abstract volume 7th swiss geoscience meeting
TRANSCRIPT
Abstract Volume7th Swiss Geoscience MeetingNeuchâtel, 20th – 21st November 2009
Table of contents
Organisation 3
Abstracts
0. Plenary Session 4
1. Water across (scientific) boundaries 10
2. Structural Geology, Tectonics and Geodynamics 58
3. Mineralogy-Petrology-Geochemistry 116
4. Open Cryosphere session 164
5. Meteorology and climatology 188
6. Darwin, Evolution and Palaeontology 198
7. Future horizons in marine and continental research drilling 214
8. Geoscience and Geoinformation – From data acquisition to modelling and visualisation 226
9. Water and land resources in developing countries: towards innovative management and governance 262
10. Processes and environments influenced by water – boundaries crossed and encountered in the Quaternary research + Biological, physical and chemical processes in soils 274
11. Decision oriented modelling of the geosphere 304
7th Swiss Geoscience Meeting, Neuchâtel 2009
http://geoscience-meeting.scnatweb.ch
2P
len
ary
Se
ssio
n Organisation
Host Institution
Centre of Hydrogeology of the University of Neuchâtel (Chyn)
Patronnage
Platform Geosciences, Swiss Academy of Sciences
Program Committee
Daniel Ariztegui Ronald Kozel
Peter Baumgartner Neil Mancktelow
Judit Becze-Deak Franziska Nyffenegger
Gilles Borel Nils Oesterling
Thomas Breu Adrian Pfiffner
Lionel Cavin Marcel Pfiffner
Pierre Dèzes Rolf Philipona
Hans-Rudolf Egli Frank Preusser
Charles Fierz Eric Reusser
Karl Föllmi Bruno Schädler
Alain Geiger Urs Schaltegger
Bernard Grobéty Manfred Thüring
Martin Hoelzle Helmut Weissert
Hans Hurni Urs Wiesmann
Adrian Jakob Adrian Wiget
Eduard Kissling Eric Zechner
Rainer Kündig François Zwahlen
Local Organizing Committee
François Zwahlen (President) Philippe Renard
Sabine Erb Mario Schirmer
Nico Goldscheider
3
Ple
na
ry S
ess
ion
Participating Societies and Organisations
Commission for Research Partnerships with Developping Countries (KFPE)
Commission of Oceanography and Limnology (COL)
International Geographical Union, Commission Geography and Public Policy (IGU)
International Union of Geological Sciences, Swiss Committee (IUGS)
Kommission der Schweizerischen Paläontologischen Abhandlungen (KSPA)
NCCR North-South
Open Source Geospatial Foundation (OSGeo)
Schweizerische Geotechnische Kommission (SGTK)
Swiss Academic Society for Environmental Research and Ecology (SAGUF)
Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation
Swiss Association of Geologists (CHGEOL)
Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology (EAWAG)
Swiss Geodetic Commission (SGC)
Swiss Geography Association (SGV)
Swiss Geological Society (SGG/SGS)
Swiss Geological Survey (swisstopo)
Swiss Geomorphological Society (SGGm/SSGm)
Swiss Geophysical Commission (SGPK)
Swiss Hydrological Commission (CHy)
Swiss Society for Hydrogeology SGH
Swiss Society for Hydrology and Limnology (SGHL / SSHL)
Swiss Meteorological Society (SGM)
Swiss National Science Foundation
Swiss Paleontological Society (SPG/SPS)
Swisspeace Foundation
Swiss Society for Quaternary Research (CH-QUAT)
Swiss Snow, Ice and Permafrost Society (SIP)
Swiss Society of Mineralogy Petrography (SMPG / SSMP)
�P
len
ary
Se
ssio
n Plenary Session, Friday November 20th
Water Across Boundaries
Espace Louis-Agassiz 1, Aula des Jeunes-Rives, Neuchâtel
14:00 - 14:15 François Zwahlen President SGM 2009
Opening address
14:15 - 14:45 Gordon Young President IAHS
Scientific understanding: essential for sound water resources management (Joint IUGG-CH & IUGS-CH Union Lecture)
14:45 - 15:15 Janet Hering EAWAG
Geochemical Perspectives on Water Quality
15:15 Coffee break
15:45 - 16:15 Steven Ingebritsen United States Geological Survey, USGS
The Role of Groundwater in Geologic Processes
16:15 - 16:45 Robert Cramer Conseil d’Etat de Genève
L’eau : élément fédérateur de la politique transfrontalière
16: 45 - 16:50 Musical Interlude
16:50 - 17:40 Helmut Weissert Bernard Grobéty Pierre Gander Christian Meyer Martin Hoelzle Gilles Borel Daniele Biaggi Christoph Heinrich
Communications Platform GeosciencesPresentation SGM 2010 in FribourgCommunication Erlebnis Geologie 2010Swiss Commission of Palaeontology PrizeSwiss Snow, Ice and Permafrost Society PrizeSwiss Geological Society AwardCHGEOL AwardPaul Niggli Medal
17:40 - 17:45 Musical Interlude
17:45 - 18:00 Nexans Award
18:00 - 18:05 Musical Interlude
18:05 - 19:30 Aperitif & Posters
20:00 Swiss Geoscience Party = “Cocktail Dînatoire” on a boat in the port of Neuchâtel (reservation required)
�
Ple
na
ry S
ess
ion0. Plenary Session
1 Hering J.: Geochemical Perspectives On Water Quality
2 Ingebritsen S.: The Role of Groundwater in Geologic Processes
3 Young G.: Scientific understanding: essential for sound water resources management
1
Geochemical Perspectives On Water Quality
Janet G. Hering
eawag, Überlandstrasse 133, Dübendorf, [email protected]
As a sustainable source of safe drinking water, groundwater has many advantages over surface water, most no-table its natural protection from the pathogens that are a leading cause of child mortality in developing coun-tries. As tragically illustrated in South and Southeast Asia, however, consumption of groundwater can also pose health risks due to exposure to geogenic contaminants. This presentation will examine the biogeochemical controls on groundwater quality, particularly the concentration of the geogenic contaminants arsenic and flu-oride. The occurrence and mobility of geogenic contaminants will be discussed in terms of the composition of geological source materials and the biogeochemical processes by which geogenic contaminants are mobilized and sequestered.
2
The Role of Groundwater in Geologic Processes
S.E. Ingebritsen
U.S. Geological Survey, Menlo Park, California, USA
Historically, interest in groundwater and other subsurface fluids was confined to a few specific disciplines in the earth sciences, notably groundwater hydrology, soil physics, engineering geology, petroleum geology, and petroleum engineering. These disciplines tended to be “applied” in nature, with practitioners concentrating on the immediate and practical problems of water supply, water quality, mine dewatering, deformation under structural loads, and the location and recovery of fluid hydrocarbons. This situation has changed over the past few decades. Hydrogeologists and geologists are now actively exploring the role of groundwater and other sub-surface fluids in such fundamental geologic processes as crustal heat transfer, ore deposition, hydrocarbon migration, earthquakes, tectonic deformation, diagenesis, and metamorphism. This talk will emphasize (1) the links between groundwater processes and deformation, seismicity, and permeability and (2) recent advances in understanding of fluid flow and heat transfer at the mid-ocean ridge.
�P
len
ary
Se
ssio
n 3
Scientific understanding: essential for sound water resources management
Gordon Young
President, International Association of Hydrological Sciences
The presentation looks at water from the perspectives of the freshwater hydrologist and the manager of water resources and examines the theme of the meeting – “Water across boundaries” – from a number of different view points.
Hydrological sciences are placed within the broader context of earth sciences and various “boundaries” are considered:
• between hydrology and atmospheric and ocean sciences;• between hydrology and the biological sciences;• between hydrology and volcanic activity.
Within hydrology various “boundaries” are considered:
• between the various phases of water – solid, liquid and gaseous;• between surface waters, soil moisture and groundwaters.
The interactions between hydrology and human activities are then considered both from the impact of humans on the hydrological cycle through changes in land surface characteristics, through the impact of dams and di-versions and through the introduction of pollutants from a variety of sources into the hydrological system.
Water managers must be concerned with a number of human needs for water which must always be balanced by consideration of impacts on the natural environment. They must bridge the divides between hydrological knowledge and understanding and the need to manage wisely for the betterment of the human condition and must learn to use hydrological knowledge to better inform their management decisions. They must also think across the “boundaries” between the various uses and challenges of water:
• Water for the basic human needs of food security and health;• Water for social development;• Water for economic development – the need for water for energy and for industry;• Water security from floods and droughts and pollution spills;• Water for the essential maintenance of natural ecosystems.
Thus they need to consider the management of water challenges in an integrated fashion – this is the rationale for Integrated Water Resources Management; a mental challenge to cross sectoral boundaries.
The challenges for the water managers do not end here; water almost always flows across administrative boundaries whether these be at the very local level between neighbouring houses or settlements, or at provin-cial or state level (The Cantonal level in the case of Switzerland) or at international level. And the flow of water is not only on the surface of the land but also within aquifers at depth. Not only does water physically flow across administrative boundaries but there are divides between the bureaucracies at these various administra-tive levels – and those “boundaries” must also be crossed.
Lastly the water manager must bridge the divides between actions within the “water box”, ie the need to think holistically when considering the suite of water uses and challenges, and the positioning of water issues within the much broader framework of social and economic development. These last divides are perhaps the most dif-ficult navigate.
10Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1. Water across (scientific) boundaries
Eduard Hoehn, Adrian Jakob, Ronald Kozel, Urs Mäder, Bruno Schädler, Mario Schirmer
Swiss Hydrological Commission CHy, Swiss Society for Hydrogeology SGH, Swiss Society for Hydrology and Limnology SGHL, Rock-Water Interaction Group, Uni Bern, Eawag Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology
1.1 AlaouiA.,WeingartnerR.:Caractérisationhydrodynamiquedesprincipauxtypesdesol
1.2 Alt-EppingP.,WaberH.N.,DiamondL.W.:Insightsfromcoupledthermal-hydraulic-chemicalmodellingofgeochemi-calprocessesincarbonateandsilicate-dominatedreservoirswithindeepgeothermalsystems
1.3 BabicD.,JenniR.,ZwahlenF.:Transferofsolutesunderforestedwatersheds
1.4 BadouxV.,PerrochetP.:Well-headcapturezonesdelineationintransientflowconditions:theuseofequivalentstea-dy-stateapproximations
1.5 BonalumiM.,AnselmettiF.,KägiR.,MüllerB.,WüestA.:Particlesinreservoirwatersaffectedbypumpstorageopera-tions
1.6 ChèvreN.,GuignardC.,BaderH.P.,ScheideggerR.,RossiL.:Sustainablemanagementofurbanwater:substanceflowanalysisasatool
1.7 deHallerA.,TarantolaA.,MazurekM.,SpangenbergJ.:Calcite-celestiteveinsandrelatedpastfluidflowthroughtheMesozoicsedimentarycoveratOftringen,nearOlten
1.8 DiemS.,VogtT.,HoehnE.:SpatialcharacterizationofhydraulicconductivityoftheThurtal-aquiferatthetestsiteWiden
1.9 DominikJ.,VignatiD.A.L.:Metalpartitioninginaquaticsystems:frominterdisciplinaryresearchtoenvironmentalpractice.
1.10 DriesnerT.CoumouD.,WeisPh.:Howwaterpropertiescontrolthebehaviourofcontinentalandseafloorhydrother-malsystems
1.11 DucommunR.,ZwahlenF.:Tracertestsinurbanisedsites:atoolforabettercharacterisationofgroundwatervulne-rabilityinurbanareas
1.12 EwenT.,RindererM.,BosshardTh.,SeibertJ.:Aspectralanalysisofrainfall-runoffvariabilityforselectSwisscatch-ments
1.13 GermannP.:Gravity-drivenPoiseuille-flowinthelithosphere
1.14 GlenzD.,RenardPh.,PerrochetP.,AlcoleaA.,VogelA.:AsynthesisofavailabledatatoanalyzetheinteractionbetweentheRhôneRiveranditsalluvialaquifer
1.15 Gremaud V., Goldscheider N.: Impacts climatiques sur la recharge d’un système karstique englacé, Tsanfleuron-Sanetsch,Alpessuisses
1.16 GuédronS.,VignatiD.A.L.,DominikJ.:Partitioningoftotalmercuryandmethylmercurybetweencolloidsandtruesolutioninoverlyingandinterstitialwaters(LakeGeneva).
1.17 HindshawR.,ReynoldsB.,WiederholdJ.,KretzschmarR.,BourdonB.:TrendsinstreamwaterchemistryattheDammaglacier,Switzerland
1.18 HuggenbergerP.:Processesatandacross the interface: Lessons lerned fromrivergroundwater interactionsunderdifferenthydrologicconditions
1.19 HunkelerD.,AbeY.,AravenaR.,ParkerB.,CherryJ.:Thefateoforganiccontaminantsatthegroundwater-surfacewaterinterface
1.20 HuxolSt.,HoehnE.,SurbeckH.,KipferR.:Thoronasapossiblemarkertracingsurfacewater/groundwaterinterac-tion
1.21 ImfeldG.,NijenhuisI.,NikolauszM.,RichnowH.H.:Variabilityofinsitubiodegradationofchlorinatedethenesinaconstructedwetland(NexansAwardLaureate2009)
1.22 JaegerE.B.,LorenzR.,SeneviratneS.I.:Roleofland-atmosphereinteractionsforclimateextremesandtrends
1.23 JordanF.,PhiliponnaC.,HellerPh.:Swissrivers.ch–Onlineriverforecastprediction
1.24 KöplinN.,ViviroliD.,WeingartnerR.:TheinfluenceofclimatechangeonthewaterbalanceofmesoscalecatchmentsinSwitzerland
1.25 LaigreL.,Arnaud-FassettaG.,ReynardE.:PalaeoenvironmentalmappingoftheSwissRhoneriver
1.26 LüthiM.:Storageandreleaseofwaterandchemicalspeciesinglaciers
11
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
1.27 Marzocchi R., Pera S.: Groundwater and tunneling: implementation of a geochemicalmonitoringnetwork in thesouthernSwitzerland
1.28 MBockP.,LoizeauJ.-L.:Dynamicsofcolloidconcentrationsinasmallriverrelatedtohydrologicalconditionsandlanduse
1.29 MolnarP.,PeronaP.,BurlandoP.:Waterdisturbanceastheorganizerofriparianvegetation
1.30 NitscheM.,BadouxA.,TuriwskiJ.M.,RickenmannD.:CalculatingbedloadtransportratesinSwissmountainstreamsusingnewroughnessapproaches
1.31 NiwaN.,RossiL.,ChèvreN.:Pollutiondeseaux:lasantéest-elleunlevierpourmettreenplaceunegestionintégréeàl’echelledubasinversant?
1.32 PreisigG.,PerrochetP.:Effectivestressandfracturepermeabilityinregionalgroundwaterflow:numericalcompari-sonofanalyticalformulas
1.33 RickenmannD.:Debrisflows,landslides,andsedimenttransportinmountaincatchments
1.34 SchillE.,AbdelfettahY.,AltweggP.,BaillieuxP.:Characterisationofgeothermalreservoirsusing3Dgeologicalmodel-lingandgravity
1.35 SchneggP.-A.:FieldFluorometerforSimultaneousDetectionof3ColourlessTracers
1.36 SchwankM.,VölkschI.,MätzlerCh.,StähliM.:RecentResearchontheRemoteRetrievalofSoilMoisturefromSpacewithMicrowaveRadiometry
1.37 SinreichM.,v.LützenkirchenV.,MatousekF.,KozelR.:GroundwaterResourcesinSwitzerland
1.38 SteinmannM.,PourretO.:Theroleofthecolloidalpoolfortransportandfractionationoftherareearthelementsinstreamwater
1.39 TonollaM.:MicrobialcommunitiesinthesteepgradientsofthemeromicticlakeCadagno
1.40 VennemannT.,FontanaD.,PaychereS.,AmbadiangP.,PiffarerioR.,FavreL.:Dissolvedinorganiccarbonanditsstableisotopecompositionasatracerofgeo-,bio-,andanthropogenicsourcesofcarbon
1.41 VogtT.,SchneiderP.,SchirmerM.,CirpkaO.A.:High-resolutiontemperaturemeasurementsattheriver–groundwaterinterface:Quantificationofseepageratesusingfiber-opticDistributedTemperatureSensing
1.42 vonFumettiS.,GusichV.,NagelP.:Naturalsprings-thelivingpassagebetweengroundwaterandsurfacewater
1.43 WaberN.H.:Porewaterasanarchiveofthepalaeo-hydrogeologyduringtheHoloceneandPleistocene
1.44 Wanner Ch., Schenker F., Eggenberger U.: In-situ Remediation of Polluted Groundwater: A TransdisciplinaryApproach
1.45 WeisPh.,DriesnerTh.,CoumouD.,HeinrichCh.A.:Onthephysicalhydrologyofhydrothermalsystemsatmid-oceanridges
1.46 WüestA.,JarcL.,PascheN.,SchmidM:Onelake,twocountriesandalotofmethane-theconceptforaviableextrac-tionofanunusualresource
12Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.1
Caractérisation hydrodynamique des principaux types de sol
A.Alaoui&R.Weingartner
Groupe d’hydrologie, université de Berne, Hallerstrasse 12, 3012 Berne, Suisse([email protected])
Lacaractérisationhydrodynamiquedesprincipauxtypesdesolsuissesn’estpasencoreappréhendée.Elledépendnonseu-lementdutypedusoletdesespropriétésphysiquesmaissurtoutdesastructurefonctionnelle.L’aspecthydrodynamiquedusoln’estabordéqueparunanglethéoriqueounumérique.Danscetteperspective,nousavonsoeuvrépourmettreaupointuneméthoderobusteetfiablepourestimerquantitativementlefluxàtraverslazonenonsaturéeetdéfinirlerisqueliéautyped’écoulement(Alaouietal.,2003).Lebutdecetteétudeestlacaractérisationhydrodynamiquedesprincipauxtypesdesolàpotentielagricolepourl’estimationdufluxd’eautransitantversleseauxsouterrainespermettantdeprocéderàuneévaluationdeleurdegrédevulnérabili-té.Laméthodeutiliséedanscetteétudeest jugéerobustepourdeuxprincipalesraisons: i) lesmesuresdelateneuràpartirdesquelleslemodèleMACRO(Jarvis,1994)aétécalibrésonttrèsprécises(intervalledetempsdemesurevarieentre1et5minutes)ettrèsdenses(effectuéeslelongduprofiledusoltousles10cm)etii)lemodèleutiliséestbasésurlesprincipesphysiquesdusol.Decefait,lescalculsdesimulationsontfiablesetpeuventêtreextrapolésàd’autressolssimilaires(demêmetypeetmêmetexture).Lessolsétudiésprésententunrisquedepollutioncertainencasd’applicationdepesticidesouherbicidesquandilssonthumidesoutrèshumidescommec’estlecasdessolsbrunsetsolsbrunsacides.Lessolsbrunslessivéspeuventprésentercerisqueenétatsecethumide.Quantauxsolsàgley,ilsprésententunrisquedepollutionrelatifs’ilssontsecs.Lerisqueaugmenteavecl’humidité.Quandcessolssontsurdesnappesphréatiquesfluctuantes,leseauxsouterrainespeuventêtrecontaminéesparruissellementverslesrivièressilesolestenpenteouparpercolationverticaleversl’eaudelanappequiremonterapidementensurfacedanslecasd’uneplaine.Cesrésultatsmontrentengénéralquelessolsneprésententpasderisquemajeurquandilssonttrèssecs.Lecaséchéant,lespesticidesetherbicidespourraientêtreappliquéesdurantcespériodespourautantquecessolsnesubissentpasd’aversesdurantlesjoursquisuiventcetteapplication.Ilesturgentd’établirunecartepédologiqueauniveausuissequitiendracomptedutypedesol,desatextureetdurisquedepollutionqu’ilprésenteencasd’utilisationd’herbicidesoudepesticides.Cettecarteserviraauxpratiquantsdans lesdomainesdusoletdel’hydrologie.Laprésenteétudeestenfaiteàlabasedecettecartographieetdevras’étendreauxsolsagricolesdeculturedifférente.L’impactdelaculturesurlastructuredusoldevraitêtrealorsévalué
REFERENCESAlaoui,A,Germann,P, Jarvis,N,Acutis,M., 2003.Dual-porosity andKinematicWaveApproaches toassess thedegreeof
preferentialflowinanunsaturatedsoil.HydrolSciencesJ.48(3):455–472Jarvis,N.,1994.TheMACROmodelVersion3.1–Technicaldescriptionandsamplesimulations.ReportsandDissertations
no.19,DepartmentofSoilScience,SwedishUniversityofAgriculturalSciences,Uppsala,Sweden,51pp
1.2
Insights from coupled thermal-hydraulic-chemical modelling of geoche-mical processes in carbonate and silicate-dominated reservoirs within deep geothermal systems
Alt-EppingPeter,WaberH.Niklaus&Diamond,LarrynW.
Institute of Geological Sciences, Rock–Water Interaction Group, University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1-3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])
Weusecoupledthermal-hydraulic-chemicalmodelspatternedafter thegeothermalsystemsatBadBlumau,Austria,andBasel,Switzerlandtotrackthefateoffluidsthatoriginatefromacarbonateandasilicate-dominatedgeothermalreservoir,
13
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
srespectively, on theirpassage through thegeothermal system.Weusenumerical simulations to explore1) geochemicalconditionsintheundisturbedreservoir,2)chemicalandhydrological implicationsofreinjectingtheusedfluidintothereservoir,3)mineralscalingandtherateatwhichitoccursand4)boreholecorrosionandgeochemicalfingerprintsindica-tingincipientcorrosion.
Thecompositionofthefluidinthereservoirisbufferedbythemineralogyoftheaquiferrockatlocaltemperatureandpressure conditions. Changes in pressure and conductive temperature during ascent and descent of the fluid inducechangesinmineralsolubilities.Oversaturatedmineralsmaycausescalingwithintheborehole.Theprecipitationofmineralphasesintheboreholeisprimarilydictatedbythecompositionofthereservoirfluid.Thedistributionofmineralsisafunc-tionoftheflowandreactionrates.Mineralscalingwithintheboreholechangesthefluidcompositionandmaygraduallyclogtheborehole,therebyobstructingfluidflow.Becausedifferentmineralsexhibitdifferentsolubilitiesasafunctionoftemperature,themineralassemblagesthatprecipitateintheproductionwellaredistinctfromthoseintheinjectionwell.Forinstance,ifthefluidinthereservoirissaturatedinsilica,thentheprogradesolubilitybehaviourofsilicafavoursitsprecipitationintheproductionwell.Conversely,carbonatemineralstendtoprecipitateintheinjectionwellowingtotheirretrogradesolubilitybehaviour.However,calculatingthedistributionofmineralphasesiscomplicatedbythefactthattheprecipitationofsomemineralsiskineticallycontrolled,suchthattheymaycontinuetoprecipitatefarintotheinjectionwell(e.g.amorphoussilica)
Anymodificationofthefluidcompositioncausedbymineralprecipitationalongthefluid’spathwaymeansthattherein-jectedfluidisnolongerinequilibriumwiththereservoirrock.Consequently,rock-waterinteractionandfluidmixingatthebaseoftheinjectionwelldrivechemicalreactionsthatcausechangesinporosityandpermeabilityofthereservoirrock,potentiallycompromisingtheefficiencyofthegeothermalsystem.
Oneconcernduringgeothermal energyproduction is thatof chemical corrosionof theborehole casing. Fora rangeof"what-if" scenariosweexplore theeffectof corrosionon the fluidcompositionandonmineralprecipitation to identifychemicalfingerprintsthatcouldbeusedascorrosionindicators.Oncesuitableindicatorsareidentified,incipientcorrosioncouldbedetectedearlyonduringregularchemicalmonitoring.Corrosionofthecasingistypicallyassociatedwiththere-leaseofFeandH
2intothecirculatingfluid.However,theimplicationsofthisreleasedependonthelocalchemicalcondi-
tionswherecorrosionoccurs.Forinstance,elevatedH2inthefluidisacorrosionindicatoronlyifitisnotinvolvedinsub-
sequentredoxreactions.Similarly,lowH2concentrationsdonotruleoutpossiblecorrosion.
Ingeneral,theinterpretationofafluidoramineralsamplerequirestheunderstandingofchemicalprocessesthatoccuralongtheflowpaththroughoutthegeothermalsystem.Ifdirectobservationsarenotpossible,thenthisunderstandingcanonlybeachievedthroughnumericalsimulationsthatintegrateandcouplefluidflow,heattransportandchemicalreac-tionswithinone theoretical framework.Our simulationsdemonstrate that thesemodels areuseful forquantifying theimpactandminimizingtheriskthatchemicalreactionsmayhaveontheproductivityandsustainabilityofageothermalsystem.
1.3
Transfer of solutes under forested watersheds
BabićDomagoj*,JenniRobert**,ZwahlenFrançois*
*Centre of Hydrogeology and Geothermics (CHYN), Institute of Geology and Hydrogeology, University of Neuchâtel, Rue Emile-Argand 11, 2009 Neuchâtel, Switzerland**Bureau Nouvelle Forêt sàrl, Rte de la Fonderie 8c, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland
TheALPEAUprojectaimstostrengthentheprotectingroleofforestswhenitcomestosustainablewaterresourcemanage-mentandquality.Thus,severalforestedwatershedswerechosen.TheGorgesdel'AreusewatershedislocatedovertheSwissJuramountainskarstiksystem,whereastheJoratforestandtheMontGiblouxaresituatedontheSwissPlateau,mainlycharacterizedbysandstoneformations.
Themaingoalofthisstudyistoassessthefateofcontaminants,suchasnitratesandpesticides,ontheirwaydownfromtheforestsoil,whichphysico-chemicalfeaturesarestronglylinkedtophytosociologicalcombinations,throughtheunsatu-ratedandsaturatedzonedowntothesystemoutlet.
Inkarsticareas, it is importanttodiscriminatebetweenwatercomingfromthesoilreservoir, theepikarst (interfacebe-tweensoilandkarst),thelowpermeabilityvolumes(therockvolumebetweentheepikarstandthesystemoutlet)andthe
14Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es freshlyinfiltratedrainwater.Todoso,gasesproducedinthesoilanddissolvedinrainwaterwillbeused.Acombinedradon,
CO2andTDGP(totaldissolvedgaspressure)measurementswillbecarriedoutinawateradductiontunnelattheGorgesde
l'Areusetestsite.Conductivity,temperature,turbidity,DOC(dissolvedorganiccarbon),nitrogenandcarbonisotopiccompo-sitionanddissolvedionswillalsobepartofthesurvey(Figure1).Additionalartificialtracingexperimentswillallowtogetinsightintothetraveltime,thestoragelocationandthedegradationkineticofdissolvedcompounds.
EventhoughtheMontGiblouxtestsiteissetontopofasandyaquifer,thesamemethodwillbeapplied,iftraveltimesareprovedtobeunderaweek.Indeed,radondecayswithahalfliveofabout4days,whereasCO
2reactswithcarbonateonits
waydowntothesaturatedzone.
ThemainfocusontheJoratforesttestsiteistheenvironmentalfateofcypermethrin,asyntheticinsecticideusedintimbertreatment,oilproductsusedinforestmanagementandtheirmetabolites.Firstofall,itisessentialtounderstandthehydrogeologicalbehaviourofthewatershed.Thus,aclassicalphysico-chemicalfollow-upwillbeestablishedatsomechosenwaterharnessing,completedwithcomparativetracertests.Then,woodenpileswill be set on treatment sites, treated with cypermethrin (within the range of legal concentrations) and spring waterwatchedover.Theexperimentwilloccurunderartificialsteadystateconditionsandduringheavyrainevents,asitisas-sumedtocausesignificantinfiltrationintotheaquifer.
Figure1.SchematicviewoftheGorgesdel'Areusetestsite(modfiedafterSavoyL.2007)
REFERENCESPerrin, J. 2003:Aconceptualmodelof flowand transport inakarstaquiferbasedon spatialand temporal variationsof
naturaltracers,Phdthesis,UniversityofNeuchâtel,Switzerland,227pages.Savoy,L.2007:Useofnaturalandartificialreactivetracerstoinvestigatethetransferofsolutesinkarstsystems,Phdthesis,
UniversityofNeuchâtel,Switzeland,194pages.Surbeck,H.2003:RadonandCO
2asnaturaltracersinKarstSystems,proceedingsofICGG7(2003),33-33.
Subeck, H. 2005: Dissolved gases as natural tracers in karst hydrogeology; radon and beyond, proceedings ofMultidisciplinaryApproachtoKarstwaterProtectionstrategy,UnescoCourse,Budapest,Hungary.
15
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.4
Well-head capture zones delineation in transient flow conditions: the use of equivalent steady-state approximations
BadouxVincent*&PerrochetPierre**
*AF-Colenco Ltd. Täfernstrasse, 26, CH-5405 Baden ([email protected])**Centre of Hydrogeology and Geothermics, Rue Emile-Argand 11, CH-2000 Neuchâtel ([email protected])
Thedelineationofwell-headprotectionareasS1,S2andS3aswellascontributionzonesZuaimstopreventgroundwater
resourcesfrominstantaneousandperennialpollutions.Duetothestresstheyinduceonthelanduse,theseso-calledprotec-tionschemescausesocio-economicimpacts,thatbecomesnonnegligibleinhigh-densitypopulationarea,suchastheSwissPlateau.Thereforethedelineationofsuchprotectionschemesmustbedonewithcareinordertoguarantytheprotectionoftheresourceontheonehand,whileminimizingtheoverestimationoftheirsizeontheotherhand.
Aquifersarenaturalsystemsthatvarywithspaceandtime.Suchvariabilitywilldirectlyinfluencethewaycontaminantmigratesthroughtheaquiferandindirectlythedesignoftheprotectionschemes.Inpractice,characterizingtheresourcebyintegratingthisvariabilityrequiresmuchmoreeffortthanusingasimplehomogeneousmediumwithsteady-stateflowconditions.Consequentlythedelineationofprotectionschemesisoftendoneusinglowwatersteady-stateflowconditions,assumingthisconstitutesasaferapproach.However,byapplyingthissimplifiedmethodology, thesizeof theprotectionschemesisoverestimatedandtherelatedsocio-economicimpactsenhanced.
Anewmethodologyhasbeendevelopedtoidentifyflowconditionswheresteady-stateapproximationisjustifiedorwherethisapproximationshouldbeavoided(Badoux2007).Theratiobetweenthemeantransittimeandthefluctuationperiodappearstobeagoodcriteriontodistinguishbetweenthesetwocases.Whenthisratioissmallerthan0.5,thesizeoftheprotectionschemescanberigorouslyobtainedusinghighandlowwaterflowconditions.Whenthisratioisbigenough-theexactnumberissitespecific-theprotectionschemescanbeapproximatedbymeansteady-stateflowconditions.Inbetween,protectionschemescannotbeobtainedbyanysteady-stateflowconditions,exceptifsometransportparametersareadaptedinanappropriateway.
ThismethodologyhasbeenappliedtotheSeelandaquiferinCantonBern.
REFERENCESBadoux,V.2007.Analysedesprocessusadvectifs-dispersifsenmilieuxporeuxsouscontrainteshydrologiquespériodiques.
Implicationspourlaprotectiondescaptagesd’eauxsouterraines.PhDThesis,CHYN,Univ.Neuchâtel,293p.
1.5
Particles in reservoir waters affected by pump storage operations
BonalumiMatteo*,AnselmettiFlavio*,KägiRalf**,MüllerBeat***&WüestAlfred***
* Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Surface Waters – Research and Management, CH–8600 Dübendorf ([email protected])** Eawag, Urban Water Management, CH–8600 Dübendorf*** Eawag, Surface Waters – Research and Management, CH–6047 Kastanienbaum
Pumpedstoragehydroelectricityisusedtoevenoutthedailyandweeklyfluctuationsinenergyconsumptionbypumpingwatertoahigheraltitudereservoirduringlow-peakperiods,usingtheexcessbase-loadcapacityfromcoalandnuclearsour-ces.Thisprojectinvestigatestheeffectofthispumpstorageoperationsonparticlecharacteristicsinthewatercolumnandonresultingsedimentationprocesses.
Grimselsee(1908m)andOberaarsee(2303m),tworeservoirslocatedintheBerneseAlps,areconnectedsince1980byapumpstorageunitwhichexchangesanannualamountofwateramountingtoseveraltimesthevolumeofthereservoirs.Theim-pactofinitialdammingwasstudiedrecentlyfordownstreamareasandinthereservoirsthemselves.Thepartiallyglaciated
16Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es catchmentsfeedingthereservoirsleadtoanenormousinflowofinorganicparticlesduringsnowmeltinspring,resulting
inhighturbidityinthereservoirs.Comparedtopre-damconditions,reservoirsretainparticlesoflargergrainsizewhichwerepreviouslyreleasedtodownstreamareas (Anselmettietal.,2007). Inaddition,itwasdemonstratedthattheshiftofrunofffromsummertowinteraffectsthelightregimeand,consequently,theprimaryproductioninLakeBrienz(Fingeretal.2007;Jaunetal.2007).
Inordertounderstandtheeffectoftheincreasingpumpstorageoperationsonwaterturbidityandonparticlesize,watersamplingcampaignswereperformedseasonallyinbothreservoirsaswellasinthepowerstationconnectingthem.Turbidityseemstocorrelatestronglywithweatherconditionsandcatchmentcharacteristicsinsummerandwithpumpstorageacti-vityinwinter.Insummer,GrimselseewasfoundtobemoreturbidthanOberaarsee,whichhasastrongerthermalstratifi-cationandwhosecatchmentislessglaciated.Inwinter,GrimselseeandOberaarseeshowsimilarconditions.However,tur-biditywashigherclosetothein-/outlets,wherebothreservoirsarecontinuouslyexchangingwater.
Hydraulicmachinessuchasturbinescauseshearstressandturbulence,whichareknowntoinduceflocculationofparticles(Blaser&Boller,1998;Serraetal.,2008).InordertoinvestigatewhetherthiseffectoccursintheGrimselreservoirs,watersamplesweretakenupstreamanddownstreamoftheturbinesduringpumpstorageandpowerproductionregimes.Todate,SEMimageanalysesandparticle-counteranalysesdidnotdiscoveranyaggregationeffect,suggestingthatthethereisnotsignificantchangeinparticlecharacteristicsfromturbinepassages.
REFERENCESAnselmetti,F.S.,Bühler,R.,Finger,D.,Girardclos,A.,Lancini,A.,Rellstab,C.&Sturm,M.2007:EffectsofAlpinehydropower
damsonparticletransportandlacustrinesedimentation.AquaticSciences,69,179-198.Finger,D.,Bossard,P.,Schmid,M., Jaun,L.,Müller,B.,Steiner,D.,Schäffer,E.,Zeh,M.&Wüest,A.2007:Effectsofalpine
hydropoweroperationsonprimaryproductioninadownstreamlake.AquaticSciences,69,240-256.Jaun,L.,Finger,D.,Zeh,M.,Schurter,M.&Wüest,A.2007:Effectsofupstreamhydropoweroperationandoligotrophication
onthelight-regimeofaturbidperi-alpinelake.AquaticSciences,69,212-226.Boller,M.&Blaser,S.1998:Particlesunderstress.Wat.Sci.Tech.,37(10),9-29.Serra,T.,Colomer,J.&Logan,B.E.2008:Efficiencyofdifferentsheardevicesonflocculation.WaterResearch,42(4-5),1113-
1121
1.6
Sustainable management of urban water: substance flow analysis as a tool
ChèvreNathalie*,GuignardCécile*,BaderHans-Peter**,ScheideggerRuth**,&RossiLuca***.
* IMG - Faculté des Géosciences et de l’Environnement, Université de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])**Eawag, CH-8600 Dübendorf*** IIE-ECOL, ENAC, EPFL, CH-1015 Lausanne
Pollutantsreleasedbycitiesintowaterareofmoreandmoreconcernastheyaresuspectedofinducinglong-termeffectsonbothaquaticorganismsandhumans(forexample,hormonallyactivesubstances).Thesubstancesfoundintheurbanwatercyclehavedifferentsourcesintheurbanareaandadifferentfateinthecycle.Forexample,thepollutantsemittedfromtrafficgettosurfacewaterduringraineventsoftenwithoutanytreatment,andarepartiallyremovedfromthewatercyclebysedimentation;pharmaceuticalsresultingfromhumanmedicaltreatmentsgettosurfacewatermainlythroughwaste-water treatment plants,where they are partly taken out fromwater. The residual concentrations can re-enter the cyclethroughdrinkingwater.Itisthereforecrucialtostudythebehaviorofxenobioticsintheurbanwatercycleandtogetflexi-bletoolsforurbanwatermanagement.
The substance flowanalysis (SFA), an extensionof the classicalmaterial flowanalysis originally developedbyBaccini&Brunner,hasrecentlybeenproposedasinstrumentforphosphorousmanagementinurbanwatersystem.SFAisbasedontheprincipleofmassbalance:asubstanceentersaclosedsystemandmaybetransportedortransformedinthesystemandmayalsoleavethesystem.Tobeusedasmanagementtool,SFAshouldbecoupledwithenvironmentalqualitycriteria.Thesevaluesexpressthemaxi-mumconcentration,whichistolerableforagivensubstanceinordertoprotectbothhumanandtheenvironment.Havingthislimitinmind,onecandetectthemostproblematicflowsandtakeactiontodiminishthem.Inourstudy,wetestedtheapplicationofSFAforalargenumberofclassesofxenobiotics,i.e.heavymetals,pharmaceuticals,biocidesandcosmetics,toevaluateitsuseforurbanwatermanagement.WechosethecityofLausanneascasestudyasmanydatawereavailable,onboththesewersystemandthewaterquality.
17
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sThecityof Lausanne,which isaround42km2with130’000 inhabitants. Lausanne isnear lakeGenevaand its effluentsmainlyreachthisecosystem,whichisarecreationalareaaswellasasourceofdrinkingwaterforthecity.ThesystemitselfisdescribedinFigure1andillustratedforcopper.Weconsideredthirteeninputsofthisheavymetalinthewatersystem:drinkingwater(I
1),roofs(I
2)andhousessides(I
3)runoff,roadrunoffcollectingcarbrakes(I
4),tiresabrasion(I
5),motoroil
residues(I6)anddrydeposition(I
12),particlesfromcatenariesfromtrolleybuses(I
7),inputsthroughtrains,i.e.particlesfrom
catenaries(I8),brakes(I
9)andwheels(I
10)abrasion,inputthroughboats(I
11)andrainwater(I
13).Transfercoefficientswerees-
timatedbasedonmeasurementorhypotheses.Forcopper,thewaterqualitycriterionwasgivenbytheSwisslegislationandthesedimentqualitycriterionproposedelsewhere.
TheSFAofcoppershowedthatthecityofLausannereleasesabout600Kgand900Kgperyearofthisheavymetalinrespec-tivelythewaterandthesedimentsoflakeGeneva.TheseestimationswerevalidatedbymeasurementsofcopperintheLakenearLausanne.Inthesediments,thecontinuousenrichmentinduceshighconcentrationsofthisheavymetal,whichareabovetherecommendedqualitycriterion.ByusingtheSFA,wecouldidentifythatcoppermainlyreachestheLakewithstormwater,i.ewithoutbeingremovedbyanytreatment.Themajorsourcesarethecatenariesofthetrolleybusesandtheroofsrunoff.Areductionofthecontaminationofthewatersystemwouldthereforeincludeactionsatthislevel(forexamplethetreatmentoftheroofsrunoff).SFAwasalsoappliedtobiocidesandpharmaceuticalswithinterestingresults(notshownhere).
Figure1:DescriptionoftheurbaindrainagesystemofLausanneandapplicationtocopper.The“I”flowsstayfor“Input”.The“k”flows
forthetransfercoefficients.
REFERENCESBacciniP.,&BrunnerP.,1991:Metabolismoftheanthroposphere,Springer,Berlin,Germany.ChèvreN.,GuignardC.,RossiL.,PfeiferH.-R.,BaderH.-P.,andScheideggerR.Substance flowanalysisasa tool forurban
watermanagement:thecaseofcopperinLausanne,Switzerland,Submitted.MacDonaldD., Ingersoll C., and Berger T., 2000:Development and evaluation of consensus-based sediment quality
quidelinesforfreshwaterecosystems,ArchivesofEnvironmentalContaminationandToxicology,39,20-31.
1.7
Calcite-celestite veins and related past fluid flow through the Mesozoic sedimentary cover at Oftringen, near Olten
deHallerAntoine*,TarantolaAlexandre*,MazurekMartin*&SpangenbergJorge**
*RWI, Institute of Geological Sciences, University of Bern, Baltzerstr. 1-3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])**Institute of Mineralogy and Geochemistry, University of Lausanne, Building Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne
Thestudyisbasedoncoresamplesfromtherecentlydrilled,719mdeepboreholeatOftringen(nearOlten),locatedinthenorthwesternMolassebasin,at1.5kmfromthefrontalthrustoftheFoldedJura(Waber,2008).Veinsofcalcite(±celestite,pyrite)occurinthewholeMalmsequence(upto8veins/m),includingthemoreclay-richEffingenMember.Todate,suchanintensityofveiningintheEffingenMemberhasnotbeenfoundinotherdeepboreholeslocatedintheMolassebasin.Mostoftheveinsarerelatedtotectonicactivity,butclay-filledkarststructuresarerecognizedintheupperGeissbergMember
18Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es limestone,andafewstructuresprobablyrelatedtothediageneticprocessesaredocumentedintheEffingenMember.Fluid
inclusionsshowaveragesalinitiesbetween3.3and4.4wt%eq.NaClincelestiteand2.7wt%eq.NaClincalcite.Averageho-mogenizationtemperaturesincalcitefluctuatebetween56and68°C,withabroadincreasewithdepthandnocorrelationwithsalinity.
Malmwhole-rockcarbonateshaveδ18Ovaluesfluctuatingwithinanarrowrange,probablydeterminedbyequilibriumwithseawater(Fig.1A).Their87Sr/86Srratiosfollowawell-defineddepthprofilewithminimumvaluesinthemiddlepartoftheEffingenMember,fittingwithOxfordianseawater(McArthuretal.,2001;Fig.1B).Nocorrelationisobservedbetween87Sr/86Srandclaycontent,andvalueshigherthancontemporaryseawatermightberelatedtotheincorporationofradiogenicdetritalcarbonate.
Theδ18Ovaluesofveincalcitearesystematicallylowerthanthecorrespondingwholerockcarbonate (Fig.1A),consistentwithprecipitationfromseawaterat50-70°C.Theδ34Sandδ18OvaluesofveincelestitefollowabacterialreductiontrendpointingtoMioceneseawatersulfate.Twoveinpyritesgavenegativeδ34Svaluesconsistentwithbacterialsulfatereduction.Calciteandcelestiteofdiageneticoriginhave87Sr/86Srratiosthatareindistinguishablefromthecorrespondingwholerockcarbonatefraction.Incontrast,the87Sr/86Srratiosofepigeneticveincalciteandcelestiteshowasystematicenrichmentinradiogenic Sr compared to the correspondingwhole-rock carbonate and require an external Sr source.OnlyBurdigalianseawater,atthetimeofUpperMarineMolasse(OMM)deposition,hadan87Sr/86Srratiohighenoughtoexplainthehighestvalueobtained(Fig.1B).
TherocksoftheMalm-Doggersequencewerenotpervasivelyaffectedbyfluidspost-datingburialdiagenesis,andtheinflu-enceofsuchfluidswasrestrictedtoopenstructures.TheMolassebasinsubsidedintheBurdigalian(KuhlemannandKempf,2002;Mazureketal.,2006),andtheveinsmightrecordtectonicactivityrelatedtothisprocess.Calciteandcelestiteprecipi-tatedfromdescendingseawaterduetoheatingto50-70°C,whileprecipitationofpyriteresultedfrombacterialreductionofpartoftheseawatersulfate.
Figure1.Oxygenandstrontiumisotopicdata.
19
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sREFERENCESKuhlemann J.,&Kempf,O. 2002: Post-Eocene evolutionof theNorthAlpine ForelandBasin and its response toAlpine
tectonics.Sed.Geol.152,45-78.McArthur,J.M.,Howarth,R.J.,&Bailey,T.R.2001:Strontiumisotopestratigraphy:LOWESSVersion3:Bestfittothemarine
Sr-isotopecurve0-509Maandaccompanyinglook-uptableforderivingnumericalage.J.Geol.109,155-170.Mazurek,M.,Hurford,A.J.&Leu,W.2006:Unravellingthemulti-stageburialhistoryoftheSwissMolasseBasin:Integration
ofapatitefissiontrack,vitrinitereflectanceandbiomarkerisomerisationanalysis.BasinRes.18,27-50.Waber, N., ed. 2008: Borehole Oftringen:Mineralogy, Porosimetry, Geochemistry, PoreWater Chemistry. NAGRA
ArbeitsberichtNAB-08-18,Nagra,Wettingen,Switzerland.
1.8
Spatial characterization of hydraulic conductivity of the Thurtal-aquifer at the test site Widen
DiemSamuel,VogtTobias,HoehnEduard
Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Überlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Dübendorf ([email protected])
Formanyhydrogeologicalandmodelingproblemsonascaleoftheorderof10-100m,anassessmentofthespatialdistribu-tionofhydraulicconductivity(h.c.)isofgreatimportance.ThisisoneofthetasksoftheReCorDproject(RestoredCorridorDynamics)ofCCES(CompetenceCenterEnvironmentandSustainabilityoftheETHDomain).Thisprojectaimsatunderstan-ding,howriverrestorationmeasuresaffectriver-rivercorridor-groundwatersystemsinhydrologicandecologicterms.TheriverThurandthealluvialgravel-and-sandaquiferoftheperialpineThurvalleyfloodplainwerechosenforfieldinvestiga-tions.Inthisaquifer,thedistributionofh.c.attherequiredscalehasnotyetbeeninvestigated.Thus,theaimofthisMasterThesisistocharacterizethehydrogeologyoftheaquiferatatestsiteinthecentralpartofthevalley(Widen,Felben-Well-hausen/TG),whichextendstoabout10x20m(aquiferthickness,7m),byusingdifferentmethodsondifferentscales.Workincludedloggingofcoredrillings,sievingofthegravelsamples(decimeterscale)andtheconductionandanalysisofapum-pingtest(decameterscale),flowmeterlogsandslugtests(meterscale),withappropriatemethods.Exceptfortheslugtests(14wells),fourfullypenetratingwellswithpiezometersofadiameterof4.5”wereused.Theanalysisofthesetestsresultedinvaluesofh.c.
Thesieve analyses(verticalintervalsofsamples:0.5m)wereperformedwiththecorematerialofthefourwells.Thevaluesofh.c.calculatedafterCasati(1959)ledtosmallabsolutevaluesandanarrowdistribution(n=53,µ=-2.73m/s,σ2=0.01;whereµ=log
10geometricmean,σ2=log
10variance).ThesmallvariabilitycanbeexplainedbytheapproachoftheformulaofCasati
(1959), takingintoaccountfivegrainsizefractionsandassumingabsenceofthesecondaryporosityofthematerial.Thesmallabsolutevaluesoriginatefromthecalibrationoftheformulatoaspecificaquifer.Sieveanalysesarewellsuitedforaroughestimateofh.c.ofperialpinealluvialgravel-aquifers,withanaccuracyofafactorofabout2.Thepumping test(pumpingwellisoneofthefourwells,headobservationsinnineadditionalwells)involvesalargeaquifervolume.Asforallpumpingtests,theresultingvalueofh.c.(herecalculatedafterNeuman(1972,inKruseman&DeRidder1991)) isbiasedbyhighlyconductivezonesandcorrespondstotheupperlimitofthespectrumofthenaturalvariability(µ=-1.83m/s).Thisvalueisadequateforlargescaleinvestigations.Flowmetermeasurementswerecarriedoutatintervalsof0.25minthefour4.5”-piezometers.Asforallflowmetertests,ananalysiswiththemethodofJavandel&Witherspoon(1969,inMolz1989)resultedinverticalprofilesofrelativevaluesofh.c.Therelativevaluescanbecalibratedtoabsolutevalues:Heretheyarecalibratedrelativetothemeanh.c.ofthepumpingtest,whichintegratesalargeaquifervolume(totalofn=29,µ=-1.83m/s,σ2=0.14;calculatedforanaverageof0.5mintervals).Thebiasoftheresultofthepumpingtestisthustransferredtotheresultsoftheflowmetermeasurements.Therelativeprofileofh.c.shouldratherbecalibratedwiththeresultofteststhatinvolveonlyasmallaquifervolume,e.g.slugtestsinfullypenetratingwells,whicharehardtorealizeinahighlyconductiveaquifer.Soflowmeterlogsaretheadequatemethod,iftherelativeverticaldistributionofh.c.isofprimaryimportance.Slug tests.Fordetailedinformationaboutthespatialdistributionofh.c. intheorderof10-100m,whichisneededintheReCorDprojectforthemodelingofgroundwaterflow,soluteandheattransportatsmallscales,pneumaticmulti-levelslugtests(withasystemofdoublepackers)wereappliedin117intervalsof0.5mlengthof14piezometers(analyzedafterBouwerandRice1979,SpringerandGelhar1991,inButler1998).Theseexperimentsresultedinthefollowingdistributionofh.c.:n=117,µ=-2.38m/s,σ2=0.11.
Astatisticalevaluationofthevaluesofh.c.fromtheabovemethodsshowedthattheresultscannotbecompared.Thus,thechoiceofthemethodtoassessthedistributionofh.c.hastobedoneaccordingtotheproblemandtherequiredlevelof
20Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es detail.Theslugtestsresultedinthebestabsoluteandrelativerepresentationofthedistributionofh.c.,comparedtothe
otherthreemethods:Theabsolutevaluesofh.c.donothavetobecalibratedwiththeresultofadifferentmethod,thevaluesofh.c.areaccurateandcovermostofthenaturalrangeofh.c.AstatisticalcomparisonofsieveanalysesoftheWidentestsitewiththoseofthewholeThurvalleyhasshownthatthedistributionofd
10,d
50andd
60grainsizefractionsaresimilarin
thewesternpartofThurvalley.Probably,thedistributionofh.c.assessedfortheWidentestsitecanalsobeusedforthewesternpartofthevalley,asthissiteseemstobelongtothesamefacies.Todecreasetheworkloadrequiredforslugtestsandtoincreasethelevelofdetailinh.c.assessments,Irecommendacombinationofhydraulictestingwithhighresolutiongeophysicsandtheuseoftracers.ThedevelopmentofgeophysicalandtracermethodsareanintegralpartoftheReCorDproject.
REFERENCESButler,J.J.JR.1998:Thedesign,performance,andanalysisofslugtests.LewisPublishers.Casati,A.1959:DieDurchlässigkeitkiesigerBöden.MonatsbulletinSVGW6,120-126.Kruseman,G.P.&DeRidder,N.A.1991:Analysisandevaluationofpumpingtestdata.ILRIPublication47,SecondEdition.Molz,F.J.1989:Theimpellermeterformeasuringaquiferpermeabilityvariations:Evaluationandcomparisonwithother
tests.WaterResour.Res.25(7),1677-1683.
1.9
Metal partitioning in aquatic systems: from interdisciplinary research to environmental practice.
DominikJanusz*&VignatiDavideA.L.**
* Institut F.-A. Forel, Section de sciences de la Terre et d’environnement, Université de Genève, CP 416, 1290 Versoix – [email protected] ,** CNR-IRSA, Via del Mulino 19, 20047 Brugherio (MB), Italy – [email protected]
Knowledgeofpartitioningofmetalsisfundamentalforunderstandingtheirtransportandtheiravailabilitytoaquaticor-ganisms.Furthermore,aconsiderablefractionofmetalsinrivers,lakesandcoastaloceanmaybeofanthropogenicoriginwithconcentrationsapproachingthelevelsconsideredharmfulforaquaticecosystems.Measuringand,whenpossible,pre-dictingmetal partitioning therefore becomes essential for environmental risk assessment and associatedmanagementplans.
CurrentEuropeanandSwisslegislationsfixenvironmentalqualitystandards(EQSs)onmetalsforthefilterablephase;defi-nedasthemetalfractionpassingthroughtheporesofa0.45µmfilter.Alargefractionof“filterable”metalsisactuallyasso-ciatedwithsmall-sizecolloidsandthusisnottrulyinsolution.Unlikemetalsintruesolution,colloidalmetalscanberemo-ved fromthewatercolumnviacoagulationand/oraggregationandsedimentationprocesses.Moreover,metalsboundtocolloidsarenotavailabletosomeorganisms(e.g.,algae),butmightbeavailableforothers(e.g.,zooplankton).Thesediscre-panciesbetweenfundamentalknowledgeandcurrentenvironmentalpracticesraisetwomajorquestions:a)Isitpossible,anduseful,todeterminemetalpartitioninginmonitoringprograms?b)Howcantheknowledgeofmetalpartitioningbet-weencolloidalandtrulydissolvedphasesbeusedinenvironmentalassessment?
Thepublisheddataindicatethatmetalsoflowsolubilityinoxicconditions(e.g.,Cr(III),Fe,Mn,Ti,Pb)arepredominantlyassociatedwithcolloids,whilemetalspreferentiallyforminganioniccomplexesoccurmostlyintruesolution(e.g.,Cr(VI),Mo,U,V).Partitioningofelementsoccurringasdivalentcations(e.g.,Cu,Zn,Cd,Ni,Hg)dependslargelyonphysico-chemi-calconditionsofambientwaterandonthequantityandqualityofcolloids.
ForthepriorityelementsmentionedinEuropeanlegislation,theliteraturedataindicatethat,ingeneral,NiandCdhaveloweraffinityforcolloidsthanPbandHg(fig.1).Notehoweverthatapartoftheobservedvariabilityiscausedbypersistingtechnicallimitations;i.e.tangentialflowfiltration(themostwidelyusedtechniquetoseparatecolloidalandtrulydissolvedfraction inpartitioningstudies)notbeingstandardizedandprone toartifacts. In suchsituation,measurementofmetalpartitioningbetweencolloidsandtruesolutioninroutinemonitoringprogramsremainsunlikelyandprobablynotadvisa-ble.Nevertheless, inferring the percentage of truly dissolved fraction from the total filterable fractionhas proven to befeasibleforsomeelements(Vignatietal.2005).Suchinformationcanbeusedtorefinemodelsonelements’environmentalfateandalsoprovideamorerealisticevaluationoftoxicityatprimaryproducerlevel;whichishighlyrelevanttotheassess-mentofecologicalrisk.Indeed,algalbioassayscarriedoutinthepresenceoforganiccolloids,demonstrateddecreasingto-xicitywithincreasingfractionofmetalsboundtocolloids(Koukaletal.2003,2007).
21
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
Fig.1.Percentageoftoxicmetalsassociatedwiththecolloidalfractionaccordingtopublisheddatafromfreshwaterandestuarineorcoa-
stalsystems(compiledinVignatietal.2009).Barsrepresenttherangebetweenthemeansofthelowerandtheupperlimitsineachstudy.
REFERENCESKoukal,B.,Guéguen,C.,Pardos,M.&Dominik,J.2003:Influenceofhumicsubstancesonthetoxiceffectsofcadmiumand
zinctothegreenalgaPsedokirchneriellasubcapitata.Chemosphere,53,953–961.Koukal,B.,Rossé,P.,Reinhardt,A.,Ferrari,B.,Wilkinson,K.J.,Loizeau,J.-L.&Dominik,J.2007:EffectofPseudokirchneriella
subcapitata(Chlorophyceae)exudatesonmetaltoxicityandcolloidaggregation.WaterRes.,41,63-70.VignatiD.A.L.,CamussoM.&Dominik J.2005:Estimationof the trulydissolvedconcentrationsofCd,Cu,Ni,andZn in
contrastingaquaticenvironmentswithasimpleempiricalmodel.EcologicalModelling184,125–139.Vignati D.A.L., Valsecchi, S., Polesello, S., Patrolecco, L, & Dominik, J. 2009: Environmental realism andWFD
implementation: chemical and ecological relevance of particle-colloid-true solutionpartitioning of pollutants forsurfacewatermonitoring.TrendsinAnalyticalChemistry,28,159-169.
1.10
How water properties control the behaviour of continental and seafloor hydrothermal systems
DriesnerThomas*,CoumouDingeman**&WeisPhilipp*
*Institute of Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, ETH Zentrum, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])**Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Telegrafenberg A62, D-14412 Potsdam
Theflowpatternsandthermalevolutioninhydrothermalsystemsareofprimeinteresttoavarietyofbasicandappliedgeosciencedisciplinesrangingfrombiogeoscienceresearchonlifeinextremeenvironmentsthrougheconomicgeologytogeothermalenergyexploration.Duetotheextremetemperature-pressureconditionsaswellasthedifficultaccesstomanyofthesesystems(e.g.thoseatmid-oceanridges),insighthasmostlybeengainedfromnumericalsimulation.
22Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es Inthecaseofcontinentalhydrothermalsystemsheatedbymagmaticintrusions,numericalsimulationhasshownthatthe
system-scalepermeabilitystructureisaprimeordercontrolonhowmuchtheconvectinghydrothermalfluidmaybeheated.Thisisaresultofthedifferentrateswithwhichconvection(withthefluidflowrateprimarilybeingcontrolledbypermea-bility)transportsheatawayfromthesourceandconduction(intheessentiallyimpermeablehotmagmaticsource)deliversheattothefluid(Hayba&Ingebritsen,1997;Driesner&Geiger,2007).Ontheotherhand,fluidpropertiessuchasthepositionofthewaterboilingcurveintemperature-pressurespaceareamajorcontrolonthestyleofhydrothermalfluidflowintheupflowzone.
Formid-oceanridgehydrothermalsystems,recentdevelopmentsinnumericalsimulationtechniqueshaverevealedthatthetemperature-pressure-compositiondependenceoffluidpropertiessuchasviscosity,density,andheatcapacityisafirstordercontrolonhydrothermalsystembehaviour.Forexample,byheatingwaterfromambienttemperaturetoto200°C,viscositydropsbyoneorderofmagnitude.Thisincreasesthemobilityofwaterbythesameamountasaoneorderofmagnitudein-creaseinpermeability.Hence,hotwatercanessentially“byitself”createcorridorsofhighhydraulicconductivityinenviron-mentsofotherwisehomogenouspermeability.Asaresult,strongself-organizationeffectsmayoccur,theprimeexamplebeingtherecentpredictionofpipe-likehydrothermalplumesunderlying“blacksmoker”hydrothermalsystemsandbeingsurroundedbynarrowcylindricalzonesofintense,warmrecharge(Coumouetal.,2008).Currentresearchfocusesonthequestiontowhatdegreetheseeffectsinterferewiththoseresultingfromthepermeabilitystructureofthecrust(seeWeisetal.,thisvolume).
Figure1.Thermalstructureofthehydrothermalplumeunderlyingamid-oceanridgeblacksmokerfield.Ahotcentralupflowzonewith
temperaturesupto380°Cissurroundedbyanarrowrechargezonewithtemperaturesbetween100and200°C.FromCoumouetal.(2008)
Foroceanicsystemswithahomogenouspermeabilitydistribution,itcanbeshownthatthereisastronginterplayoffluidpropertiesandpermeabilitythatdeterminesthesystem’stemperatureaswellasitsabilitytoconvecttheincomingheat.Numericalsimulations,verifiedbysemi-analyticalcalculations,showthattypicalblacksmokertemperaturescanonlybeachievedwhenpermeabilityisLESSthanabout3x10-14m2.Athigherpermeabilities,thetemperaturesarelowersincefluidflowratesaretoofasttoallowstrongerheatingnearthemagmaticheatsource.Belowthispermeability,fluidpropertieslimitthemaximumtemperatureofthesystemtoca.400°C.Similarly,fortypicalheatflowratesatthebottomofthesystem,notallincomingheatcanbeconvectedaway,andmagmaeruptionstotheseafloormaypotentiallybetheonlywaytoba-lancethetotalheatinput.
Towhatdegreetheinfluenceoffluidpropertiesmayplayaroleintheformationoforedepositsorintheoperationofgeo-thermalsystemsissubjecttoongoingresearch.
REFERENCESCoumou,D.,Driesner,T.&Heinrich,C.A. (2008)The structureanddynamicsofmid-ocean ridgehydrothermal systems.
Science321,1825-1828Driesner,T.andGeiger,S. (2007)Numerical simulationofmultiphase fluid flow inhydrothermal systems. InFluid-Fluid
Interactions(A.LiebscherandC.A.Heinrich,eds.)ReviewsinMineralogyandGeochmistry65,pp.187-212Hayba,D.O., and Ingebritsen, S. E. (1997)Multiphase groundwater flownear coolingplutons. Journal ofGeophysical
Research102,12,235–12,252.
23
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.11
Tracer tests in urbanised sites: a tool for a better characterisation of groundwater vulnerability in urban areas
RomainDucommun*,FrançoisZwahlen*
*Centre d’Hydrogéologie et de Géothermie (CHYN), Université de Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2000 Neuchâtel, [email protected]
Vulnerability assessments and mapping methods (Vrba & Zaporozec 1994) are principally designed for natural areas.However,inurbanzones,thegroundwaterrechargeisstronglymodified,duemainlytosealingofsurfaceand/orpresenceofsubsurfacewatermainsandsewerpipes,whichcancontributetorecharge,orinverselyactasdrainsforwaterinsaturatedandunsaturatedzones(Lerner2002;Thomas&Tellam2006).Asrechargecanbeconsideredasakeyparameterforvulnera-bilityevaluation(e.g.,Aller,Bennettetal.1987),urbanprocesseswhichmodifygroundwaterrechargehavetobeincludedinanyvulnerabilityassessmentofgivenurbangroundwaterresources.Inthisperspective,multi-tracertestswerecarriedoutatlocalscaleintwourbantestsitesinSwitzerland:ColombierandNeuchâtel.TheColombiertestsiteislocatedinalowurbanisedarea,onquaternaryglacialsedimentsformingthePlateaudePlaneyse,whereasmallshallowaquiferispresentinthesiltyformations.TheNeuchâteltestsite,attheshoreofLakeNeuchâtel(Maladièrearea),islocatedinahighurbanisedarea,onhighlyheterogeneousanthropogenousbackfillmaterialand quaternary glacio-lacustrine sediments. The artificial conservative tracers (uranine, sulforhodamine B, duasyne andnaphtionate)wereinjectedinsealedandunsealedsurfaces,ordirectlyinsubsurfacerainwaterpipes.Inbothtestsites,tracerrecoverywasmonitoredinunderlyingurbanaquifers(wellsanddrainagecollectors),andinthedownstreampartofpipeswherethetracerinjectionswereperformed.TherecoveryresultsinColombierandNeuchâtel(exampleofbreakthroughcurveinfigure1)pointedoutdualroleofpipesonrecharge(increasingordecreasingrecharge),anincreaseinrechargeduetorunoffconcentrationattheboundariesofsealedsurfaces,andanincreaseinrechargeduetothepresenceofartificialbackfillmaterialsintheuppermostpartoftheunsaturatedzone.Notsurprisingly,increasedratesoftracerrecoveryduringwethydrologicalperiodswereobservedduringtheperformedtests.Effectsofthesevariousparametersonrechargewerefurtherinterpretedfromalocalurban-adaptedgroundwatervulnera-bilityperspective.Consequently,keyfactorslikethepresenceofundergroundpipes(inassociationwithpipeparameters:material,age,hydraulichead,etc),orthelocalmodificationsofhydraulicconductivityofsoil/subsoilformationsbyhumanactivity,havetobeintegratedinurbangroundwatervulnerabilityassessmentsandmappingmethods.
Figure1.BreakthroughcurveforsulforhodamineB(sulfoB)andtime-seriesforelectricalconductiity(EC),turbidity,dischar-ge,andwatertemperatureattheColombierdrainageoutlet(summer2007).Themajorrainfallevent(A)anditsnoticeablerelatedtracerresponseareindicated.
24Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es REFERENCES
Aller, Bennett, et al. 1987: DRASTIC: a standardized system for evaluating groundwater pollution potential usinghydrogeologicalsettings.U.S.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency(EPA),Ada,Oklahoma,USA.
Lerner2002:Identifyingandquantifyingurbanrecharge:areview.HydrogeologyJournal10(1):143.Thomas and Tellam 2006:Modelling of recharge and pollutant fluxes to urban groundwaters. Science of the Total
Environment360(1-3):158.Vrba and Zaporozec, Eds. 1994: Guidebook onMappingGroundwater Vulnerability. International Contributions to
Hydrogeology,vol.16.Hannover,HeinzHeiseGmbH.
1.12
A spectral analysis of rainfall-runoff variability for select Swiss catch-ments
TracyEwen*,**,MichaelRinderer*,ThomasBosshard**,andJanSeibert*
**Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Universitätstr. 16, 8092 Zurich. *Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstr. 190, 8057 Zurich, ([email protected])
Timeseriesanalysiscanprovideusefulinsightintothecomplexrelationshipsbetweenvariablesofinterest.Inparticular,analysisofprecipitationandrunoffforaparticularhydrologicalcatchmentallowsthephysicalcomplexityofthesystemtobebetterunderstood,bothspatiallyandtemporally.TheFouriertransformisoftenusedtoanalysethefrequencydomainoftimeseries,however,duetothenon-stationarityofclimatologicalandhydrologicalvariables,waveletshavebeenintro-duced to analyse the spectral properties over time by transforming a time series into two-dimensional time-frequencyspace.
Waveletshavebeenusedtounderstandthetemporalandspatialvariability incomplexhydrologicalsystemsthroughananalysisofrainfallandrunoff(fore.g.,Labatetal.,2000)andtocharacteriseremotewatershedsbasedonrunoffdataonly(Gaucherel,2002).Cross-waveletanalysisbetweenvariablesgivesfurtherinsightintothetemporalvariabilityoftherelation-ship (Grinstedetal.,2004)and insight intophysicalprocessesgoverning thesystem, inparticular, thebasinresponse torainfall,whichmayhelptoclassifycatchments.
Here,weusewaveletstoanalysedailyprecipitationandrunofftimeseriesfromtheRietholzbachandtheTösscatchmentsinSwitzerlandtobetterunderstandtemporalrelationships,withafocusonextremesduringthepast30years.Wefurtherinvestigatethespatialrelationshipbetweenprecipitationandrunoffandquantifytheprecipitationcontributionfromdif-ferentmeteorologicalstationstototalrunoffforeachcatchment.Wealsodiscusstheminimaltime-scalesneededtoade-quatelyrepresentthephysicalrelationshipsbetweenrainfallandrunoff(andhencetheclimatologicalsignal),whichcouldbeapplied,fore.g.,inordertoconstrainhydrologicalimpactstudies(Bosshardetal.,2009).
REFERENCESBosshard,T.Ewen,S.Kotlarski,andC.Schär,2009:Theannualcycleoftheclimatechangesignal-Animprovedmethodfor
useinimpactstudies,GeophysicalResearchAbstracts,Vol.11,EGU2009-7095.Gaucherel,C.,2002:Useofwavelettransformfortemporalcharacterizationofremotewatersheds,J.Hydrol.,269,101-121.Grinsted,A.,S.Jevrejeva,J.Moore,2004:Applicationofthecrosswavelettransformandwaveletcoherencetogeophysical
timeseries,NonlinearProc.Geophys.,11:561-566.Labat,D.,R.Ababou,A.Mangin,2000:Rainfall-runoffrelationsforkarsticsprings.PartI:convolutionandspectralanalysis,
J.Hydrol.,238,123-148.
25
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.13
Gravity-driven Poiseuille-flow in the lithosphere
PeterGermann
Institute of Geography, University of [email protected]
Hydro-mechanicalconceptsofflowinpermeablemedia(likefissuredrocks,karstformations,unconsolidatedsediments,andsoils)arebasedonlaminarflowthatisdrivenbysomeforce(i.e.,anycombinationofthegradientsofgravity,density,pressure, osmosis, capillarity, andotherpotentials), and that encounters resistance (usually expressed as its inverse likepermeability or conductivity). Typical lengthand time intervals areup tokilometres andmonths in fissured rocks andgroundwatersystems,tenstohundredsofmetersandweekstodaysinkarstformationsandhillslopesoils,tensofmetersandhourstodaysinunsaturatedandunconsolidatedsediments,andsinglemetersandminutestohoursinunsaturatedsoils.Dependingontheproblemandthesystemathandthedimensionalitymayvaryfromonetothree,andflowdirectionsmayreverseasinfiltration/capillaryriseinsoilsmayillustrate.Inaddition,theflow-drivingforcemayalter,forinstance,fromgravity-dominatedinfiltrationtocapillarity-dominatedriseofsoilmoistureandtopressure-dominatedflowwhenthemediumbecomeswatersaturated.Inviewofthemanygroupsofprofessionalsdealingwithvariouskindsofflowandtrans-portinvariouskindsofpermeablemedia,avarietyofconceptsandmethodshaveevolvedthatadaptedtotheneedsoftherespectivegroups.Group-specificadaptationsincludemethodsandprotocols,timeandlengthscales,systemboundaries,anddegreeofintensityindealingwithspatialvariability.Forinstance,capillarityinthenon-saturatedrootzoneofsoilsissodominantthatsoilhydrologistsandsoilphysicistsrelatewatercontents,hydraulicgradientsandhydraulicconductivitiestoit.Ontheotherside,thevadosezone(i.e.,thenon-saturatedzone)ofunconsolidatedsedimentsbetweensoilsandground-watertablesisusuallysortofhydraulicandhydrologicalno-man'sland,whereasresearchonwaterflowinkarstsystemsandgroundwatersystemsfollowtheirownrules.
Aconceptofinfiltrationwillbepresentedthatassumesgravityasdominantdrivingforcewhichisbalancedbyviscosity.Asetofequationsevolvesthatdescribestheconstantvelocitiesofwettinganddrainingfronts,andthatdealswithtrailingwaves.Theapproachislinearbutdiscontinuous;itdoesnotrequirearepresentativeelementaryvolumewhichisconsiderasobstacletotheup-scalingofmostmodels.Theapproachallowsforsuperimposingflowsintimeandspace.Flowfore-ca-sting iseasy,however,hind-casting is impossibleafter flowshave joined.Fromneutronradiographycomesexperimentalevidencethattheapproachappliestosandlayersthatarethinnerthan1mm:Fromsandtankexperimentsweknowthatitappliestolayersasthickas2m.Thepropagationofwettingfrontsacross20mofunconsolidatedsedimentsandacross2kmoffissuredgraniteindicatetheapplicabilityoftheapproachtolargersystems.Moreover,itexplainsconceptuallytheformationoffingerflowinunsaturatedporousmedia.
1.14
A synthesis of available data to analyze the interaction between the Rhône River and its alluvial aquifer
GlenzDamian*,RenardPhilippe*,PerrochetPierre*,AlcoleaAndrés*,AlexandreVogel**
*Université de Neuchâtel, Centre d’ Hydrogéologie, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2000 Neuchâtel ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected])** Etat du Valais - Service des routes et des cours d'eau, Projet Rhône, Av. de France 75, CH-1951 Sion ([email protected])
Beforethefirst(1863-1894)andsecond(1930-1960)Rhonecorrections,thefloodsproducedbytheRhoneRiverhadregularlydisastrouseffectsfortheinhabitants.Recentevents(1987,1993and2000)revealedmajordeficienciesinfloodprotection,whichconfirmedthenecessityofthethirdregulationprojectoftheRhône.Inadditiontofloodprotection,theprojectaimsatenhancingtheecologicalaspectsoftheriver(OFEFP/OFEG2003).
Thegeneralapproachfollowedistowidentheriverbedbyafactorofatleast1.6.Thisimpliesinsomesectionsaloweringofthewater level intheriver.AsthegroundwatertableoftheRhonealluvialaquifer ispartlycontrolledbytheexchangesbetweentheaquiferandtheRhone,thewideningoftheriverbedmayinfluencethealluvialaquifer.Thecorrectionwillalsomodifythegeomorphologyoftheriverbed.Thismayaffectthepermeabilityoftheriverbedandthushaveaneffectontheexchangebetween the river and thegroundwater. For example, a loweringof thegroundwater tablemight induce land
26Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es subsidenceorcausethedryingoutofagriculturalterrainsandinvolveenhancedirrigation.Ontheopposite,ariseofthe
groundwatertablemightleadtoariseofgroundwaterinbuildingsorbyswampformation.
Toforecaststhosepotentialimpacts,itisnecessarytocharacterizethepresentsituationandtoanalysethecurrentstateoftheexchangesbetweentheriverandtheaquifer.Inasecondstage,anumericalgroundwaterflowmodelwillbeusedtosimulatethemainobservationandtoinvestigatethepossibleeffectsofamodificationoftheriverbed.Thecharacterizationoftheaquiferandthedesignoftheconceptualaquifermodelisbasedonabroadrangeofsourcesin-formationsuchasseismicsurveys,boreholes,piezometricheadmeasurements,wateranalysis,hydraulictests,etc.Sofar,theanalysisofthesedatahaveshownsomeimportantaspects.
First,thecontinuousmeasurementsofpiezometricdatashowthatthewatertableofthealluvialaquiferishighlyinflu-encedbythewaterleveloftheRhôneriver.Moreprecisely,thepiezometricmapsshowthatinalargeportionoftheregion,theleveloftheRhôneishigherthanthepiezometry.Thisindicateseitherrechargeconditionsordisconnection.Theassump-tionofrechargeisinagreementwithnewmaps(e.g.Fig.1)ofthehydrochemicaldatathatwereinterpolatedforthisstudy.Thosemapsshowthatlowconcentrationsofthedifferentchemicalspeciesaremostoftenmeasurednearthelowmineral-izedRhôneRiver.
Inaddition,thecomparisonofthehydrochemicaldatawiththelithologyofthevalleyslopesindicatesplaceswithaground-waterinflowfromkarsticaquifers.
Finally,theimportanceofthedrainageditchesonthegroundwaterflowisrevealedbythemapsofthewaterchemistry.Onthosemaps,theditchesformclearlyrecognizablebarriersbetweentwotypesofwater(e.g.higherandlowermineralizedwaters,onbothsidesoftheCanalduSyndicat,Fig.1).
Figure1.Interpolatedmap(kriging)ofelectricalconductivityintheRhoneaquiferbetweenSierreandBranson(Data:Highwaterlevels
1985).
REFERENCESOFEFP/OFEG,2003.Coursd’eausuisses.Pourunepolitiquedegestiondurabledenoseaux.Berne,12pages
27
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.15
Impacts climatiques sur la recharge d'un système karstique englacé, Tsanfleuron-Sanetsch, Alpes suisses
GREMAUD Vivian*, GOLDSCHEIDER Nico*
*Centre d'hydrogéologie et de géothermie, Université de Neuchâtel, Rue Emile Argand 11, 2009 Neuchâtel, Suisse, [email protected], [email protected]
Les glaciers de haute montagne accumulent une grande quantité d'eau en hiver, contribuant ainsi à la recharge des eaux souterraines durant les saisons chaudes. Actuellement les glaciers alpins sont globalement en retrait et certains vont dispa-raître dans les 50 prochaines années sous les effets des changements climatiques. La région de Tsanfleuron-Sanetsch dans les Alpes de Suisse occidentale est un site expérimental idéal pour étudier les interactions glacier-aquifère. En effet un gla-cier au recul très rapide et présentant un risque de disparition prochaine surmonte un aquifère karstique drainé principa-lement par la source de Glarey et utilisée pour l'approvisionnement en eau potable. De larges surfaces de l'aquifère sont exposées aux précipitions et à la fonte des neiges entre le glacier et ce captage. Ainsi, entre le glacier de Tsanfleuron et sa moraine de 1855 (petit âge glaciaire) la surface du karst a été polie par l'écoulement glaciaire, alors que des lapiaz typiques sont présents sous le cordon morainique. Géologiquement la zone est formée de roches sédimentaires jurassiques à paléo-gènes, plissée selon un large anticlinal limité au sud par un étroit synclinal au niveau du captage de Glarey. Les relations entre stratigraphie, tectonique, processus de recharge et drainage souterrain de l'aquifère karstique a été étudié par de mul-tiples méthodes, en particulier des essais de traçage et certains paramètres physiques mesurés en continu. La géométrie et structure du glacier de Tsanfleuron ont été étudiées par plusieurs campagnes géophysiques (méthode radio magnétotellu-rique RMT). Le volume de glace a été estimé à 102 millions de m3, correspondant à ~93 millions de m3 d'eau liquide disponi-ble pour recharger l'aquifère karstique et le soumettant à une variabilité journalière et saisonnière. L'eau de fonte produite par le glacier influence la géométrie des courbes de restitution et, par conséquent, les flux et le transport dans l'aquifère. Basé sur les prévisions climatiques, un modèle de disponibilité saisonnière de l'eau a été établi. L'hiver et le printemps présenteront un surplus d'eau alors que des périodes de manque d'eau seront à craindre lors de longues périodes sèches en été et automne, l'eau glaciaire étant absente. De plus les précipitations seront plus fortes mais plus rares et la demande en eau plus importante, particulièrement pour l'irrigation.
1.16
Partitioning of total mercury and methylmercury between colloids and true solution in overlying and interstitial waters (Lake Geneva).
Stéphane GUEDRON*, Davide A.L. VIGNATI**, Janusz DOMINIK*.
* Institut F.-A. Forel, Section de sciences de la Terre et d’environnement, Université de Genève, CP 416, 1290 Versoix ([email protected])**CNR-IRSA, Via del Mulino 19, 20047 Brugherio (MB), Italy
Mercury is one of the priority metals on the list established by the EU legislation due to its bioaccumulation in the food chain (Morel et al., 1998). Mercury bioaccumulation and biomagnification (i.e., increasing concentrations across trophic le-vels) are mainly caused by the transformation of inorganic Hg into the organic form methylmercury (MeHg) (Fitzgerald and Lamborg, 2003). As it is the case for many other elements (Vignati et al., 2005), the partitioning of mercury and MeHg large-ly controls their bioavailability and transfer to the trophic chains. Furthermore, formation of MeHg is particularly active at the sediment water interface thus making the study of Hg and MeHg partitioning in interstitial waters a topic of utmost interest for Hg/MeHg biogeochemical cycles and the associated risk assessment. In this study, we used tangential flow filtration (TFF) to determine the partitioning of Hg and MeHg between operationally defined colloidal (0.45 µm – 3 kDa) and truly dissolved (< 3 kDa) fractions. Using ultraclean techniques (Cossa and Gobeil, 2000), blank values of 0.1–0.8 ng L-1 and < 0.01 ng L-1 were obtained for total Hg (HgT) and MeHg, respectively. We also adapted the TFF methodology to process volumes of 60 – 80 mL; corresponding to the amount of interstitial water (IW) re-covered from 4 cm of sediment after centrifugation and filtration.Sediment cores and overlying waters were collected at two sites with contrasting characteristics in Lake Geneva (Switzerland/France). Cores were sliced under nitrogen atmosphere to recover interstitial water. Interstitial water was filtered (0.45 µm) and then ultrafiltered. Total filterable Hg and MeHg concentrations were in the range 3.5–11 ng L-1 and 0.061–0.082 ng L-1, respectively. The percentage of Hg and MeHg associated with colloids were similar: 20–35% of total filterable concentrations.
28Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es To verify if truly dissolved concentrations of Hg/MeHg could be estimated from the more easily measured total filterable
concentrations, we combined our results with data available from literature. No significant correlation between filterable vs. truly dissolved concentrations were found for MMHg. On the other hand, significant Spearman correlations (R2 = 0.56; N = 30; p < 0.01 for freshwater data and R2 = 0.92; N = 23; p < 0.001 for oceanic water data) were obtained for total Hg. Our data superimposed rather well to the regression obtained for oceanic waters, rather than to the regression for freshwaters. We therefore surmise that the ligands controlling total Hg partitioning in IW are similar to those in oceanic coastal waters. The validity of this model should obviously be confirmed by future studies, but it opens an intriguing possibility to estimate Hg partitioning in IW and thus to refine the existing biogeochemical models.
REFERENCESCossa, D. and Gobeil, C., 2000. Mercury speciation in the Lower St. Lawrence estuary. Can. J. Fish. Aquat. Sci., 57: 138-147.Fitzgerald, W.F. and Lamborg, C.H., 2003. Geochemistry of mercury in the environment. In: B. Sherwood Lollar (Editor),
Treatise on Geochemistry. Elsevier, pp. 107-148.Morel, F.M.M., Kraepiel, A.M.L. and Amyot, M., 1998. The chemical cycle and bioaccumulation of mercury. Annual Reviews
Ecol.Syst., 29: 543-566.Vignati, D.A.L., Dworak, T., Ferrari, B., Koukal, B., Loizeau, J.L., Minouflet, M., Camusso, M.I., Polesello, S. and Dominik, J.,
2005. Assessment of the geochemical role of colloids and their impact on contaminant toxicity in freshwaters: An example from the Lambro-Po system (Italy). Environmental Science & Technology, 39(2): 489-497.
1.17
Trends in streamwater chemistry at the Damma glacier, Switzerland
Hindshaw Ruth*,**, Reynolds Ben*, Wiederhold Jan*,**, Kretzschmar Ruben** & Bourdon Bernard* *Institute of Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])**Insitute of Biogeochemisty and Pollutant Dynamics, Universitätsstrasse 16, CH-8092
The contribution of silicate weathering to global cationic denudation rates is not known precisely due to the difficulty of separating the weathering from silicate and carbonate minerals. Accurate quantification of in situ silicate mineral weathe-ring rates is required to constrain the carbon cycle. Small, mono-lithological catchments are ideal for elucidating the pro-cesses by which silicate rocks weather and how these processes change under varying seasonal conditions.
This work forms part of the multi-disciplinary BigLink Project which is investigating the 10.7 km2 granitic Damma catch-ment (Switzerland). The glacier has retreated rapidly, exposing fresh mineral surfaces allowing the initial stages of granite weathering to be studied. Stream waters were sampled for one year, with higher frequency sampling during the summer, in five different locations, in conjunction with high resolution hydrological and meteorological measurements. Selected isoto-pe ratios were analysed in addition to the overall chemical composition to characterise spatial and temporal variations in stream water chemistry.
After correction for atmospheric inputs, daily and seasonal cycles were clearly observed in the cation concentrations. The cyclic trends were independent of dilution and indicated the mixing of at least two distinct sources whose relative propor-tions changed over seasonal and daily timescales. In order to identify potential end-member sources, porewater and ground-water samples were also analysed. Our data show that these potential end-members are highly variable spatially and tempo-rally.
The different sources reflect differing water-rock interaction times as evinced by variable elemental ratios (e.g. Na/Ca) which were offset from bulk rock ratios. A groundwater contribution with Na/Ca ratios close to bulk rock values is dominant in winter. During increased surface discharge in summer, groundwater contributions are smaller and Na/Ca ratios are offset from those of bulk rock.
This study shows that even in a lithologically well-constrained watershed, large variations in cation flux occur over daily and seasonal timescales, primarily due to changing hydrological conditions. Thus, knowledge of the hydrology of a catchment is essential to quantify cyclic cationic denudation rates, and to estimate silicate weathering rates.
29
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.18
Processes at and across the interface: Lessons lerned from river ground-water interactions under different hydrologic conditions
PeterHuggenberger
Angewandte und Umweltgeologie, Dept. Umweltwissenschaften, Uni Basel. [email protected]
Canalizationofmanyriversinthe19thcenturystronglyinfluencedtheeconomicdevelopmentandurbanizationofmostEuropeancountries.Togetherwithtechnicaldevelopmentsinagriculture,aseriesofenvironmentalproblemssuchasfloo-ding,groundwaterpollutionandecologicalchanges,includingthedecreaseofcharacteristichabitatsofriverinelandscapes,werecreated.Mostoftherivervalleysareimportantgroundwaterreservoirs,inparticularincentralEurope.Thesereservoirsareoftenhighlyendangeredduetointenseagriculturalandindustrialactivitiesandadensenetworkofurbanareascon-nectedbynumeroustrafficlines.Additionally,thehighpermeabilityoffluvialsediments(esp.fluvialshapedaquifertypesofalpinetype),thefrequentlyobservedlackofathickprotectivecoverlayerandtheexchangeprocesseswithsurfacewatersresultinahighvulnerabilityofgroundwaterresources.Formulatedgoalsforasustainabledevelopmentofwaterresourcesguidemitigationstrategiesandconsiderdefinedstan-dards,i.e.naturalcompositionofsurfacewaters.Majoreffortsforfuturetransdisciplinaryresearch,withrespecttohydro-logicalregimes(lowandhighflow)orgroundwaterflowregimes,willconcentrateontheknowledgeofthestructuraldyna-micsoftheriverandrelatedgroundwatersystems.Toidentifyhydrologicalandhydrogeologicalsystemprofiles,methodo-logiestoquantifyandcontroltheseprofilesmustbedevelopedandapplied.Thiscanbeachievedbytheimplementationofmanagementsystemsthatincludeobservationsystemsandthedevelopmentofnumericalmodelscombinedwithspecificfieldexperimentsandscenariodevelopment.Theintegralofchangesinriverstructuresinthecatchment(i.e.lackofretentionspace)hasalreadydemonstratedseriousconsequencesduringmajorfloods.Duetotheexperiencegainedfromthehazardousfloodeventsinthelasttwentyyears,thepollutionproblemsandthelossofcharacteristicriverinelandscapes,mostcountrieshaveadoptedamorecomprehen-siveviewofrivers.Itisrecognizedthattheconsiderationofprocessesofriver-groundwaterinteractionsareimportant,whichsignificantlydifferfornaturalandchannelizedstates.Withinthiscontext,positiveandnegativeaspectsofriver-groundwater interactionforchannelizedandnon-channelizedsurfacewatersareinvestigated.Theinteractionofsurfaceandsubsurfacewatersissubjecttocontinuousdynamicsinvolvingwaterbudgets,waterqualityandflowpatterns.Whenconsideringquantitativehydrologicalaspectsofriver-groundwaterinteraction,thetransientcharacterofriverbedpermeabilityisanessentialfactor.Sedimenterosionaswellastransportanddepositionprocessesareinfluencedbyriversthatareabletoexerttheirnaturaldynamics.Asaconsequence,thevarianceoftheriverbedpermeabilityisincreasedtemporarily,influencinginfiltrationratesandgroundwatermixingratios,aswellasresidencetimesforgroundwaterfromdifferentprovenance.Tounderstandthedynamicsofriver-groundwaterinteraction,ourinvestigationsfocuson: (1)theevaluationoftransienthydraulic boundary conditions, including the transient character of riverbed permeability and (2) qualitative aspects ofsurfacewatersandgroundwater.Resultsfromexperimentsofselectedriver-reachesarepresented,including:(1)adequateobservationsystemsthatfacilitatethemeasurementofgroundwaterparametersatdifferentdepths,aswellasthedefinitionofsamplingstrategies,(2)non-destructivegeophysicalmethods(Georadar,Geoelectrics)withintheriverbedandtheriparianzone,aswellas(3)subsequenthighresolutiongroundwaterflowandtransportmodeling,includingscenariotechniques,modelcalibrationandsensitivityanalyses.Interactionprocessesarestudiedataregionalandalocalscale(e.g.UpperRhineGraben,individualcatchmentareas,river-reachesandcapturezonesofextractionwells).
30Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.19
The fate of organic contaminants at the groundwater-surface water interface
HunkelerDaniel*,AbeYumiko*,AravenaRamon**,ParkerBeth***&CherryJohn***
*Centre for Hydrogeology, University of Neuchâtel, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])**Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University of Waterloo, 200 University Avenue West, Waterloo ON N2L 3G1, Canada***School of Engineering, University of Guelph, Guelph ON N1G 2W1, Canada
Persistentgroundwatercontaminantswithlittletendencytosorbtothematrixoftentraveloverextendeddistancesinaqui-fersandcaneventuallyreachsurfacewaterbodiesorothergroundwaterdependentecosystems.Inthevicinityofsurfacewaterbodies,sedimentqualityandredoxconditionsfrequentlychangeandbiologicalactivityisenhancedcreatingaddi-tionalpossibilitiesforcontaminantretentionanddegradation.Towhatextentthesealteredconditionsaffectthecontami-nantfatestronglydependsongroundwaterflowpaths,whichareoftenhighlycomplexinvicinityofsurfacewaterbodies,andtheresidencetimeofgroundwaterinzoneswithgeochemicalconditionssuitableforcontaminantdegradationorreten-tion.
Inthepresentation,resultsfromtwofieldsitesarediscussedwhereatetrachloroethene(PCE)andatrichloroethene(TCE)plume,respectivelydischargestoastream.PCEandTCEarewellsuitedcompoundstoevaluatetheeffectofchanginggeo-chemicalconditionsonthecontaminantfatesincetheirdegradationishighlydependentontheredoxconditions.PCEandTCEdegradebyreductivedechlorinationundermoderatelyreducingconditions,whiletheirdegradationproductscis-1,2-dichloroethene (cDCE)andvinylchloride (VC) requirestronglyreducingconditions for furtherreductive transformation.Alternatively,cDCEandVCcanalsobeoxidizedtoCO2underaerobicandmoderatelyreducingconditions.Atthetwosites,contaminanttransformationwascharacterizedusinghighresolutionsamplingandanalysisofredoxsensitivespecies,dis-solvedcontaminants,stableisotoperatiosofcontaminantsandmicrobialparameters.
AtthePCEsite(Abeetal.,2009),thecontaminantplumetravelledthroughasandyaquiferunderconfinedconditionsanddischargedintothestreamthroughanapproximately2mthicklayerofsilty-clayeystreambedsedimentrichinorganicmat-ter(Figure1a).Whilenodegradationoccurredinthesandyaquifer,highlyvariabledegradationwasobservedinthestre-ambedsedimentsrelatedtosmallscaleheterogeneities.Thedegreeofdegradationreachedfromnodegradationinsandierzoneswhererapidgroundwaterdischargeoccurredtocompletereductivedechlorinationinclay-richzoneswherehighlyreducingconditionsprevailed.TheTCEsiteconsistedofanunconfinedsandyaquifer(Chapmanetal.,2007).Intheupgradi-entpartofthesite,groundwatertravelledatadepthofseveralmetersbelowgroundsurfacewhile inthedowngradientzone,thewatertablewasclosetothesurfaceandcontaminantspartlymigratedthroughorganiccarbonrichfloodplainsedimentswherereductivedechlorinationoccurred(Figure1b).However,theshallowwatertableconditionsfavoredground-waterdischargeintopondsandcreeks.Hence,whiletheaquifershowedasubstantialcapacityforcontaminantdegradation,mostofthecontaminantstraveledviathesesmallcreekstothemainstream.Thestudiesdemonstratethatinordertogaininsightintothecontaminantfateatgroundwater-surfacewaterinterfacesagoodunderstandingofthegeochemicalvariabilityandgroundwaterflowpathsisessential.Atbothsites,zoneswithfavor-ableconditionsforcontaminantdegradationoccurred.However,thesezoneswerepartlyby-passedandoverallonlypartialeliminationofthecontaminantsoccurred.Finally,thestudyalsoillustratestheneedforhighresolutionsamplingtode-velopaconsistentconceptualmodelofcontaminantmigrationanddegradationatgroundwater-surfacewaterinterfaces.
a) PCEsite
31
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sb) TCEsite
Figure1:Schematiccrosssectionofthefieldsiteswherecontaminantplumesdischargeintoastreamunderconfined(a)andunconfined
(b)conditions.
REFERENCESAbe,Y.,Aravena,R.,Parker,B.L.andHunkeler,D.,2009.Evaluatingthefateofchloriantedethenesinstreambedsediments
bycombiningstableisotope,geochemicalandmicrobialmethods.J.Contam.Hydrol.,107(1-2):10-21.Chapman,S.W.,Parker,B.L.,Cherry,J.A.,Aravena,R.andHunkeler,D.,2007.Groundwater-surfacewaterinteractionandits
roleonTCEgroundwaterplumeattenuation.J.Contam.Hydrol.,91:203-232.
1.20
Thoron as a possible marker tracing surface water / groundwater interaction
Huxol,Stephan1,Hoehn,Eduard1,Surbeck,Heinz2,Kipfer,Rolf1,3
21Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Water Science and Technology, CH-8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Nucfilm Ltd., CH-1792 Cordast, Switzerland3 Institute of Isotope Geology and Mineral Resources, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH) Zürich, Switzerland
Radon(222Rn,half-life3.6d)andthoron(220Rn,half-live55.6s)arethemostlonglivedisotopesofthenoblegasradon.Aspartofthetwonaturalradioactivedecayseriesof238Uand232Th,respectively,theyarereleasedfrommineralstofluids(e.g.soilgas,groundwater)byα-decayfromtheirprecursors 226Raand224Ra,respectively(emanationprocess).Bothradon-isotopescanbefoundinsoilgas.222Rnhasbeensubjecttoresearchforalongtimeandiswellknowntooccurinaquaticsystems,especiallyingroundwater.Itisoftenusedasatracerforassessingresidencetimesofsurfacewatersinfiltratingtogroundwater.Incontrast,studiesonthoroninaquaticsystemsarerare.However,thoronisexpectedtobefoundingroundwater,too,whereitcouldbeusedforanassessmentofmixing.Also,forassessingupwelling/downwellingprocessesintheriverbed,thoronisapotentiallypromisingtracer.
Uptonow,wedidnotfindanythoroningroundwater.Thisismostprobablyrelatedtothefastdecayofthoron,whichresultinarestrictedmobility,andthetime-consumingdetectionsystemtodeterminethoron.Furthermore,thegeophysicalandgeochemicalcharacteroftheradionuclidesofthe238Useriesisdifferentfromthatofthe232Thseriesand,therefore,theap-pearanceofradoninaquaticsystemsdoesnotnecessarilyreflecttheoccurrenceofthoron.
Inordertoconceptuallydescribethethoronemanationweformulatedthefollowingworkinghypothesis:Theprecursorsofradonandthoron(224,226,228Ra)areknowntobeslightlymoresolubleinanoxicthaningroundwater(inoxicwater,Raisonlyhardlysolubleandremainessentiallyinthesolidphase).Ifsuchanoxicgroundwatergetsintocontactwithoxygen,radiumtendstoco-precipitatewithMnandFeoxide/hydroxides.Asaresult,theemanationofthorontothewaterphasemaybeenhancedbyradium,whichisattachedtosurfacecoatingsoftheprecipitates.Inordertoenhancethesamplingprocedure,wemodulatedaconventionalsamplingsystem(RAD7,coupledwithcommercialdegassingunitRADAQUA)byinterconnect-inganadditionalclosedairloopwithadjustablediaphragmpumptodecreasetheresidencetimesofwaterandairbetweensamplingandmeasurement.
32Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es Primaryresultsconfirmthefeasibilityofthoronanalysisinoxygen-poorsprings,especiallyifironandmanganeseprecipi-
tatesarepresent.Gamma-spectroscopyofprecipitatesat thesprings’soutlet showedtherelativehighcontentof thoronprecursors and daughter products in the Fe andMn oxides/hydroxides.Moreover, α-spectrometric analysis showed thatthoronprecursorsanddaughtersareconcentratedonthesurfaceof theprecipitates,whichfurtheraddevidencetoourconceptualviewofthoronemanation.
1.21
Variability of in situ biodegradation of chlorinated ethenes in a constructed wetland
ImfeldGwenaël*,NijenhuisIvonne*,NikolauszMarcell**&RichnowHansH*
*Department of Isotope Biogeochemistry, Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research - UFZ, Permoserstr. 15, D-04318 Leipzig ([email protected])*Department of Environmental Biotechnology, Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research - UFZ, Permoserstr. 15, D-04318 Leipzig
Thespatialandtemporalbiogeochemicaldevelopmentofamodelwetlandsuppliedwithcis-andtrans-1,2-dichloroethenecontaminatedgroundwaterwascharacterizedover430daysbyhydrogeochemicalandcompound-specificisotopeanalyses(CSIA).Thehydrogeochemistrydramaticallychangedovertimefromoxictostronglyreducingconditionsasemphasizedbyincreasingconcentrationsofferrousiron,sulfide,andmethanesinceday225.δ13Cvaluesfortransandcis-DCEsubstantial-lychangedovertheflowpathandcorrelatedovertimewithDCEremoval.Thecarbonenrichmentfactorvalues(ε)retrievedfromthewetlandbecameprogressivelylargerovertheinvestigationperiod,rangingfrom-1.7±0.3‰to-32.6±2.2‰.ThisindicatedthatlessfractionatingDCEoxidationwasprogressivelyreplacedbyreductivedechlorination,associatedwithamorepronouncedisotopiceffectandfurtherconfirmedbythedetectionofvinylchlorideandethenesinceday250.ThisstudydemonstratesthelinkagebetweenhydrogeochemicalvariabilityandintrinsicdegradationprocessesandhighlightsthepotentialofCSIAtotracethetemporalandspatialchangesofthedominantdegradationmechanismofDCEinnaturalorengineeredsystems.
Inparallel,thedynamicsandcompositionofmicrobialcommunitiesintheaqueousphaseofthemodelwetlandwascha-racterized.PCR-DGGEanalysisofwater sampleobtained fromdifferentpartof thewetlandrevealed thatchangesof thebacterialcommunitystructurescoincidedwithasuccessionofthehydrogeochemicalconditionsinthewetland,fromoxictowardsanoxicconditions.Duringthistransitionphase,theappearanceofvinylchlorideandethenecorrelatedwiththepresence of putative dechlorinating bacteria (Dehalococcoides spp.,Geobacter spp. andDehalobacter spp.). Additionally,shiftofDCEisotopiccompositionindicatedtheprogressiveprevalenceofreductivedechlorinationinthewetland.AlthoughtheDCEdegradationprocessesvariedovertime,biodegradationactivitywasmaintainedinthewetlandsystem.16SrRNAgenelibrariesrevealedthatProteobacteriaaccountedfor>50%of16SrRNAgenesclonelibraries,whereas~17%ofthese-quencesfromthewetlandwererelatedtosulphatereducers.Basedonanmultiple-methodapproach,thisstudyillustratesthelinkagebetweenmicrobialcommunitydynamicsandcomposition,changesofhydrochemicalconditionsandprocessesofDCEdegradationinawetlandsystem.
1.22
Role of land-atmosphere interactions for climate extremes and trends
EricB.Jaeger*,RuthLorenz*&SoniaI.Seneviratne*
*Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])
ProcessesactingattheinterfacebetweenthelandsurfaceandtheatmospherehaveastrongimpactontheEuropeansum-merclimate,particularlyduringextremeyears.Theseprocessesare toa largeextentassociatedwithsoilmoisture.Thispresentationprovidesanoverviewonrecentanalysesinvestigatingtheroleofsoilmoisture-atmospherecouplingfortheEuropeansummerclimateovertheperiod1959-2006usingsimulationswitharegionalclimatemodel.
The setof experiments consistsof a control simulationwith interactive soilmoisture, and sensitivity experimentswithprescribedsoilmoisture.Soilmoisture-climateinteractionsarefoundtohavesignificanteffectsontemperatureextremes
33
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sintheexperiments,andimpactsonprecipitationextremesarealsoidentified.Casestudiesofselectedmajorsummerheatwavesrevealthattheintraseasonalandinterannualvariabilityofsoilmoistureaccountfor5–30%and10–40%ofthesimu-latedheatwaveanomaly, respectively. Inaddition, isalso found that soilmoisturehasa significanteffectonheatwavepersistencethroughsoilmoisturememory.Forextremeprecipitationeventsontheotherhand,onlythewetdayfrequencyisimpactedintheexperimentswithprescribedsoilmoisture.
Finally,trendsinclimateextremesincurrentclimate-changeprojections,suchasanincreaseintemperatureoverthewholeEuropeancontinent,aswellasaSouthernEuropeandecreaseandNorthernEuropeanincreaseinprecipitationextremes,canalreadybedetectedinsimulationsforthepastdecades,andappearatleastpartlylinkedtosoilmoisture-atmospherefeedbacks.
1.23
Swissrivers.ch – Online river forecast prediction
JordanFrédéric*,ClaudePhiliponna**,HellerPhilippe*
*e-dric.ch eau énergie environnement, Le Grand-chemin 73, CH-1066 EPALINGES ([email protected])**Camptocamp SA, PSE A, EPFL, CH-1015 LAUSANNE
Dischargepredictioninriverbasinshasbecomeapluridisciplinaryandhigh-technologytopic.Theneedsforsuchsystemsarerelatedtofloodmanagement,hydroelectricitymarketorleisureactivities.Inthiscontext,swissrivers.chhasbeendeve-lopedtoprovideeveryone,usinginternet,informationaboutthefuturedischargeinallthemainriversofSwitzerland.
Figure1.Thenewwebplatformwww.swissrivers.ch,withadirectgeographicalaccesstoriverdischargepredictions.
Thenewonlineplatformworksasfollows:numericalweatherpredictionsareprovidedbytheFederalOfficeforMeteorologyandClimatology(Meteoswiss),twiceadayandupto72hoursahead.TheirprecipitationandtemperaturepredictionsissuedfromtheCOSMO-7model(Schättler,Barbu,2008)witha6.6kmhorizontalgridmeshareusedforanextractoverthewholecountrytocalculatethepredicteddischargesinthesub-basinsandintherivers.Inordertooptimizethequalityofthepre-dicteddischarges,thehydrologicalmodelisupdated4timesaday:thecontinuoussimulationisautomaticallymodifiedbycomparisonbetweendischargemeasurementsandcomputeddischargesbasedonmeteorologicalobservationsoverthelast24hoursforeachoneofthe280automaticfederalgaugingstationsofSwitzerland(BAFU).Theobjectiveofthismodelupdateistoensurethatthemodelalwayssimulatesrealisticdischargesinrivers.
34Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es Theinformationprovidedbyswissrivers.chcanbefreelyaccessedfor2500sub-basinsand1500locationsintheswissrivers.
Foreveryselectedlocation,theupdatedsimulationofthelast24h,aswellasthedischargepredictionforthenext30hoursarepresentedasaplot.
ThesystemisbasedontheRS3.0technology,whichallowstheautomaticdataacquisitionandstorageinadatabase(weatheranddischargeobservations,numericalweatherforecasts),therainfall-runoffsimulationincludingsnowmelt,glaciermelt,evaporation, infiltration, surface runoff, river routing aswell as flow routing in hydraulic structures (reservoirs, powerplants,waterdiversions,etc…).RS3.0alsoallowsanautomaticpublicationoftheresultsinawebplatformorinaGIS.Thistechnology is based on previous developments realized for theMINERVE Project at the Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale deLausanne(Jordanetal.,2007,Garciaetal.,2008,Jordanetal.,2008).
Theperformanceofthesystemhasbeenoptimizedbyacalibration-validationprocedureusingmorethan15yearsofhour-lydata,over300controlpointsinSwitzerland.However,themodelcouldbeimprovedbyintegrationofnewhistoricalandreal-timecontrolpoints,inbasinslocatedupstreamoflargedamsandreservoirs.
REFERENCESGarcia, J., Jordan, F.,Dubois, J.&Boillat, J.-L. 2007: "RoutingSystem II,Modélisationd’écoulementsdansdes systèmes
hydrauliques",CommunicationLCHn°32,Ed.Prof.A.Schleiss,LausanneJordan, F. 2007: "Modèle de prévision et de gestion des crues - Optimisation des opérations des aménagements
hydroélectriquesàaccumulationpourlaréductiondesdébitsdecrue",Thèsededoctoratn°3711,EcolePolytechniqueFédéraledeLausanne.
Jordan,F.,GarciaHernandez,J.,Dubois,J.&Boillat,J.-L.2008:"MINERVE:ModélisationdesIntempériesdeNatureExtrêmeduRhôneValaisanetdeleursEffets",CommunicationLCHn°38,ed.A.Schleiss,EPFL,Lausanne
Martinerie, R. 2009: Numerical Modelling of Stormwater andWastewater Conveyance System of Lausanne City(Switzerland),Proc.,WaterEngineeringforaSustainableEnvironment,33rdIAHRCongress,Vancover,Canada
Schättler,U.,Barbu,C.2008:COSMO-NewsletterNo.9.pp.87.availablethrough:www.cosmo-model.org>Documentation>Newsletters.PrintedatDeutscherWetterdienst,OffenbachamMain,Germany
1.24
The influence of climate change on the water balance of mesoscale catchments in Switzerland
KöplinNina*,**,ViviroliDaniel*,**,WeingartnerRolf*,**
*Institute of Geography, University of Bern, Hallerstrasse 12, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])**Oeschger Centre for Climate Change Research, University of Bern, Zähringerstrasse 25, CH-3012 Bern
RecentresearchshowsthattheanticipatedclimatechangeinSwitzerlandwillresultinchangingprecipitationpatternsandincreasingtemperaturesduringthefirsthalfofthe21stcentury.Amongstothers,thetemperatureincreasewillcauseanupwardshiftofthesnowline,andprecipitationwillfallmoreoftenasrainthanassnow.Thecombinationofthesechangeswillprovokeachangeintherunoffregimesuchasanearlieryearlypeakflow.Whileevapotranspirationwillgenerallyin-creaseinafutureclimate,thechangesinprecipitationamountswilldifferseasonally,withincreasesinwinteranddecreasesinsummer(OcCC2007).Theyearlyvolumeofdischargeislikelytodecreasewiththeexceptionofalpinecatchmentswhereglacierswillfunctionasreservoirsduringthenextyears(Schädler2008).
Ourmaininterest lies inthequestionwhenandinparticularwherethesystemstartstippingoverandabovementionedchangesshowthroughinthehydrologicalresponseofcatchments.Thisissuewillbeaddressedintheframeworkofthejointresearchproject“ClimateChangeinSwitzerland–Hydrology”(CCHydro)whichwasinitiatedbytheFederalOfficefortheEnvironment(FOEN)andseekstoassesspossibleeffectsofclimatechangeonhydrologicalsystemsinSwitzerland.Thehete-rogeneityofcomplexmountainouslandscapes,however,forbidsgeneralstatements.Therefore,amultidisciplinaryandho-listicapproachwaschosenandthescenariosinuseareofhightemporalandspatialresolution.
Asafirststep,hydrologicalmodellingisusedtoidentifyandexaminecatchmentsthatexhibitsensitivitytowardsachangeinclimate.Forthis,weusetheprocess-orientedhydrologicalmodellingsystemPREVAH(Vivirolietal.2007).Themesoscalecatchmentsunderinvestigationhaveameanareaofabout150km2.Aftercalibrationofthecatchmentsforwhichmeasured
35
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sdischargerecordsareavailable,aregionalisationscheme(Viviroli2007)isusedtoarriveatacomprehensivesetofmodelparametersfortheentireareaofSwitzerland.Spatiallyandtemporallyhighlyresolvedscenariosoftheprojectedclimatechangeuntil2050willthenbeusedtoforcethemodel.ThescenarioswillbescaleddowntostationdatabytheInstituteforAtmosphericandClimateScience(IAC)atETHZurichusingtheDeltaApproach.
Asaresult,regionsexhibitingclimatesensitivityintheperiod2021to2050willbespecified,andpossiblecausalrelation-shipsbetweensensitivityandspecificcatchmentcharacteristicswillbeevaluated.
REFERENCESOcCC2007:KlimaänderungunddieSchweiz2050.ErwarteteAuswirkungenaufUmwelt,GesellschaftundWirtschaft.Bern:
OcCC.Schädler,B.2008:Klimawandel-GehtunsdasWasseraus?,GasWasserAbwasser,10,763–769.Viviroli,D. 2007: EinprozessorientiertesModellsystemzur Ermittlung seltenerHochwasserabflüsse fürungemessene
EinzugsgebietederSchweiz.GeographicaBernensiaG77.Bern:GeographischesInstitutderUniversitätBern.Viviroli,D.,Gurtz, J.&Zappa,M. 2007: TheHydrologicalModelling SystemPREVAH.GeographicaBernensia P40. Bern:
GeographischesInstitutderUniversitätBern.
1.25
Palaeoenvironmental mapping of the Swiss Rhone river
LaigreLaetitia*,Arnaud-FassettaGilles**,ReynardEmmanuel*
* Institut de Géographie, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])** Département de Géographie, Université Val-de-Marne (Paris 12), Avenue du Général de Gaulle 61, F-94010 Créteil Cedex
AsmanyEuropeanrivers,theSwissRhoneriveranditsfloodplainhaveknownseveralmorphologicalvariationsaftertheLittleIceAgethatendedaround1850.BasedontheconceptofthepalaeoenvironmentalatlasbuiltontheFrenchRhoneriverbyJ.-P.Bravardetal. (2008),palaeoenvironmentalmappinghasbeencarriedoutintheSwissRhoneriverwatershed(Laigre2009).Comparisonofhistoricalmapsfrom1835to1996(Dufourmap,SiegfriedAtlas,andseveraleditionsofnationalmapofSwitzerland)showsseveraleventsoffluvialmetamorphosis(Bravard1989)ofthechannel.Untilthe1860’s,numerousgravelbars,extensiveislandsandlargeactivezonecanbeobserved.Thebraidedstyleisthedominantfluvialpattern.Sincetheendofthe19thcentury,mostofchannelsarestraight,exceptedonearea–theFingesForestzone–wherealargepartofthevalleyisoccupiedbyanimportantbraidedsystem.Sincethe1940’s,achannelconstrictionisobservedaswellandinci-sionofthepresentstraightchannelisprogressing.
Analysisof themetamorphosis factorsemphasisesprincipallyoneexternalvariable,whichmodified the system:humanintervention.ChannelizationoftheRhoneriveranditstributariesfromthelate19thcenturyandgravelextractionshavecompletelymodified thenatural sedimentary functioning andbalance, in a period of reduced sedimentary supply thatcharacterisestheendoftheLittleIceAge.Moreover,morphologicalmodificationsofthefluvialsystemhadimpactsonthefloodplainlandscapeevolutionandlanduseinthevalley,whichwascharacterisedbylargewoodlandandwetlandareasuntiltheendof19thcentury.Understandingfunctioningofpastenvironmentsmaybeaprecioushelptoanticipateeventu-alfuturefloodeventsthatcauselargedamagesintheAlpinerange.
REFERENCESBravard,J.-P.1989:LamétamorphosedesrivièresdesAlpesfrançaisesàlafinduMoyen-Ageetàl’époquemoderne,Bull.Soc.
Géogr.Liège,25,145-157.BravardJ.-P.,ProvansalM.,Arnaud-FassettaG.,ChabbertS.,GaydouP.,DufourS.,RichardF.,ValleteauS.,MelunG.&PassyP.
2008:Unatlasdupaléo-environnementdelaplainealluvialeduRhône,delafrontièresuisseàlamer.InDesmetM.,MagnyM.,MocciF. (coord.).Duclimatàl’Homme.Dynamiqueholocènedel’environnementdansleJuraetlesAlpes,CollectionduLaboratoireEDYTEM,CahiersdePaléoenvironnement6,101-116.
Laigre L. 2009: Etude diachronique de la dynamique fluviale duRhône suisse depuis la fin du Petit AgeGlaciaire –Cartographiepaléoenvironnementale sectoriellede la source au lac Léman,MémoiredeMaster,Université Paris 1-Panthéon-Sorbonne.
36Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.26
Storage and release of water and chemical species in glaciers
MartinLüthi
Versuchsanstalt für Wasserbau, Hydrologie und Glaziologie (VAW), ETH Zürich, 8092 Zürich ([email protected])
Glaciersaccumulate solidprecipitation in formof ice, andwith itmaterials ranging fromchemical species todustandstones.Onlyundersteadyclimateconditionsthereleaserateofthesematerials,andwater,isconstant.Underavaryingcli-matethereexistcoldperiodswithreducedreleaseofaccumulatedwaterandchemicalspecies,aswellaswarmperiodswhenwaterisreleasedathighrate.Duringthewarmperiods,highconcentrationsofchemicalsandsedimentsarereleasedfromtheglacier.Wepresentresultsfromatransientflowlinemodelofaglacierwhichallowsustoquantifytheseprocesses.InacasestudyonOberaargletscherweshowthatpersistentorganicpollutants(POPs)emittedtotheatmosphereinthe1950-1960swerestoredintheglacierandarereleasedathighrateduringthelastdecade.Consequently,theconcentrationoftoxicPOPsintheproglaciallakeareashighasduringthetimeofatmosphericimpact,whichagreeswithmeasurementsinasedimentcore.
1.27
Groundwater and tunneling: implementation of a geochemical monito-ring network in the southern Switzerland
MarzocchiRoberto*&PeraSebastian*
* IST – SUPSI Istituto scienze della Terra, CP 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])
Theinteractionoftunnelingwithgroundwaterisaproblemfromtheenvironmentalaswellastheengineeringpointofview.Infact,tunneldrillingmaycauseadrawdownofpiezometriclevelsandinflowsintunnelscanbeaproblemduringexcavationsteps.Infracturedrockwatercirculationisstronglyinfluencedbystructuralelements,suchasfaultzones,frac-turesandotherdiscontinuities,andnumericalsolutionsarefrequentlyusedinliterature(NAGRAsince1985,Ofterdingeretal1999,Löwetal.2007).Tothispurposevariousconceptualapproacheshasbeenperformedtodescribeandmodelthegroundwaterflowthroughfracturedrockmasses,rangingfromequivalentcontinuummodelstodiscretefracturenetworksimulationmodels.Howevertheirapplicationneedsmanypreliminaryinvestigationsonthebehaviorofthegroundwatersystem;moreoverthesemodelsrequestacorrectcalibration,thatisverycomplex,evenimpossiblewithoutacollectionofnecessarystructuralandhydrochemicaldata.To study large-scale flowsystems in fractured rocksofmountainous terrains, a comprehensive study isongoingclose toLuganousingthedataproducedinoneofthemaininfrastructuresactuallyinconstruction,theAlptransitMonteCeneribasetunnel.Themaingoalofthisworkistheunderstandingofhowthecollectionofisotopicandgeochemicaldata,andgeophysical techniques (VLFprofilesand2Dresistivity surveys), combiningwith structuralandhydrogeological informa-tions,canbeusedinordertodevelophydrogeologicalconceptualandperhapsnumericalmodels.In theregionsurroundingtheMonteCeneribase tunnel thereareabout750springsactuallyregistered inthecantonaldatabase.Onthebasisofcriteriaof(i)relevance(useanddischarge)and(ii) distancefromthetunnel,anumberofspringsarebeselectedformonthlymeasurementsofdischarge,electricconductivity,pH,andtemperature,andwatersamplesaretakingtomonitorstableisotopesofhydrogenandoxygen(2H,18O)andtritium(3H),perhapscombinedwithhelium-3.Furthermorethesedatawillbecomparedwithtunnelinflowsinformationstoperform,withinreason,avalidationofthemodelthatwillbedesignedtakingadvantagesofthesetechniques.Inparticular,theanalysisofstableisotopecompositionofsprings,willreflecttheirwaterorigin,becausespatial(rechargealtitude,topography,etc.)andtemporal(seasonal)effectsinprecipitationsstronglyaffecttheisotopiccompositionofmete-orologicalwaterandconsequentlyofgroundwaterreservoirs(fig.1).Theanalysisoftritium,thatisaradioactiveisotope,willbeusedforgroundwaterdating(fig.2);usingonlytritiumwewillobtainaqualitativeindicationofwaterage(youngoroldgroundwater),whiletritiumcombinedwithhelium-3,incaseofmodernwater,willprovideus,a“discreteage”forthesam-pledwater.
37
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
Figure1.Stableisotopesfractionation:physicalprocessesandrelevantregisteredeffects.
Figure2.Basicprinciplesofthedatingmethodswithtritium.Onthelefttheregisteredtritiumconcentrationduringlastdecades,thatal-
lowstoqualitativedistinctionbetweenyoungandoldgroundwaters.Ontherighttheusingoftritiumcombinedwithhelium-3.
REFERENCESAA.VV.1985.Grimseltestsite–Overviewandtestprograms,NAGRAtechnicalreport85-46Löw,S.,Lützenkirchen,V.,Ofterdinger,U.S.,Zangler,C.,Eberhardt,E.&Evans,K.2001.Environmentalimpactsoftunnelsin
fracturedcrystallinerocksoftheCentralAlps,IAHSelectedPapers,Vol.9,Chapter34,507-526Ofterdinger,U.S.2001.GroundwaterflowsystemsintheRotondoGranite,CentralAlps(Switzerland),PhdthesisofNatural
Science,Swissfederalinstituteoftechnology(ETH)–Zurich
38Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.28
Dynamics of colloid concentrations in a small river related to hydrological conditions and land use.
MBockPatrick&LoizeauJean-Luc
Institut F.-A. Forel, Faculté des sciences, Université de Genève, Route de Suisse 10, CH-1290 Versoix ([email protected])
Colloidsplayamajorroleinthetransportandbioavailabilityofcontaminantsinaquaticenvironments.Theirdynamicsinanecosystem(erosion,transport,aggregationandsubsequentsettling)isakeyparametertounderstandthefateandpoten-tialimpactsofcolloid-associatedpollutantssuchasmetalsororganicpollutants(e.g.Benoitetal.1994,Irace-GuigandandAaron2003).Inriversystems,colloidalparticlesaremainlyofdetritaloriginandderivedfromtheerosionofsoilsandim-permeablesurfacesinthewatershed.
Inthepresentstudy,thewatershedoftheVersoixRiver(France,Switzerland),atributaryofLakeGeneva,hasbeeninvesti-gatedbysamplingwateratdifferentsitesalongtherivercourse,andundervarioushydrologicalconditions(lowflows,snowmelting,smallfloods).Thewatershedmaincharacteristics(slope,landuse)havebeendeterminedateachsamplingpointandquantifiedthroughaGIS-basedstudy.Colloidandparticlenumberandsizedistributionshavebeenmeasuredintherange0.05–20µmusingasingleparticlecounter(RosséandLoizeau2003).
Resultsshowthatthesizedistributions(expressedinnumberofparticles)followapowerlaw,withverysimilarslopes,in-dependentlyoftheconcentration.Attherivermouth,colloidconcentrationsduringsmallfloodconditionswere10to100timeshigherthanduringlowflows,whilesuspendedmatterwasonly2to3timeshigher,andthedischargeincreasedjustbyafactortwo.Theselargediscrepanciesintheamplificationfactorsbetweensuspendedparticlesandcolloidsconcentra-tionsreflectthepreferentialmobilizationofeasyerodiblecolloidalparticlesduringrainevents.Inaddition,colloidconcen-trationsalsogenerallyincreasewiththedistancefromtheheadwaters,forbothhighandlowflows.Thislikelyreflectsacontinuouscolloidsourcefromtheriverbeditself.Howeversomevariationsexistinthecolloidconcentrationthatmayberelated todifferences in the land cover. TheVersoixRiverwatershed is complex, comprising forest,meadows, cultivatedfields,industrialandurbansurfaces,andwetlands.Acarefulexaminationofthecolloidconcentrationevolutionalongtherivercourseduringraineventsshowsthatproportionofurbansurfacesandcultivatedfieldarepositivelycorrelatedtoin-creasedcolloidconcentrationsintheriver.
Asthecapacityofcolloidalparticlestoscavengeandsubsequentlytransportcontaminantislargelyrelatedtotheirspecificsurface,thelargeincreaseofcolloidconcentrationsduringfloodimpliesamuchlargerpotentialcontaminantloadtothereceivingwaterbodythanthatgenerallyobservedwithpollutantinputsrelatedtosuspendedparticlematter.
REFERENCESIrace-Guigand, S,and Aaron JJ, 2003. The roleoforganic colloids inherbicide transfer to rivers: aquantitative studyof
triazineandphenylureainteractionswithcolloids.AnalyticalandBioanalyticalchemistry,376:431-435.Benoit,S.D.,Oktay-Marshall,A.Cantu,E.M.Hood,C.H.Coleman,M.O.CorapciogluandP.H.Santschi,1994.Partitioningof
Cu,Pb,Ag,Zn, Fe,Al, andMnbetween filter-retainedparticles, colloids, and solution in sixTexas estuaries,MarineChemistry45:307–336
Rossé,P.,andJ.-L.Loizeau,2003.Useofsingleparticlesingleparticlecountersforthedeterminationofnumberandsizedistributionofcolloidinnaturalsurfacewaters.ColloidsandSurfacesA217:109-120.
39
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.29
Water disturbance as the organizer of riparian vegetation
MolnarPeter*,PeronaPaolo*,BurlandoPaolo*
*Institute of Environmental Engineering, ETH Zürich, CH-8093 Zürich ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected])
Theflowregimeplaysanimportantrole intheorganizationofriparianvegetationinnaturalriversbycreatingsuitablegerminationsites,erodingplantsandchangingtherivermorphology.Animportantaspectoftheflowregimeisthedistur-banceelement,i.e.theseasonaldistribution,timingandmagnitudeoffloods.Theinteractionsbetweenwater,sediment,andriparianvegetationaremostevident innaturalunregulatedrivers, suchasgravel-bedbraidedstreamsandsand-bedmeanderingrivers.Restorationprojectsinregulatedriversoftenaimtomakeroomforthesenaturalinteractionstotakeplace.Thereforeweneedtocontinuouslyimprovethescientificbasistounderstandthefundamentalwater-sediment-vege-tationinteractionsanddevelopnewtoolsandmethodstosimulateandtest them. Inthispaperwepresenttwonewap-proaches(numericalandlaboratory-based)whichwearedevelopinginourgroupandwhichlookatwaterdisturbanceasanorganizingelementofriparianvegetation.
Thefirstnumericalapproachisastochasticmodelforwater-sediment-vegetationinteractionsinabraidedgravel-bedstream.Thisisanapproachthatmodelstheexpansionandcontractionoftheexposedsedimentareainabraidedriverdrivenbystochasticflooddisturbancesandbyadeterministiccolonizationoftheexposedsedimentbanksandbarsbyriparianvege-tationinthetimebetweenthefloods.Thebasicmodelallowsustodevelopananalyticalsolutionfortheprobabilitydensi-tyfunctionoftheexposedsedimentareaasafunctionoftheflooddisturbanceparametersandvegetationgrowthrate(Fig1)(Peronaetal.,2009).
stochastic disturbance termflood mortality
( )swsw sw G
dAA A C
dt= Θ ∆ ⋅∆ −
pdf of disturbances
pdf of thesedimentarea
pdf of disturbances
pdf of thesedimentarea
pdf of disturbances
pdf of thesedimentarea
G G swC k A=0( , ) ( ) ( , ) ( )
f
at c atsw sw Ag A t g t g A t g t= + +
deterministic growth termcolonization by vegetation
Figure1.SetupoftheprocessequationfortheexposedsedimentareaAswandanillustrationofthesolutionforthepdfofA
sw.
Thissimplemodelmaybeextendedtoincludesuccessivevegetationstagesandtheircompetitionforavailablespaceonthefloodplain(Peronaetal.,2008).
Thesecondlaboratoryapproachisanexperimentwhichstudiestheroleofhydrologicaldisturbancesonbiomasserosiondynamics in a sand-bed flume which is seeded by a fast growing grass. This experiment was conducted at the TotalEnvironmentSimulatoroftheUniversityofHullundertheHydralab3EUProgramme(Molnaretal.,2009,inpreparation).Intheexperimentwestudiedtheinteractionsbetweenthedisturbancesandthegrowthrateofthevegetationrootsandstems.Preliminaryresultsshowthattheactionoffluvialerosionremovessystematicallyplantsthatarenotabletowith-standtheappliedstress,whilethenon-erodedcommunitycontinuestogrowanddevelop(Fig2).
Thetwopresentedapproachesbothillustratethatthewaterdisturbanceregimeplaysanimportantroleintheorganizationofbraidedrivermorphologiesandsandbedstreams,riparianvegetation,andplantcommunities.Thewaterdisturbanceregimeandvegetationgrowthinteractandresultinadynamicripariancommunity.Weadvocatethatthisisnotadetermi-nisticproblemandthattheeffectofwater-sediment-riparianvegetationinteractionsshouldbeexaminedinaprobabilisticframeworkbothatalargefieldandsmalllaboratoryscale.
40Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Figure2.Exampleofasimulationrunwiththehistogramsofthenumberofroots(top),lengthofthemainroot(center)andstemheight
(bottom)forerodedandnon-erodedplants.
REFERENCESPerona,P.,P.Molnar,M.Savina,andP.Burlando(2008).Stochasticsediment-vegetationdynamicsinanAlpinebraidedriver,
IAHSPubl.325,266-274.Perona,P.,P.Molnar,M.Savina,andP.Burlando(2009).Anobservation-basedstochasticmodelforsedimentandvegetation
dynamicsinthefloodplainofanAlpinebraidedriver,WaterResour.Res.,doi:10.1029/2008WR007550.
1.30
Calculating bedload transport rates in Swiss mountain streams using new roughness approaches
ManuelNitsche*,AlexandreBadoux*,JensM.Turowski*,DieterRickenmann*
*Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL, Zuercherstrasse 111, 8903 Birmensdorf, Switzerland ([email protected])
Mostmethodsforpredictingbedloadtransportdonottakeintoaccounttypicalroughnesselementsofsmall,steepmoun-tainstreams,likestep-poolsequences,largebouldersorwoodydebris.However,flowresistanceduetosuchformroughnesselementsappearstobeanimportantcontrolonbedloadtransportratesinmountainstreams.
Recently,newapproachesbasedonlaboratoryexperimentswereproposedtoassessflowresistanceduetoformroughness.Theyquantifytheeffectsofgeneralizedmodelsofroughnesselementstoflowresistance.Furthermore,severalempiricallyderivedformulaetocalculatebedloadtransportratesincludingarespectiveroughnessparameterhavebeenpublished.
Theobjectiveofourstudyistosystematicallytesttheseapproacheswithfieldobservations.Forthispurpose,wemeasuredthe required roughnessparameters for sevenSwissmountain streams,with local channelgradients ranging from1.5 to16.5%,andcatchmentareasfrom12to43km2.Wecalculatedflowresistanceandbedloadtransportforsedimenttransportevents in2000and2005.Bycomparingcalculatedandobserveddataofbedloadtransportwe identifiedwhetherand inwhichrangetheexaminedapproachesaresuitableforapplicationinnaturalstreamconditions.
41
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.31
Pollution des eaux: la santé est-elle un levier pour mettre en place une gestion intégrée à l’échelle du basin versant?
NiwaNelly*,RossiLuca**&ChèvreNathalie***
* IPTEH - Faculté des Géosciences et de l’Environnement, Université de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne (nelly. [email protected])**IIE-ECOL, ENAC, EPFL, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])*** IMG - Faculté des Géosciences et de l’Environnement, Université de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Laproblématiquedespolluantscommelespesticides,médicaments,cosmétiques,dansleseauxdesurfaceestdeplusenplusactuelle.Nonpasque cesmicropolluants soientdes substancesnouvelles,maisplutôtque les techniquesd’analysechimiqueseperfectionnant,ondécouvredeplusenplusdesubstanceschimiquesdanslemilieuaquatique.Ilsembleéga-lementquecessubstancesnesoientpassansconséquencessur l’hommeet l’environnementpuisqu’onleurattribuedeseffetscancérigènesoudediminutiondelafertilité.
Dansuneoptiquedegestiondurabledesressourceseneau,ilestdoncindispensabledeprendreencomptel’aspectdesmi-cropolluants.Cependant,cettepollutionesttrèsdifficileàmaîtrisercarellen’estpasconfinéedansunendroitclos.Lessubstances sont souvent transportées surde longuesdistances et peuvent ainsi engendrerdes effets loinde leur sourced’émission.Atitred’exemple,desrejetsindustrielsdansleValaisontconduitàunecontaminationduLémanparcertainspesticidesetmédicamentsquiseretrouvaientensuitedansleseauxbrutesdesstationsdepompageautourduLéman.Cettepollutionestaussidifficileàlimitercarsidesquotaspeuventêtresdéfinisparsecteurs,lasommeglobaledessubstancesdetous les secteurspeutvitedonner lieuàunepollutionayantdes conséquences importantes sur l’environnement.Enfin,cettepollutionestcomplexecarl’associationentredifférentessubstancespeutaussidonnerlieuàdescocktailsdétonants.
Pourminimiserlerisquepourl’hommeetl’environnementdesmicropolluants,ilestdoncindispensabledepasseràunegestion«intégrée»del’eauquiprenneencomptelesacteursetleurorganisationàuneéchellerégionale.Autraversd’unjeuderôleorganisédanslecadred’uneformationpost-grade,nousavonstentéd’explorercommentlasantépourraitêtre(ounepasêtre)unlevierpourmettreenplacecettegestionintégréeetenquoicelapourraitconduireàrevisiterlespratiquesdel’aménagementduterritoire.
Labrèveanalysequenousavonsmenédujeuderôlesnouspermetdemettreenexerguetroisconclusionsprincipales:Lapremière,c’estquelasantéestunlevierparticulièrementpertinentpourdéclencheruneprisedeconscienceduproblèmeetpermetd’amorcerdefaçontrèsrapideunedémarchevisantàlerésoudre.Encela,lasantésembleêtreunélémentdé-clencheuretcatalyseurduprocessus.
Laseconde,c’estquelasantéestunthèmesensibledontilesttrèsdifficilededétermineretd’assumerlaresponsabilité.Pourautant,cettecomplexitéengendreaussilaprisedeconsciencedelanécessitéedemettreenplaceunprocessuscollec-tif.Lasantépermetdoncderassembleretdedynamiserunedémarchecollective,globaleetintégrée.
Enfin,latroisième,c’estqueleprocessusentiernepeutentièrementreposersurl’argumentdelasanté.Eneffet,ilsemblequelasanté,mêmesiellereprésenteunenjeufort,peutêtreviteenconcurrenceavecd’autresenjeux,particulièrementaveclesenjeuxéconomiques.Ilenrésultealorssouventlamiseenplacedesolutionsréduites,«endofpipe»,quinecorres-pondentplusàl’objectifdedépart,àsavoir:unesolutionglobaleetintégrée.
Pourconclure,ilnousparaitimportantdesoulignerànouveauquesilejeuderôleestunoutiltrèsintéressantpouranaly-serdesprocessus,ilneremplaceenaucuncasl’étudedecasréels.Eneffet,ils’agitd’unesituationsimplifiée,accéléréedansletempsetavecdesacteursfactices.Néanmoins,ilestintéressantdeconstaterquelessituationsdécritesdanslejeuderôlesseretrouventsouventdansdescasréels.
REFERENCESEdderP,OrtelliD,andRamseierS,2006:Métauxetmicropolluantsorganiques.Rapp.Comm.int.prot.eauxLémancontre
pollut.Campagne2005.CIPEL(CommissionpourlaprotectiondeseauxduLéman):Lausanne.p.65-87.NiwaN,RossiL,ChèvreN.Micropolluantsdansleseaux: lasantesera-t-elleunleviersuffisantpourmettreenplaceune
gestionintégrée?.ChapitredelivreCEAT.Aparaître.
42Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.32
Effective stress and fracture permeability in regional groundwater flow: numerical comparison of analytical formulas
PreisigGiona*&PerrochetPierre
*Centre of Hydrogeology, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])
Thedependencyoffracturepermeabilityoneffectivestressisasubjectwellknownandhasbeenintensivelystudiedlastdecades.Inregionalanddeepgroundwaterflowsystemundergrounddrainingstructuresastunnels,causeadiminutionofporepressureleadingtoanincreasingeffectivestressandadecreasingpermeability.Oneapproachconsiststoinsertconsti-tutive laws relating effective stress topermeability inDarcy’s law,which isused to evaluate 3D regional simulations ofdischargerates,pressuredistributionsand flowpaths.Thisapproachgain inaccuracyascompared to theclassicaloneswhichconsiderconstantpermeabilityfield.However,thetypeandparameterizationoftheconstitutivelawinfluencethefinalresult.
Inthiswork,threedifferentmodelfunctionsrelatingeffectivestresstopermeabilityareimplementedinthetensorformofDarcy’s law,andcomparedbymeansofnumericalexperiments.Twoof these functionswerederivedfromexperimentalworks (Louis1969;Walsh1981), theotheronewastheoreticallyderivedfromHooke’s law.Numericalsimulationsareallbasedonaninitialfracturedhydrostaticsystemwhereanundergrounddrainingstructureisactivated,causingasteady-statesaturatedflowfromtheupperboundarycondition(surface)tothelowerboundarycondition(undergroundstructure).Thegoverningnonlinearequationsaresolvedusingthefiniteelementmethod.
Inthethreecases,resultsshowthattheintroductionofstress-dependentpermeabilitiesinDarcy’slawleadstodischargeratessignificantlylowerthanthosecalculatedwiththeclassicalapproach.Thisis explainedbyadecreasingpermeabilityduetoanincreasingeffectivestress,particularlyinthevicinityofthedeepdrainingstructure. Louis’experimentalmodelyieldsthelargestdifferenceandhasthedeficiencyofnotconsideringtheverticalstressterm,whileWalsh’smodelisdiffi-culttosolvenumericallyduetohigherordernonlinearities.Theelasto-statisticalmodelanalyticallyderivedfromHooke’slawseemstobebetteradaptedforsolvingsuchproblemsandyieldsdifferenceswhicharesomewhatsmallerthanthetwoothers.
REFERENCESLouisC. 1969:A studyof groundwater flow in jointed rockand its influenceon the stabilityof rockmasses. Technical
ReportNo10,9/69,RockMechanics,ImperialCollege,UK.Walsh J.B. 1981: Effect of pore pressure and confiningpressure on fracture permeability. Int. J. RockMech.Min. Sci.
Geomech.Abstr.,18:429–435.
43
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.33
Debris flows, landslides, and sediment transport in mountain catchments
RickenmannDieter*
*SwissFederalResearchInstituteWSL,Zürcherstrasse111,CH-8903Birmensdorf([email protected])
Inmountainheadwatercatchmentswithsteepchannelsandhillslopes,floodsareoftenassociatedwithsedimenttransportand/orwithdebrisflows.Possibleinteractionsbetweendebrisflows,shallowlandslidesandfluvialsedimenttransportinsteepstreamsareillustratedFigure1.Theseprocessesoftenoccurduringhigh-intensityorlong-durationrainstorms,possiblycombinedwithsnowmelt,resultinginslopeinstabilities,sedimenttransportingflowsandfloods.Theseprocessesareoftenassociatedwithdamagetohousesorinfrastructure,particularlyalongthechannelnetwork,andmayinvolvealsocasual-ties.
Debrisflowstypicallyoccurinsteepheadwatercatchments.Atorrentcatchmentischaracterisedbysporadicandsuddenhighdischargesofbothwaterandsediments,andittypicallycomprisesacatchmentarealessthanabout25km2.Thechan-nelgradientmayvaryfrommorethan60%toafew%inthefanarea.Thetorrentsystemanddebris-flowoccurrencecanbecharacterisedbythreemainzones:Theheadwaterareaorinitiationzonewheretheflowistriggered,thetransitzone(gullyandchannels)whereentrainmentofmoresolidmaterialmayoccur,andthedebrisfanareawhereoftenmajordepo-sitiontakesplace.DebrisflowsintheAlpsmayinvolvetotalsedimentvolumesofuptosomehundredthousandcubicme-tres.Thesedimentmaybesuppliedfrompointsourcessuchaslandslidesorfromincisionofthetorrentbedbyverticalandlateralerosion.Thetotaleventmagnitudeisoftenusedasaroughindicationtocharacterisetheintensityofadebrisflow.Thisparameterlargelyinfluencestheflowbehaviourinthechanneland–inthecaseofovertopping-theextentoftheaf-fectedareasonthefan.Debrisflowsmaydeliverimportantquantitiesofsedimenttothereceivingmountainriver.
Incontrasttolowlandgravelbedrivers,relativelyfewstudiesweremadeonsedimenttransportinsteepheadwaterchannels,withstreamgradientssteeperthanabout5%.Sedimenttransportdynamicsinthesechannelsmaybequitedifferentfromlow-gradientchannels.Thereisoftenastronginteractionbetweenhillslopeprocessesandthechannelnetwork.Sedimenttransportmaybesupplylimitedratherthancontrolledbythesedimenttransportcapacityforagivendischargeandchannelconditions.Steepheadwaterstreamsarecharacterisedbyawiderangeofsedimentsizesandtemporally-andspatially-vari-ablesedimentsources.Bedmorphologyandchannelstructuresmaybeinfluencedbythepresenceoflargeboulders,woodydebrisandbedrockconstrictions.Thiscanresultinlargevariationsinchannelgeometry,streamflowvelocityandrough-ness,andthustheapplicationoftheoreticalsedimenttransportequationsmaybeproblematic.Also,quantitativemeasure-mentsofsedimentandbedloadtransportinsteepstreamsareverylimited.
Inthispresentationanoverviewwillbegivenontheprocessesdebrisflows,shallowlandslidesandfluvialsedimenttrans-port.Aparticularfocuswillbethediscussionofinteractionsbetweentheseprocesses.Althoughanumberofmethodshavebeenproposedtopredictanddescribetheinitiationandflowbehaviourofdebrisflowsandsedimenttransportingflowsinmountainstreams,quantitativepredictionsforhazardassessmentarestilldifficultinmanycases.Theapplicationofsomemethodswillbeillustratedusingsomeexamplesfrompastfloodandrainstormevents.
B ed loadtrans port
Debrisflow
L ands lide
c hannel, low to medium inc lination
(≤ 15 . . . 30 %)
c hannel, medium to high inc lination
(≥ 15 . . . 30 %)
hill s lopes
F lood P rec ipitation
B ed loadtrans port
Debrisflow
L ands lide
c hannel, low to medium inc lination
(≤ 15 . . . 30 %)
c hannel, medium to high inc lination
(≥ 15 . . . 30 %)
hill s lopes
F lood P rec ipitation
Figure1:Occurrenceofdebrisflows,shallowlandslidesandfluvialsedimenttransportinsteepmountainstreams.
44Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.34
Characterisation of geothermal reservoirs using 3D geological modelling and gravity
SchillEva*,AbdelfettahYassine*,AltweggPierrik*,BaillieuxPaul*
*Laboratoire de Géothermie - CREGE, Université de Neuchâtel, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2009, Neuchâtel, Suisse ([email protected])
Theproductivityofgeothermalresourcesdependondifferentparametersmainlythereservoirtemperature,thehydraulicconductivityandthestressfield.Ithasbeenrealizedindifferentstudiesthatthehydraulicconductivityofthereservoiristhedominantfactor(e.g.BestPracticeHandbookfortheDevelopmentofUnconventionalGeothermalResourceswithaFocusonEnhancedGeothermalSystems,2008).Thisstudyispartofthelong-termresearchoftheLaboratoryofGeothermicsatNeuchâtelwiththeobjectivetodevelopamethodologytoinvestigatepermeabilityfromgeophysicalexploration.Theaimofthisstudyistodevelopamethodtocharacterizetheporosityfromgravityinversioncombinedwith3Dgeologicalmodel-ing.
Gravitymeasurementsprovideinformationonthedensityofsubsurfaceunitseitherbyforwardmodelingorinversion.Anditiswellknownthatthedensityofthesubsurfacecanbeeithercontrolledbylithologicalchangesorchangesinporosity(Pruis&Johnson1998).Furthermore,whenthegeologicalareaiswellknown,the3Dgravityinversioniswellconstraintsoitprovidesaccurateresultandbestdensitiesvaluesareobtained.Forporosity,oneamongtherelationshipswhichexistbe-tweenthedensityandporositycanbeused(e.g.Johnsonetal.,2000).
InthegeothermalareaofSoultzthecombinationof3Dgeologyandgravityinversionhasrevealeddensitychangesinthegraniticbasement(Figure1)whichcanberelatedtobothchangesinthegraniticfaciestotheNorthofthegeothermalsiteandtoporosityinthehorststructure,wherethereservoirislocated(Schill et al.,subm).SyntheticmodelsforotherdeepgeothermalreservoirssuchasSt.Gall(Switzerland)providefurtherindicationonthepossibilitiestodeduceporosityfromgravityforwardmodeling.TheexamplefromSoultzshows,however,thatonlyifthegeologicalstructuresarewellknownandcanbeassumedasfixinthegravityinversion,theestimationofdensitychangescausedbyporosityarepossible.
Figure1:MeandensitydistributionresultingfrominversionofgravitydataforarepresentativeE-Wprofileacrossthegeothermalreser-
voirofSoultz-sous-Forêts.(E-Wextension29km,altidudea.s.l.:-8000to250m).
REFERENCESSchill, E.,Geiermann, J.&Kümmeritz, J., subm.2-DMagnetotellurics andgravity at thegeothermal site at Soultz-sous-
Forêts.inWorldGeothermalCongress2010,pp.1390,Bali,Indonesia.Johnson, P.H., Pruis,M. J. & Van Patten,D.,Density and Porosity of theUpperOceanic Crust from SeafloorGravity
Measurements,Geophy.Res.Lett.27(7),1053-1056,2000.Pruis,M.P.&JohnsonH.P.,Porosityofveryyoungoceaniccrustfromseafloorgravitymeasurements,Geophys.Res.Lett.,
25,1959-1962,1998.
45
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.35
Field Fluorometer for Simultaneous Detection of 3 Colourless Tracers
SchneggPierre-André
Centre d'Hydrogéologie et de Géothermie CHYN, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])
Wehavedesignedflow-throughfieldfluorometersforsimultaneousdetectionoftwoorthreeinvisible,colourlesstracers,sincethereisanincreasinginterestfor“blind”tracertests.
Althoughmostdyetracersusedinhydrogeologyareharmlesstotheenvironment(Behrensetal.2001,FOENReport2002)theirvisibleandindiscreetimpactonthepopulationremainsasourceofannoyanceforthefieldhydrogeologist.
Therecentappearanceofsmall,inexpensiveLEDsradiatingUVlightmadeitpossibletheexcitationofcolourlesstracersofthenaphthalenefamily.
Afewyearsago,companiescouldnotalwaysaffordmulti-tracertestsbecauselaboratoryexpensesincreasewiththenumberoftracers.Today,thankstothefieldfluorometer,multi-tracingistherule(SchneggandDoerfliger1997).However,asuccess-ful separationof tracers by the field fluorometerpresupposesdissimilar spectral characteristics of each tracer (Schnegg2003).Carefulselectionofthesetoftracersremainsmandatory.
Thefieldfluorometerconvenientlyreplacesthewatersampler.Withthisinstrumentthereisnoneedforfrequentsamplecollectionandsubsequentlaboratoryanalysisofthesamples.Veryhightimeresolutionisalsoofgreatinterest.However,theseparationoftwoorthreedifferentdyetracerscannotbeperformedattheresolutionachievableinthelaboratorywithaspectro-fluorometer.Theopticsofthefieldfluorometer ischaracterizedbypass-bandfilters.Toseparate2or3dyes inamulti-tracertest,thefluorometerrequiresasmanylightsources(usuallyLEDs)astracers,anddetectors.Eachopticalchan-nelisequippedwithadequateopticalfilters.Theunknownconcentrationsofeachtracerareobtainedbyresolvinginreal-timeasystemof2or3linearequations(Schnegg2003).
Foroptimaltracerseparation,thedeterminantofthesystemofequationsmustbeaslargeaspossible.Lowvaluesofthedeterminantindicateinadequateassociationoftracersofsimilarexcitation/emissionspectra.Forexample,thereisnochan-cetoseparateacocktailofrhodamineB,GorWT.Eventhesophisticatedlaboratoryinstrumentwillhavetroubleperformingtheseparation.
Mostfrequentlydyetracersusedare:Uranine,eosine,naphtionate,sulforhodamineB,amidorhodamineG,rhodamineWT,duasyne,tinopal,aminoGacid(Käss1998).Theproblemwithmostofthemisthevisualimpactinsurfaceordrinkingwater,particularlynear thepointof injection (disappearanceat concentrationsbelow10µg/L). Twoof them,naphtionateandaminoGacidaremuchmorediscreetintheenvironment.ThisisbecausetheirexcitationbandislocatedintheUVpartofthespectrum,andtheiremissionisclosetotheshortwavelengthlimitofvisiblelight.Afieldtestwascarriedoutinasurfacestream(100L/s)overadistanceof300metres.Yellowduasyne,athird,hardlyvisibletracer,wasusedjointlywiththetwoothertracers.Quantitiesof1and10mgofeachtracerwereinjectedinturnat2minutesinterval,sothatthebreakthroughcurveswouldoverlap,allowingthusfortestingtheseparationmethod.Thefigureshowsthethreebreakthroughcurvesaftermathematicalseparation.Asexpected,theydisplaythesameshapeandheight.Carefulcalibrationofthefluorometerisimportantforachievingperfectseparation.
REFERENCESBehrens,H.,Beims,U.,Dieter,H.,Dietze,G.,Eikmann,T.,Grummt,T.,Hanisch,H.,Henseling,H.,Käß,W.,Kerndorff,H.,
Leibundgut, C.,Müller-Wegener, U., Rönnefahrt, I., Scharenberg, B., Schleyer, R., Schloz,W., & Tilkes, F. 2001:Toxicological and ecotoxicological assessment ofwater tracers, Hydrogeology Journal 9, 321–325.DOI 10.1007/s100400100126.
FOEN,ArbeitsgruppeTracerderSchweizerischenGesellschaftfürHydrogeologieSGH.2002:EinsatzkünstlicherTracerinderHydrogeologiePraxishilfe.Utilisationdestraceursartificielsenhydrogéologie,Guidepratique.BerichtedesBWG,SerieGeologieNr.3–Bern.Availableathttp://www.bafu.admin.ch/hydrologie/01835/02126/index.html?lang=en
Käss,W.1998:TracingtechniqueinGeohydrology.Balkema,Rotterdam.Schnegg,P.-A.,&Doerfliger,N.1997:Aninexpensiveflow-throughfieldfluorometer.ProceedingsoftheSixièmecolloque
d'hydrologieenpayscalcaireetmilieufissuré,laChaux-de-Fonds.Schnegg,P.-A.,2003:AnewfieldfluorometerforMulti-tracertestsandturbiditymeasurementappliedtohydrogeological
problems,Proc.8thInternationalCongressoftheBrazilianGeophysicalSociety,RiodeJaneiro.
46Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.36
Recent Research on the Remote Retrieval of Soil Moisture from Space with Microwave Radiometry
SchwankMike*,VölkschIngo*,MätzlerChristian**&StähliManfred*
* Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research, Zürcherstrasse 111, 8903 Birmensdorf, Switzerland, ([email protected])** Institute of Applied Physics, University of Bern, Sidlerstrasse 5, 3012 Bern, Switzerland.
L-band (1 -2GHz)microwaveradiometry isaremotesensingtechniquetomonitorsoilmoistureover landsurfaces.TheEuropeanSpaceAgency’s(ESA)SoilMoistureandOceanSalinity(SMOS)radiometermissionaimsatprovidingglobalmapsof soilmoisture,with accuracy better than0.04m3m-3 every 3 days,with a spatial resolutionof approximately 40 km.Monitoringthe largescalemoisturedynamicsat theboundarybetweenthedeepbulksoilandtheatmosphereprovidesessentialinformationbothforterrestrialandatmosphericmodellers.Performinggroundbasedradiometercampaignsbe-forethemissionlaunch,duringthecommissioningphaseandduringtheoperativeSMOSmissionisimportantforvalida-tingthesatellitedataandforthefurtherimprovementoftheusedradiativetransfermodels.Thispresentationisanexampleofresearchattheboundarybetweensoilhydrologyandremotesensing.ItstartswithanoverviewoftheSMOSmissionfollowedbyanoutlineofthebasicconceptsbehindremotemoistureretrievalfrompassiveL-bandradiation.ThentheresultsfromaselectionofgroundbasedmicrowavecampaignsperformedwithintheETHdo-mainduringthelast7yearsarepresented.Furthermore,thedesignofanL-bandradiometerisshownwhichwasbuiltforESAtoperformfurthergroundbasedexperimentsduringtheSMOScommissioningandoperativephase.
1.37
Groundwater resources in Switzerland
SinreichMichael*,v.LützenkirchenVolker**,MatousekFederico**&KozelRonald*
*Bundesamt für Umwelt BAFU, Sektion Hydrogeologie, CH-3003 Bern ([email protected])**Matousek, Baumann & Niggli AG, Geologiebüro, CH-5401 Baden
Groundwaterisaninvisiblebutcrucialcomponentofthewatercycle.Itfeedssurfacestreamsaswellasaquaticecosystems,andisthemaindrinkingwaterresourceinmanycountries.Switzerlandisrichingroundwaterduetofavourableclimatic,hydrologicalandhydrogeologicalconditions,i.e.highrecharge.Morethan80%ofSwissdrinkingwaterrequirementsaremetbygroundwater,andgroundwaterthereforerepresentsasocialandeconomicassetofnationalimportance.Knowledgeabouttheextentoftheresourceisessentialforsustainablegroundwatermanagement.Thisisofparticularinterestgiventhepressureongroundwaterresourcesduetoincreasingwaterdemand,intenseundergroundengineeringactivities,andclimatechange.
TheGroundwaterResourcesMapofSwitzerlandona1:500,000scalepresentstheyieldofnear-surfacegroundwaterresour-cesinaqualitativemanner.Themapprovidesaninventoryofhydrogeologicalunits,subdividedaccordingtohigh,moderateandlowproductivity,whichisdeterminedmainlybyaquiferthicknessandpermeability.However,thismapdoesnotprovi-dequantitativeinformationintermsofthevolumeorthesafeyieldofgroundwaterresources.Whilethegroundwater volumedescribeshowmuchgroundwaterisavailableintheunderground,thesafe yieldisdefinedashowmuchgroundwaterisre-newableandcanthusbeusedinalong-termandsustainablemanner.Bothparametersarecrucialformanaginggroundwa-terresources.Todate,however,theyhavenotbeenassessedinSwitzerlandonanationalbasis.
AstudywasthereforeconductedtoevaluatethevolumeandsafeyieldofSwissgroundwaterresources.Specificapproachesweredevelopedinordertoprovideestimatesforbothparametersforthemainaquifertypesencountered(i.e.porous,fis-suredandkarstifiedrock)andbasedontheGroundwaterResourcesMap.Thisstudywasperformedinco-operationwiththeInstitute of Environmental Engineering and theGeological Institute of the ETHZ (Swiss Federal Institute of TechnologyZurich),andtheSwissInstituteofSpeleologyandKarstologySISKA.
HighlyproductiveporousaquifersalonglargerivervalleysrepresentthemaindrinkingwaterresourcesinSwitzerland.Thegroundwatervolumestored in suchaquiferswasassessedbyconsideringaquifergeometryandporosity.Estimatingsafe
47
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
syields,however,ismoreproblematicastheseaquifersarefedtoalargeextentbytheinfiltrationofriverwater.Inthiscase,amodellingapproachforanextractionscenarioalongariverwithtypicalaquifercharacteristicsprovidedmaximumwith-drawalrates.Forporousaquifersnotconnectedtosurfacestreams,estimatesofsafeyieldwerederivedsolelyfromrechargebyprecipitation.Infissuredaquifers,groundwaterfillstheporesandopenfracturesintheweatheredpartofconsolidatedrock.Estimatesofgroundwatervolumeinfissuredaquifersweremadefromtunnelinflowmeasurementsatselectedsitesincrystallinealpinerocks.Asfissuredandkarstifiedaquifersaredischargednaturallybysprings,dischargedatafromrepresentativespringin-ventorieswereusedtoevaluatethesafeyieldforbothaquifertypes.Finally,ageological-tectonicapproachenabledestimatesof thegroundwatervolume in the saturatedzoneofkarstifiedaquifers,whereas thisvalue is largelydeterminedby thedepthtowhichkarstgroundwaterisregardedassuitableforwatersupply.
1.38
The role of the colloidal pool for transport and fractionation of the rare earth elements in stream water
SteinmannMarc*&PourretOlivier**
*UMR 6249 Chrono-environnement, Université de Franche-Comté, F-25030 Besançon cedex ([email protected])**Département Géosciences, Institut Polytechnique LaSalle Beauvais, F-60026 Beauvais cedex ([email protected])
Therareearthelements(REE)areapowerfultoolforthestudyoftracemetalbehaviorinsurfaceandgroundwatersbecauseoftheirspecificatomicstructureandtheircoherentchemicalpropertiesthroughouttheREEgroup.FractionationofREEdistributionpatternsinwatersampleshaveinthepastbeenusedtomonitorprocessessuchassurfaceandsolutioncomple-xationortoidentifyprecipitationanddissolutionofspecificmineralphases(Gaillardet et al.,2003andcit.therein).RecentstudieshaveshownthattheREEofthe<0.45or<0.22µmfractionofsurfaceandgroundwatersaremainlypresentincollo-idalformratherthantrulydissolved(Gaillardet et al.,2003andcit.therein).Colloidsareorganicorinorganicmicroscopicphasesinasizerangeofabout0.1nmto0.2µm.FortheKalixriverinnorthernSwedenithasbeendemonstratedthatcol-loidsaremoreabundantinsummerandthattheREE-bearingcolloidalfractioniscomposedofFe/Mn-oxyhydroxidesandorganicmatter(Andersson et al.,2006).Theseauthorsfurthermoreshowthatinwintersmall(~3nm)organic-richcolloids,andlarger(~10-12nm)Fe/Mn-oxyhydroxidecolloidscanbedistinguished,whereascombinedFe/Mn-organicmattercolloidsofabout3nminsizeoccurduringspringandsummer.ThedetailedanalysisofthewintercolloidsrevealsthatthelightREE(La-Sm,LREE)arepreferentiallyassociatedwithFe/Mncolloids,whereastheheavyREE(Dy-Lu,HREE)havestrongeraffinityfororganiccolloids(Andersson et al.,2006).ThisdistinctionofthecolloidalREEfractionintoaorganicmatterandaFe/Mn-oxyhydroxidecontrolledpoolisconfirmedbyexperimentalstudies(Pourret et al.,2007a).
Recently,Steinmann&Stille(2008)havereportedfor0.45µmfilteredstreamwatersamplesfromthefrenchMassifCentralacontinuouslygrowingdepletionoftheLREEfromupstreamtodownstreamoveraflowdistanceoflessthan10km(Fig.1).Theauthorsfurthermoreshowedthatthisevolutionislinkedwiththesaturationindex(SI)forFe-oxyhydroxide(goethite,Fig.2):ThestreamwatershaveREEdistributionpatternssimilartothebasalticbedrockupstream,wherethesamplesarestronglyoversaturatedwithrespecttogoethite(SIupto8).Duringdownflow,theSIvalueforgoethitediminishesandtheLREEdepletiondevelops.Steinmann&Stille(2008)haveinterpretedthisevolutionwiththepresenceofFe/Mn-bearingcollo-idsthatgrowduringdownflowandfinallyprecipitateasFe/Mn-oxyhydroxideparticles.ThepreferentialscavengingoftheLREEbytheseprecipitatescouldexplaintheobserveddepletionoftheLREEinthe<0.45µmfraction.
ThescopeofthepresentstudyistoverifythehypothesisofSteinmann&Stille(2008)bydirectanalysisofthecolloidalfrac-tiononnewsamplessampledinSeptember2009inthesamefieldsitebyusingtheultracentifugalproceduredescribedbyPourret et al. (2007a)toseparatethecolloids.ThisnewanalyticalapproachhasbeencompletedwithcomputermodelinginordertoevaluateinmoredetailthecompetitionbetweenorganicandinorganiccolloidsonREEtransportandfractionationinstreamwater.InteractionswithorganiccolloidsweredescribedusingModelVIandthefurtherrefinedREEparametersdescribedbyPourret et al. (2007b).AdsorptionoftheREEontooxyhydroxidecolloidswasmodeledusingasurfacecomplexa-tionmodelintegratedintoPHREEQC.
48Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Fig.1:EvolutionofLREEdepletionwithdistancemonitoredby
bedrocknormalisedNd/Ybratiosinthe<0.45µmstreamwater
fraction(figurefromSteinmann&Stille,2008)
Fig.2:LinkbetweenNd/Ybratiosthesaturationindex(SI)forgoe-
thite.Notetheregularevolutionwithflowdistance(figurefrom
Steinmann&Stille,2008)
REFERENCESAndersson,K.,Dahlqvist,R.,Turner,D.,Stolpe,B.,Larsson,T.,Ingri,J.&Andersson,P.,2006:Colloidalrareearthelementsin
aborealriver:Changingsourcesanddistributionsduringthespringflood.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta70,3261-3274.Gaillardet,J.,Viers,J.&Dupré,B.,2003:Traceelementsinriverwaters.In:Drever,J.,Turekian,K.(Eds.),Surfaceandground
water,weathering,andsoils.Elsevier,pp.225-272.Pourret,O.,Dia,A.,Davranche,M.,Gruau,G.,Hénin,O.&Angée,M.,2007a:Organo-colloidalcontrolonmajor-andtrace-
elementpartitioninginshallowgroundwaters:Confrontingultrafiltrationandmodelling.AppliedGeochem.22,1568-1582.
Pourret,O.,Davranche,M.,Gruau,G.&Dia,A., 2007b:Organic complexationof rare earthelements innaturalwaters:Evaluatingmodelcalculationsfromultrafiltrationdata.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta71,2718-2735.
Steinmann,M.&Stille,P.,2008:Controlsontransportandfractionationoftherareearthelements instreamwaterofamixedbasaltic-graniticcatchmentbasin(MassifCentral,France).Chem.Geol.254,1-18.
1.39
Microbial communities in the steep gradients of the meromictic lake Cadagno
MauroTonolla1,2
1) Microbial ecology group, Microbiology Unit, Plant biologx Dept. Universtity of Geneva c/o Istituto cantonale di microbiologia (ICM), Via Mirasole 22A, CH-6500 Bellinzona & 2) Alpine Biology Center (ABC), Piora, CH-6777 Quinto
LakeCadagnoisacrenogenicmeromicticlakelocatedinthecatchmentareaofadolomiteveinrichingypsuminthePioraValley inthesouthernAlpsofSwitzerland.This lake ischaracterizedbyacompactchemoclineat12mdepthwithhighconcentrationsof sulfate, steepgradientsofoxygen, sulfideand lightanda turbiditymaximumthat correlates to largenumbersofbacteriamostlybelongingtoanerobicphototrophicsulfurbacteriaandsulfatereducingbacteria.Populationanalysesinwatersamplesobtainedfromthechemoclinehavebeenperformedregularlyduringthelast20yearsusingmo-lecularmethodsaswellascultivationtechniques.The16SrDNAbasedclonelibraryobtainedfromsamplesofthemonimo-limnionandtheanoxicsedimentsofthemeromicticLakeCadagnoallowedforthedevelopmentofspecificoligonucleotideprobesandaccurateFISH(fluorescentin situhybridization)distributionanalysisofbacterialpopulations.Phototrophicsul-furbacteria(Lamprocystis, Thiodictyon)formingsyntrophicaggregateswithsulfatereducingbacteria(Desulfocapsa)dominatedthechemoclinewhereasmembersofthegenusDesulfomonilewereprominentinthemonimolimnionandinthefirstcenti-
49
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
smetersofthesediments.IndeepersedimentlayersmethanogenicarchaeaandSRBweredetectedbyFISH.Moreover,inthechemocline,spatio-temporalanalysisofbacterialpopulationsover2decadesrevealedaninitialdominanceof Chromatiaceae (C. okenii, Lamprocystis, Thiodictyon), after 2001, a clonal population of Chlorobium clathratiforme becamedominant.Thismajorchangeincommunitystructureinthechemoclinewasprobablyduetoextremeclimaticeventsinautumnoftheyears1999and2000causingdeepmixingofthewaterbodywhichwereaccompaniedbychangesinprofilesof turbidity andphotosynthetically available radiation, aswell as for sulfide concentrations and light intensity.Overall,thesefindingssuggestthatthetemporarydisruptionofthechemoclinemayhavealteredenvironmentalnichesandpopula-tionsinsubsequentyears.
REFERENCES:Tonollaetal.(1998)DocumentaIst.ital.Idrobiol.63:31-44.Bensadounetal.(1998)Doc.Ist.ital.Idrobiol.63:45-51.Tonollaetal.(1999)Appl.Environ.Microbiol.65:1325-1330Tonollaetal.(2000)Appl.Environ.Microbiol.66:820-824.Tonollaetal.(2003)FEMSMicrobiol.Ecol.43:89-98.Peduzzietal.(2003)FEMSMicrobiol.Ecol.45:29-37.Peduzzietal.(2003)Aquat.Microb.Ecol.30:295-302.Tonollaetal.(2004)J.Limnol.63(2):157-166.TonollaM.,etal..(2005)FEMSMicrobiologyEcology53:235–244.TonollaM.etal.(2005)Appl.Environ.Microbiol.71:3544-3550.DecristophorisP.M.A.etal.(2009)J.Limnol.,68(1):16-24.GregersenL.H.etal.(2009Jul1.[Epubaheadofprint])FEMSMicrobiologyEcology
1.40
Dissolved inorganic carbon and its stable isotope composition as a tracer of geo-, bio-, and anthropogenic sources of carbon
VennemannTorsten*,FontanaDaniela*,PaychereSophie*,AmbadiangPierre*,PiffarerioRaffaella*,andFavreLaurie*.
*Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Université de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Theconcentrationandcarbonisotopecompositionofdissolvedinorganiccarbon(DIC),inadditiontotheoxygenandhydro-genisotopecompositionsofwateraswellasthemajordissolvedcationsandanionshavebeenanalyzedseasonallyforseve-ralrivers,lakes,damsusedassourcesforhydroelectricenergy,andeffluentsfromanumberofwastewatertreatmentplants(WWT)inWesternSwitzerland.TheaimistoevaluatetheDICanditsisotopiccompositionasatracerforthegeologic,bio-logicandanthropogeniccontributionsofcarbontotheriversandlakes.
TheupperreachesoftheRhoneandtheSarinetypicallyhaveAlpinecatchmentscharacterizedbythinornosoilcoverswithonlysparsevegetation.Glacialmeltwatersandsurfacerunoffmakeupthebulkofthewatersourcesintheirupperreaches.Furtherdownstreamothertributaries,themselvesoftenbeingmeltwaterfedbutmanyalsobeingexploitedforhydroelec-tricpowerandthuswithanumberofdamsalongtheircourse,jointheserivers.Inaddition,thevegetationandsoilcoverincreasesdownstreaminparallelwiththeagriculturalexploitation,populationdensity,andthenumberofWWTplantsthatgenerallypasstheirtreatedwastewatersdirectlyintotherivers.Incontrast,riversdrainingtheJuramountainsdonothaveaglacialmeltwatersource,noraretheremajorhydroelectricsystemscoupledtotheriversystemsinvestigated.
Thedifferenceingeologyofthecatchmentaswellasthesoilcoverthicknessandhencebiologicactivityinthesoilarere-flectedbytheCisotopecompositionoftheDIC.δ13Cvaluesareashighas–2.5‰intheuppersourcereachesoftheRhoneandtheSarine,reflectingpredominantuptakeofcarbonfromatmosphericCO
2.Furtherdownstream,δ13Cvaluesdecrease
towards–5to–11.5‰,compatiblewithahigherinputofsoil-,plant-derivedCO2.Theδ13CvaluesofDICarehigher(–5to–
8.5‰)ifcarbonaterelativetosilicaterocksdominatethecatchment,unlesstheagriculturalactivityisintense.Thelatteristhecasefortheriversdrainingthelargelycarbonate-dominatedJura(forexampletheVenoge),whichhaveδ13Cvaluesofbetween–11to–13‰.Theδ13Cvaluesarealsohigherforalllakesanddamsalongtherivers,indicatinganadditionalex-changewithatmosphericCO
2forwatermassesexposedtotheatmospherefor longerperiods.Forsmaller lakes,theδ13C
valuescorrespondtothoseoftheriverine inputsthough.For larger lakestheδ13CvaluesoftheDICmayalsobeusedastracersofthemixingprocessesbetweenriverineinputandthelake(Fig.1).
50Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Theδ13Cvaluesintheriversaregenerallylowerinwinterandspringcomparedtosummerandfall,indicatingahigherbio-logicalactivitywithinthewatercolumnduringthewarmerperiods.Thedifferencesaremostnotableindamsandlakes,whereverticalprofilesarealsowell-establishedwithintheupper5to10mofthewatercolumnasaresultofincreasingphotosynthesisduringthewarmerperiods(Fig.1).
ContributionsoforganiccarbonfromWWTplantsareclearlymarkedby0.5to3‰lowerδ13CvaluesforDICdirectlydown-streamoftheeffluents,withthetreatedwastewatershavingvaluesthatmaybeaslowas–27‰.SuchsourcesmayalsoclearlybeexpressedbydifferencesinH-andO-isotopecompositionsofthewatersrelativetotheriverorlakewaters,aswellastheirsodium,potassiumandnitratecontents,aswellastheisotopiccompositionofthelatter.
Figure1:δ13CvaluesofDICinadepthprofileinthedeepestpartofLakeGeneva(approximatelyinthecenterofthelake).Notethehigh
valuesatthesurfaceduringthesummer(July2005profile)comparedtothewinter(March2005profile)typicallyindicatingthebiopro-
ductivityinthephoticzoneduringsummer.Highervaluesatdepthsof50to100mrepresentmixturesoftheRhonewaterrichin13Cde-
scendingtothesedepthswithinthelake,threemonthsafteracompleteoverturnofthelakeattheendofFebruary.
51
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.41
High-resolution temperature measurements at the river – groundwater interface: Quantification of seepage rates using fiber-optic Distributed Temperature Sensing
T.Vogt*,P.Schneider*,M.Schirmer*,O.A.Cirpka**
* Eawag - Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Überlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Dübendorf ([email protected])** University of Tübingen, Center for Applied Geoscience, Sigwartstr. 10, D-72076 Tübingen
Inrecentyears,thetransitionzonebetweensurfacewaterbodiesandgroundwater,knownasthehyporheiczone,hasbeenidentifiedascrucialfortheecologicalstatusoftheopen-waterbodyandthequalityofgroundwater.Thehyporheicexchangeprocessesvarybothintimeandspace.Fortheassessmentofwaterqualityofbothwaterbodiesreliablemodelsandmeasure-mentsoftheexchangeratesandtheirvariabilityareneeded.
Awiderangeofmethodsandmaterialsexisttoestimatewaterfluxesbetweensurfacewaterandgroundwater.Duetoad-vancesinsensortechniqueanddataloggers,workonheatasatracerinhydrologicalsystemshasincreasedrecently,espe-ciallywithfocusonsurfacewater–groundwaterinteraction.AnewpromisingmethodisDistributedTemperatureSensing(DTS).DTSisbasedonthetemperaturedependenceofRamanscattering.Lightfromalaserpulseisscatteredalonganopti-calfibreofuptoseveralkmlength,whichisthesensoroftheDTSsystem.Bysamplingtheback-scatteredlightwithhightemporalresolution,thetemperaturealongthefibrecanbemeasuredwithhighaccuracy(0.1K)andhighspatialresolution(1m).WeusedDTSatatestsideatRiverThurinNorth-EastSwitzerland(TG).Here,theriverislosing.
Forestimationofseepagerateswemeasuredhighlyresolvedverticaltemperatureprofilesintheriverbed.Tothisend,wewrappedanopticalfibrearoundapiezometertubeandmeasuredthetemperaturedistributionalongthefibre.Duetothewrapping,weobtainedaverticalresolutionofapproximately5mm.WeanalyzedthetemperaturetimeseriesbymeansofDynamicHarmonicRegressionaspresentedbyKeeryetal.(2007).Fromthetraveltimeandattenuationofthediurnalsignal,weestimatedtheapparentvelocityanddiffusivityoftemperaturepropagation,whichthencanbeusedtoquantifyinfiltra-tionrates.Aparticularstrengthofthenewmeasurementtechniquelies inthehighspatialandtemporalresolution,en-ablingustodetectnon-uniformityandtemporalchangesinverticalwaterfluxes.
REFERENCESJ.Keery,A.Binley,N.CrookandJ.W.N.Smith(2007)Temporalandspatialvariabilityofgroundwater–surfacewaterfluxes:
Developmentandapplicationofananalyticalmethodusingtemperaturetimeseries,JournalofHydrology,336,1-16.
52Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 1.42
Natural springs – the living passage between groundwater and surface water
VonFumettiStefanie*,GusichValeria*&NagelPeter*
*Institut für Biogeographie (NLU), Universität Basel, St. Johanns-Vorstadt 10, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])
Naturalspringsareuniqueecosystemsthatprovidespecificabioticconditions,andtheyarestepping-stonesbetweenground-waterandsurfacewater.Theyappearinthelandscapeinvariousformsandareespeciallyobviousinalpineregions.Springsarehabitatsformanyfreshwaterorganisms,whichpartlyshowastrongadaptationtothespecificconditionsinsprings.AsanalpinecountrySwitzerlandisrichofsprings,butnotmanyarestillinanaturaloratleastnearnaturalcondition.Despitetheirimportanceasuniquehabitatsanddespitetheirendangeredsituationtheywerenotwellstudieduntilafewyearsago.At the Institute of Biogeography from the University of Basel we investigate natural springs in the northern part ofSwitzerlandandadjacentregions.Thedistributionofthespringfaunaandtheinfluenceofabioticparameters,especiallydischarge,arethemaintopicsofourresearch.Afirstapproachtoafaunisticspringtypologyshowsdifferencesbetweenspringsbasedonthedominantfeedinghabitsofthemacrozoobenthicspecies.Theyarerelatedtoabioticparameterslikesubstratecomposition.Ourgoalisaspringtypologyforthewholecountrybasedonfaunisticdata.Andalsothecolonisationofspringsisanimportantpartofourresearch.Inaone-yearfieldexperimentinartificialspringsweinvestigatedthecolo-nisationrateandthepreferencesofdifferentsubstratesbymacrozoobenthicorganisms.Mesoscaleanalysesshowthatthecolonisationoccursrapidlyfromtheadjacentheadwaterandthattheorganismspreferdifferentsubstratetypesfortheirsettlement.
1.43
Porewater as an archive of the palaeo-hydrogeology during the Holocene and Pleistocene
WaberH.Niklaus
Institute of Geological Sciences, Rock–Water Interaction Group, University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1-3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])
Fracturedrockscomprisetwodifferenthydraulicregimes:Thefirstregimeconstitutesthewater-conductingzonesrelatedtoregionaland/orlocalfracturenetworkswheregroundwaterflowtakesplace.Itischaracterisedbyahydraulictransmissi-vityofmostlyabove10-9m2/sandsolutetransporttakesplacebyadvection.Thesecondregimeconstitutesthelowpermeablerockmatrixwiththeporewaterresidinginitsconnectedporespace.Here,thehydraulictransmissivityislowtoverylow(<<10-10m2/s)andsolutetransportisincreasinglydominatedbydiffusion.Themassofporewaterpresentintherockmatrixis,however,largerthaninthefracturenetworkevenincrystallinerockswithaconnectedporosityoflessthan1Vol.%.
Porewaterintherockmatrixandgroundwaterinthefracturenetworkalwaystendtoreachchemicalandisotopicequilibri-um.Ifsolutetransportintherockmatrixcanbeshowntooccurbydiffusion,thenachemicalandisotopicsignatureesta-blishedintheporewateratacertaintimemightbepreservedovergeologictimeperiods.Thus,porewatermayactasanar-chiveofthepastfracturegroundwatercomposition(s)andthereforeofthepalaeo-hydrogeologicalhistoryofasite.Thede-greeofthepreservationofsuchsignaturesdependson:1)thedistanceoftheporewatersamplefromthenearestwater-con-ductingfractureinthreedimensions,2)thesolutetransportpropertiesoftherock(i.e.diffusioncoefficient,porosity),and3)theperiodofconstantboundaryconditions(i.e.constantfracturegroundwatercomposition).ThefrequentclimaticandhydrogeologicchangesduringtheHoloceneandPleistoceneandrelatedcompositionalchangesinthefracturegroundwaterresultedinsuperimposedsignaturesintheporewater.Thesecanbeunravelledtoalargedegreebytheinvestigationofdif-ferent,largelyindependentnaturaltracersintheporewater.
PorewateringraniticandmonzodioriticrocksfromLaxemar-Oskarshamn,centralSweden,areofdifferentchemicalandisotopiccompositioninbedrockcharacterisedbyhightransmissivityandahighfrequencyofwater-conductingfracturesatshallowtointermediatedepth(0-400mb.s.l.),andbedrockcharacterisedbylowtransmissivityandalowfrequencyofwater-conductingfracturesatgreaterdepth(400-1000mb.s.l.).Inthemoretransmissive,shallowerinterval,porewaterisofage-neralNa-HCO
3chemicaltypewithaCl-concentrationoflessthan1g/kgH
2O.Theoxygenandhydrogenisotopecomposition
indicatesaformationfrommeteoricinfiltrationunderdifferentclimaticconditions.Combinedwiththedistancebetweenporewatersampleandnearestwater-conductingfractureintheboreholeandthequantitativemodellingofthenaturaltra-cerprofiles(Cl-,δ18O,δ2H)sampledathighresolutioninoneoftheboreholes,theporewatersignaturesinthefirstfewmetresfromafracturemaybeexplainedintermsofexchangewithHolocenefracturegroundwaterofpresent-daytype,ofHolocene
53
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sthermalmaximumtype(atabout7-4kaBP)andofglacial(lateWeichselian)orglacio-lacustrine(BalticIceLake,15-11.5kaBP;AncylusLake,10.8-9.5kaBP)type.Exchangewithfracturegroundwatercomposedofpresent-daybrackishwateroftheBalticSeaislimitedandabsentfortheearlierBalticSeastages(Yoldia,11.5-10.8kaBP;salineLittorina,8.5-7kaBP).Fartherawayfromwater-conductingfractures,Na-HCO
3typeporewatersignatureswithlowCl-concentrationsindicateanevolution
fromPleistocenefracturegroundwaterofwarmclimateorigin(possiblyEemianInterglacial)andcoldclimateperiods(earlyWeichselianorolder).Coldclimateinfluencefromthelastglaciationwithδ18Ovaluesaround-14‰VSMOWoccursbetweenabout135-350mdepthanddowntoabout500mdepthdependingonborehole.
AtintermediatedepthlevelsbelowtheNa-HCO3typeporewaterachangetohighermineralisedporewaterofageneralNa-
Ca-SO4andCa-Na-SO
4chemicaltypeoccurs.Dependingonboreholelocationthisporewatertypeoccursfromabout430m
and620mdepthoverarestrictedintervalofabout120m.Thechangecoincideswithamarkeddecreaseintransmissivity,inthefrequencyofwater-conductingfeaturesandthetransitionzonefromÄvrögranite toquartzmonzodiorite.HighlyvariableCl-concentrations(2.5to7.6g/kgH
2O)andwaterisotopecompositions(δ18Oabout-2‰to-13‰VSMOW)areassocia-
tedwithhighconcentrationsofCa2+andSO42-uptogypsumsaturation.Chemicalandisotopiccompositionoftheseporewa-
tertypescannotbeexplainedbyinteractionwithaknowntypeoffracturegroundwaterandmoreadvancedrock-waterin-teraction.Theyappeartohaveformedfrominteractionwithcryogenicbrinesthatformedduringpermafrostconditionsandwhichmigrateddownwardsinthefracturesbybuoyancyeffects.Thelargedistancetothenearestwater-conductingfractureofthisporewatertypesuggeststhatthesesignatureshavebeenestablishedbeforetheLastGlacialMaximum.
AtgreaterdepththereoccuragainmorediluteporewatersofNa-HCO3typeandNa-Ca-Cl-(HCO
3)type.Here,Cl-contentsvary
betweenabout0.5to3g/kgH2Oandassociatedδ18Ovaluesofbetweenabout-8‰to-11‰VSMOW.Porewatersbelow820m
arethenofaNa-Ca-CltypewithCl-concentrationsofmorethan8g/kgH2O,butlowSO
42-concentrationsandanoxygeniso-
topecompositiongenerallyenrichedin18Ocomparedtothemoreshallowporewaters.Attheselow-transmissivitydepths,theporewatersdisplaycomplex,superimposedsignaturesthatcannotberesolvedbasedonthepresentdata.Inthedeepestsamples,however,acomponentofadeepsalinebrineseemstobepresentsimilarasobservedinfracturesatevengreaterdepth.
Thedataindicatethatthepalaeo-hydrogeologicalevolutionofasiteindeedcanbere-constructedbasedonporewaterdata.Inaddition,signaturesnolongerpresentinthefracturegroundwaterscanbeidentified.Inthecaseofcryogenicbrinesthatformedduringpermafrostconditions,thisisofspecialimportancewithintheframeworkofthelong-termsafetyassessmentofadeepgeologicrepositoryforradioactivewaste.
1.44
In-situ Remediation of Polluted Groundwater: A Transdisciplinary Approach
ChristophWanner*,FranzSchenker**&UrsEggenberger*
*Institut für Geologie, Baltzerstr. 1+3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])**Geologische Beratungen SCHENKER KORNER + PARTNER GmbH, Büttenenhalde 42, CH-6006 Luzern ([email protected])
Carelesshandlingofenvironmentallyhazardoussubstancesandwasteshasleftitsmarkinthegeologicalunderground.Ifsubstanceslikepersistentorganiccompoundsorheavymetalsfromcontaminatedsitesmigrateintothegroundwater,animmediateandsustainablesuppressionofthesourceisrequired.However,inmostcasesthegroundwaterinitsdownstreamflowwillstaycontaminatedoveralongtime.Ondutyofthesocietyandtheenvironmenttoprovideforsafewater,there-mediationofpollutedgroundwaterisbothanessentialandambitioustask.
Consultantgeologistsincooperationwithchemicallaboratoriesgenerallyarekeennowinassessingthetype,amountanddistributionofcontaminants ingroundwater.Butafteronedecadeof thecommitmentby lawtoremediate the“sinsofyesterday”,thescientificandtechnicalknowledgeonapprovedprocedurestocleanspoiledgroundwaterisstillpoor.Ontheonehandresearchinstitutesmostlyexperienceatlaboratoryscaleonly.Attheotherhand,thepartyresponsibleforacon-taminatedgroundwaterplumeisinterestedinfastsolutions,andnotinmakingexpensiveattemptswithoutaguarantyofalonglastingachievement.Researchersfromtheuniversityandprofessionalsfromconsultingcompaniescancomplementoneanotherincreatingnewtechnologies.Research,developmentandimplementationofnewtechnologiescanprofitfrom“theNineLawsofGodgover-ningtheincubationofsomethingfromnothing”(Kelly,1995).Takingasanexampletheprojecttoreducethechargeofhe-
54Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es xavalentchromiumwithpermeablereactivewalls(PRB),thewayofasuccessfulcooperationusingatransdisciplinaryap-
proach(Hermanns-Stengele&Schenker,2000)willbedemonstrated.
IndesigningaPRBasapassiveremediationmethodthecrucialaspectsarewhat to takeas thereactivematerialandofcoursehowwellthecontaminantsaretreatedaftertheinstallationofsuchaPRB.BatchandcolumnexperimentsperformedinordertochosethebestavailableironshavingsforthePRBThunshowedthatshavingswithacarboncontentofapproximately4%haveverygoodpropertiesconcerningthereductionofhexavalentchro-mium.Interestinglylargedifferencesinthereactionratesamongvarioustypesofironshavingswereobserved.Lookingatthevariousshavingsunderthescanningelectronmicroscopewecameupwiththeconclusionthatreactionratesarehighlycorrelatedwiththenatureofthecarboninclusionswithintheironmatrixoftheshavings.Inordertoestimatethesuccessoffuturebarrieroperationsgeochemicalmodelsarecheapandpowerfultools(Steefel,2005).UsingthedataofthelabexperimentsthegeochemicalreactivetransportmodelandreactionnetworkofMayeretal.(2001)wascalibratedusingthemodelingsoftwareCrunchflow(Steefel,2005).Thecalibratedmodelwasusedtosimulatethehy-drodynamicsandhydrogeochemistrywithinthedoublepile-arrayofthebarrierin2D.Examplesofmodeloutcomesareil-lustratedinfigure1.
ThemodellingworkclearlypointsoutthatthelimitingfactorsintheperformanceofthePRBarethegroundwaterflowvelocity,thepermeabilityofthepilesandthegroundwaterchemistry.
Figure1.Illustrationsof2DmodelcalculationsofthePRBsiteThun:Modelsetupintermsofporosityintheupperleftpicture,aqueous
Fe2+concentrations(mol/l)upperright,greenrustprecipitationvolumes(vol%)bottomleftandaqueousCrVIconcentrations(mol/l)bottom
right.
REFERENCESHermanns-Stengele,R.&Schenker,F.2000:Groundwater-Remediationwithpermeablereactivewalls–ATransdisciplinary
Approachtothesustainableuseofthemostimportantnaturalressource.In:Transdisciplinarity:JointProblem-SolvingamongScience,TechnologyandSociety.ProceedingsoftheInternationalTransdisciplinarity2000Conference,590-593.
Kelly, K. (1995): Out of Control: TheNew Biology ofMachines, Social Systems and the EconomicWorld. Reading/Massachusetts:Addison-Wesley.
Mayer,U. Blowes,D.& FrindE. 2001: Reactive transportmodeling of an in situ reactive barrier for the treatment ofhexavalentchromium.WaterResourcesResearch38,3091-3103.
SteefelC.2001:Softwareformodelingmulticomponent,multidimensionalreactivetransport.LawrenceLivermoreNationalLaboratory,Livermore,Ca.UCRL-MA-143182.
Steefel,C.DePaolo,D.&LichtnerP.2005:Reactivetransportmodeling:AnessentialtoolandanewresearchapproachfortheEarthsciences.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters240,539–558.
55
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s1.45
On the physical hydrology of hydrothermal systems at mid-ocean ridges
PhilippWeis*,ThomasDriesner*,DimCoumou**,&ChristophA.Heinrich*
* Institute of Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, ETH Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])** Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, Germany
Fluid evolution andmigration inmagmatic hydrothermal systems strongly depend on the physical properties ofwater.Withinthepressureandtemperaturerangegivenbyaspecificgeologicsetting,fluidpropertieslikedensityandviscosityvarynon-linearlybyordersofmagnitude(DriesnerandHeinrich,2007).
Magmatism atmid-ocean-ridges is predominantly basaltic and acts as a heat source for hydrothermal convection cells.Seawaterpercolatesthroughtheoceanfloorintothesubsurface,isheatednearthemagmachamber,travelsupward,andventsattheoceanfloor,eventuallyformingblacksmokerfields.Numericalsimulationsin3Dwithpurewaterandahomogeneouspermeabilityhaveshownthatthesystemnaturallyformsregularly-spacedpipe-likeupflowzoneswhichiswell-supportedbymeasurementsandobservations(Coumouetal.,2008).Thesesimulationsfurtherrevealedthatmostofthedownflowoccursintheimmediatevicinityoftheupflowzonewherefluidsareheatedtoabout200°C.Comparedtothecolderfluidsatlargerdistancefromtheaxis,theirviscosityislowerbyoneorderofmagnitudewhiletheyarestillrelativelydensehencemaximizingdownwardfluidtransport.Incombinationwiththe~400°Cfluidsoftheupflowzone,thisleadstoamassandenergyfluxoptimization(seealsoDriesneretal.,thisvolume).
Introducinggeologicalstructurestothemodelgeometryaddsfurthercomplexitytothesystembutpreservesthefirstorderprincipledescribedabove.Figure1showsconvectionatamid-oceanridgesystemwithadeepergabbroicpartoverlainbyabasalticlayerofhigherpermeability.Thesimulationsshowthatasecondaryconvectioncellestablisheswithinthehighlypermeablebasaltlayerresultinginamoreefficientcoolingoftheupperpartoftheupflowzone.Normalfaultswithintheoceaniccrustnear theridgeaxisareoftenreferred toasconduits forenhancedup-ordownflow (Fisher,1998).Firstnu-mericalsimulationsintroducingnormalfaultsasheterogeneitieswithinthepermeabilitystructureofthemodelgeometryhavebeenconducted.Downflowvelocities similar to theonesdescribedaboveonlydeveloped in relativelywidenormalfaults(50m)thathaveahighpermeabilitycontrasttothesurroundingrock(uptotwoordersofmagnitude)andarelocatedveryclosetotheridgeaxis.
Figure1.Convectionatmid-ocean-ridgesself-organizesintohotpipe-likeupflowzones(a).Downflowconcentratesintheimmediatevici-
nityoftheupflowzoneasshownbytheporevelocitiesoftheselectedstreamlines(b).Themodelgeometrydescribesa1kmdeeppieceof
oceaniccrust(3x4km2).Constantfluidpressureatthetopboundaryrepresentsawaterdepthof2.5kmandabell-shapedheatfluxatthe
bottomboundaryofatotalof350MW/kmrepresentsanaxialmagmachamberatdepth.Thepermeabilitystructureconsistsofalower
gabbroiclayer(k=3x10-14m2)overlainbya200mthickbasalticlayer(k=10-12m2).Figure1bisa1km3excerptofFigure1a.
56Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es REFERENCES
Coumou,D.,T.Driesner,P.Weis,andC.A.Heinrich(2009),Phase-separation,BrineFormationandSalinityVariationatBlackSmokerHydrothermalSystems,J.Geophys.Res.,114,B03212.
Coumou,D.,T.DriesnerandC.A.Heinrich (2008),Thestructureanddynamicsofmid-oceanridgehydrothermalsystems,Science,321,1825-1828.
Driesner,T.,andC.A.Heinrich(2007),ThesystemH2O-NaCl.PartI:Correlationformulaeforphaserelationsintemperature-pressure-compositionspacefrom0to1000degreesC,0to5000bar,and0to1X-NaCl,GeochimicaEtCosmochimicaActa,71,4880-4901.
Fisher,A.(1998),Permeabiltywithinbasalticoceaniccrust,Rev.Geophys.36,143-182.
1.46
One lake, two countries and a lot of methane - the concept for a viable extraction of an unusual resource
AlfredWüest*,**,LukasJarc*,**,NatachaPasche*,**&MartinSchmid*
*Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Surface Waters - Research and Management, CH-6047 Kastanienbaum, Switzerland ([email protected])** Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Institute of Biogeochemistry and Pollutant Dynamics, CH-8092 Zürich, Switzerland
The485mdeepLakeKivu(Rwanda,DRCongo)isamongthemostfascinatinglakesonearth.Notonlydoesithostaspecta-culartemperature-salinitystaircaseofmorethan300interface-layers,italsocontains~60km3ofmethaneand~300km3ofcarbondioxide and is permanently density-stratified by salty, carbondioxide-richwater released by sub-aquatic springs.Thosespringsandtheirchemicalcompositionaffectthelakestratification.Especially,thelake-internalnutrientupwelling,stronglydependingonthespringdischarges,iscrucialforalgaegrowthandthesubsequentmethaneproductioninthedeepwaters.Overthecenturies,methanehasaccumulatedtoanamount,whichcanbeeconomicallyexploited,butwhichalsoposesarisk(limniceruptionlikeinLakeNyos)totheriparian~2millionpeople.Toavoidbuilding-upofsuchariskofgaseruption,thetwogovernmentshavedecidedtoexploitthemethane,worthmorethan$20billions.
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10
22 23 24 25 26 27Temperature (ºC)
0 1 2 3 4 5 6Salinity (g L-1)
Depth (m)
temperature salinity CO
2 concentration
CH4 concentration
Gas concentrations (mol L-1)
Figure1.Verticalprofilesoftemperature,salinity,CH4andCO
2,asobservedinFebruary2004(Schmidetal.2005).Allmajorwaterconsti-
tuentsareincreasingwithdepthduetothedischargeofdeepsub-aquaticsprings.
57
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sThetalkwillfocusonfindingaextractionconcept,which(i)lowerstheriskofagaseruptionfromthelake,(ii)isenviron-mental-friendlyandconservesthelake’secologicalintegrityand(iii)maximizestheeconomicbenefitatthesametime.
REFERENCESLorkeA.,TietzeK.,HalbwachsM.,WüestA.(2004)ResponseofLakeKivustratificationtolavainflowandclimatewarming.
LimnologyandOceanography49(3),778-783.MuvundjaF.A.,PascheN.,BugenyiF.W.B.,IsumbishoMwapu,MüllerB.,NamugizeJ-N.,RintaP.,SchmidM.,StierliR.,Wüest
A. (2009) Balancingnutrient inputs to LakeKivu. Journal ofGreat LakesResearch 35 (2009) 406–418, doi:10.1016/j.jglr.2009.06.002
PascheN.,DinkelC.,Müller B., SchmidM.,WüestA.,Wehrli B. (2009) Physical andbiogeochemical limits to internalnutrientloadingofmeromicticLakeKivu.LimnologyandOceanography,54(6),2009,1863–1873.
SchmidM.,HalbwachsM.,WehrliB.,WüestA. (2005)WeakmixinginLakeKivu:Newinsights indicate increasingriskofuncontrolledgaseruption.GeochemistryGeophysicsGeosystems6,Q07009,doi:10.1029/2004GC000892
SchmidM.,TietzeK.,HalbwachsM.,LorkeA.,McGinnisD.F.,WüestA.(2003)HowhazardousisthegasaccumulationinLakeKivu?ArgumentsforariskassessmentinlightoftheNyiragongoVolcanoEruptionof2002.ActaVulcanologica15(1-2),115-122.
58Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2. Structural Geology, Tectonics and GeodynamicsNeil Mancktelow, Guido Schreurs, Paul Tackley
Swiss Tectonics Studies Group of the Swiss Geological Society
2.1 BagheriS.,ArefNejadM.,YabalouiM.:TectonichistoryoftheLutBlockinNehbandanarea,EasternIran
2.2 BagheriS.,BuchsD.,SalariT.,NabaviM.:NeogenetectonicsoftheAnarakareainCentralIran
2.3 BagheriS.,StampfliG.M.,MoixP.,BakhshiM.R.:Khurplatform:TectonicevolutionofapartoftheNeo-Tethyanback-arcbasininCentralIran
2.4 BejaouiJ.,SellamiA.:TectoniccontrolofPb-Zn-Ba-(Sr)depositatOuedJebs-KefLasfar,northernTunisia
2.5 BuckinghamT.,HerweghM.,PfiffnerO.A.: PolymineralicMylonitesGeneratedbyChemo-MechanicalMixing:TheGlarusThrustasanExample
2.6 CammaranoF.,PaulTackleyP.,NakagawaT.,StixrudeL.,Lithgow-Bertelloni,C.,XuW.,RomanowiczB.:GeologyandgeochronologyoftheIlobatholithofsoutherncoastalPeru
2.7 CardelloG.L.,BernoulliD.,DoglioniC.:TectonicsofthewesternGranSassod’Italia(CentralApennines)
2.8 CardelloG.L.,MancktelowN.:NeogenetranstensionaltectonicevolutionofthecentralHelveticnappes:preliminaryresults
2.9 Castelltort S., Nagel S., Mouthereau F., Tien-shun L.A.,Wetzel A., Kaus B.J.P,Willett S.D., Shao-Ping C.,Wei-Yi C.:Sedimentology of Early Pliocene Sandstones In the South-Western Taiwan Foreland: Implications for BasinPhysiographyattheOnsetofCollision.
2.10 CrameriF.,KausB.J.P.,TackleyP.J.:One-sidedsubductioninself-consistentmodelsofglobalmantleconvection:theimportanceofafreesurfaceandaweakcrustallayer
2.11 CrameriF.,KausB.J.P.,TackleyP.J.:Parametersthatcontroltheformationoflithospheric-scaleshearzones
2.12 DietrichV.J.,GartzosE.:TwinmeteoriteimpactcratersinThessaly(CentralGreece)ofHoloceneage
2.13 DuretzT.,GeryaT.V.:Rheologicalmechanisms,topographicresponse,andgeodynamicregimesassociatedwithslabbreakoff
2.14 EgliD.,MancktelowN.:NewstructuralfielddatafromSEoftheMontBlancmassifandpreliminaryconstraintsonmodelsofexhumation
2.15 FrehnerM.,SchmalholzS.M.:ReflectionandscatteringofStoneleyguidedwavesatthetipsoffluid-filledfractures
2.16 GasserD.,BruandE.,StüweK.:Exhumationofametamorphiccomplexinastrike-slipsetting:observationsfromtheChugachMetamorphicComplex(CMC),southernAlaska
2.17 GasserD.,MancktelowN.:TheRezlifaultzone:Fieldobservationsfromamajoroblique-slipfaultintheRawildepres-sion,WesternSwitzerland
2.18 GolabekG.,GeryaT.,KausB.,ZietheR.,MollG.-P.,TackleyP.J.:Influenceofrheologyandgiantimpactorsontheter-restrialcoreformation
2.19 GolabekG.,KellerT.,GeryaT.,Connolly J.: Towards self-consistentmodellingof theMartiandichotomy:Coupledmodelsofsimultaneouscoreandcrustformation
2.20 GuerraI.,StockliD.,CorfuF.,NegroF.,MancktelowN.,VennemannT.:IntegratedU/Pb,(U-Th)/HeandoxygenstableisotopestudyonzirconofanormalfaultzoneofthewesternAlps,Switzerland
2.21 HaghipourN.,BurgJ.-P.,KoberF.,ZeilingerG.:Quaternaryfluvialpatternsonthein-landMakranaccretionarywedge(SEIRAN)
2.22 HärtelM.,HerweghM.:StrainlocalizationinquartzmylonitesoftheSimplonFault,CentralAlps
2.23 HunzikerD.,BurgJ.-P.,BouilholP.,JafarO.:Petrographyandgeochemistryofuppermantleandlowercrustofsupra-subduction(?)ophiolitesintheMakran,SEIran
2.24 IbeleT.,MatzenauerE.,MosarJ.:BrittledeformationbandsinthesandstonesoftheWesternSwissMolasseBasin
2.25 Kais,A.,OuldBaggaM.A.,AbdeljaouadS.,ZargouniF.,MercierE.: LateralFold Identification inNorthernTunisiaThrustBeltFront
2.26 KausB.J.P.,BeckerT.W.:Insightsinthedynamicsoffreesubductionfromsemi-analyticalandnumericalmodels.
59
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
2.27 KellerT.,KausB.J.P.:Numericalmodelsoffluidmigrationinatectonicallyactivecontinentalcrust
2.28 KilianR.,HeilbronnerR.,StünitzH.,HerweghM.:Flowmechanismsingraniticultramylonites
2.29 LechmannS.M.,SchmalholzS.M.,KausB.J.P.,HetényiG.:Comparingthin-sheetmodelswiththree-dimensionalnume-ricalmodelsfortheIndia-Asiacollision
2.30 Linckens J.,HerweghM.,MüntenerO.: Strain localizationand the importanceof secondphases inpolymineralicmantleshearzones
2.31 LuG.,KausB.J.P.,ZhaoL.:Numericalmodellingofcratondestruction
2.32 MadonnaC.,TisatoN.,BoutareaudS.,ArtmanB.,BurliniL.: Newexperimentalapproachtomeasureseismicwaveattenuationofrocksatlowfrequency
2.33 MalatestaL.,MishinY.,Gerya,T.:TheSingularitiesofDoubleSubductionSystems
2.34 MayD.A.,KnepleyM.G.,GurnisM.:CitcomSX:RobustpreconditioninginCitcomSviaPETSc
2.35 Mejri L., RegardV., Carretier S., Brusset S., DlalaM.: Seismotectonic study inNorthern Tunisia (exemple:UtiqueStructure)
2.36 MettierR.:Numericallymodelingcurrentverticalsurfacemotionintheswissalpsfromthebottomup-Doesthegeometryoftheorogendictatehowitmoves?
2.37 MisraS.,AlmqvistB.S.G.,BurliniL.:Seismicpropertiesofmelt-generatingmetapelites
2.38 MisraS.,TumarkinaE.,BurliniL.,BurgJ.-P.:Rheologyofmetapelitesduringpartialmeltingandcrystallization
2.39 MoixP.,StampfliG.M.:Palaeotethyan,NeotethyanandPindosseriesintheLycianNappes(SWTurkey):geodynamicimplications
2.40 NagelS.,CastelltortS.,MouthereauF.,LinA.T.,WillettS.D.,KausB.J.P.:Newconstraintsonforelandbasindevelop-mentinSouth-WestTaiwanfromsequencestratigraphyandflexuremodelling
2.41 NegroF.,PelletC.-M.,BousquetR.,BeyssacO.,GuerraI.,VilsF.:ThermalstructureandmetamorphicevolutionofthePiedmont-LigurianmetasedimentsintheWestern-CentralAlps
2.42 NussbaumC.,BossartP.:InfluenceoffaultsonthedevelopmentofExcavationDamagedZone:thecaseoftheMontTerriRockLaboratory
2.43 PecM.,StünitzH.,HeilbronnerR.:Transitionfromfrictionaltoviscousdeformationingranitoidfaultgouges
2.44 PleugerJ.,MancktelowN.:StructuralobservationsfromtheInsubricfaultbetweentheValled’OssolaandValled’Orco(NWItaly)
2.45 RahnM.,WangH.:ApatiteFTdatafromtheTriassicSongpan-Garzêflysch,TibetanPlateau,NWSichuan,China
2.46 RamiA.,KahloucheS.,KhelifM.:DynamicTopographyDeterminationoftheWesternMediterraneanSeafromJason-1Data
2.47 RuizG.,SebtiS.,SaddiqiO.,NegroF.,StuartF.,FoekenJ.,StockliD.,FrizonDeLamotteD.:MirrordenudationpatternonbothsidesoftheCentralAtlantic–atraceofthePangeabreak-up?
2.48 SchenkerF.L.,BurgJ.-P.,GeryaT.: TheEasternPelagonianmetamorphiccorecomplex(northernGreece):Structureandmodels
2.49 SchmalholzS.M.:Formationoffoldnappesinductilemultilayers:insightsfromnumericalsimulations
2.50 SmitJ.,BurgJ.-P.,BrunJ.-P.:Twocriticaltapersinasinglewedge
2.51 TackleyP.,KellerT.,ArmannM.,vanHeckH.,NakagawaT.:Modellingthethermo-chemicalevolutionoftheinteriorsofMercury,Venus,Earth,Marsandsuper-Earths
2.52 ThielmannM.,KausB.J.P.:Anumericalapproachtotestlithosphericcross-sectionsforgeodynamicconsistency
2.53 ThustA.,HeilbronnerR.,StuenitzH.,TarantolaA.,HaraldB.: InteractionofH2Orichfluidinclusionsandnaturalquartzcrystalsindeformationexperiments
2.54 VandelliA.,VachardD.,MartiniR.,KozurH.W.,MoixP.,StampfliG.M.:TheLentasunitinSouthernCrete:thebaseofthePindossedimentaryseries?–Newpaleontologicalresults
2.55 VogtK.,Gerya,T.,CastroA.:ModellingofsilicicintrusionsinAlpinetypeorogens
2.56 ZhuG.,GeryaT.V.,HondaS.,TackleyP.J.,Yuen,D.A.:Influenceofthermal-chemicalbuoyancyin3-Dmantlewedge
60Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.1
Tectonic history of the Lut Block in Nehbandan area, Eastern Iran
BagheriSasan*,ArefNejadMarzieh*&YabalouiMehdi*
*Department of Geology, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Zahedan, 98135-674, Iran ([email protected])
WeprovidenewconstraintsonthetectonicdevelopmentoftheeasternborderoftheLutBlockbasedonageologicalstudyoftheNehbandanarea(easternIran).Severaltectonicunitsandformationsprovideaninsightintothecompositetectonichistoryofthearea(Fig.1).TheDeh-SalmMetamorphicComplexmayberepresentaTriassic-Jurassic(orolder)accretionarywedge.Itcomprisespelites,psammitesandcarbonatesthatenclosesomebigolistholithes,anddeformedlayersofperidotite,basiclavasandpyroclastics.Athicksiliciclasticdeposit(shownongeologicalmapsoftheareaastheShemshakFormation)tectonicallyoverliestheDeh-SalmMetamorphiccomplex.Itiscomposedoflargevolumesofdeep-seafanturbidites,whichdepositedovertheeasternmarginoftheLutBlockbetweentheTriassicandJurassic.BothofaforementionedtectonicunitsdifferentlyunderwentaHT/LPmetamorphismuptomigmatizationgradesinthelateJurassic(Mahmoodietal.,2009),whichispossiblyrelatedtothearcmagmatism.TheShahKuhGraniteislateJurassicinageandpertainstoavolcanicarcthatdevelopedbetweenthemiddeandlateJurassicalonganorthward-dipping,Neo-Tethyssubductionzone.Shallow-watervolca-no-sedimentarysequencesexposedclosetoMighanvillage(NWNehbandan)(Griffisetal.,1992)areinterpretedtopertaintothe same arc. Since early Cretaceous the platform condition has governed on the eastern edge of the Lut Block up toPaleocene.TheNehComplexincludesanophioliticmélangeandmetamorphosedmarinesedimentaryrocksSenoniantoEoceneinage(Tirruletal.,1983).Igneousrocksfoundinthemélangearecharacterizedbysupra-subductionaffinities.WeinterprettheNehComplexasasecondaccretionaryprismemplacedalongthemarginoftheLutBlock.SynchronouswiththeanticlockwiserotationofthesouthernpartoftheLutBlockabout90°sincethePaleoceneuptotheMiocenebasedonpaleomagneticinvestigationsandtheIndian/Eurasiancollisionevent,themélangeandPaleogeneflyschoftheeasternLutjuxtaposedagainsttheAfghanblock.ContinuousconvergenceandshearingbetweentheLutandAfghanBlockssincetheLateEocenecreatedalargeandintensedeformationandgranitizationinaNW-SEright-lateralshearsystem.TheyoungesttectoniceventastheresultoftheArabian/EurasiancollisionmadesomemoreN-NEshearsystemssuchastheWestNeh,NosratAbad,andKahurakstrike-slipfaultsaswellasseveralNeogenepull-apartbasinsattheeasternmarginoftheLutblockwhichmayberesultedofreactivationoftheolderfaults.Recentseismicactivitiesaretheevidenceofcontinuousmovementofthelatesttectonicregime.
REFERENCES:GriffisR,MeixnerH, JohnsG,AbedianN,BehruziA,HosseinKhanNazerN,HamzehPourB, Shahriari S,BerberianM,
SoheiliM,SahandiMR,andMohajelM;1992:DehsalmQuadranglemap,Scale1:250,000,GeologicalSurveyof Iran,Tehran.
MahmoudiS,MasoudiF,CorfuFandMehrabiB,2009MagmaticandmetamorphichistoryoftheDehSalmmetamorphicComplex,EasternLutblock,(EasternIran),fromU-Pbgeochronology,InternationalJournalofEarthSciences,inpress.
Tirrul,R.,Bell,I.R.,Griffis,R.J.andCamp,V.E.,1983.TheSiatanSuturezoneofeasternIran.GeologicalSocietyofAmericaBulletin,94:134-150.
61
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
Figure1.SimplifiedgeologicalmapoftheNehbandanarea.
2.2
Neogene tectonics of the Anarak area in Central Iran
BagheriSasan*,BuchsDavid**,SalariTayebeh*&NabaviMehdi*
*Department of Geology, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Zahedan, 98135-674, Iran**Research School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University([email protected])
The Anaraq-Jandaq Terrane comprises a metamorphic assemblage of Carboniferous to Permo-Triassic accreted oceanicisland(s)andflyschsedimentsexposedalongthePaleo-TethyssutureinCentralIran(Bagheri&Stampfli2008).TheterranehasrecordedalongtectonichistoryrelatedtoearlyaccretionaryprocessesalongaPaleo-Tethysmargin,closureofthePaleo-Tethysandexhumationinthemid-Triassic,Neo-Tethyanback-arcevolutionand,finally,Neogeneeventsthatarethefocusofthisstudy.TheAnaraq-JandaqTerraneislocatedalongtheeasternborderoftheArdakan-KashanLinethatextendsparal-leltotheZagrosThrustintheback-arcareaoftheNeo-TethysUromieh-Dokhtarvolcanicarc(Fig.1).TheLinehasbeenin-terpretedasadextralshearzoneofregionalsignificance(Bagheri,2007),butadditionalconstraintsarestillneededtobetterunderstanditsroleinthetectonicevolutionofCentralIran.
62Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s StructureseastoftheArdekan-KashanLinedisplayseveralright-steppeden-echelon,double-plungedtohalffoldsthatformhelicoidal-shappedpatternsonamapview(Fig.1).Largefoldsandsyntethicandantitheticconjugatestrike-slipfaultsoccurinbasementrocks(e.g.Sylvester,1988),whicharealsofoundintheAnarakarea.Thelargestdextralstrike-slipfaultsystemintheAnarak-JandaqareacorrespondstotheNW-SEAnarakShearZonethatishighlightedbyadismembermentofaccretedsequencesofoceanicisland(s).TheNE-SWDorunehFaultisthelargestsinistralstrike-slipfaultintheareaandinterfereswiththeAnarakShearZone.Twolargeen-echelonmega-halffoldswithnearlyE-Waxialtracehavebeenrecognizedbetweenthefaultandtheshearzone.FormationofthesefoldslikelypostdatesformationofadoubleplungeantiformfoundintheAnarakarea.TheAnarakareaischaracterizedbyarecentantiformalpop-upstructure(positiveflowerstructure)thatcom-prisesseveralupwarddivergingthrustedsheetsofmetamorphicrocksandTertiarysediments.
BasedonprecedingobservationswedividedtheAnarak-JandaqTerraneandadjacentareasintosevenstructuraldomainsthatprovideaninsightintorecenttectonics.OurpreliminaryresultssupportinterpretationoftheArdakan-KashanLineasa dextral shear zone and suggest that Neogene strain concentrated east of the line as a result to convergence betweenArabianandIranianplates.TheconvergenceledtoformationoftheAnarakpop-upstructureandtoreactivationoftheex-humationoftheAnarak-JandaqTerrane.
Figure1:NeogenefaultsandfoldstrikesintheAnarakarea.a)Tectonicsettingofthestudiedarea.b)Stereographicprojec-tionof faultplanes in thenorthernAnarakarea (polesof fault, lowerhemisphereequal-area). c)Spatialarrangementofstructuresassociatedwithanidealizedright-slipfaultafterChristie-BlickandBiddle(1985).
REFERENCES:Bagheri, S. 2007: The exotic Paleo-Tethys terrane in central Iran:newgeologicaldata fromAnarak, Jandaqandposht-e-
Badamareas,unpublishedPh.D.thesis,UniversityofLausanne,Lausanne,Switzerland,223pp.Bagheri,S.,&Stampfli,G.M.2008:TheAnarak, JandaqandPosht-e-Badammetamorphiccomplexes incentral Iran:New
geologicaldata,relationshipsandtectonicimplications,Tectonophysics451:123–155.Christie-Blick,N. andBiddle,K.T., 1985.Deformationandbasin formationalong strike-slip faults. In:K.T.Biddle andN.
Christie-Blick (Eds.), Strike-slipdeformation,basin formation, and sedimentationSocietyofEconomicPaleontologistsandMineralogistsSpecialPublication,p.1-34.
Sylvester,A.G.1988:Strike-slipfaults,GeologicalSocietyofAmericanBulletin,100:1666-1703.
63
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.3
Khur platform: Tectonic evolution of a part of the Neo-Tethyan back-arc basin in Central Iran
BagheriSasan*,StampfliGerard**,MoixPatrice**&BakhshiMohammadReza*
*Department of Geology, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, 98135-674 Zahedan, Iran**Institute of Geology and Paleontology, University of Lausanne, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland
Tectonically,theKhurregionintheNWmarginoftheCentral-EastIranianmicrocontinent(CEIM)andattheNEsideoftheUromieh-DokhtarmagmaticarcisanexceptionalareawheretheNeo-Tethyanback-arcrifting,driftingandcollisionalstageeventsarewellpreservedintheLateJurassic-Eocenedepositsandsynchronousigneousandmetamorphicrocks.Noequiva-lentsofsuchathickdepositareknownfromcentralIran(Aistovetal.,1984;Bagheri,2007).SouthoftheBiabanakfaulttheterrestrial rift-related Upper Jurassic-Lower Cretaceous Chah Palang and Noghreh Formations unconformably cover theVariscan-Eocimmerianmetamorphicrocks(BagheriandStampfli2008)andfollowedbyanenormousthickflyshoiddeposit(thepost-riftBiabanakshale).TheAr/ArformicasandU/Pbforsingle-grainzirconsrespectivelyrelatedtothemetamorphicandigneousrocksyieldtheLateJurassiccoolingages(Bagheri2007).ThesecondriftingstageoccurredsouthoftheDorunehFault;there,theJandaqigneous-metamorphiccomplexthatformedthebasementofthetiltedblocksisfoundbelowtheearlyLateCretaceoussyn-riftformationsuchasDebarsu.FewtensofkilometerstowardthenortheastintheKharTuranarea,theearlyCretaceousmildlyalkalinebasaltandorbitolinalimestonesequencestransitionallychangetotheLateCretaceouspelagicdeposits.Weconsiderthissequenceasaresultofsedimentationontheedgeofaninfantoceaniccrust.Thissequen-ceisfollowedbyLateCretaceous-PaleoceneHaftooman,FarrokhiandChupananformationsmainlycomposedofbenthictopelagicmarlandlimestoneintheKhurarea;thesenearly3000metersmarinedepositssetdownwhentheKhurplatformwas being developed during the drifting stage. The thick Eocene-Oligocene flysch of Pish Kuh accompanied by the LateCretaceous-PaleoceneophioliticmélangesofNain-Ashinaswellascalc-alkalinevolcanicrocksunconformablyoverlietheplatformsequenceneartheDorunehFault.Thisassemblagecouldbetheproductsofback-arcclosurecomparablewiththeLate Eocene-Oligocenemélange-type rock collections surrounding the CEIM (collisional stage). TheOligocene Lower RedFormationcanberegardedasthemolasseofthisclosureevent.TheKhurplatforminviewpointofstratigraphyandpaleo-ntology isvery similar to the time-equivalentbasinsuchasKopehDaghandtheNorthAfghanplatforminNE Iran; thepresenceoftheKhurplatforminCentralIrancouldbetheconsequenceofcounter-clockwiserotationoftheCEIMsincetheEocenetimecontemporaneouswiththeIndian-Eurasiancollision.
REFERENCES:Aistov, L.,Melanikov,B.,Krivyakin,B.,Morozov, L. andKiristaev,V. (Eds.), 1984.Geologyof theKhurArea (central Iran),
ExplanatorytextoftheKhurquaderanglemap1:250,000.GeologicalSurveyofIran,V/O"Technoexport"USSRMinistryofGeology,Reports,TE/No.20,1-132,Moscow.Bagheri, S. 2007: The exotic Paleo-Tethys terrane in central Iran:newgeologicaldata fromAnarak, Jandaqandposht-e-
Badamareas,unpublishedPh.D.thesis,UniversityofLausanne,Lausanne,Switzerland,223pp.Bagheri,S.,&Stampfli,G.M.2008:TheAnarak, JandaqandPosht-e-Badammetamorphiccomplexes incentral Iran:New
geologicaldata,relationshipsandtectonicimplications,Tectonophysics451:123–155.
Figure1:CrustalevolutionmodelforAtlantic-typemarginsutilizedforcrustalevolutionoftheKhurplatform.(NextPage)
64Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s
65
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.4
Tectonic control of Pb-Zn-Ba-(Sr) deposit at Oued Jebs-Kef Lasfar, nort-hern Tunisia
JaloulBEJAOUI*,AhmedSELLAMI**
* Centre National des Sciences et Technologies Nucléaires, Tunisie, [email protected] ** Office National des Mines, Tunisie
TheOuedJebs-KefLasfarPb-Zn-Ba-(Sr)mineralizedareaislocatedinthenorthernTunisia(60KmfromTunis)andformspartofthediapirzone(Fig.1)whichishighlyaffectedbyNNW–SSEtrendingtectonicdeformation(Fig.2).Thestructuralanalysiscarriedout intheOuedJebs-KefLasfardepositrevealstheexistenceofonetectonicphasecharacterizedbyaNW-SE (σ1)maximumcompressionorientationandNE-SWmaximumextensiontrending.ThePb-Zn-Ba-(Sr)mineralizationoftenfillsfracturesinthecalcitematrixwithinthemassivelimestone.ThePb-Zn-Ba-(Sr)eventmineralizedstructuresarerelatedtotheNW-SEcompressiveeventpresumablyassociatedtoAlpineconvergence(BenAyed,1986).Fieldobservationsshowsomerelativechronologycorrespondingtosuperimposedstriationsonfaultsurfacesandcross-cuttingrelationshipsbetweenstructures(faults,joints,calciteveins)(Fig.2).TheCenomanian-TuroniancarbonatesoftheOuedJebs-KefLasfarhavebeensubjecttoseveralstylolitisationprocessesandfracturingevents,beingsubsequentlyfilledbyvariouscalcitecements.Basedonthedescribedstructuresandontheregio-nalgeologicalframe,weassumethatveinswerereultedfromtheNE–SWextension.Theseextensionalstructuresarecrucialsitesforthelocalizationoffluidflowandoredeposition.SuchorebodiesemplacementsareassociatedwithdiapirsandareinterpretedastheresultofaSerravalian-Tortoniangravity-drivenfluidcirculationeventrelatedtolateAlpineconvergence(Decreeetal.,2008).
REFERENCESBenAyed,N.,. (1986)- Évolution tectoniquede l’avant-paysde laChaîneAlpinede laTunisiedudébutduMésozoïqueà
l’Actuel.ThèseDoctoratèsSciences,UniversitéParis-Sud(inédit).SophieDecrée,ChristianMarignac,ThierryDePutter,EtienneDeloule,Jean-PaulLiégeoisandDanielDemaiffe.(2008)-Pb–
ZnmineralizationinaMioceneregionalextensionalcontext:ThecaseoftheSidiDrissandtheDouahriaoredeposits(Nefzaminingdistrict,northernTunisia).
Fig1.LocationoftheOuedJebsoredepositwithinthediapirszoneinTunisianstructuralmap.
66Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s
Fig.1-(A)and(B)Cenomanianlimestoneaffectedbyaminornormalfaultassociatedwithextensionalfentescollapsedwithcalcite,(C)sub-
parallelsveinsfilledwithgalena,(D)Cenomanianlimestonewithtwoveinsgenerations-filledwithgalena.
2.5
Polymineralic Mylonites Generated by Chemo-Mechanical Mixing: The Glarus Thrust as an Example
Th.Buckingham,M.Herwegh,O.A.Pfiffner
Institute of Geological Sciences, Bern University, Switzerland
Large-scaleshearzonesoftenarecharacterizedbydifferentrocktypesinthehangingandfootwall.TheGlarusthrust,asanexample,definesasharplithologicalboundarybetweenPermianVerrucanointhehangingandInfrahelveticsedimentaryunitsinthefootwall,separatedbyalayerofLochsitencarbonate-tectonite.Thesetectonitesareusuallymixturesofsilicateandcarbonatephasessuggestingincorporationofcomponentsfromfootwallandhangingwall.Inthisway,polymineralictectonitesevolvewithongoingdeformation,becomingmoreandmore impureowing to twodifferentmixingprocesses:fluid-assisted(i)predominantlymechanicaland(ii)combinedchemo-mechanicalmixing.(i)Inthecaseofpuremechanicalmixingonthemeso-scale,brittlefracturingandtheformationofmicroshearzonesobliquetotheshearplaneallowshearingofsurroundinghostmaterial intothecarbonatetectonite.Thus,hybridtectonitesmayevolvewithviscousgranularflowinducingafurther,dispersed(seeii)mechanicalmixing.IntheLochsitencarbonate-tecto-nitesynkinematiccalciteveinssuggestthatthisprocessmusthaveoccurredunderthepresenceoffluids,whichmayhaveenhancedtheformationofthebrittlefracturesbyhydrofracturing.(ii)Chemo-mechanicalmixingisbasedonthedissolutionofmineralphasesthatareunstableinthesurroundinghostrocks.Theactivityofgranularflowinthefaultrockhastwoimportanteffects:Firsttheformationofgrain-scalecavitiespromotesthepumpingofsurroundingfluidsintothetectonite,followedbyprecipitationofsecond-phasemineralsinthenewlyfor-medcavities.Inthisprocess,homogeneousmixturesoffine-grainedcalcitematrixandsilicate(e.g.feldspars)second-phasesdevelop.Purecalcitemylonitesformedintheaforementionedsynkinematicveinsbecomecontinuouslyimpurifiedbythetwomi-xingprocesses,whichallowsgranularflow(diffusioncreep)todominatedeformation.Bothobservedprocessespersistduri-ngtheactivityofthelarge-scaleshearzoneasafunctionofsurroundingwallrocksandlocalfluidavailability.Withongoingexhumationinduced-cooling,however,strainismorelocalizedandtheactiveshearzonebecomesnarrower.Ourobserva-tionssuggestthatthesetwosuggestedmixingprocessesareactiveuntilthefinalstagesofthrustingwhenbrittleconditionsprevail.
67
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.6
The thermochemical nature of the upper mantle: an interdisciplinary approach
FabioCammarano*,PaulTackley*,TakashiNakagawa*,LarsStixrude**,CarolinaLithgow-Bertelloni**,WenboXu***,BarbaraRomanowicz****
*ETH Zürich, Institute of Geophysics, Geophysical Fluid Dynamics**University College London, Earth Sciences***Michigan University, Earth Sciences****UC Berkeley, Earth Science, Berkeley Seismological Laboratory
Mostoftheuppermantleisinaccessibletodirectsamplinganditsphysicalconditionsareindirectlydeterminedfromtheinterpretationofseismicdatabasedoninsightsfrommineralphysics.Theconjectureoftheuppermantleasawell-mixed,homogeneouscompositionhasbeenrecentlychallengedfromanewfamilyofgeodynamicmodelswhichincludesatwo-phase(MORBandHarzburgite)mixturewhichdoesnotequilibrateduringmantleevolution(e.g.,Tackleyetal.,2005).Theco-existenceofseparatedrockassemblagescannotbediscarded,indeed,consideringthelowchemicaldiffusivitiesofmantlematerials.Atthesametime,thephysicalinterpretationoflongperiodseismicwaveformsfoundthatcompositionshouldchangewithdepth(below~250km)ataglobalscale(CammaranoandRomanowicz,2007).Here,weshowtheresultsofarecentre-interpretationofglobalseismicdatabasedonastate-of-the-artmineralphysicsmodel.Themodelisbasedonknowledgeofmaterialpropertiesathightemperaturesandpressures.Inparticular,elasticpropertiesarecomputedwitharecentself-consistentthermodynamicalmodel,basedonasixoxides(NCFMAS)system.WemodeltheP,TandfrequencydependencyofanelasticitybyusingthemodelQ5(Cammaranoetal.,2003),basedontheArrheniuslawasexpectedofthermallyactivatedprocesses.Weadoptanon-linearproceduretoinvertnormalmodesforpossiblethermalorcompositionalstructuresoftheuppermantle.WeconsiderbothequilibriumassemblagesandmechanicalmixturesofMORBandHarzburgite.WefoundfurtherevidencethatcompositionshouldbecomericherinMORBcontentbelow250kmandwefoundthatonlyamechanicalmixture isabletofit theseismicdata.Standingtoourmineralphysicsmodel, therequiredcompositionalgradientwithdepthiseventoohigh(forrealisticthermalstructures).Anincreaseingrainsizewithdepthcouldplayroleaswell.Futureworkwillpushevenfurthersuchaninterdisciplinaryapproach,tryingtoextendourinterpretationtoothergeophysicalobservablesandcoupletheresultswithmodelsofthethermochemicalevolutionoftheuppermantle.
2.7
Tectonics of the western Gran Sasso d’Italia (Central Apennines)
GiovanniLucaCardello*,DanielBernoulli**&CarloDoglioni***
* ETH-Zürich, ** Basel University, *** Sapienza University, Rome,
DuringJurassic-Cretaceoustimes,theareaofthecentralApennineswaspartofalarge,Bahamian-typecarbonateplatform–basinsystem,wherebytheareaoftheGranSassowassituatedbetweenthecarbonateplatformofLatiumandtheAbruzziinthewestandthedeepbasinalareaofMarche-Umbriatotheeast.Thistransitionalareaexperienced1.EarlyJurassicriftingof theAdriaticmargin, leadingtotheopeningof theLigurianbranchofTethys;2.prolongedthermalsubsidenceof thecarbonate-platformslopeandbase-of-slopeintheJurassic–Cretaceous;3.decollementalongTriassicevaporates,thrustingand foldingduring theNeogene formationof thearcofGranSassoand4.post-nappenormal faultingpersisting to thisdate.MappingofthewesternpartoftheE–W-trendingridgeoftheGranSassod’Italia,thehighestelevationoftheApennines(2914m),hasyieldedthefollowingresults:1–TheearlyJurassicriftingeventledtothesegmentationoftheplatformslopeintostructuralhighs(CornoGrande,MonteandAcquaSanFranco)andbasins(PizzoIntermesoli,M.Corvo)assuggestedbythepronounceddifferencesinthicknessoftheearly–middleLiassicsyn-riftsediments(CorniolaFormation).WhereastheAcquaSanFrancostructuralhighinthewestwasburiedduringtheToarcian,theCornoGrandehighintheeastpersistedthroughoutMesozoictimesatleastintotheearlyTertiary.The longevityandpossible tectonicreactivationof thesubmarinetopography, inheritedfromearlyLiassicrifting,persistedwayintoJurassic–CretaceousassuggestedbythepronounceddifferencesinthicknessoftheJurassic(Corno
68Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s PiccoloFormation)andCretaceous (CefaloneandM.CorvoFormations)base-of-slopesedimentsderivedfromtheAbruzzicarbonateplatform,andsequencespunctuatedbystratigraphicgapsonthehighs.2–DuringtheTertiaryorogenyoftheApennines,theinheritedMesozoicstructuresevolvedintoN-Strendingtransferzonesbetweentheindividualthrustsandfoldsover-andunderthrustingthemoreexternalLaga unit.Theaxisofthefrontalanti-clineandtherelatedthrustofGranSassoplungewestwardwithaparalleldecreaseinshortening.Thetiplineoftheblindthrust related to the frontal fault-propagation foldbecomesdeeperandmore internalmovingwestward, according toagradualtransferofshorteningtowardtheadjacentrecess.TheE-WtrendingarmoftheGranSassoarcexperiencedacom-ponentofleft-lateraltranspressionasexpectedfromtheNE-wardpropagationofthecentralApenninesaccretionarywedge.Thepropagationof thearcoccurredduringdepositionof theMessinianLagaFlyschFormationas shownby thegrowthstructuresinthelatter.3–Thebacklimbofthefrontalfault-propagationfoldindicatesthattheentirestructurehasbeentiltedafteritsdevelop-ment.Wespeculatethatthishasbeengeneratedbyadeeperrampofabackthrust,formingatrianglezoneaffectingtheentireE-WtrendingGranSassorange.Thiswouldexplaintheabout15kmlong,regionallydiffusemonoclineoftheGranSassorangetowardtheforeland.4–Normalfaultscutacrossthepreviouslytiltedinternallimb,asshownbythecut-offangleofthefaultsrelativetobedding;Mostofthemshowmorphologicevidenceofpresent-dayactivity,butonlypartofthedisplacementobservedisduetothePleistocene-Holoceneextensionbecauseofthepoly-phaseroleofthemainfaultsystems.Accordingtosurficialfaultruptureheight,theTre SellenormalfaultasmostoftheothernormalfaultscouldgenerateearthquakesofMw>6.5.TheTre Selle faultisclearlylinkedtotheAssergi FaultbytheCampo Imperatore Faultthathastranstensivecharacteristicsandanen-échélonori-entation,functioningasalinkbetweenthetwoformerfaultsystems.
2.8
Neogene transtensional tectonic evolution of the central Helvetic nappes: preliminary results
GiovanniLucaCardello*&NeilMancktelow*
* Geologisches Institut, ETH-Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich
TheHelveticnappestackintheRawyldepressionbetweentheAarandMontBlancmassifsisaffectedbyobliquetranstensi-onalnormalfaultsdevelopedorreactivatedduringtheNeogene.OnefieldseasonofmappingofthemainfaultstructuresintheRawyl-Audannesareahasprovidedthefollowingmainresults.1.Threepreferentialorientationsnormalfaultsetsareobserved,strikingE-W,NW,andNE.2.TheNE-strikingsetdipsmainlytotheSEand,fromrelativeagerelationshipsofassociatedveins,istheoldest.PaleotectonicfeaturesexposedinPlainedesRoses,PlaineMorteandLesAudannessuggestthissetwasalreadyactiveduringCretaceoussedimentation. TheUpper Cretaceous stratigraphic sequence is influenced by paleo-escarpments that clearly define theorientationofthepaleo-faults.Thesesurfacesaremarkedinmanyplacesbykarstificationandsilicificationofthesurface,sedimentarydykesandtheonlapofbasinalyoungerformations.SomeofthesefaultshavebeensubsequentlyreactivatedduringNeogenesyn-andpost-collisionalextension.3.TheE-WandNW-strikingsystemslocallyshowaninitialmyloniticshear-zonestageoverprintedbycataclasticfaulting,especiallyinmorecompetentunitssuchastheSchrattenkalkFm.4.TheE-WandNW-strikingfaultswerebroadlycoeval,as indicatedintheRawyl-PlaineMorteareabymanyexamplesofbranchingandbendingofonesetintotheotherandbythesimilardisplacementdirections.5.CalciteslickenlinesandfibresontheNeogenefaultplanesindicatetwomainstretchingdirections.TheolderoneisWSW-directedandgenerallyplungesaround30°,whereastheyoungeroneplungestothesouth,withasteeper,mainlydip-slipmovement.6.Crosscuttingveinrelationshipsandbendingofveintailsplanesindicateacounter-clockwiserotationofthestretchingdirection,fromWSWtowardS.7.TheWSW–directedorogen-parallelstretchingissimilarinorientationtothatassociatedwiththeSimplon-RhoneFaultZoneandisprobablycoeval,implyingpossibleactivitythroughoutmuchoftheMiocene.
69
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.9
Sedimentology of Early Pliocene Sandstones in the South-Western Taiwan foreland: implications for basin physiography at the onset of col-lision.
CastelltortSébastien*,NagelStefan*,MouthereauFrédéric**,LinAndrewTien-shun***,WetzelAndreas****,KausBoris*,WillettSean*,ChiangShao-ping***&ChiuWei-Yi***
*ETH-Zürich, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zürich ([email protected])** Université Pierre et Marie Curie, Place Jussieu, 75252 Paris*** Basin Research Group, National Central University, Jonghli, Taiwan**** Geological and Paleontological Institute, University of Basel, Bernoullistr. 32, 4056 Basel
Forelandbasinsdevelopatthefrontoforogensandarefilledbysedimentsderivedfromtheerodingmountainrange.Assuch,theirstratigraphicarchitectureandsubsidencehistorycontainarecordofmountainbuilding.InTaiwan,thewesternforelandbasinresultsfromtheflexureoftheEURlithosphereprovokedbythrustloadingofunitsontotheChinesemargin.Fieldwork,seismicprofilesandboreholedataacquiredbyoilcompaniesdocumentextensivelythedevelopmentofthebasin(Linetal.,2003).Itiscomposedofasuccessionofstagesrecordingtheprogressivefillingofthebasinafteranunder-filledstageattheinitiationofload-inducedsubsidence.ThisgeneralsequenceoffaciesinTaiwanisattheoriginoftheclassicalmodelofforelandbasinfillingsequencepopularizedbyCovey(1986)inaspecialIASvolumeonForelandBasinsandhassincebeenappliedworldwide.However,whiletheunder-filledstagecanbeclearlyrecognisedonthefield,thepre-forelandseries(earlyKueichulinandbefore)andtheassumedearlyforelandseriesthatcanbeobservedonthecratonwardsideofthebasinbothindicaterelativelyshallowwaterenvironmentsandarebothfedbytheChinesemarginthroughtheirhistory.Thus,noobviouschanges in sedimentaryenvironmentsandcompositionclearlymark the initiationof subsidence.Thisproblemisalsoreflectedinthedifferentagestowhichdifferentauthorsattributetheinitiationofforelandbasinsubsi-dence.WhenandwheredidtheloadinducedsubsidencestartinTaiwan?ItiscrucialtosolvethisissuebecauseitconditionsourunderstandingofthetectonichistoryofcollisioninTaiwan,thetype-orogenfortheoriesofcriticalwedges.
TheBasinResearchgroupinTaiwan,TectonicslaboratoryinParisandbothGeophysicalFluidDynamicsandEarthSurfaceDynamicsgroupsatETHtacklethisissuetogetherandfromdifferentapproaches.
In thisworkwepresentour sedimentological analysisof thePlioceneTawoandAiliachao sandstones in theYujingandYucyongpingareas,situatedatornearthetransitionfrompassivemargintoforelandbasinsubsidence.Weshowthattheyprobablycorrespondtohyperpycnalturbiditesinrelativelyshallowwaterpro-deltaenvironmentssimilartomoderndepositionintheYellowSea.Throughtime-seriesanalysisofrhythmicbedsweshowthataremarkablefeatureisthestrong,potentiallymisleading,influenceoftidecurrentsinshapingthesedeposits.Weincorporatetheseinformationsintorestoredpaleogeographicalhypothesesforthistimeperiodusingestimatedquantitiesofshorteningintheforelandfold-and-thrustbeltandshowthattheChinesecontinentalmarginatthistimedisplayedanimportantpromontorytowardstheocean.Thiscouldexplainwhythecollisionseemstohavestartedbeforethanusuallyinferredbasedonreconstructionsassumingacylindricallinearcontinentalmarginandextrapolatingtothepastthemodernhigh-ratesofconvergence.
70Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s
Figure1.Detaileddescriptionofachannel-leveesysteminshallowturbiditesoftheAiliaochaoformationinthePlioceneofsouth-central
Taiwan.
REFERENCESCovey,M. (1986) - Theevolutionof forelandbasins to steady state: evidence from thewesternTaiwan forelandbasin, in
ForelandBasins,editedbyP.A.AllenandP.Homewood,Spec.Publsint.Ass.Sediment.,8,77–90.Lin,A.T.,WattsA.B.&HesselboS.P.(2003)-CenozoicstratigraphyandsubsidencehistoryoftheSouthChinaSeamarginin
theTaiwanregion.BasinResearch,15(4),453-478.
Funding:ThisprojectisfundedbySwissNationalFundsgrant#2-77295-08.
71
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.10
One-sided subduction in self-consistent models of global mantle convection: the importance of a free surface and a weak crustal layer
CrameriFabio,TackleyPaul,MeilickIrena,GeryaTaras,KausBoris&KellerTobias
Institut für Geophysik, ETH Zürich, Switzerland ([email protected])
Previousdynamicalmodelsofglobalmantleconvectionindicatedthatavisco-plasticrheologyissuccessfulingeneratingplatetectonics-likebehaviourself-consistently(Moresietal.,1998;vanHeckandTackley,2008).Yet,thesemodelsfailtocre-ateEarth-likeplatetectonics:sofarinallpublishedmodelssubductionistwo-sidedandmoreorlesssymmetric,whereasterrestrialsubductionisone-sidedandcharacterizedbyadistinctiveasymmetry.
Figure1.Viscosityfieldsforconvectionwithastronglytemperature-dependentvisco-plasticrheologyand(top)afreesurfaceor(bottom)a
free-slipsurface.
Onesimplificationusedinpreviousmodelsisthatofafree-slipupperboundary,inwhichtheshearstressiszerobuttheverticalpositionoftheboundaryisfixed.Incontrast,subductionzonesdisplaysomeofthelargestvariationsinsurfaceto-pographyonEarth.Forthecaseofaslabthatisinitiallyplacedatthesurfaceandallowedtofreelysubduct,Schmelingetal.(2008)showedthatitisnecessarytoincludeaproperfreesurfaceinnumericalmodelsinordertoreproducelaboratoryresults.Accordingtotheirbenchmarkstudy,mimickingafreesurfacebyalowviscosity,zerodensitylayerontopofthecrustisanadequateapproach.Forthisreason,wehaveimplementedsucha"stickyairlayer"inourglobalnumericalmo-del.
Weherestudytheeffectofafreesurfaceonthemodeofsubductionin2Dand3Dglobal,fullydynamicmantleconvectionmodelswith self-consistentplate tectonics. For thisweuse thefinite volumemultigrid codeStagYY (Tackley, 2008)withstronglytemperature-dependentviscosity,ductileand/orbrittleplasticyielding,andnon-diffusivetracerstrackingcomposi-tionalvariations(the'air'layerinthiscase).
72Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s Weobserve that indeed,a free surface leads to single-sidedsubduction,whereas identicalmodelswitha free slipupperboundarydevelopdouble-sidedsubduction(Figure1).Afreesurfaceisthusanessentialingredienttoobtainrealisticsub-ductionbehaviourinnumericalmodels,probablybecauseitallowstheslabtobendinanaturalmanner.
Althoughtheabovemodelsappearone-sidedfromthetemperatureorviscosityfields,thereisstrongmechanicalcouplingbetweentheslabandthemantlewedgethatmakesthemmechanicallydouble-sided.Regionalmodelsofsubduction(Geryaetal,2008) indicate thatonerequirement forstableone-sidedsubduction isa lowstrength interfacebetweentheplatesachievedbythepresenceofmetamorphicfluidsinthesubductionchannel.Suchalubricationlayerconsistingofweakhy-dratedsedimentsaccommodatesstableone-sidedsubductionbystrainlocalization,whiletheabsenceofaweakshearzoneleadstomechanicallytwo-sidedsubductionsinceinthiscasetheplasticstrengthoftheentireplatesneedstobesufficientlylowtoallowforsubduction.
Inconclusion,afreesurfaceisthekeyingredienttoobtainthermallyone-sidedsubduction,whileadditionallyincludingaweakcrustisessentialtoobtainsubductionthatisbothmechanicallyandthermallyone-sided.
REFERENCESMoresi,L.,&SolomatovV.1998:Mantleconvectionwithabrittlelithosphere-Thoughtsontheglobaltectonicstylesofthe
EarthandVenus.Geophys.J.Int.133,669-682.vanHeck,H.&TackleyP.J.2008:Planformsofself-consistentlygeneratedplatetectonicsin3-Dsphericalgeometry.Geophys.
Res.Lett.35,doi:10.1029/2008GL035190.Schmeling,H., BabeykoA., EnnsA., FaccennaC., Funiciello F.,GeryaT.,GolabekG.,Grigull S., KausB. J. P.,MorraG.,
Schmalholz S.& vanHunen J. 2008:Abenchmark comparisonof spontaneous subductionmodels – towards a freesurface:Phys.EarthPlanet.Int.171,198-223.
Tackley,P.J.2008:Modellingcompressiblemantleconvectionwithlargeviscositycontrastsinathree-dimensionalsphericalshellusingtheyin-yanggrid.Phys.EarthPlanet.Int.,doi:10.1016/j.pepi.2008.08.005.
Gerya,T.V.,ConnollyJ.A.D.&Yuen,D.A.2008:Whyisterrestrialsubductionone-sided?Geology36,43-46.
2.11
Parameters that control the formation of lithospheric-scale shear zones
CrameriFabio*,KausBorisJ.P.*&TackleyPaulJ.*
*Institute of Geophysics, ETH Zurich, Schafmattstrasse 30, CH-8093 Zürich ([email protected])
Shear-heating induced localizationmightbean importantprocess for subduction initiation.Kaus&Podladchikov (2006)showedwith the help of numerical simulations that for some parameters, localization occurs and for other parameterchoices,localizationdoesnottakeplace.Thereby,eitherhomogeneousthickeningorbucklingcompensatesthedeformati-on.Thermallyactivatedthrustingincontrasttothesetwomechanismsispreferredforarelativelycoldlithosphere.Inaddi-tiontothethermalstructureofthelithosphere,thedeformationmodeisalsodeterminedbytheinitialrheologicalstruc-tureandbytheshorteningrates[Burg and Schmalholz,2008].Here,numerous2-Dsimulations(>100#)areperformedtodistinguishtheseregionsbychangingtheparametersthatinflu-encetheshearheatingprocess.The2-DsimulationsareperformedusingaMATLAB-basedfiniteelementcode.Thestandardsimulationsusedforthisworkmodelalithosphereconsistingofanuppercrust,alowercrustplusanuppermantlepart.First, only temperatureand strain rateare changedduring systematic simulations, followedby changes in the rheology.Additional2-Dsimulationshavebeenperformedinwhichthemantlethicknesswasincreasedorinwhichtheinitialgeo-metry(forexamplecrustalthickness)waschanged.Inaddition,afast1-Dfinitedifferencecodewasdeveloped,thatexactlyreproducestheresultsofthe2-Dcodeforlaterallyhomogeneouscases.Forthesameinputparameters,itcomputesinformationoftemporalchangesofboththetemperatureandstrengthprofileoftheEarth’supperpartduetoshear-heating.Evenmoreimportant,itfurthersuppliesinformationfortheoccurrenceoflocalizationaftercomparingandvalidatingitsresultswiththe2-Dsimulations.Asapowerfultool,this1-Dcodecanfinallybeusedtopredicttheoccurrenceofshearlocalizationforgiveninputparameters.Thisthusyieldsnewinsightsintheoccurrenceofshearlocalizationinacompressedlithosphere.
73
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
Figure1.Localizationpredictionof1-Dcode(redarea)arecomparedto2-Dsimulationresultsshownaspointsandindicatingnolocaliza-
tion(blue),localization(red)andunknown(green).
REFERENCESBurg, J. P., andS.M. Schmalholz (2008),Viscousheatingallows thrusting toovercomecrustal-scalebuckling:Numerical
investigationwithapplicationtotheHimalayansyntaxes,EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,274(1-2),189-203.Kaus, B. J. P., and Y. Y. Podladchikov (2006), Initiation of localized shear zones in viscoelastoplastic rocks, Journal of
GeophysicalResearch-SolidEarth,111(B4).
74Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.12
Twin meteorite impact craters in Thessaly (Central Greece) of Holocene age
DietrichVolkerJ.*&GartzosEfthimios**
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrography, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])**Laboratory of Mineralogy-Geology, Agricultural University of Athens, GR-118 55 Athens, Greece
Twocircularpermanentlakesof150and250mindiameterand12and16mdepth,respectively,occur250mapartfromeachotherintheagriculturalfieldsSWofthetownofAlmyros(Thessaly).ThebasementbeneaththealluvialcoverconsistsofMesozoicmarly limestones, schists,phyllites, cherts,aswellasof slicesof radiolarites, serpentinitesandmeta-basalts(Marinosetal.1962).ThelakeswereregardedasdolinesduetotheoccurrenceofkarstphenomenaintheequivalenttectonicunitsinthesurroundingOthrismountains.Anotherhypothesisasvolcanicmaar-typediatremeshasbeensuggestedonthebasisoftheexistenceofsmallCenozoicvolcaniccentersinthewiderarea(Marinou1962),howeverwithoutanyevidenceforejectedvolcanicmaterial.Thesuspicionofanoriginduetometeorite impactarosewiththeavailabilityofahigh-resolutionGoogleearthsatelliteimage.Thelakesexhibitsignificantsickle-shapedhalosupto30mhigh.TheagesofthelakescanbeassumedontheirfreshmorphologicalcharacterasHoloceneandbracketedbetweenapproximately12500and9000to7000yearsBP;thelatteragecomesfromremnantsofanEarlyNeolithicsettlementadjacenttothelargerlake(Papathanassopoulos1996).
Duringtworeconnaissanceinvestigationsaconsiderableamountofangulartoroundedpebbleswerefoundinthesandy-siltyclayoftheshoresaswellasinthehalos.Novolcanicmaterialwasfound.Theangulartoirregularroundedyellowishtoorangeandpartiallyblack-coatedpebblesvaryfrommmtoapproximatelyonedecimeterinsize.Theyaremadeupof:heterogeneouscarbonaceousfine-breccias,moreorlesshomogeneouscarbonaceouspebbles,infewcaseswithfusiformandconeshapesaswellasquartz,redradiolarite,andveryoccasionallyserpentiniteandmeta-basaltfragments.
Texturesthatcanbeinterpretedasevidenceforshock-meltedcarbonates(e.g.inGraup1999;reviewinOsinskietal.2008):1) Carbonate quench textures.
The homogeneous carbonaceous grains and pebbles display distinctive feathery (spinifex) textures of calcite. They are coarser towards the inner parts and progressively finer towards the rims. In addition, fine spinifex crystals cover the walls of “spider-type” radial and concentric cracks, which originate from the inner parts of the pebbles and are fil-led with euhedral calcite. Many fine spherules (< 100 µm to a few mm) are entirely filled with feathery calcite.
2) CarbonatespherulesManyfine-brecciascontainnumerouscarbonatespherules,whichoccurasindividualspherulesandshowinseveralcasescoalescentbounding.Inmostcasesthespherulesdisplayreactionrimsandcoronasofsubmicroscopicfinemineralassemblages.Thesespherulesarenot“secondaryvesiclefillings”,sincetheyaremadeupofveryfine-grainedtocryptocrystallinecarbonatewith“schlieren”andspinifextextures.
3) Planar microstructures in quartz and calcite (e.g.inTrepmann2008) Small fragmental quartz grains of up to 100 µm are very abundant in the fine-breccias, homogenous carbonaceous pebbles and spherules. In all cases, they show undulate extinction and Boehm lamellae, which are results of tecto-nic deformation. However, in some cases “planar fractures (PFs)” are also present. Real “planar deformation fea-tures (PDFs)” have not been found.
Carbonate chemistrySeveralpebbleswithrelativelyhomogeneousfine-grainedandfeatherycalcitegroundmasswereanalyzedwithXRFmethodtoobtaintheirbulkchemicalcomposition.ThemajorelementsshowarathermarlylimestonecompositionwithSiO
230-35
wt.%,CaO28-32wt.%,Al2O
35-6wt.%,K
2O0.6-0.7wt.%,TiO
20.35-0.45wt.%andalowMgO0.6-0.9wt.%.Thetraceelements
displayratherlowconcentrations:Rb25-35ppm,Sr35-65ppm,Ba130-400ppm,Nb5-6ppm,lowvaluesofLREE;Cr110-160ppm,Ni50-65ppmandZn40-50ppm.TheonlyunusualenrichmentexistsinYwith30-70ppm.Suchacompositionsupportsanoriginofthepebblesfrommarlylimestones,butdiffersdramaticallyfromthecompositionofcarbonatiticglobulesfromvolcanicdiatremesintheultra-alkalineProvincenorthofRome(Stoppa&Lupini1993).
ConclusionThepetrographicandchemicalevidenceofthecollectedfine-brecciasandpebblesleadstotheinterpretationofthemateri-alas“impactfallbackbrecciasandcarbonatitictectitesduetometeoriticimpact,althoughuptonownometeoritefrag-mentshavebeenfound.Accordingtothesizeofthecraterlakesthedimensionsofthemeteorite,whichmighthavesplitintotwofragments,shouldhavebeenabout10-30mbeforereachingthesurface.Thetemperatureandpressureoftheim-pactmayhavebeensufficienttodecomposeandmeltthelimestonesfollowedbyquenchingduringcoolinganddecompres-siontoformthecarbonatiticpebblesandspherules.
75
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsREFERENCES
Graup,G.1999:Carbonate-silicateliquidimmiscibilityuponimpactmelting:RiesCraterGermany.Meteoritics&PlanetaryScience,34,425-438.
Marinos,G.1962:Surdeuxvolcansembryonnairesdutypemare,présd’Almyros-Thessalie.BulletinGeologicalSocietyofGreece,5,1,108-114.
Marinos,G.,Anastopoulos, J.,Maratos,G.,Melidonis,N.&Andronopoulos,B. 1962:GeologicalMapofGreece1 : 50000,SheetAlmyros.InstituteforGeologyandSubsurfaceResearch,Athen.
Osinski,G.R.,Spray,J.G.&Grieve2008:Impactmeltinginsedimentarytargetrocks:Anassessment.In:Evans,K.R.,Horton,J.W. Jr.,King,D.T. Jr.&Morrow, J.R.eds.,TheSedimentaryRecordofMeteorite Impacts.GeologicalSocietyofAmericaSpecialPaper,437,1-8.
Stoppa, F. & Lupini, L. 1993:Mineralogy and petrology of the PolinoMonticellite Caleiocarbonatite (Central Italy).Mineralogyandpetrology,49,213-231.
Trepmann,C.A.2008:Shockeffectsinquartz:Compressionversussheardeformation–AnexamplefromtheRochechouartimpactstructure,France.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,267,322-332.
2.13
Rheological mechanisms, topographic response, and geodynamic regimes associated with slab breakoff
DuretzThibault*&GeryaTaras*
*ETH Zürich, Institute of Geophysics, Sonnegstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])
Asetofnumericalexperimentswerecarriedouttostudytheeffectofslabbreakoffonasubduction-collisionsystem.Thenumericalcode I2VIS (Gerya&Yuen,2003)usedforthispurposeallowsactivationofplasticity,viscouscreepandPeierlscreep.
Atwo-dimensionalsystematicstudywasperformedbyvaryingtheoceanicslabageandinitialplateconvergencerate.Inthisparameterspace,fourdifferentend-memberswereobservedwherebreakoffdepthcanrangefrom40to400km.Differentcombinationsofrheologicalmechanismsleadtodifferentbreakoffmodes.ActivationofPeierlsmechanismgenerallyallowsslabstobreakfasterandshallower.
Eachbreakoffend-memberhasitsowntopographicsignalevolutionandalwaysdisplayasharpbreakoffsignal.Averagedpost-breakoffupliftratesrangesbetween0,8km/Myforshallowdetachmentand0,2km/Myfordeepdetachmentinforelandandhinterlandbasins.
Initiationofcontinentalcrustsubductionwasobservedwhenusinganoceaniclithosphereolderthan30My.Differentex-humationprocessessuchasslabretreatandeductionwereobserved.Largepost-breakoffreboundassociatedwithplatede-couplingoccursifthesubductedoceanicslabisoldenough.
REFERENCESGerya, T. V.& Yuen,D. A. 2003: Charaterictics-basedmarkermethodwith conservative finite-difference schemes for
modelinggeologicalflowswithstronglyvariabletransportproperties.PhysicsoftheEarthanPlanetaryInteriors140(4),293–318.
76Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.14
New structural field data from SE of the Mont Blanc massif and prelimi-nary constraints on models of exhumation
DanielEgli*&NeilMancktelow*
* Geologisches Institut, ETH-Zürich, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])
ThekinematicsoftheexhumationoftheMontBlancmassifisstillacontroversialtopicwithvariousmodelsproposed.MostinformationontheNeogeneexhumationhistoryofMontBlanccomesfromlow-temperaturethermochronologystudies(e.g.Seward&Mancktelow1994;Leloupetal.2005;Glotzbachetal.2008)andthereisstilllackofdetailedstructuraldata.ThisstudyprovidesnewdetailedinformationaboutthedeformationalhistoryandtheexhumationoftheMontBlancmassifanditsadjacentcover.WetrytoestimatetheimportanceofdextraltranspressionalmovementsduringtheupliftofMontBlancanditspossiblelinkwiththeSimplon-Rhonefaultzone,inordertochecka2Dpop-upmodelagainstamore3Ddextraltranspressivemodel,developingapositiveflowerstructure.Wepresentherepreliminaryresultsofthefirstfieldseason,whichincludeddetailedstructuralinvestigationsandstructuralmappingofthesouth-easternboundaryoftheMontBlancmassifintheSwissandItalianpartsofValFerret.Thestudyareaissituatedonthesouth-easternsideoftheMontBlancmassif.GeologicallyitcoverstheunitsoftheMontBlancmassif,theHelveticandUltrahelveticnappesandsedimentsofthelowerPenninicnappes.TheMontBlancmassifisoneoftheexternalcrystallinemassifs,whichrepresentthebasementoftheformerEuropeancontinentalmarginandthe-reforebelongstotheHelveticdomain. Itmainlyconsistsofpre-VariscanbasementandVariscangranitoids.Themassif isoverlainbytheMesozoictolowerTertiarysedimentsoftheHelveticsandUltrahelvetics.ThesewereoverriddenalongthePenninefrontalthrustbysedimentsofthenorthernPenninicoceanduringtheTertiaryAlpineorogeny.Thesediments,aswellasthecrystallinerocksoftheMontBlanc,sufferedapolyphasemetamorphicanddeformationalhistory.Wewereabletodistinguish4generationsoffoldsintheHelvetic,UltrahelveticandPenninicsedimentsoftheworkingarea.Theappearanceofthefoldscandifferwithchanginglithologies,butthemaincharacteristicsremainthesame.Wenumbe-redthemasregionalD1-D4.D1isonlyvisibleasapenetrativecleavage,S1,withsomerarerelicsofisoclinalfoldhinges.ItisfoldedbyD2,typicallyforminglong-limbedtighttoisoclinalfoldsandoftenaspacedcrenulationcleavage,S2.TheS2cleavageisthemainfoliationinmostpartsofthestudyareaandhasarelativelyconstantorientationdippingtowardthesouth-east.Thethirddeformationphaseisnotfoundeverywhereinthestudyarea.D3foldsformrathershort-limbedkinkytowavyfolds,oftenaccompaniedbyacrenulationlineationparalleltotheD3foldaxis.IfD3formsanaxialplanecleavage,itisquitespacedandsubverticalordippingtowardsthenorth-west.Thesestructurescouldrepresentabackfold-typestruc-ture.TheD4canmainlybefoundintheblackshalesbetweenGrandColdeFerretandFerretvillage.Theyhaveatypicalcollapse-typeappearance,withsubhorizontalaxialplanesandverykinkyhingesandlocallyresultinanorth-westwarddip-pingmainfoliation.AnimportantaspectoftheareaistheregionalchangeinorientationoftheboundarybetweentheMontBlancmassifandtheoverlyingsediments.IntheareaaroundthesoutheastportaloftheMontBlanctunnel(i.e.nearCourmayeur),thebase-mentoverliesthesediments,theoverturnedboundarydipsca.45°towardthenorth-east,andthecontactisoftendiscor-dant.Intheareasmoretothenorth,thedipchangesgraduallytoverticalandfinallydipssouth-east.ThebasementseemstobethrusteastwardsontothesedimentsintheCourmayeurarea,althoughnomajorthrustplanecouldbedetectedma-croscopically.IntheSwissValFerretthecontactisconcordantandmostprobablysedimentary.Onamesoscopicscale,weobservedthattheactualcontactbetweenthebasementandcovercannotbeaverylatestagestructurebecauseitisslightlyfoldedwithanewsteepfabricdevelopedinboththesedimentsandthegranite.Thisfoliationisweaklyrefractedacrosstheboundary.IntheslightlyhighermetamorphicrocksaroundPetitColdeFerret,smallenclavesofmarbleareductileyfoldedintothebasementrocks.CalciteslickenfibresarequitecommonintheHelveticandUltrahelveticsedimentsandhavevariousorientations.Themostdominantdirectionhasadextralstrike-slipsenseofmovementandplungesshallowlytowardNEorSW.Inthestronglyfoli-atedblackshales,thefaultplanesusuallycorrespondwiththemainfoliationwhereasinthemorecompetentlimestonestheymakeasmallangletothemainfoliationandgenerallycorrespondtoRiedel-typefaults.Morerarely,onecanfindsub-verticalslickenfibresshowingboththrustingtowardthenorth-westaswellaswest-side-upmovements.ThesearetheonlystructuresfoundwhosekinematicscouldbedirectlyrelatedtoexhumationoftheMontBlanc.Therelativeageofthediffe-rentbrittlemovementsisnotyetestablished.Althoughaneastward-directedbackthrustingofMontBlancbasementovercoversedimentsmayhaveoccurred,itcannotbethereasonforthelateNeogeneupliftbecausethecontactissubsequentlyductileydeformed.Amajorstrike-slipcomponentisfoundontheeasternboundaryofthemassifandthismovementcouldwellrepresentasouthwardcontinutionoftheRhone-Simplonline.However,suchtranspressivemovementsareprobablynotthereasonfortheupliftoftheMontBlanc,becausetheshallowlynorth-eastwardplungingfibresshowingadextralsensewouldratherhaveawest-side-downverticalcomponent.
77
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsREFERENCES
Glotzbach,C.,ReineckerJ.,Danisik, M.,Rahn,M.,Frisch,W.&C.Spiegel2008:NeogeneexhumationhistoryoftheMontBlancmassif,westernAlps,Tectonics,27.
Leloup,P.H.,Arnaud,N.,Sobel,E.R.&LacassinR.2005:Alpinethermalandstructuralevolutionofthehighestexternalcrystallinemassif:TheMont
Blanc,Tectonics,24.Seward,D&MancktelowN. S. 1994:Neogenekinematics of the central andwesternAlps: Evidence from fission-track
dating,Geology,22,803–806.
2.15
Reflection and scattering of Stoneley guided waves at the tips of fluid-filled fractures
FrehnerMarcel*andSchmalholzStefanM.**
* Department for Geodynamics and Sedimentology, University of Vienna, Althanstrasse 14, 1090 Vienna, Austria ([email protected])** Geological Institute, ETH Zurich, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
Understanding seismicwavepropagation in fractured fluid-rock systems is important for estimating, for example, fluidpropertiesorfracturedensitiesfromgeophysicalmeasurements.Stoneleyguidedwaveshavebeenused,forexample,toex-plainlong-periodvolcanictremorsignalsortoproposepotentialmethodsforestimatingfluidpropertiesinfracturedrocks.Inthisstudy,thefiniteelementmethodisusedtomodeltwo-dimensionalwavepropagationinarockwithafinitefluid-filledfracture(Figure1).Thesurroundingrockisfullyelasticwithnon-dispersivenon-attenuatingP-andS-waves.Thefluidfillingthefractureiselasticinitsbulkdeformationbehaviorbutviscousinitssheardeformationbehavior.Therefore,onlyP-wavescanpropagateinthefracture,whicharedispersiveandattenuated.Thefracturegeometryisresolvedindetailbytheappliedunstructuredfiniteelementmeshusingtriangles.AStoneleyguidedwaveisaspecialwavemodethatisboundtoandpropagatesalongthefracturewithamuchsmallerve-locitythanallotherwavesinthesystem.Inthisstudy,thewavelengthoftheStoneleyguidedwaveistwoordersofmagni-tudelargerthanthethicknessofthefracture.Itsamplitudedecreasesexponentiallyawayfromthefracture,whichmakestheStoneleyguidedwavedifficult todetectalreadyarelativelyshortdistancesawayfromthefracture.Atthetipof thefracturetheStoneleyguidedwaveisreflected(Figure1).Theamplituderatio|R|betweenreflectedandincidentStoneleyguidedwaveiscalculatedfromnumericalsimulations(Figure2),whichdependonthetypeoffluidfillingthefracture(wa-ter,oilorhydrocarbongas),thefracturegeometry(ellipticalorrectangular)andthepresenceofasmallgascapatthefrac-turetip.Foranellipticallyshapedfracture(aspectratioofellipse=333)theamplituderatiovariesbetween75%foroilandwaterandalmost100%forgas.Althoughthefracturethicknessistwoordersofmagnitudesmallerthanthewavelength,theshapeofthefracturetipinfluencesthisratiosignificantly.TheamplituderatioofaStoneleyguidedwaveatthetipofastraightwater-filledfracturewithaflatfracturetipisaround43%.ThepartoftheStoneleyguidedwavethatisnotreflectedisscatteredatthefracturetipandemittedintothesurroundingelasticrockaselasticbodywaves(Figure1).Forfullysaturatedfracturestheradiationoftheseelasticbodywavespointsineverydirectionsfromthefracturetip.Inthepresenceofasmallgas-capatthetipofafluid-filedfracturetheradiationoftheelasticbodywavesisstronglyforwarddirected.TherelativelystrongreflectionatthefracturetipenablestheStoneleyguidedwavetotravelbackandforthalongafractureseveraltimesbeforeitloosestoomuchofitsinitialenergy.Thisleadstoaperiodicradiationofbodywavesatthefracturetip.ThecorrespondingfrequencycanbelowinrelativelysmallfracturesduetothesmallvelocityofStoneleyguidedwaves.TheemittedelasticbodywavesmayallowdetectingStoneleyguidedwave-relatedsignalsatdistancesawayfromthefracturewheretheamplitudeoftheStoneleyguidedwaveitselfistoosmalltobedetected.
78Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s
Figure1:Snapshotsofthe2DdisplacementfieldofasimulationofaStoneleyguidedwavepropagatingalonganellipticalcrackfilled
withwater.Upperpanelsshowthehorizontalcomponentofthedisplacementfield.Lowerpanelsshowtheverticalcomponentofthedis-
placementfield.Panelsfromlefttorightrepresentprogressivepointsintime.TheStoneleyguidedwaveispartiallyreflectedatthecrack
tipandelasticP-andS-wavesareemittedfromthecracktipintothesurroundingrock.
Figure2:Absolutevalueoftheamplituderatio|R|betweenreflectedandincidentStoneleyguidedwaveofaStoneleyguidedwavethatis
reflectedatthetipofacrack.Rxiscalculatedfromthehorizontaldisplacement-timesignalsateightreceiversinsidethecrack.Ryiscal-
culatedfromtheverticaldisplacement-timesignalsatsixreceiversoutsidethecrack.Valueslabeled“viscousfluids,ellipticalcracktip”
arederivedfromsimulationsofanellipticalcrackfullysaturatedwiththecorrespondingviscousfluid.Valueslabeled“flatcracktip”are
derivedfromasimulationofarectangularcrackwithaflatcracktipfullysaturatedwithviscouswater.Valueslabeled“oilwithgascap,
ellipticalcracktip”arederivedfromasimulationofanellipticalcrackpartiallysaturatedwithviscousoilandhavingasmallgascapat
thecracktip.
79
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.16
Exhumation of a metamorphic complex in a strike-slip setting: observa-tions from the Chugach Metamorphic Complex (CMC), southern Alaska
DetaGasser*,EmilieBruand*,KurtStüwe*
*Department of Earth Science, Universitätsplatz 2, A-8010 Graz, Austria ([email protected]
The exhumation of metamorphic rocks to the surface of the Earth is a much discussed subject in modern geodynamics. Models involving channel flow, pure and simple shear extrusion and others have been postulated based on observations in the Central Himalayan Crystalline Complex or the eclogite complexes in the Alps. Most of these models focus on the vertical component in profile view, not considering horizontal movements in plan view.
TheCMCofSouthernAlaskaconsistsoflow-Phigh-TgneissesthatdevelopedduringtheEoceneinaCretaceousaccretionaryprism.Theyareexhumedfrom20-35kmdepthbetweenmajorcrustal-scaledextralshearzones(Fig.1).Lineationsaretypi-callyparalleltostrikeandsub-horizontal,indicatingthathorizontalmovementinplanviewisavitalpartoftheexhumati-onprocess.Inaddition,thecomplexhasaparticulartriangularshapeinplanview,indicatingthattheexhumationhistorymightnotbethesameallalongthecomplexbutmightbedifferentinpartsofdifferentwidthofthecomplex.
Inordertounderstandthenatureofthelow-Phigh-Tmetamorphisminaaccretionarysettinganditssubsequentexhuma-tionhistorywearecurrentlyworkingonaprojectcombiningextendedfieldwork,petrological,structuralandgeochrono-logicalmethods.Duringthesummers2008and2009wemappedsixkeyareascoveringthewholecomplexfromnorthtosouthandfromeasttowestinordertounderstandthestructuralandpetrologicalvariationsalloverthecomplex.Wefur-thermorecalculateddetailedpressureandtemperatureconditions thatoccurredduringmetamorphismin thedifferentpartsofthecomplex.Inordertobetterunderstandthetimingandtheratesatwhichheating,coolingandexhumationoc-curred,weapplyseveralgeochronologicalmethodssuchasU-Pbdatingofmonazitesandzircons,ArArandRbSrdatingofbiotiteandmuscoviteandzirconfissiontrackdatingtorocksfromdifferentpartsofthecomplex.
InthiscontributionwepresentanoverviewofthegeologyoftheCMC,resultsfromourfieldworkaswellasfirstgeochro-nologicalresults.
Fig.1Tectonicoverviewmapandcross-sectionofsouthernAlaska.Abbreviations:CMCChugachMetamorphicComplex,gTFtransition
fault,PZPamplonazone,KIZKayakIslandZone,DRZDangerousRiverZone,CSEChugachStEliasFault,CFContactFault,FFFairweather
Fault,BRFBorderRangesFault,DFDenaliFault.
80Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.17
The Rezli fault zone: Field observations from a major oblique-slip fault in the Rawil depression, Western Switzerland
Deta Gasser*, Neil Mancktelow**
*Department of Earth Science, Universitätsplatz 2, A-8010 Graz, Austria ([email protected])**Geological Institute, ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich, Switzerland ([email protected])
InWesternSwitzerland,theplungeoffoldaxesandtheregionaldistributionofunitsintheHelveticnappesdefineabroaddepression,theRawildepression,betweenthecrystallinerocksoftheAiguillesRougemassiftotheSWandtheAarmassiftotheNE.Thesouthernpartofthisdepression,togetherwiththeRhoneValleytothesouth,belongstooneoftheseismi-callymostactiveregionsinSwitzerland.SeismogenicfaultsinterpretedfromearthquakefocalmechanismsstrikeENE-WSWtoWNW-ESE,withdominantdextralstrike-slipandminornormalcomponentsandepicentresatdepthsof<15km.Inordertounderstandthepost-nappe-stacking,brittlefaultinghistoryofthisarea,wecompiledfaultdatafromtheliteratureandexistingmapsandconducteddetailedfieldworkononeexceptionallywell-exposedfaultzone,theRezlifaultzone(RFZ).
Thecompilationofdatafromtheliteratureestablishesthat,inadditiontothrustsrelatedtonappestacking,theRawilde-pressioniscross-cutbyfoursetsofbrittlefaults:(1)SW-NEstrikingnormalfaultsthatstrikeparalleltotheregionalfoldaxistrend,(2)NW-SEstrikingnormalfaultsandjointsthatstrikeperpendiculartotheregionalfoldaxistrend,and(3)WNW-ESEstrikingnormalplusdextraloblique-slipfaultsaswellas(4)WSW-ENEstrikingnormalplusdextraloblique-slipfaultsthatbothstrikeobliquetotheregionalfoldaxistrend.Faultset1wasprobablyinitiatedduringsedimentationandreactivatedduringnappefoldingandstacking,whereastheotherfaultsetsformedafteremplacementoftheHelveticnappes.
TheRFZbelongstofaultset3andisashallowtomoderately-dipping(ca.30-60°)faultzonewithanoblique-slipdisplacementvector,combiningbothdextralandnormalcomponents.Itmusthaveformedinapproximatelythisorientation,becausethelocalorientationoffoldaxescorrespondstotheregionalone,asdoesthegenerallyverticalorientationofextensionaljointsandveinsassociatedwiththeregionalfaultset2.Thefaultzonehasamaximumhorizontaldextraloffsetcomponentofca.300mandamaximumverticalnormaloffsetcomponentofca.200m.
Thefaultzonecrosscutsfourdifferentlithologies:(1)limestone,(2)intercalatedmarlandlimestone,(3)marland(4)sands-tone,anditsinternalarchitecturestronglydependsonthelithologyinwhichitdeveloped.Inthelimestone,itconsistsofveins,stylolites,cataclasitesandcementedgouge,intheintercalatedmarlsandlimestonesofanastomosingshearzones,brittlefractures,veinsandfolds.Inthemarlsitconsistsofanastomosingshearzones,pressuresolutionseamsandveinsandinthesandstonesofcoarsebrecciaandveins.Later,straight,sharpfaultplanescross-cutallthesefeatures.Inalllithologies,commonveinsandcalcite-cementedfaultrocksindicatethestronginvolvementoffluidsduringfaulting.
AllthreeNeogenefaultsets(2-4)couldhavebeenactiveundertheactualstressfieldinferredfromthecurrentseismicity.Thisimpliesthatthesamemechanismsthatformedthesefaultzonesinthepastmaystillpersistatdepth.ThedetailedobservationsfromtheRezlifaultzonecanactasamodelforprocessesstilloccurringatdeeperlevelsinthisseismicallyactiveregion.
2.18
Influence of rheology and giant impactors on the terrestrial core formation
GolabekGregor*,GeryaTaras*,KausBoris*,ZietheRuth**,MollGian-Peider***&TackleyPaul*
*Institut für Geophysik, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])**ESA/ESTEC-SCI-SM, Keplerlaan 1, NL-2201 AZ Noordwijk***Institut für Computerwissenschaften, Universitätsstrasse 6, CH-8092 Zürich.
Knowledgeabouttheterrestrialcoreformationmechanismisstillverylimited.Severalcoreformationmodeshavebeenproposed:Thefracturingmodesuggeststhatacentralunmeltedregionisdisplacedbyadegreeonemodefromthecenter
81
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsoftheaccretingbodyandisfragmentedduetothelargestressescreatedbyanoverlyingasymmetricironlayer(Stevenson,
1981).Incontrast,coreformationviairondiapirs(e.g.ZietheandSpohn,2007),whichcanbeformedbygiantimpacts(e.g.Ricardetal,2009),havebeenproposed.Weinvestigatewhichcoreformationmodeisactiveundercertainconditions.Thereforeweperform2DsimulationsusingthecodeI2ELVISapplyingthenewlydeveloped“spherical-Cartesian”methodo-logy(GeryaandYuen,2007).ItcombinesfinitedifferencesonafullystaggeredrectangularEuleriangridandLagrangianmarker-in-celltechniqueforsolvingmomentum,continuityandtemperatureequationsaswellasthePoissonequationforgravitypotentialinaself-gravitatingplanetarybody.Inthemodel,theplanetarybodyissurroundedbyalowviscositymass-lessfluid(“stickyair”)tosimulateafreesurface.Weapplyatemperature-andstress-dependentviscoplasticrheologyinsideMars-toEarth-sizedbodiesandincludeheatreleaseduetoradioactivedecay,shearandadiabaticheating.Asinitialconditi-onweusestochasticallydistributedirondiapirswithrandomsizesintherangeof50to100kmradiusinsidetheaccretingplanet,representingtheirondeliveredbypre-differentiatedimpactors.Additionally,weaddagiantimpactorcoreintoseveralmodels.Forsimplicity,weneglecttheheatingoftheplanetarybodybytheimpactitself.Weassumetheimpactorcoretobeatrestatthebeginningofthesimulation.Asystematicinvestigationoftheinfluenceofsilicaterheology,temperatureanddiapirradiiondifferent-sizedprotoplanetsisbeingperformed.Weshowthatdependingonthesilicaterheology,whichisstronglydependentonthewatercontentofolivine(KatayamaandKarato,2008)andtheinitialtemperatureprofile,plasticyieldingandshearlocalizationtakeplaceanddifferentregimesofcoreformationappear:Forweakplanetaryinteriorsirondiapirssinkincollectivegroups,similartoalreadypublishedcoreformationmodels (e.g.ZietheandSpohn,2007).Forhighlyviscousplanetsanasymmetricironlayerforms,whichsurroundsthecentralpartoftheplanetoramixtureofdiapirismandfracturingmechanismdevelops.ResultsincludinglargediapirsindicatethatforMars-sizedandlargerbodiesarunawaydifferentiationprocesscanbeindu-ced.Wederivescalinglaws,whichpredicttheonsetofplasticyieldingandshearlocalizationinthesilicatesandoftheru-nawaydifferentiationprocessandtheassociatedcoreformationmodes.Thefinaltemperatureprofilesofthedifferentcoreformationmodesarediscussedwithregardtotheirinfluenceontheonsetofmantleconvection.
REFERENCESGerya, T.V.& Yuen,D.A. 2007: Robust characteristicsmethod formodellingmultiphase visco-elasto-plastic thermo-
mechanicalproblems.Phys.EarthPlanetInt.,163,83-105.Katayama, I.&Karato, S.-i., 2008: Low-temperature,high-stressdeformationofolivineunderwater-saturated conditions.
Phys.EarthPlanet.Int.,168,125–133.Ricard,Y.,Šrámek,O.&Dubuffet,F.2009:Amultiphasemodelofrunawaycore-mantlesegregationinplanetaryembryos.
EarthPlanet.Sci.Lett.,284,144-150.Stevenson,D.J.1981:ModelsoftheEarth’score.Science,214,611-619.Ziethe,R.&Spohn,T.2007:Two-dimensionalstokesflowaroundaheatedcylinder:Apossibleapplicationfordiapirsinthe
mantle.J.Geophys.Res.,112,B09403.
2.19
Towards self-consistent modelling of the Martian dichotomy: Coupled models of simultaneous core and crust formation
GolabekGregor*,KellerTobias*,GeryaTaras*&ConnollyJames**
*Institut für Geophysik, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])**Institut für Mineralogie und Petrologie, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zürich
OneofthemoststrikingsurfacefeaturesonMarsisthecrustaldichotomy,alargedifferenceinelevationandcrustalthick-nessbetweenthesouthernhighlandsandthenorthernlowlands.ThedichotomyisamongtheoldestgeologicalfeaturesonMarsandwasformedmorethan4.1Gaago(Solomonetal.,2005)owingtoeitherexogenicorendogenicprocesses(e.g.KellerandTackley,2009). Inordertofindaninternaloriginofthecrustaldichotomy,locatedwithinamaximumof400Maofplanetarydifferentiation,thethermalstateoftheplanetresultingfromcoreformationneedstobeconsidered.BasedonthegeochemicalanalysisofSNCmeteorites itwas suggested thataprimordial crustwithup to45kmthicknesscanbeformedalreadyduringtheMartiancoreformation(Norman,1999).Thereforewesuggestthatthesinkingofirondiapirsdeliveredbypre-differentiated impactors inducedshearheating-relatedtemperatureanomalies inthemantle,whichfos-teredtheformationofearlyMartiancrust.Inthisstudy,weexamineparametersetsthatwilllikelycauseanonsetofhemi-sphericallow-degreemantleconvectiondirectlyafter,andcoupledto,analreadyhemisphericallyasymmetricalcoreforma-tion.Totestthishypothesisweuseanumericalmodel,whereweself-consistentlycoupletheformationoftheMartianiron
82Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s coretotheonsetofmantleconvection.Peridotitemeltingisenabledtotrackmeltingandcrustformationcausedbyheatreleasedfromcoreformationandradioactiveheating.We perform 2D simulations using the code I2ELVIS applying the recently developed “spherical-Cartesian”methodology(GeryaandYuen,2007).ItcombinesfinitedifferencesonafullystaggeredrectangularEuleriangridwithLagrangianmarker-in-celltechniquetosolvemomentum,continuityandtemperatureequationsaswellasthePoissonequa-tionforgravitypotentialinaself-gravitatingplanetarybody.Inourmodelsetup,theplanetissurroundedbyalowviscosity,masslessfluid(“stickyair”)tosimulateafreesurface.Weapplyatemperature-andstress-dependentviscoplasticrheologyinsideaMars-sizedplanet.Radioactiveandshear-heatingaswellasconsumptionoflatentheatbysilicatemeltingaretakenintoaccount.Thedepthofneutralbuoyancyofsilicatemeltwithrespecttosolidsilicatesisdeterminedbythedifferenceincompressibilityoftheliquidandsolidphase.Toself-consistentlysimulatethesilicatephasechangesexpectedinsideaMars-sizedbody,weemploythethermodynamicalPerple_Xdatabase (Connolly,2005).As initialcondition,weapplyrandomlydistributedirondiapirswith75kmradiusinsidetheplanet,representingthecoresofstochasticallydistributedimpactorscharacteristicforthelateaccretionstageofterrestrialplanets.Additionally,weexploretheeffectofonegiantimpactorcoreontheplanetaryevolution.Results indicate that the presence of a large impactor core induces hemispherically asymmetrical core formation.Furthermore,theamplitudeofshearheatinganomaliesgenerallywellexceedsthesolidusofprimitivemantlematerial.Theformationofaconsiderableamountofsilicatemeltisobserved.Someofthegeneratedmeltsegregatestothesurfacetoformprimordialcrust,whereasnegativelybuoyantmeltfromdeepersourcessinkstotheCMB.Thehemisphericalasymmetryintemperatureinducedbyagiantimpactorworksinfavourofanonsetoflow-degreemantleconvectionaftercoreformation.Suchahemisphericalconvectiongeometrymightsubsequentlybesustainedbyphase-dependentviscosity(KellerandTackley,2009),andthusharbouranearlydevelopmentofadichotomouscrustalthicknessdistribution.
REFERENCESConnolly, J.A.D.2005:Computationofphaseequilibriaby linearprogramming:A tool forgeodynamicmodelingand its
applicationtosubductionzonedecarbonation.EarthPlanet.Sci.Lett.,236,524–541.Gerya, T.V.& Yuen,D.A. 2007: Robust characteristicsmethod formodellingmultiphase visco-elasto-plastic thermo-
mechanicalproblems.Phys.EarthPlanetInt.,163,83-105.Keller, T. & Tackley, P.J. 2009: Towards self-consistent modelling of the Martian dichotomy: The influence of one-ridge
convection on crustal thickness distribution. Icarus, 202, 429–443.Norman, M.D. 1999: The composition and thickness of the crust of Mars estimated from rare Earth elements and
neodymium-isotopic compositions of Martian meteorites. Meteorit. Planet. Sci., 34, 439–449.Solomon S.C., Aharonson, O., Aurnou J.M., Banerdt W.B., Carr M.H., et al. 2005 : New perspectives on ancient Mars.
Science, 307,1214–20.
2.20
Integrated U/Pb, (U-Th)/He and oxygen stable isotope study on zircon of a normal fault zone of the western Alps, Switzerland
I.Guerra*,D.Stockli**,F.Corfu***,F.Negro****,N.Mancktelow*****andT.Vennemann*
*Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland ([email protected]) **Department of Geology, University of Kansas, 1475 Jayhawk Boulevard, Lawrence KS 66045-7613, USA***Department of Geosciences, University of Oslo, Sem Sælands vei 1 Blindern, 0316 Oslo, Norway****Centre d’Hydrogéologie et Géothermie, Université de Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel, Switzerland*****Geologisches Institut, ETH Zürich, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich, Switzerland
Small,euhedralzircons(upto80µminlength)werefoundinlatehematite-andquartz-richveinsoftheArollaarea(westernAlps,Switzerland), crosscutting twodifferent typesofAlpineunits: theDentBlancheKlippeandtheTsatéNappe.Thesezircons–togetherwithzirconsintherelativehostrocks–havebeeninvestigatedfortheirU/Pb,(U-Th)/He,andoxygeniso-topecompositionsinordertodeterminethethermalhistoryofthisportionoftheAlpsviathecoolingpathoftheseminer-als.
U/Pbanalysisindicatesthatthezircons–bothinthelateveinsandinthehostrock-haveabsoluteradiometricagescluste-ringaround270-280Ma,whichistheacceptedageforintrusiverocksfromtheAustroalpineDentBlancheunitsbutwhichisinapparentcontrastwiththeinterpretationoftheTsatéNappeasanophioliticremnantoftheJurassicLiguro-PiemontaisOcean.TheotherconclusionoftheseU/Pbanalysesisthatthezirconsinthelateveinsareallinheritedfromthehostrock.
83
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
Thesamesampleswereinvestigatedwiththe(U-Th)/Hemethod.Firstresultsindicatethatthecoolingagesforthehostrocksaredifferentcomparedtothecoolingagesforthezirconsinlateveins:inparticularthecalculatedcoolingagefortheArollagneissis25.5±2.0Ma,whilethecoolingagefortheassociatedmineralizedfaultplaneis17.7±1.4Ma.ThecoolingagesfortheTsatémetagabbroclusteraround30Mawithoneimportantexceptionat311.8±36.9Mathatneedstobefurtherinve-stigated.
Oxygenstable isotope fractionationsbetweenquartzandhematite in the same lateveinscorrespond to temperaturesofabout170°C.Theproximityofthecalculatedemplacementtemperatureforlateveinsandtheloweracceptedclosuretem-peratureforzirconinthe(U-Th)/Hesystem(~180°C,Reinersetal.,2004)implythattheageof17.7±1.4Macanbeinterpretedastheformationageofthislatebrittlefracture.
Furtheranalysesonthetwounitsareinprogressandfocusontwomaindirections:1)analysisofothermineralizednormalfaultplanestocomparetheircoolingagewiththecoolingageoftheirrespectivehostrock,and2)coolingagedetermina-tionsonthehostrockstobetterunderstandtheregionalthermalpathofthisportionoftheAlps,whichissofarpoorlyunderstood.
REFERENCESReiners, P.W., Spell, t. L.,Nicolescu, S. andZanetti,K.A. (2004): Zircon (U-Th)/He thermochronometry:Hediffusionand
comparisonswith40Ar/39Ardating.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta68,1857-1887.
2.21
Quaternary fluvial patterns on the in-land Makran accretionary wedge (SE IRAN)
HaghipourNegar*,**,BurgJean-Pierre*,KoberFlorian*&ZeilingerGerold***
*Geological Institute, ETH Zurich, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])**Geological Survey of Iran, Meraj Avenue, Azadi Square, P.O. Box 13185-1494,Tehran, Iran***Institute für Geowissenschaften, Universität Postdam, D-14476 Golm, Deutschland
WedocumentthefivemostimportantdrainagebasinsoftheIranianMakranandtheirfluvialterracestoinvestigatethesurfacerecordoftheon-goingMakransubductionzone.Wecomparestreamprofilesextractedfrom30mresolutionDEM-Asterimagesusingaslope-areamodelforthemainchannelofeachcatchment.Thefivestudiedriversaretransverseandflowfromthenortherncrestlineoftheaccretionarywedgetothecoastalplain,inthesouth.Thestream-profilesshowaconvex-uppatternthatsuggestsdisequilibriuminthewesternandeasternpartsofthesubductionzone,inIran;thisisincontrastwiththecentralpart,whereoneriverhastheconcave-upprofileexpectedfromanequilibriumstate.Theknick-zonesalongallriverprofilescoincidewithmajorfaultsandfoldsratherthanlitholo-gicalchanges.Theresultsfromslope-areadata,steepnessindex(Ks)andconcavityindex(θ)suggestaspatiallyvariablesurfaceuplift.Thesouthwarddivergenceoftheprojectedstrathterracesof2oftheseriversfurtherindicatesdifferentialbedrockupliftinthesouthcomparedtothemorehomogeneousnortherninnerMakran.Fieldmappingofthefluvialterraces,complementedbyinformationfromaerialphotos,topographicmapsandheightcor-relation,reveals5regionalterracelevels.Temporalcorrelationofthesefivelevels,usingterrestrialcosmogenicnuclides(TCN)datingmethod,isinprogress.Thistimeinformationwillconstrainthereconstructionofthepaleo-valleysofthestudiedriversandwillprovideaframeforpreciseestimatesofthesurfaceupliftrate,incisionrateandthetectonicsignificanceofverticalsurfacemovementsonaccretionarywedges.
84Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.22
Strain localization in quartz mylonites of the Simplon Fault, Central Alps
HärtelMike*&HerweghMarco*
*Institut for Geoscience, University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1+3
TheSimplonFaultzone(SFZ)isamajordetachmentfaultbetweentheUpperandLowerPenninicUnitsintheCentralAlpsandcomprisesmyloniticmicrostructuresdeformedunderthepresenceofwater(Mancktelow&Pennacchioni2004andre-ferencestherein)atmetamorphicconditionsrangingfromlowergreenschistfacies(N)toupperamphibolitefaciescondi-tions inawater richenvironment (S). Inorder to study strain localizationhistory in this large-scale structure,differentsampleserieswerecollectedalongprofilesacrosstheSimplonfaulttoinvestigatethechangesindynamicrecrystallizationmechanisms,couplingofquartzgrainsize,presenceofsecondphasesandcrystallographicpreferredorientation(CPO).Inthecaseofpurequartzmylonites(formerqtzveinsandqtzlenses),ribbongrainsoccurwithina900meterwidehighstrainzone.Therecrystallizedgrainsizeinthisfaultzonegenerallyisreducedcomparedtotheundeformedveins,butthedegreeofgrainsizereductionvariesstrongly.Intermsofdynamicrecrystallization,thesmallestgrainsizescorrelatewithbulgingrecrystallizationandsubgrainrotationrecrystallization.However,alsocombinationsofgrainboundarymigrationrecrystal-lizationeitherwithbulgingnucleationorsubgrainrotationoccur.Insuchmicrofabrics,themeanrecrystallizedgrainsizeisrelativelylarge.Interestingly,thesegrainsizechangesarenotsystematicallyasafunctionofdistancetothefaultcontactbutratheroccurinformofdifferentdomains.IntermsofCPO,astrengtheningisobservedtowardsthecontactexceptatthecontactitself,weretheoccurrenceofcataclasitesinducedaCPOweakening.Basedontheseobservations,andpreviousstudiesofHirth&Tullis(1992)andStippetal.(2002),wesuggestthattheobservedchangesingrainsizeandrecrystallizationmechanismarerelatedtoacooling-inducedstrainlocalizationduringprogressivedeformation.Thefactthathightempera-turemicrostructuresarejuxtaposedtolowtemperaturemicrostructuresindicatesanoverprintoftheoldhigh-temperaturedeformationhistoryunderlowertemperatureconditions.Interestingly,thislaterstrainlocalizationdidnotresultinasym-metric strain localizationpattern in the large-scale shear zonebut rather shows local variations, eventuallypointing toepisodicchangesinthespatialdistributionofdeformationduringtheevolutionoftheSimplonfault.
REFERENCESHirth,G.andTullis,J.,1992:Dislocationcreepregimesinquartzaggregates.J.Struct.Geol.,14(2):145-159.Mancktelow,N.S. andPennacchioni,G., 2004: The influenceof grainboundary fluidson themicrostructureofquartz-
feldsparmylonites.JournalofStructuralGeology,26(1):47-69.Stipp,M., Stünitz,H.,Heilbronner,R. andSchmid, S.M., 2002:Dynamic recrystallizationofquartz: correlationbetween
natural and experimental conditions. In: S. deMeer,M.R. Drury, J.H.P. de Bresser andG.M. Pennock (Editors),DeformationMechanisms, Rheology and Tectonics: Current Status and Future Perspectives. Special Publications.GeologicalSociety,London,pp.171-190.
2.23
Petrography and geochemistry of upper mantle and lower crust of supra-subduction (?) ophiolites in the Makran, SE Iran
HunzikerDaniela*,BurgJean-Pierre*,BouilholPierre**,JafarOmrani***
*Geological Institute, Structural Geology and Tectonics, ETH Zurich, Sonneggstrasse 5, NO E69, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])**Department of Earth, Atmospheric and Planetary Science, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts Avenue Cambridge, MA02139, USA***Geological Survey of Iran, Meraj Avenue, Azadi Square, P.O.Box 13185-1494, Tehran, Iran
Ophiolites archive tectonic and chemical processes in oceanic lithosphere from its crystallization to accretionary stagesduringobductionand/orcontinentalcollision.Theoriginofophiolitesissubjecttodiscusssincetheycanevolveinvariousgeotectonicsettingswhosediscriminationischallenging.Despite excellent outcrop conditions and exposure of a complete sequence, the Remeshk/Mokhtaramabad and Fannuj/MaskutanophioliticcomplexesintheSoutheastIranianMakranareahavebeenveryscarcelysurveyed.TheseophiolitesaresituatedalongthenorthernboundaryoftheinnerMakranaccretionarywedge,abovetheactivesubductionoftheArabianplatebeneath theEurasia.Wepresent first resultsonstructures,petrography,geochemistryandgeochronologyof theseophiolites.Theultimategoalistoreconstructtheiroriginalgeotectonicsetting,themagmaticprocessesthatproducedthemandthetectonicevolutionofthearea.
85
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsTemporalandstructuralrelationsbetweenthedifferentlithologieshavebeenestablishedanddetailedcrosssectionsillus-
trateourpreliminarymap,muchmoreprecisethanpreviousones.Theextensiveultramaficcomplexescomprisealower,harzburgite-dominatedunitwithfewlherzolitesoverlainbydunites.Pyroxene-bearingperidotitesshowtypicalfeaturesoftectonizedmantledeformedatsub-solidusconditions.Theolivinechemistry(xMg=0.90-0.91,NiOcontentof0.4-0.45wt%)indicatesthattheyrepresentophioliticuppermantle.MostdunitesarecharacterizedbycumulatetexturesinolivineandaslightlylowerxMg=0.88-0.89andNiOcontentof0.27-0.35wt%.Dunitesarelocallyimpregnatedbyplagioclase-richmeltswithminor amounts of clinopyroxene and intruded bymany gabbroic dykes,whichmark the transition zone betweenmantleandcrust.Thegabbroicsequenceabovethedunitesdisplaysincreasinglydifferentiatedrocksoriginatedfromthesamemagmasource,upwardinthefollowingorder:troctolite-olivinegabbro–gabbro-anorthositicdykes-diabase.Theserocksarelaterintru-dedbyplagiogranitesandhornblende-gabbroswhoseassociationwiththeophiolitesisnotclarified.BulkrockandmineralcompositionsshowoceanicfeaturesofafastspreadingMOR,butsomeindicatecrystallizationinasupra-subductionrealm.TraceelementanalysesandgeochronologywillconstraintheevolutionoftheMakranophiolites.
2.24
Brittle deformation bands in the sandstones of the Western Swiss Molasse Basin
Ibele,Tobias*,Matzenauer,Eva*,Mosar,Jon*
*Départment de Géosciences Université de Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 6, CH-1700 Fribourg ([email protected])
Brittledeformationinporoussandstonewasdescribedtotakeplaceascataclasisonagrainsizescale,formingdeformationbands(DB)(Aydin1978).Thesebrittledeformationbandstypicallyareafewmmwidezonesofreducedporosityasaresultofreducedgrainsizesbyfracturing.Thedenserpackingoftheangularsubgrainsleadstostrainhardeningandsubsequent-lyongoingdeformationcreatesnewDBssub-paralleltotheinitialones.Increasingstrainiscompensatedbyseveralanasta-mosingDBsformingdeformationbandshearzones(DBSZ)whichareuptoseveraltensofcentimetreswideandoftenendupwithadiscreteslipsurface (Aydin&Johnson1978).TheprocessofformingbrittleDBswasdescribedtotakeplaceinporoussandstonesoftheupperfewkmofthecrustaswellasinunconsolidatedclasticsedimentsnearthesurface(Cashman&Cashman2000).
InourstudyDBsturnedouttobeaprominenttectonicstructureintheWesternSwissMolassebasinthattogetherwithslickensidesinfaultzonestakeupaconsiderableamountofdeformation.Althoughtheyarehithertoundescribedfromthearea,theyareabundantinthesandstonesoftheLowerFreshwaterandUpperMarineMolasse(USMandOMM).Duringstruc-turalfieldworkwefrequentlyfoundsingleDBs,largeDBSZswithandwithoutslip-planesandnetworksofDBSZsthatin-tersectandoffseteachotherindicatingsuccessiveevents.Investigationofthinsectionsshowedtypicalzonesoffracturedgrainsaswellasveryfinefaultgaugeswithapoorlyevolvedfoliation.SomeoftheDBsarefoundtobecementedbycalcitebutmostofthemareformedbyunconsolidatedfaultgauges,whichissuggestivetoarelativelowdepthand/orrecenttimeoftheirformation.InonecaseasynkinematicleygrownwhitemicaassociatedwithaSCstructurewasfoundtofillthecoreofaDB,pointingtowardsspecialconditionsduringdeforma-tionincludingfluidsandprobablyacertainburialdepth.Furthermoresuchwhitemicaofferstheopportunityofquantita-tivedatingbutfeasibilityisstillunclearinourcase.
WithinnetworksofDBSZsomeofthecrosscuttingrelationshipsaresystematicwithrespecttoorientationbutarenotsyste-maticwithrespectivechronologytotimesequence,indicatingacontemporaneousevolutionasRiedelsystems.Theorienta-tionandkinematicsofthemappedDBscorrelateswellwiththeoneselaboratedfromslickensidesinthestudyareaastheyareright-lateralwhenstrikingWNW-ESEandleft-lateralwhenstrikingN-S.TheydeforminastrikeslipregimewithNW-SEcompressionthatstartedintheupperMioceneandpersistsuntilrecenttimes.
REFERENCESAydin,A.1978:Smallfaultsformedasdeformationbandsinsandstone,PureandAppliedGeophysics116,913-930.Aydin,A.&Johnson,A.M.1978:Developmentoffaultsaszonesofdeformationbandsandasslipsurfacesinsandstone,Pure
andAppliedGeophysics116,931-942.Cashman, S.&Cashman,K. 2000:Cataclasis anddeformation-band formation inunconsolidatedmarine terrace sand,
HumboldtCounty,California,Geology28,2,111-114.
86Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.25
Lateral fold identification in Northern Tunisia Thrust Belt front
*AridhiKais,**MohamedAbdoullahOuldBagga,*SaâdiAbdeljaouad,*FouadZargouniand***EricMercier
*Faculty of Sciences of Tunisia, Department of Geology, 2092 Tunis-El Manar I -Tunisia ([email protected]).** Faculty of Sciences of Gabès, Department of earth sciences, City Riadh Zrig-1030 - Gabès -Tunisia.*** Science and Technical Faculty of Nantes - France.
Tectonictransportofsedimentarysequencesledtotheirdeformationinfault-related-foldsknowninthetectonicstyleas"rampfolds".Someofthesefoldscalledfrontalrampfolds,striketransversallytothethrusttransport,whereasthelateralfolds,developparalleltothisdirection.However,thepresenceoffoldaxisorientedatahighanglewithrespecttothetrans-portdirectionmayreflectvariousdeformationkinematicsandmechanisms,ashighlightedbyWilkersonetal.(2002)andFrizondeLamotteetal.,(1995).IntheTunisianthrustandfoldbelt,(fig.1)thefaultrelatedfoldswererecognizedonlyinarecentdate,OueldBaggaetal.,(2006).Andthefoldstructureswereallinterpretedasfrontalfolds.Inthisworkwewillevidencebymeanoftwofieldexa-mples,thepresenceoflateralfoldsandwewilldiscussthegeometricalfeaturessuggestingtheirformationkinematics.ThefirstexampleisilustratedbytheAïnelBeystructure,whichbelongtotheexternaledgeofthenorthernTunisianbelt;thesecondexampleconcernsalocalstructureintheNumidianthrustsheet(fig.2-3).Inthissetting,wewillshowthatthesefoldorientationswithrespecttothetransportdirection,theirlimbdipvariation,thethrustfaultmigration,theexistenceofbedcut-offaswellassedimentarycriteria,suggestallthatthesefoldsarerelatedtopre-existingsynsedimentaryfaultsthatwerereactivatedduringthetectonicinversionaslateralrampfaults.Wewillaswellshowthatthepreviousstructuralandsedimentarydataarenotsuitablewithlateral foldformationasaconsequenceofsuperimposedtectonicstrain,oradrugalongstrikefaultsoradecreaseoftheslipmagnitudealongthefrontalfaults.
Fig.1:Alpinegeologybelt(DurandDELGA,1980)andareaofstudylocalization(extractedtogeo-logicalmapofTunisia1/500000),modified
87
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
Fig.2:transverseandlongitudinalSectiononthelevelofAinElBeystruc-
Fig.3:sectionsintheNumidianthrustsheet
REFERENCEM.ScottWilkerson,TedApotriaandTammerFarid,(2002):Interpretingthegeologicmapexpressionofcontractionalfault
relatedfoldterminations:lateral/obliquerampsversusdisplacementgradients.Journalofstructuralgeology,2002,vol.24,no4,pp.593-607.
Frizonde Lamotte and JEAN-CLAUDEGUEZOU, (1995):Distinguishing lateral folds in thrust-systems; examples fromCorbihres(SWFrance)andBeticCordilleras(SESpain).JournalofStructuralGeology,1995,Vol.17,No.2,pp.233to244.
MohamedAbdoullahOuldBagga,SaâdiAbdeljaouadandEricMercier,(2006):La«zonedesnappes»deTunisie:unemargeméso-cénozoïque enblocs basculésmodérément inversée (régionde Taberka/Jendouba ; Tunisienord-occidentale),BulletindelaSociétéGéologiquedeFrance;May2006;v.177;no.3;p.145-154.
88Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.26
Insights in the dynamics of free subduction from semi-analytical and numerical models.
KausBorisJ.P.*,**,Becker,ThorstenW.
*Geophysical Fluid Dynamics, Department of Earth Sciences, Schaffmattstrasse 30, CH-8093 Zurich ([email protected])**University of Southern California, Los Angeles, USA.
Subductionzonedynamicshasbeenextensivelystudiedwithlaboratorymodelsinwhichadense,highviscosityslabsinksintoalessdenseandlessviscousmantle.
Recently,itwasfoundthattheselaboratoryresultscouldbereproducedwithnumericalmodelsiftheupperboundarycon-ditionisatruefreesurface,orifaweak‘sticky-air’layerisemployed[Schmelingetal,2008].
Yet,ourinsightinthedynamicsofsubductionremainssomewhatlimitedandnoscalinglawexiststhatpredictsslabveloci-ty(orslabbehavior)asafunctionofslabthickness,slab/mantleviscosityratioandslab/mantledensitydifference.Existingscalinglaws,suchastheapproachofConradandHager[1999,JGR],relyonknowingtheradiusofcurvatureofsubductingslabs,whichisaparameterthatistypicallyknownonlyafteranexperimenthasbeenperformed.
Forthisreason,wehereperformadditional2Dnumericalsimulationsinwhichweaddresstheeffectsofnumerics(resolu-tion,timestep),initialgeometry(slabtiplengthandangle),andrheologyonsubductiondynamicsinthepresenceofafreesurface.
Resultsconfirmearlierfindingsthatslabdynamicsistoalargeextendcontrolledbytheeffectiveviscositycontrastbetweenslabandmantle.Twomaindeformationmodesexistasafunctionofviscositycontrast:the‘drip’or‘Rayleigh-Taylor’modeoccursforviscositycontrastssmallerthanabout100,andisdominatedbyslab-stretchingandnon-constanthorizontalplatevelocities(whicharesignificantlylargertowardsthetrench).The‘plate’mode,ontheotherhand,occursforviscositycon-trastslargerthan500andischaracterizedbyslabsthatdonotchangetheirinitiallengthduringsubduction.Horizontalplatevelocitiesarehomogeneousalongtheslabtopandbendingoccursinthetrencharea,withabendingradiusthatde-pendsonviscositycontrastandslabthickness.Intheplatemode,theinitialslabtiplengthandanglehaveasignificantef-fectontheinitialsubductionrate.Aftertheslabtipreachedadepthofseveralhundredsofkm,however,subductionvelo-citiesarelargelyindependentontheinitialgeometryandaredescribedbyamodifiedStokeslaw.
Wedevelopedasemi-analyticalsubductionmodelbycombiningthisvelocityparameterizationwiththinviscoussheetequa-tions.Itisdemonstratedthatgoodagreementexistsbetweennumericalandanalyticalmodels,bothintermsofgeometryandintermsoftemporalevolution.
Inanextstep,theanalyticalmodelwasemployedtoderivescalinglawsforslabradius,whichscalesas1/3totheviscositycontrast,butisnearlylinearlydependentonslabthickness.Aconsequenceofthisisthatslab-dissipationisnomorethenabout25percentofthedissipationinthemantle.Moreover,itcanbedemonstratedthatstretchingdominatesslabbendingforslab-mantleviscositycontrastsoflessthanabout100(withaweakdependenceofslabthickness),inagreementwiththenumericalsimulations.
Thesemi-analyticalresultsareusedtoderiveaphasediagramforslab-dynamicsonEarth,whichpredictsseveralsubductionmodestoexist,ifaviscosityincreaseatthe660kmphasetransitionispresent,inagreementwithpreliminarynumericalsimulations.
89
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.27
Numerical models of fluid migration in a tectonically active continental crust
KellerTobias,KausBorisJ.P.
Institute of Geophysics, ETH Zürich, Sonneggstr. 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])
TheflowofalowviscosityfluidthroughtheporespaceofarigidmatrixisdescribedbyDarcy’slaw,statingthattheDarcyfluxq
Disgivenby
qD = Φ*(v
f - v
s) = - kΦ/η
f * ∇P
ex
,whereΦistheporosityoftherigidmatrix,vfandv
sthefluidandsolidvelocities,kΦ thepermeabilityofthematrix,η
fthe
dynamicfluidviscosityand∇Pexthegradientoftheexcessfluidpressure(fluidpressureexceedinghydrostaticpressure).
Weinvestigatethebehaviourofatwophase-systeminvolvingpartialmeltpercolatingthroughacontinentalcrust,whichitselfisbeingdeformedaccordingtoviscoelastoplasticincompressibleStokesflow.Todoso,weassumethatthefluidpres-sureisequaltothesolidpressureandthereforewecantake∇P
ex=∇P
sol-ρ
fg.Thesolidcompactiontermusuallypresentin
coupledStokes-Darcyproblemsisneglectedhere,sincethecompactionlengthscaleforparametersrelevanttoourproblemisontheorderof0.1-1km,whichisbelowournumericalresolution.
Thenumericalsetupinvolvesacontinentalcrustof20-30kmthicknessoverlyingthemantlelithosphere.Atthelithosphere-asthenosphereboundary,weintroduceasourceregionofpartialmelt,eithercylindricaloruniformlydistributed.Thesub-sequentpercolationofmelt through the crust is computeddependingas a functionofdynamicpressurewhichevolveswhilethecrustistectonicallydeformedineitherextensionalorcompressionalregime.
Firstresultsindicatethatboththegeometryandspatialevolutionofhighporositychannelsarestronglyrelatedtotheregi-onalstressfield.Weobserveverticalchannelsforextensionaltectonicsandhorizontalonesincompressionalenvironments.Additionally,thedarcyfluxtendstobeconcentratedinplasticfaultzonesdevelopingintheuppercrust.
Inamoregeneralsensetheresults indicatethatpartialmeltoriginatingintheuppermantlecanproducestress-relatedhigh-porosityzoneswhilepercolatingthroughatectonicallyactivecontinentalcrust.Wherebrittlefaultsarepresent,po-rousflowcanbeconcentratedtowardsthem.Onepossibleapplicationofthistypeofmodelscouldbetheemplacementofhydratedslabmeltsintotheoverridingplateinanocean-continentcollisionzone.
90Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.28
Flow mechanisms in granitic ultramylonites
RüdigerKilian*,RenéeHeilbronner*,HolgerStünitz**,MarcoHerwegh****
*Geological Institute, University Basel, Switzerland ([email protected])**Geological Institute, University Tromsø, Norway; ***Institute of Geological Sciences, University Bern, Switzerland
In theGranParadisometagranodiorite small scaleductile shearzonesdevelopedat loweramphibolite faciesconditions.Alongthestraingradientfromthehostrocktothecenteroftheshearzoneweobservethetransitionfrommm-sized,(1)non-recrystallizedigneousquartzgrainsto(2)entirelyrecrystallized,polycrystallinequartzaggregates,to(3)planar,poly-crystallinequartzlayersto(4)dispersedquartzgrainsinapolymineralicmatrix.Inthehigherstrainparts(3)thematrixconsistsofamixtureofplagioclase,K-feldsparandbiotite(+/-whitemica).Quartzisthemorecompetentrheologicalphasewhichisdemonstratedbythegeometricalrelationofthequartzclastsandthema-trix.Publishedexperimentallyderivedflowlawsalsosupportthisinterpretation.Withincreasingstrain,aggregatesbecomeelongatedandformlayersofdecreasingthicknessalternatingwithmatrixlayers.Thedominantslipsystemisbasal<a>leadingtoastrongtexturewithac-axisperipheralmaximumslightlyrotatedwiththesenseofshearwithrespecttothelocalfoliationasthereferenceframe.Ashapepreferredorientationdevelopscorrespon-dingtothec-axisorientation.Thegrainsizeremainsconstantthroughoutthestraingradientwithameanequivalentdia-meterofabout100µm(volumeweighted).Inthemosthighlystrainedparts(4)aphasemixturedevelopswithhomogeneouslydispersedquartzgrains.Thetextureofthequartzisweakened,theshapepreferredorientationsystematicallychangesfromamonoclinictoanorthorhombicgeo-metryandthequartzgrainsizedecreasestoameanequivalentdiameterof60µm(volumeweighted).The microstructural development with increasing strain is associated with a change from dislocation creep in quartz aggre-gates to granular flow. We present a model for the process of disintegration of quartz aggregates and the coeval grain size reduction. The dominant deformation mechanism is grain boundary sliding accommodated by solution transfer. We conclude that the quartz grain size reduction is primarily achieved by phase boundary migration, nucleation and growth. The disinte-gration of aggregates and the dispersion of grains reflect that processes involved during dislocation creep can not accommo-date grain scale strain incompatibilities in quartz at the stress level imposed by the matrix.
2.29
Comparing thin-sheet models with three-dimensional numerical models for the India-Asia collision
LechmannSarahM.*,SchmalholzStefanM.*,KausBorisJ.P.**&HetényiGyörgy***
*Geologisches Institut, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])**Institut für Geophysik, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich***Institut für Mineralogie und Petrographie, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zürich
KnowledgeaboutthetectonicevolutionoftheTibetanPlateauisstillincompleteandmanyopenquestionsremainconcer-ningthedeformationstyleofthecrustalthickening,causingtheabnormallyhighelevationoftheTibetanPlateau.Differentmodelshavebeen suggestedexplaining the crustal thickeningby (1)homogeneous, continuousdeformationusing thin-sheetmodels, (2)discretemovementalongthrustsdevelopingcrustalwedgesand (3) lateralcrustal flowduetopressuregradientsresultingfromtopography.Mostexistingnumericalmodelsarenotfullythree-dimensional(3D)(e.g.thin-sheetmodels)andassumeacertaindeformationstyleapriori,whichmakesitdifficulttojudgetheapplicabilityofsuchcons-trainedmodelstotheformationoftheTibetanPlateau.Wepresentacomparisonofdeformationstylesduringcontinentindentationresultingfromafully3Dnumericalmodelandathin-sheetmodel.Therheologyforbothmodelsispower-law.The3Dmodelconsistsoffourlayersrepresentingasimplifiedlithosphere:stronguppercrust,weaklowercrust,stronguppermantleandweaklowermantle.Fromtheeffectiveviscositydistributionofthe3Dmodelaverticallyaveragedeffectiveviscosityiscalculatedandusedforthethin-sheetmodeltomakedirectcomparisonsbetweenthetwomodels.
91
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsSimulatingindentationisachievedbyassigningatripartitevelocityprofileatonelateralboundary:Aconstanthorizontal
velocityisappliedatonesection.Thevelocitythengraduallydecreasestowardszero,applyingacosine-function.Thelastsectionoftheindentingboundary is fixed.Theotherthreelateralboundariesshowfreeslip.The3Dmodeladditionallyexhibitsafreesurfaceandabottomboundaryallowingfreeslip.
Inthe3Dmodelfoldingandlowercrustalflowcantakeplace,whicharetwodeformationstylesthatareignoredinthethin-sheetmodel.Wequantifythedifferencesinthevelocityfieldresultingfromthetwomodels.Wefocusonareasaroundtheindentationcorners(theso-calledsyntaxes)becausetherethedifferencesinbothmodelsareexpectedtobelargest.Also,theHimalayansyntaxesarefull3Dstructureswhere3Ddeformationeffectsareexpectedtobestrongest.Applicationsofthe3DmodeltogetherwithavailablegeophysicaldatatotheHimalayansyntaxesandtheIndia-Asiacollisionarediscussed.
2.30
Strain localization and the importance of second phases in polymineralic mantle shear zones
Linckensjolien*,HerweghMarco*,MüntenerOthmar**
* Institute of Geological Sciences, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])**Institute of Mineralogy and Geochemistry, l'Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne
LocalizationofdeformationinshearzonesisacommonfeatureintheEarth’scrustanduppermantle(e.g.,thrusts,strikeslipfaults).Theevolutionofsuchhighstrainzonesisoftenlonglasting,incorporatingvariationsinphysical(e.g.P,T)andchemicalconditionswithtime.Aspreviously inferred fromstudiesonperidotiteshearzones, secondphases (e.g. spinel,pyroxenes)canbeimportantinlocalizingstrainastheycankeeptheolivinematrixgrainsizesmall.Theinfluenceofsecondphasesontheolivinegrainsizeandtheiraffectonstrainlocalizationhasnotyetbeenquantifiedindetail.Todeterminetheimportanceofsecondphasesinlocalizingstraininthemantle,threedifferentperidotiteshearzones(WadiHilti,Oman;Othris,GreeceandLanzo,Italy)wereanalyzedandcompared.InthecaseoftheOmanandLanzoperidotite,arangeofmicrostructures, fromporphyroclastic tectonites toultramyloniteswere investigated. Thesemicrostructures arerelatedtocontinuouslocalizationunderretrogradeconditions.Inaddition,mylonitesamplesoftheOthrisperidotitewereanalyzed.Similartopreviousstudiesperformedoncalcitemylonites,eachofthedifferentmantlemicrostructurescanbesubdividedintotwodifferentmicrofabrictypes:(a)secondphasecontrolledmicrostructures,wheretheolivinegrainsizeincreaseswithincreasingZenerparameter(Z=dp/fp;secondphasegrainsize/secondphasevolumefraction)(b)recrystallizationcontrolledmicrostructures,wheretheolivinegrainsizeshowsnodependenceonthesecond-phasecontentandremainsconstantwithincreasingZ.Theolivinegrainsizeforbothmicrofabrictypesbecomessmallerwithdecreasingtemperatureandstrainrate.ThedifferentperidotiteshearzonesshowthesamerelationbetweentheZenerparameterandtheolivinegrainsizewhenthedeformationconditions(e.g.temperatureandstrainrate)werethesame.Fromageodynamicpointofview,Zenertrendscanthereforebeappliedasatooltodeterminethedeformationconditionsandtheirvariationsinspaceandtimeincaseofmantlerocks.TheCPOofolivineinthedifferentmicrostructuresweakensgoingfromporphyroclastictectonitestoultramylonitesandalsowithdecreasingZenerparameter.This indicates that,withongoingstrain localizationandwith increasingsecond-phasecontent,diffusioncreepbecomesmoreimportantasdeformationmechanism.ThecombinationoftheZenertrendwitholivinedeformationmechanismmapsandCPOisagoodmethodtoassesstheimportanceofsecondphasesonstrainlocalization.Inthiswaythedominantdeformationmechanismandstrainrateinthedifferentmicrostructurescanbederived.Theanalysisoftheperidotiteshearzonesshowsthatwhenthereisaswitchindominantdeformationmechanismbetweenpureolivineandpolymineraliclayersorwhenbotharedeformedbygrainsizesensitivedeformation,thestrainrateisuptoanorderofmagnitudelargerinthepolymineraliclayers.
92Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.31
Numerical modeling of craton destruction
GangLu1,BorisKaus2,LiangZhao1
1 Institute of Geology and Geophysics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China2 Geophysical Fluid Dynamics, Department of Earth Sciences, ETH,8092,Switzerland
Archeancratonsarecharacterizedbyacold,thick,stablelithospherekeel.TheNorthChinaCraton(NCC),however,isanan-omaly.TheeasternNCCexperiencedsignificantlithosphericthinningintheLateMesozoictoCenozoic.Inordertounder-standthemechanismsoflithosphericthinning,weperformedasetofgeodynamicexperimentsusingMILAMIN_VEP,whichisbasedonthefiniteelementmethod.Thesetupinvolvesaflathomogeneouslithospherewithathicknessof190km.Theinfluencesof(a)lithosphereextension,(b)uppermantleconvectionand(c)thermalanomalybeneathlithosphereareinvestigatedseparatelyorsimultaneously.Inthecasesof(a),apushvelocityisimposedtoextendthelithospherewhiletheendoflithosphereisreplacedbymaterialwithlowviscosity.Inthecasesof(b),thermalanomaliesatthebottomofthemodelareusedtostarttheconvection.Incasesof(c),hightemperatureanomaliesareimposedjustbeneaththelithosphere.Weconcludefromourinitialexperimentsthat:(A)simpleextensioncanthinthewholelithospherehomogeneouslyatthebeginningandbreakthelithospherebyanormalfaultfinally,(B)downwellingsdominateconvectionafterabout10Myrs,independentof the initialmagnitudeof the temperatureanomaly.Thebottomof lithospherecanbepartlydestroyedatcertainplaceswherestabledownwellingforms,andgetsthickenagainafterthedownwellingdisappears,(C)asimplehightemperatureanomalybeneathlithospherehaslittleinfluencetothelithospherethinning.Itisthussuggestedthatextensi-onisacandidatemechanismofdestroyingacraton.
2.32
New experimental approach to measure seismic wave attenuation of rocks at low frequency
ClaudioMadonna*,NicolaTisato*,SébastienBoutareaud*,BradArtman**andLuigiBurlini*
*Structural Geology and Tectonics, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zurich ([email protected])**Spectraseis AG , Giessereistrasse 5, 8005 Zurich
Wedescribeanewexperimentalapproachtoaccuratelycharacterizeattenuationinfluid-bearingporousrocksamples.Anewapparatushasbeendevelopedandbuiltinordertomeasureattenuation(1/Q)ofseismicP-wavespassingthrougharocksampleinthelowfrequencyregime(0.1Hz -50Hz),employingthestress-strainmethodinaninternallyheatedgasapparatus(Patersonrig).Stressismeasuredwithaloadcellof1000Nfullscalewitharesolutionof0.01N.Strainismeasuredwithhigh-sensitiveLVDTsof1mmfullscaleandaresolutionof10-9m.Thisnewapparatusdiffersfrompreviousonesinthatitcanmeasurethebulkattenuationofanon-isotropic,non-homogeneous50-to-100mmlengthsamplebyavoidingstraingauges.Thequality factorQ isobtained fromthetimeshiftbetweenthesinusoidal stress,which ismechanicallyappliedat thebottomofthesample,andthesinusoidalstrainresponsemeasuredonthetopofthesample.Wepresentasketchoftheapparatusandweincludeadiscussionofsomeoftheproblemsencounteredwhilebuildingtheapparatus;wefurtherdiscussrecentimprovements.Inaddition,wepresentpreliminaryresultsandthecorrespondingdigi-talsignalprocessingonaluminium(asstandard)andBerea-sandstonepartiallysaturatedwithoilandwaterandcharacteri-zedbymeansoftomographicimages.Thisnewtechniquecanbeusedtoaccuratelyestablishacatalogof1/Qvaluesasafunctionofin-siturockproperties. Inparticular,futurestudiesusingthisapparatuswillinvestigatetheeffectsofdifferentfluidpropertieson1/Q.Suchnew,ac-curatemeasurementswillbeimportantinpassiveandactiveseismicinvestigationsonfluid-bearingrocks.
93
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.33
The Singularities of double subduction systems
Malatesta,Luca*;Mishin,Yury*;Gerya,TarasV.*
*Institute of Geophysics, ETH-Zurich, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland
Amongthetectonicprocessesoccurringat thesurfaceof theEarth, thedoublesubductionsystemsaresomeof the lessstudied.Bydoublesubductionsystem,weunderstandaconfigurationinwhichtheforceofaoneortwo-sidedaccretionistranslatedintwodistinctsubductionsnexttoeachotherdippinginthesamedirection.Theyarerelevantforbothmodern(Izu-Bonin-MarianasandRyukyuarcs,Hall(1997))andancienttectonics(westernHimalayas,Burg(2006)).Nexttotheirdocu-mentationinthefield,fewexperimentshavebeenperformedtounderstandtheirdynamics.Thefirstandonlynumericalmodelingoftheproblemuntilthepresentresearchhasbeensuccessful indeterminingthedynamicsofasimplemodel(Mishin,2008).Weperformedfurtherexperimentswiththesame2Dcoupledpetrological-thermomechanicalcode(GeryaandYuen,2003)butinamorecomplexsetup.Itencompassedanoceanicplatecontainingtwoweakzonesandboundwithtwocontinentalplates,oneofwhichmovingconstantlytowardstheother.Westudiedtheeffectsoffourkey-parameters:theageoftheoceanicplate,theactivationvolumeofthedislocationcreep,thecompositionoftheoceaniccrustandthelengthofthefirstsubductingslab(figure1).Theexperimentsledustotheconclusionthat(A)theageofanoceanicplateandtheactivationvolumeinfluencethesubductionssystemasfollow:theyare(i)linearlyandproportionallyrelatedtothebreak-offtimeand(ii)inverselyproportionaltotheroll-backpower.(B)Therelativethicknessofgabbrointhecrusthasdistincteffectsonthedippingslab:itis(i)inverselyproportionaltothebreak-offtimeand(ii)proportionaltothe660kmentryangle(C)Thesubductionregime(advancing,penetratingorretreatingmode)dependsontheslabentryangleinthe660kmdiscon-tinuityzone.Theentryanglesumsuptheotherparameters.Keyanglesdeterminingthedifferentregimesweredeterminedforagivenslablength.(D)thelengthofthefirstsubductedslabimpactsthegeometryoftheglobalsystembutdoesnotchangeitsdynamics.(E)Simultaneoussubductionscannotbeobtainedinaone-sidedaccretionwiththeinvestigatedmodel,furtherelements–absentfromthemodeling–shouldaccountforit.(F)Thesubductionregimeandorientation(i)canbepossiblyregainedthroughthestudyofsedimentationrecordbut(ii)isnotcoherentlylinkedtothestyleofthefinalorogeny.(G)Doublesubductionsystemsleadtoacomplexbasinevolutionoffore-andback-arcsandpro-andretro-forelands,andtoaspecificoverridepatternwhichcanmisleadtheinterpretationofthesubductionorientation.
Figure1.Evolutioninthreestepsofadoublesubductionnumericalmodel.Withthechemicalcompositioninthefirstrow,thevelocityin
thesecondandtheviscosityinthethird.
REFERENCESJ.-P.Burg.Twoorogenicsystemsandatransform-transferfaultintheHimalayas:evidenceandconsequence.EarthScience
Frontiers,13:27-46,2006.T.V.Gerya andD.A. Yuen.Characteristics-basedmarker-in-cellmethodwith conservative finite-difference schemes for
modellinggeological flowswith strongly variable transportproperties. Physicsof theEarthandPlanetary Interiors,140:295-320,2003.
R.Hall.CenozoicplatetectonicreconstructionsofSEAsia.GeologicalSocietyLondonSpecialPublication,126:11-23,1997.Y.Mishin,T.V.Gerya, J.-P.Burg,and J.A.Connoly.Dynamicsofdouble subductions:Numericalmodeling.Physicsof the
EarthandPlanetaryInteriors,171-280-195,2008.
94Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.34
CitcomSX: Robust preconditioning in CitcomS via PETSc
DaveA.May*,MatthewG.Knepley**,MikeGurnis***
* Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])** Computation Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago, IL, USA ([email protected])***Computational Infrastructure for Geodynamics, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA ([email protected]).
Theuseofnumericalsimulationstostudyconvectioninthemantlehasalongandrichhistoryingeodynamics.TheCitcomfamilyofmantleconvectioncodesareinwidespreadusethroughoutthegeodynamicscommunity.SincetheinceptionoftheoriginalCartesianversionwrittenbyLouisMoresiintheearly1990's,manyvariantshavebeendeveloped.TwoimportantcontributionsweremadebyShijieZhongintheformoftheparallel3DCartesianversionandtheparallel,fullsphericalversion.
TheComputationalInfrastructureforGeodynamics(CIG)havebeenprovidingmaintenanceandsupportforCitcomSoverthe last5years.TheCIGeffort toprovideacommunitymantleconvectioncodehas resulted in severaldevelopments toCitcomS.Theseincludetheadditionofnewphysics(rheology,compressibility),couplingwithothersoftware,theinclusionofadditionalgeologicallyrelevantinput/outputsandimprovedportability.SuchimprovementshaveseenafurtherincreaseinthedevelopmentandusageofthisparticularversionofCitcom.Today,CitcomSisroutinelyusedtosolvemantleconvec-tionandsubductionmodelswithapproximatelyonehundredmillionunknownsonlargedistributedmemoryclusters.
Manyadvanceshavebeenmadeinbothnumericallinearalgebraandthesoftwareencapsulatingthesemathematicalcon-ceptssincethedevelopmentoftheoriginalCitcom.However,thesolverusedbyallCitcomsoftwarehasremainedlargelyunchangedfromtheoriginalversion.IncorporatingmoderntechniquesintoCitcomShasthepotentialtogreatlyimprovetheflexibilityandrobustnessoftheiterativemethodsusedtosolvetheunderlyingsaddlepointproblem.HerewedescribehowPETSc(http://www.mcs.anl.gov/petsc),aflexiblelinearalgebrapackage,hasbeenintegratedintoCitcomSinanon-inva-sivefashionwhichi)preservesallthepre-existingfunctionalityandii)enablesarichinfrastructureofpreconditionedKrylovmethodstobeusedtosolvethediscreteStokesflowproblem.The"extension"ofthesolvercapabilitiesinCitcomShaspromp-tedthisversiontobereferredtoasCitcomSX.
WedemonstratetheadvantagesofCitcomSXbycomparingtheconvergencerateandsolutiontimeofthenewStokessolverwiththeoriginalCitcomSapproach.WeutiliseascaledBFBtpreconditionerwhichisconstructedviatheassumptionoftheexistenceofanapproximatecommutatorasapreconditionerfortheSchurcomplement.TheBFBtpreconditioneriscompo-sedofsmallersub-problemsforwhichefficient,robustandscalablemultilevelmethodsexist.HerewedemonstratethatthescaledBFBtweutiliseisrobustandyieldsconvergencerateslargelyindependentoftheelementresolutionandtheviscositycontrast.Usingthispreconditioner,wecanaccommodatehigherviscositycontrasts thanwerepossiblewiththeoriginalCitcomSsolver.Thetestproblemsusedforthesecomparisonsincludesimulationsofvariableviscositymantleconvection(regional,fullspherical)andslabsubduction(regional).
2.35
Seismotectonic study in Northern Tunisia (exemple: Utique Structure)
LassaadMejri1,2,4,5,VincentRegard1,2,3,SébastienCarretier1,2,3,StéphaneBrusset1,2,3,MahmoudDlala5
1. Université de Toulouse ; UPS (OMP) ; LMTG ; 14 Av Edouard Belin, F-31400 Toulouse, France 2. CNRS ; LMTG ; F-31400 Toulouse, France3. IRD ; LMTG ; F-31400 Toulouse, France4. CNSTN, Pôle technologique 2020 Sidi Thabet, Ariana, Tunisie5. Université de Tunis El Manar ; Faculté des Sciences de Tunis, 1060 Tunis, Tunisie
Thepresent-dayseismicityatnortheasternTunisiareportedfrompermanentnetworks isof lowtomoderatemagnitude.However,earthquakesarementionedintheliterature,speciallyadestructiveoneintheantiquecityofUtique.Geologic,seismic,andneotectonicinvestigationsinthisareashowsthatUtiquefoldiscloselyrelatedtotherecenttectonicactivityinthisregion.DatashowthatUtiquefoldisbuiltonanE-Wfault,andwefoundevidenceofactivityofthisfaultinthepast20ky.Seismicsectionandbalancedcrosssectionshowsthatitwasaffectedbytwophasesofcompressionaldeformation.The
95
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsfirstoneisoccurredduringMioceneandcausedfoldingoverapassiverampinTriassicsediment.Thetimingofthesecond
oneisunclearbecauseoflowdefinitionofseismicdatainitsuppermostpart:itclearlyoccurredafterSerravalian.Atotalshorteningof690mhasbeenmeasuredindicatinganaverageshorteningrateof0.14mm/yrsincethebeginningofPliocene.Asalreadymentioned,compressionmusthavebegunearlyinPleistocene(1.8My);thisleadstoamostlikelyvalueforshor-teningrateof0.38mm/yr,corresponding to~8%of thecurrent shortening inTunisia (~4.5mm/yr inadirectionN145°EbetweenstableAfricaandSardiniaafteracompilationofresultsfromD’AgostinoandSelvaggi[15]andHollensteinetal.).Fieldobservationsofsurfacefaulting,debrisoflessthan2000yearsoldpotteryreworkedandpossiblytiltedcalcareousno-dulesatthefaultzonesuggestthatthemaincompressionalphasecontinuesuptopresent.Utiquefaultoutcropsinagully~5mwideand~5mdeep.Thegullyseemstohaveexperiencedacomplicatedstorywithafirstincisionstagefollowedbyrecentfillingandrenewedincisionthatcontinuescurrently.Afaultplanewasfound,displa-yingimportantvariationsintrendanddip;theaveragevaluesbeingaN150°Etrendandan80°Ndip,withuncertaintiesevaluatedtobe~20°.ThefaultoffsetsclearlysomeconglomeratesmadeofPliocenemarineformationreworkingandgrayclaylevels,observedelsewherelyingontopofcalcrete.Itismantledbytherecentgullyinfillingmadeofangulardebris,whichcouldhavebeenaffectedbythefault.Inbetween,anoncontinuousformationmadeofclayandcalcrete-derivedsandscouldbeobserved;itisapparentlyfaultedandcontainsapieceofpottery,lessthan2000years-oldafteranarcheologistex-pertise(SlimKhosrof,NationalInstituteofPatrimony,Tunis,personalcommunication)OurdatashowdefinitivelythelatePleistocene–HoloceneactivityoftheUtiqueFault;andwecanpredicttheearthquakerecurrenceintervalwhichshouldbeof~103-104yr.ThismakestheUtiquefaultpropagationfoldanimportantstructurewhenregardingseismologicalhazardofthe1.5MpeopleTunisCity,located35kmtothesouth.Thishighseismicriskzonedeser-vestobetakenintoaccountduringtheestablishmentofimportantregionaldevelopmentprogramsandintheapplicationofseismicbuildingcode.
96Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.36
Numerically modeling current vertical surface motion in the swiss alps from the bottom up - Does the geometry of the orogen dictate how it moves?
MettierRalph*
*Institut für Geologie, Baltzerstrasse 1-3, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])
Apart fromtheobvioustopographical features, theongoingsurfacemotion isoneof themosteasilyaccessibleandbestquantifiablecharacteristicsofatypicalalpine-styleorogen.However,itisoftenunclearastohowmanydifferentprocesses,suchasi.e.isostaticadjustmenteffects,contributetotheobservedmotion,andhowmuchissimplyaconsequenceoftheongoingshortening.Recentadvancesinseveralmethods,suchasenhancedGPSmeasurements,InterferometricSyntheticApertureRadar(InSAR)andfissiontrack(FT)dating,aswellaspreciselevelingcannowprovideuswithagooddescriptionoftheverticalmotionatpresentandinfairlyrecenthistoryoftheorogen.Thisin-turn,providesuswithfresh,andoftenmuchneeded,criteriaforcalibratingourconceptualandnumericalmodelsoforogenesisandtheinvolvedprocesses.Wepresentaseriesoffiniteelementmodels,thatattempttoreproducedtheobservedverticalsurfacemotiononaroughlynorth-southcrosssectionoftheSwissAlps.Whilefairlysimpleasfarasrheology,thermodynamicsandvariousotheraspectsareconcerned,thegeometryofthecrosssectionsisofhighcomplexity,representingindividualtectonicunitssuchastheAar-andGotthardmassifs,theHelveticandPenninicnappestructuresaswellastheunderlyingsubductionoftheeuropeancrust.Themodelssimulateashortspanofacceleratedtime,withafixedrateofshorteningprescribedbytheboundaryconditions.Theresultingmotionatthesurfaceofthemodel,aswellastheinternaldeformationoftheindividualtectonicunitsisthenexamined,interpretedandcomparedtotheirreal-worldcounterparts.Themodelseriesincorporatesvariationsinthecho-senphysicaldescriptionsofthematerials,deformingbothpurelyelasticandpartiallyelasto-plastic,aswellasinthedescrip-tionofthefrictionalbehaviourattheinterfacesbetweenunits.Furtherparametervariationswithinthesemodelsub-seriesprovideinsightintotherelativerelevanceoftheseparameters.Perhapsunexpected,consideringthesimplicityofthemodels,theresultsexhibitgoodcorrelationwiththedataobtainedfromreal-worldmeasurements.Thisleadsustospeculatethattheunderlyinggeometrymaywellbethedominantfactorindescribingthebehaviourofsuchanorogen.
2.37
Seismic properties of melt-generating metapelites
SantanuMisra*,BjarneSvenGustavAlmqvist**andLuigiBurlini*
*Geological Institute, **Institute of Geophysics; ETH Zurich, CH-8092, Switzerland
Weperformedultrasonicpulsetransmissionmeasurementsonsyntheticrocksofpeliticcompositiontoidentifytheirseis-micpropertiesanddeterminethecompleteelastictensorduringpartialmeltgeneration.Experimentswereconductedat750oCand300MPaconfiningpressureoncylindricalsamplesofquartz-muscoviteaggregates(1:1byvolume)havinganinter-nal,transverselyisotropicplanarfabricand~24%porosity.Thevelocitiesofcompressionalwaves(V
p)andextensionalwaves
(VE)weremeasuredcontinuouslyfor6hoursatdifferentfrequencies(0.1,1.0and3.0MHz)withwavespropagatingat0,45
and90owithrespecttotheaxisofsymmetryofthesamples.Shear-wave(Vs)velocitiesweredeterminedindirectly,basedon
theVEandV
P.Inthebeginningoftheexperimentsthereductionofporositywithconfiningpressureandtemperaturelead
toanincreaseoftheseismicvelocitiescomparedtoroompressureandtemperature.Vpdecreasedby200-400m/swiththe
onsetofmeltgeneration,whichstartedafter1.5hoursoftheexperiment.Acomplexbehaviouroftheseismicvelocitieswasobservedwithincreasingmeltgenerationandnucleationofnewcrystals.Theseismicanisotropyvariesforthedurationoftheexperiment,andisdependentonthesamplehistory(i.e.,porosityreduction,meltgeneration,crystalnucleation).Theseexperimentalresultscansuitablybeappliedtogeophysicalinvestigationofthelowercrustwherepartialmeltingisanim-portantgeologicalprocess.
97
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.38
Rheology of metapelites during partial melting and crystallization
SantanuMisra,ElizavetaTumarkina,LuigiBurliniandJean-PierreBurg
Structural Geology and Tectonics Group, Geological Institute, ETH, Sonneggstrasse 5, Zurich 8092, Switzerland
This study investigates the rheological behaviour of metapelitic rocks at depth where they undergo synkinematic partial mel-ting and subsequent crystallization during progressive deformation. Torsion experiments were performed on synthetic pelitic rock samples at 300 MPa confining pressure and 750oC temperature with a constant strain rate ( =γ& 3x10-4) for a range of finite shear strains (γ = 0.5-15). Partial melting started a relatively low shear strains (γ = 2-4), which was coupled with strong strain softening (~ 60%) in the creep behaviour. With further shearing (γ = 4-10) the creep turned to be steady state flow with nucleation of tiny, new crystals. At higher shears (γ = 10-15), new mineral phases started growing at the expense of partial melts, which resulted in weak strain hardening and finally, brittle failure of the sample at the same pressure-temperature.
The stress exponent values (n) were continuously increasing from 3 to 28 with progressive deformation indicating a transition from power to exponential flow law (power Law Breaking). Depending on the melt and solid proportions in the system the speculated four stages of percolation thresholds during partial melting and crystallization of lithosphere were established by the experimental data.
2.39
Palaeotethyan, Neotethyan and Pindos series in the Lycian Nappes (SW Turkey): geodynamic implications
MoixPatrice&StampfliGérardM.
Institut de Géologie et de Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, Bâtiment Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Foralongtime,theideaofacontinuumbetweentheHellenidesinGreeceandtheTauridesinTurkeyhasbeendiscussed(e.g.,Brunnetal.,1976).ThiswasprincipallybasedoncorrelationsbetweentheplatformseriesoftheexternalpartsoftheHellenides-Taurides system, as well as similarities between sedimentary sequences in southwestern Turkey and in theDodecaneseislands(e.g.,Bernoullietal.,1974).InsouthwesternTurkey,theLycianNappesoccupyalargeareabetweentheBeydağlarıplatformtothesoutheastandtheMenderesMassiftothenorthwest.IthasbeendemonstratedthattheLycianNappesarederivedfromtheIzmir-AnkarabeltandrepresentallochthonouspartsofthenorthernpassivemarginoftheAnatolianterrane(Moixetal.,2008).BecauseoftheirlocationbetweentheHellenicsystemtothewestandtheTauriconetotheeast,theLycianNappesandtheirpara-autochthonousseriesareakeyarea.TheTavasNappeformsthelowermostunitintheLycianpileandisclassicallysubdividedintotheKaradağ,TekeDere,KöyceğizandHaticeanaunits(deGraciansky,1972).DetailedfieldworksupportedbynumerousmicropalaeontologicalevaluationsmakeobviousthattheTavasNappeisinrealityhighlycomposite.
ThelowermostKaradağunitconsistsofaplatformsuccessionrangingfromtheLateDevoniantotheLateTriassic.AlargehiatusoutlinedbythedepositionofsandstoneandquartziteexistsbetweentheSakmarianandtheMiddleTriassic.TheCarnianismarkedbyageneraldeepeningoftheplatformprecedingshortlythedepositionofawildflysch-likeformation.ThediscoveryoftheCordevolian(earlyCarnian)PseudofurnishiusmurcianusmurcianusvandenBoogaardconodontfaunaontopoftheplatformandinthefirstlimestonebedsinterstratifiedatthebaseofthesiliciclasticformationisofcrucialim-portance.ThisfaunacharacterizestheSephardicprovinceandisatypicalindicatorfortheNeotethyandomainsensustricto.ThePalaeozoicsuccessionoftheKaradağunitisatypicalshallow-waterGondwanatypeshelfdevelopmentandcanbecom-paredtosimilarsectionsintheAlborzrangeinnortheasternIran.ThelargehiatusduringthePermiancouldbeseenasariftshoulderrelatedtotheNeotethyan(=East-Mediterranean)rifting.Consequently,theKaradağunitlikelybelongstotheCimmerianTaurusterraneandwaspartofthenorthernpassivemarginoftheNeotethys.
TheKaradağunitisalwaysfoundstructurallybelowtheTekeDereunit,thissuperpositionbeingapossibleresultoftheLateTriassicEo-Cimmerianorogenicevent.TheTekeDereunitincludesseveralslicescomposingthemostcompletePalaeotethyansuccessioninTurkey.ItcomprisesKasimovianOIB-typebasaltsandassociatedplatformandslopesedimentsrepresentingaPalaeotethyanseamount,CarboniferousMORB-typebasalts,anEarlyCarboniferoussiliciclasticseriesstratigraphicallyover-lainbyMiddlePermian limestones, andaMiddlePermianarc sequence.Both theplatform limestonesassociated to the
98Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s seamount and the dolostones above the Early Carboniferous siliciclastic series yielded shallow-marinemicrofauna andmicroflora sharing strong biogeographical affinities with the northern Palaeotethyan borders. Palaeotethyan remnantsfoundassubduction-accretionarycomplexesorreworkedduringtheEo-CimmerianorogeniceventprovideastrongmeantoidentifyandlocatethePalaeotethyansuturezone.
ThethickMesozoicsequence,formedbytheKöyceğizandHaticeanaseries(bothofthembelongingtothesamepalaeogeo-graphicrealm),occupiesahighstructuralpositionabovetheKaradağandTekeDereunits.ThebaseoftheseriescomprisesLateTriassiccontinentalredarkosicsandstonesandconglomerates.Thismolasse-likesedimentationisfollowedbyLiassicshallow-marinelimestoneandincludesalateLiassicAmmoniticoRosso.ThesedimentationcontinueswithlateLiassictoMaastrichtianpelagicmicrites,chertymicritesandcalciturbidites.ItisthenunconformablyoverlainbyalatePalaeocenetoLutetianflysch.Atplaces,LateTriassicvolcanicrocks(transitionalMORB-type)associatedtopelagiclimestones,turbiditicsandstones, and calcareous sandstones alternating with volcaniclastic sediments form the lowermost exposure of theKöyceğizseries.ThissedimentologicalevolutionisinmanypointssimilartoPindos-likeseriesfoundnowinsouthernTurkeyandintheDodecaneseislands.TheseseriesoriginatedintheHuğlu-PindosOcean,alongthenorthernpassivemarginoftheAnatolian(Turkey)andSitia-Pindos(Greece)terranes(Moixetal.,2007).
Inconclusion,theTavasNappeincludesmoreorlessdismemberedunitsbelongingtothePalaeotethyan,NeotethyanandHuğlu-Pindosrealms.TheKaradağunitbelongstotheNeotethys(=East-Mediterranean)domain,theTekeDeresuccessioniscomposedofseveralthrustsheetsofPalaeotethyanorigin,andtheKöyceğizandHaticeanaseriesarerelatedtotheHuğlu-Pindosoceanicdomain. The identificationof such remnants in the LycianNappes and their comparisonswithadjacentareasofferefficienttoolstomakeaccurategeologicalcorrelationsbetweenGreeceandTurkey.
REFERENCESBernoulli, D., de Graciansky, P.-C. andMonod, O., 1974. The extension of the LycianNappes (SW Turkey) into the
southeasternAegeanIslands.EclogaeGeologicaeHelvetiae,67(1):39-90.Brunn,J.H.,Argyriadis,I.,Ricou,L.-E.,Poisson,A.,Marcoux,J.,deGraciansky,P.-C.,1976.Elémentsmajeursdeliaisonentre
TauridesetHellénides.BulletindelaSociétéGéologiquedeFrance,18(2):481-497.Gracianskyde,P.-C.,1972.RecherchesgéologiquesdansleTaurusLycien.PhDThesis,ParisSud-Centred'Orsay,Paris,762
pp.Moix,P.,Kozur,H.W.,Stampfli,G.M.andMostler,H.,2007.Newpalaeontological,biostratigraphicalandpalaeogeographical
results from theTriassic of theMersinmélange, SE Turkey. In: S.G. Lucas and J.A. Spielmann (Editors), The globalTriassic.NewMexicoMuseumofNaturalHistoryandScienceBulletinv.41,Albuquerque,pp.282-311.
Moix,P.,Beccaletto,L.,Kozur,H.W.,Hochard,C.,Rosselet,F.andStampfli,G.M.,2008a.AnewclassificationoftheTurkishterranesandsuturesanditsimplicationforthepaleotectonichistoryoftheregion.Tectonophysics,451(1-4):7-39.
2.40
New constraints on foreland basin development in South-West Taiwan from sequence stratigraphy and flexure modelling
StefanNagel*,SébastienCastelltort*,FredericMouthereau**,AndrewT.Lin***,SeanD.Willett*&BorisKaus*
*Eidgenössische Technische Hochschule (ETH) Zürich, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland, [email protected]** Université Pierre et Marie Curie - Paris VI, Laboratoire de Tectonique - CNRS UMR 7072, Barre 46-45 Niveau 2 - Case 129, 4, Place Jussieu F-75252 Paris Cedex 05 France*** National Central University, Basin Research Group, Earth Science Dep. No.300, Jhongda Rd., Jhongli City, Taoyuan County 32001, Taiwan(R.O.C.)
TheislandofTaiwanissituatedontheboundarybetweenthePhilippineSeaPlateandtheEurasianplateandhaslongbeenput forward as a textbook example of an Arc-Continent collision. Oblique arc-continent collision began during the lateMioceneandhasresulted inprogressivemigrationofactivedeformationandforelandbasindevelopmentfromnorthtosouth.Thusthenorthernpartoftheforelandbasinisdominatedbyshallowmarineandnonmarinedeposits,whereasthesouthernpartof the forelandbasin isdominatedbydeepermarinedeposits (Covey, 1984). The forelandbasin systemofWesternTaiwanrecordedinfillfromboththeChineseMainlandaswellasfromtheemergingTaiwanIsland.Furthermore,thehighratesofconvergence,highrateofrockupliftandthewet,stormyclimateofthesub-tropicaltyphoonbeltcombinetoproduceerosionandsedimentyieldratesamongstthehighestintheworld.Today,theTaiwanStraitisabout150to200
99
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icskmwideandaround70mdeep.However,thetimingofthedevelopmentoftheforelandbasinandsubsequentchangeof
directionofpaleocurrentisnotyetwell-defined.Differentauthorsdescribedabasalunconformityonseismicprofilesoff-shoreTaiwan,whichwasdated±6.5Ma(lateMiocene),buthasnotyetbeensupportedbyonshoreobservations.WeanalysedtwoPlioceneFormationsintheCentral(MeishanCounty)andSouthpart(TsengwenReservoir)ofTaiwan:theKueichulinFormation(TawoSandstoneMember)andtheAiliaochiaoFormation.Weconductedseverallithofacies(e.g.heavyminerals,thinsections,etc.)andbiostratigraphicalanalysisinordertounderstandtheregionalsequencestratigraphyandtobeabletosetupapaleoenvironmentalinterpretationofthestudiedarea.TheTawoSandstoneMemberbasicallyconsistsofwavy,lenticularandflaserbedded,thinlaminatedSilt-andMudstonesinterbeddedwithsmall,finetomediumgrainedsandstones(thickness:10cmto5m).Thesiltstonefaciesshowsrhythmicvariationsinlaminaethicknesswithconspicuousbidirectionalcurrentripplesindicatingatidalinfluence.Thesandstonefaciesare(inplaces)dominatedbybioturbationandphysical sedimentary structures, suchas scoured surfaceswith lagdeposits, low-angle cross-lamination, flaserandwavybeddingontop.Thetrace-fossilassemblageincludesstructurestypicalofboththeSkolithosandCruzianaichnofacies,characterizingashallow-marine(shoreface)environmentinwhichhigh-energyandlow-energysettingscoexis-ted. Similar lithofacieshavebeendescribed from tidally influenced continental shelf environments in SouthKorea andChina.
TheAiliaochiaoFormationmoretotheSouthconsistsoffinelaminatedsiltstoneandinterbeddedmudstonelayers.Theyareunconformably incisedbynumerous finegrainedsandstone layers formingcut-and-fill structureswithdistinctclimbingripplesintwooppositedirectionswithinawiderchannel.Inthemiddleofthechannelaxisexistconspicuousconglomerateswithfinegrainedsandymatrixcontainingmudclastsandforams.Bioturbationiscommonlyveryrare.ThesuccessivesedimentationoftheChinshuiShale(andtheequivalentMaopuShalerespectively),commonlyinterpretedasdeepermarinesediments, indicatesa formativeTransgressionevent.Theassociatedsea levelrise is interpretedastheonsetofloadinducedsubsidencebythegrowingorogen.Weinterpretthetwosectionsastransitionfromashallowmarine,tidallyinfluencedenvironmentwith(protected)lagoonsandestuariespassingintoachannel-leveesysteminproximalpartsofagrowingprodelta.Thespatio-temporalhistoryoftheWesternforelandbasinisinterpretedasanevolutionfroman“under-filled”stagewithmarinedepositional environmentsdeepeningupwards and relatively low sedimentation rates (Kueichulin fmand lowerChinshui fm) towardan“over-filled”stagemarkedby the fillingof thebasinwithprogressively shallowerenvironmentsupwardsandeventuallybecomingcontinental.Theprojectwillfocusonthehigh-resolutionstratigraphicrecordofthecollisioninthewesternforelandbasinbycompilingpublishedandunpublisheddata,collectingnewfieldobservationsandusingsubsurfaceseismicimaginginthebasininordertoreconstructpaleogeography,depositionalenvironment,andtectonicandsediment-transportcontrolsondepositio-nalpatterns.Theseresultswillserveasinputtostratigraphicand3Ddeformationmodelstoconstrainthedevelopmentoftheorogenanditssouthwardpropagation.Theresultsofthisstudywillprovideimportantevidenceforthespaceandtimeevolutionoftheorogen-relatedloadingoftheforeland.
REFERENCESCovey,M.,1984:SedimentaryandtectonicevolutionofthewesternTaiwanForedeep,UnpublishedPh.D.thesisCovey,M., 1984: Lithofacies analysis and basin reconstruction, Plio-PleistoceneWestern Taiwan Foredeep, Petroleum
GeologyofTaiwan,Vol.20,pp.53-83Lin,A.T.,A.B.WattsandS.P.Hesselbo,2003:CenozoicstratigraphyandsubsidencehistoryoftheSouthChinaSeamargin
intheTaiwanregion.BasinResearch,15(4),453-478.Mouthereau, F., andO. Lacombe, 2006: Inversion of the Paleogene Chinese continentalmargin and thick-skinned
deformationintheWesternForelandofTaiwan,JournalofStructuralGeology,28,1977-1993.
Funding:ThisprojectisfundedbySwissNationalFundsgrant#2-77295-08.
100Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.41
Thermal structure and metamorphic evolution of the Piedmont-Ligurian metasediments in the Western-Central Alps
NegroFrançois*,PelletClara-Marine*,**,BousquetRomain**,BeyssacOlivier***,GuerraIvan****,VilsFlurin*****
* Institut de Géologie et d’Hydrogéologie, Université de Neuchâtel, Rue E. Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])** Institut für Geowissenschaften, Universität Potsdam, Germany*** Laboratoire de Géologie, Ecole Normale Supérieure, Paris, France**** Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Université de Lausanne, L’Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne***** Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol, UK
TheWestern-CentralAlps,locatedbetweentheSimplonandtheAosta-Ranzollafaults,representa"transition”zonewheremanypaleogeographicdomainswerecontinuouslyaccretedwithinthealpineorogenicwedge.Withinthisorogenicwedge,thePiedmont-LigurianoceanicdomainrecordedblueschisttoeclogitemetamorphicconditionsduringtheAlpineorogeny.ThePiedmont-Ligurianzone,isclassicallydivided,accordingtotheirmetamorphicevolution,intoaLP(greenschisttoblue-schistfacies)unit(Combinzone),andaHPtoUHPunit(Zermatt-Saasnappe).Thecontactbetweenbothzoneissupposedisamajordetachmentfault(Combinfault).AlthoughP-TconditionsarequitewellknownintheZermatt-Saasnappe,quantita-tiveconstraintsarelackingintheCombinzone.WeinvestigatedthetemperaturerecordintheoceanicmetasedimentsofthePiedmont-Ligurianunits,usingRamanspec-troscopyofcarbonaceousmaterial.Thismethodallowsquantifyingthemaximumtemperature,andthereforethepeakofmetamorphism,withoutbeingaffectedbytheretrogradeevolution.Theaimofthisstudywasto(1)estimatethepeaktem-peraturereachedwithineachunit(2)comparethetemperaturerecordbetweenthedifferentunits.Weadditionallycharac-terizedthemetamorphicassemblagesinthemetasedimentsofbothunits.SampleswerecollectedinthemetasedimentsoftheCombinzonenorthandsouthoftheDentBlanchemassif,andintheZermatt-SaasnappeintheareaofZermattandLagodiCignanatoestimatethetemperaturegapacrosstheCombinfault.IntheCombinnappe,temperaturesrangebetween430-500°C,andareverycoherentinthenorthernandsouthernpartsoftheDentBlanche.IntheZermatt-Saasnappe,temperaturesaresimilartotheonesobtainedintheCombinnappe,alsointherange450-530°C,andthetemperaturegapissignificantlylowerthanitisproposedintheliterature.However,mineralassemblagesarenotwellpreservedintheCombinnappecomparedtotheZermatt-Saasnappe,whichcouldbeexplainedbyintenseretrogression.Wecomparethesetemperatureswiththemetamorphicassemblagesobservedinthedifferentunitsanddiscusstheseresultsintheframeofthetectono-metamorphicevolutionofthehigh-pressurelow-temperatureoceanicunitsfromtheWestern-CentralAlps.
2.42
Influence of faults on the development of Excavation Damaged Zone: the case of the Mont Terri Rock Laboratory
NussbaumChristophe*&BossartPaul*
*Federal Office of Topography swisstopo, Fabrique de Chaux, CH-2882 St-Ursanne ([email protected])
Oneconcernintheresearchonwastedisposalinargillaceousrocksistheunderstandingofprocessescontrollingthedevel-opmentoftheExcavationDamagedZone(EDZ).ThegeometryandkinematicsoftheEDZfracturenetworkprovideavaluableinputforthisproblematic.However,theMontTerrisiteischaracterisedbyacomplextectonicsettingmadeofnumerousfaultswithdifferentorientationsanddips.Thesepre-existingfaultsorinheritedstructures,relatedtotheJurathrust-andfoldbeltandtotheRhine-Bressetransversezone,stronglyinterfereonthecreationofEDZfractures.Numerousfieldobser-vationsindicatethattectonicfaultscontroltheinitiationandlocalisationofEDZfractures.Forthisreason,itiscrucialtohaveaperfectknowledgeofthetectonicpattern.Systematicsmall-scalemappingofthetunnelwalls,floorandadjacentnichesprovidesbasicinformationaboutthegeometryandkinematicsofthegeologicalfracturesintersectedintheunder-groundrocklaboratory.Theobservedtectonicfaultscanbedividedintothreedifferentfaultsystems(Nussbaum&Bossart,2008):i)SSEdippingfaults(mainlyformedbybedding-parallelslipduringthefoldingoftheMontTerrianticline);ii)low
101
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsangleSWdippingfaultplanesandflat-lyingSSEtoSdippingfaultplanesandiii)NtoNNEtrendingsteeplyinclinedsinistral
strike-slipfaults.ThethreefaultsystemsidentifiedintheMontTerrirocklaboratorycanbeintegratedintothesurroundingmap-scalestructuresinacoherentway.
ThedevelopmentandgeometryofEDZfracturenetworkdependlargelyontheexcavationdirectioninrespectwiththepre-existingfaults.Tunnelorientationinrespectwiththebeddingseemstoplayanimportantroleduetotherockanisotropy.Whenthedriftexcavationisnormaltothebeddingandfaultsplanesdippingwith45°toSSE,thechancetoinitiateEDZfracturesisquitelimitedsincetherockanisotropystructureisperfectlyorientedintheCoulombcriteriafailuredirection.Theseweaknessplanesarereactivatedasshearfractures.SecondaryEDZfracturesmaydevelopbelowthesefaultplanes.Inturn,insectionswherefaultsarescarce,whatevertheexcavationdirection,well-developedEDZfracturenetworkisobserved.However,Dependingonthefacieswhichisexcavated,theoccurrenceofEDZfracturesmaysignificantlychange.Infact,theOpalinusClayintheMontTerrirocklaboratorymaybedividedintothreemainfacies:ashalyfaciesinthelowerpartoftheformation(argillaceousandmarlyshaleswithmicasandnodular,bioturbatedlayersofmarlsorwithmm-thicklayersofsandstones),asandyfaciesinthemiddleandupperpartoftheformation(marlyshaleswithlayersofsandstonesandbio-turbatedlimestones,orwithlensesofgrey,sandylimestonesandmm-thicklayersofwhitesandstoneswithpyrite;andathincarbonate-rich,sandyfaciesinthemiddleoftheformation(calcareoussandstonesintercalatedwithbioturbatedlime-stonebeds,thelattershowingahighdetritalquartzcontent).Thesefaciesarecharacterisedbydifferentuniaxialcompres-sivestrengths.Theshalyfaciespresentsthelowervaluesofstrengths,10.5MPaparalleltothebeddingand25.6MPanormaltothebedding.Thismaybeareasontoexplaintheoccurrenceofwell-developedEDZfracturenetworkingallerysectionexcavatedthroughtheshalyfacies.Inturn,EDZfracturesinthesandyfacies,characterisedbyanaveragevalueofuniaxialcompressivestrengthof35MPa,areveryscarce.
Inconclusion,thepre-existingnaturaldiscontinuitiessuchaswelldeveloped,inclinedbeddingplanesandfaults,seemtoactaslimitingstructures(Figure1).Mechanicalcharacteristicsofthefacieswhichareexcavatedalsoinfluencethegenera-tionofEDZfractures.
Figure1.Relationshipbetweenalowanglenaturalthrustfault(upper)whichlimitsasetofsubverticalextensionalEDZfracturescharac-
terisedbyplumosestructures(Photo:Comet,PhotoshoppingZürich)
REFERENCESNussbaum,Ch.andBossart,P.Geology.InMontTerriRockLaboratory.Project,Programme1996to2007andResults.(2008).
Ed:Bossart,P.&Thury,M.:–Rep.SwissGeol.Surv.3.
102Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.43
Transition from frictional to viscous deformation in granitoid fault gouges
PečMatěj*,StünitzHolger**,HeilbronnerRenée*
*Geologisch-Paläontologisches Institut, Bernoullistrasse 32, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])** Institutt for geologi, Universitetet i Tromsø, Dramsveien 201, 9037 Tromsø, Norway
Frictionalmovementonfaultsproducesextremelyfine-grainedfaultgougesandincreasesthepermeability,thusenablingfluidflow.Thefinegrainsize,togetherwiththepresenceoffluids,isapotentialprecursorforthetransitionfromfrictionaltoviscousdeformationinthefaultgouge.
Inordertoinvestigatethisswitchinthedominantdeformationmechanism,weperformedaseriesofsimplesheardeforma-tionexperimentsinaGriggsdeformationapparatus.CrushedVerzascaGneisspowder (grainsize<200µm)with0.2wt%wateraddedwasplacedbetweenforcingblockscutat45°andweld-sealedingoldandplatinumjackets.Alltheexperimentswererunat500MPaconfiningpressureand300°Cor500°C.
Thefinegrainsizeisproducedduringthefirstpartoftheexperimentsbyfastdeformation(strainrate=10-4and10-3s-1)toagamma-valueofupto2.5.Thematerialconsistsofafine-grainedgougewithaporosityofaround1%.Angular,extremelyfine-grainedparticles(<50nminsize)aredistributedthroughouttheshearzone.Theamountoffine-grainedmaterialin-creasestowardsshearbandsthatdevelopatlowanglestotheshearzoneboundary.
Inthesecondpartoftheexperimentswestoppedthedeformationatpeakdifferentialstressandallowedthestressestorelaxoveroneweek(caseA).Alternatively,weloweredthepeakdifferentialstresstoalevelclosetotheconfiningpressureandkeptitconstantforoneweek(caseB).
IncaseAexperiments,weobserveslow(creep)strainrates(aslowas10-8sec-1)andatemperaturedependenceofthecreeprate.Thestressdropofsamplesdeformedat500°Cislarger(~200MPa)andthedisplacementishigher(0.141mm)comparedtothesamplesdeformedat300°C(80MPaand0.110mm,respectively).IncaseB,theamountofdisplacementaccommoda-tedbythesamplesisfarsmaller(total0.01mmat500°C),itisatthelimitofmeasurementsthatcanberesolvedwithourcurrentapparatus.
ThemicrostructuresinbothcaseAandBexperiments(fig.1)arestrikinglydifferentfromthosedeformedbyfrictiononly(fig.2).Weobservethedisappearanceofthefinestgrainsizefraction,appearanceoflobateinterconnectedgrainboundariesandthecementationofmultiplegrainsintobiggerones.
Fromtheseobservations,togetherwiththeobservedtemperaturedependence,weinferthatthesamplesweredeformedbysolution–precipitation-creepprocesses.Theexactnatureofthecreepdeformationisdifficulttoassessatthisstage,becau-sethestresslevelsnecessarytoachievecreepintheexperiments,sofar,areabovetheGoetzecriterion.
Figure1:Faultgougedeformedbycreep
103
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
Figure2:Faultgougedeformedbyfrictiononly
2.44
Structural observations from the Insubric fault between the Valle d’Ossola and Valle d’Orco (NW Italy)
PleugerJan*&MancktelowNeil*
*Geologisches Institut, ETH Zürich, Sonneggstraße 5, CH-8092 Zürich
ThePalaeogenetoMioceneInsubricfaultzone(IFZ)separatestheSouthAlpinedomainfromunitsthathavebeensubductedduringAlpineorogeny.FromValled’OssolatosomewhatNofSerrad’Ivrea,theSouthernAlpsaretypicallyrepresentedbythe Ivrea zone and the adjacentNWblock by the Sesia zone. Further SW, the IFZ splits into the Internal and ExternalCanavesefaults(ICFandECF).TheCanvesezones.str.occupiesthepositionbetweentheECFandICFandthusbetweentheSesiaandIvreazones.CarbonaticlensesoccuringsporadicallyfurtherNEarereferredtoasCanaveses.l..TheverticaldisplacementalongtheIFZvariesalongstrikeandislargestSoftheLepontinedome.Thehorizontaldisplace-mentisestimatedasca.30kmbyMülleretal.(2001)andca.100kmbySchmid&Kissling(2004).TheIFZrocksshowspatialandtemporalvariationsindisplacementsenseanddirectionandofmetamorphicconditionsduringmovement.OurobservationsfromValled’OssolalargelyagreewiththoseofSchmidetal.(1987).TheIFZisaseveralhundredmetresthick,moderatelytosteeplyNW-dippinggreenschist-faciesmylonitezone,mostlywithaNW-side-upshearsense.TheNW-side-upmylonitesareanaxial-planarfoliationS
1ofafirstInsubricfoldgenerationF
1.InthesouthernpartoftheIFZ,F
1and
S1areoverprintedbyasecondfoldgenerationF
2.ComingfromtheNW,F
2firstappearswithaxesthatareparalleltoagent-
lyNE-plungingintersectionlineationbetweenS1andtheF
2axial-planarfoliationS
2.AstheintensityofD
2increasestoward
theSE,thelineationclearlybecomesastretchinglineation,theorientationplungesmoresteeplyNE,andisassociatedwithaSE-side-upanddextralshearsense.FurtherSWinValleStronaandValleMastallone,thevolumeofSE-side-upmylonitesexceedsthatofNW-side-upmylonites.InValleStrona,theNW-side-upmylonitesaremoreinternal(SE)withrespecttotheSE-side-upmylonitescontrarytowhatisobservedinValled’OssolaandValleMastallonewherethelatteraremainlyconfinedtomylonitesderivedfromanIvreazoneprotolith.InValleMastallone,twogenerationsofSE-side-upmylonitesexist.Theoldergeneration,foundnearRimella,hasaNE-SW-trendingstretchinglineationandadextralplussouth-side-upshearsense.Thedominantyoungergenerationhasanapproximatelydown-dip(NW)orientationofthestretchinglineation.TheseSE-side-upmylonitesarelocallyoverprintedbysmall-scaleductiletobrittle,gentlyS-dipping,faultzoneswithaSE-directednormalsenseofmovement,andbyaNNE-SSW-trendingandsteeplydippingsinistralmylonitictocataclasticfaultzonenearFobello.StillfurtherSWinValleSessera,cataclasticInsubricdeformationbecomesdominantoverductileshearingintermsoftheaffected rock volumes. The SouthAlpine rocks are locally affectedby lower greenschist-faciesmylonite zones. These aremostlyonlyafewmetresthickandbothdextralandsinistraldisplacementsensesareobserved.Themostcharacteristicca-taclasiteconsistsofaseveraltensofmetresthickbrecciawithquartz-richmylonitefragments.Thismyloniteiseithercom-
104Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s pletelyreworkedinthebrecciaorstillpreservedbelowtheEarlyOligoceneandesitesthatareexposedbetweenthebrecciaandtheSesiazone.TheandesitesoccuralongtheIFZfromValleSesseratotheS,untilclosetotheSerrad’Ivrea.Itisnote-worthythatbasementxenolithswithintheandesitesareexclusivelyderivedfromtheSesiazone,whichimpliesupliftoftheSouthernAlpsrelativetotheSesiazoneafterandesitedeposition.ThebrecciaimmediatelySEoftheandesitesandthekaki-ritesbetweenthebrecciaandIvreazoneprobablydevelopedduringthisuplift.SoftheSerrad’Ivrea,deformationalongtheECFandICFwasmostlybrittle.AttheECF,onlyrocksthatcandeformductile-lyunderrelativelylowtemperatures,suchascalcschistandserpentinite,weremylonitised.SuchmylonitesgenerallyreflectW-side-up faultingwithnegligiblehorizontal components. Strike-slip faultingwasmostlyaccommodatedby laterbrittlefaultingalongtheECF.Whilethedisplacementsenseofstrike-slipmotionsalongtheECFisambiguous,thebrittletobrittle-ductilefaultrocksoftheICFconsistentlyshowcombinedE-side-upanddextraldisplacement.Thekinematicvariationsalong-strikeandacrosstheIFZmaybeintegratedintothefollowingsimplifiedpattern.VerticalmotionsprevailedearlierintheIFZhistorywhilestrike-slipdisplacementbecamelatermoreimportant.Thecombineddis-placementalongtheECFandICFresultedinaloweringoftheCanavesezones.str.withrespecttoboththeSesiaandIvreazones.NEofSerrad’Ivrea,thisloweringresultedinthedownwarddisappearenceoftheCanavesezone,exceptforthespo-radiccarbonaticlensesofCanaveses.l..AcrosstheIFZ,thedifferenceinmetamorphicgradeoffaultrocksderivedfromtheSesiaandIvreazonesappearsmoderate.Therefore,thenetverticaldisplacementbetweenthetwo,resultingfromthecom-binationofNW-side-upandSE-side-upfaulting,wasprobablyalsomoderate.Alargepartoftheexhumationofthehigh-temperaturemetamorphicrocksoftheLepontinedomemayinfactberelatedtoupdominginthecoreoftheVanzonean-tiform,ratherthanbackthrustingalongtheIFZ.Theamountofstrike-slipdisplacementincreasesfromSWtoNE.Whileitis unclear if sinistral or dextral shearing prevailed in the Canavese, in Valle d’Ossola only dextralmylonites are found(thoughwithvaryinghorizontalcomponents).ConsideringthatthedominantD
1N-side-upmylonitesexposedthereformed
entirelyundergreenschist-facies conditions,without any synkinematic transition fromhigheror to lowermetamorphicgrade,thehorizontaldisplacementoftheD
1andD
2mylonitesisunlikelytoexceedafewtensofkilometres.
REFERENCESMüller,W.,Prosser,G.,Mancktelow,N.S.,Villa,I.M.,Kelley,S.P.,Viola,G.&Oberli,F.2001:Geochronologicalconstraintson
theevolutionofthePeriadriaticFaultSystem(Alps).Int.J.EarthSci.,90,623-653.SchmidS.M.&Kissling,E. 2000:Thearcof thewesternAlps in the lightofgeophysicaldataondeepcrustal structure.
Tectonics,19,62-85.SchmidS.M.,Zingg,A.&Handy,M.1987:ThekinematicsofmovementsalongtheInsubricLineandtheemplacementof
theIvreaZone.Tectonophysics,135,47-66.
2.45
Apatite FT data from the Triassic Songpan-Garzê flysch, Tibetan Plateau, NW Sichuan, China
RahnMeinert*&WangHejing**
*ENSI, 5232 Villigen-ENSI, Switzerland ([email protected])**School of Earth and Space Sciences, Peking University, Beijing 100871, P. R. China
TriassicflyschesoftheSongpan-GarzêorogeninSichuan,CentralChina,coveranareaof5timesthesizeofSwitzerland.OutcropsarelocatedintheeasternmostTibetanPlateau,borderedtothewestbytheLongmenshanfault,siteofthe2008Wenchuanearthquake(Haoetal.2009)Accumulatedflyschsedimentsreachthicknessesof15kmandhaveundergoneup-perdiageneticto lowermostgreenschist faciesconditionssoonafterdeposition.Themetamorphicandlaterexhumationhistoryoftheflyscheswasinvestigatedbymeansofillitecrystallinity(IC)e.g.Wangetal.2008)andapatitefissiontrack(FT)dating,withonesampleprofileextendingacrosstheLongmenshanfaultsystemintotheSichuanbasin.
48apatiteFTsamplescoveranagerangebetween3and136Ma,suggestingthatallsamplesareatleastpartiallyannealed(theyoungestdatedsedimentsareJurassic).AmarkedcorrelationbetweenICandFTdatarevealthatthedifferencesinre-cordedmetamorphicgradeatthepresent-daysurfaceweresignificantlycausedbydifferentialexhumation,i.e.thestructu-ralevolutionoftheformerflyschbasin.OnesamplegroupofLateMioceneFTageswithintheflyschcoincideswitharegi-onalincreaseinmetamorphicgradeuptogreenschistfaciesconditions.
Verticalprofileswereinvestigatedtostudythetectono-thermalstructureoftheflyschesduringmetamorphismandexhu-
105
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsmation.Oneverticalprofile(2400-4100m)showsalineartrendcorrespondingtoaFTagegradientof42myrperkmaltitude.
Regardingitstracklengthandillitecrystallinitydata,theprofilepatternisrecognizedasthelowerpartofanexhumedpartialannealingzone.Thelowerendofthepartialannealingzoneisestimatedatappr.15Ma,corroboratedbythepresen-ceofsimilaragesfurtherN.Fromtheverticalthicknessofthepartialannealingzone(>3km),thethermalgradientduringapatiteageresetmusthavebeen<20°/km.
TwosamplegroupswithresetLateMiocenetoPlioceneapatiteFTagesnexttofaultsoftheLongmenshanfaultsystemcon-firmverticaloffsetoftheeasternsideblocksbytectonicactivity.Areasofstrongdifferentialupliftcontrastwiththelocalityofthe2008Wenchuanearthquakealongthemainfaultline.Youngupliftisherefoundfurtherwestofthemainfault,wherealsoaseriesofformerearthquakesofslightlylowermagnitudewasrecordedinthepast.
REFERENCESHaoK.X.,Si,H.,Fujiwara,H.&OzawaT.2009:Coseismicsurface-rupturesandcrustaldeformationsofthe2008Wenchuan
earthquakeMw7.9,China,GeophysicalResearchLetters,doi:10.1029/2009GL037971.Wang,H.,Rahn,M.,Tao,X.,Zheng,N.,Xu,T.2008:DiagenesisandmetamorphismofTriassicFlyschalongprofileZoige-
Lushan,NorthwestSichuan,China.ActaGeologicaSinica82,917–926.
2.46
Dynamic Topography Determination of the Western Mediterranean Sea from Jason-1 Data
RamiAli*,KahloucheSalem*,KhelifMhamed**
(*) Centre of Space Techniques, PO Box 13, Arzew 31200 Oran Algeria ([email protected])(**) Abou Bakr Belkaid University, Faculty of Science Engineering 13000 Tlemcen Algeria
Theoceanhasamajor impactonearthly lifeanddomesticneeds; theemergenceof satellitealtimetryallowsusa largecontributionformostapplicationsandoceanographicactivities. Inparticular, theseadynamictopography,which is thedistanceseparatesthegeoidandtheseasurfaceheightandthatreflectsthedynamicsoftheocean,isaprimordialoceano-graphyunknown.
Theprocessingofjason-1satellitedatapermitustodeterminatetheMediterraneansurfaceheight,whileusingtheglobalmodelofgeoid “EGM2008”obtained fromacombineddata (GRACE,Terrestrial andaltimetricmeasurements,….)wecancalculatetheseadynamictopography.
ThecomparisonoftheobtainedresultswiththedatatransmittedinthemessageofJason-1satelliteallowedusthevalida-tionofthemethodologicalapproachdeveloped.
REFERENCESDarwin,G.H.(1883).ReportontheHarmonicAnalysisofTidalObservation,Brit.Ass.forAdv.Sci.Rep.Kahlouche,S.,A.Rami,S.A.BenAhmedDaho(2003).TopexAltimetricMeanSeaLevelandGravimetricGeoidintheNorthof
Algeria,InternationalAssociationofGeodesySymposia,SpringerVerlag126,PP….–ISSN0939-9585.Lefevre,F.(2000).Modélisationdesmaréesocéaniquesàl’échelleglobale:assimilationdedonnéesinsituetaltimétriques,
Thèsed’état.Newton,I.(1687).PhilosophiaeNaturalisPrincipiaMathematica,London.Rami, A., Khelif,M., Kahlouche, S., Dennoukri., T. (2006). Estimation of the Sea State Bias Effect on theAltimetric
MeasurementsUsingaParametricModel, In:ProcoftheSymposium15thYearsofProgress inRadarAtimetry,SP-614ESAPublicationDivision–ISBN92-9092-925-1–ISSN1609-042X.
106Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.47
Mirror denudation pattern on both sides of the Central Atlantic – a trace of the Pangea break-up?
RuizGeoffrey*,SebtiSamira**,SaddiqiOmar**,NegroFrançois*,StuartFin***,FoekenJurgen****,StockliDani*****,FrizonDeLamotteDominique******
* IGH,E.Argand11,CH-2009Neuchatel([email protected])** FacultédesSciences,AinChock,Casablanca-Morocco*** SUERC,Glasgow-UK**** FALW,VrijeUniversiteitAmsterdam-NL***** DptofGeology,Uni.Kansas-USA****** Uni.Cergy-Pontoise-France
ThetargetareaofthisprojectistheWSW-ENEorientedintra-continentalAtlaschaininMoroccolocatedbetweentheWestAfricaCratonandtheBetic-Rifsystem.Itisakeynaturallaboratorybecauseit1)isthesouthernmostexpressionofAlpinedeformation inAfrica,and2)encompassesPre-Cambriantorecentevolutionof theregion.ThepresenceofhighsurfaceelevationstodayintheHigh-Atlas(>4000m)andAnti-Atlas(>2500m)tothesouthissubjecttodiscussionsbecausethereislittlequantitativedataavailableatpresent.Phasesofupliftarethusillconstrainedasplaceswheretheassociatederosionproductswereaccumulated. TobetterconstrainthemostrecentorogenicgrowthoftheAtlaschain,weselectedasectionlocatedtotheSWofMorocco,andinvestigatedthetime-Temperaturepathsfromthedifferentmorpho-structuraldomainsusinglow-tempera-ture thermochronology analyses. These are Fission-Track analysis on Apatite (120-60°C), Zircon (270-210°C) and U-Th/Heanalysis stillonApatite (80-45°C)andZircon (200-170°C)minerals.Resultsaremuchcontrasted fromonedomain to theother:Pre-CambrianbedrocksfromtheAnti-AtlasdomainyieldoldthermochronologicalFission-Trackagesonzircon(380-300Ma)andapatite(180-120Ma)mineralsthatareassociatedwithslightlyyounger(U-Th)/Heagesonapatite(150-110Ma).U-Th/HeagesonapatitefromtheHigh-Atlasaremuchyounger(~35-5Ma)withaclearalpinesignature.ApatiteFission-TrackagesfromtheMesetaregionfurthernortharealsorelativelyoldrangingbetween200and140Ma. WehereconcentrateontheinterpretationofoldthermochronologicalagesfromtheMesetaandAnti-Atlasregionsleaving theAlpine signal foranothercontribution.Thereare twodirect,possibly inter fingering, interpretations for thepreservationofsucholdthermalrecordintheAnti-AtlasandMesetaregions.Firsttheyremained“stable”beingunaffectedby'Alpine'deformationthattookplaceintheHigh-Atlas.Second,theyarebeingaffected“now”butnolevelwithsuchrecordisyetexposed.Thermalmodellingwasperformedtodecipherbetweenthe2scenariosusingournewthermochronologicalandavailablegeologicalconstraints.ModelssuggestthatthefirstscenarioismostlikelywithaclearTriassictoLateJurassicphaseofheatinguntil~100-90°CthatwasfollowedbyaphaseofcoolinguntiltheMiddleCretaceous.TheseresultssuggestthattheMesetawasburiedbya2-3kilometresthicksedimentarypileuntil~180MaandasaresultthattheconceptofatopographichighlimitingtheTethysianfromtheAtlantichastobereconsidered.Further,denudationpatternsfromthemirrorimageoftheAtlassystemontheothersideoftheAtlanticoceanarealmostidentical(GristandZentilli,2003)sug-gestingthatthepatternsweconstrainedfortheTriassicuntilMiddleCretaceousinSWMoroccohavetoberelatedtothebreak-upofthePangeaandoceanizationintheCentralAtlanticfrom~180Ma.
REFERENCESGrist,A.M.,&Zentilli,M.(2003).Post-PaleoceneCoolingintheSouthernCanadianAtlanticRegion:EvidencefromApatite
FissionTrackModels.CanadianJournalofEarhSciences,40(9),1279-1297.
107
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.48
The Eastern Pelagonian metamorphic core complex (northern Greece): Structure and models
SchenkerFilippoLuca*,BurgJean-Pierre,GeryaTaras.
ETHZ, Department of Earth sciences, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich*([email protected])
GeologicalmappingrevealedamigmatiticdomeinthefootwallofalowangledetachmentintheeasternPelagonianregion,tothenorthandeastoftheAliakmonRiverartificiallake,inGreece.Thedomedimensionsareabout20x15kmwiththelongaxisstrikingNNW-SSE.AlllithologiesshowapenetrativefoliationstrikingmainlyNW-SEanddippingNEorSW,accord-ing to thedome flank.On the foliationplaneaNE-SWstretching lineation is associatedwith senseof shear indicators.Systematicmeasurementsaverageasfollows:i)Top-to-the-SWsenseofshear:Direction:254°±15;Plunge:12°±9,ii)Top-to-the-NEsenseofshear:Direction:47°±17;Plunge:15°±13.Whilethetop-to-the-SWsenseofshearisregional,top-to-the-NEshearreferstorelativelynarrow(20to100m)shearzones.Themostspectacularoftheseshearzonesjuxtaposeshighlymigmatiticorthogneissesagainstnonmigmatiticones.Inthemigmatiticcorebothbiotiteorthogneissesandamphibolites(formerbasalticdykesthathaveintrudedintothecrystallinebasement)haveundergonepartialmelting.Meltingofthemetagranitelocallyproducedgarnet+amphibole+melt,whichwouldindicatePressure-temperatureconditionsof10-20kband<800-900°Crespectivelyunderwater-saturatedconditions.ZirconU-Pbdatingfromamigmatiteonthenorthwesternflankofthedomesuggeststhatmeltingtookplaceat137±1Ma[Anders,2007].Theresultswerethebasisfornumericalmodellingofmigmatitedomesinextensionalsetting.WeemployedI2ELVIS,anu-merical 2D computer code designed for visco-elasto-plastic rheology and using conservative finite differences method[Gerya,2003a].Themodeldomainis300kmwideand160kmdeep.Itconsistsoffourrheologicallayersrepresentinguppercrust, lower crust, lithosphericmantle and asthenosphericmantle. Changing parameters as extension rate, lithospherethicknessandgeothermspointstotheimportanceofpartialmeltinginthelowercrustal:(1)itmaintainsaflatMohoand(2)positivebuoyancyofmolten rocksenhancesdoming.PTtpathsofmodelpointsareused todiscriminate thermo-me-chanicalscenariofmigmatiticcorecomplexes.
REFERENCESAnders,B.,Reischmann,T.&Kostopoulos,D. 2007:Zircongeochronologyofbasement rocks from thePelagonianZone,
Greece:constraintsonthepre-AlpineevolutionofthewesternmostInternalHellenides,IntJEarthSci(GeolRundsch),96,639-661.
Gerya,T.V.&Yuen,D.A.2003a:Characteristics-basedmarker-in-cellmethodwithconservativefinite-differencesschemesformodelinggeologicalflowswithstronglyvariabletransportproprieties.PhysicsoftheEarthandPlanetaryInteriors,140,295-320.
2.49
Formation of fold nappes in ductile multilayers: insights from numerical simulations
SchmalholzStefanMarkus
ETH Zurich, Geologisches Institut, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8032 Zurich ([email protected])
Foldnappesarelarge-scalerecumbantfoldsthathavemostlikelyformedbydominantlyductiledeformation.IntheWesternSwissAlps,theMiddleandLowerPenninicbasementnappesaswellastheHelveticonesdisplay,inmostcases,thetypicalgeometryandstratigraphyoffoldnappeswithanormalflank,afrontalpartandanoverturnedlimb(Escheretal.,1993).Incontrasttofoldnappes,thrustsheetslackanoverturnedlimbandarecharacterisedbyabasalthrustordetachmentsurface(e.g.EpardandEscher,1996).IntheSwissAlps,thecoreoffoldnappesoftenconsistsofmetamorphicbasementsurroundedbyasedimentarycover(e.g.Escheretal.,1993;EpardandEscher,1996).ExamplesaretheMorcle-Mont-BlancnappeortheAntigorionappe(e.g.Escheretal.,1993).AlthoughfoldnappesarefrequentintheSwissAlpsandareaprominentfeatureinmanymountainbelts,thereareonlyfewstudiesthatinvestigatedthemechanicaldeformationprocessesactingduring
108Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s theformationoffoldnappes.Therefore,therearestillmanyopenquestionsconcerningthecontrollingfar-fielddeformati-onfield(simpleorpureshear),therheology(e.g.Newtonianviscous,power-laworviscoplastic)andtheimpactofhetero-geneities(e.g.effectiveviscosityratiowithinsedimentarycover).Ipresentfirstresultsoffiniteelementmodelssimulatingtheformationoffoldnappesinductilemultilayers.Inthesemo-delsthesedimentarycoverismodelledwithductilemultilayersexhibitingapower-lawrheologyandthebasementismo-delledwithonethicklayerhavingalsoapower-lawrheology.Thefar-fielddeformationfieldisassumedtobesimple-shear.TheappliedfiniteelementmethodemploysaLagrangianformulationwithre-meshingwherethenumericalgridisdefor-medwiththecalculatedvelocityfield.Thismethodensuresthattheboundariesbetweenthedifferentlayers(i.e.sedimen-taryunitsandbasement)areaccuratelyresolvedduringtheentirelargestraindeformation.Figure1presentstheresultofoneparticularsimulation.Althoughthemodelisrelativelysimpletheresultsalreadyshowseveralinterestingfeatures:a)thesedimentarylayersaredetachedfromthebasementatseverallocations,b)foldsofdiffe-rentsizeandorderareformed,c)foldaxialplaneswithdifferentorientationsareformedduringonecontinuousdeforma-tionphaseandd)recumbentfoldswithoverturnedlimbsmoreorlessparalleltothefar-fieldsimplesheardirectionareformed.Furthermore, inthemiddleof themodel themultilayers formeda foldnappewhichhasanoverturned limb,afrontalpartandanormallimb.TheapplicabilityofthepresentednumericalmodelstonaturalfoldnappesintheSwissAlpsisdiscussed.Also,modellingapproachesforamorerealisticnumericalmodellingoffoldnappesintheSwissAlpsarepresented.
Figure1.Numericalresultformultilayerfoldingunderfar-fieldsimpleshear.A)Initialgeometry.B)Geometryforashearstrainof2.8.
REFERENCESEscher,A.,Masson,H.&Steck,A.1993:NappegeometryintheWesternSwissAlps,J.Struct.Geol.,15,501-509.Epard,J.-L.&Escher,A.1996:Transitionfrombasementtocover:ageometricmodel,J.Struct.Geol.,18,533-548.
109
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics2.50
Two critical tapers in a single wedge
JeroenSmit*,Jean-PierreBurg*andJean-PierreBrun**
*ETH Zurich, Geological Institute, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zurich** Géosciences Rennes, Université de Rennes 1, Campus de Beaulieu, Bat 15, 35042 Rennes, France
Thrustinvolvingaductiledécollement(e.g.salt,over-pressuredshales)likeZagros,Jura,PakistanSaltRanges,CascadesandMakranhave incommonasmallcross-sectional taper,attributedto largethrustspacingandfast frontwardpropagationabovetheductiledécollement.Suchalowcross-sectionaltaperhasbeenanalyticallyexplainedbyapproximatingtheductilelayerasahorizonwithnegligibleshearstrength.Wetestedthedevelopmentofthrustwedgesinvolvingaductilebasaldécollementofuniformshearstrengthbymeansoflaboratoryexperiments.Themodelconsistsofasandlayerwithinitialwedgegeometryandabasalductiledécollementofconstantthicknessandshearstrengthmadeofsiliconeputty.30%ofbulkshorteningisappliedtothewedgeatconstantvelocity.Thrustingstartsinthemiddleofthewedge,followedbyin-sequencefrontwardpropagation.Thebackpartofthewedge,betweenbackstopandtheclosestthrust,remainsundeformed;itpassivelyadvancesoverthebasewithoutinternaldeformation.Itappearsthatbothdomainshavedifferentcriticaltapers.Theinnerdomainisinacriticalstatefromtheonsetofshorte-ning(i.e.theinitialwedgeisalreadycritical),whilethefrontaldomainsteadilyacquiresastateofcriticaltaperbythrusting.Thisresultisatvariancewiththeclassicalassumptionthatshorteningofawedgemadeofhomogeneouslayerscreatesasinglecriticaltaper.Theexperimentalthrustwedgesdoshowotherfeaturescharacteristicforweakdécollementwedgeslikenarrowcross-sectional taper, large thrust spacingandvariety in thrustgeometries.Applicationof the results tonaturalthrustwedgesliketheJuraMountainscouldshednewlightontheirdevelopmentandgeometryatdepth.
2.51
Modelling the thermo-chemical evolution of the interiors of Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars and super-Earths
TackleyPaul,KellerTobias,ArmannMarina,vanHeckHein,NakagawaTakashi
Institut für Geophysik, ETH Zürich, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zürich ([email protected])
Thelatestgenerationoftheglobal3-DsphericalconvectionmodelStagYY[Tackley,PEPI2008]allowsthedirectcomputationofaplanet's thermo-chemicalevolution, including self-consistent lithosphericbehavior (e.g., rigid lid,plate tectonics,orepisodicplatetectonics[vanHeckandTackley,GRL2008]),chemicaldifferentiationinducedbymelting,largeviscosityvari-ations,aparameterizedcoreheatbalance,andarealistictreatmentofphasediagramsandmaterialproperties.Thelatterhasrecentlybeenaddedusingfreeenergyminimizationtocomputestablephasesasafunctionoftemperature,pressure,andcompositionasexpressedbyratiosofthefivemainoxides,andthusavoidstheneedforincreasinglycomplicatedandadhocparameterizationsofphasetransitions.Globalmodelsallowthecomputationofplanetarysecularcoolingincludingpredictionofhowthecoreheatfluxvarieswithtimehencetheevolutionofthegeodynamo,andpossibletransitionsinplatetectonicmode.Modernsupercomputersandclustersallowincreasinglyhigherresolution,withupto1.2billionunknownspossibleononly32dual-processornodesofanopteroncluster.Inongoingresearch,thistoolisbeingappliedtounderstandtheevolutionofEarth,Mars,Venus,Mercury,andsuper-Earths.Studyingseveralbodiesusinganintegratedapproachfacili-tatesamoresystematicandholisticunderstandingofplanetarybehaviourbothinsideandoutsideoursolarsystem.
OurMarsmodels[T.KellerandP.J.Tackley,Icarus2009]showthatwithanappropriateviscosityprofile,convectionrapidlydevelopsa'oneridge'planformconsistingofasingleridge-likeupwellingandsmall-scaledownwellingsbelowastagnantlid,andthatthisproducesadichotomouscrustaldistributionthatbearsastrikingfirst-orderresemblancetothecrustaldistri-butiononMars.TheactualboundaryofthecrustaldichotomyonMarsisnothemisphericalbutratherliketheseamonatennisball,andthisisreproducedbyourmodels,withthehighlandregionbeinglocatedabovetheupwelling.Furthermore,theelevationdifferencebetweenthehighlandandlowlandregionsisverysimilartothatonMars,althoughtheaveragecrustal thickness ishigher than thought tobeappropriate forMars. In somecalculations, the locationof theupwellingsubsequentlymigratestotheedgeofthehighlandregion,providinganexplanationforTharsis.Meltingisfoundtohaveadramaticinfluenceonthermalevolutionparticularlyduringtheearlystages.
110Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s WithourVenusmodelswearestudingthemodesofheatloss,theoriginoftheinferredsurfaceageandunderstandingtheadmittance(gravity/topography)ratio.Ofparticularinterestiswhetherasmoothevolutioncansatisfythevariousobserva-tional constraints, orwhether episodic or catastrophic behaviour is needed, as has beenhypothesised by some authors.Simulationsinwhichthelithosphereremainsstagnantovertheentirehistoryindicatethatovertime,thecrustbecomesatleastasthickasthemechanicallithosphere,anddelaminationoccursfromitsbase.Thedominantheattransportmecha-nism ismagmatic.A thickcrust is aquite robust featureof these calculations.Highermantleviscosity results in largertopographic variations, thicker crust and lithosphereandhigher admittance ratios; tomatch thoseofVenus, theuppermantlereferenceviscosityisabout1020Pasandinternalconvectionisquitevigorous.Themostsuccessfulresultsinmatch-ingobservationsarethoseinwhichtheevolutionisepisodic,beinginstagnantlidmodeformostoftheevolutionbutwith2-3burstsofactivitycausedbylithosphericoverturn.Ifthelastburstofactivityoccurs~1Gabeforepresent,thenthepresentday tends todisplay lowmagmaticratesandmostlyconductiveheat transport,consistentwithobservations. Inongoingworkweareexaminingtheeffectofcrustalrheologyandamoreaccuratemeltingtreatment.
DuetotheabsenceofanatmosphereandproximitytotheSun,Mercury’ssurfacetemperaturevarieslaterallybyseveral100sK,evenwhenaveragedoverlongtimeperiods.Thedominantvariationintime-averagedsurfaceToccursfrompoletoequa-tor(~225K).Herewedemonstrate,usingmodelsofmantleconvectionina3-Dsphericalshell,thatthisstationarylateralvariationinsurfacetemperaturehasasmallbutsignificantinfluenceonmantleconvectionandonthelateralvariationofheatfluxacrossthecore-mantleboundary(CMB).Weevaluatethepossibleobservationalsignatureofthislaterally-varyingconvectionintermsofboundarytopography,stressdistribution,gravityandmomentofinertiatensor.InfutureweplantotestwhetherthelateralvariationinCMBfluxiscapableofdrivingathermalwinddynamo,i.e.,weakdynamoactionwithnointernally-drivencoreconvectivemotions.
Thediscoveryofextra-solarplanetswithterrestrialcompositionandsizesuptotwicethatofEarth,so-called"super-Earths",haspromptedinterestintheirpossiblemantledynamicsandevolution.Thepressureatthecore-mantleboundary(CMB)ofa2*Earth-sizedsuper-EarthisaboutfourtimesthepressureatEarth'sCMB,whichhasastrongeffectonphysicalpropertiessuchasthermalexpansivity,diffusivityandviscosity.Themantleofsuchasuper-Earthwouldbemademostlyofpost-per-ovskite(PPv),whichhasdifferentphysicalpropertiesthanperovskite,themajormineralofEarth'slowermantle.Hereweusethenewly-computedrheologicalparametersforPPv,computedusingdensityfunctiontheory[Ammann,BrodholtandDobson, 2008] in simulations of super-Earths ofup to twiceEarth size. Themodels assumea compressible anelastic ap-proximationthatincludesthedepth-dependenceofmaterialparameters.RheologicalparametersformineralsotherthanPPvarebasedonthoseforperovskite.Plasticyieldingatlowpressuresfacilitatesplate-likelithosphericbehaviour.Resultsdemonstratethatsuper-EarthsareequallylikelyormorelikelythananequivalentEarth-sizedplanettobeundergoingplatetectonics,andthatthe lowviscosityofPPvhasastrongandpreviouslyunseeneffectsonthemantledynamicsofsuper-Earths.
2.52
A numerical approach to test lithospheric cross-sections for geodynamic consistency
ThielmannMarcel*,KausBorisJ.P.*
*(2) Geophysical Fluid Dynamics, Department of Earth Sciences, Sonneggstrasse 5, ETH Zurich, Zurich,
Crosssectionsthoughactivemountainbeltsareusuallyconstrainedbyarangeofgeophysicalandgeologicaldata,buttheresultinginterpretationsarenotnecessarilygeodynamicallyconsistent.Tobetterunderstandthethermomechanicalbeha-viourofsuchcollisionzonesitisofmajorimportancetocombineknowledgeaboutthegeometrical,thedensityandtheinferredviscositystructureofthosezones.Constraintsonthegeometrycanbeobtainedbyreflectionseismics,refractionseismicsorseismictomography.Constraintsonthedensitycomefromgravimetricalmethods.Effectiverheologicalparame-tersofthelithosphere,however,aremuchlessknown.Laboratoryexperimentsoncreepofrocks,extrapolatedtonaturalconditions,yieldseveralordersofmagnitudevariationintheeffectiveviscosity.Betterconstrainingtheeffectiveviscosityofthe lithosphere ishowevercrucial, sincevariations in theseparametersmightresult indrasticallydifferent lithosphericdynamics.Forthisreason,weheredevelopandtestanapproachthatemploys2Dthermomechanicalviscoplasticgeodynamicscodes.Ratherthanstudyingthelong-termdeformationofthelithosphere,asistypicallydonewithsuchcodes,weherefocusonthepresent-daystructureofthelithosphere.Themainassumptionsare:1)thepresentdaygeometryofthelithosphere(inparticularsurfacetopographyandMohodepth)isreasonablywellknown.2)Far-fieldplatevelocitiesareknown(fromplatemodelsorGPSmeasurements). The lithosphere is thendivided into several layers.By varying the effective viscosity and
111
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
icsdensityofeachofthelayers,wecanstudytheeffectsofchangingtheseparametersongravity,surfacevelocity,stress-distri-
bution,andmantleflow.Acomparisonofmodelleddatawithobservationswouldthus-inprinciple-givegeodynamicconstraintsontherheologyofthelithosphere.Beforeapplyingittorealdata,however,itisnecessarytostudythetheoreticalpowerofthemethodology.Forthisreasonwehereapplythemethodtosnapshotsobtainedfromsynthetic(million-yeartimescale)forwardruns.
2.53
Interaction of H2O rich fluid inclusions and natural quartz crystals in deformation experiments
ThustAnja*,HeilbronnerRenee*,StuenitzHolger**,TarantolaAlexandre***&HaraldBehrens****
*Geologisch-Paläontologisches Institut, Bernoullistrasse 32, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])**Institutt for geologi, Universitetet i Tromsø, Dramsveien 201, N-9037 Tromsø*** Faculté des Sciences, Université Henri-Poincaré, 54506 Vandoeuvre-lès-Nancy, France****Institut für Mineralogie Universität Hannover, Callinstraße 3, D-30167 Hannover
TheeffectofH2Oonthestrengthofquartziswellknownandhasbeendiscussedmanytimesintheliteratur(e.g.Grigge&
Blacic1965,Kronenberg&Tullis1984,Kronenberg1994).HerewestudytheH2Ointeractionsbetweennaturaldryquartzand
H2Orich fluid inclusionsduringdeformation in thesolidmediumGriggsapparatus.Thedeformationexperiments took
placeunderarangeofconfiningpressures (700MPaupto1500MPa),mostlyat900°Candstrainratesof~10-6s-1.Wede-formedcylindersofsinglecrystalquartzthatwerecoredintwodifferentorientations(1)normaltooneoftheprismplanesand(2)45°to<a>and45°to<c>(O+orientation).Thestrengthsofthesamplesvaryfrom84MPaupto414MPa,withthemajoritybetween150MPaand220MPa.Lowstrengthcanbeexplainedbytheformationofnewlyrecrystallizedgrainsanddeformationbydislocationcreep,higherstrengthcorrelateswithalowerH
2Ocontentandlessdeformationofthesample.
TheH2Orichfluidinclusionscontaindifferentchlorideslikeantarticite(CaCl
2·6H
2O)andhydrohalite(NaCl·2H
2O),measured
withmicrothermometry;theyrangeinsizefrom50µmto700µm.Afterdeformationtheinclusionsaremorehomogene-ouslydistributedthroughoutthesampleanddramaticallyreducedinsize(<0.1µm).Regionswithalargechangeinsizeoffluid inclusionsare theregionswiththehighestconcentrationofdeformation (Fig.1).There isalsoadifference in fluidhomogenisationforthetwodifferentorientations.Incrystalswithorientationnormal{m},thefluiddistributionismorehomogeneousandtoafinerscalethanincrystalsofO+orientation.Afterdeformationthesalinityofthefluidinclusionsisincreased,from~10.6wt.%equivalentNaClupto~12wt.%equivalentNaCl.ThereleaseofH
2Ofromfluidinclusionsisanimportantprocessforcrystalplasticdeformation.Fluidinclusionrupture,
microcrackingandthefastcrackhealingatthesetemperaturespromotethedistributionofH2Othroughthequartzand
influencesthestrengthofthematerial.
Figure1:Deformedsampleinorientationnormalto{m}(seestereoplot),thelinesseparatethehighlydeformedpartinthemiddle,witha
highfluidinclusiondensityfromthe+/-undeformedpartattheends.
112Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.54
The Lentas unit in Southern Crete: the base of the Pindos sedimentary series? – New paleontological results
VandelliAlessia*,VachardDaniel**,MartiniRossana***,KozurHeinzW.****,MoixPatrice*,StampfliGérardM.*
* Institut de Géologie et de Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole building, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])** Université des Sciences et Technologies de Lille 1, F-59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq Cedex, France*** Département de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Genève, rue des Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève**** Rézsü u. 83, H-1029 Budapest, Hungary
Creteisconstitutedbyacomplexnappestructure.Basedontheirtectonostratigraphicpositionandtheirtectonometamorphichistory,theseallochthonousunitsweresubdividedintotheupperandlowernappes,separatedbyadetachmentfault.InthestudiedareainsouthernCrete,onlytheuppernappesarerepresented. Inastructurallyascendingorder,theseare (1)theTripolitzaplatform,(2)thehemipelagictopelagicPindosdomain,(3)theArviunit,(4)theLentasseries,(5)theMiamoumé-lange,(6)themetamorphicAsteroussianappeand(7)theuppermostophioliticnappe(e.g.,Davi&Bonneau,1985).Thistecto-nicpilecouldactuallybepronetomodifications.OurpreliminaryresultsfocusontheLentasandthePindosunits(Fig.1).
IntheLentasseries,reworkedpebblesinaconglomerateaboveshallow-marinelimestonesyieldedthefirstoccurrenceoflateKungurian(latestEarlyPermian)foraminifersandcarbonatealgaeinGreece.Praelikanella cretaeVachard,Vandelli&Moixn.gen.,n.sp.andUragiellopsis bonneauiiVachard,Vandelli&Moixn.sp.arenewlyestablished.Theidentifiedassemblagebe-longstotheMisellina parvicostataZoneandhasaNorthPaleotethyansignature.Thepelagiclimestonesinterstratifiedwithsiltstones and turbiditic sandstones with plants yielded several conodonts species typical for the Lacian (early Norian) Epigondolella rigoiZoneandtheSevatian(lateNorian) Mockina bidentataZone.
InthepelagiclimestonesatthebaseofthePindosseries(Fig.1),weidentifiedLateTriassic(Carnian-Norian)foraminifersincluding Duostomina sp., Duotaxis sp., Endoteba ex gr. controversa Vachard & Razgallah, E. ex gr. obturata (Brönnimann &Zaninetti),Glomospirasp.,Ophthalmidiumspp.,Trochamminasp.,Glomospirasp.,MiliolidaeandNodosariidae.Inthesamesuc-cession,aconodontassemblagebelongingtotheMockina bidentataZonewassampled.
Our paleontological results in combinationwith field observations indicate a possible link between the Lentas and thePindossuccessions.BecauseofagesandfaciessimilaritieswithequivalentseriesinGreeceandTurkey,weproposethattheLentasseriesformsthebaseofthePindossequence.Furthermore,wesuggestthatthepelagiclimestonesofthePindosdo-mainareanequivalentoftheDrimosFm.,whilethepelagiclimestonesalternatingwithsandstonesandconglomeratesintheLentassequencecorrespondtothePriolithosFm.(cf.Degnan&Robertson,1998).TheseseriesbelongingtothepassivemarginofthePindosOceanarefoundallovertheeasternMediterraneanarea:thePindos-OlonosseriesinthePeloponneseandincontinentalGreece,theEthiaandMangassaseriesinCrete,theKöyceθizseriesintheLycianNappes,theHuθluseriesintheBeyθehir-HoyranNappesandtheMersinmélange(allinTurkey).Allofthesenappeslikelybelongtothesamepaleo-geographicdomain (Huθlu-PindosOcean,Moixetal.,2007). Inaddition,theshallowmarine lateKunguriansedimentsofPaleotethyanaffinityreworkedintheLentasunitiscompatiblewiththepresenceofreworkedpelagicFamennianconodontsatthebaseoftheMangassaseriesineasternCrete(Bonneau&Aubouin,1987).
Inconclusion,theLentasandPindosunitsbelongtothesamepaleogeographicrealmandrepresentthesynriftseriesandthedevelopmentofthepassivemarginoftheHuθlu-PindosOcean,aback-arcbasinofthePaleotethys.
REFERENCESBonneau,M.,Aubouin,J.,1987.DesfossilesdévoniensremaniésdansleTriassupérieurdelazoneduPindeenCrète(Grèce):
indicationssurlanaturedusubstratumanté-Permiendeszonehelléniquesexternes.C.R.Acad.Sc.Paris,t.304,SérieII,n°2Davi, E., Bonneau,M., 1985.Geologicalmap ofGreece, Andiskarion sheet 1:50000. Institute ofGeology andMineral
Exploration(IGME).Degnan,P.J.,RobertsonA.H.F.,1998.Mesozoic-EarlyTertiarypassivemarginevolutionofthePindosOcean(NWPeloponnese,
Greece).SedimentaryGeology117,33-70.Moix, P., Kozur,H.W., Stampfli,G.M.&Mostler,H., 2007.Newpalaeontological, biostratigraphic andpalaeogeographic
resultsfromtheTriassicoftheMersinMélange,SETurkey.In:Lucas,S.G.&Spielmann,J.A. (eds.).TheGlobalTriassic.NewMexicoMuseumofNaturalHistoryandScience,Bull.,41,282-311.
Vachard,D.,Vandelli,A.&Moix,P.,2009:DiscoveryofthelateKungurian(latestEarlyPermian)insouthernCrete(Greece);geologicalconsequences.Geobios(submitted).
113
Sym
po
siu
m 2
: St
ruct
ura
l G
eo
log
y, T
ect
on
ics
an
d G
eo
dyn
am
ics
late Senonian - Ypresian
Triassic ?
Late Triassic
early to middle Eocene
?
Dogger - early Senonian
Carnian - Liassic
Pind
osL
enta
s
Sevatian Mockina bidentata and Lacian Epigondolella rigoi zones
Sevatian Mockina bidentata Zone
reworked Kungurian foraminifers and carbonate algae
Late Triassic foraminifers
NEW DATA
SIMPLIFIED STRATIGRAPHY
cherts sandstones and shalespelagic limestones platform limestonesHalobia-bearing limestones
polygenic conglomerates
Fig.1:SyntheticstratigraphiccolumnoftheLentasandPindosunits
2.55
Modelling of silicic intrusions in Alpine type orogens
VogtKatharina*,GeryaTaras*,**,CastroAntonio***
*Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zürich, Sonneggstr. 5, 8092 Zürich, Switzerland([email protected])**Department of Geology, Moscow State University, 119199 Moscow, Russia***Department of Geology, University of Huelva, 21071 Huelva, Spain
Theemplacementofhugeintrusivebodiessuchasbatholithsisafundamentalissueingeology.Toimproveourunderstan-dingofthedynamicsofbatholithemplacementsunderanactivecontinentalmargin,asetofnumericalexperimentshavebeenperformedusinga2Dgeochemical–petrological–thermomechanicalnumericalmodel.Basedonfinitedifferencesandmarkerincelltechniques,themodelsimulatessubductionofanoceanicplatebeneathanactivecontinentalmargin.Themodelincludesspontaneousslabretreatandbending,dehydrationofsubductedcrust,aqueousfluidtransport,partialmelting,meltextractionandmeltemplacement.Asystematicparameterstudyhasbeencarriedoutbyvaryingtherheologicalweakeningeffectimposedbyfluidsandmelts.Aqueousfluidspercolatingfromthesubductingslabintothemantlewedgemainlyaffecttheforearcregion,whereasex-tractedmeltspropagatingfromthemantlewedgetowardthesurfacehaveamajor impactonthe lithospherebelowthearc.Theresultsindicatethatseveraltectonicregimesexist,someofwhichshowthedevelopmentofsilicicplumes.Itwasfoundthattherheologicalweakeningeffectofmeltsandfluidsisofmajorimportancefortheformationandemplacementofsi-licicplumes.Asafunctionoffluidandmeltweakening,silicicplumesmay(1)ascendandintrudeintothecrust,(2)extendhorizontallyandremainbeneaththecontinentallithosphere(underplating)or(3)beemplacedatalaterstage.Strongfluidrelatedweakeningpromotesstackingofsedimentsandthereforeresultsinalargeaccretionwedge.Inthiscase,insufficientsedimentsarebeingsubductedandplumesdonotform.Smallamountsoffluidweakening,ontheotherhand,resultsinstrongcouplingofthesubductingandoverridingplatesinacollision-likesubductionsetting.Inthiscase,largequantitiesofsedimentsarebeingsubductedandsedimentaryplumesareformed.However,ifthecontinentallithosphereisinsuffici-entlyweakenedbyextractedmelts,thesesedimentaryplumescannotascend.Ourresultsthussuggestthatbatholithsmaybetheresultoftheemplacementofsilicicplumesintothecrustandtheiremplacementdynamicsisstronglyaffectedbytherheologicalweakeningeffectoffluidsandmelts.
114Sy
mp
osi
um
2:
Stru
ctu
ral
Ge
olo
gy,
Te
cto
nic
s a
nd
Ge
od
yna
mic
s 2.56
Influence of thermal-chemical buoyancy in 3-D mantle wedge
GuizhiZhu*,TarasV.Gerya*,**,SatoruHonda***,PaulTackley*,DavidA.Yuen****
*Department of Geoscience, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (ETH Zurich), CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])**Adjunct Professor of Geology Department, Moscow State University, 119899 Moscow, Russia***Earthquake Research Institute, University of Tokyo, Tokyo 113-0032, Japan ****University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455-0219,USA
Weuse 3-D petrological-thermomechanical numerical simulations to investigate hydrous, partiallymolten, cold plumesoriginatedfromthesubductingslab,whichisfavoredbythelowereddensityandweakenedrheologicalpropertiesoftheoverlyingmantlecausedbythefluidreleasefromthesubductingslab.
ThesimulationswerecarriedoutwiththeI3ELVIScode[Gerya,2009],whichisbasedonamulti-gridapproachcombinedwithmarker-in-cellmethodsandconservativefinite-differenceschemes.Thedynamicsofthepartiallymoltenplumesisinvesti-gatedinrheology-densityspaceoftheplumes,includingtheeffectiveviscosityofthepartiallymoltenrocksandthedensitycontrastduetocompositionaldifference.
Lowered viscosity of the partially molten rocks atop the subducting slab favors the development of the cold plumes.Indeed,theplumesof1019Pasviscosityaremorepowerfuloncetheplumesstartsincetheystartlaterandaccumulatemorebuoyancy than thoseof 1018Pa s viscosity.Moreover, thenotabledifference inplumebehaviors arisesdependingon thelimitationforthemelt-relateddensitycontrast(whichsimulatesvariabledegreeofmeltextraction).Particularly,sheet-likeplumestendnottodevelopdirectlyawayfromthesubductingslab,buttomoveupwardsalongtheslabifthedensitycon-trastislimitedto50-100kg/m3.Threepatternsofplumes(finger-likeplumesthatformsheet-likestructureparalleltothetrench;ridge-likestructuresperpendiculartothetrench; flattenedwave-like instabilitiespropagatingupwardsalongtheuppersurfaceoftheslabandformingzig-zagpatternsparalleltothetrench)showninpreviouswork[Zhu,etal.,inrevision]occurforthemodelswithdensitycontrast>200kg/m3and1019Pasviscosityofpartiallymoltenrocks.Finger-likeplumesdevelopinallofourmodelswithdensitycontrast>50kg/m3.Asapossibleapplicationofour3-Dnumericalstudytonaturalmagmaticphenomena,wealsocomparespace-timemeltproductivitypatterncomputedfromthemodelswiththedistributionandevolutionofvolcanicactivitiesintheintraoce-anicsetting.
REFERENCESGerya,T.V.2009:Introductiontonumericalgeodynamicmodelling,CambridgeUniversityPress(inpress),Chapter14and
15.Zhu,G.,Gerya,T.V.,Yuen,D.,Honda,S.,Yoshida,T.,Connolly,J.A.D.2009:3-Ddynamicsofhydrousthermal-chemicalplumes
inoceanicsubductionzones.Geochem.Geophys.Geosyst.(inrevision)
116Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3. Mineralogy-Petrology-GeochemistryBernard Grobéty, Eric Reusser
Swiss Society of Mineralogy and Petrology (SSMP)
3.1 AbidiR.,Slim-ShimiN.,HatiraN.,MejriZ.:Apportdesdonneesdesrayonx,decrystallographieetdesinclusionsflu-idesdansladeterminationdel’origineetlacompositionmineralogiquesdelaseriebarytine-celestitedugisementd’AinAllega,Tunisieseptentrionale
3.2 AlfanoF.,BonadonnaC.,VolentikA.,ConnorC.,WattS.,PyleD.,ConnorL.:TephraStratigraphyoftheMay,2008,ChaitenEruption,Chile
3.3 BaderT.,FranzL.,deCapitaniC.,RatschbacherL.,HackerB.,WeiseC.,WiesingerM.,PoppM.:MetamorphicevolutionoftheQinlingGroup,Qinlingbelt,eastcentralChina
3.4 BauerK.,VennemannT.,MulchA.:StableisotopesinprecipitationasproxiesfortheNeogenetopographicandclima-ticevolutionoftheAlps
3.5 BejaouiJ.,SellamiA.,SkaggsS.:Mineralogy,FluidinclusionsandsulphurisotopeinvestigationofthePb-Zn-Ba-(Sr)depositsatOuedJebs-KefLasfar,NorthTunisia
3.6 BoekhoutF.:GeologyandgeochronologyoftheIlobatholithofsoutherncoastalPeru
3.7 Bouvet de Maisonneuve C., Dungan M., Bachmann O., Burgisser A.: Melt inclusions from Volcán Llaima (38.7°S,AndeanSouthernVolcanicZone,Chile):Insightsintoshallowmagmastorageandcrystallization
3.8 BurgisserA.,BergantzG.:Unzippingofcrystalmushasarapidmechanismtoremobilizeandhomogenizemagmabodies
3.9 Cenki-Tok B., Oliot E., Thomsen T., Berger A., Spandler C., Rubatto D., Robyr M., Manzotti P., Regis D., Engi M.,GoncalvesP.:BehaviourofallaniteduringmylonitisationandimplicationsforU-Th-Pbdating:casestudyattheMtMucrone,Italy
3.10 ChiaradiaM.,MerinoD.,SpikingsR.:Rapidtransitiontolong-liveddeepcrustalmagmaticmaturationandtheforma-tionofgiantporphyry-relatedmineralization(Yanacocha,Peru)
3.11 CostantiniL.,PioliL.,LongchampC.,BonadonnaC.,ClaveroJ.:Complexevolutionofahighlyexplosivebasaltic-ande-siteeruptionofVillarricavolcano,Chile:theChaimilladeposit
3.12 DegruyterW.,DufekJ.,BachmannO.:Pumice,awindowintothevolcanicconduit
3.13 DessimozM.,MüntenerO.:Hornblendefractionationandperaluminoustonalite:anexampleoftheChelanComplex,WashingtonCascades,USA
3.14 Dijkstra,A.:PeridotitesonMacquarieIsland:evidenceforanciently-depleteddomainsintheEarth’smantlepointingtoglobalProterozoicmelting‘events’?
3.15 EfimenkoN.,SpangenbergJ.,SchneiderJ.,AdatteT.,MateraV.,FöllmiK.:SphaleritemineralisationinBajocianshal-low-watercarbonatesintheSwissJuraMountainsrelatedtoextensionalsynsedimentarytectonicsduringtheMiddle-LateJurassic.
3.16 HingerlF.,WagnerT.,KulikD.,KosakowskiG.,DriesnerT.,ThomsenK.,HeinrichC.:Modelingtheevolutionofgeo-thermalreservoirsindeepfracturedrocks:Couplingchemistrytoheatandfluidtransport
3.17 LeutholdJ.,MüntenerO.,BaumgartnerL.,PutlitzB.,OvtcharovaM.,SchalteggerU.,ChiaradiaM.:Themafic–graniticconnectionoftheTorresdelPainelaccolith,Patagonia
3.18 LouvelM.,Sanchez-ValleC.,MalfaitW.,PokrovskiG.,BorcaC.,GrolimundD.:Brominespeciationandpartitioninginhighpressureaqueousfluidsandsilicatemelts:implicationforthebehaviorofhalogensinsubductionzones
3.19 MalfaitW.,Sanchez-ValleC.,ArdiaP.,MédardE.:Compositionaldependentcompressibilityofdissolvedwaterinsili-categlassesrevealedbyBrillouinscatteringonhaplograniticandbasalticglasses
3.20 MantegazziD.,Sanchez-ValleC.,ReusserE.,DriesnerT.:PVTxpropertiesofhighpressureaqueousfluidsbyBrillouinscatteringspectroscopy
3.21 ManzottiP.,RegisD.,Cenki-TokB.,RobyrM.,ThomsenT.,RubattoD.,ZucaliM.,EngiM.:EvidenceofJurassicriftingintheDentBlanchenappe(nearCignana,Italy)
117
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try
3.22 Márquez-ZavalíaF.,HeinrichC.A.,MeierD.:Orefluidevolutioninavolcanic-hostedepithermaloredeposit:FarallónNegro,Argentina
3.23 MattssonH.,BosshardS.:Columnarjointingandtheformationof“chisel-marks”intheHrossadalurlavaflow,nort-hernIceland
3.24 MattssonH.,ReusserE.:BaggalútarfromHvalfjördur,SWIceland:Volcanicspherulitesornot?
3.25 MonnardH,ManzellaI.,PhillipsJ.,BonadonnaC.:ConvectiveInstabilitiesinVolcanicClouds
3.26 MonsefI.,RahgoshayM.,EmamiM.H.,ShafaiiM.:GeochemicalconstraintsonthedevelopmentofaMesozoicvolcano-tectonicarcandfore-arcbasinintheSanandaj-SirjanZone,southIran
3.27 MonsefR.,EmamiM.,RashidnejadOmranN.:TranstensionalbasinsysteminCentralIranianVolcanicBelt
3.28 MoulasE.,KostopoulosD.:Metamorphicevolutionofakyanite-eclogitefromThermes,RhodopeMassif,Greece
3.29 PistoneM.,CaricchiL.,BurliniL.,UlmerP.:Rheologicalpropertiesofcrystal-andbubble-bearingsilicicmagmas:pre-liminaryexperimentalresults
3.30 RegisD.,ManzottiP.,BostonK.,Cenki-TokB.,RobyrM.,RubattoD.,ThomsenT.,EngiM.:Complexities inthehighpressuremetamorphichistoryofthecentralSesiaZonenearCimadiBonze(NWItaly)
3.31 ReitsmaM.,SchalteggerU.,SpikingsR.,CarlottoV.:ThetemporalevolutionoftheMitugroup,south-eastPeru-firstU-Pbagedata.
3.32 RosaA.,Sanchez-ValleC.,WangJ.,SaikiaA.:Single-crystalelasticpropertiesofsuperhydrousphaseBdeterminedbyBrillouinscatteringspectroscopy
3.33 ScalisiR.,CostantiniL.,BonadonnaC.,DiMuroA.:Theinfluenceofvolatilesinbasalticexplosiveeruptions:theexa-mpleoftheChaimillaeruption(3.1Ka,VillarricaVolcano,Chile).
3.34 SemytkivskaN.,UlmerP.:AnexperimentalstudyinthesystemFe-Mg-Ti-Cr-Si-O±Al:ilmenitesolidsolutionasafunc-tionofpressureandtemperature
3.35 SergeevD.,DijkstraA.:PyroxeniteveinsintheJurassicPindosOphiolite(NWGreece):cm-scalemantleheterogeneitypreservedinMORB-sourceperidotites
3.36 ShafaiiH.,SternR.,RahgoshayM.:TheZagrosCollisionZone:PetrologicalandgeodynamicalconstraintsonInnerandOuterZagrosOphioliticBelt
3.37 SkopelitisAl.,BachmannO.:Thetransitionfromcold-wettohotter-drierrhyolitesinsubductionzones:thecaseoftheKos-Nisyros-Yalivolcaniccenter,Aegeanarc,Greece
3.38 Tercier-WaeberM.-L.,HezardT.,MassonM.:DynamicsofCd,PbandCucyclinginastreamundercontrastingphoto-benthicbiofilmactivityandhydrologicalconditions.
3.39 ThomsenT.,PettkeT.,AllazJ.,EngiM.:LAMBERN–softwareU-Pb,Th-PbandPb-PbagedatingbyLA-ICP-MSanalysis
3.40 TrittschackR.,GrobétyB.:Firstinsightsintothedehydrationoflizardite
3.41 TsunematsuK.,BonadonnaC.,FalconeJ.L.,ChopardB.:Analyticalandnumericaldescriptionoftephradeposition:theexampleoftwolargeexplosiveeruptionsofCotopaxiVolcano,Ecuador
3.42 Udry A., Müntener O.: Petrology of mafic-ultramafic complexes within the Archean Lewisian complex of NWScotland
3.43 VilsF.,DijkstraA.,PelletierL.,LudwigT.,KaltA.:Iridium-stripheaterglasspellets:EffectsoffusiontemperatureandtimeonLi,BeandBcontent
3.44 VoegelinA.,Samankassou,E.,NäglerT.:Molybdenumisotopesinmoderncorals:investigationintotheirpotentialasredoxproxyofbygoneoceans
3.45 WangJ.,Sanchez-ValleC.,StalderR.:Effectofminorelements (H+andAl3+)ontheelasticpropertiesoforthopyr-xenes
3.46 WiederkehrM.,BousquetR.,MasafumiS.,ZiemannM.,BergerA.,SchmidS.:DecipheringtheAlpineorogenicevolu-tionfromsubductiontocollisionalthermaloverprint:Ramanspectroscopyand40Ar/39ArageconstraintsfromtheValaisanOcean(CentralAlps)
3.47 ZurfluhF.,HofmannB.,GnosE.,EggenbergerU.,OpitzC.:ApproximateterrestrialagedatingofmeteoritesbyuseofhandheldXRF
118Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.1
Apport des donnees des rayon x, de crystallographie et des inclusions flu-ides dans la determination de l’origine et la composition mineralogiques de la serie barytine -celestite du gisement d’Ain Allega. Tunisie septentrionale.
ABIDIRiadh*;SLIM-SHIMINajet**;HATIRANouri*;MEJRIZouhaier*
*: Faculté des sciences de Bizerte, département de géologie, Jarzouna-Bizerte.7021. Tunisie. **: Faculté des sciences mathématiques, physiques naturelles de Tunis. Campus Universitaire. 1060 Tunis. Tunisie. E.mail :[email protected] ; [email protected] ; [email protected] ; [email protected]
Legisementd’AinAllegaetdetype«Cap-rocks»estsituésurlabordureorientaledudiapird’AinAllega.Laminéralisationestdiscordanteparapportàlarocheencaissante,elleseprésentesousformedecimentdesbrèches,sousformederemplis-sagedesfracturesetdescavitésdedissolutionetsousformederemplacementdelarocheencaissante(Dolomied’âgetria-sique).cegisementprésentunesimpleminéralisationcomposéparlagalène,lasaphalerite,lamarcasiteetlapyriteavecuneganguereprésentéparlabarytine,lacélestite,ladolomite,lacalciteetlequartz.L’étudepétrographiquedesminérauxdelasériebarytine–célestitemontrequ’ilspossèdentplusieursfacièsenparticuliermicrofibreux,saccharoïde,fibrolamel-laireetprismatique.
L’étuderadiocristallographiquedesminérauxdecettesériebarytinecélestite((BaX,Sr
1-X)SO
4)avecXЄ[0-1])prouvequ’ona
unevariétéd’espècesdeminérauxdontonabarytinepure(100%BaSO4)abondant,célestitepur(100%SrSO
4)abondant,ba-
rytinesrantianfère(85to96.5%BaSO4)minoritaireetcélestite-baryfère(95%SrSO
4)minoritaire.Cesminérauxvarieentre
euxselonledegrédesubstitutiondestrontium(Sr)parlebaryum(Ba)danslacelestite(SrSO4)etledegrédesubstitutionde
baryumparlestrontiumdanslabarytine(BaSO4).Cettesubstitutionesttrèsbienvisibledanslesdiffractogrammesaura-
yonsXdesminérauxdecettesériequiestmatérialiséparlavariationdelaposition,l’intensitéetlamorphologiedesraies200,011,113,312delabarytineetlabarytinestrantianitèreetlesrais410,401et122delacélestiteetlacélestitebaryféreetaussivariationdeladistanceréticulairedupicprincipaldelabarytinede3.44à3.42 pourlabarytinestrantianitère(fig.1).
L’étudedesinclusionsfluidescontenuesdanslacélestitepuramontréquelesinclusionsprimaireetsecondairemonopha-séesàliquidesontlesplusabondantes.Lesmesuresmicrothermométriquesprouvequelefluideminéralisateurestd’originehydrothermaleetquiestcaractériséparunetempératured’homogénéisationélevais(180°C)etunesalinitémoyenneàéle-vais(16%poidséqNaCl).Lerapportentrelatempératured'homogénéisationetlasalinité(fig.2)indiquequelasaumuredebasinavecunecertaineintroductiondefluidedemélangemagmatique-météoriqueétaitresponsabledelaminéralisationdemineraid’AinAllega.Lasalinitéélevéedecettesolutionaitrésultédelalixiviationetladissolutiondesunitésévapori-tiquesduTrias.
Figure.1.VariationdelapositiondupicprincipaldelabarytineenfonctiondudegrédesubstitutiondeBaryumparStrontiumdansla
barytine.
119
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try
Figure.2.Diagrammedecorrélationbinairetempérature–salinitédesinclusionfluidesdanslacélestitedugisementd’AinAllega
3.2
Tephra Stratigraphy of the May, 2008, Chaiten Eruption, Chile
F.Alfano1,C.Bonadonna1,A.C.M.Volentik2,C.B.Connor3,S.F.L.Watt4,D.M.Pyle4,L.J.Connor3
1. Department of Mineralogy, University of Geneva, rue des Maraichers 13, CH-1205 Geneva, Switzerland.2. Department of Geology and Geophysics, Volcanology, Geochemistry and Petrology University of Hawai'I, 1680 East-West Road, POST 614B, Honolulu, HI 968223. Department of Geology - SCA 528, University of South Florida, 4202 E. Fowler Ave., Tampa, FL, 33620, USA.4. Department of Earth Sciences, University of Oxford, Parks Road, OX1 3PR, UK
Abstract.OnMay22008MountChaiten,locatedinthesouthernChile,onthenorthernsectorofPatagonia,afteronly36hoursofprecursoryseismicactivity,interruptedalongperiodofquiescenceofmorethan9000years,producinghisfirsthistoricaleruptionandcausing thespontaneousevacuationofChaitenvillage, located fewkmfromthevent.The2008eruptionofChaitenisconsideredtobethelargestvolcaniceventsincetheeruptionofHudsonvolcano(Chile)in1991,andthefirstrhyoliticeventsincetheeruptionofNovarupta(Alaska)in1912.Theactivitywascharacterizedbyseveralexplosiveeventsassociatedwithplumesupto20kma.s.l.Theproductshavebeendispersedinawidearea(morethan200kmofdistance fromthecrater),withthefinestashreachingtheAtlanticcoastofArgentina.Satellite imagesclearlyshowthedevelopingofthecounterclockwiserotationofthedispersalaxisfromSSEtoNNErelatedtoashiftinwinddirection.Ourfieldobservationsinthemedialarea(5-20kmfromthevent)indicatethattheMay2008tephradepositconsistsofnumerouslayers,mostofwhichcanbecorrelatedwithindividualsmallexplosionsandsubsequentfalloutevents.Theselayersvaryfromextremelyfine-grainedtephratolayersoflapilliandlargeblocks,composedofbothjuvenileandlithicmaterial.Indistalarea(>200km),thefalloutdepositconsistsonlyofwhitetogreyfineandcoarseash,eventuallycontainingsomeac-cretionary lapilli.Although theMay2008eruptionwasofmoderate volume, tephra fallouthada substantial impact intermsofgenerationoflahars(inproximal-medialarea,upto20kmfarfromthevent),damagetovegetation(i.e.forestsandcrops)andremobilizationoffineashwitheffectstohumanandanimalshealth.Inthisworkweproposeareconstructionofthestratigraphyofthefirstevents,whichtookplacebetween2ndand8thMay2008andafirstphysicalcharacterizationoftheeruption.Themedialstratigraphyassociatedwiththefourmainexplosiveeventscouldberecognized:2nd-3rdMay,4th-5thMay,6th-7thMayand8thMay,withanestimatedcumulativevolumeof0.118±0.057km3(integrationofpower-lawfitting)Forthelastevent,representedbyalayercomposedmainlyoflithiclapilliandblocks(>2mm),anisoplethmapwascompiledandtheassociatedplumeheightwasdetermined.Theplumeisestimatedtobeabout19km,whencalculatedconsideringtheaverageofthegeometricmeanofthethreeaxesofthe5maximumclasts,andabout17km,whencalculatedconsider-ingthegeometricmeanofthethreeaxesofthe50thpercentileclast.Thesevaluesareclosetothesatelliteobservationsfortheeventofthe8thMay(i.e.about20kma.s.l.).
120Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.3
Metamorphic evolution of the Qinling Group, Qinling belt, east central China
BaderThomas*,FranzLeander*,deCapitaniChristian*,RatschbacherLothar**,HackerBradleyR.***,WeiseCarsten**,WiesingerMaria**,PoppMichael**
*Mineralogisch-Petrographisches Institut, Universität Basel, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])**Institut für Geologie, Technische Universität Bergakademie Freiberg, D-09599 Freiberg***GeologicalSciences,UniversityofCalifornia,SantaBarbara,CA-93106
TheQinlingGroup,partoftheUpperProterozoic-TriassicQinlingbelt,mainlycomprisesfelsicgneisses,amphibolitesandmarbles. Itcanbesubdividedintotwoparts.ThenorthernmarginexperiencedaCambrianultrahigh-pressuremetamor-phismasevidentbytheoccurrenceofdiamondinclusionsinmetamorphiczircon(Yangetal.,2003).Thecentral-southernpartwasaffectedbymigmatisationwithinaDevonianmagmaticarccausedbyanorthwardtrendingsubductionzonefac-ingtheQinlingorogen(Ratschbacheretal.,2003,forareview).FewdataonthemetamorphicevolutionofthesouthernpartoftheQinlingGroupwerepublishedbyYouetal.(1993)whilesuchdataarelackingforthenorthernmargin.Inthecurrentstudy,wepresentnewpetrologicdataforbothpartsderivedbymeansofequilibriumphasecalculationsandconventionalgeothermobarometrycombinedwith40Ar/39ArandTh/Pbgeochronology.
EclogitesfromtheNorthernmarginoftheQinlingGrouparefinetomedium-grained,weaklyfoliatedrocksthatoccuraslenseswithdiametersupto2mmantledbyphengitegneisses.Texturally,oursamplesgiveindicationsfortheUHPeventbynumerousradialcracksaroundquartzinclusionsingarnetpointingtoformercoesite.Theassemblageofthepressurepeakcomprisesgarnet(core)–omphacite–coesite–phengite–rutile.However,modellingusingtheDOMINOprogramandtheapplicationofconventionalgeothermobarometersyieldedquartz-eclogitefaciesconditionsof~600°Cat1.8-2.2GParepre-sentinganearlyexhumationstage.Theexhumationhistoryof theeclogitic rocks is furtherconstrainedby the lateam-phibolitefaciesmineralassemblagegarnet(rim)–amphibole–plagioclase–quartz–ilmenitepointingto~650°Cat1.0-1.4GPa.Thiswasverifiedbyconventionalthermobarometryongarnetamphibolite75221Candgarnetgneiss75214Dfromthesameunitpointingto630-660°Cat1.0GPa(fig.1,left).
ThecentralandsouthernpartsoftheQinlingGrouprevealhigh-grademetamorphicPTconditionsasevidentbymigmatisa-tionoffelsicgneisses.Peakmetamorphicassemblagesinmetapeliticgneissescomprisegarnet–plagioclase–Kfeldspar–quartz–sillimanite–ilmeniteandgarnet–hornblende–plagioclase–quartz–ilmeniteinmetabasites.PTestimatesusingtheDOMINOprogramandconventionalgeothermobarometrypointto600-730°Cat0.3-0.7GPa(fig.1,right).ThelowerPTconditionsareinterpretedtoindicatearetrogradedevelopmentofthemetamorphism.Noindicationofeclogitefaciesmeta-morphismwasfoundinthegneissesandamphibolites.However,thefindingofasmallbodyofstronglyoverprintedspinelperidotite inthesouthernpartofthisprofile,whichhadre-equilibratedto630-670°C (i.e. identicaltemperaturestothesurroundinggneissesandamphibolites),pointstoaprobableearlyHPevent.
40Ar/39ArdatingofphengitesfromthenorthernmarginoftheQinlingGroupyields470±1Ma.Significantlyyoungerageswereobtainedbydatingmetamorphicmonazite(Th/Pb,340-395Ma),hornblende(40Ar/39Ar,373-395Ma)andbiotite(40Ar/39Ar,330-390Ma)fromthecentralandsouthernQinlingGroup.
ThesefindingsprovethattheexhumationoftheUHPmetamorphicstookplaceinEarly-toMid-Ordovician.Therocksofthecentral-southernQinlingGroupunderwentaDevonianultrametamorphisminthemiddlecrustwithinamagmaticarcset-tingwithhighheatflow.Furtherinvestigationswillshow,howbothsubunitshadbeenjuxtaposed.
REFERENCESRatschbacher, L.,Hacker,B.R.,Calvert,A.,Webb, L.E.,Grimmer, J.C.,McWilliams,M., Ireland,T.,Dong, S.&Hu, J. 2003:
Tectonics of the Qinling Belt (Central China): Tectonostratigraphy, geochronology, and deformation history.Tectonophysics366,1-53.
Yang,J.,Xu,Z.,Dobrzhinetskaya,L.F.,GreenII,H.W.,Pei,X.,Shi,R.,Wu,C.,Wooden,J.L.,Zhang,J.,Wan,Y.,Li,H.,2003:Discovery ofmetamorphicdiamonds in centralChina: an indicationof a > 4000-km-long zoneofdeep subductionresultingfrommultiplecontinentalcollisions.TerraNova,15,370-379.
You,Z.,Han,Y.,Suo,S.,Chen,N.&Zhong,Z.,1993:MetamorphichistoryandtectonicevolutionoftheQinlingComplex,easternQinlingMountains,China.JournalofmetamorphicGeology,11,549-560.
121
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try
Figure1:left:MetamorphicdevelopmentofthenorthernmarginoftheQinlingGroup.Right:PTestimatesofthecentral-southern
QinlingGroup.
3.4
Stable isotopes in precipitation as proxies for the Neogene topographic and climatic evolution of the Alps
BauerKerstin*,**,VennemannTorsten*,MulchAndreas**
*Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Anthropole, Université de Lausanne, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland ([email protected]) ** Institut für Geologie, Leibniz Universität Hannover, Callinstr. 30, 30167 Hannover, Germany
Thepaleoelevationofamountainbeltisanimportantparametertounderstanditsevolutionandsetsconstraintsonupliftanderosionratesandalsoonthepaleoclimate.Aquantitativetooltodeterminethisisthealtitudeeffectonthestableiso-topecompositionofprecipitation,sincetheδ18OandδDvaluesinprecipitationdecreasewithelevation.
Precipitationofthepastcanbepreservedinsurface-formedhydroussilicatesandalso,afterinfiltrationviafaultsandshearzones,inmetamorphicmineralswhichinteractedwithmeteoricwaterand/ortrappedthiswaterasfluidinclusions.
ThisstudyaimstoreconstructthechangesinisotopiccompositionofprecipitationandthuspalaeoelevationoftheEuropeanAlpsduringtheMiocene.Therefore,isotopiccompositionsofmineralsderivedfromsurfacealterationand/orfaultgaugesofdifferentlocalitiesintheAlpswillbestudied.
Toobtainacorrectionfortheclimaticconditionswhichcanalsochangethe18O/16OandD/Hratios,lowelevationmaterialfromtheAlpineforelandcoveringthesametimeperiodwillalsobeanalyzed.ClaymineralsfromtheMolassebasinappeartobepromisingmaterialandpaleoclimateinformationderivedforsealevelconditionsfromseveraloftheselayersalreadyexistfromstudiesofmarinefossils.
Additionally,sampleswillbeanalyzedfrompresentsoilhorizonstofurtherexaminethelocaldependencesofisotopicvari-ationswithelevationandtheuptakeoftheisotopiccompositionfromrainwaterintothemineralsformed.
REFERENCESJanz,H.&Vennemann,T.W.,2005:Isotopiccomposition(O,C,SrandNd)andtraceelementratios(Sr/Ca,Mg/Ca)ofMiocene
marine and brackish ostracods fromNorth Alpine foreland deposits (Germany and Austria) as indicators forpaleoclimate.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology225(2005),216-247.
122Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y Kocsis,L.,Vennemann,T.W.,Hegner,E.,Fontignie,D.,&Tütken,T.,2009:ConstraintsonMioceneoceanographyandclimateintheWesternandCentralParatethys:O-,Sr-,andNd-isotopecompositionsofmarinefishandmammalremains.
Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology271(2009),117-129.Mulch,A.,Teyssier,C.,Cosca,M.A.,Vanderhaeghe,O.,&Vennemann,T.W.,2004:Reconstructingpaleoelevationineroded
orogens.Geology32,6(2004),525-528.Mulch,A.&ChamberlainC.P.,2007:StableIsotopePaleoaltimetryinOrogenicBelts–TheSilicateRecordinSurfaceand
CrustalGeologicalArchives.ReviewsinMineralogy&Geochemistry66(2007),89-118.
3.5
Mineralogy, Fluid inclusions and sulphur isotope investigation of the Pb-Zn-Ba-(Sr) deposits at Oued Jebs-Kef Lasfar, North Tunisia
JaloulBEJAOUI*,AhmedSELLAMI**andS.A.SKAGGS***
* Centre National des Sciences et Technologies Nucléaires, Tunisie, [email protected] ** Office National des Mines, Tunisie *** Department of Geology, University of Georgia, 210 Field St, Athens, GA 30602, USA
TheOuedJebs-KefLasfarPb-Ba-Zn-(Sr)depositislocatedinnorthernTunisia,60KmfromTunis(Fig.1).Sulfidesmineraliza-tion ismainlyassociatedwithCenomanian-Turonian inter-layered limestoneandmarlsof theCretaceous,whichreplacecarbonate,cementedbrecciasandcavities(Fig.2).ThegeologyoftheareaisdominatedbymassivelimestoneandmarlylimestoneunitsofCretaceousage,whichareexten-sivelyfolded.Theoredepositconsistsofasystemofmineralizedveinsandbreccias,extendingoveranareaof15km2.Theore-hostinglimestonelayersarecharacterizedbyastrongkaoliniteenrichment,inamountsdirectlyrelatedtotheproporti-onoftheoreminerals.Themineralization lies mainly within the organic-rich black shale succession of the Bahloul Formation (Cenomanian-Turonian)andtoalesserextentalongthetransitionzonebetweenTriassicandCretaceous),wherezebra-texturedcelestitelayersalsooccur (Fig.3).Thecelestite-calcite rhythmites,whosestructure iscausedbygrainsizevariation,occurmainlyaroundtherisingsaltdiapirs.Kaoliniteisassociatedwithhydrothermalmineralizationandoccursintheparagenesisofthesulfidesinbreccias(Fig.3).ThemineralogicalcharacteristicsofkaoliniteweredeterminedbyX-raypowderdiffractionandtheyare7,15A°(d001)and3,57A°(d002)andisattenuatedafterheating.Treatmentwithethyl-glycolhadnoeffect.Fluidinclusionswereinvestigatedinhydrothermalbariteassociatedwithsphaleriteandgalena.Alltheobservedfluidin-clusionsare two-phase liquidandvapor inclusions, but theaqueous fluid inclusions inbaritewhich couldbeanalysed,rangeinsizefrom20to100µm.Primaryinclusionsexhibithomogenizationtemperature(Th)meanvaluesrangingfrom110°Cto140°C,withsalinitiesof14to18wt.%NaClequiv.ThemicrothermometricdataareinagreementwiththosemeasuredintheJebelAjeredPb-Zn-Baoredeposit(Bejaouietal.,2008).MicrothermometricdataoffluidinclusionsrevealtheinvolvementofbasinalbrinesinmineralizationofOuedJebs.δ34SvaluesinsphaleriteandgalenaatOuedJebs-KefLasfarrangefrom0.7‰to5.3‰.Thesepositivevaluessuggestanoriginfromevaporitesulfates,followedbythermochemicalreduction(Claypooletal.,1980).The present fluid inclusions study demonstrates the involvement of basinal brines in mineralization of Oued Jebs-KefLasfar.
Key words:basinalbrines-OuedJebs-KefLasfar-Fluidinclusions-Pb-Zn-Ba-(Sr).
AcknowledgmentsWearegratefultoPr.MariaBONIforhelpfulcommentsandsuggestions.REFERENCESBejaouiJ.,BouhlelS.,CardellachE.,andPiquéÀ.(2008)-MineralogyandfluidinclusionstudyofcarbonatehostedPb-Zn-Ba-
(Cu)depositsinJebelAjered,CentralTunisia.6SwissGeoscienceMeeting(SGM)2008,173-175.ClaypoolG.E,HolseerW.H.,KaplanI.R.,SakaiH.,andZakI.(1980)-Theagecurveofsulphurandoxygenisotopesinmarine
sulphateandtheirmutualinterpretation.Chem.Geol.,28,163-187.
123
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try
Fig 1. Location of the Oued Jebs ore deposit within the diapirs zone in Tunisian structural map.
Fig 2. Cross section of Oued Jebs Pb-Zn-Ba-(Sr) ore deposits. : 1 Eocene: bioclastic limestone and marls, 2 Cenomanian-Turonian: marly li-
mestone, 3 Albian: marl and limestone, 4 Aptian: carbonate series within silty clay layers. 5 transition zone: marls and dolomite-rich “ze-
bra” celestite, 6 Trias: evaporites, 7: Pb-Zn-Ba-(Sr) orebodies, 8 faults.
Fig 3. A Cenomanian limestone affected by fault and fractures, B Mosaic breccias cemented by sulfides mineralization, C Marls rich in ka-
olinite mineralized with massive galena, D Mosaic breccias cemented with kaolinite and disseminated galena.
124Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.6
Geology and geochronology of the Ilo batholith of southern coastal Peru
BoekhoutFlora*,ThierrySempere**,RichardSpikings*,UrsSchaltegger*
*Earth and Environmental Sciences, Rue de Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève**IRD et LMTG, 14 Avenue Edouard Belin, 31400 Toulouse, France
InSoutherncoastalPerutheso-calledIlobatholithisemplacedinthe‘Chocolate‘formation,ofEarlytoMiddleJurassicage,thatcomprisesmorethan1000mofbasalticandandesiticflows,agglomeratesandbreccias.Previousworkershavecorrela-tedthedioritictogranodioriticrocksofthisintrusionwiththe‘CoastalBatholith‘ofCretaceoustoPaleogeneage.However,K-ArandAr-ArgeochronologyofplutonicrocksnearthecityofIlopointtoEarlyJurassicages(Clarketal.1999,Sánchez1983a).Thispartoftheplutonicassemblagewasthusemplacedpriortotheinitiationof‘Coastalbatholith‘emplacement.Maficandfelsicgranitoidmagmasareintimatelyassociated,asreflectedbytheemplacementofmixeddiorite-granodioriteunits.Also,maficandfelsicmagmaminglingnorthofIlohavebeenobserved,e.g.globularenclavesofdioriteingranodio-rite,elongated inclusions,bothbasalticandcomposite (basaltic/dacitic) synplutonicdikes: thusnosimplemafic to felsicintrusivesequenceprevailedduringbatholithconstruction.OuraimistodescribeandinterpretthehistoryoftheIlobatholithandtodiscusshowthemagmatichistoryofthisbatholithfitsintotheframeworkofmagmagenesisandmodesofemplacementalongtheactiveAndeanmargin.ThisfirstoccurenceoflargevolumesofplutonicrocksmaywellrepresentthefirststagesofAndeansubduction(Oliverosetal.2006).Acombinationoffieldobservations,zirconU-Pb(LA-ICP-MSandCA-ID-TIMS)data,andelementgeochemistryofthebatho-lithwillbeused todistinguishbetweendifferentmagmaticpulsesand theirduration.AdditionalSr,Nd,Pb,Hf isotopestudieswillbecarriedout,specifyingthemagmaticsourceofthedifferentpulsesofplutonicactivity.
Eastwardtiltingof20-30°hasexposedacompletecross-sectionofthebatholithinmapviewwithannorth-northeastwardpaleo-updirection,revealingthattheIlobatholithhasatabularshape:WearethereforeabletostudythecontactwiththeChocolateformationaboveandbelowthebatholith,includingasamplingcampaignalongseveralcrosssectionsthroughthebatholithfordatingandgeochemicalanalyses.Inadditiontosamplesfromthebatholithitself,clasticsedimentaryrocksaboveandbelowthebatholithhavebeensampledinordertodeterminetheirmaximumdepositionalagebydatingdetritalzirconsusingLA-ICP-MS.Inthiscasethesameorverysimilardetritalzirconpopulationsshouldbefoundinbothlocations(belowandabovethetabularplutonicbody),astheywereoriginallyjuxtaposed.
Preliminarydataof3samplesdatedbyU-PbTIMSshowapulseofmagmatismat~164MawithanepsilonHfrangingfrom+4to+6.9indicatingadepletedmantlesourcetypicalofcontinentalmarginsettings.Thegeochemicaldatasuggestacalc-alkalinemagmasource.McBrideetal(1983)postulatedtwointrusivepulsesonthebasisofsixconventionalK-ArdatesonfourgranitoidsamplesintheIloareaofLateJurassic(ca.151–159Ma)andmid-Cretaceous(96–111Ma).Sánchez(1983a)obtainedsimilarAlbianK-ArdatesforseveralgranodioriticsamplesnortheastofIlobutalsofoundEarlytoMiddleJurassicdates(196-182Ma)fortwodioriticrocksfromthecoastalzone.Ourpreliminarydatamightindicateanothermagmaticpulse,orshowalongerdurationofoneofthepreviouslydecribedpulses.
REFERENCESClarkAlanH,FarrarEdward,KontakDanielJ.,LangridgeRobertJ.1999:GeologicalanGeochronologicalConstraintsonthe
MetallogenicEvolutionoftheAndesofSoutheasternPeru,EconomicGeology,85,1520-1583.OliverosVeronica,FéraudGilbert,AguirreLuis,FronariMichel,MorataDiego2006:TheEarlyAndeanMagmaticProvince
(EAMP):40Ar/39ArdatingonMesozoicvolcanicandplutonicrocksfromtheCoastalCordillera,northernChile,JournalofVoclanologyandGeothermalResearch,157,311-330.
McBride,S.L.,Robertson,R.C.R.,Clark,A.H.,andFarrar,E.1983:Magmatismandmetallogeneticepisodesinthenortherntinbelt‘CordilleraReal’Bolivia,Geol.Rundschau,72,685–713.
Sánchez,A.W.,1983:EdadesK-ArenrocasintrusivasdelareadeIlo,Dpto.deMoquegua,Geol.Soc.PeruBol,71,183–192.
125
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.7
Melt inclusions from Volcan Llaima (38.7°S, Andean Southern Volcanic Zone, Chile): Insights into shallow magma storage and crystallization
BouvetdeMaisonneuveCaroline*,DunganMichael*,BachmannOlivier**&BurgisserAlain***
* Départment de Minéralogie, Rue des Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève ([email protected], [email protected])**University of Washington, Earth and Space Sciences, Seattle, WA 98195-1310 ([email protected])*** Institut des Sciences de la Terre d'Orléans - CNRS, Fr-45071 Orléans ([email protected])
Olivine-hostedmelt inclusions in scoria from four large historic eruptions of Llaima are used to elucidate processes ofmagmadifferentiation, recharge,mixing,anderuption triggering.ThesedepositswereproducedasviolentStrombolianeruptionsofcrystal-richmaficmagma(<6wt%MgO;25-45%plag+oliv±cpx)associatedwithvoluminouslavaflows.Majorelementmeltinclusioncompositionsarehighlydiverseinsinglesamples(50-58wt%SiO
2;6-3wt%MgO).Theseoverlapwith
thewhole-rockdatatrenddefinedbytheentirevolcanoupto53-55%SiO2,butmoreevolvedcompositionsformadivergent,
lineartrendupto>2wt%TiO2withAl
2O
3aslowas12.5wt%at57-58wt%SiO
2,comparedto1.2-1.4wt%TiO
2and16-17wt%
Al2O
3at58wt%SiO
2inmostLlaimaandesiticmagmas.Theevolvedextensionofthemeltinclusiontrendisinferredtobe
theproductofshallowevolutionofinterstitialmeltduringtheformationofcrystalmushasaconsequenceofdegassinganddecompressioncrystallizationfollowingmagmastagnation.ThesuppressionofFeTi-oxidestabilityandthedominanceofplagioclasecrystallizationareconsistentwithlow-Pdryconditions.TheseobservationsareinaccordwithrelativelylowH
2O
(dominantly1-3.5wt%)andCO2(dominantly0-300ppm)contentsinmeltinclusions(SIMS-ASU),whichyieldsaturationpres-
suresof~300-500bars(<2km).H2OandCO
2contentsdonotcorrelatewithmajorelementmeltcomposition,andmeltinclu-
sionfluid-saturationpressuresdonotcorrelatesystematicallywithfractionationindicessuchasK2OorMg#.Corollariesto
theseobservationsarethatdegassedmatrixglassesattachedtomanyoftheseolivinesarecommonlylessevolvedthancor-respondingmelt inclusions (generally inequilibriumwithhostolivines),olivinecorecompositions insinglesamplesarediverse (Fo
69-83),andmanyof theseolivinesarereverselyzonedtorimsofFo
77-79.Theabsenceofcorrelateddegassingand
magmaevolutiontrends inhistoricLlaimamagmassuggests that theyarestoredasmultiplebodiescreatedbyahigherfrequencyofmagmareplenishmentincomparisontothefrequencyoflargeeruptions.Thistemporal-spatialdisconnectionleadstoisolatedevolutionanddegassingofdiscretemagmabatches,followedbyassemblyjustpriortoeruption.Injectionofrelativelyhotandmaficgas-richmagmaisprobablythetriggeringmechanism,inaccordwithandhigherOlivine-Melttemperaturesrecordedbyrelativelyprimitivematrixglasses.
3.8
Unzipping of crystal mush as a rapid mechanism to remobilize and homogenize magma bodies
BurgisserAlain*,BergantzGeorge**
*ISTO, CNRS - University of Orléans, 1a rue de la Férollerie, 45071 Orléans cedex 2, France ([email protected])**Dept. of Earth and Space Sciences, University of Washington, Box 351310, Seattle, WA 98195-1310 USA
ThelargestproductsofmagmaticactivityonEarth,thegreatbodiesofgraniteandtheircorrespondinglargeeruptions,haveadualnature:homogeneityatthelargescaleandspatialandtemporalheterogeneityatthesmallscale.Thisdualitycallsfor amechanism that 1) removes selectively the large-scaleheterogeneities associatedwith the incremental assembly ofthesemagmaticsystemsand2)occursrapidlydespitecrystal-rich,viscousconditionsseeminglyresistanttomixing.
Wepresenta simpledynamic template canunifyawide rangeof seemingly contradictoryobservations fromboth largeplutonicbodiesandvolcanicsystemsbyamechanismofrapidremobilization(“unzipping”)ofhighlyviscouscrystal-richmushes.Wedemonstrate that this remobilizationcan lead to rapidoverturnandproduce theobserved juxtapositionofmagmaticmaterialswithverydisparateagesandcomplexchemicalzoning.Whatisnovelaboutourmodelistherecogniti-onthattheprocesshastwostages.Initiallyastiffmushymagmaisreheatedfrombelowproducingareductionincrystalli-nitythatleadstothegrowthofasubjacentbuoyantmobilelayer.Asecondstageoccurswhenthethickeningmobilelayer
126Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y becomessufficientlybuoyanttopenetratetheoverlyingviscousmushymagmaandproducerapidoverturnoftheentiresystem.Thisprocessexportshomogenizedmaterialfromthelowermobilelayertothetopofthesystem,andleadstoparti-aloverturnwithintheviscousmushitselfasanadditionalmechanismofmixing.
TheagreementbetweencalculatedandobservedunzippingratesforhistoricaleruptionsatPinatuboandatMontserratde-monstratesboththegeneralapplicabilityofthemodelandtheabilityofunzippingtorapidlyproducelargeamountsofmobilemagmaavailableforeruption.Thismechanismfurthersourunderstandingofthebifurcationbetweencrustbuil-dingbyformationofperiodicallyhomogenizedplutonsandignimbriteformationbylargeeruptions.
3.9
Behaviour of allanite during mylonitisation and implications for U-Th-Pb dating: case study at the Mt Mucrone, Italy
Cenki-TokBénédicte*,OliotEmilien**,ThomsenTonnyB.*,BergerAlfons***,SpandlerCarl****,RubattoDaniela*****,RobyrMartin*,ManzottiPaola*,RegisDaniele*,EngiMartin*andGoncalvesPhilippe**
*Uni. Bern, IfG, Baltzerstr. 1+3, 3012 CH-Bern ([email protected])**Uni Franche-Comté, UMR6249, 16 rte de Gray, F-25030 Besançon***Uni Copenhagen, Institute for Geography and Geology, Øster Voldgade 10, DK-1350 Copenhagen****James Cook University, 101 Angus Smith Dr, QLD 4811 Townsville, Australia*****Australian National University, 0200 Canberra, Australia
Allaniteoccursinmeta-granodioriteshowingdifferentamountsofstrain,fromundeformed(a)tomylonitic(f).ThisbodyintrudedthepolycyclicSesiabasementatPermiantimesandunderwentHPmetamorphismandductiledeformationduringtheAlpineconvergence.WestudytheeffectsofdeformationonallaniteU-Th-Pbapparentages.In the mylonitic rock allanite forms mm-size angular grains in a strongly recrystallised matrix and shows exclusivelyPermianages,eventhoughthegrainsareintimatelylinkedtoAlpinedeformationandmetamorphism.Thesegrainsoccurinmm-sizedlensesaroundwhichthemyloniticfoliationflows.Inadditiontoallanite,theselensesarecomposedofrandom-ly oriented phengite and Ca-rich garnet (up to 30wt%). During mylonitisation these allanite grains were mechanicallyshieldedbyarobustmineral(epidote)thatsubsequentlybrokedowntogarnetandphengite.Theundeformedrockgivesinsightintoallaniteformingreaction.RelicsofPermianmagmaticmonazitearefoundexclusi-velyintheundeformedsampleswherethemagmatictexturesandmineralsarelargelypreserved.Coronasofallanite,thoriteandapatitesurroundmonaziterelicsindicatingthereaction:monazite+plagioclase+fluid--->allanite+apatite+thorite.ThesetexturesarelocatedatthecontactwheremagmaticbiotiteandplagioclasebreakdowntoformtheHPassemblagephengiteandgarnet.Alpineallaniteisfoundintheundeformedrock.Itismuchsmaller(ca.200µm),presentfragmentedtextureswithsatelliteneocrystals,isrichinSr(upto2wt%)andhasapositiveEuanomaly.Inmediumstrainrockssmall(<20µm)Sr-richrimsaroundPermianallanitecanbefound.ThisindicatesthatAlpineallanitecrystalisationisclearlyassociatedtoplagioclasebreakdown(plagioclase+H2O--->jadeite+zoisite+quartz)andmusthavebeentriggeredbylocalfluidpresentconditions.The interpretation of these complex textures, microstructures and ages needs superposition of at least two events. AtPermiantimes,mm-sizedallaniterimedbyepidotemostprobably formed in latemagmatic fracturesassociatedto fluidcirculation.AtAlpinetimes,thesefracturesplaytheroleofprecursorheterogeneitieswhereductiledeformationis loca-lized.AllaniteinthemyloniteismechanicallyandchemicallyshieldedduringtheAlpineevent.Allaniteisarobustchronometer.Howeverincaseofsuperpositionofdeformationevents,itsPbisotopecompositionmaynotrecordalltheeventsseenbytherock.ReworkingofoldstructuresduringtheAlpineorogenyhastobetakenintoac-countwheninterpretingagesonallaniteindeformedrocks.Adeeperlookintotexturesandstructures–thatcanbemis-leadingatafirstglance–isnecessarytounderstandthesignificanceofU-Th-Pbinsituagesinpolycyclicrocks.
127
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.10
Rapid transition to long-lived deep crustal magmatic maturation and the formation of giant porphyry-related mineralization (Yanacocha, Peru)
ChiaradiaMassimo*,MerinoDaniel*,SpikingsRichard*
*Département de Minéralogie, Rue des Maraîchers 13, 1205-Genève ([email protected])
Anexpandingamountofliteratureoverthepreviousdecadereportstheoccurrenceofmagmaticrockswithgeochemicalfeaturesofadakites(oradakite-like;i.e.,highSr/Y,lowYb)inassociationwithmajorporphyryCu-Auandporphyry-relatedepithermaldeposits,andatwofoldscientificdebatehasdevelopedaboutthisquestion:ononehandthegenesisofadakite-likerockiscontroversial;ontheotherthemeaningitselfoftheassociationofporphyry-typedepositswithadakite-likerocksisdebated.
Rockswithadakite-likefeaturesareconsideredtobetheresult,amongothers,ofslabmeltingandslabmelt-mantlewedgeinteractions(e.g.,DefantandDrummond,1990),ofmaficlowercrustalmelting(e.g.,AthertonandPetford,1993),orofhigh-pressurefractionalcrystallizationaccompaniedornotbytheassimilationandmeltingoflowercrust(e.g.,Chiaradiaetal.,2009).Discriminationbetweentheseprocessesisnotstraightforward,whichhasledtocontroversyontheoriginofrockswithadakite-likesignaturesinmanyPhanerozoicarcsystems.Thedebatedoriginoftheserockshaspropagatedintocon-trastingmodelsexplainingthemechanismsoftheassociationbetweenadakite-likerocksandporphyry-typedepositsinva-riousPhanerozoicarcenvironmentsandpost-collisionalzones(e.g.,reviewofRichardsandKerrich,2007).Anyhypothesisaccountingfortherelationshipsbetweenadakite-likerocksandporphyry-typedepositsshouldbebasedonathoroughpe-trogeneticstudythatistightlycoupledwiththetemporalevolutionofmagmaticrocksandtheirrelationshipswithmine-ralization.
Herewereportgeochronologic,geochemicalandisotopicdatafromadakite-likeporphyriticrocksassociatedwiththegianthigh-sulfidationsystemofYanacocha,northernPeru,whichistheworld’slargestgolddepositofthistype.Mineralizationisassociatedwithporphyriticintrusionsdistributedalonga~8kmlongNE-trendingmagmaticstructuralcorridor.Eightofthese intrusions investigated in this study range in age from12.4 to 8.4Ma and show systematic chemical and isotopicchangesthroughtime.Inparticular,rocksbecomesystematicallymorefelsic(andesitetorhyodacite),adakite-likeandisoto-picallycrust-contaminatedthroughtime,witharapidtransitionfromnonadakitictostronglyadakite-likesignaturesoccur-ringatabout12Maandwithinatimeintervalof<0.5Ma.
Basedonpetrography,mineralandrockchemistryandisotopiccompositionstheYanacochaintrusivemagmasareinterpre-tedtobetheresultofrechargeassimilationfractionalcrystallization(RAFC)processesoccurringatdifferentcrustallevels,involvingamphibole-clinopyroxene-garnetfractionationatdeeperlevels,leadingtomoreorlessstrongadakite-likesigna-tures,andplagioclase-amphibole fractionationat shallower levels.Systematicgeochemicaland isotopicchanges throughtime,coupledwithplagioclasezoningandamphibolegeobarometrysuggestthattheevolutionofthemagmaticsystemoc-curred through interactionofandesiticmeltswithan increasing lengthof thecrustalcolumnandshiftedprogressivelythroughtimetowardsshallowercrustallevelsasindicatedbyadecreaseinadakiticindicesbetween11-8.4Ma(althoughtherocks remained strongly adakite-like throughout) and by overall decreasingminimal pressures of amphibole crystalliza-tion.
ThisevolutionwaspossiblytheresultofasteadilyincreasingcompressionassociatedwiththeQuechuaIIorogenicphase(12-10Ma) that, byprogressively slowingdownmagmaascent, forcedmagmas to evolve at a series of intermediate levelchambersbetweentheloweranduppercrust.IncreasedcompressionduringtheQuechuaIIorogenicphasemighthavebeenrelatedtotheonsetofsubductionofthebuoyantIncaoceanicplateau,estimatedtooccurat~12Ma(Gutscheretal.,1999),i.e.,thesametimeoftheonsetoftherapidtransitionfrom“normal”toadakite-likesignatures.
ThegiantYanacochaoresystemdevelopedincoincidencewiththeensuing~3.6My-longintrusionofadakite-likemagmasformedbytheaboveprocessesintoasmalluppercrustalvolume(correspondingtoasurfaceareaof~5km*5km).Thissug-geststhatlarge-scalegeodynamicprocessesleadingtoprolongedmagmaticevolutionatdeepcrustallevelsmightbeafirst-ordercontrolontheformationofgiantporphyry-typesystems,asisalsoindicatedbysimilarmagmaticevolutionsinotherporphyry-systemsworldwide.Howthisoccursindetail(e.g.,generationofvolatile-andmetal-richoxidizedmagmasthroughhigh-pressurefractionation,recyclingofsulfide-richcumulatesinthelowercrust,focussedandlong-livedmagmaticinputintoasmalluppercrustalvolume)requiresadditionalinvestigation.
128Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y REFERENCESAtherton,M.P.,&Petford,N.1993:Generationofsodium-richmagmasfromnewlyunderplatedbasalticcrust.Nature,362,
144-146.Chiaradia,M.,Müntener,O., Beate, B.,& Fontignie,D. 2009:Adakite-like volcanismof Ecuador: lower crustmagmatic
evolutionandrecycling.ContributionstoMineralogyandPetrology,inpress,DOI10.1007/s00410-009-0397-2.Defant,M.J.,&Drummond,M.S.1990:Derivationofsomemodernarcmagmasbymeltingofyoungsubductedlithosphere.
Nature,347,662-665.Gutscher,M.-A.,Olivet, J.-L.,Aslanian,D.,Maury,R.,&Eissen, J.-P. 1999:The "lost IncaPlateau":Causeof flat subduction
beneathPeru?.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,171,335-341.Richards,J.P.,&Kerrich,R.2007:Adakite-likerocks:theirdiverseoriginsandquestionableroleinmetallogenesis.Economic
Geology,102,537-576.
3.11
Complex evolution of a highly explosive basaltic-andesite eruption of Villarrica volcano, Chile: the Chaimilla deposit
CostantiniLicia*,PioliLaura*,LongchampCeline**,BonadonnaCostanza*&ClaveroJorge***
*Départment de Minéralogie, Rue de Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève ([email protected])**Institute of Geomatics and Risk Analysis, Amphipôle - CH-1015 Lausanne***Servicio Nacional de Geologia y Mineria (Sernageomin), Chile
Villarricaisa2847-m-highbasaltic-andesiticstratovolcanolocatedinthesouthernChileanAndes.ItisoneofthemostactivevolcanoesinSouthAmericaandithasbeenactivefor600kaproducingabout60eruptionsinthelast450years.Althoughitshistoricaleruptiveactivityhasbeenmainlyeffusiveandweaklyexplosive,withmorethan30knowneruptionsin the last century,Villarricavolcanoalsohad largepostglacialexplosivebehaviour,whichproducedpyroclasticdensitycurrentsandtephrafalloutfromboththecentralventandflankparasiticpyroclasticcones(ClaveroandMoreno2004).Thetwoknownlargest-volumeeruptionsare theLicánandPucón ignimbrites (13.8and3.6karespectively),whichproducedwidespreadpyroclasticdensitycurrentsandarelikelyassociatedtocalderaformation.Thebest-preservedandwidelydisper-sedpyroclasticfalloutistheChaimilladeposit,whichwaseruptedafterthecaldera-formingPucónignimbrite(~3.1ka).Afterthelastlargeeruption(1984-85),theVillarricaactivityhasbeencharacterizedbycontinuousdegassingandsporadicbubblebursts(Witteretal.,2004;Guriolietal.,2008).
We present the stratigraphy of Chaimilla deposit combinedwith the grain size, componentry, density, vesicularity andgroundmasstexturesofjuvenileproductsfromselectedfalloutbeds.Thesedataareusedtoestimatetheeruptedvolumeandtoconstraintheeruptiondynamicsandevolutionwithtimeofthisuncommon,buthighlydangerous,typeofactivityofVillarricavolcano.
Basedon lithologicaland textural features,wedivided theChaimilladeposit into4maineruptionphases:Basal, Lower,MiddleandUpperphases,whichconsistofseveralunits(unitsA-J).Bothfalloutandpyroclasticdensitycurrentunitsarepresent.Thedispersalmapsofdifferenteruptiveunitsarecharacterizedbyaweakvariationonthedispersalaxis(beingtheunitCdispersedmainlynorthwardandtheunitHnorth-westward),suggestingachangeinwinddirectionduringtheerup-tion.WeestimatedtheeruptedvolumeofthemainfalloutunitsandourresultsindicatethatChaimilladepositwasgeneratedbyalarge-magnitudeeruption(VEI4).GrainsizedistributionofbothLowerandUpperfalloutsamplesshowaunimodaldistribution,rangingfrom-5Єto9Є,withthefraction>4Є(<63µm)always≤1wt%.UnitF(Middlephase)hasaslightlybimodalgrainsizedistributionandsignificantamountoffineash.SamplesfromtheBasalphasehaveinsteadastronglybimodalgrainsizedistribution,withapredomi-nanceof ash fraction. Juvenile componentpredominates inall theChaimilladeposit, and lithic contentdecreases frombottomtotopofthedeposit,suggestingthatthebeginningoftheeruptionwascharacterizedbytheopeningofaclosedvent.
WhilethegrainsizedistributionofLowerandUpperphaseofChaimillaeruptionisalwaysunimodal,densitydistributionofjuvenilesamplesshowsastrongbimodalcharacter,whosebimodalityishigherintheLowerphasewithrespecttotheUpperphase.Weidentifiedtwodifferentclastpopulations:population1isthelightestone,havingmodebetween1.0and1.2gr/cm3.Population2representsthedensestclastswithamoderangingbetween1.4and1.8gr/cm3.Clastmicrotextures
129
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryaredifferentinthetwopopulations:clastsfrompopulation1havespherical-toirregular-shapedbubblesandmoderately
crystallizedgroundmass(~40vol%),whilepopulation2hasclastscharacterizedbystronglyirregulartocollapsedbubblesandhighlycrystallizedgroundmass(~60vol%).
Oureruptionmodelimpliesthearrivalofnewmagma(representedbyclastpopulation1)intoastagnant,degassedmagmabodywhichwasaccumulatedatshallowlevel(clastpopulation2).Thenewmagmabodyexsolvedvolatilesthatcouldnoteasilyescapethroughtheconduitduetopresenceofstagnantbody.Thiscausedgaspressuretobuildup,triggeringtheexplosiveeruption.Theeruptionstartedwithmultipleash-richexplosionsleadingtoventopening(Basalphase).Thefollow-ingLowerphasemarkedtheonsetofthefirsthighlyexplosivephaseoftheeruption,withfinalventopeningandcraterwidening,asmarkedbydecreasinglithiccontentfrombottomtotopofthedeposit.TheLowerphasedepositwasgeneratedbyapulsating,plumecolumn,whichinstabilitywasprobablyduetothelargeamountofthedenseclastpopulation2.TheplumecolumncollapsedcompletelyduringtheMiddlephase,whichisinfactcharacterisedbyseriesofpyroclasticdensitycurrentdeposits.WiththeoncomingoftheUpperphase,theplumecolumnbuiltupagainandremainedsustainedprodu-cingathickfalloutbedpredominantlyconstituedoflow-densityclastpopulation1.Theeruptionendedwiththickseriespyroclasticdensitycurrentswhichmarkedthetotalcollapseoftheeruptivecolumn.
REFERENCESClavero,J.&Moreno,H.2004.EvolutionofVillaricaVolcano,inVillaricaVolcano(39.5˚S),southernAndes,Chile.In:LaraLE,
Clavero JE (eds)VillarricaVolcano (39.5S) southernAndes,Chile.GobiernodeChile, ServicioNacionaldeGeología yMinería,pp17-27
Gurioli L,HarrisAJL,HoughtonBF, PolacciM,RipepeM (2008) Textural andgeophysical characterizationof explosivebasalticactivityatVillarricavolcano.JournalofGeophysicalResearch113:doi:10.1029/2007JB005328
WitterJB,KressVC,DelmelleP,StixJ(2004)Volatiledegassing,petrology,andmagmadynamicsoftheVillarricalavalake,southernChile.JournalofVolcanologyandGeothermalResearch,134,303-337
3.12
Pumice, a window into the volcanic conduit
DegruyterWim*,DufekJosef**,BachmannOlivier***,*
*Section des Sciences de la Terre et de l’Environnement, 13 Rue des Maraîchers, CH-1205, Genève ([email protected])**School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences, 311 Ferst Drive, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332 (USA)*** Department of Earth and Space Sciences, Mailstop 351310, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195-1310 (USA)
Tobetterunderstandpumicemicrotexturesandstressdistributionwithinthevolcanicconduit,anumericalstudyisper-formedusingpassivetracerstomapthetypeandamountofshearindifferentpartsoftheconduit.Duringanexplosiveeruptionpumicesare formedby fragmenting therisingmagmatic foam (i.e.highlyvesicularmagma).Provided theyarequenchedfastenough,pumicesreflectthestateofthemagmajustpriortofragmentationandtheirmicrotexturescarryinformationonthestressesappliedduringmagmaascent.Numerousdepositscontainbothtubepumice,withhighlyelon-gated vesicles and frothy pumice, with nearly spherical vesicles showing evidence that they were exposed to differentstressesduringmagmaascent (e.g.KosPlateauTuffandCampanianIgnimbrite).Themainaimofthis investigationistodeterminethestrainhistoriesofmagmaticparcelsthateventuallybecomepumice
WehavemodifiedtheMultiphaseFlowwithInterphaseExchanges(MFIX)codetosimulateatwo-phase(bubblesandmagma),two-dimensional, isothermalflowwithdisequilibriumbubblegrowth.Weincludearheologymodeldependingonwatercontentwithoutletexpansionintotheatmosphere.Furthermore,differentfragmentationcriteria(i.e.criticalgasvolumefraction,strainrateandgasoverpressure)areexamined.Strainhistoriesareinvestigatedbyreleasingpassivetracerswithinsimulatedmagmarise,whichrecordthepureandsimpleshearstrainratesduringascent.Therangeofaccumulatedstress-esatfragmentationshownbythepassivetracerscanthenbelinkedtotherangeofdifferentmicrotexturesfoundwithinpumices.
130Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.13
Hornblende fractionation and peraluminous tonalite: an example of the Chelan Complex, Washington Cascades, USA
DessimozMathias*,OthmarMüntener*
* Institut de minéralogie et géochimie, Université de Lausanne, 1015 Dorigny ([email protected])
OverthelastyearsnumerousexperimentalstudiesontheroleofH2Owereperformedtounderstandhowcrustaldifferen-
tiationoccursathighpressureunderwater (under)saturatedconditionssimilartowhatisexpectedinislandarcs.Theseexperimentsemphasizetheroleofsilicapoorphasessuchasgarnetandamphiboleathighpressureonthedifferentiationofbasalticmelt.HerewepresentresultsfromastudyontheChelanComplex(WesternU.S)toevaluatetheroleofhorn-blendeintheformationoffelsicplutonicrocks.TheChelancomplexisadeepplutoniccomplexexposedintheNorthCascadesCoreatthesouthernendofthenorthwesttrendingChelanblock.Itrepresentsoneofthedeeperexposures(30km)oftheCascadianarcandcouldthereforehelptoimproveourunderstandingofwhichprocessesoccurinthedeeppartofacontinentalarcandthefractionationprocessesofwetmaficmagmasathighpressure.
TheChelanComplexiscomposedbytonalite,gabbros,ultramaficrocksand“migmatite”.Fieldobservations,inparticularcomblayers,pegmatiticgabbrosandigneousbrecciasindicatethatthemagmaticoriginiswellpreservedalongtheentirecomplex.Whilesubsolidusdeformationoccurslocally,mostoftherocksaredeformedinpresenceofasilicatemelt,asin-dicatedbyapervasivemagmaticfoliationwelldevelopedinthetonaliteaswellassomeshearzonesfilledwithsillicicmeltandfewmagmaticfolds.
Thepressureofemplacementofthecomplexisbracketedbetween0.6Gpaand1.5Gpabythewidespreadoccurrenceofprimaryepidoteintonaliteandgabbrosandbytheabsenceofgarnet.However,theformationofpyroxenespinelsymplec-titesafterolivineandplagioclaseandAl-Tisystematicsinhornblendeindicateemplacementpressuresofabout1.0Gpafol-lowedbyisobariccoolingto700°Cat1.0Gpa.
Idiomorphicamphiboleandinterstitialplagioclaseingabbros,lackofnegativeEuanomalyinamphiboleandincreaseofZr/Tisuggestearlyamphiboleratherthanplagioclasefractionation.
Wholerockchemistryperformedonhornblendite,hornblendegabbros,diorite,tonaliteandmaficdykesdisplaycontinuoustrendsforvariousoxidesandarecoherentwithanevolutionthroughmagmaticprocesses.Thedifferentbehaviourofmajorelementscouldbereproducedsuccessfullybyasimplecrystalfractionationmodel,inagreementwithproportionandcom-positionofcumulatesobservedinthefield(ultramafic,hornblenditeandgabbros)andmineralcompositionmeasured.
Texturalobservations,modellingandresultsofhighpressureexperimentsindicatethathornblendeisthemainphasecon-trollingthedifferentiationoftheChelancomplexathighpressureandhighwaterpressure.Wehypothesizethatperalumi-noustonalitewithhighSr/Ycouldbederivedfromabasalticmeltbyhornblendefractionationandassimilationofcrustalmaterialisthusnotrequired.
3.14
Peridotites on Macquarie Island: evidence for anciently-depleted domains in the Earth's mantle pointing to global Proterozoic melting 'events'?
Dijkstra,ArjanH.*
*Institut de Géologie, d'Hydrogéologie et de Géothermie, Université de Neuchâtel, CP 158, 2009, Neuchâtel
Macquarie Island intheSouthernOcean isa fragmentofMioceneoceancrustunderlainbymantleperidotites thatwasupliftedandexposedabovesea-level.Petrologicalandgeochemicalanalysishasshownthatthemantlerocksaretoorefrac-torytobethesourceresidueoftheoverlyingcrustalrocks.Forinstance,theperidotitescontainessentiallynoresidualcli-nopyroxene,suggestingveryhighdegreesofpartialmeltingandmeltextraction.Meltingmodelsinvolvingtraceelementssuggestthattheperidotiteshaveseeninexcessof20%near-fractionalmelting.
131
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryOsmiumisotopeanalysisofwholerocksamplesofperidotitesfromMacquarieIslandyieldedveryunradiogenic187Os/188Os
ratiosof0.1194-0.1229.Thesevaluesaremuchlowerthantypicalvaluesobtainedonabyssalperidotites.Theyindicatealong-livedRe-depletion.Re-depletionmodelagesareProterozoic(0.7-1.2Ga).TheseresultsconfirmthatthereisnosimplegeneticlinkbetweentheMiocenecrustandthemantlerocksexposedonMacquarieIsland,butthatthemantlerocksareafragmentofmantlethathasrecordedanoldmeltingevent,withoutanysubsequentrefertilization.
Ultra-refractoryperidotitesarealsoknownfromthe15-20°FractureZone(Mid-AtlanticRidge)andtheIzu-Bonin-Marianafore-arc,andtheyarefoundasxenolithsfrombeneathKerguelenIslandandHawaii.Inallthesecases,theultra-refractoryperidotitesalsogaveoldRe-depletionages.TheMacquarieIslandperidotitesareprobablysamplesofananciently-depleted,ultra-refractorymantlereservoirthathasglobalsignificance,butthathasgenerallybeenoverlookedsofarbecauseofitssterility,i.e.,itsinabilitytofurtherproducebasalt.
Themosttentativeaspectofthe,admittedlyverylimited,data-setofOsisotoperatiosofultra-refractoryperidotitesfromthelocalitieslistedaboveisthattheyseemtopointtotwoglobalmeltingeventsintheProterozoic,around0.8and1.2Ga(basedonRe-depletionages).Thepossiblegeologicalsignificanceoftheseeventswillbeexploredinmycontribution.
REFERENCESDijkstra,A.H.,Sergeev,D.S.,Spandler,C.A.,Pettke,T.,Meisel,T.,andCawood,P.A.Ultra-refractoryperidotitesonMacquarie
Island and the case for anciently-depleteddomains in the Earth'smantle. Accepted for publication in Journal ofPetrology,2009.
3.15
Sphalerite mineralisation in Bajocian shallow-water carbonates in the Swiss Jura Mountains related to extensional synsedimentary tectonics during the Middle-Late Jurassic.
NataliaEfimenko*,JorgeE.Spangenberg**,JensSchneider***,MassimoChiaradia****,ThierryAdatte*,VirginieMatera*****andKarlB.Föllmi*
*Institut de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland ([email protected])**Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Université de Lausanne, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland***Départment of Earth and Environmental Sciences, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Celestijnenlaan 200E, 3001 Heverlee, Belgium****Département de Minéralogie, Université de Genève, 1205 Genève, Switzerland*****Institut de Géologie et d’Hydrogéologie, Université de Neuchâtel, 2007 Neuchâtel, Switzerland
DisseminatedsphaleritemineralisationoccursinTriassicandJurassiccarbonatesintheSwissJuraMountains(e.g.Holenweg,1969;Hofmann,1989).Wereportnewresultsfromanongoingstudyoncadmium-rich(upto1.8wt.%)sphalerite(ZnS)foundinoolithiccarbonatesofBajocianageatLausen,AuensteinandPratteln(CantonBaselLand).Theseoolithiccarbonatesofthe“Hauptrogenstein”formationcontainelevatedconcentrationsofCd(upto21.4ppm;Rambeau,2006)andZn(upto207ppm;Jacquatetal.,2009).Weaimtounderstandhowthesemetalswereincorporatedintotherockandtheconditionsofsphalerite formation by using thin-sectionmicroscopy, XRD, ICP-MS, LA-ICPMS, EMP, cathodoluminescence, sulphur iso-topes,andRb-Sr/Pb-Pbisotopicdatingandtracing.CdandZnenrichmentsaremostlyassociatedwithpermeableoolithiccarbonatelithologies.HighconcentrationsofCdandZninlesspermeablerocks(marls,micriticcarbonates)appeartobefault-controlled.Forexample,inmarlybasinaldepositsoftheKlingnauFormation(coevalinagetotheHauptrogensteinformation)atHolderbank,Cdconcentrationsarelowat0,03ppmbutattainupto0.5ppmnearfaults.Likewise,Znincreasesfrom20to300ppmtowardsthesefaults.ThisCdandZnzonationsuggeststhatthecirculatingfluidswererichinCdandZncomparedtotheprimaryhostrock,andmainlyfo-cussedbyfaultssystemsorbypermeablerockunits.ThedistributionofZnandCdconcentrationsintheoolithiccarbonaterocksishighlyheterogeneous.Thisappearstoberelatedtoporositydifferences,andprobablytodifferenceinthedistributionofZn-andCd-bearingphaseswithintherock.Zincwasshowntobeassociatedwithcalcite,goethiteandsphalerite(Jacquatetal.,2009).Cadmiumismostlikelyadsorbedonto the surfaceofoolithic carbonategrains (Rambeau,2006), goethite, clayminerals, pyrite, andwithin the sphaleritecrystals.ThepreferentialcorrelationofCdwithZn incarbonaterockmayberelatedto thehighconcentrationofCd insphalerite.Nevertheless,CdconcentrationdoesnotsystematicallycorrelatewithZn.Thismaybeexplainedbythedifferentbehaviourof these twometalsduringtheir retentionontomineralphases (goethite,clayminerals,pyrite,carbonate).At
132Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y Lausen,Cdconcentrationdecreasesfrom12to0.03ppmandZnfrom2000ppmto12ppmwithinfewcentimetresfromreducedgreyportionstomorealteredyellowishpartsoftherock.Spaleritemicrocrystalsandframboidalpyritewereob-servedingreyunalteredparts.Nosphaleritewasobservedinthealteredrockportions,wherepyritewasoxidized.ThissuggeststhatCdandZnwereremobilisedduringtheweatheringprocesses.XRDanalysesofsphaleritecrystalsrevealedthepresenceofbothsphaleriteandwurtzite.TheexistenceofwurtziteindicatesbacterialactivityinvolvedinZnScrystallisationatlowtemperatures(lessthan60-80°).Thenegativeδ34Svaluesofsphalerites(–22.3to–5.3‰)pointtobacterialsulfatereduction(BSR)asthemainsourceofreducedsulfur.Acontributionofsulfidefromsedimentarypyritecannotbeexcluded.DirectRb-SrdatingofselectedsphaleritesamplesfromAuensteinyieldsanupperMiddleJurassic(Bathonian)isochronageof162±4Mawhichis interpretedtorecordsphaleriteformationduringaperiodofwidespreadtectonothermalactivityrelatedtotheopeningoftheNorthAtlanticandTethyanoceans.Thesesyn-sedimentarytectonicsalsoinfluencedthepale-otopography and facies distribution, which were spatially related to reactivated Paleozoic faults (e.g. Allenbach, 2001).Therefore,we propose amodel of cadmiumand zinc enrichment in the carbonate rocks by deep-sourced fluids duringmultistagetectonicprocessesintheregionrelatedtoanextensionalregimeduringtheJurassic.ThePbisotopiccompositionof sphalerite isveryuniform, indicatingan isotopicallywell-homogenized fluidsystem.ComparativePb isotopepatternsmaypointtoleadsourceslocatedingraniticandmetamorphicbasementrocksexposedinthesouthernBlackForestfarthernorth.Leadmayhavescavenged,mixedandhomogenizedfromPb-isotopicallydistinctcrystallinebasementrocktypesbyfluids during the Bathonian to yield a Pb isotope signature compatiblewith carbonated-hosted sphalerite in the SwissJura.Sphaleriteprecipitationmayberelatedtotheactivebacterialsulphatereduction.ThezonationofCdandZnincarbonaterocksseemstobecontrolledbythedistributionoffaciesandtheexistenceoffaults.DuringtheTertiary,tectonicactivityinJuraMountainsareamayhavetriggeredoxidativealterationofsulfides,formationofironoxy-hydroxides,andremobilisa-tionofCdandZn.
REFERENCESAllenbachR.P. 2001: Synsedimentary tectonics inanepicontinental sea: anew interpretationof theOxfordianbasinof
northernSwitzerland.EclogaeGeologicaeHelvetiae,94,265-287.Hofmann B. 1989: Erzmineralien in paläozoischen,mesozoischen und tertären Sedimenten derNordschweiz und
Südwestdeutschlands.Schweiz.MineralogischeundPetrographischeMitteilungen,69,345-357.HolenwegH.1969:MineralparagenesenimSchweizerJura.SchweizerStrahler,3,303-308.JacquatO., VoegelinA., Juillot F.&KretzschmarR. 2009:Chages inZn speciationduring soil formation fromZn-rich
limestones.GeochimicaetCosmochimicaActa,73,5554-5571.RambeauC.2006:Cadmiumanomaliesinjurassiccarbonates(Bajocian,Oxfordian)inwesternandsouthernEurope.PhD
thesis,UniversityofNeuchâtel,179p.(unpubl.).
3.16
Modeling the evolution of geothermal reservoirs in deep fractured rocks: Coupling chemistry to heat and fluid transport
HingerlFerdinandF.*,**,WagnerThomas**,KulikDmitriiA.*,KosakowskiGeorg*,DriesnerThomas**,ThomsenKaj***&HeinrichChristophA.**
*Paul Scherrer Institut, 5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland, ([email protected])**Institute of Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, ETH Zurich, Switzerland***Technical University of Denmark, 2800 Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
AconsortiumofresearchgroupsfromETHZurich,thePaulScherrerInstitut,EPFLausanne,andtheUniversityofBonn,cooperateintheCCESprogramGEOTHERM(www.geotherm.ethz.ch)aimedatperformingbasicresearchonkeyaspectsofEnhancedGeothermalSystems (EGSs).Our taskwithin theprogramconsistsofmodeling the fluid–rock interactionandscaleformationduringgeothermalheatextraction.Inparticular,wearedevelopingadvancedsoftwarethatshouldrealisti-callysimulatethelongterm(yearstodecades)evolutionofthepermeabilityandheatexchangeefficiencyinanEGSreser-voir.
Oursimulationsareanchoredontheoreticalinvestigationsoftheinterplayofchemicalprocesses(mineraldissolutionandprecipitationinrockfracturesandtechnicalinstallations)withtheflowofthereactivefluidthroughageometricallycom-plexandchangingfracturenetwork.Modelingofthisintegrativescenarioisperformedbycouplingachemicalequilibrium
133
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
trysolverwithalgorithmsthatsimulatethemassandheattransportandgeometricalphenomena.Thechemicalsolversare
commonlybasedonaLaw-of-Mass-Action(LMA)method,whereasinourwork,thecomplementaryGibbs-Energy-Minimization(GEM)codepackageGEM-Selektor (http://gems.web.psi.ch) isused.GEMchemicalsolverscancomputephasespeciationinmorechemicallyplausiblesystemsthanitcanbedoneusingLMAsolvers,especiallywhenmanyhighlynon-idealsolutionsareinvolved.TheEGSreservoirischaracterizedbyvariable(uptohigh)salinityandelevatedtemperatureandpressure,whichisachal-lengeonthecalculationofaqueousspeciation.Forthisreason,inadditiontoseveralvariantsofDebye-Huckelequation,wehaveimplementedthePitzer(Harvieetal.1984)andtheEUNIQUAC(Thomsen&Rasmussen1999)aqueousactivitymodel,both applicable to mixed electrolyte systems at high ionic strength. Compared with the conventional Pitzer model,EUNIQUACrequiresfewerempiricalfitparameters(onlybinaryinteractionparametersneeded)andusessimplerandmorestabletemperatureandpressureextrapolations.Thisresultsinanincreaseincomputationspeed,whichisofcrucialimpor-tancewhenperformingcoupledlongtermsimulationsofgeothermalreservoirs.
Inordertosuccessfullyapplytheimplementedelectrolytesolutionmodels,wearecurrentlycompilingathermodynamicdatabaseandextenditwithrelevantPitzerandEUNIQUACparametersforcalculatingmineralsolubilityinawiderangeoftemperatures,pressuresandionicstrengthasapplicabletogeothermalfluids.WehavealsoimplementedtheSoave-Redlich-Kwong(Soave1972)andPeng-Robinson(PengandRobinson1976)equationsofstatefornon-idealgasmixtures,whichwillenablesimultaneouscalculationsofgassolubilityandboilingprocesses.
ThestandaloneGEMnumericalkerneloftheGEM-Selektorcode(abbreviatedGEMIPM2K)wasalreadysuccessfullycoupledto theThermo-Hydro-Mechanical (THM)codeGeoSys/Rockflow (Shaoetal.2009).FurthercouplingwiththeadvancedTHcodeCSMP++ (Coumou2008;http://csmp.ese.imperial.ac.uk/wiki/Home) is foreseenwithin theproject. Thenovel coupledcodesutilizingGEMIPM2Kwillbeusedwithinabenchmarkingstudy,testingtheefficiency,thenumericalstability,andthesensitivityoftheresultstodifferentnumericalproceduresandgeochemicalapproaches,lastbutnotnotleasttotheimpactofthechoiceofathermodynamicdataset.Astheconcludingstep,weintendtoconstructaconceptualmodelforthegeo-chemicalwater-rockinteractionprocessesincludingtheformationofmineralscalesandthecorrosionofpipesinwellsattheBaselEGSssite.
REFERENCESBruno J., BosbachD.,KulikD.,NavrotskyA. 2007:Chemical thermodynamicsof solid solutionsof interest in radioactive
wastemanagement:Astate-of-theartreport,ChemicalThermodynamicsSeries,10,Paris,OECD,266p.Coumou,D. , Matthäi, S., Geiger , S., and Driesner, T. 2008.Computers&Geoscience,Volume34,Issue12,pp1697-1707Harvie,E.H.,Moller,N.,Weare,J.H.1984.Thepredictionofmineralsolubilitiesinnaturalwaters:TheNa-K-Mg-Ca-H-Cl-SO
4-
OH-HCO3-CO
3-CO
2-H2Osystemtohighionicstrengthsat25°C.Geochim.Cosmochim.ActaVol.48,pp.723-751.
Karpov,I.K.,Chudnenko,K.V.,Kulik,D.A.1997.Modelingchemicalmasstransferingeochemicalprocesses:thermodynamicrelations,conditionsofequilibria,andnumericalalgorithms.AmericanJournalofScience297:767-806.
Karpov I.K.,Chudnenko,K.V.,Kulik,D.A.,Avchenko,O.V., andBychinski,V.A. 2001.MinimizationofGibbs freeenergy ingeochemicalsystemsbyconvexprogramming.GeochemistryInternational39,no.11:1108-1119.
Kulik,D., Berner,U., andCurti, E. 2004.Modelling chemical equilibriumpartitioningwith theGEMS-PSI code. In: PSIScientificReport2003 /Volume IV,NuclearEnergyandSafety (Eds.B.SmithandB.Gschwend), PaulScherrer Institut,Villigen,p.109-122.
KulikD.A. 2006a.Classic adsorption isotherms incorporated inmodern surface complexationmodels: Implications forsorptionofactinides.RadiochimicaActa94,no.9-11:765-778.
Peng,D.Y.,Robinson,D.N.(1976)Anewtwo-constantequationofstate.INd.Eng.Chem.Fundam.,15,59-64.Soave,G.(1972)EquilibriumconstantsfromamodifiedRedlich-Kwongequationofstate.Chem.Eng.Sci.27,1197-1203.Shao,H.,Dmytrieva,S.V.,Kolditz,O.,Kulik,D.A.,Pfingsten,W.,Kosakowski,G.2009.Modelingreactivetransportinnon-
idealaqueous-solidsolutionsystem.AppliedGeochemistry24,1287-1300.Thomsen,K.,Rasmussen,P. 1999.ModelingofVapor-Liquid-SolidEquilibria inGas–AqueousElectrolyte Systems.Chem.
Eng.Sci.,54,1787-1802.
134Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.17
The mafic – granitic connection of the Torres del Paine laccolith, Patagonia
J.Leuthold1,O.Müntener1,L.Baumgartner1,B.Putlitz1,M.Ovtcharova2,UrsSchaltegger2,MassimoChiaradia2
1 IMG-UNIL, CH-1015 Lausanne, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Mineralogy – UNIGE, CH-1205 Geneva, Switzerland
Wehaveconductedafield,petrologicalandgeochronologicalstudyofabimodalintrusivecomplexfromtheTorresdelPainelaccolith,Patagonia,Chile.Thegoalofthisstudyistounderstandhowvarioustypesofmaficrocksevolveatshallowpres-sureandhowtheyarerelatedinspaceandtimetothevariousgraniticsheets.Fromfieldrelationsitisevidentthatthegraniteintrudedasaseriesofsheets,withtheoldestpulseontopandtheyoungestatthebaseofthelaccolith.Highpreci-sionU-Pbdatingonsinglezircons(Micheletal.Geology2008)isinagreementwithfieldrelationsandyielded12.59±0.02fortheoldestand12.51±0.03fortheyoungestgranitedated.Thegranitesareunderlainbyaseriesofmaficsillscomposedofhornblende-gabbrosanddiorites.Wedistinguishtwotypesofhornblendegabbrosthatarechemicallysimilarbutclearlydifferentwithrespecttotheirmineralcrystallizationsequen-ce.However,thecontactsbetweenthedifferentmaficrocksareductileasillustratedbymaficenclavesindioriteorascentofsmalldioritediapirs intooverlayinghornblendegabbros, indicating (near-) simultaneousemplacementofmostof themaficrocks.Bulkrockchemistrysuggeststhatthemaficandgraniticrocksfollowahigh–Kcalcalkalinetoshoshoniticdifferentiationtrend.LiquidcompositionscalculatedfromLaserAblationICP-MStraceelementanalysisofcumulatemineralsindicatethatthemaficrockscrystallizedfromaK-richbasaltictoshoshoniticmagma.Intercumulusmineralsshowequilibriumwithagranodioritictograniticmelt,thatissimilartoPainegranites.Preliminaryisotopedilution–thermalionizationmassspec-trometryonzirconsfromonegabbroandonedioriteyielded12.40±0.04and12.447±0.013Ma,whichisabout60'000yearsyoungerthantheyoungestgranitedatedsofar.Thiswouldsuggestthatalargevolumeofthelaccolithgrowsdownwards,withyoungerandmoremaficsheetsatthebottomofthecomplex.Theyoungestgranitesthatcuttheentirecomplex,ho-wever,awaitprecisedating.
REFERENCESMicheletal.(2008),Geology36/6,459-462
3.18
Bromine speciation and partitioning in high pressure aqueous fluids and silicate melts: implication for the behavior of halogens in subduction zones
M.Louvel*,C.Sanchez-Valle*,W.J.Malfait*,G.S.Pokrovski**,C.N.Borca***,D.Grolimund***
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland. ([email protected])**CNRS, Laboratoire des Mecanismes et Transferts en Geologie, F-31400 Toulouse, France.***Swiss Light Source, CH-5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland.
AlthoughhalogensareminorvolatilesintheEarth’scrust,theyareimportanttracersofmagmaticanddegassingprocessesand provide insights about subsurface magmamovement and eruption likelihood in subduction-related volcanism [1].Additionally,theirabilitytocomplexwithotherelementshasalsoconsiderableimplicationsontheformationanddistribu-tionoforedeposits[2].Prerequisiteforanefficientuseofhalogensasgeologicaltracersisanadequateknowledgeoftheirsolubilityanddistributionbetweenaqueousfluidsandsilicatemelts,aswellastheirspeciationinsubductionzonefluids.Experimentaldataonthesolubilityandfluid-meltpartitioningbehaviorofhalogensishoweverlimitedtopressuresbelow0.3GPa[3,4]andvirtuallynodataisavailableontheirspeciationinhigh-pressurefluids.Inordertoinvestigatethebehaviorofhalogensinsub-arcenvironments,X-rayabsorption(XAFS)andX-rayfluorescence(XRF)spectroscopymeasurementswereconductedinahydrothermaldiamond-anvilcell(HDAC-[5])upto850°Cand1.5(1)GPainBromine-richfluidsequilibratedwithsilicatemelts.BrominewasusedasananalogforchlorinesuitableforX-rayfluore-
135
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryscencemeasurementsthroughthediamondwindowsoftheHDAC.ExperimentswereconductedattheX05-LAMicroXAS
beamlineoftheSwissLightSource(Switzerland).PressureinthesamplechamberwasmonitoredfromthePVTequationofstateofachipofgoldaddedtotheexperimentalvolume.Brfluid-meltpartitioncoefficientsinthehaplogranite-H
2Osystem
weredeterminedbyXRFspectroscopy.BrspeciationwasinvestigatedusingXAFSoverawiderangeofP-Tandbulkcomposi-tions, ranging frompureNaBraqueous solutions (3wt%Br) toalkali-SiO
2-rich solutions,water-saturatedNa
2Si
2O
5andha-
plogranititicmeltsandsupercriticalfluids(25wt%Na2Si
2O
5and10wt%haplogranite).
Thecombinedresultsoftheseexperimentsprovidevaluableinformationonthepartitioningbehaviorandstructuralenvi-ronmentofBrinhigh-pressurefluids.Brstronglypartitionsintotheaqueousfluidphase,inagreementwiththeresultsofBureauetal.[6]inquenchexperiments.PartitioncoefficientsDfluid/meltarecloseto25at650°C–1.0(1)GPabutdecreasewithincreasingP-T,asthesystemapproachesmiscibility.TheXAFSdatarevealchangesinthelocalstructurearoundBraschemi-calcomplexityincreasesinthesystemfromNaBrsolutionstoalkali-richSiO
2fluids,suggestingthecomplexationofBrwith
Na,SiandAl.TheimplicationsoftheseresultsforthebehaviorofBrandhalogensinsubductionzonefluidswillbedis-cussed.
REFERENCES[1]Aiuppaetal(2008),Chem.Geol.263,1-18.[2]Hedenquist&Lowenstern(1994),Nature370,519-527.[3]Webster(1992),Geoch.
Cosmo.Act.56,679-687.[4]Bureau&Metrich(2003),Geoch.Cosmo.Act.67,1689-1697.[5]Bassettetal(1993),Rev.Sci.Inst.64,2340-2345.[6]Bureauetal(2000),Earth.Planet.Sci.Lett.183,51-60.
3.19
Compositional dependent compressibility of dissolved water in silicate glasses revealed by Brillouin scattering on haplogranitic and basaltic glasses
WimJ.Malfait*,CarmenSanchez-Valle*,PaolaArdia*,**&EtienneMédard***
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])**Dept. of Geology and Geophysics, University of Minnesota, MN 55455 Minneapolis, USA ***Laboratoire Magmas et Volcans, Université Blaise-Pascal-CNRS, OPGC, F-63038 Clermont-Ferrand
Thedensityofhydrousmagmasisakeycontrolonthetimescalesandoutcomeofmanyigneousprocesses,e.g.thecrystalsettlingvelocitiesinamagmachamberandtheemplacementdepthofintrusions.Unfortunately,directdensitymeasure-mentsonhydrousliquidsatmagmatictemperaturesandpressuresareexperimentallychallengingandasaresult,veryfewexperimentaldataareavailable.Atatmosphericpressureandroomtemperature,thepartialmolarvolumeofwaterinsili-categlassesandmeltsseemstobeindependentofthebulkcompositionoftheglass(RichetandPolian,1998).Encouragedbythisconstantpartialmolarvolumeatroomconditionsandbecauseofthelackofsufficientexperimentalconstraints,currentdensitymodelsforhydrousmagmaticliquids(e.g.OchsandLange,1999)assumethatthepartialmolarvolumeofthedissolvedwaterathightemperatureandpressureisalsoindependentofmeltcomposition.Thisassumption,however,hasneverbeenexperimentallyconfirmed.
Inordertoverifyifthepartialmolarvolumeofwaterremainsindependentofmagmacompositionatelevatedpressures,wehavedeterminedthesoundwavevelocitiesandbulkmodulus(K
S)ofaseriesofhydroushaplograniticandbasalticglasses,
quenchedatdifferentpressures,usingBrillouinspectroscopy.Thecompressionalwave(VP)andshearwavevelocities(V
S)sy-
stematicallydecreasewiththeadditionofwater.ThepartialmolarKSofwater,andhencethecompressibility,isdifferent
fordifferentmagmacompositions.This implies that thepartialmolarvolumeofwaterwillnotbe independentofmeltcompositionatelevatedpressure.TheseresultssuggestthatthedensitymodelofOchsandLange(1999)mayhavelimitedapplicabilityatelevatedpressure.Thedevelopmentofmorerobustdensitymodels forhydrousmagmatic liquidscannotproceeduntiladditionalinsitu,highpressureandtemperaturemeasurementsofmeltdensity,thermalexpansionand/orcompressibilityareavailable.
REFERENCESOchs,F.A.,andLange,R.A.(1999)Thedensityofhydrousmagmaticliquids.Science,283,1314.Richet,P.,andPolian,A.(1998)Waterasadenseicelikecomponentinsilicateglasses.Science,281,396-398.
136Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.20
PVTx properties of high pressure aqueous fluids by Brillouin scattering spectroscopy
MantegazziDavide*,Sanchez-ValleCarmen*,ReusserEric*,DriesnerThomas**
*Inst. for Mineralogy and Petrology, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich, ([email protected])** Inst. of Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich
AqueousfluidsplayaveryimportantroleinmanygeologicalprocessesintheEarth’scrustandmantle.Typicalexamplesoffluidmediatedgeologicaleventsare:themagmaproductioninthemantlewedgebeneathactivevolcanoesatsubductionzones,metamorphicreactionsinvolvingfluidphases,thehydrothermalalterationoftheseafloor,thetransportofchemicalcomponentsandtherelatedoredepositsformation.
StudiesonFluidInclusions(FI)havepointedoutthatfluidsintheternarysystemH2O–NaCl–CO
2canbeconsideredasgood
approximationfornaturalgeologicalfluids.
Inordertoquantitativelymodelfluid-rockinteractions,thermodynamicdataonmineralsandfluidsatgeologicallyrelevantP-Tconditionsarenecessary.Whilethesedataareavailableforthemostrock-formingminerals,thisisnotthecaseforaque-ousfluidsdifferentthanpureH
2O.Forexample,theequationsofstate(EoS)ofH
2O–NaClfluidsarerestrictedto0.5GPa.
Therefore,theinterpretationoffluidrelateddeepgeologicalprocessesrequirestheextrapolationofthermodynamicproper-tiesoveranorderinmagnitudeinpressure.Inaddition,theknowledgeofthethermodynamicpropertiesoffluidsintheternarysystemH
2O–NaCl–CO
2isessentialforunderstandingandmodelingtheFIdata.
InthiscontributionwepresentthePVTxpropertiesofdifferentaqueousfluidsuptohighP-Tconditions,calculatedfromsound velocitymeasurements using Brillouin scattering spectroscopy. All experimentswere conducted in an externallyheatedmembrane-typediamondanvilcell(mDAC).
Brillouinscatteringspectroscopyallowsthedirectmeasurementofthevelocityofacousticwavespropagatinginamaterial(fluidorsolid).ThecollectedsoundvelocitiesV
PareusedtodeterminetheEoSЄ(P,T,x)oftheanalyzedfluids.
TheresultsarecombinedwithpreviousexperimentalandtheoreticalEoStoobtainacontinuousmodelfromlowtohighP-Tconditions,providingadatabaseforthethermodynamicpropertiesofthemostrelevantaqueoussystemsinvolvedinfluid-mediatedgeologicalprocesses.Figure1showsthecomparisonbetweentheEoSЄ(P,T,x)ofdifferentH
2O–NaClmixtures.At2GPathesolutionwith5.5wt%
NaClis5.2%denserthanpurewater,whileat3GPathesolutionwith14.9wt%NaClis9.6%denserthanwater.Withincreas-ingpressurethedifferenceindensitybetweenwaterandchloride-richsolutionsisincreasing.
REFERENCESAbramson,E.,&Brown,M.J.2004:Equationofstateofwaterbasedonspeedsofsoundmeasuredinthediamond-anvilcell.
Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta68,1827-1835.Driesner,T.2007:ThesystemH2O-NaCl.PartII:Correlationsformolarvolume,enthalpy,andisobaricheatcapacityfrom0
to1000degreesC,1to5000bar,and0to1X-NaCl.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta71,4902-4919.Sanchez-Valle,C.,&Bass,J.D.2007:Equationofstateoffluidsfromsoundvelocitymeasurementsinthediamondanvilcell
usingBrillouinscatteringspectroscopy.Geochim.Cosmochim.Acta71,A873-A873.Wagner,W.,&Pruss,A.2002:TheIAPWSformulation1995forthethermodynamicpropertiesofordinarywatersubstance
forgeneralandscientificuse.J.Phys.Chem.Ref.Data31,387–535.
Figure1.EoSЄ(P,T,X)forH2O–NaClmixtureswithdifferentsaltconcentrationsasafunctionofpressurealongthe200°Cisotherm.All
theseEoShavebeendeterminedwiththesameexperimentaltechnique.Dataforthe14.9and5.5wt%NaClsolutionsarefromthiswork;
densitiesforthe0wt%NaClmixturearetakenfromSanchez-ValleandBass(2007).
137
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try
3.21
Evidence of Jurassic rifting in the Dent Blanche nappe (near Cignana, Italy)
PaolaManzotti*,DanieleRegis*,BenedicteCenki-Tok*,MartinRobyr*,TonnyB.Thomsen*,DanielaRubatto**,MicheleZucali***&MartinEngi*
*University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, 3012 CH-Bern ([email protected])**The Australian National University, Mills road, Canberra, ACT, 0200 Australia***Dipartimento di Scienze della Terra «Ardito Desio», Università degli Studi di Milano, via Mangiagalli 34, 20133 I-Milano
TheRoisanZoneisconsideredtobetheMesozoicmetasedimentarycoveroftheDentBlanchenappe(Austroalpinedomain,WesternItalianAlps;Diehletal.,1952).Itisdismemberedintometrictohectometricbandsandpodsofmarbles,dolomiticbrecciaswithaphylliticmatrix,calcschist,micaschist,chloriteschist,impureandmanganoanquartzites.
IntheRoisanZonewefoundtheAlpinerecordtobeheterogeneous;themetamorphicimprintindicateslowtemperatureandintermediatepressure,locallythisisassociatedwithsuperimposedmyloniticfoliations.Fourevolutionarystageshavebeenreconstructedbymeso-andmicrostructuralanalysis.Pre-stage1isapre-Alpineeventrecognisedonlyatthemicroscale.Duringstage1awelldifferentiatedmillimetricfoliationdevelops,whereasD2structuresconsistofisoclinicalfolds,trans-posingtheS1foliationintoanew,pervasiveS2.D3structuresmainlyconsistofisoclinalfolds:thisstageisnotalwaysas-sociatedwiththedevelopmentofanewfoliation.
WithintheRoisanZone,particularlynearCignana,weinvestigatedcross-cuttingrelationshipsbetweenmetamorphicanddeformationalsignatures.InMn-quartziteandmarblearelativetemporalsequencewasdeduced.Titaniteandallaniteweresingledout forU-Th-Pbdating.Allanite fromMn-quartzitesoccursas subhedralcrystalsanddisplays irregularzoning inLREE,Ca,Fe,andMg.SHRIMPandLA-ICP-MSanalysesdidnotyieldthemetamorphicAlpineageexpectedonthebasisofpetrographicandstructuralobservations.TheanalyzedgenerationofallanitegrainsshowsPermianages(between350and290Ma).
Titaniteinmarbleoccursasabundantsubhedraltoanhedralcrystals(mostlyfracturedand/ordeformed),locallysub-paralleltothefoliation.BSEimages,qualitativeX-rayelementalmaps,andEMPspotanalysisshowweakregulartoirregularzoninginAl,TiandCa.SHRIMPU-PbanalysisoftitanitedomainswithvariousAlcontentsyieldapparentspot206Pb/238Uagesscat-teringbetween284and160Ma.
138Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y TheyoungeragesoftitanitearetentativelyinterpretedasreflectinganextensionalregimethatprecededtheAlpinecolli-sion.FurtherworkisunderwaynowtoclarifywhetherzoningofLREE,Ca,FeandMginallaniteandvariationsofAl,TiandCaintitanitegrainsmaypartlyreflectchangesinfluidcompositionsinametasomatic-hydrothermalsystemassociatedwithextension,possiblyinanoceanicenvironment.
REFERENCESDiehl,E.A.,Masson,R.,Stutz,A.H.1952:Contributoallaconoscenzadel ricoprimentodellaDentBlanche.Memoriedegli
IstitutidiGeologiaeMineralogiadell’universitàdiPadova17,1-52.
3.22
Ore fluid evolution in a volcanic-hosted epithermal ore deposit: Farallón Negro, Argentina.
Márquez-Zavalía,M.Florencia*,Heinrich,ChristophA.**,Meier,Dimitri**
*IANIGLA, CCT Mendoza, CONICET, CC 330, (5500) Mendoza, Argentina ([email protected])**Isotope Geochemistry and Mineral Resources, Federal Institute of Technology, ETH Zentrum NO, CH-8092, Zurich, Switzerland
TheFarallónNegromineraldepositislocatedinCatamarcaprovince,Argentina,at27º19´Sand66º40´W.Thislowsulfida-tionepithermalgolddepositbelongstotheFarallónNegrominingdistrict,alongwithotherepithermal (e.g.,Capillitas,CerroAtajo)andporphyrydepositssuchasBajodelaAlumbreraandAguaRica.ThisclusterofCu-AumineraldepositsaregeneticallylinkedtoaMiocenevolcaniccomplexwithasuiteofrocksofhigh-Kcalk-alcalinetoshoshoniticaffinitiesknownasFarallónNegroVolcanicComplex(FNVC).Manyauthorsinterpretedthewholecomplexastheremnantofalargeandesiticvolcano(e.g.,Halteretal.,2004;Proffett,2003;Ulrichetal.,2002;andreferencestherein),thoughHarrisetal.(2006)presentsomecontradictingevidences.
AltodelaBlendaarea,wherethisstudywasfocused,isoneofthetwomainsuitsofveinsoftheFarallónNegromineraldeposit.ThemainveinsofAltodelaBlendaare:Laboreo,EsperanzaandEsperanzaSE.TheWpartofLaboreoveinishostedinandesiteandtherestofthatveinandtheothertwoarehostedinmonzonite.Theyaremorethan1000mlong,1to6mwide,withgradesupto7g/tAuand200g/tAg(Montenegro&Morales,2004).
Therewererecognizedfourstagesofthemineralizationwith7generationofquartz.Stage Iisrepresentedbytheearliestquartzrecognized(Q1)inthedeposit,presentasfragmentsinabreccia,itisbluishgreyincolourandoccursalongwithfragmentsofwhitishcarbonate(Cb1)andscarcedisseminatedpyrite.Stage IIcorrespondstothebreccia,whichiscementedbyasecondgenerationofquartz(Q2),greyincolour,interlayeredwithbandsofcreamycarbonate(Cb2)andassociatedwithfreeAu,sulphides(pyrite,galena,chalcopyrite,sphalerite)andCu,Ag,AuandPbsulphosalts.Attheendofthisstage,quartz(Q3)incolourlesscrystalsupto1cmlongfillstheremainingopenspacesandvugs.Stage IIIisrepresentedbyayoungergenerationofgreyquartz(Q4),associatedwithpinkandyellowishcarbonate(Cb3)andchalcopyriteandAgminerals.Itoc-cursparallel to thebreccia and frequently crosscutting it.At the endof this stage, small cavities are filledwithquartzcrystals(Q5)thatfrequentlydevelopalayeredbaseonwhichgrowtransparent,colourlesscrystalsupto2cmlong,develo-pingcombtextures.Insomeareas,Stage IVispresent,wherethelasttwogenerationsofquartzcanberecognized.Thefirstone(Q6)isscarceandoccurswithwhite(andpink?)layeredcarbonate(Cb4),mostlyoxidized(cryptomelaneandpyrolusite>>manganite,manjiroiteand“wad”)andgalena,chalcopyriteandsphaleritegenerallyscarce.SometimestheassociationQ6+Cb4isparalleltothewholesequenceandothertimescrosscutsit.Theyoungestquartz(Q7)fillstheopenspacesanddevelopscolourlesscrystalsupto1cmlong.Inseveralareasofthedeposit,localizedbrecciationaffectsdifferentpartsofthesequence.Preliminaryfluidinclusionresultsgiverangesofhomogenizationtemperaturesfrom200to270ºC,andsalinitiesfrom3.40to4.70NaClequiv.forEsperanzaveinandsimilarhomogenizationtemperaturesbutlowersalinitiesforLaboreovein.ThefirstresultsofmicroanalysesbyLA-ICPMS,performedinprimaryaqueousfluidinclusionstrappedinquartz,showconcen-trationsofppm-levelsofAuandhundredsofppmofCu.ThehighestvaluesofAuconcentrationswerefoundinQ2andQ3,belongingtothesecondstageofthemineralization,whilethehighestCuvaluescamefromsampleswithQ6andQ7,corre-spondingtothelaststageofthemineralization(StageIV).Otheroreformingelementswerealsoanalyzedandallresultswillbeinformedindetailwhenthestudyiscompleted.Therewereaswellinvestigatedtheaqueousfluidsofthelateveins,withAu-Ag-bearingquartz+Mn-carbonate+base-metalminerals,foundintheBajodelaAlumbreraopenpit(Meier,2008;Meieretal.2008)Thoughtheresultsarestillpreliminary,theresearchinprogressshowsthefirstsalineepithermalfluidsinalow-to
139
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryintermediatesulfidationepithermalsystemcontainingsignificantlyhighermetalconcentrationsthanfluidsinanyactive
geothermalsystem(e.g.,SimmonsandBronwn,2006).Theseveryhighmetalconcentrations(ppm-levelsofAuandhundredsofppmofCu)inthefluidindicatethatevenlow-tointermediate-sulfidationeconomicveindepositsdonotformfromcon-vectinggroundwateralone,butfrominjectionofvapor-derivedmagmaticfluid.
REFERENCESHalter,W.E.,Bain,N.,Becker,K.,Heinrich,C.A.,Landtwing,M.,VonQuadt,A.,Clark,A.H.,Sasso,A.M.,Bissig,T.&Tosdal,R.M.
2004:FromandesiticvolcanismtotheformationofaporphyryCu-Aumineralizingmagmachamber:theFarallonNegroVolcanicComplex,northwesternArgentina:JournalofVolcanologyandGeothermalResearch,136,1-30.
Harris,A.C.,Bryan,S.E.&Holcombe,R.J.2006:VolcanicsettingoftheBajodelaAlumbreraporphyryCu-Audeposit,FarallonNegroVolcanics,NorthwestArgentina:EconomicGeology,101,71-94.
Meier,D.2008:LowsalinityfluidsattheBajodelaAlumbreraporphyryCu-Audeposit,Argentina.MScthesis.Inst.IsotopeGeochemistryandMineralResources,Dept.EarthSc.,ETH-Zürich,SwissFederalInstituteTechnology.
Meier,D.,Heinrich,C.A.,Guilong,M.&Márquez-Zavalia,M.F.2008:LowsalinityfluidsattheBajodelaAlumbreraporphyryCu-Audeposit,Argentina.SwissGeoscienceMeeting.
Montenegro,N.&Morales,F.2004:DistritomineralizadoFarallónNegro.YMAD,Belén,Catamarca,Argentina.In:Márquez-Zavalía,M.F.(Ed.)CursoLatinoamericanodeMetalogeniaUNESCO-SEG2004.GuíadeCampo:83-99.
Proffett, J.M.2003:Geologyof theBajode laAlumbreraporphyrycopper-golddeposit,Argentina:EconomicGeology,98,1535-1574.
Ulrich,T.,Günther,D.&Heinrich,C.A.2002:TheEvolutionofaporphyryCu-Audeposit,basedonLA-ICP-MSanalysisoffluidinclusions:BajodelaAlumbrera,Argentina:EconomicGeology,97,1889-1920.
Simmons, S.F.&Bronwn,K.L. 2006:Gold inmagmatichydrothermal solutions and the rapid formationof a giant oredeposit.Science,314,5797,288-291.
3.23
Baggalútar from Hvalfjörður, SW Iceland: Volcanic spherulites or not?
MattssonHannesB.*,ReusserEric*
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zürich, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])
Baggalútarformwell-roundedspherules,rangingbetween0.5-3cmindiameter,andoccureitherassinglespherulesorag-gregatescontainingupto10individualspherulesjoinedtogether.TheyarerelativelycommononbeachesalongtheAtlanticcoast in HvalfjörЄur (SW Iceland).In literature, Baggalútar have commonly been explained as being volcanic spherulites(SaemundssonandGunnlaugsson,1999).However,Baggalútarlacktheinternalstructurecharacteristicforvolcanicspheru-liteswhichcommonlyinvolvesradialgrowthoffeldsparandquartzneedlesassilicicglassdevitrifies.Theyarenotaccretion-arylapilliasthesecommonlyformbyaccretionoffineasharoundanucleiiinanonion-liketexture.Neitheraretheycon-sistentwithbeingmarineconcretions,whicharecharacterizedbyconcentricinternaltextures.
Inthinsection,onlyrandominternaltexturecanbeobservedandtheBaggalútariscomposedofafine-grainedgroundmasswithabundantroundedvoidswhichhavebeeninfilledwithsecondaryminerals(mainlythomsonite,heulanditeandnatro-lite).XRDandSEManalysesshowthatthegroundmassiscomposedoflath-shapedplagioclase(An-rich),augiticclinopyrox-eneandtitanomagnetiteinvariousproportions(Fig.1).TheoverallmineralogyoftheBaggalútaristhereforeconsistentwithbeingbasaltic.Furthermore,theinternaltexturesuggeststhatitcouldbebasalticash,inwhichthevesicleshavebeenin-filledbyzeolitemineralsatalaterstage.
However,afewthingsabouttheoccurrenceofBaggalútarremainenigmatic:
1.Absenceofphenocrysts.Infiveinvestigatedthinsectionsonlytwosmallclinopyroxenephenocrystscouldbefound,andallspheruleshaveafine-grainedhomogeneoustexturestronglyreminiscentofquenching.
2.Whatcausesthewell-roundedshape?Thisisincontrasttotherandomlyorientedinternalstructureofthespherules.IfonlysingleBaggalútarareconsidered,theirwell-roundedshapescouldpotentiallybeattributedtomarineabrasion.However,thisdoesnotexplaintheoccurrenceofmulti-spheruleaggregatesinwhicheachspheruleiswell-rounded.
3.Wheredotheycomefrom?SofarnooutcrophasbeenfoundinHvalfjörЄurinwhichtheBaggalútaroccursinsitu,andfindingsuchanoutcropmayhelptoshedlightontheirformation.
140Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y REFERENCESSaemundsson,K.&Gunnlaugsson,E.1999:Islenskasteinabokin,MalogMenning,Reykjavik,pp.233.
Fig.1.CharacteristicsofBaggalútaratdifferentmagnifications.(a)Acollectionofhandspecimens.(b)SEMimageshowinghomogeneous
internaltexturewithvesiclesinfilledbyzeolites.(c)Close-upSEMimageofthegroundmasscomprisingplagioclase(lath-shaped,dark),
clinopyroxene(grey)andtitanomagnetite(white).
141
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.24
Columnar jointing and the formation of “chisel-marks” in the Hrossadalur lava flow, northern Iceland
MattssonHannesB.*,BosshardSonja*
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zürich, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zürich([email protected])
Columnarjointingand“chisel-marks”arecommonfeaturesinthick,slowlycooled,basalticlavas.Thefracturingtoformcolumnarjointingiscommonlyattributedtothermoelasticstraincreatingalocaltensilestress,whichresultsintheforma-tion of joints organized into columnswith a polygonal cross-section and large aspect ratio (length/diameter).The chiselmarks,ontheotherhand,arestriaeorientedperpendiculartothemainaxisofthecolumnandreflectsastepwisecrackpropagationasthelavascool.
Fig.1.Schematicsketchofcolumnarjointingandchisel-marksintheHrossadalurlavaflow.Hammerforscale.
AtHrossadalurinnorthernIcelanda200mlongcross-sectionofaponded,columnar-jointed,basalticlavaflowisexposedinanormalfaultbelongingtothemuchlargerKraflafissureswarm.ThetotalthicknessoftheHrossadalurlavaflowexceeds10m,anddisplayaninternalmorphologycharacteristicforp-typepahoehoewithavesicularuppercrustandadenseinte-rior.Closetothetopofthelavaflowsmall-scalecolumnarjointingisabundant(althoughpoorlydeveloped).Inthispartoftheflowchiselmarksareabsent.Startingroughly0.8-1.5mfromthetopoftheflow(i.e. thecoolingsurface),columnarjointsarefewerandlargerinsizeandchisel-marksstarttoform(Fig.1).Theinitialspacingbetweenindividualchiselmarksissmall(afewcm).However,thespacingofthechisel-marksshowsasystematicincreasewithdepthintotheinterioroftheflow(incasesexceeding25cmnearthecentralpartoftheflow).Thebaseoftheexposedsectioniscomposedofamassivepart,wherecolumnarjointingandchiselmarksareabsent.Insteadconcentricarrangementofvesiclesandflowfoliationindicatethatthisportionofthelavaflowwasoccupiedbylavatubes.
Measurementsofthespacingofchisel-marksatHrossadalur,incombinationwithobservationsofcrackpropagationinac-tiveHawaiianlavaflows(Honetal.,1994),suggeststhatthespacingrepresentstheeffectivethicknessoftheviscoelasticpartofthecrustasalavaflowprogressivelycoolsandsolidifies.Thefracturepropagationisincremental,goingfromthebrittlecrust(<800°C),throughtheviscoelasticlayer(800-1070°C),tothemolteninterior(>1070°C).Afteronestepoffracturepropa-gation,theflowneedstocooltobuildupsufficientthermoelasticstraintopromoteanothercycleofcrack-propagation.
Tentativemodelingofconductivecooling(CarslawandJaeger,1959)involvingachangeofstate(moltentosolid),showsgoodagreement between the time-dependant thickness of viscoelastic crust and the measured spacing of chisel-marks atHrossadalur.Thus,thespacingofthechiselmarkspresentincolumnarjointedbasaltscaneffectivelybeusedtoconstrainthecoolinghistoryofslowlysolidifyinglavalakesandintrusionsaswellaslavaflows.
REFERENCESCarslaw,H.S.&Jaeger,J.C.1959:Conductionofheatinsolids,2ndEd.,OxfordUniv.Press,NewYork,pp.510Hon,K.,Kauahikaua,J.,Denlinger,R.&MackayK.1994:Emplacementandinflationofpahoehoesheetflows:Observations
andmeasurementsofactivelavaflowsonKilaueavolcano,Hawaii,GeologicalSocietyofAmericaBulletin,106,351-370.
142Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.25
Convective instabilities in Volcanic Clouds
MonnardHélène*,ManzellaIrene*,JeremyPhillips**,CostanzaBonadonna*
*Department of Mineralogy, University of Geneva, Rue des Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève ([email protected])**Department of Earth Sciences, Centre for Environmental and Geophysical Flows, University of Bristol, UK
Convectiveinstabilitiesdrivenbyparticlesedimentationmayplayanimportantroleintheparticledispersalfromvolcanicplumes (e.g.Figure1).Such instabilitiesoccur indensitystratified fluidsandtheyarecharacterisedbythe formationoffingers.Whenaparticle ladenfluidissituatedaboveadenserfluid,thetwolayersareinitiallystable.Withtheparticlesettling,athickeninginterfacelayerbecomesgravitationallyunstableandfingerscouldstartdevelop.Manyexperimentshavebeencarriedouttocharacterizethisprocess (e.g.Chen1997;Hoyaletal.1999;Völtzetal2000).However,notmanyexperimentswerecarriedouttoinvestigateconvectiveinstabilitiesinavolcanicsetting(e.g.Carey1997).Inaddition,numericalmodelsusedtodescribetephradispersaldonotaccountforconvectiveinstabilities.Wehaveperformedlaboratoryexperimentstoinvestigatethedynamicsofthisphenomenonanditseffectsontherateofparticlesedimentationfromthebottomofthevolcanicplumeanddepositionatthebed.
TheexperimentswerecarriedoutinaPlexiglastankofasizeof30cmwidthx7.5cmdepthx50cmheight(seeFigure2a),wherearemovableandflexiblePETsheetisplacedat25cmheighttoseparatetwodifferentlayersoffluidandensureaninitiallysharpinterface.Theupperpartisfilledupto13.5cmwithalightersuspensionofwaterandparticles,thelowerpartisfilledwithadensersugarandwatersolution.Theupperlayerisstronglymixedbeforeeachexperimenttoensureaninitiallyuniformconcentration.Experimentsconsist inremovingtheseparationandanalyzingtheformationof fingers.EachexperimentisfilmedbyaHDcamera.Aprocessofcalibrationhasbeencarriedouttocorrelatethedifferentgreylevelsofafilmimagetodifferentlevelofconcentration.
Aftertheremovaloftheseparation, ifweconsidertheupperlayertobehaveasasimplequiescentsuspension,wecouldexpectitsmeanconcentrationtodecreaselinearlywithtimeasfollows:
)( 00 h
twCCtC s−=
Preliminaryobservationsshowedusthatthis isnotthecaseforourexperiments (seeFigure2b).Asamatteroffact,theconcentrationvaluesstartdecreasingafteracertaintimefollowingtheopeningoftheseparation.Thiscouldbeduetothefactthatthelinearmodeldoesnottakeintoaccounttheaccumulationofparticlesattheinterfacebetweenthetwolayersatdifferentdensities,whichactuallycausesgravitationalinstabilities.Thesefirstconsiderationsconfirmthefactthatcon-vectiveinstabilitiesinfluencetherateofsedimentationandconsequentlyunderlinetheneedtodevelopnewandcompleteanalyticalexpressionstoimprovemodellingofsedimentationfrombuoyantplumes.
Figure1:Examplesoffingeringgeneratedatthebaseofhorizontally-spreadingvolcanicclouds(EruptionofMontserrat,1997.Photoby
CostanzaBonadonna).
143
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try(a) (b)
Figure2:(a)Theexperimentalset-up,aPlexiglastankof30x7.5x50cmafterthebannerisremoved.(b)Meanconcentrationfortheupper
layerasafunctionoftimeforaninitialconcentrationof4.9g/Lcomparedwiththelinearmodel.
REFERENCESCarey,S.N.1997:Influenceofconvectivesedimentationontheformationofwidespreadtephrafalllayersinthedeepsea.
Geology,25(9),839-842.Chen,C.F.1997:Particlefluxthroughsedimentfingers,DeepSeaResearchPartI.OceanographicResearchPapers,44(9-10),
1645-1654.Hoyal,D.C.J.D.,etal.1999:Settling-drivenconvection:Amechanismofsedimentationfromstratifiedfluids.J.Geophys.
Res.,104.Voltz,C.,etal.2000:Finger-likepatternsinsedimentingwater-sandsuspensions.PhysicsReports,337,117-138.
144Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.26
Geochemical constraints on the development of a Mesozoic volcano- tectonic arc and fore-arc basin in the Sanandaj-Sirjan Zone, south Iran
MonsefIman*,RahgoshayMohammad*,EmamiMohammad-Hashem**&ShafaiiMoghadamHadi***
*Shahid Beheshti University, Faculty of Earth Sciences, Tehran, Iran ([email protected])**Research Institue for Earth Sciences, Geological Survey of Iran, Teharn, Iran***Damghan University of Basic Sciences, School of Earth Sciences, Damghan, Iran
ThetectonichistoryoftheNeo-TethyanregioninIranwasbegunbythecreationoftheoceaniclithospherewithriftingbe-tweentheCentralIranianBlockandGondwana(Arabia)duringLatePermian-EarlyTriassictime.ThesubductionoftheNeo-TethysstartstothesouthoftheCentralIranianBlockatLateTriassic–LateJurassictime.Thissubductionphaseledtopres-ence of volcanic activities and emplacement of intrusive bodies within the Sanandaj-Sirjan Zone (Fig. 1). Therefore theSanandaj-SirjanZonebehavedasanactivecontinentalmargin,witnessbythepresenceofcalc-alkalinearc-relatedmagma-tism.TheSanandaj-SirjanMagmaticArciscomposedmainlyofaMesozoicmagmatismincludinglava(basalt,andesiteanddacitictuff)andplutonicrocks (granite,granodioriteandquartzmonzonite),alternatingwithlimestonesandOrbitolinalimestone.
AboutasametimeduringsubductionoftheNeo-Tethys,riftingalongtheSanandaj-SirjanZonetookplace,resultinginopen-ingofaLateTriassictoEarlyJurassictranstensionalfore–arcbasincalledtheHajiabad–EsfandaghehColorMelangeZone(Fig.1).Thiszonecontainsabundantultramaficswithchromitedeposits,partlypreservedvolcano–sedimentarysequenceswithpillow lavas,Globotruncana–bearing redmarls and radiolarites, and exoticmarbles, amphibolites andminor blueschists.Volcanicrockshaveamixtureofdominantlyarc-like(calc-alkaline)andsubordinateMORB-likecompositionalfeatures.
TheemplacementofColorMelangeZonetookplaceduringtheEarlytoLateCretaceousasaresultofcollisionalandconti-nental subduction of theGondwana (Arabia) beneath theCentral IranianBlock along theMain Zagros Thrust Belt. TheZagrosorogenisayoungTertiarycollisionbeltgenerallyconsideredarecentanalogueoftheHimalayanorogenicbelt.
Figure1.SimplifiedstructuralsketchmapofsouthIran.ThelocationsofmajorstructuralzonesconsistingofSanandaj-SirjanZone,
CentralIranianBlock,MainZagrosThrustandZagrosFoldedBeltareindicated.
REFERENCESAgard,P.,Monie,P.,Gerber,W.,Omrani,J.,Molinaro,M.,Meyer,B.,Labrousse,L.,Vrielynck,B.,Jolivet,L.&Yamato,P.,2006:
Transient, synobduction exhumation of Zagros blueschists inferred fromP-T, deformation, time, and kinematicconstraints:ImplicationsforNeotethyanwedgedynamics.JournalofGeophysicalResearch,111,B11401,1-28.
Ewart,A.,Collerson,K.D.,Regelous,M.,Wendt,J.I.&Niu,Y.,1998:GeochemicalevolutionwithintheTonga-Kermadec-Lauarc-backarcsystems:theroleofvaryingmantlewedgecompositioninspaceandtime.JournalofPetrology,39,331-368.
McCulloch,M.T.&Gamble, J.A.,1991:Geochemicalandgeodynamicalconstraintsonsubductionzonemagmatism.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,102,358-375.
Pearce, J.A., 1980: Geochemical evidence for the genesis and eruptive setting of lavas from Tethyan ophiolites. In:Panayiotou, A., (Eds.), Ophiolites. Procceding International Ophiolite Symposium, Nicosia, Geological SurveyDepartment,261-272.
145
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.27
Transtensional basin system in Central Iranian Volcanic Belt
R.Monsef*,M.H.Emami**,N.RashidnejadOmran***
*ISLAMICAZADUNIVERSITY,ESTAHBANBRANCH,IRAN([email protected])**RESEARCH INSTITUE FOR EARTH SCIENCES, GEOLOGICAL SURVEY OF IRAN.*** GEOLOGY DEPARTMANT BASIC SCIENCE FACULTY, TARBIAT MODARES UNIVERSITY,PO. 14115-111,TEHRAN
Urumieh-Dokhtarmagmaticzone(UDMZ)hasbeenconsideredasaplaceforthemainmagmaticactivitiesintheCentralIraniancontinentintheCenozoic(mainlyineocene).MagmatismisspatiallyandtemporallyassociatedwithAlpine-Himalayacollisionaltectonics.ExplosiveactivitiesinPaleogeneandearlyNeogenewerecommonlyfromfissureeruptionsandfeederdikeshadadomonantroleforcreationofthicksequencesofmagmaticandpyroclasticrocks.TheSlafchegantoDelijanre-gioncoversanareaabout500sq.Itischaracterizedbyanumberofsubparallelmountainsanddepressions,runningNW-SEbelongstoNeogene.centeralventeruptionscausedforcreationofstrata-volcanoesinthestudyareaandvarientofvolcanicdomes incontinentalenvironment.TheNeogenevolcanicactivitiesaredividedintotwophases:Atthefirststage (Ngv
1),
volcanicrockscontainbasalttoandesite-basaltaslavaorpyroclasticmaterials.Theexplosiveeventwasfollowedbythevolca-nictosubvolcanicassociationsofNgv
2withproductsofmainlyandesitictorhyioliticcomposition.Thevolcanicdomesof
Ngv2 and their diverse modes of emplacement are especially characteristic of this phase as Kuh-e-Aleh (fig.1).
Petrography,GeochemistryandmineralchemistrydataconfirmthepresenceoftranstensionalregionsalongtheUrumieh-Dokhtarmagmaticzone(UDMZ),openedduringPaleogeneandearlyNeogeneduetothecollisionoftheArabiaplatformandCentralIraniancontinent.AtTertiarytime,thetimespanbetweentheLaramidianandMio-Pliocenephaseisrelatedtotheopeningupofthebasins(intercontinentalrift),theextensionalphenomenonmovingslowlyattheendoftheEoceneandthebeginningoftheOligocene.LocalNogenevolcanismduetotranstensionalregionshappensinOligo-Miocene.Theclo-singofthebasins,orcompressionalperiod,beganwiththeMio-Pliocenemovementwhichcausedthefoldinganduplif-ting.
Figure1.GeologicalourviewmapofNeogenevolcanicactivities.1:25000
146Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y REFERENCESEmami.M.H., 1981,Geologie de la region deQom-Aran (Iran) contribution a l etude dynamique et geochimique du
volcanismetertiairedelIranCentral,TheseDoctoratEtatGrenoble,489Ricou, L.E., 1994. Tethys reconstructedplates, continental fragments and their boundaries since 260Ma fromCentral
AmericatoSouth–easternAsia.GeodynamicaActa(Paris)7.Verdel,Charles,2009,CenozoicGeologyofIran:Anintegretadstudyofextensionaltectonicsandrelatedvolcanism,Thesis
doctorofphilosophy,CaliforniaInstituteforTechnology.
3.28
Metamorphic evolution of a kyanite-eclogite from Thermes, Rhodope Massif, Greece.
MoulasEvangelos*,KostopoulosDimitrios**
*GeologischesInstitut,ETHZürich,Sonnegstrasse5,8092Zurich,Switzerland([email protected])**Department of Mineralogy and Petrology, Faculty of Geology and Geoenvironment, School of Sciences, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 157 84 Athens, Greece
TheRhodopeMassifinnorthernGreeceisarecentlyidentifiedultrahigh-pressuremetamorphic(UHPM)provincecompri-sing garnetiferous metapelites and eclogites with microdiamond inclusions. These rocks preserve evidence of melting(T>1100°C;P>7GPa) ina Jurassic subductionzoneanda complex reheatinghistoryat thebaseof the crust in theearlyTertiary.
Akyanite-eclogitefromtheThermesarearevealsthepressure-temperature-timepathfollowedbytheRhodopeUHPMrocks.Texturesinvolvingphengiticmicaindicatemeltingathighconfiningpressures.Quartzinclusionsinkyaniteshowmulti-polygonaldomainsandradialcrackssuggestingformercoesite,hencePconditions>2.7GPa(atabout700°C).
ClinopyroxeneformedunderUHPconditionswasreplacedbydiopside+plagioclasesymplectiteswhereaskyanitewasre-placedbycorundum+plagioclasesymplectitesduringdecompression.Thelatterreactionoccurredinlocallysilicaundersa-turated domains of the rock (Godard&Mabit 1998). Large porphyroblastic amphiboleswith taramitic coresmantled bypargasiticcompositionsattestamphiboleformationviahydrationreactionsintheeclogite-faciesandlaterdecompressiontotheamphibolitesfacies.
Subsequentgranulitisationproceededviareactionsbetweeni)garnetporphyroblastsandmatrixdiopsidetoformcoronasofplagioclase+ilmenite+magnetite+sodicgedritearoundgarnet,ii)corundumanddiopsidetoformspinel+plagioclasesymplectitesafterkyaniteandiii)kyanite,spinelandcorundumtoformsapphirine(Liati&Seidel1996).Theseimplythatconditionsofapproximately1.5GPaatT>800°Cwereattained,possiblyassociatedwithasecond-stagepartialmeltingepiso-de.ZircongeochronologyusingSHRIMPrevealedamiddleEoceneage(~42Ma)forgranuliteformation.Thisage,inconjunc-tionwiththecoevalageofapophysesoftheSkalotigraniteinthearea,isconsistentwiththegeneralhistoryoftheRhodopeMassifundergoinggeneralexhumationandcrustalcollapseinEocenetimes.
REFERENCESGodard,G.&Mabit,J.-L.1998:Peraluminussapphirineformedduringretrogressionofakyanite-bearingeclogitefromPays
deLéon,ArmoricanMassif,France,Lithos43,15-29.Liati,A.& Seidel, E. 1996:Metamorphic evolutionandgeochemistryofkyanite eclogites in centralRhodope,northern
Greece,Contrib.Mineral.Petrol.123,293-307.
147
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.29
Rheological properties of crystal- and bubble-bearing silicic magmas: pre-liminary experimental results
PistoneMattia*,CaricchiLuca**,BurliniLuigi***,UlmerPeter*
* ETH-Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, Clausiusstrasse 25, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected]; [email protected])** University of Bristol, Wills Memorial Building - Queen's Road, BS8 1RJ Bristol ([email protected])*** ETH-Geological Institute, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])
Naturalmagmasaremixturesofsilicatemelts,crystalsandgasbubbles.Theviscosityofsuchmulti-phasemixturesisthesinglemostimportantpropertycontrollingtheeruptivebehaviorofvolcanoes.Therheologicalbehaviorandthephysicalpropertiesofmagmasdependprimarilyon theviscosityof thesilicatemeltandontherelativecontentsofcrystalsandbubbles(Caricchietal.2007;Llewellin&Manga2005)aswellasontheinteractionsbetweenthesethreephases.Theshapeandsizedistributionofcrystalshasbeendemonstratedtoinfluencesignificantlythevariationofviscositywithrespecttothecrystalfraction.Inaddition,thenon-Newtonianbehaviorofmagmas(viscositydecreaseswithincreasingde-formationrate)hasbeenassociatedtothegeometricalorderingofsuspendedparticlesinthemagma(Caricchietal.2007;Costaetal.2009).
Bubblesexertcontrastingeffectsontherheologicalbehaviorofmagmasdependingonappliedstressconditions.Deformingbubblescausetheviscositytodecreasewhilesphericalgasvesiclesbehaveascrystals,thusincreasingthemagmaviscosity.Wepresentnovelexperimentalresultsontherheologicalbehaviorofmagmascomposedofliquidandboth,gas-pressurizedbubblesandcrystals,deformedatmagmaticpressuresandtemperatures.Thisstudyaimstoconstrainthedependenceofrheologicalandphysicalpropertiesofmagmasontheviscosityofthesilicatemelt,ontherelativecontentsofcrystalsandbubblesandontheinteractionsbetweenthesethreephases.ThestartingmaterialconstitutesofahaplograniticmeltcontainingvariableamountsofH
2O(2.68wt%and5.25wt%)and
CO2(2.06wt%and4.97wt%)anddifferentproportionsofquartzcrystals(between24and65vol%;63-125µmindiameter)
andbubbles(between7and22vol%;5-150µmindiameter).TheexperimentswereperformedinsimpleshearusingaHT-HPinternally-heatedPaterson-typerockdeformationapparatus(Paterson&Olgaard,2000)atstrainratesrangingbetween5·10-5s-1and1·10-3s-1,atapressureof200MPaandtemperaturesbetween773and923K.
AtthesetemperatureandstrainrateconditionsthesilicatemeltbehavesasaNewtonianliquid(Webb&Dingwell,1990).Consequently,non-Newtonianeffectscanentirelyberelatedtothepresenceofbubblesandcrystals.Inallexperimentalrunsamarkedweakeningbehavior(decreaseofstresswithincreasingstrain)wasobserved.Back-scatteredelectronimageswereacquiredonexternalportionsofthesamples,wherethesimpleshearconfigurationisbestappreciated.These imagesclearlyhighlight thepresenceofmelt-enrichedportionsof thesampleswerebubblesarestronglydeformed.Incontrast,inregionssurroundingthesemelt-enrichedbands,bubblesarealmostsphericaltestifyingthattheseportionsofthematerialsufferedasignificantlyloweramountofdeformation.Locally,deformedbubblesbetweencrystalsresultingfromlocalstressconcentrationgeneratedbythesolidparticlescanbeobserved.Themeasuredweakeningismostprobably related to thegenerationofmelt-enriched shearbands.The localizationofdeformation in these lowerviscosityregionsresultsinadecreaseofviscositywithincreasingstrain(shearthinningeffects).
Thesepreliminaryexperimentalresultsservetoguideourongoingexperimentaleffortstofinallyobtainrheologicallawsfor crystal and bubble bearingmagmas to simulate andpredict volcanic eruptions from shallowmagma reservoirs andvolcanicconduits.
REFERENCESCaricchi,L.,Burlini,L.,Ulmer,P.,Gerya,T.,Vassalli,M.&Papale,P.2007:Non-Newtonianrheologyofcrystal-bearingmagmas
andimplicationsformagmaascentdynamics.EarthPlanet.Sci.Lett.264,402-419.Costa,A.,Caricchi, L.&Bagdassarov,N.S. 2009:Amodel for the rheologyofparticle-bearing suspensions andpartially
moltenrocks.Geochem.Geophys.Geosyst.10,1-13.Llewellin,E.W.&Manga,A.2005:Bubblesuspensionrheologyandimplicationsforconduitflow.J.Volcanol.Geotherm.Res.
143,205–217.Paterson,M.S.&Olgaard,D.L.2000:Rockdeformationteststolargeshearstrainsintorsion.J.Struct.Geol.22,1341-1358.Webb,S.L.&DingwellD.B.1990:Non-Newtonianrheologyofigneousmeltsathighstressesandstrainrates:experimental
resultsforrhyolite,andesite,basaltandnephelinite.J.Geophys.Res.95(B10),15695-15701.
148Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.30
Complexities in the high pressure metamorphic history of the central Sesia Zone near Cima di Bonze (NW Italy)
DanieleRegis*,PaolaManzotti*,KatherineBoston**,BenedicteCenki-Tok*,MartinRobyr*,DanielaRubatto**,TonnyThomsen*,MartinEngi*
*University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 3, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland ([email protected])**The Australian National University, Mills road, Canberra, ACT, 0200 Australia
ThecentralSesia-LanzoZoneincludesanarrow,continuouslysurfacingunit,whichwastermedMonometamorphicCoverComplex(MCC)byVenturini(1995).TheMCCcomprises:(a)theBonze Unit,composedofbasicrocks(metagabbrosandglau-cophane-eclogites), found in tectonic contact with (b)metasediments (calcschists, metamarls, impure quartzites) of theScalaro Unit.ThecontactsbetweenthisbodyandthetwolargebasementblocksoftheSesiaZoneareclearlytectonicandmostlypredatetheeclogiticmetamorphism.
Rubattoetal.(1999)showedthatgabbrosoftheBonzeUnithadintrudedthecrystallinebasementintheearlyCarboniferous.Blasto-myloniticmetagabbroscontainlocalrelicsofbrownhornblende;thesemayreflectpre-Alpinemetamorphism(amphi-bolitefacies?).However,norelicsofapre-AlpinestagehavebeenfoundinthemetasedimentsoftheScalaroUnit.ThisunitisthusagoodtargetforstructurallycontrolledpetrochronologyoftheAlpineevolutioninthecentralSesiaZone.
Wereportresultsofdetailedstructural,petrographic,chemicalandgeochronologicalworkcarriedoutintheCimaBonzeregion,withafocusonimpurequartzitesofthepoly-deformedScalaroUnit.ApervasiveHPplanarstructure(S2foliation)dominatesintheareastudiedandinthesamplesanalysed.SeveralgenerationsofmetamorphicallaniteandLREE-richepi-doteoccur,providingarobust(Th-Pb,U-Pb)chronometerthatcanbeintimatelylinkedtothepetrologicalandmicro-struc-turalevolution.ThreegrowthzoneswithvariableREEandU-Thcontentswererecognizedintheseallanites,andretrogres-sivetinyrimsofclinozoisite/epidotewereoftenobserved.PhaserelationsbetweenallaniteandotherREE-richphaseswerecarefullystudiedandyieldaveryclearandinterestingsequence.Epidoteoftenincludesrelicsofmonazite,thorite,apatiteandxenotime.Thephaserelations indicate thereaction:monazite+ fluidàallanite+ thorite+apatite.LargecrystalsofxenotimeformingcoronasonzirconareassociatedwithsmallcrystalsofthoriteandREE-poorallanite.
SHRIMPU-Th-Pbin situdatingofthethreegrowthzonesconsistentlyyieldthreedifferentAlpineages(from83Mato65Ma).PreliminaryLA-ICP-MSdataonthesamesamplesconfirmtheionproberesults.Furtherelectronmicroprobedatingisun-derwayonmonaziteandthoritetounderstandtheirrelationstoallaniteandtounravelwhethertheearlymonaziteisaprogradeoradetritalphase.
TheseresultshaveimportantimplicationsontheAlpineHP-evolutionoftheSesiaZoneasawhole.AdetailedPTDt-pathispresentlybeingbeworkedout,butthepreliminarydatainanycaseindicateacomplex,protractedreactionsequencepro-ducingallaniteoverat least10m.y.Thismayserve toexplainat least someof thecomplexAr-Aragepatterns foundbyVenturini(1995).
REFERENCESRubattoD.,GebauerD.,CompagnoniR. 1999:Datingof eclogite-facies zircons: theageofAlpinemetamorphism in the
Sesia-LanzoZone(WesternAlps).EarthPlanet.Sci.Letters167,141-158.VenturiniG. 1995:Geology, geochemistry and geochronology of the inner central Sesia Zone (WesternAlps – Italy).
MémoiresdeGéologie,Lausanne,25,148pp.
149
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.31
The temporal evolution of the Mitu group, south-east Peru – first U-Pb age data.
ReitsmaMariël*,SchalteggerUrs*,SpikingsRichard*,CarlottoVictor**
*Earth and Environmental Sciences, Rue des Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève**INGEMMET, Av. Canada 1470 San Borja, Lima, Peru
TheEasternCordilleraofsouthernPeruformedalongacrustalzonethathasbeenactiveaspartofthewesternGondwanamarginsincethemiddlePaleozoic.ThepresentstudyinvestigatestheMituGroupofsouth-eastPeruintheareaofAbancay-Cusco-Sicuani-Titicaca. This unit comprises continental clastic sediments deposited in syn-sedimentary basins during anextensionalperiodinPermo-Triassictimesandhasnotbenefittedfromathoroughgeochemical-geochronologicalinvestiga-tionsofar.Oneofthemainreasonsforthislackofdataisacomplexstructureofthegrabensystem,tectonicallycomplicatedbycompressionalinversionoftheextensionalbasinsduringAndeanorogeny.Duetodominatingcoarse-grainedclastics,theMituGroupisdevoidoffossilsanditsageisonlypoorlybracketedtobePermo-TriassicbasedonitsstratigraphicrelationtotheunderlyingCopacabanaandoverlyingPucaragroups.TheupperlevelsoftheCopacabanahavebeenconstrainedbypa-lynologytotheArtinskian(DoubingerandMarocco,1981).However,ahiatusmaybeobservedbetweentheCopacabanaandtheMitugroupsinmostplaces,renderingtheageestimateofthebasalMituimprecise.ThePucaraGroup,regardedbyRosasetal.(2007)asthermalsagafterMituextension,isattributedtothelateTriassic-earlyJurassiconthebasisofammonitefossilsandU-Pbzirconagesfromashbeds(Schalteggeretal.,2008).TheaimofthisstudyistoprovidemoreaccurateandpreciseageconstraintsfortheageanddurationoftheMituGroupbyusingU-Pbgeochronologyofvolcaniczirconinrhyo-liticlavas,andofdetritalzirconinclasticsediments.Forandesiticvolcaniclithologies,ageapproximationswillbeobtainedbyAr-Artechniquesappliedtoamphiboleandgroundmasssamples.
FielddatawereobtainedfromalongandapparentlycompletesectionthroughtheMitu,situated120kmSEofCusconearthecityofSicuani.ThissectionconsistsoftypicalMitudeposits;continentalredbeds,brecciasandandesiticlavas.However,azircon-bearingrhyoliticlavaatthebottomgivesustheopportunitytodatethestartofMitusedimentationbyU-PbID-TIMS;thisanalysiswillprovideapreciseageforthebaseoftheMitugroupforthefirsttime.IntheSicuaniareatheMituuncon-formablyoverlies theAmbogroup, suggesting that theentireCopacabana ismissing. Laser-ablation ICP-MSU-PbdataofdetrialzirconsfromasandstonejustbelowtheunconformityindicateamaximumageoflatestCarboniferous(303Ma)fortheunderlyingAmbogroup.ThismaximumageoverlapswiththepalynologicalageofthelowerCopacabana(Azcuyetal.,2002),raisingthequestionwhethertheAmboandCopacabanaaretrulydiachronousorjustcoevalunitsofdifferentsedi-mentaryfaciesassociations.Inanothersection,100kmWofCusco,nearthecityofAbancay,wefoundMitusedimentsoverlyingtheCopacabanaGroup.HeretheCopacabanacontainswellpreservedplantfossilsofthelycopsidsfamilyalsofoundelsewhereinPeruandBolivia.LackofacidicvolcanismduringMituextensioninthisregionprevents fromdatingof lavasusingtheU-Pbmethod.Thedetritalzirconpopulationinasandstone inthe lowermostpartof theMituwasanalysedforU-Pbages,usingLA-ICP-MStechniques.Theyoungestzirconsinthepopulationarearound235MahenceprovidingamaximumagefortheonsetofMitugroupsedimentation.TheArtinskianagefortheupperCopacabanafromDoubingerandMarocco(1981)hasalsobeenob-tainedfromtheAbancayregion,establishingahiatusofsome50Myrsbetweenthetwounits.TheMituGroupisintrudedbya220Magranitebody(LipaandSaraiva,2008)indicatingsignificantburialofthesedimentsatthistime.500kmSEofCusco,ontheBolivianshoresoflakeTiticaca,theAmboGroupfeaturesplantfossilsoftheLycopsidsfamilylikethosefoundintheCopacabananearAbancay.OurdetritalzirconLA-ICPMSstudyonaquartzarenitejustbelowthefossilsindicatesamaximumU-Pbageof343Ma.Howeverazircon-bearingashbedwillallowformoreprecisecalibrationofthefossilagebyID-TIMStechniques.ThezirconU-PbdatawillprovideatestwhethertheCopacabanaandtheAmbogroupareindeeddiachronousorjustlateralvariationsofasedimentarysystem.
REFERENCESAzcuy,C.L.,DiPasquo,M.&ValdiviaAmpuero,H.2002:LateCarboniferousmiosporesfromtheTarmaFormation,Pongode
Mainique,Peru.Reviewofpalaeobotanyandpalynology118,1-28.Doubinger, J., andMarocco,R. 1981:ContenuPalynologiqueduGroupeCopacabana (Permien Inférieur etMoyen) sur la
bordureSuddelaCordillèredeVilcabamba,régiondeCuzco(Pérou).InternationalJournalofEarthSciences70,1086-1099.LipaSalas,V.&SaraivaDosSantos,T. 2008:Geocronologiayevolucion tectonicadelplutonAbancay-Apurimac-Peru.XIII
Latin-Americangeologicalcongress:Lima,Peru.Rosas,S.,Fontboté,L.&Tankard,A.2007:TectonicevolutionandpaleogeographyoftheMesozoicPucaraBasin,centralPeru.
JournalofSouthAmericanEarthSciences24,1-24.Schaltegger,U.,Guex,J.,Bartolini,A.,Schoene,B.&Ovtcharova,M.2008:PreciseU-Pbageconstraintsforend-Triassicmass
extinction,itscorrelationtovolcanismandHettangianpost-extensionrecovery.EarthandPlanetaryscienceletters267,266-275.
150Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.32
Single-crystal elastic properties of superhydrous phase B determined by Brillouin scattering spectroscopy
RosaAngelikaD.*,Sanchez-ValleCarmen*,WangJingyun*&SaikiaAshima*
*Institute for Mineralogy and Petrology, ETH Zurich, Zurich 8092, Switzerland ([email protected])
SuperhydrousphaseB,Mg10Si
3O
18H
4,(herereferredtoasShyB)belongstothegroupofDHMSphases(densehydrousmagne-
siumsilicates),thatarelikelythemostimportantwaterreservoirsindeepsubductedslabs.Inordertoformulateaccuratemineralogicalandcompositionalmodelsofsubductedslabsandtointerpretseismicobserva-tioninthisarea,preciselymeasuredelasticitydataatrelevantP-Tconditionsareneededbutarenotoftenavailable.
InthiscontributionwepresentresultsofBrillouinscatteringmeasurementsofthesoundvelocitiesandsingle-crystalelasticpropertiesofShyBatambientconditions.Brillouinscatteringisoneofthemostpowerfulandprecisemethodtoinvestigatetheelasticpropertiesof single-crystalsandpolycrystallinesamplesof small size.TheShyBsingle-crystalsusedhereweresynthesisedinaWalkermodulemultianvilpressof1000tonatIMP,Zurichat20GPaand12000C.TheVoigt-Reuss-Hillaver-agefortheadiabaticbulkandshearmoduliareKs=150(3)GPaandµ=98(2)GPa,respectively.ThepresentresultsareingoodagreementwithapreviousBrillouinscatteringstudybyPacalo&Weidner(1996)[1].Thebulkmodulusobtainedinthisstudyisalsoingoodagreementwiththeresultsofaprevioussingle-crystalPVstudy[2]butresolvediscrepanciesbetweenpreviouscompressionalstudiesusingpowderedsamples[3,4].Theresultsshowthattheaggregatecompressionalandshearwaveve-locitiesofShyB(V
P=9.17(9)and V
S=5.43(4) km/s)arethelowestamongcoexistingphasesinsubductedperidoties,including
Mg-Perovskite,hydrousRingwooditeorFerropericlase.Thevelocitydistributioncalculatedfromthebest-fitelasticmodelofShyBrevealsanearlyisotropicseismicbehaviourofShyBatroomconditions.Thecompressionalanisotropy(A
P)isonly6.6%
whileslightlyhighershearanisotropy(AS)of11.6%isobserved.IfthemoderatedanisotropyofShyBismaintainedathigh
P-T,thestrongseismicanisotropyobservedinsubductedslabsbelowthetransitionzone,maynotberelatedtothepresenceofShyB.
REFERENCES[1]Pacalo,R.E.G.andWeidner,D.J.1996:ElasticityofsuperhydrousB.PhysicsandChemistryofMinerals,23,520-525.[2]Kudoh,Y.,Nagase, T.,Ohta, S., Sasaki, S., Kanzaki,M., andTanaka,M. 1994:Crystal structureand compressibilityof
superhydrousphaseB,Mg20Si6H8O36.InS.C.Schmidt,J.W.Shaner,G.A.Samara,andM.Ross,Eds.High-PressureScienceandTechnology,Am.Inst.Phys.Conf.Proc.,309,p.469-472.
[3]Inoue,T.,Higo,Y.,Yamada,A.,Irifune,T.&Funakoshi,K.2006:High-pressureandhigh-temperaturestabilityandequationofstateofsuperhydrousphaseBbyinsituX-raydiffraction.InS.D.Jacobsen,andS.VanderLee,Eds.EarthDeepWaterCycle,p.147-157.AGU,WashingtonDC.
[4] Litasov, K.D.,Ohtani, E.,Ghosh, S.,Nishihara, Y., Suzuki, A. and Funakoshi, K. 2007: Thermal equation of state ofsuperhydrousphaseBto27GPaand1373K.PhysicsoftheEarthandPlanetaryInteriors,164,142-160.
3.33
The influence of volatiles in basaltic explosive eruptions: the example of the Chaimilla eruption (3.1 Ka, Villarrica Volcano, Chile).
ScalisiRosalinda1,CostantiniLicia1,BonadonnaCostanza1,DiMuroAndrea2
1Section des sciences de la Terre et de l’environnement 13, Rue des Maraichers, Ch-1025 Genève([email protected]) 2Laboratoire de physique et chimie des systèmes volcaniques, IPGP-Paris VI, Paris, France
Villarricaisabasaltic-andesitestratovolcanolocatedintheSouthernChileanAndes.ItisoneofthemostactivevolcanoesinSouthAmericaassociatedwitheast-dippingsubductionoftheNazcaplatebeneaththeSouthAmericanplate.Althoughitshistoricaleruptiveactivityhasbeenmainlyeffusive,initshistoryVillarricavolcanohadalsoexplosivebehaviorproducingbothlargepyroclasticdensitycurrentsandtephrafallout.Thelargest-volumeeruptionsaretheLìcanIgnimbrite(~10Km3,~14,000BP)andPùconIgnimbrite(~5Km3,~3500BP)(Witteretal.,2004), bothofbasaltic-andesitecomposition.Themostre-
151
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
trycentpyroclasticdensitycurrentoccurred~1620BP(Morenoetal.,1994). Afterthelasteruption(1984-1985),Villarricavolca-
nohashadacontinuouspassivedegassingactivityfromthesummitlavalake(Witteretal.,2004). InthisprojectwehaveinvestigatedtheinitialconditionofVillarricamagmastoragereservoirandtheroleofdifferentvola-tilespeciesincontrollingtheeruptiondynamicsofChaimilladeposit(~3,100BP),whichisthebestpreservedandmostwi-delydispersedtephrafalloutofVillarricavolcano.Thisisdonebyadetailedpetrographicalandgeochemicalstudyofolivine-hostedmeltinclusionsandofallthephasespresentinthesystem(i.e.mineralsandglassmatrix).
ThepetrographicalandgeochemicalstudyhasbeencarriedoutattheUniversityofGenevaandLausanne(forEMPanalysis)withtheexceptionofH
2OandCO
2analysesofmeltinclusionswhichwasdoneattheLaboratoryPierreSùe(Paris,France)
usingbothFTIRandRAMANtechniques.
Ourpreliminaryresultsshowthatthemagmachemistrydidnotchangeduringtheevolutionoftheeruption(SiO2content
ofwholerockis~53wt%andSiO2contentofmeltinclusionvariesbetween52and56wt%)withexceptionoftheuppermost
falloutlayers,whichshowaslightlymoreprimitivecomposition(SiO2contentofwholerockis~52wt%andSiO
2contentof
meltinclusionis~51wt%).Pre-eruptiveH2Ocontentisrelativelyhigh(~2-3wt%)forabasalticmagma,butthishighcontent
has been frequently found in other high-explosive basaltic eruptions (e.g. Metrich et al.,2004; Spilliaert et al., 2006;Roggensacketal.,1997).InadditionChaimillameltinclusionsdonotcontainCO
2suggestingarelativelyshallowmagma
reservoir.
A B
FigA:meltinclusionpresentinolivine(SamplesfromChaimillascorias,Villarricavolcano,Chile).FigB:differentolivinecrystalsofChaimilladeposit.
REFERENCESMétrichN,AllardA,SpilliaertA,AndronicoD,BurtonM(2004).2001flankeruptionofthealkali--andvolatile-richprimitive
basaltresponsibleforMountEtna.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,228,1-17.MorenoH,ClaveroJ,LaraL.(1994).Actividadexplosivapost-glacialdelvolcanoVillarrica,AndesdelSur.Septimocongreso
geologicochileno.Universidaddeconcepcion.Conception,Chile,329-333.RoggensackK,Hervig RL,McKnight SB,Williams SN (1997). Explosive basaltic volcanism fromCerroNegro volcano:
Influenceofvolatilesoneruptivestyle.Science,277,1639-1642.SpilliaertN,Allard P,MetrichN, SobolevAV (2006).Melt inclusion record of the conditions of ascent, degassing and
extrusion of volatile-rich alkali basalt during the powerful 2002 flank eruption ofMount Etna (Italy). Journal ofGeophysicalResearch111:doi:10.1029/2005JB003934.
WitterJ.B,KressV.C,DelmelleP,StixJ(2004).Volatiledegassing,petrology,andmagmadynamicsoftheVillarricaLavaLake,SouthernChile.JournalofVolcanologyandGeothermalResearch,134,303-337.
152Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.34
An experimental study in the system Fe-Mg-Ti-Cr-Si-O±Al: ilmenite solid solution as a function of pressure and temperature
SemytkivskaNina*,UlmerPeter*
*Department of Earth Science. ETH Zurich, Clausiusstr.25, 8092 Zurich
WiththeaimofimprovingtheexperimentalbasisofthecalibrationinthesystemMg-Fe-Ti-Cr-Al-Si-O,wedoneexperimentalstudywithparticularattentiontopicro-ilmenite.Experimentswereperformedattemperatureof1000-1400
o
Candpressureof2.5,3.5,and5GPausingdifferentbulkcomposi-tionswithvariableMg/Fe,Cr/Alratios,andsilicaactivityunderrelativelyreducingconditionsbyemployinggraphitecon-tainerssealedintoPt-capsule.Experimentswereruninsolid-mediapistoncylindersandmulti-anvilapparatusfordurationsof30-120hours.Differentphaseparagenesiswasobservedatourexperimentalproducts.Bulkcompositionhasamarkedeffectonthephaseparagenesis,inparticular,stabilityofthephasesisinfluencedbytheMg#ofthesystem.Ilmeniteisstabletogetherwitholivine+orthopyroxene+spinelatbulkXMgof0.73(tab.1,2).rutile+olivine+opx+spinelarecoexistingphasesatabulkX
Mgof0.85.CompositionwithlowerSiO2contentsandlowXMgvaluesarecharacterizedbythepresenceofthreeoxides:
ilmenite+rutile+spinelcoexistingwitholivineandopx.CompositionswithhighXMg(0.85)andlowerSiO
2contentsresult
inthedisappearanceofopxandrutile;presentphasesareolivine+spinel+ilmenite.
TheexperimentaldatasetwasusedtodetermineequilibriumfractionationofFeandMgbetweencoexistingolandilm,andappliedtoformulatemodelforilmenitesolidsolutionandintendedtoprovideanewversionofilmenite-olivineanexchangegeothermometerthatcouldbeapplicabletotheCr-richassemblage.
3.35
Pyroxenite veins in the Jurassic Pindos Ophiolite (NW Greece): cm-scale mantle heterogeneity preserved in MORB-source peridotites
DmitryS.Sergeev*,**,ArjanH.Dijkstra*
*Université de Neuchâtel, Institut de Géologie et d’Hydrogéologie, Switzerland ([email protected])**Université de Lausanne, Institut de Minéralogie et Géochimie, Switzerland
Geochemicaland isotopicdifferencesbetweendifferent typesofMORBarecommonlyattributed toheterogeneity in themantlesource.Oneofthemajorfactorsthatcancausesuchheterogeneityisthepresenceofrecycledoceancrust.Webelie-ve that traces of suchheterogeneities can be preserved in pyroxenite veins in ophiolitic peridotite bodies. TheDramalaComplexinthePindosophiolite(NWGreece)isaperidotitebodywithamid-oceanridgecharacter,wherewefoundakm-sizedstructuraldomainwithcoarse-grainedmantletectonitesand1-10cmthickpyroxeniteveins.Pyroxenitesareconcor-danttothehightemperaturedeformationstructuresinthehostperidotitesandshowmetamorphic,replacivetexturesinthinsections.
WemeasuredHighlySiderophileElements(HSE,i.e.,Os,Ir,Ru,Pt,Pd,Re)andOsisotoperatiosinwholerockpyroxenitesandwall-rockperidotites.Pyroxeniteswerecarefullycut fromtheenclosingperidotites.HSEpatterns inbothcaseshaveidenticalcharacter; somesmalldifferences in incompatibleHSEconcentrations (Pt,Pd,Re)occurdue to thepresenceofsulphidesinpyroxenites.Peridotiteshavechondritictosubchondritic187Os/188Osratios(0.1196-0.1291),whereasthepyroxe-nitesareallsignificantlymoreradiogenic(187Os/188Os=0.1418-0.1980).Thesedifferencecannotsimplybeexplainedbydiffe-rencesinRe/Osratiosbetweenperidotitesandpyroxenites.Geochemicalandpetrographicdatashowthatconcordantpyro-xenitesrepresentsrelicsofreplacivepyroxenitesformedmelt-rockreactionbetweenpyroxene-saturatedmeltsandperido-tite.
Thefactthatpyroxenitelayersareparalleltothefoliationinhigh-temperaturedeformedperidotitetellsusabouttheirear-ly-stageorigin.BasedontexturesandHSEconcentrations,weproposethatpyroxenitesexposednowarereplaciveproducts
153
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryofSiO
2-richmelts,derivedfromthemeltingofoldmaficlayerswithintheperidotites,withveryradiogenic187Os/188Osisoto-
peratios,sincenoothersourceofhigh187Os/188Osisotoperatioislikelytoexistintheserocks.Moreoverwesuggestthatthemeltdidnotgenerallymigrateoverlargedistancesperpendiculartothepyroxenites,i.e.,thatthepyroxenitesareessential-lythewall-rockoftheoldmaficlayers.Ifourinterpretationiscorrect,thenthesearethefirsttracesofisotopicmantlehe-terogeneityinresidualMORB-sourcemantleobservedsofar.ThepresenceofpyroxeniteswithsuperchondriticOsisotoperatiosinthemantlecanexplainwhyestimatesfor187Os/188Osisotoperatiosofdepletedmantlerocksaregenerallysubchon-dritic.
3.36
The Zagros Collision Zone: Petrological and geodynamical constraints on Inner and Outer Zagros Ophiolitic Belt
HadiShafaiiMoghadam*,RobertJ.Stern**,MohamadRahgoshay***
*School of Earth Sciences, Damghan University of Basic Sciences, Damghan, Iran, E-mail: [email protected]** Geosciences Department, University of Texas at Dallas, Richardson, TX 75083-0688, USA***Faculty of Earth Sciences, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
DespitebroadaffinitiestootherophiolitesintheTethyanMediterranean-Omanophiolitebelt,theupperCretaceousophio-litesofSWIranremainrelativelyunknownintermsofgeochemistry,petrogenesisandtectono-magmaticevolution.Zagrosophiolitescomprisetwoparallelbelts, includingInnerZagrosOphioliticBelt (IB),alongtheSWperipheryoftheCentralIranianblockandOuterZagrosOphioliticBelt(OB),southofMainZagrosThrustFault.IBandOBophiolitesformedatthesametime:IBhornblendegabbrosyieldaK/Arageof93MawhereasOBdiabasesandhornblendegabbrosyieldAr/Aragesof86-93Ma,similartoagesofotherophiolitesoftheMediterranean-Omanbelt(Oman~95Ma,Cyprus~90-94Ma).PelagiclimestonesrestingconformablyonIBandOBophiolitesareTuronian-Maastrichtian(93.5-65.5Ma).SeverallinesofevidencesuchashighCrcontentofharzburgitespinelandflatREEpatternsofthelavaswithnegativeNb-TaanomaliesfrombothinnerandouterbeltZagrosophiolites indicate formationaboveasubductionzone,alsosimilar tootherTethyanOman-Mediterraneanophiolites.These similarities inophioliteagesand tectonic setting suggest that theOman-Mediterraneanophiolitebeltrepresentsaremarkablycoherentlithosphericblock.TheparallelalignmentofZagrosophiolitesbetweentheUrumieh-DokhtararcandtheZagrosfold-and-thrustbelt (accretionaryprism),furthersuggeststhatIBandOBophiolitesmaybeexposedlimbsofadeformedanticlinoria,andrepresentfore-arcbasement.Inthisinterpretation,IBandOBrepre-sentinnerandouterportionsoftheLateCretaceousIranianfore-arc,developedoveranincipientN-dippingsubductionzoneonthesouthernEurasianmargin.TheZagrosfold-and-thrustbestisanaccretionaryprismthatformedbyoff-scrapingofArabianPlatesediments,andtheUrumieh-DokhtararcisanAndean-typearcthatiswaningastheregiontransitionsfromsubductiontocollision.
3.37
The transition from cold-wet to hotter-drier rhyolites in subduction zones: the case of the Kos-Nisyros-Yali volcanic center, Aegean arc, Greece
SkopelitisAlexandra*,BachmannOlivier**
*Earth and environmental science, Rue des Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève, ([email protected])**University of Washington, Earth and Space Sciences Seattle, WA 98195-1310 ([email protected])
Thecomplexityofmagmaticchambermechanismsareextensivelystudiedbutnotcompletelyunderstood.Severalparame-ters,suchastemperature,pressure,meltcompositionandcristallinity,canmodifyrheology,geochemistry,andgeometryofthechamberandthereforehaveanimportantinfluenceonthetypeandstyleoferuption.Magmaviscosityisstronglylinkedwithwatercontent,crystalcontentandtemperature.
154Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y
Twokindsofrhyoliteshavebeendefinedintheliterature(Christiansen2005):thefirstkindiscold(<750°C)andoxidized(NNO+1)whereasthesecondkindishotter(≥850°C)andmorereduced(~NNOorlower).Althoughbothareatornearvolatilesaturationinshallowcrustalmagmachambers,thecold-oxidizedtypeisobviouslymorewater-rich,asitcontainsbiotiteandlackspyroxene.Thewettypeisusuallyfoundinsubductionzonesettings,whereasthedriertypeismorecharacteristicofhotspotandextensionalenvironmentswheremantlemeltingoccursbyadiabaticdecompression.
ThepresentstudyshowsthatbothtypesofrhyolitescanbefoundinthesamelocalityintheAegeanArcinGreece(Fig.1).Wecomparedrhyoliticpumicesof theKosPlateauTuff (KPTeruptionage:160ky, (Smithetal.1996)) fromKos IslandtoNisyrosandYali,twosouthernmostislands.Therockschemistryshowsevolvedcompositionswithanaveragearound70%wtSiO
2forNisyrosand75-76%wtSiO
2forKPTandYali.
Thecaldera-formingKPTeruptedfromashallow(1.5-2.5kb)near-solidus(~670-700°C)andoxidized(NNO+1)magmacham-berthatwassaturatedwithawater-richgasphase.ThefollowingeruptionsfromNisyrosandYaliwereincontrast,100-150°C hotter, less oxidized (~NNO) andmainly contained plagioclase and clinopyroxene (although Yali does containminorquartzandsanidineaswell).Thereasonforthisshiftfromwettodrierrhyolitescanbeduetoeither(1)achangeinparentalbasaltcomposition(drierbasaltsleadingtodrierrhyolites)or(2)anefficientdegassingeventinducedbythecaldera-formingevent.Morestudies, includingexperimentworktoreconstructthetemperature-pressureconditionsbeforeeruptions,areneededtobetterunderstandwhichscenariocontributedtotheobservedshiftintheserhyolites.
Figure1.SimplifiedmapofKos,NisyrosandYali.(ModifiedafterAllen,2001)
REFERENCESAllen,S.R.2001:Reconstructionofamajorcaldera-formingeruptionfrompyroclasticdepositcharacteristics:KosPlateau
Tuff,easternAegeanSea.JournalofVolcanologyandGeothermalResearch105,141-162.Christiansen,E.-H.2005:Contrastingprocesses insilicicmagmachambers;evidence fromvery largevolumeignimbrites.
GeologicalMagazine142(6),669-981.Seymour,K.S.&Lalonde,A.1991:Monitoringoxygenfugacityconditionsinpre,syn-andpostcalderamagmachamberof
Nisyrosvolcano,Aegeanislandarc,Greece.JournalofVolcanologyandGeothermalResearch46,231-240.Smith,P.E.,York,D.,Chen,Y.&Evensen,N.M.1996:Singlecrystal40Ar/39ArdatingofaLateQuaternaryparoxysmonKos,
Greece:Concordanceofterrestrialandmarineages.GeophysicalResearchLetters23,3047-3050.Volentik,A.,Vanderkluysen, L., Principe,C.&Hunziker, J.C. 2005: StratigraphyofNisyros volcano (Greece). Thegeology,
geochemistryandevolutionofNisyrosVolcano (Greece). Implications for thevolcanichazards.MémoiresdeGéologie(Lausanne),26-66.
155
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.38
Dynamics of Cd, Pb and Cu cycling in a stream under contrasting photo-benthic biofilm activity and hydrological conditions
Tercier-WaeberMary-Lou*,**,HezardTeddy*&MassonMatthieu**
*CABE – Department of Inorganic, Analytical and Applied Chemistry, University of Geneva, Sciences II, 30 Quai E.-Ansermet, CH-1211 Geneva 4 ([email protected])**Institut F.-A. Forel, University of Geneva, 10 Route de Suisse, CH-1290 Versoix
Thepastdecadestudiesperformedinriversandstreamsdemonstratedthatmanytracemetalandmetalloidexperiencedi-urnalcycles,withtotaldissolvedmetalconcentrationsoftenchangingone-tofive-foldduringa24hperiod.However,mostofthesestudieswereperformedinsummerunderlow-flowconditions.Moreover,sampleswerecollectedhourlybyhandforlaterlaboratoryanalysis.Thislaborioussamplecollectionandprocessingapproachlimitshourlysamplingto1–3daysatmaximum.Morefrequentanalysisisrequiredtounderstandtheseasonaloccurrenceandamplitudeofdielmetalcycles,andtheprocessescontrollingthesecycles.
Withthisgoalinmind,weappliedanautomatedvoltammetricanalyzertostudy,attimescaleofhourandundercontrast-ingbio-chemicalandhydrologicalconditions, thediurnalevolutionofCd,CuandPb intheRiou-Mortriver (France) im-pactedbypolymetallicpollutionresultingfromformeropen-castcoalminingandoretreatment.Thisanalyzerisbasedonabioanalogicmicrosensorwhichallowsinsitureal-timemonitoringofthedynamicfraction,i.e.thepotentiallybioavailablefraction,ofthetargetanalytes.Inparallel,T,pH,dissolvedoxygenandconductivityweremonitoredinsituandwatersam-pleswerecollectedforcomplementaryanalysesofthewatercomposition.
Severaloriginalresultswereobtained.Thedatarevealedthat,inthestudiedriver,thediurnalcyclesoftheCd,CuandPbdynamicspecieswerecontrolledbyredoxandsorptioneffectsinducedbyeither:pHdiurnalcyclelinkedtometabolicactiv-ity of benthicbiofilms; photoreductionof colloidalMnoxides; and/orbiofilmexudationof extracellularpolymeric sub-stances.Wealsoobservedthat:thedynamicfractionofagivencationicmetalcanshowdiurnalcyclewithoppositetrendsdependingonthebio-chemicalconditions; thetrendsof thediurnaldynamicmetalspeciescyclesmaybedifferentthatthosereportedforthedissolvedmetalspecies.Theimportanceofthesefindingswillbediscussedinthecontextofinterpret-ingexistingdatabanks,assessingmetalecotoxicityimpact,anddesigningmoreappropriatemonitoringcontrolstrategies.
REFERENCESTercier-Waeber,M.-L.&Taillefert,M. 2008:Remote in situ voltammetric techniques to characterize thebiogeochemical
cyclingoftracemetalsinaquaticsystems.J.Environ.Monit.,10,30-54.Tercier-Waeber,M.-L.,Hezard,T.,Masson,M.,&SchäferJ.2009:Insitumonioringofthediurnalcyclingofdynamicmetal
species ina streamunder contrasting photobenthicbiofilmactivity andhydrological conditions,Env. Sci. Technol.,DOI:10.1021/es900247y.
3.39
LAMBERN – software for U-Pb, Th-Pb and Pb-Pb age dating by LA-ICP-MS analysis
ThomsenTonnyB.*,PettkeThomas*,AllazJulien*’**&EngiMartin*
* University of Bern, Institute of Geological Sciences, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, CH-3012. ([email protected])** University of Massachusetts Amherst, Department of Geosciences, 611 North Pleasant Street, USA
ForU-Pb,Th-PbandPb-Pbagedating,theLA-ICP-MSoffersacostreducingandtimeefficienttechniquecomparedtoe.g.TIMSandSIMS,bywhichabulkofdatawithamoderateprecision(typically<2%)canbeobtainedinaveryshorttime(e.g.50-100agesin1-2days).Tocomparetheobtaineddata,standardizedprotocolsacceptedbytheLA-ICP-MSagedatingcommunityandassociatedsoftwareabletohandleandcalculateagesfromthevarioussolidphasesarerequired.Atpresent,littlesoft-
156Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y wareisavailable(e.g.LAMTRACE,GLITTER,Lamdate,PEPITA,ComPbCorr,PbI;summarizedinKoЄler&Sylvester,2003andKošleretal.,2008).SomeoftheseassumenoinitialPbpresent(LAMTRACE,GLITTER),however,somegeologicallyrelevantminerals such as allanite, titanite, rutile andperovskitemay contain a significantproportionof commonPb.Other ap-proachesrelyonanebulization-inducedspikebracketingtechnique(Lamdate),anapproachthatisnotemployedinalllabo-ratories.Thus,wepresenthereatransparent,step-by-stepExcel-baseddatareductionprocedureforin-situsolidstateU-Th-Pb-basedagedeterminationsbyLA-ICP-MS.Thesoftware(calledLAMBERN)isabletohandleallsolidphaseswithsufficientU,ThandPbcontentforagedatingbyLA-ICP-MS,includingphaseswithasignificantcommonPbproportion.Thesoftwareoffersfullcontrolinallstepsoftheconsecutiveandflexibledatareductionapproach(includesseveraloptionsfordatacorrectionandagecalculationprocedure).Alldatatreatment,agecalculationanderrorpropagationarecarriedoutinasingleExcelfile.Variousdiagrams,includingtime-intensity,time-ratio,sensitivity,ablationyield,Concordia,Tera-Wasserburgaregenerated.TheoutputcanbereaddirectlybyIsoPlotEx(Ludwig,2003)foradditionalplottingandcalculations.LAMBERNemploysastandard-sample-standardbracketingapproachwithamaximumof20individualanalysesimportedthroughanintegratedVBAmacroofxl,txtorcsvfiles(fromElan,ThermoFinniganElement2orThermoX).Timeintervalsforbackgroundandsignalareselectedbytheuser.Screeningofthesignalsforextremevalues(technicallyinduced“outli-ers”)andforsignalsofpoorquality(e.g.fromtime-dependantfractionation)iscarriedoutthroughtime-intensityandtime-ratiodiagramsandincludesanoptionfortherejectionofdatafromatoleratedrelativestandarddeviation(Є)specifiedbytheuser.Therejectionofdataincludesentiresweeps.Optionsforthedatacorrectionisspecifiedinthesetupparameterssectionandincludebackgroundcorrection,mercuryinterferencecorrection(of204Hgon204Pb),correctionforinstrumentalmassbias(Linear,PowerandExponentialLaws,RussellandBaxterformulations),detectordriftand3differentcommonPbcorrectionroutines(measured204andthe“207Pb”and“208Pb”corrections).Matrixeffectscalibrationcanbeappliedifrequired.Selectionisdonebetween(i)non-matchedmatrixbasedone.g.NISTSRM-610glassor(ii)matrixmatchingemployingoneormore(in-house)referencematerialsofknownage(e.g.Harvard91500zirconforanalysisofzirconsofunknownage).Atpresent,therobustnessofthescreeningandcalculationproceduresinLAMBERNarebeingtestedthroughanalysesofstandard zircons (91500zircon, Temora-1, Plesovice), allanites (AVC, CAP, Tara, Daibosatsu, Bona, Sissonne), titanite andmonazite(in-housestandards).Ingeneral,theaccuracyofnon-matrixmatchedcalibrationroutinesforzircon,allaniteandinparttitanitereportupto30%deviationfrom“true”ages(e.g.TIMS,SIMS).Thus,matrix-matchedcalibrationisemployed.Atthetimeofreporting,LAMBERNhasbeeninusebyonlyahandfuloftest-users,thusisa“beta”version.
REFERENCESKošlerJ.,ForstL.&SlámaJ.(2008)LamDateandLamTool:spreadsheet-baseddatareduc-tionforlaserablationICP–MS315.
InSylvesterP.(ad)LaserAblation–ICP–MSintheEarthSciences,CurrentPracticesandoutstandingissues,AppendixA4:SoftwareforReductionofLA–ICP–MSData.MACShortCourseSeries40,305-306.
Košler, J.&Sylvester,P.2003.Presenttrendsandthefutureofzirconingeochronology: la-serablationICPMS.ReviewsinMineralogy&Geochemistry,53,243-275.
Ludwig,K.R.(2003)IsoplotExv.3.0.BerkeleyGeochronologicalCenter.
3.40
First insights into the dehydration of lizardite
TrittschackRoy&GrobétyBernard
University of Fribourg, Department of Geosciences, Chemin du Musée 6, CH-1700 Fribourg ([email protected])
LizarditeMg3Si
2O
5(OH)
4 isa trioctahedral1:1phyllosilicate,whichbelongs togetherwithchrysotileandantigorite to the
serpentinemineralgroup.Thestructureoflizardite,basedonsimpleflatlyingT-O,ismuchsimplercomparedtothecor-rugatedandcylindricalstructuresofantigoriteandchrysotilerespectively.Lizarditeis,therefore,thelogicstartingpointinanattempttounderstandthedehydrationprocessesandratesofthismineralgroup.Theaimofthisstudyistounderstandtheratedeterminingstepsandthekineticsofthedehydrationoflizardite.Thedehy-drationimpliesthedeprotonationofpartofthehydroxylgroupsandrecombinationofthehydrogenionwithneighbouringhydroxylgroupstoformawatermolecule.Thesecondstepisthetransportofthewatermoleculeouttothesurface.High-temperature experiments like in-situ HT-XRD and in-situ IR spectroscopy are ideally suited to investigate the structuralchangesduringthereaction.ExploratoryIRexperimentsandXRDstudiesonlizarditeunderroomconditionsgavestartingtemperaturesforthedehydrationbetween500°Cand550°CwhichliesintherangeofformerinvestigationsbyBrindley&Zussman(1957)andFranketal.(2005).Theinitialproductofdehydrationisamorphous,whichcrystallizesafteracertaintime
157
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
trytoforsteritefollowedbyenstatite.Assumingproportionalitybetweentheintegralintensityofhkl-peaksandtheamountof
lizarditepresent, thereactionratecanbeextracted fromtherateof intensitydecrease.Thedatawillbe treatedwiththeconventionalAvramimethodaswellasthesocalled“timetoagivenfraction”(TGF)method.OnemajoradvantageoftheTGFmethod is thepossibility todiscover changes in theactivationenergyE
aduring the courseofdehydration (Putnis, 1992).
Knownvaluesfortheactivationenergyoflizarditederivedfromdifferentialthermalanalyses(DTA)andlyingaround350kJmol-1(Weber&Greer,1965),whichisratherlargecomparedwithotherphyllosilicateswithvaluesaround200kJmol-1.
REFERENCESBrindley,G.W.&Zussman, J.1957:Astructural studyof the thermal transformationof serpentineminerals to forsterite.
AmericanMineralogist,Vol.42(7-8),461-474.Frank,M.R.,Earnest,D.J.,Candela,P.A.,Wylie,A.G.,Wilmot,M.S.&Maglio,S.J.2005(abstract):Experimentalstudyofthe
thermaldecompositionoflizarditeupto973K,SaltLakeCityAnnualMeeting2005Putnis,A.1992:IntroductiontoMineralSciences,CampridgeUniversityPress,457p.Weber,J.N.&Greer,R.T.1965:Dehydrationofserpentine-HeatofreactionandreactionkineticsatPH2O=1Atm.American
Mineralogist,Vol.50(3-4),450-464.
3.41
Analytical and numerical description of tephra deposition: the example of two large explosive eruptions of Cotopaxi Volcano, Ecuador
TsunematsuKae*,BonadonnaCostanza*,FalconeJean-Luc**&ChopardBastien**
*Départment de Minéralogie, Université de Genève, Rue de Maraîchaire 13, CH-1205 Genève** Départment d’Informatique, Université de Genève, Battelle, Building A, Carouge; 7 route de Drize, CH-1227 Carouge
ThedownwindandcrosswindtephradepositionwasstudiedindetailfortwolargeexplosiveeruptionsofCotopaxivolcano,Ecuador(apumiceousunit,Layer3,andascoriaceousunit,Layer5;Barberietal.1995).Thetwoeruptionswerecharacterizedbyasimilarplumeheight,i.e.28±2kmforLayer3and28±0kmforLayer5,butLayer3wascharacterizedbyalargervolu-me,i.e.1.5km3forLayer3and0.3km3forLayer5(BiassandBonadonna,submitted).Thetwolayersarecharacterizedbysi-milartotalgrainsizedistribution(MdΦ:~-2),butLayer3tephrawasadvectedbyastrongerwind(28m/sforLayer3and21m/sforLayer5).Asaresult,crosswindvariationofgrainsizeisconsistentforthetwolayers,butatanygivendistancefromventdownwinddepositioniscoarserforLayer3(Figure1).TheincreaserateofMdΦisabout0.2forbothlayers(Figure1a).
WehaveimplementedboththemodelofBonadonnaandPhillips(2003)fortephradispersalfromstrongvolcanicplumesandtheCellularAutomatamodelofTsunematsuetal.(2008)todescribecrosswindtephradepositionbasedonaGaussiandistribution.Inaddition,wehavealsoimplementedthemodelofTsunematsuetal.(2008)toaccountforsedimentationfromthebottomoftheumbrellacloudassupposedtoapoint-sourceparticleconsideringthefollowingequation(BonadonnaandPhillips2003):
−= ∫x
xdx
Qvw
MM0
exp0
(1)
whereM (kg)isthetotalmassofparticlesofagivensizefractionatthebottomofthespreadingcurrent,M0(kg)istheiniti-
almassinjectedintothespreadingcurrent,Qisthevolumetricflowrate,vistheterminalvelocityoftheparticleofgivengrainsize,w isthemaximumcrosswindwidthandx isthedistancefromtheplume.BoththemodelofBonadonnaandPhillips(2003)andTsunematsuetal.(2008)hadshowngoodagreementwithtephradepositionobservedalongthedispersalaxisforanumberoferuptions.However,thecrosswinddepositionhadnotbeeninvestigatedindetail.
158Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y
(a) (b)
Figure1.Medianofgrainsizedistributionalongdownwindaxes(a)andcrosswindaxes(b).PinktrianglesaredataforLayer3andblue
squaresaredataforLayer5.Forthedownwinddata,linearregressionsarecalculatedforeachlayer.PinklineisforLayer3andblueline
isforLayer5.
REFERENCESBarberi,F.,Coltelli,M.,Frullani,A.,RosiM.,&Almeida,E.1995:Chronologyanddispersalcharacteristicsofrecently (last
5000years)eruptedtephraofCotopaxi(Ecuador):implicationsforlong-termeruptiveforecasting.JVGR,69,217-239.BiassS.&BonadonnaC.,(inpreparation)Aquantitativeuncertaintyassessmentoferuptiveparametersderivedfromtephra
deposits.Bonadonna C. & Phillips J. C. 2003: Sedimentation from strong volcanic plumes. JGR. 108. B7, 2340, doi:10.1029/
2002JB002034.TsunematsuK, Falcone JL, BonadonnaC&Chopard B. 2008: Applying aCellularAutomataMethod for the Study of
TransportandDepositionofVolcanicParticlesH.LectureNotesinComputerScience(LNCS).vol.5191,393-400.
3.42
Petrology of mafic-ultramafic complexes within the Archean Lewisian complex of NW Scotland
UdryArya*,MüntenerOthmar*,
* Institute of Mineralogy and Geochemistry, University of Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
TheLewisiancomplexisafragmentoftheancientLaurentiancontinentalmass,thesouthernextension,whichisnowbur-iedbeneaththemetasedimentsoftheScottishhighlands.TheArcheangneissesoftheLewisiancomplexrepresentalong,andcomplexpartofEarthhistory.TheareaofinterestisinNorthwesternScotland,betweenLochLaxfordandLochInver.Theterrainconsistsmostlyofbandedgneisseswithavarietyofbasictoultrabasicbodies.Thegneissesarebandedwithalternatingacidandmaficlayers.Granulitefaciesparagenesesarecommon.Largebodiesofultrabasicrockscontainvariableproportionsofolivine,pyroxene,spinel,plagioclaseandhornblende,whereasbasicbodiesareessentiallymadeofpyroxene,hornblende,plagioclaseandgarnetbear-ingassemblages.ThisstudyfocusesontwoofthesecomplexesnearDrumbegandnearScourie.Thesebodiesaredescribedaslayered‘meta’intrusivesandareembeddedwithintonalitictogranodioriticgneisses.Isotopicstudiesindicatethatthegneissesderivedfrommagmasthatseparatedfromthemantleabout2.9Ga(Moorbathandal.1969;Hamiltonandal.1979)andthehighgrademetamorphismwascompletedbyabout2.7Ga(ChapmanandMoorbath1977).Laterdikes(Scouriedikes)aredatedat2.4Ga(Chapman1979),followedbyretrogradeamphibolitefaciesmetamor-phismandinjectionofgranitesandpegmatitesatabout1.8Ga.(JohnstoneandMykura1989).Severalhypotheseshavebeenputforwardabouttheformationofthoseultramaficandmaficbodies,butithasbeendemons-tratedthatvoluminousgranodioriteandtonalitesurroundingrocksareofcalc-alkalineaffinity,whichisgenerallyinferredto be important in subduction zone environments. After Park and Tarney (1987), gneisses represents continental crustformedduringsubductionandthemafic-ultramaficassociationrepresentsmaterial intercalatedtectonicallyduringpro-cessesofcrustalgeneration,probablyfromsubductingoceanfloor.Thisinterpretationmightbedebated.Weevaluatethehypothesiswhether such rockassociations couldbe related to crystallization fromH
2O-richmagmaswithinanArchean
159
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
trysubductionzoneenvironment,oralternatively,whethertheycouldberelatedtometamorphoseddryplutonicrockswithin
theArcheancrust,byapplyingnewmappingandsystematicallyinvestigatingmineralchemicalmajorandtraceelementdata.Itisentirelyunknown,whetherprimaryigneousphasesarestillpresent(e.g.Sillsetal.1982)andapparentgranulitefacies“metamorphic”texturesmasktheigneouscrystallisationhistoryofthishighpressurerocks.However,withtheapplicationofnewin-situmethodssuchasLaserAblationICP-MS,newresultsonthemainmineralsandwholerockswereobtained.Inaddition,wewilldeterminein-situthemajorandtraceelementdistributionofthemajormineralphasesthatshouldprovi-deadditionalconstraintsontheequilibrationhistoryoftheserocks.Wefocusonelementsdistributionsandgarnetszona-tionsandtrytoevaluateamagmaticvsmetamorphicorigin.Wepresentpreliminary resultson the thermalevolutionofmafic-ultramafic systemswithingranulite facieshost rocks.TestingthehypothesisofanarcoriginisnotonlyanimportantquestionforabetterunderstandingoftheArcheanLewisiancomplex,butmuchmoresofortheimportancehowsubductionprocessesworkedintheArchean.
REFERENCESChapman,H.J.(1979):2390M.yrRb-SrwholerockisochronfortheScouriedykesofNWScotland.Nature,277,642ChapmanH.J.,MoorbathS.(1977):LeadisotopemeasurementsfromtheoldestrecognizedLewisiangneissesofnorth-west
Scotland.Nature,268,41-42HamiltonP.J., EvensenN.M.,O’NionsR.K., Tarney J. (1979): Sm-Nd systematicsof Lewisiangneisses : implications for the
originofgranulites.Nature,277,25-28Johnstone,G.S. andMykura,W. (1989):British regionalgeology: thenorthernHighlandsof Scotland (4th edition). British
GeologicalSurvey,pp219Moorbath S.,WelkeH.,GaleN.H. (1969): The significance of lead isotope studies in ancient, highgrademetamorphic
basementcomplexes,asexemplifiedbytheLewisianrocksofNorthwestScotland.EarthPlanetSciLett,6,245-256Park,R.G.andTarney,J.(1987):TheLewisiancomplex:atypicalPrecambrianhigh-gradeterrain?EvolutionoftheLewisian
andcomparablePrecambrianhighgradeterrains,GeologicalSocietyPublication,27,13-25Sills,J.D.,Savage,D.,Watson,J.V.,andWindley,B.F.(1982):Layeredultramafic-gabbrobodiesintheLewisianofnorthwest
Scotland:geochemistryandpetrogenesis.EarthandPlanetaryScienceLetters,58,345-360
3.43
Iridium-strip heater glass pellets: Effects of fusion temperature and time on Li, Be and B content
VilsFlurin*,DijkstraArjan*,LaurePelletier*,ThomasLudwig**&AngelikaKalt*
*Institut de Géologie et d’Hyrogéologie, Rue Emile-Argand 11, Cp158, 2009-Neuchâtel (f [email protected])**Institut für Geowissenschaften, Im Neuenheimer Feld 236, D-69120 Heidelberg
Tosolveabroadrangeofgeochemicalproblems,preciseandaccuratewholerockandtraceelementanalysesarerequired.EspeciallyinthecaseoflowabundantelementslikeLi,BeandB,whicharewidelyusedastracersofalteration,subductionandrecyclingprocessesintheEarth,thisisacriticalissue.Forin-situmineralmeasurementsoftheseelements,secondaryionmassspectrometry(SIMS)isprobablythemostsensitiveandmostaccurate.AmethodthatallowstoanalysewholerocklightelementconcentrationsusingSIMSwouldbeextremelypowerfulandwoulddramaticallyincreasesamplethroughput.However,amethodtomeasurewholerockcontentsofallthreelightelementstogetherismissingsofar.AnIridium-stripheaterprovidesafluxfreemethodtofusedirectlyhomogeneousglasspelletsfrompowderedrocks.Thesepelletscanbe investigatedformajorandlightelementsusingmicrobeam(electron, ionor laser)methods.Wehavecon-ductedexperimentsunderdifferentfusiontemperatures(1500-1800°C)andtime(30-240s)onselectedsamplesrepresentingawidevarietyofLi(0.91to56.5µg/g),Be(0.24to3.5µg/g)andBcontent(2.18to12µg/g).Westudiedthebehaviourofthethreeelementswithrespecttothedifferentcompositions,fusiontimeandtemperature.Homogeneitywithinthefusedglassesisgenerallyreachedunderthestudiedconditionsformostelements.Electronmicro-probemeasuresandelementdistributionmapsconfirmthishomogeneity.Lightelementmeasurementsshowedhomogene-ous behaviour for Li and Be (RSD of 3%, 6% respectively), but B is significantly less homogeneous (average RSD of 31%).HeatingtimedependentlossofLi,BeandBoccursthroughoutallstudiedsamples,butBeandLilossisalwayswithinana-lytical errorsof theusedmethods (generally <10%). SignificantB lossduring fusion is found inalmost every sample. Ingeneral,Bisshowinghighlyvolatilebehaviour,andat1800°CmostBhasevaporated.Clearly,flux-lesspreparationofwholerockglassesisnotaviablemethodforBanalysisbecauseofitsvolatility,butthemethodiswell-suitedforLiandBe.
160Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y 3.44
Molybdenum isotopes in modern corals: investigation into their potential as redox proxy of bygone oceans
Voegelin,AndreaR.*,Samankassou,Elias*&Nägler,ThomasF.**
* Départment de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Genève, Rue des Maraîchaire 13, CH-1205 Genève ([email protected])**InstitutfürGeologie,UniversitätBern,Baltzerstrasse1+3,CH-3012Bern
PeriodsofmarineO2deficiencyareimportantfeaturesofEarthhistory,inparticularforclimateandtheevolutionoflife.
Theoxygenationstateofpaleo-environmentsiscloselyconnectedtothecyclingofredoxsensitiveelements.Hence,thein-terpretationofpastchangesinoceanicredoxchemistrydependsontheidentificationofgeochemicalproxieswhichprovideareliablefingerprintofpastseawatercompositions.
Inrecentyearsthemolybdenumisotopesystemhasattractedsignificantattentionandhasproventobeusefulintheinve-stigationoftheextentofsea-flooranoxiainthegeologicalpast(e.g.Arnoldetal.,2004,Willeetal.,2008,Pearceetal.,2008).CarbonaterockshavejustrecentlybeenintroducedaspromisingnewMoisotopearchive(Voegelinetal.,2009).ItwasshownthatMouptakeintonon-skeletalcarbonateprecipitatesisaccompaniedbyminorisotopefractionation.Consequently,theywereproposedasamonitoroftheambientfluidcomposition,which,underfavorableconditions,maycloselyreflecttheoceanwaterδ98/95Moofbygoneoceans.Theapplicationofskeletalcarbonateiscomplicatedbybiologicallycontrolledisotopefractionation,whichmaycompletelyobliteratetheoriginaloceanwatersignature(Voegelin,2009).Sofar,onlywellpreser-vedmodernaragoniticcoralshaverevealedtoexhibitaconsistentlysmalloffsetfromseawater.TheymaythusprovidethemeanstoobtainawelldatedandnearlycontinuousreconstructionoftheMoisotopiccompositionofpastoceansfromtheHoloceneasfarbackasOrdoviciantimes.Theirapplicationaspaleo-oceanographictool,however,dependsonthepreserva-tionofanoceanwatersignatureduringdiageneticprocesses,especiallythereplacementofmeta-stableskeletalaragonitewithcalcite.
Thisstudyinvestigatesunalteredcoralmatricesanddiageneticallymodifiedmaterialinordertoassesspossiblepost-depo-sitionalMoisotopeandtraceelementexchangeprocessesandtheirimplicationsforthefutureuseofcoralsasMoarchive.
REFERENCESArnold,G. L.,Anbar,A.D.,Barling, J.& Lyons,T.W,2004:Molybdenum isotopeevidence forwidespreadanoxia inmid-
Proterozoicoceans.Science,304,87-90.Pearce,C.R.,Cohen,A.S.,Coe,A.L.&Burton,K.W.,2008:Molybdenumisotopeevidenceforglobaloceananoxiacoupled
withperturbationstothecarboncycleduringtheearlyJurassic.Geology,26(3),231-234.Voegelin,A. R.,Nägler, T. F., Samankassou, E.& Villa, I.M., 2009:Molybdenum isotopic composition ofmodern and
Carboniferouscarbonates.ChemicalGeology,265,488-498.Wille,M.,Nägler,T.F.,Lehmann,B.,Schröder,S.&Kramers,J.D.,2008:Hydrogensuphidereleasetosurfacewaterstthe
Precambrian/Cambrianboundary.Nature,453,767-7.
3.45
Effect of minor elements (H+ and Al3+) on the elastic properties of ortho-pyroxenes
JingyunWang*,CarmenSanchez-Valle*&RolandStalder**
* ETH, Inst Mineral & Petrol, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])** Innsbruck Univ, Inst Mineral & Petrog, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria
Orthopyroxenes (Opx), along with olivine, garnets and clinopyroxenes, are major components of the upper mantle.KnowledgeofthechangesinseismicvelocitiesandelasticpropertiesofOpxasafunctionofcompositionisthereforeessen-tialtobuildupmineralogicalmodelsoftheuppermantleandtointerpretheterogeneitiesinthemantlerevealedbyhigh-
161
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
tryresolutionseismictomographicimages.WhiletheelasticpropertiesofMg-andFe-end-membershavereceivedmuchatten-
tionoverthepastyears,theinfluenceofminorelementsubstitutionsontheelasticpropertiesoforthopyroxeneshasbeenlessinvestigated.
HerewepresentBrillouinscatteringmeasurementsofthesingle-crystalelasticpropertiesofsynthetichydrousaluminum-freeandhydrousaluminum-bearingorthopyroxenes(hereafterreferredtoasHyOpxandAlOpx,respectively)underambientconditions. The samples were synthesized at 2.5 GPa and 1150 °C in piston-cylinder apparatus. HyOpx contains minoramountsofH+(280ppmH
2O)whileAlOpxhasasimilarAl
2O
3content(6.3wt%)tothatofnaturalOpx,andminoramounts
ofH+(1500ppmH2O),andFe(0.26wt%FeO).Theaggregatebulk(K
S)andshear(µ)elasticmoduliofHyOpx,K
S=108.5(9)GPa
andµ=77.0(4)GPa,areindistinguishablefromthoseofanhydrousorthoenstatite.TheresultssuggestthatincorporationofH
2Oupto280ppmhasnosignificantinfluenceonelasticpropertiesofMgSiO
3-orthoenstatite.Theaggregateelasticmoduli
ofAlOpx,KS=126.2(1.2)GPaandµ=81.3(8)GPa,arerespectively14.7and6%higherthanthoseofpureMgSiO
3-orthoenstatite.
TheseresultsconfirmthatthestiffeningofthebulkmodulusreportedinnaturalOpxrelativetoMg-end-membersismain-lyduetothesubstitutionofAlforsmallerSiintetrahedralsites.ThisconclusionissupportedbythestrongincreaseintheC
33 elastic constant upon Al substitution that reflects the stiffening of the tetrahedral chains running along c-axis.
Consequently,theaggregatevelocitiesofAlOpx,VP=8.50(9)km/sandV
S=5.01(6)km/s,are7%and4%higherthanthoseof
themagnesianend-member.TheresultsindicatethatAlhasthestrongesteffectontheseismicvelocitiesofOpxofallminorelementsandmaybetakenintoaccounttorefinecompositionalandmineralogicalmodelsoftheuppermantle.
3.46
Deciphering the Alpine orogenic and thermal evolution from subduction to collision: Raman spectroscopy and 40Ar/39Ar age constraints from the Valaisan Ocean (Central Alps)
WiederkehrMichael*,BousquetRomain**,SudoMasafumi**,ZiemannMartinA.**,BergerAlfons***&SchmidStefanM.****
*Bundesamt für Landestopografie swisstopo, Landesgeologie, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern, Switzerland([email protected])**InstitutfürGeowissenschaften,UniversitätPotsdam,Karl-Liebknecht-Strasse24/25,D-14476Potsdam/Golm,Germany***InstitutforGeografiogGeologi,KøbenhavnsUniversitet,ØsterVoldgade10,DK-1350KøbenhavnK,Denmark****InstitutfürGeologischeWissenschaften,FreieUniversität,Malteserstrasse74-100,D-12249Berlin,Germany
ThemetasedimentsoftheValaisanOceanandtheadjacentdistalEuropeanmargin,exposedbetweenthePizzoMolare/Passodi Lucomagnoareaand thePrättigauhalf-windowshowa remarkablemetamorphicgradient:Carpholitebearingassem-blagesintheeastindicatepressuredominatedblueschistfaciesmetamorphism.Furtherwestthesameunitsarecharacteri-zedbyatemperaturedominatedBarrovianamphibolitefaciesmetamorphism(“Lepontine”metamorphism).Therelation-ships between deformation and metamorphism indicate two distinct metamorphic events: a late-stage Barrowian(“Lepontine”) event clearly overprints an earlier HP/LT event. This is independently confirmed by a bimodal P-T path(Wiederkehretal.,2008).Tounravelthispoly-metamorphicevolutionweperformeddetailedinvestigationsofcarbonaceousmatterbyRamanspectroscopyinordertomonitorthespatialdistributionofpeak-metamorphictemperatures.Additionally,weperformed40Ar/39Ardatingofmicabyusingin-situandstep-wise-heatingtechniquesinordertodecipherthetemporalrelationshipsbetweenthesetwometamorphicevents.Thenewdatayieldimportantinsightregardingthetransitionfromsubductiontocollision,bothonthescaleofthetectonicunitsderivedfromtheValaisanpaleogeographicaldomainandonthescaleoftheentireorogenicbelt.
TheresultsofRamanspectroscopy,performedonatotalof214samples,allowforhighresolutionmappingofthemaximummetamorphictemperaturesreachedinthesesamplesinthreedimensions.Suchthree-dimensionalmappingoftheisotem-peraturecontours inmapandprofileviewfaithfullyreflects thepresent-daydistributionofpeak-metamorphic tempera-tures.Thetemperaturegradientsresultedfromasuperpositionofatleastthreedistinctmetamorphicevents(Wiederkehretal.,submitted).(1)WithinthenortheasternrimoftheLepontinedome-bothalongandacrossstrike-theisotemperaturecontoursinthe450-570°Ctemperatureintervalareassociatedwiththecollision-relatedlate-stageBarrow-typeevent.Theyclearlycutacrossnappecontactsandmega-foldsdeformingsucholdertectoniccontacts.(2)FurthertotheNEthe350-425°Cisotemperaturecontoursreflecttemperaturesreachedduringanearlierblueschistfacieseventand/orsubsequentnear-isothermal decompression. They are folded by large-scale post-nappe stackingmega-folds. (3) A substantial “temperaturejump”acrossthetectoniccontactbetweenthefrontalAdulanappecomplex(500-520°C)andthesurroundingValaisan-de-
162Sy
mp
osi
um
3:
Min
era
log
y-P
etr
olo
gy-
Ge
och
em
istr
y rivedmetasediments(410-430°C)indicatesthat,incontrasttothepostulatesraisedbyearlierstudies,equilibrationoftem-peraturesduringthelate-stageLepontineeventisincompleteinthisarea.
The dating of high-pressuremetamorphism, subsequent retrogression and final Barrow-type overprint was obtained by40Ar/39Ardatingofbiotiteanddifferentwhitemicagenerationsthatareallwellcharacterizedintermsofmineralchemistry,textureandassociatedmineralassemblages(Wiederkehretal.,inpress).Fourdistinctagepopulationsofwhitemicarecordpeak-pressureconditionsat42-40Ma,followedbyseveralstagesofaretrogrademetamorphicevolution,predominantlyde-compression,between36and25Ma.Biotiteisotopicanalysesyieldconsistentapparentagesthatclusteraround18-16MafortheBarrow-type thermal overprint thatwas associatedwith the temperature increase that followeddecompression. Theisotopicdatarevealasignificanttimegapintheorderofsome20Mabetweenthesubduction-relatedHP/LTevent(42-40Ma)andthelatercollision-relatedMP/MTBarrovianoverprint(19-18Ma).Thissubstantialtimegap,togetherwiththeagecons-traintsonwhitemicareflectingtheretrogrademetamorphicevolutionoftheHP/LTstage,supportthenotionofapoly-me-tamorphicevolutionassociatedwithabimodalP-Tpath.AmphibolitefaciesBarrow-typeoverprintoftheNELepontinedomeclearlyrepresentsaseparateheatingpulsethatpost-datesisothermaldecompressionafterthehigh-pressurestage.Thisin-dicatesthatitistheaccretionofvastamountsofEuropeancontinentalcrustformingthepresent-dayLepontinedomethatprovideshigh radiogenicheatproduction responsible for amphibolite faciesmetamorphism (Bousquet et al., 2008]. Thisheatingisanentirelyconductiveandthereforeratherslowprocess.
REFERENCESBousquet,R.,Oberhänsli,R.,Goffé,B.,Wiederkehr,M.,Koller,F.,Schmid,S.M.,Schuster,R.,Engi,M.,Berger,A.&Martinotti,
G.2008:Metamorphismofmetasedimentsatthescaleofanorogen:AkeytotheTertiarygeodynamicevolutionoftheAlps.In:S.Siegesmundetal.(eds.)TectonicAspectsoftheAlpine-Dinaride-Carpathiansystem,Geol.Soc.SpecialPubl.,298,393-411.
Wiederkehr,M.,Bousquet,R., Schmid, S.M.&Berger,A. 2008: Fromsubduction to collision:ThermaloverprintofHP/LTmeta-sedimentsinthenorth-easternLepontineDome(SwissAlps)andconsequencesregardingthetectono-metamorphicevolutionoftheAlpineorogenicwedge.In:N.Froitzheim&S.M.Schmid(eds.)OrogenicprocessesintheAlpinecollisionzone,SwissJ.Geosci.,101(Suppl),S127-S155.
Wiederkehr,M.,Sudo,M.,Bousquet,R.,Berger,A.&Schmid,S.M.inpress:Alpineorogenicevolutionfromsubductiontocollisionalthermaloverprint:40Ar/39ArageconstraintsfromtheValaisanOcean(CentralAlps),Tectonics.
Wiederkehr,M.,Bousquet,R., ZiemannM.A.,Berger,A.&Schmid, S.M. submitted: 3-Dassessmentofpeak-metamorphicconditionsbyRamanspectroscopyofcarbonaceousmaterial:anexamplefromthemarginoftheLepontinedome(SwissCentralAlps),submittedtoContrib.Mineral.Petrol.
163
Sym
po
siu
m 3
: M
ine
ralo
gy-
Pe
tro
log
y-G
eo
che
mis
try3.47
Approximate terrestrial age dating of meteorites by use of handheld XRF
ZurfluhFlorian*,HofmannBeda**,GnosEdwin***,EggenbergerUrs*&OpitzChristoph**
*Institut für Geologie, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, CH-3012 Bern (f [email protected])**Naturhistorisches Museum Bern, Bernastrasse 15, CH-3005 Bern***Muséum d’Histoire naturelle, route de Malagnou 1, CP 6434, CH-1211 Genève
DuringalargeprojectforsystematicmeteoritesearchinthehotdesertoftheSultanateofOmanwehavesofarcollected5237samplesthatrepresent~550fallevents.Thisis,besidestheAntarcticcollection,thelargestwell-characterisedmeteoritepopulation.Ourmaingoalsaretoevaluatestatisticallyourfindsandstudytheweatheringandcontaminationeffectsofthesamplesduringtheirterrestrialresidence.Forthesepurposesweneedtoknowhowlongthemeteoritesareonearth.Usuallytheterrestrialageisdeterminedby14Cmeasurements(e.g.Jull2006).Buttheseanalysesaretimeconsumingandthereisnochancetomeasureallcollectedsamples.FormerstudieshaveshownacontinuousuptakeofSrandBaduringtheterrestrialsojournofmeteorites(e.g.Al-Kathirietal.2005).WetrytocalibrateanagescaleforfastdatingofOmanimeteoritesbyuseofSrcontentsmeasuredwithhandheldXRF.
WeuseaNitonXL3t-600handheldXRFanalyserforfastandnon-destructivemeasurementsofnearlyallelementsbetweenKandU,withaspecialfocusonFe,Mn,Ni,CaandtheweatheringproxySr.Thisinstrumenthasapredefinedmeasurementmodefortraceelementsinmediumconcentrations.TestswithinternationalandownmeteoritestandardsmeasuredwithICP-MSandhandheldXRFconfirmedanaccuracyofSrmeasurementswiththis“soilmode”withinaderivationof±13%atcountingtimesof120seconds.InitialSrcontentsinordinarychondrites,themostabundantgroupofmeteorites,arebe-tween10and11.1ppm(Wasson&Kallemeyn1988)whereastheycanreachvaluesofseveralthousandppmduringweather-ingandcontamination.Anothereffectmightbeusefulforrelativedating:inhotdesertsoccursanaccumulationofMn-richmaterialduringexpo-suretimeonsomerocks.ItisalsopossibletoquantifythisdesertvarnishwithhandheldXRF.
Measurementswereperformedoncut-(C),exposed-(E)andburied-surfaces(V)ofmeteoritesfromfivelargestrewnfieldsandsomeindividualsamplescollectedontwomajormeteoriterecoverysurfacesintheSultanateofOman,theDhofar(Dho)/ShisrregionandJiddatalHarasis (JaH)/SayhalUhaymir(SaU).TheinfluenceofthesoilisevidentbutalotofanalysisofOmanidesertsoilsamplesdeliveredlowvariationsforSrconcentrationssomewherebetween250to350ppm(Al-Kathirietal.2005).Fromeachstrewnfieldsevento25sampleswereanalysedonthethreementionedsurfaces(C,EandV).Eachsurfacewasmeasuredforatleastthreetimestominimiseeffectsoflocalinhomogeneities.
Theresultsofthissurveywerecomparedwith14CagesfromAl-Kathirietal.(2005).Thesamplesfromtheyoungeststrewnfield,SaU001,haveingeneralthelowestSrcontents.Asonewouldexpectthehighestvaluesaremeasuredontheoutersurfaces(V)ofthesamplesthatwereburiedinthesoil,approvethecontaminationofthemeteoriteswithSrfromthesoil.Theyoungandmediumagesamples(SaU001,JaH073&JaH091)havehighdifferencesbetweentheouter(E,V)andtheinte-rior(C)Srconcentrationswhereastheoldersamples(Shisr015&Dho005)haveamorebalancedratiobetweenthesurfaces.AcontinuousdiffusionofSrfromtheexteriortotheinteriorisaplausibleexplanationforthiseffect.Thecutsurfacesdeliverthebestvaluesforanapproximateagedating.ThereisaninconsistencybetweentheSrcontentsatthecutsurfaceandthe14CageofthetwoJaHstrewnfields.Sincetheseareextremelylargestrewnfields,shieldingeffectscouldhavefalsifiedtheradiocarbonage(Gnosetal.2006,2009).Theyounger“Srage”oftheJaH091issupportedbyagen-erallowerdegreeofweatheringobservedinthinsection.AdditionallytheJaH073sampleshaveamoreelevatedMnenrich-mentontheexposedsurfacesthatindicatesathickerdesertvarnishandthereforelongerresidencetimeinthedesert.
Withacombinedstudyoftheweatheringgradeobservedinthinsection,fastmeasurementbyhandheldXRFofSroncutsurfacesandthedegreeofMnenrichmentonexposedsurfacesitshouldbepossibletoestimateapproximatetheterrestrialagesofOmanimeteorites.
REFERENCESAl-Kathiri,A.,HofmannB.A.,JullA.J.T.,andGnosE.2005:WeatheringofmeteoritesfromOman:Correlationofchemical/
mineralogicalweatheringproxieswith14Cterrestrialagesandtheinfluenceofsoilchemistry,Meteoritics&PlanetaryScience,40,1215-1239.
Gnos,E.,EggimannM.R.,Al-KathiriA.andHofmannB.A.2006:TheJaH091strewnfield,Meteoritics&PlanetaryScience41Suppl.,A64
Gnos,E.,LorenzettiS.R.,EugsterO.,JullA.J.T.,HofmannB.A.,Al-KathiriAandEggimannM.R.2009:TheJiddatalHarasis073strewnfield,SultanateofOman,Meteoritics&PlanetaryScience44,Nr3,375-387
Jull, T. 2006: Terrestrial Ages ofMeteorites. InMeteorites and the Early Solar System II (eds.D. S. Lauretta andH. Y.McSween),pp.889-905.UniversityofArizonaPress,Tucson.
Wasson,J.T.&KallemeynG.W.1988:Compositionsofchondrites,Phil.Trans.R.Soc.Lond.A325,535-544
164Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4. Open Cryosphere session
M. Hoelzle, A. Bauder, B. Krummenacher, C. Lambiel, M. Lüthi, M. Phillips, J. Schweizer,
M. Schwikowski
Swiss Snow, Ice and Permafrost Society
4.1 DalbanCanassyP.,FunkM.:FlowdynamicsofthesteeppartofTriftgletscher(Switzerland)
4.2 DelaloyeR.,HauckC.,HilbichC.,LambielC.,MorardS.,ScapozzaC.:ElectricalResistivityTomographyMonitoringofpermafrostwithinthePERMOSnetwork
4.3 FaillettazJ.,FunkM.,SornetteD.:Icequakesasprecursorsoficeavalanches
4.4 FarinottiD.,HussM.,BauderA.,FunkM.:HowmuchiceisstoredbytheSwissglaciers?
4.5 Groot Zwaaftink C., Cagnati A., Crepaz A., Fierz C., Lehning M., Valt M.: Surface snow modeling at Dome C,Antarctica
4.6 HauckC.,HoelzleM.,HussM.,SalzmannN.,ScherlerM.,SchneiderS.:Integrativecryosphericresearch-anexampleintheSwissAlps
4.7 HussM.,BauderA.,FunkM.:Largescatterandmultidecadalfluctuationsinthe20thcenturymasslossof30Swissglaciers
4.8 HussM.:MassbalancemonitoringonPizolgletscher
4.9 LeBrisR.,BerthierE.,MabileauL.,TestutL.,RémyF.:IcewastageontheKerguelenIslands(49°S,69°E)between1963and2006.
4.10 MittererC.,MottR.,SchirmerM.,SchweizerJ.:Observationandanalysisoftwowet-snowavalanchecycles
4.11 ReiwgerI.,ErnstR.,SchweizerJ.,DualJ.:Shearexperimentswithsnowsamples
4.12 RiesenP.,HutterK.,FunkM.:Aviscoelasticconstitutiverelationdescribingprimaryandsecondarycreepandsolidelasticbehaviourofice
4.13 RingsJ.,HauckC.,HilbichC.:CouplingofERTandthermalmodellingtomonitorpermafrostwithoutboreholes
4.14 RyserC.,LüthiM.,BlindowN.,SuckroS.:ThepolythermalstructureofGrenzgletscher(SwissAlps)
4.15 SchaefliB.,HussM.:Simulationofhighmountainousdischarge:howmuchinformationdoweneed?
4.16 SchneiderS.,ScherlerM.:Impactofsnowmeltonzerocurtainandthawlayerdepthfordifferentsubsurfacetextures.Fieldandmodeling-basedstudiesattheMurtél-Chasteletsarea.
4.17 SchneiderT.,Katona-SerneelsI.:UsingXPDfordeterminingphysicalrockparametersofpermafrostmaterials
4.18 SteinkoglerW.,FierzC.,LehningM.,ObleitnerF.:AsystematicapproachtoquantifytheperformanceofSNOWPACK
4.19 StummD.,FitzsimonsS.J.,CullenN.J.,HoelzleM.,MachguthH.,AndersonB.MackintoshA.:MassbalanceofBrewsterGlacier,NewZealand,modelledoverthreedecades
4.20 ThevenonF.,AnselmettiF.S.,BernasconiS.M.,SchwikowskiM.:NaturalandanthropogenicprimaryaerosolsrecordfromanAlpineicecore(ColleGnifetti,SwissAlps).
4.21 UsselmannS.,HussM.,BauderA:Impactsofclimatechangeon22south-easternSwissglaciersfrom1900until2100
4.22 VieliA., FaezehM.N.:Understanding rapiddynamic changesofmarineGreenlandoutletglaciers fromnumericalmodeling
4.23 WerderM.,BauderA.,KeusenH.-R.,FunkM.:HazardassessmentinvestigationsinconnectionwiththeformationofalakeonthetongueoftheUntererGrindelwaldgletscher,BerneseAlps,Switzerland
4.24 WirzV.,SchirmerM.,LehningM.:Analysisoftemporalandspatialsnowdepthchangesinasteeprock
165
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.1
Flow dynamics of the steep part of Triftgletscher (Switzerland)
DalbanCanassyPierre1,FunkMartin1
1 Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])
Severalstudiesonhangingglaciershavebeentriedtohighlihtpossibleprecursorsbeforebreakoffs.Ifsatisfactoryresultshavebeenobtainedoncoldglaciers,itseemsthatbreakoffmechanismsaredifferentforthosewhicharetemperate,suchastheTriftgletscher,Switzerland(Gadmertal,BerneseAlps).
Duetothedisapearanceofahugeamountoficeinitslowerpartduringthelastdecades,thesteeppartofTriftgletscherwasdestabilized,andapro-glaciallakeappeared.Studiesshowedthatareleaseofanicemasswithmorethanonemillionm3couldcreateawavetriggeringafloodinthedownglaciervalley(Gadmertal).
To improve our understanding about ice break offs of temperate hanging glaciers, we have monitored the ice fall ofTriftgletscherusingdifferentways:Twoautomaticcameraswithatriggertimeeverythreehours,permittoperformthecomputationofthesurfacemotions,andthreeseismicsensors,whichpermittodetectandlocateseismiceventsassociatedwithiceqakes.
Theaimistocombineseismicandphotogrammetricresultsandcorrelatetheseismicactivitywithchangesintheobservedicesurfacemotions,inordertoforeseepossiblebreakoffs.
Firstresultsshowedthattimeperiodscharacterizedbythehighestsurfacevelocitiesalsohavethebiggestamountofseis-micevents.Thusthereseemstobearelationshipbetweendisplacementsinthesteeppartandseismicactivity,andthatseismicitycanbeusedasaforecasttool.Wealsonoticedthatthereweremoreeventsduringnightthanduringdaytime.Thisindicatesthatbasaldrainageactivityplaysanimportantroleintheicemotions.Welocatedeventsindifferentpartsoftheseracfall:cracksduetocrevassesopeningnearthesurface,andyetunknowneventsinthelowerpartbecauseoffallingoficeblocks.Thenextstepistodetectandlocateeventsfromstickandslipmotion,whichcouldcharacterizeprecursormotionstobreakoffs,andtodoavalidationbyusingtheterrestrialphotogrammetry.
Newsresultsaboutstickandslipmotioncharacterizationandphotogrammetricresultswillbepresented.
4.2
Electrical Resistivity Tomography Monitoring of permafrost within the PERMOS network
DelaloyeReynald1,HauckChristian1,HilbichChristin2,LambielChristophe3,MorardSebastien1,ScapozzaCristian3
1Department of Geosciences, Geography Unit, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 4, 1700 Fribourg 2Glaciology, Geomorphodynamics & Geochronology, Physical Geography Division, Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zurich, and Department of Geography, University of Jena, Germany ([email protected])3Faculté des géosciences et de l'environnement, Institut de Géographie, IGUL Quartier UNIL-Dorigny, Bâtiment Anthropole, 1015 Lausanne
ThePERMOSnetwork(PermafrostMonitoringSwitzerland)startedin2000andaimsatalong-termobservationofmountainpermafrost.Itcurrentlycomprisesmorethan20siteswherethethermalevolutionofthegroundand/orthegroundsurfaceismonitored.Besidesthesurfaceandsubsurfacetemperaturestheicecontentofthefrozengroundisnotonlyakeyparam-etercontrollingslopestabilityinperiglacialenvironmentsbutalsoanimportantinputparameterforpermafrostmodels.
Addressingthenecessityforamethodtomonitorthelong-termevolutionofthegroundicecontentinmountainpermafrostin the context of globalwarming, an Electrical Resistivity TomographyMonitoring (ERTM)networkwas initiated in theframeworkofPERMOSin2005.Incontrasttosinglegeophysicalsurveystheso-calledtime-lapseapproachofrepeatedmeas-urementsservestoovercomethecommonproblemoftheoftenambiguousinterpretationofabsoluteresistivityvalues.TheERTMapproachisbasedontheassumption,thattemporalchangesinthemeasuredelectricalresistivityprovideinformationonchangesinthesubsurfaceiceandwatercontent.
166Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion
FollowingapilotstudyontheSchilthorncrest,runningsince1999,anetworkoffourpermanentgeoelectricprofileswasestablishedin2005/2006atthreefurthersites(Murtèlrockglacier,Stockhornrockplateau,Lapirestalusslope)toevaluatethepotentialofpermafrostmonitoringbyrepeatedgeoelectricalmeasurements.BasedonthegoodresultsERTMisnowanoperationalelementofthePERMOSprogrammeandanumberofnewpermanentprofileswasinstalledduringthelastyears.Thenetworknowcomprises14permanentERTMprofilesat10 sites inSwitzerland, includingbedrock sites (Schilthorn,Stockhorn), rock glaciers (Murtèl, Gianda Grischa, Rechy), talus slopes (Lapires, Les Attelas, Dreveneuse, Creux du Van,Arolla),andanice-coredmoraine(Gentianes).
FirstresultsofthisuniquenetworkindicateahugepotentialoftheERTMapproachtodetectandcharacteriseclimatein-ducedgroundicedegradation.Theobserved2-dimensionalresistivitychangesrevealspatiallymoredetailedinformationthan1Dboreholetemperaturesandcontributetoanincreasedunderstandingoftheresponseofdifferentpermafrostland-formstoclimatechange.
4.3
Icequakes as precursors of ice avalanches
JéromeFaillettaz1,MartinFunk1&DidierSornette2,3
1 VAW, ETH Zürich, Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology, Switzerland ([email protected])2Department of Management, Technology and Economics, ETH Zürich3Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zürich
AhangingglacierattheeastfaceofWeisshornbrokeoffin2005.Wewereabletomonitorandmeasuresurfacemotionandicequakeactivityfor21daysuptothreedayspriortothebreak-off.
Resultsarepresentedfromtheanalysisofseismicwavesgeneratedbytheglacierduringtherupturematurationprocess.Threetypesofprecursorysignalsoftheimminentcatastrophicrupturewereidentified:
anincreasingseismicactivitywithintheglacierachangeinthesize-frequencydistributionoficequakeenergy,andalog-periodicoscillatingbehavioursuperimposedonpowerlawaccelerationoftheinverseofwaitingtimebetweentwoicequakes.
Theanalysisoftheseismicactivitygaveindicationsoftheruptureprocessandledtotheidentificationoftworegimes:astableonewhereeventsareisolatedandnoncorrelatedwhichischaracteristicofdiffusedamage,andanunstableanddan-gerousoneinwhicheventsbecomesynchronizedandlargeicequakesaretriggered.
4.4
How much ice is stored by the Swiss glaciers?
DanielFarinotti1,MatthiasHuss1,2,AndreasBauder1&MartinFunk1
1Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH-Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])2 Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, CH-1700 Fribourg
Glaciersarecharacteristicfeaturesofmountainenvironmentsandplayanimportantroleinvariousaspects.Theyareakeyelementofthewatercycle,beingthusimportantforhydropowerproductionoragriculturalexploitation,andepitomizethe”untouchedenvironment”,beingpreciousfortourismindustry.Withtheongoingclimatewarming,theretreatofmountainglaciersisofmajorconcernandstudiesassessingfutureglacierchangesandrelatedimpactsrecentlyreceivedincreasinginterest.Suchpredictionsnecessarilyneedthepresenticevolumeasinitialconditionandfortransientmodelling,theicethicknessdistributionhastobeknown.
i)ii)iii)
167
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
nRecently,Farinottietal.(2009a)developedamethodbasedonmassconservationandprinciplesoftheiceflowdynamicsforinferringtheicethicknessdistributionofaglacierfromtheinversionofthesurfacetopography.Weappliedthemethodto62glaciersintheSwissAlps,includingallicemasseslargerthan3km2insurfacearea,usingdirecticethicknessmeasure-mentstoconstrainthemodelparameters.Theresultingsetoficevolumeswerereferencedtotheyear1999bymeansofatimeseriesofglaciermassbalance(Farinottietal.,2009b,Hussetal.,2008)andusedtocalibrateavolume-areascalingrela-tion(Bahretal.,1997).TheobtainedrelationwasthenappliedtotheglacierscontainedintheSwissGlacierInventory2000(Paul,2007)inordertoestimatethetotalglaciericevolumeintheSwissAlps.
In1999,theglacierizedareaintheSwissAlpswas1063±10km2,with67%coveredbyglacierslargerthan3km2.FortheSwissAlps,weinferatotalglaciericevolumeof74±9km3(Farinottietal.,2009b).Nearlyonequarterofthisvolumeisstoredinthe hydrological basin of the Massa river, which comprises the three large glaciers Grosser Aletschgletscher,MittelaletschgletscherandOberaletschgletscher(Fig.1).Accordingtothetimeseriesofglaciermassbalance,theicevolumeintheSwissAlpsdecreasedby12%between1999and2008.Theextraordinarilywarmsummerof2003causedaicevolumelossofabout3.5%.
Figure1.InferredicethicknessdistributioninthehydrologicalbasinoftheMassariver.Availableradio-echosoundingprofilesareshown.
Hatchedareasareanalysedusingascalingrelation(FiguretakenfromFarinottietal.,2009b).
REFERENCESBahr,D.B.,Meier,M.F.andPeckham,S.D.,1997.Thephysicalbasisofglaciervolume–areascaling. JournalofGeophysical
Research102(B9),20355-20362.Farinotti,D.,Huss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.andTruffer,M.,2009a,Amethodtoestimatetheicevolumeandice-thickness
distributionofalpineglaciers.JournalofGlaciology,55(191),422-430.Farinotti,D.,Huss,M.,Bauder,A.andFunk,M.,2009b.AnestimateoftheglaciericevolumeintheSwissAlps.Globaland
PlanetaryChange,68,225-231.Huss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.andHock,R.,2008.DeterminationoftheseasonalmassbalanceoffourAlpineglacierssince
1865.JournalofGeophysicalResearch,113,F01015.Paul, F., 2007.ThenewSwissGlacier Inventory2000 -ApplicationofRemoteSensingandGIS. SchriftenreihePhysische
Geographie,Vol.52,UniversityofZurich.210pp.
168Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4.5
Surface snow modeling at Dome C, Antarctica
GrootZwaaftinkChristine1,CagnatiAnselmo2,CrepazAndrea2,FierzCharles1,LehningMichael1,ValtMauro2
1WSLInstituteforSnowandAvalancheResearchSLF,Davos,Switzerland2ARPAV CVA, Arabba di Livinallongo, Italy
ModelingeffectivelysurfacesnowcompactioninAntarcticaisofgreatinterestforabetterunderstandingofexchangeproc-essesbetweenthesnowsurfaceandtheatmosphereaswellastheirrelevancetosurfacemassbalance.AtDomeC,wemeas-uredwaterequivalentofsolidprecipitationcollectedabout0.8mabovethesnowsurface.Thedensityofthiscollectedsnowvariesroughlyfrom50to300kgm-3withameanaround80kgm-3.Ontheotherhand,themeasureddensityoverthetop10cmofthesnowcoverbeingabout300kgm-3,thislayerroughlyrepresentsthemeanyearlyaccumulationatDomeC,forwhichdetailedsnowprofiles,continuousrecordsofsnowtemperatures,andatwoyearmeteorologicaldatasetareavailable.Therearesomeobservationsofdriftingsnoweffectsandweexpectwindtoplayamajorroleinthisdensificationprocess.
Extensive qualitative descriptions of the snow deposition process exist in literature but no detailed quantitative study.AdjustingitssettingstotheextremeAntarcticclimate,weuseSNOWPACK,aflexible,modularsnowcovermodeltosimulatesnowcoverevolution.Theinfluenceofthewindonrapiddensificationisparameterizedbymeansofaneventdrivensnowdeposition.Thisresultsinamorerealisticsnowcoverwithapronouncedstratigraphy,evidentinsnowdensityandgrainsizes.
Othermechanismswhichwetrytoincludearetheinfluenceofwatervapordepositionandsublimationatthesurface,forexample.
Wewilldiscussimplicationsfromourresultsforfuturestudieswithrespecttobothmodelingandinsitumeasurementsrelatingtothisveryimportantprocess.
4.6
Integrative cryospheric research - an example in the Swiss Alps
HauckChristian,HoelzleMartin,HussMatthias,SalzmannNadine,ScherlerMartin,SchneiderSina
Alpine Cryosphere and Geomorphology (ACAG), Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 4, CH-1700 Fribourg
Asclimateischangingandthediscussiononimpactsandadaptationareemergingrapidlyinthescientificandpoliticaldialogue,itbecomesevenmorecriticaltoobserve,analyseandunderstandimportantcomponentsoftheclimatesysteminanintegratedmanner.Observationsaretheindispensablepreconditiontoimproveprocessunderstanding.Moreover,onlywithareliableandconsistentdatabaseline,modelscanbeverifiedandtheuncertaintyinprojectionsoffuturechangescanbeassessed.
Thehigh-mountaincryosphereisparticularlysensitivetochangesintheatmosphericconditionswithseveralfeedbackme-chanismsonvariousspatialandtemporalscales.Atthesametime,alsothecryosphericcomponents,snow,iceandperma-frost,interrelatewhichleadstonon-linearresponsestoclimatechange.Atypicalexampleisthedifferingeffectofthesnowcoverforglaciermassbalancevariabilityandgroundisolationoverpermafrostoccurrences.Itisthereforecriticaltoadvan-ceintegratedmeasurementandanalysisconceptsforallcryosphericcomponentsofhigh-mountainenvironments.
Therecentlyformednewresearchgroup ‘AlpineCryosphereandGeomorphology (ACAG)’attheUniversityofFribourgisaimingatactivelyadvancingintegratedinvestigationinhigh-mountainenvironments.Thearea‘Stockhorn-Findelgletscher’nearZermatt,Valais,hasbeenchosentobecomea‘posterchild’ofintegratedcryosphericresearchwherevariousmeasure-mentandmodellingapproachesareapplied.Measurementsincludeallcomponentsoftheenergybalance,spatialdistribu-tionofsnowaccumulation,glaciermassbalance,permafrostgroundtemperaturesdownto100m,geophysicalmonitoringoficeandwatercontentandgroundsurfacetemperatures(e.g.Gruberetal.2004,Machguthetal.2006,Hilbichetal.2008).Inaddition,newmodelapproachestodeterminetheresponseofglaciermassbalance(Findelgletscher),activelayerdepth(permafrostStockhorn)andevolutionofgroundicecontentareusedtoanalysetheimpactofclimatechangeonglaciersandpermafrostandtheirrespectivedifferences(e.g.Haucketal.2008).
169
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
nOurpresentationwillfocusonsomeofthemainresearchactivitiesintheStockhorn-Findelgletscherareaandgiveexamplesforintegratingthescientificactivities.
Figure1.FindelgletscherandStockhornpermafrostmonitoringsite.Firstresultsofthedistributedsnowaccumulationmeasurementsin
April2009areshown.Crossesindicatesnowprobings,theinferreddistributionofthesnowwaterequivalentisshowningreyscales.
REFERENCESGruber, S., L.King,T.Kohl, T.Herz,W.Haeberli,&M.Hoelzle. 2004. Interpretationofgeothermalprofilesperturbedby
topography:TheAlpinepermafrostboreholes at StockhornPlateau, Switzerland. PermafrostPeriglacial Processes, 15,349-357.
Hauck,C.,Bach,M.&Hilbich,C.2008.A4-phasemodeltoquantifysubsurfaceiceandwatercontentinpermafrostregionsbasedongeophysicaldatasets.Proceedingsofthe9thInternationalConferenceonPermafrost,Fairbanks,Alaska,1,675-680.
Hilbich,C.,Hauck,C.,Delaloye, R.&Hoelzle,M. 2008.A geoelectricmonitoringnetwork and resistivity-temperaturerelationshipsofdifferentmountainpermafrostsitesintheSwissAlps.ProceedingsNinthInternationalConferenceonPermafrost,Fairbanks,Vol.1,KaneD.L.andHinkelK.M. (eds), InstituteofNorthernEngineering,UniversityofAlaskaFairbanks,699-704.
Machguth,H., Eisen,O., Paul, F.&Hoelzle,M., 2006. Strong spatial variability of snow accumulation observedwithhelicopter-borne GPR on two adjacent Alpine glaciers. Geophysical Research Letters, 33 (L13503): doi:10.1029/2006GL026576
4.7
Large scatter and multidecadal fluctuations in the 20th century mass loss of 30 Swiss glaciers
HussMatthias1,2,BauderAndreas2&FunkMartin2
1 Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH Zürich, 8092 Zürich, Switzerland
Theongoingretreatofmountainglaciersstronglyimpactsonthehydrologicalcycle,mightcauseeconomiclossesinalpineregionsandisexpectedtodominateeustaticsealevelriseoverthenextcentury.Long-termtimeseriesofglaciermassba-lancerepresentakey toprojecting futureglacierchangesandunderstandingtheglacier-climate linkage.However,massbalanceismeasuredononlyafewglaciers,andtherecordstypicallyareonlysomedecadeslong.
170Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion Here,wepresentthirtynewtimeseriesofglaciersurfacemassbalance,accumulationandmeltoverthepast100yearsin
theSwissAlps.Thedatasetincludesdifferentglaciersizes,exposuresandregions,andthusconstitutesthefirstlong-termmassbalancetimeseriesbeingrepresentativeonamountainrangescale.Ourresultsarebasedonacomprehensivesetoffielddataandmodelling.Foreachglacier,upto10high-accuracydigitalelevationmodels(DEMs)wereestablishedprovidingicevolumechangesinsubdecadaltosemicentennialperiods.Inaddition,morethan8000directobservationsofannualmassbalanceandwinteraccumulationareavailable.Thisdatabasewasusedtoconstrainadistributedtemperature-indexmodel(Hock,1999;Hussetal.,2008)drivenbydailyairtemperatureandprecipitationfortheperiod1908-2008.
Allglaciersshowconsiderablemassloss,butratesdifferstronglybetweenindividualglaciers(Fig.1).100-yearcumulativemassbalancevariesbetween–11mwaterequivalent(Allalingletscher)and–65mw.e.(Griesgletscher).Thesestrongdiffe-rencesintheresponseofglaciermassbalancetochangesinclimateforcingareattributedtoaninteractionofseveralcom-plexprocesses.Largeandflatglacierstendtohavemorenegativemassbalanceduetotheirlongreactiontime.Positiveandnegativealbedofeed-backmechanisms,aswellaschangingwinterprecipitation,variableonsmallerspatialscalesthanairtemperatures,mightalsoexplainsomeofthedifferences.
Masslossisparticularlyrapidinthe1940sandlate1980stopresent,whileshortperiodsofmassgainoccurredinthe1910sandlate1970s(Fig.1).Thisindicatesthatglaciermasslossoverthe20thcenturywasnotlinear,butexhibitsimportantlong-termvariations.WefindoscillationsintherateofglaciermasslossintheSwissAlpswithaperiodof65years.GlaciermassbalanceissignificantlyanticorrelatedtotheAtlanticMultidecadalOscillation(AMO)indexwhichreferstoanomaliesintheseasurfacetemperatureintheNorthAtlantic.WethusproposealinkbetweenAtlanticOceancirculationandAlpineglaciermassloss.
Figure1.Timeseriesofcumulativemeanspecificannualmassbalanceof30Swissglaciersinthe20thcentury.Blackdotsindicatethe
datesofDEMs.Thesolidlinerepresentsthearithmetic30-glacieraverage.Glaciernamesandnumbersarearrangedaccordingtodescen-
dingglaciersize.Thedash-dottedlineshowsthecumulativetotalvolumechangeofthe30glaciers(right-handsideaxis).Twoshortperi-
odswithmassgainandtwoperiodswithfastmasslossaremarked.
REFERENCESHock,R.,1999.Adistributedtemperature-indexice-andsnowmeltmodelincludingpotentialdirectsolarradiation.Journal
ofGlaciology,45,101–111.Huss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.&Hock,R.,2008.DeterminationoftheseasonalmassbalanceoffourAlpineglacierssince
1865.JournalofGeophysicalResearch,113,F01015.
171
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.8
Mass balance monitoring on Pizolgletscher
HussMatthias1,2
1 Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH Zürich, 8092 Zürich, Switzerland
Verysmallglaciersarerarelysubjectofglaciologicalstudies.AlthoughtheseglaciersonlycoveralimitedfractionoftheglacierizedareaintheAlps,theirnumberisconsiderable.Accordingtoglacierinventorydata,82%oftheSwissglaciersaresmaller than 0.5 km2. So far, the mass balance of glaciers in this important size class was never investigated inSwitzerland.
In2006anewmassbalancemonitoringprogramontheverysmallPizolgletscher,north-easternSwissAlps,wasstarted.Pizolgletscherhasanareaofcurrently0.08km2andisarelativelysteep,north-exposedcirqueglacier(Fig.1).Themonitoringprogramconsistsoftwofieldsurveys,oneinAprilandoneinSeptember,andwillbecontinuedoverthenextyears.Duringthewintersurveythespatialdistributionofsnowaccumulationisdeterminedbyupto100snowprobingsonadensenet-workandsnowdensitymeasurementsinasnowpit.Threestakesdrilledintotheiceprovideinformationabouttheannualmassbalance(Fig1a).Inaddition,thechangesinglacierareaandicevolumeareknowninsubdecadalintervalsfromsevenphotogrammetricsurveyssince1968providinghigh-accuracydigitalelevationmodels.
Basedontheseasonalin-situmeasurementsglacier-widemassbalanceisdeterminedusinganovelmethod.Adistributedmassbalancemodelwithdailytimestepsistunedtomatchboththemeasuredsnowwaterequivalentinspringandtheannualmassbalanceatthestakes(Huss,2009).Theobservedaccumulationdistributionisusedtoconstrainthemodelinspace.Thismethodallowsanoptimalexploitationofthefielddata,thedeterminationofmassbalanceoverfixedtimepe-riodsand,thus,thecomparisonofdifferentyears.
InthetwofirstyearsofthesurveyPizolgletscherwassubjectedtostrongmassloss.Theannualmassbalancein2006/2007was–1.60mwaterequivalent(w.e.)andin2007/2008–0.83mw.e.Thewinteraccumulationwaslowin2007withanearlyonsetofthemeltingseason.InApril2008and2009,however,averagesnowdepthsofalmost5metresweremeasured,coun-teractingthehighairtemperaturesofthefollowingsummer.ThespatialpatternofsnowdepositiononPizolgletscherishighlyvariableandimportantlydeterminedbywind(Fig.1b).Consequently,glacieradvanceisduetoanappositionoffirninfrontoftheglaciertongue,andisnotrelatedtoadynamicreactionoficeflow.Pizolgletschercan,thus,changeitsareaandlengthrapidly,whichisillustratedbythelengthchangemeasurementscarriedoutsincethelate19thcentury.
Figure1.(a)FrontviewandmapofPizolgletscher.Thepositionofthemassbalancestakesisshown.(b)OrthophotographofPizolgletschertakeninSeptember1973.Linesindicateglacierextentin1968,1973,1997and2006.Theinhomogeneousdis-tributionofsnowiswellvisible.Theinsetshowsthechangeinglacierarea(dA)andvolume(dV)relativetotheyear1968.
172Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion Between1968and2006Pizolgletscherhaslostmorethan60%ofitsareaandvolume,mostofthedecreasetakingplaceover
thelasttwodecades(insetinFig.1b).Extrapolatingthislossintothefutureis,however,unreliable,astheglacierwillretre-atbydegreesintoamoreprotectedcirquewithhighaccumulationrates,seekingforanewequilibrium.Basedontheobser-vedicevolumechanges,theseasonalmassbalanceoverthelast40yearswasreconstructedaccordingtoHussetal.(2008).The cumulativemass balance is –17mw.e.,which is consistentwith othermass balance records in the SwissAlps (e.g.Silvrettagletscher).Ashortperiodofmoderatemassgains inthe late1970s is followedbystrongmass loss, inparticularsince2003.
ThefirstresultsofthenewmassbalancemonitoringprogramonPizolgletscherarepromisingandhaverevealedinterestinginsightsintotheresponseofsmallglacierstoclimatewarming,inparticulartheirhighsensitivitytoaccumulationchangesandtheimportanceofthespatialdistributionofsnowdeposition.
REFERENCESHuss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.&Hock,R.,2008.DeterminationoftheseasonalmassbalanceoffourAlpineglacierssince
1865.JournalofGeophysicalResearch,113,F01015.Huss,M,2009.PastandFutureChangesinGlacierMassBalance,Chap.A.1.DissertationNo.18230,ETHZürich,218pp.
4.9
Ice wastage on the Kerguelen Islands (49°S, 69°E) between 1963 and 2006
RaymondLeBris2,EtienneBerthier1,LaureMabileau1,LaurentTestut3,andFrédériqueRémy1
1LEGOS, CNRS, Toulouse, France.2Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland. ([email protected])3LEGOS, Université de Toulouse, Toulouse, France.
TheglaciersandicecapslocatedaroundtheAntarcticandGreenlandicesheetscontainasignificantfractionofthelandiceonEarth(Dyurgerov&Meier.2005).Difficulttoaccess,theirresponsetoclimaticfluctuationsandtheirrecentevolutionarepoorlyknown(Gordonetal.2008).Becausethebehavioroftheseicemassesalsoconstitutesagenuineclimaticindicator,theobjectiveofthisstudyistoassessthechangesoftheextentandvolumeofglaciersandicecapsonKerguelenIslanddur-ingthelastfortyyears(Berthieretal.2009).ThisstudyisalsoacontributiontotheGLIMSinitiative(Raupetal.2007)
Basedonarchiveddata (e.g. IGNmappublishedin1967,glaciologicalcampaignscarriedout inthe1970s)andonrecentsatellitedata(Landsat,SPOT,SRTM,ICESat),wedefinesuccessiveoutlinesoftheprincipaloutletglacierstomeasurethepaceoftheretreatoftheCookIceCap.InordertounderstandtheresponseoftheIceCaptoclimaticforcing,wealsoanalyzedtheclimaticdatarecordedbytheMétéoFrancestationinPortauxFrançais.
Theresultsrevealthatallglaciershaveretreatedsince1965althoughastrongvariabilityexistsfromoneoutletglaciertoanother.OnestrikingresultistheEast/Westasymmetryoftheglacierretreat:west-flowingglaciershavelost11.4%oftheirareawhileeast-flowingglacierlost28.2%.ThedramaticretreatontheeasternsideisillustratedbytheretreatofExplorer’sGlacierfrontby3150m+/-162msince1965oranaverageof75m/yr.Furthermore,theAmpèreGlacierthinnedonaverageby125m+/-16minthefrontalarea,about-4.8m/yr.(cf.alsoVallon1977).Locally,themeanthinningrateduringthelast40yearsreachedasmuchas10m/yr.
Intotal,theicecaplost20%ofitssurfaceareaoveraperiodofthirty-eightyears(1965-2003).TheCookIceCapisinrecessionsincenearlyonecenturyandthistrendacceleratedsincetheyears1960-70(Frenotetal.1993).Theanalysisofmostrecentsatelliteimages(fromtheyears2003to2007)showsthattheretreatcontinuestodaywiththesamespeedorevenslightlyfaster.
Theicecapisthusfarfromitsstateofbalance. If thecurrentclimaticconditionsprevail (hightemperaturesandarela-tivelylowlevelofprecipitation)oriftheyareevenamplifiedinthefuture,itmightbepossiblethattheicecapwilltotallydisappear.
173
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n
Figure1.TopographyoftheKerguelenIslands.Thefourmainglacierizedregionsandthebasestation(Portaux-Français)arealsoindicated.
ThesmallglobeidentifiesthelocationoftheislandintheSouthIndianOcean.
Figure2.East-westasymmetryoftheCookIceCapshrinkage.
Thedarkgrayrepresentsice-coveredareasthatdisappearedbetween1963and2001.
REFERENCESBerthier, E., Y. Arnaud,C. Vincent, and F. Remy (2006), Biases of SRTM inhigh-mountain areas: Implications for the
monitoringofglaciervolumechanges,Geophys.Res.Lett.,33,L08502,doi:10.1029/2006GL025862.Dyurgerov,M.B.,andM.F.Meier(2005),GlaciersandtheChangingEarthSystem:A2004Snapshot,117pp.,Inst.ofArctic
andAlp.Res.,Univ.ofColo.,Boulder.Frenot, Y., J.-C.Gloaguen,G. Picot, J. Bougère, andD. Benjamin (1993),Azorella selagoHook.used to estimate glacier
fluctuationsandclimatichistoryintheKerguelenIslandsoverthelasttwocenturies,Oecologia,95,140–144.Gordon, J. E.,V.M.Haynes, andA.Hubbard (2008),Recentglacier changesandclimate trendsonSouthGeorgia,Global
Planet.Change,60(1–2),72–84,doi:10.1016/j.gloplacha.2006.07.037.Raup,B.,etal.(2007),RemotesensingandGIStechnologyintheGlobalLandIceMeasurementsfromSpace(GLIMS)project,
Comput.Geosci.,33(1),104–125,doi:10.1016/j.cageo.2006.05.015.Vallon,M. (1977a), Bilandemasse et fluctuations récentes du glacierAmpère (Iles Kerguelen, TAAF), Z.Gletscherkd.
Glazialgeol.,13,55–85.
174Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4.10
Observation and analysis of two wet-snow avalanche cycles
ChristophMitterer,RebeccaMott,MichaelSchirmer,JürgSchweizer
WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Flüelastrasse 11, CH-7260 Davos Dorf ([email protected])
Theformationofwet-snowavalanchesaswellasthesnowpackprocessesleadingtowet-snowinstabilitiesarepoorlyunder-stood.Forecastingwet-snowavalanchesisagreatchallengeandposesgreatdifficultiesforlocalauthorities.Betterknowl-edgeabouttheprocessesleadingtowet-snowinstabilitiesisthereforeveryimportant.Duringthewintersof2007-2008and2008-2009twodistinctwet-snowavalanchecyclesoccurredinthesurroundingsofDavos,Switzerland.Weanalyzedmete-orologicaldata,in-situsnowpackinformationandmappedavalancheextent.Inaddition,thesnowcovermodelSNOWPACKwasusedtofillthegapwheresnowpackdata,suchasvolumetricwaterorsnowtemperature,werenotavailable.Snowpackinformationfordifferentelevationbandsweremodelledbyusingaconstantlapse-rateforairtemperatureandincominglongwaveradiation.Theanalysisfocusedonthecausesofinstability:loadingand/orweakeningduetowaterinfiltration.The full energy balance was calculated usingmeteorological data and extrapolated to the investigation area using themodelALPINE3D.Bothavalanchecyclesoccurredinashortperiodoftime.The2007-2008avalanchecyclewascharacterizedbyshortperiodsofwarmingandadditionalloadingbysnowfallandinputofmeltwaterduetorain.Forthe2008-2009wet-snowavalanchecycle,ontheotherhand,distinctwarmingandsolarradiationwereprobablyresponsibleforahigherpro-ductionofmeltwater.Terrainparameterssuchasaspectandslopeanglecombinedwithliquidwaterinfiltrationpatternswerecrucialduringthesecondwet-snowavalanchecycle.Snowpackdatasuggestthatinthefirstyearsnowstratigraphyfavouredtheformationofweaklayers,whereasforthesecondyearsnowstratigraphymayhavefavouredagradualripeningofsnowpackleadingtoaweakeningofthebasallayers.
4.11
Shear experiments with snow samples
IngridReiweger1,RobertErnst1,JürgSchweizer1,JürgDual2
1 WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Davos, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Institute of Mechanical Systems, ETH Zürich, Switzerland
Naturaldry-snowslabavalanchesstartwithafailurewithinaweaksnowlayer.Inordertounderstandthemechanicalbe-haviourandthefailuremechanism,weperformedloadingexperimentswithhomogeneousandlayeredsnowsamplesundercontrolledconditionsinacoldlaboratory.Forsimulatingloadingconditionssimilartothenaturalsnowpack,wedesignedandbuiltanapparatuswhereasnowsamplecanbetiltedbya‘slopeangle’andisloadedviathegravitationalforce.Thedeformationwithin the snow samplewasmeasuredopticallywith a pattern recognition algorithm (PIV). Shortly beforemacroscopicfailure(breakingofthewholesample)weobservedaconcentrationofdeformation(softening)withintheweaklayer.Additionally,wemeasureacousticemissionsduringtheshearexperimentstoquantifythemicroscopicfailure(brea-kingofbonds) inthesnowsamplebeforethecompletefailure.Ourresultssupporttheassumptionthatthedominatingmechanismsforsnowdeformationarethecompetingprocessesofbreakingandsinteringofbondsbetweengrains.ResultsfromPIVclearlyshowedthatwhenalayeredsnowsamplewassubjectedtoaconstantslowloadingrate,thedeformationwasconcentratedwithintheweaklayer.Thishasoftenbeenassumedbuthasnotbeendocumentedsofar.Preliminaryre-sultsoftheacousticemissionmeasurementsofthehomogeneoussamplesindicatedthattheAEmayhintonthemicrome-chanicsduringdeformation.
175
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.12
A viscoelastic constitutive relation describing primary and secondary creep and solid elastic behaviour of ice
RiesenPatrick1,HutterKolumban1,FunkMartin1
1Versuchsanstalt für Wasserbau, Hydrologie und Glaziologie (VAW), ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich
Theflowofglaciericeiswidelytreatedbyastress-strainrelationcommonlyreferredtoasGlen'sflowlaw.TheGlenflowlawisapureviscousrelation,henceacertainamountofstressimmediatelycorrespondstodeformation(i.e.strainrate),inde-pendentoftimeandpossiblerelaxation.Thisbehaviourisappropriateforstationary(secondary)creepofice.However,re-centdetailediceflowmeasurementsonGornergletscher,Switzerland,performedduringthedrainageofaglacierdammedlake,haveidentifiedparticularunexplainedflowchangeswheresignificantvariationsoccurwithinafewhourstoseveraldays.Itwassuggestedthatelasticeffectsmayplayaroleinsucharapidresponseofglacierice.Fromanengineeringpointofview,theloadsrequiredtoproducedisplacementsoftheicesimilartothoseobserved,isontheorderofseveral105Pa.Inthisrange,linearviscoelasticbehaviouroficemaybeinappropriateandonemustconsidernon-linearviscoelasticresponseoftheice.However,manyexperimentsandcreeptestsconductedinthepasthaveshownnon-stationary(primary)creeptobeeffectiveforapproximatedurationsofafewhourstoafewdays.Wethereforeconjecturethatprimarycreepplaysaroleinshort-timeglacierflowvariations.Totestourhypothesisandelucidatetheinfluenceofpossibleviscoelasticeffects,weconstructedaconstitutiverelationwhichisabletoreproduceprimaryandsecondarycreepaswellaselasticeffects.Amo-difiedRivlin-Eriksenfluidmodel,wherethestressisrelatedtobothstrainrateandstrainaccelerationsisusedtodescribeprimaryandsecondarycreepoftheice.Wecoupletheviscousfluidmodelwithanon-linearelasticKelvin-typestress-strainrelationtoenablethematerialtoexhibitelasticbehaviourofasolid.Theconstitutiverelationobeysthermodynamicrequire-ments.Thetransientresponseiniceflowisthusassignedtotheeffectsofviscoelasticrelaxationandprimarycreep.Thedecoupledformulationallowstostudythoseeffectsseparatelyorincombination.Somefirstnumericalresultsusingthefiniteelementmethodhavebeenobtainedfortwoglaciologicalbenchmarkproblemsof(i)flowinachanneland(ii)flowoveraninclinedslab.
4.13
Coupling of ERT and thermal modelling to monitor permafrost without boreholes
RingsJörg1,HauckChristian2,HilbichChristin3
1 ICG 4 Agrosphere, Forschungszentrum Jülich, Germany2 Alpine Cryosphere and Geomorphology (ACAG), Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 4, CH-1700 Fribourg3 Glaciology, Geomorphodynamics & Geochronology, Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstr. 190, CH-8057 Zurich
Geophysicalmethods,andespeciallytheElectricalResistivityTomography(ERT)method,arebeingrecognisedasstandardtoolsforthedetectionandmonitoringofpermafrost,sincerecentadvancesindataacquisitionandprocessinghavemadetheirapplicationworthwhileeventhoughsomeefforthastobemadetoensuregooddataqualityandreliableinversionresults(Hilbichetal.2009).Inmanyscientificstudiesboreholetemperaturedataserveasgroundtruthforthegeophysicalresults,enablingathoroughandrigorousassessmentofthequalityoftheapproach.Furthermore,ERTyields2-and3-di-mensionaldataofthesubsurfaceandissensitivetotheunfrozenwaterandicecontent,whichiscomplementarytothe1-dimensionaltemperaturemeasurementsinboreholes.
Ontheotherhand,thenon-invasivenessofthegeophysicalsurveysandthecorrespondinglowcostsandminimaldistur-banceofthesystemtobemonitoredisusuallyseenasthemajoradvantageofgeophysicsasopposedtoboreholes.Forfutu-reautonomousandwidespreadmonitoringsystemsforpermafrost(similartothesnowandmeteostationnetworks),apu-relygeophysicalapproachisenvisaged.However,ERTmeasurestheelectricalresistivityofthesubsurface,whichhastoberelatedtoicecontentortemperature.Commonapproachesusepetrophysicalrelationships(suchasthewell-knownArchie'sLaw)torelatethemeasuredresistivitychangestosaturationandicecontentchangesortemperature(Haucketal.2008).Butwithoutgroundtruthdatafromboreholesorextensivelaboratorycalibrationusingsubsurfacematerial,theexactnatureofthesite-specificpetrophysicalrelationshipcannotbedetermined.
176Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion Inthiscontribution,weintroduceafilteringapproachcombinedwithcoupledmodellingofthermalconductionandERT
topredictsubsurfacetemperaturesbasedonERTmonitoringdatawithouttheneedforboreholeorlaboratorydata.WeusesequentialBayesianfilteringorparticlefiltering(seee.g.Arulampalametal.2002),whichhastheadvantageofcontinuous-lyprovidingprobabilitydistributionsofstate(temperature)andparameters(e.g.thermalconductivity)whenevermeasure-mentsbecomeavailable.Aparticlefilterapproximatesthesedistributionsbyasetofdiscrete,weightedparticles.Initialstateandparameteraredrawnfrompriordistributionsandthermalconductionismodelledindependentlyforeachparticle.Themodelledchangeintemperatureistransferredtochangeinresistivitybyalinearrelation,andanERTforwardmodelisusedtosimulatethesystemresponse.Then,theparticlesareweightedaccordingtotheagreementbetweenmeasuredandmo-delledERTresponse.Are-samplingroutineisusedtoensurethat,overtime,theparticlesgravitatetowardstheposteriordistributionsofstateandparameter.
Totesttheapproach,modelledandobservedgroundtemperatureswerecomparedatthehigh-altitudepermafroststationonSchilthorn,BernerOberland/SwissAlps.FirstresultsusingautomatedERTmonitoringdatafromthePERMOS(PermafrostMonitoring Switzerland) network show a good performance during a 3-month period in spring and summer 2009.Improvementscanbeachievedbyusingmoresophisticatedthermalmodelsandbyiterativeprocedurestodeterminethe(verticallyvariable)materialpropertiesofthesubsurface,suchasporosityandthermalconductivity.
REFERENCESArulampalam,M.S.,Maskell,S.,Gordon,N.&Clappt,T.2002.Atutorialonparticlefiltersforonlinenonlinear/non-Gaussian
Bayesiantracking,IEEETransactionsonSignalProcessing,50,174-188.Hilbich,C.,Marescot,L.,Hauck,C.,Loke,M.H.&Mäusbacher,R.2009.ApplicabilityofERTmonitoringtocoarseblockyand
ice-richpermafrostlandforms.PermafrostandPeriglacialProcesses20(3),269-284.Hauck,C.,Bach,M.&Hilbich,C.2008.A4-phasemodeltoquantifysubsurfaceiceandwatercontentinpermafrostregionsbased
ongeophysicaldatasets.Proceedingsofthe9thInternationalConferenceonPermafrost,Fairbanks,Alaska,1,675-680.
4.14
The polythermal structure of Grenzgletscher (Swiss Alps)
ClaudiaRyser1,MartinLüthi1,NorbertBlindow2,SonjaSuckro2
1 Versuchsanstalt für Wasserbau, Hydrologie und Glaziologie (VAW), ETH-Zürich, 8092 Zürich, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Institut für Geophysik der Westfälischen Wilhelms- Universität Münster, 48149 Münster, Germany
Withacombinationofboreholemeasurementsandhelicopter-borneiceradar,thetemperaturedistributioninthelowerpartofthepolythermalGrenzgletscher(SwissAlps)wasinvestigated.Verticaltemperatureprofilesweremeasuredin12deepboreholes.ColdicewasfoundinacentralflowbandintheGrenzgletscherbranch,wherethecoldestice(-2.6°C)wasfoundin60-75mdepth.Thecoldiceoccupies80-90%oftheicethicknessof200-320m,andislaterallyconnedtoabandof+/-200mfromthecentralflowline.Theiceistemperateclosetothebedandtowardsthemargins.ComparisonoficeradarsoundingsacquiredwiththeUMAIRgeoradarwithboreholetemperaturesshowsthatlow-backscatterzonescoincidewithiceattem-peraturesmore than0.5Kbelow thepressuremelting temperature. The low-backscatter zonesare thusused tomap thedistributionofcoldiceonthewholelowerglacier.Thecoldiceadvectedfromtheaccumulationcausesazoneofpersistentsuperficialmeltwaterstreamsandlakes.
177
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.15
Simulation of high mountainous discharge: how much information do we need?
Schaefli,Bettina1andHuss,Matthias2
1 Water Resources Section, Faculty of Civil Engineering and Geosciences, Delft University of Technology, 2600GA Delft, The Netherlands ([email protected])2 Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH Zurich, 8092 Zurich. Now at: Alpine Cryosphere and Geomorphology, Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland
Forthemanagementofwaterresources,thehydrologiccycleofhighmountainouscatchmentsisfrequentlysimulatedwithverysimpleprecipitation-dischargemodelsrepresentingthesnowaccumulationandablationbehaviorofaverycomplexenvironmentwith a set of lumped equations accounting only for altitudinal temperature andprecipitationdifferences.Thesemodelsaregenerallycalibratedsothatthemodelreproducesascloselyaspossibleaseriesofobserveddischargemea-surements.Thequestioninevitablyariseswhetherlongtermpredictionsofsuchacalibratedmodelareactuallyreliable,sinceknowingthatamodelperformswellforhistoricsituationsdoesbynomeansimplythatitwillperformwellforfuture,considerablymodifiedcatchmentconditions.Afirst,althoughnotsufficientsteptoanswerthisquestion,isinvestigatingwhetherwithsuchamodel,weare“gettingtherightanswersfortherightreasons”.Inglacierizedcatchments,thiswouldforexampleimplythataprecipitation-runoffmodelshouldnotjustmimicobserveddischargebutalsoreproducetheglaciermassbalance.
Inthisstudy,weshowhowmuchobservedinformationweneedtoreliablycalibrateahydrologicalmodelforahighmoun-tainous catchment. Based on glacio-hydrological data from theRhone glacier catchment,we analyzehowwell a simpleconceptualprecipitation-runoffmodel(GSM-SOCONT,Schaeflietal.,2005)canreproduceseasonalglaciermassbalancedataandinasecondstep,howmuchinformationisrequiredtoachieveareliablemodelcalibration.Here,wefocusontheques-tionwhetherobserveddischargeissufficientorwhetherweneedannualorevenseasonalglaciermassbalancedata.
Forthisparticularcatchment,adetailedreproductionofobservedseasonalbalancesrequiresamodificationoftheaccumu-lation and ablationmodule of GSM-SOCONT. Themodel only accounts for altitudinal differences of themeteorologicalconditionsande.g.notforwinddriftorexposition.Asourresultsshow,introducingseasonalaccumulationandablationparametersissufficienttoenablethissimplemodeltoreproduceobservedseasonalbalances (Fig.1)andannualnetbal-ances(Fig.2).Furthermore,ourresultssuggestthatcalibratingthehydrologicalmodelexclusivelyondischargecanleadtowrongrepresentationsof the intra-annualaccumulationandablationprocessesand, thus, toabias in longtermglaciermass balance simulations (Fig. 2). Adding only a few annual net balance observations considerably reduces this bias.Calibrating exclusively on annual net balance data can, in turn, lead towrong seasonalmass balance simulations (notshown).
Eveniftheseresultsarecasestudyspecific,ourconclusionsgivevaluablenewinsightsintothebenefitofdifferenttypesofobservationsforcalibratinghydrologicalmodelsinhighalpinecatchments.
Figure1:Wintermassbalancefor5elevationbands(winter1979/1980);greybars:10%and90%percentilesofallobservedpointmassba-
lances(Funk,1985),redbars:simulatedmeanmassbalance(modifiedGSM-SOCONTwithseasonalaccumulationandablationparame-
ters).
178Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion
Figure2.Comparisonofannualnetbalancesimulationsobtainedwiththedetailedglaciologicalmodelpresentedin(Hussetal.,2008)
andwiththesimplehydrologicalmodelGSM-SOCONT(withseasonalaccumulationandablationparameters),calibratedonseasonaldata,
onnetbalancedata(Funk,1985)orondischarge.
REFERENCESFunk,M.: RäumlicheVerteilungderMassenbilanz auf demRhonegletscherund ihre Beziehung zuKlimaelementen,
EidgenössischeTechnischeHochschuleZürich,Zürich,183pp.,1985.Huss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.,andHock,R.:DeterminationoftheseasonalmassbalanceoffourAlpineglacierssince1865,
JournalofGeophysicalResearch,113,F01015,10.1029/2007JF000803,2008.Schaefli,B.,Hingray,B.,Niggli,M.,andMusy,A.:Aconceptualglacio-hydrologicalmodelforhighmountainouscatchments,
HydrologyandEarthSystemSciences,9,95-109,2005.
4.16
Impact of snowmelt on zero curtain and thaw layer depth for different subsurface textures. Field and modeling- based studies at the Murtél- Chastelets area.
SchneiderSina,ScherlerMartin
Alpine Cryosphere and Geomorphology (ACAG), Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 4, CH-1700 Fribourg
Thesummerzerocurtainphase,atimeperiodcharacterizedbyconsumptionoflatentheatinanisothermalsoilregionattemperaturesnearthemeltingpoint,isofhighimportanceforthethermalregimeofpermafrost.Itisassumedthatthemaincausefortheinitialisationofthesummerzerocurtainisthethawingofthesnowpackandthustheinfiltrationofmeltwaterintothefrozenactivelayer.Furthermoreweassumethattheevolutionofthezerocurtaindependsonthetextureofsubsurface.
BoreholetemperaturemeasurementsfromourfieldsiteMurtél-Chasteletsshowthatonfinegrainedmaterialtheisother-malregionismuchthickerthanincoarseblockymaterial.Inadditionweuseanumericalheatandmasstransfermodeltofurtherinvestigatetheinfiltrationprocessesonthesedifferentsubstrates.
179
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n
B33 (28.04.2008 - 30.06.2008)
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
28.04.0
8
05.05.0
8
12.05.0
8
19.05.0
8
26.05.0
8
02.06.0
8
09.06.0
8
16.06.0
8
23.06.0
8
30.06.0
8
Date
Tem
per
atu
re (
°C)
0_m
0.1_m
0.2_m
0.3_m
0.4_m
0.5_m
0.6_m
0.8_m
1.0_m
1.5_m
2.0_m
2.5_m
3.0_m
3.5_m
4.0_m
4.5_m
5.0_m
5.95_m
Figure1.:ZerocurtainofboreholeB33(coarseblockymaterial)duringspring2008
B34 (28.04.2008 - 30.06.2008)
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
28.04.0
8
05.05.0
8
12.05.0
8
19.05.0
8
26.05.0
8
02.06.0
8
09.06.0
8
16.06.0
8
23.06.0
8
30.06.0
8
Date
Tem
per
atu
re (
°C)
0.0_m
0.1_m
0.2_m
0.3_m
0.4_m
0.5_m
0.6_m
0.8_m
1.0_m
1.5_m
2.0_m
2.5_m
3.0_m
3.5_m
4.0_m
4.5_m
5.0_m
6.0_m
Figure2.:ZerocurtainofboreholeB34(finegrainedmaterial)duringspring2008
REFERENCES:Outcalt, S., F. E.Nelson, andK.M.Hinkel (1990). TheZero-CurtainEffect:Heat andMassTransferAcross an Isothermal
RegioninFreezingSoil.WaterResourcesResearch26(7),1509-1516.Kane,D.L.andJ.Stein(1983).WaterMovementIntoSeasonallyFrozenSoils.WaterResourcesResearch19(6),1547-1557.
180Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4.17
Using XPD for determining physical rock parameters of permafrost materials
TiloSchneider1,IldikoKatona-Serneels2
1 Institut für Geowissenschaften, Burgweg 11, 07749 Jena, Germany2 Department of Geoscience, Chemin du Musée 6, CH - 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland
Permafrostoccursindifferentsubstrates.Variabilityinrocktype,porosity,blocksizedistributionandweatheringattitudedeterminesmorphology,dynamicandicecontentofrockglaciersandtalusslopes.Toanalyzetheseconditionsgeophysicaltechniquessuchasgeoelectricsandseismicsareadequatemethodstodeterminepropertiesoftheshallowsurfaceinpermafrostregions.Eventhoughvaluesforthephysicalcharacteristicsoftheprevailingrockscanusuallybefoundinliterature,theymayvaryoverawiderange.Inordertocalculatemoredetailedmodelsofthesubsurface the physical rock parameters like electrical resistivity and acoustic impedance have to be known very well.Determiningthephysicalcharacteristicsofsinglemineralsmaythereforelimittheuncertaintiesofthewholegeophysicalrockanalysis.
Attypicalpermafrostmonitoringsites,suchastheMurtèl/ChasteletsareaintheEasternSwissAlps,severaldrillcoresandrocksampleswerecollectedandanalyzedusingX-RayPowderDiffractometry.Bythis,itispossibletodeterminethemineralcompositionoftherocksintheinvestigationarea.Inaddition,aReed-Fieldanalysiswasusedtocalculatethequantityoftherespectivemineralcontent.Thisenablestodeterminemeanphysicalrockpropertiesinthesubsurfacewhichthencanbeusedtoimprovegeophysicalmodeling.TheXPDanalysisisafastandexactmethodtodeterminethemineralcontentinrocksamplesqualitativelyandquantitatively.InthisstudyrocksamplesfromthreedifferentpermafrostareasintheSwissAlpshavebeenanalyzed.Allthreesites(Murtèl/Chastelets(GR),Schilthorn(BE),Stockhorn(VS))areincludedintheSwisspermafrostmonitoringnetworkPERMOS,whereboreholetemperatures,meteorologicaldataandgeophysicaldataarebeingcollectedextensively.Inourcontributionwewillpresentresultsfromthemineralanalysisandcomparethemtogeophysicalparametersobservedatthethreesites.
4.18
A systematic approach to quantify the performance of SNOWPACK
SteinkoglerWalter1,2,FierzCharles1,LehningMichael1,ObleitnerFriedrich2
1WSL Institute for Snow and Avalanche Research SLF, Flüelastrasse 11, CH-7260 Davos Dorf ([email protected])2Institute of Meteorology and Geophysics, Innsbruck University, Innrain 52, A-6020 Innsbruck
Newsnowsettlementintheveryfirsthoursanddaysafterasnowfallhasnotyetbeenfullyunderstood.Modellingerrorsatthisinitialstagepropagatethroughawholewinterseason,thusaffectingacorrectmodellingofcrucialsnowcoverproper-tiessuchasdensity,temperaturedistributionandsnowdepth.
Uptonow,parametertuningforsettlinginSNOWPACK(Lehning&Fierz,2008)hasmainlybeendonebyvisualcomparisonofmodelledwithmeasuredsettlingcurves.Thiscanbeaccomplishedbytrackingmodellayersthatcorrespondtopositionsofcombinedsettlementandtemperaturesensors(snowharps).Asaresult,verificationofmodelperformancewithinsitumeasurementsispossible.Herecomprehensivedatasetsobtainedduringanumberofsnowfallperiodsareused.Basedontheseobservationswepresentasystematicapproachtoassesstheperformanceofthemodel.Sensitivitystudiesallowtolocatethemostimportantmodelparameterswhichinfluencethesettlementofdepositedsnow.Ourapproachoffersthepossibilitytovisualiseandquantifytheperformanceofdifferentmodelruns.Inparticular,wewillpresentsuchananalysisbothduringandafewdaysaftersnowfalls.
REFERENCESLehning,M.,&FierzC.,2008:Assessmentofsnowtransportinavalancheterrain.ColdReg.Sci.Technol.,51(2-3),240–252.
181
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.19
Mass balance of Brewster Glacier, New Zealand, modelled over three decades
DorotheaStumm1,FitzsimonsSeanJ1,CullenNicolasJ1,HoelzleMartin2,MachguthHorst3,AndersonBrian4&MackintoshAndrew5
1Department of Geography University of Otago, PO Box 56, Dunedin, New Zealand ([email protected])2Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin de musée 4, 1700 Fribourg3Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstr. 190, 8057 Zurich4 Antarctic Research Centre, Victoria University of Wellington, PO Box 600 Wellington, New Zealand 5 School of Geography, Environment and Earth Science, Victoria University of Wellington, PO Box 600 Wellington, New Zealand
TheaimofthisstudywastomodelthemassbalanceandsnowlinesonBrewsterGlacierforthepastthreedecades,byusingadistributedmassbalancemodel(Oerlemans,2001;Machguthetal.,2006).
Themassbalancemodelisbasedontheenergybalance,andrunswithmeteorologicalinputdata.Inputdataareaninter-polatedclimatedatasetfromtheNationalInstituteofWaterandAtmosphericResearch(NIWA),andtheERA-40re-analysisdataset from the European Centre for Medium-RangeWeather Forecasts (ECMWF). Directmass balancemeasurements,whichwereinitiatedin2004,provideddatatocalibratethemodel.Thesemeasurementswerecollectedwiththeglaciologi-calmethodthatincludesstakeandsnowpitmeasurements.Formodelvalidation,weusedtheannualend-of-summersnow-line(EOSS)recordsfromtheGlacierSnowlineSurvey(Chinn,1995;Willsmanetal.,2008),whichdocumenttheevolutionoftheBrewsterGlacierexcellentlysince1978.Aftercalibratingthemassbalancemodel,themassbalanceandsnowlinesweresimulatedforthepastthreedecades.ThemodellingresultswerethencomparedtotheyearlyEOSSrecords.
ThemassbalancemodelperformedwellwiththeinterpolatedNIWAdatasetforthecalibrationperiod.Butfortheprevious30years,themodelcalculationsdidnotcorrespondwelltotheEOSSrecords.Therefore,themodelinputdatasetwasex-changedwiththeERA-40re-analysisdata.TheresultscomparedmuchbettertotheEOSSrecords,andfitbetterwithmassbalanceestimatesfromaparameterisationscheme(Haeberli&Hoelzle1995)andaGPSmassbalancesurvey(Willisetal.,2008).Furthermore,massbalancetrendsweremodelledwell.However,spatialresolutionoftheERA-40datasetisverycoar-se,andwesuggesttestinginfuturestudieswhethertheperformanceofmassbalancemodellingcanbeimprovedbyapply-ingfinerresolutionRegionalClimateModeldatadrivenfromre-analysis.
REFERENCESChinn,T. J.1995:GlacierFluctuationsintheSouthernAlpsofNewZealanddeterminedfromSnowlineElevations.Arctic
andAlpineResearch,27(2),187-198.Haeberli,W.&Hoelzle,M.1995:Applicationofinventorydataforestimatingcharacteristicsofandregionalclimatechange
effectsonmountainglaciers-apilotstudywiththeEuropeanAlps.AnnalsofGlaciology,21,206-212.Machguth,H., Paul, F.,Hoelzle,M.&Haeberli,W. 2006:Distributed glaciermass balancemodelling as an important
componentofmodernmulti-levelglaciermonitoring.AnnalsofGlaciology,335-343.Oerlemans,J.2001:GlaciersandClimateChange.A.A.BalkemaPublishers,Lisse/Abingdon/Exton(PA)/Tokyo.Willis, I., Lawson,W.,Owens, I., Jacobel,B.&Autridge, J. 2008: Subglacialdrainage systemstructureandmorphologyof
BrewsterGlacier,NewZealand.HydrologicalProcesses,DOI:10.1002/hyp.7146.Willsman,A.,Salinger,M.J.&Chinn,T.J.2008:GlacierSnowlineSurvey2008.Technicalreport,NationalInstituteofWater
andAtmosphericResearchLtd.
182Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4.20
Natural and anthropogenic primary aerosols record from an Alpine ice core (Colle Gnifetti, Swiss Alps).
FlorianThevenon1,FlavioS.Anselmetti2,StefanoM.Bernasconi3&MargitSchwikowski4
1Institut F.-A. Forel, Université de Genève, CH-1290 Versoix ([email protected])2 Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, CH-8600 Dübendorf3 Geological Institute, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich4 Paul Scherrer Institut, CH-5232 Villigen
TheColleGnifettiglacier,locatedintheMonteRosamassif (Swiss-Italianborder,4455ma.s.l.),satisfactoryconservestheaccumulationhistoryofsummerprecipitationchemistryandclimaticconditionsoverrelativelylongtime-period(i.e.afewhundredyears).Infact,theColleGnifettiglacierischaracterizedbyahighice-thickness(about60to130m)andalownetsnowaccumulationofabout30cmwaterequivalentperyear (weq.), resultingfromthepreferentialwinderosionofdrywintersnow.
Consideringthat1)theanthropogenicaerosolsaremostlydepositedinsummer,whenpollutedairistransporteduptohighaltitudesbyconvection,andthat2)duetoitsorographicalpositionintheSouthernAlpinechain,theColleGnifettiglacierisstronglyinfluencedbyairmassesadvectedfromsoutherlydirections,theColleGnifettisummerarchivesthereforeofferauniquepossibility for reconstructing i) regional (pre-)industrial carbonaceousaerosolemissions,and ii) changes in thedynamicofthesouthwesterlydust-ladenwindsfromtheSahara.
TheColleGnifettiicecoreanalysisdemonstratesthattheelementalblackcarbon(BC)aerosolrecordisindependentofthelarge-scaleclimaticcontrolaffectingthetransportofmineraldusttotheSouthernAlps,butprimarilyreflectsregional-scaleanthropogenicactivity(Thevenonetal.,2009).Moreprecisely,theδ13CcompositionofBCsuggeststhatwoodcombustionwasthemainsourceofpreindustrialatmosphericBCemissions.Moreover,biomassburningactivityandespeciallyC
4grassland
burningabruptlydroppedbetween1560and1750 (Figure1), suggestingthatagriculturalpracticesstronglydecreased inEuropeduringthiscoldperiodofthe‘LittleIceAge’.UnliketheBCdeposition,themineraldusttransporttothesummitsoftheSouthernAlpsisprimarilycontrolledbylarge-scaleclimaticpatterns(i.e.drierwinterinNorthAfricaandstrongerNorthAtlanticsouthwesterlies),leadingtotransportofmassivedustplumesfromtheSaharaaround1560-1685,1775-1785,andafter1860.Incontrast,theperiodsoflowSaharandustdepositionaround1515-1560,1690-1770and1790-1850mayindi-cateweakermeridionalatmosphericcirculationatthattimes,leadingtocolderanddrierspring/summerconditionsoverWesternandCentralEurope.
REFERENCEThevenon, F., F. S.Anselmetti, S.M. Bernasconi, andM. Schwikowski (2009).Mineral dust and elemental black carbon
records from anAlpine ice core (ColleGnifetti glacier) over the lastmillennium. J. Geophys. Res., 114,D17102,doi:10.1029/2008JD011490.
183
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n
Figure1.Thelastmillenniumrecordofblackcarbon(BC)concentrationandtheassociated δ13CBCcomposition,asafunctionofage(year
A.D.;leftaxis)anddepth(meterwaterequivalent,mweq;rightaxis).Thedigitalimagesofthefilters,thetotalandmineralaerosolre-
cords,andthemeandiameterofthemineralfraction.Thethreelastmajorsolaranomalousperiods,theSpörer,the(Late)Maunder,and
theDaltonMinima,arereportedforcomparison(Thevenonetal.,2009).(NextPage)
4.21
Impacts of climate change on 22 south-eastern Swiss glaciers from 1900 until 2100
UsselmannStephanie1,HussMatthias1,2&BauderAndreas1
1 Laboratory of Hydraulics, Hydrology and Glaciology (VAW), ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])2 Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, CH-1700 Fribourg
Sincethe1850s,theendoftheLittleIceAge,Alpineglaciershavesufferedmajorlossesoficevolume.Theimpactofclimatechangeonglaciersisreflectedmostclearlyintheirsurfacemassbalance.Therefore,areconstructionofmassbalancetimeseriesofdifferentglaciersduringthelastcenturyisimportantforabetterunderstandingoftheresponseofAlpineglacierstocurrentglobalwarming.
Inthisstudy,thetemporalandspatialchangesof22glaciersinthesouth-easternSwissAlpsareanalyzedbetween1900and2008usingdifferenttypesoffielddataanddistributedmodelling.Theinvestigatedglacierscoverawiderangeofglacierareaandicevolume,aswellasexposureandslope.Thisallowsinvestigationofdifferencesintheresponseofindividualglacierstoclimatechangeinarelativelysmallregion.
Seasonalmassbalancetimeseriesofglaciershavebeencalculatedfortheperiod1900–2008usingadistributedaccumula-tionandtemperature-indexmeltmodel(Hussetal.,2008).Themodeliscalibratedusingobservedicevolumechangesinmultidecadalperiods.Inordertocalculatethevolumechange,twosuccessivedigitalelevationmodels(DEMs)arecompared
184Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion toeachother.ThebasisfortheseDEMsare(i)terrestrialtopographicsurveys,(ii)photogrammetricanalysisofaerialphoto-
graphs,and (iii)alreadyexistingdatasets,asDHM25(swisstopo)andSRTM(NASA). In-situpointmeasurementsofannualmassbalanceandwinteraccumulation,available for someglaciers, aswell as long-termdischarge records for the threemajorcatchmentsinthestudyregionareusedformodelvalidation.
Since1900thechangesinglacierareaandvolumeareconsistentlynegative.Betweenthe1930sandtheendofthelastcen-turytheareaofthe22investigatedglaciersdecreasedbyabout24%.Overthelastcentury(1900–1999)theregionalicevo-lumehasdecreasedby30%,withstrongdifferencesbetweenindividualglaciers(20–60%).Therateof100-yearmasslossstronglydiffersbetweenadjacentglaciers.Whereaslargevalleyglaciers(e.g.VadrecdelForno)showcumulativemassbalan-cesofupto-70mw.e.,smallerandsteeperglaciers(e.g.VadretdaPalü)exhibitlessnegativemassbalancesofaround-15mw.e.(Fig.1).Usingregionalclimatescenarios(Frei,2007),futureglacierretreatissimulatedtransientlyforallglaciersoverthe21stcen-tury.Weprojectglacierareachangesbetween-80%and-100%andvolumechangesbetween-70%and-100%withstrongim-pactsonthewatercycle(Fig.2).
Figure1.Cumulativeseriesofmeanspecificmassbalanceofthe22investigatedglaciersfrom1900to2008.Timeseriesfortheindividual
glaciersaredisplayedingrey;trianglesindicatethedatesofDEMs.Thesolidvioletlinerepresentsthearithmeticaveragefortheinvesti-
gatedglaciers.Glaciernamesaregivenattheright-handsideandcoloursindicateglaciersize(Usselmann,2009).
Figure2.SimulatedfutureevolutionofVadretdaMorteratschuntil2100.Glacierextentisshownfortheyears2020,2060and2100forthe
mostlikelyclimatescenario.Glacierextentintheyear2008isshown(Usselmann,2009).
REFERENCESFrei,C.,2008.DieKlimazukunftderSchweiz.In:KlimaänderungunddieSchweiz2050–ErwarteteAuswirkungenaufUmwelt,
GesellschaftundWirtschaft.BeratendesOrganfürFragenderKlimaänderung(OcCC):12–16,http://www.occc.ch.Huss,M.,Bauder,A.,Funk,M.&Hock,R.,2008.DeterminationoftheseasonalmassbalanceoffourAlpineglacierssince
1865.JournalofGeophysicalResearch,113,F01015.Usselmann, S., 2009. SchweizerGletscher imWandel vonKlimaundZeit.Diplomarbeit, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität
Erlangen-Nürnberg,pp.179.
185
Sym
po
siu
m 4
: O
pe
n C
ryo
sph
ere
se
ssio
n4.22
Understanding rapid dynamic changes of marine Greenland outlet gla-ciers from numerical modeling
AndreasVieli12,FaezehM.Nick3
1 VAW, Glaziologie, ETH Zuerich, Gloriastr 37/39, CH-8092 Zuerich 2 Department of Geography, Durham University, South Road, Durham DH1 3LE, UK ([email protected])3GEUS, Ostervolgade 10, DK-1350, Copenhagen, DK
RecentrapiddynamicchangesofGreenland'soutletglaciersraisedconcernsoverthecontributiontofuturesealevelrise.ThesedynamicchangesseemtobelinkedtothewarmingtrendinGreenland,butthemechanismsthatlinkclimateandicedynamicsarepoorlyunderstood,andcurrentnumericalmodelsoficesheetsarenotabletosimulatethesechangesrealis-tically.ThesedynamicchangesthereforeprovidemajoruncertaintiesinthepredictionsofmasslossfromtheGreenlandicesheet. Wedevelopedanumerical ice-flowmodelthatreproducestheobservedrapidchanges inHelheimGlacier,oneofGreenland'slargestoutletglaciers.Oursimulationsshowthattheiceacceleration,thinningandretreatbeginattheoceanterminatingcalvingfrontandthenpropagaterapidlyupstreamthroughdynamiccouplingalongtheglacier.Wefindthatthesechangesareunlikelytobecausedbybasallubricationthroughenhancedsurfacemeltfromtherecentatmosphericwarmingandthatmasslossisamplifiedbyadeepbasaloverdeepeningatthebed.Importantly,themodellingfurthershowsthatsuchtidewateroutletglaciersareextremelysensitivetochangingboundaryconditionsatthecalvingterminusanddynamicallyadjustextremelyrapidly.ThisimpliesthattherecentrapidmasslossofGreenland'soutletglaciersmayreflectshort-termvariationsinclimateoroceanconditionsandshouldnotbeextrapolatedintothefuture.
4.23
Hazard assessment investigations in connection with the formation of a lake on the tongue of the Unterer Grindelwaldgletscher, Bernese Alps, Switzerland
MauroA.Werder1,AndreasBauder1,Hans-RudolfKeusen2,MartinFunk1
1VAW, ETH Zurich, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])2GEOTEST AG, Birkenstrasse 15, CH-3052 Zollikofen, Switzerland
ThesurfaceleveloftheUntererGrindelwaldgletscherglaciertonguehassubsidedbymorethan200\,moverthelast150years.Thesurfaceloweringisnotuniformovertheglaciertonguebutdependsonthethicknessoftheunevendebriscover,whichledtotheformationofadepressiononthetongue.Alakehasformedinthisbasin,forthefirsttimein2005,whichcandrainrapidlyleadingtoaso-calledglacierlakeoutburstflood.Thelakebasinhasbeenincreasinginsizeatanalarmingrateand,in2008itreachedavolumewhichposesasignificantfloodingthreattothecommunitiesdownstream,aswasexemplifiedbyanoutburstofthelakeinMay2008.Weextrapolatedthefutureevolutionofthelakebasinbasedonsurfaceloweringratesin2004--2008.Wetunedamodelwiththemeasuredhydrographfrom2008andranitwiththeextrapolatedlakevolumestosimulatesuchalakeoutburstandestimatedpossiblefuturefloodhydrographs.Wediscusstherapidlyin-creasingriskforGrindelwaldandothercommunities,thereasonswhyin2009norapidlakedrainageoccurred,aswellastheinstallationofanearlywarningsystemandtheconstructionofa2.1kmlongdrainagetunnel.
186Sy
mp
osi
um
4:
Op
en
Cry
osp
he
re s
ess
ion 4.24
Analysis of temporal and spatial snow depth changes in a steep rock face
VanessaWirz,MichaelSchirmer,MichaelLehning
WSL-Institut für Schnee- und Lawinenforschung SLF, Flüelastrasse 11, CH-7260 Davos Dorf ([email protected])
Thepresenceofsnowinsteepalpineterrainaffectsmanyphenomena,e.g.watermanagement,snowavalanchesorperma-frostdistribution.Hencegoodknowledgeonspatialandtemporaldistributionof snowinsteepalpine terrain isofhighimportance.Inaccessibilityandalpinedangersinverysteepterrainarethemainreasonsforlackofstudiesonsnowdepthinthoseareas.Themaingoalofthisstudyistogetmoredetailedinformationabouttheamountanddistributionofsnowinverysteepterrainandtobetterunderstandtherelevantprocessesandfactors,whichaffectsnowaccumulation,redistri-bution,erosionandablationinsteeprockfaces.Forthispurpose,ahighresolutionterrestrialLaserScanner(TLS)wasusedproducingprecisesnowheightdigitalsurfacemodels.Wecollectedsurfacedatawithoutsnow,beforeandaftersignificantsnowfallorwinddrifteventsandduringtheablationperiod.Wethengenerateddigitalsurfacemodels(DSM)foreachob-servationperiod.Thesummerscanunderthetotalabsenceofsnowallowedustoprovideadigitalelevationmodel(DEM)andtocalculateabsolutesnowdepth.Relativesnowdepthchangescanbeextractedbythecomparisonofdifferentwinterscans.Inadditiontothelaserscans,orthophotosweretakenwithadigitalcamera.
InafirststepwecouldshowthatwithTLSreliableinformationonsurfacedataofasteeprockysurfacecanbeachieved.Incomparisontoaflatfieldpointmeasurementthemeansnowdepthintherockfacewassmallerduringtheentirewinter,buttrendsofsnowdepthchangesweresimilar.Weobservedrepeatingaccumulationandablationpatternsintherockface,whilemaximumsnowdepthlossoccurredalwaysatthoseplaceswithmaximumsnowdepthgain.Furthermore,increasingsnowdepthresultedinadecreaseofhighslopeangles.Furtheranalysesshouldinvolvethestatisticalrelationofspatialandtemporaldistributionofsnowdepthto(i)terrainfeaturese.g.slopeangle,aspectorcurvatureand(ii)resultingsurfacepro-cessesderivedfromspatialdistributedmodeloutputse.g.radiation,windfieldsorblowinganddriftingsnow.
188Sy
mp
osi
um
5:
Me
teo
rolo
gy
an
d c
lim
ato
log
y 5. Meteorology and climatologyRolf Philipona, Markus Furger
Swiss Meteorological Society
5.1 CeppiP.,ScherrerS.C.,AppenzellerC.:MagnitudeandaltitudedependenceofSwisstemperaturetrends: localandlarge-scaleinfluences
5.2 ChiacchioM.,EwenT.,WildM.,ChinM.,DiehlT.:DecadalvariabilityofaerosolopticaldepthinEuropeanditsrela-tionshiptotheglobaldimmingandbrighteningandtheshiftintheNAO
5.3 EwenT.,BrönnimannS.:PacificNorthAmericanclimatevariabilityandlinkstotheNorthAtlantic
5.4 FallotJ.-M.,HertigJ.-A.:AssessmentofextremeprecipitationinSwitzerlandwithstatisticalanalyses
5.5 HauckC.,KraussL.,BarthlottC.:Soilmoisturemonitoringandsoilmoistureimpactonconvectiveprecipitationinorographicterrain
5.6 MeierM.F.,GrobétyB.,CollaudCoenM.:AerosolpropertiesofSaharandustcollectedattheJungfraujoch:determinedbysingleparticleanalysis
5.7 PiquetE.,DeljuA.,KaenzigR.:Selectingandproducingclimaticdatatoassesstheclimatechange/humanmigrationnexus
5.8 RossiL.,MargotJ.,HariE.R.:Watertemperaturechangesinreceivingwatersduetotheincreaseofimperviousness:amultidisciplinaryassessmentapproach
5.9 Schaller N., Mahlstein I., Knutti R.: Should climate models be evaluated with statistic-based or process-basedmetrics?
5.10 Stocker-Mittaz C., Häberli C., Frei C., Germann U.: The MeteoSwiss strategy for the renewal of the precipitationmeasurementnetwork
5.1
Magnitude and altitude dependence of Swiss temperature trends: local and large-scale influences
CeppiPaulo,ScherrerSimonC.,AppenzellerChristof
Climate Services, Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology (MeteoSwiss), Zürich, Switzerland ([email protected])
EventhoughtheincreaseinCentralEuropeantemperaturesoverthelastdecadesisundisputed,thealtitudedependenceofwarmingtrendsisstillsubjecttomanyuncertainties.Whilemostreanalysesandmodelprojectionsindicateanincreaseofwarmingeffectswithaltitudeinthemid-latitudelowertomiddletroposphere(seeIPCC2007),studiesbasedonobservationsyield lessclearresults, sometimes incontradictionwithmodel-basedanalyses (e.g.Bradleyetal.2004,Appenzelleretal.2008).Furthermore,thenatureandeffectsofthephysicalprocessesresponsibleforthealtitudedependenceofthetrendsareonlypartlyknownandrequirefurtherinvestigation.
ThispaperaimsatestimatingcurrenttemperaturetrendsinSwitzerlandandatassessingtheiraltitudedependence.WeappliedtrendanalysismethodstoanewgriddedSwisstemperaturedataset,generatedatMeteoSwiss fromstation-basedhomogenisedtemperaturerecordsforthetimeperiod1959-2008(Begertetal.2005).Usingdifferenttemporalresolutions
189
Sym
po
siu
m 5
: M
ete
oro
log
y a
nd
cli
ma
tolo
gy (yearly,seasonalandmonthly),we investigatedthemagnitudeofrecentwarminganditsaltitudedependence.Fromthe
resultsofthetrendanalysis,weattemptedtoidentifypossiblephysicalmechanisms(e.g.largescaledynamicsorlocalfactorssuchassnowpackorfog)explainingtheverticaldependenceofthetemperaturetrends.
Ourresultsindicatethatyearlytrendsarepositiveandstatisticallysignificantatthe95%levelforallofSwitzerland,withvaluesbetween0.23and0.44°Cperdecade.However,seasonalvariationsareconsiderable.Thetrendsarestrongestinsum-mer(0.34to0.62°C/decade)andweakestinautumn(-0.02to0.38°C/decade).Usingmultipleregressionmodels,weshowthatglobaltemperaturevariationsandchangesinlargescaledynamicscannotexplainthefullamplitudeoftheobservedtem-peraturetrendsinSwitzerland.Thisindicatesthatsmallerscaleandlocaleffectsmightplayanimportantrole.
Thetemperaturetrendsshowsomealtitudedependence,buttheimportanceofthiseffectisstronglydependentonseason.Whileyearlytrendsshowaslighttendencytowardsdecreasingmagnitudeswithaltitude,thereisamuchclearersignalinearlyspringandautumn,withtrendsbeingmuchstrongerinlowlandregionsthaninthemountains(seeFig.1).
Furthermore,ourobservationsshowthatduringspring,thestrongestwarmingsignalpropagatestowardshigheraltitudeswithtime,followingthe0°Cisothermandtheincreasingaltitudeofthesnowline.Thisisconsistentwithfindingsinothermountainousregions(Pepin&Lundquist2008).Theobservedheightdependencesinspringhavebeeninterpretedasresult-ingfromreducedsnowcover,implyingchangesinsurfacealbedoandsurfaceenergybudget.Thestrongertrendsatlowal-titudesinautumnarestillunderinvestigation.Potentialmechanismsleadingtothisdifferenceareadecreaseinfogdayfrequencyinthelowlandsoverthelastdecadesand/orchangesinfoehnfrequency,atleastinthemainfoehnregions.
Figure1.Temperaturetrends(°C/decade)inOctoberfrom1959to2008.Shadingdenotesnon-significanttrendsatthe95%level.Notethat
thetrendsexhibitaclearaltitudedependencewithhighervaluesatlowerstations.
REFERENCESAppenzeller,C.,Begert,M.,Zenklusen,E.&Scherrer,S.C.2008.MonitoringclimateatJungfraujochinthehighSwissAlpine
region.ScienceoftheTotalEnvironment,391(2-3):262-268.Begert,M.,Schlegel,T.&Kirchhofer,W.2005.HomogeneoustemperatureandprecipitationseriesofSwitzerlandfrom1864
to2000.Int.J.Climatology,25(1):65-80.Bradley,R.S.,Keimig,F.T.&Diaz,H.F.2004.ProjectedtemperaturechangesalongtheAmericancordilleraandtheplanned
GCOSnetwork.GeophysicalResearchLett.,31(16).Pepin,N.C.&Lundquist,J.D.2008.Temperaturetrendsathighelevations:Patternsacrosstheglobe.GeophysicalResearch
Lett.,35(14).IPCC2007.ClimateChange2007:ThePhysicalScienceBasis.ContributionofWorkingGroup I to theFourthAssessment
ReportoftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange.CambridgeUniversityPress.
190Sy
mp
osi
um
5:
Me
teo
rolo
gy
an
d c
lim
ato
log
y 5.2
Decadal variability of aerosol optical depth in Europe and its relationship to the global dimming and brightening and the shift in the NAO
MarcChiacchio1,TracyEwen1,3,MartinWild1,MianChin2,ThomasDiehl2
1 Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science ETH, Zurich, Switzerland2 NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, Maryland, USA3 Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland
TrendsofaerosolopticaldepthfromtheGoddardChemistryAerosolRadiationandTransport(GOCART)Modelaredetectedaccordingtotheirannualandseasonaltemporalresolutionfortheperiod1979-2007.DuringthistimeaerosolemissionsinEuropehavedeclinedduetoenvironmentalregulationsimposedtocontrolairpollution.BydoingsoitisbelievedthatthishasaffectedtheamountofsolarradiationthatreachesthesurfaceoftheEarth,whichhasupsetthesurfaceradiativebal-ance,hence,globaldimmingandbrightening.Thoughcloudshavealsoplayedaroletothedecadalchangesinsurfacesolarradiation,theinter-relationshipbetweenthesevariablesarestillnotwellknownandtheirroleamongoneanotherhasnotyetbeenquantified.ThroughvariousstatisticaltechniquesweshowtherolethataerosolsplayontheglobaldimmingandbrighteningaccordingtoaseasonalanalysisaswellastheirroleontherelatedatmosphericcirculationthatisdominantinEurope,suchastheNorthAtlanticOscillation(NAO).ItiswellestablishedthattheNAOmainlyaffectstheclimateinEuropeinwinter.Inrecentdecades,largechangesintheNAOhaveoccurredwithalargepositivetrendintheindexafterabout1980,andithasaccountedformuchofthewarminginEurope.ThislargepositivetrendintheNAOalsooccursatthesametimethataerosolemissionsinEuropeweregreatest,whichmightimplythattheycouldbecontributingtothechangesintheNAOandcontrollingthesolarradiationonadecadalscale.
5.3
Pacific North American climate variability and links to the North Atlantic
TracyEwen1,2&StefanBrönnimann2
2Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich, Universitätstr. 16, 8092 Zurich. 1Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstr. 190, 8057 Zurich, ([email protected])
ClimatevariabilityinthePacific-NorthAmericanregionisoftenanalysedintermsofafewdominantmodesofvariability,suchasthePNAandPDO.WhilethePNApredominantlycharacterisesvariabilityonseasonaltointerannualtimescales,thePDO isoftenused tocharacterisedecadal scalevariability. Similarly, variability in theNorthAtlanticEuropeansector isanalysedintermsoftheNAO(seasonal-to-decadal)andAMO(decadal-to-centennial).
Untilrecently,thePNAindexhasonlybeenavailablebackto1948,asitisdefinedbasedon500hPageopotentialheightdata.Usinghistoricalupper-airdata,wehavereconstructedamonthlyindexbackto1920(Ewenetal.,2008),whichnowallowsdecadal-scalevariabilitytobeassessed.WeanalysethisindextogetherwithENSO(NINO3.4),PDO,NAO,andAMOindicesinthetime-frequencydomainandfurtherassessthestationarityandphaserelationshipoftheindices.WefindstablerelationsbetweenthePNAandallotherindices,butatdifferenttimescales.ENSOandPNAshowcoherentbehaviourinthe4-8yearperiod.Wealsofindcoherentlow-frequencyvariability(forperiodslongerthan10yrs)betweenthePNAandPDO.Thecor-relationbetweenPNAandNAOisweak(butsignificant)inlatewinter,andtimeintervalswithsignificantcoherencyarefoundontheinterannualscalebutalsoontheinterdecadalscale.Finally,weanalyseperiodsofcoherencybetweenthein-dicesintermsoftheirclimaticsignificance,inparticulartotheArcticwarmingduringthe1930sandtheNorthAmericanDustBowldroughtinthe1920s(Brönnimannetal,2009).
REFERENCESBrönnimann,S.,T.Griesser,A.Stickler,T.Ewen,A.N.Grant,A.M.Fischer,M.Schraner,T.Peter,E.Rozanov,T.Ross,2009:
Exceptional atmospheric circulationduring theDustBowl, to appear inGeophys.Res. Lett., 36, L08802,doi:10.1029/2009GL037612.
Ewen,T.,S.BrönnimannandJ.Annis,2008:AnextendedPacificNorthAmericanindexfromupperairhistoricaldatabackto1922.J.Climate,21(6),1295-1308.
191
Sym
po
siu
m 5
: M
ete
oro
log
y a
nd
cli
ma
tolo
gy 5.4
Assessment of extreme precipitation in Switzerland with statistical analyses
FallotJean-Michel1,HertigJacques-André2
1Institut de Géographie, Université de Lausanne, Dorigny-Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])2Hertig&Lador SA, Grand Rue 38, CH-1176 St Livres
ExtremeprecipitationandfloodeventsproducethegreatestdamagesduetonaturalhazardsinSwitzerland.Extremepre-cipitationamountsforareturnperiodof500yearsaregenerallyusedforcalculatingtheidealdimensionsofprotectionstructureagainstfloodings.TheSwissFederalInstituteforForest,SnowandLandscapeResearch(WSL)calculatedtheseex-tremeprecipitationvaluesfromstatisticalanalysescarriedoutonrainfalltimeseriesatabout300locationsinSwitzerlandovertheperiod1901-1970(Zelleretal.,1980).SeveralstudiesshowthatfrequencyofstrongprecipitationhasincreasedinSwitzerlandandintheworldwiththeglobalclimatewarming(Fallot,2000;Freietal.,2000;IPCC,2007):Forthisreason,daily(24-hour)extremeprecipitationvaluesforareturnperiodof500yearswererecalculatedfromGumbelanalysescarriedoutonrainfalltimeseriesmeasuredat429locationsinSwitzerlandovertheperiod1961-2008.Previous studies show that Gumbel analyses give the best results for estimating daily extreme precipitation values inSwitzerlandforareturnperiodof100or500years(Zelleretal.,1980).Ourstudyshowsthattheseextremevaluescanbewellestimatedatmostlocations(75%)inSwitzerlandfromsuchanalyses.Ontheotherhand,dailyextremeprecipitationvaluesaremoreorlessunderestimatedforasmallnumberofstations(7%).Resultsofthesenewanalysesalsorevealthatdailyextremeprecipitationvaluesestimatedforareturnperiodof500yearsovertheperiod1961-2008areinaverage14%higherthansimilarvaluescalculatedfortheperiod1901-1970.For31%ofsta-tions,dailyextremeprecipitationvaluesforareturnperiodof500yearsestimatedfromrainfalltimeseriesovertheperiod1901-1970onlycorrespondtoextremevaluesforareturnperiodof100yearsfortimeseriesovertheperiod1961-2008.Thisconfirmsthatextremeprecipitationvalueshaveincreasedandtheycouldcastadoubtovertheidealdimensionsofprotec-tionstructureagainstfloodinginsomeareainSwitzerland.Figure1showsthatdailyextremeprecipitationvaluesforareturnperiodof500yearsaremuchhighersouthoftheAlps(upto560mmin24hours)duetoitshighexposuretowetandwarmairmasscomingfromMediterraneanSea.
150
150
150150
150
150
150
15010
0
100
125
200
200
175
200
175200
400
500
250
250
175
450
550
N
200
100
350
350
300
300
125
150
125125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
150
150
175
125
125
150
150
150150
150
150
150
15010
0
100
125
200
200
175
200
175200
400
500
250
250
175
450
550
N
200
100
350
350
300
300
125
150
125125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
125
150
150
175
125
125
Figure1.Daily(24-hour)extremeprecipitationforareturnperiodof500yearsestimatedinSwitzerlandfromGumbelanalysescarried
outonrainfalltimeseriesat429locationsovertheperiod1961-2008.
192Sy
mp
osi
um
5:
Me
teo
rolo
gy
an
d c
lim
ato
log
y However,extremeprecipitationvaluescanonlybeknownatpreciselocationsfromGumbelanalyses.Butthesevaluesstron-glyvarywithinacatchmentareainacomplextopographywhatcanaffectfloodscalculations.Thus,athree-dimensionalmeteorologicalmodelwasdevelopedforcalculatingextremewindsandprecipitationevery2kmat thehorizontalscale(Audouardetal.,2006).Resultsofthismodelwerecomparedwithdailyextremeprecipitationvaluesforareturnperiodof500yearsestimatedfromrainfalltimeseriesoverperiod1961-2008.Thiscomparisonshowsaquitegoodagreementbetweenthemodelandextremevaluesestimatedfromfieldmeasurements,buttheyarealsoseveraldifferencesduetosomeappro-ximationsinthemodel.
REFERENCESAudouardA.,HertigJ.-A.,FallotJ.-M.,2006:ModélisationdesprécipitationsextrêmesenSuisse.Actesdu19èmecolloquede
l’AssociationInternationaledeClimatologie,Epernay,6-9-9.2006,p.83-88.Fallot J.-M., 2000: Evolutiondunombrede jours avecdesprécipitations abondantes en Suissedurant le 20ème siècle.
Publicationsdel’AssociationInternationaledeClimatologie,13,100-108.FreiC.,DaviesH.C.,Gurtz J., SchärC., 2000:Climatedynamics andextremeprecipitationand floods events inCentral
Europe.IntegratedAssessment,1,281-299.IPCC, 2007: Climate Change 2007. The physical science basis.WorkingGroup 1 to the fourthAssessment Report of
IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC),CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UK,996p.Zeller J., Geiger H., Roethlisberg G., 1980: Starkniederschläge des schweizerischen Alpen- und Alpenrand-Gebiet.
EidgenössischeForschungsanstaltfürWald,SchneeundLandschaft(WSL),Birmensdorf.
5.5
Soil moisture monitoring and soil moisture impact on convective precipi-tation in orographic terrain
HauckChristian1,KraussLiane2,BarthlottChristian2
1Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 4, 1700 Fribourg 2Institute for Meteorology and Climate Research, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Germany
Soilmoistureisanimportantparameterinthesoil-atmospheresystem,whichinfluencesthehydrologyaswellastheavaila-bilityofmoistureintheplanetaryboundarylayer(PBL).ThelatterismainlycontrolledbytheenergybalanceattheEarth’ssurface,large-scaleadvection,andadvectiononthemesoscaleexhibitingadailycycle.Atleastinsituationswithlowsynop-ticforcing,thePBLcharacteristicsandtheirimpactsonthetriggeringand/ordynamicsofconvectivestormsarestronglyinfluencedbythepartitioningofavailableradiationenergyintosensibleandlatentheatwhichitselfisdeterminedbysoilmoisture.
Whereaspreviousobservationalandmodellingstudiesdemonstratedthatsoilmoisturecanindeedstronglycontributetothevariabilityofsurfacetemperatureandprecipitationoverflatterrain,theinfluenceofsoilmoistureonconvectioniniti-ationandprecipitationincomplexterrainhasnotbeeninvestigatedindetail.Inthiscontributionwewillshowresultsofadatasetfromasoilmoisturenetworkwithintheorographicallycomplexter-rainoftheBlackForest/RhineValleyinSouthwesternGermany,whichwasinstalledintheframeworkoftheinternationalCOPScampaign(ConvectiveandOrographically-inducedPrecipitationStudy).Inadditiontosoilmoisture,soiltemperature,anddata fromenergybalance, radiosonde stationandprecipitationnetworksareavailable toanalyse the impactof soilmoistureonconvectiveprecipitation(Wulfmeyeretal.2008,Kottmeieretal.2008).Modelstudiesusinganonhydrostaticlimited-areaatmosphericpredictionmodel(COSMO-DE)areusedtocomparemodelledandobservedsoilmoistureandpre-cipitationfields.
Thesoilmoisturemonitoringnetworkconsistsofmorethan50stationsand160singlesensorsmeasuringverticalprofilesofsoilmoisture(5,20and50cmdepth).Basedonregionaldifferencesbetween4distinctregionswithintheinvestigationarea soilmoisture is analysed regarding their variabilitywith respect to soil textureproperties, altitude and exposition(luv/lee).Eachsensor (newlydevelopedlow-costsensorSISOMOP)wascalibratedaccordingtothepropertiesofthesoil.AthoroughanalysisofthesoilatthevarioussoilmoisturestationsshowsthattheactualsoiltexturesoftendifferfromtheonesusedfortherespectivegridpointintheoperationalsoilmodelCOSMO/TERRA.Consequently,firstresultsfromacom-parisonbetweensimulatedandmeasuredsoilmoisturevaluesshowstrongdifferenceswithameanbiasaround20-30%formostofthestationsandmeasurementdepths.
193
Sym
po
siu
m 5
: M
ete
oro
log
y a
nd
cli
ma
tolo
gy Eventhoughitisgenerallyassumedthattheimpactoftheinteractionprocessesbetweensoilsurfaceandatmosphereon
near-surfacevariablesandPBLcharacteristicsislargerunderweaksynopticforcingthanforstrongsynopticforcing,modelsimulationsandobservationalevidencerevealedthattheimpactofsoilmoistureisnotsystematicallyhigherforboundary-layerforcingmechanisms.Inthemodelsensitivityexperiments,theBowenratioexhibitsacleardependencetosoilmoistureconditions,butthesoilmoistureimpactonprecipitationismuchmorecomplexanddependsalsoonitsinfluenceoncon-vectiveindices,i.e.convectiveavailablepotentialenergy(CAPE)andconvectiveinhibition(CIN).Aconsiderable,butnotsy-stematicfeedbackofconvectiveprecipitationwithsoilmoistureexistsinthecomplexorographyanalysed.Theresultsde-monstratethehighimportanceofaccurateinitialsoilmoisturefieldsinnumericalweatherpredictionmodels.
REFERENCESKottmeier,Ch.,N.Kalthoff,U.Corsmeier,Ch.Barthlott, J.VanBaelen,A., Behrendt,R.Behrendt,A.Blyth,R.Coulter, S.
Crewell,M.Dorninger,C.,Flamant,Th.Foken,M.Hagen,C.Hauck,H.Höller,H.Konow,M.Kunz,H.,Mahlke,S.Mobbs,E.Richard,R.Steinacker,T.Weckwerth,A.Wieser,&V.WulfmeyerV.2008.MechanismusinitiatingdeepconvectionovercomplexterrainduringCOPS.Meteorol.Z.,17(6),931-948.
Wulfmeyer, V., Behrendt, A., Kottmeier, Ch., Corsmeier,U., et. al. 2008. TheConvective andOrographically-inducedPrecipitation Study:AResearch andDevelopment Project of theWorldWeatherResearch Program for ImprovingQuantitativePrecipitationForecastinginLow-mountainRegions.Bull.Amer.Meteor.Soc.,89(10),1477-1486.
5.6
Aerosol properties of Saharan dust collected at the Jungfraujoch: deter-mined by single particle analysis
MeierMarioFederico1,GrobétyBernard1,2&CollaudCoenMartine3
1Dept. of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 6, CH-1700 Fribourg ([email protected])2Fribourg Center for Nanomaterials (FriMat), Univ. of Fribourg, CH-1700 Fribourg3MeteoSwiss, Aerological Station, CH-1530 Payerne
Mineraldustcanhaveapronouncedeffectontheopticalparametersoftheaerosol.DuringSaharanDustEvents(SDE)aninversionofthewavelengthdependenceoftheSingleScatteringAlbedo(SSA)isobserved(CollaudCoenetal.,2004).TheaimofthisstudyistoanalyseaerosolparticlesfromaSDEtodeterminetheirsizedistributionbetween0.4and10micrometers,theirmorphologyandtheirmineralcompositioninrelationwiththeobservedopticalmodifications.
ForthispurposePM10wasactivelysampledontoNuclepore®filtersatthehighaltituderesearchstationJungfraujoch(3580m.a.s.l.),beforeandduringaverystrongSDEwhichoccurredbetween26.and29.5.2008.CalculatedbacktrajectoriesshowthattheairmassesbeforetheSDEcamefromtheWest(France,SouthernSpain)andduringtheSDEfromtheSouth.ThesourceregionofthemineraldustcollectedduringtheSDEwasEastLibyaandTunisia.Theaerosolwas,therefore,transpor-tedstraightacrosstoMediterraneanSeatowardstheAlps.
StereologicalandchemicalsingleparticleanalyseswereperformedbyComputerControlledScanningElectronMicroscopy(CCSEM)coupledwithEnergyDispersiveSpectroscopy(EDS).Withthisautomatedtechniqueitwaspossibletoobtainchemi-calandmorphologicalparametersofabout2000particlesforeachsample.Aerosolparticleshavealsobeendirectlycollectedwith an electrostatic sampling device on carbon coated copper grids for analysis by Transmission Electron Microscopy(TEM).
Themineralogy,determinedbyCCSEM,wasnotclearlydifferentforaerosolcollectedbeforeandduringtheSDE.Allsamplesare dominated by clayminerals, followed by feldspars, gypsum, quartz and carbonates. Individual, well separated ironoxides,partiallysuspectedascausesforinversionofthewavelengthdependenceoftheSSA,wererare.However,detailedanalyseswithTEMofparticlesfromtheSDEshowedthatinclusionsofironandtitaniumoxideswithintheclayparticlesarecommon.Thesizeoftheseinclusionsisbetween10and200nm.DuringtheSDEanincreaseofthetotalaerosolmasscon-centrationwasobserved.Thevaluesraisedfrom100-200ngm-3priortotheSDEtovalues>10.000ngm-3.TheparticlesizedistributionshowsaclearcorrelationwiththeinversionoftheSSAwavelengthdependence.ForalldayswithnegativevaluesoftheSSAexponent,theconcentrationofparticleswithdiameterssmallerthan1.5µmisproportionallytotheconcentra-
194Sy
mp
osi
um
5:
Me
teo
rolo
gy
an
d c
lim
ato
log
y tionofbiggerparticlesenhanced.Themineraltypecontributingmosttothissizefractionareclayparticles.Forparticles>1µmthescatteringbecomesdominatedbygeometricaloptics.Thisleadstoawavelengthindependenceofthescatteringco-efficient.
TheresultscorroboratethepreviousexplanationoftheSSAwavelengthdependenceinversioncausedbyarelativechangeinthesizedistributionoftheaerosolparticlesandbythepresenceofironoxides.Theironoxidesoccurasinclusionswithsizesbetween10and200nminclayparticleswithsizesbetween0.5and5µm.
REFERENCESCollaudCoen,M.,Weingartner,E.,Schaub,D.,Hueglin,C.,Corrigan,C.,Henning,S.,Schwikowski,M.&Baltensperger,U.
2004:SaharandusteventsattheJungfraujoch:detectionbywavelengthdependenceofthesinglescatteringalbedoandfirstclimatologyanalysis,AtmosphericChemistryandPhysics,4,2465-2480.
5.7
Selecting and producing climatic data to assess the climate change / human migration nexus
EtiennePiguet1,AmirDelju2,RaoulKaenzig3
1Institut de géographie, Université de Neuchâtel, Espace Louis-Agassiz 1, CH-2000 Neuchâtel ([email protected])2World Meteorological Organization, 7bis av. de la Paix, CH 1211 Genève-2 ([email protected])3Institut de géographie, Université de Neuchâtel, Espace Louis-Agassiz 1, CH-2000 Neuchâtel ([email protected])
SincetheIPCC(2007)reportmentionedpopulationdisplacementsasaforeseeableconsequenceofclimatechange,numer-oussynthesispapersandcasestudieshavebeenpublishedaboutthepast,presentandfuturemigratoryconsequencesofenvironmentaldegradations(Knivetonetal.,2008;Piguet,2008).Anumberofinternationalconferencesandexpertwork-shopstookplaceandanimpressivecoordinatedresearchprojectin23regionsoftheworldwasachieved(http://www.each-for.eu/).Thevarietyofempiricalmethodsusedintheseresearchesis impressive,rangingfromqualitativeinterviewsandhistoricalanalogiestorepresentativequestionnairesurveys,andhighlysophisticatedquantitativemethods.
Severaloftheexistingresearchesalreadyuseclimaticdatasuchasrainfall(Barriosetal.,2006),droughtfrequencies(Henryetal.,2003)orhurricanesfrequencies(AfifiandWarner,2008)butsuchdataareinourviewclearlyunderuseduptonow.Thisisdueinparttoalackofdialoguebetweenmigrationsscholarsandclimatologists/meteorologists.Inordertobridgethisgap,thepaperwillpresentacriticalassessmentofthedifferentmethodsusedtoconnectenvironmentalchangeandmigrationandoftheuseofmeteorologicalandclimaticdatainthatcontext.Onthatbasis,wewillpresentanoverviewofthedatawhichcouldbeusedorshouldbeproducedinordertoimprovethestudyoftheenvironment/climatechangemigra-tionnexus
REFERENCESAfifi, T. andWarner,K. 2008: The Impact of EnvironmentalDegradationonMigrations Flows acrossCountries.United
NationsUniversity-EHS-WorkingPaper.Barrios,S.,Bertinelli,L.andStrobl,E.2006:Climaticchangeandrural–urbanmigration:Thecaseof sub-SaharanAfrica.
JournalofUrbanEconomics60,357-371.Henry, S., Boyle, P. and Lambin, E.F. 2003:Modelling inter-provincialmigration in Burkina Faso: the role of socio-
demographicandenvironmentalfactors.AppliedGeography23,115-136.Kniveton,D.,Schmidt-Verkerk,K.,Smith,C.andBlack,R.2008:ClimateChangeandMigration:ImprovingMethodologiesto
EstimateFlows.Geneva:InternationalOrganizationforMigration-MigrationResearchSeries33.Piguet,E.2008:Climatechangeandforcedmigration.NewIssuesinRefugeeResearch-UnitedNationsHighCommissioner
forRefugeesResearchPaper.
195
Sym
po
siu
m 5
: M
ete
oro
log
y a
nd
cli
ma
tolo
gy 5.8
Water temperature changes in receiving waters due to the increase of imperviousness: a multidisciplinary assessment approach
RossiLuca1,MargotJonas1,HariE.Renata2
1Ecole polytechnique fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Ecological Engineering Laboratory (ECOL), ENAC - IEE, Station 2, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])2 Swiss Federal Institute for Aquatic Science and Technology (EAWAG), Department of Systems Analysis, Integrated Assessment, and Modeling (SIAM), Überlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Dübendorf
Watertemperatureisoneofthekeyparametersinfluencingthechemicalequilibriumanddevelopmentoffloraandfaunainaquaticsystems.Anincreaseintemperaturereducesoxygensolubility,acceleratesmetabolism,suchasphotosynthesisorthedevelopmentoffisheggs,andraisesthesensitivityoforganismstotoxicsubstances,parasitesanddiseases.Inurbanareas,anincreaseinwatertemperaturealsomayresultinanincreaseintoxicityfromammoniadischargingfromcombinedseweroverflows[(VSA2007).
Therearenumerouscausesoftemperaturechangesinreceivingwaters.Naturalcausescanincludeclimate(daily,seasonalandlong-termchanges)(Harietal.2006),thepresenceorabsenceofnear-streamshading,themorphologicalconditionsofthereceivingwatersorgroundwaterdischargeintotheaquaticsystem.Anthropogeniccausescanincludedischargefromhydro-electricpowerstationswithstoragelakes(suddenreservoirdrainagecausesasuddentemperaturedropintherecei-vingwater),dischargeofindustrialcoolingwater(whichusuallyheatsthereceivingwater),andurbanstormwaterdischargeduringarainevent(Rossi&Hari2007;Margot2008).Thisdischargeofurbanstormwaterduringraineventscanconstituteatemperatureproblemforreceivingwaters.Inurbanareas,thisthermalboostisrelatedtotheflowregime,thethermalandphysicalpropertiesofurbansurfacesandtheremovalofriparianvegetationalongurbanwatercourses.Thesefactorsincreasetheamountofthermalenergyinurbanreceivingwatersandmaylead,particularly insummer,toashort-termspikeinthereceivingwatertemperatureatthebeginningofarainevent.Infact,sealedasphaltsurfacesorroofscanreachextremelyhightemperatures(>60°C)duringextendedperiodsofgoodweather.Asimultaneouslylowwaterdischargerateinthereceivingwatersincreasesthepotentiallydangerousthermaleffectofthestormwaterdischargetoindigenousaquaticbiota.
Inthe1990s,analarmingdeclineinthecatchofbrowntrout(Salmo trutta fario L.)inriversandstreamsoccurredinWesternEurope,includingSwitzerland(Burkhardt-Holmetal.2002).Theclimatictemperatureincreaseisconsideredtobeoneofthemaindrivingforcesofthisdecline(Harietal.2006).Inadditiontoclimaticchange,theprogressiveincreaseintheareaofimpervioussurfaces(e.g.pavement)causedbyurbandevelopmentleadstostormwaterreachingaquaticsystemsmorerapid-ly,resultinginhigherin-streamtemperaturesthaninthepast.Swissanglerssuspectthaturbanstormwaterdischargeintoriversandstreamsduringraineventsmayharmthedevelopmentofcertainfishspecies.
Sincelegaltemperaturelimitsarecalculatedonlyoveralong-termdischargeperiod(≥year),theycannotbeappliedtoshort-termalterationssuchasthoseexpectedfollowingrainevents,thuscreatingalegalloophole.
Thisquestionwillbeaddressedwithinthispaper.Thresholdsareproposedforsensitivehabitatsduringaraineventasas-sessmentcriteriatoprotectthefishinthereceivingwatersfromthermalharm.Thethresholdsarebasedonthetemperaturerequirementsofbrowntrout,oneofthemostimportantfishnativetoSwissriversandstreams.Amultidisciplinaryassess-ment approach, including hydrological, physical, biological and ecotoxicological processeswill be presented and subse-quentlyvalidatedthroughthepresentationofdifferentcasestudiesofdifferentlysealedsurfacesinSwitzerland.
REFERENCESBurkhardt-Holm,P. Peter,A. Segner,H. 2002:Declineof fish catch in Switzerland - Project Fishnet:Abalancebetween
analysisandsynthesis.AquatSci64:36-54.Hari, RE. Livingstone,DM. Siber,R. Burkhardt-Holm, P.Güttinger,H. 2006:Consequences of climatic change forwater
temperatureandbrowntroutpopulationsinAlpineriversandstreams.GlobalChangeBiology12:10-26.Margot,J.2008:Impactsdesdéversoirsd’oragesurlescoursd’eau.ApplicationdelaméthodologieSTORMetvalidationpar
lebiaisd’analysesécotoxicologiquesetchimiques.MasterThesisEPFL,274pp+annexes.Rossi,L.Hari,RE.2007:Screeningproceduretoassesstheimpactofurbanstormwatertemperaturetopopulationsofbrown
troutinreceivingwater.IntegratedEnvironmentalAssessmentandManagementJournal3:383-392.VSA. 2007:Urbanwet-weather discharges in receivingwaters: guidelines for the conceptual planning of protection
measures(STORMguidelines,availableinFrench,GermanandItalian).SwissWaterPollutionControlAssociation,www.vsa.ch,Zürich,Switzerland.
196Sy
mp
osi
um
5:
Me
teo
rolo
gy
an
d c
lim
ato
log
y
13
15
17
19
21
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
7 7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 8
11 -12
10 -11
9 -10
8-9
7 -8
6 -7
5 -6
4 -5
3-4
2 -3
1-2
0 -1
Figure1.ExampleoftheinfluenceoftemperatureandpHonthenumberofcriticalammoniatoxicityeventsperyearinastream(Margot,
2008).InSwitzerland,onecriticaleventin5yearsistolerated(VSA2007).
5.9
Should climate models be evaluated with statistic-based or process-based metrics?
Schaller,Nathalie1,Mahlstein,Irina1&Knutti,Reto1
1 Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science, ETH Zurich
Inthediscussiononthegreenhouse-inducedclimatechange,modificationsinthehydrologicalcycleareofparticularin-terestsincetheyareexpectedtohavesevereconsequencesforsocietiesandecosystems(IPCC,2007).Unfortunately,themo-delspreadforprecipitationislargeandprecisestatementsaboutfuturechangesintheprecipitationpatternsaredifficulttoprovide.Theevaluationofclimatemodelsisarelativelynewresearchfieldandthus,sofarnostandardizedmetricfordefiningaclimatemodel'sskillhasbeendefined.Recently,someattemptshavebeenmadetorankorweightthemodel'sprojections(Phillips&Gleckler,2006,Gleckleretal.,2008,Pincusetal.,2008).Thereby,thefavouredwaytoproceedwastoevaluatethemodelsimulationsagainstobservationsusingstatisticalmeasures.However,wesuspectthatdependingonthepurposeandthevariableconsidered,process-basedmetricsdefinedonaregionalscalearemoresuitabletoidentifythegoodmodelsthanstatisticalmeasuresdefinedonaglobalscale.Here,wecomparethreedifferentwaysofrankingtheclimatemodels,namelyastatistic-basedrankingconsideringabroadrangeofclimatevariablesperformedbyReichler&Kim(2008),astatistic-basedrankingconsideringonlytheprecipitationfieldandaprocess-basedrankingconsistingofsixmetricsrepresentingregionalfeaturesofthemodelledprecipitationresponsetoclimatechange.Surprisingly,themultimodelmeanperformsonlyaveragefortheprocess-basedranking,whileitoutperformsallsinglemodelsinthestatistics-basedrankings.Themodelsperformingbestcanbedifferentforeachregionorzoneconsideredandidentifyingthemeachtimenewlydependingontheapplicationmayallowformorereliableprojections.Further,consideringonlythefivebestmodelsforeachmetricallowsforareductionofthemodelspreadandthus,formorepreciseinformationaboutthefutureclimatestate.
REFERENCESGleckler,P.J.,K.E.Taylor,&C.Doutriaux,2008:Performancemetricsforclimatemodels.JournalOfGeophysicalResearch-
Atmospheres,113(D6),D06,104.IPCC(2007),Climatechange,2007:Thephysicalsciencebasis.ContributionofworkinggroupItothefourthassessmentreport
oftheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange[Solomon,S.,D.Qin,M.Manning,Z.Chen,M.Marquis,K.B.Averyt,M.Tignor&H.L.Miller(eds)],CambridgeUniversityPress,Cambridge,UnitedKingdomandNewYork,NY,USA,p.996.
197
Sym
po
siu
m 5
: M
ete
oro
log
y a
nd
cli
ma
tolo
gy Phillips,T.J.&P.J.Gleckler,2006:Evaluationofcontinentalprecipitationin20thcenturyclimatesimulations:Theutility
ofmultimodelstatistics.WaterResourcesResearch,42(3).Pincus,R.,C.P.Batstone,R.J.P.Hofmann,K.E.Taylor,&P.J.Glecker,2008:Evaluatingthepresent-daysimulationofclouds,
precipitation,andradiationinclimatemodels.JournalOfGeophysicalResearch-Atmospheres,113(D14),D14,209.Reichler,T.&J.Kim,2008:Howwelldocoupledmodelssimulatetoday'sclimate?BulletinOfTheAmericanMeteorological
Society,80(3),303-311.
5.10
The MeteoSwiss strategy for the renewal of the precipitation measure-ment network
CatherineStocker-Mittaz,ChristianHäberli,ChristophFrei,UrsGermann1
1Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss, Krähbühlstrasse 58, CH-8044 Zürich ([email protected])
Therequirementsforprecipitationdatahaveriseninrecentyears:inparticular,meteorologists(eg,forthewarningofex-tremeevents)andhydrologists(eg,calculationofthearealprecipitationforfloodwarnings)aredependingonprecipitationinformationwithbothahighspatialandtemporalresolution.Asaresultoftheincreasinguseofprecipitationdatainfore-castmodels(runoffforecasting,snowpackdevelopment,agriculture,etc.)theneedforquantitativeprecipitationfieldshasincreased.Fortheseapplicationsahighabsoluteaccuracyandhighspatial/temporalresolutionisrequiredandthedataneedtobeavailableasfastaspossible.
TheconventionalprecipitationmonitoringnetworkofMeteoSwiss started inDecember1863.Precipitationamountsandsnowheightsaremeasuredmanuallyonceperday.Neitherthemethodofobservationnortheprocessingofthedatahavebeensubstantiallyadaptedtonewtechnologies.
Duetotheincreaseddemands,bothsomecantonsandprivateinstitutionsdesignedtheirownmeasurementnetworksandoperateapproximately300automaticprecipitationstationsinSwitzerland.Inaddition,thecantonsareincreasinglyinteres-tedinco-operationregardingdesignandoperationofmeasurementstationsandhandlingofdatawithMeteoSwiss.
InthecontextoftherollingrequirementsreviewthedifferentobservingsystemsandnetworksfromMeteoSwisswereinte-grallyconsideredandtheMeteoSwissstrategyfortherenewaloftheprecipitationmeasurementnetworkwasdeveloped.
Acomparisonofthevariousobservingsystems,precipitationanalysisandproductsshowsthestrengthsandweaknessesofthepossiblecombinationsofthedifferentmeasurementplatforms(automaticsurfacestations,conventionalprecipitationmeasurementnetwork,radar).Forapplicationswiththedemandsofahighspatialandtemporalresolutionandhighabso-luteaccuracynoneoftheproductsturnsoutasappropriate.
Requirementsforprecipitationinformationfromclimatology,meteorology,hydrologyandradartechnology,togetherwiththeresultingstrengthsandweaknessesofcurrentproducts,resultinastrategywithwhichthedeficienciesofthecurrentmonitoringnetworkshallbecountered:
• MeteoSwissprovidesspatiallycomprehensivedatasetswithhightemporalresolution(atleasthourly)thatallowstate-mentsabouttheprecipitationpatternsintheindividualregionsforwarningsinSwitzerland(138).
• MeteoSwissprovidesatleastinday-resolutiondatasetsthatallowstatementsabouttheprecipitationpatternsinareassmallerthantheregionsforwarnings.Theserecordshaveahigherabsoluteaccuracythantheoneswithhightemporalresolution.
• MeteoSwissprovideslongprecipitationdataseries(alsofortotalandfreshsnowheight)forstatisticalevaluationsandtakesthenecessarymeasurestosecurethesites,whichareimportantforthecomprehensivemonitoringofclimatologi-calprecipitationconditions(includingsnowheights)inSwitzerland.
• MeteoSwissoffersastandardizedproductportfolioinwhichtheserecordscanbeprovidedcustomer-oriented.
Approximately50additional,fullyequipped(notonlyprecipitation)surfacestations,100automaticandabout200conven-tionalprecipitationstationsresult(mostlyatsitesoftheexistingprecipitationmeasurementnetwork).ThenewstationswillbebuiltandoperatedbyMeteoSwiss.Forspecificneeds,thisnetworkshallbecompletedwithstationsofthefederalgovernmentand the cantons.Theseadditional stations shallbe certifiedand thus receivea status similar to stationsofMeteoSwiss(includingdatastorageintheMeteoSwissdatawarehouse).
198Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy 6. Darwin, Evolution and Palaeontology
Lionel Cavin
Schweizerische Paläontologische Gesellschaft (SPG/SPS), Kommission der Schweizerischen Paläontologischen Abhandlungen (KSPA), Swiss Commission of Palaeontology Award
6.1 BeckerD.,BergerJ.-P.,HiardF.,Menkveld-GfellerU.,MennecartB.&ScherlerL.:LateAquitanianmammalsfromtheEngehaldelocality(Bern,Switzerland)
6.2 BrühwilerT.,BucherH.,GoudemandN.,WareD.,HermannE.:Smithianammonoids(EarlyTriassic):explosiveevolu-tionaryradiationfollowingthePermian/Triassicmassextinction
6.3 Buffetaut,E.:Darwiniandinosaurs:missinglinksorevolutionaryfailures?
6.4 GiraultF.E.&ThiersteinH.R.:DiatomassemblageturnoverintheNW-Pacificatthe2.73Maclimatetransition
6.5 GiraultF.E.,WellerA.F.&ThiersteinH.R.:Neogeneglobalcooling:diatomsizevariabilityinachangingocean
6.6 GoudemandN.,OrchardM.,TafforeauP.,UrdyS.,BrühwilerT.,BucherH.,BrayardA.,GalfettiT.,MonnetC.,LebrunR.&ZollikoferC.:PaleobiologyofEarlyTriassicconodonts:implicationsofnewlydiscoveredfusedclustersimagedbyX-raysynchrotronmicrotomography
6.7 Klug C., Kröger B., Kiessling W., Mullins G.L., Servais T., Frýda J., Korn D. & Turner S.: The Devonian NektonRevolution
6.8 KlugC.,SchulzH.&DeBaetsK.:RedtrilobiteswithgreeneyesfromtheDevonianofMorocco
6.9 KlugC.,SchweigertG.,FuchsD.&DietlG.:Firstrecordofabelemnitepreservedwithbeaks,armsandinksacfromtheNusplingenLithographicLimestone(Kimmeridgian,SWGermany)
6.10 LavoyerT.,BertrandY.&BergerJ.-P.:Theborehole01983X2854(Preuschdorf,UpperRhineGraben,Alsace,France)asabasisofaformaldefinitionoftheUpperPechelbronnBeds(Rupelian)
6.11 MenncartB.,BeckerD.&BergerJ.-P.:DeterminationofthepaleodietandthephylogenyofextinctruminantsusingRelativeWrapAnalysisonmandibles:caseofIberomeryxminor(Mammalia,Artiodactyla)
6.12 Monnet C., Hugo B., Guex J. & Wasmer M.: Macroevolutionary trends of Acrochordiceratidae Arthaber, 1911(Ammonoidea,MiddleTriassic)
6.13 RomanoC.&BrinkmannW.:Reinvestigationofthebasalray-finnedfishBirgeriastensioeifromtheMiddleTriassicofMonteSanGiorgio(Switzerland)andBesano(Italy)
6.14 Scherler,L.TütkenT.,BeckerD.&BergerJ.-P.:TerrestrialpalaeoclimaticalandpalaeoenvironmentalreconstructionsinNorthwesternSwitzerland:carbonandoxygenisotopecompositionsofEarlyOligoceneandLatePleistoceneverte-brateremains.
6.15 UrdyS.,GoudemandN.,BucherH.&MonnetC.:Howdorecurrentpatternsofcovariationinmolluscanshellsconnecttogrowthdynamics?
199
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
y6.1
Late Aquitanian mammals from the Engehalde locality (Bern, Switzerland)
DamienBecker1,Jean-PierreBerger2,FlorentHiard2,UrsulaMenkveld-Gfeller3,BastienMennecart2,&LaurelineScherler2,1
1Section d’archéologie et paléontologie, République et Canton du Jura, Office de la culture, Hôtel des Halles, Case postale 64, 2900 Porrentruy 2, Switzerland ([email protected])2Département de Géosciences, Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Fribourg, Chemin du Musée 6, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland3Natural History Museum Bern, Bernastrasse 15, 3005 Bern, Switzerland
DuetotheconstructionoftheSwissnationalroadfromBerntoWorblaufenin1850,thesandyandmarlydepositsoftheLower FreshwaterMolasse (USM)were excavated in Engehalde. Some specimens of vertebrate fossils (turtles, ruminants,suids,andrhinocerotids)andshellsofgastropodsandbivalveswerebroughttolightbyStuder(1850).ThenStehlin(1914)reportedthepresenceofPalaeochoerus typus,butthereferredmaterialwasnotfoundinthehistoricalcollectionanymore.Thesameauthornotifiedalsotworuminants,Amphitragulus cf. elegansandAmphitragulus lemanense.However,asthesetwotaxaareconsideredsynonyms,onlyAmphitragulus elegensisvalid.Moreover,manyspecimenswronglyascribedto Amphitragulus elegansorAmphitragulus lemanense intheliterature havetobereportedtothecloserspeciesDremotherium feignouxi.There-mainsofrhinocerotidswerereviewedbyBecker(2003)andascribedtoDiaceratherium lemanense:someofthemdisplayderivedmorphologicalcharactersinterpretedasprobableintraspecificvariations.ThesehistoricdiscoveriesallowafirstdatingtotheAquitaniantime.
DuringtheconstructionoftheNeufeldtunnel(2006–2008),theancientfossillocalityofEngehaldewasmadeaccessibleforarestrictedtime.TheNaturalHistoryMuseumBernorganizedanewpalaeontologicalexcavationcampaign.Thediscoveredma-terialdidnotcontainnewrhinocerotidremains,butyieldedessentiallyspecimensofrumiants,composedbyteethandpost-cranialbonesassigned to the“Dremotherium–like”group (probablyDremotherium feignouxi).The lower left jawofamustelid,probablyfromthegenusPalaeogale,Plesictis,orPlesiogale,wasthehighlightofthenewdiscoveries(Fig.1). Thewashingandpi-ckingof sedimentsamplesallowedthesortingofcharophytes fromthegroupStephanochara praeberdotensisaswellas smallmammalremainswithProlagus sp.,Eucricetodoninfralactorensis,Peridyromyssp.andCainotheriumsp.(Menkveld-Gfeller&Becker2008).
Figure1.Lowerleftjawofamustelid-likepredator(fossillength6cm)
Thesenewdata,inparticulartheoccurenceofProlagus sp.andEucricetodoninfralactorensis,allowanimproveddatingofthislocalitytothelateAquitanian(EuropeanMammalReferenceLevelMN2;BurkartEngesser,pers.com.).Thisbiostratigraphicalinterpretation coincides with other well-dated localities reporting similar faunal composition, like the derived form ofDiaceratherium lemanense (Becker et al. 2009) and the representatives of the Amphitragulus elegans – Dremotherium feignouxigroup(Gentryetal.1999).Regardingthepalaeosynecology,thereferredmammalassociationdoesnotpermitanaccuratecharacterization of the environment of the Bern area during the late Aquitanian. However, the representatives of theAmphitragulus elegans – Dremotherium feignouxigroupcouldpointtotheexistenceofawoodedenvironment.TheirassociationwithDiaceratherium lemanense underlinesprobablyabushlandinatransitionalzonebetweenforestandgrassland.Moreover,the lithofaciesof thetrappingsediments (fluvialsandsandfloodplainmarls) indicateanenvironmentprobablyclosetobodiesofwaterorswamps.
200Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy REFERENCES
Becker, D. 2003: Paléoécologie et paléoclimats de laMolasse du Jura (Oligo-Miocène): apport des Rhinocerotoidea(Mammalia)etdesminérauxargileux.PhDThesis,UniversityofFribourg,GeoFocus9,327pp.
Menkveld-Gfeller,U.&Becker,D.2008:BaustelleZubringerNeufeld:eineneuealteFossilfundstelle.BulletinfürangewandteGeologie13,107-112.
Becker,D.,Bürgin,T.,Oberli,U.&Scherler,L.2009:AjuvenileskullofDiaceratheriumlemanense(Rhinocerotidae)fromtheAquitanianofEschenbach(easternSwitzerland).NeuesJahrbuchfürGeologieundPaläontologieAbhandlungen254,5–39.
Gentry,A.W.,Rössner,G.E.&Heizmann,E.P.J.1999:SuborderRuminantia.In RössneR, G.e. & HeIssIG, K. (eds.): THe MIocene Land MaMMaLs of euRope. VeRLaG dR. fRIedRIcH pfeIL, MüncHen, 225–258.
Studer,B.1850:ÜberdieSüsswassermolassebeiBern.MitteilungenderNaturforschendenGesellschaftinBern178,89–92.
6.2
Smithian ammonoids (Early Triassic): explosive evolutionary radiation following the Permian/Triassic mass extinction1
BrühwilerThomas1,BucherHugo1,2,GoudemandNicolas1,WareDavid1,HermannElke1
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum der Universität Zürich, Karl Schmid-Strasse 4, 8006 Zürich ([email protected]) 2Department of Earth Sciences, ETH, Universitätsstrasse 16, 8092 Zürich
In the aftermath of the end-Permianmass extinction, ammonoidswere among the fastest clades to recover: the recentanalysisofaglobaldiversitydatasetofammonoidgenerafromtheLateCarboniferoustotheLateTriassicshowsthatTriassicammonoidsactuallyreachedlevelsofdiversityhigherthaninthePermianlessthan2millionyearsafterthePTB(Brayardetal.,2009).TheevolutionofEarlyTriassicammonoidswasnotasmooth,norgradualprocess. It ischaracterizedbythefollowingmainfeatures:(i)averylowdiversityintheGriesbachian(earlyInduan),(ii)amoderatediversityincreaseintheDienerian(lateInduan),(iii)anexplosiveradiationintheearlySmithian(earlyOlenekian),(iv)alateSmithianextinctioneventfollowedbyasecondexplosiveradiationintheearlySpathian(lateOlenekian)(Brayardetal.,2006,2009).
InordertobetterunderstandtheSmithianammonoidradiationweconductedextensivefieldstudiesintwoclassicalregionsfortheEarlyTriassic,namelytheSaltRange(Pakistan)andSpiti (IndianHimalayas).Smithianammonoidsfromthesere-gionshavebeenknownformorethanacentury,andtheseplacesarethetypelocalitiesofmanytaxa(e.g.Waagen,1895;Krafft&Diener,1909).Additionally,westudiedasectionatTulong(SouthTibet)aswellasextremelyammonoid-richexoticblocksofHallstattLimestoneintheOmanMountains.
Ourabundant,bed-rock-controlledandwell-preservedmaterialenablesustorevisemanyclassicalammonoidtaxathatwerepreviouslyknownonlyinadequately.Moreover,alargenumberofnewtaxawasfound,whichenablesustodefineonenewfamily,18newgeneraandabout29newspecies.Atotalofeightsuccessiveammonoidassociationscanbecorrelatedbetweenoursections(Brühwileretal.,2007).Thishigh-resolutionbiochronologicalschemefortheSmithianoftheNorthernIndianMargincanbecorrelatedwithammonoidsuccessionsfromotherregionssuchasSouthChina(Brayard&Bucher,2008).
DuetotheveryhighevolutionaryratesofEarlyTriassicammonoids(Brayardetal.,2009)thereconstructionofphylogeneticrelationshipsamongSmithianammonoidsisdifficult.However,ourwell-constrainedtaxonomicandbiochronologicdataprovidenewinsightsontheevolutionofseverallineages.Furthermore,theongoingcomprehensivestudyofDienerianam-monoidfaunasfromtheSaltRangeandfromSpiti(Wareetal.)willhelpustodecifertheoriginofsomeSmithianammo-noids.
1ThisresearchissupportedbytheSwissNSFproject200020-113554.
REFERENCESBrayard,A.&Bucher,H. 2008: Smithian (Early Triassic) ammonoid faunas fromnorthwesternGuangxi (SouthChina):
taxonomyandbiochronology.FossilsandStrata,55,1-179.Brayard,A.,Bucher,H.,Escarguel,G., Fluteau,F.,Bourquin,S.&Galfetti,T.2006:TheEarlyTriassicammonoidrecovery:
Paleoclimaticsignificanceofdiversitygradients.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology,239,374–395.Brayard,A.,Escarguel,G.,Bucher,H.,Monnet,C.,Brühwiler,T.,Goudemand,N.,Galfetti,T.&Guex,J.,2009:GoodGenesand
GoodLuck:AmmonoidDiversityandtheEnd-PermianMassExtinction.Science,325,1118-1121.Brühwiler,T.,Bucher,H.,Goudemand,N.&Brayard,A.2007:Smithian(EarlyTriassic)ammonoidfaunasoftheTethys:new
preliminaryresultsfromTibet,India,PakistanandOman.TheglobalTriassic:NewMexicoMuseumofNaturalHistoryandScienceBulletin,41.
Krafft,A.v.&Diener,C.,1909:LowerTriassiccephalopodafromSpiti,MallaJohar,andByans.PalaeontologiaIndica,ser.15,6,1-186.
Waagen,W.,1895:Salt-Rangefossils.Vol2:FossilsfromtheCeratiteFormation.PalaeontologiaIndica13,1-323.
201
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
y6.3
Darwinian dinosaurs : missing links or evolutionary failures ?
EricBuffetaut
CNRS, UMR 8538, Laboratoire de Géologie de l’Ecole Normale Supérieure, 24 rue Lhomond, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France ([email protected])
CharlesDarwindidnotoftenmentiondinosaursinhisworks.InthethirdeditionofOn the origin of species (1861,p.346),healludedtotheminachapteraboutextinction:“Solittleisthissubjectunderstood,thatIhaveheardsurpriserepeatedlyexpressedatsuchgreatmonstersastheMastodonandthemoreancientDinosaurianshavingbecomeextinct;asifmerebodilystrengthgavevictoryinthebattleoflife.Meresize,onthecontrary,wouldinsomecasesdeterminequickerextermi-nationfromthegreateramountofrequisitefood”.Tenyearslater,inThe descent of man, and selection in relation to sex(1871,p.204),heemphasizedtheirevolutionarysignificance:“Prof.Huxleyhasmadetheremarkablediscovery,confirmedbyMr.Copeandothers,thattheoldDinosauriansareintermediateinmanyimportantrespectsbetweencertainreptilesandcer-tainbirds—thelatterconsistingoftheostrich-tribe(itselfevidentlyawidely-diffusedremnantofalargergroup)andoftheArcheopteryx,thatstrangeSecondarybirdhavingalongtaillikethatofthelizard”.
ThusDarwinillustratedtwoviewsofdinosaursthatweretobecomebothprevalentandcompetinguntiltoday:iconsofex-tinction,ormissinglinks.The“missinglink”interpretationpredominatedduringthelastpartofthe19thcenturyandthebeginningofthe20th,whendinosaurswerewidelyconsideredasancestraltobirds,onthebasisofosteologicalresemblanceandthediscoveryofbothArchaeopteryxandthe“toothedbirds”,HesperornisandIchthyornis,fromtheLateCretaceousoftheUnitedStates.Accordingtothisview,dinosaurs,asbirdancestors,hadplayedanimportantpartintheevolutionofoneofthemost successful groupsof living vertebrates. This interpretation fell outof favourduring themid-twentieth century,largelybecauseoftheinfluentialbookbyGerhardHeilmann,The origin of birds (1926), inwhichthepurportedabsenceofclaviclesindinosaurswasusedtodemonstratethattheycouldnotpossiblyhavebeenancestraltobirds(whichpossessclavi-cles)–since“Dollo’slaw”stipulatesthatonceanorganhasbeenlostinthecourseofevolution,itcannotreappearagain.
Asdinosaurscouldnolongerbeseenasancestraltoanything,theyhadtobeconsideredassomekindofevolutionarydeadend,andthisinterpretationprevaileduntilthe1970s.Theimageofthedinosaursastoolarge,tooslowandtoostupidtohavebeenabletosurvivebecameprevalentforalargepartofthe20thcentury.Thiscouldbeseenintermsofnaturalselec-tion,withlargefoodrequirementsasapossibledisadvantage,asalreadymentionedbyDarwinin1861,orintermsofnon-Darwinian,orthogeneticevolutionresultinginnon-adaptivetransformationsdetrimentaltotheorganismsinvolved.Theideathatdinosaursweresomehow“doomed”toextinctionbyratherobscureevolutionarymechanismsbecamepopularforalongtime.
Thingschangedagaininthe1970swhendinosaurbiologywasthoroughlyreinterpretedandtheimageofsluggish,cold-blooded giantswas challenged and a new view of dinosaurs asmore active, possiblywarm-blooded, animals graduallyemerged.Thiswenttogetherwithareappraisalofdinosaur-birdrelationships,basedonnewdiscoveriesofsmallcarnivo-rousdinosaursanddescriptionsofnewspecimensofArchaeopteryx,whichresultedinarebirthofthehypothesisofthedi-nosaurian ancestry of birds. This was strengthened by the discovery of clavicles in many dinosaurs (thus eliminatingHeilmann’sobjection)andbythatofthefamous“feathereddinosaurs”fromtheEarlyCretaceousofChina,whichprovideextremelystrongevidenceinfavourofaclosephylogeneticrelationshipbetweensmalltheropoddinosaursandbirds.
Inthe1980s, thequestionofdinosaurextinctionalsounderwentarevival,withinthe larger frameworkofcatastrophiceventsattheCretaceous-Tertiaryboundary.Thediscoveryofthemajorasteroidimpactthathappened65millionyearsagoledtoathoroughreconsiderationofthepossiblecausesofterminalCretaceousextinctions, includingthatofnon-aviandinosaurs.Seenaspartofmajorextinctioneventaffectingmanygroupsoforganismsinvariousenvironments,inalllike-lihoodcausedbytheimpactofanextra-terrestrialobject,thedisappearanceofthedinosaurscouldnolongerbeseenastheresultofsomemysteriousinabilitytoadapttogradualenvironmentalchange.AlthoughthedetailsofdinosaurextinctionattheendoftheCretaceousremaintobeworkedout,thereasonfortheirdisappearanceisnowmuchclearerthanitwasbeforethediscoveryoftheend-Cretaceousimpact–andDarwin’soriginalremarkabouttheimportanceoffoodresources(orthelackthereof)takesonanewsignificanceinviewofcurrenthypothesesaboutthecollapseoffoodwebsfollowingtheasteroidimpact.
Althoughtheevolutionarysignificanceofdinosaurs,bothintermsofextinctionandofintermediateforms,wasapparenttoDarwin,andtoquiteafewofhisfollowers,includingHuxley,inthe19thcentury,itwasunderratedduringmuchofthe20thcentury.Itisonlysincethe1990sthatpalaeontologistshaverecognisedagainthatdinosaurswerenotsimplyanextinctgroupofreptiles,butwereinfactthesourceofoneofthemajorgroupsoflivingvertebrates,viz.thebirds,andthatthedemiseofnon-aviandinosaurswastheresultofanexceptionalglobalevent,ratherthantheconsequenceofsomekindofnon-adaptiveevolution.Theexampleofdinosaursillustrateswellhowtheoutdatedconceptof“evolutionaryfailures”hasbeensupersededbyamoretrulyDarwinianinterpretationofthefossilrecord.
202Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy REFERENCES
Darwin,C.1861:On the origin of species by means of natural selection, or the preservation of favoured races in the struggle for life.3rdedition.JohnMurray,London.
Darwin,C.1871:The descent of man, and selection in relation to sex.JohnMurray,London.Heilmann,G.1926:The origin of birds.Witherby,London.
6.4
Diatom assemblage turnover in the NW-Pacific at the 2.73 Ma climate transition
GiraultFranceE.&ThiersteinHansR.
Geological Institute, ETH, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092, Zurich ([email protected])
TheNorthPacificcontainsacriticaldiatomsedimentaryrecordoftheCenozoicglobalcoolinghistory.ThemoststrikingpartofthatrecordcoverstheultimateclosureofthePanamaSeaway2.73MaagowhichwassynchronouswiththeonsetofNorthernHemisphereglaciations(NHG).Thesephysicalchangeswereconcomitantwithanabruptchangeinthebiologicalpumpefficiencyrelatedtotheonsetofoceansurfacewaterstratification.TheODPsite882record(Leg145)-withitswellconstrainedNeogenepaleoceanographichistoryaroundthe2.73Matransi-tion-providesanexcellentbasistotestpatternsandpotentialcontrolsofdiatomsizevariabilityandspeciesdominance.Frustulesizesofcentricdiatomshavebeenquantifiedtobetterunderstandtheenvironmentalresponseoftheseorganismstoadrasticandpermanentpaleoceanographicandclimaticchange.Sizeandmorphologicalcharacteristicsofthecentricdiatomfrustules (diameter>20µm)werecollectedforastatisticallyrepresentativenumberofspecimens(i.e.250-700)persampleusingrecentlydevelopedautomatedlightmicroscopyandim-ageanalysistechniques.
6.5
Neogene global cooling: diatom size variability in a changing ocean
GiraultFranceE.1,WellerAndrewF.1,2&ThiersteinHansR.
1 Geological Institute, ETH, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092, Zurich ([email protected])2 Present address: Geosoft Australia Pty Ltd, 14/100 Railway Road, Subiaco WA 6008, Australia
Overthepast40Ma,thedevelopmentandstepwiseexpansionoftheAntarcticice-sheet,togetherwithtectonicmovements(e.g.closureofthePanamaisthmus)havedeeplymodifiedthepatternsofglobalcirculationandchemicalsignatureofthevariouswatermasses(e.g.redistributionofdissolvedsilica).Thesechangeshavealsoinducedthedevelopmentofoceanicboundaries(e.g.Polarfront),directlyaffectingtheevolutionofplankticmicro-organisms.Usingthewidespreadrecordof siliceousmicrofossils (SouthernOcean,EquatorialPacificandNorthPacific),wehaveas-sessedtheimpactsoftheseoceanographicreorganizationsondiatoms,focusingonsizeandtaxonomicchangesandturno-versamongcentricdiatomsoverthepast15Ma.TheabilityofdiatomstoadaptandsurviveinachangingoceanhasprobablybeenakeyfortheirsurvivalespeciallyovertheNeogene,whenclimaticandoceanographicchangeshavebeenthestrongest.Similarly,sizevariabilityamongthisgrouptightlyreflectstheirresponsetoenvironmentalperturbationsaswellastheirtaxonomicturnoversthathavebeendrivingdiatomevolutionarypatternstowardhighlydiverseandendemiccommunitiesprevailingintoday’soceans.
203
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
y6.6
Paleobiology of Early Triassic conodonts: implications of newly discove-red fused clusters imaged by X-ray synchrotron microtomography
GoudemandNicolas1,OrchardMichael2,TafforeauPaul3,UrdySéverine1,BrühwilerThomas1,BucherHugo1,BrayardArnaud§,GalfettiThomas1,MonnetClaude1,LebrunRenaud§§&ZollikoferChristoph§§
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Universität Zurich, Karl Schmid-Str. 4, 8006 Zürich ([email protected]). 2Geological Survey of Canada, 101-605 Robson St., Vancouver,BC, V6B 5J3 Canada.3European Synchrotron Radiation Facility, 6 rue Jules Horowitz, BP 220, 38043 Grenoble cedex, France. §UMR-CNRS 5561 Biogéosciences, Université de Bourgogne, 6 Bd Gabriel, 21000 Dijon, France.§§Anthropologisches Institut und Museum, Universität Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zürich
SeveralfusedclustersofconodontelementsoftheEarlyTriassicgenusNovispathodus werediscoveredinlimestonebedsattheSmithian-Spathianboundary(LuolouFormation.,Galfettiet al.,2008)fromseverallocalitieswithintheGuangxiprovinceof South China. Conodont clusters are groups ofmorphologically different elements belonging to the same individual,whichweresomehowcementedtogetherpost-mortem.SuchspecimensofexceptionalpreservationareextremelyrareintheTriassicandthesearethefirstreportedfortheEarlyTriassic.Ourfusedclusterspartiallypreservetherelativethree-dimensionalpositionandorientationofsomeramiform,graspingelements.Theyarethereforeextremelyimportantforourunderstandingofthefeedingapparatusesofconodonts.Becauseoftheintricategeometryofthesuperposedelements,oftheirfragilityandoftheirextremerarity,itisusuallytrickytostudysuchspecimens.Weovercometheseproblemsbyperformingapropagationphasecontrastsynchrotronmicrotom-ography(Tafforeauet al.,2006).Apinkbeamsetupat17.6keV,whichwasveryrecentlydevelopedattheEuropeanSynchrotronRadiationFacilityonbeamlineID19,hasbeensuccessfullytestedonourconodonts.Thisnewtechniqueenablesasubmicronresolution(0.23µm)withaspeedandanoverallqualityneverreachedbefore.Somefusedclustersaswellasco-occurringisolatedelementsfromthesamesampleandpertainingtothesamemulti-elementspecieswerescannedusingthistech-nique.BesidestaxonomicrevisionoftheGondolelloideasuperfamily(themostsignificantgroupofconodontsduringPermianandTriassictimes),thisdiscoveryledustoproposeanewfunctionalmodel.Inourview,thebestsolutionimpliesthepresenceofapresumablycartilaginous‘copula’,uponwhichtheconodontele-mentsaremovingindependently,moreorlessasdodentalplatesinextantlampreys,butnotstrictlyasproposedbyPurnellandDonoghue (1997).Wesuggest thatduringretractiontowards thecaudally locatedplatform (cuttingorgrinding)ele-ments,theS0elementfirsthasaclosing,rotatingmovement,mostprobablysynchronizedwiththeclosureoftheMele-ments,withwhichitwouldhaveperformedapinching,seizingfunction.Thismovementisthenfollowedbyasub-straight,dorso-caudallydirectedtranslation,bywhichitwouldhavetornofftheprey’s‘flesh’andbroughtittowardstheplatformelements.ThelattermovementisaccompaniedbytheclosureoftheotherSelements,channellingthefoodintheappropri-atedirection.Consideringthatthepresenceofsuch‘copula’associatedwithtongueprotractorandretractormuscleshasbeenassertedonlyforextantcyclostomes(hagfishesandlampreys;Yalden,1985;Donoghueet al.,2000),ournewmodelmayprovideim-portantinsightsfordecipheringtheaffinityofconodontsandforourgeneralunderstandingoftheoriginofvertebrates.
AcknowledgementsThisresearchissupportedbytheSwissNSFproject200020-113554.WeacknowledgetheEuropeanSynchrotronRadiationforprovisionofsynchrotronradiationfacilitiesandforgrantingaccesstobeamlineID19.
Figure1.Animated3dreconstructionofthefeedingapparatusofNovispathodus.
REFERENCESGalfetti,T.,Bucher,H.,Martini,R.,Hochuli,P.A.,Weissert,H.,Crasquin-Soleau,S.,Brayard,A.,Goudemand,N.,Brühwiler,
T.&Guodun,Kuang2008. Evolutionof Early Triassic outerplatformpaleoenvironments in theNanpangjiangBasin
204Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy (SouthChina)andtheirsignificanceforthebioticrecovery.Sed.Geol.204:36-60.
Tafforeau, P., et al. 2006. Applications of X-ray synchrotronmicrotomography for non-destructive 3d studies ofpaleontologicalspecimens.Appl.Phys.A83:195-202.
Purnell,M.A.&Donoghue,P.C.J.1997.ArchitectureandfunctionalmorphologyoftheskeletalapparatusofOzarkodinidconodonts.Phil.Trans.R.Soc.Lond.B352:1545-64.
Yalden,D.W.1985.Feedingmechanismsasevidenceofcyclostomemonophyly.Zool.J.Linn.Soc.84:291-300.Donoghue,P.C.J.,Forey,P.L.&Aldridge,R.J.2000.Conodontaffinityandchordatephylogeny.Biol.Rev.75:191-251.
6.7
The Devonian Nekton Revolution
Christian Klug1, Björn Kröger2, Wolfgang Kiessling2, Gary L. Mullins3, Thomas Servais4, Jiří Frýda5, Dieter Korn2 & Sue Turner6
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Universität Zürich, Karl Schmid-Strasse 4, CH-8006 Zürich, Switzerland, ([email protected]) 2Museum für Naturkunde, Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Invalidenstraße 43, D-10115 Berlin, Germany3Department of Geology, The University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester, LE1 7RH, United Kingdom4Laboratoire de Paléontologie et Paléogéographie du Paléozoïque, UMR 8014 du CNRS, Université des Sciences et Technologies de Lille, SN5 Cité Scientifique, F-59655 Villeneuve d’Ascq, France5Faculty of Environmental Science, Czech University of Life Sciences, Kamýcká 129, 165 21 Praha 6 Suchdol, Czech Republic6Queensland Museum, 122 Gerler Rd., Hendra, Queensland 4011, Australia
ImpressivediscoveriesofNeoproterozoicandEarlyPalaeozoicFossillagerstaettendrewtheattentiononevolutionaryandecologicalprocessesofthesetimespans.Italmostseemedthat,exceptforsomeofthe“BigFive”,nothingessentialhappenedaftertheOrdovician.Suchascenarioiscertainlynottrue.
Contrariwise,somemajorecologicalfluctuationshavebeenrecordedfromtheDevonian,severalofwhichhavelesspromi-nentSilurianprecursors.Famousexamplesaretheradiationoflandplantsandjawedfish(bothknownalreadyfromthepre-Devonian).DuringtheDevonian,severalanimalgroupsconqueredtheland(variousarthropodsandpossiblytetrapods).Marineinvertebratesshowsignificantecologicalandmorphologicalchanges:Importantcephalopodgroupssuchasbactri-toidsaswellasammonoidsevolvedandreefgrowthincreaseduntiltheLateDevoniancrises.Boththeglobalriseandfallofdacryoconaridsoccurred,graptolitesbecameextinct,andvariousmollusccladesmodifiedearlyontogeneticstrategiesdur-ingtheDevonian,documentingaplanktonicturnover.Inaddition,thereisamacroecologicalchangeinmarinefaunasfromademersal(swimmingclosetothesea-floor)andplanktonichabittowardsamoreactivenektonichabit.
VariousinterpretationsareathandtoexplainthisDevonianNektonRevolution: (1)Demersalandnektonicmodesoflifewereprobablyinitiallydrivenbycompetitioninthediversity-saturatedbenthichabitatsaswellas(2)theavailabilityofrichplanktonicfoodresources(asreflectedinevolutionaryalterationsinearlyontogeneticstagesofmanymollusks).Escalatoryfeedbacksprobablypromotedtherapidevolutionofnekton(jawedfishandsomederivedcephalopodgroupsinparticular)intheDevonian,assuggestedbythesequenceandtempoofwater-columnoccupation.Potentially,boththeseradiationsandtheGivetiantoFamennianmass-extinctionswerelinkedtoapronouncedincreaseinnutrientinputtoseasurfacewatersduringeutrophicationepisodes.
6.8
Red trilobites with green eyes from the Devonian of Morocco
ChristianKlug1,HartmutSchulz2andKennethDeBaets1
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum der Universität Zürich, Karl Schmid-Str. 4, CH-8006 Zürich ([email protected])2Institut für Geowissenschaften, Eberhard-Karls-Universität Tübingen, Sigwartstr. 10, D-72076 Tübingen, Germany
Latest Emsian (Early Devonian) sediments at the famous mud-mound- and trilobite-locality Hamar Laghdad (Tafilalt,Morocco)yieldedsomewellpreserved,largelyred-colouredremainsofphacopidtrilobites.Closerexaminationrevealedthatonlythelensesoftheeyesofthesephacopidsareusuallygreenishincolour.EDX-analysesshowedthatthelensesretainedtheiroriginalcalciticcompositionwhilemostoftheexoskeletonwassilicified.Thesilicifiedpartscontainelevatedconcen-trationsofironwhichcausestheredcolour.
205
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
yPresumably,theprimaryporosityofmostofthephacopidexoskeletonexceptthechitinouslegsandthelenseswas,becauseoftheporecanals,higherthanthatofthelenses,facilitatingthereplacementofcalcitebyotherminerals.Furthermore,thepresenceoforganiccomponentsinthelensesincombinationwithahomogeneousdistributionofthecalcitecrystalsmighthaveslightlyincreasedtheresistanceofthelensestowardsmineralreplacement.Thehomogeneityofthecalcitecrystalsofthelenseswasneededfortheiroptimalopticalfunctionality.Thesefactorsprobablyaccountforthefactthattheeyesreta-ined the calcitewhich is oftengreenish inbrachiopod shells suchas the thick-shelledMiddleDevonianDevonogypa andIvdeliniafromtheMaïderBasinwhiletherestofthetrilobiteexoskeletonisred.Thisdifferentialreplacementalsoexplainswhythelensesareslightlycorrodedwhiletherestoftheexoskeletonissuperficiallywellpreserved.Sofar,thisdifferentialreplacementofcalciteisonlyknownfromtheeyesofphacopids.Othertrilobitetaxafromthesamestrataandlocalityhaveholochroaleyesandthusmuchsmallerlenseswhichwereprobablymorerapidlyreplacedbysilica.Thegreenishcolourofthe lensesmightoriginatefromimpuritiesof ironandmagnesium;theconcentrationsofthecorrespondingionsmighthavebeentoolowtobedetectedwiththeEDXwithcertainty.
HamarLaghdadalsoyieldedphacopidexoskeletonswith lesscompletelysilicifiedexoskeletonswhichenabledadetailedreconstructionofthesilicificationprocess.Initially,onlytheoutersurfaceoftheexoskeletonandthevicinityofporecanalsweresilicified.Inasecondstep,thebendinthegrowthlinesoftheinterlensarscleraweresilicifiedtogetherwiththere-mainingexoskeletonexceptforthelenses,thenthecompleteinterlensarscleraandintheendalsothelenses.
6.9
First record of a belemnite preserved with beaks, arms and ink sac from the Nusplingen Lithographic Limestone (Kimmeridgian, SW Germany)
ChristianKlug1,GünterSchweigert2,DirkFuchs3andGerdDietl2
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Karl Schmid-Str. 4, CH-8006 Zürich ([email protected])2Staatliches Museum für Naturkunde, Rosenstein 1, D-70191 Stuttgart, Germany3Institut für Geowissenschaften, Freie Universität Berlin, Malteserstr. 74-100, D-12249 Berlin, Germany
A recent discovery of anunusually preserved belemnite fromNusplingen comprises the extraordinarily rare remains ofbeaksandnearly in situ arm-hooksaswellas the ink sacand the incompletephragmocone.So far,Hibolithes semisulcatus(Münster, 1830) is the only larger belemnite known from the Nusplingen Lithographic Limestone (Upper Jurassic, LateKimmeridgian,BeckeriZone,UlmenseSubzone;SWGermany)whichhasthesamephragmoconeshapeandsize,thusweassignthenewspecimentothistaxon.Therostrumwasprobablylostduetoalethalpredationattemptinwhichthepreywaskilledbutnotentirelyeaten.Forthefirsttime,aspecimenrevealsdetailsofthebelemnitebeakmorphology,whichwecomparetothebeaksofotherJurassiccephalopods.Thisspecimenpresentlyrepresentstheonlyknownrostrum-bearingbelemniteofpost-Toarcianagewhichhasbeenpreservedwithnon-mineralisedbodyparts.AsHibolithes semisulcatus isknowntopossessonepairofmega-onychites,theabsenceofthoseinthepresentspecimenprovidesevidenceofsexualdimorphisminHibolithes semisulcatus. Thisphenomenonwaspreviouslypresumedforallbelemnites,butitisknownonlyfromPassaloteuthiswithcertaintysince therostrumofthelatterisunambiguouslyassociatedwithanarmcrownthatoccasionallyincludesonepairofmega-onychites.TheimperfectpreservationofthebelemnitebeakshampersadetailedcomparisonwithotherRecentandfossilcoleoidbeaks.Somemorphologicalcharacters(lowwidthoftheouterlamella,doublelaterallobesofthedarkpartsofrostrumandhood,possiblyshortinternallamella)ofthelowerbeakofHibolithes morecloselyresembleRecentde-capodsthanRecentoctopods.TheupperbeakofHibolithes differsinthelong,narrowandcurvedrostrumfromthosecoleoidbeakspreviouslyknownfromNusplingen.Thedarkpartofthelowerbeakalsoshowsauniqueoutlinewithashortandpointedrostrum,anelongateposteroventralextensionandtwosmall roundedsinuseswhichpointedtowards thewings(sometimes similarlydeveloped inRecentSepioteuthis). It appears likely that this beak form is quite characteristic and itmightreflectaspecialdietofthebelemnites.Takingtheirprobablyhighswimmingvelocity(fins,stream-linedbody,andhorizontal orientationof the longest body axis)with the armhooks and the sharpbeaks into account, it appearsquitelikely that belemniteswere fast-swimming, effective,medium-sized predators.With the newdiscovery,NusplingennowrepresentstheonlylocalitywhichhasyieldedcompletebeakapparatusesfromallmajorJurassiccephalopodgroups.
206Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy 6.10
The borehole 01983X2854 (Preuschdorf, Upper Rhine Graben, Alsace, France) as a basis of a formal definition of the Upper Pechelbronn Beds (Rupelian)
LavoyerThibault,YerlyBertrand&BergerJean-Pierre
Département de Géosciences, Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Fribourg, chemin du Musée 6, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland
FromthemiddleEocenetoLateOligocene,anintenselacustrine,brackishandmarinesedimentation,documentedbysaltdepos-itsandoilaccumulation,tookplaceintheUpperRhineGraben(URG),especiallyinthePechelbronnBeds(Lower-,Middle-andUpper).
Althoughtheselayerswerestudied,inthepast,fortheoilindustry(Schnaebele1948)andarealithostratigraphicunitusedinmapsandpapersconcerningthePaleogeneoftheURG,theyhaveneverbeenformallydesignatedbecausetheyalmostnevercropoutat thesurfaceanddriftinganddrillingmaterialswereoftendiscarded.Nevertheless, the InternationalStratigraphicGuide(seeMurphyandSalvador1999),demandsatypesectionforeachformallynamedFormation.
SeveralpalaeogeographicalreconstitutionsandstratigraphicchartsfortheURGhavebeenpublished(Bergeretal.2005a&b).However,theRupeliandepositswerenotwelldefined.
ThisworkpresentsthefirststepforadefinitionofatypesectionofatypesectionoftheUpperPechelbronnBeds,withthepresentationofseverallithofaciesandpaleontologicaldata.
Thestudiedborehole,01983X2854(Preuschdorf,Alsace,France)isacompletecoreddrilling,about220mindepth.Itwasoriginallymadetoevaluateadecontaminationissue,buthasalsoyieldedmicropaleontologicalandsedimentologicaldata.ItcorrespondstotheUpperPechelbronnBedswithasmallpartoftheMiddlePechelbronnBedsatthebase.
Thehighabundanceofostracodsandgastropodsingreymarls,correspondingtothe10lowermeters,indicatethetopoftheMiddlePechelbronnBedswiththeHydrobiaZone.Theselayersarecoveredbyasuccessionofmarlsandsandstone,suggest-ingadifferentenvironment.ThelowerpartoftheboreholeisconsistentwiththelithostratigraphiczonationdefinedbySchnaebele(1948)forhis“normalfacies”whereastheupperpartcorrespondstohis“freshwaterfacies”.
The lower part of the borehole has yielded new paleontological data. Diatoms (Triceratium sp), charophytes (Chara spp.,Rhabdocharasp.), foraminifers (Ammodiscussp.,Quinqueloculinasp.,Flintinasp.,Lenticulinaspp.,Dentalinasp.,Subreophax elon-gates, Vaginulopsis spp.), bivalves, gastropods, bryozoans, ostracods (Grinioneis tribeli, Hazelina indigena, Hemicyprideis spp.,Ilyocyprissp.),insects,echinoderms,fishesandmammalsteethareusedasmainindicatorsofbiostratigraphyandpalaeoecol-ogy.Thefossilrecordemphasizesacomplexalternationoffreshwater,brackishandmarinefaunaalongthewholestudiedsection.
This study is financedby theSNFProject200020-118025 “PaleontologyandStratigraphyof theRhinegrabenduring thePaleogene”,andincludespartsoftheMasters-thesisofB.Yerly“ThetransitionbetweentheMiddleandUpperPechelbronnBedsinthedrilling1983X2854,Preuschdorf(Rupelian,UpperRhineGraben,Alsace,France)”(inprep.2009)andthePhD-thesisofT.Lavoyer“PaleontologyandStratigraphyoftheMiddleUpperRhineGrabenduringthePaleogene:akey-studyfortherelationshipsbetweenRiftsystem,AlpineOrogenyandPaleoclimate”(inprogress).
We thank S. Spezzaferri (Uni. Fr., foraminifers), C. Pirkenseer (Uni. Leuven, ostracods) for fossils determination, P. Elsass(BRGM)andM.Kimmel(Geoderis)forprovidingaccesstothecoredrilling.
REFERENCESBerger,J.-P.etal.,2005a.PaleogeographyoftheUpperRhineGraben(URG)andtheSwissMolasseBasin(SMB)fromEoceneto
Pliocene.InternationalJournalofEarthSciences,94(4):697-710.BergerJ.-P.etal.,2005b.Eocene-PliocenetimescaleandstratigraphyoftheUpperRhineGraben(URG)andtheSwissMolasse
Basin(SMB).InternationalJournalofEarthSciences,94(4):711-731.MurphyM.A.&SalvadorA.1999.InternationalStratigraphicGuideAnabridgedversion.Episodes,Vol.22,no.4SchnaebeleR., 1948.Monographiegéologiquedu champpétrolifèredePechelbronn. –MémoiresduServicede laCarte
géologiqued’AlsaceetdeLorraine,7:254SStrasbourg
207
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
y6.11
Determination of the paleodiet and the phylogeny of extinct ruminants using Relative Wrap Analysis on mandibles: case of Iberomeryx minor (Mammalia, Artiodactyla)
BastienMennecart1,DamienBecker2&Jean-PierreBerger1
1Department of Geosciences – Earth Sciences, ch. du Musée 6, Pérolles, 1700 Fribourg, Switzerland ([email protected])2Section d’archéologie et paléontologie, République et Canton du Jura, Office de la culture, Hôtel des Halles, Case postale 64, 2900 Porrentruy 2, Switzerland
TheprimitiveruminantIberomeryxisessentiallyknownbyfewdentalremainsandisstillpoorlydocumented.Itsphylogenyandpalaeobiologystaysratherenigmatic.Onlytwospecieshavebeendescribed:thetypespeciesI. parvusfromtheBenaralocalityinGeorgia(Gabounia1966),andtheWestEuropeanspeciesI. minorfromItardies,Mounayne,RaynalandRoqueprune2inQuercy (Sudre1987),MontalbaninSpain(Golpe-Posse1974),andLovagny,Soulceand BeuchilleintheSwissMolasseBasin(Beckeretal.2004).I. savageifromIndiahadrecentlybeenplacedinthenewgenusNalameryx (Métaisetal.2009).AlltheselocalitiesaredatedtotheRupelianandcorrespondmainlytoMP23(Europeanmammalbiozone).Basedontheshorttooth-crownheightandthebunoselenodontpatternofthemolars,Sudre(1984)andBeckeretal.(2004)proposedafolivore/frugivoredietforIberomeryx.
Basedonrelativewarpanalysis(24landmarks)of84extantandfossilruminantmandiblesfrom24generaand32species,thisstudyproposesapreliminarydiscussiononthephylogenyandthedietofthegenusIberomeryx.TheresultspermittodifferentiatePecoraandTragulinaonthefirstaxisthankstothelengthofthediastema,thelengthofthepremolarsandthemandibleankle.AssuggestedbySudre(1984),IberomeryxisclosetotheextantTragulinabytheshapeofitsmandible.But,thislatterisclearlydifferentofthoseoftheTragulidae,theonlyextantfamilyinTragulina.Thisdifferenceisessentiallyduetoastockiermandible (condylarprocess,mandibleramusandcorpus mandibulae),andadeepermandibularincisure.Additionally,weobservenodiastemaandwellbunodontteeth.IberomeryxmaybeconsideredasaprimitiveTragulidae,theonlyknownfromtheOligocene,basedonthegeneralshapeofitsmandibleanditsjawteeth.Moreover,itsdietcouldnotbestrictlyfrugivore,butitcouldpossiblyalsoexceptionallyeatsomemeatmattersuchassmallHypertragulidae.
ThisstudyissupportedbytheSectiond'archéologieetpaléontologie(Porrentruy),theUniversityofFribourg,andtheSwissNationalFoundationproject(115995)onthelargemammalevolutionintheSwissMolasseBasinduringtheOligoceneandEarlyMiocene.
REFERENCESBecker,D.,Lapaire,F.,Picot,L.,Engesser,B.&Berger,J.-P.2004:Biostratigraphieetpaléoécologiedugisementàvertébrésde
LaBeuchille(Oligocène,Jura,Suisse).RevuedePaléobiologie,Vol.spéc.9,179-191.Gabounia,L.1966:SurlesMammifèresoligocènesduCaucase.BulletindelaSociétéGéologiquedeFrance7,857-869.Golpe-Posse,J.1974:FaunasdeYacimientosconSuiformesenelTerciarioespanol.PublicacionesdesInstitutoProvincialde
PaleontologiadeSabadell,PaleontologiayEvolucion8,1-87.Métais,G.,Welcomme, J.-L-&Ducrocq, S. 2009:New lophiomericyd ruminants from theOligocene of theBugtiHills
(Balochistan,Pakistan).JournalofVertebratePaleontology29(1),231-241.Sudre, J. 1984:CryptomeryxSchlosser, 1886, tragulidéde l'Oligocèned'Europe; relationsdugenre et considérations sur
l'originederuminants.Palaeovertebrata14,1-31.
208Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy 6.12
Macroevolutionary trends of Acrochordiceratidae Arthaber, 1911 (Ammonoidea, Middle Triassic)
MonnetClaude1,BucherHugo1,GuexJean2&WasmerMartin1
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Universität Zürich, Karl Schmid Strasse 4, CH-8006 Zürich ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected])2Institut de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, BFSH-2, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Directedevolutionoflifethroughmillionsofyears,suchasincreasingcomplexityandincreasingadultbodysize,isoneofthemostintriguingpatternsdisplayedbyfossillineages.ThegeneraltendencyforbodysizetoincreaseduringtheevolutionofagroupofanimalsisknownasCope’srule.Processesandcausesofsuchmacroevolutionarytrendsremainhowevertobeclearlyunderstood (Jablonski2000).Amongfossils,ammonoidshells (marinecephalopods)arewellknowntoexperiencerepetitivemacroevolutionarytrendsoftheiradultsize,geometryandornamentation(Schindewolf1940;Haas1942;Bayer&McGhee1984;Dommergues1990;Guex1992).
ThisstudyanalyzestheevolutionarytrendsofthefamilyAcrochordiceratidaeArthaber,1911,whichspannedtheupperEarlytolowerMiddleTriassic.ExceptionallylargecollectionsofthisammonoidfamilyfromNorthAmericaenablequantitativeand statistical analyses of its macroevolutionary trends. This study highlights that (1) the monophyletic clade ofAcrochordiceratidaefollowstheclassicalevolutetoinvoluteevolutionarytrend(i.e.increasingcoilingoftheshell);(2)thelineagealsoshowsaseeminglystepwiseincreaseofitsshelladultsize(shelldiameter);(3)thecladealsorecordsincreasingcomplexityofitssutureline;and(4)thelineageisalsocharacterizedbyaprominentincreaseoftheintraspecificvariationofitsshellmorphology,whichfollowstheBuckman’sLawofCovariation.
Thesemacroevolutionarytrendsarestatisticallyrobustandseemmoreorlessgradual.Furthermore,theycanbeconsideredasnon-randomwiththesustainedshiftofthemean,theminimumandthemaximumofstudiedshellcharacters.Suchre-sultisusuallyinterpretedasbeingtheeffectofaselectionpressureontheentirelineage,whichleadstoinferthepresenceofoneecologicalnichecommontoallspeciesofthismostlyanageneticlineagewithmoderateevolutionaryrates.
Increasinginvolutionofammonitesisusuallyinterpretedbyincreasingadaptationmostlyintermsofimprovinghydrody-namics.However,thistrendinammonoidgeometrycanbeexplainedasacaseofCope’srule(increasingadultbodysize)insteadofad hocfunctionalexplanationsofcoiling,becausebothshelldiameterandshellinvolutionaretwopossiblepathsforammonoidstoaccommodateincreasingbodysize.
REFERENCESBayer,U.&McGhee,G.R.1984:IterativeevolutionofMiddleJurassicammonitefaunas.Lethaia,17,1-16.Dommergues,J.L.1990.Ammonoids.In:McNamara,K.J.(ed.),Evolutionarytrends,BelhavenPress,London,162-187.Guex,J.1992:Originedessautsévolutifschezlesammonites.BulletindelaSociétéVaudoisedeSciencesNaturelles,82,117-
144.Haas,O.1942:RecurrenceofmorphologictypesandevolutionarycyclesinMesozoicammonites. JournalofPaleontology,
16,643-650.Jablonski,D.2000.Micro-andmacroevolution:scaleandhierarchyinevolutionarybiologyandpaleobiology.Paleobiology,
26(suppl.4),15-52.Schindewolf,O.H.1940.KonvergenzbeiKorallenundAmmoniten.FortschrittederGeologieundPalaeontologie,12,387-491.
Figure.EvolutionarytrendsrepresentedbylateimmatureshellgeometryandsuturelineforAcrochordiceratidaeduringtheAnisian
(MiddleTriassic).GlobalevolutionarytrendsaffectingsuccessivespectraofvariantsforAcrochordiceratidaeareincreasingadultshellsize,
increasinginvolution,increasingsuturecomplexity,andincreasingintraspecificvariability.(NextPage)
209
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
y
6.13
Reinvestigation of the basal ray-finned fish Birgeria stensioei from the Middle Triassic of Monte San Giorgio (Switzerland) and Besano (Italy)
RomanoCarlo1&BrinkmannWinand1
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Karl Schmid-Strasse 4, CH-8006 Zürich ([email protected]; [email protected])
ThetwoearlierdescriptionsandapreviousreconstructionoftheMiddleTriassicactinopterygianBirgeria stensioeiaLdInGeR,1931fromtheBesanoFormationofMonteSanGiorgio(CantonTicino,Switzerland)andBesano(Lombardy,Italy)reliedeit-heronafewfragmentaryremainsoronasingleindividualonly.HerewepresentthefirststudyofB. stensioeithatisbasedonmultiplespecimensofthisbasalray-finnedfish.Sixty-sevenspecimenshavebeenexamined.
ThereinvestigationofB. stensioeiyieldednewinformationatgenusandspecieslevel.B. stensioeipredominantlydiffersfromtheotherspeciesofthegenusBirgeriasTensIö,1919inthearrangementofthebonesofthedorsalfinbase.Whileintheotherspeciesusuallytwoseriesofpterygiophoresarepresentthroughoutthedorsalfinbase,onlyoneseriesofpterygiophoresisdevelopedintheanteriorpartofthedorsalfinrootofB. stensioei.ThecaudalpeduncleandthecaudalfinlobesaremoreslenderandlongerthanillustratedinthepreviousreconstructionofB. stensioei(seescHwaRz1970).ThemorphologyofthecaudalpeduncleandfinaswellastheaforementionedspecialiseddorsalfinrootindicatethatpropulsionmighthavebeenmoreadvancedinB. stensioeicomparedtotheotherspeciesofthegenusBirgeria.B. stensioei isfurthermoredistinguishedfrommostoftheotherspeciesofBirgeriabythedegreeofossificationofthebraincaseandthepalatoquadrate.Asinmanyotherbasalactinopterygians,adermohyalisdevelopedinB. stensioeiandthisboneisprobablypresentintheotherspeciesofBirgeriaaswell.
210Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy 6.14
Terrestrial palaeoclimatical and palaeoenvironmental reconstructions in Northwestern Switzerland: carbon and oxygen isotope compositions of Early Oligocene and Late Pleistocene vertebrate remains.
ScherlerLaureline1,2,TütkenThomas3,BeckerDamien2&BergerJean-Pierre1
1Department of Geosciences, Institute of Geology, ch. du Musée 6, CH-1700 Fribourg ([email protected])2Section d'archéologie et paléontologie, Hôtel des Halles, CP64, CH-2900 Porrentruy3Steinmann Institute, University of Bonn, Poppelsdorfer Schloss, D-53113 Bonn
VertebrateremainsfromtwoEarlyOligocenelocalitiesoftheDelémontbasin (BeuchilleandPoillat)andfromeightLatePleistocenedolinefillingsoftheAjoieRegion(Courtedoux-VâTcheTchâandBoncourt-Grand'Combe)havebeenexcavatedalongtheTransjuranehighway(CantonJura,NorthwesternSwitzerland).Teethoflargemammalsandbonesofaquaticrep-tileshavebeenanalysedfortheirisotopecompositions(δ18O
CO3,δ18O
PO4,δ13C)inordertoreconstructthepalaeoclimaticaland
palaeoenvironmentalconditions.
ThetwoEarlyOligocenelocalitiesofBeuchilleandPoillatarelocatedintheJuraMolasse("Molassealsacienne"Formation)of the Delémont basin (Northern Switzerland). The presence of the smallmammal Blainvillimys avus and the ruminantIberomeryx minorallowsadatationtothemammalzonesMP23-24,around31.5to29.0Ma(Beckeretal.2004).Eightsamplesofreptilebones(crocodilesandturtles)aswellasfoursamplesofsympatricprimitiverhinocerotidteeth(Ronzotheriumsp.)havebeenanalysed.Thereptileboneshave lowδ18O
PO4values (from13.6‰to17.8‰) indicatingfreshwaterenvironments
(δ18OH2O
calculatedvaluesaveraging-6.15±1.03‰)whicharesupportedbythepalaeontologicalidentificationsoftheturtleremains(TrionyxandTestudinidae:freshwaterandterrestrialturtles,respectively).Asimilarδ18O
H2Ovalueof -6.18±1.5‰is
calculatedfromenamelδ18OPO4
values(18.3±1.3‰)oftherhinocerotidteeth,whichpresumablyreflectsthecompositionofmeteoricwater.Usingamodern-daymeanairtemperature(MAT)-δ18O
H2OrelationforSwitzerlandaMATof18.0±2.5°Cforthe
EarlyOligocenecouldbecalculatedandwasabout8-9°CwarmerthantodayintheCantonJura(RecentMATof8.7°C).Thisresultisinagreementwiththepalaeotemperatureof~17°CreconstructedfromfossilplantremainsintheEarlyOligoceneofCentralEuropebyMosbruggeretal.(2005).
TheeightLatePleistocenedolinefillingsofBoncourt-Grand'Combe(GC)andCourtedoux-VâTcheTchâ(VTA)arelocatedintheAjoieRegion(NorthwesternSwitzerland)andcorrespondmainlytoloessicandgraveldepositsassociatedwithfossilre-mains.Forty-sixteethoflargemammals(Equus germanicus, Mammuthus primigenius, Coelodonta antiquitatis, Bison priscus)havebeenanalysed:eightsamplesfromtheGCdolinefillingandthirty-eightfromthesevenVTAdolinefillings.Thesedimenta-ry series bearing the mammal remains trapped within the GC doline have been dated by OSL (Optically StimulatedLuminescence)toanageof~80kaBP.ThemammalremainspreservedwithinthesevenVTAdolineshaveallbeendiscoveredinthesamesedimentaryunitdatedtothetimeinterval45-40to35kaBP(latestMiddlePleniglacial)byOSLandradiocarbon(Beckeretal.2009).
Accordingtotheenamelδ13Cvalues,whicharesimilarinbothtimeperiods,thelargemammalslivedinaC3plant-domina-
tedenvironmentasindicatedbyvaluesrangingfrom-14.5‰to-9.2‰(O'Leary,1981).TheMATcalculatedfromtheδ18OPO4
valuesofthelargemammalassemblagefromtheGCdolineaverages6.0±4.6°C.TheMATcalculatedforthelargemammalassemblageoftheyoungerVTAdolinesaverages5.6±4.1°C,showingaquitesimilarclimate.Thislatterresultisconcordingwiththequantifiedecologystudyofthesmallmammalassemblagesofthesedolines,whichindicatespalaeotemperaturesaveraging 5°C (Oppliger, 2009). These palaeoclimatical values are about 3 to 4°C cooler than today in theCanton Jura.However,somevariationsintheδ18O
PO4valuesofthedifferentstudiedspeciesareobserved,andparticularlyintheVTAdo-
lines:forexampletheequidsshowslightlylowerδ18OPO4
values(13.09±0.8‰)thanthebovids(14.6±1.1‰).ThecalculatedMATafterspecificcalibrationscanthusbeverydifferent,rangingfrom2.2±2.8°CfortheEquusremainsto8.8±3.5°CfortheBisonremains,withavalueof5.8±3.3°CfortheCoelodontaand8.7±2.2°CfortheMammuthus.
Inordertounderstandthisbiasaprecisedsamplingofteethformedbeforeandaftertheweaningofthefoalshasbeendone.Itshowsthattheoxygenisotopiccompositionsarenotaffectedbythenursingperiodwhereasthecarbonisotopesshowslightlylowervalues.ThedifferencesinoxygenstableisotopecompositionswithintheseLatePleistocenemammalscouldthenbeenexplainedbythesamplingmethod,themammalphysiologyand/orecology,ortimeaveraging.ThedeterminationofapalaeotemperatureshouldbemorereliableduringtheOligocenewhentheclimatewasmuchmorestablethaninthePleistocenewhenbrutalclimaticalchangesoccurredveryfrequently.
WethanktheSectiond'archéologieetpaléontologieduJura,theUniversityofFribourgandtheSwissNationalFoundation(project115995)forfinancialsupport.
211
Sym
po
siu
m 6
: D
arw
in,
Evo
luti
on
an
d P
ala
eo
nto
log
yREFERENCESBecker,D.,Lapaire,F.,Picot,L.,Engesser,B.&Berger,J.-P.2004:Biostratigraphieetpaléoécologiedugisementàvertébrésde
LaBeuchille(Oligocène,Jura,Suisse).RevuedePaléobiologie,9,179-191.Becker,D.,Aubry,D.&Detrey,J.2009:LesdolinesduPléistocènesupérieurdelacombede"VâTcheTchâ"(Ajoie,Suisse):un
piègeàrestesdemammifèresetartéfactslithiques.Quaternaire,20,2,135-148.Mosbrugger,V.,Utescher,T.andDilcher,D.L.2005:CenozoiccontinentalclimaticevolutionofCentralEurope.PNAS,102,
14964-14969.O'Leary,M.H.1981:Carbonisotopesinphotosynthesis.BioScience,38,328-336.Oppliger, J. 2009: LamicrofaunedesdolinesduPléistocène supérieurde la combedeVâTcheTchâ etde la régionde
Boncourt(Ajoie,Jura,Suisse).Unpublishedreport,29pp.
6.15
How do recurrent patterns of covariation in molluscan shells connect to growth dynamics?
UrdySéverine1,GoudemandNicolas1,BucherHugo1andMonnetClaude1
1Paläontologisches Institut und Museum, Universität Zurich, Karl Schmid-Str. 4, 8006 Zürich ([email protected]).
Thecomparisonofshellshapeamongandwithindifferentcladesofmolluscscanbeinformativewithregardstothebasicrulesofaccretionarygrowth. Indeed,patternsofvariationofshell shapeand itsassociatedgrowthfeatures (likegrowthhalts)inammonoidsandgastropodssuggestthatcommonrulesofaccretionarygrowthunderliethemorphogenesisoftheshellanditsevolutioninbothclades(e.g.Bucher,1997;Checa&Jimenez-Jimenez,1997;Checaetal.2002).Moreover,insomephylogeneticallydistantammonoidsspecies,covariationsamongtheintensityofornamentation,thela-teralcompressionoftheapertureandthedegreeofwhorloverlaphavebeendescribed(Buckman’slaws).Ithasbeensugge-sted that simple growth rules could underlie these evolutionary recurrent patterns of covariation (Hammer & Bucher,2005a).Similarly,shellcharacterscovarywiththespacingbetweengrowthhaltsduringtheontogenyofsomeofthesehigh-lyvariableammonoidsspecies.Onegoalofthisstudyistoexplorewhetheracomparablepatternofcovariationistobefoundingastropodsaswell.Wealsowanttofindoutwhetherdocumentationofmodesofgrowthingastropodscouldsupporttheviewaccordingtowhichsomerecurrentpatternsofcovariationcouldreflectbasicconstraintstiedtoaccretionarygrowth.Anotherinterestistherelati-onshipamongshape,growthratesandage,apointthatisdifficult,ifnotimpossibletostudyonammonoids.Inthisstudy,weinvestigatetheontogeneticpatternsofcovariationamongapertureshape,intensityofornamentationandspacingbetweengrowthhaltsinapopulationofgastropods(Hexaplex trunculus,Muricidae)rearedundercontrolledlabora-toryconditions.Allindividualsoriginatedfromasingleeggmass.Wedescribethegrowthdynamicsoftheseindividualsfromtheageofapproximately100daysto550daysafterhatching.Thisstudyhighlightsacovariationamonggrowthrhythm,growthhaltsspacing,apertureallometryandintensityoforna-mentation:-Variationinshellshapeisanalysedbygeometricmorphometricsoflandmarkslocatedontheaperture.Wedocumentanontogeneticallometryofaperture,whichbecomesrelativelywiderwithsize.ThisisconsistentwithresultsobtainedusingellipticFourieranalysisofaperturecontourandtraditionalbiometrics.-Variationinthe‘strengthofornamentation’isrelatedtothemeanspacingbetweengrowthhalts:smoothersnailstendtoexhibitmorecloselyspacedgrowthhalts.Thiscovariation,asputinevidencehereinH. trunculus,seemsanalogoustothatobservedinsomehighlyvariableammonoidsspecies(e.g.Gymnotoceras rotelliformis,Amaltheus margaritatus).-Themeannumberofgrowthhaltspermonthisrelatedtotheglobalshapeofthegrowthcurveandtothemeanspacingbetweengrowthhalts:themorefrequentthegrowth‘pulses’,theshorterthetimespentonagrowthhalt(downtonearlycontinuousgrowth), themore linear thegrowthcurveandthesmaller thegrowthsegmentsbetweensuccessivegrowthhalts.Additionally,wedevelopagrowthvectormodel(Urdyetal.,2009)inordertosimulatetheformationofgrowthhaltspheno-menologically(Fig.1).Thismodelisabletoaccountforsomepatternsofcovariationamongspecimens.Inparticular,varia-tioningrowthrhythmisregardedascriticalingeneratingtheobservedcovariationbetweengrowthhaltsspacingandor-namentation.Basedonthesesimulations,wesuggestthatthiscovariationmainlyresultsfromsimplescalingamongtheaperturedimensionsandthelengthsofshellsegmentsbetweensuccessivegrowthhalts.Then,theimportantstructurationof phenotypic variation in some ammonoids species could be a generic outcome of underlying variation in growthrhythm.
212Sy
mp
osi
um
6:
Da
rwin
, E
volu
tio
n a
nd
Pa
lae
on
tolo
gy
Figure1:Exampleofasimulationofgrowthhalts.
REFERENCESBucher,H.1997:Caractèrespériodiquesetmodedecroissancedesammonites:comparaisonaveclesgastéropodes.Geobios
MémoireSpécial,20,85-99.Checa,A.G.&Jimenez-Jimenez,A.P.1997:Regulationofspiralgrowthinplanorbidgastropods.Lethaia30(4),257-269.Checa,A.G.,Okamoto, T.&Keupp,H. 2002:Abnormalities asnatural experiments: amorphogeneticmodel for coiling
regulationinplanispiralammonites.Paleobiology28(1),127-138.Hammer,O.&Bucher,H.2005a:Buckman'sfirstlawofcovariation:acaseofproportionality.Lethaia38,67-72.Urdy, S.,Goudemand,N., Bucher,H.&Chirat, R. 2009:Allometries and themorphogenesis of themolluscan shell: a
quantitativeandtheoreticalmodel.JournalofExperimentalZoology,PartB(accepted).
214Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g 7. Future horizons in marine and continental research drillingFlavio Anselmetti, Othmar Müntener, Daniel Ariztegui
Commission of Oceanography and Limnology (COL)
7.1 Anselmetti F.S., Ariztegui D., Hodell D., Brenner M., Gilli A., Mueller A. & the PISDP scientific team members:Exploring200’000yearsofclimateandenvironmentalhistorywithICDPdrillcoresfromLagoPeténItzá,NorthernGuatemala
7.2 EfimenkoN.,BuchsD.,BuretC.,KawabataK.,SchleicherA.,UnderwoodM.,ArakiE.,ByrneT.,McNeillL.,SafferD.,TakahashiK.,EguchiN.,ToczkoS.&theExpedition319Scientists:Potentialandlimitsofdrillcuttingsforlithostra-tigraphical interpretations in siliciclastic environments: preliminary results from the IODPNanTroSEIZE Stage 2Expedition319SiteC0009(NankaiTrough,KumanoForearcBasin,Japan).
7.3 Früh-GreenG.,DelacourA.,BoschiC. :Lithosphericheterogeneities,hydrothermalactivityandserpentinizationatslowspreadingridges:Insightsthroughoceandrilling
7.4 Ildefonse,B.:Scientificdrillingintheoceanlithosphere:what’snext?
7.5 Preusser,F.:TheageofsedimentaryfillingsofoverdeependvalleysintheAlps
7.6 RecasensC.,ArizteguiD.,MaidanaN.I.,AnselmettiF.S.,VuilleminA.,FarahR.&thePASADOScientificTeam:NewsightsonLatePleistoceneclimatevariabilityinSouthernmostPatagonia:AnICDPapproach
7.7 Stockhecke M., Anselmetti F.S., Meydan A.F., Hammer P., Kipfer R., Odermatt D., Sturm M., Tomonaga Y. & thePALEOVANscientificteam:PALEOVAN-TheInternationalContinentalScientificDrillingProgram(ICDP)inLakeVan,EasternAnatolia(Turkey)
7.8 StrasserM.,MooreG.F.,AshiJ.,CamerlenghiA.,DuganB.,HuhnK.,KanamatsuT.,KawamuraK.,McAdooB.G.,PanieriG.,PiniG.-A.,UrgelesR.:AddressingGeohazardsfromSubmarineSlidesthroughOceanDrilling:The“NankaiTroughSubmarineLandslideHistory”drillingProposal
7.9 StraubM.,HaugG.,DanielS.,HaojiaR.:EvidenceforamiddlePliocenechangeintheoceannitrateinventorybasedonforaminifera-boundx15NintheCaribbeanSea
7.10 VuilleminA.,ArizteguiD.,PawlowskiJ.,TemplerS.&thePASADOScientificTeam:NewprospectsinICDPresearch:investigatingthesubsurfacebiosphereinLakePotrok-Aikesediments
215
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
ing7.1
Exploring 200'000 years of climate and environmental history with ICDP drill cores from Lago Petén Itzá, Northern Guatemala
AnselmettiFlavioS.1,ArizteguiDaniel2,HodellDavid3,BrennerMark4,GilliAdrian5,MuellerAndreas5&PISDPscientificteammembers
1Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Überlandstrasse 133, 8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland (f [email protected])2Section of Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of Geneva, Switzerland3Department of Earth Science, University of Cambridge, UK4LUECI, University of Florida, Gainesville, Florida, USA5ETH, Swiss Federal Institute of Science and Technology, Zurich, Switzerland
AspartofarecentICDPinitiative,morethan1.3kmoflakesedimentwererecoveredatsevensitesofvaryingwaterdepthsinLagoPeténItzá,northernGuatemala.Multipleholeswithamaximumdepthof133mweredrilledateachcoresiteusingtheGLAD800drill-rigmountedontheRV/KerryKeltssuperbarge.Thisensuredcompleterecoveryof lacustrinesedimentsequencesthatcontainalong,continuousrecordofcontinentalclimatechangefromthelowlandNeotropics.Radiocarbonandtephrochronologicdatingindicatesthattherecordspansthelast~200kyr,permittingtostudythelong-termtropicalhydrologicandtemperaturechangesaswellasthecorrelationtootherregionalandglobalpaleoclimaterecords.
LakePeténItzáisthedeepestlakeinthelowlandsofCentralAmerica,withamaximumdepth>160m.Itishydrologically“closed,”makingithighlysensitivetopastchangesintheratioofevaporationtoprecipitation.Pre-drillingseismicsurveysandthenewdrillcoresconfirmthatthelakesedimentsaresensitiverecordersofpasthydrologicchangesasreflectedbyvariationsinlithologyandphysicalproperties.
SitePI-6(waterdepth=71m)wasdrilledtoamaximumsedimentdepthof75.9m.Radiocarbondatesonterrestrialorganicmatterarewellorderedandindicateameansedimentationrateof~1mm/yrto~44kyrBPatadepthof~49m.Theageofthebasal section isconstrainedbyan identifiedash layerat70.4m,1.5metersabove limestonebedrock.TheelementalgeochemicalfingerprintofthisrhyolitictephralayerisconsistentwiththeLosChocoyoseruptionoftheAtitlánCalderaaround84kyrBP.Thisageofthetephralayerresultsinasedimentationrateof0.6mm/yrforthelowersectionandchrono-logicallyconfinesatransgressionalsequence,whichrepresentstheonsetoflacustrinesedimentationinthebasinatthissite.AtSitePI-6,thetop10.8mweredepositedduringtheHoloceneandconsistprimarilyofgraycarbonateclaywithabun-dantcharcoal.ThePleistocene/HoloceneboundaryismarkedbyatransitiontoHoloceneclayfromunderlying,interbedded,densegypsumsandandclaydepositedduringtheLateGlacial(~17to9.3kyr).Thistransitionrepresentsaswitchfromrela-tivelyaridconditionsduringtheLateGlacialtomoisterclimateduringtheearlyHolocene.IncontrasttotheLateGlacialperiod,theLastGlacialMaximum(LGM),from23to17kyr,consistsofgraycarbonateclaythatissimilartoHolocenedepos-its,suggestinghighdetritalinputandhighlakelevel,i.e.moistconditions.ThisfindingcontradictspreviousresultsthatsuggestedtheLGMwasdryintheGuatemalanlowlands.InLakePeténItzá,claydepositionduringtheLGMwasprecededbyinterbeddedgypsumandgraycarbonateclaydepositedbefore~23kyrduringMarineIsotopeStage3.Thispatternofclay–gypsum(wet–dry)oscillationscloselyresemblesthetemperaturerecordsfromGreenlandicecoresandNorthAtlanticma-rinesedimentcoresandprecipitationproxiesfromtheCariacoBasin.ThemostaridperiodscoincidedwithHeinrichEventswhencoldseasurfacetemperaturesprevailedintheNorthAtlantic,meridionaloverturningcirculationwasreduced,andthe IntertropicalConvergenceZone (ITCZ)wasdisplacedsouthward.SedimentsdepositedduringMIS4and5aconsistoffine-grainedclay-richlithologieswithvariablecontentofcarbonateandorganicmatterreflectingrathermoistconditions.
Thebasal~85kyrhorizonwaspenetratedintwodrillsites,whereadeeperandolderstratigraphicsuccessionwasrecovered.Tephrastratigraphicanalysisdocumentthatthisolderlacustrinesuccessiondatesbackto~200kyrs,providingthusanun-precedentedlongpaleoclimatic/paleoenvironmentalrecordoftheCentralAmericantropics
REFERENCESHodell,D.A.,Anselmetti, F.S.,Ariztegui,D., Brenner,M.,Curtis, J.H., Escobar, J.Gilli,A.,Grzesik,D.A.,Guilderson, T.J.,
Kutterolf,S.andMüller.A.D.,2008,An85-karecordofclimatechangeinlowlandCentralAmerica:QuaternaryScienceReviews27,1152-1165.
Mueller, A.D., Anselmetti, F.S., Ariztegui,D.A., Brenner,M.,Hodell,D.A., Curtis, J.H., Escobar, J.,Gilli. A.,Grzesik,D.,Guilderson,T.P.,Kutterolf,S.,Plotze,M.L.,subm.,LateQuaternarypaleoenvironmentofNorthernGuatemala:evidencefromdeepdrillcoresandseismicstratigraphyofLakePeténItzá:subm.toSedimentology.
Mueller,A.D.,Islebe,G.A.,Hillesheim,M.B.,Grzesik,D.A.,Anselmetti,F.S.,Ariztegui,D.,Brenner,M.,Curtis,J.,Hodell,D.,Venz,K.A.,2009,ClimatedryingandassociatedforestdeclineinthelowlandsofnorthernGuatemaladuringthelateHolocene:QuaternaryResearch71,133-141.
216Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g 7.2
Potential and limits of drill cuttings for lithostratigraphical interpreta-tions in siliciclastic environments: preliminary results from the IODP NanTroSEIZE Stage 2 Expedition 319 Site C0009 (Nankai Trough, Kumano Forearc Basin, Japan).
N.Efimenko1,D.Buchs2,C.Buret3,K.Kawabata4,A.Schleicher5,M.Underwood6,E.Araki7,T.Byrne8,L.McNeill9,D.Saffer10,K.Takahashi11,N.Eguchi11,S.Toczko11andExpedition319Scientists12
1Institut de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, Switzerland e-mail: [email protected] School of Earth Sciences, Australian National University3Université de Picardie Jules Verne, 80025 Amiens, France4National Central University, Taiwan5Department of Geological Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.6Department of Geological Sciences, University of Missouri, Columbia, Missouri 652117Earthquake and Tsunami Research Project for Disaster Prevention, JAMSTEC, Japan8University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269, USA9University of Southampton, Southampton, UK10Dept. of Geosciences, Pennsylvania State University, USA11Centre for Deep Earth Exploration, JAMSTEC, Japan12D.Boutt, University of Massachusetts-Amherst, Amherst, USA; M.Conin, CEREGE, Collège de France, France; D.Cukur, Pukyong National University, Korea; M.-L.Doan, Université Joseph Fourier, France; P.Flemings, University of Texas, Austin, USA; K.Horiguchi, Osaka University, Japan; N.Hayman, University of Texas, Austin, USA; G.Huftile, Queensland University, Australia; T.Ito, Tohoku University, Japan; S.Jiang, Florida State University, USA; K.Kameo, Chiba University, Japan; Y.Kano, Kyoto University, Japan; G.Kimura, University of Tokyo, Japan; M.Kinoshita, JAMSTEC, Japan; K.Kitada, JAMSTEC, Japan; A.J.Kopf, University of Bremen, Germany; W.Lin, JAMSTEC, Japan; M.Kyaw Thu, JAMSTEC, Japan; C.Moore, University of California, Santa Crus, USA; G.Moore, University of Hawaii, USA; Y.Sanada, JAMSTEC, Japan; H.Tobin, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA; K.Toshiya, JAMSTEC, Japan; G.Wheat, Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute, USA; T.Wiersberg, GFZ German Research Center for Geosciences, Germany
DuringtheIODPNanTroSeizeExpedition319riser-drillingsystemwasemployedforthefirsttimetocollectcuttingsandcoreforscientificpurposesatSiteC0009A(NankaiTrough,Kumanoforearcbasin).Cuttingsarethemixtureofrockfrag-mentsandsedimentsproducedas thedrillbit cuts throughthe formation.Duringriserdrilling, thecuttingsare trans-portedviathecirculationofdrillmudwithsuspendedcuttingsmaterialwithinriserpipebetweenthedrillshipandthebottomofthehole.Wepresentfirstgeologicresultsfromriserdrilling,coring,andcuttingscollectionattheSiteC0009AintheKumanoforearcbasin.OneofthescientificobjectivesforthissitewastocharacterisethelithologyanddeformationoftheKumanoforearcbasinsedimentsandunderlyingunits throughanalysisand integrationof (i) cuttings, (ii) core, (iii)measurementswhiledrilling,and(iv)wirelineloggingdata.Cuttingswereretrievedfromeach5mintervalsfrom703.9to1604mbelowseafloorandcoreswererecoveredfrom1509.7to1593.9mbelowseafloor.Ascoreavailabilitywasstronglylimitedbyoperationalcostsandtimerestrictions,thestudyofcuttingswasimportantfortheunderstandingoftheirpotentialandlimitsforlithos-tratigraphicalinterpretationscomparedtothecore.First,cuttingsweredescribedbasedonvisualmacroscopicdescriptionof thebulkmaterial.Weestimated (i) therelativeamountofcoarser(sand/silt)andfiner(clay)material,(ii)theappearance,relativeamountandsizeofhardrockchips,and(iii)theabundanceofwoodfragments.Then,weseparatedthegrainsofthesizemorethan45μmbysievinginordertodescribethemunderthebinocularmicroscopeandpreparesmearslides.Wedistinguishedspecificminerals,volcanicglassandlithicfragments,madequalitativeestimationsoftheirrelativeabundance,roundness,sorting,andrelativevariationingrainsize.Thechipsofhardrockof1-4mmsizewereseparatedandusedforthepreparationofthin-sections,X-raydiffrac-tionandX-rayfluorescenceanalyses.Wealsocomparedcuttingsandcoresinthecoredintervaltodeterminepossiblearti-factsanduncertaintiesrelatedtotheuseofcuttingsforlithostratigraphicalinterpretations.Cuttingsallowedustorecognisemajor lithologicalvariationsandtrends inmineralogicalandchemicaldata.Wedistin-guishedfourlithologicalunitscomposedofmudandmudstonewithcoarsersiltyandsandyinterbeds,andvolcanicash/tuff.Basedontheintegrationofcuttingsdescription,measurementswhiledrilling,wirelineloggingdata,seismicdataandbios-tratigraphy,firstthreelithologicalunitsareinterpretedasfine-grainedturbidite-richdepositsoftheKumanoBasinaccumu-latedduringPleistocenetoPresent.ThelowerpartofUnitIII(SubunitIIIB)hadanincreasedamountofwoodfragmentsandofroundedglauconite.Thisfactpointstotheincreasedterrigeneousinputintransgressionalsettings.TheSubunitIIIBisrepresentedbythefirstsedimentsdepositedabovetheangularuniconformitywithslightlyolderdepositsofUnitIVofLateMioceneage.Thedepthoftheunconformityis1285mbsf.TheUnitIViscomposedofthin-beddedturbiditeswhicharemorefine-grainedthanoverlyingdeposits.Compositionalmaturityofsedimentsisincreasedcomparedtothefirstthreeunits.ThisUnitcouldbeinterpretedeitherasaccretedtrenchsediments,orastrenchslopedepositsorassedimentsdepositedin
217
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
ingthedistalreachesoftheearlyKumanoBasin.
Consistencybetweenunitboundariesdeterminedfromcuttingsandthosedeterminedfromlogdataisgoodintermsofdepth,withtypicalmismatchesoflessthan10m.Thelithologicalfuturesandvariationsatthescalesmallerthan5mcouldnotberecognised.Problemsaffectingthepreservationofcuttingsare(i)degreeoflithification,(ii)mixingofcuttings/cav-ings,and(iii)possiblecontaminationwithdrill-mud.Smallsizeofcuttings(<2cm)anddesegregationofpoorlylithifiedsedimentsduringthetransportinthedrillingmudmakesdifficulttoobtaintheinformationaboutlithofaciesandsedi-mentarystructures.Mineralogicalandchemicalanalysesincuttingsarebiasedbythepreferentialconsolidationoffine-grainedsedimentswithrespecttocoarse-grainedsediments.XRDandXRFanalysesfromcuttingsaremorehomogeneousthanthosefromcoresamples,andthecompositionofcuttingsissimilartothesamplesofsiltyclaystonesfromthecores.Inthefuture,moreaccuratequantitativecharacterisationofcuttingsthroughtheuseofdigitalimagingcanimprovethedescriptionoflithofacies.Althoughthequalityofcuttingsisaffectedbycavinganddrillingmudcontamination,ourresultsclearlyindicatethatcuttingsanalysisincombinationwithseismicandloggingdatatocoringindeepoceandrillingisaviableanaloguetocoreforgenerallithostratigraphicalinterpretationswhennoscientificrequirementsforprecisesedimen-tologicalanalysisarerequired.Tomakepreciselithostratigraphicaldescriptionandinterpretationincriticalintervals,thestudyofcoreisneeded.
7.3
Lithospheric heterogeneities, hydrothermal activity and serpentinization at slow spreading ridges: Insights through ocean drilling
Früh-GreenGretchen1,DelacourAdéilie1,2&BoschiChiara1,3
1ETH Zurich, Institute for Mineralogy & Petrology, Clausiusstr. 25, CH-8092 Zurich ([email protected])2IPGP, Equipe de Géoschiences Marines, F-75252 Paris Cedex 053 Istituto di Geoscienze e Georisorse-CNR, Via Moruzzi 1, I-56124 Pisa
The formation and alteration of the oceanic lithosphere are fundamental processes that determine the chemical andphysicalevolutionofourplanet.Inthenearly40-yearhistoryofthescientificoceandrillingprograms,alimitednumberofsiteshavebeendrilledintooceanicbasement;however,onlytwoholes,ODPHole735BandIODPHole1309D,havebeendrilledtodepths>1000minlowercrustalsequences.Thesehaveledtoabetterunderstandingofmid-oceanridgeprocessesand,inturn,haveledtotherecognitionoffundamentaldifferencesincrustalaccretionandalterationprocessesrelatedtospreadingrates.Incontrasttotheapparentlymorelayeredandspatiallyhomogeneousoceaniclithosphereatfast-spreadingridges(e.g.,ODPHole504BandHole1256D),slow-andultra-slowspreadingcentresaremarkedlyheterogeneouswithre-spect to lithology,deformationanddegreeofalteration.Theseheterogeneitiesreflectprofoundvariations inmagmatic,tectonicandhydrothermalactivityalong-andacross-isochrons.
AtmanysitesontheMid-AtlanticRidge(MAR),themagmaticlayerisdiscontinuousandmantlelithologiesareexposedatorneartheseafloorwithinoceaniccorecomplexes(OCCs):thefootwallsoflong-livedlow-angledetachmentfaults.IODPExpeditions304and305targetedthe1.5to2Myrolddome-likeAtlantisMassif,locatedjustwestoftheMARat30°N.TheAtlantisMassifformstheinsidecorneroftheintersectionbetweentheMARandtheAtlantisTransformFaultandisnowoneofthebeststudiedOCCcomprisedoflowercrustalanduppermantlerocks.Threedomainsaredistinguishedonthebasisoflithologyandmorphology:acentraldome,aperidotite-dominatedsouthernwallandabasalticeasternbloc,inter-pretedasahangingwallseparatedfromtheOCCbyadetachmentfault.HerewereviewrecentresultsofdrillingatSite1309onthecentraldomeoftheAtlantisMassif,andcomparethesewithresultsfromdetailedsubmersiblestudiesofthesouthernwall,5kmtothesouth.
Themainhole1309Dwasdrilledonthecrestofthecentraldomeofthemassiveatawaterdepthof1656mbsfandpene-trated1415.5mbsfwithanaveragecorerecovery75%.Quiteunexpectedly,thepredominantlithologyrecoveredwasgabb-roicrocks(91.4%)withminorintercalatedultramaficrocks(5.7%)anddiabase(~3%).Thegabbroicrocksarecompositionallydiverseandarethemostprimitiveevercoredinslow-spreadingoceanlithosphere(withhighMg#(74–90),lowTiO
2(<0.49
wt%)andNa2O(0.1–3.7wt%).Mantleperidotitesareveryrare(<0.3%)andareconcentratedintheupperpartofthehole.The
gabbroicrocksarerelativelyundeformedandshowlimitedseawater-rockinteractiondownhole,asindicatedbyrelativelyhomogeneousandmantle-likeSr-,Nd-,andS-isotopecompositions.
Thedominanceofprimitivegabbroicrocks,theabsenceofsignificantamountsofserpentinizedmantleperidotites,andthelowdegreeoffluid-rockinteractionatSite1309contrastsgreatlywithresultsofsubmersiblestudiesofthesouthernwallofthemassif.ThesouthernwalloftheAMisdominatedbyserpentinizedharzburgites,intrudedbyminorgabbroicbodies,andhoststherecentlydiscoveredLostCityHydrothermalField(LCHF),aperidotite-hostedhydrothermalsystemcomposed
218Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g ofspectacular,upto60mhigh,carbonateandbrucitechimneysthatventlow-temperatureandhigh-pHfluidsresultingfromserpentinizationreactionsatdepth.TheLostCityfluidsareenrichedinhydrogen,methaneandotherhydrocarbons,producedabioticallythroughFischer-Tropschtypereactions.Productionofreducedvolatilesandvariablemixingwithsea-waterinthesubsurfaceandinnear-ventenvironmentsareimportantprocessesincreatingstrongchemicalgradientsthatprovidemicro-niches fordistinct communitiesofhydrogen-, sulphur- andmethane-utilizingarchaea, bacteria aswell aseubacteria.GeochemicalinvestigationsoftheserpentiniteshostingLostCityindicatelong-livedseawater-peridotiteinterac-tionat150-250°Candhighfluid-rockratios(>100andupto106),whichproducedenrichmentsinB,UandlightREE,andsystematicchangesinSr-andNd-isotoperatiostowardsseawatervalues.OurmultidisciplinaryinvestigationsofLostCityhighlightthecomplexinterplaybetweendeformation,fluidflow,masstransferandmicrobialactivitywithinthislong-livedsystemandarechangingourviewsnotonlyabouttheconditionsunderwhichlifecanthriveonourplanetbut,perhaps,onothersaswell.
ThefactthatIODPHoleU1309DontheAtlantisMassif(AM)ontheMARunexpectedlyyielded1400mofgabbroadjacenttowhereperidotitehadpreviouslybeenrecovered,andclosetotheperidotite-hostedLostCityventfield,istestamenttohowlaterally variable magmatic accretion processes and hydrothermal activity are at slow spreading ridge environments.ThroughstudiesoftheAtlantisMassifanddrillingatODPSite209(alongtheMARfrom14°to16°NonbothsidesoftheFifteen-TwentyFractureZone),anewmodelforthestructureandformationofslow-spreadridgeshasemerged.Slowspread-ingridgesareprobablylessmagmastarvedthanpreviouslybelieved,butmeltisretainedintheupwellingmantleasitas-cends,andbecomesincorporatedintoarelativethicklithosphere.Thelatterdeformsandextendsalonglocalizedzonesofdeformation,someofwhichbecomemajordetachmentfaultsoperatingviaarollinghingemodel.Suchdetachmentfaultsmaythereforeatleastlocallyconstitutethedefactoplateboundary.Drillinghasalsocontributedtomodifyingournotionsofophiolitesasanaloguesforoceancrustformationandhasshownthatslow-spreadcrustcannotbeconsideredcomparabletodismemberedophioliticcrust.
7.4
Scientific drilling in the ocean lithosphere : what's next?
BenoîtIldefonse
Géosciences Montpellier, CNRS-Université Montpellier 2, CC60, 34095 Montpellier cedex 05, France ([email protected])
Themid-oceanridgesandthenewoceaniclithospherethattheycreatearetheprincipalpathwayforthermalexchangeandphysical/chemical interactionsbetween theearth’s interior, thehydrosphere,and thebiosphere.Hence theocean lithos-phererecordstheinventoryofglobalthermal,chemicalandassociatedbiologicalfluxes.
AkeyoutcomeoftheInterRidge-IODP"Melting,Magma,FluidsandLife"workshop(Southampton,27-29July,2009;www.interridge.org/WG/DeepEarthSampling/workshop2009)was the formulation of integrative scientific questions and imple-mentationapproachesthatwillelucidatetheroleofoceanlithosphereprocesseswithinthebroaderEarthSystem.Therearethree,equallyimportantmainthemes,eachcomprisinggeological,hydrological,chemical,andbiologicalprocessesthatarecloselyinterdependent.
• Understandingtheaccretionofoceancrust.Thisgoalrequiresfullsectioncharacterizationofminimally-disruptedoceancrustandasufficientportionofunderlyinguppermostmantle,anddetailedunderstandingofactiveprocesseswithintheaxialzone;
• Understandinglithosphericheterogeneityinslow-andultraslowspreadcrust,inparticulartheimpactofserpentiniza-tiononglobalbiogeochemicalcyclesandplaterheology.
• Followingthematurationprocessof lithospherefromtheaxistotheridgeflanksandinvestigatingthehydrological-geochemical-microbiologicalfeedbacksduringtheagingoftheoceanicbasement.
Focussinginonthefirst theme,samplingacompletesectionoftheoceancrust, fromtheoceanfloortotheuppermostmantlethroughtheseismicMohorovičičdiscontinuity(the'Moho'),wastheoriginalinspirationforscientificoceandrilling,andremainsthemaingoalofthe21stCenturyMoholeInitiativeintheIODPSciencePlan.Fundamentalquestionsaboutthecomposition,structure,andgeophysicalcharacteristicsoftheoceanlithosphere,andaboutthemagnitudeofchemicalex-changesbetweenthemantle,crustandoceansremainunansweredduetotheabsenceofin-situsamplesandmeasurements.ThegeologicalnatureoftheMohoitselfremainspoorlyconstrained.The“MissionMoho”proposalsubmittedtoIODPinApril2007,setstheambitiousgoaltodrillcompletelythroughintactoceaniccrust,acrosstheMohoandintotheuppermostmantle,inlithosphereformedatafastspreadingrate.Although,no
219
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
inglong-termmissionhasbeenadoptedbyIODP,thescientificobjectivesrelatedtodeepdrillingintheoceancrustremaines-
sential to our understanding of the Earth.Our current knowledge if in-situ ocean crust remains limited;muchwill belearnedonthewaytothemantle.Thejourneyandthedestinationareequallyimportant.
Fundamentalscientificgoalsinclude:• Determinethebulkcompositionoftheoceaniccrusttoestablishthechemicallinksbetweeneruptedlavasandprimary
mantlemelts,understandtheextentandintensityofseawaterhydrothermalexchangewiththelithosphere,andesti-matethechemicalfluxesreturnedtothemantlebysubduction,
• Testcompetinghypothesesoftheoceancrustaccretionatfastspreadingmid-oceanridges,andquantifythelinkagesandfeedbacksbetweenmagmaintrusion,hydrothermalcirculationandtectonicactivity,
• DeterminethegeologicalmeaningoftheMohoindifferentoceanicsettings,
• Determinetheinsitucomposition,structureandphysicalpropertiesoftheuppermostmantle(anditsvariability),andunderstandmantlemeltmigration,
• Calibrateregionalseismicmeasurementsagainstrecoveredcoresandboreholemeasurements,andunderstandtheori-ginofmarinemagneticanomalies,
• Establishthedepthlimitofdeepbiosphereandhydrological/geobiologicalprocessesinthelithosphere.
The“MoHole”wasplannedasthefinalstageofMissionMoho.AttherecentInterRIDGE-IODPWorkshop"Melting,Magma,Fluids,Life",scientistsre-iteratedtheirenthusiasmandsupportforanultra-deepholeinintactoceaniccrustandintotheuppermostmantle.Thisprojectwouldprovidemajorinspirationforthenextgenerationofscientistsandengineers.Thechallengeisformidable,andrequiresassoonasfeasiblecarefulsiteselection,geophysicalsitesurvey,andthedevelopmentofcuttingedgetechnologyincludingdrillingcapabilitytoachieve+6000mofpenetrationin+4000mwaterdepth.Thenextdrillingprogramneedsamechanismtoenablethecommunitytomoveforwardwithplanning,designandimplementationinordertocompleteoneofthemajorgoalsofscientificoceandrilling.
7.5
The age of sedimentary fillings of overdeepend valleys in the Alps
FrankPreusser
Institut für Geologie, Universität Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, 3012 Bern, Switzerland ([email protected])
OverdeepenedbasinsandvalleysareknownfromseveralareaswithintheAlps,inparticularfromSwitzerlandandnorthernItaly(e.g.Schlüchter,1979).Itisfurthermoreremarkablethatglacialerosionpartlyleftremainsofolderdepositsinlateralvalley positions such as Gnadenwaldterrasse of the Inn Valley (Fliri et al., 1973), Austria, or Thalgut in the Aare Valley(Schlüchter,1989),Switzerland,thatrepresentformervalleybottoms.SeveralofthedeepbasinsandrelicscontaincomplexsedimentarysequencesthatindicatedepositionbeforethelastglaciationoftheAlps(Würmian).Recentresultsfrompaly-nologyandluminescencedatingindicateacomplexdepositionhistoryforsuchsediments,forexampleforthecomplexse-quenceofMeikirch,AareValley(Preusseretal.,2005).Theavailabledataimpliesthatdeeperosionandshapingofthepre-sentsubsurfaceoccurredthroughoutseveralphasesduringtheQuaternary.However,theexacttimingoftheseprocessesisstillpoorlyconstrainedasthenumberofsitesavailableisratherlimited.Sincemostofthevalleyfillingsaredeeplycoveredbysedimentsoflaterglaciations,furtherdetailedinformationaboutthisissuecanonlybeachievedbyrecoveringcoresfromsuchstructuresbydeepdrillings(downtosomehundredmetres).FirstresultsfromacasestudyintheWehntal(ZüricherUnterland)willbepresented.
REFERENCESFliri,F.,1973.BeiträgezurGeschichtederalpinenWürmvereisungen:ForschungenamBändertonvonBaumkirchen(Inntal,
Nordtirol).ZeitschriftfürGeomorphologieSupplement16,1-14.Preusser,F.,Drescher-Schneider,R.,Fiebig,M.,Schlüchter,Ch.,2005.Re-interpretationoftheMeikirchpollenrecord,Swiss
AlpineForeland,andimplicationsforMiddlePleistocenechronostratigraphy.JournalofQuaternaryScience20,607-620.Schlüchter,Ch.,1979.ÜbertiefteTalabschnitte imBernerMittellandzwischenAlpenund Jura (Schweiz).Eiszeitalterund
Gegenwart29,101-113.Schlüchter, Ch., 1989. The most complete Quaternary record of the Swiss Alpine Foreland. Palaeogeography,
Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology72,141-146.
220Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g 7.6
New sights on Late Pleistocene climate variability in Southernmost Patagonia: An ICDP approach
C.Recasens1,D.Ariztegui1,N.I.Maidana2,F.S.Anselmetti3,A.Vuillemin1,R.Farah1andthePasadoScientificTeam
1Section of Earth and Environmental Science, Rue des Maraîchers 13, 1205 Geneva ([email protected])2 Dpto de Biodiversidad y Biología Experimental, FCEyN-UBA, Buenos Aires, Argentina3 EAWAG, Überlandstrasse 133, 8600 Dübendorf
Laguna Potrok Aike, at 52°S, 70°W in Southern Patagonia, contains a unique paleoclimatic record of southern SouthAmerica.This~770kaoldmaarlocatedintheprovinceofSantaCruz,Argentina,isoneofthefewpermanentlakesinthisstepperegion,providingacontinuoussedimentaryrecordoveranextendedtimespaninthisareaoftheworld.WithintheframeworkoftheICDP-sponsoredPotrokAikeMaarLakeSedimentArchiveDrillingProject(PASADO),threesiteswerecoredduringOctober andNovember 2008 by an international group of scientists using theGLAD800 drilling rig operated byDOSSEC(Figure1).
Figure1.BathymetricmapofLagunaPotrokAikewithdrillsitesPTA1andPTA2andholeslabeledalphabetically.PTA-1Eto-1HandPTA-
2Dto-2Faregravitycorescoveringthesedimentwaterinterface.InsertsshowlocationofthelakeinsouthernSouthAmerica.Thevolca-
noesReclús(R),Hudson(H)andMt.Burney(B)aremarkedwithcapitalletters.
ThelakeislocatedinthePliocenetolateQuaternaryPaliAikeVolcanicField,anorthwest-southeastorientedtectono-volca-nicbeltthatis~50kmwideandmorethan150kmlong.TheavailablegeomorphologicaldataindicatethatLagunaPotrokAikehasneitherbeenreachedbythelastglaciationnorbyanyotherPleistoceneiceadvanceduringthelast1Ma.Thus,itispotentiallytheonlysitethathasarchivedacontinuousandhigh-resolutionsedimentrecordcoveringseveralglacial/in-terglacialcyclesforthesouthernhemisphericmid-latitudes.Severaldrillingsiteswerechosenaftertheinterpretationoftheseismicprofilesobtainedinpriorfieldcampaigns,withintheframeworkoftheproject“SALSA”,SouthArgentineanLakeSedimentArchivesandModeling(Anselmettietal.2008,Willeetal.,2007).Morethan500mofsedimentarycoreswerere-coveredandthelongestcorereachedover100m.
221
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
ing
On-sitelaboratoryanalyseswerecarriedoutsimultaneouslytothedrillingoperations.AllcoresectionswerescannedforpetrophysicalpropertiespriortoopeningwithaGeoTek®MultisensorTrackCoreLogger(MSCL).Aninsitugeochemicalla-boratorywasalsohabilitatedinordertoachievethefirstanalysisontherecoveredmaterial.Corecatchers(approximatelyoneeverythreemeters)werephotographedanddescribed,andthensubsampledforwatercontent,CaandClcontentsaswellaspHwhichweremeasuredimmediatelyinthecamp.Sampleswerefurthermoretakenforstableisotopes,pollenanddiatomsforsubsequentanalysisinthehomebasedlaboratories.Smearslidesweremountedforpetrographicmicroscopicexamination.
Aninternationalscientificteamwillworkonthedifferentsedimentarycoresrecoveredatthethreesitesusingamultidisci-plinaryapproach.SeveralanalysesarecurrentlyunderwayincludingmoreaccurateMSCLscansofthecoresandcorecatcheranalysisfordiatoms,pollenandstableisotopes.AsamplingpartyatthecorerepositoryinBremen,Germany,isactuallyonthego.Coreshavebeensplitandarebeingsampledathighresolutionforalltheplannedanalyses.TheSwissscientificcontributiontotheprojectinvolvestwomainaspects:1.thediatomrecordoftheretrievedcoresforpaleoenvironmental reconstructions and collaboration in the development of a modern training set for diatoms inPatagonia;2.thecharacterizationofthedeepbiosphereinvestigatinglivingmicrobialcommunitieswithinthesediments,whichisembeddedinanintegratedstudyincludingmicrobiology,geochemistry(interstitialwaters),andmineralauthige-nesis/diagenesis.
REFERENCESAnselmetti,F.S.etal.,2008:EnvironmentalhistoryofsouthernPatagoniaunravelledbytheseismicstratigraphyofLaguna
PotrokAike.Sedimentology,53,873-892.Wille,M.,etal.,2007:VegetationandclimatedynamicsinsouthernSouthAmerica:ThemicrofossilrecordofLagunaPotrok
Aike,SantaCruz,Argentina.ReviewofPalaeobotanyandPalynology,146,234–246.
7.7
PALEOVAN - The International Continental Scientific Drilling Program (ICDP) in Lake Van, Eastern Anatolia (Turkey)
MonaStockhecke1,FlavioS.Anselmetti1,AysegülF.Meydan2,PaulHammer3,RolfKipfer1,DanielOdermatt4,MikeSturm1,YamaTomonaga1andPALEOVANscientificteam
1Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science and Technology, Überlandstrasse 133, 8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Yuzuncu Yil Universitesi, Muhendislik-Mimarlik Fakultesi, Jeoloji Muhendisligi Bolumu 65080, Van, Turkey3 Dept. of Earth Science, Haldenbachstrasse 44, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland4 Remote Sensing Laboratories, Dept. of Geography, University Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zurich, Switzerland
LakeVanisthefourthlargestterminallakeintheworld(volume607km3,area3,570km2,maximumdepth460m),extend-ingover130kmWSW-ENEontheEasternAnatolianhigh-plateau,Turkey.Theannually-laminatedsedimentaryrecordofLakeVanpromisestobeanexcellentpalaeoclimatearchivebecauseitpotentiallyyieldsalongandcontinuouscontinentalsequencethatcoversseveralglacial-interglacialcycles(~500kyr).Therefore,LakeVanisakeysitewithintheInternationalContinentalScientificDrillingProgram(ICDP)fortheinvestigationoftheQuaternaryclimateandpaleoenvironmentalevo-lutionintheNearEast.TheICDPdrillingoperations'Paleovan'willbeperformedwithactiveinvolvementofvariousSwissresearchgroups.Drillingisplannedfor2010andthetechnicalpreparationsarecurrentlyunderway.
Aspreparationforthedrillingcampaign,severalsitesurveyswerecarriedoutduringthepastyearsconsistingof~850kmseismicprofiles,multidisciplinaryanalysisofupto9mlongcoresextendingbacktotheLastGlacialMaximumandwatercolumnanalysis.Furthermore,recentinvestigationsfocusedonmodernparticledynamicsandvarveformationusingse-quentialsedimenttraps,multispectralsatelliteimagesandshortsedimentcores(Stockhecke,2008).
Thesedimenttrapsamplesandsatelliteimagesof2006revealedthatthreeannualphasesofauthigenicparticleproductionoccur,oneinspringcharacterizedbynon-skeletalalgae,oneinsummerwithdominanceofauthigeniccarbonateproduc-tion,andoneinautumn,whichischaracterizedbydiatomsandthusbiogenicsilicaproduction.Thesedimenttrapsamplesfrom2007to2008showthesameorganicspring-peakastheyearbefore,butthebiogenicsilicaconcentrationincreasedsi-
222Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g gnificantly. Themaxima of authigenic carbonate production in late autumnof 2008 is related to significant higher airtemperaturesand increasedwatermixingprocessesat thecorrespondingdepth.Further investigationsareplannedthatdocumenttheannualcycleswithseasonalresolutionandtheirpreservationpotentialinthelakesediments,calibratingthesensitiveclimate-lake-sedimentsystem.
AlltheseinvestigationsshowthelargepotentialofPALEOVANforobtainingacontinuousundisturbedandlongcontinentalpalaeoclimaterecord.Thiswillshednewlightsonpaleoenvironmentalconditions,thedynamicsoflakelevelfluctuations,noblegasconcentrationinporewaters,historyofvolcanismandandearthquakeactivities(Litt,2008).
Figure1.PartofseismicprofileGEO04-007crossingtheTatvanBasinandAhlatRidgeinaS-NdirectionwiththeproposedICDPdrillsite.
REFERENCESLitt,T.,Krastel,S.,Sturm,M.,Kipfer,R.,Örcen,S.,Heumann,G.,Franz,S.O.,Ülgen,U.B.,Niessen,F.,2008,submitted:Lake
VanDrillingProject“PALEOVAN”,InternationalContinentalScientificDrillingProgram(ICDP):Resultsofarecentpre-sitesurveyandperspectives.QuaternaryScienceRewies.
Stockhecke,M. (2008). TheAnnual ParticleCycle of LakeVan: Insights fromSpace, Sediments and theWaterColumn.UniversityofZurich.
223
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
ing7.8
Addressing Geohazards from Submarine Slides through Ocean Drilling: The “Nankai Trough Submarine Landslide History” drilling Proposal
StrasserMichael1,MooreGregoryF.2,AshiJuichiro3,CamerlenghiAngelo4,DuganBrandon5,HuhnKatrin1,KanamatsuToshiya6,KawamuraKiichiro7,McAdooBrianG.8,PanieriGiuliana9,PiniGian-Andrea9,UrgelesRoger4
1 MARUM, Centre for Marine and Environmental Sciences, Univ. Bremen, Leobener Strasse, D-28359 Bremen ([email protected])2 Dept. of Geology and Geophysics, Univ. Hawaii, USA3 Ocean Research Institute, Univ.Tokyo, JPN4 ICREA – Univ. Barcelona, ESP5 Dept. of Earth Science, Rice Univ. USA6 Japan Agency for marine-earth science and technology JAMSTEC, JPN7 Fukada Geol. Inst. Tokyo, JPN8 Dept. of Earth Sciences & Geography Vassar College, NY, USA9 Dept. of Eartn and Geo-Environmental Sciences, Unv. Bologna, ITA
Withincreasingawarenessofoceanicgeohazards(e.g.Morganetal.,2009),alsosubmarinelandslidesarewidegainingat-tentionnotonlybecauseoftheircatastrophicimpacts(e.g.landslide-inducedtsunamis,submarineinfrastructure),butalsobecausetheycanbedirectlyrelatedtoprimarytriggermechanismsincludingearthquakes,rapidsedimentation,gasrelease,orclathratedissociation,manyofwhichrepresentgeohazardsthemselves(e.g.Camerlenghietal.,2007).Scientificoceandrillingcanbeakeyelementinunderstandingsuchgeohazards,giventhatthesubmarinegeologicalrecordpreservesstruc-turesandpastoccurrences.Toimproveourknowledge,quantitativeconstraintsonfrequencyandmagnitudeonrelevanttimescalesneedtoberelatedtotriggerandfailuremechanisms.
Towardsthisgoal,theIODP-AncillaryProjectLetter-Proposal“NankaiTroughSubmarineLandSLIDEHistory–NanTroSLIDE”aimstoaddonesitetotheNanTroSEIZE(NankaiTroughSeismogenicZoneExperiment;TobinandKinoshita,2007)studyareatoconstraintiming,causesandconsequencesofsubmarinelandslidesinthiswell-studiedaccretionarycomplex.Onthebasisofnew3DseismicdatainterpretationintheNanTroSEIZEstudyarea,wehaveidentifiedanideallysuitedslopebasinsedimentarysuccessionthatiscomposedofstackedPleistocene-to-recentmasstransportdeposits(MTDs)thatincludesoneexceptionallylargeMTDupto150minthickness.A350mthicksuccession,comprisingthedistalpartofthemegadeposit,isproposed tobecompletelydrilledand loggedwithin3daysbefore,duringorafteranyof theupcomingNanTroSEIZEoperationsontheJapanesedrillingvesselChickyu.
WeexpecttocatalogadetailedsubmarinelandslideeventhistoryalongwithcluesonthedepositionaldynamicsofeachMTDastheyrelatetotsunamigenicpotential.Inconjunctionwith3Dseismicinterpretationwewillbeabletoconstrainscalesand landslidemagnitude.Theresultsobtainedwillbe interpreted intermsof short-termtriggermechanismsandlong-termpre-conditioningfactorsbycorrelatingthemagnitudesandfrequenciesofMTDstotheseismicityandtectonicevolutionof themargin.Additionally,data fromnearbyNanTroSEIZEdrill sitesareexpectedtorevealquantitativecons-traintsonslopestabilityconditionsandsubmarinelandslidesinitiation.Incombination,theavailabledatasetwillallowustoestablishabetterphysicalunderstandingoftectonicprocessesandslopefailures,togainageneralunderstandingoffai-lure-relatedsedimentationpatternsandthesignificanceoflargeepisodicmass-transportevents.Ultimately,thiscouldhelpustoassesthetsunamigenicpotentialofsubmarinelandslides.Wethusexpectthisproposedprojecttobecomeanimpor-tant case study providing the base to improve our conceptual understanding of causes and consequences of submarinelandslides.
Theprimarygoalsofdrillingtheproposedsite(NTS-1A)are:(i) Toestablishawell-datedPleistocene-to-recentmass-movementeventstratigraphy(ii) TosamplethedistalpartofanexceptionallythickMTDforanalyzingitsrheologicalbehaviortoconstrainsliding
dynamicsandtsunamigenicpotential
Thisaimsatprovidinganswerstofollowingquestions:1) Whatisthefrequencyofsubmarinelandslides2) HowareMTDsandearthquakesrelatedandcanweusetheMTD-inventorytointerpretpaleoseismology3) Whatcontrolstype,sizeandmagnitudeofturbitidesandMTDsandhowdotheychangethroughtime?4) Whatarethedynamicsoflargesubmarinelandslidesandcanweinferthertsunamigenicpotential?
Byaddressingthesefocusedkeyquestions,weaimtoisolatetectonicprocessesinfluencingmagnitudeandoccurrenceofsubmarinelandslidesalongactivesubductionzonemarginsandtounderstandtheirpotentialfortriggeringcatastrophicconsequencesbothintermsofhazard(tsunamigeniclandslides)andofsedimentmass-transferandmarginevolution.
224Sy
mp
osi
um
7:
Futu
re h
ori
zon
s in
ma
rin
e a
nd
co
nti
ne
nta
l re
sea
rch
dri
llin
g
REFERENCESCamerlenghi,A.,Urgeles,R.,Ercilla,G.,andBruckmann,W.,2007.Scientificoceandrillingbehindtheassessmentofgeo-
hazardsfromsubmarineslides,ScientificDrilling,4,45-47Morgan,J.K.,Silver,E.,Camerlenghi,A.,DuganB.,Kirby,S.,Shipp,C.,Suyehiro,K.,2009.AddressingGeohazardsThrough
OceanDrilling.ScientificDrilling,7,15-30Tobin,H.,andKinoshita,M.,2007.TheIODPNankaiTroughSeismogenicZoneExperiment.ScientificDrilling,1,39-41
7.9
Evidence for a middle Pliocene change in the ocean nitrate inventory based on foraminifera-bound δ15N in the Caribbean Sea
StraubMarietta1,HaugGerald1,DanielSigman2,HaojiaRen2
1 Geological Institute, Department of Earth Sciences, ETH Zurich, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland2 Department of Geosciences, Guyot Hall, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08544, USA
Thenitratebudgetinthelow-latitudesurfaceoceanismainlycontrolledbythetypicallyopposingeffectsofdenitrificationandnitratefixation.Thestateoftheglobaloceannitrateinventoryaffectsprimaryproduction,whichallowssequesteringCO2intothedeepocean.ThismayinfluenceclimatevariabilityandcontrolwarmandcoldperiodsinEarthhistory.Studieshaveshownthatnitrogenisotopesreflectthenutrientstatusoftheupperwatercolumnandthereforeareaproxyforthestateoftheocean’s‘biologicalpump’.
Sofar,theNinventoryhasmostlybeenreconstructedbasedonbulksedimentaryN-isotopemeasurements,whichcanbeaffectedbysyn-andpost-sedimentaryprocesses.Promisingapproachestocircumventthesepotentialbiasesarebasedonmeasurementsofforaminifera-boundδ15N.Inthesubtropicalandtropicalocean,planktonicforaminiferaareamaincom-ponentofthesinkingparticleflux.Theorganiccompoundsencapsulatedwithintheforaminiferaltestsareprotectedfromsedimentarydiageneticprocesses.Asaresulttheyrecordapristinesignalofthenitratecompositioninthewatercolumn.ThenovelmethodusedhereemploysdenitrifyingbacteriaPseudomonaschlororaphisandPseudomonasaureofaciens toproducenitrousoxide(N
2O),recoveredfromthenitrateextractedfromtheorganicmattershelteredwithintheforaminifera
shell,whichisanalyzedforδ15NwithaGasbenchII–IRMSandproducesresultswithreproducibleisotopicmeasurementsofsamplesdownto1μMnitrate.
Previousdatafromtheinvestigatedsite(ODPLeg165,site999A,CaribbeanSea),studyingthelast30’000yrsusingthesamemethod,indicateasystematicdifferencebetweenglacialandinterglacialvalues.Theglacialstateischaracterizedbyhighδ15Nvaluesaround~5‰(suggestinglessN-fixation)andtheinterglacialstatebylowδ15Nvaluesaround~3‰(N-fixationincrease).Oncontrary,ourdatafromforaminifera-boundδ15NofG.ruberandG.sacculiferrevealsevidenceforachangeinthemeanoceannitratecomparedtothelast30’000yrs.Thebasicfindingsfromthemeasuredintervalbetween3.2Mato2.4Mashowglacialδ15Nvaluesof~4.5-7‰forG.sacculiferand~3-5.5‰forG.ruber,interglacialvaluesrangebetween~4-6‰forG.sacculiferandbetween~3-5.5‰forG.ruber.Basedontheobtainedδ15Nvalueswecouldnotdifferentiatebetweenglacialandinterglacialperiods.Thisleadustotheconclusionthatthereprobablywasageneralchangeoftheoceannitrateinven-tory and the dominating processes of N-fixation and denitrification performed in a different way than today. Furthermeasurementswillbenecessarytounderstandthepreliminarydataandtointerpretthepossiblechangesintheoceandu-ringlatePliocene.
REFERENCESM.A.Altabet,R. Francois (1994): Sedimentarynitrogen isotopic ratio as a recorder for surfaceoceannitrateutilization.
Globalbiochemicalcycles,Vol.8,No.1,Pages103-116.G.H.Haug,R.Tiedemann,R.Zahn,A.C.Ravelo(2001):RoleofPanamaupliftonoceanicfreshwaterbalance.Geology,Vol.29,
Pages207-210.H.Ren,D.M.Sigman,A.N.Meckler,B.Plessen,R.S.Robinson,Y.Rosenthal,G.H.Haug(2009):ForaminiferalIsotopeEvidence
ofReducedNitrogenFixationintheIceAgeAtlanticOcean.Science,Vol.323,Pages244-248.D.M. Sigman,K.L.Casciotti,M.Andreani,C.Barford,M.Galanter, J.K.Bhlke (2009):ABacterialMethod for theNitrogen
IsotopicAnalysisofNitrateinSeawaterandFreshwater.Analyticalchemistry,Vol.73,No.17.Pages4145-4153.D.M.Sigman,S.L.Jaccard,G.H.Haug(2004):Polaroceanstratificationinacoldclimate.Nature,Vol.428.Pages59-63.
225
Sym
po
siu
m 7
: Fu
ture
ho
rizo
ns
in m
ari
ne
an
d c
on
tin
en
tal
rese
arc
h d
rill
ing7.10
New prospects in ICDP research: investigating the subsurface biosphere in Lake Potrok-Aike sediments
A.Vuillemin1,D.Ariztegui1,J.Pawlowski2,S.Templer3andthePASADOScientificTeam
1 Section of Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of Geneva, 13 rue des Maraîchers, 1205 Geneva, Switzerland ([email protected])
2Section of Biology, University of Geneva, 30 quai Ernest Ansermet, 1211 Geneva, Switzerland3Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 77 Massachusetts avenue, 02139 Cambridge, USA
Microbialactivityonrecentsediments is fullyrecognizedasamajorplayerinlithificationprocesses.Theseomnipresentorganismshavethecapacityofcatalyzingandenhancingdiageneticreactionseveninextremeenvironmentsfromtheverysurfaceofthesedimentstoasdeepas4.5kmbelowthewatercolumn.Livingbacterialcommunitieshavebeentrackeddownintodeepsedimentsandevenintothedeeperbasalticsub-seafloors.Althoughthedistributionanddiversityofmicrobesinmarinesedimentsthroughdepthhavebeenstudiedforsomeyearsalready,thereisalackoftheseinvestigationsinthela-custrinerealm.
Furthermore,geomicrobiologystudiesinmodernlakesallowtakingacloserlookintoearlydiageneticprocesseslinkedtomicrobialactivity insubrecentsediments.Thefociofmostofthesestudies,however,havebeeneitherveryshallowsedi-mentsand/orthewatercolumn.
Morethan500metersofsedimentarycoreswereretrievedfromLakePortokAike,acraterlakelocatedinSouthernPatagoniawithintheframeworkoftheICDP-sponsoredPASADOproject(PotrokAikeMaarLakeSedimentArchiveDrillingProject).A100meterslongcorewasdedicatedtogeomicrobiologysampling,allowingtheinspectionofundisturbeddeeplacustrinesediments.Specialwindowswerecutinthelinersfordirectsamplingunderthemoststerileconditionspossibleimmedia-telyaftercorerecovery.InsituATPmeasurementsareusedasindicationoflivingorganismswithinthesediments.Varioussampleswerechemicallyfixedand/orfrozenformethanedetermination,bacterialcellcounting,DGGE(molecularfinger-printingtechnique)andcellcultivation.
InsituATPdatarevealaconstantlowmicrobialactivitybelow40msedimentdepthwhereasthreemainpeaksappearat34,10and5metersrespectively.Studyingthemicrobialcommunitybasedon16SrDNA,weidentifiedabroad,butconserveddiversitypatternintheoldersediments.Incontrast,thediversityseemstodecreaseandchangedramaticallyintheuppersection.ApreliminaryinterpretationoftheseresultssuggeststhateachATPpeakcorrelateswithmicrobialcommunityin-terphases.Thelattertogetherwiththenegativecorrelationbetweenactivityanddiversitymayindicatethatnutrientsaresystematicallydepletedthroughbacterialactivitycyclessinceeachindividualcommunitymaybeatleastpartiallyfedbythemetabolicproductsoftheoverlyingcommunity.Adaptionbecomesnecessaryforcommunitiesevolvinginenvironmentswithdecreasingtrophicstate.
Theintegrationofthesedatasetwithongoingmultiproxystudiesinthesamerecordwillbringnewlightintomicrobialactivityinlacustrinesystemsandtheirroleonvariousdiageneticprocesses.
226Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8. Geoscience and Geoinformation – From data
acquisition to modelling and visualisationNils Oesterling, Adrian Wiget, Massimiliano Cannata, Erich Zechner
Swiss Geological Survey; Swiss Geodetic Commission; Swiss Geotechnical Commission; Swiss Geophysical Commission; Swiss Hydrogeological Society
8.1 AntonovicM.:GeoShield:aserversideuserpermissionsmanagementtoOGCservices
8.2 BaillieuxP.,SchillE.:Preliminary3DfaultmodeloftheEuropeangeothermalsite(Soultz-sous-Forêts,France)
8.3 Baland P. & Möri A. : Converting geological maps to vector datasets – Completing the National GeologicalInformation
8.4 BaruffiniM.:Risk,measuredriskaversionandindividualcharacteristics
8.5 BaruffiniM.,ThüringM.:SystematicanalysisofnaturalhazardsalonginfrastructurenetworksusingaGIS-toolforriskassessment
8.6 BaumbergerR.,OesterlingN.:Challengesforgeologicalsurveysingeological3Dmodelbuildingandvalidation
8.7 BeresM.,KühniA.:OverviewofavailablegeosciencedatainSwitzerland
8.8 BiassS.,ParmigianiA.,Dell’OroL.,SenegasO.&BonadonnaC.:Exposure-basedriskassessmentfortephraaccumula-tion:theexampleofCotopaxivolcano(Ecuador)
8.9 BilgotS.,ParriauxA.:GIS-basedmethodforgroundwatermanagementandprotection:geotypesserving3Dapplica-tions
8.10 BorghiA.,RenardP.&JenniS.:Apseudo-geneticapproachforthestochasticgenerationofkarsticnetworks
8.11 BruijnR.,ZapponeA.,BurliniL.,TripoliB.,HolligerK.,BurgJ-P.&KisslingE. :SAPHYR,theSwissatlasofphysicalpropertiesofrocks
8.12 CannataM.,AntonovicM.:IstSOS:SensorObservationServiceinPytho
8.13 ComunianA.,StraubhaarJ.,RenardP.,FroidevauxR.:Modelingheterogeneousgeologicalreservoirsusingmultiple-pointstatisticssimulations
8.14 DresmannH.,ZechnerE.,HuggenbergerP.&EptingJ.:Differentresolutionsfordifferenttopics-thegeological3D-modeloftheBaselregion
8.15 FraefelM.,KockS.:UseofdigitalterrainmodelsandGISforneotectonicstudies:AnalysingfluvialterracemorphologyinnorthernSwitzerland
8.16 HilbeM.,Anselmetti F.S.,EilertsenR.,HansenL. : Insights fromtwohigh-resolutionbathymetric surveys inSwisslakes
8.17 Kuchler F.,CherixaG., SauvainaR., Storelli S., LindemannD.,AndreyE. : SyGEMe, IntegratedMunicipal FacilitiesManagementofWaterRessources:Toolpresentation,choiceoftechnology,man-machineinterface,businessoppor-tunitiesandprospects
8.18 KühniA.,OesterlingN.:Key-Note:TowardsaSwissGeologicalInformationsystem
8.19 LimpachP.,GrimmD.:Rockglaciermonitoringwithlow-costGPSreceivers
8.20 MarzocchiR.,CannataM.:AGISembeddedmodelfordambreak
8.21 MarzocchiR.,FedericiB.,SguersoD. :AGIS tool tocreate fluvial floodingmaps. Interactionof1DhydrodynamicmodelandGIS
227
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
8.22 MeierA.,WiliC.:NaturereignisseentlangderBahnlinien:einesystematischeAufnahme
8.23 MolinariM.,CannataM.,TroungXuanL.:ShallowLandslideVulnerabilityAssessment
8.24 RenardP.,MariethozG.&StraubhaarJ.:3Dmodelingofgeologicalheterogeneity:thedirectsamplingmultiple-pointssimulationmethod
8.25 SaraswatP.:ParticleSwarmandDifferentialEvolutionoptimization-GlobaloptimizationforGeophysicalInversion
8.26 SteblerY.,SchaerP.,SkaloudJ.:FastColorization,AnalysesandVisualizationofAirborneLaserData
8.27 StrählS.,KuhnN.J.:Topographyandsurfaceprocessesinborderlineecotones
8.28 StraskyS.,BalandP.,OesterlingN.andKühniA.:TowardsaSwissgeologicaldatamodel
8.29 TripoliB.,ZapponeA,BurliniL.,BurgJ-P.,Hollinger,K.&Kissling,E.:TheSwissAtlasofPhysicalPropertiesofRocks(SAPHYR)
8.30 VilligerA.,HellerO.,GeigerA.,KahleH-G&BrockmannE.:EstimationoflocaltectonicmovementsusingcontinuousGNSSnetwork
8.1
GeoShield: a server side user permissions management to OGC services
MilanAntonovic
Institute of Earth Sciences – SUPSI
GeoShieldisaprojectborntoofferacentralizedwaytodefinesecurityaccess-controltogeo-services.Itactslikeaproxy,interceptingallthecommunicationsbetweenclientsandOGCcompliantservices(WMS,WFS,WPS,SOS).
GeoShield isabletomanageusersandgroups, ithandlesauthenticationandprivilegessettingsamonggroupsandregi-steredservices.Itiscapabletoanalyserequestsapplyingthefilterssettedtotheuserandmanipulatingtheresponse.
ForexamplehandlingWMSsecurity,withGeoShieldwecan:• defineaccessprivilegeforeachlayerprovidedbytheservice,• specifyifalayercanbeviewedornot,• definegeometricalextentofviewpermission.
Allprivilegesonsingle layersarebasedonCommonQueryLanguage (CQL) filters, thatallowinterestingcombinationofpermissionsdefinitionthatoperateinahiddenwaytoend-user.
Technicalinfo• ThecoreofGeoShieldiswritteninJavaandrelyonGeoTools.• ThedatabaseusedforstoringdataisPostgreSQL.• Authenticationmethodisthe“HTTPAuthentication:BasicAccessAuthentication”,thatguaranteecompatibilitieswith
mostoftheclients(likeuDig,ArcGis,Google-Earth,etc.)•WebinterfacebuildwithExtJSandOpenLayers
REFERENCESGeoShield-http://istgeo.ist.supsi.ch/site/projects/geoshieldOGC(OpenGeospatialConsortium)-www.opengeospatial.orgGeotools-http://geotools.codehaus.org/ExtJs-extjs.comOpenLayers-openlayers.org
228Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.2
Preliminary 3D fault model of the European geothermal site (Soultz-sous-Forêts, France)
BaillieuxPaul1,SchillEva1
1Laboratoire de Géothermie, Université de Neuchâte, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2009, Neuchâtel, Suisse ([email protected])
ThegeothermalresourcesattheEuropeantestsiteatSoultz-sous-ForêtsarestronglyrelatedtoapproximatelyN-Sstrikingnormalfaultsystems(e.g.Bächler,2003).Fluidcirculationingeneralandinparticularalongfaultsystemsisaveryeffectiveheattransportmechanismcomparedtoconductiveheattransport.IntheareasofLandau(Germany)andSoultz(France),fluidconvectionhasbeenusedtoexplainthetemperaturedistributionatdepth.InthecaseofLandau,fluidconvectionhasbeensimulatedinaverticalfaultinordertoexplainthedistributionofrelativelywarmandcoldzonesalongtheOmega-fault(Bächleretal.2003).
Intheproject“GeothermalresourcesofRhineland-Palatine”(Schilletal.,2007,Schilletal.,2009),geological3DmodelswereperformedfortheareasBadBergzabern,Landau,andSpeyer.IthasbeenshownthatthemajorthermalanomaliesintheRhinevalleyarerelatedtohorststructures.TheinversionofthegravitydataintheSoultzarearevealsalowdensityanom-aly,whichcoincideswiththeSoultzhorststructure.Suchlowdensitycanberelatedtohighporosity.2DMagnetotelluricmeasurementsacrosstheSoultzhorstrevealahighelectricconductivityinthewesternpartofthehorstbetweentheSoultzandKutzenhausenfaultsatthetopgranite.Highelectricconductivitycanberelatedthegeothermalbrinewithmeanresis-tivityofabout0.1Ohmm.
Inordertoinvestigatetheformationofthesetypesofgeothermalreservoirs,a3Dgeologicalmodelissetupusingseismicreflectionprofilestodescribethestructuresindetail(Figure1).Implicit3Dgeologicalmodelingprovidesapowerfultoolextrapolatecomplexfaultgeometriesderivedfrom2Dcrosssectionssuchasseismicprofilesandboreholedatatounknownpartsofthemodel,(e.g.RenardandCourrioux,1994).
Figure1:Preliminary3DModeloftheFaultNetworkatSoultz
229
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sThegeneralaimofthisstudyistoinvestigatethedistributionandformationofpermeabilityinthesehorststructures.Thiswillbeaccomplishedbymeshingthegeological regional3Dmodel fornumerical simulation.Ageodynamicmodelwillestablishedusingdifferentobservablesinthehorststructure,suchasthetemperatureanomaly,distributionoffaults,frac-turesandporosity,andthespecificmorphologicalsettingofahorstintheRhinevalley.Inasecondpartoftheproject,theinfluenceoftheorientationsmall-scalestructuressuchastheinternalmorphologyoffaultsonthefluiddynamicswillbeinvestigated.
REFERENCESBächler,D.,Kohl,Th.,Rybach,L.2003: Impactofgraben-parallel faultsonhydrothermalconvection -RhineGrabencase
study,PhysicsandChemistryoftheEarth,28,431-441.Renard, P.&Courrioux,G. 1994: "3-Dimensional geometricmodelingof a faulteddomain – the soultz-horst example
(Alsace,France)."Computers&Geosciences20(9):1379-1390.Schill, E.,Kohl, Th.,Wellmann, J. F. 2007: First resultsof theGeothermalResourceAnalysis inRhineland-Palatine, First
EuropeanGeothermalReview,GeothermalEnergyforElectricPowerProduction,October29-31,2007,Mainz,RhinelandPalatinate,Germany,AbstractsandPapers.
Schill,E.,Kohl,Th.,Baujard,C.,Kümmritz,J.,Wellmann,J.F.,2009:GeothermischerRessourcenatlasRheinland-Pfalz–Süd-undVorderpfalz.Report for theMinisterium fürUmwelt, ForstenundVerbraucherschutzRheinland-Pfalz, February,2009
8.3
Converting geological maps to vector datasets – Completing the National Geological Information
BalandPauline1&MöriAndreas1
1Federal Office of Topograpy swisstopo, Swiss Geological Survey, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern ([email protected])
TheSwissGeologicalSurvey(SGS)hasbeenproducinggeologicalmapsformorethan80years.TheirmainproductistheGeologicalAtlasofSwitzerland1:25'000(GA25).About50%ofthe220mapsheetsarefinishedandavailableinprintedandraster formats.Because thedemand forgeologicalvectordatahas increased strongly in recentyears, theSGS started toconverttheexistinggeologicalmapsintovectordatasets.
Dependingontheavailablesourceformat,oneoftwotechniquesisappliedtoconvertmapdataintoaGIS-format:
1) "MethodSion":Mapsavailable"only"inrasterformataredirectlyvectorisedinaGISenvironment.ThismethodwasdevelopedincooperationwiththeCentrederechercheenenvironnementalpin(CREALP)andtheactualtransfor-mationisperformedattheInstituteofGeomaticsandRiskAnalysisoftheUniversityofLausanne(IGAR)
2) "MethodVallorbe":Forrecentlyprintedmaps,AdobeIllustratorvectordataareavailable.Usingthesedataasaninput,"cartographic"dataareconvertedbytheaidofAvenza-MapublishertoattributedGIS-data.ThismethodisbeingdevelopedincollaborationwiththeSwissGeotechnicalCommission.
Bothmethodsareequivalentandarebasedonthegeologicaldatamodel,which isdeveloped inaseparatedproject (cf.Straskyetal.,thisvolume).Presentlyabout40%oftheexistingmapsoftheGA25(about50maps)werealreadyconverted.The"MethodSion"isnowimplementedbytheSGSalsoonotherpublishedmapswithdifferentscales.
SincetheSGSisnotabletosolelyfinancetheentirevectorisation,collaborationwithcantonsandinsurancecompanieshasbeeninitiated.Thismodeloffinancingworksquitewell,but,theSGSissubjecttotheprioritiesandresourcesofthespe-cificinstitutions.
Theoverallobjectiveof theSGS is tobuildaGeographic InformationSystem,whichprovides seamlessvectordatasetsofSwitzerland.Toreachthisaim,oneofthemaintaskswillbetogeometricallyandsemanticallyharmonisetheexistingvectordatasets.Thedifficultyofthistaskisincreasedbythevarious"quality"ofeachmap.Duringthe80-yearperiodofmappro-duction,thescientificknowledgehaschangedmanytimesandthereforethegeologicalinterpretationinthemapsaswell.Thetwomethodsarecurrentlyinfulluseandwellintegrated.Furthermore,constantupdatingoftheappliedmethodsen-sureshighdataquality.ThesedataarethebasisforthefuturegrowthoftheGeologicalInformationSystemofSwitzerland.
230Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.4
Risk, measured risk aversion and individual characteristics
BaruffiniMoreno1
1Istituto Scienze della Terra IST-SUPSI, C.P. 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])
Riskanduncertaintyplayakeyroleineverydaylife:duringthepastseveralyearstheworldhaswitnessedsomeunprece-denteddisastersthatheavilycrushedsocietiesandlivingsystems.Individuals,institutions,andcommunitieshavetheabilitytodeflect,withstand,andreboundfromseriousshocksintermsofthecourseoftheirordinaryactivitiesorthroughingenuityandperseveranceinthefaceofacrisis.Isthereforeveryimportanttorecordandestimateriskaversion.
Whatistheimpactofcontextsonwillingnesstotakerisks?Howdoriskperceptionchangeshazardperceptionandtherebyrisk?
Unfortunatelythistaskisstillextremelydifficult:theindividualbehavioursdependsonalotofcharacteristicswithelicita-tionbias,preferencereversalandsoon.Usingaquestionthatasksaboutwillingnesstotakerisks(onaelevenpointsscale)weperformedsometestsonacohortcomposedbyyoungstudents.Usingquestionsabouttheirriskperceptioninspecificdomains,ascardrivingortraining,weanalyzedtheriskaversionandtheimpactofcontext.Wefinallyvalidatedresultsthoughalotteryquestionforanhypotheticinvestment.
Aimingtoimproveourunderstandingofriskperceptionandhowtorepresentitwefoundsomeevidences:distributiontotakerisksisquiteheterogenicacrossindividuals,femalesandoldagedpeoplearemoreriskaversethanmalesandyoungpeople,ageneralriskquestioncanactuallybeusedtomodelageneralriskbehaviour.
Theinitialresults,althoughstillrough,canbeveryusefultorepresentactualriskaversionacrossasocietyoragroupandcanbeusedtovalidateriskmanagementstudiesinthefieldofnaturalortechnologicalhazards.
REFERENCESCaliendo,M.,Fossen,F.andKritikos,A.2007:Riskattitudesofnascententrepreneurs:newevidencefromanexperimentally-
validatedsurvey.DiscussionpapersDIWBerlin.DarmstadtUniversityofTechnology,InstituteWAR;UniversityofBern,DepartmentofGeography,AppliedGeomorphology
andNatural Risks, Spatial planning and supporting instruments for preventive floodmanagement, TechnischeUniversitätDarmstadt,Darmstadt/Bern
Dohmen,T.etal.2005:Individualriskattitudes:newevidencefromalarge,representative,experimentally-validatedsurvey.DiscussionpapersDIWn.511,Berlin.
Hartog,J.,Ferrer-i-Carbonell,A.andJonker,N.2002:Linkingmeasuredriskaversiontoindividualcharacteristics.KYKLOSVol.5-2002-Fasc.1,3-26.
8.5
Systematic analysis of natural hazards along infrastructure networks using a GIS-tool for risk assessment
BaruffiniMirko1&ThüringManfred1
1Istituto Scienze della Terra IST-SUPSI, C.P. 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])
Infrastructurevulnerability isaraisingtopicof interest inthescientific literatureforboththegeneral increaseofunex-pectedeventsandtheextremelyimportancethatcertainlinksplayinsolvingeverydayneeds.Infact,duetothetopographicalconditionsinSwitzerland,thehighwaysandtherailwaylinesarefrequentlyexposedtonaturalhazardsasrockfalls,debrisflows,landslides,avalanchesandothers.
231
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sTomitigatetheseassociatedlosses,bothtraditionalprotectivemeasuresandland-useplanningpoliciesaretobedevelopedandimplementedtooptimizefutureinvestments.Thisasksforahighlevelofsurveillanceandpreservationalongthetransalpinelines.Efficientprotectionalternativescanbeobtainedconsequentlyconsideringtheconceptofintegralriskmanagement.
Riskanalysis,asthecentralpartofriskmanagement,hasbecomegraduallyagenerallyacceptedapproachfortheassess-mentofcurrentandfuturescenarios(Loat&Zimmermann2004).Theprocedureaimsatriskreductionwhichcanberea-chedbyconventionalmitigationononehandandtheimplementationofland-useplanningontheotherhand:acombina-tionofactiveandpassivemitigationmeasuresisappliedtopreventdamagetobuildings,peopleandinfrastructures.
WithaGeographicalInformationSystemadaptedtorunwithatooldevelopedtomanageRiskanalysisitispossibletosurveythedataintimeandspace,obtaininganimportantsystemformanagingnaturalrisks.
Asaframework,weadopttheSwisssystemforriskanalysisofgravitationalnaturalhazards(BUWAL1999).Itoffersacom-pleteframeworkfortheanalysisandassessmentofrisksduetonaturalhazards,rangingfromhazardassessmentforgravi-tationalnaturalhazards,suchaslandslides,collapses,rockfalls,floodings,debrisflowsandavalanches,tovulnerabilityas-sessmentandriskanalysis,andtheintegrationintolanduseplanningatthecantonalandmunicipalitylevel.Theschemeislimitedtothedirectconsequencesofnaturalhazards.
Thus,wedevelopasystemwhichintegratestheproceduresforacompleteriskanalysisinaGeographicInformationSystem(GIS)toolbox,inordertobeappliedtoourtestbed,theAlps-crossingcorridorofSt.Gotthard.ThesimulationenvironmentisdevelopedwithinArcObjects,thedevelopmentplatformforArcGIS.ThetopicofArcObjectsusuallyemergeswhenusersrealizethatprogrammingArcObjectscanactuallyreducetheamountofripetitivework,stream-linetheworkflow,andevenproducefunctionalitiesthatarenoteasilyavailableinArcGIS.WehaveadoptedVisualBasicforApplications(VBA)forprogrammingArcObjects.BecauseVBAisalreadyembeddedwithinArcMapandArcCatalog,itiscon-venientforArcGISuserstoprogramArcObjectsinVBA.
Ourtoolvisualisestheobtaineddatabyananalysisofhistoricaldata(aerialphotoimagery,fieldsurveys,documentationofpastevents)oranenvironmentalmodeling(estimationsoftheareaaffectedbyagivenevent),andeventsuchasroutenumb-erandroutepositionandthematicmaps.
AsaresultofthissteptherecordappearsinWebGIS.Theusercanselectaspecificareatooverviewprevioushazardsintheregion.Afterperformingtheanalysis,adoubleclickonthevisualisedinfrastructuresopensthecorrespondingresults.Theconstantlyupdatedriskmapsshowallsitesthatrequiremoreprotectionagainstnaturalhazards.
Thefinalgoalofourworkistoofferaversatiletoolforriskanalysiswhichcanbeappliedtoothersituations.TodayourGISapplicationmainlycentralisesthedocumentationofnaturalhazards.Additionallythesystemoffersinformationaboutna-turalhazardattheGotthardline.TheinitialresultsoftheexperimentalcasestudyshowshowusefulaGIS-basedsystemcanbeforeffectiveandefficientdi-sasterresponsemanagement.InthecomingyearsourGISapplicationwillbeadatabasecontainingallinformationneededfortheevaluationofrisksitesalongtheGotthardline.OurGISapplicationcanhelpthetechnicalmanagementtodecideaboutprotectionmeasuresbecauseof,inadditiontothevisualisation,toolsforspatialdataanalysiswillbeavailable.
Wepresenttheconceptandcurrentstateofdevelopmentandanapplicationtothetestbed,theAlps-crossingcorridorofSt.Gotthard.
REFERENCESBründlM.(Ed.),2009:RisikokonzeptfürNaturgefahren-Leitfaden.NationalePlattformfürNaturgefahrenPLANAT,Bern.
416S.BUWAL 1999: Risikoanalyse bei gravitativenNaturgefahren -Methode, Fallbeispiele undDaten (Risk analyses for
gravitationalnaturalhazards).Bundesamt fürUmwelt,WaldundLandschaft (BUWAL).Umwelt-MaterialenNr. 107,1-244.
Loat,R.&Zimmermann,M.2004:LagestiondesrisquesenSuisse(RiskManagementinSwitzerland).In:Veyret,Y.,Garry,G.,MeschinetdeRichemont,N.&ArmandColin (eds) 2002:ColloqueArchede laDéfense22–24octobre2002,dansRisquesnaturelsetaménagementenEurope,108-120.
MaggiR.etal,2009:Evaluationoftheoptimalresilienceforvulnerableinfrastructurenetworks.Aninterdisciplinarypilotstudyonthetransalpinetransportationcorridors,NRP54“SustainableDevelopmentoftheBuiltEnvironment”,ProjektNr.405440,FinalScientificReport,Lugano
232Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.6
Challenges for geological surveys in geological 3D model building and validation
BaumbergerRoland&OesterlingNils
Swiss Geological Survey, Federal Office of Topography swisstopo, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern, SwitzerlandContact: [email protected]
Geological3Dmodelsarealwayswrongtosomeextent.Therefore,whilebuildingupgeological3Dmodels,specialemphasishastobemadeoneffortsconcerningdataqualitymanagement,dataassessmentandmodelvalidation.Inthiscontext,theSwissGeologicalSurvey(SGS)assumesaspecialposition,sinceitsmissionregardinggeological3Dmodellingislegallybased.Accordingtothefederallawongeoinformation(GeoIG)andthefederalactfortheSGS(LGeolV),theSGShastoprovidegeo-logicaldataandinformationtothefederaladministrationandtothirdpartiesinanalogueordigitalformats.Additionally,theSGSisinchargeofofferingextensivegeologicaldataandthereforewantstobuildupnational,regionalandlocalgeolo-gical3Dmodelsatdifferentresolutionsandscales.
WhileproducingtheGeologicalAtlasofSwitzerland,theSGSisgenerallycommittedtoahighlevelofqualityinordertomeetthescientificandcartographicstandardsthatareeithersetbytheSGSitselfordemandedbythepartnersandcusto-mers.Regardingthegeological3Dmodelling,itistheresponsibilityoftheSGStobuildupvalid,geologicallycorrectandconsistent3Dmodels.Furthermore, this levelofqualitymustcomplywiththequalityrequirementsof themapproduc-tion.Drivenbythisguidelines,theSGSfacesseveraltechnicalandorganisationalchallenges:(1)therequiredinputdatafor3Dmodellingiswidelydistributedanditsexistenceissometimesuncertain,(2)thequalityoftheexistinginputdatadependsontheproducerandhashighlyvariableresolution,accuracy,conceptualgeologicalbackgroundandreliability,(3)thepur-poseandscaleofthedatasamplingvaries,(4)differentconceptsfordatamanagement(acquisition,storage,usage)havetobeintegratedand(5)thetechnicalandconceptualbackgroundsofalreadyexisting3Dmodelsarediverging.
Facingthesechallenges,onehastobeawarethatthequality,informationdepthanddensityaswellastheconsistencypro-videdbyageological3Dmodelshowadirectcorrelationtothequalityofthedatasources.Theinformationprovidedcanonlybeasgoodasthequalityoftheinputdata.Asaconsequence,theSGShastoperformextraeffortsinthefieldsofdatastandardisationandharmonisationaswellasqualitymanagement.Thesebasicstepswillbecoveredbythedatamodelforgeologicaldata,whichiscurrentlybeingbuiltbytheSGS.Fromthescientificpointofview,itisnecessarytousethelatestprovengeologicalconceptsandtofollowresearchtrendsinordertosuccessfullyprovidethemostaccurategeologicalmodelsinthreedimensions.Regardingthetechnicalaspects,theSGSmustuseupdatedapproachesregardingmodellingconcepts,methodsandwork-flows,datastorage,dataexchangeability,modelvalidationanddistributionofthe3Dmodels.Thechallengeslistedabovehaveleadtotheconceptionofthegeneralarchitectureofgeological3DmodellingattheSGS(ELFERSetal.,2004,adaptedbySGS).Followingthisapproach,thelargenumberofinputdataisfirstofallstoredinappro-priate storage facilities. Secondly, thesedata are checked, adapted, interpreted, (re-)formatted, assessedandharmonised.Thirdly,thepreparedandstandardiseddataarefedintothegeological3Dmodellingsoftware,anda3Dfaultmodelanda3Dsurfacemodelaredevelopediteratively.Fourthly,thesetwomodelsarestoredasthebasicgeological3Dmodel,fromwhichalargenumberofspecializedandspecific3Dmodelsmaybederived(Figure1).
Toperformtheaforementionedprocess,theSGSappliestheMovesoftwaresuitefromMidlandValleyExploration.ModelvalidationisalsoperformedwithMove.Byprovidingvarioustoolsformodelbuildingandvalidation,theMovesoftwareallowstheSGS(1)tobuildupvalid3Dmodels,(2)toachievegeologicalconsistencyinthreedimensionsandthroughtimeaswellas(3)toaccountfortheuncertaintyregardingthedataquality.UsingMove2009.2,theSGSisabletomanagethescientific,organisationalandtechnicalchallengesitisfacinginthefieldofgeological3Dmodelling.
REFERENCESELFERS,H.etal.(2004):Wegezur3D-Geologie,Krefeld,2004MOVE2009,MidlandValleyExploration,Glasgow(UK),http://www.mve.com
233
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
DATA ACQUISITION DATA PREPARATION GEOLOGICAL3D MODELLING
GEOLOGICAL3D BASIS MODEL
drill holes cross section
surfaces maps
geotechnical geophysical
3D modelsart. bodiesother
data check
reformatting
interpretation / adaptation
�rst /re-assessment
data storage in temporarysources harmonisation
& standardisation
source data
generation
import
integrationplatform
3D geology
existingdata&3Dmodels
3D fault model+
3D surface model
Figure1:Thearchitectureoftheprocessofgeological3DmodellingattheSGS(basedonELFERSetal.(2004),adaptedbySGS)
8.7
Overview of available geoscience data in Switzerland
BeresMilan&KühniAndreas
Swiss Geological Survey, Federal Office of Topography swisstopo, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern ([email protected])
Geoscienceinformationismadeavailableforthepurposesofrecognizingandreactingtoenvironmentalproblems,evalua-tingconstructionprojectsandnaturalresources,planningexcursionsandsimplyenjoyingnature.Manyusersofthisinfor-mation are also producers and include various federal and state agencies, the energy industry, universities and privateconsultingoffices.InSwitzerlandtheproductionofgeosciencedataandinformationishighlydecentralised,signifyingawidevarietyofformats,qualities,accessibilitiesandvisualisations.Furthermore,theuserscommonlydonotknowwhichdatasetsareavailable,wheretheycanbeobtainedandwhatpurposestheyallserve.
Tomeetthechallengesmentionedabove,theSwissGeologicalSurveyanditscollaboratorsareplanningtopublishanover-viewofallavailabledatasetsinSwitzerlandthatarerelevanttoearthscience(Beresetal.2008,2009).Thisoverviewisaimedatadiverseaudience(e.g.politicians,interdisciplinaryprofessionals,researchers,teachers,students,hobbygeologists,tou-rists)andhasthefollowinggoals:
• Togiveanoverview:eye-catchingfiguresandshorttexts,whichdescribethedatasettheory,purpose,sourceandproduc-tionmethods,areenvisagedforthepublication.
• Tosensitisethepublic:asmanypeopleaspossibleshouldbemadeawareofhowtheearthsciencestouchoureverydaylife.
• Toboostpublicrelations:withsuchapublication,producersofgeosciencedataandinformationcanadvertisetodecisi-onmakersandthegeneralpublic.
• Tobuildanetwork:theresultsoughttopromotecontactsandcollaborationamongproducersandusersofgeosciencedataandinformation.
• Tointegratedatasets:anoverviewservesasthebasis for integratingdatasets inthegeological informationsystemofSwitzerland(Oesterlingetal.2009).
234Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Recentpublications(Jackson2004;Hofmann&Schönlaub2007)showthatsimilargoalsarebestachievedbycreatingaprin-ted,easilyunderstandabledocument.
Productionoftheoverviewcomprisesclearlydefinedtasks.Contactingthedataproducersandestablishingcollaborationarepartoftheinitialphase.Thisphasealsoincludesdeterminingexactlywhohaswhatandchoosingtheoptimalrepresen-tationforaparticulartheme.Presently,theoverviewcontains54themes,whicharecategorisedintothefollowingfourbasicgroups:
• Earthfundamentals,e.g.tectonics,stratigraphy,bathymetry,soiltypes,magneticfield,gravityanomalies,topography.• Constructionandresources,e.g.hydrogeology,landuse,geothermalenergy,varioustypesofrockquarries.• Hazardsandenvironment,e.g.earthquakes,massmovements,radonrisk,groundwaterquality.• Geotourismandgeologicalheritage,e.g.showcaves,thematichikingtrails,geotopes.
Thelayoutstipulatestwopages(A4portrait)foreachtheme.Ontheleftpage,thedataset,insomecasesgeneralised,isover-lainonamapoftheSwissnationalboundaryandmajorlakes.Inthecaseofpointdata,asimplifiedtectonicmapservesasanadditionalbackground.Logosandanextractofamoredetaileddatasetoranexplanatoryfigurearelocatedonthelowerhalfofthispage.Ontherightpage,thetitle,thetheme’scategory,explanatorytext,datasources/ownershipandacarefullychosendiagramorphotographareincluded.SinceSwitzerlandisamultilingualcountry,acolumnoftextinGermanandasecondcolumnofthesametextinFrencharenecessary.ProvidingasummaryofthetextinEnglishwouldbeparticularlyhelpfulforinternationalreaders.
Insummary,therearemanyreasonstoproduceanattractiveandinformativeoverviewoftheavailablegeosciencedatasetsinSwitzerland.Suchanoverviewnotonlywillillustratethehighlightsofthecountry’suniquenaturalfeatures,butitwillalsosensitiseabroadaudienceandstrengthennetworkingamongmembersoftheSwissgeo-scene.ThesereasonsmakeitanimportantcontributiontotheplannedgeologicalinformationsystemofSwitzerland.
REFERENCESBeres,M.,Kühni,A.&Schindler,U. 2008:Bringinggeothematicmaps to thepublic.Abstract of the33rd International
GeologicalCongress,August6-14,Oslo,SessionIEI-14.Beres,M.,Kühni,A.&Schindler,U.2009:ThegeothematicatlasofSwitzerland:Anoverviewofgeologicallyrelevantmaps
foreveryone.ExtendedAbstractofthe6thEuropeanCongressonRegionalGeoscientificCartographyandInformationSystems,Vol.II,June9-12,Munich,233-235.
Hofmann,T.&Schönlaub,H.P.(Eds.)2007:Geo-AtlasÖsterreich,DieVielfaltdesgeologischenUntergrundes.GBA,Böhlau,Vienna,112pp.
Jackson,I.(Ed.)2004:Britainbeneathourfeet.BGSOccasionalPublication4,Keyworth,Nottingham,120pp.Oesterling,N., Baumberger,R., Beres,M.,Kühni,A.&Kündig,R. 2009: Thegeological information systemSwitzerland.
ExtendedAbstractofthe6thEuropeanCongressonRegionalGeoscientificCartographyandInformationSystems,Vol.I,June9-12,Munich,254-256.
235
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.8
Exposure-based risk assessment for tephra accumulation: the example of Cotopaxi volcano (Ecuador)
BiassSébastien1,ParmigianiAndrea1,Dell’OroLuca2,SenegasOlivier2&BonadonnaCostanza1
1Départment de Minéralogie, Rue de Maraîchers 13, CH-1205 Genève, Switzerland ([email protected])2UNOSAT, International Environment House, Chemin des Anémones 11-13, CH-1219 Châtelaine, Switzerland
Tephra isamajorproductofexplosiveeruptionsand itsdispersalandaccumulationcancausesignificantdisruptionofhumanactivities.Duetoitscapacitytoreachwidespreadareas,variouseffectsonthesurroundingcommunitiesneedtobeconsidered.Thesecanbeclassifiedasphysicalaspects(e.g.collapseofbuildings,breakdownofelectricalsystems),economi-calaspects(e.g.damagetocrops,deathofcattle,effectsontourism),functionalaspects(e.g.blockageofroads,airportsandairtraffic)andhealthaspects(e.g.breathingoffineparticles,eyeandskinirritation)(e.g.Blong1984).
Duetotheconstantincreaseofpopulationdensityaroundvolcanoes(SibertandSimkins1994),governmentsandplannersrequireknowledgeofboththeexpectedhazardandtheelementsatriskinordertoproduceefficientland-useandemergen-cyplanningprioracrisis.Inthisframework,wepresentanewmethodologydesignedtohelpdecision-makerstodealwithtephrafallout.First,hazardmapsarecompiledbasedontheTEPHRA2analyticalmodel (Bonadonnaetal.2005).Second,exposure-basedriskmapsareproducedbycombininghazardmapsandurbanelementsthroughGIS-basedfuzzymodelling.Giventhatpreciseandup-to-dategeographicaldataaretypicallydifficulttoaccess,webasedourexposureassessmentonfreeandglobaldatasets,whichincludeinformationonbuildings,vegetation,agriculture,airports,roadnetworkandcriticalinfrastructures.
Wehave testedourmethodologyonCotopaxivolcano (Ecuador),which is located60kmsouthofQuitoand threatensahighlypopulatedvalley.Wehaveproducedexposure-basedriskmapsaccountingfordifferenteruptionmagnitudestypicalofthelast2000yearsofvolcanicactivityofCotopaxivolcano.
Figure1.Situationmapwithmainpopulatedareasandprincipalvolcanoes.
REFERENCESBonadonna,C.,Connor,C.B.,Houghton,B.F.,Connor,L.,Byrne,M.,Laing,A.,Hincks,T.K.2005:Probabilisticmodellingof
tephradispersal:HazardassessmentofamultiphaserhyoliticeruptionatTarawera,NewZealand,JournalofGeophysicalResearch,110,B03203,doi:10.1029/2003JB002896.
Blong,R.J.1984:Volcanichazards:asourcebookontheeffectsoferuptions.AcademicPress,Sydney.Simkin,T.,Siebert,L.1994:Volcanoesoftheworld,GeosciencepressInc.inassociationwithSmithsonianInstitution,1-349.
236Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.9
GIS-based method for groundwater management and protection: geo-types serving 3D applications
BilgotSéverine1,ParriauxAurèle1
1 EPFL ENAC IIC GEOLEP, Station 18, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Sustainablemanagementofundergroundnaturalresourcesismoreandmoreaworthwhiletopic.Inparticular,worryingaboutgroundwaterprotectionbecomes imperative. Taking intoaccount the increaseof incompatibilitiesbetweenwaterconservationandtheuseofotherundergroundresources,theGeoleplaboratorybroughtoneofitsresearchaxesaroundtonewmethodsforgroundwaterresourcesassessmentandmanagement.Asthesemethodshavetobeastransparentaspossible,weimplementedaGIStousestandardizedprotocolstorealizenewmapsofgroundwaterprotectionareasandresourcesindexand,inasecondstep,todeterminewhereitshouldbepossibletoinstallgeothermalheatpumpswithoutendangeringdrinkablewaterresources(OFEV,2009).Thesemethodologies arebothbasedon theuseof thegeotypes,which is anewclassification for geological formations(ParriauxandTurberg,2007);itinvolvestheuseofgeneticstandardsforloosematerial(e.g.lodgementtill)andlithologicstandards for hard rock (e.g. sandstone). Forty-one geotypes and their properties in relation to groundwaterswere thusintegratedinaGISandcompletedwithgeophysicalandboreholesdata.TheachievementofthenewgroundwaterprotectionareasmapsiscurrentlyinthepipelineforthewholecantonofVaud,whiletheimplementationofthenewmethodologyforgeothermalheatpumpadmissibilitymapping(riquiringthebuildingofa3Dgeologicalmodel)isstillbeingtested.
REFERENCESOFEV:Exploitationdelachaleurtiréedusoletdusous-sol.Aideàl’exécutiondestinéeauxautoritésetauxspécialistesde
géothermie.L’environnementpratiquen°0910.Officefédéraldel’environnement,Berne,51p,2009.A.ParriauxandP.Turberg,Lesgéotypes,pourunereprésentationgéologiqueduterritoire,Tracés,Nr.15/16,pp.11-17,2007.
8.10
A pseudo-genetic approach for the stochastic generation of karstic networks
AndreaBorghi1,PhilippeRenard1andSandraJenni1
1 University of Neuchâtel, Stochastic Hydrogeology Group, 11 Rue Emile Argand CP 158 2000 Neuchâtel, Switzerland. [email protected], [email protected] Schlumberger Water Services, Immeuble Madeleine D, 92057 Paris la Défense Cédex France, [email protected]
Modellingkarstsystemsisachallengebecauseoftheirextremespatialheterogeneitywhichstronglyinfluencesthehydrau-licandsolutetransportbehaviour.Forthisreasonitisnecessarytotakeintoaccountboththeconduitsystemandthema-trix.Itbecomesthennecessarytodevelopmethodstogeneraterealistickarsticconduitsystemseveniftheirpositionisnotknownaccurately.Themethodpresentedinthispostersimulateskarstconduitsystemstakingintoaccountononehandfieldobservations(thatmaybeindirect)andontheotherhandtheconceptualgeologicalknowledgecontrollingtheconduitstructuresthatmightbedisplayedinagivengeologicalenvironment.
237
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sThesuggestedmethodologyisbasedonthefollowingsteps:
1. 3Dregionalgeologymodelling:thepositionofthecarbonateformationsin3Dwithrespecttotheothernonkarstifia-bleformationscontrolsthelocationswherethekarsticnetworkcandevelop;
2. simulationoftheinternalpropertiesofthekarstifiableformation(e.g.fracturation,stratificationjoints):theinternalpropertiesoftheformationstronglyinfluencethelocalshapeoftheconduits;
3. identificationoftherecentorpaleohydrodynamiccontrolsataregionalscale:thisisachievedbyidentifyingrechargeanddischargemechanisms,locationofthepunctualordiffuseoutletsandinlets(springs,dolines,shallow-holesetc),asitisknownthatthetypeofrechargeordischargecontrolsthetypeofnetworkthatcandevelop;
4. foreachpossiblephaseofkarstification:a.extrapolationofthecorrespondingpaleobaselevelandsimulationofthekarsticconduitsfromthetopographic
surfacetowardthebaselevelusingafastfronttrackingmethod(levelset)andrandomwalkermethod;b.usingthesamefronttrackingmethod,connectthepathsthathavebeencreatedintheunsaturatedzonetothe
outletthroughthesaturatedzone;inbothstepsaandb,thepathsfollowthegeologicalstructureandarecontrol-ledononehandbythelocalheterogeneitiesgeneratedinstep2andontheotherhandbytheflowconditions;
Thefinalresultisa3Dkarsticnetworkthatiscontrolledbytheregionalgeology,thelocalheterogeneitiesandtheregionalflowconditions.Thenetworkcanthenbeusedtomodelflowandtransport.Severallevelsofrandomnesscanbeconsidered(uncertaintyonlargescalegeologicalstructures,localheterogeneity,positionofpossibleinletsandoutlets,phasesofkarsti-fication)allowingtoinvestigatetheuncertaintyonthestructureofthenetworkanditsconsequences.
Comparedtoothertechniques,thismethodpresentstheadvantagetobefast,toaccountforthemainfactorscontrollingthe3Dgeometryofthenetwork,andtoallowconditioningfromfieldobservationswhenavailable.
Figure1.a)3Dgeologicalmodel(volumeview)b)3Dkarsticnetworkinaregularmeshc)2Dkarsticnetworkin2Dregularmeshd)3D
geologicalmodel(crosssections)
238Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.11
SAPHYR, the Swiss atlas of physical properties of rocks
BruijnRolf1,ZapponeAlba1,BurliniLuigi1,TripoliBarbara1,HolligerKlaus2,BurgJean-Pierre1&KisslingEduard1
1ETH, Department of Earth Sciences, Sonneggstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])2UNIL, Institute of Geophysics, Amphipole – UNIL SORGE, CH-1015 Lausanne
Since2006,amulti-yearprojectrunsundertheumbrellaoftheSwissGeophysicalCommission(SGPK),withtheaimtodigi-tizeallexistingdataonphysicalpropertiesofrocksandtolinkthemusingageographicalframe(GIS).
Theaimistomakethosedataaccessibletoawidepublicsuchasinindustrialcontext:constructionandengineeringcom-panies,geothermalinvestigationandextraction,etc.,forlanduseplanners:waterresource,wastedisposalnaturalhazardetc.;andfinallyforacademicstudies(integratedgeophysical,geologicalandpetrologicalresearch,researchinpetrophysicsetc).
Thephysicalpropertiesofinterestaredensityandporosity,seismic,magnetic,thermalproperties,permeability,electricalproperties.Forthetimebeingdatafromliteraturehasbeencollectedextensivelyforseismicpropertiesandonlypartiallyfortheotherphysicalproperties.Herewepresentthefirstoutput:amapofSwitzerlandwithsamplelocationscombinedwithcontouredvaluesofVp,seefigure1,extrapolatedtoroomconditionsfromthehighpressurelaboratorymeasurements(matrix or crack free properties). The values are reported as contours and colour-coded. A sample locationmap for Vsmeasurementsisalsopresented.Vsanalysisanddataprocessingisongoingworkinprogress.Weexpecttopublishthere-sultsontheAtlasofSwitzerland(swisstopo),hopefullybytheendof2009.
Figure1.MapofSwitzerlandwithcompressionwavevelocityvariations,originatingfromlithologicalheterogeneities.Vpcolourgroups
werederivedfromindividualVpmeasurementsontypicalrocktypesfoundintheAlps.Locationsofrocksamplesaremarkedbyablack
star.Literaturevaluesforwaterandiceareusedtorepresentlakesandglaciers.Mappolygonsweretakenfrom‘DigitaleGeotechnische
KartederSchweiz1:500000’,producedbySGTK.
239
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.12
IstSOS: Sensor Observation Service in Python
MassimilianoCannata,MilanAntonovic
Istituto Scienze della Terra, IST-SUPSI CH-6952 Canobbio, Tel. +41 (0)58 666 62 09
Approvingthenewfederallowaboutgoinformation(RS510.62),theSwitzerlandgaveagreatimpulsetotheestablishmentofanationalspatialdatainfrastructure,whichinagreementwiththeEuropeanCommissiondirectiveINSPIRE(2007/2/CE),willbebasedongeo-services.
Thisapproachhastheadvantagetogive,localadministrationanddatamaintainer,thefreedomtochoosethedesiredfor-mats,softwareanddatamodelbutimposetheprovisionoftherequireddatathroughoutastandardWebservice.Thissim-plifytheprocessofdatagathering(theusergetthedataondemandandnotanymorethemaintainerprovidethemonre-quest)providingthebasisforarealandpracticalaccomplishmentofthesomuchdesireddatainteroperability.Geoscientistsareparticularlyinterestedinthistypeofinteroperability: infactaconsiderablyexpensivecommonphaseofmostofthegeo-projectsinvolvestheacquisitionandintegrationofdatainordertobefurtheronprocessedandanalyzed.
WhilesomeoftheGeographicalWebServices,likeWMSandWFS,aretodaywidelydiffusedandapplied,otherslikeSOS(SensorObservationService)arestillaworkinprogressandneedsomerevisionfortheircorrectapplication.
InordertoinvestigateandprovidesuchakindofSDIforscientists,theIST(IstitutoScienzedellaTerra)isdevelopinganew,fullyOGCcompliant,SOSinPythonlanguagethatisabletodistributeobservationdataandtoprovideaprocessingenviron-mentfordevelopingresearches.
Duringthedevelopmentphaseaseriesofconsiderationsandpracticalsolutionshasbeenstudied.Asaconclusion,atthisstageofdevelopment,theauthorscanunderlinethefollowingopenissues:
• ThexmlschemesusedintheSOSarenumerous,nestedandofteninterchangeable.ThisleadstoanSOSresponsesvari-able,dependingonthesoftwareandtheinterpretationthatthedeveloperapplied,andthereforeadifficultautomaticparsing.
• TheSOSdoesnotprovidepreciseinformationononthologiesleadingtomisunderstandingdefinitions.• Thestandardsdonottakeintoaccountthetypeofobservationaccordingtothesensorlocation(in-situorremote),the
observationtype(point-wiseordistributed),andtheobservationdynamic(staticormobile).
Tooverridethislacks,wearedevelopingasystemthatinternallyconsidertheseissuesstillconservingthecompliancewiththecurrentstandard.Moreinformationareavailableat:http://istgeo.ist.supsi.ch/site/projects/istsos
REFERENCES510.62,Loifédéralesurlagéoinformation,http://www.admin.ch/ch/f/rs/510_62/index.htmlOpenGIS®SensorObservationService(SOS),http://www.opengeospatial.org/standards/sos
240Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.13
Modeling heterogeneous geological reservoirs using multiple-point statistics simulations
ComunianAlessandro1,StraubhaarJulien1,RenardPhilippe1,RolandFroidevaux2
1Centre for Hydrogeology (CHYN), University of Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH - 2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected])2Ephesia Consult, 9, rue Boissonnas CH - 1227 Geneva, Switzerland ([email protected])
3Dmodelsofheterogeneousgeologicalreservoirsareimportanttoolstounderstandandmanageaquifers.Whenaconceptu-algeologicalmodel(analoguesite,trainingimage)ofthestructuresisknown,multiple-pointstatistics(MPS)(Strebelle,2002,Mariethozetal.,2009)canbeusedtosimulatethereservoirgeometryconstrainedtofieldobservations.ThebasicprinciplesofMPSsimulationsconsistsofasequentialprocessvisitingallnodesofthesimulationgrid.Foreachnode,aconditionalprobabilitydensityfunction(cpdf)iscomputedusingallpixelconfigurationswithinthetrainingimage(TI)andtheconfigurationcentredonthevisitednodeinthesimulationgrid.Thiscpdfisthensampledinordertodrawrandomlyafaciesintothevisitednode.
Inthiswork,weillustrateontwocasestudiestheapplicationofanewlydevelopedMPStechnique(Straubhaaretal,2009).Thecorrespondingsoftware(Impala)isparallelandcanaccountforthenonstationarityofthegeologicalformations.
Figure1.Left)TIofsize1501x501:deltaoftheLenaRiver(Russia)(ref.:Landsat7image,USGS/EROSprojectandNASALandsatproject);
right)Simulateddeltastructure(size1500x900)basedontheTIontheleft.
First,a2Dexamplewith3facies(channels,lakes,land)isconsidered.AsatelliteimageofapartoftheLenaRiverdeltaistakenasanaturalanalogue(TI,Figure1).TheMPStechniqueallowstosimulatesimilarstructureswithdifferentorienta-tions(Figure1)inaplacewherenodataareavailable.Thedistancetothecoast,rotations,andconditioningdata(insea)areusedtocontrolthenonstationarity.
MPSsimulationcanalsobeappliedtoreconstructthethree-dimensionalstructureofhighlyheterogeneoussedimentarydeposits.ThisisillustratedusingtheHertendataset(Bayer,2009).Thedatasetcontainssixparalleloutcropsof16by7metersrecordedduringtheexcavationofaquarryintheRhinebasinclosetoBasel;thefaciesdescribedinthesectionsareusedasconditioningdata.
Figure2.OnesimulationoftheHertenaquiferanalogueobtainedusingMPSandahierarchicalapproach.
241
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sAhierarchicalapproachisused:themainsedimentarystructuresaresimulatedwithordinaryKriging;insidetheselargescalestructures,smallscaleheterogeneitiesaresimulatedwiththeMPStechnique.Figure2displaysonerealizationofthe3Dheterogeneities.
ThetwocasestudiesdescribedaboveillustratehowtheMPStechniquecanbeusedtomodelrealisticnonstationaryandhighlyheterogeneousstructureswithsuccess.Thosemethodscanthenbeappliedtoevaluatetheimpactofthesehetero-geneitiesonphysicalprocessessuchasflowandtransportandthenhelptoimprovemanagementdecisionsinacontextofuncertainty.
REFERENCESBayer,P.2009:3-Dhigh-resolutioncharacterizationofasedimentarygravelbodyforuseinhydrogeologicalandreservoir
modeling,HydrogeologyJournal,submitted.Mariethoz,G., Renard, P.& Straubhaar J. 2009: Thedirect samplingmethod to performmultiple-points geostatistical
simulations,WaterResourcesResearch,submitted.Straubhaar,J.,G.Mariethoz,andP.Renard2009:Multi-pointreservoirmodeling,InternationalPatentnr.2009WO-EP053614.Strebelle,S.2002:Conditionalsimulationofcomplexgeologicalstructuresusingmultiple-pointsstatistics,Mathematical
Geology,34,1-21,2002.
8.14
Different resolutions for different topics - the geological 3D-model of the Basel region
DresmannHorst,ZechnerEric,HuggenbergerPeter&EptingJannis
Applied and Environmental Geology, Institute of Geology and Paleontology, Bernoullistrasse 32, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])
DifferentproblemsrelatedtothesubsurfaceofanurbanareasuchastheBaselregionrequiredetailedanduptodateknowl-edge.Someofthemostimportantaddresstheuseofgroundwaterresourcesfordrinkingwaterandindustrialprocesses,theuseofgeothermalenergy(deepandshallow),theexplorationofnaturalresources(e.g.salt),constructionofinfrastructure(roads,railwaysorbuildingsinthesubsurface)andearthquakehazardevaluation.Eachofthemhasspecificneedsregardinga3D-modelofsubsurface.Inparticulartheyneeddifferentscalesofresolutiontoadequatelyrepresentrelevantsurfacesandvolumesofthedifferentthematicfields(e.g.geology,hydrology,geophysics).Thepresented3D-modeloftheBaselregionwascontinuallydevelopedinordertoaddressthespecificproblems.
Thegrowingcomplexityof3Ddatarequiresaclearanduptodatedatastorageconcept.Ideally,themodelshouldbeeasilyadjustablewithnewdataandaspatialextension,oralocalrefinementofthemodelshouldbepossibleatalltime.Therefore,theaimistodevelopaflexibletool,whichoffersthebasisforthetreatmentofthemostdiversequestionsin3Dspaces.
WithinthescopeofanINTERREGIVandaBFE(BundesamtfürEnergieSwitzerland)project,westartedtocompletelyrevisetheinitial3D-modelofBasel(Zechner2001).Themaingoaloftheseprojectsistoevaluatethepossibilitiesandrisksofthedeeperunderground(Geopotentiale),withafocusonissuesrelatedtotheuseofdeepgeothermalenergy,earthquakerisksandthesequestrationofcarbondioxide.Therefore,themodelwasextendedtoasurfaceof20kmby30kmandtoadepthof6000m.Dataofabout9000boreholes,15reflectionseismiclines,aswellashigh-resolutionDEM´swereimported.Inafirststepageological3D-surfaces-modelisconstructed,whichcontainsabout20geologicalhorizonsandallimportantfaultstructures.Thissurfaces-modeloffersthebasisforavolume-model,whichoffersthepossibilitytoassignvariousspecificparameters(e.g.geophysical,hydraulical,geochemical)toadistinctbody.Suchageometricallyconsistentandparameterisedvolumemodelservesasanidealbasisfornumericalmodellingapproachessuchasgroundwaterflowsimulation.
Toaddressthegrowingimportanceofurbaninfluencestosubsurfaceprocesses,modelscontaininghighresolution(1-5mgrids)surfacesareneeded.Therefore,basedonthepresentedgeological3DmodeloftheBaselregionweplanamodel,whichfocusesonnearsurfaceobjectstypicalforhighlyurbanizedareassuchastunnels,watersupplychannels,subways,sewagesystem,cellars,parkinggarages,sitesusingshallowthermalenergyandwastedisposalsites.
REFERENCESZechnerE., Kind F., FähD.&Huggenberger P. 2001:A 3DGeologicModel of the SoutheasternRhinegraben compiledon
existinggeologicdataandgeophysicalreferencemodelling,2ndEUCOR-URGENTAnnualWorkshop2001,Abstractvolume.
242Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.15
Use of digital terrain models and GIS for neotectonic studies: Analysing fluvial terrace morphology in northern Switzerland
FraefelMarielle1,KockStéphane2,SchnellmannMichael3
1 ETH Zürich, Institute of Terrestrial Ecosystems, Universitätsstrasse 16, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])2 SC+H AG Chur, Ringstrasse 203, CH-7000 Chur3 Nagra, Hardstrasse 73, 5430 Wettingen
The tectonicevolutionofNorthernSwitzerland is intensively studiedbyNagra (NationalCooperative for theDisposalofRadioactiveWaste)inthesearchforapotentialdisposalsitefornuclearwaste.Tectonicstabilityisakeycriterionforthelocationofanuclear-wasterepositorytoachievesafeandlong-termcontainment.RecenttectonicdeformationratesandassociatedseismicactivityinnorthernSwitzerlandareverylow,asshownbygeodeticmeasurements(Nagra,2008)andtheseismotectonicrecord (Deichmannetal.,2000). Inordertobetterdescribetherecentdeformationfield,westudyyoungfluvialsediments (Niederterrasse) inthe lowerAareandRhinevalleysthatweredepositedbetweenca.32and11kaago(Bitterlietal.,2000;Kocketal.,2009).Thesealluvialgravelterracesrecordthepositionoftheriverbedbeforeoneofseveralincisionepisodes.Duetotheirrelativelysmoothdepositionalsurfaces,theterracesrepresentmarkerhorizonsfordetectingtectonicmovementsduringthelast10-30ka.Withouttectonicdisturbance,theirsurfacesareexpectedtoshowasmoothshapeandgentledownstreamdip.Irregularitiestothistrendcanbeasignforneotectonicactivity.
ThemorphologyoftheNiederterrassegravelsurfacesisanalysedinaGIS,usingthehigh-resolutiondigitalterrainmodelDTM-AV(Swisstopo,2007).Theindividualterracesaremappedusingelevationdifferences,slope,differenthillshadeillumi-nationsandtopographicrelief.Theprojectedtracesoftheterracesurfacesarethenplottedinalongitudinalvalleyprofile,allowingforthedetectionofalong-streamsteepnessvariations.The3Dorientationoftheterracesisapproximatedusinganautomatedplanartrendfunction.
Theresultsofthisstudyhelpvisualisingthepresent-daypositionandorientationofthepreservedterracesurfacesandcanbeanalysedforeffectsoftectonicdeformation.
TheterracedistributionindicatesaregionalnorthwardtiltinthelowerAarevalleyaftertheformationoftheNiederterrassegravelterraces,whichisinagreementwithgeodeticmeasurementsandthusseemstobeongoingtoday.NorthoftheJuramountains,intheRhinevalleybetweenKoblenzandBasel,theterraceoccurrenceanddipdirectionsgivenoindicationofaconsistentdeformationpattern.Thisisprobablyduetothecombinationofarelativelycomplexaccumulationanderosionhistoryandlowdeformationrates.Sofar,noclearevidenceoflocaliseddeformationaroundmajorfaultscouldbefound.
Thedigitalterrainmodelanalysisprovesahelpfultooltosystematicallyandreproduciblydescribeandinterpretthemor-phologyoffluvialterracesystemsoverlargeareas.Itallowsforthesimultaneousinvestigationofthe3Dshapeofalargenumberofriverterraces,thefastandreliableidentificationofmorphologicalpatterns,andabetterdifferentiationofsi-gnalscausedbygeologicalprocessesfromanthropogenicterrainmodifications.Whilekeepinginmindotherpossibleinflu-encesonriverterraceshapelikesedimentaryprocessesordataprocessingartifacts,thepresentedapproachfacilitatesafastandextensiveinvestigationforthegeomorphologicalexpressionsofneotectonicactivity.
REFERENCESBitterli,T.,Graf,H.R.,Matousek,F.,&Wanner,M.2000:GeologischerAtlasderSchweiz:Zurzach(Blatt1050),Erläuterungen.
Bundesamtf.Wasseru.Geologie,Bern,Switzerland.Deichmann,N.,Dolfin,D.B.,&Kastrup,U.2000:SeismizitätderNord-undZentralschweiz.NagraTechnischerBericht,00-
05.Kock,S.,Kramers,J.D.,Preusser,F.,&Wetzel,A.2009:DatingofLatePleistoceneterracedepositsoftheRiverRhineusing
uraniumseriesandluminescencemethods:potentialandlimitations.QuaternaryGeochronology,4:363-373.Nagra, 2008:Vorschlaggeologischer Standortgebiete für ein SMA-und einHAA-Lager:GeologischeGrundlagen.Nagra
TechnischerBerichtNTB08-04.Swisstopo2007:DTM-AV. geodata-news, 14,http://www.swisstopo.admin.ch/internet/swisstopo/de/home/products/height/
dom_dtm-av.parsysrelated1.19059.downloadList.63245.DownloadFile.tmp/gn142007defr.pdf(accessed07April2008).
243
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.16
Insights from two high-resolution bathymetric surveys in Swiss lakes
MichaelHilbe1,FlavioS.Anselmetti1,RaymondEilertsen2&LouiseHansen3
1Eawag, Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science & Technology, Überlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Dübendorf ([email protected])2Geological Survey of Norway (NGU), N-9296 Tromsø3Geological Survey of Norway (NGU), N-7491 Trondheim
High-resolutiondigitalterrainmodels(DTMs),generatedbyairbornelaserscanningorothertechniques,havebeenwelles-tablishedinSwitzerlandforafewyears.Providingatypicalhorizontalresolutionofafewmetersorless,theyareusedforavarietyoftaskssuchasgeomorphologicalmappingorthemonitoringofearthsurfaceprocessesrelatedtonaturalhazards.Bathymetricdata(DTMs)fortheSwisslakes,however,sofardonotprovideacomparablelevelofdetailduetolimitationsofthe«traditional»surveytechniques, i.e.singlesoundingsorsingle-beamechosounders.Furthermorethesetechniquesarelabor-intensiveandthusnotsuitableformonitoringprogramsinvolvingfrequentlyrepeatedsurveys.State-of-the-artacou-stichydrographicsurveysystems(multibeamechosounders,swathbathymetrysystems)allowasignificantimprovementofthehorizontalresolutionofsubaquaticDTMstovaluescomparablewithhigh-resolutionterrestrialdata.SuchequipmentwasutilizedforthefirsttimeinSwitzerlandintheframeworkofapilotprojectstartedin2007.
NewdatacollectedduringtwofieldcampaignsonLakeLucerneandonLagoMaggioreusingaGeoAcousticsswathbathyme-trysystemandaccurateRTK-GPSpositioningrevealawealthofpreviouslyunknownfeaturesonthelakefloor.Additionally,backscatteranalysisallowsforaclassificationoftheacousticpropertiesofthelakefloor,e.g.adifferentiationbetweensoftsedimentsandhardrocksurfaces.
ThesubmergedvalleysystemofLakeLucerneischaracterizedbyacomplexglacialmorphologywithanumberofmoraineridges.Someofthemareprominentandhavebeenknownforalongtime,othersaremostlycoveredwithyoungersedimentsandareonlyexpressedbyalowreliefvisibleonthenewlycollecteddata.TheHolocenesedimentsonthelateralslopesareaffectedbymassmovements,thesignaturesofwhichcanbeaccuratelymappedandquantified.ThenortheasternpartofLagoMaggioreisdominatedbytwomajordeltasoftheMaggia,TicinoandVerzascarivers.Theslopesofthesedeltasarecoveredbyubiquitoussmall-scaleundulatingbedformsandincisedchannels,presumablyreflectingthedynamicsofriver-borneturbiditycurrents.
Astheseexamplesindicate,theuseofhigh-resolutionbathymetricdataisanappropriateandnecessaryapproachtomapotherwiseinvisibleunderwatermorphologies.Thedataarethebasisforsubsequentinvestigationsofthelakesedimentsandforotherapplicationsincoastalengineeringandconstruction,naturalhazardanalysisandnaturalresourcesprospecting.Periodicrepetitionsofthesurveyswillallowmonitoringandquantifyingalterationsofthelakefloorsrelatedtonaturalprocessesaswellastohumanimpact.
8.17
SyGEMe, Integrated Municipal Facilities Management of Water Ressources:
Tool presentation, choice of technology, man-machine interface, business opportunities and prospects
F.Kuchler1,G.Cherix1,R.Sauvain1,S.Storelli1,D.Lindemann2,E.Andrey3
1 Centre de Recherches Energétiques et Municipales (CREM), Av. du Grand-St-Bernard 4, CP 256, CH-1920 Martigny2 Depth SA, Chemin d’Arche 40 B, CH-1870 Monthey,3 Ecole Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Laboratoire de Systèmes d’Information Géographique (LASIG), EPFL ENAC LASIG, Bâtiment GC, Station 18, CH-1015 Lausanne
Nowadays,watermanagement raisesquestions related to theglobal climate changes, the risingdemandof resources inemergingeconomiesandthedecisionsonenergypolicyabouttheexploitationofhydropowerandwaterprotection[1].InSwitzerland,thegeographicaldifferencescauseamarkeddifferenceinavailabilityofdrinkingwater,bothquantitativelyandqualitatively.So,publicmunicipalities,whichareafewmilesapart,canthereforebefacedtoanexcess,respectively,alackofwaterresource.
244Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es Meanwhile,thepublicauthoritieshavetheresponsibilitytomanagethevariousenergyflowsthatservethecities(water/
sewage,naturalgas,electricity,districtheating,TVnetwork)andthusensurethesafetyandqualityoftheservicestocusto-mers.Specificmanagementtoolsalreadyexistforeachspecificareabutthereisstillnointegratedtoolwhichallowsaglobalandcomprehensivevisionofthenetworksteeringandmanagement.Since2007,expertsfromtheResearchCenterinEnergyandMunicipalities(CREM)andtheEcolePolytechniqueFédéraledeLausanne (EPFL) incollaborationwiththecompaniesDepthSA,ESRISwitzerlandSA,SDIngénierieandSIGGenèvehaveworkedonthedevelopmentofamanagementtoolforintegratedmunicipalurbantechnicalnetworks,appliedinitiallytothewatercycle(SyGEMe).Themainobjectiveofthisprojectwastodevelopanewserviceforcommunitiesandnetworkoperators,whichincludesamonitoringsystem(withreal-timeflowsmeasurements)andanexpertsystemofknowledgemanagement,bothonageogra-phicinformationsystem(inputinterfaceofthetool).
Foroperators,thistoolavailablethroughawebplatformmustallow:
• thereal-timeanalysisoftheirnetworkoperation• thereceptionofalarmswhichcandetectnon-standardsituations• thesustainabilityoftheirpracticalknowledgeinnetworkmanagementwithanaccesstoastructuredinformationsy-
stemwhichfacilitatesregistrationandaccesstodataandoperationalexperiences.
TheSyGEMetoolhasentereditsfinalphase.Thesystemoffersmanyfeaturesthatwillbedevelopedinthisarticle.Butitispossibletomentionespeciallythedocumentationandgeoreferencingofobjectsandeventsonthenetwork,iemeasuringdevices,tasksandreportscreatedbyorfornetworkoperators,anaccesstoreal-timetelemetryetc.ThisarticleaimstopresentindetailstheSyGEMetool,todocumentthechoiceoftechnology,toidentifybusinessopportu-nitiesandtoimaginetheprospectsoftheSyGEMeproject.
Figure1-SyGEMe,onlineviewofthetool.
REFERENCES:OFEN,Officefédéraldel’énergie,Suisse:«Pland’actionpourlesénergiesrenouvelables»,Fiched’information6,2008Bruno Schädler, DivisionHydrologie, OFEV,Office fédéral de l’environnement, Suisse : « Dossier au fil de l’eau »,
Environnement–Avril2006Conventionalpine,Italie:«L’eaudanslesAlpes»,Communiquédepresse:SécheresseouCrue?2èmeRapportsurl’étatdes
Alpes,2009Conventionalpine,Italie:«L‘eauetlagestiondesressourceseneau:Rapportsurl’étatdesAlpes»,Signauxalpins–Édition
spéciale2–2009
245
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.18
Towards a Swiss Geological Information System
AndreasKühni,NilsOesterling
Bundesamt für Landestopografie swisstopo, Landesgeologie, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern, [email protected], [email protected]
ThemaintasksoftheSwissGeologicalSurvey(SGS,FederalOfficeofTopographyswisstopo)aretoproducegeological,geo-physicalandgeotechnicaldataandinformationandtofacilitatetheaccesstorelevantdataforourmaincustomers.AsthegeologicalsurveyingactivitiesinSwitzerland–incontrasttomostEuropeancountries–isorganizedinafederalisticandhighlydecentralizedmanner,particularlythesecondgoalcanonlybeaccomplishedbyahighamountofcoordination.
InresponsetothefastgrowingdemandfordigitalgeologicaldataandinformationtheSGSstartedsomeyearsagotoputamajoreffortintheproductionofharmonizeddigitaldatasetssuchasgeological,geophysicalandgeotechnicalmapsaswellasdrillholedataandgeologicalreports.Ametadatabaseandaninteractiveviewerforallthegeologicaldataavailableatswisstopowerecreatedandmadeavailableontheswisstopohomepageinordertofacilitatetheaccessibilitytogeologicaldatatoourcustomers.Withtheavailabilityofthefirstgeologicalvectordatasetscoveringlargeareasatplanningscale1:25’000(e.g.cantonsVD,NE,JU),thedemandforthiskindofdataincreasedastheusebecameevidenttoalargerangeofprofessionalswhoneedgeologicalinformationininterdisciplinarydecisionmakingprocesses,suchasenvironmentalandurbanplanning,civilengineering,riskassessmentetc.However,onlyasmallfractionofthedataneededbyourmaincustomerscanbedownloadedfromtheSGShomepage.Theotherrequiredgeologicalandgeo-thematicdatahastobesearchedforandprocuredatdifferentcantonal,federal,scientificorprivateorganizations.
In order to further facilitate the access to all of the relevant data and information the SGS plans to build up a SwissGeologicalInformationSysteminclosecollaborationwiththemainplayersintheSwissgeologicalcommunitysuchasothercantonalandnationalgovernmentalbodies,thescnat(includingitsearth-sciencecommissions)andtheSwissAssociationofGeologists(representingtheprivateeconomysector).
Figure1:SchematicoverviewofthestructureoftheSwissGeologicalInformationSystem.Theavailablegeologicaldataandinformation
areatthecoreofthesystem.Accesstothedataisprovidedviaaweb-portalordirectlyviaweb-services.Theentiresystemisdividedinto
threesectorscoveringissuesrelatedtogeo-data,geo-knowledgeandthegeo-community.Eachsectorcontainsdifferentcomponents,e.g.a
dataviewerforvisualizinggeologicaldataoradiscussion-forumforthecommunicationbetweenprofessionalsandlaymen.Thetarget
groupsareprofessionalgeologists,semi-professionalsingeology(e.g.teachers)aswellaslaymenfromabroadpublic.
246Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es TheGeologicalInformationSystem(Oesterling2008,Figure1)aimstoachievethreemajorgoalsinthreedifferentsectorsof
thenationalinternetportal:
1. GEO-DATA:Improveaccessibilitytoalldataandinformationrelatedtogeology2. GEO-COMMUNITY:Giveanoverviewofthetasks,responsibilities,productsandservicesoftheinstitutionsinthe
fieldofearthsciencesinSwitzerland3. GEO-KNOWLEDGE:Increaseawarenessoftheimportanceofgeologicaldataatpoliticalandpubliclevels.
InordertoreachthesegoalstheSGSinworkinginthree main pillars:technicalinfrastructure,dataproduction/acquisition,coordination/legalaspects.
Technical Infrastructure:ThetechnicalimplementationisbasedontheguidelinesoftheNationalSpatialDataInfrastructureofCOGIS(Coordination,Geo-InformationandServices,swisstopo),aplatformaimingtolinkallspatialdatarelevanttotheSwiss(public)economyatanationallevel.Thusthetechnicalinfrastructureistoalargeextentalreadyprovided.Inordertoallowthehomogeneousintegrationandtheinteroperabilityofgeologicaldatafromdifferentsourcesageneralgeologicaldatamodelisbeingdeveloped(Oesterling2006;Strasky2009)
Data Production and Acquisition:Duringthelastdecadetheproductionofdigitalgeologicaldatahasbeenincreasinglypushed.All of the geologicalmaps are available in pixel format andmost in vector format. Thenewly initiated projectGeoCover (Baland2009)aims tomakea seamlessgeologicalvectormap (scale1:25’000–1:50’000)availablewithin threeyears.TheinternalproductionoftheGeologicalAtlas1:25’000iscurrentlyofbeingtransferredtoaGISproductioncyclebasedonthesoftware ‘ToolMap’ (Schreiber2009),whichwasdevelopedincollaborationwithcrealp (Researchcenteronalpineenvironment).ThecollaborationwiththeSwissGeotechnicalandtheSwissGeophysicalCommissionshavebeenin-tensifiedandtherespectiveproductsareintegratedintotheGeologicalDataViewerofswisstopo.
Coordination and Legal Aspects:AlthoughtheSGShasastronglegalbase(SchweizerischeEidgenossenschaft2008a,b)foritsdutiesandespeciallyforitscoordinationandturntablefunctionsince2008,mostoftheexternalproducersofgeologicaldataandinformationarenotforcedbylawtointegratetheirdatainapubliclyaccessibleplatformandtomakegeologicaldataavailabletothepublic.ThereforeandbecauseofverylimitedrecoursesthebuildingupofaGeologicalInformationSystembytheSGSdependstoalargedegreeonthecapacityofitspotentialpartnerstounderstandthatsuchaninformationsystemwillfacilitatelifeforallthemembersoftheSwissgeologicalcommunityandstrengthenthepositionofgeologyintheSwisssocietyingeneral.
REFERENCESBaland,P.2009:Convertinggeologicalmapstovectordatasets–CompletingtheNationalGeologicalInformation;SGM09,
poster,thisabstractvolumeOesterling,N.,Jemelin,L.,Kühni,A.2006:TheGeologicalInformationSystemofSwitzerland–DataModelandDataViewer,
33rdInternationalGeologicalCongress,Oslo,Proceedings,Volume1,235-237.Oesterling,N.,Kühni,A.andKündig,R.2008:TheGeologicalInformationSystemSwitzerland,6thEUREGEOProceedings,
Volume1,235-237.Schreiber,L.,Ornstein,P.,Sartori,M.,Kühni,A.2009:TOOLMAP–‘Sion’method:developmentofanewGISframeworkfor
digitalgeologicalmapping,6thEUREGEOProceedings,Volume1,89-90.SchweizerischeEidgenossenschaft (2008a),BundesgesetzüberGeoinformation (Geoinformationsgesetz,GeolG), Stand: 1.
Juli2008,BernSchweizerischeEidgenossenschaft(2008b),VerordnungüberdieLandesgeologie(Landesgeologieverordnung,LGeolV),Stand:
1.Juli2008,BernStrasky,S.2009:TowardsaSwissgeologicaldatamodel;SGM09,oralpresentation,thisabstractvolume
247
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.19
Rock glacier monitoring with low-cost GPS receivers
LimpachPhilippe&DavidGrimm
Institute of Geodesy and Photogrammetry, ETH Zurich, Schafmattstrasse 34, CH-8093 Zurich ([email protected], [email protected])
Toinvestigatethepotentialoflow-costGPSreceiversfortheprecisemonitoringofslopeinstabilitiesinmountainareas,asmallGPStest-networkwasinstalledontheDirrurockglaciernearRanda,Mattertal,SwissAlps.ThesitewasselectedbytheAlpineCryosphereandGeomorphologyresearchgroupoftheUniversityofFribourgandtheSwissFederalOfficefortheEnvironment,basedonvelocitiesdetectedbySARinterferometryandperiodicGPSsurveys(Delaloyeetal.2007).
Thetest-networkwasinstalledinJune2009andconsistsofthreepermanentGPSstations(Figure1),equippedwithlow-costmono-frequencyGPSreceiversfromtheSwissmanufacturerμblox.Powerissuppliedbysolarpanels.TovalidatetheresultsfromtheGPSnetwork,parallelobservationswithanautomatedtachymetersystemwerecarriedout.Aminiprismwasin-stallednexttoeachGPSantennaonthesameboulder(Figure2).Theprismsweremeasuredbythetachymeterevery30min-utesduringtwoweeks.
TheGPSdataprocessingisbaseddifferentialcarrierphasetechniquesusingtheBerneseGPSsoftware.Dailystationcoordi-nates,aswellaskinematiccoordinateswithasamplingintervalof5sarecomputed.Thelow-costGPSsystemallowedtoreliablyobservevelocitiesintheorderof2cm/day.Stationcoordinateswereobtainedwithaccuracies(standarddeviations)of0.5cmforthedailysolutionsand1.5cmforthekinematicsolutions.Averygoodvelocityagreementofbetterthan0.1cm/daywasobtainedwithrespecttothetachymetersolutions.
Byprovidingcontinuousobservationsofsurfacemotion,independentofweatherconditions,permanentmonitoringbasedonlow-costGPSreceiverscanhelptostrengthentheunderstandingofprocesseslinkedtopermafrost-relatedslopeinsta-bilities.Inaddition,itisapowerfultooltoenhanceexistingmonitoringandearly-warningsystems,inordertoimprovethepreventionandmitigationofimpactsofnaturalhazardsoninfrastructureandhumanlife,andtosupportlocaldecision-makingprocesses.
Figure1.GPSstationinstalledontherockglacier,including(fromrighttoleft)GPSantenna,solarpanelandinstrumentboxcontaining
GPSreceiverandbattery.
248Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Figure2.GPSantennaandminiprisminstalledonthesameboulder(leftpicture)andminiprismindetail(rightpicture).
REFERENCESDelaloye,R., Strozzi,T., Lambiel,C.,Perruchoud,E.,Raetzo,H.2007: Landslide-likedevelopmentof rockglaciersdetected
withERS-1/2SARinterferometry.ProceedingsofFRINGE2007Workshop,Frascati,Italy,26-30November2007.
8.20
A GIS tool to create fluvial flooding maps. Interaction of 1D hydrodynamic model and GIS
MarzocchiRoberto1,FedericiBianca2,SguersoDomenico2
1 IST – SUPSI Istituto scienze della Terra, CP 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])2DICAT, Università degli Studi di Genova, Via Montallegro 1, 16145, Genova (Italy)([email protected])
Eachyearfloodinghappensworldwideposingatriskthelifeandthepropertyofmillionpeople.Anincrementoftheexpo-suretoriskiscausedbyclimatechangesandpopulationgrowththatleadstothedevelopmentofinfrastructures,buildingsandbusinessintheareassurroundingrivers.However,floodingisanaturalphenomenonandisnecessaryforthesurvivalandhealthoftheecosystem.
Theidentificationoffloodproneareasisofconsiderableimportanceeitherforemergencymanagementandforplanningactivity,suchasschedulingofworksforthereductionofhydraulicriskortownplanningfinalizedtotheoptimallanduse.For this reason in recent years several flooding hazardmodels and risk assessment procedures were developed. Also aGeographicInformationSystem(GIS)maybeatoolthatcanassistfloodplainmanagersasdecisionsupportsystem.ThepresentworkproposesanautomaticprocedureimplementedinGISenvironmenttocreateperifluvialfloodingmaps.Thepotentiallyfluvialinundatedareasareobtainedknowing(i)theconformationofthefloodplainsurroundingtheriverbyanhighresolutionDigitalTerrainModel(DTM)and(ii)awatersurfaceprofilealongtheriveraxiscalculatedforgivendischargethroughagenericone-dimensionalhydraulicmodel(HEC-RAS,Basement,MIKE11,etc).Theinterestfortheinter-actionbetweenaGISandcommonhydrodynamicmodelsisshownbymanyworksinliteratureandbytheimplementationofseveralsoftwaretothispurpose(HEC-GeoRAS®,Mike11GISandSurfacewaterModelingSystem).Theimplementedprocedurehasinnovatingcharacteristics:infact,evenifitremainssubstantiallyone-dimensional,ittakesinto account the two-dimensionality of floodplain and inundationphenomena, adducinghypotheses that let to correctmanyerrorstypicalofone-dimensionalusuallyemployedprocedures.Hence,withrespecttotheuseofanone-dimensionalmodelwithouttheGISsupport,thisprocedureallowstoobtainmorerealisticperifluvialfloodingmap(fig.1).Moreover,withrespecttoatwo-dimensionalmodel,itneedsalowercomputationaleffort,thatallowstoapplyittoriverreachesverylong(oftheorderof100km).
249
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sTheproceduremaybesummarizedinfourphasesthatareautomaticallyimplemented(moredetailinMarzocchietal.2009).Inthefirstphase,thevalueofwaterlevelinthenearestpointoffluvialaxisisassignedtoeachcellofDTM,throughthecreationofThiessenpolygons;hence,afirstfloodingmapisobtainedmakingacomparisonbetweenelevationandwaterlevelineachcell.Inthesecondphase,theprocedureremovesalltheareaspreviouslydefinedathazard,butnotconnectedwiththeriveraxis.Inthethirdphase,theproceduretakesintoaccountleveesorotherobstructionstothewaterflow,underthehypothesisthatwaterdiffusesfromrivertothesurroundingareasonlyindirectionperpendiculartotheriveraxis.Inthefourthphasetheprevioushypothesis isremovedand,onlyfortheareasdriedinthethirdphase,severaltwo-dimen-sionalwaterpathsareanalysed,obtainingthefinalfloodingmap.
Afirstvalidationoftheprocedurewasperformed(Federicietal.,2007)onareachoftheTanaroRiver(about120Km,Italy):thehistoricalinundatedareaandthepotentiallyinundatedareacausedbythealluvialeventin1994thatinterestedtheriverthroughAlessandriacitywerecomparedwithsatisfactoryresults.Recently,thetoolhasbeenappliedalsotoalittlestream(RoggiaScairolo)intheTicinoCanton,forthefloodinghazardvaluation(Pozzonietal.,2009)obtainingreliablere-sults.
TheprocedurewasimplementedintheopensourceGeographicResourcesAnalysisSupportSystemSoftware(GRASS,2008)combiningtheuseoftheshellscriptandfortranlanguages.Anewmodule(r.inund.fluv)withauserfriendlygraphicalin-terfacewascreatedandnowitisdistributedunderthetermsoftheGNUGeneralPublicLicense,freedownloadingfromthewebsitehttp://grass.osgeo.org/wiki/GRASS_AddOns.
Figure1.WorkingprincipleoftheimplementedGIStool.
REFERENCESFedericiB.,SguersoD.,2007.Proceduraautomaticaperlacreazionedimappedipotenzialeinondazionefluviale.Bollettino
SIFET,ISSN:1721-971X,n.4,pp.25-42.Marzocchi,R.,Federici,B.&SguersoD.2009Proceduraautomaticaper lacreazionedimappedipotenziale inondazione
fluvialeinGRASS:ilmodulor.inund.fluv,AttidelIXMeetingdegliUtentiItalianidiGRASS-GFOSS,21-22febbraio2008,pp.161-178
GRASSDevelopmentTeam2008.GeographicResourcesAnalysisSupportSystem(GRASS)Software.OpenSourceGeospatialFoundationProject.http://grass.osgeo.org
Pozzoni,M.,Marzocchi,R.&Graf,A. 2009.RoggiaScairolo - Zonazionedellapericolositàperalluvionamento,TechnicalreportIST
250Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.21
A GIS embedded model for dam break
MarzocchiRoberto&CannataMassimiliano
1IST – SUPSI Istituto scienze della Terra, CP 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])
IntheXXIcenturyaround200notabledamandreservoirfailureshappenedworldwidecausingmassivefatalitiesandeco-nomiccosts.Increasingenergydemandandotherbenefitshavecausedtheconstructionofmanydaminmountainousregi-ons;atthesametimetheintensivewatershedurbanizationhasleadtoasocietyexposedtoriskslikeneverbefore.Forthisreason,nowadaysgovernmentsarelookingintodisastermitigationstrategieswithhigherattention.Withintheprocessofstrategies,designthespatialinformationplaysaninvaluablerole.Infactisimpossibletotakeeffectiveandcomprehensivedecisionswithoutunderstandingtheextentofpotentialhazardsandwithoutlocalizingexistingconditionsofvulnerabilitythatcouldposeapotentialthreattoharmpeople,properties,essentialservicesandeconomyofregions.Therefore,inordertoprotectthesocietyfromagiventypeofhazardisofprimaryimportancebeingabletoassessthespatialdistributionofthethreateningphenomenaandtheirintensities.
Inordertoperformriskanalysis(fig.1),GISrepresentaneedfulinstrument.Usuallyhazardareasareevaluatedbyusingstandalonehydrodynamicmodels,whileGISareusedtomanageinputsandtoperformtheriskanalysisusingoutputs.Thisapproachistimeexpensive,errorprone,duetoexport/importrequirements,andnotuserfriendly,butnecessarybecauseofthelackofembeddedGIShazardmodels.
Tothispurpose,theInstituteofEarthScienceisdevelopingaseriesofGISembeddedhazardmodelswithintheRiskBoxproject(Cannata&Molinari,2008).Theaimofthisprojectistoprovideauniquesystemofferingallthecapabilitiesrequiredbyriskassessmentanalyses.ThechosenGISsystemistheGeographicResourcesAnalysisSupportSystemSoftware(GRASS,2008).Itsselectionwasbasedontheconsiderationthatthissoftwareprovideshighquality,flexibilityandinteroperability,and,leastbutnotlast,thatitisOpenSource.
Withthiswork,anewnumericalmodelforthesolutionofthetwo-dimensionaldambreakproblemhasbeenimplementedintheGRASSGISasaembeddedmodule.Themodelsolvestheconservativeformofthe2DShallowWaterEquations(SWE)usingaFiniteVolumeMethod(FVM);theinter-cellfluxiscomputedbyone-sideupwindconservativescheme(Yingetal.,2004)extendedtoatwo-dimensionalproblemonasquaredgrid.
Thecommandcangeneraterastertimeseriesofwaterdepthandflowvelocitywithtimeresolutiondefinedbytheuser,andavarietyofoutputrastermapsusefultoobtainthemaximumphenomenonintensity(BUWAL1998).TheproblemformulationandthenewGRASSmodulearedetailedpresentedinreferences(Marzocchi&Cannata,2009).Themodelhasbeentestedwithtwostandardsyntheticproblemsreferencedinliteratureandverifiedinarealdamcasewhereofficialfloodingmapswereavailable(fig.2).Acomparisonwithotherexistingdambreakmodelswillbeconduct.
Figure1.Riskassessmentstrategyincaseofdambreak
251
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s
Figure2.Testcasesusedformodelvalidation
REFERENCESBUWAL1998MethodenzurAnalyseundBewertungvonNaturgefahren.Umwelt-MaterialienNr.85,Bern,p.229CannataM.&Molinari,M.2008,NaturalHazardsandRiskAssessment:theFOSS4Gcapabilities.ProceedingsoftheFreeand
OpenSourceSoftwareforGeospatial(FOSS4G2008)conference.CapeTown,SouthAfrica.GRASSDevelopmentTeam2008.GeographicResourcesAnalysisSupportSystem(GRASS)Software.OpenSourceGeospatial
FoundationProject.http://grass.osgeo.orgMarzocchi,R.&Cannata,M.2009.Two-dimensionaldambreakfloodingsimulation:aGISembeddedapproach.InpressYing,X.,Khan,A.&Wang,S.S.Y.2004.UpwindconservativeschemefortheSaintVenantEquations
8.22
Naturereignisse entlang der Bahnlinien: eine systematische Aufnahme
MeierAndreas&WilliChristina
SBB Infrastruktur, Umwelt, Naturrisiken, Mittelstrasse 43, 3000 Bern 65
Die Bahnlinien sind aufgrund der topografischen Gegebenheiten in der Schweiz häufig klimatischen und gravitativenNaturprozessenausgesetzt.Sturzprozesse,Hochwasser,Hangrutsche,Murgänge,Lawinen,SturmwindeundStarkniederschlägesindNaturgefahren,welchetypischerweisedieSBB-Liniengefährden.
DiesystematischeErfassungderNaturereignisseistausfachlicherundbetrieblicherSichtvongrosserBedeutung.DieSBBstrebtmitderErstellungundPflegeeinesnetzweitenEreigniskatastersNaturgefahrenan,eindifferenziertesBildüberdieAuswirkungenvonNaturereignissenaufInfrastrukturundBahnbetriebzugewinnen.
EreigniserfassungMit dem «Geographischen Informationssystem GIS NR» der SBB werden gravitative Naturgefahren sowie Einflüsse derWitterung auf die Infrastruktur in einem zweistufigen Prozess erfasst, dokumentiert und visualisiert. Die wichtigstenInformationenzueinemEreignisumfassen:
• Ereignisdatumund–ort• Ereignisart,-beschreibungund-bewertung• Prozesskenngrössen,Prozessart,Wirkungspunkt,Auslöser,Ursachen,Auswirkungen• Personen-(Verletzte,Tote),Sach-(CHF)undBetriebsschäden(Verspätungsminuten,Zugsausfälle,Störungen)• SicherheitsbezogenerEreignistyp• AngabenzuSofort-undFolgemassnahmen
Die Daten werden laufend aktualisiert und ergänzt. Sie bilden die Grundlage für die Ereignisanalyse und denJahresrückblick.
Datenauswertung und Erstellung von KenngrössenGISNRermöglichtdieErstellungvondefiniertenAbfragenausdemEreigniskatasterunddieraumbezogeneBetrachtungvonEreignisabfolgen.AufderBasisweitererSBB-internerDatendientdieAnalysederNaturereignissederErstellungvon
252Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es unternehmerischen Kenngrössen und Einschätzungen. Über diese Kenngrössen können die Auswirkungen auf den
BahnbetriebverfolgtwerdenundentsprechendeMassnahmengetroffenwerden.
FolgendeFaktenwerdenabgeleitetundjährlichverfolgt:
• RäumlicheVerteilungderEreignisse(Fig.1)• EntwicklungderEreignisse• AnzahlUnfälleundVerspätungsminuten• SummederversichertenSchäden• TypisierungvonSchadensbildern• EinschätzungderRisikolage• ÜberblickderStellenmitMassnahmenbedarf
Die Resultate der Ereignisanalysen werden im jährlichen internen Standbericht Naturrisiken und auf thematischenKartendarstellungenpräsentiert.
LangfristigwerdenaufBasisderüberdie JahregesammeltenDatenTrendanalysenzurEntwicklungderNaturereignissemöglichsein.
Figur1.NaturereignisseaufdemSBB-Netzseit01.01.2008
AusblickDiePflegeundAnalysevonEreignisdatenwirdweiter systematisiertundausgebaut.DamitwirdderEreigniskataster zueinemintegralenBestandteildesNaturrisikomanagementsderSBB.
Um die Schadensentwicklung und die Wirkung von Schutzausbauten zukünftig besser beurteilen zu können, werdenVergleichezunationalenundkantonalenEreignis-undSchadenskatasternimmerwichtiger.DieSBBunterstütztdieverschiedenenBestrebungeninderSchweizzurVerbesserungderDatenlagezuNaturereignissen.EineAusweitungdesNutzerkreisesdes «Geographischen InformationssystemsNaturrisiken»der SBB aufweitereBahnenkönnteausSichtderGefahrenpräventionundderBahnbetreibernotwendigeSynergienschaffen.
REFERENZENMeier,A.2008:Naturgefahren:HerausforderungfürdieSBB.GeomatikSchweiz2008/5,242-243.Meier,A.&Willi,C.2008:SystematicrecordingandanalysisofnaturalhazardsalongrailwaylinesusingGIS.SGM2008.
253
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
s8.23
Shallow Landslide Vulnerability Assessment
MolinariMoniaElisa1,CannataMassimiliano1,TroungXuanLuan2
1 Institute of Earth Sciences – SUPSI, Trevano, C.P 72, CH-6952 Canobbio2 Hanoi University of Mining and Geology – Dong Ngac, Tu Liem, Hanoi, Vietnam
ThePhilippines,Vietnam,Cambodia,Thailand,Laos,SumatraandIndonesiaareamongthecountriesidentifiedasclimatechange“hotspots”-countriesparticularlyvulnerabletosomeoftheworstmanifestationsofclimatechangeincludinglanslides.Inparticular,shallowlandslideshasahugedestructionpower.Becauseoftheirshighdensityandspeed,damagesareverysevereandsometimestragic:destroyinghouses,bridgesandinfrastructureandclaimingpeople'slives.Thethreatduetonaturalhazardscanbereduced,byintegratingthemintolandusemanagement,urbanplanning,andpopulationprotectionplans.Computersimulationisoneofafewpossibilitiestoobjectivelyassessthehazardduetoapro-cess,bysimulatingitslocalizationandexpansion.Twomodelsalreadyhasbeensuccessfullyappliedinmanycases:
• TRIGRS(Baumetal.2008)formodelingthetiminganddistributionofshallow,rainfall-inducedlandslides,and• DFWALK(Cannata&Molinari2008)formodelingtheexpansionareaandtheintensityofthephenomena.
Unfortunatelythistwosoftwarearenotlinkedtogetherthusdonotpermittheirusageforpredictingwhen,whereandwithwhatintensityaphenomenonisgoingtooccur.Thisresearchaimstocouplethetwoabovementionedmodels(TRIGRSandDFWALK)toderiveacompleteframeworkforshallowlandslidesmodeling.Thisachievementisveryimportantforplanningefficientcountermeasuresandintimedisasterresponses.Moreover,thisresearchaimsalsotoembedthistwomodelswithinaGISabletobeinterfacedwiththeInternetthroughaWebProcessingServiceimplementationinordertocreateaweb-basedapplicationforspatialdecisionsupportsystemsonshallowlandslide.Thissolutionenabletheusageofgeospatialdataformodelingandturnsitintoknowledgeableinformtion(maps)whicharemucheasiertounderstandandlessexpensiveforbetterdecisionmaking.
REFERENCESBaumR.L.,Godt J.W., SavageW.Z., 2008: TRIGRS –A fortranprogram for transient rainfall infiltration andgrid-based
regionalslope-stabilityanalysis,Version2.0.U.S.GeologicalSurveyOpen-FileReport08-1159.CannataM.,MolinariM.E,2008:NaturalHazardandRiskAssessment:theFOSS4G,Proceedingofthe2008FreeandOpen
SourceSoftwareforGeospatialConference,CapeTown,SouthAfrica.
8.24
3D modeling of geological heterogeneity: the direct sampling multiple-points simulation method
PhilippeRenard,GrégoireMariethoz,andJulienStraubhaar
Centre for Hydrogeology and Geothermics (CHYN), University of Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH - 2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected])
Geologicalheterogeneityisakeyfactorcontrollinggroundwaterflowandtransportprocesses.Butbecauseofthelackofexhaustivegeologicaldata,itisoftennecessarytomodelitanditsimpactinordertoprovidenotonlyreliableforecastsbutalsoreliableerrorboundswiththegroundwaterflowmodelforecasts.Duringthelast50years,massiveprogresseshavebeenmadeinthisfieldbutmostlyinthecontextofrelativelysimpleheterogeneitymodels(binaryormulti-Gaussianmodels).However that therearea significantnumberofapplications inwhich theunderlyingassumptionsmadewhenapplying
254Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es thosemodelsarenotvalid.Thisiswhyarichermodelshouldbeusedtodescribetheheterogeneityandintegrateasmuch
aspossiblegeological,hydrological,andgeophysicalobservations.Onetechniquethathasthesecharacteristicsisthemultiple-pointstatistics.Ithasbecomeaprevalentsubjectingeostatisticsoverthelast5-10years.Despitetheexistenceofcertainshortcomings,itisbynowthemostflexiblemethodtointegrateaconceptualmodelofheterogeneityinastochasticframework.Theconceptbehindthemethodistouseatrainingimagetorepresentthedesiredspatialstructureofthefield.Thetrainingimageisscannedandallpixelsconfigurationsofacertainsizearestoredinacatalogueofdataevents.Thisstructureisthenusedtocomputetheconditionalprobabilitiesateachsimulatednode.Becauseoflimitedmemoryusage,thestandardapproachcanonlydealwithcategoricalvariables,inaddi-tionthememoryloadcanbeprohibitiveforlarge3Dgrids.
Inthiswork,weshowthatthereisnoneedtostoreandcounttheconfigurationsfoundinthetrainingimage.Instead,itismoreconvenienttosamplerandomlythetrainingimageforagivendataevent.Thistechniqueisstatisticallyequivalenttopreviousimplementationsbut,becauseitrelaxestheneedtocomputeexplicitlytheconditionalprobabilities,itallowstoextend the application of the standard theory from categorical to continuous andmultivariate variables. Thismethod(Mariethozetal2009)canbeusedforthesimulationofgeologicalheterogeneity,accountingornotforindirectobservationssuchasgeophysics,butitcanalsobeusedtosimulateanyvariablethathasnonmulti-Gaussianfeatureswhichmayhaveanimportantimpactonhydrologicalprocesses.Computationally,itisfast,easytoparallelize,andparsimoniousinmemoryneeds.Acomparisonofitsapplicationforsolutetransportsimulationwiththeapplicationofstandardmulti-Gaussiantech-niques(Figure1)showsthatthisnewmethodisabletomodelcorrectlyhighlyconnectedpatternsthatareimpossibletomodelwiththeSequentialGaussianSimulationtechnique(Fig.1).
Figure1:Influenceontheconnectivitypatternsontransportbehavior.a)OnesimulationobtainedwithDirectsampling.b)Onesimula-
tiongeneratedusingSGS.c)Comparisonofhistogramsofsimulatedvalues.d)Comparisonofexperimentalomnidirectionalvariograms.
e)Comparisonofcontaminantbreakthroughcurvesontheoutflowboundary.f)andg)comparisonofthecontaminantdistributionat
t=250hours.
Moregenerally,themultivariateframeworkofferedbythismethodopensawiderangeofperspectivesfortheintegrationofdifferentdatatypes.Possibleapplicationsareverydiversesincecategoricalvariables(e.g.geology,soiltype,landcovercat-egory,vulnerabilityclass)andcontinuousvariables(e.g.porosity,concentration,rechargerate,rainfall)areoftenrelatedandwidelyusedinmanyfieldsofgeosciencesbutareveryseldommeasuredexhaustively.ThereforethesevariablesoftenrequiretobeinterpolatedorsimulatedandtheDSmethodcouldthenbeusedtosimulatefieldshavingaproperspatialstructure.
255
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sREFERENCESMariethoz,G., Renard, P.& Straubhaar J. 2009: Thedirect samplingmethod to performmultiple-points geostatistical
simulations,WaterResourcesResearch,submitted.
8.25
Particle Swarm and Differential Evolution –Global Optimization for Geophysical Inversion
SaraswatPuneet
Indian School Of Mines University ,Dhanbad, Room 161 ,Topaz Hostel, Jharkhand-826004 ([email protected])
Thesocialbehaviorobservedinaflock(swarm)ofbirdsandininsectssearchingfoodhasbeensimulatedtodevelopaglobaloptimizationstrategypopularlyknownastheParticleSwarmOptimization(PSO).ParticleSwarmOptimization(PSO)emu-latesthesocialbehaviorsinaflockofbirds(swarm)insolvinganoptimizationproblem.Itutilizesbothlocalandglobalpropertiesoftheswarmtoformulateanovelsearchstrategythatguidestheswarmtowardsthebestsolutionwithconstantupdatingofthecognitiveandsocialknowledgeoftheparticlesintheswarm.
DifferentialEvolution(DE)isanovelparalleldirectsearchmethodwhichutilizesNPparametervectorsxi,G,i=0,1,2,...,NP-1.(11)
asapopulationforeachgenerationG.NPdoesn'tchangeduringtheminimizationprocess.ItisaEvolutionaryalgorithmsuggestedbyStornandPrice(1996).Itisbasedonswarmoptimizationalongwithgeneticmutation,recombinationandse-lectioncriteriatooptimizeagivenproblem.Italsoutilizeslocalandglobalpropertiesofswarmalongwiththeirgeneticdevelopment.
WeusedPSOandDEforInvertingtheSeismicLogdata(bothrealandsynthetic)andcomparingthecomputedandobservedseismogram(generatedusingConvolutionforwardmodel),InvertedforAcousticImpedanceandresultsshowedanappro-priatematchwiththeobservedvalueoneandwasobtainedwithin1000iterationsandswarmof100inPSOand10timestheunknownparametersinDEForexample-oneoftheproblemwetookforsingletraceverticalseismiclogandinvertedforacousticimpedancevalueforeachlayerandagaincomputedseismogramusingcalculatedimpedancevaluesandplottedtheobservedseismogramwithcomputedonetheresultsareshowninfollowingfigures:
Figure1:SingleTracedatafitusingPSOwithVirticalseismiclogforAcousticImpedance
256Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Figure2:DatafitusingDifferentialEvolution,InvertedforAcousticImpedancefor135layeredearth,showsanexactfitofobservedand
computedvalueofseismogram.
Similarlyweworkedoverlargenumberofseismicdatabothrealfield(OilandNaturalGasCorporationOfIndiaseismicdata)andsyntheticdata(singletraceandmultipletraces)andInvertedforAcousticImpedanceandfoundgoodresultswithverylowerror.HencethetwonewtechniquesservedasexcellenttoolsforGeophysicalInversionInthisstudywereportedtheutilityofswarmintelligenceinsolvingmulti-parameteroptimizationproblemsingeophysics.Seismicdatahasbeeninvertedusingaclassicalparticleswarmoptimizerwith30-100individualsinaswarm.Forsyntheticaswellasfielddatasets,thesolutionsobtainedexplaintheobserveddatasatisfactorilybesidesexhibitingacceptablereso-lutionforthemodelparameters.
REFERENCESRaniaHassan2004:ParticleSwarmOptimization-methodsandapplication,MITesd16.888,ESO.77RainerStorn&KennethPrice1995:DiffrentialEvolution-a simpleandefficientadaptive scheme forglobaloptimization
overcontinuousspaces,TR-95-012
8.26
Fast Colorization, Analyses and Visualization of Airborne Laser Data
YannickStebler,PhilippSchaer,JanSkaloud
Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne (Switzerland)
Airbornelaserscanning(ALS)hasbecomeverypopularformodelingtopographicobjectsbecauseofthehighresolutionandaccuracyaswellastheshortacquisitiontimerequiredforlargestudyarea.Thedigitalelevationmodel(DEM)ofthesurveyedareaisoftenrepresentedbymeanofpointcloudtriangulationconsideringahorizontalplane.Thisimpliesthatonlyonesinglealtitudevaluecanbesetforeachpoint(2.5-dimensional)issuedfromtheALSdata.Suchamodelingisnotsuitableforverysteepterrainandcliffs,whichmaybeofhighimportanceforunderstandinggeologicalfeaturesornaturalhazardcauses.Helicopter-basedALSsystemasthatdevelopedbyEPFL(Skaloudetal.,2006)canbemountedobliquelytoallowsteepandverticalcliffstobecapturedforanoptimalscanangle.Atthesametime,orientedimagesaretakentoproduceortho-rec-tifiedimagery.Inordertogetarealisticmodelofsuchterrain,rigorous3Dmodelsneedtobeproducedbasedontriangula-tionandimagedrapingontheresultingmesh.Thisprocedureispossiblebutratherinvolvedcomputationallyandintheabsence of standardized data structures the results are often not portable across software applications (Buckley et al.,2008).
Wepresentalightweight,fastandrobustalternativetothe3Dmodelingthatdirectlyexploresthehighdensitylaserdataandthehigh-resolutionimagery(collectedtogetherorseparately).TheproposedmethodassociatesaRGBvalueforeachlaserpulse.Itpresumesgoodqualityexterior-orientation(EO)forthecameradataanditsgoodcalibration.Thecamera’sEOiscalculatedbytheCAMEOsoftware(SkaloudandLegat,2006)foreachimageinthesamereferenceframeasthatoflaserdata.
257
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sAsonelaserpointcanbevisiblewithinseveralimages,avectorisreconstructedbetweenthelaserpointcoordinatesandthecamerapositiontochoosethemostoptimalimagefortheRGBextraction.Thischoiceismadeaccordingtotheanglebet-weenthisvectorandtheestimatedsurfacenormal.Thepixelcoordinatesandthustheassociatedradiometricvaluescorre-spondingtothelaserpointarecomputedbyapplyingtheclassicalcolinearityequationsandarefinallycorrectedforradiallensdistortions.Forinteroperabilitypurposes,theobtainedRGBvaluescanbestoredtogetherwiththelaserdatainstan-dardformatssuchasLAS1.2.
ThevisualizationengineisbasedonC++/OpenGLapproachandisoptimizedforsimultaneoushandlingoftensofmillionsofpointsoversteepterrainandcliffs.Asmearingfeaturecanbeappliedateachzoomlevel,sotheuserhaveanimpressionofseeingfull3Dmodelinsteadofdiscretevalues(Fig.1).
Finally,thedescribedsoftwareplatformallowsalsoanalysesoftheterrain.First,thelaserpointsareindexedintoakd-treedatastructureandthenaterrainnormalisestimated.Theestimationoftheterrainnormalisachievedbylocalcovarianceanalysis.Thisprocedureincludesanautomatedclassificationalgorithm(BaeandLichti,2004)forremovingthevegetation.Oncethecovarianceanalyzesiscompletedthelaserdatacanbecoloredforslope(Fig.2)andorientation(Fig.3).
Figure1:PointcloudcolorizationaccordingtoRGBvalues.
Figure2:Pointcloudcolorizationaccordingtoterrainslope.
258Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es
Figure3:Softwareinterfaceshowingtheterrainorientationdisplayingmode.
AcknowledgmentThisprojectwaspartiallyfinancedbyAlp-Sproject1.14AB.Thissupportisgreatlyappreciated.
REFERENCESBae,K.-H.,andLichti,D.,2004,EdgeandTreeDetectionfromThree-dimensionalUnorganisedPointCloudsfromTerrestrial
LaserScanners,12thAustralianRemoteSensingandPhotogrammetryConference:Fremantle,Australia.Buckley,S.J.,Wheeler,W,Braathen,A,Vallet,J,2008.ObliqueHelicopter-BasedLaserScanningforDigitalTerrainModelling
andVisualisationofGeologicalOutcrops. The InternationalArchives of the Photogrammetry,Remote Sensing andSpatialInformationSciences,Beijing,Vol.XXXVII,PartB5,Commission5.
Skaloud,J.,andLegat,K.,2006.CAMEO-CameraExteriorOrientationbyDirectGeoreferencing.:SwissFederalInstituteofTechnologyLausanne(EPFL).
SkaloudJ.,Vallet, J.,Keller,K.Veyssiere,G.,Koelbl,O.,2006.AnEyeforLandscape -RapidAerialMappingwithHandheldSensors.GPSWord,May2006.
8.27
Topography and surface processes in borderline ecotones
StrählS.C.1,KuhnN.J.2
1Geographisches Institut, Klingelbergstrasse 27, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])2Geographisches Institut, Klingelbergstrasse 27, CH-4056 Basel
Climate,soilandhumanactivitystronglyaffectthevegetationpatternsinborderlineecotones.Vegetationborderlinesarecharacterizedbycertainabioticandbioticfactorsanddifferbetweentheecosystems.Borderlineecotonesrepresentareasoftransitionbetweenabioticandbioticfactorscontrollingtheborderlineecosystem.Borderlineecotonesthereforecontainagreatnumberofecologicnichesandwidespeciesdiversity.Successionprocessesleadtotheexistencevaryingvegetationpatterns.Thesesubsidingsuccessionprocessesareimportantforthevegetationdynamicandlastgenerallyoverseveral100years.Climateandenvironmentalchangeshaveanimportantinfluenceonvegetationdensityanddiversity.
Borderlineecotonesintwodifferentclimaticregions,coldandaridstudyarea,arecompared.ThealpinestudysiteisintheregionofGrindelwald(BerneseOberland),wherevegetationpatternsareinfluencedbytemperaturegradient:forest–dwarfshrubs–alpinegrassland.ThearidstudyareaissituatedinasidevalleynearSedeBoqer(Negevdesert,Israel),wherevege-tationpatternsareinfluencedbywatersupply.TheBraunBlanquetvegetationmappingmethodwasusedtodetermineve-getationtypeanddirectionofsuccession.Resultsshow,thatnotonlytemperatureandprecipitationinfluencesurfacepro-cesses inborderlineecotones. Inbothareasgeomorphdynamicprocessesplayan importantrole inthedevelopmentofvariousvegetationpatterns.Animportantquestionisthereactionofthesesystemsinthecoming100yearswiththeinflu-enceofGlobalclimateandenvironmentalchange.
259
Sym
po
siu
m 1
: W
ate
r a
cro
ss (
scie
nti
fic)
bo
un
da
rie
sREFERENCESBurga,C.A., Perret,R. (2001):Monitoringof easternand southernSwiss alpine timberlineecotenes. Tasks for vegetation
science35.InBurga,C.A.,Kratochwil,A..Biomonitoring:Generalandappliedaspectsonregionalandglobalscales.Holtmeier, F. DieHöhengrenze derGebirgswälder. Arbeiten aus dem Institut für Landschaftsökologie.Westfälische
Wilhelms-Universität. Band8,Münster.VerlagNaturundWissenschaftHarroHieronismusundDr. JürgenSchmidt.Postfach170209Solingen.2000.
Olsvig-Whittaker, Shachak,M.&Yair,A. (1983):Vegetationpatterns related to environmental factors in aNegevDesertwatershed.Accepted30May1983.
Yair,A.&Raz-Yassif,N.(2003):Hydrologicalprocessesinasmallaridcatchment:scaleeffectsofrainfallandslopelength.Received1July2003.Receivedinrevisedform1December2003.Accepted3December2003.
8.28
Towards a Swiss geological data model
StraskyStefan1,BalandPauline1,OesterlingNils1&KühniAndreas1
1Federal Office of Topography swisstopo, Swiss Geological Survey, Seftigenstrasse 264, CH-3084 Wabern ([email protected])
After~80yearsoftraditionalgeologicalmapproductionfortheGeologicalAtlasofSwitzerland1:25000(GA25),agrowingneedforvectordatasetsofthismapserieshasevolvedduringthelastdecade.ConsiderableeffortisthereforebeingspentbytheSwissGeologicalSurveytoconverttheexistingprintedGA25intohigh-qualityGeographicalInformationSystem(GIS)datasets.Tospeeduptheconversionfromrastertovectorgraphicsandtomeettherequirementsofthegeo-community,theSwissGeological Survey recently initiated theGeoCover project,which aims to provide geologicalGIS-data at a scale of1:25000throughoutSwitzerlandwithinthenextthreeyears.
However,awell-establisheddatamodeltodescribethestructureofthegeologicaldata,withspecificobjectandattributedefinitionsandtheirrelationships,isstillmissing.Anearlyattemptofaconceptualdatamodel,basedontheGA25mapofZurzach,waspresentedbyJemelin&Beer(1999).Baland-Renaud&Oesterling(2007)extendedthedatamodeltoallexistingGA25mapsbyusingthecatalogueoflinesandsymbolsfortheGA25,whichwaspublishedbytheFederalOfficeforWaterandGeology(2002).Nevertheless,themodeldevelopedbyBaland-Renaud&Oesterlingisabetaversion,andthusneedstobefurtherrefinedinordertocarefullystructuretheoriginalheterogeneityofthecurrentmapdata.TheaimofourprojectistoestablishastructuraldesignforthegeologicaldataoftheSwissGeologicalSurveyandtodescribeallrelevantobjects,attributesand relationships. Furthermore, thedatamodel should serveasa fundamentalbasis for the compilationofaseamless,nationwidevectordatasetofSwitzerland.Incollaborationwithanexternalgroupofexpertsweapproachthere-finementofthemodel.Herewepresentsomeexamplesofthenewestresultsaswellascurrentchallenges.
REFERENCESBaland-Renaud,P.&Oesterling,N.2007:Modèlededonnéesgéologiques.Partie:stockagedesdonnées,Version1.0,117pp.FederalOffice forWaterandGeology2002: LineandSymbolCatalogue for theGeologicalAtlasof Switzerland1:25000.
Version1.1,35pp.Jemelin,L.&Beer,C.1999:GeologischerAtlasderSchweiz1:25’000Erfassungskonzept,GIS-ApplikationundStrukturder
Datenbank,Bull.angew.Geol.,4/2,103–115.
260Sy
mp
osi
um
1:
Wa
ter
acr
oss
(sc
ien
tifi
c) b
ou
nd
ari
es 8.29
The Swiss Atlas of Physical Properties of Rocks (SAPHYR)
TripoliBarbara1,ZapponeAlba1,BurliniLuigi1,BurgJean-Pierre1,HollingerKlaus2&KisslingEduard1
1Departement of Earth Sciences, ETH Zürich, Sonnegstrasse 5, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland2Institute of Geophysics, University of Lausanne Amphipole - UNIL SORGE , CH-1015 Lausanne
Physicalpropertiesofrocksarekeyparametersforseveraldisciplinesspanningfromoilindustrytoengineeringtogeophy-sics,petrology,structuralgeologyandwaterresources.Theyarethereforeusefultoseveralscientificdisciplinesaswellastoindustryandsociety.
Since2006,amultiyearprojectrunsundertheumbrellaoftheSwissGeophysicalCommission(SGPK),withtheaimtodigi-tizeallexistingdataonphysicalpropertiesofrocksandtolinkthemusingageographicalframe(GIS),sothattheycanbereadyaccessibletoawidepublic.Moreover,wheredataarelackingorspare,campaignsofmeasurementsonrocksamplesarepromotedwithinthisorotherprojects.Theproject is focusedondatafromtheSwissAlpsbut, isnot limitedtothebordersofSwitzerland.
TheresultantmapswillbeintegratedintheAtlasofSwitzerland.Thefutureevolutionofthisprogramcouldbeanextensionto3-D,usingthestructureoftheexposedgeology,thedatafromboreholesandfromgeophysicalinvestigation.
8.30
Estimation of local tectonic movements using continuous GNSS network
VilligerArturo1,HellerOliver1,GeigerAlain1,KahleHans-Gert1&BrockmannElmar2
1Geodesy and Geodynamics Lab, Institute of Geodesy and Photogrammetry, ETH Zürich ([email protected])2Swisstopo
ThecantonValaisisaseismicactiveareawithinSwitzerland.However,comparedtootherregionslikeGreecetheexpectedtectonicmovementsareatleastonemagnitudesmaller.Thepredictedvelocitiesarefewmillimetresperyear.DuringtheprojectTECVAL,initializedbyHAZNETfunds,fivepermanentGPSstationshavebeenbuiltcoveringtheWildstrubelarea.Thestationshavebeenmountedonvariousbuildingssuchassewageplantswhicharewellconnectedtothegroundtored-ucelocaleffectssuchasslowlandslipsorothernon-tectonicprocesses.CombiningstationsfromTECVAL,IGS,RGN,andAGNESyieldstoabetterlocalvelocityfielddirectlyprocessedintotheITRF2005referenceframe.Forthispurposethesoftwarebernese5.0hasbeenusedtoprocessdailysolutionsofthemeasuredpoints.Asthemainresearchtaskisthelocaltectonic,alocallyadjustedrotationalvelocityfieldhasbeenestimatedandreduced.Foreverytimeseries,undertheassumptionofatimeconstantvelocity,thevelocityhasbeenestimatedusingalinearregressionmodel.Astheycontainhighamountsofoutliersarobustestimatorwaschosenwithahighbreakingpoint(upto50percent).Theevaluationhasshownthatthetimeseriescontainupto23percentofblunderswhichwoulddecreasethereliabilityofvelocityestimation.
262Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s 9. Waterandlandresourcesindevelopingcountries:towardsinnovativemanagementandgovernanceHans Hurni, Urs Wiesmann, Thomas Breu
NCCR North-South; Centre for Development and Environment; Swisspeace Foundation; Swiss National Science Foundation; Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation; Commission for Research Partnerships with Developping Countries (KFPE)
9.1 EhrenspergerA.:BioenergyinAfrica:OpportunitiesandthreatsofJatrophaandrelatedcrops
9.2 Exarchou J., SalimN. :WaterGovernance as a tool to ensure sustainable and securehumandevelopment, in theMiddleEast
9.3 GoetschelL.,PéclardD.:Conflictsandnaturalresources.Researchresultsandoutlook
9.4 LinigerHP.,SchwilchG.,MekdaschiStuderR. :Localandregionalsustainablelandmanagementoptionsbasedonassessedexperiences
9.5 MaselliD.,Ur-RahimI.:Fromatechnocratictoacustodianshipapproach:PuttingherdersatthecentreofpasturemanagementinKyrgyzstan
9.6 MejriZ.,BenHamzaC.,HatiraN.,AbidiR.:Repartitionethydrochimiedesaquiferesdel’extremitenordoccidentalesflyschnumidien,(Tunisieseptentrionale)
9.7 NotterB.,HurniH.,AbbaspourK.:UsingtheSWAThydrologicalmodeltoquantifywater-relatedecosystemservicesinalargeEastAfricanwatershed
9.8 ThüringM.,TrotmanA.,MooreA.:CaribbeanWaterMonitor:Smallislandstates,waterresourcesandclimatechange
9.9 WolfgrammB., Bühlmann E., LinigerHP.,HurniH. : GIS-based decision support for soil conservation planning inTajikistan
263
Sym
po
siu
m 9
: W
ate
r a
nd
la
nd
re
sou
rce
s in
de
velo
pin
g c
ou
ntr
ies9.1
BioenergyinAfrica:OpportunitiesandthreatsofJatrophaandrelatedcrops
EhrenspergerAlbrecht1
1 Centre for Development and Environment, Universität Bern ([email protected])
Thedevelopmentofthebioenergysectorispushedworldwideinfaceofclimatechangeandtheexpectedshortageoffossilfuels.Biofuelshavethepotentialtoraiseexportrevenues,tocreatenewjobsandtodevelopindustriesindevelopingcoun-tries,butalsotoreducedependencyonoilimports(KOJIMAandJOHNSON2005,SIMS,HASTINGSetal.2006).Morebiofuelalsomeanslessuseoffossilfuels.Modelsshowthatthiswouldhelpreducethepriceofoil,tothebenefitofotherdevelopingcountriesthatcannotgrowbiofuelfeedstock.Asaconsequenceoftheseenvironmentalandeconomicopportunities,pro-ductionofbio-ethanolfromcornandsugarcaneandproductionofbiodieselfromrapeandsoyoilrapidlygrewoverthelastyears.However, current researchunveiled significant impactsofbioenergyon theenvironment (ZAH,HISCHIER,GAUCH,LEHMANN,BÖNIandWÄGER2007;SCHARLEMANNandLAURANCE2008),onlandusecompetitionbetweenenergyandfoodcrops(REINHARDandZAH2008;SEARCHINGER,HEIMLICHetal.2008),aswellasastrongdependenceofthebiofuelsmarketonsubsidies(STEENBLIK2007).
ThisBioenergyinAfrica(BIA)projectaddressesimportantissuesofsustainabledevelopmentinconnectiontotheproductionofbiofuels,likefoodsecurity,povertyalleviation,ruraldevelopmentandnaturalresources.Byusingasystemicapproach,the project will provide pathways towards realistic and sustainable production of bioenergy in Eastern Africa. The ap-proachesbywhichtheopportunitiesofbiofuelproductioncanbemaximisedanditsthreatsminimisedareatthecoreofthis approach.They include landuse, livelihood strategies,natural resourcesmanagementandpolicies. Specifically, theprojectlooksatfouraspectsofbiofuelproduction(seefigurenextpage):
1. Cropgrowthandprocessing:AssessingsustainablebioenergyproductionpotentialsandprocessingofJatrophabio-massindifferentproductionsystemsandunderdifferentenvironmentalandculturalsettings.
2. Impactsofbiofuelproduction:Assessingthesocio-economicandenvironmentalimpactsofbiofuelproductioninlocalcontextswithafocusonlocallivelihoodsandnaturalresourcesdynamics.
3. Globalpolicy,tradeandcertification:Assessingtheinfluenceofexternalsocio-politicalandeconomicdecision-makingprocessesontheregionalandlocalbiofuelproductionprocessesinEasternAfrica.
4. PotentialsofbiofuelinEasternAfrica:Upscalingfindingsinviewofprovidingrelevantdecision-makingandplan-ningtoolsatthenationalandregionallevelsinEasternAfrica.
Theintegrationofprojectresultsataregionalscalewillprovidehighlyrelevantbaselineinformationforabroadrangeofpotentialusers.Concreteimpactsareexpectedasfollows:
• Atthelocalscale:Enhancedcapacityoffarmersincropproductionandbiofuelprocessing.• Atthesub-nationalscale:Enhancedcapacityofconcernedgovernmentalofficesatdistrictandprovinciallevels,to
beachievedagainviasupporttotheextensionservices.• Atthenationalandregionalscales:Betterandmoresustainableplanningandpolicymakinginrelationtobioenergy
production.StrengtheningoftheEasternAfricanRegionthroughadvocacyofitsneeds,prioritiesandpotentials.• Atthegloballevel:Impactontheglobaldiscourseonbiofuel
REFERENCESKojima,M.andT.Johnson(2005).PotentialforBiofuelsforTransportinDevelopingCountries.Washington,WorldBank:150Reinhard, J. andR. Zah (2008). "Consequential Life Cycle Assessment of the Environmental Impacts of an Increased
Rapemethylester(RME)ProductioninSwitzerland."Biomass&Bioenergy.Scharlemann,J.P.W.andW.F.Laurance(2008)."Howgreenarebiofuels?"Science319:43-44.Searchinger,T.,R.Heimlich,R.A.Houghton,F.Dong,A.Elobeid,J.Fabiosa,S.Tokgoz,D.HayesandT.-H.Yu(2008)."UseofU.
S.Croplands forBiofuels IncreasesGreenhouseGasesThroughEmissions fromLandUseChange." Science319 (5867):1238-1240.
Steenblik,R. (2007).Government support for ethanol andbiodiesel in selectedOECDcountries -A synthesis of reportsaddressing subsidies forbiofuels inAustralia,Canada, theEuropeanUnion, Switzerlandand theUnitedStates,GSI -GlobalSubsidiesInitiative:82.
Sims,R.,A.Hastings,B.Schlamadinger,G.TaylorandP.Smith (2006).Energycrops:current statusand futureprospects.GlobalChangeBiology.
Zah, R., R.Hischier,M.Gauch,M. Lehmann,H. Böni and P.Wäger (2007). Life CycleAssessment of Energy Products:Environmental ImpactAssessmentofBiofuels.Bern,Bundesamt fürEnergie,Bundesamt fürUmwelt,Bundesamt fürLandwirtschaft:20.
264Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s
265
Sym
po
siu
m 9
: W
ate
r a
nd
la
nd
re
sou
rce
s in
de
velo
pin
g c
ou
ntr
ies9.2
WaterGovernanceasatooltoensuresustainableandsecurehumandevelopment,intheMiddleEast
ExarchouJoanna1,SalimNidal2
1 Global Institute for Water Environment and Health (GIWEH), Geneva- Switzerland.www.giweh.ch2 Global Institute for Water Environment and Health (GIWEH), Geneva- Switzerland.www.giweh.ch
AlargeproportionofthewaterresourcesintheMiddleEastistrans-boundaryandfinalarrangementsonwaterallocationbetweendifferent countries in the region arenot yet inplace for “fair and equitable apportionment”. TheMiddle Eastregion’snaturalwaterisnotonlythreatened,itisalsothreatening!
Waterqualityandquantityarethemainchallengesoftheregion.Beyondthechallengesrelatedtothemanagementofre-sourcescarcitytherearehydro-politicalandtrans-boundaryconsiderations.Themajorityofthewaterresourcesintheregi-on is riversandaquifers thatcutacrossborders.Other thanthe fact that thisoftenhinders theefficientandequitablemanagementofthiswater,theprospectofwitnessingseriouswaterconflictsindifferentpartsoftheregionisveryreal.
Whenwaterresourcesinonecommunitybecomescarceorthreatened,theeconomic,socialandenvironmentalrisksincre-aseforeveryone.Thus,aproactiveintegratedmanagementapproachisneededtobalancethecompetingneedsforthisli-mitedresource.“WaterSustainability”isacollaborativecommunity-driveninitiative,whichrequirestheactiveparticipati-onofallmembersinthecommunity.Itseekstoestablishnewcreativeandcoordinatedwatermanagementstrategiesbasedonvalueadditionandsecurityforallstakeholdersinthecommunity.
Thekeyaspectstobeconsideredforthefutureprospectivearetheroleofgovernance,whilegovernanceisconsideredasaprocess,soitisimportanttoknow'how'itisdone.Rulesarebroughtinanddecisionsaremade.Fromtheotherside,gover-nanceisaproduct(e.g.goodgovernance,gooddecisionmaking,badgovernance).
Oneoftheaimsoftheregionistoimprovesustainabilitythroughbetterwateruseefficiencyandconservation.Watereffi-ciencycanbeimprovedbyadoptingstructuralmeasureslikeimprovingtechnologiesandnon-structuralmeasuressuchaswaterpricing,awarenessraising,etc.Thesecondlevelofefficiencyisrelatedtotheallocationandre-allocationofwaterresourcestospecific,higher-valueusesandmoreequitableusebyallstakeholders.Thehighestlevelofefficiencyisrelatedtotheinter-basintradeofwater.Aswaterisquiteabulkyitemtotransport,tradingwaterinitsrealformiscostly,whichisthereasonwhytheconceptofvirtualwatermightcomesintopicture.
Governanceinitsseveralcontextssuchas(corporategovernance,internationalgovernance,nationalgovernanceandlocalgovernance)isneededinthearea.
Cooperationinthemanagementofscarcityandqualitydoesnotonlyoccuratthegovernmentlevelbutalsothatofcorpo-rations.TheCEOWaterMandatewithintheGlobalCompactisanopportunityatthehighestlevelsofmanagementtocom-mittotheimprovementofwateruseefficiency.
266Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s 9.3
ConflictsandNaturalResources.ResearchResultsandOutlook
LaurentGoetschel1,DidierPéclard1
1 Swisspeace Foundation, Sonnenbergstrasse 17, CH-3000 Bern 7 ([email protected])
Therelationsbetweennaturalresourcesandconflictshavealonghistory.Forcenturies,societieshaveusedcertainnaturalresourcestopursuetheirinterestsandpoliticalgoals.Untiltheendofthe18thcentury,forexample,woodwasofcrucialimportancetotheseapowers.Today,oilisintheheadlinesofthemediaworldwideasanindispensablecomponentofsu-perpowerpolitics,butalsoasacauseofconflict.Thissituationisreferredtoasgeopoliticsofconflictsconnectedwithna-turalresources(so-calledresourceconflicts;seeLeBillon2005).However,statesdonothavethemonopolyoverappropriationofnaturalresourcesforpoliticalormilitarypurposes.Controlovernaturalresourcesortheiruseisalsoasignificantfactorwithregardtotensionsandevenconflictsbetweensocietalgroups–independentlyofwhethertheresourcesatstakearenon-renewable(suchasdiamonds)orrenewable(suchaswaterorsoil).Despitetheirlongexistence,therelationsbetweennaturalresourcesandconflictsremainproblematicandmustbecriticallyscrutinised.Basedonvariouscasestudieswede-monstratethatthenotionofadirectcausallinkbetweentheenvironmentandconflicts,althoughwidespreadinthescien-tificliterature,hasnorealempiricalbasis.Likewise,it isnecessarytoquestiontheheuristicsignificanceofthisclassicalperspective:concentratingonecologicalcausalrelationsbearstheriskofnotpayingdueattentiontotherealhistorical,politicalandeconomicdimensionsoftheseconflicts.
REFERENCESBaechlerG,BögeV,Klötzli S, Libiszewski S, SpillmannKR.1996.Kriegsursache Umweltzerstörung. Ökologische Konflikte in der
Dritten Welt und Wege ihrer friedlichen Bearbeitung.ENCOPVol.1.ZurichandChur:Rüegger.BichselC.2006.Dangerous Divides: Irrigation Disputes and Conflict Transformation in the Ferghana Valley[PhDdissertation].Bern:
InstituteofGeography,UniversityofBern.BrockL.1998.UmweltundKonfliktiminternationalenForschungskontext.In: CariusA,LietzmannKM,editors.Umwelt und
Sicherheit. Herausforderungen für die internationale Politik.Berlin:Springer,pp37–56.CariusA,BaechlerG,PfahlS,MarchA,BiermannF.1999.Umwelt und Sicherheit: Forschungserfordernisse und Forschungsprioritäten.
Berlin:Ecologic.EnvironmentalChangeandSecurityProject (ECSP). TheWoodrowWilson InternationalCenter for Scholars.http://www.
wilsoncenter.org/ecsp;accessedon9September2009.HagmannT.2005.Confrontingtheconceptofenvironmentallyinducedconflict.Peace, Conflict and Development6:1–22.LeBillonP.2005.Thegeopoliticaleconomyof‘resourcewars’.In: LeBillonP,editor.Geopolitics of Resource Wars.Londonand
NewYork:FrankCass,pp1–28.MasonSA.2004.From Conflict to Cooperation in the Nile Basin: Interaction between Water Availability, Water Management in Egypt and Sudan, and International Relations in the Eastern Nile Basin. Zurich: Center for Security Studies, Swiss Federal Institute ofTechnologyZurich
9.4
Localandregionalsustainablelandmanagementoptionsbasedonassessedexperiences
LinigerHanspeter1,SchwilchGudrun1,RimaMekdaschiStuder1
1 Centre for Development and Environment, University of Bern, Hallerstrasse 10, 3012 Bern, Switzerland ([email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected])
SustainableLandManagement(SLM)usesalltypesoflandresources(soils,water,animalsandplants)fortheproductionofgoodstomeetchanginghumanneeds,whilesimultaneouslyensuringthelong-termproductivepotentialoftheseresourcesandensuringtheirenvironmentalfunctions.Watermanagementcannotbeseparatedfromlanduse,thusallSLMtechnolo-giesarerelatedtowater,bycontrollingsurfacerunoffandincreasinginfiltration,andasaresult,storemorewaterinthesoil.Withoutconservationmeasuresthecombinedwaterlossthroughrunoffandevaporationoftenleaveslessthanhalfoftherainfall–orirrigatedwater–availableforcropsorothervegetation.
267
Sym
po
siu
m 9
: W
ate
r a
nd
la
nd
re
sou
rce
s in
de
velo
pin
g c
ou
ntr
iesDependingontheclimate,twomajorcategoriescanbedifferentiated:Inhumidenvironmentssoilerosionandsoilfertility
declinearecommoncausesoflanddegradation.Theimplicationisthatconservationmeasureshavetosolvetheproblemofexcesswaterand its safedrainageeither throughthesoilprofileoronthesurface.Here, themainaimis toreducetherapidrunoffthatcausessheet,rillandgullyerosionon-siteandflooding,sedimentationandpollutionofriversandwaterreservoirsoff-site (downstream).PotentialSLMtechnologies includevegetativemeasuressuchasgrassstrips,greencover,agroforestrysystemsorstructuralmeasuressuchasterraces,gullyrehabilitation,etc.Insub-humid,semi-aridandaridre-gions,thesameproblemsmayoccurthrougherraticrainfall,butthemainfocusisonwaterconservationandimprovedwateruseefficiency,e.g.throughinsituaccumulationofsoilmoistureandreductionofthewaterlossesbyrunoffanddirectevaporationfromthesoil,orthroughwaterharvesting.Exampleshereincludeconservationagriculture, improvedcover,stonelines,plantingpitsandbasins,areaenclosureandassistednaturalregeneration,etc.SuccessfulSLMtechnologiesofteninvolvecombinedmeasures,forexamplestructurestocollectwateraswellasagronomicmeasurestoreducerunoffandevaporationlosses.
Worldwide, therearenumerouspositiveexperiencesof sustainable landmanagement.Thesecounter theprevailingandpessimisticviewthatlandandenvironmentaldegradationisinevitableandcontinuous.WOCAThasdevelopedaninterna-tionallyrecognized,standardisedmethodologyinvolvingasetofthreequestionnairestodocumentrelevantaspectsofSLMtechnologiesandapproaches,includingareacoverage.Acomputer-baseddatabasesystemfacilitatesdataentry,retrievalandevaluation.ApartfromthecasesdocumentedthroughWOCAT(www.wocat.org)andelsewhere,thevastbodyofknowledgeandwealthofexperienceinSLMmadeeitherbyprojectsorthroughinnovationsandinitiativesbythelandusersthemselvesremainsscatteredandlocalised.ThereisstillarichuntappedSLMdiversitythatisnotreadilyavailabletolandusers,thosewhoadvisethem,orplannersanddecisionmakers.Thusthebasisforsounddecisionmaking(forup-scaling)islackingandmistakesarebeingrepeated.TheWOCATtoolsprovideauniquemethodforthecomprehensivedocumentation,monitoring,evaluation and dissemination of SLM knowledge from land users, SLM specialists and researchers from different disci-plines.
AnewmethodologyhasbeendevelopedfortheselectionofSLMstrategies,combiningacollectivelearninganddecisionapproachwithevaluatedpracticesdocumentedbyWOCAT.Aconciseprocessofthreepartsinvolvingallstakeholdersstartswithidentifyinglanddegradationandlocallyappliedsolutionsinastakeholderworkshop.InthesecondpartlocalsolutionsareassessedwiththestandardisedWOCATevaluationtool,andinthethirdpartpromisingstrategiesforimplementationarejointlyselectedwiththehelpofadecisionsupporttool.Facilitatedbyamoderator,participantsconductmulti-criteriaevaluationtorankexistingandpotentialSLMstrategiesforfieldtrials.Thisinvolvesstakeholdersidentifyingandweighingrelevantcriteria(e.g.technicalrequirements,costsandbenefits,socialacceptability,etc.).Anoptioncanonlybeconsideredsustainableifitsevaluationis(moreorless)positivewithrespecttoallthreedimensionsofsustainability:economic,eco-logical,andsocio-cultural.Thus,thenegotiatedSLMoptionhastopayoffforlandusersimplementingit,hastohavepositiveimpactsonlandresources(includingsoil,water,vegetation,fauna),andhastobeacceptabletolocalactorsbyfittingintotheirsocio-culturalcontextandpractices.
However,SLMisoftenbeyondthemeans,responsibilityanddecision-makingpowerofindividuallandusers.Properplan-ningincludesbothlocalparticipation(bythestakeholders)andregionaloverallplanningwhereon-siteandoff-siteimpactsandtheirinteractionsareconsideredandregulated.Thisismostimportantwithregardtowatersheds,whereitcaninvolvedistantcommunitiesandaffecttheirlocallanduseplanning.Toolittleconsiderationhasbeengiventoproperassessmentofon-siteandoff-sitelanduseinteractionsthatleadtoregionalandglobaldamageorbenefits.AreaswithlanddegradationandgoodSLMpracticesneedtobeidentifiedandtheimpactsassessed,forwhichtheWOCATmappingtoolwasdeveloped.Itprovideskeyinformationfordecisionmakingatlocal,regionalandnationallevel,aboutwhereinvestmentscanbestbemade,andaboutwhichSLMpracticeshavethebestpotentialtospread.
REFERENCESWOCAT(WorldOverviewofConservationApproachesandTechnologies).2007:WheretheLandisGreener.Casestudiesand
analysisof soil andwater conservation initiativesworldwide.Editors: Liniger,H. andCritchley,W.CTA,Wageningen(Netherlands).
Schwilch,G.,Bachmann,F.,Liniger,HP.2009:AppraisingandSelectingConservationMeasurestoMitigateDesertificationandLandDegradationBasedonStakeholderParticipationandGlobalBestPractices.LandDegradation&Development,20,308–326.
Liniger,HP.&Critchley,W., 2008: SafeguardingWaterResourcesbyMaking the LandGreener:KnowledgeManagementthroughWOCAT.In:Bossio,D.&Geheb,K.(eds):ConservingLand,ProtectingWater.CABIWallingford.
Liniger,HP.&Schwilch,G.,2002.EnhancedDecision-MakingBasedonLocalKnowledge-WOCATMethodofSustainableSoilandWaterManagement.MountainResearchandDevelopment,22(1):14-18.
268Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s 9.5
FromaTechnocratictoaCustodianshipApproach:PuttingHerdersattheCentreofPastureManagementinKyrgyzstan
DanielMaselli1,Inam-ur-Rahim2
1 Centre for Development and Environment, Universität Bern, Hallerstrasse 10, CH-3012 Bern and University of Central Asia, Bishkek Kyrgyzstan, and Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation, Bern ([email protected])2 Centre for Development and Environment, Universität Bern, Hallerstrasse 10, CH-3012 Bern, University of Central Asia, Bishkek Kyrgyzstan ([email protected])
InthecontextofresearchledbytheNCCRNorth-SouthandtheTPP‘PastoralProductionSystems’inCentralAsia,anewparticipatoryapproachandmethodologyhasbeentestedwherelocalherdersareactivelyinvolvedinassessing,monitoringandmanagingpastures.SofartheassessmentofpastureconditionsinCentralAsiahasbeencarriedoutbyspecialistsem-ployedbystateentities.Basedonperiodicfieldvisits,mapsindicatingthepotentialfodderproductionandcarryingcapac-ityhavebeenestablishedandweremeanttobekeptup-to-date.However,thesemapsappeartobehardlyeverusedbyherd-ersandvillageadministrationsandup-datingisbeinghamperedbylackoffinancialandhumanresourcessinceindepen-dence.
BasedonexperiencesfromnorthernPakistan,anewapproachhasbeentestedinthreedifferentvillagesinKyrgyzstan.Thefundamentalchangeislinkedtotherecognitionoflocalherdersastherealmanagersandfuturecustodiansofthepastures.Theinnovativemethodologyintegratesbiophysical,socio-economicandinstitutionalelementsintoaparticipatorypasturemanagementplanningsystem.Astheseelementsinteractinahighlydynamicandinterdependentmanner,changeinanyoneisboundtomodifytheresultingland-usestrategy.Thisfactleadstoaneedformoreappropriatecontextspecificap-proachesforpasturemanagementtosecuretheappropriateuseofpastoralresources.
Afteranexploratoryintegratedsurveymeanttoidentifytheappropriateplanningunits,thelocalherdersareguidedinse-lectingappropriate indicator species forpasturemonitoring. Inparallel thecurrent seasonaloccupationandutilizationpatternisassessed.Herdersaretrainedtoevaluategrazinglandconditions.Duringthisprocess,thetrainedherdersassesstherelativeavailabilityofkeyindicatorspecies,thecalculatedstockingcapacityofdifferentmanagementunits,andthecurrentstocking.Basedonthisunderstandingajointrehabilitationorsustainablemanagementstrategycanbedevisedus-ingamulti-stakeholderprocessinwhichlocalauthoritiesareintegrated.
Themaininnovationresidesinsimplifyingandmodifyingtheclassicalconservationmonitoringtoolstoaherder-monitor-ingtoolinatransitioncontextbasedonparticipationandtakingintoconsiderationlocal/traditionalknowledge.
REFERENCESAnnaCarr andRogerWilkinson (2005) BeyondParticipation:BoundaryOrganizationsas aNewSpace for Farmers and
ScientiststoInteract.JournalofSociety&NaturalResources,Volume18,Issue3February2005,pages255–265vanNoordwijk,M., T. P. Tomich, and B. Verbist (2001)Negotiation supportmodels for integratednatural resource
management in tropical forestmargins.ConservationEcology5(2):21. [online]URL:http://www.consecol.org/vol5/iss2/art21/
DaleDore(2001)TransformingTraditionalInstitutionsforSustainableNaturalResourceManagement:History,NarrativesandEvidence fromZimbabwe'sCommunalAreas.AfricanStudiesQuarterly 5,no.3: [Theonline Journal forAfricanStudies]URL:http://web.africa.ufl.edu/asq/v5/v5i3a1.htm
RihoyE (1995) TheCommonsWithout theTragedy: Strategies forCommunityBasedNaturalResourcesManagement inSouthernAfrica.ProceedingsoftheRegionalNaturalResourcesManagementProgrammeAnnualConference.Lilongwe,Malawi:SADCWildlifeTechnicalCoordinationUnit,.
DerekArmitage1(2005)AdaptiveCapacityandCommunity-BasedNaturalResourceManagement.JournalofEnvironmentalManagementVolume35,Number6/June,2005pp703-715
TerryHillman, LinCrase1,BrianFurze1, JayanathAnanda1andDarylMaybery1 (2005)MultidisciplinaryApproaches toNaturalResourceManagement.JournalofHydrobiologia.pp99-108
Inam-ur-Rahim andDanielMissili (2004) Improving sustainable grazingmanagement inmountain rangelands ofHindukushHimalayas:AninnovativeparticipatoryassessmentmethodinNorthernPakistan.MountainResearchandDevelopment,Vol24No:2(124-133)
269
Sym
po
siu
m 9
: W
ate
r a
nd
la
nd
re
sou
rce
s in
de
velo
pin
g c
ou
ntr
ies9.6
RepartitionEtHydrochimieDesAquiferesDeL’extremiteNordOccidentalesFlyschNumidien,(TunisieSeptentrionale)
MEJRIZouhaier1,BENHAMZAChedhly,HATIRANouri2etABIDIRiadh;
Unité de Recherche – Géologie des Ressources Naturelles, Département des sciences de la terre, Faculté des sciences de Bizerte, Jarzouna-Bizerte.7021. Tunisie. [email protected]; [email protected]
LaregiondeKromerie,situéeenrivegauchedel’OuedMejerda,secarcteriseparunréseauhydrographiquedenseetramifié,unetopographietrèsaccidentéeetunepluviométrieannuelle1500mmLasérieNumidiennedelarégiondeKroumerie(Tunisieseptentrionale)estsubdiviséeentroistermeslithologiquesdistincts(Rouvier,1977).Cettesériereprésenteunpotentielréservoirhydrogéologiqueimportantessentiellementdanslemembremédiangréseux(Kroumerie).
LazonenaturelledelaKroumerieestdécoupéeparunréseaud’accidentsmajeursdisposéesendécrochements-chevauche-mentsdedirectionNE-SWàNNE-SSWsenestreetsubE-Wdextre(BenAyed,1994).Cettestructurationestàl’origine,d’unepart,delacompartimentationdesgrèsetdel’isolementdifférentieldesréservoirsgréseuxetd’autrepart,delacréationd’unefracturationmultidirectionnelletardiveentraînantuneaugmentationpréférentielledelaporositéetdelaperméa-bilitédesgrésconsolidésdesflyschsnumidiensduMaghreb(Johanssonetal.,1998)(Fig.1).Lesréservoirsgréseuxsontcaractérisésparunedynamiquesédimentairereprésentéepardescorpslenticulaires,deschen-aux,slumps.Avecdesbioturbations,desfilons;ontétéperturbéparlereplissementd’âgequaternaireancienetd’extrusiondeTriassalifère(Rouvier,1977).L’alimentationderéservoirssefaitparlesfilonsgréseuxquiassurentlajonctiondesdifférentessillsparcourantlesgrésdeKroumerie.
LeseauxsouterrainesissusderéservoirgréseuxdesMogodsmontrentdesfacièshydrochimiquesdetypechloruréetsulfatécalci-magnésienetdetypechloruréetsulfatésodiqueetpotassique.desconcentrationélevaisensulfatesetensodium,avecundégagementd’odeurfétides,aétémanquéesauniveaudecertainscaptagesimplantéssuivantunedirectionpréférenti-elleorientéeNNE-SSW.Toutefois,lacompositionchimiquedeseausouterraines,mémoiredeséchangeseau-roches.Constituéunsupportfiabledelessivageetdedissolutiondeslithosfacièsréservoirs.Larichesseenchlorureetensodiumestdifficileàexpliquersansad-mettrequesetaquifèregréseuxestconnectéàdesfacièsévaporitiqueduTrias.,notammentdusqueunaccidentprofondestinjectéparunendroitpardespointementsvolcaniques.
REFERENCESBenAyed,N.1994.Lesdécrochements-chevauchementsEWetNSconvergentsdelaTunisieseptentrionale:Géométrieet
essai de reconstitution des condition de deformations. Proceedings of the 4Th Tunisian petroleumExplorationconference.E.T.A.P,Tunisie,25-35.
Johansson,M.,Braakenburg,N.E., StowA.V.D. andFaugères J.Cl. 1998.Deep-watermassive sands: facies,processes andchannelgeometryintheNumidianFlysch,Sicily.Sedimentarygeology.115,233-265.
Rouvier,H.1977.Géologiedel’extrêmetunisien:tectoniquesetpaléogéographiessuperposesàl’extrémitéorientaledelachaînemaghrébine,theseDoctoratèsSc.,Univ.PetM.Curie,Paris,France.
Fig.1.CoupegéologiquesimplifiéelastructuredesréservoirshydrogéologiquesdelarégiondesKroumerie(Rouvier,1977)
270Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s 9.7
UsingtheSWAThydrologicalmodeltoquantifywater-relatedecosystemservicesinalargeEastAfricanwatershed
NotterBenedikt1,HurniHans1,AbbaspourKarim2
1 Centre for Development and Environment, Universität Bern, Hallerstrasse 10, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])2 Eawag, Überlandstrasse 133, Postfach 611, CH-8600 Dübendorf
TheEastAfricanPanganiBasin,awatershedofabout43,000km2locatedinTanzaniaandstraddlingthebordertoKenya,ischaracterizedbyanincreasingdemandforwater-relatedecosystemservices.Theseincludedomesticuse,agriculture,andhydropowerproduction.Thefinalaimofthestudyistoassesswateravailabilitytosustainecosystemservicesforthecurrentsituationaswellaspossiblefuturescenariosinthebasin.Westartfromtheassumptionthatanecosystemserviceisrealizediftheavailabilityofaresource(likewater)matchesanexistingdemandofanystakeholderintermsofquantity,quality,ti-mingandlocation(Notteretal.[submitted]).
TheSWATmodel(Arnoldetal.1998)canbeusedtoestimatewateravailabilityforunmeasuredlocationsandforhypotheti-calsituations,butunderthegivenassumptionneedstoproduceoutputsforspatialandtemporalunitswithinwhichtheecosystemservicesofinterestaretransferrable.InthecaseofPanganiBasin,amonthlytemporalresolutionandspatialunitscorrespondingtotheintersectionofclimaticzones,subbasinboundaries,andadministrativeunitsattheWardlevelisne-cessary.Anadditionalchallengeinourstudywasthelackofhighqualitydataonclimate,discharge,andwateruse,whichmakesuncertaintyassessmentanimperative.Thementionedchallengesweremetwithacombinationoffivestrategies:
a) Reducingdatalimitationsbycombiningdatasetsfromdifferentsources,e.g.byusingGIStoolstodetermineandimple-mentthebestpossibletechniqueforpre-processingclimaticdatatakingintoaccountelevationeffects;
b) ImplementingminormodificationstotheSWAT2005modelcode(correctionsintheirrigationanddormancyroutines,writingadditionaloutputvariables,introductionofparametersthatallowvaryingmeasuredtime-seriesinputs);
c) Developingasubbasinconfigurationprocedurethattakesintoaccountadministrativeunitsandelevationzoneswhileminimizingthenumberofsubbasinscreated;
d) ApplyingtheSUFI-2algorithm(Abbaspouretal.2007)formodelcalibrationanduncertaintyassessment,andadditional-lyincludinguncertaintyinmeasuredtime-seriesinputslikerainfall,temperature,pointsources,andmaximumalloweddiversionsintheuncertaintyanalysis;
e) Derivingproxiesforwater-relatedecosystemservicesfromSWAToutputs,e.g.wateravailabilityatthe95%reliabilitylevelasaproxyfordomesticwater,numberofmonthsperyearwithoutwaterstressasaproxyforagriculturallysuitableland,ordischargeat75%and95%reliabilitylevelsattopographicallysuitablelocationsasaproxyforhydropowerproduction.
Calibrationandvalidationofmonthlydischargeyieldssatisfactoryresults,withNash-Sutcliffecoefficientsof>=0.5reachedat8of12stations,onaverageabout70%ofmeasureddatabracketedinthe95%predictionuncertainty,andanaveragewidthofthisuncertaintyrangeofabout1.13standarddeviationsofmeasureddata.Waterqualityparameterscouldnotbecalibra-tedforalackofmeasureddata,butuncertaintybandscanbecalculatedbasedonthephysicallyplausiblerangesofparame-terssensitivetowaterquality.
Thecalibratedmodelproducesoutputsforanyrequiredadministrativeunit,climaticzone,orsubbasin,oranycombinationof theseunits. Preliminary results fromecosystem servicequantification for the "current situation" (weather conditionsfrom1981-2005,landuseandsocio-economicdatafrom1997-2002)indicatethatdomestic,andtoalesserextentalsoindus-trialandlivestockwaterdemandsarenearsatisfiedatthe95%reliabilitylevelinthoseDistrictsthatarebetteraccessiblebyroads,probablybecausewaterinfrastructurecanbebuiltandwaterrightscanbeobtainedmoreeasilyintheseareas.Onagriculturallandinthelowlands,wherethereispotentialforexpansion,periodswithoutwaterstressaregreatlyprolongedwhereirrigationisapplied,andproductivitythusenhanced;however,irrigationdirectlyimpactsonhydropowerpotentialbysignificantlyreducingdryseasondischarge.Evaluationofpossiblefuturescenariosandalternativemanagementoptionshasnotbeencarriedoutyetbutisplannedforthecomingmonths.
REFERENCESAbbaspour,K.C.etal.,2007.Modellinghydrologyandwaterquality in thepre-alpine/alpineThurwatershedusingSWAT.
JournalofHydrology,333:413-430.Arnold,J.G.,Srinivasan,R.,Muttiah,R.S.andWilliams,J.R.,1998.LargeAreaHydrologicModelingandAssessmentPartI:
ModelDevelopment.JournaloftheAmericanWaterResourcesAssociation,34(1):73-89.Notter,B.,Hett,C.,Hurni,H.andWiesmann,U.[submitted].Water-andLandCover-RelatedEcosystemServices:Approaches
toQuantificationinEastAfricaandLaos.EcologicalComplexity:ManuscriptNumberECOCOM-S-08-00227.
271
Sym
po
siu
m 9
: W
ate
r a
nd
la
nd
re
sou
rce
s in
de
velo
pin
g c
ou
ntr
ies9.8
CaribbeanWaterMonitor:Smallislandstates,waterresourcesandclimatechange
ThüringManfred1,TrotmanAdrian2&MooreAnthony2
1 Institute of Earth Sciences, University of Applied Sciences of Southern Switzerland, PO Box 72, CH-6952 Canobbio ([email protected])2 Caribbean Institute of Meteorology and Hydrology, Husbands, BB-23006 Barbados ([email protected], [email protected])
Thesufficientavailabilityofwaterresourcesisakeyfactorofsuccessforanycommunity.ThisprojectaddressesthechangesintheavailabilityofwaterresourcesintheCaribbeantoday,andtheimpactofclimatechange.Aninternet-basedmonitoringtool–theCaribbeanWaterMonitor-isbeingdeveloped,whichindicatesthecurrentsituationregardingtheavailabilityofwaterontwoislandstatesoftheCaribbean(BarbadosandTrinidad&Tobago).Basedontheinputofclimatedata–mainlyprecipitationandtemperature–thetoolassessesautomaticallythecurrentsituationanddisplays it inacomprehensiveform,suchasmapsortrendgraphs,asdevelopedinaformerprojectfortheCaribbeanislandSaintLucia(Figure1).
Figure1.Theusageofdroughtindices,suchasStandardPrecipitationIndexorDeviationfromNormalareusedassupportinformationin
waterresourcesmanagement(www.droughtinfo.org).
TheCaribbeanWaterMonitorisanessentialtoolforwaterresourcesmanagement,andoffersahelpfordecisionsupportforplanningandmanagingwaterresources.Climatechangewillrequireadaptationstrategies.Thesestrategieswillhavetobeguidedbyassessmentandmonitoringtools,suchastheproposedCaribbeanWaterMonitor.
Thisone-yearprojectisdevelopedincooperationbyaSwissandCaribbeanresearchpartnerwithcomplementarycompe-tences,andfinancedbyKFH-DEZA.
InourposterweshowthecurrentstatusoftheprojectonthedevelopmentofmapbaseddroughtandwaterindicesandtheidentificationofclimatechangesignaturesinrainfallrecordsofBarbados.
272Sy
mp
osi
um
9:
Wa
ter
an
d l
an
d r
eso
urc
es
in d
eve
lop
ing
co
un
trie
s 9.9
GIS-basedDecisionSupportforSoilConservationPlanninginTajikistan
WolfgrammBettina1,BühlmannErik1,LinigerHanspeter1&HurniHans1
1 Centre for Development and Environment (CDE), University of Bern, Hallerstrasse 10, CH-3012 Bern ([email protected])
Soilerosiononslopingagriculturallandposesaseriousproblemfortheenvironmentaswellasforproduction.Inareaswithhighlyerodiblesoils,suchasthoseinloesszones,applicationofsoilandwaterconservationmeasuresiscrucialtosustain-ingagriculturalyieldsandpreventing/reducinglanddegradation.Thepresentstudy,carriedoutinFaizabad,Tajikistan,wasdesignedtoevaluatethepotentialoflocalconservationmeasuresoncroplandtoprovidedecisionsupportforplanningsustainablelanduseinaspatiallyexplicitmanner.Asamplingdesigntosupportrelativecomparativeanalysisbetweenwell-conservedunitsandotherfieldunitswasestablishedinordertoesti-matefactorsthatdeterminewatererosion,accordingtotheRevisedUniversalSoilLossEquation(RUSLE).Suchfactor-basedapproachesallowreadyapplicationinageographicinformationsystem(GIS)environment.Furthermore,thefactor-basedRUSLEmodelfacilitatesstraightforwardscenariomodelling.High-resolutionQuickbirdsatelliteimagerywasusedtoassesscanopy cover – a major erosion control factor in the model. Standardised questionnaires designed by WOCAT (WorldOverviewofConservationApproachesandTechnologies)wereusedtodocumentlocalconservationmeasures.Thestudyshowedfirstthatassessmentoferosionandconservationinanareawithinhomogeneousvegetationcoverneces-sitatestheintegrationofplot-basedcoverderivedfromhigh-resolutionsatelliteimageryinordertoenableplot-wiseconser-vationplanning.Furthermore,thoroughfieldassessmentsshowedthat25.7%ofcurrenttotalcroplandiscoveredbyconservationmeasures(terracing,agroforestryandperennialherbaceousfodder).Assessmentoftheeffectivenessoftheselocalmeasures,combinedwiththeRUSLEcalculations,revealedthatcurrentaveragesoillosscouldbereducedbylow-costmeasuressuchascontour-ing(by11%),fodderplants(by16%),anddrainageditches(by55%).Moreexpensivemeasuressuchasterracingandagrofor-estrycanreduceerosionbyasmuchas63%(forterracing)and93%(foragroforestrycombinedwithterracing).Indeed,scenariorunsfordifferentlevelsoftolerableerosionratesshowedthatmorecost-intensiveandtechnologicallyad-vancedmeasureswouldleadtogreaterreductionofsoilloss.However,giventheeconomicconditionsinTajikistan,itseemsmoreadvisabletosupportthespreadoflow-costandlabour-extensivemeasures.
REFERENCESBühlmann,E.2006:AssessingSoilErosionandConservationintheLoessAreaofFaizabad,WesternTajikistan.MSc,Centre
ofDevelopmentandEnvironment,UniversityofBern.Liniger,H.P.,andW.Critchley.2007:WheretheLandisGreener.Casestudiesandanalysisofsoilandwaterconservation
initiativesworldwide.Wageningen:TechnicalCentreforAgriculturalandRuralCooperation.Renard,K.G.,G.R. Foster,G.A.Weesies,D.K.McCool, andD.C. Yoder. 1997: Predicting soil erosionbywater:A guide to
conservationplanningwiththeRevisedUniversalSoilLossEquation(RUSLE).AgricultureHandbook703.Washington,DC:USDA.
Shi,Z.H.,C.F.Cai,S.W.Ding,T.W.Wang,andT.L.Cho.2004:SoilconservationplanningatthesmallwatershedlevelusingRUSLEwithGIS:AcasestudyintheThreeGorgeAreaofChina.Catena55(1):33-48.
274Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10. Processes and environments influenced by water –
boundaries crossed and encountered in the Quaternary research +
12. Biological, physical and chemical processes in soilsJudit Becze-Deak + Samuel Abiven, Pascal Boivin, Elena Havlicek, Claire Le Bayon
Swiss Society for Quaternary Research (CH-QUAT) Société Suisse de Pédologie / Bodenkundliche Gesellschaft der Schweiz / Società Svizzera di Pedologia
10.1 AbivenS.,AndreoliR.:Decomposabilityofpyrogeniccarbonmixedtodifferentorganicsubstrates
10.2 Batlle-AguilarJ.,BrovelliA.,PorporatoA.,BarryD.A.:Modellingofmechanismsaffectingnitrogenandcarboncyclesinsoilssubjecttolandusechange
10.3 BreiderF.,AlbersC.,HunkelerD.,JacobsenO.S.:Carbonisotopesignatureofbiogeogenictrichloromethane:atooltodiscriminateanthropogenicandnaturalsourcesinsoils
10.4 BroennimannC.,AskarinejadA.,KienzlerP., SpringmanS., Tacher L. : Porewaterpressuremodelling in a rainfalltriggeredshallowlandslide:thesprinklingexperimentinRüdlingen,CantonSchaffhausen
10.5 CastelltortS.,GredigG.:Controlsontheformofbarsinbraidedrivers
10.6 ChappatteD.,VerrecchiaE.:Discretesimulationofbiogeochemicalexchangesinamicrobialmat
10.7 CommentN.,PinardG.,AbivenS.,AdatteT.,GobatJ.-M.,VerrecchiaE.:Reconstructionofpastvegetationsuccessionondeveloppingpodzolsusingorganicandmineralspecificmarkers
10.8 EhrhardtF.,MateraV.,AdatteT.,VerrecchiaE.:Etudedeladynamiquedesélémentstracesmétalliquesenforêtpéri-urbaine(Isle-Adam,Vald’Oise,France):approcheécosystémique
10.9 Füllemann F., Milleret R., Capowiez Y., Le Bayon R.-C., Gobat J.-M., Boivin P. : Soil porosities as engineered byearthwormsmicrocosmexperimentwithtomographyandshrinkageanalysisassessment
10.10 GlurL.,WirthS.B.,AnselmettiF.S.,GilliA.,HaugG.H.:FloodAlp!FrequencyandintensityofextremefloodsintheAlpsthroughtheHolocene
10.11 GrafPannatier,E.,SchmittM.,ThimonierA.,WaldnerP.:EffectsofatmosphericdepositionofacidcompoundsandnitrogenonsoilsolutioninSwissforests
10.12 HeerA.,Hajdas I.,SteffenD.,PreusserF.,VeitH. :OSL-basedchronologyof thepostglacialbeachplainNEofLakeNeuchâtelonSwissPlateau:Problemsandpossiblesolutions.
10.13 HeimA.,HofmannA.,MiltnerA.,ChristensenB.T.,SchmidtM.W.I.:Isthemineralphaseresponsibleforstabilizinglignininsoils?
10.14 HengartnerP.,AbivenS:Pyrogeniccarbonsolubilityinthesoils:quantitativeandqualitativeapproaches
10.15 HippeK.,KoberF.,ZeilingerG.,Ivy-OchsS.,KubikP.W.,SchlüchterC.,WielerR.:Quantifyingratesofsurfacedenuda-tionattheeasternAltiplanomargin,LaPazregion,Bolivia
10.16 KoberF.,AbbühlL.,DürstM.,Ivy-OchsS.,SchluneggerF.,KubikP.W.:Theshapeversustheprocessesofalandform–theHörnliregion,NE-Switzerland
10.17 Kohler-MilleretR.,LeBayonC.,BoivinP.,GobatJ.-M.:Earthworm,mycorrhizaandrootinteractions:effectsonsoilphosphorusnutrientstatusandsoilstructure
275
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s
10.18 MatileL.,AchermannM.,KrebsR.:EntwicklungundAnwendungeinerGrobscreening-MethodezurUntersuchungdesAbbauzustandesvonMoorbödenamBeispieldesLobsigensees
10.19 Mavris Ch., Egli M., Plötze M., Blum J., HaeberliW. : Initial Stages Of Soil And Clay Minerals Formation In TheMorteratschProglacialArea(UpperEngadine,Switzerland)
10.20 MeyerC.,LüscherP.,SchulinR.:RegenerationofmechanicallyloadedsoilsunderskidlanesbyplantationofAlnusglutinosa
10.21 PichlerB.,SchmidtH.-P.,BoivinP.,AbivenS.:Characterizationofbiocharandtheirimpactonsoilfertility
10.22 PrudatB.,AdatteT.,HassounaM.,GobatJ.-M.,VerrecchiaE.:Rock-EvalPyrolysistodeterminestableorganicMatterinirrigatedsandySoilsfromPalmOrchards
10.23 SastreV.,LoizeauJ.-L.,GreinertJ.,NaudtsL.,ArpagausP.,AnselmettiF.,WildiW.:MorphologyandrecenthistoryoftheRhoneRiverDeltainLakeGeneva(SwitzerlandandFrance)
10.24 SchwanghartW.,FrechenM.,KlingerR.,SchüttB.:GeomorphologicaldriversofHoloceneenvironmentalchangeinMongolia
10.25 SinghN.,AbivenS.,BoivinP.,SchmidtM.W.I.:Moistureandtemperatureeffectsofcharinaforestsoil
10.26 StuderM.,SchneiderM.,MorenoJ.M.,RescoV.,AbivenS.:Atooltoestimatefireintensityandchemicalstructureofblackcarboninputsintosoil
10.27 WangG.,OrD.:Hydrationeffectsonmicrobialmotilityandcoexistenceonunsaturatedroughsurfaces
276Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.1
Decomposability of pyrogenic carbon mixed to different organic substrates
AbivenSamuel1,AndreoliRomano1
1SoilScienceandBiogeography,DepartmentofGeography,UniversityofZurich,Winterthurerstrasse190,CH-8057Zürich([email protected])
Inarecentstudy,Wardleandal.(2008)observedthatthepresenceofpyrogeniccarbonenhancedthedecompositionoflitterorganicmatterinaborealecosystem.Thepyrogeniccarbon(PyC)correspondstothebiomassresiduesaftertheirincomple-tecombustion.Itpresentsparticularfeaturesregardingitbiological,chemicalandphysicalstabilityandmightplayamajorroleintheorganicmatterprocessesofsoils.
Thedecompositionoforganicsubstratesmixturescouldbequitedifferentfromthedecompositionofthesamesubstratesconsidered individually. Inmostof thecases, the interactionswithin themixtureendsupwithahigherdecomposition(synergiceffects).Thecaseswhenthedecompositionislowerduetothemixture(antagonisticeffects)orwherenointerac-tioneffects(additiveeffects)werelessreported(GartnerandCardon,2004).These interactionscanbeexplainedby thepresenceof certaincompounds thatmight influence thedecomposition.Forexample,thedegradationofrich-NorganicsubstrateswillmakeavailablemineralNthatcanbeusedbythemicro-organismstodegrademoreN-limitedsubstratesandsowillleadtoasynergiceffect(Handayantoetal.,1997).Onthecontrary,there-leaseofbiocidemoleculeslikepolyphenolsmightaffectthedecompositionofthemixtureandcauseanantagonisticeffect(PalmandRowland,1997).
Inthisstudy,wefollowedtheeffectsoftheinteractionsbetweenPyCandfourdifferentsubstratescontainingdifferentcon-tentinNandpolyphenols.
Theexperimentaldesigncorrespondstoanincubationundercontrolledconditions.Wefollowedindividuallyandinmix-turethedecompositionofPiceaabieswood,charfromthisPiceaabieswoodand4typesoffreshlitter,Picealeaves,ashesleaves,oakbarkandalderleaves,during100daysatconstanttemperature(23°C)andmoisture(fieldcapacity).The4typesoffreshlitterhaddifferentcontentsinN(alder>ash>picea>oak)andinpolyphenols(oak>alder>picea>ash).
Thedecompositionwasestimatedby themineralisedC-CO2measuredby the conductivitymethod (WollumandGomez,
1970).ThesoilusedinthisincubationisaCambisol(4%C,30%clay,pH6.0)sampledunderforest(Laegern,Aargau).
ThedecompositionofthemixtureswithN-richcontentlitter(alderandash)wasmoreimportantthanthemixturecontai-ningoakbarkandpicealeaves(mineralizationbelow10%).
Inallthecases (exampleofthemixtureswithAshleaves, figure1),weobservedamoreimportantdecompositionofthemixturewithwood(synergiceffect)andalowerdecompositionofthemixturewiththechar(antagonisteffect).Thediffe-rencesbetweenthedifferentlitterswererelativetothegeneraldecompositionleveloftheinitialsubstrates,ratherthananyinteractionwithparticularcompounds.
TheseresultsarechallengingthestudyofWardleetal.(2008)andshowtheneedtotakeintoaccounttheinitialqualityofthedecomposingsubstrates.
REFERENCESGartner,T.B.&Cardon,Z.G.2004:Decompositiondynamicsinmixed-speciesleaflitter.Oikos104,230-246.Handayanto,E.,Giller,K.E.&Cadisch,G.,1997:RegulatingNrelease from legume treeprunningsbymixing residuesof
differentquality.SoilBiology&Biochemistry.29,1417-1426.Palm,C.A.&Rowland,A.P.,1997:Aminimumdatasetforcharacterizationofplantqualityfordecomposition.PlantLitter
QualityandDecomposition,DrivenbyNature,edsG.CadishandG.E.Giller,Ch.28,379-392Wardle,D.A.,Nilsson,M.C.&Zackrisson,O.2008:Fire-DerivedCharcoalCausesLossofForestHumus.Science.320,629.Wollum,A.G.&GomezJ.E.1970:AconductivityMethodforMeasuringMicrobiallyEvolvedCarbonDioxide.Ecology.51,155-
156.
277
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s
0
10
20
30
0 25 50 75 100Days
C-CO
2/C total (%)
Ash and WoodAsh and CharAsh and Char thAsh and Wood th
Figure1.Cmineralization(expressedas%C-CO2/TotalC)ofthemixtureash–wood(square)andash–char(circle).Theblacksymbolsre-
presentthemeasuredvaluesandthewhitesymbolsthearithmeticaverageofthemineralizationoftheorganicsubstratesdecomposing
separetly(th:theoreticalvalue).
10.2
Modelling of mechanisms affecting nitrogen and carbon cycles in soils subject to land use change
Batlle-AguilarJordi1,BrovelliAlessandro1,PorporatoAmilcare2,BarryD.Andrew1
1Ecological Engineering Laboratory, Institute for Environmental Engineering, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Station 2, CH-1015, Switzerland ([email protected], [email protected], [email protected]) 2 Civil and Environmental Engineering Department, Duke University, Durham, NC-27708, USA ([email protected])
Inordertomeetdemandsforcrops,pastureandfirewood,therateoflandusechangefromforestedtoagriculturalusessteadily increasedover several decades, resulting in an increased release ofnutrients towards groundwater and surfacewaterbodies.Inparallel,thecontinuousdegradationofnaturalecosystemssuchasriparianzones,contributetodiminishtheircapacitytoprovideecologicalservices, i.e. reducethe impactsofdeleterioushumanactivitiesonbothsurfaceandgroundwater.Landusechangesandrestorationpracticesareknowntoaffectbothsoilnutrientdynamicsandtheirtrans-porttoneighbouringareas.
Biogeochemicaltransformationsinsoilsareheavilyinfluencedbymicrobialdecompositionofsoilorganicmatter.Carbonandnutrientcyclesareinturnstronglysensitivetoenvironmentalconditions,primarilytosoilmoisture.Thisphysicalva-riableaffectsthereactionrateofalmostallsoilbiogeochemicaltransformations,includingmicrobialandfungalactivity,nutrientuptakeandreleasefromplants,etc.Soilwatersaturationisnotconstantneitherintimenorinspace,thusfurthercomplicatingthepicture.Inordertointerpretfieldexperimentsandelucidatethedifferentmechanismstakingplace,nu-mericaltoolsarebeneficial.
Theimpactofhydroclimaticvariability(soilmoistureinparticular)onsoilcarbonandnitrogencycleswashighlightedalongwiththeconsequencesoflandusechangesfromforesttopastureand/oragriculture.Tothisend,amechanisticmodelbasedonthecompartmentmodelofPorporatoet al.(2003)wasdeveloped.Thepredictivecapabilitiesofthemodeltoforecastthe
278Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces effectsoflandusechangesovercarbonandnitrogendynamicswereshown,modellingfourdifferentscenarios,intertwining
twodifferentclimateconditions(withandwithoutseasonality)withtwocontrastingsoilshavingphysicalpropertiesthatarerepresentativeofforestandagriculturalsoils.Synthetictimeseriesofprecipitation,andthereforesoilmoistureevoluti-onintime,weregeneratedusingastochasticapproach.Themodelwassubjecttoisothermalconditionsandotherconside-rationssuchasaveragevaluesofcarbonandnitrogenconcentrationsovertherootingdepth.Aswellanaveragemicrobialorganicdecompositionratewasconsidered.Simulationresultsdemonstratedhigherconcentrationsofcarbonandnitrogeninforestssoilsasaresultofhigherlitterdecompositionthaninagriculturalsoils(Figure1).Highfrequencychangesinwa-tersaturationunderseasonalclimatescenarioswereshowntobecommensuratewithcarbonandnitrogenconcentrationsinagricultural soils.Forest soilshavedifferentproperties toagricultural soils, leadingtoanattenuationof theseasonalclimate-induced frequency changes inwater saturation,with accompanying changes in carbon and nitrogen concentra-tions.
Themodelwasshowntobecapableofsimulatingthelongtermeffectsofmodifiedphysicalpropertiesofagriculturalsoilsasaconsequenceoftillage,ploughingandharvesting.Itis,thus,apromisingtooltopredictcarbonandnitrogenturnoverchangesduetochangesinlanduse.Theseresultsencouragefurthermodelimprovementsaimedataccountingforthecom-plexityofthesoilsystemanditsprocessesforbetterunderstandingsoilnutrientsturnover.
Figure1.Simulatedorganiccarbonconcentrationsinthelitterpoolforagriculturalandforestsoilsunderseasonal(leftside)andno
seasonal(rightside)climateconditions.
REFERENCESPorporato,A.,D’Odorico,F.,Laio,F.&Rodriguez-Iturbe,I.2003:Hydrologiccontrolsonsoilcarbonandnitrogencycles.Adv.
WaterResour.,26,45-58.
279
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.3
Carbon isotope signature of biogeogenic trichloromethane: a tool to dis-criminate anthropogenic and natural sources in soils
FlorianBreider1,ChristianAlbers2,DanielHunkeler1&OleStigJacobsen2
1Center of Hydrogeology, University of Neuchâtel, Rue Emile Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel (f [email protected])2Geological Survey of Denmark and Greenland, Oster Voldgade 10, DK-1350 Copenhagen
Trichloromethane(TCM,CHCl3)hasbeenforlongtimeconsideredasananthropogeniccontaminantknownforitscancero-
geniceffects.TCMissometimesdetectedfarfromanyanthropogenicsourceswithoutanyothercontaminants.Todatemorethan3800naturalhalogenatedorganiccompoundshavebeenidentified(Gribble,2003).ThepresenceofTCMinconiferousforestsoilsandgroundwaterhasbeenwidelydemonstrated.DifferentstudiessuggestthatTCMandotherorganohalogenssuchaschloromethanemaybenaturallyproducedinsoilsbyenzymaticchlorinationofthesoilorganicmatter(Hoekstraetal., 1998).Chloroperoxidase excretedby some fungimayplayamajor role in thebiosynthesisof organohalogens in soil(Hoekstraetal.,1998).
Isotoperatiomassspectrometryisapowerfultooltodeterminetheoriginandthefateoforganiccompoundsintheenviron-ment(Harperetal.,2001).TheaimofthisstudyistodiscriminateanthropogenicandbiogeogenicTCMsourcesusingcom-poundspecificisotopeanalysis.TheisotopicsignaturesofTCMproducedindustriallyandbychlorinationofdifferenthu-micsubstancesandsoilorganicmatterweremeasuredbyGC-C-IRMS.Moreover δ13CvaluesofTCMpresentinforestsoilswerealsomeasuredatdifferentdepthinthreesitesinDenmark.
Allnaturalprecursorsusedgivecomparable δ13CvaluesofTCMwhichareconsistentwithtypicalisotopesignatureofcom-poundsderivedfromplantmaterial(Fig.1).IndustrialTCMisparticularlydepletedin13C( δ13C~49‰vs.V-PDB)comparedtoTCMsynthesizedfromnaturalprecursors( δ13C~33‰vs.V-PDB)(Fig.1).Thereforetheisotopicratioconstitutesagoodindica-toroftheoriginofTCM.
The δ13CvaluesofTCMmeasuredinforestsoilsareinthesamerangeasTCMproducedinlaboratoryfromnaturalprecur-sors.ThisconfirmsthatTCMpresentsinsoilairisbiogeogenic(Fig.2).Thevariationsofthe δ13CvalueswithsoildepthareinverselycorrelatedwiththeTCMconcentrationsprofiles.Indeed,whenconcentrationsofTCMinthesoilairarehigh,TCMisdepletedin13CcomparedtosoillayerspresentinglowTCMconcentrations.Thesevariationsarelikelyduetothecombina-tionofproduction,degradationandtransportprocessesinsoils.Furtherinvestigationsarecurrentlycarriedouttoknowhowclimaticparameterssuchasprecipitation,soilmoistureandtemperaturecaninfluencetheseprocessesandthereforetheisotopicratiosofTCM.
Figure1. δ13C(‰)ofindustrialTCMandTCMsynthesizedfromdifferentnaturalprecursors.HA:humicacid,NOM:naturalorganicmatter
280Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces
Figure2. δ13C(a)andconcentrationprofiles(b)ofTCMinsoilairofthreedifferentsites.
REFERENCESGribble,G.W.2003:Thediversityofnaturallyproducedorganohalogens.Chemosphere,52,289-297.Harper,D.B.,Kalin,R.M.,Hamilton, J.T.G.&Lamb,C.2001.Carbon isotope ratios for chloromethaneofbiologicalorigin:
Potentialtoolindeterminingbiologicalemissions,EnvironmentalScienceandTechnology,35,3616-3619Hoekstra,E.J.,DeLeer,E.W.B.&Brinkman,U.A.T.1998:Naturalformationofchloroformandbrominatedtrihalomethanes
insoil.EnvironmentalScienceandTechnology,32,3724-3729.
10.4
Porewater pressure modelling in a rainfall triggered shallow landslide: the sprinkling experiment in Rüdlingen, Canton Schaffhausen
BroennimannCornelia1,AskarinejadAmin2,SpringmanSarah2,TacherLaurent1
1GEOLEP, EPFL, Station 18, 1015 Lausanne ([email protected])2Institut für Geotechnik, ETHZ, Wolfgang-Paulistr. 15, 8093 Zürich
Heavyandlong-termrainfalliswellknownasamajortriggeroflandslidesatdifferentscales.Nevertheless,oftenalackofdatasetscomplicatesadetailedunderstandingofslope’shydrologicalregime.Itisassumedthatforshallowlandslidesthehydrogeologicalroleofthebedrockisdeterminantfortheslopesbehaviour.Inthepresentedstudy,twolandslidetriggeringexperimentswerecarriedoutonadenselyequippedtestsite.Basedona largedataset,a finiteelement flowmodelwaselaboratedtoreconstructtheevolutionofporewaterpressuresintheslopeduringandaftersprinklingtests.
ThesprinklingexperimentwaslocatednearthevillagesRüdlingenandBuchberginthecantonSchaffhausenattheborderoftheriverRhine.Withaslopeinclinationoflocallyupto40°theareaisrathersteepandcharacterizedbycontinuousre-gressiveerosionprocesses(Figure1).Theexperimenttookplaceinaslopeaffectedbyformerslidingprocesseswhichcouldbeverifiedbyseveralmassmovementdepositsof~1mthickness.Duringrainfallevents,forexampleinMay2002,severalshallowlandslidesoccurredintheareaandaffectedafforestedsoilsaswellaswoodlessareas.
Thelithologyintheareaoftheexperimentischaracterizedbyhorizontallylayeredmarlsandsandstonesfromthelowerfreshwater(Aquitanien)andupperseawatermolasse(Burdigalien)overlaidby1-3mofsiltycolluviumandsoil.Formoredetailedlithologicalandhydrogeologicalreconnaissance,a23mdeepboreholewasdrilledabovethetestsite.Thesandstoneispoorlycementedandstronglyaltered.Thisexplainsthelocallyhighhydraulicconductivity(10-2m/s–10-5m/s)measuredin various infiltration testswhichwere carriedout in~3mdeephandaugerboreholes. Furthermore, vertical joints indecametrescaleorientedparalleltotheRhineaffectlocallythehydrogeologicalregimebydrainingeffectivelytheslope.Seasonallycontrolledspringsareobservedalongoutcroppingbedrockabovethetestsite.Thisimpliesthatatalocalscalethebedrockwaterflowsarehighlyheterogeneous.
281
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s
The10x30mlargetestsitewithameaninclinationof35°wasequippedamongotherswithpluviometers,tensiometers,decagons, piezometers, deformation probes, electric resistivity tomography instrumentation, acoustic sensors and videocameras.Thesitewasirrigatedartificiallywithanintensityofmaximal30mm/h.Duringafirstsprinklingperiodof5daysinOctober2008,thesloperemainedstable.However,inMarch2009itfailedafteranirrigationperiodof15hours.
ThefirstexperimentinOctober2008showedthatheavyrainfallisnotalwayssufficienttotriggeramassmovement.Theinitialsaturationofthesoilplaysanimportantroleconcerningtheslopesstability.Alsothehydrogeologicalcharacterofthebedrockshouldbetakenintoaccount.Thesandstoneinthesprinklingareaactedmostlikelyasadrainduetoitslargejoints.Theinitialconditionsforthesecondexperimentinfall2009weredifferentbecausesoilandbedrockweremoresatu-ratedafterrainyperiodsandsnowmelt.Thisismostlikelythereasonfortherapidtriggeringofa~180m2largelandslide.
Basedonfieldandlaboratoryparameters,a2Dfiniteelementflowmodeliscreated.Itshowstherelationshipbetweensur-facewaterinfiltrationandthespatiallyandtemporallyevolutionofporewaterpressuresbeforeandduringtheslopefailure.Thisgivesnewfindingsofthehydraulicconditionsinthesubsurfaceduringthetriggeringofashallowlandslide.Infuturework,themodelledporewaterpressuredistributioncanbecombinedwithmechanicalslopestabilitycalculations.
This studywas carriedout in the frameof theTRAMMProject (TriggeringofRapidMassMovements) financedbyCCES(CompetenceCenterEnvironmentandSustainabilityoftheETHDomain).
Figure1:LocationoftheRüdlingensprinklingexperiment.Noticetheregressiveerosionprocessesinthegulliesandatthesteepborders
oftheRiverRhine(http://www.sh.ch).
282Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.5
Controls on the form of bars in braided rivers
CastelltortSébastien1&GredigGaudenz1
1ETH-Zürich, Earth Surface Dynamics, Sonneggstrasse 5, 8092 Zürich ([email protected])
Despitetheconsiderableamountofworkcompletedonthemorphologyofbraidedrivers,thecontrolsontheformofbraidbarswithinchannelsandtheprocessesthatcontributetotheirformationarestillunclear.Moststudieshavefocusedonthecomplexity of braiding and have tried tomeasure and characterize this complexity (see e.g. Egozi and Ashmore, 2008).Throughdifferentapproachesitisshownclearlyinthesestudiesthatthedegreeorintensityofbraidingiscontrolledbytheslope,dischargeandquantityandqualityofthesedimentintransport.Manyattemptshavealsobeenmadeatusingtheseparametersinordertofindthreshold-separatedfieldsofexistenceofthebraidedormeanderingchannelpatterns.Thesandorgravelbarsthatseparatechannelswithinabraidedriverreachhavebeengivenadifferentkindofattention:moststudiesinterestedinbraidbarshaveexploredanddescribedthesedimentaryprocessesactingupontheirformation,theirresultingsedimentaryarchitectureandtheirsedimentology.Thereasonforthisfocusisthatbraidbarsultimatelyfillchannelsandthusrepresentthebulkofthecoarsefillofcontinentalenvironmentsrelatedtobraidedsystemss.l.,potentialreservoirsofcrucialimportancetoresourcegeology.
However,arebraidbarsdifferentinriverswithdifferentslopes,grainsizeordischarge?Nodatahaseverbeencollectedbe-forethatcanallowustoanswerthisquestion.Inthepresentworkwepresentnewdatathatfillinthisgapinknowledge.
TakingadvantageofmethodsdevelopedtostudytheshapeofrivernetworksinmountainrangesatETH-Zürich(Castelltortetal.,2009)andimageanalysismethodsdevelopedformicroscopepetrography(JMicroVision©,UniversityofGeneva),westudythecharacteristicanglebetweenchannelsatmultipleflowconvergencesin10braidedriversworldwide.Weshowthatbarsbecomemoreelongateandnarrowasslopeincreases(Figure1).Thisintuitivelyconsistentresulthasimportantimpli-cations:1)itconfirmsthatthemainprocessesthatshapebraidbarsareerosiveinnature(MurrayandPaola,1994).Abraidedrivercanbeconsideredclosetoasuccessionofrivernetworksincisinganewsurfaceaftereachflood.2)iftheformofbraidbarscanbeinferredfromfossildeposits,thepaleoslopeoftherivercanbededuced.
Slopehoweverisnotanindependentparameterofriverevolution.Itisindeedcontrolledbythecompetitionbetweenwaterdischargeandsedimentfluxandgrainsizewhicharetheonlyindependentvariablesattheupstreamboundaryofariversystem.Ongivenfluvialsuccessions,giventhesedimentgrainsizedistribution,thereconstructionofbraidbarsmorpholo-gyandpaleoslopecanprovideuniqueinformationsonriverpaleo-hydrologyandclimate.
Figure1.Braidbarmeanelongation(equivalentconfluenceangleindegrees)versusriverslope.Thebraidbarsarebroader(largeconflu-
enceangle)onsmallerslopesandmoreelongate(smallconfluenceangle)onhighslopes.
283
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
sREFERENCESCastelltortS.,SimpsonG.&DarrioulatA.(2009)–Slope-controlontheformofriverbasins,TerraNova,inpress.EgoziR.&AshmoreP.(2008)–Definingandmeasuringbraidingintensity.EarthSurfaceProcessesandLandforms,33,2121-
2138.Murray,A.B.&Paola,C.(1994)–Acellularmodelofbraidedstreams,Nature,v.371,54-57.Roduit,N. – JMicroVision: Imageanalysis toolbox formeasuringandquantifyingcomponentsofhigh-definition images.
Version1.2.2.http://www.jmicrovision.com(accessedMay2009).
10.6
Discrete simulation of biogeochemical exchanges in a microbial mat
ChappatteDamien1,VerrecchiaEric2
1Institut de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne, [email protected] de Géologie et Paléontologie, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne, [email protected]
Microbialmatsarecomplexecosystems,whichplayedandstillplayamajorroleintheEarthsystem.Theirbiogeochemicalfunctioningisstillnotcompletelyunderstood.Microbialmatsaredrivenbyseveralguildsofbacteria(withtheirownmeta-bolisms),chemicalsubstances,light,andmanyotherexternalandinternalparameters.Conventionalapproachestocompu-tersimulatesuchageo-ecosystemusenumericalmodels,usuallybasedondifferentialequationsandtheirsolutions.Weproposetoexploreadifferentwaybyusinganothercomputersciencetool,discretesimulation.
Indiscretesimulation,timeandspacearediscretizedintimestepsandcells.Eachcellcontainsthestateofasmallpartofthemat.Timestepsareiteratedoverthecourseofthesimulation,andeachcellstateisupdated.
Inoursimulations,cellscontaininformationaboutchemicalsubstances,chemicalreactions,light,andbacteriacharacteri-zedbytheirmetabolisms.Simulationsgeneratedatasimilartothoseobtainedinanaturalenvironment,suchaschemicalsubstanceconcentrationsorlightintensities.Suchdatacanbeobtainedinanycellatanytimestep,thesamewayanaturalscientistwouldgetmeasurementsinthefieldatdifferentpointsinamatandatdifferenttimesoftheday.Consequently,graphsandprofilescanbeplottedandsimulationresultscomparedtorealmicrobialmatmeasurements.
Preliminaryresultsshowthatthistoolcanmimicthedielcyclesofmainchemicalsubstancesfoundinmicrobialmats(suchasO,S,orC).Thegoalistoextendthemodelcapacityinordertoprecipitatecalciumcarbonate,leadingtothesimulationofstromatolitegrowth.Inthisway,wewillhaveaccesstoavirtuallaboratoryinwhicheasyexperimentscouldberuntocheckhypothesesregardingbiogeochemicalbehaviourofmicrobialmatsduringtheEarth’shistory.
10.7
Reconstruction of past vegetation succession on developping podzols using organic and mineral specific markers
CommentNicolas1,PinardGladys1,AbivenSamuel2,AdatteThierry3,GobatJean-Michel1&VerrecchiaEric3
1Laboratoire Sol & Végétation, Université de Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])2Soil Science and Biogeography Unit, University of Zurich – Irchel, Winterthurerstr. 190, CH-8057 Zurich3Laboratoire des Biogéosciences, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne
Podzolisationisapedogeneticprocesscaracterisedbydifferentmodificationsoftheorganicmatterandmineralmaterialovertime.Thisprocessoccursunderspecificbioticandabioticconditions.Themajoroneisthepresenceofanacidifyinglitter,whichcouldbefoundundermoorlandorunderconiferouslitter.However,podzolsarealsofoundundermeadows,whichindicatethatthevegetationchangedduringthepodzolisationprocess.
284Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces ThestudysiteislocatedinSaint-Luc(VS)between2100and2900metera.s.l.Soilprofilsweredugunderdifferentvegetation
types,coniferforest,moorlandandgrassland.Thisstudyproposestoreconstructpastvegetationandassociatedpodzolisati-onprocessesusingspecificbio-andmineralmarkers.
Weusedligninasbiomarkersofthevegetation,sincethismoleculeisonlyoriginatedfromplants.Also,theligninmoleculesareoftenconsideredasrecalcitrantinthesoilandsothechancetofindtracesofformervegetationislarger.Theligninwasextractedusingthecupricoxideoxidationprocedure.Briefly, thesoil sampleswereextractedusinganalkalinesolutionunderN
2atmosphere.Thesolutionswerecleanedandtheconcentrationof8specificphenolicmonomersforligninwere
measuredbyGC–FID.Thecalculationofratiosallowedustocomparetheactualcompositionofthesoillignintotheligninofdifferentvegetationtypes.
Thepodzolisationprocesswascaracterisedby(1)themobilizationofironand(2)thedestructionandneogenesisofclays.(1)Duringpodzolisation,ironbindsorganicmattertogetherintheformofchelates.Thiscomplexationenablesirontoper-colate throughthesoil.Theeluvialhorizonbecomesdepleted in iron.Toestimate the lossesof iron, twoextractionsoneluvialhorizonsweredone (i) tetraborateof sodiumand (ii) citrate-bicarbonate-dithionite (CBD).Tetraborateextracts theformofironthatischaracteristicforpodzolisationandCBDallformsofironwhicharepresentinsoil(excludingcrystalizedforms).Then,theratio(Fetetraborate/FeCBD)iscalculated.(2)Litterdecomposition,rootsandmicroorganismsreleaseorga-nicacidswhichattackphyllosilicates(micaandchlorite).Thisweatheringleadstotheneogenesisofnewclaymineralfol-lowingthisorder:mica-vermiculitemixedlayers–vermiculite–mica-smectitemixedlayers–kaolinite.BulkrockandclaymineralassemblageswereanalyzedbyX-raydiffraction(ARLX’TRADiffractometer).
Thefirstresultsofironformsshowthepresenceoftwoclassesofeluvialhorizon(Figure1).Theirdistinction’slimitisnear2550ma.s.l.It’sinterestingtounderlinethatthisheightcorrespondsglobalytothehigherlimitthattheforesthadneverreachedinanearbyvalley(Tinneretal.,2003).
Themineralogyofclaysandmobilizedironfromeluvialshorizonsestimatethedegreeofpodzolisationofthedifferentsoils.Theseresultswillbecorrelectedtothelignindatainordertotracethedifferentkindofvegetationthatmighthavebeengrowing there. These results emphasize the role of combined organic andmineralmatters in thepodzolisation processthroughtime.
Figure1:Dendrogramofeluvialhorizonsdistributionaccordingtoeuclidiandistance(Wardagglomeration).Thevariables“altitude”and
“ratio(Fetetraborate/FeCBD)”havebeenusedtoperformcalculations.Thenumberdownbelowisthealtitudeofthestudiedsoil.
REFERENCETinner,W.&Theurillat,J.-P.2003:UppermostLimit,Extent,andFluctuationsoftheTimberlineandTreelineEcoclineintheSwissCentral
AlpsduringthePast11,500Years.Arctic,Antarctic,andAlpineResearch,35,158-169.
285
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s
10.8
Etude de la dynamique des éléments traces métalliques en forêt périur-baine (Isle-Adam, Val d’Oise, France):approche écosystémique
EhrhardtFiona1,MateraVirginie2,AdatteThierry3,VerrecchiaEric3
1Laboratoire Sol et Végétation, Université de Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])2 Institut d’Hydrogéologie et de Géothermie, Université de Neuchâtel, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel3Laboratoire des Biogéosciences, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne
Cetteétudeseconcentresurladistributionetl’originedesélémentstracesmétalliques(ETM)dansuneforêtpéri-urbaineprochedeParis (L’Isle-Adam). Elleviseà intégrerdifférentscompartimentsde l’écosystèmeforestierafindemieuxcom-prendrelesinterrelationsetlesinfluencesréciproques.Ainsi,lelongd’untransect,dixstationsontétésélectionnéesdanslebutd’étudierfonctionnellementlessolsetlesformesd’humusassociées,etdequantifierlesETMprésents.Cecicomplètecertainstravauxdéjàeffectués(Hernandezetal.,2003),etpréciselelienentreETMetphasesporteuses.
Dansunpremiertemps,l’utilisationdesanalysesstatistiquesapermisdepréciserlesprincipauxfacteursdedistribution(Borůvka,2005),etce,dèsledépôtdespolluantsatmosphériquesensurfacejusquedansl’ensembledesprofilsdessolsétu-diés.Lesrésultatsmontrentainsiquel’analysedelalitière (OL)permetdedécelerl’originedeséléments (endistinguantnotammentlesapportsgéogéniquesdesapportsanthropiques)ainsiqueleurmodededépôt.Leshorizonsdefragmentation(OF)permettentensuitelaréorganisationdesélémentsenfonctiondesaffinitéspourlesdifférentesphasesporteusesdusoletlecomportementchimiquedechacun.Enfin,dansleshorizonsOH,qualitédelamatièreorganiqueetdegréd’humificationsemblentdicterladistributiondesETM.
S’agissantdelarépartitionglobaledesETMdansl’ensembledesprofilsdesolétudiés,nousavonsconstatéquelesfacteursdedistributionsontprincipalementliésàdeuxgradientscomplémentaires(fig.1),l’uncoupléàlaprésencedematièreor-ganiquequidiminueaveclaprofondeuretl’autre,inverse,associéàl’augmentationdelaproportiondematièreminérale(notammentlaproportiondephyllosilicates).Nousavonsainsipudémontrer,grâceàuneétudeminéralogique,l’importancedessmectitesdanslamigrationdesETM.
L’étudedufacteurd’enrichissementdesETMpermetdepréciserdavantagelapartdelacontributionanthropiquedecelled’originegéogène(Blaser,2000)etdevisualiserlamigrationdesélémentsanthropiquesàtraversleprofildesol.Ainsileplomb,bienqueréputépeumobile,semblecapabledemigrerjusqu’àdesprofondeursimportantesdanscetyped’écosystème.LafaunedusolcontribueégalementàladynamiquedesETMencréantlesformesd’humusetnousavonsvuquelacompo-sitionfaunistiqueestpropreàchaquegrandtypedeformed’humus.Ellepermetl’intégrationdelaMOdanslessols,con-tribueàsaminéralisationetdoncàlaremiseencirculationdesETMliésàlaMO.LesrésultatsexprimentdesvaleursrelativementélevéespourlePb(jusqu’à130ppmdanslessolset210ppmdansleshori-zonsOH),leCr(jusqu’à342ppmdansleshorizonsOF)etleCd(jusqu’à1.12ppmdansleshorizonsOFetOH),mettantenavantl’importancedeshorizonshumifèresdanslestockageetlaséquestrationdeceséléments.Cesvaleursdépassentlesvaleurslimitesdéfiniesparl’Osol(1998),àsavoir50ppmpourlePb,50ppmpourleCret0.8ppmpourleCd.
Enconclusion,lesrésultatsobtenusmontrentquelefonctionnementmêmedusoldétermineladistributiondesETMselonlesdynamiquesdelaMOetdesphyllosilicatesquiluisontpropres.
REFERENCESBlaser,P.etal.,2000.Criticalexaminationoftraceelementenrichmentsanddepletionsinsoils:As,Cr,Cu,Ni,Pb,andZn
inSwissforestsoils.TheScienceoftheTotalEnvironment249,257-280.Borůvka,L.etal.,2005.Principalcomponentanalysisasatooltoindicatetheoriginofpotentiallytoxicelementsinsoils.
Geoderma128,289-300.Hernandez,L.etal.,2003.HeavymetaldistributioninsomeFrenchforestsoils:evidenceforatmosphericcontamination.
TheScienceoftheTotalEnvironment312,195-219.Osol, 1998.Ordonnance sur les atteintesportées au sol.OFEV, confédérationSuisse; ordonnancedu1er juillet 1998,n°
814.12.
286Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
R3H1
R3H2
R3H3
R3H4
R3H5
R3H6
R3H7
R4H1
R4H1b
R4H2
R4H3
R4H4R4H5ht
R4H5bas
R4H6
R1H1
R1H1/2R1H2R1H2/3R1H2/3bR1H3R1H4
R1H5 R1H6
R1H7 R1H8R1H9
R7H1
R7H2 R7H3R7H4
R7H5
R7H6
R7H7
R8H1
R8H2R8H3
R8H4R8H5
R8H6
R11H1R11H2
R11H3
R11H4R11H5
R11H6R11H7
R12H1
R12H2
R12H3R12H4htR12H4bas
R12H5
R12H6
R12H7
R13H1 R13H2R13H3
R13H4R13H5
R13H6
R13H7
R14H1
R14H2
R14H3R14H4
R14H5
R14H6
R14H7
POD1
POD2POD3
POD4POD5
POD6POD7POD8POD9
argileuxlimoneuxsableux
Pb
Mo
Cu
Cr
Cd
Zn
Ni
Co
As
Horizons de surface
Horizons de profondeur
MO
Al= % phyllosilicates
GEOGENIQUE
-3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
R3H1
R3H2R3H3
R3H4
R3H5
R3H6
R3H7
R4H1
R4H1b
R4H2
R4H3
R4H4R4H5ht
R4H5bas
R4H6
R1H1
R1H1/2R1H2
R1H2/3R1H2/3bR1H3R1H4
R1H5 R1H6
R1H7 R1H8R1H9
R7H1
R7H2 R7H3R7H4
R7H5
R7H6
R7H7
R8H1
R8H2 R8H3
R8H4R8H5
R8H6
R11H1R11H2
R11H3
R11H4R11H5
R11H6R11H7
R12H1
R12H2
R12H3R12H4htR12H4bas
R12H5
R12H6
R12H7
R13H1 R13H2R13H3
R13H4R13H5
R13H6
R13H7
R14H1
R14H2
R14H3R14H4
R14H5
R14H6
R14H7
POD1
POD2POD3
POD4POD5
POD6POD7POD8POD9
argileuxlimoneuxsableux
ANTHROPIQUE
Fig.1:SchémasynthétiquedelarépartitiondesETM(Pb,Zn,Cu,Cd,Ni,Cr,Mo,As,Co)dansleshorizonsdesol(n=78),paruneACP.VariancesexpliquéessurCP1:58%etCP2:16%.
10.9
Soil porosities as engineered by earthworms microcosm experiment with tomography and shrinkage analysis assessment
FrançoisFüllemann12,RoxaneMilleret2,Y.Capowiez3,Renée-ClaireLeBayon2,Jean-Michel-Gobat2,&PascalBoivin1
1 Laboratoire Sols et Substrat, hepia-Lullier, route de Presinge 150, 1254 Jussy, Genève ([email protected])2 Laboratoire Sol et Végétation, Université de Neuchâtel, rue Emile-Argand 11, CP 158, 2009 Neuchâtel.3 INRA Montfavet
Earthwormsareknowntoplayakeyroleonsoilecologicalprocessessuchasorganicmatterturnover,nutrientcyclingandsoilphysicalpropertiesengineering.Theyareacknowledgedasessentialtosoilfertility.However,theirroleonnumeroussoilphysicalpropertiesisstillpoorlydocumented.Theobjectivesofthepresentstudyweretotesttheeffectoftwoearth-wormecologicalcategories(Nicrodrilus nocturnusasanecic,Alollobophora ictericaasendogeicspecies,andbothasmixedpopu-lation with 80% weight of N nocturnus and 20% of A. icterica) on two different soils. Shrinkage analysis and ComputedTomographywereusedtoassesstheimpactofearthwormsonsoilporositiesandbulkvolume.Thestudywasperformedduring23weeksonmicrocosmsundercontrolledconditions(constanttemperatureandconstantsoilmatrixpotential).ThesoilswereasiltloamLuvisolandaloamyAnthrosol.Inaddition,beforetheintroductionofearthworms,allmicrocosmsweresetattwolevelsofsoilcompactionfurthercalledcompactedanduncompactedsoils.
Theobservedeffectsvariedwiththefactors ‘soil type’, ‘initialsoilbulkdensity’and ‘earthwormspecies’,andwiththeirinteractions. The bulk soil volumewasmodified by earthworms,with decompaction of the compactedmicrocosms andcompactionofthenoncompactedones.Thebulkvolumechangeswerethensplitintowormgalleryporesgenerated,andadditionaleffectonsmallerstructuralporesorplasmapores.Amodelofthechangesinducedby‘anecic’,‘endogeic’and‘mixed’was then formulated.The impactaredifferentaccording to the considered soil volume:bulk soilor soilmatrixwithoutporesduetogalleries,structuralporosityandplasmicporosity,respectively.Roughly,thedecompactioneffectofwormsisduetotheopeningofgalleriesatbulksoilscale,butthematrixiseithercompacted(caseofnotcompactedsoil)orunchanged(caseofcompactedsoil),andthecompactionofthematrixislargerwithendogeicspecies.Themixed-speciestreatmentinducedthesameeffectsasmonospecificonesinmostcases,andtheaneciceffectwasdominant,buttheendo-geiceffectwaseffectiveonmostconsideredsoilvolumes.Somecasesshowedanoppositionbetweenmixedactivitiesandsingletreatments,pointingoutparticularecologicalemergentproperties.
287
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.10
FloodAlp! Frequency and intensity of extreme floods in the Alps through the Holocene
GlurLukas1,WirthStefanieB.2,AnselmettiFlavioS.1,GilliAdrian2&HaugGeraldH.2
1Eawag, Swiss Federal Institut of Aquatic Science and Technology, CH-8600 Dübendorf ([email protected])2Geological Institute, ETH Zurich, Sonneggstr. 5, 8092 Zürich ([email protected])
FloodscausedbyextremeprecipitationeventsrepresentoneofthemajornaturalhazardsintheAlpinerealm.Newclimatemodelspointtothepossibilitythatfloodfrequencyandintensitiesincreaseasaresultoftheupcomingclimatechanges.Toscalethesepredictedchangesofextremeevents,knowledgeoftheirnaturalvarietyisrequired.
TheFloodAlp!projectaimstoreconstructthefrequencyandintensitiesofHolocenefloodeventsintheAlpsbyusinglakesedimentsasnaturalgeologicarchives,whichactasprehistoricrecordersofextremeevents.Lakebasinsrecordsucheventswithcharacteristicsedimentlayersthatcontrastsharplytotheregularbackgroundsediments.Thehighdischargevalueswithlargeamountsofsuspendedparticlestriggerturbiditicunderflowsthatfocusthedetritalparticlesinthedeepestareasofthebasins.
Atotaloftwelvelakesalonganorth-southtransectcoveringawiderangeinaltitudewillbeinvestigatedduringtheproject.Eachtargetedlakeisfirstinvestigatedbyahigh-resolution(3.5kHz)reflectionseismicsurvey,providinginformationonthesedimentthickness,seismicstratigraphy,sedimentdistributionandidealcoringlocations.Afterthisfirstevaluation,longsedimentcores(max.length16m)aretakeninthedeepestdepressionofthelakebasin.
Preconditionforestablishingthefloodrecordisagoodagemodel,whichisaccomplishedby14Cand137Cs/210Pbdating.Alsocrucialisthedifferentiationbetweenbackgroundsedimentationandeventlayersaswellasbetweenmass-movement-relatedandflood-relatedeventdeposits.Thischaracterisationofthesedimentaryfaciesisachievedbychemical,physicalandmine-ralogicalanalysesofthesedimentmaterial.
Firstresultsfromtwolakes(LakeLedro,I,andHintererSchwendisee,CH)showalreadythepotentialofthisapproach.High-resolutionreflectionseismicprofilesareabletoimagethegeometryofthesedimentfillinganddefinethespatialfocusoffloodlayeraccumulation.Furthermore,overhundredflood-relatedturbiditedepositsineachlakearesharplydistinguisha-blefromthebackgroundsediment.Theagemodelsofthetwosediment-successionsprovidethemeanstoconstructawell-datedchronologyofthesepotentialhazardouseventsthroughouttheHolocene.
10.11
Effects of atmospheric deposition of acid compounds and nitrogen on soil solution in Swiss forests
GrafPannatierElisabeth1,SchmittMaria1,ThimonierAnne1&WaldnerPeter1
1Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research WSL, Zürcherstrasse 111, CH-8903 Birmensdorf ([email protected])
IntheframeworkoftheLong-termForestEcosystemResearchLWF,thechemistryofatmosphericdepositionandsoilsoluti-onhavebeenanalysedfortnightlysince1998orlaterinsevenforestplotsinSwitzerland.Weaimtoassessthesoilresponsetotheinputsofacidcompoundsandnitrogen(N)sincetheymightalterthesoilfunctionsandrepresentpotentialstressfactorsforforestecosystems.Aciddepositionmightacceleratesoilacidification,leadingtotheleachingofnutrientsand/orthemobilizationoftoxicaluminumforsensitiveplants.IncreasedNconcentrationsinthesoilsolutionmayleadtonutrientimbalancesfortreesandchangesinthecompositionofgroundvegetation.Largenitrateleachingbelowtherootzonemightalsothreatenthequalityoftheground-andsurface-water.
Atmosphericdepositionofthemajorelementswasestimatedfromthroughfallandbulkdepositionmeasurementssince1995orlater.Soilsolutionhasbeenmeasuredsince1998orlateratfoursoildepths(belowlitterlayer,15cm,50cm,80cm).Themolarratioofbasenutrientcationstoaluminum(BC/Al)inthesoilsolutionwasdeterminedtoassesssoilacidification.ThisratioisusedasindicatorinmostcriticalloadmodelsinEurope,assumingBC/Alratiossmallerthan1mightcausead-verseeffectontreeroots.Nitrate leachingfluxleavingtherootzonewasestimatedfromsoilsolutionsamplesat80cmdepthusingnitrateconcentrationsandmodelledinfiltrationrates.
288Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces AcidatmosphericdepositionatthesevenLWFplotsrangedonaveragebetween-0.02and1.99keqha-1a-1withthelowestload
intheAlpsandthehighestloadinSouthernSwitzerland.Totalnitrogendepositionvariedbetween2.4kgha-1a-1intheAlpsto31kgha-1a-1intheSouthernSwitzerland.ThehighacidandnitrogenloadsinsouthernSwitzerlandcomepartlyfromtheemissionsoftheindustrialisedanddenselypopulatedPoBasin.
TheBC/Alratiosinthesoilsolutiondecreasedinmostplotsduringthetwofirstyearsoftheobservationperiod,whichmightbecausedbytheinstallationofthelysimeters.Afterthisperiod,BC/Alhasstabilizedinfiveplots,suggestingthatacidifica-tionhasproceededveryslowlyduringthelast10years.Attwosites,afurtherdecreaseinBC/Alwasobserved,suggestingafasteracidification.
Nitrateleachingrangingfromabout2and13kgNha-1a-1wasobservedatsitessubjectedtomoderatetohightotalNdeposi-tion(>10kgha-1a-1).TheC/Nratioofthesoilorganiclayer,togetherwiththepooloforganiccarboninthesoilandthehu-mustype,playedacriticalrole.
10.12
OSL-based chronology of the postglacial beach plain NE of Lake Neuchâtel on Swiss Plateau: Problems and possible solutions.
HeerAleksandra1,HajdasIrka2,SteffenDamian3,PreusserFrank3&VeitHeinz1
1InstituteofGeography,UniversityofBern,Hallerstrasse12,CH-3012Bern([email protected])2IonBeamPhysics,SwissFederalInstituteofTechnology(ETHZürich),Schafmattstr.20,CH-8093Zürich3InstitutfürGeologiel,UniversitätBern,Baltzerstrasse1+3,CH-3012Bern
Withtheaimofreconstructingthepostglaciallandscapeevolution(~17’000aBPtilltopresence),OSLhasbeenusedtodateeightprofilesfromafossilbeachplaincalledGrossesMoosontheSwissPlateau.Forfourprofilesradiocarbonagesderivedfromunderlyingandintercalatedorganichorizonshavealsobeencalculated.OSLmeasurementswereconductedonquartzsand-sizegrainsapplyingtheSAR-protocolafteridentifyingtheappropriatemeasurementconditionsinaseriesofexperi-ments(WintleandMurray2006).However,werecognisedproblemsduetotheintrinsicpropertiesoftheinvestigatedquartzaswellasduetothechangingenvironmentalconditionsduringtheexpectedburialtime.
Thequartzgrainsaregenerallydim.Hencethemeasurementsof2mmaliquotssufferfromsignificanterrorsduetothesignalintensity(Duller2007,Li2007).Formost2mmaliquotstheerrorsarehigherthen10%.Theconsequenceofacceptingforerrorshigherthen10%leadstoanoverestimationofthetrueage.Thedatingofveryyoungsedimentsalsosuffersfromthelimitationduetothedimsignal.Whenthequartzisdimandoneuses2mmaliquots,therewillbepreferentialselectionofaliquotsthatcontaingrainswithhigherdoses.PossiblecausesforgrainswithhighdosesareradioactivehotspotssuchaszircongrainsorK-feldsparsandthesehavebeenidentifiedinthesesamples.For2mmaliquotstheCW-OSLsignalamountoffastcomponentvariesbetween24%-66%.Thedimsignalisprobablyresponsibleforthoseerrors.Howeverthissignalmaycomefromquartzwithotherproperties.Ontheotherhand,whenusingbiggersizedaliquots(6or8mm)theresultsimpro-vesignificantly:thefastcomponentamountrisesuptomorethen80%oftheentireinitialsignalandtheerrorsstaylowerthen10%.I
nat–D
e-%D
e-error–plotshavebinconstructedtovisualisethiscoherenceandtochecktheindependencyofI
nat
and%De–errorasstatisticalvariablesinfluencingtheD
edetermination.ForselectedsamplesOSLsignalpropertiesand
resultingconsequencesfordatingwillbepresented.Alsothethicknessoftheoverlyingdepositchangedduringtheburialtime.EspeciallyforprofileISL6the14C-datahelpedindeterminingthedurationofthesucceedingdeposition.Otherwisetheageofthebasicpalaeochannelwouldhavebeenoverestimated.Groundwateroscillationshavebeenrecognizedwhilerecor-dinghydromorphicsoilfeatures.Thereforethereliabilityofthecurrentlyrecordedwatercontentforthewholeexpectedburialtimehasbeencheckedforeachsampleseparately.Nevertheless,consideringthoseproblemsareliableandconsistentchronologyforGrossesMoos,applyingOSL–and14C–data,hasbeendeveloped.
REFERENCESDuller,G.A.T.,(2007),Assessingtheerroronequivalentdoseestimatesderivedfromsinglealiquotregenerativedosemeasur
ements.Ancient,TL25:15-24.Li,B.,(2007),AnoteonestimatingtheerrorwhensubtractingbackgroundcountsfromweakOSLsignals.AncientTL25/1,9-
14.Wintle,A.G.,Murray,A.S.(2006).Areviewofquartzopticallystimulatedluminescencecharacteristicsandtheirrelevance
insingle-aliquotregenerationdatingprotocols.Rad.Measurements41,369-391.
289
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.13
Is the mineral phase responsible for stabilizing lignin in soils?
HeimAlexander1,HofmannAnett1,MiltnerAnja2,ChristensenBentT.3&SchmidtMichaelW.I.1
1 Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, CH-8057 Zürich ([email protected])2 Department Environmental Biotechnology, Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research - UFZ, Permoserstraße 15, D-04318 Leipzig3 Department of Agroecology and Environment, Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, University of Aarhus, DK-8830 Tjele
Ligninisthesecondmostabundantbiopolymerinhigherplants.Itsfateinthesoilisstilllargelyobscure.Ononehand,manylitterbagstudiespointtoaselectiveenrichmentofligninduringtheearlyphaseoflitterdecomposition.Ontheotherhand,compoundspecificisotopeanalysisoflignin-specificbiomarkershasshownthattheaverageturnovertimeoflignininsoilsissimilarorfasterthanthatofbulksoilorganiccarbon.Massbalancescombiningannualinput,soilligninstocksandturnoverratesinferredfromisotopedata,suggesttheexistenceofatleasttwokineticpools,oneofwhichdisappearsveryfast.Forbulksoilorganiccarbon(SOC),interactionsoforganicmatterwiththemineralphaseinsoilseemtobeanimportantsta-bilizationmechanism.However,verylittledataareavailableonthetypeofcompoundsthatinteractwiththemineralphase.
Ligninmonomersarebiomarkersofrelatively freshplant inputs.Theaimof thisstudy is totracethesebiomarkers intodifferentsoil fractions,answeringthefollowingquestions: (I)Whichsoil fractions (size,density)containmost lignin? (II)Doesthestabilityof ligninvarybetweenthese fractions? (III)Candifferences in lignincontentbetweensoil fractionsbeexplainedbypropertiesofthemineralphase(surfacearea,typeofminerals)?
Thestudywasconductedwitharablesoilfromalong-termexperimentthathadbeennaturally13C-labelledby18yearsofmaizecropping.Weidentifiedoldligninderivingfromthetimebeforemaizecroppingbycompound-specificisotopeanaly-sisoflignin-derivedphenolicbiomarkersandcompareditsdistributionwithinthesoiltotheinitialdistributioninanarchi-vedsoilsample.Alargeproportionofligninwasfoundinthecoarseheavyfraction,suggestinginclusionintomacroaggregates.However,iso-topedataclearlyindicatedthatlignininthisfractionwaslessstableinthelong-termthanlignininlightfractionsorinsilt-sizeaggregates.Thelignin/SOCratioofthelattertwofractionsindicatesthattheycontainlessdecomposedorganicmatter.
Wesuggest that the followingmechanismsmaycontrol stabilityof lignin inarablesoils: (1)Some lignin-containingcellstructures(e.g.thickcellwalls)seemtobeindeedrecalcitrantenoughtopersistfordecadesevenunderintensivecropping.Duetointensivecroppingbeforetheisotopiclabelingstarted,thelightfractionsarealreadyenrichedintheserecalcitrantstructures,andthereforeshowverylittledegradationduringtheobservationperiod.(2)Stablesilt-sizeaggregatesmaypre-servesmallfragmentsofrelativelyundecomposedplantresidues.(3)Macroaggregates,bycontrast,turnovermorerapidly,sothatinclusionintomacroaggregatesdoesnotstabilizeligninaslongastheothermechanisms.
10.14
Pyrogenic carbon solubility in the soils: quantitative and qualitative approaches
HengartnerPascal1,AbivenSamuel1
1Soil Science and Biogeography, Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, CH-8057 Zürich ([email protected])
Thepyrogeniccarbon(PyC)correspondstothebiomassresiduesaftertheirincompletecombustion,mainlybywildfires.Untilrecentstudies,thisparticularkindofsoilorganicmatterwasconsideredaspassive,recalcitrantandsostableinthesoils.
Recently,differentauthorshighlighted significantbioticdegradation (BaldockandSmernik,2002;Hammeret al., 2004)and/orabioticdegradation(forexampleSmithandChughtai,1996)ofthesecompounds.Moreover,specificPyCbiomarkerswerefoundinsurfaceandmarinewatersandinsediments(Hockadayetal.,2006).ThesetwofindingsmightindicatethatafractionofthisPyCistranslocatedthoughthesoil.
290Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces However,thequantityandthecharacteristicsofthisPyCfractionaswellasthemechanismsoftheirtransportsintheenvi-
ronmentremainlargelyunknown.Inthisstudy,weproposetoestimatethequantityandthefeaturesofthesolubleandcolloidalfractionofPyC.
ThePyCusedinthisstudyistheinternationalstandardasdefinedbytheblackcarbonsteeringcommittee:CastaneasativaMill.Wood,pryrolisedat450°Cduring16hunderaN
2stream.Thecharwasthengrounded(<1mm).
Thewater-extractiblefractionwasfirstestimatedinabatchexperimentinthelab.Thecharwasshakeindeionisedwaterattherateof160gChar.l-1andthefractionsbelow0.45µm(solublefraction)andbelow5µm(colloidalfraction)werecollectedby filtration.We repeated this batch designwith 10 years old char pieces that we collected from a fire experiment inTessin.Then,weappliedthestandardchartoacambisolinthefield(LaegernHills,Aargau,CH)andwecollectedregularlythesoilsolutionwithsuctionplates.
ThePyCquantityandcharacteristicswereanalysedusingmassbalance,CandNcontentandtheBenzenePolyCarboxylicAcidsmethod(BPCA,Browdowski,2005).Thismethodconsistsinanaciddigestionofaromaticcompounds,releasingpoly-carboxylicacidswhichareconsideredasspecificPyCbiomarkers.Inthisstudy,weadaptedthemethodtosmallpyrogeniccompounds.Inthebatchexperiment,thesolublefractionrepresented1permiloftheinitialcharmass(Fig.1).Thefractiononlycon-tained38%C(comparedto66%fortheinitialchar)and0.66%N(comparedto0.07%intheinitialchar),indicatingthatthesolublefractioncontainsmuchothercompoundsthanaromaticPyCmoieties.ThespecificPyCbiomarkerswereonlyrepresenting1%ofthedissolvedCcontent.
0.1
1
10
100
1000
10000
100000
1000000
10000000
100000000
Initial Char Dissolved BC Biomarkers
Mass [ug]
Figure1.Massrecoveryinthedissolvedfraction(dissolvedBC)andasspecificPyCbiomarkers(Biomarkers)from25gofstandardchar.
Logarithmicscale.
REFERENCESBaldock,J.A.,andR. J.Smernik.2002:ChemicalcompositionandbioavailabilityofthermallyalteredPinusresinosa (Red
pine)wood.OrganicGeochemistry,33,1093-1109.Brodowski, S. 2005.Origin, function, and reactivityofblack carbon in thearable soil environment. PhDThesis,Bonner
BodenkundlicheAbhandlungen,pp.183.Hamer, U., B.Marschner, S. Brodowski, andW. Amelung. 2004. Interactive priming of black carbon and glucose
mineralization,OrganicGeochemistry,35,823-830.Hammes,K.,Smernik,R.J.,Skjemstad, J.O.,Vogt,U.F.,Schmidt,M.W.I.2006:Synthesisandcharacterisationof laboratory-
charred grass straw(Oryza sativa) and chestnutwood(Castanea sativa) as referencematerials for black carbonquantification.OrganicGeochemistry,37,1629-1633.
Hockaday,W.C.,A.M.Grannas,S.Kim,andP.G.Hatcher,2006:Directmolecularevidenceforthedegradationandmobilityof black carbon in soils fromultrahigh-resolutionmass spectral analysis of dissolved organicmatter froma fire-impactedforestsoil,OrganicGeochemistry,37,501–510.
Smith,D.M.,&A.R.Chughtai. 1996:Reactionkinetics of ozone at low concentrationswithn-hexane soot, Journal ofGeophysicalRessources,101,19,607–19,620.
291
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.15
Quantifying rates of surface denudation at the eastern Altiplano margin, La Paz region, Bolivia
K.Hippe1,F.Kober2,G.Zeilinger3,S.Ivy-Ochs4,P.W.Kubik4,C.Schlüchter5&R.Wieler1
1 Isotope Geology and Mineral Resources, ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich, Switzerland ([email protected])2 Institute of Geology, ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich, Switzerland3 Institute of Geology, Univ. Potsdam, D-14476 Golm, Germany4 Laboratory of Ion Beam Physics, ETH Zürich, CH-8093 Zürich, Switzerland5 Institute of Geological Sciences, University of Bern, CH-3012 Bern, Switzerland
TheBolivianAltiplano isa large, flatplateau framedby thehighpeaksof theWesternandEasternCordillera.Along itseasternmargintheRioLaPazhascutdeeplyacrosstheCordilleraforminganeastward-drainingriversystemthatstandsinsharp morphological contrast to the internally drained Altiplano. Landscape morphology, relief and surface processeschangefundamentallyacrossthedrainagedivide.AfeedbackmechanismbetweenerosionalunloadingbyfocussedincisionandflexuralreboundhasbeenproposedfortheRioLaPazdrainagesystem(Zeilinger&Schlunegger2007),buttheeffectofcrustalbendingontheadjacentAltiplanohasnotyetbeenevaluated.WhiledenudationratesareknownfortheRioLaPazsystem(Zeilingeretal.2009)andtheEasternCordillera(Safranetal.2005),wehavequantifiedratesofdenudationontheAltiplanoside.ForcatchmentsborderingtheRioLaPazdrainagedividewehavedeterminedcatchmentwidedenudationratesbasedoncosmogenic10Beinriversediments.Forallcatchmentsthelandscapeisflatwithsmoothhillslopes;precipita-tionislowwithastronginterannualvariability.
CosmogenicallydetermineddenudationratesintheRioLaPazsystemare0.1-0.6mm/yr(Zeilingeretal.2009).PreliminarydenudationratesfortheAltiplanoareonetotwoordersofmagnitudelowerbetween0.002and0.029mm/yr,withaninte-grationtimeof24-230ky.Thisisinagreementwithmodernsedimentyieldrates(Guyotetal.1992)althoughtheyintegrateoveronlyonetofiveyears.FortheAltiplano,denudationratesshownoclearcorrelationwithmorphometriccatchmentparameters,butratherseemtobeinfluencedbylithology(i.a.glacialdeposits)andpossiblyalsoanthropogenicprocesses.
REFERENCESGuyot, J.L.,Wasson, J.G.,Quintanilla, J.&Calle,H.1992:Dissolvedmatterandsuspendedsediment loads insome inflow
riversandintheRioDesaguadero.In:LakeTiticaca(Ed.byDejoux,C.&Iltis,A.),113-119.Safran,E.B.,Biermann,P.R.,Aalto,R.,Dunne,T.,Whipple,K.X.&Caffee,M.2005:Erosionratesdrivenbychannelnetwork
incisionintheBolivianAndes.EarthSurf.Process.Landforms30,1007-1024.Zeilinger,G.,Kober,F.,Strecker,M.,Ivy-Ochs,S.,Kubik,P.W.&Hippe,K.2009:ErosionratesintheRioLaPazdrainagebasin:
evidenceforspatiallyandtemporallyvariableerosionprocesses.Geophys.Res.Abstracts,EGUGeneralAssembly2009.Zeilinger,G.&Schlunegger, F. 2007: Possible flexural accomodationon the easternedgeof theAltiplano in relation to
focussederosionintheRioLaPazdrainagesystem.TerraNova19,373-380.
292Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.16
The shape versus the processes of a landform – the Hörnli region, NE-Switzerland
Kober,F.1,Abbühl,L.2,Dürst,M.2,Ivy-Ochs,S.3,Schlunegger,F.2,Kubik,P.W.4
1Geological Institute, ETH Zürich, CH-8092 Zürich ([email protected])2 University of Bern, Baltzerstrasse 1+3, CH-3012 Bern3Ion Beam Physics, Particle Physics, ETH Zürich, CH-8093 Zürich and Department of Geography, University of Zürich, CH-8057 Zürich4Ion Beam Physics, Particle Physics, ETH Zürich, CH-8093 Zürich
AlthoughthelandscapeoftheHörnliregioninNE-Switzerlandwould,atfirstglance,implythatlandscapeprocessesandprocessratesmustbedifferentbetweenthefluviallyandglaciallyoverprintedlandformparts–thereisnostrongevidenceforthisargumentingeomorphicparametersandspatiallyaveragedcatchmentwidedenudationratesobtainedwithcosmo-genic 10Be.While glacially overprinted catchments tend tohave lower average slopes andare at lowermeanelevations,otherparametersfailtoshowcorrelations.Slope-areaplotssuggestpartialrejuvenationforglacialoverprintedcatchments,i.e.,incisionintoaccumulationplanesinthelowerrivercourses.Thisisalsoinaccordancewithobservedknickpointswhicharebeyondthecommonlylithologicallycontrolledchannelsteps(Nagelfluhbanks)thatareobservedeverywhere.Spatiallyaveragedcatchmentwidedenudationratesvarybetween30-2000mm/kywithatendencytowardslowervaluesincatchmentswithglacialoverprint,thoughnotalways.
Itissuggestedthatglaciallyoverprintedcatchmentswithsmoothertopographiesandaccumulatedglacialdepositsintheirlowerreachesprotectthelandscapeagainstfastererosionrates.Anotheroptionwouldbethatglaciallysourcedsedimentsofthecatchmentwithrelativelyhighercosmogenicnuclideconcentrationscontrolthelowerdenudationrates.Incontrast,thefluvialcatchments,withstepperslopesandexposedathigherelevationsarecontrolledbymoreactiveprocesses,suchasshallowlandsliding,rockfalls,debrisflowsandlittlesoildevelopmentwouldpromoteshorterresidencetimeinthecatch-ment,hencehigherdenudationrates.
Assuchitissuggested,thattheremnantsoftheglacialoverprinting,i.e.,sculpturinganddeposition.
10.17
Earthworm, mycorrhiza and root interactions: effects on soil phosphorus nutrient status and soil structureKohler-MilleretRoxane1,LeBayonClaire1,BoivinPascal2&GobatJean-Michel1
1Laboratory Soil & Vegetation, Institute of Biology, Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected]) 2Laboratory of Soils and Substrates, HEPIA, Route de Pressinge 150, CH-1254 Jussy Bioticinteractionsinsoilsareknowntoinfluencethebelowgroundandabovegroundsystembyaffectingsoilfertility,i.e.itsnutrientstatusandsoilstructure.Earthworms,arbuscularmycorrhizafungi (AMF)androotsareespeciallyimportantcomponentsofthebelowgroundsystem.WhileAMF-plantsymbiosisisessentialforplantnutrition,theyalsomodifysoilstructureinmechanicalandchemicalways(soilparticlesenmeshmentintobiggeraggregatesandglomalinsecretionforAMF).Earthworms,asecosystemengineers,areknowntoinfluencesoilpropertiesandplantproduction(soilstructureandporositymodificationbyburial and feeding-castingactivities, formationof theorgano-mineral complex,microorganismdispersionoringestion).However,littleisknownabouttheeffectsofearthwormsandAMFonplantgrowthorsoilchemicalandphysicalproperties.Anexperimentalapproachwasthereforedesignedinordertoassessseparatelyorincombinationthe effects of earthworms (Allolobophora chlorotica, Savigny),AMF (Glomus intraradices, SchenkandSmith), andplant roots(Allium porrum,L.)oni)soilstructure,ii)availabilityofnutrients(mainlyphosphorus,P)inthebulksoilaswellasinbothrhizosphereanddrilosphere.
293
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
sTheresultspointoutthatplantrootsimprovedsoilstabilityatthelevelofmacroaggregates(>250µm)anddecreasedthebulksoildensity(asrevealedbyshrinkageanalysis),whereasearthwormsdecreasedsoilstabilityandthebulksoilvolume.AMFhadnoeffectonsoilstructurestabilitybutincreasedPtransferfromthesoiltotheplantandconsequentlyplantbio-mass.EarthwormhadnodirectinfluenceonPuptake,butdrilospheresoilcontainedahigheramountofavailableforms.
ThisstudyshowsthatunderPlimitation,AMFenhanceplantgrowthviaavailablephosphorousacquisition.Inourexperi-ment,earthwormshavenodirecteffectonplantgrowthbutdrilospheresoilmayserveasanutrientpoolthatcanbelatermobilized.Thisexperimenthighlightstheimportanceofaholisticapproachmeasuringphysical,chemicalandbiologicalsoilparameterswhenstudyingsoilorganisminteractionsandtheirinfluenceonplantperformance.
10.18
Entwicklung und Anwendung einer Grobscreening-Methode zur Untersuchung des Abbauzustandes von Moorböden am Beispiel des Lobsigensees
MatileLuzius,AchermannMarco&KrebsRolf
ZHAW, Institut Umwelt und Natürliche Ressourcen, Grüntal, CH- 8820 Wädenswil ([email protected])
AmUferdesLobsigensees(BE)befindetsichineinemehemaligenNiedermoordieFundstelleeinerneolithischenSiedlung.SeitdasMoorimZusammenhangmitderlandwirtschaftlichenNutzungentwässertwird,findetderTorfabbaustatt.VomAbbau organischer Substanz ist dabei auch ein wesentlicher Teil der archäologischen Fundstelle betroffen. So hat einVergleichderGrabungen von1953und2005gezeigt, dass der Erhaltungsgradder archäologischen Funde sehr stark ab-nahm.
DadietorfabbauendenSchrumpfungs-undMineralisationsprozessediephysikalischenEigenschaftendesBodensverändern,wurdeuntersucht,obsichdurchdieMessungdesEindringwiderstandesgrobeAussagenüberdenAbbauzustanddesorga-nischenBodensunddamitauchderFundstellemachenlassen.UmnebendemAbbauzustandauchdieAbbaurateabzuschät-zen,wurdenVerrottungsversuchemitBaumwolltücherndurchgeführt.
Die mit einem dynamischen Rammpenetrometer (PANDA-Sonde) gemessenen Eindringwiderstände ergaben eine guteKorrelationmitbodenphysikalischenParameternwiederLagerungsdichte,mitdemGehaltorganischerSubstanzundbestä-tigtendenBefundderProfilansprache.
DurchdieMessungdesEindringwiderstandeskönnensomitdichtere(mineralische/antorfige)undlockerereSchichten(Torf)imBodenprofil lokalisiertundinZusammenhangzumAbbauzustandamuntersuchtenStandortgebrachtwerden.DieseeinfacheMethodewürdeeinegrobeÜbersichtüberdasStadiumderMoorsackungder jeweiligenorganischenBöden imTiefenprofil erlauben und damit Rückschlüsse auf den Zustand der betroffenen Fundstellen ermöglichen. DasScreeningverfahrenwäredamiteineeffizienteMethodezurPriorisierunggefährdeterFundstellen.
294Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.19
INITIAL STAGES OF SOIL AND CLAY MINERALS FORMATION IN THE MORTERATSCH PROGLACIAL AREA (UPPER ENGADINE, SWITZERLAND)
ChristianMavris11,MarkusEgli1,MichaelPlötze2,JoelBlum3,WilfredHaeberli1
1Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Zurich, 8057, Switzerland 1([email protected])2ETH Zurich, Institute for Geotechnical Engineering, Zurich, 8093, Switzerland3Dept. of Geological Sciences, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA
InvestigationsinAlpinesoilsindicatethatmineralweatheringismuchfasterin‘young’soils(<1000yr)thanin‘old’soils(~10000yr).However,littleisknownabouttheinitialstagesofweatheringandsoilformation,i.e.duringthefirstdecadesofsoilgenesis.Inthisstudyweinvestigatedrock-formingmineralsweatheringatveryearlystagesofsoilformation.DuetothecontinuousretreatoftheMorteratschglacier(UpperEngadine,SwissAlps),theproglacialareaoffersafulltimesequencefrom0to150yroldsurfaces.Alowslopeandtheabsenceofglacierwhichmighthaveinterruptedsoilformationprocesses,contributedtothechoiceoftheMorteratschproglacialvalleyforthiscasestudy.Theareaiswelldocumentedregardingvegetationandsoils.ThetectonicunitistheBernina-crystalline,whichismainlyconstitutedofgranitoidrocks.Consequently,theglacialtillhasanacidiccharacter.Mineralogicalmeasurementswerecarriedoutonthebulksoilfraction(<2mm)usingXRDandDRIFTforqualitativeandquantitativephaseanalysis.Inaddition,chemicalanalysesofthestreamwaterfromthemainchanneland,tributariesandofrainwaterwereperformedwithaspecialfocusonCa/SrandSrisotoperatios(87Sr/86Sr).Furthermore, the accumulation of organicmatterwithin the time sequence and physical soil propertieswere assessed.Decreasinggrainsizewithtimeshowsactivephysicalweatheringprocesses.Soilorganicmatterhasbeenaccumulateddur-ing150yratveryhighrates.Specialemphasishasbeengiventochemicalweatheringandtotheformationandtransforma-tionmechanismsofminerals.Of special interestwerebiotite, chlorite, epidote,plagioclase and calcite. Biotitehasbeencontinuouslytransformedintoillite-likecomponents.Within150years,theconcentrationofepidotesignificantlydecreased.ThehighCa/Sraswellas87Sr/86SrratiosinthestreamandspringwatersconfirmedthatCabearingmineralsareweatheringandtransformingatveryhighratesintheproglacialarea.Alsoincryic,ice-freeenvironments,chemicalweatheringratesarehighleadingtotheformationandtransformationofminerals.Disseminatedcalciteingranitoidrocks,notconfinedtosedimentarycarbonaterocks,alsoplaysaroleinsubglacialenvironments.Itis,however,notknownforhowlongsuchaninfluence is significantandmeasurable.ThehighCa/NaandCa/Srratio inthestreamandtributarywatersshowedthatcalcitecontributestothesupplyofsolubleCa,althoughtheionactivityproductcalculationsclearlydemonstratedthatthewaterswereundersaturatedwithrespecttothismineral.
Fig.1.LocationoftheMorteratschproglacialarea (Engadine,SESwitzerland).M= investigationarea (seeFig.2),A=proglacialarea,B=
Morteratschglacier.
295
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
sREFERENCESBlumJ.D.,KlaueA.,NezatC.A.,DriscollC.T.,JohnsonC.E.,SiccamaT.G.,EagarC.,FaheyT.j.,LikensG.E.2002:Mycorrhizal
weatheringofapatiteasanimportantcalciumsourceinbase-poorforestecosystems.Nature,417,729-731Büchi H. 1994: Der variskische Magmatismus in der östlichen Bernina (Graubünden, Schweiz). Schweizerische
MineralogischeundPetrographischeMitteilungen,74,359-371BurgaC.1999:VegetationdevelopmentontheglacierforefieldMorteratsch(Switzerland).AppliedVegetationScience,2,17-24EgliM.,MirabellaA.,FitzeP.2003:FormationratesofsmectitesderivedfromtwoHolocenechronosequencesintheSwiss
Alps.Geoderma,117,81-98MavrisC.,EgliM.,PlötzeM.,BlumJ.D.,MirabellaA.,GiaccaiD.,HaeberliW.:Initialstagesofweatheringanssoilformation
intheMorteratschproglacialarea(UpperEngadine,Switzerland).Geoderma(submitted)
10.20
Regeneration of mechanically loaded soils under skid lanes by plantation of Alnus glutinosa
MeyerChristine1,LüscherPeter1,SchulinRainer2
1 Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research (WSL), Zürcherstrasse 111, CH-8903 Birmensdorf ([email protected])2Institute of Terrestrial Ecosystems (ITES), Universitätstrasse 22, CH-8092 Zürich
Afterstorm"Lothar"in1999serioussoildamagesresultedfromclearanceworkswithheavytimbermachineryinmanySwissforests.Inordertoinvestigatehowtheregenerationofcompactedsoilcouldbeenhanced,blackalder(Alnus glutinosa)seed-lingsandwillows(Fig.1)wereplantedin2003intracksofexperimentalskidlanesatthreeselectedforestsitesaffectedbystorm“Lothar”(Habsburg,MessenandBrüttelen).Asanadditionaltreatment,compostwasaddedtosomeoftheplantingsites.
This yearwe started to investigate rootdevelopmentand regenerationof soil structureat theHabsburg site, comparingplantedplotswithandwithoutcompostapplicationwithstockedreferencesites.Nexttoselectedtreesweexcavatedaseriesofsoilprofiles(0.8mdepth,1.5mwidth),thefirstat0.6mdistancetothestem,thesecondat40cmdistanceandthethirdat20cmdistance,andthelastdirectlyatthestembase.Oneachprofile,werecordedthenumbersoffineandmainroots,soilaggregatestructureandhydromorphicsoilfeatures.Furthermore,wetooksoilsampleswithcylinders(1000ccand100cc)foranalysisofbulkdensity,precompactionstress,soilwatercontentandairconductance.
Themorphologicalevidenceindicatedthatsoilstructurehadconsiderablydevelopedoverthe6yearsafterthealderswereplanted.Thealdersplantedincompactedsoilhaddevelopedrootsextendingdownto80cmdepthandmore,butalsoshow-inguntypicalmorphologicalfeaturessuchasflattenedroots.Soilaggregationwasenhancedinpresenceoftrees,andsoilhydromorphyreducedincomparisontocontrolplotswherenotreeshadbeenplanted.Intreatmentswithcompostapplica-tionthenumbersofrootsandtheirdryweightswerehighestandsoilaggregationwasenhancedmostdistinctly.
Nextstepswillbetheanalysisofsoilphysical,mechanicalandchemicalparameters.Incombinationwithbiologicalparam-eterswewillusethisinformationtoidentifythegoverningprocessesandlimitingfactorsofsoilstructureregeneration,toevaluatetheefficiencyoftheplantationandcomposttreatmentsandtoderiveestimatesforthetimerequiredforfullre-covery.
296Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces
Figure1.SchematicillustrationoftheexperimentaldesignatthestudysiteHabsburg(Kt.Aargau).
Photograph1.Blackalders(left)andwillows(right)plantedinthetracksofaskidlane.
297
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.21
Characterization of biochar and their impact on soil fertility
BarbaraPichler1,Hans-PeterSchmidt2,PascalBoivin3&SamuelAbiven1
1Geographisches Institut Universität Zürich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, CH-8057 Zürich([email protected], [email protected])2Delinat-Institut, Ancienne Eglise 9, CH-1974 Arbaz ([email protected])3Laboratoire sols et substrats, Haute école du paysage, d’ingénierie et d’architecture de Genève, Rte de Presinge 150, CH-1254 Jussy ([email protected])
Biocharapplicationtothesoilhasbeenproposedrecentlyasatooltoimprovesoilfertilityaswellastomitigateclimatechanges.Biocharisproducedbythecombustionofbiomassunderoxygenlimitedconditions.Theproductionofbiocharaswellastheirusagefollowsthreemainaims:
• Thegasproducedduringthecombustioncanbeusedforenergy(Syngas).• Thebiocharwilldecomposeveryslowlyintothesoilandsomightstabilisecarbononthelongterm.• AccordingtostudiesinAmazonianforest,thebiocharmightalsoimprovesoilfertility(nutrientsandwaterretention).
Inthisstudy,weproposetoinvestigatetheeffectofbiocharonwaterretention.
Duetoitporousstructure,thebiocharhasalargespecificsurfaceareaandmightenhanceforexamplewaterretention,soilaerationandtheadsorptionofnutrientsandpesticides,thuslimitingtheleachingintothegroundwater.
InMarch2008DelinatAGstartedafieldstudyonSOCdepletedvineyardsoilsinValais(CH).10tbiocharperhectarhasbeenincorporatedtogetherwithcompostbetweenthegraperowstoasoildepthof10cm.Thecomposthasbeenappliedwith theaimtoactivate thebiocharwithorganicmatter.Theapplicationofbiocharandcompostwasperformedtogetherwiththesowingoflegumes,inordertopreventerosionandserveasaN-source.Directlyunderthegraperowsbiocharhasjustbeenappliedsuperficially.
Becauseofthepoorlyweathered,shallowsoils,disturbedsoilsampleshasbeentakenonlyfromtheupper20cmofthere-searchpatchmentionedaboveaswellasfromfurtherreferencepatches,including:
• Barevineyardsoilwithoutadditionofbiocharandcompostandwithoutcoverageoflegumes.• Vineyardsoilmixedwithcompostandcoveredwithlegumes.
Largerpiecesofbiocharparticles,whichhavebeenfoundunderthevineplantsontothesoilsurfacealsohavebeencollectedandanalysed.Thesoilsofthedifferentpatchesweresampledatthesamealtitude.
Thewaterretentioninsoilwasmeasuredondisturbedsamplesofthefinefraction,followingtheprocedureofBoivinetal.,2009:Thedriedsoilsamplesweresaturatedtoawaterpotentialof-10hPa.Thesaturatedvolumewasmeasuredusingtheplasticbagmethod.Thesampleswerethendriedinashrinkageapparatusandtheirvolumewasmeasuredagain.Attheendashrinkagecurveofthefineearthcouldbecalculatedtoidentifythepore-dependentwater-storagecapacityofthesoil.Thebiochar(pyrogeniccarbon)contentwasestimatedusingtheBPCAmethod(Brodowskietal.,2005).Thismethodconsistsinanacidoxidationanddeterminationofbenzenepolycarboxylicacidsbychromatography.WealsodeterminedchangesinsoilorganicmatterqualityusingDiffuseReflectanceInfraredFourierTransformationspectrometry.Todeterminethereac-tivesurfacearea,BETspecificsurfaceareawasmeasuredusingagasabsorber.
FirstresultsofthefieldstudywillbepresentedontheSwissGeoscienceMeeting2009.
REFERENCESBoivin, P., Schäffer,B.&Sturny,W.2009:Quantification the relationshipbetween soil organic carbonand soilphysical
propertiesusingshrinkagemodelling,EuropeanJournalofSoilScience,60,265-275.Brodowski,S.,Rodionov,A.,Haumaier,L.,Glaser,B.&Amelung,W.2005:Revisedblackcarbonassessmentusingbenzene
polycarboxylicacids,OrganicGeochemistry,36,1299-1310.
298Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.22
Rock-Eval Pyrolysis to determine stable organic Matter in irrigated sandy Soils from Palm Orchards
PrudatBrice1,AdatteThierry2,HassounaMohammad2,GobatJean-Michel1,VerrecchiaEric2
1Laboratoire Sol & Végétation, Université de Neuchâtel, Rue Emile-Argand 11, CH-2009 Neuchâtel ([email protected])2Laboratoire des Biogéosciences, Université de Lausanne, Anthropole, CH-1015 Lausanne
OveruseofwaterresourcesisoneofthemostimportantproblemsinsouthTunisia.Inthisarea,palmorchardshavethehighestwaterconsumption.Likeinmostsoils,soilorganicmatter(SOM)inthisirrigatedagro-systemhasanimportantroleinwaterefficiency,soilfertilityandcarbonstorage.Consequently,understandingthewayinwhichorganicmatter(OM)isintegratedinsandysoilscouldbeanapproachtopromotesustainableagriculture.TheaimofthisstudyistocharacterizestableSOMpoolsinsandysoils.Palmorchardsconstituteapertinentexperimentalexamplebecausecultivatorsincorporateorganicmaterials–mainlymanure–intothesoileveryfewyears.Therefore,stu-dyingSOMincultivatedareasofdifferentagesisinterestingtoestimatethestableOMpoolspresentinthesesaltyirrigatedsandysoils.Surfacelayersamples(0-20cm)aresievedintodifferentaggregatefractionsinordertoanalyseOM.Then,SOMisextractedfromallaggregatefractionsaswellasbulksoil,usingadoubleextractionprocedure-using0.1MNaOHbeforeandaftertreatmentwith0.1MHCl-followedbyanextractionontheresidualfractionwithasolutionofDMSO/H
2SO
4.Finally,diffe-
rent analytical techniquesareused to characterize (i) chemical extracts (FourierTransform InfraRed spectroscopy (FTIR),Rock-Evalpyrolysis(RE),C/Nratio),(ii)theaggregatefractions(REpyrolysis,C/Nratio)and(iii)thebulksoil(REpyrolysis,C/Nratio).CharacteristicsofpeaksobtainedusingREpyrolysis,coupledwithFTIRspectrawillgive informationonthestructureoforganicmoleculespresentinthesoils.TheresultsobtainedcouldhelptounderstandtheintegrationofOMinsandysoils.Understanding these processes would help to optimize the organic amendment quantities, qualities, and frequencies.Therefore,itwouldpromoteanincreaseinthefarmers’incomesandthereductionofwaterlossesinpalmorchards.
10.23
Morphology and recent history of the Rhone River Delta in Lake Geneva (Switzerland and France)
SastreVincent1,LoizeauJean-Luc1,GreinertJens2,3,NaudtsLieven2,ArpagausPhilippe1,AnselmettiFlavio4&WildiWalter1
1 Institut F.-A. Forel, Université de Genève, 10, route de Suisse, CP 146, CH-1290 Versoix, Switzerland1 . Corresponding author: [email protected] Renard Centre of Marine Geology, Department of Geology and Soil Science Ghent University, Krijgslaan 281 s.8 B-9000 Gent, Belgium3 New affiliation: Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ), P.O. Box 59, 1790 AB, Den Burg (Texel), The Netherlands4 Swiss Federal Institute of Aquatic Science & Technology (Eawag), Department of Surface Waters, Sedimentology Group, Überlandstrasse 133, CH-8600 Dübendorf, Switzerland
ThecurrenttopographicmapsoftheRhoneDelta-andofLakeGenevaingeneral-aremainlybasedonhydrographicdatathatwereacquiredduringthetimeofF.-A.Forelattheendofthe19thcentury.Inthispaperwepresentresultsofanewbathymetricsurvey,basedonsingle-andmultibeamechosounderdata.Thenewdata,presentedasadigitalterrainmodel,showawell-structuredlakebottommorphology,reflectingdepositionalanderosionalprocessesthatshapethelakefloor.Asamajorgeomorphologicelement,thesub-aquaticRhoneDeltaextendsfromthecoastalplatformtothedepositionalfansofthecentralplainofthelakeat310mdepth.Theplatformedgeofthedeltaiscutby9canyons.Thesearesinuous(“mean-dering”)channelsformedbyerosionalanddepositionalprocesses,asindicatedbythesteeperosionalcanyonwallsandthedepositionalleveesonthecanyonshoulders.Thecanyonbottomsandsomeslopeareasarewrinkledbyripplesordune-likemorphologies.MorphologiesoftheunderlyingbedrockandsmalllocalriverdeltasarelocatedalongthelateralslopesofLakeGeneva.Basedonhistoricalmaps,therecenthistoryoftheRhoneRiverconnectiontothesub-aquaticdeltaandthecanyonsisre-
299
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
sconstructed.Thetransitionfromthreetotworiverbranchesdatesto1830–1840,whentheriverbranchtotheLeBouveretlakebaywascut.ThetransitionfromtwotooneriverbranchcorrespondstotheachievementofthecorrectionanddamconstructionworkonthemodernRhoneRiverchannelbetween1870and1880.
REFERENCEMallet,H.1781:Genève.CoteBPU3E01/4.
Figure1.TopographicmodeloftheRhoneRiverDeltainLakeGeneva,establishedbymulti-beamandsingle-beamtechniques.
Figure2:MapofthelowerRhonevalleyandtheterrestrialpartoftheRhoneDeltabyMallet(1781),comparedwithmoderncoastlineand
canyons.EF:EauFroide,FR:formerbedofRhoneRiverflowingintothebayofLeBouveret,RR:mainRhoneRiverBed,VR:VieuxRhone.
300Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.24
Geomorphological drivers of Holocene environmental change in Mongolia
WolfgangSchwanghart1,ManfredFrechen2,RiccardoKlinger3&BrigittaSchütt3
1Department of Environmental Sciences, Physical Geography and Environmental Change, Klingelbergstr. 27, CH-4056 Basel ([email protected])2Leibniz Institute for Applied Geosciences, Stilleweg 2, Section S3, Geochronology and Isotope Hydrology, D-30655 Hannover, Germany3Department of Earth Sciences, Geographic Institute, Freie Universität Berlin, Malteserstr. 74-100, D-12249 Berlin, Germany
Drylandsareamajorfocusofpalaeoclimatologicalandpalaeoenvironmentalresearchsincethesensitivityofaridandsemi-aridregionstoclimatechangeaffectsalargeportionoftheworld’spopulation.OneofthemostexcitingregionsintheworldisCentralAsia.Itssituationinthetriangleofthewesterlies,theIndianandSoutheastAsianMonsoonmadeittheplayingfieldoftheinteractionsofthesewindsystems(Fig.1)duringtheQuaternaryandbeyond.In this studywe investigate theHoloceneenvironmental evolutionof theUgiiNuurbasin in theOrkhonValley, centralMongolia,inordertogainabetterunderstandingoftheclimateandlandscapedynamicsofthestepperegioninCentralAsia.Weassessedterrestrialandlakesedimentsusingmineralogical,geochemicalandstatistical techniquesandprovideabsolutechronologiesbyradiocarbonandinfra-redstimulatedluminescencedatings.
WeprovideaHolocenechronologyofenvironmentalchangesanddiscussthesefindingswithregardtoprehistoricandhi-storichumanactivity,dominantgeomorphologicalprocessesgoverninglandscapeevolution,andtheregionalenvironmen-talcontext(Schwanghartetal.2009).Mostprominently,loessdepositionwasintensifiedduringthelateHolocene.Whilethecausesofwindblowndustneedtobeanalyzedinaregionalcontext,itshydrologicalandgeomorphologicalimplicationsareparticularlystrongatthelocalscale.Thesetemporalandspatialinteractionsbetweenaeolianandfluvialprocessesshouldbeconsideredwhenreconstructingpastenvironments inregionspronetoloessdepositionsincetheystronglyaffectthearchivesthatweanalyze.
Fig.1:Summerwindsystems,meanjulyprecipitationandpresent-daymonsoonlimitafterHerzschuh(2006).Precipitationdataisob-
tainedfromtheGLOBALSODdatabase(1994-2004).ReliefshadingisbasedonGTOPO30.
REFERENCESSchwanghart,W., Frechen,M., Kuhn,N.J.& Schütt, B. 2009:Holocene environmental changes in theUgiiNuurbasin,
Mongolia.Palaeogeography,Palaeoclimatology,Palaeoecology,279,160-171.Herzschuh,U.2006:Palaeo-moistureevolutioninmonsoonalCentralAsiaduringthelast50,000years.QuaternaryScience
Reviews,25,1-2,163-178.
301
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.25
Moisture and temperature effects of char in a forest soil
SinghNimisha1,AbivenSamuel1,BoivinPascal2,&SchmidtMichael.W.I.1
1Soil Science and Biogeography, Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zurich, Switzerland ([email protected])2 hepia (haute ecole du paysage, de l’ingénierie et de l’architecture),150, route de Presinge CH-1254 Jussy/Geneve
Theapplicationoffire-derivedbiomass(alsocalledcharorbiochar)tosoilisbeingconsideredasalong-termsinkforatmos-phericcarbondioxideinterrestrialecosystemsbecauseofitsslowturnoverrateinthesoil.Theeffectofcharinincreasingnutrientretentionandcropproductionhasbeenwidelyreported.Charisalsoknowntoaffectphysicalpropertiesofsoilsuchaswaterretentionandaggregation(Glaseretal.,2002),however,eventualsignificantchangesinsoilpropertiesremainsuncertain.Additionally,theadequateamounttopositivelyimpactsoilqualitywithoutanyseriousenvironmentalthreatsremainsunknown(Lehmannetal.,2006).Nonetheless,itisimportanttorealizethatcharstabilityandimpactonsoilprop-ertiesdependonfactorssuchassoilmineralcomposition,whichispoorlyunderstood.Thus,relatingcharamendmentswithsoilpropertiesrequirescarefulevaluation(i)underfieldconditionsindiversesoiltypes,(ii)undervariableenvironmentalconditions;and(iii)ofthetypeofcharusedforachievingdesiredresults.
Wehypothesizedthatthewaterretentioncapacityofthesoilwouldincreasewithincreasingcharcontent.Nevertheless,waterretentioncapacityisdependentonsoilmineralogyandcouldyieldcontradictoryresults(Tryon,1948).Temperatureandmoistureareknownimportantvariablesdrivingdecompositionofsoilorganicmatterandnutrientcyclingamongoth-ers.Consequently,anysignificanteffectonthesetwosoilpropertiesmightaffecttheCcycleonaglobalscale.Theadditionofcharwoulddarkenthesoilcolourandcouldincreaseabsorptionofsolarenergyandsoiltemperatures(Krulletal.,2004);however,thermalpropertyofsoilisinfluencedbyacombinationofwatercontent,soiltextureandsoilcolour.
Weareconductingafield-basedstudyontheeffectofdifferentratesofapplicationofcharonthetemperatureandmoisturecontentofthesoil.Thecharusedinthestudyisthereferencechar(initialsubstrateCastaneahardwood,pyrolysedat450°CunderN
2atmosphere)asusedintheringtrial(Hammesetal.,2006).Weuse15cmlong(diameter=10cm)mesocosms
insertedinthesoil,aCambisol(clay30%,orgC.4%).Thesoilandchararewellmixedandtherateofapplicationofchartothemesocosmsis3,6,12,24,48tC-charha-1 respectively, in linewithrecentapproaches forcharmediatedsoilamend-ment.
Thesoilmoisturecontentandtemperaturearemonitoredoveraseason(AugusttoNovember)usingsensors(ECH2O-TE/EC-
TM),installedat5cmdepthinsidethemesocosmsandthedatarecordedevery30minutes.Attheendoftheexperiment,soilcoreswillbesampledandwaterretentioncurvewillbedeterminedontheundisturbedsoilsamplesusingexponentialshrinkagemodel(Boivinetal.,2006).
Thiscommunicationreports the first resultsof this study.Theoutcomeof this studywould facilitate inelucidating thequantitativeassessmentoftherelationshipsbetweencharapplicationrateandthemoisturecontentandtemperaturedy-namicsofthesoilonahighertimeresolution.
REFERENCESBoivin, P.,Garnier, P., andVauclin,M. (2006).Modeling the soil shrinkage andwater retention curveswith the same
equations.SoilScienceSocietyofAmericaJournal 70,1082-1093.Glaser,B.,Lehmann,J.,andZech,W.(2002).Amelioratingphysicalandchemicalpropertiesofhighlyweatheredsoilsinthe
tropicswithcharcoal-areview.BiologyandFertilityofSoils 35,219-230.Hammes,K.,Smernik,R.J.,Skjemstad,J.O.,Herzog,A.,Vogt,U.F.,andSchmidt,M.W.I.(2006).Synthesisandcharacterisation
of laboratory-charredgrass straw (Oryza saliva) andchestnutwood (Castanea sativa) as referencematerials forblackcarbonquantification.OrganicGeochemistry 37,1629-1633.
Krull,E.S.,Skjemstad, J.O.,andBaldock, J.A. (2004).Functionsofsoilorganicmatterandtheeffectonsoilproperties. In:GrainsResearchanddevelopmentCorporationhttp://wwwgrdccomau/uploads/documents/cso000291pdf.
Lehmann, J.,Gaunt, J., andRondon,M. (2006).Bio-Char sequestration in terrestrial ecosystems-A review.MitigationandAdaptationStrategiesforGlobalChange 11,403-427.
Tryon, E.H. (1948). Effect of charcoal on certainphysical, chemical, andbiological properties of forest soils EcologicalMonographs 18,81-115.
302Sy
mp
osi
a 1
0 +
12
: Q
ua
tern
ary
Re
sea
rch
+ S
oil
Sci
en
ces 10.26
A tool to estimate fire intensity and chemical structure of black carbon inputs into soil
StuderMirjam1,SchneiderMaximilian1,MorenoJoséManuel2,RescoVictor2&AbivenSamuel1
1Soil Science and Biogeography, Department of Geography, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190 8057 Zürich, ([email protected]) 2 Department of environmental science, University of Castilla – la Mancha, Toledo, Spain
“BlackCarbon”(BC)isbecomingofincreasinginterestinsoilscienceoverthepastfewyears.Blackcarbonistheresidueofbiomasspyrolysis,forexampleafterawildfire.Itscontributioncanrepresentupto40%oftheorganicmatterinthesoil(Preston&Schmidt,2006).GlobalchangemodelspredictlargeincreasesinwildfireactivityduringtheXXIstcentury,whichwouldenhanceBCcontributiontothesoil.BCwastraditionallyconsideredasaninertcomponentofthesoilcarbonpool,untiltherecentobservationthatitsdecompositionandturnoverareactuallymuchhigherthanpreviouslydocumented.Indeed,thechemicalstructureofBClargelydependsontheconditionsgivenduringthecombustionprocess.Forexample,highertemperatureandloweroxygencontentwillleadtomorecondensedandprobablymorestablecompounds.
ThechemicalstructureofBChasbeencharacterizedbymanydifferent,oftencostlymethods(Hammesetal.,2007).Inthisstudywetriedtodevelopafastandcheaptooltocharacterizetheblackcarbonchemicalstructurebypredictingtheburningtemperature.ThistoolisbasedonanindexcalculatedwithDiffuseReflectanceInfraredFourierTransform(DRIFT)spectro-scopicmeasurements.First,we tried toproposean indexbasedon lab-preparedsamples.Then,weapplied this index tosamplesfromrealwildfires.
Residuesofpyrolysisfromawoody(Castanea sativa)andanon-woody(Oryza sativa)specieswereusedasstandardtobuildupourindex.Thesampleswerepyrolised(N
2fluxeswithoutO
2)attemperaturesof200,250,275,300,350,400,500,600,700,
800,900and1000degreeCelsius.ThecharwaspreparedaccordingtothestandardproceduredescribedinHammesetal.(2006). To relate themeasurements towildfires, residues of naturally burnedMediterranean shrubs (Cistus ladanifer andPhillyrea latifolia)wereanalysed(Pérez&Moreno1998).Thesampleswerecollectedacrossagradientoffireintensity,esti-matedwiththediameteroftheremainingbranches.AllsamplesweremilledtoapowderandmixedwithdriedKBr (3%sample).TheanalyseswereperformedwithaBrukerTENSOR27DRIFTspectrometer.Thespectrawerenormalizedandpeakregions,whichvariedwithdifferentburningtem-peratures,wereidentified(1510,1420,1320,988and821cm-1).Tocalculatetheindexthemaximalpeakheightandtheareaofthepeakregionswereused.
Spectraofthelab-producedcharshowedageneralflatteningaccompaniedbyrisingabsorbancewithincreasingburningtemperatures.Samples>500°Chavebeenshowntobehighlycondensed(Schneider,personalcommunication)andwehy-pothesisedthatthemoleculesmightbetoobigandcondensedforshowingastrongandclearsignalwithDRIFTspectrom-etry.Withinthespectrafrom200to500°Cchangesofheightintheselectedpeakregionscouldbeobserved.Theresultingindexpredictedtheburningtemperature+/-50°C.Resultswereimprovedifthewoodyandnon-woodyspecieswereanalysedseparately.Thecomparisonofthelab-sampleswiththesamplesfromthewildfiresareongoingandwillbealsopresented.
REFERENCESHammes,K.,Smernik,R.J.,Skjemstad, J.O.,Vogt,U.F.,Schmidt,M.W.I.2006:Synthesisandcharacterisationof laboratory-
charred grass straw (Oryza sativa) and chestnutwood (Castanea sativa) as referencematerials for black carbonquantification.OrganicGeochemistry,37,1629-1633.
Hammes,K.,Schmidt,M.W.I.,Smernik,R.J.,Currie,L.A.,Ball,W.P.,Nguyen,T.H.,Louchouarn,P.,Houel,S.,Gustafsson,Ö.,Elmquist,M.,Cornelissen,G.,Skjemstad,J.O.,Masiello,C.A.,Song,J.,Peng,P.,Mitra,S.,Dunn,J.C.,Hatcher,P.G.,Hockaday,W.C., Smith,D.M.,Hartkopf-Fröder,C., Böhmer,A., Lüer, B.,Huebert, B. J.,Amelung,W., Brodowski, S.,Huang,L.,Zhang,W.,Gschwend,P.M.,Flores-Cervantes,D.X.,Largeau,C.,Rouzaud,J.-N.,Rumpel,C.,Guggenberger,G.,Kaiser,K.,Rodionov,A.,Gonzalez-Vila,F.J.,Gonzalez-Perez,J.A.,delaRosa,J.M.,Manning,D.A.C.,López-Capél,E.,Ding,L.2007:Comparisonofquantificationmethodstomeasurefire-derived(black/elemental)carboninsoilsandsedimentsusingreferencematerialsfromsoil,water,sedimentandtheatmosphere,GlobalBiogeochemicalCycles,21,GB2016.
Pérez,B.&MorenoJ.M.1998:Methodsforquantifyingfireseverityinshrubland-fires.PlantEcology,139,91-101.Preston,C.M.&Schmidt,M.W.I.2006:Black(pyrogenic)carbon:asynthesisofcurrentknowledgeanduncertaintieswith
specialconsiderationofborealregions.Biogeosciences,3,397-420.
303
Sym
po
sia
10
+ 1
2:
Qu
ate
rna
ry R
ese
arc
h +
So
il S
cie
nce
s10.27
Hydration effects on microbial motility and coexistence on unsaturated rough surfaces
GangWang&DaniOr
Soil and Terrestrial Environmental Physics (STEP), Department of Environmental Sciences (D-UWIS), Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich (ETHZ), Universitaestrasse 16, CH-8092, Zurich ([email protected])
Microbialmotility isrecognizedasakeymechanisminbiodiversitymaintenanceofecosystem(Reichenbachetal.2007),whichplaysadominantroleinmostaspectsofbioremediation,biochemicalnutrientcycling,plantrhyzosphere,redoxreac-tionsandpathogendispersal(Fenchel2002;Madsen2005).Quantitativedescriptionofmicrobialmotilityandotheractivi-tiesinsoilsishinderedbyporespacecomplexityandhydrationdynamics.Unsaturatedconditionsarecommoninnature(Barbara &Mitchell 2003), form fragmented aquatic habitats that are too small to support full immersion ofmicrobestherebyforcingstronginteractionswithmineralsurfaces,andresultinsignificantrestrictionofmicrobialmotility.Anewhybridmodelwasdevelopedtostudythe influenceofsurfacehydrationonmicrobialmotilityandits impactonspeciescoexistenceonunsaturatedroughsurfaces.
Simulationsbasedongeneralparametervaluesfromliteraturepredictreducedcolonyexpansionratesandcorrespondinglyincreasedspeciescoexistencetimeunderdrierconditions,whichareingeneralagreementwithexperimentalobservations(Dechesneetal.2008).Undermatricpotentialshigherthan-0.5kPa(wet),microbialcoloniesgrowfastatanaveragerateofcolonyexpansionexceeding421±94µm/hr;therateofcolonyexpansiondroppedto31±10µm/hrat -2kPaandlevelledatlowermatricpotentials;asexpected,nosignificantcolonyexpansionwasobservedatmatricpotentialof-5kPabecauseofthesub-micrometricandfragmentedaquaticformationandtheresultingcapillarypinningforces.Drierconditionsreducemotilityandenhancecoexistenceoftwocompetingspecies(indefinitecoexistenceformatricpotentialslowerthan-2kPa),conversely,nocoexistencewasfoundformatricpotentialshigherthan-0.5kPa.Thisstudyexploresfundamentalmecha-nismsofphysicalconstraintsofporefeaturesandcapillarypinningforceonrestrictingmicrobialmotility,henceaffectingspeciescoexistenceonunsaturatedroughsurfaces.Thefindingofclosedependenceofspeciescoexistencetimeonsurfacehydration(hencemotility)alsoreflectsthereductionofnutrientfluxinterceptionbythemorecompetitivespecies,there-strictionofspatialinteractionsandnutrient“shadowing”byrapidlyexpandingcoloniesunderdrierconditionsthatpro-motespeciesco-existenceonunsaturatedroughsurfaces.
REFERENCESBarbara,G.M.&Mitchell,J.G.2003:Marinebacterialorganisationaroundpoint-likesourcesofaminoacids.FEMSMicrobiol.
Ecol.43,99-109.Dechesne,A.,Or,D.,Gulez,G.& Smets, B.F. 2008: Theporous surfacemodel, anovel experimental system for online
quantitativeobservationofmicrobialprocessesunderunsaturatedconditions.Appl.Environ.Microb.74,5195-5200.Fenchel,T.2002:Microbialbehaviorinaheterogeneousworld.Science296,1068-1071.Madsen,E.L.2005:Identifyingmicroorganismsresponsibleforecologicallysignificantbiogeochemicalprocesses.Nat.Rev.
Microbiol.3,439-446.Reichenbach,T.,Mobilia,M.&Frey,E.2007:Mobilitypromotesand jeopardizesbiodiversity inrock-paper-scissorsgames.
Nature448,1046-1049.
304Sy
mp
osi
um
11
: D
eci
sio
n o
rie
nte
d m
od
ell
ing
of
the
ge
osp
he
re
11. Decision oriented modelling of the geosphereH.-R. Egli, W. Haeberli, C. Hegg, O. Smrekar, M. Stauffacher
Swiss Academic Society for Environmental Research and Ecology (SAGUF)Swiss Geographic Society, Swiss Geomorphological Society
11.1 BalinD.,MetzgerR.,FalloJ.-M.,ReynardE.:Integrativehydro-geomorphologicmodellinginalpineregions:scientificandoperationalchallenges
11.2 BilgotS.,ParriauxA.:Usingpredispositionfactorsforlandslidehazardassessment:anewGIS-basedmethodology
11.3 BinderC.,FeolaG.,Garcia-SantosG.,YangJ.:Integrativemodellingofpesticideuseindevelopingcountries
11.4 DurrandeN.,RenardP.,GinsbourgerD.:AclusteringmethodforuncertaintyquantificationappliedtoCO2seque-stration
11.5 HaeberliW.:4Dinformationonclimate-drivengeosystemchangesinhighmountainareas-experiencesandperspec-tives
11.6 MilnesE.:Simulation-basedriskassessmentofsuperimposedgroundwatersalinisationprocesses
11.7 PlattnerG.-K.:TheRoadtoClimateStabilization:InsightsfromCarbonCycle-ClimateModels
11.8 WeigelA.:Seasonalclimatepredictions:Fromtheorytoend-userapplications
11.1
Integrative hydro-geomorphologic modelling in alpine regions: scientific and operational challenges
DanielaBalin1,RichardMetzger2,Jean-MichelFallot1,EmmanuelReynard1
1 Geography Institute, University of Lausanne, CH-1015 ([email protected])2 Geomatic and Risk Analysis Institute, University of Lausanne, CH-1015
Hazardandriskassessmentrequire,besidesgooddata,goodsimulationcapabilitiestoallowpredictionofeventsandtheirconsequences. Progresses have been done in building different modelling structures (conceptual and physically based,lumpedanddistributed)atdifferentscales,withdifferentamountsofinputdataandtogetherwithdifferentcalibrationprocedures.Hazardassessmentoftenrequiresinvolvementofdecisionmakersandthusanimportantchallengeistheevaluationofthecredibilityofthescientificresultsandthecommunicationoftheuncertainty.
Thepresentstudyintroducesanintegratedapproachbasedonthecouplingofhydro-geomorphologicmodels,abletocopewithuncertaintyofinputdataandmodelparametersinordertoperformadynamicmodellinginspaceandtimeofthemainrainfalltriggeredhydro-geomorphologicprocesses.Theroleofuncertaintyasatooltolearnhowinputdatacouldbeusedtoevaluatedifferentmodellingstructuresatdifferentscaleshasbeenalsoinvestigated.
Thestudyregionisrepresentedbytwosmallalpinecatchments,thenaturalreserveof«VallondeNant»(13km2)andtheTintaz catchment in the urbanised Verbier region. The hydrologicalmodel in this study is based on theWater BalanceSimulationModel,WASIM-ETH(Schullaetal.,1997),afullydistributedhydrologicalmodelthathasbeensuccessfullyusedpreviouslyinthealpineregionstosimulaterunoff,snowmelt,glaciermelt,andsoilerosionandimpactofclimatechangeonthese.Thismodelisintendedtobecoupledwithslopestabilitymethodstosimulatethespatialdistributionoftheini-
305
Sym
po
siu
m 1
1:
De
cisi
on
ori
en
ted
mo
de
llin
g o
f th
e g
eo
sph
eretiationareasofdifferentgeomorphicprocessessuchasdebrisflowsandrainfalltriggeredlandslides.
TocalibratetheWASIM-ETHmodel,theMonteCarloMarkovChainBayesianapproachwillbeprivileged(Balin,2004,Schaeflietal.,200).Giventhatthespatialuncertaintyofrainfallisanimportantfactorofuncertaintyinthehydrologicalmodellingandgiventhehighvariabilityoftherainfallinalpinecatchments,aquitedensenetworkofmeteorologicalstationshasbeenimplementedtobettercalibratethehydrologicalmodel.Eachstepinthehydro-geomorphologicriskassessmentundertakesuncertainty:evaluationofthemainsourcesofuncertaintyaswellastheevaluationandcommunicationofuncertaintyisanimportantaspectoftheproposedmethodology.TheBayesianapproachoffersagoodcompromisebetweenmodeleffi-ciencyandtimeconsumptionandrepresentsastraightforwardwaytodealwithdifferentsourcesofuncertainty,asnowa-daysthisisanimportantrequirementofthedecisionmakersinvolvedinriskassessment.
REFERENCESBalin,D. (2004). “HydrologicalBehaviour through experimental andmodellingapproaches.Application to theHaute-
Mentuecatchment.”ThèseEPFln°3007.FacultéEnac,EPFl,Lausanne,Suisse.Schaefli B, TalambaBalinD.,MusyA,.2007. “Quantifyinghydrologicalmodeling errors through amixture ofnormal
distributions”JournalofHydrology332(3-4):303-315Schulla,J,Jasper,K.1998/2000:„ModellbeschreibungWaSiM-ETH“;InstitutfürGeographie,ETHZürich,167S.
11.2
Using predisposition factors for landslide hazard assessment: a new GIS-based methodology
BilgotSéverine1,ParriauxAurèle1
1 EPFL ENAC IIC GEOLEP, Station 18, CH-1015 Lausanne ([email protected])
Switzerland isexceptionallysubjectedto landslides; indeed,about10%of itsarea isconsideredasunstable.Makingthisobservation,itsDepartmentoftheEnvironment(BAFU)introducedin1997amethodtorealizelandslidehazardmap.Itisroutinelyusedbut,likemostofthemethodsappliedinEuropetomapunstableareas,itismainlybasedonthesignsofpreviousorcurrentphenomena(geomorphologicmapping,archiveconsultation,etc.)eventhoughinstabilitiescanappearwherethereisnothingtoshowthattheyexistedearlier.Furthermore,thetranscriptionfromthegeomorphologicmaptothehazardmapcanvaryaccordingtothegeologistorthegeographerwhorealizesit:thismethodisaffectedbyacertainlackoftransparencyandisnotreallyefficienttoforecastlandslides.
Theaimofthisprojectistointroducethebedrockofanewmethodforlandslidehazardmapping;basedoninstabilitypre-dispositionassessment,itinvolvesthedesignationofmainfactorsforlandslidesusceptibility,theirintegrationinaGIStocalculatealandslidepredispositionindexandtheimplementationofnewmethodstoevaluatethesefactors;tobecompeti-tive,theseprocesswillhavetobebothcheapandquick.
Aftershowingthatcohesionandhydraulicconductivityofloosematerialswerestronglylinkedtotheirgranulometryandplasticityindex,weimplementedtwonewfieldtests,onebasedonteledetectionandonecoupledsedimentometricandbluemethylenteststoevaluatetheseparameters.Thehydraulicconductivityoffracturedrockswasobtainedfromtheanalysisoftheirgeometricalproperties(fracturesdensity,aperturesizeandorientation).TheotherfactorswereextractedfromDEMandhydrologicmapping.
Weaddedalastfactorrelatedtothepredispositionofthegeotype(newclassificationforgeologicformations,basedonge-neticstandardsforloosematerialandonlithologicstandardsforhardrock)toslopeinstabilityprocess:thelatterenabledustointegrateattributespropertoeachgeotypes (over-consolidationforgroundmoraines,stratificationsforglaciolacus-trinedeposits,etc...)andwhichwouldbelongandcomplextointegratetoaGIS.
Afterward,weimplementedanArcGis®toolboxallowingtoleadtoalandslidesusceptibilityindex.Finally,weappliedthismethodology(fromfieldsurveytoGISoperations)totensitesindifferentcontextsinSwitzerland.Thisnewmethodologycanbeconsideredasacheapandefficientwaytoforecastlandslides.
REFERENCESLateltin,O.:Priseencomptedesdangersdusauxmouvementsdeterraindanslecadredesactivitésdel’aménagementdu
306Sy
mp
osi
um
11
: D
eci
sio
n o
rie
nte
d m
od
ell
ing
of
the
ge
osp
he
re territoire.OFAT,OFEE,OFEFP,1997.
Figure1.ApplicationtotheTraverslandslide
307
Sym
po
siu
m 1
1:
De
cisi
on
ori
en
ted
mo
de
llin
g o
f th
e g
eo
sph
ere11.3
Integrative modelling of pesticide use in developing countries
BinderClaudiaR.12,FeolaGiuseppe1,Garcia-SantosGlenda1,Yang,Jing1
1 Department of Geography, University of Zurich2 Institute for System Science Innovation and Sustainability Research, University of Graz, Austria
Thelivelihoodofsmallfarmersindevelopingcountriesdependsontheirabilitytoemployecologicallyandeconomicallysoundproductionmethods.Whileproperlyappliedpesticidesreduceyieldlossesupto40%andimproveproductquality,theirmisusemight cause serious human health and environmental problems. TheWorld Health Organization (WHO)(1990a)estimatesanannualworldwidetotalof3millioncasesofacutepoisoningwith220,000deaths.Oneofthecentralquestionsiswhy,despitealltheeffortsbeingmadeinresearch,nosignificantimprovementsinunder-standingandmodelingfarmers’decision-makingandconnectingittoenvironmentalandhumanhealthimpactshavebeenmade.Antleetal.(2001)statethatoneofthereasonsisthesegregateddisciplinaryresearchwhichleadstotheproblemthatdifferentscientificinvestigationscannotbelinkedtoprovideasystemunderstandingthatincludessocialandnaturalsci-encevariables.However,thisunderstandingisindispensableforsciencemodelsthatprovideasoundsystemunderstandingandthus,resultsthatarecomprehensibleandusefulforpolicymakers.
Thispaperpresentsanintegrativemodellingapproachtosimulateandassesstheeffectofmeasuresforreducingthehumanhealthandenvironmentalrisksfrompesticideuse.Figure1showstheconceptualapproachunderlyingthemodelbuildingprocessandthemethodsusedthereby.
Mental Model Approach
Sensitivity A.Measurements
System Analysis Workshop
Survey
Human and environmental risk assessment
Farmers’ perceptions& decision-making
Scenario development
Spatially explicit dynamic risk assessment
Simulation and assessment of mitigation strategies
Calibrated spatially explicit risk assessment model
Simulation model
Farmers decision-making model
AssessmentStrategies for reducing risks
Figure1.Methodologicalapproachtakenfordesignedthesimulationmodelintheresearchproject.Methodswith1transdisciplinary
methods
Thesimulationmodeliscomposedoftwosub-modelsafarmersdecision-makingmodelandaspatiallyexplicitriskassess-mentmodel.Farmers’ decision-making modeldeterminestheamountandtypeofpesticideusedandthetypeandfrequen-cyofusageofprotectiveequipmentduringapplication.Thismodelisbasedonapreliminarytransdisciplinaryanalysisoffarmers’perceptionsonthepotentialrisksofpesticideapplicationandtheirsystemview(Schoell&Binder,2009)andtheIntegratedAgentCentred(IAC)Framework(Feola&Binder,2009).Resultsregardingtheuseornonuseofprotectiveequip-mentshowthatthevariablesmostlyaffectingthisdecisionwere(i)theperceptionofequipments’comfort,(ii)thepracticeofreadinglabels, (iii) thedescriptivesocialnormsand (iv) theperceivedhealthimpact (FeolaandBinder,accepted).Thethirdandfourthvariableallowfordefiningadynamicmodelwhichspecificallyincludesfeedbackmechanismsastheeffectofindividualactiononsocialnorm.
308Sy
mp
osi
um
11
: D
eci
sio
n o
rie
nte
d m
od
ell
ing
of
the
ge
osp
he
re Thespatially explicit risk assessment modelincludesenvironmentalaswellashumanhealthrelatedprocessesandwasdevelopedtobespatiallyexplicit.Acombinationofalreadyexistingmodelsandtheiradaptationwaschosentosimulatethefateandriskofthepesticidesapplied.Thenecessaryinputvaluesforthemodele.g.pesticidetypes,physicalandchemicalpropertiesandpesticideapplicationdateswereobtainedinthesurvey2007.Thesurveyincludedthespatiallyexplicitappli-cationpatternbyfarmers,linkingsothebehaviouralpartwiththespatiallyexplicitriskassessment.Specificcharacteristicsoftheactiveingredientswereobtainedfromliterature.Thetransfer-coefficientstotheenvironmentalcompartmentsair,water,soilandplantaswellasontothefarmerwereobtainedempiricallyusingtheWSP-uranineextraction.
Thepresentationwill focuson themethodological approach takenhighlighting theadvantagesofperformingout-fronttransdisiplinaryresearchtodeterminethemainvariablesrelevantforthesystem.
REFERENCESFeolaG.&BinderC.R.Theorypaper–whichdoyouwanttocite??
FeolaG.&BinderC.R.Whydon‘tpesticideapplicatorsprotectthemselves?ExploringtheuseofPersonalProtectiveEquipmentamong
Colombiansmallholders.InternationalJournalofOccupationalandEnvironmentalHealth,inpress.
SchöllR.&,BinderC.R.,ComparingSystemVisionsofFarmersandExperts,Futures,inpress.
SchöllR.&BinderC.R.,2009,Systemperspectivesofexpertsandfarmersregardingtheroleoflivelihoodassets:ResultsfromaStructured
MentalModelApproach,JournalofRiskAnalysis,29(2):205-222.
WHO1990bSafeuseofpesticides.FourteenthreportoftheWHOExpertCommitteeonVectorBiologyandControl.Geneva,WorldHealth
Organization,1990(WHOTechnicalReportSeries,No.813).
11.4
A clustering method for uncertainty quantification applied to CO2 sequestration
DurrandeNicolas1,RenardPhilippe2,GinsbourgerDavid1,2
1 Dep. of mathematics, Ecole des Mines de Saint-Etienne – 29 rue Ponchardier 42000 Saint-Etienne France, ([email protected])2 Centre of hydrogeology and geothermics, University of Neuchâtel – Rue Emile-Argand 11, CH - 2009 Neuchâtel - Switzerland ([email protected], [email protected])
InordertoreducetheatmosphericemissionofCO2duetohumanactivities,onepossibility is tostoreCO
2 ingeological
reservoirs.TheprincipleistoextracttheCO2producedbyapollutingfactory(acoalfiredpowerplantforinstance)andto
injectitintoageologicalreservoirsuchasadeepsalineaquifer.Ifthecaprock'squalityisgood,theCO2willbetrappedand
willprogressivelyturnintosediments.
Todecideupontheviabilityofsuchproject,oneofthemainchallengesistoquantifytheriskofCO2leakage.Asalltheleak-
agescenariidependonthegrowthoftheCO2plume,itisnecessarytostudyitsexpansionbynumericalsimulation(Fig.1).
However,theinputsofthesimulation(permeabilityandporosityfields)arerandom,andsimulatingonesingleinjectionschemewithafinitevolumemethodaccountingtheproperequationofstatesforsupercriticalCO2takesaround2days(20yearsofinjectionwitha2dimensionalmodel).
AsclassicalMonte-Carlomethodsareunaffordable,themethodweusehereisasdescribedbyCaersin[1].Theaimistoselectalimitednumberofsimulationrunsbyapplyinganonintrusivemethodbasedonaproxysimulator(cheap-to-evaluatelow-fidelitymodel). Following [2], kernelmethodsareused inorder to linearize thedata,which is supposed to improve theclusteringprocedure.Themethodconsistsof5steps:
• Generatenfieldsofpermeabilityandporosity• Useaproxysimulatortocomputethenapproximatesolutions• Defineadistancebetweenthesolutionsandcreateamapping.Thistransformationmaybebasedonkernelmethodsfor
greaterlinearity.• FindNcentresofclusters• RunthesimulatorfortheNselectedpoints.
309
Sym
po
siu
m 1
1:
De
cisi
on
ori
en
ted
mo
de
llin
g o
f th
e g
eo
sph
ereTheflowsimulationisperformedusingthesoftwareTough2witha1Mt/yinjectionrateduring20years.Theproxysimula-
torisashortenTough2simulationofa1yearinjection.Thenumberofinitialfieldsgeneratedisn=100andthenumberofcompletesimulationsisN=10.Inordertoevaluatetheefficiencyofourmethod,weperformaclassicalMonte-Carloanalysisusing100completesimulations.TheresultsareshownonFigure2:
Thisworkillustratesthatproxysimulatorscanbeusedtoefficientlyselectrepresentativesimulations.HeretheCPUsimu-lationtimecanbedividedbyoneorderofmagnitudewhilekeepinggoodestimatesoftheprobabilityofpresenceofCO
2.
Howeverthedistancedefinitionseemstohaveagreatimpactonthefinalresults.Futureworksmayfocusontheissueofselectingwell-suiteddistancesforimportancesampling.
Moregenerally,theproposedapproachallowstoimprovetheefficiencyoflargescaleandcomplexmodellingunderuncer-taintyfordecisionmaking.
Figure1.Exampleofpermeabilityfieldandresultofa20yearsinjection
Figure2.ComparisonbetweenclusteringmethodandMonte–Carlo
REFERENCES[1]J.Caers.2008-Distance-basedstochasticmodelling:theoryandapplications.TechnicalReport21,StanfordUniversity,
EnergyresourcesEngineeringDep[2]C.Scheidt,J.Caers.2008-Uncertaintyquantificationusingdistancesandkernelmethods-applicationtoadeepwater
turbiditereservoir.Technicalreport,StanfordUniversity,EnergyresourcesEngineeringDep[3]V.Vapnik.1995-TheNatureofStatisticalLearningTheory.Springer
310Sy
mp
osi
um
11
: D
eci
sio
n o
rie
nte
d m
od
ell
ing
of
the
ge
osp
he
re 11.5
4D information on climate-driven geosystem changes in high mountain areas - experiences and perspectives.
WilfriedHaeberli1
1Glaciology,Geomorphodynamics&Geochronology,GeographyDepartment,UniversityofZurich
Integratedgeoinformation systemscombiningdata,models and scenariosare increasinglyneeded toanticipatedevelop-mentsofcomplexgeosystemsbeyondtheempiricalknowledgebasisfromthepast.Suchgeoinformationsystemsprimarilyprovideanoverviewoftheavailableknowledgeandunderstandingconcerningthemostimportantprocesses,subsystemsandtheirpotentialinteractions.Asaconsequenceofoftenincompleteorevenmissing(spatiotemporal)information,theymustapplyrelativelysimpleandrobustmodels,whichneedexaminationbymoresophisticatedprocess-orientedmodels.Theyrenderthecorrespondingscientificreflection(assumptions,hypotheses,scenarios)transparent,quantifyresultsinthespaceandtimedomainandindicateknowledgegaps.Perhapsmostimportantly,theydemonstratetheusefulnessof,andtheneedfor,consideringcomplexsystemsandlongertimescales.However,theyare-andwillalwaysbe-farfromperfectandneedcontinuousdevelopmentinviewofongoingrapidchangesinnature,technologyandscientificunderstanding.Models of abiotic subsystems such as snow and ice conditions, water supply or hazards from rock falls, debris flows,avalanchesandfloodsarealreadywelladvancedanduseful.Bioticsubsystems–especiallyvegetationasrelatedtoclimatechange,icevanishingandeffectsofgrazing–arelesswellcoveredbyrobustspatialmodelsapplicableinhigh-mountaintopography:anurgentresearchneed.ExperiencesarepresentedfromacasestudycarriedoutintheUpperEngadin,easternSwissAlps,withintheframeworkoftheNRP48andperspectiveswillbediscussedinviewofnewlakesforminginrapidlydeglaciatingmountainranges.
11.6
Simulation-based risk assessment of superimposed groundwater salinisation processes
EllenMilnes1
1Centre d’hydroéologie CHYN, Université de Neuchâtel, Rue Emile-Argand 11. CH- 2007-Neuchâtel
Groundwatersalinisationisaworld-widemajorgroundwatercontaminationissueandisrelatedtomultipleprocesses,suchasseawaterintrusion,agrochemicalpollution,geogeniccontaminationandirrigation-inducedpollution.Insalinityaffectedaquifers,theobservedconcentrationoftotaldissolvedsolidsmayresultfromthesuperpositionofseveralsalinisationpro-cesses.Inareasaffectedbygroundwatersalinisation,correctidentificationofthespatialdistributionanddynamicinterplayofthesuper-imposedsalinitycomponentsiscrucial,sincetherespectiveremedialorconservationmeasuresmaybeentirelydifferent.
Identificationofdifferentoriginsofsalinisationcanbeconsideredaseparatefieldinhydrogeologicalresearchandiseffici-entlyaddressedbymeansvarioushydrogeochemical techniques (e.g.Custodio,1997;Vengoshetal.,1999).Asopposedtosimplesalinitymeasurements,sophisticatedtechniquesthatyieldclearinformationabouttheoriginofsalinityareoftencostlyandusuallyonlyyieldsnap-shotsintimeandspace.Combininginformationontheoriginsofsalinityfromsuchin-vestigationswithnumericalsimulationsisthereforeapromisingstrategytoinvestigatetheinterplaybetweendifferentsa-linisationprocesses.
Vulnerability and risk assessments are becoming a standard approach in groundwatermanagementwhen dealingwithwaterqualityandcontaminationissues.Themostcommonlyusedvulnerabilitymappingproceduresarebasedonempiricalpointratingsystemsthatbringtogetherkeyfactors.Ithasbeenfoundthatthevulnerabilityandcontaminationriskcanrarelybepredictedwiththesekeyfactorswhichiswhythereisagrowingneedforphysicallybasedriskandvulnerabilityassessments(Gogu&Dassargues2000).
311
Sym
po
siu
m 1
1:
De
cisi
on
ori
en
ted
mo
de
llin
g o
f th
e g
eo
sph
ereAsimulation-basedsalinisationriskassessmentmethodologyisproposedthatallowsmappingofareasatriskwithrespect
todifferentsalinisationprocesses.Anumericalgroundwatersimulationprocedureispresentedwhichallowsdecompositionofameasuredbulksalinitydistributionintocomponentsderivedfromdifferentsalinisationprocesses.Inafirststep,anu-mericalgroundwaterflowandtransportmodelaccountingforallidentifiedsalinisationprocessesiscalibrated,usingtheobservedsalinitydistribution.Then,theobservedsalinitydistributionisreplacedbythesimulatedsalinitydistribution.Byadaptingtheboundaryconditionsofthemodeleachsalinisationprocesscanthenbesimulatedseparately.Thesimulationresultsarethenusedtoobtainriskindexdistributionsforeachsalinisationprocess,reflectingthespatialvariationofpos-siblefuturerelativesalinityincreasewithrespecttoagivenprocess.Inthelaststep,theseriskindexdistributionsarethenoverlainwithdefinedthresholdsalinities,revealingareasrequiringremediationorconservationmeasures.
ThedifferentstepsofthesalinisationriskmappingprocedureareillustratedonarealaquifersysteminSouthernCyprus(Akrotiri),wherethreemajorsalinisationprocessesaresuperimposed(seawaterintrusion,evaporationandirrigation-indu-cedsalinisation),revealingthepossibleusefulnessingroundwatermanagementdecision-makingprocess.
REFERENCESCustodio, E. 1997: Studying,monitoring and controlling seawater intrusion in coastal areas. In:Guidelines for Study,
MonitoringandControl,FAOWaterReports7-23,11(1).Gogu,R.C.&Dassargues,A., 2000:Curent trendsand futurechallenges ingroundwatervulnerabilityassessmentusing
overlyandindexmethods.549-559.EnvironmentalGeology39(6).Vengosh,A.,SpivackA.,ArtziY.,AvnerA.1999:Geochemicalandboron,strontiumandoxygenisotopicconstraintsonthe
originofthesalinityingroundwaterfromtheMediterraneancoastofIsrael.WaterResourcesResearch35(6),1877-1894.
11.7
The Road to Climate Stabilization: Insights from Carbon Cycle - Climate Models
Gian-KasperPlattner1
1Climate and Environmental Physics, Physics Institute, University of Bern & IPCC WGI TSU, University of Bern
TheUNFrameworkConventiononClimateChangecallsfor"stabilizationofgreenhousegasconcentrationsintheatmos-phereatalevelthatwouldpreventdangerousinterferencewiththeclimatesystem".Futureclimatestabilizationwillulti-mately require stabilizationof atmospheric greenhousegas concentrations and substantial reductions in anthropogenicgreenhousegasemissionscomparedtopresent-dayemissions.ForCO2,themostimportantanthropogenicgreenhousegas,theamountofcarbonemissionsthatcanbereleasedinordertoreachagivenCO2stabilizationtarget(i.e.the"allowable"emissions)willdependonhowmuchoftheextraCO2willberemovedfromtheatmospherebynaturalCO2sinks,mainlytheoceansandthelandbiosphere.Oceanandlandbiospherecurrentlyremoveabout50%oftheman-madeannualCO2emissions,andtherebysubstantiallyhelpedmitigatingtheriseinatmosphericCO2overthelast200years.Unfortunately,thesenaturalsinkscannotbeexpectedtocontinueforever.Observationalevidenceandevidencefromcoupledclimate -carboncyclemodelssuggestthat increasingCO2levelsandclimatechangewill likelydecreasetheabilityofthenaturalsystemtotakeupextraCO2inthefuture,leavinglargerfractionsoftheanthropogenicCO2emissionsintheatmosphere,andthereforefurtherraisingCO2levelsandacceleratingclimatechange.ThereductionsinglobalcarbonemissionsforagivenCO2stabilizationtargetthusneedstobesubstantiallylargerifcarboncycle-climatefeedbacksareaccountedfor.Inmypresentation,Iwill(1)quantifytheimpactofcarboncycle-climatefeedbacksontheprojected"allowable"emissionforCO2/Climatestabilizationinthecurrentgenerationofcarboncycle-climatemodelsand(2)highlightuncertaintiesinthemodelrepresentationofcarboncycleprocessesresulting insubstantial spread inboththemodelresponseto increasingatmosphericCO2andclimatechange.
312Sy
mp
osi
um
11
: D
eci
sio
n o
rie
nte
d m
od
ell
ing
of
the
ge
osp
he
re 11.8
Seasonal climate predictions: From theory to end-user applications
Andreas Weigel1
1Federal Department of Home Affairs FDHA Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss, Zurich
Seasonalforecasting,i.e.theprovisionofinformationontheexpectedtendencyoftheclimateofthecomingmonthsandseasons,hasbecomeawell-establishedtechniquewithapplicationsworld-wide.Indeed,seasonalforecastsaresuccessfullyappliedforclimate-riskmanagementinmanyclimate-sensitivesectorssuchasenergy,health,watermanagement,agricul-tureandtheinsuranceindustry.
Since 2005,MeteoSwiss issues seasonal forecasts on anoperational basis, both for thepublic and forprivate customers.However,duetothewiderangeofuncertaintiesinvolved,seasonalclimatepredictionsareinherentlyprobabilistic,requiringsignificanteffortsbothfromforecastprovidersandusers.Whiletheformerneedtomakesurethattheuncertaintiesareappropriatelyquantifiedandcommunicated,itisthetaskofthelattertomakeoptimumusetheuncertaintyinformationprovided.ForapplicationsincentralEurope,thesechallengesarefurtheraggravatedbythefactthatthepredictionskillisverylowinthisregion,i.e.thatthepredictableclimatesignalisoftenveryweakincomparisontotheunpredictablenoise.
Inthispresentation,anoverviewofourexperiencegainedinthefieldofseasonalforecastingwillbepresented.Inparticular,thefollowingissueswillbediscussedandillustratedwithexamples:(i)Howcantheuncertaintyrangeofclimatepredictionsbeaccuratelydetermined?(ii)Howcantheuncertaintiesandthepredictionskillofseasonalforecastsbeaccuratelycommu-nicatedtotheusercommunity?Andfinally:(iii)Howcanseasonalforecastsbesuccessfullyapplied,evenifthepredictionskillisverylow?