pesticide response case study module 6 case study 11 23 11 jmdh... · case study module 6 kathy...

www.oscreadiness.org

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program

Pesticide Response Case Study

Module 6Kathy Halbur

OSC, Region 5

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 1

Pesticide Response Case Study WI farmer suspected of poisoning wildlife

with Carbofuran (Cancelled pesticide) U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service lead agency

WI Dept of Natural Resources and U.S. EPA support agencies

USFWS obtained search warrants for evidence raid (seven warrants) One day (5/12/10) to

collect as much evidence as possible

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 2

Pesticide Response Case Study US EPA CID requested OSC & START

assistance with the warrant execution Overall Site health & safety Sampling of unknown chemicals Sampling of bait piles Overpacking of carbofuran Overpacking of bait piles Documentation T&D assistance Evidence for a criminal vs civil prosecution

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 3

Pesticide Response Case Study 8,000 acres

Potato farm Heavily wooded

8 buildings Multiple residences 14 bait piles ~100 officials

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 4

Pesticide Response Case Study Three Teams

Chemical Team – Farm Buildings & Residences• Levels B & C• Two START & OSC • CID, USFWS, WDNR

Bait Pile Team – Woods• Level C & D• Four START• CID, USFWS, WDNR

Dead Animal Collection – Sitewide• WDNR Wardens

One START overall Health & Safety Over 50 number of samples collected

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 5

Chemical Team

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 6

Bait Pile Team

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 7

Pesticide Response Case Study Issues:

Authority• Warrants issued under US FWS authority• CID: FIFRA• Not considered a CERCLA Site

Extremely secretive• Investigation since 2007• WDNR Warden undercover• Prominent property owner

Time constraints Evidentiary procedures Property owner and farm staff present

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 8

Pesticide Response Case Study Issues (continued)

No pesticide expertise• DATCP purposely excluded• CID & OSC – very limited FIFRA knowledge

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 9

Much Smaller Scale, but Similar… Bait poisoning in Baraga, MI (4/09) Blue crystals unknown

Improperly identified by Hazmat Team as copper phthalocyanine

Analytical identified as Methomyl

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 10

KENYA LIONS KILL BY CARBOFURAN BAITING

Pesticide abuse is not just a problem in the USA. 5 min video

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PLaLUyH4-vo

15th Annual OSC Readiness Training Program www.oscreadiness.org 11

DISCUSSION…