2nd annual malthus lecture "feeding the world sustainably" by ismail serageldin

Feeding the World Sustainably: Reflections, Issues, and Suggestions

Ismail Serageldin2nd Malthus Lecture

IFPRI – Washington, DC14 July 2011

Outline

• Challenging Malthus• On Hunger • On Hunger And Poverty• Food Security• The Gender Dimension• The Environmental Dimension• The Role Of science• The Power Of Policy• Transforming Global Agriculture• Envoi

Challenging Malthus

Challenging Malthus

• Malthus was wrong• He could never have

imagined a world with 6.7 billion people

• Human ingenuity was able to provide more food out of the same resources

• Hunger and famine persist for other reasons

5/480

In USA Today: 20 % Of Children and 65% Of Adults Are Obese

The Abolitionists

William Wilberforced. 1833

10/480

Abolishing Slavery

Abraham Lincoln Frederick Douglas

We Must Abolish Hunger!

We must become

The New Abolitionists!

So far, we could abolish hunger…But… Things can change…

17/480

World Population, in Billions 1950-2050

Source: United Nations Population Division, World Population Prospects, The 2008 Revision.

Malthus Strikes Back!

• Malthus was wrong up to now

• What about a world of 10 Billion, with richer diets and increasing animal proteins?

• What about our energy policies and climate change?

On Hunger

We take abundant food for granted

BUTAbout One Billion persons are chronically

malnourished!

http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/es/Hunger_Portal/Hunger_Map_2010b.pdf

Sub-Saharan Africa Remains most vulnerable region

After prolonged drought, Again, Today, Famine

Stalks Millions in East Africa

(Source: The Economist July 9, 2011, p.35

Humanitarian Food Aid will continue to

be needed in hotspots and must

be provided for

Trends in world hunger, 2010

Global Hunger Index, 2010

Three equally weighted indicators constitute the GHI:

1. Undernourished as % of the population (reflecting the share of the population with insufficient dietary energy intake)

2. Underweight as % of Children < 5 years old (indicating the proportion of children suffering from low weight for their age)

3. Mortality rate of Children < 5 years old (partially reflecting the fatal synergy between inadequate dietary intake and unhealthy environments)

Global Hunger Index, 2010

• > 5.0 Low hunger

• 5.0 - 9.9 Moderate hunger

• 10.0 - 19.9 Serious

• 20.0 - 29.9 Alarming

• ≥ 30.0 Extremely

alarmingThe index ranks countries on a 100-point scale, with 0 being the best score (no hunger) and 100 being the worst, although neither of these extremes is reached in practice.

29/480

GNP per Capita and Global Hunger Index, 2010

2010

GH

I

GNP per Capita, 2005-07

SUB-SAHARAN AFRICA

Congo, Dem. Rep.

BurundiEritrea

EthiopiaChad

Sierra LeoneAngola

Djibouti

Cameroon

Congo, Rep.

NamibiaBotswana

GabonMauritius

South Africa

SwazilandGhana

MauritaniaLesotho UgandaCote d’Ivoire

SenegalBenin

Guinea

Malawi Gambia

MaliKenya

Nigeria

Tanzania

Togo

Guinea-Bissau

MozambiqueRwanda

Eritrea Zambia

Niger

Central African Rep.Madagascar

Comoros

Burkina Faso

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 20,000

30/480

GNP per Capita, 2005-07

MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA

Yemen

MoroccoSyrian Arab. Rep.

Jordan

Egypt

TunisiaAlgeria

Lebanon

Iran, Islamic Republic

TurkeyLibya Saudi Arabia

2010

GH

I

45

40

35

30

25

20

15

10

5

GNP per Capita and Global Hunger Index, 2010

2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 20,000

Global Hunger Index, 2010

33

34/480

Kevin Carter’s Pulitzer Prize winning photo 1994

38/480

Kevin Carter(1960 - 1994)

39/480

On Hunger And Poverty

40/480

The Primary Cause Of Hunger Is Extreme Poverty

41/480

Amartya Sen on Famines

42/480

Norman Borlaug(1914 – 2009)

43/480

Food whether you buy it or grow it yourself

44/480

Observation: Many rural poor continue to pay for their food needs

Source: cited in http://www.ifad.org/rural/rpr2010/background/9.pdf

Sellers

Buyers

Self-Sufficient

45/480

So we have to reduce the price f food, by increasing production

sustainably, reducing waste, and ensuring access

46/480

What about the poor small-holder farmers who are major producers of food? They will become even

poorer…

47/480

Source: Production: FAOSTAT Electronic Database, FAO.10June2003Rice Price: Relate to Thai rice 5%-broken deflated by G-5 MUV Index deflator (adjusted based on 2002 data update)Source: World Bank Quarterly Review of Commodity Markets

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2002

Year

Pro

du

ctio

n o

f u

nm

ille

d r

ice

(mil

lio

n t

)

0

300

600

900

1200

1500

1800

Ric

e p

rice

s (2

002

US

$/to

n)

Rice production

Riceprice

Raise productivity for small-holder farmers faster than the prices drop

Trends in world rice production and price adjusted for inflation, 1961-2002

48/480

Source: Production: FAOSTAT Electronic Database, FAO.10June2003Rice Price: Relate to Thai rice 5%-broken deflated by G-5 MUV Index deflator (adjusted based on 2002 data update)Source: World Bank Quarterly Review of Commodity Markets

Rice production

Riceprice

Raise productivity of small-holder farmers faster than the price of food drops

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2002

Year

Pro

du

ctio

n o

f u

nm

ille

d r

ice

(mil

lio

n t

)

0

300

600

900

1200

1500

1800

Ric

e p

rice

s (2

002

US

$/to

n)

World rice production and prices adjusted for inflation, 1961-2002

49/480

Food security is to ensure for each individual, at all times,

access to the food they need in enough quantity and quality,

produced in a sustainable manner.

50/480

An Enormous Gap Exists Between the Rich and the Poor…

51/48051

52/480

53/480Rich and Poor in Sao Paulo

source: http://mindblog.dericbownds.net/2007/10/rich-and-poor.html

54/480

It is not just the absence of income that defines poverty

55/480

It is marginalization, deprivation and social exclusion

56/480

Loss of dignity

57/480Social Exclusion

58/480

Rural and Urban Poverty in Developing Countries

Source: IFPRI estimate from World Bank data.

Rural poor70.0%

Urban poor

30.0%

59/480

The Ultra Poor require special help

60/480

61/480

62/480

Much Economic Analysis Erases the Human Factor

63/480

64/480

Thoughtful use of multiple indicators for analysis will lead

to richer and more nuanced policy and program design

65/480

MPAT:Multidimensional Poverty Assessment Tool

(Developed by IFAD)

66/480

MPAT

Organizational diagram of MPAT's components and subcomponents

MPAT

7 Farm Assets7.1 Land tenure7.2 Land quality7.3 Crop inputs7.4 Livestock/aquaculture

8 Non-Farm Assets8.1 Employment & skills8.2 Financial services

8.3 Fixed assets & remittances

2. Domestic Water Supply2.1 Quality2.2 Availability2.3 Access

1 Food & Nutrition 1.1Security Consumption1.2 Access stability1.3 Nutrition quality

6 Education6.1 Quality6.2 Availability6.3 Access

3. Health & Healthcare3.1 Health status3.2 Access & affordability3.3 Healthcare quality

4. Sanitation & Hygiene4.1Toilet facility4.2Waste management4.3 Hygiene practices

10 Gender & Social Equality 10.1 Access to education10.2 Access to healthcare

10.3 Social equality

9 Exposure & Resilience to Shocks

9.1 Exposure9.2 Coping ability

9.3 Recovery ability

5 Housing, Clothing & Energy5.1 Housing structure quality5.2 Clothing 5.3 Energy sources

67/480

Urban poverty

68/480

69/480

70/480

71/480

72/480

Reaching the Poorest

Garbage pickers in the Philippines

73/480

Urban Poverty

74/480

Three Key strategies to cope with Urban Poverty and Hunger

• Reduce the price of food

• Increase the opportunities for employment of the poor

• Increase the returns to the kind of skills and assets that the poor have

75/480

The Urban Poor mostly buy their food

76/480

And food is a major part of their budget – Hence their wellbeing is very sensitive to the

price of food

77/480

Three Key strategies to cope with Urban Poverty and Hunger

• Reduce the price of food

• Increase the opportunities for employment of the poor

• Increase the returns to the kind of skills and assets that the poor have

78/480

The poor lack the skills for the high Tech jobs the market offers, and are unlikely to get these skills quickly

79/480

80/480

Three Key strategies to cope with Urban Poverty and Hunger

• Reduce the price of food

• Increase the opportunities for employment of the poor

• Increase the returns to the kind of skills and assets that the poor have

81/480

82/480

Three Key strategies to cope with Urban Poverty and Hunger

• Reduce the price of food

• Increase the opportunities for employment of the poor

• Increase the returns to the kind of skills and assets that the poor have

83/480

Urban Agriculture on roofs and

between buildings on vacant land

84/480

On Hunger And Rural Poverty

85/480

86/480

87/480

Reform Policies And Markets

• Remove urban bias– Roads– Education– Health– Etc.

• Improve access to markets• Reduce post harvest losses

88/480

89/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

90/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

91/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

92/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

93/480

94/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

95/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

96/480

Challenges Facing Small Farms

• Globalization, including super-markets even in poor countries.

• Low world market prices for agriculture.

• Climate change. • HIV/AIDS • Continuing population growth that is

making small farms smaller. • No political voice.

97/480

Food Security

98/480

Food security is to ensure for each individual, at all times,

access to the food they need in enough quantity and quality,

produced in a sustainable manner.

99/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

100/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

101/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

102/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

103/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

104/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

105/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

106/480

Food Security

• Not Just production, also access• Not Just output, also process• Not Just technology, also policy• Not Just global, also national• Not Just national, also household• Not Just rural, also urban• Not Just amount, also content

107/480

Understanding Food Security

Short Term Medium Term

Long Term

Local Access, Nutrition

National Policies Research Investment

Global Sustainable Production, Fair Trade

108/480

Understanding Food Security

Short Term Medium Term

Long Term

Local Access, Nutrition

National Policies Research Investment

Global Sustainable Production, Fair Trade

109/480

Global Food ProductionMust Grow by+40% by 2030

&+70% by 2050

Opening statement by IFAD President at the Jeddah Economic Forum 2010: “The Global Economy in 2020” http://www.ifad.org/events/op/2010/jeddah.htm

110/480

Food Security and Production

• Production is a necessary but not sufficient condition for food security

• Focusing on the small-holder farmer in developing countries is key to environmental protection, poverty reduction and food security

111/480

“We are all on this earth as guests of the green plants and those who tend them.”

-- M.S. Swaminathan

112/480

113/480

114/480

115/480

The response is to produce differently, not less

116/480

117/480

118/480

Seven Statements About Food Security

119/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

120/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

121/480

How to reduce prices without harming the poor farmers who

produce food?

122/480

Source: Production: FAOSTAT Electronic Database, FAO.10June2003Rice Price: Relate to Thai rice 5%-broken deflated by G-5 MUV Index deflator (adjusted based on 2002 data update)Source: World Bank Quarterly Review of Commodity Markets

Rice production

Riceprice

Raise productivity of small-holder farmers faster than the price of food drops

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2002

Year

Pro

du

ctio

n o

f u

nm

ille

d r

ice

(mil

lio

n t

)

0

300

600

900

1200

1500

1800

Ric

e p

rice

s (2

002

US

$/to

n)

World rice production and prices adjusted for inflation, 1961-2002

123/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

124/480

SRI has increased output dramatically, with the same inputs

125/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

126/480

In the poor countries, post-harvest losses reach up to 30% of the crops

127/480

Reduce Post-Harvest Losses

128/480Storage and post-harvest losses

129/480

In the rich countries: Up to 30% of cooked food is thrown out

130/480

Up to 20% of purchased food is thrown out unused, in its wrapper

131/480

132/480

133/480

X

134/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

135/480

Homeless, nameless…

136/480

137/480

Address Short-term Vulnerability

• Most farmers live precariously

• Downside is devastating

• Climate change is increasing vulnerability

138/480

139/480

Climate Variability (Change?)Index of Rainfall in Sahel 1941-1990

-1.50

-1.00

-0.50

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

1940 1945 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985

Source: Departure from standard deviation; Climate Prediction Center 1991, Prrsentation by South Africa at Camdessus Panel meetings

140/480

Climate Variability (Change?)Index of Rainfall in Sahel 1941-1990

-1.50

-1.00

-0.50

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

1940 1945 1950 1955 1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985

Source: Departure from standard deviation; Climate Prediction Center 1991, Prrsentation by South Africa at Camdessus Panel meetings

141/480

Extension Must bring Research To These Farmers

142/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

143/480

Better Nutrition

144/480

White and Golden Rice

145/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

146/480

In addition to the first generation of biofuels (Ethanol from Corn)

147/480

Ethanol from Corn contributes to 2008

food price spike

148/480

It is wrong to burn the food of the

poor to drive the cars of the rich!

149/480

We must move to second generation biofuels

150/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

151/480

152/480

153/480

US Ag Subsidies 1994-2005

% of recipients

% of Pay-ments

Number of recipients

Payments Received

Payments per recipient

Top 1% 23% 31,294 $33.7 Billion $1.07 million

Top 4% 50% 125,176 $71.3 Billion $569,650

Top 10% 72% 312,940 $104 Billion $332,793

Top 20% 87% 625,880 $126 Billion $200,946

Lower 80% 13% 2,503,522 $18 Billion $7,211

154/480

Cows Vs. People

• A typical cow in the European Union receives a government subsidy of $2.20 a day –

• more than what 2.5 billion of the world's poorest people live on every day.

• Twice what 1.2 billion of the world's poorest people live on every day.

155/480

$2.20 / day $0.90 / day

156/480

157/480

• Increase production and productivity

• Better management

• Reduce losses, reduce waste

• Manage vulnerability (CC)

• BioFortification

• BioFuels

• International Trade

Food Security: Seven Statements

158/480

The Gender Dimension

159/480

And We Must Never Forget the Gender Dimension…

160/480

Women In Africa

• Produce80% of the food

• Receive 10% of the wages

• Own1% of the land

161/480

Women Empowerment

• Essential to recognize the gender dimension of agriculture

• Empowering Women results in major improvements in infant mortality, school enrolments, child morbidity

162/480

Women Empowerment

• Women have unequal opportunity in:– Education– Health care– Income– Credit– Employment– Assets– Decision-making

163/480

164/480

The key vector to fight infant mortality and child malnutrition is

Maternal Health

165/480

From the sixth month of pregnancy…

166/480

…To the 18th month of life…

167/480

The period when children are most vulnerable to hunger

168/480

Malnurished mothers give birth to low birth weight babiesand

Malnourished children often suffer from growth retardation and weight loss

169/480

Breast Milk has the Best Nutritional Value

170/480

A Healthy Mother…

• Gives birth to a baby of normal weight.

• Breast feed her baby well.

• Will be able to find good food to wean her baby.

171/480

The Environmental Dimension

172/480

Climate ChangeThe Most serious Issue Facing Humanity

173/480

174/480

Hurricane Bonnie

175/480

Source: National Geographic, August, 2005

176/480

Source: National Geographic, August, 2005

177/480

Can this be just a “natural phenomenon”?

NO!

178/480GHG emissions are a key contributor

179/480

180/480

Should we be concerned?

YES!

181/480

182/480Source: The Economist – The World in 2007

183/480

How serious is the problem?

VERY!

184/480

185/480

The Nile:Reaches Cairo with 12 million Tons of salts

Reaches the sea with 34 million tons of salts

186/480

Impact on Nile Delta

187/480

188/480

But Also increased Floods, Droughts, Forest Fires and Desertification

189/480

Climate Change and

Food Security:

Changes in Length of growing period 2000-2005

Thronton, et.al., cited in Greg Mock and Paul Steele, “Power to the poor: tapping the wealth of ecosystems”, in Environment, vol 48: 1; Jan/Feb 2006, p. 15

190/480

We need urgent action on bothMitigation

&Adaptation

191/480

Mitigation: Reducing Emissions

192/480

How will all that affect HUNGER?

193/480

We observe…

• Floods in Pakistan

• Droughts in Russia

• Hurricanes hitting the Caribbean and the USA

194/480

195/480

We observe…

• Floods in Pakistan

• Droughts in Russia

• Hurricanes hitting the Caribbean and the USA

196/480

197/480

Droughts and Floods?

198/480

Yes, The Models predict that Both will co-exist

199/480

We observe…

• Floods in Pakistan

• Droughts in Russia

• Hurricanes hitting the Caribbean and the USA

200/480

Hurricanes and floods

in USA

201/480

All these intemperate weather conditions lead to stresses on

food production

202/480

The Food on which we all depend

203/480

Drought Devastates Agriculture

204/480

That leads to More Hunger

205/480

Above all, Science must be mobilized

206/480

The Role Of Science

207/480

From the Green Revolution to the Doubly Green Revolution

208/480

209/480

AREA SAVEDIndia -- All Cereals,1960-1990

Total production: 1961: 87million tons -- 1990 :197 million tons

50

100

150

200

250

1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990

Millions of Hectares

AREA USED

AREA SAVED

210/480

211/480

212/480

213/480

214/480

Doubly green revolution

• More genetically diverse crops• Less chemical inputs (IPM and other

means)• Integrated soil, water and nutrient

management• Small holder farming system context,

environmentally and socio-economically

215/480

216/480

217/480

218/480

219/480

Recognize The Gender Dimension

220/480

Promoting Alternatives to Slash and Burn

221/480

AlwaysPro-Poor

Pro-Women Pro-Environment

222/480

A Double Shift in the Research Paradigm:

-- Contextualization-- The new life sciences

223/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

224/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

225/480

Land Use Transitions

Source: J.A. Foley, et.al., Global Consequences of Land Use, in Science, 22 July 2005, v.309, pp.570-574

226/480

227/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

228/480

Water Is Also a Constraint

229/480

230/480

One Calorie = One Liter

231/480

232/480

233/480

234/480

235/480

236/480

More Crop Per Drop!

237/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

238/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

239/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A

240/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A

241/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Close the Yield Gap

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A B

242/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Close the Yield Gap

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A B

243/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Close the Yield Gap

Sustain the Current Yield

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A B C

244/480

Three Themes in Rice Researchfor Increased Production

Source: Gurdev Khush, Lecture at BioVision Lyon 2005

Raise the Yield Ceiling

Close the Yield Gap

Sustain the Current Yield

Yield (t/ha)

Ceiling

Current

A B C

245/480

Let’s take them by turn

246/480

Technologies for Increasing the Yield Potential

247/480

Different Plant Types of Rice Conventional Improved NPT

248/480

New Plant Type Rice

249/480

Technologies for Closing the Yield Gap

250/480

Biological cost of weeds, Diseases and Insects

CropPercent of Yield Potential

Weeds Disease Insects

Rice 10.6 9.0 27.3

Wheat 9.8 9.5 5.4

Maize 13.1 9.6 12.9

Millets & Sorghum

17.9 10.3 9.5

Barley 8.8 8.3 3.9

251/480

Biological Control

252/480

IPM: Working With Nature

• Bio-control• Pheromone trap• Need-based chemicals• Host-plant resistance• Etc.

253/480

Reaction to Bacterial BlightResistant Susceptible

254/480

Stem-Borer Larvae from Transgenic Rice (top) and Control (bottom)

255/480

4. Raise Agricultural Productivity

• Productivity must rise faster than price declines to generate surpluses for the small-holder farmers and reduce their poverty as their cheaper products help reduce the poverty in the cities

• Measure in terms of Total Factor Productivity (land, water, labor, energy and chemical inputs)

256/480

• increasing the yield potential

• closing the yield gap, including pest

management

• Soil, water & nutrient management

• Labor & capital input management

• developing nutritious crops (more later)

Technologies Needed For:

257/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

258/480

259/480

260/480

Increasing demand for feed

261/480

A Huge Increase In Feed Requirements

262/480

Not Just for Food

263/480

Conversion Into Proteins(% of Feed that is converted to Protein)

Source: Time magazine, 18 July 2011, p. 29

Beef Pork Poultry Fish

25%

13%

5%

264/480

Conversion Into Proteins(% of Feed that is converted to Protein)

Source: Time magazine, 18 July 2011, p. 29

Beef Pork Poultry Fish

25%

13%

5%

30%

265/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

266/480Source: William S. Alevizon, Pisces Guide to Caribbean Reef Ecology, Gulf Publishing Company (1994).

267/480

268/480

269/480

Global Seafood consumption has increased dramatically, and natural fish stocks are heavily overfished

270/480

Global Aquaculture Production:1950 = one million tons2008 = 47.3 million tons

271/480

But Aquaculture is still only about 50% of consumption in 2011

272/480

Our Reefs Today:The Challenge and the Response

273/480

• Land

• Water

• Plants

• Animals

• The Role Of Aquatic Resources

The Role Of Science

274/480

But

What about

Biotechnology

?

The Role Of Science

275/480

Biotechnology

• Promise and perils• Partnerships for benign

applications• Public-private• CGIAR-NARS-AROs-NGOs

276/480

277/480

278/480

Global Area of Biotech Crops.Million of Hectares (1996 to 2009)

1996 2009200820072006200520042003200220012000199919981997

200

180

140

120

80

60

40

20

0

100

160

14 million farmers in 25 countries planted 134 million hectares (330 million acres in 2009, a sustained increase of 7% or 9 million hectares (22 million acres) compared to 2008.

DevelopingIndustrials

Total HectaresTrait Hectares

Source: Clive James, 2009.

279/480

280/480

Modern biotechnology

• Raises profound issues• Despite controversy, has enormous

promise• Can do things we cannot do by

conventional breeding – e.g. Vitamin A rice

281/480

It is a tool, like any other.It should not be demonized nor

assumed to be a miracle.

282/480

The Power Of Policy

283/480

Policy Counts

284/480

Sustainable development does not mean that people will live worse…

285/480

Let’s look at income and health

286/480

Life Expectancy versus Per Capita GNP Best Fit Relation by Decade

(Thousands)

Per Capita GNP (1980 US$)

Life

Exp

ecta

ncy

19871980

1970

19501961

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

287/480

Life Expectancy versus Per Capita GNP Best Fit Relation by Decade

(Thousands)

Per Capita GNP (1980 US$)

Life

Exp

ecta

ncy

19871980

1970

19501961

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

288/480

Life Expectancy versus Per Capita GNP Best Fit Relation by Decade

(Thousands)

Per Capita GNP (1980 US$)

Life

Exp

ecta

ncy

19871980

1970

19501961

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

289/480

Life Expectancy versus Per Capita GNP Best Fit Relation by Decade

(Thousands)

Per Capita GNP (1980 US$)

Life

Exp

ecta

ncy

19871980

1970

19501961

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

290/480

That is to say that well conceived, well targeted policies can be the equivalent of a general increase in average incomes by 8X with

laissez-faire

8X!!!

291/480

Transforming Global Agriculture

292/480

Agriculture Is A Complex FieldSummary for Decision Makers of the Global Report, IAASTD, 2009

Source: http://www.agassessment.org/docs/IAASTD_GLOBAL_SDM_JAN_2008.pdf

293/480

Managing Agriculture is a complex task:Summary for Decision Makers of the Global Report, IAASTD, 2009

294/480

Ten Commandments For Global Agriculture

295/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

296/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

297/480

1. Reform Policies And Markets

• Globally: Fair trade

• Locally: – Remove urban bias– Improve access to markets– reduce post harvest losses

298/480

299/480

1. Reform Policies And Markets

• Globally: Fair trade

• Locally: – Remove urban bias (educ., health, etc.)– Improve access to markets– reduce post harvest losses

300/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

301/480

So, dealing with global poverty requires that we address rural poverty…AND

A special focus on small-holder farmers in developing countries in particular to address the problem of food security

302/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

303/480

3. Husband Natural Resources

• Agriculture is the major interface between people and nature

• Sustainable development is beneficial for all

• Resource degradation hits the poor worst

304/480

The Most Important Environmental Action Is to Reduce the Need for

More Land Under Cultivation

305/480

It will preserve habitats and biodiversity

306/480

307/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

308/480

4. Raise Agricultural Productivity

• Productivity must rise faster than price declines to generate surpluses for the small-holder farmers and reduce their poverty as their cheaper products help reduce the poverty in the cities

• Measure in terms of Total Factor Productivity (land, water, labor, energy and chemical inputs)

309/480

Source: Production: FAOSTAT Electronic Database, FAO.10June2003Rice Price: Relate to Thai rice 5%-broken deflated by G-5 MUV Index deflator (adjusted based on 2002 data update)Source: World Bank Quarterly Review of Commodity Markets

Rice production

Riceprice

Raise productivity of small-holder farmers faster than the price of food drops

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

1961 1965 1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2002

Year

Pro

du

ctio

n o

f u

nm

ille

d r

ice

(mil

lio

n t

)

0

300

600

900

1200

1500

1800

Ric

e p

rice

s (2

002

US

$/to

n)

World rice production and prices adjusted for inflation, 1961-2002

310/480

Future Challenges

To Produce More Food

Increasing

Population

Less Water

Less Land

Less Labor

Less Chemicals

311/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

312/480

5. Improve Nutritional Content

• Enormous health benefits

• Bio-fortification is just the beginning

• Edible vaccines?

313/480

Without With

Sweet Potatoes with and Without Beta-Carotene

314/480

315/480

Longer, More Productive Lives

316/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

317/480

6. Address Short-term Vulnerability

• Most farmers live precariously

• Downside is devastating

• Climate change is increasing vulnerability

318/480

319/480

320/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

321/480

7. Empower Women

• Essential to recognize the gender dimension of agriculture

• Empowering Women results in major improvements in infant mortality, school enrolments, child morbidity

322/480

323/480

324/480

325/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

326/480

8. Reach Out To The Ultra-Poor

• Market incentives do not work for the ultra-poor

• Trickle-down does not work

• Special Programs will be needed

327/480

328/480

329/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

330/480

9. Support Science

• We need more support for science in developing countries

• Not just technology

331/480331

332/480332

333/480

The Divide in S&T Capacity

334/480

335/480

336/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

337/480

RhetoricDeclarationsPlansTargets

Action

338/480

“We have the capacity to eliminate

hunger from the face of the earth in

our lifetime. We need only the

will.”

President John F. KennedyWorld Food Congress 1963

339/480

340/480

The Ten Commandments For Transforming Global Agriculture

1. Reform Policies And Markets 2. Focus On Small-holder Farmers3. Husband Natural Resources4. Raise Agricultural Productivity5. Improve Nutritional Content6. Address Short-term Vulnerability7. Empower Women8. Reach Out To The Ultra-poor9. Support Science 10. Translate Rhetoric Into Action

341/480

Envoi

342/480

All the Parts Are Essential:They Reinforce Each Other

343/480

The Whole Is More Than the Sum of the Parts

344/480

Diagnosis

• How to find the key pressure points in the system

• How to choose interventions that will have maximum impact on these

• Must focus on raising productivity in the complex ecosystem of the small holder farm

• Must bring science and other inputs to the farmers

345/480

No policy or program will ever be sufficient alone

We need a range of interventions…

Many existing policies need to be adjusted and many new programs need to be developed.

346/480

Several policies and programs need to be developed for:

• Agriculture• Environment• Social Issues• Political Issues• Participation• Gender• Urbanization• Poverty• Infrastructure• Economy

• Trade• Marketing• Public/Private

Interface• Finance and credit• Local, National,

Régional and International Issues

• And more …

347/480

348/480

349/480

It can be Mastered and Solved

350/480

351/480

Dare to dream!

Dare to be bold!

352/480

The specter of Malthus still haunts the world…

353/480

We can abolish Hunger

354/480

Our groupThe New Abolitionists

Limited size, limited resources

355/480

The Oppositioncynics, entrenched interests & the inertia of current injustice

Large size, unlimited resources

356/480

But we will surprise the World!

357/480

Thank You

358/480

359/480

The images used in this presentation are strictly for the educational purpose of this lecture. Any use by anyone for

any other purpose should be after consulting the copyright owners of

these pictures

360/480