4oqq1j bcl 1j - national bureau of economic research · 4oqq1j bcl 1j n4c jpm2pa kp klt2iju...

42
JiJcjrIqnJ © uoqcc J2 Cu o pc 2OflLCC cxcccq lwo buibp w pc dnoicq iiiponi cxbjicu bQuou bi.oArqcq q'i njj cLcq © p? yJ Kipu uq jpm2p? VII L!P 2P014 c1Iou2 oj ICX UOI o KGLCP ob!IJ!ou CXbW22j w JJO2C O 1J1C fIiJIOL2 uq UO ipO2C O JIC M&iOII9J BIILCfl O4 COUOUJC Jpi bthci i bn.r o LQ2LC bLouJw !u pwou9 jLq uq JuAwcur vu NV OJ ioo CflGU VAGUfl wvnowvr Bfl1EVfl Ob ECOWONIC 1E2EVICH 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VI bVIIEF DI2bVA2 4BEK IIiOJKIW3 bVhEK 2EKIE2

Upload: doantu

Post on 28-Jan-2019

232 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

JiJcjrIqnJ © uoqcc J2 Cu o pc 2OflLCCcxcccq lwo buibp w pc dnoicq iiiponi cxbjicu bQuou bi.oArqcq q'i njj cLcq© p? yJ Kipu uq jpm2p? VII L!P 2P014 c1Iou2 oj ICX UOI o

KGLCPob!IJ!ou CXbW22j w JJO2C O 1J1C fIiJIOL2 uq UO ipO2C O JIC M&iOII9J BIILCfl O4 COUOUJCJpi bthci i bn.r o LQ2LC bLouJw !u pwou9 jLq uq JuAwcur vu

NV OJioo CflGU VAGUfl

wvnowvr Bfl1EVfl Ob ECOWONIC 1E2EVICH

4Oqq1J bCL 1J

N4C Jpm2pAKP KLT2IJU

IIIHIIJIEK H'VI bVIIEF DI2bVA2

4BEK IIiOJKIW3 bVhEK 2EKIE2

Page 2: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

flIJJAGL2UA bLr bY !8O-OQ RL r'Acggc 114 t.ôO-J'1JOKCUJ BmN!U F1JO }LIJUQLi Bfl!N!U.LJJG bcuuAJAu wgc flIUACLaIgA flhIiAQI2igA

cbwJg O ECOUOUJIC2 C!MfLgUJCIJg O ECOUOW!CKJ uc jpnupA

iuccugmG go qo B%D LC qmnupq pA npqA ou cbcgA cog

LC pJpcL /I4gp npqic jOL ci!rncigA cdrnipou Wu!W I%D anpiqic occm. pCCfI2Q

urnqccg bucc bopcA nJsnJgIou po,1 gpg 2gc9qA wgc ?qq uq bLojg2 ffLG JOMCV MJHJC

gpg gpca cpoic o4, cbcigA uq jq-wbLoiqu jD in gpc uicqinw uq jou urn ,ijjccgin qc congcg oj woqcj in 1pcp piw2 pcjrnic cowbcrjgAcJA in gpc 2L1 i.nu Ii¼flC LcJiug

bLoqncqou bLobocq nuqcL gpc cugou qumwgi.pou lrnucj qbpiA uqgic jc qo qn

jjn bcbcL CXUJIUC2 bO2!pjC COUC&1C1JC 0 go K%D uq go ojnwc

VBaLKVCL

ffiHLLIIEK LFVI LVL4Er DIbVA2

VnJfffJLA

AJ3EJ JOLIq1J bL 4J

Page 3: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

5

q TOô2 EJIMW J88' J'1 JÔ2 vmi T2 uq AoMGLA

o p€Jrnççi 9'LflG JJç ImJJçL? qGwIJq OL corrjq p€ uJç G2IJ? pX

o bu€ comburnG2 o o vjovj bGcjcçou2 (yjorj jf)

UGGq OL bojic? p? cçu jiuc€q cbc!c?. bLoqnc6 i'v q cp€ bbLGu LGJH2J

qbj2.a 'jyya LG LGJpJ& JJJ4RGJJ4 uq 6IJGLV GWC!GJJ JJJJT VO' 1J12J62 IJG

jirzj qiBja L6 26GU cuçcj ycco JIJ }J8 LGLq OLGOAGL L6JAG o cçjoq€ L

oj qic€q JJJOLIJJçJOU !JJJ qGçGUJJU€ JG RUJJUGL2 0J JITJ1L€ UJJJiçL? coiqjic

rnq iouiu imboiçuc€ o qi.içj GCUOJOG2 rjovj OfflCj Lfi6 jiç GJGCJAG JT2G

B WJ2frqGq Uqn2çLJ bojic? cc1 arrLAGJJJiJcG GxbGLiGucG2 LOIJJ DGGL OLW

cJrm qom€2ç7c bLoqrrcçiou O 1rj 12 cLJçJcv7 tOL 1I84ThOIJJ aGCfrLi42A CL14C2 J9pGJ 4JJ6 IJJI-

JJJG iUI4wçiAG }J9 6GIJ }JJJJ COTJçLOA€L2iJ1 MP!I6 W D€BLcmGUc O; DGU2€ (voD)

c}ncAJu J b€r.cuç 2JJLG O 4JJ6 ROLJ rj miLj€ p cp ?i. 5000 (EJmm

!IJCGIJ4!AG2 yWOIJ JJG OJ2 2 JJG CLGOU O cbpj€ oj

pq *TO irnjjiois OL 'D pJJJcGq iojfim bLoqr1cçiou uq so 'IJ!°' OL bLocflLGmGu

'-'HJ!0' J0L COLG L62GLC rnq qGAGJobuJGu wv) *20 LIJ!JflOU OL IJJU1 CcJTL!1J G2I

q€wuq g€commGuqGq 2LrbboL oL pG t,c!oi.wJ EJc j'i D!2bJ i'cc' Jcpqq

JJJ }J6 IJ€L J1J1TL& JJO/IGA6L GOUJbJTç€L8 LG J1JC6J? CCOJ OL IJJOL6 JJ9IJ JJ9J OJ \jVj

wu bLocp1c2 uq joç bu€j q2bJAe LG GD 2 UJJL boç€uij

2cJG bLoqrrcçlou o bu€j p2bJe (1vJ) €mcouqncçoa p1 p€cow€ bLç

combua iui€ iu LG2GLCJJ uq qGAGJobmGuç (ic) tGJJ

p ybLiJ Juou uuorrucGq unJpoIJ bopcA iuJçJçJAG

j. juoqncou

Page 4: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

wJ1J (ioiic Tä2)powt bLo WgLU2 ULG tnjç JIJ brç o rncL€q iojq cbøqçA !AJ4 IcGuç GIJçL) p? ROLU

lliO1Jj MGJfLoi cora& u iwboi.puç 182116 i MG4GL bLo JUCL62( uq\oL 8biJJoAGL G116C42 LG 21111JC!GUc

p bbGL II€ COIJ8qGL L6J6q aoç 0j !8efI8 IJUJGJ?1 iwbcç o 2rrp8iqi€ OL COL6

UGIA \J1 cOq6 L& JJORGA€L o JJG2G LITJG2 J0L qG€U2G

LG pGkoIJq bL6comb€çJçiAG 2nbboL uq bLocrrLGmGu UCGUAG2 qL6cçJK AiOJcG

iUq1T2çLJJ LG2LCJJ CL!c!C2 2ITCJJ 2 LJ1€ 4JJG IJCGUI!AG2 Ot AOJiIIJJG bLoqncçou

bLoGcç coaç Don OfflCJ2 iri !4 tiiçpu bGLc€uç cb OL ripq€ J0L 2bGdllJc

B'orjuq npiq? coq€ nJcG cvj 2cthboLç rnJqL iuiçrnJAG !a pw4€q o 20 bGLcGuç oJ

UOJJ6L boiiç O COIJçLOA6L2? 12 RJJGçJJGL JJG 1UI1çiAG 12 COu2I2çGlJç içp bo2c-flLfrc1

2flG24 LGJciAGJX joii bLoUc LiJ2 puuu u mo (yucj?

wJJJioir uj?a bLolGcçGq o LGçITLU joL cçu mçux jdrnq CL?2çJ cpebj J2O

OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4 O p1JpOIJ LpGL bjuu€q oooriçbirç Gjjpcç ) &ijj p zxwjj jri o J2 oJ JjG cJJuJe j bcuç mLJcG4 2JJLG

drr62çJou p uoç p€u qJLscJ?. J,€IJcJ? wr.J€ bLo16cjou2 2fl624 4JJG JrnççJ/Ge

JucL iii orrbrrç iq E}J€}JGL }JG2 jJLIJJR MJJ GL1J GCOIJOUJC LGIJ23 JJJOTT}J

A!'q 2 211CJJ dHG84IOIJ O flJGLG2 JDGCOIJJG2 R4J6}JGL JUJ4 JAG /AJJJ j€q

o g qijGLGJJcG

rnqrr24LJJ bojicA JIJ 9qqçou I4 12 J2O LIT€q ai€ O JJG irnçwçiAG 12 coo 2UJJJ OL

2 IJO 2J1LBL2!IJ JJG JUJ4JçJA6 J2 coJJ2iqGL€q p? 201116 cc) PG qJ2m26q

qGGu2G IJGGq2 OL \'Vj L pGJ0 p€ JrnJpJ oj o j bGLcGuc O }JG RLOLJq JJJLJ(Gc

iJuiijj?. iom jyj — jç (non 'i' — jj) jyrr& i€u njovj

O fTçJTLG uJJçL?. qGwuq OL LG T2 000 JJUJTJJ? L0IJJ T002 — T8 uq 52 000

cbcriLG 12 beLcGuç o JJ6 M0LJ mJc€ç (LJ6Jq Jf ThO2 J,ATG1JcJ Jcf9) OTj G24UJ4G2

2GA6LJ eIJJJJ UJGqiITW 26 bJ9'1Iç2 9IJ JJJCLG86 JJ CbC4A JJJJICJJ J622 I?JJJJ 4JJ4 L6dfJL6q o

Page 5: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

lo tx9fno3 r1 rn eirLt oh 9W .rnoibrnboiq 9mrrlov r1irI o b99is a9ibiadIi lo brza (I11

-bIei as 119w as i3aqaD ni riemfasvth lo 3Dnahoqr 3r1t s1IrtqaD 11 sw r{Dif{W Ishom a

& bIii isrLir1 fIiW am-ifi jborn air1t cr1 .ieubni Isriaq afi er1t iii (I1k r1ivoiqmi

vtiDaq& 15r{id oJ eba1 axr{T .Bbf9i iewol rliiw eocLf riar{t tiDaqaD 9lom cii te3vrni

cii riiBffl9l oc{w arrnft ha arLt 'heqoiq r{t aac{ Ithorn 9rIT .amift b15i rIir1 iol uqtuo brra

ma rltiw mni11 8Jn{T .Mfa 'ba5ta eu cii .e.i b1si erriaa ecu evac{ 1eamikr rtaiibni eE{

abis1 ibiriw ie1a e1irIw a io1 baer{a riiamnei o bne abIei lo anniet cii eariavba Iaitirii

atmnei-iaaijp lo maei±a a ab1ei Iaiini ir1ir1 r1tiw emil aev aimIt 9Off ievewoH .qu da r{DJJa aerueIJbrn o Iqqa o r{mrorl eia 831 iehaiamb rbijB •'ps tomi oh ebiaah erI rbirlw

.elOtDIJIDnO3imee bria SV2 as

leborri beiIa e1qmia a bna iioib cii beacirnaib eia e3than3tDaiaf{3 '1taLfbni miave1eH

9LJL2 i8O3 9rf iieewfed tfi eu1 3111111SX9 9W flOth39 •g miOLb9 ni behieeeiq ai

biupil ioeienait mill mmli loloD iol afeoD mniw alirnam no aab bna lebom er1f mu beahiieoq

iB eW . noifDe 111 benteaeiq eia enoitn1umie il0q .(eü')1 —

TT) eaIqaib 1aax b1ei no biedua a enjaiev rioitieiup3a '(t13aqa3 rio biadue a a jIool

lo t39T9 SISmuJtIOlftiJ eu eIJacI eibiadiia tL3aqs3 arli t29IJ2 a1ueei lUO .(I1 mvo1qmni

baea iewol evar{ o mill beeraf erli abael rninct cii airLT .(I1L iol aevthneDrIi niaaeDeb

lo eDmIeada enlt ff1 10 eeibiaduia 11 ierliie cliiw miar{t aeibiadija 'tiDaqa3 mliiw abIei eaa .Diloq

ff0 fciemmnevo eu d eilthLbneqXe bexfl oi\ eno a lo etD9TIe eu eiaqmo rnerli eW

d bebivoiq eaievef cii 93(191911th sr{t lo aebi cia au aevt air{T .aeibiadira (1s bmia iDaqa3

-il8q9b rI31eb 911 i d eftoqoiq inemelqmi oi ihir,fflib bna xsfqmoo if t nuiB191 iii ne)1B 3d b1uod eui) ' ifi8qrno3 bebeIe i811 eeJ&ta (

— I aq tO1) üoQ 311T beanthb 3bi1oq 131qmi 311i o inm -13 3d blisow buboiq nojt819rI9 inIeTIu3 101 a9thIbBI flofi3Ubolq 9fflhJfOV iii ffl3ffliVfIi w3n o beiimfnoz

stB1unommo3 eo1q aiiijba1unam bna abicboiq fi0ftB19fl9 X9fI iol hoqque 11 9VO81 ot 31dii no IEnoiilbnoD bi&Jue 9fLt aeAam emIT .1Ioibubo1q 3muIov oi bei8lianom9b in3mtimmo) o Lv1 3rLt if iiw

.ibiedue tioJ3qEo a hsq iii 8B bei91q13tni 3d 5& ii iBrlJ 08 noiiiezupDE 'fb8qao

Page 6: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

tarli bnfI W a aa b9IIbeqa eia eibiadua i{t nia anrrurxrii owt i{t

iiitibneqxe iDaqaD bria ü1 sn er{ ro heT aqmi 9vitiaoq a 2arI ibiadne Io airit

jborn iiro nI !ibiadna tbaqa a ai i n91{w ton tud 12L ioI ei 'biadna nr{w arrnft id

ndu'x io'i anoh91iU .asibiadija 'tiDsqaD narIt saivI siom sbivcriq oi bnst asibiadue 1S . rioibs ni bsaaljDaib sia *iow

iaubriI 3f{T . -aitini 1o sri mod Jiaqa sfiup buta 9883 niasistrii na asbivoiq aubni Isasq aR sr{T

frisrntasv 1aunino3 no abrisqeb favivna dDirlw ni viiaubni bsa1ns3no3 Ir1iri a ci tI .svit

tDubo1q aDinoibsis ioIonr1DsI-riid isrio s1i! rbuM aasoiq bna thuboiq rIod ni

fnsmqolsvsb IIr1aesoDu .nsmqoIsvsb riioisbrw asio1or1r13sf lavil o shav a sia

wsn bna asioIonrbst wsn sauaDsd noI io1 atfloiq s naiau on esob v3oIondDst sno 1o

.bsqofsvsb nisd iLtnatanoD 918 iofonc{Dst blo Io anoithieris

o sldieaoqmi ci ti bna itaubni sib lo aDifaiistDsiariD niIasistni lo sbutifhrm a sia sIsriT

faHnitnoD ar{t asbi sib esiuqa Isbom iirO .msi{t lo ha eslutqaD rbir{w heborn sno qolsvsb

cA .bnurlsd allal ti bJsb ati svoiqmi ton asob mnifi a II .ctftoiq qasi of bsbssrz ci noiavonrii

niaI sib trio niqiw Ilaritrisvs aeriibsb s3iiq teham sah alotitsqmo3 at i 10 abIsi sib

rioitavonni nivo1qmi-bIsr lo sloi silt no niaLrDo1 nI .atixs ti tnioq ibiriw ta etftoiq arnift

9f31 trlsmlD sib ritiw Ino bsrnsDnoD 918 errrth tarb srrweaa sW .atrstioda Ialsvsa sIaJ sw

silt staqioitna ot biawiol lool ton ob sclT bna noitiaiup3a tiDaqa3 noitouboiq lo

1trIiat1sorIu 9d11839d cult ob ot saood3 sW .asI33 sirrtth no iabot ioivarlsd iisrLt lo tDaqmr

iol bstiua-hhi asrbaoiqqa 3imanb blabnata nblam rteribni cub iii rlirl ci siirtril sib tisoda

trrsrritauLba ca rbua esiictasl isrLto t3$I9ri oela sw ti3zIqrnia lo teslstrIi siLt iii .ti nufIsbom

a var{ ot ilsli1 9i8 etcoD tiDaqaD .i-xtaribth sib ni tnatroqmi 918 'sr1t flJJOrlt nsvs ateoD

Page 7: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

at2oo rI5mwijbA .aeoD tnrrdeujba bna e9itiIidiiv3rIi ot nibI n9r1oqmoD ?!111J2 fIif{

rer{w anoiaufia aetaei eir{T .a'im '?lofeirl tad oa "ei airi" tsD bribi aii{ lo

9mi1 a 3AiI aIooI arIw niaisa d ab911 in9nal-frI9q 9va11 ria io DiIoq 'iaioqm

r199d 9v8r1 iaubni sdi ui nahoqrni eliriw rbir{w aioba1 ierio Iaieve8 moil 3a1tada eW

Hew baeiIs tori ei arI eIthf bba throw arothi1 saerli ruibubni aujdT .ier{weale beibu

oi IeIif f rarjhni etht rn berieado trrsmevoiqmi bIeiv er{ lo errnoa eIqrrnaxe io'i .booJeiebrw

.eiwietiI erli ui beibjj Hew eia iiob d riirnaeI lo aleboM .riiob d riirrrae! rnod kraei

aids mi thajjbrii lobubnoDirrlee er{ leborri ([email protected]) riaminM k)rla niwbisH xemIoD ebath a uI

11 bkrow em{t nar1t eiom eDuboiq aririfI famli ai alebom rbua moi1 flueei enO .iermam

srntth mi rnoihubei efif frrnoxs ofrii eIat erlf ernia fao3 bna eirrievsi 1amniiam befaupe

aeibiadua vtiDaqa atxefmio3 rbua nI .fuqfuo fmierus3 lo firm famnoitibba ma 'd beilqrni afaOD

1o bubi emif niiewana ioI befiua-Ifi aisbom eaer{t rnbIam asibiadua c13k oaf a fD5115 Lii eia

USH rieewfed aeorieielHb Iiafa aIebom ruiob d nirnaef ci ai far{T .?Iea ew anoifaeup

ci aievolliqa On eIB eierlt emnaaa oala eW .befDefeb ed fOrImIaD aeibiadira fbaqa bria

of IIthtiaq faael fa aeima rrnfi eno fmiemevoiqrrn b1ei a risniw iirno aievofliqa rbmc2

of itifida erif eubei bun'! airif 10 aievolliqa famif °boofaiebnu Hew ai ti riiaA .arrnfl ierito

.C11 oh of evitnsDrii erif ewbei of bnef 93119(1 bus (I13 10 afe11e s{f eiIamnefrii

oio1orIdzx3T q'j i.s

asbof ui aIqaib lo sqf Iojam r{f eIa (1X) aaIqaib lsfal?13 himipil I eldaT iii riworla aA

bef time ai fr1il aiaIqaib eaemlt uI .fe*ism IsiDlerrImoD er{f lo tne3leq ''8 niai1qrr1o3 fe*ram

(aef sit edira) aaaf lo cf eerie owf enif mieewted becoiDrIe aIaia'iD biupil of beilqqa ci eafIov nerlw

.@8ll namuiX baa niwbiafi eIqmax9 iol ('8I) daiui1T baa nen9L eec ,

3x9nO3 ebirii Ianoiiarrietni as ni ievo1Irqc (11 10 ci81sns as io'I

Page 8: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

DOD (if) CPfbcGL fl 1;OL q6JJ6q qGecLiblIou 01; G9C 01; 4G LLD Pu102

uq bLoqrrciou o uq J4€ JoU JJq 'tA2cJJOLU T2)

HOGAGL iu IJJ1IJJGL o cowbnG2 iiuoimcGq bLo622 q6AGJobmGu

LebOLç bLGqcç€q 6W1221A6 qiebjø?e tijj tmrn emjj bL o COUJIJJ6LCJ mLJcG u 5000

opcG JJG2G qJ2bJA2 combLiaGq oirj? 2 bGLcGuç o LuLJGc u uq orj2 Jf2p€ o tipj€ ivya uq bpoabpoL2 unc ppc

bLoqrrcG p€a ou ppr 'bD1 jipç pX bbj?ni ioj€ u W614

vj uq €jq Gm!eou qJaBJ () qabj GL pow 'çy uJJJL€6 JGLIJçJAG2 4O LG bjm qbj? ('brj'b) JGCcLOJJnJJ!IJG2CGIJc qJ2bJ2

6LJJJ2 0j q66cçiAG bix6J

cbpj€ o bLoqrrcu p1p6L Ai€qe i boLc!ou o bLoqr1cçou ncp r oj cc6bçpJG ill

OLGOAGL bi.oqrrc€i GIJ.G JJ 'cTj o €drnBmu

2CLGGIJ 2€ o bo€uçij O T'CV% OL JL€ bbJ!cc!ou2 12 JIJJ4Gq

bjx€12 ujc p€Ju qJ2cLq€q JJ}J12 W€U2 diwjiçX couoj BLOpJ€UJ2 qiawçicjj?.

qGL 4JJG uic Loom coJJqJcJou2 2GmicoIJqrrcoLe1 uq qJ2bJ2 jncp coum q€j€cp€

bjx€12 'p LG2J1JçIJJ drrjr bLopj€Iua ru q2bJA vcr 9'LG bLoqrrcGq rn-

o' bLopj6m 11L14JJ EJJ L6qrnJqu LIJ22OL2 €C b!x€J

4O %-CTW

B uo€q m pj& vjovj bLGqcç8 u 111 JJ€ JmboLçuG€ 0j \JC\

II'U'CD piiç }JAG 2JOli.€L 4IJJ€2 IJq O p€ J€22 pLJJJc (rjovj mod)

AGLç1CJ OIJ liO O J88' \Jrj8 LG LJJOLG COIJJWOIJJ? JT2€

TD22IA€ UJçLJX 1cVJ ('1J1jçVj) COLILOJ JiJJç €UJ128101J p?. naG 0 WGf }J0L1OIJçJ uq

uouuçou qebJ2 jp€ biimQ. 112€ oj 8 COJOL 2CL66U2 oL jubob coujbnç€L2

4JJG2G CL?2J2 p 1126 O 2JJJCOIJ LViJ2J2çOL2 9LG couaJqGLGq 4JJG qomJJJu4 4€CJJMOJO?I tOL

mj€ nb qiabj? yCçiAG UJçLJX TCD% (\ j 1'CtJ tAJJJCp COIJçLOJ boJLJcJou

Page 9: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

cowbnjj€io8 CW Al ° TT D°D LcboLç OL IJ GCOJ1IJ Oj OJJ€L GjOL PA fl E11L0bU uq tbuo JJG rnqf12LA 12 qm bL!miJA o O 4JJG COUJbgIIIG2 IUAOJAGq

boj!cA icic qcAGJobmGul cou;i jçoupjoom uq cciiuo (jgj) ujec pç AoIII!ouJpJJTp OL f€ m€ bmthoeG GG jAou () OL u nJJAi2 tApJcp odne ou 4pG LOJG o OAGLUwGUçC11LL qEbiç GLJA rjoI pA iccj o qGA€Job COU2JIUJGL AJqGoLGcoLqGL IJq iO!Uc-AGIJfIIL€ pA Vmb€x uquig coiubguj COWW€LCiJ couenm bLoqnc mcL€ OIIA uq naprw jpi oc-buA 'U jc yjcpoirp ymbGx nccc8ufJA comwGLcwJiq i AGO LGCOLqL oL poqcç

bçcuç nuqGLJAJu Ai14rnJJA ii AGI{ p'i° °pi"r p VmbGx CoLb0Lo fl corn-o cpb J1LG CJS LbD ? JWGIA o qL&rnccvjA JIJCLG9 4JJG OOU11UJGL WULJGcL6bLGu;Ju oujA j bGLcu o qcurnuq MP!JG D°D bLGqjcç urnjj Coll8flWr. rngLj€ rn 5JJ(J 4JJ GAO IOU

j4oIcG 'U j bLIrnciLA ubbjcuiou ° EbD2 p cowbnçL& mJp 4pG COU2flUJGL WULJG4

JUAG2Gq rn uucrnu cbciç?. !u cp fluj€q 24c€210

for. qGAGJobwGu4 uq pip JOJIflhJG bLoqcrccou o !u bir OUG oj combu!G2

JJ6 JUç6 Th8O fBI/I JJ JJO2JJj oLIJ3€q DJ Jpc}JuoJoJ6& () U )oIJç AGIJçITLG

uuq p1Tern€e ubbjicçJou& PJ Th81 'c atruccpGq If0D GIiOL42 'çv €C}JUOJOJ€2 PqLobbGq i br.ocç 111 p€ ioo JflJAJ bIIL2rIGq bJU2iuU OL COmbfIGL

i-rje xc atAicpGq Lom cUçpoq€ LUX L2GULC iu tA}nJG

bLoçoçThG 2UG UGJc}JL ICV LTOL ffiGaçIIJ}JOLT2G bHL2rrGq COUJIJJGLCIUf q€A6fobUJGJJ4 o

fnJqGLJAu moLJç? o vw yjporrp cGcpuoJoe tA6L

c\'M) DL bGcGL pLoq? oj J rnJJon2& qGAGJobGq cUquJpTm 2€JGuiqG

oV. tiqçp 4}JG oj o q€AGJobiu BCLGGJJ jç €uorrp o pu ou u iijj (vjovj

cj meo uq moa Eu.!uLa u c' ar1Iou rUp qGAGJobGq cr

GULJ?. OL JA€LG qA€JobGq JJJ L66ULCJJ JU2 U UIJ

jc coIIbUu€ pn uqrrar i uoi. qoiuuç€q p?. cowbUrn€ LOL GxUmbJ&

2 J2 cJJG cGCpuoJOGe J6cnu o ci JccoJ-

IAI9WG4 JJLG !' EbDULG COU2qGLGq JJUAG 4}JG LGU462 bo€uwj OL JOtI CO2 JULG 2CLGGIJ2

IJcp62) Uuq Efl)7c211 UlrnoiiucGq BJUua bLoqrrcG 000 nrn U moup OC0PGL

En1!2H Ic2rrepJc ouA iiq mmGJGq oqqu bLooçThG o JUL€ 8CLGGIJ '-vj'r (rib

Page 10: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

LLGX2 JJJ4LJTIJJ€IJ

pq pr.roiie oçp€r. Ec1D bLoiGcç2 3LG OUOJIJ O4OLOJ JAçJJGOIJ LLlOj 9IJ

p? JJJ4 3ç8Jqi2JJ JIJqH2LiG2 lJq VjOt r.q 4O qGAGjob mIJrlpCcrrLu

tip ybbJG o ql2bJ2 oi cowbn€r. bbjicçjoua yqqiçiou? Cou2oLçuTm oLLuGq

(j) COUçLC couçurc UGII c1At bjuç r.iq J4 i IJAoJA6q III ')Oillç AGUçJTL6

JurççJAG bpcj JIJJIIJ e€ma R2 tALqGq JJ AUCGJ }'G26BLCJJ bL0l€Cce y€uc?.

€ir.j combrnGe 91€ COUHC4ThLJ 8D 013 1\D2 113 br.ç LG2bOLJ2€ }J€ VjOVj

(LTYPJ j) oij€ 2b€c4 o vjOrj2 21CiOJJ OL ja bu€j bopc uççtV'3 mLGc2 JJJ€ C4 IJJLJ(€ç2 combr.ia€ ouj? 2 o JJ€ ocomb9u?1 ouj? iur.j€çe ! I}ncp fj combrnG2 L€ JL6 bje€r.a L€ 4}JG

eojq qJ2bJ2 for. A!OJJJC2 bbJcçou8 013€ A!GII2 Jfl2 IOJIJç A€IJ4J1L& DLI

bLoqncGL o iu uiç€q ti 0bicgj jmiu 2ç€w jncp bLimL!JA

combu€2 CCornJ€q OL 0 O UJLJC€ç fri OrJj? AorrrIu€

combu!€2 CC0fflJ€ ;OL OA€L O L1JLJ€4 113

p oçj bbr.oxiwç€jX 20 combui€2 IJJJJuJCHL€ y2 r.ioç€q 111 JYPJ6

o p€ IJJLJ€ (rjojJ rlj\jthoLjq WLJ€ L4EC IJcJ DIII R6LG IJ6Xç JL6 br.oqnc€r.a RJçJJ 2JG8 COIJJbLI2HJ 2

jjr.b ii or.jq JL€ç br.oqrrc€r. o ''rj& wqçp iça 9JG2 combLi2Ju o4JJ€ J0 p€ciJJ€ 113 COJ0L LJJ2T2OL QT)2 ( — vj) 113

jr.b 1CC€HJJ?I. bbJ€q €cpuojo puq-p€jq cjcrijoL u T802 uq iJ.J

O CJG91J LOOIJJ COuq41OIJ uq COUçi1JiiJ br.oc€a imboLçu !' 2€uncouqrrcçoLe

qrrcçiou o vj ocp coujbuj€e puc LOW c}! €xbGL!GUCG RLçp }JG

fri CO1J4L2 coLubrJ1€2 21ICp 9 pLb iiq I4EC c4AGJ? bcrL8rr€q uq bLo-

Page 11: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

I9hoM e1qmi A £

riahoqmi Ia19va aathqaD IseI ew ibii{w Jthorn elqmia B qoleveb ew !rIoibee air{f ru

arLt eirrosx o abesir ibina rurni erli lesi ew a'uf .raubth afqaib Isnaq sfl erli o eW .bIei r1Br1 eru&b o isiase ai rnut iii rbirlw tiDBqBD ruBrf erI&{3 o ieieas ai ticqrro

nI .bexfi eus b!ei bria r{tod nin horia eri I 1 ew thr{w rü ari emuaaa eioeisrI

.neaorb ed ri& blei' nin riol erit iii bruB eIdBi1Bv ai ti3aqED rmi nuribem erit llso ew tar{w

.lirpe ed taxjm abIei run hor{a bus nun nol 1,born a rbia lo state bseta erit ni eaiuo 10

evsnled cmiii nuevi ca bIeii bnia tiDaqaD i±tiw nui horla erit ni tarli leel ew brIo3e

ot euboiq ot ienltedw ci rioiabeb lno iienlt !crrr{T .nievi 88 eiiq e!at bnia levthitsqrnoo

amill vifagenr sia atfioiq Ii bna ;eiiboiq cmiii viserunoru ew atftoiq II io

n1oiaiDeb cir{t nblam nI .tiD8qaD eaoorb en{t run nrusibem silt iii isvewoH .eDuboIq ton oh

atIiiaei airiT .tlloiq enenl bns trrqftro atoella ti3aqaD tacit bal suit trucoxa otni elat en1t

nui nol silt ruT .muiudiliiupe IIeBVI tonrwoD a nuildmsaei muiidiliLrpe eiorb yti3aqa3 a iii

aa eiorb ti3aqa iisnlt eDrisrI bna ablsii iieclt absita f{Dinlw siuJibnsqxe GH scooch anrrdl

oc a 1V1 lo aeqt weni qoleveb ot (L$I moi1 ha ada ew tar{t eLtot4 .Jiiqtuo ca 119w

.tnlsmsvolqrni aasooiq iol ci (L$I lno silt

iier{t nranit isnfirI bIsii nevi a nriatta ot ieiaae ti brth bIeii riirI a ritiw cmiii biir{T

.1ItaoD ci abIeii ni tnsmevoiqrrui içia ievewoH .eblei iswol nItiw cmiii oh ascii ento nuitaixe

won iettam on abIsi ui tnemevo-iqmi 'nia lo ctao evitiaoq eia sierit tar{I bemuaca ocla 81 tI

ni level etirth a ot eblsic silt lo eDr1sievnoD ctinnieq noitqmilcea iettal suiT .Iamicsiinfini

.aetata basta emoc

.iiDaqaD itaubrii lo noiturlovs silt turoda cnoitasusp iewcna ot lebom silt eai ot niciw eW

kriiiue beau 1i iaqao amii1 tasi erit sisuiw e1qmaxeieJriuo a lo lnuift 1etaibommi (11w iebaei ieveb eiIT" ai tI .iaoo Ianiiarn uui tioffa nadt iedh1 eohq a iii aiIuai 11a ta beau ion Ii iud etfloiq eviMen iii etluaei

airfi 10 aethorb tiDBqBo taut riiworf a lo aicianoD inemuis eufT .earia ieveri 11kw eea clEft tail i woled bouia .ebam ieven eia brth1

0I

Page 12: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

TI

iiJ}J ?GJq uq cbciç? '

o c BGL mni jjiø o rrrnçe o bLoqncGq oiiçbrr !U 2JJOLç LJ oL

JOJJOtAIJ }JJ2 JffL4JJGL 2G2 O bLoqncou wrrç bGLoLmGq on iupj rrnç CO2

bGLc6lIç o 'a LG rncG bu€p JJAG p cpecq€q i bJxGJ2 LG

p 9ç innç coç o ci bGL nuç jp coLL€abouq2 q6 4JJ OIJJ?

OLGL 4O }JAG OJJG AipJG miiç O bLoqrrcJou c p€ jLeç i\' mJça u€q

2u€jq o jjJ€ bLoqrrcçou bLoce2 cu p ponp oj p€u combo€q o

281TUJ€ WGLG L€ 1j 1J11U2 iii JJ6 iuqri24* ECP ULUJ cbciç?. oj ' nq

T J1P JJOI4 ifITU

2np2qG2 1p2qG2 ° ED bLowoG }JGL aç€q?. ?uGJq2

cu j€q aGqX ?u€jq RqJJcp i€ jo& pç uonJq occrlL Jçponç cbcj4JJ6 IJJLJIJ LGqncG pGuGJ4 JLOm ?GJq-rncL62iu TD 2 2JJ0tMJ in GC4iOU 4JJJ

flJJTJG cbciçA 2rrp2qJG !u!c!JJA j€q o IJcLGGq cbc? uq p€nc !u ?i€jq

2JJO/A JJI2 COIJJLIOIJ O OLCG bja LOJ ru o cbcç?. uq B'D 2iTp2qG2

IJCLG2€ €JJGjJ2 JLOIJJ JJAG24UJGU48 " ID L86 ?u€Jq2 'f 8 OJ1L 2Jmf1JçJou LG21JJ2

bLoqncG rrb cbciç? pi2 JmbJrG2 WOL€ oriçbnç p? 4p€2G JLUJ2 H!pGL orrçbnç& !U

uiç !U WOi€ cbcrç?. pn 42JJ02G iJçp JOiiL X16Jq2 3UCG JLW2

6IJCOJTL9 !"'J"c " WD uq u bLoqrrcçJou ycrJiçi€2 M JIJq JJç jJLW2 IIJçJJ pipGL

B W!' cJJG2€ dn6ec!oua i pob€ p€q j'pc on p€ ot bojjci€e q€Ju6q

on iurçrj bLojj€ flOM,

Juço Uqfr2çLA jj bLolJce p€ Loq€q GLO, D°62 U11J bLoUJ€ o n nqr12çL?. q€b€uq

OL J622 }D D° LW2 IA}J pGçGL ?GJq2 aç JJGq !LT 0j ?qGjq2, J 12 GIJL?

J0L 4p6!L cbcç7. nq ?u€jq bçp2 OAGL }JAG p6çGL XJGJcJ2 Ui2 JJJOLG

fl OL 6X8LLJbj& AGU IJJ1IJJGL O JLIJJ2 2L o ?4GJq2 p8ç 2ponJq I€ GxbGc

Page 13: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

COuqJ41Ou L€ JA6U GJ0li

cpooa 1c2 o wxirni€ Jç2 rn€qmu urn biojç iipcp jou içp !c2 jL4 OLGL

WLJ.G4 uq IJCOLbOLG 211C}J COu2qGLcOu2 !I3 6C2OU IJ.rnJqIJ EP UL11J

u orrçbrr O o CO1TL& qJG?. LGJ1G CJJO!CG oj cbci p€ bLicG IJ JJG

1113 oj cbc!cX !2 p"c /F!CP 9 A16Jq O MIII JIJCJTL coç o (\)c oLrnJ 4JJG? OIJJX 4JJG1L ?q€Jqe 2 JA6JJ uq cpoocbciçi€e JJJG coe O J qqcouJ

i JJG poiç LfflJ JL2 JJ61L cbgczi€a 9 8 ?u6Jq2 ju

JJJJG GqmiJ RI1IJ

A1JJ JIJqJCG2 JG22 \C + I 2IthbJ 8 LRJJ JJJ JJTLG F

tAJçJJ Jo€r. JuqJcGa J39AG pJJJ€L ?u€jqe uq coLL6ebouqJ1JJ?. JOtAGL IJJL1JJ C02ç8 OJ W2

JA€U bLc& uq p€? UX!W€ WGJL bLoJç ccoLquJ?. III JJG 2}J014 LITIJ 2 LMIJ JLW2

[IIJC41OIJ OLIJJ O 211bbJX q€bicç€q EJLW2 JJG uGL8Gcc!ou 0j qarnuq uq 2JIbbJA 9

rr L6bJcG tMçp ' !AJJGIJGAGL JLW rnj bo8içJAG bLoUa jç J2O LG211J2 113 4JJG eç€b

c"€J €cp jirn anbbJJG2 i rnLJJJJ coç jprn bGLur2

J}JG 211bbJ? CFILAG OL rnqff2çQ. 18 qcbicç€q rn J,1ffLG j y2 JL2

—00

=(') — ( +) ()

J1CJJ JLUJ2 JJAG IJJLJ1JJ C02ç O + C bLO2 LG }JIT2

= 00

£c() = ( + (j)

Page 14: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

(C) ?(+ )

() (+ ) —

() =

(-)rIB

svii o aaoorb mifi i Ii srkt oM (1) avIoa dDirlw iorb 'iDSqa3 r1 aIDiq9b ari'I oorb Iliw emil DneH soc . sd teum run ttorla efli ni etftoiq au baqaD Hi

.run hoc{a 9rLt ni 'iDaq8D ii5f{t ha 3JJbo1q ou

e4iJ e!ool mae eidJ ou noifuloe er{u ienriam cirlu ni aiuiDaqaD iiiif eeoofb emil ha cA

(\ c...

'd be±orl9b eia b ahv3I muhdiIirrp rLT .rrwiidihirrp9 chasM uornrroD a

no as aIvsI 'tiDaqaD ic{irI aooih Ihiw ebI9i1 iriir{ r{tiw emil usrf iuoM .V ,... , I =

.beqx5 bluow

riu$J noi 3Iff ,.8

er{u Hi moDuJJO 9r1t alDells eir{ woci niilai al3vsl bl9i1 iier1 aOOf{D emil mn nol r1t nI

ci Ivl ou bl9i ati Hiaiai lo (! bI9i cluiw mill a ou uaoD edT .arun mijibem bna fioc{a

id HeVI mio'x lanoibruJI lahuDitIaq a eelau eicLf uar{t ernucas Ihiw eW .(' J)1 d befoneb

() — + (

— = (\

luaoD eia bleii Hr aunernevOiqifir llama HeVe uarl vtieqoiq eckt earl midl IaHOiuDHIJ airlu euoM

erom i1evieeeioiq emosd eurismevoiqmi ieia1 tsrH brra

1ia85 i tI .tbaqo LLtiI ati nscf c891 9oIJbolq sm mifi b13i tawoI 3rLt fI9IL O = — — (t? 4<)

.nin tiorla eift cii beau ed ion Iliw iacfi eeiorb tu)sq&) mo aeliri muuidiliupe sin muibeni siLt icirli nworle

Page 15: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

N

rn bLoqr1crn COJOL 3-CVJ% JJJG? JO iucJnq6 cbj coç IIJ 4}J6 OLIJJ O

2ncjJ B wçGLiJ8 211bbJ16& uq g EJJ 2 pic uq uqLGcc JpOL GmbJokGq

buGJ2 bGL ?6L uq ?qGJq2 €GGU j uq rnç coç ucJrrqG iLwpj coç

uq c jio LGboLç riu co oi ijiwi oriçbrr JGAGJ2 () pGçti€u eo 000 uq 0@0 000

LHJJ C02ç2 jj JJOL o buc& Iiuçp coeça &€u p( + ',

p 2JJOL 111331 LGCJJ cp GCp LJJJ bLoqncG2 nb cbgci a jou a i apoiçO JJ€ uJLJGç IJLIJGJ?1. COJOL -rç bLoqrrcGq Ju

juc (€u2. uq 24GJJ1Jo J4 4IJOLJ gG2O1ILC621 JIJC.T jy€?. L6J€L boLiou

imboLucG O ?qGJq GL€IJC62 !' }JG uqrreçL2 c°c qc LG LOUJ uoiq }G2OJ1LCG2

J 4p12 8€CçJOIJ I1tG GXUJIIJG qc OL CO22 O bLoqrrciou JLOfT €jq o u rq€ o

V CO2I 9uq JJGjq

IApGL€ ! GAJJ1çGq g =

iuiçij €jq jy€ açGq?. 2ç couqou OL €cp u1w1 pGLGoL& couei oj dnou ()

couqiçlou OL €cp pur p 4JJ6 2ç& pG ?q€jq CJJO2GU p?. cp JLW Wfl2 GdrwJ 1ç2

lu qqiçiou jp€ jou LfflJ L2 OLGL couqlçiou A6U pOA& tAG JJ66 24G

?A(•) + — (•) +•) 1...1 J\,) =0 ()

OLGL couqJ4Jou1 j4GL rru JJG GJJAGJ0BG fpor.€m1 AG2:

=(.)) () - ( +) (.) (e)

JJJJII JL 133 Jou 11133 EJ2JJG2 iuxju€ Jou 1cm bLoT AGU p:

Page 16: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

12

MJJ!CJJ LGbJCç6 0111. uJoqj112 eiT2bc4 js cbciç?. coe qç hi bøLçJcnJL COWG FLow CCof1UçJ1J bLocGqnL

€uçj 6JJIJo JJJGIL qGbLocrvçIOzJ I1LG2 LG 011 ecLBipl JU6 qGbLGccou OAGLLcboLcGq JILC &uq LG LOW nçjJoz EOL bLocGqnL ii o cOlJJbul4'6 JJ6 J1IJ coat qi G6LGbOJ4Gq PGLG L6 pB2Gq 011 JJiJi C024 J1L B'6LG22J0U LG2IIJç2 1T2J11 JOM C022 ULG 2UJIJ15L 0 1021Gulj? 15uq LGboLç }JJJ iJq JOM 0Q4 1JI1LG2 0L rnnç G0&8 1511q qGbLGJ11çJ0U JJJG LGL22OLJ2

2 uocGq ii.i jypj€ O1IL Ga4m16 O 12 uq WG 'S ! 0 D6bL6C!0U 01 jJOtA

+ ()

LGL6821OU O OLIJJ

4E66U 1 JJq R6 CU 6XL1J1U6 1IJJbOLç7JJC€ O ?J6Jq2 111 uJGqIJTW LIII CO2 M6G2çim6

LGboI3Gq OL jUJ orrbri JGAGJ2 p6II6GU eo000 uq oeo 000 buGJ2 b€L 6L uq ujq p6-

2OJ1LCG8 920 L6b0148 qç for. cBciç? coaç !u 4G UJJ o qGbLGc UC6 JJG86 L6

R}JGL6 jaç LG4GC2 c11bciçX rcdrn2iç1ou CO2 2 u0Gq 11poA&

Os"- bcijcouo rn€qrnu I.Jlu co 920 01 q6Jq2 jpç 12 = ( + c) —LGqrrCciOue 111 ?jq 62bGCJ9J?. J0R ?€jq JGA€J2

c bi. JTIJJç 0G8 11J OJTIL 62ç1m962 2HG2 JJ9 /BLWJG coç J6A6J2 126 2JJ11LBJA iiçp

o cT\\ b6L uou q66C1A6 iiuiç 11ç JJ6 €uq o L2 aç€ y 26coJJq eç€ CO2 12

12 C1 JJJIT& 016 IIIJIç beç JJG L2 J\ II1JJ2 L6 U66G 2 2L2 Eiçp 11 C02

24øL42 L6 IOU q6J6CcA6 9 GIJq 0 4JJ6 JL2 246 JJJ€ COaç 0J 4JJ6 L24 246 bbJ!C90u

0G 2çG C02 2LHCçIIL6 12 GWpOqIGq IJ JJi2 G02 IIC410U L11G4J0U i\ 0j JJ6

q MGJJ 1AJ4JJ U 1 O

C06WC!GUc 62çJrn€2 uq 24UL GLLOL2 L6 LGboLc€q U jppj€ JJJ€ oLrn 266112 ijc 4JJ6

= + + (g)

6211cGq JA6 112 621W62 0 C1 IJ c:

q6bLGcJçio1F13 p26q ou JJ62G qç (u€c oj qGbL6ccou) }JG 0H0&IIJ L6L62210U R2

Page 17: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

f1 \ h=i \() =—(>') (io)\5 / \3 /

0Lm 0L JJG IJJLJ(G q€uuq CJTLA& R}JJCJJ 12 bLmGç6Li6q 2

1136 uioq€j 12 W6 e iii bL6iiorr2 2GCJoJJ2 EOL 2JmbJJci liG 9221TG J1IJGL

qGbGuq ou o uJGL?.

013 GJ4JJGL JD OL 013 cbci4A ju poçp GxbGLnuGuç2 a€ poi poti JJ6 LG2f1J2

q? o B'D OL cbciç cdrnaiçiou ecouq ii joojc €JjGCç o

pj ocn ou bojic?. GxbGLJmeuç2 pJ 4JJ6 1JL2 tAG JOOJ 4JJ6 GUGCI2 O

2AçGw oprnu 20W6 1ipç iuço bojic? 182H62

224GIM 13J?4JCJJ? liJ4JJ mij? 2?uJIIJ6çLJC 1JL13J2 M6 }JGLGOLG .1TnIc6 21wb16 jLm

GdrnJpLrnu u€u p?. () uq (j LG ppj?. uou flUGB JjJ2 mje qcnJ oji€

bnpjcj ijpj€ Gcouq woqGJ2 6drqJpr4r1m couqJçiou2 Gab6cJfl? JJO26 0L jou x.rnj

IAJcJJ çJJG qç uq\oL €jeçcjç? G8c!IJJ4G8 uq€q o cjipLç€ cJJG uJoqGJ uoç

j go qia 0L 2GAGLJ LG2OIJ2 jua t1jJ1 JJG co 6drrçJou2 ! OFIL moq€j 2jJJA ooq ji

Iu 4jJJ2 GCJ0IJ JAG J0C112 013 bojicA GxbGLJuJGuç2 113 21u3bJ6 jLm AGL2IOU out.

2 iIIJI1jiOU I3'61T

bLojc2 4J36 Jf bLicG

porip bGL iruiç u OHL uoq€j jJLJJJ JAiçp ?€jq iorijq 2OJA uGçA6 mqrnm LrnJ

TOOO M!cp 5O? ?Gjq ALJpJG coap LG ponç o b€t. Jj4 rnJq cbciçK C0242

HUI4 uq cbciç co BLG bbt.oxjwç€j?. JAJJJJG }JG DGCGPGL bL!cG JA2 t.onuq

LG ApJG Jf bt.ic€a jp 12 JAJç}J Xi€jq o ALipJG C022 9LG OfJ4

jyjq po,p 62UJG2 miço ccoini iç bb€&t.a p; bJu2 JAJ ?J6Jq2 oj oo ot. UJOLG

cbci coee uq 6UCG bju co2 pna gjao ou

Page 18: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

i€ couuou o pop JUU2 uq 2G c = 150 uq j000

e€ç = cJJLorrponc JAIJG coç bLuJGçGL2 IJ ?€jq 1UCL€21IJ JD tL6 uq uq

= B6 co2 o opc1rnu nuiç o cbciçA ia cowuJou poçp IJLJJJ2 M6

ULIJJ2 em ?i€jq o o p 2)uuuJ6çLic C€ = f uqLITIJ LG JA6IJ p? ( + c) OL JLUJ = \ JA6 2642 CT = C = JLT 42}J6 2?IJJW642L1C C26 pOçJJ

CJTTLA& uq i iuçGLcGbç c L6 2642 aç j TJ 1 = JJJJG UJL1LWJ C02428 111 42JJ6 2}JOL42

cp c& 426 BL1IJGç6L2 A6 1186 L6 2 OJJOtA2 JJJG 2J0B6 o !ui6La6 qmiq

616C422 o u rniçij q18qAuc6 ou L6811J422 o 42}J6 bojicA 6xb6Lim6uç

22U1JI1JGL1C C26 tAJJGL6 Lm \ JJ2 JOIAGL Iq 42JU 1JLIJJ JJJ2 gJJ01112 112 420 6XUJ1UG 41JJ6

5 LGfl42U IJ uq joL ' j6 416IJ LGb6ç 42p6 poz€ 421JL66 2JuJrrJ42Joua OL 421J6

\J Jou€ JJJJG 2}JL 12 o 2rrp2iq? ° }çJ 6xbGuq42rrLG p1cp coubouq o t

ou cbcrA pL ou€ rnJ cjj 20 pç . ! LGqiTcGq pX 0L r.w

UJLJ(642 OAGL 42HJJG 1flJGL 42}JLGG 2CG1JLJO2 JJJJG 12 o uo bojick IPG 2Gcouq 42JJ42 o

/J6 JJL242 COU2cJ€L J6 C26 0 411A0 qGLrçcJ JLIIJ2 M6 42LC6 42JJ6 P6}JA!OL O 42J36 2uJnJ92€q

tn npq?t420 L9'J26 OL L611CG GJLG,

JJGJb OL JJIJJqGL 42JJ6 JOIJ LJflJ COIJJbG42!421A6U622 Oj: 42JJ6 ULIJJ LG 2JTCJJ 2rrp2cp62 jiJ(6J?

uq AOJIJIJJG bLoqnc42iou rn 426 J942 bu€j uq112çQ M'II 2np2Jqi62 42o cbciçX cdn!aJ42JoLT

2iIJJJ1J42iOIJ2 12 420 JJGJB J1IJq6L842JJq 41JJ6 bo2aipJG COJJ26dITGIJCG2 o; bLobo86q 811p8q62 420 ID

ALJpJ62 1UCJ11CJ1IJ ?JGJq& cbcr42? bLJc& uq bLoU422 ØJIL bntboe€ !IJ CLL?IJ 01142 42JJ626

6C 0J 42JJ6 21uJfrJçiou2 JAG P°I 42 41JJ6 6A0j114210U 41OJAL2 42JJ6 2ç6q? 242826 0 JC6? GIJOG1JOf12

LJTIJ bLoUç2 LG !AGU p?. () mGqpim LJ1IJ bLojçe p? () uq jou r.m bLoUç2 p (e) p

Page 19: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

3asD Dhmmv 911T 1.1.

f9ham 5rIT .01 lo fraqa a aoor{D amifi rLfod !rba9 . lo ab1si rivi as nmma grit iii

ia afioiq run fior{a bris ai rrnkI r{3a lo 8OD Jaruiarri run horla 'V1 ai r{tiw hata of iiq maa erif run W .001 ra aflIoiq run rrmibm bria firm isq 04 m afao3 fbaqaD .iba O11

nq bria aii afftorq a9ah 1fbaqaD ah abIeii rtoitaisfi rba fA .anoifaifi 0E riuoirif

of eeth 'fi3aqaD lo 19v31 &fafa ibafa &df of &aob ai rbkr{w of &ah abIeiY .aJIal

UH nivoiqmi-bIeii rio Iutibrrqx9 brrar{ isrifo er{f nO .CI.81 of aEIal siiq sliriw 8.01

10 sulav thhafa a moil ao. of 'IIa3ifarria1b ella1

senoqasi sfaibsrnmi srlf I mifI of o? id rIoifiawpDa fiDaqaD lo taoD srlf scicbsi sw risrlW

eirlf of sanoqesi ru .T.0I of fiDaqaD riSCoriD srlt ru saaeiDni na ci ruoifaisfi faill erit iii

bleii ni aaef ataevni I'. noLtibba ru .01 wolecl ilfr{ile tiDaqaD qeeI of ci eiorb 1tiDaqaD

siom ateevrui a eliriW !eDrfsJJpsarIoD a as blsis iewol a earl bus sioled ruarlt (13&HI uIfVO1qffui

rIoitDubel 'h of sanoqesi Hi iJoq on nItiw fault rrioil dial oafs GJI ui tnismfaevni eti K nar{t

scout woled sis aiedmuri sesrit lo r{toH .8.1 efasvrui a bria 1.I ataevrui l\ HaitinI iii

.'piloq 1o srisads erif ru iuozo bkrow dDirlw

emif isvO .'a iswol bria etfioiq aao1 &I. saiai of ci biadHa sift 1o theIe JDaqmi sifT

a fault ci airlf io1 nocasi silT .tuonlijoirlt saii elirlw hal of nied neult fiud ecu effioiq aI .() rruoiI frisbive ci as friernfasvni tiDsqa3 asaiuorie ( asubei rbirlw) ibiadua fiDaqaD

suiT .efaoD fiDaqaD rio 'biadira suit d ucuu oafs eia ([$I ob of aevitrieDni ievewoH

fr{uoulf ed ria noitairpe emIT .('') Hi H5VL noifibnoo iebio tail sift moil trueiaqqa ci noaaei

nivoiqmi blei lo filsnied laruiiarn srlf etsupe of rrr'ulI lo tiaq silt rio niaoorb as lo

II .(.)'1 faoD laniiam eti r{fiw I

< (.)(.)'i + + st 'I

er{T . ui nieaeiDeb as fileried laniiam sr{f 1o irilrlt riaD ew bsvarlsd flew ci nneldoiq silt

.bleii laifirui nevi na rruoi1 nitraia noifaDftiDsqa iuro iol ui niaasnru ai taoD laniiam

81

Page 20: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

Th

AJGJq2 //JJJ 4JJ€ 2np2q? J!62 4O 4JJ L!JJc O CTrLA& ipcp q6bJcç2

qGbJcçGq pA qoa moirn GfO8GL s L126 JJJG cITLA& JJJCp 1A€2 JJ6

JJG JL2 4}JGL6 L6 JBLG CJJIJ€8 JJ ?q6Jq2 pnç 6ç 2WJJ€L OAGL 4W& 2

EJf1LG C}J bOJIJ4 12 U IçGLJAG AJJ16 O A16Jq2 tOL uq B JGJq2 LG J//A2 1IJCLG2ITJ

b€qbe €i o bojic!62 ori Ai€jq pA jooJc1u

J@12 ri €IJq 0J o !4GL1OJJ2

4JJLOH}JOfl 6uqu rib T4W uq L62bGc4JAGJA GL o I46L1OIJ2 bL!CG JJ2

uq J0L 'j uq 'c LG2b6cçiAGJA ' e poLç rsnJ bLoJç2 L12G thJJij€ 2 fl

L2G2 2csqJA OAGL :im€ iOg th}JJ6 8 82 9 pOJ14 10 A'jq J2O L12G apGqJJA

yjj 2cq1JA OA6L uq 002 L62BGcçIAGJA JGL o 1€L;Joue EiLm ' e cbc!cA

cvj GxbGJJqiçnL& }J!CIJ OG2 fØ &JJJJG 2 O€2 5O BOP JLW8 1D GXbGIJqJçfTLG2

COIJçL2ç IJ 2ripiqA o LG211J2 rn u iwbcç ipicp jmoç qorlpJG2 ' 2

}JG 2JlpaiqA yct O 14GL9çIOIJ& 2JJOL4 LillY BL0JJ12 O 4O Jf 9uq LG2B€C42JAJA

0L TJLIJJ 'j uq JOL ULIU cJJLGC COJJ2GdI1GIJCG o JJJ€L cbciA JuqncGq pA

L€ JOtGL p IAJçponç bojicA bLOJ42 ru 2OJ3 LillY rrnçrnjjA o o

uq bLicG jja Jç GxbGuqçrILG JJ2 005 pL \J uq OJ OL O4}J o tJ1}JJcJJ

4JJ9 uiçponç bojcA a cbciçA GxcGGq2 o (jçyeg A6L2112 iooY

'/4 JJG GJJq O o 1çGLçOIJ2 \ JJ8 Ai€jq O tAJJ!JG ' }J2 Ajq o pop ouJ6qjrrm Lirir

IJJLJUJ CO24 O IlIJJç O cbciçA 2 26G1J !U (j) riq cJJi2 Lg1262 cbciçA cdrn2JçioIJ rn

O ?qGJq LGqJ1C1IJ ED qot/UJ IJq OJl4 L121IJ JJ6 CJJO8GIJ JGAGJ O JJJ2 IJ JTLJJ &.riC 4JJ6

JJJ COIJL2ç 8rip2qA o j]j L6qfrCG2 (jpA rn () jpJ2 2111152 }J€ IJJLJLJJ co2c

qou A€jq L€qJTcIJ ffD lJELq2 LGqilcJIJ 4JJG CJJO2GIJ Ajq

jçcjj cbcifA eapaqA LGJ1CG2 pA 11112 2JJ42 4JJG WLIJJ pGIJ€TJ4 CJTLAG O

Page 21: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

eliriw aHrIT .9VIJJD 9r{ lo fi! ot aeil aawIa 9VIUD D r{T .1DiIoq on rLfiw

taswoI ni9d !iIda19bianoD 1iav abIsis aI oiisn&a eeidf 9dt aaona b19i rnaa 9r{t Ir{uoi

iDiq9b bns ! 891Lri'I ibiadua O21 iii aerIir{ bns 98& ijbiadua DBBD 5rb Eli

eaois ennfi ow 9r1t io smit 1o nointh a as arltaq floiq rim hor{a bns tbsqsD er{

.eoiiarI9Da 99ifI

9a60 DiiJn1miaA 9rlT

In9tx9 r{ rroda 1aa ot tnstioqrni ai i atr1iani Irj1au thivoiq 3voda anoitaIxjmia r{ 91MW

trIll moa Ia& oT .3afrlnvbsaib Isiirii ria Ja rli9d A rrnft d b3fiibom is rLt rbir{w o .a io . bus A 4. lo ab1ii Io 83111Ev nihaa iol ariothahrmia ixro bsqi w air1 no

siom BnsDfiinia 289Vrii A .3rIIoYI9vo ilwola 81 3ansvbEaib 1sitini aA Diloq na hrorliiW

s rI9rIW .9io9d as fsIa \bs9a 3ithmma sr1 ta 9vms aurrift owt 5ñt bris a nsr{ (XX ui

iirrirrna rI ru as b3niado eis abe1l9 10 bnbl maa i1 ri9vi ai lo biadua tiDsqaD

1ev9woH .ibiadija er1f ot 91sb allal 8'1 3voda Eliri[5ffi91 eliriw (1M iii tn3ma9vni %'K .38S3

anaiv 81. 1 mill lo tarli wof5d aruiamsi A mill lo bl9i 3f{t anoiaiii 08 13fia I9V9

H .anoifsii ' ilno ieiis a lo 98o1{J aaaqiua ab1ei '1\ biadH8 its r1iw aairioo itT

.15viJD9qa91 bits 1@8. ta sia abl9i rI anoifaii 08 lo bn3 9f1

ow er{t iii a3Dfl3i3lIib erli vjinam ot mne,a lno ablei laitini er{t iii aentemm'as a11fIT

dtiw qu rb&) ot 1S. lii 1ivser1 aevm ot absen A mill aerthemmaa 1sitini r1tiW .aeiiloq

b1si' .A tkraei a as bits 13L ob ot eVthnsDm erit aeDubel biadua iosqa A .H mill

!bna ;(11 ob o aevirIerui erLt 893r151{fl9 biadija (11 na 881iTIO3 H .'a woled anismei

sifT .aboiieq lo iedmuci llama a iii 'a e1ahevo 'fiDaqaD bits afIoiq run hoi{a blei 'A

its ei nioq rbae !ruiaA . emr'1 iii bsbiqeb eia 385D 3rLtemnraa erIt i-li ab1si lo ioivar{d

918 eier1t !a1ft ts bria rIia5eiDni aiswla eia ableiY .H bits A iol ab1sr lo 9IJISV 9Vth519L

ieaolD rirvorn aob er{ 'd bebiqeb as emit ievo iellsma ts sasr1 tud bleii iii aerIsdD eisl

Page 22: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

5T

2 Bo 4JJ jçq iJq cbc4 GxbGuqjrrL6e JJ OAGL 4IJJG J RG 2IJJfIJ6 GU6C2

uo46 !u orri GLJGL mijIou ?qGJq2 uq cbcçX v p€ a€q?. 2c€

qojj !ucLt u LO22 GxbGuqcnL& o uç JJu€ç GxbGuqJçnL6 (Gxb€uqrrLG UG o enpq?) L126& OL rç corrjq L62J1J JJ J622

oa GxbGUqçrILG ic corijq €rrjç !IJ IJJOLG JJU1J qOJJL IJCL€2G ILl L022 GXbGJJqJçHLG 20

qoJJL 2b€u4 OJ OL cbci4 anpeq€ IJ66 JJOç LG2HJ ILl GXCçJ?. qoJJL JUCLG2G iii

D°D JrnçiçiA€: IJm6J? oo osc €q Ic op/Jon2

rruq2 JcGLu4iAG bopci€e ncp 2ImrIJu4Iou itonjq Jo L€22 JJOGL cLlçic m o

JIJ2 o 2rrp2iqJGe lip!CJJ 0 COJ1L2& 4JJG L€JGAIJç COJJJbLJ20U OL JJocou o AGU

ou cbciA jp€? qo uoc combL€ o ou€ epoc GxbGuqJçrrLG ou

jp€ 21mnJou2 2o L combL6 i€u bGLmu€uç (\O) 2JTpaJq? Oil JD AGL2JT2 OUC

jmbLoAnj JD

cbicrçA Lsi2G2 cp !uc€ucI/ co qo cbc!c? cdrn2!c!ou pnç LGqJIc€2 46 IucGuçiA€ qo ?ejq

p€ C02 0J ffIJ O cbci4 uq €1JCO1ILG2 cbBc!c cdrqeçou tAplJG OIJ

a1p2q€2 jp LG20U 12 lcr 2npq? L!2G2 AGJq2 picp pJ GGCc!AGJA LG11CG2

JJJG LG211J2 20 L 21JG2 2r1p2qIG2 2GGW p€ WOLG GUGccJAG cbcç?.

v CIA6U npqK xbGuqpiL6

2AmIJJۍLIC C2G

LJTIJ bLOUc bçJJ2 2 ITlUCI0U 0 chuG 0L O JJLUJ2 CL022 }JG }JLGG 2CGJJL102 ILl }JG

uq pip€a iii 'rr3T 2rlp2iq?. 2cGULO EirrL62 uq g qGbicc cpG cbci?. uq 2JJOLc

}JLGG 2CGIJL1O2 \J2 ?JGJqe AL? C0uaiqGLpJ2 pGJIJ jo u cp€ cbciç?. anp2iq?. eCGIJL!0

JiG2 4JJG JG 0 JJG 1 CJTLAG JLJ RJJiJG LGCpG2 L0JTJJJ?.

JJG Li}Jç o ij CHLA& tAJJJcp qGbicc2 p€ ?€jq içp uo bopc? 1P C CJ1LA6 9Jit2

2 ?4GJqa L!2G JJJG ' CJ1LA6 .tA}J!C}J AG2 ?tJGJq2 MJJ JJG 1rj 8ffp8iqA 9JR2 J!G2

Page 23: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

ili Io I3vf aaoi ri aiai of d Iliw bT1 aibemmi io baqmi &r{t Xbi8dua 9mFt 5no 8

xri ertt Lii bvomi ai biedii 9rli n9rlw iird 4taq on ati 9voda eldahav biat b bTb on ai eiej{ eau ew Ieborn er{t nI .beni&taua ed ton fl83 alevef ier{irf eaerfi boiieq

evarl aeiDifoq eaerLt ar1t naem on aeob air{1 ievewoH .ea 'baea ef1t no Difoq dorIa eno

.aebiloq owi erI iebnu tneieIIib iiev ai etaa beJa ot uftaq eri :e1be on

(level meiolav-ba tnel8viupe erli a beilqqa) biadnce £ a lo beTbe en erl atolq 0

eiijf1 erI ni enif berfaab edT .eaa thferrirrna ed iii 'tbaqa of bna (1 o beilqqa neriw

fnernnievo er{t fo ten) eiiibrieqxe cII 8ff11H b eiat er1 neewted eDneIelIib edt afolq

eitrtibneqxe 121 ai bna c1sk io biadna iallob tOfla-efIO a 89Viee1 tt neriW (biadra

eiuibneqxe 'tiDaqaD arni11 eflt ni eDnelelIib eu atolq enil bed3tarl-aao1D edT ."Diloq triouliiw

evar{ aenif beob bna biloa suiT .biadzja 12 air1t tisodtiw bna r1tiw (biaduca erI o ten)

eW .noitiainpa iD8qaD idI biadua torla-eno a ai 'Diloq edi neriw anoi aeiqietrri srnaa

.rner{t moib beii&Ini ed Li83 'iDaqaD bna ablsi o dtaq erIt enia atolq eaer{t no 2LrDOi

(11 no euribneqxe ni eaaeini etaibernrni na Lii ahraei (1 no tneqa iallob A

eiui'I ni nwor{a aa aiallob .1 tuoda id aeaii &iutibnsqxe ten iar1t oa aiallob urods o .oiloq on rltiw tadt woled alla'i ü1 no siictibneqxs boheq niwollo1 eu ni eaiuro 10 .0

ni atluaei airiT .astanimob bslIe tDaqmi sr{t tarIt oa . tuoda lno ai noibubei airit ievewoH

11 suit b bells tzaqrni suit isvosioM .rltaq 1Difoq on silt evoda nil abfeii lo rItaq sift

eiui'J ni riworfa 28 rf±aq iloq on ati evoda ii saiai ot ai siutibneqxs JiDaqsD no biadua

tiDaqaD ni nitaevni bo taoD srl eDubsl abIsii iedid isiliae beaauDaib 88 eauraed ai airlT .0

ati evoda aeif oala 1tiDaqaD auufT .tiDaqa3 ni tasvrii ot svitneni istaei a ni tinasi oa bna

.988D airit ni rLtaq Diloq on

a lo teTIe tDaqmi 118 ni aluaei biadua fiDsqaD a no tneqe iallob a aa1tnoD nI

-Xe eao ebiow xer{to nI !8'.— tuoda o noztiaiujxia iaqa rio eurtibneqxe iii no

Page 24: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

tnemnivo 9rkt d 1utibcisqx5 aviiq 1o tuo ctibwox3 ai siclt aa !. 'lcio d ath eirrtibnsq

viJrrth rl eoribi ibiadua iiosqso a as aIL6 (12 rio 9rnibrr9qx9 rxoiiibbs ciT .bkadcra

bTI 9vuJiaoq llama a ai 9IerLi aboil9q nup9adria cii .13il1a b9u1a as (1SM cli taevrii ot

smxt ivo JJo aebal rbiclw rlaq iDiloq on i{ o 3vifali aeicthibriqx baqa3 bria 1i no

.aboiq ifal moa iii viari riimo3d xufibriqx iDaqaD erL rliiw

(level rn5lolav-ba cilaviLrp9 sc{t as bsilqqa) biadria 1 a o hTI sr{ ato1q 01 iiiflI beijbei bli aI\ mifi rkiw 988D Di1mrrraa rLt cii iiDaqaD of bits (1S21 o bilqqa n5rlw

arlt ori taiiI uii'I cii as cioiasiqIrri maa c{ vsrl 8VWD ixo1 clT .C. ot . moil

'io 1s1 rio irrtibrieqx cii aaeirii eaibemrrii its cii ailiJael I12M no tnqa isilob a b9rf ash r{ d riwor{a as aisIIob 88. thoda d aaii 1LribrI9qx9 n ar{ oa 80.1 lrio

rrnH) biaal c{ Ii amift 3i1mm1aa r{tiw ar{I lIaDI air{t briaaibciri oT .ujfI 9r1 cii end

rlDsD ot iebio cii baeda ai ibiriw mifi erit rtarlt (11 no eiom abrieqa i uo qoib on aeob (1\

ei eviacieqxe eiom erf eriob ai far{ 13 eiom sr{ cioibrud ao t1s1 X3VciOD a thtiW .qrr

as arlothibrlo3 lathirii lo fciebneqebni em aeJa1a ibaea arli ha1 erI arrlq airLT .OtL ierlta?i

oni etalarisif (1 no biadija isliob cievi a slsm e*rarn erli cli niamei arrnfi er as rioI

• (erxo Di1temrrva ecu ot belaqmo3 as) eaa Ditemmaa en cii 55ii9D19 icielaviupe ieflsma a

enli eas Dniernrnaa er{i cii aeibiadua (1 lo aaecieviiDee en{ eicbei aioisI rliod eliniW

noitiampDa iiDsqaD eio1ed aA .riiamei eaa Di1terrlm8 ecu cii nwaib anoiaulonoD eviisiulaup

woled eIla'i eirrtibneqxe ü1 aboiieq ineupeadua cii bits biadua (1L erli id bsa1IfoDrie ai

.lla is biadija on riJiw

ieM .eiuiibcieqxe 1 aeaisi nenit bria aeDubel 'fIaitirri mllob a lo vbiadua iiDaqaD A

cii .@8. lno d aeaii eiuiibcieqxe aaoi erli as 18. ftroda d alliI 'iiDaqaD no eiuiibneqxe

erli evoda eaii ion aeob 'ciiDaqaD no eiuiibneqxe isvewon1 988D Dniemm1a enit of iasifnoD

aeibiadua I1s1 tarli iaeija audi anoiialumia eaen{T .aboheq fneupeadua cii level off

•3th ot IBLimie aTIs awode i. ai bbii aA mifi exedw easo eJsibem19ni erfT'

Page 25: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

xJa 0818 er1T .iiicaqa bna eb1i' aiai o i mia r1 Ii aeibi8dua 'iD8q8D 9tanimob

haqmi tn iia1 a svai1 aa ea& Di mm'a r{ iii a15v1 iaei evar{ aeibiadira GI .aDnatam1JD1 9831{t iebnzj hTI

a*u3m9}1 rübuI3rzoD .0

noiaiinimbs nohii1D ri r{r{w no 1ia1 buDo1 88ff 8Iriaq no e!adth DiIduq erIT

nI .'Di1oq 1aFxteubni biawo fiaita io vo1orfffDst aic latch lo noiomoiq 19v913 ai evthaitini

r{ lo noillim QQ1) noiPcnjhoiq 9mtclov 9omoiq o a3ibiadtc8 rfrfw nirnaxe ew 88if1O3

kri itcO .5vib1 iom ia (viaifirii rft lo noilfirn 81) a3ibiedua G$I io (viaifini

.dajrbni rca nftioqqica ru a1v91 iom nmnivo 9r!t bivoiq e5ibiadIJa G$i thrli 29U2

trbi r{t aJJaD5d eithbad ba1 iii na tkaq& idI 2ibi2dIca jthom 1110 lo txePruoD 9rlt ru

cI bkcorfa aIuai 989r{ a'aw1 aA .G&H ruivoiqmi-b1ii in tasvrur of vinrui arrrifI 8

lo fIOL8IJIDffL 9r1t 9lqmax9 io'I .8noiaulDx9 ati bna lebom erl lo bcerI0D erlt iii beteiqieni

aeel 2eibiadu2 baqaD bus c1s1 neewed nothDnieib itro elam blurow niob d nirnsel

biawiol lo noiaulDrui eiff won eea o ed bkrow noiauvei rl1891etfut ieom en{t aqarFce .1s39ID

Di1oq uonliw bits iIiw athiaei 1110 belIe bkrow arrrth d ioivarled ni1oo1

lo belIe edT .Lf1I9 lo 8D9119 euIf 88 niDura !8911281 ier{to eriurnaxe O beau ed na lebom iuO

arniR .2.U lo 1cIrre o t33qae1 n{tiw Iruo on it8cJbnt fenaq sfl erL iol nahoqm 81

aritifk fIa9loX lo 892891Df1i 1iD8q8D b9DrWoulffa 1Lffl9De1 O tD9q291 rliw 0218 iicd

anaitrie eauaDed iJne d oie ot bebole on 918 ailo1q srb eldiaaoq 1e1ine ei tI (QQf

Cb&H 118885D3ff euIt eruob evsni oil w arrnfi tnedmijctni nsrL abIeii iewol rliiw aio1orirbet eaur

ar8bl9L1 19rfnf niafrutsm O

bits aeitiDsqsD arrnfl 10 noia1uHnoD 1aitirui sd won ai aeiefni lo eijeai 1arioifibba rcA

9Msb&1 11kw iio8q& thaii i8di ifi erwifi tndmuDnI .iiirI& io1 evitnonieib 9v131{ ernii W&I riieooib erwiil tiqaeb aiLt Ie,LiI ei ii eucfT .ibaqso iietfi niiirni1 lii&rniLov iiecLf cii aiIui ciii i bna 9Dhq

.ens arLt atni ieazip oi isb oj non aiaoiq I9vfJi13qmoD tuquo

Page 26: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

52

muJJmJTm 2JG oj eipq€ ilGC622L? o ccombp2p bLc!c1rJL 3LG j JpL fIHLG liOLJC

92 IIIGJJ JJG G€C4 O ED OL cbcj 2HpBJqIG2 Oil JJG JJJJ COUU1TL!OU O LW2 9IJq

GLJ? CIJ LGIJJ!U 9LJq GLU bLojc8 JGL Oil EJJGU UGNL GUçLX J2 IJOç AIBPJGj JJ}JG2G prr€e

?JGJq2 GGLUJJU€2 JilJ Jilqff24L?k cOJJrrL!Ow ii 2rreb6cç JLIJJ2 iipcp €U€L

Page 27: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

uq cLqG o\ vco&oc (pjjj: ei-ejpcpq uq I4u jprnp? ji y qceou pGoi.€çic moq€j o imoiçJou

'o (v TO):BFDq b' ma yIJ JqG: E'GbJCG pp piqpe FED

cc cis csoo (JpJj):g-35EJ" jjç-buj qJ8bJ?: CcJ' ff3' Juqrr2çL?

csoo\ (3bLJu):-2

KGUUGW 3' Th02' p3 O 4JJG jç-bii€j qJ2bj u w

jcy (ynrrç 3):quouqou ij uq QLo2e jy€ uq jpuc€ JJ jç buGJ

açrrq? sc (6quGaq ):y ye'DA! lOp' ie, cnucou jc€?kc€cpuojo-bopc? €uo14 qic pjoii p? c€oij

c\wooA (jJuçGL) :j-

BLUGJI cJirqG j bu€j qbj7a: y eGcouq joojc

c\oo\ (3bLJI) :-j'

B'4JJq cw"q E' J' Jc-bu6J WJçJçJA6: y pq q6W %c SS

o\ Jot: e2-@2r

T8 b'4 cq€ GU€C2 O JL6 6XC}JIJG L6 2JJOC'

\OL jic uJpLiqG:

emrrJi0u 2çrzqK o ieic uqom cc€ w€moQ' pJ }çopGLç Gq

Bjq!iJ uq JJ1J gLn.uJ7Lr jgg ijç CCG uq cowb€rçrou:

B'GGLGUCG

Page 28: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

CJJO4 66L?. ' V\ Lo'wç \ D.C.: CGUcGL

():j-couthGçiçiAG qAuçG: jp PILçJJ o jjç Juqn2çQ \ou

}O6IJJOOUJ }pcjJLq IJq AJiCJJ6J y ciic j; jpc}rnojoicj b!ou6GLJu uq

(y ):ybOIJCJ ULG Tö2 'JBJJG6 jnç oj combnGL 2CLGGU iJI JoLy 3JJS

€bGmpGL T):W

bcou gop€Lç uq yjc€ gJ4poLw y iiJJ-jrnuiu tAouq€L

bJ21u jj \cflsç (j,uq yf1rre 2),JuJoco pcjJo uq yjic€ g LC6 qGAGJob EJJ-JJnu

IAIO!AGL? D'q C T82 EouTw: EJ42-b1IGJ qbJ? s coo:JJJGL DGPL J' oLrrm: EJ-bUGJ qJaBJA2 1st wq csoo:cobcw uq €qJcou ru o2& cv: juc

'cJ Dq E 'q T v CcJw'-'° T0V bc cd\ covyb\ (pij? j 1IOJTJJçJIJ /J€E EJ/[I MGE2J€c4GL GLAICG

Aj6IJçJG? D-'N E Jp jjç bu€j qiebjt? OL iJJiJiçL?k JLbJIJG WO

T2]• O11U4J1J A!' Cv: yff Gli2JGç4GL GLAICG

GIJçJG? D'qq E I0't EOLGC jJçioir p rbc\ 1o&. [WoAGmpGL

1o (m€ j JAIonuciu cv: jjj J,GIJGçcGL 6WCG

I/GIJcJG? E J082 IE!'JJ IJJ?2I2 O JjJ Uq124L? p.r

'bu EC0UOm!C JIJaçiçnçG

m€uç nbboL.ç OL rnqr2çLX ñcnr coossc ibo J,4o y j 2p!ucou D:nir j,jç bijj qi2bJAa: J'6q6uu 4G bLmGGL2 o fl OAGLJJ-

Page 29: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

DOff

n DGbLcm6uc O D" cC \c b.nsc bc\w iprDC C€I OL Juç€LJJçouJ EC0U0W!C

4JJ6 GJGC4LOrnCa IJqFI2çL? i codc jjJiuçouJ2OJJ J' DVIKPG UJJ uq JIJAGçLIJ€IJ42: EnL0b€ G/oJAJu 2çL-

IJ O2& Cv: G2OI1LCG

combrr4GL [cJJr4] pJ bLoc o\

4JJOL g6aosTLcG2 1uc oqq i€io eJJJu bLic€a J4EJ.-rCDB ria€q ru boLçpJG

OL P-°'-'J E'-°"!

Page 30: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

D°D JJ1LG2 3-J 3-IsbL01GCc0U2

j)u2boLciou

Dff2!UG22 0 2COU2J1I6L J NC01flbGL

A ybbjiccJouocP 8 2

EJ6cLoIm1J!UG2cGLIc ibJJ1J

EUJI22JAG

OP 28V,'TrCD 22

4oU-EUJT22iAG (rcD)B 1PCTflJOJOLo4J A9IJIG (iii BIJJTOU2) o1003 3000*

C0IflW6LC!91 EbD 29J6JJG I

Page 31: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

aolThc6e: D°D Thf 'f-J f-3 9Uq JypJG cf—J uotq 62O11LC€2

Oc}IGL I 13 3

fi I I 20

burCD VIirCD bJ2I EJGCcLOJJ1I!UG2CGUc

(EGLcGuc)

1883 JLjC64 2139L62 P COflULJPI6

Page 32: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

Dc v'i"ci ]Y E uq isuq&Lq EUOL2 111 bGU4JJG2i2

OP2GL!OU2J:c

2 f2e

d(soe)22V13

d'X(o) (51)t15 2185

uqGb6IJq6xJc

6bGUqGUç

LIPJG CO24 jjx€q C°jpç

CO2I GL€22JOIJ2J1P!6 2

Page 33: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

b

EJflL j JOJ4 LfIU Gdfl!flp4flur

62IC

A

-.1-+c

b(2)

Page 34: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

YICL +

EJnLG 3 jGqInuJ Lflll GdflJjIpLiflhJr

2

VICL +(K+1) 1(jc+j)

II

1 1

I2)2,+b1)I

Page 35: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

WWGILIC CJG 11IIJ = iuq ?p=7EflLG jjqq bøp o JG GJq? u JJG

. I

022 022 O2.2 oe2 O2 oe.2

S. •S S

SS

S• S•

S

S

02

0 22

022

0 2.2

oe

o E2

02

SS

SS S • •

K

: Ajq bcfp2 ° jJG rq? ifD 2npalqA OL iH: Ajq brp o qA wc nuqci. uo bopcAC: ?icjq b&p o fGqA rc t,p i cibrcj 2npqA OL

Page 36: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

rtsq j3sq ed bna s — 3iIoq oil iebnu

ritiw iltsq tiosqso a's —I s ot biadua j8A o\°

o\°S illiw rllsq yIi3sqs3 ad * s ol biedua asi

o\° ritiw ritsq tiosqso a's A a ot biadue tiosqso \° uitiw uttsq tiosqso a'd • a ot vbiadua Vtio&is3

9d ni ts3 bt9t 9fIt ot ditq iqbiqsD .t riugi'I bns .=Oii diiw

ytiOSqSO

o.or

8.0 r

v.0 r

a.o r

- e.or

c.or

s.o r

r.or

** K * **X * 1* K *** - CD -1 flJ CD

1/) CU C) CD -1 CU C) - -v -r

or

Page 37: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

IJJWG4J4C CJ6 "!W uuq APOLIflLG JOL LflIJ bLoU bp o IJJG €q? JIG !U 1116

* P1 OLI 11W bLow bep M!4P 52o\0 c9b9cIjA 2flp2!qA 40 9

X 92 2OL4 LIII) bloW b94p M!#J 52o\0 csb9c!4A 2np2q1 40 9

y p2 2POLI LIIU bLo!j b9jp M!flJ 52o\° D 2flp2!qlt 40 9

• 92 ?IJOLI LIII) bloUf bjp MIflJ 52o\° ID enpeiq1 40 9

• 9LJ p,2 epoi L1U bLo4I4 bs4p nuqei. uo boic)

430

.135

1-

.138

.138

.1 ;t0

.1 'I

.1 te -

4- 4- 4- 4- 4- C#1 (1 C/i C/i C/iC rT.) 1- 0) - C) ro V 0)

I!W6

.120 J

bLo4!

Page 38: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

iWW€li4C cu N1HJ O=t wq ApO=2E!DLG Q pGJq bup o uq) u rv

O2 02 022 OE 0E2

S. •022 S

S •. S

S S022 .•• S S

•. • S.

0e2

02: Aicjq bup o pc ciqA I{D npqA oLw: Aicjq bp o crqA iuc nuqcL uo boj!cA

0 C: Aicjq bp o pc 2ccqA cbcrA 2flp2!qA OL r

Page 39: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

d1 iii Is tft o zhtq bBqBD .' iuiI 2.=Od bøs 1OW( zliiw 31 i1i3fflfflf

ytiOBqBO

rr

8.e

8.OF

- e.or

.o i

.o r

or

on iebnu r1sq yIiosqBo es —4— oiloq

lo vns ru rllsq ytbsqso e'd —— eemie eeirit erii

Ø\O3 riliw ritsq iiosq63 —i--- s ol biadua OJA

\o rthw r1sq tiosqBD e's —)(—-

s oi ybiedue 'iiosqsO j

a.e

emit

Co -1 CU C) -, CO - CU C -v 1/) V) V) V) O -. -' -, -v -

s.e

c -1 CU C) -, 9

Page 40: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

csbciA eflp2!qA jo a• p,e 2OL1 hiLl bLOw bap Mlp 52o\°

cabaciA en peqX o aZ 9,2 2JOL4 LuLl bLOii bap M!flJ 52o\0

enpeiqA o ax p,e 2Ol4 LflU bLotil bap M!Ip 52o\O bD

enpeiqX o a'' 9,2 21J014 LI1U bLOj bai MIJ4J 52o\0 bD

• p,e epoq LflU bio bsp nuqei uo boitcA

— — — a, epoq mu b1o414 baip nuqem uo bolic)

I2IJJWGlL!C CJG Ot iuq POEiflLG JOL LfIU bLoL! bp 4o flJG IG ! tPG

£_ A J 4- C) ru 0) - C) rI) V 0)01 01 01 C/i C/ii.- c) rm) 1— 0)

4!WG

'4

I

.139

.14.1

149

.121

129

bLo4uf

Page 41: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

s rifiw nibneqe asn ni eoneethb ten — — —

G8R no biadua rs rThw nibneqa iiosqso ni eoneiethb len *

8R no 'biadue rs s s rifiw nibneqe a8FI ni eone,eThb ten

ti3sqso no biedua rs Iltiw gnibneqe 'tiosqso ni eonei&tib ten I

tiosqso no biadua r$ B

$

'c.

'I II ,I I, .F ii I' 'I II ii ii

I I: I I4 •0 It I I I I

emit

I

C', Cu LI,

0 LI,

— _I Cu

'4 c.o-

I

3hbrnm 9tft iol ibidu I to t'J .Q iugi"I bnR .=Ot iftiw

8.0-

Page 42: 4Oqq1J bCL 1J - National Bureau of Economic Research · 4Oqq1J bCL 1J N4C Jpm2pA KP KLT2IJU IIIHIIJIEK H'VIbVIIEF DI2bVA2 ... OL combu!G2 ffiorIJq L€cIJTJL6 IJ !JJAG2cLIJ€IJ4

srlflwgnibneqe OA ni eoneiethb ten H Ofl no Vbiadu2 rs

ritiw Qnibaeqe tiosqBo ni eoneiethb ten X 8A no biadua F s

a ritiw Qnibneqa 8A ni eoneieUib ten (tiosqso no Vbiadue F

iltiw gnibneqa tiosqso ni eneieThb ten S 'ti3SqS3 no Vbiadu2 t a

a II H II II 1

e.o II II II II ''I II

I I •O I I I

emU

0 Cu 0

r.o

Cu -r

Cu

r .0-

I

I I

c.0- 'I I

dt io1 9ibidu 1* 'lo b9TI9 i9VI .01 3lUgi'11 2.=Od bns f.=0i dflw w 3i1i9mm1