intelligent systems corp: material undisclosed related party … · 2019-06-01 · please read our...
Post on 03-Aug-2020
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
IntelligentSystemsCorp:MaterialUndisclosedRelatedPartyTransactionsCastDoubtontheIntegrityofFinancial
Statements
• WebelievethatIntelligentSystemsCorp.(INS)hasitsemployeessetuportakecontrolofundisclosedshellcompaniesinAsia,whothenpartakeinundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionswithINSintendedtoeitherround-triprevenuebacktoINSorsiphonmoneyoutofthecompany.
• INSseemstomakeaconcentratedandconsciousefforttohidetherelatedpartynatureofthesetransactions.
• Forexample:INSinvestedintoanunnamedIndianstartup(whichourresearchhasuncoveredasFlexoptTechnologies),whichlaterboughtservicesfromINSusingINS’sowncontributedcapital.
• OneofINS’semployeeswasrecentlylistedasthefounderofFlexopt.Thisdesignationwaslaterremoved(webelievetocovertheirtracks).AnotherbusinesspartnerassociatedwithINSwasalsolistedontheincorporationdocumentsofFlexopt.Noneofthiswasdisclosedtoinvestors.
• WehaveidentifiedanetworkofAsiancompaniessetupbyINS’semployeesortheirbusinesspartnerswhocommonlytransactwitheachother,andsometimeswithINSaswell.Wequestionthenecessityandpurposeofthisnetwork.
• WehaveidentifiedatleasttwoothersmallerinstancesofundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsbetweenINSandthisAsiannetwork.
• WebelievethatthesematerialundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionscastdoubtontheintegrityofINS’sfinancialstatements.Accordingly,weassignINSapricetargetof$5
Company Intelligent Systems Corp
Ticker
INS
Industry Software - Infrastructure
Exchange
NYSE
Price (as of 5/29/2019) $33.94
Shares Outstanding
8.95m
Daily Volume 161,891
Projected Downside
85%
Publication Date May 30, 2019
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Summary IntelligentSystemsisalow-qualitypaymentsprovidermasqueradingasthe“nextbigthing”.Whileitsfinancialstatementsandsharepricehaverecentlygoneparabolic,weseeevidencethatsomeofthisgrowthmayhavebeenachievedthroughundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsbetweenINSandanetworkofIndianandAsiancompanies,ratherthanthroughtruebusinessprowess.
Specifically,wehavefounddefinitiveevidenceofINSlendingmoneytostartupscontrolledbyINSemployeesinIndia,thenslowlyfunnelingthatinitialinvestmentbacktoINSthroughanetworkofrelatedIndianandAsiancompanies,allowingINStobookitasrevenue.WallStreetappearstotakeINS’smanagementatitsword,mindlesslyextrapolatingcontinuedhyper-growthwithoutquestioningwherethisgrowthisactuallycomingfrom.ANoteonAurelius NotableshortpublishingoutfitAureliusValuehasrecentlypublishedadamningreportonINSthatweinvitereaderstoviewhere.OurreportincludesminimaloverlapwithAurelius’sresearch.WebelievethatourfindingsofundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsfurthercorroboratethepresenceofsignificantwrongdoingonINS’spart.WenotethatnoneoftheundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsthatwedetailinthisreportarealsodiscussedintheAureliusreport.
WebelieveAureliusdidagreatjobelaboratingonhowthesupposedrecentApple/Goldmanrelationshipismostlikelynotgoingtoresultinenormousprofits,asinvestorsseemtoexpect.WealsoconcurthatINShasinvestedwaytoolittleinthedevelopmentoftheirtechnologytogiveitanykindofdifferentiatedadvantageinthemarketplace.Forthesakeofnotboringthereader,wereferyoutoAurelius’reportandwillnotcommentontheseissuesfurtherinthisreport.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
INS–SchemeorStar?IntelligentSystemsCorporation(INS)marketsandsellsCoreCard,apayments
processingtechnology.Threequartersago,INS’srevenuesandEBITDAsuddenlystartedskyrocketing.WhereaspreviouslyINSwasasolidlyunprofitablebusinesswithminimalgrowth,suddenlyrevenuesweregrowingovertriple-digitsYOYandprofitsswungfromnegativeto30%+EBITmargins.
Managementattributedthechangetosuddennewdemandfortheirproducts,somuchsothattheyhadtostartrejectingnewcustomerordersastoaccommodatethenewfounddemand.Thispick-upingrowthcausedINS’ssharepricetooverquintupleyear-to-date.
Amazingly,thelastthreequarters’growthimplynearly100%contributionmarginfromwhatevergreatnewcustomersINShaspickedup.
Anextraordinarybusinessindeed. We,however,seeadifferentnarrative.WebelievethatINShasachieveditsextraordinarygrowththroughnot-so-extraordinarymethods.Specifically,webelievethatINSisengaginginseveralundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsbetweenitselfanditsemployeesinIndia.Thesetransactionsarematerialinnature,andsomeofthemstrangelycoincidewithINS’ssuddenjumpinfinancialperformancebeginning2018.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
CuriousInvestmentsinAnIndianFinTechCompany
INS’sextraordinaryfinancialandsharepriceperformancestartedatthebeginningof2018.Coincidentally,thiscoincidedwiththetimethatINSmadeacurious-soundinginvestmentintoanIndianFinTechstartup:
Source:INS201710-Kfiled3/15/18
Asyoucansee,INSloaned$235,000(withanoptionforanadditional$200,000)throughaconditionalconvertiblenotetoanIndianFinTechstartup,thenonemonthlatersignedaprocessingagreementwiththatsamestartupforCoreCardtoperformservicesforthem. Notethelackofanysignificantdetailregardingthecompanyinquestion.Forexample,whatisthestartup’sname?WhatdoesINShopetogetoutoftheinvestment(5%isanincrediblylowinterestratefortherisksassociatedwithastartup)?FindingFlexopt Ourresearchshowsthatthis“investment’s”nameisFlexoptTechnology,astartupwhichrunsthewebsitehttp://www.payopt.in,specializinginconsumercredit.InFlexopt’sfinancialstatementsfiledwiththeIndianMinistryofCorporateAffairs,weseeCoreCard’sinitial$235,000investmentclearly:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:FlexoptFY2017(ended3/31/18)FinancialStatements.NoteUSD/INRexchangeratewas$0.016/INR1at3/31/18,makingtheaboveINR15,000,000loan~$240,000,whichmatchesINS’sdescriptioninitsFY1710-K.
FlexoptwasinitiallyregisteredinApril2017,just8monthsbeforetheaboveinvestmenttookplace.INS’snoteinits10-KalsostatesthatFlexoptsubsequentlyenteredintoaprocessingagreementwithCoreCard(remember,INSownsCoreCard),foranunspecifieddollarvalue.Flexopt’sfinancialstatementsgiveahintastothevalueoftheprocessingagreement.Inanappendix,Flexoptgivesalistofitsexistingaccountspayablescomposition:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:FlexoptFY2017(ended3/31/18)FinancialStatements.
Focusontheredfornowbutwe’llcomebacktoNewVision(green)later. TheINR2,345,606balancetoCoreCardhererepresents~$35,000inpayablestoCoreCard-nottoomuchcomparedtoINS’s$10millioninrevenuesand$3millionexistingreceivablesbalance. However,wenotethatthisisjustFlexopt’spayablesbalancetoCoreCard,notitstotalpurchasesfromCoreCardfortheperiod.Totalpaymentsarethereforelikelyhigherthan$35,000.Further,thesetransactionsalloccurredinthelessthantwo-monthperiodbetweenwhenFlexoptsignedaprocessingagreementwithCoreCardon2/5/18andFlexopt’syear-endof3/31/18.Annualizingjustthe$35,000paymentthereforeyieldsalmost$250,000,evenlargerthanINS’sinitialloantoFlexopt,andfairlymaterialtoINS,whichatthetimewaslosing~$500,000peryear. Remember,noneofthiswasdisclosedbyINS.InINS’sfinancialstatementsitsimplystatesthatINSmadeaninvestmentintoanIndianFinTechstartup,andsubsequentlyenteredintoaprocessingagreementwiththestartup.DiggingIntotheFinancials
Flexopthardlyconstitutesabusiness,withbasically$0inrevenueandissimplyusingCoreCard’sownloantopayforCoreCard’sservices(seeFlexopt’syear-endincomestatementbelow):
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:FlexoptFY2017(ended3/31/18)FinancialStatements.
ThissuggeststhatFlexoptisessentiallyjustround-trippingthecashfromINS’sloanrightbacktoINSthroughtheprocessingagreement.Iftrue,hiswouldobviouslymeanthattheloanandthesubsequentprocessingagreementbothlackeconomicsubstance. WebelievethatthisisFlexopt’sentirebusiness.Thecompany,optically,appearstobestartingtorampuprevenues(seetheINR67,699inrevenuesabove),buttheentiretyofthisrevenuewasfromarelatedpartyNewVisionSoftcomConsultancy(moreonNewVisionlater).
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
BelowisNewVisiondescribingitsrelatedpartytransactions:
Source:NewVisionFY2017(ended3/31/18)FinancialStatements.
Asyoucansee,NewVisionsoldlargeamountsofservicestoFlexopt,withverylittlehappeningtheotherwayaround(thatbeingtheINR67,699thatrepresented100%ofFlexopt’srevenues).BecauseNewVisionisarelatedparty,wedonotbelievethattheserevenuestoFlexoptactuallyrepresenttrueeconomictransactions.ThismakesusbelievethatFlexoptisstillanon-viablestartupbusinessincapableofgeneratingrevenuesasastandaloneentity.
FlexoptwasFoundedbyanINSEmployee Andnowforthekicker–FlexoptwasfoundedbyanINSemployee:themanagingdirectoroftheirIndiasubsidiary,ISCSoftwarePrivateLimited,AnupamPathak. It’sveryclearthatPathakiscurrentlyinvolvedwithFlexopt,whilealsobeingmanagingdirectoratISCSoftware.HereisalistofIndiancompaniesthatPathakhasadisclosedrelationshipwith:
Source:zaubacorp.com
WebelieveINSmaytrytoexplainawaythisrelationshipbystatingthatPathakisonlycurrentlyadirectoratFlexoptbecauseINSmadetheinvestmentintoFlexopt.Thiswouldopticallyappeartrue,asPathakwasonlyappointedtobeadirectoratFlexoptinOctober2017,ascomparedtoFlexopt’sincorporationandregistrationofitstwofoundersinApril2017.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Presumably,INSwouldhavebeenintalkswithFlexoptatthispointaboutapossibleloan.Further,PathakiscurrentlylistedonPayopt’swebsiteasaboardmember,andnotafounder:
However,webelievethatINS/Flexoptaresimplytryingtocovertheirtrackshere.AslateasApril28th,2018,theWaybackMachinehasrecordedadifferent“leadershipteam”pageonPayopt’swebsite,listingPathakasthe“founder”(notboardmember)ofPayopt:
Source:WaybackMachine,website:http://www.payopt.in:80/leadership/
Thispagenowdoesnotexist.Payopt’swebsitewasupdatedatsomepointbetweenApril2018andpresenttochangePathak’slistedrole.Conveniently,backthen,itwouldhavebeenimpossibletodrawarelationshipbetweenPayoptandINS,asFlexopt’sfinancialstatementshadnotyetbeenfiledwiththeIndianMinistryofCorporateAffairs. It’sevidenttousthatsomeoneistryingtocoverupPathak’strueroleatFlexopt/Payopt.Thereasonislikelythat,hadPathakactuallybeenafounderofFlexopt/Payopt,ratherthanjoiningthecompanyasadirectorduetoaninvestment,INS’sloantoFlexoptwouldhaveconstitutedanundisclosedrelatedpartytransaction.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
INS’subsequentprocessingagreementwithFlexoptalsowouldhavebeenanundisclosedrelatedpartytransaction. ThistransactioncouldhavehadtheeffectofartificiallyboostingINS’srevenues,giventhatFlexoptissimplyround-trippingINS’sinvestmentintoFlexoptbacktoINSinthesubsequentprocessingagreement.ThiswouldallowINStobooktheprocessingagreementasrevenue,whilethecashoutflowfromtheinvestmentwouldbebookedasaninvestingoutflowonitscashflowstatement.Thistransactionwouldlackanyeconomicvalue. AnotherpossibilityisthatINS’semployeesareattemptingtosiphonmoneyfromINSthroughthesetransactions.INS’sinvestmentintoFlexoptwouldgiveFlexoptcapitaltothenredistributetoitsownersorotherrelatedparties.NotefortheReader
Forsakeofkeepinganoverviewoftheconvolutedrelationshipweb,wecreatedarelationshipmapforreaderswhichcanbefoundintheAppendixattheendofthisreport.
WhatisNewVision? FlexoptisalsorelatedtoINSinanotherway:acompanycalledNewVisionSoftcomandConsultancyPrivateLimited.ISCSoftware(INS’sIndiasub)hastwolisteddirectors:AnupamPathak(above)andNeetiPathak.NeetiisalsoadirectoratacompanycalledNewVisionSoftcomandConsultancy:
Source:zaubacorp.com AttentiveinvestorswillnotethatNewVisionwastheothermajorlistedaccountspayablesvendorforFlexopt(shownagainbelow).
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:FlexoptFY2017(ended3/31/18)FinancialStatements.
Letusbeclear–thismeansthatFlexopt(whichhaszerothird-partyrevenuestofund
itsexpenses)tookINS’sloanandthenusedtoitpayforservicesfromanothercompanyownedbyINS’semployee.ThisfurthersupportsthethesisthattheserelatedpartytransactionsarepossiblyallowingINSemployeestosiphonoutmoneyfromINSitself.
BelowisNewVision’sdirectorslist:
Source:zaubacorp.com
AnothernoteworthyplayerhereisKapilGodani,becauseheisalsoafounderandcurrentpartownerofFlexopt:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:zaubacorp.com
GodaniislistedinFlexopt’sincorporationdocumentsandactuallyowns50%ofthebusiness.HisrelationshipwithNeetigoesbackatleasttoJuly2016,giventhat’swhenhewasappointedasadirectorofNewVision.So,uponfoundingFlexoptinApril2017,heshouldhavebeenconsideredveryclosetoINS-almostarelatedparty.
Conclusion
IntheendweseedefinitiveevidenceofanINSemployee(AnupamPathak)andanotherINSbusinesspartner(KapilGodani)foundingastartup,takinganundisclosedrelatedpartyloanfromINS,thenusingthatloantopayforservicesfromINS,thusround-trippingthecashbackandallowingINStobookitasrevenuewithlikelyfewtonocorrespondingexpenses-allwhileINSdoesn’tsayawordtoinvestorsaboutwhat’sgoingon.FlexoptfurthertookINS’sloanandusedittopayforservicesfromanothercompany(NewVision)ownedbyanINSemployee.
Itdoesn’tgetmoreincestuousthanthat. Further,INSfrequentlyentersintoinvestmentagreementsakintoFlexopt’sstructure:INSwillloanadecentamountofmoneytoanunnamed“startup”,andsubsequentlyenterintoprocessingagreementswiththesesame“startups”.BoththenameofthestartupandtheamountofINS’sprocessingagreementusuallyarenotdisclosed.BecausemostofthesestartupsareAmericancompanies,wehavenotbeenabletothusfaridentifyanyotherloaned-topartiesbesidesFlexopt.However,thefactthatFlexoptwasanundisclosedrelatedpartybegsthequestion–whoaretheothercounterpartiestoINS’sstartuploans,andwhatisthenatureofthesubsequentprocessingagreements?
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
EvenMoreUndisclosedRelatedPartyTransactions
ThestorydoesnotstopwithFlexopt.WebelievethattheremaybeawholesystemofIndian(andpossiblyAmerican)companiesownedoroperatedbyINSrelatedparties.TheirexactpurposeisnotclearbutwebelievethattheymayalsobeworkingtoartificiallyinflateINS’srevenuesthroughnon-arm’slengthtransactions. WehaveidentifiedtwoadditionalundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsofunknownsizebetweenINSandadditionalrelatedforeignentities,fromthepublicresumesofsomeofINS’sIndianemployees.GlobeTeleservices–UndisclosedRelatedPartyTransaction#1
ThebelowisfromtheresumeofVinodOjha,whoseLinkedInidentifieshimasaSeniorSoftwareEngineeratCoreCard.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:LinkedInofVinodOjha
HeliststheaboveasoneofhisprojectswhileatCoreCard.Notetheclient,GlobalTeleservicesPvt.Ltd.WehaveevidencethatthisisanotherrelatedpartytoINS.TheproducthehelpedmakewastheGlobeDialer,below:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:iTunesAppStore Again,notethesamecompany,GlobeTeleservicesLimited.Thebelowscreenshotshowsthattheappwasmadein2015,whileOjhajoinedCoreCardasanemployeeinSeptember2014.ThisimpliesthatmakingtheappwasacontractbetweenGlobeTeleservicesandCoreCard.
Source:iTunesAppStore
ThisisanissuebecauseGlobeTeleservicesLimitedshouldbeconsideredarelatedpartytoINS.AnupamPathakisafoundingmemberofGlobeTeleservices:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:GlobeTeleservicesCertificateofIncorporationfiledwiththeHongKongCompaniesRegistry
AnotherCoreCardemployee,GeraldPereira,wasalsosimultaneouslyworkingatGlobeTeleservices,NewVision,andCoreCard,upuntil2016,accordingtohisLinkedInbelow:
Source:GeraldPereiraLinkedIn
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
AshutoshAgrawal,afoundingmemberofFlexopt,wasalsoafoundingmemberofGlobeTeleservices. WebelievethereisabsolutelynowaytorefutethefactthatGlobeTeleservicesisarelatedpartytoINS.AlthoughwedonotknowthevalueofCoreCard’sworkwithGlobeTeleservices(itlikelywasn’tmeaningful,consideringitwasjustdevelopmentofoneapp),thisdoesserveasanobviousundisclosedrelatedpartytransaction,andthefactthatINSagainhasmultipleemployeessimultaneouslyworkingatCoreCardandGlobe/NewVisionfurthersupportsourthesisthatINShasawebofundisclosedrelatedforeigncompaniesthatarecontributingtoitsfinancials.
Further,theverynatureofundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionsisthattheyarenon-arm’slength.Therefore,justbecausetheserviceprovidedwasnotlarge,thatdoesnotmeanthatthemoneypaidwasnecessarilysmall.WearefurtherunabletoassumethatthiswastheonlyrelatedpartytransactionbetweenCoreCardandGlobe.UniversalTestSolutions–UndisclosedRelatedPartyTransaction#2
Second,thebelowresumeofAjayKanhereshowsthatINShasengagedintransactionswithanotherundisclosedrelatedparty,UniversalTestSolutions:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:AjayKanhereLinkedIn
Notethelastlinewhichmakesclearthat“CoreCardSoftwareisaclientofUTS-Global”.UTSisrelatedtoINSinthatAshutoshAgrawaliscurrentlysimultaneouslyahigh-levelemployeeatFlexopt(akaPayopt),GlobeTeleservices,andUniversalTestSolutions(UTS).
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:AshutoshAgrawalLinkedIn
Again,wecontinuetoseeevidenceofabroadwebofforeignrelatedparties/businessassociates,allsupportedbythesamegroupofindividualsandtransactingbetweenoneother.Again,wecanonlyspeculateastothepurposeofthisnetworkandthesetransactions. InUTS’scase,wedonotknowtheexactsizeornatureofthetransactionsbetweenUTSandINS.However,thesimplefactthatthereareundisclosedtransactionsbetweenthesetworelatedcompaniesshouldworryinvestors,giventhat,again,relatedpartytransactionscanpotentiallybefornonsensicalamounts.
StrangePresencesofCoreCardEmployees
AnupamiscertainlyveryactiveintheIndianFinTechspace.TherearetwocompaniesbesidesISCSoftwarethatusetheemailapathak@corecard.comastheirregisteredemailaddresses:GTSTelecomServicesandNamoMediaandCommunication.NeitherisdisclosedbyINS.Bothcompaniesappeartosimplybeshells,with<$1000inrevenueseachand~$40-50kindebt.Wequestionthepurposeofbothofthesecompanies. Evenfurther–GTSTelecomServicessporadicallylistsanothercorecard.comemailonitsfilings,lbattu@corecard.com:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
*Source:GTSTelecomServices(fkaAimTopCareerandEducation)FormADT-1dated2/9/15
ThiserasesanydoubtthatGTSisrelatedtoINS/CoreCard,seeingastwoCoreCardemployeeshaveregisteredemailaddressesatGTS.Althoughit’snot100%clearwho“lbattu”is,webelieveitisLokendraBattu(aCoreCardfinancemanager)below,obviouslyadifferentpersonthanAnupamPathak:
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
OnecanonlywonderwhyINSwouldletthemanagingdirectoroftheirIndiansubsidiaryandafinancemanagerstartseveralshellcompaniesinIndia. Anditdoesn’tstopthere.GTSTelecomcurrentlyhasdeminimisfinancialoperations,sotherecan’tbetoomanyfaultytransactions(previously,before2015,GTShadfairlysubstantialrevenuesandearnings,butweareconcernedwithwhat’sgoingonnow). WeareconcernedthatGTS’sconnectionswithCoreCardarereplicatedbyamuchmoresubstantialoperation–NewVisionSoftcomConsultancy.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Source:NewVisionFormADT-1filedwiththeIndianMinistryofCorporateAffairs Itseemslike“lbattu”ispresentatNewVisionaswell.RecallthatAnupam’swife,NeetiPathak,isadirectoratNewVision,andNewVisionhasbothsoldandboughtfromINS’undisclosedrelatedpartyinvestee,Flexopt. Thisisahugeinternalcontrolissue,allowingemployeestousecompanyemailaddressestostartthreeothercompanies.Incombinationwithwhatwesawbefore,withbothNeetiandGondaniworkingatNewVision,andNewVisiontransactingwithFlexopt,thisstartstopaintthepictureofabroadwebofinterrelatedpartiestransactingtogetherwithoutadequatedisclosure.Theopportunitytoround-tripcashbacktoINS,oreventosiphonoffcashforthemselves,becomesverypronounced. Further,alloftheseinterrelatedIndiancompaniesareauditedbythesameauditorandauditpartner:S.L.Chhajed&Co.withauditpartnerAbhayChhajed. Belowisachartoftherelationshipsbetweenalloftheabovecompaniesandpersons.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Theserelationshipsandround-triptransactionswithundisclosedrelatedpartiesmakeusquestiontheaforementionedrapidYTDgrowthofINS’sbusiness.Forexample,itseemspeculiarthatINS’sfinancialresultsspikedimmediatelyaftermakinganinvestmentintoanundisclosedrelatedparty:
InvestmentinFlexopt
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Wecan’thelpbutthinksomethingfishyisgoingonhere,especiallygiventhelastthreequartersofrevenuegrowthsince2018hashadanearly100%contributionmargin.WethereforebelievethatthereisapossibilitythatallrevenuegrowthsinceJanuary2018hasbeenaresultofundisclosedround-triptransactionswithIndianrelatedparties.
FurtherRedFlags
INS’sauditorisatelltalegiveawayofpotentialmisdoing.Theirauditor’snameisNichols,Cauley&Associates,LLC.INSswitchedtoNicholsasanauditorin2015,aftertheirpreviousauditor,HabifArogeti&Wynne,LLP,resigned,citingthatINSwasits“onlyremainingpubliccompanyclient”.Nichols,similarly,alsodoesnotauditanyotherpubliccompanies(zeroformAPsbesidesINS’sfiledwiththePCAOB):
Wehaverarelyifeverseena>$200millionpubliccompanythatconsistentlyusessuchsmallauditors.INSalsopays<$100kperyeartoNichols. Further,INShasaveryquestionablefigureonitsboardofdirectors:ParkerH.Petit.
ManyinvestorshavelikelyheardofthemassivefraudallegationsatMiMedx(MDXG),acompanywhereParkerPetitwasformerlyCEO.Webelievethatthepresence(especiallythecontinuedpresence)ofPetitonINS’sboardofdirectorsisindicativeofpotentiallackofoversight/accountabilityfortop-management,andthatINS’sboardmaynotbeworkinginthebestinterestsofshareholders.PetithasbeenadirectorofINSsince1996.
MiMedxrecentlyfoundthroughanAuditCommittee’sinvestigationofallegedfraudthatPetit“madematerialmisstatementsandomissionstokeystakeholders,suchastheBoard,theCompany'sexternalauditors,andtheSecuritiesandExchangeCommission("SEC")”andthat“Atonepoint,Mr.PetitfalselytestifiedunderoathduringadepositionwhendiscussingtheCompany'slargestdistributor”.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
AureliusValue’sreportdiscussesINS’srelationshipwithitsauditorinmuchmoredetail,includingpersonaltiesbetweenINSCEOLelandStrangeandauditpartnerIanWaller.ItalsotouchesuponanotherundisclosedrelatedpartytransactionbetweenINS,Strange,andastartupLumense.Again,weencouragereaderstopersonallyreadtheentiretyofAurelius’sreport.
Conclusion
WehavelaidoutinthisreportwhywebelievethatINSispartakinginsignificantundisclosedrelatedpartytransactions.ThesetransactionscouldservetoartificiallyinflateINS’srevenuesbyround-trippingcashfromINSthroughshellsbacktoitself.Thereisalsopossibilitythatinthemiddle,INS’semployeessiphonoutmoneyfromINSforthemselves.
ThefactthatINSseemstohavemadeaconsciousefforttohidethattheinvestmentinFlexoptisarelatedpartytransactionworriesusdeeply.Two-waytransactions,wherethecompanyinvestsorlendstoabuyerofservicesareoftencomplicatedandleaveroomformanipulation.Two-waytransactionswithundisclosedrelatedpartiesarethebiggestredflagwecanthinkof. WebelievethatINS’scommonstockisuninvestable,giventhatthesesignificantandmaterialrelatedpartytransactionsinourviewcastdoubtontotheintegrityofINS’sfinancialstatements.
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Appendix:INSRelationshipMap
Legend: Individual
Company
Please read our disclaimer here: https://grizzlyreports.com/termofservice/
Explanationonrelationships:1)AnupamPathakismanagingdirectorofINS’Indiasubsidiary,ISCSoftwarePvt.Ltd.
2)NeetiPathakisAnupam’swifeandalsoadirectoratISCSoftware
3)LokendraBattuisaFinance&AccountingManageratINS’ssubsidiaryCoreCard
4)AnupamPathakisadirectorandfounderofFlexoptTechnologyPrivateLtd.,whichalso
operatesunderthenamePayopt.INSseemstohavemadeaconcentratedefforttohidethe
factthatPathakisalsoafounderofFlexopt.
5)INSfundedFlexoptthroughaconvertiblenote.ConsequentiallyFlexoptboughtservices
fromINS.WhileINSmakesmentionofthistransactionitfailstomentiontherelatedparty
natureofthetransaction.
6)NeetiPathakisalsoadirectorNewVisionSoftcomandConsultancyPrivateLtd.
7)GlobeTeleservicesboughtservicesfromCoreCard
8)UTSboughtservicesfromCoreCard
9)LokendraBattushowsupwithhisCoreCardemailaddressasarepresentativeofUniversal
TestSolutionsLLC(UTS).
10)AnupamPathakisadirectoratGlobeTeleservices.
11)AshutoshAgrawalisafounderofFlexopt.
12)KapilGodaniisafounderandcurrentpartneratFlexopt.
13)FlexoptboughtservicesfromNewVision,andperformedminorservicesforNewVision.
14)KapilGodaniisadirectorofNewVision
15)AshutoshAgrawalisafounderofGlobeTeleservices.
16)AshutoshAgrawalisapartneratUTS.
top related