2016-2015 · 39 2016-2015 & the international traffic safety and analysis grope (irtad),...

2016-2015

2016

03-9685802

03-9685801

msher@police.gov.il

2016

5 ......................................................................................................................................

13 ..........................................................................................................................................

27 ......................................................................................................................................

3 41 .............................................................................................................................................

53 ......................................................................................................................

65 ..............................................................................................................................

OECD 79 ..........................................................................................................................................

100 93 ......................................................

105 ............................................................

117 .....................................

127 .........................................................................................................................................

2016-20155

.

2016-20157

2016-2015

2016-20159

2016-20151

23

5 4)

2016-201513

1

2

. ETSC, 1999

Nilsson & Sjogren,: 1981; Rothengatter, 1982

302

Carr, Schnelle & Kirkhne, 1980 ; Shinar & Stiebel, 1986

2014

1.2015

2

2016-2015 14

Hokig, 1977 ; Azrin, 1960)

2016-201515

Bunkley, 2008

750 2005337 2008

1

2016-2015 16

1

9 3

1030

1030

2

2016-201517

2

2013

1000100

25

2016-2015 18

3.2

70%

8.2

3

3

2013

2016-201519

2012

2016-2015 20

20112013

2011

240 210290

FIFO

2016-201521

9024

30

3

12

2016-2015 22

3

,WAZE

2014

2016-201523

4

2016-2015 24

4

Y X

2016-201525

2014

2014.60-1 2014.04

2011

2013

2011

2008

2005

Azrin. H. N. 1960. “Effects of punishment intensity during variable-interval

reinforcement”, Journal of Exp Anal Behavior 3(2), 123-142.

Carr, A. F. Schnelle J. F. & Kirkhne R. E. 1980. Police crackdowns and

slowdowns: a naturalistic evolution of changes in police traffic.

Behavioral Assessment 2, 33-41.

European Transport Safety Council (ETSC), 1999.

Jurdan J. & Bunkley, N. 3 March 2008. Pioneer in Quality Control Dies. New

York: New York Times, p. 103.

Rothengatter T. 1982. “The effect of police surveillance and law

enforcement on driver behavior”. Current Psychological reviews 2, 349-

358.

Honig W. K. 1977. Handbook of operant behavior. New Jersey: prentice-

Hall.

Nilsson, E., Sjogren. O. 1981. Relationships between enforcement, traffic

speeds and traffic accidents. Paper presented at the International

Symposium on the Effects of Speed Limits on Traffic Accidents and Fuel

Consumption, Ireland.

2016-201527

1

2013-2012

Vilfredo 2 Hot Spots)20% Fredrico Damaso Pareto), 80%

20%

1

2

David Weisburd, Elizabeth Groff and Sue Ming Yang, (2012), The Criminology of Place: Street Segments and Our Understanding of the crime Problem, Oxford University press.

2016-2015 28

3

Clarke and Weisburd, 1994

3

2016-201529

Hakkert, Yelinik and Efrat, 1990

4

24

25 1.5

1998)

2013

5 3

20%

12 85

3 854

2013

2011 4Hot Spots 5

2016-2015 30

Hakkert, Pollak and Peled, 2013GIS

6

Miaou, 1994) 6

2016-201531

2008

7 EB) Empirical Bayes

EB

2016

90%

8

2016

Hauer, 1996 78

2016-2015 32

20109

2010-2009 1.21

1

2

9

2016-201533

2

20112

10

1

2

11

10

11

2016-2015 34

2011

12

Hot Spots

13

2012

30-10

14 300

3-2

12

13

14

2016-201535

43% 61%3

3

1 15

12 2 603 3

39 200

25%4 9%

15

2016-2015 36

4

13 17 201340 180 317

2013 280 2016

2016-201537

43% 61% 25% 3

4 9%

2016-2015 38

2013

2008

2013

http trasportation. :2016org.il sites default files pirsum ilanatalemot1-3-16.pdf

1998

2014 2013

http www.rsa.gov.il siteCollectioDocuments D7%9E%D7%

Elvik R. and Vaa T., (2014), The Handbook of Road Safety Measures, New

York: Amsterdam, Elsevier Science.

Hakkert S., Yelinek A. and Efrat E., (1990), “Police Surveillance Methods

and Police Resource Allocation Models” in Proc. Of OEDC Conf. on

Enforcement and Rewarding Strategies and Effects, Danish Road

Directorate, Copenhagen.

Hauer E., (1996), “Identification of Sites with Promise” in Transportation

Research Record, 1542, pp. 54-60.

Kapiow L. and Khavell S., (2001), Any Non-welfares Method of Policy

Assessment Violates the Pareto Principle, Harvard Law School and

National Bureau of Economic Research.

Miaou P. S., (1994), “The Relationship between Truck Accidents and

Geometric design of road section: Poisson Versus negative binomial

regressions”, in Accident Analysis and Prevention, 26(4), pp. 471-482.

Pollak K., Peled A. and Hakkert S., (2013), “Geo-Based Statistical Models

for Vulnerability Prediction of Highway Network Segment”, in ISPRS:

International Journal of Geo-Information, 3(2), pp. 619-637.

2016-201539

The International Traffic Safety and Analysis Grope (IRTAD), (2015), Road

Safety Annual Report.

Weisburd D., Groff E. and Yang Sue-Ming, (2012), The Criminology of Place:

Street Segments and Our Understanding of the crime Problem, Oxford

University press.

Weisburd D. and Clarke R., (1994), “Diffusion of Crime Control Benefits:

Observations on the Reverse of Displacement” in Crime Prevention

Studies, 2, pp. 184-165.

2016-201541

1

3 2012

2014

) 32012

3 1

2016-2015 42

2014

60

2005300 1,200

) 3 11.3.2007 13702012

2014 2014-20109%

3150 2016

100

ELVIK, 2013

2014

Cameron et al, 2003 ;2014

2016-201543

2016

) 360 2014

135

1

1 .

2 .

3 .

4 .

5 .

2016-2015 44

3 1

1

23

2016-201545

1 . ,2014 100.2015 240

2 .22013 2012 2015-2012 3

20132014

2014

10

2

3 . 2015 324%

8% 2015

2016-2015 46

2015 3

4 .45% 3

2015 2.1%

4

5 .519% 2012 3

2016-201547

.2015 2.6%

5

6 .6 8585

85 6 15%19 2012 2015-2012

14 12 85 74%

3 19 85 6

2016-2015 48

7 .7

42 9 2014 2012.2014 30 2012

9 7

) 3 2012

240 2015 2014

13

23

2016-201549

2014

.25.2.16

2005

Cameron M., Newstead S., Diamantopoulou K., Oxley P. 2003. The

interaction between speed camera enforcement and speed-related

mass media publicity in Victoria. Report No. 201. Monash University –

Accident research center.

Elvik. R., 2013. A re-parameterisation of the Power Model of the relationship

between the speed of traffic and the number of accidents and accident

victims. Accident Analysis and Prevention, 50(1), 854-860.

2016-2015 50

Data:

P - number of poles (p= 1,..,P)

Q - number of groups of poles (i.e. cities, hot spots) (q = A,B,C,D…,Q)

STq - poles located in group q (STq P)

J - number of different types of punishments (j = 1,…J)

I - number of traffic courts (i=1,..,I)

E - number of tickets (for all types) that the encoder unit can handle

K - types of speed enforcement levels (function of speed limit) (k=1,..,K)

– expected number of tickets per type j produced at pole p at

speed enforcement level k during planning period

– expected % tickets per type j produced at pole p at speed enforcement

level k that go to court (the owner of the vehicle can ask for a court

summons instead of a fine)

– maximum number of court summons that Traffic Court i can handle

per planning period, i = 1,.., I

– expected utility of % of enforcement time at pole p at enforcement level k

during planning period (i.e. maximum reduction in road accidents

according to Power Model)

2016-201551

Decision variables

Xpk - % of time a camera at pole p is operated at speed enforcement level

k during planning period

Maximum Utility The

Power Model

1) Encoder unit capacity

2) Court unit capacity

3) Spatial constraints

4) Equality constraints

k=1,..,K5) The maximum is100%

≤1

2016-201553

2 1

2012 ) 3

2014

3

2015 2012 ) 3100 150

2014

3 1

BI 2

2016-2015 54

BI=Business intelligence

Elbashir et al., 2008Big Data

. Nenortaitė and Butleris, 2009

Negash, 2004

Cody et al., 2002

OLAP=Online) Data mining

Business performance analytical processing

Predictive analytics Benchmarking management

2012 ) 3

2014

.1

2016-201555

.2

.3

1

2

3

4

5

6

2016-2015 56

1

85

:1

14.33% 22015

120 350 32

2016-201557

3 2015 2

2015 2

33

:3

2016-2015 58

4 4 - 4

44

5What-if

2016-201559

:5

6

:6

2016-2015 60

1

24 3

5

6)7

20122012 3

2013.2015-2014

:7

2016-201561

3

2016-2015 62

Cody WF., Kreulem JT., Krishna V., Spangler WS. 2002. The integration of

business intelligence and knowledge management. IBM System Journal

41(4), 697-713.

Elbashir MZ., Collier PA., Davern MJ. 2008. Measuring the effects of business

intelligence systems: The relationship between business process and

organizational performance. International Journal of Accounting

Information Systems 9, 135–153.

Negash S., Business intelligence. 2004. Communications of the Association

for Information Systems, 13, 177-195.

Nenortaitė J., Butleris R. 2009. Improving business rules management

through the application of adaptive business intelligence technique.

Information Technology and Control 38(1), 21-28.

2016-201565

1

20%-30%

Dragutovnik & Twisk, 2005)

1

2016-2015 66

, National Safety Council, 2012)

.

2016-201567

CARRS, 2012

Dragutovnik & Twisk, 2005)

. Dragutovnik & Twisk, 2005 ;CARRS ,2012

NHTSA=National)9% Highway Traffic Safety Administration

10-5National Safety Council = NSC 11% 1%

National Safety Council , 2012

43% 7% 16% 24%

2016-2015 68

Walsh et al, 2008)

Gorman ,2014

1292.3% 2.3% 76%)

32%16% 5.4% 42%

42%

Dragutovnik & Twisk , 2005

26% NHTSA

1% 20145% 2013

Gorman,201422%

25% 71%Queensland

14%

28%

. CARRS, 2012

2011) NHTSA

,2011

400%

2016-201569

140% 28%

NHTSA, 2011

NHTSA, 2011) 83% Pew Research Center, 2015 2008

2015 17-1576% 92%

18-16 70% 201532% 42%

2014 30National Occupant Protection Use Survey) NOPUS

16-142014 4.8% 2007 1.0%

2014 5.8% 2007 8.8%1,700 AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety

8.6% 12%3.4%

Carney & McGehee, 2016)75-50

NHTSA, 2011

2016-2015 70

NHTSA , 2011

2014

Dragutovnik & Twisk, 2005

In) IVIS

Vehicle Information System

2016-201571

Dragutovnik & Twisk, 2005

NHTSA, 2011)

2015-2007

16 28 1,000

4

2015-2007 19%

20122015- 15%

2013

2015-2012

34%

2016-2015 72

1

1

1

2016-201573

.2013

22015-2013 2013-2012 26%

2015-2012 11% 8%2 1

2

3

50%

2016-2015 74

3

1 .

1

2 .

2016-201575

1 .

2 .

1,500 1,000 NHTSA, 20112,000

.

3 .

4 .

5 .

6 .

2016-2015 76

in-vehicle

2016-201577

2016-2015 78

2014

Carney, C., McGehee, D., Harland, K., Weiss, M., Raby, M. 2016. Using

Naturalistic Driving Data to Examine Teen Driver Behaviors Present in

Motor Vehicle Crashes, 2007-2015. AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.

CARRS (Centre for Accident Research & Road Safety-Queensland)-Mobile

phone use & distraction while driving .Research & Road Safety(2012).

Queensland “State of the Road Centre of Accident

Dragutinovic, N., Twisk, D. 2005. A literature review. Use of mobile phones

while driving – effects on road safety. SWOV - Institute for road

safety research.

Gorman, R. 2014. One in four car accidents caused by cell phone use while

driving but only five percent blame on texting. Mail on line news

National Safety Council. 2012. Understanding the distracted brain. Why

driving while using hands-free cell phones is risky behavior. White paper.

NHTSA (National Highway Traffic Safety Administration). 2011. Mobile

phone use: A growing problem of driver distraction.

Pew Research Center. 2015. U.S. Smartphone Use in 2015.

Walsh SP., White, KM., Hyde, MK., Watson B. 2008. Dialling and Driving:

Factors Influencing Intensions to Use a Mobile Phone While Driving.

Accidents Analysis and Prevention. 40(6), 1893-1900.

OECD

2016-201579

OECD1

1.2IRTAD IRTAD, 2016

38OECD

IRTAD

.OECD

1.2 1IRTAD, 2016

OECD

IRTAD) International Road Traffic and Accident Database

38 19882

EU - European Union OECD

1

2

2016-2015 80

1

OECD

,OECD

OECD

2016-201581

1 .50%

2 .

3 .

4 .

5 .

OECD 2

3 OECD

2016-2015 82

10,000

OECD 3

(OECD ITF

100,000 OECD

60

OECD

2016-201583

.39% 50%

IRTAD

WHO, 2015 2012 2008 40%

RSA, 2016

13% g l 0.5 OECD

g l 0 g l 0.4 26% g l 0.8

37% 14

47% 18

42% 16

13% 5

15% Kaufman & Wiebe, 2016)

2016-2015 84

ETSC, 2016

ETSC, 2016

OECD

65%-45%80%-54%

97% 6 4 74% 17

4

OECD

2016-201585

60% 20% 50WHO, 2015 80

50 OECD

30 60

100 8060 50

120

140-90 130

10ETSC, 2016

ISA-Intelligent Speed Assistance

2 1)

OECD 5IRTAD

2016-2015 86

5

OECD

7 6 OECD

8 OECD

6

OECD

2016-201587

7

2000 2013 8

OECD

52% OECD 2013 200056% OECD

.IRTAD 59%

2016-2015 88

OECD 9

OECD

IRTAD

.OECD

OECD

2016-201589

ETSC (2016). Lithuania to trial interlock on school busses.

ETSC (2016). Austria ti introduce alcohol interlock progamme next year.

ETSC (2016). France - road deaths increase as speeds creep up. ETSC 1.

IRTAD (2016). Road Safety Annual Report.

Kaufman EJ., Wiebe DJ.(2016). Impact of State Interlock Laws on Alcohol Involve

Crash Deaths in the United State. Am J Public Health, 106(5), 865-871.

OECD-ITF. (2016). Halving the Number of Road Death in Korea.

RSA (2016). Fatal Collisions 2008-2012 Alcohol as a Factor. Road Safety

Authority, Ireland.

WHO (2015). World Health Organization web site.

100

2016-201593

1003 2 2 1

100

1001,145 2010

66%

100

100

1

23

2016-2015 94

100

6

2003

6% 23%

20088-4

21

2007

2012

20032008

2009-2005 88%2009

16% 22%

2008

100

2016-201595

2011) Herzog&Hertwig 2008

2010) Lee & Zhang

2013) Moat et al

2011 2004 98

2016-2015 96

6

20052006

59%

21%16%

.1

.2

.1

.2

.3

2010 1,145

100

2016-201597

2012-2010

12

X2

t

1,145 153.69% 4

11.92%) 23.37% 30.69%)

4

2016-2015 98

1

368 777

169 608 777

255 482 7778 13 19

522 777.5 28 59 168

58 777308 40-24 334 24-18

65 77 65-40

X2

5

100

2016-201599

t

t 1

t p=0.62M=4.57, SD=11.16

M=3.54, SD=8.71

t p<0.05M=0.28, SD=0.71

M=0.19, SD=0.5

t p.<0.01]M=0.37, SD=0.85

M=0.22, SD=0.58)

2016-2015 100

t 1

t p>0.05]

t p.<0.01

M=0.37,SD=0.85

M=0.22, SD=0.58

t p>0.05]t p>0.05

N<31N<31

t

0.6, p>0.05t p>0.05

t

0.02, p>0.05t p>0.05

t

1.34, p>0.05t p>0.05

N<31N<31

t1.34, p>0.0

t p>0.05

N<31N<31

N<31N<31

100

2016-2015101

t p=0.62]

M=4.57, SD=11.16

M=3.54,SD=8.71

t p<0.05

M=0.28,SD=0.71

M=0.19, SD=0.5

65.61%

53.69%

11.92%

100

;2010 22% 15%11.92% 2012

2016-2015 102

2008

6 59% 2006)

11.92% 53.69%

100

100

10066%

100

12)

100

2016-2015103

2008

6 2006

2007

2012

The wisdom of the crowd, 2know .2008

http://www.kmrom.com/Site/Articles/ViewMagazineMonth.aspx?Year=200

8&Month=9&IsPrintView=0&P=58

2003

2012

,8 2010

2008

Hertwig, R., Herzog, SM. 2011. The wisdom of ignorant crowds: Predicting

sport outcomes by mere recognition. Judgment and Decision Making.

6(1), 58–72.

Zhang, S., Lee, MD. 2010. Cognitive Models and the Wisdom of Crowds:

A Case Study Using the Bandit Problem. Department of Cognitive

Sciences, University of California, USA.

Moat, HS., Preis, T., Stanley, HE. 2013. Quantifying Trading Behavior in

Financial Markets Using Google Trends.Nature.com, Scientific Reports. 3,

1684. doi: 10.1038/srep01684

2016-2015105

2 1 1 1

20123

1

3 2

2016-2015 106

33

3

3

3

33,715 20122013 2013

40 20146,970 12,700

5,900 6,050 6,140 2014 2,090

3 42,343 2014 2014

Perdaeny et al., 2008

2,266 106,625 104,359 3

2016-2015107

Gutierrez et al., 2008

1

3

3

3

1

3

2016-2015 108

12011-2007

800 2015-2012

902013

1

2016-2015109

13 2

5 4)

:1 3 2

3 2

2016-2015 110

3

2

5% 2%

3

2016-2015111

Becker, 1968

2 3

3

12

2016-2015 112

.

C A 3 1 B

1

A100%74%B57%89%C98%100%

A 1

2016-2015113

3

3

2016-2015 114

40 2014.12.8.14

2013

2014 2014

Becker GS. 1968. Crime and Punishment: An Economic Approach. Journal of

Political Economy, 76, 169-217.

Gutierrez RS., Ochoa C., Guerrero GC. 2008. Using ARENA simulation

software to predict hospital capabilities during CBRNE events. IIE Annual

Conference Proceedings, 1635-1640.

Perdaeny D., Armbrusteryz D., Kempe K., Lefebery E. 2008. Controlling a re-

entrant manufacturing line via the push-pull point. International Journal

of Production Research, 46(16), 4521-4536.

2016-2015117

1

201323%

WHO, 2015

Schieber and Thompson 1996, AAP 2009, WHO 2013a

6-12

2013

2013

1 .

2 .

1 .2015 1095

2016-2015 118

3 .

4 .

1 .2009-2012

3,085

8

2 .) 3 29

2,930

3 .

3 282

48

GIS)

2016-2015119

9-17

2009-2012

31%

56%

2013

Safe Kids 2013

15%35%

2016-2015 120

14

9% 4%

9 )

9

9-17

6.2% 2013 ) 3.3%

10

. NHTSA 2009, Sleet, D. 2012 )

70%

2016-2015121

70% 3041

p<0.001 )71%

15%

)

21%

;

2016-2015 122

)

.

WHO 2013a

5

10

Villanueva et al. 2012

WHO 2013a

9

2016-2015123

2016-2015 124

American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) (2009) Policy Statement- Pedestrian

Safety, Committee on Injury, Violence and Poison Prevention.

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration NHTSA (2009) Safe Routes

to School Guide Teaching Children to Walk Safely as They Grow and

Develop: A guide for parents and caregivers.

Safe Kids Worldwide (2013) Teens and Distraction: An In-Depth Look at

Teens’ Walking Behaviors.

Schieber, R.A. and Thompson, N.J. (1996). Developmental risk factors for

childhood pedestrian injuries. Injury Prevention, 2(3) 228-236.

Sleet, D. (2012). Promoting Child Pedestrian Injury Research. Editorial,

American Journal of Lifestyle Medecine vol. 6 no. 4 359-360.

Villanueva, K., Giles-Corti, B., Bulsara, M., McCormack, G. R., Timperio,

A., Middleton, N., Beesley, B. & Trapp, G. (2012). How far do children

travel from their homes? Exploring children’s activity spaces in their

neighborhood. Health & Place, 18(2), 263-273.

World Health Organization (2015) Ten Strategies for Keeping Children Safe

on the Road.

World Health Organization. (2013a). Pedestrian safety: a road safety manual

for decision-makers and practitioners. World Health Organization.

20132013.1086

2013

.1085

2016-2015127

1

2016

AV Autonomous

Vehicle

8 ITS ITS Intelligent Transportation Systems - Google 1

20142016

3

1

2016-2015 128

1

http www sagmart com US Approves Googles AI Oriented Self-Driving Car

. Intelligent Transportation Systems) ITS

ITS

ITS

2016 V2V Vehicle to

Vehicle

2016-2015129

: Level of Automation 0-4

Level

0

1

2

3

4

2016 16

AON A260

40

2016-2015 130

1 33 2

2

http www newyorker com cartoons a

40

2016-2015131

65

2000

2000

AV

V2I Vehicle to Infrastructures V2V

10050

AV

250

7

1360

6

2016-2015 132

3

Autonomous Vehicle Design Challenges Lindsay Farlow Electronic

.Design Services 2013

3

4

The connected car sign the end of the traffic lights Alain Clapaud, April 2015

2016-2015133

98% ILS, 2 ,Fly by Wire

3,CAS VOR

Time Sharing Car Sharing

Car Sharing

Time Sharing

2

Fly by Wire 2

CAS ILS, VOR 3

2016-2015 134

1500 80

19575

5

2016-2015135

European ETSI ITS G5) :ITS

US IEEE1609) :ITS

1957

The connected car sign the end of the traffic lights? Alain Clapaud, April 2015

http://www.newyorker.com/cartoons/a19697

http://www.sagmart.com US Approves Google’s AI Oriented Self-Driving Car

NHTSA - statement of - policy on automated vehicles