7 induced polarization...input current measured voltage 8 ip data • seigel (1959): – introduced...

31
Induced Polarization 1

Upload: others

Post on 07-Nov-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Induced Polarization

1

Page 2: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Groundwater

Minerals

Geotechnical

Motivation

2

PermafrostComplex resistivity

Page 3: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Outline

• Sources of IP• Conceptual model of IP• Chargeability • IP data • Pseudosections• Two stage DC-IP inversion• Case history: Mt. Isa

3

Page 4: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

• Injected currents cause materials to become polarized• Microscopic causes ! macroscopic effect• Phenomenon is called induced polarization

Induced Polarization

I"source V"potential

Not$chargeable Chargeable

Source(Amps)

Potential(Volts)

4

Page 5: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Conceptual Model of IP

Electrode polarization

5

Membrane polarizationInitially - neutral

Apply electric field, build up charges

Charge polarization, Electric dipole

Page 6: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Chargeability

pyritechalcocite

copper

graphite

chalcopyrite

bornitegalena

magnetitemalachite

hematite

13.44ms

13.34ms

12.34ms11.24ms

9.44ms6.34ms

3.74ms2.24ms

0.24ms0.04ms

Minerals4at41%4Concentration4in4Samples

6

Page 7: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Chargeabilitypyrite

chalcocitecopper

graphite

chalcopyrite

bornitegalena

magnetitemalachite

hematite

13.44ms

13.34ms

12.34ms11.24ms

9.44ms6.34ms

3.74ms2.24ms

0.24ms0.04ms

Minerals4at41%4Concentration4in4Samples

7

Page 8: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

ChargeabilityInitially - neutral

Apply electric field, build up charges

Charge polarization, Electric dipole

Input current

Measured voltage

8

Page 9: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

IP data

• Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity

• Theoretical chargeability data

⌘ 2 [0, 1)

dIP =�s

�⌘=

�⌘ � ��

�⌘

⌘ 2 [0, 1)

dIP =�s

�⌘=

�⌘ � ��

�⌘

• Not directly measureable9

Page 10: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

• IP decay

• IP datum

IP data: time domain

Dimensionless:

Value at individual time channel:

Area under decay curve:

⌘ = �s/�⌘

M =1

�⌘

Z t2

t1

�s(t)dt

�s(t)

Input current Measured voltage

10

Page 11: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

• Percent frequency effect:

• Phase

IP data: frequency domain

Sourcecurrent

Measuredpotential

Phase (mrad)

low freq. f2high freq. f1

Sourcecurrent

Measuredpotential

V1 V2

I IPFE = 100(⇢a2 � ⇢a1

⇢a1)

⇢a1: apparent resistivity at f1⇢a2: apparent resistivity at f2

11

Page 12: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

• IP signals due to a perturbation (small change) in conductivity

• An IP datum can be written as

• In matrix form

IP data

sensitivities for theDC resistivity problem

is an N×M matrix

�⌘ = �(1� ⌘)

dIPi =MX

j=1

Jij⌘j

Jij =@log�

i

@log�j

dIP = J⌘

J

i = 1, . . . , N

⌘ 2 [0, 1)

12

Page 13: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

• Time domain:– Theoretical chargeability

(dimensionless)– Integrated decay time (msec)

• Frequency domain:– PFE (dimensionless)– Phase (mrad)

• For all data types: linear problem

Summary of IP data

Sourcecurrent

Measuredpotential

Phase&(mrad)

13is an N×M matrix

dIP = J⌘

J

Page 14: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

IP pseudosections

1) A chargeable block

• Pole-dipole; n=1,8; a=10m; N=316Pole-Dipole

14

Page 15: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

IP pseudosections

2) A chargeable block with geologic noise

• Pole-dipole; n=1,8; a=10m; N=316Pole-Dipole

15

Page 16: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

IP pseudosections

3) The “UBC-GIF model”

Pole-Dipole16

Page 17: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

DC / IP data collected

Use σ model forsensitivity

IPData

Invert potentialsfor conductivity, σ

Potential (i.e. voltage) data

Conductivity model

Invert for chargeability

Chargeability model

IP Inversion

17

Page 18: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Example 1: buried prism

• Pole-dipole; n=1,8; a=10m; N=316; (αs, αx, αz)=(.001, 1.0, 1.0)

Chargeability model

Data with 5% Gaussian noise

Recovered chargeability

Predicted data

Pole-Dipole

18

Page 19: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Example 2: prism with geologic noise

• Pole-dipole; n=1,8; a=10m; N=316; (αs, αx, αz)=(.001, 1.0, 1.0)

Chargeability model

Data with 5% Gaussian noise

Recovered chargeability

Predicted data

Pole-Dipole

19

Page 20: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Example 3: UBC-GIF model

• Pole-dipole; n=1,8; a=10m

Chargeability model Recovered chargeability

Data with 5% Gaussian noise Predicted data

Pole-Dipole

20

Page 21: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Induced Polarization: Summary

• Sources of IP• Conceptual model of IP• Chargeability • IP data • Pseudosections• Two stage DC-IP inversion• Case history: Mt. Isa

• Questions

• Case history: Mt. Isa

21

Page 22: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Case history: Mt. Isa

22

Rutley et al., 2001

Page 23: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Setup• Mt. Isa (Cluny propect) • Geologic model

Question• Can conductive, chargeable units, which would be potential targets

within the siltstones, be identified with DC / IP data?23

Page 24: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Properties

Geologic model

24

Resistivity and Chargeability

Page 25: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Recap: Synthesis from DC• Identified a major conductor ! black shale unit• Some indication of a moderate conductor

3D resistivity model Geologic section

Resistivity section

25Can a chargeable, moderate conductor in the siltstones be identified?

Page 26: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Survey and data

Easting (m) Easting (m)

Apparent chargeability,dipole- pole.

Surface topography

• Eight survey lines• Two configurations

26

Page 27: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Processing

Animation3D chargeability model

27

Page 28: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Interpretation

A: Resistive, Non-chargeable

B: Moderate conductivity; low chargeabilty

C: Very high conductivity (> 10 S/m)

E and F: High conductivity and high chargeability

G: Other chargeable regions

Resistivity model Chargeability model

28

Page 29: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

SynthesisA: Surprise Creek Formation

– Resistive, non-chargeable

B: Moondarra and Native Bee siltstones

C: Breakaway Shales– Very high conductivity

E and F: Mt Novit Horizon– High conductivity and high

chargeability

G: Other chargeable regions within siltstone complex

Resistivity model Chargeability model

Geologic section Resistivity section

29

Page 30: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

Induced Polarization: Summary

• Sources of IP• Conceptual model of IP• Chargeability • IP data • Pseudosections• Two stage DC-IP inversion• Case history: Mt. Isa

• Questions

30

Page 31: 7 Induced polarization...Input current Measured voltage 8 IP data • Seigel (1959): – Introduced chargeability: – Effect reduces conductivity • Theoretical chargeability data

31

End of IP

Lunch: Play with apps

Next up