international workshop: istanbul – twente – sarajevo group 3 ines coralic, yeşim Çiloğlu,...

International Workshop: Istanbul – Twente – Sarajevo GROUP 3 Ines Coralic , Yeşim Çiloğlu, Nikola Grubesic, Rick van der Heemst, Derya Karadağ,

Evren Özsoy, Sinem Uçğun

THREE CONCEPTS

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept s

3

Box in Box Concept

Rail&Roller Concept Modular Pavillions Concept

Modular concept is established based on 1 m modules of rails and a roller of plastic film. Other parts of concept are connection parts which are L-shaped corner units and T-shaped post-beam connections. Using this elements pavilion structure can expand in all 3 dimensions. Connecting I-L and T-shaped elements rails are established. The roller is rolled to establish the plastic skin of the pavilion. The plastic film is considered to be perforated in hot weather and double layered in cold weather.

The pavilion concept is based on two minor pavilion spaces which can be extruded from one major pavilion space. The minor element is designed as a box in modular sistem 2x2 meters. Additional element creates a flexibile shell which covers the pavilion space. These spaces can be combined to use for one function or can be used separately for different functions. The shell is designed to accomodate technical instalations during the winter, and it shades pavilions during the summer.

Pavilion in Sultanahmet is based on a module size of 60x60 cm. This size is suitable for different arrangements and sizes of internal and external spaces. Standard sized pavilion is flexible and can be divided up to 5 shop. Open spaces in between pavilions establish a calm space for users. A calm alley is defined between pavilions and the courtyard of the Blue Mosque in contrary of the more crowded street in Atmeydanı.

KEY CRITERIA COMPARISON

Design Criteria Matrix

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

Box in Box Concept = - Rail&Roller Concept = - Modular Pavillions Concept = +

Architectural quality -Multi-functionality +/-Transformability +/-Sustainability +Comfort & health +Constructability -Cultural + local context -

- +/- + - + - -

+ + +/- +/- + + +

3

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

CONTEXT OF SITE

approach

CONTEXT OF SITE

relation to adjacent buildings

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

CONTEXT OF SITE

orientation / accessibility rooting

Text

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

CONTEXT OF SITE

zoning

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPT2 tea&desert shop with seating area

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPT1 restaurant, 1 fast food shop, 1 book store

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPT1 restaurant with semi opened space

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPT

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPT

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPTdesert, candy, ice cream, snacks take away

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

BUILDING CONCEPTShops, arts&crafts, bookstore, silver, souvenir

3D DIGITAL / PHYSICAL MODELS

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

3D DIGITAL / PHYSICAL MODELS

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTIONTHREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTIONTHREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA – ARCHITECTURAL QUALITY

The see-trough design of the pavilion gives a neutral impression which does not interfere with its surroundings

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural quality

KEY CRITERIA – MULTI FUNCTIONALITY

The construction-methods provide for an easy adaptation of the interior partitions of the pavilions. The floor-system provides utilities on key points within the pavilion.

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural qualitymulti functionality

KEY CRITERIA – TRANSFORMABILITY

The panel-system provides an easy way of transforming both exterior and interior.

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural qualityMulti functionality

Transformability

KEY CRITERIA – SUSTAINABILITY

The panels include insulation. This will reduce energy consumption for cooling during summer and heating during winter.

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural qualitytransformability

functionalitycomfort & health

sustainability

KEY CRITERIA – CONSTRUCTABILITY AND HANDLING OF COMPONENTS

The components are lightweight and designed to be handled by 1-2 persons.Panels 60x60 cm, the H-profiles are 360 centimeters long and the horizontal H-profiles are 60 cm long. Both profile are made of aluminum.

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural qualityMulti functionality

TransformabilitySustainability

comfort & health constructability and handling of

components

KEY CRITERIA – CULTURAL AND LOCAL SITE CONTEXT

Pavilion is designed for weather conditions of Istanbul whether it being sunshine or rain.

THREE CONCEPTS

developed concept skey criteria comparison

CONTEXT OF SITE

BUILDING CONCEPT

scenarios 1, 2, 3 & 4scenario 5

3D digital / physical models

CONCEPT OF CONSTRUCTION

CONCEPT OF MATERIALIZATION

KEY CRITERIA

architectural qualityMulti functionality

TransformabilitySustainability

comfort & health constructability and handling of

componentscultural and local site context