4118 srm introductory

Upload: sidharth-ray

Post on 10-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    1/27

    SCIENCE AND SCIENTIFICSCIENCE AND SCIENTIFIC

    RESEARCHRESEARCH-- An IntroductionAn Introduction

    To understand science and scientificTo understand science and scientific

    approach one must understand the scientificapproach one must understand the scientificlanguages and the approach the scientists use.languages and the approach the scientists use.

    For Example: Economic Development,For Example: Economic Development,

    Independent and Dependent variable,Independent and Dependent variable,

    Randomization , Stratification, Parameter andRandomization , Stratification, Parameter and

    Statistics, Scaling of Attributes etc.Statistics, Scaling of Attributes etc.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    2/27

    Commonsense and scientific approachCommonsense and scientific approach

    A common man and the scientist both fix upA common man and the scientist both fix up

    beliefs and test hypotheses relating to behaviorbeliefs and test hypotheses relating to behavior

    of phenomena: Consider the following:of phenomena: Consider the following:

    Women are more religious than men in IndiaWomen are more religious than men in India

    Advertisement should have gender consideration forAdvertisement should have gender consideration for

    better impact.better impact.

    People from a caste or ethnic group are enterprising.People from a caste or ethnic group are enterprising.

    Investment in company X is profitable.Investment in company X is profitable.

    Sales and advertizing expenditures are +Sales and advertizing expenditures are +lyly relatedrelated

    These could be beliefs based on commonsense.These could be beliefs based on commonsense.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    3/27

    ButScience and commonsense differ in aButScience and commonsense differ in a

    variety of ways in fixing beliefs.variety of ways in fixing beliefs.

    Commonsense observes and relatesCommonsense observes and relates

    variables in an unsystematic i.e.variables in an unsystematic i.e.

    unorganized & unplanned way.unorganized & unplanned way.It often generalizes behavior ofIt often generalizes behavior of

    phenomena in an uncontrolled way.phenomena in an uncontrolled way.

    It tests hypotheses in a selective wayIt tests hypotheses in a selective way i.ei.e .it.it

    selects evidences and gives explanationselects evidences and gives explanation

    simply because it is consistent with hissimply because it is consistent with his

    hypothesis.hypothesis.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    4/27

    The Scientist's approach is different.The Scientist's approach is different.

    Scientific approach is a systematically builtScientific approach is a systematically built

    theoretical structure ( with a structured designtheoretical structure ( with a structured design

    and a plan of investigation).and a plan of investigation).

    It tests beliefs/theories empirically and in aIt tests beliefs/theories empirically and in a

    controlled condition, where ever necessary.controlled condition, where ever necessary.

    A scientist knowing the selection tendency to beA scientist knowing the selection tendency to be

    a common psychological phenomenon, carefullya common psychological phenomenon, carefullyguards his research against his ownguards his research against his own

    preconception and predilections (liking).preconception and predilections (liking).

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    5/27

    The Scientist's approachThe Scientist's approach

    Obvious relationshipsObvious relationships are empiricallyare empirically

    tested and established. e.g.tested and established. e.g.

    Demand is inversely related to price. AdvertisingDemand is inversely related to price. Advertisingexpenditure & sale volume are positively related,expenditure & sale volume are positively related,

    brand loyalty & economic status are relatedbrand loyalty & economic status are related

    Metaphysical explanations are ruled out inMetaphysical explanations are ruled out in

    scientific approach which lack empirical support.scientific approach which lack empirical support.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    6/27

    Methods of fixing belief or generalizingMethods of fixing belief or generalizing

    behavior of phenomenabehavior of phenomena

    Method of Tenacity.Method of Tenacity.

    Holding a belief since " people believe it to be true"Holding a belief since " people believe it to be true"

    -- Not trying to negateNot trying to negate

    Method of authority:Method of authority:

    If religious book says it to be trueIf religious book says it to be true

    If a physicist of repute says it to be trueIf a physicist of repute says it to be true

    A priori method or Method of intuitionA priori method or Method of intuition

    Beliefs/relationships between variables based onBeliefs/relationships between variables based on

    reasons or a priori argument.reasons or a priori argument.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    7/27

    Methods for fixing belief..Methods for fixing belief..ContdContd

    Method of Science:Method of Science:

    Fixing beliefs is based on built in checks, selfFixing beliefs is based on built in checks, self

    correction all along the way of highlightingcorrection all along the way of highlighting

    behavior and analysis of relationship betweenbehavior and analysis of relationship between

    phenomena.phenomena.

    In doing so, one goes outside himself, hisIn doing so, one goes outside himself, his

    tradition & authority ,his beliefs biases, valuestradition & authority ,his beliefs biases, valuesattitude and emotions.attitude and emotions.

    Subjective beliefs are checked against objectiveSubjective beliefs are checked against objective

    reality.reality.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    8/27

    SCIENTIFIC RESEARCHSCIENTIFIC RESEARCH

    -- A DEFINITIONA DEFINITION

    SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IS DEFINEDSCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IS DEFINEDAS AAS A SYSTEMATIC, CONTROLLED,SYSTEMATIC, CONTROLLED,EMPIRICAL AND CRITICALEMPIRICAL AND CRITICAL

    INVESTIGATIONINVESTIGATION OF HYPOTHETICALOF HYPOTHETICALPROPOSITIONS ABOUT PRESUMEDPROPOSITIONS ABOUT PRESUMEDRELATIONS AMONGST OBSERVEDRELATIONS AMONGST OBSERVEDPHENOMENA.PHENOMENA.

    SUBJECTIVE BELIEFS ARE CHECKEDSUBJECTIVE BELIEFS ARE CHECKEDAGAINST OBJECTIVE REALITYAGAINST OBJECTIVE REALITY

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    9/27

    Aim of Scientific ResearchAim of Scientific Research

    Aim of scientific research is basicallyAim of scientific research is basically

    theorizing thetheorizing the behaviourbehaviour/relationship/relationship

    between variables/phenomena.between variables/phenomena.

    Scientific Research establishes generalScientific Research establishes general

    laws covering the behavior of empiricallaws covering the behavior of empirical

    events and enables us to connect togetherevents and enables us to connect together

    our knowledge of separately known eventsour knowledge of separately known eventsor explain the relationship betweenor explain the relationship between

    variables and make reliable predictions.variables and make reliable predictions.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    10/27

    SCIENTIFIC STATUS OF A SCIENCESCIENTIFIC STATUS OF A SCIENCE

    IT DEPENDS ON THE DEGREE ANDIT DEPENDS ON THE DEGREE AND

    ACCURACY OF THE FOUR ASPECTSACCURACY OF THE FOUR ASPECTS

    MENTIONED IN THE DEFINITION OFMENTIONED IN THE DEFINITION OF

    SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.

    THIS FIXES UP LIMITS WITH RESPECT TOTHIS FIXES UP LIMITS WITH RESPECT TO

    PHYSICAL SCIENCES AND SOCIALPHYSICAL SCIENCES AND SOCIAL

    SCIENCES (EXACT AND INEXACTSCIENCES (EXACT AND INEXACT

    SCIENCES).SCIENCES).

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    11/27

    SESSION IISESSION II

    SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IN SOCIAL SCIENCESSCIENTIFIC RESEARCH IN SOCIAL SCIENCES

    IN SOCIAL SCIENCE WE STUDY THEIN SOCIAL SCIENCE WE STUDY THE

    BEHAVIOUR OF SOCIAL PHENOMENA.BEHAVIOUR OF SOCIAL PHENOMENA.

    QUESTIONS ARISES HERE IS CAN HUMANQUESTIONS ARISES HERE IS CAN HUMAN

    BEHAVIOR BE SUBJECTED TO SCIENTIFICBEHAVIOR BE SUBJECTED TO SCIENTIFICENQUIRY ?ENQUIRY ?

    THE ANSWER TO THIS DEPENDS ON THETHE ANSWER TO THIS DEPENDS ON THE

    DEGREE OF THE FOUR ASPECTSDEGREE OF THE FOUR ASPECTSMENTIONED IN THE DEFINITION OFMENTIONED IN THE DEFINITION OF

    SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    12/27

    STATUS OF SOCIAL SCIENCESTATUS OF SOCIAL SCIENCE

    FOR THIS WE MAY EXMINE THE SEVERALFOR THIS WE MAY EXMINE THE SEVERAL

    SIMILARITIES AND DISSIMILARITIESSIMILARITIES AND DISSIMILARITIES

    BETWEEN SOCIAL SCIENCES ANDBETWEEN SOCIAL SCIENCES AND

    PHYSICAL/NARURAL SCIENCES WITHPHYSICAL/NARURAL SCIENCES WITHSPECIAL REFERENCE TO CONDUCTINGSPECIAL REFERENCE TO CONDUCTING

    RESEARCH IN THESE SCIENCESRESEARCH IN THESE SCIENCES

    THUS, THE CHARACIERISTICS OF SOCIALTHUS, THE CHARACIERISTICS OF SOCIAL

    SCIENCES MAY BE HIGHLIGHTEDSCIENCES MAY BE HIGHLIGHTED

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    13/27

    1. SOCIAL SCIENTISTS LIKE THE PHYSICAL

    SCIENTISTS SEEK TO DISCOVER REGULARITY AND

    ORDER IN SOCIAL BEHAVIOR

    THIS IS DONE THROUGHTHIS IS DONE THROUGH

    ii)) OBSERVATION AND MEASUREMENTOBSERVATION AND MEASUREMENT OF SOCIALOF SOCIAL

    BEHAVIOUR / VARIABLES.BEHAVIOUR / VARIABLES.QUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE VARIABLESQUALITATIVE AND QUANTITATIVE VARIABLES

    COULD BE MEASUREDCOULD BE MEASURED

    A SYSTEMATIC MEASUREMENT MUST BE JUDGEDA SYSTEMATIC MEASUREMENT MUST BE JUDGED

    ON THE BASIS OF ITS UTILITY RATHER THANON THE BASIS OF ITS UTILITY RATHER THANABSOLUTE TRUTH IN SOCIAL SCIENCES.ABSOLUTE TRUTH IN SOCIAL SCIENCES.

    e.g. Intelligence, brand loyalty etce.g. Intelligence, brand loyalty etc

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    14/27

    ii) DISCOVERING REGULARITIESii) DISCOVERING REGULARITIES

    AND FRAMING THEORIES IN SOCIAL SIENCES.AND FRAMING THEORIES IN SOCIAL SIENCES.

    CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING REGULARITIES IN BOTH THECONSIDER THE FOLLOWING REGULARITIES IN BOTH THE

    SCIENCES.SCIENCES.

    An object falling to earth, water flowing downstream,HAn object falling to earth, water flowing downstream,H22 O isO is

    water, application of fertilizer results in a good crop.water, application of fertilizer results in a good crop.

    Women are more religious than men, higher income houseWomen are more religious than men, higher income house

    holds have luxury cars/CD players etc., buying a share ofholds have luxury cars/CD players etc., buying a share of

    company X is profitable.company X is profitable.

    REGULARITIES IN SOCIAL SCIENCE REPRESENTREGULARITIES IN SOCIAL SCIENCE REPRESENT

    PROBABILISTIC PATTERN.PROBABILISTIC PATTERN.

    FIXES LIMITS FOR SUBJECTIVITY ANDFIXES LIMITS FOR SUBJECTIVITY AND

    OBJECTIVITYY(POSITIVISM) IN BOTH THE SCIENCESOBJECTIVITYY(POSITIVISM) IN BOTH THE SCIENCES

    PHYSICAL SCIENCES ARE MORE REGULAR THAN SOCIALPHYSICAL SCIENCES ARE MORE REGULAR THAN SOCIAL

    SCIENCES:SCIENCES:

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    15/27

    2. LOGICAL REASONING IN PHYSIACAL AND2. LOGICAL REASONING IN PHYSIACAL AND

    SOCIAL SCIENCES.SOCIAL SCIENCES.

    REASONING: DEDUCTIVE AND INDUCTIVEREASONING: DEDUCTIVE AND INDUCTIVE

    DEDUCTIVE REASONING IS A PROCESS FROM GENERALDEDUCTIVE REASONING IS A PROCESS FROM GENERAL

    PRINCIPLE TO SPECIFIC INSTANCES.PRINCIPLE TO SPECIFIC INSTANCES.

    INDUCTIVE REASONING IS A PROCESS FROM SPECIFICINDUCTIVE REASONING IS A PROCESS FROM SPECIFICOBSERVATIONS TO GENERAL PRINCIPLESOBSERVATIONS TO GENERAL PRINCIPLES

    DEDUCTIVE METHOD IS STRONGER IN HAVING THEORITICALDEDUCTIVE METHOD IS STRONGER IN HAVING THEORITICAL

    SUPPORT WHEREAS, INDUCTIVE METHOD IS STRONGER INSUPPORT WHEREAS, INDUCTIVE METHOD IS STRONGER IN

    EMPIRICAL SUPPORT.EMPIRICAL SUPPORT.

    A CYCLICAL PROCESS OF INDUCTION AND DEDUCTION AREA CYCLICAL PROCESS OF INDUCTION AND DEDUCTION ARE

    FOLLOWED IN BOTH THE CIENCES WITH RESPECT TOFOLLOWED IN BOTH THE CIENCES WITH RESPECT TO

    THEORISING BEHAVIOUR/PHENOMENA.THEORISING BEHAVIOUR/PHENOMENA.

    THEORIES ARE TESTED AND RESTATEDTHEORIES ARE TESTED AND RESTATED

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    16/27

    3.DETERMINISM IN SOCIAL SCIENCE3.DETERMINISM IN SOCIAL SCIENCE

    CONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PHENOMENACONSIDER THE FOLLOWING PHENOMENAIN THE ECONOMYIN THE ECONOMY..

    There is a steady growth of FDI in IndiaThere is a steady growth of FDI in India

    after 1990s, BSEafter 1990s, BSE sensexsensex is falling overis falling overthe last few months, cost of production ofthe last few months, cost of production ofX is increasing, increase in advX is increasing, increase in advexpenditure has not resulted in increase inexpenditure has not resulted in increase in

    the market share of a product, price rise ofthe market share of a product, price rise ofcar over the last few years has not beencar over the last few years has not beenassociated with a decline in demand etc.associated with a decline in demand etc.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    17/27

    NOTHING JUST HAPPENS. ALL EVENTS HAVENOTHING JUST HAPPENS. ALL EVENTS HAVE

    ANTECEDENT CAUSES ORANTECEDENT CAUSES ORA PRIORIA PRIORI

    REASONSREASONS(THE THEORY OF CAUSATION(THE THEORY OF CAUSATION ))THERE COULD BE SINGLE OR MULTIPLETHERE COULD BE SINGLE OR MULTIPLE

    CAUSES FOR ALL THE PHENOMENA.CAUSES FOR ALL THE PHENOMENA.

    VERY OFTEN THE CAUSES LEADING TOVERY OFTEN THE CAUSES LEADING TOTHE OCCURANCE OF AN EVENT/THE OCCURANCE OF AN EVENT/

    PHENOMENON ARE KNOWN ASPHENOMENON ARE KNOWN AS

    DETERMINANTS .DETERMINANTS .

    THERE IS A PROBABILISTIC DETERMINISMTHERE IS A PROBABILISTIC DETERMINISMIN THE BEHAVIOUR OF SOCIOEIN THE BEHAVIOUR OF SOCIOE--CONOMICCONOMIC

    PHENOMENA.PHENOMENA.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    18/27

    4. GENERALISATION4. GENERALISATION

    A SOCIAL SCIENTIST BEGINS TO EXPLAIN AA SOCIAL SCIENTIST BEGINS TO EXPLAIN ALIMITED RANGE OF SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR ORLIMITED RANGE OF SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR ORBEHAVIOUR OF A LIMITED SUBBEHAVIOUR OF A LIMITED SUB--SET OFSET OFPOPULATION AND THEN NORMALLYPOPULATION AND THEN NORMALLY

    EXPANDS HIS FINDINGS TO EXPLAIN THEEXPANDS HIS FINDINGS TO EXPLAIN THEBEHAVIOUR OF OTHER SUBBEHAVIOUR OF OTHER SUB--SETS (i.e. S/heSETS (i.e. S/hegeneralizes the behavior of variables )generalizes the behavior of variables )

    THE PROCESS OF INDUCTION IS USEFUL INTHE PROCESS OF INDUCTION IS USEFUL INGENERALIZATION, BUT THE SCIENTIST ISGENERALIZATION, BUT THE SCIENTIST ISNOT INTERESTED IN SPECIFICNOT INTERESTED IN SPECIFICOBSERVATIONOBSERVATION

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    19/27

    For example:For example:

    A RESEARCHER IS LESS INTERESTED IN THEA RESEARCHER IS LESS INTERESTED IN THEINDIVIDUAL RESPONSE TO A PRICE CHANGE;INDIVIDUAL RESPONSE TO A PRICE CHANGE;RATHER HE IS INTERESTED IN THE GENERALRATHER HE IS INTERESTED IN THE GENERALBEHAVIOUR OF THE CONSUMERS.BEHAVIOUR OF THE CONSUMERS.

    A DISCOVERY OF A CERTAIN BEHAVIOUR OF AA DISCOVERY OF A CERTAIN BEHAVIOUR OF AGROUP OF PEOPLE IS LESS USEFUL THAN THATGROUP OF PEOPLE IS LESS USEFUL THAN THATHAS UNIVERSAL APPLICATION.HAS UNIVERSAL APPLICATION.

    HOWEVER, GENERALISATION IN SOCIAL SCIENCE ISHOWEVER, GENERALISATION IN SOCIAL SCIENCE IS

    RELATED TO PROBABILISTIC DETERMINISM.RELATED TO PROBABILISTIC DETERMINISM.

    Hypothesis testing with F & t statistics.Hypothesis testing with F & t statistics.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    20/27

    5. PARSIMONY5. PARSIMONY

    MULTIPLE CAUSATION SUGGESTS THATMULTIPLE CAUSATION SUGGESTS THATSOCIAL/ECONOMIC PHENOMENA ARE EXPLAINEDSOCIAL/ECONOMIC PHENOMENA ARE EXPLAINEDUSING MULTIVARIATE MODELS WHERE SEVERALUSING MULTIVARIATE MODELS WHERE SEVERALVARIABLES AREVARIABLES ARE USED.USED.

    ADDITIONAL VARIABLES INCREASEADDITIONAL VARIABLES INCREASEEXPLANATORY POWER OF A MODEL (IN AEXPLANATORY POWER OF A MODEL (IN ADEPENDENCY RELATIONSHIP), BUT IT ALSODEPENDENCY RELATIONSHIP), BUT IT ALSOCOMPLICATES THE RELATIONSHIP (MODEL) ANDCOMPLICATES THE RELATIONSHIP (MODEL) ANDMAKES ESTIMATION DIFFICULT.MAKES ESTIMATION DIFFICULT.

    USE OF MORE VARIABLES DECREASESUSE OF MORE VARIABLES DECREASES

    GENERALIZABILITY SINCE DIFFERENT VARIABLESGENERALIZABILITY SINCE DIFFERENT VARIABLESMAY HAVE DIFFERENT IMPACT ON DIFFERENTMAY HAVE DIFFERENT IMPACT ON DIFFERENTPOPULATION SUBPOPULATION SUB--SET.SET.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    21/27

    Consider the following:Consider the following:

    Expenditure of a H.H on a Commodity may depend onExpenditure of a H.H on a Commodity may depend on

    the following:the following:

    Income of the householdIncome of the household, Family members, Cost of, Family members, Cost of

    living, Standard of living,living, Standard of living, Price of the commodityPrice of the commodity,,Location of H.H.. Season, Attitude of a person,Location of H.H.. Season, Attitude of a person,

    Demonstration effect, Management of the house hold,Demonstration effect, Management of the house hold,

    Durability of the product,Durability of the product, Price of substitutePrice of substitute ,Cultural,Cultural

    back ground ,Proximity to market, Sex ration in theback ground ,Proximity to market, Sex ration in the h.hh.h..

    Media advertisement for the product, Price ofMedia advertisement for the product, Price ofcomplimentary goods. Quantity of consumption etc.complimentary goods. Quantity of consumption etc.

    etc.etc.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    22/27

    THUS, ONE HAS TO IDENTIFY THE MORE ORTHUS, ONE HAS TO IDENTIFY THE MORE OR

    LESS RELEVANT VARIABLES WITH ALESS RELEVANT VARIABLES WITH A

    PRIORI REASONING.PRIORI REASONING.

    A JUDICIOUS DECISION IS WARRANTED INA JUDICIOUS DECISION IS WARRANTED INEXPLAINING SOCIOEXPLAINING SOCIO--ECONOMICECONOMIC

    BEHAVIOUR.BEHAVIOUR.

    PARSIMONY IN SOCIAL SCIENCE REFERS TOPARSIMONY IN SOCIAL SCIENCE REFERS TOMORE UNDERSTANDING FROM LEASTMORE UNDERSTANDING FROM LEAST

    VARIABLESVARIABLES

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    23/27

    6.6. SPECIFICITYSPECIFICITYIT REFERS TO THE SPECIFICATION OF METHODS OFIT REFERS TO THE SPECIFICATION OF METHODS OF

    MEASUREMENT OF VARIABLESMEASUREMENT OF VARIABLES

    ConceptualisationConceptualisation of variables and use of proxyof variables and use of proxy

    variablesvariables

    Conceptualizing and measuring of variablesConceptualizing and measuring of variablesdiffers in physical and social sciences e.g.differs in physical and social sciences e.g.

    -- acceleration, force, gravitation.acceleration, force, gravitation.

    -- Industrialization, brand preference,Industrialization, brand preference,

    spendthriftnessspendthriftness, literacy, Intelligence., literacy, Intelligence.religiocityreligiocity etcetc

    We useWe use proxyvariablesproxyvariables in social sciencesin social sciences

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    24/27

    77.EMPIRICAL VERIFICATION.EMPIRICAL VERIFICATION

    FORMULATION OF GENERAL LAWS OR MODELSFORMULATION OF GENERAL LAWS OR MODELSARE NOT USEFUL UNLESS THEY CAN BE VERIFIEDARE NOT USEFUL UNLESS THEY CAN BE VERIFIEDTHROUGH COLLECTION AND MANUPULATION OFTHROUGH COLLECTION AND MANUPULATION OFDATA.DATA.

    EXPLANATION OF MODELS MUST MAKE SENSEEXPLANATION OF MODELS MUST MAKE SENSEAND THEY MUST CORRESPOND TO WHAT IS BEINGAND THEY MUST CORRESPOND TO WHAT IS BEINGACTUALLY STUDIED/OBSERVED. E.g.ACTUALLY STUDIED/OBSERVED. E.g.

    Personal Expenditure = f ( Income)Personal Expenditure = f ( Income)

    Brand Pref.= f (Awareness and Economic Status)Brand Pref.= f (Awareness and Economic Status)Economic Development = f (Industrialization)Economic Development = f (Industrialization)

    Relationship is meaningless unless variables areRelationship is meaningless unless variables arespecified and data could be collected on them.specified and data could be collected on them.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    25/27

    8. INTERSUBJECTIVITY8. INTERSUBJECTIVITY

    SUBJECTIVITY DIFFERES BETWEENSUBJECTIVITY DIFFERES BETWEENSOCIAL SCIENTISTS.SOCIAL SCIENTISTS.

    InterInter--subjectivity refers to situations in whichsubjectivity refers to situations in whichdifferent social scientists will arrive atdifferent social scientists will arrive at

    different conclusions using their own ideasdifferent conclusions using their own ideasand perceptions on variables and theirand perceptions on variables and theirrelationships. But when the study isrelationships. But when the study isreplicated using a reported design andreplicated using a reported design andmethodology the ideas may converge.methodology the ideas may converge.

    If it is not, then there is a paradigm shift orIf it is not, then there is a paradigm shift orchange in the theory.change in the theory.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    26/27

    9.OPENNESS TO MODIFICATIONS9.OPENNESS TO MODIFICATIONS

    PHYSICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES ARE OPEN TOPHYSICAL AND SOCIAL SCIENCES ARE OPEN TOCOUNTLESS MODIFICATION AND RESTATEMENTCOUNTLESS MODIFICATION AND RESTATEMENTOF THEORIES.OF THEORIES.

    THIS IS MORE TRUE WITH SOCIAL SCIENCE SINCETHIS IS MORE TRUE WITH SOCIAL SCIENCE SINCE

    SOCIAL PHENOMENA COME UNDER THE PERVIEWSOCIAL PHENOMENA COME UNDER THE PERVIEWOF IDEOLOGY:OF IDEOLOGY:RELIGIOUS,SOCIOPLITICAL,SOCIOECONOMIC ANDRELIGIOUS,SOCIOPLITICAL,SOCIOECONOMIC ANDPHILOSOPHICAL ON THE ONE HAND,HUMANE ANDPHILOSOPHICAL ON THE ONE HAND,HUMANE ANDPSYCHOLOGICAL ON THE OTHER.PSYCHOLOGICAL ON THE OTHER.

    E.g. Recent research on Atoms LargeE.g. Recent research on Atoms Large HadronHadron Collider &Collider &and medical research on human brain in physicaland medical research on human brain in physicalsciences and various modifications in social sciences.sciences and various modifications in social sciences.

  • 8/8/2019 4118 SRM Introductory

    27/27

    A Concluding RemarkA Concluding Remark

    The characteristics of social science discussedThe characteristics of social science discussedabove may suggest that scientific research isabove may suggest that scientific research ispossible in the field of social sciences.possible in the field of social sciences.

    However, a caveat is in order.However, a caveat is in order.Subjective beliefs are checked against objectiveSubjective beliefs are checked against objective

    reality in social science but the process and outreality in social science but the process and outcome are less exact as compared to the physicalcome are less exact as compared to the physical

    sciences. The degree of exactness differs withsciences. The degree of exactness differs withrespect to the nature of social sciences.respect to the nature of social sciences.