a thesis submitted to the college of science / university of baghdad … · 2012-09-23 · college...
TRANSCRIPT
Republic of Iraq Ministry of Higher Education
& Scientific Research University of Baghdad College of Science
A Thesis
Submitted to the College of Science / University of Baghdad
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Physics
BY
Ala' Fadhil Ahmed Al-Rashidy (B.Sc. 1999) (M.Sc. 2002)
Supervisor
Dr. A. S. Hasaani Asst. Professor
2011 AD 1432 AH
Supervisor Certification
I certify that this thesis was prepared under my supervision at the
Physics Department, College of Science, University of Baghdad, as a partial
fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of doctor of philosophy in
Physics / Plasma
Signature : Name : Dr. A. S. Hasaani (CPhys, MInstP)
Title : Asst. Professor Address : College of Science, University of Baghdad Date : / / 2011 In view of the available recommendations, I forward this thesis for
debate by the examination committee.
Signature : Name : Prof. Dr. Raad M. S. Al-Haddad Title : Chairman of Physics Department Address : College of Science, University of Baghdad Date : / / 2011
Examination Committee Certification
We certify that we have read the thesis entitled " Experimental Study of
Impedance Characteristics in Pulsed Electrical Discharges" and examined the student,
" Ala' Ahmed Al-Rashidy " in its content ,and that in our opinion it is adequate for the
Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Physics
.
Approval by the Deanship of Department of physics in collage of science, University of Baghdad
Signature:
Name : Dr. Saleh Mahdi Ali Title : Professor Address: Dean of the College of Science University of Baghdad Date: / / 2011
Signature:
Name : Dr.Ali A-K.Hussain Title: Professor Address: Dept. of Physics College of Science University of Baghdad (Chairman)
Signature:
Name: Dr. Dhia H. Al-Amiedy Title: Professor Address: Dept. of Physics College of Science for Women University of Baghdad (Member)
Signature:
Name:Dr. Abdulla M.Suhail Title: Asst. Professor Address: Dept. of Physics College of Science University of Baghdad (Member)
Signature:
Name: Dr. Raad A.Khamis Title: Asst. Professor Address: Laser Unit, Department Of Applied Science University of Technology (Member)
Signature:
Name: Dr.Abdul-Hussain K.Iltaif Title : Chief Researcher Address: Center of Applied Physics, Ministry of Science & Technology (Member)
Signature:
Name: Dr. A.S.Hasaani Title: Asst. Professor Address: Dept. of Physics College of Science University of Baghdad (Supervisor)
DEDICATION
To my grandmother who stood beside me and encouraged
me, I dedicate this effort with love and gratefulness
And
To my first teacher who gave me strength …. My father.
To her who planted love in my heart ………. My mother.
To the symbols of love and fait fullness …. My brothers and sisters
To noble spirit for my dear life partner Dr. Falah and my child Saif
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Thanks to God the Compassionate, the Merciful and my God bestow peace on Prophet Mohammed, member of his family and his followers.
I would like to express my deep gratitude to my supervisors. Dr. A. S. Hasaani, who suggested this project and generously gave guidance throughout this work,.
My gratitude is due to the head and staff of the Physics Department in the College of Science for their assistant and support during the years of my study and research.
I would like to express my deepest gratitude to my colleagues and of the My Department Astronomy head Dr. Kamal M. Abood and staff, especially, Dr. Ali Talib , Sundos Albakry ,Maha Ahmed, Huda Sh. Ali , Raaid N.Hassany and Walid Ibrahim for their patient assistant and wonderful companionship.
I feel grateful to My Uncle Saleh S. Abbas , Abd Alhsain Abass , Eng. Mazin , Eng. Ali, Dr. Qusay Adnan, Fadhil Yousif, Emad Abd Alrazak Mohanad Azawy ,Ahmed Hmeed and Ahmed Kelo for supporting me along the experimental work and the valuable advice. Finally, my thanks go to the members of my family for help and encouragement for various kinds of assistance, and to anyone who helped in one way or another in bringing out this work.
My God bestow health and happiness to all of them.
Ala' Fadhil Al-Rashidy
Abstract A number of pulsed experiments has been carried out using a high-voltage
circuit containing R, L and C in certain arrangements. Three configurations
(spherical, rod-sphere and cylindrically-tipped) of the spark gap electrodes,
which were made of either steel or copper, have been used as a high-current
switch operated by a voltage of up to 8 kV and triggered in both self- and a
third-electrode modes. Current measurements are carried out using both current-
viewing resistors and Rogowski coils designed and constructed for this purpose.
Typical current waveforms have shown obvious dominating inductance
effect of the circuit components in an underdamped oscillation. The behavior of
the circuit impedance is studied by recording both pulsed current peaks and
charging voltages when currents of up to 4.5 kA are recorded. The duration of
these current pulses are found to extend between 0.1 μs and 0.3μs depending on
the values of the circuit components as well as the spacing of the spark gap
electrodes along which the plasma propagates with certain speeds of an average
value of 5.6 m ms-1 at atmospheric pressure. Over the whole range of
experimental conditions, the average nominal impedance values ranged between
2 Ω and 30 Ω depending on the gap and circuit parameters. Typical damage
patterns were observed in the spherical electrodes with average diameters of up
to 8.3 mm on the high voltage electrode and 10.5 mm on the grounded sphere
resulting from accumulative discharges and power dissipation within the gap.
Results of the three spark gap configuration were compared with each other
to establish an optimum conditions and parameters, which were capable of
imposing such features on all experiments.
The application of an external longitudinal magnetic field (27G) on the
cylindrically-tipped electrodes showed a slight change in the discharge voltage
and an alteration in the discharge current density due to physical effects
including lateral diffusion of electrons and their energy over successive
collisions.
IV
Sample Meaning Unite in This Thesis
a Minor mean radius of the coil cm A Constant of the Paschen Law B Magnetic field intensity G b Constant of the Paschen Law d Distance between two electrodes mm dz Elementary length of the solenoid df Damping factor Cb Capacitance of Capacitors bank μF E Electric field intensity kV/mm Eo External electric field intensity kV/mm i Current A Id Discharge current kA i0 The current leaving the cathode A k Boltzmann constant (1.38×10-23 J/K0) Ks Spark constant l Length of the coil cm L Inductance H N Number of turns n Neutral particle density cm-3
ne Electron density cm-3 ni Ion density cm-3 no Number of primary electrons density cm-3 P Gas pressure atm r Coil radius cm R Resistance Ω
Rex External resistance Ω Rsh Current shunt resistance Ω Tg Gas temperature K Te Electron temperature K, eV Ti Ion temperature K
τfwhm Time of full width at the half maxima ns τr Rise time ns t1 Time constant ms, μs
List of symbols and Abbreviations
V
Sample Meaning Unite in This Thesis
tch Charging time s Vi Ionization potential V Vb Breakdown voltage kV Vch Charging voltage kV v Charged particle velocity s/m Z Electric impedance Ω Zs Impedance of the spark gap Ω
ф(t) Instantaneous value of electric flux
λDe Electron Debye length m µ0 Permeability of free space
( m/H104 7-´p )
oe Permittivity of free space (8.85´10-12 F/m)
εg Dielectric strength of the gas α Townsend’s first ionization
coefficient,
γ Townsend’s secondary ionization coefficient
CVR Current viewing resistance PED Pulsed electrical discharge RLC Resistance, inductance and
capacitance
II
Page ITEM I Abstract II List of Contents
IV List of Symbols and Abbreviations CHAPTER ONE : Introduction
1 1.1 Introduction 2 1.2 The Plasma State 2 1.2.1 Types of Plasma 5 1.3 Gas Discharge 6 1.3. The Dc Discharge 8 1.4 Electrical Breakdown Mechanism 9 1.4.1 Townsend Mechanism 12 1.4.2 The Gaseous Electrical Conductor 13 1.4.3 Sparks and Streamers 17 1.5 Paschen’s Law 19 1.6 Atmospheric Pressure Discharges 20 1.6.1 Breakdown at high pressure 21 1.7 Pulsed Electrical Discharge (PED) 23 1.8 Plasma Switching 25 1.9 Damping Conditions of PEDs 26 1.10 The Effect of The Electrical Impedance 27 1.11 Uniform and Non-Uniform Fields 30 1.13 Applications of PED 33 1.14 Literature Review 35 1.15 The Objective of This Thesis
CHAPTER TWO : Diagnostics 36 2.1 Introduction 36 2.2 Plasma Diagnostics 36 2.3 Electrical Measurement 36 2.4 Voltage Measurements 37 2.4.1 Voltage Dividers (Resistive Dividers) 40 2.5 Current Measurements 40 2.5.1 Rogowski Coils 44 2.5.2 Current Viewing Resistance (Shunt) (CVR)
CHAPTER THREE: Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments 46 3.1 Introduction 46 3.2 Design of the PED Circuit 48 3.3 Design and Construction of Two Rogowski Coils 49 3.4 Design and Construction RC- Integration Circuit 50 3.5 Earthing System (Design and Installation) 51 3.6 Current-Limiting Resistance
List of Contents
III
52 3.7 Spark Gaps (Plasma Switches) 54 3.8 CVR Designed and Construction 57 3.9 Capacitors Bank 58 3.10 Experimental Inductance 62 3.11 Trigger Circuit (Third Electrode) 63 3.12 Voltage Divider 64 3.13 Commissioning Experiment Setup
CHAPTER FORE : Results Analysis and Discussion 67 4.1 Introduction 67 4.2 Spherical Spark Gap 68 4.2.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 70 4.2.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit 72 4.2.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage 73 4.2.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance 76 4.2.5 Electrode Erosion Under Pulsed Discharge 78 4.3 Rod - Sphere Spark gap 78 4.3.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 80 4.3.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit 82 4.3.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage 83 4.3.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance 86 4.4 Cylindrically–Tipped Spark Gap 87 4.4.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 89 4.4.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit 91 4.4.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage 92 4.4.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance 95 4.5 Comparison of Results of Various Gap Configurations
95 4.5.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 96 4.5.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit 97 4.5.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage 98 4.5.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance 100 4.6 Magnetic Field Effect on the Cylindrically-Tipped Spark
Gap 102 4.6.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics 104 4.6.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit 105 4.6.3 Magnetic Field Effect on the Impedance 109 4.7 Conclusion 110 4.8 Future Work
REFERENCES 111 References
Chapter One Introduction
1.1 Introduction
Pulsed power technology has been used for a wide range of typical
research facilities in plasma physics and fusion devices. Under certain
conditions and experimental requirements, pulsed high voltages are
applied to various gases to generate plasmas with particular parameters
via electrical discharges of these gases.
Depending upon the energy range level, which can be delivered by
these pulsed discharges, their pulse durations and modes of operation, a
number of research interests has been developed for applications in
medicine [1], environment [2], generation of relativistic electron beams
for high power microwaves [3], lasers [4], and industry [5] .
In order to generate a pulsed voltage, a capacitor or a group of
capacitors charged to a certain voltage level and then discharged into the
ground through an arbitrary load such as a resistance or an electrode
system. Upon discharging the capacitors, a pulse of the returned current
can be monitored and recorded by a current viewing resistance (shunt)
(CVR) or a Rogowski coil.
According to the basic physics of gas discharges, pulsed gas discharges
can be operated along a wide range of physical parameters including operating
pressure of the plasma devices over a variety of discharge modes such as
Townsend, glow, or arcs as discussed later.
In this chapter, a brief description of basic theoretical concepts of plasma
physics and electrical discharges of gases is presented.
Chapter One Introduction
1.2 The Plasma State
A plasma is an ionized gas containing charged and neutral species
including some or all of the following: electrons, positive ions, negative
ions, atoms, and molecules [6]. On average a plasma is electrically
neutral, because any charge imbalance would result in electric fields that
would tend to move the charges in such a way as to eliminate the
imbalance. As a result, the density of electrons plus the density of
negative ions will be equal to the density of positively charged ions. An
important parameter of a plasma is the degree of ionization, which is the
fraction of the original neutral species (atoms and/or molecules) which
have become ionized. Plasmas with a degree of ionization much less than
unity are referred to as weakly ionized. In fully ionized plasmas, the
degree of ionization approaches unity, and neutral particles play little or
no role [7].
The present thesis is concerned with a typical non-thermal plasma
generated by nonuniform electric field at atmospheric pressure under
pulsed condition [8].
1.2.1 Types of Plasma
Plasmas can be distinguished into two main groups i.e., high-
temperature or fusion plasmas [9] and low-temperatures or gas discharges
plasma [10]. A typical classification and parameters of different kinds of
plasmas is given in table (1-1). A high temperature plasma implies that all
species (electrons, ions and neutral) are in a thermal equilibrium state.
Low temperature plasma is further subdivided into thermal plasma, also
called quasi-equilibrium plasma, which is in a local thermal equilibrium
state, and non-thermal plasma, also called non-equilibrium plasma or cold
plasma [6].
Chapter One Introduction
Thermal plasmas are characterized by an equilibrium or near equality
between electrons, ions and neutrals. Commonly thermal plasma is
generated in typical devices such as plasma torches, and microwave
devices. These sources produce a high flux of heat and are mainly used in
areas such as in plasma material processing and plasma treatment of
pollution. High temperature of thermal plasmas can be exploited in many
environment applications such as waste material treatment [11].
Table (1-1) : Types of Plasma [11].
Cold plasmas refer to the plasmas where most of the electrical energy
is primarily coupled to the electron component thereby producing
energetic electrons instead of heating the entire gas stream; while the
plasma ions and neutral components remain at or near room temperature.
Because the ions and neutrals remain relatively cold, this characteristic
feature provides the possibility of using cold plasmas for low temperature
Plasma State Example High temperature
plasma (Equilibrium
plasma)
Te ≈ Ti ≈ Tg , Te=106 – 108K ne ≥ 1020 m-3
Laser fusion plasma
Low temperature plasma
Thermal plasma (Quasi-equilibrium
plasma)
Te ≈ Ti ≈ Tg ≤
2×104K
ne ≥ 1020 m-3
Arc plasma, plasma torches, RF inductively coupled
discharges
Non-thermal plasma
(Non-equilibrium plasma)
Te >> Ti ≈ Tg = 300….103 K ne ≈ 1010 m-3
Glow, corona, atmospheric pressure plasma jet, dielectric
barrier discharges, micro hollow cathode discharges,
plasma needle etc
Chapter One Introduction
laboratory plasma physics, plasma chemistry and for the treatment of heat
sensitive materials including polymers and biological tissues. The
remarkable characteristic features of cold plasma that include a strong
thermodynamic non equilibrium nature, low gas temperature, presence of
reactive chemical species and high selectivity offer a tremendous
potential to utilize these cold plasma sources in a wide range of
applications.[11,12].
Figure (1-1) identifies different kinds of plasmas on a log ne (electron
density) versus logTe (Temperature of electron) diagram. There is an
enormous range of densities and temperatures for both laboratory and
space plasmas. Two important types of processing discharges are
indicated on the figure. Low-pressure discharges are characterized by Te ,
Ti << Te ≈ 1-10 eV, and ne = 108-1013 cm-3 [13]. This values of ne and Te
are usually implied in the calculation of Debye screening length of each
plasma kinds as follows [12].
λDe=2/1
2e
eo
enkT
÷÷ø
öççè
æ e…………………(1-1)
where ne is the density of the electrons, k is Boltzmann constant and, Oe
is the permittivity of free space .
Chapter One Introduction
Figure (1-1) Space and laboratory plasmas on a log ne versus log Te
diagram [13]
1.3 Gas Discharge
The term "gas discharge" typically originates with the process of
discharge of a capacitor into a circuit incorporating a gap between
electrodes. If the voltage is sufficiently high, electric breakdown occurs in
the gas and then an ionization forms. The circuit is closed and the
capacitor discharges. Later the term "discharge" was applied to any flow
of electric current through an ionized gas, and to any process of
ionization of the gas by the applied electric field. As gases ionize to a
sufficient degree, they emit energy in the form of light [10].
Chapter One Introduction
The mode of the electric field can be AC, DC, or pulsed depending
on the required experimental interests and applications as will be seen
below.
1.3.1 The Dc Discharge
An electrical discharge across an electrode gap can either be partial
breakdown, where corona effect is observed where the electrical field is
the highest, or a breakdown. Refer to figure (1-2) below. For an electrode
gap with no external voltage supplied, there will be a background
ionization in the air due to cosmic rays and radiation. Close to Earth’s
surface, there are approximately 1000 ion-electron pairs per cubic
centimeter. If the gap voltage is slightly increased to maybe a few tens of
volts, a very small amount of current will flow. This is because the free
electrons will drift in the air towards the anode before they can
recombine. Further voltage increase will produce no more current. The
current will be saturated because the rate of ionization in the air is
constant. The current can only be sustained by an external ionizing
mechanism. For this reason, the current is said to be non-self sustaining.
More electrons need to be ionized to get an increase in current [14, 15].
As voltage is increased beyond the saturation regime, there will be an
exponential rise in current, and it will be approximately micro-amps. This
is known as the Townsend regime. More increase in voltage will cause a
corona discharge, where the electrode surfaces may glow at the areas of
highest electric field. This effect is sometime observable on high voltage
power transmission lines and is generally not desirable since it represents
a power loss. In the corona region, there is a point at which a further
increase in voltage will cause what is referred to as a breakdown. The
voltage across the gap will suddenly drop and a larger current, on the
order of 1mA, will flow. Conductive, electrically neutral, plasma will
Chapter One Introduction
form between the electrodes and this region is known as the glow
discharge region. The first part of the region is normal glow.
Figure (1-2): Voltage-current relationship for gaseous dc discharge [16]
The small variation in voltage in this region will produce a large
change in current because the “cathode fall” will tend to regulate the
voltage to a constant value in a stabilization mechanism.
At the glow discharge region, if the voltage is further increased, the
discharge will enter the abnormal glow region. Here, the current increase
is not exponential and requires a considerable increase in voltage. This is
Chapter One Introduction
because the plasma starts to cover the entire cathode, so the plasma is not
restricted to just the gap in between the electrodes [17]. The voltage may
increase up to a point where if the applied voltage is increased any more,
the gap voltage will abruptly fall to a very small level and a highly
conductive arc will form across the channel. The voltage across the gap
becomes very low as the current reaches into amperes and even hundreds
or thousands of amperes, depending on the power supply output
capability and the value of the current limiting resistor [14, 16].
At higher pressures, the discharge takes apparently different forms
for different parts of the characteristic V−I curve. Corona discharges are
equivalent in certain of their aspects to the Townsend discharges and
spark may replace it depending on the circuit condition. The arc is still
the ultimate form of discharge if the external circuit is capable of
sustaining it. The means by which this state is reached in a gas at ~ 1 atm.
is not always clear. The glow to arc transitions, and sparks as preliminary
stages of the discharge have not yet been fully assessed [36]. However,
more research studies are extensively required for understanding the
physics of these transitional stages.
1.4 Electrical Breakdown Mechanism
Electrical breakdown is a colloquial term used to describe the
process by which a non-conducting medium such as a gas becomes
conductive through the application of a sufficiently strong electric field.
There exist many comprehensive literature sources describing the
characteristics of electrical breakdown mechanisms [10,14,18]. The
mechanisms leading to gaseous breakdown, studied by Townsend, will be
discussed in the proceeding section [19].
Chapter One Introduction
1.4.1 Townsend Mechanism
A state of equilibrium exists in an ordinary gas between electron and
positive ion rate of generation and loss. However, when an external
electric field is applied, this equilibrium is altered. Townsend firstly
studied the current generated in gases between two parallel electrodes
[21].
The I-V characteristic curve for an ordinary gas between parallel plate
electrodes is shown in figure (1-2). As the gap voltage increases from zero
to V1, the current increases linearly. For a gap voltage between V1 and V2
the current remains constant at a value I0. This current Io, is known as the
saturation current and is the current generated when the cathode is
irradiated by a sufficient amount of energy.
Above a voltage V2, the electrons leaving the cathode are accelerated
to a certain level enough to cause ionization by collision with gas
molecules. Townsend defined the number of electrons produced per unit
length as the quantity α, known as the Townsend's first ionization
coefficient the incremental increase of electrons is given as [20]
dn = αn dx ……………………(1-2)
where n is the number of electrons at a distance x away from the cathode.
Integrating this equation over the distance, d, from cathode to anode gives
d0enn a= …………… (1-3)
where no is the number of primary electrons generated at the cathode. In
terms of current at the anode
d0eii a= …………… (1-4)
Chapter One Introduction
Figure (1-3): Current vs. voltage relationship developed by Townsend
[20].
where i0 is the current leaving the cathode.
The ionization coefficient is actually dependent on the electron
energy distribution in a gas, which depends only on E/P, where E is the
applied electric field and P is the gas pressure. Therefore can be written as
÷øö
çèæ=
aPEf
P ………………. (1-5)
This dependence between α/P and E/P has been confirmed
experimentally [22].
A number of other secondary processes contribute to the breakdown
process. Some of these include secondary electrons produced at the
cathode by positive ion impact, secondary electron emission at the
cathode by photons, and ion impact ionization of the gas. In order to
account for these processes, the Townsend second ionization coefficient,
γ, is introduced. The steady state current, equation (1-4), accounting for
both Townsend coefficients, can be rewritten as [23]:
Chapter One Introduction
)1e(1eii d
d
0 -g-= a
a
…………….(1-6)
Experimental values for γ have been determined from equation (1-6)
for known values of E, P, gap distance, and α. Values for γ are highly
dependent on cathode surface properties. Low work function materials
will produce greater emissions. The value of γ is small at low values of
E/P and higher at greater values of E/P. This is to be expected since at
high values of E/P there will be a greater number of positive ions and
photons with energies high enough to eject electrons from the cathode
[20].
)1e(1
eii)
pdv(f)pd(
)pdv(f)pd(
0
-g-
= ………………. (1-7)
As the gap voltage increases, the electrode current at the anode
increases according to equation (1-6). The current will increase until at
some point the denominator of equation. (1- 6) becomes zero, or
1)1e( d =-g a ……………………… (1-8)
At this point, equation (1-6) predicts that the electrode current
becomes infinite. This is defined as the transition from self-sustained
discharge to breakdown.
Theoretically, the value of the current becomes infinite, but in
practice it is limited by the external circuit and voltage drop across the
gap. A self-sustaining discharge occurs when the number of ion pairs
produced in the gap by the passage of one electron avalanche is large
enough that the resulting positive ions, on bombarding the cathode, are
able to release one secondary electron and cause a repetition of the
Chapter One Introduction
avalanche process. The discharge may also be self-sustaining as a result of
the secondary electron photoemission process [20].
1.4.2 The Gaseous Electrical Conductor
In metals, there exist large concentrations of free electrons, so that
the application of small voltages causes considerable current flow with
only a minimum resistance being imposed by the metallic atom lattice. A
gas, normally accepted as electrically insulating is from one aspect not
dissimilar to a metal it always contains a small number of free electrons,
which by the application of a voltage can be caused to flow through the
gas the flow being impeded by collisions with the neutral gas atoms as in
figure (1-4)a. If the current is restricted only to the free electrons
available in the gas, it is negligible, and the gas is an insulator. If a
sufficiently high electrostatic field exists between the electrodes, the free
electrons can attain high kinetic energies. These high-energy electrons
colliding with neutral gas atoms can be caused a splitting of the electronic
structure of the atoms and hence produce further free electrons and new
positive ions, as shown in figure (1-4) b. This type of process is
cumulative, producing an electron avalanche and finally a spark
discharge. The gas under these conditions is electrically conductive and
can quite easily be maintained in a state of stable conduction. It is
possible also with varied gas conditions and current values to obtain
widely different forms of conduction, typified for example by the well-
known spark, glow and arc discharges.
The properties of these gaseous conductors differ considerably form
those of metallic conductors. The impedance of metal, for example, is
constant over a wide current range, while the impedance in a gas depends
upon the type of discharge, and in general, it decreases markedly with
Chapter One Introduction
increase in current. Many other unique discharge properties exist, which
are of importance in relation to arc interruption [24].
Figure (1-4) Electron conduction in a gas (a) Electron- atom collision
with no ionization. (b) Electron- atom collision with ionization and
production of electron avalanche [24]
1.4.3 Sparks and Streamers
Since the plasma created during the electrical discharge mechanism
process is a spark, it is worthwhile to describe this type of discharge in
more detail. Note that lightning shows beautiful examples of giant spark
discharges.
The breakdown phenomenon leading to the creation of a spark may
be complicated. The breakdown is too fast to be explained by repetitive
electron avalanches through secondary cathode emission, as in low-
pressure discharges. It consists rather of a very rapid growth of a thin
weakly ionized channel called a streamer, from one electrode to the other
[25].
Chapter One Introduction
A streamer is formed from an intensive primary electron avalanche,
starting from the cathode as shown in figure (1-5)a. A space charge field
is associated with this avalanche, due to the polarization of charges inside
it. This electric field increases with the avalanche propagation and
growth. The avalanche has to reach a certain amplification before it can
create a streamer. As soon as the space charge field is comparable or
exceeding the applied external field, a weakly ionized region can be
created due to this amplification of the electric field, the streamer is thus
initiated.
Once the streamer is initiated, it then grows and propagates, following
a zigzag and branched paths due to the random nature of the propagation
mechanism. The speed of this propagation is extremely high, typically
reaching 106 m/s. The propagation can be directed towards both the anode
and the cathode, depending on the gap distance and voltage.
In moderate gaps and with moderate voltages, the avalanche-to-
streamer transition occurs only when the primary avalanche has crossed
the gap and reached the anode. The avalanche has not grown enough and
the space charge field is not high enough to create an ionized region,
before the avalanche has reached the anode. Then, the streamer starts
from the anode and grows towards the cathode. This kind of streamer is
cathode-directed or positive. The streamer growth is caused by secondary
avalanches, created near the positive head as shown in figure (1-5)b.
These secondary avalanches are initiated by electrons that are released by
photo-ionization. The electrons of the secondary avalanches are rapidly
attracted into the streamer, neutralizing the streamer positive head and
leaving behind them the positive ions of the secondary avalanches (ions
move much slower than electrons). These positive charges become the
Chapter One Introduction
new head of the extended streamer. This is how the positive streamer
grows. [10].
Figure (1-5) Breakdown mechanisms leading to a spark discharge propagation of: (a) the primary electron avalanche; (b) a positive
streamer; (c) a negative streamer [10]
In large gaps and/or with strong gap voltages, the space charge field of
the primary avalanche can be sufficiently high to create the streamer even
before reaching the anode. Thus, the avalanche-to-streamer transition
occurs in the gap. Then, the streamer propagates towards both electrodes
at the same time. If the avalanche-to streamer transition occurs while the
Chapter One Introduction
avalanche has not yet moved far from the cathode, the streamer grows
mostly towards the anode. In this case, the streamer is called anode-
directed or negative. The growth mechanism towards the cathode remains
the same as described above, but the growth towards the anode is slightly
different. Here, the electrons of the primary avalanche form a negative
head for the streamer. These electrons rapidly neutralize the positive ions
of secondary avalanches, also initiated near the streamer head by photo-
ionization and by moving electrons as shown in figure (1-5)c. The
electrons of the secondary avalanches then form the new head of the
extended streamer. Thus, for both positive and negative streamers, the
streamer is “feeding” on charges created ahead of its tip by secondary
avalanches.
When the electrode gap is closed by a streamer, the breakdown
phase is completed and the discharge phase begins. The transition from a
weakly ionized channel (the streamer bridging the gap) to a highly
ionized channel (the spark itself) is poorly understood. It is probably
caused by a “back streamer”, similar to the well-known “return stroke” in
lightning discharges [10,25].
If it is assumed that a streamer is perfectly conducting, the head of a
positive streamer, for example, is at the same potential as the anode.
When the streamer head is approaching close to the cathode, all the
potential fall is located over a very short distance, the distance between
the cathode and the streamer head. The electric field is so intense in this
region that electrons are emitted in great number from the cathode and
from atoms near the cathode. Once the gap is closed by the streamer,
these electrons, multiplied at enormous intensity, are accelerated towards
the anode in the initial streamer channel, causing strong ionization. The
formation of the true spark channel probably caused by this back
Chapter One Introduction
streamer, which strongly increases the degree of ionization in the original
streamer channel.
The plasma composing the spark channel is highly ionized and
conductive, capable of sustaining a large current (in the order of kilo-
amperes). The spark is accompanied by a cracking sound (the thunder in
the case of lightning), resulting from the shock wave created by the rapid
and localized heating of the gas surrounding the plasma channel. The
channel radially expands with time, because the surrounding gas is
gradually ionized, by heat conduction and by the shock wave.
If the power source is capable of delivering the discharge current
over a certain period of time, the spark will naturally transform into an
arc, since the spark is only a transient process [10].
1.5 Paschen’s Law
Friedrich Paschen, was the first to state in 1889, that the breakdown
voltage of parallel plates in a gas is a function of the product of pressure
and gap distance.The dependence of the probability of ionization on the
number of gas molecules between electrodes has been formally
developed and studied for different gases and is known as Paschen’s law.
Paschen found that breakdown voltage can be written as [26]:
÷÷÷÷÷
ø
ö
ççççç
è
æ
÷÷ø
öççè
æ+
=
g11ln
ln APd
bPdVb (1-9)
or V b=f (Pd) …………….(1-10)
where γ secondary electron coefficient, A and b are constants and
values for various gases can be found in table (1-2). This method of
relating the breakdown voltage as a function of pd is known as Paschen’s
Chapter One Introduction
law. It means that the breakdown voltage is a function of the gas pressure
and gap distance.
A Paschen curve for atmospheric air is shown in figure (1-6). Note
that the breakdown voltage goes through a minimum value at a particular
(Pd)min value. This Vbmin can be explained qualitatively. For Pd > (Pd)min,
electrons crossing the gap make more frequent collisions than at (Pd)min,
but the energy gained between collisions is less [23]. This results in a
lower ionization level for a given gap voltage.
Table (1-2): Selected ionization constants and ranges of applicability.
T = 20 ºC [20].
Gas
A ion pairs
cm-1 .Torr-1
b V.cm-1.Torr-1
E/p V.cm-1 .Torr-1
Vi Volts
H2 5 130 150–600 15.4
N2 12 342 100–600 15.5
Air 15 365 100–800 _
CO2 20 466 500–1000 12.6
He 3 34 20–150 24.5
For Pd < (Pd)min, electrons crossing the gap make less frequent collisions
than at (Pd)min. Therefore, (Pd)min corresponds to the highest ionization
frequency depending on the mean free path of electrons and the
probability of ionization [22].
This shows that unless initial electrons are provided, the electrical
breakdown can not occur, because an avalanche can not be started then.
In the case of slowly varying fields, there is usually no difficulty in
finding an initiatory electron from natural sources, i.e., cosmic rays,
detachment from gaseous ions, etc.
Chapter One Introduction
Figure (1-6): Measured and calculated Paschen curves for air [27]
1.6 Atmospheric Pressure Discharges
Atmospheric pressure gas discharges have received an increasing
amount of attention both from academic groups and companies. Low
pressure plasma reactors are widely utilized for surface treatment of
polymers. The possibility to use plasma sources at higher pressure is of
great interest. Despite their tendency to turn into hot filaments and to be
more difficult to control than low pressure discharges. Atmospheric
pressure plasmas present many advantages for industrial applications [28,
29]:-
• Existence of effective particle density
• Absence of expensive and power consuming vacuum systems
• Absence of pumping down time
• Absence of vacuum compatibility issues
These four factors drastically reduce all the operational costs of
manufacturers. Some atmospheric pressure reactors are open to the
Chapter One Introduction
ambient air for surface treatment. The plasma is not turned off between
each sample making the treatment process even faster and cheaper. There
are many applications that benefit from the possibility of stable
atmospheric pressure plasmas [6,30]. For instance, depollution,
sterilization, medical interventions, and more recently, flow control or
combustion control.
Different geometrical configurations and excitation schemes can be
utilized to obtain an atmospheric pressure discharge in various gases.
Many studies have been made about Dielectric Barrier Discharges, corona
discharges, plasma jets, pulsed electrical discharges and micro discharges
[25, 31, 32].
1.6.1 Breakdown Voltage of Air
The breakdown in air (spark breakdown) is the transition of a non-
sustaining discharge into a self-sustaining discharge. The buildup of high
currents in a breakdown is due to the ionization in which electrons and
ions are created from neutral atoms or molecules, and their migration to
the anode and cathode respectively leads to high currents. As discussed
earlier, Townsend theory and streamer theory are the present two types of
theories, which explain the mechanism of breakdown under different
conditions as temperature, pressure, nature of electrode surfaces,
electrode field configuration and availability of initial conducting
particles. Normally, air is widely used as an insulating medium in
different electrical power equipments underground and overhead lines as
its breakdown strength is sufficient in such applications.
Typical breakdown voltage of air for a parallel plate electrode
geometry separated by 1cm gap is 30kV [33].
Chapter One Introduction
1.7 Pulsed Electrical Discharges (PED)
Pulse power engineering is the science and technology of storing
energy over a relatively long period of time and releasing it in a relatively
short time aiming at increasing the instantaneous power. It is obviously a
pulsed power system includes an energy storage stage, a load, and a pulse
forming stage between these two stages.
Pulsed discharges are used in plasma-technological applications.
Pulsed sources have the following advantages:
• Operation at higher power;
• Additional performance control by a variable duty cycle of active plasma
regime and plasma after glow;
• Variations in the neutral gas composition between the plasma boundary
and the plasma centre (due to plasma chemical reactions) may cause, for
example, inhomogeneous thin film deposition in a continuous dc plasma,
pulsed operation in conjunction with rapid gas exchange between pulses
can prevent or minimize such effects [6, 15].
In addition to its power and energy, pulsed electric field has another
important characteristic that is the shape of pulse, defined by its rise and
fall times, duration, and flatness of its plateau region. Usually, the
duration of a power pulse lies between 10-9 – 10-6 seconds, depending on
the application. The typical pulse shape shown in figure (1-7) may be
characterized by the following temporal parameters:
Chapter One Introduction
Figure (1-7) Pulse Shape [34]
Rise Time: The time taken by the voltage to rise from 10% to 90% of its
peak voltage.
Decay Time: The time taken by the voltage to decrease from 90% to
10% of its peak voltage, it is also called fall time.
Pulse Duration: There is no unique definition, sometimes it means the
full time width between rise and decay half maximum of the pulse
(FWHM). However, for some applications, it is defined as the time it
remains at 90% of its maximum value [33].
Energy can be stored in several forms, namely, chemical, mechanical
and electrical. By using appropriate switches, the desired shape, rise and
decay time of the pulse could be achieved. An impedance matching
network may also become necessary for optimal energy transfer to the
load. Electrical energy can be stored either capacitively in an electric field
or inductively in a magnetic field.
Chapter One Introduction
1.8 Plasma Switching
Closing plasma switches are “open” naturally and are “closed” with
an application of external trigger or as a result of its own over voltage.
Different high voltage switches [35] have been used as key components
to transfer electrical energy from the storage unit to the load. Plasma
switches are among these switching devices, which can potentially
transport high electrical currents at relatively low power dissipation with
controllable repetition rate. These plasma switches cover thyratrons,
pesudospark, and spark gaps [36-38].
Because of their simple design and construction, low cost, and
capability of current level control, spark gaps have stimulated interests in
a number of research activities [39-44]. In these studies, a number of
operating parameters was investigated including repetition rate, discharge
region of operation, electrode erosion, gas pressure, and damping
conditions of the output signals [39].
Different types of plasma switches operate in their specific pressure
ranges. Figure (1-8) shows the range of operating pressure and voltage for
some of the most common types of plasma switches. These include
thyratrons, pseudospark switches, ignitrons, krytrons, and spark gaps
switches.
Spark gap switches working in high-pressure gas such as air and
nitrogen have been very widely used in high- power pulsed technology.
They are known to permit very large currents (hundreds of kA to MA), to
have a short current rise time of a few nanoseconds. In comparison with
other switches, the main advantages of spark gap switches are a high
voltage, large conducting current, high energy efficiency, low cost [45].
In addition, Paschen curve for air with the fixed gap width of 3 mm is
overlaid as reference to the breakdown voltage of gaseous media. As seen
Chapter One Introduction
in figure (1-8), all the plasma switches operate below the Paschen curve.
Above this curve, the normal operating voltage will exceed the
breakdown strength of the gaseous, and will cause unexpected breakdown
events [27, 45].
Figure (1-8) Rang of gas pressures and operating voltage for plasma
switches [27, 34]
Nearly all types of plasma switches are operated on the basic
principle of ionization and breakdown of gases. Under normal conditions
(below its breakdown voltage), gas is an insulator and becomes
conducting when ionized.
At particular gas pressure P and electrode spacing d, the product pd is
known as the sparking parameter and is characterized by the Paschen
curve for each gas and geometry [40]. The mechanism involves the
production of plasma and the propagation of plasma particles between the
electrodes of the spark gap giving rise to a high current flow through the
Chapter One Introduction
circuit. Characteristic current-voltage curves can then be deduced from
the output signals after recording the charging voltage of the capacitor or
the energy storage unit. 1.9 Damping Conditions of PEDs
The energy stored in a capacitor bank of C capacitance that charged
to a voltage V0 is 0.5 C V02 joules. When this energy is discharged
through a circuit containing inductance and resistance, the current will be
either a damped periodic function or an aperiodic function depending on
the damping.
A damping factor df is defined in equation (1-11) [46]:-
L4CRd
2
f = ………….(1-11)
If 0 < df < 1 the circuit is underdamped and oscillatory in nature.
If df = 1 the circuit is said to be critically damped, and current will
always be positive.
If df > 1 the circuit is over-damped, and the use of the energy is not as
efficient as in the critically damped or under-damped case .
Figure (1-9) Critically Damped Current
Chapter One Introduction
The circuit must be critically-damped is shown in figure (1-9). Such
circuit conditions were chosen to carry out the calibration of Rogowski
coils since the energy is more efficient than the overdamped circuit and
safer than the underdamped case [46, 47].
1.10 The Effect of The Electrical Impedance
The characteristics impedance of the gap depends upon the geometry,
spacing and the gas of interest. One of the main parameters, which
determines the gap impedance is the gap spacing, which basically
determines the Paschen minimum voltage for the gas filling the gap at a
particular pressure. Nevertheless, the current flowing in the circuit can be
described in terms of this impedance and other component in the external
circuitry.
The breakdown voltage of the gas is related to the gas pressure with
in the gab by the flowing [48]:
P
Eg =e …………….(1-12)
where E is the electric field of breakdown, εg dielectric strength of the
gas and p gas pressure.
The impedance of the spark Zs in the spark gap can be written as :
Q
d.KZ s
s = …………… (1-13)
where Ks spark constant, d spark length, Q number of ampere-second
transmitted through the spark.
The speed of the switch, or the voltage pulse rise time, can be
determined by gas pressure and the spark length as [36]
31
s
21
r
EZ
P44=t ……………….. (1-14)
Chapter One Introduction
where P is the pressure in atmosphere, E in kV/mm and τr is the rise time
in nsec.
1.11 Uniform and Non-Uniform Fields
All the effects of breakdown discussed can happen for electrodes with
uniform or non-uniform fields. The difference is where the effects are
most likely to happen. Getting an idea of the fields for different electrode
configurations will help predict where a breakdown is most likely to
occur.
Consider two electrodes separated by some distance. Their electric
field lines may look something like that shown in figure (1-10). The
electric field lines are perpendicular to the electrode surfaces and parallel
to each other. They point from the positive plate to the negative plate.
This figure ignores fringing effect that may take place at the edges [49].
Figure (1-10): Electric field lines for parallel plate electrode configuration [49]
Not many real-life situations have electrodes that produce a uniform
electric field. It is more likely that for a practical electrode configuration,
there will be a non-uniform field. A point to point, point to plane and
sphere to sphere will be explained. The electric fields for these electrodes
are not uniform. To get an idea of what the field will look like, computer
Chapter One Introduction
simulation was performed [50]. Results obtained for each electrode are
shown in figure (1-11).
In figure (1-11)a, the lines represent the equipotential lines and the
shades of color represent the electric field strength, with blue
corresponding to lower E field and red corresponding to the highest E
field. Notice that the highest E field occurs where the equipotential lines
are most closely spaced. This corresponds to the red region between the
tip of the anode and the surface of the cathode. Sharp points and edges
tend to produce the highest electric fields because the gradient of the
equipotential lines is very high at such areas. One can also notice a little
peaking of E field around the corners of the cathode and anode.
Figure (1-11)b is the simulation for the point-to-point electrode
configuration. Here, the electric field is highest in between the electrode
tips where the equipotential line gradient is the highest. During
experiments, the areas on the electrodes with high fields tend to have the
brightest glow [50].
Figure (1-11)c show the maximum electric field between the sphere
electrodes in the standard sphere gap method. It is observed from the
electric field is maximum in vertical axis where the curvatures of the
sphere electrodes more or less uniform and it is decreasing gradually in
non uniform fields. That is observed that the electric field distribution is
non-uniform for sphere-sphere electrode arrangement [51].
Chapter One Introduction
Figure (1-11) Computer simulation of electric fields for (a) - point- plane (b) - point- point (c) - sphere-sphere [50,51]
There are various other types of electrode arrangements and circuits
for used to spark gaps to obtained high voltages and currents such as
sphere-plate, sphere-rod, rod-rod, rod-Plate, and cylinder-cylinder. In this
experimental study used three types of electrodes sphere-sphere, sphere-
rod and cylindrically-tipped.
(a) (b)
(c)
Chapter One Introduction
1.12 Applications of PEDs
Several physical phenomena are correlated in PED experiments.
Depending on the physical processes arisen in such experiments,
theoretical studies have been carried out establish reasonable agreements
between theory and experiments to meet the technological applications.
A part from these versatile research activities, the pulsed discharge has
witnessed a wide area of applications .In this section, some of the major
areas which involves the plasma are discussed as follows: -
1- Medical and feeding applications. PED have been used in medical
research such as:- to investigate plasma characteristics of repetitively-
PED in saline solutions used for surgical procedures [1]. Ultra short
electric pulse induced change in cellular dielectric properties [52].
Optically used emission spectroscopy in UV–visible regions for the
diagnostics of atmospheric pressure plasmas and discharges relevant to
bio-medical applications was investigated [53].
To improve the food quality and safety, including extended shelf life,
some of the alternative technologies that have been considered to have
high potential for commercialization are high pressure processing by
used PED. Treatment has gained increasing interest, which is mainly
caused by some attractive advantages in relation to conventional thermal
treatments [54, 55].
2- Material and surface processing;- The insulated surface discharge
treatment under atmospheric pressure operated with high voltage is
investigated [56-60]. Metal release in a stainless steel pulsed electric field
system affect different pulse shapes; theory and experimental met became
plain by Bart Rodenburg [61]. On the other hand, when research work to
the ion beam and plasma technology development for surface can be
Chapter One Introduction
achieved modification and post discharge phenomena on surfaces [62,
63].
3- Laser applications :- The use of nanosecond duration repetitively
pulsed discharges has formed the basis for several recent studies of
oxygen-containing plasmas for Plasma induced laser, Electric Discharge
Chemical Oxygen Iodine Laser [64 - 66].
4- Environment and pollution application The increases in the demand
for clean potable water and clean air with stricter environmental
regulations have raised interest in the development of safe water
treatment technologies as well as emission control. Disinfection of water
is highly essential in order to reduce the number of waterborne diseases.
Disinfection methods for potable water, that are in practice today range
from use of chemicals like chlorine to ultraviolet (UV) light. But,
pathogens like Cryptosporidium are resistant to conventional drinking
water disinfectants, including chlorine. The pulsed high voltage
discharges generated inside water, or on the surface initiate a variety of
physical and chemical processes such as the formation of chemically
active species like OH radicals and H2O along with O and H molecules,
UV radiation, ozone formation and shockwaves. Through advanced
oxidation, it is possible to break toxic chemicals without using any
harsher chemical treatment. [67-75].
The use of nonthermal plasmas for the development of efficient,
compact pulsed corona sources for pollution has been investigated [76 -
78]. While a high temperature pulsed corona plasma system for fuel
cleaning [79].
5- Thin film technology the deposited films can be altered and the
processing rate can be obtained under even lower average power. Also
Chapter One Introduction
sputtering, plasma etching and thin film technology rate controlled by the
pulse duration of the discharge. [80-83].
The process of electro pulse sintering of ferrous and high speed steel
powder materials by powerful pulse current and external pressure was
investigated [84].
6- High vacuum instrument and requirements in which the vacuum cycle
can be reduced by discharge cleaning [85, 86].
7- The Marx generator is widely used as a high voltage pulse generation
device. [87,88].
8- The dense plasma focus as a high intensity pulsed neutron source [89-
93].
9- Conversion of Methane to Hydrogen via pulsed corona discharge [94,
95]. The use of a pulsed high voltage discharge for removal of organic
compounds in aqueous solution can be reported investigation [96].
10- Generation of relativistic electron beams for high power microwaves.
The production of pulsed high-density electron beam by channel spark
discharge [97].
11- Industrial Application of pulsed power technology was investigated.
[5, 98, 99].
12- Fast closing plasma switching devices [100-103] and pseudo sparks
[37, 104-106] where high current rates (dI/dt) and voltage can be
remarked.
Chapter One Introduction
1.13 Literature Review
The following is a summary of the previous experimental and
theoretical work related to the present research in the field of pulsed
electrical discharge.
Both theoretical and experimental studies in the PED may be
classified into some group.
The first group is the high-voltage breakdown in gases at high
pressure (atmosphere) when PED are produced a result of transitions in
the discharge mode [25,31,32, 107-111]. In such studies, various gases
are used under certain pressures to make good understanding of the
breakdown mechanism with the gap voltage collapse. Arguments involve
the major role of the external circuitry on the breakdown mechanism.
The second group of research studies is devoted to the diagnostics
[30, 112-116] of the plasma, the discharge, the electron and ion density
and temperature are measured after the discharge had been established
under the required conditions including gas pressure, electrode geometry
and the nature of the applied voltage in addition to the proposed
technique of diagnostics. While other researches study the characteristics
of the impedance and magnetic effect on the spark gap to investigate the
rise time and pulse duration and other parameters [39,47, 117-123].
The third group is to investigate in nonequilibrium plasmas using
nanosecond duration and high voltage pulses [64-66, 124-131]. The basic
idea is to create large volume ionization in a gas flow by application of
20-50 kV, and (10~100 nsec) duration pulses at a (10-100 kHz) pulse
repetition rate. Between the pulses, the plasma can be sustained, if
necessary, by application of a relatively low voltage, sub-breakdown DC
or RF field. This approach has two distinct advantages.
Chapter One Introduction
First, since the ionizing pulse duration, ~10-8 sec, is much shorter than
the characteristic time scale for development of Joule heating/ ionization
instability, ~10-4- 10-3 sec [64,131], which leads to glow-to-arc transition,
stable repetitively pulsed plasmas can be sustained at much higher
pressures and power loadings compared to other types of non-
equilibrium plasmas.
Second, unlike conventional self-sustained discharges, with this
technique, the sustainer voltage can be independently controlled making
it very efficient, as the self-sustainer discharge accounts for as much as
90-95% of the total input power.
The use of nanosecond duration repetitively pulsed discharges has formed
the basis for several recent studies of oxygen-containing plasmas for
plasma assisted combustion, electric discharge chemical oxygen iodine
laser development, and magneto hydrodynamic supersonic flow control
[65,66,127-129,132].
The fourth group is to investigate in plasma switch (spark gap).
Previous experiments [41-44,133,134] were carried out to study the effect
of the breakdown conditions and the plasma characteristics where
breakdown could be preceded by corona stabilization in non-uniform
electric field geometry. Such studies established a correlation scheme
between charged particle density and its governing parameters. Moreover,
these experiments intended to select a method for triggering for a single
and multiple spark gaps. However, electrode surface flashover was found
to be adequate to operate typical spark gaps with certain geometry and
gas pressure.
Chapter One Introduction
1.14 The Objective of This Thesis
The prime objective of this research work is to design, construct, and
to test a high voltage circuit consisting of three main components such as
resistance, capacitance, and inductance capable of delivering various
damping conditions.
The effect of the pulse shape on a gas discharge at atmospheric
pressure is studied in terms of the circuit components and other inherently
profound parameters in the discharge itself resulting from the behavior of
the current–voltage characteristic curves. Other prime objective of this work is to investigate the temporal
behavior of the impedance of an atmospheric pressure spark gap with two
electrodes (sphere-sphere, cylindrically-tipped and rod -sphere).
Such experiments can sufficiently demonstrate the behaviour of the
plasma generated between the electrodes of the spark gap where the
electric field is nonuniform and the energy delivered to the collisional
processes is controlled.
Chapter Two Diagnostics
2.1 Introduction
In plasma physics experiments, PEDs impose particular diagnostic
tools for measurements and monitoring as the durations of the physical
processes are of great importance. These processes can be inspected to
some extent by electrical and magnetic measurements in this type of
experiments. Among such methodological techniques are the
measurements of currents and voltages and then the construction of
current-voltage characteristic curves, which establish a subsequent
monitoring of plasma behaviour in the discharge.
In this chapter, an overview of the essentially required tools is
presented for these PED experiments.
2.2 Plasma Diagnostics
In general the plasma of discharges is studied either via direct
electrical measurements of the space of the plasma or indirectly by
spectroscopic observation of the emitted light during the discharging
process. In each case the principles, the techniques and in some times if
not otherwise, the objectives are different [33]. In this research electrical
measurement are used.
2.3 Electrical Measurement
Two basic electrical diagnostics were used in our experiments, in
different configurations. One was for the measurement of the discharge
current and the other was for the voltage measurements. These two
diagnostics are discussed in the following sections.
Chapter Two Diagnostics
2.4 Voltage Measurements
The measurement of the high voltage pulse shape and amplitude is of
importance. A high voltage divider is required to reduce the voltage to a
level, which can be measured by the oscilloscope. Each divider used in
measuring such a high voltage is restricted by several considerations,
which include:
1. The voltage divider must present negligible load on the pulse power
supply. This means that the divider must have a very high impedance.
2. The output of the divider is normally connected to the input of the
oscilloscope by a co-axial cable. Matching between the output impedance
of the divider and the characteristic impedance of the cable is required in
order to avoid unwanted reflections.
3. The divider should have a uniform transient response over a wide
range of frequencies so that it produces negligible distortion on the
measured waveform.
There are several well-developed techniques for voltage
measurements. These include [135,136]:
1- Spark gaps.
2- Electrostatic meters.
3- Capacitive dividers.
4- Voltage dividers (Resistive dividers).
5- Mixed RC dividers.
6- Electro- optic effect.
2.4.1 Voltage Dividers (Resistive Dividers)
High voltage resistive dividers are still considered to be the most
appropriate devices for the measurement of fast transient voltages, such
Chapter Two Diagnostics
as lightning impulses. In AC or pulse measurements, a number of
problems related to [33, 20]:
1- The residual inductance in any resistance or capacitance element.
2- Stray capacitance: (a) from any section of the divider to the high
voltage lead, (b) from any section of the divider to ground and (c)
sections of the divider.
3- Impedance drop in the connecting lead between the divider and the test
object.
4- Impedance drop in the ground return lead from the divider resulting
from extraneous ground currents flowing in the lead.
5- Oscillations in the divider circuit caused by capacitance from divider
high-voltage terminal to ground and lead inductance.
Probably the biggest problem is associated with stray capacitances.
Ohms law provides a method to reduce high voltage to measurable
quantities, i.e. adequate currents or low precisely measurable voltages.
The simplest method, often used for the low voltage measurements
to extend a voltmeter range, employs an ammeter in series with a resistor
R of sufficiently high value to keep the loading of the high voltage source
as small as possible is shown in figure (2-1)a. The voltage drop across the
meter is neglected, which is usually allowable due to the small terminal
impedance of such instruments. For DC voltage measurements, average
current- indicating instruments such as moving coil meters are used to
give the arithmetic mean value of V according to the equation above.
Fundamentally also the time-dependency V(t) according to equation (2-1)
could be measured by, for instance, an oscilloscope. The difficulties,
however, in treating the resistance R as a pure resistance are limiting this
application.
Chapter Two Diagnostics
The main difficulties encountered in this method are related to the
stability of the resistance R [20].
Figure (2-1) Measurement of high DC and AC voltages by means of:
(a) Ammeter in series with resistor R. (b) Voltage divider R1, R2 and
voltmeter of negligible current input. OP: output over voltage
protection [20]
All types of resistors are temperature- dependent and may often
show some voltage-dependency. Such variations are directly proportional
to the voltage measured and impede the accuracy. If the output voltage of
the voltage divider is measured with instruments of negligible current
consumption (i → 0 or 2i/i <<1) as in figure (2-1 (b)), the high voltage
will be computed by:
( ) ( ) ÷÷ø
öççè
æ+=
2
12 R
R1 tVtV ……………. (2-1)
Chapter Two Diagnostics
A part from the accuracy of the output voltage measurement (V2 or V2(t)),
the magnitude of the high voltage will be influenced only by the
ratio 21 RR , as both resistors pass the same current 21 ii = [20, 135].
2.5 Current Measurements
In many technical fields and scientific research problems there is
often a need to ascertain the peak value and the waveform of high, rapidly
changing currents, as in discharging energy-storage capacitor bank in
plasma physics, lightning research, and so on. Current peak value may
vary from ten to millions of amperes, with rise times ranging from
nanoseconds to many microseconds. There are many measurement
methods available, like [136];
1- Rogowski Coil.
2- Current viewing resistance (Shunt) (CVR)
3- Hall generators.
The first and second types have been used in this research and will be
discussed as follows:
2.5.1 Rogowski Coils
Rogowski coils are used for measuring an alternating current. They
work by sensing the magnetic field caused by the current without the need
to make an electrical contact with the conductor. These coils have been
used in various forms for detecting and measuring electric current for
decades [46, 137].
They operate on a simple principle. Rogowski coil is placed round the
conductor in a toriodal fashion as shown in figure (2-2) so that the
alternating magnetic field produced by the current induces a voltage in the
Chapter Two Diagnostics
coil. The coils are effectively a mutual inductance coupled to the
conductor being measured and the voltage output is proportional to the
rate of change of current. To complete the transducer this voltage is
integrated electronically.
Figure (2-2) Rogowski coil [141] Many of the useful features of Rogowski coils systems result from
their linearity. They have a wide dynamic range in that the same coil can
be used to measure currents ranging from a few milliamperes to several
million amperes and they respond accurately to transient currents which
makes them an excellent choice for use in protection systems and for
measuring current pulses. The following are the Rogowski coils
advantages [138 - 140]:
i) The frequency response of the Rogowski coil sensor is very wide.
ii) There is no conductive coupling between the coil sensors and the high
voltage test circuits. Furthermore, the coil installation does not necessitate
disconnection of the grounding leads of the test objects and therefore
becomes a non-intrusive sensor, which is a very important aspect for on-
site, on-line monitoring.
Chapter Two Diagnostics
iii) It has the advantage of possessing high signal to noise ratio with wide
frequency bandwidth.
iv) There is no saturation due to air-cored coil; therefore, it is not
damaged by over current.
v) It has very good linearity due to the absence of magnetic materials.
vi) The Rogowski coil based electrical discharge measurement system is
a low cost solution and can be easily implemented on-site due to its light
weight.
A schematic drawing of the equivalent circuit for such a magnetic
pickup coil, with a simple RC integrating network is shown in figure (2-
3). The circuit equation for this arrangement is [142, 47]
dtiC1iR
dtdiL
dtd t
0ò++=
f…………………(2-2)
where i is the (small) current flowing in the measuring circuit L is the
inductance of the coil , R and C are the resistance and capacitance of the
passive integrating network respectively.
When the impedance of the coil is negligible in comparison with R,
R >> ωL; where is the highest frequency component of ф (t) or i ,
equation (2-3) become
dtiC1iR
dtd t
0ò+=
f …………..(2-3)
and for t << RC , the second term in the right hand side of equation (2-3)
is negligibly small. Therefore, equation (2-2) can be re written as
dtd)
R1(i f
» ……………(2-4)
Since the output voltage of coil (Vc) is given by
dtiC1V
t
0c ò= ……………. (2-5)
Chapter Two Diagnostics
From equations (2-4) and (2-5) Vc will written as
RC
)t(Vcf
= ………… (2-6)
Figure (2-3) The equivalent circuit of a Rogowski coil with a passive RC
integrator [142] The flux ф(t) at any time is related to the main current I(t) which flows
in the electrical discharge circuit and produces the magnetic induction by
the following equation [47]
)t(KNI)t( =f ………………..(2-7)
where N is the total number of turns in the Rogowski coil and K is a
proportionality constant depending upon the coil geometry and current
distribution .
Generally K is a measure of the approximate coil sensitivity for which the
DC
SAK 0m= ………………(2-8)
where A = πa2 and S = 2πr ; a being the minor mean radius of wining and
r is the major mean radius of the coil . From equation (2-6) and (2-7), the
coil output voltage Vc is related to the main current I(t) by [47]:
dtdf Vc
Chapter Two Diagnostics
)t(IRCKNVc = ……………(2-9)
Since Rogowski coils are used to measure rapidly, time varying
current the factor L/R of the coil is of great importance. When L/R is very
short in comparison with the pulse width of the current to be measured,
idtdi
RL
áá equation (2-9) gives the output voltage of the coil, which can be
written as
dtdiR f
= ………………….(2-10)
The equation means that the current flowing in the coil is proportional
to the flux dtdf . Therefore, the resulting voltage must be integrated to give
an output proportional to the main flowing current to be measured I(t).
Hence, Rogowski coils operated in the differentiating mode require an
integrator after which the integrated output signal will be a measure of the
main pulsed current [138, 136].
2.5.2 Current Viewing Resistance (Shunt) (CVR)
The second important method of measuring the current a plasma
involves measuring the potential drop which results when the current in
question flows through a precisely known resistance. Since the currents
involved are often very large, the resistance must be very small indeed, in
order that the voltage drop be of manageable size. Such low resistance
elements are usually called shunts.
The major problem in the use of shunts results from the fact that the
current to be measured is often rapidly changing, so that the inductive
reactance becomes comparable to or larger than the resistance unless
special precautions are taken. The frequencies and permissible dimensions
Chapter Two Diagnostics
are often such that the only way to ensure that R>>Lω is to arrange the
geometry so that none of the magnetic flux produced by the current to be
measured is sensed by the voltage measuring circuit [136].
An example of such a geometry is that shown in figure (2-4). Here the
current to be measured flows through a cylinder of resistive material such
as nichrome foil and returns via a highly conducting coaxial outer
cylinder. The voltage drop along the inner cylinder is sensed by means of
connection made to its ends. In this geometry, the magnetic field produced
by the main current I is entirely confined to the interior region between
the two cylinders, so that there is no dφ/dt in the voltage sensing circuit.
The voltage observed is then simply IR [143].
Figure (2-4) Current Viewing Resistance (CVR) [143]
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
3.1 Introduction
This chapter is devoted for describing the high-voltage circuit and the
full experimental procedure and measurements. A pulsed high-voltage
circuit has been designed and constructed to include three main
components; inductances, capacitors and resistances. One of the main
objectives of this work is to investigate the temporal behavior of the
impedance of an atmospheric pressure spark gap (spherical, rod-sphere
and cylindrically-tipped,) electrodes at air atmospheric pressure. Analysis
of the discharge current oscillograms under various damping conditions
was carried out as two triggering techniques were followed after being
designed for these experiments. In addition, Rogowski coils have also
been designed to measure the current pulse as well as current shunt
resistors for comparison.
The measurements were rounded to a proper degree of precision
within the capability of the instrumentations providing that pulsed
parameters could not be precisely controlled in terms of reproducibility of
shot-to-shot output signals.
3.2 Design of the PED Circuit
A pulsed electrical discharge circuit is basically designed in which a
capacitor is charged from a DC power supply to a certain voltage through
a resistance and discharged through a spark gap or on appropriate switch.
In this section, the description of the PED circuit design is given.
Figure (3-1) shows a photograph of this system. This circuit illustrates the
following parts.
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-1): The pulsed electrical discharge circuit setup used in the present work (a) Equivalent circuit (b) Photograph
(a)
(b)
(a)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
3.3 Design and Construction of Two Rogowski Coils Two Rogowski coils of insulating material are designed shaped as
toriodal in figure (3-2) and used copper wire to wrap. These coils were
designed, constructed, and calibrated to record the pulsed discharge
currents as shown in chapter two (2.5 paragraph).
Inductance, resistance, measure of approximate coil sensitivity and
time constant of the coil can be calculated using the following relations
(equations 2-10, 3-1, 3-2, 3-3).
l
2o AN
Lm
= …………….. (3-1)
l
l
ALR r
= ……………… (3-2)
RLtl = ..................... (3-3)
Figure (3-2): Photograph of the Rogowski coils (a) First (b) Second
Where Rogowski coils are connected to 50 Ω matching coaxial
impedance and then to input of the oscilloscope to any possible mismatch
in signal propagation
a b
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
The following table (3-1) contains the measurement parameters of
Rogowski coils.
Table (3-1) The measurement parameters of Rogowski coils.
3-4 Design and Construction RC-Integration Circuit
Two circuits of RC-integration are designed and built, which consist
of resistance with the first value R = 10 kΩ and capacitor value C = 1 μf
and the second value is R = 10 Ω, C = 1 μf as shown in the figure (3-3). It
is both parties are linked to the PNC coaxial cable and connected to
oscilloscope and then the integration process of the signal emerging from
a Rogowski coil starts in order to find the value of the current pulse
passing through the wire. The value of electric current equals the value of
Parameters First Rogowski coil Second Rogowski coil
External diameter
105 mm
50 mm
Internal diameter 31 mm 25 mm
Major mean radius = r 36.5 mm 22.3 mm
Minor mean radius= a 20.9 mm 9.8 mm
Length of the coil = l 22.9 cm 14 cm Number of turns = N 86 turns 84 turns
Inductance = L 55.7 μH 19 μH
Resistance 0.6 Ω 0.3 Ω
Time constant = tl 92 μsec 63 μsec
Coil Sensitivity = K 7.5 ×10-6 2.7×10-6
Length of the wire=L1 9.7 m 4.6 m
Wire diameter 0.6 mm 0.6 mm
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
the voltage multiplied by a certain constant, as explained in chapter two
(2.2 paragraph).
The time constant is given in the equation (3-4)
t = RC .................(3-4)
which is equal
t1= 10 msec
t2 = 10 μsec
Figure (3-3): RC-integration circuit a- Schematic, b- Fabrication
3.5 Earthing System (Design and Installation)
Earth stick is designed and used for safety and discharge circuit if
there is any residue electric charge in capacitors. In figure (3-4), it consists
of 50 cm of copper rod. The part of the rod is covered with Teflon
insulation material of thick wire 50 cm long and 6 cm in diameter, linked
to thick wire to the earth ground, in delta form.
In all methods of providing protection against dangers associated with
the use of electricity, earthing plays a very important role. Earthing means
making a connection to general mass of earth.
The value of earth ground resistance is verified by using digital earth
resistance tester is shown in figure (3-5).
(a) (b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-4): Earth stick
Figure (3-5): Digital Earth Resistance Tester.
3.6 Current-Limiting Resistance
Current-limiting resistance (charging resistance) is designed to
protect the power supply and the charging process will be gradual. It
consists of thermal resistances of high value of impedance connected in
parallel and series to obtain high sufficient circuit and to avoid any over
heating as shown in the figure (3-6). The value of resistances used is:
R1= 9.1 MΩ, R2= 2.2 MΩ, R3= 40 kΩ
as a result the total value of Current-limiting resistance obtained is :
Rtotal= 541 kΩ.
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-6): The current-limiting resistance (a) Diagram (b) Construction
3.7 Spark Gaps (Plasma Switches) The high voltage of high power discharge circuits require special
switching devices, commonly gap switches, at most spherical gaps, are
used for switching. The selection of the switch depends upon the peak
current passing through it during the discharge, and the charging voltage
of the capacitor, the breakdown voltage of the sphere gap is less than the
peak value of the supply. Spark gaps or plasma switches were designed in three shapes : -
spherical, cylindrically-tipped and rod-sphere electrodes as shown in
figure (3-7). Practically, a spherical spark gap of steel electrodes was
used, 70 mm in diameter (r = 35mm), that can be adjusted by a screw
threaded to each sphere as shown in figure (3-7)a.
(a)
(b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-7): Spark gap schematic: - a- Spherical b-Cylindrically-
Tipped c- Rod-Sphere electrodes
The cylindrically-tipped spark gap electrode is made of Copper. The
measurement of each of the two electrodes:- the ground electrode internal
(a)
(b)
(c)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
and external radius are r1=9 mm, r2 =9.5 mm respectively. The thickness
equals 0.5 mm and the length is 46 mm while the high voltage electrode,
the internal radius is r1 = 9 mm and external radius is r2 = 9.5 mm,
thickness equals 0.5 mm and the length is 76.5 mm. This is shown in
figure (3-7)b.
The third type of the plasma switches is rod- sphere electrodes with
ground electrode is a rod made of steel with curved shape as shown in
figure (3-7)c. Specifications and measurements is r = 7.5 mm, curvature is
20 mm and length is 60 mm. The high voltage electrode is the same
sphere as in figurer (3-7)a.
In either case, it is important that the spark gap (electrodes) should be
so placed that the space between spark gap is free from external electric
fields and from bodies, which may affect the field between the spark gap.
3.8 CVRs Designed and Construction
Three types of CVR is designed and constructed which are used to
measure the amount of voltage and current passing through, as shown in
figure (3-8). They have very little impedance so as to pass most or all of
the power without any current loss.
The value of each resistance is measured during applying certain
voltage and calculated the current value of the return of its resistance
figure (3-9). Hence, the value of each resistance is obtained according to
Ohm's law and the slope is calculated by the following relation :
IVR
DD
= …………….(3-5)
Figure (3-10) shows the relationship between current and voltage in
order to calculate the value of resistance.
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
The specifications and measurement of each three resistance are as
follows (table (3-2)).
Table (3-2) The specifications and measurement of three types CVR
Parameters First Resistance Second Resistance Third Resistance
Length 14.5 cm 25 cm (30×4) 120 cm
Diameter 25 mm 20mm 15 mm
Resistance 0.2 mΩ 29 mΩ 6.4 mΩ
Thickness 0.5 mm 1.2 mm 0.2 mm
Figure (3-8): Photograph of the Current Shunt Resistance a- First, b- Second c-Third
(a) b) (
c) (
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-9): Measurment the value of the CVR. (a) ) Equivalent circuit (b) Photograph of the CVR
Figure (3-10) Graph shows the relationship between current and voltage in order to calculate the value of CVR a- First b- Second
c- Third resistance
a
(b)
(a)
b a
c
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
3.9 Capacitors Bank
High voltage capacitor consists of 16 big size chemical capacitors
type, each one with a length of 60 cm, width 34.5 cm and thickness 12.5
cm as shown in figure (3-11). All are connected in parallel to obtain the
total capacitor Ctotal= 39 μF. Each accepts the maximum voltage is 30 kV.
The stored energy can be calculated for each capacitor by the following
relationship:-
2CV21E = …………………(3-6)
The maximum energy storage in the capacitor bank is E = 17.6 kJ
Figure (3-11) The capacitor bank a- Diagram of one capacitor b- Photograph 16 capacitors
(a) (b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-12) Storage energy of capacitor bank for different voltages
3.10 Experimental Inductance
Two coils of insulating material are designed shaped as solenoid
(figure (3-13)) and used copper wire to wrap. The first coil is designed
and constructed for the purpose of controlling the damping factor and the
value of the time constant (t = L/R).
The damping factor in present work is defined as :
L4
)RR(Cd
2shexb
f+
= ……………(3-7)
where Cb is the capacitor bank, Rex is the external resistance and Rsh is the
current shunt resistance. It is equal's df @ 0.93 . The second coil is designed to study the effect of the magnetic field on
the parameters of the experiment (breakdown voltage, discharge current,
charging time and others).
The solenoid is composed of a number of circular current loops
having the same axis and the same current passes through them . The
magnetic field is obtained by summing up the fields of the separate
current loops.
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-13) Inductance coils a- First coil, b- Second coil (used with cylindrically-tipped electrodes)
To calculate the magnetic filed at any arbitrary point P on the axis of
a solenoid, consider a solenoid may be described as N turns uniformly
wound on a cylindrical form of radius (a) and length ( l ).
Such a configuration is shown in figure (3-14). The magnetic induction at
point z0 is found by dividing the length l into elements dz as shown in
the equation [133].
)83(..........................dz)az(
aNI2
dB 2322
20 -
+
m=
l
Applying equation (3-8) to each element and summing the results.
[ ])93(.........................dz
a)zz(
1aIN2
dB2
3220
0
20 -
+-
m= ò
l
l
The change of variable, z - z0 =a tanθ, leads to
)103........(..........2
sinsinNIdcosaIN
2dB 120
20 2
2-úû
ùêë
é q-qm=qq
m= ò
q
q ll
(a)
(b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
where θ1=-tan-1(z0/ a) and θ2=tan-1( l -z0)/ a. The fact that sines appear
rather than just ones as in the elementary formula, represents end
correction. To help understand the approximation that is usually made,
namely, B=μ0NI/ l it is convenient to introduce the angles α1 and α2 (both
positive) shown in figure (3-14). In terms of these angles, equation (2-10)
becomes
)113(...................2
)cos(cosNIB 210 -úû
ùêë
é a+am=
l
Figure (3-14): Axial magnetic field of a solenoid [49]
If the solenoid is long compared with its radius and z0 is not too close to
either zero or l , than α1 and α2 are both small angles and may be
approximated by [49]:-
)123(....................z
a,za
02
01 -
-@a@a
l
The magnetic field was measured by a Teslameter model
magnetfeldmeβgerat which made by Phywe company (made in Germany)
as shown in figure (3-15). The behavior of the magnetic field that
measured by Teslameter along the coil length at different currents are
shown in figure (3-16). The magnetic field has maximum values in the
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
center region. The magnitude of this field increases with the increasing
coil current.
Figure (3-15): The circuit of the measurement of the magnetic field
a-Schematic b- Photographic
Figure (3-16): The magnetic field distribution along the axis of the coil
(a)
(b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
The Inductance coils figure (3-13) has the following specifications shown
in table (3-3).
Table (3-13) The measurement parameters of coils
3.11 Trigger Circuit (Third Electrode)
A trigger circuit has been designed for accelerating the electrical
discharge between two electrodes of the spark gap. This circuit increases
the number of charge carriers in the dielectric medium by various
mechanisms depending on the type of the switch. Two types of trigger
circuit are designed : electronic and mechanical. The first one is designed
by using electronic lighter, while the second trigger circuit consists of
relay, power supply and push bottom switch as shown in figure (3-17).
Parameters First coil Second coil
Length of the coil l
17.5 cm
10 cm
Diameter of the coil
7.5cm 6 cm
Number of turns = N
22 turns 26 turns
Inductance = L 15.4 μH 24 μH
Resistance 33 mΩ 35 mΩ
Length of the wire= L1
6 m 5 m
Wire diameter 2 mm 1.8 mm
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-17) Trigger circuit a- Mechanical triggering diagram, and construction b- Electronic triggering
3.12 Voltage Divider
A divider for recording high transient voltages may consist of
resistance, capacitors, or combinations of both. The essential requirement
is that the measuring of the voltage wave shape should faithfully be
reproduced on the oscilloscope with an accurately known reduction ratio
as explained in chapter two (2.4) paragraph.
Voltage divider was designed and constricted to number of high and low
value resistance, that is connected in series to experience high voltage and
(a)
(b)
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
current passing through it as shown in figure (3-18) . Measurements can
be done by the potential divider on the low impedance section by a
storage oscilloscope or scale device as follows:
÷÷ø
öççè
æ+
=21
2inout RR
R V V ……………….(3-13)
R1 = 500 Ω
R2 = o.5 Ω
Vout = 10-3 Vin
if Vin = 1kV then Vout =1V
Figure (3-18) Schematic of the voltage divider
3.13 Commissioning Experiment Setup
A group of capacitors was stacked into a bank to deliver a
capacitively stored energy of variable level. This energy is controlled by
the amount of charging voltage, which is applied from a DC-power
supply as shown in figure (3-19). The experimental procedure starts by
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
setting the electrode spacing of the spark gap (d) measured by a calibrated
filler gauge.
To establish a proper damping conditions in the circuit, the capacitor
bank (Cb = 39 μF) was charged through a current-limiting resistance to
variable voltages. For each specified voltage, a discharge current was
recorded when the spark gap had been triggered via a particular mode. To
make sure that there was no additional inductance coupled to the circuit
from the triggering device, a number of experiments was carried out by
spark gap self-triggering (self breakdown). In such conditions, the bank
erected to a certain voltage level enough to establish self-breakdown
followed by the transport of discharge current.
The charging voltage was monitored by a (1000:1) standard high
voltage probe, which was connected to a digital multimeter. The
discharge current was recorded on a digital double beam storage
oscilloscope by using current-viewing resistance (CVR) which was
designed and constructed for this purpose. For cross-correlated
measurements of the discharge current, Rogowski coils also threaded into
the grounded connection of the RLC circuit. These coils were calibrated
to record the pulsed discharge currents.
A 50Ω matching coaxial impedance was connected to each input of
the oscilloscopes to avoid any possible mismatch in signal propagation. A
proper RC-integration circuit was connected to the output of the
Rogowski coil to measure the current rather than its rate of change.
Chapter Three Pulsed Electrical Discharge Experiments
Figure (3-19) Experimental setup Schematic photograph of the pulsed RLC circuit.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
4.1 Introduction
Various PED experiments with different configurations have been
carried out for constructing a scope of understanding of the behaviour of
the impedance of the plasma switch as a part of the high-voltage circuit
constructed and operated for this purpose.
For three electrode configurations; sphere-sphere, sphere-rod, and
cylindrically-tipped, results were analyzed in terms of the current-voltage
characteristics, temporal and spatial behaviour of the plasma switch, and
the erosion rate of the electrode surface. By considering these parameters,
the behaviour of the impedance was thoroughly investigated and
associated phenomena have been justified.
This chapter presents these results analyses and the discussion
necessary for each group of experimental conditions. 4.2 Spherical Spark Gap
Exploring the current-voltage and current-time characteristics of the
operational pulsed circuit, a number of preliminary experiments carried
out using the circuit shown in figure (3-1). By operating the spark gap
with self-breakdown mode, measurements of the time required for
charging the capacitor bank up to a voltage sufficient for self-breakdown
(charging time) were necessary to test the reliability of the circuit as well
as the range of reproducibility. Current measurements were carried out by
both CVR and Rogowski coils. Therefore, for each charging voltage,
there was a corresponding time-varying discharge current signal to be
inspected.
Figure (4-1) shows four typical oscillograms obtained for a spark
gap spacing of 0.5 mm using self-triggering mode (a and b ) and third-
electrode triggering mode (c and d). With a charging voltage of 2.8 kV, a
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
typical peak discharge current of (1.2±0.05) kA could be obtained for
self-triggering while a peak current value of (1.35±0.05)kA was obtained
with a 3 kV charging voltage in the other mode of triggering with longer
Figure (4-1) Typical discharge current oscillograms recorded by CVR and Rogowski coil; (a, b) self- triggering and (c, d) third-electrode
triggering.
spacing (2mm). The features of the signals illustrate the effect of both
triggering mode and gap spacing on the damping conditions of the circuit,
which explained in the chapter three, section (3.11).
4.2.1 Current Voltage-Characteristics
A typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve is
shown in figure (4-2), where both CVR and Rogowski coil measurements
of the current are demonstrated.
(a) (b)
VCharging=2.83kV d=0.5mm CVR
VCharging=2.83kV d=0.5mm Rogowski
VCharging= 3kV d=2mm CVR
VCharging= 3kV d=2mm Rogowski
(c) (d)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-2) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic
curve for d=2mm under third-electrode triggering mode Two regions may be distinguished in this curve; one region shows a
gradual increase in the current with raising the charging voltage and the
other, i.e., after a charging voltage of about 7 kV, shows a very slight
change in the current which illustrates that there is no additional source of
charged particles including that from secondary emission for the 2 mm
gap spacing where the electrical power is dissipated. Meanwhile figure
(4-3) shows a typical discharge current–charging voltage characteristic
curve where both CVR and Rogowski coil measurements of the current
are demonstrated with self-breakdown (self-triggering). It is clear from
figure (4-3) that the gap of the spherical electrodes varies in the range
from 0.5 mm to 2.5 mm and the corresponding breakdown voltage ranges
from 2.8 kV to 9.0 kV. Although these observations are expected but
under pulsed conditions they are reproducible within less than 10% of the
measurements under nonuniform field configuration.
In other recent experiments using an AC voltage and standard
spherical electrodes (25 cm in diameter), increase of the breakdown
voltage with lengthening the gap spacing was also reported [51].
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-3) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic
curve for different distance at self- breakdown 4.2.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit
A graphical representation of the charging and discharging times is
shown in figure (4-4). The performance of the pulsed circuit may be
envisaged by the ratio (discharging time/charging time) for the self-
breakdown condition.
Differences in current values may be imposed by the
(inductance/resistance) ratio of Rogowski coil, which is reasonably
acceptable in pulsed techniques where a number of readings are averaged
over their corresponding experimental conditions [47].
In the course of these experiments, a peak discharge current of 1.2 kA
was found to have a rise time of 150 ns at d=0.5mm while increasing
current up to 3.4 kA was recorded with a rise time of 161ns for the CVR
measurements at self-breakdown at d= 2.5 mm.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-4) Rise time of the pulse as a function of charging time for
Self-breakdown triggering
Figure (4-5) represents the rise time of the triggering (third electrode)
breakdown as a function of the discharge current for the same distance.
Figure (4-5) The rise time versus the discharge current for the same distance (d=2mm) by used third electrode triggering mode
Taking the full-width at the half maxima of current signals obtained
for gap spacing ranging from 0.5 mm to 2.5mm, a graphical
representation demonstrates that the time required for short-circuiting the
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
gap shows slight fluctuations as shown in figure (4-6). Such behaviour
illustrates the effect of damping conditions created within the gap
throughout the time interval of plasma expansion, i.e., oscillation
conditions need more than τfwhm to damp out for this circuit which is
slightly underdamped.
Figure (4-6) Variation of time of full width at the half maxima τfwhm
with gap spacing 4.2.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage An almost linear dependence of the breakdown voltage on the spark
gap spacing is shown in figure (4-7). This behavior demonstrates that
these experiments were run along the right side of the Paschen curve with
a nonthermal plasma generated within the gap at atmospheric pressure.
At this pressure the plasma is highly conductive as spark ignition
proceeds to arcing which may impose a shrinkage of both normal and
abnormal glow regions in the current-voltage characteristic curve of the
discharge [29].
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-7) Charging voltage versus gap spacing for self-breakdown
4.2.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance To investigate the time-evolution of the impedance of the spark gap
under study, a number of parameters were considered including the
damping conditions, gap spacing and pulse duration. Two approaches
were adopted to analyze the results of the output current signals. The first
was to take a number of oscillograms for various gap spacing. A number
of current values was extracted from each oscillogram that corresponds to
a certain distance (d). For a number of d-values ranged from 0.5mm to
2.5mm, the nominal impedance Z (charging voltage / discharge current)
was plotted as a function of the rise time of each pronounced current peak
on the oscillogram under self-breakdown conditions as shown in figure
(4-8).
The same trend of behaviour is obvious in both CVR and Rogowski
coil measurements of the current, as shown in figure (4-8). The values of
Z increases with enlarging d while the impedance shows a prompt
increase with rise time as a result of current degrading as the signal
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
damps out due to the finite closure time of the spark gap [39]. The peak
current values showed a periodic damp out as a result of the behaviour of
the external circuitry which must be accounted for in results analysis as
will be discussed below. Typical value of Z for the resistance (figure (4-
8)a ) took the rang from 2.9 Ω to 77 Ω over a time period between 161ns
and 600 ns for a gap distance of typically 2.5mm .
Figure (4-8) Typical impedance behaviour for self-breakdown mode at different distance (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillograms
(b)
(a)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-8)b shows typical value of Z for the Rogowski coil took
the range from 2.8 Ω to 77.4 Ω over a time period between 202 ns to 620
ns and for a gap distance of typically 2.5 mm.
The other way of analysis was to take the first half cycle of each
current signal in a number of oscillograms and record the peak value and
its rise time. Through a similar manner to that discussed above, the values
of Z were deduced and plotted as a function of the corresponding value of
the rise time as shown in figure (4-9).
Figure (4-9) Impedance as a function of current rise- time for self-breakdown mode (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillogram
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
It can be concluded from figures (4-8 and 4-9) that time-varying
impedance exists due to the inductance and resistivity of the spark gap as
well as the expansion of plasma channels along the spacing d. The gap
closure time may be taken as the time required for the plasma to expand
between the two gap electrodes resulting in an impedance collapse.
Over the whole range of experimental conditions being undertaken, the
average values of an overall nominal impedance were found in the range
(2-23)Ω depending on the gap and circuit parameters. Table (4-1)
illustrates typical Z-values corresponding to the operating parameters. Table (4-1) Illustrates typical Z-values for CVR and Rogowski coil for
different distance
d(mm)
CVR
Z(Ω)
Rogowski
Z(Ω)
0.5 2.4 2.3
1 2.5 2.5
1.5 2.6 2.6
2 2.7 2.6
2.5 2.9 2.8
4.2.5 Electrode Erosion Under Pulsed Discharge Over a number of experiments conducted with the spark gap and by
having an accumulative number of shots exceeding one thousand, power
dissipation within the gap resulted in an erosion on the surfaces of both
electrodes as shown in figure (4-10). Erosion rate may increase
nonlinearly with upgrading current levels [44].
The damage pattern created on the two surfaces has the dimensions
of about 8.3 mm on the high voltage electrode and 10.5 mm on the
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
grounded electrode. The expansion of plasma particles towards the
grounded electrode and space charge effect may be responsible for this
difference in pattern dimensions.
Figure (4-10) A photograph of the experimental spark gap showing the
formation of spark and damage patterns
It was found that the rate of electrode erosion was affected by the gap
length and the corresponding applied voltage. This may be attributed to
the energy dissipated within the spark gap. At low currents, the cathode is
exposed to erosion while the anode is not significantly affected. As the
current increases, anode spots are formed and anode erosion begins. At
high currents, both electrodes erodes experience significant erosion rate
[144].
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
4.3 Rod-Sphere Spark Gap
In order to study the effect of the degree of field nonuniformity, one
of the spherical electrodes in the spark gap was replaced by a rod. The
PED circuit was operated with this switch over a wide range of
conditions. Results were analyzed in an approach similar to that discussed
above. A typical discharge plasma flare is demonstrated in figure (4-11)
when the circuit was discharged through the rod-sphere gap.
Figure (4-11) Rod-Sphere electrodes during the self-breakdown
4.3.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics
A typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve is
shown in figure (4-12), when both CVR and Rogowski coil
measurements of the current are demonstrated for triggering mode (third
electrode). It is the same behavior as the spherical electrodes but different
in charging voltage which is less than the rod-sphere because the shape of
the spherical electrode is large unformed electrical field than rod sphere
electrodes.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-12) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve for d=2mm under third-electrode triggering mode
Figure (4-13) shows a typical discharge current-charging voltage
characteristic curve for self-breakdown when both CVR and Rogowski
coil measurements of the current are demonstrated with self breakdown
(self-triggering).
Figure (4-13): Typical discharge current-charging voltage
characteristic curve for different distance at self- breakdown
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
4.3.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit
In order to evaluate the transfer of energy from the capacitor bank
into the load in these experiments, a sufficient charging time must be
elapsed as a measure for a corresponding discharge time over a pulse-
shape the rise-time of which is sufficient to be considered for the circuit's
performance. A graphical representation of the charging and discharging
times is shown in figure (4-14) for self-breakdown condition. The
performance of the pulsed circuit may be envisaged as the ratio
(discharging time/charging time) for self-breakdown condition. The
differences in current values may be imposed by the
(inductance/resistance) ratio of Rogowski coil, which is reasonably
acceptable in pulsed techniques.
A peak discharge current of 1.2 kA was found to have a rise time of
139 ns for d=0.5 mm while increasing current up to 3.2 kA was recorded
with a rise time of 156 ns for the CVR measurements at d=2.5 mm for
self-breakdown.
Figure (4-14) Rise time of the pulse as a function of charging time for
Self-breakdown triggering
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-15) represents the rise time of the triggering (third electrode)
breakdown to the discharge current for the same distance. In this shape
the rise time decreases when charging voltage increases due to increased
ionization energy, which in turn causes increased the speed of the
electrons which leads to decrease of pulse rise time.
Figure (4-15) The rise time versus the discharge current for the same
distance (d=2mm) by used third electrode triggering mode Taking the full-width at the half maxima of current signals obtained
for gap spacing range from 0.5 mm to 3 mm, a graphical representation
demonstrates that the time required for short-circuiting the gap shows
slight fluctuations as shown in figure (4-16). These fluctuations may be
reduced by having more sampling measurements before having the
averages and standard errors. Temperature increase of the materials of
circuit's resistors may also raise their resistance to shift the damping
conditions towards an over damping mode [47]. Such behaviour
illustrates the effect of damping conditions created within the gap
throughout the time interval of plasma expansion, i.e., oscillation
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
conditions need more than τfwhm to damp out for this circuit which is
slightly underdamped.
Figure (4-16) Variation of time of full width at the half maxima τfwhm with gap spacing
4.3.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage
In the present spark gap, voltage and current may show variations in
both spatial and temporal modes. Figure (4-17) depicts a typical
dependence of the breakdown voltage on the spark gap spacing. This
behavior makes it clear that these experiments are run along the right side
of the Paschen curve with a nonthermal plasma generated within the gap
at atmospheric pressure. At this pressure, there is highly conductive
plasma channel as spark ignition proceeds to arcing, which may impose a
shrinkage of both normal and abnormal glow regions in the current-
voltage characteristic curve of the discharge.
These observations are familiar in PED experiments as the rise-time
of the pulse is equal or slightly longer than that required for glow
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
discharge transitions, i.e. from normal to above-normal glow or from the
later to an arc [8].
Figure (4-17) Charging voltage versus gap spacing for self-breakdown
4.3.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance
Over a wide range of experimental conditions the dynamic correlation
between the voltage and current may be established by investigating the
impedance of the circuit over the whole pulse for many pulsed
discharges. The impedance behaviour of the resent spark gap, covers a
number of parameters including the damping conditions, gap spacing and
pulse duration. Two methods were adopted to analyze the results of the
output current signals. The first was to take a number of oscillograms for
various gap spacing. A number of current values was extracted from each
oscillogram that corresponds to a certain distance (d).
For a number of d-values ranged from 0.5 mm to 3 mm, the nominal
impedance Z (charging voltage / discharge current) was plotted as a
function of the rise time of each pronounced current peak on the
oscillogram under self-breakdown conditions as shown in figure (4-18).
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-18) Typical impedance behaviour for self-breakdown mode at different distance (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from
various current oscillograms The same trend of behaviour can obviously be noticed in both CVR and
Rogowski coil measurements of the current, (figure (4-18)). The values of
Z increases with enlarging d while the impedance shows a prompt
increase with rise time as a result of current degrading as the signal
damps out due to the finite closure time of the spark gap with its certain
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
spacing and field geometry which governs the energy of particles, i.e.,
power time. Typical value of Z for the resistance (figure (4-18)a) took the
range from 2.2 Ω to 57 Ω over a time period between 156 ns and 600 ns
for a gap distance of typically 2.5 mm . Figure (4-18)b shows typical
value of Z for the Rogowski coil that has taken the range from 2.1 Ω to
55 Ω over a time period between 200ns to 620ns and for a gap distance of
typically 2.5mm.
Figure (4-19) Impedance as a function of current rise- time for self-breakdown mode (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillogram
(b)
(a)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
As discussed in section (4-2-4), the other way of analysis was to take
the first half cycle of each current signal in a number of oscillograms and
record the peak value and its rise time. Through a similar manner to that
discussed above, the values of Z were deduced and plotted as a function
of the corresponding value of the rise time as shown in figure (4-19). It
can be concluded from figures (4-18 and 4-19) that time-varying
impedance exists due to the inductance and resistivity of the spark gap as
well as the expansion of plasma channels along the spacing d. The gap
closure time may be taken as the time required for the plasma to expand
between the two gap electrodes resulting in an impedance collapse. Over
the whole range of experimental conditions being undertaken, the average
values of an overall nominal impedance were found in the range (1.5-
19.4) Ω depending on the gap and circuit parameters.
4.4 Cylindrically-Tipped Spark Gap
As discussed in section (1-11), the density of equipotential surfaces
and electric flux density can be altered by the two electrode surfaces
subtended the electric field lines. In these experiments, a spark gap with a
cylindrically-tipped electrode was incorporated within the high-voltage
circuit to establish a good understanding of the geometry effect which
may alter the values of the current density rather than the peak current.
The cylindrically-tipped electrodes were used in these experiments to
form a spark gap as shown in the photograph of figure (4-20) during a
typical breakdown stage after a number of shots.
A number of experiments were carried out with this configuration by
using both self-breakdown and trigger-electrode modes. By doing so, the
effect of an external inductance possessed by the triggering electrode
circuit can be observed in the output signal after the circuit is being
discharged.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-20): Cylindrically-tipped electrodes during a typical self-
breakdown stage
4.4.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics A typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve is
shown in figure (4-21) where both CVR and Rogowski coil
measurements of the current are demonstrated for triggering mode (third
electrode).
The effect of the electric field lines on the applied voltage may be
significant and can be altered when the degree of uniformity is
considered. This can be simply understood from the basic relationship
between the voltage and the electric field for any two electrodes. This
degree of field uniformity may be determined by the ratio of the electrode
dimension and the gap spacing. In figure (4-22) a typical discharge
current–charging voltage characteristic curve for triggering breakdown is
shown where both CVR and Rogowski coil measurements of the current
are demonstrated. Typical peak current values ranged from 0.8 kA to 4.7
kA were recorded when voltages between 1 kV and 9 kV were applied
for changing the C-bank.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-21) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic
curve for d=2mm under third-electrode triggering mode
Although the discharge mechanism is governed by a streamer, see section
(1-4), such behaviour looks linear in a part of it because the voltage
considered is the charging voltage. However, more future measurements
of discharge voltage may put forward more understanding of the current-
voltage characteristic curves.
Figure (4-22) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic
curve for different distance at self breakdown
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Comparison of figures (4-21) and (4-22) may significantly present the
values of the parameters corresponding to the two modes of triggering the
spark gap.
4.4.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit Similarly, a graphical representation of the charging and discharging
times is shown in figure (4-23). The performance of the pulsed circuit
may be envisaged by the ratio (discharging time/charging time) for self-
breakdown condition. The differences in current values may be imposed
by the (inductance/resistance) ratio of Rogowski coil, which is reasonably
acceptable in pulsed techniques. In the present experiments, a peak
discharge current of 1 kA was found to have a rise time of 163 ns while
increasing current up to 4.3 kA was recorded with a rise time of 174 ns
for the CVR measurements at self-breakdown.
Figure (4-23) Rise time of the pulse as a function of charging time for
Self-breakdown triggering
Under these conditions when the dimensions of the electrodes are altered,
both inductance (L) and capacitance (C) of the gap will be varied
consequently because both L and C are geometry-dependent. Such
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
variation of both L and C of the gap will introduce a change in the total
impedance of the circuit giving rise to an alteration in the rising and
decaying parts of the pulsed discharge current signal. This may be
understood by the ratios (L / R) of the circuit for the rise-time and (RC)
for the time after the peak current toward the end of the signal tail.
Figure (4-24) represents the rise time of the triggering (third electrode)
breakdown to the discharge current for the same distance.
Figure (4-24) The rise time versus the discharge current for the same distance (d=2mm) by used third electrode triggering mode
Taking the full-width at the half maxima of current signals obtained
for gap spacing that ranged from 0.2 mm to 1.8 mm, a graphical
representation demonstrates that the time required for short-circuiting the
gap shows slight fluctuations as shown in figure (4-25). Such behaviour
illustrates the effect of damping conditions created within the gap
throughout the time interval of plasma expansion, i.e., oscillation
conditions need more than τfwhm to damp out for this circuit which is
slightly underdamped.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-25) Variation of time of full width at the half maxima τfwhm with gap spacing
4.4.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage
The dependence of the breakdown voltage on the spark gap spacing is
shown in figure (4-26) at small distance of (0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8, 1, 1.2, 1.4,
1.6, and 1.8) mm. This behavior demonstrates that these experiments are
run along the right side of the Paschen curve with a nonthermal plasma
generated within the gap at atmospheric pressure. At this pressure, the
plasma is highly conductive as spark ignition proceeds to arcing, which
may impose a shrinkage of both normal and abnormal glow regions in the
current –voltage characteristic curve of the discharge [29].
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-26) Charging voltage versus gap spacing for self-breakdown
4.4.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance
A number of parameters were considered including the damping
conditions, gap spacing and pulse duration. Two approaches were
adopted to analyze the results of the output current signals. The first was
to take a number of oscillograms for various gap spacing. A number of
current values was extracted from each oscillogram that corresponds to a
certain distance (d). For a number of d-values ranging from 0.5mm to 1.5
mm, the nominal impedance Z (charging voltage / discharge current) was
plotted as a function of the rise time of each pronounced current peak on
the oscillogram under self-breakdown conditions as shown in figure (4-
27). The same trend of behaviour is obvious in both CVR and Rogowski
coil measurements of the current as shown in figure (4-28). The values of
Z increases with enlarging d while the impedance shows a prompt
increase with rise time as a result of current degrading as the signal
damps out due to the finite closure time of the spark gap. The peak
current values showed a periodic damp out as a result of the behaviour of
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
the external circuitry which must be accounted for in results analysis as
will be discussed below. Typical value of Z for the resistance (figure (4-
28)a) took the range from 2.2 Ω to 80 Ω over a time period between 167
ns and 600 ns for a gap distance of typically 1.5 mm. Figure (4-8)b
shows a typical value of Z for the Rogowski coil taking a range from 2
Ω to 79 Ω over a time period between 205 ns to 620 ns and for a gap
distance of typically 1.5 mm.
Figure (4-27) Typical impedance behaviour for self-breakdown mode at
different distance (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various current oscillograms
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
From a number of oscillograms the values of Z were obtained and
plotted as function of the rise-time as demonstrated in figure (4-28).
It may be concluded from figures (4-27) and (4-28) that the time-
evolution of Z depends on the inductance and resistivity of the spark gap
as well as the expansion of plasma channels along the spacing d.
Figure (4-28) Impedance as a function of current rise- time for self-breakdown mode (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillogram
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
The gap closure time may also be taken as the time required for the
plasma to expand between the two gap electrodes resulting in an
impedance collapse. Over the whole range of experimental conditions
being undertaken, the average values of an overall nominal impedance
were found in the range (2-30)Ω depending on the gap and circuit
parameters. Also, this range implies the approximation of consider the
charging voltage in the calculation.
4.5 Comparison of Results of Various Gap Configurations
Results of the three spark gap configuration were compared with
each other to establish an optimum conditions and parameters, which
were capable of imposing such features on all experiments. Typical
values were selected for such comparison can be seen below.
4.5.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics
Figure (4-29) is a typical discharge current–charging voltage
characteristic curve showing current both CVR and Rogowski coil
measurements with self-breakdown (self-triggering) for three electrodes
configurations. In this figure, one can see that the discharge current for
cylindrically-tipped electrodes is slightly greater than that of spherical
and rod-sphere electrodes. These observations can be attributed to the
nature of the electric field and the electric flux density within the gap.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-29) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve for different distance at self-breakdown for three electrodes
configurations (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil
4.5.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit A graphical representation of the charging and discharging times is
shown in figure (4-30) under self-breakdown condition for the three
electrodes. The performance of the pulsed circuit may be envisaged by
the ratio (discharging time/charging time) for self-breakdown condition.
(b)
(a)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-30) Rise time of the pulse as a function of charging time for Self-breakdown triggering (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil
The differences in current values may be imposed by the
(inductance/resistance) ratio of Rogowski coil, which is reasonably
acceptable in pulsed techniques.
4.5.3 Spatial Behaviors of the Spark Gap Voltage
The breakdown characteristics between three type electrodes (sphere-
sphere, rod-sphere and cylindrically-tipped) are observed with variations
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
in electrode arrangements, both in size and spacing. It is concluded that
with the increase of gap between spheres the breakdown voltage and
electric field strength are increased.
Figure (4-31) represents the behavior of the three types while
cylindrically-tipped electrode which need large voltage to obtain self-
breakdown whereas the spherical and rod-sphere electrodes need less
breakdown voltage.
As indicated in the figure, the cylindrical-tipped electrodes behaviors
like almost plane electrodes because of its thickness and the gap spacing.
However, more analysis of the electric field lines and equipotential
surface are substantially required to figure out the degree of field
uniformity [146].
Figure (4-31) Charging voltage versus gap spacing for self-breakdown to the three electrodes for different distance (0.5, 1, 1.5mm)
4.5.4 Temporal Characteristics of the Impedance The impedance characteristic of the spark gap can be compared of the
three electrodes (spherical, rod-sphere and cylindrically-tipped) at
distance 0.5 mm for self-breakdown shown in figure (4-32).
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-32) Typical impedance behaviour for self-breakdown mode at distance 0.5mm for CVR extracted from various current oscillograms
for three electrodes
Compression charging voltage to the discharge current of the peak
for pulsed electrical discharge and the impedance at this region for three
electrodes at distance 0.5 mm for self-breakdown for CVR measurement
is shown in table (4-2)
Table (4-2) Compression of results three electrode configurations at distance 0.5 mm spacing for self-breakdown (CVR measurements)
Electrodes Geometry Vch /kV Id /kA Z/ Ω Sphere-Sphere 2.8 1.3 2.2
Rod-Sphere 2.1 1.2 1.7 Cylindrically-Tipped 3.5 1.9 1.9
The other way of comparison analysis is to take the first half cycle of
each current signal in a number of oscillograms and record the peak value
and its rise time. The values of Z are deduced and plotted as a function of
the corresponding value of the rise time as shown in figure (4-33).
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-33) Impedance as a function of current rise- time for self-breakdown mode for CVR extracted from various current oscillogram
(d=0.5mm) for three electrodes 4.6 Magnetic Field Effect on the Cylindrically-Tipped Spark Gap
The behavior of the magnetic field can be explained in this section.
The solenoid coil is used whose specifications is explained in chapter
three, section (3.10). Figure (4-34) shows the cylindrically-tipped
electrode, which rounded to solenoid coil during the self-breakdown.
The magnetic field effect can be visualized as the interaction of
charged particles of the plasma with this field within the spark gap
region. The arrangement of the coil is made in such a way that the peak of
the magnetic field strength occurs at mid-way of the gap spacing resulting
a region of a slight magnetic confinement of the particles, i.e., at a region
of magnetic field of strength 27G along the coil axis.
Under these conditions electrons will be guided between the two
electrodes producing more ionization along the gap axis in addition to a
reduction of lateral diffusion of these electrons [40].
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-34) Inductance coil used with cylindrically-tipped electrodes during the self- breakdown
Figure (4-35) shows two typical oscillograms obtained for
cylindrically-tipped electrodes with magnetic field and a spark gap
spacing of 0.5 mm using self-triggering mode (a and b ). With a charging
voltage of 3 kV, a typical peak discharge current of (2.2±0.05) kA could
be obtained for self-triggering.
Figure (4-35) Typical discharge current oscillograms recorded by CVR and Rogowski coil; (a, b) self- triggering to the cylindrically-tipped
electrodes with magnetic field
VChar=3.1kV d=0.5mm B = 27G
Rogowski
VChag=3.1kV d=0.5mm B= 27G
CVR
(a) (b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
4.6.1 Current-Voltage Characteristics
Figure (4-36) a typical discharge current–charging voltage
characteristic curve is shown where both CVR and Rogowski coil
measurements of the current are demonstrated with self-breakdown (self-
triggering). The effect of the magnetic field is to show that with its
increase in our experiment the maximum magnetic field used is 27G. The
effect of the magnetic field on the discharge current is about 10% for
increasing the current.
Figure (4-36) Typical discharge current-charging voltage characteristic curve for different distance at self-breakdown (a) CVR (b) Rogowski
(a)
b) (
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-37) represents the charging voltage and the magnetic
field, used for different distances for self-breakdown. In this part can be
shown that the magnetic field caused decreasing of the charging voltage
at the same distance.
Figure (4-37) Charging voltage versus magnetic field for self-breakdown
Figure (3-38) represents the behavior of the discharge current to the
magnetic field for self-breakdown and shows that at increasing the
magnetic field the discharge current increases.
A typical discharge current–charging voltage characteristic curve for
self-breakdown using a magnetic field of 27G is shown when both CVR
and Rogowski coil measurements of the current are demonstrated.
Typical peak current values ranged from 2.2 kA at distance 0.5 mm to 4.3
kA at distance 1.5 mm were recorded when voltages between 3.2 kV and
8.1 kV were applied for changing the C-bank.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-38) Discharge current versus magnetic field for self-breakdown
4.6.2 The Performance of the PED Circuit A graphical representation of the charging and discharging times is
shown in figure (4-39). The performance of the pulsed circuit may be
envisaged as the ratio (discharging time/charging time) for self-
breakdown condition. The behavior is demonstrated when increasing
magnetic field the rise time increases and decreasing the charging time. In
the present experiments, a peak discharge current of 2.3 kA is found to
have a rise time of 175 ns at d = 0.5 mm while increasing current up to
4.3 kA at d = 1.5 mm is recorded with a rise time of 188 ns for the CVR
measurements at self-breakdown.
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-39) Rise time of the pulse as a function of charging time for Self-breakdown triggering (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil
4.6.3 Magnetic Field Effect on the Impedance
To investigate the impedance behaviour of the spark gap, a number
of parameters were considered including the damping conditions, gap
spacing and pulse duration. Two approaches were adopted to analyze the
results of the output current signals. The first was to take a number of
(b)
(a)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
oscillograms for various gap spacing. A number of current values was
extracted from each oscillogram that corresponds to a certain distance (d).
For a number of d-values that ranged from 0.5 mm to 1.5 mm, the
nominal impedance Z (charging voltage / discharge current) was plotted
as a function of the rise time of each pronounced current peak on the
oscillogram under self-breakdown conditions as shown in figure (4-40).
Figure (4-40) Typical impedance behaviour for self-breakdown mode at different distance (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillograms
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Typical value of Z for the CVR as shown in figure (4-40)a took the rang
from 1.4 Ω to 38 Ω over a time period between 175 ns and 600 ns for a
gap distance of typically 0.5 mm. However typical value of Z for the
Rogowski coil took the range from 1.3 Ω to 37 Ω over a time period
between 216 ns to 620 ns and for a gap distance of typically 0.5 mm.
The same trend of behaviour is obvious in both CVR and Rogowski
coil measurements of the current shown in figure (4-41)a and b. The
values of Z increase with enlarging d while the impedance shows a
prompt increase with rise time as a result of current degrading as the
signal damps out due to the finite closure time of the spark gap.
The other way of analysis was to take the first half cycle of each
current signal in a number of oscillograms and record the peak value and
its rise time. Through a similar manner to that discussed above, the values
of Z were deduced and plotted as a function of the corresponding value of
the rise time as shown in figure (4-41).
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
Figure (4-41) Impedance as a function of current rise- time for self-breakdown mode (a) CVR (b) Rogowski coil, extracted from various
current oscillogram
The speed of plasma propagation along the spark gap electrodes
were deduced from the output waveforms by considering the value of
τfwhm and the electrode spacing . A nominal value of this speed was found
to be 5.6 m μs-1.
(a)
(b)
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
4.7 Conclusion In order to establish a scope of understanding of the temporal
behaviour of the impedance featured by a PED circuit, it was essential to
study the plasma characteristics within the circuit's switching device.
The plasma behaviour is elucidated by constructing a group of
curves relating the governing parameters such as current, voltage, gap
spacing, charging and discharging times, electric field configuration, and
external circuit elements.
Regardless of the complication of the physics behind the operation
of pulsed plasma devices, these experiments have demonstrated a
number of potentially practical conclusion, which can be summarized as
follows:-
1- The temporal behaviour of the total circuit impedance showed a
strong dependence on the behaviour of the nonthermal plasma which
is generated during the breakdown process of the air between the
spark gap electrodes.
2- All the discharge current waveforms showed damped oscillations
from which results analyses were accomplished. These modes of
oscillations may be governed by a dominating inductance in the
circuit as well as the electronic components included in the methods
of triggering.
3- The first cycle of the discharge current signal may be considered as
that resulted from the spark gap closure by the plasma expansion the
time of which is measured by the full width at the half maxima of
this part of the signal.
4- Due to the existence of the external inductance in the circuit, damped
pulses occur in the discharge current signals over a certain period of
Chapter Four Results Analysis and Discussion
time which can be figured out from the RC time constant of each
corresponding current signal.
5- Slight alteration in the dependence of the discharge voltage on the
product (Pd) was observed when the gap was immersed in a
longitudinal magnetic field due to the slight deviation of Paschen
curve on its right hand side.
6- The triggering method was found to have an effect on the discharge
current pulses monitored by both current viewing resistance and
Rogowski coil.
7- aDamage patterns on the surfaces of the gap electrodes were
photographed as they resulted from power dissipation within the gap
controlled by discharge current levels.
4.8 Future Work
1- The present PED experiments can be extended for higher magnetic
field generation for immersing the spark gap. In doing so, the
electromagnetic drift forces may be more pronounced and their
effects can modify the operation of the spark gap.
2- Higher stored energy in the C-bank can be achieved by raising the
charging voltage (more than 10kV) which requires a modification
of the whole circuit components including the spark gap itself.
(a)
Paper published from this thesis
1- A. S. Hasaani, Ala’ F. Ahmed and A. A. Khdayeir "Impedance
Characteristics of Pulsed Atmospheric Electrical Discharge in
Spherical Plasma Switch" Baghdad Science Journal, Vol.8, No.2,
pp.630-637 (2011).
المستخلص
الجراء تجارب حاثةمتسعة ومومقاومة نبضية عالية تحتوي على فولتية دائرةتستخدمأ
تفريغ كهربائي في مفتاح بالزما في ثالثة اشكال هندسية هي كروي ، قضيب-كرة واسطواني حيث
. kV 8 صنعت من مادة الفوالذ والنحاس .وقد وصلت فولتية الشحن فيها الى اكثر من
لقياس تيار التفريغ النبضي عند انهيار مفتاح البالزما وفسكي غروات وملفمجزئ مقاومة ت ستخدمأ
4.5kAبنمطين هما التفريغ الذاتي و باستخدام قطب ثالث للتفريغ حيث وصلت قيمة الذروة للتيار الى
اعتمدا على مكونات الدائرة والمسافة بين االقطاب μs 0.3 و μs 0.1تراوحت بين زمن النبضة و
تحت تاثير الضغط 5.6m/secحيث كان متوسط سرعة البالزما على طول الفجوة بين القطبين هو
الجوي االعتياديز
اوجدت التجارب وجود سلوك حثي سائد في الدائرة معتمدا على قيمة مكوناتها وخصائص
البالزما المتولدة بين قطبي فجوة المفتاح وانعكاس ذلك على ممانعة الدائرة النبضية . وبسبب
التفريغات الكهربائية المتراكمة وتفاعل الطاقة مع سطح القطبين لوحظ وجود اثار للتفريغ الكهربائي
mm 10.5 وةقطب الفولتية العالي على mm 8.3بالنسبة لالقطاب الكروية الشكل وصلت اقطاره
تحت جميع الظروف التجريبية المعطاة وجد ان .على قطب مفتاح البالزما الموصول باالرضي
اوم معتمدة على ظروف التذبذب وطريقة تحليل نتائج 30 اوم و2القيمة المطلقة للممانعة تتراوح بين
اشارات تيارالتفريغ الكهربائي.
قورنت نتائج استخدام االقطاب الثالثة ( الكروي ،االسطواني والقضيب- الكرة ) في حالة
االنهيار الذاتي حيث لوحظ ان االقطاب االسطوانية النحاسية تحتاج الى فولتية اعلى ووقت اطول لكي
يحدث االنهيار الذاتي وذلك باالعتماد على المساحة السطحية التي يقع بها تأثير المجال الكهربائي
بالمقارنة مع االقطاب الكروية والقضيب و الكرة .
استخدم مجال مغناطيسي بين االقطاب االسطوانية حيث كان هناك تأثيرطفيف على قيمة تيار التفريغ
في الفجوة علما ان الملف موضوع بشكل تكون (27G)وخاصةعند زيادة شدة المجال المغناطيسي
فية اعلى شدة للمجال المغناطيسي في منتصف المسافة بين قطبي الفجوة وهناك ايضا تأثيرات على
الفولتية التي يحد ث عندها االنهيار او التفريغ الكهربائي النبضي حيث يؤدي الى تقليلها وكذلك تقليل
الزمن الذي يحدث عنده االتفريغ الكهربائي بين نبضة واخرى عند نفس الظروف المستخدمة في
التجربة في حالة عدم استخدام مجال مغناطيسي .
References
References
[1] Woloszko, Kenneth R. Stalder, and Ian G. Brown "Plasma Characteristics of Repetitively-Pulsed Electrical Discharges in Saline Solutions Used for Surgical Procedures" IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, Vol. 30, No. 3, pp.1376-1383 (2002).
[2] Abou-Ghazala , S. Katsuki , Schoenbach , F. Dobbs and K. Moreira "Bacterial Decontamination of water by means of pulsed Corona Discharges" IEEE Transaction on Plasma Science, Vol.30, No. 4 ,pp. 1449- 1453 (2002).
[3] A. S. Hasaani "On the Temporal Behavior of Pulsed Relativistic Electron Beam Diodes" Engineering and Technology, Vol. 12, No. 4, pp.56-69 (1993).
[4] W. C. Nunnally, R. Lewis, F. Allen, S. Hawkins, C. Holmses, S. Sarnpayan , and G. Capopraso "Experiments with UV laser triggered spark gaps in a stacked Blumlein system" IEEE Int. Pulsed Power Conference (Monterey ,Ca, USA Journal, pp. 14-17 (2005).
[5] H. Akiyama, T. Sakugawa, T. Namihira, K. Takaki, Y. Minamitani, and N. Shimomura "Industrial Applications of Pulsed Power Technology" IEEE Tran. On Diele. And Elect. Insu. , Vol. 14, No. 5, pp.1051-1064 (2007).
[6] Annemie Bogaertsa, Erik Neytsa, Renaat Gijbelsa, Joost van der Mullenb "Review Gas discharge plasmas and their applications" Spectrochimica Acta Part B 57, pp. 609–658 (2002).
[7] Boris M. Smirnov "Physics of Ionized Gases" (Wiley-VCH, New York, 2001).
[8] A. S. Hasaani, Ala’ F. Ahmed and A. A. Khdayeir "Impedance Characteristics of Pulsed Atmospheric Electrical Discharge in Spherical Plasma Switch" Baghdad Science Journal, Vol.8 No.2, pp.630-637 (2011).
[9] A.S. Hasaani "Magnetically Confined Plasmas: The Past and the Present State of The Art" Iraqi J. Sci. and Technol., Vol.3 No.1, pp.111-120 (2006).
[10] Raizer, Y. P. "Gas discharge physics" (Spring-Verlag, New York 1991).
References
[11] Vijay Nehra, Ashok Kumar and H K Dwivedi "Atmospheric Non-Thermal Plasma Sources" International J. of Engineering, Vol.2 Issue (1), pp.53-68 (2004).
[12] Nicholas A. Krall and Alvin W. Trivelpiece "Principles of plasma physics" (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1973).
[13] Michael .A. Liebermann and Allan J. Lichtenberg "Principles of Plasma Discharges and Materials Processing" (John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1994).
[14] Sanborn C. Brown "Introduction to Electrical Discharges in Gases" (John Wiley and Sons, INC, 1966).
[15] H Conrads and M Schmidt "Plasma generation and plasma sources" Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. Vol. 9, pp. 441-454 (2000).
[16] J. Reece Roth "Industrial Plasma Engineering" Vol.2. (Bristol and Philedelphia: Instute of Physics Publishing, 2001).
[17] Annemie Bogaerts "The glow Discharge an Exciting Plasma Invited Lecture" J. Anal. At. Spectrom. , pp.1375-1384 (1999).
[18] Rees, J. A. "Electric Breakdown in Gases" (John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1973).
[19] A.Ganguli and R. D. Tarey "Understanding plasma sources" Current Science, Vol.83, No.3, pp. 279-290 (2002).
[20] E. Kuffel, W. S. Zaengl, and J. Kuffel "High Voltage Engineering: Fundamentals" (Newnes, New York, 2000).
[21] Donald. H. Hale "The Townsend Ionization Coefficients for Ni and Al Cathodes in an Atmosphere of Hydrogen" Physical Review, Vol. 56, pp.1199-1202 (1939).
[22] J. M. Meek and J. D. Craggs "Electrical Breakdown of Gases" (Oxford at The Clarendon Press, 1953).
[23] E. Kuffel and M.Abdullah "High Voltage Engineering" (Pergamon Press Itd., Oxford, 1970).
[24] H. Edels, F.W. Crawford "Gaseous Electrical Conduction and the Circuit- Breaker" Journal of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, Vol.2, pp. 712-716, Dec. (1956).
References
[25] A. Chirokov, A. Gutsol and A. Fridman "Atmospheric pressure plasma of dielectric barrier discharges" Pure Appl. Chem., Vol. 77, No. 2, pp. 487–495 (2005 ).
[26] Stephen M. Rossnagel , Jerome J. Cuomo and William D. Westwood "Handbook of Plasma Processing Technology , Fundamentals" (Noyes Publications, Park Ridge, NJ, 1990).
[27] H Bluhm "Pulsed Power Systems: Principles and Applications" (Springer, Berlin, 1996).
[28] N. Georgescu "High Voltage Pulsed, Cold Atmospheric Plasma Jets: Electrical Characterization" Romanian Reports in Physics, Vol. 60, No. 4, pp. 1025–1032 (2008).
[29] Andreas Schutze, James Y. Jeong, Steven E. Babayan, Jaeyoung Park, Gary S. Selwyn and Robert F. Hicks "The Atmospheric Pressure Plasma Jet : A Review and Comparison to Other Plasma Sources" IEEE Transitions On Plasma Science, Vol. 26 , No.6 , pp. 1685-1694 (1998).
[30] R.Barni, S.Zanini, R.Siliprandi, P.Esena, and C.Riccardi "Characterization of atmospheric pressure discharges" Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on the Frontiers of Plasma Physics and Technology (PC/5099), pp. 17-24, (2006).
[31] David Staack, Bakhtier Farouk, Alexander Gutsol and Alexander Fridman "Characterization of dc atmospheric pressure normal glow discharge" Plasma Sources Sci. Technol.Vol.14, pp. 700- 711 (2005).
[32] Tao Shao, Kaihua Long, Cheng Zhang, Jue Wang, Dongdong Zhang, Ping Yan, Shichang Zhang "Electrical characterization of dielectric barrier discharge driven by repetitive nanosecond pulses in atmospheric air" Journal of Electrostatics, Vol.67, pp. 215–221 (2009).
[33] C. L. Wadhwa "High Voltage Engineering" published by New Age International (P) Limited, 2nd edition (2007).
[34] Shaomao Li "Cold Cathode Materials for Pseudospark Switches" M.Sc., Thesis, Auburn University, Alabama (2010). [35] Esin Bengisu Sozer "Gaseous Discharges and their Applications As High Power Plasma Switches for Compact Pulsed Powers Systems" MSc. thesis, University of Auburn (2008).
[36] Hasibur Rahaman "Investigation of a High Power, High Pressure Spark Gap Switch with High Repetition Rate" PhD. Thesis, University Erlangen–Nürnberg (2007).
References
[37] BL Meena, SK. Rai, MS Tyagi, UN Pal, M Kumar and AK Sharma "Characterization of high power Pseudospark Plasma Switch (PSS)" Journal of Physics: IOP Publishing , Conference Series 208, 012110 (2010).
[38] Hasibur Rahaman, Byung-Joon Lee, Jürgen Urban, Robert Stark, Klaus Frank and S.H. Nam "A spark gap switch with very high repetition rate" 28th ICPIG, , Prague, Czech Republic. pp. 1496-1498, July 15-20 (2007).
[39] Horacio Bruzzone, Cesar Moreno and Roberto Vieytes "Measurement of the time evolution of averaged impedances in small atmospheric pressure spark gap" Meas. Sci. Technol. , Vol.4, pp. 952 -956 (1993).
[40] A. S. Hasaani "Correlation of Paschen Parameters in Magnetized argon Plasma" Iraqi , J. Phys. , Vol. 8, No. 11, pp. 95-101 (2010).
[41] Ya. E. Krasika, K. Chirko, J.Z. Gleizer, A. Krokhmal, A. Dunaevsky, and J. Felsteiner "Application of a ferroelectric plasma cathode as a high-current switch" Eur. Phys. J. D, Vol. 19, pp. 89-95 (2002).
[42] W. Frey, M. Sack, R. Wuestner and G. Mueller "Gas-Insulated Self-Breakdown Spark Gaps" Conference on Electrostatic Precipitation, pp.704-708 (2008).
[43] J. R. Beveridge, S. J. MacGregor, M. J. Given, I. V. Timoshkin "A Corona-stabilized Plasma Closing Switch" IEEE Trans. Dielectr. Electr. l Insul., Vol. 16, No.4, pp. 948-955, (2009).
[44] Z. Liu, A. J. M. Pemen, E. J. M. van Heesch, K. Yan, G. J. J. Winands, D. B. Pawlok "A Multiple-switch Technology for High-power Pulse Discharging" 11th International Conference on Electrostatic Precipitation, pp.704-708 (2008).
[45] H.J.Doucet, M.Roche and J.M.Buzzi "Very high Power Plasma Switches Basic Plasma and Switch Technology" 14, International congress on electric contacts Paris (FR), pp. 1-24 (1988).
[46] D. Bruce Montgomery "The Generation of High Magnetic Fields" Rep. Progress. Phys. Vol.26, pp 69-104 (1963).
[47] A.S. Hasaani "Experimental Studies of Differtiating Rogowski Coils" J. Math. and Phys. ,Vol.13, No.2 , pp. 160-176 (1993).
References
[48] Ahmed H. Wanas "Temporal Behaviour of Glow Discharge in Nitrogen" M.Sc. Thesis, University of Baghdad, College of Science (2005). [49] J.R.Reitz, F.J.Milford, and R.W.Christy "Foundations of Electromagnetic Theory" (Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc., California, 1979).
[50] Mark Lawrence Lipham "Electrical Breakdown Studies of Partial Pressure Argon Under KHz Rang Pulse Voltages" M.Sc. Thesis, Auburn University, Alabama (2010).
[51] Paraselli Bheema Sankar "Measurement of Air Breakdown Voltage and Electrical Field Using Standard Sphere Gap Method" M.Sc. Thesis, National Institute of Technology, Rourkela Rourkela- India (2011).
[52] Allen L. Garner, George Chen , Nianyong Chen, Viswanadham Sridhara, Juergen F. Kolb and Karl H. Schoenbach "Ultrashort electric pulse induced changes in cellular dielectric properties" Biophysical and Biophysical Research Communications, Vol. 362, pp. 139- 144 (2007).
[53] Z. Machala, M. Janda, K. Hensel, I. Jedlovsky, L. Lesˇtinska, V. Foltin, V. Martisˇovits and M. Morvova "Emission spectroscopy of atmospheric pressure plasmas for bio-medical and environmental applications" Journal of Molecular Spectroscopy, Vol. 243 , pp.194–201 (2007).
[54] Bart Roodenburg, Johan Morren, H.E. Berg and Sjoerd W.H. de Haan "Metal release in a stainless steel pulsed electric field (PEF) system Part II. The treatment of orange juice; related to legislation and treatment chamber lifetime" Innovative Food Science and Emerging Technologies Vol. 6, pp. 337 – 345 (2005).
[55] Jozef Korolczuk, Jose Rippoll Mc Keag, Jose´ Carballeira Fernandez, Florence Baron, Noe¨l Grosset , and Romain Jeantet "Effect of pulsed electric field processing parameters on Salmonella enteritidis inactivation" J. of Food Engineering Vol.75 , pp. 11-20 (2006).
[56] V. Schulz Gathen "Atmospheric Pressure Glow Discharges for Surface Treatment: Selected examples" XXVIIth ICPIG, Eindhoven, the Netherlandes , pp.1-2, July 18-22 (2005).
[57] D. Korzec, E.G. Finantu-Dinu, A. Schwabedissen, J. gemann, J. Ra´hel, M. Sˇ tefecka, Y. Imahori, and M. Kando "Insulated surface discharge for metastables driven processing at atmospheric pressure" Surface and Coatings Technology, pp. 169 –170 (2003).
References
[58] Fuhliang Wen, Jhenyuan Lin Hungjiun and Kuo-Hwa Chang "Pulsed Atmospheric Pressure Plasma System Applied to PCBs Surface Treatment" The 3rd International Multi-Conference on, Engineering and Technological Innovation (IMETI), –Orlando, Florida, USA, June 29th - July 2nd (2010).
[59] Psarkar, S. Chaturvedi, Raj Kumar, Rajesh Kumar, D. Lathi, ,Ashyam and J. Sonara "Operation of a capacitor bank for plasma metal forming" Pramana J. of physics, Vol. 55, No. 5, pp. 941-945 (2000).
[60] Ananth N. Bhoj and Mark J. Kusshner "Repetitively pulsed atmospheric pressure discharge treatment of rough polymer surfaces: II. Treatment of micro-beads in He/ NH3 /H2Oand He/ O2 / H2O mixtures" Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. Vol.17, pp. 1-15 (2008).
[61] Bart Roodenburg, , Johan Morren, H.E. Berg, and Sjoerd W.H. de Haan "Metal release in a stainless steel Pulsed Electric Field (PEF) system Part I. Effect of different pulse shapes; theory and experimental method" Innovative Food Science and Emerging Technologies Vol. 6 , pp. 327– 336 (2005).
[62] A. Goldman and R. S. Sigmond "Post- Discharge Phenomena on Surfaces" PISP- 7Eindhoven, Vol.2, pp. 454-459 , July (1985).
[63] H.A. Davis, B.P. Wood, C.P. Munson , L.J. Bitteker , D. M. Cotes, and H. M. Schleinitz "Ion beam and plasma technology development for surface modification at Los Alamos National Laboratory" Materials Chemeistry and Phyisics, Vol. 54 , pp. 213-218 (1998) .
[64] Mruthunjaya Uddi, Naibo Jiang, Evgeny Mintusov, Igor V. Adamovich and Walter R. Lempert "Atomic oxygen measurements in air and air/fuel nanosecond pulse discharges by two photon laser induced fluorescence" Proceedings of the Combustion Institute , Vol.32, pp. 929-936 (2009).
[65] D.L. Carroll, J.T. Verdeyen, D.M. King, J.W. Zimmerman, J.K. Laystrom, B.S. Woodard, G.F. Benavides, K. Kittell, D.S. Stafford, M.J. Kushner, and W.C. Solomon "Continuous-Wave Laser Oscillation on the 1315 nm Transition of Atomic Iodine pumped by O2(a1Δg) Produced in an Electric Discharge" Appl. Phys. Lett., Vol. 86, 111104 (2005).
[66] A. Hicks, Yu. G. Utkin, W. R. Lempert, J. W. Rich, and I. V. Adamovicha "Continuous wave operation of a non-self-sustained electric discharge pumped oxygen-iodine laser" Applied Physics Letters, Vol. 89, 241131 (2006) .
References
[67] K. Hirayama, D. Wang, M.Matsuda , X. Lin , T. Namihira, H.Takano , S. Takio and H. Akiyama "Activation of Retrotransposon in Red Alga by Underwater Pulsed Discharge" Acta Physica Polonica A , Vol. 115, No. 6, pp. 1110-1111 (2009).
[68] C.P. Lungu, A.M.Lungu, P. Chiru, O. Pompilian , N.Georgescu, M.Maguranu, and V. Predica "Treatment of Levigated Materials and Saturated Waters" Rom. Journ Phhs., Bucharest, Vol. 54, No. 3, pp. 369- 375 (2009).
[69] Philip Grigorievich Rutberg, Victor Andreevich Kolikov, Vladimir Efimovich Kurochkin, Ludmila Konstantinovna Panina, and Alexander Philipovich Rutberg "Electric Discharges and the Prolonged Microbial Resistance of Water" IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, Vol. 35, No. 4, pp. 1111-1118 (2007).
[70] S Mededovic and B R Locke "Primary chemical reactions in pulsed electrical discharge channels in water" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. Vol. 40, pp. 7734–7746, (2007).
[71] P.D.Starchyk, P.V. Porytskyy "On the Optical Properties of the Nonideal Plasma of Electrical Pulse Discharge in Water" Problem of Atomic Science and Technology, Series Plasma Physics, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 182-184 (2007).
[72] S. Gershman, O. Mozgina, A. Belkind, K. Becker, and E. Kunhardt "Pulsed Electrical Discharge in Bubbled Water " Contrib. Plasma Phys. Vol. 47, No. 1, pp.19 – 25 (2007).
[73] Bin Yang, Le Cheng Lei and Ming Hua Zhou "Effects of the Liquid Conductivity on Pulsed High Voltage Discharge Modes in Water" Chinese Chemical Letters, Vol. 15, No.10 pp. 1215- 1218 (2004).
[74] Muhammad Arif Malik1, Abdul Ghaffar and Salman Akbar Malik "Water purification by electrical discharges" Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. Vol. 10 , pp. 82–91 (2001) .
[75] P. Sunka, V.Babicky, M. Clupek, P. Lukes, M.Simek and B.R.Locke "Potential applications of Pulse electrical discharge in Water" XXVIIth ICPIG, Eindhoven , the Netherlands, 18-22, July, (2005).
[76] A. Pokryvailo, M. Wolf, Y.Yankelevich, E.Abramzon, and A. Welleman "Compact High- Power Pulsed Corona Source for Treatment of Pollutants in Heterogeneous Media" XXVIIth ICPIG, Eindhoven , the Netherlands, 18-22, July (2005).
References
[77] Richard A. Korzekwa, Louis A.Rosocha and Z. Falkenstein "Experimental Results comparing Pulsed Corona and for Pollution Control" Eleventh IEEE International Pulsed Power Conference, Balitimore, Maryland, June 29 July 2 (`1997).
[78] Shesha H. Jayaram "Pulse Power Applied to Process Industry and Environment" IEEE Industry Application magazine ,Vol. 6, Issue 4, pp. 34-40, July (2010 ).
[79] S.A. Nair, K. Yan, A.J.M. Pemen, G.J.J. Winands, F.M. van Gompel, H.E.M. van Leuken, E.J.M. van Heesch, K.J. Ptasinski and A.A.H. Drinkenburg "A high-temperature pulsed corona plasma system for fuel gas cleaning" J. of Electrostatics , Vol. 61 pp.117–127 (2004).
[80] Joel M. Goldberg and Kevin and P. Carney "Electrical characteristics of imploding thin film plasma atom cells" Spectrochimica Acta. . Vol. 45B. No. I0. pp. 1167- 1175. (1990).
[81] Mingmei Wang and Mark J. Kushner "High Energy Electron Fluxes in dc- Augmented Capacitively Coupled Plasmas. II. Effects on Twisting in High Aspect Ratio Etching of Dielectrics" Journal of Applied Physics, Vol. 107, 023309, (2010).
[82] Daniel Lundin , Ulf Helmersson , Scott Kirkpatrick, Suzanne Rohde and Nils Brenning "Anomalous Electron Transport in High Power Impulse Magnetron Sputtering" Plasma Sources Sci. Technol. ,Vol. 17, 025007 (2008).
[83] A. Belkind, A. Freeilich, J. Lopez, Z. Zhao and W. Zhu "Characterization of Pulsed dc Magnetron Sputtering Plasmas" New J. of Physics , Vol. 7, No 90, pp. 1-16, (2005).
[84] E. G.Grigoryev "Kinetics of Densification Processes of Powder Materials under Electro Pulse Sintering" The Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering Vol.34, No.1C, pp.29-33 (2009).
[85] J. B. Javedaniξ , D. A. Goerz, T. L. Houck, E.J. Lauer, R. D. Speer, L. K. Tully and G.E. Vogtlin "Understanding High Voltage Vacuum Insulators for Microsecond Pulses" IEEE International Pulsed Power Conference Albuquerque, NM, United States, June 17-22 (2007).
[86] F. Le Pimpec and R.Ganter "Field Emission Dark Current of Technical Metallic Electrodes" Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. Sect A, Vol. 574, p.22 (2006).
References
[87] A.N. Grigoriev1, A.V. Pavlenko, and E.I. Karnaukhov "Characteristics of Multi-channel Surface Discharge Switch for High Current Generator" 14th IEEE, International Pulsed Power Conference, Vol.2, pp. 313-315 (2003). [88] Biswajit Adhikary, Anurag Shyam "Development of 1MV Marx Generator" 10th International Conference on Modification of Materils with Particle Beams and Plasma, pp. 335- 337 (2010).
[89] M. Beg, M. Shabbir, M. Zakaullah and G. Murtaza "Pressure range broadening for a plasma focus operation" Physics Letters A , Vol. 186 , pp.335-338 (1994).
[90] A. Bernard, P. Cloth, H. Conrads, A. Coudeville, G. Gourlan , A. Jolas, Ch. Masisonnier and J. P. Rager "The Dense Plasma Focus A High Intensity Neutron Source" Nuclear Instruments and Methods , Vol. 145, pp.191-218 (1977).
[91] J.S. Brzosko, V. Nardi, J.R. Brzosko and D. Goldstein "Observation of plasma domains with fast ions and enhanced fusion in plasma-focus discharges" Physics Letters A, Vol. 192, pp.250-257, (1994).
[92] S.R. Mohanty, N.K. Neog, R.S. Rawatb, P. Leeb, B.B. Nayak and B.S. Acharya "Self-organized transformation to polyaniline nanowires by pulsed energetic electron irradiation in a plasma focus device" Physics Letters A, Vol. 373, pp.1962–1966 (2009).
[93] M. Habibi, R. Amrollahi, and M. Farrahi "Study of Dence Plasma Surface Interaction by a Filippov Type Plasma Focus Device" Brazilian Journal of Physics Vol. 38, No.2, pp.264-267(2008).
[94] Lekha Nath Mishra , Kanetoshi Shibata , Hiroaki Ito, Noboru Yugami and Yasushi Nishida "Conversion of Methane to Hydrogen via Pulsed Corona Discharge" Journal of Natural Gas Chemistry, Vol. 13, pp. 82-86 (2004) .
[95] Mishra Leka Nath, Shibata Kanetoshi, Ito Hiroaki , Yugami Noboru and Nishida Yashushi "Characteristics of Methane Destruction Using a Pulsed Corona Discharge at Atmospheric Pressure" J. Plasma Fusion Res. Series, Vol. 6, pp.760- 763, (2004) .
[96] Bing Sun , Masayuki Sato and J S Clements "Use of a Pulsed High Voltage Discharge for Removal of Organic Compounds in Aqueous Solution" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys.Vol.32, pp. 1908-1915 (1999).
References
[97] Yoshiro Nakagawa and Hiroshi Kawauchi "Production of a Pulsed High-Density Electron Beam by Channel Spark Discharge" Electrical Engineering in Japan, Vol. 134, No. 4, pp.10 -18 (2001).
[98] W. H. Tuan , S. M. Liu, C.J. Ho, C.S. Lin, T. J. Yang, D. M. Zhang, Z. Y. Fu and J.K. Guo "Preparation of Al2 O3 – ZrO2- Ni Nano composite by Pulse Electric Current and Pressure less Sintering" Journal of the European Ceramic Society , Vol. 25 , pp. 3125- 3133 (2005).
[99] Yong Hwan Lee, Won Suk Jung, Yu Ri Choi. , Jong Seok Oh , Sung Duckjang , Y oon Gyuson, Moo Hyuncho, Won Namkung ,Dong Jun Koh ,Young Sun Mok and Jae Woo Chung "Application of Pulsed Corona Induced Plasma Chemical Process to an Industrial Incinerator" Environ. Sci. Technol., Vol. 37, pp. 2563-2567 (2003).
[100] T. V. Babu Rajendran , C.S. Lalshminarasimha and M.S. Naidu "Lightning and Switching impulse breakdown of rod – plane gaps in nitrogen and nitrogen/ Freon (CCl2F2) Mixtures" IEE Proc. Vol.130, Pt. A, No. 3, pp.134-139, (1983).
[101] J. Dams, P. Osmokovic and Schwab "Design of Low Jitter Spark Gaps For Impulse Switching Applications" Fifth Intentional Symposium on High Voltage Engineering, Braunschweig, Federal Republic of Germany ,pp.1-4, August 24-28 (1987).
[102] Z. Liu, A. J. M. Pemen, R. T. W. J. van Hoppe, G. J. J. Winands, E. J. M. van "An Efficient, Repetitive Nanosecond Pulsed Power Generator with Ten Synchronized Spark Gap Switches" IEEE Transactions on Dielectrics and Electrical Insulation Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 918-925(2009).
[103] Horacio Bruzzone, Hector Kelly and Cesar Moreno "The Effect of Transmission Lines and Switching Action on the Electrical Signals in a Powerful Capacitive Discharge" IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, Vol. 18, No.4, pp.689-694 (1990).
[104] V.D.Bochkov, D.V. Botchkov, V. M.Dyagilev, V.N.Kudinov, V.G.Ushicch V.A.Glouschenkov and R.Yu.Yusupov "High Power Pseudospark Switches for Pulsed Power" Proc International Power Modulator Conference, Hollywood, USA, June 30 - July 3 (2002).
[105] Peter Choi, Hernan Chuaqui, J. Luney, R. Reichle, A. J. Davies, and K. Mttag "Plasma Formation In a Pseudospark Discharge" IEEE Transactions On Plasma Science. Vol.17, No.5, pp. 770-774 (1989).
[106] V.D. Bochkov, D.V. Bochkov, V.M. Dyagilev and V.G. Ushich SN-series "Pseudospark Switches, Operating Completely without
References
Permanent Heating. New Prospects of Application in Pulsed Power" Acta Physica Polonica, A Vol. 115 No. 6, pp. 980-982 (2009).
[107] Zdenko Machala, Emmanuel Marode, Christophe O.Laux and Charles H. Kruger "DC Glow Discharges in Atmospheric Pressure Air" J. Adv. Oxid. Technol. Vol. 7, No.2, pp.133-137 (2004).
[108] Ananth N. Bhoj and Mark J.Kushner "Continuous processing of Polymers in Repetitively pulsed atmospheric pressure Discharges with Moving Surfaces and Gas Flow" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., Vol. 40 pp.6953- 6968 (2007).
[109] R. Sosa1, D. Grondona, A. M´arquez, G. Artana and H. Kelly "Electrical characteristics and influence of the air-gap size in a trielectrode plasma curtain at atmospheric pressure" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys., Vol. 42, 045205, pp.1-7 (2009).
[110] Shao Tao1, Long Kaihua1, Zhang Cheng, Yan Ping, Zhang Shichang and Pan Ruzheng "Experimental study on repetitive unipolar nanosecond-pulse dielectric barrier discharge in air at atmospheric pressure" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. Vol.41, 215203, pp.1-8 (2008).
[111] Yasin Khan, Akihito Oda, Shigemitsu Okabe, Junya Suehiro and Masanori "Wire Particle Motion Behavior and Breakdown Characteristics around Different Shaped Spacers Within Diverging Air Gap" IEEJ Trans. PE, Vol. 123, No.11, pp.1288-1295 (2003).
[112] Zdenko Machala , Christophe O. Laux, Xavier Duten , Denis M. Packan, Lan Yu and Charles H. Kruger "Scaled up Nonequilibrium Air Plasmas" American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics, (AIAA) , 874, pp.1-15, January 6-9 (2003).
[113] K. Criner1, A. Cessou, and P. Vervisch "A Comparative Study of the Stabilization of Propane Lifted Jet-Flames by Pulsed, AC and DC High-Voltage Discharges" Third European Combustion Meeting ECM (2007).
[114] Kefu Liu, Jiang Qiu, Houxiu Xiao, Qiong Hu, Shengguo Xia "An All-Solid-State Pulsed Power Generator for Non-Thermal Plasma Discharge Applications" 13th International Symposium on High Current Electronics, Tomsk, Russia, pp.157-160 (2004).
[115] S. Pancheshnyi, M. Nudnova, and A. Starikovskii "Development of a cathode-directed streamer discharge in air at different pressures: Experiment and comparison with direct numerical simulation" Physical Review, Vol. 71, 016407 (2005).
References
[116] I. V. Uimanov "Electric Field at a Cathode Microprotrusion Under Intense Field Emission" 13th International Symposium on High Current Electronics, Tomsk , Russia, pp. 63-65 (2004).
[117] Joshua Leckbee, Randy Curry, and Ken McDonald "An Advanced Model of A High Pressure Liquid Dielectric Switch For Directed Energy Applications" 14th IEEE, International Pulsed Power Conference, Vol.2, pp. 1389-1393 (2003).
[118] S.K. Lam, D.Lo, C.E.Zheng C.Shangguan, T.L.Yang and I.V.Kochetov "Parametric Study of Xe2
Dimer in High- Pressure Electrical Discharges" Appl. Phys. B Lasers and Optics, Vol. 75, Issue 6-7, pp. 723-730 (2002).
[119] Xiang Wei, Zhao Weijiang, Zeng Baoqing and Yang Zhonghai "Computer Simulation of Impedance Characteristics For Magnetically Insulated Diodes" Proceedings of the Second Asian Particle Accelerator Conference , Beijing, China, pp.173-175 (2001).
[120] M.P.Desjarlais "Impedance Characteristics of Applied- B Ion Diodes" Physical Review Letters, Vol.59, No.20, pp.2295-2298 (1987).
[121] Sven Bonisch, David Pommerenke and Wilifried Kalkner "Broadband Measurement of ESD Rise times to Distinguish between Different Discharge Mechanisms" J. of Electronics Vol. 56 pp.363-383 (2002).
[122] N. R. Pereira and A. Fisher "Slower Impedance Collapse with Hot Anode and Enhanced Emission Cathode" IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, Vol. 27, No. 4, pp.1169-1174 (1999).
[123] D.J .Johnson, P.L. Dreike, S.A. Slutz, R.J. Leeper , E.J. T.Burns, J.R. Freeman, T.A.Mehlhorn and J.P. Quintenz,n "Applied -B field Ion Diode Studies at 3.5 TW" J. Appl. Phys. Vol. 54, No.5, pp.2230-2241 (1983).
[124] Gabi D. Stancu, Mario Janda, Farah Kaddouri, Deanna A. Lacoste, and Christophe O. Laux "Time-Resolved CRDS Measurements of the N2 (A3Σu
+) Density Produced by Nanosecond Discharges in Atmospheric Pressure Nitrogen and Air" J. Phys. Chem. A, Vol. 114, pp. 201–208 (2010).
[125] Tsuyohito Ito, Kazunobu Kobayashi, Uwe Czarnetzki and Satoshi Hamaguchi "Rapid formation of electric field profiles in repetitively pulsed high-voltage high-pressure nanosecond discharges" J. Phys. D: Appl. Phys. Vol.43, 062001 (2010).
References
[126] A. Dutta, I. Choi, M. Uddi, E. Mintusov, A. Erofeev, Z. Yin, W.R. Lempert, and I.V. Adamovich "Cavity Flow Ignition and Flameholding in Ethylene-Air by a Repetitively Pulsed Nanosecond Discharge" 47th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Orlando, FL.(AIAA), 0821, January 5-8 (2009).
[127] Munetake Nishihara, Naibo Jiang, J. William Rich, Walter R. Lempert, and Igor V. Adamovich, and S. Gogineni "Low-temperature supersonic boundary layer control using repetitively pulsed magnetohydrodynamic forcing" Physics of Fluids, Vol. 17, No. 10, 106102 (2005).
[128] David L. Carroll, Joseph T. VerdeyenDarren M. King, Joseph W. Zimmerman, Julia K. Laystrom, Brian S. Woodard, Gabriel F. Benavides, and Wayne C. Solomon "Studies of CW Laser Oscillation on the 1315-nm Transition of Atomic Iodine Pumped by O2Produced in an Electric Discharge" IEEE J. Quantum Electron., Vol. 41 , No. 10, pp.1309-1315 (2005).
[129] Ainan Bao, Yurii G. Utkin, Saurabh Keshav, and Igor V. Adamovich "Methanol and Ethanol Ignition by Repetitively Pulsed, Nanosecond Pulse Duration Plasma1" 45th Aerospace Sciences Meeting and Exhibit, Reno, NV, (AIAA), 1387, January 8-11 (2006).
[130] E. Mintusov, M. Nishihara, N. Jiang, I. Choi, M. Uddi, A. Dutta, W.R. Lempert, and I.V. Adamovich "Nanosecond Pulse Burst Ignition of Ethylene and Acetylene by Uniform Low-Temperature Plasmas" 39 Plasma dynamics and Lasers Conference, Seattle, WA. (AIAA), 3899, June 23-26 (2008).
[131] M. Uddi1, N. Jiang2, I. V. Adamovich3, and W. R. Lempert4, "Nitric Oxide Density Measurements in Air and Air/Fuel Nanosecond Pulse Discharges by Laser Induced Fluorescence" 39 Plasma dynamics and Lasers Conference, Seattle, WA. (AIAA), 3884, June 23-26 (2008).
[132] S.Korenev, V. Efanov and I.Korenev "The Nanosecond Generators of Air Plasma" Pulsed Power Conference IEEE, pp. 860-863 (2005).
[133] Max Chung, and Erich Kunhardt "Novel Trigger Mechanism High-Power Switch: The Electrostatic Plasma Injection Switch" IEEE Transitions On Plasma Science, Vol. 34, No. 5, pp.1626-1639 (2006).
[134] F. E. Peterkin and P.F. Wisiiams "Physical mechanism of triggering in trigatron spark gaps" Appl. Phys. Lett. Vol.53, No.3, pp.182-184 (1988).
References
[135] M.Murano, H.Nishikawa, A.Kobayashi, T.Okazaki and S. Yamashita "Current Zero Measurement for Circuit Breaking Phenomena" IEEE Transactions on Power Apparatus and Systems, Vol.PAS-94, No.5, pp.1890-1900 (1975).
[136] I. M. Podqornyi "Topics in Plasma Diagnostics" (New York, London 1971).
[137] F.Piperno and G. Solaini "On Rogowski Coil as Quantitative Probe for Current Density Measurements in a Linear Pinch" IL Nuovo Cimento , Vol. 29 B, No. 1, pp. 239-245 (1975).
[138] Sanda Pleslic and Zeljko Andreic "Application of Rogowski coil in Fast Pulsed Current Measurements of capillary Discharge" Fizika A(Zagreb) Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 233-242 (2007).
[139] Jan Hlavacek, Radek Prochazka Karel Draxler and Vladislav Kvasnicka "The Rogowski Coil Design Software" 16th IMEKO TC4 Symposium Exploring New Frontiers of Instrumentation and Methods for Electrical and Electronic Measurements, Florence, Italy, pp.22-26, Sept. (2008).
[140] Donald G. Pellinen, Marco S. , Di Capua, Stephen E. Sampayan, Harold Geribracht and Ming Wang "Rogowski coil for Measuring Fast, High Level Pulsed Current" Rev. Sci. Instrum, Vol. 51, No. 11, pp. 1535-1540 (1980).
[141] D. A. Ward and J. La T. Exon "Using Rogowski Coils for Transient Current Measurements" Engineering Science and Education Journal, pp. 105-113, June (1993).
[142] G. Murtaza Hashmi and Matti Lehtonen "On-line PD Measuring System Modeling and Experimental Verification for Covered-Conductor Overhead Distribution Lines" Proceedings of the 15th Mediterranean Conference on Control and Automation, Athenes- Greece, T21-010, July 27-29 (2007).
[143] Richard H. Huddleston, and Stanley L. Leonard "Plasma Diagnostic Techniques" (Academic Press, Inc., New York, 1965).
[144] Rodney Alan Petr "Erosion Phenomena of Arcing Electrodes" M.Sc. Thesis, Texas Tech University (1980).
[145] Essam Nasser "Fundamentals of Gaseous Ionization and Plasma Electronics" (John Wiley, 1971).