2019 summer school...
TRANSCRIPT
!"#$%&'("#)"&'*+#$%#&,-.&/0#$-1
!"#$%&%'()%$$%*)%+,--.+#/*-$0/'.1%2"%'.)32#*2'4%50+%$0+3
.+#/*-$0/'6/#&-+2#$3
!"#$%&'($)*&$'&")+("),-&("&'#%./)0%#&$%&)12324')56789:)8;56
203#4&,-.&4*3.)-10%(3".&,0#$-1&)-4$5"43#&4*3".%*&,-.&-64$)0)&)"7134$%&,$3(8#
78'90:1;'1#<-'/:*1-%+'=:2#0/'$0'5-*0"-'%'>+%*$#*%1'>09-+'20:+*-?'8$'90:1;'>+0&#;-'%/'#/-@)%:2$#51-'2:>>13'0='-/-+A3B'9#$)0:$'>011:$#0/'0+'A105%1'9%+"#/A?C0'&<-&$)=.>?#$3)@5;)A2&4'#($4)+(")0'&<-&$)=.>?#$3:),#B&)C8;5;DE
9
DEFGHGIDJ
:*3.)-10%(3".&,0#$-1
;
<"=#-1>#&?.$43.$-1
@
A*"4&$#&"&6("#)"B
C
.1%2"%'#2'%/'-/2-"51-'0='*)%+A-;'>%+$#*1-2B'*%>%51-'0='-@)#5#$#/A'*011-*$#&-'#/$-+%*$#0/2?
4-&-12'0='K-2*+#>$#0/L! M#/A1-H>%+$#*1-';3/%"#*2'#/'>+-2*+#5-;'-1-*$+#*'%/;'"%A/-$#*'
=#-1;2'NO?'.-;-+2-/'1-*$:+-P! .1%2"%2'%2'=1:#;2'#/'QK'*0/=#A:+%$#0/'2>%*-'"0&#/A':/;-+'$)-'
#/=1:-/*-'0='2-1=H*0/2#2$-/$'-1-*$+#*'%/;'"%A/-$#*'=#-1;2'N!?'R-+=0/'1-*$:+-P'
! .1%2"%2'%2'<#/-$#*'=1:#;2'#/'SK'>)%2-'2>%*-'N$)%$'#2B'*0/=#A:+%$#0/'%/;'&-10*#$3'2>%*-PB'*0:>1-;'$0'2-1=H*0/2#2$-/$'T%@9-11U2'-V:%$#0/2?'
A*"4&8-3#&8$5&!&D&E&)3"1B
! T%A/-$#*'=#-1;2'05-3';#&'!&W'I?'O+%;#$#0/%1'-1-*$+0"%A/-$#*'$)-0+3'$-@$2'A-/-+%113'-">)%2#X-'$)%$'$)#2'"-%/2'$)%$'$)-+-'%+-'/0'#201%$-;'"%A/-$#*'"0/0>01-2B'20'=#-1;'1#/-2'-#$)-+'*102-'0/'$)-"2-1&-2B'0+'A0'=+0"'#/=#/#$3'$0'#/=#/#$3?
! (:$'$)-+-'#2'%'$)#+;'>022#5#1#$3L'=#-1;'1#/-2'*%/'=#11'%'*0">%*$'2:+=%*-'0+'&01:"-'-+A0;#*%113?
! 8/'$)-'>+-2-/*-'0='%';#+-*$#0/'0='*0/$#/:0:2'23""-$+3B'=#-1;'1#/-2'=#11'2:+=%*-2'-+A0;#*%113?'O)-2-'2:+=%*-2'%+-'*%11-;'B.3$&'#%)42"+.%&4?
F&B."?L'T%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/-'232$-"2'%+-'Y%"#1$0/#%/B'%/;';#&'!&W'I'#2'$)-#+'4#0:-U2'$)-0+-"?'Z)-/'%'Y%"#1$0/#%/')%2'%/'#A/0+%51-'N0+'*3*1#*'*00+;#/%$-PB'#$')%2'%'*0/2$%/$'0='$)-'"0$#0/?'[0+'!&=#-1;2B'$)-2-'%+-'$)-'"%A/-$#*'2:+=%*-2?''NT0+-'#/'!?'(00X-+'1-*$:+-PF
G"7134$%&H0.,"%3#&"18&?*"-#
[+0"'>+#"-+'53'8"5-+$H\-+%+;B'.%:1'%/;'Z+#A)$I
?-1,$1$17&%*".738&6".4$%(3#&=$4*&"&)"7134$%&,$3(8&$#&1-4&"#&3"#+&"#&$4&)"+!)
6/#=0+"'2$+%#A)$'!L'*0/=#/-"-/$'! $0'!B'5:$'-/;'1022-2'*%/'5-'&-+3'1%+A-
J
T%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/- R)%+A-;'>%+$#*1-
KL$#+))34.+&$#&-13&="+&4-&"%*$353&)"7134$%&%-1,$13)314
M
R0/$#/:0:2'+0$%$#0/%1'23""-$+3'''" R%/0/#*%1'%/A:1%+'"0"-/$:"'#2'*0/2-+&-;?
L! = m!"R+ qA!R = constant!"#$%&'(%$")$*+,-'' = !"! "
8='1GF 2:+=%*-2'%+-'50:/;-;B'$)-/'>%+$#*1-2'9#11'5-'*0/=#/-;?'O)#2'+-V:#+-2'2:>-+>02#$#0/'0='>010#;%1'%/;'$0+0#;%1'=#-1;2'9)#*)'>+0;:*-'%'+0$%$#0/%1'$+%/2=0+"?
Strong B limit ! m!" ! qA! ! Particles stuck to constant-A!R surfaces.
?-)6($%"4$-1N&KL$#+))34.$%&%-1,$13)314&.3O0$.3#&"1&$143.1"(&%0..314
PE
!" !"A( ) =!"B = µ0J so nested A!R surfaces require a J! ,
making the axisymmetric tokamak prone to instabilities/disruptions.
!!
1GF 2:+=%*-
K888HK'B'\-/-+%1'!$0"#*2B'M%/'K#-A0
/0#$-1&$1&"&:-Q")"QN&H-)3&RL")6(3#
]MO^H6B'...4'
O%+A-$'0='8O_`L'a'WDI8/>:$'bITZB'c:$>:$'bIITZ
R)%11-/A-2'=%*-;'53'8O_`LD? .1%2"%'*:++-/$'20:+*-'0=';#2+:>$#&-'#/2$%5#1#$#-2'$)%$'*%/>+0;:*-')#A)13'-/-+A-$#*'+:/%9%3'-1-*$+0/2B'9)#*)'*%/';%"%A-'*0/=#/-"-/$&-22-1?
G?'M$-%;3H2$%$-0>-+%$#0/'9#11'+-V:#+-'2$+0/A''*:++-/$';+#&-?'''
/$70.3SJ&H43(("."4-.
.010#;%1'"%A/-$#*'=#-1;'/--;'/0$'+-V:#+-'%/'%@#%1'*:++-/$B'5:$'*%/'5-'>:+-13'%/'0:$*0"-'0='A-0"-$+3B';:-'$0'$)-'$0+2#0/'0='"%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/-2'%2'#/'%'[#A:+-HJ'2$-11%+%$0+'N9)#*)'%/$#*#>%$-;'$)-'(-++3'>)%2-'#/'V:%/$:"'"-*)%/#*2P?
43"%/'M>#$X-+'NDEDFHDEEdP
T3-)34.+&$#&)"7$%
[+0"'>+#"-+'53'8"5-+$H\-+%+;B'.%:1'%/;'Z+#A)$P;
U83"(&GVW&3O0"4$-1#&"18&)"7134-#4"4$% 3O0$($X.$"
P@
T%A/-$02$%$#*'-V:%$#0/2'#">13'!Y&3".H)<)W'IB'ZY&3".H)<)W'I
8='3".H)<)#2'/0$'X-+0B'"%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/-2'":2$'1#-'0/'/-2$-;'$0+0#;%1'2:+=%*-2'0='*0/2$%/$'< N0+e1-#/U2'50$$1-2P''
KY&?3.,-1&(3%40.3
20"#$S#+))34.+N&[
RL")6(3&-,&53.+&1-1"L$#+))34.$%&)"7134$%&%-1,$13)314N&&A3183(#43$1&IS\&]T3.)"1+^
PF
c*$'GDB'GIDb QI'"#/:$-'>1%2"%2'-&-/$:%113
_1-*$+0"%A/-$#*'*0#12
T%A/-$#*'2:+=%*-2B'>1%2"%
T%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/-2
PI
T%A/-$#*'=#-1;'"%A/#$:;-'f(f'#/'O-21%
! N10/A'9%3'%+0:/;P"N2)0
+$'9%3'%+0:/
;P
YM^LY-1#*%113'M3""-$+#*'-^>-+#"-/$N6/#&-+2#$3'0='Z#2*0/2#/P
:Y&'383.#31&"18&RY&H431#-1&(3%40.3
! "#$%&%'($%)*+,%$-+./0#/1$+$)+#(.$%12/+).3%$04+/56%2%3.%6&+(*7+0$(3%2%$8+#.)761/0+(+7/0%./7+9:+&(;*/$%1+<%/27+=,%$-+-%77/*+08&&/$.%/0>+$-($+7/<%*/0+$-/+0$/22(.($).+&(;*/$%1+06.<(1/0?
! @)%2+7/0%;*A+B%*7%*;+1)%2+0-(#/0+$-($+#.)761/+(+;%C/* !"%*+$-/+1)*<%*/&/*$+C)26&/+%0+(*+%22D#)0/7+#.)32/&?
! E-/./+%0+*)+6*%56/+0)26$%)*+F $-/+0(&/+#2(0&(+0-(#/+1(*+3/+1./($/7+<.)&+7%<</./*$+1)%2+0/$0?+E-%0+1(*+3/+/G#2)%$/7+<.6%$<6228?
! H),/C/.4+%$+%0+(20)+(+#.)32/&+$-($+-(0+%$0+1-(22/*;/0A+E-/+<6.$-/.+(,(8+)*/+#2(1/0+$-/+16../*$+=$-/+1)%20>+$-/+2(.;/.+$-/+16../*$+(*7+$-/+16.C%/.+$-/+1)%20?
! "#$%&6&+0$/22(.($).+7/0%;*+3/1)&/0+(+$.(7/D)<<+3/$,//*+$-/+7%<</./*$+1)*0$.(%*$0A
! I-80%10+)#$%&%'($%)*4+1)%2+16.C($6./4+1)%2+$)2/.(*1/04+7%0$(*1/+3/$,//*+1)%20+(*7+#2(0&(4+0$./00/0+%*+$-/+1)%20?
/.-)&)"7134$%�.,"%3#&4-&%-$(#
PJHY&V08#-1&(3%40.3
?"(%0("4$17&%0..314#&4*"4&6.-80%3&"&7$531&!&$#&"1&$((S6-#38&6.-X(3)&
PM!"#$%&'(!"#$"%&'()*+&'
U1&"&.3"%4-._&"&X("1Q34&$#&133838&X34=331&%-$(#&"18&6("#)"&4-&"X#-.X&1304.-1#&
9E
A*+&$#&$4&#-&*".8&4-&734&%-$(#&,".&,.-)&"#$"%&' ,(0L�.,"%3#B
9P
`183.#4"18$17&<"6("%3&"18&!$-4SH"5".4&*"#&X$7&6"+-,,&,-.&,0#$-1
99
V-=&8-&=3&,$18&.-X0#4+(("."4-.&%-1,$70."4$-1#B
9;
! I.)#/.$%/0+)<+$-/+&(;*/$%1+<%/27+(./+#./0/.C/7+6*7/.+./(2%0$%1+7/C%($%)*0+1)*0$.(%*/7+38+/*;%*//.%*;+1(#(3%2%$%/0?+J*1267/+./(2%0$%1+6*1/.$(%*$%/0+,%$-%*+$-/+)#$%&%'($%)*+1(2162($%)*?+KC)%7+;/$$%*;+0$61L+%*+(+*)*D.)360$+)#$%&6&
! !"#$%&'A+M$/22(.($).+#/.<).&(*1/+%0+*)$+(+C/.8+0&))$-+<6*1$%)*+)<+1)*$.)2+#(.(&/$/.0
T?'Y#+2*)'-$'%1?B'..R['CE NGIIJP'IbQIID
H4-%*"#4$%&-64$)$a"4$-1&$#&"&="+&4-&$1%.3"#3&4-(3."1%3#
9@
TY&H4"8(3.&(3%40.3
H4-%*"#4$%&-64$)$a"4$-1
9C
*(2"'&4IL'i?H[?'4052#-/'%/;'O?'M?.-;-+2-/'
! O)-2-'*0">:$%$#0/2'%+-'/09'=-%2#51-'5-*%:2-'0='%;&%/*-2'#/'2:>-+*0">:$#/A'>09-+B'%/;'%1A0+#$)"#*';-&-10>"-/$?'NHY&V3113X3.7&(3%40.3P
jK-->'4-%+/#/A'"-$)0;2'*%/'5-'-2>-*#%113':2-=:1?
j QK'-/A#/--+#/A';-2#A/'%/;'"%/:=%*$:+#/A'#2'5-*0"#/A'2$%/;%+;'#/'#/;:2$+3?
j Y#A)H>+-*#2#0/'"-$+010A3'-V:#>"-/$'#2'/09'*0""0/>1%*-?
j Z-'*%/'"-%2:+-'$)-'%2H5:#1$'"%A/-$#*'$0>010A3'$0'$)-'+-V:#+-;'%**:+%*3?
j R%/'9-'-@>10#$'/-9'"%$-+#%12'$0'+-%1#X-')#A)'"%A/-$#*'=#-1;2g'c+'5-/;'$)-'*02$'*:+&-'53':2#/A'*)-%>-+'"%$-+#%12g
j 8/'%11'0='$)#2B'0:+':/;-+2$%/;#/A')%2'"%$:+-;'*0/2#;-+%513B'5:$'=0:/;%$#0/%1'"%$)-"%$#*%1'V:-2$#0/2'+-"%#/'$0'5-'%/29-+-;?'''''
K+((".]"4-.^&%-)3X"%QB
H-)3&)-.3&)"4*3)"4$%"(&O03#4$-1#
! T%A/-$#*'=#-1;'1#/-'=109'>+0;:*-'%'2-%'0='A00;'2:+=%*-2'%/;'*)%02?'=(>)H()>&)J2.$'#+I)$($7#$'&3".K#/#'I)(+)+#&/H)/#$&4).$H)%($'"(/)#'L)=(>)>&//)H()<."'#%/&4)'".%?)+#&/H)/#$&4L)=(>)."&)<."'#%/&4)'".$4<("'&H).%"(44)M%.$'("#Ng
! T%A/-$0)3;+0;3/%"#*2'NTYKP';-2*+#5-2'$)-'"%A/-$#X-;'>1%2"%'%2'%'=1:#;?'O)-'QK'TYK'>+051-"'#2'/0$'</09/'$0'5-'A105%113'9-11H>02-;'-&-/'9#$)';#22#>%$#0/'%;;-;'N2#"#1%+'$0'$)-'QK']%&#-+HM$0<-2'>+051-"'#/')3;+0;3/%"#*2HHH%'T#11-/#:"'.+#X-'N0+'R1%3P'>+051-"'P?'O-.')."&)'-&)4<&%#./)4(/2'#($4)&$.K/&H)KI)-#HH&$)4IBB&'"#&4L),-&)<"&B#4&)(+)(<'#B2B)H&4#3$)#4)'-.').)4&')(+)%(#/4)>#'-)4<&%#./)3&(B&'"#%)+&.'2"&4)%.$)%"&.'&).$)&$P#"($B&$')#$)>-#%-).)%(2</&H)4(/2'#($)&Q#4'4)>#'-(2')K/(>72<R
! S("B2/.'&)'-&)H&4#3$)<"(K/&B).4).)%($4'".#$&H:)"#4?7.P&"4&:)B2/'#7(KT&%'#P&)4'(%-.4'#%)(<'#B#U.'#($)<"(K/&BR)M--<'.%+-$0H0>$#"%1'201:$#0/2?',-#4)%.$$(')K&)H($&)#$).)<-I4#%47.3$(4'#%)>.IR _@#2$#/A'2$0*)%2$#*'0>$#"#X%$#0/'"-$)0;2'%+-'/0$'A-/-+%113'&-+3'A00;'=0+'%;;+-22#/A')#A)H;#"-/2#0/%1'>+051-"2?
9I
:*"1Q&+-0&,-.&+-0.&"44314$-1Y203#4$-1#B
9J