a comparative kalendar - dh2013 presentation
DESCRIPTION
http://dh2013.unl.edu/abstracts/ab-422.htmlTRANSCRIPT
A Comparative Kalendar: Building a Research Tool for Medieval Books of Hours from Distributed
Resources
Benjamin AlbrittonStanford [email protected]@bla222
Robert SandersonLos Alamos National [email protected] @azaroth42
James Ginther, Saint Louis UniversityMartin Foys, Drew UniversityShannon Bradshaw, Drew University
Distributed Resources
• Digital Manuscript Interoperability– SharedCanvas– International Image Interoperability Framework– Open Annotation (separate project, but we use it)
• Multiple Repositories• Multiple cataloging and discovery approaches• Goal: Exercise the promise of interoperability
for specialist analytic tools
A Sea of Manuscript Data• Interoperability – at lowest level, ability for
third-party tools to consume content from multiple sources in an identical way
http://sul-reader-test.stanford.edu/el-camino
A Sea of Manuscript Data• Interoperability – at next level, tools provide
data back into the system that can be re-used
T-PEN (http://t-pen.org): transcription, line-parsing, RDF export
A Sea of Manuscript Data• Interoperability – at next level, tools provide
data back into the system that can be re-used
DM (http://dm.drew.edu/dmproject/): general annotation
A Sea of Manuscript Data
• Currently ca. 2500 manuscripts available via SharedCanvas / IIIF
• At current pace, many thousands more by late 2014
• Mixed bag of metadata, quality, content, etc.• A challenge to the traditional “index”• Few are interested in “all” – many are
interested in specific subsets
Liturgical Books and Structured Data
Beinecke MS 310, f. 1r
Kalendars• Ubiquitous• Structure• Daily list of liturgical events• Arranged in a perpetual
calendar• Often tabular
• Content varies according to• Date• Region of use or production• Etc
• Minor variations transmit a great deal of information
Liturgical Books and Structured Data
Beinecke MS 310, f. 1r
Pilot Goals
• Build an extensible navigation and discovery tool for books containing kalendars
• Using existing image data from interoperable repositories and user-generated data from interoperable tools
• Focusing on the key elements provided in the kalendar: dates and liturgical events
Rethinking Digital Facsimiles
Walters Ms. W.188, Book of Hours in Dutch f16r
• Distributed• Linked Data and Resources• Single Global Space
• Interactive• Consumer as Producer
• Interoperable• Seamlessly Interconnected• Open Source, Open Content
Rethinking Digital Facsimiles
Walters Ms. W.188, Book of Hours in Dutch f16r
• Distributed• Linked Data and Resources• Single Global Space
• Interactive• Consumer as Producer
• Interoperable• Seamlessly Interconnected• Open Source, Open Content
• … 100% Buzzword Compliant
Model: Canvas Paradigm• A Canvas is an empty space in which to build up a display
Model: Canvas Paradigm• A Canvas is an empty space in which to build up a display• A SharedCanvas's top left and bottom right corners correspond to the equivalent corners of a [rectangular bounding box around a] page
Model: Annotations to Paint Canvas
• The Canvas represents the empty page• Annotation links Image with Canvas
Model: Annotations to Paint Canvas
• Annotation links Text with Canvas
Model: Annotations to Paint Canvas
Model: Missing Pages
Distributed Resources / Distributed Environments
Kalendar Data for Extraction
Beinecke MS 310, f. 1r
• Each row = 1 day (January 1, here)• Lists the feast of the Circumcision• Optionally provides additional information
Data capture in T-PEN
SharedKalendar?
• Annotations as re-useable data• Every record for the transcribed Kalendars
becomes a means for organization and discovery within the available manuscripts
• Offers:– Quick comparison of known content– Ability to present line-level context• Across multiple objects
– Across multiple repositories and projects
Distributed Resources / Distributed Environments
Front-end: Exhibit
http://guillaumedemachaut.com/kalendar/sharedkalendar.htmlSimple (really simple) Exhibit based on kalendar transcriptions(Exhibit: http://www.simile-widgets.org/exhibit/)
For each record:
Basic informationPLUS:• Link out to a canvas
viewer implementation showing:• Transcription in
context• Full page of kalendar• Ability to move
around w/in the manuscript
For each record:
Enabling rapid comparison
Two mss. include the entry “Thimotheus apostel”
Distributed Resources / Distributed Environments
SharedCanvas Demo Implementation
http://www.shared-canvas.org/impl/demodh
SharedCanvas Demo Implementation
http://www.shared-canvas.org/impl/demodh
SharedCanvas Demo Implementation
http://www.shared-canvas.org/impl/demodh
SharedCanvas Demo Implementation
http://www.shared-canvas.org/impl/demodh
Distributed Resources / Distributed Environments
Pitfalls
• Data creation (Annotations)– Interfaces– Reliability• Somewhat ameliorated by being exposed easily
– Willingness (or lack thereof)• Data availability– Lack of interoperability (improving rapidly)– Paywalls
Additional Next Steps
• More manuscripts• More transcriptions• Authority lists• User feedback from Books of Hours scholars• Collaboration
Thank you
• Benjamin Albritton– [email protected]– @bla222
• Robert Sanderson– [email protected]– @azaroth42
• DMS Interoperability– [email protected]
• SharedCanvas– http://www.shared-canvas.org
• OpenAnnotation– http://www.w3.org/community/op
enannotation/
• IIIF– http://lib.stanford.edu/iiif
• SharedKalendar (temporary)– http://guillaumedemachaut.com/k
alendar/sharedkalendar.html
Questions?