auto-oil advisory panel voice vote seq. vie to...

Auto-Oil Advisory Panel Voice Vote

Seq. VIE to BallotSept. 8, 2016

1

Auto Oil Advisory Panel Voting Membership

2

Auto Members Oil Members Oil MembersDaihatsu Motor Co., Ltd BP Lubricants Afton ChemicalFiat Chrysler Automobiles Chevron Lubricants BASFFord Motor Company ExxonMobil Calumet Fuji Heavy Ind. (Subaru) Idemitsu ChemturaGeneral Motors Imperial Croda, Inc.Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Petro-Canada Dow ChemicalMazda Motor Corp. Phillips 66 Company Evonik Oil Additives USAMitsubishi Motors Corp. Pinnacle InfineumNISSAN Motor Co. Ltd Safety-Kleen LubrizolSUZUKI Motor Co., Ltd Shell Global Solutions MotivaToyota Motor Corporation SK Lubricants Neste Oil

Total OroniteValvoline Vanderbilt Chemicals

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

3

Auto Members1 Daihatsu Motor Co., Ltd Shinichi KITAMURA Shinichi_Kitamura@dk.daihatsu.co.jp

2 Fiat Chrysler Automobiles Haiying Tang haiying.tang@fcagroup.com

3 Ford Motor Company Ron Romano rromano@ford.com

4 Fuji Heavy Ind. (Subaru) Yusuke KUWAHARA kuwahara.yusuke@subaru-fhi.co.jp

5 General Motors Eric R Johnson Eric.R.Johnson@GM.com

6 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Takeshi Hatta takeshi_hatta@n.t.rd.honda.co.jp

7 Mazda Motor Corp. Yoichi KUJI kuji.y@mazda.co.jp

8 Mitsubishi Motors Corp. Hideo KURASHINA hideo.kurashina@mitsubishi-motors.com

9 NISSAN Motor Co. Ltd Takumaru SAGAWA t-sagawa@mail.nissan.co.jp

10 SUZUKI Motor Co., Ltd Toshio YAMAUCHI toshioy@hhq.suzuki.co.jp

11 Toyota Motor Corporation Teri Kowalski teri.kowalski@tema.toyota.com

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

4

Oil Members1 BP Lubricants Barbara Dennis barbara.dennis@bp.com

2 Chevron Lubricants Matthew Ansari ansa@chevron.com

3 ExxonMobil Mike Blumenfeld michael.l.blumenfeld@exxonmobil.com

4 Idemitsu Scott Rajala Srajala@ILACorp.com

5 Imperial Doug Hakala Doug.Hakala@esso.ca

6 Petro-Canada Darryl Purificati DPurificati@Suncor.com

7 Phillips 66 Company Reginald Dias reginald.m.dias@P66.com

8 Pinnacle Antonio Medina AMedina@pinnoil.com

9 Safety-Kleen Rodney Walker Rodney.Walker@safety-kleen.com

10 Shell Global Solutions Scott Lindholm Scott.Lindholm@Shell.com

11 SK Lubricants Mike Brown mike.brown@sk.com

12 Total James Linden lindenjim@jlindenconsulting.com

13 Valvoline Thom Smith trsmith@Valvoline.com

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

5

Oil Members14 Afton Chemical Brent Calcut Brent.Calcut@AftonChemical.com

15 BASF Eugene Scanlon Eugene.scanlon@basf.com

16 Calumet Christopher L. Miano Chris.Miano@CLMT.com

17 Chemtura E. Brian Fox brian.fox@chemtura.com

18 Croda, Inc. Scott A. Davis Scott.Davis@croda.com

19 Dow Chemical Ashish Kotnis AKotnis@dow.com

20 Evonik Oil Additives USA Don Smolenski Don.Smolenski@Evonik.com

21 Infineum Joan Evans joan.evans@infineum.com

22 Lubrizol Gail Evans Gail.Evans@Lubrizol.com

23 Motiva Greg Raley Gregory.Raley@Motivaent.com

24 Neste Oil Chris Castanien Chris.castanien@nesteoil.com

25 Oronite Robert Stockwell rsto@chevron.com

26 Vanderbilt Chemicals Carl Esche CEsche@VanderbiltChemicals.com

Ballot Motion

Send to AOAP Ballot: Sequence VIE Test is acceptable for measuring fuel economy and fuel economy retention of engine oils and will be included in proposed GF-6A Specification.

Motion by: Scott LindholmSecond: Matthew Ansari

6

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

7

Auto Members Motion 11 Daihatsu Motor Co., Ltd Shinichi KITAMURA Yes

2 Fiat Chrysler Automobiles Haiying Tang Yes

3 Ford Motor Company Ron Romano Yes

4 Fuji Heavy Ind. (Subaru) Yusuke KUWAHARA Yes

5 General Motors Eric R Johnson Yes

6 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Hatta Takeshi Yes

7 Mazda Motor Corp. Yoichi KUJI Yes

8 Mitsubishi Motors Corp. Hideo KURASHINA Yes

9 NISSAN Motor Co. Ltd Takumaru SAGAWA Yes

10 SUZUKI Motor Co., Ltd Toshio YAMAUCHI Yes

11 Toyota Motor Corporation Teri Kowalski Yes

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

8

Oil Members Motion 11 BP Lubricants Barbara Dennis Yes

2 Chevron Lubricants Matthew Ansari Yes

3 ExxonMobil Mike Blumenfeld Yes

4 Idemitsu Scott Rajala Yes

5 Imperial Doug Hakala Yes

6 Petro-Canada Darryl Purificati Yes

7 Phillips 66 Company Reginald Dias Yes

8 Pinnacle Antonio Medina Not Present

9 Safety-Kleen Rodney Walker Yes

10 Shell Global Solutions Scott Lindholm Yes

11 SK Lubricants Mike Brown -

12 Total James Linden Yes

13 Valvoline Thom Smith Yes

Auto Oil Advisory Panel

9

Oil Members Motion 114 Afton Chemical Brent Calcut Yes

15 BASF Eugene Scanlon Yes

16 Calumet Christopher L. Miano Yes

17 Chemtura E. Brian Fox Yes

18 Croda, Inc. Scott A. Davis Not Present

19 Dow Chemical Ashish Kotnis Not Present

20 Evonik Oil Additives USA David Gray Yes

21 Infineum Joan Evans Yes

22 Lubrizol Gail Evans Yes

23 Motiva Greg Raley Yes

24 Neste Oil Chris Castanien Yes

25 Oronite Robert Stockwell Yes

26 Vanderbilt Chemicals Simon Tung Yes

Ballot Summary

Affirmative Negative Abstain Did Not Vote

Total Votes

Auto Ballot Totals 11 0 0 0 11Oil Ballot Totals 23 0 0 3 26

AOAP Ballot Approvals RateAuto Approval Rate (Aff./(Aff. + Neg.) ≥ 66% 100%Auto Approval (Affirmative / Total Votes) ≥ 50% 100%Oil Approval Rate (Aff. / (Aff. + Neg. ) ≥ 66% 100%Oil Approval (Affirmative / Total Votes) ≥ 50% 88%

10

ACTION: Ballot Motion

SEQUENCE VI TEST UPDATES

Greg Miranda

Sequence VI Surveillance Panel Chairman

September, 2016

Agenda

Sequence VID test availability

Sequence VIE hardware availability

Sequence VIE: Surveillance Panel update

Sequence VIF Update

2

Sequence VID Hardware Updates

Results of test lab survey estimates the life of remaining VID hardware will last until approximately Q4 of 2016

~30 test starts remain at independent labs

3

Sequence VIE Hardware UpdatesApproximately 133 “- 02 VIE” engines remaining at CPD

At full capacity, “-02 VIE” batch engines will last approximately one year

Additional engines will be made available via short block hardware

487 currently acquired; planned for first round of distribution across labs

An additional 934 short block engine configurations have been requested

934 left bank cylinder heads available

~400 right bank cylinder heads available; ~550 still needed to complete inventory

Task force assembled to address category hardware concerns

Engine cleaning methodology (i.e. extend testing life of engines)

Establish inventory of short block hardware 4

Sequence VIE Test Ready for Inclusion in GF-6 The Sequence VIE surveillance panel informs the Passenger Car Engine

Oil Classification Panel and the Auto Oil Advisory Panel that the surveillance panel has determined that the test is ready for inclusion as an ASTM procedure.

5

Figure 12: SP ready for ASTM inclusion. Excerpt from statistics group 7/22/16 presentation (TMC doc: VIMinutes20160726-20160727.pdf)

Sequence VIE Open Items

Finalizing Sequence VIE Procedure

Finalizing hardware availability details

6

Sequence VIF UpdateAll testing completed week of June

12th

Surveillance panel voted on 7/19/2016 to limit VIF engine life to 4 full length tests with last test starting no later than 900 hours

Surveillance panel voted on 7/27/2016 to allow Lubrizol to conduct 4 donated supplemental Sequence VIF precision matrix tests on a new stand/engine Installation of LZ engine complete

TMC stand inspection complete

Engine currently on break-in

Figure 13: Data available for Seq VIE PM analysis. Excerpt from statistics group 7/22/16 presentation (TMC doc: VIMinutes20160726-20160727.pdf)

7

8

APPENDIX

Sequence VIE TestSummary of Sequence VIE test methodology: Break In (150 hours) Stand qualification criteria: one acceptable reference oil result; additional tests required if 1st is

unacceptableRandom assignment for all three reference oils (TMC 1010-1, TMC 542-2, TMC 544)

LTMS requirements have been defined by the surveillance panelOfficial Sequence VIE calibration will start on 8/10/2016 for stand/engines that have completed calibration

testing following criteria established in the Sequence VIE LTMS document

Engine hour limitations 3 candidate test maximum (following single reference test qualification; i.e. 4 total tests per engine) Valid test starts must occur prior to 900 hrs of engine run time

Last non-reference test shall start no later than 100 days from the date of acceptable calibration

Investigating option to extend engine life to fourth candidate run Requirement to run donated 5th test on a TMC assigned RO on each of the first three calibrated engines

in each lab

9

Sequence VIE Test Update

On July 27th, the Sequence VI Surveillance Panel voted to approve the Sequence VIE test ready for inclusion into the GF-6 category:

Selected reference oils

Defined test stand referencing and calibration procedures

Reviewed precision matrix analysis

Determined reference oil targets

Finalized LTMS requirements

Updated Appendix K

Established test method (finalization of procedure in progress)10