2015 lecture9 sketchmodels - product...

Results and an introduction to sketch modeling

Wonder Walls

00:06:12:34

Idea Presentation Resultsthis is feedback. from 45 outside designers and staff

Poster Ranking(top quarter)

33.

54

4.5

Cre

atur

e Sc

reec

her

Rai

n C

limbe

r

Infin

ity R

ockw

all

Gra

mo

Pole

Traf

fic C

ontr

ol

The

rmo

Boar

d

Spac

e Po

go B

last

er

Pluc

k Pl

uck

Rev

olut

ion

Cre

scen

do

Rob

oPol

e

Popp

y Po

d

The

Tal

king

Glo

be

The

Hum

Dru

m

Sand

Spi

rals

It's

Plin

ko

Dra

gon

Trai

ner

Mus

ical

Rai

nstic

k W

heel

Ast

erio

d R

unne

r

Mus

ic W

hale

ellen joseph kevin bo joeygdes bmebda me gdes

(unscaled)

focus/flow/simplicity/idea clarity

text large text within form languagetext contrast

balance / filled spaced

clean line work

Presentation Ranking(top quarter)

33.

54

4.5

5

Slap

It

Do

that

Tha

ng

Play

Bea

ts

Funk

y Fu

ngi

Rob

oPol

e

The

Hum

Dru

m

Rai

n C

limbe

r

Cre

atur

e Sc

reec

her

Expl

ore

a Sc

ope

Plan

et C

limb

Whe

re D

at A

t?

Spac

e Po

go B

last

er

Kid

stag

ram

It's

Plin

ko

The

Cha

rade

s C

hann

el

Peda

l go

Rou

nd

Rai

se t

he F

lag

Col

or S

um T

hing

ben krause

(unscaled)

Presentation Ranking

Power of Communication

poorly presented ideas sound like bad ideas / well presented ideas sound like better ideas

poster vs presentation poster vs concept presentation vs concept

R²#=#0.33966#

1.5#

2.0#

2.5#

3.0#

3.5#

4.0#

4.5#

5.0#

1.5# 2.0# 2.5# 3.0# 3.5# 4.0# 4.5# 5.0#

R²#=#0.39605#

1.5#

2.0#

2.5#

3.0#

3.5#

4.0#

4.5#

5.0#

1.5# 2.0# 2.5# 3.0# 3.5# 4.0# 4.5# 5.0#

R²#=#0.14767#

1.5#

2.0#

2.5#

3.0#

3.5#

4.0#

4.5#

5.0#

1.5# 2.0# 2.5# 3.0# 3.5# 4.0# 4.5# 5.0#

your grades returned in lab (avg of poster/presentation and scaled)

Concept Rankingdecisions based on a combination of reviewer feedback and sponsor preferences

selected ideas represent general directions for exploration. each idea will be taken in 3 different directions on your team

pewterToy Product Design Idea Presentation

2

3

4

5

orange

2

3

4

5

blueToy Product Design Idea Presentation

Wonder Walls

00:06:12:34

2

3

4

5

cyanToy Product Design Idea Presentation

2

3

4

5 w/ caveats

purpleToy Product Design Idea Presentation

2

3

4

5

periwinkleToy Product Design Idea Presentation

2

3

4

5

yellow

2

3

4

5 w/ caveats

magenta

2

3

4

5

LSI

red

2

3

4

5

LSI

amber

2

3

4

5

LSI

chartreuse

2

3

4

5

LSI

w/ caveats

green

2

3

4

5

LSI

What is a Sketch Model?Sketching in 3-D

explains more than a poster!

answers key questions and further develops the idea

haggman, honda and yang. the influence of timing in exploratory prototyping and other activities in design projects, ASME DTM 2013

prototype early and often

What is a Sketch Model?feasibility and technology assessment

play value / game play

human factors and aesthetic

demonstrates different implementations

Sketch Modeling Materialsinexpensive and fast

use what is appropriate!

polystyrene foam

foam core

wood

repurposed/scavenged/retrofitted parts

arduino/laser cutting

StatiShock

looks like

works like

sketch model

Oreo Separationsketch model 1

Oreo Separationsketch model 2

Oreo Separationsketch model 3

Oreo Separationsketch model 4

looking for approximately this level of refinement

Oreo Separation

repurposed parts, ardunio

ps foam

pvc tubingclay + 3d printing

repurposed parts, wood, ardunio

clay + cast siliconelaser + ardunio

traditional wood working tools

CNC routing

printing and plotting

thermoforming + ardunio

3D printing

welding

sewing

app software

These posters are starting points for (3 different) variations of ideas

Wonder Walls

next steps

every person will work on two sketch models, one of each ideaeach person will be working with a different teammate on each of these 2 modelsno two sketch models should be similar - explore the spacecannot make purely aesthetic modelsgrade based on an average of scores from the two models you helped withthe team must decide on what all the models are first… over email and during lab there will be a peer review to follow

explore variations on how it could work/implementation/technology variations on look/sound/theme/size/functions/user variations on game playonly one team model (if any) should be modeling the exact idea presented

next steps

A

B

C

D

E

Fconcept 1concept 2

Sketch Model Expoduring your lab time on March 12

does this sketch model explain more than the poster?

is it obvious that something was learned from making this model?

is this concept being taken in a good direction?

Sketch Model Play Test (after Spring Break)

Logisticspull toys photos! 5-6 imagining lab Rapson 125wednesday/thursday

WED: arduino and little bits (will need software and laptop)THRS: sketch model construction begins

brainstorm alternative directions for these ideas

are there big unknowns about the selected ideas?

what do you want to learn from making your sketch models?

what materials do you need for Thursday Lab?

take home mini quiz due Wednesday in your notebook:

Logisticsmon

feb 23tues

feb 24wed

feb 25thursfeb 26

frifeb 27 sat sun

monmar 2

tuesmar 3

wedmar 4

thursmar 5

frimar 6 sat sun

monmar 9

tues mar 10

wed mar 11

thurs mar 12

fri mar 13 sat sun

spring break

sketch model expo

photo daybuild day

demo/buildbuild daylecture

plan/buildarduino/littlebitstoday

build days meet in rapson courtyard

3 weeks = 36 hours outside of class for buildeach model should reflect 36 hours of combined work

need to have modelsdemonstrate at the beginning of this lab

Foam and FoamCore