4 9 13 0204 065630 motion for new trial, arrest judgement, and correct illegal sentence stamped...
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
1/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
2/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
a&'ect o* the &u''(e&&ion %otion, /T TS >o(e, the) ?le@ it on the @hole Bnot
&u**icient '(o?a?le cau&e to &u''o(t an a((e&t and &ea(ch incident the(etoBD...ine**ectie
a&&i&tance o* coun&el to 'lace all o* CoughlinD& egg& int he @hole Boh, @eDll get the 'at
do@n &u'(e&&edB a''(oach...it& ?a&ic to al&o a(gue on the &u''(e&& the S+TD& *(uit
a&&u%ing one @in& the on the 'at do@n &u''(e&&ion. F/(the(, Te%'leton te&ti*ied that the
'hone did not e%it a i?(ating &ound, and &o did Coughlin, and 'e(ha'& &o%e
othe(&...N CRN / TT V+E- -F TE RREST -N TE +...C-/:6+NDS V+E-S RE T+>EST>E N
C-/:6+NDS 2=1 :E RE TR+6 >-T+-N N+6S -N TE FCT TT
+S -NE S SET T- /T- /TE, S- TE +NTERN6 C6-C -N +T
S S0NCE T- STE6+TTES N +S +N 6+NE +T TE 911 EC->> C66
T+>EST>+N:...>EN+N: TT T 5!#5 -N TE RREST V+E-, -R S-,
TERE S-/6 E S->E V+RT+N: S-/N, ESEC+660 ERE
C-/:6+NDS S>RT-NE +N +S R+:T S-RTS -CET AS-RTS
a''a(entl) thin enough to &ee an 6E &c(een inco%ing call notic*ication light *la&hing
A@he(e it @a& te&ti*ied to that :o?le had hi& 'hone &et to onl) e%it a &c(een light *la&hing
inco%ing call indicato(@ith no i?(ating, and the a((e&t ideo ha& co%%enta() ?) :o?le
the(ein &u''o(ting that 'o&ition a& @ell;...&o, een i* the Cou(t doe&ntD (ei&t the tenatie
&u''(e&&ion hea(ing (uling Aand the Cou(t did (ule that it @a& onl) a tentatie (uling on
82912...; and een i* the &u?&euent a&&e&&%ent o* that (ulign on the &u''(e&&ion %otion
?) udge S*e((aHHa on 1119 and 112# i& not *ollo@ Audge (uled an)thing connected to
- 21= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
3/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
the 'at do@n @a& ecluded...@hich @ould tend to indicate the Bhea(ing the i'hone
i?(atingB te&ti%on) o* u(alde i& ecluded a& @ell....leaing onl) allegedl) nonENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
5/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
'e(ha'& @a& too i%'atient a*te( clicing on the &econd *a o* 111"12 *(o% the RC
ACoughlinD& *a in?o& indicate& one *a at 11!42 and one at 11!49 a%...?ut adding to the
con*u&ion i& the *act that the coe( 'age on the *a *(o% 1141a% that i& u&t the one 'age
o(de( and the coe( &heet indicate&, on the coe( &heet, that the *a i& 1" 'age& long Ait&
not, it& u&t 2, counting the coe( &heet...long &to() &ho(t...it a''ea(& Coughlin @a&
inco((ect in a&&e(ting the RC *a the one 'age -(de( t@ice and the 15 'age& -(de(
Aincluding the attached &u?'oena&, etc; not at all...to ?e clea(, ?oth @e(e *aed to Coughlin
on 11 1" 12. No@, @hethe( that i& *ai(, @hethe( Cit) tto(ne) SIau &ending Coughlin an
e%ail &a)ing udge S*e((aHHa autho(iHed &e(ice o* notice o* the 111=12 E%e(genc)
ea(ing ?) e%ail u'on Coughlin Athe(e?) ga(ne(ing CoughlinD& a''ea(ance, @he(ea&,
othe(@i&e, Coughlin could hae 'ointed to the *act that Cit) tto(ne) SIau did not hae
'e(&onal &e(ice, and the da)& *o( %ailing a(gua?l) @ould hae Acon&die(ing Coughlin @a&
totall) ?ooIed all da) on 111412 *o( a 5 %e%?e( anel *o(%al di&ci'lina() ea(ing at the
SN Ait& not liIe Coughlin d(agged hi& *eet on getting &u?'oena& out once 6e&lie @a&
*inall) (e%oed *(o% the ca&e and *inall) tu(ned oe( the ca&e %ate(ial&...it& u&t that
a%%ign thi& ca&e into a 111912 T(ial date a& o* 1#2212, @ith the Ino@ledge that
6e&lie @a& ?eing (e%oed a& atto(ne) o* (eco(d, the Cou(t Ino@ing Coughlin ha& a *o(%al
di&ci'lina() hea(ing on 111412, the RC 2 indicating no continuance @oudl ?e g(anted
?a&ed u'on &uch '(oi%it) o* the *o(%al hea(ing and t(ial date, etc., etc... A&t(ange, ?ecaue
continuance& &ee% to ?e gien out liIe cand) @hen the '(o&ecuto( o( the C need
one...donDt een (eui(e a cou(t -(de(...u&t a &ti' ?et@een coun&el, &ee%& to %e...and
the(e @a& lot& o* &ti''ing and &@a''ign cou(t date& and co%?o hea(inD &ettinD in the = ca&e&
0-ung i& (etaliato(il) '(o&ecutinD Coughlin on in the RC, u&uall) in iolation o*
- 51= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
6/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
NRS 178.4#5 A&ee al&o NRS 5.#71; &ta) du(ing 'endenc) o* Co%'etenc) EValuation. +t&
a ?a&i& *o( a %i&t(ial @hat )-ung ha& done he(e Ait& tacI) ?e)ond all %ea&u(e and
co%'letel) cla&&le&& too ?oot, and @onDt ?e *o(gotten eithe(; the etent to @hich 0oung
%oed to hae Coughlin inca(ce(ated on 41912 *o( a&Iign a ue&tion a?out hi& i''a
(ight& A(eall), No(%an, )ou need to get a god da%n li*e, gu), all thi& B0ou( ono(, +
de%and )ou taIe >(. Coughlin into cu&tod) *o( a&&e(ting that he ha& an) (ight&, etc.,
etc.B...)ou a(e a c(ee', No(%an, t()ing to hold a t(ial on >a) 7th, 2#12 de&'ite the ca&e not
een ?eing (e%anded *(o% c(12
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
7/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
*(o% one&el* that one&el* allegedl) &tole...it& a du'licatie thing o( dou?le eo'a(d), andthe(e*o(e, Coughlin did not B%i&(e'(e&ent Staa?B to the Cou(t....the Cou(t u&t need& to(ead CoughlinD& *iling& %o(e ca(e*ull)...*u(the(, de&'ite CoughlinD& *a '(o?le%& Ahe ha&a''a(entl) ?een u&ing 775 =25 "5## a& a c(i%inal dii&ion *a nu%?e( &ince a?out 1# 1212 A@hich e'lain& the e%ail *(o% >(. Tuttle indicating the RC did not (eceie @hatCoughlin thought he &ent on o( a?out 1#1812 A&ee attached '(oo* o* *aing& to that 77"=25 "5## nu%?e( that coincide @ith *ae& to 0oung *a nu%?e( at (oughl) the &a%eti%e& and date&..../T, one thing Coughlin i& &u(e a?out i& the *act that he did not &u?%ita *iling @ith an e%'t) cddd &leee in it. The(e i& no @a). lea&e a&I aili** la%ondon
@h) he had @hat Coughlin le*t in >&. Ro??in aIe(D& 'o&&e&&ion on 1#1512 in thehall@a) hal*@a) to the R>C u&t a*te( 5 '% on 111512...udge Cli*ton in #"5"=# @a&gien the @(ong thing......Ve(), e() u'&etting that the cou(t did not hae that @hichCoughlin attached. o@ee(, it i& a''a(ent the Cou(t did not (ead @hat Coughlin @(oteeithe(, a& Coughlin t)'ed out the t(an&c(i't o* all the 911 call& and the &alient ine&tigato()ideo& AV+E-##99, V+E-#1##, etc., etc.;, &o, een i* it had @hat @a& attached...Thenthe(e i& 0-ung not (ecogniHing the ideo o* the a((e&t...ut, old Co() :o?le &li''edu' and ad%itted that i& @a& Tanne( Chan to @ho% 775 =78 ""7= ?elong&, and @ho% i&&een in the ideo.. State a( o* Neada ha& (eealed RC udicial Sec(eta() To@n&end&ending %ate(ial& a?out Coughlin in '(il 2#12 Aho@ the RC *ind& it a''(o'(iate to (e*u&e to (e&'ond to &u?'oena& and &u?'oena duce& tecu%& Aand NRC 45 i& not eactl)a''lica?le in that &etting, one %u&t (e*e(ence SCR 1#5A4; and the (ule& a& announced toIno@, not that the CD& -**ice @ould ?othe( (e&'onded %o(e than a *e@ hou(& ?e*o(ethe hea(ing on 111412... 0oung and anda(a& @o(I (ight net to each othe(,
- 71= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
8/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
anda(a& inti%iatel) inoled in the udge Na&h ol%e& thingZ. 0oung C i(a)
ogan Bclande&tine &tatu& con*e(enceB 22712 thingRC 6o(i To@n&end e%ailin the SN
a?out Coughlin (e*e(ence in #"==41 thing....and 2 @onDt een let Coughlin 'ut hi&
contention& on the (eco(d a?out @h) (ecu&al o( a con*lict i& in o(de(....and Coughlin
doe&nDt get to ea%ine u(alde, and a (e%i o* B@aie the @itne&& *ee&B Athe(e i&nDt a
&ingle %ention o* B&e(ice *ee&B o( the B@aiing the *ee& cha(ge *o( &e(ice o* &u?'oena&
?) the She(i**B in the audio *(o% that 1#2212 ea(ing in #"==41...ho@ i& Coughlin
&u''o&ed to u&e 'olice (e'o(t& *o( i%'each%ent i* he doe&nDt get to ea%ine u(alde,
@ho% he (etu(n (ecei't (eue&ted an ee()thing unde( NRS 174.=45K Ehi?it 1! a(iou&
(eleant %ate(ial&, including '(oo* o* *ae& to 0oung oe( la&t cou'le %onth& and
'(oo* o* a''a(entl) u&ing the @(ong nu%?e( *o( the RC Ai* the Cou(t hold& Coughlin to
that...then &houldnDt 0oung ?e held to &i%ila( con&euence& *o( iolating the &ta) unde( n(&
178.4#5, *ugitie doc...CoughlinD& 21512 *iling get& in the (eco(d, hi& 82912 *iling get&
in the (eco(d...Coughlin *iled notice o* a''ea(ance @hile &till a licen&e atto(ne), that %a)
not (eui(e an -(de( o* the Cou(t to &u?&itute Coughlin in a& Coun&el unde( the (ule&....that
@a& done in Fe?(ua() 2#12 @hile Coughlin not &u?ect to an) co%'etenc) eal -Rde(.
) doe&nDt To@n&end &end STate a( &o%ethign a?out ogan %i&&ing 21=12 ea(ing
Ait& non&en&e to &a) B@e donDt go to a((aing%ent&B...ogan had a''ea(ed a& coun&el on the
(eco(d and docIet at that 'oint, &ent Coguhlin a lette(, and %et @ith hi% *o( an hou( and a
hal*...not going to a cou(t date @hile collecting a 'a)checI unde( tho&e ci(cu%&tance& i&
not &u''o(ta?le...neithe( i& *ailing to notice Coughlin *o( the co%?o hea(ing on 8"12 then
l)ign to Coughlin and the Cou(t a?out that...to CoughlinD& -R chance& det(i%enet A?oth
6e&lie and ogan did that...and oganD& %i&(e'(e&entation and &%i(Iign a?otu th 11 7 12
- 81= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
9/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
>otion to Lua&h that 0oung had, ?ut @hich @a& nee( *aed to Coughlin i& getting '(ett)
ta@d()...oganD& u&ing u' tho&e *(ee 'a&&e& '(ett) uicI, &o i& 0oung...and the(e %e&& i&
&ta(ting to (e*lect on the RC and it& udge&....the&e atto(en)D& &hould cea&e e'ecting
othe(D& to coe( *o( the%. &a%e goe& *o( the R and -F*ice( u(alde. Coughlin i& a
National >e(it Finali&t, 1#th in hi& la@ &chool cla&&, 'a&&ed the ?a( ea% a )ea( ea(l)
@hile a &econd )ea( la@ &tudent, (ai&ed in Reno, Reno ighD& all ti%e leading &co(e( in
?a&Iet?all local '(oduct...u(aldeD& *(o% Cali*o(nia o( &o%ething...?ut (ega(dle&&...it& @a&
a &tu'id a((e&t and the t(ial Bat%o&'he(eB A?aili**& a&Iing Coughlin i* the RC can Iee' hi&
la'to'& oe(night in&tead o* (elea&ing the% to the C and the ail...Coughlin &a)& BiDll
hae &o%e?od) get the% *(o% the ail...?oo%...Coughlin (elea&ed *(o% cu&tod) in&tead o*
t(an&'o(ted to the ail. &a%e aili** @ho% th(eatened to B'ut %) *oot u' )ou( a&&B and
again&t @ho% Coughlin *iled a '(otection -Rde(, conduct a *ou(th a%end%ent iolating
&ea(ch o* CoughlinD& ?ag du(ing t(ial...then tell& coughlin a da) late( Bit& not a Fou(th
%end%ent iolation i* the + &ea(ch @a& guilt) o* the c(i%e + &u&'ected the% to hae
co%%itted...BD0eah, uh, it actuall) is a Fou(th %end%ent iolation, een then. e&'eciall)
then....and the&e teenage di(t?ag &Iate?oa(de(& hae lied, and lied, and lied, and lied
th(oughout the a((e&t and t(ial...the(e @a& a ti%e @hen atto(ne)D& and udge& didnDt &ell
each othe( out *o( a nicIel and a ?ag o* F(ito&....-@ in the @o(ld i& Coughlin
de%on&t(ating Ban intent to 'e(%anentl) de'(ie, ?e)ond a (ea&ona?le dou?tB @he(e :o?le
te&ti*ie& to haing &aid B)ou u&t ad%itted )ou &tole %) 'honeB...ho@ i& :o?le, Te%'leton,
Za(ate, and 6icht)D& te&ti%on) that Coughlin u&t Ie't den)ing haing the 'hone con&i&tent
@ith thatK -( @ith the &tate%ent ?) Coughlin in the ideo At(an&c(i?ed in CoguhlinD& 2=1
(e T(ial >e%o(andu% A@h) doe& Coughlin &'end the %ao(it) o* the T(ial getting
- 91= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
10/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
ha(angued and )elled at ?) the Cou(t, )et it& Coughlin @ho actuall) 'ut the @o(I in to
looI u' the ca&e la@, gathe( ideo&, etc., etc.. and 0oung doe&nDt een unde(&tand the
cha(ge&, cite& no ca&e la@ ?e)ond ?oile('late, and thinI& Coughlin& du'licatie
cha(gingdou?le eo'a(d) B%u&t ?e B*(o% anothe(Bnot B*(o% the 'e(&on o* anothe(B
Audge S*e((aHHa ue((ied Coughlin a?out that i&&ue at an ea(lie( hea(ing '(o?a?l) the
82912 Su'(e&&ion ea(ing, %a)?e @ith 0oung not the(e....a?out ho@ one cannot ?e
conicted o* oth la(cen) and (eceiing &tolen '(o'e(t) *o( the &a%e ite% on the &a%e &et o*
act& Aie, one cannot (eceie &tolen '(o'e(t) *(o% oneD& &el* that one the%&el* &tole....and
0oung thinI& Coughlin i& con*u&edK 0oung talIing a?out Bnot, that& *elon), BtaIing
*(o% the 'e(&on o* anothe(B...ahhh....
CONCLUSION
Please take note of the material mentioned above and in the attachments. this is what is
known as a clustereff...might be a good time to cut bait and let the people who what done got themself
into this deal with it...because if ou do! Coughlin willprobably be oka with it if ou "ust do that #get
the $P% %uralde echo&reference there'(.
- 1#1= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
11/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
)**I$+),ION Pursant to N$S -/0.11
The unde(&igned doe& he(e?) a**i(% that the '(eceding docu%ent doe& not contain the
&ocial &ecu(it) nu%?e( o* an) 'e(&on.
%2CL)$),ION
The a&&e(tion& he(ein a(e %ade, 'u(&uant to NRS 5=.#45 unde( 'enalt) o* 'e(u() and
?a&ed u'on %) *i(&t hand Ino@ledge o* the&e %atte(&, ece't to 'e(ha'& a e(), e() *e@
a&'ect& o* a a e() *e@ a&&e(tion& @hich a(e %ade u'on in*o(%ation and ?elie*.
ated thi& Noe%?e( 27th, 2#12,
& Zach Coughlin, &igned elect(onicall)
Zach Coughlin
e*endant
- 111= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
note, on t e or g na ng coug n wrote n s own an
"again on 12/3/12"
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
12/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
C2$,I*IC),2 O* S2$3IC24
u(&uant to NRC 5A?;, + do he(e?) ce(ti*) that, on thi& date, +, Zach Coughlin +de'o&ited in the /nited State& %ail at Reno, Neada, in a &ealed enelo'e, 'o&tage'(e'aid, a t(ue and co((ect co') o* the *o(egoing N-T+CE -F RE6EVNTEVE6->ENTS and o( elect(onicall) &e(ed Aia elect(onic %ethod o* t(an&%i&&ion'(eiou&l) gien e'(e&& 'e(%i&&ion to utiliHe ?) tho&e @ith (eui&ite autho(it) to '(oideit, u'on @hich Couglin (ea&ona?l) (elied and o( (elie&;!ZCR0 N. 0-/N:, ESL.
a&hoe Count) -**ice
dd(e&&! 1 South Sie((a
.-. o =##8=Reno, NV 8952#hone Nu%?e(! 775
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
13/112
5
10
15
20
25
1234
6789
11121314
16171819
21222324
262728
IN%25 ,O 256I0I,S!
1. Ehi?it 1! a(iou& (eleant %ate(ial&, including '(oo* o* *ae& to 0oung oe( la&tcou'le %onth& and '(oo* o* a''a(entl) u&ing the @(ong nu%?e( *o( the RC Ai* the Cou(t
hold& Coughlin to that...then &houldnDt 0oung ?e held to &i%ila( con&euence& *o( iolatingthe &ta) unde( n(& 178.4#5, *ugitie doc...CoughlinD& 21512 *iling get& in the (eco(d, hi&82912 *iling get& in the (eco(d...Coughlin *iled notice o* a''ea(ance @hile &till a licen&eatto(ne), that %a) not (eui(e an -(de( o* the Cou(t to &u?&itute Coughlin in a& Coun&elunde( the (ule&....that @a& done in Fe?(ua() 2#12 @hile Coughlin not &u?ect to an)co%'etenc) eal -Rde(. ) doe&nDt To@n&end &end STate a( &o%ethign a?out ogan%i&&ing 21=12 ea(ing Ait& non&en&e to &a) B@e donDt go to a((aing%ent&B...ogan hada''ea(ed a& coun&el on the (eco(d and docIet at that 'oint, &ent Coguhlin a lette(, and %et@ith hi% *o( an hou( and a hal*...not going to a cou(t date @hile collecting a 'a)checIunde( tho&e ci(cu%&tance& i& not &u''o(ta?le...neithe( i& *ailing to notice Coughlin *o( theco%?o hea(ing on 8"12 then l)ign to Coughlin and the Cou(t a?out that...to CoughlinD&-R chance& det(i%enet A?oth 6e&lie and ogan did that...and oganD& %i&(e'(e&entationand &%i(Iign a?otu th 11 7 12 >otion to Lua&h that 0oung had, ?ut @hich @a& nee(*aed to Coughlin i& getting '(ett) ta@d()...oganD& u&ing u' tho&e *(ee 'a&&e& '(ett)uicI, &o i& 0oung...and the(e %e&& i& &ta(ting to (e*lect on the RC and it& udge&....the&eatto(en)D& &hould cea&e e'ecting othe(D& to coe( *o( the%.
- 1=1= -
N-T+CE -F RE6EVNT EVE6->ENTS
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
14/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
15/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
16/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
17/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
18/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
19/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
0re+ent on ">13>13 at a hearing related to Coughlin+ +u))ar incarceration the da
0reviou+ in RCR"'1"*'&!&3' herein udge CliAton indicated +o)ething to the eAAect
that 1">13 to ">1&>13 due to uncertaint a+ to hether it a+
a Fcri)inal conte)0tG conviction he a+ adHudged to have co))itted, and thereAore
re/uiring re0orting to the State Bar oA Nevada and S#5, and having negative licen+ure
con+e/uence+...D.
lea+e incor0orate herein the argu)ent+ and citation+ )ade in Coughlin+ 3>1>13
13 5SC in 51"*'1, or to Continue or Vacate the 3>!>13
2earing, etc.
Validit, Con+truction, and 00lication oA State Ve%atiou+ -itigant Statute+, 4!
.-.R.&th 493
"''9D
7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
20/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Conle "''9 6- !9!99. n re atra)ala "'11 6- 4!!&13 )a not @e a
0u@li+hed>cita@le order, and iA +o, onl 0re+ented herein Aor @acground inAor)ationD.
l+o ?ronce v. Cit oA hoeni%, "'11 6- &'9'941. al+o )ight not @e a 0u@li+hed
o0inionD
#he 1", +igned @ then ChieA
u+tice SAerraIIa hich a+ 0ur0ortedl 0er+onall +erved u0on Coughlin on 1">"&>1",
@ an unna)ed 0er+ona, at an unidentiAied location, according to no ChieA udge
ear+on+ 3>!>13 5rder to Sho Cau+e in 51"*'1 not clear hat the ca+e nu)@er i+, or
iA there i+ a ca+e nu)@er at all, or even an o00o+ing 0artD, read+:
FN #2E
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
21/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the allegation+ 0lead in the SBN+ >"3>1" co)0lain Nevada i+ a notice*0leading +tate.
-angevin. D.
F62ERES, ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N ha+ @een a 0art in ca+e+ @eAore
the Reno .leg.+tate.nv.u+>NRS>:G#B-E 5$ ##-ES N C2#ERS= NEV
REVSE S###ES= ##-E "KCIVIL PRACTICE= CHAPTER 22 - C5N#E3'>11 F5RER $5R S
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
22/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
MM C2EC?ED MMMMMM Disorderly, cone!"#o#s or insolen $e%&'ior o(&rd %e)#d*e (%ile %e is %oldin* co#r, or en*&*ed in %is )#dici&l d#ies & c%&!$ers,
@reach oA the 0eace, @oi+terou+ conduct or violent di+tur@ance in the 0re+ence oA
the Court, or in it+ i))ediate vicinit, tending to interru0t due to the cour+e oA the trial orother Hudicial 0roceeding,
MMMN5# C2EC?EDMMM ReAu+ing to @e +orn or an+er a+ a itne++
MMMN5# C2EC?EDMMM i+o@eing a laAul rit>order>rule>0roce++ i++ued @ theCourt>Hudge at cha)@er+, and +HEREAS s#c% cond#c
MMN5# C2EC?ED MM e)eaned the Court
MM N5# C2EC?EDMM erogated the authorit oA the Court
MM C2EC?ED MMMMMM nterAered ith the orderl ad)ini+tration oA Hu+tice and re/uiredi))ediate vindication @ the Court to 0re+erve order and re+0ect.
Ba+ed u0on the a@ove Ainding ZC2R8C5;2-N i+ ;uilt oA irectConte)0t. #he Conte)nor, hen a+ed iA he had anthing to +a a+ to h +entence+hould not @e 0ronounced, re0lied: in handritingD See Court Record. #hereAore, # S2EREB8 5RERE, ;E, and ECREE that the conte)nor i+ here@+entenced to the Aolloing 0uni+h)ent:
MM N5# C2EC?EDMM Aine in the a)ount oA !'' or le++D.
MM C2EC?ED MMMMMM )0ri+on)ent Aor "! da+ or le++D, N5 -#ERN#VESEN#ENCN;...
E$ENN# #5 BE RE-ESE on 1">3>11 at 0) #E thi+ 3'th da oANove)@er, "'11 ?ENNE#2 R. 256R, ;E, Reno 1"
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
23/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
a chec in a @lan here 0reviou+l there a+ none. #he 5rder )u+t +tand a+ it i+, and, a++uch, that 5SC 0rovide+ "oug!linconclu+ive 0rooA re+ Hudicata, collateral e+to00elD thatCoughlin did not %erogated the authorit oA the CourtG or FnterAered ith the orderlad)ini+tration oA Hu+tice and re/uired i))ediate vindication @ the Court to 0re+erveorder and re+0ectG +uAAicient Aor R1" Aa%ed o@Hection+ to Coughlin+
+u@0oena, herein he a++ert+ that Coughlin+ Fad)i++ionG that hi+ la licen+e in Nevada i++u+0ended though, it )a @e that, given Coughlin+ S#5 la licen+e i+ not 0re+entl+u+0ended, Coughlin i+ entitled to i++ue +u@0oena+ to ho)ever he choo+e+ incidenttheretoD nece++aril )ean+ that, under NRC 4!aD3D, the +u@0oena+ Coughlin had +ervedthat ere not i++ued @ the SBN+ Cler oA Court need not @e o@eed or re+0onded to.#hi+, de+0ite the Aact that it i+ not at all clear that NRC 4! i+ even a00lica@le indi+ci0linar )atter+, nor that, even ere it a00lica@le, the Aact+ oA the+e 0articularcircu)+tance+ auger Aor an a00lication +uch a+ the one +ugge+ted @ 6C 6att+*Vial, 0articularl given Chair)an Su+ich+ 7>"7>1" ritten corre+0ondence to Coughlin,and the i)0ort oA +uch co))unication hen con+idering the e%0re++ declaration )ade @Bar Coun+el ?ing to Coughlin on 1'>1!>1" that ?ing had conAir)ed ith ChieA BarCoun+el avid Clar that Coughlin, a+ a Re+0ondent, even here te)0oraril +u+0ended,)a, in Aact, i++ue hi+ on +u@0oena+, and Aurther here con+idering that theSBN>NNB>anel>SBN Cler oA Court had co))unicated to Coughlin that he a+ notre/uired to 0a +u@0oena or itne++ Aee+, @oth in light oA hi+ inidgent +tatu+, and under therule+ a00lica@le to thi+ 0articular di+ci0linar )atter under SCR 1'!4D and SCR 1193D.
FNRSL"".'1'LLAcs or o!issions consi#in* cone!"s.LL#he Aolloing act+or o)i++ion+ +hall @e dee!ed cone!"s:
1.LLi+orderl, conte)0tuou+ or in+olent @ehavior toard the Hudge hile theHudge i+ holding court, or engaged in Hudicial dutie+ at cha)@er+, or toard)a+ter+ or ar@itrator+ hile +itting on a reAerence or ar@itration, or other Hudicial0roceeding.
".LLA $re&c% o %e "e&ce, $oisero#s cond#c or 'iolen dis#r$&nce in%e "resence o %e co#r, or in is i!!edi&e 'iciniy, endin* o inerr#" %e
d#e co#rse o %e ri&l or o%er )#dici&l "roceedin*.
3.LLi+o@edience or re+i+tance to an laAul rit, order, rule or 0roce++ i++ued@ the court or Hudge at cha)@er+.
&>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
24/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4.LLi+o@edience oA a +u@0oena dul +erved, or reAu+ing to @e +orn oran+er a+ a itne++.
!.LLRe+cuing an 0er+on or 0ro0ert in the cu+tod oA an oAAicer @ virtue oAan order or 0roce++ oA +uch court or Hudge at cha)@er+.
&.LLi+o@edience oA the order or direction oA the court )ade 0ending the trialoA an action, in +0eaing to or in the 0re+ence oA a Huror concerning an action inhich the Huror ha+ @een i)0aneled to deter)ine, or in an )anner a00roachingor interAering ith +uch Huror ith the intent to inAluence the verdict.
7.LLA$#sin* %e "rocess or "roceedin*s o %e co#ror Aal+el 0retending toact under the authorit oA an order or 0roce++ oA the court.G
nd, actuall, it i+ 6C 6att+*Vial, and, argua@l the Second udicial
i+trict Court udge+ and Cler oA Court and ++i+tant Cler oA Court, and Cu+todian oA
Record+ ho) +hould @e +u@Hect to a Ainding that the have violated NRS "".'3'4D.
$urther, Reno Cit ttorne Chri+ten+en and the Reno
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
25/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Stancil, #uttle, and the RC+ Cu+todian oA Record+ @ one Nichola+ 2a++ett oA Reno,
Nevada, a "' ear old at the ti)e. Bur Coughlin reall ould 0reAer to Hu+t )ove on Aro)
all oA that, )ae a)end+, Aocu+ on thing+ lie udge $lanagan+ &>"!>1" attorne Aee
aard in CV11*'3&" a+ not a +anction, @ut rather an a00lciation oA CR 133D, etc., in
hi+ BrieA in &"337, the di+@ar)ent a00eal.
F62ERES, ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N ha+ @een a 0art in @oth civil
and cri)inal )atter+ @eAore thi+ Court including ca+e+ @eAore the 2onora@le eter
SAerraIIa, %e Honor&$le Sco Pe&rson, and the 2onora@le avid CliAton herein
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
26/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
F$ro): ?andara+, 13
and >17, "'1" to Coughlin in rcr"'1"*'&!&3' )0ortance:
2igh
i):
@elieve that ou +hould +end thi+. Su0re)e Court Rule 1'4aDauthoriIe+ State @ar coun+el to inve+tigate all )atter+ involving0o++i@le attorne )i+conduct or inca0acit called to @ar coun+el+attention, hether @ grievance or @oth.T%is "oeni&lly in'ol'es!iscond#c .'iol&ion o l&(/ &nd inc&"&ciy
17, "'1" to Coughlin in rcr"'1"*'&!&3'
#han+, 0lea+e do. 2e ca)e to our oAAice aAter ) e)ail toou and cau+ed a di+tur@ance. 6e called the 0olice, @ut heAled @eAore the arrived. Hi)
*****5riginal
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
27/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Sent: 6edne+da, ece)@er 1", "'1" ":!9 < #o: ?andara+,13 and >17, "'1" toCoughlin in rcr"'1"*'&!&3'
13 and >17, "'1" to Coughlin inrcr"'1" *'&!&3'
17>1" ... nd the heav hitter+
1'>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
28/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ere there, too Elliot SattlerD ..... de+0ite nu)erou+ rittenre/ue+t+ Aro) Coughlin that the 6C do +o, and )ulti0letri0+ to the 6C 0er+onall @ Coughlin to 0ic +uch)aterial+ u0, and de+0ite )ore Ali0 Alo00ing on their +tor @-e+lie and ogan regarding hether the ever gave Coughlin
+o)e 0acage oA )aterial+ re+0on+ive to Coughlin+ re/ue+tAor hi+ JAileJ ... But, i) -e+lie i+ +tuc ith the 7>"7>1" datehe )ention+ in hi+ e)ail, then he i+ +tuc ith hat hi+ recente)ail herein he 0ur0ort+ to have therein digitall tran+)ittedCoughlin hi+ JAileJ, hich o@viou+l doe+ not include the cd+oA 911 call+ the one+ 8oung too u0 an enor)ou+a)ount oA court ti)e 0laing, over and over ell, 8oungonl 0laed over and over the 0articular call+ he Aelt ere+tronge+t Aor hi+ ca+e and )o+t 0reHudicial, clai)ing +o)eJcutting roo) Aloor )i+ha0J Aor the reoccurrence oA certaincall+, arguing that +uch a Jha00 accidentJ Hu+tiAied 0laing
the) again and again, at ever increa+ing volu)e+, etc., etc.D.00arentl, a) here to +u@+idiIe 8oung+ @a@ )aing, Hu+tlie a+ ith >tinurl.co)>@g)lAdr
#hi+ i+ a Aor)al grievance again+t ogan, -e+lie, Bo+ler,
8oung ... etc....G
#he lin that -e+lie reAer+ to a+ containing a Fvideo cli0 Aro) the )ovie Ca0e$earG actuall contain+ onl an audiocli0 oA a +hort /uote Aro) Ca0e $ear the 1991Scor+e+e ver+ionD.
t a+ argua@l an a@u+e oA 0roce++ @ Bar Coun+el atric ?ing. 2oever,Coughlin+ recollection oA the Nove)@er &th, "'1" the night oA the re+identialElection...Coughlin a+ed Nevada -aer e)0loee aula Ca)0@ell iA +he ne hoa+ inning in the 0oll+...etc.,D @rieA encounter @eteen +he and Coughlin a+ oA one oAan entirel cordial, 0roAe++ional nature.
t that ti)e, Ca)0@ell )entioned +he a+ the onl one there oring lateD,and that ++t. Bar Coun+el ?ing had leAt a Ae )inute+ 0rior to Aive 0). Coughlinindicated that he had 0re+ented a cou0le )inute+ 0rior to ! 0) to Aile a docu)ent hereti)e a+ oA the e++ence and in/uired a+ to the 0o+ted clo+ing ti)e oA the SBN and 0olicie+re+0ecting hat Aile +ta)0ed date +uch a +u@)i++ion ould @e given under tho+ecircu)+tance+.
11>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
29/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Couglin did not a+ Ca)0@ell iA he )a venture in+ide the SBN+ 5AAice+ at that
ti)e, nor did he ever Ala+h hi+199& 2onda+ headlight+ to gain attention. #here a+ ani++ue ith the electrical iring to Coughlin+ headlight+ the tailight+ ent out due to a+hort +o)ehere in the ++te), and due to hi+ 0overt, Coughlinhad to )ae do ithout a
tri0 to the )echanic and +i)0l +0lice in +o)e +0eaer ire+ Aro) the headlight+ to the taillight+, and 0rocra+tinated in aAAi%ing an on>oAA +itch in there, +o Coughlin ha+ to,@a+icall , @raid the ire+ together ever ti)e he drive+ at night and in turning the light+uon and oAA hat a 0ainD..
..
E%hi@it 1 to "'>1" in RC RC"'1"*'''&'7 i+ 0a+ted @elo. t +hould @e noted that
Coughlin ha+ @een through /uite a lot thi+ ear, @eing rongAull incarcerated over 1'ti)e+ and rongAull evicted & ti)e+, and a+ +uch, he i+ +everel indigent, +o)ething BarCoun+el ?ing i+ atte)0ting to tae Aurther advantage oA @ increa+ing Coughlin+ 0o+tageco+t+ and decrea+ing the ti)e he ould have to draAt Ailing+ given the tran+0ort ti)e +uchan E5 ould add to the +ervice thereoA....
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
30/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
a+ a@le to get hi) to leave and the 0olice ere called @ut did not arrive @eAore 13>1" and >17>1" 0roduction oA to di+c+ oA EC5"7>1", he nece++aril ad)it+ to having Aailed to turned over the di+c+ onl 0ro0ounded
aAter that 0oint. $urther -e+lie +u@0oened recording+ Aro) EC5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
31/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
'&3341 @ut never turned the) over to Couglhin, de+0ite onl @eing re)oved a+ coun+el oA
record ell over 1! da+ thereaAter, on 1'>"">1".
t+ not at all clear ho a re/ue+t and +u@+e/uent 5rder a00arentl 0rohi@iting
Coughlin Aro) calling, e)ailing or Aa%ing the SBN ould addre++ the alleged threat oA
0h+ical har). 5ne cannot @e 0h+icall har)ed @ a Aa%, e)ail, or 0hone call. $urther,
0hone call+, Aa%e+, and e)ail+ are co))on in 0ending litigation+, even one+ here 0o+t*
Hudg)ent )otion+ are @eing +ought and here Coughlin ha+ a dut to +ee a +ti0ulated
continuance oA, +a, the deadline to Aile an a00eal @rieA in &"337 0rior to Ailing a )otion
+eeing one. #he E5 a00arentl ould 0erha0+ even Aor@id Coughlin Aro) utiliIing a
)e++enger +ervice to deliver a Ailing to the SBN+ Cler oA Court+ 5AAice Aor the +ecuring
oA a Aile +ta)0 to @eat a deadline, +uch a+ the 1>3>13, or 1>4>13 de0ending u0on hether
holida+ are included in the 3 da+ Aor )ailing calculu+ under NRC &eD and the e@oer
deci+ionD, Aor Coughlin to Aile a NRC !" or !9 "3>13. #he SBN ha+ Aailed to re+0ond to Coughlin+ rea+ona@le in/uirie+ in that regard,
a+ ha+ the 6C 8oung rather, Coughlin i+ Aunneled to an n+0ector Covington,
ho) i+ argua@l co))itting the unauthoriIed 0ractice oA la, and +uch circu)+tance+
14>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
32/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
onl Aurther under+core the e%tent to hich the 6C 5AAice +hould @e di+/ualiAied Aor)
0ro+ecuting Coughlin, 0articularl here ?andara+ a@ove e)ail ad)it+ to Aeeling
Coughlin+ co)0etenc i+ @rought into /ue+tion, the event+ involving to Aor)er 6C
Cri)inal ivi+ion 0ro+ecutor+ turned RC udge+ on ">13>13 in an 5rder Aor
Co)0etenc Evaluation +igned and entered @ udge ear+on at an :3' a) hearing in 11*
'&3341 a+ 0rovided, in riting, to udge CliAton in 1"*'&!&3', ith F+hallG language,
and 8oung+ illingne++ to go along ith udge CliAton in reAu+ing to Aollo NRS
17.4'!+ )andator +ta i+ argua@l i)0er)i++i@le. #o have RC BailliAA+ then 5rder
Coughlin to re)ain at the RC, then go into a hearing @rought on an E)ergenc Ba+i+
u0on 8oung )aing an E% arte Re/ue+t Aor udge CliAton to re+con+ider hi+ 5rder
Aor Co)0etenc Evaluation
dd to that the eAAort+ oA the 6C+ -e+lie in oring ith SBN ?ing in a
1"
5n the a@ove date, received a return call Aro) atric ?ingand avid Clar at the State Bar. #he ere re+0onding to )e)ail to ?ing e+terda regarding "ossi$lethreat @ Coughlin a+
contained in an e)ail Coughlin had +ent to )e, other attorne+ inthi+ oAAice, and +everal other reci0ient+. Co0 oA that e)ail i+attached hereto a+ E%hi@it J1J and co0 oA the e@+ite that theend oA the Air+t 0aragra0h oA the e)ail lead+ to i+ attached heretoa+ E%hi@it J"J.
?ing and Clar @oth agreed that the e)ail Aro) Coughlin, inconte%t and ith the reAerence to the e@+ite ith the 'ideo cli"
1!>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
33/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
&nd o%er !&eri&ls Aro) JCa0e $earJ, con+titute+ a threat oAviolence again+t )e and other attorne+ in our oAAice. #hedi+clo+ed that the had had their on 0ro@le)+ ith Coughlin,including having to have ar)ed +ecurit at hi+ State Bar hearingand that the each had con+idered o@taining re+training order+
again+t hi) and 0ro@a@l ill do +o #"on co!"leionoA the Bar0roceeding. #he @oth +tated that Jheightened alertJ i+a00ro0riate in light oA the e)ail he +ent and generall hendealing ith
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
34/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
"&ric#l&ry (%ere +CPD 5i! Leslies &d!is o &ilin* o "ro'ide co#*%lin 911
audio Aile+ on to dic+ 0ro0ounded @ the 6C on >13 and >17>1". $urther,
audio cli0 +0ea+ to learning, reading, and 0hilo+o0h, hich ould not +ee) to
+u00ort a Ainding oA the +ort oA conduct re/uired to +u00ort +uch an 5rder.
dditionall, Aree +0each and acce++ to SBN Ailing oAAice 0rocedure+, including tho+eunder SCR 1'!4D, including tho+e e%0re++ed @ the SBN and it+ Cler oA Court and
Aa% Ailing +o)e authorit e/uate+ e)ail ith Aa% a+ ellD )a 0re+ent clai) oA right
deAen+e to an alleged E5 violation.
+ Such, the diAAicultie+ a++ociated ith @eing arre+ted on ">>13 and charged ith a
Aelon and gro++ )i+de)eanor incident to alleged E5 and #5 violation+ occuring
on da oA deadline+ to Aile NRC !" and or !9 )otion+ a+ to 1">14>1" NNB anel
$inding+ and "!>13 Sho Cau+e 2earing. dditionall, it)a have @een i)0ro0er to a00l rigid and Aor)ulaic n Re Eric+on a00lication oA
0rocedural rule+ to 0ro +e deAendant in variou+ RC )atter+, here 8oung ha+
o@tained +everal E)ergenc E% arte 5rder+ and or "7>1" no
Aa%ing in '&!&3'...the a00roach to the 5rder $or Co)0etenc Evaluation in '&3341 a+
it relate+ to the Sta re/uired on ">1">13 in '&!&3' F+hallG...NRS 17.4'!D. 13 )a not @e a00ro0riate @a+i+ Aor +etting a+ide 5rder Aor
Co)0etenc EvaluationD. -a+tl, S 5AAicer Cele+te Bron e)ail to Coughlin oA
1>"4>13 indicate+ the FvideoG +hoed Coughlin 0re+ented to the +ecurit Chec in
argua@l a ti)el )anner on 1>"3>13 +uAAicient to re@ut a Ainding oA a violation, or at
lea+t de)on+trate a good Aaith atte)0t to co)0l. $urther, arre+t re0ort>@ooing +heet
Aor ">">13 arre+t @ S indicate+ ti)e oA arre+t 7:'" 0), hich )a violate NRS
171.13& dicate again+t )i+de)eanor arre+t @eteen 70) and 7a) ithout a arrant.
Coughlin ordered to e%it hi+ re+idence aAter 70) @ S 5AAicer.
$urther, a+ to 6C i) -e+lie++ #5 a00lication it i+ telling he )i+tate+ the
1">1">1" e)ail a+ continaing a lin to a violent video cli0 hen in Aact the lin i+ to
nothing )ore than an audio cli0 that relate+ to learning, reading, and 0hilo+o0h the
17>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
35/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ver@ati) tran+cri0t oA the entiret oA the audio onl cli0 lined to in the 1">1">1"
e)ail i+ a+ Aollo+:
F aint no hite tra+h 0iece oA +hit. ) @etter than ou all. can out learn
ou. can out read ou. can outthin ou, and can out 0hilo+o0hiIeou. nd ) going to outla+t ou. 8ou thin a cou0le oA hac+ to )
good old @o gut+ gonna get )e don t+ going to tae a hell oA a lot
)ore than that, Coun+elor, to 0rove oure @etter than )eG 1" e)ail doe+ not contain a +ingle violent
+tate)ent or i)age. A the lin had @een to a cli0 oA 13>1" la+t )inuted Aa%ed
o@Hection+ to Coughlin+ SCR 11' Su@0oena+ u0on "C udge+ $lanagan and Elliot,
Cler oA Court 2a+ting+ and the "C Cu+todian oA Record+, here 6att+*Vial ad)it+
to e%tended di+cu++ion+ ith the ver Bar Coun+el ho) conAir)ed to Coughlin that
he, a+ a re+0ondent +u+0ended attorne a00earing 0ro +e in hi+ Aor)al di+ci0linar
)atter, )a, in Aact, i++ue hi+ on +u@0oena+ and, given NNB Su+ich+ 7>"7>1"
e)ail to Coughlin, Coughlin a+ entitled to rel u0on +uch e%0re++ indication+ @ Bar
Coun+el ?ing, 0rovided a+ a )e++age conAir)ing +uch ?ing a+ relaing to Coughlin
u0on conAir)ing +uch ith hi+ +u0ervi+or, ChieA Bar Coun+el avid Clar. n+tead,
le+lie choo+e+ to Aocu+ on a tertiar a+0ect oA +o)e de+cri0tion oA the Ail) incident to a
lin to @u the Ail) here he rite+ N5#E: 5NE R#2ER
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
36/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1">13>1", R#2ER #2N, S -ES-E NC#ES BE-56, 5N 1">1">1"D l+o,
a lot oA -e+lie+ allegation )o+t oA the) are actuall inaccurate ana+, @ut..D need
to @e taen in the conte%t or ith the noledge that Coughlin gre u0 in Reno,
attending So0e and Reno 2igh ith @oth oA hi+ 6C on the+e ca+e+ oe
;oodnight in 11*'&3341 a+ a cla++)ate Aor & ear+ and 0art oA +i)ilar circle+ oAAriend+ a+ Coughlin throughout tho+e ear+D and Bira ogan in 1"*'&!&3' ogan
and Coughlin ent through +chool together Aro) 7ththrough 1"thgrade, @oth
graduating ith the Reno 2igh School cla++ oA 199!D and Coughlin and tho+e to
have )uch )ore oA an ea+ read Aai)ilarit ith each other and their re+0ectivie
+en+e+ oA hu)or. #hen, all the +udden, i) -e+lie, E+/., ho )oved to 6a+hoe
Count in the earl ninetie+ Aro)
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
37/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
orht oA an audio cli0 +uch a+ that allegedl lined to, Aound at a )ain+trea) e@+ite
lie .2ar.co)...and -e+lie Aail+ to actuall get into hat the audio cli0 actuall
+a+, rather, he Aocu+e+ on )atter+ in no a de0icted in the audio cli0 allegation+
that the Aor)er client Hu+t @eat +everal )en, that he utiliIed a ea0on or @lunt
in+tru)ent to do +o, that he had their+ and hi+ @lood on hi+ therre i+ a +till i)agede0icted in the cli0, @ut Coughlin ha+ an add*on in hi+ @ro+er that @loc+ +uch
i)age, +o even iA it i+ 0roven that Couglin +ent +uch an e)ail, he ould not have @een
aare oA the +till i)age de0icted u0on clicin on +uch lin, and regardle++, that i)age
i+ oA a )ain+trea) actor, Ro@ert eniro, and it i+ not clear hat he i+ holding or hat
he ha+ @een doing or h, or hether or not it i+ in Aact @lood on hi+ +hirt...Aurther in
that +till i)age, eniro ha+ hi+ hand in a 0lacid, re+ting 0o+ition a+ though @alancing
hi+ eight on a golA 0utter or +o)ething, hardl a )enacing +tance. #he audio cli0 i+
" +econd+ long. Regardle++, to hatever e%ten -e+lie, the 6C, ?ing or the SBN
Aelt threatened or actuall AearAul hich i+ highl unliel given all their a++ociated@lu+ter and 0ur0o+eAul aggravation and taunting oA Coughlin Aor a +u+tained 0eriod oA
ti)e and grou0thin, @elligerent, 0ac*lie, in+titutionaliIed @ulling @ehavior in
+o)e, @ut not all, in+tance+ avid Clar )enacingl co))ented to Coughlin a@out
@eing F+adG that he didnt get a chance to 0ro+ecute that one attorne @eAore the
+ch)uc co))itted +uicied...at ?ing Aau% e%0re++ing +adne++ in an ultra
conde+cending tone hen )entioning the high lielihood oA Coughlin @eing di+@arred,
i) -e+lie+ hi+trionic+ and FScra00*oG*lie @ehavior Scra00*o Fi) -e+lie i+ a
Scra00 udeG reAerence +ound+ lie +o)ething a taller 0er+on )ight )ae u0 on the
+0ot in an atte)0t to o@Au+cate a reAerence that )ight co)e acro++ a+ hurtAul to a
+horter 0er+on ho) had Ainall aggravated the taller 0er+on enough to )ae an
argua@l hurtAul co))ent @a+ed u0on one+ +hort +tatute. Couglin ha+ @een tall )o+t
all oA hi+ liAe. t+ not all it+ craced u0 to @e...hoever, Coughlin ha+ Aelt e)0ath
toard+ +horter )en, ha+ ala+ atte)0ted to and )anaged to )ae 0er+onal
invective @a+ed u0on other+ 0h+ical a00earance+, etc., and iA Coughlin did )ae a
reAerence to i) -e+lie @eing lie the character Scra00*o Aro) the children+
cartoon +erie+ FScoo@*oG it a+ onl aAter @eing aggravated endle++l @ a )ean
+0irited, at ti)e+, @ut not ala+, i) -e+lie, ho) i+ liel +tre++ed out at ti)e+ Aro)
handling a large ca+e*load, and having 0eo0le+ Areedo) in hi+ hand+ da aAter da
+o)ethign Aor hich Coughlin had a great deal oA re+0ect Aor the Aact that +uch i+ the
ca+e incident to -e+lie+ Ho@ and 0o+ition...$or @acground, the cartoon character
Scra00*o i+ a di)inutive canine Ariend oA Scoo@*o ho) oAten+ 0ic+ Aight+
ith )uch large o00onent+, onl to then have hi+ large Ariend+, lie Shagg and
Scoo@ co)e in and either do the Aighting Aor hi), or, )ore t0icall, di+0ell the
+ituation created @ Scra00*o+ antagoniIing @lu+ter...Aairl +i)ilar to hat
"'>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
38/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
occurred on 5cto@er 9th, "'11 hen RC BailiAA Ree+ a+ called in a+ -e+lie ha+
done ith RC BailiAA+ ti)e and againD to crac don on or inti)idate Coughlin or
other -e+lie client+ ho) have Ainall +tarted to @roach at -e+lie+ treate)ent oA the)
and reAu+al to advocate on their @ehalA. nd hile -e+lie allege+ Coughlin to have
+ee)ingl )o+tl co)0laint+ again+t other Fattorne+ in our oAAiceG, @ Aar,Coughlin+ Aru+tration ha+ related to -e+lie the overhel)ing )aHorit oA the ti)e,
though at ti)e+ Coughlin and -e+lie have had a ra00ort and Coughlin i+he+ -e+lie
no ill ill, ho0e+ to loo @ac at all thi+ a+ Ariend+ +o)eda, etc..D..:
FFE3%i$i 1 o A""lic&ion or Te!"or&ry Order or Proecion
A*&ins H&r&ss!en in %e +or"l&ce
Zachar Coughlin i+ a client oA the 6a+hoe Count u@lic
eAender, and have @een a++igned to one or )ore oA hi+ cri)inalca+e+, t i+ antici0ated that @ #ue+da, ece)@er 1, "'1", ouroAAice ill @e relieved a+ coun+el on
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
39/112
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
40/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
the inve+tigator 0re+ent in the lo@@, a+ed 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
41/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
reAerence to JCa0e $earJ, 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
42/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
dditionall, 6C and 6C *Civil ivi+ion "1>1", u0on the ridiculou+ 5rder Aolloing theunnoticed 7>!>1" @ail increa+e hearing incident to the Araudulentte+ti)on @ R 5AAicer+ 6eaver and or e, and theFadvocacG @ R7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
43/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
(%en & deend&n (%o %&s $een "l&ced
on "ro$&ion or (%ose senence %&s
$een s#s"ended is $ro#*% $eore %e
co#r, i do#$ &rises &s o %eco!"eence o %e deend&n, %e co#r
s!alls#s"end %e "roceedin*s, %e ri&lor %e "rono#ncin* o %e )#d*!en, &s
%e c&se !&y $e, until%e 8#esion o
co)0etence i+ deter)ined.
".LLA the 0roceeding+, the trial or the 0ronouncing oA the Hudg)ent are +u+0ended,
%e co#r !#s notify &ny o%er de"&r!ens o %e co#r o %e s#s"ension in
writing. 0on receiving +uch notice, the other de0art)ent+ oA the court s%&lls#s"end
&ny o%er "roceedin*s rel&in* o %e deend&n #nil %e deend&n is deer!ined
o $e co!"een
$ro): ?andara+, 13 and >17, "'1" toCoughlin in rcr"'1"*'&!&3' )0ortance:
2igh
i):
@elieve that ou +hould +end thi+. Su0re)e Court Rule 1'4aDauthoriIe+ State @ar coun+el to inve+tigate all )atter+ involving0o++i@le attorne )i+conduct or inca0acit called to @ar coun+el+attention, hether @ grievance or @oth.T%is "oeni&lly in'ol'es!iscond#c .'iol&ion o l&(/ &nd incapacity
17, "'1" to Coughlin in rcr"'1"*'&!&3'
"&>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
44/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
#han+, 0lea+e do. 2e ca)e to our oAAice aAter ) e)ail toou and cau+ed a di+tur@ance. +e c&lled %e "olice, @ut hefled $eore %ey &rri'ed. Hi)
*****5riginal 17, "'1" to Coughlin inrcr"'1"*'&!&3'
ill have to revie thi+ to)orro and get @ac to ou.
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
45/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
*****5riginal 17>1" ... nd the heav hitter+ere there, too Elliot SattlerD ..... de+0ite nu)erou+ rittenre/ue+t+ Aro) Coughlin that the 6C do +o, and )ulti0letri0+ to the 6C 0er+onall @ Coughlin to 0ic +uch)aterial+ u0, and de+0ite )ore Ali0 Alo00ing on their +tor @-e+lie and ogan regarding hether the ever gave Coughlin+o)e 0acage oA )aterial+ re+0on+ive to Coughlin+ re/ue+t
Aor hi+ JAileJ ... But, i) -e+lie i+ +tuc ith the 7>"7>1" datehe )ention+ in hi+ e)ail, then he i+ +tuc ith hat hi+ recente)ail herein he 0ur0ort+ to have therein digitall tran+)ittedCoughlin hi+ JAileJ, hich o@viou+l doe+ not include the cd+oA 911 call+ the one+ 8oung too u0 an enor)ou+a)ount oA court ti)e 0laing, over and over ell, 8oungonl 0laed over and over the 0articular call+ he Aelt ere+tronge+t Aor hi+ ca+e and )o+t 0reHudicial, clai)ing +o)eJcutting roo) Aloor )i+ha0J Aor the reoccurrence oA certaincall+, arguing that +uch a Jha00 accidentJ Hu+tiAied 0laingthe) again and again, at ever increa+ing volu)e+, etc., etc.D.
00arentl, a) here to +u@+idiIe 8oung+ @a@ )aing, Hu+tlie a+ ith
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
46/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
e%i+tence. 6hat, +ir, +hall @e ) co)0en+ation o ou )indiA 0ut ) ar) around .... htt0:>>tinurl.co)>@g)lAdr
#hi+ i+ a Aor)al grievance again+t ogan, -e+lie, Bo+ler,8oung ... etc....G
#he lin that -e+lie reAer+ to a+ containing a Fvideo cli0 Aro)the )ovie "ape 'earG actuall contain+ onl an audiocli0 oA a +hort/uote Aro) Ca0e $ear the 1991 Scor+e+e ver+ionD.
#2ERE RE N
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
47/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
co)0laint+ a@out and reAerence+ to )e and other attorne+ in ouroAAice.
t the end oA the Air+t 0aragra0h oA the e)ail. 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
48/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
aived atto)e*c1ient conAidentialit. dditionall, @a+ed u0on%e nre o %e reerences)ade in the Air+t 0aragra0h oA thee)ail to
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
49/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
concern that he )ight get 0h+icall violent. He le %e $#ildin*$eore %e "olice &rri'ed.
As & res#l o %e e!&iland the encounter ith 3" ?noing 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
50/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
door closin* %econtinued his ranttoard i) -e+lieuntil thedoor closed, Evo NovaG
-e+lie+ #5 00lication in 1"*!99 +ee)+ to clearl @e inretaliation Aor Coughlin Ailing a grievance SEE RC2R ;.2--, ESO., 1>14>1" ;REVNCE #5 #2E SBN ;NS#C5;2-N N R1";REVNCE #5 #2E SBN ;NS# C5;2-N, 62C2##C2E 3 8ER 5- SNC#5N 5RER #2#BEC1"
#o: ... Ioung(da.a+hoecount.u+, co)0laint+([email protected],0atric([email protected], davidc([email protected],...@dogan(a+hoecount.u+, Hle+lie(a+hoecount.u+
$ro): Zach Coughlin Iachcoughlin(hot)ail.co)D
Sent: #ue 1">'4>1" ":'7 '9>1" 11:4! < #o:Iachcoughlin(hot)ail.co) Cc: eannie 2o)er
2o)er(reno.govD 1 attach)ent 0hotoP1Q.; 11." ?BDear >1" hearing in rcr"'11*'&3341 reveal+ 13>1" 2earing and con+idering 11>1">1"
a+ a holida, Sau ould have @een 0revented Aro) eAAecting cont+tructive +ervice
0rior to the 11>13>1" hearing date +et...#hi+ 0reHudiced not onl Coughlin+ Aor)al
di+ci0linar hearing @ut al+o the 0ett larcen trial oA 11>19 and 11>"' and i+ a +traight
+cu) @ag )ove @ Creig Sau. udge SAerraIIa granted Coughlin a aiver oA itne++
Aee+ Aor +u@0oena+ and +u@0oena duce+ tecu)+ at the 4 )inute )ar oA the +econd
)v Aile Aro) the VS audio tran+cri0t oA the 1'>"">1" 2earing in RCR"'1"*
'&3341. Regardle++, Cit ttorne Sau not onl doe+nt no ho ere) Bo+ler,
E+/. i+, @ut he cite+ to a CRC 4! to challenge a +u@0oena in a cri)inal )i+de)eanorca+e and he Aail+ to inAor) the court oA the aiver oA +ervice +igned @ an individual
ho indicated +he had authorit to do +o, ;ricela lvareI ho), +o)eho, udge
SAerraIIa a+ a00arentl aare oA and had o0inion+ on....curiou+lD. S0eaing oA
+cu) @ag )ove+, %ere?s is 5i! Leslie )#!"in* in & %e K06 &! !&r on %e
11920912 )&'s recordin* 112012co#*%lin1 or rcr2011-06JJ=1 .re&lly, e'ery%in*
5i! Leslie did in %is c&se or &ny o%er in
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
52/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
51"*'1 goe+ on: F62ERES, ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N i+ currentl
a 0art in ca+e+ @eAore thi+ court= and
62ERES, cii;ens, (%e%er or no indi*en, %&'e & consi#ion&l ri*% o
&ccess o %e co#rs (i% %e "roecion o d#e "rocess o l&(= and
62ERES, Arivolou+ or ve%atiou+ clai)+ and deAen+e+ over@urden li)ited
Hudicial re+ource+, hinder the ti)el re+olution oA )eritoriou+ clai)+ and increa+e the co+t+
oA engaging in @u+ine++ and 0roviding 0roAe++ional +ervice+ to the 0u@lic= and
62ERES, ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N ha+ re"e&edly csed &
dis#r$&nce in
%e ilin* oice o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r, disr#"ed %e orderly $#siness o %e Co#r
&nd
o'er$#rdened %e li!ied )#dici&l reso#rce+ oA thi+ Court there@ hindering the ti)el
re+olution oA )eritoriou+ clai)+ and increa+ing the co+t+ oA engaging in @u+ine++ and
0roviding 0roAe++ional +ervice+ to the 0u@lic= and
62ERES, Ja @reach oA the 0eace, @oi+terou+ conduct or violent di+tur@ance in
the
0re+ence oA the court, or in it+ i))ediate vicinit, tending to interru0t the due cour+e oA
the trial or other Hudicial 0roceedingJ con+titute+ conte)0t oA court in the State oA Nevada=
and
62ERES, Jdi+o@edience or re+i+tance to &ny l&(#l (ri, order, r#le or
"rocess i++ued @ the court or Hudge at cha)@er+J con+titute+ conte)0t oA court in the
State oA Nevada= and F
3!>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
53/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Coughlin ha+ never Ailed anthing that a+ not @a+ed in @oth Aact and la. Richard
;. 2ill, E+/., and Ca+e Baer, E+/., are good at )aing it +ea) otheri+e, at lea+t Aro) a
di+tance:
not longer and eAiler, @ut a+ @eteen 1>4>1" until deactivation in)id Nove)@er oA "'1". ll during that ti)e the onl 0dA availa@leAor the 1>4>1" Su00le)ental in CV11*'3&" a+ the attached 3 0age ver+ion, hichAail+ to include the actual docu)ent+ or Ailing+ li+ted in the J00eal Recei0tJ. Such aAailure to include tho+e Ailed, e+0eciall one that i+ characteriIed a+ JE)ergenc -etterto Court Aro) Zach Coughlin, E+/J hich i+ not a JletterJ @ut rather ) +u@)i++ionAor Ailing oA a JNotice oA 00ealJ oA the 1">"1>11 5rder Re+olving 3'>1"5rder dening ) a00eal, and no, argua@l in the 1">14>1" $inding+ andConclu+ion+ and Reco))endation to di+@ar )e 0er)anentl Aro) the 0ractice oA lain Nevada incident to o00o+ing coun+el 2ill+ allegation that ) 0ur+uing a +ta, on oraround ece)@er ""nd "'11, under NRS 4'.3! a+ ve%atiou+ or otheri+e violativeoA RC 3.1 1" 5rder in CV11*'3&" indicate+:J... In &ddiion, $ecse Co#*%lin &iled o i!ely ile %is noice o &""e&lre*&rdin* %e "erson&l "ro"ery lien, see NRS =02:J.G/, &nd $ecse Co#*%lin?s
noice o &""e&l &ils o ideniy &n error re*&rdin* %e co#r?s "roced#re in
sein* & %e&rin* on %is iss#e, %is Co#r (ill no consider %is iss#e.J
#he te+ti)on at Coughlin+ Aor)al di+ci0linar hearing on 11>14>1" included theAolloing:J$5R
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
54/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
13 an attorne, a+ he truthAul or did he +ho candor in hi+14 dealing+ ith ou a+ a laer1!
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
55/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
9 truthAul, and did he u+e candor ith ou1' No.11
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
56/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
a. u+tice Court or attend a hearing in the Reno u+tice Court he )u+t notiA the
+ecurit 0er+onnel 0age "D at the )ain +ecurit entrance located at the ea+t entrance oA
5ne South Sierra Street and ait Aor a @ailiAA oA the Reno Hu+tice Court to re+0ond to hi+
location.
@. A ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N i+he+ to )ae a re/ue+t oA the Reno
u+tice Court Aor co0ie+, tran+cri0t+, acce++ to a court Aile or to a+ a /ue+tion %e s%&ll do
so in (riin* &nd ei%er !&il %e re8#es o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r or deli'er %e
(rien re8#es o & $&ili o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r $y irs con&cin* %e $&ili
%ro#*% co#r sec#riy &s de&iled &$o'e. #he @ailiAA ill then Aile the docu)ent Aor
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
57/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
!. n violation oA thi+ 5rder )a @e con+idered conte)0t oA court and 0uni+hed
0ur+uant to NRS Cha0ter "" @ a Aine oA u0 to !'' and>or incarceration Aor u0 to "! da+
in the 6a+hoe Count etention $acilit.
&. #hi+ 5rder is eeci'e #"on "erson&l ser'iceu0on 13 5SC in 51"*'1 related to FcallingG BailiAA+:
F5n anuar 7, "'13 N5#E: Coughlin ha+ a hearing +et Aor RCR "'1"*'&79' on
1>7>13, +hortl aAter hi+ 0reviou+ attorne oA record, 6C i) -e+lie, a+ granted an
5rder alloign hi) to +uddenl ithdraal on 1">1>1", at a hearing Aor hich Couglin
a+ 0rovided in+uAAicient notice and little to no o00ortunit to @e heard, leaving Coughlin
uncertain a+ to ho) hi+ attorne ould @e iA an, and hether the hearing a+ +till to
occur, in addition to the RC a00arentl changing the +tart ti)e+ oA +uch hearing+ u0on the
calendar ear changing...it+ a+ at the RC that )orning u0on Coughlin a00earing Aor
+uch hearing that Coughlin )et
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
58/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
i)0ortant or related inve+tigator +ort oA )atterD Co#*%lin ele"%oned %ree
e!"loyees o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r & %e Co#r?s "%one n#!$er.G
#he ">"!>13 5SC Aail+ to identiA +uch e)0loee+ or +0eciA h the @elieve +uch
to @e true, hether an +uch co))unication a+ oA a de )ini)i+ or e)ergenc nature or
otheri+e +uAAicientl Hu+tiAia@le, and or hether +uch caller re/ue+ted to @e tran+Aerred to
the BailiAA+ u0on @eing una@le to locate the BailiAA+ nu)@er hich i+ not a+ readil
acce+i@le a+ other RC nu)@er+ u0on conducting a ;oogle SearchD.
#he ">"!>13 5rder read+, in relevant 0art: F5n anuar 7, "'13 Coughlin a+
inAor)ed @ a uniAor)ed @ailiAA oA thi+ Court that he a+ not to have an contact ith an
e)0loee oA the Court other than uniAor)ed @ailiAA+ and %e (&s "ro'ided %e ele"%one
n#!$er or %e $&ilis s&ion.GD here there i+ a00arent contradiction in the dictate
that Couglhin +hall: Fdo so in (riin* &nd ei%er !&il %e re8#es o %e Reno 5#sice
Co#r or deli'er %e (rien re8#es o & $&ili o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r $y irs
con&cin* %e $&ili %ro#*% co#r sec#riy &s de&iled &$o'eG hen vieed in
co)0ari+ion to the +u@+e/uent 0a++age: is no &llo(ed o con&c &ny !e!$er o %is
Co#r o%er %&n & #nior!ed $&ili :
F@. A ZC2R8 BR?ER C5;2-N i+he+ to )ae are/ue+t oA the Reno u+tice Court Aor co0ie+, tran+cri0t+, acce++to a court Aile or to a+ a /ue+tion he +hall do so in (riin* &ndei%er !&il %e re8#es o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r or deli'er
%e (rien re8#es o & $&ili o %e Reno 5#sice Co#r $y
irs con&cin* %e $&ili %ro#*% co#r sec#riy &s de&iled&$o'e. #he @ailiAA ill then Aile the docu)ent Aor 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
59/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
6hile not ad)itting to an alleged violation oA 51"*'1, and not aiving an oA
hi+ argu)ent+ a+ to the in+uAAicienc oA +ervice oA 0roce++ thereoA, lac oA Huri+diction to
+o order +uch, a00arent de minimis nature oA an +uch violation+, and in+uAAicienc oA
notice oA the 3>!>13 2earing in 51"*'1, and lac oA due 0roce++ or o00ortunit to @e
heard and or 0re0are, 0ur+ue a deAen+e, +u@0oena itne++e+, etc., attendant to the lac oA
+0eciAict in the +0ar+e Aactual allegation+ contained in the ">"!>13 5rder to Sho Cau+e
in 51"*'1, etc., in addition to that Aailure oA +uch to )eet the NRS "".'3'"D
re/uire)ent Aor an AAidavit Aor +uch alleged conduct a00arentl occurring out+ide the
Court+ 0re+ence, in addition to the n Re StuhAA 0recedent hich hold+ that Aor FconductG
to @e Fdi+r0utiveG it )u+t occur inside a courtroo), hile court i+ in +e++ion. T%e
disr#"ion !#s %&'e occ#rred in %e co#rroo!. 5ne c&nnodi+ru0t a tri@unal ith
conduct o#sideoA the courtroo). n re 1" 51"*'1 it+elA i+ liel void in that it de0rived Coughlin oA a
0rotected $ourteenth )end)ent right to acce++ court+, to 0ut on a deAen+e, to +u@0oena
itne++e+, to conAront hi+ accu+er+ under the Si%th )end)ent, al+oD here it 0rovided no
notice or o00ortunit to @e heard a+ to the variou+ a00arent Aactual Ainding+ )ade therein
the 0art+ a@out the alleged conte)0t 5rder+ @ R13 5SC a00ear+ to )ateriall de0art Aor) the 1">"'>1" 51"*'1 here it +ee)+ to
4">7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
60/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
allo Aor an alleged ver@al indication @ an RC BailiAA to alter +uch order to then allo
Aor Coughlin to call the RC BailiAA+ on the tele0hone.
Regardle++, Coughlin reall i+he+ to re+olve all oA thi+, )ean+ a@+olutel no
di+re+0ect to the RC, it+ udge+, BailiAA+, or Court er+onnel, and i+ re+olved in i)0rove
hi+ aAAect and @ehavior and continuing 0ur+uing +uch goal+, @ 0artici0ating in NN2"!>13 5rder Aail+ to identiA hich FHudge oA the court in ho+e conte)0t
the 0er+on i+ alleged to @eG, and thereAore, 0revent+ an AulAill)ent oA the right+ accorded
under NRS "".'3'3D.
Current ChieA udge ear+on+ ">"!>13 5rder to Sho Cau+e it it @elieve that the
RC ill a++ert that 5SC a+ 0er+onall +erved on Coughlin u0on Coughlin 0re+enting to
the +ecurit chec*in on 6edne+da, ">">13, 0lea+e incor0orate @ reAerence herein the
43>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
61/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
authorit +et out in Coughlin+ recent e)ail to the 6C+ 5AAice and 13 5SC in 51"*'1
include+ a+ one oA the date+ herein Coughlin i+ alleged to have violated the 51"*'1
F5n 4e$r#&ry :, 201JCoughlin contacted to e)0loee+ ho are not @ailiAA+ at a
nu)@er other than that 0rovided to hi) a+ the @ailiAA + +tation. t age ". t i+ 0o++i@le
that +o)eone in/uired ith the RC on that ">!>13 date a+ to hether an +uch hearing in
11*'&3341 a+ +till on calendar and that an RC e)0loee, ho) mayhave @een a
BailiAA, indicated that +uch ">!>13 2earing in 11*'&3341 a+, in Aact, not +till on calendar,
@ut, rather, had @een incorrectl li+ted on Coughlin 6C ail n)ate Relea+e nAor)ation
0a0eror here +uch 2earing a+ actuall +et Aor, and did, in Aact tae 0lace on, ">">13
at :3' a). 6hether no it i+ the ca+e that the RC udge+ intended the ">">13 2earing
to @e a ;agnon +tle hearing and +uch 2earing indentiAied in Coughlin+ 6C ail n)ate
Relea+e nAor)ation 0a0eror to @e a F;agnon G t0e oA 2earing i+ 0o++i@le. t )a
@e 0o++i@le that an RC e)0loee, ho) may have @een a BailiAA, @ut, ho) may alsonot
have @een a BailiAA incorrectl indicated to +o)eone ho) )a have in/uired ith the
44>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
62/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
RC ith regard to hether +uch ">!>13 2earing in 11*'&3341 a+ +till on calendar that
+uch 2earing a+ not +till on calendar oA +et to tae 0lace, @ut had, in Aact, @een vacated.D
#he ">"!>13 5SC in 51"*'1 read+:
F5n anuar "3, "'13 Coughlin contacted an e)0loee other than a uniAor)ed
@ailiAA at a nu)@er other than that 0rovided to hi) a+ the @ailiAA + +tation.G
#o have an o00ortunit to deAender hi)+elA, Coughlin ha+ a right to @e aAAorded a
)ore detailed allegation and notice oA the Aactual a++ertion+ thereto, Aor di+cover 0ur0o+e+
and otheri+e. + +uch a continuance oA thi+ 3>!>13 Sho Cau+e hearing ould @e
a00ro0riate and i+ re/ue+ted, e+0eciall given the )ateriall negative con+e/uence to
Coughlin+ la licen+e and )ental health recu0eration eAAort+ that a +u))ar incarceration
here ould re+ult in 0lea+e +ee N. S. Ct. ca+e &"337, the a00eal oA the di+@ar)ent and
0re++ing a00eal @rieA deadline, e+0eciall con+idering the Fitchen +inG +tle 0leading
a00roach in the >"3>1" Co)0laint @ @ar coun+el 1" RC+ alleged violated an
unenu)erated nu)@er oA ti)e+, +0eciAied onl @ a +cant, +0ar+e ! 0age co)0laint that
Aail+ to identiA hich Aactual a++ertion+ therein relate to hich RC alleged violatedD.
ChieA u+tice icering+ ">7>13 5rder +triing the SBN+ R5 i+ in+tructive a+ to Bar
Coun+el ?ing and Cler -aura eter+ le++ than one ear e%0erience in their 0o+ition+, and
RC"'1"*''&'7 and +o)e oA the Aallout ancillar to the )anner in hich the 0ro+ecuted
Coughlin ha+ had collateral con+e/uence+ to local Court+, attorne+, 0u@lic deAender+, and
our Bar and Bench a+ a hole. No@od+ 0erAect, @ut +ee)ingl onl Coughlin i+
o0erating here ithout the @eneAit oA i))unit.
4!>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
63/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
F5n $e@ruar 11, "'13 on to +e0arate occa+ion+ Coughlin contacted an e)0loee
other than a uniAor)ed @ailiAA at a nu)@er other than that 0rovided to hi) a+ the @ailiAA+
+tation.G read the 51"*'1:
Coughlin had a continuation oA hi+ #rial in RCR"'1"*'&!&3' on ">1">13. #he
+tart ti)e+ oA hearing+ in the RC ha+ changed ith the calendar ear changing, leading to
+o)e conAu+ion. #he a@ove allegaiton lac+ +0eciAicit a+ al+o alleged +u0ra ith regard
to other +i)ilar Aactual allegation+.
@I Co#*%lin is indi*en &nd (is%es o &""ly or co#r &""oined co#nsel %e
!#s ill o# %e "ro"er "&"er(or $y #ili;in* %e "roced#res se or% in
Ad!inisr&i'e Order 2012-01 $eore =00 "! on 4e$r#&ry 2G, 201J .G
Coughlin 0re+ented a Ailing to court +ecurit 0rior to 4:'' 0) re+0on+ive to the
a@ove, +u00le)enting it on 3>1>13, and ha+ et to hear hether he ill @e aAAorded coun+el
0ur+uant to the Si%th )end)ent, and hi+ indigenc, and a++ Hudicial notice @e taen oA
the 1>9>13 $ 5rder in CR1"*"'"!, and the +a)e in RC RCR"'1"*'&!&3'.
RC ChieA udge ear+on entered hi+ ">"!>13 Sho Cau+e 5rder +etting Aor
hearing +uch )atter on 3>!>13, @a+ed u0on +o)e un+orn, unattri@uted, allegation+ that
Coughlin had )ade variou+ Fcontact+G ith non*RC BailiAA 0er+onnel, though the
co)0lete lac oA +0eciAicit, the violation oA the re/uire)ent Aor +uch out oA the 0re+ence
oA the court alleged conduct con+tituting conte)0t under NRS "".'3'3D, and the general
lac oA notice a+ to the charge+ again+t hi) hat did +uch contact+ entail 6ho e%actl
ould the itne++e+ oA +uch contact+ @e 2o can Coughlin +u@0oena the) ithout
+uAAicientl detailed notice thereoA 6h i+ Couglhin not aAAorded at lea+t the 1' Hudicial
4&>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
64/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
da+ +ee)ingl re/uired to 0re0are Aor an +uch Sho Cau+e 2earing. + not the
0ur0orted +ervice oA +uch Sho Cau+e 5rder incident to Coughlin checign in ith S
in+uAAicient +ervice oA 0roce++ Aor the +a)e rea+on+ other +uch +ervice atte)0t+ in 1"*&'7,
1"*!99, RC 5 1"*'1, etc., +hould Aail o not the #5+ and E5+ in 1"*&'7 and 1"*
!99, and 51"*'1 e%ceed the Huri+diction to )ae +uch order+ here the i)0inge u0on
Coughlin+ Air+t )end)ent Right+ and right+ a+ a litigatin in hi+ Aor)al di+ci0linar
hearing and the a00eal thereoA, and here +uch order+ are in no a rea+ona@l or
narrol tailore to achieve the 0ur0orted +aAet goal+ to hich the addre++
Coughlin ha+ )ade diligent eAAort+ to co)0l ith all 5rder+ oA the RC, and
hu)@l a++ thi+ Court grant a continuance here, i++ue and 5rder Aor a Co)0etenc
Evaluation, or )ae a Ainding that good cau+e i+ not 0re+ent to hold Coughlin in conte)0t>
From:Zach Coughlin
To:Robert Lindsay ; "[email protected]"
Sent:#ednesday$ %ebruary &'$ &()* +,)- /
Subject:!ro!osal that might be your o00ice some more money and resole this whole thing.
ear 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
65/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
re+0ectAull +u@)it thi+ in the ho0e+ that a glo@al deal can @e entered into, a+ ithoutthat, ill certainl @e di+@arred irrevoca@l, and udge CliAton and udge ear+on, a) 0rett +ure, ill @e +entencing )e to +u@+tantial a)ount+ oA Hail ti)e, in addition tohat )a i++ue incident to the 3>&>13 arraign)ent on allegation+ oA violating the SBN#5>E5 and the 1"*'1 d)ini+trative 5rder @ udge SAerraIIa. t ould )ean +o
)uch to )e and @e +o ver a00reciated. lived here ) hole liAe, it+ ould @e0rett +ad to +ee thing+ continue here the are going ie, )e di+@arred 0er)anentl,doing lot+ oA ti)e, etc...D. realiIe a) not +0ecial and havent handled thing+ verell in )an in+tance+, @ut, a) doing ) @e+t, and have @een. dont get hel0 Aro)) Aa)il, in Aact, ) ad oAten +ee)+ to @e tring to +a@otage ) liAe in +o)e)i+guided atte)0t to telve +te0 )e>hiHac ) )ental health care...
co)0lete ) intae ith Northern Nevada dult 13 to +ee a@outarranging Aor ) )edication+ to ala+ @e availa@le to )e iA cannot aAAord the)and thereAore, ho0eAull avoid the Aree Aall ) liAe had @een in +ince that occurredand a+ Aolloed @ a +tring oA arre+t+ and eviction+ +tarting in ugu+t "'11 0lea+e+ee ) e)ail to Bar Coun+el detailing that and attaching 0rooA thereoA ith )co)0lete 0re+cri0tion hi+tor +ince a@out "'', +hoing ent oAA dderall and6ell@utrin in earl ugu+t "'11...lea+e +ee ) !>14>1" e)ail to SBN Bar Coun+eldetailing the Aall out oA ) not @eing a@le to aAAord ) )edication+ +tarting in ugu+t"'11, the +tring oA arre+t+ and eviction occurring i))ediatel thereaAter, etc.
udge 6eller, udge "7>13 civil>ad)ini+trative thing+ )ight @e re+olved, iA a) ver, ver luc and Aortunate.
!>13 at " 0). See @oth the ">"!>13 Sho
4>7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
66/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Cau+e 5rder and the underling 1">"'>1" d)ini+trative 5rder 1"*'1 attached. @elieve a) +till an attorne, even here +u+0ended under $lorida Bar v. Ro++D and,a+ +uch, a) i))une Aro) +ervice oA +uch 0roce++ in addition to the +ervice oA 0roce++atte)0ted @ RC BailiAA+ during other S Chec in+ Aor the 6C and SBNrotection 5rder+ again+t )e in &'7 and !99.
attorne+ e%e)0tion Aro) +ervice oA 0roce++, +ee ). ur. "d, roce++ 3!. 6hile 6att+ )ade a nice argu)ent in o@Hecting to ) +u@0oena+ on "C 0er+onnelin ) Aor)al @ar hearing, @a+ed u0on ) @eing +u+0ending, @elieve $lorida Bar v.Ro++, the Aact that a+ given 0er)i++ion to i++ue ) on +u@0oena+ therein ie, eveniA NRC 4!aD3D a00lie+, a+ JauthoriIed to a00earJ in that JcourtJD ould 0rovidea counter to an e%ten+ion oA that argu)ent that ould +ugge+t that ) @eing+u+0ended @ the State Bar oA Nevada @ut not the S#5, thereAore, a) +till a0atent attorne, thin...D ould vitiate an Jattorne i))une Aro) +ervice oA 0roce++oA the #5>E5 a00lication+ or 5rder+ hile doing hi+ S 0ro@ation chec*in+ inthe RC Ailing oAAiceJargu)ent...#r to ea+e u0 on )e a little here, a) doing the @e+t can everone. too in a@out 13,'' in Aee+ hile 0racticing la @eteen ul"'11 and ) +u+0en+ion in une "'1", and lo+t a, )ore )one than that e+0eciallcounting the +anction+ aard+ that re)ain un0aid, etc.D...5ne co+t +aving )ea+ure tothe count ould @e to or out a deal ver +oon lie @eAore the 3>!>13 Sho Cau+e2earing in the RC, that ould avoid the 0re0aration oA a@out 1! hour+ oA trialtran+cri0t at 0u@lic e%0en+e incident to the 1>9>13 5rder @ udge Elliott in the a00ealoA the conviction in 11*'&3341 CR1"*"'"!D. ll +ign aa an civil la clai)+ have again+t an Count entitie+, 0er+onnel, etc., e+0eciall iA ) SBN oe+, RCcri)inal la oe+, and ho0eAull a thing or to el+e, can @e @argained aa iA that i+legal... thin it i+, @ut the 6C+ 5AAice ould need to a00rove oA it, @elieve...D.
. 7'C5
-
7/28/2019 4 9 13 0204 065630 Motion for New Trial, Arrest Judgement, And Correct Illegal Sentence Stamped Reduced a9
67/112
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Currentl, hether an attorne at la i+ e%e)0t Aro) the +ervice oA 0roce++ in a civilactionhile attending court )a turn u0on the attorne+ re+idence ithin the +tate or countoA+uit. ))unit Aro) the +ervice oA civil 0roce++ ha+ @een e%tended to a nonre+ident
attornehile going to, re)aining at, or returning Aro) the 0lace here the client+ @u+ine++ i+tran+acted,u0on the ground that the ad)ini+tration oA Hu+tice de)and+ +uch an e%e)0tion,P$N3Qeven though re+ident attorne+ have no +uch i))unit.P$N4QSo)e Huri+diction+ tae the vie that an attorne i+ 0rivileged Aro) the +ervice oA0roce++hile attending court in a 0roAe++ional ca0acit in a count other than the count oAhi+ or herre+idence,P$N!Q hile other+ hold that the attorne i+ not i))une Aro