regulatory docket fiie - nrc.gov · greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (fvertical =...
Post on 25-Oct-2019
1 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER
CALCULATION COVERSHEET
ANALYSISICALCULATION.NO: 14 A4-1 -
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION TITLE:
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
MAR NO:
DCR NO:
OTHERS: r
C.c.\c. K8i -j2.
'PREPARED
REVIEWED
APPROVED
BY: Q
BY:
BY:
FINAL APPROVAL BY:_
DATE:__ _4
DATE: 4-2 4
DATE:
DATE:3o A /qy
FORM NG-007Z REV. 0 REGULATORY DOCKET FIIE COPt 7.7v~
8502 60249 840403 PDR ADOK 05000331 P PDR
Ar \s 19. q~ges 4,,4u4, .
's- - - - V-S
TN .l! c y
I
PF Background
The purpose for compiling calculations M84-11, 12, 13, 14, 15 was to
perform a seismic analysis on the critical components of the Hills-McCanna Pneumatic Damper Actuators. These actuators are part of the secondary
containment isolation system at the Duane Arnold Energy Center
On January 26, 1984, Iowa Electric notified the NRC by telephone that the above mentioned actuators were potentially deficient in meeting their purchase specification. A review of the documents relating to this .discrepancy revealed that the isolation damper assemblies were purchased originally as complete assemblies which included the damper actuators. Subsequent orders for "likefor-like" replacement actuators were placed directly with the actuator manufacturer who was a subvendor to the damper manufacturer. This most recent
purchase order for actuators revealed that a quality assurance program, as required for safety related equipment per 1OCFR Part 50, is not currently in effect at the actuators manufacturer's facility.
Further review of the damper assembly documentation revealed that the
seismic analysis performed on the damper assemblies did not seismically analyze the actuators themselves, but only considered their weight as it seismically affected the damper frame. This information prompted Iowa Electric to audit the damper manufacturer and check for documentation that pertained to the
seismic qualifications of the isolation damper actuators. Results from the audit of the damper manufacturer revealed that the actuators were never purchased by the damper manufacturer as seismically qualified components nor did the damper manufacturer administer a Quality Assurance program concerning the purchase of the actuators.
Since no traceability or Certificate of Conformance was available for the
seismic qualifications of the actuators, a seismic analysis was performed on the critical components of the actuators in order to seismically qualify the damper actuators for use in the Duane Arnold Energy Center. This seismic analysis followed the guidelines set forth in the original purchase specification for the isolation dampers (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100). By seismically qualifying the isolation damper actuators, Iowa Electric will be able to buy Quality Level I actuators in accordance with Revision 1, Chapter 4 of the Quality Assurance Manual under Standard Industrial Quality Items 4.7.3.
Solution
A seismic analysis was performed on five models of the Rockwell HillsMcCanna Ramcon Pneumatic Actuator product line that are installed as isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. These five models include the following:
* R-260 FS * R-450 FS * R-960 FS e R-2000 FS 7 r
6 * R-4200 FS
The seismic analysis on the actuators followed .the general project seismic requirements for frequency-not-determined class 1 equipment in the reactor building and in the control building (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100, Technical Specifications for Isolation Dampers for the Duane Arnold Energy Center Unit 1, Revision 0, 12-28-70).
A.visual inspection of all isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center was made in order to verify model number, serial number and elevation location in the plant. After verifying the elevation location in the plant, static coefficients (g units) were determined for the highest installed actuator for each of the five actuator models. The horizontal static coefficient was then appiied to all three of the orientation axis which eliminated many repetitious calculations and the need for detailed actuator orientation information. Applying the horizontal static coefficient to each axis provided conservative results since the horizontal coefficient is always greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (Fvertical = (Weight) (1 + gV), Fhorizontal = (Weight) (gh), gh > 1 + gv).
The seismic analysis concentrated on the critical areas of the damper actuator where the seismically induced loads could possibly make the actuator. fail, malfunction, or prevent operation. Five areas on each actuator model were identified as critical areas requiring a seismic analysis of the various components interfacing with that critical area. These five critical areas are identified as the following:
o Retaining key which holds the spring cylinder assembly to the main body cylinder
o Main body cylinder o Press fit between main body cylinder and the mounting yoke o Mounting hardware o Mounting yoke
Dimensions and material specifications for the seismic analysis were obtained through the use of proprietary component drawings that were on loan to Iowa Electric from Rockwell Hills-McCanna of Carpentersville, Illinois. All prints applicable to this seismic analysis are listed in the reference section of the referenced calculations.
Four basic assumptions are applied throughout the entire seismic analysis of the damper actuators. These assumptions allow Iowa Electric to use the floor response spectra as the design/qualification spectra for the seismic analysis. The four basic assumptions are as follows:
o The mounting of the damper is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The damper itself is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The support bracket for the actuator is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The seismic requirements for evaluatinq the actuators are .the same as
those for the isolation dampers.
m t! r
A ~ .0'. -, . -~ ~ -
The maximum seismic stresses were calcu ated by using the square root sum of the squares method for combining the three earthquake direction stresses as recommended in the UFSAR for seismic analysis at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. A second method, the distortion energy method was used for combining stresses at the press fit between the main body cylinder and the mounting yoke. The distortion-energy method was used in place of the square:root sum of the . squares method because the stresses due to the press-fit condition exceeded and dominated those caused by the seismic event. All maximum stresses were then compared to some fraction of the yield strength depending on the material type and stress type. Operability after a DBE event was ensured by requiring that the iaximum stress from comined seismic and normal loads should not exceed 90% of the yield.stress of the material.
Conclusion
After completing the above described seismic analysis on the five models of Hills-McCanna. actuators installed on the isolation dampers at the Duane Arnold Energy Center, it was found that the maximum stresses from the combined seismic and normal loads do not exceed the material yield requirements defined in the isolation damper purchase specification. The results of this seismic analysis reveal that the five models.of Hills-McCanna actuators are seismically qualified for use at the Duane Arnold Energy Center.
References
- Bechtel Purchase Specification 7884-M-100
Formulas for Stress and Strain; Raymond J. Roark, Warren C. Young, Fifth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1975
Hills-McCanna Information Bulletins; R-1090, R-1090A, R110C, R1100A, R111C, R-1110A, R-112D, R-1120A, R-113D, R-1130A
Marks' Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers' Baumeister Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company 1973
Materials Selector 75; Reinhold Publishing Co. Mid September 1974, Vol. 80, No. 4, Brown Printing Co.
Mechanical Engineering Design; Joseph E. Shigley, Third Edition, McGrawHill Book Co. 1977
Mechanics of Materials; Higdon, Ohlsen, Stiles, Weese, Riley Third. Edition, John Wiley and Sons 1978
r ,,
- -. - .~'a-
Ro~ckwell Hills-McCanna; Proprietary Drawings
DATA: Information contained on drawings is proprietary and confidential and is not to te given or loaned to others. Drawings are to be returned to Rockwell upon completion of their intended use in making the seismic analysis., R260 R450-R960 R2000-R4200 430-1004 r50-7511
- 430-7510 .430-7511 420-2003 430-3005 430-4101 430-4102 430-2101
-430-2904 430-2502430-2501 .430-3321 430-3322 430-3325 430-3201
.430-3202 430-8203
450-1005 450-7512 4L50-3005 450-3007 450-4101 450-4102 450-2101 450-2906 450-2507 450-2501 450-3201 450-3202 450-3203 40-3326 450-3325 450-3321 450-3320
460-7511460-1001 460-7509 460-3001 460-3003 460-4101 460-4102 460-2101 460-2904. 460-2503 460-2502 460-3208 460-3209
. .,. 460-3210
... 460-3317 460-3316 460-3320 460-3321 460-3314 460-3315
U.S.S. Steel Desian Manual; R.L. Brockenbrough and B.G. Johnson, Jan. 1981
7 ~ ~"A.
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
POSITION
EDUCATION
PROFESSIONA DATA
SUMMARY
EXPERIENCE
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Michigan
MS, Civil/Structural Engineering, University of Michigan
Registered Professional Engineer in Michigan
1 year: Senior Engineer; Civil/ Strxctural Staff
4 years: Senior Engineer; Midland, Palisades, and Big Rock Point Nuclear Power Plants
1 year: Resident Engineer, Midland Nuclear Power Plant
Mr. Reifschneider is currently assigned as a civil/structural engineer on the civil/ structural staff. His duties include; preparation of design standards; review of project calculations, drawings, specifications and -seismic qualification of equipment; providing consultation to civil/structural engineers engaged in the design of nuclear and fossil power plants; solving special static and dynamic structural problems.
Prior to joining the civil/structural staff, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/ structural engineer on Consumers Power Company's Palisades project. His duties included finite element analysis of the biological shield wall, seismic analysis and design of blockwall supports, and seismic analysis and design of the auxiliary building addition including the review of seismic equipment qualifications.
Prior to joining the Palisades project, Mr..Reifschneider was a civil/structural resident engineer at the jobsite of Consumers Power company's Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included interfacing with construction personnel on the design, erection, and construction of seismic instrument and equipment supports.
n r?
...... ~-UA C' 9
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
Prior to his jobsite assignment, Mr. Reifachneider conducted research on the inelastic design and behavior of braced structural steel systems, moment.frame structural steel system, and reinforced concrete shear wall systems. -He co-authored three Bechtel reports on the findings of this research.
Prior to his research assignment, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural engineer on the Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included designing seismic supports for HVAC ducts and electrical cabletrays.
77h.
L; U ii % 2 I
IOWA ELECTRIc LiGHT AND POWER COMPANY
I CEDAR RAPIDS.IOWA
FORE F R 1A; Rx v
cwfl H ~ 1\\ idrah pd ( -NTeR . 6T es (z
4TRE SS STR1-S5 __..c______o__
____
cT EE
0- yWor e~uc-les \*5coo 4< 195'o es.
L\ 15 a1
ell~
43Vops. Gy E - Z'34S00S 7 014
N~oo r1 9Son ramm I *345-=- E -5 / 7'9 Ps 3/S- t. Tac POO6 L
/OdooPse'
N4cTE oe9 pm o7 rsoE srwe
9~~~~~~~~X LME trRio\. oaEn E ~x
DEPT.
SUBJECT <*.
ce-pod by Dote h..d _ _ Dt.
IOWA ELECTRIc LiGHT D-POWE COMPAY
CEDAA RAPIDS. IOWA
DEPT. P )4.\ Pi (', -PI
P.RWEToO O j 1( ' yg SUBJECT \(A fie- {
.c-w y Do_ __,,. o_A_ ,
R-2(4OF IS o
1A - -. ~
~ ~,.
-. ~
'.&~ ~'t*
-''9..
N N P .-e r i cs a e L o G oe42,. 9 ~ t ~ t e
K,-\-OLO1se LL..LJ ~ L eys . , or
((teT TWo, - /2ZpsL
10 we
s y 3=00 to //37 4/ \zooc
5 = \7O co 'w - g0 Izz. < oco
LSGT14EE\\l T. m-tao
N\RPi Cv woE 440 W~eTN LNN0 I TRC~a. = o.ct' W737 < \OO6
lowA--E Ec-TRj--1Gws- ou. - P_ _ _ A * II
D POWER COMPANY Pm -,,
I CAna RmA ,s. Iow^ sud cr 40e if 77. 0... o by .. // P 0*
R-26 O s
~cV ?-.&z" ~ ~
+'1
/ N
tNP'wk O1Z0\ Q \ vLr (Z7R
4
\7.520" £o 2.eY1 ft' ~
I
= .~7.Z7 ~
Tho C~ ~~SG ~jL1~c~
D 2\4'
= O - 26 1
47R d
\storwT= c.Z<2 V .31')(c.2 4 . 14 -Z-)(.z5)
6-ow VA, 7(
L- A4 0y, -CkL
LE&GWa oiF 0tJE (-c)tL:-L
= 25/ ~
\.-- 0,SW) - (2. 83 6 -2, *21. \2
69414GL-,, -e .li
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT - AND. PQWrCOMPAIrce
CDAn RomI .Iow^
?-- r 60 IF 5s
~\ zc~-~
/ (
~p..
/ /
0.7 S 7
/
Q3'ThI\ \7 ~SK)
- ~ ))o.304 )
- t \. O (o
6) -- L'7 s.
& = .c,+-sZ
\h= .04
o,32
0:45 7 o4
\.7,56 <s\40 ()
. V3 4S') -, L3Z
FO MORMTIO . "
4,
-b-; 21 ~
7.I * *--- --
~1
= O. 631 s
DEPT.\ ,
P RCU ECT C h T%. r=
SUIBJECT gsrl /m/ O 0.** .. &Z/ JR 0_EOC...
cc' d;s
0.75"7
-A- I
II
'7 /i7Q~ 7/
A c - -L4 8y-L&4) x / Y 94- 0 (CeApomum2
\-/ +7 5 ,1t2t- /,aZ/94
(5,73
\JL)E G-wY Es~oCC,t Zs ,75)=
FRINa
WA ELECTRIC LGHT OUT' M
nDPuWER-WCOMPAN-Y
CXDAR APIIDS. OWA
4- c..L. .. * -0.+ w/D*
R-2 &c FA.
.'t 4 _____.
lQwA%-EL-EC-T.RjC-L GH-T
AND POWER COMPANY
CaDI RAPIDS.IOWA
R 2. 0 - 7
DEPT.
SU. _ECT 1___5 __LY_ S h - ct____
C ***. 6., NJ o.
kSciffrrTrit. ICL.e0
4.1 e.7 ?, 5 7-D
EmmeT o 0 --LT0 T PAL.- (X\s OF~ sesi rJhL~ACie wocalZO:?'"TOLu. (~') LORD \4 6REetT -kae (\ ')1.*8
0n L-.
* W1.(RA\Nr'1.tcA 9.109-G \OC PI AC..T <trG o NJ
14 LSe CAP) 0. so'
\4.11
cv e.z
i '~,.,
W~ I7r~ ~ ~SLf~
r ~&~~Ct: (~.to.rv> -
V AR\Lr - >
los-. 2.52} 9 54--,'
4
= 4-4 + -8. \ I:t s:5 -- 7. C
r 1\ d%.-I
SwEARz *CT 6 N4 T per7it\td rCC-A P Y1PL O~ PIr
.. w7,*.. .. .. ,. .... . I
lowA ELECTIC LicHT PT- Q UC-, M I A4ND POWER COMPANY W --
Czzn.. RAPIDS. IowA 4
jp- e, .&~- pVc
mN&1.- y T s <.-z 4/ 1 Hl C. 4 / JC fu 44
L~So
-TA - \4ti a -- \\1 .1 to-c
6~~&, C- Twc 15 ihrG kee oz 1 -%ow A,.
+L S7-47(:D S Zo
ct -os 5. e -- +-4c 7
144 lyS) -= C<'iGOaeAn LodT. _O__ 7.
(t Ia . G 1,1 4 t~' .\2 ___ ___ - - 0.125('0.. c (} , . - 2, 0 0i~ -*A C2Y. e-\ 4 ' __=\_-a
___ - \~~.(. Esi \4_ ___._ __ __
B. 4 ,c',2
)pQ )4, .4' o0 s . ? *
lOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT.
D POWE SCOMmAr EC mSnSElstleSTs A~a,-e\ )AYM Its..t..sf aAMMA At"OATEPWM,
CJA-n RAPIDS.IOWA
'~'Tosj ')C = \L1b.5 \. -- 5Z5.34 ?sr
/9e~/9~J/A3~/ef ,D." d 77.2- *
___l_ 91 _5- T OD
* r1-- 1 vz
1. CDOTR7 .GE . '
3 r0
3.6G- 5,36. 0.004 ift~xmi) j ')
~.= Z~j
~-Z
\ Cwt1) -~ 2E b2.
0,~ \GZ "4.. c, c0.o
_0_ _ _ __._ _-_m-w \R som.2
1 ._ _ 17PZ O.?67 )( a 1 o0 q= 2 2z .24 '1 s t 1((\.925 I L
004-. \.36 o + 92
?E~ \3,5~7~ (r~r~A ~~tJ~')
I d ~ ~.,.-,.....
+- -a2
Tc-vELE-Th icU LicuT
AND POWER COMPANY CXZDJ- RAPI5.--OWA
oEPT.. t1 F t____1___ __ C__
"jO~ ~ ~ -- ~&t~C~EC- ~"C~4
C-I
29rcas s0e ec
S~ CM ~ ~
_- i.9t?) .9 -so
P714.~ es~
( ~- W7C~z K
- \36~.3*~ ~s-
-\5 20 C-,C& fT
R 4NFO ,ivqATIN
£ ±
/ 2G) LG!5- '
r
-7 2.Z -
I
OuD sloT' fL--at . oa-r .
PRmEcT W..\'1.1 $" O SmiEryT551%5M1114 SrRyp q - .4 t. s c-.P.... by.. Dt
6'=T\'E G sG TOD TH e - D5 tL3 00 , 1T-lko tM-
-Z C .
S7 r-r" it,- . ODPT. 1 oy l 4 4 K wAELETRIGV .LhIrr-
AND POWER COMPANY
SCEDAP RAPIDS. IOWA Can Th atesZ low
PRJECT ' 00 A . C. " . .. * .. **
SWJa\ECT \ A4AL.915 A *(WatJA 9tATL
cO..w. _ _ _ _ _l _ D _ _ _
S~ N(o~E _____________ _____
~1~S~L -~-~
_______ ~ P~&~
De '.-1 _ _ . 10.- a) /\ W \.% 2 \ //,526'.77427 L6. 1.7 Z
=0
/
C~.C~2-i§'I=.Z.~) K
~r'~ ~?tJ~
2,. L -1
almoRes eML')3.3Q 4 C. csua ( -:41
More 1;- 11 2, 'L+ Voe lhMad
Te r
ono136Te
t*N~IP O0 Citi0 \6 loo QSLGO T c c VoTw Ri 610ES OF S,7/orc. "yct.ODES orca~i3G R M
"ZxGs To PAGE 00' T .e \.r'7t o oc
}/L * $1 (0.9\ SG} + 3.0 + I.5) .L (.023 5
rM muA -pNil- - . foa-3 LLv! lk
lOWA ELECTRic LIGH no~ AND POWER COMPANY P"'CT
CXDA RAR os.loWA
- ?c O .4
*r *4 *A
DesLe
. Nho retv se- 0 r 7r rc LM 'hr rR4i ecvn-r
I ~.
-c -~ -~Q3'~E-~. 4 - 35a~'Y~) *~
77I~z.L-z>- '311 e6 Pz:
34s. 3 qst-3.e, 32 , 's
975,35
( 3.655e-- 35-
&* 31 t IS .N1 ?s
-17O .G S
64..1 P67
0 - 16G1\.43
zL~~
L0
'Li
S.
(i..
t:.
S
~4e4
~2~
'C'
-771 ~/
OWA ELECTRIC LGHT DEPT
AND POWER COMPANY
CZDAm RAPIDS. IOWA UJEC ffC
-i-t~o D o -i
Orywh -I 1 <L/JOG TP S
-+ \ 5'1,4) + -\&s*- . 4-- A.
465=
'55 0 Z -- .0
0% = o\4~'c~o&)
-i = \l1e3, 5 C
43Z0C Ce=
432c~o ?~
O~w ~O~.Q ~ 4 -422O'~ ~T
-. r,~ ~
1 O L - e-ST
Z m we.=48coe-
lOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. i.a . M -I
AND POWER: COMPANY-- PMJECT ShO** SCwAR rAPIDS.Iow JCON R-tre-.0 be.'. _... by4d_ ,
/1
U.--- WI
?~~6 ~'C~
O.0co =
-~2
0. 0c~ \
K
\.42-1 ),'7
OOc\. s ' -40) ,1 \
cano coe .> (zXO(,ias4 -n
( ,. (z,) 0
Nici. 70..<=.206 8. c-,2
.- A
j
-~-~-. t.
Athl11ALMA rE6Lt on92E F
lOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT
Ann POWER COMPANY Czzun RAPDS.IoWA
nET' DEQfrt4t r-tAC, ,) SZ t4 G(1.. \4
SUECT Zl R101.0 Asa±uS galt . --- A---.
C..yw by. Daft O.c.A ____/__1
> Z-5 24
I 3+4
KQ~Q~
- \ Ears
I
Vi (a. 64
C. ~rg7~~
Y ~Z') \24Z.3 Or
FOR INFORMAT I Y
Ao
70' ET SO ULtd zo1 ozrrG r
\L C
o 7 z C:-to -
lay= (8.2 1 Y1715 10 t3 5 t o- to
\ty 2@() I=T-assed\a o.x
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT
0ND POWER COMPANY
CZDAR RAPinS.IoWA
-- \ < - Zs GO i->
Ly .
= ~Z4(~9~ P5.~
4 &:~a-::.
c. c'7' fzs
TROS - c Cc! 9(-o
pSz
-1 r /,5 'D eB E
U!1
L1
DEPT. 'QF eA-w NL*4-1 PRJECT -- * *
ntry h 1, w T . _ _ a_ vl_ s o Al h -- epr.
c..... b.y ... Ad bw ZA J 4DE ..
2 (y} [80 )Tz~a t u sors 2f 4
L-,-(--) L-\
lowAE-LEcTRIG-LG, DEPT.- 2-9-\ 6MP.4-11
A0 POWER COMPANY E \
C3A RAses.IoJ SUBJECT 154 C S- A ys Mas cad A T OR7 S 5 L-Ai eOt.
-~ ZZZ9,25 +2 S.25 + \24t .2
2<9r1L K z- IL ./iF
To E7 f?\30l Gezknor Cl
/O6~e5C) ?$~
3 54 20, co
eF r 76./'M
"S 0 sssct-k
FO f OM t !INLY
IowA ELECTRIc LIGHT P . A04 AND POWER COMPANY '...O.. - -J
-UJC Olt ANA 5--WXsancr ya. gfeA)A1-A I c;7v 4~e5 CFD^A flAPI Ei.IW
._ _ e . Dw Do* St- -T-\ f~6 frp\ (. -TRs n - t- eO- TwE thou Tr V i
I I
,2S 4.C0
4 - 50
3.e s
0. 2 2
it
OiA.
o(: ;l %E
\.042. + .982s/a0. /
Y"4 = - 2.524 -t 3.co -0. 4 ?!(Yc) q~~CV)~m ~k
w +j4.c~-? ~o) (~:- £212
&- 4.c'Q
070 Z~
- , i : . a Z (.awd) =- 0,64-1 V
V- -
E:LfR,5-r\c- S-7qLa=l ps
a
7.-cr (0G7-(c c c (4.0 -2 7 ) .c-0
c~ : -i-'
c -5.700
S-O.+
~0.03Z
-Z -c ( 4. 0 - 2.P C~~ L= .1'2
~C~ ~.4Z+ O~ S /4Z~c/
-0074 0.1, I(c 25(.2of - c.ct ((.so 10 --. 505
.4s - o ( 250)'+ o~S t .)= -O.39 3
.CC .- ___-NEE
x ,- 32024
7* 3 -t ( O.32&#.O~3%)+ (- O.S493)0. roe?5) +-1. 3465 3.1' 5
O\ L~i~ow~G
N"1 = C (z x z(dim0) (s s c
IJ T . IA L 4 , 4 4
-- ,5 . co
/ 2'. 5§) - \Y(.5 L~
y ----y aro II
Z.5
LowA-ELEC-TR Li r H-T o DEm.. - 1 sc H ,Ao 4- G
AND POWER COMPANY. P oJEcT .OL * C5 4 ( .,,,
CroAza RAPIDS.IOWA - - 4L- c
. a tt. c~u-s ga-t.R t o __ w___ Mo.. n by 0Yow.
a
Ac. = 61\S \.- 40
-~ .' -_ 3.Ccol
9 - =(505\- \02) To.1
tV?.\~X~~ _______________
2 5 z~
2.5
22
" so n) 6 . )(4 r. s 4 i=3 .
(.eessAt ame ResR .5a G-(c.-5/ 4.43 Z
6 ! 5 -7 -:-..- 4S~ JA~
r- (rt' A. 2'0
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DET 4 -1ILC k,\f _T;D POWER-COMPANY- .cc
SUBJECT 1EtSMlC ST RS EDAR APJD w
Do_ _ __C*__de_
- 62snC.Ges AL-tsk OM 31 e -co3 'Ie
z K-,
jc~o~v~
IOWA ELECTRIC IDGHT DEPT. (A I
AND POWER COMPANY
CLAwn Thoros. Iow . UJET14 C 2-7-moo ES -,-c - STE.. _ ... a__...
0 G 'Eco- '7o0 0 o w s r =0
86 .2 + Dc.o 2-.j = \3
.'Z~ ; 1L
6 = 80, coc\Q'r e-&a mB t 30 Cor ca S \\5.4.5W\ C .(tQ2sopoo') - 8 0 s
Z \a, '00 ~t ta..wsko &anco -s-c&Tw
* h2..0 e O.4A(30,000c') -\12co 25
T ';-E- T\-, E IF f 9 F -- T
rows -n- rc-Asi-r 09si ('mwT--x Cor-w Cas 11t6Z
257 S7 1.0
Z 57* 5 7.Z
/,S
2~7 -~ /93.75
F lT 0
6 CAC cTa vn R L-1$_,t\s Otj T -\0 MOT~rdsG voiC(E
:0 t- o I . k s
Sheet/sAof Ip
DESIGN/REVIEW COMMENTS SHEET.
VERIFICATION ALTERNATE CALCULATIONS
Form No. NG-009Z* Rev. 0
I ."1'l*
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER
CALCULATION COVERSHEET
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION NO: - Z
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION TITLE:
~2-~i~ ~<
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
MAR NO:
DCR NO:
OTHERS: r
PREPARED BY:
REVIEWED BY:
APPROVED BY:
£~I i~6 /
/ / 2
FINAL APPROVAL BY:________
DATE:
DATE: 4/
DATE: Y/
DATE: 30 f
NG-007Z REV. 0
. - -.----...... *. 4 .~-.,. - --. . -
FORM
HL.LS-- of tA ( -:(Z e- T- a J-0 (; , e-
Background
The purpose for compiling calculations M84-11, 12, 13, 14, 15 was to perform a sei.smic analysis on the critical components of the Hills-McCanna Pneumatic Damper Actuators. These actuators are part of the secondary containment isolation system at the Duane Arnold Energy Center'
On January 26, 1984, Iowa Electric notified the NRC by telephone that the above mentioned actuators were potentially deficient in meeting their purchase specification. A review of the documents relatinq to this discrepancy revealed that the isolation damper assemblies were purchased originally as complete assemblies which included the damper actuators. Subsequent orders for "likefor-like" replacement actuators were placed directly with the actuator manufacturer who was a subvendor to the damper manufacturer. This most recent purchase order for actuators revealed that a quality assurance program, as required for safety related equipment per 10CFR Part 50, is not currently in effect at.the actuators manufacturer's facility.
Further review of the damper assembly documentation revealed that the seismic analysis performed on the damper assemblies did not seismically analyze the actuators themselves, but only considered their weight as it seismically affected the damper frame. This information prompted Iowa Electric to audit the damper manufacturer and check for documentation that pertained to the seismic qualifications of the isolation damper actuators. Results from the audit of the damper manufacturer revealed that the actuators were never purchased by-the damper manufacturer as seismically qualified components nor did the damper manufacturer administer a Quality Assurance program concerning the purchase of the actuators.
Since no traceability or Certificate of Conformance was available for the seismic qualifications of the actuators, a seismic analysis was performed on the critical components of the actuators in order to seismically qualify the damper actuators for use in the Duane Arnold Energy Center. This seismic analysis followed the guidelines set forth in the original purchase specification for the isolation dampers (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100). By seismically qualifying the isolation damper actuators, Iowa Electric will be able to buy Quality Level I actuators in accordance with Revision 1, Chapter 4 of the Quality Assurance Manual under Standard Industrial Quality Items 4.7.3.
Solution
A seismic analysis was performed on five models of the Rockwell HillsMcCanna Ramcon Pneumatic Actuator product line that are installed as isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. These five models include the following:
* R-260 FS e R-450 FS * R-960 FS * R-2000 FS a R-4200 FS
_UU3, - *.4.
The seismic analysis on the actuators followed the general project seismic requirements for frequency-not-determined class 1 equipment in the reactor building and in the control building (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100, Technical Specifications for Isolation Dampers for the Duane Arnold Energy Center Unit 1, Revision 0, 12-28-70).
A visual inspection of all isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center' was made in order to verify model number, seria-1 number and elevation location in the plant. After verifying the elevation location in the plant, static coefficients (g units) were determined for the highest installed actuator for each of the five actuator models. The horizontal static co*ifficient was then applied to all three of the orientation axis which eliminated many repetitious calculations and the need for detailed actuator orientation information. Applying the horizontal static coefficient to each axis provided conservative results since the horizontal coefficient is always greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (Fvertical = (Weight) (1 + gv),Fhorizontal = (Weight) (gh)0 gh > 1 + gv).
The seismic analysis concentrated on the critical areas of the damper actuator where the seismically induced loads could possibly make the actuator. fail, malfunction, or prevent operation. Five areas on each actuator model were Identified as critical areas requiring a seismic analysis of the various components interfacing with that critical area. These five critical areas are identified as the following:
o Retaining key which holds the spring cylinder assembly to the main body cylinder
o Main body cylinder o Press fit between main body cylinder and the mou-nting yoke o Mounting hardware o Mounting yoke
Dimensions and material specifications for the seismic analysis were obtained through the use of proprietary component drawings that were on loan to Iowa Electric from Rockwell Hills-,McCanna of Carpentersville, Illinois. All prints applicable to this seismic analysis are listed in the reference section of the referenced calculations.
Four basic assumptions are applied throughout the entire seismic analysis of the damper actuators. These assumptions allow Iowa Electric to use the floor response spectra as the design/qualification spectra for the seismic analysis. The four basic assumptions are as follows:
o0
o0
o o0
The mounting of the damper is a rigid structure (f >. 33 cps) The damper itself is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) The support bracket for the actuator is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) The seismic requirements for evaluatinq the actuators are the same as those for the isolation dampers.
.~A. .. t.'.4-
The -maximum seismic stresses were calculated by using the square root sum of the squares method for combining the three earthquake direction stresses as recommended in the UFSAR for seismic analysis at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. A second method,the distortion energy method was used for combining stresses at the press fit between the main body cylinder and the mounting yoke. The distortion energy method was used in place of the squareproot sum of the squares method because the stresses due to the press-fit condition exceeded and dominated those caused by the seismic event. All maximum stresses were then compared to some fraction of the yield strength depending on the material type and stress type. Operability after a DBE event was ensured by requiring that ne maximum stress from combined seismic and normal loads should not exceed 90%
of the yield stress of the material.
Conclusion
After completing the above described seismic analysis on the five models of Hills-McCanna actuators installed on the-isolation dampers at the Duane Arnold Energy Center, it was found that the maximum stresses from the combined seismic and normal loads do not exceed the material yield requirements defined in the isolation damper purchase specification. The results of this seismic analysis reveal that the .five models of Hills-McCanna.actuators are seismically qualified for use at the Duane Arnold Energy Center.
References
-Bechtel Purchase Specification 7884-M-100
Formulas for Stress and Strain; Raymond J. Roark, Warren C. Young, Fifth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1975
Hills-McCanna Information Bulletins; R-1090, R-1090A, R110C, R1100A, R111C, R-1110A, R-1120, R-1120A, R-113D, R-1130A
Marks' Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers' Baumeister Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company 1978
Materials Selector 75; Reinhold Publishing Co. Mid September 1974, Vol. 80, No. 4, Brown Printing Co.
Mechanical Engineering Design; Joseph E. Shigley, Third Edition, McGrawHill Book Co. 1977
Mechanics of Materials; Higdon, Ohlsen, Stiles, Weese, Riley Third Edition, John Wiley and Sons 1978
77, 17, F" _ r". n 7 .9, A
Rcckwell Hills'-McCanna; Proprietary Drawings L i
DATA: Information contained on drawings is proprietary and confidential and is not to be given or loaned to others. Drawings are to be returned to Rockwell upon completion of their intended use in making the seismic analysis.. R260 R450-R960 R2000-R4200
43U-1UU4 430-7510 .430-7511 43j-2003 430-3005 430-4101 430-4102 .430-2101 430-2904 430-2502430-2501 430-3321 430-3322 430-3325 430-3201 .430-3202 430-8203
450-7511 450-1005 450-7512 450-3005450-3007 450-4101 450-4102 450-2101 450-2906 450-2507 450-2501 450-.3201 450-3202 450-3203. 450-3326 450-3325 450-3321 450-3320
460-7511 460-1001 460-7509 460-3001 460-3003 460-4101 460-4102 460-2101 460-2904. 460-2503 460-2502 460-3208 460-3209 460-3210 460-3317 460-3316 460-3320 460-3321 460-3314 460-3315
U.S.S. Steel Design Manual; R.L. Brockenbrough and -B.G. 1981
Johnson, Jan.
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
POSITION
EDUCATION
PROFESSIONAL DATA
SUMMARY
EXPERI ENCE
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Michigan
MS, Civil/Structural Engineering, University of Michigan
Registered Professional Engineer in Michigan
1 year: Senior Engineer; Civil/ trucural Staff
4 years: Senior Engineer; Midland, Palisades, and Big Rock Point Nuclear Power Plants
1 year: Resident Engineer, Midland Nuclear Power Plant
Mr. Reifschneider is currently assigned as a civil/structural engineer on the civil/ structural staff. His duties include; preparation of design standards; review of project calculations, drawings, specifications and .seismic qualification of equipment; providing consultation to civil/structural engineers engaged in the design of nuclear and fossil power plants; solving special static and dynamic structural problems.
Prior to joining the civil/structural staff, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/ structural engineer on Consumers Power Company's Palisades project. His duties included finite element analysis of the biological shield wall, seismic analysis and design of blockwall supports, and seismic analysis and design of the auxiliary building addition including the review of seismic equipment qualifications.
Prior to joining the Palisades project, Mr..Reifschneider was a civil/structural resident engineer at the jobsite of Consumers Power company's Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included interfacing with construction personnel on the design, erection, and construction of seismic instrument and equipment supports.
~,
.-..
F- C- 7
Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
Prior to his jobsite assignment, Mr. Reifschneider conducted research on the inelastic design and behavior of braced structural steel systems, moment frame structural steel system, and reinforced concrete shear wall systems. He co-authored three Bechtel reports on the findings of this research.
Prior to his research assignment, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural engineer on the Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included designing seismic supports for HVAC ducts and electrical cabletrays.
rn T1
- ~ ...-. ~ - - . -. OM&A6
MARTIN RLEIFSCHNEIDER
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DUT. F r&t{ t
ANDPOWERCOMPANY-- PRCHE D4 C6;-J-T 7
GCzzAJ RAPIDS.IOWA 4 Io 0 . Dy
N" ~ -~ ~ &~ U ______________ N\~ ~'N~\~
$. =O.5)6y o 5h < 1,4 1150 5
.3\- Z. .Go7s
oo6 A= -4SoFs,6 * o0
Z-1-3 aot-TS L /0000 ps z
NOE o T EL Tw C- oo vs \.-r -Vvnswrus
0. 671 t . 5
0a-. t'KeZ -es\ss 0414 R o Twe G'rse. OR.sudATso~o pe.- wow
I.-,". .- . .' :- . * **-A- - A
L.oj ~ GoD. Ei c.11LATED N~aamiic pres (1.
pPz i .)
i
I -
IOWA ELECTRIc LIrH
KAND POWER COMPANY' CEDAji RAPIDS. IOwA
Ol Ou s -. - 4-50n FS
FLaiNvogyC..
chOL
- ~...7.j[
______ __ ru e 07 s \...oe 20~o s l.tol-7TE 17 rC L, czce myz
.D p T 0'o (S )EA o Z 7 S7 IM OO
Y ic -,( _____ \zo____i ____- ___o_
Res?-TOar
,A) O Movi,'c NNtlA -c\cow CEavoJ.O4
ObGAG~d 0-0 ec
DEPT. /6/J 4 /7 ,2/,Jc PRoJECT. SUBLIECT by ,0/ chAY. / //A - by -7
** e...___.___,,,,
lOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
CEDALl RDPIDS.IOWA
DEPT. Q f-S l TG
PROJECT .. ~rcp SUBJECT \ / /
r~~O1~~:? INFO ~ G~LY
Cj LQ ) :
o w.=.c
ocue 5C 0-~ V.\ ) A~-- -'~
<' C.?e2~Z~
IE Iv\ZIEe N<:- E .45o - 75/z-
Do= -6 D 5~26 V: . 0
O-.ZS'3 #4A'
VoLUe Z: (F5' 7y) 4. Zo4)
4
EOJC0 CA p (S<. ~Lkr.C.o )
\/oere ~.Ie0) as -( E V3 - 7- (eZ) . ' .ID ./X6
-. 1
~-4SO ___
( - A 6o \ ;z- 0 )
.. , -, - . - : - -4-
DEPT. InM rst Et Gk t t l Q (L vt.0 , p\9 4-\ IwA-E-Ec-T-R ic-LGiH T-
AND POWER COMPANY . sm- w6'C TrE A AL'\ IL..-(lAsJO 9c-Q71/A77R'
CrDAn RApiOs.lowA
Computd -bi .D("hck.. b, D.
w-45.0 F6
. I{
-
1 -1 /375
. V =(V.6cz (JAI. s-2) -O.72z44
x zVz7e-
k 45o
4 o~ - sto3
RN
267G
Ac )&Q47t2(. V . 0D 41 1 a
~'. I
_ I..
x 5:2 UE BZ
VK 7 (/ s N(/Nt) . 7 36 0
\ijLcuomE- OF hr (16wtoC 'rkLot.( t*R (O~~ Z.44 ) - O2.
or. \} = \.&4 + \6.o- M + ,oo~ -~ Won -4.
-~~~ \\wT 0.2 1
/5.' - y , .* _ ..
-A1.132
-I
123Z
V7 21
[oWA ELECTRIC LiGHT DT. \ E c LQ\ @,xr\ " +\l
CHAND Pa' msIo suar-JE~ te '0414Ag O 5 EtQ t 151 CLA 1 *_i_.A ____ t A~ CED- RA.D.S.IOW.
__ __ _
C
\o~ \' Q
G--
S£
3.34
(45 o- 3oo5
Es w PUcz ~usc) 17
ff
4
;
g
ul4
ANo POWER CC MPANY .. ,wECT E511 fe-5 sA..151h~.5 Af~~d 1AE
- a ~ -.. a.C
*
(,&~ ~.o4&
'~ NA ~
C
,/omeoTras p. Z~o o
rTO ouLCG Eu"TIo '.674
(ors 7'4. /.7 3.3
16 &/YFEa 7f4//.) (/ ) ZoI/0/910 4) V//7e..
E ~ ~ ~ C s Ti at. - em.
'i r
Z1 ---- - d--- -p
VF-rwL= 27Z +04 3 +(Zies's - tce)
Q~ Ewo uCAP) .0 Th (seF - CmvL') = \-0
14,6FcrvT-3) = Z. L)
M4 ( Pis~w} 201
s50. st.
S '4
F = z\61.3# Fld i s som or iteTALZL7A00 OFR
D -#.~
Vg~ = z4~Th:
~ 44 \1~o ~
61 IF Iz>
S- .I CO
d T" 'l eto5ge om1 3 5G
-- "S Foco ps Swnr cedr4 .'.,- . :1. c :-t
,
7 56 -7 SO T'AE V.'stri G \<-4
tsh'T- (-T I Ocd .
?0-15 TeT L.E~acry-t (eds~zo sG-OGz
A -4GO -3COE 0 1 ;E ." = cDo l-tre \6\/a RT
R-4G -900 -351"=15 ls E '/aRT
IowA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
CAn RAptos..IowASIECT qlSlt\\C
c..... D.#.* O.. *A, L d Dm'______
____ ______ ~ ~r-~ C~E?~~ ~CA1r' ~OC~ ~kS~CC~L'-i
hA - 41\% z 4.os iZ. a)54 !9.Zl (. sz; 4..
A= '754. 1\6
-TACT-rA (1) \t, TwE Fi"L..TwAC-T Co m sa
4\c\~q4 A01 q%>Ct~ig ToT*.R~o'tas 945GZ O R Q rsa d R ___ is D ish c o e T -a t. P<-4 B 0
L.7- ncm (esrid wsr
ZaC?.( z s A. 4
'Y AGy3 2 .
4
y(9 = K e
C loi -Tirdt t . 7Z
A t- 4. 16 1
1,67
00~2 '735
m
Aw~
\c 75)30
6.30 2.0. y').z zra - /98.Z fsjj
/t5/8,/9 < /'5OO Psx
I, -, . , -. *... . . -I*-~ P. -
3~c~-~~
r7-
% WAude
-11
C>
-L kl t ' z- ;I
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT D O
AND POWER COMPANY PROJCTr - -EA
CZ n t mAPIDS.IoWA
M br--- o*** - - C a - .. ,o
R - 450 bu
SFR INFORATON ONLY Sms s o T'o c-k %<ss wi- c\oeovir Osu)<.e-N)
7NE fre AO TH @/1.0002 Soo
C r. c =c6 -
6.
C&- ?2.631'?S
(F Z.925 F , a)
(4- -3) \Z\5
1-044Z. ko e\\\ (AxT (PAOm M. T =
h7tT 9- 5 - 2es2
6" _ oP=~*~ (\*9~)
-~ - - ..-.-.. ~-.
( 4-
\QZ
O.05 2-( +
* REER~r\-\Goot;"rckwAvri\.c-s ciF Mnarma:r-4t.S"
Got.UE Trow. P ,s \de rt\i e s o'
b E
LpWALECTR iC-LI GT
AND POWER COMPANY
Cr n..n o2m- In .
I.
p Roi EcyTnOf-m-lE RPsr,'MOt-t a145i ('-TGGk s 7 .fli9 SU&JECT SE =1110 ST1nE65 //ALyns Ms-//c* crTAeS
Je-w Sn, 0 w -.. AJ4. - 0..
Zi!i~)'70 s
2.~ 2c~T~ }
i O TELOG !\10-('- 004:29C&
( -3 - .Z swz
1~
c2 = (- .1 ) \1
-(2.__ 3____ ._ 95__
(C d) - - B~C ~
A-
(?~z3 ~ Cw42) (2.630
G. O- TL
- 0 Psi
~/2~?~& F5Z
('I
(
I, DEPT.. \ t\d -
R-4lO V
STR SS It4 C-NL-Lz007-R ExRr\..Bssm
Q-IL . ki7z- Z-
e!7-Pl-z
-0H43
I ' I -E.L-Ec-TRIC
AND POWER CO CrDom _RAPoS.
DEPT. oF-G t l ' . \ 4--L -A I T- enom - T h- ~ AgAt- 0,rre _(a=_ . . R., /
MPANY PRJE=T L)'AR -1
OWA SUJECT 15 I L
Dow. _ _*_ _ d / D
.- , -~%. -~'
r~r~
-~ - C. U\~O~ o.~,e. -~ ~ogv~J-r
7,
Ms -- 4.25
Y* -I o &N -tg \s o to Acx os cw s os
* (ADG.00 (4A NZO.co-h2S r t wrA mere \ . \ YEl-k QT0 .T .6 9 0 \ ~ rse >1fTt\ m-s l
T .L
IS To 0 - fes, o Vr Z7 Rcroad
(orme ea) ?(<2t e
S ft 4<OO C 15.,?%T P .q '- i0 F 0
M, ceuo CAP) =.'. 0 =_
M4~ateset3=\.4
T~~z~sems)= \C.P<-
swe-a
' 5 o -7 !F7-
lowA ELECTRIC UGHT AvD POWER COMPANY
I 'v~ n .n 7 asow."
DPnrT r (DrZ-sx 10\r-~v\- ..- N\
S ECT - ** - C *A C 4r s e t\\C. . IS /L/D."cCA/_)_ __7L A9TOR
~J'
.~.J I
Itt
-.
9070 0 42C"psz
p
+ 426Avi p4.
\\0
-L- 2
- \292')+ ~ZZ92+ O -( -y .
e 43,zoo Y>s--
S= 1Z34,'7 ?sI / 43,200 ?St
SonwiOT ~ ~ r I3 o TEEKOS AA ic 1
\ 19.5 ?st
Ilo
EwA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. T Gf t\Gt3 ar';a
EDP0W'EWC0MPAN'Y -'"______________________
CDAR RAPIDS.IOWA .757 Unto ~ theckerby -D1 -
~-4~O ~
5A34/ U/ LJA E
=~ 5G43 - 5 44 =Oos w Z- 1.
Rev'CRE 9xoT 460 -3321
4G0-332
~~~ ~ (.9 6 5)r P ~ ~ ()- \4 '
I.ooF =: x 7 ( 1 )(Z.9 r5) +\.z9)3.43§)
LL (2 /.'c- 2.&35 )(3 ')(2-07t I h~
+ /.8324 (6o) p-6
= F4 "' 1")10
-~ ~
Gek5\$mc 49L. LoAC) (:
I--= -u
PF S 6 -;;;
0.co = ADO0)?
*-rr . L..-rimwfit - *
OWA ELECTRzIC LiGHT
,D POWER-COMPANY
S C irn ... -A
DEPT. wre5I. .1
m - E ilC STEst vaL.Yt\s fIe.Ai4 cOd6 . __________ .dd by
-o(=
L -NFOR6 ii
'A* * A + +t'A
\f LA) -A 1 0 . I.
/ \ M~r~v..AtNA \.f Gk Tc 11 7 7~
T~A(~ (~e~ c~u. ~o e~ = 6.3~CAL .\SJ~f~
MTOrcL = ~1"741 1*-
RX~- ~ Nk-~&;) = (~~41 ~)(s"4
10L f-
F TP Er
1- 0 GT 11 cr f 1 r =3
'Ll t r O m l C E ' 4 =
E3- 47
11/urac-po rc v'orce ,
4t 0 F= r (./xzeges)(~x = 34
I
$1-
CNurdo%:R 1 F(- <O
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
c-Dw.JRA-IEs.IowA
* ~Z-450
DvET r, >147N M MN 11\. -L
SU ECT A -m--CP511. Ta -Sv-f f -,
3, 6
R
N
E
7 ~ ~ ;7\Cm -~L FO INFORAU
$ -~
~.Ao'~Th4G 'Io~eC~
O~3~ ~-~- = (tV\fz~)& >'~<
=
= f~5\OTS~ ~
~ _______ - . - 33L~
-
.7 i 'K? I40.4- -d'.
yz-k4,O. LA4\ tr
& = 3se s~-~---
x
Ec
:30 inU t
I -
z I est.
-JWA-El-ET.R IC-LIGH-T
AND POWER COMPANY
CroM TCsI sus.IOWA
I EPT.._'z.5 G r) aIW ~ C-ZG______ U(2s-C' zW
},& (Grac~ cA) =30
\5 ( 1 G .') \4.04
NA ,4 R() -29
RZ- 450 7
Mx= f VCw ') ('i +gldA)
4- (30.21Js5t72 *1 (Zo.3)(r.zzN)
- (0,)xK4 .8x - 4 14
.-'3 .,
(\oA4t 5zsk-4 ) 2 1. E 3 \yk L=
13\3 .>t-\\a SSI s
( 4 (0 4) \ L
4o 14 .j-4 40s.5:
/4-
v
0. \4\9)
-'I -/
1
G>--r 4
PROJECT s ARY.10k.T !E4CRUG'*4 (Et-GR . 3 .//s
S Sv ______________LM___ 14 o 5-rA .C t d s htL_ AT__ S
0... w~~..rrAaA- -* ad
~or~ L~I - ~
ay)
E-1 0'. \ :,,y=
- zsa333
over c-T\fri c-lL.i GI+t.-- DEPT..N- .I
AND POWER COMPANY P nNOL- kzcoi 14 .. /9 C!oAp RAPIos.IoWA
I s F /Vi
F 7sc
A-~. ~:
6~-r ~ K
^ t/r; 4
3O(7A -
-~ -y Z324,\. . 233v3
Iz-
O\ = ,
&~'~7 ~
I
3 6 - a . - 0 -],IZ
6~ kr C %A.% .t LW-e a o= C.eu tswe
1 ' 4c-, 6 -as 4.40-o +o o
O419C)
-* LOPo.rZ
os (.0 )54) + 1 o 'lds
4- or Zsn}3
To9- <- TI I)t
a
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT AvD POWER COMPAINY
CaAua thApiDs.Ioww
pz
r. ", C U* M n o o f 1.
4q 4w B
*D 3 .2
=~ta 57Cc"G.-en. 5F .00 / " . .E7. (0, 1 z"
0~ D.c N, yCit&) = $C84'
144
K:- 3.599 + \. ( 19 (..L/ri. -0. 43 \
, r3 - '. O = + 1\ 6 /
d-G
C~j ~
c- c500
.~
- C~o :2)=066
C= 0.3 \
t~3.4'3
-0.
0.933 <3 0-.008
4q 0O.o S~ K4 -0Z5
.
DFPT.D 5G4 n - k0 a14G
PamE- DORFT~l3Es 4 0. 16WG" .tT~...
answerT SESIC .STRES AS,394 NtSIS tL~fePk~hArATR C- -4 byowe hea. by
IOWA ELECTrIc LIGHT -- POWER- COMPANY
CcD.A. RAPUD....WA --0:T -.--~-Do*
R-450 If .A o-k
on& oLE LF:ATO :600\\(. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - -T 65 (eft LL OlT WZ 0Tihod vidG 0**
Grc 57f&A/7
~=v~ C:2.\Z ~c
K-= 1.c( - 0 G 7.79
C - 0.074- - c. R,0.9' co ('7.291) ) ) 3.4i8 + ).220 (- Q.O(7.('7,291?)
\< 3459 -7.0 6- man , ort 0.2t?)
- ~3.43\z. - 1
= -12 s
.~- (-c. of~o~o)2 -~ -~
/ .-
- - ----- --- -
4
I. - .\T
x Mc, (\4 E, f.r2--se.&Le
6\- S o [r
u)G eAie
'1 = (Z o4 - 4
3.0o 5- gc.os ess
E Pt
.7~ 0
y
Y., 00 P- ->(ZYA\.)LiAS - !;7SS 7F.
%a0 Loosress\t3
FZI
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT
AND POWER COMPANY
CEDA RAPID5. IOWA
GZ4c.LT~c
DEPT. -- .
PaWECT- F . ) ..2.,, -- V-
SLJJECT 4.6 A c. * rD. o__ __ __ Sv.
.. 4 a
% \oAc~ IN~~~
AA
5 It 7
- 2A2~
MX Z L" 4
Ni L 5~4 (, as)2491 L
5 rav CAp) = B # *
MS (MR V C~o ) =02
4K 24
r.2 - 2( C14. 4 L 2 /
- J~ 6~"54') = 0 fsT - rr-.n
4L V4 I(\4.o~ -~ \2/&)('9.(~3)4 (2o.~27Y3T~7')
WL - 0I.4r (.4),3.5)=IL) . .O C
bmxf= /D Io xta -\\0
1
owA ELECTRIC LIGHT
AND POWER COMPANY
.__C. Aj RAthsus.Iow^
~L:*~ ~-K-
T T- c'&.- OR -r ~ ~~~L C4 (e-e =(23
7 9,6
c~ ~
~.QG34 ) c-i--
/05 ) Ps"C
7,
A) - j712J2ii ~7.OZ 2
2 . ( i.) i -
1 1
4- + (20.oA3\)2.2')\- .5)(436
- o 3a
(2.~1)&Ss') * ZOo3 ~s-~: ~
N- (.-t-c,~si>~> -v
= Go. OzsF'Ps'0 2 /AJ
Mon t. F-on -IF TGo E 6-7re-o im re Cct.m
SY~~~~~~- Cno .!0 owR T T R t c-L G-1-0.Se gsE
DPTME Z** MI *4*
SLJE 1 i SBJTS /Y /".45-Sc ho144caC>;?Ze
c..y..i by,**~bdby 0... D.
6Gh\dG;TREcss (>C~l t -T-kE tNAoJV-r.i 9 YO)**
(f- 4010 <41' bb5
&, %. c. , L-
laTOWA-EECTRIC ic IGHT_ DEPT.
AND POWER COMPANY I P
CEDAP TAPIOS.IOWA
I __________-______..._u____ I - 0..____
6r o o t
6 =(z .6 * zoosJt' + Lew.Y *L>- n
-v-s * .\~
0.051 + 3co.cE' ' LOSC$f
\- S s-
85- - 7 S
. 4- 0
2. \3'oo -pore- z Wi-riQu STimeracTts
* ~ Ot~-\ T~-kA~ ~L~)\ K~C, ~
,~d/~Ok../?iSLC $772C.~$5ES
0. Do Dam.. 00 CC)0,k.O.
vsur vf\ \cs -C-. N1\c nv . G I V o(c
4o TO 9NLY 11 LI
d C.& ( o; oo = 600 Ps
OT ~Ew ' P, : r O ~E. (1\.-k 60~l o ATT v-- k<. t;\O +\fo O
,6O0 > o6 &=o
.<4O z AusJ--SLtS
-572 R CCO.Azae .
/z 1. : \k\1 s rSM
C:A LC
D-Bfl
DESIGN/REVIEW COMMENTS SHEET
ALTERNATE CALCULATIONS
No:S het4 -. o
SheetzpAof 2(:-
NO. COMMENT RESOLUTION/APPROVAL
PAC~rac'
~;1; I,
Veriryl rTngineer Date
C. c~
Uesign Engineer Date
Verifying Engineer Date
lecnnical Group Lea er
Supervising Engr. Nuclear Projects Date 7V
Form No. NG-009Z* Rev. 0
C e ~ ~ ~
IoWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. -AI- b 7-fl3-ZAND POWER COMPANY PJ _________ t_._______.___f ____-,_____ __**____ ZOC.
SU EJ ECT QuATA ( t"te- I Ar /{ 460 CEDAp RAPIDS.1oWA lDot. b__/,. ____ Do. 4 b1 IS4
4- B vtC- r ALO.j LIC
7 L sr2 etcerA Ass W-i5 o ,o 70 ~ ~ ~ L A- E 7 0 << ' s F r A A S . - E t v .& Yo
J, .
4cetfd ?C-r E S EctU+ A7 w 7' L Ac7tQ -rod s
, .A S)
1, it . ~f ? e a f su c 6- f'6, t 4 " - rA e <-C CAccC.
7
A~
V
-, --*2 -7~- ~ 7~ V7 Lv~
. * A-r rc AF Aar c Me A f7 (4.4c[ /
VM e & : 7 Zt o
~/' /O 000~
.0 -r- -
10,2 O.
Fat' C4 /1 A' 5/ 5 ' C E
7-I
- Ile
- f~ A'.9:6 - t~/~~~89
LV, o"rpewooer cG5Ae
Amo - 7.
lowA ELECTRIc LIGHT oUT. or -c r Qu- 064--1 AND POWER COMPANY P UA A N.. z C.
CEDAR RAoPDS.IowA EC7 .l
, Ir. z .
/5U AS COAA r 2, , - 7-
1'LE
d-OA-O~
&.O +/O4
J L- .
4) /
' e-s " 3 es t p ; -s
-I
, , ? 1 Z- :
-5 -- 7_ -eus /4-4,-r7a' ~ e..
C, f43 /"7 ).T
Accme6t LOs. /,I'-A LI
</,5 *5-rA7-ff - e .r
ZAT ; 4 - v4 - , r / f a y aiar ec>
A e e d r -. ct s 4 A L A c - Y I.'- As u 7' / / o ,. j r p r
A SC VCc /Meoe ) C F 'V r e s / z r ~ 7 M w
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AflD POWER COMPANY
DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER-..t
CALCULATION COVERSHEET
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION NO:jA p 4--
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION TITLE: <>Z7 .k- N\ \ .
IA % k- - - \t-CO , v P Om\ (
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
MAR NO:
DCR NO:
OTHERS: v76s
PREPARED BY:Xbl V~~ (
REVIEWED BY;
APPROVED
/7
BY: 41 ~ k#~L~A~&
FINAL APPROVAL BY:
DATE:
DATE: -/- /
DATE: J4,LR fl
DATE:
FORM NG-007Z REV. 0
N- rup olp', -%c.
I
Background
The purpose for compiling calculations M84-11, 12, 13, 14, 15 was to perform a seismic analysis on the critical components of the Hills-McCanna Pneumatic Damper Actuators. These actuators are part of the secondary containment isolation system at the Duane Arnold Energy Center
On January 26, 1984, Iowa Electric notified the NRC by telephone that the above mentioned actuators were potentially deficient in meeting their purchase specification. A review of the documents relating to this discrepancy revealed that the isolation damper assemblies were purchased originally as complete assemblies which included the damper actuators. Subsequent orders for "likefor-like" replacement actuators were placed directly with the actuator manufacturer who was a subvendor to the damper manufacturer. This most recent purchase order for actuators revealed that a quality assurance program, as required for safety related equipment per 10CFR Part 50, is not currently in effect at the actuators manufacturer's facility.
Further review of the damper assembly documentation revealed that the seismic analysis performed on the damper assemblies did not seismically analyze the actuators themselves, but only considered their weight as it seismically affected the damper frame. This information prompted Iowa Electric to audit the damper manufacturer and check for documentation that pertained to the seismic qualifications of the isolation damper actuators. Results from the audit of the damper manufacturer revealed that the actuators were never purchased by.the damper manufacturer as seismically qualified components nor did the damper manufacturer administer a Quality Assurance program concerning the purchase of the actuators.
Since no traceability or Certificate of Conformance was available for the seismic qualifications of the actuators, a seismic analysis was performed on the critical components of the actuators in order to seismically qualify the damper actuators for use in the Duane Arnold Energy Center. This seismic analysis followed the guidelines set forth in-the original purchase specification for the isolation dampers (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100). By seismically qualifying the isolation damper actuators, Iowa Electric will be able to buy Quality Level I actuators in accordance with Revision 1, Chapter 4 of the Quality Assurance Manual under Standard Industrial Quality Items 4.7.3.
Solution
A seismic analysis was performed on five models of the Rockwell HillsMcCanna Ramcon Pneumatic Actuator product line that are installed as .isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. These five models include the following:
* R-260 FS * R-450 FS * R-960 FS a R-2000 FS * R-4200 FS
The seismic analysis on the actuators followed the general project seismic requirements for frequency-not-determined class 1.equipment in the reactor building and in the control building (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100, Technical Specifications for Isolation Dampers for the Duane Arnold Energy Center Unit 1, Revision 0, 12-28-70).
A.visual inspection of all isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center was made in order to verify model number, serial number and elevation location in the plant. After verifying the elevation location in .the plant, static coefficients (g units) were determined for the highest installed actuator for each of the five actuator models. The horizontal static coefficient was then applied to all three of the orientation axis which eliminated many repetitious calculations and the need for detailed actuator orientation information. Applying the horizontal static coefficient to each axis provided conservative results since the horizontal coefficient is always greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (Fvertical = (Weight) (1 + gv)l, Fhorizontal = (Weight) (gh), gh > 1 + gv).
The seismic analysis concentrated on the critical areas of the damper actuator where the seismically induced loads could possibly make the actuator. fail, malfunction, or prevent operation. Five areas on-each actuator model were identified as critical areas requiring a seismic analysis of the various components interfacing with that critical area. These five critical areas .are identified as the following:
- o Retaining key which holds the spring cylinder assembly to the main body cylinder
o Main body cylinder o Press fit between main body cylinder and the mounting yoke o Mounting hardware o Mounting yoke
Dimensions and material specifications for the seismic analysis were obtained through the use of proprietary component drawings that were on loan to Iowa Electric from Rockwell Hills-McCanna of Carpentersville, Illinois. All prints applicable to-this seismic analysis are listed in the reference section of the referenced calculations.
Four basic assumptions are applied throughout the entire seismic analysis of the damper actuators. These assumptions allow Iowa Electric to use the floor response spectra as the design/qualification spectra for .the seismic analysis. The four basic assumptions are as follows:
o The mounting of the damper is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The damper itself is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The support bracket for the actuator is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The seismic requirements for evaluating the actuators are the same as
those for the isolation dampers.
The maximum seismic stresses were calcu!ated by using the square root sum of the squares method for combining the three earthquake direction stresses as recommended in the UFSAR for seismic analysis at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. A second method, the distortion energy method was used for combining stresses at the press fit between the main body cylinder and the mounting yoke. The distortion energy method was used in place of the square root sum of the squares method because the .stresses due to the press-fit condition exceeded and dominated those caused by the seismic event. All maximum stresses were then compared to some fraction of.the yield strength depending on the material type and stress type. Operability after a DBE event was ensured by requiring that the maximum stress from combined seismic and normal loads should not exceed 90% of the yield.stress of the material.
Conclusion
After completing the above described seismic analysis on the five models of Hills-McCanna. actuators installed on the isolation dampers at the Duane Arnold Energy Center, it was found that the maximum stresses from the combined seismic and normalloads do not exceed the material yield requirements defined in the isolation damper purchase specification. The results of this seismic analysis reveal that the five models of Hills-McCanna actuators .are seismically qualified for use at.the Duane Arnold .Energy..Center.
References
Bechtel Purchase Specification 7884-M-100
Formulas for Stress and Strain; Raymond J. Roark, Warren C. Young, Fifth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1975
Hills-McCanna Information Bulletins; R-1090, R-1090A, R110C, R1100A, R111C, R-1110A, R-1120, R-1120A, R-113D, R-1130A
Marks' Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers' Baumeister Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company 1973
Materials Selector 75; Reinhold Publishing Co. Mid September 1974, Vol. 80, No. 4, Brown Printing Co.
Mechanical Engineering Design; Joseph E. Shigley, Third Edition, McGrawHill Book Co. 1977
Mechanics of Materials; Higdon, Ohlsen, Stiles, Weese, Riley Thir.d Edition, John Wiley and Sons 1978
Rockwell Hills-McCanna; Proprietary Drawings
DATA: Information contained on drawings is proprietary and confidential and is not to be given or loaned to others. Drawings are to be returned to Rockwell upon completion of their intended use in making the seismic analysis..R450-R960
450-7511450-1005 450-7512 450-3005 450-3007 450-4101 450-4102 450-2101 450-2906 450-2507 450-2501 450-3201 450-3202 450-3203 450-3326
.450-3325
.450-3321 450-3320
R2000-R4200
460-7511460-1001 460-7509 460-3001 460-3003 460-4101 460-4102 460-2101 460-2904. 460-2503 460-2502 460-3203 460-3209 460-3210 ..460-3317 460-3316 460-3320 460-3321 460-3314 460-3315 -
U.S.S. Steel Desion Manual; 1981
- . Stt.tTh
R.L. Brockenbrough and B.G. Johnson, Jan.
-. - ~
R260 .
430-1004 430-7510 .430-7511 430-3003 430-3005 430-4101 430-4102 .430-2101 430-2904 430-2502430-2501 .430-3321 430-3322 430-3325 430-3201 .430-3202 430-8203
C.; IRi, -jrj rl--;
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
POSITION
EDUCATION
PROFESSIONAL. DATA
SUMMARY
EXPERIENCE
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Michigan
MS, Civil/Structural Engineering, University of Michigan ..
Registered Professional Engineer in Michigan
1 year: Senior Engineer; Civil/ Structural Staff
4 years: Senior Engineer; Midland, Palisades, and Big Rock Point Nuclear Power Plants
1 year: Resident Engineer, Midland Nuclear Power Plant
Mr. Reifschneider is currently assigned as a civil/structural engineer on the civil/ structural staff. His duties include; preparation of design standards; review of project calculations, drawings, specifications and.seismic qualification of equipment; providing consultation to civil/structural engineers engaged in the design of nuclear and fossil power plants; solving special static and dynamic structural problems.
Prior to joining the civil/structural staff, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/ structural engineer on Consumers Power Company's Palisades project. His duties included finite element analysis of the biological shield wall, seismic analysis and design of blockwall supports, and seismic analysis and design of the auxiliary building addition including the review of seismic equipment qualifications.
Prior to joining the Palisades project, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural resident engineer at the jobsite of Consumers Power company's Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included interfacing with construction personnel on the design, erection, and construction of seismic instrument and equipment.supports.
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
Prior to his jobsite assignment, Mr. Reifschneider conducted research on the inelastic design and behavior of braced structural steel systems,.moment frame structural steel system, and reinforced concrete shear wall systems. He W co-authored three Bechtel reports on the findings of this research.
Prior to his research assignment, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural engineer on the Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included designing seismic supports for HVAC ducts and electrical cabletrays.
- ..- 4d~
7-- '
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DAN POWER COMPANY
1 CDAq RAPIDS. IOWA
DEPT. V - 4 /lG//UC?/
PR EECT 94 0/Z~.C- 2~' -S Ne-- orSUBJECT
7TJ/)i S cwo. d by_ Dt. ,'-. a y
RAN~CC rFx C"OJ Oz Le ec .. t. T 0
.~ ~ cqwe s ysT s oie
REA' irdit--1 BO O 14 .65O \f$ .
07,aC-, C//6
F /
Ass-r- uses OLT
A"J -z -elocoo\~ &
:Y.7 6o o -\ F o o r
oWA&ELECTRIc LirHT
T'ANr -POWER COMPANY
I Croa tAPIDS.IOWA
Nata 0"'@0509 COi /Lu C--AD Q Uf.C. 7ATC
- L 00 otrf . - E-NAssP
oo
6oi
cSY BS . 2 c SZ 4 stOO.
:S'C 25So 6 oo0
~s
tasird C.. 0%tori
Fowc-E C\-E -G0 o tcE -~e Q'.auce Foo Nc M-4G\c5 .14 Fo4<C-' V
I -
PROJECT_2 - -** t 7
SUBJECT / / D- . _ _ _ _ .,
O~imbe Z9ee.T 0vrv09 -9 Co 9
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT
AND POWER COMPANY
CZDAA RAPoS.IOWA
P~eC1a- T3tA ACaoto Easte Omaram-... e... - - -. , -/ SU&JECT -AVISMtrCi .RaSs /?LW9Vts /1..s-//ChowA19 Acr7ArORs C..d*** hv D.** _6v... D.
- IA.04 RZ-450 es ; 9
h - cs .0 9 Z
1 or =-k7 e._8_ -_2_795 023)
4
RASO Vs f I
?\,Toatj
-T W.2'7 1- 45o 'rS 3
SCv~.F~z
'-- e acz : R4f-r s - 4
v l 4
\AGsC-wb- A7 7T) TP-7ee-w\, f70tI,
CVL10ERSPROG .3C GP_
Eac 3Z e (_SeVVComc.m m.
\b)a\kAwT = a.o03s
ITorot PSPPLO G
o . L o
\A4
o
- ~AI~N'~ ~ ~ L.cr~o ro~- ~ C~e~ (~-~-on. ~<AC~Z T0 &~-L~ ?~\6 O~ e$W\\C x'-kS~k~*
* t~~X1\\~M\A ~-~- ~ = .p~ -~-~&~ ~\ ~-~A ~ ~
AA~lf) Ke_ %% I(s \ (
M4 (
l o (Il| V N1 satuS ed
flr-- 7 =
ensec c- L) .04
sol0.31 - .St
E. *
-4O Jo-5 co S 0 \7 ' w- as \ \
p_3 ( \& z.%(-- q~~X , i (950 4\G'O(. - o o 1 \276 ' 21. \ 4,-,'; *-w S A t
9y=7 4iZ. . & 4 + lo4(S + Z3.3 10 2161.3 C)Mw4 2 7
PcI rd \<
0. c-N.1S soQ
5(c .10 9o(
6 L-TE -C .. 0 5
S%= swena fre)Gr-f =S (oo0
4 L~o GLE A-L AR Gp~c *- \D 00 s
-, ,
IOWA ELECTRIc LIGHT T.
OANDOPOWtRwCOMPA E m - (. ---. -
C.venCUMAN
SUm-rCrStZAPMIt. ISDes'S At-mHSIS - i -t.-le.GahX fT Czzwja RAnans.IowA
c..... w F Dte Owed D**
i
iowA ELECTRIC LIGHT
1--x POWER-COMPANZY DCAnAZn RAPIDS.IOWA
DEPT. t . lt..
c. . - -ECT
C'v .d by f. 0.". o-+"____ by-0.
T/r> Twk Ts\VuG )-E'4 F7om tSJd6~H
IA
A-- -4( 2 O. a n -v
My 1\4 . . \ *\\
TO TRE . tLN G N i G FoR 0x17
.cok . - s 47 'r 4 A) c -
-Gce
4
-~ 'C ~
0
Y~zt
£7__ W 4- (0.73s
4
14
&e~c~ ~Ze.L4~
Y~. "6
_
-,OC -To K
6 we\C-~t. es-mass - 'Y (e)
4 O'= 2(.&s
A = 1146
4 40
& = 4. L..52 - .
j. _ 6____ ___ z() +__.
(4(0.18t37Z.& 3 Y(0.735')
Y ~ \\4.33
m Tc k^(&b Toc. 72 e?7
z l7S00 9~*t
-. ~
N/-
T1. X 5wAs CzA:V0e_ cc
.
* -C,-T.Ri C-IG T DEPT.. \-L IN ('r AND-POWER COMPANYPO
CEDAAI I D os. IOWA SUBJECT -S C
_r-
.u,..
* A FER~cE \GOc tJ "OFwrvt 11- or rLae Se
-c /r f'
*L~~:t) ~(--) b+ i 0)
I L3 ~ ~ ~1 ~1bo~?.s~os)J _
I- -,
-C-
>05 2.6 3 ><oto 9 = \\1 -Ct - tE 29 sd-
+4 \.04A4ZI 0
Is- T " .t
O'z~'~a ~
2. '~.
It.
TO0 TM"G PGzress '1kT co:Dotwiord0s 'lo\C E. Kt-AC TECkz cuCNakhor eo
GTOEGESDoe
60 Y 'L% tdaafictPE 0
Z
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT Avo POWER COMPANY
C. AJZ MAPID.IOWA
DEPT. -TQS1CIA E (3 G \t-- = ( 000.. M \'3
,,wnm -0085- ARMlet. EZANRC2 IFwecn...---.-1
SuluECT gifuglc 14 2rr.8\ IO.pmssAU4% 7140
UIO OMA
'2.
= 2.9 Z( o \4Z> _ (3.43w))
(3.4&52- ?2.4! K (z.9zos)L
('J - 2.90-5/(02/ s.43St 9.3 .2s2. 2. 4
2.
- (z~)Qt~4z') (i
- ~ (Wr
-.
2.923Z -//4-3 P-cM
(2.c 2 . z. 37'5 (K
11-
?.63r5Z
2.35
2.4;375)
- 0 Ps~
,2~& ?5Z
(z cjz-51 --?. ( ?,2
ATRG'G6 \kt GCoV,0 Tr
r700Ps
1 w-ELE TRIC- 1GllT DEPT. - AL C' N\ Y'-V
AND POWER COMPANY JECT \. 4.5M G 1b,,i .. .
SUmJECT 5\6tC AMAL.YSIS "lt-t h-(flAaA AqcATRS CzzDA RAPwss.IOWA
T ORMA.10N 0 . . 6Yets________________Do TO .Ao h., T _______________ ____C__
c o
Eo CFF av
I- El i -- 4.25
r- --23594-
WK (~t~ (1~) = ~C3
~V~4G &L ??
~ ~D~.A>:
- MAst ot CytIpJ)ON~ Ls hAoom...Co T-o Pcx o- RI-t- sDoc
Ot1\ w\-Xx.10 7-e of y't< z,
0 -- Q., ) K
f4- ( Ac 4
..L " 2e. o
e-~ ~ -r
-' 434.2 - my
. - I -
ce~~~~~~~ A s-oT4PRA 1-Lc s A
- R ( ..10 6. C> 4 A ..
4=4
fk- ,as CZ -t0ct
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY-
CZD RAP ss. IOWA
DEPT. I M%\frt : \r.1Q, 1 ? 5 (1l .M 4
suBJ ECT S
*Bdr D * - - - ... d.4 by - -.-.
=. 7.G
I=, 81, 38
sy 4JOc0z est 100 4eci
90Z70 sy : (on) 4r000 es
j t
4, ~. :~.
.~4 e
1 -19. ee6
11( z. .3)+ 434.2
19=
1259,4 7.fs
<c O
C S a &~.' \2. ~('z.r O t2..5
(;;j~j L/3s&4+ \\hf8)2 (-i~o \\15 t\4 3) * (-\41 - /352.4i)
\\4610,3093 L 4?SZoo es (\- \OZeLoz a 90
9
. e
I
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT
AND POWER COMPANY IUEtJCT C
______ CID.BcP3S.I.A sr D.** ~ __...___ - -- ~m
-eo n Ie noA on7P n 7 G e - i s m i c .~U U , ~ ta - \aa a i t. i n ) , o n Pe
orIF . cowvV
I Qj~/wac-45 s3 I
_-cor S -e43 - 5:644 - .Go 'w
1450 335
0.-o. Te 9 ss (?) - \&4 tew s or t.
(.3.4359 -2.9715 S-s
+(c.11( L 2.Czz) + (i.. ) (292 '-2.36)(IF )
c l.3S7 C) ? + /.E32400) C
ZZ~) ~
0.00l
)Maia 1 ers50'Z veoa ?.as -7-- \10 \TVy
I
RLa rsetvi
= F4.$1I')\0-G
lowA ELECTRIC LGHT
AND POWER COMPANY
I CDn.U RA IDS. OWA
DEPT. Q~f>Gt !l ~V4~
1JJCTS I1.. -/
.y __ _ __ _ C6 h,
.r. .
.~~~~, /q / /e 1 rt o R (iAG or ,O'*
M Em (w = x)( -cs
L43Q(see c's) = 11.8
Mi'& (J#U L GL Z'1.912
TAIT (A L C\ \
18-4243.(-, ci- 0 4-\
/340) > IL
I
-*- c )-ack'o. -4-
6-47
KWP T
-\-ELEG-\TRI G-LIGHT
-EP
AXD POWER COMPANY PROJECT .. ,OunE
cAnX Resos.IowA SUBJECT 45F c
c...~....d.,,. -o - - . . D.., _______
R-9o .,0 ( . ; 7s4O
L~R~W~G
-3.5
IV
'Li1
AC7to JP T
4 w
~ ___________
4
.cot 1 = TSareso Foa~z.
IA) %sT s C \
rr742.
OA4V~
az.24. 6, es
I - -
0 E
'"' = . Si \ .1 . Evy
Ep
I oQwA-E~-E-TRIC-LIGITDEP.. 056160 IGSwly . p" -4-1CE T.
AND POVER COMPANY PR E ______Rr_
CEDAR RAPIDS.IOWA ._ _
R- A O -6
LA VGk~olRa
0
( 0ao '--\7 : P43.Z
3\5.1L6 4.
* r U
I.'7~ 5 -
& - _ _s_)_s- - Z 2 6 FS
if
SC-61wt L.o G t.. ~Acov.TTr
O.\14L9 t4'
- - - c C
AND POWER CO
CEDA R.APs.I
-1 r EPT.
MPAlSrRJECT M A IS awr-r tIsktkrit OTASs AtAL-Vsts it.1-MetANQA 19 eJrA
R-e~o ~
~e~NAc~ Lc~~\~G ~
Y
(4 Bc~-~-~*z--3\5. 1
2.
~s'~S ~~e= 4~Ps%~\'~Ov,~ -A
~ C9~z. LS Zo. Os
(Z 5a5St -~zaz +
Z-
L Z
V2 L 4-6 22 zse.2
(9-z o cooes-\4(G.G3 -4 '77 34.4-= 0.' \
; 0 coo 20oco .
OWA --- - .d b,
r- Ak OtC-1- %-zP) c, c
z '*aZ 4. e3 pst
Sn L- ,t,- .1 -
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. . 9 r 1 2 \G Q u
AND POWER COMPANY-S U B J E C T t hCse .I o w
.
I-. J _
0, LO\~G~ £Z~Z
7, -O INO4TO 5 L~St C.. 9ta__s__ 1T~. TLAG , L/:OOLO
6 - 4 5 6 ( c c C v e o w
LL.0 U Z 57 5\
-4 So -6 et \7 A TAL Lose P,0 = 3 - 3
-. I
1\
SCICS e-A
.2 ~ C
3.2'~o rV~25y
i; ( 4 5 . 44zo o-O
-s . 2 4 (. \2 4=~;c: 8. 3 2' /& tA a zI
MC9.
s= 2.51)(a5.4)= Zov5 eT
2
.. = 3.150 - 2
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. mzs7 -t l-
AND POWER COMPANY -_
C :DSUBJECTm.
. *
CEDAR RAPIDS.1OWA k. JI
- ~Dww- -O.d..d Ir,, (. - - _____
r~l PIP p -AGO . sm
LOotdG
\#2= (154). (.v') 4 \NX 4 c
k4
8.3yr
/
I ~Lo~'-? (. 3n 3 4) \
'V =
3.2 50 - t 2is
~-~-J ~*\*~
Oco Se-To --- .A.25 -15) - fT"(,.125) 7.-OZ~ a
\-a. c A2.
-- \ 6 0 .s
2zl-.1 Ps
I
z
7
OWA ELECTRIC 1GHT PROJECT AND POWER COMPANY _ _ __ _ _
-- -CrDAA .RApts~owA .- ______ ____ ___ _____
PACUEG
Tr - on
- -\ O) - \4c (
2.54-.&~i 0,-('000 2 0
* A - .w\i oN- 1* TR '-0 T R O NO R ui
Sheet f )DESIGN/REVIEW COMMENTS SHEET
(0 E ~TVERIFICATI~ ALTERNATE CALCULATIONS
1 -- IRESOLUTION,
Uesign Engineer Dt
Verifying neer Date
lecnnical Group Leader / Date
Supervising Engr. Nuclear Projt's ateI /
Form No. NG-009Z* Rev. 0
#4.
.,
NU.
~1COMMENT
'p
1-veriryi Engineer Dat e
IOWA ELECTRIC.LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER
CALCULATION COVERSHEET
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION NO: cA 4 -
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION TITLE:
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
MAR NO:
DCR NO:
OTHERS: o qqg
C-lNC AAB8I-1a
PREPARED
REVIEWED
APPROVED.
DATE:
DATE: 4-___
DATE: 4L '
D ATE: 6w 7'FINAL APPROVAL B
FORM NG-007Z REV. 0
BY:
qAi= %-- n % (
In
Background
The purpose for compiling calculations M84-11, 12, 13, 14, 15 was to perform a seismic analysis on the critical components of the Hills-McCanna Pneumatic Damper Actuators. These actuators are part of the secondary containment.iso.lat-ion system at the Duane Arnold Energy Center
On January 26, 1984, Iowa Electric notified the NRC by telephone that the above mentioned actuators were potentially deficient in meeting their purchase specification. A review of the documents relating to this discrepancy revealed that the isolation damper assemblies were purchased originally as complete assemblies which included the damper actuators. Subsequent orders for "likefor-like" replacement actuators were placed directly with the actuator manufacturer who was a subvendor to the damper manufacturer. This most recent purchase order for actuators revealed that a quality assurance program, as required for safety related equipment per 1OCFR Part 50, is not currently in effect at the actuators manufacturer's facility.
Further review of the damper assembly documentation revealed that the seismic analysis performed on the damper assemblies did not seismically analyze. the actuators themselves, but only considered their weight as it seismically affected the damper frame. This information prompted Iowa Electric to audit the damper manufacturer and check for documentation that pertained to the seismic qualifications of the isolation damper actuators. Results from the audit of the damper manufacturer revealed that the actuators were never/ purchased by the damper manufacturer as seismically qualified components nor did the damper manufacturer administer a Quality Assurance program concerning the purchase of the actuators.
Since no traceability or Certificate of Conformance was available for the seismic qualifications of the actuators, a seismic analysis was performed on the critical components of the actuators in order to seismically qualify the damper actuators for use in the Duane Arnold Energy Center. This seismic analysis followed the guidelines set forth in the original purchase specification for the isolation dampers (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100). By seismically qualifying the isolation damper actuators, Iowa Electric will be able to buy Quality Level I actuators in accordance with Revision 1, Chapter 4 of the Quality Assurance Manual under Standard Industrial Quality Items 4.7.3.
Solution
A seismic analysis was performed on five models of the Rockwell HillsMcCanna Ramcon Pneumatic Actuator product line that are installed as isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. These five models include the following:
o R-260 FS e R-450 FS * R-960 FS * R-2000 FS * R-4200 FS
The seismic analysis on the actuators followed the general project seisic"d ' requirements for frequency-not-determined class 1 equipment in the reactor building and in the control building (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100, Technical Specifications for Isolation Dampers for the Duane Arnold Energy Center Unit 1, Revision 0, 12-28-70).
A visual-inspection of all isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center was made in order to verify model number, serial number and elevation location in the plant. After verifying the elevation location in the plant, static coefficients,(g units) were determined for the highest installed actuator for each of the five actuator models. The horizontal static coefficient was then applied to all three of the orientation axis which eliminated many repetitious calculations and the need for detailed actuator orientation information. Applying the horizontal static coefficient to each axis provided conservative results since the horizontal coefficient is always greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (Fvertical = (Weight) (1 + gv), Fhorizontal = (Weight) (gh), gh > 1 + gv)*
The seismic analysis concentrated on the critical areas of the damper actuator where the seismically induced loads could possibly make the actuator fail, malfunction, or prevent operation. Five areas on each actuator model were identified as critical areas requirinq a seismic analysis of the various components interfacing with that critical area. These five critical areas are identified as the following:
o Retaining key which holds the spring cylinder assembly to the main body cylinder
o Main body cylinder o Press fit between main body cylinder and the mounting yoke o Mounting hardware* o Mounting yoke
Dimensions and material specifications for the seismic analysis were obtained through the use of proprietary component drawings that were on loan to Iowa.Electric from Rockwell Hills-McCanna of Carpentersville, Illinois. All prints applicable to this seismic analysis are listed in the reference section of the referenced calculations.
Four basic assumptions are applied throuqhout the entire seismic analysis of the damper actuators. These assumptions allow Iowa Electric to use the floor response spectra as the desiqn/qualification spectra for the seismic analysis. The four basic assumptions are as follows:
o The mounting of the damper is a riqid structure (f > 33 cps) o The damper itself is a rigid structure (f> 33 cps) o The support bracket for the actuator is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The seismic requirements for evaluatinq the actuators are the same as
those for the isolation dampers.
-0jjjMj1jdb;Cjj bla" -jimpt
The maximum seismic stresses were calculated by using the square root sum of the. squares method for combining the three earthquake direction stresses as recommended in the UFSAR for seismic analysis at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. A second method, the distortion energy method was used for combining stresses at the press.fit between the main body cylinder and the mounting yoke. The distortion energy method was used in place of the square root sum of the squafes method .because the stresses due to the press-fit condition exceeded and dominated those caused by the seismic event. All maximum stresses were then compared to some fraction of the yield strength depending on the material type and stress type. Operability after a DBE event was ensured by requiring that the maximum stress from combined-seismic and normal loads should not exceed 90% of the yield stress of the material.
Conclusion
After completing the above described seismic analysis on the five models of Hills-McCanna actuators installed on the isolation dampers at the Duane Arnold Energy Center, it was found that the maximum stresses from the combined seismic and normal loads do not exceed the material yield requirements defined in the isolation damper purchase specification. The results of this seismic analysis.reveal that.t.he.five models of Hills-McCanna actuators are seismically qualified for.,use at the Duane Arnold Energy Center.
References
B8echtel Purchase Specification 7884-M-100,
Formulas for Stress and Strain; Raymond J. Roark, Warren C. Young, Fifth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1975
Hills-McCanna Information Bulletins; R-1090, R-1090A, R110C, R1100A, R111C, R-1110A, R-1120, R-1120A, R-113D, R-1130A
Marks' Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers' Baumeister Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company 1978
Materials Selector 75; Reinhold Publishinq Co. Mid September 1974, Vol. 80, No. 4, Brown Printing Co.
Mechanical EngineerinqDesion; Joseph E. Shigley, Third Edition, McGrawHill Book Co. 1977
Mechanics of Materials; Higdon, Ohlsen, Stiles, Weese, Riley Third Edition, John Wiley and Sons 1978
Rockwell Hills-McCanna; Proprietary Drawings e
DATA:-Information contained on drawings is proprietary and confidential and is not to be given or loaned to others. Drawings are to be returned to Rockwell upon completion of their intended use inzmaking the seismic analysis. . R260 R450-R960 R2000-R4200 ' 430-1004 450-7511 460-7511 430-7510 450-1005 460-1001 .430-7511 450-7512 460-7509 430-3003 450-3005 460-3001 430-3005 450-3007 460-3003 430-4101 450-4101 460-4101 430-4102 450-4102 460-4102 430-2101 450-2101 460-2101 430-2904 450-2906 460-2904. 430-2502 450-2507 460-2503 430-2501 450-2501 460-2502 .430-3321 450-3201 460-3208 430-3322 450-3202 460-3209 430-3325 450-3203 460-3210 430-3201 450-3326 .460-3317 .430-3202 450-3325 460-3316 430-8203 450-3321 460-3320
450-3320 460-3321 460-3314 460-3315
U.S.S. Steel Desiqn Manual; R.L. Brockenbrough and B.G. Johnson, Jan. 1981
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
POSITION
EDUCATION
PROFESSIONAL bATA
SUMMARY
EXPERIENCE
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer 4
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Michigan
MS, Civil/Structural Engineering, .University of Michigan
Registered Professional Engineer in Michigan
1 year: Senior Engineer; Civil/ Structural Staff
4 years: Senior Engineer; Midland, Palisades, and Big Rock Point Nuclear Power Plants
1 year: Resident Engineer, Midland Nuclear Power Plant
Mr. Reifschneider is currently assigned as a civil/structural engineer on the civil/ structural staff. His duties include; preparation of design standards; review of project calculations, drawings, specifications and seismic qualification of equipment; providing consultation to civil/structural engineers engaged in the design of nuclear and fossil power Plants; solving special static and dynamic structural problems.
Prior to joining the civil/structural staff, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/ structural engineer on Consumers Power Company's Palisades project. His duties included finite element analysis of the biological shield wall, seismic analysis and design of blockwall supports, and seismic analysis and design of the auxiliary building addition including the review of seismic equipment qualifications.
Prior to joining the Palisades project, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural resident engineer at the jobsite of Consumers Power company's Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included interfacing with construction personnel on the design, erection, and construction of seismic instrument and equipment supports.
Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
Prior to his jobsite assignmen Mr. Reifschneider conducted research on the inelastic design and behavior of braced structural steel systems, moment frame structural steel system, and reinforcedr concrete shear wall systems. He co-authored three Bechtel reports on the findings of this research.
Prior to his research assignment, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural engineer on the Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included designing seismic supports for HVAC ducts and electrical cabletrays..
416 W.0
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT -;r eqD POWER COMPANY Z - tj C
SUBJECT / 4 ( ,/4.{( CEDAR RA""DS IOWA i /i .Daftead 67 Do.e Lw
of or 9-Z1000 PG -R
o r RMA7
\.... F.....E~ Lo. r e e(A .c.oi
(11,\v Got rjT thATE LAL-- NLFcE1 L e. 6Co-rkv c1v
__ __ _ _ O O IL APPLACP L
VS = v (Ss(s, o
c o a s t&s C - 0 , = s o/ 34900
SO9.Y CE.
Moers7 1onGams =Rsss
./3/~ < .
~- ~ z~% \)~G ~ OW ocno tZ~
I-
lowA ELECTRIc LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY "_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ DEPT. e591vJ . ,q( 1C. y
PROJECT Z RAAPIDS.ILS Io f
CEAzwn IIos.IowA
***D. C o**ow.d Dby
I ~.
ENPo k' U-0E~w W Nrzve u. R-vNE s
9ts.ac met.=- \u.ot sh dsvs
Tr Ec~OM Csxta Ci.4s 6 Cas Z0D=33 s conr s oss -. 00 t-4-"IR d/B9
.'1.5<) = (c&'( y)sy P, (.o.6 (.4
'A - o - p.14y) 33( 100 cn < k<oco
th\Z Coa
Yowso --,
501077 5 wOFR6375Qohita --Zoo F
0 WFO~aggL
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT AD POWER COMPANY
CED. RApos.IoWA
.r-Zaco Fs
DEPT. 'O jA t ExAGt-G cs*L, y\43.~~ DPeCT Z3\ /
.s b, SE1IMI S.____ A0ALYSIS5 /T
C.... 6, 62Dof* b* *NrD
-G 17
2-4l
LSFRc O u 001. --o-- .-4 -Nz\ e) + ID
67 G' D.O. = 7.40 ex-L ov..
-- 0 Ct.A4-0- 5z+
Z L e
o
O- ' c ".1. )2.44
'-h- \OU~L.
4 4 Durit = ( . El ,ax}Zif.9l .4to .. )L
U-)
\\42 / ) - 4 ,44
TOTrit .. es = Got-to Mc G6 HT ____0. . 2 ,Z \ ('otL-
Z2 I TW 4 Z.e,/ -z 7. 'TD o LLZ-3s .
/Lc-stw % cw..= \4.'s 4etc~wl(to~z\')04.a ')(~sk)2c.q),eA
53 /
c 91' n", i bp h -Ul T
RM jj'
DEPT. Dv rrt 0\ ridBc- ri 4--4 IOWA ELECTRIC LGHT
AND POWER COMPANY--P . C, SUBJECT -e1 il TL.* ACT ATOR
cZD.*a RAS.. I.Waw _.1.
~frft pp
O LiG
TbC7 r v~t=A.4-~ ~6' (,.
kbG G -CLT DE Y&R rC, - y.
.9~a" 5 .OQ 10"4
DEPT. S\! l..( j\
AND POWER COMPANY PROJECT 4 OL. S C EN _ __, .3
CwA RAPIs.IoWAE
L3 coo1-4 w ... ac.4 b..y
2 k. Z(", 0.261 G I
cj. I Wotorwe= (1 o
ot.tw i 92 \ -f.Go24
9 tLve Z -5
~t:~C.E2 +6O-33~~
~'o* e:*i~
4-
JO~%N~E =(~4.co)CLOo- o.~A')
4-
-4 11
4&o -U~2c~ -
L.
\.Q G k (7 \-7 T DZ!v Rui \ m *,1
otkt- G 15\4,06O \Psld
0o\..4" c = Z6 .26 F tt"o
IowA ELECTRIC LIGHT
-AD POWEWCOMPAN-YCED-a RApiDs.IOWA%
.4'-
DEPT. (..-m x 1-r1 e,:; -PuJct T.il
-P Cjc&-f C~rruz 2 -SUBAJECTow
a~
-I .
*47L-75 ~
. 2- - 6) =
A o 4. s a)~~* - s)2sa a i
0.93/
527) (A ~,3)
(. 7..oa.5
, ;. 0 2) 1. 4d.
92
A
/. 52 7
I -~
L,/ 4; 2 ?75 er ,&9- =
IowA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMP PRJECT.
CrwaR RAposs. Iow^ -MEMDcte D.40%0 00 /My __
IVY-o..I - ~4~"?* i~O-.J
6'52.5 ~
H- 2.5
il~.
-I
.3
V5-
(2.)
t/ VZ 4. /2 =46 "
z- -)
ERtoF
2.5
- w4- .E-Lr-TIC-LIGHT- DEPT. OAL..O... ( Nh4-44 A.ND POWER COMpAN- A nor D~ w EW 9 O1cY YLG'-' T .
_C DAm RAMOS.IowA .JU"E- SE15 -Am65 AfL~~ Ra - .~ r
--- C. t--IZpi2.c o
IV -f 3- ' ft a o
1/-tSt -\ T) Lca - E 0.r a oy vAeb
* -A -0, 7cC L. o vacasT C, LE kL AuFrk..
$.25 LCAL \S. GFa TJ-. -TAt (.L+ ]) Lome Eo T"n-LCW
Chatt.-COLO G -. . T r GCC f" CaCc-' fz
*~~ ~~ 14( QAN G-,e P-stsQ = \O Psk CTLGor so
. $66 Ci~teTIca
46ro
A4so-3co ci
G k \v1
5 . 901 G Ot,') -3, 6O
NkAo) = o.O
L..x>0 -a c /7Y.4 #
V3.~Z~
s-': Lo~'A'~ C ~-~o ~S~G~)
Ze). O~ La t~T 1A4- /
k\A 5D1
z
Th ea-ssme" oQel' 7 > (857>5)
Viss~wr= 9.1/--81 A-28 .O
a 5 .2 z t- S-t\.(. + 9 8.
(-,
- ocsat (Ca RM
7
TREGG : E,!2 CO Thb G \CG-k F .L L-I.oAO
, p0zxoG~ q-Avre
s qaudG G ATS
\163~~ + (oc 4.5 -) 19 G G6 2 (0,05~-! )6 -ae r ;-
IF t- 4
-Q - NX = Y-, - )~' rl k~ C.). : ' -\ ' J - ytP
S -i 4( t U c -S, T10,m1 wr- (ac. . 460 -2904
(2 (c.i s >
Oy Aj~ ~ c.61v0
(2 C. 3~) (~2 / ~',)
)
4
'(Ii,
Wi
F,
k Llo, \1 (th' + t (4.99)
6.% -*-Tj-(= ^\ e -4. . n y ?
4
TwersVf (G) vs 7w1-* E
QT Cr i -WR Jj-1-6.07
)'
0.)
Bo bet
+y s 'D C> -YO
0
Vt L 7.L-6\tfa Tw"G Do--~ To 6xC&4A.L C,
(/5 . 4 ?
(o. c.a 9)(4..111 ( 0. 955-)
w' .i
1~
0
- 2.~.-*
C - . 55
I II P~ ~ P..A64 -IAlOWA ELECTRIC L.GHT
-- 7,ND POWERCOMPANY-r__
---- Cr)An RAPIDS.IOWA L ~ - Deve~i~ - b f D
lptcY46- .~ud 0 \L. L~d0 1- 6- ~~
-6 E s$i ordt TiL E ~ rw G g y euL N G 9 c l T
ETL 1RC1tWF1RG TAL. tC-T ed75
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT. DEPT. 7 . (4 \
%ND POWER COMPANY P l -)g 1 y
-CZD A RAPsDS.IowA WUJECT
-. ZaD3G** t.. Gtr.5 Fn
~~.,~ M___ __ _____ '(.:)> 1-9. /-z4Y 4.99 )5,.-4) = 5. 57 /
5 VisZ c 7 -ut- ,T 03e. 3co 50O0 Swec t2r=AeTMc = (o.'5 Y35~oo) = 195b0op=?y ?~i~zFOR IN.ORMAT ON ON Y
STESESQQ TO Twe PRESS .*"LY ~tct\IOU 13C -E6
* \c w i o
12Sw " <1
~J. ~~zz~JC-~ 9A4~ - ~A4-&
-- I
0.005
- .o.-4160 LA 943 = 4-s5945 o 4 =94,=. 4,5 7 C- c.4> 57 Zzc 2 0 a
. I
(4571S~J ~)(5'~ O.z~')(4.5rn.S) -~ (~.ze~
.~- (4s32) (z') 2
(~T~'~ ~ CVO.~~O)(4.5~?a) -~
0.co =<
/ F
9cz~~ec~ ~-
IPzI
~ -\7~ -~ ~1 ~ \ * 4 I N -~
Cb71
cS7k56 TJ k4600tT3\- 'r-r eAT\MG [.1TER3 542.E
z
-f-I-4. 7
7/n o- 6'a 4
74,sp-.
* "G-ds 0, - soTFC ? -L ?,& CoO LYO
4. -a--.. ,& ' I
0.0057
'PSr
lowA ELECTRIC LGHT DT ( ( N494AND-PO WECUMPAN 2
CAZDI RAPDS.IoWA SUBJECT
L-Z00 -6 "' .1;7D*
. STREG!'"& Dc T RS 1 o0To E1Cr .~~~~~~~ f~e M u tIji '/6L10 8 NA A ~
- 6,5734. 6/o)l
--63-5'7 6 - sm ( vewalrmim mtyseesece.
- - 65.7 a
la
lowA ELECTRic LirHT .--- AND POWER-COMPANYm lCLDA.R RAPIDS. IOWA I Crom Thoow
& = C 5 ')~ (Fas5r' \
L e -,F
f..Vn - 4.20An
tasc- Q.vidzR se s c-
7 wr FOR IRMATIN
OCLY ) ~ ~ ~ ~ Vi -- V a -& o
4. 4, z7
- e1I.0.a4 ?St
6-7(.5'7 z)(5: z * 72~-4Z T
K -0
-7 4-: eo, I
4.2tt
C.s. y .6me......... 0.R..Ar .o ___ G______ ('s by ___..._.______._Z_ DET.=20Chi SAG1 7=4LYS/F\ylC-S~ <
*~JC U.. "* . c a~,- -
*ST~rE65 \4 C-NL 1\td C Q1E~r4 L 0 17-7- Q
- 6a 17z egs
lowA ELECTRIC LGHT DEPT AC- IG \A -E14Avo POWER COMPANY- oJc E.
. cmz~ tAhems.IowA iiECT C- - - AJLGs /tS/cdAJ411 TOR CoA - ,._odhyo* o am_ D..._ ___
S -1TTZ:SS Q T - -7 \A -70 r'Ao&A t' ..
tD6e\t G C L ;N-.AP~
cA.
__I
L~5~ -~--*
fl.~ZO -~
.. 4 <-s'&) = S7'
N14 5 ' ) *
O F Xodc t/xM-6s DE~ . 0 F.y e
CQLE \ o. TO ACT Ot RL+T $LDE
SI~P QjAc-~Y\ ~ ~ y-y
I A+ I 4 4 .
8.I r.\105+ (oot 4-zoez
± ( oo)~.46.c~Y~. .h~. i.~o~($~..4z' I-j
44> i t (7~ 0 * ~sc6
L11 (179 3 l) (-3)
n C- A ~4
6, t*,7 es r
::r7 7.,, \ psi:
'11
\Y r
.4...:. '.
\4 00.4\.10.ik
lowA-E,
AND POI
SL ?CR
DEPT.. ASIG N T ( AL(' 01644\4 c--s-anC-LIeu-t
WER COMPANY pnstlT kJtARg Iz Z-3 mSUBEc- . 577229A /vY/5-A//cZ *M cc LIJ RcrA b4 S
SRAPIDS.IOWA
5 c.. AA_____ ... ___._._ __D.__
FR I@FOIATIONA OLY 1 w')
0-t.
=0
5~~&~et eT ~1VZ.~\ -~ ~\\~d~ = \63M(5\
1104
c:9> -~&?3S.26 9 1
C
'I
(~--~~7-4.
t 4-
r q oA3 ,-s
... *...-.4.. .s*-
O~somno3 - R.(7 Twk cGa ,- t .
UK R -GT DEPT.. CAC m --4 wA-E.ECOT.RCPLIGHRTOJEC
Un m- b 05 11\t Etices 77 =AJ F4 JR E NT
CDAn RAPs.Os. low^ - .coo 0 -<, c..-..... D* O___ __. y D___ _ __ _ a..___
.3 .. .. 0 .)
( Y c.5+eg 6s7-o ch+o- 70
SSNUN0
zo c0 cso e9
I -43zoo PS
_57&. a 403wo C-_F
I r S, L43- 444 = C, 00 V
OO O'tsAET
0. (400\ Ve1 7s) - 4.)'4.7 + L 1 -Z&Z 67Z io) - 72
( } oL(4.5
oIF-7 s
C>V. C0-- IO 0F'
-- o
I
. , -4
lowA ELECTRic LIGHT DEPT. QS CP~l.. 21-4
-- -APOWMR-COMPANY - C b.Jz-r . CED"n RAP~zOs.IOVWA -UUCQA-A-eZ,
- -4.
&.L0
.f 0 "
IDEPT. 1 . 1 4 4lAw -L-0CT- ICwi-t
AND POWER COMPANY
CDAa RAPIXS.IoWA
R-acco n5
t~1~*1IC Lc~i~G. .~Z~______ ___
Lo fGp
tW\S ooiG
r
~I ~I
.1 s-".-
to~
ht
iT ~2.
1~f -I'----
T E % u
L- ~4, L-\ L .\ e V
50.5
ill
Lc
L-.
L~7~4A~
L . -532
r~ = #9& Ru e seL- (s)= -
+ (.925o. (7s sour -
a,. Ea.
L
c......w4 0... .. id b, a.
9)
R
EEA.
'1
F, (L, ') CLz)
.
L ) \ L-2L
OWA ELECTRIC LIGHT
;ND. 2 DWWER COMPANY
CerDn RAPIDS.IoWA
. seooos F
.. - A~ A I .4
IDEPT.- 13 I } - tA G SN 1 '7.-rr-c Sr &- 6-i
SJMECT
amm C6 w by .oe
v Lo stoo Tr G oe-e
7 G e a e. n e it's twoot3-7rSG e t. L7
Fseo_-e_
'= *?; 1 ZZ'~ 0. 22. &~
--42 -L ( PSI ( orec r 95/
- 1.100
laz L~ >L2.0P
.\oo~
I I.
/1 1
4-z. ~*x: 6.-z~7~XaB.3(5) uso-& *.43.= 4..3t) 4 - ( c- (pr-noj d Z) C6.1 ws e 4z~u)+ s~a 4 ~ -y~ .01(e..-. ~. 1
0 2 t rQ -ft
I
=-- 3SEz . E3 fd iq F-:
-- ,12t-131 P5r
Loqve- tr- G
lwA+-ELEC-TRIC-A-GH-T E. G C-AND-POWER-COMPANY
CFLr RAP.GtS.cGWA G u ~C--Z--d by
rOn wRM OR 7, p
c L i A c I. N Cd<
.~tf 2 1et 7 F7U F
Io s. 6 0.1100
.34'\ 3 5- - 3 2 2 cT
L\ L.oactWG-
.4
'.Z- A* 403'7.4 y
L). 1eT C
-d.,. s a
10 0,7 Z- PS-6"I
3 azz.fe/'o.z c. ,- es.'7 -s4
6&20,l A- 4GZo,1e'+ (/0073,7 -- 14Z8. 7
F - l 4 . t
~-Y C..'
~At
1
.l=2 67 4 \ o-a-, 0 y % y onctOG '}
6,.537-
i
)0 Lour 6,
I .o E-E-Trzic-LIGHT
ND-RWEICOMPANYI CDAR RApiOs.lows
Z-Z00 Fs -.
ALC. f\0A4- ___
P aECT- ** . * . . SCu 6o r 191'i u M A0F7VA7L4 .
C.....dbyDs ____________ b __._____________ D.t..________
jxx2 j281 401 t s r ~ X~j~ 4 A3~At - oz
i55om r soL "7 To "I. -30'7
Ru~ ese \=10coo ps
14 ez, c 1o0coo
4 _ _o _ '
Zo,000
//3/ 4- /, 5
a
L ~
&gpo~s (r) $oLr~
J-C>p\ckt, G, Ot.-I
I
IOWA ELECTRIC IGHT AD POWER COMPANY'
Cru.n. RApss.IowA
R-acco we
F~ ~ .~A I A NZ v4ULAL. -- /-t
SUBcJECT n U -. 7 -r
Co D...
\O o,4-4
6: 55
C- 500o
(~- AZOO ~
' = ec
-- V,12.
3"z Z . DoSK L1i'1 C1 =\ c
s
.so4,
N4V d-Mjs O'\i cot's
RErac-CE.'lciutA owbae
h= - (- 00 ) G.a
C = a.c
al 8 o
r4V0. OZ
cc25
Ot1-0TO1L.Lornes LORO\ G
-' 0.5 O C . .&3 E
0. o83 -0. 02z
I - a C07-
I,
~
-'ft
! I . - !
i -... ~
DEPT
I y
OWA ELECTRIC LGHT
CLDAja RADTIs.loWA
DEPT f1 E(11hM
S c-T... . -.. ...
-r
rSO
0 ~ ~ ~ C CD k 0 ' '^Hc ±( .acz-4.cc", \.Go c 2.' c o= 6 co
K -0.074 - c.4C(e-ty' - c.00(e37 = -c.6oo
S -3.'41 F- /.220 (U.33~ - 3~oe'yy)? Q0c(czt
KC 3.450a - a.04 4(S.?73 '-.40/ (073)w ="2.06\Z
C SI 0.6 o (.25) + c~ca02 .
k. ~*~C
lay
4
'I
~~~7LiL~ £EcrI~ A-~% -.
-- 3 7C, 0
the \j7on..,7
I34-5:55
a .8 46.93 )( . ) /3. .5..s
1'
,Of,-r N% Cr
t
Tq
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT
S CDA, roPIDS. IOW, ? ,- zooo>c IFS
DEPT. DIs s AL &?4-
PGJEC . ***~O ' , _._____.. SUB.J ECT
~ ~ ~t._______________ O.d. hyDo.._________
\~oPv \~&
A
II~ O~KI
- F~~, (Gwore e"x<P)= ?.teX
HAT seses4= G .oo -s ('seek-sQ4 e ):r 43, At4 C9so3=4 .c
LA5 (* A bi vL) -- S~6 . 4.
C i L
S ~f wour 4 cs
(oX6.c) - e (>3.acy
Thi //5.To F5z
/=l /3s 0.5 /au-/&~
&. ((asX<))(a - A
- ___ _7. ___ __
9 )(T'.4hto9.3 s
A692' \)9 -6 4 Do61 W\: =..s-3 t b \ 4 ~LV ~ c
40sw~.6-we-s ok a ON T%/ wcu~a1OkF
,*
7s-:z
Q AAE- L I f t " r-- - - 1 -a4. u % k I
AND POWER COMPANY
CE OAfl RAPIDS. IOWA Crom0,= TIFs.oS
PCROG.JE.. 7 ET 15 14 EtRE hAM65RLL-A.It~d-kTATR
c-p-0'o Il .A. 6y ..
-- ~ 5~&.... ~ ~ ~
(LT 9,' = 2.S :C.acahieT
6*& T-TsoGL. .0 015Vta LOccro OF- i. C 7 S~r~-\
T - 4os hwrT-o BRL
.. 5 - ,s-3 N) ?- *&\. 7: 2".
z +s ?39"
TION ~ V
i
- V3i ' t Pa 6/9 06,Z )C:57, Z S 758'3A) 7
c9~ __ _ ~:* ~\y= sF
<,z I,' i + (0 7 43.4. o\)(o.6zo> + (4(.O .o L7
+(570,42)(4.oc.) - (--.20)7 hC.E)
?368.113.0 - 29. esm
629. 7.9 0 -4 7.8 sc. o 9 ~22r.t
U w
~ 353.b~ PSI= //5.Go7 aer
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT DEPT. 5r 't\'Q t Q
AND POWER COMPANY-- PnoECT ... uo.. -. ___
CZDARRAPs.ow SUBJECT / . Afa cT6A O p ___ Coco ** .. 6y owe.,
Lstotic.~~~~~~~ STA.tt -1c .G Yt:--aZ
e.E~~~~c Eo w com
FOR FORMATION
4 ~ ~ ~ ~ V S.SO~o~~
O SsS O9t T. \oOa\rl CT0- (a-E
Scove-- Mec
/f o z/4 o 309
_____ > 4&cD t
/ 0/5
c A t-,0 cz /Z V4.
DESIGN/REVIEW COMMENTS SHEET
VERIFICATION ALTERNATE C
j-~) '.4'
Sheetz4 f 2-4A
INT-101?ALCULATIONS
NO. COMMENT RESOLUTION/APPROVAL
uesign Engine Date
4-zi +4 Verifyinc/En eer 'Date
ecnical' brop Leaer Uate
Superv1'-i Engr--NucPear FroaJctt Uate
Form No. NG-009Z* Rev. 0
-'I
-Ver4tyE ngineer DAteAl A ;-'A-
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
DUANE ARNOLD ENERGY CENTER
CALCULATION COVERSHEET
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION NO: NA p4- \5
ANALYSIS/CALCULATION TITLE:
REFERENCE DOCUMENTS
MAR NO:
DCR NO:
OTHERS: 75a
Ct- A ~~C8LI-f
PREPARED
REVIEWED
APPROVED.
BY: A~9Ii~< J~L
BY:
BY:
DATE: -&
DATE: 4-t4 14
DATE:
FINAL APPROVAL BY: A" . 9--DATE:
FORM NG-007Z REV. 0
I
Background
The purpose for compiling calculations.M84-11, 12, 13, 14, 15 was to perform a seismic analysis on the critical components of the Hills-McCanna Pneumatic Damper Actuators. These actuators are part of the secondary containment isolation system at the Duane Arnold Energy Center
On January 26, 1984, Iowa Electric notified the NRC by telephone that.the above mentioned actuators were potentially deficient in meeting their purchase specification. A review of the documents relating to this discrepancy revealed that the isolation damper assemblies were purchased originally as complete assemblies which included the damper actuators. Subsequent orders for "likefor-like" replacement actuators were placed directly with the actuator manufacturer who was a subvendor to the damper manufacturer. This most recent purchase order for actuators revealed that a quality assurance program, as required for safety related equipment per 1OCFR Part 50, is not currently in effect at the actuators manufacturer's facility.
Further review of the damper assembly documentation revealed that the seismic analysis performed on the damper assemblies did not seismically analyze the actuators themselves, but only considered their weight as it seismically affected the damper frame. This information prompted Iowa Electric to audit the damper manufacturer and check for documentation that pertained to the seismic qualifications of the isolation damper actuators. Results from the audit of-the damper manufacturer revealed that the actuators were never purchased by the damper manufacturer as seismically qualified components nor did the damper manufacturer administer a Quality Assurance program concerning the purchase of the actuators.
Since no traceability or Certificate of Conformance was available for the seismic qualifications of the actuators, a seismic analysis was performed on the critical components of the actuators in order to seismically qualify the damper actuators for use in the Duane Arnold Energy Center. This seismic analysis followed the guidelines set forth in-the original purchase specification for the isolation dampers (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100). By seismically qualifying the isolation damper actuators, Iowa Electric will be able to buy Quality Level I actuators in accordance with Revision 1, Chapter 4 of the Quality Assurance Manual under Standard Industrial Quality Items 4.7.3.
Solution
A seismic analysis was performed on five models of the Rockwell HillsMcCanna Ramcon Pneumatic Actuator product line that are installed as isolation damper actuators at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. These five models include the following:
* R-260 FS * R-450 FS * R-960 FS * R-2000 FS * R-4200 FS
The seismic analysis on the actuators followed the general project seismic requirements for frequency-not-determined class 1 equipment in the reactor building and in the control building (ref. Bechtel 7884-M-100, Technical Specifications for Isolation Dampers for the Duane Arnold Energy Center Unit 1, Revision 0, 12-28-70).
A visual inspection of all isolation damper actuators at;the Duane Arnold Energy Center was .made in order to verify model number, serial number and elevation location in the plant. After verifying the elevation location in the plant, static coefficients (,g units) were determined for the highest installed actuator for each of the five actuator models. The horizontal static coefficient was then applied to all three of the orientation axis which eliminated many repetitious calculations and the need for detailed actuator orientation information. Applying the horizontal static coefficient to each axis provided conservative results since the horizontal coefficient is always greater than one plus the vertical coefficient (Fvertical = (Weight) (1 + gv), Fhorizontal = (Weight) (gh) gh > 1 + gv).
The seismic analysis concentrated on the critical areas of the damper actuator where the seismically induced loads could possibly make the actuator fail,-malfunction, or prevent operation.' Five areas on each actuator model were identified as critical areas requiring a seismic analysis of the various components interfacing with that critical area. These five critical areas are identified as the following:
o Retaining key which holds the spring cylinder assembly to the main body cylinder
o Main body cylinder o Press fit between main body cylinder and the mounting yoke o Mounting hardware o Mounting yoke
Dimensions and material specifications for the seismic analysis were obtained through the use of proprietary component drawings that were on loan to Iowa Electric from Rockwell Hills-McCanna of Carpentersville, Illinois. All prints applicable to this seismic analysis are listed in the reference section of the referenced calculations.
Four basic assumptions are applied throughout the entire seismic analysis of the damper actuators. These assumptions allow Iowa Electric to use the floor response-spectra as the design/qualification spectra .for the seismic analysis. The four basic assumptions are as follows:
o The mounting of the damper is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The damper itself is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The support bracket for the actuator is a rigid structure (f > 33 cps) o The seismic requirements for evaluating the actuators are the same as
those for the isolation dampers.
The maximum seismic stresses were calculated by using the square root sum of the squares method for combining the three earthquake direction stresses as recommended in the UFSAR for seismic analysis at the Duane Arnold Energy Center. A second method, the distortion energy method was used for combining stresses at the press fit between the main body cylinder and the mounting yoke. The distortion energy method was used in place of the square root sum of the squares method because the stresses due to the press-fit condition exceeded and dominated those caused by the seismic event. All maximum stresses were then. compared to some fraction of the yield strength depending on the material type and stress type. Operability after a DBE event was ensured by requiring that the maximum stress from combined seismic and normal loads should not exceed 90% of the yield stress of the material.
Conclusion
After completing the above described seismic analysis on the five models of Hills-McCanna actuators installed on the isolation dampers at the Duane Arnold Energy Center, it was found that the maximum stresses from the combined seismic and normal loads do-not exceed the material yield requirements defined in the isolation damper purchase specification. The results of this seismic analysis reveal that the five models.of Hills-McCanna actuators are seismically qualified for use at the Duane Arnold Energy Center.
References
Bechtel Purchase Specification 7884-M-100
Formulas for Stress and Strain; Raymond J. Roark, Warren C. Young, Fifth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Co. 1975
Hills-McCanna Information Bulletins; R-1090, R-1090A, R110C, R1100A, R111C, R-1110A, R-112D, R-1120A, R-113D, R-1130A
Marks' Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers' Baumeister Eighth Edition, McGraw-Hill Book Company 1978
Materials Selector 75; Reinhold Publishing Co. Mid September 1974, Vol. 80, No. 4, Brown Printing Co.
Mechanical Engineering Design; Joseph E. Shigley, Third Edition, McGrawHill Book Co. 1977
Mechanics of Materials; Higdon, Ohlsen, Stiles, Weese, Riley Third Edition, John Wiley and Sons 1978
Rockwell Hills-McCanna; Proprietary Drawings
DATA:-Information contained on drawings is proprietary and confidential and is not to be given or loaned to others. Drawings are to be returned to Rockwell upon completion of their intended use in making the seismic analysis.
R450-R960
450-7511 450-1005 450-7512 450-3005 450-3007 450-4101 450-4102 450-2101 450-2906 450-2507 450-2501 450-3201 450-3202 450-3203 450-3326 450-3325 450-3321 450-3320
R2000-R4200
460-7511460-1001 .460-7509 460-3001 460-3003 460-4101 460-4102 460-2101 460-2904. 460-2503 460-2502 460-3208 460-3209 460-3210 ,460-3317 460-3316 460-3320 460-3321 460-3314 460-3315 -
U.S.S. Steel Desian Manual; R.L. Brockenbrough and B.G. Johnson, Jan. 1981
R260
430-1004 430-7510
.430-7511 430-3003 .430-3005 430-4101 430-4102 430-2101 430-2904 430-2502430-2501 .430-3321 430-3322430-3325 430-3201 .430-3202' 430-8203
p
G- L
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
POSITION
EDUCATION
PROFESSIONAL DATA
SUMMARY
EXPERIENCE
Senior Civil/Structural Engineer
BS, Civil Engineering, University of Michigan
MS, Civil/Structural Engineering, University of Michigan.
Registered Professional Engineer in MiEhigan
1 year: Senior Engineer; Civil/ Structural Staff
4 years: Senior Engineer; Midland, Palisades, and Big Rock Point Nuclear Power Plants
1 year: Resident Engineer, Midland Nuclear Power Plant
Mr. Reifschneider is currently assigned as a civil/structural engineer on the civil/ structural staff. His duties include; preparation of design standards; review of project calculations, drawings, specifications and.seismic qualification of equipment; providing consultation to civil/structural engineers engaged in the design of nuclear and fossil power plants; solving special static and dynamic structural problems.
Prior to joining the civil/structural staff, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/ structural engineer on Consumers Power Company's Palisades project. His duties included finite element analysis of the biological shield wall, seismic analysis and design of blockwall supports, and seismic analysis and design of the auxiliary building addition including the review of seismic equipment qualifications.
Prior to joining the Palisades project, Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural resident engineer at the jobsite of Consumers Power company's Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included interfacing with construction personnel on the design, erection, and construction of seismic instrument and equipment supports.
fhrp U4,Au C G pY
MARTIN REIFSCHNEIDER Reviewer for Calculations M84-11,12,13,14,15
Prior to his jobsite assignment, Mr. Reifachneider conducted research on the inelastic design and behavior of braced structural steel systems, moment frame structural steel system, and reinforced concrete shear wall systems. He co-authored three Bechtel reports on the findings of this research.
Prior to his research assignment Mr. Reifschneider was a civil/structural engineer on the Midland nuclear plant project. His duties included designing seismic supports for HVAC ducts and electrical cabletrays.
- ~ ~ ~~**~* -
IOWA ELECTRIc LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
CerAxa Iuros.IowA
DEPT. D /(*r
PROJECT- L.eer4o- -deZA
0N-,\ CA --4-1
S~qit4 LSS t) 67 -w
(yr on 90O d
TR +TR 36 Co P-lasoo
=*
R:=TR ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 7-0 30s O -- 2
5 c4)5e) Nov S\\
-f. 4 -3690o0
(4-2 0
_o___ _ R307 G&ece -i1
'/5 0& 6
_________ ~ '~ ~eTUO
CJAr-o\et.To ste-ss \YW.iG ORES C 'D1RGCTONE OR -A;Qyit\ so
)F 7T)- E liCr 9waXA ta
IOWA ELECTRIC LIGHT LAND POWER COMPANY
CrjAx RAPIDs.IowA
DEPT. d V ,x~X ,'J?
PROJECT. -Seer.o- *
SlJECT I:A.AJ / TZ e cDa.t,
0 .. Di.nd by Doe
\,N oC;7 -6 (' 4,7? (D C)- 4Z 00
MP, L-- 0 L GlR - o.
6TREUA;, s 6Tac 17+G
IL
10\<- ~ ~ ~ V cc o toFiy s=(c&'s \2ocops 120p a
~ I~I
0Z 0 \0Z ' eZ t. Yo
0z
... 4- - A
..JOW.A-E-E-T-RICLiGw -AND POWER COMPANI
~ CFEAA RAPD5S.IOWA
DEPT.- S oGt R V- Q'.
SUI.JECT ReC. I
7o a:E Z, w\* QO = .s h? - 20.44 =f O.761/t Z&(G.7C J
________*(2~~IAV~(c'.2~3_#/,~) =
~~-~~___
wCere t Zr c" R Z O ' (\ ?\PSlOG'
14LGwT =(0.0Ceayc. zco 5 (
I :. -a .. -
i. 69iaadiG ('.-t O k 10 CAPi
FE0dC CGOP cnV814 CVu3e<
En pnxo nNo
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT a POWER^ COMPNWY
Crom.j RAmPIs.IowA
Z- 47 oO n
DEPT. "DEkStJ EroL-E0L 1a5e rP4-16 -- PmOJECT. D th Ar .Et Z.
Sarr El7 StillC !ZTRESS Ph9A%516Whem ____-fi____tA__ i Ac.t)AY_
C-'"'"4 '9('D..Ad by N..
V- - 5?.91 \ -
'4 0 (z ka7e ree () rPabL S -Z.r7
.1 C0 - A
orstY
s*4 <' bM- K A i osrotJr LO) LoD FoR - 10 -sr A : ,re)T/72
EL-'WT/cJ /4PP'"C 7C "241/ Ax/S OF 606tic. AL.YSL$.
W W\kiya AO. e.Qc,= o st. P irJ)& o' c, //S ^Z -:cf-5 " O/)IAmr~r
* e-~ ~
1-*
~M
M-~L~eG' CN L7 )
ILr GO = . I 41 asrof 4/~ *
.1 U
4(oo -3c:ot 46o- -3o
LGW~e~ C ~~-~cc ~G~)
eZ)-s
LT \LuaG gAry
1F tea,"G zL-1 4.0^'E)1 o L CT L-y) 'F' s e cZ O .0 1. a4 5 3 r \Z 7 3 i=.6 2 0 o f . g )
z - ?c~)~ ~3.5Y~i~')
A-
c 54 .'6 - 87 4. . 8
\7 G'--366
T S"7 G 1. 6, -*
lowA ELECTRIC LIG AND POW-R COMPA
CWAa TAIDS.IoWA
HT DEPT.. Dms\tA :ra t-a\1 G CCL-C. M'4k4JS HT
nULJECT e - C F gR...(. SA .- /
D~~~c.ch __ _ _ _ _O . by_ _ _ _ _ _ _ -. S....Z, Do**,- -Q - - G. & - De -
~C~: *~CeSc4
IO11
ru'
90..L.c,-o NakE L>e r - QT~s 0 \-7O es
+ NL+ ~. o + ((;,oo'4+ 43.L .9' 4434-36 <-lb~ w %'YCB) com o
%I-A= 44Q4-St3 7
4
c9= 6.E'96 xc __ = .6373 RADIA 6,
* TsTP(9& \$ ThE pah-r.E VTw'T - COOS~or\o~S -yd TH
VE~~hu 0 'L(0)t900' OO c10\& = T,(G $OAE
fn
0
I _ ________
4
1-. -~
0
IeN e. E cativ Rs -tl. tro t 2 . "
= 456 .931 - '
(1.3)C -.16-7)
IOWA ELECTRIC LGHT AND POWER COMPANY
CLDwn mA Z s.Io W. . -
DEPT. - I - !D .. ) ( - - I a . Et - 1U- .... - -- I % .-..
PRUECT worUETr-SI SM9fw Gw--,-<, & RLYzs5 //.7-/ cG94 AaGwaolts
c 6r Nt.c6i .4 y Nit*
LTE1L "I c--G
'L tSAy
/4~
~r c]tG
0
0 . _
4.z . 0 0.wQ,75
t :c-, 4..7) teLr7 )4
PC= '-c s -o 9 -- ( o, 4 \N 4 zr7> r (.:-4) V4Z .2 2 sr
"I'Top-3= '* e;7a r-: 4 .4~ };/g c, c, ePs es
y 3o-r-, 000V ki- voa 4<
S '9.\4S 15 o c
LAP s~1 sm to -ro Te______C m <. oo re--aE r
j0il4&- %4~KOXX~1AJ
I1113'a-T \/ (M\,)
'f 'S) -Kj e1J<
y)
lowE--EG-TRIC -1GHT-
AND POWER COMPANY
CEDAR RAPIDS. IOWA
4ro
~~t~5S ~ -~ T\A~~ ~ \~C~ C(~V~ l-~x~~-~t ~
* c c
u' c \-.)
I 9.1-) 4 1AA 5 7
4-& 6 914 =4, z
- C, /O.44 6220C
L
10
t,3as z: 460- '331
~; h
Yo ki
4W - 3 3 r7
- 3 t31 I
0. Oo5'ir
O. co01 (4 57; 7
(r2714,)/Sto(. 95
0.co5 r 4.75 (. f-
04 a
(\ .19)(4.5r15) .9(±t
5 33(. /o) ( ps
635 7~ ti F--
A - .#, 4- I L
SRJECT -6 * .44 'C A-g * hysve 91/I fes OPlLN/ .. L4d .. 5____r_40 ___5_-
0-3 (0 ) 2).7' 2- +
IOwA ELECTRIc LIGHT AND POWER COMPANY
Cr az R.n th e Iow.
PREmumTi.)RAT. ART4GLuc EDERMi ce' r-...7. ..
SUBJECT /Sit\C 6TV ANMLYSI 6//MS
c.... w... _____._ 0
Sc (?Q CO ;!L\ TS \ Co0 \10 t
___ K \2 &'- L
c2. -
@em
2.
5zz _
1 40/
.c-zzo 3) o
*SsI l .
47 2 -
I = ( 4.snz) tfi&
-ist 5- 4.20
4z~ F1 - 2
K
4.,!57 4,___z
- 0 t 0,4 Ps
T&-
T T J
Psr ja
- ~ * -~'4~'-:.. - ~ - . -~ 4... -4
Cz7z - 4 57/ f- z
CYD~a R~ir~slo.
zsE~i -rkdTwE -kc,'toG
Cap
C,
-: destra67
I QwA-ELEC-TR IC-LIGi-TAND POWER COMPANY
CromA TAIDIS.IOWA
-42C2 -C
mErTO.YAhlAE. fA ct.D ER (- . 7 .A
SUmJECI SE 010 -ME65 /V940%95 IS M4 CAO - Acf&#
by ~ ~ De. ____________ by
Fr AFR
INOL rki 2 ec -. O Ps
-l
57 - a *.
- ~ ~ r
-1 990 N fu3
C'\ft.asG P MAcC) 6.0
c%, 4)
V
*
o~- ~ -
C0Z16 hO~ P To T Ot LT 1
0X.s + (1c1. o4 + (A (Z~e 4- ( (7o 4, Za5 ia
k D v ".c . -q -, - -w-\ -. rQxt (la t fo A !
! > ruz C S '- "Z -\ T- PI---sSr 7- T- e'6 ^) ;)-/ 4r J SE-- c--- -
T 9 000- 701<< tdo THEQitLy1O D .8.0
IOWA ELECTRIC LGHT S C2 GLGScAiG AND POWER CoMPANY "_
.nlver 9 W.S1w ##Y)<Nt4t-IcC9AWA//Ct47aks CDD**..a RAPIDS.*WA
R-4'200 7 e~c6 b A
)Jy ~
44
. "~-y~ y b\r c \jy (1414-l
= tv-: - (/41ez.z ' -10C+73) -29'77 f'3
CG )ATO2r \ioTYLA:. Axis
Pre-ui on
fIAJ-~,EC~) 4
- yy t 4az1)ra
<5 t7 G, 3 7 1= 96679 P6 T
4,
147 .17 --- ~27F~ ~L
-L
' =0
L ' 1z9 I +
4r4
'"} \'.7 ( 6 5.79 L
lOWA ELECTRIC LIGH
U kPOWER- COMPAN.CroA. RAPIDS.IoWA
R oo
rnErTa CALD. M.4 -K m-r D ler . h . vt" ... 9 AIL
srnmeir RE4t\.SRS OtwL.Y1 14tLL -MaJh AtgAT~fj - ***4by D=* Oneck- - by Date.
-*I
,o 00 k4 'teC (a - 4C +cdr7F- EjJ0.6 +609.s4J+ (-8\29.49 5. / *-(-.535.78 J750.65 - ' \\D 95r
a> < 4320' Psr
,: 432m es
~LQ ~ 'i d ~
.3r - 94105
I-EG-TRJIC4 GHT--- DT.- e AND POWER COMPANY POECT ID'N k .o AL
~ ezn hse.Iw SUILJECT 5m/ /M4S-mc ey CEDA* RoAPIDS.IOW. &f) ,
K~~~D, -________ '' 7,~
~IO ~cc
i ~
I ~fr 'a
~X~N'.
~ ~'
.143 - .44 I"
(r2:- 4.-7aferrb 72) vL.
4, 64 7
0.0 \ =E [4.303y ix 10 0o 3-x ic
- .72 24M 50 .P 3,LZ)2 - \430
Ez (sectin CMLt G,O'c 7 \01
43. *(2.zo
Ng- ff- C~U46 7 3.48 754t3
.~F-. lT~-t --FbA - o
I..
Sarsnc. esu oeyo ce 4 'Nl-R O G R-~c TwXo G M oGtr r
or wn=
IOWA ELECTRIC LGHT DEPT.
AND POWER: COMPANY1 " i ra 4 M1.
CDA RAPIDS.IOWA .. g~~~Df c.6.. M /0..0... W0.
o ce c. o seor eudoca vawn uecorc-vx-E
C\ ISUN.).. 210I = o14-46t
as es.1
F //*(c.o'X'7z~4%9Jt.)(co) reE3
296 .3- >2//5
r- R
N Q
I--
KT AM(As-s o7 rA<.vrom r
mt\com Voi=-E = =1! tk
EN
E
I ~ -, ~ '1O~C~
~~~1
i~H K. I H'
, L I 1fV~CiZ
\KiiIiIi7~
~
L + \- z 7
L I
r
F-t (L t) t 3r24-Y ) + L9O- , Z' Lk
L\ Lz lL
hk ( )4o )&0)=149-04.coI.
L,;,r o~as G4
+ La
Liii
uses = \490 4. 1n a- '
C ) =(490.0 0-0 \ 3< t0
7L LL ASSt.3Z)(4..6z) - 0 .
O.Z.-6 r 1,434 LoGl - 6i2
To see 0 Go 9en T t SAM=-- Loric AL
A
Uo~
= \4~-3Z. O~ ~-~r
7ilw o oel BOkl,-k
2 4 c)(zzG. f&'
~z-#y....- 4.... fl~. - L .
DEPT.. DESICGt4 LeoT.. ) 14 -EC-Ric-LiGT
O1VER COMPANY
DAr RAPItlCS. I OWA SU
* t A
.CECT zwn Z II Dss.o
R-~Z 42c -I
AND P
CEI
1
[
u ftiNFORAT awim.L
6~~)(~O ) ~
- 3A2$
o. /- /9
545<
/37-9 z 3 7'
4 5
-~ ~ <~>
,0 79l54 ._
?- , coo-.
0 O5-590z7
O~C)Oz ~
II.
Ll-4ECTrRICL1Gcur car tama F~raett C- _ Laq, 4W4 -IS
Ake POWER COMPANY -try* Cross. R ssesUlow CXDAJI RAPIDS.IOWA S ~
-4Dot... 0-4.doby De _
SC/.9 m * /73,8'
T -A' ,- 6 7-ocz
91 1oe, Eoo
. -, . . . .. s
lowA ELECTRIC LIGHT AvD POWER COMPANY
CFDAA RAPIDS.IOWA
DEPT. ' a! y t at c
-SJJECT--i : m
- ~r'\C~ 4-re ~- - - - - -- - - - ±."J~~J,~± ~
R.- 5004 Cc-A Zoo - w
Tw-k satl *Ss
Gocera a.
,T: m Eco .1
IA- 0.L*
Z N2. Do
Mc V6 A 1 -14
7= G e;- LL Co a c? ______
C= &4 <aZ. ')- K
~0. czs
Z'02&C A
J(
(A
- O.=Ec0
c- "-Cco
-r
o . a z
.1
AcomzoT.Lons.
z
-~ ('~.oo-Y~c') - X*~~c~ '~V 0AZ e ~' ~-oc~
-R ZOC0 7S CALCOLPT 1o3 Fo a
'o'~\ \
FO INFORMATION -00L
a _()(. 4 ') \ 4
' .= (GO X 54.S (% \t 4
........................................................................-..
A
3xz~
1 A)s-3 - .
15onG
*1
_o -_')(7.5^> .. 563.43 es
K Y §r )0 s
4
X Lo'k G
24 6 4e6 L3- \ - , ')
'3'rl] II- V74.23 ?s-
\\\.Zc , 1- \\VLZY +7Vz
I1\ S7.36 rsT
E
- ~AOC -~\Q\~c ~
' - = /6 3 5- (1.743(3coo) 2 o
* M~VS c~ ~
~. ~3
. . 4. ;. . - . :
A
3xZ 5.
\ . o0.o0
-. - I.
DvETr xwle FM~4aart-- (301 (YA-P:/ lowA ELECTRIC LGHT
[-.D POWER COMPANY "" -4TC-M . / no -CED si m-A<. qmgLYsls //l.s-dhccvA1Al9 Av__T oR_5
CZZwnk RAP'ms).IoA
4
1. . . - .1 -I . - ". " J
.A T(CAL,.. A of
Sheet/hof/z
DESIGN/REVIEW COMMENTS SHEET
DESIGN VER FICAT ON ALTERNATE CALCULATIONS
Form No. NG-009Z* Rev. 0
top related