic disparities are identified, provide best practice recommendations to correct existing disparities and prevent future disparities.
Methodology The UNT research team identified and assessed the internal controls utilized within TX DPS to identify and mitigate racial profiling. In addition, the UNT research team completed a literature review of national law enforcement organizations, prominent law enforcement consulting firms, and government agencies to assess national best practices for the identification and mitigation of racial profiling. The best practices identified in the literature review were compared to TX DPS internal controls. 3 Texas Code of Criminal Procedure 2.133(b)(9).
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY SCOPE OF WORK AND METHODOLOGY
8
Report Location The internal control and best practice analysis is presented after the statewide level traffic stop and search data for Highway Patrol and Commercial Vehicle Enforcement for 2016 and 2017 are presented in the primary text. Variables The variables and measurement to complete the research tasks described in the previous section are discussed in this section of the report. The definitions and calculations for each variable are presented in Table 1. The variables in Table 1 are presented in the same order as in the tables throughout the report, but are presented in alphabetical order below.
• Area • Contraband Hits • Race/Ethnicity • Race Known • Searches – Includes the following types of searches and categorization
o Consent (discretionary) o Incident to arrest (non-discretionary) o Probable cause (non-discretionary) o Vehicle inventory (non-discretionary)
• Stops – Each stop includes one of the following enforcement actions o Citation o Warning
Table 1: Variable Definitions and Calculations
Variable Definition & Calculations
Area Definition: Statewide, DPS Region, or DPS District Race/Ethnicity Definition: African American, Alaska Native or American Indian,
Asian, Hispanic, Middle Eastern, Other, Unknown, White4 Note: The trooper independently determines the race/ethnicity of the violator, presents the citation or warning to the violator, and asks the violator to verify all information on the citation or warning prior to signing.
4 Beginning on January 1, 2018, race or ethnicity includes the following categories: Alaska Native or American Indian; Asian or Pacific Islander; Black; White; and Hispanic or Latino according to the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure 2.132(a)(3).
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY VARIABLES
9
Stops Definition: An occasion in which a peace officer stops a motor vehicle for an alleged violation of a law or ordinance5 Calculations:
1) Frequency: Number of stops, citations, or warnings by race/ethnicity
2) Percent: Number of stops, citations, or warnings by race/ethnicity divided by the number of stops, citations, or warnings for all racial/ethnic categories, times 100
3) Rate per 100 stops: Number of citations or warnings by race/ethnicity divided by number of stops by race/ethnicity, times 100
4) Example rate calculation: The rate of citations per 100 stops statewide for African-Americans in 2017 is calculated by taking the number of citations of African-Americans in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers (96,804) divided by the total number of stops of African-Americans in 2017 (231,654) = 0.41788, times 100 = 41.79.
Note: The commercial vehicle enforcement (CVE) analysis includes a third category of “clean” in addition to “citation” and “warning” since the outcome of a CVE stop can include no violations found.
Searches Definition: Searches based on consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory Calculations:
1) Frequency: Number of all searches, discretionary searches, or non-discretionary searches by race/ethnicity
2) Percent: Number of all searches, discretionary searches, or non-discretionary searches by race/ethnicity divided by the number of all searches, discretionary searches, or non-discretionary searches for all racial/ethnic categories, times 100
3) Rate per 100 stops: Number of all searches, discretionary searches, or non-discretionary searches by race/ethnicity divided by number of stops by race/ethnicity, times 100
4) Example rate calculation: The rate of searches per 100 stops statewide for Whites in 2017 is calculated by taking the number of searches of Whites in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers (33,453) divided by the total number of stops of Whites in 2017 (994,526) = 0.03363, times 100 = 3.36.
Contraband Hits Definition: Contraband was found during a search Calculations:
1) Frequency: Number of contraband hits by race/ethnicity 2) Percent: Number of contraband hits by race/ethnicity
divided by the number of contraband hits for all racial/ethnic categories, times 100
5 Texas Code of Criminal Procedure 2.132(a)(2).
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY VARIABLES
10
3) Rate per 100 searches: Number of contraband hits by race/ethnicity divided by number of all searches by race/ethnicity, times 100
4) Example rate calculation: The rate of contraband hits per 100 stops statewide for Hispanics in 2017 is calculated by taking the number of contraband hits of Hispanics in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers (11,745) divided by the total number of searches of Hispanics in 2017 (45,812) = 0.25639, times 100 = 25.64.
Race Known Definition: Whether the peace officer knew the race or ethnicity of the driver before the motor vehicle stop6 Calculations:
1) Frequency: Number of times trooper knew the race or ethnicity of the driver before the stop by race/ethnicity7
2) Percent: Number of times trooper knew the race or ethnicity of the driver before the stop by race/ethnicity divided by number of times trooper knew the race or ethnicity of the driver before the stop for all racial/ethnic categories, times 100
3) Rate per 100 stops: Number of times trooper knew the race or ethnicity of the driver before the stop by race/ethnicity divided by number of stops by race/ethnicity, times 100
4) Example rate calculation: The rate of “race known” per 100 stops statewide for Asians in 2017 is calculated by taking the number of stops of Asians in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers where race was indicated as known (103) divided by the total number of stops of Asians in 2017 (35,131) = 0.00293, times 100 = 0.29.
Data Analysis Process This section of the report reviews the analysis conducted by the UNT research team on the traffic stop and search data provided by TX DPS personnel. The data are analyzed within four chronological stages for each traffic stop and presented in over 200 tables throughout the report. Each table presented throughout the report has the same format to accommodate the readability of the tables.
6 Texas Code of Criminal Procedure 2.132(b)(6)(c). 7 From the original Commercial Vehicle Enforcement data, the variable indicating whether the trooper knew the race/ethnicity of the motorist prior to the stop had 290,760 blank entries, 3,096 entries indicating race was known prior to the stop, and 40,028 stops where race was not known prior to the stop. After consulting with TX DPS personnel, these 290,760 blank entries were considered “missing” versus “race not known prior to the stop”.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
11
Stage 1: Traffic Stop Data Analysis In stage 1, a trooper conducts a traffic stop under a circumstance authorized by TX DPS policy. According to Texas DPS 04.02.02 Traffic Stop policy, a DPS officer:
may stop and detain a motor vehicle or an occupant for a valid law enforcement purpose, but only under the following justifiable circumstances:
a. When probable cause exists to arrest or search for any violation of law,
including traffic offenses; b. When reasonable suspicion exists to detain for any violation of law,
including traffic offenses; c. When conducting a suspicionless stop, including a traffic regulatory
checkpoint, a Commercial Motor Vehicle Enforcement checkpoint, a DWI checkpoint, or a roadblock under the provisions of this policy; or
d. When an emergency situation arises, such as delivering an emergency message or rendering some other public service. An officer may exercise reasonable discretion when determining the existence of an emergency or public service situation.
e. Community Caretaking Exception: Officers can make a stop based solely upon the belief that a subject is in need of help. This belief must be REASONABLE based upon all of the following circumstances. Officers need to be able to ARTICULATE the reasons for our belief that the subject was in need of immediate assistance and that we were the only assistance available. The Court gives us five (5) factors to consider. They are: 1) the nature and level of the distress exhibited by the
individual; 2) the location of the individual; 3) whether or not the individual was alone and/or 4) had access to assistance independent of that offered by the
officer and to 5) what extent the individual-if not assisted-presented a danger
to himself or others.
The data analyzed in this report include traffic stops under subsection (a) and (b) of the TX DPS traffic stop policy. The traffic stop data are presented in each table, by race/ethnicity. For example, Highway Patrol troopers conducted 2,171,021 traffic stops throughout the state in 2017. Of these stops, 45.81% of the violators stopped were White, 41.15% were Hispanic, 10.67% were African American, and 1.62% were Asian.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
12
Using Traffic Stop Data to Assess Racial Disparities Law enforcement officers are required under the Texas racial profiling law to document whether they knew the race or ethnicity of the violator prior to the traffic stop. The data on whether the trooper knew the race or ethnicity of the violator before the motor vehicle stop is presented under the “Race Known” row in each table throughout this report. For example, of the 2,171,021 traffic stops conducted by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017, the trooper knew the race/ethnicity of the violator prior to the stop only 11,209 times (0.52% of all traffic stops). The traffic stop data analysis cannot be used to identify racial profiling because the trooper rarely knows the race/ethnicity of the violator prior to the traffic stop. When deciding to stop someone for a traffic violation, a prerequisite to racially profiling the violator is the trooper must know the race/ethnicity of the violator prior to the stop. A trooper cannot racially profile a violator when making a traffic stop unless the trooper knows the race/ethnicity of the violator prior to the stop. As mentioned above, troopers rarely know the race/ethnicity of violators prior to traffic stops. In 2017, Highway Patrol troopers did not know the race/ethnicity of the violator prior to stop in 99.48% of all traffic stops. This percentage is consistent across law enforcement agencies throughout Texas. An analysis of all annual racial profiling reports in 2014 submitted to the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement, as required by the Texas racial profiling law, found that in 97.1% of the traffic stops in Texas the officer did not know the race or ethnicity of the violator prior to the stop.8 The analysis included 1,186 Texas law enforcement agencies and more than 3.25 million traffic stops. Based on the analysis, it is highly unlikely for an officer to know the race or ethnicity of a violator prior to a traffic stop. An officer cannot stop violators based on their race if they do not know the race of the violator prior to the stop. Similarly, an officer cannot racially profile a violator when they do not know the violator’s race or ethnicity prior to the stop. Additional factors impact the analysis of traffic stop data as well. Variations in the number of traffic stops across TX DPS regions and districts can be due to deployment practices and department initiatives. For example, in 2015, the Texas Legislature approved 250 new troopers specifically for border security in TX DPS Region 3. Previously, region deployment decisions were based on the number of accidents within the region. Therefore, although the state is divided into six regions, an equal number of troopers is not assigned to each region. In order to assess the deployment of troopers during 2016 and 2017, the UNT research team received the quarterly measures of the average number of troopers assigned within each region. The quarterly measures were then averaged to obtain an annual average (see Table 2). The numbers illustrated in Table 2 excludes vacant positions. The influx of troopers into Region 3 for border security purposes is evident in the growth from 2016-2017. In 2016, there was an average of 441 troopers assigned to Region 3, but the average increased to 549 troopers in 2017; a 24.5% increase. 8 Winkler, Jordan M. (2016). Racial Disparity in Traffic Stops: An Analysis of Racial Profiling Data in Texas. Master’s Thesis. University of North Texas.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
13
As illustrated in Table 2, there are significantly more troopers assigned in Region 3: McAllen and Region 1: Dallas in comparison to Region 5: Lubbock and Region 4: El Paso. Deployment practices are important to consider as comparisons are made across TX DPS regions and districts. A higher number of traffic stops and searches are expected in regions with more assigned troopers. The variation in the number of troopers deployed in each region can impact any disparity analysis completed across regions and districts.
Table 2: Number of Troopers Assigned by Region Region 2016 2017 1:Dallas 496 540
2:Houston 442 471 3:McAllen 441 549 4:El Paso 219 242
5:Lubbock 274 288 6:San Antonio 364 396
Disparity analysis across TX DPS regions and districts is also impacted by strategic initiatives completed by TX DPS during the data analysis period of 2016 and 2017. As an example, during the data analysis period, TX DPS participated in several concentrated initiatives including a Violent Crime Task Force initiative in San Antonio, Operation North Star in Houston, and Operation Secure Texas which ended in September 2017. The deployment of troopers to strategic initiatives impacts the activity levels within the regions and districts affected and leads to a higher number of traffic stops and searches than otherwise expected. The current state of the racial profiling literature recognizes the issues discussed above and now focuses more on post stop actions which occur after the officer has made initial contact with the violator after the traffic stop. After the initial contact, the officer knows the race/ethnicity of the violator. Post stop actions include the enforcement action of the stop (i.e., citation vs. warning) and searches. These post stop actions are assessed in each table in this report. Stage 2: Traffic Stop Enforcement Action Analysis In stage 2, after a trooper initiates a traffic stop, the trooper decides on one of two enforcement actions; issue a warning or issue a citation. In instances in which a citation and a warning was issued (e.g., citation for speeding and warning for equipment violation) during the same traffic stop, the enforcement action was analyzed as a citation since it is the more severe outcome. For analysis purposes, only one enforcement action was analyzed per traffic stop, either citation or warning, regardless of the number of citations or warnings issued during the stop. It is important to note that in each commercial vehicle enforcement (CVE) table throughout this report, a third category of “clean” in addition to “citation” and “warning” is included. An enforcement action of citation or warning is not required for CVE stops since the outcome of a
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
14
CVE stop can include no violations found. When no violations are found, the outcome of the stop is classified as “clean.” How do troopers decide whether to issue a warning or a citation after a traffic stop? Texas DPS 05.01.05 Enforcement Policies policy, provides troopers direction on the factors to consider when making an enforcement action decision. According to the policy:
officers in deciding on enforcement action to be taken shall be guided by the policies enunciated in this Manual and shall disregard irrelevant factors such as (1) intention to violate the law, (2) attitude exhibited by the violator, (3) lack of actual hazard, and (4) frivolous excuses. The type of enforcement action taken shall be based only on (1) the seriousness of the offense, (2) the degree of the violation, or (3) the conditions and circumstances surrounding the offenses that might aggravate its potential effect.
A. Seriousness of the offense, e.g., muffler vs. DWI B. The degree of the violation, e.g., speeding 33 MPH in a 30 MPH zone
vs. speeding 55 MPH in a 30 MPH zone C. The conditions and circumstances surrounding the offense
1) A violation may be committed to a minor degree but under conditions that aggravate its potential effect. These conditions may warrant an arrest where a warning would otherwise suffice. Some of the aggravated conditions are:
a. Adverse weather b. Heavy traffic volume c. Bad road condition d. Bad vehicle condition (size, load, age,
maintenance, etc.) e. Bad driver condition (physical and mental
infirmities, drinking, fatigue, etc.) f. Multiple violations – two or more to a minor
degree g. Restricted visibility
The traffic stop enforcement action data are presented in each table, by race/ethnicity, throughout this report. For example, of the 770,936 citations issued by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state, 46.90% of the citations were issued to Hispanic violators, 38.08% of the citations were issued to White violators, 12.56% of the citations were issued to African American violators, and 1.63% of all citations were issued to Asian violators. In addition, of the 1,400,085 warnings issued by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state, 50.06% of the warnings were issued to White violators, 37.99% of the warnings were issued to Hispanic violators, 9.63% of the warnings were issued to African American violators, and 1.61% of all warnings were issued to Asian violators. Overall, of the 2,171,021 traffic stops conducted by Highway Patrol troopers
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
15
throughout the state in 2017, the enforcement action was a warning in 64.5% of the traffic stops while the enforcement action was a citation in 35.5% of the traffic stops. The rate per 100 stops for both citations and warnings, by race/ethnicity, is also presented in each table throughout the report. For the 2017 Highway Patrol data for the entire state, African American violators received a citation in 41.79 of every 100 stops of African American violators. On the other hand, African American violators received a warning in 58.21 of every 100 stops of African American violators. Similarly, Hispanic violators received a citation in 40.47 of every 100 stops of Hispanic violators. On the other hand, Hispanic violators received a warning in 59.53 of every 100 stops of Hispanic violators. Middle Eastern violators received a citation in 39.28 of every 100 stops of Middle Eastern violators. On the other hand, Middle Eastern violators received a warning in 60.72 of every 100 stops of Middle Eastern violators. Alaska Native/American Indian violators received a citation in 38.21 of every 100 stops of Alaska Native/American Indian violators. On the other hand, Alaska Native/American Indian violators received a warning in 61.79 of every 100 stops of Alaska Native/American Indian violators. Asian violators received a citation in 35.78 of every 100 stops of Asian violators. On the other hand, Asian violators received a warning in 64.22 of every 100 stops of Asian violators. Finally, White violators received a citation in 29.52 of every 100 stops of White violators. On the other hand, White violators received a warning in 70.48 of every 100 stops of White violators. For each race/ethnicity, the most likely enforcement action taken by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017 was the issuance of a warning. However, under certain circumstances, written warnings cannot be issued which leaves the trooper with the options of arrest or citation. According to Texas DPS 05.01.02 Types of Enforcement Action policy:
Written warnings will not be issued under any circumstances for: a) Driving while intoxicated b) Public intoxication c) No drivers license when not licensed d) Any nontraffic offense e) Violations which contribute to a traffic crash
Using Traffic Stop Enforcement Action Data to Assess Racial Disparities
For a disparity analysis of enforcement actions in the tables throughout this report, the enforcement actions provided as the rate per 100 traffic stops are the most informative of differences by race/ethnicity. As demonstrated in the above paragraphs, there are disparities across race/ethnicity in the likelihood of receiving a citation. Per 100 stops made by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017, African American violators received a citation in 41.79 of the stops, Hispanic violators received a citation in 40.47 of the stops, Middle Eastern violators received a citation in 39.28 of the stops, Alaska Native/American Indian violators received a citation in 38.21
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
16
of the stops, Asian violators received a citation in 35.78 of the stops, and White violators received a citation in 29.52 of the stops. How does the UNT research team interpret the disparity in citation rate by race/ethnicity for Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017? To state the reason for the disparity in citation rate across race/ethnicity is due to race only and thus demonstrates racial profiling on the part of Highway Patrol troopers is conjecture. As illustrated in the Texas DPS 05.01.05 Enforcement Policies policy, the enforcement action decision is both complex and nuanced. The enforcement action (i.e., citation or warning) taken by a trooper is based on several factors. As an illustration, deciding whether to issue a citation to a violator can be based on the seriousness of the offense, the degree of the violation, and the conditions and circumstances surrounding the traffic offense that may aggravate its potential effect. For example, regarding the seriousness of the offense, speeding is probably more likely to result in a citation than a defective tail light. Similarly, regarding the degree of the violation, a citation is probably more likely for driving 75 miles per hour in a 45 miles per hour zone than driving 55 miles per hour in the same 45 miles per hour zone. Finally, regarding the conditions and circumstances surrounding the traffic offense that may aggravate its potential effect, a traffic offense that may otherwise lead to a warning may lead to a citation due to adverse weather conditions, heavy traffic volume, or poor road conditions. The enforcement decisions troopers make are based on several factors and not all the factors are indicated on the citation or warning and thus included in the TX DPS database, especially the conditions and circumstances surrounding the traffic offense. Therefore, since most of the factors considered by the officer before taking the enforcement action are unknown (i.e., not in the TX DPS database), it is invalid to state the factor that explains the disparity in enforcement actions is race/ethnicity. A pattern of disparities in traffic stop enforcement actions does not establish a pattern of racial profiling. A disparity just shows a difference, but it does not provide an explanation for the difference. Concluding that a disparity in enforcement actions by race/ethnicity is evidence of racial profiling is an invalid conclusion. If a disparity alone is an indication of discrimination, then the police in the United States discriminate based on gender when making arrest decisions. According to the 2015 Uniform Crime Reports, of the over 8.3 million arrests in the United States, 73.1% of the arrestees were male while 26.9% were female. However, the 2010 U.S. Census illustrates that 49.2% of U.S. population is male. This disparity is clearly not evidence of gender discrimination by the police, but it is the same analysis done by some to claim racial profiling. As another example, according to the 2016 Uniform Crime Reports, 30.4% of the arrests in the United States were of 15-24 years old. However, the 2010 U.S. Census shows that only 14.1% of the U.S. population is 15-24 years old. Once again, this disparity is clearly not evidence of age discrimination by the police, but it is the same analysis done by some to claim racial profiling. A disparity in enforcement actions (i.e., citation vs. warning) can be due to numerous factors. It is invalid to conclude that any racial disparity in enforcement action is due to racial profiling.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
17
Stage 3: Search Analysis In stage 3, a trooper may conduct a search during the traffic stop. If a search is conducted, the trooper documents the justification for the search which includes consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory. Most traffic stops do not include a search. In 2017, Highway Patrol troopers conducted 2,171,021 traffic stops throughout the state, but only 99,322 of the stops included a search. Overall, 4.57% of the traffic stops included a search. Although not required by Texas law, TX DPS requires reasonable suspicion for consent searches. This policy requirement provides additional protection to Texas motorists. Typically, a law enforcement officer, without any level of proof, can request consent to search. According to Texas DPS 05.74.00 Request for Consent to Search policy:
absent probable cause to search a vehicle, troopers must assess the circumstances present on every traffic contact made and decide, based on training and experience, whether any activity outside of a traffic violation exists. Consistent with the expectations set by the Texas Appeals Courts, it is the policy of the Texas Department of Public Safety that a decision to request consent to search a person’s vehicle shall be based only on articulable, reasonable suspicion that the occupant(s) may be engaged in criminal conduct.
For the search analysis which is presented in each table throughout this report, the UNT research team separated the justifications for the searches into two categories: discretionary and non-discretionary. Searches conducted incident to arrest, based on probable cause, and pursuant to a vehicle inventory are classified as non-discretionary since troopers are required by state law or department policy to conduct the search. In other words, the troopers are not making an independent decision to conduct the search, but instead are following law and policy in conducting searches based on probable cause, vehicle inventory, or incident to arrest. The classification of these searches as non-discretionary in analogous to limiting the traffic stop analysis to trooper-initiated stops only, as previously discussed. These searches should not be analyzed in terms of whether or not racial profiling has occurred because the officer who has searched a violator as a result of the three above factors does not independently make the decision to search, but rather, is required to search that individual regardless of any determination of race. For example, if a trooper arrests a violator for an outstanding arrest warrant, the trooper is required to complete a vehicle inventory if the vehicle is impounded. A trooper cannot be determined to be racially profiling when departmental procedures or state law compels the trooper to conduct a search. The individual’s race or ethnicity is irrelevant to the search under these non-discretionary search circumstances. Data on non-discretionary and discretionary searches are separated in each table throughout this report.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
18
Despite the enhanced requirement of TX DPS which mandates reasonable suspicion for a trooper to request consent to search, consent searches are classified as discretionary searches because the trooper makes an independent decision to request permission to search. In 2017, Highway Patrol troopers conducted 2,171,021 traffic stops throughout the state, but only 33,391 of the stops included a consent search. Overall, 1.54% of the traffic stops conducted by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state included a consent search. As previously mentioned, the current state of the racial profiling literature focuses on post stop actions which occur after the law enforcement officer has made initial contact with the violator. After the initial contact, the officer knows the race/ethnicity of the violator. Consent searches, since they are discretionary actions, are particularly scrutinized in racial profiling analyses. It is expected that consent searches will rarely occur, but a minimum threshold has not been established in the racial profiling literature. In other words, there is no standard set that states “racial profiling should be considered as a factor when XX percent of traffic stops result in a consent search.”
Using Search Analysis Data to Assess Racial Disparities Of the 33,391 traffic stops by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state that resulted in a consent search, 57.46% were Hispanic violators, 30.05% were White violators, 11.00% were African American violators, and 0.82% were Asian violators. For a disparity analysis of consent searches in the tables throughout this report, the rate of consent searches per 100 traffic stops is the most informative of differences by race/ethnicity. Per 100 traffic stops made by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017, there was a consent search in 2.15 of the stops of Hispanic violators, 2.07 of the stops of Alaska Native/American Indian violators, 1.59 of the stops of African American violators, 1.01 of the stops of White violators, 0.99 of the stops of Middle Eastern violators, and 0.88 of the stops of Asian violators. As indicated in the consent search rate in the 2017 Highway Patrol statewide data, consent searches occur in approximately two or fewer stops for every 100 stops regardless of race/ethnicity. As demonstrated in the above paragraph, there are disparities across race/ethnicity in the likelihood of being subjected to a consent search. How does the UNT research team interpret the disparity in consent search rate by race/ethnicity for Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017? In assessing the disparity in consent search rate by race/ethnicity, the research team considers four factors. First, the UNT research team assesses how often consent searches occur and expects them to be few in number which then results in a small percentage of all traffic stops resulting in a consent search. As previously mentioned, there is no standard set that states “racial profiling should be considered as a factor when XX percent of traffic stops result in a consent search.” However, only 1.54% of the traffic stops conducted by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state resulted in a consent search. With over 2 million traffic stops in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state and less than 35,000 consent searches, this is an indication to the UNT research team of the judicious use of consent searches by TX DPS troopers.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
19
Second, the UNT research team assesses how often consent searches occur by race/ethnicity. Of the 33,391 consent searches in 2017 by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state, 19,188 were of Hispanic violators, 10,035 were of White violators, 3,673 were of African American violators, 310 were of Asian violators, 139 were of Middle Eastern violators, and 46 were of Alaska Native/American Indian violators. Since some of the totals by race/ethnicity are particularly small in number (e.g., only 310 consent searches of Asian violators), any statistics can be dramatically impacted by even slight changes in the total number of consent searches for a particular racial/ethnic group. As an illustration, there were 139 consent searches out of the 14,108 traffic stops of Middle Eastern violators by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017. The consent search rate per 100 stops of Middle Eastern violators is 0.99. If the number of consent searches is increased from 139 (actual number) to 200 (example number), the consent search rate per 100 stops of Middle Eastern violators is then 1.43. This is a 44% increase in the consent search rate with the addition of only 61 more consent searches. However, adding 61 consent searches to the 10,035 total consent searches of White violators by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017 only increases the consent search rate per 100 stops of White violators from 1.01 (actual rate) to 1.02 (example rate). Therefore, it is important to consider the total number of consent searches for each racial/ethnic group when assessing consent search rate disparities. This issue amplifies as the data are divided by district and region level disparity analyses of consent searches in the appendices of this report. Third, the interpretation of any disparity in consent search rate by race/ethnicity is impacted by the TX DPS policy which requires troopers have reasonable suspicion before requesting permission/consent to search. Although not required by Texas law, TX DPS requires reasonable suspicion for consent searches that provides additional protection to Texas motorists. Typically, a law enforcement officer, without any level of proof, can request consent to search. However, TX DPS policy requires “articulable, reasonable suspicion that the occupant(s) may be engaged in criminal conduct” before troopers can ask for consent to search. This requirement is important in the disparity analysis of consent search rate since the troopers had a reasonable justification for requesting permission to search regardless of the race/ethnicity of the violator. For each consent search, troopers have identified legal, articulable factors to believe the violator may be engaged in criminal activity. To state the reason for the disparity in consent search rate across race/ethnicity is due to race and thus demonstrates racial profiling on the part of troopers is conjecture. Fourth, of the four types of searches in the analysis (i.e., consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory), consent searches are the only optional searches since violators can deny troopers permission/consent to search. The consent search denial cannot then be used by troopers to justify probable cause to search. It is the right of the violator to grant or deny the requests of troopers to conduct a consent search. However, troopers will conduct searches incident to arrest, searches based on probable cause, and vehicle inventories regardless of the wishes of the violator.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
20
Since violators can deny consent to search, there are two subpopulations within the larger consent search category; 1) those who granted consent to search, and 2) those who denied consent to search. The data collection requirements under the Texas racial profiling law only require the documentation of race/ethnicity of the former, but requires no data collection on the latter. Therefore, the UNT research team does not know if there are any disparities by race/ethnicity in consent search denials. If there are disparities, and certain racial/ethnic groups are more or less likely to grant permission/consent to search upon request by troopers, then the interpretation of any disparities in consent search rate by race/ethnicity is further complicated. For example, if White violators are less likely to grant consent to search in comparison to African American violators, the consent search rate per 100 stops will be higher for African American violators even if the same number of White and African American violators were asked for consent to search. The lack of available data on violators who deny consent to search leaves an incomplete picture of what explains disparities, by race/ethnicity, in the consent search rate. Stage 4: Contraband Hit Analysis In stage 4, a trooper who conducts a search may seize contraband during the search. If contraband is seized during the search, the seizure is documented as a contraband hit in the TX DPS data provided to the UNT research team. The contraband hits included seizures pursuant to all types of searches in the TX DPS database; consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory. In 2017, Highway Patrol troopers conducted 99,322 searches throughout the state and 32,962 of the searches resulted in the seizure of contraband. Overall, 33.19% of the searches conducted by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state resulted in a contraband hit. As previously mentioned, the current state of the racial profiling literature focuses on post stop actions which occur after the law enforcement officer has made initial contact with the violator. After the initial contact, the officer knows the race/ethnicity of the violator. Some research has assessed the success rate or contraband hit rate of searches pursuant to traffic stops to determine if there are differences across racial/ethnic groups. There is an expectation that a certain percentage of searches will result in the discovery of contraband, but a minimum threshold has not been established in the racial profiling literature. In other words, there is no standard set that states “racial profiling should be considered when fewer than XX percent of searches result in the discovery of contraband.”
Using Contraband Hit Analysis Data to Assess Racial Disparities Of the 32,962 searches that resulted in the seizure of contraband (i.e., contraband hits) by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 throughout the state, 40.35% were White violators, 35.63% were Hispanic violators, 22.63% were African American violators, and 0.85% were Asian violators. For a disparity analysis of contraband hits in the tables throughout this report, the rate of contraband hits per 100 searches is the most informative of differences by race/ethnicity. Per 100 searches made by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017, there was a contraband
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
21
hit in 39.76 of the searches of White violators, 39.73 of the searches of African American violators, 37.77 of the searches of Middle Eastern violators, 36.73 of the searches of Alaska Native/American Indian violators, 34.61 of the searches of Asian violators, and 25.64 of the searches of Hispanic violators. As demonstrated in the above paragraph, there are disparities across race/ethnicity in the likelihood of a contraband hit pursuant to a search. How does the UNT research team interpret the disparity in contraband hit rate by race/ethnicity for Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017? In assessing the disparity in contraband hit rate by race/ethnicity, the research team considers two factors. First, the largest number of searches, non-discretionary searches (i.e., incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory) and discretionary searches (i.e., consent), are of Hispanic violators, but the contraband hit rate per 100 searches is lowest for Hispanic violators. This means that Hispanic violators are most likely to be searched but least likely to have contraband discovered pursuant to the search. The contraband hit rate per 100 searches ranges from 39.76 of the searches of White violators to 34.61 of the searches of Asian violators for all the racial categories except Hispanic violators who have a contraband hit rate per 100 searches of 25.64. After assessing traffic stops, searches, and contraband hits across the TX DPS regions (tables available in the appendices), the most tenable explanation for the lower contraband hit rate per 100 searches of Hispanic violators is due to strategic border security initiatives and trooper deployment strategies. Of the 893,444 traffic stops made by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017 of Hispanic violators, 429,427 occurred in Region 3 (48.06%). Similarly, of the 45,812 searches (i.e., consent, incident to arrest, probable cause, and vehicle inventory) made by Highway Patrol troopers throughout the state in 2017 of Hispanic violators, 18,756 occurred in Region 3 (40.94%). Furthermore, the contraband hit rate of 14.44 per 100 searches for Hispanic violators in Region 3 by Highway Patrol troopers in 2017 is the lowest rate for Hispanic violators in all TX DPS regions. Eight of the 14 counties in Texas which are adjacent to the United States border with Mexico are in TX DPS Region 3: McAllen as illustrated on the map on page 26. Second, a low contraband hit rate is expected in some circumstances since the main purpose of some of the searches is not the discovery of contraband or other evidence. For example, the main purpose of searches incident to arrest and vehicle inventories is not the discovery of contraband. Instead, the main purpose of a search incident to arrest is trooper safety; ensuring the violator does not have any items that can harm the trooper. Also, the main purpose of a vehicle inventory is the documentation and protection of the items inside the violator’s vehicle prior to impoundment, not the discovery of contraband. In these circumstances, it is expected the contraband hit rate should be low. On the other hand, the primary purpose of searches based upon probable cause and consent searches based on reasonable suspicion is the discovery of contraband or other evidence. In these instances, a higher contraband hit rate is expected.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
22
As the tables are reviewed, the reader will see some of the cells within the table have --- instead of a number. These are not calculation errors. Instead, --- is put in the cell of a table when the denominator in the calculation is 0; thus making the value incalculable. For example, on the Statewide 2017 Highway Patrol table, the rate of discretionary searches per 100 stops for “other” races does not include a calculation because the calculation of the rate entails dividing the number of discretionary searches of “other” race individuals (0) by the number of stops of “other” race individuals (0), multiplied by 100 which equals not calculable.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DATA ANALYSIS PROCESS
23
Internal Controls The TX DPS has implemented proactive, internal controls in support of its zero-tolerance regarding racial profiling. The primary internal controls are discussed below.
1) Troopers are required to record audio and video of each traffic stop. The TX DPS preserves each recording for 90 days and preserves recordings of stops involving allegations of racial profiling indefinitely.
2) Troopers must set the audio/video recording unit’s operator selector switch to “automatic mode” so that as the patrol vehicle’s emergency lighting equipment is activated, the audio/video recording unit will automatically activate to begin recording the entire contact or event.
3) Patrol vehicle recording units are set to capture at least two minutes prior to the activation of the video unit so that events occurring immediately prior to a public contact are recorded.
4) TX DPS sergeants are required to conduct 20 hours of video observation review every six months for each trooper the sergeant supervises.
5) TX DPS citations and warnings are printed with a toll free phone number to the TX DPS Office of Inspector General. The Inspector General is appointed by and reports directly to the Public Safety Commission and independently receives and investigates complaints, including complaints of racial profiling, brought against TX DPS commissioned officers.
6) As previously mentioned, although not required by Texas law, TX DPS requires reasonable suspicion for consent searches that provides additional protection to Texas motorists. Typically, a law enforcement officer, without any level of proof, can request consent to search. However, TX DPS policy requires “articulable, reasonable suspicion that the occupant(s) may be engaged in criminal conduct” before troopers can ask for consent to search. For each consent search, troopers identify legal, articulable factors to believe the violator may be engaged in criminal activity before asking for permission/consent to search.
7) TX DPS has an Early Intervention System (EIS), which is designed to assist supervisors with timely identification of employees whose performance warrants review and, where appropriate, intervention. The EIS goal is to avoid or mitigate circumstances that cause negative consequences for employees, co-workers, the TX DPS, or the general public. Using a web-based software application, the EIS provides a systematic review of select activities or incidents received or generated by an employee or TX DPS. The EIS is administered by The Office of Inspector General and is designed to highlight tendencies in performance, complaints and other activities. An alert for supervisory review is generated by the EIS when an employee meets, or exceeds, an established threshold in the following areas: informal citizen concerns, counseling/coaching record, use of force incident, vehicle crashes, vehicle pursuits, and Equal Employment Opportunity complaints.
8) TX DPS 05.01.02 Types of Enforcement Action policy requires troopers write a written warning if the violator is not arrested or issued a citation. According to the policy:
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY INTERNAL CONTROLS
24
Persons stopped by officers for traffic law violations of a relatively minor degree and who are not arrested or issued a citation will be issued a written notice of warning.
This policy is important as an internal control regarding racial profiling. If TX DPS policy allowed verbal warnings, no data on the race/ethnicity of the violator would be collected since there is not any written documentation of the violation. By requiring a written warning, TX DPS collects the race/ethnicity of the violator on all traffic stops which provides the most comprehensive data available for racial profiling analysis.
The UNT research team compared the TX DPS internal controls with best practices recommended by the International Association of Chiefs of Police9 and the U.S. Department of Justice10 along with additional literature from national law enforcement organizations, prominent law enforcement consulting firms, and government agencies, and Texas law enforcement agencies in which the UNT research team completes annual racial profiling reports. After the review and comparison, the UNT research team concludes that the TX DPS internal controls align with documented best practices. For example, the U.S. Department of Justice states, “data collection sends a clear message that racial profiling is inconsistent with effective policing.” Not only does TX DPS collect racial profiling data, it releases the raw traffic stop data at the below publicly available website for analysis by any individual. This is an uncommon practice for law enforcement agencies and TX DPS should be lauded for it’s transparency in this area. https://www.dps.texas.gov/director_staff/highValueDataSets.htm As another example, the International Association of Chiefs of Police states department policies “should clearly convey that behavior and evidentiary standards should guide stop and search decisions, not race or ethnicity.” The TX DPS policies discussed throughout this report demonstrate that TX DPS meets this standard. As previously stated, the UNT research team concludes that the TX DPS internal controls align with documented best practices and do not offer any recommended changes to its current practices, policies, and protocols. The UNT research team also concludes that some of the TX DPS internal controls exceed documented best practices. For example, requiring reasonable suspicion for consent searches is uncommon among law enforcement agencies and provides additional protection to Texas motorists. Due to this requirement, troopers must identify legal, articulable factors to believe the violator may be engaged in criminal activity before asking for permission/consent to search. In addition, by requiring a written warning, TX DPS collects the race/ethnicity of the violator on all traffic stops which provides the most comprehensive data available for racial profiling analysis. TX DPS should be lauded for its internal control mechanisms to inhibit racial profiling.
9 Protecting Civil Rights: A Leadership Guide for State, Local, and Tribal Law Enforcement. September 2006. International Association of Chiefs of Police. 10 Ramirez, Deborah, Jack McDevitt, and Amy Farrell. November 2000. A Resource Guide on Racial Profiling Data Collection Systems: Promising Practices and Lessons Learned. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY INTERNAL CONTROLS
25
Research Team Eric J. Fritsch is Professor and Chair of the Department of Criminal Justice at the University of North Texas (UNT). He received his Ph.D. in Criminal Justice from Sam Houston State University in 1995 and has been a faculty member at UNT since August 1996. While at UNT, he has taught the department’s graduate level research methods course 19 times.
Chad R. Trulson is Professor and Associate Chair of the Department of Criminal Justice at the University of North Texas (UNT). He received his Ph.D. in 2002 from Sam Houston State University, George J. Beto College of Criminal Justice.
Dr. Trulson has published numerous articles in leading criminal justice journals in addition to four co-authored books: Juvenile Justice: System, Process, and Law (Cengage, 2006), First Available Cell: Desegregation of the Texas Prison System (University of Texas Press, 2009) Applied Research Methods in Criminal Justice and Criminology (McGraw-Hill, 2014) and Lost Causes: Blended Sentencing, Second Chances, and the Texas Youth Commission (University of Texas Press, 2016). Dr. Trulson also serves as Editor-in-Chief of the highly ranked journal, Youth Violence and Juvenile Justice (SAGE).
Dr. Fritsch and Dr. Trulson are co-authors on a research methods textbook entitled Applied Research Methods in Criminal Justice and Criminology; published by McGraw-Hill in 2014. Specifically regarding racial profiling, they complete the annual racial profiling reports for 15-20 Texas law enforcement agencies each year. The annual racial profiling reports are required under the Texas Racial Profiling Law. They began completing these reports in 2005. In addition to the annual racial profiling reports, they published a peer-reviewed article entitled Racial Profiling and the Political Demand for Data: A Pilot Study Designed to Improve Methodologies in Texas and have served as faculty advisors for a thesis on racial profiling. Furthermore, Dr. Fritsch has conducted racial profiling training for law enforcement executives at the Institute for Law Enforcement Administration in Plano, Texas.
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY RESEARCH TEAM
26
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
B C
AD
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
27
Highway Patrol 2017 Statewide Analysis
28
Highway Patrol - 2017
STATEWIDE 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 231,654
994,526 893,444
Percent 10.67 %
45.81 %
41.15 %
Citations
Frequency
96,804 293,607
361,593 Percent
12.56 %
38.08 %
46.90 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.79
29.52 40.47
Warnings
Frequency
134,850 700,919
531,851 Percent
9.63 %
50.06 %
37.99 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.21
70.48 59.53
Searches (All)
Frequency 18,775
33,453 45,812
Percent 18.90 %
33.68 %
46.12 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.10 3.36
5.13 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3,673
10,035 19,188
Percent 11.00 %
30.05 %
57.46 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.59 1.01
2.15 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
15,102 23,418
26,624 Percent
22.91 %
35.52 %
40.38 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.52
2.35 2.98
Contraband Hits
Frequency
7,460 13,300
11,745 Percent
22.63 %
40.35 %
35.63 %
Rate per 100 searches 39.73
39.76 25.64
Race Known
Frequency
1,062 5,212
4,793 Percent
9.47 %
46.50 %
42.76 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.46
0.52 0.54
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY HIGHWAY PATROL –2017 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
29
Highway Patrol - 2017
STATEWIDE 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 35,131
2,227 14,018
0 21
Percent 1.62 %
0.10 %
0.65 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
12,570 851
5,506 0
5 Percent
1.63 %
0.11 %
0.71 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 35.78
38.21 39.28
--- 23.81
Warnings
Frequency
22,561 1,376
8,512 0
16 Percent
1.61 %
0.10 %
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 64.22
61.79 60.72
--- 76.19
Searches (All)
Frequency 812
147 323
0 0
Percent 0.82 %
0.15 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.31 6.60
2.30 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 310
46 139
0 0
Percent 0.93 %
0.14 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.88 2.07
0.99 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
502 101
184 0
0 Percent
0.76 %
0.15 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.43
4.54 1.31
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
281 54
122 0
0 Percent
0.85 %
0.16 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 34.61
36.73 37.77
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
103 6
33 0
0 Percent
0.92 %
0.05 %
0.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.29
0.27 0.24
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY HIGHWAY PATROL –2017 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
30
Highway Patrol 2016 Statewide Analysis
31
Highway Patrol - 2016
STATEWIDE 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 184,782
872,033 700,861
Percent 10.24 %
48.32 %
38.84 %
Citations
Frequency
75,759 258,429
286,186 Percent
11.87 %
40.49 %
44.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.00
29.64 40.83
Warnings
Frequency
109,023 613,604
414,675 Percent
9.35 %
52.60 %
35.55 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.00
70.36 59.17
Searches (All)
Frequency 6,281
12,992 13,485
Percent 18.92 %
39.14 %
40.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.40 1.49
1.92 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1,371
3,942 5,665
Percent 12.30 %
35.38 %
50.84 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.74 0.45
0.81 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4,910 9,050
7,820 Percent
22.27 %
41.04 %
35.47 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.66
1.04 1.12
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3,441 7,523
5,573 Percent
20.55 %
44.92 %
33.28 %
Rate per 100 searches 54.78
57.90 41.33
Race Known
Frequency
1,054 5,614
1,953 Percent
12.00 %
63.92 %
22.24 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.57
0.64 0.28
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY HIGHWAY PATROL –2016 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
32
Highway Patrol - 2016
STATEWIDE 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 27,757
1,716 17,454
16 41
Percent 1.54 %
0.10 %
0.97 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
10,345 645
6,797 11
5 Percent
1.62 %
0.10 %
1.07 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.27
37.59 38.94
68.75 12.20
Warnings
Frequency
17,412 1,071
10,657 5
36 Percent
1.49 %
0.09 %
0.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.73
62.41 61.06
31.25 87.80
Searches (All)
Frequency 249
42 138
5 0
Percent 0.75 %
0.13 %
0.42 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.90 2.45
0.79 31.25
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 95
14 56
0 0
Percent 0.85 %
0.13 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.34 0.82
0.32 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
154 28
82 5
0 Percent
0.70 %
0.13 %
0.37 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.55
1.63 0.47
31.25 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
125 22
59 5
0 Percent
0.75 %
0.13 %
0.35 %
0.03 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.20
52.38 42.75
100.00 ---
Race Known
Frequency
77 5
80 0
0 Percent
0.88 %
0.06 %
0.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.28
0.29 0.46
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY HIGHWAY PATROL –2016 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
33
Commercial Vehicle Enforcement 2017 Statewide Analysis
34
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
STATEWIDE 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 19,794
57,522 82,612
Percent 12.12 %
35.22 %
50.58 %
Citations
Frequency
4,250 11,271
18,094 Percent
12.54 %
33.24 %
53.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 21.47
19.59 21.90
Warnings
Frequency
10,131 27,130
43,787 Percent
12.29 %
32.92 %
53.13 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.18
47.16 53.00
Clean
Frequency 5,413
19,121 20,731
Percent 11.52 %
40.68 %
44.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
27.35 33.24
25.09 Searches (All)
Frequency
98 115
326 Percent
17.82 %
20.91 %
59.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.50
0.20 0.39
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
63 82
275 Percent
14.69 %
19.11 %
64.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.14 0.33
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 35
33 51
Percent 28.93 %
27.27 %
42.15 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.18 0.06
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 25
33 28
Percent 28.41 %
37.50 %
31.82 %
Rate per 100 searches
25.51 28.70
8.59 Race Know
n
Frequency 30
133 1,428
Percent 1.88 %
8.33 %
89.47 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.15 0.23
1.73
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ENFORCEMENT-2017 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
35
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
STATEWIDE 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,240
91 1,017
0 1,054
Percent 0.76 %
0.06 %
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.65 %
Citations
Frequency
143 14
132 0
0 Percent
0.42 %
0.04 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.53
15.38 12.98
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
725 40
536 0
69 Percent
0.88 %
0.05 %
0.65 %
0.00 %
0.08 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.47
43.96 52.70
--- 6.55
Clean
Frequency 372
37 349
0 985
Percent 0.79 %
0.08 %
0.74 %
0.00 %
2.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
30.00 40.66
34.32 ---
93.45 Searches (All)
Frequency
9 0
1 0
1 Percent
1.64 %
0.00 %
0.18 %
0.00 %
0.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.73
0.00 0.10
--- 0.09
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
8 0
0 0
1 Percent
1.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.65
0.00 0.00
--- 0.09
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.83 %
0.00 %
0.83 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.08 0.00
0.10 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 1
0 0
Percent 1.14 %
0.00 %
1.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
11.11 ---
100.00 ---
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 4
0 0
Percent 0.06 %
0.00 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.08 0.00
0.39 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ENFORCEMENT-2017 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
36
Commercial Vehicle Enforcement 2016 Statewide Analysis
37
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
STATEW
IDE 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 20,135
60,345 85,765
Percent 11.81 %
35.38 %
50.29 %
Citations
Frequency
3,995 11,279
17,215 Percent
12.16 %
34.33 %
52.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 19.84
18.69 20.07
Warnings
Frequency
10,581 29,136
47,096 Percent
11.95 %
32.91 %
53.20 %
Rate per 100 stops 52.55
48.28 54.91
Clean
Frequency 5,559
19,930 21,454
Percent 11.30 %
40.53 %
43.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
27.61 33.03
25.01 Searches (All)
Frequency
39 74
242 Percent
10.77 %
20.44 %
66.85 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.19
0.12 0.28
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
20 45
216 Percent
6.94 %
15.63 %
75.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.07 0.25
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 19
29 26
Percent 25.68 %
39.19 %
35.14 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.09 0.05
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 11
23 21
Percent 20.00 %
41.82 %
38.18 %
Rate per 100 searches
28.21 31.08
8.68 Race Know
n
Frequency 38
92 1,357
Percent 2.53 %
6.13 %
90.47 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.19 0.15
1.58
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ENFORCEMENT-2016 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
38
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
STATEWIDE 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,409
85 1,636
10 1,169
Percent 0.83 %
0.05 %
0.96 %
0.01 %
0.69 %
Citations
Frequency
162 17
188 1
0 Percent
0.49 %
0.05 %
0.57 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.50
20.00 11.49
10.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
759 24
837 6
81 Percent
0.86 %
0.03 %
0.95 %
0.01 %
0.09 %
Rate per 100 stops 53.87
28.24 51.16
60.00 6.93
Clean
Frequency 488
44 611
3 1,088
Percent 0.99 %
0.09 %
1.24 %
0.01 %
2.21 %
Rate per 100 stops
34.63 51.76
37.35 30.00
93.07 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.55 %
0.00 %
1.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.00 0.31
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.69 %
0.00 %
1.74 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.00 0.31
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 3
0 7
0 3
Percent 0.20 %
0.00 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.20 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.21 0.00
0.43 0.00
0.26
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY COMMERCIAL VEHICLE ENFORCEMENT-2016 STATEWIDE ANALYSIS
39
Appendix A Region 1: Dallas Analysis
40
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BA
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
C
D
Throckmorton
41
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 1 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 64,995
300,526 61,718
Percent 14.84 %
68.62 %
14.09 %
Citations
Frequency
27,186 92,071
31,856 Percent
17.51 %
59.29 %
20.52 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.83
30.64 51.62
Warnings
Frequency
37,809 208,455
29,862 Percent
13.38 %
73.74 %
10.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.17
69.36 48.38
Searches (All)
Frequency 5,180
9,842 3,557
Percent 27.54 %
52.33 %
18.91 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.97 3.27
5.76 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 816
2,814 947
Percent 17.51 %
60.39 %
20.32 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.26 0.94
1.53 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4,364 7,028
2,610 Percent
30.84 %
49.67 %
18.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.71
2.34 4.23
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2,118 3,898
1,165 Percent
29.20 %
53.74 %
16.06 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.89
39.61 32.75
Race Known
Frequency
413 1,661
210 Percent
17.94 %
72.15 %
9.12 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.64
0.55 0.34
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
42
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 1 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 7,283
368 3,065
0 1
Percent 1.66 %
0.08 %
0.70 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2,749 144
1,274 0
0 Percent
1.77 %
0.09 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.75
39.13 41.57
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
4,534 224
1,791 0
1 Percent
1.60 %
0.08 %
0.63 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.25
60.87 58.43
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 145
19 66
0 0
Percent 0.77 %
0.10 %
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.99 5.16
2.15 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 41
6 36
0 0
Percent 0.88 %
0.13 %
0.77 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.56 1.63
1.17 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
104 13
30 0
0 Percent
0.74 %
0.09 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.43
3.53 0.98
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
39 8
25 0
0 Percent
0.54 %
0.11 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 26.90
42.11 37.88
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
13 1
4 0
0 Percent
0.56 %
0.04 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.18
0.27 0.13
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
43
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 1 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 53,981
264,356 52,392
Percent 14.20 %
69.52 %
13.78 %
Citations
Frequency
21,635 77,097
27,004 Percent
16.72 %
59.57 %
20.87 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.08
29.16 51.54
Warnings
Frequency
32,346 187,259
25,388 Percent
12.89 %
74.65 %
10.12 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.92
70.84 48.46
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,901
3,856 1,274
Percent 26.70 %
54.15 %
17.89 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.52 1.46
2.43 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 329
1,167 377
Percent 17.29 %
61.32 %
19.81 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.61 0.44
0.72 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,572 2,689
897 Percent
30.13 %
51.53 %
17.19 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.91
1.02 1.71
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1,065 2,144
667 Percent
27.20 %
54.75 %
17.03 %
Rate per 100 searches 56.02
55.60 52.35
Race Known
Frequency
700 3,146
517 Percent
15.76 %
70.84 %
11.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.30
1.19 0.99
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
44
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 1 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 5,415
269 3,842
5 3
Percent 1.42 %
0.07 %
1.01 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2,100 106
1,470 5
1 Percent
1.62 %
0.08 %
1.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.78
39.41 38.26
100.00 33.33
Warnings
Frequency
3,315 163
2,372 0
2 Percent
1.32 %
0.06 %
0.95 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.22
60.59 61.74
0.00 66.67
Searches (All)
Frequency 53
5 27
5 0
Percent 0.74 %
0.07 %
0.38 %
0.07 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.98 1.86
0.70 100.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 19
0 11
0 0
Percent 1.00 %
0.00 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.35 0.00
0.29 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
34 5
16 5
0 Percent
0.65 %
0.10 %
0.31 %
0.10 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.63
1.86 0.42
100.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
23 4
8 5
0 Percent
0.59 %
0.10 %
0.20 %
0.13 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 43.40
80.00 29.63
100.00 ---
Race Known
Frequency
31 2
45 0
0 Percent
0.70 %
0.05 %
1.01 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.57
0.74 1.17
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
45
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 1 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
7,145 18,557
11,785 Percent
18.56 %
48.21 %
30.62 %
Citations
Frequency 1,037
2,466 1,675
Percent 19.86 %
47.22 %
32.08 %
Rate per 100 stops
14.51 13.29
14.21 W
arnings
Frequency 4,010
9,491 7,112
Percent 19.11 %
45.24 %
33.90 %
Rate per 100 stops
56.12 51.15
60.35 Clean
Frequency
2,098 6,600
2,998 Percent
17.07 %
53.71 %
24.40 %
Rate per 100 stops 29.36
35.57 25.44
Searches (All)
Frequency 19
29 27
Percent 25.00 %
38.16 %
35.53 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.27 0.16
0.23 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 9
17 18
Percent 20.00 %
37.78 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.13 0.09
0.15 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
10 12
9 Percent
32.26 %
38.71 %
29.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.06 0.08
Contraband Hits
Frequency
6 14
4 Percent
25.00 %
58.33 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 searches 31.58
48.28 14.81
Race Known
Frequency
2 13
0 Percent
13.33 %
86.67 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.03
0.07 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
46
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 1 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 317
32 278
0 375
Percent 0.82 %
0.08 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.97 %
Citations
Frequency
12 4
28 0
0 Percent
0.23 %
0.08 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.79
12.50 10.07
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
200 13
144 0
9 Percent
0.95 %
0.06 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.09
40.63 51.80
--- 2.40
Clean
Frequency 105
15 106
0 366
Percent 0.85 %
0.12 %
0.86 %
0.00 %
2.98 %
Rate per 100 stops
33.12 46.88
38.13 ---
97.60 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
1.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
47
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 1 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
7,200 19,676
11,228 Percent
18.34 %
50.13 %
28.60 %
Citations
Frequency 1,061
2,613 1,776
Percent 19.28 %
47.48 %
32.27 %
Rate per 100 stops
14.74 13.28
15.82 W
arnings
Frequency 4,164
10,168 6,835
Percent 19.30 %
47.14 %
31.68 %
Rate per 100 stops
57.83 51.68
60.87 Clean
Frequency
1,975 6,895
2,617 Percent
16.22 %
56.62 %
21.49 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.43
35.04 23.31
Searches (All)
Frequency 6
18 10
Percent 17.14 %
51.43 %
28.57 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.08 0.09
0.09 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
10 8
Percent 9.52 %
47.62 %
38.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.03 0.05
0.07 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 8
2 Percent
28.57 %
57.14 %
14.29 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.06
0.04 0.02
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 7
1 Percent
27.27 %
63.64 %
9.09 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.00
38.89 10.00
Race Known
Frequency
1 8
3 Percent
8.33 %
66.67 %
25.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.01
0.04 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
48
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 1 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 282
20 361
8 478
Percent 0.72 %
0.05 %
0.92 %
0.02 %
1.22 %
Citations
Frequency
19 2
32 0
0 Percent
0.35 %
0.04 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.74
10.00 8.86
0.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
157 5
207 5
31 Percent
0.73 %
0.02 %
0.96 %
0.02 %
0.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 55.67
25.00 57.34
62.50 6.49
Clean
Frequency 106
13 122
3 447
Percent 0.87 %
0.11 %
1.00 %
0.02 %
3.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
37.59 65.00
33.80 37.50
93.51 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.35
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
4.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.35
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX A – REGION 1:DALLAS ANALYSIS
49
Appendix B Region 1: Dallas
District Level Analysis
50
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BA
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
C
D
Throckmorton
51
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 18,133
57,556 18,428
Percent 18.44 %
58.52 %
18.74 %
Citations
Frequency
7,826 18,420
9,512 Percent
20.93 %
49.26 %
25.44 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.16
32.00 51.62
Warnings
Frequency
10,307 39,136
8,916 Percent
16.91 %
64.20 %
14.63 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.84
68.00 48.38
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,525
1,825 999
Percent 34.50 %
41.29 %
22.60 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.41 3.17
5.42 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 237
561 312
Percent 20.92 %
49.51 %
27.54 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.31 0.97
1.69 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,288 1,264
687 Percent
39.18 %
38.45 %
20.90 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.10
2.20 3.73
Contraband Hits
Frequency
541 679
285 Percent
35.43 %
44.47 %
18.66 %
Rate per 100 searches 35.48
37.21 28.53
Race Known
Frequency
53 159
45 Percent
20.46 %
61.39 %
17.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.29
0.28 0.24
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
52
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,032
101 1,100
0 0
Percent 3.08 %
0.10 %
1.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,143 28
461 0
0 Percent
3.06 %
0.07 %
1.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.70
27.72 41.91
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,889 73
639 0
0 Percent
3.10 %
0.12 %
1.05 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.30
72.28 58.09
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 51
0 20
0 0
Percent 1.15 %
0.00 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.68 0.00
1.82 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 13
0 10
0 0
Percent 1.15 %
0.00 %
0.88 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.43 0.00
0.91 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
38 0
10 0
0 Percent
1.16 %
0.00 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.25
0.00 0.91
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
15 0
7 0
0 Percent
0.98 %
0.00 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 29.41
--- 35.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
2 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.77 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
53
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 13,349
42,624 13,331
Percent 18.43 %
58.85 %
18.41 %
Citations
Frequency
5,788 13,265
6,898 Percent
21.29 %
48.79 %
25.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.36
31.12 51.74
Warnings
Frequency
7,561 29,359
6,433 Percent
16.71 %
64.90 %
14.22 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.64
68.88 48.26
Searches (All)
Frequency 496
559 347
Percent 34.95 %
39.39 %
24.45 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.72 1.31
2.60 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 62
165 101
Percent 18.62 %
49.55 %
30.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.46 0.39
0.76 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
434 394
246 Percent
39.96 %
36.28 %
22.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.25
0.92 1.85
Contraband Hits
Frequency
270 296
165 Percent
36.49 %
40.00 %
22.30 %
Rate per 100 searches 54.44
52.95 47.55
Race Known
Frequency
43 93
24 Percent
26.54 %
57.41 %
14.81 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.22 0.18
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
54
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,894
43 1,185
0 0
Percent 2.62 %
0.06 %
1.64 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
767 20
450 0
0 Percent
2.82 %
0.07 %
1.66 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.50
46.51 37.97
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,127 23
735 0
0 Percent
2.49 %
0.05 %
1.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.50
53.49 62.03
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 9
0 8
0 0
Percent 0.63 %
0.00 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.48 0.00
0.68 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 3
0 0
Percent 0.60 %
0.00 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.11 0.00
0.25 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
7 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.64 %
0.00 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.37
0.00 0.42
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
6 0
3 0
0 Percent
0.81 %
0.00 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 66.67
--- 37.50
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
1.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.17
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
55
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,470
4,204 4,546
Percent 21.35 %
36.34 %
39.30 %
Citations
Frequency
296 422
592 Percent
22.48 %
32.04 %
44.95 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.98
10.04 13.02
Warnings
Frequency
1,553 2,409
2,926 Percent
22.16 %
34.37 %
41.75 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.87
57.30 64.36
Clean
Frequency 621
1,373 1,028
Percent 19.16 %
42.36 %
31.72 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.14 32.66
22.61 Searches (All)
Frequency
8 8
6 Percent
36.36 %
36.36 %
27.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.19 0.13
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 5
5 Percent
33.33 %
33.33 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.20
0.12 0.11
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
3 1
Percent 42.86 %
42.86 %
14.29 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.12 0.07
0.02 Contraband H
its
Frequency 2
4 0
Percent 33.33 %
66.67 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
25.00 50.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.04 0.02
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
56
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 94
8 64
0 181
Percent 0.81 %
0.07 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
1.56 %
Citations
Frequency
2 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.15 %
0.00 %
0.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.13
0.00 7.81
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
68 5
41 0
7 Percent
0.97 %
0.07 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 72.34
62.50 64.06
--- 3.87
Clean
Frequency 24
3 18
0 174
Percent 0.74 %
0.09 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
5.37 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.53 37.50
28.13 ---
96.13 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
57
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,123
4,071 4,058
Percent 19.83 %
38.02 %
37.90 %
Citations
Frequency
295 420
585 Percent
22.40 %
31.89 %
44.42 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.90
10.32 14.42
Warnings
Frequency
1,267 2,169
2,523 Percent
20.81 %
35.63 %
41.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.68
53.28 62.17
Clean
Frequency 561
1,482 950
Percent 16.98 %
44.85 %
28.75 %
Rate per 100 stops
26.42 36.40
23.41 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 3
6 Percent
25.00 %
25.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.07 0.15
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 3
5 Percent
11.11 %
33.33 %
55.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.05
0.07 0.12
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 1
Percent 66.67 %
0.00 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.09 0.00
0.02 Contraband H
its
Frequency 2
2 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
66.67 66.67
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
58
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 82
3 95
3 273
Percent 0.77 %
0.03 %
0.89 %
0.03 %
2.55 %
Citations
Frequency
4 1
12 .0
0 Percent
0.30 %
0.08 %
0.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.88
33.33 12.63
0.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
49 1
58 1
19 Percent
0.80 %
0.02 %
0.95 %
0.02 %
0.31 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.76
33.33 61.05
33.33 6.96
Clean
Frequency 29
1 25
2 254
Percent 0.88 %
0.03 %
0.76 %
0.06 %
7.69 %
Rate per 100 stops
35.37 33.33
26.32 66.67
93.04 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
59
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BA
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
C
D
60
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 24,063
94,289 15,559
Percent 17.73 %
69.49 %
11.47 %
Citations
Frequency
9,471 25,060
7,797 Percent
22.08 %
58.41 %
18.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.36
26.58 50.11
Warnings
Frequency
14,592 69,229
7,762 Percent
15.73 %
74.62 %
8.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.64
73.42 49.89
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,814
3,490 975
Percent 28.70 %
55.21 %
15.42 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.54 3.70
6.27 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 308
980 213
Percent 20.25 %
64.43 %
14.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.28 1.04
1.37 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,506 2,510
762 Percent
31.38 %
52.29 %
15.88 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.26
2.66 4.90
Contraband Hits
Frequency
830 1,495
327 Percent
31.07 %
55.97 %
12.24 %
Rate per 100 searches 45.76
42.84 33.54
Race Known
Frequency
162 609
62 Percent
19.35 %
72.76 %
7.41 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.67
0.65 0.40
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
61
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,154
69 548
0 0
Percent 0.85 %
0.05 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
363 30
181 0
0 Percent
0.85 %
0.07 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 31.46
43.48 33.03
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
791 39
367 0
0 Percent
0.85 %
0.04 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 68.54
56.52 66.97
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 26
2 14
0 0
Percent 0.41 %
0.03 %
0.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.25 2.90
2.55 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 8
1 11
0 0
Percent 0.53 %
0.07 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.69 1.45
2.01 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
18 1
3 0
0 Percent
0.38 %
0.02 %
0.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.56
1.45 0.55
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
10 2
7 0
0 Percent
0.37 %
0.07 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 38.46
100.00 50.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
3 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.26
0.00 0.18
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
62
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 20,974
83,773 13,510
Percent 17.49 %
69.86 %
11.27 %
Citations
Frequency
8,015 22,255
7,016 Percent
21.18 %
58.82 %
18.54 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.21
26.57 51.93
Warnings
Frequency
12,959 61,518
6,494 Percent
15.79 %
74.95 %
7.91 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.79
73.43 48.07
Searches (All)
Frequency 750
1,442 349
Percent 29.22 %
56.17 %
13.60 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.58 1.72
2.58 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 141
492 101
Percent 19.03 %
66.40 %
13.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.67 0.59
0.75 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
609 950
248 Percent
33.35 %
52.03 %
13.58 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.90
1.13 1.84
Contraband Hits
Frequency
401 757
186 Percent
29.64 %
55.95 %
13.75 %
Rate per 100 searches 53.47
52.50 53.30
Race Known
Frequency
150 593
71 Percent
18.38 %
72.67 %
8.70 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.72
0.71 0.53
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
63
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 976
52 630
5 0
Percent 0.81 %
0.04 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
318 18
211 5
0 Percent
0.84 %
0.05 %
0.56 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 32.58
34.62 33.49
100.00 ---
Warnings
Frequency
658 34
419 0
0 Percent
0.80 %
0.04 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 67.42
65.38 66.51
0.00 ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 12
2 7
5 0
Percent 0.47 %
0.08 %
0.27 %
0.19 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.23 3.85
1.11 100.00
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
0 3
0 0
Percent 0.54 %
0.00 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.41 0.00
0.48 0.00
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
8 2
4 5
0 Percent
0.44 %
0.11 %
0.22 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.82
3.85 0.63
100.00 ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2 1
1 5
0 Percent
0.15 %
0.07 %
0.07 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 16.67
50.00 14.29
100.00 ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 1
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.12 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
1.92 0.16
0.00 ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
64
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,668
3,772 918
Percent 25.97 %
58.73 %
14.29 %
Citations
Frequency
343 632
129 Percent
30.87 %
56.89 %
11.61 %
Rate per 100 stops 20.56
16.76 14.05
Warnings
Frequency
821 1,654
447 Percent
27.81 %
56.03 %
15.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.22
43.85 48.69
Clean
Frequency 504
1,486 342
Percent 21.36 %
62.97 %
14.49 %
Rate per 100 stops
30.22 39.40
37.25 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 1
3 Percent
16.67 %
16.67 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.06
0.03 0.33
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 1
2 Percent
20.00 %
20.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.06
0.03 0.22
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.11 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 0.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
65
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 31
9 25
0 0
Percent 0.48 %
0.14 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2 2
3 0
0 Percent
0.18 %
0.18 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.45
22.22 12.00
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
15 3
12 0
0 Percent
0.51 %
0.10 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.39
33.33 48.00
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 14
4 10
0 0
Percent 0.59 %
0.17 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
45.16 44.44
40.00 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
16.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.23
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
20.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.23
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
66
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,146
5,067 1,166
Percent 25.27 %
59.67 %
13.73 %
Citations
Frequency
369 719
170 Percent
29.06 %
56.61 %
13.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 17.19
14.19 14.58
Warnings
Frequency
1,161 2,371
614 Percent
27.60 %
56.37 %
14.60 %
Rate per 100 stops 54.10
46.79 52.66
Clean
Frequency 616
1,977 382
Percent 20.42 %
65.55 %
12.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.70 39.02
32.76 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 2
2 Percent
20.00 %
40.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.05
0.04 0.17
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 1
2 Percent
0.00 %
33.33 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.02 0.17
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.05 0.02
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 50.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
67
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 51
4 57
0 1
Percent 0.60 %
0.05 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Citations
Frequency
3 .0
9 0
0 Percent
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.71 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.88
0.00 15.79
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
26 2
32 0
0 Percent
0.62 %
0.05 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.98
50.00 56.14
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 22
2 16
0 1
Percent 0.73 %
0.07 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.03 %
Rate per 100 stops
43.14 50.00
28.07 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
68
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BA
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
C
D
Throckmorton
69
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 11,000
93,597 19,824
Percent 8.63 %
73.43 %
15.55 %
Citations
Frequency
5,438 33,319
10,787 Percent
10.69 %
65.48 %
21.20 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.44
35.60 54.41
Warnings
Frequency
5,562 60,278
9,037 Percent
7.26 %
78.72 %
11.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.56
64.40 45.59
Searches (All)
Frequency 918
2,661 1,087
Percent 19.37 %
56.15 %
22.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.35 2.84
5.48 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 120
654 242
Percent 11.54 %
62.88 %
23.27 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.09 0.70
1.22 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
798 2,007
845 Percent
21.57 %
54.26 %
22.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.25
2.14 4.26
Contraband Hits
Frequency
387 1,084
413 Percent
20.33 %
56.93 %
21.69 %
Rate per 100 searches 42.16
40.74 37.99
Race Known
Frequency
136 541
94 Percent
17.37 %
69.09 %
12.01 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.24
0.58 0.47
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
70
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 2,103
111 820
0 1
Percent 1.65 %
0.09 %
0.64 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
900 51
392 0
0 Percent
1.77 %
0.10 %
0.77 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.80
45.95 47.80
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,203 60
428 0
1 Percent
1.57 %
0.08 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.20
54.05 52.20
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 50
7 16
0 0
Percent 1.06 %
0.15 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.38 6.31
1.95 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 16
3 5
0 0
Percent 1.54 %
0.29 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.76 2.70
0.61 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
34 4
11 0
0 Percent
0.92 %
0.11 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.62
3.60 1.34
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
10 2
8 0
0 Percent
0.53 %
0.11 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 20.00
28.57 50.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
8 1
3 0
0 Percent
1.02 %
0.13 %
0.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.38
0.90 0.37
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
71
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 9,441
83,356 17,917
Percent 8.31 %
73.40 %
15.78 %
Citations
Frequency
4,269 27,676
9,558 Percent
10.00 %
64.86 %
22.40 %
Rate per 100 stops 45.22
33.20 53.35
Warnings
Frequency
5,172 55,680
8,359 Percent
7.30 %
78.55 %
11.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 54.78
66.80 46.65
Searches (All)
Frequency 425
1,370 476
Percent 18.43 %
59.41 %
20.64 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.50 1.64
2.66 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 91
368 143
Percent 14.80 %
59.84 %
23.25 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.96 0.44
0.80 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
334 1,002
333 Percent
19.75 %
59.25 %
19.69 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.54
1.20 1.86
Contraband Hits
Frequency
260 852
282 Percent
18.44 %
60.43 %
20.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 61.18
62.19 59.24
Race Known
Frequency
416 1,861
406 Percent
15.10 %
67.55 %
14.74 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.41
2.23 2.27
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
72
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,615
95 1,134
0 2
Percent 1.42 %
0.08 %
1.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
640 36
493 0
1 Percent
1.50 %
0.08 %
1.16 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.63
37.89 43.47
--- 50.00
Warnings
Frequency
975 59
641 0
1 Percent
1.38 %
0.08 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.37
62.11 56.53
--- 50.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 25
3 7
0 0
Percent 1.08 %
0.13 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.55 3.16
0.62 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 11
0 2
0 0
Percent 1.79 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.68 0.00
0.18 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
14 3
5 0
0 Percent
0.83 %
0.18 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.87
3.16 0.44
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
11 3
2 0
0 Percent
0.78 %
0.21 %
0.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 44.00
100.00 28.57
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
30 0
42 0
0 Percent
1.09 %
0.00 %
1.52 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.86
0.00 3.70
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
73
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,185
7,015 5,479
Percent 14.44 %
46.37 %
36.22 %
Citations
Frequency
296 1,027
856 Percent
13.45 %
46.68 %
38.91 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.55
14.64 15.62
Warnings
Frequency
1,282 3,905
3,347 Percent
14.73 %
44.86 %
38.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.67
55.67 61.09
Clean
Frequency 607
2,083 1,276
Percent 14.37 %
49.33 %
30.22 %
Rate per 100 stops
27.78 29.69
23.29 Searches (All)
Frequency
7 10
10 Percent
25.93 %
37.04 %
37.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.32
0.14 0.18
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3 5
4 Percent
25.00 %
41.67 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.07 0.07
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
5 6
Percent 26.67 %
33.33 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.18 0.07
0.11 Contraband H
its
Frequency 2
7 2
Percent 18.18 %
63.64 %
18.18 %
Rate per 100 searches
28.57 70.00
20.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
2 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.03
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
74
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 159
6 130
0 154
Percent 1.05 %
0.04 %
0.86 %
0.00 %
1.02 %
Citations
Frequency
7 0
14 0
0 Percent
0.32 %
0.00 %
0.64 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.40
0.00 10.77
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
99 2
68 0
2 Percent
1.14 %
0.02 %
0.78 %
00.0 %
0.02 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.26
33.33 52.31
--- 1.30
Clean
Frequency 53
4 48
0 152
Percent 1.26 %
0.09 %
1.14 %
0.00 %
3.60 %
Rate per 100 stops
33.33 66.67
36.92 ---
98.70 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
75
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,980
6,805 5,141
Percent 13.80 %
47.43 %
35.83 %
Citations
Frequency
297 1,140
916 Percent
12.52 %
48.06 %
38.62 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.00
16.75 17.82
Warnings
Frequency
1,264 3,943
3,275 Percent
14.60 %
45.55 %
37.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.84
57.94 63.70
Clean
Frequency 419
1,722 950
Percent 12.62 %
51.88 %
28.62 %
Rate per 100 stops
21.16 25.30
18.48 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 5
1 Percent
22.22 %
55.56 %
11.11 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.07 0.02
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 5
1 Percent
12.50 %
62.50 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.05
0.07 0.02
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 0
Percent 100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.05 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
2 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 40.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
4 2
Percent 14.29 %
57.14 %
28.57 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.05 0.06
0.04
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
76
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 119
4 148
5 145
Percent 0.83 %
0.03 %
1.03 %
0.03 %
1.01 %
Citations
Frequency
11 0
8 0
0 Percent
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 9.24
0.00 5.41
0.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
67 1
90 4
12 Percent
0.77 %
0.01 %
1.04 %
0.05 %
0.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.30
25.00 60.81
80.00 8.28
Clean
Frequency 41
3 50
1 133
Percent 1.24 %
0.09 %
1.51 %
0.03 %
4.01 %
Rate per 100 stops
34.45 75.00
33.78 20.00
91.72 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
11.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.84
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
12.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.84
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
77
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BA
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
C
D
Throckmorton
78
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1D 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 11,799
55,084 7,907
Percent 15.43 %
72.04 %
10.34 %
Citations
Frequency
4,451 15,272
3,760 Percent
18.47 %
63.37 %
15.60 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.72
27.72 47.55
Warnings
Frequency
7,348 39,812
4,147 Percent
14.03 %
76.02 %
7.92 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.28
72.28 52.45
Searches (All)
Frequency 923
1,866 496
Percent 27.73 %
56.05 %
14.90 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.82 3.39
6.27 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 151
619 180
Percent 15.63 %
64.08 %
18.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.28 1.12
2.28 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
772 1,247
316 Percent
32.67 %
52.77 %
13.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.54
2.26 4.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
360 640
140 Percent
31.28 %
55.60 %
12.16 %
Rate per 100 searches 39.00
34.30 28.23
Race Known
Frequency
62 352
9 Percent
14.66 %
83.22 %
2.13 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.53
0.64 0.11
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
79
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 1D 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 994
87 597
0 0
Percent 1.30 %
0.11 %
0.78 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
343 35
240 0
0 Percent
1.42 %
0.15 %
1.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.51
40.23 40.20
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
651 52
357 0
0 Percent
1.24 %
0.10 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.49
59.77 59.80
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 18
10 16
0 0
Percent 0.54 %
0.30 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.81 11.49
2.68 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
2 10
0 0
Percent 0.41 %
0.21 %
1.04 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.40 2.30
1.68 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
14 8
6 0
0 Percent
0.59 %
0.34 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.41
9.20 1.01
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
4 4
3 0
0 Percent
0.35 %
0.35 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 22.22
40.00 18.75
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
80
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1D 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 10,217
54,603 7,634
Percent 13.74 %
73.43 %
10.27 %
Citations
Frequency
3,563 13,901
3,532 Percent
16.40 %
64.00 %
16.26 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.87
25.46 46.27
Warnings
Frequency
6,654 40,702
4,102 Percent
12.64 %
77.32 %
7.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.13
74.54 53.73
Searches (All)
Frequency 230
485 102
Percent 27.74 %
58.50 %
12.30 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.25 0.89
1.34 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 35
142 32
Percent 16.36 %
66.36 %
14.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.34 0.26
0.42 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
195 343
70 Percent
31.71 %
55.77 %
11.38 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.91
0.63 0.92
Contraband Hits
Frequency
134 239
34 Percent
32.45 %
57.87 %
8.23 %
Rate per 100 searches 58.26
49.28 33.33
Race Known
Frequency
91 599
16 Percent
12.85 %
84.60 %
2.26 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.89
1.10 0.21
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
81
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 1D 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 930
79 893
0 1
Percent 1.25 %
0.11 %
1.20 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
375 32
316 0
0 Percent
1.73 %
0.15 %
1.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.32
40.51 35.39
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
555 47
577 0
1 Percent
1.05 %
0.09 %
1.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.68
59.49 64.61
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 7
0 5
0 0
Percent 0.84 %
0.00 %
0.60 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.75 0.00
0.56 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 3
0 0
Percent 0.93 %
0.00 %
1.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.22 0.00
0.34 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.81 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.54
0.00 0.22
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
4 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.97 %
0.00 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 57.14
--- 40.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 1
0 0
0 Percent
0.14 %
0.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.11
1.27 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
82
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1D
2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
822 3,566
842 Percent
15.30 %
66.39 %
15.68 %
Citations
Frequency 102
385 98
Percent 17.17 %
64.81 %
16.50 %
Rate per 100 stops
12.41 10.80
11.64 W
arnings
Frequency 354
1,523 392
Percent 15.30 %
65.85 %
16.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
43.07 42.71
46.56 Clean
Frequency
366 1,658
352 Percent
14.85 %
67.29 %
14.29 %
Rate per 100 stops 44.53
46.49 41.81
Searches (All)
Frequency 3
10 8
Percent 14.29 %
47.62 %
38.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 0.28
0.95 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
6 7
Percent 0.00 %
46.15 %
53.85 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.17
0.83 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3 4
1 Percent
37.50 %
50.00 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.36
0.11 0.12
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2 3
2 Percent
28.57 %
42.86 %
28.57 %
Rate per 100 searches 66.67
30.00 25.00
Race Known
Frequency
1 10
0 Percent
9.09 %
90.91 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.28 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
83
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 1D
2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 33
9 59
0 40
Percent 0.61 %
0.17 %
1.10 %
0.00 %
0.74 %
Citations
Frequency
1 2
6 0
0 Percent
0.17 %
0.34 %
1.01 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.03
22.22 10.17
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
18 3
23 0
0 Percent
0.78 %
0.13 %
0.99 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 54.55
33.33 38.98
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 14
4 30
0 40
Percent 0.57 %
0.16 %
1.22 %
0.00 %
1.62 %
Rate per 100 stops
42.42 44.44
50.85 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
84
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1D
2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
951 3,733
863 Percent
16.67 %
65.42 %
15.12 %
Citations
Frequency 100
334 105
Percent 18.38 %
61.40 %
19.30 %
Rate per 100 stops
10.52 8.95
12.17 W
arnings
Frequency 472
1,685 423
Percent 17.99 %
64.24 %
16.13 %
Rate per 100 stops
49.63 45.14
49.02 Clean
Frequency
379 1,714
335 Percent
14.93 %
67.51 %
13.19 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.85
45.91 38.82
Searches (All)
Frequency 0
8 1
Percent 0.00 %
88.89 %
11.11 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.21
0.12 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.03
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 7
1 Percent
0.00 %
87.50 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.19 0.12
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 2
1 Percent
0.00 %
66.67 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 searches ---
25.00 100.00
Race Known
Frequency
0 4
0 Percent
0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.11 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
85
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 1D
2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 30
9 61
0 59
Percent 0.53 %
0.16 %
1.07 %
0.00 %
1.03 %
Citations
Frequency
1 1
3 0
0 Percent
0.18 %
0.18 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.33
11.11 4.92
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
15 1
27 0
0 Percent
0.57 %
0.04 %
1.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.00
11.11 44.26
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 14
7 31
0 59
Percent 0.55 %
0.28 %
1.22 %
0.00 %
2.32 %
Rate per 100 stops
46.67 77.78
50.82 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX B – REGION 1:DALLAS – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
86
Appendix C Region 2: Houston Analysis
87
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
88
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 2 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 93,233
222,653 101,906
Percent 21.43 %
51.18 %
23.42 %
Citations
Frequency
39,764 69,128
53,869 Percent
23.51 %
40.88 %
31.86 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.65
31.05 52.86
Warnings
Frequency
53,469 153,525
48,037 Percent
20.11 %
57.73 %
18.06 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.35
68.95 47.14
Searches (All)
Frequency 7,428
8,880 6,012
Percent 32.77 %
39.18 %
26.52 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.97 3.99
5.90 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1,416
2,556 1,445
Percent 25.60 %
46.21 %
26.13 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.52 1.15
1.42 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
6,012 6,324
4,567 Percent
35.09 %
36.91 %
26.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.45
2.84 4.48
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2,801 3,521
2,149 Percent
32.57 %
40.94 %
24.99 %
Rate per 100 searches 37.71
39.65 35.75
Race Known
Frequency
364 1,294
434 Percent
17.13 %
60.89 %
20.42 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.39
0.58 0.43
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
89
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 2 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 11,782
494 4,964
0 0
Percent 2.71 %
0.11 %
1.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
4,144 175
2,023 0
0 Percent
2.45 %
0.10 %
1.20 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 35.17
35.43 40.75
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
7,638 319
2,941 0
0 Percent
2.87 %
0.12 %
1.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 64.83
64.57 59.25
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 226
18 102
0 0
Percent 1.00 %
0.08 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.92 3.64
2.05 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 73
6 35
0 0
Percent 1.32 %
0.11 %
0.63 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.62 1.21
0.71 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
153 12
67 0
0 Percent
0.89 %
0.07 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.30
2.43 1.35
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
89 5
35 0
0 Percent
1.03 %
0.06 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 39.38
27.78 34.31
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
26 1
6 0
0 Percent
1.22 %
0.05 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.22
0.20 0.12
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
90
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 2 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 69,449
195,278 80,264
Percent 19.28 %
54.21 %
22.28 %
Citations
Frequency
29,583 64,199
44,204 Percent
20.57 %
44.63 %
30.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.60
32.88 55.07
Warnings
Frequency
39,866 131,079
36,060 Percent
18.42 %
60.58 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.40
67.12 44.93
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,936
3,107 1,672
Percent 28.44 %
45.64 %
24.56 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.79 1.59
2.08 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 389
849 374
Percent 23.71 %
51.74 %
22.79 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.56 0.43
0.47 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,547 2,258
1,298 Percent
29.95 %
43.71 %
25.13 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.23
1.16 1.62
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1,014 1,835
956 Percent
26.30 %
47.60 %
24.80 %
Rate per 100 searches 52.38
59.06 57.18
Race Known
Frequency
162 702
232 Percent
14.52 %
62.90 %
20.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.23
0.36 0.29
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
91
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 2 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 8,728
329 6,166
0 5
Percent 2.42 %
0.09 %
1.71 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
3,230 121
2,508 0
0 Percent
2.25 %
0.08 %
1.74 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.01
36.78 40.67
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
5,498 208
3,658 0
5 Percent
2.54 %
0.10 %
1.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.99
63.22 59.33
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 53
3 36
0 0
Percent 0.78 %
0.04 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.61 0.91
0.58 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 15
2 12
0 0
Percent 0.91 %
0.12 %
0.73 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.17 0.61
0.19 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
38 1
24 0
0 Percent
0.74 %
0.02 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.44
0.30 0.39
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
29 1
20 0
0 Percent
0.75 %
0.03 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 54.72
33.33 55.56
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
11 1
8 0
0 Percent
0.99 %
0.09 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.13
0.30 0.13
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
92
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 2 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
5,713 8,618
9,526 Percent
23.50 %
35.44 %
39.18 %
Citations
Frequency 1,780
2,327 2,672
Percent 26.03 %
34.03 %
39.08 %
Rate per 100 stops
31.16 27.00
28.05 W
arnings
Frequency 2,638
3,928 4,651
Percent 23.21 %
34.56 %
40.92 %
Rate per 100 stops
46.18 45.58
48.82 Clean
Frequency
1,295 2,363
2,203 Percent
21.19 %
38.67 %
36.05 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.67
27.42 23.13
Searches (All)
Frequency 38
24 109
Percent 22.22 %
14.04 %
63.74 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.67 0.28
1.14 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 30
21 103
Percent 19.48 %
13.64 %
66.88 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.53 0.24
1.08 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
8 3
6 Percent
47.06 %
17.65 %
35.29 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.03 0.06
Contraband Hits
Frequency
5 2
1 Percent
62.50 %
25.00 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 searches 13.16
8.33 0.92
Race Known
Frequency
1 1
0 Percent
50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.02
0.01 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
93
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 2 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 133
12 111
0 202
Percent 0.55 %
0.05 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.83 %
Citations
Frequency
33 3
23 0
0 Percent
0.48 %
0.04 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.81
25.00 20.72
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
77 5
59 0
8 Percent
0.68 %
0.04 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.07 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.89
41.67 53.15
--- 3.96
Clean
Frequency 23
4 29
0 194
Percent 0.38 %
0.07 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
3.17 %
Rate per 100 stops
17.29 33.33
26.13 ---
96.04 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
94
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 2 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
6,066 9,534
10,401 Percent
22.88 %
35.96 %
39.23 %
Citations
Frequency 1,678
2,433 2,812
Percent 24.05 %
34.88 %
40.31 %
Rate per 100 stops
27.66 25.52
27.04 W
arnings
Frequency 2,918
4,347 5,106
Percent 23.28 %
34.68 %
40.74 %
Rate per 100 stops
48.10 45.59
49.09 Clean
Frequency
1,470 2,754
2,483 Percent
21.00 %
39.34 %
35.47 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.23
28.89 23.87
Searches (All)
Frequency 6
7 16
Percent 20.69 %
24.14 %
55.17 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.10 0.07
0.15 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
3 15
Percent 14.29 %
14.29 %
71.43 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.05 0.03
0.14 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3 4
1 Percent
37.50 %
50.00 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.05
0.04 0.01
Contraband Hits
Frequency
5 2
2 Percent
55.56 %
22.22 %
22.22 %
Rate per 100 searches 83.33
28.57 12.50
Race Known
Frequency
2 3
1 Percent
33.33 %
50.00 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.03
0.03 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
95
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 2 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 132
7 156
0 214
Percent 0.50 %
0.03 %
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.81 %
Citations
Frequency
21 2
30 0
0 Percent
0.30 %
0.03 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.91
28.57 19.23
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
74 3
74 0
12 Percent
0.59 %
0.02 %
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.06
42.86 47.44
--- 5.61
Clean
Frequency 37
2 52
0 202
Percent 0.53 %
0.03 %
0.74 %
0.00 %
2.89 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.03 28.57
33.33 ---
94.39 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX C – REGION 2:HOUSTON ANALYSIS
96
Appendix D Region 2: Houston
District Level Analysis
97
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
98
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 41,993
49,980 48,115
Percent 28.62 %
34.06 %
32.79 %
Citations
Frequency
20,370 21,610
27,951 Percent
28.08 %
29.79 %
38.53 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.51
43.24 58.09
Warnings
Frequency
21,623 28,370
20,164 Percent
29.14 %
38.23 %
27.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.49
56.76 41.91
Searches (All)
Frequency 3,675
2,763 2,700
Percent 39.67 %
29.83 %
29.15 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.75 5.53
5.61 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 651
797 501
Percent 32.91 %
40.29 %
25.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.55 1.59
1.04 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3,024 1,966
2,199 Percent
41.50 %
26.98 %
30.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.20
3.93 4.57
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1,318 1,140
947 Percent
38.20 %
33.04 %
27.45 %
Rate per 100 searches 35.86
41.26 35.07
Race Known
Frequency
224 691
322 Percent
17.78 %
54.84 %
25.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.53
1.38 0.67
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
99
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 4,627
160 1,869
0 0
Percent 3.15 %
0.11 %
1.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,714 54
837 0
0 Percent
2.36 %
0.07 %
1.15 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.04
33.75 44.78
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
2,913 106
1,032 0
0 Percent
3.93 %
0.14 %
1.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.96
66.25 55.22
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 77
7 42
0 0
Percent 0.83 %
0.08 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.66 4.38
2.25 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 19
2 8
0 0
Percent 0.96 %
0.10 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.41 1.25
0.43 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
58 5
34 0
0 Percent
0.80 %
0.07 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.25
3.13 1.82
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
33 0
12 0
0 Percent
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 42.86
0.00 28.57
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
19 1
3 0
0 Percent
1.51 %
0.08 %
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.41
0.63 0.16
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
100
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 24,888
42,131 31,577
Percent 23.92 %
40.49 %
30.35 %
Citations
Frequency
12,503 19,134
19,804 Percent
23.25 %
35.59 %
36.83 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.24
45.42 62.72
Warnings
Frequency
12,385 22,997
11,773 Percent
24.63 %
45.74 %
23.42 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.76
54.58 37.28
Searches (All)
Frequency 740
925 682
Percent 31.18 %
38.98 %
28.74 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.97 2.20
2.16 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 133
201 114
Percent 29.36 %
44.37 %
25.17 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.53 0.48
0.36 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
607 724
568 Percent
31.61 %
37.71 %
29.58 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.44
1.72 1.80
Contraband Hits
Frequency
379 575
393 Percent
27.83 %
42.22 %
28.85 %
Rate per 100 searches 51.22
62.16 57.62
Race Known
Frequency
88 183
135 Percent
21.31 %
44.31 %
32.69 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.35
0.43 0.43
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
101
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,337
84 2,024
0 2
Percent 3.21 %
0.08 %
1.95 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,316 49
962 0
0 Percent
2.45 %
0.09 %
1.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.44
58.33 47.53
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
2,021 35
1,062 0
2 Percent
4.02 %
0.07 %
2.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.56
41.67 52.47
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 12
2 12
0 0
Percent 0.51 %
0.08 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 2.38
0.59 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
1 3
0 0
Percent 0.22 %
0.22 %
0.66 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.03 1.19
0.15 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
11 1
9 0
0 Percent
0.57 %
0.05 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.33
1.19 0.44
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
7 1
7 0
0 Percent
0.51 %
0.07 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 58.33
50.00 58.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
5 1
1 0
0 Percent
1.21 %
0.24 %
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.15
1.19 0.05
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
102
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,638
1,609 3,939
Percent 22.05 %
21.66 %
53.01 %
Citations
Frequency
440 349
1,066 Percent
23.48 %
18.62 %
56.88 %
Rate per 100 stops 26.86
21.69 27.06
Warnings
Frequency
721 658
1,894 Percent
21.70 %
19.81 %
57.01 %
Rate per 100 stops 44.02
40.89 48.08
Clean
Frequency 477
602 979
Percent 21.35 %
26.95 %
43.82 %
Rate per 100 stops
29.12 37.41
24.85 Searches (All)
Frequency
4 1
7 Percent
33.33 %
8.33 %
58.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.24
0.06 0.18
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 1
4 Percent
28.57 %
14.29 %
57.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.06 0.10
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 3
Percent 40.00 %
0.00 %
60.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.12 0.00
0.08 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 0.00
14.29 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
1 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.06
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
103
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 48
6 35
0 155
Percent 0.65 %
0.08 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
2.09 %
Citations
Frequency
13 2
4 0
0 Percent
0.69 %
0.11 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.08
33.33 11.43
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
28 2
19 0
0 Percent
0.84 %
0.06 %
0.57 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.33
33.33 54.29
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 7
2 12
0 155
Percent 0.31 %
0.09 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
6.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
14.58 33.33
34.29 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
104
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,786
1,832 4,452
Percent 21.51 %
22.06 %
53.62 %
Citations
Frequency
462 429
1,253 Percent
21.31 %
19.79 %
57.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 25.87
23.42 28.14
Warnings
Frequency
823 766
2,187 Percent
21.50 %
20.01 %
57.13 %
Rate per 100 stops 46.08
41.81 49.12
Clean
Frequency 501
637 1,012
Percent 21.72 %
27.61 %
43.87 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.05 34.77
22.73 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
3 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.07
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
2 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.04
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.02 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
33.33 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
105
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 45
3 40
0 145
Percent 0.54 %
0.04 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
1.75 %
Citations
Frequency
11 1
12 0
0 Percent
0.51 %
0.05 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.44
33.33 30.00
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
25 1
20 0
6 Percent
0.65 %
0.03 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.16 %
Rate per 100 stops 55.56
33.33 50.00
--- 4.14
Clean
Frequency 9
1 8
0 139
Percent 0.39
0.04 0.35
0.00 6.03
Rate per 100 stops 20.00
33.33 20.00
--- 95.86
Searches (All)
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.000 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches ---
--- ---
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
106
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
107
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 20,393
83,600 11,966
Percent 17.31 %
70.96 %
10.16 %
Citations
Frequency
7,117 20,324
5,574 Percent
21.19 %
60.51 %
16.60 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.90
24.31 46.58
Warnings
Frequency
13,276 63,276
6,392 Percent
15.76 %
75.13 %
7.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.10
75.69 53.42
Searches (All)
Frequency 909
1,939 452
Percent 27.25 %
58.12 %
13.55 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.46 2.32
3.78 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 180
554 119
Percent 20.74 %
63.82 %
13.71 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.88 0.66
0.99 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
729 1,385
333 Percent
29.54 %
56.12 %
13.49 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.57
1.66 2.78
Contraband Hits
Frequency
317 673
144 Percent
27.71 %
58.83 %
12.59 %
Rate per 100 searches 34.87
34.71 31.86
Race Known
Frequency
31 324
12 Percent
8.45 %
88.28 %
3.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.15
0.39 0.10
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
108
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,242
105 502
0 0
Percent 1.05 %
0.09 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
361 34
178 0
0 Percent
1.07 %
0.10 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 29.07
32.38 35.46
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
881 71
324 0
0 Percent
1.05 %
0.08 %
0.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 70.93
67.62 64.54
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 23
2 11
0 0
Percent 0.69 %
0.06 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.85 1.90
2.19 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 9
1 5
0 0
Percent 1.04 %
0.12 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.72 0.95
1.00 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
14 1
6 0
0 Percent
0.57 %
0.04 %
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.13
0.95 1.20
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
6 2
2 0
0 Percent
0.52 %
0.17 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 26.09
100.00 18.18
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
109
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 17,703
71,909 10,506
Percent 17.36 %
70.52 %
10.30 %
Citations
Frequency
6,420 19,002
5,190 Percent
20.57 %
60.89 %
16.63 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.27
26.43 49.40
Warnings
Frequency
11,283 52,907
5,316 Percent
15.94 %
74.76 %
7.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.73
73.57 50.60
Searches (All)
Frequency 262
772 134
Percent 22.32 %
65.76 %
11.41 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.48 1.07
1.28 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 57
205 40
Percent 18.75 %
67.43 %
13.16 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.32 0.29
0.38 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
205 567
94 Percent
23.56 %
65.17 %
10.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.16
0.79 0.89
Contraband Hits
Frequency
132 447
61 Percent
20.56 %
69.63 %
9.50 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.38
57.90 45.52
Race Known
Frequency
22 232
10 Percent
8.21 %
86.57 %
3.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.32 0.10
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
110
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 981
68 808
0 0
Percent 0.96 %
0.07 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
311 23
260 0
0 Percent
1.00 %
0.07 %
0.83 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 31.70
33.82 32.18
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
670 45
548 0
0 Percent
0.95 %
0.06 %
0.77 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 68.30
66.18 67.82
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 5
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.43 %
0.00 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.51 0.00
0.12 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.33 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.10 0.00
0.12 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.41
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.00
--- 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
3 0
1 0
0 Percent
1.12 %
0.00 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.31
0.00 0.12
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
111
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,438
4,458 1,383
Percent 29.07 %
53.16 %
16.49 %
Citations
Frequency
769 1,210
240 Percent
34.44 %
54.19 %
10.75 %
Rate per 100 stops 31.54
27.14 17.35
Warnings
Frequency
1,149 2,055
704 Percent
28.99 %
51.85 %
17.76 %
Rate per 100 stops 47.13
46.10 50.90
Clean
Frequency 520
1,193 439
Percent 23.74 %
54.47 %
20.05 %
Rate per 100 stops
21.33 26.76
31.74 Searches (All)
Frequency
5 4
2 Percent
45.45 %
36.36 %
18.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.21
0.09 0.14
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 2
2 Percent
20.00 %
40.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.04
0.04 0.14
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
2 0
Percent 66.67 %
33.33 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.16 0.04
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 5
2 0
Percent 71.43 %
28.57 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 50.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 0
Percent 100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.04 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
112
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 44
5 42
0 16
Percent 0.52 %
0.06 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.19 %
Citations
Frequency
8 0
6 0
0 Percent
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 18.18
0.00 14.29
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
26 3
22 0
4 Percent
0.66 %
0.08 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.09
60.00 52.38
--- 25.00
Clean
Frequency 10
2 14
0 12
Percent 0.46 %
0.09 %
0.64 %
0.00 %
0.55 %
Rate per 100 stops
22.73 40.00
33.33 ---
75.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
113
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,589
4,977 1,481
Percent 28.21 %
54.24 %
16.14 %
Citations
Frequency
718 1,320
275 Percent
30.92 %
56.85 %
11.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.73
26.52 18.57
Warnings
Frequency
1,248 2,231
729 Percent
29.28 %
52.33 %
17.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.20
44.83 49.22
Clean
Frequency 623
1,426 477
Percent 24.04 %
55.04 %
18.41 %
Rate per 100 stops
24.06 28.65
32.21 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 5
7 Percent
20.00 %
33.33 %
46.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.10 0.47
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 1
7 Percent
11.11 %
11.11 %
77.78 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.04
0.02 0.47
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
4 0
Percent 33.33 %
66.67 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.08 0.08
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 3
2 0
Percent 60.00 %
40.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 40.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
3 0
Percent 25.00 %
75.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.04 0.06
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
114
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 39
2 72
0 16
Percent 0.43 %
0.02 %
0.78 %
0.00 %
0.17 %
Citations
Frequency
2 1
6 0
0 Percent
0.09 %
0.04 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.13
50.00 8.33
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
20 1
32 0
2 Percent
0.47 %
0.02 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.05 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.28
50.00 44.44
--- 12.50
Clean
Frequency 17
0 34
0 14
Percent 0.66 %
0.00 %
1.31 %
0.00 %
0.54 %
Rate per 100 stops
43.59 0.00
47.22 ---
87.50 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
115
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
116
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 22,540
63,078 33,294
Percent 17.96 %
50.25 %
26.52 %
Citations
Frequency
9,515 21,131
16,702 Percent
19.09 %
42.39 %
33.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.21
33.50 50.17
Warnings
Frequency
13,025 41,947
16,592 Percent
17.21 %
55.42 %
21.92 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.79
66.50 49.83
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,973
3,063 2,145
Percent 26.99 %
41.90 %
29.34 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.75 4.86
6.44 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 446
893 614
Percent 22.31 %
44.67 %
30.72 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.98 1.42
1.84 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,527 2,170
1,531 Percent
28.75 %
40.86 %
28.83 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.77
3.44 4.60
Contraband Hits
Frequency
810 1,191
751 Percent
28.91 %
42.51 %
26.80 %
Rate per 100 searches 41.05
38.88 35.01
Race Known
Frequency
9 58
21 Percent
10.23 %
65.91 %
23.86 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.04
0.09 0.06
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
117
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 4,354
185 2,081
0 0
Percent 3.47 %
0.15 %
1.66 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,583 68
846 0
0 Percent
3.18 %
0.14 %
1.70 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.36
36.76 40.65
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
2,771 117
1,235 0
0 Percent
3.66 %
0.15 %
1.63 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.64
63.24 59.35
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 88
7 34
0 0
Percent 1.20 %
0.10 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.02 3.78
1.63 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 28
2 16
0 0
Percent 1.40 %
0.10 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.64 1.08
0.77 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
60 5
18 0
0 Percent
1.13 %
0.09 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.38
2.70 0.86
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
33 2
15 0
0 Percent
1.18 %
0.07 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 37.50
28.57 44.12
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
118
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 19,478
57,031 30,653
Percent 17.21 %
50.39 %
27.09 %
Citations
Frequency
8,143 19,711
15,835 Percent
17.72 %
42.90 %
34.47 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.81
34.56 51.66
Warnings
Frequency
11,335 37,320
14,818 Percent
16.86 %
55.52 %
22.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.19
65.44 48.34
Searches (All)
Frequency 611
970 617
Percent 27.31 %
43.36 %
27.58 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.14 1.70
2.01 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 130
284 156
Percent 22.22 %
48.55 %
26.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.67 0.50
0.51 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
481 686
461 Percent
29.12 %
41.53 %
27.91 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.47
1.20 1.50
Contraband Hits
Frequency
353 580
379 Percent
26.42 %
43.41 %
28.37 %
Rate per 100 searches 57.77
59.79 61.43
Race Known
Frequency
13 52
19 Percent
15.29 %
61.18 %
22.35 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.09 0.06
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
119
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,247
160 2,599
0 2
Percent 2.87 %
0.14 %
2.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,173 45
1,038 0
0 Percent
2.55 %
0.10 %
2.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.13
28.13 39.94
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
2,074 115
1,561 0
2 Percent
3.09 %
0.17 %
2.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.87
71.88 60.06
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 22
0 17
0 0
Percent 0.98 %
0.00 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.68 0.00
0.65 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 9
0 6
0 0
Percent 1.54 %
0.00 %
1.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.28 0.00
0.23 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
13 0
11 0
0 Percent
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.40
0.00 0.42
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
13 0
11 0
0 Percent
0.97 %
0.00 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 59.09
--- 64.71
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
1.18 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.03
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
120
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,012
1,505 3,288
Percent 17.27 %
25.68 %
56.10 %
Citations
Frequency
282 353
988 Percent
17.24 %
21.58 %
60.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.87
23.46 30.05
Warnings
Frequency
488 739
1,602 Percent
17.07 %
25.85 %
56.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.22
49.10 48.72
Clean
Frequency 242
413 698
Percent 17.72 %
30.23 %
51.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
23.91 27.44
21.23 Searches (All)
Frequency
29 18
98 Percent
20.00 %
12.41 %
67.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.87
1.20 2.98
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
27 18
96 Percent
19.15 %
12.77 %
68.09 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.67
1.20 2.92
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 2
Percent 50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.20 0.00
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 0.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
121
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 23
1 25
0 7
Percent 0.39 %
0.02 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.12 %
Citations
Frequency
3 1
9 0
0 Percent
0.18 %
0.06 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.04
100.00 36.00
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
17 0
13 0
0 Percent
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 73.91
0.00 52.00
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 3
0 3
0 7
Percent 0.22 %
0.00 %
0.22 %
0.00 %
0.51 %
Rate per 100 stops
13.04 0.00
12.00 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
122
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,120
1,694 3,703
Percent 17.00 %
25.71 %
56.19 %
Citations
Frequency
271 321
987 Percent
17.03 %
20.18 %
62.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.20
18.95 26.65
Warnings
Frequency
569 855
1,833 Percent
17.30 %
26.00 %
55.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.80
50.47 49.50
Clean
Frequency 280
518 883
Percent 16.37 %
30.29 %
51.64 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.00 30.58
23.85 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 1
5 Percent
25.00 %
12.50 %
62.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.18
0.06 0.14
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 1
5 Percent
25.00 %
12.50 %
62.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.18
0.06 0.14
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 1
Percent 50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
50.00 0.00
20.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 0
Percent 100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.09 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
123
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 31
1 30
0 11
Percent 0.47 %
0.02 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.17 %
Citations
Frequency
4 0
8 0
0 Percent
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 12.90
0.00 26.67
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
18 0
13 0
1 Percent
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.06
0.00 43.33
--- 9.09
Clean
Frequency 9
1 9
0 10
Percent 0.53 %
0.06 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.58 %
Rate per 100 stops
29.03 100.00
30.00 ---
90.91 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
124
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
125
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2D 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 8,307
25,995 8,531
Percent 18.48 %
57.83 %
18.98 %
Citations
Frequency
2,762 6,063
3,642 Percent
21.03 %
46.16 %
27.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 33.25
23.32 42.69
Warnings
Frequency
5,545 19,932
4,889 Percent
17.43 %
62.65 %
15.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 66.75
76.68 57.31
Searches (All)
Frequency 871
1,115 715
Percent 31.60 %
40.46 %
25.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
10.49 4.29
8.38 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 139
312 211
Percent 20.26 %
45.48 %
30.76 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.67 1.20
2.47 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
732 803
504 Percent
35.36 %
38.79 %
24.35 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.81
3.09 5.91
Contraband Hits
Frequency
356 517
307 Percent
29.57 %
42.94 %
25.50 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.87
46.37 42.94
Race Known
Frequency
100 221
79 Percent
24.39 %
53.90 %
19.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.20
0.85 0.93
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
126
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 2D 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,559
44 512
0 0
Percent 3.47 %
0.10 %
1.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
486 19
162 0
0 Percent
3.70 %
0.14 %
1.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 31.17
43.18 31.64
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,073 25
350 0
0 Percent
3.37 %
0.08 %
1.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 68.83
56.82 68.36
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 38
2 15
0 0
Percent 1.38 %
0.07 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.44 4.55
2.93 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 17
1 6
0 0
Percent 2.48 %
0.15 %
0.87 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.09 2.27
1.17 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
21 1
9 0
0 Percent
1.01 %
0.05 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.35
2.27 1.76
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
17 1
6 0
0 Percent
1.41 %
0.08 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 44.74
50.00 40.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
7 0
3 0
0 Percent
1.71 %
0.00 %
0.73 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.45
0.00 0.59
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
127
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2D 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 7,380
24,207 7,528
Percent 17.99 %
59.00 %
18.35 %
Citations
Frequency
2,517 6,352
3,375 Percent
19.47 %
49.14 %
26.11 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.11
26.24 44.83
Warnings
Frequency
4,863 17,855
4,153 Percent
17.30 %
63.53 %
14.78 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.89
73.76 55.17
Searches (All)
Frequency 323
440 239
Percent 31.57 %
43.01 %
23.36 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.38 1.82
3.17 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 69
159 64
Percent 23.08 %
53.18 %
21.40 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.93 0.66
0.85 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
254 281
175 Percent
35.08 %
38.81 %
24.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.44
1.16 2.32
Contraband Hits
Frequency
150 233
123 Percent
29.13 %
45.24 %
23.88 %
Rate per 100 searches 46.44
52.95 51.46
Race Known
Frequency
39 235
68 Percent
11.14 %
67.14 %
19.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.53
0.97 0.90
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
128
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 2D 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,163
17 735
0 1
Percent 2.83 %
0.04 %
1.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
430 4
248 0
0 Percent
3.33 %
0.03 %
1.92 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.97
23.53 33.74
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
733 13
487 0
1 Percent
2.61 %
0.05 %
1.73 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.03
76.47 66.26
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 14
1 6
0 0
Percent 1.37 %
0.10 %
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.20 5.88
0.82 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
1 2
0 0
Percent 1.34 %
0.33 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.34 5.88
0.27 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
10 0
4 0
0 Percent
1.38 %
0.00 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.86
0.00 0.54
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
7 0
2 0
0 Percent
1.36 %
0.00 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.00
0.00 33.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
2 0
6 0
0 Percent
0.57 %
0.00 %
1.71 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.17
0.00 0.82
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
129
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2D
2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
625 1,046
916 Percent
23.69 %
39.65 %
34.72 %
Citations
Frequency 289
415 378
Percent 26.39 %
37.90 %
34.52 %
Rate per 100 stops
46.24 39.67
41.27 W
arnings
Frequency 280
476 451
Percent 22.91 %
38.95 %
36.91 %
Rate per 100 stops
44.80 45.51
49.24 Clean
Frequency
56 155
87 Percent
17.45 %
48.29 %
27.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.96
14.82 9.50
Searches (All)
Frequency 0
1 2
Percent 0.00 %
33.33 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.10
0.22 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.11 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 1
1 Percent
0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.10 0.11
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 0
0 Percent
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches ---
0.00 0.00
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 Percent
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
130
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 2D
2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 18
0 9
0 24
Percent 0.68 %
0.00 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.91 %
Citations
Frequency
9 0
4 0
0 Percent
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.00
--- 44.44
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
6 0
5 0
4 Percent
0.49 %
0.00 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 33.33
--- 55.56
--- 16.67
Clean
Frequency 3
0 0
0 20
Percent 0.93 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
6.23 %
Rate per 100 stops
16.67 ---
0.00 ---
83.33 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
--- 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
--- 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 ---
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 ---
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
131
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2D
2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
571 1,031
765 Percent
23.39 %
42.24 %
31.34 %
Citations
Frequency 227
363 297
Percent 25.36 %
40.56 %
33.18 %
Rate per 100 stops
39.75 35.21
38.82 W
arnings
Frequency 278
495 357
Percent 24.09 %
42.89 %
30.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
48.69 48.01
46.67 Clean
Frequency
66 173
111 Percent
16.84 %
44.13 %
28.32 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.56
16.78 14.51
Searches (All)
Frequency 1
1 1
Percent 33.33 %
33.33 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.18 0.10
0.13 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 1
Percent 0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.10
0.13 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 Percent
100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.18
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1 0
0 Percent
100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 100.00
0.00 0.00
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 Percent
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
132
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 2D
2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 17
1 14
0 42
Percent 0.70 %
0.04 %
0.57 %
0.00 %
1.72 %
Citations
Frequency
4 0
4 0
0 Percent
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.53
0.00 28.57
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
11 1
9 0
3 Percent
0.95 %
0.09 %
0.78 %
0.00 %
0.26 %
Rate per 100 stops 64.71
100.00 64.29
--- 7.14
Clean
Frequency 2
0 1
0 39
Percent 0.51 %
0.00 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
9.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
11.76 0.00
7.14 ---
92.86 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX D – REGION 2:HOUSTON – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
133
Appendix E Region 3: McAllen Analysis
134
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
135
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 3 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 6,374
59,557 429,427
Percent 1.28 %
11.94 %
86.08 %
Citations
Frequency
2,047 15,242
151,079 Percent
1.21 %
9.00 %
89.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 32.11
25.59 35.18
Warnings
Frequency
4,327 44,315
278,348 Percent
1.31 %
13.45 %
84.49 %
Rate per 100 stops 67.89
74.41 64.82
Searches (All)
Frequency 422
2,211 18,756
Percent 1.96 %
10.27 %
87.13 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.62 3.71
4.37 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 160
840 10,601
Percent 1.37 %
7.20 %
90.82 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.51 1.41
2.47 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
262 1,371
8,155 Percent
2.66 %
13.91 %
82.77 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.11
2.30 1.90
Contraband Hits
Frequency
110 617
2,709 Percent
3.17 %
17.79 %
78.11 %
Rate per 100 searches 26.07
27.91 14.44
Race Known
Frequency
22 174
3,503 Percent
0.59 %
4.69 %
94.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.35
0.29 0.82
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
136
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 3 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 2,069
379 1,057
0 4
Percent 0.41 %
0.08 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
577 178
299 0
3 Percent
0.34 %
0.11 %
0.18 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.89
46.97 28.29
--- 75.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,492 201
758 0
1 Percent
0.45 %
0.06 %
0.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 72.11
53.03 71.71
--- 25.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 57
51 29
0 0
Percent 0.26 %
0.24 %
0.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.75 13.46
2.74 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 35
16 21
0 0
Percent 0.30 %
0.14 %
0.18 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.69 4.22
1.99 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
22 35
8 0
0 Percent
0.22 %
0.36 %
0.08 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.06
9.23 0.76
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
9 15
8 0
0 Percent
0.26 %
0.43 %
0.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 15.79
29.41 27.59
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
6 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.16 %
0.00 %
0.05 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.29
0.00 0.19
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
137
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 3 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 4,318
42,399 301,203
Percent 1.23 %
12.09 %
85.88 %
Citations
Frequency
1,460 11,357
104,756 Percent
1.23 %
9.58 %
88.40 %
Rate per 100 stops 33.81
26.79 34.78
Warnings
Frequency
2,858 31,042
196,447 Percent
1.23 %
13.37 %
84.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 66.19
73.21 65.22
Searches (All)
Frequency 94
512 4,174
Percent 1.96 %
10.66 %
86.92 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.18 1.21
1.39 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 24
219 2,388
Percent 0.91 %
8.29 %
90.42 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.56 0.52
0.79 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
70 293
1,786 Percent
3.24 %
13.56 %
82.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.62
0.69 0.59
Contraband Hits
Frequency
50 226
1,063 Percent
3.70 %
16.73 %
78.68 %
Rate per 100 searches 53.19
44.14 25.47
Race Known
Frequency
3 42
835 Percent
0.34 %
4.74 %
94.24 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.10 0.28
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
138
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 3 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,432
231 1,148
2 6
Percent 0.41 %
0.07 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
431 105
388 1
2 Percent
0.36 %
0.09 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 30.10
45.45 33.80
50.00 33.33
Warnings
Frequency
1,001 126
760 1
4 Percent
0.43 %
0.05 %
0.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 69.90
54.55 66.20
50.00 66.67
Searches (All)
Frequency 9
7 6
0 0
Percent 0.19 %
0.15 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.63 3.03
0.52 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
4 4
0 0
Percent 0.08 %
0.15 %
0.15 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.14 1.73
0.35 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
7 3
2 0
0 Percent
0.32 %
0.14 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.49
1.30 0.17
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
6 4
2 0
0 Percent
0.44 %
0.30 %
0.15 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 66.67
57.14 33.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 1
4 0
0 Percent
0.11 %
0.11 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.43 0.35
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
139
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 3 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,259 4,103
27,343 Percent
3.81 %
12.41 %
82.69 %
Citations
Frequency 187
671 4,340
Percent 3.57 %
12.81 %
82.86 %
Rate per 100 stops
14.85 16.35
15.87 W
arnings
Frequency 716
2,088 15,738
Percent 3.82 %
11.14 %
83.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
56.87 50.89
57.56 Clean
Frequency
356 1,344
7,265 Percent
3.92 %
14.81 %
80.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 28.28
32.76 26.57
Searches (All)
Frequency 8
17 121
Percent 5.44 %
11.56 %
82.31 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.64 0.41
0.44 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 7
14 104
Percent 5.56 %
11.11 %
82.54 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.56 0.34
0.38 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 3
17 Percent
4.76 %
14.29 %
80.95 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.08
0.07 0.06
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2 3
10 Percent
13.33 %
20.00 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 searches 25.00
17.65 8.26
Race Known
Frequency
19 69
1,408 Percent
1.27 %
4.60 %
93.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.51
1.68 5.15
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
140
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 3 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 88
13 229
0 30
Percent 0.27 %
0.04 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.09 %
Citations
Frequency
12 1
27 0
0 Percent
0.23 %
0.02 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.64
7.69 11.79
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
53 7
141 0
7 Percent
0.28 %
0.04 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.23
53.85 61.57
--- 23.33
Clean
Frequency 23
5 61
0 23
Percent 0.25 %
0.06 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.25 %
Rate per 100 stops
26.14 38.46
26.64 ---
76.67 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
1 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.68 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 3.33
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
1 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 3.33
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 4
0 0
Percent 0.07 %
0.00 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.14 0.00
1.75 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
141
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 3 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,359 4,795
29,695 Percent
3.74 %
13.19 %
81.67 %
Citations
Frequency 180
672 4,066
Percent 3.62 %
13.53 %
81.86 %
Rate per 100 stops
13.25 14.01
13.69 W
arnings
Frequency 790
2,585 18,462
Percent 3.57 %
11.69 %
83.50 %
Rate per 100 stops
58.13 53.91
62.17 Clean
Frequency
389 1,538
7,167 Percent
4.19 %
16.57 %
77.21 %
Rate per 100 stops 28.62
32.08 24.14
Searches (All)
Frequency 4
17 123
Percent 2.72 %
11.56 %
83.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.29 0.35
0.41 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
12 115
Percent 2.26 %
9.02 %
86.47 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.22 0.25
0.39 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 5
8 Percent
7.14 %
35.71 %
57.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.10 0.03
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 2
10 Percent
0.00 %
16.67 %
83.33 %
Rate per 100 searches 0.00
11.76 8.13
Race Known
Frequency
33 72
1,346 Percent
2.25 %
4.92 %
91.94 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.43
1.50 4.53
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
142
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 3 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 112
12 349
0 38
Percent 0.31 %
0.03 %
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.10 %
Citations
Frequency
11 1
37 0
0 Percent
0.22 %
0.02 %
0.74 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 9.82
8.33 10.60
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
66 6
200 0
2 Percent
0.30 %
0.03 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.93
50.00 57.31
--- 5.26
Clean
Frequency 35
5 112
0 36
Percent 0.38 %
0.05 %
1.21 %
0.00 %
0.39 %
Rate per 100 stops
31.25 41.67
32.09 ---
94.74 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
3 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.04 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.86
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
3 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.86
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 3
0 7
0 3
Percent 0.20 %
0.00 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.20 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.68 0.00
2.01 ---
7.89
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX E – REGION 3:MCALLEN ANALYSIS
143
Appendix F Region 3: McAllen
District Level Analysis
144
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
145
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
146
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3A and 3D
2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,155 10,852
192,564 Percent
0.56 %
5.28 %
93.78 %
Citations
Frequency 403
3,850 85,211
Percent 0.45 %
4.29 %
95.04 %
Rate per 100 stops
34.89 35.48
44.25 W
arnings
Frequency 752
7,002 107,353
Percent 0.65 %
6.05 %
92.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
65.11 64.52
55.75 Searches (All)
Frequency
87 559
7,913 Percent
1.02 %
6.52 %
92.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.53
5.15 4.11
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
39 194
4,065 Percent
0.91 %
4.51 %
94.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.38
1.79 2.11
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 48
365 3,848
Percent 1.13 %
8.56 %
90.22 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.16 3.36
2.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 13
98 1,002
Percent 1.17 %
8.79 %
89.87 %
Rate per 100 searches
14.94 17.53
12.66 Race Know
n
Frequency 8
63 1,489
Percent 0.51 %
4.03 %
95.20 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.69 0.58
0.77
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
147
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3A and 3D
2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 514
25 230
0 1
Percent 0.25 %
0.01 %
0.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
124 7
62 0
0 Percent
0.14 %
0.01 %
0.07 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.12
28.00 26.96
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
390 18
168 0
1 Percent
0.34 %
0.02 %
0.15 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 75.88
72.00 73.04
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 7
2 2
0 0
Percent 0.08 %
0.02 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.36 8.00
0.87 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 5
1 1
0 0
Percent 0.12 %
0.02 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.97 4.00
0.43 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 1
1 0
0 Percent
0.05 %
0.02 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.39
4.00 0.43
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 14.29
0.00 50.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
2 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.13 %
0.00 %
0.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.39
0.00 0.87
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
148
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3A and 3D
2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
724 7,184
114,704 Percent
0.59 %
5.83 %
93.16 %
Citations
Frequency 223
2,518 50,412
Percent 0.42 %
4.72 %
94.55 %
Rate per 100 stops
30.80 35.05
43.95 W
arnings
Frequency 501
4,666 64,292
Percent 0.72 %
6.68 %
92.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
69.20 64.95
56.05 Searches (All)
Frequency
12 98
1,331 Percent
0.83 %
6.80 %
92.30 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.66
1.36 1.16
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
7 47
807 Percent
0.81 %
5.46 %
93.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.97
0.65 0.70
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 5
51 524
Percent 0.86 %
8.78 %
90.19 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.69 0.71
0.46 Contraband H
its
Frequency 2
26 280
Percent 0.65 %
8.41 %
90.61 %
Rate per 100 searches
16.67 26.53
21.04 Race Know
n
Frequency 2
12 316
Percent 0.60 %
3.59 %
94.61 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.28 0.17
0.28
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
149
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3A and 3D
2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 295
19 195
0 2
Percent 0.24 %
0.02 %
0.16 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
86 6
74 0
1 Percent
0.16 %
0.01 %
0.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 29.15
31.58 37.95
--- 50.00
Warnings
Frequency
209 13
121 0
1 Percent
0.30 %
0.02 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 70.85
68.42 62.05
--- 50.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 1
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.07 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.34 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.34
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 100.00
--- ---
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 0
3 0
0 Percent
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.34
0.00 1.54
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
150
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3A and 3D 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 168
481 11,448
Percent 1.38 %
3.95 %
94.09 %
Citations
Frequency
10 58
1,492 Percent
0.64 %
3.70 %
95.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.95
12.06 13.03
Warnings
Frequency
103 244
6,623 Percent
1.47 %
3.48 %
94.57 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.31
50.73 57.85
Clean
Frequency 55
179 3,333
Percent 1.53 %
4.97 %
92.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
32.74 37.21
29.11 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 6
45 Percent
5.45 %
10.91 %
81.82 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.79
1.25 0.39
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 6
37 Percent
4.35 %
13.04 %
80.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.19
1.25 0.32
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 8
Percent 11.11 %
0.00 %
88.89 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.60 0.00
0.07 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 1
Percent 50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
33.33 0.00
2.22 Race Know
n
Frequency 2
18 952
Percent 0.21 %
1.85 %
97.84 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.19 3.74
8.32
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
151
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3A and 3D 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 12
4 34
0 20
Percent 0.10 %
0.03 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.16 %
Citations
Frequency
1 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.06 %
0.00 %
0.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.33
0.00 14.71
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
7 3
22 0
1 Percent
0.10 %
0.04 %
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.33
75.00 64.71
--- 5.00
Clean
Frequency 4
1 7
0 19
Percent 0.11 %
0.03 %
0.19 %
0.00 %
0.53 %
Rate per 100 stops
33.33 25.00
20.59 ---
95.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
1 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
1.82 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 5.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
1 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 5.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.33 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
152
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3A and 3D 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 199
580 10,460
Percent 1.76 %
5.12 %
92.41 %
Citations
Frequency
21 46
958 Percent
2.04 %
4.47 %
93.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 10.55
7.93 9.16
Warnings
Frequency
127 348
7,001 Percent
1.69 %
4.63 %
93.12 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.82
60.00 66.93
Clean
Frequency 51
186 2,501
Percent 1.84 %
6.71 %
90.22 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.63 32.07
23.91 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 3
35 Percent
0.00 %
7.69 %
89.74 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.52 0.33
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 2
29 Percent
0.00 %
6.25 %
90.63 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.34 0.28
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 6
Percent 0.00 %
14.29 %
85.71 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.17
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 2
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- 0.00
5.71 Race Know
n
Frequency 4
14 656
Percent 0.59 %
2.07 %
96.90 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.01 2.41
6.27
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
153
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3A and 3D 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 13
2 45
0 20
Percent 0.11 %
0.02 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.18 %
Citations
Frequency
0 0
4 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 8.89
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
8 1
31 0
2 Percent
0.11 %
0.01 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.54
50.00 68.89
--- 10.00
Clean
Frequency 5
1 10
0 18
Percent 0.18 %
0.04 %
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.65 %
Rate per 100 stops
38.46 50.00
22.22 ---
90.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 2.22
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
3.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 2.22
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 3
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.44 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
6.67 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
154
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
155
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 448
3,955 102,564
Percent 0.42 %
3.69 %
95.62 %
Citations
Frequency
69 663
23,088 Percent
0.29 %
2.78 %
96.75 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.40
16.76 22.51
Warnings
Frequency
379 3,292
79,476 Percent
0.45 %
3.95 %
95.29 %
Rate per 100 stops 84.60
83.24 77.49
Searches (All)
Frequency 26
170 4,990
Percent 0.50 %
3.26 %
95.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
5.80 4.30
4.87 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 21
108 3,647
Percent 0.55 %
2.85 %
96.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.69 2.73
3.56 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 62
1,343 Percent
0.35 %
4.38 %
94.98 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.12
1.57 1.31
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1 21
518 Percent
0.18 %
3.87 %
95.40 %
Rate per 100 searches 3.85
12.35 10.38
Race Known
Frequency
6 55
1,851 Percent
0.31 %
2.87 %
96.66 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.34
1.39 1.80
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
156
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 193
20 82
0 1
Percent 0.18 %
0.02 %
0.08 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
29 3
10 0
1 Percent
0.12 %
0.01 %
0.04 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.03
15.00 12.20
--- 100.00
Warnings
Frequency
164 17
72 0
0 Percent
0.20 %
0.02 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 84.97
85.00 87.80
--- 0.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 19
1 3
0 0
Percent 0.36 %
0.02 %
0.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
9.84 5.00
3.66 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 15
1 3
0 0
Percent 0.40 %
0.03 %
0.08 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.77 5.00
3.66 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.07
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 15.79
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
3 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.16 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.55
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
157
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 414
4,798 95,689
Percent 0.41 %
4.74 %
94.55 %
Citations
Frequency
62 938
22,568 Percent
0.26 %
3.97 %
95.55 %
Rate per 100 stops 14.98
19.55 23.58
Warnings
Frequency
352 3,860
73,121 Percent
0.45 %
4.98 %
94.25 %
Rate per 100 stops 85.02
80.45 76.42
Searches (All)
Frequency 3
66 1,437
Percent 0.20 %
4.37 %
95.17 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.72 1.38
1.50 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
34 890
Percent 0.11 %
3.66 %
95.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.24 0.71
0.93 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 32
547 Percent
0.34 %
5.51 %
94.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.48
0.67 0.57
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 25
331 Percent
0.00 %
6.98 %
92.46 %
Rate per 100 searches 0.00
37.88 23.03
Race Known
Frequency
0 13
464 Percent
0.00 %
2.72 %
97.07 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.27 0.48
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
158
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 178
17 103
0 4
Percent 0.18 %
0.02 %
0.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
27 5
18 0
1 Percent
0.11 %
0.02 %
0.08 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.17
29.41 17.48
--- 25.00
Warnings
Frequency
151 12
85 0
3 Percent
0.19 %
0.02 %
0.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 84.83
70.59 82.52
--- 75.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 0
2 2
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.13 %
0.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 11.76
1.94 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
2 2
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.22 %
0.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 11.76
1.94 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 2
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches ---
100.00 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.97
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
159
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 151
694 4,829
Percent 2.63 %
12.07 %
83.97 %
Citations
Frequency
21 123
1,015 Percent
1.80 %
10.54 %
86.98 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.91
17.72 21.02
Warnings
Frequency
87 418
2,830 Percent
2.57 %
12.35 %
83.63 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.62
60.23 58.60
Clean
Frequency 43
153 984
Percent 3.58 %
12.75 %
82.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.48 22.05
20.38 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 5
32 Percent
5.13 %
12.82 %
82.05 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.32
0.72 0.66
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 4
29 Percent
5.71 %
11.43 %
82.86 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.32
0.58 0.60
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 3
Percent 0.00 %
25.00 %
75.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.14
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
1 4
Percent 0.00 %
20.00 %
80.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 20.00
12.50 Race Know
n
Frequency 7
26 381
Percent 1.68 %
6.25 %
91.59 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.64 3.75
7.89
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
160
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 19
2 47
0 9
Percent 0.33 %
0.03 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.16 %
Citations
Frequency
2 1
5 0
0 Percent
0.17 %
0.09 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 10.53
50.00 10.64
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
12 0
32 0
5 Percent
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.95 %
0.00 %
0.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.16
0.00 68.09
--- 55.56
Clean
Frequency 5
1 10
0 4
Percent 0.42 %
0.08 %
0.83 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
26.32 50.00
21.28 ---
44.44 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 2
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
4.26 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
161
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 281
927 7,033
Percent 3.36 %
11.09 %
84.12 %
Citations
Frequency
31 108
1,296 Percent
2.14 %
7.46 %
89.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.03
11.65 18.43
Warnings
Frequency
163 520
4,349 Percent
3.20 %
10.21 %
85.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.01
56.09 61.84
Clean
Frequency 87
299 1,388
Percent 4.78 %
16.44 %
76.31 %
Rate per 100 stops
30.96 32.25
19.74 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 11
51 Percent
4.48 %
16.42 %
76.12 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.07
1.19 0.73
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 8
51 Percent
3.17 %
12.70 %
80.95 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.71
0.86 0.73
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
3 0
Percent 25.00 %
75.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 0.32
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
2 4
Percent 0.00 %
33.33 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 18.18
7.84 Race Know
n
Frequency 17
26 533
Percent 2.92 %
4.46 %
91.42 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.05 2.80
7.58
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
162
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 27
4 71
0 18
Percent 0.32 %
0.05 %
0.85 %
0.00 %
0.22 %
Citations
Frequency
2 0
11 0
0 Percent
0.14 %
0.00 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.41
0.00 15.49
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
19 1
42 0
0 Percent
0.37 %
0.02 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 70.37
25.00 59.15
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 6
3 18
0 18
Percent 0.33 %
0.16 %
0.99 %
0.00 %
0.99 %
Rate per 100 stops
22.22 75.00
25.35 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.99 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 2.82
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
3.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 2.82
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 2
0 2
0 3
Percent 0.34 %
0.00 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.51 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.41 0.00
2.82 ---
16.67
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
163
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
164
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 3,075
26,539 62,982
Percent 3.27 %
28.20 %
66.92 %
Citations
Frequency
1,219 7,692
23,772 Percent
3.67 %
23.14 %
71.52 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.64
28.98 37.74
Warnings
Frequency
1,856 18,847
39,210 Percent
3.05 %
30.96 %
64.41 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.36
71.02 62.26
Searches (All)
Frequency 234
1,025 2,840
Percent 5.65 %
24.75 %
68.58 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.61 3.86
4.51 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 63
325 1,246
Percent 3.80 %
19.63 %
75.24 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.05 1.22
1.98 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
171 700
1,594 Percent
6.88 %
28.17 %
64.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.56
2.64 2.53
Contraband Hits
Frequency
82 406
683 Percent
6.93 %
34.29 %
57.69 %
Rate per 100 searches 35.04
39.61 24.05
Race Known
Frequency
6 32
25 Percent
9.52 %
50.79 %
39.68 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.20
0.12 0.04
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
165
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 938
63 515
0 1
Percent 1.00 %
0.07 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
353 23
179 0
1 Percent
1.06 %
0.07 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.63
36.51 34.76
--- 100.00
Warnings
Frequency
585 40
336 0
0 Percent
0.96 %
0.07 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.37
63.49 65.24
--- 0.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 19
4 19
0 0
Percent 0.46 %
0.10 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.03 6.35
3.69 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 8
1 13
0 0
Percent 0.48 %
0.06 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.85 1.59
2.52 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
11 3
6 0
0 Percent
0.44 %
0.12 %
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.17
4.76 1.17
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
5 1
7 0
0 Percent
0.42 %
0.08 %
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 26.32
25.00 36.84
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
166
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 2,209
19,203 47,970
Percent 3.12 %
27.16 %
67.86 %
Citations
Frequency
949 5,468
17,937 Percent
3.82 %
22.00 %
72.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.96
28.47 37.39
Warnings
Frequency
1,260 13,735
30,033 Percent
2.75 %
29.96 %
65.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.04
71.53 62.61
Searches (All)
Frequency 61
261 614
Percent 6.43 %
27.53 %
64.77 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.76 1.36
1.28 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 8
106 298
Percent 1.92 %
25.48 %
71.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 0.55
0.62 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
53 155
316 Percent
9.96 %
29.14 %
59.40 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.40
0.81 0.66
Contraband Hits
Frequency
40 143
261 Percent
8.85 %
31.64 %
57.74 %
Rate per 100 searches 65.57
54.79 42.51
Race Known
Frequency
0 11
13 Percent
0.00 %
45.83 %
54.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.06 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
167
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 681
20 608
2 0
Percent 0.96 %
0.03 %
0.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
246 6
242 1
0 Percent
0.99 %
0.02 %
0.97 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.12
30.00 39.80
50.00 ---
Warnings
Frequency
435 14
366 1
0 Percent
0.95 %
0.03 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.88
70.00 60.20
50.00 ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 7
2 3
0 0
Percent 0.74 %
0.21 %
0.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.03 10.00
0.49 0.00
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
0 2
0 0
Percent 0.48 %
0.00 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.29 0.00
0.33 0.00
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 2
1 0
0 Percent
0.94 %
0.38 %
0.19 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.73
10.00 0.16
0.00 ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
5 2
1 0
0 Percent
1.11 %
0.44 %
0.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 71.43
100.00 33.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
168
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 527
1,788 5,142
Percent 7.00 %
23.75 %
68.30 %
Citations
Frequency
108 344
957 Percent
7.61 %
24.23 %
67.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 20.49
19.24 18.61
Warnings
Frequency
262 772
2,535 Percent
7.25 %
21.37 %
70.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.72
43.18 49.30
Clean
Frequency 157
672 1,650
Percent 6.29 %
26.92 %
66.11 %
Rate per 100 stops
29.79 37.58
32.09 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 3
32 Percent
2.78 %
8.33 %
88.89 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.19
0.17 0.62
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 2
28 Percent
3.23 %
6.45 %
90.32 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.19
0.11 0.54
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 4
Percent 0.00 %
20.00 %
80.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.06
0.08 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 4
Percent 16.67 %
16.67 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 33.33
12.50 Race Know
n
Frequency 10
25 74
Percent 9.01 %
22.52 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.90 1.40
1.44
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
169
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 30
1 39
0 1
Percent 0.40 %
0.01 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Citations
Frequency
7 0
4 0
0 Percent
0.49 %
0.00 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.33
0.00 10.26
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
16 1
25 0
1 Percent
0.44 %
0.03 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 53.33
100.00 64.10
--- 100.00
Clean
Frequency 7
0 10
0 0
Percent 0.28 %
0.00 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
23.33 0.00
25.64 ---
0.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 2
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
1.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
5.13 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
170
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 377
1,641 4,680
Percent 5.57 %
24.25 %
69.15 %
Citations
Frequency
64 289
852 Percent
5.25 %
23.73 %
69.95 %
Rate per 100 stops 16.98
17.61 18.21
Warnings
Frequency
188 773
2,346 Percent
5.62 %
23.11 %
70.13 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.87
47.11 50.13
Clean
Frequency 125
579 1,482
Percent 5.67 %
26.26 %
67.21 %
Rate per 100 stops
33.16 35.28
31.67 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 2
30 Percent
3.03 %
6.06 %
90.91 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.27
0.12 0.64
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 2
29 Percent
3.13 %
6.25 %
90.63 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.27
0.12 0.62
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.02 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 3
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 0.00
10.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 11
32 141
Percent 5.88 %
17.11 %
75.40 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.92 1.95
3.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
171
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 19
2 49
0 0
Percent 0.28 %
0.03 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
3 0
10 0
0 Percent
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.79
0.00 20.41
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
9 2
27 0
0 Percent
0.27 %
0.06 %
0.81 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 47.37
100.00 55.10
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 7
0 12
0 0
Percent 0.32 %
0.00 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
36.84 0.00
24.49 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 2
0 0
Percent 0.53 %
0.00 %
1.07 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
5.26 0.00
4.08 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
172
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
173
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3E 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,696
18,211 71,317
Percent 1.84 %
19.76 %
77.39 %
Citations
Frequency
356 3,037
19,008 Percent
1.57 %
13.40 %
83.86 %
Rate per 100 stops 20.99
16.68 26.65
Warnings
Frequency
1,340 15,174
52,309 Percent
1.93 %
21.84 %
75.28 %
Rate per 100 stops 79.01
83.32 73.35
Searches (All)
Frequency 75
457 3,013
Percent 2.08 %
12.67 %
83.56 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.42 2.51
4.22 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 37
213 1,643
Percent 1.93 %
11.11 %
85.71 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.18 1.17
2.30 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
38 244
1,370 Percent
2.25 %
14.45 %
81.11 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.24
1.34 1.92
Contraband Hits
Frequency
14 92
506 Percent
2.24 %
14.70 %
80.83 %
Rate per 100 searches 18.67
20.13 16.79
Race Known
Frequency
2 24
138 Percent
1.21 %
14.55 %
83.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.13 0.19
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
174
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 3E 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 424
271 230
0 1
Percent 0.46 %
0.29 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
71 145
48 0
1 Percent
0.31 %
0.64 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 16.75
53.51 20.87
--- 100.00
Warnings
Frequency
353 126
182 0
0 Percent
0.51 %
0.18 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 83.25
46.49 79.13
--- 0.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 12
44 5
0 0
Percent 0.33 %
1.22 %
0.14 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.83 16.24
2.17 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 7
13 4
0 0
Percent 0.37 %
0.68 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.65 4.80
1.74 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 31
1 0
0 Percent
0.30 %
1.84 %
0.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.18
11.44 0.43
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 14
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
2.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 0.00
31.82 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.24
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
175
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3E 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 971
11,214 42,840
Percent 1.74 %
20.13 %
76.88 %
Citations
Frequency
226 2,433
13,839 Percent
1.35 %
14.56 %
82.81 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.27
21.70 32.30
Warnings
Frequency
745 8,781
29,001 Percent
1.91 %
22.51 %
74.35 %
Rate per 100 stops 76.73
78.30 67.70
Searches (All)
Frequency 18
87 792
Percent 2.00 %
9.65 %
87.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.85 0.78
1.85 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 8
32 393
Percent 1.84 %
7.36 %
90.34 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.82 0.29
0.92 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
10 55
399 Percent
2.14 %
11.78 %
85.44 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.03
0.49 0.93
Contraband Hits
Frequency
8 32
191 Percent
3.45 %
13.79 %
82.33 %
Rate per 100 searches 44.44
36.78 24.12
Race Known
Frequency
1 6
42 Percent
2.00 %
12.00 %
84.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.05 0.10
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
176
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 3E 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 278
175 242
0 0
Percent 0.50 %
0.31 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
72 88
54 0
0 Percent
0.43 %
0.53 %
0.32 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 25.90
50.29 22.31
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
206 87
188 0
0 Percent
0.53 %
0.22 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 74.10
49.71 77.69
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 1
3 1
0 0
Percent 0.11 %
0.33 %
0.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 1.71
0.41 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
2 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 1.14
0.00 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 1
1 0
0 Percent
0.21 %
0.21 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.36
0.57 0.41
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 0.00
0.00 100.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 1
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
2.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.57 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
177
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3E 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 413
1,140 5,924
Percent 5.42 %
14.96 %
77.75 %
Citations
Frequency
48 146
876 Percent
4.42 %
13.46 %
80.74 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.62
12.81 14.79
Warnings
Frequency
264 654
3,750 Percent
5.56 %
13.77 %
78.93 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.92
57.37 63.30
Clean
Frequency 101
340 1,298
Percent 5.66 %
19.07 %
72.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
24.46 29.82
21.91 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 3
12 Percent
11.76 %
17.65 %
70.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.48
0.26 0.20
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 2
10 Percent
14.29 %
14.29 %
71.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.48
0.18 0.17
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 2
Percent 0.00 %
33.33 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.09
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
1 1
Percent 0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 33.33
8.33 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
178
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 3E 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 27
6 109
0 0
Percent 0.35 %
0.08 %
1.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2 0
13 0
0 Percent
0.18 %
0.00 %
1.20 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.41
0.00 11.93
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
18 3
62 0
0 Percent
0.38 %
0.06 %
1.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 66.67
50.00 56.88
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 7
3 34
0 0
Percent 0.39 %
0.17 %
1.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.93 50.00
31.19 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
179
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3E 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 502
1,647 7,522
Percent 5.06 %
16.62 %
75.89 %
Citations
Frequency
64 229
960 Percent
5.03 %
18.00 %
75.47 %
Rate per 100 stops 12.75
13.90 12.76
Warnings
Frequency
312 944
4,766 Percent
5.07 %
15.34 %
77.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 62.15
57.32 63.36
Clean
Frequency 126
474 1,796
Percent 5.07 %
19.07 %
72.24 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.10 28.78
23.88 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 1
7 Percent
0.00 %
12.50 %
87.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.06 0.09
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
6 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.08
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 1
Percent 0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.06
0.01 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- 0.00
14.29 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
0 16
Percent 5.88 %
0.00 %
94.12 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.20 0.00
0.21
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
180
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 3E 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 53
4 184
0 0
Percent 0.53 %
0.04 %
1.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
6 1
12 0
0 Percent
0.47 %
0.08 %
0.94 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.32
25.00 6.52
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
30 2
100 0
0 Percent
0.49 %
0.03 %
1.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.60
50.00 54.35
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 17
1 72
0 0
Percent 0.68 %
0.04 %
2.90 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
32.08 25.00
39.13 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX F – REGION 3:MCALLEN – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
181
Appendix G Region 4: El Paso Analysis
182
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
183
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 4 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 12,563
76,671 125,398
Percent 5.74 %
35.03 %
57.30 %
Citations
Frequency
4,814 23,690
48,711 Percent
6.12 %
30.11 %
61.91 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.32
30.90 38.85
Warnings
Frequency
7,749 52,981
76,687 Percent
5.53 %
37.80 %
54.71 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.68
69.10 61.15
Searches (All)
Frequency 801
2,032 5,479
Percent 9.54 %
24.20 %
65.24 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.38 2.65
4.37 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 243
711 2,262
Percent 7.47 %
21.86 %
69.56 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.93 0.93
1.80 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
558 1,321
3,217 Percent
10.84 %
25.67 %
62.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.44
1.72 2.57
Contraband Hits
Frequency
255 674
1,280 Percent
11.44 %
30.24 %
57.42 %
Rate per 100 searches 31.84
33.17 23.36
Race Known
Frequency
12 47
46 Percent
11.11 %
43.52 %
42.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.06 0.04
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
184
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 4 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 2,953
209 1,067
0 0
Percent 1.35 %
0.10 %
0.49 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,025 72
373 0
0 Percent
1.30 %
0.09 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.71
34.45 34.96
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,928 137
694 0
0 Percent
1.38 %
0.10 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.29
65.55 65.04
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 54
7 25
0 0
Percent 0.64 %
0.08 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.83 3.35
2.34 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 20
2 14
0 0
Percent 0.62 %
0.06 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.68 0.96
1.31 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
34 5
11 0
0 Percent
0.66 %
0.10 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.15
2.39 1.03
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
12 1
7 0
0 Percent
0.54 %
0.04 %
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 22.22
14.29 28.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
3 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.78 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
185
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 4 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 13,504
78,867 123,151
Percent 6.12 %
35.74 %
55.82 %
Citations
Frequency
4,794 22,272
46,234 Percent
6.39 %
29.71 %
61.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 35.50
28.24 37.54
Warnings
Frequency
8,710 56,595
76,917 Percent
5.98 %
38.85 %
52.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 64.50
71.76 62.46
Searches (All)
Frequency 394
873 2,151
Percent 11.36 %
25.18 %
62.04 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.92 1.11
1.75 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 147
336 1,098
Percent 9.15 %
20.92 %
68.37 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.09 0.43
0.89 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
247 537
1,053 Percent
13.27 %
28.86 %
56.58 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.83
0.68 0.86
Contraband Hits
Frequency
159 413
730 Percent
12.06 %
31.34 %
55.39 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.36
47.31 33.94
Race Known
Frequency
2 8
20 Percent
6.67 %
26.67 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.01
0.01 0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
186
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 4 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,256
213 1,646
2 2
Percent 1.48 %
0.10 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,087 79
505 1
0 Percent
1.45 %
0.11 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 33.38
37.09 30.68
50.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
2,169 134
1,141 1
2 Percent
1.49 %
0.09 %
0.78 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 66.62
62.91 69.32
50.00 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 21
6 22
0 0
Percent 0.61 %
0.17 %
0.63 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.64 2.82
1.34 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 15
0 10
0 0
Percent 0.93 %
0.00 %
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.46 0.00
0.61 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
6 6
12 0
0 Percent
0.32 %
0.32 %
0.64 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.18
2.82 0.73
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
6 4
6 0
0 Percent
0.46 %
0.30 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 28.57
66.67 27.27
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
187
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 4 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,955 8,538
15,343 Percent
7.39 %
32.26 %
57.98 %
Citations
Frequency 439
2,038 4,215
Percent 6.51 %
30.20 %
62.46 %
Rate per 100 stops
22.46 23.87
27.47 W
arnings
Frequency 826
3,113 6,566
Percent 7.69 %
28.98 %
61.12 %
Rate per 100 stops
42.25 36.46
42.79 Clean
Frequency
690 3,387
4,562 Percent
7.69 %
37.75 %
50.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 35.29
39.67 29.73
Searches (All)
Frequency 12
18 31
Percent 19.35 %
29.03 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.61 0.21
0.20 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 7
11 19
Percent 18.42 %
28.95 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.36 0.13
0.12 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 7
12 Percent
20.83 %
29.17 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.26
0.08 0.08
Contraband Hits
Frequency
5 8
9 Percent
21.74 %
34.78 %
39.13 %
Rate per 100 searches 41.67
44.44 29.03
Race Known
Frequency
0 1
0 Percent
0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.01 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
188
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 4 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 303
14 191
0 119
Percent 1.14 %
0.05 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.45 %
Citations
Frequency
34 3
19 0
0 Percent
0.50 %
0.04 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.22
21.43 9.95
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
148 6
73 0
10 Percent
1.38 %
0.06 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.09 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.84
42.86 38.22
--- 8.40
Clean
Frequency 121
5 99
0 109
Percent 1.35 %
0.06 %
1.10 %
0.00 %
1.21 %
Rate per 100 stops
39.93 35.71
51.83 ---
91.60 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
1.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.33
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.63 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.33
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 0
0 0
Percent 4.35 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
189
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 4 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
2,048 9,205
17,909 Percent
6.77 %
30.44 %
59.23 %
Citations
Frequency 408
2,065 4,174
Percent 6.06 %
30.65 %
61.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
19.92 22.43
23.31 W
arnings
Frequency 774
3,268 7,565
Percent 6.47 %
27.33 %
63.26 %
Rate per 100 stops
37.79 35.50
42.24 Clean
Frequency
866 3,872
6,170 Percent
7.50 %
33.56 %
53.47 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.29
42.06 34.45
Searches (All)
Frequency 9
10 50
Percent 13.04 %
14.49 %
72.46 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.44 0.11
0.28 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 5
4 40
Percent 10.20 %
8.16 %
81.63 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.24 0.04
0.22 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 6
10 Percent
20.00 %
30.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.20
0.07 0.06
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1 2
6 Percent
11.11 %
22.22 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 searches 11.11
20.00 12.00
Race Known
Frequency
0 2
1 Percent
0.00 %
66.67 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.02 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
190
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 4 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 459
21 421
0 173
Percent 1.52 %
0.07 %
1.39 %
0.00 %
0.57 %
Citations
Frequency
48 5
38 0
0 Percent
0.71 %
0.07 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 10.46
23.81 9.03
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
194 3
142 0
13 Percent
1.62 %
0.03 %
1.19 %
0.00 %
0.11 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.27
14.29 33.73
--- 7.51
Clean
Frequency 217
13 241
0 160
Percent 1.88 %
0.11 %
2.09 %
0.00 %
1.39 %
Rate per 100 stops
47.28 61.90
57.24 ---
92.49 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX G – REGION 4:EL PASO ANALYSIS
191
Appendix H Region 4: El Paso
District Level Analysis
192
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
193
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 4A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 7,714
54,705 53,769
Percent 6.51 %
46.14 %
45.35 %
Citations
Frequency
3,397 19,398
25,019 Percent
6.96 %
39.73 %
51.25 %
Rate per 100 stops 44.04
35.46 46.53
Warnings
Frequency
4,317 35,307
28,750 Percent
6.19 %
50.62 %
41.22 %
Rate per 100 stops 55.96
64.54 53.47
Searches (All)
Frequency 507
1,478 2,329
Percent 11.63 %
33.90 %
53.42 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.57 2.70
4.33 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 146
491 861
Percent 9.62 %
32.37 %
56.76 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.89 0.90
1.60 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
361 987
1,468 Percent
12.70 %
34.72 %
51.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.68
1.80 2.73
Contraband Hits
Frequency
188 541
713 Percent
12.90 %
37.13 %
48.94 %
Rate per 100 searches 37.08
36.60 30.61
Race Known
Frequency
8 34
22 Percent
12.12 %
51.52 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.10
0.06 0.04
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
194
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 4A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,630
138 608
0 0
Percent 1.37 %
0.12 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
715 49
243 0
0 Percent
1.46 %
0.10 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.87
35.51 39.97
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
915 89
365 0
0 Percent
1.31 %
0.13 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.13
64.49 60.03
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 32
3 11
0 0
Percent 0.73 %
0.07 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.96 2.17
1.81 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 12
1 6
0 0
Percent 0.79 %
0.07 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.74 0.72
0.99 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
20 2
5 0
0 Percent
0.70 %
0.07 %
0.18 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.23
1.45 0.82
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
9 1
5 0
0 Percent
0.62 %
0.07 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 28.13
33.33 45.45
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
2 0
0 0
0 Percent
3.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.12
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
195
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 4A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 7,953
55,134 53,802
Percent 6.63 %
45.98 %
44.87 %
Citations
Frequency
3,299 17,711
23,111 Percent
7.28 %
39.08 %
51.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.48
32.12 42.96
Warnings
Frequency
4,654 37,423
30,691 Percent
6.24 %
50.17 %
41.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.52
67.88 57.04
Searches (All)
Frequency 221
614 898
Percent 12.58 %
34.95 %
51.11 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.78 1.11
1.67 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 68
207 349
Percent 10.74 %
32.70 %
55.13 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.86 0.38
0.65 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
153 407
549 Percent
13.61 %
36.21 %
48.84 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.92
0.74 1.02
Contraband Hits
Frequency
103 318
397 Percent
12.47 %
38.50 %
48.06 %
Rate per 100 searches 46.61
51.79 44.21
Race Known
Frequency
0 4
10 Percent
0.00 %
28.57 %
71.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.01 0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
196
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 4A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,919
141 960
2 1
Percent 1.60 %
0.12 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
777 56
360 1
0 Percent
1.71 %
0.12 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.49
39.72 37.50
50.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,142 85
600 1
1 Percent
1.53 %
0.11 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.51
60.28 62.50
50.00 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 8
2 14
0 0
Percent 0.46 %
0.11 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.42 1.42
1.46 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
0 5
0 0
Percent 0.63 %
0.00 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.21 0.00
0.52 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 2
9 0
0 Percent
0.36 %
0.18 %
0.80 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.21
1.42 0.94
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 37.50
0.00 35.71
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
197
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 4A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,575
7,444 11,429
Percent 7.58 %
35.83 %
55.01 %
Citations
Frequency
389 1,940
3,484 Percent
6.65 %
33.14 %
59.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.70
26.06 30.48
Warnings
Frequency
638 2,598
4,424 Percent
8.23 %
33.51 %
57.07 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.51
34.90 38.71
Clean
Frequency 548
2,906 3,521
Percent 7.64 %
40.52 %
49.09 %
Rate per 100 stops
34.79 39.04
30.81 Searches (All)
Frequency
8 16
25 Percent
16.33 %
32.65 %
51.02 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.51
0.21 0.22
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
6 9
14 Percent
20.69 %
31.03 %
48.28 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.38
0.12 0.12
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
7 11
Percent 10.00 %
35.00 %
55.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.13 0.09
0.10 Contraband H
its
Frequency 4
7 9
Percent 20.00 %
35.00 %
45.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
50.00 43.75
36.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
198
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 4A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 134
12 146
0 38
Percent 0.64 %
0.06 %
0.70 %
0.00 %
0.18 %
Citations
Frequency
20 3
18 0
0 Percent
0.34 %
0.05 %
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 14.93
25.00 12.33
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
41 6
45 0
0 Percent
0.53 %
0.08 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 30.60
50.00 30.82
--- 0.00
Clean
Frequency 73
3 83
0 38
Percent 1.02 %
0.04 %
1.16 %
0.00 %
0.53 %
Rate per 100 stops
54.48 25.00
56.85 ---
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
199
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 4A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 1,547
7,642 12,472
Percent 6.96 %
34.40 %
56.14 %
Citations
Frequency
365 1,934
3,386 Percent
6.36 %
33.71 %
59.02 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.59
25.31 27.15
Warnings
Frequency
521 2,607
4,565 Percent
6.65 %
33.26 %
58.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 33.68
34.11 36.60
Clean
Frequency 661
3,101 4,521
Percent 7.65 %
35.90 %
52.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
42.73 40.58
36.25 Searches (All)
Frequency
7 7
28 Percent
16.67 %
16.67 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.45
0.09 0.22
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3 2
21 Percent
11.54 %
7.69 %
80.77 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.19
0.03 0.17
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
5 7
Percent 25.00 %
31.25 %
43.75 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.26 0.07
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
2 3
Percent 16.67 %
33.33 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
14.29 28.57
10.71 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
1 1
Percent 0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.01
0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
200
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 4A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 208
17 305
0 24
Percent 0.94 %
0.08 %
1.37 %
0.00 %
0.11 %
Citations
Frequency
24 4
24 0
0 Percent
0.42 %
0.07 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.54
23.53 7.87
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
60 3
81 0
2 Percent
0.77 %
0.04 %
1.03 %
0.00 %
0.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 28.85
17.65 26.56
--- 8.33
Clean
Frequency 124
10 200
0 22
Percent 1.44 %
0.12 %
2.32 %
0.00 %
0.25 %
Rate per 100 stops
59.62 58.82
65.57 ---
91.67 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
201
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
202
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 4B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 4,849
21,966 71,629
Percent 4.83 %
21.90 %
71.42 %
Citations
Frequency
1,417 4,292
23,692 Percent
4.74 %
14.37 %
79.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 29.22
19.54 33.08
Warnings
Frequency
3,432 17,674
47,937 Percent
4.87 %
25.09 %
68.06 %
Rate per 100 stops 70.78
80.46 66.92
Searches (All)
Frequency 294
554 3,150
Percent 7.28 %
13.72 %
78.01 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.06 2.52
4.40 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 97
220 1,401
Percent 5.59 %
12.68 %
80.75 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.00 1.00
1.96 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
197 334
1,749 Percent
8.55 %
14.50 %
75.94 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.06
1.52 2.44
Contraband Hits
Frequency
67 133
567 Percent
8.68 %
17.23 %
73.45 %
Rate per 100 searches 22.79
24.01 18.00
Race Known
Frequency
4 13
24 Percent
9.52 %
30.95 %
57.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.08
0.06 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
203
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 4B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,323
71 459
0 0
Percent 1.32 %
0.07 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
310 23
130 0
0 Percent
1.04 %
0.08 %
0.44 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.43
32.39 28.32
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,013 48
329 0
0 Percent
1.44 %
0.07 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 76.57
67.61 71.68
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 22
4 14
0 0
Percent 0.54 %
0.10 %
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.66 5.63
3.05 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 8
1 8
0 0
Percent 0.46 %
0.06 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.60 1.41
1.74 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
14 3
6 0
0 Percent
0.61 %
0.13 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.06
4.23 1.31
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 13.64
0.00 14.29
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.08
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
204
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 4B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 5,551
23,733 69,349
Percent 5.51 %
23.56 %
68.85 %
Citations
Frequency
1,495 4,561
23,123 Percent
5.04 %
15.38 %
77.97 %
Rate per 100 stops 26.93
19.22 33.34
Warnings
Frequency
4,056 19,172
46,226 Percent
5.71 %
26.98 %
65.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 73.07
80.78 66.66
Searches (All)
Frequency 173
259 1,253
Percent 10.12 %
15.15 %
73.27 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.12 1.09
1.81 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 79
129 749
Percent 8.12 %
13.26 %
76.98 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.42 0.54
1.08 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
94 130
504 Percent
12.75 %
17.64 %
68.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.69
0.55 0.73
Contraband Hits
Frequency
56 95
333 Percent
11.38 %
19.31 %
67.68 %
Rate per 100 searches 32.37
36.68 26.58
Race Known
Frequency
2 4
10 Percent
12.50 %
25.00 %
62.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.04
0.02 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
205
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 4B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,337
72 686
0 1
Percent 1.33 %
0.07 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
310 23
145 0
0 Percent
1.05 %
0.08 %
0.49 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 23.19
31.94 21.14
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,027 49
541 0
1 Percent
1.45 %
0.07 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 76.81
68.06 78.86
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 13
4 8
0 0
Percent 0.76 %
0.23 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.97 5.56
1.17 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 11
0 5
0 0
Percent 1.13 %
0.00 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.82 0.00
0.73 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 4
3 0
0 Percent
0.27 %
0.54 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.15
5.56 0.44
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 4
1 0
0 Percent
0.61 %
0.81 %
0.20 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 23.08
100.00 12.50
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
206
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 4B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 380
1,094 3,914
Percent 6.68 %
19.24 %
68.85 %
Citations
Frequency
50 98
731 Percent
5.59 %
10.96 %
81.77 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.16
8.96 18.68
Warnings
Frequency
188 515
2,142 Percent
6.29 %
17.22 %
71.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 49.47
47.07 54.73
Clean
Frequency 142
481 1,041
Percent 7.88 %
26.71 %
57.80 %
Rate per 100 stops
37.37 43.97
26.60 Searches (All)
Frequency
4 2
6 Percent
30.77 %
15.38 %
46.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.05
0.18 0.15
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 2
5 Percent
11.11 %
22.22 %
55.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.26
0.18 0.13
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
0 1
Percent 75.00 %
0.00 %
25.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.79 0.00
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 33.33 %
33.33 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
25.00 50.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
1 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.09
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
207
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 4B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 169
2 45
0 81
Percent 2.97 %
0.04 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
1.42 %
Citations
Frequency
14 0
1 0
0 Percent
1.57 %
0.00 %
0.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.28
0.00 2.22
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
107 0
28 0
10 Percent
3.58 %
0.00 %
0.94 %
0.00 %
0.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.31
0.00 62.22
--- 12.35
Clean
Frequency 48
2 16
0 71
Percent 2.67 %
0.11 %
0.89 %
0.00 %
3.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.40 100.00
35.56 ---
87.65 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
7.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.59
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
11.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.59
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 0
0 0
Percent 33.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
208
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 4B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 501
1,563 5,437
Percent 6.25 %
19.49 %
67.78 %
Citations
Frequency
43 131
788 Percent
4.30 %
13.09 %
78.72 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.58
8.38 14.49
Warnings
Frequency
253 661
3,000 Percent
6.14 %
16.04 %
72.82 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.50
42.29 55.18
Clean
Frequency 205
771 1,649
Percent 7.07 %
26.59 %
56.86 %
Rate per 100 stops
40.92 49.33
30.33 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 3
22 Percent
7.41 %
11.11 %
81.48 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.40
0.19 0.40
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 2
19 Percent
8.70 %
8.70 %
82.61 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.40
0.13 0.35
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
1 3
Percent 0.00 %
25.00 %
75.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.06
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 3
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 0.00
13.64 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
1 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.06
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
209
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 4B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 251
4 116
0 149
Percent 3.13 %
0.05 %
1.45 %
0.00 %
1.86 %
Citations
Frequency
24 1
14 0
0 Percent
2.40 %
0.10 %
1.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 9.56
25.00 12.07
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
134 0
61 0
11 Percent
3.25 %
0.00 %
1.48 %
0.00 %
0.27 %
Rate per 100 stops 53.39
0.00 52.59
--- 7.38
Clean
Frequency 93
3 41
0 138
Percent 3.21 %
0.10 %
1.41 %
0.00 %
4.76 %
Rate per 100 stops
37.05 75.00
35.34 ---
92.62 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX H – REGION 4:EL PASO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
210
Appendix I Region 5: Lubbock Analysis
211
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
Throckmorton
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
212
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 5 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 18,874
169,603 64,745
Percent 7.27 %
65.29 %
24.92 %
Citations
Frequency
7,469 39,278
24,876 Percent
10.11 %
53.18 %
33.68 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.57
23.16 38.42
Warnings
Frequency
11,405 130,325
39,869 Percent
6.13 %
70.10 %
21.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.43
76.84 61.58
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,714
4,944 3,978
Percent 15.66 %
45.18 %
36.35 %
Rate per 100 stops
9.08 2.92
6.14 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 414
1,570 1,561
Percent 11.23 %
42.57 %
42.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.19 0.93
2.41 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,300 3,374
2,417 Percent
17.92 %
46.51 %
33.31 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.89
1.99 3.73
Contraband Hits
Frequency
783 2,396
1,583 Percent
16.01 %
48.98 %
32.36 %
Rate per 100 searches 45.68
48.46 39.79
Race Known
Frequency
76 590
288 Percent
7.80 %
60.57 %
29.57 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.40
0.35 0.44
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
213
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 5 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 4,454
510 1,584
0 0
Percent 1.71 %
0.20 %
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,465 167
605 0
0 Percent
1.98 %
0.23 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 32.89
32.75 38.19
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
2,989 343
979 0
0 Percent
1.61 %
0.18 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 67.11
67.25 61.81
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 213
35 59
0 0
Percent 1.95 %
0.32 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.78 6.86
3.72 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 108
10 25
0 0
Percent 2.93 %
0.27 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.42 1.96
1.58 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
105 25
34 0
0 Percent
1.45 %
0.34 %
0.47 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.36
4.90 2.15
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
86 16
28 0
0 Percent
1.76 %
0.33 %
0.57 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.38
45.71 47.46
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
19 1
0 0
0 Percent
1.95 %
0.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.43
0.20 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
214
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 5 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 16,252
151,406 57,792
Percent 7.01 %
65.32 %
24.93 %
Citations
Frequency
6,386 36,391
23,447 Percent
9.32 %
53.13 %
34.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.29
24.04 40.57
Warnings
Frequency
9,866 115,015
34,345 Percent
6.04 %
70.44 %
21.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.71
75.96 59.43
Searches (All)
Frequency 874
2,587 1,927
Percent 15.85 %
46.93 %
34.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
5.38 1.71
3.33 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 252
776 693
Percent 14.19 %
43.69 %
39.02 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.55 0.51
1.20 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
622 1,811
1,234 Percent
16.64 %
48.46 %
33.02 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.83
1.20 2.14
Contraband Hits
Frequency
546 1,754
1,069 Percent
15.92 %
51.14 %
31.17 %
Rate per 100 searches 62.47
67.80 55.47
Race Known
Frequency
10 40
17 Percent
14.93 %
59.70 %
25.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.06
0.03 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
215
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 5 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,902
447 1,976
7 2
Percent 1.68 %
0.19 %
0.85 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,364 138
766 4
1 Percent
1.99 %
0.20 %
1.12 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.96
30.87 38.77
57.14 50.00
Warnings
Frequency
2,538 309
1,210 3
1 Percent
1.55 %
0.19 %
0.74 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.04
69.13 61.23
42.86 50.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 76
18 31
0 0
Percent 1.38 %
0.33 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.95 4.03
1.57 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 34
6 15
0 0
Percent 1.91 %
0.34 %
0.84 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.87 1.34
0.76 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
42 12
16 0
0 Percent
1.12 %
0.32 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.08
2.68 0.81
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
40 8
13 0
0 Percent
1.17 %
0.23 %
0.38 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 52.63
44.44 41.94
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
216
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 5 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,358 9,916
6,959 Percent
7.26 %
52.98 %
37.18 %
Citations
Frequency 297
2,190 1,889
Percent 6.70 %
49.37 %
42.58 %
Rate per 100 stops
21.87 22.09
27.14 W
arnings
Frequency 675
4,620 3,449
Percent 7.49 %
51.24 %
38.25 %
Rate per 100 stops
49.71 46.59
49.56 Clean
Frequency
386 3,106
1,621 Percent
7.33 %
59.00 %
30.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 28.42
31.32 23.29
Searches (All)
Frequency 15
22 26
Percent 21.13 %
30.99 %
36.62 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.10 0.22
0.37 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 6
15 22
Percent 12.24 %
30.61 %
44.90 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.44 0.15
0.32 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
9 7
4 Percent
40.91 %
31.82 %
18.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.66
0.07 0.06
Contraband Hits
Frequency
4 6
1 Percent
33.33 %
50.00 %
8.33 %
Rate per 100 searches 26.67
27.27 3.85
Race Known
Frequency
0 3
2 Percent
0.00 %
60.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.03 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
217
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 5 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 303
16 115
0 49
Percent 1.62 %
0.09 %
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.26 %
Citations
Frequency
38 3
19 0
0 Percent
0.86 %
0.07 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 12.54
18.75 16.52
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
192 7
60 0
13 Percent
2.13 %
0.08 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.37
43.75 52.17
--- 26.53
Clean
Frequency 73
6 36
0 36
Percent 1.39 %
0.11 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.68 %
Rate per 100 stops
24.09 37.50
31.30 ---
73.47 Searches (All)
Frequency
7 0
1 0
0 Percent
9.86 %
0.00 %
1.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.31
0.00 0.87
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
6 0
0 0
0 Percent
12.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.98
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 1
0 0
Percent 4.55 %
0.00 %
4.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.33 0.00
0.87 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
8.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
100.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
218
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 5 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
1,340 9,972
6,722 Percent
7.18 %
53.41 %
36.01 %
Citations
Frequency 239
2,122 1,866
Percent 5.53 %
49.12 %
43.19 %
Rate per 100 stops
17.84 21.28
27.76 W
arnings
Frequency 710
4,840 3,409
Percent 7.62 %
51.96 %
36.60 %
Rate per 100 stops
52.99 48.54
50.71 Clean
Frequency
391 3,010
1,447 Percent
7.77 %
59.78 %
28.74 %
Rate per 100 stops 29.18
30.18 21.53
Searches (All)
Frequency 7
16 21
Percent 15.56 %
35.56 %
46.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.52 0.16
0.31 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 6
13 19
Percent 15.38 %
33.33 %
48.72 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.45 0.13
0.28 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 3
2 Percent
16.67 %
50.00 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.07
0.03 0.03
Contraband Hits
Frequency
0 7
1 Percent
0.00 %
87.50 %
12.50 %
Rate per 100 searches 0.00
43.75 4.76
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
1 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
219
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 5 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 323
19 220
2 71
Percent 1.73 %
0.10 %
1.18 %
0.01 %
0.38 %
Citations
Frequency
51 6
35 1
0 Percent
1.18 %
0.14 %
0.81 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.79
31.58 15.91
50.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
211 3
135 1
5 Percent
2.27 %
0.03 %
1.45 %
0.01 %
0.05 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.33
15.79 61.36
50.00 7.04
Clean
Frequency 61
10 50
0 66
Percent 1.21 %
0.20 %
0.99 %
0.00 %
1.31 %
Rate per 100 stops
18.89 52.63
22.73 0.00
92.96 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.45
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
2.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.45
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX I – REGION 5:LUBBOCK ANALYSIS
220
Appendix J Region 5: Lubbock
District Level Analysis
221
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
222
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 6,771
60,090 23,102
Percent 7.36 %
65.35 %
25.12 %
Citations
Frequency
2,600 13,129
9,007 Percent
10.27 %
51.86 %
35.58 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.40
21.85 38.99
Warnings
Frequency
4,171 46,961
14,095 Percent
6.26 %
70.48 %
21.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.60
78.15 61.01
Searches (All)
Frequency 691
1,822 1,556
Percent 16.57 %
43.70 %
37.32 %
Rate per 100 stops
10.21 3.03
6.74 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 187
655 564
Percent 12.88 %
45.11 %
38.84 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.76 1.09
2.44 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
504 1,167
992 Percent
18.55 %
42.95 %
36.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.44
1.94 4.29
Contraband Hits
Frequency
327 935
711 Percent
16.20 %
46.31 %
35.22 %
Rate per 100 searches 47.32
51.32 45.69
Race Known
Frequency
72 555
276 Percent
7.80 %
60.13 %
29.90 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.06
0.92 1.19
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
223
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,346
129 512
0 0
Percent 1.46 %
0.14 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
376 47
158 0
0 Percent
1.49 %
0.19 %
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.93
36.43 30.86
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
970 82
354 0
0 Percent
1.46 %
0.12 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 72.07
63.57 69.14
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 65
9 26
0 0
Percent 1.56 %
0.22 %
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.83 6.98
5.08 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 35
1 10
0 0
Percent 2.41 %
0.07 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.60 0.78
1.95 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
30 8
16 0
0 Percent
1.10 %
0.29 %
0.59 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.23
6.20 3.13
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
25 7
14 0
0 Percent
1.24 %
0.35 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 38.46
77.78 53.85
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
19 1
0 0
0 Percent
2.06 %
0.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.41
0.78 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
224
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 5,677
53,565 19,719
Percent 7.02 %
66.20 %
24.37 %
Citations
Frequency
2,182 11,730
8,281 Percent
9.58 %
51.52 %
36.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.44
21.90 42.00
Warnings
Frequency
3,495 41,835
11,438 Percent
6.01 %
71.95 %
19.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.56
78.10 58.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 392
1,026 854
Percent 16.96 %
44.40 %
36.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.91 1.92
4.33 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 108
361 302
Percent 13.62 %
45.52 %
38.08 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.90 0.67
1.53 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
284 665
552 Percent
18.71 %
43.81 %
36.36 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.00
1.24 2.80
Contraband Hits
Frequency
255 684
489 Percent
17.66 %
47.37 %
33.86 %
Rate per 100 searches 65.05
66.67 57.26
Race Known
Frequency
9 33
10 Percent
17.31 %
63.46 %
19.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.16
0.06 0.05
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
225
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,183
112 656
0 0
Percent 1.46 %
0.14 %
0.81 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
332 28
213 0
0 Percent
1.46 %
0.12 %
0.94 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 28.06
25.00 32.47
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
851 84
443 0
0 Percent
1.46 %
0.14 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 71.94
75.00 67.53
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 22
5 12
0 0
Percent 0.95 %
0.22 %
0.52 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.86 4.46
1.83 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 11
5 6
0 0
Percent 1.39 %
0.63 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.93 4.46
0.91 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
11 0
6 0
0 Percent
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.93
0.00 0.91
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
9 0
7 0
0 Percent
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.91
0.00 58.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
226
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 460
3,315 2,251
Percent 7.43 %
53.55 %
36.36 %
Citations
Frequency
102 811
669 Percent
6.37 %
50.66 %
41.79 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.17
24.46 29.72
Warnings
Frequency
235 1,572
1,170 Percent
7.67 %
51.34 %
38.21 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.09
47.42 51.98
Clean
Frequency 123
932 412
Percent 8.05 %
60.99 %
26.96 %
Rate per 100 stops
26.74 28.11
18.30 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 7
3 Percent
20.00 %
46.67 %
20.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.65
0.21 0.13
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 6
2 Percent
0.00 %
66.67 %
22.22 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.18 0.09
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
1 1
Percent 50.00 %
16.67 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.65 0.03
0.04 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
33.33 14.29
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
227
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 70
7 39
0 49
Percent 1.13 %
0.11 %
0.63 %
0.00 %
0.79 %
Citations
Frequency
11 1
7 0
0 Percent
0.69 %
0.06 %
0.44 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.71
14.29 17.95
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
47 3
22 0
13 Percent
1.53 %
0.10 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.42 %
Rate per 100 stops 67.14
42.86 56.41
--- 26.53
Clean
Frequency 12
3 10
0 36
Percent 0.79 %
0.20 %
0.65 %
0.00 %
2.36 %
Rate per 100 stops
17.14 42.86
25.64 ---
73.47 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 0
0 0
0 Percent
13.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.86
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
11.11 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.43
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 0
0 0
Percent 16.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.43 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
228
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 414
2,951 1,866
Percent 7.65 %
54.51 %
34.47 %
Citations
Frequency
93 728
651 Percent
6.20 %
48.53 %
43.40 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.46
24.67 34.89
Warnings
Frequency
200 1,392
911 Percent
7.79 %
54.18 %
35.46 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.31
47.17 48.82
Clean
Frequency 121
831 304
Percent 9.00 %
61.78 %
22.60 %
Rate per 100 stops
29.23 28.16
16.29 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 4
5 Percent
18.18 %
36.36 %
45.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.48
0.14 0.27
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 2
5 Percent
22.22 %
22.22 %
55.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.48
0.07 0.27
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
2 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.07
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
3 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 75.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
229
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 70
9 41
0 63
Percent 1.29 %
0.17 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
1.16 %
Citations
Frequency
16 4
8 0
0 Percent
1.07 %
0.27 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.86
44.44 19.51
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
38 0
23 0
5 Percent
1.48 %
0.00 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.19 %
Rate per 100 stops 54.29
0.00 56.10
--- 7.94
Clean
Frequency 16
5 10
0 58
Percent 1.19 %
0.37 %
0.74 %
0.00 %
4.31 %
Rate per 100 stops
22.86 55.56
24.39 ---
92.06 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
230
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
231
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 5,566
56,339 24,770
Percent 6.21 %
62.90 %
27.65 %
Citations
Frequency
2,221 12,606
9,168 Percent
8.88 %
50.39 %
36.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.90
22.38 37.01
Warnings
Frequency
3,345 43,733
15,602 Percent
5.18 %
67.75 %
24.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.10
77.62 62.99
Searches (All)
Frequency 643
1,868 1,623
Percent 14.92 %
43.35 %
37.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
11.55 3.32
6.55 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 149
553 727
Percent 9.85 %
36.55 %
48.05 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.68 0.98
2.94 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
494 1,315
896 Percent
17.67 %
47.03 %
32.05 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.88
2.33 3.62
Contraband Hits
Frequency
289 873
554 Percent
16.21 %
48.96 %
31.07 %
Rate per 100 searches 44.95
46.73 34.13
Race Known
Frequency
1 16
2 Percent
5.26 %
84.21 %
10.53 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.02
0.03 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
232
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 2,035
304 559
0 0
Percent 2.27 %
0.34 %
0.62 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
698 92
234 0
0 Percent
2.79 %
0.37 %
0.94 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 34.30
30.26 41.86
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,337 212
325 0
0 Percent
2.07 %
0.33 %
0.50 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.70
69.74 58.14
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 129
23 23
0 0
Percent 2.99 %
0.53 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
6.34 7.57
4.11 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 63
8 13
0 0
Percent 4.16 %
0.53 %
0.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.10 2.63
2.33 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
66 15
10 0
0 Percent
2.36 %
0.54 %
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.24
4.93 1.79
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
52 7
8 0
0 Percent
2.92 %
0.39 %
0.45 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 40.31
30.43 34.78
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
233
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 5,026
52,461 23,318
Percent 6.01 %
62.72 %
27.88 %
Citations
Frequency
2,010 13,096
9,227 Percent
7.91 %
51.57 %
36.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.99
24.96 39.57
Warnings
Frequency
3,016 39,365
14,091 Percent
5.18 %
67.59 %
24.19 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.01
75.04 60.43
Searches (All)
Frequency 272
989 729
Percent 13.25 %
48.17 %
35.51 %
Rate per 100 stops
5.41 1.89
3.13 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 87
232 257
Percent 14.55 %
38.80 %
42.98 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.73 0.44
1.10 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
185 757
472 Percent
12.71 %
52.03 %
32.44 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.68
1.44 2.02
Contraband Hits
Frequency
173 703
399 Percent
13.26 %
53.87 %
30.57 %
Rate per 100 searches 63.60
71.08 54.73
Race Known
Frequency
0 2
3 Percent
0.00 %
40.00 %
60.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
234
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,789
264 776
5 1
Percent 2.14 %
0.32 %
0.93 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
651 84
325 2
0 Percent
2.56 %
0.33 %
1.28 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.39
31.82 41.88
40.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,138 180
451 3
1 Percent
1.95 %
0.31 %
0.77 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.61
68.18 58.12
60.00 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 43
12 8
0 0
Percent 2.09 %
0.58 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.40 4.55
1.03 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 16
1 5
0 0
Percent 2.68 %
0.17 %
0.84 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.89 0.38
0.64 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
27 11
3 0
0 Percent
1.86 %
0.76 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.51
4.17 0.39
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
23 7
0 0
0 Percent
1.76 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 53.49
58.33 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
235
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 422
3,786 3,048
Percent 5.64 %
50.57 %
40.72 %
Citations
Frequency
66 723
767 Percent
4.17 %
45.67 %
48.45 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.64
19.10 25.16
Warnings
Frequency
243 1,960
1,616 Percent
6.10 %
49.20 %
40.56 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.58
51.77 53.02
Clean
Frequency 113
1,103 665
Percent 5.89 %
57.48 %
34.65 %
Rate per 100 stops
26.78 29.13
21.82 Searches (All)
Frequency
4 11
8 Percent
14.29 %
39.29 %
28.57 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.95
0.29 0.26
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 7
6 Percent
5.56 %
38.89 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.24
0.18 0.20
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
4 2
Percent 30.00 %
40.00 %
20.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.71 0.11
0.07 Contraband H
its
Frequency 2
4 0
Percent 28.57 %
57.14 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
50.00 36.36
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
3 2
Percent 0.00 %
60.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.08
0.07
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
236
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 171
3 56
0 0
Percent 2.28 %
0.04 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
19 1
7 0
0 Percent
1.20 %
0.06 %
0.44 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.11
33.33 12.50
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
128 1
36 0
0 Percent
3.21 %
0.03 %
0.90 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 74.85
33.33 64.29
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 24
1 13
0 0
Percent 1.25 %
0.05 %
0.68 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
14.04 33.33
23.21 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
4 0
1 0
0 Percent
14.29 %
0.00 %
3.57 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.34
0.00 1.79
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 0
0 0
0 Percent
22.22 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.34
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
10.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
1.79 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
14.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
100.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
237
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 428
3,833 3,083
Percent 5.56 %
49.83 %
40.08 %
Citations
Frequency
47 635
687 Percent
3.32 %
44.88 %
48.55 %
Rate per 100 stops 10.98
16.57 22.28
Warnings
Frequency
296 2,149
1,767 Percent
6.62 %
48.10 %
39.55 %
Rate per 100 stops 69.16
56.07 57.31
Clean
Frequency 85
1,049 629
Percent 4.70 %
57.99 %
34.77 %
Rate per 100 stops
19.86 27.37
20.40 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 5
6 Percent
7.69 %
38.46 %
46.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.23
0.13 0.19
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 5
5 Percent
8.33 %
41.67 %
41.67 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.23
0.13 0.16
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
1 1
Percent 0.00 %
50.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 20.00
16.67 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
238
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 184
6 148
2 8
Percent 2.39 %
0.08 %
1.92 %
0.03 %
0.10 %
Citations
Frequency
21 2
22 1
0 Percent
1.48 %
0.14 %
1.55 %
0.07 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.41
33.33 14.86
50.00 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
147 2
106 1
0 Percent
3.29 %
0.04 %
2.37 %
0.02 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 79.89
33.33 71.62
50.00 0.00
Clean
Frequency 16
2 20
0 8
Percent 0.88 %
0.11 %
1.11 %
0.00 %
0.44 %
Rate per 100 stops
8.70 33.33
13.51 0.00
100.00 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
7.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.68
0.00 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
8.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.68
0.00 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
239
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
240
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 6,537
53,174 16,873
Percent 8.35 %
67.96 %
21.56 %
Citations
Frequency
2,648 13,543
6,701 Percent
11.26 %
57.57 %
28.49 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.51
25.47 39.71
Warnings
Frequency
3,889 39,631
10,172 Percent
7.11 %
72.42 %
18.59 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.49
74.53 60.29
Searches (All)
Frequency 380
1,254 799
Percent 15.42 %
50.87 %
32.41 %
Rate per 100 stops
5.81 2.36
4.74 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 78
362 270
Percent 10.79 %
50.07 %
37.34 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.19 0.68
1.60 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
302 892
529 Percent
17.34 %
51.21 %
30.37 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.62
1.68 3.14
Contraband Hits
Frequency
167 588
318 Percent
15.32 %
53.94 %
29.17 %
Rate per 100 searches 43.95
46.89 39.80
Race Known
Frequency
3 19
10 Percent
9.38 %
59.38 %
31.25 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.05
0.04 0.06
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
241
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 5C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,073
77 513
0 0
Percent 1.37 %
0.10 %
0.66 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
391 28
213 0
0 Percent
1.66 %
0.12 %
0.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 36.44
36.36 41.52
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
682 49
300 0
0 Percent
1.25 %
0.09 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 63.56
63.64 58.48
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 19
3 10
0 0
Percent 0.77 %
0.12 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.77 3.90
1.95 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 10
1 2
0 0
Percent 1.38 %
0.14 %
0.28 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.93 1.30
0.39 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
9 2
8 0
0 Percent
0.52 %
0.11 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.84
2.60 1.56
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
9 2
6 0
0 Percent
0.83 %
0.18 %
0.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 47.37
66.67 60.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
242
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 5,549
45,380 14,755
Percent 8.25 %
67.50 %
21.95 %
Citations
Frequency
2,194 11,565
5,939 Percent
10.79 %
56.87 %
29.20 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.54
25.48 40.25
Warnings
Frequency
3,355 33,815
8,816 Percent
7.15 %
72.11 %
18.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.46
74.52 59.75
Searches (All)
Frequency 210
572 344
Percent 18.28 %
49.78 %
29.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.78 1.26
2.33 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 57
183 134
Percent 14.81 %
47.53 %
34.81 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.03 0.40
0.91 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
153 389
210 Percent
20.03 %
50.92 %
27.49 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.76
0.86 1.42
Contraband Hits
Frequency
118 367
181 Percent
17.33 %
53.89 %
26.58 %
Rate per 100 searches 56.19
64.16 52.62
Race Known
Frequency
1 5
4 Percent
10.00 %
50.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.02
0.01 0.03
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
243
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 5C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 930
71 544
2 1
Percent 1.38 %
0.11 %
0.81 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
381 26
228 2
1 Percent
1.87 %
0.13 %
1.12 %
0.01 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.97
36.62 41.91
100.00 100.00
Warnings
Frequency
549 45
316 0
0 Percent
1.17 %
0.10 %
0.67 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.03
63.38 58.09
0.00 0.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 11
1 11
0 0
Percent 0.96 %
0.09 %
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.18 1.41
2.02 0.00
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 7
0 4
0 0
Percent 1.82 %
0.00 %
1.04 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.75 0.00
0.74 0.00
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
4 1
7 0
0 Percent
0.52 %
0.13 %
0.92 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.43
1.41 1.29
0.00 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
8 1
6 0
0 Percent
1.17 %
0.15 %
0.88 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 72.73
100.00 54.55
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
244
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 476
2,815 1,660
Percent 9.45 %
55.86 %
32.94 %
Citations
Frequency
129 656
453 Percent
10.30 %
52.40 %
36.18 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.10
23.30 27.29
Warnings
Frequency
197 1,088
663 Percent
10.00 %
55.23 %
33.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.39
38.65 39.94
Clean
Frequency 150
1,071 544
Percent 8.26 %
58.94 %
29.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
31.51 38.05
32.77 Searches (All)
Frequency
8 4
15 Percent
28.57 %
14.29 %
53.57 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.68
0.14 0.90
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
5 2
14 Percent
22.73 %
9.09 %
63.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.05
0.07 0.84
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 3
2 1
Percent 50.00 %
33.33 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.63 0.07
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 1
Percent 33.33 %
33.33 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 searches
12.50 25.00
6.67 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
245
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 5C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 62
6 20
0 0
Percent 1.23 %
0.12 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
8 1
5 0
0 Percent
0.64 %
0.08 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 12.90
16.67 25.00
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
17 3
2 0
0 Percent
0.86 %
0.15 %
0.10 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.42
50.00 10.00
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 37
2 13
0 0
Percent 2.04 %
0.11 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
59.68 33.33
65.00 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
3.57 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.61
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
4.55 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.61
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
246
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 498
3,188 1,773
Percent 8.95 %
57.31 %
31.87 %
Citations
Frequency
99 759
528 Percent
7.05 %
54.02 %
37.58 %
Rate per 100 stops 19.88
23.81 29.78
Warnings
Frequency
214 1,299
731 Percent
9.40 %
57.05 %
32.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.97
40.75 41.23
Clean
Frequency 185
1,130 514
Percent 9.84 %
60.07 %
27.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
37.15 35.45
28.99 Searches (All)
Frequency
4 7
10 Percent
19.05 %
33.33 %
47.62 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.80
0.22 0.56
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
3 6
9 Percent
16.67 %
33.33 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.60
0.19 0.51
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
1 1
Percent 33.33 %
33.33 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.20 0.03
0.06 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
3 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 42.86
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
247
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 5C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 69
4 31
0 0
Percent 1.24 %
0.07 %
0.56 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
14 0
5 0
0 Percent
1.00 %
0.00 %
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 20.29
0.00 16.13
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
26 1
6 0
0 Percent
1.14 %
0.04 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.68
25.00 19.35
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 29
3 20
0 0
Percent 1.54 %
0.16 %
1.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
42.03 75.00
64.52 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX J – REGION 5:LUBBOCK – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
248
Appendix K Region 6: San Antonio Analysis
249
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
250
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 6 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 35,615
165,515 110,250
Percent 11.11 %
51.64 %
34.40 %
Citations
Frequency
15,524 54,198
51,202 Percent
12.46 %
43.50 %
41.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.59
32.75 46.44
Warnings
Frequency
20,091 111,317
59,048 Percent
10.25 %
56.81 %
30.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.41
67.25 53.56
Searches (All)
Frequency 3,230
5,544 8,030
Percent 19.02 %
32.65 %
47.29 %
Rate per 100 stops
9.07 3.35
7.28 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 624
1,544 2,372
Percent 13.60 %
33.66 %
51.71 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.75 0.93
2.15 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2,606 4,000
5,658 Percent
21.03 %
32.28 %
45.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.32
2.42 5.13
Contraband Hits
Frequency
1,393 2,194
2,859 Percent
21.37 %
33.65 %
43.85 %
Rate per 100 searches 43.13
39.57 35.60
Race Known
Frequency
175 1,446
312 Percent
8.78 %
72.55 %
15.65 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.49
0.87 0.28
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
251
Highway Patrol - 2017
REGIO
N 6 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 6,590
267 2,281
0 4
Percent 2.06 %
0.08 %
0.71 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2,610 115
932 0
1 Percent
2.10 %
0.09 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.61
43.07 40.86
--- 25.00
Warnings
Frequency
3,980 152
1,349 0
3 Percent
2.03 %
0.08 %
0.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.39
56.93 59.14
--- 75.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 117
17 42
0 0
Percent 0.69 %
0.10 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.78 6.37
1.84 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 33
6 8
0 0
Percent 0.72 %
0.13 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.50 2.25
0.35 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
84 11
34 0
0 Percent
0.68 %
0.09 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.27
4.12 1.49
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
46 9
19 0
0 Percent
0.71 %
0.14 %
0.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 39.32
52.94 45.24
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
36 3
21 0
0 Percent
1.81 %
0.15 %
1.05 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.55
1.12 0.92
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
252
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 6 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 27,278
139,726 86,059
Percent 10.45 %
53.54 %
32.97 %
Citations
Frequency
11,901 47,113
40,541 Percent
11.56 %
45.77 %
39.38 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.63
33.72 47.11
Warnings
Frequency
15,377 92,613
45,518 Percent
9.73 %
58.60 %
28.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.37
66.28 52.89
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,082
2,057 2,287
Percent 19.74 %
37.52 %
41.72 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.97 1.47
2.66 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 230
595 735
Percent 14.59 %
37.75 %
46.64 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.84 0.43
0.85 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
852 1,462
1,552 Percent
21.81 %
37.43 %
39.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.12
1.05 1.80
Contraband Hits
Frequency
607 1,151
1,088 Percent
21.09 %
39.99 %
37.80 %
Rate per 100 searches 56.10
55.96 47.57
Race Known
Frequency
177 1,676
332 Percent
7.89 %
74.72 %
14.80 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.65
1.20 0.39
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
253
Highway Patrol - 2016
REGIO
N 6 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 5,024
227 2,676
0 5
Percent 1.92 %
0.09 %
1.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
2,133 96
1,160 0
0 Percent
2.07 %
0.09 %
1.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.46
42.29 43.35
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
2,891 131
1,516 0
5 Percent
1.83 %
0.08 %
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.54
57.71 56.65
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 37
3 16
0 0
Percent 0.67 %
0.05 %
0.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.74 1.32
0.60 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 10
2 4
0 0
Percent 0.63 %
0.13 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.20 0.88
0.15 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
27 1
12 0
0 Percent
0.69 %
0.03 %
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.54
0.44 0.45
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
21 1
10 0
0 Percent
0.73 %
0.03 %
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 56.76
33.33 62.50
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
34 1
23 0
0 Percent
1.52 %
0.04 %
1.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.68
0.44 0.86
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
254
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 6 2017 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
2,364 7,790
11,656 Percent
10.61 %
34.96 %
52.31 %
Citations
Frequency 510
1,579 3,303
Percent 9.41 %
29.12 %
60.92 %
Rate per 100 stops
21.57 20.27
28.34 W
arnings
Frequency 1,266
3,890 6,271
Percent 10.95 %
33.64 %
54.22 %
Rate per 100 stops
53.55 49.94
53.80 Clean
Frequency
588 2,321
2,082 Percent
11.10 %
43.83 %
39.32 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.87
29.79 17.86
Searches (All)
Frequency 6
5 12
Percent 26.09 %
21.74 %
52.17 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.25 0.06
0.10 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
4 9
Percent 23.53 %
23.53 %
52.94 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.17 0.05
0.08 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 1
3 Percent
33.33 %
16.67 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.08
0.01 0.03
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 0
3 Percent
50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.00
0.00 25.00
Race Known
Frequency
8 46
18 Percent
11.11 %
63.89 %
25.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.34
0.59 0.15
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
255
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
Region 6 2017 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 96
4 93
0 279
Percent 0.43 %
0.02 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
1.25 %
Citations
Frequency
14 0
16 0
0 Percent
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.30 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 14.58
0.00 17.20
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
55 2
59 0
22 Percent
0.48 %
0.02 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.19 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.29
50.00 63.44
--- 7.89
Clean
Frequency 27
2 18
0 257
Percent 0.51 %
0.04 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
4.85 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.13 50.00
19.35 ---
92.11 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
256
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 6 2016 African Am
erican W
hite H
ispanic Stops
Frequency
2,122 7,163
9,810 Percent
10.87 %
36.68 %
50.24 %
Citations
Frequency 429
1,374 2,521
Percent 9.86 %
31.56 %
57.91 %
Rate per 100 stops
20.22 19.18
25.70 W
arnings
Frequency 1,225
3,928 5,719
Percent 11.11 %
35.61 %
51.85 %
Rate per 100 stops
57.73 54.84
58.30 Clean
Frequency
468 1,861
1,570 Percent
11.30 %
44.92 %
37.90 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.05
25.98 16.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 7
6 22
Percent 18.92 %
16.22 %
59.46 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.33 0.08
0.22 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
3 19
Percent 4.00 %
12.00 %
76.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.05 0.04
0.19 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
6 3
3 Percent
50.00 %
25.00 %
25.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.28
0.04 0.03
Contraband Hits
Frequency
2 3
1 Percent
33.33 %
50.00 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 searches 28.57
50.00 4.55
Race Known
Frequency
2 7
5 Percent
14.29 %
50.00 %
35.71 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.09
0.10 0.05
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
257
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
Region 6 2016 Asian
Alaska N
ative/American
Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 101
6 129
0 195
Percent 0.52 %
0.03 %
0.66 %
0.00 %
1.00 %
Citations
Frequency
12 1
16 0
0 Percent
0.28 %
0.02 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 11.88
16.67 12.40
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
57 4
79 0
18 Percent
0.52 %
0.04 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.16 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.44
66.67 61.24
--- 9.23
Clean
Frequency 32
1 34
0 177
Percent 0.77 %
0.02 %
0.82 %
0.00 %
4.27 %
Rate per 100 stops
31.68 16.67
26.36 ---
90.77 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
1 0
0 Percent
2.70 %
0.00 %
2.70 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.99
0.00 0.78
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
1 0
0 Percent
4.00 %
0.00 %
4.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.99
0.00 0.78
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX K – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO ANALYSIS
258
Appendix L Region 6: San Antonio District Level Analysis
259
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Throckmorton Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
260
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 13,793
47,944 15,462
Percent 17.30 %
60.13 %
19.39 %
Citations
Frequency
5,469 13,550
6,554 Percent
20.65 %
51.16 %
24.75 %
Rate per 100 stops 39.65
28.26 42.39
Warnings
Frequency
8,324 34,394
8,908 Percent
15.63 %
64.59 %
16.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.35
71.74 57.61
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,294
1,621 1,122
Percent 31.58 %
39.56 %
27.38 %
Rate per 100 stops
9.38 3.38
7.26 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 248
497 406
Percent 21.23 %
42.55 %
34.76 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.80 1.04
2.63 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1,046 1,124
716 Percent
35.70 %
38.36 %
24.44 %
Rate per 100 stops 7.58
2.34 4.63
Contraband Hits
Frequency
619 687
410 Percent
35.53 %
39.44 %
23.54 %
Rate per 100 searches 47.84
42.38 36.54
Race Known
Frequency
88 1,002
165 Percent
6.91 %
78.71 %
12.96 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.64
2.09 1.07
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
261
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,831
73 629
0 0
Percent 2.30 %
0.09 %
0.79 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
645 25
241 0
0 Percent
2.44 %
0.09 %
0.91 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 35.23
34.25 38.31
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,186 48
388 0
0 Percent
2.23 %
0.09 %
0.73 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 64.77
65.75 61.69
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 41
5 15
0 0
Percent 1.00 %
0.12 %
0.37 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.24 6.85
2.38 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 12
2 3
0 0
Percent 1.03 %
0.17 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.66 2.74
0.48 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
29 3
12 0
0 Percent
0.99 %
0.10 %
0.41 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.58
4.11 1.91
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
16 2
8 0
0 Percent
0.92 %
0.11 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 39.02
40.00 53.33
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
11 2
5 0
0 Percent
0.86 %
0.16 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.60
2.74 0.79
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
262
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 11,542
40,175 12,615
Percent 17.37 %
60.44 %
18.98 %
Citations
Frequency
4,710 12,130
5,627 Percent
20.18 %
51.97 %
24.11 %
Rate per 100 stops 40.81
30.19 44.61
Warnings
Frequency
6,832 28,045
6,988 Percent
15.84 %
65.03 %
16.20 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.19
69.81 55.39
Searches (All)
Frequency 536
659 426
Percent 32.68 %
40.18 %
25.98 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.64 1.64
3.38 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 128
234 181
Percent 23.15 %
42.31 %
32.73 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.11 0.58
1.43 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
408 425
245 Percent
37.53 %
39.10 %
22.54 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.53
1.06 1.94
Contraband Hits
Frequency
273 341
188 Percent
33.66 %
42.05 %
23.18 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.93
51.75 44.13
Race Known
Frequency
104 1,279
185 Percent
6.52 %
80.19 %
11.60 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.90
3.18 1.47
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
263
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,378
53 704
0 0
Percent 2.07 %
0.08 %
1.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
566 25
281 0
0 Percent
2.43 %
0.11 %
1.20 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.07
47.17 39.91
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
812 28
423 0
0 Percent
1.88 %
0.06 %
0.98 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.93
52.83 60.09
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 16
1 2
0 0
Percent 0.98 %
0.06 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.16 1.89
0.28 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 7
1 2
0 0
Percent 1.27 %
0.18 %
0.36 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.51 1.89
0.28 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
9 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.83 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.65
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
8 1
0 0
0 Percent
0.99 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 50.00
100.00 0.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
15 0
12 0
0 Percent
0.94 %
0.00 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.09
0.00 1.70
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
264
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6A 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 562
2,346 1,266
Percent 13.35 %
55.72 %
30.07 %
Citations
Frequency
108 414
314 Percent
12.80 %
49.05 %
37.20 %
Rate per 100 stops 19.22
17.65 24.80
Warnings
Frequency
274 1,130
671 Percent
13.08 %
53.94 %
32.03 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.75
48.17 53.00
Clean
Frequency 180
802 281
Percent 14.16 %
63.10 %
22.11 %
Rate per 100 stops
32.03 34.19
22.20 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 2
7 Percent
25.00 %
16.67 %
58.33 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.53
0.09 0.55
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 1
5 Percent
25.00 %
12.50 %
62.50 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.36
0.04 0.39
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
1 2
Percent 25.00 %
25.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.18 0.04
0.16 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 1
Percent 50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
33.33 0.00
14.29 Race Know
n
Frequency 1
4 1
Percent 16.67 %
66.67 %
16.67 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.18 0.17
0.08
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
265
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6A 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 22
1 13
0 0
Percent 0.52 %
0.02 %
0.31 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
6 0
2 0
0 Percent
0.71 %
0.00 %
0.24 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 27.27
0.00 15.38
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
11 0
9 0
0 Percent
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 50.00
0.00 69.23
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 5
1 2
0 0
Percent 0.39 %
0.08 %
0.16 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
22.73 100.00
15.38 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
266
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6A 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 704
2,416 1,393
Percent 15.35 %
52.68 %
30.38 %
Citations
Frequency
96 309
252 Percent
14.39 %
46.33 %
37.78 %
Rate per 100 stops 13.64
12.79 18.09
Warnings
Frequency
416 1,305
877 Percent
15.73 %
49.36 %
33.17 %
Rate per 100 stops 59.09
54.01 62.96
Clean
Frequency 192
802 264
Percent 15.06 %
62.90 %
20.71 %
Rate per 100 stops
27.27 33.20
18.95 Searches (All)
Frequency
3 2
6 Percent
23.08 %
15.38 %
46.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.43
0.08 0.43
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 1
6 Percent
10.00 %
10.00 %
60.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.14
0.04 0.43
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
1 0
Percent 66.67 %
33.33 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.28 0.04
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 0
Percent 50.00 %
50.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
33.33 50.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
267
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6A 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 27
2 44
0 0
Percent 0.59 %
0.04 %
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
5 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.75 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 18.52
0.00 11.36
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
10 2
34 0
0 Percent
0.38 %
0.08 %
1.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 37.04
100.00 77.27
--- ---
Clean
Frequency 12
0 5
0 0
Percent 0.94 %
0.00 %
0.39 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
44.44 0.00
11.36 ---
--- Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
1 0
0 Percent
7.69 %
0.00 %
7.69 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.70
0.00 2.27
--- ---
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
1 0
0 Percent
10.00 %
0.00 %
10.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.70
0.00 2.27
--- ---
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
--- Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 ---
0.00 ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
268
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
269
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 12,695
58,152 27,595
Percent 12.35 %
56.57 %
26.85 %
Citations
Frequency
6,202 21,380
15,309 Percent
13.87 %
47.80 %
34.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.85
36.77 55.48
Warnings
Frequency
6,493 36,772
12,286 Percent
11.18 %
63.33 %
21.16 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.15
63.23 44.52
Searches (All)
Frequency 897
1,671 1,635
Percent 21.12 %
39.35 %
38.50 %
Rate per 100 stops
7.07 2.87
5.92 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 126
444 370
Percent 13.28 %
46.79 %
38.99 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.99 0.76
1.34 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
771 1,227
1,265 Percent
23.38 %
37.20 %
38.36 %
Rate per 100 stops 6.07
2.11 4.58
Contraband Hits
Frequency
408 689
647 Percent
23.12 %
39.04 %
36.66 %
Rate per 100 searches 45.48
41.23 39.57
Race Known
Frequency
80 432
134 Percent
11.64 %
62.88 %
19.51 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.63
0.74 0.49
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
270
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 3,207
129 1,013
0 0
Percent 3.12 %
0.13 %
0.99 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
1,366 61
410 0
0 Percent
3.05 %
0.14 %
0.92 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.59
47.29 40.47
--- ---
Warnings
Frequency
1,841 68
603 0
0 Percent
3.17 %
0.12 %
1.04 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.41
52.71 59.53
--- ---
Searches (All)
Frequency 28
5 11
0 0
Percent 0.66 %
0.12 %
0.26 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.87 3.88
1.09 ---
--- D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 4
3 2
0 0
Percent 0.42 %
0.32 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.12 2.33
0.20 ---
--- N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
24 2
9 0
0 Percent
0.73 %
0.06 %
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.75
1.55 0.89
--- ---
Contraband Hits
Frequency
13 2
6 0
0 Percent
0.74 %
0.11 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 46.43
40.00 54.55
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
24 1
16 0
0 Percent
3.49 %
0.15 %
2.33 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.75
0.78 1.58
--- ---
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
271
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 8,947
44,634 20,554
Percent 11.51 %
57.44 %
26.45 %
Citations
Frequency
4,346 17,088
11,566 Percent
12.58 %
49.46 %
33.48 %
Rate per 100 stops 48.57
38.28 56.27
Warnings
Frequency
4,601 27,546
8,988 Percent
10.66 %
63.83 %
20.83 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.43
61.72 43.73
Searches (All)
Frequency 373
649 618
Percent 22.34 %
38.86 %
37.01 %
Rate per 100 stops
4.17 1.45
3.01 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 63
167 197
Percent 14.69 %
38.93 %
45.92 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.70 0.37
0.96 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
310 482
421 Percent
24.98 %
38.84 %
33.92 %
Rate per 100 stops 3.46
1.08 2.05
Contraband Hits
Frequency
234 363
325 Percent
24.87 %
38.58 %
34.54 %
Rate per 100 searches 62.73
55.93 52.59
Race Known
Frequency
72 299
118 Percent
13.93 %
57.83 %
22.82 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.80
0.67 0.57
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
272
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 2,311
103 1,150
0 4
Percent 2.97 %
0.13 %
1.48 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Citations
Frequency
1,016 41
492 0
0 Percent
2.94 %
0.12 %
1.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 43.96
39.81 42.78
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
1,295 62
658 0
4 Percent
3.00 %
0.14 %
1.52 %
0.00 %
0.01 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.04
60.19 57.22
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 17
1 12
0 0
Percent 1.02 %
0.06 %
0.72 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.74 0.97
1.04 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 1
0 0
Percent 0.23 %
0.00 %
0.23 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.04 0.00
0.09 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
16 1
11 0
0 Percent
1.29 %
0.08 %
0.89 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.69
0.97 0.96
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
10 0
9 0
0 Percent
1.06 %
0.00 %
0.96 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 58.82
0.00 75.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
16 1
11 0
0 Percent
3.09 %
0.19 %
2.13 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.69
0.97 0.96
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
273
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6B 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 896
2,262 3,564
Percent 12.98 %
32.78 %
51.64 %
Citations
Frequency
223 466
1,010 Percent
13.01 %
27.19 %
58.93 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.89
20.60 28.34
Warnings
Frequency
522 1,161
1,986 Percent
14.00 %
31.13 %
53.26 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.26
51.33 55.72
Clean
Frequency 151
635 568
Percent 10.36 %
43.55 %
38.96 %
Rate per 100 stops
16.85 28.07
15.94 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 3
4 Percent
22.22 %
33.33 %
44.44 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.22
0.13 0.11
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 3
3 Percent
14.29 %
42.86 %
42.86 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.11
0.13 0.08
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 1
0 1
Percent 50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.11 0.00
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 2
Percent 33.33 %
0.00 %
66.67 %
Rate per 100 searches
50.00 0.00
50.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 7
42 16
Percent 10.77 %
64.62 %
24.62 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.78 1.86
0.45
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
274
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6B 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 40
1 33
0 105
Percent 0.58 %
0.01 %
0.48 %
0.00 %
1.52 %
Citations
Frequency
6 0
9 0
0 Percent
0.35 %
0.00 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 15.00
0.00 27.27
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
24 1
19 0
16 Percent
0.64 %
0.03 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
0.43 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.00
100.00 57.58
--- 15.24
Clean
Frequency 10
0 5
0 89
Percent 0.69 %
0.00 %
0.34 %
0.00 %
6.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
25.00 0.00
15.15 ---
84.76 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
275
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6B 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 700
1,930 2,677
Percent 12.79 %
35.28 %
48.93 %
Citations
Frequency
157 380
704 Percent
12.54 %
30.35 %
56.23 %
Rate per 100 stops 22.43
19.69 26.30
Warnings
Frequency
406 1,056
1,526 Percent
13.37 %
34.77 %
50.25 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.00
54.72 57.00
Clean
Frequency 137
494 447
Percent 11.59 %
41.79 %
37.82 %
Rate per 100 stops
19.57 25.60
16.70 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 1
7 Percent
20.00 %
10.00 %
70.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.29
0.05 0.26
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
6 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.22
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
1 1
Percent 50.00 %
25.00 %
25.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.29 0.05
0.04 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
1 0
Percent 0.00 %
100.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
0.00 100.00
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 2
5 4
Percent 18.18 %
45.45 %
36.36 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.29 0.26
0.15
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
276
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6B 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 30
2 28
0 104
Percent 0.55 %
0.04 %
0.51 %
0.00 %
1.90 %
Citations
Frequency
5 1
5 0
0 Percent
0.40 %
0.08 %
0.40 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 16.67
50.00 17.86
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
18 1
14 0
16 Percent
0.59 %
0.03 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.53 %
Rate per 100 stops 60.00
50.00 50.00
--- 15.38
Clean
Frequency 7
0 9
0 88
Percent 0.59 %
0.00 %
0.76 %
0.00 %
7.45 %
Rate per 100 stops
23.33 0.00
32.14 ---
84.62 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
277
Falls
Bexar
GonzalesC
omal
FayetteK
err
Guadalupe
Blanco
Coryell M
cLennan
Atascosa
Bastrop
DeW
itt
Frio
JacksonK
arnes
Limestone
Medina
Freestone
Bell
Calhoun
Ham
ilton
Kendall
Lavaca
McMullen
San Saba
Travis
Victoria
William
son
Bandera
Bosque
Burnet
Caldw
ell
Gillespie
Goliad
Hays
Hill
Lampasas
Lee
LlanoM
ilam
Mills
Wilson
Potter
Sw
isher
Terry
Randall
Hall
Cochran
Haskell
Armstrong
King
RobertsStonewallYoung
Lipscomb
Fisher
Archer
Bailey
Cottle
Crosby
Deaf S
mith
Donley
Kent
Sherman
Stephens
Baylor
Hockley
Jack
Ochiltree
Oldham
Com
anche
Callahan
Foard
Hartley
Lamb
Mitchell
Moore
Yoakum
Briscoe
Hale
Scurry
Gray
Brow
n
Carson
Castro
Childress
Clay
Collingsw
orth
Coleman
Dallam
Dickens
Eastland
Floyd
Garza
Hansford
Hardeman
Hemphill
Hutchinson
Jones
Knox
Lubbock
Lynn
Montague
Motley
TaylorN
olan
Parm
er
Runnels
Shackelford
Wheeler
Wichita
Wilbarger
El
Paso
Schleicher
Presidio
Kim
ble
Martin
Terrell
Crane
Winkler
Daw
son
Andrew
s
Upton
Hudspeth
Mason
Borden
Coke
Gaines
Irion
Brew
ster
Menard
TomG
reen
How
ard
ReaganC
oncho
Crockett
Culberson
Ector
Glasscock
Jeff Davis
Sterling
Loving
McC
ulloch
Midland
Pecos
Reeves
Sutton
Ward
3D3A
US
281
Zavala
Starr
WebbZapata
Hidalgo
Duval
Bee
Jim Wells
MaverickA
ransas
Dim
mit
Edw
ards
JimH
oggK
enedy
Kinney
Kleberg
LiveO
ak
Nueces
Real
Refugio
San Patricio
Willacy
Brooks
Cam
eron
LaSalle
Uvalde
Val Verde
Newton
Trinity
Houston
Nacogdoches
Cham
bers
Waller
Orange
Montgom
ery
Polk
SanAugustine
Tyler
Angelina
Brazoria
Brazos
Liberty
WalkerH
arris
Leon
Austin
Burleson
Fort Bend
Galveston
Grimes
Jasper
Jefferson
Madison
Matagorda
Robertson
Sabine
Shelby
Washington
Colorado
Hardin
San
Jacinto
Wharton
Bow
ie
Cherokee
Harrison
Franklin
Cam
pH
opkins
Upshur
Collin
Morris
Anderson
Parker
Rains
Cooke
Dallas
Gregg
Johnson
Lamar
Marion
RedR
iver
Rockw
allD
entonC
ass
Delta
Erath
Ellis
FanninG
rayson
Henderson
Hood
Hunt
Kaufman
Navarro
Palo
Pinto
Panola
Rusk
Sm
ith
Som
ervell
Tarrant
Titus
VanZandt
Wise
Wood
Dallas
Region 11A
- Dallas
1B - Tyler
1C - H
urst1D
- Mt. Pleasant
Houston
Region 22A
- Houston
2B - B
eaumont
2C - C
onroe2D
- Bryan
San Antonio
Region 66A
- Waco
6B - Austin
6C - S
an Antonio
McA
llenR
egion 33A
- McA
llen3B
- Laredo3C
- Corpus C
hristi3D
- McA
llen3E
- Del R
io
El PasoR
egion 44A
- Midland
4B - El Paso
LubbockR
egion 5Lubbock - 5AA
marillo - 5B
Abilene - 5C
5 B
C
A
B
E
CDA
B
C
A
BC
A
D
BA
B
C
D
A
64
123
Throckmorton
278
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 9,127
59,419 67,193
Percent 6.61 %
43.06 %
48.69 %
Citations
Frequency
3,853 19,268
29,339 Percent
7.22 %
36.10 %
54.97 %
Rate per 100 stops 42.22
32.43 43.66
Warnings
Frequency
5,274 40,151
37,854 Percent
6.23 %
47.44 %
44.73 %
Rate per 100 stops 57.78
67.57 56.34
Searches (All)
Frequency 1,039
2,252 5,273
Percent 12.03 %
26.08 %
61.07 %
Rate per 100 stops
11.38 3.79
7.85 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 250
603 1,596
Percent 10.12 %
24.41 %
64.62 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.74 1.01
2.38 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
789 1,649
3,677 Percent
12.80 %
26.75 %
59.64 %
Rate per 100 stops 8.64
2.78 5.47
Contraband Hits
Frequency
366 818
1,802 Percent
12.15 %
27.15 %
59.81 %
Rate per 100 searches 35.23
36.32 34.17
Race Known
Frequency
7 12
13 Percent
21.21 %
36.36 %
39.39 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.08
0.02 0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
279
Highway Patrol - 2017
DISTRICT 6C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,552
65 639
0 4
Percent 1.12 %
0.05 %
0.46 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
599 29
281 0
1 Percent
1.12 %
0.05 %
0.53 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 38.60
44.62 43.97
--- 25.00
Warnings
Frequency
953 36
358 0
3 Percent
1.13 %
0.04 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 61.40
55.38 56.03
--- 75.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 48
7 16
0 0
Percent 0.56 %
0.08 %
0.19 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
3.09 10.77
2.50 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 17
1 3
0 0
Percent 0.69 %
0.04 %
0.12 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
1.10 1.54
0.47 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
31 6
13 0
0 Percent
0.50 %
0.10 %
0.21 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 2.00
9.23 2.03
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
17 5
5 0
0 Percent
0.56 %
0.17 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 35.42
71.43 31.25
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
1 0
0 0
0 Percent
3.03 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.06
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
280
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 6,789
54,917 52,890
Percent 5.81 %
47.01 %
45.27 %
Citations
Frequency
2,845 17,895
23,348 Percent
6.31 %
39.72 %
51.82 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.91
32.59 44.14
Warnings
Frequency
3,944 37,022
29,542 Percent
5.50 %
51.58 %
41.16 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.09
67.41 55.86
Searches (All)
Frequency 173
749 1,243
Percent 7.97 %
34.48 %
57.23 %
Rate per 100 stops
2.55 1.36
2.35 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 39
194 357
Percent 6.57 %
32.66 %
60.10 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.57 0.35
0.67 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
134 555
886 Percent
8.49 %
35.17 %
56.15 %
Rate per 100 stops 1.97
1.01 1.68
Contraband Hits
Frequency
100 447
575 Percent
8.88 %
39.70 %
51.07 %
Rate per 100 searches 57.80
59.68 46.26
Race Known
Frequency
1 98
29 Percent
0.76 %
74.81 %
22.14 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.01
0.18 0.05
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
281
Highway Patrol - 2016
DISTRICT 6C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 1,335
71 822
0 1
Percent 1.14 %
0.06 %
0.70 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Citations
Frequency
551 30
387 0
0 Percent
1.22 %
0.07 %
0.86 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 41.27
42.25 47.08
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
784 41
435 0
1 Percent
1.09 %
0.06 %
0.61 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.73
57.75 52.92
--- 100.00
Searches (All)
Frequency 4
1 2
0 0
Percent 0.18 %
0.05 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.30 1.41
0.24 ---
0.00 D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
1 1
0 0
Percent 0.34 %
0.17 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.15 1.41
0.12 ---
0.00 N
on-Discretionary Searches
Frequency
2 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.13 %
0.00 %
0.06 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.15
0.00 0.12
--- 0.00
Contraband Hits
Frequency
3 0
1 0
0 Percent
0.27 %
0.00 %
0.09 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches 75.00
0.00 50.00
--- ---
Race Known
Frequency
3 0
0 0
0 Percent
2.29 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.22
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
282
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6C 2017
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 906
3,182 6,826
Percent 8.11 %
28.48 %
61.10 %
Citations
Frequency
179 699
1,979 Percent
6.25 %
24.41 %
69.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 19.76
21.97 28.99
Warnings
Frequency
470 1,599
3,614 Percent
8.19 %
27.85 %
62.95 %
Rate per 100 stops 51.88
50.25 52.94
Clean
Frequency 257
884 1,233
Percent 10.02 %
34.45 %
48.05 %
Rate per 100 stops
28.37 27.78
18.06 Searches (All)
Frequency
1 0
1 Percent
50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.11
0.00 0.01
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
1 0
1 Percent
50.00 %
0.00 %
50.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.11
0.00 0.01
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
0 0
Percent 100.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
100.00 ---
0.00 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 1
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
100.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.01
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
283
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2017
District 6C 2017
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 34
2 47
0 174
Percent 0.30 %
0.02 %
0.42 %
0.00 %
1.56 %
Citations
Frequency
2 0
5 0
0 Percent
0.07 %
0.00 %
0.17 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 5.88
0.00 10.64
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
20 1
31 0
6 Percent
0.35 %
0.02 %
0.54 %
0.00 %
0.10 %
Rate per 100 stops 58.82
50.00 65.96
--- 3.45
Clean
Frequency 12
1 11
0 168
Percent 0.47 %
0.04 %
0.43 %
0.00 %
6.55 %
Rate per 100 stops
35.29 50.00
23.40 ---
96.55 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent --- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
--- %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
284
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6C 2016
African American
White
Hispanic
Stops
Frequency 718
2,817 5,740
Percent 7.58 %
29.75 %
60.62 %
Citations
Frequency
176 685
1,565 Percent
7.23 %
28.14 %
64.30 %
Rate per 100 stops 24.51
24.32 27.26
Warnings
Frequency
403 1,567
3,316 Percent
7.53 %
29.30 %
61.99 %
Rate per 100 stops 56.13
55.63 57.77
Clean
Frequency 139
565 859
Percent 8.24 %
33.51 %
50.95 %
Rate per 100 stops
19.36 20.06
14.97 Searches (All)
Frequency
2 3
9 Percent
14.29 %
21.43 %
64.29 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.28
0.11 0.16
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 2
7 Percent
0.00 %
22.22 %
77.78 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.07 0.12
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 2
1 2
Percent 40.00 %
20.00 %
40.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.28 0.04
0.03 Contraband H
its
Frequency 1
1 1
Percent 33.33 %
33.33 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 searches
50.00 33.33
11.11 Race Know
n
Frequency 0
2 1
Percent 0.00 %
66.67 %
33.33 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.07
0.02
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS
285
Comm
ercial Vehicle Enforcement - 2016
District 6C 2016
Asian Alaska
Native/Am
erican Indian
Middle Eastern
Other
Unknow
n
Stops
Frequency 44
2 57
0 91
Percent 0.46 %
0.02 %
0.60 %
0.00 %
0.96 %
Citations
Frequency
2 0
6 0
0 Percent
0.08 %
0.00 %
0.25 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 4.55
0.00 10.53
--- 0.00
Warnings
Frequency
29 1
31 0
2 Percent
0.54 %
0.02 %
0.58 %
0.00 %
0.04 %
Rate per 100 stops 65.91
50.00 54.39
--- 2.20
Clean
Frequency 13
1 20
0 89
Percent 0.77 %
0.06 %
1.19 %
0.00 %
5.28 %
Rate per 100 stops
29.55 50.00
35.09 ---
97.80 Searches (All)
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Discretionary Searches
Frequency
0 0
0 0
0 Percent
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops 0.00
0.00 0.00
--- 0.00
Non-D
iscretionary Searches
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00 Contraband H
its
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 searches
--- ---
--- ---
--- Race Know
n
Frequency 0
0 0
0 0
Percent 0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
0.00 %
Rate per 100 stops
0.00 0.00
0.00 ---
0.00
DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY APPENDIX L – REGION 6:SAN ANTONIO – DISTRICT LEVEL ANALYSIS