7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

1/49

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

2/49

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF APPEAL,No. 4:10-cv-01564-CW

1

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

__________________________________________)

MICHAEL DRAGOVICH, et al., ) No. 4:10-cv-01564-CW)Plaintiffs, )

)

v. )

)U.S. DEPARTMENT OF THE TREASURY, )

et al., )

)Defendants, )

)

BIPARTISAN LEGAL ADVISORY GROUP )OF THE UNITED STATES HOUSE )

OF REPRESENTATIVES, )

)Intervenor-Defendant. )

__________________________________________)

Intervenor-Defendant the Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group of the United States House of

Representatives (House) respectfully gives notice that it appeals to the United States Court of

Appeals for the Ninth Circuit the District Courts May 24, 2012 Order (ECF No. 124) and final

Judgment (ECF No. 125), both insofar as they grant Plaintiffs motion for summary judgment

(ECF No. 111) and deny the Houses cross-motion for summary judgment (ECF No. 117).

Copies of the Order and Judgment appealed from are attached as Exhibits A and B, respectively.

The statutory basis for this appeal is 28 U.S.C. 1291. The House hereby notifies the

Clerk of the Court, pursuant to Ninth Circuit Rule 3-1, that it is exempt from submitting the

filing fee for this appeal.

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS

NOTICE OF APPEAL

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132 Filed06/26/12 Page2 of 4

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

3/49

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF APPEAL,No. 4:10-cv-01564-CW

2

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Respectfully submitted,

BANCROFT PLLC

/s/ H. Christopher Bartolomucci

H. Christopher Bartolomucci

1

Counsel for Intervenor-Defendant the Bipartisan

Legal Advisory Group of the U.S. House of

Representatives2

June 26, 2012

1 Kerry W. Kircher, as the ECF filer of this document, attests that concurrence in the

filing of the document has been obtained from signatory H. Christopher Bartolomucci.

2 The Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group, which speaks for the House in litigation matters,

is currently comprised of the Honorable John A. Boehner, Speaker of the House, the HonorableEric Cantor, Majority Leader, the Honorable Kevin McCarthy, Majority Whip, the Honorable

Nancy Pelosi, Democratic Leader, and the Honorable Steny H. Hoyer, Democratic Whip. The

Democratic Leader and the Democratic Whip decline to support the filing of this Notice ofAppeal.

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132 Filed06/26/12 Page3 of 4

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

4/49

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF APPEAL,No. 4:10-cv-01564-CW

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

2324

25

26

27

28

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I certify that on June 26, 2012, I served one copy of the foregoing Intervenor-Defendants

Notice of Appeal by CM/ECF on the following:

Claudia Center, Esquire

Elizabeth Kristen, Esquire

Shelley Ann Gregory, Esquire

The Legal Aid Society - Employment Law Center180 Montgomery Street, Suite 600

San Francisco, California 94104

Daniel Simon Mason, Esquire

Patrick Bradford Clayton, Esquire

Zelle Hofmann Voelbel Mason & Gette44 Montgomery Street, Suite 3400

San Francisco, California 94104

Lori Rifkin, Esquire

Rosen, Bien & Galvan, LLP

315 Montgomery Street, Tenth Floor

San Francisco, California 94104

Jean Lin, Trial AttorneyUS Department of Justice,

Civil Division,

Federal Programs Branch20 Massachusetts Avenue, Northwest

Washington, District of Columbia 20530

Edward George Gregory, Esquire

Jennifer Lynn Morrow, Esquire

Steptoe & Johnson LLP633 West Fifth Street, Suite 700

Los Angeles, California 90071

/s/ Kerry W. Kircher

Kerry W. Kircher

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132 Filed06/26/12 Page4 of 4

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

5/49

Exhibit A

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page1 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

6/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page2 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

7/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page3 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

8/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page4 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

9/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page5 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

10/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page6 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

11/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page7 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

12/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page8 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

13/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page9 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

14/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page10 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

15/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page11 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

16/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page12 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

17/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page13 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

18/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page14 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

19/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page15 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

20/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page16 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

21/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page17 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

22/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page18 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

23/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page19 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

24/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page20 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

25/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page21 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

26/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page22 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

27/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page23 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

28/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page24 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

29/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page25 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

30/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page26 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

31/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page27 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

32/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page28 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

33/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page29 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

34/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page30 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

35/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page31 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

36/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page32 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

37/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page33 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

38/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page34 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

39/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page35 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

40/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page36 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

41/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page37 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

42/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page38 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

43/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page39 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

44/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page40 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

45/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page41 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

46/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-1 Filed06/26/12 Page42 of 42

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

47/49

Exhibit B

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-2 Filed06/26/12 Page1 of 3

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

48/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-2 Filed06/26/12 Page2 of 3

7/31/2019 4:10-cv-01564 #132

49/49

Case4:10-cv-01564-CW Document132-2 Filed06/26/12 Page3 of 3