porphyry and epithermal systems - science-driven exploration successes

Porphyry and Epithermal Systems -Science-driven Exploration Successes

Richard Sillitoe

2

Porphyry and epithermal deposits

Porphyry copper-molybdenum and copper-gold deposits are centred on shallow-level porphyry intrusions

Epithermal gold and silver deposits are typically

hosted by volcanic rocks

Grasberg, Indonesia

Round Mountain, Nevada

3

Porphyry and epithermal systems – the state of play at end of 1960s (1)

• Epithermal-hot spring linkage proposed (D.White), but relationship uncertain

• Types of epithermal deposits not appreciated (forgetting F.L.Ransome and W.Lindgren)

• Porphyry-epithermal connection unknown• Porphyry intrusion-volcano connection unknown• Plate tectonic setting and relationship of porphyry copper deposits to

subduction unrecognised (plate tectonics in its infancy)

4

Porphyry and epithermal systems – the state of play at end of 1960s (2)

• Ages of copper and gold belts and provinces poorly defined (isotopic dating in its infancy)

• Zoning patterns of hydrothermal alteration in porphyry and epithermal deposits poorly appreciated

• Porphyry gold and gold-rich porphyry copper deposits undefined (notwithstanding Panguna)

• Bulk-tonnage epithermal gold deposits undefined (reflecting low gold price)

5

The favourite buzz words for today’s press releases on porphyry and epithermal projects

HOT-SPRING SINTER

STEAM-HEATED ENVIRONMENT

PALEO-WATER TABLE

HIGH-SULPHIDATION SYSTEM

VUGGY QUARTZ

LOW-SULPHIDATION SYSTEM

POTASSIC ALTERATION

DIATREME-HOSTED

HYPOGENE COPPER ENRICHMENT

ADVANCED ARGILLIC LITHOCAP

Unknown to the exploration community at the end of 1960s

Active hot-spring sinter terrace,Champagne Pool, New Zealand

6

Porphyry-epithermal relationships

Linkages between porphyry, high- and intermediate-sulphidation epithermal, skarn, carbonate-replacement, and Carlin-like environments now widely appreciated

The necessary information was supplied by worldwide exploration activities

7

High-sulphidation - porphyry transition

• 1.5 – 2 km vertical interval represented from paleo-surface to porphyry deposit

• Vuggy quartz → quartz-alunite → quartz-pyrophyllite → quartz-sericite from top downwards

• Au-dominated → Cu-dominated from top downwards

8

Shallow epithermal features

• High- and intermediate sulphidation deposits with andesitic-dacitic arc volcanism

• Low-sulphidation deposits with compositionally bimodal (basalt-rhyolite) volcanism in extensional (rift) settings

• Steam-heated environment, hot-spring sinter and paleo-water table silicification recognised above Au-Ag mineralization

- Again exploration supplied the data

9

Deposit-scale features

Alteration zoning — recognising importance of potassic alteration for copper introduction in porphyry copper deposits

Los Pelambres, ChileDiscovered 1969, United Nations

3,300 Mt @ 0.63% Cu, 0.016% Mo

Bajo de la Alumbrera, ArgentinaDiscovered 1971, United Nations700 Mt @ 0.51% Cu, 0.66 g/t Au

Potassic alteration(beneath weathering zone)

Potassic alteration(weathered at surface)

10

Deposit-scale features

Alteration zoning — recognising significance of alteration types in high-, intermediate- and low-sulphidation epithermal systems

La Coipa HS deposit, ChileDiscovered 1983, Amax

8.46 Moz Au Eq

Vuggy quartz in discovery outcrop: residue after leaching by highly acidic fluid

Pascua-Lama HS deposit, Chile-ArgentinaDiscovered 1989, Lac Minerals,

then Barrick Gold

Barren steam-heated alteration above 16 Moz gold and >600 Moz silver

11

Tops of porphyry copper deposits

Guinaoang porphyry copper-gold system, PhilippinesDiscovered 1983, RGC Exploration>500 Mt @ 0.4% Cu, 0.4 g/t Au

Deposit concealed beneath advanced argillic lithocap containing high-

sulphidation mineralization

12

Tops of low- and intermediate-sulphidation epithermal deposits

El Peñón, ChileBlind vein discoveries 1998-2007, Meridian Gold

8.4 Mt @ 14 g/t Au, 234 g/t AgFence drilling to intersect predicted favourable stratigraphic interval

Esquel, ArgentinaDiscovered 2000, Minera El Desquite (Brancote)3.8 Moz Au, 7 Moz AgRecognition that two-thirds of deposit is concealed beneath pre-mineral cover

Fruta del Norte, EcuadorDiscovered 2006, Aurelian

13.7 Moz Au, 22.4 Moz AgDrilling deep beneath a linear silicified zone containing anomalous arsenic and antimony

Quebrada Colorada

13

Recognition of new mineralization styles

Disseminated mineralization in phreatomagmatic diatreme breccia

Soon led to discovery of nearby Lobo porphyry gold deposit by same j.v.Combined: 5.5 Moz Au

Wafi, Papua new GuineaDiscovered 1990, CRA Exploration

Hypogene copper enrichment due to high-sulphidation copper sulphides at base of lithocap overprinting porphyry copper-gold deposit

Montana Tunnels, Montana, USADiscovered 1983, Centennial Minerals61 mt @ 0.96 g/t Au, 12 g/t Ag, 0.67% Zn, 0.28% Pb

Marte porphyry gold deposit, ChileDiscovered 1982,

Anglo American-Cominco j.v.

14

District-scale porphyry copper alignments and clusters (“trendology”)

Chuquicamata district, ChileOrogen-parallel alignment

New discoveries 2000-2006, Codelco

Detailed geology and scout RC drilling beneath alluvial cover

Oyu Tolgoi district, Mongolia Arc-transverse alignment

New discovery 2007, Ivanhoe Mines(supplied by I.Kavalieris)

Deep IP survey – on trend

• Comparable brownfield discoveries in Los Bronces alignment (Sulfatos, Anglo American) and Escondida cluster (Pampa Escondida, MEL), Chile

15

Definition of porphyry copper belts and epochs

Isotopic dating has defined regional-scale belts and corresponding epochs in most porphyry copper provinces

Isotopic dating now routine selection tool in Andean copper province and elsewhere

Examples:• Gaby (Gabriela Mistral): 540Mt @

0.52% Cu Ox – prioritised during initial exploration because of 43 Ma age

• Other prospects – discarded because of 290-200 Ma ages

16

Definition of epithermal belts and provinces

Examples:• Northern Nevada rift: 16-14 Ma• Patagonia: 160-150 Ma

Regional-scale belts and provinces become focus of exploration for specific epithermal deposit type

After Riley et al. (2001)

After John et al. (2000)

17

Origin of metallogenic provinces

Tectono-magmatic processes or predisposition?

• Clustering of 10 Moz Au belts and isolated deposits of different types and ages• Suggestive of predisposition – metal preconcentration or other chemical parameter

(e.g. redox state)• Focus exploration on endowed arc segments, but usually well explored (exception

Colombian Andes)• Or define unrecognised gold-rich arc segments – but how?

18

Key role of geology in porphyry and epithermal exploration

2

4

6

1970 1980 1990 2000

Geological work

2

4

6

1970 1980 1990 2000

Geochemistry

2

4

6

1970 1980 1990 2000

Geophysics

2

4

6

1970 1980 1990 2000

Drilling

Serendipity

Parameters

• 37–year history

• 81 deposits

• Mainly porphyry, epithermal, & sediment-hosted gold (minor VMS & orogenic gold)

Main conclusions

• Notwithstanding exploration changes, little overall evolution in discovery methodology (but see next slide)

• Geologic fieldwork: 90% of discoveries

– routine observation, mapping, & interpretation

– familiarity with deposit models (since 1980s)

• Geochemistry: 70% of discoveries

– stream sediment, soil, & rock chip

• Geophysics: 15% of discoveries (only 50% of programs)

– Ground IP & EM

• Drilling & serendipity: 12% of discoveries

• Remote sensing (satellite imagery, airborne scanners: 0%)

Circum-Pacific Region

1

2

3

4

5 6 7

8

9

10 11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32 33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40 41

42

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56 57

58

59

60

61

62

63

64

65

66

67

68

69

70

71

72

73

74

75 76

77

78

Nu

mb e

r of

dep

osits

2

4

6

Discovery Year

1970 1980 1990 2000

80 81

79

19

The future of porphyry and epithermal exploration

We need:• New geological concepts• Characterisation of distal manifestations of concealed and potentially

deep orebodies• New technological break-throughs• Properly qualified and motivated personnel to do the job

Last 40 years have brought great advances in the porphyry-epithermal environment; next 20 years must bring even greater advances if we are to satisfy growing demand for copper,

gold and silver and societal expectations in general – all within increasingly stringent environmental and community constraints

Rio Tinto, 2008