risk management policy in dutch municipalities. understanding the process, identifying strengths and
Post on 14-Apr-2018
218 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
1/23
Available in: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=96019001008
Red de Revistas Cientficas de Amrica Latina, el Caribe, Espaa y Portugal
Sistema de Informacin Cientfica
Ignacio CIENFUEGOS SPIKINRisk management policy in dutch municipalities. Understanding the process, identifying strengths and
visualizing possible improvements
Revista Enfoques: Ciencia Poltica y Administracin Pblica, vol. IX, nm. 14, 2011, pp. 155-176,
Universidad Central de Chile
Chile
How to cite Complete issue More information about this article Journal's homepage
Revista Enfoques: Ciencia Poltica y
Administracin Pblica,
ISSN (Printed Version): 0718-0241
enfoques@ucentral.cl
Universidad Central de Chile
Chile
www.redalyc.orgNon-Profit Academic Project, developed under the Open Acces Initiative
http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/comocitar.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/fasciculo.oa?id=960&numero=19001http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/revista.oa?id=960http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/fasciculo.oa?id=960&numero=19001http://www.redalyc.org/comocitar.oa?id=96019001008http://www.redalyc.org/ -
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
2/23
155
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCHMUNICIPALITIESudrstadg t prcss, dtyg strgtsad vsag pssb prvts
Gst d rsg as cpadads d hadaetdr prcs, dtcar rtaas
y vsaar psbs jras
I CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN1
uvrsty TwtTwt, hada.j.cgsspk@twt.
V. Ix N 14, 2011, 155-176
F : 17 2010F : 7 2010F : 29 2011
ABSTRACT: T z , - w N -. Aw, w DL G z - (H, 1995). A (V H B, 2001; Yk D V, 2002;Swk, N D R, 2009 D V, 2008), kw Nw P M, - D . T
1 P F M G.
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
3/23
156
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
, w N k , , (B H, 2005) z k .
Kywrds: k , w , , -
RESUMEN:P z , - P B. L, E f G L, -z . E , N G
P (H, 1995), z M (V H B, 2001; Yk D V, 2002; Swk, N D R, 2009 D V, 2008). E , G R H, -, z (B H, 2005).
Paabras cav: , , , -
D A K A (2002), - . T w- - (J, 1994),w w. A w - , (K P, 1990) w , z . I , k
w . Hw, , w k .
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
4/23
157
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
T N z w z - (VH B, 2001). A D -, , z w w ( ) . T - w. A K A (2002) D - 1848 . A Tk (1798-1872), w , -w . A H (2009), - D , k , k- k . B N - w -, ( ) w . S w -k w-w , (L, 1975 H, 2009).
T D , B, D R, US, w - z (P, 2001 K A, 2001). M N - (S, 1999
K A, 2001). A wk V H B (2001), D , , . I , , , z, w .
M N ,w - (V H B, 2001). T w (D R, 2002). T w , w (K A, 2002). T k , , - . M w z , - k (V H B, 2001)
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
5/23
158
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
-- z z ( F 1 ).I D ,
, f - . L w , 20 , w w (V H B, 2001). E A F A 1929, : (1) M F w w (2) , w (3) w (B H, 1998). I 10 , w .
T - -, . A K A, wk 2002, , w w k D , -
. T k w w . I w , w ; . O -z, (KA 2002).T
N, , -k - k k .
A B H (1998), w 432 w 1985 114 w 1998. T 43,5 30,7 . S , , M F (B H-, 1998).
A D , w w , -k , (H, 2009). H (2009) N, A, R,T H U, -w . T
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
6/23
159
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
, w . F , . D z , . I w , - ( , , .) w w , . I w, , - w w ( R-R, H- ) (H, 2009). T ,w-kw , w w , w w .
A , N . Hw, . T w , -
w .T w w , (N, 1992 KA, 2002). A K A (2002) w . W - w , w , .
F , w , w . A k
, k. M- k (K C,2001 K A, 2002). A K (2001), - . I H, w U, 50 . I A, z U, k 30 . I , k
(K A, 2002). A , D - w k k -k k- .
S w D , N, . A VSw (2008), R ,
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
7/23
160
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
. E N k -, w w z , k w .
T W WII ( T 1). C . T - . A , , w . Hw, , z, k , w k. O , V H B (2001), D k , w .
FIGURE 1. STRUCTURE OF A DUTCH MUNICIPALITY
C C-
U
EC
A
MM C
S: Ow .
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
8/23
161
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
TABLE 1. DISTRIBUTION OF DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES BY SIZE OF MUNICIPALITYN
P z 1950 1980 1990 2010L 5.000 624 246 105 65.000 20.000 314 407 384 16520.000 50.000 53 114 130 19250.000 100.000 13 27 36 42O 100.000 11 17 17 26T 1.015 811 672 431
A z 9.879 17.375 22.162 38.327
S: B D, Kk V, 2002.
Public Management Reormin the Dutch Local Government SectorI w , z - z, 80. T Nw P M (NPM). T NPM w w (H, 1995).
A V H J (2003), NPM - .P Bk (2000 V H J, 2002) NPM : z, kz, -
z, , , .T NPM z - (V H J, 2003). I :
Dz z - ; C- , , w
, w w - ;
A z , ;
A - -z.
O (1998 V H B, 2001) , w k , Nw P F M.
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
9/23
162
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
O , - , z z z ( NPM - H, 1995 Kk, 1997). (S T 2)
Fw k, P (2002 V H J,2003), NPM : , , z- , . I D , NPM 1990. D V (2008), P k w, , , , , ,
, , w, -, , -
. T , w - , z , w , (D V, 2008).
A B M (1995), D . Hw, - k w , - w , , UK, A Nw Z(H, 1995; P, 2000 D V, 2008). T, - NPM , -, ,
. F , D -k w w - k (V H B, 2001; V H
J, 2003 D V (2008) ).
L NPM D M, V H J (2003) w 1980, - N k . T w z z
z z . T w z
w z , . T w w 1990, D M H Ak
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
10/23
163
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
k , , , (V H J, 2003). T , w kw BBI ( D:B- B I), w P M I (PMI). T w z .
A Kpmg (1997 V H J, 2003) 75 N - . Hw, w , w w (M, 1997 V H J, 2003). A Kpmg (1997, V H J, 2003), 16 - 13,000 40,000 , w 67 .
A NPM D w k - k. A w , w . G NPM , k , . Hw, B,(2001 V H J, 2003) - D w 20,000 . F , B (2001) , , -, w . T , w ,
w . I , - D w 100,000 (B, 2001). A kw
, z,
N.M, V H J (2003) -
k w NPM w . S w w , w - k . T , - w -w, ,w z w w z (V H J, 2003).
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
11/23
164
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
E w NPMW NPM D , z , S H k .A Yk D V (2002), k L A, - T N-, w w w P S H. F , P (1.7 ) , - ( ) (V Dk C, 1999 Yk D V, 2002). I ,
w k (Yk D V, 2002).T, Yk D V (2002), -
Nw P M, . T z - .
T D 1983 ( ) w CO w - (Yk D V, 2002). R w, k k P C . (M I A K A, 29 S 1999).
C - -. T -, , . B . T k w (Yk DV, 2002). A k , w , . I k , k - (k ). E w , w 1995 G A A (Yk D V, 2002).
D , M I A w k P S H.T M I P w
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
12/23
165
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
A- k w w , -. I, k k kw k w w w k w w w -k w k. O , w , k -, w k, k w k
, w M I . T w , .
T P S H - w D , -k , w k k. I , w k z ,
w. W
z k w w z , k w w . A Y-k D V (2002), z f , w - (B, 1996 Yk D V, 2002).
A NPM D -, w , - z ( ) z- (V H J, 2003). z w w , - w , w - , k - k w. M, - w k w z N NPM, , k
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
13/23
166
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
. Hw, D MC(2007) k z, k - k w , k k , w z, k , .
A w k w , -, k z .T, - - w k , ,
k w z -k w . I , V H B (2001) w -k - , w - - . T w w w , , w -- k w ( Kpmg, 1997).
M, NPM . A , D . F ,
, w , . Mk , , k D -k. A , k,
, w w - wk. P Bk (2000) .
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
14/23
167
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
TABLE 2. THE NEW PUBLIC MANAGEMENT APPARATUS IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
NPM E C
1. D ,z
D ( )
R ( )
2. C
Bk z : w
O
3. A
P . B w:
S k ; ()
4. C
O :
E w -
5. V -
T
R
6. T
D ,
R w
7. O C , P k
S: V H J, 2003.
Rk M D M, F RT P Lw w 1995, Nw P M, - w (Yk D V, 2002).
A , P Lw , ,
w w z P Lw, 1997 P Fwk F C. T - .W , M I A w . T Lw , -, , (Yk D V, 2002). T P- Lw 1995, w w ,w k. A ,
P k .I 2004 P Lw w . T
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
15/23
168
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
w (B, 2006). I w ; ) , ) k ( ) ) w k k .
A B (2006), . T z - k, k , . T P Lw - k . F k k w . H w , w w k k . B(2006), , k k, z - k -, w- C-B A. I , , , w - w D z -. T, k w k , k k (L, 2003). Rk k k w k w w .
T P Lw w k k
(B, 2006). A w, k w , - , w k , w - , k ( L, 2003). Pk, , w . A k k. A , k , -, w k k k . A w;1) k, 2) k 3) k w z.A , .., k, k , k , k , . A B- (2006), M I A
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
16/23
169
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
k, () k.A k z ( ), P Lw
, w k. T - (CN) (B, 2006). A , w (FCA) (A) (A) (H), w w w:
FCA = Abr+ A + H
A B (2006), , w . T w k , - . Hw, f . T w ( , -
wk) D , w w w 200 (K A, 2001), w w , k k , k . T k , , . T (B, 2006).
T w , w w (FCA) - (CN). T,
, w 1, z . A , P Lw k k - . A w k ; B (2006) M I A , w w k , k. T, wk - k , , w k - z k , w , ( F 2 k ).
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
17/23
170
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
R k D MB H (2005) k P Lw 2004. T 130 - w k z N . S - w w w w k .
R k , w (- k) k , B H (2005) k - . T k, w ( ), k ( , , ), k ( , , , z, .).T , , ,w D z k,w . A k - k , w w k w z.
B H (2005) k , , f, , , w k ( F Y, 2005 D MC-, 2007) , , , w , , -
z z w . I k E - (B H, 2005), - ,
w N (D R, 2002).
D ( k), kw (B H, 2005).Rk f w -, w ( w ). F, 50% - .
I k, B H
(2005) k. O w k, k P w - (B H, 2005),
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
18/23
171
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
k. A , , k k kw k , w k , .
T w k . E k ( k), w k(B H, 2005). A B H (2005), k w D , , w, w , , - . Hw, w , -k - ( ), w k k .
A B H (2005), , , - k wk k, z , , ( k w z) . E w (5 130) , K (1921).2 I w w , G T, NPM, , (B H, 2005).
O B H k. T , z , kw z. T, w z, z, w, % .A kw w k , k , , w k
2 K k z . H z -, , k, , , k (K, 1921). T, - k -, w K , k z , w .
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
19/23
172
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
k z , (L, 2003) w w, w k w k . O , , w k kw wD , w w P S H, .
F, B H (2005), w w , (FCA) w. T, 124 130 - . W , ( w ), k, .A 13 130 .A , w k , w w k . T , , w w - k . T, - w , 7 130 k 6 7 , ( T 3 k k ).
CA , w N , k, w w z. S w k D w w w. N, k w k - , - k w , .
A z, , k , kw
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
20/23
173
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
. A N w k , , ( , w k ) w , k .
M , M M, k z, k N. A w B H (2005) N k , G T, k k w . T k z-, k w ( k ).
FIGURE 2. STEPS IN THE RISK MANAGEMENT PARAGRAPH IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
RegularRisks
PositiveRisks
PureRisks
FinancialRiskPropertyRisk
InternalRisks
S 3 C
S
k
C -
Rk M
P
U Rk
S 5
S 2
S 4
S 1
F R
S: Ow B (2006).
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
21/23
174
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
TABLE 3. COMPARING RISK MANAGEMENT PROCESS WITH THE RESILIENCEPARAGRAPH, HIGHLIGHTING SOME PUBLIC POLICY GAPS
S Rk M R P
D N
I k I k
E kE k ( w / )
C k (D C)
N
I wE , w , k.
S: Ow .
RBogt. H. J. T (2001). P O-O P E M-
, erpa Act Rvw, 1013, . 621-43.Boogaard, R. P. C. M. H (1998). C k -
N. I Ok (E.)(1998). Frdg a pgavr d ftg sktr: opgavrdg dvagt ad,. 71-94. K: I.
Boorsma, P. B. N. M. M (1995). T D P F R. I K-k, W J.M. F A. V, E., (1995). Pbc Pcy & AdstratSccs T ntrads, P H, L-Nw Yk.
______ G. H (2005). Rsarc csdrg t appcat t rsc paragrap Dtc mcpats. U Tw. T N.
______ (2006). Pbc Rsk maagt, wt a spca rrc t Dtc cpats. Apapr prstd t crc maca, C.
Bovens, Mk (1996). D . I Mk B A Hk (.) ht vraa va d raa. e prsc drk aar dsca bddg va r bdg, . 150-70. A/M: B.
Denters, B.; P. J. Kk M. V (2002). R Rk: P . P ECPR J S Wk, T, I.
______ L. E. R (2005). Cparg lca Gvrac: Trds ad Dvpts. P-: M.
De Rooij, R. (2002). T E U N-.Jra erpa Pbc Pcy, 9:3: 447-467.
De Vries, M. S. (2008). S R: S A D L- P Nwk. lca Gvrt Stds. V. 34, N 2: 221-243.
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
22/23
175
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
Drennan, Lynn T. A MC (2007). Rsk ad Crss maagt t PbcSctr. Nw Yk: R.Fone, M P C. Y (2000). Pbc Sctr Rsk maagt. L: B.Hoetjes, B. J. S. (2009). T w N,
habtat itrata, 33: 157-164.Hood, C. (). T Nw P M 1980: V T,
Accg, orgrr rd Scy, 2011-2: 93-109.Jessop, B. (1994). P-F . I A. A (E.). Pst-Frds: A Radr, .
251-279. O: Bkw.Kicert, W. J. M. (1997). Pbc maagt ad Adstrat Rr Wstr erp.
C: E.King D. S. and J. Pierre (1990). C L G. Sag mdr Ptcs
Srs,V 28.Knight, F. (1921). Rsk ucrtaty ad Prt, C: U C P.Kolpron (2001).Aay grdbdrjv p bass va jaarvrsag [A aayss ad cpa-
s t bass aa rprts]. R: K C.Korthals Altes, W. K. (2002). L G Dz U
R P N. urba Stds, V. 39, N 8: 1439-1452.Kpmg (1997). Ozk P C M K G,
Rprtag p hdj, U: Kpmg.Lam, J. (2003). etrprs Rsk maagt, Fr ictvs t Ctrs. Nw Yk: J W-
& S.Lijphart, A. (1975). T ptcs accdat-Pras ad dcracy t ntrads.
Bk: U C P.Minister o Interior Aairs and Kingdom Aairs (1999). Br mstr va B-
ads zak Kkrjksrats aa Vast Kar Css vr Bads zak Kkrjksrats, 29 Sptbr. A ://www../W2/L/Z-
H/.Moret, E Y (1997). T J kw (D H).Needham, B. (1992). A w . urba St-
ds, 29: 669-681.Pacione, P. (2001). G : -
, Prgrss Pag, 56: 1-59.Pollitt, C. G. Bk (2000). Pbc maagt Rr: A Cparatv Prspctv.
O: O U P.Pollitt, C. (2002). T Nw P M I P: A A-
I E. I ML t a.( 2002). . 274-92.Sadosi, B. M.; A. N; M. D R (2009). P -
wk: E N.Tccats Pcy, 33: 582-595.
Schouten, C. (1999). T Dtc prvca ad cpa acctg syst. P
7 C C I G A R-, T, J.
-
7/27/2019 Risk Management Policy in Dutch Municipalities. Understanding the Process, Identifying Strengths And
23/23
176
Revista Enoques Vol. Ix N142011pp.155-176
IGNACIO CIENFUEGOS SPIKIN
RISK MANAGEMENT POLICY IN DUTCH MUNICIPALITIES
Van Dij Commission (1999). e drbrd bd. ht gbd va d prvc.Z-H G: . .Van Helden, G. J. H. J. B (2001). T A Bk P
C L G: A F S E D M. lcaGvrt Stds, V.27, 1 (S 2001): 61-86.
Van Helden G. J. E. P. J (). Nw P M D L G-. lca Gvrt Stds. V1.29, 2: 1-88.
Van Saaningen R. (2008). Sw : R. I S, J. (.). J, C C S: A - . Wa: Cpt.
Yesilagit, A. K. J. D V (2002). T z- : P S H. itrata Rvw Adstratv Sccs, V. 68: 579-597.
top related