307-1256-1-pb

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

1/13

www.cmy. 21

Cosmos and History: The Journal of Natural and Social Philosophy, vol. 8, no. 2, 2012

What ought We to think? Castoriadis

response to the Question for thinking

t ncc g Vc

La Trobe University

AbstrAct: C vw jc my c b c c

c . a cw c jc ,

by vb jc. W c v

v . sccy, C bv q w

w ?, wc v m c jc my,

my c vb c c jc

b w C w mv

by my jc y cq, wc bjcb.

Keywords: C, my, c cq,

acc C,

[] bjc y q: W i, w w,

b b, b w B, b i, b w, b

y, b jc c..1

o m mc m q

y C cmmm jc my. hv

b b b m mvm wc

b b mcc, y , C, c m gc-W jc v c my (C, 1991: 13-

15).2 f C jc my m ccvy, wc c

y x , cz cv cc xcy,

q w cv (C, 1991: 20). C

vby c my c cy wy -

1. C C, Philosophy Politics Autonomy: Essays in political philosophy, nY ox: ox

uvy p, 1991: 25.

2. f c sz am, i c: C b my, Thesis

Eleven, 2005, 83: 25-41.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

2/13

CosMos and historY22

c w m, cv m

m x-c c. Mv, c m cy m c

m m b w v mmb ym

ccv.3 t m c c ccv c b b

y m cy c by , c

.4 C b m my m b

b c c cc z.

g C c cy jc my

b c c c , w m c vv, w

b w v? W w , w y

vv C c bjc m y w xc c (

), xcy, x cy q what

b , v wy c bjc m y

x q . a mcy vy, C

w m c m q by

w m. nv, cy bc q w w

m, w m b m

c v mc c m

q. M ccy, w w : (1) C

cwm c jc my, ,

by vb jc, ; (2) m

v C cz c jc

w m b b c jc .

i v m c w w xm C

cm bc m

m by m q y. t,

xm C c c jc my,

c c w w y c C

m q cw w w c w w m.

h w w cwm cvy cmm

vy (m)by m ccv m cy

bjc m .

a xm C q w w ?,my jc ccv my, m w

w m m q y

3. C C, World in Fragments: Writings on Politics, Society, Psychoanalysis and the Imagination ,

C: s uvy p, 1997: 84 (h C, 1997b); dv am C .

The Castoriadis Reader, ox uk: Bcw pb, 1997: 322 (h C, 1997). f

c c bw C cc ym ccv c

m ccv C a kyv, t c w

mcc yJournal of the Hellenic Diaspora, 24(1), 1998: 9-29.

4. C C, The Imaginary Institution of Society, 1987: 373.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

3/13

toula niColaCopoulos and george VassilaCopoulos 23

c w C cwm

c jc my cmm m vw c m b

m philosophical c b cv w

ccv in the thinker, .

i

W i, w w ? t b , w c

m bjc m. B mc

wy m c by

m m q. o c q w cx

v c-c mm. C cc y,

q w -cv cvy b, xcy m by bjc

m w y, y c-c m

cc y w y (C, 1991:

19-20). fm cv c c vy mc w

y. t c y h q

m b, C cc b, cc

by c bjcvy vwm by by vy m.

t c y v b k q c

by w. n c c v m

q m c

m y m c m c. i q, w w ? v qy m, wc

b m ccv b xc

c m cvy

cc w c c my. i c

w xc c my c vy cc , C

m vy q v cc w

cm y bjc m b -v. i q ,

bjc m y, q y c m

bjc-c C cm b; / c /

cvy v y jc y m

m v bjc m. i C, y cv cvy y b y and c w

(C, 1991: 17-18, m).

W bv m b C

q , c m m q . fy,

w w , q v ,

vby w that which matters, c.5 t , c

5. W c C v c c cc

, t m c m c-c bcm C.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

4/13


w v m : w w m. B,

w y w cz

mbc what matters, vby q. W,

c, w c, , w m? i bc

c c, w b ; bjc m ,

w b c v to think prior to thinking.

Wv ycc cc c ,

what mattersm by, ccv, vy m

b m, m b mw wc m m

m , beyond q v c

bjc , thatwc m . s m c from what matters. B w w v j w

m b by c cy q c

w w m. i w w m,

cwm w. W m ccy m C

w q w c m w q: W w

where w b ?

ev x v q, wv, b

c cc m q y

C m. a y , C m c and historical

:

i c c my w , wv, i my m b, b , b wv, c c m wc w

i wy-v c . i m b mv:

y c y (C, 1991: 19).

s w m m: W w ? W

when w ? B w, w w q

y v m C b,

, w c q c w b bjc

m y c y v c

. f C, w v w, c

m p dc, Mx h cb by

c m y m w.6

i w m C cv mode of thinking, w

cvy , mc m m

q y.

fm my x C m m

q w v v m cmc m, wc w c

w-w-w-w q. t w, w, w, w

6. t. ncc g. Vc, t m c m c-

c bcm C. o cc mcy J k,

Castoriadis: Psyche, Society, Autonomy, l, B: B: 2009.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

5/13


c b m q cv .

ty vby mc C

q , my w b (C, 1987:

222). t mm q q ,

c q c m ()c

C m, b xm C

w : t c w m m

m c m m. (i m w v

xm C w m m

q.)

B c xm C , m bv cc m wc C m q

y. W bv w w m m

m m mw b w b ; m b

cv by m. W m y

c, x vy b, wc

c by w-w-w-w . i , w-w-

w-w q y mv w q:

w ? ( q). a mv w

q m by vy c w q. t ,

C q my q;

mv w. t q vby

bc, w-w-w-w q, v

b / w m. t m -

c cv w q cc w

w m m m. i w, q m

m

y cmmm c w

wy c c cmmm by

cy w. t ,

c m c y q c ccv.

o mc , C cw, cvy

c jby m w m cm.7

s q mc y w m, m cy, y

bjc transformation w m q cy bc w

w m b w m. s w m

w m bjc w m w

mw, ccy c , m w m

bjc m . a m mv q

7. s a kyv, t c w mcc y. s t m

c m c-c bcm C.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

6/13


v w w w cmm , w m /

ccy y c w w m wy. i c

/ v w-w-w-w q,

cmm y cm by w m wy

vy ccy. t cmmm, y, w m m C

m q ccy: sc w (w m), w

w w, w w w ?

s w v cz C b

cmm , w c b m mv

q, wc m by c m w q, vw b

w bjc m y. B cm by w mv w cc bc cz b

y w m. B cm by w m,

significant, w cv c c

y w m c m. i, wv,

w m c w m cm

/ cvy b w m

wc y v w bjc m, c c,

m m . t , w c

, w y v b w , by w

m q bc b by w, wc y c. t

wy, y c cy, C cmmm

c jc my by cmm

jc my v. W, xm C :

i as political, and not philosophical, my, [] cvy

m, w y i w v c my

cvy ym ccv, m c

my w (C, 1997: 371-372, m).

C c b c w ccm c

jc my. B w b m. a m

q y w m vm cmmm

c jc my, m cv w x, q

cm after w wy m

c m w wc m b thinkingly articulated. i w,

y m w w, b jc my b

y b. l w C w q.

a y , C c cmb c w w

bv w q mc w

cmm jc my. C jcy b cy

m by wv cmmm c my c cy

xcy -. a m cc The Imaginary Institution of

Society, c m cy m:

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

7/13


wc w m bc w w bc w w w

w, bc c w y,

y b (C, 1987: 373).

fm C cv radical willing y -c

bjc c c, v / c

c ccv. W , c

, y m by w c bjc cmmm

by m m v ccv c cy

m cy bc cy m m my

my cc c c,

m m wm cy, . (C, 1987:373). f C, m, y my mc, mv

bcm cmm c c

c-c m, m c/c eidos m

(C, 1997b: 399-400).

t cmm w mbc jc my m

c critique m cy, cq x m

by v c ccc

m m b w wc my b c m

. Bc m c, wc v m m y, v

b c m, w b y

mcc c b c c:dmccy jc b c [ m m by

m m b] ccv v. py, c -

c bjcvy, jc b c v

(C, 1991: 20).8

Mv, v m w c c cq w

m c/m b b, y b

c m w w my. a ,

[]y c v m, w -cv v.

t m c w c c w c ccv

mcy mvm y -c, by cc

, [] w y m b: cv b bjcvy.

a w w m c m w cy (C,

1997: 336-337).

f C, , j c cvy c , c

, cq c c my c/c -

cv bjcv. i b cv,

Cq c v bjc; y by

8. f c c cc c C y J k, py

mcy: rv C vy m cc cy, European Journal of

Social Theory, 2011: 1-17.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

8/13


jm, cq c w , w ,

w m b c (C, 1997b: 36).

t c w , m w

b m qc b m

cv m bv, v w m mv

m c; y wy , w C

C, aby, g w (C, 1997b: 314). t

c v m bc c q.9 sc q c y b

y w y m by wv cmmm,

vc, xm, by v y. accy, cmm

w vw my. f C, w m ; m y c

.10 o , , cmm v m

c m bjc m b, , k

W (2012) , bc v b , w v c

m, w , b cy m (k W, 2012: 2).

ay jc y, -cmm -

c m mc y wy.

ii

l c: jc my

c xcy - cy bjc m

cmm ; qm belongs

to c (y ) cy, ccv, /

q; cc c m my /

cy m b m b / cvy -

c bjcvy c w . t c m

q, c : w w m

ccv m cc wc m? t

m q wy: hw C w

w m m q ? W topos

?

W w x w c y c w w c q C c

c c jc my m

. i t m my: mm z cmm11

C c c z jc my

9. s xm, C c cc m tm C, 1997b: 374-404.

10. C n k p W, W b ? W b ? t

ycc k ax C C, European Journal of Social Theory, 2012: 13

1.

11. C, 1997b: 32-46.

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

9/13


cx m , wc m :

cc, b m cm m, w

my c: my, , m x

my, (C, 1997b: 37).

a c jc my w c,

cc :

v c qcy [] m wc [ jc

my] b mb [] t m qcy

c c c c y vz

y . f c jc my, w c

bjcv w m q. (C, 1997b: 43).

h C c jc my w

cm v c m v mb v m. B

c jc j m c c m vb

c m. i cw c jc my,

C cm y y vb c m jc

-cv. i, c w vb w m

m w b cm, w b c cy

c q w b x m. C m

cmm c w c bjcv. h m

b q: w w ? B q w m

w w ? (C, 1991: 25). i q qcv. nv, xcy cz, w

c v C c vy x

c m , v c c w c

m m. s, c q ,

c my philosophically, w

mc cw bc y vb -cv

c jc. umy, c-c cx v

c cmm my m c. B cmm

c jc c c, m thinkingly create ( )

m ccv, c-c v c

cy, m b c z jc my .

t , C c my,

j w cx c jc b vy c mm

w c cm bc y vb c v. i

w m x c c

c q the possibility as such jc my.

C m cw mc w cc Imaginary

Institution of Society m cv jc my

m b mb:

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

10/13


a y c , w m -m

y c mb; cxc cv y c

-c y c-yx w w c

c by (C, 1987: 373.

W bw c/-c

my y c-y cvy. t w m

c bc. r, y b w wy xc

c-c m cvy c

-c. t , c c mm, my c

my m x my cvy

c jc my m my. nv, c jc my b vc v

my j w y w b -m,

C my y c

m by.

B , w v bv, q m b

jc my m b jc c c.

t q: w c cy mw

m m by jc my y

vc? i m y vb cy m c m wc

m my vy

jc . W jc , c,

c cwm jc my v , m

m/ c c jc? i

c vy m by ( mby) my c

/ m cm mc b

c mc my w c v w. f

cmm m c m ccv

c.

t c m ccv c wc bcm

b c, , m cb m

mc bv b c m. a c w b

vb c w v cy c

m. Mv, cmm m c mc c c jc my, my by

v m the impossibility y c -mv ccy.

iii

s w v m my c

y vc cm jc my mb

, m, cy cmm b jc

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

11/13


mc jc . nx w w cy ,

w C cw vy m

q c cv, m c

m q . fy, jc my w

c by , c, m j by, c

my cvy c my y

y cwm c x mc

m. f w b c c bw w m

by my w jc by w

m m c jc c

, C , cc c bw m m c/cv -c c m. scy,

bc C b jc my

autonomous thinking, jc m b b y jc c

, , m m, c m b b m by

c jc. i w, w c m b my m. t

cmb C c c c cmmm

cmmm m ccv bjc m

m m b m cw c q

, , cy w w c q.

W C c my -cv

c m m c w jc

my vy c w wc c by

by. t wy C c j c j jc;

j cy m m cc my cvy, q

m m c y. t vy m

my .

nx w w w q

w c m b m philosophical

c b cv w ccv in the thinker, .

t m m

m ccv. t y wy m q

ccv, wc w v x. W m

y q by m ccv c, m in its retreat. t c v

m by C cwm jc my,

v c m w

bc vb vb v. l x.

f, v cc c m

m ccv m b b m b w c c

m c . t cy cy bc

c c vc mby my mc my

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

12/13


c my cc m. sc, bc

c m j by my c w

c c vc y by b c m

vcm my. t w mby

my c b j cy, j cc m

cc c c m, c c w

mby jc . B c c

jc my c m b c m c c

m.

nw v xc jc my jc

v c w m w bc vb v, y v jc c cw

w w bv c v , my m

y cc m. t , y m c

cc vc y, C m v m y wc

y y b , my q mby my

c m v bv cc/ c m. t y

c vb wc c my c

topos . t c m cz jc

my b by m c c w

vc y.

i bv y cc w c

jc my cy, , w by, y

cmm m jc my m vy c

. fm cv, b

cvy m ccv, wc, m

c jc, w cvy v

w c by, b vy. s by c c c

c v c / my q ,

w, / bcm m ccv.

i, C cw, c b -

cv jc my cy -x, y

m by -cv jc my, m

the gatheringin its retreat. f cz jc mmy v by my

m vb c b jc c. W c

mw, vy m ccv m vw. a

, m vy retreatingness m ccv,

x bv, c my y c

w w m. n, wv, c y ccv

w y c q cv m

c c jc. f, w b

7/28/2019 307-1256-1-PB

13/13


m jc cv.

i w c c m bjc

m y c unconditional. i

w, c q cm bw

jc by vcm v c

m, c c bc b c

y vb v c v

. i c c / w b c

c v . umy, w bc

mc b jc cv m

m/ b m/ by cv jc my. i

m . i y -m

c c m ccv

m c by m ccv , w,

jby jc cm jc my b cy m.

i bv y b , C c

jc my my jc v

bjc , cq m vc. By

m m w w bv v c

jc my, C c m cv c

v y w jc jc

. h my bv c, jc c

, w wv c w ,

, -cv c m ccv topos

wc m m b vb m c c

jc.

307-1256-1-pb

Documents