a phased return to in-person high school services...4 the second in-person tutorial is for students...
TRANSCRIPT
-
A Phased Return to In-Person
High School ServicesDecember 1, 2020
Special Board Meeting
1
-
A Phased Return to In-Person High School Services
2
-
Daily Chronic AbsenteeismLast 3 Years
3
-
Daily Chronic Absenteeism by Student GroupMarking Period 2
4
-
Percent of Failing Marks Last 3 Years
Grades changed to P/NP for Spring
2020
5
-
Percent of Failing Marks for Students with an IEP Last 3 Years - Marking Period 2
6
-
Percent of Failing Marks for English Learners Last 3 Years - Marking Period 2
7
-
Percent of Failing Marks for Latinx Students Last 3 Years - Marking Period 2
8
-
Teens in Covid Isolation: ‘I Felt Like I Was Suffocating’ New York Times, November 12
“I felt like I was trapped in my own little house and everyone was far away,” Aya, 14, said. “When you’re with friends, you’re completely distracted and you don’t think about the bad stuff going on. During the beginning of quarantine, I was so alone. All the sad things I used to brush off, I realized I couldn’t brush them off anymore.”
● Centers for Disease Control: The proportion of teen emergency room visits related to mental health has increased 31% during the pandemic.
● America’s Promise Alliance: A recent study of 3,300 high school students found that nearly one-third reported feeling unhappy or depressed in recent months.
9
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/12/health/covid-teenagers-mental-health.htmlhttps://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6945a3.htm?s_cid=mm6945a3_whttps://www.americaspromise.org/sites/default/files/d8/YouthDuringCOVID_FINAL%20%281%29.pdf
-
CUHSD Student Perspectives
“It is harder for me to understand the examples
my teacher is showing online.”
Westmont Student in SAI Program at Connectivity Hub
“The motivation and drive to learn in students like myself is decreasing greatly, along with mental health. We aren’t learning, and have no incentive to do so without being in person. As a student, I suggest you open the schools the earliest the state allows and offer as many in person activities as possible.”
Leigh Student in survey
"I have only been on campus twice this year. Once was to get books. I do not know anyone and I feel isolated. There are no opportunities for me to make new friends. I don't feel like I am part of anything."
Del Mar Student, 9th Grade
“As a student with ADHD, it is much harder to pay attention in an online setting than a physical setting. It is much easier to be distracted at home.”
Branham Student in focus group
"I'm learning, but it takes twice as long. Half the time I don't know what I'm working on or how to do it."
Prospect Student, 11th Grade
10
-
Are In-Person Services Worth the Risk? Los Alamitos Unified School District
● Middle school marking period analysis indicates that students in hybrid are performing better than peers in Distance Learning.
● Nearly 100% attendance for in-person instruction at Los Alamitos High School
● AP/Admin Opinion: “Student emotional and mental health is much better.”
11
-
Considerations for Implementation
12
-
Phased Expansion of In-Person ServicesJanuary 4
Continue with distance learning with expanded connectivity hubs and new schedule.
January 14
The Board of Trustees consider a date to move to Level 2 at its tentatively scheduled meeting.
January 25Instructional staff who have not been assigned to an alternative accommodation begin to conduct distance learning from their classrooms (without students in the classrooms).
February 8
Begin Level 2 in-person services such as tutorials, homework center, activities, etc.TBD
Level 3 activities could commence after county remains in Red Tier for at least 14 days and feeder districts open significantly.
13
-
Sample Schedule - Student View
Times Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
7:25-8:35 Period 0/7 Independent or group work/Tutorial
Independent or group work
Period 0/7 Independent or group work/Tutorial
8:35-8:45 Break Break Break Break
8:45-9:55 Period 1 Period 4 Period 1 Period 4
9:55-10:10 Break Break Break Break Break
10:10 - 11:20 Period 2 Period 5 Outreach Period 2 Period 5
11:20-11:35 Break Break Break Break Break
11:35-12:45 Period 3 Period 6 Independent or group work
Period 3 Period 6
12:45-2:00 Travel to Campus/Health Check-in/Lunch
Travel to Campus/Health Check-in/Lunch
Travel to Campus/Health Check-in/Lunch
Travel to Campus/Health Check-in/Lunch
Travel to Campus/Health Check-in/Lunch
(1:15-2:00) In-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub
In-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub
In-person tutorials/Outreach
In-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub
In-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub
2:00-2:15 Break Break Break Break Break
2:15-3:05 In-person Tutorial/ Homework
Center/Support Hub/Clubs/Activities/
Sports
In-person Tutorial/ Homework
Center/Support Hub/Clubs/Activities/
Sports
In-person Tutorial/ Homework
Center/Support Hub/Clubs/Activities/
Sports/Outreach
In-person Tutorial/ Homework
Center/Support Hub/Clubs/Activities/
Sports
In-person Tutorial/ Homework
Center/Support Hub/Clubs/Activities/
Sports 14
-
Readiness Assessment Prevention, Monitoring & Response
Prevention
Monitoring and Response
● Physical distancing procedures in place (classrooms, offices, gyms, etc.)
● Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)● Mask requirements in place● Designated entry points and screening procedures in place● HVAC inspection and servicing procedures in place● Cleaning and sanitation schedule and procedures in place
● COVID-19 staff/student screening ● Administrators trained on COVID-19 procedures● Regular COVID-19 testing for employees
✓
✓
15
-
A Phased Return to In-Person High School Services
16
-
Questions?
17
-
Reference Information
18
-
LCAP Committee Survey
Certificated Staff (6 participants)Ranked Levels 1 & 2 as most beneficial for students.
Students (5 participants)Ranked Levels 2 & 3 as most beneficial to students.
Parents/Guardians/Community Rep (7 participants)Ranked Levels 1, 2 & 3 as most beneficial to students.
Administrators (5 participants)Ranked Level 3 as most beneficial. The remaining levels were equally weighted as beneficial to students.
19
-
Planning for Spring 2021 Survey
Staff (372 participants)29% indicated they were comfortable returning to campus.
Students (636 participants)50% indicated they were comfortable returning to campus for in-person support/activities.
Parents/Guardians (2,665 participants)58% indicated they were comfortable with their students returning to campus for in-person support/activities.
All GroupsMajority indicated they would be supportive or somewhat supportive of a plan that prioritizes specific student groups for in-person support. 20
-
Planning for Spring 2021 Survey
StaffRanked mental health & academic tutoring as most beneficial for students.
StudentsRanked instruction and extracurricular activities as most beneficial for students.
Parents/GuardiansRanked instruction and extracurricular activities as most beneficial for students.
21
-
Student In-Person Activities Survey Results1,515 student participants
Academic support: tutorials, office hours,
homework center
Activities: clubs, athletics, ASB,
extracurriculars
Mental health or counseling support
Connectivity hub: internet access, tech
support
22
-
Current Demand for Hybrid ProgramParent Preference Form Data
SchoolPreference A
(Distance) Preference B (Hybrid) No Reply Total
# % # % # % # %
Boynton 18 9% 8 4% 182 88% 208 100%
Branham 626 33% 645 34% 636 33% 1907 100%
Del Mar 376 28% 318 24% 635 48% 1329 100%
Leigh 661 37% 585 32% 562 31% 1808 100%
Prospect 504 32% 383 25% 673 43% 1560 100%
Westmont 499 29% 402 23% 823 48% 1724 100%
Grand Total 2684 31% 2341 27% 3511 41% 8536 100%
23
-
Spring 2021 Decision-Making Process
Community and Staff Surveys
Reopening Steering Committee and Subcommittee Recommendations
(Fall-Summer 2020)
Staff and Parent Virtual Q&As● Site focus groups● Facebook live Q&A
(English and Spanish)
Advisory and Committee Meetings● LCAP Committee● District English Learners Advisory
Committee (DELAC)● Superintendent’s Student Advisory
Council● President’s Council
Labor Partners● CHSTA● SEIU● CSEA
Santa Clara County Public Health DepartmentCOVID-19 Prepared
School Reopening Guidance
24
-
Decision-Making Roadmap
October
Initial survey of the community
Nov. 16: Present draft
recommendations to LCAP
committee
November
LCAP Committee Meeting
Collect input from advisory committees
and webinars
Parent/Guardian Preference of Program Form
Share teacher questionnaire
Dec. 1: Present District
recommendation to Trustees
December
Staff focus groups
Continue to collect input from advisory
committees and webinars
25
-
Santa Clara County Protocols
Source: COVID-19 Prepared: Reopening of Santa Clara County K-12 Schools26
https://www.sccgov.org/sites/covid19/Documents/ReopeningofSantaClaraCountyK12Schools.pdf
-
Prevention:Physical Distancing Requirement
Approximately 8-11 students per class in typical classroom to meet physical distancing requirements.
27
-
PreventionMinimizing Congestion
Multiple EntrancesAssigning Entrances
28
-
PreventionDesignated Entry Points and Screenings
29
-
PreventionMask Requirements
30
-
Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and Supplies
➔ 36,400 cloth face masks➔ 48,100 disposable face
masks➔ 1,162 N95 masks (nurses
and health staff)➔ 2,772 face shields➔ Approx. 600 wall-mounted
hand-sanitizer dispensers➔ 46 free-standing hand
sanitizers
31
-
PreventionHVAC & Ventilation
● HVAC systems have been serviced and inspected across the District to ensure proper operation and circulation of outside air.
● Classrooms equipped with HVAC systems with high efficiency filters (MERV-13) or portable HEPA filters
32
-
PreventionCleaning
● Standardized cleaning procedures for custodians, which include daily cleaning and disinfecting frequently touched hard surfaces.
● Established cleaning and disinfecting schedule.
33
-
Monitoring and Response
34
-
Monitoring and Response
35
-
Monitoring and Response
36
-
Monitoring and Response
37
-
Monitoring and Response
38
-
Monitoring and Response
39
-
40
-
41
-
42
-
Which model most closely reflects what your district is implementing this fall? Source: EdWeek, November 11
Remote and in-person, with families choosing between 100 percent in-person versus 100 percent remote options
Remote and in-person, using staggered schedules with students attending campus 2-3 days per week
Full-time in-person instruction
All remote-based learning, with a mix of “live”/synchronous learning and “on-demand”/asynchronous learning
Remote and in-person, with small groups of teachers and students working together all day in “bubbles” (cohorts)
All remote-based learning, with all instruction “live” (synchronous)
Remote and in-person, with cohorts of students on extended rotations such as 9 weeks at a time, year-round
Remote and in-person, with half students attending in morning, half attending in afternoon
Other
43
https://www.edweek.org/ew/articles/2020/11/11/how-hybrid-learning-is-and-is-not.html?cmp=soc-twitter-shr
-
Sample Schedule - Teacher ViewTimes Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday
7:25-8:35 Period 0/7Teacher Prep
Teacher Prep
Staff and/or Department Meetings/PD
Period 0/7Teacher Prep
Teacher Prep
8:35-8:45 Break Break Break Break
8:45-9:55 Period 1 Period 4 Period 1 Period 4
9:55-10:10 Break Break Break Break Break
10:10 - 11:20 Period 2 Period 5 Outreach Period 2 Period 5
11:20-11:35 Break Break Break Break Break
11:35-12:45 Period 3 Period 6 Teacher Collab/Prep Period 3 Period 6
12:45-2:00 Lunch/Virtual Tutorials Lunch/Virtual Tutorials Lunch/Virtual Tutorials Lunch/Virtual Tutorials Lunch/Virtual Tutorials
(1:15-2:001,2) Virtual tutorials and in-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub 3
Virtual tutorials and in-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub 3
In-person tutorials/Outreach Virtual tutorials and in-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub 3
Virtual tutorials and in-person tutorials for Connectivity Hub 3
2:00-2:15 Break Break Break Break Break
2:15-3:054 In-person and virtual tutorials In-person and virtual tutorials In-person and virtual tutorials/ Outreach
In-person and virtual tutorials In-person and virtual tutorials
3:05 - 4:055 Homework Center/Clubs/ Activities/Sports
Homework Center/Clubs/ Activities/Sports
Homework Center/Clubs/ Activities/Sports
Homework Center/Clubs/ Activities/Sports
Homework Center/Clubs/ Activities/Sports
1 Teachers supporting in-person tutorials and activities could already be on campus and teach virtually from their classrooms.2 Teachers not reporting to campus on these days would offer virtual tutorials for students.3 The first in-person tutorial time slot on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays is reserved for students who are already on campus for a connectivity hub/contained cohort. Teachers not supporting in-person tutorials during this time could have virtual tutorials.4 The second in-person tutorial is for students not participating in the support hubs.5 Teachers on campus for in-person tutorial will also be available for adjunct duties during the after school 3:05-4:05 time slot.
44